AN ANTITRUST REFRESHER: SETTLEMENT COMPLIANCE BY “LEGAL JOHN” JOHN WAIT General Counsel
This fall marks the three-year anniversary of the jury verdict in Burnett v. NAR, et al., and this past August marked two years since new MLS rules were instituted in response to the settlement. For anyone practicing brokerage during this time period, you know that it has been a lot of adjustment. Even some of the most recent forms changes this past July are aimed at helping members more easily comply with the settlement and giving consumers a better understanding of how broker compensation can be negotiated. Given these major milestones, it might surprise some readers to know that the Burnett case continues to be litigated as well as other cases that are part of the settlement, such as Gibson v. NAR, et al. In fact, the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals just issued an opinion about Burnett on August 19, 2026, upholding the settlement and denying the claims of several parties who objected to it. A similar decision was issued by the same court in Gibson on September 1, 2026. It is unclear whether the objectors in either case will ask the U.S. Supreme Court to weigh in. It is also unclear whether SCOTUS will take either case even if they do. The Eighth Circuit’s recent decisions reaffirm something I have been stressing in my educational sessions for a while now. Settlement compliance did not end after MLSs instituted new rules, and all members must continue to be vigilant about the core issues that caused the settlement in the first place. The settlement is about much more than a set of new rules to be followed by brokers who operate in the MLS. Burnett and Gibson are antitrust cases, and therefore, the issues that led to them involve claims of that nature. So, let’s revisit those claims, and then look at ongoing settlement compliance. 14 INSIGHT • November 2026
What were the core allegations in the Burnett case? The plaintiffs in Burnett were sellers who alleged that they overpaid commissions when selling their homes. In particular, these sellers claimed that if it were not for MLS rules that required listing agents to cooperate with and offer compensation to buyer’s agents, the sellers would have paid a lot less in commissions. Certain pieces of evidence were important factors for both the judge’s orders before trial and for the jury. Specifically, the sellers offered into evidence the MLS rules mentioned above, then-existing Standards of Practice 16-15 and 16-16, and historical rates of compensation in the Kansas City MLS and nationwide. The sellers also submitted into evidence training materials used by firms, firm policies on minimum commission rates, and data showing that agents steered their clients based on agent compensation instead of client need. Before submitting the case to the jury, the judge in Burnett noted that an antitrust conspiracy does not require an explicit agreement. The judge specifically noted that commission rates in the United States have remained unusually uniform, even with increased market pressure from real estate technology companies in the years just prior to the case. Given all the above, the judge concluded that the sellers had forecast enough evidence to send the question to the jury.
Did the changes required by the settlement fix all the issues raised in Burnett? In short, no. Look carefully again at the evidence listed above that the judge and jury in Burnett considered. Aside from revised Standards of Practice and MLS rules, do you still sometimes encounter the others? It is quite possible that you do. While none of the items above by themselves are automatically anticompetitive, they can, when put together, continue to present antitrust concerns. This means that a lot of the same evidence that caused the Burnett case still exists today, even after the settlement.
How can REALTORS® and their firms maintain settlement compliance? At a minimum, there are some rules from the settlement that members and firms must follow.
1. Offers of compensation in the MLS banned – Any offer
to pay buyer agent compensation cannot be in the MLS.
should strongly consider consulting with legal counsel and training their agents to effectively manage the following issues:
Steering Buyer agents should show their clients homes based on those clients’ needs and preferences. If the agency agreement is on the Exclusive Buyer Agency Agreement (Form 201), the buyer has agreed to pay their agent regardless of whether the seller offers compensation or not. The buyer agency agreement also makes clear that the seller has no obligation to pay the buyer’s agent.
with a buyer as their agent, you must have a written buyer agreement in place before touring a home. The agreement must specify how much you will be paid. Once fully executed, a buyer agency agreement cannot be amended to permit additional compensation unless the amendment itself complies with the settlement.
Firms and agents who steer buyers to homes just based on whether or how much buyer agent compensation is offered should review their policies to ensure compliance with both the settlement and the license law. To avoid allegations of non-compliance, buyer agents may want to stop asking sellers or listing agents ahead of an offer whether buyer agent compensation is being offered, and instead just include the buyer’s request in the offer to purchase itself.
3. Agency services are not free – Unless a broker’s services
Negotiating buyer agent compensation
4. Sellers must agree in advance to any compensation
As the MLS rule above states, a seller must be informed in writing that agent commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable. The Exclusive Right to Sell Listing Agreement (Form 101) fulfills this requirement and makes clear that even if the seller authorizes the listing firm to advertise buyer agent compensation, the final amount is negotiable and subject to the seller’s final agreement in a written contract.
2. Written buyer agreements – If you are working
are, in fact, free, then the broker should not advertise that they are.
paid by listing firm to a buyer agent – If the listing firm is going to offer or pay any compensation to a buyer’s agent, then they must obtain the seller’s consent in advance.
5. Disclosure of negotiability of agent commissions – Both buyers and sellers must be informed that brokerage commissions are not set by law and are fully negotiable.
Beyond the above minimum rules, the parties objecting to the settlement raised the following issues in their court briefs. Given how the issues raised in these court briefs overlap with the evidence above in the Burnett case, members and firms
Firms and agents who adopt a policy setting a minimum that the seller must offer in order to be a client should review those policies with counsel to ensure compliance. Especially now that buyer agent compensation can be negotiated as a term of the purchase contract, listing agents should negotiate this contract term as aggressively as they would any other contract term for their seller.
ncrealtors.org • INSIGHT 15
Accurate information about written buyer agreements As stated above, a written buyer agreement is required before touring a home if brokerage services are going to be provided to the buyer as their agent. This means you do not need a written buyer agreement to show a home to a buyer if you are going to be acting only as a listing agent or a seller subagent. Firms should make sure their agents provide accurate information to buyers to avoid allegations that their agents are requiring buyers to sign unnecessary agency agreements just to gain clients. Admittedly, the above scenarios are difficult to deal with. They all involve complicated and difficult conversations between agents and consumers.
That said, these conversations must be had, and they must have factual information as a base. It may be hard to believe, but settlement compliance will expire in August 2031, because it is only effective for seven years. We are already two years in.
What will happen in August 2031? I will be honest and tell you that I am horrible at predicting the future. My lawyer training has beaten all optimism out of my system, unfortunately. Or maybe it was my teenagers . . . Anyway, I do not know what will happen. What I can say is that firms and agents who prioritize going beyond minimum settlement compliance will be the most prepared for what comes.
STUCK ON A CONTRACT?
CALL THE LEGAL HOTLINE.
Quick Resolution. Unlimited Access. Included with your membership. (And worth about $300/hour.) 336.294.1415 | legalhotline@ncrealtors.org 16 INSIGHT • November 2026