INSIDE : Mandel Humanities Center • Lee - Van Aken Rapid Station • Environmental Solutions
June 2016/$7.95
Top-Class Hospitality R Renovated d Cl Cleveland l dB Boardd of Education Building reopens as new Drury Plaza Hotel
Try it Free for a Month www.skysite.com
Ƥ ◆ ◆ ◆ Roof Asset Management
www.DiamondRoofSystems.com CORPORATE OFFICE
AKRON/CLEVELAND BRANCH
8031 E. Market St. Suite #6 Warren, Ohio 44484 330-856-2500
6726 Tallmadge Rd. Rootstown, Ohio 44272 330-850-5360
Service@DiamondRoofSystems.com
ting Celebreaars 70 Y 1946
June 2016, Volume LXX, Number 6
Since
FEATURES phone: 216.251.0035 toll free: 888.641.4241 fax: 216.251.0064 www.propertiesmag.com CLEVELAND 3826 W. 158th St. Cleveland, Ohio 44111 AKRON P.O. Box 9 Munroe Falls, Ohio 44262
MANAGING EDITOR/ART DIRECTOR Mark Watt mwatt@propertiesmag.com 216.251.2655 CONTRIBUTING WRITERS Doug Bardwell, Jeanne Bluffstone, Dennis Castiglione, Ian Frank, Lou Kren, Matt Lehnert, Alec Pacella, Diane DiPiero Rodio, John Slagter, David Woodburn ACCOUNT EXECUTIVES Matt Lehnert mlehnert@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6753
Photo by Kevin Reeves
OWNER/PUBLISHER Kenneth C. Krych kkrych@propertiesmag.com 216.251.0035
11
NAIOP Awards of Excellence recognizes best in local commercial real estate community
14 New Construction Starts in April Slide 8% Nationally 19 Top-Class Hospitality Renovated Cleveland Board of Education Building reopens as new Drury Plaza Hotel
31 Building Connections New Lee-Van Aken RTA Station brings style to Shaker Heights transportation hub
51 Idea Building Tri-C embraces leadership development with new Mandel Humanities Center
59 Environmental Solutions
Larry Overbey loverbey@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6649
59 Due Diligence Aquatic Resource Evaluations: Do surface water features on a property bring value? Or just headaches? 61 Applying ‘Lean’ to Building Performance: Utilizing proven principles to achieve facility energy savings, waste reduction 63 Acknowledging Environmental Action: Cleveland 2030 District’s annual challenge recognizes energy use reduction efforts 65 Here Comes Sunshine: Considerations when allowing tenants to install PV systems on your properties 67 Project Profile: Cullen Park – Green infrastructure as ecological, economic resources 70 ABCs of EE Retrofits: Managing applications, installation & customer expectations on retrofit projects
OFFICE MANAGER Lisa Larissey 216.251.8506 Cover photo: Drury Plaza Hotel Cleveland Downtown, by Lauren Pacini / Artography
Properties (ISSN 033-1287) is published monthly for architects, engineers, building owners and managers, general contractors, home builders, mortgage bankers, savings and loans, real estate agents, appraisers, servicers and suppliers in Northern Ohio by Properties, Inc., 3826 W. 158th St., Cleveland, Ohio 44111. Copyright © 2016 by Properties, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction or use, without written permission, of editorial or pictorial content is strictly prohibited. Periodicals postage paid in Cleveland, Ohio and additional offices. Subscription rates: one year $24.95, single copy $7.95, back issues $10 when available. Postmaster: send change of address notices to Properties, P.O. Box 112127, Cleveland, Ohio 44111.
Honoring Excellence
DEPARTMENTS 8 17 36 38 40 42 45 74
PROPERTIES PEOPLE BOMA BUSINESS FINANCIAL STRATEGIES ACAR CORNER NAIOP NEWS LEGAL PERSPECTIVES BILLBOARD CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT www.propertiesmag.com 5
PUBLISHER’S NOTE June 2016
Evolving Environment elcome to our June 2016 issue! Every year, we devote our June issue to “Environmental Solutions,” which is an ever-ongoing process involving our surroundings, where we live, play and work.
W KEN KRYCH
This year, we take a look into topics involving law issues, lighting, wetlands, energy conservation and local efforts to move closer to carbon zero. We appreciate the input from contributing firms, including Brouse McDowell LPA, Leff Electric, HzW Environmental Consultants, The Mannik & Smith Group, Lean Project Group, Cleveland 2030 District and the NEO USGBC Cleveland Chapter. Drury Plaza Hotel Cleveland Downtown Our cover story this month centers on the restoration and conversion of the
former Cleveland Board of Education Building on East 6th Street into the latest new Drury Plaza Hotel. The historic restoration of this 85-year-old, stately building into an exquisite and unique hotel was quite an effort and we endeavor to give you insights on how Drury Southwest and project partners accomplished their challenging goal. GCRTA Lee-Van Aken Rapid Station We then transport you to the site of the reconstruction of the Lee-Van Aken Rapid Transit Station, which is one of many projects in the master plan of the
The Leader in Loading Dock Systems Since 1957
TRUSTED • EXPERIENCED • RELIABLE Timbers-Kovar Company is a recognized leader in the sale & service of high quality loading dock & industrial door safety products. With our own fully equipped, factory-trained service department, we have the capability to service & install all manufacturers of loading dock equipment & will contract Planned Maintenance Programs annually.
Industrial Doors Ergonomic Lifts Overhead Doors Big Industrial Fans Loading Dock Seals Rolling Steel Doors
7653 St. Clair Ave., Mentor, OH 44060 800-222-DOCK • 440-951-1210 • www.timberskovar.com 6
Truck Restraints Properties | June 2016
Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Authority (GCRTA) to improve and develop aging structures and stations. One of the busiest on the Blue Line, the station was completed this past winter after much thought and input in the design by Bialosky Cleveland and HWH Architects, Engineers, Planners, Inc., along with in-house GCRTA staff. The project was challenging as it required keeping the busy line running during the construction period on a very tight site with traffic lanes on three sides. The Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Humanities Center at Tri-C Located at Cuyahoga Community College East in Highland Heights, this recently transformed, unique learning space is built for leadership. Handpicked student scholars will be using it to bring forth ideas as they strive to become our local leaders of tomorrow. The new center incorporates a modern, colorful and thoughtful design by Richard Fleischman + Partners and is furnished with the latest cutting edge equipment to generate and mold ideas, while promoting collaboration. Coming in July Next month, we will shine a light on the talented designers and craftsmen who provide the beautiful and effective interiors of our surroundings. From floors to ceilings, we will focus on diverse skilled trades and bring you some of the best examples of their art and skill in the region. Also, we are happy to be documenting the latest addition to Cleveland’s skyline with an extensive tour of the Hilton Cleveland Downtown. We will also be taking a look at the newly created Hattie Larlham Akron Food Hub, as well as The Hotel at Oberlin, a unique project targeting LEED Platinum certification. Until then, enjoy the beautiful, early days of summer! Positively,
Kenneth C. Krych Owner/Publisher
reliable & local CALL OUR COMMERCIAL SALES MANAGERS TODAY, TO DISCUSS YOUR ELECTRIC SERVICE NEEDS
Wes Tarver: 216.664.3922 ext.145 Kim Smith: 216.664.3922 ext. 253 VISIT US AT WWW.CPP.ORG
Sustainable practices. Superior results. Only from Schill.
5HWDLO _ &RPPHUFLDO _ ,QGXVWULDO _ &RQGRPLQLXPV +2$V _ $SDUWPHQWV _ +RVSLWDOV _ $VVLVWHG /LYLQJ *URXQGV 0DLQWHQDQFH /DQGVFDSLQJ 6QRZ ,FH 5HPRYDO 6HUYLFHV 6XVWDLQDEOH /DQGVFDSLQJ 5H 'HVLJQ 3ODQQLQJ &XVWRP *URXQGV 0DLQWHQDQFH 3ODQV WR 5HGXFH &RVWV 2YHU 7LPH ,PSURYHPHQW RI &XUE $SSHDO 5HGXFH /LDELOLW\ ZLWK 6DIH (QYLURQPHQWDO 6ROXWLRQV )LQG RXW KRZ 6FKLOO FDQ KHOS \RX FUHDWH KHDOWK\ JUHHQ VSDFHV IRU OLYLQJ ZRUNLQJ RU VKRSSLQJ &DOO XV IRU D TXRWH WRGD\
<RXU EHVW VRXUFH IRU ODQGVFDSLQJ VQRZ UHPRYDO LFH PDQDJHPHQW VHUYLFHV LV 6FKLOO *URXQGV 0DQDJHPHQW 0LOOV ,QGXVWULDO 3DUNZD\ 1RUWK 5LGJHYLOOH 2+ VFKLOOJURXQGVPDQDJHPHQW FRP www.propertiesmag.com 7
PROPERTIES PEOPLE Highlighting notable industry events
1
2
3
4
1
5
6
7
1 Rob Telecky (University Hospitals)
2
3
ACE Mentor Program Dinner 2 Cassandra Johnson (University Hospitals) and Recently, over 400 attendees gathered at Windows on the River in Cleveland for the 2016 ACE Mentor Program Dinner. The program provides junior and senior high school students guidance in the fields of architecture, construction and engineering. Students presented conceptual plans for the beautification of the Cultural Gardens Centennial Greenway and a new visitor center on E. 99th St. More than over $113,000 in college scholarships were awarded as well. P
Kenneth Hale (Cuyahoga Community College) 3 Courtney Behm and John Coughlin (Gilbane Building Co.) 4 Glen Shumate (CEA/Construction Employers Association), Tom Laird (Gilbane Building Co.), Don Dreier (Donley’s Inc.), Tim Linville (CEA) and Sylvia Perez (Cleveland Foundation) 5 Joanne Brown (Case Western Reserve), Chris Ronayne (University Circle) and India Pierce Lee (Cleveland Foundation) 6 Don Dreier (Donley’s Inc.), Tim Linville (CEA) and Sylvia Perez (Cleveland Foundation) 7 Tom Laird (Donley’s Inc), Diana Eidenshink (ACE National) and Eric Gordon (Cleveland Metropolitan School District)
1
2
5
NAIOP Annual Awards First Look: Drury Plaza Hotel of Excellence
Ulmer & Berne hosted an exclusive first look at the redevelopment of the Drury Plaza Hotel. Joined by executives from Drury, Ulmer & Berne attorneys shared information on the historic tax credits and alternative state of Ohio loan and grant programs that helped transform the former Board of Education Building into a modern hotel. (See full story, pg. 19.) P 8
Recently, the Northern Ohio chapter of NAIOP held its annual Awards of Excellence at Windows on the River in Cleveland. Over 300 individuals attended the event, which recognizes top projects, transactions, and individual performance within the commercial real estate industry. (See full story on pg. 11) P
6
3
4
7
8
1 Terry Noonan and Charles Marshall (Beacon Marshall), and Kimberly Marshall (City of Medina) 2 Jim Doyle Sr. (Bellwether Enterprises), Mike Dostal (First Merit Bank) and Bill Valerian (Liberty Bank) 3 Kyle Davis and Randy Hoover (Fabo Architecture), and John Solich (The Middlefield Banking Company) 4 Bill Eberhard (William Eberhard AIA) and Jim Streff (HSB Architects), and Tara Mercio (GLSD Architects) 5 Donna Haders (NAIOP), Mark Panzica, Maureen Crotty, Mike Smith and Bill O’Hare (Panzica Construction) 6 Bryan Falk (Vorys) and Eliot Kijewski (Cushman & Wakefield/CRESCO Real Estate) 7 Jack Waldeck and Josh Hurtuk (Walter Haverfield LLP) 8 Megan Huebner, Chuck Kostrab and Jeff DeFranco (Turner Construction)
Properties | June 2016
Photos courtesy of Tom McInerney / Poses A Studio
4 1 Amy Whitacre (First America Title Insurance Company), Amanda Seewald (Forest City Realty Trust, Inc.), Kim Campbell (Title Source, Inc.) and Katie Grendell. 2 Ryan Shasserre, Danielle Poyner, Krisandra Lippert, Justin Davidson and Dennis Vollink (Drury Southwest, Inc.) 3 Henry Bailey, Jodi Rich, Michael Tangry, Brett Altier and Bill Gagliano (Ulmer & Berne LLP) 4 Karen Lauber (K & D), Mary Stempihar (K & D) and Matthew Rodusky (PNC Bank)
OUR BUSINESS WILL MAKE YOUR BUSINESS SHINE!
Perfection. It’s more than a word. It’s what business owners and property managers strive for each and every day. Perfect Power Wash is the company that can keep the exterior surfaces of your commercial business or multi-unit properties clean and maintained.
BUILDINGS l CONCRETE l ROOFS l CONDOS & APARTMENTS Call or click today for an instant quote:
216.255.6771 l PerfectPowerWash.com
When your fair share of taxes is neither fair... nor your share
Fostering Fairness for All Taxpayers The attorneys at Siegel Jennings bring experience as accountants, appraisers and real estate developers to the practice of law. Our property tax services include: Ŷ Representation at the administrative level through the State Supreme Court Ŷ Local expertise in every state through the American Property Tax Counsel Ŷ Tax management – acquisition/disposition strategies Ŷ Cutting edge approaches to property tax reductions
Siegel Jennings Call J. Kieran Jennings, Esq at 216.763.1004 23425 Commerce Park Drive, Suite 103, Beachwood OH 44122
www.siegeltax.com
Cleveland Ŷ Pittsburgh Ŷ Columbus Founding member, American Property Tax Counsel (APTC) • www.aptc.com
Honoring Excellence NAIOP Awards of Excellence recognizes best in local commercial real estate community AIOP Northern Ohio Chapter presented its annual Awards of Excellence on Wednesday, May 11, at Windows on the River in Cleveland. The annual program recognizes the best projects, real estate transactions and individual performance during the previous year in the commercial real estate industry in Northern Ohio. Over 300 of the area’s top commercial real estate professionals attended the program, which is dedicated to recognizing design, development and marketing successes in industrial, office, retail, mixed-use and multi-family developments completed in 2015. A cocktail reception followed to recognize the nominees and winners, and for networking among industry representatives. Featured emcees for the program included Fred Margulies, of Herschman Architects, and Rob Weeks, of R-Weeks Consulting. Erin Ryan, of SME, served as the event chair and Vince Adamus, of Greater Cleveland Partnership, acted as vice chair. Celebrated winners included:
Photos courtesy of NAIOP Northern Ohio
N
Third District Police Station (City Architecture / Richard L. Bowen + Associates / Panzica Construction)
MULTI-FAMILY CONSTRUCTION
Honors Academic Village at the University of Toledo 2125 Campus Rd., Toledo MAROUS BROTHERS CONSTRUCTION
OFFICE CONSTRUCTION
Third District Police Station 4501 Chester Ave., Cleveland PANZICA CONSTRUCTION The Creswell (The Dalad Group & Slyman Group) PIRHL (RDL Architects, Inc.)
MULTI-FAMILY DEVELOPMENT OFFICE INTERIOR DESIGN
The Creswell
PIRHL
1220 Huron Rd., Cleveland THE DALAD GROUP & SLYMAN GROUP
800 W. St. Clair Ave., Cleveland RDL ARCHITECTS, INC.
MULTI-FAMILY ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN RETAIL INTERIOR DESIGN
Govberg Jewelers
Progressive Field (Gilbane Building Company)
34105 Chagrin Blvd., Moreland Hills HERSCHMAN ARCHITECTS
RETAIL CONSTRUCTION
INDUSTRIAL CONSTRUCTION
Blair Rubber Company 5020 Panther Pkwy., Seville BEACON MARSHALL
Cleveland Indians Progressive Field, Right Field Renovation 2401 Ontario St., Cleveland GILBANE BUILDING COMPANY
INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT
Mariner’s Watch 3107 Detroit Ave., Cleveland DIMIT ARCHITECTS
OFFICE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN
Third District Police Station 4501 Chester Ave., Cleveland CITY ARCHITECTURE / RICHARD L. BOWEN + ASSOCIATES
Arhaus Corporate HQ and Distribution Center
RETAIL ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN
The Residences at the East End 1201 E. Market St., Akron WELTY BUILDING COMPANY
55 E. Hines Hill Rd., Boston Heights PREMIER DEVELOPMENT PARTNERS
300 W. 119th St., Leawood, KS RDL ARCHITECTS, INC.
MIXED-USE CONSTRUCTION
Arhaus Furniture-Leawood
www.propertiesmag.com 11
INDUSTRIAL TRANSACTION
MIXED-USE TRANSACTION
Tarkett Houston Manufacturing Disposition
The Foundry/MCPc Family Charities
Lord Corporation HQ
1831 Columbus Rd., Cleveland ADAM GIMBEL (ALLEGRO REALTY ADVISORS) AND LARRY HUNT (CRM)
2455 Robison Rd. E., Summit Township, PA WEBER MURPHY FOX
1705 Oliver St., Houston, TX ADAM WOLINTZ & GEORGE HUTCHINSON (ALLEGRO REALTY ADVISORS)
INDUSTRIAL RENOVATION
MULTI-FAMILY RENOVATION OFFICE TRANSACTION
The Creswell
INVESTMENT TRANSACTION
Asurint HQ
925 Euclid
1111 Superior Ave., Cleveland GEORGE HUTCHINSON AND JULIE ISELIN (ALLEGRO REALTY ADVISORS) AND MYRNA PREVITE (KOWIT & COMPANY REAL ESTATE)
1220 Huran Rd., Cleveland SLYMAN GROUP & THE DALAD GROUP
925 Euclid Ave., Cleveland TERRY COYNE (NEWMARK GRUBB KNIGHT FRANK)
OFFICE RENOVATION
Our Lady of Mercy Campus 2425 W. 11th St., Cleveland WEBER MURPHY FOX
RETAIL RENOVATION
Arhaus Furniture-Kierland 7030 E. Greenway Pkwy, Ste. 150, Scottsdale, AZ RDL ARCHITECTS, INC.
Does your parking lot look like this? Then it’s time to make a call to:
800.PAVE.NOW The Residences at The East End (IRG / ThenDesign Architecture)
MIXED-USE RENOVATION
The Residences at The East End 201 E. Market St., Akron IRG/THENDESIGN ARCHITECTURE
INDUSTRIAL BROKER
Kristy Hull • Asphalt Paving • Pavement Milling
Newmark Grubb Knight Frank
• Pavement Marking
OFFICE BROKER
• Hot Mix Production Facility
Cushman & Wakefield/CRESCO Real Estate
• Concrete and Excavating Services
DEVELOPER OF THE YEAR
Rico Pietro
Premier Development Partners MEMBER OF THE YEAR
Rob Weeks R-Weeks Consulting Quality and Excellence in Asphalt Paving Since 1939
INDUSTRY RECOGNITION
Joe Cimperman Cleveland City Council
www.RonyakPaving.com
LIFETIME ACHIEVEMENT
Jim Doyle
Hemingway Development P 12
Properties | June 2016
VALUE
Partner with us...
engineering
• Due Diligence • Development & Leasing • Retail, Commercial • Historical/Industrial and Industrial Renovations • Architecture/Engineering • Design/Build
330-659-2040
...it’s time we help you grow. Real Estate & Construction Practice Group John P. Slagter • Nicholas T. George • John Swansinger • Tara J. Rose Michael J. Matasich • David L. Drechsler • Matthew R. Duncan David J. Lindner • David W. Woodburn • Anthony R. Vacanti
Charles Marshall – cmarshall@mccdesignbuild.com
Construction Company a division of
P.O. Box 1092, Bath, OH 44210 • www.beaconmarshall.com
Buckingham, Doolittle & Burroughs LLC A Northeast Ohio Business Law Firm Akron • Canton • Cleveland bdblaw.com
Space Comfort co. )$0,/< 2:1(' 23(5$7(' :,7+ +$1'6 21 (;3(5,(1&( ,1 0(&+$1,&$/ &2175$&7,1* 6$/(6 6(59,&( 6,1&( ([SHUWV LQ Q 7XUQNH\ VROXWLRQV GHVLJQ EXLOG YDOXH HQJLQHHULQJ Q 6HUYLFH LQVWDOODWLRQ PDLQWHQDQFH RI DOO PDNHV PRGHOV RI +9$& HTXLSPHQW ERLOHUV Q 1HZ UHQRYDWLRQ UHPRGHOLQJ UHVWRUDWLRQ Q 3XEOLF SULYDWH 3URYLGLQJ UHOLDEOH SHUVRQDO VHUYLFH WR RZQHUV RI UHWDLO FHQWHUV PDOOV DSDUWPHQW FRPSOH[HV UHWLUHPHQW KRXVLQJ LQ 2KLR QHLJKERULQJ VWDWHV
5201 CLARK AVENUE, CLEVELAND OHIO 44102 Q PH. 216-281-2000 Q FAX. 216-281-8420 Q 800-203-9645 www.propertiesmag.com 13
New Construction Starts in April Slide 8% Nationally he value of new construction starts in April fell 8% from the previous month to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of $608.3 billion, according to Dodge Data & Analytics. Nonresidential building pulled back following its sharp March increase, and residential building also declined due to a slower pace for multifamily housing. Meanwhile, the nonbuilding construction sector showed improvement, with public works strengthening after its lackluster March performance. Through the first four months of 2016, total construction starts on an unadjusted basis were reported at $198.4 billion, down 12% from the same month a year ago.
