NE F L C A I . C OM
V OL .
8
|
I s s u e
3
No r t h e a s t F l o r i d a C h a p t e r C o mmu n i t y A s s o c i a t i o n s I n s t i t u t e
THE COMMUNITY CONNECTION
THE ROAD AHEAD THESE ARTICLES (AND MORE) THESE TIMES. THESE THINGS. if you weren't already doing these things for your company or association, you will be now
CORONAVIRUS AND INSURANCE could there be some claims in the coming months?
HALLOWEEN SAFETY how to have a happy Halloween
events
contact information 42200 N Checkerberry Way St. John's, FL 32259 ced@neflcai.com
2020 board of directors President - David Robinson First Coast Mulch President - Elect - Pilar Willis Dixon, CIC, CIRMS Brown & Brown Insurance
Did you miss the program with Dawn Bauman, Senior Vice President, Government & Public Affairs with CAI headquarters? You missed a great overview of the 2021 Legislative Session priorities. CLICK HERE TO SEE THE PRESENTATION Also, stay tuned, we are working on some inperson events (following safety guidelines) for November and December.
welcome video from our new chapter executive director
Secretary - Leslie Pragasam, LCAM Vesta Property Services Treasurer- Jesse Skinner, LCAM, CMCA Leland Management Director - Scott Francis, CAM Manager Director - Cindy Dunlop Cogent Bank, SVP, Commercial Relationship Manager Director- Carmen Mazzeo, LCAM Homeowner Leader Immed. Past President - Catie Marks, CAM MAY Management Chapter Executive Director- Robin Miller NEFLCAI
NEFLCAI provides education, networking, resources, and advocacy for Community Associations in Northeast Florida and the professionals who serve them.
2020 committees Membership Carmen Mazzeo - Board Liaison Mary Price James Klempin Social Leslie Pragasam - Board Liaison Kyle Stoudenmire Program Pilar Willis Dixon - Board Liaison Ed Ronsman
letter from the president WRITTEN BY DAVID ROBINSON FIRST COAST MULCH Wow,
another
quarter
has
come
and
gone!
They are developing additional events and
While this quarter did not turn out as social as
meetings. Please reach out if you'd like to get
we’d hoped, a lot has been accomplished by
involved. While we can not know what’s going
our members, committees and new CED.
to happen this quarter, it shouldn’t prevent us from planing to fulfill our ultimate goals of
First and foremost our chapter has teamed up
Educating and Networking safely. Please keep
with a CED that hit the ground not running, but
an eye on your email for attempts to hold
sprinting. Robin started with us Mid-July and if
events in person as well as virtual
you have had any interaction with her at this
events/meetings. Lastly, if you are
point, you’ve already experienced her level of
interested in running to join the Chapter Board
professionalism.
please reach out to Robin to inquire.
She
ran
our
Education event, which was with
800
registrations
Wham
Bam
a massive success
from
participating
managers and/or community leaders. The event provided the opportunity for members to gain approved
continuing
education
credits
by
members with approved courses. She has also worked
with
implement
a
our
website
platform
developers
that
increases
to
both
member engagement as well as data tracking and streamlined event processing. The website has taken a bit longer to develop due to the additional
functions,
but
will
be
Find the hidden
launched
shortly and was well worth the additional wait.
Our chapter has successfully gone virtual. This
Somewhere in this publication (other than this page) is the icon above. Find it and submit your answer of what page you found it on. Sumbit your answer HERE ON THIS GOOGLE FORM.
transition will prove to be a useful tool even after we start meeting in person by allowing members
to
Committees recruiting
view are
meetings still
additional
from
meeting
members
anywhere.
and to
always
help
work
through the pandemic's unnavigable waters.
If you found it correctly, you will be entered to win a 1/4 page ad in the next newsletter. We will pick the winner at random, and let you know.
