Skip to main content

Northeast Ohio Properties, January 2014

Page 1

,16,'( (QYLUR6FLHQFH +4 3DUPD 6QRZ /LEUDU\ )LQDQFLDO 5HYLHZ )RUHFDVW

January 2014/$7.95

6WLULK MVY )\ZPULZZ

9LUV]H[PVU [YHUZMVYTZ MVYTLY OLHS[O JLU[LY PU[V ZWHJPV\Z UL^ ,X\P[` ;Y\Z[ OLHKX\HY[LYZ


Build Your Competitive Edge CEA Professional Development Day February 13, 2014 • When to Write/Reply to a Proposal, Estimate or Quote • Employment & HR Principles and Best Practices • Employee Skill Development - How to Get, Develop & Keep the Best

AGC of America Project Management Development (Certification) Program February 20, 2014 – June 13, 2014 Module 1 | Estimating and Job Costing – February 20-21, 2014 Module 2 | Risk Management – March 20-21, 2014 Module 3 | Leadership – April 3-4, 2014 Module 4 | Contract Administration – May 1-2, 2014 Module 5 | Project Administration – June 12-13, 2014

AGC of America - Supervisory Training Program CONSTRUCTION SUPERVISOR OVERVIEW February - March 2014 Course is activity-based, with case histories, problems and exercises. It will develop attributes of a construction supervisor/foreman/superintendent in planning, scheduling and productivity.

AGC of America’s Lean Construction Education Program May 8-9, 2014 Learn key concepts used in Lean Construction. • • • •

Variation in Production Systems Pull In Production Lean Workstructuring Production Management

Join us | Register | Engage

www.ceacisp.org | 216.398.9860 CEA IS AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER


Ignoring your environmental issues won’t make them go away.

EA Group has provided environmental consulting and laboratory services to a wide range of clients for over 25 years. We’ve helped

BREATHE EASIER

hundreds of companies solve their most challenging environmental issues from assessments and analysis to project management and remediation. Stop hiding from the problem and put our team to work early to avoid environmental emergencies that can result in costly and unexpected delays. Our expert technicians are experienced in: • Asbestos and Hazardous Materials Management • Site Assessment and Remediation • Indoor Air Quality Assessment • Industrial Hygiene and Safety • Mold Remediation Management • Analytical Laboratory Support

800.875.3514 • 440.951.3514 • www.eagroupohio.com 7118 Industrial Park Boulevard • Mentor, OH 44060


,JV :HS[

2XU 6$)(67 GH LFLQJ DJHQW HQVXUHV \RXU EXVLQHVV LV DFFLGHQW IUHH

6$)(7< ),567 :HS[& Advantages of Eco 2 Salt >OH[ PZ ,JV

÷ :HMLY [OHU YLN\SHY ZHS[ ÷ >VYRZ [V á÷ :RUNV IDVWHU WKDQ UHJXODU VDOW ÷ (QYLURQPHQWDOO\ IULHQGO\ ÷ /HVV FRUURVLYH WR ò 3DUNLQJ ORWV ò 8QGHUJURXQG ZLULQJ ò 0HWDO GRRUV ò ,QWHULRU IORRULQJ

AR E F NO RRIES O NO W

(FR 6DOW LV D VWDWH RI WKH DUW LFH PDQDJH PHQW V\VWHP WKDW SUHWUHDWV URFN VDOW ZLWK PDJQHVLXP FKORULGH DQG VDOW EULQH 7KLV PHWKRG KDV EHHQ XVHG E\ 2'27 IRU \HDUV 5HOLDEOH LV RQH RI WKH SLRQHHUV EULQJLQJ WKLV PHWKRG WHFKQRORJ\ WR WKH FRPPHUFLDO VHFWRU

>L J\YYLU[S` OH]L HSS [OL ZHS[ ULLKLK MVY [OL ZUV^ ZLHZVU :;6*2 703,+ /V^ 0Z ,JV :HS[

Rock Salt

Eco2 Salt

(FR 6DOW SURYLGHV RSWLPDO VDIHW\ ZLWK OHVV GDPDJH WR \RXU SURSHUW\

,U]PYVUTLU[HSS` -YPLUKS`&

7KH V\VWHP UHGXFHV RYHUVSUD\ RI VDOW GXVW JRLQJ LQWR WKH ODQGVFDSH DUHDV DQG JUDVV\ DUHDV ,W DOVR JUHDWO\ UHGXFHV VDOW ERXQFH NHHSLQJ WKH LFH PHOW RQ WKH SDYHPHQW 7RJHWKHU WKH V\QHUJ\ RI WKHVH SURSHUWLHV UHGXFHV WKH DPRXQW RI FKORULGHV UHOHDVHG LQWR WKH HQYLURQPHQW

$VN \RXU 5HOLDEOH 5HSUHVHQWDWLYH IRU D 6DOW V\VWHP ZKLWH ZKLWH SDSHU VWXG\ RQ WKH (FR

9,30()3, :56> 736>05. :7,*0(30:;: 1-877-WE PLOW 1 ZZZ UHOLDEOHVQRZSORZLQJ QHW 9,30() (&2 6$/7 ,6 7+( %(67 ,&( &21752/ 6<67(0 ,1 7+( ,1'8675<


January 2014, Volume LXVIII, Number 1

phone: 216.251.0035 toll free: 888.641.4241 fax: 216.251.0064 www.propertiesmag.com

FEATURES

CLEVELAND 3826 W. 158th St. Cleveland, Ohio 44111

Photo by Eric Hanson

AKRON P.O. Box 9 Munroe Falls, Ohio 44262 OWNER/PUBLISHER Kenneth C. Krych kkrych@propertiesmag.com MANAGING EDITOR/ART DIRECTOR Mark Watt mwatt@propertiesmag.com CONTRIBUTING WRITERS Doug Bardwell, Jeanne Bluffstone, Dennis Castiglione, John Elliott, Lou Kren, Alec Pacella, Molly Reeves, John Slagter, David Woodburn

10

Top Shops of 2013 ABC’s Northern Ohio Chapter honors leading merit shops’ work at annual awards

13 Architectural Achievements 2013 AIA Cleveland + ASID Ohio North Design Awards recognize top projects

17

2013/2014 Financial Review & Forecast: Crunching the numbers on Northeast Ohio’s real estate & construction markets 18 Look Back, Look Forward: CBRE delivers overview of Northeast Ohio commercial real estate 2013/2014 25 Hot Topics: Survey of Northeast Ohio construction industry reveals outlook for 2014 27 BOMA Business: IRS’s ‘Tangible Property’ Regulations... & Why You Should Be Nervous 28 National Construction Outlook 2014: McGraw Hill Construction observes ongoing expansion within construction industry 31 Improving Outlook: Progress in 2013 promises bright 2014 for commercial real estate in Cleveland 33 Surety Bonds – The Role of Surety Credit on Construction Projects 35 HBA Presents Annual Economic Housing Forecast 36 Financial Strategies: Are We There Yet? 38 Legal Perspectives: Expanding Role of State Court Receivers in the Rebirth of Distressed Commercial Properties 40 Vantage Point: Reviewing Real Estate Tax Assessments 42 ACAR Corner: Outlining NAR’s Commercial Real Estate Forecast 44 NAIOP News: NAIOP’s 2013 Year in Review + Looking Forward in ‘14

ACCOUNT EXECUTIVES Larry Overbey loverbey@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6649 Katy Wellington kwellington@propertiesmag.com 216.251.2520 OFFICE MANAGER Lisa Larissey 216.251.8506 Cover photo: Equity Trust Headquarters, by Jim Maguire

52

Opened for Business Renovation transforms former health center into spacious new Equity Trust headquarters

62

Natural Fit Adaptive reuse project creates new EnviroScience headquarters in Stow

Properties (ISSN 033-1287) is published monthly for architects, engineers, building owners and managers, general contractors, home builders, mortgage bankers, savings and loans, real estate agents, appraisers, servicers and suppliers in Northern Ohio by Properties, Inc., 3826 W. 158th St., Cleveland, Ohio 44111. Copyright © 2014 by Properties, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction or use, without written permission, of editorial or pictorial content is strictly prohibited. Periodicals postage paid in Cleveland, Ohio and additional offices. Subscription rates: one year $24.95, single copy $7.95, back issues $10 when available. Postmaster: send change of address notices to Properties, P.O. Box 112127, Cleveland, Ohio 44111.

68 Going with the Flow Sloping site drives design for CCPL’s Parma-Snow Library addition & renovation

DEPARTMENTS

8 PROPERTIES PEOPLE 46 BILLBOARD 74 CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT www.propertiesmag.com 5


PUBLISHER’S NOTE January 2014

Planning for Prosperity appy 2014 to everyone! This is the time of year for resolutions and a big one for most people is financial. Save more, spend less. Catch up on bills, etc. It is also a time to plan for wise investments and develop your strategy and tactics in making 2014 a most profitable year.

H

For what it’s worth, 2014 is the “Year of the Green Wooden Horse” and according to Chinese astrology, that can suggest a year of good fortune. We will see! KEN KRYCH Look back, look forward…. Every January, we publish a Financial Review/Forecast section in which experts weigh in on industry trends and issues of the past 12 months and those coming in the new year, with a particular focus on financial affairs. That tradition continues this month as a great team of contributors lends expert data analyses

\ 174 75 61/ 4%*+6'%674#. '6#. 2'%+#.+565[

and opinions, providing us with a lot of information to consume and consider. We thank David Browning and his team at CBRE; McGraw-Hill Construction; Skoda Minotti; Properties contributor Alex Pacella, of NAI Daus; the North Coast Home Builders Association (HBA); Walter & Haverfield; Buckley King LPA; CNA Surety Insurance; and Sleggs Danzinger Co., LPA. Equity Trust Headquarters With this month’s financial focus, it is fitting that Equity Trust’s new headquar-

1746#& 0%T *VTTLYJPHS 0UK\Z[YPHS 0UZ[P[\[PVUHS 9L[HPS :WLJPHSPaPUN PU LUNPULLYPUN MHIYPJH[PVU PUZ[HSSH[PVU VM! TL[HS YVVMPUN YVSSLK VU ZP[L MSHZOPUN [YPT J\Z[VT MHZJPHZ MYPLaL IVHYKZ LH]LZ JVWWLY Z[HPUSLZZ Z[LLS Z`Z[LTZ JVTWVZP[L TL[HS ^HSS Z`Z[LTZ J\Z[VT N\[[LYZ KV^UZWV\[Z JVTTLYJPHS N\[[LYZ YVSSLK VU ZP[L

GGNTFKHTGENN T T 1: LFKX #067#X HHFII 999T%1746#&+0%T%1/

6

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


ters in Westlake graces our cover. Equity Trust has been an expert in managing retirement portfolios and more, and has enjoyed explosive growth with a $12 billion portfolio since starting out in 1974. The company’s new home – a renovated former healthcare center off of Crocker Road – is quite striking with its use of glass and metal and was completed in an amazingly short amount of time.

'2(6 $ /,*+7,1* 5(752),7 0$.( 6(16( )25 <285 3523(57<"

EnviroScience Headquarters Another adaptive reuse project highlighted this month is the new EnviroScience headquarters in Stow. The environmental company has relocated to a former city services facility that’s been creatively renovated with new office and lab space.

6ROYLQJ \RXU /,*+7,1* (/(&75,&$/ QHHGV 72'$< IRU D EHWWHU 52, WRPRUURZ &/(9(/$1' _ $.521

:H FDQ SURYLGH UHDO LQSXW LQYHVWPHQW VWUDWHJLHV WR KHOS \RX GHFLGH

2+ /LF (/

9LVLW XV RQOLQH DW ZZZ DFHOHFWULFRKLR FRP RU FDOO IRU D )5(( HVWLPDWH

Parma-Snow Library We also revisit Cuyahoga County Public Library’s ongoing master plan and its latest completed project: the renovation/addition of its Parma-Snow branch. This facility is unique in that it is now physically connected to CCPL’s main administration office building, which sits up and above where the old library stood. In addition to the new connecting corridor and overall renovation of library space, the project introduces a black box theater for public and private use.

Sustainable practices. Superior results. Only from Schill.

Coming in February Next month will be our Landscaping issue as we look forward to warmer times and temperatures. We will also be covering the new Hard Rock Rocksino Northfield Park, a project 15 years in the making that creates a tremendous entertainment and dining venue right between the Cleveland and Akron areas. As always, we are looking to you for suggestions on what you consider to be the best projects to cover, significant anniversaries to highlight and companies and key people in our industry to profile, so contact us at 216-251-0035 or email me at kkrych@propertiesmag.com with your ideas and feedback. Let’s make this our best year yet!

Kenneth C. Krych Owner/Publisher

Now, we’re pioneering the use of sustainable business practices and products.

©Schill Grounds Management

Positively,

Schill Grounds Management has been a trusted provider of commercial landscaping and snow removal services to premier properties in Northern Ohio for 20 years.

From propane-powered equipment to bio-nutritional fertilizers to reduced pesticide use, Schill delivers earth-friendly solutions that protect the planet and your property – without costing more. Find out how Schill can help you create healthy, green spaces for living, working, or shopping. Call us today.

5000 Mills Industrial Parkway • North Ridgeville, OH 44039 • (440) 327-3030 • schillgroundsmanagement.com

www.propertiesmag.com 7


PROPERTIES PEOPLE Highlighting notable industry events

1

2

3

5

6

1

4

2

8

7

AIA Cleveland & ASID Ohio North Chapter Awards 3 1 Terry Schwarz (Kent State University), Evan Klotzman (Alpha Park, Inc.) and Mark Panzica (Panzica Construction) 2 Werner Minshall (Minshall Development Management/Minshall Stewart Properties) 3 Tim Panzica (IQ Advisors), Amy Whitacre (First American Title Insurance), Alex Russo (Cresco Real Estate), Mark Panzica (Panzica Construction) and Tom West (Cresco Real Estate)

NAIOP Holiday Meeting Recently, NAIOP’s Northern Ohio Chapter held its annual holiday event at the Tower at Erieview in Cleveland where there was an official announcement of 2014 officers, a cocktail reception and complimentary gifts. This year, officers include President Mark Panzica (Panzica Construction), President-Elect Alex Russo (Cresco Real Estate), Past President Amy Whitacre (First American Title Insurance National Commercial Services), Treasurer Gabe Adler (Zinner & Company) and Secretary Jeff Wherry (Wherry Associates). P 8

The recent AIA Cleveland & ASID Ohio North Chapter Awards drew one of its largest gatherings ever with 374 members attending. Held at the Global Center for Health Innovation in Cleveland, the event started with cocktails and light hors d’oeuvres in the Atrium, then moved to the ballroom for dinner and the awards presentation. Andrea Steele of TEN Arquitectos was the keynote speaker. (See complete story, pg. 13.) P

1

Properties Holiday Party Properties recently held its annual holiday party for its team of editors, advertising consultants and freelance writers at the 100th Bomber Squadron in Berea. P

9

1 Mehmet Turkel (Technical Assurance Inc.), Bill Eberhard (Eberhard Architects, LLC) and Jeff Gliebe (The Krill Company) 2 Ken and Jing Krych (Properties) 3 Doug Steidl (Braun & Steidl Architects, Inc.), Mike and Linda Thorson (Thorson Baker & Associates, Inc.) 4 Sue Steidl (Braun & Steidl Architects, Inc.) and Amanda Romeo (Herschman Architects, Inc.) 5 Hank and Peggy Reder (Henry Reder Attorney at Law) and Dan Kennedy (R. W. Sidley Precast) 6 Michaila Crislip, Mary Stiger, Evan Andersy and Arushi Patel (Kent State University) 8 Ron M. Czaplicki (Barber & Hoffman Associates) and Julie Murphy (Progressive Insurance) 11 David and Wendy Robar (Vocon) 12 Darlene Kirchner, Eric Pempus, Kathie Krozser and Vanetee Bayne (Oswald Companies)

2

3

1 Lou Kren (Falls Communication), Lisa Larissey and Katrina Wellington (Properties) 2 Larry Overbey and Molly Reeves (Properties) 3 Mark Watt (Properties) and Doug Bardwell (Properties/Travel Photo US)

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


1

2

3

Jason Chio (Icon Building & Maintenance, LLC), Thomas M. Rice and Michael S. Kovatch (North Bay Construction, Inc.), and Rick Lorenzen (Associated Building Contractors, ABC)

4

5

HBA of Greater Cleveland Installation & Awards Banquet The Home Builders Association (HBA) of Greater Cleveland recently held its annual Installation and Awards Banquet at the Terrace Club in downtown Cleveland. The event raised more than $7,500 for the George J. Goudreau Scholarship Fund, primarily by the efforts of incoming 2014 HBA President Rick Colwell, owner of Little Mountain Homes. Inc. Almost 200 people attended the event as Colwell took the oath of office and gave a speech about the P importance and value of HBA.

1 Rick Colwell (Little Mountain Homes, Inc.) 2 Roger, Ross and Ryan Puzztiello (Parkview Homes) 3 Marie Marali (First Federal of Lakewood) and Barry Ezell (Westfield Bank) 4 Mike Ellis (R. Kashmiry & Associates), Ted and Kelly Otero (Otero Signature Homes), Helen and Alan Brucato (Home Savings) 5 Ken Krych (Properties) and Slider

ABC 2013 Excellence In Construction & Safety Awards Recently, 75 members of Associated Building Contractors (ABC) Northern Ohio Chapter gathered for the annual Awards of Excellence to showcase the best of merit shop work throughout the region. The event was held at the 700 BETA Banquet & Conference Center in Mayfield Village and also included presentation of numerous “Safety Awards” for qualified firms. (See complete story, pg. 10.) P

Space Comfort co. )$0,/< 2:1(' 23(5$7(' :,7+ +$1'6 21 (;3(5,(1&( ,1 0(&+$1,&$/ &2175$&7,1* 6$/(6 6(59,&( 6,1&( ([SHUWV LQ Q 7XUQNH\ VROXWLRQV GHVLJQ EXLOG YDOXH HQJLQHHULQJ Q 6HUYLFH LQVWDOODWLRQ PDLQWHQDQFH RI DOO PDNHV PRGHOV RI +9$& HTXLSPHQW ERLOHUV Q 1HZ UHQRYDWLRQ UHPRGHOLQJ UHVWRUDWLRQ Q 3XEOLF SULYDWH 3URYLGLQJ UHOLDEOH SHUVRQDO VHUYLFH WR RZQHUV RI UHWDLO FHQWHUV PDOOV DSDUWPHQW FRPSOH[HV UHWLUHPHQW KRXVLQJ LQ 2KLR QHLJKERULQJ VWDWHV

5201 CLARK AVENUE, CLEVELAND OHIO 44102 Q PH. 216-281-2000 Q FAX. 216-281-8420 Q 800-203-9645 www.propertiesmag.com 9


Top Shops of 2013 ABC’s Northern Ohio Chapter honors leading merit shops’ work at annual awards ecently, members of the Associated Builders and Contractors, Inc. (ABC) Northern Ohio Chapter gathered at 700 BETA Banquet & Conference Center in Mayfield Village to honor top regional projects completed in 2013. The Annual ABC Excellence in Construction and Safety Awards Celebration recognizes outstanding quality and innovations in merit shop construction. The Chairman’s Cup award – ABC’s top honor – was presented to Kwest Group LLC for the Holes Creek Restoration Project for Miami Conservancy District (Dayton, Ohio) and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) Louisville District. Independent judges, representing a cross-section of construction industry experts, found the restoration as the best project of 2013. Receiving a “Greener Tomorrow Award” was Hummel Construction Company for its LEED Silver-targeted work at Kent State University’s Heer Hall. ABC also recognized five member companies with Diamond Safety Awards, which recognize workplace safety. These included sub-contractors/ specialty contractors Bay Mechanical & Electrical Corp.; Kwest Group, LLC; and Preferred LLC, as well as general contractors Clouse Construction Corp. and North Bay Construction, Inc. Merit Awards and Excellence Awards to top merit shops included:

MERIT AWARD WINNERS Hummel Construction Company General Contracting / Construction Management

10

Photos courtesy of ABC Northern Ohio

R

RAISING RECOGNITION Cleveland Construction’s work at The Residences at Hanna was recognized with an Award of Excellence at ABC’s annual awards program.

Commercial: Less than $5 million Project: Huntington National Bank Owner: Huntington National Bank Architect/Engineer: Professional Design Group

Project: Classic Ford / Lincoln Auto Dealership Owner: Classic Auto Group Architect: Anthony Paskevich & Associates

Cleveland Construction, Inc.

General Contracting / Construction Management Commercial: $5 to $10 Million Project: Pat O’Brien Chevrolet

Star Inc. General Contracting / Construction Management Commercial: $5 - $10 million

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


Owner: Pat O’Brien Chevrolet Architect: Star Architectural Group Engineer: Bramhall Engineering

Awards Of Excellence B and J Electric of Poland, Inc.

reliable & local

Specialty Contracting - Electrical Commercial: Less than $2 million Project: Youngstown State University - Fifth Avenue Athletic Fields Owner: Youngstown State University Architect: GPD Group Engineer: GPD Group

Miami Conservancy District’s Holes Creek Restoration Project (Kwest Group LLC)

Kwest Group LLC General Contracting / Construction Management Other Specialty Construction: Under $10 million Project: Holes Creek Restoration Project Owner: Miami Conservancy District & the USACE Architect: N/A Engineer: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) Louisville District

Clouse Construction Corp. General Contracting / Construction Management Commercial: Under $5 million Project: Lincoln Way Animal Hospital Owner: Todd Price Architect: R.D. Neff & Associates

Cleveland Construction, Inc. General Contracting / Construction Management Historical Restoration / Renovation - Under $25 Million Project: The Residences at Hanna Owner: K & D Group Architect: Berardi + Partners, Inc. Engineer: Donald G. Bohning & Assoc. Inc.

Clouse Construction Corp. General Contracting / Construction Management Commercial: Under $5 Million Project: Sunrise Co-Op Fertilizer Building

CALL OUR COMMERCIAL SALES MANAGERS TODAY, TO DISCUSS YOUR ELECTRIC SERVICE NEEDS

Wes Tarver: 216.664.3922 ext.145 Kim Smith: 216.664.3922 ext. 253 VISIT US AT WWW.CPP.ORG

ABC National Safety Award Winner 2010, 2011, 2012 Sectors Serviced • Energy • Environmental • Federal Facilities • Transportation

• Airport Infrastructure • Rail/Intermodel • Manufacturing

Services Provided • Earthwork • Road/Runway Construction • Underground Utilities • Structural Concrete • Erosion Control/SWPPP

• Remediation • Mitigation • Marine Services/Piling • Value Engineering • Complete Site Development Services

Regional Office

Main Office

Regional Office

5650 Blazer Parkway, Ste. 152 Dublin, OH 43017 Phone: 614.734.4664 Fax: 614.734.1734

8305 Fremont Pike Perrysburg, OH 43551 Phone: 419.874.4284 Fax: 419-874-4306

20 Noble Ct., Suite 145 Heath, TX 75032 Phone: 972.722.3874 Fax: 972.722.3875

www.kwestgroup.com An SBA Firm

www.propertiesmag.com 11


Owner: Sunrise Co-Op Architect: Technical Design Group, Inc.

Hummel Construction Company General Contracting / Construction Management Institutional: Under $5 million Project: KSU Heer Hall Owner: Kent State University Architect: The Collaborative Architecture

Architect: CT Taylor General Contractor Engineer: CT Taylor General Contractor

Kwest Group LLC General Contracting / Construction Management Federal Government/Military: Under $10 million Project: Spofford Runway Reconstruction Owner: Laughlin Air Force Base Architect: N/A Engineer: URS Group, Inc.

Project: American Electric Power Vassell Substation Earthwork/Sit Development Owner: American Electric Power Architect: N/A Engineer: EMH&T

Clouse Construction Corp. General Contracting / Construction Management PreEngineered Building Project: Seneca County Agency Transportation Owner: Seneca County Commissioners/Seneca County Agency Architect: TFC Architects and Engineers

Northbay Construction

JSJ Interiors

General Contracting / Construction Management Other Construction: $2 to $100 Million Project: Biosolids Reduction Project Owner: Portage County Architect: URS Corporation Engineer: URS Corporation

Specialty Contracting Interiors: Acoustical, Drywall, Millwork or Plaster Project: Vitamix Headquarters Owner: Vitamix Headquarters

General Contracting / Construction Management Industrial: Under $5 million

Vitamix Headquarters (JSJ Interiors)

Kwest Group LLC

Opportunities are waiting

Lorain County Metro Parks Mercy Health & Recreation Center (Star Inc.)

