7 4 0
DECADES GENERATIONS COMPROMISES
Since 1947
Mike Hicks President For over seven decades we’ve earned the reputation of being more than just roofers. Our four generations carry the tradition of partnering with our customers, who trust us to provide the right product, at the right price, installed with integrity to last for decades. Contact Hicks Roofing to get the maximum life out of your top-level investment with zero compromises.
www.HicksRoofing.com • 800-750-4425
Call to setup your free consultation today!
Walmart 200,800 Sq Ft | 2014
Wooster City Schools Custom Color Membrane Simulate Metal
Buehler’s Grocery Store 84,800 Sq Ft | 2016
15,700 Sq Ft | 2017
hicks_ad.indd 1
7/25/19 1:38 PM
Have occupied space? Need flooring solutions? Talk to the occupied space solutions providers.
BEFORE: Carpet & Workstations
BEFORE: Carpet
AFTER: New Carpet
Specialists in Corporate, Healthcare & Industrial Occupied Office Space for 35 Years ► Single-source accountability ► No downtime to end-user/client ► Reduced timelines & costs/fees
AFOC is recognized as the experts in occupied space change-outs. With in-house labor for both floor covering & furniture relocation, we provide single-source expertise coupled with our moving division, Business-on-the-Move.
For further info on occupied spaces, visit www.afocfloors.com.
Architectural Floors of Cleveland
COMMERCIAL FLOORING SOLUTIONS PROVIDER 18200 Brookpark Road, Cleveland, Ohio 44135 216-898-1550 / www.afocfloors.com / afoc@afocfloors.com 1:38 PM
PROPERTY TAX S SA AVINGS AVINGS
WE KNOW HOW TO GET RESULTS BECAUSE WE KNOW PROPERTY TAX LAW. We are the property tax law firm. It’s all we do, with more than 40 years of experience and billions in assessment reductions nationwide. Contact Kieran Jennings and the team at Siegel Jennings for a no-fee, no-risk review of your portfolio.
216-763-1004 • siegeltax.com
SIEGEL BOLD JENNINGS RESULTS P R O P E R T Y TA X L AW
Cleveland
• Chicago • Columbus • Pittsburgh
ore t
January 2020, Volume 74, Number 1
Phone: 216.251.0035 Toll Free: 888.641.4241 Fax: 216.251.0064 www.propertiesmag.com CLEVELAND 3826 W. 158th St. Cleveland, Ohio 44111 AKRON P.O. Box 9 Munroe Falls, Ohio 44262 OWNER/PUBLISHER Kenneth C. Krych kkrych@propertiesmag.com 216.251.0035
CONTRIBUTING WRITERS Doug Bardwell, Eric Eakin, Scott Esterly, Ian Frank, Christopher Johnston, Lou Kren, Matt Lehnert, Alec Pacella, Diane DiPiero Rodio, Carlo Wolff, David Woodburn MEDIA CONSULTANTS Matt Lehnert mlehnert@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6753 Larry Overbey loverbey@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6649 OFFICE MANAGER Lisa Larissey 216.251.8506 Cover photo: Cuyahoga Community College Metro Campus Center, by Christian Phillips
Photo by Todd Biss
MANAGING EDITOR/ART DIRECTOR Mark Watt mwatt@propertiesmag.com 216.251.2655
11 Prized Designs
AIA Cleveland honors architectural achievements with annual awards
19 Opening Doors to Opportunity
An overview of resources available to minority entrepreneurs in Northeast Ohio
20 Lake Local Schools Lands New Look $34.6 million renovation & addition re-imagines middle/high school in Uniontown 25 Nature + Nurture Girl Scouts of North East Ohio invests in future with new Chickadee Program Center 38 Fresh Face for Surgery Practice
Innovations abound at specialty oral, maxillofacial health facility in Mentor
45 2019/2020 Financial Review & Forecast 46 Where We Are + Where We’re Going: CBRE offers an overview of Northeast Ohio commercial real estate 2019/2020 56 National Construction Outlook 2020: Dodge Data & Analytics sees U.S. economy, construction market at ‘tipping point’ 58 Financial Strategies: Gone But Not Forgotten 62 Vantage Point: Depreciation – The Easiest Deduction to Control
o.
gh
FEATURES
Properties (ISSN 033-1287) is published monthly for architects, engineers, building owners and managers, general contractors, home builders, mortgage bankers, savings and loans, real estate agents, appraisers, servicers and suppliers in Northern Ohio by Properties, Inc., 3826 W. 158th St., Cleveland, Ohio 44111. Copyright © 2020 by Properties, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction or use, without written permission, of editorial or pictorial content is strictly prohibited. Periodicals postage paid in Cleveland, Ohio and additional offices. Subscription rates: one year $30, single copy $9, back issues $12 when available. Postmaster: send change of address notices to Properties, P.O. Box 112127, Cleveland, Ohio 44111.
DEPARTMENTS 8 32 34 58 62 66
PROPERTIES PEOPLE NAIOP NEWS BILLBOARD FINANCIAL STRATEGIES VANTAGE POINT CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT www.propertiesmag.com 5
PUBLISHER’S NOTE January 2020
Look Back + Look Forward
H
appy 2020 to all as we turn the page toward a new year – and a new decade. Each January we publish our annual Financial Review & Forecast special section, in which we collect the latest insights on real estate trends and issues of the past 12 months with projections for the coming year.
KEN KRYCH
This decades-long tradition continues this month with a collection of relevant and insightful articles, including CBRE’s annual forecast/review and Dodge Data & Analytics’ national construction outlook for 2020. Regular contributor Alec Pacella, president of NAI Pleasant Valley, offers his thoughts on the state of Northeast Ohio’s commercial real estate market in this month’s Financial Strategies column. Lastly, we thank Craig Miller, president of Duffy + Duffy Cost Segregation Services, Inc., for his
article on depreciation and how it’s the easiest tax deduction item to control. Ohio’s Center For Oral, Facial & Implant Surgery Our diverse coverage this month features a new innovative medical clinic in Mentor. It’s a combination of renovating the original center and constructing a new Tudor-style and modern farmhouse style facility behind the original building. Great thought and detail went into the design pertaining to comfort and
christian phillips photography architectural interiors landscape info @ c-p-photo.com christianphillipsphoto.com 617.990.4587 OH/NY/MA will travel Associate AIA Member rialto theater/mitchell’s ice cream headquarters by dimit architects
...see the difference a trained architect can make looking through the lens!
6
Properties | January 2020
ambiance for patients, coupled with state-of-art technology.
StRuctuRal Steel FabRicatORS & eRectORS SiNce 1958
Lake Middle/High School A recent $34.6 million renovation and addition for Lake Local Schools has provided the district with an upgraded middle/high school. The facility serves approximately 1,900 students – grades seven through 12. Located in Uniontown, the school’s campus also features the Stark County Library, Mercy Medical Center, Lake YMCA and district administration offices.
Mason Steel
Chickadee Program Center Situated in Peninsula along the border of Cuyahoga Valley National Park, the Girl Scouts of North East Ohio’s Camp Ledgewood has been upgraded with numerous projects over the past decade. Its newest addition is Chickadee Program Center, which provides the scouts with flexible space for training, special events and gatherings. AIA Cleveland Design Awards Also this month, we are proud to present you with a comprehensive overview of the AIA Cleveland Design Awards, with details on all of the winning projects. The annual awards program honors excellence in design among Northeast Ohio firms. Coming in February Looking ahead to next month, our February issue will feature our annual Legal Services and Risk Management special section featuring contributions from experts in the field from throughout the region. We will also be providing an inside look at the new Lorraine and Bill Dodero Center for Performing Arts at Gilmour Academy in Gates Mills, The Statler Cleveland and more. Until then, enjoy this issue as we continue to promote building progress in Northeast Ohio. Contact us today to find out how you can become a part of it all and make a difference. Positively,
www.masonsteel.com
Contact Mike Smith for a Proposal:
(440) 439-1040 | (800) 686-1223 7500 Northfield Rd. | Walton Hills, OH 44146 www.masonsteel.com Other Fine Products Available: | Stone Pavers | Fireplaces | Windows | Doors
Restoration Contractors
440.243.5535 BEREA, OHIO
FACADE RESTORATION BALCONY RESTORATION BUILDING CLEANING CAULKING & SEALANTS COATING SYSTEMS GARAGE RESTORATION HISTORIC PRESERVATION MASONRY RESTORATION STONE RESTORATION WATERPROOFING
www.aiconstruction.com
Contractors with a passion for people and community. Defining the Skyline since 1968
Kenneth C. Krych Owner/Publisher
TOLEDO | CLEVELAND | COLUMBUS
ocpcoc.com
www.propertiesmag.com 7
PROPERTIES PEOPLE Highlighting notable industry events
1
2
3
4
5
76th Annual HBA Banquet 2
The Home Builders Association of Greater Cleveland held its 76th annual installation banquet recently at the 7-UP City Club at FirstEnergy Stadium in Cleveland. The event combined an awards ceremony, dinner and installation of officers for 2020, while raising funds for the Make-A-Wish Foundation and HBA’s Charitable & Education Foundation. P
6
7
1 Tessa and Josh Edgell (JEMM Construction) 2 Al Scott and Jason Scott (North Star Premium Custom Homes) 3 Ted Otero (Otero Signature Homes) and Ryan Puzzitiello (Parkview Homes) 4 Mike Wirica and Jason Ohlsson (Gilbane Building Company) 5 George Goudreau (Goudreau Companies) 6 Mark Maltry and Josh Edgell (JEMM Construction LLC) 7 Lara and Dean Tompkins (Payne & Payne Renovations & Design)
3 1 Dawn Mayes (Burton Bell Carr Development Inc.), Susie Chaplin (Redwood Living Inc.), Sylest Lofton (Moxx Creative) and Alethea Ganaway (Cuyahoga Community College) 2 Glen Shumate (CEA), Cynthia Leitson (Cuyahoga Community College) and Goren Dillard (Urban League) 3 Stanley Miller, Angela Jones (NEORSD) and Ramona Lower (City of Cleveland Water Pollution Control)
1
2
3
MACE Holiday Reception Approximately 100 members and guests of CAA (Contractors Assistance Association), NOMA (National Organization of Minority Architects) and NSBE (National Society of Black Engineers) gathered at Oswald Centre in Cleveland recently for the fourth annual MACE (Minorities in Architecture, Construction and Engineering) Holiday Party. Among information shared were reports of the continued growth of the ACE Mentor program and news that with the help of CEA and labor leaders, more than 1,100 new individuals were trained and put to work locally in the industry this year. P 8
4
NAIOP Annual Meeting Recently, NAIOP Northern Ohio held its annual election and installation of 2020 officers at the offices of Van Auken Akins Architects (VAA) in the Hanna Building in downtown Cleveland. The combined annual meeting and holiday party included a tour of VAA’s headquarters, networking and refreshments. P
5 1 Michael Panzica (Hemingway Development) and Ryan Moore (Marcus & Millichap/2020 president) 2 Dennis Check (Hasenstab Architects) and Chris Dewey (Van Auken Akins Architects LLC) 3 Tom West (Cresco) and Jill Van Auken Akins (Van Auken Akins Architects LLC) 4 Tim Panzica (IQ Advisors), Michael Panzica (Hemingway Development) and Mark Panzica (Panzica Construction) 5 NAIOP past presidents: Tom West (Cresco), Tim Panzica (IQ Advisors), Michael Panzica (Hemingway Development), Robert Weeks (Topline Partners, LLC.), Mark Panzica (Panzica Construction), Dave Robar (Vocon), Craig Miller (Duffy + Duffy Cost Segregation Services) and Mike Sikora (Sikora Law LLC)
Properties | January 2020
Photos by DM Harris Photography
1
2
1
3 1
4
AIA Cleveland Design Awards Recently, the Cleveland chapter of American Institute of Architects (AIA Cleveland) hosted its annual awards program at Hilton Cleveland Downtown. The event recognizes excellence in design by Northeast Ohio architecture and interior design firms. More than 500 members and guests enjoyed a celebratory dinner and a keynote speech by awards jury chair Lawrence Scarpa, FAIA (Brooks + Scarpa), followed by the awards presentation ceremony. (See full story, pg. 11.) P
5
6
1 Patty Lampert (AIA Cleveland) and Donald Lampert (Calfee) 2 Chris Toddy (Christopher @ Architects, LLC) and Adam Rosekelly (The Architecture Office, LLC) 3 Amy Todd (Bostwick Design Partnership), Lawrence Scarpa, Richard Ortmeyer (Bostwick Design Partnership) and Chris Toddy (Christopher @ Architects LLC) 4 Jack Bialosky Jr. (Bialosky Cleveland), Aaron Hill (Bialosky Cleveland) and Lawrence Scarpa (Brooks + Scarpa) 5 Robert A. Weeks (Topline Partners, LLC), Steven Kordalski (Kordalski Gatta Architects) and Craig Miller (Duffy + Duffy Cost Segregation Services, Inc.) 6 Paul Westlake (DLR Group) and Lawrence Scarpa (Brooks + Scarpa)
2 1 John Wagner, Alex Pesta and August Fluker (City Architecture) 2 Brian David, Christopher Bednar (Karpinski Engineering) and Benny Chew (City Architecture)
City Architecture Open House Recently, City Architecture celebrated its 30th anniversary with a party at its new headquarters (3200 Euclid Ave., Cleveland). Friends and colleagues enjoyed refreshments and tours of the firm’s offices. P
www.propertiesmag.com 9
For paving projects large or small...
CALL ON CARRON
Complete Paving Services • Site Analysis and Planning • Excavation and Grading • Storm Water Retention • Storm Drainage • Soil Stabilization
• Concrete Walks and Curbs • Milling • Asphalt Paving • Marking, Signs & Lighting • Maintenance Programs
director@aiacleveland.com
440-439-6464
www.carronasphalt.com carronsales@carronasphalt.com Licensed, bonded and insured • ODOT approved
By every measure, 2019 was the most successful year in our company’s history. We extend genuine thanks to our valued clients, and trusted architects, engineers, subcontractors, vendors and suppliers.
Cleveland 216-663-3777 Toledo 419-865-7100 www.infinityconstruction.com
10
Properties | January 2020
Prized Designs
AIA Cleveland honors architectural achievements with annual awards Provided by AIA Cleveland
E
This year’s keynote speaker and awards jury chair was Lawrence Scarpa, FAIA from the internationally renowned design firm Brooks + Scarpa. Scarpa and his firm have been recognized with over 100 major design awards including 20 National AIA Awards, and the 2014 Smithsonian Cooper Hewitt National Design Award. In 2010, Brooks + Scarpa was awarded both the National and State of California Architecture Firm Award from AIA National. There were six categories in this year’s program, including Architecture (39 total project entries), Interior Architecture (13 entries), Small Projects (10 entries), Unbuilt Projects (eight entries), Student Projects (10 entries) and Makers (four entries). The Architecture category celebrates the best contemporary architecture regardless of budget, size, style or type, while the Interior Architecture category celebrates innovative and spectacular interior spaces. The Small Projects category recognizes high quality projects less than 5,000 square feet. The Unbuilt Projects category focuses on projects that are not expected to be constructed, but which demonstrate excellence in research and design theory and performance. Student design work is highlighted by the Student Projects category. Lastly, the Makers category recognizes unique materials, details or technologies in which the expression of architecture and the craft of making come together.
ARCHITECTURE Honor Award
University Arts Building
DLR Group | Westlake Reed Leskosky Owner: University of Nevada, Reno (Reno, NV) Size: 42,500 sf / Cost: $32.97 million
Photo of Mott Branch Library by Scott Pease; University Arts Building by Scott Frances
ach year, the Cleveland chapter of American Institute of Architects (AIA Cleveland) recognizes excellence in design by inviting Northeast Ohio firms to submit their best work to be reviewed by nationally renowned juries from all over the country. This year’s Design Awards ceremony was held at the Hilton Downtown Cleveland, where approximately 525 attendees gathered to celebrate and recognize architectural and design excellence.
WINNING WORK Bostwick Design Partnership received an Honor Award for its design of the Toledo Lucas County Public Library Mott Branch.
greeted by a multi-tiered lobby, connecting to the plaza, street and bridge levels and serving as a hub and showcase for performance, display and learning.
Honor Award
Toledo Lucas County Public Library Mott Branch Bostwick Design Partnership
University Arts Building
The energy-efficient 42,500-squarefoot arts building emerges as the epicenter for the School of the Arts at the University of Nevado, Reno, opening the way for enhanced musical and visual arts. The three-story facility features a 287-seat recital hall, museum, fabrication lab, electroacoustic composition lab, soundproof rehearsal spaces, music practice rooms, faculty office spaces and a recording studio. Combining these spaces into a single building creates opportunities for learning, collaboration and partnerships. Upon entering the University Arts Building, visitors are
Owner: Toledo Lucas County Public Library (Toledo, OH) Size: 18,950 sf / Cost: $8.95 million The Mott Branch Library located in Toledo’s Smith Park is a 21st century library and community gathering space defined by a bold undulating roof that is shaped by two influences. First, the branch namesake Anna Mott, daughter of Toledo abolitionists, inspired geometries found in Underground Railroad quilts. Also, the park site deserved a design that enhanced and respected the landscape and adjacent grove of trees. The quilt and tree canopy references combined to form a signature identity, revitalizing the Mott namesake and honoring the park www.propertiesmag.com 11
All photos on this page by Kevin Reeves
Register Now!
Eric Baker Nord Performing Arts Annex
setting. The design helps redefine this neighborhood’s identity, literally and metaphorically supporting the community’s journey towards a better future.