Travel Tips & Tricks by JM Lorenzo WRITTEN BY NINA LOPEZ PHOTOGRAPHY: LUZ SIMPSONS
Thanks to our Speakers! Nick Brenneman, Reserve Advisors Shar Caballero, Envera Systems Kelly Corcoran, Ball Janik Brian Crevasse, Ball Janik Mark D'Amico, First Coast Claim Consultants & ATAC Adjusters Christene Ertl, Ansbacher Law
Travel is the movement of people between relatively distant geographical
Pilar Willis Dixon, Brown & Brown Insurance
locations, and can involve travel by foot, bicycle, automobile, train, boat, airplane,
Cindy Dunlop, Cogent Bank
or other means, with or without luggage, and can be one way or round trip. Travel
Jeff Gay, Leland Management
can also include relatively short stays between successive movements.
Jennifer Mitchell, St. Johns River Water Management District
Travel may be local, regional, national (domestic) or international. In some countries, non-local internal travel may require an internal passport, while international travel typically requires a passport and visa. A trip may also be part of a round-trip. The origin of the word "travel" is most likely lost to history. The term "travel" may originate from the Old French word travail.
Ed Ronsman, McCabe|Ronsman Robyn Severs, Becker & Poliakoff Charlie Sheppard, Community Advisors Laurie Shrader, Angius & Terry Paul Terry, Angius & Terry Hans Wahl, Jimerson Birr
According to the Merriam Webster dictionary, the first known use of the word travel was in the 14th century.
NEFLCAI - 2020 Sponsors Many thanks for your support Platinum Sponsors
Gold Sponsors
Silver Sponsor
Bronze Sponsors
How to Have a Safe Halloween COURTESY OF: COMMUNITY ASSOCIATIONS INSTITUTE Halloween is a kid’s delight. It’s a blast to dress
Use party games and trick-or-treating as an
up in costumes, go trick-or-treating, attend
opportunity
parties and, most of all, eat candy.
for kids to get their daily dose of 60 minutes of physical activity.
At the same time, Halloween can be scary for
Be sure walking areas and stairs are well-lit
parents.
and free of obstacles that could cause falls.
Costumes can be dangerous, too much candy
Keep candle-lit jack-o-lanterns and other
can be sickening and walking around
open flames away
at night can be risky.
from doorsteps, walkways, landings and curtains. Place them on sturdy tables,
If you’re hosting a party or expecting trick-or-
keep them out of reach of pets and small
treaters:
children and never leave them
Provide healthy treats, such as individual
unattended.
packs of raisins, trail mix or pretzels. Offer
Drive safely and watch out for trick-or-
fruits, vegetables and cheeses to party
treaters.
guests.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention offer these tips (in anagram form) to make sure your little ghouls and goblins have a safe Halloween [during a normal year, please double-check their guidelines or the guidelines in your county/town due to COVID-19]:
S – Swords, knives and similar costume accessories should be short, soft and flexible. A – Avoid trick-or-treating alone. Children should walk in groups or with a trusted adult. F – Fasten reflective tape to costumes and bags to help drivers see trick-or-treaters. E – Examine all treats for choking hazards and tampering before they’re eaten.
H – Hold a flashlight while trick-or-treating to help see and help others see you. A – Always test make-up in a small area first. Remove it when done to avoid skin irritation. L – Look both ways before crossing the street. Use established crosswalks wherever possible. L – Lower the risk for serious eye injury by avoiding decorative contact lenses. O – Only walk on sidewalks or on the far edge of the road facing traffic to stay safe. W – Wear well-fitting masks, costumes and shoes to avoid blocked vision, trips and falls. E – Eat only factory-wrapped candy. Avoid eating homemade treats unless you know the cook. E – Enter homes only if you’re with a trusted adult. N – Never walk near lit candles or other open flames. Be sure to wear flame-resistant costumes.
