,16,'( /DUU\ 6HDUV DQG 6DOO\ =ORWQLFN 6HDUV WKLQN>ER[@ DW &:58 3KRHQL[ %XLOGLQJ
January 2016/$7.95
g n i t a r b e Cel ears 70 Y 1946 Since
9LZ\YNLUJL VU [OL >H[LYMYVU[ -SH[Z ,HZ[ )HUR 7OHZL 00 ZWYV\[Z UL^ YLZPKLU[PHS KPUPUN LU[LY[HPUTLU[ L_WLYPLUJLZ PLUS: -PUHUJPHS 9L]PL^ -P P S9 -VYLJHZ[
Proud to provide interior stone at FLATS EAST BANK PHASE II
4XDOLW\ 6HUYLFH ¥ &RQVLVWHQWO\ %UDGOH\ 6WRQH RIIHUV H[SHUW VHUYLFHV LQ D ZLGH UDQJH RI FRPPHUFLDO UHVLGHQWLDO DSSOLFDWLRQV
*UDQLWH 4XDUW] 0DUEOH /LPHVWRQH 6RDSVWRQH 2Q\[ 7UDYHUWLQH 3RUFHODLQ *ODVV 7LOH 6WRQH &DUH &DUWHU 6W _ 6RORQ 2KLR _ ZZZ EUDGOH\ VWRQH FRP
ENV I RON M E N T A L C O N S ULTIN G AN D LABO R ATO R Y S ER V I CE S
EA Group can help you make the pieces fit! EA Group is a recognized leader in environmental analysis and management. We’ve worked with a multitude of businesses and institutions to help discover, analyze, and manage their environmental issues. Since 1982, we have provided environmental, health and safety consulting, field, and laboratory services to thousands of clients throughout Ohio and the region. Our consulting staff has extensive experience in environmental, health and safety assessment, remediation, and management. Our laboratory capabilities include full environmental analysis, industrial hygiene analysis, and asbestos analysis.
BREATHE EASIER
EA Group works with clients in the following industries: • Construction & Design Companies • Environmental Consulting and Contracting • Educational Institutions (K-12, Public & Private, Universities) • Healthcare Facilities • Commercial Real Estate Development & Property Management Firms • Manufacturing Companies Put our expertise to work for your organization and start to breathe a little easier with EA Group.
800.875.3514 • 440.951.3514 • www.eagroupohio.com 7118 Industrial Park Boulevard • Mentor, OH 44060
Reducing Real Property Tax Assessments Throughout Ohio And Across The United States Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill, Co., LPA
When you hire Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill, you work directly with Sleggs, Danzinger and Gill. Each client is directly represented at all levels by a principal of the firm with a combined 75 years of experience. No pyramid, no associates, no on-the-job training. Our clients deserve the very best representation, so we structured our firm to allow each client, throughout the entire process, to work directly with Messrs. SLEGGS, DANZINGER and/or GILL. Our philosophy is to work cooperatively with school district and County officials to ensure that our clients pay the lowest possible real property tax obligations. If a fair resolution requires litigation, SLEGGS, DANZINGER & GILL have the depth of trial and appellate experience to handle the most complex valuation issues. Whether the valuation relates to large industrial plants, apartments, shopping centers, warehouses, office buildings, vacant land or any other type of commercial property, the faces above will ensure that you receive the best counsel, legal advice and litigation expertise.
Member Firm
Todd W. Sleggs, Esq.
Robert K. Danzinger, Esq.
Steven R. Gill, Esq.
tsleggs@sdglegal.net
rdanzinger@sdglegal.net
sgill@sdglegal.net
(216) 771-8990 sdglegal.net
Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill 820 West Superior Ave. Seventh Floor Cleveland, OH 44113
ting Celebreaars 70 Y 1946
January 2016, Volume LXX, Number 1
Since
FEATURES phone: 216.251.0035 toll free: 888.641.4241 fax: 216.251.0064 www.propertiesmag.com CLEVELAND 3826 W. 158th St. Cleveland, Ohio 44111
OWNER/PUBLISHER Kenneth C. Krych kkrych@propertiesmag.com MANAGING EDITOR/ART DIRECTOR Mark Watt mwatt@propertiesmag.com CONTRIBUTING WRITERS Doug Bardwell, Jeanne Bluffstone, Dennis Castiglione, Ian Frank, Lou Kren, Matt Lehnert, Alec Pacella, Diane DiPiero Rodio, John Slagter, David Woodburn
Photo by Ken Krych
AKRON P.O. Box 9 Munroe Falls, Ohio 44262
10 ABC Northern Ohio Honors Top Shops of 2015 Associated Builders and Contractors awards recognizes leading merit shops’ work
13 Will Your Buy-Sell Agreement Work When You Need It? What to consider when developing a succession plan
14 Finding Long-Term Certainty Through the Tax Extenders Bill 17
Phoenix Building Rises Again Historic rehabilitation project provides supportive housing for homeless
23 Resurgence on the Waterfront Flats East Bank Phase II sprouts new residential, dining & entertainment experiences
ACCOUNT EXECUTIVES Matt Lehnert mlehnert@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6753
54 Is Project Management a “Strategic Process” in Your Business?
Larry Overbey loverbey@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6649
65 2015/2016 Financial Review & Forecast
57
Building Outside the Box CWRU embraces innovation at Larry Sears and Sally Zlotnick Sears think[box] 66 Where We Are + Where We’re Going: CBRE offers an overview of Northeast Ohio commercial real estate 2015/2016 76 National Construction Outlook 2016: Dodge Data & Analytics anticipates 6% growth in construction starts 78 Highlighting the Housing Market: HBA hosts Annual Economic Housing Forecast, shares local, national data 80 Hot Topics in Northeast Ohio: Survey of regional building & real estate professionals illustrates outlook for 2016 82 Financial Strategies: Winning Ways 84 ACAR Corner: A Year of Growth, Change, Opportunity 86 Challenges and Opportunities to Watch for in 2016
OFFICE MANAGER Lisa Larissey 216.251.8506 Cover photo: Flats East Bank Phase II, by Scott Pease
88 ABCs of Energy Efficiency Benchmarking and EE-as-a-Service
Properties (ISSN 033-1287) is published monthly for architects, engineers, building owners and managers, general contractors, home builders, mortgage bankers, savings and loans, real estate agents, appraisers, servicers and suppliers in Northern Ohio by Properties, Inc., 3826 W. 158th St., Cleveland, Ohio 44111. Copyright © 2016 by Properties, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction or use, without written permission, of editorial or pictorial content is strictly prohibited. Periodicals postage paid in Cleveland, Ohio and additional offices. Subscription rates: one year $24.95, single copy $7.95, back issues $10 when available. Postmaster: send change of address notices to Properties, P.O. Box 112127, Cleveland, Ohio 44111.
DEPARTMENTS 8 44 45 48 50 52 90
PROPERTIES PEOPLE BOMA BUSINESS BILLBOARD LEGAL PERSPECTIVES VANTAGE POINT NAIOP NEWS CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT www.propertiesmag.com 5
PUBLISHER’S NOTE January 2016
Fast Forward appy New Year to everyone! This past year, as predicted, brought continued growth and development in the realty, construction and architecture communities. In covering this region for over 40 years, I can’t remember a time when there was more going on – especially in downtown Cleveland.
H KEN KRYCH
We are nearing the “critical mass” that was talked about years ago that will attract more retail and office activity as the residential revolution of Cleveland’s downtown continues pushing forward with the RNC in sight. There is also continued growth and renewal in Akron, Canton and Youngstown. Look back, look forward Every January, we publish a Financial Review/Forecast special section, in which local, regional and national
experts weigh in on industry trends and issues of the past year and those coming in the New Year, with a particular focus on financial affairs and real estate issues. This multi-decades-long tradition continues today as numerous experts have contributed data analysis and opinions, offering us invaluable information to consider and absorb as we begin 2016. Flats East Bank Phase II Fitting with Cleveland’s growth and development, we celebrate the New
Connect your facilities management to BIM. Save time and money. :RZ_ ^f]Rab M]Q SMPWZWcWRb \M]MURab \MYR \^aR W]S^a\RQ QRPWbW^]b ^] cVRWa OdWZQW]Ub͙ ?^QRZb P^]]RPcRQ c^ SMPWZWcWRb \M]MUR\R]c bhbcR\b PM] _a^eWQR͛ Л
E_MPR
Л
2bbRcb
Л
?MW]cR]M]PR W]S^a\McW^]
Ba^eR cVR eMZdR ^S h^da 3;? ORh^]Q QRbWU] M]Q P^]bcadPcW^]͙
Learn more at www.imaginit.com/FMandBIM or call us at 800-356-9050.
6
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
Year’s start with a cover story on the latest key phase in the rebirth of the riverfront at Flats East Bank, including input from all the major contributors, developers, architects and engineers. think [box] at CWRU Northeast Ohio historically has been a hub for entrepreneurial innovation in manufacturing and health. Case Western Reserve University continues that tradition with the recent opening of [think]box. This is a story of how, as a team working together, the private business and institutional sector can take an unused hulk storage facility and recreate it into a center for innovation that provides students, faculty, alumni and members of the community with a place to imagine and creatively invent, test and provide marketing input for new products and inventions. Phoenix Building rises Also this month, we look at the adaptive reuse and historical rehabilitation of the Phoenix Building, an 1853 landmark in downtown Ravenna. Conceived by Coleman Professional Services, nonprofit provider of behavioral health and rehabilitation services, the building has been transformed to house previously homeless tenants with 10 apartments, plus new retail on the first floor. The project was recently recognized with an Award of Excellence by Associated Builders and Contractors, Inc. (ABC). On the way in February Coming through a relatively mild November and December, it’s still never too early to look to spring with our annual Landscapes & Hardscapes issue. We look forward to input from many of the top landscaping designers and firms in the region on the latest techniques and important topics in this special section. Additionally, we will highlight the new Kent State University Institutional Advancement Building, as well as an important new facility called Swagelok Cleveland (formally the Abbot Valve & Fitting Company center) in Solon. Until then, we wish you a most profitable and successful New Year!
Kenneth C. Krych Owner/Publisher www.propertiesmag.com 7
PROPERTIES PEOPLE Highlighting notable industry events
1
2
3
4
1
5
AIA Cleveland 125th Anniversary Celebration 2
7
6
1 John P. Rach (CBLH Design) and Hillary Lyon (Richard Fleischman + Partners Architects) 2 Matt Stevenson and Dan Rerko (City Architecture), with Alan Renzi (Richard Bowen + Associates) 3 Christopher Diehl (City of Cleveland) and Arron Hill (Richard Fleischman + Partners Architects) 4 Jim Herman and Jim Gibans (Herman Gibans Fodor) 5 Beth Kalapos (Kalapos Architects) and Pradnya Martz (AIA) 6 Matt Lindsay (Robert Maschke Architects), Jack Bialosky (Bialosky & Partners) and Alex Mann (Robert Maschke Architects) 7 Hank and Peggy Reder (Henry Reder Attorney at Law)
Recently, over 150 members of the Cleveland AIA (American Institute of Architects) held a 125th anniversary celebration at the Cleveland Institute of Art’s new CIA Gallery. Displayed at the event were images and significant events from throughout the chapter’s history. A panel discussion highlighting Cleveland’s rich history of architecture was held at the new CIA Cinematheque. P
3 1 Mark and Stacey Mazzurco (H&M Landscaping & Snow Pros) 2 Marie Marrali and Georgette Tobia (First Federal Lakewood) 3 Richard Puzzitiello Sr. and Ryan Puzzitiello (Parkview Homes), Ted Otero (Otero Signature Homes), Jason Scott (Pepperwood Homes at Greyhawk) and Mike Payne (Payne & Payne Builders)
HBA Cleveland Awards & Officers Installation The 72nd annual Home Builders Association (HBA) Annual Awards & Installation Banquet was held recently at the Renaissance Cleveland Hotel Grand Ballroom in downtown Cleveland. Nearly 250 members enjoyed the evening event, which included the annual Past Presidents Procession, award presentations and the installation of 2016 officers and Board of Trustees, including incoming HBA president Ryan Puzzitiello of Parkview Homes. P 8
1
2
4
5
Joint Associations Holiday Social Nearly 200 members representing 12 top industry associations gathered recently to celebrate the holidays at the 12th Annual Joint Associations Holiday Social. Held at the Embassy Suites in Independence, the event included a cocktail reception and buffet dinner, plus a 50/50 raffle, gift baskets and door prizes awarded throughout the evening. Entertainment was provided by Rick and Sharona – A Swingin’ Affair, with proceeds donated to Cleveland Food Bank. P
3
6
7
1 Peggy O’Neil and Fred Hollman (Fred H. Hollman P.E. Consulting Engineers) 2 Trina Hyatt (Chas E. Phipps, Co.) and Sarah Rudyk (OCP Contractors) 3 Dionne Isabella, Doreen Jakob, Cindy Miniello, Carla Spencer, Lisa Gross and Tanya Theobald (Dunlop & Johnston Inc.) 4 Maria Mrosek (Nordson Co.) and Chris Cabot (Westfield Insurance) 5 Sarah Rudyk (OCP Contractors), Mirol Wells (MetroHealth Systems) and Ariane Kirkpatrick (The AKA Team) 6 Don Dreier and Lynn Gaukin (Donley’s Inc.) 7 Rick and Sharona Burke (A Swingin’ Affair)
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
The Road to Cleanliness Starts Here Ê ",Ê Ê "Ê "-/Ê* , Ê , Ê -- --
UÊ-Üii« } UÊ*ÀiÃÃÕÀiÊ7>Ã } UÊ-VÀÕLL } UÊ*>Ûi i ÌÊ,i«> ÀÃ UÊ-ÌÀ « } UÊ-> Ì }
/
UÊ- ÜÊ* Ü } UÊ ÃÌÀÕVÌ Ê- Ìià UÊ*>À }Ê Ìà UÊ*>À }Ê iV à UÊ7>Ài ÕÃià UÊ-«iV > Ê Ûi ÌÃ
SERVICE, TEAMWORK, & COMMITMENT TO EXCELLENCE Experts in creating educational, worship, and commercial projects built with exceptional service.
- ViÊ£ ä
GENERAL CONSTRUCTION • CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT • DESIGN/BUILD
330-798-9200
P.216.938.5050 • F.216.938.5033 • johngjohnson.com
ÜÜܰLÕV iÞiÃÜii« }°V
6ȥ3ȫ $Ȧ1ȭ$Ȥ 5ȧ&ȣ 1ɤ %ȧ:Ȥ Ȉ Ȏ )Ȫ,Ȝ$ȱ )ȝ%Ȫ8ș5ȱ ȑ7Ƞ
%ȹFɃ Eɑ SɇSɍOȹU GȽP PȹQȼȼ 6036 1(2·V ORQJ UX XQQLQ QJ DQQXDO IXQGUDLVHU LV P PDNLQJ D VHFRQG ¶URFNXPHQWDOO· UUHWXUQ DW &ORYHUOHDI /DQHV
5ȽJɁVɌHɊ DɌ VɅSɋQȽRȆȆRɊJ WHDPV RRI RU LQGLYLGXDOO\ 6SDFH H LLV OOLPLWHG
6ɈRɆVɇUɋKɁS RɈSɇUUɌXɆLɌLȽV DɎDɁOȹEɄHȆ &RQWDFW /LDQQD /DNH DWW OODNH#DUNLQHWLFV FR RP IIRU P PRUH LQIIRUPDWLLRQ www.propertiesmag.com 9
ABC Northern Ohio Honors Top Shops of 2015 Associated Builders and Contractors awards recognizes leading merit shops’ work ecently, more than 160 individuals of the Northern Ohio chapter of Associated Builders and Contractors, Inc. (ABC) gathered at the Aloft Hotel Banquet Facility, situated on the east bank of downtown Cleveland’s revitalized Flats area, to honor top projects completed in the region in 2015. The Annual ABC Excellence in Construction and Safety Awards Celebration recognizes outstanding quality and innovations in merit shop construction projects.
R
Photos courtesy of Associated Builders and Contractors, Inc.
Award winners and their guests celebrated at a formal dinner followed by an elegant awards presentation ceremony and video presentation. Independent judges, representing a cross-section of construction industry experts, awarded more than 30 companies the awards of Merit, Excellence, Greener Tomorrow, STEP Safety and Project of the Year. Award winners included:
MERIT AWARD WINNERS
HONORED EFFORT Cleveland Construction’s work at Marshberry Corporate Offices was recognized with a Merit Award at ABC’s annual awards program.
Cleveland Metroparks Zoo Circle of Wildlife
Hummel Construction Company Infrastructure - Heavy - All Contract Amounts Project: Cleveland Metroparks Zoo Circle of Wildlife Client/Owner: Cleveland Metroparks
Primary Architect: DS Architecture Primary Engineer: Hinkel Engineering
Client/Owner: Ohio Department of Transportation Primary Engineer: TEC Engineering
Cleveland Construction, Inc.
Hummel Construction Company
Commercial - Less Than $5 Million Project: Marshberry Corporate Offices Client/Owner: Marshberry & Company, Inc. Primary Architect: Bialosky + Partners Architects Primary Engineer: McHenry & Associates
Other Construction -$2 to $100 million Project: Geauga Park Frohring Meadows Client/Owner: Geauga Park District Primary Architect: Peninsula Architects Primary Engineer: J.F. Denk Jr.
Perram Electric, Inc.
Cleveland Construction, Inc.
Up to $100 Million Project: ODOT 110361 Dayton ITS
Renovation- $25- $100 Million Project: The Residences at 1717
Northeast Ohio’s Leading Fitness Equipment Supplier Since 1979
www.healthandfitnessohio.com Commercial & Residential Equipment • Facility Planning Design Delivery & Installation • Service & Preventative Maintenance
Commercial Division: 440.946.0839 x 4 Fairlawn/Akron 330.836.6640
10
North Canton 330.492.7773
Eastlake 440.946.0839
North Olmsted 440.734.4888
Woodmere 216.593.0233
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
Client/Owner: K & D Group Primary Architect: Berardi + Partners, Inc. Primary Engineer: Cleveland Construction, Inc.
Wojcik Builders Inc Less Than$10 million Project: Highland Springs Hospital Healthcare Client/Owner: Highland Springs Hospital Primary Architect: Architectural Investments Primary Engineer: Willett Engineering Company General Contractor: ARC Construction
Corporate Electric Company Renovation - Less Than $4 million Project: Corporate Electric Office Renovations Client/Owner: Corporate Electric Company, LLC Primary Architect: MANN Architects
Hummel Construction Company Institutional - Less Than $5 million Project: Kent State University Prentice House & Poetry Park Client/Owner: Kent State University Primary Architect: The Collaborative Architecture and Design Primary Engineer: Moradi Engineering, Mosyjowski and Associates
AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE
Kuhlman Builders Inc Building Alterations- Less Than $4 Million Project: Marion Township / Hamler Fire Department Building Alterations Client/Owner: Marion Township Trustees Primary Architect: Technicon Design Group, Inc Primary Engineer: Technicon Design Group, Inc
M.W. Mielke, Inc Mechanical - Industrial Less Than $10 million Project: NASA Repair Steam Distribution Client/Owner: NASA Primary Engineer: AEE Emersion General Contractor: RJ Runge
Clouse Construction Corp. Renovation - Less Than $4 million Project: A Credit Renovation Client/Owner: AG Credit Primary Architect: Technicon Design Group, Inc
Bay Mechanical and Electrical Corporation Electrical - $2-10 Million Project: Project Gold Coast Pepperidge Farm Plant Expansion Client/Owner: Pepperidge Farm, Inc. Primary Architect: Janotta & Herner Primary Engineer: SSOE Group General Contractor: Janotta & Herner
Pinnacle Construction and Developmental Group Fed Gov / Military - Less Than $10 million Project: Defense Supply Center Client/Owner: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Primary Architect: Barge - Wagner Primary Engineer: USACE - Omaha District
Air Force One Ariel Arena
Institutional - Less Than $5 million Project: Wellington High School Client/Owner: Wellington High School Primary Engineer: Rick Mindzora
Simonson Construction Services, Inc. Institutional - $5 to $10 million Project: Mt. Vernon Nazarene University - Ariel Arena Client/Owner: Mt. Vernon Nazarene University Primary Architect: SoL Harris / Day Architecture Primary Engineer: Barber & Hoffman, Inc.
Kwest Group, LLC Fed Gov / Military - Less Than $10 million Project: Sanitary Sewage Lagoons Repair Client/Owner: Grand Forks Air Force Base (U.S. Air Force) Primary Architect: Kenneth Hahn Architects Primary Engineer: Advanced Engineering and Environmental Services, Inc.
2'%+#.+<+0) +0 #.. #52'%65 1( '6#. 4#/+0)X 4;9#..X %1756+%#. '+.+0)5 #0& .114+0)
Kwest Group, LLC Other Construction - Less Than $2 million Project: Rehab Taxiway Bravo and Runway 18-36 Client/Owner: Erie - Ottawa International Airport Authority Primary Engineer: C&S Engineers, Inc.
f n 6 X 174 )1#.5 #0& 8#.7'5 #4' %105+56'06 9+6* #.. %.+'065U &'.+8'4 37#.+6; 914-X 10 6+/' #0& 10 $7&)'6T ' 564+8' 61 ':%''& '8'4; %.+'06 5 ':2'%6#6+105 #0& (14/ # .#56+0) 2#460'45*+2T 74 56#0&5 9+.. '0574' # (.#9.'55 241,'%6 '8'4; 6+/'T KMF T #).'; &T '4'#X HHNEK ).'00u+%109%(T%1/ 999T+%109%(T%1/
Bay Mechanical and Electrical Corporation Environmental - Up To $100 Million Project: Avon Lake Water Filtration Plant Client/Owner: Avon Lake Municipal Utilities Primary Architect: CDM Smith Primary Engineer: CDM Smith
HHNgFFEgLFKI www.propertiesmag.com 11
Hummel Construction Company Project: Coleman Phoenix Building Historical Restoration / Renovation Under $25 million Client/Owner: Coleman Professional Services Primary Architect: DS Architecture Primary Engineer: C.L. Firestone
Primary Architect: ADA Architects Inc. Primary Engineer: Timothy J. Norris & Associates General Contractor: O’Neill General Contractors, LLC
Janotta & Herner Pre-Engineered Building Project: New Russia Township Complex Client/Owner: New Russia Township / Fred Swanson Primary Architect: Janotta & Herner Primary Engineer: Janotta & Herner General Contractor: Janotta & Herner
M.W. Mielke, Inc.
Pennex Aluminum Addition
Graft Electric Electrical - Industrial Less Than $2 million Project: Pennex Aluminum Addition, Leetonia Client/Owner: Pennex Aluminum Primary Engineer: C.L. Firestone
M.W. Mielke, Inc Mechanical - Industrial More Than $10 Million Project: Metropolitan at the 9 Client/Owner: Geis Hospitality Primary Architect: Geis Primary Engineer: Karpinski Engineering General Contractor: Geis
Mechanical - Industrial - Less Than $10 million Project: Trident Seafood Client/Owner: Trident Sea Food Primary Architect: The Austin Company Primary Engineer: The Austin Company General Contractor: The Austin Company
Healthcare - Less Than $10 million Project: Health Partners of Western Ohio Client/Owner: Health Partners of Western Ohio Janis Sunderhaus Primary Architect: R.D. Neff & Associates
Clouse Construction Corp Healthcare Less Than $10 million Project: Mercy Hospital of Tiffin Elevator Client/Owner: Mercy Health Primary Engineer: SSOE Group
Other Construction - Less Than $2 million Project: Avon Oaks Country Club - Tennis Dome Facility Client/Owner: Davine LLC Primary Architect: North Bay Construction, Inc. Primary Engineer: North Bay Construction Inc.
Kwest Group, LLC
Kwest Group, LLC Sitework - All Contract Amounts Project: Camp Perry - Storm Drainage Rehabilitation Client/Owner: Ohio Army National Guard Primary Engineer: Kusmer and Associates, Inc. General Contractor: Calvary Contracting, Inc.
Westland HVAC Mechanical - All Projects Project: Garnett Health Campus Client/Owner: Garnett Health Campus, LLC 12
Knoch Corporation Institutional $5 to $10 million Project: The Restored Church of God World HQ Client/Owner: The Restored Church of God Primary Architect: Cameron Design Group Primary Engineer: Ohlin & Reed General Contractor: Knoch Corporation
CSI Construction Services Inc
North Bay Construction, Incorporated
Camp Perry Storm Drainage Rehabilitation
The Restored Church of God World HQ
Other Specialty - Industrial - Less Than $10 million Project: Pound - Jenkins Line Restoration & Access Roads Client/Owner: American Electric Power Primary Engineer: American Electric Power General Contractor: Kwest Group LLC
Bay Mechanical and Electrical Corporation Mechanical - Commercial $2-10 Million Project: Project Gold Coast Pepperidge Farm Plant Expansion Client/Owner: Pepperidge Farm, Inc. Primary Architect: Janotta & Herner Primary Engineer: SSOE Group General Contractor: Janotta & Herner
ABC STEP SAFETY AWARD Bronze Level Bell & Blaire LLC (Akron) Dawn Incorporated (Warren) J. Herbert Construction (Salem) Ross Builders Co. (North Ridgeville)
Silver Level Janotta & Herner, Inc. (Monroeville) Mel Lanzer Co. (Napoleon) Peerless Electric Co. (Mentor) S.A. Sauber Inc. (Sycamore) Simonson Construction Services (Ashland)
Gold Level AC Split Bolt, Inc. (Wooster) Ayrshire Inc. (Chardon) Campbell Construction (Wooster) Knoch Corp. (N. Canton) North Bay Construction (Westlake) Tradesmen International (Cleveland)
Platinum Clouse Construction Corp.
Diamond Kwest Group, LLC
CHAIRMAN’S CUP The 2015 Chairman’s Cup award honored Kwest Group’s $1.4 million storm drainage rehabilitation project for the Ohio Army National Guard at Camp Perry near Port Clinton. Project partners included primary engineer Kusmer and Associates, Inc. and general contractor Calvary Contracting, Inc. P 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
Will Your Buy-Sell Agreement Work When You Need It? What to consider when developing a succession plan By Tony Constantine Ciuni & Panichi, Inc.
losely held businesses need a well-developed succession plan to ensure a successful transfer to new ownership when the time is right. The plan generally should include a buy-sell agreement to provide an orderly ownership and control transfer when an owner dies, becomes disabled or leaves the business.
C
It also should create a market for otherwise unmarketable ownership interests, providing a departing owner’s family with a fair price and the liquidity needed to pay estate taxes and other expenses. To work effectively, a buy-sell agreement must have a valuation provision, which sets the purchase price for a departing owner’s shares. If the agreement undervalues or overvalues the company’s shares, it can result in disputes. Most buy-sell agreements use one or more of these approaches to set the price: • Negotiation between the parties • Valuation by one or more independent professional appraisers (either at regular intervals or after a “triggering event,” such as the death, disability or departure of an owner) • A valuation formula tied to book value, earnings or other factor The agreement should clearly spell out how the value of the stock is to be determined. This includes valuation
approach and valuation date, as well as payment terms.
