Skip to main content

Northeast Ohio Properties, March 2016

Page 1

,16,'( 8+ $YRQ 5HKDELOLWDWLRQ +RVSLWDO %ODLU 5XEEHU &RPSDQ\ /HJDO 6HUYLFHV

March 2016/$7.95

ting a r b e l e C s 70 Yee1a94r6 Sinc

+L]LSVWPUN *VUULJ[PVUZ

:^HNLSVR *SL]LSHUK LTIYHJLZ ZSLLR VWLU VMMPJL LU]PYVUTLU[ H[ UL^ ZHSLZ ZLY]PJL MHJPSP[` PLUS: ; K P ; ;YLUKZ PU ;LJOUVSVN`


'ZRGTKGPEG %NGXGNCPFũU 2TGOKGT +PFWUVT[ 0GVYQTMKPI CPF 'FWECVKQP 'XGPVК 6WGUFC[ #RTKN ^ RO (KTUV'PGTI[ 5VCFKWO %NGXGNCPF $TQYPU 5VCFKWO 9JGTG KPFWUVT[ RTQHGUUKQPCNU DWKNF PGY TGNCVKQPUJKRU CPF Ɠ PF PGY QRRQTVWPKVKGU

,QKP 7U

3UH 6KRZ 6HPLQDU ˳ SP *HW WKH LQVLGH VFRRS RQ WKH ODWHVW LQ LQGXVWU\ QHZV VXSSRUW DQG WHFKQRORJ\

([KLELW +DOO 2SHQV ˴ SP

Ű &RQQHFW ZLWK FROOHDJXHV Ű 3XW \RXU TXDOLͤ FDWLRQV RQ WKH WDEOH Ű %XLOG QHZ YHQGRU OLVWV Ű (QMR\ FRPSOLPHQWDU\ KRUV G̵RHXYUHV DQG EHYHUDJHV

.WPEJ YKNN DG UGTXGF CV RO

5HJLVWHU 7RGD\ &OHYHODQG6KRZFDVH FRP


Ǥ Ƥ Ǧ Ƥ Ǧ Ǥ ơ ǡ ȋ ͖͘Ȁ͛ Ȍ ǡ Ǥ Ƥ Ǧ ơ Ǧ Ǧ Ǧ Ǥ

Ǥ Ǥ

͔͕͗͜ Ǥ Ǥ ͓͚ ǡ ͘​͘​͘͘͜ ͗​͔͗Ǧ͙͚͜Ǧ͖͙͔​͔

Ȁ

͚͖͚͛ Ǥ ǡ ͘​͖͖͛͘ ͗​͔͗Ǧ͙͔͜Ǧ͙͚͔͗

̷ Ǥ


Reducing Real Property Tax Assessments Throughout Ohio And Across The United States Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill, Co., LPA

When you hire Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill, you work directly with Sleggs, Danzinger and Gill. Each client is directly represented at all levels by a principal of the firm with a combined 75 years of experience. No pyramid, no associates, no on-the-job training. Our clients deserve the very best representation, so we structured our firm to allow each client, throughout the entire process, to work directly with Messrs. SLEGGS, DANZINGER and/or GILL. Our philosophy is to work cooperatively with school district and County officials to ensure that our clients pay the lowest possible real property tax obligations. If a fair resolution requires litigation, SLEGGS, DANZINGER & GILL have the depth of trial and appellate experience to handle the most complex valuation issues. Whether the valuation relates to large industrial plants, apartments, shopping centers, warehouses, office buildings, vacant land or any other type of commercial property, the faces above will ensure that you receive the best counsel, legal advice and litigation expertise.

Member Firm

Todd W. Sleggs, Esq.

Robert K. Danzinger, Esq.

Steven R. Gill, Esq.

tsleggs@sdglegal.net

rdanzinger@sdglegal.net

sgill@sdglegal.net

(216) 771-8990 sdglegal.net

Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill 820 West Superior Ave. Seventh Floor Cleveland, OH 44113


ting Celebreaars 70 Y 1946

March 2016, Volume LXX, Number 3

Since

FEATURES phone: 216.251.0035 toll free: 888.641.4241 fax: 216.251.0064 www.propertiesmag.com

Photo by Harry Dempsey, Autohaus Image

CLEVELAND 3826 W. 158th St. Cleveland, Ohio 44111 AKRON P.O. Box 9 Munroe Falls, Ohio 44262 OWNER/PUBLISHER Kenneth C. Krych kkrych@propertiesmag.com MANAGING EDITOR/ART DIRECTOR Mark Watt mwatt@propertiesmag.com CONTRIBUTING WRITERS Doug Bardwell, Jeanne Bluffstone, Dennis Castiglione, Ian Frank, Lou Kren, Matt Lehnert, Alec Pacella, Diane DiPiero Rodio, John Slagter, David Woodburn

11

January Construction Starts Rise 2% Nationally

14

Expanding Opportunities Blair Rubber Company increases production capabilities with facility additions

20

UH Avon Rehabilitation Hospital brings acute rehab services to Cleveland’s west side

27

Trends in Technology 27 Top Trends in AEC Tech for 2016: ARC Document Solutions survey identifies emerging construction technology trends 33 Technology is Creating New ‘Masters of Construction’: Latest tools remove guesswork, empower users to execute projects with expert precision 35 Want to Save Taxes & Increase Cash Flow? Upgrade Your Technology 36 ACAR Corner: Buyer Trends = Social Media Opportunities 38 Financial Strategies: Caution – Left Turn Ahead

ACCOUNT EXECUTIVES Matt Lehnert mlehnert@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6753 Larry Overbey loverbey@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6649

Building Well-Being

46 Developing Connections Swagelok Cleveland embraces sleek, open office environment at new sales & service facility

OFFICE MANAGER Lisa Larissey 216.251.8506

53 Legal Services 53 Where Do You Turn When Your Leased Commercial Space Is Damaged? A look at three documents that help determine rights, responsibilities of involved parties 55 Proposed City Ordinance Will Mandate Building Façade Inspections 59 Vantage Point: The Reward of Patience In Workout Situations 61 Law Issues in Construction 62 Legal Perspectives: Joint Ventures – Teamwork Done Right 65 Safekeeping Through Shredding: Protecting vital data through information destruction 67 Does Your Ohio Real Estate Tax Bill Need a Little Spring Cleaning? If you plan to challenge your tax bill, the deadline is March 31, 2016 71 Everything but the Kitchen Sink... Should your property tax assessment include that? 73 Beware When Filing Tax Complaints: The School District is Watching

Cover photo: Swagelok Cleveland Sales & Service Center, by Harry Dempsey, Autohaus Image

Properties (ISSN 033-1287) is published monthly for architects, engineers, building owners and managers, general contractors, home builders, mortgage bankers, savings and loans, real estate agents, appraisers, servicers and suppliers in Northern Ohio by Properties, Inc., 3826 W. 158th St., Cleveland, Ohio 44111. Copyright © 2016 by Properties, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction or use, without written permission, of editorial or pictorial content is strictly prohibited. Periodicals postage paid in Cleveland, Ohio and additional offices. Subscription rates: one year $24.95, single copy $7.95, back issues $10 when available. Postmaster: send change of address notices to Properties, P.O. Box 112127, Cleveland, Ohio 44111.

DEPARTMENTS 8 13 41 44 74

PROPERTIES PEOPLE BOMA BUSINESS BILLBOARD NAIOP NEWS CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT www.propertiesmag.com 5


PUBLISHER’S NOTE March 2016

Spring Forward elcome to our March issue. Although it’s been a mild winter, spring will soon be upon us and the velocity of project completions will only increase – especially with the upcoming RNC convention just months away. It’s an exciting time to be in Northeast Ohio.

W KEN KRYCH

This month, we highlight a handful of area projects, ranging from industrial to commercial to institutional. We also feature two special sections dedicated to separate, major themes relevant to the construction, architecture and real estate communities: Legal Services and Trends in Technology. Legal Services In our annual Legal Services special section, we’ve gathered a number of educational articles from some of the region’s top professional firms specializing in real estate, property tax, financial and construction law. We welcome contributions from Buckingham, Doolittle & Burroughs LLC; Brouse McDowell; Frantz Ward LLP; Meyers, Roman, Friedberg & Lewis; Northcoast Shredding Services & Record Center; Siegel Jennings Co., LPA; Sleggs,

Danzinger & Gill Co., LPA; J. Norman Stark; and Walter | Haverfield LLP. Trends in Technology With technology always evolving and becoming even more integrated into all aspects of our daily lives, we also present our annual Trends in Technology special section this month. We thank the diverse group of experts who contributed articles to make this special section possible, including ARC Document Solutions; Precision Laser & Instrument, Inc.; and Zinner & Co., plus monthly contributors Stephen Merkle (Akron Cleveland Board of Realtors) and Alec Pacella (NAI Daus). Swagelok Cleveland Our cover feature is a bright new building, recently completed by Geis Construction and designed by GSLD Architects LLC, which is a great example

BRICKLAYERS LOCAL 5 Ŷ CLEVELAND, OHIO Providing Highly Skilled Work Force for Public & Private Projects Since 1867

• Brick, Block, Stone & Marble Masonry • Masonry Restoration • Educated Skilled Labor • Comprehensive Safety Training

6200 Rockside Woods Boulevard North, Independence, Ohio 44131 216-447-9965 Ŷ www.bricklayerslocal5ohio.org 6

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


of design and technology. One of the latest to be finished in Glenwillow’s Diamond Industrial Park, it is an extremely clean, sleek modern building for Swagelok Cleveland’s sales and service staff. UH Avon Rehabilitation Hospital Another new, impressive building, University Hospitals’ Avon Rehabilitation Hospital accommodates medical staff who utilize the latest techniques and equipment to rehabilitate patients who are disabled by accidents, falls or strokes. Blair Rubber Company HQ addition We also visit Blair Rubber Company’s headquarters/manufacturing facility in Seville, where a recent expansion project has essentially doubled its square footage. A global leader in specialized rubber linings, the company is now equipped for significant growth in the coming years. Coming in April Looking ahead, we are proud to once again promote the finest in building, design, real estate and development by publishing the event program for NAIOP Northern Ohio’s Annual Awards of Excellence event, to be held on May 11 at Windows on the River. This printed program will also be included as a special supplement in our April 2016 issue. Additionally next month, our Roofing/ Building Envelope special section targets the latest techniques, products and applications of building enclosures with project profiles and articles from a host of the top specialists in the area. We also are working on feature articles on the Schofield Residences and Kimpton Hotel, Cleveland Clinic’s Avon Rehabilitation Hospital, and Akzo Nobel’s newest office and laboratory project in Strongsville. Know that your input is very important to us and be aware that we are the vehicle that can shine a light on news about your company and projects – and broadcast it directly to the entire industry here in Northeast Ohio and beyond, so keep those calls and emails coming! Positively,

> COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE expertise. > PERSONALIZED COMMUNITY BANK service.

It’s all about collaboration, individualized service and fostering economic growth in our community. We’re committed to it. And nearly 80 years of community banking expertise supports it.

LET OUR TEA M HELP YOUR S THR I V E . Contact Rig Goss at (216) 239-5904.

Kenneth C. Krych Owner/Publisher www.propertiesmag.com 7


2'%+#.+<+0) +0 #.. PROPERTIES PEOPLE #52'%65 1( '6#. Highlighting notable industry events 4#/+0)X 4;9#..X %1756+%#. '+.+0)5 #0& .114+0) 2

1

4

5

n

6

7

1 Bonnie Teeuwen (Osborn Engineering), Chris Panichi (CWRU), Jim Thompson (The Ruhlin Co.), Jennifer Stull (Osborn Engineering) and Don Rife (The Ruhlin Co.) 2 Craig Nauman, Jim Smolik, West Davis and Bob Kelly (City of Westlake) 3 Hillary Lyon (Richard Fleischman + Partners), John P. Rach (CBLH Design) and Keri Ash (DIRTT) 4 Lee Hooper (Osborn Engineering) and Dannette Hauck (Cleveland Clinic) 5 Samantha Bittenger (NASA Glenn) and Marc Bittinger (CBLH Design) 6 Marty Burgwinckle Jr. (Turner Construction) and Don Rife (The Ruhlin Co.) 7 Amanda Romeo (Herschman Architects), Jesenia Medina (CHA), Carole Sanderson and Roberto Pinedo (Herschman Architects)

Osborn Engineering Groundhog Day Party f

3

Cleveland-based firm Osborn Engineering held its 6th annual Groundhog Day celebration at its corporate headquarters downtown recently. Approximately 150 employees, colleagues and guests enjoyed an evening of fine food, drink and conversation, while looking toward an early spring. P

6 X 174 )1#.5 #0& 8#.7'5 #4' %105+56'06 9+6* #.. %.+'065U &'.+8'4 37#.+6; 914-X 10 6+/' #0& 10 $7&)'6T ' 564+8' 61 ':%''& '8'4; %.+'06 5 ':2'%6#6+105 #0& (14/ # .#56+0) 2#460'45*+2T

1

2

3

74 56#0&#4&5 9+.. '0574' # (.#9.'55 241,'%6 '8'4; 6+/'T KMF T #).'; &T '4'#X HHNEK ).'00u+%109%(T%1/ 999T+%109%(T%1/

HHNgFFEgLFKI 8

4

5

SMPS Rock N Bowl 2016 Eighteen teams participated in the annual Sales Marketing Professional Society (SMPS) Rock N Bowl event recently, held this year at Cloverleaf Lanes in Independence. The event raised $1,800 in scholarship funds to send an association member to the SMPS National Conference in Philadelphia later this year. P

1 Erin Luke, Ben McKelvey, Jenny Hamilton and Bill Thrush (Thompson Hine, Inc.) 2 Jessy Medina (CHA Companies), Scott Zanick and Erin Blaskovic (The Krill Co., Inc.) 3 Bruce Taylor and Liana Lake (Arkinetics) 4 Scott Bindel, Ed Valentine, Nick MacKenzie, Travis Okel, Soma Nwaokafor, Lyuda Pasechnyk, Kolby Kahley and Jessica Henderson (Gilbane Building Company) 5 Marissa Petrovic, McKinzie, Christopher and Chris Trotta (Levelheads Inc.)

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


EA Group can take the fear out of unforeseen conditions that cause costly delays and keep your project running smoothly.

Don’t be afraid of the environmental emergencies that may be lurking around the corner at your site.

EA Group has been providing hazardous materials assessment and management services to the construction and real estate

BREATHE EASIER

industry for over 25 years. We can evaluate your site, prepare abatement plans and monitor the remediation work. Put our team to work early to avoid environmental emergencies that can cause costly delays and unexpected liabilities. We offer: • Pre-Construction Hazardous Materials Surveys • Abatement Design and Management • Air Monitoring and Exposure Assessment • Mold Assessment and Remediation Management 800.875.3514 • 440.951.3514 • www.eagroupohio.com 7118 Industrial Park Boulevard • Mentor, OH 44060


Y landscaping Your l d makes k a powerful f l statement to your clients l and prospective clients. Let our Grounds Maintenance Division keep yours in top condition all year long.

*5281'6 0$,17(1$1&( ',9,6,21 3URIHVVLRQDO _ 'HGLFDWHG _ ([SHULHQFHG

ZZZ KPODQGVFDSLQJ FRP *5((1


January Construction Starts Rise 2% Nationally Provided by Dodge Data & Analytics

he value of new construction starts in January grew 2% to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of $607.9 billion, according to Dodge Data & Analytics. The gain for total construction relative to December reflected moderate growth for housing. At the same time, nonresidential building retreated slightly in January, as increases for commercial building and manufacturing plant construction were offset by diminished activity for institutional building. The nonbuilding construction sector also retreated slightly in January, as modest improvement for public works was offset by a downturn for the electric utilities/gas plant category.

T

On an unadjusted basis, total construction starts in January were reported at $40.6 billion, down 14% from the same month a year ago which featured the start of two massive liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminal projects in Texas. If these projects are excluded, total construction starts in January would be up 1% from last year’s corresponding amount. The January statistics raised the Dodge Index to 129 (2000=100), compared to a revised 127 for December. “The construction industry, as shown by the construction start statistics, seems to be gradually regaining upward momentum,” says Robert A. Murray, chief economist for Dodge Data & Analytics. “Last year, construction activity proceeded at a healthy clip during the first half, followed by a 20% drop in the third quarter, and then a slight 1% rebound in the fourth quarter. January’s modest gain for construction starts is consistent with what was shown at the end of last year. On the plus side, long-term interest rates remain low, and such market fundamentals as occupancies and rents are supportive of further growth by multifamily housing and commercial building. The new five-year federal transportation act is in place and fiscal 2016 appropriations have been passed, which should help public works construction. On the negative side, the struggling global economy, the extended drop in energy prices, and the sliding stock market in early 2016 have raised the degree of uncertainty in the economic environment, which may contribute to a more restrained approach towards investment in the near term.”

Residential building Residential building in January advanced 5% to $294.0 billion (annual rate), helped by a 6% gain for single-family housing. “January’s improved pace for

single-family housing may be the initial sign that it’s moving beyond the lengthy plateau that took hold during the second half of 2015,” Murray says. Multifamily housing in January increased 2%, showing further strength-

“The construction industry, as shown by the construction start statistics, seems to be gradually regaining upward momentum.” Robert A. Murray Dodge Data & Analytics ening on top of the 22% jump that was reported in December.

Nonresidential building Nonresidential building, at $180.3 billion (annual rate), slipped 1% in

January. The institutional categories as a group fell 10%, pulling back from the improved volume reported in December. Healthcare facilities dropped 20%, as occasional gains such as the 11% hike reported in December for this project type continue to be followed by retreat. The smaller institutional categories registered weaker activity in January – public buildings, down 5%; transportation terminals and religious buildings, each down 35%; and amusement-related work, down 49%. The amusement-related category in December had been boosted by such projects as the $478 million renovation and expansion of the Miami Beach Convention Center in Miami Beach, Florida and the $130 million renovation of the Nassau Coliseum in Uniondale, New York. In January the largest amusement-related project was an $84 million addition to the Charleston Civic Center in Charleston, West Virginia. In contrast

We specialize in light rigging with custom crating and shipping options. Movers of The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Museum, The Cleveland Orchestra and more...

216.898.2990

www.bereamoving.com

COMMERCIAL Q RESIDENTIAL Q INSTITUTIONAL FAMILY OWNED AND OPERATED SINCE 1961 www.propertiesmag.com 11


to the generally weaker activity reported for the institutional building group, the educational facilities category was able to climb 17% in January. The largest educational facilities project entered as a January start was a $108 million bioscience research laboratory at the University

of Arizona in Tucson, Arizona. The latest month also included groundbreaking for several large high schools, including one in Batavia, Ohio ($99 million). The commercial building categories as a group grew 3% in January, following the 12% increase reported in December.

&203/(7( )$&$'( 5(6725$7,21 ZZZ DLFRQVWUXFWLRQ FRP Restoration Contractors

Office construction led the way with a 29% gain. Warehouse construction in January increased 17%, lifted by the start of a $134 million logistics center in Carlisle, Pennsylvania. Hotel construction in January grew 14%, with the upward push coming from the $205 million conversion of an office building to a hotel in the Times Square district of New York, New York. Both stores and garages/service stations fell back in January after December gains, retreating 10% and 35% respectively. The manufacturing plant category in January jumped 59%, running counter to its generally declining activity witnessed throughout much of 2015. Large manufacturing plant projects that were entered as January starts included a $750 million methanol plant in Louisiana and a $125 million pipe manufacturing plant in Nebraska. The 14% decline for total construction starts on an unadjusted basis for January 2016 relative to January 2015 was the result of this performance by sector – residential building, up 13%; nonresidential building, down 5%; and nonbuilding construction, down 45%. By geography, total construction starts for January 2016 relative to January 2015 showed growth in three of the five major regions – the Northeast, up 36%; the South Atlantic, up 8%; and the Midwest, up 4%. Decreased activity was reported for the West, down 1%; and the South Central, down a substantial 53% given the comparison to January 2015 that included the start of the two massive LNG terminals in Texas. Useful perspective is made possible by looking at 12-month moving totals, in this case the 12 months ending January 2016 versus the 12 months ending January 2015, which lessens the volatility present in one-month comparisons. For the 12 months ending January 2016, total construction starts were up 6%, due to this pattern by sector – residential building, up 15%; nonresidential building, down 7%; and nonbuilding construction, up 11%. By geography, the 12 months ending January 2016 showed the following performance for total construction starts – the Northeast, up 19%; the South Atlantic and the Midwest, each up 5%; the South Central, up 3%; and the West, up 2%. P

12

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


BOMA BUSINESS Exploring timely topics with BOMA members

Maintaining the Building Fire Alarm oo often in today’s economy, budgetary restrictions and expense cuts are forcing building owners and managers to cut back on services and maintenance functions in order to make ends meet. Imagine cutting back on one specific program that will end up costing thousands of dollars to rectify, not to mention endangering lives and property itself. Lack of attention in this area can result in the loss of occupancy and closure of your building. Getting this wrong can result in one of the biggest liability issues you could face as an owner or manager. What is this horrendous issue you may ask? The lack of testing and maintenance of the fire alarm system.