These times. These things. WRITTEN BY ROBIN L. MILLER NEST COMMUNITY MARKETING CHAPTER EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, NEFLCAI
if you weren't already doing these things, you will now If you didn’t already see the power of groups
If you didn’t spend time understanding the
coming together and working in unity, you will
emotional and personal needs of your staff, you
now.
will now.
If you didn’t already focus on innovation and
If you didn’t already have a plan in place for
ideation as a regular part of your group or
crisis communications and risk management
company’s goals, you will now.
and business interruption, you will now.
If you didn’t already have a futures component
If you didn’t already have a solid and clean
to your regular conversations and staff
database to be able to quickly and efficiently
meetings, you will now.
reach your customers, members and vendors, you will now.
If you didn't spend time thinking about the “T” and “W” in a SWOT analysis “Threats” and
If you didn’t already understand who your
“Weaknesses,” you will now.
customers are and what they want from you, you will now.
If you didn’t already know the many, many stakeholders you have—the people and groups
If you didn't already rely on a cross-sectional,
whom your organization, company or products
diverse leadership team where all departments,
impact, you will now.
despite their differences, are needed to solve problems, you will now.
If you didn’t already have alignment from your boards and staff and funders related to policies and procedures, you will now.
About the Writer: Robin L. Miller is a seasoned trade association consultant, marketing and branding expert, and community engager. She is the President of NEST Community Marketing LLC, and NEFLCAI is happy to be her client.
NEFLCAI Bronze Sponsors
The Overlooked Facet of Community Pond Management: Structure WRITTEN BY SHANNON JUNIOR, AQUATIC ECOLOGIST & SENIOR BUSINESS DEVELOPMENT CONSULTANT PHOTOGRAPHY: SOLITUDE LAKE MANAGEMENT
Lakes and ponds can be amazing focal points of
although, more commonly, it is the responsibility of
our
the pond owners.
communities.
water,
and
People
local
are
innately
waterbodies
drawn
create
to
natural
spaces to enjoy a morning run, an afternoon walk
Unfortunately,
with
understand your HOA’s obligations for each of the
the
Many
dog,
or
a
neighborhood
communities
implemented
that
I
social
event.
with
have
work
beautification
and
habitat
facilities
in
it
the
responsibilities
can
also
community, can
vary
be
confusing
especially between
to
when
the
localities,
enhancement projects for their ponds, and some
communities, and the facilities themselves. The key
have even hosted kids fishing derbies or remote
documentation that outlines the responsibilities of
control boat races. But while maintaining healthy
the HOA for stormwater facilities in the community
and attractive waterbodies is a priority for most
is the Stormwater Maintenance Agreement with the
HOAs,
functional
locality. This document should exist for every facility
maintenance activities are frequently overlooked.
that is part of an approved site development plan,
It’s
and should be on file with the locality if you aren’t
the
basic
relatively
manager
easy
or
structural
for
the
resident
to
and
average identify
community when
their
able to locate it.
stormwater pond is experiencing problems when it’s covered in weeds and algae or when the fish
Your
stop
typically a knowledgeable resource when it comes
biting,
but
many
of
the
tell-tale
signs
of
lake
and
structural trouble are more subtle and difficult to
to
identify.
professional
pond
understanding
the
management
frequency
inspections.
and
provider
is
formality
Typically,
the
of
age,
condition, and complexity of the facility are taken Lakes
and
ponds
can
occur
naturally
in
the
into account, as well as the regulatory requirements
landscape, but more often they are man-made,
of
constructed for drinking water supply, irrigation,
management
livestock watering, recreational use, or stormwater
inspections of the entire facility. If concrete inlet
management—as
pipes are present, they should also be checked for
waterbodies.
is
the
There
case
are
for
most
many
HOA
important
the
locality.
spalling,
On
a
regular
professional
cracking,
and
basis,
will
your
provide
misalignments.
lake visual
The
outlet
components in a stormwater management facility
structures should be checked to ensure that water
that help regulate water levels, filter debris, and
is properly flowing and that there are no blockages
prevent
or damage to the trash rack, if one is present. It is
flooding.