Engage an appraiser Negotiation can be a way to arrive at a price that’s fair to all concerned – when the parties agree. But if they can’t agree, litigation may result. One potential solution is to provide for a negotiated price but, if the parties can’t agree within a certain amount of time, then bring in an independent appraiser. Independent appraisals near the date of a triggering event generally produce the most accurate results. A professional appraiser will scrutinize your company, taking into account the special characteristics that distinguish it from other industry businesses and determine its value. Instead, many companies develop valuation formulas and incorporate them into their buy-sell agreements. Formulas are easy to use, but they’re also risky. Why? They become obsolete soon after the buy-sell agreement is signed. Book value may approximate fair market value
at the time a company is established, but it quickly becomes out of date. Case in point: Two business partners had a buy-sell agreement that set the price at net book value plus $50,000. When one partner died, the surviving partner was able to acquire the deceased partner’s interest for just under $200,000 – even though its fair market value had grown to more than $2 million. Some companies use formulas based on earnings multiples, but they also can be unreliable. A multiple of earnings may approximate a company’s value at the time an agreement is signed, but won’t necessarily reflect the company’s value over time.
Review your agreement It’s a good idea to review your buy-sell agreement periodically to ensure its valuation provisions reflect your company’s current circumstances. This is particularly important if your valuation formula is more than a year or two old. Rely on your CPA for advice. P
Ciuni & Panichi, Inc.’s Real Estate & Construction Services Group has helped hundreds of companies successfully transfer to new owners. For valuation and litigation help or assistance creating a transition plan, contact Tony Constantine, CPA, senior manager, 216-765-6925 or tconstantine@cp-advisors.com.
͖͕͚Ǥ͕͗͜Ǥ͕͕͛͛ Ǧ Ǥ
͔͘ Ǥ Ǥ
www.propertiesmag.com 13
Finding Long-Term Certainty Through the Tax Extenders Bill By Craig Miller, CPA, CGMA, CGFM Duffy+Duffy Cost Segregation
he U.S. House and Senate waited until just two weeks left in the calendar year to pass the Protecting Americans from Tax Hikes Act of 2015 (PATH). The new law makes some temporary tax provisions important to commercial real estate a permanent fixture of tax law. Overall, the $622 billion dollar package of tax breaks extends 52 tax provisions for business and individuals, and also makes 22 provisions permanent, including the very business-friendly bonus depreciation, 15-year leasehold improvements, the research and development tax credit, the deduction of state and local sales taxes, and the $500,000 Sec. 179 expense limit.
T
Using depreciation as a tax shield Depreciation is used by most businesses. An extremely important source of funds is cash flow added back from depreciation. We frequently refer to depreciation as “a source of cash flow.” Proponents of bonus and accelerated depreciation argue that it is an important incentive to spur business investment and keep effective marginal tax rates on capital investment low. On average, during the last 20 years businesses raised about 40% of their funds internally through retained 14
be eligible for expensing. It increases the expensing limit to $500,000. Businesses exceeding a total of $2 million of purchases in qualifying equipment will have the Section 179 deduction phase-out dollar-for-dollar and completely eliminated above $2.5 million. Additionally, the Section 179 cap will be indexed to earnings and depreciation, according inflation in $10,000 increto BEA.gov (see illustration above). ments in future years. Since 1982, depreciation has provided 77% of those internal funds. New R&D tax credit eligibility The new law will foster innovation Bonus depreciation and is expected to boost investment by Accelerated and bonus deprecation incentivizing the development of cutallows assets to be depreciated faster ting-edge technology with a permanent than their economic life. Accelerated extension of both the Research and depreciation and bonus depreciation is Development (R&D) Tax Credit. In the largest corporate tax break, allowing addition to the permanent extension, companies to deduct the costs of assets for the first time businesses with less faster than their value actually declines. than $50 million in gross receipts will The preference is the largest in the cor- now be able to claim the credit against porate tax code and is broadly enjoyed their alternative minimum tax (AMT), by most businesses. Bonus depreciation thereby removing the single greatest baris extended through 2019. Businesses rier preventing companies from claiming of all sizes will be able to depreciate the credit in the past. Secondly, the bill 50% of the cost of constructed personal includes a provision that opens the credit property in commercial properties, in up for start-ups, allowing businesses with land improvements, and for equipment gross receipts of less than $5 million a acquired and put in service during 2015, year to take the credit against their pay2016 and 2017. Bonus depreciation will roll taxes (capped at up to$250,000 per phase down to 40% in 2018 and 30% year) for up to five years. P in 2019.
Section 179 The bill permanently extends small business expensing limitations and phase-out amounts, and makes permanent the rules allowing for certain qualified leasehold improvements to
Craig Miller, CPA, CGMA, CGFM, MBA, is president of Cost Segregation Services, Inc. Information in this article was sourced through BEA.gov and Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. For more information visit CostSegExperts.com or call the Cleveland office at 1-440-892-3339. 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
Graphic provided by Duffy+Duffy Cost Segregation / Data from www.BEA.gov
These victories, coupled with what did not happen in Congress – such as a carried interest tax increase or the elimination of Section 1031 like-kind exchanges – provide the commercial real estate industry with remarkable cer tainty going into the new year. This tax legislation is a major victory for the commercial real estate industry. These powerful incentive programs help businesses grow and successfully compete both in the U.S. and abroad. Business-friendly provisions such as the extension of bonus depreciation, the Sec. 179 Expense election, and the Section 179D tax deduction for energy-efficient commercial buildings will be a massive help to companies across the nation. Extremely important among these is the permanent provision for 15-year qualified leasehold improvement depreciation. In addition, we have achieved longer-term extensions (five years) and a $3.5 billion allocation for New Markets Tax Credits. Many of our local businesses will also benefit by the act delaying the medical device tax.
ARE THERE TAX DEDUCTIONS HIDING IN YOUR BUILDING?
J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc. • Commercial Buildings • Construction Sites • Special Event Clean-Up • Concrete Cleaning • Carpet Cleaning • Window Cleaning
Many building owners have millions of dollars in income tax deductions they don’t know about. If you own commercial or industrial property and need more tax deductions, let our Cost Segregation professionals furnish you with an estimate. It won’t cost you anything to find out!
• Wall Washing • Acoustical Ceilings
1230 East Schaaf Road Brooklyn Heights, OH 44131
216-749-1150 www.jvjanitorial.com
Call Dennis Duffy or Craig Miller: Cleveland 440.892.3339 / Columbus 614.949.4185 Detroit 248.752.7433 or visit our website www.costsegexperts.com
THE REGION’S LEADING INCOME TAX REDUCTION EXPERTS
Serving Northeast Ohio For Over 60 Years! Residential Ŷ Commercial Ŷ Industrial Ŷ Institutional
Expert Brick Matching and Complete Inventory of Brick, Block, Masonry, Cast & Natural Stone, Plaster Products & Tools
9005 Woodland Ave., Cleveland, OH 44104 216.791.9800 Ŷ www.bruderinc.com www.propertiesmag.com 15
Meeting All Your Construction Needs. :LWK RYHU IRXU GHFDGHV RI H[SHULHQFH ZH DUH SURXG WR EH WKH &RQVWUXFWLRQ 0DQDJHU DW 5LVN RQ WKH &2/(0$1 3+2(1,; 352-(&7
%XLOGLQJ D %HWWHU 7RPRUURZ %8,/',1* *5((1 6,1&( *HQHUDO &RQWUDFWRU &RQVWUXFWLRQ 0DQDJHU *UHHQ %XLOGHU
Phoenix Building Rises Again Historic rehabilitation project provides supportive housing for homeless By Mark Watt | Photos courtesy of DS Architecture
s the result of a $2.5 million historic rehabilitation project, a long neglected relic in Portage County has found new life – and is positively changing the lives of the tenants who now call it home. The Phoenix Building, a landmark 1853 Greek Revival masonry building in the heart of downtown Ravenna’s Historic District, has been renovated to deliver safe and affordable permanent housing for individuals with a history of homelessness. The complex encompasses 10 onebedroom apartments situated across three floors, plus three commercial spaces at street level. The adaptive reuse project was conceived by the Coleman Professional Services, a non-profit provider of behavioral health and rehabilitation services. According to Kathy Myers, director of public relations with Coleman Professional Services, the organization has 250 housing units across its footprint of eight counties in Ohio. “There is a huge need for this type of housing,” Myers says, noting that the homeless population in Portage County is estimated to be at least 70 individuals. “These individuals often have some sort of mental illness or disability, and are working through their challenges. We are trying to reduce the stigma of mental illness by showing that people can live happy and productive lives, and be part of the community.” With Kent-based DS Architecture acting as project architect and Hummel
Construction, of Ravenna, serving as construction manager at risk, the project was designed to update the Phoenix Building for modern needs while respecting its rich historical details.
Traces of the past According to the National Register, the 12,000-square-foot building is Ravenna’s first major commercial block and its oldest existing commercial building. Completed in 1853, it was first occupied by the Independent Order of Odd Fellows (IOOF), a worldwide fraternal organization with roots in 18th Century England; the organization still owns and occupies a portion of the building’s third floor. In 1875, the Odd Fellows were responsible for contributing the building’s more architecturally recognizable features, adding an intricate wood and pressed metal Italianate façade. Ornamentation includes cornice work and a central raised parapet incorporating a broken pediment and finials.
In the ensuing decades, the building would house a wide range of commercial tenants, including grocers, drug stores, hardware shops, printing companies, law offices and others. Numerous physical changes were made over time, including the addition of plate glass windows, aluminum framing and wood canopies above some storefronts, and even a fire escape attached to the front of the building. By the early 2000s, the block was showing signs of disrepair. The roof had deteriorated and was leaking, water and neglect had damaged interior spaces and layers of paint applied to the façade were peeling and flaking. “It was dilapidated,” says Marty Snode, vice president and project manager with Hummel Construction. “The building was falling down.” In 2010, Portage Community Bank acquired the building as the result of a defaulted loan, and took steps to find a new owner interested in saving the building. Discussions among commuwww.propertiesmag.com 17
Photo by Mark Watt
A
Point. Click. Connect. Visit Properties online today to view past & current editions in digital format – featuring interactive magazine ads that take you directly to advertisers’ websites with one mouse-click!
Photo by Mark Watt
www.propertiesmag.com
HINTS OF THE PAST To accommodate the new apartments, a central public corridor was added, incorporating open doorways framed by wood beams and brick reclaimed from elsewhere in the building.
nity officials connected the bank with Coleman Professional Services, who entered an agreement to buy several blocks of the building in June 2011. To make the renovation possible, Coleman would secure financing through over 30 funding sources. This included historic preservation tax credits at the state and federal level totaling approximately $1.2 million.
Balancing history, modern needs In early 2012, DS Architecture was selected to design the project, working with historic preservation consultant Diana Wellman, of NaylorWellman, to modernize the building while adhering to the National Park Service’s guidelines for historic preservation. Applicable portions of the building (105-113 E. Main St.) were designated as certified historic structure in early 2013. Hummel Construction began construction in June 2014. The project included major structural work, Snode says, noting that portions of the existing floor were cut out and rebuilt to increase public loading from the entry at street level. “There’s new steel, new columns and new framing to meet the code-required loading designs of all public landing areas,” Snode says, adding that the sidewalk outside needed to be raised up to 14 inches in areas to make entryways accessible. “An existing stairwell was reconfigured to meet code, a second stair was added and an elevator was added. In 18
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
TRACING HISTORY Although a datestone on the façade indicates the year 1846, construction of the building was actually completed in 1853. The block housed a wide range of tenants over the decades – and experienced plenty of wear and tear – before the historical rehabilitation project began in 2014 (right).
those early stages, the building was sitting wide open as it was braced and shored for those new elements to be added.” Complicating the effort, it was discovered that the south-facing façade was beginning to pull away from the structure on the Main Street side of the building. Structural Engineer John Fenton, of Fenton Engineering, Inc., devised a solution utilizing heavy gauge steel cables and large plate washers to secure the façade. “We had to thread the cables through the joists and then use turnbuckles to tighten the cables,” Snode says. Refreshing the façade was a primary focus. The renovation targeted the late 1870s as the building’s period of historical significance, utilizing a black and white photo from 1878 as reference. “We had precedent for a painted façade,” says Bridget Tipton, interior designer with DS Architecture. “This was not a full restoration. It was rehabilitation to a point in time and to prevent further deterioration.” Previously white with gold trim, the building required a light bristle brush cleaning and some tuckpointing, while built-on awnings were removed to uncover the fascia. The entire building was then
repainted a rich brick-toned red with cream and brown accents, juxtaposed by white storefront at pedestrian level. Windows within the Coleman Professional Services portion of the
Inside, a previously dank, dark and largely dirt-floored basement was rebuilt with new concrete footers and new floors in several areas. “DS Architecture designed for basically a cavity wall inside the original sandstone foundation and a new waterproofing system,” Snode says. “There used to be water trickling through the sandstone in the basement. Now it’s a clean, dry, humidity-controlled and well-lit space.” To accommodate the new apartments, a central public corridor was added, incorporating open doorways framed by wood beams and brick reclaimed from elsewhere in Kathy Myers the building. “All public areas are built out Coleman Professional Services with damage resistant trim,” says building were replaced, while others Sean Barbina, project architect with were painted to match. A new EPDM DS Architecture. “Instead of wood that roof was installed over the renovated could be chipped, it’s a resilient material. portions of the building. The flooring is hardy with LVT robust
“The tenants love their new homes. These are individuals who have been homeless and have gone through some struggles and now they have an awesome apartment that they can call home. The gratitude is overwhelming.”
www.propertiesmag.com 19
ǤǤǤ Ȉ ͳͺͺ
Ȉ ʹͲͳͷ
Ǥ ͳͻͻͺǡ ϐ Ǥ ǡ Ǥ ǯ ǯ Dz Ǥdz ǯ Ǣ ǯ ǡ ǡ Ǥ Ǥ Ǩ
ͳ͵ͳͳ Ǥǡ Ȉ ͵͵ͲǦʹͻǦͺͲͻͲ ȁ ͳͷ͵ʹ Ǥ Ǥǡ Ȉ ͵͵ͲǦͺǦͺͲͺͲ ȁ Ǥ Ǥ
20
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
LASTING LOOK Finishes in the apartments (top) and common areas (bottom) are commercial grade in quality, yet homey in appearance to create a warm residential environment that should endure for years.
vinyl tile and a wood plank pattern to keep a warm look.” While the entry stair was rebuilt to meet current code, the design acknowledges the placement of the original stair by exposing remnants of the old structure with an angled cutout in the wall. Original tin ceiling tiles in the commercial spaces were carefully removed and sent to a cleaner in Cincinnati, Snode says. “They were alkalinecleaned and lead paint was removed, and then we brought them back for reinstallation,” he says. Working within the existing confines of the building presented challenges, particularly in routing new mechanical systems for each residential unit, Barbina says. There are 18 HVAC units on the roof that feed into the building, with pipes concealed within soffits, walls and floors. “It was a real challenge to get the mechanical and electrical infrastructure into place – the plumbing, HVAC, electrical and new sprinkler system – particularly since all apartments are uniquely shaped to fit within the existing structure,” Snode says. That meant that walls were not uniformly placed from floor to floor. “As 3-D modeling was not available for the existing structure, it was a process of ‘bump steering’ where we’d go until we hit an obstacle, then find a way around it.” Apartments range from 450 to 800 square feet and can be converted into ADA accessible units as needed, Barbina says. Each includes an entry closet, bedroom closet, kitchen, bedroom, living room and a bathroom. Apartment ceilings were lowered from over 12 feet to about nine feet, while incorporating light wells above windows and transoms above bedroom doorways. “Finishes in the apartments are more commercial grade quality, but residential in appearance,” Tipton says. “The carpet we selected is typically used in nursing homes. It’s welded in the seams and can be cleaned with bleach.” Within residential units, a color palette of cream and muted blue accentuates design details, while black and white subway tile lends a historical feel in bathrooms.
“We tried to make sure the apartments were architecturally interesting,” Tipton says. “If they’re white boxes, it becomes too institutional. Applying color and architectural accents gives people a greater sense of ownership and reinforces the supportive housing idea where tenants can actually grow and learn as a result of the environment they live in. The end goal is to positively impact the people who use the space.”
Brighter futures Myers, of Coleman Professional Services, notes that all 10 apartments are occupied and feedback from residents has been exceedingly positive. “The tenants love their new homes,” she says. “These are individuals who have been homeless and have gone through some struggles and now they have an awesome apartment that they can call home. The gratitude is overwhelming.” Myers says that while there was a degree of NIMBY (“not in my back-
yard”) resistance in the community when work began, the completed project has since evoked a favorable response from neighbors. “The community has been very positive,” she says. The project team is currently working to finish the three commercial spaces at street level. These includes a restaurant/ coffee shop called Bean and the Baker, due to open by spring 2016, and space for another tenant to be determined. Looking ahead, Coleman Professional Services is planning a second phase of renovation that will incorporate two additional blocks within the building. Phase Two, due to start later this year, will create an additional six apartments and two retail spaces. “This has been an excellent project,” Barbina concludes. “As a supportive housing project, it is changing people’s lives. It’s well built, and it’s helping to revitalize downtown. Ravenna has beautiful historic architecture and it is rewarding to see it maintained and preserved.” P www.propertiesmag.com 21
#ONGRATULATIONS TO &AIRMOUNT 0ROPERTIES AND THE 7OLSTEIN &AMILY ON THE SUCCESSFUL COMPLETION OF THE &LATS %AST "ANK APARTMENT BUILDINGÏÏ
WWW DIMITARCHITECTS COM
panzica.com • 440.442.4300
Panzica is honored to have served as the Construction Manager on the Flats East Bank Apartments.
CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT • DESIGN-BUILD • GENERAL CONTRACTING 22
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
Resurgence on the Waterfront Flats East Bank Phase II sprouts new residential, dining & entertainment experiences By Doug Bardwell | Photos by Scott Pease
ersistence.” In one word, that summarizes how Scott Wolstein and his team are transforming the Flats into what you see today at Flats East Bank. Taking up an entire block at 1065 Old River Rd. in Cleveland, the 550,000-square-foot, eight-story, $155-million, Phase II includes 241 apartments, a 250-space private parking garage and a number of restaurant/entertainment units along with a 1,200-foot boardwalk along the Cuyahoga River.
“P
As Phase II opens, this “impossible” project has many other developers scratching their heads as people gravitate here to work, to live and to play. Phase II now brings the residential component down to the river, linking recreation and entertainment to create Cleveland’s hottest new neighborhood. This development builds off of Phase I, completed in 2013, which incorporated the 23-story Ernst & Young Tower and attached Starwood Aloft Hotel. As if that weren’t enough, plans are already underway for an even larger Phase III than originally envisioned.
Success is elusive When business boomed in the Flats in the ‘80s and ‘90s, nationally known restaurant chains were eager to join the mix,
recalls Scott Wolstein, principal of The Wolstein Group. Although the Cuyahoga River was a drawing card, “the only way you could enjoy it was to pay a cover charge, walk through a bar, and go sit on their patio,” says Wolstein. The river was there, but it couldn’t be enjoyed by other than a select few at a time. Drinking wasn’t enough to maintain the momentum, the environment wasn’t conducive to affluent clientele, and the excitement and entertainment gradually faded away. Having traveled the world, Wolstein was impressed with The Rocks historic district in Sydney, Australia; as well as others in Lisbon, Portugal; Seattle, Washington; and the island of St. Maarten. Cleveland needed that vibe. Vacant industrial buildings weren’t the vision that Scott’s parents Bart
and Iris Wolstein originally had for the Flats. With much property already acquired back in the ‘80s by Scott Wolstein and James Schoff, the potential was too great to ignore. “It was probably in the mid-‘90s, we decided that we needed to really control the entire district, and we needed to start over and open up the site to provide access to the riverfront,” says Wolstein. “So then, that’s when we started coming up with the master plan to open up the site and provide view corridors to the river. Providing public access to the river made the larger property more valuable than just a strip of land that was along the west side of River Road.” Partnering with Fairmount Properties in 2005, plans began to coalesce. “I knew Randy Ruttenberg and Adam Fishman www.propertiesmag.com 23
3TQWF VQ DG RCTV QH VJG 7($0 $7 )NCVU (CUV %CPM
1RW WRR ELJ 1RW WRR VPDOO -XVW ULJKW *HDXJD 0HFKDQLFDO FRPELQHV ELJ FLW\ H[SHULHQFH DQG H[SHUWLVH ZLWK VPDOO WRZQ VHUYLFH DQG YDOXHV 2XU H[SHULHQFH RYHU WKH ODVW \HDUV JLYHV XV WKH DELOLW\ WR SURYLGH XQLTXH VROXWLRQV WDLORUHG WR SURMHFWV LQ DOO W\SHV RI PDUNHWV 2XU VPDOO WRZQ FXOWXUH PHDQV WKDW ZH WUHDW RXU FXVWRPHUV WKH ZD\ ZH·G OLNH WR EH WUHDWHG RXUVHOYHV *HDXJD 0HFKDQLFDO MXVW ULJKW IRU WKH )ODWV (DVW %DQN SURMHFW
! IGCWICOGEJCPKECN EQO &DOO RU FOLFN WRGD\
'(6,*1 %8,/' ! 6+((7 0(7$/ )$%5,&$7,21 ! ,167$//$7,21 ! %8,/',1* $8720$7,21 ! 6(59,&( 0$,17(1$1&( ! *5((1 %8,/',1* 6(59,&(6
FINDING THE RIGHT FLAVOR The residential and entertainment complex was designed to nod toward The Flats’ past with a brick warehouse appearance, merged with modern elements including long curving façades, plenty of glass and a diverse neighborhood feel at street level.
very well, and they were the perfect team of young, energetic guys who could get things moving,” says Wolstein. “It’s been such an honor to be a part of this project with The Wolstein Group,” says Adam Fishman, developer and principal of Fairmount Properties. “With the opening of Phase II, we’ve truly created an entertainment destination. Being in a waterfront live-work-play environment is a difference-maker and desired by a lot of people moving back to the urban core. What has been created here is also attracting businesses to Cleveland, providing more jobs and increasing residency. While we’re excited to see the Flats East Bank project come to fruition, it’s bigger than that. It’s about Cleveland rising.” “What you have to do on a project like this is just take it one day at a time and knock down one domino at a time,” explains Wolstein. “Sooner or later, you develop some momentum, and the project gets moving. “Frankly, it isn’t as simple as basically saying, ‘This is what we’re going to do
and this is how we’re going to do it.’ You have to take it one step at a time. A project like this needs tremendous public support, and that doesn’t come easy. It really requires you to create a vision and share that vision to the various public partners and explain to them why you can’t make the numbers work financially without their support. It was impossible to do this with a conventional capital structure.”
Luckily, the team was undaunted and worked every angle imaginable. Wolstein continues, “So, we had to piece it together, and when we finally closed on the financials for Phase I, we actually had 35 different funding sources in the capital stack, which is entirely unprecedented. “I don’t think any of us could have envisioned the hurdles that we were going to have to overcome during that
STRUCTURAL STEEL FABRICATORS & ERECTORS SINCE 1958
Mason Steel Contact Mike Smith for a Proposal: (440) 439-1040 | (800) 686-1223 7500 Northfield Rd. | Walton Hills, OH 44146 www.masonsteel.com Other Fine Products Available: Stone | Pavers | Fireplaces | Windows | Doors www.propertiesmag.com 25
HVAC ■ Plumbing ■ Fire Protection ■ Process Piping ■
Proud of our involvement with Panzica Construction at Flats East Bank Phase II 800-776-7181 www.sacomunale.com
“Large Enough To Meet Your Needs, Small Enough To Care”
Congratulations Design & Construction Teams of the
Flats East Bank Phase II FROM YOUR
Mechanical, Electrical, and Plumbing Engineering Partner
330.659.6688
500+ E M P L OY E E S
55 YEARS
50 S TAT E S
12
OFFICES N AT I O N W I D E
1
I N T E G R AT E D SOURCE
$5&+, 7(& 76 _ (1*,1((56 _ 3/ $11(5 6
26
GPD GROUP
VISIT US ON THE WEB WWW.GPDGROUP.COM OR AT 1.800.955.4731
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
WELCOME RECEPTION The residential component of the project includes 241 apartments across floors three through eight. A 24/7 concierge is always available in the lobby, providing a sense of comfort to tenants as well as their guests.
crisis. But in some ways, there’s a silver lining to everything. And that silver lining was that it was much easier to convince the public partners that they needed to play a role, because they certainly could understand why this wasn’t a project where you could just go to the bank and get a loan at that time.” Part of Phase I was totally unexpected and unplanned, but has been instrumental in the success of the project as a whole. At the time, many large tenants were looking for office space, but not necessarily in the Flats. Fairmount and Wolstein however were able to put together a package that excited them. “We were able to persuade them to be part of something that would be transformative for the city,” says Wolstein. “So, that kind of caught me a little bit by surprise – a very pleasant surprise. And then the office component fit into the hotel piece, because the anchor tenants wanted a hotel as part of the project. “EY wanted to move their training center and they needed a place where
their employees could stay. So all of that kind of evolved. Phase II really is much more what the original vision was. Phase I kind of took us by surprise. That opportunity jumped out of nowhere, but with that completed, it made Phase II a lot easier to finance.“ With people moving back into the city, and with the need for quality
City of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, State of Ohio, Cleveland International Fund, and the Cleveland-Cuyahoga County Port Authority.
Designing for Phase II
It may or may not be a textbook case of practice-makes-perfect, but master planning for the eventual Phase II of Flats East Bank dates back to the 1990s, with a number of architectural firms working on various concepts. Based on prior experience working with the project site and the Wolstein family, Dimit Architects was selected to assist four national A&E firms in 2007 and 2008 to develop and refine plans for Flats Phase II. “It was during that period that the collective charrettes estabAdam Fishman lished the rough ‘zero-lot-line’ Fairmount Properties shape of the center block and the overall fit with the urban conapartments downtown, a demand text,” recalls Scott Dimit, managing could now be seen that hadn’t existed principal of Dimit Architects. Then the recession hit in fall 2008 and 10 years prior. Going to the financial market was now considerably easier and plans slowed considerably for many years. “In 2013, Dimit Architects was asked a package was put together with financial partners, including Wells Fargo, to re-explore the earlier designs for the www.propertiesmag.com 27
Photo by Kristin Piteo / Courtesy of Fairmount Properties
“What has been created here is attracting businesses to Cleveland, providing more jobs and increasing residency. While we’re excited to see the Flats East Bank project come to fruition, it’s bigger than that. It’s about Cleveland rising.”
(1*,1((56 $5&+,7(&76 6859(<256 &216758&7,21 0$1$*(56
5 : :DUQHU LV SURXG WR KDYH SURYLGHG FRQVWUXFWLRQ VXUYH\LQJ VHUYLFHV IRU
FLATS EAST BANK PHASE II
Photo by Ken Krych
/$ 2I¿FH 3OD]D ,, # /$ &HQWUH 'HWURLW 5G 6WH :HVWODNH 2+ FRQWDFWXV#UHZDUQHU FRP ZZZ UHZDUQHU FRP
FORM + FUNCTION Half-width floating soffits help to make the curving corridors seem shorter and more attractive, while providing a way to conceal mechanical and electrical runs, according to Interior Designer Analia Dimit.
central Apartment Building 4 as part of a coordinated team approach led by Fairmount Properties and Metro Consulting,” says Dimit, “and we were successful in eventually being selected as overall architect of record for the project by Flats East Development.” Donald Frantz, president of Metro Consulting, acting as owner’s rep, adds that “about that time, Mark Panzica was brought in for predevelopment estimating and constructability services.” “There was a desire by the clients to create a ‘modern warehouse’ feel for the project,” explains Gary Ogrocki, project principal with Dimit Architects. “They wanted the brick warehouse look evolved during the 2008 team studies, but with lots of added glass and all of the modern amenities.” “Given its irregular, curving shape, the Building 4 exterior design presented challenges – for the large bending façades, we studied many industrial and vernacular materials and window arrangements to retain the flavor of the Flats, but also to break down the scale of the building” continues Ogrocki. “So if you look at the east-facing facade, the building height is interrupted and reduced to 28
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
Photo by Kristin Piteo / Courtesy of Fairmount Properties
MODERN WARMTH Low profile, contemporary furniture paired with a wood panel-framed fireplace in the apartment lobby creates a cozy but forward-looking atmosphere where tenants and guests can gather for conversation.
retail street façade level, to transition to the scale of the neighborhood.” The long curved façades of the building following Old River Road also gave the design team some additional interior challenges. “We were able to create a half-width ‘floating’ soffit in those curving corridors that help the hallways seem shorter and more attractive, while at the same time giving us a place to hide all of the necessary mechanical and electrical runs typically housed there,” explains
Analia Dimit, principal and director of interior architecture. Along these corridors, each apartment entrance is also slightly recessed with unique entry signage and material changes. “We were always looking for opportunities to make this project unique.”
