N
N A N T U C K E T ’ S
PERSON of the YEAR DR. TIM LEPORE
HUNTING FOR SOLUTIONS TO
THE TICK CRISIS
NANTUCKET’S DWINDLING
MIDDLE CLASS
MARK CUTONE RESTORES
DEAN MARTIN’S HOUSE REVISITING THE LEGACY OF
WINTER 2026
WALTER BEINECKE
Spectacular Cliff Property 84 Cliff Road
Newly Constructed in Cliff | Offered at $14,500,000
New Construction
Welcome to 84 Cliff Road, a spectacular newly constructed home in Nantucket’s sought-after Cliff neighborhood. Designed with sophisticated finishes and effortless indoor-outdoor living in mind, the property offers six bedrooms and six-and-a-half baths across three levels, including spacious living and dining areas, a gourmet kitchen, guest accommodations, and a finished lower level. Outdoors, a private pool, landscaped patio spaces, and charming guest cottage complete the setting. Less than half a mile from the beach and downtown, 84 Cliff Road combines luxury, privacy, and convenience.
6 Bedrooms | 6.5 Bathrooms Private Pool Guest Accommodations Finished Lower Level Close to Town + Beach
Gary Winn
Morgan Winn
Derek Dohanos
Principal Broker 508.330.3069 gary@maurypeople.com
Sales Associate 508.332.9088 morgan@maurypeople.com
Sales Associate 419.309.7088 derek@maurypeople.com
Maury People Sotheby’s International Realty
Each Office is Independently Owned and Operated. Equal Housing Opportunity.
37 Main Street, Nantucket MA 02554 | www.maurypeople.com 2
N
M A G A Z I N E
Custom Interior & Exterior Door Designs WINDOW & DOOR GALLERY 4 Bayberry Ct. • marinehomecenter.com • 508-228-0900 N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
3
WE REPRESENT RELATIONSHIPS
We are an independent family business, not Wall Street firm. With the freedom to put our clients first, always. Offering fully integrated Elite Concierge Services for real estate, mortgage, insurance, and wealth management. Investing in Raveis365+ AI technology to deliver you the highest standard of personalized service. William Raveis. The highest standard in real estate. Who represents you matters.
508.228.9117 | 17 MAIN ST | NANTUCKET | MA 02554 4
N
M A G A Z I N E
photo byWendy Mills
k at h l e e n h ay d e s i g n s nantucket & beyond her shores
t 508.228.1219
www.kathleenhaydesigns.com N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
5
A Safe Place, Island Kitchen’s emergency food fund partnership
Nantucket Book Foundation
Elder Services of Cape Cod & the Islands, Our Island Home
Housing Nantucket
A Thriving Nantucket Depends on ALL of Us.
Please help the Community Foundation make a difference by donating to The Nantucket Fund, our permanent grantmaking fund that suports critical programs and initiatives essential to our Islanders’ wellbeing, convening community leaders, and guiding informed philanthropy. This year, The Nantucket Fund has provided $1 million in grants to local nonprofits. Currently, we are only able to meet about half of the requests from organizations on the front lines helping those who are coping with personal struggles, in need of food or safe housing, searching for affordable childcare, and hoping to age in place with dignity. Your gift means more neighbors in need can be supported. Together, we can keep Nantucket thriving today and for generations to come.
Please give generously to CFNAN.org
6
Nantucket Boys and Girls Club, Our House, N MTide A G A Z I N E Rising Pre-School, St. Mary’s Parish
B-ACK Yard BBQ warm meals partnership with The Warming Place
PASCON, Fairwinds, Nantucket Cottage Hospital
A Note From Nantucket... The Landing
C II
SA
E
·
AN
N
Your next chapter in Nantucket awaits.
P E R PLA
·
There’s something special about finding a place on Nantucket that feels ready from the moment you arrive. At Sandpiper Place II, a final collection of newly built homes is now available, including fully furnished residences ready for immediate move-in. Just moments from town, each home offers the comfort and ease of a thoughtfully finished Nantucket residence, complemented by the private Club, The Landing, with outdoor heated pool, fitness center, and more.
PI
N
D
Dear Future Neighbor,
T U CKET M
A
Future Neighbor Sandpiper Place II, Final Phase Nantucket, Massachusetts 02554
Sandpiper Place II P.S. 7 OPPORTUNITIES TO OWN. PRICED FROM $2,295,000*
FINAL PHASE: GOING...GOING... ALMOST GONE...
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
7
Making Seasons Bright. Rudolph may handle one night a year. Jobe Systems takes care of the other 364. From elegant lighting and automated shades to whole-home audio and smart control, we create spaces that feel warm, welcoming, and ready for every celebration. Make every season bright with Jobe Systems.
INTEGRATED TECHNOLOGY SYSTEMS jobesystems.com | 508.332.4950
8
N
M A G A Z I N E
Elevated Living on Boston’s Greenway The most anticipated boutique condominium collection arrives early 2027.
55india.com
CONTENTS / W I N T E R 2 0 2 6
16 CONTRIBUTORS Meet the talented group of writers and photographers who helped make this issue possible. 18 N TOP TEN All the places you need to be and see. 20 NECESSITIES Put these items on your winter wish list. 22 BY THE NUMBERS A numerical snapshot of Nantucket this season.
110 High Fashion at Egan Maritime
24 KID’N AROUND How to keep your kiddos entertained this winter. 26 NBUZZ All the news, tidbits and scuttlebutt that’s fit to print, courtesy of the Nantucket Current. 28 NEED TO READ Tim Ehrenberg of Tim Talks Books gives his winter reading list.
1 0
N
M A G A Z I N E
HER SWEATER: SOUTHERN TIDE SKIRT AND BAG: MURRAY’S TOGGERY SHOP EARRINGS AND NECKLACE: KATHERINE GROVER RING: DARYA SPA AND SALON HIM SWEATER: RESPOKE SHIRT, PANTS, BELT, WATCH AND BRACELET: MURRAY'S TOGGERY SHOP
NGREDIENTS 32 Pizza Napoletana from Chef Elio DiMambro
NOSH NEWS
NQUIRY
36 Raising the bar: Inside Nantucket’s two new lounges
46 Select Board Member Bobby DeCosta
34 Four drinks to toast to the holidays
40 Nantucket’s Person of the Year: Dr. Tim Lepore
92 Decking the Traps
NDEPTH
52 The Man Who Reimagined Nantucket Revisiting the Legacy of Walter Beinecke
66
Sailing the Chugalugatug Nantucket’s little wooden cruise
60 Searching for the Holy Rail One man sets out for a lost railroad engine
70
Time to Cull the Herd? How to combat Nantucket’s tick problem
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 1
60
Searching for the Holy Rail
NVESTIGATE
76 Nantucket’s Missing Middle Nantucket’s middle class faces a worsening housing crisis. 80 Drought? What Drought? Are the concerns real or exaggerated?
NDESIGN
86 That’s Amore! Nantucket Architect Mark Cutone Restores Dean Martin’s Palm Springs Home
Winter 2026
DR. TIM LEPORE
Dr. Tim Lepore with his late hawk Ajax Photo by Kit Noble HUNTING FOR SOLUTIONS TO
THE TICK CRISIS
NANTUCKET’S DWINDLING
MIDDLE CLASS
fishernantucket.com
MARK CUTONE RESTORES
DEAN MARTIN’S HOUSE
Nantucket Magazine
21 Main Street, Nantucket, MA | 508.228.4407
92 Decking the Traps Dan Pronk’s lobster trap tree
ON THE COVER
The Local Magazine Read Worldwide
ttable egins here
N
NSPIRE
N A N T U C K E T ’ S
PERSON of the YEAR
REVISITING THE LEGACY OF
WINTER 2026
WALTER BEINECKE
96 Hope in Times of Need Barnaby’s Cares’ Art Kits 100 Hitting the Ground Running Kezia Duarte’s path to all six major marathons 104 Betsey Minihan retires after 53 years at Nantucket Cottage Hospital. 106 Gridiron Grannies Nantucket’s Patriots Ladies keep their tradition alive.
1 2
N
M A G A Z I N E
NVOGUE
110 Night at the Museum High Fashion at Egan Maritime
NHA
FOGGY SHEET NUPTIALS
123 Open Season 128 A recap of the island’s Bay scalloping hottest events. through the years
132 Frances Walsh and Connor Rice tie the knot.
66 Inside The Chugalugatug
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 3
N PUBLISHER & EDITOR-IN-CHIEF Bruce A. Percelay
EDITORIAL DIRECTOR Brian Bushard
ART DIRECTOR Paulette Chevalier
DIRECTOR OF ADVERTISING & PARTNERSHIPS Emme Duncan
CHIEF PHOTOGRAPHER Kit Noble
FASHION PHOTOGRAPHER Brian Sager
ADVERTISING COORDINATOR Lola Piuggi
NANTUCKET CURRENT
Jason Graziadei, Editor in Chief David Creed, Deputy Editor JohnCarl McGrady, News Reporter
CONTRIBUTORS Darya Afshari Gault Mary Bergman Jack Bradner Jurgita Budaite Khuyen Dinh Tim Ehrenberg Petra Hoffmann Larry Lindner Wendy Rouillard Jonathan Soroff John Stanielon John Stanton
PHOTOGRAPHERS Charity Grace Mofsen Brian Sager Chris Tran
PUBLISHER N. LLC
CHAIRMAN: Bruce A. Percelay First Nantucket Media 17 North Beach Street Nantucket, MA 02554 508-228-1515
A Local Financial Partner You Can Trust for All Your Wealth Needs Investment Management • Retirement & Financial Planning Trust & Estate Services • Nonprofit Services • Socially Responsible Investing
Reach out to us. We’re here to help. capecodfive.com • 877-409-5600 112 Pleasant Street NOT A DEPOSIT • NOT FDIC-INSURED • NOT INSURED BY ANY FEDERAL GOVERNMENT AGENCY • NOT GUARANTEED BY THE BANK • MAY GO DOWN IN VALUE
THE CHRISTMAS COLLECTION SMALL CHRISTMAS DORY PENDANT LARGE CHRISTMAS DORY PENDANT CHRISTMAS DORY BROOCH AVAILABLE AT: SYLVIA ANTIQUES | 15 MAIN STREET, NANTUCKET | (508) 228-0960
TWO HOLIDAY TRUNK SHOWS Black Friday, November 27 and Saturday, November 28 Stroll Weekend, Friday, December 4 and Saturday, December 5 11am - 5pm Sylvia Antiques, 15 Main Street
©Copyright 2026 First Nantucket Media. First Nantucket Media (N Magazine) is published six times annually from April through December. Reproduction of any part of this publication is prohibited without written permission from the publisher. Editorial submissions may be sent to Editor, First Nantucket Media, 17 North Beach Street, Nantucket, MA 02554. We are not responsible for unsolicited editorial or graphic material. Office (508) 228-1515 or fax (508) 228-8012. Signature Printing and Consulting 800 West Cummings Park Suite 2900 Woburn
WWW.KATHERINEGROVERFINEJEWELRY.COM | CALL (646) 896-4013 1 4
N
M A G A Z I N E
Publisher’s Letter
The Irreplaceable
DR. TIM LEPORE N
antucket is known for its enduring landmarks,
Beyond his work in the
from Brant Point Lighthouse to the Old Mill, the
medical field, Lepore has
Whaling Museum, the Atheneum and more. However,
emerged as an important
if ever there was an individual on the island who has
member of the Nantucket School
truly achieved landmark status, it is Dr. Tim Lepore.
Committee, which he has served
With a career that has spanned 45 years at Nantucket
on for over 40 years, all while
Cottage Hospital, where he has interacted with tens
supporting the schools’ athletic
of thousands of patients, Lepore has had an impact
programs as the athletic doctor.
like no other. Eccentric, fearless and strong willed,
As the public schools have
Lepore’s medical stories have become legend,
expanded, Lepore has been a stalwart for results-driven
including the time he saved the life of a stabbing
educational programming targeting everything from
victim by putting his fingers inside the person’s chest
reading to teaching students with learning disabilities.
cavity to restart his heart. Wherever there is a pressing issue on Nantucket,
BRUCE A. PERCELAY Publisher
Now 81, Lepore is offering his expertise at a time when the lone star tick has emerged as one of the most
Dr. Lepore seems to be at the forefront. Over the last
pressing public health issues on Nantucket. While
few decades, he has become the go-to person for those
lone star ticks represent a new variation of tick-borne
who have contracted tick-borne illnesses. He has been
concerns, one can be assured that Dr. Lepore’s historical
so impactful in regard to tick matters on Nantucket
knowledge will play a role in addressing the problem
that in 2013, author Pam Belluck authored a non-
going forward.
fiction book called Island Practice detailing Lepore’s
Lepore is indeed an irreplaceable asset to Nantucket,
many exploits, which is reportedly in development for
and his wide-ranging skill set is not likely to be
a television production.
replicated. For his service to the island, both past and
As drug abuse on Nantucket has become a major
present, N Magazine has selected Dr. Tim Lepore as
health issue, Lepore founded Addiction Solutions,
Nantucket’s Person of the Year, and we are grateful for
an organization that, for many people, has literally
his service.
saved their lives. While topics like alcoholism and substance abuse tend to be stigmatized and discussed
Sincerely,
only in hushed tones, the fact is they have affected thousands of islanders. Last year alone, Lepore interacted with 230 people through Addiction Solutions, providing treatment for anyone who
Bruce A. Percelay
needs it.
Publisher
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 5
Contributors
John STANTON Khuyen DINH Khuyen Dinh is a freelance journalist from the Virginia suburbs of Washington, D.C. She earned her bachelor's degree from the University of Virginia and a master's degree in journalism from Northwestern University's Medill School of Journalism. Her reporting has appeared in The Skimm, Well+Good, UVA Today, SB Nation and other publications, with work spanning sports, health, lifestyle and culture.
1 6
N
M A G A Z I N E
John Stanton is a journalist and documentary filmmaker living on Nantucket. He was previously the editor of Nantucket Today and an award-winning reporter for The Inquirer and Mirror, where he covered town and state politics, the impacts of sea-level rise and erosion, and the housing crisis on the island. He is married to Marianne Stanton, former publisher of The Inquirer and Mirror, and has raised three now-grown children. For this issue of N Magazine, John Stanton interviews Kezia Duarte, a nurse, musician and now marathon runner looking to complete all six World Majors.
Larry LINDNER Larry Lindner is a New York Times bestselling author who also penned a nationally syndicated column for The Washington Post for several years. His writing has appeared in The Los Angeles Times, The Boston Globe Sunday Magazine, Condé Nast Traveler and Reader’s Digest. In this issue of N Magazine, Lindner writes about the dual housing and affordability crises pricing out the working class on Nantucket, and the struggles of employers to hire and retain their staff.
B O S TO N
NANTUCKET
CAPE COD N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 7
10 Events for Winter
n top ten
11/19-12/24
11/26
Artists Association of Nantucket
Children’s Beach
HOLIDAY WORKS EXHIBITION
The Artists Association of Nantucket wraps up its 2026 season with its annual Holiday Works exhibition, offering everything from the perfect stocking stuffers to Yuletide masterpieces. Check out works from local artists at the AAN’s Cecelia Joyce and Seward Johnson Gallery at 8 Federal Street, with a Holiday Open House reception on December 4 at 5 p.m. nantucketarts.org
11/24-12/5
FESTIVAL OF WREATHS Thomas Macy Warehouse
Haul out the holly! The Nantucket Historical Association’s annual Festival of Wreaths takes over the historic Macy Warehouse to ring in the holiday season. For two weeks, the museum is adorned with dozens of decorative wreaths designed by local shops, restaurants, schools and nonprofits. Free to the public, with a preview party on November 23. nha.org
11/24-12/6
ELIN HILDERBRAND’S WINTER STREET Theatre Workshop of Nantucket
Back by popular demand, Winter Street returns to Bennett Hall to close out Theatre Workshop of Nantucket’s 70th season on the island. The adaptation of Elin Hilderbrand’s 2014 novel Winter Street follows the Quinn family through holiday magic, weddings, insider trading, new loves, old loves and lots of laughs. theatrenantucket.org
1 8
N
M A G A Z I N E
COLD TURKEY PLUNGE Support the Nantucket Atheneum in the 25th annual Cold Turkey Plunge at Children’s Beach, a festive event daring children and adults alike to brave the frigid harbor waters in a wetsuit or bathing suit for a quick dip at 10 a.m. on Thanksgiving morning. Proceeds support the Atheneum’s Weezie Library for children and its free, year-round programming. nantucketatheneum.org
11/27
CHRISTMAS TREE LIGHTING CEREMONY
As downtown Nantucket embraces the holiday spirit with more than 150 decorated trees lining the streets, there’s no Christmas tree as big or as bright as the one at the top of Main Street. At 4 p.m. on the Friday after Thanksgiving, that tree will be lit to the tune of Christmas carols, officially kicking off the holiday season. nantucketchamber.org
12/4-6
CHRISTMAS STROLL
Whether you’re on the island year-round or just visiting for the weekend, Christmas Stroll is the perfect opportunity to experience Nantucket this holiday season, all while supporting local businesses. Over the past 52 years, Stroll has become the preeminent off-season weekend on the island, with craft fairs, a magical talking tree and a visit from Santa himself. nantucketchamber.org
12/4
DECK THE WHARF BASH Straight Wharf Fish
The Maria Mitchell Association’s holiday party is back for its third year, taking over Straight Wharf Fish on the Friday of Stroll. Try extravagant bites, caviar and burgers from the team at Straight Wharf, while raising a glass of champagne and rocking around the Christmas tree in support of the Maria Mitchell Association’s year-round programming. mariamitchell.org
12/4-31
FESTIVAL OF TREES Whaling Museum
The Nantucket Historical Association’s annual Festival of Trees is back this December, transforming the Whaling Museum and the Candle Factory into a winter wonderland of unique and beautifully decorated trees. Free admission for island residents and NHA members, with a preview party December 3. (Closed Christmas Day) nha.org
12/5
LIGHTHOUSE SCHOOL YULETIDE FAIR White Elephant Ballroom
The Nantucket Lighthouse School’s annual Yuletide Fair offers everything from handmade crafts, heirloom gifts and local artwork, to a holiday bake shop, warm hot chocolate and can’t-miss festive activities for children. You’ll be sure to find something at the fair at the White Elephant Ballroom. nantucketlighthouseschool.org
12/31
NEW YEAR’S EVE GALA Nantucket Hotel
An elegant way to welcome 2027, the Nantucket Hotel’s New Year’s Eve Gala provides a chef-curated three-course a la carte menu, caviar, oysters, fine wines and live piano music. After dinner, dance the night away at the hotel late-night party, with hors d’oeuvres, drinks and a DJ set to enter the new year in style. thenantuckethotel.com
BERNADETTEMEYER.COM
Distinctive Homes. Exceptional Addresses.
7 Brewster Road | Monomoy
34 Hulbert Avenue | Brant Point
$18,750,000
$10,750,000
9 BR | 10 BA | 1 HB
7 BR | 3 BA | 1 HB
Bernadette Meyer Real Estate Broker License# 9503060 508.680.4748 bernadette @maurypeople.com
17 Ipswich Street | Tom Nevers
44 Madequecham Valley Road
$7,195,000
$4,995,000
7 BR | 6 BA | 1 HB
3 BR | 2 BA
©2026 Sotheby’s International Realty. All Rights Reserved. Sotheby’s International Realty® is a registered trademark and used with permission. Each Sotheby’s International Realty office is independently owned and operated except those operated by Sotheby’s International Realty. Inc. All offerings are subiect to errors, omissions, changes including price or withdrawal without notice. Equal Housing Opportunity
12 Myles Standish Street | Surfside $3,500,000 Land
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 9
n ecessities SIMON PEARCE NEGRONI SET Raise a glass to this timeless collection celebrating craft cocktails born in NYC and artisanal Vermont glassware. The ultimate Negroni-lover’s gift containing one Classic Negroni, one White Negroni, a stirrer, and a pair of Simon Pearce hand-blown Greenwich Lowball tumblers. VIA CAROTA @viacarotacraftcocktails drinkviacarota.com
FORK + CHOPSTICKS COOKBOOK From classically trained chefs Mei Liu and Kyong Han – the duo behind the popular food blog Two Plaid Aprons – comes a versatile and accessible Asian-inspired cookbook. With easy-to-follow steps, each recipe honors traditional methods and essential ingredients while remaining achievable for cooks of any skill level. NANTUCKET BOOK PARTNERS @nantucketbooks • nantucketbookpartners.com
SOUL 92 OPEN SKIS The new Sender Soul 92 is the ski of choice for anyone who would like to enjoy the sensation of freeride without compromising the resort experience. Thanks to its sidewall construction, the ski will deliver the right level of grip and performance, while the AirTip will increase the flotation. ROSSIGNOL @rossignol • rossignol.com
NANTUCKET BRACELET
WINTER WISH LIST
Your favorite island, in bracelet form. Crafted in 14k yellow gold and adjustable in length, the Nantucket Bracelet is the perfect addition to your stack – or a meaningful gift for someone who loves the island just as much as you do. ANNA P. JAY @annapjay annapjay.com
THE ARIA MIRROR
COTTON WEIGHTED BLANKET This buttery soft and breathable organic cotton weighted blanket is ideal for all seasons. Crafted to help you fall asleep faster and feel calmer naturally, whether a cat nap or overnight slumber, you’ll wake feeling rested and revitalized. BEARABY @mybearaby • bearaby.com
2 0
N
M A G A Z I N E
The Aria Mirror is inspired by the transformation of natural materials. A Sandblasted White Oak frame lends a tactile, textural presence, while the smoked mirror drapes across it in a fluid gesture that softens the structure. MAIDEN HOME @maidenhome maidenhome.com
C E L E B R AT I N G T H E H O L I D AY S I N S C A N D I N AV I A N S T Y L E
S
E
VAN BREE ISH M LE
HOME
E L E I S H VA N B R E E M S H O M E WESTPORT • NANTUCKET • NEW PRESTON | @ELEISHVANBREEMS N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
2 1
n an t u ck e t b y th e n u m b e r s
$
1.1
1,604
Billion
The total 2026 dollar volume of Nantucket real estate transactions through mid-October.