T
rate). This follows the 26% hike reported for March, which included the start of several large transportation terminal projects plus several large hotel and casino projects. The institutional side of the nonresidential building market fell 24% in April after surging 50% in March, with widespread declines for its individual structure types. Most notable was an 86% plunge for the transportation terminal category, which had been lifted in March by $663 million for work on the rail terminal caverns at Grand Central Terminal in New York, New York and $537 million for the new North Terminal building at Louis Armstrong International Airport in Robert A. Murray New Orleans, Louisiana. By contrast, the largest transportation terminal Dodge Data & Analytics project reported as an April start was a $17 million rail station platform more cautious approach towards commer- replacement in Wantagh, New York. cial real estate loans. Residential building Healthcare facilities in April dropped is still deriving some benefit from this 10% after soaring 57% in March, while year’s low interest rate environment, and the public buildings category retreated increased funding under the new federal 16% after its 48% March rise. Even with transportation act should provide support its decline, the healthcare facilities category in April did see the start of several for the public works sector.” large projects, including a $275 million medical center expansion in Tucson, Nonresidential building Nonresidential building in April Arizona and a $180 million psychiatric dropped 19% to $185.1 billion (annual center in Staten Island, New York. The amusement category settled back 8% in April, after climbing 39% in March STRUCTURAL STEEL FABRICATORS & ERECTORS SINCE 1958 with the push coming from the $284 million casino portion of the Montreign Resort and Casino in Kiamesha Lake, New York. There were still several large amusement projects that were entered as April construction starts, including Contact Mike Smith for a Proposal: two Star Wars-themed park expansions (440) 439-1040 | (800) 686-1223 valued each at $135 million, located at 7500 Northfield Rd. | Walton Hills, OH 44146 Disneyland in Anaheim, California and Walt Disney World in Orlando, Florida. www.masonsteel.com Educational facilities, the largest instiOther Fine Products Available: tutional category, had a relatively small 3% drop in April after climbing 21% in Stone | Pavers | Fireplaces | Windows | Doors
The first four months of 2015 had been lifted by several exceptionally large projects, including three liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminals with a total value of $15.4 billion and three large petrochemical plants with a total value of $11.9 billion, which substantially increased last year’s January-April amounts for the electric utility/gas plant and manufacturing building categories. If the electric utility/ gas plant and manufacturing building categories are excluded, total construction starts during the first four months of 2016 would be down a modest 4% from a year ago. April’s data lowered the Dodge Index to 129 (2000=100), compared to 140 for March. The Dodge Index had registered improved activity during February and March, averaging 141. April’s decline returned the pace of construction starts to what was reported during the July 2015-January 2016 period, when the Dodge Index averaged 129. “The construction start statistics on a month-to-month basis are subject to frequent ups-and-downs, so April’s decline after two months of improved activity was not a surprise,” says Robert A. Murray, chief economist for Dodge Data & Analytics. “The elevated volume for nonresidential building in March was not expected to be sustained in the near
term, yet the strength shown by its institutional segment in March does provide an indication of where growth is likely to come over the course of 2016. The prospects for the commercial segment of nonresidential building, while still positive, have grown more tenuous given signs that banks are beginning to take a
“The construction start statistics on a month-to-month basis are subject to frequent ups-and-downs, so April’s decline after two months of improved activity was not a surprise.”
0DVRQ 6WHHO
14
Properties | June 2016
March. Major educational facilities projects reported as April starts were a $134 million high school in Spring, Texas and a $98 million middle school in Beverly, Massachusetts. The depressed religious building category ran counter to the broad pullback for institutional building, as it climbed 10% in April. The commercial building categories as a group fell 18% in April, following a 5% gain in March. Hotel construction dropped 49% after its 47% March jump, which reflected the $332 million hotel portion of the Montreign Hotel and Casino. The largest hotel project entered as an April start was an $87 million hotel in Washington, D.C. Store construction in April decreased 17%, reversing its 17% March gain. On the plus side, growth was reported in April for warehouses, up 15%; and office buildings, up 8%.
Residential building Residential building, at $269.1 billion (annual rate), slipped 8% in April. The weaker activity was due to a slower pace for multifamily housing, which declined 26% after advancing 14% in March. There were five multifamily projects valued at $100 or more that were entered as April starts, compared to 12 such projects in March. The largest multifamily project in April was a $316 million apartment building in New York, New York, followed by a $300 million residential tower in San Francisco, California; a $231 million apartment complex in Denver Colorado; a $152 million apartment building in Honolulu, Hawaii; and a $100 million apartment building in West Orange, New Jersey. Through the first four months of 2016, the top five multifamily metropolitan markets in terms of the dollar amount of multifamily starts were led by New York, New York, followed by Miami, Florida; Boston, Massachusetts; San Francisco, California; and Los Angeles, California. The New York metropolitan area’s share of the national multifamily dollar amount during this year’s January-April period was 24%, still very high by historical standards although down slightly from the 26% share reported for the full year 2015. Single-family housing in April was unchanged from March, maintaining the essentially flat pattern that’s been present for at least the past nine months. By major region, single-family housing in April showed a 5% increase
DESIGN s INSTALL s MANAGE
U Install to your specs or our design U Complete maintenance services U Quality...Value... Professional
Landscape Development Management s Garden Center
5157 Akron-Cleveland Rd. s www.SuncrestGardens.com s 330.650.4969
Excelsior SSign, Excelsior iggn, a ddivision v s of of EExcelsior xcce s orr M Marking, rk n iss ddedicated eedd cated ed ttoo hhelping elp lpingg Northeast Noort N rtheast Ohio Ohhioo businesses, O busi si esssess, s, Architects Arc r hi hitteect cts and a d Contractors an Co tra Co ract ctors rs withh interior with terr r sign s projects. projj cts cts FFrom ro de ddesign e g ttoo pr es pproduction. rodduct ct Specializing Speci eci l z ng i all in a types typpes ooff AD A ADA DA signage. sig ge. Offering si Offer eri ringg fu ffull u ccolor, or,r ddimensional, or im sii l, eengraved, gr vveddd,, castt and ca cast a d architectural arc rchi rchi h tecctturral signs. sig s Expertise Expperrtis ise in i Corporate Corp Cor rpor rpo orate t and a d Donor Do orr Do Recogn Re Recognition cog itt ddisplays co isspl yyss andd aawards. w rd rds
Contact Amandas@excelsiormarking.com
www.excelsiormarking.com
COMPLETE FACADE RESTORATION www.aiconstruction.com Restoration Contractors
440.243.5535
www.propertiesmag.com 15
Who’s taking care of your facility?
Single-Source Solution for All Facility Management & Maintenance Service
440.365.1725 www.simplifiedfacilities.com
We specialize in light rigging with custom crating and shipping options. Movers of The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Museum, The Cleveland Orchestra and more...
216.898.2990
www.bereamoving.com
COMMERCIAL Q RESIDENTIAL Q INSTITUTIONAL FAMILY OWNED AND OPERATED SINCE 1961
YOUR ONE-STOP SHOP FOR ALL CUSTOM FABRICATED METAL NEEDS AND ROOFING SUPPLIES SINCE 1953
State-of-the-Art Equipment Folds Metal to Most Precise Dimensions, Ensuring Quality Design, Function and Durability ARCHITECTURAL SHEET METAL • FLASHINGS • GUTTERS • DOWNSPOUTS STANDING SEAM PANELS • OTHER METAL FABRICATIONS Phone 216.252.3700 | Fax 216.252.0500 www.truform-metal.com | 12305 Grimsby Avenue, Cleveland, OH 16
in the South Atlantic, but slight declines were reported in the South Central and Northeast, each down 1%; and the Midwest and West, each down 2%. The 12% slide for total construction starts on an unadjusted basis during the first four months of 2016 came as the result of sizable declines for both nonresidential building and non-building construction, relative to their particularly heightened activity a year ago. For both sectors, the year-todate comparisons should strengthen as 2016 proceeds. Nonresidential building fell 21% in this year’s January-April period, with manufacturing building down 72%, the institutional building segment down 10%, and the commercial building segment down 4%. The first four months of 2015 had been boosted by such projects as the $8.1 billion Sasol ethylene cracker and derivatives complex in Louisiana, the $2.5 billion 30 Hudson Yards office-retail building in New York, New York; and the $705 million National Bio and Agro Defense Facility in Manhattan, Kansas. Nonbuilding construction dropped 25% year-to-date, with public works down 23% and electric utilities/ gas plants down 28%. The JanuaryApril amount for public works in 2015 was lifted by the $2.3 billion Interstate 4 project in Orlando, Florida, while electric utilities/gas plants were lifted by the $15.4 billion for three LNG terminals in the Gulf Coast region. Residential building is the one major sector to show year-to-date growth so far in 2016, rising 8% with single-family housing up 8% and multifamily housing up 5%. By major region, total construction starts for the first four months of 2016 revealed these comparisons to last year – the South Central, down 34%; the Midwest, down 7%; the Northeast, down 4%; the South Atlantic, unchanged; and the West, up 2%. Added perspective is made possible by looking at 12-month moving totals, in this case the 12 months ending April 2016 versus the 12 months ending April 2015. On this basis, total construction starts are down 3%, due to this performance by major sector – nonresidential building, down 17%; residential building, up 12%; and nonbuilding construction, down 7%. P Properties | June 2016
BOMA BUSINESS Exploring timely topics with BOMA members
Partnering with Customers in the Buying Process undreds of property managers were asked to list the mistakes vendors make when they sell to them. The responses probably won’t surprise you: They don’t listen, don’t follow up, don’t explain their solutions well enough, make exaggerated claims, and the biggest mistake... vendors don’t understand the property manager’s business and buying process.
H
A buying process is not a selling process. A selling process is what most vendors use to guide their selling. When someone buys, he or she goes through a number of steps that start at a logical place: the customer thinks they have a problem. Not all problems get fixed, especially if it costs money to fix them. So the customer has to decide to spend money and give the issue more attention or else the buying process stops, for now. Once a spending commitment is made, the customer defines the requirements of a solution and develops an RFP. Imagine you are out shopping for a flat screen TV. If you do not yet know the differences between HD, plasma and LCD, you are there to learn. The eager salesperson that tries to load a theater-quality rear projection system into your cart, when you were looking for a 30-inch screen for your kitchen, runs the risk of putting you off to the point you will not return to that store when you are ready to buy. How should a salesperson align their selling process to the buying process? First, ask plenty of questions: • Have they identified a problem? • What’s the potential economic cost? • Who is affected? • Have they committed to spending money to fix the problem?
• Who’s authorized to spend money? • What’s the timing of the next steps? • Is there a chance you could do nothing at all to address the problem? Second, once you determine where the customer is in the buying process, you then have a much better idea of how you can help them. If they need to learn more, then your focus should be on educating them. If they need to know how your product or service in general can fix their problem, maybe you could offer a demonstration or provide testimonials from clients that have had similar problems that you were able to find a solution for. Selling to their buying process makes you a trusted advisor and helps customers do what is natural for them – make a purchase. This approach should score you more points and win you more sales. P BOMA Greater Cleveland is proud to provide this space to our Associate Members so they can inform, educate and share their knowledge with property management professionals. This article was written by Tim Korte, VP Business Development of H&M Landscaping. Korte can be reached at 440-564-1157 or tim-korte@ hmlandscaping.com. H&M Landscaping can be found on the web at hmlandscaping.com.
B
Behold the Revolutionary New Kitchen
5528 Mayfield Rd. Lyndhurst, OH 440-449-2650 www.snowappliance.com
Mon, Tues, Thurs 10-8 Wed, Fri, Sat 10-6 www.propertiesmag.com 17
Proud to have represented Drury Hotels on the redevelopment of the historic Board of Education building.
History in the heart of Cleveland. Ulmer & Berne has extensive experience in tax credits. Our real estate and tax attorneys counsel developers in the strategic use of Federal and State Historic Tax Credits, New Markets Tax Credits, alternative State of Ohio loan and grant arrangements to >VµÕ Ài] Ài Û>Ìi] > ` w > Vi ÌÀ> Ãv À >Ì Ûi ÕÀL> «À iVÌð
ulmer.com
Cleveland | Columbus | Cincinnati | Chicago | Boca Raton
Photo credit: Thomas Song Photography©
Top-Class Hospitality Renovated Cleveland Board of Education Building reopens as new Drury Plaza Hotel By Doug Bardwell | Photos by Lauren Pacini
ome 85 years later, work is wrapping up once more on the stately Beaux-Arts style Cleveland Board of Education Building at 1380 E. 6th St. With a soft grand opening in April, Drury Plaza Hotel has become Cleveland’s latest hotel to open downtown, and customers are giving the hotel chain and project partners an “A” for their exquisite restoration work on this conversion to a $50 million, 189-room hotel.
S
The 200,000-square-foot, six-story, Walker and Weeks designed building was part of the Cleveland Group Plan of 1903, an effort inspired by the Columbian Exposition in Chicago, embodying what was known as the City Beautiful Movement. Arranged around a green mall, the six remaining buildings continue today to be one of the best examples of this movement
anywhere in the country. In 1975, this building was added to the National Register of Historic Places.
Moving out to move on As part of the restructuring of the school system, the Cleveland School District relocated its offices to 1111 Superior Ave. East in early 2013. With the building becoming vacant, and no
other charter school entity interested in acquiring it, the District was required to put it up for auction. “We had several properties in Ohio [including Columbus, Cincinnati, Dayton and Findlay], so our customer base indicated a need for a hotel in Cleveland,” says Kevin Whitfield, senior vice-president of design, development and construction for Drury Southwest, www.propertiesmag.com 19
Halper Lighting Solutions is grateful to Drury Hotels for the opportunity to refurbish & re-purpose historic light fixtures at DRURY PLAZA HOTEL
STATELY SETTING The building’s location along Mall A provides a uniquely grand setting. An existing statue of Abraham Lincoln sits just steps beyond the lobby entrance, for example.
BUSINESS OFFICES/STUDIO: 549 E. Washington St. Chagrin Falls, OH 44022
MANUFACTURING: 5425D Hamilton Ave. Cleveland, OH 44114
Contact: Bob Halper LC, IESNA • bob@halperlightingsolutions.com • 440.247.8363
͙͙͔͔ ǡ ǡ ͕͕͗͘͘ Ǧ ͖͕͚Ǥ͚͖͘Ǥ͚͔͔͘ ͖͕͚Ǥ͚͖͘Ǥ͚͔͕͘
Ƭ Ƭ Ȁ Ǧ Ƭ
Ǥ Ǧ Ǥ
Inc. “In January 2013, the building was listed for auction, so the Drury team quickly conducted a due diligence of the property and prepared for the auction.” An open outcry auction was held on March 7, 2013. Five groups competed in the bidding process, with Drury Hotels being the successful bidder at $4.8 million. In a 5-to-3 vote, the school board approved the sale April 8. Drury looks for specific attributes when placing its hotels – a combination
“What we have here is a green oasis in the midst of a concrete jungle.... We now have the best backyard in all of Cleveland.” Scott Schmelzer Drury Plaza Hotel Cleveland Downtown of both high traffic and unique locations. Memorial Plaza certainly offers both, and the proximity to central downtown will be a major draw.
Downtown’s greenest campus
͖͘Ȁ͛Ȁ͚͙͗ 20
When you think of large downtown Cleveland hotels, green grass and trees are not what typically come to mind. “That’s just one of the things that makes the Drury Plaza so unique,” beams Cleveland native Scott Schmelzer, general manager of the Drury Hotel. “What we have here is a green oasis in Properties | June 2016
LASTING IMPRESSION The two-story marble lobby features a pair of murals, completed in 1931 by Cora Millet Holder, called “The Branches of Education” and “The Progress of Education.” Each depicts 16 people influential in the history of education.
the midst of a concrete jungle. I challenge any of our competitors to make that statement.” The building is surrounded by expansive lawns and tall trees on all four sides. The west lawn, facing Memorial Plaza, is especially large, benefiting from the closure of East 4th Street years ago. At that time, the front door of the building was reoriented toward East 6th Street. “We now have the best backyard in all of Cleveland,” Schmelzer says. Dominated by the Abraham Lincoln statue immediately outside
and the Fountain of Eternal Life further west, sweeping views of downtown Cleveland and the mall abound through the massive arch-shaped windows in the lobby. Inside, the two-story marble lobby features two wonderful murals completed in 1931 by Cora Millet Holder: “The Branches of Education” and “The Progress of Education.” Each mural depicts 16 people influential in the history of education. “I’m excited and hopeful that our guests, and the people of Cleveland,
PERFORMANCE PAINTING )%( 6%( ('*( &HUWLÀHG FBE City of Cleveland
will enjoy the amount of open space surrounding the hotel,” Whitfield says. “Additionally, I think the building exterior is quite striking and very appealing from the standpoint of both proportion and fenestration.”
Do-it-yourself The old adage “When you want something done right, do it yourself” could certainly apply in Drury’s case. Dennis Vollink, Drury’s president, is a mechanical engineer and has direct input in the mechanical design and systems developProud to be part of the team at DRURY PLAZA HOTEL CLEVELAND DOWNTOWN
SBE Cuyahoga County Commercial, Institutional & Industrial Painting Contractor Serving all of Northeast Ohio • Interior/Exterior Painting • Wallcovering • High Performance Coatings • LEED Projects • Historic Preservation • Rigid Wall Protection • Female-Owned Enterprise • Epoxy Flooring • Dry Erase Surfaces
Let our PERFORMANCE help your bottom line 7603 First Place Suite 3B Oakwood Village, OH 44146 Q 440-735-3340 Q F: 440-735-3341 Q Performpaintllc@aol.com www.propertiesmag.com 21
FRESH WATER Fitting the pool into the building’s basement presented challenges. “We had to raise the pool elevation in order to avoid some underground utilities,” says Terry Brennan, of High-Tech Pools. “The resulting pool is both aesthetically pleasing and seems to fall in line architecturally with indoor urban pools of the past.”
ment of all of their projects. Coming to Cleveland, he was very hands-on in the design of this project. “One of the most challenging parts of the design for Vollink and others was fitting the swimming pool into the basement,” recalls Krisandra Lippert, development project manager with Drury Southwest, Inc. “Given the placement of the columns, we ended up with an ‘accidental’ lap pool [long and narrow].” Access was challenging, adds HighTech Pools Sales Manager Terry Brennan, regarding the pool installation. “We had to raise the pool elevation in order to avoid some underground utilities,” he says. “The resulting pool is
22
both aesthetically pleasing and seems to fall in line architecturally with indoor urban pools of the past.” In addition to the deep-blue tiled pool, a hexagonal spa hot tub and lots of lounge chairs complete the pool area. Designing guest rooms where offices used to be was also a challenge. Aligning mechanicals and making transitions from floor to floor, the design ended up featuring 49 unique room floor plans – from double-queen rooms to kings to suites. “We have architectural and engineering teams on staff at Drury Southwest, Inc., in addition to real estate, development and construction personnel,” Whitfield says. “We utilized a number
of local professional and construction firms on this particular project due to its complexity and importance to the Downtown Cleveland landscape. We do self-perform a number of duties on a given project. With our background in construction, many of the project components such as the hotel furniture and casework are built by Drury team members, so our whole development and construction process is very vertically integrated from start to finish.” Vollink worked with Karpinski Engineering for cooling, electrical, plumbing, lighting and life safety. Getting conduit and sprinkler piping to align was a major task, but each area was deftly accomplished by some talented tradespeople. “To complete an extensive gut and remodel required endless amounts of coordination between contractors and engineers,” says Greg Vittardi, CEO of Lakeland Electric Inc. One advantage offered by this building was a seventh-floor attic space where all the rooftop mechanical equipment could be located. Elevators received beautifully restored interiors, but did not need to be relocated. A new sidewalk lift was added for deliveries being made from the Rockwell side of the building. Properties | June 2016
BETWEEN THE WEATHER & YOU SINCE 1922
WARREN ROOFING WARREN ROOFING AND INSULATING COMPANY
Proud to be part of the team at DRURY PLAZA HOTEL CLEVELAND DOWNTOWN
Commercial/Industrial Roofing + Architectural Sheet Metal
440.439.4404
Fax 440.439.7523
www.warrenroofing.com
www.propertiesmag.com 23
Proud to Provide Electrical Contracting for
DRURY PLAZA HOTEL CLEVELAND DOWNTOWN
R. W. Clark is proud to have provided the window restoration services for the new Drury Hotel! GENERAL CONTRACTOR | RESTORATION SPECIALIST | CONSTRUCTION MANAGER
RWCLARK@RWCLARK.COM WWW.RWCLARK.COM
1677 E 40TH STREET CLEVELAND, OHIO 44103 PHONE 216-432-3155
(216) 520-5025 5350 Grant A Avenue, Cl Cleveland, l d Ohi Ohio 44125
Congratulations to Drury Southwest. We are proud to have been the skylight canopy contractor for DRURY PLAZA HOTEL CLEVELAND DOWNTOWN
Skylight Contractor & Sales Specializing in all aspects of skylights with custom design and installation services. We offer complete lines of residential, commercial & industrial products for any size project.