T

Here are some tips to avoid this pitfall: 1. Always make sure a licensed, reputable company performs the inspection on your system and at the required intervals indicted by the local fire department and/or your insurance company. The frequency of the inspection will be dictated by the occupancy type of your building. For example, an assisted living facility will need to be inspected more frequently than an average office building. 2. Be certain that your alarm panel has a sticker or tag indicating the last time the inspection was completed. The inspection company will provide you with a report detailing the results of the inspection and any deficiencies found. Best practice is to keep all paperwork regarding your system, from initial installation documents and drawings to all reports of inspections and repairs made. Retain in a permanent fire-safe place. 3. Make sure to have all deficiencies corrected as soon as possible. A reputable company will provide you with an estimate to make repairs. The fire

department must be notified of problems and will give you a certain amount of time to have repairs made before they issue a citation. Remember, deficiencies with your system indicate that it is not in proper operating condition and this could result in liabilities in the event of an emergency. 4. Use a company that performs multiple services, such as fire extinguishers, emergency/ exit lighting, kitchen hood suppression, sprinkler and fire pumps, etc. It is possible to leverage a combination of these services into a substantial savings on your maintenance expense. In addition, many companies also offer central station monitoring of your system, as well as other services including burglar alarm, access control and camera system installation and service. P BOMA Greater Cleveland is proud to provide this space to our associate members so they can inform, educate and share their knowledge with property management professionals. This article was written by Alarm & Engineered Systems Division Manager Phil Huffman, of County Fire Protection. Huffman can be reached at 330673-3600 ext 120 or phuffman@county-fire. com. County Fire Protection can be found on the web at www.county-fire.com.

&9$&--&/$& */ &7&3: Simplicity %&5"*-

is the new luxury.

.BZGJFME 3E -ZOEIVSTU 0) www.snowappliance.com

.PO 5VFT 5IVST 8FE 'SJ 4BU www.propertiesmag.com 13


Expanding Opportunities Blair Rubber Company increases production capabilities with facility additions By Mark Watt | Photos by Todd Williams

here are a lot of hazardous chemicals that make the wheels of industry roll,” says Dave Jentzsch, general manager of Blair Rubber Company. He would know. Over the past 35 years, the Seville-based company has grown to become one of the world’s leading manufacturers of specialized rubber linings that provide safe containment and transportation of corrosive chemicals.

“T

“We take the raw material, which is tree sap from rubber trees, and process it into rubber linings that are ready to install for customers in a range of markets, such as phosphoric acid mining, gold and copper processing, or the transportation of highly corrosive chemicals like bleach or hydrofluoric acid,” Jentzsch says. The company’s rubber products are used to line chemical storage tanks, rail cars, trucks, pipes and fittings, food processing tanks and similar equipment. “It’s a niche market,” he continues, noting that for each chemical or application, there’s an ideal formulation of rubber lining. “Our specialty is customizing a rubber formulation for a customer’s specific use, producing liners for them in our facility and then delivering the product to its destination, whether 14

domestically or globally. We’re the only company in our industry that provides that full spectrum of services.”

Increasing capabilities A recent $4.1 million facility expansion project has bolstered the company’s ability to serve customers with increased production capabilities and ample space for growth. Situated at 5020 Panther Parkway in a business park just off of I-76, the facility has effectively doubled in size, increasing from 55,000 square feet to a total of 107,000 square feet of office, warehouse and manufacturing space. Designed by JBA Architects, of Newark, with Akron-based Beacon Marshall/EM Construction Company as general contractor, the expansion includes a 44,000-square-foot northern

addition housing a manufacturing floor, machine shop, chemical storage room, cold storage area and electrical room, plus a new 8,000-square-foot southern addition for raw material storage. The project also includes new construction and renovation of existing office space to add a break room, an expanded locker room and two new offices, plus a training center.

A need for growth Jentzsch points to increased marketing efforts internationally and subsequent business growth, plus an overall increase in demand for rubber linings across different market sectors, as primary drivers for the project’s inception. “The space had become too small for us,” he says of the company’s exist3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


PROUD TO SERVE AS GENERAL CONTRACTOR FOR BLAIR RUBBER COMPANY

- Manufacturing - Industrial - Office - Business Parks - Recreation - Sports - Retail - Renovation - Re-Purposing - Repairs - Design/Build - Plan/Spec - Value Engineering - Total Turnkey - Leasing - Construction Management

Mailing Address: P.O. Box 1092, Bath, OH 44210 Phone: 330.659.2040 Web: www.beaconmarshall.com


BOOSTING PRODUCTION The expansion project has doubled the square footage at Blair Rubber Company’s headquarters and manufacturing facility in Seville, where raw material (top) is processed into protective rubber liners using a Rotocure (middle) and other specialized machinery (bottom).

ing facility, which originally opened in 2006. “We had recently brought in more machinery and it was getting a bit crowded. More space was needed.” Additionally, the company recognized an opportunity to add new product lines. “Our specialty has been the production of uncured linings, because they are flexible and can be formed into any shape the customer desires,” Jentzsch says. “Once rubber has cured, it wants to stay that shape. For some of our customers, however, it’s getting harder and harder to cure rubber onsite so there has been a demand to introduce cured rubber products as well. It gets us into a whole new market, predominantly overseas.”

Design and construction process In November 2013, once the company had identified the need to expand,

“When approaching the design of the additions, we were trying to optimize the flow of material through the facility as part of the production process.” Greg Cotterman JBA Architects JBA Architects was brought onboard to begin developing the design. “We looked at the existing building and worked out with Dave [Jentzsch] and [Plant Superintendent] Roy Eikelberry to determine what they needed for the facility and then began creating the documents,” says Greg Cotterman, vice president of JBA Architects. “A goal was to maximize the seven-acre site.” Soon after, Beacon Marshall was selected as general contractor. Fittingly, this would reunite the design/construction team that built Blair Rubber Company’s existing facility. “When bidding, we did have an advantage because we already knew the building, and because of that familiar16

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


MAKING SPACE The 44,000-square-foot northern addition includes a machine shop, chemical storage room, cold storage area and electrical room, plus an open manufacturing floor that’s large enough to accommodate future growth.

ity, we brought along some cost-saving design recommendations,” says Steve Marshall, director of marketing/operations with Beacon Marshall, noting that a design-assist construction delivery method was utilized. The construction team broke ground in August 2014. Helpfully, site work was minimal, Marshall says. “An access road needed to be moved and we

worked around a retention pond on the south side of the property,” he says. “Otherwise, it was actually a prepared pad when we started.” The additions are conventional structural steel with a split-face masonry façade, made to match the original building. “The project was pretty straightforward, like most industrial projects,”

HVAC ■ Plumbing ■ Fire Protection ■ Process Piping ■

Cotterman says. “Essentially, we made a big box to house the client’s equipment – although there were some specialized foundations under the new equipment to support the increased load.” One unique aspect of the project was the roofing system, which was provided by Blair Rubber’s parent company IKO Industries of Canada, Marshall says.

Proud of our involvement with Beacon Marshall/EM Construction LLC for Blair Rubber Company’s Plant & HQ Expansion 800-776-7181 www.sacomunale.com

“Large Enough To Meet Your Needs, Small Enough To Care” www.propertiesmag.com 17


3LHU 7YVQLJ[Z .YV\W SLHUWYVQLJ[ZNYV\W JVT <ZL 3LHU 7YVQLJ[ 4HUHNLTLU[ [V *YLH[L @V\Y *VTWL[P[P]L (K]HU[HNL

Photo by Mark Watt

*(33 (5+ (:2 /6> >, *(5 /,37 >0;/ @6<9 5,?; 7961,*;

PROCESS IN PROGRESS Raw rubber is dosed with formulations of chemicals, compounded in Banbury mixers and then dropped onto a mill where it’s pressed into sheets, cooled and eventually run through calendars to create finished liners.

“Today, most roofing systems for this type of building would be single-ply or TPO, but this was an older style torchdown system with the big pot, hot tar and asphalt,” Marshall says. “It’s a good quality style but it’s labor intensive and time consuming. That said, most rubber roof systems are a 20- to 30-year roof, but this one is more like a 50-year roof. It should last a long time.” A challenge for the construction team was building the additions while the business remained open, Jentzsch says. “Beacon Marshall really coordinated the project well, working around our existing operations,” he says. “We never had to shut down.” Seven months after construction began, the building was ready for early move-in by March 2015. “The project actually came in one month ahead of schedule and under budget by about $150,000,” Jentzsch says.

Along the production line “When approaching the design of the additions, we were trying to optimize the flow of material through the facility as part of the production process,” Cotterman says. That circulation of product begins on the south end of the building within the newly constructed storage area, where all material is shipped in from overseas. “These came all the way from Indonesia, Malaysia, Vietnam and Thailand,” Jentzsch says, motioning toward pallets of ribbed smoked sheet 18

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


rubber. “They’ve boiled the water out of the tree sap like you would make maple syrup, only they dry it so much that it finally coagulates. We store a huge amount of raw material because we are a custom shop. When a customer calls, we can make it and ship it within a couple of days.” From here, the raw material is dosed with formulations of chemicals, compounded in Banbury mixers – a process that Jentzsch likens to making bread dough – and then dropped onto a mill where the rubber is pressed into sheets. “It heats up from frictional heating, so we put it through some water and then fans will dry it off, cool it down and prepare it for the next phase,” he explains. In the center of the existing facility are three calenders, which are READY TO SHIP Finished product is packaged in boxes and stored in a massive cold storage room specialized machines that form, ply within the north addition, since cooler temperatures help to slow the natural curing process. and smooth rubber sheets to specirubber and cut them to meet customers’ “When we first built the facility here, fication using a series of heated and I thought we’d never outgrow it,” he hard pressure rollers. Sheets are first run specifications,” Jentzsch says. Finished product is packaged in boxes says. “Now 10 years later, here we are. through a mill to get the rubber hot, soft and pliable, creating a loud smacking and stored in a massive cold storage Not only do we have enough room with noise as bubbles of air are squeezed out, room within the north addition, since the additions, but we actually have cooler temperatures help to slow the more than we currently need. However and then fed through the calenders. “The calenders gauge the thickness of natural curing process. From here, the the business grows, we can decide what the rubber, which is quite a process for rubber linings will be loaded onto trucks to put here.” Not only that, the current design was tank lining,” Jentzsch says. “You’ll work and transported directly to customers multiple types of rubber into the sheet, around the country or to shipping docks conceived with an option to expand the building even further to the west, layer by layer, to get different corro- to be delivered overseas. with a possible 30,000-square-foot sion resistance from different chemicals. Eyes ahead addition if needed. These are not thin sheets. This is beefy Save for a machine shop, electrical “Our owners are always looking ahead, stuff. We do sheets that are between a room and chemical storage room, much 10 or 20 years down the road, and with quarter-inch to a half-inch thick.” Select liner products are then trans- of the 44,000-square-foot north addi- this project we know we can really grow ferred to a newly installed Rotocure, tion remains empty, ready to be filled into this building,” Jentzsch says. “We’re a machine that provides continuous with additional calenders or Rotocures as very happy. It’s a first-rate workplace. vulcanization of rubber sheets. “The needed. Filling the space shouldn’t take It’s still heavy industry, but it’s quite a remarkable space.” P Rotocure enables us to cure flat sheets of too long, Jentzsch says.

Congratulations to Beacon Marshall/EM Construction and Blair Rubber Company on your continued success.

ASPHALT PAVING | ASPHALT PATCHING | CONCRETE WORK | EXCAVATING MILLING | PAVEMENT MAINTENANCE | CRACK FILLING | SEALCOAT

Call 440-543-2253 for a Free Estimate! www.chagrinvalleypaving.com www.propertiesmag.com 19


Building Well-Being UH Avon Rehabilitation Hospital brings acute rehab services to Cleveland’s west side By Doug Bardwell | Photos by Scott Pease

ith the number of senior citizens expected to double over the next 30 years, and with one in five Americans already suffering from a disability, it’s no wonder hospitals are reevaluating how best to prepare for these groups. University Hospitals and Kindred Healthcare Rehabilitation Services just recently opened one of the area’s newest specialty hospitals – University Hospitals Avon Rehabilitation Hospital at 37900 Chester Rd. in Avon, Ohio.

W

Sitting on an eight-acre site, this 58,000-square-foot, two-story facility can accommodate 50 patients. “Different than an acute care hospital, Avon Rehabilitation Hospital exists for those needing both medical monitoring and functional rehab,” explains Allison Gilgenbach, area director of business development. University Hospitals originally partnered with Kindred Healthcare Rehabilitation Services of Louisville, Kentucky to provide an acute inpatient rehabilitation hospital in Beachwood in 2012, with that facility opening in 2013. Based on its success, the decision was made in the summer of 2014 to provide 20

a similar facility for those living on the west side. “Acute rehab is a step above the services provided by skilled nursing facilities, so, if a patient has special medical needs as well as physical therapy needs, they would qualify for acute rehab care,” says Gilgenbach. Treatment for victims of stroke, trauma, brain injury, amputations, neurological conditions, orthopaedic or spinal cord injuries are just some of the special needs addressed both here and at the Beachwood Rehabilitation Hospitals. Doctor of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation Dr. Fadeel Mahmood, MD leads the resident staff in Avon

as interim medical director. Based on Medicare guidelines, all patients receive at least three hours of physical therapy at least five days a week. “As a physiatrist, my specialty is physical medicine and rehabilitation,” explains Mahmood. “It’s a specialty that has been around since World War II, but is still not widely known. We primarily deal with orthopaedic and neurologic diseases and their functional impairments as well as being experts in non-surgical musculoskeletal care.”

Taking a tour Entering the building and signing in at the front desk, you are immedi3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


+&3"/0&16 ,0-&1 )0 "% &)&1 1&,+ ,0-&1 )

$921 2+,2

3528' 72 +$9( 6(59(' $6 &216758&7,21 0$1$*(5 )25

&+!/"! " )1% /" &+(67(5 $9(18( &/(9(/$1' 2+,2 3+21( )$; ::: $0+,*/(< &20 0$,/#$0+,*/(< &20

!30(!,4 0!6).' !30(!,4 2%0!)2 3%!,#/!4).' #2!#+ &),,).' #/-0,%4% 3)4% #/.3425#4)/.

0!6 ) . ' ) . # s %XCELLENT QUALITY COMPETITIVE PRICING RELIABILITY

%8#!6!4)/. 4/ #/-0,%4)/.

s #UNNINGHAM 0AVING IS A FAMILY OWNED BUSINESS WITH OVER YEARS OF EXPERIENCE s ,ICENSED BONDED INSURED s /UR MOTTO h+EEPING OUR CUSTOMERS SATISFIED KEEPS THEM COMING BACK v

* iÊӣȰxn£°nÈää >ÝÊӣȰxn£°nÈnÎ !URORA 2OAD 7ARRENSVILLE (EIGHTS /( www.propertiesmag.com 21


ENABLING EXERCISE Walls of equipment and rows of workout tables line the bright and cheerful Therapy Gym. Just outside is a courtyard where patients can learn and practice negotiating a variety of sidewalk surfaces, ramps and inclines.

ately impressed with the more intimate feel of a smaller facility. The pleasant greens, blues and warm oak tones are echoed throughout the corridors and patient rooms. The first floor features the very large Therapy Gym where physical therapists have their workstations and handle the intensive therapies needed by patients. Walls of equipment and rows of workout tables line the bright and cheerful room that looks out onto the courtyard. In the courtyard, patients learn to negotiate multiple sidewalk surfaces like concrete, pavers and gravel, and deal with ramps and inclines, all with the goal of eventually reaching the relaxing gazebo at the end of the path. While different people progress at different rates, some people strive for days to work up the endurance to get all the way

Next to the gym is the dining room where patients are encouraged to come for each of their meals. Getting dressed each day and meeting other people at mealtime all contribute to successful rehabilitation. An active daily living (ADL) suite enables patients and their families to practice regular daily activities before the patient is actually discharged. This 600-square-foot suite is set up with standard home Kristen Mackowiak seating, a full kitchen, standard bathroom and regular double bed. ESa From doing laundry in the washer and dryer, to getting in and out of therapy,” says Kristen Mackowiak, AIA, a standard bathtub, to preparing a meal NCARB, LEED AP project manager in the kitchen, to sleeping in a standard with architectural firm ESa for the Avon bed, all the daily activities can be practiced until patient and their caregivers Rehabilitation Hospital. For more mobile patients, a three- are comfortable with what are somehole putting green and a basketball times relearned skills. “Rehab is a total holistic process and court enable them to get outside and we really encourage families to parremain active. to the gazebo – for them it’s a shining beacon, beckoning them to keep going with their rehab. “Some hospitals have exterior courtyards for patients, but it is rare that the design of the entire courtyard is used for

“Some hospitals have exterior courtyards for patients, but it is rare that the design of the entire courtyard is used for therapy.”

22

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


Landscaping Contracts – with Extraordinary Color Plans Planting, Design & Installation • Irrigation Installation & Repair Routine Ro outtine ti Property Property ope pe y Ins Inspection sspec pecti pec tion o & Mainte Maint Maintenance a tenaa ccee

T HHNTIFJTGFIK GGNTFGMTEMMI '48+0) .. 1( *+1

5(387$7,21 %8,/7 21 75867 NATURAL ATMOSPHERE In the corridors and patient rooms, blues, greens and warm oak tones mirror nature.

ticipate or at least observe the safe techniques for transfers and mobility,” says Mahmood. “In order to create warm and bright spaces for the guests, we capitalized on natural light and views by providing finishes to pull the light throughout the building,” says Leslie McClenny, IIDA, NCIDQ, LEED AP ID+C with ESa. “Because a rehab facility may require prolonged stays for the patients, it was imperative to provide an environment that promotes hope and healing for the mind, body and spirit in a safe environment. To accomplish this, we utilized products that, through color and texture, evoke a sense of nature.” Entering the patient room wings, blues, greens and wood tones mirror nature. There are 26 rooms on the first floor, all within sight of the central nursing station, close to the core of the building. Additional nurse’s stations are located within each wing for more immediate access to all the patients. Restrooms in each of the patient rooms feature multiple levels of stainless steel grab bars. Walls are all a richly textured, bronze-color ceramic tile. Floors are poured, seamless resin, making maintenance as easy as possible. The second floor mirrors the first with just 24 patient rooms – 12 of which are in a secured, traumatic brain injury (TBI) unit. Because these patients can become more agitated and can be very sensitive to loud noises, they are kept separate from the other patients. The

6WDWLRQ 5G &ROXPELD 6WDWLRQ 2+ ZZZ VXSHULRUQUJ FRP _ 3URXG WR KDYH SURYLGHG WKH EDFN XS SRZHU SURSDQH V\VWHP IRU 8+ $921 5(+$%,/,7$7,21 +263,7$/

6XSHULRU 'HVLJQ 6XSHULRU 4XDOLW\ 6XSHULRU 6HUYLFH :K\ ZRXOG \RX VHWWOH IRU DQ\WKLQJ OHVV" Proud to have provided flooring for the

UH Avon Rehabilitation Hospital

Commercial, Institutional & Industrial Floor Covering Provider & Installer

Specializing in the healthcare marketplace with the highest quality & best service since 1989. We provide 24/7 service & installation. Call us today to take advantage of our trained in-house staff and extensive library of product information. Complete line of flooring including: Carpeting • Resilient Flooring, Vinyl & Ceramic Tile • Athletic Floors

Call today for a FREE estimate! 4300 Brookpark Rd., Cleveland, OH 44134 • 216-595-0100 • Toll Free 888-271-8200 www.propertiesmag.com 23


ȝȺȿȶ ȘɃɅ ȧȺȴɅɆɃȶ ȝɃȲȾȺȿȸ ȘɃɅ ȠȿɄɅȲȽȽȲɅȺɀȿ

ȧɃɀɇȺȵȺȿȸ ɄȺɅȶ ɄɁȶȴȺȷȺȴ ȴɀɃɁɀɃȲɅȶ ȲɃɅɈɀɃȼ Ʌɀ ȥɀɃɅȹȶȲɄɅ ȦȹȺɀ Ʉ ɅɀɁ ȴɀȾɁȲȿȺȶɄ ɄȺȿȴȶ ǁǁǁ͘ƚŚĞĨƌĂŵĞƌƐŐĂůůĞƌLJ͘ĐŽŵ ź ϰϰϬ͘ϱϮϲ͘ϵϮϲϮ ź ϳϳϯϬ ŚŝƉƉĞǁĂ ZĚ͕ ƌĞĐŬƐǀŝůůĞ

TBI unit features its own therapy gym and its own dining room. Administrative offices and meeting areas are also located in the core of the second floor.