Construction begins Scott Dimit recalls, “They called us in to a meeting at the end of August 2013 and let us know that they wanted to start
deep foundations for the new building by early January of 2014!” “We got the phone call in September 2013,” says Mark Panzica, executive vice-president of Panzica Construction Company. “We had been looking at another building, but were told we needed to switch gears and get an RFP out for Building 4, and it would be due in two weeks. “We were also asked if we would team up with LeChase Construction from
www.propertiesmag.com 29
3URXG WR KDYH ZRUNHG DW FLATS EAST BANK PHASE II ZLWK 3DQ]LFD &RQVWUXFWLRQ &RPSDQ\ :ROVWHLQ *URXS )DLUPRXQW 3URSHUWLHV
WHEN IT COMES TO CLEAN, WE MEAN BUSINESS.
BUILDING SERVICES A TOTAL FACILITY MAINTENANCE COMPANY &216758&7,21 &/($1,1* /$%25(56 528*+ &/($183 ),1$/ &/($183 ,17(5,25 (;7(5,25 :,1'2: :$6+,1* 21 %8,/',1*6 2) $// 6+$3(6 6,=(6 '$,/< 1,*+7/< &8672',$/ 6(59,&(6 7,/( )/225 5(6725$7,21 32:(5:$6+,1* 3$5.,1* *$5$*(6 %8,/',1*6 :$/.:$<6 (7& 26118 Broadway Avenue • Oakwood Village, Ohio 44146 • 440-439-2288 www.crystalclearbuildingservices.com • www.crystalclearhome.com
Proud to be part of the team at Flats East Bank
SPECIALIZING IN:
Sheeting | Shoring Piling | Marine Construction Bridge Construction 1085 Rockside Road, Suite 5 | Parma, Ohio 44134 PHONE (216) 741-7453 | FAX (216) 803-3444 jguinto@gsengineer.com | www.gsengineer.com ODOT DBE, NEORSD: SBE, MBE & FBE, City of Cleveland: MBE, CSB, FBE & LPE, State of Ohio: MBE & EDGE 30
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
CONCRETE DECISION The eight-story structure is constructed of post-tensioned concrete, which promises longevity, superior sound insulation and flexibility for the future. The material selection also meant that ceilings in residential units didn’t need to be drywalled, as the project team embraced the exposed concrete as a design feature.
can use for residential building, and the client team wanted a first-class product. Considering both longevity and sound insulating properties, it ended up being the best choice here.” “Using concrete allowed a number of other advantages,” adds Frantz. “Ceilings
didn’t need to be drywalled. Floor-tofloor heights get smaller, so there’s less exterior skin. And ultimately, it allows for future flexibility.” “So, knowing we wanted to get retail open in summer 2015, we knew we needed to be in the ground, drilling deep
PROUD TO PARTNER WITH PANZICA CONSTRUCTION & FAIRMOUNT PROPERTIES FOR FLATS EAST BANK PHASE II
NORTHERN OHIO PLUMBING CO. YOUR FULL-SERVICE PLUMBING SERVICES PROVIDER
CLEVELAND PLUMBING INDUSTRY
35601 CURTIS BLVD., EASTLAKE, OHIO 44095 Ŷ 440-951-3370 www.propertiesmag.com 31
Photo by Kurt Shaffer
Rochester, New York. They had extensive experience with the firm that would be managing the residential component. “We met with them a couple days later in Erie, Pennsylvania; struck a deal, and formed a joint venture as the CM for the building. June of 2015 was our target date for opening the retail portion of the project, and we couldn’t go fast enough at that point.” “At that time, we were sitting with just conceptual drawings and a number of major decisions needed to be made, including the structural framing,” says Frantz. “Since we wanted an exposed structure for the industrial aesthetic, I asked the team to investigate concrete as opposed to steel framing, which is typically cheaper.” That team included Steve Ebersole, of Ebersole Structural Engineers, Ltd. (now with GDP Group in Akron). After looking at numerous framing systems, the group concluded that post-tensioned concrete was the best solution. “The building’s shape is a combination of so many angles and radii that stick framing wasn’t the best choice,” says Dimit. Ogrocki continues, “Concrete is really one of the highest quality structures you
Photo by Kristin Piteo / Courtesy of Fairmount Properties
MOVING FORWARD In addition to the primary 550,000-square-foot structure, Phase II also incorporated construction of a boardwalk and two freestanding establishments, included Alley Cat Oyster Bar (above) and a nightclub called Forward Day & Nightclub situated nearby.
foundations in January 2014,” Panzica says. “With that date firmly established, milestone dates for the design team were agreed upon and we began to assemble design-assist subcontractors through a competitive process. That enabled us to get mechanical, plumbing, electrical and concrete contractors on board very early on.” Dimit notes that “one of the great advantages of the ‘design-assist’ project approach is the ability to have structural engineers sitting right there with Panzica and Cleveland Cement, who can then collectively determine whether an idea is practical or not.” “With a complicated building like this, it was invaluable to have our engi-
neers, Thorson Baker Associates, meeting weekly with the mechanical contractors, Geauga Mechanical, to analyze the pluses and minuses of the various systems and options,” Dimit adds. “In the really short time frame available, it was essential to have the various contractors working directly with the engineers and designers.” One of the biggest challenges to fasttracking the process was providing for kitchen exhaust for the development’s numerous restaurants. Before layout of commercial spaces was complete, a system needed to be devised that would accommodate whatever hood the tenants chose to install later. Project consultant Harley Cohen, Thorson Baker + Associates and Geauga
Mechanical finally found a system that was perfect. Three risers to the roof were installed and an adjustable flow fan system increases exhaust as each tenant’s hood comes online. “Each exhaust hood has a control device that when the hood is activated, manually by a switch or by a sensor sensing heat, the main exhaust fan will operate at the proper air quantity required for all the different restraints,” says Thorson Baker + Associates Mechanical Engineering Principal Guy Hicks, PE, LEEP AP. Frantz notes that various subtrades made suggestions and coordinated with each other throughout the project, while guaranteeing their price, which was
Let our PERFORMANCE help your bottom line Proud to be part of the team at FLATS EAST BANK PHASE II
PERFORMANCE PAINTING )%( 6%( ('*( &HUWLÀHG FBE City of Cleveland
SBE Cuyahoga County Commercial, Institutional & Industrial Painting Contractor Serving all of Northeast Ohio • Interior/Exterior Painting • LEED Projects • Female-Owned Enterprise
• Wallcovering • Historic Preservation • Epoxy Flooring
• High Performance Coatings • Rigid Wall Protection • Dry Erase Surfaces
7603 First Place Suite 3B Oakwood Village, OH 44146 Q 440-735-3340 Q F: 440-735-3341 Q Performpaintllc@aol.com 32
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
&21*5$78/$7,216 3DQ]LFD &RQVWUXFWLRQ IRU WKH 6XFFHVVIXO &RPSOHWLRQ RI WKH )ODWV %OGJ 5HVLGHQFH 3URMHFW (3, RI &OHYHODQG LV 3URXG WR KDYH 3URYLGHG WKH 6WUXFWXUDO 0LVFHOODQHRXV 6WHHO IRU WKH 3URMHFW
(3, RI &OHYHODQG ,QF ( 3, R RI ( (QWHUSULVH 3DUNZD\ ( ( ( 7ZLQVEXUJ 2KLR 7ZLQVE EXU X 3+21( 3+21 3+ 21( ( )$;
ZZZ HSLPHWDO FRP
BETWEEN THE WEATHER & YOU SINCE 1922
WARREN ROOFING WARREN ROOFING AND INSULATING COMPANY
3URXG WR EH SDUW RI WKH WHDP ZLWK 3DQ]LFD &RQVWUXFWLRQ DW )ODWV (DVW %DQN 3KDVH ,,
Commercial/Industrial Roofing + Architectural Sheet Metal
440.439.4404 Fax 440.439.7523
www.warrenroofing.com www.propertiesmag.com 33
Photo courtesy of Punch Bowl Social
Photo by Ken Love Photography
FUN & GAMES Among the diverse tenants occupying street-level commercial spaces is Punch Bowl Social, a dining and drinking establishment that includes bowling, darts, billiards, ping pong, shuffleboard, vintage arcade games and more.
essential. “If that coordination breaks down, there is no way we could have made our dates,” he says. By phasing the drawings, 100-footdeep augercast piles were able to start on January 14 as further details were still being worked out. The skin of the building, the window locations and even the layouts of the suites hadn’t been decided at that point. To meet the schedule, “Bi-weekly meetings were held right from the start to coordinate and review the various aspects of the evolving project directly with the pertinent department heads from the City of Cleveland,” Ogrocki says. “Remember that at this time, there was also an incredible amount of additional work going on in the neighborhood with the new street infra-
structure, the boardwalk project, and the outlying night clubs which were under design simultaneously. Given all of this activity, the City was extremely cooperative and helpful during this time.” Cleveland Public Power was also a key partner, cooperating early on with open-minded suggestions for placing transformers inside, and making sure adequate power was always available as needed. “From an electrical design standpoint, one goal was to maximize available leasable space in the building by minimizing the space occupied by electrical equipment,” says Thorson Baker + Associates’ Electrical Engineering Principal Jeffery Miterko. “For example, the emergency generator serving the building was located on the lower level roof and the
transformer vault was located on the interior of the building to allow more space for grade-level retail tenants. With Great Lakes Crushing responsible for completing the private streets around the building and Giunto Schirack, Inc., of Parma, trying to complete the boardwalk, it was a worksite in constant motion. The city didn’t let the team cut any corners, but they did allow partial submittals with segmented reviews and approvals. “Everyone from the building department to the fire department were wonderful to work with,” says Panzica. The last submittal wasn’t done until June, when they were already pouring the third floor. “But it was that open line of communication between the city and all of our team that was key to the success on this project.”
A walk around the building
reliable & local CALL OUR COMMERCIAL SALES MANAGERS TODAY, TO DISCUSS YOUR ELECTRIC SERVICE NEEDS
Wes Tarver: 216.664.3922 ext.145 Kim Smith: 216.664.3922 ext. 253 VISIT US AT WWW.CPP.ORG
34
If you are anywhere on the west side of the river, you won’t have any trouble finding the project. Just look up and you can’t miss the colossal “Flats East Bank” neon sign. With a wonderful retro feel, the sign is reminiscent of the iconic manufacturing signs used a century ago, and serves as the calling card for the entire neighborhood. A medium to dark brown brick was selected for the building exterior that 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
Proud P roud t to o h have ave p provided rovided e electrical lectrical c contracting ontracting services s ervices f for or F Flats lats E East ast B Bank ank P Phase hase IIII
New + Renovation Electrical Construction Communications High Voltage Instrumentation Wiring Energy Management Card Readers Sound CCTV + Security Fire Alarm Systems Gateway Electric, Inc. is dedicated to providing electrical contracting service of outstanding quality and value throughout Northern Ohio. We are committed to profitable partnerships with our employees, customers and suppliers. 4450 Johnston Parkway, Cleveland, Ohio 44128 www.gateway-electric.com | mail@gateway-electric.com
216.518.5500
THE FOUNDATION SPECIALISTS SPECIALTY & DESIGN BUILD CONSTRUCTION SERVICES &RPSUHVVLRQ 3LOHV 7HQVLRQ 3LOHV 5HVWULFWHG $FFHVV /RZ +HDGURRP ,QVWDOODWLRQV (DUWK 5HWHQWLRQ 6\VWHPV + 3LOHV /DJJLQJ &XW 2II :DOO 3LOHV 7% 6RLO 5RFN $QFKRUV 0LFUR 3LOHV 6RLO 1DLOV 6KRWFUHWH
Flats Eastbank Phase II Building is supported by 450 augercast piles, each 16” diameter and 95’ to l05’ in length. Design capacity was 100 tons with a #9 re-bar the full length of the augercast piles. The piles were installed using two pile rigs during the brutal winter months of January and February 2014 and completed ahead of schedule.
PH 330-336-8871 P.O. BOX 557 WADSWORTH, OHIO 44282 AUGERCASTPILES@AOL.COM WWW.AUGERCASTPILES.NET www.propertiesmag.com 35
We’re proud to have furnished/installed all aluminum windows, terrace doors, composite panels & louvers at FLATS EAST BANK PHASE II. Congratulations to Fairmount Properties & The Wolstein Group on the successful completion of this exciting project.
& *
CARROLL GLASS 6LQFH ZH KDYH SURYLGHG D ZLGH YDULHW\ RI SURGXFWV DQG VHUYLFHV LQFOXGLQJ FXUWDLQ ZDOOV VWRUHIURQWV ZLQGRZV FRPSRVLWH SDQHOV DUFKLWHFWXUDO DOXPLQXP SURGXFWV DQG DOO W\SHV RI GRRUV DQG KDUGZDUH
216-261-4965 www.carrollglass.com • info@carrollglass.com • 21721 Tungsten Rd., Euclid, OH 44117
INTO THE MIX Phase II’s commercial tenants are diverse, including Punch Bowl Social (top), On Air Studio (middle) and Beerhead Bar & Eatery (bottom), as well as Big Bang Dueling Pianos bar, Crop Rocks and more.
Photo courtesy of Punch Bowl Social
had a range of tones and hues, adding interest to the overall appearance. Even darker Ironspot brick was used for accents. Aluminum composite panels make up the balance of the exterior façade facing the street. Individual tenant balcony areas are accessed through hinged, hurricane-type patio doors with positive latch and sound seals. Each balcony offers great views with a steel mesh, see-through railing. On the first floor, restaurant and entertainment tenants were allowed to create their own storefronts. From the VW mini-bus at Crop Rocks, to the giant microphone at On Air Studio, to the fire
“What you have to do on a project like this is just take it one day at a time and knock down one domino at a time.” Scott Wolstein The Wolstein Group
Photo by Ken Love Photography
Photo by Megan Church
pit at Beerhead Bar & Eatery, each individual tenant’s personality shines through. A number also feature sidewalk seating. The Nashville-based Big Bang Dueling Pianos bar, Crop Sticks and Punch Bowl Social bowling alley and bar make up the other food tenants open presently in the building. Complementing these entertainment spaces are the newly opened Alley Cat Oyster Bar and Forward Day & Nightclub, built on outlying lots. The diversity of design among the commercial tenant spaces creates an interesting neighborhood feel, notes Welty Building Company Cleveland Group President Alan Pollack. “All of these spaces are uniquely different to the individual operators,” Pollack says. Welty provided build-out for the Crop restaurants, Beerhead Bar & Eatery and Punch Bowl Social, and is currently building a new freestanding restaurant called Coastal Taco, due to open this spring. “Coastal Taco is a rustic beachfront-style taco place like you’d see in the tropics, for instance, while Crop Rocks has www.propertiesmag.com 37
ʲʴʱʷʦ ʶʱ ʲʴʱʸʫʦʧ ʯʣʵʱʰʴʻ ʥʱʰʶʴʣʥʶʫʰʩ ʨʱʴ
ʨʮʣʶʵ ʧʣʵʶ ʤʣʰʭ ʲʪʣʵʧ ʫʫ
9DOHQWLQH
ʥ ʱ ʰ ʶ ʴ ʣ ʥ ʶ ʱ ʴ ʵ ʏ ʫ ʰ ʥ ʎ
ʕʕʒʐʔʖʖʐʓʗʒʘ ʙʘʚʒ ʹʪʫʲʲʮʧ ʣʸʧʎ ʰʹ ʰʎ ʥʣʰʶʱʰʏ ʱʪ ʖʖʙʔʒ
DEFINING THE SKYLINE®
38
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
Photo by Nicole Kelly
a design focused on Cleveland music and rock and roll history.” The entire second floor of the building is parking garage, but its roof makes up a central courtyard wrapped by the apartments. With the exception of an Ipe wood deck and walkway, the majority of the courtyard is covered by a plush ForeverLawn artificial grass. Padding and an underlayment help make it a lightweight, yet ultra-comfortable solution for a roof deck. The focal point of the 30,000-squarefoot roof area is a labyrinth meditation path created in artificial turf. “Iris Wolstein wanted this inner courtyard to be not only a place where you could lay in the grass and read a good book, but also she was hoping this would also be a place where groups could gather to enjoy the summer afternoons,” recalls Analia Dimit. Near the third floor community room, outside areas were programmed for the fire pit and four outdoor barbecues. Surrounding the building, the entire site offers tremendous possibilities. While it’s a little cold now to be thinking of outside activities along the river, Wolstein mentions that there are big plans for the neighborhood this spring and summer. “We have a three-acre park that sits on the river, and a boardwalk below that,” Wolstein says. “We have the ability to accommodate thousands of people onsite for public events. Ultimately, weather permitting, we’d like to have events going on down there almost every week, if possible. We really want
AIMING TO ENTERTAIN “We have a three-acre park that sits on the river, and a boardwalk below that,” says Developer Scott Wolstein. “We really want this to be a gathering place for public events and festivals and everything that a major waterfront city can offer.”
this to be a gathering place for public events and festivals and everything that a major waterfront city can offer.”
Back inside the building With the first floor being entirely retail, and the second floor entirely parking, floors three through eight are all residential. The building has a combination of 241 apartments, two-thirds of which are one-bedroom. Approximately 72 are two-bedroom and eight are three-bedroom. Finishes in the suites are primarily light tones with dark zebrawood flooring and white accents. “The views are the main focal points of each suite,” notes Analia Dimit, “so each suite is intentionally designed very simply.”
All kitchens feature high-gloss custom white wood cabinets and ample granite countertops. Sinks sparkle with stainless steel bowls and chrome Moen faucets. All appliances are stainless steel as well. Every unit includes a stackable, energy efficient Bosch washer/dryer. “The dryers are ventless, which eliminated the need to incorporate venting for all 241 units, while still providing a high-quality product,” says Rick Ritt, sales with Snow Brothers Appliance. Bathrooms provide waterfall heads in the showers and each bath is equipped with “smart switches” controlling the exhaust fans. Floor-to-ceiling height on all but the penthouse floor is 9’4”. The eighth floor
Proud to provide and install DuPont™ ForeverLawn® Select LX Turf for the Flats East Bank Phase II project 'X3RQW )RUHYHU/DZQ 6HOHFW 6\QWKHWLF *UDVV ORRNV DQG IHHOV UHDO XQOLNH RWKHU W\SHV RI V\QWKHWLF JUDVV ,W ZLOO OHDYH \RXU QHLJKERUV ZRQGHULQJ KRZ \RX NHHS \RXU ODZQ LQ SULVWLQH FRQGLWLRQ ,GHDO IRU FRPPHUFLDO DQG UHVLGHQWLDO SXUSRVHV WKLV DUWLILFLDO JUDVV ZLOO VWDQG WKH WHVW RI WLPH UHGXFLQJ PDLQWHQDQFH FRVWV DQG ZDWHU XVDJH
EXCLUSIVE DEALER SERVING CENTRAL & NORTHEAST OHIO
7KH 'X3RQW 2YDO /RJR DQG 'X3RQW DUH UHJLVWHUHG WUDGHPDUNV RI ( , GX 3RQW GH 1HPRXUV DQG &RPSDQ\ DQG DUH XVHG XQGHU OLFHQVH E\ )RUHYHU/DZQ ,QF ,Q FDVH RI TXHVWLRQV SUREOHPV RU HPHUJHQFLHV SOHDVH FRQWDFW )RUHYHU/DZQ DW RU IRUHYHUODZQ FRP ZKR DVVXPHV OLDELOLW\ IRU WKH PDQXIDFWXUH RI WKLV SURGXFW
(O\ 9LVWD 'U 3DUPD 2+ VWHYH#QRKLR IRUHYHUODZQ FRP ZZZ IRUHYHUODZQRKLR FRP www.propertiesmag.com 39
LUXURY LIVING “The views are the main focal points of each suite [top], so each suite is intentionally designed very simply,” notes Analia Dimit, interior designer. Kitchen are furnished with high-gloss white wood cabinets and granite countertops (middle), while bathrooms feature waterfall showerheads (bottom).
Photo by Kristin Piteo / Courtesy of Fairmount Properties
Photo by Kristin Piteo / Courtesy of Fairmount Properties
ceiling slopes with the roofline, but ceilings are typically 12 feet. Penthouse tenants also have access to a tremendous view from a private roof deck below the large neon sign. Back on the third floor, tenants have access to a community room, a business center and a small fitness room. Residents also have an opportunity to use the large fitness center atop the hill in the office complex. “We really enjoyed working with Iris [Wolstein], who had such wonderful design ideas for all parts of the building,” Analia Dimit says. “While the suites were kept simple, her personality came through in areas like the main lobby and the community room.” A 24/7 concierge is always available in the lobby, providing a sense of welcoming comfort to tenants as well as their guests. An additional amenity for the tenants comes through a special promotion with AT&T, which will be providing the building with gigabit Internet speeds. Ultra-high-speed fiber will be run into every tenant unit.
Another successful phase completed
Photo by Kurt Shaffer
Looking back, now that’s it’s completed, “it was an amazing opportunity to work with Iris Wolstein on this project,” Analia Dimit says. “She has such finely tuned aesthetics and is into all the details of the project,” echoes Scott Dimit. Ogrocki also adds, “There was an exceptional commitment from Iris, Scott, and Fairmount Properties to realize Bart’s vision for the Flats, and realizing how important this legacy project is for Cleveland, they really wanted this project to be done the right way.” “The Panzica-LeChase joint venture worked like a well-oiled machine,” recalls Panzica. “You couldn’t tell which team member worked for which company. I believe this was such a success, primarily because our company cultures were so similar.” “What’s truly unique about this project is the local, Cleveland feel,” says Fishman. “Yes, it’s new construction 40
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
Photo by Ken Krych
ATTRACTING ATTENTION Perched atop the eight-story building, the colossal “Flats East Bank” neon sign serves as the calling card for the entire neighborhood.
7PSL +YP]PUN 4VUP[VYPUN MVY [OL )\SROLHK >HSS HSVUN [OL *\`HOVNH I` [OL -V\UKH[PVU ;LZ[PUN ,_WLY[Z
*5/ LV SURXG WR KDYH WHVWHG WKH FDSDFLW\ DQG WKH LQWHJULW\ RI WKH IRXQGDWLRQV RI PXOWLSOH SURMHFWV RI WKH )ODWV (DVW %DQN UHGHYHORSPHQW ^^^ .93LUNPULLYZ JVT .93 6/'.93LUNPULLYZ JVT ^^^ .93LUNPULLYZ JVT ;07 PUMV'.93LUNPULLYZ JVT
but we made sure that local businesses were represented amongst other national draws because it’s Cleveland’s lifeline. It’s an extremely entrepreneurial city and, to be successful, we knew we had to capture that spirit. It’s been an honor to be a part of this project with the Wolstein Group and it’s exciting to see the Flats East Bank project come to fruition. It’s something the entire city can be proud of because it represents us.” The owners are also quite pleased with the project and want to build on the
“What’s truly unique about this is the local, Cleveland :H ZHUH SURXG WR EH SDUW RI WKH project feel.... It’s something the entire WHDP IRU )ODWV (DVW %DQN 3KDVH ,, city can be proud of because it represents us.”
ZLWK 3DQ]LFD &RQVWUXFWLRQ
&OHYHODQG &HPHQW &RQWUDFWRUV ,QF %XLOGLQJ IRU WKH )XWXUH 6LQFH 9DQ (SSV 5RDG &OHYHODQG 2KLR ZZZ FOHYHODQGFHPHQW FRP 42
Adam Fishman Fairmount Properties success. When asked about Phase III, Wolstein says, “All is well. We’d like to be in the ground next year with more retail and residential. I think we are now looking at more like 200 units. We’re also talking to a VIP Movie Theater, to be one of the retail anchors for the next phase. So if all goes well, we can have that open summer of 2017.” Reflecting further, Wolstein says, “It’s probably the line I like hearing the most – when people are walking around there saying, ‘I can’t believe I’m in Cleveland.’ And obviously, that’s what we were going for. Hopefully, over time, that will transition to ‘Cleveland is such a wonderful, wonderful city,’ and maybe then people won’t be so surprised.” P 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
5528 Mayfield Rd. Lyndhurst, OH 44124 440-449-2650 Monday, Tuesday, Thursday 10AM - 8PM Wednesday, Friday, Saturday 10AM - 6PM www.snowappliance.com
Proud Appliance Provider of The Flats East Bank Congratulations to Panzica construction
BOMA BUSINESS Exploring timely topics with BOMA members
Historic Natural Gas Lows Open New Opportunities for Property Managers to Save
WE SPEAK
ENERGY SO YOU DON’T HAVE TO IGS Energy has been providing customized pricing, expert product recommendations, and dedicated support to businesses for over 25 years.
Preferred natural gas supplier
ANDREA LONGBRAKE Senior Commercial Account Manager
614-659-5190 alongbrake@IGSenergy.com
44
ecent unseasonably warm weather coupled with an abundance of natural gas production has resulted in the lowest average spot price for a calendar year since 1999, a full 16 years since prices were this low.
R
Many area companies are now taking note of the price drop, which can be attributed to several key factors.
latest 30-day outlook continues to call for mild weather across the northern part of the U.S.
Horizontal drilling
What does all of this mean for natural gas users?
One major driving force behind the falling natural gas market is the widely publicized U.S. drilling boom. Technical advancements in horizontal drilling – which allows for vertical drilling and a horizontal turn at depth, visually similar to the shape of a “J” – enable producers to capture significantly more natural gas and oil now compared to 10 years ago.
