The Old Mill 2023 Holiday Catalog

Christmas SINCE 1830

PI

GE

O N FO R G E , T

N

BUY THIS PRINT SEE PAGE 23!

2023

Get the family together and create sweet memories this season

FOOD | GIFTS | POTTERY | Grains | CANDY | DELIVERED TO YOUR DOOR

1

A Nostalgic Christmas with

Gather together & make memories This holiday season, make those cherished moments with family and friends even more special with a touch of the holidays from The Old Mill.

Our Smoky Mountain traditions are filled with the comforts that bring loved ones together. Set a table adorned with family favorites, gather by the fireplace warming your hands with mugs full of hot cocoa and fresh baked snickerdoodles, or send a handmade gift to those you hold dear. Let The Old Mill be your guide to a heartwarming and unforgettable Christmas.

From our family to yours, we wish you the happiest of holidays and the warmest greetings for a very Merry Christmas.

ON THE COVER: Original artwork of The Old Mill

by Chuck Finley. To purchase a print see page 23.

2 ORDER ONLINE AT OLD-MILL.COM OR CALL +1-877-653-6455

Give the gift

of the

OLD MILL GIFT CARD Can’t decide on a gift? Let them choose their own.

Our Gift Cards may be redeemed at The Old Mill Restaurant, Old Mill Pottery House Cafe, or any of our shops here in Pigeon Forge, Tennessee. To redeem for mail order, simply call us at 877-653-6455. The Old Mill Gift Cards never expire and there are no fees!

A

NEW!

Gift-worthy goodies Snowy Smiles, Cozy Bites D

E A. A VINTAGE CHRISTMAS EVE $84.99 Leaving cookies for Santa is a tradition that goes back to everyone’s childhood on Christmas Eve. A rare, original, 1950’s Santa Mug is paired up with a package of our new Snickerdoodle Cookie Mix (13 oz.) so you can make cookies with the kids, our Double Chocolate Cocoa tin, and some Reindeer Food to sprinkle out on the lawn. Quantities are limited, so order quickly.

B

“Gave one as a Christmas gift and liked it so much that I went back to order one for myself.” — Fran

C

B. BATTER BOWL BREAKFAST GIFT SET $79.99 For the pancake enthusiast on your list, our classic Batter Bowl Breakfast Gift Set is the ultimate gift. Our Buttermilk Pancake Mix (2 lb.) and Pure Maple Syrup (8 fl. oz.) will arrive in a handmade Batter Bowl from Pigeon River Pottery, in our LeConte Mountain Ridge glaze.

C. SNOW DAY BREAKFAST GIFT SET $39.99 What better way to warm up the family for a day of playing in the snow than with a fresh batch of pancakes! Let our snowman, full of pure maple syrup, inspire sweet moments while making your own. Includes Buttermilk Pancake Mix (2 lb.) and Pure Maple Syrup Snowman (12.7 oz.).

F

D. BRITTLE SAMPLER GIFT SET $39.99 Our brittle is made with sugar, butter, and fresh cream. It’s cooked in copper kettles, and then we hand-stir in the nuts before pouring it onto the cooling table. This collection includes 12 oz. of each Peanut, Pecan, and Cashew Brittle.

E. SYRUP SAMPLER $22.99 For our best-selling flavors to last throughout the season, our Syrup Sampler needs to be on your table! Makes a great gift too. Roasted Pecan, Blueberry, and Butter Maple flavored syrups. 2 oz. bottles each in a gift crate.

F. WINTER TAFFY BOX $14.99 A favorite treat, our salt water taffy is just the right size for a stocking. Made on our centuryold taffy pulling and wrapping machines, sweet and flavorful taffy comes assorted in a souvenir gift box. 1 lb.

3

A

A Biscuit Bar

will feed a hungry crowd!

B

NEW!

A. HOLIDAY BISCUIT BAR GIFT SET $74.99 Make holiday brunch entertaining a breeze with all the essentials for a yummy biscuit bar set up. We’ve made preparation and set-up easy with all that we’ve included. From sweet to savory, everyone can make their ultimate biscuit. Gift set includes 2 Buttermilk Biscuit Mixes (2 lb. each), Peppered Gravy Mix (8 oz.), Chocolate Gravy Mix (8 oz.), Christmas Jam (10 oz.), and Cranberry Pear Jam (10 oz.).

C

NEW!

B. BREAKFAST AT THE OLD MILL $79.99 Here’s everything you need to make an authentic Old Mill Restaurant breakfast at home for your own family or give as a gift to brighten anyone’s morning. Includes Buttermilk Pancake Mix (2 lb.), Biscuit Mix (2 lb.), Yellow Corn Grits (2 lb.), Peppered Gravy (8 oz.), Banana Nut Muffin Mix (18 oz.), Triple Berry Jam (10 oz.), and Roasted Pecan Syrup (12 oz.). Comes in a ready-to-gift box.

4 ORDER ONLINE AT OLD-MILL.COM OR CALL +1-877-653-6455

C. MUG, COCOA, & CHRISTMAS BARK $69.99 Warm up this winter with our Cocoa, Peppermint Bark and Mug Gift Set. Includes Double Chocolate Hot Cocoa Mix, a Potter’s Mug glazed in a unique bubble red, and a ½ pound of Christmas Bark. Gift boxed and ready for gifting.