Honor Award
Eric Baker Nord Performing Arts Annex
68th Annual Design & Construction Conference & Tradeshow "Sustaining the Region Through Design, Engineering and Construction" FRI., MARCH 27, 2020 8:00 A.M. – 4:00 P.M. LaCentre Conference & Banquet Center Westlake, OH
Engineers Earn Up to 5 CPD hours! Register by January 31 for early bird discounts. www.cesnet.org/events MAGAZINE INC.
is a proud media sponsor of the Cleveland Engineering Society 12
DLR Group | Westlake Reed Leskosky Owner: Oberlin College (Oberlin, OH) Size: 24,000 sf / Cost: $10.6 million
The Eric Baker Nord Performing Arts Annex – a new 300-seat adaptable theater addition to the 550-seat Harrison & Abramovitz-designed 1953 Hall Auditorium at Oberlin College – provides new performance opportunities for faculty and students, while complementing the landmark structure and establishing continuity between new and old venues. The Annex is set back from the street façade of the Hall Auditorium, inviting the landscape to penetrate deeper into the block. This setback maintains the prominence of Hall Auditorium on the square and reinforces the rhythm of building and landscape zones established in the original master plan by Cass Gilbert.
Merit Award
Massillon Museum
institution in Massillon. An addition provides a new home for the Paul Brown and Massillon Tiger Football Gallery and Archive, office spaces, a flexible community event space and additional classroom spaces. Renovations of the existing museum building allowed for the creation of gallery space for regional artists, general gallery space, ceramic studios and support areas.
Massillon Museum Expansion + Renovations
Tri-C Metro Campus Center
Owner: Massillon Museum (Massillon, OH) Size: 20,000 sf / Cost: $4.5 million
Metro Campus Center
DLR Group | Westlake Reed Leskosky
The newly expanded and renovated Massillon Museum provides new opportunities for patrons and staff, as well as new modern vitality to a community
Merit Award
Bialosky Cleveland
Owner: Cuyahoga Community College (Cleveland, OH) Size: 106,900 sf / Cost: $29 million Once an impermeable fortress set in a sunken court, Campus Center was Properties | January 2020
Ohio Desk Wishes to Congratulate the Winners of the 2019 AIA Cleveland Design Awards!
www.ohiodesk.com | Akron Cleveland Erie Warren Youngstown
Photo by Bob Perzel
the most disengaged building on the urban campus of Cuyahoga Community College (Tri-C) in Cleveland. Discarding a brutalist identity, it becomes the central heart of the campus and community – and brings truth to the name Campus Center. The design strategy: to connect and activate. Shedding its heavy masonry skin, the building form is softened, transparent and organic. Like a chameleon, the skin assumes and reflects its surroundings – buildings, clouds, dusk and flora. (See full feature story in Properties, October 2019, available at www.propertiesmag.com.)
King Road Branch Library
Merit Award
King Road Branch Library HBM Architects
Owner: Toledo-Lucas County Public Library (Toledo, OH) Size: 22,240 sf / Cost: $6.7 million The new King Road Branch Library in Toledo is a unique interpretation of a modern library. The materials collection is housed in a connected wing, allowing the monumental main space to feature new and popular materials in a bright display of merchandising and open reading and meeting areas. Reflected in both plan and elevation, large expanses of glass and white metal panels have been articulated to mimic the motion of flipping through the pages of a book. The interior of the building has tonal and textural variations similar to a natural landscape, evoking imagery like pebbles near a creek and bark on a tree.
Merit Award
Cleveland Public Library Facilities Master Plan
King Road Branch Toledo Lucas County Public Library Design Award Winner
LEADING THE WAY IN LIBRARY PLANNING AND DESIGN SINCE 1976 216.241.1100 | HBMarchitects.com
Bialosky Cleveland
Owner: Cleveland Public Library (Cleveland, OH) Reflecting on its 150-year history, Cleveland Public Library sought to www.propertiesmag.com 13
Photos of Vocon Headquarters and Floor 24 by Matthew Carbone; Visocky O’Grady Residence by Paul Sobota
develop a facilities master plan to chart the future. Presented as a graphically rich 400-page book, this foundational master plan sets new design principles, explores case studies of specific branches, compounds local and global statistics, and illustrates aspirational branch designs. The plan is organized around a deliberately planned network of branch types and thoroughly considered the best option for each individual branch: renovation, expansion, consolidation or relocation. Design principles were authored as a guidepost to reimagining all 27 branches across a spectrum of socioeconomic neighborhoods.
INTERIORS Merit Award
Vocon Headquarters
Vocon Headquarters
Vocon
Owner: Vocon (Cleveland, OH) The vision for Vocon’s redesigned headquarters in Cleveland was to create a welcoming, activity-based work environment that offers flexible options for employees and guests to work successfully, either independently or in groups. The 28,000-square-foot headquarters occupies two floors, with a working reception, lounge area, large café spaces, virtual reality room and a variety of inspiring spaces. (See full feature story in Properties, March 2019, available at www.propertiesmag.com.)
office in North America. With a growing and evolving practice, the firm needed to explore new business opportunities. As a result, Floor 24 opened in January 2019, creating a reception, conference center, experience center and café.
style “saltbox” structures. Between each form, the kinetic motion of moving from public to private space is displayed by a modern glass prism containing a floating stair with a slatted wood screen wall.
Fujairah Fine Arts Academy Visocky O’Grady Residence
SMALL PROJECTS CATEGORY Merit Award
Visocky O’ Grady Residence AODK
Floor 24
Merit Award
Floor 24 Vocon
Owner: Confidential (New York, NY) Size: 23,000 square feet 300 Madison is the current headquarters to a professional services firm’s largest 14
UNBUILT PROJECTS CATEGORY Honorable Mention
Fujairah Fine Arts Academy
DLR Group | Westlake Reed Leskosky
Owner: Ken and Jenn Visocky O’ Grady (Bay Village, OH)
Owner: Middle East Investment and Management Consultancy (Fujairah, United Arab Emirates)
This 3,500-square-foot suburban home in Bay Village, designed for a passionate graphic design couple, was meant to capture both their affinity for Cape Cod-style architecture and modern design along with their love for visual aesthetics and composition. In order to complement the scale of the neighboring properties, a plan was developed to split the overall volume of the home into two similar traditional New England-
The aspirational design of the new Fujairah Fine Arts Academy in the United Arab Emirates blends 80,000 square feet of performance and academic areas, 120,000 square feet of mixed-use space, and 40,000 square feet of future expansion to cultivate learning and creativity; allow immersion in arts; enable mastery and cross-disciplinary collaboration; and impart a multi-generational impact on the community. The design Properties | January 2020
intends to establish a new and significant legacy, addressing the transparency and optimism of the arts. Articulation of the architecture amalgamates surrounding foothills and unique geology, long cultural history of pottery and ceramics, and Islamic influences such as hypostyles, arcades, vaulting and mosaics.
within the new Red Line Greenway project between Ohio City and Duck Island in Cleveland. The proposed site layout seeks to intertwine the housing and trail as a porous, punctured and shared public-private landscape in order to maximize connectivity and access. Nearby houses were digitally modeled and then manipulated through a boolean operation that generated new contextually based forms which evoke curiosity and exploration.
Martin Luther King Jr. Library
Honorable Mention
Martin Luther King Jr. Library LDA architects / MASS Design Group
Photo of ‘Light Tornado,’ by Christian Phillips; MLK Jr. Library rendering courtesy of LDA architects; Cleveland Boolean Collective rendering by Justin Crasi
Owner: Cleveland Public Library (Cleveland, OH)
Dr. King wrote in his letter from Birmingham Jail, “All of life is interrelated. We are all caught in an inescapable network of mutuality, tied in a single garment of destiny. Whatever affects one directly, affects all indirectly.” The metaphor of a garment was the conceptual underpinning in the design of Cleveland’s Martin Luther King Jr. Library – a fabric that binds us together, a covering that warms us and protects us, and a quilt that weaves a community narrative through storytelling.
‘Light Tornado’
MAKERS CATEGORY Honorable Mention
Light Tornado
Bialosky Cleveland
Owner: Cuyahoga Community College (Cleveland, OH) The Light Tornado is the crown jewel of Tri-C’s Metro Campus Center in Cleveland. Like a lighthouse, the soaring stainless-steel sculpture floats with a glow that can be seen blocks away. The collaboration between architect and fabricator ensured the original design intent was upheld, making the Light Tornado a true community beacon.
Honorable Mention
Tower East Lobby Desk & Benches Kordalski Architects
Cleveland Boolean Collective
STUDENT CATEGORY Merit Award
Cleveland Boolean Collective Student: Justin Crasi, Kent State University
The design explores a formal and urban planning strategy for housing
Owner: E2G Properties, LLC (Shaker Heights, Ohio) This new desk in a 1965 Walter Gropius-designed mid-rise replaced the lobby desk/directory that had been added in the 1980s. The desk was designed to be lighter in scale while complementing building elements. It relates to the module of precast panels www.propertiesmag.com 15
the original handrails. Benches using similar vocabulary were added.
Client Award
Photo courtesy of Kordalski Architects
Cuyahoga County Public Library
Tower East Lobby desk & benches
and brass strips within the terrazzo flooring. The thickness of the desktop and waterfall panels mimic that of the original Gropius stair handrails. The black solid surface material relates to the color of the original lobby wall tiles. The walnut glued-up privacy panels are the same construction as
One of the roles of AIA Cleveland is to advocate for the community of local architects and designers. The ‘Client Commitment to Cleveland Award’ is intended to recognize clients within the Cleveland community who consistently seek to support both design excellence and the local design community, and who understand that it is possible to strengthen them both together. The 2019 Client Commitment to Cleveland Award was presented to Cuyahoga County Public Library (CCPL). As a system of 27 branches serving 47 communities, CCPL is com-
Suntrol It! SUNTROL
™
G L A S S
E N H A N C I N G
F I L M S
Suntrol.com 800-466-TINT(8468) ESTABLISHED 1975
Love Your Windows!
Select Pro Window Film Dealer: • Security • Privacy/Custom • Energy Savings • Glare Reduction • Sun Protection
mitted to its mission of being at the center of community life by creating an environment where reading, lifelong learning and civic engagement thrive. The system has ranked number one in per-capita visits nationwide for nine years among public library systems. Since 2010, CCPL’s $122 million master plan project has resulted in local architects leading 11 new libraries and the renovation of an additional 18 throughout the county. The nine new buildings completed so far represent one of the most significant investments in new work by local architects made by any public entity in Northeast Ohio over the past decade. CCPL hired local as a way to make sure fees would circulate within the local economy. These libraries represent a series of spirited and often delightful variations on a theme, accented with widely varying architectural styles, public art and specialized local features.
ACTIVISM AWARD
Hallie Crouch, Assoc. AIA
Hallie Crouch – director of marketing and strategy, senior associate with Bialosky Cleveland and secretary of AIA Cleveland – was recognized for influencing a sustainable future of the profession by making architecture accessible and relevant to the public while both educating and learning from the broader community.
EMERGING PROFESSIONAL AWARD
Commercial, Institutional & Industrial Floor Covering Provider & Installer
Adam Rosekelly, AIA
Adam Rosekelly, AIA, of AO (Architecture Office), was honored as an outstanding member of the next generation of design leaders, contributing to the workplace and further developing the profession of architecture.
PRESIDENTIAL CITATION
Sandra Madison, AIA
Specializing in the healthcare marketplace with the highest quality & best service since 1989. We provide 24/7 service & installation. Call us today to take advantage of our trained in-house staff and extensive library of product information. Complete line of flooring including: Athletic Floors Resilient Flooring • Vinyl & Ceramic Tile • Carpeting
Call today for a FREE estimate! 4300 Brookpark Rd., Cleveland, OH 44134 • 216-595-0100 • Toll Free 888-271-8200 16
Sandra Madison, CEO and chairperson of Robert P Madison International, was recognized for outstanding service to AIA, as well as dedication and commitment to the success of AIA Cleveland as chair of its anti-harassment taskforce and its lead on the Tamir Rice Foundation Community Center initiative. P Properties | January 2020
Southside High
Tulane University Freeman Business School
Public Square Cleveland
Wooster Community Hospital
Integrated Project Solutions BIM Coordination Services • Site Logistics • 3D Content Creation Revit® • Navisworks® • 3D Studio Max • Residential Design
216.662.5200 chassvecinc@brightdsl.net
MIKE FURLONG, CM-BIM Managing Principal 330.414.9970 | mike@iprojsolutions.com | www.iprojsolutions.com
Your Historic Window Replication Partner from Start to Finish Celebrating
50
Years 1969—2019
www.jamiesonricca.com | 1845 East 40th St. Cleveland OH 44103 | (216) 621 4277 www.propertiesmag.com 17
“10 Years of Embracing Diversity, Enhancing Relationships: Celebrating Pioneers in Northeast Ohio’s Construction Industry” CAA Officers: Margaret Hewitt, President | Shakorie Davis, Vice President Chris Howse, Secretary | Heather Baines, Treasurer Glen Shumate, Executive Director
CAA Members: Adrian Maldonado & Associates The AKA Team, Inc. Albert M. Higley Co., LLC Alert Pioneer Plumbing Bolton Pratt Company, Inc. Brigadier Construction Services, LLC Cleveland Building Restoration Cleveland Cement Contractors The Construction Green Team, LLC Cook Paving & Construction Donley’s, Inc. Dunlop & Johnston, Inc. Forest City Erectors, Inc.
Frantz Ward, LLP G. Stephens, Inc. Gilbane Building Company, Inc. Great Lakes Construction Co., Inc. Howse Solutions HR Construction Services, LLC Journey Steel, Inc. JWT&A, LLC KBJ Construction Leggon Construction Services M. Rivera Construction Co., Inc. McTech Corp., Inc. Next Generation Construction, LLC
North Coast Concrete, Inc. North Star Contracting, Inc. Ozanne Construction Company, Inc. Panzica Construction Co., Inc. Pinkney Perry Insurance Regency Construction Services, Inc. ROMA Designs Construction, LLC RL Cole Trucking RWJ Wiring, Inc. Shook Construction Co., Inc. Turner Construction Company, Inc. The Whiting-Turner Contracting Co. WTD Construction
Committed to advancing and strengthening inclusion in the Northeast Ohio Construction Industry in partnership with Construction Employers Association (CEA). www.ceacisp.org/caa
y”
c.
c.
. o.
Opening Doors to Opportunity An overview of resources available to minority entrepreneurs in Northeast Ohio By Lewis Rice
G
reater Cleveland is fortunate to have an infrastructure of organizations whose mission is to help guide and support aspiring entrepreneurs whose success is increasingly essential to keeping our community, region and nation competitive in the rapidly evolving global marketplace. In growing numbers, these entrepreneurs are likely to belong to demographic groups with special challenges that may arise from their color, culture or gender, making the path to success more perilous.
At the start of the new decade, we highlight several resources that are especially keen to help nontraditional entrepreneurs enter the mainstream or prepare for deeper waters. The list is in alphabetical order, but there is no wrong place to start; most of these agencies will steer you to the resources most apt to be of use to your individual needs.
Contractors Assistance Association
www.ceacisp.org/advocacy/contractorsassistance-association CAA supports its members in the development of best practices, prequalification programs in conjunction with more than 40 top construction management and general contractors, and mentor-protégé efforts designed to increase capacity. CAA supports employment and diversity in the construction workforce through collaboration with the construction trades, city/county governments, and community organizations. Its laser-focus on one industry and its relationships with over 600 union contractors and most of the region’s largest public and private property owners give particular heft to its work.
Economic & Community Development Institute
www.ecdi.org/locations/cleveland ECDI Cleveland provides technical assistance, training and access to capital for small businesses.
Greater Cleveland Partnership
www.gcpartnership.com Through its Equity & Inclusion division, Greater Cleveland Partnership focuses on growing businesses owned by people of color and increasing workforce diversity, equity and inclusion. As the area’s largest private economic development organization, it offers access to abundant resources for minority business
enterprises and sets the agenda for much of the area’s DEI (diversity, equity and inclusion) work through initiatives like the Business Growth Collaborative.
assistance along with some structured programs and keeps a constant lookout for high-potential startups.
Growth Opportunity Partners
development.ohio.gov/bs/bs_mbac.htm Minority Business Assistance Centers are state agencies created to support the growth and sustainability of small and minority businesses. They offer a variety of services, including assistance in accounting, contract procurement, loan packaging, estimating/bidding and marketing plan development.
SAVE THE DATE
Ohio Minority Supplier Development Council
www.growthopps.org Growth Opportunity Partners focuses on businesses that are already healthy, thriving and ready to expand, but for a variety of reasons can’t access traditional bank financing. It provides lending and coaching assistance to small businesses that are ready to grow and are commit-
Cleveland Building Excellence & Craftsmanship Awards Thursday, March 26, 2020 FirstEnergy Stadium | Cleveland, OH Visit www.ClevelandCraftsmanship.com for info. ted to community development through the creation of “meaningful-wage” jobs.
Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
www.hbcenter.org Northeast Ohio Hispanic Chamber of Commerce aims to promote and support the economic development of Hispanic commerce and to serve as liaison to the Hispanic market in Northeast Ohio. It has evolved into a comprehensive business support center that provides technical assistance and training for those looking to start, build or grow a business. Its successes have attracted many non-Latino business clients as well, and it serves over 300 clients annually.
JumpStart
www.jumpstartinc.org JumpStart is an active venture capital investor. It offers personalized business
Minority Business Assistance Centers
www.ohiomsdc.org OMSDC expands opportunities for minority business enterprises (MBEs) to supply goods and services to the public and private sector by facilitating mutually beneficial relationships that lead to more diverse supply chains.
The Presidents’ Council
www.thepresidentscouncil.com Through its programming and advocacy, TPC is a voice for the region’s African American entrepreneurs in its efforts for sustainable wealth creation. It offers training for emerging entrepreneurs and networking opportunities for its members who collectively employ thousands of greater Clevelanders.