components
All
require
of
these
and
also important to monitor the water level in the
maintenance to ensure the continued integrity and
pond – an abnormally high or low water level for an
functionality of the waterbody. Without proactive
extended
monitoring,
serious structural issue. The pond banks, including
it
is
frequent
structural
easy
to
inspections
accidentally
overlook
dam
period
of
time
embankment,
could
should
be
be
a
sign
of
inspected
a
serious structural damage and volume loss until
the
for
the problems require costly repairs and invasive
erosion and animal burrows. They should be well
solutions like dredging.
vegetated with no bare spots. Finally, there should be no woody growth on the dam embankment or
In some localities, the inspection and maintenance
within 10 feet of any pond structure since tree roots
of
can
stormwater
referred
to
as
management ‘BMPs’
or
facilities
'best
(also
management
practices’) is handled by the City or County;
compromise
the
structural
integrity
of
the
embankment and can cause cracking, displacement or blockage of pipes.
If potential areas of concern are identified, it is always cheaper to remediate them early rather than to perform costly repairs after the problems become more severe. For wet ponds, bathymetric
NEFLCAI The Community Connection Advertising
studies should be performed periodically to document
the
current
storage
facilities
and
the
extent
Likewise,
more
comprehensive
volume
of
of
the
sedimentation. monitoring
with
annual lake and pond assessments can pinpoint areas of potential concern and facilitate the development solutions
of
custom
include
management, biological
aquatic
aeration,
weed
hydro-raking
nutrient and
Common
and
nanobubble
augmentation,
mechanical
solutions.
algae
technology, remediation,
strategic
erosion
control. These strategies can be implemented as needed
depending
characteristics,
on
the
goals
and
unique
and
unique budget
property of
the
community.
Each
facility
managed stormwater
is
using
a
is
most
customized
maintenance
effectively
approach.
professional
Full Page - $300/issue Half Page - $200/issue Quarter Page - $100/issue Logo - $50/issue
can
A
help
you develop a specific plan that prioritizes the goals of your community, so you can cut down on maintenance and expenses over time.
About the Writer: Shannon Junior is an Ecologist with SOLitude Lake Management, a nationwide environmental firm that provides sustainable lake, stormwater pond, wetland and fisheries management solutions. Learn more at www.solitudelakemanagement.com/knowledge.
Upcoming Issues 4th Quarter December 2020 (due 11/15) 1st Quarter February 2021 (due 1/15) 2nd Quarter May 2021 (due 4/15) 3rd Quarter August 2021 (due 7/15) 4th Quarter November 2021 (due 10/15)
FLORIDA LEGISLATIVE ACTION COMMITTEE UPDATE Legislative Action Committees work to monitor state legislation, educate lawmakers, and protect the interests of those living and working in community associations. Each committee is comprised of homeowner leaders, community managers, and representatives from community association business partners who graciously volunteer their time. For our region, Pilar Willis Dixon, Brown & Brown Insurance, and Robyn Severs, Becker & Poliakoff represent our chapter and the region at large.
CAI’s Florida Legislative Action Committee is preparing for the 2021
legislative
proposed
this
session.
year
will
We
expect
relate
to
an
that
many
of
association’s
the
bills
ability
to
respond to COVID-19 and other similar viruses, as well as to provide some protections to such associations. Until we have further information to report about any proposed bills, below is a recap of what passed in 2020.
EMOTIONAL SUPPORT ANIMALS-SB 1084 Effective July 1, 2020, Section 760.27, Florida Statutes, was amended,
regarding
emotional
support
animals
(ESA),
to
expand the type of allowable documentation that can be used to verify the need for an ESA; to allow telemedicine providers and
out
of
state
licensed
providers
to
provide
ESA
documentation so long as they are acting within their scope of practice, have knowledge of an individual’s disability, and have seen the patient in person on at least one occasion;
and to require a person requesting more than one ESA, to provide a specific need for each animal. The bill also allows providers
who
provide
false
documentation
to
be
punished
under Florida law and updates liability language to ensure the owner of the ESA can be held liable for any damage done by an ESA.