T houghtful gifts

Bring

T he Old Mill's

A

breakfast home

B

C

D

E

A. SMOKY MOUNTAIN CHRISTMAS MORNING $109.99 A Christmas morning in the Smokies is spent with family gathered around the breakfast table, reminiscing of Christmases past, the aroma of freshly baked biscuits and cinnamon bread fills the air, and a steaming cup of coffee wakes you up, while everyone piles on the pancakes with syrup flowing, and more memories are made.

Includes Buttermilk Pancake Mix (2 lb.), BarrelAged Bourbon Maple Syrup (8 oz.), Biscuit Mix (2 lb.), Cranberry Pear Jam (10 oz.), Peppered Gravy Mix (8 oz.), Reindeer Lift Coffee (1.5 oz. makes one pot), Cinnamon Swirl Bread Mix, and a tin of Double Chocolate Cocoa. Gift boxed and ready for gifting.

B. From our Table $39.99 We compiled some of our signature favorites that have earned an esteemed place at our tables in The Old Mill Restaurant. Bring a welcoming warmth to any gathering with this favorite set that includes our Signature Corn Chowder Mix (10.2 oz.), Fritter Mix (2 lb.), and Maple Crystals (6 oz.). All packaged in a burlap gift tote.

C. FUDGE SAMPLER GIFT TIN $29.99 Handmade with the freshest ingredients and lots of Smoky Mountain flavor! We use real butter and cream in every batch. Our sampler features our customer’s favorite classic fudge flavors: Chocolate, Cookies & Cream, Chocolate Walnut, and Peanut Butter in a holiday tin (1/4 lb. of each flavor). Ready for gift giving. Or check out all the regular and seasonal varieties on our website that are sold by the pound.

D. CHRISTMAS JAM & CHRISTMAS PICKLE COMBO $29.99 Our pickles are festive with bright red peppers and the fresh crunch you want. Our Christmas Jam is made in small batches in our Farmhouse Kitchen with pears, oranges, and cinnamon. Gift packed and ready to give.

E. CRAFTER’S MUGS 69.99 The Crafter’s Mug holds a generous 12 oz. of your favorite hot beverage. Glazed in Smoky Mountain Autumn. Set of 2 mugs in a gift box.

5

Give the gift of

A

IN PIGEON FORGE, TN

handcrafted pottery

Perfect presents for the season

B

See pottery being made here!

Make it a

gift combo D

add mixes from our Baker’s Pantry

on page 12

E

D. BATTER BOWL $64.99 Both beautiful and functional, this handcrafted batter bowl from Pigeon River Pottery is made with a sturdy handle to grip while pouring from the spout. Holds approximately 7-8 cups. Glazed in Flowering Dogwood.

E. WHISK BOWL & WHISK $39.99 So handy in the kitchen, you’ll find you can’t do without it! Measuring about 3.5 inches deep and 5.5 inches wide. It’s just the right size for whisking eggs or 2 cups of liquid or dry ingredients. Glazed in Cades Cove Fields. Whisk included.

A. CHIP & DIP PLATTER $109.99 Nothing gets the party started faster than our fabulous chip and dip platter. Handcrafted by our artisan potters, this platter is the perfect way to serve your favorite snacks and dips. The platter measures wide to 14-inch diameter and, approximately 5 inches tall, and is glazed in Smoky Mountain Autumn. See other glazes online.

Party-Perfect!

OIL AND VINEGAR APPETIZER SET

B. SALAD BOWL $89.99 A gorgeous piece from Pigeon River Pottery, this bowl is perfect for serving large salads, holding fresh fruit, and more. Glazed in Lazy River Blue and measures 11 - 12 inches in diameter, 4.5 inches tall. Teak Salad Serving Set sold separately.

C. APPETIZER GIFT SET $89.99 This gift is perfect for the entertainer on your shopping list! Includes a beautiful, handcrafted Pigeon River Pottery bread dipper plate (glazed in Flowering Dogwood), Rosemary Garlic Seasoning Blend (1 oz.), Series 7 Balsamic Vinegar (3.38 oz.), and Rosemary Olive Oil (3.3 oz.). Add your favorite warm, crusty bread and enjoy! Comes in a ready-to-gift box.

6 ORDER ONLINE AT OLD-MILL.COM OR CALL +1-877-653-6455

C

“The quality of the pottery is top notch. These are sure to be a family heirloom.” — Rickey A. STEMLESS WINE GOBLETS SET $62.99 Our Stemless Wine Goblets are handmade by local artisans in our Pigeon River Pottery studio. These feature a Flowering Dogwood glaze and are perfect for any wine lover. Each holds 8 ounces and comes in a set of two. Comes in a ready-to-gift box, making them the perfect gift for any occasion.

A

B. CAKE STAND $ 129.99 Elevate your desserts with our unique handmade pottery cake stand from Pigeon River Pottery Studio, where skilled artisans meticulously craft each piece to ensure both its stunning appearance and flawless functionality. Designed to display baked goods up to 8-9 inches in diameter, it comes in a beautiful Flowering Dogwood glaze.