Star Inc. General Contracting / Construction Management Other Construction: $2 to $100 Million Project: Lorain County Metro Parks Mercy Health & Recreation Center Owner: Lorain County Metro Parks/Mercy Regional Medical Center Architect: Star Architecutral Group Engineer: LJB, Inc. P

• Landscape maintenance contracts – extraordinary seasonal color plans • Landscape planting, design and installation • Irrigation installation & repair • Daily/weekly routine property inspection & maintenance

6LWH :RUN /DQGVFDSLQJ 3URSHUW\ 0DLQWHQDQFH 440-526-3257 • 330-239-1995 Fax 330-239-0265 4843 Ridge Road Wadsworth, Ohio 44281 12

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


Architectural Achievements 2013 AIA Cleveland + ASID Ohio North Design Awards recognize top projects he Cleveland Chapter of the American Institute of Architects (AIA Cleveland) and the Ohio North Chapter of the American Society of Interior Designers (ASID) recently celebrated exemplary designs of Northeast Ohio firms at the bi-annual joint AIA/ASID Cleveland Design Awards. Held within the Grand Atrium and adjacent Junior Ballroom of the Global Center for Health Innovation, the event drew the largest attendance in a decade with nearly 400 association members and guests.

T

Photos courtesy of AIA Cleveland + ASID Ohio North

TEN Arquitectos Founder/ Principal Enrique Norten and Managing Partner Andrea Steele served as jury co-chairs for the awards. Additional jury members included Paul Lewis (LTL Architects), Mimi Hoang (nArchitects) and Galia Solomonoff (Solomonoff Architecture Studio). Steele, of TEN Arquitectos, also served as keynote speaker for the event. Honored with awards for outstanding design achievements were:

Interior Design Student Awards HONORABLE MENTION

Outlook Inc. Workplace Design (Los Angeles, CA – Unbuilt) Student: Tiffany Contic Professor: Ji Young Cho (Kent State University)

Architecture Student Awards HONORABLE MENTION

Atlantic Yards Pre-Fab Housing (Brooklyn, NY – Unbuilt) Student: Ulyana Shtyrkalo Professor: Thomas A. Stauffer (Kent State University)

HONORABLE MENTION

Cut in the Strip District

PRIZED PERFORMANCE The renovation of Bibbins Hall at Oberlin College Conservatory of Music earned Westlake Reed Leskosky an AIA Design Honor Award.

(Pittsburgh, PA – Unbuilt) Student: William Cody Professor: Gregory Stroh (Kent State University)

MERIT AWARD

linC Living Infrastructure Network (Cleveland, OH – Unbuilt) Students: Neil Reindel & Claire Markwardt Professor: Charles Graves (Kent State University)

HONOR AWARD

Atlantic Yards: MHP (Brooklyn, NY – Unbuilt) Student: Kyle Davis Professor: Thomas Stauffer (Kent State University)

HONOR AWARD

[De] Isolate: Revival of Duquesne Heights and the South Shore

Northeast Ohio’s Leading Fitness Equipment Supplier Since 1979

www.healthandfitnessohio.com Co ommercial & Residential Equipment • Facility Planning Design Delivery & Installation • Service & Preventative Maintenance

Co ommercial Division: 440.946.0839 x 4 Fairlawn/Akron n North Canton 330.836.6640 330.492.7773

Mayfield Hts. 440.461.4900

Eastlake North Olmsted Woodmere 440.946.0839 440.734.4888 216.593.0233

www.propertiesmag.com 13


2013 AIA-ASID CLEVELAND DESIGN AWARDS Congratulations to all winners & nominees The Global Center for Health Innovation

Cleveland Clinic Fairview Hospital

Aloft Hotel

Hard Rock Rocksino Northfield Park

E&Y Tower

:H ZRUN WRJHWKHU WR EXLOG H[FHOOHQFH Metal Framing/Drywall Q Exterior Finishing Q Acoustical Painting Q Preconstruction Q Specialties Q Millwork AIA Cleveland 1001 Huron Road Suite 101 Cleveland, Ohio 44115 (216) 575-1224/FAX (216) 575-1244 ©1990, AIA

ZZZ RFS FRQWUDFWRUV FRP W W

:KDW GRHV %,0 PHDQ WR \RX" %,0 FDQ EH PDQ\ WKLQJV²JUHHQ LQWHJUDWHG D SURFHVV D WHFKQRORJ\ D WHFKQRORJ\ %XW DOO \RX FDUH DERXW LV \RXU %,0 \RXU WHDP DQG \RXU FOLHQWV FOLHQWV $OO ZH FDUH DERXW LV PDNLQJ %,0 ZRUN IRU \RX 5HYLW 1DYLVZRUNV DQG )DFLOLWLHV 0DQDJHPHQW H[SHUWV WV ,PSOHPHQWDWLRQ WUDLQLQJ WHFKQLFDO VXSSRUW²LQ SHUVRQ RU RQOLQH RQ RU RQOLQH WR %,0 DQG ,0$*,1L7 &ODULW\ IRU $XWRGHVN 5HYLW 6HUYHU 6FDQ WR %,0 DQG ,0$*,1L7 8WLOLWLHV IRU 5HYLW 3URGXFWLYLW\12: 3RUWDO SURYLGHV VXSSRUW H/HDUQLQJ IUHH IUHH 8WLOLWLHV DQG DQ DFWLYH FRPPXQLW\ 7KH 3URGXFWLYLW\12: 3RUWDO KDV 2: 3RUWDO KDV FRQWHQW IRU HYHU\RQH ZLWK DGYDQFHG IXQFWLRQDOLW\ DYDLODEOH RQO\ WR DLODEOH RQO\ WR ,0$*,1L7 FOLHQWV 7R JHW VWDUWHG RU DVN D TXHVWLRQ FDOO RXU &OHYHODQG RI¿FH ¿FH DW RXU &ROXPEXV RI¿FH DW RU RU YLVLW LPDJLQLW FRP

14

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


(Pittsburgh, PA – Unbuilt) Student: Andrew Hofbauer Professor: Gregory Stroh (Kent State University)

Joshua Dixon Elementary School (Kimberly Janson, with Strollo Architects)

ASID Awards HONORABLE MENTION

Wright State University Enrollment Services Renovation (Robert Maschke Architects)

Joshua Dixon Elementary School (Columbiana, OH / Completed 2011) Name: Kimberly Janson, with Strollo Architects Client: Columbiana Exempted Village School District

HONORABLE MENTION

Dollar Bank at Erie View (Cleveland, OH / Completed 2008) Name: Anne Diedrich, with Eberhard Architects Client: Dollar Bank

Firm: Bialosky + Partners Architects Client: Lorain County Community College

HONORABLE MENTION

Cleveland Browns, Training & Administrative Complex Renovations

HONORABLE MENTION

Cleveland Clinic, Retail Spaces at Avon Health Center (Avon, OH / Completed 2012) Firm: Bucchieri Architects Client: Cleveland Clinic Foundation

(Cleveland, OH / Completed 2013) Firm: Westlake Reed Leskosky Client: Cleveland Browns

HONORABLE MENTION

Hyatt Regency

HONORABLE MENTION

(Cincinnati, OH / Completed 2013) Name: Kelli Schaffran, with K2M Design Client’s Name: LLAMCO LLC

Women’s Recovery Center

(Gates Mills, OH / Completed: Anticipated 2015) Firm: Westlake Reed Leskosky Client: Private School in Ohio

HONORABLE MENTION

(Cleveland, OH / Unbuilt) Firm: Robert Maschke Architects Client: Women’s Recovery Center

Academic Building

HONORABLE MENTION

Wright State U. Enrollment Services

&RQJUDWXODWLRQV WR DOO RI WKH $,$ $6,' &OHYHODQG 'HVLJQ $ZDUG ZLQQHUV

Hyatt Regency (Kelli Schaffran, with K2M Design)

AIA Awards HONORABLE MENTION

Mintz Residence (Cleveland, OH / Completed 2009) Firm: Robert Maschke Architects Client: Charles and Patricia Mintz

HONORABLE MENTION

Lorain County Community College, Ben & Jane Norton Culinary Arts Center (Elyria, OH / Completed 2013)

:H ZRXOG EH SURXG WR SURYLGH VWUXFWXUDO FRQVXOWLQJ ZRUN RQ \RXU QH[W SURMHFW

3(//(5 $662&,$7(6 ,1&

6 7 58 & 7 8 5 $ / ( 1 * , 1 ( ( 5 , 1 * (QHUJHWLF $QG 3UHSDUHG 7R 7DNH 2Q 1HZ &KDOOHQJHV ([SHUWV LQ VWUXFWXUDO HQJLQHHULQJ LQ (GXFDWLRQDO 6HQLRU +RXVLQJ &LYLF +HDOWKFDUH ,QVWLWXWLRQDO $TXDULXPV 5HFUHDWLRQDO 7KHPH 3DUN &RPPHUFLDO GHVLJQ FRQVWUXFWLRQ

ZZZ SHOOHUDQGDVVRFLDWHVZHVWODNHRK FRP &RUSRUDWH :D\ 6XLWH &OHYHODQG 2KLR www.propertiesmag.com 15


(Dayton, OH / Completed 2013) Firm: Robert Maschke Architects Client: Wright State University

smarter. Fairview Townhouse (Bucchieri Architects)

MERIT AWARD Congratulations 2013 Cleveland AIA/ASID Award Winners! Smart relationships lead to strong results. Whether we’re working as your Construction Manager, General Contractor or in a Design-Build capacity, we take a proactive, early partnering approach to your project. Working smarter earlier means greater savings later.

Star t working smarter. Visit krill.com or call 216.357.4777

SUBSCRIBE NOW R TWO YEARS!

AR! OR $34.95 FO FOR JUST $24.95 A YE% off cover price! Up to 75

Fairview Townhouse (Cleveland, OH / Completed 2011) Firm: Bucchieri Architects Client: Stephen and Jeannie Bucchieri

MERIT AWARD

GCRTA Buckeye-Woodhill Station Rehabilitation (Cleveland, OH / Completed 2010) Firm: Richard Fleischman + Partners Architects Client: Greater Cleveland Regional Transit Authority

HONOR AWARD

Oberlin College Conservatory of Music, Bibbins Hall Renovation (Oberlin, OH / Completed 2013) Firm: Westlake Reed Leskosky Client: Oberlin College Conservatory of Music

AIA PRESIDENTIAL CITATIONS Your Powerful Ally in Building Business in Northeast Ohio

Subscribe to Properties today and stay informed on the very best in construction and development activity in Northeast Ohio. The longest running publication of its kind in the state, Properties delivers vital news and revealing in-depth features on residential, commercial, industrial and institutional building!

Leadership in Advancing the Cause of Architectural Education in Cleveland and Northeast Ohio Recipient: Douglas Steidl, FAIA

Outstanding Service to AIA Cleveland, AIA Ohio, and AIA National Recipient: Robert Maschke, FAIA

Call Lisa at 216-251-8506 & subscribe today! 16

Also recognized at the program was Jill Christoff, Assoc. AIA, with the Emerging Practitioner Award, plus three recipients of AIA’s Activism Award: Michael Christoff, Assoc. AIA; Theodore Ferringer, Assoc. AIA; and Adam Yaracs, Assoc. AIA. P 3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67

Crunching the numbers on Northeast Ohio’s real estate & construction markets


),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67

Look Back, Look Forward CBRE delivers overview of Northeast Ohio commercial real estate 2013/2014 Story & images provided by CBRE

e at CBRE are pleased to present a review of 2013 and a preview of commercial real estate activity for 2014 in Northeast Ohio. This past year was very active across all property types in terms of leases, sales and new development.

W

trains, automobiles, ships, boats, tugs, rapid transit, birds, deer and sky! Tenants committed to the Tower for move-in for 2014 include: OM Group; 2)),&( ,1'8675,$/ 5(7$,/ Zashin & Rich Co.; McKinsey & 9$&$1&< Co.; and Porter Wright, LLP. Rumors Northeast Ohio Office Market abound of new tenant activity for ,19(1725< By Mary Izant the area, which could kick off buildVice President ing the second building of the office $&7,9,7< complex on land just north of the The Cleveland current site. The building would be 4827(' /($6( 5$7(6 office market had low rise and approximately 150,000 to a banner year of 180,000 square feet. This is combined 1(*27,$7(' activity. The with Fairmount Properties/Wolstein /($6( 5$7(6 Central Business Group finalizing their financing for 6$/(6 35,&(6 District (CBD) the Flats East Bank Phase 2, which office market is will kick off construction of new sev ,19(670(17 approximately 15 eral new restaurants and residential/ 6$/(6 million square apartment housing. Also, the new $&7,9,7< 35,&(6 feet, and ends the year with a vacancy Source: CBRE 150-room Aloft Hotel has opened, rate of around 18.3%, a slight decrease adjacent to the Tower, with three over 2012’s vacancy rate of 18.4%. In restaurants located on the first floor (140,000 RSF); law firm Tucker Ellis, the CBD, the new Ernst & Young Tower, LLP (108,000 RSF); Wells Fargo (25,000 – Ken Stewart’s, Lago and Willeyville with 550,000 rental square feet (RSF), RSF); Gilbane Construction (5,000 – along with the new Flats East Bank opened late May and generated a flurry RSF); Northwestern Mutual (17,000 Fitness Center, a state-of-the-art facility of interest. This is the first new office RSF) and CBRE, Inc. (14,419 RSF). I with fabulous views and programs. construction in the City since 1991. New must say the view from my fabulous cube The CBD also saw the re-stacking tenants occupying space in the Tower, on the north end of the second floor is of Key Tower, as KeyBank will re-size at year-end, include Ernst & Young just wonderful: Lake Erie with planes, to 487,621 RSF; the relocation of the

Downtown Cleveland, in particular, has garnered national attention as a place to invest, live, work and play. We should be proud and work hard to build upon this success.

1RUWKHDVW 2KLR 287/22.

YOUR LOCAL MARKET EXPERTS We believe that you are only as good as the people you are in business with. That’s why we make it a priority to be in business with the best.

The Osborne Group

KW Commercial / The Osborne Group has expertise in all facets of commercial real estate. We are your local market experts with the resources of a national platform, cutting edge tools and international network at our disposal.

7400 Center Street | Mentor, Ohio 44060 | 440-299-5190 | www.KWCommercialOhio.com 18

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


Cleveland Metropolitan School District (CMSD) headquarters to Eaton Center (88,575 RSF); the relocation of Oswald Companies to 71,703 RSF at 1100 Superior Avenue, which is now renamed Oswald Centre; plus the relocation of Plain Dealer to Skylight Office Tower. Ohio City is the big winner for the relocation of Skylight Financial Group to the top floor of the United Bank Building, located in the heart of Ohio City across from the historic West Side Market. The continued interest by developers in office-to-hotel conversions, and officeto-residential living units, has generated another burst of activity and taken several older Class C office buildings out of the CBD office market inventory. The new construction of the headquarters for Cuyahoga County Administration, at E. 9th and Prospect Avenues, by Geis Cos., has kicked off a re-do of the former Ameritrust Tower into residential apartments renamed as the Metropolitan, a 156-room Marriott Autograph Collection hotel and retail. Heinen’s Fine Foods will open a new 33,000-square-foot store in the CBD for the first time, located in the former Ameritrust Rotunda building at the corner of E. 9th and Euclid Avenue, and expanding east along Euclid Avenue into two vacant buildings. The southwest corner of E. 9th and Euclid Avenue will also see a new Kimpton Hotel in the renovated E. 9th Street Building, a Le Meridien Hotel in two former office buildings along the north side of Euclid, east of 925 Euclid (about to undergo its own re-do). And, of course, the former CMSD building will become a Drury Hotel, and is slated to open in 2016. The opening of the new Cleveland Convention Center and the attached Global Center for Health Innovation, just north of Public Square, has the City of Cleveland moving ahead with a new “convention center” hotel. Hilton Hotels has signed on as the operator and plans are underway for the construction of a 600-room hotel, featuring a garage with 280 parking spaces. Also, the former East Ohio Gas Building’s renovation into apartments is finally underway by the K&D Group, taking another older office building out of the CBD inven-

# #

#

# #

#

#

#

#

# #

tory. The Hanna Annex building at Playhouse Square has been converted to apartments, and the floors of the former Embassy Suites at Reserve Square have been turned back into rental units as well. Together, this marks a dramatic increase in rental opportunities for potential downtown dwellers.

The suburban office market was dominated by the relocation of Eaton Corporation to its new world headquarters building in Beachwood, in a portion of the Chagrin Highlands Development at Richmond and Harvard Roads. This 600,000-square-foot building sits on a 53-acre site with impressive 360-degree

ARE THERE TAX DEDUCTIONS HIDING IN YOUR BUILDING?

Many building owners have millions of dollars in income tax deductions they don’t know about. If you own commercial or industrial property and need more tax deductions, let our Cost Segregation professionals furnish you with an estimate. It won’t cost you anything to find out!

Call Dennis Duffy or Craig Miller: Cleveland 440.892.3339 / Columbus 614.949.4185 Detroit 248.752.7433 or visit our website www.costsegexperts.com

THE REGION’S LEADING INCOME TAX REDUCTION EXPERTS www.propertiesmag.com 19


),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67

ued vibrancy to the CBD office market and the Cleveland area in general.

#

#

Northeast Ohio Industrial Market

#

#

By Fred Herrera First Vice President

#

#

#

#

#

views of Northeast Ohio. In addition, Omnova Solutions, currently located in suburban Akron, has purchased land also in the Chagrin Highlands business park to build its new headquarters building. Other notable deals include TMW Systems consolidating a few east side offices into a 59,000 RSF commitment at Eastpoint I in the Landerhaven Corporate Park. Occupancy is targeted for January 2014. In addition, RX Options, Inc. expanded to 40,000 SF in the Canyon Falls Corporate Center I in Twinsburg, and ReliabilityFirst is moving north, from Akron to Independence, to a new 32,000-square-foot suite at Summit Office Park. The east side also saw the end of the foreclosure situation for the former Gotham King group of buildings: Corporate Circle I and II located on Chagrin Blvd. at Lander Circle in Pepper Pike, One Corporate Exchange

and Corporate Place in Beachwood on Science Park Drive, Landerbrook Corporate Center, I, II, II in Mayfield Heights, plus Metropolitan Plaza and One Harvard Crossing in Highland Hills. These buildings total almost one million square feet. Lone Star Funds bought the “note,” settled the litigation, and it is anticipated they will be very aggressive in leasing up the vacant spaces in the coming year. The big news from the west is American Greetings finally pushing ahead with the construction of its new corporate headquarters building at Crocker Park in Westlake. This 650,000-square-foot building is anticipated to open in 2014 and is certainly a significant new and major presence for the area. We anticipate another active and exciting year for 2014, with the potential of announcements of new construction, new tenants in the market and contin-

In 2013, Northeast Ohio’s industrial market continued to improve with availability decreasing from 8% in 2012 to 7.16%, while yearend 2013 average asking lease rates remained flat at $4.51 per square foot. Sale and leasing activity increased over 2012, hitting a high of 2.8 million square feet in Q3 2013, levels not seen since pre-recession. Construction activity remained weak as Northeast Ohio’s construction drought continued through 2013. Nevertheless, 2014 is poised to be a breakout year for industrial construction starts. Pent-up demand has significantly increased the pipeline of planned and pending projects, potentially pushing the anemic 250,000 square feet of construction starts in 2013 to over 2,000,000 square feet in 2014. The majority of the construction will be buildto-suit while spec development remains almost absent as developers continue to wait for significant preleasing. The majority of the planned construction will be in the 300,000-square-foot-plus bulk distribution category, led by the announced 1 million-square-foot, $43 million, corporate headquarters and distribution center

Result-Oriented and Reliable Legal Assistance for the Construction Industry Claims Management aND !VOIDANCE s #OMPETITIVE "IDDING s 3CHEDULE $ISPUTES $EFECTIVE 7ORK AND $ESIGN #LAIMS s 0ROJECT $ELIVERY AND #ONCEPTUALIZATION s -ECHANIC S ,IENS 3URETY "OND #LAIMS s ,ABOR AND %MPLOYMENT s !RBITRATION AND -EDIATION s ,ITIGATION

OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING YOUR YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED. BUSINESS SUCCEED. YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED.

127 Public Square | 2500 Key Center | Cleveland, Ohio 44114-1230 216.515.1660 - FAX 216.515.1650 | www.frantzward.com

20

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


for Arhaus Furniture in the Village of Boston Heights. The availability rate for bulk distribution facilities (defined as buildings larger than 100,000 square feet built in the last 12 years, with 24-foot clear height or higher, and featuring ESFR sprinkler systems) remained constrained with a vacancy level of under 6% for 2013. One developer that was able to kick off a speculative project was Ray Fogg Building Methods, which is under construction with a 32-foot clear height, 103,000-square-foot distribution facility at the 68-acre Bluestone Business Park in Euclid. The project is being anchored by Remedi Senior Care of Ohio-Northeast LLC, for 32,000 square feet. Developer Brookwood Capital Partners of Raleigh is under construction with a 75,000-square-foot distribution facility in Cleveland on the East Shoreway, near East 55th Street. Owens & Minor, a medical product supplier to University Hospitals, will be the only tenant in this build-to-suit facility. The most significant industrial sale of 2013 was the CalSTRS’s 16-building, 1.5 million-square-foot Northeast Ohio portfolio sale to Hackman Capital with properties located in Solon, Twinsburg, Highland Heights and Strongsville. This was part of a larger portfolio sale of 28 buildings, brokered by CBRE, which sold for $90 million. Shortly after closing the transaction, Hackman spun off the 170,000-square-foot warehouse located at 12850 Darice Parkway in Strongsville. The user/buyer was Pat Catan’s. Separately, InSite of Chicago sold the 811,200-square-foot Rubbermaid build-to-suit in Brimfield to American Realty Capital for $34,900,000, representing a CAP rate of 7.45%. Significant leases for 2013 include Hammer Company’s 200,928-square-foot lease of 7800 Cochran Road, in Solon, and the National Business Furniture lease of 100,560 square feet at 1261 Highland Road, in Macedonia. Other activity included the Terry’s Tire Town lease of 150,828 square feet at 5555 Massillon Road, in Green. The most significant industrial investment property offering of 2013

Local Knowledge, Global Reach, Proven Results +HUH DW *OREDO RXU PLVVLRQ LV WR SURYLGH WKH KLJKHVW TXDOLW\ RI UHDO HVWDWH VHUYLFHV DYDLODEOH :H RIIHU D FRPSUHKHQVLYH EURNHUDJH VSHFLDOL]LQJ LQ FRPPHUFLDO LQGXVWULDO ODQG DQG LQYHVWPHQW UHDO HVWDWH VHUYLFHV WKURXJKRXW WKH HQWLUH 1RUWKHDVW 2KLR PDUNHW $V DQ LQGXVWU\ OHDGHU ZH DUH H[SHUWV LQ HVWDEOLVKLQJ FUHDWLYH RSWLRQV WR DFKLHYH FOLHQW REMHFWLYHV LQ WKH EX\LQJ VHOOLQJ DQG OHDVLQJ RI UHDO HVWDWH &DOO XV WRGD\ IRU &RPSDUDEOHV (FRQRPLF ,QFHQWLYHV DQG 6ROXWLRQV WR \RXU &RPPHUFLDO 5HDO (VWDWH

Real Estate Advisors Inc. Broker

440-255-5552 www.GlobalCommercialRe.com

Corporate Real Estate Services SALES • LEASING • BUYER/TENANT REPRESENTATION • CONSULTING

www.propertiesmag.com 21


),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67

oil/gas industry and the resurgence of automotive, plastic/rubber, chemicals and food industries.