Students enrolled at Nantucket Public Schools, a nine-year low.
90,000
18,259 Parking tickets issued between June and September.
3
Mudslides sold at the Gazebo in its final year.
1
RD
Place
Whalers football defensive back Kyden Whitfield’s jawdropping interception in Sports Center’s Top 10 on ESPN.
5.74
150
Offered by the Nantucket Conservation Foundation to each hunter who donates a deer to Nourish Nantucket.
The price for a gallon of gas on Nantucket, as of mid-October.
300
Lobster traps in Dan Pronk’s Christmas tree.
N
M A G A Z I N E
Minutes viewed of Elin Hilderbrand’s The Five Star Weekend in its first week on Peacock.
$
$
2 2
Billion
45
$
Million
For a recently listed residential property along the Cliff, which if purchased, would be a state record.
Envision What’s Next
4 Cathcart Road
54 & 56 Meadow View Drive
Monomoy | 7+ Acres | $11,750,000
Hummock Pond | 5 BR, 4 BA | $5,995,000
47 Hi nsdal e Road
1 H o o p er Fa r m Roa d
Mid Island | 6 BR, 5/2 BA | $3,995,000
Mid Island | 0 BR, 0/2 BA | $3,000,000
3 Hooper Farm Road
2 Fo r rest Ave nue, # 3
Mid Island | 6 BR, 3/2 BA | $3,000,000
Mid Island | 2 BR, 2 BA | $2,395,000
Gary Winn Principal Broker Call: 508.330.3069 gary@maurypeople.com
Morgan Winn Sales Associate Call: 508.332.9088 morgan@maurypeople.com
Maury People Sotheby’s International Realty 37 Main Street, Nantucket MA 02554 www.maurypeople.com
Each Office is Independently Owned and Operated. Equal Housing Opportunity. N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
2 3
sweatshirts through size 14. Open daily from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. at 19 Main Street, with shipping and delivery available. Peachtreekidsnantucket.com, @peachtreekidsnantucket.
CREATE DURING THE HOLIDAYS WITH BARNABY’S TOY & ART Barnaby’s Toy & Art, located at 12 Oak Street in downtown Nantucket, offers a variety of Holiday art classes for children ages two and up from Thanksgiving through Stroll, with classes ranging from Holiday Ornaments to Gingerbread Houses, Holiday Winter Wonderlands and much more. Barnaby’s also features a thoughtfully curated collection of art kits, toys and creative gifts to enjoy at home, on the go or wherever inspiration strikes. Barnaby’s proudly introduces Barnaby’s Cares, a charitable foundation dedicated to bringing the healing power of creativity to children facing life-altering diagnoses. barnabysworld.com, @barnabystoyandart. HOLIDAY TRADITIONS WITH THE NHA Visit the Nantucket Historical Association’s Whaling Museum for a winter wonderland this holiday season, with two island traditions: the Festival of Wreaths and the Festival of Trees. Each year, community members, merchants, organizations, artists and school children design more than 80 trees and wreaths, transforming the museums into a festive celebration of Nantucket’s creativity and holiday spirit for all ages to enjoy. Admission is free for the year-round community and NHA members. nha.org, @ackhistory. LET CREATIVITY SHINE AT THE AAN Give your child the opportunity to imagine, create and grow at the Artists Association of Nantucket’s Visual Arts Center at 24 Amelia Drive, with after-school classes, seasonal workshops and hands-on creative experiences for children and teens this winter. For children ages 4-5, the AAN’s Exploring Art program provides hands-on mixed-media projects that spark imagination and creative expression. Children ages 6-9 can explore mixedmedia art and clay; children ages 9–12 can develop skills through drawing, painting, seasonal crafts and three-dimensional construction projects; children ages 10–14 can participate in wheel throwing and the fundamentals of ceramics; and teenagers ages 15 and up can build technical skills through wheel throwing and workshops
2 4
N
M A G A Z I N E
created specifically for adolescent artists. Thanks to the generosity of the Nantucket Golf Club Foundation, AAN youth program tuition is discounted by 25%. Additional tuition assistance is also available. Winter Youth Program registration opens December 3. nantucketarts.org, @ackartists. STEP INTO THE MAGIC OF THE SEASON AT PEACHTREE KIDS & MONOGRAM Peachtree Kids offers a thoughtfully curated collection of timeless classics and fresh, stylish finds for infants through size 14. The shop proudly supports small, women-owned, and sustainable brands, including Joy Street, Nantucket Kids, Oso & Me, Timo & Violet, The Beaufort Bonnet Company, Bits & Bows, Rylee & Cru, Piping Prints, as well as a charming selection of locally inspired children’s books, including Nantucket Nelly, 1-2-3 ACK!, Thank You, Nantucket, Barnaby Bear, and ACK, the Nantucket Duckling. Make every gift extra special with inhouse monogramming and embroidery. Add a child’s name, initials or a sweet embroidered detail to sweaters, pajamas, stockings and more. This holiday season, look for Christmas stockings with complimentary monogramming, and the exclusive Nantucket Stroll print, created by local illustrator, Tori Samuel, which is available on cozy pajamas and
EXPLORE AND LEARN THIS WINTER WITH THE MMA Throughout the school year, the Maria Mitchell Association invites children and families to explore Nantucket’s sky, land and sea through hands-on science and discovery. Visit the Hinchman House Natural Science Museum at 7 Milk Street to meet live animals and discover the remarkable biodiversity of the island. Throughout the year, families can enjoy programs such as Ravenous Reptiles, Nature Story Hour, Weekend Crafting, Sensational Science and other engaging science-based activities. For those fascinated by the stars, stargazing programs at Loines Observatory offer a chance to explore the night sky, while MMA’s After-School Discovery programs provide children with opportunities to learn, experiment and explore beyond the classroom. Each March, the MMA’s STEAM Festival brings families together to discover science, technology, engineering, art and math through interactive experiences and activities. mariamitchell.org, @maria_mitchell_association. SHINE AT THE NANTUCKET STAGE COMPANY Nantucket Stage Company is gearing up for a winter of unforgettable performances for the whole family. Based on the beloved DreamWorks film, How to Train Your Dragon Jr. flies onto the stage in January, and just in time for its 50th anniversary, Annie Jr. opens in February. Set your alarms for November 25, when registration opens for NSC's summer season of shows and classes, including our highly anticipated productions of Matilda Jr. and West Side Story. Discover what makes NSC one of the island's most exciting arts organizations. Through professional-quality productions, inspiring classes, and exceptional theatre training, students build confidence, develop lifelong friendships, and discover their creative voices. Nantucketstagecompany. org, @nantucketstagecompany.
POLPIS 256 Polpis Road | $33,000,000
QUIDNET 9 Sesachacha Road | $11,650,000
NAUSHOP 14 Goldfinch Drive | $2,395,000
MONOMOY 34 Brewster Road | $15,995,000
MADEQUECHAM 10 Waquoit Road | $6,995,000
SCONSET 110 Baxter Road | $6,550,000
SCONSET 86 Baxter Road | $1,995,000
MID-ISLAND 20 Bartlett Road | $1,425,000
CLIFF 15 Hallowell Lane | $22,000,000
Great Point Properties sold 30% of all listings on Nantucket in 2025, totaling $475,000,000 on 94 transactions. 1 NORTH BEACH STREET NANTUCKET, MA 02554 508.228.2266
6 MAIN STREET SIASCONSET, MA 02564 508.257.6335 N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
2 5
nbuzz
REPORTED BY THE NANTUCKET CURRENT
NHA REMOVES OLD MILL'S TOP IN ONGOING RESTORATION
TEEN REELS
NANTUCKET’S FIRST EVER
CUBERA SNAPPER
Fourteen-year-old Stone Fornes thought he had a shark on the line on a late August evening as he was fishing along Nantucket’s south shore. But what he reeled in was far more surprising, a cubera snapper, believed to be the first one ever caught from a Nantucket beach. “I was in absolute shock that there was one cruising the south shore of Nantucket,” Fornes told the Current. Growing up to five feet long and weighing 125 pounds, cubera snappers are the largest snapper species in the Atlantic. While their official range extends from South America all the way up to Nova Scotia, they are rarely caught north of Florida. In Massachusetts, there is no official state record for a cubera snapper, as the species isn’t even listed in the state’s Saltwater Game Fish Records table. And while they are supposedly good eating, Fornes said he released the one he caught back into the surf.
The next phase of repairs on the Old Mill got underway this fall with the removal of both the cap of the mill, which can be turned to face the wind, and the long tail pole that extends from the side of the mill directly opposite where the sails would usually be. The work gave islanders a unique opportunity to see the Prospect Street windmill disassembled. The cap weighed an estimated 9,000 pounds, while the tail pole is believed to weigh 4,200 to 4,800 pounds, according to Husk Preservation's Amy Boyce, who completed the work with Toscana Corp. Built in 1746 and purchased by the Nantucket Historical Association in 1897, the Old Mill is believed to be the oldest working mill in the United States—although it has not operated for over two years. Like many restoration projects, there is more to restoring this mill than what meets the eye. When the Nantucket Historical Association set out to restore the historic building two years ago, they uncovered mysteries that they were not expecting, forcing them to embark on the biggest restoration of the mill in its 280-year history. “Removing the cap is a delicate, yet vital step in the restoration process. And from our knowledge, this will be the first time the cap has ever been temporarily lifted off the structure,” NHA executive director Niles Parker said.
NANTUCKET GETS THE FLOCK OUT
After a contentious month of debates in public meetings, online posts and in letters to the editor, the Select Board voted unanimously in September to take down the controversial Flock automatic license plate readers at the corner of Easy Street and Broad Street, joining a growing wave of towns across the country that have ended contracts with the surveillance company. While the Nantucket Police Department has long maintained that the cameras are a useful law enforcement tool and have helped solve crimes on the island, there was
2 6
N
M A G A Z I N E
an outpouring of public opposition over privacy concerns and mass surveillance, with the footage recorded being vulnerable to exploitation by police officers and cyberattacks. Still, some town officials wonder if taking them down was a step too far. “My concern here is, what do we lose in terms of policing if we take away this tool?” Select Board member Brooke Mohr said. “If we’re going to remove these, I would like the police chief to consider an alternative version of this that would then be vetted more broadly among the community if we decided to bring it back.”
NOR’EASTER UNCOVERS SHIPWRECK
The September nor’easter that unleashed powerful wind and three inches of rain on the island also provided an unexpected discovery. On the south shore, where pounding waves caused significant erosion in some places, the storm revealed the remains of a shipwreck. The large fragment that became exposed at the drive-on beach access near the sewer beds first appeared to be the 19th-century coastal schooner Warren Sawyer, a wooden ship that wrecked near Miacomet Beach on December 22, 1884 on its way from New Orleans to Boston. Pieces of that wreck had previously been exposed in another storm in 2022. Several weeks after the September nor’easter, however, a chief archaeologist of the Massachusetts Board of Underwater Archaeological Resources traveled to Nantucket to examine the wreck. When he saw it, he said the wreck looked “very different” than the Warren Sawyer. The newly exposed remains appear to be from the late
19th or early 20th century, according to David Robinson, the state archaeologist. But they also appear “significantly larger” than the previously exposed wreck. “Archaeological sites are like puzzles without the box top,” he said. “Most of the pieces are missing, and the ones we have have been chewed on by the dog. They’re just intriguing puzzles to try to piece together, and the way we do that is we look at the archaeological evidence, we look at the historical record, and try to make correlations and connect the dots between those two bodies of information.”
NANTUCKET COTTAGE HOSPITAL NAMED 10TH MOST BEAUTIFUL HOSPITAL IN AMERICA The Nantucket Cottage Hospital was named the 10th “Most Beautiful Hospital In America” in Soliant Health’s 2026 Most Beautiful Hospitals contest, earning national recognition following weeks of public voting. NCH was one of 57 facilities nationwide that advanced to the public voting stage of Soliant’s 14th annual contest, which celebrates healthcare organizations that stand out for the environments they create for patients, families, healthcare professionals, and their communities. Soliant Health said in a release that Nantucket Cottage Hospital
was nominated for its welcoming island setting, thoughtful design, and the warmth and compassion of its staff. “Seasonal touches, from hydrangeas and a whale-tail statue in the courtyard to warm interior lighting and peaceful views in winter, reflect the hospital’s connection to Nantucket,” the organization stated. “Its friendly, attentive staff and strong community atmosphere further help create an environment where patients and families can feel comfortable and supported, helping Nantucket Cottage Hospital earn the number 10 spot nationwide.”
SCAN FOR MORE INFO
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
2 7
n e e d to re ad
Tim Ehrenberg, creator of “Tim Talks Books” and president of the Nantucket Book Foundation, recommends holiday gifts for the readers in your life. W R I T T E N
B Y
T I M
E H R E N B E R G
TIM’S TOP 10 FAVORITE BOOKS OF 2026
SEVEN ANTICIPATED BOOKS FOR 2027
The Calamity Club by Kathryn Stockett Whistler by Ann Patchett Kin by Tayari Jones The Things We Never Say by Elizabeth Strout The Rush by Nathaniel Philbrick Good People by Patmeena Sabit Miss Wolcott’s Ghost by Louise Penny Hollow Bones by Jodi Picoult The Disappearers by Marlon James John of John by Douglas Stuart
In One Brief Moment All Eternity by Elif Shafak (January) Twist by Alice Feeney (February) The Ace of Spades by Sara DiVello (March) Christabel by Kate Morton (March) Serious Music by Percival Everett (March) Dead in the Water: The Lost Passengers of Titanic by Caitlin Doughty (April) Heart of the Wild by Patti Callahan Henry (April)
All books are available in store at Mitchell’s Book Corner and Nantucket Bookworks or online at nantucketbookpartners.com. Follow @timtalksbooks for more book recommendations all year long.
2 8
N
M A G A Z I N E
SCAN HERE to connect with @TimTalksBooks
For the armchair detectives: MISS WOLCOTT’S GHOST LOUISE PENNY
Whenever I am asked my favorite fictional place that I wish I could live in forever, I answer the village of Three Pines from Louise Penny’s mystery series. Even though the village has a gruesome murder or global catastrophe to solve with each new book, I love the characters and the setting with my entire heart. What I wouldn’t give to browse the shelves at the fictional Myrna’s bookstore, eat at Gabri and Olivier’s Bistro, banter with Ruth, or meet Rosa, the duck. Miss Wolcott’s Ghost is the newest entry (No. 21 in the series) and it’s my favorite in years. The mystery is ingeniously layered with multiple threads to untangle from a rare plant previously thought extinct and the widely unheard of real-life sinking of the RMS Empress of Ireland in 1914. Like all good mysteries, this one begins with a dead body and a crime to solve, but Louise Penny’s procedurals give us much more to unravel, ponder and savor. All the books can be read as stand-alones, but I do recommend starting with Still Life and reading all 21 novels this winter. I’m jealous of anyone who has the chance to read them all for the first time.
For the literary fiction lovers: PARTITA BARBARA KINGSOLVER
Barbara Kingsolver is one of the greatest storytellers writing today. I have loved her ever since I picked up The Poisonwood Bible back in 1998. Her Pulitzer Prize winning novel Demon Copperhead was one of my favorite books of 2022, and this year we celebrate her latest masterpiece, Partita. There is a musicality to how Ms. Kingsolver composes words on a page and it’s on full display in this new book. Shifting between past and present, we are consumed with the story of Livia Cable, a piano prodigy who receives a phone call from an old lover. The call seems to trigger an emotional reaction causing her to reflect on her life in memories, her losses and loves, her passion for art and music, and how she got where she is today. A “partita” is a musical composition, popular in the Baroque times, that is either a suite of dance movements or a set of variations written for a solo instrument or small ensemble. The word perfectly accentuates the structure of the novel and how, through each part, we truly live inside the head and heart of Livia throughout her days. It’s a reading experience only Barbara Kingsolver can provide.
For the cinema buffs: HOLLYWOOD, ENDING JOHN GREEN
I have read every book by John Green, but Hollywood, Ending, his adult debut and immediate No. 1 global bestseller, is officially my favorite. It follows two rising actors Kai Laramie and Juniper Castillo, who are cast in an Andy Warhol biopic titled Andy Warhol Never Gets Old. As the movie and their lives blow up in the public eye, they fall in love while navigating the pressures of fame, celebrity and the tension between a private and public life. I have always been fascinated with an actor’s life and what they go through for the sake of their art, and this novel takes a deep dive and an insider’s look into celebrity culture. When the cameras stop rolling for your favorite actors and actresses, what are they experiencing and feeling? This is a behindthe-scenes, gorgeously written novel told through dual points of view, contrasting the characters' varying experiences with fame and how they respond to it. I wish I could have spent hundreds of more pages in the minds of Kai and Juniper.
For the classicists: EAST OF EDEN JOHN STEINBECK
East of Eden by John Steinbeck is my favorite classic novel, hands down. I’ve reread it several times over the years. I love the characters, or in the case of Cathy, love to hate her. It’s truly the ultimate generational family saga, a subgenre that I adore. East of Eden actually features two families so it’s double the drama, intrigue and backstory. The writing is simple yet succinct and stunning, so precise, as if each sentence is perfectly structured the only way it could have been written. Did you know that Steinbeck wrote a large portion of East of Eden on Nantucket in the summer of 1951? While thoughts of this brilliant classic are never far from my mind, the new screen adaptation on Netflix that came out this fall made me want to insist you pick up a copy before or after you watch the show.
For the Nantucket Strollers: NANTUCKET CHRISTMAS STROLL NANCY THAYER
Nancy Thayer’s holiday novels feel like Christmas morning: cozy, warm and surrounded by loved ones. Her newest, Nantucket Christmas Stroll, brings to life one of my most anticipated and celebrated Nantucket weekends—Christmas Stroll. Within this novella, you can hear the carolers, see the twinkling lights and taste the eggnog and hot cocoa. Nantucket for the holidays is something out of Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol, and Nancy so perfectly sets the scene. Brick and Jane Parsons host a yearly house party for the occasion. This year, all three of their children are coming back to the island for it. As we all know, time with family at the holidays isn’t always joyful or filled with good tidings. Secrets come out for the Parsons family and emotions run high in a dramatic evening of holiday happenings. Nancy gives us a true gift of a story here, one that ultimately proves family (and chosen family) are the reason for the season. You can meet Nancy and get your book signed on Saturday, December 5 at Mitchell’s Book Corner for our Stroll Signing Extravaganza, along with authors Nathaniel Philbrick, Elin Hilderbrand and many more.
For the Nonfiction Readers: VIBE: THE SECRETS OF STRONG CONNECTIONS IN A LONELY WORLD ADAM GRANT
Whenever Adam Grant has a new book out I make sure to include it in this “Need to Read” write-up. I have always vibed with his books and his messaging since I first met him at The Nantucket Project in 2015. His newest book, Vibe, is the perfect book to wrap up for a loved one under the tree this holiday season and for us all to read to begin a new year. It focuses on our interactions with people and how we can forge and build deeper relationships and tighter communities. With polarizing politics, the fear of artificial intelligence and impersonal connections on social media, and the increase of loneliness and depression as we head into the colder winter season, this book is the remedy and hope I have been looking for on the shelves. Every page of this book provides an eyeopening takeaway of what it means to be human and to connect with other humans. Whether you want to work on team building at work, deal with dramatic conflict with your friends and family, or connect more deeply with your spouse, Vibe is the book for you. If your New Year’s Resolution is to start a book club or read more books, start 2027 with Vibe. N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
2 9
Save the Date for the 30 th Annual
Saturday
A U G U ST 1 4 , 2 02 7 Jetties Beach
Mark your calendars to celebrate the 30th anniversary of this beloved island tradition. Jetties Beach will transform into a world-class concert venue for an unforgettable evening of music to benefit Nantucket Cottage Hospital.
For information about Reserved Seating, call 508-825-8250. General Admission tickets will be available in the Spring. 3 0
N
M A G A Z I N E
Oceans of real estate knowledge.