B

Elevate your home with handcrafted pottery creations and gourmet essentials

C

E

D

NEW! C. CHEESE BOARD $39.99 The old-world charm of our rustic cheeseboard is the ideal way to serve cheeses at your next gathering. This handmade pottery cheeseboard offers an impressive presentation and easy cleanup. Approx. 11” long, 5” wide, ½” thick.

D. OIL & VINEGAR GIFT SET $42.99 Our 2 best selling infused olive oils (Tuscan Herb & Black Truffle) are packed up with the Series 7 Balsamic Vinegar, giving the cook an endless combination of flavors for their next creation. Each 100ml bottle holds 3.3 oz.

Comes in a ready-to-gift box.

NEW! E. POTTERY SPOON REST SET $46.99 Keeping your kitchen counter clean, and adding some beauty to your kitchen, our handcrafted pottery spoon rest is the perfect spot to set down this amazing wooden spoon, carved from Pakka Hardwood. Comes in a ready-to-gift box.

7

Heartwarming Flavors of our

Signature Soups

Soups Spread

Soup is the ultimate comfort food. It can warm your body and soul on a cold winter night or provide a light, satisfying meal on a crisp, sunny day. When we first opened The Old Mill Restaurant 30 years ago, the corn chowder became a guest favorite. Our Signature Soup Mixes provide an easy way to recreate our favorite recipes at home.

OLD MILL SIGNATURE SOUPS $12.99/EACH Ready in less than 30 minutes, each of our Signature Soup mixes require nothing more than water to prepare. You will have a hearty meal with fresh-picked flavor that your family will love.

SIGNATURE CORN CHOWDER LOADED BAKED POTATO BROCCOLI CHEDDAR CREAMY VEGETABLE TOMATO BASIL

Savor the season!

Ideal for Gifting & Entertaining!

“Homemade taste like Mom & Grandma used to make. Great flavor and enjoyable to eat!” — Jim

A

B

C

A. SOUP MUG GIFT SET $88.99 Handcrafted at Pigeon River Pottery, these handled soup mugs are perfect to enjoy your favorite soup on a cold night. Made by our team of Appalachian artisans, glazed in Farmhouse Frost. Each mug holds approximately 1.5-2 cups and stands about 2 1/2” tall. Set of 2.

B. WINTER SOUP GIFT SET $39.99 A hearty pair of our most popular soups to get you and your family through those cold winter days. Includes Corn Chowder Mix (10.2 oz.), Loaded Baked Potato Soup Mix (12 oz.), four freshly-baked Bread Bowls from our cafe.

C. SOUP SAMPLER $34.99 It’s hard for us to pick a favorite soup so we picked four just for you. Our Soup Sampler includes our Signature Corn Chowder (10.2 oz.), Loaded Baked Potato (12 oz.), Creamy Vegetable (12.5 oz.), and Broccoli Cheddar (9.4 oz.) mixes.

Each package makes four 1-cup servings.

8 ORDER ONLINE AT OLD-MILL.COM OR CALL +1-877-653-6455

“OMG….this was delicious. Just the right amount of heat and you can add more jalapeños if you want it extra hot! Try it, you’ll love it!” — Paulette

Spice up your holidays with hearty chili, savory beans and more!

A

C

C. SOUP BEAN POT $68.99 In the tradition of cooking beans in a pot, our Pottery Bean Pot is perfect for preparing and serving sizeable portions of your favorite beans. From a basic white bean to enjoy with cornbread to a side dish of baked beans full of smoky, sweet flavor, just serving them is a treat because it’s also a beautiful piece. The Bean Pot holds approximately 6-7 cups.

B

Seasonal beans and soup varieties

A. CHILI & JALAPEÑO CORNBREAD SAMPLER $28.99 Chili and cornbread are the perfect winter combo. Each box includes one Chili Starter package (3 oz.) and a Yellow Jalapeño Cornbread Mix. Makes enough cornbread for a 10-inch skillet, and a full batch of chili.

B. CHILI STARTER PACK $26.99 Spice up dinner with this Chili Starter Party Pack. Featuring fullbodied flavor and a wide array of spices, you’ll just need to add your choice of beans, meat, and a big spoon! 3-3 oz. packages.

Harvest Lentil Soup Mix

$11.99

Christmas Lima Beans

$13.99

Campfire Mixed Bean Soup Mix

$11.99

Country Vegetable Soup Mix

$11.99

Savory Mixed Bean Soup Mix

$11.99

Hearty Black Bean Chili

$11.99

Shop more soups and beans ONLINE!

CHRISTMAS DELIVERY Last day to order with expedited delivery is TUESDAY, DEC. 19, 2023.

Additional shipping charges may apply.

9

Great Gifts

Personalized & Festive

for the chef in your family

A

B

A. ENGRAVED CHERRY BOARD $109.99 B. ENGRAVED ACACIA BOARD $89.99 A gift that will surely take your taste buds down memory lane, this custom engraved board can be etched with your favorite family recipe. Simply place your order online, and email a photo of your favorite handwritten family recipe to customerservice@old-mill.com. Be sure to include your order number in the email! Gift boxed and ready for giving, this gift will surely be a keepsake for generations to come. A. Rectangular Cherry Board measures 11”x 7.75” B. Round Acacia Board measures 15”x10”

NEW!