FLORIDA INSURANCE GUARANTEE ASSOCIATION (FIGA)-HB 529 Effective
July
1,
2020,
Section
631.57,
Florida
Statutes,
was
amended to increase the FIGA limit from $100,000 to $200,000 per unit in a building. FIGA is similar to FDIC insured bank accounts. If there is a major storm event and the Association’s insurance carrier is unable to pay the claims, FIGA steps in to pay them. Before the amendment, FIGA could only pay up to $100,000 per unit. With this bill, that limit has been increased to $200,000 per unit.
LAW ENFORCEMENT VEHICLES- SB 476 Effective February 21, 2000, Chapters 718, 719 and 720 were amended to prohibit community associations from prohibiting law enforcement officers to park their law enforcement vehicles in the community.
FIREWORKS- SB 140 Effective April 8, 2020, Section 791.08, Florida Statutes, was amended to allow the use of fireworks on New Year’s Day, Independence
Day,
and
New
Year’s
Eve.
If
a
homeowners’
association wants to restrict or prohibit the use of fireworks, it must do so by a provision in a declaration of covenants and restrictions, not by a board adopted rule. However, the bill did not affect any rights of condominiums and cooperatives.
DISCRIMINATORY ASSOCIATION LANGUAGE- SB 374 Effective September 4, 2020, Section 712.065, Florida Statutes, was amended to clarify that any discriminatory restriction in any covenant or restriction is null and void. Upon the request of a parcel owner, a community association’s board of directors may amend any governing document to remove such discriminatory restriction.
HOUSING FOR OLDER PERSONS- HB 255 Effective July 1, 2020, Section 760.29, Florida Statutes, was amended
to
remove
the
requirement
for
55
&
older
communities to register with the state biennially and pay fees associated
with
such
registration.
While
55
&
older
communities still have to follow certain statutory requirements to maintain their 55 & older status, such communities no longer have to register their community with the state.
These are definitely unchartered waters. CORONAVIRUS AND COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION INSURANCE MANAGING EXPECTATIONS DURING THE PANDEMIC WRITTEN BY JOEL W. MESKIN, ESQ., CIRMS, CCAL FELLOW, MLIS, EBP
the coronavirus pandemic has found most of us with our arms up in the air. My
question,
spending
a
questions
on
coverage is:
as
someone
great the
deal
who
has
time
answering
of
Coronavirus
and
been
insurance
I
presume,
but
do
not
requirements
will
coverage
direct
for
not
assume, be
that
met
physical
to
these trigger
damage
in
the
did any prior pandemic, epidemic
majority of jurisdictions. I also presume, but do
or outbreak of a communicable disease lead to
not assume, that contingent damages arising or
the
now
resulting from the alleged property damage will
and
not
myriad
being
of
asked
immediate
insurance to
issues
respond
responses.
we
with
Maybe
are
clear
our
standard
response should be “maybe” or “it depends” on
be
covered.
include
business
These
potential
interruption
coverages
loss,
loss
of
business income or loss of use.
many variables before an intelligible response can be provided.
The
anticipated
arguments,
protracted
litigation, attorney fees and costs, as well as This
conundrum
provides
numerous
the fees and costs of countless multidisciplinary
opportunities for creative coverage attorneys
experts will depend on specific policy wording,
representing
state
Insureds
to
boldly
assert
and
laws,
court
interpretation,
will
coverage
ultimately determine coverage or no coverage.
coverage
under
the
to
exist.