Buying or selling a home can feel like heading into uncharted waters. That’s why it’s important to work with a crew whose expertise runs deep. With Gail, Ed and the team, it’s always smooth sailing. Venturing out soon? Call Coldwell Banker Realty’s #1 team in New England. 617-844-2712 • gailroberts.com
GAIL RO ROB B E RTS, E D F E IJ O & TE A M N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
3 1
ngredients
A SLICE OF
HEAVEN WRITTEN BY JACK BRADNER PHOTOGRAPHY BY BRIAN SAGER
Internationally ranked Neapolitan pizza by Gemelle’s Elio DiMambro
F
or Elio DiMambro, the chef at Pizzeria Gemelle, pizza napoletana is an art. Spending summers in Italy with his extended family, DiMambro grew up in and around the pizzeria on the ground floor of his grandparents’ apartment building. “As soon as I could reach the stove, in the back of my mind, I always knew I wanted to cook,” DiMambro said. “From a very young age, [going to] the pizzeria was
Pizza chef Elio DiMambro, of Pizzeria Gemelle
3 2
N
M A G A Z I N E
always something I looked forward to. The smell of the oven, the wood fire, everything.” While Gemelle’s Neapolitan pizza has arguably become Nantucket’s best slice, DiMambro’s craft has also captivated offisland audiences. In 2021, DiMambro attended the International Pizza Expo & Conference in Las Vegas, Nevada. Planning to make the dough at the competition, DiMambro packed a suitcase with flour, Nantucket water, homemade Gemelle mozzarella, Calabrian olive oil, Parmigiano (the “king of cheeses”) and an assortment of tomatoes. But when he got to Nevada, an unexpected hurdle cut DiMambro’s competition entry short. When he opened his luggage at his hotel in Vegas, he found his clothes were covered in flour. After looking closer, he realized that TSA officers had cut his vacuum-sealed bag of flour open, presumably to screen for illicit substances. “I had two kilograms of flour in a big vacuum-sealed bag,” he said. “Obviously that didn’t look good on the X-ray.” Without his ingredients, he was forced to withdraw from the pizza-making portion of the games. DiMambro returned to Vegas for the 2025 expo—this time with his dough prepared before the flight. Competing in the Neapolitan pizza division’s preliminary round, he rose past a hundred competitors and became one of five pizzaiolos to qualify for the finals. He finished in fourth place. “It really comes down to the quality of the ingredients. I think that’s what makes the difference,” DiMambro said. “It was crazy, you know, to place that high. I still can’t believe it.” This winter, DiMambro hopes to return to the international competition stage. With a couple of modifications to the dough’s proofing time and the tomato sauce’s seasoning, he might rise to the top of the pizza world.
NEAPOLITAN MARGHERITA PIZZA INGREDIENTS
INSTRUCTIONS
• 10 ounces pizza dough (available at Pizzeria Gemelle)
Preheat the oven to 550 degrees Fahrenheit, or as high as it can go. If you have a pizza stone, place the stone into the oven 45 minutes before you plan to bake.
• 2 ounces tomato sauce (available at Pizzeria Gemelle) • 2 ounces mozzarella • 4 to 6 basil leaves • Handful of pecorino Romano or Parmigiano • Drizzle of fresh olive oil • Dash of semolina (or cornmeal)
• Take the dough—whatever your favorite recipe is—out of the fridge and let it temper for at least one hour. If the dough is colder than room temperature, it won’t be easy to sculpt, won’t rise correctly and will end up too chewy. On a cutting board or cookie sheet, stretch the dough evenly to a 12-inch diameter. • Ladle the tomato sauce into the center of the dough and, using the bottom of the ladle, spread it out in a circular clockwise motion. Spread the sauce evenly, leaving 1 to 1.5 inches for the crust. • Before adding the mozzarella to the pizza, cut the mozzarella balls into smaller pieces. If the mozzarella was stored in water, let it drain to reduce excess moisture. Distribute the mozzarella evenly across the pizza. • Break up the basil into halves and lay them across the pizza. Drizzle olive oil across the pizza to your liking. Scatter a handful of pecorino Romano or Parmigiano over the pizza. • If you have a pizza stone, lightly dust a cookie sheet with semolina to transfer your pizza onto the stone. If you don’t have a pizza stone, bake the pizza directly on a cookie sheet. At 550 degrees, bake the pizza for 5–7 minutes or until the crust is golden brown. If you prefer meltier cheese, finish it off on broil for up to 1 minute. • Enjoy your pizza with another drizzle of olive oil and a sprinkle of Parmigiano.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
3 3
noshnews
DRINK & BE MERRY WRITTEN BY JEN LASKEY
Four winter drinks for Stroll and beyond.
D
espite the sun setting by 5 o’clock, downtown Nantucket is arguably at its most charming this time of year. Decked out for the holidays, the historic district glimmers with a halo of twinkling lights—and there’s plenty of cheer to keep your spirits high. Whether you’re joining in the revelry or staying cozy at home, local drinks purveyors from Main Street to Mid-Island are teeing up winter tipple ideas for all occasions.
MOËT & CHANDON, CHAMPAGNE, IMPÉRIAL BRUT RÉSERVE
($105/bottle, $23/glass at or, The Whale) Recommended by PAT WYNN, bar manager, or, The Whale
Photo by Pat Wynn, or The Whale
3 4
N
M A G A Z I N E
From Nantucket strolling and tree-trimming to New Year’s Eve partying, this bottle brings the sparkle to any celebration. Moët & Chandon’s Impérial Brut Réserve is a perennial crowd-pleaser—crisp and dry with a soft, rounded finish, toasty brioche aromas and snappy flavors of green apple, pear, almond and citrus. This blend draws from more than 100 wines, including 20% to 30% specially selected reserve wines, all made from Champagne’s classic grape trio: Pinot Noir, Pinot Meunier and Chardonnay. “It’s an elevated sparkling wine that reminds you of celebrating a year well spent and a new year to come,” said Pat Wynn, the bar manager at or, The Whale. “The Impérial Brut Réserve stands up to many of the delicious foods on our menu, [but] pair it with our duck carnitas and it’ll be the best night of your winter season.” And if you want the sparkle without the alcohol, Prima Pavé crafts superb de-alcoholized bubbly wines with crisp acidity, delicate bubbles and nuanced flavors that are so good, your guests might not even notice they’re nonalcoholic. Prima Pavé offers Blanc de Blancs, a dry Rosé Brut, a sweet Rosé Dolce Demi-Sec and a Grand Cuvée in 750-milliliter bottles ($28-35/bottle). The Blanc de Blancs and Rosé Brut are also available in 200-milliliter bottles ($10/bottle).
CHÂTEAU CALON SÉGUR, LE MARQUIS DE CALON SÉGUR, BORDEAUX, 2023
($49.99/bottle at Nantucket Meat & Fish Market) Recommended by SEAN READY, co-owner, Nantucket Meat & Fish Market Champagne may get top billing this season, but red Bordeaux is made for big holiday meals, cozy nights at home and even huddles around the fire pit. Sean Ready, who co-owns Nantucket Meat & Fish Market with his father John, wants more Nantucketers to know about Château Calon Ségur’s Le Marquis de Calon Ségur. “It’s a great wine that checks off a lot of boxes,” he said. This distinctive 50% Merlot-led blend with 48% Cabernet Sauvignon and 1% each Cabernet Franc and Petit Verdot is rich, velvety and plush—and it’s the château’s second wine (meaning it’s made from grapes and batches of wine selected separately from those in its flagship bottlings), so it’s a more affordable and approachable introduction to this prestigious Saint-Estèphe estate. “It pairs well with the hearty foods we tend to want on our dinner tables this time of year,” Ready said. “I’m a steak and potato guy, so I’d pair it with steak tips or filets and our twicebaked potatoes. But it’s also a good match for our market-made meatballs or Shepherd’s pie.” This bottle makes for a memorable gift, too. “I just love the bottle—it’s got a little heart on the front of it,” he said. “It can immediately say a lot of things that you want to say without you actually having to say them.” Photo courtesy of the Nantucket Meat and Fish Market
JINGLE JUICE ($18 at Fusaro’s)
Recommended by LILLY UNDERWOOD, manager, Fusaro’s Equal parts merry and bright, the Jingle Juice is a rosy-toned cocktail that combines bittersweet tropical fruit notes with fresh lemon. The vivid color from the Italian liqueur Sarti Rosa makes it an especially festive spin on the classic sour. This light, tangy sipper is one of the new seasonal cocktails on Fusaro’s revamped drinks menu. The restaurant reopened this year under local restaurateur and drinks veteran Mark Smith with Lilly Underwood as manager. “We love how the base of the cocktail shows its versatility by staying delicious with the different spirits,” Underwood said. “We recommend making it with Bombay Dry Gin, Aspen Vodka or Cazadores Reposado Tequila.” It’s a great pairing for Fusaro’s chicken Milanese with mixed greens and orange rosé vinaigrette, she added. Photo courtesy of Fusaros, Lilly Underwood
Recipe courtesy of Fusaro’s • Makes 1 serving • Glassware: Coupe INGREDIENTS
INSTRUCTIONS
• 2 ounces Sarti Rosa • 2 ounces dry gin, vodka or reposado tequila • 1 ounce fresh lemon juice • ½ ounce agave syrup • 3 dashes of orange bitters • Garnish: lemon twist
• Combine all ingredients in a shaker with ice, shake well, and strain into a coupe glass. • Garnish with a lemon twist.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
3 5
noshnews
RAISING THE BAR WRITTEN BY BRIAN BUSHARD
PHOTOGRAPHY BY KIT NOBLE
INSIDE NANTUCKET’S TWO NEW LOUNGES INTRODUCING THE DIVE
Z
“Our goal is to bring a shareable approach to things,” Corson ebra print and crocodile skin. Quite possibly the last said. “Can I say that’s missing on Nantucket? I’m not sure. Our things you would expect to find at a restaurant in goal is to be able to bring a very upscale environment with a casual downtown Nantucket. And yet at The Dive, a new attitude where people can meet and have fun.” restaurant and bar on South Water Street, a safari of animal print is The Dive had a soft opening over the summer, bringing staring you straight in the face as you walk in the front door. customers back into the South Water Street space that had “This high-energy, youthful, exuberant vibe is something previously gone by the names The Charlie Noble, Cy’s Green that Nantucket is missing,” said Denise Corson, a co-owner of Coffee Pot and the Atlantic Cafe. For the past year, it had been The Dive. “There are not a lot of places that have zebra print and dormant, undergoing myriad renovations by its new ownership flamingos. That’s definitely missing.” group, called Sneaky Good Hospitality. It’s the team behind a With a flock of inflatable flamingos strewn in the rafters and half dozen Boston restaurants, including on the bar, The Dive is to interior design The Pink Flamingo, Espresso Martini Rock & Rye, Pinky’s and The Flamingo. what yacht rock is to music. That is and P*rn Star Martini at The Dive to say, it’s something good in its own right that isn’t taking itself too seriously. In a high-end restaurant scene of $40 small plates, The Dive counters with mozzarella sticks, fried calamari and roasted cauliflower. And to drink, a Bud Light, a P*rn Star Martini, or maybe a Pink Flamingo, a cocktail of Bacardi, grenadine and pineapple juice served in a glass on an inflatable pink flamingo. As part of renovations to the longtime restaurant space, the owners of The Dive installed a U-shaped bar that serves as the centerpiece of the new restaurant.
3 6
N
M A G A Z I N E
Anyone who hasn’t been inside since its days as The Charlie Noble will be in for a surprise. In addition to the zebra print and faux crocodile skin, the new restaurant features a U-shaped bar in the front and a second bar facing out toward Easy Street and Nantucket Harbor. “The U-shaped bar lends to the communal sense of a good time,” Corson said. “We can all look together and socialize. You’re looking at each other in the eye rather than the back of each other’s head.” As far as the menu goes, the focus is on small, shareable plates, and “nothing that’s going to be scary,” Corson said. “The food and drink menus are going to be comfortable, fun, shareable, cheersable cocktails and food. It’s going to change and evolve from what it is now. The more we grow into ourselves, the more the menu and cocktail list is going to grow.”
The Green Room opened this fall behind the Greydon House.
INSIDE THE GREEN ROOM
B
The Myth and
esides the house-made nut The Petal at The Green Room mix, breadsticks and olives, you won’t find much food on the menu at The Green Room, the newest bar in town. It might be only the second true bar on Nantucket, second only to The Chicken Box. “We want to be a complementary addition to the restaurant scene,” said Evan Leventhal, who opened The Green Room on North Water Street in August. Leventhal also co-owns the Greydon House with Elliot Gould and his brothers Alexander and Jeremy Leventhal. “You can imagine a lot of these bars are packed with people waiting for dinner. People can’t just sit and grab a drink at a lot of restaurants because they’re so food-oriented. We wanted a pre-drink and after-drink spot, and even an early afternoon spot where people can grab a drink and a small bite here, but have a more full meal somewhere else.” Like its neighbor Via Mare, The Green Room is a vibe unto itself. True to its name, the walls are painted green. Beyond the bar, an assortment of low-top tables and coffee tables, wicker chairs and leather chairs, sofas and nooks, giving it the feel of an open-space living room, adorned with bookcases, chests, porcelain, a lightship basket, conch shells, transom windows, globes, sconces and plenty of paintings of old ships. “I’ve noticed a lot of people coming in as the afternoon shoppers that want to pop in and sit down for a little bit,”
Bar manager Shannyn Trujillo said. “There’s a huge pre-dinner and post-dinner crowd, so everyone’s coming in at least for one or two cocktails, going to wherever their reservation is.” Cocktails and wine are the name of the game at The Green Room. Fan favorites so far have been the neon green tequila and curacao cocktail bursting with fresh mint called The Myth, a bright pink option with house-infused hibiscus tea vodka, yuzu and limoncello called The Petal, and a bourbon and maple forward low ball called The Night Watch. And as a sign of the times, there’s also an entire page on the menu dedicated to non-alcoholic mocktails. The Green Room is set to stay open year-round, with several months off during its first winter. In addition to free bar snacks and an abbreviated snacking menu, Trujillo said the menu will include caviar, tinned fish and potentially a charcuterie or cheese plate down the line. “It’s going to be drinks, little light bites, and we always want to have something complimentary to everyone as well, which doesn’t really happen out here. But if you go to a lot of places in New York or in Europe, they’re giving you a little something,” Trujillo said. “It’s a place where you can come and feel relaxed but well taken care of.”
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
3 7
YO UR N ANTU C KE T G E TAWAY AWAITS Just moments from Nantucket’s beautiful South Shore beaches and historic downtown, The Nantucket Inn is the perfect destination for island getaways, special celebrations, and memorable gatherings. Welcoming guests since 1986, our resort combines comfort, convenience, and exceptional amenities for a truly relaxing Nantucket experience. Take a dip in our indoor or outdoor pool, enjoy a delicious lobster roll at Nobadeer Cafe, sip an après-beach cocktail at NobaBar, or enjoy a match on our Har-Tru tennis courts. Explore the island with ease aboard our complimentary shuttle to downtown Nantucket and Surfside Beach, or hop on one of our complimentary cruiser bikes and discover the island at your own pace. Planning something special? From corporate retreats and family celebrations to intimate gatherings and grand weddings, our versatile event spaces provide the perfect setting for every occasion. With beautifully appointed guest rooms, on-site dining, and everything your guests need in one place, The Nantucket Inn makes every gathering feel exceptional.
1 M ILLER LN, NANTU CKET, MA 02554 • W W W. N ANTU C KE TIN N. N E T • 800.321.8484
3 8
N
M A G A Z I N E
The One for Nantucket Living
36 Warrens Landing Road
Eel Point | 7 Bedrooms | 8 Full, 3 Half Bathrooms | $19,950,000
Set across three private acres in Nantucket’s coveted Eel Point, 36 Warrens Landing Road is an exceptional estate completed in 2017, offering sophisticated design, outstanding craftsmanship, and remarkable privacy. Elevated views extend toward Madaket Harbor, Tuckernuck, and Nantucket Sound while complemented by expansive lawns, mature landscaping, and a resort-style pool and spa. The 6,488 square foot main residence features seven bedrooms and is complemented by distinctive indoor/outdoor cabanas and an oversized two-car garage with a finished studio above. More than 3,900 square feet of finished outdoor living space includes expansive decks, covered porches, a screened-in porch, and generous patios, creating elegant settings for al fresco dining, sunset cocktails, and poolside entertaining. A rare private compound of exceptional scale and versatility, the property seamlessly blends architecture, landscape, and Nantucket living, offering an extraordinary retreat equally suited to intimate family gatherings and grand-scale entertaining.
WWW.36WARRENSLANDING.COM
Exclusively Presented By: John McGarr Sales Associate
Maury People Sotheby’s International Realty
Call: 508.577.5450
37 Main Street, Nantucket MA
mcgarr@maurypeople.com
www.maurypeople.com Gary Winn, Broker Each Office is Independently Owned and Operated. Equal Housing Opportunity.
nquiry
In 45 years on Nantucket, Dr. Tim Lepore has treated tens of thousands of people, from some of the richest in the world to longtime islanders struggling to afford a place to live.
4 0
N
M A G A Z I N E
Nantucket’s Person of the Year
DR. TIM LEPORE WRITTEN BY BRIAN BUSHARD & BRUCE A. PERCELAY PHOTOGRAPHY BY KIT NOBLE
E
verybody has a Tim Lepore story. There was the man with appendicitis who Lepore operated on only to realize the man didn’t have health insurance, so he paid with a batch of oatmeal raisin cookies. There’s the man who was stabbed in the heart by his wife after he forgot to pick up potatoes at the store. Lepore rushed him to the operating room, stuck his finger in the man’s heart to restart it and tied it back together using an 1800s technique involving black silk thread, earning Lepore a reputation as an “encyclopedia of arcane facts” by The New York Times. In 45 years, he’s treated tens of thousands of people, from some of the richest in the world to longtime islanders struggling to afford a place to live. He’s become the foremost tick expert on Nantucket, worked as Nantucket High School’s athletic doctor and continues to serve as a member of the School Committee, which he calls the “most important job on Nantucket.” For the past 20 years, he’s run Addiction Solutions out of his office at Nantucket Cottage Hospital, treating drug and alcohol misuse on the island. He was the firstever recipient of the Dreamland’s Fred Rogers Good Neighbor Award. For his four-plus decades of work in the community and his countless contributions to life on Nantucket, he is N Magazine’s person of the year.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
4 1
T
here’s a lot about Lepore that mainland he said. “MedFlight was a huge physicians might find curious. Maybe it’s his change because before we used collection of antique pistols and firearms (some to have to take the seats out of the 200 of them). Maybe it’s his eccentric collections Cessna 402, and you had to turn the of irreverent sculptures and paintings, or the structure to get the patient in, and arrowheads, rocks, knives and bones he keeps in his if they were heavy, it was a little office—or the human skulls in a display case by the more exciting. But then we would receptionist’s desk. “It’s not an Indian,” he said. fly them to the Cape, fly them to The most interesting man on Nantucket, he kept a Boston. I was flying with them, but pet red-tailed hawk named Ajax for years, becoming my wife was not fond of me taking so attached he constructed a $10,000 birdhouse for off in the middle of the night.” him. He’s run the Boston Marathon nearly 50 times. At 81 years old, Lepore has no He’s hunted, with mixed results, mostly for the fun plans to slow down. A doctor who of shooting. You can find him at high school football will make time for any patient, games, and you can certainly find him at the deer and sometimes their pets too, he weigh-in station on the first day of each hunting has been called the last of his kind. season, checking for ticks. “If I’m seeing a patient, I see the As a small-town doctor, he likes to say he patient as long as it takes,” he said. understands the problems he’s bound to face on the island. On Nantucket, he’s seen them “I’m not having somebody all. “There are things we do well and things that just graduated from we don’t, things we need the helicopter for,”
business school who has made up his mind on how long I should see the patient. I see the patient and do the amount of work that they need.” – Dr. Tim Lepore
“I had somebody come to the door and her dog had died and she was upset,” he recalled. “It wasn’t my patient, but we went back. I watched her for about an hour. I gave her a book, Man Meets Dog by Konrad Lorenz. She didn’t get charged for anything, but I took care of someone. I helped someone. Sometimes it takes five minutes. Sometimes it takes an hour and a half and my nurses are banging on the door. But I’m not having somebody that just graduated from business school who has made up his mind on how long
4 2
N
M A G A Z I N E
I should see the patient. I see the patient and do the amount of work that they need.”