Mini CookbookTreasures

SMALL IN SIZE, BIG ON FLAVOR!

We've combed through old family cookbooks and recipe boxes to put together these little cookbooks.

Each book dives deep into a single topic, so there's a favorite for everyone!

OUR DAILY BREADS $9.99 From biscuits and griddle cakes to cherished loaves and sweet delights, these recipes evoke the flavors passed down through generations.

HOLIDAYS & GATHERINGS $9.99 Transport yourself to a bygone era of holiday celebrations and discover cherished recipes inspired by Southern Appalachian traditions for appetizers, main dishes, sides, and sweets.

Cooking Tips from our Test Kitchen

10 ORDER ONLINE AT OLD-MILL.COM OR CALL +1-877-653-6455

CORNBREAD FAVORITES $9.99 From classics like hoe cakes and skillet cornbread to innovative dishes, our stone-ground cornmeal brings the Great Smoky Mountains’ heritage to your table.

CAKES & PIES $9.99 From celebrations to church gatherings, these beloved recipes allow you to recreate sweet memories in your own kitchen, carrying on our two-century legacy at The Old Mill.

Mix up

holiday magic!

NEW!

BAKING MIX TRIO $34.99

Make memories with loved ones by baking up some holiday magic with this trio of Old Mill baking mixes. Includes Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix (13 oz.), Double Chocolate Brownie Mix (18.25 oz.) and Banana Nut Muffin Mix (18 oz.).

A

NEW!

A. COOKIE MIX BUNDLE $19.99 Introducing our NEW line of Old Mill cookie mixes! Our Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix (13 oz.) and Snickerdoodle Cookie Mix (13 oz.) are all-natural and can be baked as drop cookies or in a skillet. Packaged in a burlap gift tote.

C

Homemade taste

C. PECAN PIE MIX $14.99 If you’ve ever tasted a bite of The Old Mill Restaurant’s famous pecan pie, you will understand why we put the pie into a mix that you can bake anytime you are ready. You’ll be amazed by the homemade taste! Each pouch (21.44 oz.) makes one 9-inch pie.

B

NEW!

B. TENNESSEE ORANGE BROWNIE GIFT SET $52.99 A great gift kit for the chocolate lover on your list, our Double Chocolate Brownie Mix (18.25 oz.) is prepared with Blood Orange Olive Oil (3.3 oz.) for a decadent flavorful treat. Includes reusable Fancy Panz 8” x 8” in. baking pan, recipe card and Old Mill Tennessee Traditions kitchen towel.

I'll never try to bake it from scratch again.

After many failures at a scratch pecan pie, I now have my go-to.”

— Jennifer

Order a bag of ie Miller's Choice PeEcRaFEnCTP ION Unbleached

P

ADD A TOUCH OF HOMEMADE LOVE!

Flour on page 12 to make a pie crust.

11

Stock your pantry with all your essentials Preserving Heritage Since 1830, our grits and meals have been stone ground, using the power of the Little Pigeon River to turn the massive two-ton granite stones. In keeping with tradition, each bag is carefully filled and weighed by hand, just as it was in the days of old, and our millers proudly tie them off with the classic Miller’s Knot.

The Old Mill GRITS

2-LB.

5-LB.

Stone Ground White Grits

$6.99

$11.99

Stone Ground Yellow Grits

$6.99

$11.99

The Old Mill Cornmeal 1830 Unbolted White or Yellow Cornmeal

Instant Dry Yeast 4 oz.

$4.99

Dried Buttermilk 8 oz.

$10.99

Classic White Bread Flour

$7.99

2-LB.

5-LB.

Whole Wheat Bread Flour

$6.99

$7.99

$11.99

Thick Table Rolled Oats

$8.99

Self-Rising White or Yellow Cornmeal

$9.99

$11.99

Double Chocolate Brownie Mix

$10.99

Yellow Jalapeño Self-Rising Cornmeal

$10.99

$14.99

Cream Cheese Pound Cake Mix

$9.99

Miller’s Special Popcorn Meal

$11.99

Banana Nut Muffin Mix

$14.99

Pecan Pie Mix

$14.99

Cornbread Dressing Seasoning

$8.99

Specialty

FLOURS

Our flours have been preferred by bakers for generations. From soft, unbleached flour to a rustic and grainy cracked wheat flour, you can rely on great results every time. Available in 2 lb. bags.

Specialty MIXES

“Delicious muffins. Taste great and smell amazing.”

— David

AVAILABLE IN 2-LB BAGS

Miller’s Choice Unbleached Flour

$7.99

Miller’s Choice Self-Rising Flour

$7.99

Country Style Golden Corn Flour

$6.99

Old Fashioned Buttermilk Biscuit Mix $9.99

Original Whole Wheat Flour

$6.99

Old Mill Restaurant Fritter Mix

$14.99

Cracked Wheat Flour

$8.99

Classic Fried Chicken Breading

$9.99

American White Rye Flour

$8.99

Fried Green Tomato Breading

$13.99

Rustic Dark Rye Flour 1.5 lb.