Since 1960 6510 Lorain Avenue Cleveland, Ohio 44102 216.621.4659 24
www.wilsonshaw.com Properties | June 2016
Photo courtesy of Smith & Oby
LONG VIEW APPROACH The building’s unique copper roof was completely replaced, maintaining the original exterior appearance while providing a very long-lasting solution. The new roof system has a life expectancy of about 100 years.
A new porte cochère has been added for valet drop-off on the East 6th Street side of the building. A small garage is located in the basement and accessed from St. Clair, but will be used primarily for maintenance purposes. Parking for guests will be handled by valets and cars will be parked around the corner in a garage at 801 Rockwell.
Historic Tax Credits played their part “Historical projects are always challenging from the standpoint of unknowns, whether it be unforeseen conditions of the building structure, or the ability to adequately predict how easy or hard a given construction process may be with a particular type of building,” Whitfield says. “Working the plumbing and mechanical systems around the amount of historical features and areas we had in the building was particularly challenging on this project.” All windows are actually still original, albeit fitted with new glass. Originally designed as double hung, the windows are too large to be operable by today’s standards, so they have been converted to fixed-in-place. Original brass hardware was retained, refinished and reinstalled as well. All doors, frames and large transoms on the lower three floors are also original. Each was repaired or restored as needed, but all match for a seamless look.
Historical light fixtures were salvaged and have been brought up to code and reinstalled. Exit signs were originally flush with the walls and would not meet current code, so the lighting restoration contractor made new, antique-looking metal boxes so they could all be reused, protruding from the walls. Marble was salvaged and reused wherever possible. Lower floor lobbies shine today with large marble squares on the floor and five-foot-high white marble slabs as wainscot. High barrel-vaulted
ceilings complement the lower hallways. The two-story lobby on the first floor and the 20-foot-high, third-floor corridor are possibly the most striking. The balance of the floors has 14-foot-high ceilings. Mary Lovett, chair of Ulmer & Berne’s Real Estate Group notes that significant support from the State of Ohio made the project particularly unique. “From State Historic Tax Credits alone, we secured $5 million,” Lovett says. “This project was also a job creator and involved a significant amount of environmental
CONGRATULATIONS Drury Hotels on the
restoration of the historic Board of Education building (1380 E. 6th Street) & 801 Rockwell garage.
Welcome to Cleveland
950 Main Avenue Suite 200 Cleveland, OH 44113
Conor Coakley is proud to assit on both transactions.
T +216 687 1800
www.propertiesmag.com 25
Proud Partner for Drury Plaza Hotel Downtown Cleveland
Adrian Maldonado&Associates Inc. *UD\WRQ 5G %HUHD DGULDQ PDOGRQDGR#\DKRR FRP
Proud to partner with Drury Southwest Inc. on the DRURY PLAZA HOTEL DOWNTOWN CLEVELAND
NORTHERN OHIO PLUMBING CO. YOUR FULL-SERVICE PLUMBING SERVICES PROVIDER
Photo by Ken Krych
POST CONSTRUCTION CLEAN-UP, MAINTENANCE, DEMOLITION DEBRIS REMOVAL, FURNITURE MOVING, STAGING & INSTALLATION :H DUH D FHUWLÀHG ('*( 0%( '%( +8' 6HFWLRQ 6HUYLFH 'LVDEOHG 9HWHUDQ 2ZQHG %XVLQHVV H[SHULHQFHG ZLWK FRPPHUFLDO LQVWLWXWLRQDO UHVLGHQWLDO VWUXFWXUHV
REGAL RECEPTION One of several meeting spaces, the 43-foot-long by 25-foot-wide Cuyahoga Room boasts historic details, while providing modern audio/video presentation needs.
remediation. Those factors combined to help us secure alternative State of Ohio loans and grants totaling $8 million.” With approximately $13 million available in historic tax credits, ownership made the decision to replace copper-for-copper on the existing roof, maintaining the total exterior appearance. “Warren Roofing worked with Drury to remove the entire, original copper roofing system and replace it with an upgraded system that is consistent with the original design,” says Trevor Cost, president of
;d]n]dYf\ k Kl]]d @]Y\imYjl]jk
CLEVELAND PLUMBING INDUSTRY
35601 CURTIS BLVD., EASTLAKE, OHIO 44095 Ŷ 440-951-3370
Proud to have provided fire-stop & insulation services for DRURY SOUTHWEST INC.
&ROXPELD %XLOGLQJ 3URGXFWV LOCALLY OWNED + OPERATED FOR 40+ YEARS
216-651-3370 www.compassinsulationohio.com 26
Spray Foam & Sprayed Insulation Systems Spray Acoustics | Spray Fireproofing Roof Restoration Systems [10 yr Warranties] Energy Consulting Infrared Thermal Imaging Building Restoration | Specialty Coatings
STEEL JOISTS STRUCTURAL IRON METAL ROOF DECK STEEL STAIRS & RAILS STEEL ERECTION
440-235-3363 *-1.) =de Kl&$ ;d]n]dYf\$ G@ ,,)+0
Properties | June 2016
ONE-OF-A-KIND AURA The building’s historical features provide a memorable experience for overnight guests and business meeting crowds alike: extra-wide corridors with vaulted ceilings (top), a relaxed bar/ restaurant called The Teacher’s Lounge (middle) and the grand Great Lakes Ballroom with balcony seating (bottom).
Warren Roofing & Insulating Co., who notes that copper sheeting is gauged in weight per square foot. “The original 16-ounce copper had a useful life of approximately 80 years, while the new 20-ounce roofing system has a life expectancy of approximately 100 years.” The copper roof removal and replacement process was a first for Drury, according to Whitfield. “The swimming pool in the basement, the renovation of the large exterior light fixtures on the entrance of the building, the renovation of the existing windows, the renovation and repair of the sandstone exterior of the building – all of these components proved to be challenging, but fortunately we had a great set of contractor partners in the project who each displayed the level of expertise required to meet the challenge,” Whitfield says.
Let’s have a meeting
Photo by Ken Krych
Appealing to the urban business meeting niche, even more features will be of special interest. All the meeting rooms here have large windows and high ceilings, unique among hotel meeting venues. The largest meeting room, the Great Lakes Ballroom on the first floor, is 45 feet by 50 feet, including a stage. Seating is available for 200 people on the ground floor, or 250 people if you include the second floor balcony, complete with original velvet-covered seats. The 43-foot by 25-foot Cuyahoga Room and the 27-foot by 17-foot Boardroom make up the balance of the 3,900 square feet of total meeting space available. A small but full-service bar/restaurant called appropriately The Teacher’s Lounge will be available for lunch or dinner on the first floor near the lobby. It will also handle room service. The third floor features the 900-square-foot Executive Suite in the old Board of Education Library. Maintaining the bookshelves on the perimeter walls, the old library was www.propertiesmag.com 27
Photos by Ken Krych
GLIMPSES OF THE PAST Key to the project was the careful preservation of existing elements, such as original marblework (left), woodwork light fixtures and murals (right).
divided into three sections – a living room area with comfortable leather furniture, a meeting room with a large custom conference table and a dozen chairs, and the bedroom area complete with original wood-burning fireplace. The original hand-painted linen wallcovering has been lovingly restored and has a one-of-a-kind built-in wall clock.
All a traveler could want The Drury chain of hotels, 130 strong and growing across 21 states, has won the
J.D. Powers award for “Highest in Guest Satisfaction Among Upper Midscale Hotel Chains” for 10 years in a row. “With what we refer to as our ‘Plus One’ service, we deliver a substantial amount of value with our increased attention to detail,” Schmelzer says. “That combined with our amenities package sets us apart.” A company tagline is that “the extras aren’t extra” at Drury properties. Highspeed Wi-Fi is free throughout. Free long distance phone service is included as well.
THE CLEVELAND MARBLE MOSAIC COMPANY CONGRATULATES
DRURY HOTELS ON THE RENOVATION OF THE
DRURY PLAZA HOTEL CLEVELAND DOWNTOWN THE CLEVELAND MARBLE MOSAIC COMPANY IS PROUD TO HAVE PROVIDED THE INTERIOR MARBLE INSTALLATION
EXCELLENCE IN STONE FOR OVER 90 YEARS 4595 Hinckley Industrial Pkwy Cleveland, OH 44109
1425 Brummel Street Chicago, IL 60007
219 East Bristol Lane Los Angeles, CA 92865
(216) 749-2840
(847) 593-3050
(714) 998-3280
28
A 24-hour business center is available for printing boarding passes or for use by those who failed to bring their laptop. Another guest favorite is the hotel’s multiple, free hot meals available each day. An extensive choice of hot selections are available for breakfast each morning. From 3 p.m. until 10 p.m., free popcorn and soft drinks are available, and at the 5:30 Kickback event each day, a different hot entrée is available until 7 p.m. on a weekly rotating menu. Meals aren’t the only memorable perks. All room plans offer abundant square footage and come with refrigerators, microwaves and large desks with ergonomic roller chairs. Large windows offer tremendous views of downtown Cleveland. In the basement, a 24-hour fitness center houses multiple treadmills and ellipticals, along with weight machines and other miscellaneous equipment. Parents will be able to work out and at the same time keep an eye on their teens using the pool immediately adjacent.
Once again, open to the public “This building had only one owner [the Cleveland Board of Education] until we acquired it,” Whitfield says. “It was very unique and special to all of our team that we were able to preserve features that were original to the building, such as the existing doors and lightProperties | June 2016
STAY IN COMFORT All 189 hotel room plans include free Wi-Fi and long distance phone service, plus multiple complimentary hot meals each day.
ing, marblework and artistic murals. The Auditorium, where school board meetings were conducted, was preserved and restored for a meeting space, and is one of the areas most people really enjoy seeing.” “This was the most cohesive team of tradesmen I’ve worked with anywhere,” Lippert says. “What you see here today is a tribute to the skill of Cleveland’s union tradespeople. We certainly would not be completed and standing here now if it weren’t for the sub-trades and their foremen. In each of the job meetings, literally everyone pitched in with ideas and solutions to the challenges faced throughout the project. It was incredible to see how invested each of them were in delivering this amazing product.” Whitfield concurs. “The skill and professionalism of all the trades who helped us in construction of the project was outstanding in my opinion,” he says. “Everyone pulled together with a focus and determination to make an outstanding project from a quality and scheduling perspective. Also, Cleveland has a very deep bench of very highly skilled craftsmen in areas particular to historical restoration/rehabilitation, such as stonework, plaster, marble, artwork, historic lighting and brass restoration.”
June 23 will mark the official grand opening of the Drury Plaza Hotel, but everyone who has had a chance to grab a
meet an extraordinary amount of people during that timeframe,” Whitfield adds. “All of us have been appreciative and moved by the number of people who have aided us in the development of the project. The City of Cleveland staff, the subcontractors, groups who took an interest in the building – everyone provided encouragement and advice to help us along the way. Knowing that so many people in Cleveland passed though these doors at one Kevin Whitfield time or another in their lives Drury Southwest, Inc. when the Board of Education was here, we tried to maintain a level sneak peek has been duly impressed with of respect and engagement to everyone. what they’ve seen. The care and concern that people con“When it takes you three years to tinually expressed for the building itself develop and construct a project, you was quite impressive.” P
“What you see here today is a tribute to the skill of Cleveland’s union tradespeople. We certainly would not be completed and standing here now if it weren’t for the subtrades and their foremen.”
9G YQWNF DG RTQWF VQ DG RCTV QH [QWT VGCO QP [QWT PGZV EQPUVTWEVKQP RTQLGEV
CONTAINER SERVICE, INC.
¸;OL 3LHKLY PU *VU[HPULY :LY]PJL¹ -), *:) ,+., *,9;0-0,+
>>> 7,;,(5+7,;,05* *64
@6<9 *65:;9<*;065 :7,*0(30:;: .9,,5 3,,+ 7961,*;: @(9+ -965; 36(+ *65;(05,9: @(9+ 96336-- *65;(05,9: www.propertiesmag.com 29
YOUR SOURCE FOR CONCRETE AND MASONRY REPAIR, CLEANING AND RESTORATION SOLUTIONS.
BEFORE
AFTER
Client: The Pro Football Hall of Fame - Fawcett Stadium (Canton, Ohio) Products: Sika SikaQuick 1000 (concrete repair) Miracote Multi-Purpose Coating MPC (coating)
Relying on over 100 years of professional design services, HWH delivers creative, functional, cost-effective solutions to further enhance your vision.
hwhaep.com
216.875.4000
Innovative Construction Product Solutions QUALITY PRODUCTS. TECHNICAL EXPERTISE. TRUSTED SERVICE. C L EVEL AN D
C AN T O N
T O L ED O
216.641.2150 330.754.0467 419-874-0033 www.chasephipps.com
General Contractor for the reconstruction of LEE-VAN AKEN GCRTA RAPID STATION
31350 INDUSTRIAL PARKWAY | NORTH OLMSTED, OH 44070 | 440.716.4900
General Contractors Ÿ Construction Management Ÿ Heavy Highway Ÿ Commercial Ÿ Industrial 30
Properties | June 2016
Building Connections New Lee-Van Aken RTA Station brings style to Shaker Heights transportation hub By Dennis J. Castiglione | Photos by Ken Krych
he Lee-Van Aken Rapid Station for the Greater Cleveland RTA was designated a “key station” in 2008 and, as such, was earmarked for upgrades to adhere to American Disabilities Act compliance requirements. It was also due for a significant facelift, so the $6 million redesign and construction project kicked into high gear once funding was secured.
T
“Taking nothing away from the difficulty and complexity of the project, but one of the toughest challenges was pinning down the finances,” says Deputy General Manager of Engineering and Project Management Michael Schipper P.E., with the Greater Cleveland RTA. “This project drew more than half our annual capital formula grant money for the year and we were chasing a very tight deadline, too.” Once the financing was secured, things moved rapidly. Schirmer Construction LLC of North Olmsted broke ground on the project in June 2014 with a firm deadline requirement of December 31, 2015. The dedication ceremony was held
on December 22, 2015, nine days ahead of the deadline.
Communication + coordination “On a project like this, there are several key players who need to weigh in, be kept in the loop and play their part in keeping us on budget and on schedule,” offers Mike DiLoreto, project manager with Schirmer Construction LLC. “That includes the partners like Bialosky Cleveland [design architect], HWH Architects Engineers Planners [architect of record], the City of Shaker Heights and RTA. But it also means the utility companies, the county and the state because we were working on a tight site that required partial road,
sidewalk and power shut-downs along the way. It was important to keep the tracks and roadways surrounding the station operational throughout the project, too, for the sake of the many passengers who use the train to access the businesses surrounding the site and for the residents who use the train as transportation to their place of employment.” “We had some very specific concerns about things like access to the roadways for our residents,” says City of Shaker Heights Deputy Chief of Police Mike Schwarber. “Schirmer and the RTA were very respectful of that in every way and used only the amount of roadway that was necessary for staging www.propertiesmag.com 31
POPULAR STOP The Lee-Van Aken station has the second highest ridership of the Blue Line stations east of Shaker Square, which makes it an important “destination station” for the Greater Cleveland community.
and safety of the workers, so that traffic could be maintained and our residents and businesses were not inconvenienced unnecessarily. We had to coordinate this project with another road construction company doing a big paving project at the same time on Van Aken and everyone proved to be fantastic to work with. “Our residents were very understanding. They recognized that RTA isn’t just a city resource, it’s a regional one. Many of [the residents] use the trains throughout the week and they appreciated the effort to make it a safer, more attractive station.”
The station has the second highest ridership of the Blue Line stations east of Shaker Square, which makes it an important “destination station” for the community. Public meetings were held with RTA to keep residents in the loop. The plan and the timeline were well laid out and the City took extra measures to assure that everyone knew what was happening, when and why. Mailers were sent and some were hand delivered to those closest to the construction site to alert them about any pending noise issues during the project. The City posted
updates on its website and even included a “construction zone” feature with the latest schedules and expectations. Social media was also employed to provide instantaneous news on the project. “We wanted to be sure there were no surprises for our community during the construction,” says Schwarber.
Tight timeframe, creative planning Some structural work had to be done on the site prior to renovating the station. A 20-foot retaining wall that was part of the original structure had to be improved and modified to support the
BIALOSKY IS HONORED TO HAVE BEEN THE DESIGN LEAD FOR THE LEE VAN AKEN RTA STATION. THANK YOU AND CONGRATULATIONS TO OUR COLLABORATORS! VISIT OUR NEW WEBSITE: WWW.BIALOSKY.COM
32
Properties | June 2016
new structure. “A lot of shoring was needed,” Schipper says. A key component in the construction of the station was the use of precast concrete. “Quite a bit of the work was done off-site and brought to the location ready to drop into place,” says Schipper. “This had to be done for a few reasons – schedule, budget and safety.” “Most of the 3,000-square-foot platform flanking the tracks is built from precast concrete sections that fit together like a giant concrete puzzle,” DiLoreto says. “These sections as well as the walls for the two 400-square-foot buildings on both sides of the track had to be crane loaded and carefully lowered into place. There was virtually no staging around the construction site for obvious reasons so we could only deliver materials when they were needed.” Close coordination and communication allowed for the precast materials to be delivered within a short timeframe. “Site surveys had to be right on with the precast work done on the project,”
“We worked 24 hours a day during a nine-day outage and six weekend outages to minimize the inconvenience to residents and passengers.”