Urban League of Greater Cleveland
www.ulcleveland.org Through its Entrepreneurship Center, ULGC provides early stage small businesses with hands-on management counseling and assistance to help with growth that will increase sales and create jobs. Its workforce development programs assist about 1,000 people every year. Its capital access fund has granted over 50 loans totaling $8 million. P www.propertiesmag.com 19
Lake Local Schools Lands New Look
$34.6 million renovation & addition re-imagines middle/high school in Uniontown By Lee King | Photos by Todd Biss
A
s part of a comprehensive school district redesign, five buildings were consolidated into three. The final step in transforming Lake Local Schools was achieved with the completion of the middle/high school. This newly re-imagined school underwent a 65,000-square-foot renovation and 107,000-square-foot addition to the existing building located at 709 Market Ave. SW in Uniontown. Designed by Stark County-based SōL Harris/Day Architecture and built by Hammond Construction as CM at Risk, Lake Middle/High School serves approximately 1,900 students from grades 7 through 12. With these improvements comes a new way for students and teachers to interact and learn by providing a student-centered environment that fosters relationships with students, families and communities. These innovative learning spaces encourage flexibility and collaboration while providing growth opportunities to meet the district’s needs for the next 50 years.
Street presence
Located on a sprawling campus housing not only the high school 20
and middle school, but also the Stark County Library, Mercy Medical Center, Lake YMCA and district administration offices, the existing high school lacked a real “presence” and main entry focal point for visitors. Part of the project’s goal was to create a more impactful impression along Market Avenue, defined with two-story glass and a generous pedestrian walkway. The two-story addition houses an academic wing, combining both high school and middle school students under one roof, creating opportunities for increased interaction, collaboration and mentorship. The new, main entrance is surrounded by open grassy areas, with benches lining the entry walkway. An
outdoor learning space with tables adjacent to the sidewalk brings education outdoors and offers comfortable spaces where students can interact before and after school.
Visioning for the future
Lake enlisted the help of Frank Locker, a nationally recognized educational planner, to conduct a three-day educational visioning session. Together, community members, staff, administrators and students at this session laid the groundwork for the design of the building. “SōL Harris/Day hit a grand slam in the design and follow-through on the goals and objectives of the Lake Local facility project,” says Kevin Tobin, superintendent of Lake Local Schools. Properties | January 2020
IT HAS BEEN AN HONOR TO SERVE LAKE LOCAL SCHOOLS THROUGH THIS INCREDIBLE CAMPUS TRANSFORMATION
OPEN ENTRY Two-story glass and a generous pedestrian walkway help to create a more impactful presence for the school district on Market Avenue.
“From the onset of the pre-bond meetings and through the visioning and eventually the build, they delivered on the three main focal points of the project. As a 21st century learning environment, the need for flexible spaces, the integration of technology and flexible use of furniture all came to fruition under the direction of the architectural team.”
www.solharrisday.com
Building organization
Armed with extensive feedback from the school district, SōL Harris/Day designed an addition and renovation that would achieve its key goals of flexibility, openness and adaptability. The addition, containing most of the learning studios (classrooms) and extended learning areas (ELAs), was carefully planned and designed so that the main circulation space is at the core of the school building, and all learning areas have views to the outdoors. “The design and workmanship have created a learning environment that can effectively change the playing field for the delivery of instruction and the changing needs of our students for decades to come,” Tobin says. “Lake Middle/High School is a state-of-theart learning environment that allows www.propertiesmag.com 21
STEPPING FORWARD An open, centralized “collaboration stair,” which can seat 150 people, creates a hub of activity that can be used in a variety of ways by students and the community.
Lake Local to bring its vision of teaching and learning to life.” Research has shown that connecting indoor spaces to nature can improve student productivity and morale, and reduce absenteeism in schools. The building offers moments to connect with nature throughout. Large openings in the upper floors allow natural light to reach the lower levels, as do skylights which provide views between the two levels. Wide corridors, infused with light from floor-to-ceiling windows and skylights, facilitate informal interaction, with built-in seating along the walls and small breakout tables. In addition to having all the benefits of views and natural daylighting,
“The design and workmanship have created a learning environment that can effectively change the playing field for the delivery of instruction and the changing needs of our students for decades to come.” Kevin Tobin Lake Local Schools the learning studios are connected to each other via moveable walls and glass garage doors, which can be opened to create larger venues for team-teaching and project-based learning. Moveable walls painted with whiteboard paint replace chalkboards, and cutting-edge technology is integrated throughout in the form of mobile, interactive displays. Outside the learning studios, ELAs are dispersed in the circulation space, offering flexible seating for both group work and individual learning. An open, centralized ‘collaboration stair’ creates a hub for student activity, as well as a presentation venue 22
Properties | January 2020
FLEXIBLE LAYOUT Learning occurs throughout the entire building. Extended learning areas (top left) are surrounded by classrooms (top right) with large glass garage doors that can be opened to create large, contiguous spaces for collaboration. Elsewhere, a variety of breakout areas encourage students to interact and study together (bottom left, right)
with seating for approximately 150 students, with standing room above, around all sides. Rich with technology in the form of a 16-foot-wide by ninefoot-high media wall, this hub can be used by students in a variety of ways – from breakout space, to large group lecture, to student presentations and more. Clad in wood with multi-colored acoustic panels, it creates a warm and casual gathering space for student interaction and collaboration.
District pride displayed
comfort, and balance glass walls and surfaces throughout.
A new district
Along with the new middle/ high school, Lake Local Schools recently completed a new, 57,500-square-foot primary school (pre-kindergarten through first grade) and 135,500-square-foot elementary school for grades 2-6 (see full feature story in Properties, July 2019, available at www.propertiesmag.com).
“It was an absolute wonderful synergy that took place between SōL Harris/Day Architecture, Hammond Construction, the Ohio Facilities Construction Commission and our district,” Tobin says. “We were blessed to have each of the members see this project through to completion.” P Lee King is a senior project manager with SōL Harris/Day Architecture. For more information, visit Sōl Harris/day online at www.solharrisday.com.
Materials and finishes throughout the school building reflect the district’s pride. On the exterior, alternating shades of blue glass panels create an aesthetic brand, combining with red brick to blend with the surrounding neighborhood. Inside the school, light walls contrast with bright blue and green accents, providing pops of color in strategic locations. Additional interior elements of wood adorning beams and colorful furniture in the newly appointed ‘commons’ area give warmth and www.propertiesmag.com 23
QUALITY
|
SPEED
|
VALUE
Metis Construction Services is proud to be the construction management firm for the new CHICKADEE PROGRAM CENTER. We would like to thank Girl Scouts of North East Ohio, Brandstetter Carroll Inc. and our contractor/supplier partners for helping to make this another successful Metis Construction project.
General Contracting | Construction Management | Design/Build | Facilities Management World Headquarters | 175 E. Erie St., Suite 303 | Kent, OH 44240 | www.MetisConstruction.com | 330.677.7333
nt
33
Girl Scouts of North East Ohio invests in future with new Chickadee Program Center Story & photos by Mark Watt
“C
hick-a-dee-dee-dee!” Jane Christyson extends her arm with sunflower seeds in the palm of her hand and calls out to the tiny birds cautiously looking on from branches of nearby trees. “They’re still scoping things out and getting used to us.” It’s a chilly December morning and Christyson, CEO of the Girl Scouts of North East Ohio, is showing off a newly installed bird feeding area, cheekily named Chickadee Diner. The short looping trail is one small portion of a $6.2 million investment at Camp Ledgewood, a 350-acre Girl Scouts property in Peninsula about two miles west of the intersection of Rt. 8 and the Ohio Turnpike. Over the past decade, the camp has been upgraded with phased construction projects, including the addition of 14 heated cabins, a unit house and a pair of troop houses. Accommodating an average of 3,400 Girl Scout visits each year, Camp Ledgewood now provides 318 beds yearround, and up to 600 in warmer weather with semi-permanent yurts and primitive tent camping. This October, the Girl Scouts celebrated the opening of its latest
improvements, including a new ‘great lawn’ with a bell tower, a fire pit, a bridge and water feature, a walking trail and a brick plaza commemorating Girl
ity with a fitting name: Chickadee Program Center. Designed by architect Rick Parker of Brandstetter Carroll, Inc. and built by Kent-based Metis Construction, the 8,500-square-foot building provides flexible meeting space, a teaching kitchen and a welcome center. “We’ve been building here for several years now but Chickadee Program Center is the most visual representation of our effort to help Girl Scouts now and in the future,” Christyson says. “It replaces the Jane Christyson functions of several outdated cabins Girl Scouts of North East Ohio we had on the property, while providing year-round space for programs Scout supporters, as well as the new bird- and activities, which we didn’t really feeding area. Nearby is Whippoorwill have before.” Cabin, a newly constructed building Packing up housing volunteer and staff quarters, Christyson explains that the project plus an infirmary. The centerpiece of the $3.1 million began 10 years ago when five Girl Scout project is a new, multi-purpose facil- councils throughout the region joined
“[Chickadee Program Center] replaces the functions of several outdated cabins we had on the property, while providing yearround space for programs and activities, which we didn’t really have before.”
www.propertiesmag.com 25
Photo courtesy of Girl Scouts of North East Ohio
he ew to er ers etis
Nature + Nurture
WE PROTECT WHAT’S MOST IMPORTANT.
Chickadee Program Center Girl Scouts of North East Ohio - Camp Ledgewood
LOW SLOPE ROOFING. STEEP SLOPE ROOFING. SIDING. ARCHITECTURAL METAL. RESIDENTIAL & COMMERCIAL EXTERIORS
www.camporoof.com | 330.391.7799
TRUSTED. ®
BBB
ACCREDITED BUSINESS
A+ Rating
NATURAL FIT Chickadee Program Center nods toward the naturalistic architecture of WPA-era historic National Park System buildings with exposed timber framing, stone accents and a grand hall featuring a 25-foot-high stone fireplace.
together as Girl Scouts of North East Ohio (GSNEO) to realize efficiencies and cost savings. “When we merged, there were 14 camp properties and that was way too many,” she says. “We went through a process of deciding which ones to keep and which ones to leave behind. Some properties were given back to the cities where they were located and others were sold. We ended up with three, including Camp Sugarbush in Kinsman and Camp Timberlane in Vermillion. We kept Camp Ledgewood as well, because it’s centrally located and it’s uniquely situated right within Cuyahoga Valley National Park. There’s rich wildlife and vegetation here. It gives the girls a great opportunity to explore nature.” Brandstetter Carroll assisted GSNEO in developing a master plan to determine what investments could be made at the three remaining camps. “It was a very engaged process,” says Parker, of Brandstetter Carroll. “We met with membership several times and hosted open townhall sessions and visioning sessions, with big groups and little groups. That approach works because it consistently ensures that
completed projects will reflect what was originally envisioned by stakeholders. We were trying to reflect the essence of what the organization is and solve its needs.” Funding was provided by the sale of previous properties, totaling $9 million, plus donations, Christyson says. In total, $11.5 million was utilized for improvements at the three camps.
Metis Construction was brought onboard in 2015 to lead construction of the various buildings throughout the camp, with new cabins and troop houses built throughout 2016 and 2017. Work culminated with construction of Chickadee Program Center and Whippoorwill Cabin, starting in November 2018 and completed last fall.
“We took our design cues from the grand lodges built during the early 1940s through the WPA programs. Large porches, large volume spaces and the use of wood paneling and timber help to provide some of the imagery that the great buildings are known for.”
Center of attention
The new program center blends comfortably with its wooded surroundings, incorporating green metal roofing, earth-toned metal siding and stone columns. “We took our design cues from the grand lodges built during the early 1940s through the WPA [Work Projects Administration] programs,” Parker says. “Large porches, large volume spaces and the use of wood Rick Parker paneling and timber help to provide Brandstetter Carroll some of the imagery that the great buildings are known for.” Inside, the facility similarly nods Construction at Camp Ledgewood toward the naturalistic architecture of began in 2013 with infrastructure those historic National Park System upgrades, including a new wastewater structures with exposed timber framing treatment system, water and fire suppres- and stone accents, plus a grand hall that sion systems and upgraded electrical lines. features a 25-foot-high stone fireplace. www.propertiesmag.com 27
Asphalt Paving Complete Site Construction
Proud to have provided asphalt paving for The Girl Scouts of Northeast Ohio with Metis Construction
Drainage Seal Coating Concrete Line Striping Find us on
ASPHALT & CONCRETE
We Maintain Your Investment 1324 Kenmore Blvd., Akron, OH 44314 330-745-9585 | 800-528-9078
RUSTIC RELICS Old camp artifacts can be found throughout the welcome center, such as an oxen yoke that previously hung in one of the cabins and a Camp Ledgewood sign which was converted into a coffee table.
2008-2018
28
The centrally located 3,440-squarefoot meeting hall provides a flexible, modern space for diverse programming, equipped with a drop-down 110-inch projection screen, a wall-mounted largescreen television and fold-away walls that allow the room to be divided in two. Just beyond the meeting area is a 480-square-foot teaching kitchen, called The Feeder, which incorporates ceiling-mounted cameras and a television monitor. “Having an on-site kitchen facility like this is a first for us,” Christyson says. “It’s a staging kitchen where scouts can not only learn how to cook and bake, but also explore the scientific principles that take place in the kitchen – to get girls interested in understanding the science behind cooking. When a chef is in here, we can project live video not only on the screen within the kitchen, but also broadcast it out to the screens in the meeting room for larger groups.” Just down the hallway is a storage room housing the camp’s FabCab, a portable mini digital fabrication lab with laser cutting and vinyl cutting technology used to create rapid prototypes. “We use it for girls to have enhanced experiences when earning their badges,” Christyson says. “For example, we have a mechanical engineering badge called the ‘Paddle Wheel Challenge’ and girls make a paddle wheel boat as part of the badge requirements. With FabCab, they can Properties | January 2020
GATHERING ATTENTION The welcome center (top) includes a staff office, souvenir shop and seating area, while just down the hall (middle), a teaching kitchen provides space for hands-on instruction (bottom).
design the rudders and paddles and then print and cut them out using the vinyl cutter. We have another badge where they make board games. We are trying to elevate the experience and give girls confidence to consider STEM careers.” The Roost, a 995-square-foot welcome center located on the east side of the building, houses a staff office and a snack/souvenir store called the Trading Post, as well as a comfortable seating area and community space. “As you look around the welcome center, you’ll see a lot of artifacts from the old camps,” Christyson says. “There were a lot of donated items. We have old wood camp signs. There’s an oxen yoke that used to
“There was an effort to use natural materials that will last, and products made with recycled content.” Julie Brandle Metis Construction
Photo courtesy of Girl Scouts of North East Ohio
hang in one of the cabins. There’s an old Girls Scouts logo plaque that was found at another camp. It was fun to include these nostalgic elements. Some of the older visitors get emotional when they see these reminders from their childhood.” Downstairs on the building’s lower level is the Nest, a 1,500-square-foot program area with open raw space and a kitchen. The area, which doubles as a storm shelter, is available for messier group activities. “Upstairs is a glitter-free zone,” Christyson says, with a laugh, “but the lower level can be used for art activities and science experiments.”
Green, naturally
Throughout the facility, sustainable building materials have been incorporated to reduce operating costs and be environmentally responsible, notes Julie Brandle, president of Metis Construction – and a lifetime Girl Scout. www.propertiesmag.com 29
Photos courtesy of Girl Scouts of North East Ohio
EAG_H
ADDED AMENITIES In addition to the program center, the overall camp improvement project included construction of Whippoorwill Cabin (left), which houses volunteer/staff quarters and an infirmary, plus the new Weiss Bell Tower, displaying four historic bells (right).
“There was an effort to use natural materials that will last, and products made with recycled content,” says Brandle. “The flooring throughout is a low-VOC luxury vinyl tile that has a great, wood grain look, for instance.” All light fixtures are LED and incorporate motion-sensors, while solar tubes – essentially skylights lined with reflective interior surfaces – bring diffused natural light into key areas, such as the kitchen and restrooms. Forest green-colored DuctSox HVAC ductwork, containing about 50% post-industrial recycled content, is used in the great hall. “The fabric ductwork is designed for a good, even distribution of air,” Parker says. “It also provides savings in manufacturing and shipping costs, because it can be delivered onsite by FedEx versus being trucked in like traditional metal ductwork.”
New paths ahead
While the new program center concludes GSNEO’s 10-year master plan, the organization is already looking forward to additional upgrades at Camp Ledgewood. “We are still very early on in the fundraising and design phases, but we intend to construct a STEM Center of Excellence here,” Christyson says. “We envision a fully tricked-out, dedicated 30
building for STEM [science, technology, engineering and math] learning.” The wishlist for the new facility includes classrooms with 3D printers and laser cutters, a vegetative roof, water/air quality testing benches, labs and more, she says. “People think of us as ‘cookies, crafts and camping,’ but really what we’re trying to do is create the talent
go into STEM fields. Very early on, as young as third grade, youth will start to articulate that math is ‘for boys’ and not ‘for girls.’ Girl Scouts is uniquely positioned because we’ve always been a leadership organization for girls. The goal is to take that leadership [approach] and everything that is baked into our program and then give these girls real experiences in STEM – and eventually access to the high-paying and fast-growing parts of the American economy.”
“People think of us as ‘cookies, crafts and camping,’ but really what we’re trying to Last bite do is create the talent pipeline for the next Back at Chickadee Diner, the outdoor bird-feeding area, snow has generation of workers in STEM fields.” Jane Christyson Girl Scouts of North East Ohio pipeline for the next generation of workers in STEM fields. We know that even though women are 50% of the workforce in the U.S., only 24% are in STEM fields. So we’ve switched a lot of our programming, offering new badges in cybersecurity and mechanical engineering and other STEM-related subjects, so girls can have hands-on experiences with these different subjects and build confidence. “What we also know is that by the time girls get to high school, only 11% of them have the confidence to
started to fall lightly. Christyson spies a brave bird that has crept a little closer, perched on a nearby tree. “Is that a nuthatch? No, no, that’s a titmouse,” she says. “He’s not coming any closer today. The whole process takes about six months for the birds to become acclimated but we’ll get there.” By late spring, Girl Scouts will likely be able to feed birds by hand along the trail, she says. “There’s nothing like that feeling,” Christyson says. “You have that connection with nature. It makes you care about nature more, appreciate it better and want to learn more. That’s the kind of ‘wow’ experience that we’re trying to create with the girls here.” P Properties | January 2020
EAG_Head_in_Sand_Ad_Layout 1 3/25/11 12:03 PM Page 1
Ignoring your environmental issues won’t make them go away.