Mild weather The other significant factor in the current pricing is the uncharacteristically warm weather throughout the heating season. In fact, the average daily temperatures for both Cleveland and Chicago this season were at least five degrees above their respective historic low temperatures through early December. Compare that to these cities’ 2014 record lows, and there has been a full 10-degree rise in seasonal temperatures. Several well-respected weather services predicted a mild start to the heating season stemming from El Nino, which is a warm phase in the Pacific Ocean that typically lasts from 12 to 18 months. It often leads to milder winter weather in the Midwest. With this year’s El Nino noted as one of the strongest on record, AccuWeather’s
This is all great news for anyone using natural gas for the foreseeable future. With the lack of cold weather early on in the heating season, it’s unlikely that natural gas prices will match that of more seasonably cold past heating seasons. These next few months offer an excellent opportunity for companies to lock in long-term fixed pricing for natural gas. In fact, many end-users are already taking advantage of these low prices – with some even extending their contracts as long as three years. If ever there was a chance to secure incredible pricing, now is the time. P
BOMA Greater Cleveland is proud to provide this space to our Associate Members so they can inform, educate and share their knowledge with property management professionals. This article was written by Andrea Longbrake, a senior commercial account manager for IGS Energy and Dedicated Natural Gas Representative for BOMA Greater Cleveland. To learn more, visit IGSenergy. com or contact Andrea via phone at 614-6595190 or email alongbrake@IGSenergy.com. For more info on BOMA Greater Cleveland, contact Janice Parham at 216.575.0305 or jparham@bomacleveland.org. 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans
Purple Hearts Homes Renovates Home for Marines Veteran urple Hearts Homes recently completed its second total home renovation in South Euclid. The Veterans Home Ownership Program (VHOP) works to help provide veterans with homes donated from various sources so that disabled vets have the opportunity to obtain a mortgage and own one for no more than 50% of the final appraised value. Located on Harwood Road, the recently completed house was obtained from the Cuyahoga County Land Bank and updated as a modern, accessible home for a U.S. Marines veteran. To celebrate the project’s success, John G. Johnson Construction Company and numerHarwood Road Home ous other subcontractors who donated their time and talent for the effort gathered for a flag raising at the home. For more information on Purple Hearts Homes, visit www.purpleheartshomesusa.org.
Photo by Ken Krych
P
KS Associates Welcomes Hamid Homaee as Principal KS Associates Inc., a civil-transportation engineering and surveying firm located in Elyria, recently announced that Hamid V. Homaee, P.E., has joined the firm as principal. He is KS Associates’ first new princi-
pal since the company was founded by Lynn S. Miggins, P.E., president, and Mark Skellenger, P.E., vice president, in 1987. In addition to his primary role of strategic firm leadership, Homaee will guide KS Associates’ efforts to grow its Transportation Group, which provides planning, design
and construction-related services for transportation infrastructure projects. Prior to joining KS Associates, Homaee established a 30-plus year track record of contributing to the growth and prosperity of regional and national engineering firms. In his new role, Homaee will be responsible for working
Hamid Homaee, P.E.
directly with KS Associates’ transportation clients including Ohio Department of Transportation; Ohio Turnpike & Infrastructure Commission; Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Authority; other transit authorities, counties, and municipalities throughout Ohio; and private-sector clients. Homaee is a Professional Engineer licensed in eight states including Ohio. He has a Master of Science degree in structural engineering from Virginia
www.propertiesmag.com 45
Complete Glass Experts Family-Owned & Operated for 60 years! Specializing in: • Commercial Glass and Glazing • Aluminum Doors & Storefronts • Custom Sandblasted “Etched” Glass with Clearshield • Bullet Resistant Glass & Polycarbonate • Custom Frameless Shower Doors, Mirrors & Glass Table Tops
Free Commercial Estimates 24 Hour-Board-Up Service
216.662.5200 chassvecinc@brightdsl.net
Stewardship
Professional
phone 216-621-1971 | fax 216-621-6602 www.sandgloglass.com 2316 St. Clair Avenue | Cleveland, Ohio 44114
Integrity
Consistency
Visionary
Brian-Kyles has distinguished itself as a dependable partner for professional landscape management services for nearly three decades. Centered on building trust and adding value, the Brian-Kyles signature approach is sought by the following types of commercial clients:
Retail Commercial Office Industrial Public Multi-Family Residential Discover our signature approach at www.briankyles.com | Call us today at 855.926.0303 46
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
BILLBOARD
2015 Canstruction Juror’s Favorite by Domokur Architects
Polytechnic Institute and State University and a Bachelor of Science degree in structural engineering from West Virginia Institute of Technology.
Canstruction Event Calls Attention to Hunger Canstruction Cleveland and Canstruction Akron recently joined forces as Canstruction® ClevelandAkron. The new joint chapter has also announced its annual event, to take place Thursday
evening April 7, 2016 at a new location in South Park Mall. Local teams will design and build structures made entirely of full cans of food. At the end of the exhibit, the cans will be donated to local food banks assisting families in Northeast Ohio. Last year, through combined Canstruction Cleveland and Canstruction Jr. efforts, more than 29,000 pounds and an additional check for $3,000 was donated from the event. Canstruction, which was founded in 1992, is a unique food drive created by the Society for Design Administration (SDA) to call national attention to hunger. Events are held annually in more than 150 cities and have grown to become one of the largest and most consistent canned food contributors to food banks around the world. For information on how to form a team, volunteer or sponsor the 2016 Canstruction event, contact the planning committee at 216-223-3202 or
Photo courtesy of The Davey Tree Expert Company
News about people, products, places & plans
Cleveland Clinic Twinsburg Campus Walking Trail
canstruction@herschmanarchitects.com.
Davey Tree, Cleveland Clinic Partner on Walking Trail Patients and staff at the Cleveland Clinic have a scenic new walking trail to explore thanks to a partnership with The Davey Tree Expert Company. About one and-a-half miles of natural paths running over wetlands and alongside massive rock outcroppings at the Clinic’s Twinsburg Campus are now open for walking. The trail is open to the public.
Cleveland Clinic officials partnered with Davey Tree to build the all-natural trail, which winds its way through more than 12 acres of 88 total acres of woodland. The property, which abuts I-480, includes a nature conservancy and natural wetlands. The proximity to wetlands and the nature conservancy meant all construction materials had to be unprocessed, natural materials. P WHAT’S NEW? For coverage within Billboard, send along company news, story ideas and project information to billboard@propertiesmag.com.
Where does your business fit? Call Properties now at 216.251.0035 today to book your ad in these upcoming Special Sections. FEBRUARY
MARCH
APRIL
LANDSCAPES & HARDSCAPES The latest information in a growing field, from how to create curb appeal for your property through well designed landscapes & hardscapes to selecting the best maintenance & outdoor lighting contractor.
LEGAL SERVICES A look at the real estate lawyers who help create & manage projects behind the scenes.
ROOFING/BUILDING ENVELOPE
AD CLOSE: Monday, January 25, 2016
AD CLOSE: Thursday, February 25, 2016
TECHNOLOGY An overview of game-changing software & hardware tools, from BIM to the latest apps.
An overall report on managing exterior systems, from new roofing, window & wall products to the design & implementation of maintenance programs. AD CLOSE: Friday, March 25, 2016
For info on advertising & editorial opportunities opportunities, call 216 216.251.0035 251 0035 or email kkrych@propertiesmag kkrych@propertiesmag.com. com View the 2016 Media Planner at www www.propertiesmag.com. propertiesmag com www.propertiesmag.com 47
LEGAL PERSPECTIVES Navigating property laws & regulations
Is That Improvement/Construction Real Property? our Ohio business may substantially benefit from personal property characterization for an improvement to be constructed or even an existing building/structure. How can that be? This is because Ohio no longer has a personal property tax. As a result, real estate taxes are avoided if the property, or any portion thereof, is properly characterized as real property.
Y
STEVEN A. DIMENGO
Keep in mind, the characterization of property as real or personal property is governed by the same statutory provisions for purposes of all Ohio state and local taxes, and consisting of R.C. 5701.02 (real property) and 5701.03 (personal property). Real property includes land, buildings, improvements, fixtures and structures, while personal property includes “business fixtures.” These terms are statutorily defined with the most critical aspect being that property devoted to a special business purpose conducted on the land generally is not real property, but is a business fixture. So, how can that be? A massive improvement, building or structure permanently attached or embedded into the land can be characterized as personal property? Well, based upon
existing Ohio Supreme Court authority (and even the Ohio Department of Taxation’s own guidance), if the property at issue is devoted to the particular business conducted on the land (i.e., not likely to have utility to a subsequent user in a different line of business), the item is personal property. This is the rule even if for non-tax purposes the property is clearly real property under the general property laws of Ohio. See the Ohio Supreme Court’s decision in Funtime, Inc. v. Zaino (2004), in which Court held that personal property included station houses sheltering patrons waiting in line to ride an amusement park attraction. Clearly, many Ohio buildings, structures and improvements, or components thereof, have the requisite special purpose so that they are not
BRICKLAYERS LOCAL 5 Ŷ CLEVELAND, OHIO Providing Highly Skilled Work Force for Public & Private Projects Since 1867
• Brick, Block, Stone & Marble Masonry • Masonry Restoration • Educated Skilled Labor • Comprehensive Safety Training
6200 Rockside Woods Boulevard North, Independence, Ohio 44131 216-447-9965 Ŷ www.bricklayerslocal5ohio.org 48
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
real property and, thus, should not be subject to real estate tax. Of course, this article assumes that the subject property is permanently attached. So the focus is on the purpose for the property. Does the property have utility to a subsequent owner or tenant in a different line of business? If the answer is “no” – that the property has some degree of special purpose confining its use to a similar business, it is likely personal property. However, if the property does have broad utility so that almost any subsequent owner or tenant would use it, then the property is likely real property. Even as real property, all is not lost since the property may independently be exempt from real estate tax based upon its use (e.g., charitable exemption) or location (e.g., enterprise zone). Moreover, from a sales tax perspective, if the item is real property, only the party purchasing the materials and incorporating them into the real property owes the sales tax on the material cost. There are also sales tax
exemptions for materials incorporated into government-owned property or property to be owned by certain charitable institutions. Let’s assume you can support personal property characterization and thereby avoid real estate tax. Well, how about sales tax? Yes, sales tax is due on the purchase of personal property at rates ranging from 6.5% to 8.0%. However, there are many exemptions, including the purchase of the seller’s own used property, in which case the casual sale exemption would apply. Also, if the property is used for an exempt purpose, it would not be taxable upon purchase. Exempt purposes include property used in: • Manufacturing, processing & assembling • Refining • Mining • Agricultural, floriculture & horticulture • Farming • Rendering a public utility service • Oil/gas production • Water production
ALWAYS on time
• Due Diligence • Retail, Commercial and Industrial • Value Engineering
Even if the property is not exempt upon its purchase using one of the above exemptions or the casual sale exemption, perhaps the one-time sales tax is offset by real estate tax to be saved – real estate taxes to be saved forever! Presumably, the handful of years without real estate tax surely offsets the one-time sales tax paid upon purchase of the tangible personal property. Business owners should closely revisit their property holdings and future purchases, including property to be constructed. Then, they must strongly consider the potential for classifying some of their holdings as personal property and thereby avoid real estate tax, especially if sales tax can also be avoided based upon an exemption. P
• Development & Leasing • Historical/Industrial Renovations • Design/Build
The material appearing in this article is meant to provide general information only and not as a substitute for legal advice. Readers should seek the advice of their attorney or contact Steven A. Dimengo at sdimengo@bdblaw.com or 800.686.2825. This article may not be reprinted without the express permission of Buckingham, Doolittle & Burroughs, LLC © 2016.
)DEULFDWLRQ ,QVWDOODWLRQ 6HUYLFH LQ \HDUV U H Y R RU OL]LQJ I 6SHFLD WRS U HG URRI J D RW ZDWH N F K D 3 P GLQJ ¥ VWHD ZHO Q R L W D F %RLOHUV UL HWDO IDE HOGLQJ 6KHHWP ULFDWLRQ Z IDE W 3ODVWLF HHULQJ DUWPHQ Q S L H J G Q H H F 9DOXHG H PDLQWHQDQ UYLF )XOO VH
330-659-2040 Charles Marshall – cmarshall@mccdesignbuild.com
Construction Company a division of
P.O. Box 1092, Bath, OH 44210 • www.beaconmarshall.com
ZZZ OLVFRKYDF FRP 6WDWH 5G 1 5R\DOWRQ 2+ www.propertiesmag.com 49
VANTAGE POINT Experts weigh in on industry issues
Controlling Property Taxes Paves Way for Economic Sustainability By J. Kieran Jennings, Esq. Siegel Jennings Co. LPA
ike many resurging cities in the United States, Cleveland is enjoying strong demand for downtown living. The high costs of converting existing properties to residential use had made it economically infeasible to develop downtown, however. Despite healthy demand, the downtown submarket lacked profit potential for developers.
L
In order to offset the cash flow deficit confronting developers, city leaders in Cleveland instituted an abatement program to control property taxes. In doing so, the city successfully enabled new investment downtown, not only improving the residential market, but also strengthening the office and retail markets, helping the overall downtown community to blossom. So what lesson does Cleveland’s downtown experiment offer? The takeaway is that reining in property taxes is a catalyst for economic growth and sustainability. Granted, not all taxpayers benefit from abatement programs like the one instituted in Cleveland. All taxpayers still need to control their taxes, however. This rings especially true in Ohio and Pennsylvania, which are the only states in the country that permit local school districts to file tax increase complaints.
School boards often hire attorneys who aggressively seek out specific properties they believe to be under-assessed. Upon filing complaints on these properties, the attorneys will then conduct an investigation, attend the hearings, and even subpoena financial institutions in order to obtain existing appraisals. Therefore, when school boards pursue a tax increase, taxpayers must be prepared and determined to respond accordingly. A recent sale is the red flag that indicates to a school board that a property
What lesson does Cleveland’s downtown experiment offer? The takeaway is that reining in property taxes is a catalyst for economic growth and sustainability.
Costly complaints While being singled out by a school district for a tax increase is bad enough, it proves even worse for property owners in Northeast Ohio because of the region’s excessive tax rate. For comparison, much of the country has a 1% to 2% tax rate, whereas Cuyahoga County boasts an average tax rate of approximately 3.39% of market value, with the highest tax rate being more than 5.79%. To properly contain taxes, it is therefore vital for all taxpayers to be on guard and ready to defend their properties when a school district files an increase complaint. Taxpayers should be aware, however, that defending against a tax increase complaint is more complex than it seems. 50
is ripe for an increase complaint. School board attorneys will often argue that a recent sale of a property is the best evidence of that property’s value. However, a sale price commonly differs from the value that should be used for taxes. In recognition of these differences, the Ohio legislature recently amended its statutes to allow auditors to exercise their own discretion in deciding whether to assign the sale price as value. Auditors “may” use the sale if the sale reflects the “fee simple as if unencumbered value,” according to the statutory language. That means an assessor must strip away non-taxable components before a sales price becomes a useful indicator of market value. For instance, in addition to buying real estate, hotel buyers are often purchasing in-place contracts, existing work forces, personal property, reservation systems,
the reputation of food and beverage providers, and other intangible items associated with a hotel business. As a result, the sale price of a hotel tends to reflect more than the actual value of the bricks and sticks. Additional non-real estate items that often factor into a sale price include the length of lease terms and the value attributable to the credit-worthiness of tenants. Thus, for assessment purposes, taxpayers must take measures to ensure these non-real estate items are removed from a sale price before that value is used in a tax calculation. Controlling taxes requires not only defending against increase suits; taxpayers must also take the initiative in monitoring their property assessments. When roles are reversed and property value is over-assessed, taxpayers should be diligent in contesting their taxes to make sure they are only paying their fair share. Failure to maintain fair taxation may not only result in a diminished return on investment, but may even drive a property into disrepair due to insufficient cash flow. On the other hand, maintaining fair taxation affords a property its greatest chance at economic sustainability, and creates the greatest growth opportunity for the taxpayer. The time for filing a complaint is limited. Tax complaints must be filed in Ohio no later than March 31, 2016, in order to challenge a 2015 tax bill. P J. Kieran Jennings is the managing partner in the law firm of Siegel Jennings Co. LPA, the Ohio and Western Pennsylvania member of American Property Tax Counsel, the national affiliation of property tax attorneys. He can be reached at kjennings@siegeltax.com. 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
When your fair share of taxes is neither fair... nor your share
Fostering Fairness for All Taxpayers The attorneys at Siegel Jennings bring experience as accountants, appraisers and real estate developers to the practice of law. Our property tax services include: Ŷ Representation at the administrative level through the State Supreme Court Ŷ Local expertise in every state through the American Property Tax Counsel Ŷ Tax management – acquisition/disposition strategies Ŷ Cutting edge approaches to property tax reductions
Siegel Jennings Call J. Kieran Jennings, Esq at 216.763.1004 23425 Commerce Park Drive, Suite 103, Beachwood OH 44122
www.siegeltax.com
Cleveland Ŷ Pittsburgh Ŷ Columbus Founding member, American Property Tax Counsel (APTC) • www.aptc.com
NAIOP NEWS Commercial real estate happenings
Making Cleveland Great Again hat a time to be a Clevelander! The RNC will shine the national, and the worldwide, spotlight on Cleveland. The Cavs will win the NBA Championship (they really will). There are so many great projects that are coming online in downtown Cleveland. Many of those projects preserve the history and character of our beautiful buildings and add modern amenities to make them universally appealing.
W
MICHAEL J. SIKORA III
Downtown Cleveland has a positive, vibrant energy that it has not had in a long, long time. There is more excitement in Cleveland than I have seen in my lifetime. For those who are really into commercial real estate, we know it is only going to get better. The future looks bright in Cleveland. We now have an opportunity before us to make Cleveland better than it’s ever been. Cleveland could soon become one of the best cities in the country. We have to make the most of this opportunity, capitalize on it, take advantage of it, and exploit it in a good way. We have to work together to make Cleveland great again. This is an opportunity for all of us, for our friends, for our families, for our children. We have to keep this positive momentum moving forward.
3FBEZ 8IFO :PV /FFE 6T
There is a newfound openness in Cleveland. Commercial real estate professionals are realizing that we can work together in a healthy, collegial way and accomplish more that way. The days of close-mindedness, competition for the sake of competition, and isolationism are fading. The Northern Ohio Chapter of NAIOP is made up of 150 of the top commercial real estate professionals in Northern Ohio. We are going to work together in the coming year and lead a movement to help people see what Cleveland is becoming, what it could be, and how we could get there. It will be up to all of us to make it happen. Our educational programming has been the best in the area for years, thanks to NAIOP’s diverse and talented
%POnU 3FQMBDF *U 3FWJUBMJ[F *U
Q !;'8 !1!+' '9;38!ধ32
Q !86'; £'!2-2+
Q -8' !1!+' '9;38!ধ32
Q -£' £'!2-2+
Q 3£& '1'&-!ধ32
Q 83<; £'!2-2+
)25 <285 +285 (0(5*(1&< 6(59,&( 1(('6 { 52
>>>W '8=-$' !9;'8 W$31 %(5($ 2+ d $9$,/$%/(
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
NAIOP Northern Ohio 2016 Leadership
EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE COMMITTEE CHAIRS
Mike Sikora President
Mark Panzica Past President
Alex Russo Immediate Past President
Jeff Wherry/Donna Haders Executive Director/Secretary Gabe Adler Treasurer Thomas Scanlon Legal Advisor
Mike Merle National Trustee
Bob Vecchione Tax Advisor
Erin Ryan Awards
Brad Nosan Dev. Leaders
Chris Westbrook Golf
Amy Regal Sponsorship
Rob Weeks Membership
Brian Dardis Giving
Vince Adamus Awards Vice
Amber Tanzillo Dev. Leaders Vice
Carmen Fiorilli Golf Vice
Michael Panzica Membership Vice
Don Obermeier Membership Vice
Alex Russo Membership Vice
Education Committee. NAIOP’s lobbying in Washington D.C. and Columbus has protected and advanced the interests of commercial real estate professionals – such as when historic tax credits were taken off the chopping block several months ago, for instance. We will become even stronger in the areas of advocacy and education. Our Spring Market Update on the morning of April 20, 2016 will illustrate both of those strengths. Mark your calendars. It will be our best ever. This year will bring more collaboration to our community, more membership
Ryan Moore Education
Dominic DeLuca Education Vice
our organization, and who will help us make Cleveland great again. Congratulations to NAIOP’s 2016 Board Members represented in the Organizational Chart above. I look for-
Craig Miller Govt. Affairs
Amy Whitacre Dave Robar Strat. Initiatives REAP-ACE Mentor
Shane Farolino Govt. Affairs Vice
Vince Adamus Strat. Initiatives Vice
ward to working with you in the coming year. We look forward to working with all of you in the coming year to do everything we possibly can to make Cleveland great again! P
Mike Sikora is the founder and managing officer of Sikora Law LLC, which focuses on real estate legal matters throughout Ohio, and the president of Omni Title LLC, which performs title and escrow services on commercial real estate transactions throughout Ohio.
HOW BAD IS THAT LEAK?
Save the Date! SCHMOOZAPALOOZA 4 Join NAIOP Northern Ohio at its membership mixer, SchmoozaPalooza 4, with the Blues Cowboys Band at On Air Studio (Crop Restaurant Group), Flats East Bank on January 27, 2016 at 5:30 p.m to our organization, and more engagement of our members. Special thanks to 2015 NAIOP President Alex Russo, who advanced the movement of breaking down barriers and sparked the recruitment of more top developers, owners and brokers as members. Alex has graciously agreed to help NAIOP’s Membership Committee continue those efforts in 2016. NAIOP’s 2016 Board is made up of true professionals – leaders who have already made a difference in their careers and who are now giving back to
Keep your assets safe by taking the time to ensure that problems at the top of your building are not damaging your bottom line.
Carey Roofing Corp. has eliminated asset damage due to a leaking roof with practical solutions since 1946. 216 • 881 • 1999 CAREY www.careyroofing.com
Roofing Corp.
founded in 1946
MEMBER: National Roofing Contractors Association www.propertiesmag.com 53
Is Project Management a“Strategic Process”in Your Business? By Rick Kanzleiter & Ernie Kulik Lean Projects Group, LLC
ithin the real estate, property management and AEC communities, the majority of work completed by organizations are either projects, repeated processes or tasks. Project management is an established discipline (“process”) used to define, plan and manage projects. However, too often projects are not evaluated or managed in a consistent manner “as a process” and typically do not achieve the expected results.
W
The task of managing a project is often simply assigned to the facility manager or outsourced to an external consultant or contractor with different degrees of success. Without an owner’s ability to plan and manage a project in a consistent manner as a process, projects can and often do fail.
to select the right projects, effectively manage, and successfully complete them to provide a competitive advantage. We have seen success rates with Lean process improvements at levels of: • 30% reduction in costs in projects. • 35% reduction in schedule length. • 25% reduction in resources needed.
Project success rate Studies conducted by Project Management Institute (PMI) and other professional organizations indicate on average a 35-50% success rate for projects. There are many reasons for this, such as organizations: • Selecting the wrong project – no selection criteria or alignment with strategic plan • Failing to define a project scope that meets customer needs and specific constraints • Not effectively managing the project or simply outsourcing responsibility to an external consultant or assigning internal staff to be the “project manager” • Taking a “just get it done” approach without taking the time to develop a project plan Too often, the success of a project is dependent on the skills of the individual
Implementing Lean PM
project manager and not on following a consistent process.
Applying Lean to project management Long ago, manufacturing companies realized the need to improve their production processes using the Toyota Production System (TPS or Lean Process Improvement). After Fortune 500 firms improved their production lines and strategic manufacturing processes using Lean, they recognized an additional competitive advantage in applying these same concepts to administrative and support processes, including project management. An established project management process can provide a consistent way
• Evaluate the current process and identify waste (“non value add activities”) • Define the best way your team could/ should manage projects in the future • Brainstorm ideas/opportunities to improve the process • Evaluate and prioritize the ideas listed and select the best ones to implement (action items) to improve the project management process
• Repeat the above sequence of steps periodically (recommended at minimum six months)
SLHUWYVQLJ[ZNYV\W JVT
54
• Prepare a process map of the current way you are managing projects
• Use this improved process to manage future projects & continue collecting ideas
3LHU 7YVQLJ[Z .YV\W *(33 (5+ (:2 /6> >, *(5 /,37 >0;/ @6<9 5,?; 7961,*;
It seems obvious that Project Management is a strategic “process” that should be developed to improve an organization’s competitive advantage. The question then is: how to implement? There is no need to start from scratch. The basic Lean process improvement steps can be applied. They include:
<ZL 3LHU 7YVQLJ[ 4HUHNLTLU[ [V *YLH[L @V\Y *VTWL[P[P]L (K]HU[HNL
By developing a standard/baseline process, which is continually improved, you can internally develop project management as a strategic process.
Three critical areas to consider A Lean process improvement approach can eliminate three critical areas related 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
to project management that many organizations still struggle with. They include:
&200(5&,$/ 522),1* 0$,17(1$1&(
1. Identifying and developing project management as a strategic process for a competitive advantage 2. Improper project selection, which can have significant impact on business results 3. Project management “Lite” effective training for front line or facility managers on projects to leverage limited resources and lower costs
6HUYLQJ (DVWHUQ 2+ :HVWHUQ 3$
ZZZ VUL URRÀQJ FRP
Summary Just as many production line processes have been improved by applying Lean, strategic support processes such as project management have also benefited from the same approach. In addition to improving project management as a process, you can also leverage Lean to support a culture of continuous improvement, engage workers for their ideas and eliminate other non
Just as many production line processes have been improved by applying Lean, strategic support processes such as project management have also benefited from the same approach. value add steps often found during process improvement. The application of Lean to improving project management has provided significant cost savings, on-time delivery and improved quality of final product, which provides a competitive advantage for many companies. There are many documented success stories that demonstrate how this approach can be applied to your organization’s projects to generate similar results. P Rick Kanzleiter, MS Eng, MBA and Ernie Kulik, P.E., PMP are principals at Lean Projects Group, LLC. Lean Projects Group is an experienced team of senior industry professionals who developed project management as a strategic process using process improvement concepts at Fortune 200 companies. For additional information, or to discuss in further detail, contact Lean Projects Group at Barrington Town Square, Suite 318, Aurora, OH, 44202; 330.562.1156; www.leanprojectsgroup.com.
Sustainable practices. Superior results. Only from Schill.
5HWDLO _ &RPPHUFLDO _ ,QGXVWULDO _ &RQGRPLQLXPV +2$V _ $SDUWPHQWV _ +RVSLWDOV _ $VVLVWHG /LYLQJ *URXQGV 0DLQWHQDQFH /DQGVFDSLQJ 6QRZ ,FH 5HPRYDO 6HUYLFHV 6XVWDLQDEOH /DQGVFDSLQJ 5H 'HVLJQ 3ODQQLQJ &XVWRP *URXQGV 0DLQWHQDQFH 3ODQV WR 5HGXFH &RVWV 2YHU 7LPH ,PSURYHPHQW RI &XUE $SSHDO 5HGXFH /LDELOLW\ ZLWK 6DIH (QYLURQPHQWDO 6ROXWLRQV )LQG RXW KRZ 6FKLOO FDQ KHOS \RX FUHDWH KHDOWK\ JUHHQ VSDFHV IRU OLYLQJ ZRUNLQJ RU VKRSSLQJ &DOO XV IRU D TXRWH WRGD\
<RXU EHVW VRXUFH IRU ODQGVFDSLQJ VQRZ UHPRYDO LFH PDQDJHPHQW VHUYLFHV LV 6FKLOO *URXQGV 0DQDJHPHQW 0LOOV ,QGXVWULDO 3DUNZD\ 1RUWK 5LGJHYLOOH 2+ VFKLOOJURXQGVPDQDJHPHQW FRP www.propertiesmag.com 55
5HJHQF\ LV 3URXG WR KDYH 3URYLGHG &RQVWUXFWLRQ 0DQDJHPHQW DW 5LVN 6HUYLFHV RQ &DVH :HVWHUQ 5HVHUYH 8QLYHUVLW\¶V /DUU\ 6HDUV DQG 6DOO\ =ORWQLFN 6HDUV WKLQN>ER[@ DW WKH 5LFKH\ 0L[RQ %XLOGLQJ &OHYHODQG _ &ROXPEXV
&2//$%25$7,21
&5($7,9,7<
,1129$7,21
&RQVWUXFWLRQ 0DQDJHPHQW _ 'HVLJQ %XLOG _ *HQHUDO &RQWUDFWLQJ _ 2ZQHU¶V 5HSUHVHQWDWLRQ
Photo by Scott Pease
Building Outside the Box CWRU embraces innovation at Larry Sears and Sally Zlotnick Sears think[box] By Dennis J. Castiglione | Photos by Ken Krych
ntrepreneurs and engineers have an incredible resource available to them on the campus of Case Western Reserve University in Northeast Ohio. Its existence is drawing worldwide attention in both academia and the business world. Located in the Richey Mixon Building (11201 Cedar Ave, Cleveland), the Larry Sears and Sally Zlotnick Sears think[box] is a center for innovation and entrepreneurship that provides space for students, faculty, alumni and members of the community to creatively invent.