Insured(s)
To
trigger
Association
these
factors
creative
intended
All
and
plausibly argue to find coverage where no such was
attorneys.
judges
These coverage issues and related litigation
Property Policy requires the existence of the
will undoubtedly go on for years, or until the
coronavirus
insureds can no longer afford the fight.
in
a
common
area
constituting
“property damage.” To satisfy the existence of
would
property
expect, just Google Insurance Coverage Issues
damage,
most
property
policies
like
to
out
get
of
a
the
taste
of
World
what
If you
Trade
we
can
require that there is a "Covered Cause of Loss"
arising
Center
(i.e. is the coronavirus a covered cause of loss)
Occurrence/Occurrences.
that results in direct physical loss of or damage
insurers may choose to resolve such claims on a
to the Insured(s) covered property?
cost of business basis. This is less likely due to
On the other hand,
the nature and extent of the potential claims.
I do not believe that insurers ever intended for
The focus of the issues set forth below involves
coverage to exist under these circumstances.
the
There
amenities”
are
potential
language, providing
caseswhere
endorsements coverage
exist.
or I
express
definitions
also
confidently
“common
elements,
of
a
property
not-for-profit
and
community
association such as a Condo, Coop or HOA. In addition,
the
focus
here
the
exposures
in
coronavirus existing in/on a common element.
modeling
they
acceptable
use
and
anticipate
the
These may have issues that differ from an analysis of a business where direct financial
criteria, necessary to properly price coverage
loss will result from the closure of a business
for
due
intended
ratios
best
other
of
underwriting
the
loss
to
and
existence
alleged
consequences
rating
the
on
contend that actuaries did not consider these developing
from
is
exposure.
Again,
this
is
different where there is specifically crafted or
to
direct
physical
loss
to
the
Insured’s
property.
included provisions creating coverage. In order to analyze the existence of coverage
COMMUNITY ASSOCIATION FOR CORONAVIRUS
INSURANCE
under
the
various
community
association
program, it is helpful to understand how to look and
review
an
Notwithstanding
association insurance puzzle.
policies have for being filled with small print
that Insured(s) may seek coverage under the
and
four highlighted policies below, General
madness.
Liability, Coverage,
Directors Workers
and
Officers
Compensation
and Property Coverage.
legalese, The
bad
there carriers
is
rap
a
need
that
policy.
The above chart sets forth the basic community It is anticipated
the
insurance
insurance
method to
to
protect
the the
Liability
intent they have behind an insurance product.
Coverage
Accordingly, if they do not cross every “t” and dot every “i”, they will be challenged on virtually every claim because without being this careful,
the policy will be attacked as having language that is vague and ambiguous resulting in having the language being construed in favor of the Insured(s).
For
all
intent
casualty
and
policies
purpose, are
built
all
property
the
same
and way.
Specifically, they are structured as follows:
Insuring Agreement – Gives you the world • Definitions – Defines the World • Exclusions – Takes away a part of the world •
-Covered under another policy -Would make the policy unaffordable if not excluded -Against Public Policy •
Conditions – What Insured must do to trigger coverage
•
Endorsements and Amendments
– change
the basic form. -Issued with policy -Including State Amendatory endorsements -Added later
As the issues on the next pages are reviewed, the
structure
set
forth
above
will
help
your community counts. your vote counts.
understand why coverage is applicable to the potential coronavirus alleged claim for injury or
Register to Vote.
damage.
Issue No. 1:
Most property insurance policies
require that the Insured(s) property suffer direct
Research the Candidates.
physical damage to Insured property resulting from a covered peril. Does the existence, or possible direct
existence
physical
of
loss
coronavirus
or
damage
property?
Response No. 1:
Get Out the Vote.
constitute to
Insured
Go Vote. Probably not.
CLICK HERE to go to CAI's election & voter registration page
Issue No. 1:
Most property insurance policies require that the Insured(s) property suffer direct physical
damage to Insured property resulting from a covered peril. Does the existence, or possible existence of coronavirus constitute direct physical loss or damage to Insured property?