EA Group has provided environmental consulting and laboratory services to a wide range of clients for over 25 years. We’ve helped hundreds of companies solve their most challenging environmental
EATHE BRE E ASIER
issues from assessments and analysis to project management and remediation. Stop hiding from the problem and put our team to work early to avoid environmental emergencies that can result in costly and unexpected delays. Our expert technicians are experienced in: • Asbestos and Hazardous Materials Management • Site Assessment and Remediation • Indoor Air Quality Assessment • Industrial Hygiene and Safety • Mold Remediation Management • Analytical Laboratory Support
800.875.3514 • 440.951.3514 • www.eagroupohio.com 7118 Industrial Park Boulevard • Mentor, OH 44060
NAIOP NEWS Commercial real estate happenings
Transitioning into 2020
G
oing into last year, NAIOP’s goal was to be the premier real estate association in Northern Ohio. I believe we accomplished that in 2019 as it was a very successful year for NAIOP Northern Ohio – and one of which all our members should collectively be very proud.
Keeping with the trend of prior years, our board of directors convened a strategy session to steer the direction of our chapter, and we exited with four main areas of focus: membership, advocacy, programming and communications. We set the ambitious but attainable goal of 300 total chapter members in the next three years and now sit at 220 members, the largest membership base in our chapter’s history. With the growth in membership, we have reinvested in membership services and events and continue to show value to our members. Perhaps most importantly, we started the Women’s Leadership Network, an initiative to help foster career advancement for women in our industry. We are proud to be only the second chapter in the county with such an initiative. On the advocacy front, we are increasing our presence at our local municipalities to help streamline development in our industry and working on issues such as timing of permits, tax abatement, historic tax credits and other incentives that help drive our
RYAN MOORE
MICHAEL PANZICA
SAFETY & SECURITY
SUPERIOR INSULATING
industry. We are also working to have exclusive, members-only events with our policymakers to stay in front of them and discuss issues relevant to development. New in 2019, we formed a Communications Committee and launched a new chapter website. We have increased our presence on social media platforms and will be rolling out new features within these platforms. Finally, we had the most relevant and interesting programs in the region, most notably the All-Star Site Selectors event. Leveraging off of a once-in-a-generation opportunity, the MLB All-Star game, we put together an event that featured Ohio Governor Mike DeWine, Cuyahoga County Executive Armond Budish and six national site selectors who highlighted the advantages (and perhaps disadvantages) that Northeast Ohio has in attracting businesses to the region. It truly was a pleasure to serve as president for our chapter in 2019, and I am very excited for the succession plan we have in place. Ryan Moore will be an excellent president and we are very for-
ENERGY CONSERVATION
DECORATIVE
www.SunrayFilms.com
800.295.8468
Minority Owned Owned Company Company A Female & Minority “It’s Always a Sunny Day at Sunray!”
32
Authorized Dealer Dealer & & Applicator Applicator Authorized
Properties | January 2020
tunate to have a very active and strong board to shepherd our strategic plan. – Michael Panzica, 2019 President • As we move into a new decade, we look forward to continuing our growth in the last. As the incoming president, it’s always a challenge to take the leadership role of a well-run organization with a long tenure of successful directors. I want to thank our outgoing president Michael Panzica and the 2019 board of directors for a fantastic and productive 2019. I am excited to get to work with our board and staff, and to demonstrate real value to our members and industry partners. We will work to continue to add value through best-in-class networking, education events and legislative initiatives. Our chapter member count has significantly increased over the last few years and we will continue to explore ways to grow and add even more. We hope to do this through demonstrating continued value-add events and opportunities. Last year’s events and programing including our annual market update through a new lens with Richey Piiparinen (demographics expert) and quarterly developers and owners roundtables. New in 2019, we started having joint events with our Developing Leader Tours and Membership Mixers. This year, we look forward to a relaunch of our Mentorship Program and the continued growth of our communications initiatives and brand-new Women’s Leadership Network. We plan to continue our path forward as the premier commercial real estate development association in Northern Ohio. We would like to sincerely thank all of our supporters, from the event sponsors to our gavel sponsors – without you, our organization would not be the same. –Ryan E. Moore, 2020 President
We’re Out to Clean Up This Town SWEEPING PRESSURE WASHING CONSTRUCTION SITES PARKING LOTS & DECKS WAREHOUSES SPECIAL EVENTS FLUSHING
Since 1990
330.798.9200 | WWW.BUCKEYESWEEPING.COM 330-798-9200
www.buckeyesweeping.com
• For updated info regarding future NAIOP Northern Ohio events, visit www.naiopnorthernohio.com/events. P Michael Panzica, outgoing 2019 president of NAIOP Northern Ohio, is principal with Hemingway Development. (www.hwrep.com). NAIOP Northern Ohio Incoming President Ryan Moore is first vice president, investments with Marcus & Millichap (www.marcusmillichap.com). Visit NAIOP Northern Ohio online at www.naiopnorthernohio.com.
Brennan www.propertiesmag.com 33
BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans
Canstruction Akron/Cleveland Announces Call for Entries
A
call for entries was recently announced for the 15th annual Canstruction Cleveland/Akron Design/ Build Competition, which will be held at South Park Mall in Strongsville in April to benefit the Greater Cleveland Food Bank. For the annual contest, teams of architects, engineers, contractors, interior designers and students design and build structures made entirely from canned foods within a 10-foot by 10-foot space. The completed sculptures will be on public display at the mall from April 2-13. Canned goods Bialosky Cleveland’s Wonder Woman 2019 entry will then be collected and provided to those in need in surrounding communities. In 2019, the event totaled more than 35,000 pounds of food, providing 26,350 meals and a monetary donation of $8,000 to the Greater Cleveland Food Bank. The deadline for entries is Monday, January 27. For additional information or registration, contact the Canstruction committee at construction@onyxcreative.com.
Davey Names Commercial Landscape Services VP, GM The Davey Tree Expert Company recently announced the promotion of Mark Svozil to vice president and general manager, Commercial Landscape Services (CLS). Svozil started with Davey in 1992 as a landscape fore-
man in the West Cleveland Residential/Commercial (R/C) office and has been promoted periodically over the past 18 years. Most recently, he was promoted to vice president, Midwest region in 2013 and in 2016 was promoted to senior vice president, CLS. Svozil is an International Society of Arboriculture
Certified Arborist and a National Association of Landscape Professionals Certified Manager. He is a 1995 graduate of the Davey Institute of Tree Sciences (D.I.T.S.), Davey’s flagship training program in biological sciences, safety, tree and plant care and management techniques. Svozil is a
Mark Svozil
past member of the Davey President’s Council, whose members serve a three-year term on various committees to brainstorm and research new ideas related to the company’s operations. He is a recipient of a Davey Outstanding Manager Award and the Best of Davey Leadership Award.
Frantz Ward’s Construction Group Welcomes Ouambo Frantz Ward recently announced that Bradley N. Ouambo has joined the firm as associate in its nation-
10 • 20 • 30 • 40 Yard Roll off Dumpsters 2 • 4 • 6 • 8 Yard Front Load Dumpsters Topsoil • Mulch • Aggregates Boulders • Fill Sand • Clay We Accept Construction Debris, Clean Fill Dirt, Concrete and Organic Waste
34
BOYAS RECYCLING
PETE & PETE
11311 Rockside Rd., Valley View, OH 44125 216-524-3620 www.boyasrecycling.com
4830 Warner Road Garfield Hts., OH 44125 216-441-4422 www.peteandpeteinc.com Properties | January 2020
BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans ally recognized Construction Practice Group. Ouambo’s practice is focused on construction law and related litigation, with experience in contract review and litigating construction, transportation and real estate cases. Ouambo earned his J.D. from Case Western Reserve University School of Law and a B.A., in Political Science, from Miami University. He is the head coach of Case Western Reserve University’s undergraduate mock trial program. As a coach, he helps students develop critical thinking skills, trial advocacy skills and teamwork. In other news for Frantz Ward, the firm recently announced that Thomas E. Cardone, Thomas G. Haren
Business Law and Litigation practice groups.
Onyx Creative Announces New Shareholders
Bradley Ouambo
and Allison Taller Reich have been elected to the partnership effective January 1, 2020. Cardone and Reich are members of the Frantz Ward’s Construction Practice Group and Haren is a member of the firm’s
Cleveland’s Steel Headquarters
Columbia Building Products Steel JoiStS Structural iron Metal roof Deck Steel StairS & railS Steel erection
440-235-3363 25961 Elm St., Cleveland, OH 44138
National architecture, engineering and design firm Onyx Creative recently announced the addition of three new shareholders, effective January 1, 2020. These include Don Alexander, architect, director; Richard Knapp, electrical engineer, P.E., director; and Jonathan Novak, architect, design director. All are based in Northeast Ohio. Onyx Creative is a nationally recognized, awardwinning professional services firm specializing in retail and commercial environments. With a staff consisting of 100+
architects, engineers, interior designers, graphic designers, and brand specialists, they provide a full spectrum of design, production, development, and construction administration services. Office locations include Cleveland, Tucson, Los Angeles and Atlanta.
Diamond Roofing Welcomes Chief Estimator Diamond Roofing Systems recently announced that Dean Ritchie has joined the company as a chief estimator. Prior to joining Diamond Roofing Systems, Ritchie worked in the commercial roof industry for a large national roofing contractor, working in service, production, technical support and as a senior roof estima-
One Call Solves it All Fire Life Safety
Barberton/Akron Branch 2900 Newpark Drive Barberton, OH 44203
Service & Inspection
Mechanical
Cleveland Branch 135 Alpha Park Highland Heights, OH 44143
sacomunale.com 800-776-7181 www.propertiesmag.com 35
BILLBOARD
C
News about people, products, places & plans renovations for Bellwether Enterprise, Parker Hannifin, Benesch, Cleveland Clinic, Case Western Reserve University and MOCA, as well as WKYC’s Transmitter Building addition.
tor. He brings over 27 years of commercial roofing and construction industry experience.
Donley’s Inc. Announces Recent Promotions Donley’s Inc. recently announced two promotions within its Interiors Group. Andy Lesnick has been promoted to director of the Interiors Group. In his 11 years at Donley’s, Lesnick has played a key role on numerous projects including Cleveland Public Square and the Cleveland Clinic/Case Western Reserve University Samson Pavilion. His recent work includes renovations for Cleveland Clinic and Cleveland Institute of Art. He will oversee operations of the
CES Announces Conference & Tradeshow Details
Andy Lesnick
business unit which focuses on interior renovation and special projects. Billy Painter has been promoted to project manager for Donley’s Interiors Group. Since joining the company in 2018, he has worked on
What’s New?
Cleveland Engineering Society (CES) recently announced details of its 68th Annual Design & Construction Conference & Tradeshow. This year’s event takes place at LaCentre Conference & Banquet Center on Friday, March 27, from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. This year’s theme is “Sustaining the Region Through Design, Engineering and
Construction.” For more info, visit www.cesnet.org/events.
JGJ Welcome Project Engineer Cleveland-based John G. Johnson Construction (JGJ) recently announced the addition of Ryan Rovniak as a project engineer. Rovniak graduated from Bowling Green State University in 2018 with a bachelor’s degree in applied sciences in construction management. He will serve as the project engineer on the firm’s phased renovation at Cedar Fair’s Castaway Bay Indoor Water Park in Sandusky. P WHAT’S NEW? For coverage within Billboard, send along company news, story ideas and project information to billboard@propertiesmag.com.
COMMERCIAL & INDUSTRIAL ELECTRICAL SERVICE: Upfront Pricing • Trouble-Shoot & Repair
Promote your company announcements and events here in the Billboard section of Properties. Best of all, it’s FREE!
NEW CONSTRUCTION: Design/Build • Spec/Build
Add us to your mailing list: billboard@propertiesmag.com
BUILDING & PROCESS AUTOMATION: Engineering • Installation
ENERGY-SAVING UPGRADES ON-TIME PERFORMANCE GUARANTEED
OH LIC #21927
INDUSTRY LEADER SINCE 1946
36
Exclusive | Focused | Informative | Dependable | Connected
www.jltaylorcompany.com
www.Propertiesmag.com
440.834.1223 Properties | January 2020
Cover Your Investments With Confidence
Count on Commercial Roofing and Coating Systems, Inc. to get on top of your roofing project – no matter the size. We specialize in roofing repairs, replacements and maintenance for Commercial, Industrial and Residential clients throughout Northeast Ohio. Our main focus? Providing efficient and cost-effective service. Our full line of services includes: Roofing Maintenance | Inspections & Reporting Infrared Leak Detection & Reporting | Low Slope Roofing Single-Ply Membrane Roof Systems | TPO, PVC, EPDM, Modified Asphalt Sheet Metal & Custom Flashings | ACM Composite Panels | Coatings Insulation | Tapered Insulation, Tapered Roofing | Metal-Retrofit Systems Daylighting | Solar Roof Systems | New Construction & Roof Replacement
Contact us today at 330-207-3879 to handle all of your roofing needs! Mailing Address: P.O. Box 73, Garrettsville, OH 44231 | Physical Address: 10025 SR-82, Windham, OH 44288 brandon@ohiocommercialroofing.com | www.ohiocommercialroofing.com
Fresh Face for Surgery Practice
Innovations abound at specialty oral, maxillofacial health facility in Mentor By Christopher Johnston | Photos by Ken Krych
S
everal years ago, Keith M. Schneider, MS, DMD, FACS, felt like his dental surgery practice in Mentor was grinding against two obstructions: space and technology. The business he had taken over from his father, Edward Karl Schneider, DDS, in 2013, continued to grow quickly. He changed the business name to Schneider Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery. He also purchased Northeast Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons, the practice of one of his current partners, Donald P. Lewis, Jr., DDS, CFE. (His third partner is Jill M. Weber, DDS.) In 2014, they changed the name again when they merged with another practice, becoming Ohio’s Center for Oral, Facial and Implant Surgery. The have since grown to four full-time surgeons, one part-time surgeon and 32 full-time staff with two locations, in Mentor and Highland Heights. Growth has been so steady that Dr. Schneider is currently considering adding a third location.
Time to move
The 2014 merger confirmed Dr. Schneider’s belief that it was time to 38
expand their older 1,574-square-foot facility. “It was mostly a space issue, and how we were evolving as a practice,” he explains. “We had unmet needs within the space, but it was also because we were under the restraints of the physical location.” Fortunately, his father and a business partner, Hudson Fowler, had purchased four contiguous parcels of land to construct their existing building, which was completed in 1997. Their exact intention was to own enough surrounding land for future expansion on that property. Dr. Schneider and his team knew a complete gutting of the first building would not have provided enough extra space. More important, the older facility could not easily accommodate the
high-tech equipment necessary for the practice’s sophisticated, 21st century oral surgery procedures. So they decided to build a new, larger building in a similar design style. “It was a great facility and worked for a long time, but it didn’t have the electronic and digital networking we wanted for a modern practice,” Dr. Schneider says. “So we made sure our new space was built to be state-of-the-art and was completely networked, with a lot video displays.”
New facility, improved amenities
“I want my buildings to be different designs and styles, and to focus on making it the owner’s building, not mine,” says Michael Turner, project architect for Design Build Evolutions/The Evolutions Properties | January 2020
Group – Ohio LLC; Turner has since joined HFG Health Architecture in Tulsa, Oklahoma. Turner worked with Dr. Schneider on the initial concept for a new 3,633-square-foot companion building directly behind the original, starting from early hand-drawn sketches. “Dr. Schneider wanted a combination of Tudor and modern farm house styles and was very clear on his vision,” Turner adds. “I wanted to capture the owner’s personality since they are the ones who would be living and working in it.” Turner also oversaw the reconfiguring and re-skinning of the original building. The previous entranceway was redesigned, and he added a new entry. The facility now houses the practice of an orthodontist who remained in the original building, along with an updated space for conferences and continuing education programs. The new meeting
Proud to be part of the team for Ohio Center for Oral Facial & Implant Surgery
Euromark Cabinets
Custom Cabinets Counter Tops Mark Studer President
38348 Airport Parkway, Unit D, Willoughby, OH 44094 440.951.EURO (3876) | Fax 440.951.0951
We are proud to have provided general contracting services for Ohio Center for Oral, Facial & Implant Surgery
“Dr. [Keith] Schneider wanted a combination of Tudor and modern farm house styles and was very clear on his vision. I wanted to capture the owner’s personality since they are the ones who would be living and working in it.” Michael Turner Project architect space is named the E. Karl Schneider Center for Education to honor Dr. Schneider’s father, who died in 2017. The exterior of the new building features Westby Sheeting materials complemented by Hardie Board composite concrete that is durable, long-lasting and designed to resemble wood. Fiberglass insulation provides an R19 value in the walls. The building is primarily wood frame with a wood roof deck and threedimensional black roofing shingles. Except for black doors, the new structure was originally painted white with an all-white trim. The Hardie siding came in beige, and at first, everyone liked the contrast with the white trim – everyone except Dr. Schneider, who thought a black trim might really pop visually. He took a photo of the freshly constructed building, “doctored” it to
National Leaders in the Construction of Controlled Environment Facilities
KRC
KLINE ROSTOCIL c o n s t r u c t i o n 440-357-4500 | 9385 Hamilton Dr., Mentor, OH 44060 www.klineconstruction.com | Since 1980 | Nationwide Builder
Commercial | Medical | Veterinary | Dental www.propertiesmag.com 39
SETTLING DOWN In the lobby, patients can relax in comfortable furniture while a television monitor nearby runs a looped video of tropical fish swimming through an underwater sea cavern.
display black trim, and sent it to the City of Mentor officials. “They had no problem with it,” says Robert Greiser, senior project manager from Kline Rostocil Construction, General Contractors in Mentor. “The white was kind of ‘blah,’ and now the black trim really jumps out at you.” Above an eye-catching recessed ceiling, the wood truss attic houses the sprinkler system and four separate HVAC units to serve four distinct quadrants within the building. The four quadrants and the separation of reception and patient consultation areas, Dr. Schneider explains, are important for the practice to earn accreditation as an ambulatory
surgery center, which he is now in the process of pursuing.