E
A seven-story, 50,000-square-foot facility, the Sears think[box] is one of the largest university-based innovation centers in the world. This particular building actually represents a momentum-driven, significant second step by the university into the realm of makerspaces. The pilot space for Sears think[box], the Prentke Romich Collaboratory was made possible by a $1 million gift from alumnus Barry Romich in memory of his business partner Edwin Prentnke. The Collaboratory was initially a mere 3,000 square feet of basement space that grew to 4,500 square feet, drew over 100,000 visitors and contributed to the launch of 20 start-ups. Those start-ups, in turn, attracted about $3 million in funding from its inception in 2012. CWRU 2005 alumnus Ian Charnas and Dr. Malcolm Cooke, PhD were instrumental in the early brain-
storming and organization of the pilot space. Charnas, who holds degrees in both computer and mechanical engineering, serves as the manager of think[box] and Cooke is the executive director. “I received a call about six years ago when I was at the University of Texas at El Paso indicating that interest was rising for the development of a think tank for the engineering school at Case,” explains Cooke. “I had previously served as an adjunct professor at [CWRU] and had also received my doctorate there. At the time, there was motivation to find space for the engineering students to work and build their projects and as the idea gained a groundswell of interest, I returned to the university to join the team.” Nottingham Spirk, the product design innovation firm known for its Vertical Innovation™ process, was also
involved very early in the development of the think[box]. “We basically have an innovation center just up the hill from the campus that was a prototype for think[box]. We enthusiastically supported the project from its genesis,” says John Nottingham, principal of the organization. “We were able to give them some valuable guidance because we literally do much of what they had planned to do there. We’ve become part of their entrepreneurial ecosystem, which we believe is quite remarkable.” A small committee was formed in 2010 to look for space and funding. A consultant was hired to explore the need for and value of the think tank and this helped determine that there was an interest broader than just at the engineering school. The provost provided some financing and other CWRU www.propertiesmag.com 57
CUSTOM REPRINTS MAKE A GREAT IMPRESSION Did you know you can order custom reprints of articles originally published in Properties? Imagine the impact of a customized publication – a profile on your company or a project with which you were involved – that can be distributed to your existing and future clients. Powerful, personalized, timeless & affordable, reprints are a proven, effective marketing tool to build your business. COM
Februaryy 2015/$7.95 /$ .95
6XSSRU WLQJ WL &DVW ILOPUK :WV[SPN O[PUN [ OL WYV Z\JJL OL
MLZZPVU ZZM\ ZZM\S J VUZ[Y\ HS ZLY]PJL WY J[PVU W YVQLJ[ZV]PKLYZ
Plan Ahead
& Negotiate
By Megan C. Zaidan, Esq. Walter | Haverfie ld LLP
Wisely to Maxim ize
O
9VHKTHW [V *VUZ[Y\J[PVU ,_JLSSLUJL ;OL 9\OSPU *V
Return to Splendor Phased restoration
Saviour in Clevelandd Heights effort revitalizes Church of the
TWHU` JLSLIYH[LZ `LHYZ VM Z\JJLZZ ^P[O L`LZ VU [OL WH[O HOLHK
of the Saviour
| Photos courtesy of Church schoolon one-room its congregation met in a has come a long way since grew in the early 20th century, hurch of the Saviour UM in the late 1800s. As membership archiC he 1920s, Cleveland house in Cleveland Heights conduct services. In the in larger spaces in which to me for the congregation church leaders looked for permanent home was asked to design a larger en the new Church of the tect John W.C. Corbusier in 1928, when His drawings became a reality French Gothic Revival style. Heights. at 2537 Lee Rd. in Cleveland its toll. Plaster was Saviour sanctuary was dedicated
By Diane DiPiero Rodio
C
taking ime was taki that time the church, including a of the church; turrets were made to fallingg in several areas From ornate pinnacles outlining four bell tower in 1952. A wing added to the was wreaking havoc on to the water damage wa below years ago accommodated on the church’s west façade thing from tthe roof decking the nave, church several everything and high Gothic arches accenting wing and another location gutters, interior plaster the built-in gutte the grandeur an education Not Corbusier’s design captured services. stained glass windows. orate staine style while for Sunday as the oldest elaborate of French Gothic Revival As sturdy and impervious la wing of the building of the buildthe long after the last reinforcing the spiritual focus of the church seemed from leaders decided it ch several decades, sections knew was erected, church www.ruhlin.com ing. Through the next by the 2000s members 1 enhancements outside, www.propertiesmag.com architecturally appropriate
Value of Shop ping Cente
Call 216.251.0035 today for a free quote!
utparcels r Outparcels – small lots on the to shopping centers. Outpa periphery of a retail attractive center – allow rcels are often to these users developers utilized by a patio or based on to create banks or the increa drive-thru, added value restaurants, sed visibili which are Developers as outparcels ty and ability important will most to the user’s are more to add specifi convey the often business. parcels either c features, term ground by longsuch as lease or
to the end
user.
outright sale
Recorded docume nts
Once subdivi ded, the subdivisions tive obligat respecFrom a ions developer’s and the parcel of the develop tive, it may perspecer owner (or be necessa lessee) will ground outparcel ry likely be to be legally for the by a governed vided from Reciprocal subdithe Agreement Easeme nt center parcel larger shoppin (an “REA” g as a conditi REA will ). The sale to the on of set forth end user. each obligation oper knows If a develfor matters party’s access, such as of develop in the initial stages utilitie ment that and insuran s, maintenance to sell off it is likely one the develop ce. In additio cels, it would or more outparn, er may also be wise to impose look the separat certain to create e operati ng building development parcels early in the and restrictions process. outparcel upon the pro-active Such a within approach including the larly import is particu height restrict REA, ensure any ions to with time-coant in jurisdictions building constructed thereon sion process nsuming subdivi will not es. block the ibility or of the outparc The sub-dividing vissignage Megan C. Zaidan, Esq. el from the center’s tenants of the shoppin shoppi ng g center could large Equally The develop . subsequent important expedite er may sales for the oper is to limit the also look parcels created of any such develto ensure number of out- plans users of the tenants or independently that outparcel Altern atively. meet or exceed is not restricte lot. If the outparc applicable , developer the el parking d may require requirements could be develop to a single user, the end-use it ed into a r to cause ant strip-ce multi-te parcels to the nter that be subdivi could eventu nhow ded c ll
Legal
From a develo per’s perspective ne it
3URXG WR 3URYLGH 6WUXFWXUDO (QJLQHHULQJ IRU WKLQN>ER[@ DW &:58 3(//(5 $662&,$7(6 ,1&
6 7 58 & 7 8 5 $ / ( 1 * , 1 ( ( 5 , 1 * ([SHUWV IRU RYHU \HDUV LQ VWUXFWXUDO HQJLQHHULQJ LQ (GXFDWLRQDO 6HQLRU +RXVLQJ &LYLF +HDOWKFDUH ,QVWLWXWLRQDO $TXDULXPV 5HFUHDWLRQDO 7KHPH 3DUN DQG &RPPHUFLDO 'HVLJQ &RQVWUXFWLRQ ZZZ SHOOHUDQGDVVRFLDWHVZHVWODNHRK FRP :HVWSRLQW 3DUNZD\ 6XLWH &OHYHODQG 2KLR Proud to have provided flooring for the
Sears think[box] at CWRU Commercial, Institutional & Industrial Floor Covering Provider & Installer
Specializing in the healthcare marketplace with the highest quality & best service since 1989. We provide 24/7 service & installation. Call us today to take advantage of our trained in-house staff and extensive library of product information. Complete line of flooring including: Carpeting • Resilient Flooring, Vinyl & Ceramic Tile • Athletic Floors
Call today for a FREE estimate! 4300 Brookpark Rd., Cleveland, OH 44134 • 216-595-0100 • Toll Free 888-271-8200 58
Photo by Jim Maguire
e de rade r Trades Trad Tra Trade i n tio ti t cti ct ctio ction nstruct P onstruc Constru RAFTSMANSHI MITTED TO C
SLEEK ENVELOPE Composed of cast-inplace concrete and sheathed in metal panels and glass, a new vertical circulation tower was built to provide an egress stairway, which was lacking in the original building.
alumni got involved to assemble the necessary funding to renovate and equip the initial pilot space. The success of that pilot, the growing interest and use of the space by the general public and additional funding prompted a search for a larger space, which ultimately landed the former Lincoln Storage building at the edge of campus (and at the foot of Cedar Hill). A poured-in-place concrete structure, this 50,000-square-foot cold storage building was gifted to the program by the University. Marco Ciccarelli, principal of studioTECHNE and his team were hired as architects for the project, which included preservation of the exterior of the building and the renovation of the seven-story interior. A glass skyway was also designed and built to physically link the Sears think[box] entrance to the Veale Convocation, Recreation and Athletic Center on the main campus. The new facility, the Richey Mixon Building, was named for (recently deceased) J.B. Richey, the retired president of technologies at Invacare and creator of the first full-body CAT scan, and A. Malachi Mixon, retired executive chairman of the board of Invacare. Together they committed $5 million to the project. Another CWRU alumnus, Larry Sears, and his wife, Sally, stepped forward early in the development phase to contribute funding. “When I was in the engineering 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
CREATING A CONNECTION Linking think[box] and the nearby convocation/ recreation center is a bridge that incorporates architecturally exposed pipe elements, wood paneling and glass.
school at Case, we’d get all excited about a project and go back to our dorm and try to build it,” says Mr. Sears. Counting previous contributions, the Sears’ have become the largest individual donors to the Case School of Engineering in its history, with their $10 million contribution to think[box]. “I owe whatever success I’ve had to my extracurriculars,” he says. “It was the work I did outside the classroom that consolidated the theoretical knowledge learned in the class.” Three years after he earned his degree, Mr. Sears founded Hexagram, an electronics company that ultimately created a remote automatic meter-reading device for gas, water and electric companies. He sold the company in 2006, and the month after the sale Larry and Sally made a $6 million gift commitment to the Sears Undergraduate Lab. Their first $5 million commitment to think[box] in 2012 helped launch a major fundraising effort
which included an additional $5 million contribution by Mr. and Mrs. Sears. “English and history majors have the library to do research,” Mr. Sears says. “Athletes have their facilities to prepare and musicians have their studios to practice. From an academic standpoint, we felt that it was important for engineering
students to have a place to work on their projects, as well.”
A fast-track build out Regency Construction Services was selected as the construction manager at risk. The firm’s experience in the college and university market and a
BETWEEN THE WEATHER & YOU SINCE 1922
WARREN ROOFING WARREN ROOFING AND INSULATING COMPANY
3URXG WR EH SDUW RI WKH WHDP ZLWK 5HJHQF\ &RQVWUXFWLRQ 6HUYLFHV IRU 6HDUV WKLQN>ER[@ DW &:58
Commercial/Industrial Roofing + Architectural Sheet Metal
440.439.4404 Fax 440.439.7523
www.warrenroofing.com www.propertiesmag.com 59
PROUD EXTERIOR RESTORERS AT CASE WESTERN RESERVE’S THINK[BOX] M-A Building Maintenance brings more than 45 years of experience in historic building preservation, concrete & masonry restoration. Specializing in: Q Tuckpointing Q Masonry Cleaning Q Stone & Terra Cotta Restoration Q Caulking
0-$ %XLOGLQJ 0DLQWHQDQFH &R
Q Waterproofing
2OG %UHFNVYLOOH 5RDG ,QGHSHQGHQFH 2+ ZZZ PDEOGJ FRP 3K )D[
Q Floor Restoration & Coating
Q Parking Garage Repair Q Deck Coatings
%ULQJLQJ 7KH 3DVW 7R 7KH )XWXUH 7KURXJK 5HVWRUDWLRQ
HVAC ■ Plumbing ■ Fire Protection ■ Process Piping ■
60
Q Foundation Repair Q Exterior Coatings
Proud of our involvement with Regency Construction Services at the Larry Sears and Sally Zlotnick Sears think[box] at CWRU 800-776-7181 www.sacomunale.com
“Large Enough To Meet Your Needs, Small Enough To Care”
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
LEVELS OF DEVELOPMENT Each of the seven floors of the Sears think[box] is designed to accommodate a different stage of developing a project, such as prototyping on the third floor (top) and fabrication on the fourth floor (bottom).
strong reputation for its client-centric approach made Regency a solid partner for studioTECHNE and the CWRU construction team, which was led by Susan M. Kirkhope, LEED AP, AIA, project manager of planning, design and construction. Work on the building began in October 2014. Since the building was initially used strictly as a cold storage unit, there was minimal lighting in place and there was no infrastructure for utilities. Holes were cut between the 12-inch-thick floors for utilities. Windows were also cut from the second floor up to provide natural light. “External light was desired for these floors to add some natural energy for innovative thinking,” says Ciccarelli. The restoration of the exterior, performed by The M-A Building and Maintenance Company, also included extensive repair to the numerous concrete columns, tuckpointing, building cleaning, reconstruction of much of the parapets and penthouse structures, extensive limestone sill and header features, and the application of a high build acrylic coating. “These are our favorite types of projects,” says Monty Guest, president of M-A Building and Maintenance. “To take a building in that kind of visual shape, make it beautiful again, and add the new architectural features is really in our wheelhouse.” The erection of the bridge between think[box] and the Veale Convocation, Recreation and Athletic Center posed a unique challenge, however. “The end points of the bridge are at a different elevation as required by the configuration of the individual buildings it connects. It also curves horizontally,” says Miklos Peller, P.E., president of structural engineering firm Peller & Associates, Inc., noting that the superstructure of the bridge was designed as a three-dimensional space frame with pipe elements, some of which are architecturally exposed. To affirm that the bridge would fit between the two buildings, the steel fabricator constructed the entire bridge in its shop, notes Tari Rivera, president of Regency Construction Services.
“The bridge was cut into two pieces and delivered to the site,” Rivera says. “The ironworkers welded the pieces back together on the ground before lifting it in place. In order for the bridge to land properly, it had to be lifted above both buildings and was lowered in place with an overall tolerance of two inches. This added effort and the expertise of the erectors allowed for this operation to occur with ease.” A new vertical circulation tower was built to provide an egress stairway, which was lacking in the original building. The age of the existing concrete building as well as the absence of copies of the original structural drawings prompted the team to separate the stair and elevator tower from the building by the introduction of an expansion joint, Peller explains. “This required that the slender stair tower be completely self-supporting,” he says. “Since the tower is situated close to
the corner of the existing building, buffeting by wind was another concern so that no perceptible movement would occur within the tower and that the tower be designed having an adequate factor of safety against overturning. Two faces of the tower were designed as a glass façade, so diagonal bracing system was out of the question. For these reasons we opted for a cast-in-place concrete structure with the solid walls used as shear walls, which permitted the use of a thin eight-inch slab for the tower’s floors.” The total weight of the tower is 2,700,000 pounds, he notes. “One of our biggest challenges was getting utilities to the building,” says Corey Campbell, superintendent and the on-site project manager for Regency at think[box]. Water was brought from the campus quad via the skyway bridge. There is also low clearance (floor to ceiling) on each of the seven floors, which www.propertiesmag.com 61
called for creative means of running electrical, HVAC and internet infrastructure throughout. A split system was installed for HVAC. The design by studioTECHNE took full advantage of the natural features of the building. Rather than installing flooring material, the cement floors were ground and polished. Plywood and aluminum was used throughout for both a functional and aesthetic blending of materials and color palette. The “look” created by Ciccarelli and his team appropriately represents the strong innovative technology side of the think[box]. Simply put – it fits. Complementing this approach, signage provider/installer Communications Exhibits Inc. (CEI) utilized metal, Plexiglas and vinyl to achieve an industrial appearance for gateway, floor, wayfinding and directory signage, as well as a donor wall. Each of the seven floors of the Sears think[box] represents a hive of activities from conceptualizing to researching, collaborating, prototyping and fabricating to business incubation and development. “The seven floors were designed to accommodate different stages of development for a project,” Dr. Cooke says. “Each floor represents a phase of the planning or execution component of a given project and our building structure enables and encourages that cooperative integration.” The internal build-out has been equally strategic, as floors two through four were
NEW ANGLES More than just a way to move between floors, an internal staircase is used for study, meeting and presentation opportunities. Beneath and behind the stairs are private, glass-enclosed “think” spaces for meetings and collaboration.
targeted in Phase I construction. Floor two (the Wyant Collaboration Floor, supported by James Wyant, a CIT 1965 graduate) includes open areas and meeting spaces for interaction. The third floor, the Prentke Romich Floor (supported by Barry Romich, 1967 CIT graduate) is used for prototyping. An internal central staircase appropriately ties the second and third floors together. The staircase, itself, is functional beyond a means to move between floors. The stairs are used for study, meeting and presentation opportunities. Beneath and behind the stairway are private, glass-enclosed “think” spaces
s
62
for meetings and collaboration. Meeting and office spaces line the outside walls of the second floor, as well. The Lubrizol Foundation and Kent H. Smith & Kelvin Smith Fabrication Floor (floor 4) features a machine shop and project space. Plans call for the internal build-out of Phase II to begin in March 2016, with completion in time for the start of classes in fall 2016. A $3.1 million construction budget for this phase will cover a redesigned fourth floor and build-out of floor five, a new freight elevator and external renovation of the façade facing the railway. Constructions plans are still being determined for floors one, six and seven. The total construction budget for think[box] is $15 million. The fourth floor will house traditional wood shops and metal shops and the fifth floor is for open projects space, featuring workbenches and storage for active projects. Future phases of the work include floor six (the Cloud L. Cray Jr. and Sally Hunter Cray Center for Innovation and Entrepreneurship, the Burton D. Morgan Suite for Entrepreneurship and the Mandato Family Innovation Office), which is designated for organized resources for entrepreneurs. Floor seven will serve as an incubator for small groups that might form to develop new products. “The Nottingham Spirk Community Floor [floor one] is an inviting space for community programming and a brainstorming haven for people on campus and across the community to gather and create 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
3URXG WR SURYLGH DUFKLWHFWXUDO PLOOZRUN IRU /DUU\ 6HDUV DQG 6DOO\ =ORWQLFN 6HDUV WKLQN>ER[@ DW &DVH :HVWHUQ 5HVHUYH 8QLYHUVLW\
Partner with us..
...it’s time we help you grow.
:%( )%( &HUWL¿HG
9,:,9=, 4033>692 05* ),1( &$%,1(75< $5&+,7(&785$/ :22':25.
Real Estate & Construction Practice Group Anthony R. Vacanti • John P. Slagter • James S. Simon • David L. Drechsler David W. Woodburn • John Swansinger • David J. Lindner Nicholas T. George • Matthew R. Duncan
&DQQRQ 5G %HGIRUG +HLJKWV 2+
ZZZ UHVHUYHPLOOZRUN FRP Akron • Canton • Cleveland
bdblaw.com
ʂ<RXU &XVWRP $UFKLWHFWXUDO 0HWDO 6SHFLDOLVWVʃ &200(5&,$/ ,1'8675,$/ ,167,787,21$/ 5(7$,/
6SHFLDOL]LQJ ,Q (QJLQHHULQJ )DEULFDWLRQ ,QVWDOODWLRQ 2I &RPSRVLWH 0HWDO :DOO 6\VWHPV &RSSHU 6WDLQOHVV 6WHHO 6\VWHPV &XVWRP )DVFLDV )ULH]H %RDUGV (DYHV 0HWDO 5RRILQJ 5ROOHG RQ 6LWH )ODVKLQJ 7ULP &XVWRP *XWWHUV 'RZQVSRXWV &RPPHUFLDO *XWWHUV 5ROOHG RQ 6LWH
3 2 %R[ 0DQWXD 2+
FRXUWDGLQF FRP www.propertiesmag.com 63
ENCOURAGING COLLABORATION The Wyant Collaboration Floor (second floor) includes open, private and semi-private meeting spaces for interaction among project contributors.
ideas to take upstairs,” says Jeff Duerk, dean of the Case School of Engineering. The relationship between Nottingham Spirk and think[box] is certainly strategic for both parties, too. The partnership is designed to both inspire new inventions and bring existing ideas to fruition. “We are building on Nottingham Spirk’s reputation for creating innovative products in the consumer and medical
device fields by helping faculty members, and eventually students, fully develop their own ideas,” Duerk adds. CWRU showcased the Sears think[box] at its own “Thinkapalooza” in October 2015, as part of an Innovation Summit in Cleveland. Case President Barbara Snyder welcomed 500 people to the event, including Nolan Bushnell, founder of Atari; Jeff Hoffman, the
:H ZHUH SURXG WR EH SDUW RI WKH WHDP IRU WKH /DUU\ 6HDUV DQG 6DOO\ =ORWQLFN 6HDUV WKLQN>ER[@ DW &:58 ZLWK 5HJHQF\ &RQVWUXFWLRQ 6HUYLFHV ,QF
&OHYHODQG &HPHQW &RQWUDFWRUV ,QF %XLOGLQJ IRU WKH )XWXUH 6LQFH 9DQ (SSV 5RDG &OHYHODQG 2KLR ZZZ FOHYHODQGFHPHQW FRP 64
founder and CEO of Priceline; and Jim Clifton, CEO of Gallup, Inc. Other visitors have included Apple inventor and co-founder Steve Wozniak.
A reflection of the region The reputation of the Case School of Engineering is already strong. The word is spreading about think[box], making it a key recruitment tool, as well. A recent student survey revealed that about 40% of the students indicated that think[box] was a significant factor in their decision to attend Case Western Reserve University. Community involvement includes K-12 interaction as well as summer camps for groups like the Progressive Arts Alliance. Charnas and Cooke see tremendous potential in collaboration with other educational institutions in the region, as well, like the Cleveland Institute of Art. John Nottingham is also quick to point out what makes this region of the country unique – and therefore what makes think[box] a special resource for the rest of the world. “As you compare Northeast Ohio to other parts of the country, it’s important to recognize what our DNA is – what we’re good at,” Nottingham says. “We get our hands dirty and make things. We may not be a Silicon Valley but we are a ‘medical valley’, a ‘polymer valley’ and a ‘make it valley’. We build things here and think[box] is synergistic to the heritage of what makes Northeast Ohio unique. This is an extraordinary benefit to the student, faculty, outside company and community stakeholders.” P 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67
Crunching C hi th the numbers b on N Northeast th t Ohi Ohio’s ’ real estate & construction markets
),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: $ & $ )25(&$67 2 &$
Where We Are + Where We’re Going CBRE offers an overview of Northeast Ohio commercial real estate 2015/2016 Story & images provided by CBRE
or the third year in a row, CBRE continues to see solid lease and sale activity in all property categories within Northeast Ohio’s commercial real estate market. There is a flight to quality with investors and occupiers, so older, obsolete buildings and properties located in tertiary submarkets continue to be challenged.
F
Drivers of the market continue to be the creation of mixed-use projects or districts within downtown and suburban areas. The evolving healthcare environment is also generating significant activity. Here is a look at where we stand in Northeast Ohio as we review 2015 and preview the New Year. Best wishes for continued success!
Northeast Ohio Office Market By Conor Coakley Vice President Buzz around Northeast Ohio hit new levels in the fortuitous week of June 8-11, 2014 with the double whammy a n nou ncement s of the Republican National Convention (RNC) and LeBron James’ “I’m Coming Home” to 66
1RUWKHDVW 2KLR 287/22. 2)),&(
,1'8675,$/
5(7$,/
9$&$1&< ,19(1725< $&7,9,7< 4827(' /($6( 5$7(6 1(*27,$7(' /($6( 5$7(6 6$/(6 35,&(6
,19(670(17 $&7,9,7<
6$/(6 6 35,&(6 6
the Cavaliers. These two marquee events helped reinforce the confidence in the overall Northeast Ohio Market throughout 2015 and into 2016, particularly in the Central Business District (CBD), for inves-
tors (including real estate developers), office tenants and residents alike. Investments Both the CBD and suburban submarkets of Northeast Ohio saw an uptick in institutional investment in 2015. Time Equities (NYC) closed on a six-building office portfolio on Rockside Road and has already invested millions into improvements. Hertz (California) expanded its local holdings, buying Fifth Third Center and Skylight Office Tower. Dan Gilbert’s Bedrock companies continue to expand their operations and footprint in and around Quicken Loans Arena and Tower City Center. We anticipate more out-of-town investors in 2016 as Forest City Enterprises downsizes its headquarters. Local developers Geis/Hemingway, Weston, K&D and Millennia continue to be very active, with no signs of slowing down into the New Year. Hotel investment in the CBD is at an all-time high in preparation of the 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
RNC with the following projects under construction and ready to open in 2016: Hilton Cleveland Convention Center Hotel (600+ rooms, 46,000 square feet of event space, restaurant, roof-top bar); Drury Plaza on Mall A in the former and historic Board of Education building (180 rooms, pool, restaurant/bar); and The Schofield Hotel (Kimpton branded, 128 rooms). Hyatt Place, Aloft, Drury, Fairfield Inn, Curio and AC Hotel Cuecna also have plans for new suburban locations this upcoming year. Office tenants Cleveland’s Class A office market tightened considerably in 2015, currently at 91% occupancy, with new construction on the horizon to meet demand. Overall vacancy rates in the CBD are down, with the continuing trend of converting Class C buildings into residential. Proposed new construction projects include Stark Enterprises’ NuCLEus at E. 4th and Prospect (mixeduse development with 200,000 square feet office), Weston’s “super block” in the Warehouse District (mixed-use, 200,000 square feet office in Phase II), and Trammell Crow/Cumberland’s 28-acre lakefront site (see rendering on pg. 66) at North Coast Harbor (mixed-use, up to 1 million square feet office). The largest office transactions in the CBD this year were the consolidation and relocation of AECOM (post URS merger) to 1300 E. 9th St., now AECOM Centre (71,000 square feet); Asurint (38,000 square feet) to 1100 Superior; Taft Stettinius & Hollister (52,000 square feet) and Fox Sports (31,000 square feet) in 200 Public Square. Local office trends mirror the national trend of tech-related and creative companies targeting downtown office options in order to recruit and retain Millennials. PIRHL, StartSmart, Spero-Smith and Gottlieb Organization all relocated to the CBD from the suburbs this year in large part to wanting to be “closer to the action.” The year 2016 will usher in the opening of the new American Greetings headquarters at Crocker Park (650,000 square feet); Dealer Tire’s headquarters move to the Victory Center in Midtown
""# ! ) )& % % + ! '! (!'
% + (!
Cleveland (166,000 square feet) and numerous projects between the Cleveland Clinic, University Hospitals, Summa Health Systems and MetroHealth. Residents Once the great industrialists who helped create Cleveland’s economy moved from Millionaire’s Row on Euclid
! '! (!