$9.99

Southern Style Okra Breading

$11.99

Light Buckwheat Flour

$9.99

Crispy Hushpuppy Mix

$9.99

$9.99

State Fair Funnel Cake Mix

$12.99

Sausage Ball Mix

$9.99

Rustic Dark Buckwheat Flour

12

Baker's PANTRY

Pickles,

Make it a

RELISH & CHOW CHOW

gift combo

The Old Mill’s harmonious blend of zesty pickles, chow chows, and tangy relishes create the perfect condiment for a burst of flavor in every bite.

add a handcrafted

Salsas

PINT JARS

Pickles

relish & chow chow

Chip & Dip Platter

on page 6

Christmas Pickles

$13.99

Sweet Corn Relish

$12.99

Perfect for dipping chips, but also makes a great topping for steak, chicken, pork, or fish.

Bread & Butter Pickles

$11.99

Vidalia Onion Mustard Relish

$10.99

PINT JARS

Dill Pickle Spears

$11.99

Black Eyed Pea Relish

$11.99

Peach Salsa

$12.99

Sweet & Crunchy Dill Pickles

$11.99

Pear Relish

$10.99

Black Bean Salsa

$12.99

Old Fashion Lime Pickles

$11.99

Mild Chow Chow

$10.99

Garlic Salsa

$12.99

Moonshine Pickles

$11.99

Hot Chow Chow

$10.99

Medium Chucky Salsa

$12.99

Hellfire Pickles

$11.99

Five Pepper Chow Chow

$10.99

Smoke On The Mountain Salsa

$12.99

NEW! “I buy these every year!! They taste just like what my Mama used to make. I miss her pickles, but these are almost as good. I highly recommend!!”

— Candace

DILL PICKLE SAMPLER $32.99 Why choose just one? For our fellow pickle lovers, this Dill Pickle Sampler lets you enjoy our top selling Spicy, Sweet & Crunchy, and Classic Dill Pickles. These small batch pickles are delicious right out of the jar, or add a flavorful zip to any recipe! Pint jars.

T he best memories

Buy More! Save More!

Shipping CHARGES for orders:

are made gathered around the table

ay memories THheolidbest

under $49.99

$16

$50-$99.99

$14

$100-$149.99

$12

over $150.00

$10

The Old Mill Dip Mixes

Whether you’re planning a festive gathering or indulging in a cozy night at home, these irresistible blends are a must-try. Plus, they’re incredibly easy to prepare. Spend less time in the kitchen and more time explore the full are made around a well-stocked pantry enjoying the holiday season! selection online

ic ory Mag v a S & t e Swe

Shop our Sweet & Savory Dip Mixes ONLINE!

ORDER ONLINE AT OLD-MILL.COM OR CALL +1-877-653-6455 13

s e i l l e J , s m a J RVES

& PRESE

Preserving Tradition

heritage Collection Our Heritage Collection is a scrumptious array of Jams, Jellies, and Preserves, brimming with the finest fruits and berries, plucked fresh from nearby farms. These delightful flavors are whipped up in small, artisanal batches in The Old Mill Farmhouse Kitchen using the time-honored tradition of making them in copper pots.

We use the same methods our ancestors did to make jams, jellies, & preserves in small batches here in Southern Appalachia, so ours tastes just like you remember.

HALF-PINT JARS Christmas Jam $13.99 Strawberry Preserves $10.99 Mountain Blueberry Preserves $10.99 Chocolate Cherry Moonshine Preserves $13.99

“Mmmmmmmmm!!!! GREAT! Christmas should be every month. This jam is sooooooo good!!!” — Jeff

Pepper

Mountain Jellies, Jams & Preserves Made in our Farmhouse Kitchen in small batches, just as it’s been done for generations in the Smoky Mountains.

The Old Mill Restaurant

Favorite

14

HALF-PINT JARS

$8.99 JELLIES HALF-PINT JARS

Triple Berry Jam

$8.99

Wild Huckleberry Jam

$8.99

Crabapple Jelly

$8.99

Black Raspberry Jelly

$8.99

Muscadine Jelly

$8.99

Habanero Pepper Peach

$8.99

Pear Preserves

$8.99

Strawberry Habanero

$8.99

Bear Jam

$8.99

Jalapeño Blackberry

$8.99

Strawberry Jam

$8.99

Habanero Blackberry

$8.99

Peach Preserves

$8.99

Jalapeño Strawberry

$8.99

Habanero Four Pepper

$8.99

SHOP MORE JAMS, JELLIES & PRESERVES

ONLINE

The perfect blend of sweetness, with just the right amount of warmth. Perfect for making dips, glazes, or hors d’oeuvres.

Fruit BUTTERS

Make it a

gift combo

Our butters preserve the fresh fruit flavor to be enjoyed all year long.

add Our Homemade breads

Apple Butter (19 oz.)

$12.99

Apple Butter (9 oz.)

$9.99

Pumpkin Butter (19 oz.)

$10.99

on page 18

Juice Sweetened Apple Butter (19 oz.) $9.99

& W e k a affle c n a P MIXES

You’re getting the exact pancake and waffle mixes straight from The Old Mill Restaurant and Pottery House Cafe, so you can count on your family falling in love with them.

And, for the ultimate breakfast experience, don’t forget to crown them with our syrups or honey — your family won’t be able to resist!

2 LB. BAGS Buttermilk Pancake Mix

$13.99

Apple Cinnamon Pancake Mix

$12.99

Blueberry Pancake Mix

$12.99

Light Buckwheat Pancake Mix

$13.99

Classic Dark Buckwheat Pancake Mix

$12.99

Banana Caramel Pancake Mix

$12.99

Pumpkin Spice Pancake Mix

$12.99

Pecan Praline Pancake & Waffle Mix

$12.99

Belgian Waffle Mix

$10.99

Syrups Elevate your breakfast with our versatile premium syrups, perfect for drizzling on crepes, waffles, or sweetening morning oats.

Barrel Aged Bourbon Maple Syrup (8 oz.) $24.99 Pure Maple Syrup (8 oz.)

$14.99

Blueberry Syrup (12 oz.)

$12.99

Roasted Pecan (12 oz.)

$12.99

Blackberry Syrup (12 oz.)

$12.99

Apple Butter Syrup (12 oz.)

$12.99

Triple Berry Syrup (12 oz.)

$12.99

Sugar Free Maple Praline Syrup (12 oz.)

$12.99

Sugar Free Roasted Pecan Syrup (12 oz.) $12.99

Peach Butter (19 oz.)

$9.99

Cherry Butter (10 oz.)

$13.99

Honey

Savor the goodness of our Honey Butter!

This creamy nut butter is sweetened with golden honey for the ultimate upgrade for your breakfast game. Slather it on toast, biscuits, pancakes, waffles, or whatever else tickles your fancy.

BUTTERS

12 OZ. JARS Cinnamon Honey Butter

$14.99

Praline Pecan Honey Butter

$14.99

Pecan Honey Butter

$14.99

Cranberry Orange Honey Butter

$14.99

Maple Pecan Honey Butter

$14.99

Orange Pecan Honey Butter

$14.99

Pumpkin Pecan Honey Butter

$14.99

Honey & sorghum Strained Sourwood Honey (44 oz.)

$35.99

Strained Sourwood Honey (22 oz.)

$18.99

Muddy Pond Sorghum (16 oz.)

$19.99

Get Holiday-Ready with our breakfast essentials and holiday flavors.

More of our Pantry Collection

Available ONLINE

BREAKFAST AT THE OLD MILL $79.99 Here’s everything you need to make an authentic Old Mill Restaurant breakfast at home for your own family or give as a gift to brighten anyone’s morning. Includes Buttermilk Pancake Mix (2 lb.), Biscuit Mix (2 lb.), Yellow Corn Grits (2 lb.), Peppered Gravy (8 oz.), Banana Nut Muffin Mix (18 oz.), Triple Berry Jam (10 oz.), and Roasted Pecan Syrup (12 oz.). Comes in a ready-to-gift box.

ORDER ONLINE AT OLD-MILL.COM OR CALL +1-877-653-6455 15

More than 70 years of Tradition

Pigeon River Pottery

C

Timeless Gifts

A

C. FARMHOUSE PITCHER $68.99 Handmade by our skilled potters and perfect for serving up warm cider on a cold day, this pitcher is a favorite here at The Old Mill. It holds approximately 44-48 oz. and measures approximately 7.5 – 8 inches inches tall. Glazed in Smoky Mountain Autumn.

D

B

A. PIE PLATE GIFT SET $99.99 An ideal gift for the baker on your shopping list! Our handmade pie plate is crafted exclusively in our Pigeon River Pottery studios by local artisans.

Sure to be a memorable keepsake for years to come. Includes 10-inch Pottery Pie Plate, glazed in LeConte Mountain Ridge, 2 lb. bag of Miller’s Choice Unbleached Flour, and Old Mill Pecan Pie Mix (21.44 oz.).

B. BREAD BAKER GIFT SET $109.99 There’s nothing like the smell of fresh baked bread! This handcrafted Bread Baker from Pigeon River Pottery is glazed in Cades Cove Fields and comes with Old Mill Whole Wheat Flour (5 lb.), Classic White Bread Flour (5 lb.) and a 4 oz. packet of Instant Dry Yeast. Bread Baker is approximately 6 inches tall by 7.7 inches wide.

16

D. FLUTED RIM BOWL $99.99 Looking for a bowl that’s bolder than the rest? Your quest ends here!

With its dramatic, fluted rim and striking color scheme, this handsome, handcrafted bowl makes a statement all its own. Approx. 6” tall, and 12” in diameter. Glaze: LeConte Mountain Ridge.

Shipepryiningfo

& deliv

Functional and Beautiful

Make crispy, delicious bacon with easy clean-up!

A

Pigeon River Pottery A. BACON COOKER $68.99 Our popular Pottery Bacon Cooker delivers crispy, delicious bacon with easy clean-up. Generously sized, it cooks up 6-8 strips of bacon in minutes in the microwave or conventional oven. No skillet, spatula, or sweating over a hot stove required! The reservoir base collects grease for easy pouroff. Dishwasher safe. Flowering Dogwood glaze.

B. POTTERY BEARS $59.99 Inspired by the black bears that call the Great Smoky Mountains home, our handmade pottery salt & pepper shakers are a Pigeon River Pottery original design and grace the tables at both of our restaurants. Includes one salt and one pepper shaker, measuring approximately 5 in. tall. Gift boxed and ready for giving.

C. APPLE BAKER GIFT SET $54.99 This apple baker, handcrafted in our Pigeon River Pottery studio, will have you making delicious treats in no time! We’ve included a 1½-pound bag of our Thick Table Rolled Oats and a recipe to get you started. Glazed in Flowering Dogwood.

B

D. & E. ENTERTAINING BOWL $17.99 Perfect for serving up your favorite dips, spreads, soups, and more!

Handcrafted in our Pigeon River Pottery studio. Holds approximately 9 oz.

Available in Lazy River Blue (D) or Greenbrier Moss (E).

F. CHICKEN COOKER $57.99 Prepare a perfectly tender, juicy chicken every time with our artisan-made Chicken Cooker. Fill the center with beer, cola, or marinade of choice.

Each Cooker is handcrafted, finished in a Lazy River Blue glaze, and will hold a 5-6 lb. chicken. As easy to clean as it is to use! 10-11 inch diameter.

D

E

C

F

ORDER ONLINE AT OLD-MILL.COM OR CALL 877.653.6455 17

Breaking Bread

The Heartwarming Tradition of Fresh-Baked Holiday Loaves

Fresh Baked

Breads

Our Pottery House Cafe bakes bread fresh every morning, so when you order it, it’s shipped the day it’s baked, and we always make sure it arrives within 2 days for maximum freshness. We ship all baked goods Monday – Wednesday. Each loaf is 1 lb. 12 oz.

Sourdough Honey Wheat Onion Rye

$10.99

Multi Grain

each

Cinnamon Raisin Pecan Cranberry Walnut “I have always loved The Old Mill homemade breads and I thought what better way to show some love by giving each child and spouse a pack. And trust me, everyone loved their surprise.”

— Teresa

OLD FORGE MOONSHINE CAKE COMBO $39.99 Celebrate the Appalachian tradition of soaking cakes in spirits at holiday time! Our Moonshine Cake Combo is a double treat, featuring fresh-baked, buttery pound cake and the tastes of the Old Forge Distillery’s famous moonshines. Includes two 8½” loaf cakes: Moonshine & French Toast Moonshine. Each loaf serves 6-8.

“I sent several Moonshine cake combos for Christmas & got positive responses.

It will definitely be on my mind when I'm looking to give more gifts.” — George 18

A

D

Decadent Desserts

B E

CAFE

Favorite!

C A. CRANBERRY ORANGE CORNMEAL CAKE $44.99 An aromatic and delightful combination of tart, plump cranberries and orangeinfused cake made with our fresh-ground Yellow Cornmeal. Everyone at your holiday gathering will enjoy this seasonal favorite. Serves 10-12.

B. COCONUT RUM CAKE $49.99 We’ve combined two classic Southern cakes into one, soaking our moist and tender, buttery yellow coconut cake in Old Forge Distillery Rum. This regal cake is right at home during the holidays. Serves 12 C. THE OLD MILL RESTAURANT PECAN PIE $39.99 Folks will drive for miles to get a slice of The Old Mill Restaurant’s legendary Pecan Pie. It’s that good! We’ve been baking and serving our authentic version of this Southern treasure every day for more than 25 years. From the crunchy pecans to the perfect crust, every piece is a slice of holiday heaven. 10” Serves 6-8. Gift boxed.

D. OLD MILL SIGNATURE POUND CAKE $42.99 When you want a pound cake, this is the one you want! Buttermilk makes this a moist cake and the flavors of lemon, coconut, vanilla, butter, and rum make it delicious! Serves 10-12.

E. POTTERY HOUSE CAFE CHOCOLATE PECAN PIE $44.99 Our Pottery House Cafe created its own loyal pie fans with this signature Chocolate Pecan Pie. Adding premium quality chocolate was the only way we could think of to improve the grand Southern classic, and it worked like a charm! Baked fresh daily. 9-inch diameter. Serves 6-8. Gift boxed.

19

Candy Wonderland

Dive into Irresistible Holiday Treats!

B

d

f

C 20

A. BOURBON NUTS GIFT TIN $28.99 Talk about irresistible! We bring bourbon and pecans together to create a sweet, crunchy, satisfying holiday snack. Bourbon lovers go nuts for them… and so does everybody else!

12 oz tin.

B, ASSORTED BEAR PAWS GIFT BOX $38.99 Our candy makers prepare caramel in-house from scratch, stirred by hand in our old-fashioned copper kettles, then they pour it over the freshest pecan pieces we can find. Sampler of rich milk, dark, and white chocolate — 2 each.

1 pound boxed and ready for gifting.

More options available online.

C. CHOCOLATE COVERED PEANUT GIFT TIN $21.99 These crunchy, chocolate treats make the perfect gift for any occasion! Packaged in our Candy Kitchen, enjoy 2 lbs. of chocolate covered peanuts packaged in a festive red tin.

A

D. ENGLISH TOFFEE $42.99 Made in small batches by our Old Mill Candy Kitchen confectioners. Our English Toffee is hand-poured, topped with chocolate and chopped almonds, then hand-broken into generous pieces. (1 lb.)

E. BUCKEYES $28.99 A classic from grandma’s kitchen that brings back sweet memories. Our own peanut butter mixture dipped in milk chocolate to resemble the nut of the buckeye tree. 1 lb.