Form + function
In the original building, space for waiting patients was at a premium, often resulting in awkward standingroom-only situations. Now, patients can relax in comfortable furniture selected by Dr. Schneider, after he worked with Turner to make initial design and color choices. He wrestled with the idea of purchasing a large aquarium to provide a dynamic visual accent for patients next to the reception desk. However, concerns over dealing with the ongoing care
PROUD TO HAVE PROVIDED THE SPRINKLER SYSTEM FOR OHIO’S CENTER FOR ORAL, FACIAL & IMPLANT SURGERY
and maintenance of real fish convinced him to instead have the audio/video equipment installer set up a television monitor that runs a 20-minute video loop of tropical fish frolicking through an underwater sea cavern. Fittingly, for the 2019/2020 holiday season, Dr. Schneider switched the video loop to a fireplace scene. “At the coffee bar in the lobby, we usually do some product displays, but mostly we try to make things seem like you’re not in a surgeon’s office,” he says. “We wanted the building to feel right regarding the human scale which is very important and do something that resembles a comfortable living room,” says Turner of the building, which was completed in April 2019. “You’re also looking at patient flow so a patient who is just discharged never crosses paths with one who is waiting. There is a special corridor towards the back where patients can exit when they are finished and can be picked up on the side of the building.”
Offices + operatory spaces
440.234.0700 | WWW.RMRIGGLE.COM 879 W. BAGLEY RD. | BEREA, OH 44017 40
Opening the door into the office space, patients transition from one carpet tile design to a matching color luxury vinyl tile that resembles stone flooring. Properties | January 2020
C O M M E R C I A L
Proud to be the window supplier and part of the project team at Ohio’s Center for Oral, Facial and Implant Surgery For more information, contact the Pella Commercial Dept. at 216-586-6959 or visit www.pella.professional.com
www.northcoastpaving.com
2417 Woodhill Rd., Cleveland, OH 44104
(216) 421-1203
• Pavement Milling • Asphalt Paving & Maintenance • Site & Sewer Work • Line Striping & Sealcoating
HIDDEN FROM VIEW Situated just behind a comfortable operating chair (top), handsome cabinetry conceals dental equipment (middle). Complementary storage cabinets can be found throughout the building (bottom).
Throughout, the color palette features light gray walls with matching tones in the floor. Patients are then greeted by coordinators who can discuss dental insurance and payment options. From there, they can progress directly into a high-tech room equipped with a dental cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) scanner, which is a special type of x-ray equipment used when regular dental or facial x-rays are not sufficient. Dr. Schneider and his partners employ this technology to produce three-dimensional (3D) images of a patient’s teeth, soft tissues, nerve pathways and bone in a single scan. “With that equipment, a lot of software and data files merge so that we can create an implant guide for surgical procedures,” Dr. Schneider says. “We don’t
“We made a template so that when we roughed everything in we knew where each piece of equipment was going to be located. There was no room for it to be even a few inches off. Each one had to be right on the money.” Robert Greiser Kline Rostocil Construction do goopy impressions anymore. Instead, it’s all digital scans of people’s mouths.” Further down the hallway, there are two consultation rooms equipped with a patient examination chair, comfortable chairs for family members, a desk and a sizable video monitor high on the wall to project digital scans of the patient’s head and mouth. Blackout shades ensure clearer images for discussion of treatments or more complex surgical procedures, such as sinus lifts to create more breathing space and restore bone, for example. In the office’s dental lab, there is a 3D printer which staff can use to print models of people’s teeth. In addition to acting as implant guides, the models enable doctors to pre-bend plates that www.propertiesmag.com 43
go on individuals’ faces, saving time in the operating room and shortening the length of surgical procedures. “Essentially, we’re all about less pain for our patients,” Dr. Schneider says. “We strive for faster surgery, which leads to less swelling and thus less pain.”
Pièce de résistance: operatory suites
Dr. Schneider worked closely with Turner and Greiser to develop innovative operatory cabinetry. Before sitting in a comfortable, ergonomically designed operating chair, patients see only the chair, an equipment table and some attractive counters and cabinets. Within the cabinets, all of the drills, nitrous oxide tanks and other anesthesia apparatus, and the more intimidating dental equipment are well-concealed. Once the patient is seated, the doctor can then open the cabinets and pull out all of the equipment on rollers. The cabinets above the counters also have dispensary holes in them for gloves, cups, paper towels and surgical masks. There are also dispensary holes for waste and biohazardous materials. The only items visible on the counters are the sink, mouth rinse and tongue depressors to lend a couple of familiar, functional medical touches. “Keeping the medical equipment hidden within special cabinetry throughout the building helps keep the patients comfortable,” Turner says. “We call them the ‘12 o’clock cabinets,’ so when patients walk into the room they don’t see all the equipment which is situated behind them.” Turner explains that Dr. Schneider helped design much of that cabinetry after extensively researching the equipment and their optimum placement within the operating rooms.
COMPLEMENTING COLORS Throughout the surgery center, a muted color palette features light gray walls with matching tones in the floor.
“Everything had to be in a certain place” says Greiser. “We made a template so that when we roughed everything in we knew where each piece of equipment was going to be located. There was no room for it to be even a few inches off. Each one had to be right on the money.” Individual medical gas monitors and controls are located outside of each operating room.
Mission accomplished
Dr. Schneider and his partners all wanted the staff to be comfortable, too. So, the staff lounge boasts customdesigned lockers that match the floor paneling design, as well as kitchen equipment and a monitor above the table where they can watch YouTube videos at lunchtime. The room also doubles as a casual morning meeting room.
SINCE 1972
Façade Inspection | Tuckpointing/Caulking Pressure Washing | Brick & Stone Repair/Replacement 216.881.4142 | 4408 St. Clair Avenue | Cleveland, Ohio 44103 www.hmhrestoration.com 44
Down the hallway, a soundproofed closet contains the vacuum equipment and compressed air tanks, which alternate each day to save wear and tear and provide a backup. There is also water filtration equipment; all water is filtered, and then re-filtered for the autoclave instrument sterilization room. A rear door built for gas tank delivery features a buzzer and camera so that staff can see who has arrived. There are also two recuperation and recovery bays to provide a quiet, comfortable place where patients can recuperate. Procedures range from an hour-long basic examination or treatment to more intense, three- to eight-hour surgical procedures. The latter require more extensive recovery time. Ultimately, the doctors and staff do everything in their power to ensure that patients are comfortable and relaxed throughout their stay. The design and construction of the new building certainly support that key mission. “Our new space is phenomenal; we couldn’t ask for better,” enthuses Amanda Robinson, practice manager, who joined the center when her business merged with Dr. Schneider’s. “It truly is an awesome entryway and lobby. It’s comfortable, relaxing and very inviting. “Not only is our staff welcome, but patients feel a little bit less apprehensive, so a lot of good things happen just because of the new atmosphere.” P Properties | January 2020
2019
FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST
2020 Crunching the Numbers on Northeast Ohio’s Real Estate & Construction Markets
2019
FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST
Photo on pg. 45 & 46 by Aerial Agents
2020
Where We Are + Where We’re Going
CBRE offers an overview of Northeast Ohio commercial real estate 2019/2020 Story & graphics provided by CBRE
A
s 2020 kicks off, these continue to be very good times in the commercial real estate industry with solid fundamentals across the board. Challenges remain however, as we confront tight labor markets and rising construction costs. As we launch the new decade in 2020, exciting new developments are underway and on the horizon throughout the region. Best wishes for continued success and let’s hope that the momentum continues!
Northeast Ohio Industrial Outlook By Michael Howard Vice President
2020
Northeast Ohio OUTLOOK OFFICE
INDUSTRIAL
RETAIL
VACANCY INVENTORY LEASE RATES SALES PRICES
It’s an exciting time here in Northeast Ohio. We’re witnessing a transformation of the area through the repurposing of our real estate. In and around downtown Cleveland, residential demand has developers offering premiums for well-located industrial properties. This adaptive re-use 46
Capital Markets ACTIVITY
SALES PRICES
provides companies such as Cleveland Vibrator and Voss Industries the opportunity to relocate out of what in many cases are functionally challenged buildings and into properties with greater efficiencies. We see craft brewers, such as Platform, renovating long vacant multi-story
industrial buildings and a charter school now occupying a former Hugo Boss plant. Self-storage operations are filling vacated grocery stores, retail and factories. Other big box retail, such as the Garfield Heights Kmart and the Walmart in Bedford, are being converted to industrial uses. Although Northeast Ohio retains a large number of very vibrant manufacturing operations, overall, we have made the transition from a manufacturing to a service/distribution oriented economy. The U.S. Bureau of Labor indicates that 12% of our employment is from manufacturing. This is substantiated in the Weatherhead 100 with 27 manufacturing-related companies and, even more significant, only 15 manufacturers in their 100 fastest growing companies list. The impact of e-commerce has been a tremendous boon to our econProperties | January 2020
When all you do is construction law, complex issues are a lot simpler
Claims Management, Analysis & Avoidance | Competitive Bidding Disputes | Workplace Safety Construction Litigation, Arbitration & Mediation | Contract Drafting & Negotiation | Surety Law | Lien & Bond Claims FrantzWard.com
FW091_CnstrcnAD20_7x4.875_121819.indd 1
12/20/19 4:53 PM
LOCAL ADVANTAGE. CBRE knows Cleveland. Through our industry leading perspectives, scale and local connectivity, we deliver outcomes that drive business and bottom-line performance for every client we serve in Cleveland. How can we help transform your real estate into real advantage? For more information contact or visit: David Browning | Managing Director T 216 687 1800 | www.cbre.us/cleveland Jan2019_PropMGZ.indd 1
12/17/2018 11:45:23 AM 47 www.propertiesmag.com
4.5 4 3.5 3
Q1 2018
Q2 2018
Q3 2018
Q4 2018
R&D/Flex
Q1 2019
Q2 2019
Q3 2019
Multifamily
Industrial – Michael Howard
2019 Industrial Net Absorption & Lease Rate 250000
8 7
200000
6
150000
5 4
100000
3
50000
1st CHOICE ROOFING COMPANY
0 -50000
2 Southeast Southwest
South
West
Lake County West
Net Absorption
Geauga West
Northeast
East
Downtown
1 0
Lease Rate
omy. Amazon’s redevelopment of Euclid Square, Randall Park and Rolling Acres malls has created hundreds of jobs and stability to revenue-starved communities. As such, developers have responded through both redevelopment of retail and former large manufacturing facilities, such as the Chrysler plant in Twinsburg, and also new construction of high bay product geared toward distribution. In forecasting, I like to begin with the premise that few things are able to turn on a dime. Without a significant disruptive event, change is likened to a ship altering course. Therefore, in reviewing the trends over the past year, 2020 should see the following:
• Construction: 2019 showed around 1 million square feet of new industrial construction. Given the success of speculative construction along with continued low interest rates, I believe that we’ll see an increase in the number.
• Industrial vacancy: 2019 saw a drop from 4% to 3.5% and I expect that trend to continue. I expect the demolition of functionally obsolete buildings, such as the Ford Motor plants, will reduce our industrial base and more than offset new construction.
• Growth is primarily organic: companies that are not new to the area and already have a Northeast Ohio presence
unavailability of product. Although we may be looking at an even tighter market in 2020, I believe that absorption will increase slightly through occupancy of the new high cube/efficient buildings.
1st CHOICE ROOFING COMPANY We are a customer service company providing unmatched integrity and education in the roofing and construction industry.
COPPER SLATE TILE HISTORICAL RESTORATION & PRESERVATION
1st CHOICE ROOFING COMPANY
10311 Berea Rd. Cleveland, OH 44102 www.1stchoiceroofing.com
216.227.7755 48
• Lease rates: 2019 witnessed an increase in the average industrial lease rate of a bit over 5%, from $4.67/SF to $4.93/ SF. Sustained demand and fewer alternatives for tenants, along with higher rates for new high cube product, will translate into another landlord-favored market with similar increases.
Some additional observations: • 2019 showed around 1 million square feet of new industrial construction. Given the success of speculative construction along with continued low interest rates, I believe that we’ll see an increase in the number.
• As companies review their facility alternatives, they will remain very aware of retaining and attracting employees • The demand for land will remain high due to the lack of existing product alternatives • Opportunity Zone (OZ) incentives will drive development in urban areas
• Sales prices: Demand will continue to outstrip supply and, with the cost of new construction so high, companies will seek existing buildings and be willing to pay a premium.
• The redevelopment of the former City View retail complex and the sale of at least one of the Ford Motor plants will facilitate industrial growth and the migration from old/inefficient properties
• Absorption: 2019 saw a drop-off in absorption, primarily due to the
• With developers focused on construction of high cube warehouses, small Properties | January 2020
bay flex product will see rate increases as demand continues to exceed supply In summary, I’m positive about the upcoming year for the Northeast Ohio industrial real estate market. The automotive and steel industry appear to be stable while our diversification could prove beneficial if the Bloomberg report of a 2020 pullback in capital expenditures by U.S. manufacturers proves accurate. (Non-manufacturing firms expect a 1.3% increase.)
Northeast Ohio Office Market By Isabel DeRoberts Associate, Advisory & Transaction Services & Conor M. Coakley First V.P., Advisory & Transaction Services 2020 is anticipated to be a pivotal year for the Northeast Ohio office market with “final-final” decisions forthcoming on the Sherwin Williams Headquarters relocation, Stark’s nuCLEus mixed-use development, and Millennia’s Centennial redevelopment of the historic Union Trust at 925 Euclid Ave. in Cleveland. With many large projects looming on the horizon, 2019 was the proverbial calmbefore-the-storm. Several distinct trends emerged, including “right-sizing,” blend-andextends and the success of landlords who invested in “amenitizing” their buildings in order to attract/retain those relatively few credit occupiers in the market. Factors such as the tightening labor market, increasing numbers of millennials in the workforce and overall cost efficiencies have all contributed to the changing preferences of occupiers. As the labor market continues to tighten, a shift is taking place with occupiers across all industries. Office space in no longer viewed as purely an
COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE FINANCING
Let us help you finance: • Multi-family, industrial, retail, office, residential lot development • Construction, refinancing and purchase financing • Fixed and variable rates
• Construction
expertise
• Market knowledge
and experience
LET’S TALK. John Funderburg
Vice President/Division Manager jfunderburg243@dollarbank.com
216.736.8955
Ron Adair
Vice President radair230@dollarbank.com
216.736.8957
Brandon Bucknell
Equal Housing Lender. Member FDIC. Copyright © 2020, Dollar Bank, Federal Savings Bank BUS889_19
Assistant Vice President bbucknell003@dollarbank.com
216.736.8962
Since 1922, Snow Bros. Appliance has offered exceptional service and extraordinary savings. With an unmatched selection, featuring all of your favorite kitchen and laundry brands, the possibilities are endless!
5528 Mayfield Rd. | (440) 449-2650 | www.snowappliance.com www.propertiesmag.com 49
2019
FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST
Y
2020 expense, but rather as a valuable tool for talent recruitment and retention. As we continue to witness the dominant trend of “right-sizing,” companies are opting for cooler spaces, with a strong emphasis on in-house amenities and location. “Right-sizing” has been driven largely by the need for increased efficiencies and accomplished primarily through the migration to open concept workplaces. As tenants reduce the amount of square footage occupied, they are opting to put that cost savings to work by investing in making their offices as inviting as possible. Conversely, landlords who have invested in their buildings’ common area amenities – such as fitness centers, conference facilities, on-site dining options, communal lounges and collaborative spaces – have experienced tremendous success over the past few years. Buildings with these amenities have a tremendous competitive advantage when occupiers get down to final decisions. Occupiers see additional building amenities outside of their four walls as further perks to pass on to their employees. Most notably is K&D Group’s success at Post Office Plaza, which was approximately 30% occupied
Leasing Activity (000s SF)
-
20
40
60
80
100
120
Southwest East CBD South
when they purchased in August 2017 and negotiate for tenant improvement and today is over 85% occupied.Retail – Jeremy allowances to revamp their space. This Bates 2019 was also the year of the “blend- has been a very common practice for and-extend” with many sizable tenants companies who understand the value and associated costs savings with SF (000s) $/SFcreated right-sizing and/or the 3,500 value from higher quality office space, but who are too far out on 3,000 their remaining term. 2,500 The market has seen a shift, primarily in millennial-heavy tenants, 2,000 trending away from the prototypi1,500 cal office parks and/or monolithic office towers and more towards 1,000 buildings with unique architec500 tural features, such as exposed opting for an brick-and-beam, and located in walk0 early renewal and modest 2017 Tenants H2 2017 have H1 2018 H2 2018 H1 2019 refresh of theirH1space. able neighborhoods/districts. Examples Under Construction taken this opportunity toPlanned lock in lower include The Avian, the conversion of lease rates, reduce total square footage a two-story historic brick warehouse building in the emerging Thunderbird GENERAL CONTRACTOR neighborhood in the Flats’ Scranton Keeping architects, engineers, subcontractors, and construction business owners on the Peninsula, as well as Settlers Pointe, same page is VITAL. the conversion of the former Sammy’s Restaurant & Catering Center into premier office space, and the soon-to-becompleted former Arhaus building along the East Bank of the Flats. The suburban office market has responded to these changing preferences as well. The Eastern Sub-Market experienced Trust Building Point Ohio Valley an incredible year of activity with the successful lease-up of Pinecrest, speaking Precision Laser & Instrument, Inc. to occupiers’ shifting preference to be in is Now Your Local BuildingPoint walkable environments with high-qualWe are dedicated to continually improving productivity for the ity amenities. Most notably was Time construction industry through Equities Inc.’s purchase of the former advanced and intuitive technologies. PNC Bank Building in Highland Hills. Our portfolio of solutions streamlines communication and collaboration, Through their aggressive leasing strategy helping realize greater efficiency and heavy investment in amenities, the and profitability. building will be at 90% occupancy in just The Experts in Design-Build-Operate Solutions over a year. The Western Sub-Market WWW.BUILDINGPOINTOHIOVALLEY.COM Ben Little | 330-607-6622 | BJL@bpohiovalley.com saw strong activity as well through sev-
Landlords who have invested in their buildings’ common area amenities – such as fitness centers, conference facilities, on-site dining options, communal lounges and collaborative spaces – have experienced tremendous success over the past few years.
Authorized Distribution Partner
50
Properties | January 2020
You Already Take Enough Risks You work with industry experts to reduce risks to you and your employees. Shouldn’t the same be true for your accounting firm?
ACCOUNTING EXPERTISE ◆ BUSINESS PLANNING ◆ TAX PLANNING SUCCESSION PLANNING ◆ PROFIT ENHANCEMENT ◆ BID REVIEWS COST CONTROL ◆ LITIGATION SUPPORT SERVICES ◆ JOB-COST AUDITING
MEADENMOORE.COM | 216.241.3272 AKRON | BEACHWOOD | CLEVELAND | WOOSTER
Commercial & Industrial 24/7/365, Since 1987
5500 Old Brecksville Road Independence, Ohio 44131 216-642-6040 p | 216-642-6041 f www.precision-env.com
eral sizeable lease commitments at new projects, including One Lakewood Place and Convergent. Looking forward in 2020, the Cleveland office market will begin to see the stronger impacts of coworking as large corporate occupiers continue to trend towards memberships at co-working spaces in lieu of smaller satellite offices. Smaller local/ regional companies will continue to take a closer look at these options as well. The attractiveness of premier office space, flexible lease terms and first-class amenities that co-working spaces offer will continue to shake-up the industry. For many smaller tenants, co-working presents the easiest means to achieve the highest quality work environment for their employees. As national co-working groups circle the Cleveland Market, the impact will be more substantially felt once one plants its flag. While working from what closely resembles a boutique hotel lobby with concierge services, espresso bar and Great Lakes Dortmunder on tap may not be for everyone, it certainly will be a viable future option for many.
Northeast Ohio Retail Market By Jeremy Bates Vice President The positive momentum carried into 2019 just as it did in 2018, which carried over from 2017 as the Northeast Ohio retail market continued to grow with new retailers such as Meijer and Menards entering the market. There is a positive outlook looking ahead in 2020. The availability rates at community centers and super regional centers dropped in 2019, as well as in mixed-use developments, such as Crocker Park in Westlake and Pinecrest in Orange. Meijer opened new locations in Mentor, Avon and Stow totaling over 540,000 square feet of positive net absorption. Menards 52
Properties | January 2020
New development With recent openings at Pinecrest (such as West Elm, Shake Shack, Whole Foods, Silverspot Cinema and Pinstripes) and The Van Aken District (including Bonobos, Shinola, Brassica, CLE Clothing Co. and GrooveRyde), there are other mixeduse developments on the horizon for Northeast Ohio. Such notable developments include: • Stark Enterprises’ plans to open nuCLEus, which is a proposed $350 million mixed-used development complex planned for the Gateway MIXED-USE MODEL In Shaker Heights, the Van Aken District incorporates a blend of commercial office space, retail storefronts and restaurants. A variety of similarly minded District of downtown Cleveland developments are currently in development throughout the region. in 2023. nuCLEus consists of two 24-floor towers, one residential opment at the marquee intersection this March and tenant delivery is tower and one office tower on top of West 25th and Lorain in Ohio scheduled for summer 2021. of retail and parking, including 250 City, Northeast Ohio’s most dynamic residential units, 1,300 parking spaces, urban neighborhood. Market Square • Horizon Group Properties is planning 80,000 square feet commercial/retail to develop The Outlet Shoppes at will consist of 36,000 square feet space, and 400,000 square feet of Class Cleveland, located across from Burke of retail and restaurant space, 290 A office space. Lakefront Airport at the I-90 and Route luxury apartments (eight stories) and • Harbor Bay is developing Market Square, a new high-profile redevel-
a 450-car parking lot adjacent the site. Demolition on the site will commence
2 interchange. The Outlet Shoppes at Cleveland will offer 323,000 square
www.propertiesmag.com 53
Photo by Aerial Agents
opened new locations in Avon and Brooklyn totaling over 460,000 square feet positive net absorption as well. Both the vacancy and availability rates have dropped in the past year making the current rates the lowest they have been in the past two years.
2019
FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST
2020 feet of outlet retail shopping, restaurants and entertainment on two levels. Development is projected to start spring 2020 and open in spring 2022. • Fairmount Properties is developing The Bluffs, a 52-acre mixed-use development on Rockside Road in Seven Hills, one of the most connected and regional
trade areas in the area via I-77 and I-480. The Bluffs will consist of approximately 80,000 square feet of retail and restaurant space, 100,000 square feet of Class A Office space, 350 luxury apartments and 160 single-family homes. The project is expected to break ground this spring, with tenant delivery in late 2021 and tenant opening in spring 2022.
• A new 16-acre mixed-use Crocker Road PUD development in Westlake. The development will feature 36,000 square feet of retail space and 63,000 square feet of office space, directly across from Crocker Park. The developer is planning to break ground in spring 2020, deliver space in spring 2021, and the opening is planned for fall 2021. • Somera Road is developing The Royalton Collection, a new development on Royalton Road in Strongsville across from SouthPark Mall and just off I-71 and I-80 Ohio Turnpike. Development is currently underway with the remaining turnover planned for spring and summer 2020. Outlook Northeast Ohio’s retail outlook for 2020 is optimistic and strong. The theme will continue as older inventory becomes obsolete and national and regional retailers, restaurants and entertainment venues increase their demand in Northeast Ohio for new developments or repositioning within the marketplace. This is a prime opportunity to be part of the retail community of Northeast Ohio.
Northeast Ohio Capital Markets By Jamie Dunford Associate, Advisory and Transaction Services | Occupier
Downtown Cleveland’s Premier Building Solutions Provider • Sustainable Heating and Cooling Solutions • Energy Auditing and Retro-Commissioning • Building Performance Optimization • Maintenance and Service Contracting
To learn more visit www.clevelandthermal.com 216.241.3636 | www.clevelandthermal.com 54
2019 continued the trend of heightened capital markets activity, not only in the U.S., but also locally in Northeast Ohio with a notable increase in real estate acquisitions and dispositions. In line with the past two years, CBRE expects this robust activity to carry over and continue into 2020 as total investment volume is expected to be between $478 and $502 billion. The U.S. real estate market will continue to remain a safe haven for investment, as its returns will become more attractive to investors, given the extremely low bond yields and Properties | January 2020
10
12.5
12.8
12.7
12.1
11.0
H1 2017
H2 2017
H1 2018
H2 2018
H1 2019
Vacancy Rate
-1000
Net Absorption
Capital Markets – Jamie Dunford
the expected increase in volatility of the equity markets. With historically low interest rates coupled with the downward pressure on cap rates from the increased capital markets activity, the demand for debt has increased as investors are using leverage to boost returns. The increase in the debt markets is attributable to the rise in lending from debt funds, mortgage REITs and other alternative lenders. Given the low cost of capital, investors continue to search for higher yields, which have, and will continue, to drive increased investments into secondary and tertiary markets such as Cleveland. The time to close deals in 2019 began to slow due to heightened investor caution, selectivity and escalated asset prices. Further, buyers are becoming more concerned with real estate tax reassessments from these increased asset prices – many of the assets are currently valued based on when they were constructed or acquired in the early innings of the recovery from the Great Recession. This has caused downward pressure on forwardlooking NOIs from acquirers and is resulting in lower initial purchase offers. Even with a few potential headwinds on the horizon, such as uncertainty surrounding the upcoming 2020 presidential election, investment capital or dry powder remains abundant. Expect M&A activity to continue, particularly among money managers, REITs, hedge funds and private equity as they have capital that needs to be deployed. Within Northeast Ohio, investors are seeking industrial properties as the property of choice – especially flex – being driven by e-commerce. Multifamily remains active and is also one of the preferred assets of choice. Valuations across most assets in the market are close to or are at the peak, and as a result, profit taking from local and private owners is likely. Cleveland has seen a wave of outside capital – institutional and private equity – flow into real estate assets over the past two years. This is a trend expected to continue given that Northeast Ohio doesn’t experience the abrupt shock waves like the coastal markets do during intermittent periods of downturn.
Vacancy Rates in R&D/Flex and Multifamily 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
Q1 2018
Q2 2018
Q3 2018
Q4 2018
R&D/Flex
Value-add acquisitions will continue to be the dominant theme due to the ability to generate strong returns in a short period, particularly within multifamily and office properties. There is an increased appetite for portfolio transactions where out-of-town buyers can
Northeast Ohio’s retail outlook for 2020 is optimistic and strong. The theme will continue as older inventory becomes obsolete and national and regional retailers, restaurants and entertainment venues increase their demand in Northeast Ohio. realize economies of scale on expenses, primarily staffing, across multiple assets. Larger institutional players are seeking Class A or NNN lease product that is stabilized with long-term tenant-credit leases where they can simply clip a coupon in the investment.
Q1 2019
Q2 2019
Q3 2019
Multifamily
The downtown Cleveland renaissance is still moving forward, and the downtown population is expected to surpass 20,000 residents in 2020 with the delivery of new living product, both ground-up construction and building conversions. In addition to downtown, an increase in Class B or workforce housing is expected, given its general stability from economic shocks and the solid returns it provides to cautious investors. The sale of multifamily developments and conversions should be on the horizon over the coming years as many of these were delivered in the early half of the decade. Further driving these expected dispositions is the upcoming burn-off of historic tax credits and new markets tax credits which allow owners and developers to sell once the window expires. Given the access to leverage, the vast amounts of investment capital that is available, and the improving dynamics of the greater Cleveland economy, CBRE expects 2020 to be very active yet again. P
Experts In Exterior Masonry Repair & Restoration
McMahon Masonry Restoration Brick + Stone Repair & Replacement Caulking | Tuckpointing | Sealing Pressure Washing | Building Cleaning 9449 Brookpark Rd. Unit A, Parma, OH 44129 216-778-9666 | Fax 216-661-4520 | mcmahonrest1@att.net
Call for Your Free Building Inspection & Assessment www.propertiesmag.com 55
2019
FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST
2020
National Construction Outlook 2020
Dodge Data & Analytics sees U.S. economy, construction market at ‘tipping point’ Provided by Dodge Data & Analytics
T
he U.S. economy and construction market have reached a tipping point. After a solid 10-year economic expansion and moderately healthy recovery in construction, total construction starts are now tipping over the edge into decline. Total starts reached a peak at $815 billion in 2018 and will inch down 1% to $809 billion in 2019. The Pattern of U.S. Construction Starts Billions of Dollars Total Construction
Residential construction Housing starts are almost always at the leading edge of the business cycle because their fate is closely tied to interest rates, which the Federal Reserve Board uses in monetary policy to slow down or speed up economic growth. So, even though neither the overall economy nor the construction market has yet reached a peak, the apex for housing starts has likely already come and gone. Total housing starts on a Dodge basis reached 1.375 million units in 2018 and are expected to have fallen 6% in 2019 to 1.290 million units. The dollar value of starts pulled back 5% in 2019 to $314 billion after reaching a peak at $330 billion in 2018.
Commercial construction Commercial construction, like housing, typically turns early in the business cycle. And, like housing, the peak for commercial construction has already come knocking. The square footage of commercial construction starts actually peaked in 2017 at 770 million square feet (msf), while the dollar value of those starts (before adjusting for inflation) is expected to peak this year at $126.6 billion. Commercial construction starts are expected to have fallen 2% in 2019 to 741 msf (4% below the 2017 peak), while dollar value will gain 3%. In 2020, commercial starts will decline in both square footage and dollar value as the economy softens after a decade of 56
Commercial Buildings
2015
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
689.9
739.0
788.3
815.1
808.7
776.4
+14%
+7%
+7%
+3%
-1%
-4%
93.5
115.3
116.9
123.3
126.6
119.5
+12%
+23%
+1%
+6%
+3%
-6%
25.3
20.3
26.2
32.8
23.1
22.7
-29%
-19%
+29%
+25%
-29%
-2%
Institutional Buildings
110.1
122.7
144.8
140.5
142.7
142.5
+5%
+11%
+18%
-3%
+2%
0%
Single-Family
186.2
201.2
218.4
230.1
223.5
216.8
+14%
+8%
+9%
+5%
-3%
-3%
+87.5
96.4
88.8
99.8
90.6
78.5
+24%
+10%
-8%
+12%
-9%
-13%
129.3
136
161.4
164.4
157.9
164.3
+6%
+5%
+19%
+2%
-4%
+4%
58.0
47
31.8
24.1
44.2
32.2
+131%
-19%
-32%
-24%
+83%
-27%
Manufacturing Buildings
Multifamily Public Works Electric Utilities/Gas Plants
expansion. Commercial square footage will decline 10% in 2020 to 670 million square feet, and dollar value will drop 6% to $119.5 billion.
Institutional construction Institutional building includes a diverse group of structure types, from schools and hospitals to airline terminals and enclosed sports arenas. The common thread linking these structures is that to some degree they all rely on public funding. The stabilizing influence of public funding also results in a lagged relationship with the overall business cycle. While the Great Recession ended in 2009,
the dollar value of institutional starts didn’t reach bottom until 2012, and square footage reached a cyclical low in 2013. Starts rose rapidly in the aftermath. And although they pulled back in 2018, the decline was the result of a large pullback in transportation following 2017 groundbreakings on massive projects at both LaGuardia International Airport and Los Angeles International Airport. In 2019, institutional starts increased 2% to $142.7 billion, although square footage slipped a slight 1% to 337 msf. The dollar value of starts will remain essentially flat in 2020 at $142.5 billion with square footage declining 4% to 323 msf. Properties | January 2020
Source: Dodge Data & Analytics
With a potential economic storm (or at least some rain) gathering on the horizon, total construction starts are expected to decline 4% further in 2020 to $776 billion.
Here’s a quick look at the highlights of the 2020 forecast: • Single-family housing starts peaked in 2018 at 833,000 units ($230 billion), then headed 3% downward in 2019 and will drop another 5% in 2020 to a cyclical low of 765,000 units. The dollar value of singlefamily housing starts will slide 3% in 2020 to $217 billion after falling 3% in 2019. The single-family downturn will be mild since its recovery barely got off the ground. • Multifamily housing starts reached a peak in 2018 at 542,000 units ($99.8 billion) and will drop 11% in 2019 and 15% in 2020 as starts fall to 410,000 units. In dollar terms, multifamily starts slid 9% in 2019 and will be followed by a 13% drop this year to $78 billion. The multifamily downturn will be more definitive since the sector’s expansion was robust – even exceeding the previous 2005 peak. • Commercial building starts are expected to have peaked in 2019 at $127 billion, although square footage peaked in 2017 at 770 msf. In 2020, starts will slide a more pronounced 10% to 670 msf, and dollar value will fall 6% to $120 billion. Performance in commercial building has varied substantially by category – warehouses and hotels have performed exceptionally well, offices have increased moderately but stores and shopping centers have shown dismal outcomes. • Institutional building starts peaked in 2017 at $145 billion (347 msf) as a number of massive airline terminal renovations/expansions broke ground. Starts pulled back in 2018 as activity returned to more sustainable levels. In 2019, a modest increase in the dollar value of starts was unable to pull activity above that 2017 level. Starts will grow 2% to $143 billion, although square footage will dip 1% to 337 msf. In 2020, institutional starts will slide
effects of the economic slowdown in 2020 because the sector is publicly funded and responds to changing economic conditions with a lag.
4% to 323 msf, and dollar value will remain little changed at $142 billion. • Manufacturing construction peaked in 2018 at $32.8 billion (84.7 msf) and tumbled sharply in 2019, to be followed by another decline in 2020. The downturn is the result of the U.S.-China tumult over trade and tariffs that has pushed the U.S. manufacturing industry into decline. After falling 16% in 2019, the square footage of starts will slide another 9% in 2020 to 64.4 msf. Dollar value fell a steeper 29% in 2019, then is expected to drop just 2% in 2020 to $22.7 billion.
• Electric power/utility construction consists of a small number of very large (multi-billion-dollar) projects and therefore does not particularly move with economic cycles. Rather, it rides a roller coaster of ups and downs based on energy prices and legislative/regulatory changes. In 2019, starts surged 83% to $44.2 billion, following two years of doubledigit declines. In 2020, the market will respond to last year’s massive increase with another 27% decline to $32.2 billion – still an elevated level of activity for the sector. P
• Public works construction starts will drop 4% to $158 billion in 2019, but the downturn will be due to a sharp decline in other nonbuilding following a surge in pipeline construction. Starts will revive 4% in 2020 to $164 billion. Public works won’t yet feel the
Reprinted with permission from Dodge Data & Analytics’ “2020 Dodge Construction Outlook.” For more information, visit Dodge Data & Analytics online at www.construction.com.
Subscribe Now & Save Over 80% Stay informed on the very best in construction and development in Northeast Ohio. Subscribe online or by phone at 216.251.8506.