# #

5. Investor demand is strong with a significant imbalance between investor demand and offerings on the market.

#

# #

Northeast Ohio Retail Market

#

#

#

#

# #

is the Harbor Group 10-building, 815,000-square-foot Northeast Ohio portfolio with properties located throughout Northeast Ohio. The buildings are in Oakwood, Parma, Streetsboro, Twinsburg and Valley View. The portfolio is reportedly under contract with a scheduled closing of Q1 2014. Other projects for 2013 include the relocation of Nestlé’s Pizza Division from Northbrook, Illinois to Solon, creating 250 new jobs with a payroll of over $21 million. Exterran Energy Solutions’ 60,000-squarefoot Youngstown plant came online in the spring, supplying the growing oil and gas industry as an equipment manufacturer. Legacy Measurement Solutions opened a new 73,000-square-foot manufacturing facility in Brookfield Township (near Warren). Netherlands biomedical firm Quest Medical Imaging established its U.S. headquarters in Akron.

Very significant oil- and gas-related projects related to the Utica Shale region (East/Central Ohio) include the Baker Hughes $10 million project on 108 acres in Massillon and Chesapeake Energy’s $10 million facility on over 284 acres in Louisville (east of Canton), creating a significant number of new jobs. Into 2014, key market trends include: 1. New construction should spike in 2014, to levels not seen in Northeast Ohio since pre-recession levels. 2. Lease rates will continue to increase for Class A & B properties, given the continued tightening trend. 3. Sale prices continue the rebound to pre-recession levels. 4. Our region will continue to see a positive impact of the improving manufacturing sector, along with the positive impact of the Utica Shale

By Keith Hamulak Sales Professional The Northeast Ohio retail market has improved, and vacancy rates are once again under double digits. Trade areas proximate to the urban core have experienced the largest decrease in vacancy rates. Retailers in Brooklyn, Fairview Park, Lorain, Parma and Rocky River, all densely populated communities, absorbed large chunks of space. Greenfield trade areas also improved occupancy levels with the most active communities being Avon, Green and Streetsboro. The bulk of the absorption can be attributable to only a few retail segments. Mattress, dollar-discounters, automotive, fitness and quick-serve restaurants are the most aggressive retailers expanding in Northeast Ohio. Generally speaking, we are still in a “tenant’s market.” However, landlords have the upper hand in premier lifestyle projects and new construction. Several new projects broke ground and/ or opened in 2013. A few of the projects were driven by retailer demand, such as

/HW·V %XLOG 7RJHWKHU With almost 95 years of experience in the construction industry, we understand the business cycles, the special income tax issues, the reporting and bonding requirements, and the unique risks and opportunities contractors face each day. Meaden & Moore services, tailored to the needs of construction firms, include: Ƈ Accounting Expertise

Ƈ Succession Planning

Ƈ Cost Control

Ƈ Business Planning

Ƈ Profit Enhancement

Ƈ Litigation Support Services

Ƈ Tax Planning

Ƈ Bid Reviews

Ƈ Job-Cost Auditing

216.241.3272 22

meadenmoore.com 3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


Oakwood Commons, in South Euclid, and Heritage Crossings, in Green. Other projects such as Cedar Center North are the culmination of eminent domain and redevelopment. New construction is still well below the one million square feet of space we added annually for the five years prior to the recession. The hospitality market made a big comeback in 2013 as several hotel brands have announced projects in the City of Cleveland CBD. Additional hotels are planned in Avon, Beachwood, Sheffield Village and Strongsville and in the City of Cleveland at Emerald Corporate Park. Also making a comeback in 2013 was the automotive industry. Automotive retailers made significant capital improvements into existing dealerships, expanded when feasible or relocated when necessary. Real estate investors looking for yield have been actively acquiring retail product in Northeast Ohio. Demand for Class A grocery-anchored shop-

ping centers far exceeds availability and single-tenant net-leased assets continue to be the most desirable. Starwood Capital and Phillips Edison were the most active buyers, while Westfield and Kimco were the most active sellers. The auction market has been hit-or-miss as potential buyers are becoming more sophisticated, due to the speed and

availability of information made possible by the Internet. Retail brokers have a lot to look forward to in 2014 as several new retail concepts will enter the Northeast Ohio market for the first time. Equally exciting is the proposed development of PineCrest, a mixed-use development located at the northeast corner of

Come join the newest, hippest, in-crowd in Cleveland, BEC-CLE. And yes, we’re all about the science of building enclosures, too!

;d]n]dYf\ k Kl]]d @]Y\imYjl]jk

Thank you to our charter sponsors for helping to make BEC-CLE a reality:

&ROXPELD %XLOGLQJ 3URGXFWV STEEL JOISTS STRUCTURAL IRON METAL ROOF DECK STEEL STAIRS & RAILS STEEL ERECTION

440-235-3363 *-1.) =de Kl&$ ;d]n]dYf\$ G@ ,,)+0

PLATINUM LEVEL Dow Corning DuPont Tyvek / Parksite Johns Manville / Reps of Ohio Tremco VIP Wiss, Janney, Elstner (WJE) Assoc. Inc. GOLD LEVEL Derbigum Firestone/AAdvanced Prosoco Technical Assurance SILVER LEVEL ECO Commissions Integrated Engineering Consultants Inc. Mid-State Restoration Sika / Chilco Diversified Siplast The Chas. E. Phipps Co.

The Building Enclosure Council / Cleveland is an interdisciplinary forum of architects, engineers, consultants, manufacturers, contractors, developers, owners, facility managers and other construction professionals. We invite you to be part of our efforts in elevating the knowledge base of local professionals to effectively deal with the unique climatic conditions affecting building enclosures in N.E Ohio. Visit our website for information on our meetings, seminars and events, and how to become a member!

Become a member today!

www.bec-cleveland.org www.propertiesmag.com 23


),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67

Harvard and I-271. Voters in Orange Village passed legislation at the general election, which allows for the development of one of the most desirable land parcels in the suburbs. In closing, retailers and consumers are sharing the learning curve as our industry evolves into a hybrid of bricks and mortar, recycled shipping containers, pop-ups, store within a store, and the Internet. Newer retail formats such as the pop-up and small box will gain momentum in 2014 and will inspire a broader range of retail entrepreneurs. The diversity of retail concepts and the increase in distribution channels will benefit retailers and consumers alike.

sales, such as the mega-note acquisition by Lone Star Funds, which included the former Gotham King portfolio (nine east suburban office buildings with 900,000 square feet). Nationally, there was the usual high level of interest in core cities as equity battled over assets in those markets,

Interest rates continue to be attractive and financing available for experienced investors. We see 2014 shaping up as a solid year for investors as the market gains momentum.

Northeast Ohio Investment Market By Vicki Maeder Vice President Throughout 2013, the capital markets continued to march along toward a more normal environment of debt and equity investing. Fewer distressed properties and more conventional sales occurred. Ownership transfers were generated as a result of conventional marketing, auction and note

leading to further cap rate compression and frustration with the limited number of offerings in the target cities. Foreign capital from Canada, China and Middle East countries closed the most transactions – primarily office buildings. Our region and other secondary markets also saw an influx of interest from Canadian firms and New York-based firms with ties to other countries. The highest demand was for multifamily and grocery-anchored, stabilized retail centers. Several major malls transferred to new ownership.

The downtown office building market offerings were primarily functionally obsolete or vacant buildings offering redevelopment opportunities, such as the Ameritrust complex, Board of Education building, 1717 E. 9th and other smaller buildings. Those buildings will be converted to apartments and hotels. The demand for downtown housing rose with the increased desire over the past several years to live/work downtown. The opening of the convention center, which will attract more visitors to the area for meetings, coupled with the Horseshoe Casino, sporting events and other visitor attractions has increased the demand for hotel rooms. In the suburbs, more of the office building transactions continued to be user-driven, but there were several offerings of Class A buildings which generated solid interest and a new source of investors who had not previously been looking in this market. Interest rates continue to be attractive and financing available for experienced investors. We see 2014 shaping up as a solid year for investors as the market gains momentum. With an increasing demand for rental space coupled with a lack of new construction, vacancy levels should continue to improve. As capital seeks out stabilized real estate, there will be an expansion into more markets in search of opportunities. P

ÊÃà ٠® ½ Z ½ Ýã ã D Ä ¦ Ù͛Ý ZÊÊ¥ ÝÝ ã D Ä ¦ à Äã WÙʦ٠à tĞ ĂŶ ƐƐŝƐƚ tŝƚŚ͗ Q ZŽŽĨ ŽŶĚŝƟŽŶ ŶĂůLJƐŝƐ Q WƌĞͲWƵƌĐŚĂƐĞ /ŶƐƉĞĐƟŽŶƐ Q dƵŶĞͲƵƉ /ŶƐƉĞĐƟŽŶƐ Q ZĞƉĂŝƌ Θ DĂŝŶƚĞŶĂŶĐĞ WƌŽŐƌĂŵƐ

EŽďŽĚLJ ŽǀĞƌƐ zŽƵ ĞƩĞƌ͘Ρ ))L^IVKML *]QTLQVO 8ZWL]K\[ 44+

ϵϯϮϭ ZĂǀĞŶŶĂ ZĚ͕͘ ^ƚĞ͘ ͕ dǁŝŶƐďƵƌŐ͕ K, ϰϰϬϴϳ ͻ WŚ͘ ϭͲϴϬϬͲϰϵϴͲϯϵϳϱ͖ &dž͘ ϭͲϯϯϬͲϰϬϱͲϰϴϲϭ ǁǁǁ͘ĂĂĚǀĂŶĐĞĚ͘ĐŽŵ ŝŶĨŽΛĂĂĚǀĂŶĐĞĚ͘ĐŽŵ 24

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


Hot Topics Survey of Northeast Ohio construction industry reveals outlook for 2014 By Roger T. Gingerich, CPA/ABV, CVA, CCA Skoda Minotti

ast year, the Real Estate and Construction group at Skoda Minotti took a closer look at the Northeast Ohio construction market. This article contains a brief summary of some of our findings.

L

3HUFHQWDJH RI ZRUN WKDW UHTXLUHV ERQGLQJ

Ohio Construction Reform Ohio Construction Reform has been a hot topic recently, and it ranked third on our question related to which political issues would impact the construction industry most significantly going forward. The impact thus far hasn’t been quite as clear: 53% said it had “no impact” while 25% thought it had a positive impact and 22% thought it had a negative impact. Some of the specific impacts of reform included competition, project size and contract type. Nearly half (48%) of respondents said that competition from “regional and national firms” increased due to reform. Reform also had an impact on project size. More than half of respondents (56%) said that they are seeing larger projects packaged together due to reform. These larger projects likely led to less overall opportunities: 46% and 47%, respectively, of subcontractors and general contractors felt that reform resulted in less overall opportunities while only 26% and 31% of subcontractors and general contractors, respectively, felt that there was an overall increase in opportunities due to reform. In terms of the types of contracts that were available, our respondents saw a very even mix of the three types of methods allowed through reform: design/build, single prime bidding and construction manager at risk proposals.

Healthcare and Tax Reform Healthcare and Tax Reform finished first and second respectively as the politi-

eventually. According to our survey, 10% of companies with less than 50 employees say they plan to remain below that threshold in order to avoid the effects of reform that impact companies with 50+ employees. Overall, our survey respondents felt that healthcare reform would have a negative impact on the industry (37%), while only 2% of respondents felt healthcare reform would have a positive impact. The remaining respondents were unsure of its impact. Feelings were slightly less negative toward tax reform as only 26% felt it would have a negative impact on their plans for business growth.

Bonding cal issues that would have the most impact on the industry in 2013. Since the time of our survey, the mandate that required employers of 50 or more employees to provide insurance or pay a penalty has been delayed until January 1, 2015. However, it seems as though reform is going to have an impact on hiring within the industry

We asked, “What percentage of your work requires bonding?” and this year, we had our highest ever percentage of respondents (24%) fall into the “greater than 80%” category. This coincided with our lowest ever percentage of respondents (44%) in the “less than 20%” category. This is likely pointing to less private work being available.

SPECIALIZING IN EXTERIOR MASONRY REPAIR & RENOVATION SINCE 1972 • COMPLETE INSPECTION/ASSESSMENT OF FAÇADE CONDITIONS • TUCKPOINTING/CAULKING

• BRICK & STONE REPAIR/REPLACEMENT

• SEALING/WATERPROOFING

• CLEANING/PRESSURE WASHING

Ph 216.881.4142 | Fx 216.881.6557 | 4408 St. Clair Ave., Cleveland, OH 44103 www.propertiesmag.com 25

Graphic courtesy of Skoda Minotti

You can download the complete survey recap for free online by visiting www.skodaminotti.com/survey.


),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67

This year, only 30% of respondents thought it would be “more difficult” to acquire bonding than in the past, compared to 35% in 2012 and 40% in 2011.

0RUH RSSRUWXQLWLHV IRU 1HZ %XVLQHVV LQ 1RUWKHDVW 2KLR

Lending We asked about our survey respondents’ ability to obtain financing over the past year and 18% felt that it has “increased.” This is up from 15% last year and only 4% in 2011. In 2009, 78% of respondents felt that their ability to obtain financing had “decreased.” This year, only 29% of respondents felt the same way, which is the lowest percent since we began asking the question in 2009.

Green Construction This year 22% of respondents said that they had “greater than 10” LEED jobs compared to 11% last year, 9% in 2011 and 8% in 2010. Also, the percentage of respondents with “zero” LEED

certified jobs dropped to an all-time low of 23%.

Outlook for Construction Industry in Northeast Ohio There was no surprise as to where our respondents see future opportunities arising – once again “institutional” and “governmental” opportunities led the way while “residential (multi-family)” and “residential (single family)”

were the least popular responses. Overall though, 43% of respondents felt that there would be “more opportunities” in Northeast Ohio over the next three years. While this is slightly down from 2012 (49%), it is still the second most optimistic response that we have seen from respondents since 2008. This year, 41% of respondents felt that their average job size “decreased” over the past 12 months while only 33% saw an “increase” in job size. Competition increased for many of our respondents as 66% of our respondents saw five or more bidders on most jobs. That number was only 51% last year, but had previously been as high as 78% (2009) and 82% (2010). P Roger T. Gingerich, CPA/ABV, CVA is the partner-in-charge of Skoda Minotti’s Real Estate and Construction Group. You can contact Roger at 440-449-6800 or rgingerich@skodaminotti.com.

When your fair share of taxes is neither fair... nor your share Billions in assessment reductions The attorneys at Siegel Jennings bring experience as accountants, appraisers and real estate developers to the practice of law. Our property tax services include: Ŷ Representation at the administrative level through the State Supreme Court Ŷ Local expertise in every state through the American Property Tax Counsel Ŷ Tax management – acquisition/disposition strategies

Siegel Jennings 26

Call J. Kieran Jennings, Esq at 216.763.1004

Cleveland Ŷ Pittsburgh Ŷ Columbus

23425 Commerce Park Drive, Suite 103, Beachwood OH 44122 www.siegeltax.com

Founding member, American Property Tax Counsel (APTC) • www.aptc.com

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014

Graphic courtesy of Skoda Minotti

Ŷ Cutting edge approaches to property tax reductions


Building B uilding Owners Owners and a nd M Managers anagers Association Association

Join Us!

B U S I N E S S ooff GGreater reater Cleveland Cleveland IRS’s ‘Tangible Property’ Regulations... & Why You Should Be Nervous ffective January 1, 2014, taxpayers need to be cognizant of the new regulations on the capitalization of expenditures related to tangible property. These regulations greatly change the definition of a “capital expenditure” and, more importantly, include a “bright line” test for IRS agents. These changes coincide with large decreases in immediate expensing of capital items. But it’s not all bad news… well, actually it is. And this article will detail why numerous employees of an organization need to be aware of these drastic changes. Taxpayers have enjoyed favorable treatment of certain capital expenditures’ immediate expensing for several years through either 100% or 50% direct write-off of capital expenditures (“bonus depreciation” and “Section 179”). In 2014, “Bonus” is gone; Section 179 is now $25,000. Now the really bad news – what you have been expensing as repairs, maintenance and supplies may now need to be capitalized. IRS expects that your tax and internal accounting capitalization policies will be the same. Generally, individual purchases less than $5,000 may be expensed (“de minimis rules”) if you have Audited Financial Statements and maintain a written capitalization policy; if you do not have an Audit, then only items less than $500 may be expensed under the de minimis rules. For all individual items above these thresholds, the fun begins. Generally, any item that has a useful life over 12 months – whether used in a production process, parts for a truck, building renovation components, desks or computers – needs to be capitalized and depreciated typically over five, seven or 15 years for personal property; 27.5 or 39 years for real property.

E

Clear definitions of your capitalization policy must be communicated to everyone in your organization who purchases, approves, codes or is otherwise part of the procurement process. The IRS now has a clear definition (“bright line test”) of tangible property. Under audit, it is anticipated that all expenses will be reviewed for capitalization potential, not just your repairs and maintenance accounts. A few suggestions:

62nd Annual Design & Construction Conference & Tradeshow

1) Review or create a capitalization policy that makes sense for your organization, which incorporates the new IRS tangible property rules. 2) Be sure to circulate the policy to the entire organization.

X EGX FNEH

3) Establish an oversight process to review all expenditures to ensure IRS compliance.

KUGN g JUNN

This is a daunting task indeed, but should not be marginalized. The IRS took eight years to finalize the regulations, so we are quite confident IRS auditors will be focusing on these areas. With any IRS regulation, there are numerous “ands, ifs and buts.” Consult your Board of Directors, your CFO, your accountants and your tax preparers soon – 2014 is already here. Material discussed in this article is meant to provide general information and should not be acted on without professional advice tailored to your individual needs. This article was written by Paul Etzler, CPA, CGMA, GACR Skoda Minotti. Paul can be reached at (440) 449-6800 x7150 or petzler@skodaminotti. com. Skoda Minotti can be found at the web at www.skodaminotti.com.

Janice Parham Executive Vice President BOMA Greater Cleveland

# '064' FIKKK '641+6 1#& '56.#-'X *+1 HHEHI

2105145*+2 n :*+$+614 2214670+6+'5 8#+.#$.' #4)'6 0'#4.; HNN *+)*.; +0(.7'06+#. &'%+5+10 /#-'45 n -'; 12+0+10 .'#&'45 +0 6*' '5+)0 n 105647%6+10 0&7564; 0641&7%' 0'9 241&7%65 #0& 5'48+%'5 '0'4#6' 0'9 5#.'5 .'#&5 7+.& 8+5+$+.+6; (14 ;174 %1/2#0; +0 # %1/2'6+6+8' /#4-'62.#%'

+'9 /14' &'6#+.5 10 6*+5 '8'06 #0& 16*'45X 8+5+6 999T%'50'6T14) 14 %#.. FEJgGJEgGENNT -!'!:).% ).#

For more info on this article or BOMA Greater Cleveland, contact Janice Parham at 216.575.0305 or jparham@bomacleveland.org

+5 # 2417& /'&+# 5210514 1( 6*' .'8'.#0& 0)+0''4+0) 1%+'6; www.propertiesmag.com 27


),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67

National Construction Outlook 2014 McGraw Hill Construction observes ongoing expansion within construction industry here’s an expansion underway for the construction industry, but depending on one’s perspective it can be viewed in a variety of ways. Looking at total construction, the pattern of recovery was slow and tenuous early on, with McGraw Hill Construction reporting that total construction starts edged up just 2% in both 2010 and 2011.

T

28

The Pattern of U.S. Construction Starts Billions of Dollars 2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

2013

2013

Total Construction

558.2

426.3

435.3

442.9

485.3

508.1

555.3

-13%

-24%

+2%

+2%

+10%

+5%

+9%

Single-Family Housing

122.4

94.3

100.0

97.3

125.8

159.5

201.1

-39%

-23%

+6%

-3%

+29%

+27%

+26%

38.1

17.9

22.0

29.4

40.2

48.0

53.1

Multifamily Housing

-37%

-53%

+23%

+34%

+36%

+19%

+11%

Commercial Buildings

81.4

47.3

42.1

48.3

54.0

62.4

72.7

-19%

-42%

-11%

+14%

+12%

+15%

+17%

Institutional Buildings

130.6

112.3

112.2

100.0

90.7

87.1

89.1

+11%

-14%

-0-

-11%

-9%

-4%

+2%

31.0

9.7

9.5

17.3

12.9

13.8

14.9

Manufacturing Buildings

+50%

-69%

-2%

+82%

-25%

+6%

+8%

Public Works

121.2

123.6

120.7

106.6

110.9

114.3

108.9

-0-

+2%

-2%

-12%

+4%

+3%

-5%

Electric Utilities

33.5

21.1

28.7

43.9

50.9

23.0

15.5

+77%

-37%

+36%

+53%

+16%

-55%

-33%

over approving federal spending for fiscal 2014 and raising the debt ceiling has dealt another blow to the economy. While the October 16 budget vote ended the government shutdown and the likelihood of default, it has contributed to more uncertainty, which may prove to be persistent. For 2013, the U.S. economy was estimated to grow at just 1.6%, down from 2.8% in 2012. Assuming the federal budget deliberations can proceed in a more orderly manner, then there are enough positive factors in the U.S. economy to enable it to grow in the range of 2.5% to 3.0%, with the working estimate for this Outlook being 2.7%. Job growth was moving at a reasonable pace during 2013, and less uncertainty could encourage firms to hire more workers. Interest rates, while edging up, are still low. Market fundamentals for com-

mercial building, such as occupancies and rents, are improving, and bank lending standards for commercial real estate development are easing gradually. And while federal spending restraint will prove to be a drag on publicly financed construction, the improved fiscal posture of states and localities will offset some of that drag. In this environment, it’s forecast that total construction starts will climb 9% to $555 billion, a bit faster than 2013 although still at a measured clip. The following are the main points by sector for the 2014 construction market: • Single-family housing will grow 26% in dollars, corresponding to a 24% increase in units to 785,000 (McGraw Hill Construction basis), 3URSHUWLHV | January 2014

Source: McGraw-Hill Construction

Multifamily housing was showing signs of life and the stimulus-supported public works sector was moving at a decent clip, but other parts of the industry continued to languish. The year 2012 brought single-family housing into the recovery process, and at that point it appeared that a more typical construction upturn was taking hold. That year, total construction starts advanced 10%, lifted by healthy percentage growth for housing. This also raised the expectation that nonresidential building with its commercial and institutional sectors would soon follow in 2013, but that has only partially materialized. For 2013, total construction starts were estimated to rise 5% to $508 billion, and the main driver of growth continues to be housing. For nonresidential building, there’s been some lift coming from its commercial sector, but the level of activity for the commercial categories remains very low. The institutional sector in 2013 proved to be a drag on nonresidential building for yet another year, keeping the volume of nonresidential building close to the depressed amounts reported from 2009 through 2012. In effect, the process of turning the corner for nonresidential building has been stretched out, which is not surprising given the sluggish economic conditions. The backdrop for the construction industry remains the hesitant U.S. economy. At the outset of 2013, it seemed that some of the uncertainty affecting economic activity would ease, given the fact that the presidential election had been decided and the fiscal cliff averted. There was some dampening from the tax hikes in January and the start of the sequester in March, but the economy seemed to be adjusting. However, the prolonged Congressional impasse in October


and basically matching the gains in 2012 and 2013. The positives for single-family housing are numerous – the pace of foreclosures has eased, home prices are rising, and mortgage rates remain near recent lows. However, the demand for housing will continue to be restrained by careful bank lending practices towards issuing mortgages. • Multifamily housing will rise 11% in dollars and 9% in units. While growth continues, the percentage gains will be smaller than the previous four years, reflecting a maturing multifamily market. This structure type is still a favored investment target by the real estate finance community, which in the near term should lead to more high-rise residential buildings in major cities. • Commercial building will increase 17%, a slightly faster pace than the 15% gain estimated for 2013. Warehouses and hotels will continue to lead the way, while stores and office buildings pick up the pace. The positives for commercial building are improving market fundamentals and more bank lending for commercial development. Next year’s activity in dollar terms will still be 28% below the 2007 peak. • Institutional building will edge up 2%, turning the corner after five years of decline. For the educational building category, colleges are revisiting capital expansion plans, and passage of recent construction bond measures in several states should help K-12 construction projects. Healthcare construction is expected to remain flat, given continued emphasis on cost containment. • Public works construction will drop 5%, pulling back after a 3% gain in 2013 that was lifted by the start of several large highway and bridge projects. More focus on deficit reduction will limit federal support for environmental public works, although the improved fiscal posi-

tion of state and local governments will help to cushion the extent of the public works decline. • Electric utilities will retreat 33%, continuing the 55% correction estimated

for 2013 that followed the current dollar high reached in 2012. Capacity utilization is down sharply, limiting the near term need for new generating capacity. The need for transmission line work remains strong. P

Reprinted with permission from McGraw-Hill Construction’s “2014 Dodge Construction Outlook.” For more information, visit McGraw-Hill Construction online at www.construction.com.