Avenue east to the Heights, downtown was not considered a viable place to live. Over a century later, this reality has come full-circle, with over 13,000 residents living in the CBD, and another 4,000 residential units either under construction or in development. In 2015 alone, the Flats East Bank Phase II opened (240 units, six restau-
> COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE expertise. > PERSONALIZED COMMUNITY BANK service.
It’s all about collaboration, individualized service and fostering economic growth in our community. We’re committed to it. And nearly 80 years of community banking expertise supports it.
LET OUR TEA M HELP YOUR S THR I V E . Contact Rig Goss at (216) 239-5904.
www.propertiesmag.com 67
),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: $ & $ )25(&$67 2 &$
rants, FWD Day & Nightclub), The Ivory on Euclid, Creswell at Playhouse Square, Schofield Residences, Southworth Buildings and The Archer (rehab) all opened as market-rate apartments. The trend will continue with the Garfield Building, Halle Building, 925 Euclid Avenue and the former May Company building conversions expected to open (or start construction), and absorb the 1,800+ person waiting list for units in the CBD. Helping spur this housing demand is the community’s emphasis on quality-of-place and quality-of-life. Transformational park and greenspace initiatives are currently underway at Public Square ($35 million full rehab), Canal Basin Park in the Flats (20acre new park) and the Rotary Club/ RTA’s Red Line Greenway rails-to-trail project connecting downtown to Ohio City. These public/private projects, in addition to the Cleveland Metroparks expansion along Cuyahoga River and Lake Erie, have helped create a dynamic environment, which people are choosing to live in. Retail certainly follows rooftops, evident along Lower Euclid with the wildly successful (and delicious) Heinen’s Grocery Store in the former Cleveland Trust Rotunda and next door, with Geiger’s Clothing and Sports. With the CBD daytime population of over 125,000 workers, and with the success of the 5th Street Arcade shops, 2016 is poised to be a big year for downtown retail with the announcements of many other national/local soft-goods retailers, restaurants and amenities.
""# ! % + ! '! (!'
% + (!
We are incredibly excited to share the renaissance of Greater Cleveland with the rest of the world in July of 2016. From our perspective, the upcoming Republican National Convention will be a lot more than politics.
Northeast Ohio Industrial Market By Jacob Westfall Associate The Northeast Ohio Industrial Market continued to tighten in 2015. Vacancy dropped as low as 5.7% throughout the year, which has not been achieved since 1999. The majority of this space is tired. The average age of industrial properties with vacancy is 1965. The availability of large block, Class “A” space (100,000+
Suntrol It! SUNTROL
™
G L A S S
E N H A N C I N G
F I L M S
Suntrol.com 800-466-TINT (8468) ESTABLISHED 1975
Love Your Windows! 68
Avoid the High Cost of Replacement Windows • Save Money • Save Energy • Enhance Security
! '! (!
square feet, 24-foot clear, built after 2000) has dropped to well below 2%. This has caused rental rates to increase, which has tempted developers to build on speculation. A few spec buildings were delivered in 2015, and we expect more to come in 2016. The following have current availability: 99 Independence Parkway, Twinsburg (207,360 square feet) Delivered in November of 2015. Scanell Properties, based in Indianapolis, built this facility after securing Tire Wholesale Warehouse for 53,000 square feet. The remaining 154,300 square feet is still available for lease. This is the first speculative project at Cornerstone Business Park (the former Chrysler Stamping Plant). Seasons Business Center, Stow (108,000 square feet) Slated to be delivered in January of 2016. This is Phase I of the new industrial park at the intersection of Route 8 and Seasons Road in Stow. Fogg teamed up with David Brennan to develop this property. Bluestone Business Center 2, Euclid (127,020 square feet) Fogg was 75% leased on their first building in the industrial park after six months. In April of 2015, they leased out the remaining 25%, which led to the construction of their second building in the park. The building was delivered in December 2015, and 127,020 square feet remains available. 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
:H EHOLHYH HYHU\ EXLOW HQYLURQPHQW FDQ PRYH EXVLQHVV DQG SHRSOH IRUZDUG &%5( WXUQV VFDOH LQWR VWUHQJWK VTXDUH IHHW LQWR HIÀFLHQF\ DQG H[SHQVH LQWR SHUIRUPDQFH +RZ FDQ ZH KHOS \RX WUDQVIRUP \RXU UHDO HVWDWH LQWR UHDO DGYDQWDJH" )RU PRUH LQIRUPDWLRQ FRQWDFW RU YLVLW 'DYLG %URZQLQJ 0DQDJLQJ 'LUHFWRU FEUH FRP FOHYHODQG
Build on Advantage
% )'(&# $ * #$ #$#(+ ! '! (!' Local manufacturing companies had another good year in 2015. Many companies are growing at a fast pace and require additional space. This, combined with low vacancy rates, is forcing manufacturers to contemplate ground-up, build-to-suit facilities. This provides a great opportunity for manufacturers to consolidate multiple facilities, which can greatly reduce operational inefficiencies and improve workflow. Industrial construction should be strong in 2016. Notable build-to-suit projects completed or started in 2015 include: Arhaus Furniture, Boston Heights (779,000 square feet) Expected to be delivered in the first quarter of 2016. The former Boston Mills Country Club is being developed by Premier Development Partners LLC and will be the future headquarters for Arhaus. This is a consolidation of Arhaus’ corporate offices, distribution center and multiple warehouses. FedEx, Twinsburg (380,000 square feet) Scannell Properties completed construction in August. The FedEx distribution center is currently the largest facility at Cornerstone Business Park. Ramco Specialties, Inc., Hudson (165,000 square feet) Expected to be delivered in February of 2016. Geis is building this facility in the Hudson Industrial Business Park. This will be the future headquarters for Ramco, which is consolidating three locations. Nestlé, Solon (144,000 square feet) Delivered in June 2015. Nestlé invested $53 million on this groundup research and development center. This is one of 11 Product Technology Centers that Nestlé has globally. The center will support Nestlé’s frozen and chilled foods business.
* #$ #$#(+
cap rates has caused a dramatic increase in sales price per square foot for investment-grade industrial assets. Sellers are taking advantage of the opportunity to realize above average returns. Some of the more notable investment sales in 2015 were: STAG Industrial, Inc., Macedonia (202,000 square feet) STAG purchased the facility from Sun Life Insurance Company in July for $12 million. The multi-tenant building, located off of Highland Road, is currently 100% leased by National Business Furniture, Penske and Mygrant Glass.
! '! (!'
Cintas, Brecksville (216,729 square feet) Taking advantage of a hot market, Cincinnati-based Cintas completed a sale/leaseback at their Brecksville location in June. They sold the building to a private investor for $11.9 million. Weston Inc., Euclid (175,000 square feet) In April, local developer Weston Inc. purchased the former H.C. Starck manufacturing facility for $2.2 million in Euclid. They immediately leased over 60% of the building to Mechanical Dynamics and Analysis, Inc. The remaining manufacturing space has since been leased.
Restoration Contractors American International Construction, Inc. is a company dedicated to the restoration and preservation of numerous types of buildings, including related services on new structures. Let our commitment to quality and client satisfaction work for you. UÊ >Õ }ÊEÊÃi> > ÌÃ
UÊ Õ ` }ÊV i> }
UÊ >V>`iÊÀiÃÌ À>Ì UÊ/ÕV « Ì } UÊ >à ÀÞÊEÊÃÌ iÊÀiÃÌ À>Ì UÊ-Ì ÀivÀ ÌÊÀi Û>Ì UÊ ÃÌ À VÊ«ÀiÃiÀÛ>Ì UÊ7>ÌiÀ«À v }
Michael Petrasek The Northeast Ohio industrial capital market remains active and healthy. The average cap rate has fallen roughly 2% in the last 6 years. This decrease in
president
1073 WEST BAGLEY ROAD, BEREA, OHIO 44017 ph: 440.243.5535 f: 440.243.7745 www.aiconstruction.com
www.propertiesmag.com 71
Invacare, five properties between Ohio and Florida (+/-575,000 square feet) Invacare completed a sale/leaseback of five of their properties in order to raise money and strengthen their balance sheet. Industrial Realty Group purchased the assets for $23 million. The total rent in year one of the long-term leases is $2.275 million. Looking forward, expect rental rates to continue to escalate. Investment activity will stay lively. Construction levels will rise and companies considering a move will have to start analyzing their options earlier than ever.
Northeast Ohio Retail Market By Tim Soeder Senior Associate At the end of 2015, the Northeast Ohio retail real estate market found itself healthy and full of confidence with significant growth on the horizon. The past year has made for an exciting time in the industry with vacancy continuing to gradually decline, retailers new and old competing for prime positions in key markets, new developments of all sizes breaking ground or in various stages of planning, and the flight to quality remaining a central theme among all retailers. Although pre-recession strength has not yet been achieved in Northeast Ohio’s retail sector and the market is not without some of its old blemishes, the outlook appears to be optimistic for the future. Overall, retail vacancy declined again over the past year. The current vacancy rate stands at 11.3%, which is a slight improvement from the 11.5% reported at the end of 2014. Portage County enjoyed the lowest vacancy of all tracked submarkets with a mere 4.4% of retail space left vacant at the end of 2015. Summit and Stark County also showed strong occupancy levels with vacancy of 6.7% and 9.5%, respectively. The remainder of the submarkets continues 72
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
to experience double-digit vacancy rates, as many are still contending with older centers in secondary markets that are carrying available space. Unfortunately, the struggle of such centers to keep from becoming obsolete seems less likely to occur now more than ever, as the majority of retailers are looking to do more with less when it comes to their brick-and-mortar distribution. The energy efficiency of newer green construction has proven its worth in reducing retailers’ bottom line when compared to the aging centers of the past era. Creativity in re-purposing such space, or tough decisions to demolish it, will be needed in the future in order to bring the market into balance. While retailers’ focus on quality over quantity has negatively affected existing space in secondary markets in Northeast Ohio, the opposite can be said for space in primary markets in the region. Research shows that the
vacancy has continued to decline in Northeast Ohio’s strongest retail nodes. Competition among retailers in select markets was so great in 2015 that it allowed landlords to begin exerting
New retail development appeared to have returned in full swing to Northeast Ohio in 2015 with approximately 355,000 square feet of new construction completed throughout the year and 2.1 million square feet of planned space in the pipeline at year’s end. their power again in both tenant selection and lease negotiations, which has pushed rents to reach all-time highs in some instances. New retail development appeared to have returned in full swing to Northeast
Ohio in 2015 with approximately 355,000 square feet of new construction completed throughout the year and 2.1 million square feet of planned space in the pipeline at year’s end. Highlights of the new robust return to retail development include: • Downtown Cleveland’s continued revitalization creates more retail space with the completion of Phase II of the Flats East Bank mixed-use project and the opening of several eclectic restaurants and lively nightlife spots on its ground floor. Developers announced plans for three additional mixed-use projects in the Downtown Cleveland market throughout the year, all of which will contain a significant retail component. • Organic grocery chain, Whole Foods, opened its newest location in the region on Cleveland‘s west side in Rocky River in 2015. Whole Foods also announced plans to open an additional location on the west
!30(!,4 0!6).' !30(!,4 2%0!)2 3%!,#/!4).' #2!#+ &),,).' #/-0,%4% 3)4% #/.3425#4)/.
0!6 ) . ' ) . # s %XCELLENT QUALITY COMPETITIVE PRICING RELIABILITY
%8#!6!4)/. 4/ #/-0,%4)/.
s #UNNINGHAM 0AVING IS A FAMILY OWNED BUSINESS WITH OVER YEARS OF EXPERIENCE s ,ICENSED BONDED INSURED s /UR MOTTO h+EEPING OUR CUSTOMERS SATISFIED KEEPS THEM COMING BACK v
* iÊӣȰxn£°nÈää >ÝÊӣȰxn£°nÈnÎ !URORA 2OAD 7ARRENSVILLE (EIGHTS /( www.propertiesmag.com 73
),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: $ & $ )25(&$67 2 &$
side of Akron in 2017 and to relocate their existing Beachwood store to the Planned Pinecrest mixed-use development in the City of Orange. • Big box development returns to Northeast Ohio after a five-year hiatus with the announcement of Wisconsin-based home improvement chain Menard’s and Michigan-based discount chain Meijer’s plans to expand in the region. Each reports average store size in excess of 200,000 square feet, and both have closed on initial locations in primary markets with plans to move forward with construction on those sites in 2016. • Outdoor gear megastore competitors, Cabela’s and Bass Pro Shops, each announced plans to build locations in the region, while REI, a smaller competitor within the outdoor segment, is being touted as one of the likely occupants of the planned Pinecrest mixed-use development in the City of Orange. In the coming year, look for uncertainty to remain in the economy and markets, both locally and globally. Vacancy will continue to fluctuate as planned new centers are constructed, leaving obsolete centers with uncertain futures. Lease rates should steadily increase, as retailers move into new spaces and rent conces-
sions begin to evaporate. Landlords of older centers will continue to give creditworthy retailers tenant improvement dollars with intentions to make their centers more competitive.
Northeast Ohio Investment Market By Vicki Maeder, CCIM Vice President – Investment Properties As 2015 was winding down in mid-December, the Federal Reserve increased rates, which has been forecast and expected for a long time. This anticipated action has been a driver for sellers who wanted to take advantage of the higher values that come with lower interest rates and the availability of good debt financing. In Cleveland and certainly across the country, the investment activity has returned to normal levels as real estate continues to be a vehicle that is highly desirable for placing capital. The interest in Cleveland and most secondary markets has been strong from private capital sources who view the stability of the Midwest as a plus in placing equity. The recent press that Cleveland has been generating over the past couple
of years as a result of LeBron returning and the Cavs’ NBA Finals run in 2015, the upcoming RNC convention in mid-2016 and past international events held here such as the Senior Games and Gay Games and the Monet exhibit at the Museum of Art (offered in only two cities worldwide), coupled with our world renowned orchestra, quality healthcare providers, well known chefs/ restaurants and our sports teams all provide us with positive press. Okay, the Browns could be suspect here, but the point is that all these things combine to provide a good focus on Cleveland and overcoming misperceptions. As a result, investors are noticing Cleveland, which is bringing them here to take a look at the recent offerings in the market. The more active investors have been from Ohio, California, New York, New Jersey, Illinois, Minnesota, Florida and Canada. A number of these investors such as Philips Edison, Inland, Shelbourne Global, RMC Group and Hertz invested in 2015 in multiple properties or added to their existing holdings. In many cases, they are bringing in foreign capital as part of their ownership structure. The office investment sector downtown saw a return of the sales of large, stable assets with Skylight Office Tower and Fifth Third transferring to Hertz. The trophy asset of Key Tower was in the market in the fall with bids due in
9G YQWNF DG RTQWF VQ DG RCTV QH [QWT VGCO QP [QWT PGZV EQPUVTWEVKQP RTQLGEV
CONTAINER SERVICE, INC.
¸;OL 3LHKLY PU *VU[HPULY :LY]PJL¹ -), *:) ,+., *,9;0-0,+
>>> 7,;,(5+7,;,05* *64
74
@6<9 *65:;9<*;065 :7,*0(30:;: .9,,5 3,,+ 7961,*;: @(9+ -965; 36(+ *65;(05,9: @(9+ 96336-- *65;(05,9: 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
(XFOLG *ODVV 'RRU December. The largest block of space that sold, 925 Euclid Avenue (formerly known as the Huntington Building) will be a redevelopment project of mixed-use hotel, office, retail and apartments now that it has won the catalytic tax credit award from the State of Ohio. In the suburbs, the larger sales over $5 million also continued the trend of selling well located, stable assets with the exception of the value add acquisition by Time Equities in Independence. Fewer office building sales were of distressed, lender-owned properties. Small sales of properties under $5 million in value were primarily sales to user/investors, or the buyers acquired them as a redevelopment opportunity. Retail sales in the market ran the spectrum from prime grocery-anchored to distressed lender-owned assets with
The interest in Cleveland and most secondary markets has been strong from private capital sources who view the stability of the Midwest as a plus in placing equity. distressed more numerous, as we continue to eliminate those properties from our inventory and bring in fresh capital to reposition the assets. The apartment market continues to be in high demand just as it has been in recent years. There are still a number of assets that were lender-owned or distressed trading but this is diminishing in number. The largest recorded transfers were as a result of the sale of Associated Estates to Brookfield and the Forest City/Gross Builders cross sales to terminate the partnership. Interest rates have risen, but rates are still at historically low levels. Capital will continue to be abundant and investors will seek out opportunities for investment as they chase yield. There are always concerns that can impact the markets negatively such as the recent terrorist attacks, the turmoil in the international markets, the U.S. economy plus the fall election. P
SERVICE! PROMPT PROFESSIONAL 440.269.1335 | www.euclidglass.com 4560 Glenbrook Rd., Willoughby, OH 44094
You Already Take Enough Risks. You work with industry experts to reduce risks to you and your employees. Shouldn’t the same be true for your accounting firm?
With over 95 years of experience in the construction industry, we understand the business cycles, the special income tax issues, the reporting and bonding requirements, and the unique risks and opportunities contractors face each day. Accounting Expertise x Business Planning x
Tax Planning
Succession Planning x Profit Enhancement x Bid Reviews Cost Control x Litigation Support Services x Job-Cost Auditing
To reach our Cleveland Office, call 216.241.3272 or visit www.meadenmoore.com
AKRON | BEACHWOOD | CLEVELAND | WOOSTER www.propertiesmag.com 75
),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: $ & $ )25(&$67 2 &$
National Construction Outlook 2016 Dodge Data & Analytics anticipates 6% growth in construction starts he expansion for the construction industry has been underway for several years now. The construction start statistics show 2010 as the initial year of recovery, although a real recovery with a meaningful contribution from the housing sector did not take hold until 2012.
T
76
The Pattern of U.S. Construction Starts Billions of Dollars 2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
Total Construction
435.3
441.3
492.5
545.2
594.7
674.7
712.0
+2%
+1%
+12%
+11%
+9%
+13%
+6%
Single-Family Housing
100.0
97.3
125.8
159.2
163.8
187.4
224.8
+6%
-3%
+29%
+27%
+3%
+14%
+20%
22.1
29.7
40.6
51.5
69.9
85.1
91.2
Multifamily Housing
+23%
+34%
+37%
+27%
+32%
+25%
+7%
Commercial Buildings
42.2
48.3
55.1
67.3
81.2
84.3
93.7
-11%
+15%
+14%
+22%
+21%
+4%
+11%
Institutional Buildings
112.2
100.3
91.8
92.0
103.6
110.2
120.3
-0-
-11%
-8%
-0-
+13%
+6%
+9%
Manufacturing Buildings
9.5
17.3
13.1
18.8
35.3
25.3
25.0
-2%
+82%
-25%
+44%
+88%
-28%
-1%
Public Works
120.7
106.9
112.3
126.7
119.8
122.4
122.9
-2%
-11%
+5%
+13%
-5%
+2%
-0-
Electric Utilities
28.7
41.5
53.8
29.7
23.2
60.0
34.0
+36%
+45%
+30%
-45%
-22%
+159%
-43%
electric utility and gas plant category is excluded, total construction starts in 2015 would be up a more moderate 8%, slightly less than the corresponding 11% increase reported for 2014. The residential building sector in 2015 is providing a greater contribution to the construction expansion than last year, with its 2015
increase pegged at 18%. Single-family housing has moved beyond its 2014 plateau and is now seeing moderate growth, while the upward track for multifamily housing continues. Public works construction this year will edge up a modest 2%, as activity has settled back after its brisk pace in early 2015.
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
Source: Dodge Data & Analytics
Since then, there’s been an increasing contribution from commercial building, and 2014 saw the institutional building sector (namely educational facilities) finally join the recovery process after a lengthy decline. Public works construction has registered some growth in the current decade, while manufacturing plants and electric utilities/gas plants have introduced a measure of volatility on a year-to-year basis. After bottoming out in 2009 at $426 billion, total construction starts by 2014 had climbed to $595 billion, a gain of 40%. This evolving expansion for the construction industry has taken place against the backdrop of a generally hesitant U.S. economy, with GDP growth hovering around 2%. As 2015 has entered the record books, total construction starts for the previous 12 months are estimated to have climbed 13% to $675 billion, which will be the strongest yearly gain so far in the current expansion. Much of this increase is coming from a huge 159% hike for the electric utility and gas plant category, reflecting the start of several massive liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminals in the Gulf Coast region, as well as renewed growth for new power plant starts. If the
One noteworthy change for 2015 is that nonresidential building is now estimated to be flat to slightly down, which follows its substantial 24% jump in 2014. The primary reason behind this year’s pause for nonresidential building is the steep drop for the manufacturing plant category, which reported a surge of petrochemical plant starts in 2014 and is now seeing a decline for energy-related projects. At the same time, both the commercial and institutional segments of nonresidential building have decelerated in 2015. While economic factors remain generally supportive, last year’s gains for both commercial and institutional building possibly overshot their underlying growth trends. The economic environment going into 2016 carries a mixture of headwinds and tailwinds. The Federal Reserve will move towards a more neutral monetary stance this year, with the initial increase in the federal funds rate anticipated to take place in December or early 2016. The increases are expected to be gradual, however, leaving the federal funds rate at about 1.5% towards the end of next year. Global economic conditions are anticipated to remain sluggish – a negative for U.S. exports but a plus for helping to keep long-term interest rates and energy prices low in the near term. Political uncertainty as it relates to the U.S. Congress appears to be rising, yet the need to demonstrate the ability to govern may avert a return to the brinksmanship that occurred in 2013. On the plus side, the U.S. economy continues to register moderate job growth, lending standards are still easing, market fundamentals for commercial real estate continue to improve, and more funding support is coming from state and local construction bond measures. Overall, the U.S. economy is expected to grow 3.1% in 2016, up from 2.5% this year. For 2016, total construction starts are forecast to advance 6% to $712 billion. Gains are expected for nonresidential building, up 9%; and residential building, up 16%; while the nonbuilding construction sector slides 14% following this year’s substantial jump. If the electric power and gas plant category is
excluded, total construction starts next year will be up 10%. The pattern by more specific sectors is the following: • Single-family housing will rise 20% in dollars, corresponding to a 17% increase in units to 805,000 (Dodge basis). Access to home mortgage loans is improving, and some of the caution exercised by potential homebuyers will ease with continued employment growth. • Multifamily housing will increase 7% in dollars and 5% in units to 480,000, slower than the gains in 2015 but still growth. Low vacancies, rising rents and the demand for apartments from Millennials will encourage more development. • Commercial building will increase 11%, up from the 4% gain estimated for 2015. Office construction will resume its leading role in the commercial building upturn, aided by more private development as well as construction activity related to technology and finance firms. • Institutional building will advance 9%, picking up the pace after the 6% rise in 2015. The educational facilities category is seeing an increasing amount of K-12 school construction, supported by the passage of recent school construction bond measures. • Manufacturing plant construction will recede an additional 1% in dollar terms, following the steep 28% plunge for 2015 that reflected the pullback for large petrochemical plant starts. • Electric utilities and gas plants will fall 43% after the sharp 2015 jump. The lift coming from new starts for LNG (liquefied natural gas) export terminals will be substantially less, and new power plant starts will recede moderately. P Reprinted with permission from Dodge Data & Analytics’ “2016 Dodge Construction Outlook.” For more information, visit Dodge Data & Analytics online at www.construction.com.
Register Now & Save 20%! Discounts available for attendees and exhibitors! Don’t miss out – early registration ends Jan. 25!
64th Annual Design & Construction Conference & Tradeshow
GX FNEJ KUNN g IUNN # '064' FIKKK '641+6 &T '56.#-'X HHEHI 210514 #0& ':*+$+614 12214670+6+'5 #4' #8#+.#$.' 019 g %#.. #6 FEJgGJEgGENN (14 &'6#+.5T 10('4'0%' #66'0&''5 '#40 72 61 J *1745 g 8+'9 /14' 241)4#/ &'6#+.5 10.+0' #6 999T%'50'6T14)T -!'!:).% ).#
+5 # 2417& /'&+# 5210514 1( 6*' .'8'.#0& 0)+0''4+0) 1%+'6; www.propertiesmag.com 77
),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: $ & $ )25(&$67 2 &$
Highlighting the Housing Market HBA hosts Annual Economic Housing Forecast, shares local, national data By Brenda Callaghan HBA of Greater Cleveland
n late 2015, the Home Builders Association (HBA) of Greater Cleveland held its Annual Economic Housing Forecast to a sellout crowd of more than 200 people at the Cleveland Downtown Hilton DoubleTree hotel ballroom.
I
Serving as keynote speaker at the event was Ivy Zelman, CEO of Zelman and Associates, who has roughly 25 years of experience covering housing and housingrelated industries and provides analyses across all aspects of the housing spectrum. Zelman began her presentation stating that the housing industry is “the giant among midgets in today’s economy.” She highlighted some of what is driving the industry today, such as young adult momentum driving stronger household foundation formation as well as employment growth among that same demographic, which continues to outpace other age cohorts. While income growth has been disappointing, with the recession driving young adults to stay at home longer, HBA expects the release of pent-up demand as employment improves. She added that household formation benefits the entire housing spectrum and touched on birth rates. The preliminary 2014 birth data reflects strong increases, supporting the need for additional new single-family construction. There was a 1.4% increase in birth rates in 2014 of adults 25+ (strongest
• Single-family projected at 870 million in 2016 (19%) and 985 million in 2017 (up 13%) Multi-family housing reflected the following:
• Multi-family starts of 375 million in 2015 (up 6%) • Multi-family projected at 375 million units in 2016 (flat) and 360 million multifamily units in 2017 (down 4%)
since 2007) and an overall growth of 3.4% (strongest since 1990) Zelman addressed the multi-family market, stating that it had recovered, and noted that single-family construction still remains well below normalized levels. While improvement is evident across the housing spectrum, she stated the single-family trajectory has been bumpy based on the following statistics and predictions: • Single-family starts of 730 million in 2015 (up 12%)
SPECIALIZING IN EXTERIOR MASONRY REPAIR & RENOVATION SINCE 1972 • COMPLETE INSPECTION/ASSESSMENT OF FAÇADE CONDITIONS • TUCKPOINTING/CAULKING
• BRICK & STONE REPAIR/REPLACEMENT
• SEALING/WATERPROOFING
• CLEANING/PRESSURE WASHING
Ph 216.881.4142 | Fx 216.881.6557 | 4408 St. Clair Ave., Cleveland, OH 44103
78
statistics
Current improving conditions spur investment in entry-level housing, Zelman said, supporting HBA’s positive outlook; the tight supply is driving price appreciation and affordability remains extremely favorable. The non-banks had only 33% of the market share in 2013; today their share is 52% while the banks continue to pick and choose.
Labor and land constraints Zelman also addressed the labor and land issues that are affecting housing, stating that construction-related employment is slower to recover than the remainder of the economy. Since the fourth quarter of 2012, construction-related employment has strongly surpassed the remainder of economy but the share remains depressed, suggesting even more outsized growth to come. The most-constrained trades were framing and concrete, although the supply of flooring labor was highlighted as above average. Which leaves us with the question – can constraint be solved without immigration reform? Regarding the availability of lots, Zelman stated that the A and B lot supply is below 50% and the C lot 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
locations are just above 50%, although expanding capital availability should help ease supply constraints and reinforce the long term outlook.