INSIDE : Cleveland
Clinic Rehabilitation
l • Roofing/Building Hospital • AkzoNobe
INSIDE : SpringHill Suites Independence
Envelope
• Hyatt Place at Legacy Village •
Green Building
September 2016/$7.95
April 2016/$7.95
INSIDE : MetroHealth Brecksville
Health & Surgery Center
INSIDE : Larry Sears • Renovation & Restoration
and Sally Zlotni ck Sears think[ box] at CWRU
• Phoenix Buildi
ng
October 2016/$7.95
January 2016/$7.9 5
Celebrating 70 Years Since 1946
The Schofield ping akensResha Building Reaw historic Renovation revives to new structure as home Hotel apartments, Kimpton
Public Square
$50 million public-private project brings renewed energy to Cleveland’s most visible intersection
Encore Performance Resurgence on the
Restoration specialists re-create Ohio Theatre’s original lobby design at Playhouse Square
Waterfront
Flats East Bank Phase II sprou new residentia ts l, entertainment dining & experiences PLUS: Financial Revie w & Forecast
INDUSTRY LEADER SINCE 1946 Exclusive | Focused | Informative | Dependable | Connected
www.Propertiesmag.com www.propertiesmag.com 57
2019
FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST
2020
FINANCIAL STRATEGIES Smart use of fiscal planning & action
Gone but Not Forgotten
M
ost people have no idea who George Santayana is, or more importantly, what significance he has as it relates to this month’s column. The good news is that, by the time you finish reading this, you will have learned a new tidbit of knowledge. The bad news is that you may not be thrilled with how everything ties together.
ALEC J. PACELLA
The Financial Strategies column in the January issue of Properties magazine has traditionally been a look back at the prior year, specifically in the wonderful world of commercial real estate investment. This year, I’m going to take a slightly different approach. We are still going to review activity and trends from last year but against a backdrop of what was going on in Northeast Ohio’s real estate market a decade earlier. That’s right, I’ve reached way back into the Properties magazine archives to find the Financial Strategies column that appeared in the January 2009 issue. The significance of that specific issue may not be immediately apparent. But consider the following; the real estate
investment sales volumes in 2006, 2007 and 2008 were $1.25 billion, $1.4 billion (which, at that time, was a record volume) and $550 million, respectively. Some saw this trend as a return to normal while others saw it as an ominous forewarning of a pending downturn. We all know which scenario proved to be correct. Fast forward several years and the sale volumes in 2017, 2018 and 2019 were $1.3 billion, $1.47 billion (which set a new record in volume) and $570 million, respectively. Before we draw any conclusions, let’s discuss some other similarities. One of the highlights of the January 2009 column was what I called ‘Slow but Steady’; vacancy rates were hover-
www.ramservices.com The Lumen (Cleveland)
FOUNDED IN 1918
New Construction Building Façade Weatherproofing Restoration
Concrete Restoration
Department of Transportation
Maintenance & Repairs
440.740.0100 | 100 CORPORATION CENTER, BLDG 4 | BROADVIEW HEIGHTS, OHIO 58
Properties | January 2020
ing at historically low levels, there was moderate growth in rental rates, new construction was occurring with increasing frequency and the industrial sector was performing the best, followed by the multi-family and retail sectors, with the office sector bringing up the rear. The story for 2019 was very similar. Vacancy rates rivaled the historically low levels from a decade earlier across all of the major sectors. Rent growth was widespread, averaging between 1% and 3% year over year, depending on property type and location. New construction was humming last year, with over three million square feet underway in the bustling
Most believe the catalyst for the downturn a decade ago was rooted in the disastrous subprime mortgage sector... Once the sector turned into a freefall, there was enough suction to take everything else down with it, including the commercial real estate market. A decade later and the financial landscape is much different. industrial sector and nearly 1,000 units under development in the multi-family sector. And the industrial sector was again the star. Another highlight of the January 2009 column was termed ‘Low Stress’; despite a tightening debt market, interest rates had fallen over the course of 2008. The example I used was the oft-quoted 10-year treasury rate, which started that year at 4.12% and ended the year at 2.10%. Fast-forward to 2019 and we find that same 10-year treasury rate was 2.56% at the start of the year as compared to 1.88% at the end of the year. In that same 2009 highlight, I made reference to the performance of the U.S. stock market, as represented by the Dow Jones Industrial Average. Over the course of that prior year, this index had increased 16.5%. Again, fast-forward to 2019 and the DJIA increased by just over 21%.
The last highlight in the January 2009 column was called ‘Blue Light Special’. This illustrated several properties which had sold for record pricing in prior years but had subsequently seen their value dramatically diminished over the course of 2008. A specific example used was the now-infamous CityView Center. It had sold for a record $100 million in 2006 but due to a series of store closures as well as
site and construction flaws (real, perceived or a combination), it was worth a fraction of that as 2009 came to a close. Ten years later and the market appears to be falling into this same pattern. Although nothing compares in magnitude to CityView, there are several transactions that may be heading down this same path. There have been numerous single-tenant sales in the $700 to $800 per-square-foot range featuring Thorson • Baker + Associates Structural, Mechanical, Electrical, Technology, Commissioning & Civil Engineering Services
330.659.6688
www.thorsonbaker.com
How Bad is tHat Leak?
Keep your assets safe by taking the time to ensure that problems at the top of your building are not damaging your bottom line.
Carey Roofing Corp. has eliminated asset damage due to a leaking roof with practical solutions since 1946. 216 • 881 • 1999 CaReY www.careyroofing.com
Roofing Corp.
founded in 1946
MEMBER: National Roofing Contractors Association www.propertiesmag.com 59
Buying, Building and Managing, We Are Your Team
Construction
Facility Management
Property Management
FAMILY OWNED. SUSTAINABLE GROWTH. SINCE 1976.
At the foundation of every Pleasant Valley client relationship and every project is our focus on meeting your needs for buying, building and managing facilities within a full circle of integrated services. 1093 Medina Rd., Medina, OH 44256 | 330.239.0176 | www.pleasantvalleycorporation.com
tenants with less-than-stellar credit, retail center sales in the $300 to $400 per-squarefoot range featuring suspect tenant rosters and industrial build-leases with sale prices that exceeded replacement cost. We are but one hiccup away from many of these razor-thin deals turning ugly. In spite of these striking similarities, there are some distinct differences. Foremost is the underlying financial market. Most believe that the catalyst for the downturn a decade ago was rooted in the disastrous subprime mortgage sector. Although this sector was fairly narrow, it had deep inroads in the more traditional financial market. And once the sector turned into a freefall, there was enough suction to take everything else down with it, including the commercial real estate market. A decade later and the financial landscape is much different. Although subprime mortgages are still around, regulation and safeguards that surround their use has greatly increased. Equally impor-
dramatic growth of e-commerce, continued low cost of energy and a long run of historically low unemployment rates. So how does George Santayana fit into all of this? He was the famed writer who once said, “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” I’m not saying that everything is going to fall off the cliff in 2020, just like it did in 2009. However, we’ve been on a long run, just like a decade ago. It seems like the party isn’t going to stop anytime soon, just like a decade ago. We can come up with all sorts of “yeah, but this time it’s different” arguments, just like a decade ago. What I am saying is that although 2019 was another great year in the commercial real estate market, I’m not forgetting 2009. P
What I C @ PVC SCRATCH A retail/showroom located at 6505 Mayfield Rd. sold in late November. The 12,300-square-foot facility was built in 2004 and sold for $2.25 million or $183 per square foot. It had been built, owned and occupied by Danny Veghs, which filed for bankruptcy in 2018. –AP tant are subsequent changes that have occurred in the securitized debt industry, which was a favored ‘exit strategy’ for subprime loans once they were originated. If the subprime loan sector was fueling the fire, the CMBS market was a major fan that spread those flames. There are other differences. Some are related to the broader financial markets, including increased regulation and scrutiny within the commercial real estate lending sector, a broader base of lenders and a long run of historically low interest rates. Others are related to the general economy, including the
Serving Northeast Ohio For Over 60 Years!
Residential ■ Commercial ■ Industrial ■ Institutional
Alec Pacella, CCIM, senior vice president at NAI Pleasant Valley, can be reached by phone at 216.455.0925 or by email at apacella@naidaus. com. You can follow him on twitter @dausyouknow or on his blog at http://blog.sbequitiesinc.com.
Fabrication, Installation & Service
lizing f
Specia
Expert Brick Matching and Complete Inventory of Brick, Block, Masonry, Cast & Natural Stone, Plaster Products & Tools
16900 Rockside Rd., Maple Heights, OH 44137
216.791.9800 ■ www.bruderinc.com
ars in:
35 ye or over
top ater ed roof g Packag team & hot w weldin s – & s n r e o l i Boi icat tal fabr & welding e m t e e Sh tion fabrica c i t s nt a g l P ineerin nce departme g n e d tena Value e main c i v r e s Full
440.237.1777 • www.liscohvac.com 12608 State Rd., N. Royalton, OH 44133 www.propertiesmag.com 61
2019
FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST
2020
VANTAGE POINT Experts weigh in on industry issues
Depreciation – The Easiest Deduction to Control
I
n business, what is the easiest tax deduction item to control and change? The answer is depreciation. Ever Since President Reagan signed the Economic Recovery Act of 1981, combined with the Tax Reform Act of 1986 and the Modified Accelerated Cost Recovery System (MACRS), business and individual taxpayers have enjoyed income tax shielding when investing in business assets through favorable depreciation regulations. CRAIG MILLER
62
Businesses invest in assets of all types. Investing in, acquiring or constructing productive-use business assets requires at least a basic knowledge of the capital budgeting decision-making process. Simple payback and ROI (net present value analysis) on an investment most often make or break a decision to invest. The timing and the tax method of accounting for the investment is in the taxpayer’s control. Proper accounting for business assets, including real estate, is more complex than you might think. An “owner” of depreciable buildings used in a trade or business or to produce income can be the lessor, lessee, owner or occupant. A careful examination of any “Lease Inducement” or “Tenant Allowance”
may be needed to determine the actual owner for tax purposes.
“Ownership” of assets defined: a. Legal title and right of possession of the property – not determinative per IRS and courts b. Legal obligation to pay for the property c. Responsibility to pay maintenance and operating expenses d. The obligation to pay any taxes on the property e. The risk of loss if the property is destroyed, condemned or diminished in value through obsolescence or exhaustion
Properties | January 2020
It is important for taxpayers and their advisors to understand that the IRS and courts place greater emphasis on points c, d and e. MACRS consists of two depreciation systems, including the General Depreciation System (GDS utilizes more aggressive and accelerated methods) and the Alternative Depreciation System (ADS provides longer lives; no accelerated methods). Consult with your CPA or tax professional to help determine depreciation deduction options for specific business assets. Depreciation is a powerful income tax shield and source of cash flow. To maximize this tax shielding benefit, companies most often use the accelerated depreciation method (GDS) to take advantage of the timing of the deductions. Taxpayers have options if they don’t need the tax deductions this year – either claim, or don’t claim, the accelerated deductions. Any accelerated deductions taken, but not fully used, merely carry forward in the form of a suspended loss.
New Bonus Depreciation Percentages
acquired personal property only, new or used. The 2019 deduction limit is now $1.02 million on qualifying busiPlaced in Service Qualified property ness assets, and Section 179 expensing Sept. 28, 2017 − Dec. 31, 2022 100% was expanded by Congress for the first time to also include qualified improve2023 80% ment property (QIP) and qualified real 2024 60% estate in the form of replacement roofs, 2025 40% replacement HVAC, replacement fire 2026 20% protection and alarm systems, and replacement security systems in non2027 None residential buildings beginning in 2028 and thereafter None 2018. Under the new tax laws you may also be eligible to claim the temporary special first year 100% bonus depreciacost recovery method that takes advantion deduction on new or used assets tage of the time value of money. that qualify through 2022.
Section 179 deduction expansion
First year 100% bonus depreciation
The Section 179 expensing allowance has been a permanent fixture of the Federal Tax Code since 1958. A business taxpayer can make an election under Section 179 to take some or all of the depreciation in the year of purchase for
The new tax law allows owners or investors in real estate to immediately write off all personal property and land improvements in any newly constructed or purchased properties through 2022. The special bonus depreciation was not
CELEBRATING
YEARS
Benefits of accelerated depreciation Each class of assets has a life and IRS table that specifies the amount of accelerated depreciation you are entitled to each year under GDS for different asset classes. (your CPA can show you the IRS table). When to take advantage of the timing of depreciation deductions requires planning and analysis. It is important to understand that taxpayers with business losses or expiring tax credits may have no need for additional tax deductions through depreciation in a particular tax year. The benefit of accelerated depreciation applies to segregated personal property or land improvements contained in a building structure and sitework, and can include electric service, special-use HVAC, special-use plumbing and interior finishes. You are getting more of a tax deduction in earlier years and therefore you recover the cost of your investment by getting tax deferrals now versus later. Simply put, accelerated depreciation is a
17
OF COST SEGREGATION 2002-2019
ACCELERATE DEPRECIATION AND SHIELD INCOME TAXES NOW • Cost Segregation • Energy Efficiency Certifications (179D) • New IRS Repair v. Capitalization
Call Craig Miller
Cleveland 440.892.3339 / Columbus 614.949.4185 Detroit 248.752.7433 / www.costsegexperts.com
THE REGION’S LEADING INCOME TAX REDUCTION EXPERTS www.propertiesmag.com 63
2019
FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST
2020 available for “used” building acquisitions prior to the 2017 tax law change. A buyer of commercial property or residential buildings can control the timing of depreciation deductions, depending on profit, anticipated length of ownership, and appetite for tax deductions. Don’t need the deductions? Don’t claim the Bonus Depreciation. For a purchase of an older building, owners will need a cost segregation study to identify qualifying personal property and land improvements. Bonus Depreciation-eligible personal property includes property that is permanently affixed to real estate, including primary and secondary business-specific electrical, business-use plumbing, possibly business-use HVAC, voice and data cabling, interior finishes and other building components.
“Permissible” method of accounting A growing number of real estate owners are turning to cost segrega-
tion studies, especially since 2017. The identification and segregation of personal property and land improvements in an acquired or constructed building asset is a “permissible” method of accounting under MACRS. Studies may be performed throughout the real estate lifecycle on acquired, renovated or newly constructed properties. Most studies are undertaken by qualified engineers and construction estimators when properties are initially placed in service, establishing this method of accounting. These studies are conducted by qualified engineers for any building or facility, existing or new. With the aid of an engineered cost segregation study, it is not unusual to identify and segregate 20%-30% of the depreciable building cost basis to a seven-year MACRS class life and 10%12% to a 15-year MACRS class life. The result is additional tax deductions in the current year. Be sure to seek out a cost segregation provider knowledge-
able about the IRS regulations in this specialized field.
Changing the depreciation method Internal Revenue Code Section 446 provides rules for accounting for different classes of assets, with the authority to change a method of accounting for depreciation of a building asset. Owners previously unaware of this technique may change their method of accounting for one or more buildings or facilities and realize previously unclaimed depreciation in the current tax year. Business and individual taxpayers must change their method of accounting by filing an “Application for Change in Accounting Method” with a timely filed income tax return. The change is allowed by the IRS Commissioner. Together with the accounting method change, cost segregation “look-back” studies allow taxpayers to replace their prior depreciation method, and retroactively claim all the depreciation that
M A R C U M R E A L E S TAT E & C O N S T R U C T I O N
WANT TO REMAIN ON TOP OF REAL ESTATE & CONSTRUCTION TRENDS? From financing and bonding issues to skilled labor challenges, count on a proactive business advisor with hands-on industry expertise to help your business exceed growth objectives. Ask Marcum.
For more information about Marcum Real Estate & Construction, contact: Roger Gingerich, Partner 440.605.7129 roger.gingerich@marcumllp.com
marcumllp.com
64
Properties | January 2020
they would have received had they performed a study when the property was originally placed in service.
IRS tangible property repair regulations Owners of commercial properties expend significant amounts of money each year for ongoing expenditures to operate and maintain their properties for the benefit of their business, their employees and their customers. In addition to being able to deduct bonus and accelerated depreciation, since 2014 owners can also elect to expense certain expenditures that previously were required to be capitalized and depreciated. This is a facts-and-circumstances determination. The new authority to change the accounting method for previously capitalized building or leasehold improvements from prior tax return years can generate large write-offs, all by automatic consent of the IRS. This accounting method change results in “squeezing” cash flow out of a building asset with permanent tax deductions. The IRS has also created three favorable Safe Harbor Elections that are available to evaluate ongoing expenditures as Routine Maintenance, as DeMinimis, or for Small Taxpayers only. Any of these Safe Harbors are annual elections available to the taxpayer. Be aware that building additions, adaptations (changes in use) or building restorations are categorized as “betterments” in the eyes of the IRS and are required to be capitalized over the longer building asset life. If you are planning to purchase or construct a building, or if you or your company acquired, constructed or made improvements to a building asset or constructed tenant improvements since 1986, consult with your CPA or a tax professional knowledgeable about real estate and accounting method changes. There could be significant depreciation and income tax benefits available for you – all IRS-approved. P
WE CRUSH OUR COMPETITION
Craig Miller, CPA, CGMA is president of Duffy + Duffy Cost Segregation Services Inc. For information, visit www.costsegexperts.com.
216-881-0608 | www.careydemolition.com 2695 E. 55th St. | Cleveland, OH 44104
YOUR INDUSTRY IS OUR BUSINESS. At Hahn Loeser, our Construction Team members are recognized as industry leaders by ChambersUSA ®, Best Lawyers® and SuperLawyers®. We offer our clients exceptional strength, leadership and industry knowledge. Our responsive team of hardworking professionals is committed to seeking outstanding results for our clients around the corner and across the country. For the latest legal developments impacting your business, subscribe to our blog at constructionlawinsights.com.