COUNTRY DOCTOR
Lepore, who graduated from Harvard in 1966 and from Tufts Medical School in 1970, has worn a number of hats since moving to Nantucket in 1981 with his wife, Cathy, and their three children. Several years in, he was named the hospital’s head of surgery, and when he had time, he took on primary care. “Then it got out of hand,” he said. Four decades in, Lepore has met tens of thousands of patients, from summer residents to year-rounders, second homeowners and homeless people. He’s taken care of some of the wealthiest people on the planet, and even more patients without health insurance. Where a typical primary care physician will see roughly 2,000 patients each year, Lepore alone sees more than 7,000. He’s been known to offer free service to patients so many times that his staff jokingly says there’s an internal rule at the office never to let the doctor talk about payments. In addition to cookies, he’s taken lobsters, littlenecks and a photographer’s framed photo when patients didn’t have insurance. “Does the government take a quarter of a lobster from me?” he said. In 2005, he added another job to his resume, founding Addiction Solutions. “Addiction is an equal opportunity disaster,” he said. “You’ve got people sleeping around the cars, and
Lepore moved to Nantucket with his wife, Cathy, and their three children in 1981, and has worn a number of hats with Nantucket Cottage Hospital ever since.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
4 3
lone star ticks, a faster, more resilient and more aggressive tick whose bite can trigger alpha-gal syndrome, which can cause an allergy to mammalian meat. Like deer ticks, adult lone stars cling to white-tailed deer as hosts. With an estimated population of between 7,500 and 10,000 deer on Nantucket, researchers say it’s only a matter of time until Nantucket sees an explosion in alpha-gal cases, though as of October, Nantucket Cottage Hospital had seen only 80 positive tests for alphayou’ve got people worth a million bucks, and they’ve all got the gal, compared to same problem. Everybody here has had someone, a brother, sister, more than 1,200 “If I’m seeing cousin or whatever, that has a drug or alcohol problem. Nobody on the Vineyard. two or three should die of it. If people want help, we can help them.” “The people people a day Like a lot of Lepore’s work, Addiction Solutions didn’t fit who get ill [for alpha-gal], the idealized image of Nantucket seen on the big screen or more with alpha-gal then I would consider recently on the feed of social influencers’ pages. But for years, are actively [it] an explosion.” the problem around drug and alcohol misuse continued to rear its sicker, but not – Dr. Tim Lepore head, from cocaine to synthetic opioids like fentanyl. “I was on the everybody School Committee, and I was seeing kids that had graduated who I gets horribly had given diplomas to, coming in dead, overdosed,” he said. sick,” Lepore For more than 20 years, Lepore has not only been treating addiction, but said. “Some people get a big rash, has made it his mission to fight the stigma around addiction and make care wheezing, diarrhea and muscle aches. accessible, going so far as putting his personal cellphone on his radio ads Those people are at a bigger risk of to make it easier for someone struggling to connect with him. “I don’t want having problems. There’s already been people that are calling me for addiction to get a secretary. I want them to get somebody that died of anaphylaxis my [personal] answering machine,” he said. “You strike while the iron’s hot, [caused by alpha-gal in North and so if somebody’s calling me for help, I can meet them. We can talk. I can Carolina]. But with Lyme disease, you get them set up. I can prescribe things for them. It’s an opportunity to help don’t die.” people without barriers.” While Lepore said the Asian longhorned tick is actually the most TICK DOCTOR prevalent tick on Nantucket, his Beyond Nantucket, Lepore has become renowned for his expertise in tickconcern is that the lone star ticks are borne illnesses. He’s been called on by publications and programs from The more aggressive. When asked why Boston Globe to 60 Minutes to explain the myriad efforts to curb tick-borne Nantucket isn’t seeing the case load illness, from proposed expansions to the deer hunting season to an ambitious the Vineyard has, Lepore said the tides effort to introduce genetically engineered mice immune to Lyme disease. have started to turn. “We are in the Over the past year, however, the attention has moved from deer ticks to middle of it,” he said. “If I’m seeing
4 4
N
M A G A Z I N E
two or three people a day [for alpha-gal], then As Nantucket’s doctor, it’s clear Lepore is a I would consider [it] an explosion.” source of comfort to the entire population. While This year, Nantucket Cottage Hospital announced he was speaking with N Magazine, a former island the creation of the Nantucket Tick Center, a facility resident came in just to catch up with him, and of to be built on the course, Lepore brought her a seat. “It’s hospital’s campus just comfortable being here,” Lepore “We currently have that will support the said. “I mean, all of the stuff, everything possibly as many as evaluation and treatment 200 [deer] per square mile, of patients with tick-borne and that is a problem.” illnesses. The Tick Center – Dr. Tim Lepore will also provide space for research and community education on preventive measures. According to Lepore, any conversation on the tick problem must inherently start with deer. “If we get the deer population down to 10 to 15 per square mile, the tick diseases pretty much go away,” he said. The state has recommended reducing the population to 12 to 18 per square mile. “We currently have possibly as many as 200 per square mile, and that is a problem.” “How do you control them? If you use darts, the birth control guys aren’t going to want to eat the deer because they’re injecting these hormones in them. If you bring in sharpshooters, it would be like Apocalypse Now, and the thing is, they want about $1,000 a deer. That’s not going to touch [the population],” he added. “Hunting is a good way to do it. But you’ve got to open up a lot of these lands that are privately owned that have hunting signs.” As long as he’s involved in tick research, and as long as he’s working with Addiction Solutions, Lepore said he’s going to keep his office. in this office has a story—the giant rat from the “And if I’m going to be in the office, I might as dump, the armadillo, the picture of when the Blue well see people,” he said. “I’m not under any time Angels came out. My parents are on the wall. I constraints except my office staff yells and bangs like it here. Nantucket is a beautiful place. I get to on the door. But I meet interesting people, ask them spend a lot of time roaming around the woods.” where they’re from, how they got here. They’re all As much as Nantucket means to Lepore, Lepore interesting stories.” means even more to Nantucket.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
4 5
nquiry
BOBBY DECOSTA WEIGHS IN INTERVIEW BY BRUCE A. PERCELAY PHOTOGRAPHY BY KIT NOBLE
A conversation with the charter fisherman
A
fter a career on the water and countless hours in town board meetings, charter fishing captain Bobby DeCosta decided he needed to take things into his own hands. A decade removed from his last term on the Nantucket Select Board, DeCosta launched a write-in campaign for a third term on the board. Even though his name did not appear on the ballot, he managed to garner 1,919 votes, the most votes any candidate to a town board had received in nearly 20 years. DeCosta sat down with N Magazine this fall to discuss the biggest issues facing the town, from the cost of housing to the rise in lone star ticks, and what the town needs to do to address them. You have fished out of Nantucket nearly your entire life. In the last decade, have you noticed any remarkable changes in the species or the quantity of fish you’re finding that have either hurt or helped your business? DeCOSTA: I’ve watched the striped bass population my whole life go from tons of fish in the ’60s and ’70s to a five-year moratorium in the ’80s to where the fish came back in the ’90s and the 2000s. Now we’ve had five years of very low [striped bass] that can be attributed more to the health of Chesapeake Bay than anything else. This year, we had the best [striped bass] hatch in the spring since 2018. I would not be surprised if we see some type of partial closure or complete moratorium in the next five years to give the stock a chance to rebound. The bluefish numbers are way down compared to what it was when I was a kid and from when I first took over the charter business in 1993. My dad started fishing here in the ’40s, and he remembers in the ’50s there was a five-year period when they didn’t catch a bluefish on Nantucket, so they seem to be cyclical as well.
4 6
N
M A G A Z I N E
How has fishing on Nantucket, both recreationally and as a profession, changed since your childhood? DeCOSTA: My dad started the charter business in ’68 and prior to that, he was a fireman, but he also commercially fished. A lot of guys commercially fished to supplement their income, whether it was scalloping in the winter or fin fishing for bass and blue fishing in the summer months, in spring and fall.
“Alpha gal has scared everyone. It was one thing to get Lyme disease, babesiosis or one of the other tick-borne illnesses, but there were [antibiotics] for them.” – Bobby DeCosta
We had three fish markets on the island that actively bought fish and shipped fish off Nantucket. We don’t really have that here at all now, except for scallops. We also had a working ice house and we had working commercial docks. We don’t have any of that anymore. Back then, guys couldn’t afford boats, so they fished from the beach pretty consistently. You could access
every inch of beach on this island. You could drive on the beach at Jetties Beach and drive all the way around the tip of Coatue, and there were no closed beaches. There were no endangered bird [closures], so guys just drove to where the fish were, and they fished hard off the beaches. That all has changed. Let’s move on to another species. Not that long ago, there seemed to be resistance to killing deer on a large scale, however with the lone star tick, the mood appears to have changed on the island. What do you feel is the prevailing attitude of people toward reducing the herd? DeCOSTA: Alpha gal has scared everyone. It was one thing to get Lyme disease, babesiosis or one of the other tick-borne illnesses, but there were [antibiotics] for them. At present there’s no vaccine, no cure [for alpha gal syndrome]. To not be able to eat any kind of hoofed animal or dairy product is pretty frightening to people. I have friends that have it, some more severe than others. It seems like there are no standardized symptoms. I don’t know if we know enough about it yet. This is a whole different tick than what we’re used to.
The deer population here has taken 20 years to get to this point, if not longer. There’s no magic switch or solution to fix it overnight. I’ve been hunting here since I was 12 years old, and I shot my first deer when I was 15. You only got one deer tag a year back then, and you didn’t automatically get a doe tag. You had to apply, and I would say 50% of the hunters that applied got one. You hunted all deer season to shoot that one deer. If you saw five deer in a week, that was a lot. But the difference back then was most of the island was open to hunting, and over the course of time, more and more of the land got developed, and fewer hunters hunted. The deer do what deer do. They’re very good at adapting to urban environments. From a hunter’s perspective, how has the Land Bank and Nourish Nantucket’s deer processing facility affected the issue, in allowing hunters to donate venison? DeCOSTA: It’s a big step, but what needs to happen is homeowners need to give hunters permission to hunt on their property. It doesn’t have to be with a gun, it could be with archery equipment, which is just as deadly as a gun, especially if you’re using a crossbow, and it’s very safe. You start at Polpis Road. You start at the beginning of Polpis Road where the lumberyard is, and you drive to Sconset. The entire left side of that Polpis Road is all posted. It’s all private land, and it’s all developed in three- and five-acre lots, or big chunks of land that are posted. Now there are some guys that have permission to
Bobby DeCosta was sworn in for his third term on the Select Board this year.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
4 7
hunt some of these pieces, but until the homeowners give neighborhoods and shoot [the deer] at 3 a.m. on somebody’s [permission] to someone—whether it’s your caretaker, lawn. First of all, you’ve got to pay somebody to do it, but someone you know or your landscaper—there are plenty you’ve got guys here that will do it for nothing, and would be of guys on the island that will hunt these deer, kill them, happy to do it. If it comes to that, I would rather see us find 10 or and take them or donate them. It’s just a matter of getting 20 local guys and make sure they’re trained properly to do it. into the areas where the deer are. We did an aerial survey when I was on the Select Board The other thing is that the deer season had always ended the first time [in 2013]. They estimated the number of deer that here on December 31. Now we’re going until February. they counted in February when we had a snow cover on the I think you’re going to see a lot of extra deer killed here ground. They flew the island with thermal cameras and they did because there’s not a lot else to hunt that time of year and it from the plane back then because they didn’t have drones. most of the homeowners are gone. The They estimated that the herd was way our deer season is set up now, our around 2,000 deer based on the “They’re going to come here, shotgun season falls on the week of Stroll, numbers that they counted. Most get a job, work for the town, which is when we have the most people of the deer that they found at that gain experience, and then here. You drive around at night and you point were in backyards. Around the they’re probably going to leave look, and all the houses that were dark cranberry bogs or behind the dump, because they can live a better for a month now all have lights on them, there weren’t that many deer. But lifestyle somewhere else.” so you can’t hunt around those houses when you flew Cliff Road, Polpis – Bobby DeCosta because the minute you show up with a Road or Tom Nevers across from the couple guys in orange, they’re going to Cranberry Bog, that’s where all the deer were. You can get those deer out of those neighborhoods with a bow and arrow in January and February, especially when most of the homeowners in these houses aren’t there. All they have to do is write permission to a hunter, and he can sit right on the porch and shoot him off the porch with a bow. You don’t necessarily have to send a sharpshooter in there at 3 a.m. The state now estimates as many as 8,000 deer live on Nantucket. How can you reduce the herd to even 2,500 if the reproduction rate is roughly equal to the number of deer that hunters take each year? DeCosta at Annual Town Meeting
call the police or the game warden. The off-islanders that would come and hunt can’t find an Airbnb or a home to stay in because everyone’s renting their houses for Stroll. I think you’ll see more hunters come from off-island in January and February. I would not be surprised if we kill an extra 200 to 300 deer this year. And if we do that two or three years in a row, we’ll see a big decline. A viable alternative to expanded hunting is to hire professional sharpshooters through the USDA or a private firm. What are your thoughts on sharpshooters significantly reducing the herd, and are there alternative approaches? DeCOSTA: I’m not in favor of it. Basically, we’re talking about night culling. They call themselves sharpshooters, but they’re no different than half the hunters on this island with a small caliber suppressed rifle. [They] drive around the
4 8
N
M A G A Z I N E
DeCOSTA: This year we added two weeks of hunting in the fall, and we’re adding nearly two months in the winter. The number of deer that will be killed this year in January and February, I think you’re going to see a couple hundred extra deer killed at least. If you’re killing 100 does, each one of those does is probably pregnant, so you’re killing anywhere from 200 to 400 deer, depending on whether they’re having singles, twins or triples. That’s a big difference. You’ve got a lot of areas on this island where you can’t kill deer right now. You can’t hunt deer on any of the Linda Loring property or the Audubon properties, which are loaded with deer. You can’t kill deer in Ram Pasture, except for the Head of the Plains, and that’s only for five days. These are all areas that people walk and get ticks on, and these are all areas that have large amounts of deer. If you opened them to hunters even for four or five days, and just said, “All right, we’re going to close down this property to dog walkers for five days and let the hunters go in here and kill deer,” you would be amazed at how many you took out of these areas.
Moving on to town government, do you think the town needs to reimagine how it operates on a broader scale, possibly to a mayoral system? DeCOSTA: I could see that, but I don’t think it will happen in my lifetime. Any changes like this have to go to Town Meeting, and I don’t see Town Meeting ever giving up their authority. The government study committee had looked at this pretty hard, and they thought that a town council form of government to get away from Town Meeting would work. I think it will go down very hard and fall in flames at Town Meeting. People like to come to Town Meeting and say their piece. You have been critical of excessive town spending on large capital projects, the sluggish pace of government bureaucracy and the reliance on consultants. Does the town need to rein in municipal spending? DeCOSTA: We’re not a little town anymore. We’re a small city. We can call ourselves a town still, but we have 15,000 people living here, we have a pretty big budget, and we have a lot of things that I don’t think we need. I think we need to streamline our government some. We’re going in so many different directions with so many different departments. I’m worried about the rate we’re spending money. This year we’re looking at probably coming in with another $100 million in overrides, and our budget for the next 10 years is almost $1 billion, even after all the cuts we made. I know everyone says, “We don’t have to pay for it, we have our summer residents to foot the bill.” But at some point, everyone’s going to just say, “Enough’s enough.” I’m not against spending money when you need to spend money, but sometimes, I think we overstudy things and we get too far off the mark. I would like to see us be a little more focused. Let’s take care of our important services, like making sure the roads are right, making sure we have a good fire
department, a good police department, and municipal employees are happy. We need to house our municipal employees to make sure that we have good qualified people and schools. It’s no secret that I’m not a big believer in this whole coastal resiliency plan and the $550 million they want to spend on that stuff. I just think we have more important things to spend money on than that.
to leave because they can live a better lifestyle somewhere else. It’s not any different than any other resort community, whether it’s Aspen or Vail. They have the same issues.
Housing for the middle class has become an issue whereby islanders can no longer afford to live here. If you go out 10-20 years from now, and the trajectory continues the way it is, what happens to Nantucket?
DeCOSTA: I don’t think that we’ll get to the point where our visitors feel that way. For every one person that I’ve ever met that gets on the boat and says this place is cooked and they’re never coming back, five more get off and say this is the best place they’ve ever been. Some of our seasonal residents complain about the traffic, but they’re the ones that have been here for a while. I see it more from our year-round population. I think that the 30-year-olds are looking at it and saying, “I’m making good money, but I can’t afford to live here.” If the quality of the schools go down and the quality of services go down, they’re going to leave. There are other places they can live and work and have the same quality of life or a better quality of life. We don’t seem to have the multigenerational families that are staying here as they used to. At least that’s what it looks like to me. If you’re a kid in your 20s or 30s and you don’t have a parent to help you or leave you a piece of property or something like that, you’re pretty well cooked here.
DeCOSTA: There’s no easy answer. My son and his fiancée are a perfect example. He’s a fireman and she’s a nurse at the hospital. They make good money together between the two of them, and they probably won’t afford to buy a house here. My wife and I have discussed building an [accessory dwelling unit] and moving into the ADU as we get older and giving them the house. The ADUs could help the problem, but if we’re going to build all these ADUs, I think we need to have some type of restriction that they have to be for year-round occupancy. The reality is that we’re going to retain a lot of employees for three to five years, whether they’re teachers, nurses, doctors, firemen or policemen. They’re going to come here, get a job, work for the town, gain experience, and then they’re probably going
People have said for decades that Nantucket is at a tipping point with too much traffic, too many visitors and too much development. At what point does Nantucket have difficulty functioning or lose its appeal because it’s reached a tipping point?
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
4 9
DESTINATION FUN! FOUR SEASONS FAMILY GETAWAY
The North Conway Grand Hotel provides fun for the entire family from our indoor and outdoor swimming pools to pickleball to our indoor theater and arcade, we provide entertainment for all ages.
72 Common Court, North Conway, NH 03860
5 0
N
M A G A Z I N E
Located next to Settler’s Green shopping district, we offer wonderful access to hiking and biking trails for those looking to enjoy the great outdoors. Come explore our destination to fun and make your family reservations today.
• northconwaygrandhotel.com
•
800-655-1452
Dionis
Town
119 Eel Point | 8 BR 7+ BA $36,500,000 | Ty Costa
39A Milk Street | 5 BR 5.5 BA $4,995,000 | Amy & Henry Sanford
Beach Plum
Beach Plum
6 Thistle Way | 4 BR 3.5 BA $3,995,000 | John Arena
8 Fox Grape Lane | 4 BR 3.5 BA $3,995,000 | Robert Young & Blakney Young
E XP LO RE OU R WOR L D O F L U X U RY L I VI N G
Jupter Island, FL
183 S Beach Road | $32,000,000 Jupiter Island Office | 772.546.2381
Naples, FL
266 15th Avenue South | $11,995,000 Naples 5th Ave S Office | 239.231.3380
Boca Raton, FL
591 Golden Harbour Drive | $9,995,000 Boca Raton Office | 561.576.7085
| RAVEISNANTUCKET.COM | 17 MAIN STREET | NANTUCKET, MA | 02554 | 508.228.9117 N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
5 1
n depth
Revisiting the Legacy of
WALTER BEINECKE WRITTEN BY BRIAN BUSHARD PHOTOGRAPHY BY KIT NOBLE AND COURTESY OF THE NANTUCKET HISTORICAL ASSOCIATION
The Man Who Revolutionized Nantucket
T
he name Walter Beinecke is not likely to resonate with the majority of people coming to Nantucket today, and yet he might just be the most influential person on Nantucket in the past century—and possibly the most divisive.
5 2
N
M A G A Z I N E
Walter Beinecke’s vision for the Nantucket Boat Basin was realized in 1970. Courtesy of the NHA
Beinecke turned Nantucket from a dilapidated fishing town into the world-class resort it is today. He’s been praised for reimagining the island as an upscale tourism destination and he’s been criticized for erasing the character of old Nantucket. He was so prolific that today, 22 years after his death, it’s impossible to walk even 100 feet in town without seeing the mark he left on the island. Looking back, Beinecke’s legacy is a complicated one. “If we didn’t have Walter Beinecke building the Boat Basin and redoing the wharves, where would we be?” asked John Warner, state archivist, longtime summer resident and author of a new book called Walter Beinecke and the Reimagining of Nantucket. Beinecke’s legacy is one of transformation and gentrification.
It’s a matter of building an “attractive welcome mat” to the island, as Beinecke once called it, and at the same time tearing down and upgrading the shabby buildings and shacks that gave Nantucket a sense of place. It’s a question of who benefits when the identity of a place is irreversibly changed. “Most people today don’t realize the impact one person had,” said Mary Bergman, former executive director of the Nantucket Preservation Trust. “One person really had his finger on the scale to make it what it is now. He really was a visionary. We didn’t become Atlantic City, we’re stuck with something else.” Beinecke was a visionary. The heir to the S&H Green Stamps fortune, Beinecke saw an opportunity on Nantucket, where his parents first took him when he
was five years old. It came at a time when a ferry to Nantucket took four hours, when the waterfront was a mix of coal sheds, shanties, smoke stacks and rickety wharves, and summer tourism only consisted of a few unreliable weeks. “For 50 years, we took in each other’s washing and stared at the sheep,” Beinecke said in a 1990 interview. In the span of two decades, Beinecke bought hotels, wharves and retail space, restoring them and creating a new image for the island, which he referred to as “enlightened self-interest.” As Warner put it, “He told people, ‘You’re not going to sell hot dogs and beers, you’re going to sell wine and paintings.” Almost overnight, Beinecke had turned one of those hotels— the White Elephant—into an asset worth more than $1.4 million in 1964 dollars. On the wharves, he
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
5 3
“He wasn’t somebody who was going to sit on a beach blanket and hang out.” – John Warner, on Walter Beinecke
The Nantucket Boat Basin today. Photo by Kit Noble
replaced what had been a fish market, restaurant, coal shed and cheaply rented artist shanties with, as Beinecke put it, “nice shops for attractive customers.” He was invited to lunch with President Lyndon B. Johnson and received the President’s Historic Preservation Award from Ronald Reagan. He was once called “a savior of old Nantucket” by The New York Times. “He wasn’t somebody who was going to sit on a beach blanket and hang out,” Warner said. “His mind was restless. He was an entrepreneur. He referred to himself as a Yankee peddler, but what he wanted to do was put his own vision on how he wanted Nantucket to be.” By buying up nearly 80% of the commercial space in town, Beinecke effectively squeezed out the artists and the mom-and-pop shops that could no longer afford
5 4
N
M A G A Z I N E
to pay the rent. According to his critics, he had outpriced the working man. A 1967 article in The Washington Post lamented the new waterfront had become a “compound of chic souvenir, handicraft and art shops” that contributed to make “island prices skyrocket.” Some island shops even started selling buttons that read “Ban the B” and “No Man Is an Island.” So who benefited from these changes and what was the outcome of the changes that Beinecke ushered in? On the one hand, the tourists came in droves, many of them bought summer houses, the tourist economy boomed and Nantucket became the world-class resort Beinecke always envisioned. On the other hand, because property values and the price of summer rentals skyrocketed, the cost of living displaced working-class islanders and congestion made for constant summer traffic and parking headaches.