When Quality Counts, Count on Delta.

Providing Industrial Cleaning, Painting & Maintenance with Quality & Service that is Second to None. INDUSTRIAL CLEANING & MAINTENANCE • Hot pressure / steam cleaning • Waterproofing and sealing • Parking deck cleaning, painting, and striping • Overhead cleaning / painting • Exterior and interior building cleaning • Industrial oven cleaning • Dust collector cleaning • Pigeon / bat excrement removal • Graffiti removal

• Roof fan and ventilator cleaning • Industrial exhaust system cooling and heating coil cleaning • Kitchen exhaust system and kitchen equipment cleaning • Machinery cleaning / painting • Welding exhaust cleaning • Construction clean-up or restoration of property for sale and leasing

INDOOR AIR QUALITY • HVAC system cleaning & sanitizing • Air duct cleaning • Mold remediation

Contact Delta Industrial today! 216-281-8700 5201 DENISON AVE., CLEVELAND OHIO 44102 www.propertiesmag.com 29


CUSTOM DESIGN & DEVELOPMENT OF COMMERCIAL CONSTRUCTION 0TCPSOF 3FBM &TUBUF 4FSWJDFT MFBE CZ 3JDL 0TCPSOF +S JT B GVMM TFSWJDF DPNNFSDJBM EFTJHO BOE EFWFMPQNFOU DPOTUSVDUJPO DPNQBOZ UIBU JT EFEJDBUFE UP BMM PG ZPVS DPNNFSDJBM SFBM FTUBUF OFFET 8F PGGFS B XJEF WBSJFUZ PG TFSWJDFT UIBU XJMM FOTVSF UIBU XIFO ZPVS QBSUOFS XJUI VT BMM PG ZPVS DPNNFSDJBM SFBM FTUBUF CVJMEJOH OFFET BSF DPWFSFE 4QFDJBMJ[JOH JO

Custom Design & Development Construction, Interior Build-Outs Renovations, Expansions Property Management

;OL -LKLSP .YV\W PZ H ^PKLS` YLZWLJ[LK PUZ\YHUJL IYVRLYHNL HUK JVUZ\S[PUN ZLY]PJL VYNHUPaH[PVU >P[O H ZWLJPHSPaLK JVUZ[Y\J[PVU ZLY]PJLZ KP]PZPVU [OH[ PUJS\KLZ Z\IZ[HU[PHS L_WLY[PZL ^P[O Z\YL[` IVUKZ ;OL -LKLSP .YV\W JHU TLL[ [OL ULLKZ VM `V\Y I\ZPULZZ 7SLHZL JHSS ;VU` :JOLWPZ :LUPVY =7 VM *VUZ[Y\J[PVU :LY]PJLZ VY 9VI ,KNLY[VU =7 VM :\YL[` [V KPZJ\ZZ OV^ ;OL -LKLSP .YV\W JHU OLSW

Osborne O sb borne R Real eall E Estate sttate t Services Serviices )JHI 4U 'BJSQPSU )BSCPS 0) ] XXX PSFTMMD OFU

^^^ [OLMLKLSPNYV\W JVT 9VJRZPKL 9VHK -PM[O ÅVVY 0UKLWLUKLUJL 6/

T H E AR T O F P R OBL EM S OL VI NG Providing creative legal solutions for real estate matters

The Real Estate Attorneys of

Leasing _ Development _ Real Estate Finance _ Tax Credit Transactions _ Land Use & Zoning _ Urban & Historic Redevelopment _

Cleveland | 216.781.1212 | walterhav.com

30

Tech, Multi-Family & Shopping Centers

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


Improving Outlook Progress in 2013 promises bright 2014 for commercial real estate in Cleveland By John W. Waldeck, Esq. Walter | Haverfield

here’s a sense of optimism regarding commercial real estate in the City of Cleveland. Not only are people in the industry feeling it, but they can also see it in the form of more deals getting done.

T

• Completion of phase I of the Uptown Apartments, including retail and residential housing lease-ups, and the beginning of phase II

Photo by Jim Maguire

In 2013, credit was more readily available for development and refinancing. With more cash flowing, area developers and property owners saw opportunities they had not seen in many years and were quick to act upon them – especially in the area of residential housing. High demand, combined with high occupancy rates, particularly in and around the downtown area, drove much of the development. What were some of the more significant accomplishments within the City’s limits in 2013? Starting with the east side, the University Circle area experienced tremendous growth, including: CENTER OF ATTENTION Downtown Cleveland saw its share of development in 2013, including the opening of the Global Center for Health Innovation and Cleveland Convention Center.

• Renovation of housing units for students at The Music Settlement

• Extension of Cleveland State campus to provide for its new Department of Theatre and Dance

• Expansion of galleries Cleveland Art Museum

• Renovation of Playhouse Square

at

the

• Opening of the Marriott Courtyard on Cornell near University Hospitals

Of course, downtown Cleveland saw more than its share of development, including:

Midtown Cleveland also saw growth through such projects as:

• Preliminary construction of Cuyahoga County headquarters building on East 9th Street, including redevelopment of the Rotunda

• Completion of construction in the Euclid Corridor between 65th and 75th streets • Renovation of the Agora Building on Euclid to be used as incubator space for new business

• Sale of building by Cleveland Municipal School District, which moved into vacant space at 11th Street and Superior Avenue

• Preservation of the Agora Theatre

• Construction of Old Bond Court Hotel

• Expansion of Cleveland State student housing on Chester between 26th and 30th streets

• Preliminary construction to convert the old East Ohio Gas Building on East 9th Street into apartments

• Development of Flats East Bank, including announcement of numerous leases and promising lease-up projections • Completion of the Global Center for Health Innovation and Cleveland Convention Center • Connection of the north and south sides of the Shoreway with completion of the underground connector While much of this work had been projected for 2013 earlier in the year, few people would have expected as much progress on many of the construction projects, including all the work being done by The Geis Companies on East 9th Street. Such development also translated into other benefits, including the creation of numerous construction jobs www.propertiesmag.com 31


),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67

and the attraction of more people to live downtown. Based on the progress made in 2013, the new year is promising equally positive growth. Money from lenders for real estate projects is expected to be available at the current level or possibly even at an accelerated pace. Thanks to decisive governmental action, tax credit programs (which were instrumental in building up the City of Cleveland in recent years) will continue to be available, especially in the form of New Markets Tax Credits. Although the City of Cleveland continues to be challenged in the area of job creation, the downtown area is still attracting people to move downtown. With the success of multiple initiatives designed to combat “brain drain,” downtown Cleveland will be home to more young adults than what most of us can remember. Some of the more noteworthy commercial real estate projects projected for the City in 2014 (starting on the west side) include:

• Ongoing development on East 9th Street at Euclid, including development of The Rotunda and the 1010 Euclid Avenue building

• Construction of the Le Meridien Hotel on East 9th Street

• Opening of the new Heinen’s grocery store on East 9th Street, occupying more than 35,000 square feet

• Development of new apartments in the old East Ohio Gas building

• Development of the Metropolitan Hotel on East 9th Street with apart-

• Completion of new streetscaping for Playhouse Square

• Tentative construction near Browns Stadium as part of the overall lakefront development plan (final bidders to be chosen in 2014)

Although the City of Cleveland • Addition of the Hofbrauhaus, a franchise with an continues to be challenged Germany-based 1100-seat beer garden under cover and brewery, at 15th and Chester (to in the area of job creation, the onsite also house a refurbished Hermit Club) downtown area is still attracting As was the case in 2013, these new people to move downtown. projects projected for 2014 are expected ments above (projected to be the tallest residential apartment building in the City) • Completion of the Cuyahoga County Headquarters building, which will bring 770 jobs to the location

• Completion of The Shoreway apartments near The Gordon Square Arts District

• Construction of the new Kimpton hotel and apartments in the old Schofield Building on the southwest corner of East 9th and Euclid

• Phase II development of the Flats East Bank project which will likely include apartments and some office space

• Development of a new, yet undetermined, mixed-use project in the old Huntington Building

to have a significant impact on the local job market with nearly 1,000 new jobs being created just at the corner of East 9th Street and Euclid Avenue. So hang on to your hat if you work in the commercial real estate market, because 2014 is promising a whirlwind of activity. That’s good news for a city that has struggled for the past decade to rebound from an economy characterized by an extremely tight lending market. P Waldeck is a partner and head of the Real Estate Practice Group at downtown Cleveland-based Walter | Haverfield.

%QPETGVG 5CYKPI CPF &TKNNKPI 2TQHGUUKQPCNU # &K)GTQPKOQ %QORCP[

9CNN 5CYKPI 5NCD 5CYKPI 9KTG 5CYKPI %QTG &TKNNKPI

5JQV $NCUVKPI )TKPFKPI 5JQTKPI 0GGFNG $GCOKPI %QPETGVG 4GOQXCN 4GRNCEGOGPV +PVGTKQT $WKNFKPI 'ZECXCVKQP )TQWPF 2GPGVTCVKPI 4CFCT 0'9

5RGEKCNV[ GSWKROGPV RTQXKFKPI GOKUUKQP CPF FWUV HTGG QRVKQPU KPENWFKPI XQNV OKPK GZECXCVQT RTQRCPG RQYGTGF DQDECVU CPF *'2# ſNVGTGF CKT ſNVTCVKQP FGXKEGU 1NF $TGEMUXKNNG 4QCF +PFGRGPFGPEG 1JKQ RJQPG Ŗ HCZ

YYY RTGEKUKQPRTQEWV EQO 32

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


Surety Bonds – The Role of Surety Credit on Construction Projects By Kevin W. Birch CNA Surety

roperty owners have many issues to address when beginning a new construction or renovation project. Unfortunately, there is a critical issue often neglected – surety bonds and the protection they offer.

P

Surety bonds are risk management tools, which provide private owners the financial security and assurance that their construction project will be completed according to contract terms and conditions and that all bills will be paid. Suretyship has been a tried and tested tool for centuries. The earliest known contract that was guaranteed by a surety was discovered on a clay tablet from about 2700 BC. Corporate surety bonds have been used since the 19th century when Congress recognized the need to protect taxpayers and others from contractor failures. The Federal Miller Act of 1935 was enacted to require performance and payment bonds on federal public works construction projects. The 50 states and local municipalities have enacted laws that require surety bonds on public works projects. Private owners can also require surety bonds, which protect their financial interest and assure completion.

to their clients (the principal) working through independent agents or brokers.

Types of construction surety bonds There are three types of construction surety bonds. These include bid bonds, performance bonds and payment bonds. Bid Bond – Assures the principal has met a rigorous underwriting process and that the principal is qualified to perform the work. This bond provides assurance that the principal can secure the necessary performance and payment bond if a contract is awarded.

Performance Bond – Guarantees the terms and conditions of the construction contract. The obligee is given a high level of assurance that principal will fulfill contractual obligations. The principal is motivated to ensure there is successful completion because the principal will indemnify the surety in the event of failure to perform. Payment Bond – Provides assurance to the obligee that the construction contractor (principal) will pay direct subs, material suppliers and laborers. If subs and suppliers do not have this payment protection, private owners should be

Three parties to every surety bond When two parties have entered into a construction contract, the owner can require a surety to guarantee the terms of the contract by requiring a surety bond. A surety bond ultimately guarantees that the construction contractor will perform. Every surety bond has three parties: Principal – The construction contractor that has entered into a contract with the project owner (obligee) to perform on a new construction or renovation project. Obligee – The construction project owner that requires the construction contractor (principal) to be bonded. Surety – The corporation engaged in the business of providing surety credit

When you need a surety provider with capacity, expertise and dedication, CNA Surety can show you more. CNA Surety writes more bonds than any other surety company in the world. A survey of producers has voted CNA Surety as the best overall surety bond carrier in the country. PropertyCasualty360’s biennial survey asked more than 400 independent agents to rate 74 insurers and 19 lines of business. CNA Surety was voted the best for its broad portfolio of surety products.

Contact your CNA Surety agent or broker or Kevin Birch at 614/516-2014 kevin.birch@cnasurety.com 8470 Orion Place Ste 300 Columbus, OH 43240 www.cnasurety.com www.propertiesmag.com 33


),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67

prepared for liens being filed if the construction contractor does not pay or is slow to pay subs and suppliers. This bond provides the motivation for the principal to assure that every sub, material supplier and laborers are paid.

Cost of surety bonds Generally there is no cost for bid bonds. If the principal is awarded the contract and performance and payment bonds are required, there is a premium charge at the time of executing the performance and payment bonds. The amount of both the performance and payment bonds are usually for 100% of the contract amount. The actual cost of the bond is based upon the amount of the contract, not the bond amounts. Since the bonds guarantee the scope of work performed according to contract terms and conditions, the amount of the contract is the basis for determining the cost for the surety bond. There are other factors that contribute to the actual cost of surety credit, such

as type of work performed, duration of the contract, maintenance and warranty obligations and the financial wherewithal (balance sheet strength) of the principal. Generally, the cost of surety credit ranges from 0.5% to 3% of the construction contract amount. This is a small price in return for the high level of assurance, security and protection offered to the private owner, lenders, subcontractors and/or suppliers from construction contractor failure.

Management of risk Construction projects present unique risks. Surety bonding is an excellent risk management tool that provides financial security and assurance to the owner. The factors that contribute to contractor failure may have little to do with the risk elements on your specific project. For instance, contractor failure can come from the unbridled risks that the contractor may have acquired through other construction contracts. Subcontractor

failure, being over-extended with other work, death of a shareholder/key staff and strain in cash flow are also contributing factors that could be the reason why a contractor cannot complete a construction project, none of which were known at the start of the construction project. A performance and payment bond, regardless of the reason for contractor failure, provides a high level of financial security and assurance. Lack of a performance and payment bond on a construction project could become a very regrettable decision for the owner. Surety bonds are proven financial instruments that tame the risks associated with construction contractor performance and payment. P Kevin W. Birch is Surety Director for CNA Surety, based in Columbus. He may be reached at kevin.birch@cnasurety.com. The advice in this article is the author’s view of the value of bonding on a construction project and is not to be regarded as providing legal advice.

:H +DYH G H Y R 0

The Atwell team has expanded to the

Independence Corporate Center in Independence. Stop by and check out our new digs!

$7:(//

ϳϭϬϬ ͘ WůĞĂƐĂŶƚ sĂůůĞLJ ZĚ͘ ^ƵŝƚĞ ϮϮϬ /ŶĚĞƉĞŶĚĞŶĐĞ͕ K, ϰϰϭϯϭ

Phone: (440) 349-2000 Fax: (440) 349-2028 www.atwell-group.com

E'/E Z/E' ͮ W> EE/E' ͮ ^hZs z/E' ͮ Es/ZKED Ed > ͮ KE^dZh d/KE D E ' D Ed 34

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


HBA Presents Annual Economic Housing Forecast he Greater Cleveland Association of Home Builders Association (HBA) recently presented its annual Economic Forecast & Vendor Tabletop before a sold-out crowd at Embassy Suites in Independence. The evening included a series of presentations from local experts who offered their predictions for the regional housing market in 2014.

T

New Privately Owned Residential Building Permits Cleveland & Cuyahoga County, Ohio 2500

Building Permits Reported

Speakers included Ohio Home Builders Association (OHBA) President Al Scott, Professor Robert Simons from Cleveland State University and Anna Marie Wiersch, a policy analyst at the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland. There were spirited moments throughout the evening regarding the future of new residential construction – especially when the discussion surrounded building in urban areas versus suburban and rural areas. Professor Robert Simon’s presentation suggested that we are currently heading in the right direction and cited housing statistics that show the demand side for housing and mortgages improving and foreclosures down. In 2011, almost 30% of homeowners were underwater in their mortgages while today that figure stands at only 23.6% according to Zillow. Simon stated that there is still an artificial backlog of foreclosed property and banks are still slow to pick up lending. Both Fannie and Freddie are still in limbo and strengthening house sales will slow rental growth. Professor Simons predicts housing trends will still bounce along the bottom, although 25% to 50% of some regions are partly back, others are more like zero to 15%. Both Professor Simons and Al Scott believe the Cleveland area has a lot to offer: a great geographical location, great universities, world-renowned healthcare, manufacturing and Ohio’s shale boom. In Scott’s presentation, he stated that housing starts in Northeast Ohio are expected to be 2,500 in 2014, and up 7.3% statewide with 17,600 starts in Ohio in 2013. Home prices continue to trend upward and in 2014, 24,800 housing starts are expected, growing that rate to 22%. From a “muddy boots” perspective, Scott says both Cleveland and Akron builders agree that business is doing better and

2000

1500

1000

500

0

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

Single Family in Cuyahoga

1865

1347

1153

807

610

346

312

336

260

350

2013 560

Total in Cuyahoga

1920

1377

1189

825

614

350

314

337

267

359

580

Single Family in Cleveland

372

374

345

253

184

109

87

91

86

110

121

Total in Cleveland

394

398

372

278

200

120

95

99

95

123

136

Building permits for 2013 adjusted by data of the first three quarters. (Source: U.S. Census, 2013)

that sales have increased 20% to 30% in 2013 – with expectations for a 20% increase in 2014, despite difficulties finding lots and qualified labor. Scott also addressed “10 Yellow Caution Flags” builders should be aware of. Among these are regulatory and legislative actions (i.e., flood insur-

shadow inventory; and competition from new builders as the market rebounds. Fielding the majority of the questions at the event, Weirsch of the Federal Reserve stated that the atmosphere for small business lending is contradictory due to the definition of what constitutes a small business. The Small Business Administration (SBA) defines it as fewer than 500 employees while under the Affordable Health Care Act that threshold is 50 – creating conflicting reports as to whether or not lending is improving. Overall tighter lending is still lingering from the recession; however, small business owners are cautiously optimistic for the future. The Federal Reserve continues to examine and elevate small business issues because they account for nearly 50% of all private sector jobs and they are extremely important for the productivity and health of our economy, she noted. P

Housing starts in Northeast Ohio are expected to be 2,500 in 2014, and up 7.3% statewide with 17,600 starts in Ohio in 2013. ance maps, tax reform, GSE reform and codes), interest rates (“watch for quick spikes”) and lot availability (“very low in ‘A’ area”). Also noted were declining homeownership rates and changing views on homeownership, particularly among millennials (18 to 24) with studies showing that only 52% want to buy houses. Scott also says to watch for cost increases (labor, materials and lots);

www.propertiesmag.com 35


),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67

FINANCIAL STRATEGIES Smart use of fiscal planning & action

Are We There Yet? ver the last few years, there has been an ever-increasing number of conversations about the Cleveland investment market returning to normal. Sometimes I am an active participant in these conversations, while other times I’m just a fly on the wall. But the words “normal” and “investment market” are clearly being used in the same sentence with increasing frequency.

O

ALEC J. PACELLA

Webster’s Dictionary defines the word “normal” as usual or ordinary. In reviewing Cleveland’s investment market over the course of 2013, some of the more pronounced trends certainly fit this description. But others clearly have a ways to go. To find out just how usual or ordinary we were, read on.

November, Westfield Group sold a sevenmall portfolio that included the Great Northern Mall, a 1.2 million-square-foot super-regional mall. And after a few attempts in recent years, Duke Realty successfully sold a portion of its Rockside Road office holdings, disposing of a fivebuilding, 630,000-square-foot portfolio at the end of the year.

Headline deals

Variety of deals by size and type

A normal investment market will have a handful of keynote deals each year. These transactions typically involve highprofile properties and help shape the overall definition of a “market transaction.” Considering this trend, Cleveland was normal as we saw several keynote transactions. In June, CalSTRS sold a 28-property portfolio that included 16 local industrial properties encompassing nearly 1.6 million square feet. In

A normal investment market will have a relatively even balance of deals concentrated among the four major food groups of office, industrial, retail and apartment. Considering this trend, the Cleveland market was again normal. Of the 77 total investment sales that occurred in our region last year, 17% were office properties, 22% were industrial properties, 18% were retail properties and 17% were apart-

Custom Reprints Make a Great Impression Did you know you can now order custom reprints of articles originally published in Properties? Imagine the impact of a customized publication – a profile on your company or a project with which you were involved – that can be distributed to your existing and future clients. Use reprints as a proven, effective marketing tool to build your business.

Call 216.849.4350 today for a free quote! 36

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


ment properties. A normal market also will not be strongly weighted toward either smaller or larger deals in terms of price point. Again, of the 77 total transactions, 60% were below a $5 million sale price and 40% were above.

Solid volume of market transactions Single-tenant net lease (STNL) transactions are a very good barometer for the broader investment market. These transactions typically involved motivated buyers and sellers and there are a limited number of outside influences that affect the transaction. A healthy and robust STNL sector is usually indicative of an investment market that is performing normally. Using this measurement, Cleveland can again be considered normal. Last year, the market had 13 STNL transactions, representing 17% of the overall investment transactions. And pricing was strong, with transactions involving credit tenants trading in the 6% to 7% CAP range.

Low level of distressed transactions A normal investment market will have a limited number of sales that involve distressed or non-performing properties. This type of sale can take many forms, including foreclosure, deed in lieu or short sale, among others. This is the first trend in which Cleveland was not so normal. Although the number of transfers involving distressed properties has certainly decreased over the last few years, the market continues to have a noteworthy number of sales that fall into this category. Last year, there were eight such transfers, including the 960,000-squarefoot eastside suburban office portfolio commonly known as the Gotham King portfolio, the 800,000-square-foot Southgate USA regional retail complex and Lakewood Center North, a 260,000-square-foot suburban office building. Several other properties were sold as a part of a larger redevelopment plan. Leading this list was the 1.2 million square foot Ameritrust complex down-

Daus, You Know? GRADING TIME Once again, it’s time to check back on my annual prognostication for Cleveland’s overall sales volume. In last year’s column, I boldly predicted a total investment volume of $800 million – proof that even a blind squirrel is capable of finding an acorn every once in a while. Looking ahead to 2014, I’m going to plant my sales volume flag just a little higher at $825 million. Stay tuned throughout the year to see if I can string together two accurate predictions in a row. –AP town, which is being redeveloped in part as a new home for the Cuyahoga County government. Other properties falling into this category include the 330,000-squarefoot CBD office tower known as 1717 East 9th Street and Rockport Plaza, a 70,000-square-foot suburban retail center.

Viable & competitive debt market The ability to secure a real estate loan at economical terms and from a variety of sources is another characteristic of a normal investment market. Although the Cleveland investment market has made serious strides over the past few years in this regard, obtaining financing can remain a challenge. The largest voids are for deals in the $5 million to $15 million range, (especially if the asset is not an apartment) and for construction loans for speculative new development.

Solid commercial market fundamentals It is difficult for an investment market to perform in a normal manner if the

underpinnings of the broader real estate market are weak. And this is probably the biggest mixed bag for the Cleveland region. Some of the commercial real estate market segments performed very well – apartment vacancy rates have been strong for several years and quality industrial space has become downright scarce. But other segments have languished – the overall suburban office vacancy rate continues to hover around 20% and CBD office space has largely been a shell game, characterized by a lot of lateral moves but very little positive net absorption. New construction remains scant in most sectors and rent growth across the property sectors has been the exception, not the norm. Now it’s time to shake all of these trends up and pour them out. The overall sales volume came in at $791 million last year, which is a solid increase over 2012’s volume of $690 million. The deals were nicely balanced, both amongst property type as well as deal size. Market transactions dramatically outpaced distressed sales. And the drags created by a loosening but still choppy debt market as well as an uneven landscape of real estate fundamentals was not enough to damper overall sales activity. Sounds like the investment market is certainly getting back to normal. P Alec Pacella, CCIM, senior vice president at NAI Daus, can be reached by phone at 216.455.0925 or by email at apacella@naidaus.com. You can follow him on twitter @dausyouknow or on his blog at http://blog.sbequitiesinc.com.

www.propertiesmag.com 37


),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67

LEGAL PERSPECTIVES Navigating property laws & regulations

Expanding Role of State Court Receivers in the Rebirth of Distressed Commercial Properties ourt-appointed receivers, and the property managers they typically employ, can play a decisive role in positioning distressed commercial properties for redevelopment.

C JEFFREY C. TOOLE

The continuing transformation of Parmatown Mall from a tired venue long past its prime into a reconfigured and more vibrant destination, The Shoppes at Parma, illustrates the opportunities that can flow from a carefully managed receivership. Under evolving Ohio law, receivers have numerous powers that, if employed judiciously, can set the stage for a commercial property’s renewal and rebirth.