Proud partner with Greater Cleveland RTA & Schirmer Construction LLC as the sole provider of signage & graphics for the new LEE-VAN AKEN RAPID TRANSIT STATION
216.741.3800
www.brilliantsign.com
4811 Van Epps Road, Cleveland, Ohio 44131
Mike DiLoreto Schirmer Construction LLC Schipper says. “Placing those first pieces absolutely correctly was crucial to fitting everything perfectly, especially on our timeline. Schirmer did a great job.” The use of cranes and the existence of “hot” overhead rapid transit lines called for a shut-down of the tracks while material was lowered into place. More than 40% of the construction of this 18-month project was done in nine days since a rail shut-down was required. “Months and months of preparation along with close coordination was necessary to pull this off,” says DiLoreto. “We’re very proud of how safely and efficiently all of our employees and subcontractors worked to make this come together, especially our superintendent Mr. Andy Costello, who was instrumental in the success of the project.” In addition to the structural work, elevators were added on both sides of www.propertiesmag.com 33
SPECIALIZING IN EXTERIOR MASONRY REPAIR & RENOVATION SINCE 1972 • COMPLETE INSPECTION/ASSESSMENT OF FAÇADE CONDITIONS • TUCKPOINTING/CAULKING
• BRICK & STONE REPAIR/REPLACEMENT
• SEALING/WATERPROOFING
• CLEANING/PRESSURE WASHING
Ph 216.881.4142 | Fx 216.881.6557 | 4408 St. Clair Ave., Cleveland, OH 44103
ARTFUL ADDITION The station is adorned with bronze sculptures, inspired by Cleveland’s industrial history.
the track which required a 23-foot shaft installed for each. This called for crane work, as well. Portions of the tracks were replaced by Schirmer Construction LLC subcontractor Delta Railroad during the project, too. “We worked 24 hours a day during a nine-day outage and six weekend outages to minimize the inconvenience to the residents and passengers,” adds DiLoreto. “Noise was another consideration and we did our best to keep that to a minimum as well.” RTA ran passengers by bus between the Warrensville Center Road station and Shaker Square during the shut-downs.
Design teamwork The conceptual design for the project was done by Bialosky Cleveland in 2008. “The city loved some of the concepts presented in the original design and we worked hard to preserve them and still squeeze costs to fit the available budget,” says Bialosky Cleveland Principal Mark Olson. “For example, the city loved the trellis that linked the north and south towers of the station. Some changes were made to keep that element in a scaleddown approach.” There were a number of redesigns for budgetary considerations between 2008 and 2011 that impacted everything from aesthetics to safety. The trellis arch creates a street wall on the west side of Lee Road. “It was inspired by traditional Triumphal Arches that 34
Properties | June 2016
COMMUNITY LINK The trellis arch, which creates a street wall on the west side of Lee Road, was a way to “graphically and symbolically unite Shaker Heights city with the civic and commercial heart of the community to the south,” says Mark Olsen, of Bialosky Cleveland.
celebrate events and people,” says Olsen. “It was also our way to graphically and symbolically unite Shaker Heights city hall with the civic and commercial heart of the community to the south.” HWH Architects Engineers Planners Inc. was tasked with reducing cost and the design of a smaller project. “We had great coordination between all parties to preserve the key elements of the original design by Bialosky, minimize the inconveniences for the riders, residents and businesses in the area and keep the end deadline in focus,” says Terry Angle, vice president with HWH Architects Engineers Planners, Inc. There were a number of aspects of the station design that were specific to satisfy ADA requirements and also provide train riders optimum safety, including the new elevators for handicapped riders. “Blue light” call boxes, several cameras and several LED lights were installed as safety features. Both entrances (on either side of the track) feature weather-protected vestibules that are connected to the elevators and stairways to the platform level making access equitable for all riders. The sidewalk bridge above the rail line (in front of the station) was widened for safer bus waiting and passenger circulation, creating greater distance between pedestrians and the street. “The overall design was inspired by the mix of architecture from neighboring buildings, including the city of Shaker Heights city hall and the library,” offers Jim Gerger, project architect with HWH Architects Engineers Planners Inc. Reduced maintenance and vandal
resistance were also in consideration during the design planning phase. For example, the precast concrete mixture includes Xypex waterproofing and the hand railings running from the street level to the platform have a thermoplastic no-paint, no-chip surface. Each updated RTA station features artwork and the Lee-Van Aken Station is no exception. Both the north and south buildings feature bronze sculptures by Tucson, Arizona-based artist Rachel Slick. Titled “Railway Dream,” the artwork features interlocking gears, flowers, birds and faces. “They are inspired by Cleveland’s industrial history, the
tradition of art nouveau and art deco architectural enhancements, and the reputation of Shaker Heights as a ‘garden community,’” Slick says. The artwork completes a project that embraces the surrounding community, while improving the functionality and comfort of the Shaker Heights transportation hub. “This was a true partnership and joint effort between all the key stakeholders,” says Schipper. “Everyone worked diligently to deliver a great project that satisfies our objectives and provides a great resource to the communities we’re serving.” P
Proud to have performed the electrical installation on the GCRTA Lee-Van Aken Station with Schirmer Construction
Committed to providing an IBEW Local 38 high quality electrical installation Electrical Power • Lighting • Fire Alarm Temperature Control Wiring • CCTV • Security Wiring 216-881-8215 Cleveland | 440-245-3532 Lorain | MinorityElectricCoInc.com www.propertiesmag.com 35
FINANCIAL STRATEGIES Smart use of fiscal planning & action
What’s Your Basis? everal years ago, we focused on the concept of cost recovery (also known as depreciation) in a couple of columns. This month, we are going to dig a little deeper into this concept, but before you tune out and flip to a different part of the magazine, ask yourself two questions. First: do you/your company/your clients pay taxes? And second: do you/your company/your clients care more about how much you make or how much you keep? If the answer to these questions is “yes,” I would recommend that you read on.
S
ALEC J. PACELLA
Cost recovery is an acknowledgment by the IRS that real estate is subject to wear and tear over time. To offset this, they allow an owner to recognize cost recovery. The general concept is that the owner’s original basis in the real estate is reduced each year as a result of the deprecation of the improvement portion of the real estate. This can be a clear benefit to the owner, as the cost recovery taken each year is deducted from any income each year. The result is a shelter for the owner, as they will be subject to tax on income after recognizing cost recovery, not before. I have simplified this concept and there are numerous nuances associated with the process. This month, we will focus on a specific nuance that occurs at the very
beginning of the process – establishing original basis. Basis is both an accounting and a tax concept. It is the benchmark value that is subsequently used to determine the amount of cost-recovery deduction, amortization deduction and gain or loss when the property is sold. Basis is established at the time of acquisition and must be allocated between the portions of the property that are attributable to land, improvements and, if applicable, personal property. Allocating the original basis is important because land is not subject to cost recovery. But, similar to many things in my life, we’ll put that in a box on the shelf and deal with it another day. The focus this month is on the nuances associ-
Result-Oriented and Reliable Legal Assistance for the ŽŶƐƚƌƵĐƟŽŶ /ŶĚƵƐƚƌLJ ůĂŝŵƐ DĂŶĂŐĞŵĞŶƚ ĂŶĚ ǀŽŝĚĂŶĐĞ ͻ ŽŵƉĞƟƟǀĞ ŝĚĚŝŶŐ ͻ ^ĐŚĞĚƵůĞ ŝƐƉƵƚĞƐ ĞĨĞĐƟǀĞ tŽƌŬ ĂŶĚ ĞƐŝŐŶ ůĂŝŵƐ ͻ WƌŽũĞĐƚ ĞůŝǀĞƌLJ ĂŶĚ ŽŶĐĞƉƚƵĂůŝnjĂƟŽŶ DĞĐŚĂŶŝĐ͛Ɛ >ŝĞŶƐ ͻ ^ƵƌĞƚLJ ŽŶĚ ůĂŝŵƐ ͻ >ĂďŽƌ ĂŶĚ ŵƉůŽLJŵĞŶƚ ͻ >ŝƟŐĂƟŽŶ
&ƌĂŶƚnjtĂƌĚ͘ĐŽŵ 36
Properties | June 2016
ated with establishing Determining the buythe original basis. er’s original basis in The most common BIG DEAL For the past few years, one of the replacement propway that original basis the things that I have said that has been erty, we would add is determined is during missing from our investment market was a the purchase price of an outright purchase. “blockbuster sale.” With potential sales of $2,000,000 plus the When a property is Terminal Tower, Key Tower and North Point total acquisition costs purchased, the basis is Tower all swirling in the rumor mill, 2016 of $8,000 plus the the buyer’s purchase may be the year that all changes. –AP intermediary fee of price of the property. $10,000 less the gain This includes the cash associated with the down payment, any mortgages, any other property that is being sold of $700,000. good and valuable consideration and any So the substitute basis in the property acquisition costs that may be capitalized acquired would be $1,318,000, which is and added to the basis. For example, sup- what would then be allocated into land pose a buyer purchases a property. The and improvement components. original equity is $500,000, the mortgage Sometimes, a property is gifted. When is $1,500,000, the closing costs are $1,000, this occurs, the original basis of the donee the associated legal and title work are (or party receiving the property) is usu$2,000 and the buyer has a phase one ally the same as the adjusted basis of the study completed at a cost of $5,000. In donor (or party giving the property), plus this instance, the original basis would be a proportional share of any gift taxes paid the total of all of these or $2,008,000. by the donor. However, the total basis Real estate owners will often utilize a may not exceed the property’s fair market strategy commonly called an exchange value at the time of the gifting. Using an as a part of their acquisition. The details example, suppose that the property being and nuances associated with exchanges gifted has a market value of $2,000,000 is in a box right next to the box labeled and the adjusted basis in the property “allocation of basis” and this month, at the time of gifting is $1,200,000. The I’m only going to focus on the part of original basis in the property for the exchanges related to establishing original donee would be $1,200,000; market value basis. When completing an acquisition of $2,00,000 less gain at the time of giftas a part of an exchange, a concept ing of $800,000. Note that gifting will known as “substitute basis” is introduced. transfer the gain from the person holding Depending on the terms, the substitute the property prior to the gift (or donor) basis in the property being acquired may to the person acquiring the property be greater than or less than the adjusted through the gift process (or donee). basis in the property being exchanged. Finally, a property may be inherited. The gain not reported on the disposi- The original basis in this instance would tion of one property is subtracted from be established by the market value of the value of the property acquired in that property at the time of the previous the exchange, plus the acquisition costs owner’s, or decedent’s, death – regardless including intermediary fees, to establish of the decedent’s adjusted basis at that the original basis. For example, suppose time. Once again using our example, that a buyer is acquiring a property as a suppose that a property has a market part of an exchange. The value of the value of $2,000,000 and the adjusted property that is being sold is $1,500,000 basis in the property at the time of and the adjusted basis of that property the decedent’s death is $1,200,000. The at sale is $800,000. This means that original basis for the person inheriting the buyer will have a $700,000 gain on the property would be $2,000,000, the the property they are selling; $1,500,000 market value at the time of the decevalue less $800,000 adjusted basis at sale. dent’s death. Any gain, in this instance Switching to the property the buyer is $800,000, would be the responsibility of acquiring, we will use the same scenario the estate of the descendent. P that is used for the outright purchase scenario above; $2,000,000 value plus Alec Pacella, CCIM, senior vice president at NAI $8,000 in total acquisition costs. Because Daus, can be reached by phone at 216.455.0925 this is a trade, there will also be fees asso- or by email at apacella@naidaus.com. You can ciated with the intermediary, which in follow him on twitter @dausyouknow or on his this instance are estimated to be $10,000. blog at http://blog.sbequitiesinc.com.
Daus, You Know?
Please join us! Cleveland Engineering Society
39TH ANNUAL GOLF OUTING Thursday, August 4, 2016 Boulder Creek Golf Club 9700 Page Road Streetsboro, OH Sign up by June 30 and save $10 per golfer or $50 per foursome! Golf with CES and support our education outreach programs including the NEW FACES OF ENGINEERING ROADSHOW! SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES ARE AVAILABLE. CONTACT CES FOR DETAILS OR TO SIGN UP. Call 216-361-3100 or visit CES online at www.cesnet.org/events -!'!:).% ).#
is a proud media sponsor of the Cleveland Engineering Society www.propertiesmag.com 37
ACAR CORNER Issues in the real estate industry
Lending Remains Largest Real Estate Concern ealtors specializing in commercial real estate expressed confidence in the continued recovery seen in the market but concern over the availability of commercial financing, during a commercial economic issues and trends forum May 12 at the 2016 Realtors Legislative Meetings & Trade Expo in Washington, D.C.
R
STEPHEN MERKLE
National Association of Realtors Chief Economist Lawrence Yun discussed the forces affecting commercial markets and said that while the overall market is seeing continued recovery, trepidation remains about the availability of financing for smaller commercial properties. Clients of Realtors who practice commercial real estate traditionally receive financing from smaller local or regional banks, many of which have slowed their lending as a result of the new financial
regulations. When the audience was polled about their major concerns for 2016, lending was the number one issue by a wide margin. “The big guys have access to big money, while those specializing in smaller transactions do not have access to those sources,” Yun said. “The largest banks can handle the compliance and higher capital requirements, but the smaller banks have less resources to meet these new regulations.”
New Roofs Ì Tear-Offs Ì Repairs Ì Flat Roofs Ì Coatings Flashings Ì Custom Copper Work Ì Factories Ì Warehouses Churches/Steeples Ì Additions Ì Apartments Ì Condos
FAMILY OWNED & OPERATED
APPROVED APPLICATORS FOR RPI, FIRESTONE, POLYGLASS, CTD & GAF
Ph 216.898.1563 Ì Fax 216.898.1853 Ì www.absoluteroofing.com 2013 NARI Contractor of the Year Award Winner – Commercial Specialty 38
Properties | June 2016
Yun called for a relaxing of regulation on small financial institutions. “Smaller sized banks do not cause systemic risk,” he said. “If a small bank goes under, it will not affect the entire market. They, and the businesses that depend on them, need regulatory relief.” Despite these restrictions, the smaller commercial market is experiencing steady recovery, and market fundamentals have seen improvement across most sectors. Industrial and apartment sectors are seeing vacancy rates below pre-recession numbers, and the office sector is almost at its pre-recession level. However, recovery in the retail sector has remained sluggish, with vacancies still high and rents slow to rise. “People are no longer walking around the city to buy things,” Yun says. “They are going online and having purchases delivered. This has kept the retail sector from fully recovering, leaving it as the only ‘soft’ sector in commercial real estate.” Mark Vitner, managing director and senior economist for Wells Fargo, spoke about the effect of the global economy on commercial markets. “The global outlook is so bad that Argentina and New Zealand are some of the few bright spots in the global economy,” Vitner said. “Devaluation of Chinese currency has had an enormous impact on the American economy. China accounts for 70% of the U.S.’s growth in exports, and the adverse effect it has had on the economies of our other trading partners has led to a slowdown in their economic growth.” Vitner insists, however, that things could be much worse. “We may be seeing gross domestic product growth underperforming at 2%; however, Europe and Japan are seeing no growth, and many other countries have fallen into a recession,” he said. “Comparatively, the U.S. is performing well. As Johnny Cash said, ‘We are the cleanest dirty shirt in the closet.’” If you would like more information on the housing market in Northeast Ohio, visit www.akronclevelandrealtors.com or follow ACAR on social media outlets. P
Proud to Serve as the General Contractor for the WAYNE COUNTY COURTHOUSE Exterior Preservation Project Congratulations to the entire team and the ‘16 Class of Celebration of Preservation Award Winners! PRESENTED BY:
P.216.938.5050 • F.216.938.5033 • johngjohnson.com
Stephen Merkle is the president of the Akron Cleveland Association of Realtors (ACAR). ACAR is the voice for real estate in Northeast Ohio – to our members, the real estate industry and the public. ACAR is a regional leader, dedicated to the excellence and advancement of our more than 5,000 real estate professionals. www.propertiesmag.com 39
NAIOP NEWS Commercial real estate happenings
Who Cares About Your Interests? AIOP has become a powerful lobbying force nationally to help the commercial real estate business thrive. NAIOP modified and tailored the national Energy Bill that recently passed in Congress, and we helped make that new law more manageable, yet still effective. The administration wanted to eliminate 1031 exchanges, and ultimately proposed limiting them to $1,000,000. What effect would that have had on your business?
N MICHAEL J. SIKORA III
NAIOP’s national advocacy team helped convince many U.S. senators and congressional representatives of the wisdom of keeping 1031 exchanges in place, despite the administration’s goal to significantly limit them. NAIOP is also becoming strong and respected in Ohio and locally on advocacy issues. We have the benefit of having the top commercial real estate professionals in our markets as members. Our members are extremely well-respected professionals that are experts on particular subjects, and NAIOP members help drive the economy forward. We have found that the opinions of NAIOP members matter to Ohio’s General Assembly and legislators in our local communities. Craig Miller, Shane Farolino, Rob Weeks and I attended the NAIOP Ohio
Legislative Day in Columbus on May 4, 2016. We met with Ohio senators, state representatives and their staff. For those of you who do not remember or are not aware, Historic Preservation Tax Credits were seriously on the chopping block in the Ohio General Assembly’s budget bill last year. How would your business have been affected if they had been eliminated? At NAIOP’s Legislative Day a few weeks ago, we learned that Governor Kasich and certain members of the General Assembly remain in favor of eliminating Historic Tax Credits. We’ve decided that we need to continue to collaborate and align with other interested associations in support of Historic Tax Credits. We have one of the top lobbyists in the state on retainer. The bottom line is that we
EDUCATIONAL EQUIPMENT Serving Cleveland and Northeast Ohio Since 1936 We are specialists in: • Operable Panel Partitions • Accordion Doors • Chalk/Marker Boards • Bulletin Boards • Trophy & Display Cases • Signage • Directories SALES
INSTALLATION
SERVICE
845 Overholt Rd., P.O. Box 154, Kent, Ohio 44240 — Phone (330) 673-4881 Fax ((330) 673-4915)
40
Properties | June 2016
will advocate effectively and regularly concerning the value of Historic Tax Credits to our economy. We also learned in our meetings that one of the main bills that we support should pass, which should significantly curb the effects of technical defects in recorded real property instruments. Another bill that NAIOP supports would significantly limit the use and effect of cognovit notes in Ohio. That bill faces challenges, mainly because it is opposed by financial institutions and their interest groups, but it makes a lot of sense and could move forward. NAIOP played a key role in the collaborative advocacy efforts concerning Cleveland’s new Building Façade Inspection Ordinance. That ordinance becomes effective on June 6, 2016. NAIOP’s collaborative efforts with the Downtown Cleveland Alliance and BOMA were instrumental in accomplishing three of our primary objectives, including: 1) broadening the definition of “Qualified Inspector,” to help ensure that the available supply of inspectors will be sufficient to satisfy the market demand, 2) making the inspection process two-tiered with an initial visual inspection, warranting further assessment only if the initial inspection reveals problems, and 3) adding a sunset provision that triggers review of the ordinance after one year and expiration after two years if Cleveland City Council does not vote to continue it. We are having a members-only education program on June 22, 2016 from 8:30-11:30 a.m. on the top-floor patio of Music Box (yes, outdoors), where we will (hopefully) enjoy Cleveland’s beautiful summer weather. We will be able to slide indoors, if necessary. That program will cover “The Hottest Legal and Accounting Issues and How They WILL Affect Your Commercial Real Estate Business.” It should qualify for real estate broker and salesperson CE credit. The line-up of presenters in this action-packed session includes some of the top experts in Ohio on the hottest current subjects, including: •
“National Political Climate and How It Will Affect Commercial Real Estate,” by Aquiles Suarez (NAIOP National Lobbyist)
•
“What the Ohio General Assembly Will Do This Session on Real Estate Issues,” by Matt Kallner (NAIOP Ohio Lobbyist)
•
“Future of State Historic Tax Credits,” by Dave Sobochan (Cohen & Company)
•
“Ohio Section 401 Water Quality Certification,” by Shane Farolino (Roetzel)
2'%+#.+<+0) +0 #.. #52'%65 1( '6#. 4#/+0)X 4;9#..X %1756+%#. '+.+0)5 #0& .114+0)
• “Curative Statute, Good Funds Statute, and Cognovit Judgment Statute,” by Mike Sikora (Sikora Law LLC & Omni Title LLC) •
“How the New FASB Accounting Standard Will Affect Commercial Real Estate Leases,” by Gabe Adler (Zinner & Co.)