“He told people, ‘you’re not going to sell hot dogs and beers, you’re going to sell wine and paintings.’” – John Warner
Broad Street. After Beinecke’s Sherburne Associates took over the building, it was converted into a high-end retail space, wiping out the watering hole. In John Stanton’s documentary Last Call, Stanton asks Beinecke about the bar and its role in the community, and if people need a physical place to hang around. Beinecke’s response: “Well, what kind of people, and what kind of place?”
“Have we priced ourselves out?” Warner asked. “Have we made it too expensive to live here? But who’s we? I don’t know [if we have]. If you ask people in February if we’ve made it too expensive to live here, they would say it’s the time of year [they] like best, and other people would say they hate it here.” One example of the changing of the times came at the Bosun’s Locker, a popular dive bar on Main Street. When Beinecke was looking to obtain a liquor license for the Jared Coffin House, he purchased the Bosun’s Locker and transferred its license to his hotel on
Author John Warner, a Massachusetts state archivist and longtime homeowner on Nantucket, released his book, Walter Beinecke and the Reimagining of Nantucket.
“There still is a community here,” Warner said. “It’s the people who still love this place, and it’s not easy to try and make a living here. It’s not easy to keep the sand from washing out to sea. It’s not easy to deal with the crowds and the traffic and all these challenges. But we have to realize that it’s not an us-versus-them [mentality].”
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
5 5
The Ropewalk restaurant at the end of Straight Wharf
W
ith Beinecke, there are questions we’ll never be able to answer. What would he think of Nantucket today, for example, now that tens of thousands of visitors travel to the island every summer, even if the beautification of town contributed to a higher cost of living for the year-round community? “I think he would be shocked,” Warner said. “Even in 1999, he talked about plywood palaces. He talked about things working themselves out and that employers would have to step up, but that you’re always going to
The Sweet Shop on Main Street, one of Beinecke’s many commercial properties.
have people who are more affluent than others.” Of course, the big question is what would Nantucket be today if it hadn’t been for Beinecke? What if the wharves were never restored and the Boat Basin never built? Would Nantucket without those changes be a better, more affordable place? “People always think when the first people got here it was great, but that’s not really true,” Warner said. “We put on our rose-colored glasses and say it was a fabulous place to grow up [before Beinecke’s work began], but there were people here scrapping along and couldn’t make a living,” Warner added. “It’s an island, so there were people struggling with alcohol and substance abuse. That hasn’t gone
“He referred to himself as a Yankee peddler, but what he wanted to do was put his own vision on how he wanted Nantucket to be.” – John Warner
Robinson’s Five and Ten
5 6
N
M A G A Z I N E
Walter Beinecke Jr. and Richard Kuehl standing on the newly renovated fuel dock, between Old South Wharf and Commercial Wharf.
“We put on our rose-colored glasses and say it was a fabulous place to grow up, but there were people here scrapping along and couldn’t make a living.” – John Warner
Ronald Reagan presents Walter Beinecke with an award for historic preservation.
away, though it might be under the surface. What makes Nantucket different is we have a tremendous amount of natural resources, and people with buy-in to move the island forward in a way that makes sense.” It could also be argued that Beinecke was simply in the right place at the right time. Nantucketers had had their eyes on boosting summer tourism for decades before Beinecke stepped in. As the late Pulitzer-winning journalist and Nantucket summer resident David Halberstam put it in Last Call, “these things all were going to happen anyway. If it hadn’t been Walter Beinecke, it was going to be someone else, because the force of the money, the value of property downtown, the instinct to gentrify—that was going to happen.” Whatever your take is on Beinecke, there is no debating that Nantucket would not be what it is without him. Beinecke was once asked at a Rotary Club meeting in the ’80s, after all of his renovations had been completed, what was in it for him. The entrepreneur responded, “I could never live long enough to have the money I have
invested return to me.” The real beneficiaries, he argued, were the future generations. “[Beinecke] does end up with the last word, and he said, ‘You’re always going to have people who have more money than other people,’” Warner said. “He had a great quote that’s so acerbic and Yankeeish: ‘People say what is fair? Fair is Ferris wheels and Kewpie dolls. Life is not fair. There are always going to be people with more means than others.’” That thought is more true today than ever.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
5 7
5 8
N
M A G A Z I N E
Custom Historic Shutters Seaport Shutter Company Brewster 508.896.8900 • South Natick 508.653.5535 Showroom: 1714 Main Street, Brewster, MA • seaportshutter.com
ndepth
Near the start of the tracks, Engine No. 1 is rolled onto the tracks on Easy Street. Courtesy of the Nantucket Historical Association
Searching for the
HOLY RAIL WRITTEN BY BRIAN BUSHARD PHOTOGRAPHY BY BRIAN SAGER AND COURTESY OF THE NANTUCKET HISTORICAL ASSOCIATION
One man sets out for a lost railroad engine
6 0
N
M A G A Z I N E
J
ust over 100 years ago, when the Nantucket Central Railroad Company finally succumbed to the automobile, nearly every last rail, spike and train car from the failed company were shipped off-island or preserved—except for one railcar, a locomotive. Presumed to be buried and long forgotten, the mystery engine has become the holy grail for railroad enthusiasts, including Michael Kizilbash, a Madaket resident who has fallen into a deep rabbit hole researching the train. “No one else would be crazy enough to dig this thing up, but I am,” he said.
Not much is known about the lost locomotive. Legend has it the massive engine was buried underground after a derailment in one of any number of spots near Orange Street and Washington Street, where the tracks once stood. Other theories suggest the engine was shipped off-island with the rest of the rolling stock, or that it was sent to the scrap heap and sold for parts. It’s one of the great Nantucket unknowns, one that feels tantalizingly close to being solved. The possibility of a lost piece of Nantucket history sitting six feet under has intrigued Kizilbash for years. His search for the train started, of all places, at the TakeIt-or-Leave-It at the dump. One Saturday, he found a book by island historian Clay Lancaster on the history of the Nantucket Railroad. He became obsessed with the story of the lost train and started combing
through estate sales for any piece of the railroad he could get his hands on, piecing together a collection of artifacts that tell the history of the short-lived railroad, which ran for nearly 40 years until 1918. What’s known about the last days of the train comes from the Nantucket Historical Association’s collection, old books at the Atheneum and old Inquirer and Mirror clippings. According to
those records, the railroad’s rails, spikes, two passenger cars and an engine dubbed “No. 2” were sent to Bordeaux, France, for the American Expeditionary Forces at the tail end of World War I. There were two other locomotives, called Sconset and Dionis, which had been replaced years earlier. It’s the final resting place of a locomotive called Engine No. 1 that remains unknown. “It’s a game of telephone played over 100 years,” Kizilbash said. “The information was lost in the vapor trail of time.” Engine No. 1 derailed on Washington Street, dislodging the rails and tilting its tender.
Not convinced with the theories that the mystery engine was shipped overseas or to the mainland, Kizilbash started doing his own digging, both physically and metaphorically, around Orange Street and deep into the Atheneum and NHA archives. This fall, he convened a team of archaeologists and metal detectorists to find the train, forming a search party resembling something out of an Indiana Jones movie. “It might take a while, but I’m not going anywhere,” Kizilbash said. “And I’m going to chip away at this until we once and for all determine if it’s buried or not.” Engine No. 1 after derailing in 1910. Courtesy of the NHA
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
6 1
“I’m going to chip away at this until we once and for all determine if it’s buried or not.”
Clockwise from right: Kizilbash reads through Clay Lancaster’s book on the Nantucket Railroad Company, spikes and a ticket from the railroad, and an unknown object believed to be associated with the train.
– Michael Kizilbash
F
H
e may have struck gold in a 1974 book by Helen Wilson Sherman called A Photographic Journey to Nantucket in 1911. According to Sherman, Nantucket’s Engine No. 1 was “retired in 1910 after having turned over in an accident running off the track and suffered internal injuries.” Eventually, Engine No. 1 was buried “near where Fayette Street runs into Washington Street and no doubt could be dug up if enough present-day buildings were moved.” Some images from the NHA also show the engine derailed on Washington Street, though it’s possible
6 2
N
M A G A Z I N E
the train was placed back on the tracks. According to a 1910 Inquirer and Mirror article, derailments “seemed to be almost a daily occurrence, and once or twice in years gone by the locomotive even took a bath in the surf at Low Beach.” But if, as Sherman wrote, the train needed to be replaced, one cheap option would surely be to dig a hole next to the engine and topple it into its final resting place, out of sight, out of mind. After researching a bit more, Kizilbash narrowed his search to three areas, one on Washington Street—where Sherman said the train was buried—another off Orange Street and a last one near Old North Wharf. “I happen to know not one but two metal detectorists and the head of Columbia University archaeology, who is on the island,” Kizilbash said. “Between the NHA and myself, we have the [engine] bell, the spikes and a [train] ticket. Let’s go get the train.” On their first reconnaissance mission, the team of Kizilbash and metal detectorists Travis Nichols and Karen Russell didn’t find what they were looking for. But it wasn’t a total waste of time. Instead of a locomotive, they found a 1904
lawnmower part. Kizilbash started thinking that if a hunk of metal from the same decade was discarded in the same general area, it’s a sign that someone might have thought the area suitable to bury something else, something larger. Solutions like that weren’t uncommon on Nantucket a century ago. According to island historian Nat Philbrick, when people in the early days of automobiles had a car to get rid of, they would wait for Capaum Pond to freeze over, drive to the center of the pond, and wait a few weeks for the melting ice to finish the job. “These Yankees were tighter than bark on a tree,” said Rafael Osona, the auctioneer behind Rafael Osona Auctions. “They weren’t paying anything to throw something away.” If you ask Osona, an auctioneer with over 40 years of experience on Nantucket, there’s one spot in particular where the locomotive could be. Off Orange Street, across from the Cumberland Farms, there’s a 10-by-20-foot rectangular patch where not much
vegetation is growing. “If you get yourself an eightfoot piece of rebar and some boots, you might hit a piece of metal,” Osona said. “The old-timers told me it’s there, guys who are dead now,” Osona added. “I didn’t give a rat’s ass about it back then, but the more I got into this business and inquired why nothing would grow there, it stands to reason that it could be there. If I had to put money on it, I’d bet that it’s there.” Kizilbash’s team plans to return to that area later this year. The next step, once the team is back together, is to bring in ground-penetrating radar to determine once and for all if they’ve found it. (Ground-penetrating radar has actually been used in the area once before, in 2017, when the town paved a bike path over the former railroad near the Goose Pond. At the time, town transportation planner Mike Burns told The Inquirer and Mirror that they found no train car or engine. But that search was not extensive and stuck close to the rail trail.)
“No one else would be crazy enough to dig this thing up, but I am.” – Michael Kizilbash
Michael Kizilbash at his home in Madaket
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
6 3
As part of his research, Kizilbash went through the NHA’s collection, the Inquirer and Mirror’s archive and several books on the railroad.
Photo by Kit Noble
“I
f it’s underneath a sidewalk or a house, it may be that we come to an official dead end,” Kizilbash said. But if it’s under part of the Land Bank’s Consue Springs property or even the backyard of a cooperative homeowner, the search isn’t over. If Kizilbash and his crew do find the engine, the 100-ton question becomes what to do with it. “Within the spectrum of things, it’s either that we do what [the Land Bank] did on Easy Street, which is a plaque that gives the history of the railroad, maybe with a QR code that helps spread the information and education around the history of the train,” he said. “The other, more aspirational end, would be to resurrect it. That would be years in the making, and I’m in no rush.” Of course, there’s a chance the train engine was never buried. There’s also a chance the engine has decayed beyond recognition after a century underground, or that it was buried in an obscure location not on anyone’s radar. But the romance of
A replacement to Engine No. 1, Engine No. 2 was introduced in 1910. It was ultimately sent to France for the war effort.
6 4
N
M A G A Z I N E
finding one of Nantucket’s original steam engines is enough to drive people to continue the search. “If after we’re done with all of this, we jump-cut to two years from now and we don’t find it, that would be OK because in the meantime, it wasn’t for lack of effort,” Kizilbash said. “I got to meet amazing people along the way. For me personally, it wouldn’t hit my goal of giving back to the island in a historic preservation way, but it would be OK.”
Who’s #1 When it Comes to Nantucket Real Estate? The Client. Your Goals. Your Priorities. Always First.
141 Main Street $32,000,000
59 Baxter Road $10,900,000
79 Baxter Road $3,100,000
20 Madequecham Valley Road $5,350,000
When you partner with MBG, your goals and priorities always come first. Grateful for your trust, your loyalty, and the opportunity to share another remarkable year together.
MARYBETH GILMARTIN-BAUGHER 917. 561. 5995 | 508.257.0888 marybeth.gilmartin@compass.com marybethgilmartinbaugher 2026 Top Real Estate Agent, Boston Magazine RealTrends Verified 2023, 2024, 2025 & 2026 compass.com
Marybeth Gilmartin-Baugher is a licensed real estate agent affiliated with Compass, a licensed real estate broker and abides by Equal Housing Opportunity laws. All material presented herein is intended for informational purposes only. Information is compiled from sources deemed reliable but is subject to errors, omissions, changes in price, condition, sale, or withdrawal without notice. This is not intended to solicit property already listed. Photos may be virtually staged or N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M digitally enhanced and may not reflect actual property conditions. *Marybeth is included in RealTrends Verified 2026 list, which includes the top 1.5% of real estate professionals nationwide.
6 5
n d epth
TUGGING ON EMOTIONS WRITTEN BY BRIAN BUSHARD
PHOTOGRAPHY BY KIT NOBLE
A NOSTALGIC CRUISE ON A WOODEN CLASSIC
After a half-day endeavor to get the motor running, another day hauling the oversized hull out of the Indiana lake, and a 900-mile ride to Nantucket Sound, Erika and Matthew Mercer had their boat.
L
ast year, Matthew and Erika Mercer were browsing the web for a new boat, the kind of search not too uncommon for lifelong boaters. When they saw a listing for a 45-year-old wooden Crosby tugboat, a bell went off. The only catch, the tugboat had been sitting unused for three years in someone’s boathouse on a small lake in rural Indiana, and it wouldn’t start, even when a mechanic tried. Looking for a challenge, Matthew and Erika took the next flight they could find to Indiana—just as they were returning from their own wedding.
6 6
N
M A G A Z I N E
“The craftsmanship there is just unbelievable,” Erika said. After a half-day endeavor to get the motor running, another day hauling the oversized hull out of the lake, and a 900-mile trip to Nantucket Sound, they had their boat, as well as a new charter company they purchased called the Nantucket Tug Company. “It ticked all the boxes,” Erika said. “I actually had a list that I wrote down of my perfect boat that I wanted for this company Matthew Mercer pokes his head out of the cabin. before I saw this one, and it literally has everything.” The Chugalugatug (its original name) now operates as the smallest harbor cruise boat on Nantucket. “Most Crosby tug boats are just a commercial hull, kind of empty, like a launch that’s meant for seating tons of people,” Matthew said. “But there are a couple of these Crosby tugs that were built. Most are not for sale, and they’re all kind of old and beat up.”
“The craftsmanship there is just unbelievable.” – Erika Mercer
Not your average launch hull, this one features a fully wooden cabin, N - shag M A G A Z I N E .aCwood O M stove. 6 7 original carpet and
T
hat’s not the case with the new boat. Despite sitting around in a boathouse on a lake for three years, the previous owners kept it in pristine condition. Built in the early ’80s in Osterville, Massachusetts, the 26foot Crosby River Tug was designed by the original boat owner specifically for Lake Wawasee, a four-square-mile lake in northern Indiana farm country. The boat had not been moved from the lake since then. What caught Erika and Matthew’s eye was the attention to detail. On top of the hull is a wooden cabin, complete with a wooden helm, which the Mercers freshly varnished once they purchased the boat. An original wood stove keeps the interior cabin heated, with shag carpeting and upholstered banquettes for people to cruise comfortably. On top of that, the boat had only 400 hours on it when Matthew and Erika purchased it, despite being in operation for 45 years cruising around Lake Wawasee.
The original wood stove keeps the boat sailing into the shoulder season.
“For a guy in a pontoon lake in Indiana to build that is incredible.” – Matthew Mercer
6 8
N
M A G A Z I N E
“That’s like 1,000 miles on a car,” Erika said. “We have already put, in two seasons, another 400 hours on it. What it ran in its first 45 years of its life, we’ve doubled that.” While it’s not a true sister ship, the Chugalugatug was made in the same Cape Cod boatyard as the Nantucket Tug Company’s former boat, Gertrude, which former Nantucket Tug Company owners Jonas Baker and Tim Feeney ran for one season before the Mercers bought the company. Unlike the Chugalugatug’s wooden house, Gertrude was made of fiberglass and did not have the original carpeting the Chugalugatug has. “All that bronze casting [on the Chugalugatug] is custom,” Matthew said. “For a guy in a pontoon lake in Indiana to build that is incredible.” As a smaller boat, sailing around Nantucket in the Chugalugatug is an inherently intimate experience. Over the past two years, Matthew and Erika have hosted over a dozen engagements on board their lunch and sunset cruises. One night, they even held a small wedding. While other Nantucket-based charter yachts offer full food and drink service, the Mercers allow customers to bring their own food and drinks on board. And for people who are looking for a catered experience, Nantucket Tug Company works with PPX for prepared food service. “I want it to be open to the public,” Matthew said. “With [The Westmoor Club’s yacht] Belle, you have to be a member of The Westmoor Club, which is $750 a year to join. With Barton and Gray [Mariners Club], you have to be a member of Barton and Gray. We want something where people can have that same experience.”
Erika Mercer captaining the Chugalugatug.
Despite being in operation for 45 years, the boat had only 400 hours on it when Matthew N - Mand A GErika A Z I purchased N E . C O it. M
6 9
ndepth
HUNTING FOR A PERMANENT
SOLUTION WRITTEN BY JONATHAN SOROFF
HOW TO COMBAT NANTUCKET’S TICK PROBLEM
T
he old aphorism “No good deed goes unpunished” is true, at least as far as Nantucket’s burgeoning problem with deer and the tick-borne illnesses they spread is concerned. When English settlers arrived on the island in 1659, there were no deer. Fast-forward to 1922, when fishermen found a buck struggling in Nantucket Sound and brought him to the island. Four years later, an islander imported two females as solace for the lone stag. Today, the island’s white-tailed deer population is estimated to be 7,500 or more. According to Dr. Martin Feehan, Deer and Moose specialist for the Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife, the healthy density for a deer population is 12-18 per square mile. “Nantucket has 70-80, and in some places, more than 100.”
7 0
N
M A G A Z I N E
banded together to more significantly reduce the deer Compounding the problem is the fact that over half population. The group is asking islanders to buy in to of the island is preserved as conservation land, which reducing the deer population via deer donation and provides a perfect habitat for the deer and mice that ticks deer damage permits from the state government. rely on for their “blood meals.” If left unchecked, the These permits give greater latitude on methods of deer population on Nantucket could soar, according to managing the deer population. Those include extending some mathematical models. the hunting season, the use of (otherwise illegal) Add to that alpha-gal syndrome, the potentially lifebaiting and rifle silencers, and expanding the capacity altering malady that can make its human victims allergic to of Nantucket Community Food Hub’s deer meat red meat and most dairy products. With alpha-gal, the culprit processing facility, operated jointly by the Land Bank is the lone star tick, which was first recorded on the island and Nourish Nantucket. in 2019 and has since spread across the entire island. In Select board member Bobby DeCosta believes 2025, there were only seven positive tests of alpha-gal that hunting is the only practical solution to reduce the recorded at Nantucket Cottage Hospital, but that number deer population, and because so many of the animals has swelled to 80. If that’s not enough to make your skin congregate on private property, he crawl, Tucker Taylor of the Nantucket believes the effort will require the Conservation Foundation pointed out “We have little choice but majority of landowners to allow that each lone star tick can lay more to take whatever steps hunters on their properties—though than 2,000 eggs, roughly twice as many necessary to once and he acknowledges that might not be for all solve this as black-legged ticks. problem before it becomes a realistic expectation. Widespread While Lyme disease can be actually unsolvable.” professional hunting initiatives could treated with antibiotics, alpha gal is also be thwarted by the inability currently untreatable, and if a person – Bruce A. Percelay to isolate large numbers of deer, is bitten and infected, within half an according to DeCosta. That said, there are many who hour, that victim could ultimately be unable to process feel a large-scale approach is the only possible solution meat or any by-product from hoofed animals. “It’s to meaningfully reduce the herd. the way the individual’s body reacts to exposure, and “Any large-scale plan for the reduction of the everyone reacts differently,” Taylor said. “There’s no herd would need to be supported by the town and the antibiotic or treatment, no systematic diagnostics.” local hunting community, and before we undertake any It is unclear whether the allergic reaction to meat specific action, we will want full buy-in from elected products is a lifelong condition, however, once a person town officials,” NCF president Cormac Collier said. is positive with alpha-gal, it is expected that the negative While these efforts may well increase the number reaction to any product produced by a hoofed animal can of deer killed during the hunting season, they will not last at least several years and possibly for a lifetime. solve the long-term problem. While the hunting season The first and most obvious way to try to reduce the deer is essential to slow down the growth, the question still herd is through hunting. Some efforts to reduce the deer remains as to how to reduce the core population of deer population appear to have worked so far. In the 2025on the island. 2026 hunting season, a record 1,003 deer were killed, The ultimate and perhaps only solution to make a and in an expanded early season over the last week of deep reduction in the deer population might just come September 2026 alone, hunters took another 73 deer. through the use of professional sharp shooters, a bold Hunters on the island have and will continue to play an effort that has proven effective in other communities. important role in reducing the growth of the herd, but On Catalina Island in California, officials approved a in order to significantly thin the population of deer on plan to eradicate the island’s population of mule deer Nantucket, more comprehensive approaches are needed. in order to stave off the destruction of the island’s This year, islander Mike Leavitt, along with native ecosystem. Under the plan, professional hunters the Nantucket Land Bank, Nantucket Conservation have been tapped to shoot the estimated population of Foundation and N Magazine publisher Bruce A. Percelay
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
7 1
“The overpopulation of deer and the fear of the lone star tick could ultimately impact people’s choices regarding recreation on our property.” – Land Bank executive director Rachael Freeman
Deer carcasses at the Land Bank’s deerprocessing facility.