When a receiver can be appointed The Ohio Revised Code (ORC) authorizes courts to appoint a receiver in various circumstances. Often this occurs in mortgage foreclosure actions. Section 2735.01 of the ORC permits a receiver if (i) the mortgaged property is probably insufficient to pay the mortgage debt and (ii) either the mortgaged property is in danger of loss or material

injury, or the borrower has violated the mortgage. Once appointed, the receiver (and any property manager the receiver employs) assumes control of the mortgaged property and is responsible for collecting its rents, preserving the premises’ condition, and maximizing its value during the foreclosure. The receiver is a neutral and therefore cannot unlawfully favor the lender or other party who sought the receiver’s appointment. Instead, a receiver is an arm of the appointing court and, as such, is an independent fiduciary acting under the court’s supervision.

Positioning assets for redevelopment A receiver derives its powers from the order appointing it. Ohio state courts have broad discretion in deciding how much power to confer upon a receiver.

7,5(' 2) %(,1* 5,33(' 2))"

7KHQ VWRS KLULQJ À\ E\ QLJKW ³URR¿QJ FRQWUDFWRUV´ ZKRVH RQO\ RI¿FH DGGUHVV LV ZKHUHYHU WKHLU SLFN XS WUXFN KDSSHQV WR EH SDUNHG DW WKH WLPH 7KH QR LQVXUDQFH LUUHVSRQVLEOH RSHUDWRUV DUH GULYLQJ WKH IHZ UHPDLQLQJ KRQHVW URR¿QJ FRQWUDFWRUV RXW RI EXVLQHVV 8QOHVV WKH FRQVXPHU JHWV ZLVHU WKHUH ZLOO EH QR TXDOLW\ URRIHUV OHIW :H DUH ORRNLQJ IRU D IHZ ZLVH FRQVXPHUV ,I \RX ¿W WKH ELOO FDOO XV WRGD\

6,1&(

(DVW WK 6WUHHW &OHYHODQG 2+ ZZZ FDUH\URR¿QJ FRP )D[ 38

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


A recent decision from the Ohio Eighth District Court of Appeals, U.S. Bank, N.A. v. Gotham King Fee Owner, LLC, 2013-Ohio-1983 (8th Dist. No. 98618, May 16, 2013), illustrates just how expansive a receiver’s powers can be. It ruled that a trial court can authorize a receiver, for example, to enter into new long-term commercial leases (or modify existing leases) without the borrower’s consent, and to borrow money from the foreclosing lender to make repairs or improvements with only that lender’s approval, if such powers comport with what the borrower agreed (long before) in its original mortgage documents. These and other powers can enable a receiver to stabilize a commercial property’s operations, improve its cash flow, enhance its going concern value, elevate the property’s attractiveness to prospective buyers, and otherwise set the stage for such property’s sale. Apart from powers the appointing court may convey in its orders, Ohio law also gives a receiver certain powers that it can use to resurrect tired commercial properties. A receiver can sue others under the control of the appointing court. This allows a receiver to evict delinquent tenants, to collect unpaid rent or debts, and to seek recovery of property that belongs to the receivership. In addition, some Ohio courts have concluded that, with court approval, a receiver can “reject” pre-receivership leases and contracts (that are not yet fully performed) if they are burdensome or unprofitable. By recovering overdue rent, removing nonpaying tenants to make room for more desirable ones, and shedding burdensome agreements, a receiver can better position a commercial property for redevelopment.

tunity to be heard about a proposed sale and, second, the appointing court approves the terms of the sale. This sale power is critical to attract prospective buyers, because it gives them greater certainty that they can acquire marketable property free of existing encumbrances. As compared to a sheriff’s sale at foreclosure, a receiver’s sale free and clear of liens presents several advantages for lenders and prospective buyers. For example, a receiver’s sale often can be accomplished more quickly. A receiver with the power to market and sell can begin searching for prospective bidders and can elicit potential offers much earlier in the foreclosure litigation. A receiver and its brokers can “beat the bushes” to find strategic buyers interested in revitalizing the asset and who may be willing to pay a better price to acquire it. Unlike a sheriff’s sale, at which bidding typically begins at only 2/3 of the property’s appraised value, a receiver may be able to find a “stalking horse” bidder willing to offer more than

that sum, in exchange for being given protections with court approval (such as expense reimbursement or a “break-up fee”) if the receiver thereafter obtains a higher or better offer from someone else.

Conclusion Receivers’ powers continue to evolve. Since early 2013, the Ohio General Assembly has been considering legislation that would clarify receivers’ powers and would establish uniform procedures for receiver sales “free and clear of liens.” If that legislation is enacted, it may further enhance receivers’ abilities to stabilize distressed commercial properties and prepare them for rebirth. P Buckley King focuses on business reorganizations, troubled loan workouts and receiverships. This article is meant to provide general information only and not as a substitute for legal advice. Readers should seek the advice of their attorney or contact Jeffrey Toole (toole@buckleyking.com; 216.685.4749). This article may not be reprinted without the express permission of Buckley King LPA © 2014.

on time on budget on mark

Asset sales “free and clear of liens” To facilitate redevelopment, perhaps the most striking power a receiver can be granted is the ability to sell property “free and clear of liens,” with valid liens attaching to the sale proceeds for distribution to lien holders or other creditors. The trend among Ohio appellate courts is in favor of granting receivers this power, provided (among other potential requirements) that first all affected lien holders are given notice and an oppor-

Rethink Your Outside Counsel 216.363.1400 I buckleyking.com

CLEVELAND I COLUMBUS I CINCINNATI I ATLANTA I PHOENIX I LAS VEGAS

www.propertiesmag.com 39


),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67

VANTAGE POINT Experts weigh in on industry issues

Reviewing Real Estate Tax Assessments or those of you who pay commercial real estate taxes, the receipt of your 2013 Real Estate Tax Bill may dampen your holiday spirits. These tax obligations, referred to as “ad valorem” taxes in Ohio, are levied against real property according to the County’s assessment of the property’s value; the greater the assessment, the greater the tax obligation.

F

KIP DANZINGER

Importantly, these taxes generally have a significant downward effect on an owner’s investment return or business profits. As a concern, these taxes are based upon the County’s opinion of your property’s market value, which is sometimes formulated with insufficient or unreliable information. However, if you act promptly and follow certain specific procedures, tax relief is available.

First step: Review the County’s assessment Pursuant to state statute, the county auditor or fiscal officer is required to

reappraise or update the values of each parcel of real property located within his/her district every three years. It is imperative for taxpayers to review the assessed values and determine if the values as determined by the County are fair and lawful. This review should include an analysis of the following: • vacancy problems • reduction in income attributed to the property • damage to the property • construction costs for a newly constructed property

Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill, Co., LPA CONTESTING REAL PROPERTY TAX ASSESMENTS IN ALL OF OHIO’S 88 COUNTIES

We help taxpayers maximize property investments by reducing property taxes.

EXPERIENCED LEGAL COUNSEL IN PROPERTY TAX LAW 216.771.8990 | www.sdglegal.net | 820 West Superior Ave., Seventh Floor | Cleveland, OH 44113 40

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


• changing market conditions In addition, taxpayers should review the information utilized by the Counties in performing the assessment and to verify the accuracy of the property information. Some of this information can be obtained by visiting the Counties’ websites.

Next step: Contest the real property tax assessment If a taxpayer concludes that the new assessment is too high resulting in an unfair tax obligation, then Ohio law affords the taxpayer with an opportunity to contest the assessment. To initiate the process, a complaint must be filed with the auditor/fiscal officer in the county in which the property is located. This complaint must be filed by no later than March 31, 2014. With limited exceptions, only one complaint can be filed during the “triennial” period. Although the complaint form appears to be fairly straightforward, many pitfalls exist that render a complaint defective. Therefore, prudence requires contacting an attorney prior to filing a complaint.

Conclusion The following Counties have either updated or reappraised real property values for tax year 2013: Carroll, Champaign, Clark, Fairfield, Logan, Marion, Medina, Miami, Ross, Union, Wyandot, Adams, Columbia, Hancock, Hocking, Holmes, Lawrence, Meigs, Monroe, Paulding, Scioto, Tuscarawas and Washington. The tax assessments in these and all other counties should be carefully reviewed annually to ensure that the assessments and resulting tax obligations are fair, and that the property is not being burdened with an unjust tax obligation. P Robert K. Danzinger, JD is a partner of Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill Co., L.P.A., a law firm with a concentrated practice in assisting real property owners in contesting assessments. Danzinger can be reached by phone (216) 771-8990 or by email at rdanzinger@sdglegal.net.

Precision Environmental has reached our 25th anniversary as an abatement, selective demolition and specialty services company serving Northeast Ohio. Thank you to everyone who has contributed to the success of our company for the past 25 years.

We look forward to working together for many more years to come.

5500 Old Brecksville Road • Independence, OH 44131 216.642.6040 • www.precision-env.com

Are you satisfied with your current investment returns? Is your IRA growing at 11% - 15% per year? Do you have ANY investments worth DOUBLE what you paid for them? YOU CAN...

NOW YOU HAVE A CHOICE! TURNKEY INVESTOR PROPERTIES, A STARK COMPANY offers a unique and effortless way to earn 11%, 12%, 15% annually, starting with a very low minimum investment. Call Brian Stark directly today at 216-310-1470 to learn more! www.turnkeyinvestorproperties.com

“The Stark Group Live!” Talking Real Estate Thursdays at 7 pm on Newstalk 1490 AM WERE www.propertiesmag.com 41


),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67

ACAR CORNER Issues in the real estate industry

Outlining NAR’s Commercial Real Estate Forecast ommercial real estate leasing patterns are showing steady but modest growth, according to the National Association of Realtors (NAR) quarterly commercial real estate forecast.

C

Lawrence Yun, NAR chief economist, projects only modest changes in the coming year, and indicated that jobs are the key driver for commercial real estate, and the accumulation of 7 million net new jobs from the low point a few years ago is steadily showing up as demand for leasing and purchases of properties. However, Yun noted the difficulty of accessing loans remains a hindrance to a faster recovery.

SETH TASK

The gross domestic product rose from 2.5% in the second quarter to 2.9% in the third quarter. NAR’s recent Commercial Real Estate Quarterly Market Survey shows leasing activity rose 2% in the third quarter from the second quarter, and higher sales levels than a year ago. Yun says there have been some shifts in commercial purchases. “Investors have been looking for better yields, and have

! " # $ %

& % '## %%( )%

&*+ % ,- # .+ - .

42

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


found good potential in smaller commercial properties, notably in secondary and tertiary markets,” he says. “Sales of commercial properties costing less than $2.5 million in the third quarter were 11% above a year ago, while prices for smaller properties were 4% above the third quarter of 2012.” Commercial investment in properties costing more than $2.5 million rose 26% from a year ago, while prices for large properties were 9% above the third quarter of 2012. National vacancy rates over the coming year are forecast to decline 0.2% in the office market, 0.6% in industrial, and 0.5% for retail real estate. The average multifamily vacancy rate will edge up 0.1%, but that sector continues to see the tightest availability and biggest rent increases. NAR’s latest Commercial Real Estate Outlook offers overall projections for four major commercial sectors and analyzes quarterly data in the office, industrial, retail and multifamily markets. Historic data for metro areas were provided by REIS, Inc.

Office markets Vacancy rates in the office sector are expected to decline from a projected 15.6% in the fourth quarter to 15.4% in the fourth quarter of 2014. The markets with the lowest office vacancy rates presently (in the fourth quarter) are New York City, with a vacancy rate of 9.8%; Washington, D.C., at 9.9%; Little Rock, Arkansas, 12.0%; and Nashville, Tennessee, 12.9%. To compare, the office vacancy rate in the greater Cleveland area is 23.8%. Office rents should increase 2.4% this year and 2.5% in 2014. Net absorption of office space in the U.S., which includes the leasing of new space coming on the market as well as space in existing properties, is seen at 32.2 million square feet this year and 46.1 million in 2014.

Industrial markets Industrial vacancy rates are likely to fall from 9.2% in the fourth quarter of this year to 8.6% in the fourth quarter of 2014.

The areas with the lowest industrial vacancy rates currently are Orange County, California, with a vacancy rate of 3.9%; Los Angeles, 4.0%; Miami, 6.0%; and Seattle at 6.3%. Locally, we are seeing a 9.0% vacancy rate for industrial. Annual industrial rents are expected to rise 2.3% this year and 2.5% in 2014. Net absorption of industrial space nationally is anticipated at 97.0 million square feet in 2013 and 104.9 million next year.

Retail markets Retail vacancy rates are forecast to decline from 10.4% in the fourth quarter of this year to 9.9% in the fourth quarter of 2014. Presently, markets with the lowest retail vacancy rates include Fairfield County, Connecticut, at 3.9%; San Francisco, 4.0%; and Long Island, New York, 5.2%. Retail vacancy in the Cleveland metropolitan area is at 15.3%. Average retail rents should increase 1.4% in 2013 and 2.2% next year. Net absorption of retail space is projected at

11.0 million square feet in 2013 and 18.1 million next year.

Multifamily markets The apartment rental market – multifamily housing – is likely to see vacancy rates edge up 0.1% point from 3.9% in the fourth quarter to 4.0% in the fourth quarter of 2014, with new construction helping to meet higher demand. As a rule, vacancy rates below 5% are considered a landlord’s market, with demand justifying higher rent. Cleveland’s multifamily vacancy rate is 3.1%. Average apartment rents are forecast to rise 4.0% this year and 4.3% in 2014. Multifamily net absorption is projected to total 239,400 units in 2013 and 211,300 next year. The Commercial Real Estate Outlook is published by the NAR Research Division. NAR’s Commercial Division, formed in 1990, provides targeted products and services to meet the needs of the commercial market and constituency within NAR. For more info or to find a Realtor, visit www.cabor.com or call (216) 901-0130. As always, our staff is happy to assist with any questions you may have. P

Seth Task is the President of the Akron Cleveland Association of Realtors (ACAR). For more information, visit www.CABOR.com.

COMMERCIAL & RESIDENTIAL SPECIALISTS Full service for residential and commercial real estate transactions including: Title Insurance, For Sale By Owner Packages, Closing and Escrow and Home Builder Services, including:

1031 Exchange Services Limited Lien Searches

MENTOR 8500 Station St., Ste 285, Mentor, OH 44060 440.974.8242 CLEVELAND 2077 E. 4th St., Cleveland, Ohio 44115 216.325.0400

www.lakecountytitle.com www.propertiesmag.com 43


),1$1&,$/ 5(9,(: )25(&$67

NAIOP NEWS Commercial real estate happenings

NAIOP’s 2013 Year in Review + Looking Forward in ‘14 hank you to Properties Magazine for its steadfastness and support in bringing awareness of NAIOP to the Northeast Ohio real estate and business community. Your commitment to providing exposure to our organization’s people and programming has, once again been tremendous.

T

AMY WHITACRE

Special thank you to Phill Badalamenti, with Herschman Architects, for his continue support and dedication in producing our NAIOP column within Properties. I am also very thankful for both the NAIOP board and the membership who together helped us achieve many great things in 2013 including:

Developer’s Showcase Amongst this year’s greatest achievements was the planning and execution of the inaugural Developer’s Showcase, a collaboration between the public and private sectors that included a panel of national real estate professionals, a vendor marketplace and tours of the new EY tower. The event began with Mayor Frank Jackson welcoming guests and highlighting the city, its growth and planned growth under his leadership. Brian Tucker of Crain’s Business moderated a panel consisting of both Site Selectors and Capital Markets professionals from outside Ohio. After a tour of the region, these pro-

44

fessionals shared their insight into our market’s strengths and weaknesses in order to relate what we could do better as a region to recruit and retain corporations to further economic growth. This event could not have happened without a team of committee volunteers: Doug Miller (Skye Group), Vince Adamus (Greater Cleveland Partnership), Mark Panzica (Panzica Construction), Scott McCready (Cardno ATC), Suzanne Hamilton (First Federal of Lakewood), Alex Russo (CRESCO Real Estate) and Neil Viny (Dalad Group). A special thanks to the Pittsburgh NAIOP chapter, a predecessor for this event, for their guidance and support in helping us achieve the success we did.

Membership We also set a goal to expand our membership to include more real estate professionals from Akron as well as civic organizations including Greater Cleveland Partnership, Team NEO, Port of Cleveland and Downtown

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


Cleveland Alliance. Membership Chair Erin Ryan, Atwell Group and her committee, Rob Weeks with Cleveland Construction, Lynn Bayer of TDA and Doug Miller put together this year’s unique and creative networking event. We kicked off this year’s mixer with a lively and entertaining band consisting of musicians from the real estate community. We followed that with a mixer held at the Akron law office of Roetzel and wrapped up the year with a great mixer in Fairlawn.

Education Our year included two special events, each featuring national experts in their respective fields. Gene Reilly, president of Prologis Americas and the 2013 NAIOP National Chairman, spoke to over 50 members about the impact NAIOP had on him, personally and professionally. Later in the year, we had the great pleasure of welcoming Doug Duncan, chief economist with Fannie Mae in D.C. This event afforded the 75 members who attended a glimpse into the national real estate economy with the opportunity to ask questions. This particular event also became an example of how multiple, like-minded organizations could work together to bring an event such as this to fruition. NAIOP collaborated with a number of organizations, including GCMBA and CREW Cleveland, which allowed us to leverage our strengths, talents and financial capabilities. Thank you to JR Fairman, of Jones Lang LaSalle, the chair of the Education committee, for organizing these events. This year’s final event was a Core Law continuing Education class taught by Mike Sikora

Charities, Social Events & Media NAIOP’s 19th Annual Charity Golf Classic, chaired by Evan Klotzman of Alpha Park and Neo Park, was another great success. This sold-out event at Weymouth Country Club raised nearly $15,000 for a number of local charities and programs. Many of the charity recipients who attended this year’s holiday party noted how the gifts specifically allowed them to fill mission critical initiatives. On October 12, NAIOP members swung hammers, axes, dug holes and hung fences in a Habitat

for Humanity event, organized by Bryan Dardis, of Meyers Roman Law Firm. In September the Fall Event Committee, co-chaired by Anna Dotson (American Interiors + Knoll) and Julie White (The King Group), organized a fantastic networking event at the Oak Barrel in Valley View. Big congratulations to the Social Media committee, comprised of Ryan Rivchun of the Rivchun Law Firm, Evan Klotzman and Scott McCready, for the completion of our website, available at www.naiopnorthernohio.com. Great job!

Public Affairs Our chapter continued to represent the Northeast Ohio Development community at the local, state, regional and federal levels, advocating for legislation to improve our ability to do our work. Amongst the committee’s more important work is the tracking of bills, some of which are noted below: • HB5 Municipal Corporations Income Tax (to revise the laws governing income taxes imposed by municipal corporations) • HB 198 Tax Increment Financing (establishing procedures to notify property owners within political subdivisions with respect to utilizing TIF’s) • HB358 Joint Economic Development Zone Contracts (to institute mandatory 90 day moratoriums on the authority of townships and municipal corporations to approve JED zone and district contracts)

Developing Leaders We had another successful year with the Mentorship program. Led again by Past Presidents Amy Regal (Erie Title Agency) and Mark Polansky (Crescendo Commercial Realty), this year’s group consisted of eight young real estate professionals eager to engage and learn from senior executives and owners. This year’s mentors were Spencer Pisczak (Premier Development Partners) and Jim Doyle (Hemingway Development). Events were held several times throughout the year with great feedback from both the mentors and those they mentored. I am proud to mention that our chapter won the National Chapter Merit Award – Developing Leader, Small Chapter award in Washington, D.C.

In closing A very special thank you to Jeff Wherry, Donna Haders, Maureen Leech and the staff at Wherry Associates, who worked behind the scenes to make sure that all of the events and programs were a success. We couldn’t have done it without you! Finally, thank you to the NAIOP Northern Ohio Chapter for the opportunity to serve as the 2013 chapter president. It has been such a pleasure working with all of you and I wish you the very best in 2014. For information on upcoming events, sponsorship opportunities and other information please visit our website at www.naiopnorthernohio.com or you can contact Donna Haders at 440-8990010 or djh@wherryassoc.com. P

Amy Whitacre (awhitacre@firstam.com) is Vice President at First American Title Company and 2013 NAIOP Northern Ohio President.

Congratulations to

CECILIA HYUN, ESQ. of Siegel Jennings Co., L.P.A. CREW Cleveland’s 2013 Member of the Year! www.propertiesmag.com 45


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans

departments to maximize client savings. Prior to joining CBRE, he was associated with Community Development Trust where he had a longstanding role in supporting all loan production activity for CDT’s Chicago-based team. He was responsible for approving more than $150 million of financing that resulted in over $620 million in new construction of more than 7,000 units.

BioCellar at Château Hough Breaks Ground round was broken recently for the innovative BioCellar, which will be located at 1650 E. 66th St. in Cleveland, adjacent to The Vineyards of Château Hough. Conceived of by biologist Jean Loria of Upstream Permaculture, and designed by “green” architect Rob Donaldson, the BioCellar utilizes the basement of an abandoned home that was recently demolished to create a year-round underground growing environment in the baseBioCellar at Château Hough ment. The basement will be capped with a passive solar greenhouse structure that will help to maintain a constant temperature suitable for crop propagation inside the structure without the need for any additional source of heat. Outside solar panels will provide needed electricity, and excess power will be sold back to the grid. Rain gardens will be incorporated into the surrounding landscaping to prevent water runoff, and all rainwater that falls off the roof of the BioCellar will be harvested for filtration and irrigation. Other state-of-the-art “green” techniques will be incorporated into the facility for educational demonstrations and community use. Don Laster of ALLS Construction is the general contractor, and Mansfield Frazier of Neighborhood Solutions is the project manager. Currently the sandstone walls of the existing basement are undergoing tuck pointing and strengthening, a drainage system is being installed underground, and above grade construction has begun. The facility is scheduled to open in March of 2014, weather permitting.

Rendering courtesy of Neighborhood Progress

G

CBRE Welcomes Bitar CBRE recently announced the appointment of Bryant Bitar as an associate at its Cleveland office focusing on office and retail properties.

Bitar has been involved in commercial real estate since 2004. During that time, he has worked in various sectors of the business, including property management, construction and estimating,

Fallon Joins CT Consultants

asset acquisition/disposition, leasing and development. Bitar strategically manages the commercial real estate requirements of owners, tenants, city officials and economic development

CT Consultants, Inc. recently announced the addition of Eric M. Fallon, P.E. to its staff. Fallon joins CT Consultants as senior project engineer in the firm’s Fairlawn office. His responsibilities will include project management, staff supervision and overall client relationship management. Fallon brings over 15 years experience as a civil engineer. He is experienced in water treatment and distribution, wastewater treatment and

Where does your business fit? Call Properties now at 216.251.0035 today to book your ad in these upcoming Special Sections. FEBRUARY

MARCH

APRIL

LANDSCAPING The latest information in a growing field, from how to create curb appeal for your property to selecting the best maintenance and outdoor lighting contractor.

LEGAL SERVICES A special look at the real estate lawyers that help create & manage projects behind the scenes.

ROOFING/BUILDING ENVELOPE An overall report on managing exterior systems, from new roofing, window & wall products to the design & implementation of maintenance programs.

AD CLOSE: Friday, January 24

AD CLOSE: Tuesday, February 25

TECHNOLOGY An overview of game-changing software & hardware tools, from BIM to smartphone apps.