•
“Cleveland’s New Building Façade Inspection Ordinance,” by Michael Deemer (Downtown Cleveland Alliance)
NAIOP has a lot of positive activity underway. The market is strong, and we are helping our members make the most of the present market opportunities. Our educational programs are becoming even more pointed and valuable. Real estate is a big part of national, state and local political agendas, and NAIOP is playing a key role in those discussions, which will shape the policies that will affect the commercial real estate business for many years to come. You do not want to be left behind. No organization cares more about the advancement of the commercial real estate industry than NAIOP. If you are not a member, join us. • The Northern Ohio Chapter’s next signature event will be its Annual Charity Golf Outing on June 13 at Shaker Heights Country Club. For more information, visit www.naiopnorthernohio.com. P Michael J. Sikora III is the president of the Northern Ohio Chapter of NAIOP, the managing officer of Sikora Law LLC, and the president of Omni Title LLC. He also serves on the Council of the Real Property Section of the Ohio State Bar Association, the Broker’s Counsel Roundtable of the Ohio Association of Realtors, and the Title Counsel of the American Land Title Association.
f n 6 X 174 )1#.5 #0& 8#.7'5 #4' %105+56'06 9+6* #.. %.+'065U &'.+8'4 37#.+6; 914-X 10 6+/' #0& 10 $7&)'6T ' 564+8' 61 ':%''& '8'4; %.+'06 5 ':2'%6#6+105 #0& (14/ # .#56+0) 2#460'45*+2T 74 56#0&5 9+.. '0574' # (.#9.'55 241,'%6 '8'4; 6+/'T KMF T #).'; &T '4'#X HHNEK ).'00u+%109%(T%1/ 999T+%109%(T%1/
HHNgFFEgLFKI www.propertiesmag.com 41
LEGAL PERSPECTIVES Navigating property laws & regulations
The Art of the “Short-Term Deal” – Negotiate Like Trump any companies and individuals are attempting to cash in on opportunities that exist from the Republican National Convention coming to Cleveland this July. Some of these opportunities result from short-term leases of your commercial premises and other facilities. Although these opportunities can be somewhat lucrative, keep in mind a few key points to ensure your deal is negotiated on a level that would even make “The Donald” proud.
M
JOHN P. SLAGTER, ESQ.
This article applies to non-residential transactions, and most provisions set forth herein would not apply to a residential lease. I have provided five key provisions that will protect you if you enter into this type of short-term commercial lease.
1. Writing Detail the transaction in writing signed by all parties to the transaction.
Ohio Revised Code Section 1335.04 provides that leases need to be in writing to be enforceable. Therefore, a writing is necessary since the protections that are recommended in this article will not be enforceable unless they are specifically agreed to in writing. The first step is to make sure that all the terms, including the following recommended provisions, are agreed to
!30(!,4 0!6).' !30(!,4 2%0!)2 3%!,#/!4).' #2!#+ &),,).' #/-0,%4% 3)4% #/.3425#4)/.
0!6 ) . ' ) . # s %XCELLENT QUALITY COMPETITIVE PRICING RELIABILITY
%8#!6!4)/. 4/ #/-0,%4)/.
s #UNNINGHAM 0AVING IS A FAMILY OWNED BUSINESS WITH OVER YEARS OF EXPERIENCE s ,ICENSED BONDED INSURED s /UR MOTTO h+EEPING OUR CUSTOMERS SATISFIED KEEPS THEM COMING BACK v
* iÊӣȰxn£°nÈää >ÝÊӣȰxn£°nÈnÎ !URORA 2OAD 7ARRENSVILLE (EIGHTS /( 42
Properties | June 2016
in writing and signed by all parties to the transaction.
2. Get paid Have the lease amount and security deposit paid upfront. Before granting possession to the short-term tenant, require payment upfront of the entire lease amount and security deposit. It is typical in long-term leases to receive payment on a monthly basis; however, for short-term leases, which would typically last less than one month, there is no good business reason not to be paid upfront. As a practical matter, if the tenant cannot afford payment in full, there is an increased risk that there may be failure to perform the financial terms of the short-term lease and any benefits resulting therefrom would be lost from such breach, not to mention the cost of enforcing the agreement. It is also a good idea to require a security deposit even if the full lease amount is paid upfront to ensure that there are funds to cover potential damage to the premises and other costs including hold-over costs, such as rent and utilities, for the time period after the lease term ends.
use self-help, it may draw a claim for damages including lost profits, if the landlord wrongfully used the self-help remedy. To avoid a claim for lost profits, there should also be a provision in the lease that prohibits any consequential damages from breach of the lease or any other potential conversion of the tenant’s property. In fact, the lease
term lease because the time needed to relet the premises may be as long as the lease term itself. To ensure that a tenant does not have the ability to assert the landlord’s failure to mitigate its damages as a defense to a claim for payment, the landlord should specify in the lease agreement that the duty to mitigate damages has been waived.
Although short-term leases can have Although short-term leases can have significant monetary benefits significant monetary benefits for the for the landlord, the terms of the lease need to be artfully landlord, the terms of the short-term lease short-term crafted to ensure that your deal need to be artfully crafted to ensure that is as beneficial as you expected. Many of these provisions would your deal is as beneficial as you expected. be considered overreaching in a
3. Attorneys’ fees In commercial leases, it is permitted to include a provision that would require payment of attorneys’ fees associated with enforcement of the terms of the lease. If the lease does not provide for payment of attorneys’ fees, courts are not permitted to order that your attorneys’ fees be paid by the tenant. Therefore, the short-term lease should have a provision that specifically provides that all attorneys’ fees associated with the enforcement of the lease shall be paid to the prevailing party.
4. Self-help It is legal, as long as there is no breach of peace, for a lease to provide for the remedy of self-help, meaning that the landlord can lock the tenant out of the premises if the tenant breaches the lease. Whenever exercising this right, caution needs to be taken as it relates to tenant’s personal property to ensure that it is secure, inventoried and protected, so there is no claim for damage or conversion of such personal property. Additionally, when landlords
should limit any damage recovery by the tenant to a return of the lease payments only.
5. Eliminate duty to mitigate damages Ohio law provides that a landlord has a duty to mitigate, or reduce, damages by taking reasonable efforts to relet the premises if there is a breach. Such provision makes little sense in a short-
long-term lease, but in a short-term lease scenario, these provisions are reasonable and appropriate. P The material appearing in this article is meant to provide general information only and not as a substitute for legal advice. Readers should seek the advice of their attorney or contact John Slagter at jslagter@bdblaw.com or 216.621.5300. This article may not be reprinted without the express permission of Buckingham, Doolittle & Burroughs, LLC © 2016.
HOW BAD IS THAT LEAK?
Keep your assets safe by taking the time to ensure that problems at the top of your building are not damaging your bottom line.
Carey Roofing Corp. has eliminated asset damage due to a leaking roof with practical solutions since 1946. 216 • 881 • 1999 CAREY www.careyroofing.com
Roofing Corp.
founded in 1946
MEMBER: National Roofing Contractors Association www.propertiesmag.com 43
Proud to have provided construction clean-up at FRESH THYME FARMERS MARKET (Toledo, OH) for CE Gleeson Contractors
Quality Products & Services Since 1933 dŚĞ Z͘>͘ tƵƌnj ŽŵƉĂŶLJ ŝƐƚƌŝďƵƚŽƌ ŽĨ ŽŶƐƚƌƵĐƟŽŶ Θ ZĞƐƚŽƌĂƟŽŶ WƌŽĚƵĐƚƐ ^ƚĂƚĞǁŝĚĞ ([SHUWV LQ Sealants • Waterproofing
Simply the best. Specializing in: Construction Cleanup Window Cleaning • Pressure Washing Janitorial Services • General Labor
Architectural Panels Supplies • Air Barriers Concrete & Masonry y Products 7ZR 7HFKQLFDO 6HUYLFH &KHPLVWV RQ 6WDII
GM EQUITY
DEVELOPMENT 1080 D Center Rd., Auburn Hills, MI 48326 • 248-933-6990
44
13320 Enterprise Ave., Cleveland, OH 44135 1-800-969-1754 www.rlwurz.com Žǁ ŽƌŶŝŶŐ ŝƐ Ă ƌĞŐŝƐƚĞƌĞĚ ƚƌĂĚĞŵĂƌŬ ŽĨ Žǁ ŽƌŶŝŶŐ ŽƌƉŽƌĂƟŽŶ͘
Properties | June 2016
BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans
Tec Inc. Announces W.E. Monks Merger ec Inc. Engineering & Design and W.E. Monks & Co. Engineers recently announced that Monks, a prominent Columbus engineering firm established in 1960, has merged with and become part of Tec, as of May 9, 2016. The firms both offer similar mechanical, electrical, plumbing (MEP) engineering services to clients in similar vertical markets, including health care and higher education. With the merger, Tec’s Columbus office now has 10 engineers providing a full range of engiRuss Edwards and Terry Kilbourne neering services to clients throughout Central Ohio. Monks, located on North High Street, now houses Tec’s Columbus office. The merger brings the total number of engineers and design professionals at Tec to 27. Russ Edwards, president of W.E. Monks, will continue as principal with Tec and is now the managing principal of Tec’s Columbus office. Monks will operate as Monks Engineers, LLC, a subsidiary of Tec, until the transition is complete and all operations and professionals have been integrated into Tec Inc. Engineering & Design.
Photo courtesy of Tec Inc.
T
Bradford Joins Skoda Minotti Real Estate/Construction Skoda Minotti, a national CPA, financial and business advisory firm, recently announced the addition of Dale Bradford, Esq., to its Real Estate and Construction group. In his role, Bradford will provide
consultative services for acquisition, development, financing and construction of commercial projects. Bradford has 33 years of combined legal, development and construction expertise in the real estate and construction industry. He has represented all interested parties in all facets
of real estate transactions, including owners, tenants, professionals and contractors in planning and structuring transactions, acquiring land, obtaining project approvals, securing financing and completing construction. Bradford earned his Bachelor of Arts in business administration from
James Neville
Wittenberg University, and his Juris Doctor, with honors, from Wake Forest University School of Law.
RDL Architects Adds Principal RDL Architects recently announced that James R. Neville, RA, NCARB has joined its firm as a principal. Neville has more than 45 years of experience, serving as executive vice president of Christian & Klopper for 20 years and president of the successor firm, Neville Architects, since 2005. Neville has served on the City of Shaker Heights’
THE FOUNDATION SPECIALISTS SPECIALTY & DESIGN BUILD CONSTRUCTION SERVICES &RPSUHVVLRQ 3LOHV 7HQVLRQ 3LOHV 5HVWULFWHG $FFHVV /RZ +HDGURRP ,QVWDOODWLRQV (DUWK 5HWHQWLRQ 6\VWHPV + 3LOHV /DJJLQJ &XW 2II :DOO 3LOHV 7% 6RLO 5RFN $QFKRUV 0LFUR 3LOHV 6RLO 1DLOV 6KRWFUHWH
Contracted to design, build & install the sheeting shoring system (8’ to 30’ cut), consisting of H-piles, lagging, walers, tie-back soil anchors & the installation of 350+ augercast piles to rock for support of the new five-story KSU SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE building in Kent.
PH 330-336-8871 P.O. BOX 557 WADSWORTH, OHIO 44282 AUGERCASTPILES@AOL.COM WWW.AUGERCASTPILES.NET www.propertiesmag.com 45
BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans
Architectural Board of Review since 1993 and numerous Shaker Heights citizen advisory committees. He is a board member of the Cleveland Clinic Children’s Hospital for Rehabilitation; a trustee for the Cleveland Clinic Foundation; a board member of Ronald McDonald House of Cleveland; and a founding director of the Fresh Air Camp for Ventilator-Dependent Children since 2000.
Leff Electric Welcomes New Executive Director Leff Electric has named Mark Kelly as its new executive director of National Accounts and Energy Solutions. Kelly’s work experience includes positions at
brings a strong background in lighting to the Leff Electric executive team. An independently owned electrical supply distributor founded in 1921, Leff Electric is headquartered in Cleveland, with branches in Akron, Elyria, Mentor, Strongsville, Warren, Warrensville Heights and Youngstown. James Neville
GE, Eaton/Cooper and most recently as the managing principal at Kel-Lume, a consulting firm specializing in the lighting retrofit market. Kelly received his Bachelor’s Degree in electronic engineering from the University of Akron and his MBA from Case Western Reserve, and
approach to the productivity needs within the fire protection industry, stand-alone customer service and one that increases job opportunities within the Northeast Ohio and Western Pennsylvania regions.” The company recently purchased a well-rooted industry competitor, Akison Fire & Safety, which serves Western Pennsylvania. The company also purchased a 4,300-square-foot building in Toledo. As a direct result, new jobs have been created and County Fire Protection has increased its staff by 25%.
County Fire Protection Announces Expansion Plan Kent-based County Fire Protection, Inc. recently announced a multi-region expansion plan, signaling the company’s continued growth within the fire protection industry. President John Lubinski’s growth plan aims to provide “a highly efficient
Property Managers Named for Lee-Harvard Shopping Center R.G. Nieto Co. and Arnold J. Eisenberg Co. were recently
Serving Northeast Ohio For Over 60 Years! Residential Ŷ Commercial Ŷ Industrial Ŷ Institutional Dedicated to real estate & building progress in Northeast Ohio since 1946 TODAY
,16,'( (XFOLG &RPPRQV DW &68 6WHSKDQLH 7XEEV -RQHV 7UDQVLW &HQWHU &($ ,16,'( :KLWH 3RQG 7KH 5HVLGHQFHV DW 6L[ 6L[ (LJKW 3DUWQHUV IRU 8URORJ\ +HDOWK
January 2011/$7.95
June 2010/$6.95
)\PSKPUN ) \PSK /HYTVU` / HYT
2010
Celebra ting 65 Years
11Haa Z[\KPLZ WYVNYHT [HRLZ Haaa ZZ[\KPLZ [ KP [ R JJLU[LY Z[HNL H[ 6ILYSPU *VSSLNL LUU[LLY Z[HNL ^P[O KYHTH[PJ UL^ MHJPSP[` ^ P[[O K KYHTH[P
Since 1946
,16,'( 'HYHORSHUV 'LYHUVLILHG 5HDOW\ +4 7ULSRLQW 0HGLFDO &HQWHU 3K\VLFLDQV 3DYLOLRQ
Pinnacle of Patient Care
December 2009/$6.95
University Hospitals weds wellness, healthcare at new Ahuja Medical Center
73<:! 7 3<:! ,U] ]PYYVUTLU[H ,U]PYVUTLU[HS :VS\[PVUZ : WLLJPHS :LJ[PV :WLJPHS :LJ[PVU
INSIDE: W Wellington ellingtton Place • East Hall H at Hiram College • Security & Firee Prevention Preveentiion n
October 2008/$ 2008/$6.95 $6.995
2000
-VY^HYK 7YVNYLZZ <UP]LYZP[` VM (RYVU JOHYNLZ <UP]LYZP[` VMM (RYVU JOHYNLZ ,16,'( 6WRQHEULGJH 3OD]D 1DJHOH 0DQXIDFWXULQJ &R 6HFXULW\ )LUH 3UHYHQWLRQ HOLHK ^P[O UL^ 0UMV*PZPVU :[HKP\T :\TTH -PLSK G[lgZ]j *((/' .&1-
PLUS: Financial Review & Forecast 2010/2011 Crunching C i the numbers on Northeast Ohio’s real estate & construction markets market
73<:!
)<03; ;6 :<0; A special i l llook k att C Con Construction struction t ti n Management in Northeast Ohio
1990
Expert Brick Matching and Complete Inventory of Brick, Block, Masonry, Cast & Natural Stone, Plaster Products & Tools
HIGHFLYING
DESIGN Celebrated Viennese architectural firm creates new Akron Art Museum addition as cultural beacon
Class Act PLUS Cleveland Clinic Courts equips Cavs with state-of-the-art athletic training facility
Dramatic renovation re-imagines Hanna Theatre as permanent home for Great Lakes Theater Festival
1980
1970
1960
1950
9005 Woodland Ave., Cleveland, OH 44104 216.791.9800 Ŷ www.bruderinc.com 46
1946
www.propertiesmag.com Properties | June 2016
PAVING WITH PRIDE FOR 30+ YEARS Since 1982, we’ve been building our reputation job by job
LET’S MAKE YOUR JOB OUR NEXT STOP >L ^V\SK HWWYLJPH[L HU VWWVY[\UP[` [V Z\ITP[ V\Y YLJVTTLUKH[PVUZ HUK LZ[PTH[LZ MVY `V\Y!
5L^ 7HYRPUN 3V[ *VUZ[Y\J[PVU
.YHKPUN ,_JH]H[PVU
:P[L +L]LSVWTLU[
(ZWOHS[ 9LZ\YMHJPUN
*H[JO )HZPUZ +YHPU[PSL
:[VYT :L^LY >VYR
(ZWOHS[ 9LWHPYZ
*YHJR -PSSPUN :LHSJVH[PUN
4PSSPUN
Specialists from site development to chuckhole patching!
We're doing it better for less every day
Call us today at 216.421.1203 2417 Woodhill Rd., Cleveland, OH 44104 • Fax 216.421.1278
^^^ UVY[OJVHZ[WH]PUN JVT
BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans
appointed co-property managers of the Lee-Harvard Shopping Center on Cleveland’s east side. AJE will be the exclusive leasing agent. “We are happy to add Lee-Harvard to our family of managed properties and take pride in providing our boutique style services to our new client and tenants,” says Bob Nieto, president of R.G. Nieto Co. The two real estate companies have been in business almost 40 years each, Nieto notes. This is the fourth co-managed property for the duo. Located at the corner of Lee Road and Harvard Avenue, Lee-Harvard Shopping Center is the largest shopping plaza in Cleveland and accommo-
dates over 210,000 square feet of retail space.
Hasenstab Architects Names Two New Principals Daniel Herstine, AIA, LEED AP, EDAC and Brian Miner, AIA, LEED AP BD+C were recently named principals of Hasenstab Architects. Herstine and Miner join the firm’s current principals, bringing the ownership group to six. Herstine, a graduate of Kent State University, has been with Hasenstab Architects since 1999. During his 17-year tenure with Hasenstab, he has played an integral role within the firm’s healthcare design studio, incorporating evidence-based and patient-centered design
Daniel Herstine
into his projects. He is currently managing projects for Aultman Hospital, the Ohio Department of Mental Health & Addiction Services (OMHAS) and Summa Health System. Miner, also a graduate of Kent State University, has
worked on a variety of higher education, laboratory and healthcare projects since joining Hasenstab Architects in 1999. He will help lead the team with sustainable design and LEED (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) efforts. Miner is currently working on projects for Kent State University, The Ohio State University and Ohio University. Miner is also the co-founder of Elves & More Northeast Ohio, an organization that gifts bicycles to children in impoverished neighborhoods during the holiday season. P WHAT’S NEW? For coverage within Billboard, send along company news, story ideas and project information to billboard@propertiesmag.com.
11528 Royalton Road, North Royalton, OH 44133 (440) 582-5200 • www.royaltonsupply.com
*URZLQJ WR PHHW \RXU QHHGV :H¶YH PHUJHG ZLWK $EUD[XV 6DOW //& WR PHHW \RXU QHHGV DOO \HDU ORQJ . 3URYLGLQJ FRPPHUFLDO DQG UHVLGHQWLDO ODQGVFDSH VXSSOLHV SURPSWO\ ZLWK WKH DUHDV EHVW VHUYLFH Ɣ 7RSVRLO Ɣ 0XOFK Ɣ &RPSRVW Ɣ 'HFRUDWLYH 6WRQH Ɣ &RQVWUXFWLRQ $JJUHJDWH Ɣ <DUG :DVWH 'LVSRVDO Ɣ 7UXFNLQJ Ɣ 'HLFLQJ &KHPLFDOV 48
Properties | June 2016
)DEULFDWLRQ ,QVWDOODWLRQ 6HUYLFH
LQ \HDUV U H Y R RU OL]LQJ I 6SHFLD WRS U HG URRI J D RW ZDWH N F K D 3 P GLQJ ¥ VWHD ZHO Q R L W D F %RLOHUV UL HWDO IDE HOGLQJ 6KHHWP ULFDWLRQ Z IDE W 3ODVWLF HHULQJ DUWPHQ Q S L H J G Q H H F 9DOXHG H PDLQWHQDQ UYLF )XOO VH
ZZZ OLVFRKYDF FRP 6WDWH 5G 1 5R\DOWRQ 2+
www.propertiesmag.com 49
Proud to have served as General Contractor for the Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Humanities Center 18440 Cranwood Parkway Warrensville Heights, Ohio 44128 infinityconstruction.com p 216-663-3777 f 216-663-3778
Creative Architectural & Fine Interior Photography kevinreevesphotographer.com 50
Properties | June 2016
Idea Building Tri-C embraces leadership development with new Mandel Humanities Center By Jeanne Bluffstone | Photos by Kevin Reeves
here do we find the future leaders of Northeast Ohio? That was the question philanthropist Morton Mandel posed to leadership at Cuyahoga Community College in July 2014 as they sat in an open area near the Liberal Arts building at Eastern Campus in Highland Hills.
W
story is different with Tri-C students. Eighty-five percent of them spend their entire earning life in Northeast Ohio. “If this area wants to have civically engaged leaders, then the place to foster that is right here at Tri-C,” Thomson says. “Bright students can be found throughout the college’s four campuses and they come from all walks of life. We know there is leadership potential in our classrooms.” Tri-C leaders suggested renovating the Liberal Arts building and renaming it the Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Humanities Center. The plan called for minor renovation of 9,000 square feet on the first floor of the building and a major renovation of 14,000 square feet on the second floor. It was a $1.9 million capital project.
The Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Foundation and the Mandel Supporting Foundations responded to the plan in the spring of 2015 by awarding $10 million to Tri-C through the Cuyahoga Community College Foundation to establish the Humanities Center. It was the largest gift the college has ever received.
Making the dream a reality The College dedicated the Mandel Humanities Center in September 2015 and opened it for classes four months later. Faculty, students and the community began gathering at the Center in January for classes, seminars, lectures and special events designed to foster civic engagement. Upon entering the renovated building, visitors found a technology-rich www.propertiesmag.com 51
Photo by Ken Krych
In the past, leaders came from the humanities, but today they often come from science disciplines. “Mr. Mandel very much favors the humanities, and when we talked about the stress of STEM [science, technology, engineering and math], he questioned where future leaders would come from if we kept focusing on science,” says Dr. J. Michael Thomson, president of Tri-C’s Eastern Campus, who was at the meeting. The College offered a solution: the creation of the Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Humanities Center to continue the Mandel legacy and call attention to the study of the humanities as a viable path to leadership development. When bright students graduate from high school and go away to college, they generally don’t come back – but the
FRESHLY REFURBISHED The $1.9 million project included minor renovation of 9,000 square feet on the building’s first floor, plus a major renovation of 14,000 square feet on the second floor (above).
environment and innovative spaces that encouraged collaborative learning, reflection and ideation. “We had a very aggressive project schedule for an entirely new program to the community college environment,” says Jason Nolde, partner for Richard Fleischman + Partners Architects, Inc. (RF+PA). “Our team was able to complete a quick design turnaround from concept to con-
52
struction documents in order to get the space open for January classes. Despite the aggressive design and construction schedules, the accepted bid was below the project budget.” “The most challenging part of the project was procuring all of the highend and long lead-time finish materials to meet the condensed and aggressive schedule,” says Jeff Young, project manager with Infinity Construction, Inc.
The Humanities Center opened with a pilot class of 24 Mandel Scholars who met specific requirements such as a 3.0 GPA in their college coursework and recommendations from Tri-C faculty and community leaders. The Scholars embarked on an educational journey into the humanities that included guest speakers, a study of Cleveland’s history and field trips to places like the Maltz Museum of Jewish Heritage.
Properties | June 2016
RICHARD FLEISCHMAN+ PARTNERS ARCHITECTS www.studiorfa.com
LIVELY LOOK Updated finishes, signage and lighting have brought new energy to the first floor, including the entrance to the existing Simon and Rose Mandel Theatre.
As a class project, the students partnered with the City Club of Cleveland to present a community forum at the Humanities Center in the Simon and Rose Mandel Theatre. The chairman of the National Endowment for the
“The most challenging part of the project was procuring all of the high-end and long lead-time finish materials to meet the condensed and aggressive schedule.” Jeff Young Infinity Construction, Inc. Humanities, William Adams, headlined the May event. A new class of 200 Mandel Scholars will be selected in the fall to carry on the Center’s mission and build more leaders for the region’s future.
Proud to have provided electrical service at 0DQGHO +XPDQLWLHV &HQWHU ZLWK ,QˉQLW\ &RQVWUXFWLRQ
Commercial | Industrial | Institutional | Residential Service Ground Up | Renovation | Maintenance Generator Installations | Design Build | /LJKWLQJ 5HWURˉW Dedicated Management with “Team Player” Philosophy
440 - 542 -0735 Proud to have provided flooring for Tri-C’s
JACK, JOSEPH & MORTON MANDEL HUMANITIES CENTER Commercial, Institutional & Industrial Floor Covering Provider & Installer
A space to awaken creativity Designing the Mandel Humanities Center was a collaborative effort and brought together representatives from the administration, staff, architects and faculty – at least 100 in all – collaborating to study how the space should and could be used, and selecting furniture that was flexible and would encourage group study and interaction. The objective was to nurture the power of thought and drive the formation of
Specializing in the healthcare marketplace with the highest quality & best service since 1989. We provide 24/7 service & installation. Call us today to take advantage of our trained in-house staff and extensive library of product information. Complete line of flooring including: Carpeting • Resilient Flooring, Vinyl & Ceramic Tile • Athletic Floors
Call today for a FREE estimate! 4300 Brookpark Rd., Cleveland, OH 44134 • 216-595-0100 • Toll Free 888-271-8200 www.propertiesmag.com 53
EMBRACING OPENNESS Overall, the second floor utilizes an open floorplan, with glass panels instead of drywall separating classrooms, offices and public areas.
ideas with an attitude of cooperation and interactive technology. The second floor of the Humanities Center immediately captures attention with its tempered glass panels. Since it includes what had previously been a balcony, there’s an unobstructed view of the lobby and the entrance to the Simon and Rose Mandel Theatre. Mandel Scholars can look down on
the first-floor activity and students below can look up into the hub of the Humanities Center, perhaps with curiosity. The glass offers more than aesthetic appeal and transparency as it acts as a sound barrier when events are taking place in the theater or the large open lobby. “The overall open floor space, with glass panels where drywall would typi-
Suntrol It! SUNTROL
™
G L A S S
E N H A N C I N G
F I L M S
Suntrol.com 800-466-TINT(8468) ESTABLISHED 1975
Love Your Windows!
54
Select Pro Window Film Dealer: • Security • Privacy/Custom • Energy Savings • Glare Reduction • Sun Protection
cally be placed for classroom and office walls, is a particularly unique aspect of this design,” says Young. A curved red soffit, representing an intellectual ring, visually links the upper and lower floors and creates a branding element which is visible from the lower level, Nolde says. In addition to connecting the two areas, the soffit acts as a wayfinding element, circling around the study area, then leading to the Ideation space and flowing to the three glass-enclosed classrooms. Dozens of 28” x 60” USG panels – with channel LED lighting set in utility troughs – float above the space, creating a cloud-like ceiling that never touches the walls and adds to the illusion of endlessness. Above the six-foot ceiling, and barely visible, is a blacked-out area that houses the mechanicals for heating, cooling, electricity and technology, adding mystery to the theme of curiosity, freedom and openness. Properties | June 2016
Congratulations to Infinity Construction on the successful completion of the Tri-C Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Humanities Center. We were proud to be part of the team.
J.P.
PLUMBING & HEATING, INC. COMMERCIAL
INDUSTRIAL
INSTITUTIONAL
Plumbing Installations Industrial Piping | Medical Gas Fire Sprinkler Installation & System Testing
Now Providing Vactor Sewer Cleaning & Jetting
SERVING NORTHEAST OHIO SINCE 1928 216.831.5165 | www.jpplumbing.com www.propertiesmag.com 55
> COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE expertise. > PERSONALIZED COMMUNITY BANK service.
It’s all about collaboration, individualized service and fostering economic growth in our community. We’re committed to it. And nearly 80 years of community banking expertise supports it.
LET OUR TEA M HELP YOUR S THR I V E . Contact Rig Goss at (216) 239-5904.
The Jack, Joseph & Morton Mandel Humanities Center
IX`j`e^ pfli Ylj`e\jj kf e\n _\`^_kj% Access Floor Specialists is an authorized Tate Dealer serving the Cleveland, Akron and Columbus markets, utilizing Building Technology Platform®, Tate’s fully integrated system of Access Flooring and critical building services – Power, Voice, Data & HVAC. Building Technology Platform is a registered trademark of Tate Access Floors, Inc.
For more information, visit www.accessfloorllc.com or call 330-656-3015 56
Properties | June 2016
AROUND THE CENTER Curves are evident throughout the space, from sectional seating (top) and ideation nodes (middle), to the gray-flecked carpet tiles with a yellow curved design (bottom) that replicates the shape of the red soffit above.
“The most unusual features of this part of the project were the LED dimming linear lights that are four inches wide and up to 20 feet long,” Young says. The large format acoustical tile ceiling with independent floating clouds was also unique, he says. The goal of the design was to produce an environment of creativity, and allow instructors ultimate teaching flexibility by providing a broad range of spaces and technology, Nolde says. “Before the space was designed, instructors from all Tri-C campuses were brought in so we could study their teaching styles and arrange what would be effective spaces for active learning,” he says. The faculty also met with Steelcase to discuss how furniture can improve
“I think what is most exciting about the space is that it reflects the mission of the Center: to bring students, faculty and community members together to learn in collaboration.” Dr. Lauren Onkey Cuyahoga Community College learning. The entire design process was orchestrated in a very collaborative way, he says. Curves are evident throughout the space, from sectional seating and ideation nodes, to the gray-flecked carpet tiles with a yellow curved design that replicates the shape of the red soffit above. Ideation areas include cubelike coffee tables with USB ports, and a smooth white surface for writing notes with felt pens. Curved chairs are on casters and can be clustered into groupings around moveable tables, or pushed to the room’s perimeters to allow for presentations or activities “The space also serves as a homeaway-from-home for the scholars of www.propertiesmag.com 57
ADAPTABLE SPACES The design aims to produce an environment of creativity, allowing instructors ultimate teaching flexibility by providing a broad range of spaces and technology.
this community college during their time on campus,” Nolde says.
Encouraging the “collision of ideas” The Ideation space is technology at its best, with systems that are easy to grasp and manage. A Nureva™ Span™ classroom collaboration wall system enables students and instructors to discuss their ideas visually on a large screen and interact technologically on ideas. The room can be used for classes, seminars or presentations, and all of the furniture can be moved and clustered around the space for large or small group discussions. ClickShare systems in classrooms and the Ideation space enable instructors and students to visually hold conversations on flat screen monitors, wirelessly connecting by computer, iPad or cell phone. “I think what is most exciting about the space is that it reflects the mission
of the Center: to bring students, faculty and community members together to learn in collaboration,” says Dr. Lauren Onkey, chair and dean of the Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Humanities Center. “The open and flexible design, the use of light, and the way that the design invites people
to create small groups supports those principles. The use of light is inspiring as well. It gives the students the sense of possibility and potential. “As a field, the humanities is a record of human ideas and memory, and the space is designed to bring all of that creativity to the fore.” P
Thanks to Infinity Construction + Cuyahoga Community College
The Jack, Joseph and Morton Mandel Humanities Center
director@aiacleveland.com
Metal Studs | Drywall Acoustic Ceilings | Carpentry 26100 Broadway Ave., Oakwood Village 440-232-2626 | www.centurycontractors.net
58
Properties | June 2016
Photo courtesy of HzW Environmental Consultants, LLC
environmental solutions
Due Diligence Aquatic Resource Evaluations Do surface water features on a property bring value? Or just headaches? By Jason McKenney and Benjamin Latoche, M.S. HzW Environmental Consultants, LLC
uring the due diligence period of property acquisition, one aspect which regularly gets overlooked is the presence/absence of aquatic resources. While a stream or pond on a property may seem like an added bonus, some new property owners are not fully aware of the regulatory requirements and restrictions which come along with such features.
D
Surface water features, including streams, lakes, ponds and wetlands, are heavily protected by both the federal government and the State of Ohio. In order to encroach upon or impact these aquatic features, permits from one (state or federal) or both bodies of government are typically required. Add to this fact that these resources are not always easily identifiable and one can understand how this issue can become a hidden pitfall. Surface water features can create quite a headache for property owners and their representatives. An initial
and less costly approach to identifying whether surface water features are located on the site is to request a preliminary aquatic resource evaluation be conducted by a trained professional. While this evaluation will not demarcate wetland boundaries or stream center exactly, the results should yield enough information for determining if regulatory permitting is needed to achieve the project goals. If there is a potential that the surface water features will not or slightly impede on the development footprint, additional studies in
the form of an aquatic resource delineation (typically referred to as a wetland delineation, or simply, delineation) may be needed. Once the delineation process is initiated, potential aquatic resource areas are first sampled in the field. The methodology of sampling varies depending on what type of resource is identified, but can include taking photographs, examining soil samples, identifying vegetation species and coverage, and/or evaluating hydrological indicators. If the area in question is www.propertiesmag.com 59
deemed to be a resource, it is then marked in the field with the appropriately labeled flagging and/or stakes. These limits can then be surveyed either by a professional surveyor or by the consultant using a handheld global positioning system (GPS) device so that a representative map can be generated at a later time illustrating the locations of the aquatic features. Following the gathering of this data, it is compiled into a delineation report summarizing the consultant’s findings. The report generated by the aforementioned process can help the potential buyer provisionally determine whether or not impacts to aquatic resources will need to be incurred to reasonably use the property. It is important to note, however, that the official mapping of any present aquatic resources can only come from the United States Army Corps of
Engineers (the Corps) in the form of a Jurisdictional Determination letter (JD). Any citizen that legally has access to the property in question can petition the issuance of a JD from the Corps by submitting a written request along with a copy of the site’s delineation
consultant’s, they may request changes be made to the aquatic resource map before issuing the JD. In summary, wetlands and other waterways tend to add yet another layer to the complex process of realty. Without careful prior examination, a potential buyer could end up purchasing a property that is essentially useless. What’s more, a potential buyer’s due diligence window may not be long enough to fully initiate coordination with the Corps and receive a JD. Therefore it is imperative to retain a trustworthy and experienced consultant when purchasing any property that may potentially contain aquatic resources. P
Wetlands and other waterways tend to add yet another layer to the complex process of realty. Without careful prior examination, a potential buyer could end up purchasing a property that is essentially useless. report. However, the Corps will likely vet the submitted report in numerous ways including the review of background resources, examination of aerial imagery and/or a visit to the site. If their findings differ with those of the
Jason McKenney and Benjamin Latoche, M.S. are environmental scientists with HzW Environmental Consultants, LLC. For more information, visit www.hzwenv.com.
HZW ENVIRONMENTAL CONSULTANTS, LLC
Our goal at HzW Environmental Consultants, LLC is to provide quality environmental services to meet the varying needs of business, industry and government in today’s challenging regulatory climate. HzW provides environmental services in the following areas:
www.hzwenv.com 440.357.1260 440.357.1510 6105 Heisley Rd. Mentor, OH 44060 60
•Phase I & II Environmental Site Assessments •3 Professionals Certified under the Ohio EPA Voluntary Action Program •Environmental Compliance Audits •Wetland Delineation, Permitting & Mitigation •Safety and Industrial Hygiene, Asbestos Management •Geoprobe® Sub-Surface Sampling
AKRON ∙ CANTON ∙ MENTOR ∙ EUCLID Properties | June 2016
environmental solutions Applying ‘Lean’ to Building Performance Utilizing proven principles to achieve facility energy savings, waste reduction By Rick Kanzleiter & Ernie Kulik Lean Projects Group, LLC
reen building, renewable energy, zero waste manufacturing…. When it comes to energy savings for buildings, achieving sustainability and waste reduction, there’s an abundance of information and options for property owners and managers to consider – almost too much. There are so many energy solution providers selling various technologies, products and services that it can quickly become confusing. Yet the opportunities for cost savings can be difficult and unwise for a facility owner/manager to ignore.
G
The key is identifying which “solutions” are worth the time, effort and upfront cost and will provide real value. The best approach is to adopt a systematic method of evaluating all the available options and selecting the best one(s) for a specific facility. Consider two proven concepts: Lean Process Improvement and the Pareto Principle. Together, these tools provide a proven, effective process to identify (Lean Process Improvement) and select (Pareto Principle) the best course of action for a specific facility to lower energy costs and eliminate waste.
Lean Process Improvement Lean has been successfully used by Toyota and many other companies to improve their manufacturing processes and eliminate waste for over 50 years. This same Lean process improvement approach that is successful in manufacturing can also be applied to lower energy use and reduce required process resources (water, chemicals, materials, etc.) at your facility. The basic steps include: 1) Identify the “current state” (as is condition) of your facility – e.g. current energy infrastructure and main processes (energy, resource use and significant process waste) 2) Define an “ideal future state” of what your facility can achieve? - e.g. target energy efficiency, zero waste, cost reduction initiatives, etc. 3) Organize a diverse team to brainstorm and identify action items or
• Align your future state with strategic plan and annual targets. – e.g. 10% less energy use, LEED certification level, 10% less process water, and applicable best practices. • Most facility operations can be divided into two parts: 1) the main production process, storage, admin or service functions, and 2) the facility itself (the “box”). Each part contains many opportunities to list and evaluate. projects needed to achieve this “ideal future state.” 4) Evaluate the list of projects (“wish list”), and then prioritize the “critical few” to focus on. Some tips to consider: • First gather data to help determine which areas or processes the team should focus on.
Pareto Principle Once your team has completed the above steps, there are typically a large number of ideas to consider. Use the Pareto Principle to identify the critical few from the list of action items that will provide the most benefit for the lowest cost, required resources or other key criteria identified. The Pareto principle states that 80% of the results or benefits can be achieved
Lean Projects Group (330) 562-1156
leanprojectsgroup.com
CALL AND ASK HOW WE CAN HELP WITH YOUR NEXT PROJECT!
Use Lean Project Management to Create Your Competitive Advantage. www.propertiesmag.com 61
from completing only 20% of the items. It has proven to be an effective method that can help focus limited budget and resources on the critical few projects that achieve the best return on investment for reducing energy or resource use. Something to consider is that the best results come from limiting the number of action items or projects to
less than five. Complete these, then repeat the Lean Process Improvement / Pareto selection cycle periodically (every six months, for example). Application of this method to facility energy efficiency was first implemented by Toyota in 2001 and is often called an “Energy Treasure Hunt,” given the average amount of energy savings was
Fire Protection
➧ Sprinklers ➧ Fire Extinguishers ➧ Kitchen Hood Suppression ➧ Special Hazards Full Service ➧ Alarm & Detection Fire Protection
Mechanical
➧ Service ➧ Plumbing ➧ Heating ➧ Air Conditioning ➧ Process Piping Call
800-776-7181 62
24 / 7 Wee do it all. W all
Corporate C t Office Offi
20%. The combination of identifying action items to get from current to ideal future state (Lean Process Improvement) and then selecting the critical few projects (Pareto Principle) provides a proven approach. Tip: When looking at overall facility energy and resource use, don’t forget to include your main operations and production processes. Savings in these areas are often greater than projects to reduce facility energy use. For example, one Northeast Ohio client was able to eliminate process water use on a production line by simply changing a process step to generate an annual savings of $450,000. Cost to complete this project was less than $25,000. There is an excessive amount of information online and too many consultants trying to sell facility managers their specific solutions. This article’s intent is not to provide a “list of solutions,” but rather an overview of a proven process used by many leading companies. Every facility owner can easily apply the same approach to select the best projects to reduce their energy and resource use. At most facilities, there are extensive opportunities to find these items. Since Profit = Price – Cost, lowering cost through energy, process waste and resource cost savings can increase profit! Toyota, GE and many other companies experienced in applying this approach have demonstrated the large number of low cost energy efficiency projects possible, many adding thousands of dollars to their bottom line. The results of the above approach have provided many facilities with significant cost savings. P
2900 Newpark Drive Barberton, OH 44203 330-706-3040 800-776-7181 Fax 330-861-0937
sacomunale.com Other Locations to serve you... Atlantic City, NJ Cincinnati, OH Cleveland, OH Columbus, OH Fremont, OH Harrisburg, PA Marion, OH
Norton, OH Philadelphia, PA Phillipsburg, NJ Pittsburgh, PA Reading, PA Youngstown, OH Washington DC
Rick Kanzleiter, MS Eng, MBA and Ernie Kulik, P.E. are principals at Lean Projects Group, LLC. Lean Projects Group is an experienced team of senior industry professionals who have led teams to develop energy reduction and sustainability programs to support strategic initiatives at Fortune 200 companies. For additional information, or to discuss in further detail, contact Lean Projects Group at Barrington Town Square, Suite 318, Aurora, OH 44202; 330.562.1156, www.leanprojectsgroup.com. Properties | June 2016
environmental solutions Acknowledging Environmental Action Cleveland 2030 District’s annual challenge recognizes energy use reduction efforts By Cindy Cicigoi Cleveland 2030 District
he Cleveland 2030 District (C2030D) was founded in 2012. It is a non-profit organization that asks commercial buildings to voluntarily commit to a 50% reduction in energy and water consumption as well as CO2 emissions from commuter transportation.
The model is one of colWinner: United Way laboration between private The top performer, United and public sectors, connectWay, reduced their EUI score ing property owners and by an impressive 48.5%. managers with local and national professional partMost Improved EUI 2014 ners who can assist them in to 2015 achieving these lofty goals. The District provides perforHonorable Mention: mance reports for member Progressive Field buildings to benchmark their Third Place: United Way property and measure progHONORING EFFORTS (From left) Cindy Cicigoi (Cleveland 2030 District), Second Place: Forest City ress toward the 2030 goals. John Caputo (United Way of Greater Cleveland), Jerry Crabb (Cleveland Realty Trust Tower City C2030D also provides a Indians Progressive Field), Rex Lewers (The Albert M. Higley Co.), David number of educational ses- November (Tri-C), Jill Ziegler (Forest City Realty Trust) and Joe Paterniti Winner: Forest City Realty sions to inform owners and (NEO Chapter U.S. Green Building Council/KeyBank). Trust Post Office Plaza managers on a variety of topics. This year’s Building 2015” and “Most Improved EUI 2014 In this final category, Education Series is a collaborative effort to 2015.” again, the scores were very close. The with COSE, the City of Cleveland, the The scores were very close, in some winner, Post Office Plaza, improved by Northeast Ohio Chapter of the U.S. cases separated by just two tenths of a 8% and Terminal Tower by 7.8%, almost Green Building Council and the local percent. As measured by the Cleveland too close to call. chapters of ASHRAE and AIA. 2030 District, here are the winners of the The Cleveland 2030 District has also 2015 Green Building Challenge: So, how did these buildings achieve been partnering with the Northeast such commendable results? In the case Ohio Chapter of the U.S. Green Greatest Reduction from Baseline of United Way and Forest City’s Post Building Council on a friendly Green EUI Through 2014 Office Plaza and Terminal Tower, much Building Challenge for the last few of the reduction was due to behavioral Honorable Mention: K2M Design years. The participants in The Green changes. After Cleveland 2030 District Building Challenge are member proper- Third Place: Midtown Professional Building set a baseline for United Way, they ties of the Cleveland 2030 District. Second Place: The Albert M. Higley Co. began looking at changes they could The challenge measures reduction make with no cost or a high return on Winner: United Way in energy use intensity (EUI). EUI is a investment. Here are a few examples of calculation which includes all sources The winner, United Way, achieved a changes they implemented: of energy used, measured as kBtu/sf per reduction of 43.3% in their EUI score. year. Using an online tool, Energy Star • The HVAC system operated with no Portfolio Manager, a baseline EUI is set back during unoccupied hours. Greatest Reduction Through 2015 generated based on the characteristics They now reduce demand/operation of each building. The challenge calls Honorable Mention: Cuyahoga when the building is not occupied. for improvement in three categories, Community College including “Greatest Reduction from • The building’s steam operated at twice Baseline EUI Through 2014,” “Greatest Third Place: Midtown Professional Building the necessary pressure and consumed Reduction from Baseline EUI Through Second Place: The Albert M. Higley Co. additional energy with no benefit to www.propertiesmag.com 63
Photo courtesy of Cleveland 2030 District
T
comfort. Adjustments were made to balance pressure.
electricity usage data. The project enabled them to track data at 15-minute intervals. This allowed the operations manager to adjust the schedule of the HVAC system as well as the temperatures to better coincide with tenant occupancy schedules and comfort.
• Thermostats in different areas of the building were set to different temperatures, providing uneven heating and cooling. Thermostats were set to one temperature throughout the occupied spaces.
These are just a few
• After behavioral changes DRAWING SAVINGS Tracking real-time electricity usage data examples of how buildings were made, lighting fixtures at 15-minute intervals allows operations managers to adjust can reduce energy conwere replaced with high per- the schedule of the HVAC system as well as the temperatures to sumption with no cost and better coincide with tenant occupancy schedules and comfort.
• Historically, United Way turned the steam system on in early October and shut it down in late May. An electronic valve at the main supply line was installed. The valve is controlled
low cost projects. P
by building occupancy and outside air temperature. This resulted in a reduction in consumption of more than 20%. In the case of Forest City’s Post Office Plaza and Tower City, both buildings participated in a project to gain real-time
Are you interested in participating in this year’s Green Building Challenge or in the Cleveland 2030 District? Contact Cindy Cicigoi, executive director of the Cleveland 2030 District at cindycicigoi@2030districts.org. To become a member of the Northeast Ohio Chapter of the US Green Building Council, visit www.neogreenbuilding. org/membership.
Targeted Solutions for Environmental Issues
Regulatory permitting and compliance with federal, state, local and international environmental laws Environmental risk assessment for business, commercial and real estate transactions Environmental litigation The Cleveland 2030 District and the Northeast Ohio Chapter of the U.S. Green Building Council would like to congratulate the winners of the 2015 GREEN BUILDING CHALLENGE
For more information on Brouse McDowell’s Environmental Law practice, please contact: Meagan Moore mmoore@brouse.com
Cleveland Q Akron Q Lorain County Q www.brouse.com
600 Superior Ave. East, Suite 1600, Cleveland, Ohio 44114 Phone: 216.830.6830 Fax: 216.830.6807
64
Properties | June 2016
Graphic courtesy of Cleveland 2030 District
formance LED fixtures. This enabled them to reduce the total number of fixtures by 35% and the new fixtures disperse better light.
environmental solutions Here Comes Sunshine Considerations when allowing tenants to install PV systems on your properties By Daniel K. Wright, II, Brouse McDowell Co., LPA
n the past, property owners rarely received requests from tenants to locate solar photovoltaic systems (a “PV System”) on rooftops and other exterior areas of their properties. However, such requests are now being made with increasing frequency, and as the commercial viability of photovoltaic technology improves, landlords can expect more of these requests.
I
We offer the following tips to property owners and their tenants when considering such an arrangement.
cause glare that may annoy (or worse yet, result in claims) by neighbors.
Initial installation
Finally, the property owner may wish to specify that the electricity generated by the solar panels be used solely by the tenant to supply its own needs in the premises, and not be resold to third parties, particularly if the property owner is engaged in (or expects in the future to engage in) the generation and sale, or resale, of electricity to its tenants.
Use of electricity Before approving the installation of a PV System, property owners should protect their rights and interests in the broadest manner possible by reserving the right to review and approve detailed construction drawings and specifications and a schedule for the work. In this way, the property owner will know exactly what is going to occur, and when, and can prevent both damage to existing building improvements and systems, and interference with the operations of other tenants. More often than not, solar arrays (or “solar panels”) will be installed on a roof. The installation (as well as subsequent maintenance) must be done in such a way that it does not violate or invalidate any roof warranties. In this regard, it is always best to specify that a factory authorized roofer designated by the property owner will handle all roof penetrations. And of course, the party who owns the solar panels (in our example, the tenant) should continue to own and insure them, notwithstanding any lease provisions that purport to pass title to any equipment that is affixed to the building to the landlord.
Maintenance, repair & removal As sole owner of the PV System, the tenant should also be responsible for all maintenance, repairs and removal of the PV System, as well as repairs to the roof necessitated by damage caused by
the tenant and its contractors, including repair of roof penetrations upon removal of the equipment. And, the entire PV System should be installed, maintained, used and removed in accordance with all federal, state and local laws, ordinances, codes, rules, regulations, and requirements, including local zoning laws relative to approval of the initial installation and its aesthetic appearance, and federal and state law governing the sale and use of the electricity generated by the panels.
“View” easements & restrictions The tenant may ask for an easement or restriction that prohibits the property owner from blocking sunlight to the solar panels. The property owner should be very cautious about this, particularly if it desires to develop the area covered by the easement or restriction in the future. Such restrictions can cause serious diminution in the value of the owner’s property. Along the same lines, the property owner should take precautions to assure that the solar panels do not detract from the appearance of its property, or
Tenant concerns At the top of the list of concerns for the tenant in this situation will be that the property owner recognize it is the sole and exclusive owner of (1) all electricity generated by the solar panels, (2) all environmental rights and benefits arising from the installation, maintenance and operation of the PV System, and (3) any and all credits (including tax credits), rebates, allowances and benefits of any kind resulting from the PV System. The tenant may also wish to restrict the property owner from publishing any statements about the PV System and the environmental attributes, benefits and incentives therefrom without the tenant’s approval. Careful consideration of these issues at the outset will further a more harmonious relationship between the property owner, its tenant, adjacent tenants and adjacent owners, while facilitating the environmental benefits that PV Systems can provide. P Daniel K. Wright, II, Esq. is a partner with Brouse McDowell Co., LPA in Cleveland, Ohio. www.propertiesmag.com 65
Proudly serving Cleveland for 1 0 years Complete Pest Control Services FHA/VA/HUD Termite Inspections/Pretreatments Residential - Commercial Industrial Integrated Pest Management Programs Wild Animal/Bat Removal Pre-Construction Animal Exclusion Consulting Industrial Weed Control Sentricon™ Termite Colony Elimination System
GROVE CITY LIBRARY
WE PROVIDE CONCRETE SOLUTIONS. VMI Group, Inc. is a concrete construction contractor located in Macedonia, Ohio. Our company focuses on commercial and industrial building and site concrete work in the Akron, Cleveland and Columbus areas.
Cleveland Chemical Pest Control, Inc. Quality Pest Control Service Since 1903
18400 S. Waterloo Road Cleveland
ZZZ WKHYPLJURXS FRP LQIR#WKHYPLJURXS FRP
Free Telephone Consultation
330.405.4113
™-Trademark of Dow AgroSciences
216-481-8400
COMMERCIAL & INDUSTRIAL ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS
SERVICE Upfront Pricing • Trouble-Shoot & Repair NEW CONSTRUCTION Design/Build • Spec/Build ENERGY-SAVING UPGRADES BUILDING & PROCESS AUTOMATION Engineering • Installation ON-TIME PERFORMANCE GUARANTEED 66
15035 Berkshire Industrial Pkwy, Middlefield, OH 44062 service@jltaylorcompany.com • www.jltaylorcompany.com
440.834.1223
OH LIC #21927
Properties | June 2016
environmental solutions Project Profile: Cullen Park Green infrastructure as ecological, economic resources By Matthew Horvat and Sally Gladwell The Mannik & Smith Group
he City of Toledo’s Cullen Park is a 36-acre parcel located at the confluence of the Maumee River and the westernmost basin of Lake Erie. The park has Toledo’s only public boat ramp with direct access to Lake Erie. Although the boat-launch facility has consistently been well-used, the park’s natural areas had long been largely overlooked and neglected.
T
Photo courtesy of The Mannik & Smith Group
grant’s $300,000 award. With the grant A grant from the Ohio Department in hand, the City contracted with The of Natural Resources, Division of Mannik & Smith Group, Inc. (MSG) to Watercraft helped to renovate the public design improvements for the Cullen Park ramp in 2014, which was great for boatBest Management Practices (BMP) projers, but did little for other park visitors. ect. MSG worked closely with the City Birders, for example, travel to Cullen Park and residents to better understand their semi-annually from areas well outside varied concerns and the opportunities Northwest Ohio to observe migrating to both restore ecological services to the neo-tropical species, but had little access park and to draw visitors back to its open or reason to stay and meander amongst the park’s open naturalized areas, which OPENING ACCESS Boardwalks now allow space and unique habitat. Playing to the strengths of the existing were restricted by low quality wetlands. access throughout the park without disrupting property conditions, including its floodOvergrown vegetation on the edges of the hydrology of the surrounding wetlands. prone areas and its location in such a Cullen Park blocked the neighbors’ views of the lake and left some concerned for funding through the Great Lakes prime migratory path, MSG designed about safety, given the lack of visibility Restoration Initiative (GLRI), a federal a solution that improves water quality, into the park. Plus, flooding of residential program focused on improving the water appeals to residents, and helps the City streets that dead-ended at the park was a quality of the Great Lakes. The City’s minimize maintenance. The low quality major concern of residents. intent was to innovatively improve water wetlands were enhanced and enlarged Recognizing the need to improve this quality and transform the park. They through connectivity, removal of invaunique park property, the City applied committed a $300,000 match to the sives, and planting of native trees and
www.propertiesmag.com 67
All Things Concrete – Your Commercial & Decorative Total Concrete Solution
J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc. • Commercial Buildings • Construction Sites • Special Event Clean-Up • Concrete Cleaning • Carpet Cleaning • Window Cleaning • Wall Washing An Equal Opportunity Employer
21ST CENTURY CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION INC. 13925 Enterprise Ave., Cleveland, OH 44135
216.362.0900 www.21stcenturyconcrete.com SBE | CSB | EDGE | ODOT Certified
• Acoustical Ceilings
1230 East Schaaf Road Brooklyn Heights, OH 44131
216-749-1150 www.jvjanitorial.com
“Your Custom Architectural Metal Specialists” COMMERCIAL INDUSTRIAL INSTITUTIONAL RETAIL 330.274.3100 68
Specializing In Engineering, Fabrication & Installation Of: • Composite Metal Wall Systems • Copper & Stainless Steel Systems • Custom Fascias, Frieze Boards, Eaves • Metal Roofing (Rolled on Site!) • Flashing & Trim • Custom Gutters & Downspouts • Commercial Gutters (Rolled on Site!)
P.O. Box 827, Mantua, OH 44255
courtadinc.com Properties | June 2016
Prairie Grass & Tree Plantings
Level Spreaders
Rip Rap Outlet Protection
Preserving Existing Vegetation
Wetland Preservation
Vernal Pools
Straw Wattles
Soil Erosion Fence KEY Permanent Measures
Inlet Filters Boardwalks
Vegetated Swales
Vegetated Filter Strips
Temporary Measures
Gravel Verge
WORKING WITH THE LAND Playing to the strengths of the existing conditions at Cullen Park, including its flood-prone areas and its location in a prime migratory path, the team designed a solution that improves water quality, appeals to residents, and helps minimize maintenance.
wetland plants. The wetlands will act as vernal pools, retaining water for much of the year, and drying in late summer – a seasonal change that makes them an ideal habitat for amphibians, in particular. These pools now also accept excess stormwater runoff from the adjoining neighborhoods, alleviating flooding concerns while filtering and absorbing runoff, resulting in another benefit to Lake Erie. The stormwater discharges through an outlet into Maumee Bay at the western most point of the lake. Several times throughout the year, according to prevailing winds, a seiche (pronounced “saysh,” meaning to sway back and forth) may pull the water from western Lake Erie toward Buffalo in the east, or it can direct water into the western basin, into the Maumee River, and/or up into these vernal pools to be stored and processed by the plants and biology, helping to remove nutri-
ents. ADA-compliant walking paths now wind through the vernal pools, crossed on low boardwalks in some places so as to facilitate continuous trail access without disrupting the hydrology of the surrounding wetlands. By March 2016, a few months following construction, Western Chorus frogs, an important indicator species, were documented at the site signaling a healthy ecosystem and habitat. Among the BMPs employed at Cullen Park are: vernal pools, vegetated filters, native plantings, a gravel verge to slow and filter stormwater along the parking lot edge, level spreaders to dissipate the energy of concentrated stormwater flow, habitat restoration and bio-retention techniques to manage stormwater runoff and improve water quality. What’s more, MSG designed three interpretive signs, now installed at the park, helping to educate visitors on the importance of restoring
and maintaining ecological resources in the landscape. Green infrastructure practices are safe and proven methods of incorporating natural principles into design, while providing the necessary function to meet demands we all place on the land. Over time, the value of green infrastructure appreciates as plants mature and biological processes develop fully, unlike conventional gray infrastructure, the value of which depreciates over time. Establishment of the plantings at Cullen Park will take two to three years. In the meantime, park visitors and neighbors are already touting the dramatic transformation of this space that was for years just a diamond in the rough. P Matthew Horvat is an environmental scientist and Sally Gladwell is principal with The Mannik & Smith Group. For more information, visit www.manniksmithgroup.com. www.propertiesmag.com 69
Graphic courtesy of The Mannik & Smith Group
environmental solutions
Photos courtesy of Leff Electric
BEFORE
AFTER
ABCs of EE Retrofits Managing applications, installation & customer expectations on retrofit projects By Mark Kelly Leff Electric
n today’s world of aging infrastructure, rising maintenance issues and escalating electricity, water and gas costs, the focus on property refurbishment has never been greater. The advances in lighting, electrical gear and HVAC equipment has fueled the energy efficiency (EE) industry. Many companies are in the market to sell products which lower operational expenses and give an attractive ROI, but there is always the devil in the details. Project management is a crucial aspect to consider when choosing a partner to manage your EE project.
I
What is the process for upgrading a facility, and providing a program which significantly reduces operating expenses while enhancing growth, performance
70
and longevity? Some projects can be fairly straightforward, where a supplier works with an end user directly to upgrade the building. The other end
of the spectrum is refurbishing a large, multi-site property, or a public sector facility. In these cases, an energy services company (ESCO) or a consulting engineering firm, manufacturers reps, and distribution partner would all likely be involved. Over the past year, Leff Electric has been involved in just this sort of public sector situation, upgrading a multi-site school system. The process began with a room by room energy survey, creating the baseline documentation of the existing energy systems. Light levels and energy draw information was captured in the site survey. After the survey was completed, the Leff Energy Solutions group began the process of specifying EE prodProperties | June 2016
ARE THERE INCOME TAX DEDUCTIONS HIDING IN YOUR CLIENT’S BUILDINGS? ucts. The gymnasium was lit with metal halide high bay fixtures; this application was updated with bi-level lighting, a method that offers a “low mode” to be used day-to-day and a “high mode” to be used during competition events. Troffer fixtures (2x4) in the classrooms would be retrofitted and de-lamped. The move to employ bi-level lighting and installing lower wattage lamps plus de-lamping from three lamps to two lamps, while maintaining the required light levels as per IES standards, proved the best approach for EE and ROI standpoint in both applications. All screw in and 2/4 Pin lamps were replaced with LED products and occupancy sensors were specified. As a further measure, vending misers were recommended to limit the electrical consumption of all vending machines. A vending miser is a control device to place the machine in a low power state, switching to full power when someone is close in proximity. Working with a national ESCO, a kick-off meeting with school officials was planned to discuss timelines, walk the property, detail the process and review any implications and contingencies that might arise during the project. Waivers were signed, and any safety concerns were addressed. Leff Energy Solutions now moved into a project management function, managing product ordering, logistics and directing a local electrical contractor for installation services. Additionally, two mobile storage units were placed on the property. Installation was scheduled to occur at night. Material was coordinated to be delivered and placed within these storage units to only be accessed by the install crew. There is a saying that “projects are projects, and projects are problems.” This came true in dealing with the school system. The gymnasium was originally scheduled at a later point in the scope-of-work timeline. Then, school officials decided to pull up that timeline. This presented a significant challenge, and stress, to the project. Leff Energy Solutions pivoted and,
• Cost Segregation • Energy Efficiency Certifications ( 179D) • New IRS Repair v. Capitalization
Call Craig Miller Cleveland: 440.892.3339 Columbus: 614.949.4185 Detroit: 248.752.7433 www.costsegexperts.com
THE REGION’S LEADING INCOME TAX REDUCTION EXPERTS
We are Proud to Provide our
Leff Managed Inventory Service to the Hilton Cleveland Downtown Convention Center Hotel Contact us for a site survey for your next project.