Locating a site, beginning design Looking to serve the population of both Cuyahoga and Lorain counties, Kindred did an area analysis of anticipated needs and identified eastern Lorain County as ideal for their patients. Duke Realty put together a package for the partnership with a triple-net lease on the Chester Road property and design work began in 2014. “ESa of Nashville was approached for design services in summer of 2014,” says Mackowiak. “We worked with Duke Realty, the owner; Kindred Healthcare for the physical therapy portion; and UH for their clinical expertise.” ESa utilized its preferred team of engineers for the project, but hired R.E. Warner locally for civil engineering. “The client’s requested floorplan guided the overall design of the building, but we oriented the building according to the site, using materials to capture that region of Ohio,” Mackowiak says.

ʲʴʱʷʦ ʶʱ ʲʴʱʸʫʦʧ ʯʣʵʱʰʴʻ ʥʱʰʶʴʣʥʶʫʰʩ ʨʱʴ

ʷʪ ʣʸʱʰ ʴʧʪʣʤʫʮʫʶʣʶʫʱʰ ʪʱʵʲʫʶʣʮ

9DOHQWLQH

ʥ ʱ ʰ ʶ ʴ ʣ ʥ ʶ ʱ ʴ ʵ ʏ ʫ ʰ ʥ ʎ

ʕʕʒʐʔʖʖʐʓʗʒʘ ʙʘʚʒ ʹʪʫʲʲʮʧ ʣʸʧʎ ʰʹ ʰʎ ʥʣʰʶʱʰʏ ʱʪ ʖʖʙʔʒ

24

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


PATIENT FOCUS There are 26 patient rooms (top) on the first floor, all within sight of a nursing station (middle). Restrooms in each patient room feature multiple levels of stainless steel grab bars, ceramic tile walls and poured, seamless resin floors (bottom).

The building exterior features lots of glass, light beige-colored brick and EIFS. Plans were completed in time for bidding in late 2014. “It was a pleasure to continue our working relationship with University Hospitals which we have built over our 90-plus years,” says Jason Monter, project manager for A.M. Higley Company, the construction manager (CM at Risk). “We agreed on a GMP in the end of November and had a trailer on site just before the end of December 2014.” Work began in earnest in January, only to be thwarted by the extreme temperatures of February and March 2015. “We did get shut down in February for two weeks due to the extreme tem-

“Because a rehab facility may require prolonged stays for the patients, it was imperative to provide an environment that promotes hope and healing for the mind, body and spirit in a safe environment.” Leslie McClenny ESa peratures,” recalls Monter. “I’ve been doing this for 15 years and maybe lost a weeks-worth of work over that time due to weather, but never two weeks straight. Luckily it didn’t seriously affect our schedule.” The construction schedule for this project was very aggressive, just 10-½ months from start to finish. Working six days a week for almost the entire duration of the project, and in some cases seven days, the project went smoothly. “We were extremely impressed with The City of Avon Building Department. They couldn’t have been better to work with,” Monter says. “We were respectful of each other’s time and that went a long way, but toward the end of construction, Bob Schumacher, chief building official, and his team took www.propertiesmag.com 25


SERVING PURPOSE Next to the gym is the dining room where patients are encouraged to come for each of their meals. Getting dressed each day and meeting other people at mealtime all contribute to successful rehabilitation.

the time to meet on site to ensure that prompt final inspections were achieved. Having a head building official actually come to your site is extremely rare.” Even the neighbors were terrific assets on this project. East of the project, A.J. Rose Manufacturing let the team tie into their retention pond for drainage. Across the street, The Great Escape (a home leisure retailer) allowed construc-

tion workers to use their parking lot for the project’s duration of the project. Construction was completed with few complications and turned over to UH on December 11, 2015.

Summing it up Now that the facility has been open for a month, everyone involved is pleased with the results.

Suntrol It! SUNTROL

™

G L A S S

E N H A N C I N G

F I L M S

Suntrol.com 800-466-TINT(8468) ESTABLISHED 1975

Love Your Windows! 26

Select Pro Window Film Dealer: • Security • Privacy/Custom • Energy Savings • Glare Reduction • Sun Protection

“I love coming here every day,” Mahmood says. “It’s a great facility, we’ve got great staff, and it’s working extremely well. I know the patients really appreciate being here.” “We really enjoyed working with Duke Realty, Kindred and University Hospitals,” says Monter. “Having customers that really know what they want and don’t make lots of changes is extremely gratifying.” “Cleve Haralson, director of construction for Kindred, was a great owner to work with,” adds Mackowiak. “He understands construction as well as the clinical side. It was wonderful working with someone like that who understands all the moving parts.” And, as the facility begins to fill with patients, most of them can look forward to going home after a mere 12-day average stay. While some do require additional skilled nursing care, 80% of the patients do go directly home. P 3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


7UHQGV LQ 7HFKQRORJ\

Top Trends in AEC Tech for 2016 ARC Document Solutions survey identifies emerging construction technology trends By Dilantha Wijesuriya ARC Document Solutions

he construction industry has experienced seismic shifts over the past few years. A struggling economy and an evolving workforce, combined with advances in technology, have made change a necessity for many construction firms. They have had to adapt their processes, structure and competencies to continue to succeed.

T

Today’s environment for construction companies is tougher and more complex than ever before. Tight margins, intense competition and demands for faster completion times are increasingly common and put enormous pressure on construction firms. However, part of the changing environment is also a solution to many other challenges – and that is the adoption of technology solutions. Today, construction firms should be aware of key technology trends that will allow them to be more agile, com-

petitive and efficient. A recent ARC Document Solutions survey provides an overview of five key trends for 2016.

Virtual reality (VR) The top trending technology, named by 65.3% of respondents, was that virtual reality applications will be used much more in the future to experience a building’s design before it is built. Virtual reality in the construction industry is characterized by the creation and use of three-dimensional computerized modeling. Such models

are used to facilitate project management, detect problems before actual construction occurs, design workflow sequencing and to improve client interactions. The top benefits of virtual reality cited by survey participants were: 1) projects will be easier to visualize (51.9%); 2) projects will be completed faster (48.3%); and 3) projects will require fewer workers (42.2%).

Drones Another top technology trend, identified by 61.9% of the responwww.propertiesmag.com 27


WE SPEAK

ENERGY SO YOU DON’T HAVE TO IGS Energy has been providing customized pricing, expert product recommendations, and dedicated support to businesses for over 25 years.

VIRTUAL REALITY IN VIEW A top technology trend, named by 65.3% of respondents to a recent ARC Document Solutions survey, is the growing and/or anticipated use of virtual reality applications to experience a building’s design before it is built.

dents, is the growing use of drones for surveying and for photo and video documentation. More than 60% (60.5%, specifically) recognized drones’ ability to help with mapping and surveying, inspection and creating image-based records as their primary benefits. Close to half (49.7%) of the participants named improved surveillance and safety as the top benefit of drone use by AEC professionals.

Absence of paper Preferred natural gas supplier

ANDREA LONGBRAKE Senior Commercial Account Manager

614-659-5190 alongbrake@IGSenergy.com

28

According to survey findings, the future of the AEC industry will also be characterized by the absence of paper (38.1%) and the use of virtual technology to address not only two-dimensional drawing and three-dimensional modeling but also for project sequencing, cost estimating, sustainability and facilities management, often referred to as a “7D” building process. Over half of respondents (57.8%) predicted that design and development will become paperless in the next two to five years. Asked to identify the main reason behind the elimination of paper in the AEC

industry, respondents named these factors: 1) mobile/tablet technologies have replaced printed sets of drawings (43.5%); 2) Building Information Model (BIM) helps design and construction teams resolve building problems without having to print numerous drawings (27.2%); and 3) project teams are more environmentally conscious (25.2%). It is widely believed that removing paper in the industry will help diminish project over-runs. This was confirmed by survey respondents, who noted several beneficial results of reducing paper use, including: 1) better communication between workers (58.5%); 2) outdated data will no longer be shared (55.8%); and 3) changes will be easier to see as they are made (54.4%).

IoT (Internet of thing) The AEC industry will also see increased use of IoT. According to ARC’s survey, the top benefit of IoT (defined as a network of physical objects or “things” embedded with electronics, software, sensors and network connectivity) will be 3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


Try it Free for a Month ǁǁǁ͘ƐŬLJƐŝƚĞ͘ĐŽŵ


Architectural Illustration 3D Visualization Architectural Walkthroughs 216-359-1003 ] www.triplet3d.com ] info@triplet3d.com

the ability to better collect and exchange data on a job site. It will help industry professionals by: 1) improving onsite/ offsite equipment management (68.8%); 2) pinpointing the reason behind a delay (50%); and 3) giving clear indicators of a project delay (31.3%).

Big Data Also very prominent on the AEC industry’s radar is Big Data, identified as very large, complex data sets that can be analyzed computationally to reveal trends, associations and patterns. The top advantages of Big Data, according to the respondents, are to help improve planning and decision-making by providing granular, real-time data about utilization and usage patterns, enabling project leaders and owners to improve demand forecasts as well as their future project progress monitoring. Top Big Data benefits mentioned by survey participants are the potential to: 1) facilitate well-informed decisionmaking on a consistent basis (62.5%); 2) improve urban planning decisions (50.0%); and 3) create reports on construction operations frequently and in real time (43.85%) Transformative technological change is well under way, and its adoption will only accelerate in the future. These technologies will bring unprecedented collaboration, coordination and connectivity in the AEC industry, increasing efficiency, bringing down costs and making the industry more competitive. P

Dilantha (“Dilo”) Wijesuriya is CEO of ARC (American Reprographics Company). The ARC “AEC Future of Technology Study” was conducted among a random sampling of 147 architecture, engineering and construction management professionals around the United States, using an email invitation and online survey. Executives were from both large enterprises of 1,000 people or more and small boutique firms of ten people or less. ARC Document Solutions is a leading document solutions company serving businesses of all types, with an emphasis on the nonresidential segment of the architecture, engineering and construction industries. For more info, visit www.e-arc.com. 30

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


285 %86Ζ1(66 :Ζ// 0$.( <285 %86Ζ1(66 6+Ζ1(

3HUIHFWLRQ ΖWȇV PRUH WKDQ D ZRUG ΖWȇV ZKDW EXVLQHVV RZQHUV DQG SURSHUW\ PDQDJHUV VWULYH IRU HDFK DQG HYHU\ GD\ 3HUIHFW 3RZHU :DVK LV WKH FRPSDQ\ WKDW FDQ NHHS WKH H[WHULRU VXUIDFHV RI \RXU FRPPHUFLDO EXVLQHVV RU PXOWL XQLW SURSHUWLHV FOHDQ DQG PDLQWDLQHG

%8Ζ/'Ζ1*6 O &21&5(7( O 522)6 O &21'26 $3$570(176 &DOO RU FOLFN WRGD\ IRU DQ LQVWDQW TXRWH

O 3HUIHFW3RZHU:DVK FRP


7851 7+( *($56 6$9( 021(<

/HDN\ %XLOGLQJV (QHUJ\ (IÀFLHQF\ 3URMHFWV :H PLJUDWH FRPPHUFLDO LQGXVWULDO QRQ SURÀW FOLHQWV IURP FRVWO\ HQHUJ\ DSSURDFKHV WR DQ XSGDWHG HQHUJ\ VWUDWHJ\ UHGXFLQJ FRVWV 2XU VWDII ZLOO FRQGXFW DQ HQHUJ\ VXUYH\ SURYLGH D IXOO SURSRVDO WR WUDQVIRUP DQ\ IDFLOLW\ /(' %$< /,*+76 /(' )/22' /,*+76 /(' 75$&. /,*+76 /(' 78%(6 /(' 3$1(/ /,*+76 025(

ZZZ .HO /(' FRP

_ ZZZ NHO OXPH &R

;d]n]dYf\ k Kl]]d @]Y\imYjl]jk

&ROXPELD %XLOGLQJ 3URGXFWV STEEL JOISTS STRUCTURAL IRON METAL ROOF DECK STEEL STAIRS & RAILS STEEL ERECTION

440-235-3363 *-1.) =de Kl&$ ;d]n]dYf\$ G@ ,,)+0

Connect your facilities management to BIM. Save time and money. :RZ_ ^f]Rab M]Q SMPWZWcWRb \M]MURab \MYR \^aR W]S^a\RQ QRPWbW^]b ^] cVRWa OdWZQW]Ub͙ ?^QRZb P^]]RPcRQ c^ SMPWZWcWRb \M]MUR\R]c bhbcR\b PM] _a^eWQR͛ Л

E_MPR

Л

2bbRcb

Л

?MW]cR]M]PR W]S^a\McW^]

Ba^eR cVR eMZdR ^S h^da 3;? ORh^]Q QRbWU] M]Q P^]bcadPcW^]͙

Learn more at www.imaginit.com/FMandBIM or call us at 800-356-9050.

32

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


7UHQGV LQ 7HFKQRORJ\

Technology is Creating New ‘Masters of Construction’ Latest tools remove guesswork, empower users to execute projects with expert precision By Shane Zysk Precision Laser & Instrument, Inc.

n the old days, becoming a “master of your craft” was achievable only by means of years of hard work and dedication, usually through an apprenticeship, where time-tested knowledge was passed along, and the professional skills needed to competitively, accurately and effectively perform certain tasks belonged to a select number of individuals and was theirs to hold alone.

I

Planning & design There once was a time when literally everything was done by hand. Then came CAD, and the realm of drafting and design was changed forever. Perhaps no other innovation has been as impactful on the planning and design stages of construction as CAD, until now. Today, new software is taking things to the next level – specifically conceived to make 3D model creation a breeze with built-in tools and styles. A simple click-of-the-mouse set of commands quickly turns lines and shapes into 3D, scalable forms, whether from scratch or preexisting CAD data. Furthermore, access to such software has also been combined with access to sharable libraries of existing 3D fig-

MODELING SUCCESS New 3D model creation software packages include built-in tools and styles, plus access to sharable libraries of commonly modeled 3D figures.

facets of this process, and focus their efforts on what makes each specific project unique. ures of commonly modeled features that ultimately save time and money. This software additionally gives users the ability to create top-notch deliverables in the form of detailed proposals, scaled construction drawings, and customized lists or reports in familiar CAD and PDF formats. The aim is to give users the ability to automate the repetitive, frequent

3UHFLVLRQ /DVHU

,QVWUXPHQW ,QF

ZZZ ODVHULQVW FRP

Estimation Automated solutions for repetitive calculations and optimization of layout elements are helping those in the construction industry, not only with planning and design, but with detailed estimations of projects as well. The existence of frequently used structural and civil cal-

&RQVWUXFWLRQ 6XUYH\ *,6 6DOHV 6HUYLFH 5HQWDOV 7UDLQLQJ 6XSSRUW 6KRS 2QOLQH

%XLOG &RQVWUXFWLRQ 6ROXWLRQV

5REHUW )DQFKHU _ %XLOG &RQVWUXFWLRQ 6ROXWLRQV 2I¿FH _ &HOO _ 5-)#ODVHULQVW FRP

'HVLJQ

%XLOG

2SHUDWH

www.propertiesmag.com 33

Images courtesy of Precision Laser & Instrument, Inc.

This is the Information Age, however, and technology, both in the form of data-sharing and builtin functionality, has empowered us all with the ability to execute projects with expert precision. Specifically within the realm of building construction, there now exist time- and frustration-saving features that, far from removing the human element, free it to be more compelling and potent with regard to the final product. By taking the guesswork out of the process, modern innovations are allowing those involved in all aspects of the construction process to come together like never before to participate in a shared vision. Through the development of comprehensive, new software, automated checks and balances, and streamlined communication, the world of professional building construction is now both simpler and sharper.


culations in customizable databases can now save users time-consuming math on clunky spreadsheets and keep things moving forward. Software exists that immediately aids in constructing the best-possible layout for common elements of buildings, such as rebar within concrete components or steelwork. The detailed drawings gleaned from such processes can give users precise material quantities for early, accurate cost assessment. Additionally, the analytical engines within this software can aid in the exploration of design choices prior to physical construction. This allows users to determine the most cost-effective options for their clients and bid more competitively.

Construction Once a design has been chosen, the benefit of new software is only more prevalent in its ability to keep everyone informed and on the same page. Mobile capability means that the power of BIM collaboration is now possible in the palm of your hand. Able to handle large, 3D models and extract the info contained in such, what was once possible only in the office can now be found at the jobsite. Streamlining workflows like never before, the same layout plans are now accessible and compatible with desktops, laptops, smart phones, tablets, and even

34

TECH ON THE GO Mobile capability means that the power of BIM collaboration is now possible in the palm of your hand.

the finely tuned positioning instruments that have become an essential part of the physical construction process. Robotic total stations and other such instruments now link up wirelessly to control devices that work directly off of the same designs created back at the office. This links

Perhaps the most intriguing thing about new construction software... is its ability to automate the mundane, yet necessary, and still allow for complete customization where it matters. hardware and software like never before and empowers a team of one to perform a complete range of layout functions accurately, through automated functions, guided workflows and built-in checks directly in-line with the same plans that

everyone else is working from, ensuring the level of quality and accuracy in the final results. Perhaps the most intriguing thing about the new software being developed for the construction industry is its ability to automate the mundane, yet necessary, and still allow for complete customization where it matters. Coupled with this is the ability to explore a variety of design options early without disturbing a single clod of dirt. This means users can be as creative as they want, yet still know, beforehand, what the costs, materials and schedule will be early, letting them nail down an economically intelligent route that makes them more competitive. New software – through intuitive controls, built-in analytical tools and unified cooperative systems – are giving the average user the power to be as potent a force as someone that needed decades of on-site experience before, making them the new “masters of construction.” P Shane Zysk is marketing coordinator with Precision Laser & Instrument, Inc. For more information, visit www.laserinst.com.

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


7UHQGV LQ 7HFKQRORJ\

Want to Save Taxes & Increase Cash Flow? Upgrade Your Technology By Gabe Adler & Howard J. Kass Zinner & Co.

n today’s technology-driven world, it is no longer a matter of simply purchasing software upgrades for security or buying the fastest computer to remain competitive. Many businesses recognize technology is an investment that not only sustains business, but also improves their position in the marketplace.

I

For companies considering purchases of hardware, laptops, servers or handheld devices, the time is now to explore how the new tangible property regulations could reduce the amount of tax owed while enhancing their business. The recently issued Tangible Property Regulations control how businesses may deduct costs incurred in connection with the acquisition and use of tangible business property. The first factor considered in determining what costs can be deducted is whether a company has applicable financial statements in place at the time of the purchase. For this purpose, applicable financial statements can include (1) financial statement required to be filed with the SEC; (2) audited financial statements used for credit purposes; (3) audited financial statements used to report to shareholders, partners or similar persons; (4) audited financial statements used for another substantial non-tax purpose; or (5) a financial statement (not a tax return) required to be provided to the federal or state government or any federal or state agency. So, how much may a company deduct in tangible property costs? The second factor will be whether a company has an accounting policy in place. • If a company does not have applicable financial statements in place, if they have an accounting policy in place so designating, the threshold is a maximum of $2,500 per item • If a company does have both applicable financial statements and an accounting policy so designating, the threshold is a maximum of $5,000 per item This is known as the de minimis safe harbor, an elective provision that allows taxpayers to currently deduct amounts paid to acquire, produce or improve

and guidelines are met. (See example at left.)

Beyond technology In their entirety, the final regulations provide rules to determine whether an amount paid for an item of tangible property is currently deductible (expensed) or if it must be capitalized. The rules encompass five broad areas:

The Smith Widget Company purchased a $4,500 computer server. How should they treat this purchase? Determine if the company has applicable financial statements and then, if they have an accounting policy in place. Following the decision tree, you can easily determine if the company will need to capitalize the purchase or if it can be deducted. If it is to be deducted, you can continue to follow the decision tree to see which per-item threshold amount applies. In another scenario, let’s assume that the company decides to purchase five servers, all at the same time, each priced at $4,500. Again, determine first if there are applicable financial statements in place, then an accounting policy. When deducting expenses in this scenario, it is important to receive an itemized invoice so the company can expense each of those five servers, despite the total cost exceeding $5,000. In this example, Smith Widget Company has just effectively reduced their tax liability and now has more funds available to make other improvements. tangible property for tax purposes. The safe harbor does not apply to inventory or land and you must attach an election statement with your timely filed return, including extensions. Without the de minimis election in place, you must comply with the general rules regulating the acquisition of tangible property, which will generally result in capitalizing all such assets. Your CPA will work with you to ensure the rules

• • • • •

Materials and supplies Capitalized costs (which includes the de minimis safe harbor election) Costs incurred to produce or acquire tangible property Costs incurred to improve tangible property Dispositions of modified accelerated cost-recovery system property

While I’d like to say there is a cookiecutter approach as to what qualifies, it is not that simple. Your CPA should be familiar with the nuances of the Tangible Repair Regulations and, when they are properly applied, the shrewd use of the regulations can be part of a very effective tax strategy – whether you’re a small start-up, a mid-size entity or a large company. This is the time many of our clients review their accounting policies to determine if they comply with the most current regulations as well as to think about ways they can grow and build their businesses. P Gabe Adler, CPA, CGMA and Howard J. Kass, CPA, CGMA, AEP® are Partners at Zinner & Co. To learn more about the tax and economic ramifications of investing in technology, business upgrades or structuring your business for growth, contact the professionals at Zinner & Co. at 216-831-0733. www.propertiesmag.com 35


ACAR CORNER Issues in the real estate industry

Buyer Trends = Social Media Opportunities any real estate agents use social media to communicate with their current and prospective clients. Yet many may find it challenging to take their social media usage to the next level.

M

STEPHEN MERKLE

I have found that one way to successfully propel a social post is to identify a key buyer behavior and tie that into a trending topic or event on a local, regional or even national level. Engagement and interaction seem to rise when you connect your audience to a topic they are already interested in. One event, or topic, that the National Association of Realtors (NAR) recently used to incite engagement on social media was the 140th Annual Westminster Kennel Club Dog Show. You may be asking yourself what this topic has to do with real estate. But as agents, we must keep up with industry trends, from available inventory and mortgage rates to homebuyer purchasing behaviors. In this instance, consider: a majority of

homebuyers wish to work with a Realtor that is pet friendly and realizes how important having a pet in the home is in the purchasing process. According to a recent survey by NAR, 65% of American households own a pet, and of those, 83% consider their pet to be a member of the family. This staggering statistic showcases that pets in the home are a major buyer behavior. It also reveals that there is a benefit for agents to market themselves as pet-friendly and understand that the property, in many cases, should appeal to that specific homebuyer preference. This can include making sure the property is near a dog park, pet store or dog-friendly business. However, knowing how to integrate that message into social media outreach is equally important.

[Social media] engagement and interaction seem to rise when you connect your audience to a topic they are already interested in.

PCS CONTAINER SALES LLC • (330) 696-6458 Call Carol Pack for Pricing

DOUBLE DOORS, OPENS ON BOTH ENDS!

Ā 1PG 9C[ 7PKVU (QT 5CNG Ā 7UGF %QPVCKPGTU (QT 5CNG Ā 1PG 9C[ 7PKVU HQT 5CNG Ā 7UGF %QPVCKPGTU (QT 5CNG Ā 7UGF *KIJ %WDG %QPVCKPGTU (QT 5CNG

MANY USES, MODIFICATIONS AVAILABLE! Farm, Industrial, Professional, Construction, School, On-Site Ground Level Storage, Pop-Up Boutiques & Stores as Seen in Ohio City, Built-out Homes for Sustainable Living 36

POP-UP BOUTIQUES!

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


:H DUH 3URXG WR 3URYLGH RXU

/HII 0DQDJHG ,QYHQWRU\ 6HUYLFH WR WKH +LOWRQ &OHYHODQG 'RZQWRZQ &RQYHQWLRQ &HQWHU +RWHO &RQWDFW XV IRU D VLWH VXUYH\ IRU \RXU QH[W SURMHFW

NAR created a Twitter and Facebook hashtag, or way to identify messages or specific topics of interest, called #RealtorDogs to directly tie into the dog show. NAR’s social media accounts used this to drive interest and make their social channels more relevant during a time when people where thinking about the show itself, using the show to redirect consumer thoughts back to real estate, or pets in the home. The mini-campaign was designed to encourage followers on NAR’s Facebook and Twitter pages to share photos of their dogs and create dialogue about animals, the show and pets in the home. The social sharing campaign has already become a hit with their online audience, garnering over 1,000 tweets and trending on Twitter for approximately a day after the show! This is a great example of how to take a national topic and make it relevant to the real estate industry for the purposes of engaging your audience in yet another interesting way, while tying into an industry trend. If you would like more information on how to market yourself to increase interest in your business among current and prospective clients, visit ACAR online at www.akronclevelandrealtors.com or find us via social media. P Stephen Merkle is the president of the Akron Cleveland Association of Realtors (ACAR). ACAR is a regional leader, dedicated to the excellence and advancement of more than 5,000 real estate professionals.

6SULQJ 5G &OHYHODQG

ZZZ OHIIHOHFWULF FRP

BUILDING QUALITY AND COLLABORATIVE INTERIOR SPACES Experts in creating ȣ healthcare and ƣ commercial projects built with exceptional service.

GENERAL CONSTRUCTION • CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT • DESIGN/BUILD P.216.938.5050 • F.216.938.5033 • johngjohnson.com www.propertiesmag.com 37


FINANCIAL STRATEGIES Smart use of fiscal planning & action

Caution – Left Turn Ahead few months ago while attending a conference in Austin, Texas, I had my first experience with Uber. Although I certainly knew about this service, I never had the occasion to give it a try. But on this particular evening, several of my conference colleagues had consumed enough rubber chicken dinners and decided we should head out on the town – a perfect opportunity to give Uber a try.

A

ALEC J. PACELLA

38

For any of those who have never used this service, I would highly recommend it. The driver was there within minutes, the car was new and clean and the entire process was painless. Oh – and it cost a whopping $3.75. Uber is a great example of how technology has turned the personal transportation industry upside down. Traditional competitors such as taxi and limousine companies are scrambling to figure out how to deal with the disruption that Uber has created. But the personal transportation industry isn’t alone in facing major disruptions thanks to technology. Virtually any industry you can think of has been forced to adapt. Banking, retail, newspapers and music/entertainment all look drastically different today as compared to just five or 10 years ago. Certain segments of the real

estate industry have also been impacted. Companies such as Zillow and Trulia have opened the door for consumers to search for homes and research prices, while Quicken Loans has become a dominant online home lender. The commercial real estate segment has not been under as much siege as the residential segment. But I think that could change in the near feature. To find out some of the potential catalysts for disruption, read on. Information is a pivotal component in the world of commercial real estate. Tenants and buyers alike need to know what properties are available, commonly known as listings. And they need to understand the sale price or lease rate for similar properties, commonly known as comparables. Traditionally, real estate brokers have possessed much of this information but this is ripe for change. Several

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


7UHQGV LQ 7HFKQRORJ\ states have well-developed commercial multiple listing systems (MLS), including nearby Michigan. These are free for the public to access and search listings. (Michigan’s MLS contains nearly 14,000 commercial listings, for instance.) But there is no free system on a nationwide basis and if you are in Ohio, there is also no statewide MLS that focuses on commercial real estate. There are a few national data vendors that are active here, including Co-Star and Xceligent. And while their listing data is very good, both companies only offer certain information to the public for free, instead focusing on paid subscriptions. Several tech companies have attempted to fill this void, including 42Floors and Hubble. However, to date, all have met with limited success, especially when focusing on commercial space that is available only for lease. The situation is similar when considering sale and lease comparables. There is actually a way for the public to access sales comparables for free – through the county auditor web sites. And while the information is current and accurate (it had better be, as this is the same source used to reset values for taxing purposes), there are some associated issues. First is the fact that each county needs to be accessed individually. So if I’m searching for shopping center sales in the northeast Ohio area, I would need to access and search auditor sites for Cuyahoga, Lake, Lorain and Medina counties separately. The second issue is that each site has its own nuances – no two sites are set up or searched exactly the same way. A third issue is that the information is directly derived from public records, so searching on specific criteria, such as size or year built, is only possible if this information has been captured. And fourth is output, as most of the county auditor websites do not have reports available to print results. The best that you are likely to find is the ability to export the results. Bottom line: while finding sale comparables for commercial real estate is possible, it is not as seamless of a process as most consumers would want, nor is it as comprehensive. But I only have to look as far as Zillow to realize that someone will be figuring out the commercial side very soon.

Daus, You Know? SPEAKING OF AIRBNB Cleveland City Hall recently proposed regulations and taxes associated with shortterm rentals. These would include capping how many days a residence can be rented and imposing a 3% transient-occupancy tax. –AP Turning to lease comparables, the current situation is sparser. Even data vendors, such as Co-Star and Xceligent, have trouble sourcing and securing lease comparables. One problem is motivation; if I have a space available for lease, I want the world to know about it. But if I just completed a lease, I’m likely to keep the economic information very close to the vest. Another problem is the fact that the only people typically “in the know” of the details are the landlord, the tenant, the broker and the attorneys – none of whom will be particularly motivated to share any details. It’s tough enough for people who are in the brokerage business to be able to find lease comparables, let alone the outside public. However, a few companies are attempting to fill this void using a concept known as “crowdsharing.” This is the same concept that has allowed companies such as Uber and Airbnb to prosper. CompStak and DealX are two examples

CWRU Tinkham Veale University Center

CSU CIMP

of firms applying crowdsharing to commercial real estate – specifically lease comparables. The idea is simple. In order to access a database of lease comparable, I first have to share a lease comparable. This is no different than a strategy I employ all of the time with appraisers who call me looking for verification on deals that I’ve been involved with – I’ll do it but ask for a comparable or two in return. These new kids on the block just use a significantly larger scale. CompStak is only in selected U.S. markets (not including Cleveland) and DealX is in the UK. But both are growing rapidly – in less than five years, CompStak has accumulated over a quarter of a million lease comparables. And they have less than a dozen employees. Twenty-five years ago, a wise real estate Yoda told me that the only thing a real estate broker can offer is time and knowledge. Although a lot has changed in the world since then, this basic premise still holds true in the real estate industry. At least, for now. P Alec Pacella, CCIM, senior vice president at NAI Daus, can be reached by phone at 216.455.0925 or by email at apacella@naidaus.com. You can follow him on twitter @dausyouknow or on his blog at http://blog.sbequitiesinc.com.

MOCA Cleveland

CWRU Tinkham Veale University Center

Integrated Project Solutions BIM Coordination Services • Site Logistics • 3D Content Creation Revit® • Navisworks® • 3D Studio Max • Residential Design MIKE FURLONG, CM-BIM Managing Principal

330.414.9970 | mike@iprojsolutions.com | www.iprojsolutions.com www.propertiesmag.com 39


*65.9(;<3(;065:

4LJOHUPJHS *VU[YHJ[VYZ» (ZZVJPH[PVU VM *SL]LSHUK

*65.9(;<3(;,:

1HZO\ (OHFWHG 2IILFHUV DQG %RDUG 0HPEHUV RI &OHYHODQG 3OXPELQJ &RQWUDFWRUVâ $VVRFLDWLRQ

$QQLH 6WHUOH

DQG WKH 1HZO\ (OHFWHG %RDUG 0HPEHUV

Daniel Miller, Vice President Miller Plumbing and Heating Co.

Terry Bumgarner, Treasurer

Cathy Hattenbach, Treasurer

John Marotta Chairman of the Board

+DWWHQEDFK &R

Jeffrey Epstein, Board Member

President of Northern Ohio Plumbing Co., Inc.

THE CLEVELAND PLUMBING CONTRACTORS’ ASSOCIATION, INC.

2L`UV[L *PYJSL :\P[L *SL]LSHUK 6/ 7OVUL! ^^^ THWPJ VYN TLTILYZ JWJH

Michael Brandt Chairman of the Board 6PLWK DQG 2E\ &R

Commerce Plumbing

Charles Caye, Board Member

Michael J. Gallagher Board Member

Geoff Engel, Board Member

John F. Gallagher Co.

President of CPCA

'LYHUVLðHG 3LSLQJ DQG 0HFKDQLFDO ,QF

Coleman Spohn Corp.

Ridge Plumbing Inc.

James J. Roddy, Jr.

Richard Bukovec, Vice-President

James E. Jones, Board Member Jones Technologies Enterprises, Inc.

Layne Kendig, Board Member

6PLWK DQG 2E\ &R %UHZHU *DUUHWW &R

Michael J. Gallagher Board Member -RKQ ) *DOODJKHU &R

Annie Sterle

David Katz, Board Member

President of MCA

Relmec Mechanical, LLC

( % .DW] ,QF

Timothy Lavelle Board Member

James Primozic, Board Member

Gorman-Lavelle Corp.

David Williams, Board Member

Scott Wallenstein Board Member

3URMHFW 0DQDJHU IRU 5HOPHF 0HFKDQLFDO //&

1RUWKHDVWHUQ 5HIULJHUDWLRQ &RUS 6RHKQOHQ 3LSLQJ &RPSDQ\

Thomas Wanner, Executive Director

Neptune Plumbing and Heating Co.

Keith Willkomm Board Member United Mechanical Contractors, Inc.

Thomas Wanner Executive Director

&/(9(/$1'

2L`UV[L *PYJSL :\P[L *SL]LSHUK 6OPV 7OVUL!

^^^ THWPJ VYN TLTILYZ TJH JSL]LSHUK

The Leader in Loading Dock Systems Since 1957

TRUSTED • EXPERIENCED • RELIABLE Timbers-Kovar Company is a recognized leader in the sale & service of high quality loading dock & industrial door safety products. With our own fully equipped, factory-trained service department, we have the capability to service & install all manufacturers of loading dock equipment & will contract Planned Maintenance Programs annually.

Industrial Doors Ergonomic Lifts Overhead Doors Big Industrial Fans Loading Dock Seals Rolling Steel Doors

7653 St. Clair Ave., Mentor, OH 44060 800-222-DOCK • 440-951-1210 • www.timberskovar.com 40

Truck Restraints 3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans

DCA Report Identifies Draw of Cleveland’s Transportation Assets owntown Cleveland’s transportation assets are helping to attract residents and workers, according to a recently released report from Downtown Cleveland Alliance (DCA). DCA’s Downtown Cleveland Market Update for the fourth quarter of 2015 reveals a comprehensive overview of recent developments in area housing, office, retail, hospitality and transportation trends. Four out of five millennials reported wanting a variety of transportation options for commuting to work and daily activities. Downtown Cleveland’s access to public transit, walkability and amenity-rich neighborhoods makes it a desirable location to live, work and play. Since 2010, the overall ridership of the Greater Cleveland Regional Transit has grown 5%, with downtown trolley ridership growing 62%. The report also illustrates the city’s growth both from a residential and business perspective. During the fourth quarter, Downtown Cleveland experienced a 97% occupancy rate. Since 2011, the Downtown market has added 1,700 new apartments. The occupancy rate has continued climbing an upward trend, rising from 91% to more than 97% – situated above the national average of 95%. For more details, a downloadable PDF version of the report is available at www.downtowncleveland.com/marketupdate.

Photo by Kevin Reeves

D

NPS Designates Mantua, Zoar as CLG Communities The National Park Service (NPS) designated 34 communities from across the United States as Certified Local Governments in 2015, including two in Northeast Ohio: Mantua in Portage County and Zoar in Tuscarawas County. More than 1,900 communities now participate in the program, which provides local

governments access to historic preservation guidance and grants. Certified Local Government (CLG) designation makes communities official partners in the portion of the federal historic preservation program, which engages local, state and federal partners to promote historic preservation at the grassroots level. As CLGs, communities can use expert technical historic preservation advice from

the National Park Service and their respective state historic preservation offices. The designation also gives localities access to grants for historic preservation that are available exclusively from the Historic Preservation Fund for Certified Local Governments. Administered by the NPS through State Historic Preservation Offices, the CLG program links the three levels of government into a preservation partner-

ship for the identification, evaluation and protection of historic properties. In order to become certified a local government must meet several requirements, chief of which is committing to enforcing local and state historic preservation laws and establishing a qualified historic preservation commission.

NGKF Welcomes David Leb as Associate Commercial real estate advisory firm Newmark Grubb Knight Frank (NGKF) recently announced that David Leb has joined the team as an associate in the company’s Cleveland office. In his new role with NGKF, Leb will work closely with landlords and tenants to help them achieve their specific real estate objectives. Joining a team led by Executive Managing Director Jeff Cristal, Leb specializes in office tenant representation, with a focus on leasing and sales. Prior to joining NGKF, he was employed as the associate director of development and national affairs with The American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC)

Northeast Ohio’s Leading Fitness Equipment Supplier Since 1979

www.healthandfitnessohio.com Commercial & Residential Equipment • Facility Planning Design Delivery & Installation • Service & Preventative Maintenance

Commercial Division: 440.946.0839 x 4 Fairlawn/Akron 330.836.6640

North Canton 330.492.7773

Eastlake 440.946.0839

North Olmsted 440.734.4888

Woodmere 216.593.0233

www.propertiesmag.com 41


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans strategies. She is a graduate of the University of Dayton with a Bachelor’s in Marketing and International Business.

of Heartland PAC. In addition, he is an active member of AIPAC Cleveland, NAIOP Northern Ohio and Playhouse Square Partners, a not-for-profit group in Northeast Ohio that engages young professionals in leadership, volunteer and social activities.

David Leb

ThenDesign Architecture Hires Three New Staff Members

in Chicago, where he comanaged annual fundraising and political goals for the Ohio market. Leb received his Master’s Degree from Northwestern University in Evanston, Illinois and earned a Bachelor of Arts degree from The Ohio State University. He is a licensed real estate broker in the state of Ohio and is active in numerous professional and charitable endeavors. Leb is a board member for the Young Leadership Division of the Cleveland Jewish Federation and is treasurer

ThenDesign Architecture (TDA) recently announced that three professionals have joined the firm in connection with its ongoing growth. Stacey Little joins the firm as a project manager with 10 years of experience. She has worked on a variety of complex, large-scale projects for both public and private clients. She will also be part of the firm’s Revit Leadership team. She is a graduate of Penn State University. James Cowan has been hired as project designer/ project architect. With over five years of experience, he brings extensive knowledge

Allegro Realty Brokers Hudson Retail Property Purchase

James Cowan

of renovation and new construction projects, spanning the healthcare, commercial and residential markets. He is a graduate of Kent State University’s Cleveland Urban Design Collaborative, where he earned a Master’s of Architecture. Emily Danis has joined the marketing and communications team to support the firm’s culture, business development and marketing efforts. She has specific experience with branding and digital marketing, and will provide expertise in developing messaging and outreach

Allegro Realty Advisors, Ltd. recently brokered the purchase of a retail property anchored by Starbucks for $2.7 million. The property is located at 85 S. Main in Hudson. Starbucks has operated there since 1998, and the property also includes Great Lakes Bakery, Hudson School of Music, a full-service salon and an upscale fashion boutique. Russell Lamb, Julie Iselin and Chelsea Kulhanek of Allegro represented the buyer, a private investor from New York. John Talbot of Emmco Realty Group represented the seller. P WHAT’S NEW? For coverage within Billboard, send along company news, story ideas and project information to billboard@propertiesmag.com.

9G YQWNF DG RTQWF VQ DG RCTV QH [QWT VGCO QP [QWT PGZV EQPUVTWEVKQP RTQLGEV

CONTAINER SERVICE, INC.

¸;OL 3LHKLY PU *VU[HPULY :LY]PJL¹ -), *:) ,+., *,9;0-0,+

>>> 7,;,(5+7,;,05* *64 42

@6<9 *65:;9<*;065 :7,*0(30:;: .9,,5 3,,+ 7961,*;: @(9+ -965; 36(+ *65;(05,9: @(9+ 96336-- *65;(05,9: 3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


Serving Northeast Ohio For Over 60 Years! Residential Ŷ Commercial Ŷ Industrial Ŷ Institutional

Expert Brick Matching and Complete Inventory of Brick, Block, Masonry, Cast & Natural Stone, Plaster Products & Tools

9005 Woodland Ave., Cleveland, OH 44104 216.791.9800 Ŷ www.bruderinc.com

ʂ<RXU &XVWRP $UFKLWHFWXUDO 0HWDO 6SHFLDOLVWVʃ &200(5&,$/ ,1'8675,$/ ,167,787,21$/ 5(7$,/

6SHFLDOL]LQJ ,Q (QJLQHHULQJ )DEULFDWLRQ ,QVWDOODWLRQ 2I &RPSRVLWH 0HWDO :DOO 6\VWHPV &RSSHU 6WDLQOHVV 6WHHO 6\VWHPV &XVWRP )DVFLDV )ULH]H %RDUGV (DYHV 0HWDO 5RRILQJ 5ROOHG RQ 6LWH )ODVKLQJ 7ULP &XVWRP *XWWHUV 'RZQVSRXWV &RPPHUFLDO *XWWHUV 5ROOHG RQ 6LWH

3 2 %R[ 0DQWXD 2+

FRXUWDGLQF FRP www.propertiesmag.com 43


NAIOP NEWS Commercial real estate happenings

Advocating for the Commercial Real Estate Industry AIOP is hard at work advocating for the interests of the commercial real estate industry at the national, statewide and local levels. From February 8 through 10, several members of the NAIOP Northern Ohio Chapter (Craig Miller, Ryan Moore, Michael Panzica and I) attended NAIOP’s National Leadership & Legislative Conference. We spent a day on Capitol Hill meeting with our Ohio senators and multiple congressional representatives and their staff.

N

MICHAEL J. SIKORA III

44

With tax reform looming on the horizon, we spent most of our time with them sharing stories about the value of 1031 exchanges, federal historic tax credits, capital gains treatment for real estate partnership carried interests, and how all of those things are good for our economy as a whole. NAIOP has worked closely with Senator Rob Portman (and others) on an energy efficiency bill that allows a reasonable time to achieve energy efficiency in buildings and sufficient opportunities to recoup the associated costs through tax deductions and rebates. That bill is nearing passage, after a multi-year cooperative effort, so we encouraged members of Congress to help push it past the finish line.

At the state level, there are several major initiatives underway. Many of you probably know that Ohio Historic Tax Credits were on the chopping block last year. The efforts of NAIOP of Ohio leadership, NAIOP grassroots efforts, and certain other interest groups helped save Ohio Historic Tax Credits within a matter of a two- or three-day period, saving some of our members hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars, and allowing major projects in our area to move forward. Although we won that battle, a Tax Policy Study Commission was put in place to assess the future of Ohio Historic Tax Credits. In turn, the Downtown Cleveland Alliance has re-established its Tax Policy Working Group. Dave Sobochan will serve as

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


NAIOP’s representative of that Working Group, which will look out for the interests of Northeast Ohioans, as this discussion unfolds and the debate resumes later this year. Ohio has a very weak Curative Statute, and that weakness allows real estate instruments to be scrutinized and attacked here, far more than in any other state. I drafted an overhaul of that statute, which the Ohio State Bar Association is taking the lead on advancing. The bill has been introduced in the Ohio Senate as SB 257. I will serve as the expert for the Ohio State Bar Association on the issue. That bill is being supported by NAIOP of Ohio, the Ohio Association of Realtors, and the Ohio Land Title Association. Ohio lien priority law is not as clear as it should be, and it varies throughout the state on certain issues, which should not be the case. NAIOP of Ohio is supporting the efforts of the Ohio State Bar Association to clarify lien priority law, and we are working with the Ohio Bankers League to attempt to agree upon language that would be acceptable to all of the interested parties. HB 12 would impose specific notice requirements and provide for “opt-out” rights for property owners in TIF incentive districts. We had already worked with the sponsor of that bill to modify the language, so it is not as problematic as it would have been for our members. There was a call for final testimony on that bill in the Ohio House on February 16, 2016, and NAIOP expressed its position in opposition to that bill. We do not anticipate that it will move forward. NAIOP of Ohio will be holding its Annual Legislative Day in Columbus on May 4, 2016, beginning at 11:30 a.m. Any NAIOP Northern Ohio members who are at all interested in our advocacy efforts should plan to attend. We will also be hosting a local members-only event focused on our advocacy efforts, where things stand with each of those initiatives, how the experts on each subject anticipate they will play out, and what effect they will have on the commercial real estate business. That event will likely be held sometime in mid-to-late May, and CE credit will be available for it. More details will follow. Locally, the proposed City of Cleveland Building Façade Inspection Ordinance is justifiably garnering a great deal of

attention. This ordinance will almost certainly pass in some form before the end of March. The question is: what will its requirements be? As drafted, it would require inspections of all buildings that are more than 30 years old and five stories (or 75 feet in height). The worst part of the proposed ordinance (as drafted) is that there are only a very limited number of “qualified inspectors” based upon the definition in the ordinance, which means that demand for these services would far outweigh the

that visual inspection would a more comprehensive inspection become necessary. Based upon our communications with the City of Cleveland, we believe certain modifications will be made to the ordinance, which will hopefully address our concerns. We anticipate receiving a modified draft of the ordinance in the near future, which we will share with our members for further discussion and input. As you can see, there are numerous legislative initiatives that are underway, and NAIOP is playing a key role concerning many of them. We are ensuring that we have a seat at the table and are not on the menu as these important discussions unfold. Commercial real estate is too important to our economy and our way of life to let bad things happen to it, when we could instead help shape our destiny. Commercial real estate is also a critical part of the renaissance in Northeast Ohio, and we have to make sure it is protected, so that this wonderful momentum that is underway in our fine region may continue for as long as it possibly can. If you would like to be a part of any of these initiatives, or any others, please contact me. It would be great to have you involved in our efforts. P

There are numerous legislative initiatives that are underway, and NAIOP is playing a key role concerning many of them. We are ensuring that we have a seat at the table and are not on the menu as these important discussions unfold. available supply of professionals, leading to increased costs and delays. NAIOP is working closely with DCA and BOMA to address our concerns, which are significant. Primarily, we think the definition of “qualified inspector” should be expanded to include all licensed architects and engineers. Additionally, we believe this should be a phased process (depending upon necessity) that generally allows a visual inspection in the first instance, and then only if warranted based upon

Mike Sikora is the president of the Northern Ohio Chapter of NAIOP, and he serves on the DCA Advocacy Committee. He is the managing officer of Sikora Law LLC real estate law firm, and he is the president of Omni Title LLC, a commerciallyfocused independent title agency.

Stop Leaks • Increase Energy Efficiency • Extend Roof Life

Don’t re-roof. Re-cover.

Turn this...

Into this...

and avoid this!

5HQHZ DQG LQVXODWH ZHDWKHUHG DQG OHDNLQJ URRIV UP TO 20-YEAR LEAK-FREE WARRANTY

ZZZ 0LGZHVW5HVWRUDWLRQ*URXS FRP www.propertiesmag.com 45


Developing Connections Swagelok Cleveland embraces sleek, open office environment at new sales & service facility By Dennis J. Castiglione | Photos by Harry Dempsey, Autohaus Image

he sleek, contemporary building at the top of a cul-de-sac on Diamond Parkway in Glenwillow, Ohio is definitely an eye-catcher. It’s the new Swagelok Cleveland Sales and Service Center, designed and built by The Geis Companies, and everything about it says “progressive and pristine.”

T

“We were striving for a high-tech, modern, inviting and collaborative design,” explains Brian Jarzenski, associate AIA, senior designer for GLSD Architects, Geis Companies’ in-house design team. The 15,000-square-foot building sits on a 3.95-acre plot in the Diamond

Industrial Parkway, which is owned and developed by Geis Companies. “We worked closely with the Swagelok Cleveland team through [Swagelok Cleveland Operations Manager] Mark Thomas from design through finished construction and he expressed their vision for a crisp, clean,

6 6 ,QWHULRUV ,QF LV SURXG WR KDYH EHHQ FRPPLWWHG WR WKLV TXDOLW\ SURMHFW &RQJUDWXODWLRQV

6 6 ,QWHULRUV ,QF Ŷ &RPPHUFLDO &DUSHQWHUV Ŷ 6XVSHQGHG &HLOLQJV Ŷ 0HWDO 6WXGV Ŷ 'U\ZDOO 6\VWHPV 46

6DP 6FKLOOHUR -U 2ZQHU 6 %R\GHQ 5G 6DJDPRUH +LOOV 2+

modern look, which I believe we’ve accomplished,” Jarzenski says.

Natural light & open floor plan The facility’s exterior is entirely precast concrete, sporting a simple, white painted finish. The front entry and canopy is an expression of glass and metal panel, and this treatment carries through into the interior design. Just inside is a spacious, central “bullpen” with rows of workstations, flanked by outer offices with large windows and interior glass walls. The back wall of the bullpen area replicates the metal panel entry and front interior architecture to give the open area a decidedly symmetrical feel. It is drywall, but is painted in special silver paint that emulates the entranceway in texture and color. The overall interior office design palette incorporates white, silver, light 3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


Dedicated to real estate & building progress in Northeast Ohio since 1946 TODAY

,16,'( :KLWH 3RQG 7KH 5HVLGHQFHV DW 6L[ 6L[ (LJKW 3DUWQHUV IRU 8URORJ\ +HDOWK

,16,'( &X\DKRJD &RXQW\ $GPLQLVWUDWLYH +4 7KH 5HVLGHQFHV DW 6SRWOLJKW RQ 6DIHW\

June 2010/$6.95

August 2014/$7.95

)\PSKPUN )\PSKPUN N /HYTVU` / /HY /HYTVU

1Haa Z[\KPLZ WYVNYHT [HRLZ 1H 11Haa Z[\KPLZ WYVNYHT [ KP [ R JLU[LY Z[HNL H[ 6ILYSPU *VSSLNL JLU[L JL LU[LY LLY Z[HNL H[ 6ILYS ^P[O ^P[O K ^P[ ^ [O KYH KYHT HTH[PJ UL^ MH ^P[O KYHTH[PJ UL^ MHJPSP[`

2010 ,16,'( 'HYHORSHUV 'LYHUVLILHG 5HDOW\ +4 7ULSRLQW 0HGLFDO &HQWHU 3K\VLFLDQV 3DYLOLRQ 73<:! 7 3< <: :!! ,U]PYVUTLU[HS :VS\[PVUZ ,U U]PYYVUTLU[[HSS :VVS\[PV :WLJPHS :LJ[PVU : WLJPHHS : :LJ[PVVU

December 2009/$6.95

INSIDE: NSIDE: Wellington Welling gton n Pl Place lace • East Eaast Hall Hall att Hiram Hirram College • Secu

2000

-VY^HYK 7YVNYLZZ

<UP]LYZP[`,16,'( <UP]LYZP[` VM (RYVU JOHYNLZ VMM (RYVU JOHYNLZ 1DJHOH 0DQXIDFWXULQJ &R 6HFXULW\ )LUH 3UHYHQWLRQ 6WRQHEULGJH 3OD]D HOLHK ^P[O UL^ 0UMV*PZPVU :[HKP\T :\TTH -PLSK G[lgZ]j *((/' .&1-

*VTLIHJR VU *HTW\Z 1VOU *HYYVSS <UP]LYZP[` \WKH[LZ Z[\KLU[ SP]PUN THPU[HPUZ OPZ[VYPJHS KL[HPSZ H[ 4\YWO` /HSS

73<:!

)<03; ;6 :<0; A special i l llook k att C Const Construction tructio tion Management in Northeast Ohio

1990

HIGHFLYING

DESIGN Celebrated Viennese architectural firm creates new Akron Art Museum addition as cultural beacon

CClass PLUS Cleveland Clinic Courts equips Cavs with state-of-the-art athletic training facility

Dramatic re re-imagines as permane Great Lakes

1980

1970

1960

1950

1946

www.propertiesmag.com www ww w.pr w.pr w. proop op ope

www.propertiesmag.com 47


STRUCTURAL STEEL FABRICATORS & ERECTORS SINCE 1958

Mason Steel Contact Mike Smith for a Proposal:

Join us!

(440) 439-1040 | (800) 686-1223 7500 Northfield Rd. | Walton Hills, OH 44146 www.masonsteel.com Other Fine Products Available: Stone | Pavers | Fireplaces | Windows | Doors

LEADERSHIP BREAKFAST SERIES

IX FNEJ t 4'#6+0) 6*' 0'4); 1/2#0; 1( 6*' 7674't +%' 4'5+&'06f +)*6+0) 210514'& $;U *' *+1 '4152#%' 056+676' 4190' .#<# 16'. IGNN 1%-5+&' 1#& 0&'2'0&'0%'X KUGN g MUNN

14 /14' +0(1 14 61 4')+56'4X 8+5+6 999T%'50'6T14) 14 %#.. FEJgGJEgGENNT -!'!:).% ).#

+5 # 2417& /'&+# 5210514 1( 6*' .'8'.#0& 0)+0''4+0) 1%+'6; 48

3528' 3529Ζ'(5 2) 6(&85Ζ7< $8'Ζ2 9Ζ'(2 6<67(06 )25 6:$*(/2. &/(9(/$1' 6$/(6 6(59Ζ&( &(17(5 6(&85Ζ7< $/$506

)Ζ5( $/$506

9Ζ'(2 6859(Ζ//$1&(

$&&(66 &21752/

&20387(5 1(7:25.6 6758&785(' :Ζ5Ζ1* $/$50 021Ζ725Ζ1*

$8'Ζ2 9Ζ'(2

$XURUD +XGVRQ 5G +XGVRQ 2+

330.468.3366

ZZZ $PHULFDQ6HFXULW\$QG$9 FRP 3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


TEAMWORK + TRANSPARENCY Open workstations in the central “bullpen” and interior glass office walls help to create a collaborative environment for Swagelok Cleveland’s sales and service team.

grays and some black. “We coordinated closely with the furniture team to make certain we had a cohesive design look,” offers Jarzenski. All furnishings held to the color scheme with the exception of the large graphics depicting Swagelok products and industries served. Open deck ceilings in common areas accentuate the smooth inner walls and contribute to the sleek look of the building. There are only two support columns in the structure, which also contributes to the open space concept. A staggered wall configuration towards the back of the office portion of the building cleverly hides the warehouse, which occupies roughly half of the building. The warehouse features a burnished concrete floor, high ceilings, natural light from large exterior windows and unique LED light fixtures. There are two bays for receiving and shipping on the east wall of the building, as well as a walk-in entrance for customer pick-up of product.

The office and warehouse spaces are complemented by formal and casual conference rooms at the front of the building, plus a training room and

lounge between the office space and warehouse. The furnishings in the training room are modular to allow for various size groups and rapid reconfigu-

3 5 2 8 ' 6 7 5 8 & 7 8 5 $ / ( 1 * , 1 ( ( 5 6 ) 2 5 6 : $ * ( / 2 . & / ( 9 ( / $ 1 '

Z Z Z V L [ P R D H F R P

www.propertiesmag.com 49


CONTEMPORARY COMFORT The crisp, modern design incorporates glass conference room entryways (top) and restroom mirrors with indirect lighting (middle). The work café (bottom) includes a large flat-screen TV, an open kitchen and a mix of seating options, while offering wide-open views of the wooded property.

ration depending upon the dynamics of the gathering. The work café affords employees a great spot for “decompression” collaboration. It includes a large flat-screen television, a gaming console and kitchen appliances. “This is perfect for groups that are using the training room,” Jarzenski says. The interior of the building is bathed in natural light, which adds to its open architecture.

Fast work reputation is earned Perhaps one of the most impressive elements of the project is the short time frame from groundbreaking to

“We had a good plan and worked through obstacles as they presented themselves with a collaborative approach.... It was a streamlined project.” Michael Bauer Geis Construction open doors. The Geis Companies finished in less than eight months. Construction began in December 2014 with a July 2015 turnover. “We had a good plan and worked through obstacles as they presented themselves with a collaborative approach,” says Michael Bauer, project manager for Geis Construction. “The plans were completed before construction began and with the exception of a few finishing details, it was a streamlined project.” Bauer notes that the biggest challenge was starting construction in the cold winter weather, which gave way to a record wet spring. This made negotiating equipment and 50

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


ORGANIZED FOR EFFICIENCY The warehouse features a burnished concrete floor, high ceilings, natural light from large exterior windows and unique LED light fixtures.

materials around the existing culvert more difficult. The site borders a residential area, so Geis and Swagelok Cleveland were sensitive to noise concerns during design and construction. “We were careful to be respectful of our neighbors during

the build and also made certain that the sight lines were as unobtrusive as possible,” says Bauer.

Build to budget philosophy Geis has a “fast work” reputation, which was certainly demonstrated in

HVAC ■ Plumbing ■ Fire Protection ■ Process Piping ■

the schedule from design to delivery on this project. “We also pride ourselves on a budget-driven approach,” says Bauer. Adds Jarzenski, “We build to budget and work closely with our subcontractors to make sure they embrace our approach, as well.” P

Proud of our involvement with GLSD/Geis Companies at Swagelok Cleveland Sales & Service Center 800-776-7181 www.sacomunale.com

“Large Enough To Meet Your Needs, Small Enough To Care” www.propertiesmag.com 51


Collective Experience. Collaborative Culture. Creative Solutions.

Beyond Legal Advice… Real Business Solutions Q Real Estate Transactions and Litigation

Q Construction Contracting &

Dispute Resolution

Q Leasing Q Real Estate Development & Finance

Q Debt Restructuring

Q Real Property Tax Valuation Complaints

Q Environmental Law

Q Tax Consulting and Structuring for

Q Government Incentives

Real Estate Investments Q Zoning and Land Use Planning

Q Insurance Recovery Actions for

Policyholders

For more information, contact Tom Gattozzi (tgattozzi@brouse.com) at or Jim Dixon (jdixon@brouse.com) at .

Cleveland Q Akron Q Lorain County Q www.brouse.com

Superior Ave. East, Suite , Cleveland, Ohio Phone: Fax:

WHEN IT COMES TO CLEAN, WE MEAN BUSINESS.

BUILDING SERVICES

A TOTAL FACILITY MAINTENANCE COMPANY &216758&7,21 &/($1,1* /$%25(56 528*+ &/($183 ),1$/ &/($183 ,17(5,25 (;7(5,25 :,1'2: :$6+,1* 21 %8,/',1*6 2) $// 6+$3(6 6,=(6 '$,/< 1,*+7/< &8672',$/ 6(59,&(6 7,/( )/225 5(6725$7,21 32:(5:$6+,1* 3$5.,1* *$5$*(6 %8,/',1*6 :$/.:$<6 (7& 26118 Broadway Avenue • Oakwood Village, Ohio 44146 • 440-439-2288 www.crystalclearbuildingservices.com • www.crystalclearhome.com 52

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


/HJDO 6HUYLFHV Where Do You Turn When Your Leased Commercial Space Is Damaged? A look at three documents that help determine rights, responsibilities of involved parties By David Lum Brouse McDowell

cenario: 30,000 square feet of commercial space is leased to a tenant in a large multi-tenant building. There was an extensive build-out of the tenant’s space that included not only furniture, fixtures and equipment, but also significant improvements to the building. Shortly after completion of the build-out, a pipe burst and caused damage to the tenant’s personal property, the building and improvements, as well as neighboring tenants.

S

Whether you are the tenant or the landlord, a scenario like this can pose numerous challenges. Who caused the problem – the tenant, the landlord, the contractor? Who is responsible for repair? Is there insurance available that will pay for repairs? What about damage to the other tenants’ property? Three documents will be important and require careful analysis to determine the rights and responsibilities of the parties: the lease, the insurance policies, and the agreement with the contractor.

insurance. The key for landlords and tenants, however, is not where the line is drawn between insurance responsibilities, but to make sure that there are no gaps in coverage.

The agreement with the contractor

The lease The first place the landlord and tenant should turn is to the lease. The lease will define who owns the property and improvements, who is responsible to insure them, and who is responsible to repair and/or replace them. Typically, the landlord will own and insure the building and improvements, and the tenant will own and insure its personal property and trade fixtures. In a situation where there was a significant build-out of the premises, however, this can be a tricky issue. Can the tenant claim ownership over improvements to the building if it paid for them, or does ownership of the improvements rest in the landlord once installed? The answers to these questions will likely control the restoration obligations, and the respective insurance companies will look to the lease to determine their rights and obligations as well.

Regardless of who pays for the repairs, it is imperative that the parties include a mutual waiver of subrogation in the lease. Such a provision prevents landlord’s insurer (if it paid for the repairs) from seeking to recover those costs from the tenant.

The insurance policies A typical commercial lease will likely require the landlord to insure the building and improvements and the tenant to insure its personal property and fixtures. Where you draw the line between the real property and the tenant improvements and fixtures can be a tricky one. The landlord (and its property insurer) may argue that certain improvements (even if affixed to the real property) are really trade fixtures that should be covered by tenant’s personal property

While the bursting of the pipe may have been caused by a construction defect, insurance coverage issues that pertain to defective work situations are quite complicated. Whether hired by the landlord or tenant, the construction contract should require the contractor to maintain builder’s risk insurance during the pendency of the construction as well as adequate liability coverage for itself and all of the subcontractors working on the project. Consequently, before you sign a lease (whether as landlord or tenant), run this potential scenario by your attorney and your insurance advisor and make sure that the lease appropriately addresses the buildout, casualty, insurance and repair issues. Moreover, make sure that you obtain certificates of insurance coverage from the other parties (tenant/landlord and any contractors that may be working on the build-out), to ensure that the necessary coverages are actually put in place. P David Lum is partner of the Real Estate & Construction practice group at Brouse McDowell. For more information, visit www.brouse.com. www.propertiesmag.com 53


Our strength is in our numbers. Put one of the region’s largest real estate practice groups to work for you. We have the resources and experience to handle transactions of any size. Urban & Historic Redevelopment Land Use & Zoning

The Real Estate Attorneys of

Real Estate Finance

Leasing

Development

Tax Credit Transactions

Tech, Multi-family & Shopping Centers

Josh Hurtuk, Megan Zaidan, Kevin Murphy, Tyler Bobes, Todd Hunt, Jack Waldeck, Sophia Deseran, David Mansbery, Nick Catanzarite, Rick Amburgey, Nate Felker, Jennifer Heimlich, David Ricco and Geoff Goss

Cleveland | 216.781.1212 www.walterhav.com

BETWEEN THE WEATHER & YOU SINCE 1922

WARREN ROOFING WARREN ROOFING AND INSULATING COMPANY

Working directly with manufacturers to provide efficient, reliable service and installation of a complete selection of roof systems, from single-ply to solar & green roofing. ABOVE ALL... WE ARE THE ROOFING PROFESSIONALS

Commercial/Industrial Roofing + Architectural Sheet Metal 54

440.439.4404

Fax 440.439.7523

www.warrenroofing.com 3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


/HJDO 6HUYLFHV

Proposed City Ordinance Will Mandate Building Façade Inspections By Jack Waldeck Walter | Haverfield LLP

fter several recent incidents of building façades deteriorating and falling onto public walkways around Greater Cleveland, City Council has responded with a newly proposed ordinance that would require regular inspections of the building façades of older buildings. The ordinance is still in the legislative process, so some of the provisions may change.

A

Councilman Joe Cimperman led the charge, proposing the new Chapter 3143 which would require inspections every five years on buildings that are five stories high or 75 feet above grade (whichever is shorter) at any point along their perimeters and more than 30 years old. Buildings subject to the new inspection requirement must also have a protected distance (defined as the space between the building and public way, other structure or adjoining property) that is equal to or less than the height of the substantial structure from its tallest height above grade. One-, two-and three-family residential buildings are exempt from the ordinance. Although no injuries had been reported as a result of the falling façades, property damage did occur and the potential does

exist for people to get hurt. One of the most newsworthy incidents of a deteriorated façade occurred at East 6th Street near Euclid, where a large piece of the façade fell from the building, damaging public property and several vehicles. Other downtown buildings have experienced similar problems in recent years. Downtown Cleveland is not the only part of the city with a high percentage of older buildings that would be subject to the new inspection requirements. Numerous buildings on Lorain Avenue, as well as throughout Ohio City and Tremont and around University Circle would also be directly affected. Nor is Cleveland alone in implementing such an ordinance. Other cities that already require building owners to periodically inspect certain building facades to help

ensure public safety include Columbus, Pittsburgh, Detroit, Chicago, New York, Boston, Milwaukee, Philadelphia and St. Louis. Once approved, the new ordinance will take effect within 60 days, although building owners would have one year to complete and document the required inspections. The inspection report will need to document all significant deterioration, unsafe conditions and movement observed. Building owners are then expected to begin repairs or implement reinforcement or precautionary measures immediately. Assuming a building passes the inspection, a certificate will be issued and should be conspicuously displayed to communicate that the building has met the imposed requirements. www.propertiesmag.com 55


)DEULFDWLRQ ,QVWDOODWLRQ 6HUYLFH LQ \HDUV U H Y R RU OL]LQJ I 6SHFLD U URRIWRS G H J D RW ZDWH K 3DFN P GLQJ ¥ VWHD ZHO Q R L W D F %RLOHUV UL HWDO IDE HOGLQJ 6KHHWP ULFDWLRQ Z IDE QW J 3ODVWLF LQHHULQ QFH GHSDUWPH J Q H G HQD 9DOXH PDLQW H F L Y U H )XOO V

216.662.5200 chassvecinc@brightdsl.net

56

ZZZ OLVFRKYDF FRP 6WDWH 5G 1 5R\DOWRQ 2+

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


Failure to comply with the new ordinance carries stricter penalties than is the case with many city ordinances. Building owners who do not comply with any of the provisions of the Chapter can be found guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree. Each day of noncompliance constitutes a separate offense. Perhaps of equal importance, and certainly something building owners must be mindful of, is the fact that owners not possessing the required certificate evidencing compliance may have trouble refinancing or transferring the property. The final terms and requirements of the ordinance are still being debated. NAIOP, DCA and BOMA have organized a task force that is providing comments and recommendations for making the new ordinance more workable. The work of the task force is described in the NAIOP

The new Chapter 3143 would require inspections every five years on buildings that are five stories high or 75 feet above grade (whichever is shorter) at any point along their perimeters and more than 30 years old. News column in this issue (see pg. 44). Currently, for example, building owners would be subject to a separate offense for every day that the building remains occupied after the passage of the ordinance. Since there will likely be a schedule backlog for inspectors immediately after the new ordinance passes, it will be difficult and, potentially, very costly for building owners who cannot immediately comply. The new ordinance will also make it more important for developers and property owners to involve legal counsel experienced in real estate matters for the transfer of properties covered under the ordinance to ensure their new acquisitions are in full compliance. P Jack Waldeck is a partner and chair of the real estate practice group of Cleveland-based Walter | Haverfield, LLP.

reliable & local CALL OUR COMMERCIAL SALES MANAGERS TODAY, TO DISCUSS YOUR ELECTRIC SERVICE NEEDS

Wes Tarver: 216.664.3922 ext.145 Kim Smith: 216.664.3922 ext. 253 VISIT US AT WWW.CPP.ORG

You Already Take Enough Risks. You work with industry experts to reduce risks to you and your employees. Shouldn’t the same be true for your accounting firm?

With over 95 years of experience in the construction industry, we understand the business cycles, the special income tax issues, the reporting and bonding requirements, and the unique risks and opportunities contractors face each day. Accounting Expertise x Business Planning x

Tax Planning

Succession Planning x Profit Enhancement x Bid Reviews Cost Control x Litigation Support Services x Job-Cost Auditing

To reach our Cleveland Office, call 216.241.3272 or visit www.meadenmoore.com

AKRON | BEACHWOOD | CLEVELAND | WOOSTER www.propertiesmag.com 57


PAVING WITH PRIDE FOR 30+ YEARS Since 1982, we’ve been building our reputation job by job

LET’S MAKE YOUR JOB OUR NEXT STOP >L ^V\SK HWWYLJPH[L HU VWWVY[\UP[` [V Z\ITP[ V\Y YLJVTTLUKH[PVUZ HUK LZ[PTH[LZ MVY `V\Y!

5L^ 7HYRPUN 3V[ *VUZ[Y\J[PVU

.YHKPUN ,_JH]H[PVU

:P[L +L]LSVWTLU[

(ZWOHS[ 9LZ\YMHJPUN

*H[JO )HZPUZ +YHPU[PSL

:[VYT :L^LY >VYR

(ZWOHS[ 9LWHPYZ

*YHJR -PSSPUN :LHSJVH[PUN

4PSSPUN

Specialists from site development to chuckhole patching!

We're doing it better for less every day

Call us today at 216.421.1203 2417 Woodhill Rd., Cleveland, OH 44104 • Fax 216.421.1278

^^^ UVY[OJVHZ[WH]PUN JVT


/HJDO 6HUYLFHV VANTAGE POINT Experts weigh in on industry issues

The Reward of Patience In Workout Situations lmost three years ago, a client came to me facing a difficult situation. He owned a building in Northeast Ohio, which was 50% vacant and his loan was coming due. He owed approximately $2.5 million on the property and, at the time, it was doubtful that the property would have appraised for more than $2 million. My client was also personally liable for the full amount of the loan.

A

I asked the lender for an extension on an interest-only basis at the same interest rate as my client was currently paying under the Note. This was all my client could afford in light of the 50% vacancy. I pointed out to the lender that if it elected to foreclose on the property, it would presumably appoint a receiver to which it would have to pay a receiver’s fee, the receiver would probably hire a manager to which he would have to pay a management fee (my client was taking no management fee), and if the prop-

ROBERT A. FUERST

erty went through foreclosure it would not get enough to pay off its loan. Due to financial reversals during the economic downturn, my client’s net worth would not have been sufficient to pay the deficiency. Although this argument made a lot of sense, in my experience, particularly three years ago, most lenders, faced with government regulators who often forced them to make bad decisions, would have barged ahead, had a receiver appointed, foreclosed on the property, and ended up writing

Offers a full range of legal services to businesses and individuals, providing clients with practical solutions

UÊ ÕÃ iÃÃÊEÊ À« À>Ìi

UÊ ÃÌ>ÌiÊ* > }ÊEÊ*À L>Ìi UÊ iÀ}iÀÃÊEÊ VµÕ Ã Ì Ã

UÊ ÕÃ iÃÃÊ-ÕVViÃÃ

UÊ > Vi

UÊ"VVÕ«>Ì > Ê->viÌÞÊEÊ i> Ì

UÊ Û ÊEÊ iÀV > Ê Ì }>Ì

UÊ À> V ÃiÊ >Ü

UÊ,i> Ê ÃÌ>Ìi

UÊ ÃÌÀÕVÌ

UÊ Õ > Ê,ià ÕÀViÃ

UÊ-ÕÀiÌÞÊEÊ ÃÕÀ> Vi

UÊ Ài` Ì ÀýÊ, } ÌÃÊEÊ > ÀÕ«ÌVÞ UÊ Ìi iVÌÕ> Ê*À «iÀÌÞ UÊ Û ÀViÊEÊ > ÞÊ >Ü

UÊ >L ÀÊEÊ « Þ i Ì

UÊ iÀ}ÞÊ >Ü

UÊ i` >Ì

UÊ/>Ý UÊ7 À iÀÃ½Ê «i Ã>Ì

28601 Chagrin Blvd., Suite 500 Cleveland, OH 44122 Phone: 216.831.0042 Fax: 216.831.0542 www.meyersroman.com attys@meyersroman.com

www.propertiesmag.com 59


The Road to Cleanliness Starts Here Ê ",Ê Ê "Ê "-/Ê* , Ê , Ê -- --

UÊ-Üii« } UÊ*ÀiÃÃÕÀiÊ7>Ã } UÊ-VÀÕLL } UÊ*>Ûi i ÌÊ,i«> ÀÃ UÊ-ÌÀ « } UÊ-> Ì }

/

UÊ- ÜÊ* Ü } UÊ ÃÌÀÕVÌ Ê- Ìià UÊ*>À }Ê Ìà UÊ*>À }Ê iV à UÊ7>Ài ÕÃià UÊ-«iV > Ê Ûi ÌÃ

- ViÊ£ ä

330-798-9200

ÜÜܰLÕV iÞiÃÜii« }°V

Space Comfort co. )$0,/< 2:1(' 23(5$7(' :,7+ +$1'6 21 (;3(5,(1&( ,1 0(&+$1,&$/ &2175$&7,1* 6$/(6 6(59,&( 6,1&( ([SHUWV LQ Q 7XUQNH\ VROXWLRQV GHVLJQ EXLOG YDOXH HQJLQHHULQJ Q 6HUYLFH LQVWDOODWLRQ PDLQWHQDQFH RI DOO PDNHV PRGHOV RI +9$& HTXLSPHQW ERLOHUV Q 1HZ UHQRYDWLRQ UHPRGHOLQJ UHVWRUDWLRQ Q 3XEOLF SULYDWH 3URYLGLQJ UHOLDEOH SHUVRQDO VHUYLFH WR RZQHUV RI UHWDLO FHQWHUV PDOOV DSDUWPHQW FRPSOH[HV UHWLUHPHQW KRXVLQJ LQ 2KLR QHLJKERULQJ VWDWHV

5201 CLARK AVENUE, CLEVELAND OHIO 44102 Q PH. 216-281-2000 Q FAX. 216-281-8420 Q 800-203-9645 60

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


/HJDO 6HUYLFHV off a substantial portion of the loan. Fortunately, this lender decided to listen, although it was only willing to extend the loan for six months at a time. As early as one year ago, the property was still 50% vacant and the best offer that my client had received for the property was $1.5 million. But our luck was about to change. The broker who I suggested to lease the property found a national credit tenant to take the remaining 50% of the building. After briefly attempting to refinance the property, I suggested that my client list the property for sale with a different broker who had contacts with out-of-state buyers – buyers who typically will pay more. Within

As early as one year ago, the property was still 50% vacant and the best offer that my client had received for the property was $1.5 million. But our luck was about to change. two months, we had the property under contract for $3,650,000, and the sale closed last month. As a result, my client, who as recently as a year ago could have lost the property and still owed somewhere between $500,000 and $1 million, ended up paying the lender off in full, and, after paying some other obligations relating to the property, walked away with close to $500,000. Obviously, this was a great result for my client, but it also was a great result for the lender, which was rewarded for its patience. As Benjamin Franklin said, “He that can have patience can have what he will.” P

Robert Fuerst is an attorney with Meyers, Roman, Friedberg & Lewis who focuses his practice on real estate transaction work. For more information, call 216-831-0042 or visit http://meyersroman.com.

Law Issues in Construction Identifying critical phases of construction worth legal scrutiny By J. Norman Stark

he legal issues in construction begin even before the demolition of existing structures to accommodate new ones. The improvements to real property are interrelated with the traditionally recognized laws of contracts, torts and real property.

T

Even before one spade of earth may be turned and before any work commences on real property, several legal milestones must be carefully addressed by Counsel, experienced in construction. Thereafter, each critical phase should be regularly monitored to minimize or, hopefully, preclude damage or delay claims and increased project costs. Several phases are worthy of careful scrutiny:

Constructive Changes, Contract Termination, Defective and Deficient Construction Documents, Schedule Delay, Differing Site Conditions, Directed Changes, Implied Warranty, Impossibility of Performance, Maladministration, Owner Furnished Items, Strikes, Superior Knowledge, Weather, Work Suspension, Payments, Final Payments, Guarantees, Warranties, Equipment Testing, Startup, Beneficial Occupancy, Claims, Liens, Damages.

Before construction commences: Letters of Intent, Feasibility/ Business Plan, Title, Zoning, Financing, Commitment, Survey, Preliminary Designs, Cost Estimates, Construction Documents, Building Permits.

Bidding, award, commencement of construction: Construction Contract Terms, Invitations to Bid, Qualified Bidders, Award, Approval of Subcontractors, Initial Project Meeting, Project Schedule, Project Management, Safety.

During construction: Commencement of Construction, Acceleration, Cardinal Changes,

Post-construction: Liquidated Damages, Loss of Income, Unresolved Claims, Product Liability, Repairs, Replacements, Remodeling, Arbitration, Mediation, Litigation, Fees, Costs, Settlements. The proverbial “ounce of prevention” is highly recommended as opposed to the alternatives. P J. Norman Stark is an attorney, architect emeritus (OH) AIA, N.C.A.R.B. and author of The Construction Claims Investigation Worklist. Contact J. Norman Stark at 1109 Carnegie Ave., Cleveland, Ohio 44115; 216-531-5310 x7100; email normstark@aol.com. www.propertiesmag.com 61


LEGAL PERSPECTIVES Navigating property laws & regulations

Joint Ventures – Teamwork Done Right ven though our Presidential candidates cannot seem to get along, teamwork and cooperation are keys to success in the construction industry. Whether looking for growth opportunities or fighting to survive in a competitive market, sometimes going it alone is not the answer.

E IAN FRANK

The scope, complexity and dollar value of projects continues to increase in Ohio, due in no small part to Construction Reform passed by the legislature a few years ago, as well as nationally. This trend presents challenges to many industry stakeholders because it can stretch them beyond their comfort zone with respect to bonding, financing, technical expertise or geography. Teaming and joint venture relationships present a means to overcome these challenges, by allowing multiple entities that could not pursue a new project individually to pool their resources and relationships, spread risk and attain it collectively. But while

5HVXOW 2ULHQWHG DQG 5HOLDEOH /HJDO $VVLVWDQFH IRU WKH &RQVWUXFWLRQ ,QGXVWU\ &ODLPV 0DQDJHPHQW DQG $YRLGDQFH &RPSHWLWLYH %LGGLQJ 6FKHGXOH 'LVSXWHV 'HIHFWLYH :RUN DQG 'HVLJQ &ODLPV 3URMHFW 'HOLYHU\ DQG &RQFHSWXDOL]DWLRQ 0HFKDQLFªV /LHQV 6XUHW\ %RQG &ODLPV /DERU DQG (PSOR\PHQW $UELWUDWLRQ DQG 0HGLDWLRQ /LWLJDWLRQ

collaborative relationships like these are an opportunity to adapt to an everchanging marketplace, a recent Ohio appellate court decision in October, Schlaegel v. Howell, 2015-Ohio-4296 (2d Dist. 2015), demonstrates that they can also be a source of significant dispute and risk if not handled properly. A joint venture (JV) is simply a “contractual association which the parties intend to carry out a common business purpose.” Nilivar v. Osborn, 127 Ohio App. 3d 1, 20 (2d Dist. 1998). JV agreements may be oral, but that is certainly not recommended, as the parties in the Schlaegel case will no doubt attest. Joint ventures must be for

OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED.

3XEOLF 6TXDUH 6WH &OHYHODQG 2KLR 3KRQH )D[ ZZZ IUDQW]ZDUG FRP 62

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


/HJDO 6HUYLFHV a limited purpose rather than a continuing business, include contributions from each venturer to the common enterprise, and comprise an agreement to share profits and losses. Teaming agreements, on the other hand, are often precursors to a joint venture, whereby the parties allocate and define their respective roles (e.g., estimating, scheduling, preliminary design, planning, etc.) in pursuing a prospective opportunity. Teaming is also used for “vertical” relationships between parties that seek to pursue a project, most notably in the federal contracting arena. Joint venturers owe each other a fiduciary duty. Such duties of trust require heightened obligations, and thus increased risk, so these agreements should not be pursued without careful thought, preparation and guidance. The dispute in Schlaegel arose out of a failed arrangement between Schlaegel and Howell to build and lease a research facility. Apparently, the parties had agreed to purchase the property together, build the facility and lease it to Pioneer Hi-Bred International. This arrangement, unfortunately, was not reduced to writing in either a teaming or joint venture agreement. Howell was to act as the general contractor, and submitted a proposal for the construction of the facility. Schlaegel assisted by submitting prices for the site work, but Howell did not use these prices in its proposal. Howell formed an entity that held the option for the purchase of the property, and also executed a lease with Pioneer. Only then did Howell and Schlaegel begin to negotiate an operating agreement for this

new entity. The negotiations failed when the parties could not agree on the allocation of responsibilities for the construction work and other terms. As a result, the option expired and the lease was terminated. Howell then pursued the project alone, causing Schlaegel to sue for breaching their alleged joint venture agreement. Though the court in Schlaegel acknowledged that JV agreements need not be in writing, it denied all of Schlaegel’s claims. The court concluded that the so-called agreement required further actions to be formalized, and therefore was nothing more than an indefinite and unenforceable “agreement to agree.” Schlaegel’s fate might have been much different with some additional forethought and documentation at the beginning of the relationship. First, the parties could have executed a teaming agreement allocating responsibility for pricing the work, involvement in assembling the proposal, and specifying which party would perform select scopes of work if the proposal was accepted. Also, it would have been advisable to negotiate the terms of the joint venture or operating agreement in advance, and have a firm written commitment to execute it if the proposal was successful. Finally, if the parties anticipated that additional conditions might exist after the proposal was accepted, or further actions were required, those actions/conditions should have been enumerated, along with clearly defined, objective criteria regarding how they would be satisfied through good faith, best efforts or similar standards.

Teaming and joint venture relationships present a means to overcome these challenges, by allowing multiple entities that could not pursue a new project individually to pool their resources and relationships, spread risk and attain it collectively.

Structuring JV Ventures Though one size does not fit all, every joint venture (JV) agreement should address a few basic structural areas:

OPERATIONAL ISSUES • Scope of the work or services, and division of responsibility – either joint or apportioned • Subcontracting, billing, reimbursement by JV partners • Resource allocation – administrative, labor, equipment, etc. • Overhead reimbursement – percentage of direct costs, lump sum or defined methodology to calculate

JV MANAGEMENT • Managing venturer – cost accounting, financial reporting, tax, books and records • Executive committee – JV member appointment, overall JV management authority, and definitive voting process • Project management – select project management team, define their duties and authority level

RISK ALLOCATION • Indemnity • Insurance • Financing • Bonding

DEFAULTS AND REMEDIES • Default – define consequences such as lockout of operational or management decisions, alteration of profit rights, dissolution, or allowing direct competition where default occurs before owner award • Dispute resolution – mediation, arbitration and litigation Pursuing a teaming or joint venture relationship involves an inherent level of risk. These arrangements require mutual trust and deliberate planning in order to manage this risk efficiently. P

Ian H. Frank is a partner in Frantz Ward LLP’s Construction Law Group in Cleveland, Ohio, where he dedicates his practice to representing contractors, subcontractors, suppliers, construction managers, developers, design professionals, and sureties. www.propertiesmag.com 63


ARE THERE TAX DEDUCTIONS HIDING IN YOUR BUILDING?

J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc. • Commercial Buildings

Many building owners have millions of dollars in income tax deductions they don’t know about.

• Construction Sites

If you own commercial or industrial property and need more tax deductions, let our Cost Segregation professionals furnish you with an estimate. It won’t cost you anything to find out!

• Concrete Cleaning

• Special Event Clean-Up • Carpet Cleaning • Window Cleaning • Wall Washing • Acoustical Ceilings

Call Dennis Duffy or Craig Miller: Cleveland 440.892.3339 / Columbus 614.949.4185 Detroit 248.752.7433 or visit our website www.costsegexperts.com

THE REGION’S LEADING INCOME TAX REDUCTION EXPERTS

Stewardship

Professional

Integrity

1230 East Schaaf Road Brooklyn Heights, OH 44131

216-749-1150 www.jvjanitorial.com

Consistency

Visionary

Brian-Kyles has distinguished itself as a dependable partner for professional landscape management services for nearly three decades. Centered on building trust and adding value, the Brian-Kyles signature approach is sought by the following types of commercial clients:

Retail Commercial Office Industrial Public Multi-Family Residential Discover our signature approach at www.briankyles.com | Call us today at 855.926.0303 64

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


/HJDO 6HUYLFHV Safekeeping Through Shredding Protecting vital data through information destruction By Allison Marimpietri Northcoast Shredding Services & Record Center

dentity theft, data breaches and privacy law provisions make up our daily news. According to the FTC, identity theft is the fastest growing crime in the U.S. and U.K. Your personal information is most vulnerable when it is discarded. It is accessible through the traditional means of dumpster diving, or through more advanced electronic fraud schemes. Now, more than ever, data protection laws are being enforced and often have fines attached to a data breach.

I

The most prevalent privacy law is the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). HIPAA’s Privacy, Security, and Breach Notification Rules now apply to covered entities, those who collect protected health information (PHI), and their business associates, or one who “creates, receives, maintains, or transmits” PHI while performing services on behalf of the covered entity. Even an employer is technically considered a covered entity as they obtain their employee’s PHI. The Office of Civil Rights is required to impose civil penalties for those data breaches that are the result of willful neglect. These penalties are tiered depending on the extremity and can be detrimental to a company. A violation where the covered entity/business associate did not know, and would not have known, of the violation by exercising reasonable diligence results in fines ranging from $100 to $50,000 per violation. This is just the least severe form. It is important to keep in mind that a single action, such as the loss of a computer hard drive, may result in multiple violations as hard drives contain numerous files. At the same time, the OCR may reduce or waive penalties for those who did not demonstrate willful neglect, and those who correct the violation may not receive a penalty. It is essential to address any violation promptly and also put the proper safeguards in place to prevent future violations. In order to safeguard confidential information, there are essential steps organizations should take. The most

READY TO SHRED Many companies give employees discretions on what should be shredded versus recycled. This is a risky move. All documents, even a simple sticky note, should be shredded.

important factor to remember is that a security breach can happen to anyone at any time, no matter how big or small the company. In fact, it is believed that smaller companies are more susceptible to a data breach, and they are easier to be “hacked” as they often do not have the proper security procedures in place.

1. Create an information destruction policy State and Federal regulations require that all organizations have written policies and procedures for handling confidential information. They should detail all facets of protecting and disposing of confidential information. Without these policies, you are not only jeopardizing the security of the company, its clients and employees, you may be found negligent should

a data breach occur. This policy should include those responsible for developing, implementing and overseeing the policies and procedures, employee training, destruction methods for each type of media, what should be destroyed before disposal, service provider qualifications, data breach notification, auditing process and employee acknowledgement. Helpful hint: Many companies give employees discretions on what should be shredded versus recycled. This is a risky move. We advise that all documents, even a simple sticky note, be shredded.

2. Ongoing employee training Employee training should be included in an information destruction policy, but the training should also recur on a regular basis. Training should not www.propertiesmag.com 65


1( 2KLR·V (OHFWULFDO 6HUYLFH 0DLQWHQDQFH 6ROXWLRQV 6SHFLDOLVWV

&/(9(/$1'

6LQFH 7URXEOH 6KRRWLQJ ([SHUWV 6XUJH 3URWHFWRUV /LJKWLQJ 5HWURILWV &RQVXOWDWLRQV /,9( 'LVSDWFKHU 2Q &DOO

$.521

,Q +RXVH IW %XFNHW 7UXFN (PHUJHQF\ +RXU 5HVSRQVH 9 /DQGVFDSH² 9 6\VWHPV 758( 52, /LJKWLQJ $QDO\VLV

ZZZ $&(OHFWULF2+,2 FRP

>ŝĐĞŶƐĞ EŽ͘ >ͲϮϰϭϲϭ

'21·7 /(7 <285 %86,1(66 *2 287 :,7+ 7+( 75$6+

NORTHCOAST Shredding & Record Center 0,66,21 72 3529,'( 6(59,&( 7+$7 (;&(('6 285 &86720(5¶6 (;3(&7$7,216

7+( &267 ,6 /(66 :+(1 <28 86( 7+( %(67 1$,' $$$ &HUWL¿HG

5HFRUG 6WRUDJH

,Q +RXVH 6KUHGGLQJ

+RVWLQJ :LWK $FFHVV

2Q 6LWH 6KUHGGLQJ

6FDQ 2Q 'HPDQG

0RQWKO\ 6HUYLFH 3URJUDPV +DUG 'ULYH 'HVWUXFWLRQ

&RPSOLDQFH :LWK $OO ,QGXVWU\ /DZV DQG 5HJXODWLRQV

6KUHGGHU 6DOHV

DQG 0XFK 0RUH

,PDJLQJ 6FDQQLQJ 6HUYLFHV WR WKH 0HGLD RI <RXU &KRLFH

&DOO &KHW *UHHQ DW

ZZZ QRUWKFRDVWUHF\FOLQJ FRP 66

only address destruction of confidential media, but also confidential information through electronic means such as e-mail, cloud storage, etc. Employees should also sign an acknowledgement recognizing their participation and understating of the training.

3. Select a qualified secure destruction vendor With the increased attention to data protection laws and fines, many organizations are outsourcing their secure destruction needs. Having a regular, recurring service eliminates the misconceptions that may arise from sporadic shredding. When selecting a secure destruction vendor, do not be afraid to ask questions: What insurances do you carry? What do you do with the destroyed media? What is your shred size? Oddly enough, there currently is no data protection law that specifies particle size before destruction, so it is important to check for your own comfort level. The National Association for Information Destruction (NAID) is the secure destruction industry’s trade organization. NAID offers their members accreditation through the NAID AAA Certification program. This certification is awarded to companies that meet or exceed rigorous security standards and document handling procedures, and it is compliant with all privacy laws. The NAID AAA Certification does the work for the consumer by auditing the vendor’s qualifications. By selecting a NAID AAA Certified company, the OCR and other regulating authorities may recognize this vendor selection as performing one’s due diligence. All in all, it is vital for any organization to demonstrate their due diligence by following the steps outlined above. It is simply foolish to believe that your organization is not susceptible to these threats. P Allison Marimpietri, CSDS is vice president of operations with Northcoast Shredding Services & Record Center. For more information, visit www.northcoastrecycling.com. 3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


/HJDO 6HUYLFHV Does Your Ohio Real Estate Tax Bill Need a Little Spring Cleaning? If you plan to challenge your tax bill, the deadline is March 31, 2016 By Anthony R. Vacanti, Esq. Buckingham, Doolittle & Burroughs LLC

pring is right around the corner. It is a time for owners of Ohio real estate to spruce up and perform maintenance on their assets. Just like spring cleaning and maintenance of physical real estate can result in long term cost savings by avoiding costly repairs/improvements and attracting quality users, periodic spring cleaning of Ohio real estate tax values can result in often large tax savings for years to come.

S

The number of commercial property sales in 2015 significantly increased over previous years. These acquisitions can have an impact on real property tax values. Have you recently checked your Ohio retail, commercial, industrial or residential real property valuation on your tax bill to see if it is accurate? Unfortunately, property valuations conducted by the various counties can be inconsistent and inaccurate. But there is good news: there are tools you can use to decrease your real estate tax valuation, and in return, your tax bill. Understanding the tools at your disposal may help in determining if you should challenge the value attributed to your real estate. However, you have to take steps to protect your right to challenge your real estate valuation by March 31, 2016. The procedure by which real estate is valued for tax purposes is set forth in Ohio Revised Code Chapter 5713. Real estate is taxed at 35% of its true value, which is referred to as the assessed value for property. The county auditor is charged with adjusting the assessed value of each parcel within a county every three years. There are two different valuations that occur: “Reappraisal Year” and “Update Year.” The Reappraisal Year occurs every six years, and during the Reappraisal Year, each parcel is viewed and evaluated based on market conditions. The Update Year occurs three years after the Appraisal Year, and involves re-valuing real estate without physical inspection. This is often done using computer-assisted modeling of value changes by neighborhood and type of real estate within the county. The

Anthony R. Vacanti, Esp.

value of real estate is based on its condition on January 1st of each year. The county auditor’s valuation of real estate may be challenged. Pursuant to Section 2, Article XII of the Ohio Constitution, real property is to be taxed “according to value.” Ohio Revised Code Section 5713.03 also requires that each separate tract of real estate be valued according to its “true value.” Section 5713.03 states, in relevant part, that “[t]he county auditor, from the best sources of

information available, shall determine, as nearly as practicable, the true value of each separate tract, lot, or parcel of real property and of buildings, structures, and improvements located thereon.” This begs the question: How is “true value” of real estate determined? True value is equivalent to fair market value, which is an actual recent sale of such property between one who is willing to sell but not compelled to do so and one who is willing to buy but not compelled to do so. (In Re Estate of Sears, 172 Ohio St. 443, paragraph 2 of syllabus [1961]). This is known as a recent arm’s length transaction. When this information is not available, or when a sale is not conducted at arm’s length, appraisal evidence becomes necessary. In sum, when Ohio real estate is the subject of a recent arm’s length transaction between a willing seller and willing buyer, the sale price of the real estate is the best evidence of the value for taxation purposes. The determination of how “recent” a real estate transaction has to be is determined on a case-by-case basis.

www.propertiesmag.com 67


Partner with us... Complete Glass Experts Family-Owned & Operated for 60 years! Specializing in: • Commercial Glass and Glazing • Aluminum Doors & Storefronts • Custom Sandblasted “Etched” Glass with Clearshield

...it’s time we help you grow.

• Bullet Resistant Glass & Polycarbonate

Real Estate & Construction Practice Group

• Custom Frameless Shower Doors, Mirrors & Glass Table Tops

John P. Slagter • Nicholas T. George • John Swansinger • Tara J. Rose Michael J. Matasich • David L. Drechsler • Matthew R. Duncan David J. Lindner • David W. Woodburn • Anthony R. Vacanti

Free Commercial Estimates 24 Hour-Board-Up Service phone 216-621-1971 | fax 216-621-6602 www.sandgloglass.com 2316 St. Clair Avenue | Cleveland, Ohio 44114

68

Buckingham, Doolittle & Burroughs LLC A Northeast Ohio Business Law Firm Akron • Canton • Cleveland bdblaw.com

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


/HJDO 6HUYLFHV Only the value of real estate, not the value of personal property, is considered when determining real estate value. A sale might not be considered evidence of true value if it was not arm’s length – for example sales involving bankruptcy, foreclosure or sales involving a seller under duress. When real estate is not subject to a recent sale or such sale was not conducted at arm’s length, then an appraisal or other evidence may be necessary to challenge the county’s real property value applied to the subject property. Given the inconsistencies in the county valuations, it is a good idea to periodically engage in a spring cleaning and maintenance of your Ohio real estate tax values for your retail, commercial, industrial and/or residential real estate. If you disagree with the assessed value of your Ohio real estate, the primary tool you have at your disposal is to file a tax valuation complaint with your local county board of revision. A complaint must be filed with the board of revision by March 31, 2016. This is an absolute deadline. The county provides a form with instructions referred to as Form DTE 1, Complaint Against the Valuation of Real Property. While the complaint form appears to be straightforward, it is important that the complaint is accurately and thoroughly completed, as there are many pitfalls and that could result in

dismissal of the complaint. Additionally, although the instructions accompanying the complaint indicate that certain non-attorneys may prepare the complaint and file it on behalf of a company, it is important to note that the Ohio Supreme Court has questioned the constitutionality of that provision, and has determined that in many circumstances having a non-attorney prepare the complaint may constitute the unauthorized practice of law, especially if the matter involves legal

If you disagree with the assessed value of your Ohio real estate, the primary tool you have at your disposal is to file a tax valuation complaint with your local county board of revision. issues and would involve the questioning of witnesses, such as appraisers. (See, e.g., Dayton Supply & Tool Company, Inc. v. Montgomery County Board of Revision [2006], 111 Ohio St.3d 926, 927). Consequently, it is advisable to consult an attorney when filing a complaint. If you are thinking of utilizing an appraisal, you are not required to submit an appraisal with the complaint. An appraisal may be submitted after the complaint is filed. After the complaint is filed,

in many cases the local school board of education may file a counter-complaint seeking to keep the higher tax value. Then, the board of revision will schedule a hearing where it will take evidence of the recent arm’s length transaction or appraisal, and it will render a decision. The parties have the opportunity to appeal the board of revision’s decision either to the local court of common pleas or to the Ohio Board of Tax Appeals. By periodically making a review and update of your Ohio real estate tax valuation part of your spring cleaning, you will be well on your way to getting the most out of your investment by mitigating against the risk of overpaying on your real estate tax liabilities. It is important to consult with an attorney knowledgeable in property tax valuation challenges for an assessment of the possibility for a reduction in value and tax liabilities and the procedure to do so. So take the opportunity this spring to clean up your tax bill! P The material appearing in this article is meant to provide general information only and not as a substitute for legal advice. Readers should seek the advice of their attorney or contact Anthony R. Vacanti at avacanti@bdblaw.com or 800.686.2825. This article may not be reprinted without the express permission of Buckingham, Doolittle & Burroughs, LLC © 2016.

͖͕͚Ǥ͕͗͜Ǥ͕͕͛͛ Ǧ Ǥ

͔͘ Ǥ Ǥ

www.propertiesmag.com 69


When your fair share of taxes is neither fair... nor your share

Fostering Fairness for All Taxpayers The attorneys at Siegel Jennings bring experience as accountants, appraisers and real estate developers to the practice of law. Our property tax services include: Ŷ Representation at the administrative level through the State Supreme Court Ŷ Local expertise in every state through the American Property Tax Counsel Ŷ Tax management – acquisition/disposition strategies Ŷ Cutting edge approaches to property tax reductions

Siegel Jennings Call J. Kieran Jennings, Esq at 216.763.1004 23425 Commerce Park Drive, Suite 103, Beachwood OH 44122

www.siegeltax.com

Cleveland Ŷ Pittsburgh Ŷ Columbus 70

Founding member, American Property Tax Counsel (APTC) • www.aptc.com 3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


/HJDO 6HUYLFHV Everything but the Kitchen Sink... Should your property tax assessment include that? By Cecilia J. Hyun Siegel Jennings Co., LPA

case study: Imagine you are a young entrepreneur who has been hearing great things about the resurgence of downtown Cleveland – the Cavaliers are winning, the Republican National Convention is coming to town, and more professionals are making downtown their home.

A

Feeling optimistic about the Cleveland real estate market, you decide to buy some investment property in an up and coming neighborhood. You settle on a mixed-use building close to the local universities. The first floor of the building is retail space. It is occupied by a trendy new food spot. There are two apartments on the second floor, one occupied by a student and one occupied by a doctor who just started working at the Cleveland Clinic. The food spot has recently won awards and acclaim, garnering national foodie attention, so you decide to purchase the restaurant as well. After hammering out the details, your purchase ends up including the land and building and the restaurant business, which includes all of the equipment (freezers, walk-in cooler, stoves, ordering and reservation software, etc), and all the trademarks and goodwill associated with the restaurant. You agree to buy the building and the business for a total purchase price of $1,000,000. Half of the price is consideration for the real estate and the remaining $500,000 is for all of the personal property and business value associated with the restaurant. Your purchase agreement lists the various pieces of equipment and goodwill but there is no allocation of the total price; and, when the title transfers, the price recorded is the total asset purchase price of $1,000,000. As part of your due diligence prior to closing, you looked at the property taxes, and the county had assessed the property for tax purposes at $500,000. However, after the school board sees the recorded transfer price of $1,000,000 in the public record, its attorneys file a

cation of the purchase price in any of the sale documents, and because the total price was recorded at $1,000,000, they raise your tax assessment to $1,000,000. You are now paying real estate taxes on double the value, for items that are not real estate.

Now what?

Cecilia J. Hyun

complaint asking your property value be increased to $1,000,000. At the hearing on the complaint, you explain that the $1,000,000 price included what you paid for the restaurant business and all of its non-real estate components, like the kitchen equipment and the ongoing business operations. The reviewing board acknowledges that those other items were included in the purchase and that they did not constitute real estate. But because there is no allo-

Sales with similar circumstances occur all the time: these sales may include tangible personal property like restaurant or manufacturing equipment, they may include above-market leases, they may include the value of the business operated on the property. All of these sales include items that are not real estate whose value should not be included in your real property tax assessment. When the value of these non-realty items is captured in your tax assessment, it results in unfair assessments and non-uniform taxation. Maybe the property owner across the street to the young entrepreneur above has an identical property but that owner was less savvy and bought a building that is not leased to a popular restaurant business

SPECIALIZING IN EXTERIOR MASONRY REPAIR & RENOVATION SINCE 1972 • COMPLETE INSPECTION/ASSESSMENT OF FAÇADE CONDITIONS • TUCKPOINTING/CAULKING

• BRICK & STONE REPAIR/REPLACEMENT

• SEALING/WATERPROOFING

• CLEANING/PRESSURE WASHING

Ph 216.881.4142 | Fx 216.881.6557 | 4408 St. Clair Ave., Cleveland, OH 44103 www.propertiesmag.com 71


and is sitting empty. If your properties are otherwise equal, she should not pay less in real estate taxes.

A change in the law In response to these problems of non-uniform and unfair taxation, the Ohio legislature amended the law not too long ago to require that these non-

real estate items are not included in your property tax assessment. For tax purposes, your property value should only include the value of the real estate (land, building, improvements) – that is, the market value of the fee simple estate, as if encumbered. Two recently decided Ohio Supreme Court cases involving a Steak ‘n Shake

Sustainable practices. Superior results. Only from Schill.

and Rite Aid store reinforce the concept that these other non-real estate items should be separated out from your property tax valuation. In reviewing data used by the appraisers in those cases, the Ohio Supreme Court said that the effect of these other items, such as costs of development, business value, and tenants with higher credit ratings, must be removed from sale prices so that only the value of the real estate remains. Although the Steak n’ Shake and Rite Aid cases involved properties that were not encumbered by leases, the Ohio Supreme Court’s analysis reinforces that these other non-real estate items have an effect on sale prices. Sales must be investigated for such items and their value removed when determining value for property tax purposes. This is the only way to ensure that similar property owners and taxpayers are treated equally and fairly.

Practical tips for the future The next time the young entrepreneur or investor decides to buy real estate, here are some steps to help remove those non-real estate items from the property tax assessment:

5HWDLO _ &RPPHUFLDO _ ,QGXVWULDO _ &RQGRPLQLXPV +2$V _ $SDUWPHQWV _ +RVSLWDOV _ $VVLVWHG /LYLQJ *URXQGV 0DLQWHQDQFH /DQGVFDSLQJ 6QRZ ,FH 5HPRYDO 6HUYLFHV 6XVWDLQDEOH /DQGVFDSLQJ 5H 'HVLJQ 3ODQQLQJ &XVWRP *URXQGV 0DLQWHQDQFH 3ODQV WR 5HGXFH &RVWV 2YHU 7LPH ,PSURYHPHQW RI &XUE $SSHDO 5HGXFH /LDELOLW\ ZLWK 6DIH (QYLURQPHQWDO 6ROXWLRQV )LQG RXW KRZ 6FKLOO FDQ KHOS \RX FUHDWH KHDOWK\ JUHHQ VSDFHV IRU OLYLQJ ZRUNLQJ RU VKRSSLQJ &DOO XV IRU D TXRWH WRGD\

<RXU EHVW VRXUFH IRU ODQGVFDSLQJ VQRZ UHPRYDO LFH PDQDJHPHQW VHUYLFHV LV 6FKLOO *URXQGV 0DQDJHPHQW 0LOOV ,QGXVWULDO 3DUNZD\ 1RUWK 5LGJHYLOOH 2+ VFKLOOJURXQGVPDQDJHPHQW FRP 72

• Make an allocation of the total purchase in the purchase documents identifying the real estate and nonreal estate items. • Make sure that the consideration recorded on your conveyance fee statement is the price paid for real estate only. • Do not assume that your tax assessment will stay the same after purchase. Depending on the price, you may be facing an increased tax liability, or in some cases, potential savings on your property taxes. P Cecilia J. Hyun is an attorney with the law firm of Siegel Jennings Co., LPA and president-elect of CREW Cleveland. Siegel Jennings is the Ohio and Western Pennsylvania member of the American Property Tax Counsel (APTC), the national affiliation of property tax attorneys. Hyun can be reached at chyun@siegeltax.com or 216-763-1004. 3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


/HJDO 6HUYLFHV Beware When Filing Tax Complaints: The School District is Watching By Kip Danzinger Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill Co., L.P.A.

eal property taxes, referred to as ad valorem taxes in Ohio, are levied against the property according to fair market value; the more valuable the property, the higher the tax, and vice versa. The underlying theory (but certainly not only factual) of ad valorem taxation is that those owning the more valuable property are wealthier and able to pay more tax.

R

As a concern to property owners, these taxes generally have a significant downward effect on an owner’s investment return or business profits. Of equal concern, these taxes historically have been the single largest source of income for Ohio local governmental programs and services, such as fire and police departments, local welfare programs, public libraries, parks, hospitals and, most importantly, the local school districts in which the property is situated. Due to the importance of the role property taxes play on school funding, Ohio law mandates that the school district in which a property is located is notified of the filing of a tax complaint. Specifically, counties receiving a tax complaint requesting a value reduction of $50,000 or more are required by Ohio law to notify the school district. Once notified of the property owner’s complaint, the school district has the opportunity to file its own counter complaint. In other words, the school district becomes the taxpayer’s adversary at the local board of revision and subsequently during the appellate process, if applicable. Critically, the school district – which is now involved in a tax assessment dispute initiated by the property owner – can hire its own appraiser, subpoena documents on appeal, depose witnesses and seek to increase the value of the very same property that the taxpayer initially sought to decrease. Moreover, once involved, the school district may attempt to have the taxpayer’s complaint dismissed based upon various jurisdictional grounds, primarily based upon the complaint not being prepared or filed correctly. Importantly,

even if the taxpayer decides to dismiss its complaint after it is filed, the school district has legal basis to proceed with its counter complaint. Since the real estate market crash in 2008, school districts across Ohio have seen their tax base erode in large

The deadline to file a tax complaint in Ohio for both property owners and school districts is March 31. The following Northeast Ohio counties have either reappraised or updated their values for tax year 2015 (payable 2016): Cuyahoga, Lake, Lorain and Stark. Certainly, a property owner must continue to review property assessments in these and all other Ohio counties to insure the property is being taxed fairly and in accordance with Ohio law. But prior to filing any complaint, the taxpayer must pay close and special attention to the possible downside. Beware when filing your tax complaint: The school district is watching. P

The school district – which is now involved in a tax assessment dispute initiated by the property owner – can hire its own appraiser, subpoena documents on appeal, depose witnesses and seek to increase the value of the very same property that the taxpayer initially sought to decrease. part due to the record number of tax complaints filed by property owners. In speaking to many school district attorneys across the state, the school districts intend to be aggressive in recouping these losses of tax revenues by aggressively defending new complaints filed by taxpayers or by initiating their own original complaints.

Robert (Kip) Danzinger, JD is a partner of Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill Co., L.P.A., a law firm with a concentrated practice in assisting real property owners in contesting assessments. Danzinger can be reached by phone 216.771.8990 or by email at rdanzinger@sdglegal.net. www.propertiesmag.com 73


CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT Updated info on important projects in the region

Project Report #: 01331 SOUTHWICK MANOR APARTMENTS LOCATION: 4326 Southwick Blvd. Brunswick, OH (Medina County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Residential CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STATUS: Recently Opened EST. VALUE: $7,000,000 OWNER: JV between Miller Valentine Group and Medina Metropolitan Miller Valentine Group 9349 Water Stone Blvd. Cincinnati, OH 45249 Phone: 513-774-8400 Medina Metropolitan Housing 850 Walter Rd. Medina, OH 44256 Phone: 330-725-7531 ARCHITECT: TC Architects Contact: Robert Chordar 755 White Pond Dr. Akron, OH 44320 Phone: 330-867-1093 GC: Owner subcontracts DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 4 stories. 54 units of senior living. Project features include laundry on each floor - w/d hookups in each unit - lounge on each floor - meeting room computer room - exercise room - theater. Project Report #: 01488 CLEVELAND MUSEUM OF NATURAL HISTORY PARKING GARAGE LOCATION: Off East Blvd. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction

CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Plans in Progress - Project To Proceed in Phases OWNER: Cleveland Museum of Natural History 1 Wade Oval Dr. Cleveland, OH 44106 Phone: 216-231-4600 www.cmnh.org ARCHITECT: Kaczmar Architects, Inc. 1468 W. 9th St., Ste. 400 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-687-1555 www.kaczarch.com CONSTRUCTION MANAGER: Thomarios Construction 1122 Jacoby Rd. Copley, OH 44321 Phone: 330-670-9900 www.thomarios .com DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg. 300-car new parking facility - part of multi-phased renovation and redevelopment. Project Report #: 01489 THE FOUNDRY LOCATION: The Flats- 1772-1800 1831-1853 Columbus Rd. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: Renovation/Addition CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Schematics CompleteConstruction Start Indefinite EST. VALUE: $9,000,000 OWNER: The Foundry c/o MCPc Charities Contact: Mike Trebilcok & Andy Jones

1801 Superior Ave., Ste. 300 Cleveland, OH 44114 Phone: 800-777-7178 www.teammcpc.com ARCHITECT: Kaczmar Architects 1468 W. 9th St., Ste. 400 Cleveland, OH 44113 CONSTRUCTION MANAGER: The Krill Co. Inc. 1275 Main Ave. Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-357-4777 www.krill.com DESCRIPTION: Converting group of buildings into year-round training center for rowers and indoor rowing - tank, fitness center, boathouse and banquet center. 400 feet of river front docks. Project Report #: 01487 LORAIN COUNTY HEALTH & DENTISTRY CENTER LOCATION: Main St. Oberlin, OH (Lorain County) www.lorainhealth-dentistry.org PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Work 85-90% Complete - Set for Completion Within 60 days. OWNER: Lorain County Health & Dentistry Contact: Stephanie Wiersma 1205 Broadway Ave. Lorain, OH 44052 Phone: 440-233-0159 ARCHITECT: Kaczmar Architects, Inc. Contact: Christine Raymond 1468 W. 9th St., Ste. 400 Cleveland, OH 44113

Where does your business fit? Call Properties now at 216.251.0035 today to book your ad in these upcoming Special Sections. APRIL

MAY

ROOFING/BUILDING ENVELOPE PLUMBING & HVAC SYSTEMS An overall report on managing With summer coming, we explore how engineering exterior systems, from new roofing, window & & service are key in keeping buildings comfortable. wall products to the design & implementation of FLOORING & WALL COVERING maintenance programs. Spotlighting the functional & aesthetic impact of interior surfaces. AD CLOSE: Friday, March 25, 2016

AD CLOSE: Monday, April 25, 2016

JUNE ENVIRONMENTAL SOLUTIONS From site assessments & decontamination services to wetlands & brownfields legal issues, we’ll ask the experts for advice & answers. AD CLOSE: Wednesday, May 25, 2016

For info on advertising & editorial opportunities, call 216.251.0035 or email kkrych@propertiesmag.com. 74

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


Phone: 216-687-1555 www.kaczarch.com CONSTRUCTION MANAGER: The Krill Co. Inc. Contact: Scott Zanick 1275 Main Ave. Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-357-4777 www.krill.com DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 1 story, 7,000 sf. Health clinic - waiting area - eye clinic - behavioral health, dentistry and dental laboratory. Project Report #: 01485 CHAGRIN HIGHLANDS DEVELOPMENT MIXED-USE LOCATION: South of Harvard & East of 271 Orange, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Commercial PROJECT STATUS: Project Proposed - Project to Proceed in Phases - Construction Indefinite OWNER: Richard E. Jacobs Group Contact: Jim Eppele 25425 Center Ridge Rd. Westlake, OH 44145 Phone: 440-871-4800 www.rejacobsgroup.com ARCHITECT: To Be Announced DESCRIPTION: 78 acres. Documents submitted for a 170-room hotel & 20,000 sf for two restaurants at the outset - 250,000 sf of offices in Phase 2 200,000 sf of offices in a later phase of construction. Project Report #: 01423 ABOVE THE BARRE DANCE & GYMNASTIC STUDIO PHASE 2-3 LOCATION: 1087 Berea Industrial Parkway Berea, OH (Cuyahoga County) www.abovethebarre.com PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Phase One Complete/Open Construction Set to Start on Phase 2 In April or May Pending Financing - Start of Phase 3 Not Set OWNER: Above the Barre 1087 Berea Industrial Parkway Berea, OH 44017 Phone: 440-625-0000 www.abovethebarre.com ARCHITECT: Christopher @ Architects LLC Contact: Christopher Toddy 820 W. Superior Ave., Ste. 140 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 440-239-9560 DESIGN/BUILDER: American International Construction Contact: Mike Petresek 1180 Berea Industrial Parkway Berea, OH 44017 Phone: 440-243-5535 www.aiconstruction.com

9PZL :OPUL *SL]LSHUK

Complete Construction Cleaning

Window Cleaning

Div. of KOZLOVICH ENTERPRISES

@6<»33 *3,(93@ :,, ;/, +0--,9,5*, PRESSURE WASHING ALSO AVAILABLE

*HSS ;VKH`

S I

&216758&7,21 0$1$*(0(17 *(1(5$/ &2175$&7,1* '(6,*1 %8,/'

www.propertiesmag.com 75


DESCRIPTION: 5 acres, 2 bldgs, 2 stories, 36,000 sf. Multiple phases - Phase 1 - 14,000 sf gymnastics training center complete/ open - Phase 2 - 8,000 sf dance academy - 6 dance rooms - pro shop - offices with mezzanine. Phase 3 - 14,000 sf expansion of gymnastics area with specialized Cirque Du Soleil training center. ͙​͙͔​͔ ǡ ǡ ͘​͕͕͗͘ Ǧ ͖͕͚Ǥ͚͖͘Ǥ͚͔͔͘ ͖͕͚Ǥ͚͖͘Ǥ͚͔͕͘

Ƭ Ƭ Ȁ Ǧ Ƭ

Ǥ Ǧ Ǥ

͖͘Ȁ͛Ȁ͚͙͗

HOW BAD IS THAT LEAK?

Keep your assets safe by taking the time to ensure that problems at the top of your building are not damaging your bottom line.

Carey Roofing Corp. has eliminated asset damage due to a leaking roof with practical solutions since 1946. 216 • 881 • 1999 CAREY www.careyroofing.com

Roofing Corp. 76

founded in 1946

MEMBER: National Roofing Contractors Association

Project Report #: 01260 ONE UNIVERSITY CIRCLE-APARTMENTS LOCATION: 10730 Euclid Ave. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Residential CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Preliminary Plans in ProgressPossible 2nd Quarter 2016 Start with Potential October 2017 Phased Completion EST. VALUE: $115,000,000 OWNER: First Interstate Properties Contact: Mitchell Schneider 25333 Cedar Rd. Lyndhurst, OH 44124 Phone: 216-381-2900 ARCHITECT: Dimit Architects LLC Contact: Scott Dimit 14414 Detroit Ave., Ste. 306 Lakewood, OH 44107 Phone: 216-221-9021 www.dimitarchitects.com BUILDER: Panzica Construction DELIVERY METHOD: Construction Management / Design Assist Contact: Mark Panzica 739 Beta Dr. Cleveland, OH 44143 Phone: 440-442-4300 www.panzica.com DESCRIPTION: 1.3 acres, 1 bldg, 20 stories, 530,033 sf. 280 units ranging in size from 7204,200 sf penthouse - fitness center with private training rooms - indoor - outdoor pool facility - common area green rooftop for community gathering - outdoor kitchen - entertainment gaming room - lounges - business center - café bistro - four-story parking garage - 16-story residences - 12 penthouses. Project Report #: 01464 AURORA SCHOOL OF MUSIC ADDITION LOCATION: S. Chilicothe Rd. Aurora, OH (Portage County) www.auroraschoolofmusic.com PROJECT TYPE: Addition CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Project Complete and Opened OWNER: Aurora School of Music Contact: Vera Holczer 211 S. Chillicothe Rd. Aurora, OH 44202 Phone: 330-954-0211 3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


DESIGN/BUILDER: GLSD/Geis Companies Contact: Jen Dotson & Brian Jarzenski 10020 Aurora-Hudson Rd. Streetsboro, OH 44241-1621 Phone: 330-528-3500 www.geisco.net DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 1 story, 4,000 sf. Additional classrooms - two-level concert hall to accommodate more than 800 students and guests. Project Report #: 01460 CHOICE ONE DIALYSIS CENTER LOCATION: W. 25th St. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT STATUS: Preliminary Plans in Progress - Construction Indefinite Pending Approvals OWNER: Choice One Medical Group LLC 511 NE 3rd Ave. Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301 ARCHITECT: Herman Gibans Fodor 1939 W. 25th St. Cleveland, OH 44113

181 W. Madison Ave. Chicago, IL 60602 Phone: 312-558-3882 OWNER’S REPRESENTATIVE: The Krill Company 1275 Main Ave. Cleveland, OH Phone: 216-357-4777 ARCHITECT: Kaczmar Architects Inc. Contact: Stan Kaczmar 1468 W. 9th St., Ste. 400 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-687-1555 CONSTRUCTION MANAGER: The Walsh Group Contact: Patrick Kenny 929 W. Adams St.

Chicago, IL 60607 Phone: 312-563-5400 DESCRIPTION: 1.8 acres, 1 bldg, 9 stories, 165,370 sf. 276 room hotel - valet parking area off of Euclid Ave. Information included in Construction Progress Report has been produced, processed and/or verified through sources believed to be reliable. Properties Magazine makes no warranty of any kind for this information, express or implied, and is not responsible for any omissions or inaccuracies. To contribute project data or to notify Properties of any reporting errors, we encourage you to email cpr@propertiesmag.com.

Project Report #: 01374 OATEY COMPANY CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS LOCATION: 20636 Emerald Parkway Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Work Underway 30% Complete - Possible Completion September 2016 EST. VALUE: Not released OWNER: The Oatey Company Contact: John McMillan, CEO 4700 W. 160th St. Cleveland, OH 44135 Phone: (216) 267-7100 ARCHITECT: Vocon 3142 Prospect Ave. Cleveland, OH 44115 Phone: 216-588-0800 CM AT RISK: Donley’s Inc. Contact: Nate Heitner 5430 Warner Rd. Cleveland, OH 44125 Phone: 216-524-6800 www.donleyinc.com Description: 7.6 acres, 1 bldg, 2 stories, 43,500 sf. Office space - meeting rooms - lab space. Project Report #: 01319 CLEVELAND CLINIC HOLIDAY INN SELECT HOTEL LOCATION: Euclid Ave. & E. 86th St. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Work Underway - Completion Set For June 2016 EST. VALUE: $40,000,000 OWNER: M.B. Real Estate Contact: John T. Murphy www.propertiesmag.com 77


&RPLQJ LQ $SULO 7KH 6FKRILHOG %XLOGLQJ 5HVLGHQFHV +RWHO

AC Electric & General Contracting, LTD...... 66

Interstate Gas Supply, Inc.................................. 28

AIA Cleveland.......................................................... 52

J Norman Stark, LPA............................................. 60

Albert M. Company, The.....................................21

J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc..................................64

American International Construction ..........12

Jamieson Ricca Fenestration ............................18

American Security & Audio Visual ................ 48

John G. Johnson Construction Co. ............... 37

ARC Document Solutions ................................. 29

Kel-Lume Group .................................................... 32

Berea Moving, Co. ..................................................11

Kurtz Bros.................................................................. 43

Blue Book Building & Construction

Lean Projects Group .............................................18

Network, The .........................................................2

Leff Electric............................................................... 37

BOMA Greater Cleveland .................................. 47

Lisco Heating & Cooling, Inc. ........................... 56

Brennan & Associates.......................................... 77

Maguire Photographics ..................................... 68

Brian-Kyles Construction, Inc. .........................64

Mason Structural Steel, Inc............................... 48

Bricklayers Local 5....................................................6

Masonry Restoration Maintenance .................7

Brouse McDowell .................................................. 52

Mechanical Contractors Association ........... 40

Bruder Building Materials, Inc. ........................ 43

Meaden & Moore, Ltd ......................................... 57

Buckeye Sweeping, Inc....................................... 60

Messina Floor Covering, Inc. ............................ 23

Buckingham Doolittle & Burroughs............. 68

Meyers, Roman, Friedberg & Lewis .............. 59

Building Enclosure Council............................... 56

Midwest Restoration Group ............................ 45

Carey Roofing ..........................................................76

Miller Goler Faeges, LLP..................................... 79

Chagrin Valley Paving ......................................... 38

Nelson Contracting .............................................. 23

Chagrin Valley Steel Erectors............................19

North Coast Paving .............................................. 58

Charles Schulz Building Company................ 67

Northcoast Inc. Recycling Specialists .......... 66

Charles Svec Inc. .................................................... 56

Olsavsky Jaminet Architects, Inc. ..................44

Ciuni & Panichi Advisors LLC ........................... 69

Paladin Protective Systems, Inc...................... 30

Cleveland Engineering Society ...................... 48

PCS Container Sales ............................................. 36

Cleveland Plumbing Industry ......................... 40

Pease Photography .............................................. 24

Cleveland Public Power ..................................... 57

Perfect Power Wash..............................................31

Columbia Building Products ........................... 32

Pete & Pete Container Service ........................ 42

County Fire Protection Inc.................................12

Precision Environmental Co..............................76

Courtad Construction Systems. Inc.............. 43

Precision Laser & Instrument, Inc. ................. 33

Crystal Clear Building Services, Inc............... 52

S & S Interiors, LLC ................................................46

Cunningham Paving Inc. ....................................21

S.A. Comunale Company ............................17, 51

WXUH DUWLFOHV DGYHUWLVLQJ UDWHV

Diamond Roofing Systems..................................3

Sandglo Glass & Mirror Co. ............................... 68

Duffy & Duffy Cost Segregation Services .64

Schill Grounds Management .......................... 72

WLRQ

EA Group ......................................................................9

Siegel Jennings ..................................................... 70

EM Construction Co./Beacon Marshall Companies ............................................................15

Sixmo Architects Engineers, Inc. ................... 49

First Federal Of Lakewood...................................7

Sleggs Danzinger & Gill.........................................4

Framer’s Gallery ..................................................... 24

Snow Brothers Appliance, Inc. .........................13

Frantz Ward LLP ..................................................... 62

Space Comfort Co................................................. 60

Geis Construction ................................................. 47

Suntrol Co. ................................................................ 26

GLSD Architects, LLC/Geis Companies....... 48

Superior Energy Systems .................................. 23

H & M Snow Pros & Landscaping, Inc. .........10

Timbers-Kovar ........................................................ 40

Health & Fitness Equipment Centers............41

Triplet 3rd.................................................................. 30

HMH Restoration Ltd........................................... 71

Valentine Contractors, Inc. ............................... 24

Icon Interiors...............................................................8

Walter & Haverfield LLP ..................................... 54

IMAGINiT Technologies...................................... 32

Warren Roofing & Insulating Co. ................... 54

Infinity Construction ........................................... 75

Window Cleaning Specialists .......................... 75

Integrated Project Solutions............................ 39

Zinner & Company ............................................... 34

&OHYHODQG &OLQLF $YRQ 5HKDELOLWDWLRQ +RVSLWDO $N]R 1REHO 2IILFHV /DE 1$,23 $ZDUGV RI ([FHOOHQFH 5RRILQJ DQG %XLOGLQJ (QYHORSH 6SHFLDO 6HFWLRQ DQG PRUH ,QWHUHVWHG LQ DGYHUWLVLQJ" &DOO 3URSHUWLHV WRGD\ DQG DQ DFFRXQW UHSUHVHQWDWLYH FDQ KHOS \RX ZZZ SURSHUWLHVPDJ FRP 9LVLW XV RQOLQH IRU DUFKLYHG IHD DGGUHVV \RXU DGYHUWLVLQJ QHHGV

VSHFV DQG VXEVFULSWLRQ LQIRUPD

ZZZ SURSHUWLHVPDJ FRP

9LVLW XV RQOLQH WRGD\ WR GRZQORDG DUFKLYHG LVVXHV IHDWXULQJ OLYH K\SHUWH[W OLQNV WR DGYHUWLVHUV· ZHEVLWHV 78

ADVERTISER INDEX

Skoda Minotti Company.................................... 80

3URSHUWLHV | March 2016


6WUDWHJLF &RXQVHO (IIHFWLYH $GYRFDF\

70

0,//(5 *2/(5 )$(*(6 /$3,1( //3 0,//(5 *2/(5 )$(*(6 //3 LV UHFRJQL]HG DV RQH RI &OHYHODQG¶V SUHPLHU EXVLQHVV ERXWLTXH ODZ ¿UPV VHUYLQJ FRPSDQLHV IURP 2KLR DQG DURXQG WKH ZRUOG 2XU SUDFWLFH LQFOXGHV UHDO HVWDWH EDQNLQJ ¿QDQFH EXVLQHVV OLWLJDWLRQ DUELWUDWLRQ FRUSRUDWH VHFXULWLHV LQWHUQDWLRQDO FRPSXWHU HPSOR\PHQW IUDQFKLVH FUHGLWRU¶V ULJKWV KHDOWK FDUH DQG LQWHOOHFWXDO SURSHUW\ ULJKWV

( WK 6W 6XLWH &OHYHODQG 2KLR 3 _ ) _ ZZZ 0LOOHU*ROHU)DHJHV FRP


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Northeast Ohio Properties, March 2016 by REjournals - Issuu