AD CLOSE: Tuesday, March 25

For info on advertising & editorial opportunities, call 216.251.0035 or email kkrych@propertiesmag.com. View the 2014 Media Planner at www.propertiesmag.com. 46

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


Painting

Managedwith Properties

Call today today for a free Call free estimate estimate 216.823.0064 or 800.GoCerta 216.823.0064 www.certapro.com cleveland.certapro.com

216.662.5200 chassvecinc@brightdsl.net

7KH %XLOGLQJ 2ZQHUV 0DQDJHUV $VVRFLDWLRQ RI *UHDWHU &OHYHODQG

<RXU 0RQH\ DYLQJ 5HVRXUFH zŽƵƌ ŝŶǀĞƐƚŵĞŶƚ ŝŶ KD 'ƌĞĂƚĞƌ ůĞǀĞůĂŶĚ ƉƌŽǀŝĚĞƐ ƐŝŐŶŝĮĐĂŶƚ ƌĞƚƵƌŶƐ ƚŽ LJŽƵ ĂŶĚ LJŽƵƌ ĐŽŵƉĂŶLJ͛Ɛ ďŽƩŽŵ ůŝŶĞ͘ DĞŵďĞƌ͛Ɛ ƌĞĐĞŝǀĞ ƐƵďƐƚĂŶƟĂů ƐĂǀŝŶŐƐ ĨŽƌ ƚŚĞ ĨŽůůŽǁŝŶŐ ŝƚĞŵƐ ĂŶĚ ƐĞƌǀŝĐĞƐ͗ ŝƌ &ŝůƚĞƌƐ x x ůĞĐƚƌŝĐŝƚLJ ^ƵƉƉůLJ x EĂƚƵƌĂů 'ĂƐ ^ƵƉƉůLJ x tŽƌŬĞƌƐ ŽŵƉĞŶƐĂƟŽŶ /ŶƐƵƌĂŶĐĞ >ĂŵƉƐ͕ ĂůůĂƐƚƐ Θ ůĞĐƚƌŝĐĂů ^ƵƉƉůŝĞƐ x x ŶĚ ŵĂŶLJ ŽƚŚĞƌ ŝƚĞŵƐ Θ ƐĞƌǀŝĐĞƐ͊ x WĂŝŶƚ Θ ZĞůĂƚĞĚ ^ƵƉƉůŝĞƐ

&DOO DERXW PHPEHUVKLS DQG VWDUW VDYLQJ WRGD\

dŚĞ ŵŝƐƐŝŽŶ ŽĨ ƚŚĞ ƵŝůĚŝŶŐ KǁŶĞƌƐ Θ DĂŶĂŐĞƌƐ ƐƐŽĐŝĂƟŽŶ ŽĨ 'ƌĞĂƚĞƌ ůĞǀĞůĂŶĚ ŝƐ ƚŽ ƉƌŽǀŝĚĞ ĂĚǀŽĐĂĐLJ͕ ƉƌŽĨĞƐƐŝŽŶĂů ĚĞǀĞůŽƉŵĞŶƚ͕ ŶĞƚǁŽƌŬŝŶŐ ĂŶĚ ĞĐŽŶŽŵŝĐ ƐĂǀŝŶŐƐ ŽƉƉŽƌƚƵŶŝƟĞƐ ĨŽƌ ŝƚƐ ŵĞŵďĞƌƐ͘

ϮϬϬ WƵďůŝĐ ^ƋƵĂƌĞ͕ ^ƵŝƚĞ ϮϬϵ͕ ůĞǀĞůĂŶĚ͕ KŚ ϰϰϭϭϰ ǁǁǁ͘ďŽŵĂĐůĞǀĞůĂŶĚ͘ŽƌŐ ƉŚ͗ Ϯϭϲ͘ϱϳϱ͘ϬϯϬϱ www.propertiesmag.com 47


All Things Concrete – Your Commercial & Decorative Total Concrete Solution

J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc. • Commercial Buildings • Construction Sites • Special Event Clean-Up • Concrete Cleaning • Carpet Cleaning • Window Cleaning • Wall Washing An Equal Opportunity Employer

21ST CENTURY CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION INC. 13925 Enterprise Ave. Cleveland, OH 44135

• Acoustical Ceilings

1230 East Schaaf Road Brooklyn Heights, OH 44131

216.362.0900

216-749-1150

www.21stcenturyconcrete.com

www.jvjanitorial.com

Commercial Window Systems ...You Can Count on

Q Save Energy Q Improve Appearance

Q Increase Year-round Comfort Q Less Maintenance

www.commercial-windows.com Call for a free window consultation: Gordon M. Priemer at 216.621.4277 ext 207 2800 Euclid Avenue | Cleveland, OH 44115 | www.jamiesonricca.com 48

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans

collection, and stormwater projects. He has experience completing detailed analysis and evaluations for preliminary design, project feasibility, and inflow/infiltration studies and performing detailed design projects ranging from small utility work to large pumping station and treatment plant improvements. He is a registered engineer in Ohio and graduated from the University of Akron.

Finkler & Co. Welcomes Two New Associates Finkler & Company, CPA’s recently announced the addition of Rosalee Hetzel as firm administrator and Kim Seeley, CPA, as senior associate.

Rosalee Hetzel

Kim Seeley

Hetzel brings 17 years of experience in public accounting to her new role, including nine years as firm administrator for a regional accounting firm. Her responsibilities will include overseeing all administrative activities of the firm, as

well as other accounting and bookkeeping responsibilities. She holds an associate’s degree in accounting from Bryant & Stratton Business Institute, is an active member of St. Joseph’s Church in Strongsville, and a volunteer with Achievement

Serving Northeast Ohio For Over 60 Years! Residential Ŷ Commercial Ŷ Industrial Ŷ Institutional

Expert Brick Matching and Complete Inventory of Brick, Block, Masonry, Cast & Natural Stone, Plaster Products & Tools

9005 Woodland Ave., Cleveland, OH 44104 216.791.9800 Ŷ www.bruderinc.com

Centers for Children’s Camp Cheerful and animal rescue organizations in the area. Seeley graduated Magna Cum Laude from Sonoma State University with a Bachelor of Science degree in Business Administration. He has four years of experience in the field of accounting, most recently as senior accountant at Trinchero Family Estates in Napa, California.

BEC Cleveland Launches Corporate Membership Coming on the heels of a successful first year of operation, the Building Enclosure Council (BEC) Cleveland has launched a new membership category, Corporate

)DEULFDWLRQ ,QVWDOODWLRQ 6HUYLFH LQ \HDUV U H Y RU R OL]LQJ I 6SHFLD RS U G URRIW H J D RW ZDWH N F K 3D LQJ ¥ VWHDP DWLRQ ZHOG V U H O L R % ULF HWDO IDE ZHOGLQJ P W H H K 6 ULFDWLRQ E D I F L W W 3ODV HHULQJ DUWPHQ Q S L H J G Q H H 9DOXHG H PDLQWHQDQF UYLF )XOO VH

ZZZ OLVFRKYDF FRP 6WDWH 5G 1 5R\DOWRQ 2+ www.propertiesmag.com 49


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans

Membership, to augment education and training of facilities staffs at large corporate and institutional entities in Northeast Ohio; provide a safe venue where users and practitioners such as architects, engineers, enclosure consultants, material manufacturers, code officials and contractors can exchange ideas, learn new practices, products and services; enable networking with other facility professionals to foster exchange of ideas, tips and discuss benchmarking of respective operations; and provide CEUs/HSWs and other relevant learning credits required for professional certification. “BEC-CLE welcomes Cleveland Clinic as our first Corporate Member,” says

Co-Chair Ed Taylor. “We are looking forward to have the Clinic staff to be among our regular attendees and we appreciate their support of our chapter.” Corporate membership is open to all companies with in-house facilities organization looking to stay current on fast changing building enclosure technologies. An annual fee of $500 includes number of benefits including full participation of five members at BEC-CLE technical programs which are scheduled five to six times a year except summer.

Lorain County Chamber of Commerce Appoints President The Lorain County Chamber of Commerce

Anthony Gallo

Board of Directors has announced the appointment of Anthony (Tony) Gallo to President effective January 1, 2014. Gallo now serves as the chief executive and administrative officer of the Chamber, primarily overseeing the development of

programs and policies that will best serve the Chamber and its 650 members. He will be responsible for functions critical to the success of the Chamber, including strategic and long-range planning, research, budget management and supervision of staff. Gallo previously served as the Chamber’s director of business development, a position he held for more than 10 years since joining the organization in 2003. In this role, Gallo served as a member liaison and was also responsible for membership development, promoting Chamber benefits to existing and prospective members, and planning special events. P

BETWEEN THE WEATHER & YOU SINCE 1922

WARREN ROOFING WARREN ROOFING AND INSULATING COMPANY

Working directly with manufacturers to provide efficient, reliable service and installation of a complete selection of roof systems, from single-ply to solar & green roofing. ABOVE ALL... WE ARE THE ROOFING PROFESSIONALS

Commercial/Industrial Roofing + Architectural Sheet Metal 50

440.439.4404

Fax 440.439.7523

www.warrenroofing.com 3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


<HDUV RI 0DN J Q L W D U LQJ &HOHE Complete Glass Experts Family-Owned & Operated for 60 years! Specializing in: • Commercial Glass and Glazing • Aluminum Doors & Storefronts • Custom Sandblasted “Etched” Glass with Clearshield • Bullet Resistant Glass & Polycarbonate • Custom Frameless Shower Doors, Mirrors & Glass Table Tops

Free Commercial Estimates 24 Hour-Board-Up Service phone 216-621-1971 | fax 216-621-6602 www.sandgloglass.com 2316 St. Clair Avenue | Cleveland, Ohio 44114

&OHYHODQG +RUVHVKRH &DVLQR

:LQGRZ ILOP FRXOG VDYH PLOOLRQ EDUUHOV RI RLO LQ MXVW RQH VWDWH ,PDJLQH WKH LPSDFW 6XQWURO FRXOG PDNH LQ 1RUWKHDVW 2KLR $FFRUGLQJ WR WKH &(& ZLQGRZ ILOP QHHGV WR EH FRQVLGHUHG DV DQ LPSRUWDQW UHWURILW VROXWLRQ DV ZH XSJUDGH OHJDF\ EXLOGLQJV ,QIRUPDWLRQ SURYLGHG E\ WKH ,QWHUQDWLRQDO :LQGRZ )LOP $VVRFLDWLRQ

6 8 1 7 5 2 / &DUO % 6WRNHV )HGHUDO &RXUWKRXVH

7KH /HDGHU ,Q (QYLURQPHQWDO 'HVLJQHU *ODVV )LOP ZZZ VXQWURO FRP

/LPD /LEUDU\

&RPPHUFLDO ƒ 5HVLGHQWLDO ƒ 5HWDLO /((' &RQWULEXWLQJ 3URGXFWV 6HUYLQJ 2KLR )RU 0RUH 7KDQ <HDUV www.propertiesmag.com 51


Opened for Business Renovation transforms former health center into spacious new Equity Trust headquarters By Doug Bardwell | Photos by Jim Maguire

fter experiencing dramatic growth in the last three years, Equity Trust Company needed to consolidate operations. The company wanted an inspiring building to attract and retain the best and brightest minds for its alternative investments business.

A

When the former 73,000-square-foot Cleveland Clinic site near the corner of Crocker Road and Clemens Road in Westlake became available, the company recognized this was the location for them. Fast-forward 16 months, and an extensive $16 million renovation effort by Infinity Construction and architectural firm Vocon has turned the former Westlake Family Health Center into Equity Trust’s impressive new headquarters building.

Company background Richard Desich founded several businesses in the Northeast Ohio area dating back to 1974. Desich was a pioneer in utilizing real estate as an IRA asset and 52

became well known across the country for this service. By 1996, the company had customers in all 50 states. In 2001, Equity Trust Company was formed and, until 2009, was primarily retail-focused, acquiring customers one investor at a time. With an acquisition of Sterling Trust in 2009, the company expanded into the institutional market, working with approximately 10,000 financial advisors, which would see a tripling of customers in three years to now over 130,000 clients. Equity’s customers can now diversify their portfolios with combinations of notes, deeds of trust, real estate, private placements, tax liens, foreign currency, ad infinitum. As a national leader in

self-directed IRAs and 401(k)s, with over $12 billion of retirement plan assets under administration, the firm decided it was time to bring all of its operations under one roof within a new headquarters building. The Desich family, with deep ties to Lorain County, first looked throughout Elyria for the right building. Berea came next and then downtown Cleveland. While many 100,000-square-foot manufacturing buildings were available, none seemed to be the type of facility that would attract the next generation of elite employees and management level personnel that the company needed. The Westlake facility was not only the perfect building for the company’s 3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


INFINITY CONSTRUCTION CONGRATULATES EQUITY TRUST ON ITS NEW CORPORATE HEADQUARTERS AND IS PROUD TO HAVE SERVED AS ITS CONSTRUCTION MANAGER

GENERAL CONTRACTING | CONSTRUCTION MANAGEMENT | CONSULTING

www.propertiesmag.com 53


Proud to have provided exterior curtain wall, windows & composite panels at Equity Trust Headquarters. Congratulations to Equity Trust & Infinity Construction.

& *

CARROLL GLASS Since 1967, we have provided a wide variety of products and services, including curtain walls, storefronts, windows, composite panels, architectural aluminum products, and all types of doors and hardware.

216-261-4965 www.carrollglass.com • info@carrollglass.com • 21721 Tungsten Rd., Euclid, OH 44117


MAKING SPACE With the incorporation of a new glass skylight, the atrium now allows light all the way to the lowest level with progressively larger floor openings as you go down each floor.

vision, but also offered a great location right off the I-90/Crocker exit and free parking as well – needed for the anticipated 400-plus employees who would occupy the building.

Project delivery model Before entering into contract on the property, Equity hired Project Management Consultants (PMC) as owner’s representative. Starting in August 2012, Steven Zannoni, director for PMC, realized that the only way to assure the owner’s aggressive schedule would be to use a Construction Management at Risk with a guaranteed maximum price (GMP). “Having used this method very successfully with Vocon on the Goodyear Headquarters and Infinity on the Warrensville Heights YMCA, we could recommend them both unequivocally,” Zannoni says. When pushing ahead so aggressively, this model requires a great deal of trust between all parties. “Equity was the perfect owner for this model of delivery,” Zannoni says. “They really embraced the concept and were terrific to work with. That enabled us to start planning all the logistics with Infinity by November 1.” Michael A. Dea, president and CFO of Equity Trust, agrees. “I think we knew right from the start that all our personalities were going to work well together,” he says. By November, the team was already beginning to pre-visualize the entire project calendar.

The plans begin Michael Christ, project architect for Vocon, recalls that the firm was retained to perform a facility assessment on the property in October 2012. At the time, Equity was operating with facilities in Elyria, Berea and Waco, Texas. The operation in Texas was relocated to the Cleveland area in November 2013, so additional space was needed for approximately 100 employees. Neither the Elyria or Berea buildings could accommodate that number of people, so temporary space was needed. The goal then was to be in the new, consolidated facility as quickly as possible.

“Based upon one rendering of the exterior and a site plan, we put together the required development plan for submission to the Westlake Planning Department in early December 2012, with the hopes of preliminary approval in January of 2013,” Christ says. “Final drawings were submitted to the City, and for bidding, at the end of March.” “We began very preliminary budget forecasting in December,” says Jim

Fantozzi, vice-president of operations at Infinity Construction Inc. and project manager for this project. “To make the very aggressive schedule of six months, Infinity worked with Carroll Glass in preordering glass, which meant guaranteeing dimensions before openings were ever created. The order went out in late spring 2013.” As Dea recalls, a surprise awaited Equity on day one. www.propertiesmag.com 55


CLEAR OUTLOOK The lower level of the atrium provides an open seating area. At the building entry level, the atrium is surrounded by glass railings with a slim stainless steel cap.

“I’ll never forget the first day I took possession of the keys for the building’” he says. “I went in to get the elevator identification information for the architect. Meeting with the elevator mechanic, he proceeded to show me that the pits had flooded and immediate work was needed.” Some emergency repairs were completed and exploratory demolition was begun in March. At the beginning of June, plans and specifications were approved by the City

and construction work began in earnest. By then, there were only six months remaining to complete $16 million worth of a complete exterior and interior renovation that the owners wanted for occupancy by December 9, 2013.

No time to waste The adjacent parcel was also purchased to enable expansion and to create more parking for all the anticipated employees. The combined site grew to

16.3 acres. However, several things did not work in the project’s favor. Fantozzi discovered that the existing site was a combination of shale and unstable soils, requiring extensive site rehabilitation in which over 5,700 tons of stone were needed for fill. Fortunately, 1,800 tons of stone were recycled from demolished concrete on site. Transforming a former clinic into wide-open office space necessitated the entire gutting of the building.

2TQWF VQ DG RCTV QH VJG VGCO YKVJ +PHKPKV[ %QPUVTWEVKQP CV 'SWKV[ 6TWUV JGCFSWCTVGTU

CONTAINER SERVICE, INC.

¸;OL 3LHKLY PU *VU[HPULY :LY]PJL¹ -), *:) ,+., *,9;0-0,+

>>> 7,;,(5+7,;,05* *64 56

@6<9 *65:;9<*;065 :7,*0(30:;: .9,,5 3,,+ 7961,*;: @(9+ -965; 36(+ *65;(05,9: @(9+ 96336-- *65;(05,9: 3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


“Before we were a month into the project, the owners agreed that everything would be removed and replaced,” recalls Fantozzi. “We pulled out 86 40-yard dumpsters from the interior demo and another 27 40-yard dumpsters with the exterior cladding and glazing. From just steel studs alone, we were able to recycle over 14 tons of metal.” By gutting the space, new mechanical and electrical equipment could be brought in, often in a fraction of the space of the old systems. With less than seven weeks until completion, a prep kitchen and cafeteria were added to the project. “The downside to the last-minute change was that we had to tear into

&RQJUDWXODWLRQV WR (TXLW\ 7UXVW DQG ,QÀQLW\ &RQVWUXFWLRQ :H DUH SOHDVHG WR KDYH FRQWULEXWHG WR WKH VXFFHVV RI WKLV SURMHFW & / ( 9 ( / $ 1 ' _ & 2 / 8 0 % 8 6 _ & 5 $ 1 % ( 5 5 < 7 : 3

%$5%(5 +2))0$1 % & 2 1 6 8 /7 , 1 * ( 1 * , 1 ( ( 5 6

( WK 6W &OHYHODQG 2+ _ _ EDUEHUKRIIPDQ FRP

“Scheduling and trade coordination became a paramount issue... Our subs were terrific to work with. We couldn’t have kept to our schedule without their cooperation.” Jim Fantozzi Infinity Construction Inc. some completed work and now we had to work through an area that was already completed,” Fantozzi says. “Scheduling and trade coordination became a paramount issue. We were having job meetings on a daily basis and our subs were terrific to work with. We couldn’t have kept to our schedule without their cooperation.”

Congratulations,

Is that a new building? Driving past the site in early July, with all the glass removed, motorists on I-90 could easily mistake it for the skeleton of a new building on the site. Before installing the new exterior envelope, some alterations were added to the scope. A cube-shaped addition on the east creates a new entry portal, and the entire façade was re-imagined to project the contemporary and forward-thinking nature of the client. The building was clad with a combination of composite panels, storefront windows and glass curtain walls accenting all four corners. The south side of the building now provides a large patio, which was sunken into the southeast corner of the building and involved mass excavation and utility relocation.

Equity Trust, on your spectacular new headquarters. PMC is proud to have been a part of the Equity Trust Team as Owner’s Representative.

Partnering For Success www.propertiesmag.com 57


WAYS TOWARD WELLNESS An open stair connects the ground floor to the atrium’s lower level, where employees can enjoy the fresh food café called Sprout, a workout room, a yoga studio and a massage therapy room.

This area, where the former service dock was located, is for employees to enjoy in warmer weather. The building took on an entirely new look with a combination of aluminum and charcoal tones. The darker panels on the entry “cube” contrast nicely with the lighter tones framing it and the blue Equity Trust signage above. All glazing is bluish grey. A series of color-changing LED strip lights add a decorative punch as you enter the cube. Inside, not only were all the partitions removed, the atrium walls were opened up as well. With the incorporation of a new glass skylight, the atrium now allows light all the way to the lowest level with progressively larger floor openings as you go down each floor. As the removal and replacement 58

of the old skylight took place, a 50-foot by 50-foot tent was installed on the roof over the opening to provide protection to the interior for the duration of the work. Heavily engineered and ballasted, it withstood even the monsoon-like storms Cleveland experienced in 2013. In the center of the atrium, original colored cast glass “clouds” are suspended from stainless steel cables and provide a splash of color seen from every floor. A total of 34 multi-colored pieces face every conceivable angle in this piece of art called “Ascend,” by Shan Shan Sheng of San Francisco. A special lift, lowered in by crane, was used to reach the 70-plus feet required to install the artwork, which was completed in a finished environment, just two weeks prior to turnover.

The lower level of the atrium provides an open seating area. At the building entry level, the atrium is surrounded by glass railings with a slim stainless steel cap. All remaining floors have floor-to-ceiling, butt-glazed glass panels at the edge of the atrium, giving an unobstructed view. “The owners were willing to go with this more expensive glazing to make the employees feel that the atrium was actually an integral part of their work area,” Dea says. In the footprint of the building – at 90 feet by 150 feet – and with this large atrium in the middle, virtually all employees enjoy an abundant amount of natural light at their workstations. By utilizing C-shaped and snowflake-shaped, 48-inch-high furniture 3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


systems, light now flows generously throughout the space. “We were looking for maximum collaboration in this new space as we joined three previously separated workforces,” Dea says. Through provisions of the building code, the existing stairs were allowed to remain as is toward the south end of the building, explains Christ. “Equity opted to additionally install an open stair at the north end, connecting floors two through four to connect employee groups and foster collaboration,” he says. To provide smoke control in case of fire, the mechanical systems can exhaust the atrium filled with smoke in just 30 seconds. At the same time, a separate system forces fresh air down through the egress stairwells.

Employee benefits From early on, the owners recognized that the building could be both a productivity- and a morale-booster for those who come here every day. Everything in the building design is intended to meet both goals. Around the perimeter of the building, triangular projections serve as collaboration and meeting spaces. With floor-to-ceiling glass, views are great and invite people to meet and exchange ideas. Each conference area is named after an Ohio landmark or personality. High-backed, colorfully striped banquette seating with leather seat cushions line many corridors, providing more opportunities to sit and compare notes with colleagues. The first floor accommodates reception as well as Finance, Compliance, Audit and Governance departments. Floor two is for Marketing, Sales and IT. Operations occupies the third floor, while the Investment teams are on the fourth floor. On each floor, large cafés make it easy for those who wish to bring their lunch, or meet in an impromptu fashion. Thin ribbons of black, grey and white glass tiles make for an interesting counter-toceiling backsplash. On the lower level, Equity engaged Marigold Catering to develop a new fresh food concept and café called Sprout. All foods are wholesome and a wide variety of good snack options are available throughout the day. The company subsidizes the food offerings

with meals that are under $5 each. Plans are in the works for a takehome food service at the end of the day. The operation is sustainable with 99% of everything being recycled, and composting containers will also be incorporated.

To keep employees informed, large flat screens are placed abundantly throughout the building. They can be programmed to deliver current company messaging and statistics. All meeting rooms have large interactive monitors and white markerboard walls.

Proud to have provided flooring services for the new Equity Trust Headquarters

0HVVLQD )ORRU &RYHULQJ //& Commercial, Institutional & Industrial Floor Covering Provider & Installer Specializing in the healthcare marketplace with the highest quality & best service since 1989. We provide 24/7 service, installation & floor maintenance. Call us today to take advantage of our trained in-house staff and extensive library of product information. Complete line of flooring including: Carpeting • Resilient Flooring, Vinyl & Ceramic Tile • Athletic Floors

Call today for a FREE estimate! 4300 Brookpark Rd., Cleveland, OH 44134 • 216-595-0100 • Toll Free 888-271-8200

3URXG WR SHUIRUP PHWDO VWXGV GU\ZDOO DQG DFRXVWLFDO FHLOLQJV IRU (TXLW\ 7UXVW ZLWK ,QÀQLW\ &RQVWUXFWLRQ

2VERUQH 'ULYH 0HQWRU 2KLR

RSSHQKHLPFRQVWUXFWLRQ FRP www.propertiesmag.com 59


Proud to be part of the team with Infinity Construction for Equity Trust Headquarters.

Proud to be part of the team with Infinity Construction for Equity Trust Headquarters.

Equity Trust Headquarters

X Commercial, Industrial & Institutional X New Installations X Design Assistance X Inspections & Service

Equity Trust Headquarters

X Plumbing X Heating X Air Conditioning X Power & Process Piping X Service

216/361- 5730

216/391-1030

1285 East 49th Street, Cleveland, OH 44114

4975 Hamilton Avenue, Cleveland, Ohio 44114-3972

!30(!,4 0!6).' !30(!,4 2%0!)2 3%!,#/!4).' #2!#+ &),,).' #/-0,%4% 3)4% #/.3425#4)/.