4700 Spring Rd. Cleveland. 216.432.3000
www.leffelectric.com www.propertiesmag.com 71
Photos courtesy of Leff Electric
BEFORE
AFTER
ILLUMINATING SAVINGS In classrooms, troffer light fixtures were retrofitted and de-lamped. De-lamping from three lamps to two lamps, while maintaining the required light levels as per IES standards, proved to be a key approach for energy efficiency and return on investment.
using strong relationships, coordinated with the product manufacturers to accelerate the delivery of the new fixtures, lamps and mounting hardware. Material was coordinated to arrive in waves, as to not overcrowd the storage units but also provide the installers with material. The next challenge was the overall project completion date, for due to the holiday, the date for completion had to be moved up. In order to meet the new
requirement, coordination with product manufacturers and logistics providers increased and two additional installation crews were hired to help with retrofits and installation of sensors throughout all buildings. Installation moved from a serial process to a parallel process. Once the majority of the job was completed, school officials, the ESCO and Leff Energy Solutions walked the site and created a punch list of what was in need of adjustment or modifi-
Stop Leaks • Increase Energy Efficiency • Extend Roof Life
Don’t re-roof. Re-cover.
Turn this...
Into this...
and avoid this!
Renew and insulate weathered and leaking roofs! UP TO 20-YEAR LEAK-FREE WARRANTY
330-622-1466 www.MidwestRestorationGroup.com 72
cation. With the punch list addressed, a Substantial Completion waiver was signed for the project. Post job electrical readings and light levels were captured and compared to the base line readings, verifying wattage reduction while maintaining foot-candle standards as per IES. Projects do not have to be problems – especially if the project management team has the experience, scope, expertise and relationships in place to positively administer the changes on both customer and vendor sides. Consider the following when choosing a project management partner: They must have the technical and professional bandwidth to baseline projects, specify the correct material, own logistical control, manage on-site product inventory, oversee installation services and verify results, all while dealing with the unforeseen issues inherent to almost any project. If the firm does not possess these attributes, the detail devil can rear its ugly head. This decision can make or break any EE project. P Mark J. Kelly is executive director, National Accounts and Energy Solutions with Leff Electric, which specializes in migrating customers to new energy strategies that greatly reduces operational costs. Learn more at www.leffelectric.com. Special thanks to Mark Sabatino, of Leff Energy Solutions, for contributing to this article. Properties | June 2016
Ignoring your environmental issues won’t make them go away.
EA Group has provided environmental consulting and laboratory services to a wide range of clients for over 25 years. We’ve helped
BREATHE EASIER
hundreds of companies solve their most challenging environmental issues from assessments and analysis to project management and remediation. Stop hiding from the problem and put our team to work early to avoid environmental emergencies that can result in costly and unexpected delays. Our expert technicians are experienced in: • Asbestos and Hazardous Materials Management • Site Assessment and Remediation • Indoor Air Quality Assessment • Industrial Hygiene and Safety • Mold Remediation Management • Analytical Laboratory Support
800.875.3514 • 440.951.3514 • www.eagroupohio.com 7118 Industrial Park Boulevard • Mentor, OH 44060
CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT Updated info on important projects in the region
Project Report #: 01233 ARHAUS FURNITURE CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS & DISTRIBUTION CENTER LOCATION: 51 E. Hines Rd. Boston Heights, OH (Summit County) CATEGORY: Contracting Method: PROJECT STATUS: Construction Underway Completion Set for June Completion EST. VALUE: $43,000,000 OWNER: Arhaus Furniture Corporation Contact: Greg Teed 7700 Northfield Rd. Walton Hills, OH 44146 Phone: 440-439-7700 www.arhaus.com ARCHITECT: Davison Smith Certo Architects Contact: Jeff Certo 26031- B Center Ridge Rd. Westlake, OH 44145 Phone: 440-835-3957 www.dscarchitects.com CM: Premier Development Partners, LLC Contact: Jerry Gruszewski
5301 Grant Ave. Cleveland, OH 44125 Phone: 216-341-1200 www.premierdevelop.com DESCRIPTION: 64 acres, 1 bldg, 1 story, 786,000 sf. New office headquarters and training center - 625,000 sf warehouse completed in December 2015 - 122,500 sf offices set for June completion. Project Report #: 01304 CLEVELAND LAKEFRONT DEVELOPMENT LOCATION: Voinovich Park North of Rock Hall & Stadium Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only/ Design Build PROJECT STATUS: Preliminary Plans in Progress - Phase One A Underway - Set for July Completion - Phase One B to start 3rd or 4th Quarter 2016 - Additional project multiple phases to proceed over the next several years into 2017
Built to work. for Cleveland.
EST. VALUE: $700,000,000 DEVELOPER: Joint Venture between Cumberland Development and Trammell Crow Cumberland Development Richard Y. Pace 6801 Brecksville Rd. Independence, OH 44131 Phone: 216-583-3665 www.cumberland-development.com Trammell Crow 2100 McKinney Ave. Dallas, TX 75201 Phone: 214-863-4101 ARCHITECT: Dimit Architects LLC Contact: Scott Dimit 14414 Detroit Ave., Ste. 306 Lakewood, OH 44107-4473 Phone: 216-221-9021 CM: Gilbane Co. 950 Main Ave., Ste. 1410 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-535-3000 DESCRIPTION: 20 acres. Phased development with three sites - Phase One includes 2 bldgs, 2-story, 3,000 sf restaurant -
The Road to Cleanliness Starts Here Ê ",Ê Ê "Ê "-/Ê* , Ê , Ê -- --
UÊ-Üii« } UÊ*ÀiÃÃÕÀiÊ7>Ã } UÊ-VÀÕLL } UÊ*>Ûi i ÌÊ,i«> ÀÃ UÊ-ÌÀ « } UÊ-> Ì }
/
UÊ- ÜÊ* Ü } UÊ ÃÌÀÕVÌ Ê- Ìià UÊ*>À }Ê Ìà UÊ*>À }Ê iV à UÊ7>Ài ÕÃià UÊ-«iV > Ê Ûi ÌÃ
For over years, The Krill Co., Inc. has constructed and restored landmark buildings that make our city unique. With clients from world-class laboratory research facilities and hospitals, to college campuses and corporate headquarters, Krill has earned its reputation of being a premier contractor.
Cleveland is our home, our commitment and our pride.
- ViÊ£ ä Visit krill.com or call 216.357.4777
74
330-798-9200
ÜÜܰLÕV iÞiÃÜii« }°V
Properties | June 2016
4-story 15,000 sf multi-use bldg w/ retail - restaurants - apartments - 6-8 units. Additional phases to include: 800 apartments - new parking area - 50,000 sf retail - school - boutique - restaurants. Project Report #: 01260 ONE UNIVERSITY CIRCLE - APARTMENTS LOCATION: 10730 Euclid Ave. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Residential CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Work underway June 2016 - Potential October 2017 phased completion. EST. VALUE: $115,000,000 OWNER: First Interstate Properties Contact: Mitchell Schneider 25333 Cedar Rd. Lyndhurst, OH 44124 Phone: (216) 381-2900 ARCHITECT: Dimit Architects LLC Contact: Scott Dimit 14414 Detroit Ave., Ste. 306 Lakewood, OH 44107 Phone: 216-221-9021 www.dimitarchitects.com CM: Panzica Construction Contact: Mark Panzica 739 Beta Dr. Cleveland, OH 44143 Phone: 440-442-4300 www.panzica.com DESCRIPTION: 1.3 acres, 1 bldg, 20 stories, 530,033 sf. 280 units ranging in size from 720-4,200 sf penthouse - fitness center with private training rooms - indoor - outdoor pool facility - common area green rooftop for community gathering - outdoor kitchen - entertainment gaming room - lounges - business center - cafe bistro - 4-story parking garage - 16-story residences, 12 penthouses.
Landscaping Contracts – with Extraordinary Color Plans Planting, Design & Installation • Irrigation Installation & Repair Routine Ro outtine ti PProperty roperty ope pe y Ins Inspect Inspection sspec pection pec tion io & Maint Maintena Maintenance a tenaa ccee
T HHNTIFJTGFIK GGNTFGMTEMMI '48+0) .. 1( *+1
Project Report #: 01353 METRO HEALTH SYSTEMS CRITICAL CARE CENTER VERTICAL ADDITION LOCATION: Metro Health Center Dr. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: Addition CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STATUS: Work Nearing Completion- June Opening EST. VALUE: $80,,000,000-$82,000,000 OWNER: Cleveland Metro Health Systems Contact: Walter Jones & Rick Mayer 2500 Metro Health Dr. Cleveland, OH 44109 Phone: 216-778-2705 www.metrohealth.org ARCHITECT OF RECORD: CBLH Design Inc. 7850 Freeway Circle, #101 www.propertiesmag.com 75
Commercial & Residential Service for 30+ Years
Cleveland, OH 44130-6317 Phone: 440-243-2000 www.cblhdesign.com DESIGN ARCHITECT: CannonDesign 225 N. Michigan Ave., #1100 Chicago, IL 60601 Phone: 312-332-9600 www.cannondesign.com CM: Gilbane Company 950 Main Ave., Ste. 1410 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-535-3000 www.gilbaneco.com DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 2 stories, 100,000 sf. Two-story addition to include 88 beds and a landing pad for Metro Health’s life flight. Project Report #: 01390 THEATRE LOBBY RENOVATION/ RESTORATION LOCATION: Playhouse Square - Euclid Ave. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: Renovation CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Project Completed EST. VALUE: $5,300,000 OWNER: Playhouse Square Foundation Contact: Tom Einhouse 1501 Euclid Ave. Cleveland, OH 44115 Phone: 216-771-4444 www.playhousesquare.com ARCHITECT: A joint venture between Westlake Reed Leskosky and Evergreen Architectural Arts Westlake Reed Leskosky 1422 Euclid Ave. Cleveland, OH 44115 Phone: 216-522-1350 Evergreen Architectural Arts 450 W. 31st St. New York, NY 10001 Phone: 212-244-2800 CM: A joint venture between Turner Construction and The Coniglio Company Turner Construction 1422 Euclid Ave. Cleveland, OH 44115 Phone: 216-522-1180 The Coniglio Co. 4400 Commerce Ave. Cleveland, OH 44103 Phone: 216-391-1800 DESCRIPTION: Renovations to 11,600 sf lobby and mezzanine - interior trades restoring lobby to 1920s appearance - plastering, painting - wall coverings - interior restoration - renovation of lower level restrooms. OHIO
LIMITED APPLICATION ELEVATOR • VERTICAL WHEELCHAIR LIFTS • PLATFORM LIFTS INCLINED PLATFORM LIFTS • GARAVENTA HOME ELEVATORS • ACORN STAIRLIFTS
Burning River Lifts and Elevators, LLC Hiram, OH • 877-372-6835 • www.brlifts.com
Project Report #: 01498 HARBOR WOODS LIVING AT BRUNSWICK LOCATION: 4241 Center Rd. 76
Properties | June 2016
Brunswick, OH (Medina County) www.harborwoodsliving.com PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Residential PROJECT STATUS: Broke ground November 2015 – Scheduled to be complete Fall 2016 EST. VALUE: Over $10 million ARCHITECT: Braun & Steidl Architects Inc. 1041 W. Market St. Akron, OH 44313 Phone: 330-864-7755 www.bas-net.com DESCRIPTION: Age 55+ housing community - 127 one & two bedroom units - fitness room - beauty salon - private patio - community room - games rooms - library.
Phone: 216-861-2030 www.signatureflight.com ARCHITECT: Rivers & Christian Contact: Chad Nielsen 11661 San Vincente Blvd., #1001 Los Angeles, CA 90049 Phone: 310-826-8381 BUILDER: Turner Construction Contact: Jeff Poore & Domonic Deluca 1422 Euclid Ave., 14th Floor Cleveland, OH 44115 Phone: 216-522-1180 www.tcco.com DESCRIPTION: 4 acres, 1 bldg, 1 & 2 stories, 23,975 sf. One-story building with a two-story
canopied entrance - 18,000 sf hangar - 8,000 sf for terminal operations - passenger waiting area - car rental - offices - 52 parking spaces.
Project Report #: 01528 SIGNATURE FLIGHT TERMINAL LOCATION: Burke Lakefront Airport Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) www.signatureflight.com PROJECT TYPE: Renovation/Addition CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Work Underway - Potential June/ July Completion EST. VALUE: $6,000,000 OWNER: Signature Flight Support Contact: Jim Price 1601 N. Marginal Rd. Cleveland, OH 44114
1( 2KLR·V (OHFWULFDO 6HUYLFH 0DLQWHQDQFH 6ROXWLRQV 6SHFLDOLVWV
Information included in Construction Progress Report has been produced, processed and/or verified through sources believed to be reliable. Properties Magazine makes no warranty of any kind for this information, express or implied, and is not responsible for any omissions or inaccuracies. To contribute project data or to notify Properties of any reporting errors, we encourage you to email cpr@propertiesmag.com.
&/(9(/$1'
6LQFH 7URXEOH 6KRRWLQJ ([SHUWV 6XUJH 3URWHFWRUV /LJKWLQJ 5HWURILWV &RQVXOWDWLRQV /,9( 'LVSDWFKHU 2Q &DOO
$.521
,Q +RXVH IW %XFNHW 7UXFN (PHUJHQF\ +RXU 5HVSRQVH 9 /DQGVFDSH² 9 6\VWHPV 758( 52, /LJKWLQJ $QDO\VLV
ZZZ $&(OHFWULF2+,2 FRP
>ŝĐĞŶƐĞ EŽ͘ >ͲϮϰϭϲϭ
www.propertiesmag.com 77
Coming in July Hilton Cleveland Downtown Hattie’s Food Hub The Hotel at Oberlin CRS & AIA Cleveland Annual Preservation Awards Interior Design & Construction Special Section ...and more Interested in advertising? Call Properties today and an account representative can help you www.propertiesmag.com address your advertising needs: Visit us online for archived fea-
ture articles, advertising rates, 216.251.0035 / 888.641.4241 specs and subscription information.
www.propertiesmag.com
Visit us online today to download archived issues featuring live hypertext links to advertisers’ websites! 78
ADVERTISER INDEX 21st Century Concrete Construction, Inc. .....68 Absolute Roofing Inc...............................................38 AC Electric & General Contracting, LTD .........77 Access Floor Specialists ..........................................56 Adrian Maldonado & Associates ......................26 AIA Cleveland ..............................................................58 ALL Construction Services ....................................49 American International Construction............. 15 ARC Document Solutions ........................................3 Artography Studios ..................................................23 Berea Moving, Co. .....................................................16 Bialosky Cleveland ....................................................32 BOMA Greater Cleveland ......................................44 Brennan & Associates ..............................................34 Brilliant Electric Sign Co..........................................33 Brouse McDowell ......................................................64 Bruder Building Materials, Inc.............................46 Buckeye Sweeping, Inc........................................... 74 Buckingham Doolittle & Burroughs ................ 13 Burning River Lifts & Elevators, LLC..................76 Carey Roofing..............................................................43 CBRE, Inc. .......................................................................25 Century Contractors, Inc........................................58 Chagrin Valley Steel Erectors...............................52 Charles Schulz Building Company ...................70 Chas. E Phipps Company, The ...........................30 Cleveland 2030 District...........................................64 Cleveland Chemical Pest Control, Inc. ............66 Cleveland Engineering Society ..........................37 Cleveland Marble Mosaic Co. ..............................28 Cleveland Public Power ............................................7 Columbia Building Products ...............................26 Commercial Roofing & Coating Systems, Inc..............................................................79 Compass Insulation & Coatings .........................26 County Fire Protection Inc....................................39 Courtad Construction Systems. Inc. ................68 Cunningham Paving Inc. .......................................42 Diamond Roofing Systems .....................................4 Duffy & Duffy Cost Segregation Services.....71 EA Group........................................................................73 Educational Equipment .........................................40 EM Construction Co./Beacon Marshall Companies ............................................................... 13 Excelsior Marking ...................................................... 15 First Federal Of Lakewood....................................56 Fleischman, Richard + Partners, Inc................53 Frantz Ward LLP .........................................................36 GM Equity Development, LLC ............................44 Grout Systems, Inc. ...................................................45 Halper Lighting Solutions .....................................20 High Tech Pools Inc. .................................................22 HMH Restoration Ltd...............................................34 HWH Architects Engineers Planners Inc........30
HZW Environmental Consultants, Inc.............60 Icon Interiors ................................................................ 41 Infinity Construction................................................50 J Norman Stark, LPA .................................................33 J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc......................................68 Jamieson Ricca Fenestration ...............................75 JL Taylor, Co. Inc..........................................................66 John G. Johnson Construction Co....................39 JP Plumbing & Heating, Inc..................................55 Kevin Reeves Photographer ................................50 Krill Company, Inc...................................................... 74 Lakeland Electric, Co................................................24 Lean Projects Group ................................................61 Leff Electric ...................................................................71 Lisco Heating & Cooling, Inc. ...............................49 Maguire Photographics .........................................77 Mannik & Smith Group ...........................................67 Mason Structural Steel, Inc................................... 14 Masonry Restoration Maintenance..................76 Messina Floor Covering, Inc. ................................53 Midwest Restoration Group ................................72 Minority Electric .........................................................35 Nelson Contracting ..................................................75 North Coast Paving ..................................................47 Northern Ohio Plumbing, Co. .............................26 Ohio Desk/Integrated Interiors Group...........56 Pease Photography ..................................................49 Perfect Power Wash ....................................................9 Performance Painting .............................................21 Pete & Pete Container Service ............................29 Precision Environmental Co.................................20 Ronyak Paving............................................................. 12 Royalton Supply Landscape Center ................48 RW Clark .........................................................................24 S.A. Comunale Company ......................................62 Schill Grounds Management .................................7 Schirmer Construction LLC ..................................30 Siegel Jennings ..........................................................10 Simplified Facilities Group ....................................16 Skoda Minotti Company...........................................2 Snow Brothers Appliance, Inc............................. 17 Space Comfort Co. .................................................... 13 Suncrest Gardens ...................................................... 15 Suntrol Co......................................................................54 Timbers-Kovar/Commercial Dock & Door............................................................................6 Tri-County Electric.....................................................53 Tru Form Metal Products.......................................16 Ulmer & Berne LLP ....................................................18 Unilock Ohio ................................................................80 VMI Group, The...........................................................66 Warren Roofing & Insulating Co. .......................23 Wilson Shaw Skylights ............................................24 Wurz Company, The R.L.........................................44
Properties | June 2016
Cover Your Investments With Confidence
Count on Commercial Roofing and Coating Systems, Inc. to get on top of your roofing project – no matter the size. We specialize in roofing repairs, replacements and maintenance for Commercial, Industrial and Residential clients throughout Northeast Ohio. Our main focus? Providing efficient and cost-effective service. Our full line of services includes: Roofing Maintenance | Inspections & Reporting Infrared Leak Detection & Reporting | Low Slope Roofing Single-Ply Membrane Roof Systems | TPO, PVC, EPDM, Modified Asphalt Sheet Metal & Custom Flashings | ACM Composite Panels | Coatings Insulation | Tapered Insulation, Tapered Roofing | Metal-Retrofit Systems Daylighting | Solar Roof Systems | New Construction & Roof Replacement
Contact us today at 330-207-3879 to handle all of your roofing needs! Mailing Address: P.O. Box 73, Garrettsville, OH 44231 | Physical Address: 10025 SR-82, Windham, OH 44288 brandon@ohiocommercialroofing.com | www.ohiocommercialroofing.com
THE POSSIBILITIES ARE ENDLESS.
Our team has been trusted for over 40 years to provide technical expertise and project support in the exploration of segmental paving product options. Optimizing color, finish, texture and size, we have what it takes to bring your vision to life.
PROJECT: MOCA & Uptown Alleyway, Cleveland, OH DESIGN:
James Corner Field Operations / McKnight & Associates / Riverstone Company
PRODUCT: Promenade™ Plank Paver with Series 3000® finish - Permeable installation
Contact your Unilock Representative for samples, product information and to arrange a Lunch & Learn for your team.
UNILOCK.COM 1-800-UNILOCK