Skip to main content

LMD | 11-2025

Page 1

Riding Herd Saying things that need to be said. November 15, 2025 • www.aaalivestock.com

Volume 67 • No. 11

A Different Animal J

LEE PITTS

ust because plant-based beef is in a downward spiral doesn’t mean that our problems with alternative beef are over, in fact, it could be argued that our biggest battle is yet to come. After all, how does real beef compete with real beef? Wa r n i n g ! This is going to get complicated because one classification of real beef is raised on our nation’s grasslands and in feedlots while the other is cultivated beef made from real beef cells that are raised in scientific laboratories in sterile conditions much like a prescription drug would be made. And the production of what are called pharma-foods is where a lot of smart money on Wall Street is placing their bets. Even Tyson and JBS, the two biggest names in traditional beef production, are investing in lab-based meat. Beef made in labs is a far different animal than plant-based burgers and it’s going to take a different kind of defense than what was employed with plantbased beef because whether beef is produced from cows eating grass, or in a beaker in a lab, how does one criticize one beef without condemning the other?

identical to conventional beef. One big difference between the lab-based meat fraternity and the plant-based crowd is the veg-head’s stated goal was to completely rid the world of cowboys and cattlemen by replacing conventional beef once and for all. While the lab-meat promoters, for the most part, say they only want to augment the supply of protein to “meet the growing Take care of yourself global demand for as well as you do protein in a more humane way.” your horse and you’ll At least that’s both be healthy. what they’re saying for now. The stated goal of the lab-coatcrowd is to provide op lab-based meat, fast forward one half of one percent of total ten years and the industry has meat supply (including seafood) grown to over 175 companies on six continents, backed by over by 2030 which would make it a $3.1 billion in investments. And $25 billion dollar industry! Its here’s the scariest part: accord- promoters say lab-meat is “cruing to Hudson Robotics, a half elty-free” and is more sustaingram of cow stem cells could able than traditional meat. And theoretically produce 4.4 billion according to the Food and Drug pounds of ground beef! And Administration, lab-grown meat we’re talking about genuine real is safe for humans to eat. Unlike beef that could be nutritionally plant-based beef, it’s not com-

Cruelty Free Beef

Ever since Dutch scientist Mark Post unveiled the first lab beef burger on live television in 2013, companies have been experimenting with the idea that lab-based beef could someday replace conventionally produced beef. In 2015 there were two companies trying to devel-

Printing Meat The Good Food Institute is the de-facto mouthpiece for the lab-meat industry. They are a self-described, “Nonprofit think tank working to make the global food system better for the planet, people, and animals. As an international network of organizations, we advance alternative proteins to help meet climate, global health, food security, and biodiversity goals.” We’ll let the Good Food Institute describe how lab-meat is made: “The manufacturing process begins with acquiring and banking stem cells from an animal. These cells are then grown in bioreactors (known colloquially as cultivators) at high densities and volumes. The cells are fed an oxygen-rich cell culture medium containing basic nutrients such as amino acids, glucose, vitamins, and inorganic salts, and typically supplemented with growth factors and other proteins. Changcontinued on page 2

USDA Announces Opening of Sterile Fly Dispersal Facility in Tampico, Mexico

EPA Proposes Scaled-Back Definition of Protected US Waters

he U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) has announced the next milestone in the fight against New World screwworm (NWS) – the opening of a sterile fly dispersal facility in Tampico, Mexico. The Tampico facility will allow USDA to disperse sterile flies aerially across northeastern Mexico, including in Nuevo Leon. “The opening of the Tampico sterile fly dispersal facility is another incredibly important tool in our arsenal to stop the spread of screwworm. The facility will ensure flexibility and responsiveness in northern Mexico, giving us a greater ability to drop sterile flies and continue to push the pest south,” said U.S. Secretary of Agriculture Brooke L. Rollins.

BY BOBBY MAGILL & STEPHEN LEE, REPORTERS WITH ASSISTANCE FROM SKYE WITLEY / BLOOMBERG LAW

T NEWSPAPER PRIORITY HANDLING

posed of three dozen different ingredients and it tastes like real beef because it is real beef.

“Stopping the spread of screwworm is a top priority for the entire Trump Administration. Last week I had a productive meeting with Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum and my counterpart Secretary Julio Berdegue on the joint response to screwworm. We are boosting our efforts and completing a joint review of our screwworm operations in Mexico to ensure our protocols are being followed. As we enter the winter months, we continue to prioritize the response in Mexico and the rest of our five-pronged plan to protect U.S. livestock and the livelihoods of American farmers and ranchers.” continued on page 3

O

n November 17 The EPA proposed a revised definition of waters of the US, putting the second Trump administration’s stamp on wetlands

protections. The proposal aims to bring Clean Water Act protections for waters and wetlands in line with the US Supreme Court’s 2023 ruling in Sackett v. EPA, which reduced the scope of federal jurisdiction over waters and wetlands. The Biden administration issued a rule conforming to Sackett, but the EPA says this proposed rule is more in line with the ruling. If finalized, the rule would reverse the Biden administration’s definition of waters of the US, or WOTUS, continuing a nearly two-decade tradition of each new president updating the terms of federal waterway protections. The public will have 45 days to comment on the proposal once it’s published in the Federal Register in the coming days. The proposal is meant to be “durable,” and stop the swinging pendulum of new WOTUS definitions and regulatory overreach, EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin said in a statement. Even after the Sackett ruling, the Biden administration attempted to claim most of Alaska’s Arctic Coastal Plain as wetlands protected continued on page 5

by LEE PITTS

Bovine Bill of Rights

J

ust as Thomas Jefferson is remembered as the author of the Declaration of Independence and James Madison as the principal author of the Constitution, so too will I be remembered for The Bovine Bill of Rights. Article X: Beef animals not retained for breeding shall have the right to be placed in feedlots where they will be served breakfast in bed every morning and fed supper after their afternoon nap. They have the right to gobble down as much tasty feed as they desire of a delicious and expensive ration consisting of mouthwatering grains, appetizing roughage and sugary molasses for dessert. And all without having to worry about being bullied and made fun of by their fellow bovines for their obesity. Article IX: Cattle shall have the right to clean water and tight fences to prevent having to intermingle with the neighbor’s inferior mongrels. Article VIII: Bovines shall have the right to be transported in a well-ventilated trailer free from any off-putting fragrance from leftover swine or sheep dung. They have the right to be transported to their new destination as quickly as possible without speed governors or being stopped by over-zealous highway patrolman or delayed by over-eager scale masters. Article VII: At a branding, and periodically through the year, cattle have the right to be injected with pricey pharmaceuticals to keep them healthy and alive. Bovines also have the right to be branded so that after blizzards, floods or fires they can be sorted and returned home. They also have the right to wear ear tags to ward off flies and to provide additional information such as their sire. Cattle shall have the option to wear electronic ear tags but only if their caretaker deems them necessary. Article VI: During a threeday snowstorm cattle have the right to be kept alive by ranchers wearing five layers of clothing and with icicles hanging from their mustaches bringing them life-giving hay in the blinding snow. Article V: Cattle have the right to a painless death, free from worry about ignorant politicians and urban bureau-

continued on page 5


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
LMD | 11-2025 by Livestock Publishers - Issuu