0!6 ) . ' ) . # s %XCELLENT QUALITY COMPETITIVE PRICING RELIABILITY

%8#!6!4)/. 4/ #/-0,%4)/.

s #UNNINGHAM 0AVING IS A FAMILY OWNED BUSINESS WITH OVER YEARS OF EXPERIENCE s ,ICENSED BONDED INSURED s /UR MOTTO h+EEPING OUR CUSTOMERS SATISFIED KEEPS THEM COMING BACK v

* iÊӣȰxn£°nÈää >ÝÊӣȰxn£°nÈnÎ !URORA 2OAD 7ARRENSVILLE (EIGHTS /( 60

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


KEEPING STATS To keep staff informed, large flat screens are placed abundantly throughout the building, including office areas (top) and café seating spaces (bottom). They can be programmed to deliver current company messaging and statistics.

In addition to the food service, a workout room and a bamboo-floored yoga studio have been installed. Plenty of treadmills, bikes and weight machines offer something for everyone. A full-time wellness consultant is on staff to help craft workout routines, while the yoga instructor holds classes for those interested. A separate room is available for chair massages and each employee is given a complimentary number of treatments each year. Outside, a half-mile walking track was paved around the perimeter of the property. Several trees were marked and saved along the path, and throughout the site.

It all worked From the start in June to completion on December 9, over $16 million of work was completed on a tight site. “On average, we had 80 workers on site – sometimes as high as 129,” Fantozzi says. “From start to finish, we had over nine aerial lifts, three lulls and many pieces of excavating equipment taking up every available area around the building. We worked six-day workweeks to make our deadline.” Looking back on the project, Zannoni compares this to the success PMC brought to the Global Center for Health Innovation and Cleveland Convention Center, completed in 2013. “Our team was able to facilitate pre-construction services, contract negotiations and even coordination of

the multiple employee relocations to bring this all together as the owner wanted,” Zannoni says. The building is getting high marks from its new inhabitants. “I’m already impressed with how quiet the building

is,” relates Dea. “It’s hard to believe almost 400 hundred people are working in here. The site is fantastic and we think the Westlake location is very conducive to the people we are trying to attract. We couldn’t be happier.” P

www.propertiesmag.com 61


Natural Fit Adaptive reuse project creates new EnviroScience headquarters in Stow By Mark Watt | Photos by Jim Maguire

wo years ago, Stow-based EnviroScience was hunting for a larger facility to house its growing operations – and finding a right-sized home was proving difficult for the highly specialized company.

T

“We’re a niche business,” says Martin Hilovsky, founder and partner. “We knew we wouldn’t fit into a typical industrial park or office building.” Founded in 1989, the business provides a range of environmental services, including bioassay water toxicity analysis for municipalities and industries, ecological consulting and restoration, commercial diving, wetlands delineation, stream restoration, biological surveys and species assessments. It also provides emergency response to ecological disasters, such as train derailments and oil spills. As Hilovsky notes, his company demands plenty of office and lab space to operate, but also warehouse space to store boats and diving equipment. Its team of more than 50 biologists works at computers at times, and sometimes outside, knee-deep in field grass and marshes. Although it wasn’t a perfect fit, the company had located a boxy warehouse in nearby Cuyahoga Falls and started space planning with architectural firm 62

Vocon. That’s when a call came from Stow Mayor Sara Drew. “She caught wind that we were selling our existing building [at 3781 Darrow Rd.] and planning to move to an adjacent city,” Hilovsky says. “She wanted me to come look at a building they had.” That property, just a few miles away at 5070 Stow Rd., included a 19,000-square-foot building, which formerly housed the city’s Parks and Recreation department, plus its Urban Forestry service staff with some office space and numerous high-bay garages for vehicle storage and maintenance. “We immediately saw the possibilities,” Hilovsky says. Although it would require some creative problem solving – financially and architecturally – EnviroScience had found its new home.

Making a deal work Mayor Drew explains that in 2012 the City of Stow began reorganizing to eliminate inefficiencies within service

departments, which included staff reduction and consolidation of operations where needed. As part of this effort, it was determined that the city could no longer sustain its Parks and Recreation/ Urban Forestry building, which was constructed in 2004. “By vacating the facility, it saves the City of Stow $50,000 in utilities and ancillary costs,” Drew says. “It is a specialized building and we knew it was going to be a specialized company that took it over.” Hilovsky says the building was a good match for EnviroScience, but first needed to see if the project was feasible. The hurdle was that the facility was tied to public bonds issued in 2008 and wasn’t scheduled to be paid off until 2020. That meant the City of Stow couldn’t simply sell the property outright until then, unless bonds were paid off immediately, which wasn’t a good option. “We would need to lease the building for seven years but that meant we were looking at financing close to $1 million 3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


Proud HVAC Provider at EnviroScience Headquarters

Custom Fabrication SUITABLE SETTING The City of Stow’s former Parks and Recreation/Urban Forestry building became a surprisingly good fit for the specialized needs of EnviroScience.

Installation 1HZ FRQVWUXFWLRQ UHQRYDWLRQ RU UHSODFHPHQW

Service &RPSUHKHQVLYH VHUYLFH RQ DOO PDNHV PRGHOV

Preventative Maintenance 6HUYLFH DW VFKHGXOHG LQWHUYDOV

Energy Management/Savings & Air Quality 3URPRWLQJ FRVW VDYLQJV DQG HQYLURQPHQWDO VWHZDUGVKLS ZLWK KLJK HIÀFLHQF\ WHFKQRORJLHV

Service: 330-945-6223 | Office: 330-630-9822 ZZZ FKRLFHDLUH FRP _ VHUYLFH#FKRLFHDLUH FRP _ (QJOHZRRG $YH $NURQ

Proud to provide bark wall panels at the new EnviroScience Headquarters

Mod job With the structure of the deal resolved, the project team could turn its attention toward the structure of the facility itself. This included the 18,000-square-foot main building with roughly 3,750 square feet of offices and 2,250 square feet of support space, including a utilitarian lunchroom, locker rooms and storage areas, plus eight garage bays along two sides of the structure. The property also included a pair of separate service garages totaling an additional 9,500 square feet. Fortunately, key portions of the complex required little to no work to serve its new tenant. Spacious, highly

Natural | Sustainable | Architectural Products

BARK HOUSE® B

MANUFACTURED EXCLUSIVELY BY HIGHLAND CRAFTSMEN INC. M

828-765-9010 8

BARKHOUSE.COM

of improvements for a building we didn’t even own,” Hilovsky says. “That’s when the city stepped forward and brought the Greater Akron Chamber of Commerce aboard to provide a significant loan that made the transaction possible.” The project utilized a $400,000 loan for gap financing through the Akron Development Fund, administered by the Akron Chamber of Commerce, Drew explains. The overall result is a 30-year, $2.5 million lease to sale agreement. EnviroScience leases the building for the first seven years and then the deal converts to a sale. The arrangement should save the City of Stow $280,000 in interest by paying off the bond earlier than originally planned, Drew says, and will provide city schools with $40,000 each year in property taxes. “It gives us very favorable terms but over the life of the note, the residents are getting paid back,” Hilovsky says. “It’s a win-win.”

)URP VWDQGDUG GXFW MRLQHG E\ PHFKDQLFDO FRQQHFWLRQV WR ZHOGHG +9$& SURGXFWV

www.propertiesmag.com 63


WOODSY WELCOME A horizontal band of frosted glass has replaced a former receptionist window, cut into a wall that’s now covered entirely with a specialty bark wood product created by Bark House, of Spruce Pine, North Carolina.

durable locker rooms used by the city’s Urban Forestry workers were a perfect fit for EnviroScience team members who often work in the field. Existing office spaces were in nearly movein condition. Lastly, several high bay garages along the north side of the main building could house the company’s

marine services equipment and fleet of 12 boats. In fact, one bay even included a five-ton crane that could be used to lift boats from trailers for maintenance. “That’s certainly nothing we ever had before,” Hilovsky says. Still, EnviroScience did require additional workspace and that demanded

transformation of numerous existing garage bays into offices and labs. “Clearly, renovation costs would be a lot higher here than at the other property we’d considered, but we thought that the end product was going to fit us better,” he says “We could customize it right from the start.” Vocon drew up plans to convert four bays into an open, 8,000-squarefoot office area within the main building. Elsewhere, another series of bays would become a 3,700-squarefoot lab area, while also offering room for future expansion. After reviewing bids from several building companies, EnviroScience selected RiverReach Construction to serve as construction manager. Although RiverReach’s typical work includes wetland enhancement, storm water management and other heavy construction work, the company was a good fit for the project, Hilovsky says.

Exceptional Architectural and Interior Photography Visit us at www.maguirephoto.com or give us a call at 330.630.9050.

64

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


CREATIVE CONVERSION Four garage bays (top) were converted into open office space (middle). An adjoining kitchen (bottom) with café seating serves as a hub to connect new and existing portions of the building.

“We’ve been working with them on stream restoration [efforts] and other projects through the years, so we were comfortable with them,” he says. The $1.3 million building project launched in late 2012. The main building opened in June 2013 and the testing labs followed, opening in September.

Inside observation Today, visitors approach the building complex from a 30-space parking lot and into an entry vestibule that immediately establishes a new feel for the building. A horizontal band of frosted glass has replaced a former receptionist window, cut into a wall that’s now covered entirely with a specialty bark wood product created by Bark House, of Spruce Pine, North Carolina. “The bark has been stripped off of trees and cured in such a way that it can be installed as a building material,” says Mary Burkhardt, interior designer with Vocon. As Burkhardt notes, the team searched for interesting yet affordable materials to use in the space. “We didn’t want to make this over-the-top expensive,” she says. “This isn’t a law office that might dictate using stone and wood. Instead, we tried to use economical materials that would reflect the company’s culture and its work in the natural environment.” Supporting that theme is a dark wood laminate flooring in the reception space, as well as a word wall that utilizes key phrases to communicate the company’s mission and range of services. The entry vestibule opens to the former Parks and Recreation offices, now serving as an executive office suite for EnviroScience. In this area, including offices, a copy room and small conference room, renovation work was minimal: new carpeting, furniture and paint, with largely neutral colors enhanced by vibrant orange and green accents. “The colors that Mary [Burkhardt] brought into the space went a long way,” says Vocon’s Bob Porter, project architect.

From institutional to inspirational A corridor leads from the executive offices to the former Urban Forestry www.propertiesmag.com 65


INVIGORATING ENVIRONMENT The café features a corncrib ceiling, can lighting and recycled rubber flooring, which together create a striking setting for casual lunches and office parties. Alluding to the company’s expertise working in aquatic environments, a saltwater tank has been recessed into a feature wall.

portion of the building, previously an institutional-style space with painted cinderblock walls, stark lighting and simple vinyl flooring. This space has been dramatically altered with new drywall and carpeting, as well as oversized wall graphics incorporating the company’s tagline: “Excellence in Any Environment.” Just off of the corridor, a wall separating a former lunchroom and adjacent storage room was removed and the space rebuilt as a conference room with high-end acoustic tile ceilings, a versatile A/V system and modular furniture that can be arranged together as a boardroom table or separated for classroom seating. Beyond the boardroom is the garageturned-open office, the most dramatic new area in the building. Previously, the space was accessed through four massive garage doors. RiverReach replaced these with walls of windows and split-face brick detailing, evened the sloped floors and removed CO2 monitor systems and other equipment that was no longer needed. Now the towering 17-foot-high space houses two large clusters of lowset workstations. 66

“The lower workstations and open office feel creates more opportunities for casual interactions that make work less stressful and more productive,” Porter says. Dividing the two workstation clusters is a gabled “cabin” structure in the center. Serving as a dramatic architectural feature, the cabin is adorned with reclaimed corncrib wood material and

wood panels, which are hinged to provide access. “It would have been cost prohibitive to move the equipment so the screen wall became a good solution,” Porter says. The panels provide acoustic control, as do a pair of suspended ceiling clouds. To the east, a portion of the wall has been removed to create an open kitchen with an island and café seating, plus access to an existing patio outside. The café features a corncrib ceiling, can lighting, shiny red laminate cabinetry and recycled rubber flooring, which together create a striking setting for casual lunches and office parties. Alluding to the company’s expertise Marty Hilovsky working in aquatic environments, a saltwater fish tank has been recessed EnviroScience into a feature wall within the café. The aquarium’s water and air filtration contains a pair of huddle rooms for system is routed along existing trench small groups and one-on-one meetings. drains as well as newly cut trenches that The cabin’s sloped roof is functional as run beneath the floor to a mudroom well, concealing ductwork for newly nearby, notes Jeff Zanolli, project superininstalled HVAC equipment. tendent with RiverReach Construction. Fire safety equipment along the “The support system for a salt water southern edge of the office area is tank like this is pretty complicated, tucked behind a screen wall com- with continuous filtration of water, so posed of four-foot by eight-foot bark that was a bit of a challenge,” Zanolli

“[EnviroScience is] 20% over what we projected for 2013 and having a record year. Six months after we first moved in, I’m convinced that this facility is helping to fuel our growth.”

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


LAB FABRICATION A separate existing service garage has been transformed to house a 3,700-square-foot lab for aquatic toxicity testing and analysis.

says. “Another part of the challenge is ensuring that the tank was accessible but not having any contact with metal studs and rust materials. Everything needed to be sealed.”

New labs About 50 yards to the west of the main building is a long service garage totaling 6,100 square feet. Approximately 3,700 square feet within the facility has been built-out to create a lab for aquatic toxicity testing and analysis. Work in the lab required similar replacement of garage doors with walls and windows, and installation of lab casework, coolers and aquariums, as well as durable, easy-to-clean epoxy flooring. HVAC equipment was added as well. “The lab space is fairly simple but very functional for [EnviroScience’s] needs,” Zanolli says. Nearby, adjacent to the lab, about 2,400 square feet of existing garage space remains untouched and ready

for future build-out. As Hilovsky says, expansion may take place sooner than once imagined. “When we moved in, we hired several new individuals and we’re almost full again,” he says, noting that business is up considerably, owing in large part to the new headquarters. “We were 20% over what we projected for 2013 and ended up having

a record year,” Hilovsky says. “Six months after we first moved in, I’m convinced that this facility is helping to fuel our growth. We’ve had clients here and the building itself resulted in us getting additional work. It’s making us more efficient and gives us a workspace that makes people proud of where they are. It’s really making a difference.” P

6036 1(2 LV QHDUO\ WKH ODUJHVW ZH·YH EHHQ LQ RXU &KDSWHU·V KLVWRU\ $QG ZH·UH JURZLQJ

+HUH·V ZK\ &OLHQW 3DQHO /XQFKHRQV 0DUNHWLQJ 'RPDLQ 6SHDNHU 6HULHV (GXFDWLRQDO 3URJUDPV 1HWZRUNLQJ DQG 6RFLDO (YHQWV %HQHÀWV RI 0HPEHUVKLS DQG 2QOLQH 5HVRXUFHV 9ROXQWHHU 2SSRUWXQLWLHV 1RW RQO\ GRHV D PHPEHUVKLS RIIHU DFFHVV WR ORFDO LQGXVWU\ RSSRUWXQLWLHV 6036 LV D QDWLRQDO RUJDQL]DWLRQ ZLWK PRUH WKDQ PHPEHUV DQG HQGOHVV RSSRUWXQLWLHV IRU DGYDQFHPHQW 6036 SURYLGHV EXVLQHVV SURIHVVLRQDOV ZLWK WKH RSSRUWXQLW\ WR OHDUQ QHWZRUN DQG EXLOG EXVLQHVV H[SDQG WKHLU XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI WKH LQGXVWU\ GLVFRYHU WKHLU LQWHUHVWV GHÀQH WKHLU IRFXV DQG H[SORUH WKH SRVVLELOLWLHV IRU WKH IXWXUH

/HDUQ PRUH DERXW 6036 1RUWKHDVW 2KLR DQG XSFRPLQJ HYHQWV DW ZZZ VPSVQHR RUJ

www.propertiesmag.com 67


Going with the Flow Sloping site drives design for CCPL’s Parma-Snow Library addition & renovation By Jeanne Bluffstone | Photos by Eric Hanson

f it seems that a new Cuyahoga County Public Library branch has opened every month or two for the past couple of years, that’s because it has. The efforts of the library system’s $110 million Facilities Master Plan to update its branch locations began with the opening of the Warrensville Heights branch in April of 2012. Since then, nearly a dozen new construction and renovation projects have opened throughout the county. The latest to be completed is the newly renovated, 41,000-square-foot ParmaSnow branch, which opened in December 2013 on a seven-acre site at 2121 Snow Rd.

I

As a result of a $15.2 million, 14-month renovation project, the Parma-Snow branch has been updated with expanded library and meeting spaces, complemented by the addition of a flexible, 400-seat “black box” public auditorium. As CCPL Deputy Director Tracy Strobel

notes, each of the library system’s new or renovated library buildings has a distinct personality; the Parma-Snow project was aimed at creating a combination civic center and library. “The theater can be used as an auditorium and we want to open it to the

9 /,(;05. 4 (09 *65+0;06505. 6505. - 0 9 , 7 9 6 ; , * ; 0 6 5 * 6 5 ; 9 ( * ; 6 9 * 6 5 : < 3;( 5 ; : + , : 0 . 5 , 9 : 0UZ[ P[ \[ PVU HS 9LZP KL U[ P H S 0 UK\Z [ Y P H S *VT T L YJ P H S * V U Z[ Y \ J [ P V U : L Y ] P J L Z .(9@ :()6 79,:0+,5; , 4 ( 0 3 ! N H Y ` Z H I V ' Y T O [ N J V T *,33!

68

,X\HS 6WWVY[\UP[` ,TWSV`LY , YK :[ *SL]LSHUK 6/ WO c MH_

community and schools at no cost,” Strobel says. Since the library is centrally located in the city and has highway access, the theater can also be used as a mini-conference center or rented for corporate meetings, weddings and other private events and can be cordoned off from the library if it is used during hours when the library is closed. An additional objective of the renovation was to physically link the existing library to CCPL’s administrative building, located some 250 feet away. The project sought to weave the two separate facilities together in an architectural treatment that felt continuous and unified. “We carefully considered using the existing library building and we had 3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


GATHER AROUND A curved glass wall and decorative cylindrical light fixtures at the entrance are functional and add to the quality of the interior environment.

to create the right design to integrate it into the overall design,” says Peter Bolek, design principal of Holzheimer Bolek Meehan Architects (HBM).

Construction challenges Planning for the project began the summer of 2011, the job was bid in June 2012, and groundbreaking occurred in August 2012 with Donley’s, Inc. as construction manager. While the library temporarily moved to a strip mall across the street during construction, the administration building remained open throughout and there were some 200 people who needed access to the building, which was a consideration in organizing the project. Another early challenge was preparing the site. “None of the utilities were installed as shown in the existing survey drawings, so storm sewers, sanitary sewers and gas lines had to be relocated and the auditorium was built in a different sequence than originally planned,” says Jay Waddell, senior project manager for Donley’s, Inc. “I thought the auditorium’s construction might be delayed, but everything was completed on time.” The building is constructed of durable masonry and brick with glass curtain wall and corrugated metal panels, says Shawn F. White, senior project manager for Infinity Construction Co., Inc., which served as general trades contractor. Salvaged brick was used to match exist-

INFINITY IS PROUD TO HAVE BEEN THE GENERAL TRADES CONTRACTOR ON THE NEW PARMA SNOW LIBRARY

www.propertiesmag.com 69


ing masonry so the two buildings blend seamlessly. The roof structure is steel bar joist with a metal roof deck covered by a TPO roofing membrane.

Glass & light Much of the existing library’s original exterior envelope remains, with a glass curtain wall bump-out to expand the children’s area and to allow more light and space while accentuating the new design. “An important aspect of the design was to create comfortable spaces filled

with natural light and transparency that contributed to the feel of the space and acted as an expression to the people passing by,” Bolek says. Through creative use of glass internally and externally, the library is designed to utilize natural illumination and rely less on artificial light. In some areas, lighting fixtures are used to enhance the feeling of natural light and properly light specific areas. Elsewhere, decorative fixtures create diffused light for evening and nighttime use. A curved glass wall and decorative cylindrical light fixtures at

3URXG ODQGVFDSLQJ SURYLGHU IRU WKH QHZ 3$50$ 612: 38%/,& /,%5$5<

Down to Earth

/$1'6&$3,1* ,1&

&203/(7( /$1'6&$3( 6(59,&( 3+21( )$; ZZZ GWHRKLR FRP &8<$+2*$ &2817< 38%/,& /,%5$5<

3$50$ 612: %5$1&+ +%0 $UFKLWHFWV LV SURXG WR SDUWQHU ZLWK &&3/ WR SURYLGH DQ H[SDQGHG OLEUDU\ IRU WKH 3DUPD &RPPXQLW\

75$16)250,1* 9,6,21 ,172 5($/,7< +RO]KHLPHU %ROHN 0HHKDQ $UFKLWHFWV

ZZZ +%0DUFKLWHFWV FRP _

70

the entrance are functional and add to the quality of the interior environment. “There is a significant use of glass here and introducing it to the building, which was concrete, opened the interior,” says James Shook, project architect/manager for HDM Architects. “The glass is highly energy efficient and provides a great quality environment. The way the glass is broken up on the exterior follows the same pattern on the interior. Bookshelf end panels also follow the same pattern. The exterior palette is designed as an accent to the façade.”

Built to flow One of the most important aspects of the design was to call out the entry to the facility and create an intuitive flow of space from the library’s collection to the social gathering area, and then to the administration building, Bolek explains. “[CCPL Executive Director] Sari Feldman expressed a desire that anyone who came to the facility should enter in and experience the library first instead of the office building,” he explains. Expanded parking areas to the east and west provide access without visitors going back onto Snow Road, while the front of the building is accessible for drive-up and drop-off with zero curbs and no barriers to entry. As the library is built on sloping land, the topography also became an important factor in creating the concept of the building. The design had to mediate through the change in elevation since there is a drop in floor levels from the administration building to the library. “The north end of the building is where the existing branch library was and includes a lower floor-to-roof structured area, which was a limitation we needed to work within,” Bolek says. “By creative organization of the program in this area, removal of some of the ceilings, reorganized mechanical systems and lighting and the introduction of interior and exterior glass walls, we were able to increase openness and provide an inviting space.” There are two different floor levels, designed to flow without interruption. The first floor is the 30,000-squarefoot library with its collection of more than 35,000 books, 5,500 DVDs, 2,000 music CDs and more. Included are flexible A/V-equipped meeting rooms, 3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


LITERAL LINE A word wall acts as a demarcation between the new addition and the existing library spaces beyond.

study and gathering spaces, a dedicated teen area, computer areas, a technology training center, a full service drive-up window and café. “The children’s areas [at our branch libraries] are always special,” Strobel says. “This branch has a colorful and interactive children’s ‘Play, Learn and Grow’ area, which brings to life the book LMNO Peas, by Keith Baker. The play area is designed around the question, ‘What do you want to be when you grow up?’ Interactive activities are designed around different types of work.” A palette of muted blues, greens, and browns is used throughout. “How those colors are combined in different ways on computer tables, chairs, everything, creates an environment that is easy to maneuver and intuitive to use,” says Shook. Upstairs on the second floor are the balcony of the black box theater and the entrance to the administration building, both of which are accessible by a wide, open stair or passenger elevator.

Inside the black box Designed with ultimate flexibility in mind, the black box theater can accommodate a wide variety of performances, banquets, meetings or other events. It is

available for use by the community at no charge and can be rented for corporate or private events as well. “[Incorporating] a black box theater was the desire expressed by the client,” Bolek says. The unadorned theater is square, like a box, and painted black, because black is a neutral color that will not clash with

costumes, sets and lighting. The floor is flat and open with a raised platform that can serve as a stage. The center of the space is open, allowing seating to be arranged in any configuration desired. There is also built-in theater-style seating, which be pulled out to fill in the open floor space. A dramatic stairway leading from the second to the first floor

Proud to contribute to CCPL’s new Parma-Snow Branch with Infinity Construction

181=,2·6

&$%,1(7 6+23

&RPPHUFLDO &DELQHWU\ $UFKLWHFWXUDO 0LOOZRUN

Custom-Built Cabinetry to Suit All Needs & Budgets COMMERCIAL • MEDICAL • RESIDENTIAL

4147 Pearl Road, Cleveland, Ohio 216.459.2051 www.propertiesmag.com 71


VERSATILE VENUE The black box theater offers ultimate flexibility with moveable seating and staging available in a range of configurations.

green area offers space for guests to gather and mingle during intermissions or before or after events or performances. It is also an area where library visitors can lounge and read. Landscaping includes bio-retention areas planted with native materials that are tolerant to oils and road salts and help break them down before releasing the water back into the environment.