Response No. 1:
Probably not.
Insured(s) will try and assert that the coronavirus introduced into the common elements constitutes direct physical loss or damage. Policy interpretation is subject to state law. Courts in some states have opined that contamination and other incidents that render property uninhabitable or otherwise unfit for its intended use constitutes a "physical loss."
I believe that this is the minority opinion. Moreover,
this argument would not be to the Coronavirus.
The Coronavirus issue in community associations is not really the existence of contaminated property as a result of the virus. One study concluded as follows:
“The researchers behind the new study tested the virus' life span in a 71-degree-Fahrenheit room at 65% relative humidity. After three hours, the virus had disappeared from printing and tissue paper. It took two days for it to leave wood and cloth fabric. After four days, it was no longer detectable on glass or paper money. It lasted the longest, seven days, on stainless steel and plastic.� (Business Insider, April 7, 2020 - https://www.businessinsider.com/coronavirus-lifespan-on-surfaces-graphic-2020-3)
The coronavirus issue in community associations arising out of the closing of non-essential common elements to prevent social gathering and the spread of the virus. An association not heeding governmental orders or the recommendation of virtually all health care providers what the association should be concerned with.
The coronavirus as is discussed each day all day in the news has an extremely short life. By the time that the property can be tested for any contamination by coronavirus, or the governmental orders are lifted, the existence of the coronavirus would be moot. The coronavirus would no longer exist.
The physical nature and life of the coronavirus is different than that of asbestos and mold where there are much stronger arguments that they constitute contamination of actual property damage and will not go away without remedial measures. Coronavirus will self-eliminate.
Issue No. 2: Is there coverage for testing and or remediating costs? Response No. 2: Probably Not. There is no coverage for testing or remediation costs, again if there is no direct physical damage or loss. The discussion to this response is the same as Response No. 1.
Issue No. 3:
In the unlikely event that the coronavirus is considered “property damage� will there be any
other impediment to coverage?
Response No. 3: A. Yes.
Even if the property damage is established, there are numerous exclusions that would apply.
These exclusions further support that insurers had no intent to provide coverage. B.
No.
Coverage may exist where a policy may have a specific endorsement. This is not likely for
community associations, however, because of extremely prohibitive costs. This is more likely in an industry such as Restaurants and the Hospitality industry where the significant cost can be included in the cost of doing business. These supplemental coverages in the normal course will not include the direct physical loss of damage requirement. Accordingly, the mental gymnastics of whether there is property damage or not is avoided.
Issue No. 4: Is there coverage for consequential damages such as Business Interruption, Loss of Income or Loss of Use?
Response No. 4: No. For these coverages for consequential damages, the damage must again result from Direct Physical damage or loss to The Insured(s) property. Accordingly, the same discussion in Response No. 1 above will apply here.
Keep in mind that Business Interruption insurance is intended to protect businesses against income losses sustained as a result of disruptions to their operations. Contingent business interruption coverage similarly provides insurance for financial losses resulting from disruptions to a business's customers or suppliers, usually requiring that the underlying cause of damage to the customer or supplier be of
a type covered with respect to the business's own property.
In the community association context, the interruption of operations may be argued to be the unit owner members’ inability to pay fees and assessments.
This is not the result of coronavirus in the community
association, but the result of the impact on their business or employment. This is too attenuated from the community association.
With respect to the association’s inability to pay business partners such as
landscapers, pool services or the like, the potential issue would not be a property policy issue. potential risk will a claim or suit against the association for breach of contract.
As a breach of contract
issue, there may be a defense pursuant to a Force Majeure provision in the contract (unforeseeable circumstances that prevent someone from fulfilling a contract.)
Issue No. 5: If the Board opens common elements such as pools, clubhouses and gyms, will any insurance policy defend or indemnify the Board?
Response No. 5:
No.