ROB REMINGTON, ESQ. | Construction Group Chair | rrr@hahnlaw.com ANDY NATALE, ESQ. | anatale@hahnlaw.com JEFF BRAUER, ESQ. | jabrauer@hahnlaw.com A ARON EVENCHIK, ESQ. | aevenchik@hahnlaw.com JEFF ROUSH | Director of Construction Services | jroush@hahnlaw.com
Hahn Loeser & Parks LLP | hahnlaw.com 200 Public Square | Suite 2800 Cleveland, OH 44114 | 216.621.0150 CLEVELAND | COLUMBUS | NAPLES | FORT MYERS | SAN DIEGO | CHICAGO CLEVELAND | COLUMBUS | NAPLES | FORT MYERS | SAN DIEGO | CHICAGO
COMMERCIAL, RESIDENTIAL & INDUSTRIAL DEMOLITION ASBESTOS SURVEYS & ABATEMENT • WRECKING
CAREY DEMOLITION www.propertiesmag.com 65
CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT Updated info on important projects in the region Project Report #: 01661 CSU SCIENCE & RESEARCH BUILDING RENOVATIONS PHASE 2 LOCATION: 2351 Euclid Ave. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) www.csuohio.edu PROJECT TYPE: Renovation CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STATUS: Work Underway OWNER: Cleveland State University Contact: Bruce Ferguson 2121 Euclid Ave., PS 218 Cleveland, OH 44115-2214 Phone: 216-687-5008 www.csuohio.edu ARCHITECT: Van Auken Akins Architects Contact: Justin Fleigel 1422 Euclid Ave., Ste. 1010 Cleveland, OH 44115 Phone: 216-241-2220 www.vaakens.com CM: Welty Building Company Ltd 3421 Ridgewood Rd., #200 Fairlawn, OH 44333-3119 Phone: 330-867-2400 www.tcco.com DESCRIPTION: Phase 2 - renovation of teaching labs including all interior remodeling trades - electrical - HVAC - controls - flooring drywall - painting - ductwork. Project Report #: 02063 OFFICE BUILDING LOCATION: Independence, OH (Cuyahoga County) www.pvcinc.com PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Project Proposed Pending Site Selection OWNER/DEVELOPER: Pleasant Valley Corp.
66
Contact: Gino Faciano, CEO 1093 Medina Rd., Ste. 100 Medina, OH 44256 Phone: 330-239-0176 www.pvcinc.com DESIGN/BUILDER: Pleasant Valley Northern Ohio 1093 Medina Rd., Ste. 100 Medina, OH 44256 Phone: 330-239-0176 www.pvcinc.com Project Report #: 02025 CUYAHOGA COMMUNITY COLLEGE MAIN CAMPUS PLAZA RENOVATION (PHASES 1 -3 ) LOCATION: E. 30th & Woodland Ave. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) www.tric.edu PROJECT TYPE: Renovation CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STATUS: Work Underway on Phase 3 - Set for 2020 Completion EST. VALUE: $28 million OWNER: Cuyahoga Community College Contact: Cindy Leitson 700 Carnegie Ave. Cleveland, OH 44115 Phone: 216-987-3510 www.tri-c.edu ARCHITECT: City Architecture Contact: Alex Pesta & Benny Chew 1368 E. 55th St. Cleveland, OH 44103 Phone: 216-881-2444 www.cityarch.com BUILDER: Cold Harbor Building Company Contact: Dale Griffis II & Werner Kunzi 115 Industrial Pkwy. Chardon, OH 44024 Phone: 440-285-8842 www.coldharbor.us
CIVIL ENG: R.E. Warner Associates STRUCTURAL ENG: R.E. Warner Associates MECH ENG: Algebra ABC DESCRIPTION: Phased renovation to exterior and plaza of main campus. Phase One: Completed 2016, demo of existing walls. Phase Two: Renovation of north and east sides. Phase Three: Renovation to southeast side to be completed yet 2019 - overall renovation of northwest side set for 2020 completion Project includes waterproofing - concrete work - drainage systems - benches, bike racks, ceiling barriers - irrigation system plantscaping - exterior lighting. Project Report #: 01763 NEXEN TIRE TECHNICAL CENTER LOCATION: 4014 Wheatley Rd. Richfield, OH (Summit County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Industrial PROJECT STATUS: Project Completed EST. VALUE: $5.2 million OWNER: Nexen Tire Contact: Aaron Neumann, Project Manager 4150 Highlander Pkwy., #400 Richfield, OH 44286 www.nexentireusa.com DESIGN/BUILDER: Ray Fogg Building Methods Inc. Contact: Mike Novachek 981 Keynote Circle, Ste. 15 Cleveland, OH 44131 Phone: 216-351-7976 www.fogg.com DESCRIPTION: 4 acres, 1 bldg, 2 stories, 34,000 sf. Two-story office with technical and testing area - modern lobby - working and break spaces - workout area - patio area. Project Report #: 01842 CLEVELAND POLICE HEADQUARTERS LOCATION: E. 75th St. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STATUS: Preliminary Plans In ProgressPossible 2021 Start EST. VALUE: $40 million OWNER: City of Cleveland Contact: Calvin Williams, Chief of Police 1300 Ontario St. Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-623-5000 www.cityofcleveland.oh.us OWNER’S REP: DS Architecture Contact: Jeff Meyers 315 Gougler Ave., Ste. 102 Properties | January 2020
Repair. Charting Your Destination? Restore. We’ve been helping companies steer new and better futures as Preserve. toward an icebreaker in forging strong new experts in exterior masonry
relationships for over 70 years!
Vertical Masonry Surfaces Brick Façades Storefronts Concrete Balconies Garage Structures
MMASONRY ASONRY ESTORATION RRESTORATION AINTENANCE, Inc. Inc. MMAINTENANCE, 216-883-1526
www.mrmrestoration.com
J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc. • Commercial Buildings • Construction Sites • Special Event Clean-Up • Concrete Cleaning • Carpet Cleaning • Window Cleaning • Wall Washing • Acoustical Ceilings
INDUSTRY LEADER SINCE 1946
1230 East Schaaf Road Brooklyn Heights, OH 44131
Exclusive | Focused | Informative | Dependable | Connected
216-749-1150
www.Propertiesmag.com
www.jvjanitorial.com
ASPHALT PAVING ASPHALT REPAIR SEALCOATING
UNNINGHAM
CRACK FILLING
PAVING CO
SEWER REPAIRS
• Excellent quality, competitive pricing & reliability
DRAINAGE
• Cunningham Paving is a family-owned business, with over 30 years of experience
LAYOUT & DESIGN COMPLETE SITE CONSTRUCTION EXCAVATION TO COMPLETION
• Licensed, bonded & insured • Our motto: “Keeping our customers satisfied, keeps them coming back.”
216.581.8600 www.cunninghampaving.com 20814 Aurora Rd., Warrensville Hts., OH 44146-1006 www.propertiesmag.com 67
Space Comfort co.
Heating & Cooling Family owned & operated with hands-on experience in mechanical contracting sales & service since 1964. Experts in: n Turnkey solutions, design/build & value engineering n Service, installation & maintenance of all makes & models of HVAC equipment & boilers n New, renovation, remodeling & restoration n Public & private Providing reliable, personal service to owners of retail centers, malls, apartment complexes, retirement housing in Ohio & neighboring states.
5201 Clark avenue, Cleveland OhiO 44102 n Ph. 216-281-2000 n Fax. 216-281-8420 n 800-203-9645
BETWEEN THE WEATHER & YOU SINCE 1922
WARREN ROOFING WARREN ROOFING AND INSULATING COMPANY
With 94+ years in business, Warren Roofing knows what it means to provide top-notch customer service and quality workmanship. We work directly with manufacturers to provide a complete selection of roof systems from single ply to modified/built up, liquid applied coating, solar and green roofing, along with maintenance and repairs.
Commercial/Industrial Roofing + Architectural Sheet Metal 68
440.439.4404
Fax 440.439.7523
www.warrenroofing.com Properties | January 2020
Kent, OH 44240 Phone: 330-678-6144 www.dsarchitecture.com ARCHITECT: K2M Design Inc. Contact: Scott Ross, project architect 3121 Bridge Ave. Cleveland State: OH Zip: 44113-3068 Phone: 216-357-2794 www.mbi-k2m.com BUILDER: GLP Superior Ltd. Contact: Fred Geis 1975 E. 61st St., Ste. 102 Cleveland, OH 44114 STRUCTURAL ENG: Barber & Hoffman Assocs DESCRIPTION: 10 acres, 1 bldg. New campus-style police station to replace former facility. Project Report #: 01877 ROCKY RIVER POLICE STATION LOCATION: 21012 Hilliard Blvd. Rocky River, OH (Cuyahoga County) www.rrpolice.com PROJECT TYPE: Renovation/Addition CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STATUS: Plans Complete - Demolition Underway - Completion Set For Fall 2020 Pending GC Selection EST. VALUE: $9 million OWNER: City of Rocky River Contact: Chief Kelly Stillman 21012 Hilliard Blvd. Rocky River, OH 44116 Phone: 440-331-0600 www.rrcity.com ARCHITECT: Richard L. Bowen + Assocs Inc. 2019 Center St., Ste. 500 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-491-9300 www.rlba.com STRUCTURAL ENG: Peller Associates DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 2 stories. New 3,000 sf jail - evidence processing and storage area special bay for processing cars as evidence - dispatch - offices - phased construction. Project Report #: 01883 BEACHWOOD POLICE STATION ADDITION LOCATION: 2700 Richmond Rd. Beachwood, OH (Cuyahoga County) www.beachwodohio.com PROJECT TYPE: Addition CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STATUS: Preliminary Plans in Progress Start Date Not Determined EST. VALUE: $12 million OWNER: City of Beachwood Contact: Chief Gary Haba 2700 Richmond Rd. Beachwood, OH 44122 Phone: 216-464-1234 ARCHITECT: Richard L. Bowen + Assocs Inc. 2019 Center St., Ste. 500 Cleveland, OH 44113
Phone: 216-491-9300 www.rlba.com CM AT RISK: Panzica Construction 739 Beta Dr. Cleveland, OH 44143 Phone: 440-422-4300 www.panzica.com DESCRIPTION: Detention center addition. Project Report #: 02078 BRENNAN MANUFACTURING OFFICE & WAREHOUSE ADDITION LOCATION: 6701 Cochran Rd. Solon, OH (Cuyahoga County) www.brennaninc.com PROJECT TYPE: Renovation/Addition CATEGORY: Industrial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Work Underway 2nd Quarter Completion OWNER: Brennan Industries 6701 & 30205 Solon Rd. Solon, OH 44139 Phone: 440-248-7088 www.brennaninc.com ARCHITECT: Richard L. Bowen + Assocs Inc. Contact: David Bowen 2019 Center St., Ste. 300 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-491-9300 www.rlba.com DESIGN/BUILD: Adam Building Company Contact: Gene Stancak 4475 Renaissance Pkwy. Warrensville Hts., OH 44128 Phone: 216-831-3131 www.adambuilding.net DESCRIPTION: Office expansion 14,000 sf, warehouse expansion 35,000 sf. Project Report #: 02069 AVON HIGH SCHOOL’S PERFORMING ARTS CENTER & CAFETERIA RENOVATION LOCATION: 37545 Detroit Rd. Avon, OH (Lorain County) PROJECT TYPE: Renovation/Addition CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STATUS: Design Development in Progress - Bidding Set For GMP Mid-April 2020 EST. VALUE: $17 million OWNER: Avon Local School District Contact: Michael Laub, superintendent 36600 Detroit Rd. Avon, OH 44011 Phone: 440-937-4680 www.avonlocalschools.org ARCHITECT: Architectural Vision Group Contact: Andre Smiltars 23850 Sperry Dr. Westlake, OH 44145-1523 Phone: 440-808-8520 www.avgl.com CM AT RISK: Dunlop & Johnston, Inc. Contact: Daniel White, project mgr.
5498 Innovation Dr. Valley City, OH 44280 Phone: 330-220-2700 www.dunlopandjohnston.com CIVIL ENG: Lewis Land Professionals Inc. STRUCTURAL ENG: Osborn Engineering MECH ENG: Osborn Engineering ELEC ENG: Osborn Engineering DESCRIPTION: 2 bldgs, 41,367 sf. Constructing a 27,790 sf primary 1,600-seat auditorium addition - 14,660 sf secondary auditorium addition - renovating 4,891 sf of existing space - building a 2,368 sf orchestra pit which will be housed below the 4,000 sf stage - renovating the cafeteria - 2,145 sf commons addition administration offices relocation - new school entrance - overall building height approximately 49 feet. Project Report #: 02068 EMMA WINE BAR & MIXED-USE OFFICE DEVELOPMENT LOCATION: Ghent & Cleveland-Massillon Rds. Bath Township, OH (Summit County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Mixed-Use CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Working Drawings Nearing Completion - Possible Construction Start Early 2020 - Possible Completion Late 2020 DEVELOPER: Stonemill Real Estate Contact: Tom Giltner 2811 Walnut Ridge Rd. Akron, OH 44333 Phone: 216-520-2160 ARCHITECT: Joint venture of DC Builders and MPG Architects DC Builders Contact: Brandon Borthwick 10984 SE 232nd Ave. Damascus, OR 97089 Phone: 888-975-2057 www.dcbuilding.com MPG Architects Contact: David Mann 3660 Embassy Pkwy. Akron, OH 44333 Phone:330-666-5770 www.mpg-architects.com BUILDER: To Be Determined DESCRIPTION: 2 acres, 1 bldg, 3 stories, 22,000 sf. Upper floors professional service offices lower floor EMMA Wine Bar - hospitality. Information included in Construction Progress Report has been produced, processed and/or verified through sources believed to be reliable. Properties Magazine makes no warranty of any kind for this information, express or implied, and is not responsible for any omissions or inaccuracies. To contribute project data or to notify Properties of any reporting errors, we encourage you to email cpr@propertiesmag.com. www.propertiesmag.com 69
Coming in February Pleasant Valley Corporation Gilmour Academy’s Lorraine and Bill Dodero Center For Performing Arts The Statler Cleveland Legal Services Risk Management …and more Interested in advertising? Call Properties today and an account representative can help you www.propertiesmag.com address your advertising needs: Visit us online for archived fea-
ture articles, advertising rates, 216.251.0035 / 888.641.4241 specs and subscription information.
ADVERTISER INDEX 1st Choice Roofing Co...............................................48 Abraxus Snow Removal............................................28 AIA Cleveland.................................................................10 Air Control Products, Inc..........................................72 American International Construction.................. 7 Architectural Floors of Cleveland.......................... 3 Brennan Heating & Associates..............................33 Bruder Building Materials, Inc................................61 Buckeye Sweeping, Inc.............................................33 Building Point Ohio Valley/Precision Laser & Instrument, Inc.........................................50 Campopiano Roofing................................................26 Carey Demolition.........................................................65 Carey Roofing................................................................59 Carron Asphalt Paving, Inc......................................10 CBRE, Inc...........................................................................47 Chagrin Valley Steel Erectors.................................62 Charles Schulz Building Company......................66 Charles Svec Inc............................................................ 17 Christian Phillips Photography................................ 6 Cicogna Electric & Sign Co........................................ 9 Cleveland Engineering Society.............................12 Cleveland Public Power............................................70 Cleveland Thermal......................................................54 Columbia Building Products..................................35 Commercial Roofing & Coating Systems, Inc................................................................37 Construction Employers Association.................18 Cunningham Paving Inc...........................................67 Diamond Roofing Systems.....................................71 Dollar Bank......................................................................49 Duffy & Duffy Cost Segregation Services........63 EA Group..........................................................................31 Euromark Cabinets......................................................39 Frantz Ward LLP............................................................47 Hahn Loeser & Parks, LLP.........................................65 Hammond Construction, Inc.................................21 Harlan & Assocs............................................................52 HBM Architects.............................................................13 Hicks Roofing................................................................... 2
HMH Restoration Ltd.................................................44 Infinity Construction..................................................10 Integrated Project Solutions.................................. 17 J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc........................................67 Jamieson Ricca Fenestration.................................. 17 JL Taylor, Co. Inc............................................................36 John G. Johnson Construction Co.......................13 Kline Rostocil Cosntruction.....................................39 LDA Architects...............................................................15 Lisco Heating & Cooling, Inc...................................61 Marcum LLP....................................................................64 Mason Structural Steel, Inc....................................... 7 Masonry Restoration Maintenance....................67 McMahon Masonry Restoration...........................55 Meaden & Moore, Ltd................................................51 Messina Floor Covering, Inc....................................16 Metis Construction Services...................................24 North Coast Paving.....................................................42 OCP Contractors............................................................. 7 Ohio Desk Co./Integrated Interiors Group......13 Pella Window & Door Company/ Gunton Corp..............................................................41 Pete & Pete Container Service...............................34 Pleasant Valley Corporation...................................60 Precision Environmental Co...................................52 RAM Construction Services of Cleveland........58 RM Riggle Enterprises, Inc.......................................40 Rycon Construction Co............................................... 9 S.A. Comunale Company.........................................35 Sable Asphalt Maintenance....................................28 Scheeser, Buckley, Mayfield Inc............................23 Siegel Jennings .............................................................. 4 Snow Brothers Appliance, Inc................................49 Sol Harris Day Architects, Inc.................................21 Space Comfort Co........................................................68 Sunray Window Films LLC.......................................32 Suntrol Co........................................................................16 Thorson Baker & Associates....................................59 Warren Roofing & Insulating Co...........................68 Zinner & Company......................................................53
Call our commercial sales managers today, to discuss your electric service needs.
www.propertiesmag.com Visit us online today to view archived issues in an interactive digital format. 70
reliable & Mark Herron local 216.563.7331
Visit us at www.cpp.org
Kim Woodford 216.563.7240 Properties | January 2020
Partnering With You: Delivering Solutions and Service
Why choose Air Control Products?
Serving you through education and collaboration
Our 40+ years of expertise Leading manufacturers in HVAC and Architectural Industries Inventive products In-house engineering team Our knowledge is YOUR knowledge On-site warehouses for immediate needs Devotion to our core values Easy to do business with mentality
Partnering With You: Delivering Solutions and Service
Columbus 1201 Essex Avenue Columbus, Ohio 43201 P 614-299-1747
440-526-3020
Cleveland 3800 Towpath Road Cleveland, Ohio 44147 P 440-526-3020
Toledo 2164 Tedrow Road Toledo, Ohio 43614 P 419-380 -8990
Learn more at www.aircontrolproducts.com