Cleveland market highlights Zelman ended her presentation with a look at the Cleveland housing market. Although Las Vegas, Chicago and Cleveland were the only markets surveyed with below average overall market conditions, builders can expect price appreciation in Cleveland that is ahead of the broader market (4.9%). In addition, Cleveland’s resale market favors buyers, and years 2015 through 2017 look good – something the housing industry has not heard in quite some time. Other presenters at the HBA’s Housing Forecast event were Ann Marie Wiersch, senior policy analyst at the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, and Professor Robert Simons, of Cleveland State University. Wiersch addressed the overall conditions of small business credit and alternative lending sources. The main point of her presentation was the fact that small businesses are seeking alternative sources for lending – many of which are online. Some of the advantages of using online resources were a simple application process, quick approval, easier standards and no collateral needed. The disadvantages were the high costs and lack of clarity on terms. Professor Simons, former director of the Masters of Urban Planning, Design and Development program at the Levin College of Urban Affairs, reminded everyone that Cleveland is nested in a world economy with seven of the fortune 500 companies here in Northeast Ohio. Although manufacturing is down in the region, medical is up and housing is inexpensive. Simons also noted that Ohio’s unemployment is 5.2%, versus the national rate of 5.5%, and that we are the fifth fastest growing population of workers with advanced degrees. Downtown apartment housing is at 97.5% with 1,800 on a waiting list for downtown apartments, Simons said. Cleveland home prices are up with an increase of 9.4% compared to the prior
year, and sales prices have appreciated 20.4% over the last five years in Cleveland. Professor Simons noted that firms are doing better and employment is increasing, adding that there is little risk-taking and lots of cash on the sidelines. Although we are experiencing a mostly jobless recovery, the unemployment rate is low and housing prices
and resales have stabilized at lower levels – but are creeping back up. In addition, residential construction is up 17.5% since August of 2014. Ending on a positive note, Simons stated that new construction has improved activity and could be robust for the next few years, although he cautioned against irrational exuberance. P
'21·7 /(7 <285 %86,1(66 *2 287 :,7+ 7+( 75$6+
NORTHCOAST Shredding & Record Center 0,66,21 72 3529,'( 6(59,&( 7+$7 (;&(('6 285 &86720(5¶6 (;3(&7$7,216
7+( &267 ,6 /(66 :+(1 <28 86( 7+( %(67 1$,' $$$ &HUWL¿HG
5HFRUG 6WRUDJH
,Q +RXVH 6KUHGGLQJ
+RVWLQJ :LWK $FFHVV
2Q 6LWH 6KUHGGLQJ
6FDQ 2Q 'HPDQG
0RQWKO\ 6HUYLFH 3URJUDPV +DUG 'ULYH 'HVWUXFWLRQ
&RPSOLDQFH :LWK $OO ,QGXVWU\ /DZV DQG 5HJXODWLRQV
6KUHGGHU 6DOHV
DQG 0XFK 0RUH
,PDJLQJ 6FDQQLQJ 6HUYLFHV WR WKH 0HGLD RI <RXU &KRLFH
&DOO &KHW *UHHQ DW
ZZZ QRUWKFRDVWUHF\FOLQJ FRP www.propertiesmag.com 79
),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: $ & $ )25(&$67 2 &$
Hot Topics in Northeast Ohio Survey of regional building & real estate professionals illustrates outlook for 2016 By Roger T. Gingerich, CPA/ABV, CVA, CCA Skoda Minotti
n 2015, Skoda Minotti completed its annual survey of the Northern Ohio real estate and construction industries, collecting opinions on a variety of issues that are in the minds of decision-makers throughout the region. The results are encouraging.
I
In a word, the respondents of These numbers aren’t surpristhe Northeast Ohio construction ing when viewed on a national industry are feeling positive. The level. The decreasing pool of upward momentum reflected in skilled labor continues to be the survey indicates that the vast a problem across the country, majority of respondents are generone certainly echoed here in ally feeling optimistic about their Northeast Ohio. According ability to get quality work now and to the Associated General in the years ahead. Contractors of America, the As we’ve slowly recovered, the number of unemployed job downtown Cleveland construction seekers in the country who last boon is keeping larger contractors worked in construction fell by busy, freeing up the playing field for almost 200,000 from May 2014 0RUH RSSRUWXQLWHV /HVV RSSRUWXQLWHV LQ 1( 2KLR LQ 1( 2KLR other contractors. Contractors are to May 2015, ending with the seeing average job sizes increasing lowest May total since 2005. BETTER DAYS AHEAD Asked if they see their business and the lending climate improving. having more opportunities or less opportunities over Material price volatility We’re now three full years into the next three years in Northeast Ohio, Skoda Minotti’s For the first time since 2012, Ohio Construction Reform, and it survey respondents were overwhelmingly positive about material price volatility was ranked continues to be met with mixed improving conditions. by survey respondents as the politireviews. Some of the very challenges With the U.S. construction market cal issue most likely to affect their reform was intended to address are viewed by respondents with skepticism. returning to the trillion-dollar mark business this year. While beating out The lack of skilled labor continues to be a in fall 2015, it marked the industry’s healthcare by just a slight margin, it has biggest gain since it bottomed out in been ranked as either the top one or top considerable concern as well. As the construction industry budget 2007. According to U.S. Census figures, two most important political issues in climbs back slowly but steadily to the construction volume this past April five of the last six years. Conversely, when survey respondents trillion-dollar range it should be in, we was up $81 billion, a 9.7% increase over ranked business threats for the next 12 expect margins to improve – this is a March figures. Further, according to the June 2015 months, material price ranked fourth reason people are more optimistic. Bureau of Labor Statistics report, con- among the choices. This suggests that Opportunity & optimism struction employment increased by 4.5% “securing skilled labor” is viewed as a In the eight-year history of conduct- to roughly 6.4 million – its highest level much larger threat with approximately ing the Construction Survey, this is since February 2009. 40% of the ranking. the first year survey respondents have broken the 50% mark when predicting Real estate survey Skilled labor more opportunities in Northeast Ohio For the most part, 2014 was a very good Despite an increase in job opportunifor their businesses over the next three ties, for the second straight year the year for the region’s real estate industry. years. More than two-thirds of survey ability to secure skilled labor was chosen More than two-thirds of respondents respondents see more opportunities for by most respondents as the greatest per- believe the credit market has loosened their businesses between now and 2017, ceived threat to their businesses over the up, reflecting even more optimism than a more than 20% increase over last year. next 12 months – no other issue was even last year. Rents are on the upswing in Survey respondents also report more close. Lack of work, such a great threat in residential, commercial and industrial opportunities outside Northeast Ohio. previous years, is in distant second place. markets. While cash flow continues to 80
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
be a concern for most property owners, very few are reducing expenses.
Lending Every year we take the pulse of the real estate lending and equity environments, a very good measure of the health of the industry. Overall, the results were very positive and our respondents are optimistic. Similar to last year, our respondents are experiencing mixed results from lenders, all depending on the health of their companies and their projects. We asked respondents whether the credit market has loosened up with regard to investment real estate. Eighty-one percent agreed it either had loosened up by 2014 (69%) or it will in 2015 (12%). The balance of respondents are looking for improvement in 2016 and beyond.
ties and projects increased from 2014’s low of 21% to 46% in 2015. While the number is moving in the right direction, it still remains low compared to 20092012 figures. In addition to the highlights, this year’s report covers the hot topics of the skilled labor shortage, Affordable Care
Act and tangible property regulations. To download the full report, visit www.skodaminotti.com/survey. P Roger T. Gingerich, CPA/ABV, CVA is the partner-in-charge of Skoda Minotti’s Real Estate and Construction Group. You can contact Roger at 440-449-6800 or rgingerich@skodaminotti.com.
Cash Flow Those reporting that their cash flow is sufficient to support existing proper-
;d]n]dYf\ k Kl]]d @]Y\imYjl]jk
&olXPELa %XLlGLnJ 3UoGXFts STEEL JOISTS STRUCTURAL IRON METAL ROOF DECK STEEL STAIRS & RAILS STEEL ERECTION
440-235-3363 *-1.) =de Kl&$ ;d]n]dYf\$ G@ ,,)+0
www.propertiesmag.com 81
),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: $ & $ )25(&$67 2 &$
FINANCIAL STRATEGIES Smart use of fiscal planning & action
Winning Ways s most of this column’s regular readers already know, I am a big fan of the NFL. And one of the favorite sayings around the league is “when you are winning, you are never really as great as people say you are.” Although this may be a foreign concept to our football team here in Cleveland, our commercial real estate market clearly has been on a winning streak. But is it really as great as people say it is?
A
ALEC J. PACELLA
Positive momentum was a key phrase last year and nearly all of the commercial real estate sectors felt this benefit. Leading the way, once again, was the multi-family sector. It seemed as if each week, another new downtown project was grabbing the headlines. And it’s not just hype – during 2015, nearly 500 new units were completed in the downtown area but despite this additional inventory, occupancy rates continued to hover near 100%. There are approximately 275 units under construction with another 4,000 in various stages of planning. And while new apartment construction outside of downtown has been limited, occupancy rates were
5HVXOW 2ULHQWHG DQG 5HOLDEOH /HJDO $VVLVWDQFH IRU WKH &RQVWUXFWLRQ ,QGXVWU\ &ODLPV 0DQDJHPHQW DQG $YRLGDQFH &RPSHWLWLYH %LGGLQJ 6FKHGXOH 'LVSXWHV 'HIHFWLYH :RUN DQG 'HVLJQ &ODLPV 3URMHFW 'HOLYHU\ DQG &RQFHSWXDOL]DWLRQ 0HFKDQLFªV /LHQV 6XUHW\ %RQG &ODLPV /DERU DQG (PSOR\PHQW $UELWUDWLRQ DQG 0HGLDWLRQ /LWLJDWLRQ
strong across the region, with average rates in the mid-90% range for most areas. Bolstered by a healthy and expanding manufacturing sector, the industrial sector also had a strong year. Occupancy rates were in the low 90% range, rents increased and nearly 1 million square feet of speculative construction is underway. Examples include new warehouse facilities in Euclid, Twinsburg and Stow – all of which were started without substantial leasing commitments in place. After taking a beating at the beginning of this decade, the retail sector also recovered nicely, with several new retail developments underway. These include projects
OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED.
3XEOLF 6TXDUH 6WH &OHYHODQG 2KLR 3KRQH )D[ ZZZ IUDQW]ZDUG FRP 82
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
such as Pinecrest in Orange, Costco and Bass Pro Shops in Boston Heights and Cabela’s, Menards and Meijer in Avon. The fourth primary commercial sector, the office sector, was the only one that was a mixed bag. On the positive side, the overall level of leasing activity picked up and certain traditional office corridors performed well. But on the negative side, there was still a substantial amount of vacant office space in the market and overall job growth in the office sector has been lackluster. It sounds like our market has been winning, but will this streak continue? From my perspective, I’m cautiously optimistic. But you know me – nothing is ever as simple as two words. Let’s talk about the optimistic part first. The commercial real estate market is 24 months into this current expansion. Considering how far we fell during the most recent and historic downturn, we had a lot of room to make up, so it’s reasonable to think that the expansion will continue for at least another 12 to 24 months. This isn’t to say that sale prices and lease rates will increase at the same pace we have seen over the last few years. But, in general, the velocity for both leasing and sales activity should remain solid throughout 2016. Now let’s talk about the cautious part. Each commercial real estate sector is in a different stage of the real estate cycle and each faces some risks. The multi-family sector is clearly the furthest along in terms of its recovery and, as such, poses some potentially significant challenges. One of the largest is the threat of overbuilding, especially in the downtown area. While the demand has been outpacing the supply, the projects that are in the development pipeline are more complex and thus, more expensive. There is a clear danger, not only that supply will start to overpower demand but also that the overall rental rate will approach levels higher than the market can support. Investors should approach this sector with caution. The next sector with some significant risk is the retail sector. Several projects are underway but all of these are addressing specific areas of growth that have been driven more by a redistribution of popu-
Daus, You Know? GRADING TIME Once again, it’s time to check back on my annual prognostication for Cleveland’s overall investment sales volume. In the January column last year, I boldly predicted a volume of $800 million for 2015. And the actual volume came in at $796 million - proof that even a blind squirrel can stumble across a nut every now and then. Looking ahead to 2016, I’m going to plant my sales volume flag at $750 million, as I think that rising interest rates will damper the sales volume a bit. Stay tuned throughout the year to see if I can continue my stay in the rarely-seen penthouse or return to the “no-place-like home” outhouse. –AP lation versus new population. In other words, the net population of the region has remained virtually the same – it has just moved from one place to another. And while the newest retail developments should fare well, the retail centers that have lost both population and tenants to these new developments will be in for some very hard times. Investors need to understand and underwrite appropriate risk when considering specific opportunities. In contrast, the industrial sector has a less risky outlook. Although new construction is also occurring in earnest, it is sorely needed, as there continues to be a shortage of quality industrial space in our market. And the primary driver of this demand is a marked improvement in the manufacturing sector. So long as our economy continues to be solid, the industrial sector will remain strong. Investors just need to be sure to temper their enthusiasm, as it’s possible to overpay for anything. The last sector is the office market, which is accompanied by two
cautions. First, the newest office product in our market has met with great success and much of the oldest product has been taken off the market via conversions to multi-family. But the middle-age properties, those buildings developed in the 1960s through 1980s, have languished. Much of this is related to inherent inefficiencies associated with office buildings from this era. And second, the overall nature of office space utilization is quickly changing, with companies having more employees but occupying less space. The end result is a “double whammy” for our region – office jobs in northeast Ohio are generally not increasing. And the companies that are expanding are incorporating more efficient workspaces and occupying less overall square footage. Investors need to realize that a seemingly “can’t miss price” can still miss. I’m going to add one final overall caution, especially to my investor friends, and that would be interest rates. For nearly half a decade, interest rates have hovered at historically low levels but this will finally change in 2016. And it’s more of a question of how as opposed to when. If the increase occurs in a slow and measured manner, the commercial real estate markets should be able to adjust. But if rates make an abrupt and measurable jump, the markets may have a much more adverse reaction. P Alec Pacella, CCIM, senior vice president at NAI Daus, can be reached by phone at 216.455.0925 or by email at apacella@naidaus.com. You can follow him on twitter @dausyouknow or on his blog at http://blog.sbequitiesinc.com.
Landscaping Contracts – with Extraordinary Color Plans Planting, Design & Installation • Irrigation Installation & Repair Routine Ro outtine ti PProperty roperty ope pe y Ins Inspection sspec pecti pec tion o & Maint Maintenance Mainte a tenaa ccee
T HHNTIFJTGFIK GGNTFGMTEMMI '48+0) .. 1( *+1 www.propertiesmag.com 83
),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: $ & $ )25(&$67 2 &$
ACAR CORNER Issues in the real estate industry
A Year of Growth, Change, Opportunity he current pulse on the Ohio housing sector shows a changing marketplace, with many cities reporting an increase in the inventory of homes listed for sale, as well as rising list prices and faster sales cycles compared – based on a comparison of November 2014 and 2015 data.
T
SALLY JOHNSON
84
According to Realtor.com’s November 2015 Housing Report, which tracks inventory of for-sale, single-family homes and condos, median list prices, inventory levels and days on the market for 300 cities across the country indicates that the residential real estate market continues to follow the normal seasonal decline in demand. The median list price in November remained virtually the same in Ohio,
consistent with a seasonal decline in demand, coupled with limited inventory. Residential listings continue to decline from its yearly peak. In the Northeast Ohio region though, within the geographic range of ACAR, data revealed that the median list price and total listings in Akron and Cleveland-Elyria area are up. However, the median age of inventory is down, which is a good sign that properties are selling quicker.
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
In Akron, the median list price is up 8.8% and total listings are up 2.4%, while the median age of inventory is down 7.0%. In Cleveland, the median list price is up 4.7% and total listings are up 8.8%, while the median age of inventory is down 8.6%. Compared to the findings from a year ago, all nine of the Ohio markets tracked reported an increase or remained unchanged in the median list price in November. All markets reported a faster pace of sales, while a majority of Ohio markets saw an increase in the number of homes being marketed for sale compared to November 2014 levels.
͙͙͔͔ ǡ ǡ ͕͕͗͘͘ Ǧ ͖͕͚Ǥ͚͖͘Ǥ͚͔͔͘ ͖͕͚Ǥ͚͖͘Ǥ͚͔͕͘
Ƭ Ƭ Ȁ Ǧ Ƭ
Ǥ Ǧ Ǥ
A year in review for ACAR The Akron Cleveland Association of Realtors experienced a great year of positive growth and change. From crafting a comprehensive strategic action plan – developed with insights across the organization – to negotiating and signing a lease for a new office space in Broadview Heights to consolidate both the Akron and Independence offices, ACAR continues to build on the momentum of the merger two years ago. The upcoming year will be another exciting one, with the new office opening to the public and an open house reception in March, a review and tweaking of the strategic action plan, new and expanded member offerings and services, updated and enhanced continuing education events and much more. As outgoing president, I can certainly say that my time leading the ACAR board has been incredibly fulfilling and a positive learning experience. I look forward to remaining an integral part of the association in other capacities. If you would like more information on market statistics and ACAR news, please visit www.akronclevelandrealtors.com. P
Sally Johnson is the president of the Akron Cleveland Association of Realtors (ACAR). Visit www.AkronClevelandRealtors.com for more information.
͖͘Ȁ͛Ȁ͚͙͗
ůLJƐƐĂ D͘ 'ƌĂƵ
ŚĂƐ ũŽŝŶĞĚ ,ĂŶŶĂ ŽŵŵĞƌŝĐĂů ZĞĂů ƐƚĂƚĞ ĂůLJƐƐĂŐƌĂƵΛŚĂŶŶĂĐƌĞ͘ĐŽŵ Ͳ ϮϭϲͲϮϭϮͲϬϮϯϰ ůLJƐƐĂ 'ƌĂƵ ũŽŝŶƐ ,ĂŶŶĂ ŽŵŵĞƌĐŝĂů ďƌŝŶŐŝŶŐ LJĞĂƌƐ ŽĨ ĞdžƉĞƌŝĞŶĐĞ ŝŶ ĐŽŶƚƌĂĐƚ ŶĞŐŽƟĂƟŽŶƐ͕ ŽƉĞƌĂƟŽŶƐ͕ ĂŶĚ ŵĂƌŬĞƟŶŐ ĂĐƌŽƐƐ ƐĞǀĞƌĂů ĚŝīĞƌĞŶƚ ŝŶĚƵƐƚƌŝĞƐ͗ ĐŽŶƐƵŵĞƌ ƉĂĐŬĂŐĞĚ ŐŽŽĚƐ͕ ĞŶĞƌŐLJ͕ ĂŶĚ ĐŽŵŵĞƌĐŝĂů ŝŶƐƵƌĂŶĐĞ ƐĞƌǀŝĐĞƐ͘ /Ŷ ĂĚĚŝƟŽŶ ƚŽ ǁŽƌŬŝŶŐ ŝŶ ůĞǀĞůĂŶĚ͕ ƐŚĞ ŚĂƐ ŽƉĞƌĂƚĞĚ ŝŶƚĞƌŶĂƟŽŶĂůůLJ ŝŶ ƵƌŽƉĞ ĂŶĚ >ĂƟŶ ŵĞƌŝĐĂ ĂƐ ǁĞůů ĂƐ ŽƚŚĞƌ ŬĞLJ ŵĂƌŬĞƚƐ ŝŶ ƚŚĞ h͘^͘ ƐƵĐŚ ĂƐ ŚŝĐĂŐŽ ĂŶĚ EĞǁ zŽƌŬ͘ ůLJƐƐĂ ŝƐ Ă ůŝĐĞŶƐĞĚ ĐŽŵŵĞƌĐŝĂů ƌĞĂů ĞƐƚĂƚĞ ƐĂůĞƐƉĞƌƐŽŶ ŝŶ ƚŚĞ ^ƚĂƚĞ ŽĨ KŚŝŽ ĂŶĚ ƐƉĞĐŝĂůŝnjĞƐ ŝŶ ŽĸĐĞ ĂŶĚ ŝŶĚƵƐƚƌŝĂů ƐĂůĞƐ Θ ůĞĂƐŝŶŐ͘ WƌŝŽƌ ƚŽ ũŽŝŶŝŶŐ ,ĂŶŶĂ ŽŵŵĞƌĐŝĂů͕ ůLJƐƐĂ ƐĞƌǀĞĚ ŝŶ Ă ůĞĂĚĞƌƐŚŝƉ ĐĂƉĂĐŝƚLJ ĂƐ WƌŽĚƵĐƚ DĂŶĂŐĞƌ Ăƚ WƌŽŐƌĞƐƐŝǀĞ /ŶƐƵƌĂŶĐĞ ǁŚĞƌĞ ƐŚĞ ǁĂƐ ƌĞƐƉŽŶƐŝďůĞ ĨŽƌ ƚŚĞ ŽŵŵĞƌĐŝĂů >ŝŶĞƐ ďƵƐŝŶĞƐƐ ĂĐƌŽƐƐ ϭϰ ƐƚĂƚĞƐ͘ ^ŚĞ ĂůƐŽ ƐƉĞŶƚ Ă ŶƵŵďĞƌ ŽĨ LJĞĂƌƐ ŝŶ ƉƌŽĐƵƌĞŵĞŶƚ͕ ǁŚĞƌĞ ƐŚĞ ŵĂŶĂŐĞĚ ŶĞĂƌůLJ Ă ŚĂůĨ ďŝůůŝŽŶ ĚŽůůĂƌƐ ŝŶ ĂŶŶƵĂů ƐƉĞŶĚ ĂŶĚ ĐŽŶƐŝƐƚĞŶƚůLJ ĚĞůŝǀĞƌĞĚ ĂŶŶƵĂůŝnjĞĚ ƐĂǀŝŶŐƐ ŽĨ ϭϬй Žƌ ŵŽƌĞ͘ ƵƌŝŶŐ ŚĞƌ ďƵƐŝŶĞƐƐ ƚĞŶƵƌĞ͕ ůLJƐƐĂ ŚĂƐ ďĞĞŶ ƌĞĐŽŐŶŝnjĞĚ ĂƐ Ă ƚŽƉ ŶĞŐŽƟĂƚŽƌ͕ ĂŶĚ ǁŽŶ ͞ ĞĂů ŽĨ ƚŚĞ zĞĂƌ͟ ŝŶ ϮϬϭϬ ĨŽƌ ŚĞƌ ǁŽƌŬ ŝŶ ĐůŽƐŝŶŐ Ă ΨϮ ĂŐƌĞĞŵĞŶƚ͘ ůLJƐƐĂ ŐƌĂĚƵĂƚĞĚ ĨƌŽŵ dŚĞ hŶŝǀĞƌƐŝƚLJ ŽĨ ŚŝĐĂŐŽ ŽŽƚŚ ^ĐŚŽŽů ŽĨ ƵƐŝŶĞƐƐ ǁŝƚŚ ĂŶ D͘ ͘ ͘ ŝŶ &ŝŶĂŶĐĞ ĂŶĚ ^ƚƌĂƚĞŐŝĐ DĂŶĂŐĞŵĞŶƚ͘ ^ŚĞ ƌĞĐĞŝǀĞĚ ŚĞƌ ͘ ͘ ǁŝƚŚ ŚŝŐŚ ĚŝƐƟŶĐƟŽŶ ŝŶ ^ƵƉƉůLJ ŚĂŝŶ DĂŶĂŐĞŵĞŶƚ ĨƌŽŵ DŝĐŚŝŐĂŶ ^ƚĂƚĞ hŶŝǀĞƌƐŝƚLJ ĂŶĚ ĐŽŵƉůĞƚĞĚ ƚƌĂŝŶŝŶŐ ĨŽƌ ƚŚĞ ^ŝdž ^ŝŐŵĂ 'ƌĞĞŶ Ğůƚ ĚĞƐŝŐŶĂƟŽŶ͘ ^ŚĞ ŝƐ ĂŶ ĂĐƟǀĞ ƉĂƌƟĐŝƉĂŶƚ ǁŝƚŚŝŶ ŚĞƌ ĐŽŵŵƵŶŝƚLJ ƐĞƌǀŝŶŐ ŽŶ ƐĞǀĞƌĂů ĐŽŵŵŝƩĞĞƐ ĂŶĚ ďŽĂƌĚƐ͘ www.propertiesmag.com 85
),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: $ & $ )25(&$67 2 &$
Challenges and Opportunities to Watch for in 2016 By Geoff Goss Walter | Haverfield
f there is one term that aptly describes the 2015 commercial real estate construction boom more than others, especially in Cleveland, it is “hotel mania.” In 2015, Cleveland saw lots of hotels either breaking ground or initiating major renovation projects all in an effort to ramp up and provide necessary capacity for the Republican National Convention (RNC). In 2016, we can expect to see all of those hotels coming online before the start of the Convention in July.
I
Hosting such a landmark event is new hotel brand – The Kimpton – to good news, especially in the shortthe Cleveland area. term. Cleveland and, in particular, the Just beyond the central business downtown area, previously had a shortdistrict, the Flats East Bank project age of hotel rooms which restricted our continues to grow and expand its region’s ability to attract major events. development mix, and slightly farther Now we’ll have plenty. The long-term out, One University Circle is moving challenge will fall on our economic forward with anticipated construction development and commerce organizathroughout much of 2016. tions to attract sufficient events and The building boom that characcrowds to ensure that all these new terized Cleveland even before 2015 and revamped hotels maintain high AROUND THE CORNER A major milestone (but which became much more noticeoccupancy rates. for downtown Cleveland this year will be the able in the past 12 months) will also So what else can we expect in 2016 reopening of the Schofield Building at E. 9th and be reflected by a resurgence in retail beyond a lot of hotel development? Euclid as The Kimpton Schofield Hotel. activity, a direct result of the ever Lots of other development and reconincreasing downtown residential For those Cleveland-based projects struction all focused on the RNC. population. New retail stores have conLook at any contract that’s being written that are not directly related to the RNC, tracted to come downtown to give rise or renegotiated for 2016 in and around their start will likely be delayed until to a rebirth of street-level upscale retail. Cleveland. It’s all about the Convention. after the RNC has finished. Projects Heinen’s already opened with great fanThe RNC will likely dominate the head- involving only interior work or buildouts fare in early 2015, Metro Home opened lines from both a business and real estate will not be affected by the moratorium. mid-year near E. 9th and Superior, and A major milestone for downtown Geiger’s opened on Euclid Avenue, just perspective at least through July. This year will be characterized by a Cleveland will be the reopening of in time for the holiday shopping season. huge surge of construction as develBeyond the Cleveland city limits, to opers and landlords frantically work the west, Crocker Park has added a to finish prior to the Convention. In hotel and is expanding its retail space June, however, everything will come and, to the east, development of the to a screeching halt to accommonew Pinecrest project near I-271 and date the City-imposed construction Harvard is underway. moratorium prior to and during the Still further outside the City limits Convention. Between security con– in Canton – signs of progress on cerns and the desire to provide an the expansive Hall of Fame project aesthetically pleasing view of the city the Schofield Building that has been are already evident with significant addiwhich showcases Cleveland in a positive shrouded in scaffolding and other con- tional activity to be seen in the coming way for the thousands of delegates, media struction equipment for longer than year. When finished, the project will and outsiders that will be descending on many people can remember. Located at completely change how people use and Northeast Ohio, all cranes and exterior one of the busiest corners in downtown visit the Hall of Fame, and the increased scaffolding will need to be removed prior Cleveland’s business district, the build- traffic will benefit all of Northeast Ohio. to the RNC. During that time no con- ing is expected to be renovated in time In Akron, redevelopment also continues struction materials can be transported in for the RNC. The Schofield reopening to boom largely because of the progreswill also mark the debut of an attractive sion of the Goodyear project. or outside of downtown. 86
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
Photo courtesy of Kimpton Hotels & Restaurants
This year will be characterized by a huge surge of construction as developers and landlords frantically work to finish prior to the [Republican National] Convention.