F. CHOCOLATE COVERED CARAMELLOS $19.99 Pillow-soft marshmallows are coated in buttery caramel and dipped into creamy dark chocolate. Includes 9 pieces in gift box.

g

G. CLUSTERS $16.99-$29.99 We offer cashews, peanuts, or pecans covered in three different chocolates!

Roasted so they are nice and crunchy, they are coated in our silky milk chocolate, luscious white chocolate or rich dark chocolate, or include all three chocolates in a truly irresistible assortment! Available in 8-piece or 16-piece packages.

e 21

Joyful bites

C

and perfect Holiday gifts

A

D

B E

A. FRENCH TOAST KIT $124.99 Impress the family with a French Toast Casserole breakfast! Follow the recipe card to prepare the casserole using Pottery House Cafe Cinnamon Raisin Pecan Bread and The Old Mill Pure Vermont Maple Syrup (10 oz.), bake in a beautiful large casserole from Pigeon River Pottery (glazed in Leconte Mtn. Ridge), and enjoy! Arrives gift boxed, ready for giving.

D. DIVINITY GIFT BOX $32.99 This traditional Southern candy recipe has been passed down for generations! Made with real egg whites and sugar, it is whipped to perfection to make fluffy, heaven-light drops of sweet divinity blended with diced pecans and topped with a fresh pecan. 8 pieces.

B. CHERRY COBBLER & ENTERTAINING BOWLS $59.99 Nothing says the holidays quite like the rustic comforting dessert of Cherry Cobbler.

Our signature recipe is jarred to enjoy and we’ve included two Pigeon River Pottery bowls in Greenbrier glaze for the ultimate holiday hostess gift. Each bowl holds approximately 8 oz.

E. THE OLD MILL HOME-MADE FUDGE Old Mill Fudge is still made by hand in small batches using fresh, wholesome ingredients. Milk, butter, sugar, and more are combined to create sweet, smooth fudge so dense, rich and creamy that you'll wonder how you ever lived without it. Comes in one-pound box.

C. RED VELVET FUDGE $19.99 Made in small batches at The Old Mill Candy Kitchen, Red Velvet Fudge is a seasonal favorite. Layered red velvet and cream cheese fudge ensure each bite is creamy and delicious. One pound.

22

Chocolate

Maple Walnut

Chocolate Pecan

Peanut Butter

Chocolate Walnut

Chocolate Peanut Butter

$19.99

Make it an Old Mill Christmas!

A. THE OLD MILL BLANKET $59.99 For those cozy evenings when you want to curl up with a good book, our throw, with a winter scene of The Old Mill will keep you warm and toasty.

Measures 60” x 50”.

B. FELT WOOL OLD MILL ORNAMENT $18.99 The Old Mill was never cuter than in this felt ornament, made from recycled wool. No detail was left out, because if you look closely, you can see the lines of the clapboard siding and window panes. Measures 5” wide by 4” tall and has a string for hanging.

A

C. MAMA & BABY BEAR FELT ORNAMENT $18.99 This adorable felt ornament of a mama and baby bear make the perfect pair! Made from recycled wool, they measure 5” x 5” and come with a hanging string.

E

B

D. SMOKY MOUNTAIN SWEET SAMPLER $44.99 Send a little sweetness from the Smoky Mountains (or just grab some up for yourself!) with this collection of confections from our Old Mill Candy Kitchen. Handmade in-house with the freshest ingredients, you get Pecan Clusters (1/4 lb.), Bourbon Pecans (1/4 lb.), Toffee (1/4 lb.), Milk, White, and Dark Chocolate Bear Paws (1 each flavor), and Chocolate Covered Peanuts (1/4 lb.)

C

D

F

E. OLD MILL CHRISTMAS DELIVERY $54.99 From the cover. We commissioned local watercolor artist, Chuck Finley, to paint the cover for this catalog. We love it so much that we want to offer it to you. This is a Giclee, a galleryquality reproduction, capturing the essence of the original. 8”x10” and ready to frame.

Find more online old-mill.com/shop

From stoneground grains, homemade candies and jam to cakes and pottery!

F. PECAN LOGS $24.99 Homemade nougat filling is dipped in rich homemade caramel and rolled by hand in premium-quality chopped pecans for a truly Southern treat!

Includes 4 Pecan Logs. Gift boxed and ready for giving.

23

PRESORT STD. U.S. POSTAGE

PA I D

PERMIT 4542 SOUTHAMPTON, PA

Create

s e i r o m e M t e e Sw

CAFE

Favorite!

This season

POTTERY HOUSE CHOCOLATE PECAN PIE GIFT TIN $47.99 Our Pottery House Cafe created its own loyal pie fans with this signature Chocolate Pecan Pie. Adding premium quality chocolate was the only way we could think of to improve the grand Southern classic, and it worked like a charm! Baked fresh daily. 9-inch diameter. Serves 6-8.

ore Shop M ne!

Onli

Join our email list!

Exclusive offers, delicious recipes, and more – be the first to know!

24

From stoneground grains, homemade candies and jam to cakes and pottery!

“It was wonderful, felt like I was actually ordering right from the table in Tennessee, my favorite place.”

— Shelly