2,000 non-native deer. While the plan received pushback from the public, including an online petition with more than 32,000 signatures and a preliminary injunction to stop the project, a county judge ultimately allowed the killing to proceed, starting with several hundred deer this fall. On Martha’s Vineyard, some residents have considered hiring a Connecticut-based company called White Buffalo to eliminate the deer population on the island through sharpshooting. The Vineyard has suffered a large-scale outbreak of alpha-gal with an estimated 1,200 reported positive tests, creating not only a health crisis but a potential threat to its economy through the reduction of tourism. A second alternative is to bring in the United States Department of Agriculture, which also has sharpshooting teams that are designed for deer herd mitigation. The USDA has certain latitude that private firms do not, including the ability to hunt deer out of vehicles and with the use of silencers so
7 2
N
M A G A Z I N E
Stock photo
that a single shot does not spread the herd. A likely plan for Nantucket for large-scale culling of the herd would be first to identify more accurately how many deer are actually on Nantucket, through a drone survey using infrared technology. That type of survey is typically conducted in the winter for the highest heat contrast to produce the most accurate results. Once it is
determined where the deer are, the professional sharp shooters would develop a strategy as to where they would be most likely to begin their hunting program, and herd the deer to locations that concentrate them for more effective elimination. A common misconception is that eliminating the deer population in its entirety is simply a choice. The fact is, it is a complex problem that involves private property rights, following deer migration patterns, disposal issues, tracking deer on an island with 55% conservation land, and cost. Despite the enormity and complexity of the problem, according to Percelay, “We have little choice but to take whatever steps necessary to once and for all solve this problem before it becomes actually unsolvable. We do not want to have the same impact as has been experienced by the Vineyard and the time to act is now.” Major landowners on the island, including the Land Bank and the Nantucket Conservation Foundation, are on board with the idea to reduce the herd. “The overpopulation of deer and the fear of the lone star tick could ultimately impact people’s choices regarding recreation on our property,” Land Bank executive director Rachael Freeman said. “Working in cooperation with the other major land management groups on Nantucket is an essential part of solving this growing problem.”
Photo by Bill Hoenk
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
7 3
417 Corley Street, Bluffton, SC Known as “The Marsh View House,” this exceptional 2024 residence in Moreland Village at Palmetto Bluff captures the essence of refined Lowcountry living with sweeping marsh views at every turn. A chef ’s kitchen with prep pantry, separate bar, main-level owner’s suite, elevator, and private bunk room create a home designed for effortless living and entertaining. Three fully screened porches with automatic shades open to an outdoor kitchen, pool and spa, fire pit, and fenced yard overlooking the marsh. Tucked along a charming side street, this beautifully appointed home offers an idyllic Southern retreat with the added flexibility of short-term rental eligibility.
“If you are looking for an incredible real estate agent, look no further than Christine Reid. From day one, her deep industry knowledge and guidance gave us complete confidence in every decision we made. Beyond being a true professional, she is wonderfully easy to work with— approachable, organized and genuinely focused on our best interests. We are so grateful for her help and would recommend her to anyone in a heartbeat!” Rhonda & Steve — Palmetto Bluff Buyers from NJ
5 Beds | 6.5 Baths | 4,834 SQFT | 0.44 Acres | 3-Car Garage
#1 Ranked Real Estate Company in the Lowcountry
Offered for $5,250,000
Christine Reid 843.684.0097 | creidhhi@gmail.com
ENJOY SPECIAL PRICING FOR NEW ACCOUNTS* Lock in your space now.
Lock in Your Off-Season Storage Space F ALL SIZES AVAILABLE:
From small lockers to extra-large spaces, find the perfect fit.
F PREMIUM SECURITY &
CLIMATE CONTROL:
Keep your items safe, dry, and protected from winter’s harsh elements.
NEW CUSTOMERS: (774) 382-8924 Scan here to lock in your storage unit today. Or visit smartstopstorage.com and search for “Nantucket Davkim”
7 4
N
M A G A Z I N E
CURRENT CUSTOMERS: (774) 325-1450
F WINTER VEHICLE
PARKING:
Secure covered spaces or fully climate-controlled garages are available. F BOATS WELCOME:
Covered spaces fit compact trailered watercraft under 20 feet.
Gate Access Hours 6:00 AM - 10:00 PM 10 Davkim Ln, Nantucket, MA 02554
*Promos/discounts valid on select units for a limited time. Additional taxes and fees apply.
in
Year-round Nantucket residents experience food insecurity Those who live, work, and raise families on Nantucket are the island’s heart and soul. However, Nantucket’s high cost of living creates challenges for everyone— seniors, teachers, working adults, students, and families alike. Food insecurity is a reality that affects us all.
Nourish Nantucket partners with nearly 20 local food programs to identify unmet needs, strengthen existing services, and develop innovative solutions—ensuring all our neighbors have reliable access to nutritious food.
Give today, because the magic of Nantucket begins with a nourished community.
For further information scan the code, visit nourishnantucket.org, or call Meg Browers at 508-901-9201.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
7 5
n vestigate
NANTUCKET'S
MIDDLE CLASS SQUEEZE WRITTEN BY LARRY LINDNER PHOTOGRAPHY BY BRIAN SAGER
Stock Image 7 6
N
M A G A Z I N E
“I
THE IMPACT OF THE HOUSING CRISIS
interviews with candidates, and we lost three of them due ’m a 42-year-old professional, and I have two to housing.” Fire Chief Michael Cranson made the same housemates,” said Peter Burke, the executive point. “The fire department currently has five vacancies,” director of the Nantucket Chamber of Commerce. he said. “In recent hiring cycles, some otherwise strong Burke isn’t complaining. “I don’t have a family. I don’t candidates couldn’t move forward because they couldn’t have dogs. I actually feel pretty lucky that I have stable find housing on the island.” Meanwhile, “some staff who year-round housing,” he said. cannot find housing on-island commute from off-island, A carpenter on the island does not feel so lucky. which can affect ‘recall to duty’ situations and the fire Even though he earns about $120,000 a year, he department’s efficiency.” struggles to pay rent. He and his wife finally moved Put in practical terms, if you can afford a home from a cramped studio to a one-bedroom apartment on Nantucket and your house catches on fire, there’s in August, but it’s just a temporary fix because the a risk that the response might not be what you’d landlord would only give him a one-year lease. “I’m expect because those paying almost $4,000 a tasked with protecting the month,” he said, speaking on community’s infrastructure the condition of anonymity. are often priced out of that Next year the landlord “may very community. charge $300 more. Year With one-bedroom rentals by year they go higher in the ballpark of $4,000 and higher.” – Chamber of Commerce executive director Peter Burke a month, a police officer who With the man’s business earns between $100,000 expenses, including and $120,000 a year spends insurance, equipment and close to 50% of a year’s pre-tax annual salary for vehicle maintenance, he simply does not know that small unit. If the officer has a family and needs how he’s going to make ends meet—or where he two or three bedrooms, the rent is going to be and his wife are going to live—when the lease ends considerably higher. next summer. There isn’t a single aspect of life on Nantucket The problem of affordable housing for people who that isn’t touched by the affordable housing crisis. earn a living on Nantucket is only worsening. “The “I need an assistant manager pretty desperately,” said market just really isn’t creating enough year-round Acting Airport Manager Preston Harimon. “We built a housing,” said the island’s housing director, Kristie dormitory-style facility over on Nobadeer Farm Road. Ferrantella. “We’re even seeing a decrease in the [While it] can be used as a crutch for new year-round opportunities” to make it available. employees, it’s mainly intended for seasonal workers, The housing issue affects every stratum of Nantucket’s May through October. The dorms have helped, but middle class. “I have six vacant police officer positions,” they’re not the whole answer.” Police Chief Jody Kasper said. “We just conducted
“I’m a 42-year-old professional, and I have two housemates.”
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
7 7
Matt Fee, who sits on the Select Board provides employee housing for his sandwich shop.
T
he difficulties have spread to Nantucket’s public school teachers as well. Superintendent Elizabeth Hallett commented that Nantucket leads the state in the starting teacher salary, currently $80,153. That gets teachers hired, she said, “but the more challenging piece is how to keep people here. We often lose people between the three- and seven-year mark. Just when they’re really coming into their own as highly qualified professionals, they leave and go to another district because they want to buy a house.” That’s nearly impossible to do on Nantucket on a teacher’s salary because of the island’s median sales price of more than $4 million. The inability to put down roots presents a real challenge, Hallett said. “We are constantly training new teachers, providing them with really good professional learning. We have to constantly consider the turnover.” Retail businesses suffer, too.
7 8
N
M A G A Z I N E
According to a report based on surveys and interviews completed by 72 island employers and released by Remain Nantucket, nearly 70% of employers provide some kind of housing support to their workers, costing them, at a minimum, $92 million a year. The median housing cost, per business, comes to $162,500. Even with housing subsidies for workers, 64% of business owners have lost or declined hires because of issues related to housing, according to Remain. The kicker: 72% of the employers surveyed expect their housing needs to grow, turning those employers into sometimes reluctant landlords whose resources get shunted away from growing their businesses. “It’s a whole other level of responsibility, a whole other headache that you have to balance every year,” said Matt Fee, a member of the Select Board and owner of Something Natural. While Fee’s business sells bakery products wholesale to Stop & Shop year-round, the Town housing director Kristie establishment’s Ferrantella seasonal sandwich shop takes a hit because of housing issues. While Fee would like to remain open until around Thanksgiving or even Christmas Stroll, he usually has to close around Columbus Day. For all the headaches involved in employee housing, he is glad he purchased real estate for workers decades ago, when it was within easier reach. When he bought his business in 1983, the median price of a home on the island was roughly $150,000. “How do the next businesses afford to grow?” he asked rhetorically. “How do you ramp it up? They’re at the bootstrap level, right at the beginning. It’s very difficult to build a small business into a larger business” if you don’t know where your employees are going to live. “People are constrained by not being able to get staff.”
SOLUTIONS IN THE OFFING?
A number of initiatives have been put in place to help ease the housing burden for employees on the island. One new program launched by the town in August called Rooted Renters provides an incentive of $18,000 over a three-year contract to residents who continue to rent out their houses year-round to someone. Another town-based program is Lease to Locals, which has proven “really successful,” Ferrantella said. The program provides up to $27,000 in the first year for landlords who convert their unused homes or short-term rentals to yearround housing, with the rent capped at $4,000 a month for a three-bedroom unit. So far, Ferrantella reported, that initiative has helped house over 100 year-rounders. To qualify, a family of four has to earn less than $455,000 a year—250% of the median income on Nantucket. While the program helps, it goes to show that “even a family earning that much money can’t afford housing,” Ferrantella said. “People “We just conducted really need that subsidy. It’s not just about extremely low- and moderate-income households, but every household on Nantucket.” interviews with There are also lotteries to purchase affordable housing on the candidates, and we island, but getting picked is like, well, winning the lottery. And you lost three of them
due to housing.”
– Police Chief Jody Kasper
Nantucket Police Chief Jody Kasper. Photo by Kit Noble
have to show you have the assets to make a down payment, which people often don’t, in large part because they haven’t been able to build a nest egg due to skyrocketing rental costs. It becomes a vicious cycle. Legislative fixes have proven elusive as well. There’s a push at the State House to pass a law that would allow a municipality to levy a transfer fee when a home sells for more than $2 million. For any amount above the first $2 million, 0.5% would go into a housing fund. A number of well-heeled municipalities in Massachusetts, not just Nantucket, would like to see it happen, but it has failed repeatedly, most recently this past July. If it passed, it would add millions of dollars to town coffers each year to make housing attainable for more
year-rounders. “It is one of the most critical tools we need,” Ferrantella said. “We’ll be putting in another petition for the next legislative session.” For other ideas on how to fill affordable housing gaps, the Remain report looked at ways in which four other resort communities have been handling the problem: Davos, Switzerland; Scotland’s Isle of Skye; Jackson Hole, Wyoming; and Key West, Florida. Solutions have included housing cooperatives and nonprofit developers, private philanthropic contributions, inclusionary zoning and development incentives, and caps on housing growth with priority given to workforce housing. Whatever combination of approaches is used on Nantucket to address the housing crisis, time is of the essence. This is not a situation that is ready for a tidy “all fixed.” We’re “at a critical point,” Ferrantella said. “We need to make an impact on what Nantucket is going to look like for the next 10 or 20 years.” Or as Police Chief Kasper put it for her own department, “We’ll be fine for the next five to 10 years. But after that, if we’re not able to provide more stable, quality housing for people, I don’t know where we’ll go from there.”
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
7 9
nvestigate
DROUGHT? WHAT DROUGHT? WRITTEN BY BRIAN BUSHARD
PHOTOGRAPHY BY KIT NOBLE
ARE THE CONCERNS REAL OR EXAGGERATED?
8 0
N
M A G A Z I N E
E
asy Street was flooding in a foot of water, just like it had hundreds of times before and will hundreds of times again. Three inches of rain had just drenched Nantucket over a three-day September nor’easter, capping off a wetterthan-average summer and early fall. And still, despite three months of steady rainfall, the island remained in a “significant” drought, according to the state agency that controls Nantucket’s water supply. With so much rain, it’s baffling to Wannacomet Water Company director Mark Willett that Nantucket remains in a socalled level-two drought, requiring property owners to continue to limit outside water use. “I have lost what little faith and trust I had in the Massachusetts Drought Management Task Force,” Willett told the Nantucket Current. From July to September, Nantucket received 11.4 inches of rain, nearly as much precipitation as it had over the previous nine months combined. The town’s water tanks are full, while underground, Willett said there’s so much fresh water that the aquifer extends over 100 feet above the depths where Wannacomet pumps its water—and that’s not counting the water below where the pumps reach. “That’s 100 feet of water times the area of Nantucket,” Willett said. “I can’t do that math in my head. That’s billions of gallons of water.” The aquifer is so massive that researchers in the 1980s discovered fresh water as deep as 1,100 feet below the surface. Last year, a team of scientists stationed 20 miles south of Wannacomet Water Company director Nantucket discovered fresh Mark Willett water with a salinity rate of only two parts per thousand. They even found fresh water 43 miles offshore, with only a slightly higher salinity rate. The drought becomes even more perplexing when you look to Martha’s Vineyard, where a rainy summer lifted the island completely out of a drought. That means that less than 15 miles away, homeowners, landscapers, pool companies and businesses are no longer restricted in their outside water usage, while on Nantucket, they can face fines for irrigating their lawns. In fact, most of Worcester and Berkshire counties have joined Martha’s Vineyard out of a drought designation, while only Nantucket and the Cape remain in a “significant” drought.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
8 1
The staff at the Wannacomet Water Company
B
ut the answer might be a bit more complicated. RJ Conservation Foundation, has also seen the effects of a Turcotte, an ecologist and waterkeeper with the protracted drought across the island. “Some of the ponds in Nantucket Land & Water Council, compares Nantucket’s water the Middle Moors are completely bone dry, and have been supply to a “bank account” of underground fresh water. The increasingly getting that way over the last few years,” she principal deposit was made by the Laurentide ice sheet during said. “Even with additional rain, it just soaks right up [in the the last ice age thousands of years ago. The soil], so it makes little difference. We’re so far account is replenished every time it rains. behind. People think this rain is helping. Well, “We need a couple “As our population has grown, we have we need a couple years of good rain to get years of good rain continued to skim the top to pay for our things back to normal.” to get things lifestyle,” Turcotte said. “However, now our Nantucket’s aquifer is owned by the state. back to normal.” seasonal population has multiplied 20-fold, The ultimate decision to place the island in – Danielle O’Dell, Nantucket Conservation and it isn’t raining as much in recent years as drought status comes down to the Massachusetts Foundation it did in the past, so we’re officially at risk of Department of Environmental Protection. On dipping into the principal. Groundwater is retreating farther Nantucket, that decision is based on the water level in a well off from the surface. Those who live near one of the little ponds Russell’s Way that’s monitored by the U.S. Geological Survey. like Crosby or Quaise or Pout, which have gone dry, can see And as it turns out, the water level in that well has trended this with their own eyes.” downward for the past five years, while for nearly two years, it Danielle O’Dell, director of research at the Nantucket has sat below the threshold to trigger a drought.
8 2
N
M A G A Z I N E
“It’s frustrating that people complain about not being able to water their green lawns, but the implications for plants and wildlife aren’t being considered and are being brushed under the rug, and it’s so obvious,” O’Dell said. “You stand by the Pout Ponds and see a completely dry pond.” If it were up to Willett, the drought would be over, or at least dropped to a level-one status, which carries more lenient watering restrictions. While the well off Russell’s Way still falls below the state’s threshold, another well in Madaket has responded better to the recent rain. With that disparity in water levels between two wells on the island, Willett argues the state should make its decisions based on multiple wells, taking the average between them. “We’re just asking them to take a scientific approach,” he said. “It’s not very scientific to just take one dot and say, ‘This is it for everything.’” “If we averaged some of the wells we wanted to average, we would still be in a drought condition, but it would be at level one,” he added. “So people would be allowed to irrigate certain days of the week, and people would be allowed to use more water outside than they currently do. It wouldn’t get us completely out of the drought, but we would be at a much more comfortable place with drought conditions where people can actually work. Irrigation guys could work, and landscapers could work, and pool guys could fill
pools. We would be in a much better place.” As a result of the ongoing drought, the Wannacomet Water Company has pumped 100 million fewer gallons this summer compared to last summer. Since Wannacomet serves as an enterprise fund for the town, it generates revenue from pumping and selling water, and from connecting new properties to town water. With 100 million fewer gallons pumped this year, that means its revenue has dropped. Willett is now holding off on replacing some of the water company’s older equipment, as he had planned, until his revenue rebounds. And as for water usage restrictions, Willett has not fined a single property owner or landscaper who has violated state-imposed water restrictions. Instead, he’s been working with property owners to reduce the amount of water they use. “I’m at the point now where I don’t think it’s fair to tell someone who has invested millions of dollars in their home on Nantucket and who has put tons of money into their landscaping [not to water their lawn],” he said. “I know when I do my annual report and I submit the data to the [state] DEP, there may be questions from them, and I’m just going to try to be honest with them and say I was trying to work with our customers and work with the companies and work with people to keep the island moving.”
“I’m at the point now where I don’t think it’s fair to tell someone ... who has put tons of money into their landscaping [not to water their lawn].” – Mark Willett
Last summer, a team of geologists stationed 20 miles south of Nantucket discovered fresh water with a salinity rate of only two parts per thousand.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
8 3
SUSAN LISTER LO CK E J E W E L E R
Cashmere
Everyone’s favorite gift www.remycreations.com
Happy Holidays
28 EASY STREET, ON THE WATERFRONT 508.228.2132 · SUSANLISTERLOCKE.COM ©Brian Sager Photography
Thanks for a great season – Happy Holidays!
award-winning, waterfront restaurant offering innovative Japanese and Asian inspired cuisine, creative cocktails, a curated beer, sake and wine list plus takeout available
classy, seaside retreat featuring raw bar, seasonal cocktails and an extensive wine list
bagels, sandwiches, smoothies and more 44 Straight Wharf bagelbarnantucket.com
BAR-YOSHI.COM | Old South Wharf Nantucket, MA 02554
8 4
N
M A G A Z I N E
NOW SERVING NANTUCKET
Your Trusted Team On and Off the Court GEORGE & MARA VASVATEKIS Zero Main Street Nantucket, MA 02554 (781) 635-4601 cbnantucket.com george.vasvatekis@cbrealty.com mara.vasvatekis@cbrealty.com
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
8 5
n design
RAT PACK SHACK
WRITTEN BY MARY BERGMAN PHOTOGRAPHS COURTESY OF MARK CUTONE ARCHITECTURE +
NANTUCKET ARCHITECT MARK CUTONE RESTORES DEAN MARTIN’S PALM SPRINGS HOME
T
he Vista Las Palmas neighborhood is about as far away from Nantucket as you can get and still be within the contiguous United States. It isn’t just the distance (some 3,000 miles), but the desert climate and abundance of mid-century architecture that make Palm Springs a real departure from the Grey Lady. There doesn’t seem to be a weathered cedar shingle in sight. But both resorts have real star power.