9PZL :OPUL *SL]LSHUK A major factor affecting activity in 2016 will be interest rates. With the Federal Reserve having just increased its benchmark interest rate by a quarter point, there is some expectation that rates will continue to rise through the new year. A rising interest rate environment will likely push investors and developers to refinance existing debt sooner rather than later. The new year is shaping up to be exciting and prosperous for Northeast Ohio and, especially, for Cleveland. Our real estate market appears to be ahead of the national trend, largely as a result of the impact of the RNC. Moving past the time of the RNC, however, the future is a bit less certain and only time will tell which projects will continue to move forward. From a legal perspective, the overlying theme is that of optimism but a heads up to proceed responsibly since nothing this good lasts forever. P
Complete Construction Cleaning
Window Cleaning
Div. of KOZLOVICH ENTERPRISES
@6<»33 *3,(93@ :,, ;/, +0--,9,5*, PRESSURE WASHING ALSO AVAILABLE
*HSS ;VKH`
Geoff Goss is a partner in the real estate practice group of Walter | Haverfield, LLP.
Our strength is in our numbers. Put one of the region’s largest real estate practice groups to work for you. We have the resources and experience to handle transactions of any size. Urban & Historic Redevelopment Land Use & Zoning
The Real Estate Attorneys of
Real Estate Finance
Leasing
Development
Tax Credit Transactions
Tech, Multi-family & Shopping Centers
Josh Hurtuk, Carl Dyczek, Megan Zaidan, Kevin Murphy, Tyler Bobes, Todd Hunt, Jack Waldeck, Sophia Deseran, David Mansbery, Nick Catanzarite, Rick Amburgey, Nate Felker, Jennifer Heimlich, David Ricco and Geoff Goss
Cleveland | 216.781.1212 www.walterhav.com
www.propertiesmag.com 87
ABCs of Energy Efficiency Benchmarking and EE-as-a-Service By Mark Kelly Kel-Lume Group
here is no doubt that executives, senior management, building owners and facilities personnel are searching for innovative and cost-effective ways to lower operating costs and increase shareholder value. Energy Efficiency (EE) has proved to be a weapon in which to combat the combined cost effect of fluctuating energy and water prices, aging equipment and increasingly higher forms of regulation.
T
In a past article for Properties (December 2015), I wrote on the topic of one component to the EE puzzle: LED retrofits, and the “myths” surrounding them. This time, let’s look through a broader lens at the issue, and point out a few key ingredients to assist us in realizing more of what EE projects can offer. Obviously, a building doesn’t necessarily have to be new to be efficient. Today’s leading building owners are beginning to retrofit their properties, converting existing buildings into models of sustainability. Most in this group tend to pursue single technology improvements, such as in lighting or HVAC technologies. Market leaders, however, seek a comprehensive approach, grouping technologies and approaches together to realize deeper savings. But if these technologies and approaches are so wonderful, and have been implemented in many examples big and small, why doesn’t everyone upgrade their site(s) immediately? Some might argue the difference between wants and needs, applying it to EE projects. As in, “I’m busy, so if my equipment works today, upgrading is a want, or nice-to-have, but not a pressing need.” Sure, I get that, but really the wants/needs argument runs hollow, and many companies get caught in this pattern. Meanwhile, equipment keeps getting older and operational expenses (OPEX) continue to rise. In reality, two main things hold back EE projects: focus and finance.
U.S. commercial building population – nearly 6 million in all – lacks basic improvements that reduce both energy consumption and cost. Corporate sustainability experts, energy procurement professionals and facility operations managers face a difficult, if not impossible, task: how to quickly identify high impact efficiency opportunities across a multi-building portfolio.
is a slam dunk!” Maybe, maybe not, but these words are used to push for the audit. After the audit is completed, a proposal is submitted, and then the sales process takes effect in order to close the customer and move forward with the project. A main issue with this approach is focus. How can the end user know their building is really a poor performer? The use of T12 florescent lighting is not the only factor affecting building efficiency. What if there are 20 sites – are all these sites bad? Or are some worse off, in terms of energy efficiency, than others? It is a costly endeavor to run contractors around doing site audits or even to accomplish a “remote audit” (a process which introduces uncertainty into the data set). Then the consultant compiles various products into a submission, but usually there is no view or intelligence as to which site is best to focus on first. This process is repeated again and again across all the buildings in a portfolio, and then, anecdotally, up to 90% of the proposals fail to become
Energy Efficiency (EE) benchmarking is a process of comparing your property’s energy performance to similar facilities, utilizing property details, equipment information, meter data (utility, natural gas, water and sewer) and more.
Where to start According to technology company Building Energy, a Kel-Lume Group partner, only 2% of commercial and industrial building stock is considered “new.” This means virtually the entire 88
There are many consultative companies around today which target just these sorts of customers, and offer help and “expertise” to come in and accomplish EE audits. They may say, “if you are using T12 fluorescent, LED
3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
real projects. Sounds like a lot footwork with little result. Great business, right?
Benchmarking = believable results EE benchmarking is a process of comparing your property’s energy performance to similar facilities. Unlike every other approach, EE benchmarking normalizes data using building attributes like property details, equipment information and many, many others. Meter data of all kinds – utility, natural gas, water and sewer, as well as sub-meter reads – gets accurately mapped to actual buildings automatically. The benefits are significant. For the first time, any building can be benchmarked against a peer group of real buildings based on real data. The peer group can be configured using standardized criteria like building type, usage, size or geography in order to produce a relevant performance benchmark. EE benchmarking allows each site to have comparative metrics against other real sites. In the 20-site example above, EE benchmarking would show immediately where the poorest performers are. Maybe four sites stand out as the worst offenders. Now, focus is gained and all EE triage effort can be applied at those sites first, instead of wasting everyone’s time, energy and money looking at all 20 sites. Perhaps a more significant note is believability. Although this idea is based on large-scale data, EE benchmark results are easy to understand. Business and financial decision-makers are able to make rapid, informed decisions. Say goodbye to expensive and time-consuming energy audits. They become obsolete. So do remote “black box” analytics.
internal measures such at internal rate of return, payback period and return on investment (ROI). Capital lease can be compelling since not everyone can, or wishes to, pay cash. Energy financing is a method to use the saved operational expense an EE project creates as cash flows to pay for the project through time. A capital lease program can be administered to use the concept of energy financing. Things to consider are: no upfront cash, no origination or closing costs, cash flow positive from day one, and flexible leasing terms. There are different terms available within a capital lease, so be sure to look for many options.
EE saving-as-a-service: a new way Both cash and a capital lease will have impact on the balance sheet. And further, a capital lease, while a solid alternative to cash, also comes with an interest rate. These rates can be manipulated though a “buy down” process, but
• Projects are 100% installed with no end user cash out-of-pocket expense • Actual electricity draw is monitored, post-project, via revenue-rated metering • Documented savings is split between end user and EE group • Warranty: product and labor covered – i.e., no charge replacement to end user if an LED light goes out Too many companies provide questionable project metrics. This finance method provides documented and verified savings, instead of just estimates. With no cash upfront, and no effect to financial statements, plus the benefit of an extended warranty covering both product and labor, the method should be the first thing any business should ask of any EE vendor. P
Mark Kelly is chief executive officer of Kel-Lume Group, which specializes in migrating commercial and industrial buildings to new energy strategies that greatly reduce operational energy costs. Learn more at www.kel-lume.co. Special thanks to Chris Preston, VP, Building Energy, for contributions to this article.
7851 7+( *($56 6$9( 021(<
Largest barriers: capital and financial criteria So even if all sites are benchmarked and all parties wish to move forward, it will come down to the economics of the projects. Discussing financing options early in the sales process typically yields valuable insights on all sides, as to what options are available and how to implement them. Traditionally, there are two main avenues for financing: cash out-of-pocket or a capital lease. Cash is straightforward, provided the customer understands and believes the future savings generated meet common
in any case the lease still sits on the end user’s balance sheet. Increasingly, there is a third option to enable EE projects. EE savings-as-aservice has four aspects:
/HDN\ %XLOGLQJV (QHUJ\ (IÀFLHQF\ 3URMHFWV :H PLJUDWH FRPPHUFLDO LQGXVWULDO QRQ SURÀW FOLHQWV IURP FRVWO\ HQHUJ\ DSSURDFKHV WR DQ XSGDWHG HQHUJ\ VWUDWHJ\ UHGXFLQJ FRVWV 2XU VWDII ZLOO FRQGXFW DQ HQHUJ\ VXUYH\ SURYLGH D IXOO SURSRVDO WR WUDQVIRUP DQ\ IDFLOLW\ /(' %$< /,*+76 /(' )/22' /,*+76 /(' 75$&. /,*+76 /(' 78%(6 /(' 3$1(/ /,*+76 025(
ZZZ .HO /(' FRP
_ ZZZ NHO OXPH &R www.propertiesmag.com 89
CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT Updated info on important projects in the region
Project Report #: 01470 METROHEALTH BRECKSVILLE HEALTH CENTER LOCATION: Rte. 82 & I-77 Brecksville, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Work underway - potential June 2016 completion - September occupancy scheduled EST. VALUE: $32,000,000 OWNER: Cleveland Metro Health Systems Contact: Walter Jones (Written Inquiries Only) 2500 Metro Health Dr., M 123 Cleveland, OH 44109 Phone: 216-778-2705 www.metrohealth.org ARCHITECT OF RECORD: CBLH Design Contact: Marc Bittinger 7850 Freeway Circle, # 101 Cleveland, OH 44130-6317 Phone: 440-243-2000 www.cblhdesign.com DESIGN ARCHITECT: Perspectus Architects 13212 Shaker Square, Ste. B 204
Cleveland, OH 44120 Phone: 216-752-1800 www.perspectusarch.com CM AT RISK: Donley’s Inc. 5430 Warner Rd. Cleveland, OH 44125 Phone: 216-524-6800 www.donleyinc.com DESCRIPTION: 20 acres, 1 bldg, 2 stories, 65,000 sf. Emergency department, ambulatory surgery, retail, pharmacy, imaging, medical offices, infusion, laboratory and public spaces. Project Report #: 01468 WELLS BUILDING RESTORATION LOCATION: 201 W. Federal St. Youngstown, OH (Mahoning County) PROJECT TYPE: Renovation/Addition CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Work completed - leasing in progress EST. VALUE: $5,000,000 ARCHITECT: Strollo Architects Contact: Greg Strollo
S I
&216758&7,21 0$1$*(0(17 *(1(5$/ &2175$&7,1* '(6,*1 %8,/'
90
201 Federal Plaza West, Ste. 604 Youngstown, OH 44503 Phone: 330-743-1177 www.strolloarchitects.com GENERAL CONTRACTOR: Mike Coates Construction Contact: Mike Coates Jr. 800 Summit Ave. Niles, OH 44446 Phone: 330-652-0190 www.mikecoatesconst.com DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 4 stories, 30,000 sf. Extensive renovation/restoration to former 1917 department store into offices and 12 apartments with new mezzanine. All interior and exterior remodeling trades involved - terra cotta, windows, new mechanical and electrical systems seven units left to be leased. Project Report #: 01466 WOOSTER SAFETY CENTER LOCATION: Burbank Rd. & Friendsville Rd. Wooster, OH (Wayne County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STATUS: Working drawing in progress construction schedule from May 2016 to May 2017 EST. VALUE: $7,000,000 OWNER: City of Wooster Contact: Roger Kobilarcsik 538 N. Market St. Wooster, OH 44691 Phone: 330-263-5200 ARCHITECT: Richard L. Bowen + Associates Inc. Contact: Ken Shu 6677 Frank Ave. NW North Canton, OH 44720-7259 Phone: 216-491-9300 www.rlba.com DESIGN/BUILDER: John G. Johnson Construction Co. Contact: Anthony Valencic 1284 Riverbed St. Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-938-5050 www.johngjohnson.com DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 2 stories, 28,000 sf. New police & fire department. Project Report #: 01464 AURORA SCHOOL OF MUSIC ADDITION LOCATION: S. Chillicothe Rd. Aurora, OH (Portage County) www.auroraschoolofmusic.com PROJECT TYPE: Addition CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
PROJECT STATUS: Working underway - completion 1st Quarter 2016 OWNER: Aurora School of Music Contact: Vera Holczer 211 S. Chillicothe Rd. Aurora, OH 44202 Phone: 330-954-0211 DESIGN/BUILDER: GLSD/Geis Companies Contact: Jen Dotson & Brian Jarzenski 10020 Aurora-Hudson Rd. Streetsboro, OH 44241-1621 Phone: 330-528-3500 www.geisco.net DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 4,000 sf. Additional classrooms. Project Report #: 01457 RANDALL INDUSTRIAL PARK REDEVELOPMENT LOCATION: Former Randall Park Mall - Northfield Rd. & I 480 North Randall, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: Renovation/Addition CATEGORY: Industrial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Selective demolition - project proposed - construction indefinite OWNER: IRG Realty Advisors, Inc. Contact: Chris Semarjian 4780 Hinckley Industrial Parkway, Ste. 100 Cleveland, OH 44109 Phone: 330-659-7124 www.irga.com NORTH
Stuart Lichter 8847 Imperial Hwy., Ste. H Downey, CA 90242-3958 Phone: 562-803-4761 ARCHITECT: Bogart Architecture Inc. (Study) Contact: Jeff Bogart (Selective Demolition) 820 W. Superior Ave., Ste. 140 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-696-0700 www.bogartarchitecture.com DESCRIPTION: 100 acres. Redevelopment of former shopping mall into industrial, manufacturing and distribution space. Between 8 to 10 buildings, 700,000 to 1.2 million sf depending on acquisitions and tenant leasing, space redistribution and development. Project Report #: 01436 UNIVERSITY HEIGHTS LIBRARY RENOVATION & ADDITION LOCATION: 13866 Cedar Rd. University Hts., OH (Cuyahoga County) www.heightslibrary.org PROJECT TYPE: Renovation CATEGORY: Institutional PROJECT STATUS: Schematics in progress - with potential 3rd Quarter construction start OWNER: Heights Library System Contact: Nancy Levin 2345 Lee Rd.
Cleveland Hts., OH 44118 Phone: 216-932-3600 x1240 www.heightslibrary.org ARCHITECT: CBLH Design Contact: Marc Bittinger 7850 Freeway Circle, # 101 Cleveland, OH 44130 Phone: 440-243-2000 www.cblhdesign.com DESCRIPTION:1 bldg, 2 stories, 10,000 sf. Renovation to existing library and addition with finished lower level. Project Report #: 01367 LAKEWOOD NEW FAMILY HEALTH CENTER LOCATION: SE Corner Detroit and Belle Avenues Lakewood, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Proposals for design/build teams have been released - team to be selected within 60 days - Partial demolition to begin in early 2016 - Possible 3rd Quarter 2016 construction start EST. VALUE: $34,000,000 OWNER: The Cleveland Clinic 9500 Euclid Ave. Cleveland, OH 44195 Phone: 216-644-0177 www.ccf.org ARCHITECT: Not selected
Space Comfort co. )$0,/< 2:1(' 23(5$7(' :,7+ +$1'6 21 (;3(5,(1&( ,1 0(&+$1,&$/ &2175$&7,1* 6$/(6 6(59,&( 6,1&( ([SHUWV LQ Q 7XUQNH\ VROXWLRQV GHVLJQ EXLOG YDOXH HQJLQHHULQJ Q 6HUYLFH LQVWDOODWLRQ PDLQWHQDQFH RI DOO PDNHV PRGHOV RI +9$& HTXLSPHQW ERLOHUV Q 1HZ UHQRYDWLRQ UHPRGHOLQJ UHVWRUDWLRQ Q 3XEOLF SULYDWH 3URYLGLQJ UHOLDEOH SHUVRQDO VHUYLFH WR RZQHUV RI UHWDLO FHQWHUV PDOOV DSDUWPHQW FRPSOH[HV UHWLUHPHQW KRXVLQJ LQ 2KLR QHLJKERULQJ VWDWHV
5201 CLARK AVENUE, CLEVELAND OHIO 44102 Q PH. 216-281-2000 Q FAX. 216-281-8420 Q 800-203-9645 www.propertiesmag.com 91
BUILDER: Not selected DESCRIPTION: 1.7 acres, 62,100 sf. Includes demolition of existing Lakewood Hospital and construction of a new emergency department and outpatient health center. Project Report #: 01294 STATE UNIVERSITY COLLEGE OF ARCHITECTURE & ENVIRONMENTAL DESIGN (CAED) LOCATION: S. Lincoln & Haymaker Parkway Kent, OH (Portage County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STATUS: Work underway - scheduled for completion early June 2016 EST. VALUE: $40,000,000 OWNER: Kent State University Contact: Joseph Graham 615 Loop Rd., Ste. 101 Kent, OH 44242 Phone: 330-672-3880 DESIGN ARCHITECT: Weiss Manfredi 200 Hudson St., 10th Floor New York, NY 10013 212-760-9002 www.weissmanfredi.com ARCHITECT OF RECORD: Richard L. Bowen and Associates Contact: Alan Renzi 13000 Shaker Blvd. Cleveland, OH 44120 Phone: 216-491-9300 www.rlba.com OWNER’S REPRESENTATIVE: The Ruhlin Company P.O. Box 190 Sharon Center, OH 44274 330-239-2880 CONSTRUCTION MANAGER: Gilbane Building Co. Contact: Jeff Hutchison 950 Main Ave., Ste. 1410 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-491-9300 DESCRIPTION: 1 bldgs, 4 stories, 120,000 sf. Project to include studios - classrooms - administrative and various shop and research spaces - also includes new sidewalks parking and landscaping. KENT
All Things Concrete – Your Commercial & Decorative Total Concrete Solution
An Equal Opportunity Employer
21ST CENTURY CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION INC. 13925 Enterprise Ave. Cleveland, OH 44135
216.362.0900 www.21stcenturyconcrete.com 92
Project Report #: 01341 HARRIS ELEMENTARY SCHOOL LOCATION: 400 W. Market St. Akron, OH (Summit County) PROJECT TYPE: Renovation CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STATUS: Work underway - 3rd Quarter 2016 completion set EST. VALUE: Over $2,000,000 OWNER: Akron Public Schools 70 N. Broadway Akron, OH 44308 Phone: 330-761-1661 ARCHITECT: TC Architects Contact: Robert Chordar 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
755 White Pond Dr. Akron, OH 44320 Phone: 330-867-1093 www.tcarchitects.com BUILDER: JV between Panzica Construction Company and The Ruhlin Company Panzica Construction Company 739 Beta Drive Cleveland, OH 44143 Phone: 440-442-1421 www. panzica.com The Ruhlin Company P.O. Box 190 6931 Ridge Rd. Sharon Center, OH 44274 Phone: 330-239-2800 www.ruhlin.com Project Report #: 01319 CLEVELAND CLINIC HOLIDAY INN SELECT HOTEL LOCATION: Euclid Ave. & E. 86th St. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Work underway - completion set for 2nd Quarter 2016 EST. VALUE: $40,000,000 OWNER: M.B. Real Estate Contact: John T. Murphy 181 W. Madison Ave. Chicago, IL 60602
Phone: 312-558-3882 OWNER’S REPRESENTATIVE: The Krill Company 1275 Main Ave. Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-357-4777 ARCHITECT: Kaczmar Architects Inc. Contact: Stan Kaczmar 1468 W. 9th St., Ste. 400 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-687-1555 www.kaczarch.com CONSTRUCTION MANAGER: The Walsh Group Contact: Patrick Kenny 929 W. Adams St. Chicago, IL 60607 Phone: 312-563-5400 DESCRIPTION: 1.8 acres, 1 bldg, 9 stories, 165,370 sf. 276-room hotel - valet parking area off of Euclid Ave. Project Report #: 01353 METRO HEALTH SYSTEMS CRITICAL CARE CENTER VERTICAL ADDITION LOCATION: Metro Health Center Dr. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: Addition CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STATUS: Under construction with July 2016 completion scheduled EST. VALUE: $80,000,000-$82,000,000 OWNER: Cleveland Metro Health Systems
Contact: Walter Jones & Rick Mayer 2500 Metro Health Dr. Cleveland, OH 44109 Phone: (216) 778-2705 ARCHITECT OF RECORD: CBLH Design Inc. 7850 Freeway Circle, #101 Cleveland, OH 44130-6317 Phone: 440-243-2000 www.cblhdesign.com DESIGN ARCHITECT: CannonDesign 225 N. Michigan Ave., #1100 Chicago, IL 60601 Phone: 312-332-9600 www.cannondesign.com CONSTRUCTION MANAGER: Gilbane Company 950 Main Ave., Ste. 1410 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-535-3000 www.gilbaneco.com DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 2 stories, 100,000 sf. Twostory addition to include 88 beds and a landing pad for Metro Health’s life flight. Information included in Construction Progress Report has been produced, processed and/or verified through sources believed to be reliable. Properties Magazine makes no warranty of any kind for this information, express or implied, and is not responsible for any omissions or inaccuracies. To contribute project data or to notify Properties of any reporting errors, we encourage you to email cpr@propertiesmag.com.
www.propertiesmag.com 93
&RPLQJ LQ )HEUXDU\ .HQW 6WDWH 8QLYHUVLW\ ,QVWLWXWLRQDO $GYDQFHPHQW %XLOGLQJ 6ZDJHORN &OHYHODQG $EERWW 9DOYH 7KH 9LOODV RI )R[ +ROORZ /DQGVFDSLQJ 2XWGRRU /LJKWLQJ DQG PRUH ,QWHUHVWHG LQ DGYHUWLVLQJ" &DOO 3URSHUWLHV WRGD\ DQG DQ DFFRXQW UHSUHVHQWDWLYH FDQ KHOS \RX ZZZ SURSHUWLHVPDJ FRP 9LVLW XV RQOLQH IRU DUFKLYHG IHD DGGUHVV \RXU DGYHUWLVLQJ QHHGV
WXUH DUWLFOHV DGYHUWLVLQJ UDWHV VSHFV DQG VXEVFULSWLRQ LQIRUPD WLRQ
ZZZ SURSHUWLHVPDJ FRP
9LVLW XV RQOLQH WRGD\ WR GRZQORDG DUFKLYHG LVVXHV IHDWXULQJ OLYH K\SHUWH[W OLQNV WR DGYHUWLVHUV· ZHEVLWHV 94
ADVERTISER INDEX 21st Century Concrete Construction, Inc. ...92 Abraxus Snow Removal ......................................... 7 AIA Cleveland ............................................................33 American International Construction ...........71 Behnke & Associates ..............................................29 BOMA Greater Cleveland ....................................93 Bradley Stone Industries, Ltd............................... 2 Brennan & Associates ............................................81 Brian-Kyles Construction, Inc. ...........................46 Bricklayers Local 5 ...................................................48 Bruder Building Materials, Inc. ..........................15 Buckeye Sweeping, Inc........................................... 9 Buckingham Doolittle & Burroughs ..............63 Building Enclosure Council.................................84 Carey Roofing............................................................53 Carrol Glass & Maintenance ...............................36 CBRE, Inc.......................................................................69 Chagrin Valley Steel Erectors.............................76 Charles Schulz Building Company.................... 7 Charles Svec Inc........................................................46 Choice Cabinets .......................................................41 Ciuni & Panichi Advisors LLC .............................13 Cleveland Cement Contractors, Inc. ...... 42, 64 Cleveland Engineering Society ........................77 Cleveland Public Power........................................34 Columbia Building Products .............................81 Communications Exhibits Inc. .........................62 County Fire Protection Inc..................................72 Courtad Construction Systems. Inc. ..............63 Crystal Clear Building Services, Inc.................30 Cunningham Paving Inc. .....................................73 Dimit Architects LLC ..............................................22 DS Architecture ........................................................19 Duffy & Duffy Cost Segregation Services...15 EA Group........................................................................ 3 EM Construction Co./Beacon Marshall Companies .............................................................49 EPI of Cleveland ........................................................33 Euclid Glass & Door Inc. ........................................75 First Federal Of Lakewood..................................67 ForeverLawn ..............................................................39 Frantz Ward LLP .......................................................82 Gateway Electric, Inc..............................................35 Geauga Mechanical, Co. ......................................24 GPD Group..................................................................26 GRL Engineers ...........................................................42 Grout Systems, Inc. .................................................35 Guinto Schirack, Inc................................................30 Health & Fitness Equipment Centers ............10 HMH Restoration Ltd. ............................................78 Howard Hanna..........................................................85 Hummel Construction ..........................................16 Icon Interiors .............................................................. 11 IMAGINiT Technologies.......................................... 6
Infinity Construction..............................................90 Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. ...................................44 J Norman Stark, LPA ...............................................72 J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc. ...................................15 Jamieson Ricca Fenestration .............................18 John G. Johnson Construction Co. ................... 9 Kalreuth Roofing & Sheet Metal, Inc. ...........42 Kel-Lume Group.......................................................89 Kurtz Bros. ...................................................................15 Lean Projects Group ..............................................54 Leff Electric .................................................................92 Lisco Heating & Cooling, Inc. .............................49 M-A Building & Maintenance Co. ....................60 Maguire Photographics .......................................20 Mason Structural Steel, Inc. ................................25 Meaden & Moore, Ltd ...........................................75 Messina Floor Covering, Inc. ..............................58 Nelson Contracting ................................................83 Northcoast Inc. Recycling Specialists............79 Northern Ohio Plumbing, Co. ...........................31 OCP Contractors ......................................................38 Olsavsky Jaminet Architects, Inc. ....................45 Paladin Protective Systems, Inc........................28 Panzica Construction, Co. .................................22 Pease Photography ................................................95 Peller & Associates, Inc..........................................58 Performance Painting ...........................................32 Pete & Pete Container Service ..........................74 Portage Community Bank ..................................20 Precision Environmental Co...............................85 R E Warner & Associates.......................................28 Regency Construction ..........................................56 Reserve Millwork, Inc.............................................63 S.A. Comunale Company ............................26, 60 Sandglo Glass & Mirror Co. .................................46 Schill Grounds Management ............................55 ServiceMaster Cleaning & Restoration Services ....................................................................52 Siegel Jennings ........................................................51 Signature Sign Company ....................................38 Skoda Minotti Company......................................70 Sleggs Danzinger & Gill .......................................... 4 SMPS Northeast Ohio.............................................. 9 Snow Brothers Appliance, Inc. ..........................43 Space Comfort Co. ..................................................91 SRI Roofing & Sheet Metal..................................55 Studio Techne Architects ....................................60 Suntrol Co....................................................................68 Thomas Brick Company, The .............................96 Thorson Baker & Associates, Inc. .....................26 Valentine Contractors, Inc...................................38 Walter & Haverfield LLP........................................87 Warren Roofing & Insulating Co. ..............33, 59 Window Cleaning Specialists ............................87 3URSHUWLHV | January 2016
7KRPDV %ULFN LV SURXG WR EH WKH VXSSOLHU RI *OHQ *HU\ %ULFN IRU )ODWV (DVW %DQN
7+(
7+20$6 %5,&.
&203$1<
% 5 ,& . Y 6721( Y 7 , / (
%HDFKZRRG Y :HVWODNH Y ZZZ WKRPDVEULFN FRP