The
Issue No. 6:
If a unit owner or guest got sick with COVID-19 alleging the association negligently
maintained the common elements that could not be closed (i.e. Elevators, entry doors or stairways)?
Response No. 6:
Probably No.
COVID-19
Issue No. 7:
Is the COVID-19 disease covered under workers compensation policy?
Response No. 7:
No.
COVID-19
COVID-19
CONCLUSION:
In going through analysis of each issue above, it should be clear under which portion of the policy structure.
(1) Does the alleged claim meet the elements of the insuring agreement; (1) if one is satisfied,
does one of the definitions work to defeat coverage; (3) if
there are no definitions to defeat coverage,
are there any exclusions that apply and is the exclusion preclude defense and indemnity, or just indemnity still requiring the carrier pay for the defense; (4) Is there an applicable condition that has not been made, such as the time in which a claim must be reported to the carrier; and, (5) is there an endorsement that changes any terms or conditions or removes an exclusion or condition.
I always make it a practice to
review the endorsements first and be prepared to know if something I review in the actual policy has been changed.
I opine that there is not going to be coverage under any of these policies for any of the issues presented. However, that does not preclude the possibility that attorneys will not challenge the basic policy forms. Insureds will have to do a cost benefit analysis in the event there is a possibility to challenge a policy provision.
(Copyright Š 2020 Joel W. Meskin) By Joel W. Meskin, Esq., CIRMS, CCAL Fellow, MLIS, EBP THIS ARTICLE IS NOT A LEGAL OPINION, IS NOT THE POSITION OF ANY SPECIFIC INSURER OR THE MCGOWAN COMPANIES. THESE ARE THE BEST THOUGHTS OF THE AUTHOR.
Is a Community Association Responsible for the Acts of Its Volunteers? WRITTEN BY ROBYN SEVERS, BECKER LAWYERS Community associations can be a great place
-surance carrier to ensure that it has insurance
for community involvement. It is always nice to
for
see
association
members
get
involved
and
help
with
volunteer
workers.
should
not
If allow
not,
then
volunteer
the work
operating the association. However, should the
without obtaining such insurance coverage.
If
association be concerned about the actions of
there is insurance coverage, you should ensure
these volunteers?
that the person performing the work meets the definition of a volunteer, per the terms of the
An association may be held liable for the acts
insurance
policy.
Also,
there
should
be
a
of its volunteers, depending on the situation.
determination as to what work, damage, and
Accordingly, it is important to confirm that the
injury is covered per the terms of the policy.
association will be protected if something goes
a volunteer worker exceeds the scope of any
wrong. The association should contact its in-
covered work, or if the damage/injury is not
If
covered under the terms of the policy, then the association may be exposed to liability. Obviously, determining
the
scope
of
insurance
coverage
requires
a
factual
and
legal
review,
and
the
association should seek the guidance of an attorney when determining the scope of insurance coverage.
Additionally, to further assist in limiting any potential exposure to liability, an association should create a list of official duties to be performed by each volunteer and have the volunteer sign a form acknowledging that the association has only authorized the volunteer to perform the duties on the list. Volunteers should not be permitted to engage in potentially hazardous activity or any activity that involves undue physical strain. In addition, an association should: not allow volunteers to perform any services that require the use of a licensed vendor/contractor or which would require a permit. seek legal guidance on whether a licensed vendor/contractor or permit is required for the work the volunteer will be performing. consider
obtaining
releases/indemnifications
from
volunteers
performing
services
for
the
association.
While
we
understand
this
may
discourage
individuals
from
volunteering,
an
association
has
a
fiduciary obligation to its members, which could include an obligation to protect the association from potential exposures to liability. Community involvement is wonderful but protecting the association is paramount.
We miss you and can't wait to see you soon. BOARD OF DIRECTORS NORTHEAST FLORIDA CHAPTER COMMUNITY ASSOCIATIONS INSTITUTE
NEFLCAI.COM CED@NEFLCAI.COM