8 6
N
M A G A Z I N E
Dean Martin joined a wave of Hollywood A-listers who made Palm Springs their home starting in the 1950s.
Starting in the 1950s, Hollywood A-listers made Palm Springs their home, as the desert enclave was within easy commuting distance of Tinseltown. Rat Pack crooner Dean Martin was one of the most famous denizens of the desert. While Martin’s stage persona was that of a heavy-drinking party animal, the real Dean Martin was said to be more of a family man who went to Palm Springs to escape the grind of Hollywood. Nantucket architect Mark Cutone was also drawn to Palm Springs, and his love of the area led him right to Dean Martin’s doorstep. Cutone, who first came to the island in 1990 to attend the University of Florida’s Preservation
Institute Nantucket, is the founder of Mark Cutone Architecture, and has been wintering with his family in Palm Springs for the past 10 years. For years, he would drive past Martin’s home, then in a state of disrepair, and wish he could resuscitate this mid-century stunner. The house was designed in 1957 by William Krisel, the architect who transformed the California desert and beyond with affordable, modern homes. (Krisel also designed the famous “House of Tomorrow” where Elvis and Priscilla Presley honeymooned.) “I thought, gosh, this house shouldn’t be like this,” Cutone said. “It’s a shame. It’s Dean Martin’s house. It’s a beautiful home. It’s in a beautiful neighborhood.”
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
8 7
A
fter years of interest in the home, Cutone finally closed on the property earlier this year, becoming the first person outside of the Martin family to own the property since Dino bought it. Cutone is now at work on an ambitious restoration to bring the home back to the same luster the “King of Cool” would have enjoyed in his heyday. Using original floorplans and images of Martin’s family shot by Life Magazine in 1958, Cutone is breathing new life into the home while honoring its past. “My goal is when you walk into the house, it will feel like it was Dean’s house, as though, at any point he could turn a corner or step out of a room,” Cutone said. Palm Springs was a beloved getaway for all of the original Rat Pack members. Martin’s house is notable for its classic butterfly roof design set against the desert expanse and towering palms. “Palm Springs is not unlike [Nantucket]. It’s historically protected,” Cutone said. “Anything we do to the exterior needs approval from the local historic review board. But our goal is to take it back to 1958, so we are more than happy to restore it to its original state.” Mark Cutone purchased the house last year, though the structure was far removed from its glory days. For months, Cutone has undergone extensive renovations on the home.
Martin—now, Cutone’s—home will be finished in stucco as it was originally. Inside, finishes are elevated, like Terrazzo tiles where wall-to-wall carpeting once was. Cutone is sourcing midcentury fixtures and furniture, including his grandmother’s 1960s dining room set, which he is restoring himself.
8 8
N
M A G A Z I N E
Mid-century architecture can provide a challenge for preservationists as the homes were constructed with materials that were easy to obtain but not necessarily meant to last. Martin’s house has stood for 70 years. Cutone and his team have had to put in all new glasswork in the windows, new drywall, new plumbing, HVAC and electrical. Working in Palm Springs means dealing with the opposite hard climate to Nantucket. “[On Nantucket], we have horizontal rain and salt air and the occasional 100-mile-an-hour wind gust,” Cutone said, “There, it’s all about the heat and how to keep the building cool in a desert climate.” While the project is far from Nantucket, Cutone is working with many island businesses to finish the job. “All the plumbing is coming from the Water Closet, all the tile is coming from the Tile Room. I acquired some pieces I was able to direct-ship from Marine Home Center. So, I’m tapping my local resources that I’ve used for 30 years now to assist in getting the materials.” Martin—now, Cutone’s—home will be finished in stucco as it was originally. Inside, finishes are elevated, like Terrazzo tiles where wall-to-wall carpeting once was. Cutone is sourcing mid-century fixtures and furniture, including his grandmother’s 1960s dining room set, which he is restoring himself. Cutone is excited to be the next steward of the storied house, and doesn’t seem to mind that his oasis will be on the maps to stars’ homes. “We’re piping it for sound and even running a speaker in the front yard so that if the tour buses go by, you might hear Dean singing in the front yard somewhere,” Cutone said. That’s amore, indeed.
“My goal is when you walk into the house, it will feel like it was Dean’s house, as though, at any point he could turn a corner or step out of a room,” Mark Cutone said.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
8 9
RARE OPPORTUNITY TO RENT EITHER A ROOM OR AN ENTIRE HOUSE
Introducing Nantucket’s most intimate hotel. Managed by
19 Broad Street, Nantucket · 508-228-4749 · theswainhouse.com 9 0
N
M A G A Z I N E
F o r ty Y e ars. O ne Island. E nduring Excel l en ce. Since 1986, Lee Real Estate has been the name Nantucket trusts. What began as a deep belief in this island - its singular beauty, its resilient community, its enduring appeal - has grown into four decades of unmatched expertise, landmark transactions, and relationships that last long after the closing table. We don’t just sell Nantucket real estate. We live it. Our agents bring an insiders knowledge to every listing, negotiation, and client conversation. Understanding this island isn’t something you can learn overnight, it’s something you earn over decades.
Hap p y Hol i days fr om al l of u s at Le e R eal E s tate
contact
web and social
nyc studio
vt studio
info@stoneledgestudio.com (office) 212.271.1006
stoneledgestudio.com (ig) @stoneledgestudio
143 West 29 th Street | No. 903 New York NY 10001
375 Bay View Road N. Ferrisburgh VT 05473
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
9 1
n spire
DECKING
THE TRAPS WRITTEN BY BRIAN BUSHARD PHOTOGRAPHY BY KIT NOBLE
Nantucket’s newest Christmas tree is made of lobster pots. Pronk built his first tree on the Land Bank’s Petrel Landing on Commercial Wharf two years ago. 9 2
N
M A G A Z I N E
I
t’s become one of the first things you’ll spot at dusk as you sail around Brant Point into the harbor. Three-hundred lobster traps, 75 buoys, hundreds of dollars worth of string lights and a pair of Douglas firs as angels. Lobsterman Dan Pronk’s Christmas tree on the harbor is far from a traditional evergreen. Now in its third year, it’s become a wintertime staple on the waterfront.
“There are only a couple guys who work on the water here lobster fishing, and I figured why not represent us,” said Pronk, who has been fishing on Nantucket for the past 35 years. “They’ve got [lobster trap trees] all over the mainland. So why not do one here?” Pronk built his first tree on the Land Bank’s Petrel Landing on Commercial Wharf two years ago. Last year, he one-upped that first version by adding even more traps, more string lights, more buoys, and a second tree made of conch traps right next to the lobster pots. He’s not only a lobsterman. Last year, he caught 103,000 pounds of conch inside the harbor and just outside the harbor.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
9 3
“Y
ou see them on the mainland and half the time I was the only guy lobster fishing on the island, so I figured it would be cool if we put one here on the island somewhere, and all the guys that work with me said, ‘let’s do it,’” Pronk said. While it might not be a traditional community Christmas tree like the one at the top of Main Street, lobster and conch trap trees like Pronk’s have been popping up along the coast from Maine to Connecticut, including in Block Island, Winthrop, Cohasset, Gloucester, and Portland, Maine. One particularly large tree in Stonington, Connecticut, boasts more than 400 traps interspersed with 200 buoys decorated by professional and amateur artists alike. That tree has been the site of more than two dozen proposals, a gender reveal party, and has garnered so much acclaim that in 2021, the BBC named it one of the world’s 18 most amazing Christmas trees, putting it alongside the iconic trees in Rockefeller Center and London’s Trafalgar Square. Some mainland trees even open up for guests to warm up with a cup of hot chocolate. While Pronk’s two trees do not have such interior spaces, they have become the talk of the town. Last year, he started a guessing game with the Nantucket Current, giving lobsters as prizes to the people
Dan Pronk on board his boat, the Black Earl.
9 4
N
M A G A Z I N E
who could correctly guess the exact number of traps in his trees. Two people went home with lobsters. All told, it takes Pronk roughly $500 in Christmas lights, $200 in the two real trees he uses as tree-toppers, plus dozens of hours gathering and setting up the traps with zip ties to secure them against the harsh winter winds. As far as costs go, Pronk also owes a debt of gratitude to the Nantucket Boat Basin, which allows him to plug in the lights in one of their outlets. The trees serve as a point of pride for the dwindling fishing fleet out of Nantucket. Despite efforts to recruit young fishermen and maintain a healthy harbor, the number of fishermen continues to decline. One proposal to keep the fleet alive is to give fishermen another place to dock at a proposed pier exactly where the tree stands. “We tried to get the Land Bank to put a pier in at Petrel Landing, and what better way to put our foot in the door than building a tree and seeing what the response is,” Pronk said. “And the response has been great, so we kept doing it. We’re going to do it every year.” Pronk has the blistered face and calloused hands of a fisherman who’s spent years on the water. Swearing like a sailor, he’s proud to say he’s Nantucket’s last commercial lobsterman (Jim Sjolund also sets up traps around the island, though Pronk said he’s on another level). Any conversation with Pronk inevitably turns to the trials and tribulations of lobstering, the federal regulations that make it difficult for lobstermen to make a living, and the people he meets who he might call Scrooges. Instead of selling to markets, Pronk has the market come to him, and over the years it’s worked in his favor. Come Saturday afternoon, there’s a line of people with
“There are only a couple guys who work on the water here lobster fishing, and I figured why not represent us.” – Dan Pronk
The lobster trap tree includes 300 traps, with a Douglas fir on top.
coolers down the Town Pier waiting for his boat, the Black Earl, to dock. “Everybody likes it except the other fish markets, and screw them anyway,” Pronk said. “They get all bent out of shape because we’re down here, but I say ‘You know what, if you offer me a good price for my product then I’ll sell you every lobster I catch.’ You look at the [lobsters] down at Stop & Shop and they look like they just got off the refugee bus. You want to eat that thing? God knows where it came from.” Between federal regulations designed to protect the critically endangered North Atlantic right whale, the exorbitant costs of repairing his boat and the warming waters pushing lobsters farther north,
Pronk might end up being the last lobsterman on Nantucket. “With all my guys that come out with me, I say, ‘don’t ever get in this,’” he said. “The only reason I’m in this is because I’ve been doing it since I was a little kid and that’s all I know how to do,” he said. “I don’t know what else I would do, and to be honest, I don’t want to do this anymore. I’ve been saying that for 10 years, but what else am I going to do here, work for the Fire Department? It’s a good job, but I’m not a 9-5 guy.” As long as he’s making a living on the water, he’ll keep laying his traps. And as long as Pronk is on Nantucket, he said there will be a lobster pot tree.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
9 5
n spire
Hope in Times of Need WRITTEN BY BRIAN BUSHARD
PHOTOGRAPHY BY KIT NOBLE
BARNABY’S CARES PROVIDES HOPE
Wendy Rouillard launched Barnaby's Cares, named after her Nantucket children's book series, for children in need.
9 6
N
M A G A Z I N E
W
hen Wendy Rouillard’s daughter was less than a year old, she developed severe symptoms that would change the course of her life. Not knowing what was wrong with her daughter, Rouillard rushed her to Nantucket Cottage Hospital, where it became clear she required a level of care that could not be provided on the island at the time. Her daughter was taken off the island in a Boston MedFlight helicopter to Mass General, where she was diagnosed with bacterial meningitis. Instead of playing at home with her newborn daughter, Rouillard took what she needed and moved into her daughter’s hospital room in the pediatric ward. That ordeal turned into eight grueling weeks of uncertainty, all the while her daughter was sequestered in her own room, sleeping all day and staying up all night. “At that point, they told me that she might not be able to hear again. They had told me they don’t know if she’ll be able to communicate well,” Rouillard said. “We didn’t know what was going to happen. But when you’re there, you’re also seeing so many sick children and kids who might not live. It puts things into perspective.” Not sure how long the hospital stay would last, Rouillard’s dad also moved into the pediatric ward for a time, bringing with him one of Rouillard’s Barnaby bears, the stuffed animal based on the children’s series she created on Nantucket. “It’s what
we had,” Rouillard said. They didn’t know it at the time, but the bear became a source of comfort for the entire family, knowing the young daughter had a soothing toy to clutch when times got tough. “While I was there in the pediatric ward, I was in the playroom every day and noticed there were so many children who couldn’t leave the ward,” Rouillard said. “My daughter couldn’t leave for weeks. She couldn’t even go to the playroom because they were worried she could have a cold or get some infection. Being there and seeing all the kids every day, I noticed how great it would be if these kids had an art project they could work on from their beds—not only in the playroom but in their beds.”
“There were so many children who couldn’t leave the ward ... I noticed how great it would be if these kids had an art project they could work on from their beds.” – Wendy Rouillard
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
9 7
Rouillard said. “I’ve been aware that there are kids in the public schools who don’t have lunch. There are kids that don’t have food. It always amazes me how many families don’t have enough money to buy gifts every year.”
“There are kids in the public schools who don’t have lunch.There are kids that don’t have food. It always amazes me how many families don’t have enough money to buy gifts every year.” – Wendy Rouillard
One of Barnaby’s Cares’ coloring pillows, with markers that can go through the washing machine. Photos courtesy of Wendy Rouillard.
H
er daughter is now 19 years old and in college. In the time since that extended hospital stay, Rouillard— who studied art at Parsons School of Design—has gone from writing and illustrating the Barnaby Bear series to developing art kits and hosting children’s art classes at her store on Oak Street, called Barnaby’s Toy & Art. She now hosts more than 150 art classes every summer for children of all ages. Last year, with her two daughters grown up, she launched Barnaby’s Cares, sending art kits to children in
Barnaby’s Cares offers donationsupported art kits for children of all ages, providing comfort for children in need.
need at Mass General and beyond, as well as to families that cannot afford art kits on their own. Last year, she donated 88 kits to Inky Santa, 25 to the Nantucket Boys & Girls Club, and dozens more to organizations across the country. “I have always been aware of the need on Nantucket,”
Like her classes, the kits are designed for different age groups, including bears, as well as pillows, tic-tac-toe boards, hats, bandanas and blankets that kids can color themselves. They serve as a source of comfort and distraction during unnerving and sometimes lengthy stints in a hospital room, allowing children to play the way they ordinarily would at home and with friends. Several studies have found that toys for children in hospital inpatient units can also minimize fear and relieve tension brought on by a hospital environment that can trigger stress, anxiety and emotional trauma. The study also found those gifts can help form a bond between children and healthcare professionals, promote interaction, communication and help children express their feelings. “I would really love to see [Barnaby’s Cares art kits] around the country, and I think that will naturally happen as donations come in,” Rouillard said. “I would love to see it grow. I see the kids and how happy they are, even going to the Boys & Girls Club and seeing the children so happy.”
Each art kit is supported by a $45 donation. For more information, visit barnabys.giving.
9 8
N
M A G A Z I N E
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
9 9
n spire
Kezia Duarte is on a warpath to complete all six major marathons, and she’s more than halfway there.
1 0 0
N
M A G A Z I N E
HITTING THE GROUND
RUNNING WRITTEN BY JOHN STANTON
PHOTOGRAPHY BY KIT NOBLE
Kezia Duarte on track to finish the six major marathons
A
she said. “That moment I could not run a quarter marathon is 26.2 miles from start to finish, mile triggered in me all the things I had learned as an but to some runners it is a long series of athlete, as a little kid growing up, and then in high footsteps that cannot be measured by their official school. If you’re going to do this, you’re going to finish time. Those runners often take the first steps have to work for it. It really made me reconsider what of their race far from the starting line. it takes to be an athlete.” Kezia Duarte has been training to complete Duarte has a habit of using the phrase “the next the Abbott World Marathon Majors, a series of thing I knew” to connect the footsteps that led her six international marathons—Boston, Tokyo, back to Nantucket, and to explain how tapping into London, Berlin, Chicago and New York City. She her inner athlete sharpened her outlook on the rest completed her fourth in November, in New York. of her life. “It was also, in But she took her first steps essence, trying to find myself toward that goal years “That moment I could again,” she said. “And that earlier, in a bar, sharing not run a quarter mile triggered athlete in me was the biggest a few beers with friends in me all the things I had part I could cling to.” and watching whatever learned as an athlete... She had moved back to sport was playing on If you’re going to do this, you’re the island, back to her parents’ the television. going to have to work for it.” home, her life at loose ends. Duarte had been – Kezia Duarte She had finished nursing a three-sport athlete at school, but stopped short Nantucket High School, but of taking the national exam that would make her a that was a handful of years ago and she had done registered nurse. Finding that inner athlete gave her a almost no training since then. As her group at the sense of purpose in her personal life and allowed her bar watched the game playing on the TV, Duarte to tap into the island’s running community. said one of those things that ex-athletes often say: A handful of local runners have completed the She would love to get back onto the playing field. Abbott World Marathon Majors. Their advice and A friend laughed at the idea and bet her she could support put Duarte’s feet on the road. “It took me no longer even run a mile. some time to find that camaraderie, to say to myself it “The next morning, hungover, I put on is okay that I was new to this and let people help me. sneakers, walked out the door, put my foot to the I was so new and didn’t really know where to go and pavement and couldn’t even make it a quarter who to turn to,” she said. mile,” she said. “That’s when I thought, this isn’t Four years ago, on her 25th birthday, Duarte ran just about running. I had let myself get so out of a half-marathon in Newport, Rhode Island. She heard shape and out of touch with [my] athletic ability.” about the Abbott World Marathon Majors and used it Duarte started slowly. She began weight to fashion a personal challenge of finishing six halftraining. She alternated between running and marathons around New England. walking. “There really wasn’t any structure,”
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 0 1
A
friend suggested she run in the Boston Marathon Duarte’s return to her athletic self, triggered by a and sent her a link to apply for what is called a friendly barroom challenge, turned out to be just what she charity bib. Marathons often provide invitational entries to needed to fuel the other avenues of her life. She is now select nonprofit entities. The Boston Athletic Association, a registered nurse, and when she is not wearing hospital which runs the Boston Marathon, does this. Duarte’s first scrubs, she plays piano at the Summer House in Sconset, and marathon, however, would not be in Boston. will be filling in as the music director at St. Paul’s Episcopal “Next thing I know, a month and a half later, I got Church over the Christmas season. accepted by Boston Children’s Hospital to go run the One step in front of another, a quarter-mile jog, a few London Marathon in April 2025 on behalf of them, so 5K races, a handful of half-marathons, then London, Berlin, long as I could raise $10,000. I said to myself, ‘you’ve Boston and New York City. Running has become something got to be kidding me,’” she said. more than a series of footsteps to the finish line. “It is a Duarte raised the money and completed the London euphoria. All of a sudden, your legs feel light,” she said. Marathon that April, then found another charity bib, for “The pavement doesn’t feel like rock, it feels like clouds. cystic fibrosis research, and ran the You don’t have to associate with Berlin Marathon in September 2025, anything around you. You are within “The hardest part and another for Boston Children’s yourself and enjoying being within is always convincing myself Hospital for the Boston Marathon yourself. For me it has never been to go out and try to start.” in April 2026. With New York also just a footrace.” – Kezia Duarte in the books, that leaves her with Tokyo and Chicago, both in 2027. “If I map it out and stay consistent, this is where I could go,” she said of completing the Abbott World Marathon Majors. “The hardest part is always convincing myself to go out and try to start. In essence, you put one foot in front of the other.”
Duarte’s latest major marathon came in early November, when she competed in the New York City Marathon.
1 0 2
N
M A G A Z I N E
Exceptional Properties. Proven Results. Gary Winn & Team When the time comes to sell, every advantage matters.
PE
N
DI
N
G
L SA
E
PE
N
DI
N
G
Monomoy | $34,500,000
SO
LD
Sconset | $11,995,000
P
EN
DI
N
G
L SA
SO
LD
Hummock Pond | $12,000,000
SO
LD
Quidnet | $8,500,000
E SO
Brant Point | $7,995,000
E
Sconset | $26,850,000
SO
LD
L SA
LD
Hummock Pond | $5,400,000
SO
LD
Tom Nevers | $2,595,000
Town | $2,550,000
For over 40 years, Gary Winn has helped shape the Nantucket real estate market, leading Maury People Sotheby’s International Realty to eight consecutive years and counting as Nantucket’s #1 real estate agency.
Gary Winn
Morgan Winn
Derek Dohanos
Principal Broker & Owner 508.330.3069 gary@maurypeople.com
Sales Associate 508.332.9088 morgan@maurypeople.com
Sales Associate 419.309.7088 derek@maurypeople.com
37 Main Street, Nantucket, MA 02554 | (508) 228-1881 | www.maurypeople.com Each Office is Independently Owned and Operated. Equal Housing Opportunity.
n spire
Hospital Longevity WRITTEN BY BRIAN BUSHARD
Betsey Minihan retired this fall after 53 years at Nantucket Cottage Hospital.
1 0 4
N
M A G A Z I N E
PHOTOGRAPHY BY KIT NOBLE
Nantucket Cottage Hospital’s longest employee retires
P
One day, concert pianist George Winston came to play resident Richard Nixon was in the White House, for the patients, and with only a few at the hospital, the gas was 39 cents a gallon, Russia was the Soviet employees decided to dress up as patients so that Winston Union, and Jim Croce’s “Bad Bad Leroy Brown” would have an audience to perform to. topped the charts. It was also when 19-year-old Betsey During her tenure, she saw the hospital absorbed into Minihan first took a job as a medical records clerk at the Mass General Brigham network. She volunteered Nantucket Cottage Hospital, and after 53 years, she as security for the first Boston Pops fundraiser concert just announced her retirement as the longest-tenured 29 years ago, when dinner included hamburgers and employee at the hospital. hot dogs. In 1985, she watched as the first of many “I’m not totally excited [to retire], because I will miss Boston MedFlight helicopters transported a patient to this,” Minihan said, speaking at the PASCON office at the the mainland for urgent medical care that could not be new hospital on Prospect Street. “But it’s time. I’m 73. provided on the island. And in 2019, she was there as I’ll get involved in something. I left the nursing assistant officials unveiled the newly constructed hospital. job [in 2022] to take a step down for a few years, and this One of the biggest changes she has been four years. I don’t think saw at the hospital was the creation anybody’s ever like, ‘I can’t wait to of the urgent access walk-in clinic, not be there anymore.’” “I’m really proud which is now headed by Dr. Steve Since taking her first job at to have been a part of Kohler. “That was the best move the the hospital in 1973, Minihan has this all these years.” hospital could have made,” she said. worked as an assistant and executive – Betsey Minihan “I’ve been there several times. My assistant to over a dozen nursing husband’s been there, and my family. directors, served under 13 hospital You come in, they’re nice, they treat administrators or presidents, and you, and boom, you’re out. It’s amazing. For years I was for the past five years, has been the office supervisor of part of the old hospital when the ER would get jammed. Palliative & Supportive Care of Nantucket, or PASCON. What are we going to do? That’s one of the biggest Minihan has seen the hospital evolve from a rural improvements, urgent access and how it unstuck the ER facility to the highly sophisticated health provider it is and all the same-day appointments.” today. When she took her first job at the hospital, women But the thing she’ll remember the most from her were required to wear dresses or skirts, there was no human five-plus decades at Nantucket Cottage Hospital was the resources department, and most of the nurses were wives of people she worked with, many of whom became good sailors stationed at the former Nantucket Navy Base. The friends. She can look at a 50-year-old photo framed on cafeteria dished out a daily choice of “hot lunch” or cottage the hospital wall and remember the names of each person. cheese with canned fruit cocktail. The hospital president’s She can start a conversation with any employee walking secretary kept employees’ personnel files and signed them down the hallway. Her children were born at the hospital, up for insurance. and their names are listed on the “Wall of Natives.” “I’m During those first years, Minihan remembers driving really proud to have been a part of this all these years, to the newspaper to deliver a list of patients in the through my many iterations,” she said. hospital for print. The hospital was so small, the ER It’s a hospital’s goal to help patients live longer, but was often empty at night when there were no patients, in Betsey Minihan’s case, her longevity has undoubtedly and when one came in, there was a bell the staff would helped countless patients along the way. ring to the nurses’ station to have someone come down.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 0 5
n s p ire
GILLETTE’S GOLDEN GIRLS WRITTEN BY KHUYEN DINH
PHOTOGRAPHY BY KIT NOBLE
Nantucket’s Patriots Ladies Keep Their Football Tradition Alive
F
or over 30 years, the first people you would find in line for the Steamship on a crisp fall Sunday morning were three sisters dressed from head to toe in New England Patriots gear, bundled against the wind. The sisters—Joan Fisher, Jeanne Dooley and Jane Hardy—shared a ritual for decades: Drive to the dock, drive off at Hyannis and start the rest of their trek to Foxborough. After Joan’s death last year, Jeanne and Jane, who are now in their 90s, continue to keep the tradition alive and have no plans to give up their season tickets. “We’ve never stopped going to games,” Jane said. Through every iteration, the sisters have been there—for the early years when the franchise couldn’t muster a win, for every playoff win and loss, for Tom Brady’s first and last touchdowns at Gillette Stadium, and now for the era of quarterback Drake Maye and head coach Mike Vrabel. The sisters never left a game early, not even under the most extreme conditions. For most islanders, the lengthy trip eight
times per year (plus playoff games) would not be worth the effort. While age has not kept them away from the games, it has made travel more complicated. Joan, who had been the driver, as well as the host of watch parties when the Patriots were playing on the road, had to move to the passenger seat four years ago when she could no longer drive. Jane and Jeanne would push Joan through the stadium in a wheelchair, up to their usual seats in the 200 section on the visitors side. Last June, their ritual changed for the first time in a long time, when Joan passed away. She had been their leader, and the sisters lovingly described her as the president, with Jeanne as the treasurer and Jane describing herself as the “gofer” of the group. Without Joan during the 2025–2026 season, there was no question the tradition would survive. “I hosted this year’s party in honor of Joan,” Jane said. Both sisters agreed that keeping the gameday ritual alive is what Joan would have wanted.
For over 30 years, the three sisters took the first boat off Nantucket and drove to Foxborough for every Patriots home game. Jane and Jeanne keep that tradition alive.
1 0 6
N
M A G A Z I N E
“I hosted this year’s party in honor of Joan, since she had hosted the parties for years.” – Jane Hardy
Jane Hardy and Jeanne Dooley sporting their New England Patriots gear ahead of their Super Bowl appearance against the Seattle Seahawks, a decades-long tradition and now a tribute to their late sister, Joan Fisher.
It’s impressive how many details Jeanne and Jane are able to recount for a specific game. They remember everything—the snow-choked drives, the biting cold in the stands, the choppy early-morning ferry rides. Ask them about favorite memories and the answers come quickly: the “Snow Bowl” in 2001, when Adam Vinatieri’s kick cut through a blizzard and Tom Brady’s legend began. The day in 2005 the sisters were invited to walk on the field to receive a Patriots Fans of the Year plaque. And of course, the six Super Bowl victories, including the unforgettable comeback victory in the 2017 Super Bowl against the Atlanta Falcons.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 0 7
O
ver the years, they have invited their children, relatives and friends to join their weekend ritual. Many came, but none were as excited as the sisters. But perhaps most impressively, despite children and grandchildren moving away from Nantucket, they have yet to lose a single family member to another team’s fandom. Despite the Patriots’ Super Bowl loss to the Seattle Seahawks in February, Jeanne and Jane are hopeful this will be the Patriots’ year. They purchased their ferry tickets for the Pats’ home games just days after the NFL released the 2026–2027 schedule.
The three sisters were honored by Patriots owner Robert Kraft as fans of the year.
Jane, Joan and Jeanne on Nantucket in 2016.
“I think [the team has] all come together. And there’s nobody trying to be a big star,” Jeanne said of the current roster. “They’re all working together and playing, helping each other. And they all seem to love their quarterback. And he loves them. I think they all have a great togetherness. And the coach is great, of course.” While some traditions evolve, others endure. For Jeanne and Jane, devotion was never measured in wins or losses. It was measured in decades of ferry rides before sunrise, generations of memories and a steadfast belief that some rituals are worth preserving. With another season underway, the sisters are once again making their journey to Foxborough.
1 0 8
N
M A G A Z I N E
Nantucket’s #1 News Source Everything else is old news.
“Working with the Nantucket Current has been tremendously beneficial for Lee Real Estate. Their large and engaged readership, high-quality editorial content, and professional reputation have helped amplify our brand and reach new potential with our target audience.” - Kiri Mullen, General Manager, Lee Real Estate
“An investment in Nantucket Current as a communications platform is the most targeted, strategic, and cost-effective way to connect with the various factions of the Nantucket audience-at-large. My clients have repeatedly had unparalleled results through their digital advertising vehicles.”
“Advertising with the Current has been a fantastic experience. Their team truly understands the local audience and has helped me connect with clients who align perfectly with my brand. The process has been seamless and I’ve seen a noticeable boost in engagement since partnering with them.”
- Ava Rollins, Ava Rollins + Associates
- Calista West, Private Jeweler
“When 6am comes, the Current is the first thing I read. That’s where I get most of my local news on Nantucket.” - Jim Perelman, Nantucket County Sheriff
“The Current is my primary source for timely Nantucket news, relevant information, and articles of interest.” - Walt Stokowski, President, Marine Home Center
“I find the Current intelligent and timely, and it is my primary source of news on the island.” - Bob Reynolds, President & CEO, Putnam Investments
Nantucket Current provides instant news to your phone or email inbox, no paywall, no subscription fee. The news doesn’t wait to break until Thursday, so why should you? Discover why thousands of Nantucketers view the Current as their single source of island news.
TM
N
EVERYTHING ELSE IS OLD NEWS
SIGN UP AT WWW.NANTUCKETCURRENT.COM OR SCAN FLOWCODE TO SUBSCRIBE
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 0 9
nvogue
A DAY AT THE
MUSEUM
HER SHIRT: REMY SWEATER, JEANS, HAT AND JACKET: MURRAY’S TOGGERY SHOP EARRINGS AND RINGS: SUSAN LISTER LOCKE NECKLACE: THE VAULT HIM JACKET, PANTS, SUNGLASSES AND WATCH: MURRAY’S TOGGERY SHOP
PHOTOGRAPHER: BRIAN SAGER EDITORIAL STYLIST: PETRA HOFFMANN HAIR STYLING: JOHN STANIELON OF DARYA SALON + SPA MAKEUP STYLING: JURGITA BUDAITE OF ISLAND GLOW MAGGIE INC. MODELS: ANNA DALEY YOUNG AND ALDEN BLEASE LOCATION: SHIPWRECK AND LIFESAVING MUSEUM 1 1 0
N
M A G A Z I N E
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 1 1
TOP: TUCKERNUCK SKIRT: CARTOLINA EARRINGS AND NECKLACE: SUSAN LISTER LOCKE BRACELETS: HEIDI WEDDENDORF
1 1 2
N
M A G A Z I N E
HIM SHIRT: SOUTHERN TIDE SWEATER, PANTS AND WATCH: MURRAY’S TOGGERY SHOP HER TOP: TUCKERNUCK BLAZER: MURRAY’S TOGGERY SHOP PANTS: REMY EARRINGS AND BROOCH: KATHERINE GROVER RINGS: SUSAN LISTER LOCKE N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 1 3
HIM SHIRT, SWEATER AND WATCH: MURRAY’S TOGGERY SHOP PANTS: SOUTHERN TIDE HER BLAZER AND PANTS: CARTOLINA X CENTRE POINTE JEWELRY: THE VAULT 1 1 4
N
M A G A Z I N E
HER SWEATER: REMY BLAZER: SOUTHERN TIDE PANTS, HAT AND BAG: MURRAY’S TOGGERY SHOP JEWELRY: SUSAN LISTER LOCKE HIM SWEATER AND PANTS: SOUTHERN TIDE SHIRT AND COAT: MURRAY’S TOGGERY SHOP N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 1 5
HIM SWEATER: SOUTHERN TIDE PANTS: MURRAY’S TOGGERY SHOP HER DRESS: CARTOLINA X CENTRE POINTE JEWELRY: SUSAN LISTER LOCKE WRAP: MURRAY’S TOGGERY SHOP 1 1 6
N
M A G A Z I N E
SHIRT, SWEATER, JEANS, HAT AND BAG: MURRAY’S TOGGERY SHOP JEWELRY: KATHERINE GROVER
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 1 7
HER SHIRT: MURRAY’S TOGGERY SHOP SKIRT: TUCKERNUCK EARRINGS AND BRACELET: THE VAULT RING: SUSAN LISTER LOCKE 1 1 8
N
M A G A Z I N E
HIM SHIRT: SOUTHERN TIDE SWEATER AND PANTS: MURRAY’S TOGGERY SHOP
HER DRESS: CARTOLINA X CENTRE POINTE EARRINGS AND BRACELETS: HEIDI WEDDENDORF RING: THE VAULT HIM SHIRT AND SWEATER: MURRAY’S TOGGERY SHOP PANTS: SOUTHERN TIDE N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 1 9
Rooted in modern wellness, we offer curated beauty services and bridal essentials for effortless elegance
DARYA SALON & SPA 7 SOUTH BEACH ST (SALON) 50 EASTON STREET (SPA) 508.228.0550 BOOK ONLINE: DARYASALONANDSPA.COM
NANTUCKETISLANDGLOW.COM
LASHES SKIN CARE SUNLESS TAN HAIR REMOVAL MAKEUP TEXT +1(508) 680-4715 TO BOOK TODAY!
HEIDI WEDDENDORF Available at
Erica Wilson • Nantucket Artists Association HeidiWeddendorf.com
NaNtucket kNot earriNgs
NaNtucket kNot Bracelet
774-236-9064 • Heidiweddendorf@yahoo.com Follow me on
1 2 0
N
M A G A Z I N E
Here for generations of little moments...
EVERY ROOM TELLS A STORY Introducing Nantucket’s Most Captivating Hotel 76 Main Ink Press Hotel provides a fascinating glimpse into Nantucket’s media past within a totally redesigned seacoast environment. With its subtle blue hues and textured surfaces, 76 Main is more than simply a luxury hotel—it’s one that showcases the fascinating past of this historic island through a media lens over the centuries. Come experience a one-of-a-kind adventure while being pampered with luxury linens, crafted continental breakfasts, and a calming outdoor lounge. Luxuriate today while savoring the richness of Nantucket’s past.
76 Main INK PRESS H OTEL
76 Main Street, Nantucket, MA 02554 | 508.228.2533 | 76MAIN.com
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 2 1
1 2 2
N
M A G A Z I N E
nha
OPEN SEASON IMAGES COURTESY OF THE NANTUCKET HISTORICAL ASSOCIATION'S ARCHIVES
Bay scalloping through the years
Dozens of recreational scallopers brave the cold waters off Tuckernuck. N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 2 3
Outside the shanty, with a heap of discarded scallop shells, 1910s.
A scalloping boat frozen in the harbor, 1961.
The deck of a scalloping boat in 1939.
Albert Kenyon shucking scallops, 1950s.
A man on a dory out scalloping, 1917.
Scalloping in the 1950s.
1 2 4
N
M A G A Z I N E
Peter Gomes with the day’s haul in Madaket, 1950s.
Two scallopers head out on the water, 1970s.
The Nantucket Lobster and Seafood Co. fish market on Straight Wharf, 1980s.
Shanties lining Old South Wharf in the 1950s.
Three scallopers busy shucking in Walter Barrett’s shanty, 1950s. N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 2 5
Recreational scalloping in waders on Tuckernuck, 1940s.
Linda Herrick and Leslie Johnson adjusting dredges on a scallop boat, in 1992. Two men in waders scalloping, with a dory and a skiff anchored beside them, 1910s.
In Madaket, four men offload their daily catch, 1950s.
1 2 6
N
M A G A Z I N E
Boats rigged for scalloping, docked between Old South Wharf and the fuel dock, 1960s.
Mildred Jewett, better known as Madaket Millie, with shucked scallops, 1950s. Jose Reyes throwing a dredge from his boat, Sina, into the harbor, 1950s.
Scallopers on their catboats, 1940s.
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 2 7
F O G G Y
S H E E T
NANTUCKET WHALERS The Nantucket Whalers were back in action this fall, led by a boys soccer team that got off to an impressive 8-1 start (7-0 in league play). The Whalers volleyball team also continues to improve, going to 5-3 this fall, while the football team, (No. 18 in MIAA rankings) and boys soccer (No. 3) look ahead to the playoffs.
1 2 8
N
M A G A Z I N E
PHOTOGRAPHY BY DAVID CREED
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 2 9
F O G G Y
S H E E T
NANTUCKET SHORTS FESTIVAL The 2026 Nantucket Shorts Festival, presented by NCTV at the Dreamland Theater, invited islanders to express their creative sides with short films shot on and inspired by the Grey Lady. Films included comedies, documentaries and short dramas, including audience award-winner "The One-Star Weekend" with Jenny Gifford, George Vasvatekis and Jack Bulger.
1 3 0
N
M A G A Z I N E
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 3 1
PHOTOGRAPHY BY CHARITY GRACE MOFSEN
featured wedding
1 3 2
N
M A G A Z I N E
Bride: Frances Walsh • Groom: Connor Rice • Venue: Siasconset Union Chapel & Siasconset Casino • Wedding Planner: Taylor Soule Events • Photographer: Barbara Zachary Photography • Second Shooter: Becca Thompson • Caterer: Island Kitchen Bar & Beverage: Easy Street ACK • Production: Advance Production & Design Rentals & Decor: Nantucket Event Co., Nuage Designs, BBJ Linens • Stationery: Cotton Paperie and Ofelia Botella • Cake: PPX Patisserie • Florist: Soiree Floral Officiant: Father John Murray • Bridal Hair: Darya Salon + Spa • Bridal Makeup: Darya Salon + Spa & Tantucket • Bride's Dress: Oscar de la Renta • Groom's Tuxedo: Hiltons Princeton • Band: The Sultans • Transportation: Barrett’s Tours
N - M A G A Z I N E . C O M
1 3 3
N Magazine ADVERTISING DIRECTORY
N
55 India
9
76 Main
121
Bar Yoshi
84
Cape Cod 5
14
Carolyn Thayer Interiors
17
Christine Reid, Charter One Realty
74
Coldwell Banker - George & Mara Vasvatekis
85
Community Foundation for Nantucket
6
Compass - Marybeth Gilmartin-Baugher
65
Darya Salon
120
N
21 f est o The b cket all u t Nan 136 ce e pla in on
ING
ide
O ER OW ENT E P EM TH GAG EN
Wor ldw
ER
Read
MB
agaz ine
ME
Loca lM
RE
F
2023 TER WIN
Y SALLMAN SUS
PAT RIC
ree t,
Na
fis he
|
rn an
tu
.c cket
om
Jobe Systems
14
Kathleen Hay Designs
5
Lee Real Estate
91
Marine Home Center
3
Maury People - Gary McCarthy Maury People - Gary Winn
N
19, 135 58 2, 23, 103
Maury People - John McGarr
39
Murray's Toggery Shop
120
Nantucket Cottage Hospital
30
Nantucket Current
109
Nantucket Historical Association
122
Nantucket Inn
38
Nantucket Microcement
58
North Conway Grand Hotel
50
Nourish Nantucket
75
REMY
84
Roberts, Feijo & Team
31
Sandpiper II
7
Seaport Shutter Company
59
SmartStop Self Storage
74
Stoneledge Studio
91
Susan Lister Locke
84
William Raveis Nantucket
1 3 4
8
Katherine Grover Fine Jewelry
Maury People - Bernadette Meyer
M A G A Z I N E
ine
n Sag
Bria
4, 51
O M EN O NT UR AL NA HE TIO AL N’ TH S CR
FOO
ON AS
LI
GH
TR
ON
TS
NT
AU
NT
UC
KE
UC
SEC
KE
HI
P
T’
S
T
BA
DY
IS
Y
URS
SK
ET
SPE NE
IS
URIT
T
LB
JOD Y KA
NA
K KE NNE
D IN
NA
DAN IE
agaz
in St
t, MA
.44 07
tM
21 Ma
ke nt uc
28 50 8.2
CHI CKE NB OX
The
GE
ucke
aphy togr
er Pho
LLE
HEN STEPELLI SPIN Y JIMMFETT BUF
Nant
99
N
zine
J Pepper Frazier Real Estate
B
Maga
38
T ’ S
MYE TROEM SETT
CO ON NT E BS BA ESID PR
cket Nantu
Jacob Lilley Architects
e rldwid
120
ad Wo
Island Glow Nantucket
K E
e Re gazin
120
U C
cal Ma
25
Heidi Weddendorf
N T
Lo The
Great Point Properties
N A
2024
Fisher Real Estate
ON PERof Sthe YEAR May
Eleish Van Breems
The Only Place to Advertise. r 2023
90
Winte
21 Broad
W
S
CH’S
R TO
P
CO
P
MAY
2024
Over the past 20+ years, N Magazine has established itself as Nantucket’s leading luxury lifestyle publication and the most powerful advertising vehicle on the island. Renowned for its compelling content, stunning photography and premium production, each issue is hotly anticipated and becomes a permanent collectible in homes around Nantucket and beyond. Accordingly, N Magazine provides businesses with residual exposure unlike any magazine or newspaper of its kind. To learn more about the many advertising opportunities available with N Magazine, contact Emme Duncan, Director of Advertising and Partnerships, at emmeduncan@n-magazine.com.
N-Magazine.com
@Nantucket_Magazine
Nantucket Magazine
B E R NA D E T T E M E Y E R .C O M
A Landmark Estate in Historic Downtown
Moors End | 19 Pleasant Street T O W N | N A N T U C K E T, M A
1.06 Acres | 12,545 SF | 9 Beds 8 Full, 3 Half Baths | Four Parcels
Bernadette Meyer Real Estate Broker
Offered at $34,000,000
License# 9503060 508.680.4748
PRIVATE PREVIEWS BY APPOINTMENT
bernadette@maurypeople.com
©2026 Sotheby’s International Realty. All Rights Reserved. Sotheby’s International Realty® is a registered trademark and used with permission. Each office is independently owned and operated except those operated by Sotheby’s International Realty, Inc. All offerings are subject to errors, omissions, changes including price or withdrawal without notice. Equal Housing Opportunity.
Unforgettable living begins here
21 Main Street, Nantucket, MA | 508.228.4407
fishernantucket.com