New STEP

makes the space particularly desirable for weddings and important photographs. Capable of endless new configurations, the theater can also be divided to accommodate different events taking place at the same time. For instance, half of the space can be utilized with the stage and theater seating, while stage drapery zones off the balance of the space for another activity taking place simultaneously. As a consultant, architectural firm Westlake Reed Leskosky (WRL) oversaw the design of the theater’s inner workings, including acoustics, stage lighting and rigging, and audiovisual equipment. “We designed all of the dimming and control systems for theatrical lighting, audiovisual systems, seating layout, and worked with the architects on different site lines and different configurations [in

the black box theater],” says Raymond Kent, principal and director of WRL’s Innovative Technology Design Group. The lighting, video and visual capabilities are similar to those WRL designed for the Allen Theater at Playhouse Square in Downtown Cleveland. “In the systems we’ve laid out, we’ve given them a fantastic flexible space that will serve them well in a variety of ways.” By design, the theater is accessible independent of the library’s operating hours. “It was important to be able to close off a major part of the library, so if an event took place after hours, people still had access to the space,” explains Bolek. The theater is linked to a new living roof accessed from the building’s second level. Weather permitting, this pleasant

HVAC ■ Plumbing ■ Fire Protection ■ Process Piping ■

72

A unique feature of the library renovation is that it is a pilot project for the STEP™ rating system (Sustainable Technology Environments Program), says Kent. In addition to its work on the black box theater, WRL provided IT and engineering design services detailing the infrastructure of the entire building. “STEP is like LEED, except for the plug load side of the equation of IT, A/V and theater technology,” he says. “We worked with the client in designing technology systems that helped make the building efficient, but also smart by tying in energy efficiency within the technology to the building systems as well.” Working within this framework, the library will have smarter control over not only how technology is used, but also how efficiently it is managed, Kent says. “Following the STEP guidelines, WRL was able to significantly reduce the

Proud of our involvement with Donley’s Inc. & Infinity Construction at CCPL’s Parma-Snow Branch 800-776-7181 www.sacomunale.com

“Large Enough To Meet Your Needs, Small Enough To Care” 3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


KEY CHARACTERISTICS Important aspects of the project included the expansion of the existing children’s area (left) as well as a new corridor (right) that connects the Parma-Snow library to CCPL’s adjacent administrative building.

amount of electronics and infrastructure required for a comparable traditional installation,” he adds.

Master Plan continues on With this project’s completion, CCPL’s Facilities Master Plan continues to make progress. The Parma-Snow

renovation/addition joins other new or newly renovated branches in Parma, Garfield Heights, North Royalton, Chagrin Falls, Beachwood, Fairview Park, Mayfield Branch, Olmsted Falls, Solon and Warrensville Heights. Looking ahead, CCPL’s Orange Branch Library is scheduled to open

7KH 1XPEHUV 'RQ·W /LH

this fall. Other planned projects include the Brook Park, Independence, Maple Heights, Parma Heights, South EuclidLyndhurst and Southeast libraries. “We want each branch to be different, but the basic components are the same,” Strobel says. “We always strive for a line between practical and beautiful.” P

Proud partner at the CCPL Parma-Snow Branch SPRAY FOAM TECHNOLOGIES OF

OHIO

<RXU $YHUDJH +HDWLQJ &RROLQJ 6DYLQJV ZLWK 6SUD\ 3RO\XUHWKDQH )RDP 63) ,QVXODWLRQ 6RXUFH 6SUD\ 3RO\XUHWKDQH )RDP $OOLDQFH 5HVXOWV PD\ YDU\ EDVHG RQ LQGLYLGXDO +9$& XVDJH

5

3HU ,QFK

63) KDV 1HDUO\ 7ZLFH WKH ,QVXODWLQJ 9DOXH RI 7UDGLWLRQDO )LEHUJODVV· 5 SHU LQFK

&DOO &OLFN WR XWLOL]H 63) ,QVXODWLRQ RQ \RXU QH[W SURMHFW

6SUD\)RDP7HFK2KLR FRP $%$$ 1&), 26+$ &(57,),(' $XURUD +XGVRQ 5G +XGVRQ 2+

Professional, accurate, on-time. That is Straub Surveying…your Point of Beginning. 3D Laser Scanning/Surveying Professional Construction Layout Exisiting Conditions Surveys Rocky River, Ohio | (440) 333-1700 www.StraubSurveying.com | Info@StraubSurveying.com www.propertiesmag.com 73


CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT Updated info on important projects in the region

Project Report #: 956539 FORMER LINCOLN WAY ELEMENTARY PROJECT TYPE: Renovation PHYSICAL ADDRESS: 905 Pittsburg Avenue CITY/COUNTY: Wooster, OH (Wayne County) CATEGORY(S): Commercial SUB-CATEGORY(S): Office CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids STATUS: Schematic Drawings

OWNER: Community Action Wayne/Medina County 2375B Benden Drive Wooster, OH 44691 (330) 264-8677 fax: (330) 264-5170 info@cawm.org ARCHITECT: BSHM Architects - Youngstown 15 Central Square, Suite 300 Youngstown, OH 44503 (330) 744-4401 fax: (330) 744-2370

RELATED PROJECTS: Architectural Services - Former Lincoln Way Elementary DESCRIPTION: Former Lincoln Way Elementary to be converted into five Head Start classrooms, administrative offices for approximately 60 employees, various conference rooms, a commercial kitchen, pre-school child friendly restrooms and adult restrooms. DETAILS: Office, 1 Story Above Grade, 29,000 SF Renovation, 3.50 Acres. Project Report #: 959162 INDEPENDENT AND ASSISTED LIVING FACILITY PROJECT TYPE: New Construction DESCRIPTION: Brunswick Town Center PHYSICAL ADDRESS: Center Road CITY/COUNTY: Brunswick, OH 44212 (Medina County) CATEGORY(S): Residential SUB-CATEGORY(S): Assisted Living Facility CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only STATUS: Conceptual Design OWNER: McKinley Development Company 1201 South Main Street North Canton, OH 44720 (330) 497-6565 RELATED PROJECTS: Hotel (Project ID: 959141)

The Road to Cleanliness Starts Here Ê ",Ê Ê "Ê "-/Ê* , Ê , Ê -- --

UÊ-Üii« } UÊ*ÀiÃÃÕÀiÊ7>Ã } UÊ-VÀÕLL } UÊ*>Ûi i ÌÊ,i«> ÀÃ UÊ-ÌÀ « } UÊ-> Ì }

/

UÊ- ÜÊ* Ü } UÊ ÃÌÀÕVÌ Ê- Ìià UÊ*>À }Ê Ìà UÊ*>À }Ê iV à UÊ7>Ài ÕÃià UÊ-«iV > Ê Ûi ÌÃ

- ViÊ£ ä

330-798-9200

ÜÜܰLÕV iÞiÃÜii« }°V 74

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


Luxury Apartments (Project ID: 959153) DETAILS: 1 Assisted Living Facility, New Construction

Warren, OH 44481 (330) 675-2640 fax: (330) 675-2642 DETAILS: Gas Station, New Construction.

Project Report #: 948956 RESIDENCES AT PLAYHOUSESQUARE PROJECT TYPE: Renovation PHYSICAL ADDRESS: 1220 Huron Road CITY/COUNTY: Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) CATEGORY(S): Residential SUB-CATEGORY(S): Apartments/Condominiums CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only STATUS: Construction Documents. Bidding Expected January 2014 ESTIMATED VALUE: $16,000,000 OWNER: Slyman Group 3349 Kintyre Circle Richfield, OH 44286 (216) 574-6102 ARCHITECT: Vocon Design, Inc. 3142 Prospect Avenue Cleveland, OH 44115 (216) 588-0800 fax: (216) 588-0801 DETAILS: 1 Apartments/Condominiums, Renovation, 80 Unit(s).

Project Report #: 988862 HAMPTON INN & SUITES PROJECT TYPE: New Construction PHYSICAL ADDRESS: Falling Water Road CITY/COUNTY: Strongsville, OH (Cuyahoga County) CATEGORY(S): Commercial SUB-CATEGORY(S): Hotel/Motel CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only STATUS: Seeking Zoning Variances ESTIMATED VALUE: $1,000,000 to $5,000,000 OWNER: Alliance Hospitality, Inc. 600 Enterprise Drive

Project Report #: 967934 RIVER SOUTH MODERN ECOHOMES PROJECT TYPE: New Construction PHYSICAL ADDRESS: 18911 Lorain Road CITY/COUNTY: Fairview Park, OH (Cuyahoga County) CATEGORY(S): Residential SUB-CATEGORY(S): Single-Family Homes CONTRACTING METHOD: Owner to Subcontract by Invitation Only STATUS: Design Development. Sitework Start Expected first quarter 2014. OWNER: Abode Modern Lifestyle Developers 26401 Emery Road Cleveland, OH 44128 (216) 721-0027 ARCHITECT: Dimit Architects 14414 Detroit Avenue, Suite 306 Lakewood, OH 44107 (216) 221-9021 fax: (216) 221-9031 RELATED PROJECTS: Office Building (Project ID: 933085) DETAILS: Single-Family Homes, New Construction, 3 Stories Above Grade, 36 Unit(s). Project Report #: 987772 COMPRESSED NATURAL GAS FUELING STATION PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CITY/COUNTY: Warren, OH (Trumbull County) CATEGORY(S): Commercial SUB-CATEGORY(S): Gas Station CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids STATUS: Seeking Funding. ESTIMATED VALUE: $750,000 COUNTY AGENCY: Trumbull County Commissioners 160 High Street NW, 5th Floor Warren, OH 44481 (330) 675-2451 fax: (330) 675-2462 ENGINEER: Trumbull County Engineer 650 N. River Rd. W

Lewis Center, OH 43035 (614) 846-6600 fax: (614) 430-1744 Contact - Ohm Patel info@ahihotels.com ENGINEER: Mannik & Smith Group, Inc. 815 Grandview Avenue, Suite 650 Columbus, OH 43215 (614) 441-4222 fax: (888) 488-7340 DETAILS: Hotel/Motel, 18,000 SF New Construction, 5.26 Acres. Project Report #: 989554 PK-12 CONSOLIDATED CAMPUS PROJECT TYPE: New Construction, Renovation, Demolition PHYSICAL ADDRESS: Biddulph Road

Restoration Contractors American International Construction, Inc. is a company dedicated to the restoration and preservation of numerous types of buildings, including related services on new structures. Let our commitment to quality and client satisfaction work for you. UÊ >Õ }ÊEÊÃi> > Ìà UÊ Õ ` }ÊV i> } UÊ/ÕV « Ì } UÊ >V>`iÊÀiÃÌ À>Ì UÊ >à ÀÞÊEÊÃÌ iÊÀiÃÌ À>Ì UÊ-Ì ÀivÀ ÌÊÀi Û>Ì UÊ7>ÌiÀ«À v } UÊ ÃÌ À VÊ«ÀiÃiÀÛ>Ì

Michael Petrasek president

1073 WEST BAGLEY ROAD, BEREA, OHIO 44017 ph: 440.243.5535 f: 440.243.7745 www.aiconstruction.com

0DNLQJ \RX ORRN JRRG LV RXU EXVLQHVV 5HVLGHQWLDO FRPPHUFLDO ODQGVFDSH LQVWDOODWLRQ PDLQWHQDQFH 6LQFH

LLQIR#UEVWRXWLQF FRP I # E W

ZZZ UEVWRXWLQF FRP www.propertiesmag.com 75


Best Way Up? Together. with

*LDPEURQH &RQVWUXFWLRQ )XOO 6HUYLFH :%( )%( *HQHUDO &RQWUDFWRU

*LDPEURQH 0DVRQU\

0DVRQ 6WRQH ,QVWDOODWLRQ 5HSDLU

8QLYHUVDO 6FDIIROGLQJ

5HQWDO /HDVH 6DOH RI 4XDOLW\ 6FDIIROGLQJ

ZZZ *LDPEURQH FRP $NURQ &OHYHODQG $XURUD +XGVRQ 5G +XGVRQ 2+

Tough times call for smart choices. Now more than ever, teaming up with Properties is the most cost-effective way to communicate your message directly to the top 30,000 decision makers in the real estate, construction, architectural, design and property owner/management markets of Northeast Ohio. Count on over 68 years of experience to help you every step of the way. Call today or visit us online to view the 2014 Media Planner

Industry Leader Since 1

946

www.propertiesmag.com

216.251.0035

&X\DKRJD 3XEOLF /LEUDU\ *DU¿HOG %UDQFK *DU¿HOG 2+ %RVWZLFN 'HVLJQ 3DUWQHUV

76

3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


CITY/COUNTY: Brooklyn, OH (Cuyahoga County) CATEGORY(S): Education, Entertainment/Recreation SUB-CATEGORY(S): Athletic Facility, Elementary School, Middle/Senior High School CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids STATUS: Conceptual Design ESTIMATED VALUE: $26,000,000 MUNICIPAL AGENCY: Brooklyn Board of Education 9200 Biddulph Road Brooklyn, OH 44144 (216) 351-8477 ARCHITECT: ThenDesign Architecture 4135 Erie Street Willoughby, OH 44094 (440) 269-2266 fax: (440) 269-2277 DESCRIPTION: Demolition of a 27,000-squarefoot wing of the high school formerly used for vocational training. Built in its place will be conjoined elementary - including pre-K and kindergarten and middle schools. Turf and a new press box will be installed at the high school stadium. DETAILS: Elementary School, Middle/Senior High School, 107,000 SF New Construction, Athletic Facility, Renovation, Demolition Project Report #: 990043 RALLY’S RESTAURANT PROJECT TYPE: New Construction PHYSICAL ADDRESS: 11701 Superior Avenue CITY/COUNTY: Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) CATEGORY(S): Commercial SUB-CATEGORY(S): Food/Beverage Service CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only STATUS: Seeking Zoning Variances. Construction Start Expected second quarter 2014. OWNER: Checkers/Rally’s Drive-In Restaurants, Inc. 4300 West Cypress Street - Suite 600 Tampa, FL 33607 (813) 283-7000 fax: (813) 283-7001 ARCHITECT: CG Architecture 455 South Ludlow Street Columbus, OH 43215 (614) 469-1001 fax: (614) 469-1002 DETAILS: 1 Food/Beverage Service, 1 Story Above Grade, New Construction, Drive-thru. Project Report #: 990652 GIANT EAGLE MARKET DISTRICT EXPRESS PROJECT TYPE: New Construction DESCRIPTION: The Shoppes on Clifton PHYSICAL ADDRESS: West 117th and Clifton Boulevard CITY/COUNTY: Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) CATEGORY(S): Commercial SUB-CATEGORY(S): Supermarket/Convenience Store CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only STATUS: Conceptual Design ESTIMATED VALUE: $1,000,000 to $5,000,000 OWNER: Giant Eagle Supermarkets 261 Kappa Drive Pittsburgh, PA 15238 (800) 338-9147

Contact - Todd Waldo RELATED PROJECTS: The Shoppes on Clifton (Project ID: 987831) DESCRIPTION: The Market District Express, the first such store in Ohio, would include a 100seat restaurant on the second floor and a patio fronting on a promenade stretching from Clifton to the parking lot behind the retail buildings. DETAILS: 1 Supermarket/Convenience Store, 2 Stories Above Grade, 30,000 SF New Construction Project Report #: 994503 MINERAL CITY FIRE STATION PROJECT TYPE: Renovation, Addition CITY/COUNTY: Mineral City, OH (Tuscarawas County) CATEGORY(S): Government/Public SUB-CATEGORY(S): Fire/Police Station CONTRACTING METHOD: General Contractor to Subcontract STATUS: Construction Documents. Sub-Bidding Expected January 2014. MUNICIPAL AGENCY: Village of Mineral City

8728 N. High Street Mineral City, OH 44656 (330) 859-2902 ARCHITECT: Motter & Meadows Architects 600 Market Avenue North Canton, OH 44702 (330) 454-6165 fax: (330) 454-6789 info@mottermeadows.com GENERAL CONTRACTOR: Norman Eckinger Inc 2500 Krisco Circle Canton, OH 44706 (330) 452-6500 fax: (330) 452-6530 DESCRIPTION: The fire station will be upgraded from 8,150 square feet to a 9,500-squarefoot building. DETAILS: 1 Fire/Police Station, Renovation, Approximately 1,350 SF Addition.

Construction Progress Reports are provided to Properties by Construction Journal. For more building and bidding news and information, call Construction Journal at 800.880.2309 or visit www.constructionjournal.com.

([SHULHQFHG 'HSHQGDEOH

6WUXFWXUDO 6WHHO )DEULFDWRUV DQG (UHFWRUV VLQFH &RQWDFW 0LNH 6PLWK IRU D SURSRVDO ZZZ PDVRQVWHHO FRP 1RUWKILHOG 5RDG :DOWRQ +LOOV 2KLR 2WKHU )LQH 3URGXFWV $YDLODEOH 6WRQH 3DYHUV )LUHSODFHV :LQGRZV 'RRUV

),5( 3527(&7,21 6(59,&(6 Fire Extinguishers, Alarms, Exit/Emergency Lighting, Kitchen Fire Suppression, Sprinklers, FM-200/Halon/CO2 Systems/Backflow Prevention Divison 10 fire extinguishers and cabinets to construction trades

888.528.0928 www.county-fire.com

Fire protection contracting services to property owners/managers

!KRON s #LEVELAND s #OLUMBUS s 4OLEDO www.propertiesmag.com 77


&RPLQJ LQ )HEUXDU\ +DUG 5RFN 5RFNVLQR 1RUWKILHOG 3DUN 2VZDOG &HQWUH /DQGVFDSLQJ 2XWGRRU /LJKWLQJ 6SHFLDO 6HFWLRQ DQG PRUH

,QWHUHVWHG LQ DGYHUWLVLQJ" &DOO 3URSHUWLHV WRGD\ DQG DQ DFFRXQW UHSUHVHQWDWLYH FDQ KHOS \RX DGGUHVV \RXU DGYHUWLVLQJ QHHGV

ZZZ SURSHUWLHVPDJ FRP 9LVLW XV RQOLQH IRU DUFKLYHG IHD

WXUH DUWLFOHV DGYHUWLVLQJ UDWHV VSHFV DQG VXEVFULSWLRQ LQIRUPD WLRQ

ZZZ SURSHUWLHVPDJ FRP

9LVLW XV RQOLQH WRGD\ WR GRZQORDG DUFKLYHG LVVXHV IHDWXULQJ OLYH K\SHUWH[W OLQNV WR DGYHUWLVHUV· ZHEVLWHV 7KH 0HGLD 3ODQQHU LV QRZ DYDLODEOH DV D 3') GRZQORDG 78

ADVERTISER INDEX 21st Century Concrete

Jamieson Ricca Co. ............................................... 48

Construction, Inc............................................... 48

Krill Company, Inc ..................................................16

AC Electric & General Contracting, LTD.........7

Kurtz Bros...................................................................51

AAdvanced Building Products, LLC ............. 24

KW Commercial Osborne Group....................18

AIA .................................................................................14

Kwest Group, LLC ...................................................11

American Fire & Sprinkler, LLC........................ 60

Lake County Title .................................................. 43

American International Construction ......... 75

Leff Electric............................................................... 69

Atwell LLC ................................................................. 34

Lisco Heating & Cooling, Inc. ........................... 49

Barber & Hoffman, Inc. ....................................... 57

Maguire Photographics .....................................64

Bark House ............................................................... 63

Mason Structural Steel, Inc............................... 77

BOMA Greater Cleveland .................................. 47

McGraw-Hill Construction Network ............ 42

Brennan & Associates...........................................74

Meaden & Moore, Ltd ......................................... 22

Bruder Building Materials, Inc. ........................ 49

Messina Floor Covering, Inc. ............................ 59

Buckeye Sweeping, Inc........................................74

National Construction Rentals........................44

Buckley King, LPA.................................................. 39

Nelson Contracting ...............................................12

Building Enclosure Council............................... 23

Nunzio’s Cabinet Shop ....................................... 71

Carey Roofing ......................................................... 38

OCP Contractors .....................................................14

Carroll Glass & Maintenance ............................ 54

Oppenheim Construction ................................ 59

CBRE, Inc.................................................................... 80

Osborne Real Estate Services, LLC. ............... 30

CertaPro Painters................................................... 47

Pease Photography ...............................................76

Chagrin Valley Steel Erectors............................61

Peller & Associates, Inc. .......................................15

Charles Schulz Building Company................ 37

Pete & Pete Container Service ........................ 56

Charles Svec Inc. .................................................... 47

Precision Environmental Co..............................41

ChoiceAire HVAC ................................................... 63

Precision ProCut .................................................... 32

Cleveland Engineering Society ...................... 27

R&M Heating & Air Conditioning .................. 68

Cleveland Public Power ......................................11

RB Stout, Inc............................................................. 75

CNA Surety ............................................................... 33

Reliable Snow Plow Specialists .........................4

Columbia Building Products ........................... 23

Relmec Mechanical, LLC .................................... 60

Construction Employers Association .............2

S.A. Comunale Company .................................. 72

Construction Journal............................................12

Sandglo Glass & Mirror Co. ................................51

County Fire Protection Inc................................ 77

Schill Grounds Management .............................7

Courtad Inc. ...............................................................6

Siegel Jennings ..............................................26, 45

Cunningham Paving Inc. ................................... 60

Skoda Minotti Company.................................... 79

Delta Industrial Services, Inc............................ 29

Sleggs Danzinger & Gill...................................... 40

Down To Earth Landscaping ........................... 70

SMPS Northeast Ohio ......................................... 67

Duffy & Duffy Cost Segregation Services ....19

Space Comfort Co....................................................9

EA Group ......................................................................3

Spray Foam Technologies................................. 73

First Federal Of Lakewood.................................21

Star Design-Build Contractors .........................10

Frantz Ward LLP ..................................................... 20

Stark Group, The.....................................................41

Giambrone Masonry, Inc. ...................................76

Straub Surveying, LLC ......................................... 73

Global Real Estate Advisors, Inc. .....................21

Suntrol Co. .................................................................51

Health & Fitness Equipment Centers............13

The Fedeli Group................................................... 30

HMH Restoration Ltd........................................... 25

Thompson Hine LLP/Project

Holzheimer Bolek & Meehan Architects.... 70

Management Consultants (PMC).............. 57

IMAGINiT Technologies.......................................14

Vocon ......................................................................... 57

Infinity Construction ....................................53, 69

Walter & Haverfield LLP ..................................... 30

J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc.................................. 48

Warren Roofing & Insulating Co. ................... 50 3URSHUWLHV | January 2014


construct Connecting Our Construction World to You. Estimating. Project management. Labor issues. These are issues that you deal with daily in your construction world. Job costing. Increasing bidding and bonding capacity. Tax planning and compliance. These are issues that we deal with daily in our construction world. The Construction Group at Skoda Minotti can deliver on the promise of connecting our construction world to you by leveraging our reputation and relationships with bonding agents and financial institutions to help maximize your bonding capacity and obtain the necessary financing you need, when you need it. For a no-risk analysis of your construction business or to sign up for free quarterly e-mail reports on over 20 segments of the construction industry, call Roger Gingerich at 440-449-6800 or visit our website at www.skodaminotti.com.

www.skodaminotti.com


%(67 :,6+(6 72 $// )25 $ +($/7+< $1' 35263(5286

5(63216,9(1(66 5 (63 632 21 16, 6,9 9( (1(66 1(66 1( 66

()),&,(1&< ( )),&,(1&< 8 1,7 < 81,7<

6675$7(*< 75$7(*<

1(7:25.,1* 1 (7:25.,1*

: ( · 5 ( ( &&20081,7< 20081,7< $ / / / ,1129$7,21 1129$7,21 $%287 $ % 2 8 7 ,1 &2//$%25$7,21 & 2//$%25$7,21

,1 5($/ (67$7( 6(59,&(6 :25/':,'( FEUH FRP FOHYHODQG _ 0DLQ $YHQXH 6XLWH &OHYHODQG 2+


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook