Skip to main content

Northeast Ohio Properties, January 2013

Page 1

INSIDE : Buckeye-Woodhill Rapid Transit Station • 2012/2013 Financial Review & Forecast January 2013/$7.95

Modern Makeover

Lorain County Community College converts outdated library into innovative iLOFT building


The company to trust with your window replacement needs.

The Commercial Window Experts...Since 1969

2800 Euclid Avenue | Cleveland, OH 44115 | (216) 621-4277 | Fax: (216) 621-7665 | www.jamiesonricca.com

Between the weather & You Since 1922

WARREN ROOFING WARREN ROOFING AND INSULATING COMPANY

Working directly with manufacturers to provide efficient, reliable service and installation of a complete selection of roof systems, from single-ply to solar & green roofing. Above All... We Are the roofing ProfessionAls

Commercial/Industrial Roofing + Architectural Sheet Metal

440.439.4404

Fax 440.439.7523

www.warrenroofing.com


Ignoring your environmental issues won’t make them go away.

EA Group has provided environmental consulting and laboratory services to a wide range of clients for over 25 years. We’ve helped hundreds of companies solve their most challenging environmental

BREATHE EASIER

issues from assessments and analysis to project management and remediation. Stop hiding from the problem and put our team to work early to avoid environmental emergencies that can result in costly and unexpected delays. Our expert technicians are experienced in: • Asbestos and Hazardous Materials Management • Site Assessment and Remediation • Indoor Air Quality Assessment • Industrial Hygiene and Safety • Mold Remediation Management • Analytical Laboratory Support

800.875.3514 • 440.951.3514 • www.eagroupohio.com 7118 Industrial Park Boulevard • Mentor, OH 44060


Sweet Success

FROM THE KITCHEN OF:

Ingredients 2 cups character, great 1 pint unique trait and skills 6 cups creative juices 6 qts. SMPS seminars/lunch programs 3 or 4 handfuls SMPS networking & business development opportunities

2 tbsp. SMPS charitable event & donation 4 lbs. SMPS’s Specialty MDSS educational programming and resources 4 tbsp. SMPS mentoring 0 limits Continuous education to taste

1.) Measure and combine your great character, unique traits and skills, and creative juices. Set aside. 2.) In a separate bowl sift together the valuable SMPS seminars and lunch programs, SMPS networking and business development opportunities, SMPS charitable event and donations, SMPS’s Specialty MDSS educational programming and resources, and SMPS mentoring. 3.) Add the combined SMPS ingredients to your original mix and blend on high until thoroughly developed. 4.) Pour this mixture in a heat proof container and place it in an A/E/C industry oven. Watch the sweet success develop. Career advance when golden. 5.) When cool, top with as much continuous quality programming and networking events as you wish.

Sweet Success is a rich, valuable, one-of-a-kind treat that truly stands out. It’s a crowd pleaser and highly requested for all business occasions. Sweet Success is a rich, valuable, one-of-a-kind treat that truly stands out. It’s a crowd pleaser and highly requested for all business occasions. For a sample of SMPS’s Sweet Success visit www.smpsneo.org

We’re not your ordinary commercial landscapers. We’re LandsKeepers.

LandsKeepers Five

Star Landscape & Property Care

440.338.8200 15533 Chillicothe Rd. Novelty, OH 44072

Locations East & West to Serve you Best LandsKeepers is a Pattie Group sister company


January 2013, Volume LXVII, Number 1

phone: 216.251.0035 toll free: 888.641.4241 fax: 216.251.0064 www.propertiesmag.com

FEATURES

CLEVELAND 3826 W. 158th St. Cleveland, Ohio 44111

OWNER/PUBLISHER Kenneth C. Krych kkrych@propertiesmag.com MANAGING EDITOR/ART DIRECTOR Mark Watt mwatt@propertiesmag.com CONTRIBUTING WRITERS Nicole Nashar Andrews, Doug Bardwell, Jeanne Bluffstone, John Elliott, Lou Kren, Alec Pacella, John Slagter, David Woodburn ACCOUNT EXECUTIVES Andrea Keener akeener@propertiesmag.com 216.849.4350 Larry Overbey loverbey@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6649 OFFICE MANAGER Lisa Larissey 216.251.8506 Cover photo: iLOFT at Lorain County Community College, by Scott Pease

Photo by of Scott Pease

AKRON P.O. Box 9 Monroe Falls, Ohio 44262

11

Station I.D.

RTA’s Buckeye-Woodhill transformation broadcasts commitment to accessibility and safety

15 2012/2013 Financial Review & Forecast: Crunching the numbers on Northeast Ohio’s real estate & construction markets 16 Look Back, Look Forward: CBRE offers an overview of Northeast Ohio commercial real estate 2012/2013 23 National Construction Outlook 2013: McGraw-Hill Construction sees shaky start, then 5% increase in New Year 26 A Long Way Back Toward ‘Normal’ 29 Eyeing Commercial Real Estate Investment in 2013: Chasing yield will continue spurring capital investment, transaction volume in New Year 31 Testing the Temperature Among Northeast Ohio Construction Pros: Skoda Minotti’s 2012 survey reveals respondents’ opinions on range of topics

35 Resourceful Representation Examining owner’s rep services as an effective project management solution 44 Designed to Deliver Cleveland-based McTech Corp. spreads wings as GC, CM and Design/Builder 49 Modern Makeover Lorain County Community College converts outdated library into innovative iLOFT building

56 Proper Protection A look at the benefits of a well-maintained building automation system 59 Pet Project Veterinary team realizes dream with new state-of-the-art home for Animal Clinic of Chardon

Properties (ISSN 033-1287) is published monthly for architects, engineers, building owners and managers, general contractors, home builders, mortgage bankers, savings and loans, real estate agents, appraisers, servicers and suppliers in Northern Ohio by Properties, Inc., 3826 W. 158th St., Cleveland, Ohio 44111. Copyright © 2013 by Properties, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction or use, without written permission, of editorial or pictorial content is strictly prohibited. Periodicals postage paid in Cleveland, Ohio and additional offices. Subscription rates: one year $24.95, single copy $7.95, back issues $10 when available. Postmaster: send change of address notices to Properties, P.O. Box 112127, Cleveland, Ohio 44111.

DEPARTMENTS 8 10 36 38 40 41 64

PROPERTIES PEOPLE BOMA BUSINESS LEGAL PERSPECTIVES NAIOP NEWS CABOR CORNER BILLBOARD CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT www.propertiesmag.com 5


PUBLISHER’S NOTE January 2013

A Diverse Mix to Kick Off 2013

H

appy 2013 to everyone! In each issue, we attempt to bring to you a diverse blend of project types. So it is fitting that this being the first issue of the year, we feature three consttruction efforts that are all completely different in nature.

KEN KRYCH

Our cover story focuses on one of many projects to be planned and completed by Lorain County Community College (LCCC). The school’s aging campus library has been converted into a dynamic new type of learning center called iLOFT (Innovative Learning Opportunities for Tomorrow). Whereas LCCC could have gone for a much simpler “classroom” building design, they instead conceived a future-based classroom building utilizing newly designed floor plans, furniture, lighting and state-of-the-art technical systems blended into one very different and beautiful, interesting building. This could well be the model for tomorrow’s classroom building. We are glad to place it on the cover and look forward to bringing more LCCC projects to our pages. Secondly, we visit the newly renovated Buckeye-Woodland RTA station, which is unlike any other. Again,

rather than going with the “norm,” this station, designed by Richard Fleischman Architects, is completely functional yet unique for the site itself. I used to use this station myself many, many times when I was a kid and am familiar with the neighborhood. This new station is a centerpiece for hopefully more renewal to come and new development in the area. Our third feature highlights the Animal Clinic of Chardon, which incorporates best practices from around the country. Built by Kline Construction Corporation, which specializes in these types of facilities, this clinic has many interesting new features, such as a driveup window, to provide the best care for the clinic’s clients and their pets. Look back, look forward Every January, we publish a Financial Review and Forecast special section, in which national and local

Water Damage Fire Damage 24 Hour Emergency Services When the unexpected happens…..

11900 Washington St. Auburn, OH 440-­‐834-­‐1155 RestorationCleveland.com

When the unexpected happens... Residential • Commercial • Industrial • Institutional 11900 Washington St., Auburn, Ohio • www.RestorationCleveland.com

For immediate response 24/7, call 440-834-1155 6

Properties | January 2013


experts weigh in on industry trends and issues of the past 12 months and those coming in the new year, with a particular focus on financial affairs. That continues this month as a great team of contributors lend their expert data analyses and opinions, providing us with a lot of information to consume and consider. I want to thank these firms and individuals, including Dave Browning and his team at CBRE; McGraw-Hill Construction; Skoda Minotti; regular Properties contributor Alec Pacella, of NAI Daus; and Bellwether Real Estate Capital. In addition, this month we welcome an article from IQ Advisers, LLC, Tim Panzica’s new firm, on the subject of owner’s representative services; an article on building automation system maintenance from Jacco & Associates; and a very special profile on general contractor, construction management and design/ build firm McTech Corp. Coming in February Next month, we will tour the new award-winning addition to Robinson Memorial Hospital in Ravenna and its new surgery center. Also featured will be an addition to Laurel Lake Nursing Home in Hudson and the newly completed renovations to the Beachwood and Solon branches of Cuyahoga County Public Libraries. We also will be bringing you our annual special section on Landscaping. We look forward to bringing some important new information from the top experts in their field. As always, we are on the look out for the very best projects to cover, and considering special profiles of companies and anniversaries in 2013, so contact us at 216-251-0035 or email me at kkrych@propertiesmag.com with your ideas and feedback. Let’s make it a prosperous year!

Building Company

Building Company

General Contractor | Commercial & Industrial 216-749-0200 | www.cschulzbuilding.com

There is nothing

Mysterious about

Lightning Protection Just 108 years of engineering principals, field testing and best practices. Lightning protection systems are installed to conform to the following standards: ◆ NFPA 780 (National Fire Protection Association) Est. 1904 ◆ UL 96A (Underwriters Laboratories Inc.) Est. 1916 ◆ LPI (Lightning Protection Institute) Est. 1955 ◆ OSHA (The Occupational Safety & Health Act) Est. 1971

Lightning Protection Installation & Design Specialists

Positively,

Kenneth C. Krych Owner/Publisher

Quality Since 1907 Chagrin Falls, OH 44022 440-247-6727 For more information, read our article in this month’s issue of Properties magazine. www.propertiesmag.com 7


PROPERTIES PEOPLE Highlighting notable industry events

1

2

5

3

6

HBA Awards & Officer Installation Recently, nearly 200 members of the Cleveland Home Builders Association (HBA) gathered for the association’s 69th annual awards and installation banquet at The Intercontinental Hotel Cleveland. This annual event includes awards for achievement and merit, dinner and dancing, as well as installation of incoming officers. This year’s board includes President George Davis (Probuilt Homes), Vice President Rick Colwell (Little Mountain Homes), Treasurer Mike Payne (Payne & Payne Builders), Secretary Ryan Puzzitiello (Parkview Homes) and Past President Enzo Perfetto (Enzoco Homes). P

7

4

8

1 Jodi and Al Scott (NRP Group) 2 Al Scott (NRP Group) and George Davis (ProBuilt Homes) 3 Mike Payne (Payne & Payne Builders) and Enzo Perfetto (Enzoco Homes) 4 George Davis (Probuilt Homes), Rick Colwell (Little Mountain Homes), Mike Payne (Payne & Payne Builders), Ryan Puzzitiello (Parkview Homes) and Enzo Perfetto (Enzoco Homes) 5 Chris and Greg Romes (Lake Pointe Construction Co.) 6 Brenda Callaghan (HBA Cleveland), Herb Stein (Dow Building Solutions) and Enzo Perfetto (Enzoco Homes) 7 Crowd of 200 guests and friends 8 Brenda Callaghan and Stephanie Guzik (HBA)

1

2

Randy Ruttenberg (Fairmount Properties) leads a group tour at Flats East Bank.

Flats East Bank Tour The Greater Cleveland Mortgage Bankers Association (GCMBA) recently presented a luncheon at Fairmount Properties headquarters in downtown Cleveland, followed by a tour of the new Flats East Bank project, with Fairmount Properties principals Randy Ruttenberg and Adam Fishman presiding. P 8

3

Charles Schulz Building Company Christmas Party The Charles Schulz Building Company recently held a holiday party for family and friends at the company’s headquarters in Parma, with pleny of good food, drinks and live ethnic music. P

4 1 Linda Keller, Megan Keller and Annie Schulz 2 Meredith Schneider, Nick Schulz, Randy Whittington and Rick Schulz (Charles Schulz Building Company) 3 Rick Schulz, Linda Kellar, Charles Schulz, Bill and Anne Schulz (Charles Schulz Building Company) 4 Paul Hupalowsky (Marymount Hospital) and Joe Slack (Charles Schulz Building Company)

Properties | January 2013


1

2

3

1

4

5

NAIOP Installation of Officers The Northern Ohio Chapter of NAIOP held its annual meeting and holiday party at the newly renovated Ariel International Building. New officers for 2013 were announced, including President Amy Whitacre (First American Title), Immediate Past President Scott McCready (Cardno ATC), President-Elect Mark Panzica (Panzica Construction), Treasurer Dorinna Unger (McGladrey) and Secretary Jeff Wherry (Wherry Associates). The event included a buffet dinner and a tour of the building. P

13

47

6

1 Scott McCready (Cardno ATC) 2 Mark Panzica (Panzica Companies), Pat Finley (Omni Properties/North Coast Committee Homes Board) and Evan Klotzman (Alpha Park) 3 Radhika Reddy (Ariel Ventures), Diane Davies and Kim Campbell (First American Title) 4 Randy Ruttenberg (Fairmount Properties), Radhika Reddy (Ariel Ventures), Amy Whitacre (First American Title) and Suzanne Hamilton (NAI Daus) 5 Mark Panzica (Panzica Companies), Roby Simons (Cleveland State University) and Evan Klotzman (Alpha Park) 6 Iveta Slosar and Phill Badalamenti (Herschman Architects)

80

22

78

2 1 Analia and Scott Dimit (Dimit Architects) 2 Denise and John Vinton (Palmieri Builders)

Dimit Architects Holiday Party Scott and Analia Dimit, of Dimit Architects, held an annual holiday party at the firm’s expanded headquarters in Lakewood recently. Guests celebrated the good cheer with two great bands, food and drink. P

7

Al Ag Hg Ti Pt Au A L U M I N I U M

S I L V E R

82

Pb Cu L E A D

M E R C U R Y

T I T A N I U M

P L A T I N U M

G O L D

29 Rubber. Now available in silver, platinum, copper and gold.

C O P P E R

2011

Ru

M E T A L L U R G Y

Johnsonite® Metallurgy combines rubber flooring with modern metal aesthetics for a sleek, upscale look. Twelve different colors can be combined in bold and subtle ways for stunning metallic results. Then, coordinate the tile with metallic finishing borders, transitions and stair nosings for a complete flooring system that’s as practical as it is alluring. Johnsonite Metallurgy – cool elements of metal with the performance of rubber. That’s Balanced Choice. For more information, visit johnsonite.com.

Distributed by

Johnsonite_Sobol_Metallurgy_Feb2011.indd 1

Sobol Sales Company

www.propertiesmag.com 9 2/28/11 1:29 PM


Building Owners and Managers Association

Your Professional B U S I N E S S of Greater Cleveland Cleaning Choosing the Best Specialists Janitorial Contractor

or exceeding the specifications set forth in the contract.

Quality Cleaning Services for Over 40 Years Proud Member of BOMA Greater Cleveland

Experience How long has the company been in business and do they service accounts that are similar in size and scope to yours?

Certified Minority Owned Business

Reputation Be sure to contact current as well as past references. Ask for their account retention rate.

Specializing in Servicing Corporate & World Headquarter Buildings, Colleges, Medical & Surgical Facilities and Class A Office Buildings

Financial stability Request a financial statement to confirm that they can cover all of the expenses involved in starting up a new account.

Janitorial Services, Inc.

We’ll Keep It Clean! 5795 Canal Road Valley View, Ohio 44125

216.341.8601 www.jsijanitorial.com

10

R

eceiving a competitive price and a good value is of great importance in the janitorial selection process. But it is important to remember that the best bid is not always the lowest bid. Do some benchmarking by comparing multiple proposals and thoroughly reviewing what each firm has to offer. Here is a list of criteria to help you get started.

Certifications & memberships Affiliations with strong organizations provide more opportunities to increase industry knowledge and what the contractor can offer their clients. Janitorial contractors may choose to be members of BOMA, IFMA, ISSA, IREM or other associations. Minority certifications or Green Cleaning certifications are also assets that a company can bring to the table. Value-added services The best janitorial contractors are flexible, willing to meet your changing needs without over-charging. They should seek out cost savings opportunities – and pass them along.

Contract Avoid contracts that do not include a cancellation clause if you are receiving poor service. If your janitorial “The janitorial contractor is not meeting your needs, you should be selection process isn’t able to give them a reaamount of notice just a matter of finding sonable to correct the issues, and the ability to cancel the the lowest price.” contract.

Management Look for long term, experienced managers. The company you choose should have open lines of communication and managers who are in touch with you and visit your facility frequently.

The janitorial selection process isn’t just a matter of finding the lowest price. It is more about finding the best company to meet the needs of your building. Selecting the lowest bid can be a costly mistake in the long run.

Personnel The best janitorial contractors offer extensive training and development courses to their workforce. They conduct background checks on all potential candidates and require that each employee look professional and wear a uniform and ID badge at all times.

BOMA Greater Cleveland is proud to provide this space to our Associate Members so they can inform, educate and share their knowledge with property management professionals. This article was written by Kristen Yankovitz, director of sales & marketing at Janitorial Services, Inc. She can be reached at 216-341-8601 or kbenne@jsijanitorial.com.

Quality A strong janitorial service has quality control programs in place, including inspections, job tracing, and other checks and balances to promote consistency and clean buildings while meeting

Executive Vice President BOMA Greater Cleveland

Janice Parham

For more info on this article or BOMA Greater Cleveland, contact Janice Parham at 216.575.0305 or jparham@bomacleveland.org Properties | January 2013


Station I.D.

RTA’s Buckeye-Woodhill transformation broadcasts commitment to accessibility and safety By Lou Kren | Photos by Stephen Manka

B

uckeye-Woodhill Rapid Transit Station has undergone quite a change. Greater Clevelanders found out how extensive that change was last fall when RTA officials officially dedicated the newly reconstructed station, which serves patrons riding RTA’s Green and Blue rail lines. Formerly a dim depression leading to the rapid platform with covered stairs descending opposing slopes, the new $3.65 million station is accurately described as a halo. A structural-steelsupported fiberglass panel canopy forms that halo, with the effect heightened at night as lighting seeps up through translucent canopy panels to illuminate the entire structure. The canopy covers new ADA-compliant switchback ramps – with bisecting stairs – that traverse slopes on each side of the tracks down to customer platforms, with a ramp system in place allowing wheelchair users to board the trains. The platforms are accessible from both Buckeye and Woodhill roads.

The facility also includes public art. Themed “the heart and soul of Buckeye,” the main sculpture is a 21-foot-tall stainless steel, 1940s-style microphone accented with blue LED lights, visible from both the east and westbound platforms. Fabricated and installed by Moritz Wood and Metal, the microphone serves as an ode to the community’s jazz history. Commuters now have 33 free parking spots, with more possible as RTA has acquired some additional parcels adjoining the site above the south ramps.

Driving the design The halo effect of the canopy, as well as installation of the ramps, hints at why the station underwent reconstruction. RTA

officials wanted a safer, more secure station that also would be ADA-accessible. Properties recently toured the new station with Tim Neufer, project architect with Richard Fleischman + Partners Architects, Inc., of Cleveland; Art Conell, project manager from Great Lakes Crushing Ltd., of Willowick; and project manager Ken Folk, resident engineer with RTA. All three noted the importance of bringing an ADA component to this project along with addressing safety concerns. The project also was designed as a catalyst for the Buckeye-Woodhill neighborhood, as RTA has approached recent projects with an eye toward partnering with local communiwww.propertiesmag.com 11


SAFETY & STYLE Two structural steel-supported fiberglass panel shelters provide a safe and open setting at the new Buckeye-Woodhill RTA station, while a 21-foot structural steel microphone sculpture adds a dramatic, aesthetic accent.

ties to help promote surrounding development. That is happening in Buckeye-Woodhill, with ODOT set to replace a bridge that abuts the station, and with businesses slated to open in the vicinity. The project also brings a new walkway to an adjoining city park. “This updated station has an attractive, high-quality design that is

12

passenger-friendly and will make the Buckeye-Woodhill Rapid Transit Station universally accessible,” says Joe Calabrese, RTA CEO and general manager, in commenting on the dedication.

Change in plans Planning for the station’s reconstruction began about three years ago,

according to Folk, when RTA sought to address the ADA issue. “Initial plans called for an elevator and regular headhouse like at most existing RTA station facilities,” says Folk, “but elevators brought safety and maintenance issues.” With the original elevator/headhouse design out for bid and growing concern regarding the elevators, Richard Fleischman forwarded an idea for the canopy-halo design, and from there the project progressed. “We presented a halo effect for the station so at night it would light up like a beacon, representing the terminus of the Shaker line,” explains Neufer. “The ramps, with benches at the end of each turnaround, would address the ADA issue, and the canopy covering the ramps would let light through. As built, the station provides openness and good sightlines, so that helps with security. The designers, engineers and builders were challenged by the need to adapt the differing elevations and grades on each side of the tracks for the ramps, with the ramps employing a shallow incline and opportunities Properties | January 2013


FUNCTIONAL FORMS Canopies on the south side of the tracks (top) and north (bottom) combine to create a “halo” to be lit like a beacon at night.

for patrons to rest with the built-in benches along the ramp paths.”

Tight, sloping site With Great Lakes Crushing leading the effort as general contractor, crews broke ground in June 2011. The work followed an effort from the prior year to replace track sections and install concrete ties. Throughout construction, at least 100 feet of platform space stayed open, a challenging proposition on such a small site, according to Conell. “The station had to remain operating, through all of the site work, foundation construction and concrete pouring,” he says, noting that as many as 30 Great Lakes workers were on site at one time as the firm self-performed all major elements of construction. “That required coordination to stage the work and keep crews to a minimum in the tight space. We could work within 10 feet of the rail lines only during line shutdowns, so we coordinated with RTA’s shutdown schedule in scheduling our tasks, and also timed some work to coincide with shutdowns related to other RTA projects on the affected rapid lines.” The steep grade south of the tracks required major excavation to meet required ramp grades, with less site work required to the north. A new

foundation of caissons, drilled piers – from 10 to 30 feet deep – and footers support the ramps and canopies, which necessitated “creative road work,” according to Conell, to navi-

gate equipment and material down the steep slopes. To ensure that specs were met for the architecturally exposed steel that supports the aluminum-framed fibericonic sculpture decorative metal huge concrete interior / exterior enivironmental graphics

www.StephenManka.com

info@mankadesignstudio.com

216.212.5900

Cleveland OH

www.propertiesmag.com 13


t

Proud to have been part of the team for the newly completed Buckeye-Woodland RTA station

RAMP ROUTES The canopy covers new ADA-compliant switchback ramps – with bisecting stairs – that traverse slopes on each side of the tracks down to customer platforms, with a ramp system in place allowing wheelchair users to board the trains.

Pre-ConstruCtion serviCes ProjeCt ManageMent MaintenanCe and serviCe design Build Greater Cleveland and Akron’s preferred Electric Contractor for nearly 20 years, specializing in meeting customers’ needs for new construction wiring, commercial repairs or electrical design. Our philosophy is simple: “We meet the needs of our customers.”

9177 Dutton Dr., Unit 9 Twinsburg, Ohio 44087 (330) 425-1270 www.horvathelectric.com 14

glass canopy panels, project principals communicated closely with the steel fabricator and made several visits to the supplier’s production facility, according to Neufer, Folk and Conell. Grinding has removed visible weld seams, and the steel itself hides conduit for the below-canopy lighting that follows the paths of the ramps. Not only functional, the steel is a sight in itself. Come spring, a multicolored tile pattern, Ribbons of Hope, will be added to the sloped areas between the ramps as part of the project’s art component. Also, RTA will be adding LED signage to provide train information for commuters, augmenting a new sound system that also will relay RTA updates. The project also brought new light poles along the tracks as well as a new crosswalk and new and refurbished railings. Crews also installed new electrical service to the station.

The people had a say Buckeye-Woodhill Rapid Transit Station boasts a fully functional contemporary look, in sharp contrast to the 1980s-era renovation it replaces. Commuters already have commented

on the improved station, which stands to reason as the local community had a say in the project. Early on, according to Neufer, designers wondered if the ramps would be as welcoming as the original elevator-tower design. But at a community meeting, local residents opted for ramps with benches as being much more desirable than dark, enclosed elevator shafts. Desirability also extends to the lighted canopy and public art, which give the station personality above and beyond what is traditionally found in transit facilities. “The new station resembles a great performance pavilion and it seemed to need a great microphone,” says Stephen Manka, of Manka Design Studio, in Cleveland, who sculpted the microphone, titled Microphonic. “While waiting for the train, riders are encouraged to sing out. I wanted to tap into the heart and soul of Buckeye.” The station, considered a prototype for future stations, according to RTA officials, paves the way for transit-oriented development in Buckeye-Woodhill, and gives commuters a whole new level of safety, accessibility and comfort. P Properties | January 2013


2012 FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST

2013 Crunching the numbers on Northeast Ohio’s real estate & construction markets


2012 FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST

2013

Look Back, Look Forward CBRE offers an overview of Northeast Ohio commercial real estate 2012/2013 Story & images provided by CBRE

W

e at CBRE are pleased to present a review of 2012 and a preview of commercial real estate activity for 2013 in Northeast Ohio. The market clearly improved during the past year across all property types. The impact of this varied depending upon the underlying supply-demand scenario. We are pleased to report that downtown Cleveland seems to really be on a roll. The combination of public and private investment, along with a generational preference for urban mixed-use environments, is creating a demand for downtown living and office space. Although the global economy and U.S. tax policy are creating challenges, we see good things ahead for Northeast Ohio in 2013.

slow but steady, and parties are still willing to provide meaningful concessions in order to secure business with credit OFFICE INDUSTRIAL RETAIL tenants. Large block Class A space remains difficult to assemble with only VACANCY a handful of suburban opportunities to INVENTORY the east. Highlighted by a number of sizeACTIVITY able relocations from the suburbs, Cleveland’s CBD may have shined the QUOTED brightest in 2012, as overall vacancy LEASE RATES dropped the fourth straight quarter Serving the designfor & construction community NEGOTIATED Northeast Ohio Office Market to 18.6%. BrandMuscle, Dwellworks LEASE RATES By Steve Voinovich and Britton Gallagher are just three Serving & community Servingthe thedesign design & construction construction community g this proof, you are approving the content for placement inPRICES Sabre Publishing, Group Inc., publications (BXM, Ohio A&E SALES Senior Associate examples of in-migration, representonly. The payment you have agreed to is for “space only”. — Thank you for choosing Sabre Publishing Group to promote your ing a total of nearly 100,000 square vices! By you are approving the content for placement in Sabre Publishing, Group Inc., publications(BXM, (BXM, Ohio ng approving this proof,this youproof, are approving theTcontent for placement in Sabre Publishing, Group Inc., publications Ohio A&E A&E INVESTMENT he 2012 feet.the design Additionally, Alexander Mann Serving construction community Serving&the design & construction community oronly. InScope) only. The payment you have agreed to is for “space only”. — Thank you for choosing Sabre Publishing Group to promote your The payment you have agreed to is for “space only”. — Thank you for choosing Sabre Publishing Group to promote your Serving the designa & construction community Northeast Ohio Solutions, London-based recruitment SALES roducts & services! ACTIVITY vices! Office leasing firm, selected Downtown Cleveland for PRICES vingBy this proof, you approving content forcontent placement in Sabre in Publishing, Group Inc., publications (BXM, (BXM, Ohio A&E approving thisare proof, you are the approving the for placement Sabre Publishing, Group Inc., publications Ohio A&E market continued Company name: Frantz its U.S. hub and is projected toWard employ Source: CBRE By approving this proof, you are approving the content for placement in Sabre Publishing, Group Inc., publications (BXM, Ohio A&E pe) only. The payment you have agreed to is for “space only”. — Thank you for choosing Sabre Publishing Group to promote your or InScope) only. The payment you have agreed to is for “space only”. — Thank you for choosing Sabre Publishing Group to promote your or InScope) only. The paymentto you haveupon agreed to is for “space only”. — Thank you for choosing Sabre Publishing Group to promote build the over 300 withinyour three years. Jones Day, services! products & services! Issue: name: Frantz 12X Ward a year Company products & services! grow when year-end statistics are finalized. previous year’s GMAC, Oswald, GrantFrantz Thornton Company name: Ward and Section: momentum with While we noticed a minimal increase in Willis also solidified their CBD Issue: 12XN/A a yearpresence Issue: 12X a year most submarkets overall asking rental rates, actual “taking” by making long-term commitments. Sales rep: Chelsea Morris Section: N/A Company name: Frantz Ward Company name: Frantz Ward Section: Company downtown name: N/A Frantz Ward experiencing a rates vary from deal to deal and are often The thriving residential Sales rep: Chelsea Morris Issue: 12X a year Issue: 12Xaayear year steady increase in activity. At the end a reflection of the financial strength of market has triggered several office Issue: 12X Serving the design & construction Sales rep: community Chelsea Morris to both landlords and tenants as opposed to of the 3rdit for quarter, year-to-date positive residential or Section: hotel conversions, Section: N/A N/A some Please check accuracy and content. Section: Serving the design & construction community N/A By approving this proof,reached you are approving the content square for placementfeet, in Sabre Publishing, Group Inc., (BXM, Ohio a measure ofpublications the market inA&Egeneral. This ofServing absorption 400,000 which are underway (Hanna Annex) the design & construction community or InScope) only. The payment you have agreed to is for “space only”. — Thank you for choosing Sabre Publishing Group to promote your Sales Chelsea Morris Sales rep: rep: Chelsea Morris Sales rep: Chelsea Morris products & services! with the CBD accounting for nearly half inconsistency in pricing only underscores with more planned (East Ohio, which sentiment that Horizontal the recovery has been was just awarded Ohio tax credits). The of that amount. We expect this number to the 1/3 Page

2013

Northeast Ohio OUTLOOK

s is your ad proof sheckisit foris your adadproof This your proof accuracy and content. sheck is proof This your ad proof lease check itis for accuracy and content. it for your accuracy andad content. This is your ad proof check for accuracy and content. Pleaseitcheck it for accuracy and content. Please check it for accuracy and content.

This is your ad proof

1/3 Page Horizontal 1/3Page Page Horizontal Horizontal 1/3 1/3 Page Horizontal 1/3 Page Horizontal 1/3 Page Horizontal

Serving the design & construction community

Company name:

Frantz Ward

Issue:

12X a year

Section:

N/A

Sales rep:

Chelsea Morris

Serving design & construction Serving the design & construction communitycommunity Serving the design &the construction community

Result-Oriented and Reliable Legal Assistance for the Construction Industry Result-Oriented and• Competitive Reliable Legal Assistance for the Construction Industry Claims Management and Avoidance Bidding • Schedule Disputes Result-Oriented and Reliable Legal Assistance the Disputes Construction Industry Claims Management and Avoidance • Competitive Bidding •for Schedule Defective Work and Design Claims • Project Delivery and Conceptualization • Mechanic’s Liens Defective Work and Design •Claims Project Bidding Delivery Conceptualization • Mechanic’s Liens Industry Claims Management and Avoidance Competitive •and Schedule Disputes Result-Oriented and•Reliable Reliable Legal Assistance forforthe Construction BUSINESS IS HELPING OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING Result-Oriented and Legal Assistance the Construction Industry OUR Surety BondSurety Claims • Labor and Employment • Arbitration and Mediation • Litigation OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING Result-Oriented and Reliable Legal Assistance for the Construction Industry OUR BUSINESS IS IS HELPING OUR BUSINESS HELPING Claims • Labor• Project and • Arbitration and Mediation • Litigation Defective Work andBond Design Claims Delivery• Competitive and Conceptualization • Mechanic’s Claims Management and Employment Avoidance Bidding • Schedule Disputes Liens BUSINESS IS YOUROUR BUSINESS SUCCEED. YOUR BUSINESSHELPING SUCCEED. Serving the design & construction community

Result-Oriented and Reliable Legal Assistance for the Construction Claims Management and• Avoidance • Competitive Bidding Industry •Disputes Schedule Disputes Claims Management andWork Avoidance Competitive Bidding • Mediation Schedule Defective and Design Claims • Project Delivery and Conceptualization Liens Surety Bond Claims • Labor and • Arbitration and • Litigation • Mechanic’s Claims Management andEmployment Avoidance • Competitive Bidding • Schedule Disputes Defective Work and Design Claims • Project Delivery and Conceptualization • Mechanic’s Liens Defective Work and Claims Design Claims• •Project Project Delivery and Conceptualization • Mechanic’s Liens Defective Work Surety and Design Delivery and Conceptualization • Mechanic’s Liens Bond Claims • Labor and Employment • Arbitration and Mediation • Litigation OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING Surety Bond Claims • Labor and Employment • Arbitration and Mediation • Litigation OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING Surety•Bond • •Labor and Employment Arbitration and Mediation • Litigation YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED. YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED. Contact: Ian H.• and Frank Surety Bond Claims LaborClaims and Employment • Arbitration Mediation • Litigation YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED.

• Contact: Ian H. Frank • Contact: IanIan H. |Frank • Contact: H. Frank 127 Public Square 2500 Key Center | Cleveland, Ohio 44114-1230 • Contact: Ian H.H.Frank 216.515.1660• Contact: - FAX 216.515.1650 | www.frantzward.com Ian Frank 127 Public Square Center | Cleveland, Ohio 44114-1230 • Contact: Ian| 2500 H. Key Frank

127 Public Square | 2500 Key Center | Cleveland, Ohio 44114-1230 216.515.1660 - FAX 216.515.1650 | www.frantzward.com

YOURBUSINESS BUSINESS YOUR BUSINESS YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED. OUR ISSUCCEED. HELPING OUR BUSINESS ISSUCCEED. HELPING YOUR BUSINESS OUR BUSINESS ISSUCCEED. HELPING OURYOUR BUSINESS ISSUCCEED. HELPING YOUR BUSINESS OUR BUSINESS BUSINESS ISSUCCEED. HELPING OUR BUSINESS HELPING OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED. OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED. YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED. OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED. YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED. OUR BUSINESS IS HELPING YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED. YOUR YOUR BUSINESS BUSINESS SUCCEED. YOURSUCCEED. BUSINESS SUCCEED. YOUR BUSINESS SUCCEED.

127 Public Square | 2500 Key Center | Cleveland, Ohio 44114-1230 216.515.1660 - FAX 216.515.1650 | www.frantzward.com

127 Public Square | 2500 Key Center | Cleveland, Ohio 44114-1230

216.515.1660 - FAX 216.515.1650 | www.frantzward.com 216.515.1660 - FAX| 2500 216.515.1650 | www.frantzward.com 127 Public Square Key Center | Cleveland, Ohio 44114-1230 127 Public 216.515.1660 Square | 2500- Key | Cleveland, Ohio 44114-1230 FAXCenter 216.515.1650 | www.frantzward.com 216.515.1660 FAX 216.515.1650 | www.frantzward.com Approved by: __________________________________________________ Date: __________

16

Properties | January 2013


Medical Mart and Convention Center as well as the Ernst & Young Tower are nearing completion and will open on time in 2013. Both projects will generate sustainable activity in areas that have been stagnant for several years. The Cuyahoga County headquarters consolidation announcement closed out 2012. The County’s decision will certainly have ripple effects on the CBD landscape as a number of buildings are expected to change ownership and consequently take on a new use. The specifics will be announced in early 2013. While Eaton Corporation’s move to their 580,000-square-foot suburban headquarters will certainly impact 2013 statistics, we otherwise remain optimistic that positive momentum will continue in the CBD. As for the suburban submarkets, the Chagrin Corridor experienced a drop in Class B vacancy, due in large part to the demolition of the Commerce Park office complex. Former tenants in the complex were forced to relocate and therefore plugged several holes in the Class B market. High-end apartments will be constructed in place of the demolished buildings, which should reenergize the western end of the corridor. The Lander Corridor experienced negative absorption due to Progressive Insurance vacating 85,000 square feet. Overall, the Eastern suburban submarkets remained stable with 90,000 square feet of positive absorption and vacancy remains the lowest of all submarkets at 16.8%. That said, there is some uncertainty surrounding future plans for the 895,000-square-foot Gotham King Portfolio (now in receivership and under control of the special servicer), which may impact 2013 statistics. Heading south to the Rockside Corridor, overall vacancy declined and absorption was positive. Momentum is further evidenced by Sedgwick CMS signing a long-term lease for over 51,000 square feet in Seven Hills. They will relocate from Solon and occupy space in part of the Duke Portfolio (which has been rumored to trade to Och-Ziff Capital Management out of New York). While 2012 overall lease rates and vacancy remained flat in the Western

Submarket, there will be significant activity in 2013. Hyland Software is evaluating the possibility of connecting their current headquarters building to a new, to-be-constructed, 112,000-square-foot building. Equity Trust will consolidate their Northeast Ohio operations and move approximately 375 people into the former Cleveland Clinic Building on Clemens

Road. While American Greetings temporarily placed their 700,000-square-foot headquarters plans at Crocker Park on hold, due to uncertainty surrounding the Weiss family’s proposal to take the company private, we anticipate the project to resume at some point. Our firm remains optimistic about the prospects for the local office market,

Global Reach, Local Focus

Office • Industrial • Retail • Capital Markets Asset Services • Appraisal • Consulting Global Corporate Services

216.687.1800

CLEVELAND | AKRON

www.cbre.com www.propertiesmag.com 17


2012 FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST

2013 believing that while we are still in the early stages of a recovery, we are recovering. Barring any dramatic changes to the (here’s the disclaimer!) national and worldwide economies, Northeast Ohio is well positioned for continued positive absorption of its existing inventory of office space.

Northeast Ohio Industrial Market By George Stevens Vice President

Office: Suburban Vacancy vs. Lease Rate $19.00

25.0% 24.0%

$18.50

23.0% $18.00

22.0% 21.0%

$17.50 $17.00

Vacancy

19.0%

Lease Rates

18.0%

$16.50

17.0% $16.00

As forecasted last year, the 2012 Northeast Ohio Industrial Market maintained its uptrend and positive absorption, albeit slow and steady. Overall availability rate for the approximate 292 million-square-foot Northeast Ohio market year-over-year remained

20.0%

16.0% 15.0%

$15.50 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Source: CBRE

flat with a slight decrease from 8.2% in 2011 to 8% year end 2012, while lease rates have slightly increased from $4.41 per square foot to $4.57 per square foot. Certain segments of the Northeast Ohio Industrial building market showed significant strength as com-

pared to other national industrial markets. Most notably, the availability rate in modern distribution facilities (defined as buildings larger than 100,000 square feet built in the last 12 years, with 24-foot clear height or higher, and feature ESFR sprinkler systems) is under 6%.

When your fair share of taxes is neither fair... nor your share Billions in assessment reductions The attorneys at Siegel Jennings bring experience as accountants, appraisers and real estate developers to the practice of law. Our property tax services include: ■ Representation at the administrative level through the State Supreme Court ■ Local expertise in every state through the American Property Tax Counsel ■ Tax management – acquisition/disposition strategies ■ Cutting edge approaches to property tax reductions

Siegel Jennings 18

Call J. Kieran Jennings, Esq at 216.763.1004

Cleveland ■ Pittsburgh ■ Columbus

23425 Commerce Park Drive, Suite 103, Beachwood OH 44122 www.siegeltax.com

Founding member, American Property Tax Counsel (APTC) • www.aptc.com

Properties | January 2013


The notable lease deals of 2012 in the Northeast Ohio market were featured in this modern product type: Noco and Ryder Logistics leased the remaining 130,000 square feet in the Diamond Center in Glenwillow and Vita-Mix leased 175,500 square feet of modern distribution space in Strongsville. The year 2012 featured the delivery and announcements of several significant build-to-suit projects throughout the region including: the opening of Vallourec’s new $650 million rolling mill plant in Youngstown at the heart of the Marcellus and Utica Shale play; Newell Rubbermaid’s announcement it will be occupying a newly constructed 800,000-square-foot warehouse and distribution facility in Brimfield Township; Performance Food Group occupying its new 135,000-squarefoot building in Twinsburg’s new Cornerstone Business Park (former Chrysler Plant); and OverDrive moving into its 95,000-square-foot new world headquarters in Garfield Heights. The most significant industrial investment property offering of 2012 is the CalSTERS’s 16-building, 1.5 million-square-foot Northeast Ohio portfolio with properties located in Solon, Twinsburg, Highland Heights and Strongsville. It is expected there will be a buyer for the portfolio in early 2013. Looking forward into 2013, there will be four quickly evolving, key-market trends for the near-term horizon (next 12-18 months). 1. Sale prices will continue to bid up, due to the decrease in the supply of non-functionally obsolete buildings for sale and the relatively higher cost of new construction. 2. Effective Rental Rates will continue their slow upward ascent from the 2009-2010 lows as the availability rate will continue to decrease coupled with no new speculative industrial construction projects coming on line in 2013. 3. After four years with a limited number of new industrial buildings being constructed, expect owner-

Industrial: Availability Rates vs. Lease Rates $6.00

12.0%

$5.00

10.0%

$4.00

8.0%

$3.00

6.0%

Lease Rates Availability Rate

$2.00

4.0%

$1.00

2.0%

0.0%

$-­‐ 2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

Source: CBRE

users to break ground on several new build-to-suit projects throughout the region by utilizing historically inexpensive financing as well as the many state and local incentives tied to new job creation. 4. While 2013 may not have much speculative construction in the pipeline, expect to see some signs of growing confidence in the market fundamentals shown by initial planning and pre-marketing by select local and regional developers for partially pre-leased (50% or greater) modern distribution buildings that will be delivered in 2014.

Northeast Ohio Retail Market By Keith A. Hamulak Sales Associate, Retail The Northeast Ohio retail market is on the doorstep to recovery. The vacancy rate in Northeast Ohio declined to its lowest level since 2008. The rate of 10.27% represents a major improvement since 2010 where the vacancy rate peaked at 12.49%. The positive absorption can be attributed to new retailer expansion and existing retail tenants’ strategically adding new stores. Major contributors to the

positive absorption in 2012 included: Burlington Coat Factory, Michael’s, Value King, Roses, Panera Bread, Family Dollar and Dollar General and a slew of fitness operators. Also noteworthy, several retail tenants are in the process of downsizing formats and giving space back to owners including: H.H. Gregg, Staples, Kmart and Sears, and Best Buy. Average retail lease rates have increased slightly year over year as the supply of inventory declines and the competition for the best real estate increases. Rental rates in Class C shopping centers declined and most retailers that have been successful with a percentage rent only deal in this product type. Rental rates in Class B shopping centers have increased, due in part to the absorption of the majority of Class A vacancy. Grocery-anchored shopping centers and Class A power centers have experienced an increase in lease rates from the previous year. Recently built shopping centers in South Euclid and Avon have been successful in obtaining rental rates in the mid-$20s triple net. The average asking rental rate for the 77 million square feet of retail space in the eight county trade area is $16.00 per square foot. Average triple net charges for the same 77 million square feet are $3.50 per square foot. It is anticipated that new construction projects will surpass one million square feet of retail in 2013. The majority of these developments are grocery-anchored shopwww.propertiesmag.com 19


2012 FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST

2013 ping centers. The developments include the relocation of an undersized grocery store, the redevelopment of a functionally obsolete center, multiple infill projects and a greenfield development in Green. Developers eager to assist Giant Eagle and Wal-Mart in refining their retail distribution channels in Northeast Ohio will be the most active. Mature trade areas in the first ring suburbs as well as the City of Cleveland proper will be the most desirable. The brightest outlook for 2013 is investment real estate activity. Several factors will contribute to historically low capitalization rates including, increased consumer spending, a decrease in unemployment, low interest rates and most importantly the ability to raise cash from investors. Multiple investment funds are currently in the market competing for properties. Grocery-anchored shopping centers remain the most desirable, followed by single-tenant, net-leased assets.

Office: CBD Vacancy vs. Lease Rates $19.00

23.0%

$18.50

22.0%

$18.00

21.0%

$17.50

20.0%

$17.00

19.0%

$16.50

18.0%

$16.00

17.0%

$15.50

16.0%

$15.00

Lease Rates

15.0% 2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

Source: CBRE

In closing, the retail environment in 2013 will be significantly better than 2012. Early sales results suggest a stronger holiday season than last year. Increased rental rates and decreased vacancy bode well for shopping center owners. New construction and store growth will rebound to prerecession levels. The retail investment market will be ultra competitive with

Full Service Electrical Supply Distributor Energy Focused Solutions Energy Focused Solutions: Energy Audits & Retrofit Recommendations Group Relamping Programs Recycling Programs Turnkey Lighting Retrofits Available Available Full Line of Electrical Supplies Including Solar & LED Products Expert Lighting & Gear Project Management Group Contract Pricing E-Commerce Depth & Breadth of Inventory

4700 Spring Road Cleveland, Ohio 44131 P:216.432.3000 F:216.432.0051 www.leffelectric.com 20

Vacancy

an oversupply of buyers contributing to decreased capitalization rates.

Northeast Ohio Equity Market By Vicki Maeder, CCIM Vice President, Cleveland Private Capital Group Capital market activity continued to improve in 2012, in spite of concerns over the elections and the “fiscal cliff” dilemma. Investors were still cautious but eager to acquire quality assets. Others preferred to chase value-add opportunities. The focus for most of the institutional investors continued to be the strongest in the primary major cities where cap rates once again began dropping as more capital chased the same deals, thus driving up pricing. Financing options from multiple sources provided investors with more financing choices. The smaller deals attract the local banks/savings-and-loan, while larger deals generate the institutional money sources – thus eliminating many of the contingencies for financing that we saw in offers just two years ago. More investors have come back to the market but a strong track record and equity are needed. The Cleveland market attracted the majority of interest from local investors/ developers in 2012 as well as interest from national investors. The hottest demand continued to be net-leased properties with Properties | January 2013


Space Comfort co.

Heating & Cooling Family owned & operated with hands-on experience in mechanical contracting sales & service since 1964. Experts in: n Turnkey solutions, design/build & value engineering n Service, installation & maintenance of all makes & models of HVAC equipment & boilers n New, renovation, remodeling & restoration n Public & private Providing reliable, personal service to owners of retail centers, malls, apartment complexes, retirement housing in Ohio & neighboring states.

5201 Clark avenue, Cleveland OhiO 44102 n Ph. 216-281-2000 n Fax. 216-281-8420 n 800-203-9645

The Building Owners & Managers Association of Greater Cleveland The Building Owners & Managers Association of Greater Cleveland

Your Money Your Money $aving $aving Resource Resource

Your investment in BOMA Greater Cleveland provides signicant returns to you and Yourcompany’s investmentbo�om in BOMA Greater Cleveland provides signicant returns and your line. Member’s receive substan�al savings for to theyou following your company’s bo�om line. Member’s receive substan�al savings for the following items and services: items and services:  Air Filters  Electricity Supply  Air Filters  Supply  Natural Gas Supply  Electricity Workers Compensa�on Insurance  Natural Gas Supply  Workers Compensa�on Insurance  Lamps, Ballasts & Electrical Supplies  And many other items & services!  Lamps, Ballasts & Electrical Supplies  And many other items & services!  Paint & Related Supplies  Paint & Related Supplies

Call membershipand andstart startsaving savingtoday! today! Call about about membership The mission of the Building Owners & Managers AssociaƟon of Greater Cleveland is to provide advocacy, professional development, networking The mission of the Building Owners & Managers Greater Cleveland is for to provide advocacy, professional development, networking andAssociaƟon economic of savings opportuniƟes its members. and economic savings opportuniƟes for its members. 200 Public Square, Suite 209, Cleveland, Oh 44114  www.bomacleveland.org  ph: 216.575.0305 200 Public Square, Suite 209, Cleveland, Oh 44114  www.bomacleveland.org  ph: 216.575.0305 www.propertiesmag.com 21


2012 FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST

2013 over 10 years of remaining term on the lease with credit tenants. Those properties with less than 10 years of term remaining have been more difficult to finance and have a major impact on the value. Ground leases were also drawing strong interest. Multi-family, grocery-anchored retail centers and medical office properties were next in favor, as was the case in 2011.

Interest in office buildings was the strongest from user buyers and redevelopers. Offerings of stabilized office buildings attracted less interest from investors but activity and pricing were solid. Retail centers, both distressed and stabilized, brought strong interest from investors. Sales in the market were accomplished through traditional marketing

efforts, but also as a result of note sales, short sales and auctions. Overall, the capitalization rates have tended to compress as demand has increased. With strong leasing activity, vacancies are decreasing and values are improving as properties stabilize. The expectation is that 2013 will generate the same level of activity as in 2012. There are still distressed assets that need to work their way through the system. Concern about tax policy and the global economy is impacting decisions. P Information included in this article has been obtained from sources believed reliable. CBRE has not verified it and makes no guarantee, warranty or representation about it. Any projections, opinions, assumptions or estimates used are for example only and do not represent the current or future performance of the property. You and your advisors should conduct an independent investigation of properties to determine to your satisfaction the suitability of the property for your needs.

A SENSIBLE SOLUTION TO STORMWATER MANAGEMENT Porous Asphalt Pavements provide an innovative approach to detain or infiltrate storm-water runoff.

The Road to Cleanliness Starts Here CALL FOR A NO COST PARKING AREA ASSESSMENT

• Sweeping • Pressure Washing • Scrubbing • Pavement Repairs • Striping • Salting

• Snow Plowing • Construction Sites • Parking Lots • Parking Decks • Warehouses • Special Events

The design of POROUS ASPHALT PAVEMENTS allows water to flow through them. They are: •

Economical – fast, easy to construct and long lasting

•

Sustainable – conserves water, reduces runoff, improves water quality, replenishes aquifers, protects streams, cooler cities

•

Safer – imagine never again stepping in a puddle of water or on an ice covered surface

For more information, contact Flexible Pavements of Ohio at (888) 4HOTMIX or visit our website at www.flexiblepavements.org.

Since 1990 6205 Emerald Parkway, Suite B, Dublin, Ohio 43016 • www.flexiblepavements.org Twitter: @Ohio_Asphalt • www.facebook.com/flexiblepavements

330-798-9200

www.buckeyesweeping.com 22

Properties | January 2013


National Construction Outlook 2013 McGraw-Hill Construction sees shaky start, then 5% increase in New Year

A

fter the steep decline of 2007-2009, the construction industry has shown a few glimmers of recovery, but overall there’s not yet been sufficient traction to say that renewed expansion has taken hold. As reported by McGraw-Hill Construction, new construction starts in 2010 edged up 2%, followed by another 1% gain in 2011, and the current year is headed for a 5% increase to $458 billion. This still leaves the volume of total construction starts 32% below the 2005 peak on a current dollar basis, and down about 50% when viewed on a constant dollar basis. The modest gains experienced during the past two years have in effect produced an extended bottom for construction starts, in which the process of recovery is being stretched out. The pattern of construction starts seems to be in a “balancing act,” where gains for a few project types are offset by declines for other project types. The upturn for multifamily housing has been joined in 2012 by a strengthening single-family market. Several commercial project types, notably hotels and warehouses, have picked up the pace, and electric utility construction will reach a new record high. However, the institutional building sector has weakened considerably during 2012, adversely affected by tight federal, state and local budgets, while public works construction has experienced further erosion. The backdrop for the construction industry remains the fragile U.S. economy. Real GDP in the second quarter of 2012 grew just 1.3%, and for all of 2012 the GDP increase is estimated at 2.1%. The employment statistics have reflected this hesitation, as growth in the second quarter fell to just 67,000 jobs per month, before bouncing back in the third quarter to 146,000 jobs per month. The main obstacle to stronger growth for the U.S. economy is the pervasive sense of uncertainty, which has dampened business investment and hiring. Earlier in 2012, at least some of this uncertainty was related to concerns over the potential spread of the European debt crisis, but by midyear the anxiety about the impend-

ing “fiscal cliff” (the expiring tax cuts combined with reduced federal spending) became dominant. Along with the uncertainty created by the 2012 presidential election, many firms placed plans for investment on hold. The fiscal cliff posed a significant downside risk to the near-term prospects for the U.S. economy and the

A U.S. economy that avoids recession in early 2013 will allow several positive factors to benefit construction. Interest rates are very low, and lending standards for commercial real estate loans are easing. Significantly, market fundamentals for several project types are strengthening. This includes rent growth for multifamily housing, increases in revenue per available room for hotels, and retreating vacancy rates for warehouses and offices. In this environment, it’s forecast that new construction starts for 2013 will climb 6% to $484 billion, a rate of growth not much different than the 5% gain estimated for 2012. The following are the main points by sector for the 2013 construction market:

A U.S. economy that avoids recession in early 2013 will allow several positive factors to benefit construction. Interest rates are very low, and lending standards for commercial real estate loans are easing. construction industry. In May, the Congressional Budget Office warned that allowing existing policies to take effect in early 2013 could cause the U.S. economy to slide 1.3% during the first half of 2013. Now that policymakers have reached some agreement to soften the impact of the spending cuts as well as maintain some of the Bushera tax cuts. The U.S. economy will be shaky at the outset of 2013, but it’s hoped that efforts to cushion the fiscal cliff will allow some of the uncertainty to diminish. Real GDP growth for all of 2013 will still be a tepid 2.2%, but the economy should improve after a weak start to the year.

• Single-family housing will grow 24% in dollars, corresponding to a 21% increase in units to 615,000 (McGraw-Hill Construction basis). The positives for single-family housing have become more numerous – the pace of foreclosures has eased, home prices are stabilizing, and mortgage rates are at record lows. • Multifamily housing will rise 16% in dollars and 14% in units, marking healthy percentage gains yet slower growth than what took place during 2011 and 2012. Improved market www.propertiesmag.com 23


Network Half Page Ad-d:Layout 1 10/16/08 11:45 AM Page 1

Network Dodge ®

Project Opportunity

Tailored Market Coverage and Project Details

Integrity Applications

Ease of Access, Use and Integration

Stability Reliability

Personal Service

Expertise and Guidance for Optimum ROI

For more than a century, the industry leader in providing access to North America’s Construction Projects and People.

Call 866-239-4261 for more information.

www.construction.com

Messina Floor Covering, LLC Commercial, Institutional & Industrial Floor Covering Provider & Installer Specializing in the healthcare marketplace with the highest quality & best service since 1989. We provide 24/7 service, installation and flooring maintenance. Call us today to take advantage of our trained in-house staff and extensive library of product information. Complete line of flooring including: Carpeting • Resilient Flooring, Vinyl & Ceramic Tile • Athletic Floors

Call today for a FREE estimate! 4300 Brookpark Rd., Cleveland, OH 44134 • 216-595-0100 • Toll Free 888-271-8200 24

Properties | January 2013


The Pattern of U.S. Construction Starts Billions of Dollars Total Construction Single-Family Housing Multifamily Housing Commercial Buildings Institutional Buildings

Source: McGraw-Hill Construction

Manufacturing Buildings Public Works Electric Utilities

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

2013

640.6

558.6

426.3

433.7

437.7

457.9

483.7

-7%

-13%

-24%

+2%

+1%

+5%

+6%

201.2

122.4

94.3

100.0

97.3

123.5

153.1

-26%

-39%

-23%

+6%

-3%

+27%

+24%

60.1

38.1

17.9

21.6

28.6

34.6

40.3

-14%

-37%

-53%

+20%

+32%

+21%

+16%

100.7

81.4

47.3

41.8

47.7

50.1

55.9

+8%

-19%

-42%

-12%

+14%

+5%

+12%

117.7

130.6

112.3

111.8

99.5

86.3

86.6

+6%

+11%

-14%

-0-

-11%

-13%

-0-

20.7

31.0

9.7

9.5

17.1

11.8

12.8

+51%

+50%

-69%

-3%

+81%

-31%

+8%

121.3

121.1

123.6

120.4

103.8

100.6

100.0

+8%

-0-

+2%

-3%

-14%

-3%

-1%

19.0

33.9

21.1

28.6

43.7

51.0

35.0

+7%

+79%

-38%

+36%

+53%

+17%

-31%

fundamentals will help to justify new construction, and this structure type continues to be viewed favorably by the real estate finance community. • Commercial building will increase 12%, a slightly faster pace than the 5% gain estimated for 2012. Both warehouses and hotels will benefit from lower vacancy rates, while store construction will feature more upgrades to existing space and the derived lift coming from gains for single-family housing. The increase for office construction will be modest, as new privately financed projects continue to be scrutinized carefully by lenders. Next year’s level of commercial building in current dollars will still be more than 40% below the 2007 peak. • Institutional building will level off, following the steep 13% drop estimated for 2012. For educational facilities, K-12 construction will slip further while college and university construction should at least stabilize. Healthcare facilities are expected to make a modest rebound after this year’s downturn.

• The manufacturing building category will grow 8%, showing improvement after its 2012 decline. • Public works construction will slide an additional 1%, as federal spending cuts in particular restrain environmental projects. The new two-year federal transportation bill should help to limit the impact of spending cuts on highways and bridges. • Electric utility construction will drop 31%, after reaching a record high in current dollars during 2012. This year was boosted by the start of two very large nuclear power plants, and projects of similar magnitude are not expected for 2013. The expiration of federal loan guarantees for renewable energy projects would also dampen construction in 2013. P

Reprinted with permission from McGraw-Hill Construction’s “Construction Outlook 2013.” For more information, visit McGraw-Hill Construction online at www.construction.com.

Please join us! 61st Annual Design & Construction Conference "Change is Constant: Visions for the Decade" Thursday, March 14, 2013 7:00 AM to 5:00 PM

LaCentre 25777 Detroit Rd., Westlake, OH 44145

Morning PLenAry SeSSion: Joseph D. roman, President & Ceo, greater Cleveland Partnership LunCh PLenAry SeSSion: Mark r. "rusty" Sherwood, Senior Consultant, FMi Corporation Join us for a networking reception immediately following the conference from 5:00pm-6:00pm. Sponsor & exhibitor opportunities are available now; for more details, attend the preview reception on January 17, 2013 at LaCentre. Sign up for a booth at the reception and save $50!

Call CeS at 216-361-3100 to rSVP or for more details.

MAGAZINE INC.

is a proud media sponsor of the Cleveland Engineering Society www.propertiesmag.com 25


2012 FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST

2013

A Long Way Back Toward ‘Normal’

T ALEC J. PACELLA

he past five years have certainly been a wild ride. Looking back at the general economic sentiment in the early months of 2008, everyone agreed that the good times had probably come to an end and the market was in for some tough times. And back in those early months of 2008, everyone had their specific thoughts and opinions on how the coming months and years would play out. Looking back now, all of those thoughts and opinions had one thing in common: the tough times were certainly much longer and more severe than most had anticipated. But five years and two presidential elections later, it is generally acknowledged that the worst is behind us and things are getting better. To find out how much better the Cleveland real estate investment market was in 2012, read on.

Return of the STNL While not quite a Jedi, a STNL (single tenant net lease) deal is a great indicator of the health of the market. This sector raged during the strong market in the mid-2000s, marked by surging demand, upward-spiraling prices and compressed CAP rates. But as the broader market weakened, this sector became dormant. The good news for 2012 was that this sector came back to life. Approximately 15% of the overall sales volume was the

26

result of STNL transactions. And while pricing has been off the peak previously achieved, this sector became increasingly popular as the year wore on, with demand beginning to outpace supply. Strong credit tenants were favored but moderate credit and private tenants also gained some attention, which is another good sign.

Distress-less Problem properties, such as workout, foreclosed or otherwise distressed situations, continued to significantly shape the investment market last year. This was particularly true within the office and retail segments, as several high-profile properties worked their way through the disposition process. Approximately 20% of the overall sales volume originated from distressed properties. But the good news for 2012 was a shrinking pipeline of distressed assets, as far fewer properties were slip-

Properties | January 2013


Point. Click. Connect. Visit Properties online today to view past & current editions in digital format – featuring interactive magazine ads that take you directly to advertisers’ websites with one mouse-click!

ping into this category. And while it will take several more years to see the situation return to healthier levels, the fact that this segment is slowly rightsizing will give way to an even broader sense of normalcy.

Cheaper by the dozen

www.propertiesmag.com

Portfolio sales were another sector that surged during the go-go years but waned as the market eroded. And again, 2012 fared well in this regard. Local properties were a part of several notable portfolio transactions, including the largest transfer in the market’s history The art –ofthea$262 job well finished million sale of SouthPark Mall. Located in Strongsville, it was a part of a larger $1 billion transaction between Westfield and Starwood Capital. KeyBank, which is headquartered in Cleveland, was the centerpiece of a nine-property transaction that included seven area branch bank properties. And two area Family Dollar Stores were a part of a 278-property sale/leaseback acquired by Cole Real Estate Investments.

The “very b

Art Window Shades Very Best.” So how

With a new location of KEVIN BOLL, Art professional comm grown to meet toda

And in addition t Levelor, Art Windo MechoShade Syste choice for designer a lasting impression

Call us today to disc

since 1922

commercial

Market rate

institutional

The art of a job well finished Art Window Coverings, Inc.

Art Window Coverings, Inc. Coverings, Inc. Art Window t Window Coverings, Inc.

Perhaps the best news for the local market was the return of numerous market-rate transactions. In the case of a distressed sale, the balance of influThe “very best” just got better The “very best” just g ence is typically tipped toward the The “very best” just got better buyer. And in the case of a STNL sale, Art Window Shades’ slogan has always been “Next to Your Windows, We’re the Art Window Shades’ slogan has always b Veryslogan Best.”has So how canbeen “the“Next very best” getWindows, better? We’re the the balance of influence is typically Art Window Shades’ always to Your Best.” how can “the very best” Art Window Shades’ slogan has always been “Next to Your Windows,Very We’re theSoVery tipped toward the seller. But a market Very Best.” So how cana“the best” get better? With new very location and larger showroom under the experienced management Best.” So how can “the very best” get better? With a new location and larger With ashowroom new location and larger showroo rate transaction features a fairly equal of and KEVIN BOLL, Art Window Coverings, Inc. is still the same trusted source for With location larger showroom under the experienced management of KEVIN undera new the experienced management of KEVIN BOLL, Art Window Coverings, Inc.BOLL, is stillArt Window Coverings balance of influence between the buyer professional commercialInc. window coverings it has been since 1922 but has of Window Coverings, is still the same trusted source forbeen commercial window cove theKEVIN sameBOLL, trustedArt source for professional commercial window coverings itprofessional has since grown to meet today’s need for top quality, style and selection in Ohio. and the seller and, more importantly, grown professional commercial window coverings it has been since 1922 but has to meet today’s need for top qu 1922 but has grown to meet today’s need for top quality, style and selection in Ohio. ArtWindow_Caldwells_DIS_08-ad.indd 1 typifies a normal market. Market transgrown to meet today’s for toptoquality, and selection Ohio. And inneed addition great style signature brands in such as And HunterDouglas in addition and to great signature And in addition toLevelor, great signature brandsCoverings, such as HunterDouglas Levelor, Art Window actions were very rate in the lean years Art Window remains yourand primary contract dealer of Coverings, rem Levelor, Art Window And in addition to great signature brands such as HunterDouglas and Coverings remains your primary contractBeautiful dealer ofand MechoShade Systems. Beautiful and MechoShade Systems. intelligent, MechoShades are the smart of 2009 and 2010 but began to emerge MechoShade Systems. Beautiful and in Levelor, Art Window Coverings, remains your primary contract dealer of choice forare designers looking forfor stylish, qualitylooking window coverings that makelooking for stylish intelligent, MechoShades the smart choice designers forchoice stylish, in 2011. Last year saw a dramatic forquality designers MechoShade Systems. Beautiful and intelligent, MechoShades are the smart lasting impression. a lasting impression. window coveringsa that make a lasting impression. increase in this type of transaction and choice for designers looking for stylish, quality window coverings that make encompassed nearly 40% of the total Call us today to discuss YOUR next work of art. Call us today to discuss YOUR next work aCall lasting impression. us today to discuss YOUR next work of art. sales volume. And while the apartment Call us today to discuss YOUR next work of art. ® sector saw much of the activity, there were also a fair amount of transactions ® From your aut From your authorized contract dealer across the retail, office and industrial sectors as well. Art W Art Window Coverings, Inc. since 1922

institutional

commercial

ArtWindow_Caldwells_DIS_08-ad.indd 1

MechoShade MechoShade

Me

From your authorized contract dealer

Diggin’ downtown Downtown Cleveland has gained significant momentum over the past

visit us at

Art Window Coverings, Inc. 3620 Perkins Ave. visit us at our new location

3620 Per Cleveland

visit us at our new location OH 44114 Cleveland,

P

P s F 3620 Perkins Ave. Cleveland, OH 44114

P s F

www.propertiesmag.com 27 3/24/08 2:34:53 PM


2012 FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST

2013 couple of years. Over $1 billion of new development has resulted in a new casino and will result in a new medical mart and convention center as well as a new multi-tenant office building and hotel complex. This has sparked a host of infill re-development, ranging from restaurants to hotels to retail. And perhaps the

best news for downtown is the 1,000+ residential units either planned or underway. These are needed to help meet a blossoming residential demand. However, the investment front continued to be dominated by speculative buyers looking to reposition or redevelop properties by capitalizing on bargain pricing. The

recovery will not come full circle until market rate investment transactions return to the downtown area.

And the number, please If you are a regular reader of this column, you will know that the January issue always recaps the past year’s overall investment sales volume. Cleveland’s high water mark occurred in 2007, when the volume reached $1.3 billion. It fell to $700 million the following year and then dropped off a cliff, with a scant $190 million of volume in 2009 and $290 million in 2010. In 2011, the market showed signs of a solid recovery, reaching $405 million. And the volume

Daus, You Know? GRADING TIME Every year, I make a prognostication on how the market will end the year. In last year’s column, I boldly predicted a total volume of $600 million for 2012. Looks like a career as a soothsayer is not in the cards. Looking ahead to 2013, I’m going to plant my sales volume flag right at $800 million. Stay tuned throughout this year to see how the year shapes up. –AP in 2012 jumped to just over $690 million. I am often asked what a “normal” sales volume in Cleveland should be and always answer with a number of $750 million. Does this mean that our market is back to normal? I think it’s getting better but still has a ways to go. One-fifth of this year’s volume was due to distressed sales. The volume and pricing among office properties, both downtown and in the suburbs, was pretty weak as this sector continued to languish. And the pipeline of distressed properties, while slimmed down, is still pretty full. Until these issues, as well as some assorted others, get squared away, I would hesitate to classify the investment market as “normal.” But it sure has come a long way. P Alec Pacella, CCIM, senior vice president at NAI Daus, can be reached by phone at 216.455.0925 or by email at apacella@naidaus.com. You can follow him on twitter @dausyouknow or on his blog at http://blog.sbequitiesinc.com.

28

Properties | January 2013


Eyeing Commercial Real Estate Investment in 2013

Chasing yield will continue spurring capital investment, transaction volume in New Year By David S. Davenport Bellwether Enterprise Real Estate Capital, LLC

I

t is the beginning of a new year. It is a time for reflection on the past and what has been – and more importantly, a time to ponder, consider and prepare for the future and what is to come. The Northeast Ohio commercial real estate market, on a broad basis, has mirrored the overall U.S. commercial real estate recovery. There has been visible improvement in the overall fundamentals, asset pricing, total number of transactions both in leasing and sales, and the availability of capital. This trend of improvement is expected to continue in 2013. Generally, the pace of this improving trend has been modest; some prefer to even use the word “slow.” Additionally, this pace of modest improvement is expected to continue in 2013. The same macro-economic issues and concerns troubling the country will continue to influence the commercial real estate industry as well. Such macro-economic worries include a slow/muddling economic recovery, unemployment, considerable national and household debt that the country struggles to manage, global concerns from Europe’s turbulence and slowing growth in emerging markets such as China and India. More practically stated, these macro-economic concerns have an effect on commer-

cial real estate because without new jobs, companies will not need additional offices or manufacturing space, workers will not need more apartments and houses, and consumers will be more hesitant to spend their disposable income at retail shopping centers and hotels. However, despite these macroeconomic concerns, many surveys

The relationships. The expertise. The financing. The personal touch.

forecast that in 2013 investors will return to greater risk-taking in their portfolios “in an attempt to gain more yield.” “In an attempt to gain more yield” is a key phrase – and one of the major factors that has spurred investment into commercial real estate since late 2010. Similar to personal households, one can invest their own personal funds into various alternative investments such as savings accounts, money markets, bonds, stocks, and/or real estate. For each investment type, as the risk profile increases, the potential yield or return increases as well. Everyone knows this and experiences this on a personal level. This same simplified concept that one experiences at a personal household

At Bellwether Enterprise, we supply the diversification that is critically needed to thrive in the ever-changing commercial real estate finance environment. We have a very comprehensive set of lending products and will provide our clients with all the capital alternatives available. We offer competitive rates and terms, streamlined underwriting and enhanced loan servicing.

www.BellwetherEnterprise.com CLEVELAND HEADQUARTERS 1360 E. 9th Street, Suite 300 | Cleveland, OH 44114 | 216.820.4500

VISION

KNOWLEDGE

PEOPLE

ATLANTA, GA COLUMBIA, MD COLUMBUS, OH

CINCINNATI, OH DALLAS, TX LEXINGTON, KY

LOUISVILLE, KY NEW YORK, NY PITTSBURGH, PA

RALEIGH, NC SEATTLE, WA SOUTH BEND, IN

www.propertiesmag.com 29


2012 FINANCIAL REVIEW & FORECAST

2013 level applies in general to institutional capital/debt providers as well. For many institutions, the willingness to lend and invest in commercial real estate has not been driven by a belief that commercial real estate’s issues have been totally cured since 2008/2009, but rather the realistic investment strategies of an institutional portfolio manager – it is all about yield, the alternative investments, and diversification. There has been a direct correlation between the cost and availability of capital and the improving commercial real estate recovery. Yields for commercial real estate have and will remain relatively attractive, given the widened spreads between U.S. Treasury rates and real estate capitalization and achievable interest rates. Further, the cost and availability of capital for commercial real estate will continue to support increased transaction volume. The availability and lower cost of capital translates into higher potential cash flow for property owners, higher potential cash flow correlates into higher property values, increasing property values typi-

cally translates into more commercial real estate investment activity, etc. Alternatively, the debt service savings could be passed on to lower costs of occupancy for tenants; while lower rents means lower income, it is the ability to lower one’s rent that may attract or even retain tenants, thus aiding in the durability of the income stream from a property, and thus translating potentially into a higher property value. As a result, the currently low cost and availability of capital for commercial real estate will continue to aid property values well into the future for those able to take advantage and fix the interest long-term before interest rates increase. Rates are not expected to increase substantially in the near term, but at some point rates will increase – it is not a matter of if, but when that will happen. Therefore, while the hope is that the accretive value of a property is achieved through general operations over a holding period, this current low interest rate environment has presented another dynamic way to achieve accretive value for a property through securing a long-

term, fixed-rate, assumable financing. This not only negates or even removes future interest rate risk for the current property owner, but if fixed for a longterm and rates do go up, the financing put in place can also increase the value and marketability of a property. This convergence of low rates and availability of capital has created an interesting period of time in commercial real estate, particularly since only a few years ago this was unachievable and that appeared to be the new norm. Lenders feel good about lending due to yields achievable compared to alternative investments, and borrowers feel good about borrowing because of historically low interest rates. This is anticipated to be the case for 2013, as well. So take advantage of it, if you can. P David S. Davenport is senior vice president at Bellwether Enterprise Real Estate Capital, LLC. For more info, call Davenport at 216.820.4508 or visit www.BellwetherEnterprise.com.

Cleveland’s Steel Headquarters

CompleTe Fire proTeCTion serviCes

888-528-0928

• Fire Extinguishers, Fire Alarms, Fire Sprinklers, Exit/Emergency Lighting, Kitchen Fire Suppression, FM-200/Halon/ CO2 Systems • Division 10 fire extinguishers and cabinets to construction trades

www.county-fire.com

• Fire protection contracting services to property owners/ managers

Akron • ClevelAnd • Columbus • Toledo 30cfp ad.indd 3

9/18/08 3:49:24 PM

Columbia Building Products Steel JoiStS Structural iron Metal roof Deck Steel StairS & railS Steel erection

440-235-3363 25961 Elm St., Cleveland, OH 44138

Properties | January 2013


Testing the Temperature Among Northeast Ohio Construction Pros Skoda Minotti’s 2012 survey reveals respondents’ opinions on range of topics By Roger T. Gingerich, CPA/ABV, CVA Skoda Minotti

A

s you may remember, in the August 2012 issue of Properties, we took a brief look at the results of Skoda Minotti’s annual Northeast Ohio Real Estate and Construction Industry Survey. In that issue, we focused on the outlook for construction opportunities in this region and also took a look at respondents’ feelings on Ohio Construction Reform. Biggest threat to your business over the next 12 months:

Average size job that you bid on increased:

Graphics courtesy of Skoda Minotti

This month, we’ll be delving a little deeper into the survey results on topics such as banking, bidding environment, bonding, Green Construction and Building Information Modeling (BIM). If you would like the complete survey results and analysis, you can download Skoda Minotti’s entire 23-page report for free at www.skodaminotti.com/survey.html.

Figure A

Banking As we discussed in the August article, although opportunities for work are on the rise, construction professionals now seem to be focused on financing that work. “Tightened credit” was cited as the second biggest threat (up from third in 2011) to our respondents businesses with 24% choosing that option. That was up from only 8% in 2009. However, it is important to remember that 81% of our respondents chose “lack of work” as their biggest threat in 2009, so obtaining credit was not a top priority at that time.(See figure A.) While credit certainly is a major issue for our respondents, the situation does seem to be slowly improving. We have seen a steady improvement to the question, “Do you feel that over the past year, the ability to obtain financing has increased, stayed the same, decreased slightly or decreased significantly?” Starting in 2009, the percent of respondents choosing either “decreased slightly” or “decreased significantly” has declined each year,

Figure B

from 78% of respondents in 2009 down to only 34% of respondents this year. Also, 15% of respondents said that their ability to obtain financing actually increased in 2012, a high mark since we began the survey.

Bidding environment We’ve tracked the construction bidding environment since 2009 and this year’s results were the most favorable. In terms of size of jobs being bid, 41% said that the size of jobs they’ve bid over the last 12 months had “increased.” This is the highest percent since we started tracking this data. Only 24% said that the average size of the jobs that they bid had decreased which represents the lowest percentage since we started asking the question in 2009. (See figure B.) In terms of competition, the bidding environment seems to be less competitive than over the past few years. Nearly half (49%) of respondents were only competing with one to four other bidders on their average job this year.

That percentage had never been higher than 29% in the past. While it is still a competitive environment, we are no longer seeing a situation, like in 2010, where 37% of respondents saw 10 or more bidders on their average job.

Bonding Over the last five years, we’ve seen an interesting trend in terms of bonding required by our respondents. In 2008, 73% of our respondents said that less than 40% of their work required bonding. That number dropped to 71% in 2009 and all the way down to 59% in 2010. It then rebounded to 64% in 2011 and back up to 70% this year. One reason for this drop in bonding requirements and subsequent rise could be related to some increased demand for private work rather than government work, which does not typically require bonding. It could also be somewhat related to the recent “mega-projects” in town such as the Horseshoe Casino and Medical Mart. In some cases on these larger projects, the general contractors www.propertiesmag.com 31


Why ship docs when our cloud is at your fingertips? Jobs reviewed or performed with green materials or LEED-certified component:

Graphic courtesy of Skoda Minotti

Access our “cloud” and never ship documents again. By choosing SE Blueprint’s ProjectShare, you can: > Store and organize files > Share files securely > Collaborate with anyone > Print anywhere in the world Find out more at: www.bit.ly/SEBlueCloud

Cleveland 216.241.2250 | Akron 330.376.1689 www.seblueprint.com

Figure C

may utilize sub-contractor default insurance rather than bonding.

Green construction According to our survey, the Green Construction movement seems to be slow going in Northeast Ohio. Since 2010, no more than 18% of respondents said that Green Construction has had a “material impact” on their business. This year, 35% of respondents said that it had “no impact” on their business. (See figure C.)

BIM 110256-SEBlue_Properties-ad.indd 1

Building Information Modeling 5/5/11 12:32 PM (BIM) software, much like Green Construction, does not seem to be gathering much steam in our market either. This year, 70% of respondents said that BIM is having “no impact” on their business, up from 68% last year. In the near future, 49% of respondents believe that it will have “no impact,” up from 43% last year. P Roger T. Gingerich, CPA/ABV, CVA is partnerin-charge of Skoda Minotti’s Real Estate and Construction Group. Survey results were gathered March-April 2012. The survey was conducted via email by Northeast Ohio real estate and construction professionals, including the local membership of Associated Builders and Contractors, Building Owners and Managers Association International, Construction Employers Association, National Association of Industrial and Office Properties, Ohio Contractors Association, Surety Association of Ohio, and the Builders Exchange. The survey results were then compiled and analyzed by Skoda Minotti. If you have any questions regarding the survey results or would like more information on the Real Estate and Construction Group at Skoda Minotti, please call Gingerich at 440-449-6800 or rgingerich@skodaminotti.com.

32

Properties | January 2013


The Numbers Don’t Lie

SPRAY FOAM TECHNOLOGIES OF

OHIO

40%

Your Average Heating & Cooling Savings with Spray Polyurethane Foam (SPF) Insulation.* Source: Spray Polyurethane Foam Alliance *Results may vary based on individual HVAC usage.

R-6.8

Per Inch

SPF has Nearly Twice the Insulating Value of Traditional Fiberglass’ R-3.5 per inch.

Call/Click to utilize SPF Insulation on your next project!

SprayFoamTechOhio.com 330.650.1400 ABAA, NCFI & OSHA CERTIFIED 10000 Aurora-Hudson Rd. - Hudson, OH 44236

Complete Glass Experts Family-Owned & Operated for 60 years! Specializing in: • Commercial Glass and Glazing • Aluminum Doors & Storefronts • Custom Sandblasted “Etched” Glass with Clearshield • Bullet Resistant Glass & Polycarbonate • Custom Frameless Shower Doors, Mirrors & Glass Table Tops

Free Commercial Estimates 24 Hour-Board-Up Service phone 216-621-1971 | fax 216-621-6602 www.sandgloglass.com 2316 St. Clair Avenue | Cleveland, Ohio 44114

ASPHALT PAVING ASPHALT REPAIR SEALCOATING CRACK FILLING COMPLETE SITE CONSTRUCTION EXCAVATION TO COMPLETION

PAV I N G I N C . • Excellent quality, competitive pricing & reliability • Cunningham Paving is a family-owned business, with over 15 years of experience • Licensed, bonded & insured • Our motto: “Keeping our customers satisfied, keeps them coming back.”

Phone 216.581.8600 Fax 216.581.8683 20814 Aurora Road, Warrensville Heights, OH 44146-1006 www.propertiesmag.com 33


216.662.5200 chassvecinc@brightdsl.net

Maltz Museum of Jewish Heritage

Mandel Jewish Community Center

THE AREA’S FINEST DESIGNERS AND ARCHITECTS ALWAYS CHOOSE SUNTROL FOR THEIR MOST PRESTIGIOUS PROJECTS Energy Saving Window Films Opaque Privacy Filming & Screens Logos & Custom Graphics, Security Film

S U N T R O L The Leader In Environmental & Designer Glass Film

800-466-8468

Mandel JCC Entrance

www.suntrol.com

Commercial ▪ Residential ▪ Retail LEED Contributing Products Serving Ohio For More Than 37 Years

34

Properties | January 2013


Resourceful Representation

Examining owner’s rep services as an effective project management solution By Tim Panzica IQ Advisors, LLC

Y

our business is changing and you need more space, or remodeled space, or “greener” space. You are unsure how to begin or how to get from Step A to Z. Who do you call? Where do you start? Who watches the overall process? The builder? The architect? Should you control the oversight yourself? Do you have the time personally? Do you have the right in-house person and resources to do that? If not, now may be the time to look for an owner’s representative, someone who will wholly and passionately advocate for your best interests without an agenda to advance. A skilled owner’s representative provides independent advisory services for master planning initiatives and construction projects. Moreover, a talented owner’s representative translates your business vision and goals into an exceptional building project and, as a result, will exceed your expectations. Services could include, but are not limited to, leadership with early planning and budgeting; identifying and negotiating the services of the various professionals, such as the architect, contractor and engineers; guidance in the incorporation of responsible sustainability initiatives; ongoing oversight during the construction phase of the project; and efficient facilitation of the close-out phase of the project.

Attributes of a quality partner Seek a partner who can advise you through the entire lifecycle of a capital project. Look for your partner to really understand your business vision and dream, and be sure they can convince you of being able to effectively translate that business vision into a successful building project. Can they impressively demonstrate knowledge of all phases of a capital project – planning, design and construction? As the construction represents anywhere from 70% to 80% of a capital project, your advisor should have a demonstrated expertise in this area, too. It is essential for your partner to have a solid understanding of accurately budgeting for the entire project. Further, make sure they clearly and proficiently share with you the pros and cons about the varied models you can contemplate and use to contract with the design and construction firms. Given the prominent role of sustainability in today’s business environment,

look for demonstrated passion and knowledge about incorporating responsible green practices into the project. Have they persuasively convinced you that they would protect your long-term goals of low operating and maintenance costs? During the very early planning stage of the project, it is imperative to have robust discussions on all of your options related to first cost expenditures versus a demonstrated return on investment over a longer time horizon. Your owner’s rep must lead this charge. Are you able to discern if your proposed owner’s rep possesses exceptional facilitation skills with demonstrated ability to include and engage all stakeholders early and often? This is a critical skill set, given the need to ensure all voices are heard at the table. Most importantly, make sure your partner can unequivocally impress upon you that they are capable of thinking and acting like an owner. Yes. In the end, you will have selected a company for the assignment as your owner’s representative. But, make sure

you know the individual from that firm who would be assigned the primary project management role for your project.

The benefit It’s been said, “Conventional execution, even if flawlessly carried out, can only achieve conventional results.” Do not allow this to occur on your project. You want to be able to look back on the process and proclaim you received not only what you had hoped for, but much more than was ever expected. In life, as in business, successful relationships must be aligned around trust, and the best barometer of trust is plain speaking and candor. Treasure this trait! In the end, it’s imperative that your owner’s representative is a true independent, trusted advisor providing exceptional advocacy on your behalf. Know this. A talented owner’s representative will guide the entire process in the correct direction from the beginning, dramatically increasing the opportunity for a successful project outcome and, in the process, save you money overall. P

Tim Panzica, LEED AP, is president of IQ Advisors, LLC, an independent advisory firm providing owner representation for capital projects and sustainability initiatives. He may be contacted at timpanzica@iqadvisorsllc.com

IQ Advisors, LLC Owner Representation & Independent Advisory Services for Building Projects & Sustainability Initiatives

Tim Panzica, LEED AP President timpanzica@iqadvisorsllc.com 216-469-0512

www.iqadvisorsllc.com www.propertiesmag.com 35


LEGAL PERSPECTIVES Navigating property laws & regulations

When Construction Projects Go Bad: Options for Terminating a Construction Contract

W

hen a property owner enters into a commercial construction contract with a contractor, both parties typically assume that the project will be commenced and completed as planned. Unfortunately, things do not always go as planned.

DAVID LINDNER

Any number of unanticipated events can stop a project dead in its tracks, such as the loss of financing, labor or materials shortages, or natural disaster. While it is normal to be optimistic about a project at the start, it is also prudent to think through what might happen if the construction contract needs to be terminated prior to completion of the project, and draft the contract accordingly. By properly addressing termination rights in the construction contract, the parties can minimize and allocate the risks of early termination. The first thing the owner and contractor must understand is that there are two types of termination. Termination “for cause” can occur when a party breaches the construction contract. For example, the owner may have a right to terminate for cause when the contractor materially deviates from the plans and specifications, and the contractor may have a

right to terminate when the owner fails to make payment as required. Contracts usually provide for a “cure period” during which a party has a specified time to remedy the alleged breach. If the party fails to cure the breach within the time specified, the other party then has the right to terminate, usually by giving written notice. When an owner terminates for cause, the contract documents often permit the owner to hire a replacement contractor, with the terminated contractor being responsible for any difference in cost between the original contract amount and the cost necessary to complete the project, together with any damages incurred by the owner as a result of the breach. If the contractor terminates due to the owner’s failure to pay or for other causes specified in the contract, it can typically recover payment for the work

We would be proud to be part of your team on your next construction project

Container ServiCe, inC.

“The Leader in Container Service” FBE, CSB & EDGE CERTIFIED

(216) 441-4422 WWW.PETEANDPETEINC.COM 36

YOUR CONSTRUCTION SPECIALISTS GREEN & LEED PROJECTS 2, 4, 6, 8 - YARD FRONT LOAD CONTAINERS 10, 20, 30, 40-YARD ROLLOFF CONTAINERS Properties | January 2013


it has performed, plus other damages resulting from the termination. In contrast, termination “for convenience” is a right that may be reserved to the owner in a construction contract that allows the owner to terminate the contract upon notice to the contractor, even if the contractor has not breached the contract. An owner may choose to exercise its right to terminate for convenience when the owner runs out of funding, cannot obtain the necessary governmental approvals, or decides that the project is no longer economically viable. It is important to realize that termination for convenience clauses can vary substantial from contract to contract. For instance, some contracts may provide for a required notice period before the termination is effective, while in others the termination may be effective immediately. Owners who use the standard American Institute of Architects (AIA) contract forms should also be aware that, although the owner has the right to terminate for convenience under the A201 General Conditions, the contractor is then entitled to receive “payment for Work executed, and costs incurred by reason of such termination, along with reasonable overhead and profit on the Work not executed.” Put another way, if the owner terminates for convenience, the owner must nevertheless pay the contractor for overhead and profit on the remaining work. From the owner’s perspective, a better approach is to restrict the owner’s liability to payment for overhead and profit on work performed through the date of termination. In some cases, an owner may wish to terminate a contractor but be unsure if sufficient grounds exist for a “for cause” termination. Anticipating this situation, some contracts will provide that if an owner terminates “for cause,” but a court later rules that sufficient grounds did not exist, the termination is automatically deemed a “for convenience” termination. These provisions help protect the owner from claims that it breached the agreement by terminating the contractor without justification. The owner’s right to terminate for convenience can put a contractor in a difficult position with its subcontractors, so contractors should always review their subcontracts to ensure that they have the right to terminate

their subcontractors for convenience in the event that they are terminated by the owner for convenience. A contractor should also pay close attention to any post-termination obligations it may have under the contract, and what termination expenses, overhead or profit may be recoverable. Terminating a construction contract can be a delicate matter, since parties typically enter into the contract assuming the project will be taken to completion. The reality, however, is that contracts need to be terminated prior

to completion of the project for many different reasons, and both owners and contractors should make sure they are protected by the contract documents if a termination occurs. P The material appearing in this article is meant to provide general information only and not as a substitute for legal advice. Readers should seek the advice of their attorney or contact David Lindner at dlindner@bdblaw.com or 800.686.2825. This article may not be reprinted without the express permission of Buckingham, Doolittle & Burroughs, LLP © 2012.

www.propertiesmag.com 37


NAIOP NEWS Commercial real estate happenings

2012 Year in Review & Looking Forward to 2013

C

onsistent with our mission, the Northern Ohio Chapter of NAIOP has delivered another very full year of unparalleled opportunities for our members to increase their visibility, to develop new relationships, to learn something new and to get involved in a variety of ways. Our continuous improvement approach to Chapter programming has resulted in a very rich and rewarding 2012.

SCOTT MCCREADY

Thanks to member and guest support and feedback, we continue to provide diverse program and event opportunities every year. This year was no exception.

Charities, social events & media

PHILLIP BADALAMENTI

In June, NAIOP held its 18th Annual Charity Golf Classic, occupying both golf courses of Weymouth and Fox Meadow Country Clubs. Attendees enjoyed a great day of golf, fellowship and the chance to support NAIOP charities. This year’s event raised nearly $13,000.00 for local charities. Once again NAIOP Northern Ohio volunteers participated in the Chapter’s “Rebuilding Together Cleveland” initiative, which aims to preserve and revitalize houses and communities, assuring that low-income homeowners – particularly the elderly and disabled and families with children – live in comfortable and safe housing. The chapter’s Membership Mixer Events in January, April and July 2012 continued to be well attended. In lieu of the annual September clambake,

the chapter organized a Beer and Wine Tasting Event at the Market Garden Brewery next to the West Side Market to celebrate the Market’s 100th anniversary. Our new Social Media Committee was tasked with developing our new website and integration of the other social media tools such as LinkedIn, Facebook and Twitter. With all the site mapping and design element selection complete, we have made tremendous progress on our new NAIOP Northern Ohio website and are in the final design stages. Look for it in early 2013!

Strategic initiatives In February, we organized a special Board Breakfast and Member Lunch around a visit from NAIOP National Chairman William Hunt, president and CEO of the Elmhurst Corporation, which owns and manages more than 2.5 million square feet of office, flex and distribution space in the Pittsburgh region. He shared the NAIOP Strategic Plan’s initiatives for 2012, trends in national real estate, financing, government affairs and trends

Better Acoustics?

Noise Abatement • Interior Acoustics • HVAC Noise Reduction • LEED Verification Computer Analysis • Field Testing • Effective Solutions & Materials

DH KAISER CO I M P R O V I N G W H AT Y O U H E A R , W I T H G R E AT E R F R E Q U E N C Y

www.kaiseracoustics.com • P.O. Box 21035, Canton, OH 44701 • 330/456-7000 • Toll Free 800/550-7007 38

Properties | January 2013


in Pittsburgh that may be applicable for a growing Cleveland region as well as the top 10 challenges currently facing the development industry.

“Awards of Excellence” In May, we held our 29th Annual Awards of Excellence Program at Windows on the River. The event was another tremendous success, and everyone was very happy with the new format and pace of the program with so many award categories and submissions.

Education programs In April, we held our annual Market Update, Continuing Education Credit Event, “Cleveland’s Lakefront Development: Putting Our Best Foot Forward,” which focused on the state of the commercial real estate market in Northeast Ohio. The Fall Education Event “Repositioning Northeast Ohio’s Cities Through Development,” which featured projects at KSU, Goodyear HQ, and Intesa, focused on development taking place just outside Northeast Ohio’s major cities. We continued to hold quarterly “NAIOP Developers and Owners Roundtables” where members with ownership stakes in properties and developments discuss pertinent state and local issues. In December, our annual Core Ethics Continuing Education Class was held, presented jointly by NAIOP, CABOR and SIOR. The class provided attendees an opportunity to learn more about civil rights as it pertains to real estate, and more specifically, commercial real estate.

August. These breakfasts give our younger members under the age of 35 the opportunity to learn about local organizations, ask questions and network. In September, the DL Committee organized its “4th Annual Leadership Series” at the Hospitality Management Center at Public Square, also featuring a roundtable discussion of local business and development professionals. We began a new Mentorship Program this year to provide opportunities to bridge the gap between our younger professionals and senior executives and owners in commercial real estate while creating a unique opportunity for DLs. A kickoff event was held at D’Vine Wine Bar in Cleveland as an informal meet and greet where we learned that this group had immediate synergy and were excited to be a part of this newly formed program. What was supposed to be an hour-long meeting went well over two hours while everyone shared experiences, history, ideas, etc. Other mentorship events last year involved the topics “Anatomy of Our Deals” and the “Investor in Commercial Real Estate.”

Moving forward into 2013 Finally, we prepared for 2013 at our NAIOP Northern Ohio Chapter “Annual Holiday Meeting and Cocktail Reception” event held on November 29 at the Ariel International Center. The meeting included election and installation of officers for 2013, a look back

at 2012 accomplishments and a look forward to 2013. Thank you to both our host and sponsors for the event Ariel Ventures, LLC and First American Title. Thank you also to Jeff Wherry, Donna Haders, Maureen Leech and the staff at Wherry Associates, who work tirelessly behind the scenes to make sure that every event run smoothly and that everyone stays connected. We couldn’t do it without you! Thanks to Properties for your continued support and your team’s efforts working with Chapter leadership and members to cover a full spectrum of Chapter news and events throughout the year. Finally, thank you to NAIOP Northern Ohio, for allowing me to serve as president of this great organization. If you read this and are not yet a member, please consider joining and becoming active. You will be rewarded a thousand times over. We hope to see you in 2013! For additional information, visit the NAIOP Northern Ohio website at: www. naiop.org/NORTHERN_OHIO/index. cfm, or contact Donna Haders at (440) 899-0010 or djh@wherryassoc.com. P Scott McCready (Scott.McCready@Cardno. com) is LEED AP, QEP, PG, National Account Manager with Cardno ATC and 2012 NAIOP Northern Ohio President. Phillip D. Badalamenti, AIA, is architect/sr. project manager at Herschman Architects and is editor of NAIOP News. He can be reached at pbadalamenti@herschmanarchitects.com.

Public affairs In April, members of the Chapter attended the Annual State Legislative Day in Columbus to discuss the following items with our state representatives: the Ohio Job Ready Sites Program; extension of the Ohio Historic Preservation Tax Credit Program; Ohio New Market Tax Credit program; Ohio EPAs Voluntary Action Program (VAP) for brownfield development; Ohio EPA Water Rules Package; and Ohio Vacant Industrial Site Legislation.

DL & mentorship programs The DL (Developing Leaders) Committee organized two “Roundtable Breakfasts” this year in March and

Restoration Contractors American International Construction, Inc. is a company dedicated to the restoration and preservation of numerous types of buildings, including related services on new structures. Let our commitment to quality and client satisfaction work for you. • Caulking & sealants • Building cleaning • Tuckpointing • Facade restoration • Masonry & stone restoration • Storefront renovation • Waterproofing • Historic preservation

Michael Petrasek president

1073 WEST BAGLEY ROAD, BEREA, OHIO 44017 ph: 440.243.5535 f: 440.243.7745 www.aiconstruction.com

www.propertiesmag.com 39


CABOR CORNER Issues in the real estate industry

Supporting Acts

A

s 2012 came to a close, the National Association of Realtors (NAR) joined forces with the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) in encouraging the United States Senate to quickly pass S. 2231, the “Small Business Lending Enhancement Act of 2012,” sponsored by Senator Udall (D-CO) and S. 3522, the “Responsible Homeowner Refinancing Act of 2012,” introduced by Senators Menendez (D-NJ) and Boxer (D-CA). JOANNE ZETTL

40

S. 2231 increases the cap on member business lending (MBL) from 12.25% to 27.5% of total assets for well-capitalized credit unions, and will create a new source of capital to refinance commercial loans. S. 3522 offers relief to homeowners who continue to meet their mortgage obligation during this economic downturn. In December, the two organizations sent a letter to members of the U.S. Senate expressing NAR’s and the Home Builders’ belief that enactment of both pieces of legislation, whether individually or as part of a larger package, are crucial to the recovery of the fragile commercial and residential real estate markets. Specifically, the groups stated in the letter that “nearly $1 trillion of commercial real estate loans with balloon mortgages will mature over the next few years, with a very limited option to refinance. If not addressed, the swelling wave of maturities could place further stress on our nation’s already fragile financial markets and overall economy.”

NAR will continue to advocate for passage of the “Small Business Lending Enhancement Act,” in addition to the “Responsible Homeowner Refinancing Act.” Presently, both pieces of legislation are awaiting further action in the Senate. For the most up-to-date commercial advocacy information, visit the webpage for Commercial Realtors on NAR’s website, www.realtor.org/commercial. As always, CABOR’s staff is happy to assist with any questions you may have, as well. P Joanne Zettl is the Chairman of the Cleveland Area Board of Realtors (CABOR). CABOR is the voice of real estate in Northeast Ohio, serving the community, real estate professionals who sell real property, and businesses that work in or with the real estate industry. CABOR provides a variety of services to its professional members including education, insurance, affinity programs and legislative representation, as well as membership in the Ohio Association of Realtors (OAR) and the National Association of Realtors (NAR). For more information, visit www.CABOR.com.

Properties | January 2013


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans

Arkinetics Welcomes Castrovillari

A

rkinetics recently announced that Frank Castrovillari has joined the architecture firm to lead its production team as the Director of Production and handle business development for the industrial market segment. Castrovillari has 21 years of experience in industrial, retail and office design. As Director of Production, he will be involved with every project, managing the Frank Castrovillari resources within the production and technical staff and overseeing quality control. He will also take the lead in business development efforts for Arkinetics’ industrial market segment.

Panzica Construction Announces Changes Panzica Construction Co. recently announced two management changes. Company President and Chief Executive Officer Tony Panzica has announced that Tim Panzica has left the company to pursue other opportunities. “We are grateful for the contribution Tim made to the company and wish him

well in his new endeavor,” he says. Additionally, the company announced Doug Ryan has joined Panzica Construction as Director of Business Development. Ryan is responsible for developing new business and strengthening relationships with existing customers across all of Panzica’s industry segments. Ryan has 28 years of industry experience with

a variety of construction, architecture and engineering firms throughout Ohio, including Schaefer Engineering in Cincinnati and global design firm NBBJ in Columbus.

Westlake Reed Leskosky Relocates to Hanna Building Westlake Reed Leskosky recently announced the relocation of its Cleveland offices to the Hanna Building at 1422 Euclid Avenue in downtown Cleveland. The architecture, engineering and technology firm will occupy the third floor of the Hanna Building, a historic building in the PlayhouseSquare District. Specializing in cultural and performing arts and historic restoration, Westlake Reed Leskosky has revitalized five historic theatres at PlayhouseSquare, including the Hanna and, most recently, three new venues at the Allen Theatre complex. The firm served as feasibility analyst and pro-

grammer for Idea Center at PlayhouseSquare and lead design architects and engineers for the Idea Center tenant suite for WVIZ/PBS and 90.3 WCPN ideastream and PlayhouseSquare. “Our new offices in PlayhouseSquare reflect our practice achievements and aspirations in terms of working within the vitality of a dynamic and inspiring urban environment and cultural district for arts, education, and technology,” says Paul E. Westlake, Jr., FAIA, managing principal of Westlake Reed Leskosky. “We look forward to celebrating the New Year and a new era in our new quarters.” The firm also operates offices in Washington, D.C., Phoenix, New York and Los Angeles.

CBRE and Soles4Souls Collect Shoes for Needy CBRE’s second-annual National Shoe Collection Drive – held in conjunction with the international char-

TIRED OF BEING RIPPED OFF?

Then stop hiring fly-by-night “roofing contractors” whose only office address is wherever their pick-up truck happens to be parked at the time! The no-insurance, irresponsible operators are driving the few remaining honest roofing contractors out of business. Unless the consumer gets wiser, there will be no quality roofers left! We are looking for a few wise consumers. If you fit the bill, call us today!

CAREY ROOFING

CORPORATION

SINCE 1946

2695 East 55th Street • Cleveland, OH 44104 • www.careyroofing.com • 216-881-1999 • Fax 216-881-7450 www.propertiesmag.com 41


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans ity Soles4Souls – recently collected more than 15,330 pairs of shoes for people in need. In addition, CBRE Cares, the company’s corporate philanthropy program, donated $7,668 to the international charity, the equivalent of an additional 7,668 pair of shoes. As a result, the drive will enable Soles4Souls to provide shoes for more than 23,000 adults and children around the world, doubling last year’s collection. Northeast Ohio CBRE employees, in Cleveland and Akron, donated more than 200 pairs of shoes to this year’s drive, doubling their efforts from last year. “We are pleased by the kindness and compassion our employees have shown in their support of Soles4Souls,” says David Browning, CBRE’s managing director, Northeast Ohio operations. “Our donations not only filled a human need, but also helped the environment by keeping shoes out of landfills.” According to Soles4Souls resource data, over 1.5 bil-

lion pairs of shoes lay idle in American closets, many of which can be saved from landfills by sending them to Soles4Souls. Recycling new and gently worn shoes can cut down on shoes being discarded to landfills, where it can take up to 1,000 years for just one sneaker to biodegrade. The CBRE campaign was the Soles4Souls most successful internal companywide drive ever. The charity processes between 45,000 and 60,000 shoes per week and has distributed over 10,000 pairs of shoes and relief aid items to Sandy relief efforts.

TC Architects Welcomes Project Manager TC Architects recently announced the addition of Brian M. Linc to its team of experienced design professionals. Linc brings with him several years of professional expertise in architecture on a multitude of different projects including commercial, retail, industrial, education

Brian Linc

and housing projects. He also has experience in LEED, field and site work, specifications, and is proficient in computer aided drafting and modeling. He holds a Masters of Architecture from Kent State University. Linc is a registered Architect in the State of Ohio and is a member of the American Institute of Architects.

PSI Appoints Principal Consultant PSI recently announced the appointment of Paul Bowyer, PG as a principal consultant for its Phase I

ESA service line, and will be the primary principal consultant for PSI’s Cleveland operations office. Bowyer is a graduate of the College of Wooster with a Bachelor of Science in Geology. He serves a dual role as a senior geologist, and has been with PSI since April 2010. Professional Service Industries, Inc. (PSI) is an independent engineering and testing firm and one of the largest consulting engineering firms in North America, with approximately $200 million in annual revenues.

Ruhlin Announces Hires, Names IT Manager Recently, the Ruhlin Company announced the promotion of Dave Ellenberger to Information Technology Manager, as well as the addition of three new team members. Ellenberger joined Ruhlin in 2008, serving as Network Administrator. In his new

800-223-7318 www.starinc.cc

Northern Ohio Medical Specialists - Sandusky Green Circle Growers - Oberlin ~ Another Award Winning Project

“Building Trust Since 1955” 42

Properties | January 2013


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans role, work will include leading the IT functions of the company, including the Sharon Center office and all jobsites. Tim Newberry joins Ruhlin’s Industrial Division as Superintendent. His duties include the Advanced Hydro Solutions Projects. Newberry previously served in the United States Marine Corps at various duty stations and brings over 19 years of experience serving the construction industry. Paul McCutcheon joins Ruhlin’s Civil Division as a Licensed Professional Surveyor. His duties include providing surveying expertise to various projects. He brings over 24 years of experience in the construction industry, having

Applied Studies from Ohio University and brings over 8 years of experience in providing safety services.

The Pattie Group Hires Five New Employees

Dave Ellenberger

worked with both private engineering firms and major construction companies. Ryan Berkhouse returns to Ruhlin as Assistant Safety Director. His duties include assisting the Safety Director in ensuring safe work sites at all Ruhlin construction projects. Berkhouse holds a Bachelors Degree in Technical and

The Pattie Group, Inc. has recently announced several employee hires through December. With a growing Landscape Design/ Build division, The Pattie Group, Inc., has brought on two new project directors, Mike Bulone, whose background is in landscape design, and Matt Matisko, a registered landscape architect. Both men came from their own private landscape companies to join the Pattie team.

In the company’s Landscape Management division, Kate Adams was hired as a Garden and Property Manager, and will utilize her horticultural knowledge from past employment with Pettiti Garden Center and Dayton Nursery. With more than 25 years of experience including work as an arborist consultant for Augusta National, Chris Nasca is a seasoned veteran for TPG’s Plant Healthcare management team. Finally, Heidi Baumgart has been added in a new role for the company as Marketing Coordinator. Baumgart will bring skills from her previous experience as an advertising executive for a major landscape product manufacturer. P

Fabrication, Installation & Service

lizing

Specia

r 35 for ove

n:

years i

op r d rooft e g a ot wate k c h Pa & ing – steam ation & weld s r e l i o B ric ing etal fab m t e e & weld h n S o i t a fabric t Plastic eering artmen n p i e g d n e e Valued e maintenanc rvic Full se

Giambrone Construction Full Service WBE/FBE General Contractor

Giambrone Masonry

Mason & Stone Installation & Repair

Universal Scaffolding

Rental, Lease & Sale of Quality Scaffolding

440.237.1777 • www.liscohvac.com 12608 State Rd., N. Royalton, OH 44133

www.Giambrone.com Akron: 330.650.1400 Cleveland: 216.475.1200 10000 Aurora-Hudson Rd. - Hudson, OH 44236 www.propertiesmag.com 43


FOCUSED FORWARD McTech Corp.’s leadership team includes (from left) Senior Vice President of Business Development Vince Stephens, President/CEO Mark Perkins, Secretary/Treasurer Lisa Cifani and Executive Vice President/Chief Operating Officer Edwin Williams.

Designed to Deliver

Cleveland-based McTech Corp. spreads wings as GC, CM and Design/Builder By Lou Kren | Photos courtesy of McTech Corp.

W

ith expertise and experience in general contracting, design/build, construction management and program management, McTech Corp. has exhibited its talents nationwide since its founding in 1997. The company, located at 8100 Grand Ave., has served federal, state, municipal, educational, industrial, commercial and health care clients, and now boasts annual billing of $150 million. McTech, beyond its Cleveland headquarters, has offices in North Kansas City, Missouri; Riviera Beach, Florida; St. Albans, West Virginia; Columbus, Ohio; and New Orleans, Louisiana. Current and recent projects populate the U.S. map, with McTech active in Ohio, West Virginia, Virginia, Florida, Pennsylvania, Kentucky, Missouri, Louisiana, Oklahoma, Kansas, Texas, Colorado and Maryland. Its 80-employee team includes highly experienced construction professionals from project managers, field supervisors, and safety and quality-control specialists through to engineering and document-control personnel, according to Vince Stephens, senior vice president for business development at McTech. 44

Formed by Mark Perkins, now president and CEO, McTech takes on the energy of its founder. Perkins graduated the company through the Small Business Administration’s 8(a) Business Development Program, created to help small and disadvantaged businesses compete in the marketplace. It also helps these companies gain access to federal and private procurement markets. The focus of the program is to provide business development support including mentoring, procurement assistance, business counseling, training, financial assistance, surety bonding, and other management and technical assistance. In the 8(a) program, “the company must grow, and a certain percentage of work must not be federally funded,”

says Phillip Armstrong, McTech vice president of operations. “Mark did all of that, and graduated McTech from the 8(a) program in 2009, two years ahead of schedule, because the company met program goals and grew its revenue beyond the program thresholds.” In response, McTech pays forward, mentoring other contractors to complete the circle of small-business development. It has also formed McTech Foundation, whose mission is to support programs and initiatives to develop emerging businesses and offer educational assistance to disadvantaged urban-core youth. The foundation’s goal is to improve the community through grants and gifts. “What sets us apart is the ability to accomplish and deliver the owner’s Properties | January 2013


8100 Grand Ave. Cleveland, Ohio 44104 ph: 216.391.7700 www.mctech360.com

MBE General Contractor • Design/Builder • Construction Manager Bonding:

u 80 Million Dollars Single

u 200 Million Dollars Aggregate

Current Types:

u Single Award Government Contracts u Design/Build

u Indefinite Delivery Indefinite Quantity (IDIQ’s) u Construction Manager (CM) and

Construction Manager (CM) - at-Risk u Multiple Award Task Order Contract (MATOC) Bonding u Basic Ordering Agreement (BOA)

• 80 Million Dollars Single • 200 Million Dollars Aggregate

Current types • Single Award Government Contracts • Design/Build • Indefinite Delivery Indefinite Quantity (IDIQ’s) • Construction Manager (CM) & Construction Manager-at-Risk • Multiple Award Task Order Contract (MATOC) • Basic Ordering Agreement (BOA) Mark Perkins, President/CeO, MCteCh COrP.

www.propertiesmag.com 45


and wall structure to eliminate water problems, and is designed to provide a visually stimulating corridor. At platform level, the new stairs and elevator will open up into an enclosed vestibule, providing passengers the opportunity to wait in a weather-enclosed area. The platform will feature a new canopy. In addition, McTech was onsite for five years at NASA Glenn Research Center in Cleveland and Plum Brook Testing Facility in Sandusky. Work included a variety of tasks, including design/build of a geothermal heat-pump system, construcACADEMIC SUPPORT Currently, McTech Corp. is building a 151,000-square-foot, K-12 school complex tion of a greenhouse to grow plants for alternative fuels in Smithville, Ohio (Wayne County) for Green Local School District. and site improvements at desired results on a wide variety of proj- helped break ground for the new $18.5 both locations. ects,” Armstrong says. million RTA Cedar-University Red Line Also, McTech is the general The operative word there is vari- Rapid Station, formerly the University contractor for construction of a ety. The breadth of McTech’s portfolio Circle Rapid Station. McTech, as gen- 151,000-square-foot K-12 school comis staggering. Properties took a photo eral contractor, is using more than plex in Green, a $24 million greenfield tour of the company’s recent projects, 30 subcontractors while committing project. The GC package itself is $13 which include schools, military instal- approximately 25% of McTech’s pro- million. The main building will feature lations, dams, transportation facilities curement dollars to Disadvantaged two-story classroom wings flanking a and more. From site remediation to Business Enterprises. Scheduled for central gymnasium and cafeteria. construction of airtight buildings to completion in the summer of 2014, Impresses its toughest customer underground utilities installation – to the station, at the foot of Cedar Road name just a few – McTech has its hands Hill, will replace a 50-year-old bus-loop McTech has completed a host of design/ in all types of work. For example, location with a fully ADA-compliant, build projects throughout the country the company’s Environmental Division LEED-certified center. A major green for military clients, under the auspices performs a variety of work, including component includes a vegetated roof. of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. cleanups resulting from ammunition At Fort Riley, in Kansas, the company and high-explosives manufacturing as spearheaded design/build work for batwell as cleanups related to hazardoustalion headquarters, facilities for refueling material spills and contamination. battle tanks, warehouses and parking A graphic provided by the company lots. Another design/build project at Ft. shows that in each of the 24 quarters Leavenworth, Kansas, includes a training from 2009 to 2014, McTech was, or will facility for military working dogs. be, the prime contractor on more than “We called it the Puppy Palace,” 30 concurrent jobs in as many as eight recalls Armstrong, hinting at the Phillip Armstrong importance placed on specially trained states. Contract values on this list range from $500,000 to $50 million. The list McTech Corp. canines that literally save hundreds of doesn’t even include numerous projects lives each year. “It was located up a hill where McTech serves as a subcontractor. and about a mile from utilities, so we Ultimately, these statistics show that the The street-front wall will be glass to pro- had to bring in all of the utilities, and company can absorb work surges regard- vide an open, inviting feeling from the construct a complete training facility less of size and location, according to park to the train platforms, according to with obstacle courses and housing for company officials. RTA officials. Connecting the rail sta- all of the dogs.” tion and relocated bus transfer area will So impressed was the customer with Significant local presence be a significantly widened and enhanced McTech’s Fort Riley work that the comDespite its low profile locally, McTech pedestrian pathway underneath the rail pany received a letter from an Army is tackling several major Cleveland-area bridges. The walkway will be treated as Corps of Engineers district commander, projects. In September of 2012, McTech an extension of the station with a roof Col. Anthony J. Hoffmann.

“What sets us apart is the ability to accomplish and deliver the owner’s desired results on a wide variety of projects.”

46

Properties | January 2013


SPACE IMPROVEMENTS McTech Corp. has completed several projects for NASA, including at its Plum Brook Testing Facility, built in 1969 (above). Work included recoating and sealing the facility’s space vehicle vacuum chamber (below), where vehicles undergo zero-gravity evaluation.

“I note with pleasure that your firm received an outstanding performance evaluation for construction of the referenced contract [a battalion headquarters],” wrote Hoffmann. “Few contractors earn this high evaluation. The Ft. Riley Resident Office rated you outstanding for quality control, timely performance, effectiveness of management and compliance with labor standards. In essence, your staff and subcontractors provided a superb facility, ahead of schedule to the customer. You can be proud of your accomplishments.” The Corps of Engineers rates the performance on elements of each project, and on each project in total, as Outstanding, Above Average, Satisfactory, Marginal or Unsatisfactory. “’Outstanding’ is hard to achieve,” says Armstrong. “For all of our U.S. Army projects [and there are many], we have rated Above Average or Outstanding. That means we meet LEED [all Army projects are now designed to achieve some level of LEED certification] and safety requirements – we have not had an accident in five years – as well as quality control and other requirements. We repeatedly satisfy the Army Corps of Engineers – not many people do. “If Mark Perkins hadn’t built a good team at McTech, we wouldn’t be invited back for military projects and we wouldn’t be earning these evaluations,” he continues. “The Corps wouldn’t ask us to play ball on their ball field. It has the highest standards in the industry, and McTech meets them on a regular basis. To get a letter out of the blue from an Army Corps of Engineers colonel is very rare.”

Success in West Virginia Another recent project, at U.S. Customs and Border Protection’s Advanced Training Center in Harpers Ferry, West Virginia, brought recognition from that group. Work included the Leadership Academy, warehouse, helipad, wastewater treatment plant and other infrastructure projects. The Academy itself is a $35 million LEED Gold building. Due to poor design

quality, McTech came on as general contractor, acting as construction manager after the initial designer was “descoped,” according to the project manager for U.S. Customs and Border Protection. “McTech... brought an excellent new designer to the table and the project was converted to a... design/build fasttrack project,” wrote Robert Stanis, U.S. Customs and Border Protection project manager in a memo recapping the project. “Design moved rapidly and structural work started with no delays. Then it snowed a freakish five feet in two days, followed three weeks later by a foot of rain. The project was still completed on schedule. “McTech Corp. Has been receptive to our needs and supportive of

our goals,” he concluded. “They have been easy to work with and embrace a diverse environment. They find problems instead of ignoring them. Then they find the solutions. They are flexible. I whole-heartedly recommend them.”

Organization built to succeed Anchored in Cleveland, with work stretching from Fort Bliss to Fort Carson, McTech boasts a formidable footprint. “We want people to realize what a good, solid company Mark Perkins has built,” concludes Armstrong. “The quality and depth of the organization that we have assembled are phenomenal,” Perkins says. “Nobody in Cleveland knows we are here, but we are changing that.” P www.propertiesmag.com 47


Proud partner at Lorain County Community College’s iLOFT

We were proud to be part of the team for Lorain County Community College’s iLOFT building project

1955 Liberty Ave., vermiLion, oH 44089

Construction Management General Contracting Integrated Project Delivery

Professional, accurate, on-time. That is Straub Surveying…your Point of Beginning. 3D Laser Scanning/Surveying Professional Construction Layout Exisiting Conditions Surveys Rocky River, Ohio | (440) 333-1700 www.StraubSurveying.com | Info@StraubSurveying.com

Design-Build Owner’s Representative Program Management

Ozanne Construction Company, Inc.

1635 E. 25th Street │Cleveland, Ohio 44114-4214 P: 216 696 2876 │F: 216 696 8613│www.ozanne.com

48

Properties | January 2013


Modern Makeover

Lorain County Community College converts outdated library into innovative iLOFT building By Doug Bardwell | Photos by Scott Pease

E

ducational institutions don’t get to remodel or renovate all that often, so when the opportunity arose, Lorain County Community College (LCCC) brought together an award-winning team to maximize their investment. A new library building had been completed in 2008 and the original library building was available. With the college’s evolution and 120% enrollment growth over the past 10 years, the administration saw an opportunity to create a cutting-edge classroom building for the future. Called iLOFT, which stands for Innovative Learning Opportunities for Tomorrow, the building is occupied primarily by the college’s Social Sciences program, providing a collaborative and interactive learning environment that is as flexible as it is state-of-the-art. Designed by the firms of Sasaki Associates from Boston and Clark & Post Architects Inc. from Lorain, the facility is designed to provide learning opportunities not just in classrooms, but throughout the building.

Ronald Cocco, president of Clark & Post, recalls, “the provost wanted us to create a new learning paradigm, creating educational areas in multiple settings. “This opened the entirety of the building to be a learning space – not just the conventional classrooms, but also the lounge, the common areas, even the corridors,” he says. The result is a facility that is truly forward thinking, according to Katia Lucic, principal at Sasaki Associates.

“[This building] puts LCCC probably ahead of every other learning institution I know of at this point,” she says, in its holistic approach to academic training.

Expanding educational opportunities Schematic design began in September 2009. Lucic notes that, early on, the project team “looked at how the learning process occurred on campus and how other institutions were using their spaces.” The goal was two-fold: to optiwww.propertiesmag.com 49


HIGH MARKS The entire northern face of the building is devoted to private and shared spaces for faculty and adjunct professors. This teacher’s area benefits from two-story high, north-facing glass walls.

mize the active learning experience, both design team to determine the best way inside and outside the classroom, she says. to program the space. As one idea after The project increased useable space by another was proposed, the group began 22,000 square feet, adding a second floor to realize there was certainly more than in the previous two-story high central one “best” way to deliver education. library area. Now able to plan 73,600 “With all the suggestions, there was square feet of space for educational use, no unique winner – we wanted to do faculty, administrators and students them all,” says Laura Carissimi, director Precision Anniv Quarter Ad Final_Layout 1 2/9/12 11:19 AM Page 1 began a series of meetings with the of purchasing and facilities planning

Precision Environmental has reached our 25th anniversary as an abatement, selective demolition and specialty services company serving Northeast Ohio. ank you to everyone who has contributed to the success of our company for the past 25 years.

We look forward to working together for many more years to come.

for LCCC. “No longer do we use the concept of the ‘sage’ standing in front of the class. Now, we look at our faculty as coaches and mentors, interacting extensively with the students. New technologies demand new learning environments and less formal spaces. “With infinitely moveable seating, classes can be set up in traditional classroom fashion for the first 30 minutes of class and then rearranged instantly into small group discussions for the remainder of class.” Accommodating a diverse student population, ranging from age 18 through 65+, the new design provides private spaces as well as small and large areas for students to gather and collaborate. Building codes would allow 1,782 students in the building; however, with the inherent flexibility demanded of the space, current occupancy is programmed for just 1,513 students. LCCC’s student mix is roughly onethird full-time students and two-thirds part-time. The building is open six days a week, serving local and international students. Seventy percent of the students come for day classes while the other 30% attend in the evenings.

Arranging areas 5500 Old Brecksville Road • Independence, OH 44131 216.642.6040 • www.precision-env.com

50

Final configuration of the space resulted in 19 conventional classrooms, 14 study rooms with doors and five Properties | January 2013


ILLUMINATING EFFECT In the teacher’s area, multiple large glass-globe pendant fixtures provide attractive lighting.

open study rooms. Classrooms and study rooms align with the east and west walls of the building. The southern end is primarily used for open, student study areas. The entire northern face of the building is devoted to private and shared spaces for faculty and adjunct professors. “We have so many adjunct instructors that we needed a place they could go to do their work,” Carissimi says. “Taking a cue from many businesses, we utilize a ‘hoteling’ concept to provide private storage for each adjunct instructor and then they share common work surfaces. We were also able to provide them with private areas where they can counsel individual students if the need should arise.” The teacher’s area benefits from twostory high, north-facing glass walls. Multiple large glass-globe pendant fixtures provide illumination at night. The central core of the building on the first floor is occupied by the TERC – the Teacher Education Resource Center, where a wealth of tools and materials are available to teachers. The perimeter walls of the TERC are floor-to-ceiling translucent 3/8-inch-thick glass with silicone butt glazing, which allows exterior light to permeate to the interior of the space. Outside the TERC, on the public corridor side of the wall, students and teachers can utilize the full-height glass walls as oversized white boards, provided the proper erasable markers are used. Tables

and counters along these walls provide additional collaborative work surfaces. Since the building was so wide, Lucic wanted to bring light into the core of the building. Skylights were added above the north-south corridors and natural light now brightens the first floor spaces as well. Above the plastic light diffus-

ers, the area around the skylights was painted blue, to make even grey Ohio winter skies look more attractive. A number of the classrooms feature moveable partitions for increased flexibility. The door wall portion of the private offices utilizes a demountable partition system with a sliding door.

with Sasaki Assoc.

Lorain County Community College iLoft Building

440-233-8487

A N OT H E R

I N N OVAT I V E

DESIGN

SOLUTION

www.clarkandpost.co m www.propertiesmag.com 51


All Things Concrete – Your Commercial & Decorative Total Concrete Solution

Ohio Desk wishes to thank Lorain County Community College and the iLoft Learning Center for allowing us to be a

part of your team. 21st Century ConCrete ConstruCtion inC. 13925 Enterprise Ave. Cleveland, OH 44135

216.362.0900

www.21stcenturyconcrete.com

52

Furniture Solutions for Corporate, Professional Services, Healthcare, Higher Education and Government

800.326.0601 ohiodesk.com Akron Canton Cleveland Erie Warren Youngstown

Properties | January 2013


OPPORTUNITIES EVERYWHERE In the iLOFT building, educating isn’t confined to classrooms. Learning opportunities also present themselves along corridors with seating nooks (top) and study counters (middle), and in common areas featuring full-height, glass “writing walls” (bottom).

Using demountable walls and movable partitions ensures the most flexibility for years to come. A floating, free-formed area was created above the first-floor core offices and has become one of the most popular areas in the building. Called the Learning Oasis, this blue, carpeted area is home to a half-dozen large LCD screens, surrounded by banquette seating for small group collaboration on a variety of projects. To provide for future wiring flexibility, the actual floor was lowered eight inches to allow for raised, computer access flooring. Overhead, an open gridwork ceiling of four-inch by four-inch wide cells camouflages the ductwork, diffusers, sprinklers and other mechanical elements above. Single tube, strip fluorescent lighting floats just above the gridwork to augment the natural light coming from the linear skylights. The perimeter of the Oasis features long, serpentine-shaped, 48-inch-high walls that have white Corian caps and more Corian wall-mounted work surfaces following the undulating design. From below, the serpentine walls appear as a long curved soffit, covered in a light-toned birch wood wallcovering. Along the corridor walls, matching Corian study counters run the length of the corridor. Grey work chairs provide seating and abundant electrical and data outlets are easy to access at desktop height. Every so often, the continuous Corian surface dips down to seating height, enabling students to lounge or read while waiting to enter their classrooms. Just outside the classrooms, custom seating nooks of white Corian, with their own indirect lighting, invite students to sit and lounge while waiting for class. Gray Trespa wall panels are custom cut to match the bean-shaped profile of these recessed seating nooks. Aligning the upper and lower curved soffits was a unique challenge for the general contractor, Ozanne Construction Company. According to www.propertiesmag.com 53


Painting

Managedwith Properties

Call today today for a free Call free estimate estimate 216.823.0064 or 800.GoCerta 216.823.0064 www.certapro.com cleveland.certapro.com

AIA Cleveland 1001 Huron Road Suite 101 Cleveland, Ohio 44115 (216) 575-1224/FAX (216) 575-1244 ©1990, AIA

What does BIM mean to you? BIM can be many things—green, integrated, a process, a technology. But all you care about is your BIM, your team and your clients. All we care about is making BIM work for you. • Revit, Navisworks and Facilities Management experts • Implementation, training, technical support—in person or online • IMAGINiT Clarity for Autodesk® Revit® Server, Scan to BIM and IMAGINiT Utilities for Revit • ProductivityNOW Portal provides support, eLearning, free Utilities and an active community.The ProductivityNOW Portal has content for everyone, with advanced functionality available only to IMAGINiT clients. To get started or ask a question, call our Cleveland office at 216-834-8300, our Columbus office at 614-923-0914 or visit imaginit.com

54

Properties | January 2013


SUSPENDED SPACE A floating, free-formed area was created above the first-floor core offices and has become one of the most popular areas in the building. Called the Learning Oasis, this blue, carpeted area is home to a half-dozen large LCD screens, surrounded by banquette seating for small group collaboration on a variety of projects.

Patrick Monroe, project manager for Ozanne, the tradespeople “did an amazing job” of maintaining alignment as the soffit snakes its way around the Oasis.

Building from the inside out The soffit work wasn’t the only challenge for the builders. Another significant hurdle was devising a way to support the Oasis and the new second floor, an issue that was dealt with early on in the project. “The existing columns weren’t originally designed to carry this additional load,” says Robert Fitzgerald, vice president of Ozanne. So the team “needed to excavate and enlarge each foundation along with shoring each of the columns.” This process began in the fall of 2010, kicking off construction for the project. Prime contracts totaled $11 million and covered general trades, plumbing, HVAC, fire protection and a combined electrical and technology contract. LCCC directly contracted the audio/

visual and the security system through state contracts available to the college. Keeping the same exterior walls, there was extensive demolition of the interior; but 90% of the construction debris was sorted and recycled. Although the college made the decision not to apply for LEED certifi-

systems with variable speed drives were used along with water efficient devices. A new electrical system was installed using light sensors and a building automation system.” New insulated glazing replaced all the original single-pane glazing, and thermal break frames were installed. On the roof, an additional six inches of insulation was added. Mansards were sealed off and white insulating spray foam was used above the open cell gridwork in the Oasis. By January 2012, substantial completion was achieved and classes began with the summer session. Katia Lucic Students and teachers will both from this new movement Sasaki Associates benefit in education, as teachers find new ways to impart knowledge and stucation, the facility incorporates plenty dents find it easy to study however and of green features. wherever they find it most comfort“While we didn’t apply for certifi- able. While the building still looks the cation, we followed LEED guidelines same from the outside, the teaching in most every respect,” says Robert concepts and the building’s functionFlyer, director of plant operations and ality set a new standard that many construction. “High efficiency VAV others will want to emulate. P

“[This building] puts LCCC probably ahead of every other learning institution [in its holistic approach to academic training].”

www.propertiesmag.com 55


Proper Protection

A look at the benefits of a well-maintained building automation system By Steve Leister Jacco & Associates

I

n an era in which technological advances are introduced faster and more frequently than ever, it seems that one of the most underused and under-maintained is the Building Automation System. These computerized systems, utilizing an intelligent network of electronic devices, are designed to monitor and control mechanical, lighting and electric systems within a building. More and more buildings are being built with these automation systems in place, while plenty of existing facilities are being upgraded with them. Yet, all too often, these systems are not used to their potential. Working in the HVAC industry for almost 20 years, I have seen automation systems that are installed, forgotten about and not utilized. This is unfortunate, as the money paid to install them is not much compared to what a facility could save if these systems are properly used and maintained. I have talked with many customers regarding their building automation systems. One of the hardest points to convey is the importance of maintaining such a

AUTOMATION UPKEEP Building automation systems are powerful tools for monitoring and controlling energy usage, but periodic check-ups are vital.

system. Most of the time they say things like, “it’s a computer so what could go wrong” or “it’s an automation system so it should never break.” As most people know, this is not the case. It’s like buying a new car – if you don’t perform routine

maintenance, it will soon turn into a big, shiny piece of junk! With time, every system needs a tune-up. In maintaining a building automation system, there are quite a few different components that need to be checked, from temperature sensors to air flow sensors to damper actuators and so on. I have found that if one component is not working correctly, then the whole system is not operating correctly. A proper maintenance program should include periodic check-ups. We recom-

Expert Brick Matching What is your building is costing you?

Geothermal Solutions From What is your building is costing you? 0.5—300 Tons

Jacco can help reduce your operational costs, by providing an Energy and Economic Analysis for your HVAC system. The government and utility Jacco can help reduce your operational costs, by companies are offering rebates and deductions for providing an Energy and Economic Analysis for your energy efficient HVAC systems, allow us to help you HVAC system. Theoperation. government and utility maximize your building

9005 Woodland Ave. Cleveland, OH 44104 216-791-9800 office 216-791-5116 fax www.bruderinc.com 56

companies are offering rebates and deductions for Standard, Semi-Custom energy HVAC systems, to&helpatyou For efficient more information contactallow Greg us Drensky (330) 463-0100, ext. 126 or gregd@jacco.com. maximize your building operation. Custom Designs Or visit our website at www.jacco.com.

For more more information at at For informationcontact contactGreg GregDrensky Drensky (330) 463-0100, ext. 126 or gregd@jacco.com. (330) 463-0100, ext. 126 or gregd@jacco.com. Or visit Or visit our ourwebsite websiteatatwww.jacco.com. www.jacco.com. Properties | January 2013


mend quarterly visits. This provides building users with a number of benefits:

Database backup One benefit of routine maintenance is database backup. Building automation systems capture and log data from the various systems in a building to show performance history and trends. This can include energy usage, such as electricity, water and gas. It can also include building access and safety data, such as surveillance camera footage, records of employee attendance and overall facility usage. Routine maintenance provides an opportunity to ensure proper performance of these systems, while providing regular backups of this critical data.

Technology updates Often, technology updates are made available, which could be very important to a system, even critical to its proper operation and security. The best way to know if your system is up to date is through regular check-ups from a trained service provider.

reliable & local Call our CommerCial SaleS managerS today, to diSCuSS your eleCtriC ServiCe needS

Wes Tarver: 216.664.3922 ext.145 Kim Smith: 216.664.3922 ext. 253 viSit uS at www.Cpp.org

When Quality Counts, Count on Delta.

System analysis A building automation system relies on proper communication between all of its components. Even after a system has been properly installed, other technology within a building may change and can have an effect on its performance. This could include interference from other devices or a damaged communication cable, for instance. Also, there are quite a few systems using wireless technology these days and sensors for these devices are often powered by batteries, which need to be changed from time to time. Regular maintenance provides an opportunity to address these issues. If an automation system is maintained properly and is tuned properly, it will help the building owner quite a bit – and this has a ripple effect. If a system is operating properly and temperatures are constant, then the people/employees within the building are happy. If the employees are happy, they tend to not get sick or call off as often. If people are at work more often, productivity improves and everyone is happier. P Steve Leister is service operations manager with Jacco & Associates. For more information, call him at 330.463.0100 ext. 119.

Providing Industrial Cleaning, Painting & Maintenance with Quality & Service that is Second to None. INDUSTRIAL CLEANING & MAINTENANCE • Hot pressure / steam cleaning • Waterproofing and sealing • Parking deck cleaning, painting, and striping • Overhead cleaning / painting • Exterior and interior building cleaning • Industrial oven cleaning • Dust collector cleaning • Pigeon / bat excrement removal • Graffiti removal

• Roof fan and ventilator cleaning • Industrial exhaust system cooling and heating coil cleaning • Kitchen exhaust system and kitchen equipment cleaning • Machinery cleaning / painting • Welding exhaust cleaning • Construction clean-up or restoration of property for sale and leasing

INDOOR AIR QUALITY • HVAC system cleaning & sanitizing • Air duct cleaning • Mold remediation

Contact Delta Industrial today! 216-281-8700 5201 DENISON AVE., CLEVELAND OHIO 44102 www.propertiesmag.com 57


SinCe 1979 nationwide bUilder

We are proud to have provided general contracting services for Animal Clinic of Chardon

440-357-4500

CommerCial • mediCal • Veterinary • dental

9385 Hamilton dr., mentor, oH 44060

national leaderS in tHe ConStrUCtion oF

www.klineconstruction.com

Controlled enVironment FaCilitieS SPeCialiZinG in Veterinary HoSPitalS


Pet Project

Veterinary team realizes dream with new state-of-the-art home for Animal Clinic of Chardon By John Elliott | Photos by Ken Krych

P

et owners in Geauga County and the Chagrin Valley now have one of the most professional, state-of-the art animal care facilities in Ohio available to them, thanks to the construction of the nearly 7,000-square-foot Animal Clinic of Chardon on Water Street, close to the intersection of Route 44 and Route 6. The single-story, stone and wood-frame building marks the completion of a dream by the husband-and-wife veterinary team, Drs. Tom and Wendy Frankmann. The building, located on a 1.5-acre, wooded, commercially-zoned parcel, has dedicated rooms for animal surgery, lab work, owner consultation and education, animal pharmacy, patient waiting, a self-serve dog wash station, staff offices and staff break areas. Assisting the Frankmanns and the 12-member staff is associate veterinarian, Dr. Jessica DeMarco. The $1.7 million building replaces an older, 2,400-square-foot building that the Frankmanns felt was too small and outdated, given the new tools and procedures in veterinary medicine. The Frankmanns wasted no expense in developing a more modern facility, tapping the services of an architect that specializes in veterinary design and a builder who is known for veterinary construction.

The Frankmanns realized the old building they were using would not allow them to expand. The building had some water damage on the roof, the HVAC system didn’t work properly, and there was no meeting room for clients and staff. “The building was not falling apart, but couldn’t grow as a business,” explains Wendy. She envisioned a modern building and started designing an ideal facility in her mind before consulting with a builder and an architect. She met Larry Kline, owner of Mentorbased Kline Construction, a nationally known veterinary construction contractor, at a veterinary conference. She met Melanie Friedman, a principal at FMD Architects in Fairlawn, while looking at veterinary equipment at Midmark, a company in Versailles,

Ohio that makes medical equipment. FMD has been involved with nearly 20 clinics in the last two years, and won a Veterinary Economics Hospital Design Merit Award for the Creekside Animal Clinic completed in 2007. The Frankmanns secured a Small Business Administration loan through Live Oak Bank in Wilmington, N.C. Construction began in the fall of 2011 and completed this past August. Veterinary medicine is a field of medicine that has its own set of challenges, Wendy notes. “It’s a medical facility and it deals with animals,” she says. Because of this, the building must use materials that contain noise, manage air flow, and use surfaces that resist scratching, biting and liquids. Not many building types have to be as concerned with www.propertiesmag.com 59


FITTING FLEXIBILITY Exam rooms have foldable tables, allowing doctors to exam pets on the floor if they wish. Floor examinations are sometimes easier for particular pets.

design issues such as sounds, odor, air exchanges, infections, durable materials and the ability to easily clean them. An efficient floor plan is one of the most critical aspects in an animal care facility. The location of the reception desk, waiting area, surgical and treatment areas, and examination rooms must allow for smooth traffic flow that minimizes movement and allows safe entry and exit of pets and their owners. HVAC systems are designed to keep the interior air clean and fresh by containing unpleasant odors. Soundproofing that reduces noise and helps prevent sounds from reaching outer offices and waiting areas is provided through high-tech and proprietary technology. “You really need to know what you’re doing when you go to the veterinary arena,” Wendy says.

“The Frankmanns had a wonderful vision for their new clinic,” says Friedman, the architect. “It consisted of a single-story, rustic lodge with warm materials and a vaulted lobby that felt welcoming to their clients with separate dog and cat entries, and a very service-oriented clinic. Their forward-thinking practice led to the incorporation of separated boarding

room where clients can wash their pets without soaking the inside of their homes in the process.” The building features earth tones with its stone-like brick and wood exterior. “I wanted the stone work,” explains Wendy, who conceived many of the design ideas. “I wanted it to look more rustic, like a lodge.” She is as pleased with the building’s aesthetic appeal as its practical advantages. “There’s an ambiance about the place that’s less stressful and more relaxed,” she says. The front of the building has a majestic appearance with four brick columns which sport the clinic’s own symbol that is found throughout the interior: a square-shaped cross with outlines of a cat and a dog. This symbol also represents the building’s interior layout, which, beginning with the waiting area, is split into two separate sections for dogs and cats. “A big push for us was to be more cat friendly,” Tom explains. The building has all new storm sewers, front and rear parking, and new landscaping which includes benches and decorative stone structures. Much of the soil in the front was removed and replaced with compactable clay. Soil was removed four to five feet deep. Wetlands located in the rear of the buildings mandated a permit from the Army Corps of Engineers. The building is located on the top of a slope, allowing for easy drainage and cleaning. “The most challenging part of this building design was getting it to fit onto the site,” says Friedman. “The lot is a nice acreage, but is very long and narrow. We were bound in the back by a drainage ditch and tree line, and in the front by their existing building. We gave the civil engineer quite a challenge, but in the end everything came together for the perfect fit.” The entrance drive allows visitors to park either in front of the building or behind it. The east side of the building features one of the most unique concepts for

The east side of the building features one of the most unique concepts for many clients: a drive-through animal pharmacy. This saves clients from having to wait inside the building and it maximizes staff productivity. facilities, an educational room for puppy training classes that can double as a staff meeting and continuing education space, as well as a dog wash

Proud to be part of the team at The AnimAl CliniC of ChArdon COMMERCIAL BUILDERS

PETER A. CORSO, PRES.

Specializing in Metal Framing, Drywall & Acoustic Ceilings 216-403-8930 • Fax 440-867-2948 • corsoconstructio@aol.com 60

Properties | January 2013


many clients: a drive-through animal pharmacy. This saves clients from having to wait inside the building and it maximizes staff productivity. “Being located in Chardon, the Frankmanns are providing a great service to clients in the winter, and from the elderly to families with young children, we think this convenience will be appreciated all year long,” Friedman says of the drive-through. “Dr. Wendy has been gracious enough to provide tours to a few of our other veterinarian clients and this is one of the most talked about design elements.” The rear of the building has an enclosed exercise area for animals with synthetic turf and synthetic stone that are comfortable for pets and make for easy cleaning. The exterior vinyl resembles wood. There is an employee entrance in the rear, along with kennels where animals can be boarded. A walkway surrounds the building, allowing staff and clients to take a break.

in shelves and a built-in sink, which allows three animals to be examined at the same time. A modular lift scale can hold an animal weighing up to 300 pounds. This versatile scale is not fixed; it can be moved to different exam rooms. There is a “pack and prep” room where tools are sterilized close to the surgery rooms. Cat owners can have their pets boarded in a secluded section that has cages and a play area. The Frankmanns plan to add a climbing tower for cats in this area.

“Here they get a chance to exercise and relax,” Tom says.

Separating cats and dogs The separation into cat and dog sections begins at the entrance; even the glass-enclosed vestibule is separated into two sections by a partial wall. The divided waiting area with furniture, plants, TV screens, animal-themed artwork and windows faces a common reception desk. “Epoxy floors, ceramic tile with epoxy grout and some areas of epoxy

State-of-the-art equipment The clinic is furnished with stateof-the-art equipment, including a triangular treatment table with built-

Proud Team Member of the Animal Clinic of Chardon

Generations of Service & Integrity

www.propertiesmag.com 61


Congratulations to Kline Construction on completion of the Chardon animal CliniC

HALLMARK EXCAVATING, INC. Family Owned & Operated Since 1960

482 Blackbrook Rd., Painesville Township 440/352-3138 • fax 440/352-0039 hallmarkex@sbcglobal.net

Remember Hallmark Excavating for All Your Site & Trucking Needs.

An EMCOR Company

PURPOSEFUL PLACEMENT The location of the reception desk (above), waiting area, surgery and examination rooms allows for smooth traffic flow as well as safe entry and exit of pets and their owners.

Mechanical

Fire Protection

Plumbing Fire Sprinklers Heating Fire Extinguishers Air Conditioning  Kitchen Suppression Process Piping Special Hazards  Alarm & Detection Offices In: Ohio - Akron, Cincinnati, Cleveland, Columbus, Fremont, Marion, Youngstown Pennsylvania - Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, Reading New Jersey - Atlantic City, Phillipsburg Michigan - Detroit • Washington DC

www.sacomunale.com

Large Enough To Meet Your Needs, Small Enough To Care

paint were provided as the most durable and cleanable options,” Friedman says. “In an effort to keep the noise level under control with the vaulted ceiling in the lobby, we went with an acoustical ceiling tile, but Dr. Wendy selected a colored tile to still give a warm appearance, which was an excellent decision and really sets her lobby apart from other clinics.” An exam area behind the reception desk is for technicians to perform blood tests, administer vaccines, discharge and other procedures that don’t require a doctor. Dual hallways – one for cats, one for dogs – are accessed from the waiting area. Each has private offices and care areas. Unlike the former building, there are dedicated rooms for dental care and surgery, and an intensive care unit. “We didn’t have that in the other building,” Tom says. “Once you learn the right way to do it, you can’t compromise.” The exam rooms have foldable tables, allowing the doctors to exam pets on the floor if they wish. Floor examinations are sometimes easier for some pets. One exam room has a hydraulic table lift.

Kids play area A kid’s play room is situated between two exam rooms. Kline, the builder,

62

Properties | January 2013


OPERATIVE OPTIONS The clinic has state-of-the-art equipment, including a triangular treatment table with built-in shelves and a built-in sink, which allows three animals to be examined simultaneously.

notes he has built kids play rooms before, but this is the first one built between two exam rooms. The purpose is to give kids a place to stay busy while the pet is being treated. “You’ve got a dog that’s nervous to begin with, and you’ve got kids fussing around,” Kline explains. “If kids are on the other side of the window and they’re playing, you’re only worrying about the pet.” The building’s most unique feature of all, according to Kline, is the self-serve dog wash, which has its own room. This was Wendy’s idea: a place where people can wash their pets. Kline has built more than 90 animal hospitals but says he has never seen this before.

Most laboratory work is done onsite in a special laboratory room. Radiology is done on-site with a digital machine, but all X-rays are reviewed off-site by board-certified veterinary radiologists. The X-rays and the EKGs can be transmitted over the computer, thanks to Wi-Fi connectivity. A consultation room with furniture is also used to perform euthanasia so that the process is more comfortable and less sterile. The room has been much appreciated by clients, Tom says. “The people have loved that,” he says.

Proud to be part of the Team for Animal Clinic of Chardon

Mark Studer

Staff comforts When the new building was completed about three months ago, the practice nearly doubled its staff. There is a staff lounge, complete with kitchen appliances, cabinets, table and television.

There is also an education room for clients and staff with a library. Tom notes that licensed veterinary nurses are required to maintain continuing education credits. In the future, the clinic will have overnight boarding for animals with 24-hour care. The veterinary practice currently has about 3,000 active clients. That clientele is destined to grow as pet owners learn of the exceptional qualities of the new Animal Clinic of Chardon. P

President ■ ■

38348 Airport Parkway, Unit D Willoughby, OH 44094

CUSTOM CABINETS COUNTER TOPS 440/951-EURO (3876) fax 440/951-0951 www.propertiesmag.com 63


CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT Updated info on important projects in the region

PN-X1112042 AKRON CHILDREN’S CRITICAL CARE TOWER Akron, OH (Summit Co.) ESTIMATED AMOUNT: $180,000,000 CONTRACTING METHOD: G.C. Subcontracts (By Invitation Only) STATUS: Project is in design phase; groundbreaking anticipated for Spring 2013 with construction expected to begin July 2013; updated estimated amount. OWNER: Akron Children’s Hospital 1 Perkins Square Akron, OH 44308 www.akronchildrens.org (330) 543-1000 ARCHITECT: Hasenstab Architects, Inc. 190 N. Union Street, Suite 400 Akron, OH 44304 www.hainc.cc (330) 434-4464 FAX (330) 434-8546 ARCHITECT: HKS Architects - Dallas 1919 McKinney Avenue Dallas, TX 75201 (214) 969-5599 G.C.: Oscar J. Boldt Construction 2525 N. Roemer Road Appleton, WI 54911 www.theboldtcompany.com (920) 739-6321 FAX (920) 739-4409 G.C.: Welty Building Corporation 3421 Ridgewood Road, Suite 200 Fairlawn, OH 44333 www.weltybldg.com (330) 867-2400 FAX (330) 864-4566 ENGINEER/MECHANICAL: Bandwen-WilliamsKindbom Consulting Engineers

3475 Forest Lake Drive, Suite 300 Akron, OH 44685 www.bwkengineering.com (330) 839-9633 FAX (330) 889-9644 DETAILS: New 415,000 SF neonatal intensive care tower; new individual patient rooms; new emergency department; LEED silver design PN-W1115035 NEW OUTDOOR POOL Wadsworth, OH (Medina Co.) CONTRACTING METHOD: C.M. Subcontracts UPDATE: C.M. award has received final approval from council; bidding possible February 2013. OWNER: City of Wadsworth 120 Maple Street Wadsworth, OH 44281 www.wadsworthcity.com (330) 335-1521 ARCHITECT: Braun & Steidl Architects - Akron 1041 West Market Street Akron, OH 44313 www.bsa-net.com (330) 864-7755 FAX (330) 864-3691 C.M.: Welty Building Corporation 3421 Ridgewood Road, Suite 200 Fairlawn, OH 44333 www.weltybldg.com (330) 867-2400 FAX (330) 864-4566 POOL CONSULTANT: Counsilman/Hunsaker & Associates 4969 Ambs Road St. Louis, MO 63128 (314) 894-1245 FAX (314) 894-0109

DETAILS: Outdoor pool is to be located at the New Community Center Campus; approx. 4,500-5,000 SF pool could be installed PN-X0209042 TOWN HALL RENOVATION Munson Township, OH (Geauga Co.) CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids UPDATE: Drawings are being completed; bidding possible December 2012/January 2013. OWNER: Munson Township - Geauga Co. 12210 Auburn Road Chardon, OH 44024 www.munsontwp.com (440) 286-9255 ARCHITECT: Penttila Architects 10710 Mitchells Mill Road Chardon, OH 44024 (440) 285-5080 FAX (440) 285-5075 DETAILS: Expand the existing building from it’s 3,763 SF to 8,007 SF; some of the proposed changes include a new public meeting room with seating for 30 people; an updated kitchen and additional storage and work stations for trustees PN-W0321072 NEW FIRE STATION NO. 36 Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) 3552 East 131 Street ESTIMATED AMOUNT: $3,200,000 CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids UPDATE: Owner is working with Engineer on schematics and site plan design; no additional information available at this time. OWNER: City of Cleveland 601 Lakeside Avenue, Room 128

Concrete Sawing and Drilling Professionals A DiGeronimo Company

Wall Sawing Slab Sawing Wire Sawing Core Drilling

Shot Blasting & Grinding Shoring/Needle Beaming Concrete Removal & Replacement Interior Building Excavation Ground Penetrating Radar NEW!

Specialty equipment providing emission and dust free options including 480 volt mini excavator, propane powered bobcats, and HEPA filtered air filtration devices. 5500 Old Brecksville Road, Independence, Ohio 44131

216.573-2400 phone

•

216.573-2401 fax

www.precisionprocut.com 64

Properties | January 2013


Cleveland, OH 44114 www.city.cleveland.oh.us (216) 664-2620 FAX (216) 664-2177 AGENT: City of Cleveland Division of Architecture 601 Lakeside Avenue, Room 517A Cleveland, OH 44114 (216) 664-2374 FAX (216) 664-4220 Robert Vilkas, RA, LEED GA (216) 6643577, rvilkas@city.cleveland.oh.us ENGINEER: Richard L. Bowen & Associates 13000 Shaker Boulevard Cleveland, OH 44120 www.rlba.com (216) 491-9300 FAX (216) 491-8053 DETAILS: 12,500 SF, two-stories; four-bay apparatus room, training facilities, meeting facilities, kitchen and dining facilities, bathing and individual sleeping accommodations for 14 personnel; sitework; utilities; concrete; thermal and moisture protection; HVAC; electrical; tele/data systems; plumbing; carbon-monoxide exhaust. PN-V0623064 EASTERLY WWTC CHEMICAL STORAGE & FEED FACILITY (EFPI-3) Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids UPDATE: Project is off hold and is moving forward; engineering is underway; bidding possible fall 2013. OWNER: Northeast Ohio Regional Sewer District 3900 Euclid Avenue Cleveland, OH 44115 www.neorsd.org (216) 881-6600 FAX (216) 881-2330 ENGINEER: R.E. Warner & Associates 25777 Detroit Road, Suite 200 LaCentre Plaza II Westlake, OH 44145 www.rewarner.com (440) 835-9400 FAX (440) 835-9474 DETAILS: Bid File No. P-1042 A consolidated chemical storage and feed facility is to be designed and constructed that will serve the current and future needs of the Easterly WWTP. PN-X1217062 HISTORIC WOODLAND CEMETERY GATEHOUSE Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids STATUS: A/E Service RFP’s due Wednesday, January 23, 2013 at 12:00 Noon (To Owner). OWNER: City of Cleveland Dept. of Public Works 500 Lakeside Avenue Cleveland, OH 44114 www.city.cleveland.oh.us Robert Vilkas, RA, LEED AP, Manager (216) 664-3577, rvilkas@city.cleveland. oh.us AGENCY: City of Cleveland Division of Architecture 601 Lakeside Avenue, Room 517A

Cleveland, OH 44114 (216) 664-2374 FAX (216) 664-4220 DETAILS: Reconstruction of the Historic Gatehouse at Woodland Cemetery; details to be announced. PN-X1214036 MUNICIPAL COURT RENOVATIONS Medina, OH (Medina Co.) 135 N. Elmwood Ave. CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids STATUS: City council set project as a 2013 spending priority; no additional information has been released. OWNER: City of Medina 132 N. Elmwood Avenue Medina, OH 44256 www.medinaoh.org (330) 725-8861 DETAILS: Various renovation projects at the municipal court building; plumbing; electrical; HVAC; finishes; specific details to be determined. PN-X0127039 ACME FRESH MARKET Heritage Crossing of Green Green, OH (Summit Co.) 3875 Massillon Road ESTIMATED AMOUNT: $15,000,000 - $20,000,000

CONTRACTING METHOD: D/B Subcontracts (By Invitation Only) UPDATE: Final site plan has been approved by the city; no permits have been issued at this time; no additional information has been released. OWNER/DEVELOPER: Albrecht, Inc. 17 S. Main Street, Suite 401 Akron, OH 44308 (330) 376-6611 FAX (330) 376-7933 D/B: Krumroy-Cozad Construction 380 W. Exchange Street Akron, OH 44302 (330) 376-4136 FAX (330) 376-8681 DETAILS: 72,400 SF grocery store will be an anchor tenant on 16.5 acres owned and developed by Albrecht Inc.; sitework; concrete; masonry; thermal and moisture protection; steel; plumbing; electrical; HVAC; doors and hardware; finishes. PN-U0619034 3RD DISTRICT POLICE STATION Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids UPDATE: Announcing Architect. OWNER: MidTown Cleveland Inc. 3634 Euclid Avenue, Suite 215

Landscaping, Snow Plowing & Ice Control Specialists

The Jands Group, Inc. Building, Grounds & Janitorial

• Commercial, Industrial, Institutional & Residential

We’re Still Growing

• Over 20 years of experience

216.518.8478 • 4500 Lee Rd., Ste. 231, Cleveland, OH 44128 • thejandsgroup01@yahoo.com

Parking Planning, Design & Consulting Parking Technologies Parking Assessment & Studies Signage Programming Design/Build Services

5455 Broadview Road, Suite 202, Parma, OH 44134 www.graelic.com 216-335-9910 www.propertiesmag.com 65


Cleveland, OH 44115 www.midtowncleveland.org (216) 391-5080 FAX (216) 391-6285 Jeff Pesler, ext 108,jpesler@midtowncleveland.org ARCHITECT: Richard L. Bowen & Associates 13000 Shaker Boulevard Cleveland, OH 44120 www.rlba.com (216) 491-9300 FAX (216) 491-8053 DETAILS: New 3rd District Police Station and Citywide Police Dispatch and Communications Facility. SF to be determined; sitework; landscaping; foundation; concrete; masonry; wood and plastics; doors and windows; floors and finishes; roofing; drywall; painting; plumbing; HVAC; electrical. PN-W1129025 BUILDING 2 & 3 - WESTSHORE CAMPUS Westlake, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) 31001 Clemens Road CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids UPDATE: Project is in early programming phase.

OWNER: Cuyahoga Community College 700 Carnegie Avenue Cleveland, OH 44115 www.tri-c.edu (216) 987-4781 FAX (216) 987-4758 Mark A. Green, District Director of Design & Planning, Capital & Construction (216) 987-3423 ARCHITECT: Stantec - Cleveland 3700 Park East Drive, Suite 200 Cleveland, OH 44122 www.stantec.com (216) 454-2150 FAX (216) 454-9995 DETAILS: Phase 1 (Building #1) for the Westshore Campus is complete and operational. The new buildings must honor the design of the first campus building and site plan. Building #2 is currently programmed at 82,000 GSF and contains administrative offices, general education classrooms, as well as dining and conferencing space and other student center type functions. Building #3 is currently programmed at 54,000 GSF and contains faculty offices,

SPECIALIZING IN EXTERIOR MASONRY REPAIR & RENOVATION SINCE 1972 • Complete InspeCtIon/Assessment of fAçAde CondItIons • tuCkpoIntIng/CAulkIng

• BrICk & stone repAIr/replACement

• seAlIng/WAterproofIng

• CleAnIng/pressure WAshIng

Ph 216.881.4142 | Fx 216.881.6557 | 4408 St. Clair Ave., Cleveland, OH 44103

Making you look good is our business. Residential & commercial landscape installation & maintenance. Since 1956.

800-896-8811 info@rbstoutinc.com 66

www.rbstoutinc.com

engineering programs and technology programs. There are also considerable wetlands onsite. PN-X1116051 GORDON FOOD SERVICES STORE Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) 1363 West 117 Street ESTIMATED AMOUNT: $4,000,000 CONTRACTING METHOD: G.C. Bids (By Invitation Only) UPDATE: Bidding possible mid February 2013. OWNER: Gordon Food Service 333 50th St. SW Grand Rapids, MI 49501 (616) 530-7000 FAX (616) 249-4515 ARCHITECT: Paradigm Design, Inc. 550 3 Mile Road NW #B Grand Rapids, MI 49544 (616) 785-5656 FAX (616) 785-5657 John Walsh DETAILS: Approx. 15,000 SF; sitework; excavation support and protection; earthwork; casing; water distribution; underground utilities; hot-mix asphalt paving; sanitary sewerage; storm drainage; cement concrete pavement; chain link fences and gates; segmental retailing walls; landscape work. lawn irrigation; cast-inplace concrete; unit masonry assemblies; structural steel; steel joists and steel girders; steel deck; cold-formed metal framing; metal fabrications; trench frames, covers and preformed pits; rough carpentry; interior architectural woodwork; building insulation; manufactured soffit panels; EPDM single-ply membrane roofing-adhered; sheet metal flashing and trim; plastic faced canopy; roof accessories; joint sealants; steel doors and frames; aluminum impact doors; flush wood doors; sectional overhead doors; aluminum storefronts; automatic entrance doors; door hardware; glazing; gypsum board assemblies; tile; acoustic panel ceilings; resilient wall base and accessories; carpet; painting; FRP wall panels; fire protection specialties; toilet and bath accessories; specialties; loading dock equipment; plumbing HVAC; fire protection; mechanical; electrical. PN-X0815047 DUNKIN DONUTS Broadview Heights, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) Royalton Road CONTRACTING METHOD: G.C. Bids (By Invitation Only) UPDATE: Owner seeking final municipal approval. OWNER: Dunkin Brands Inc. 130 Royall Street Canton, MA 02021 (781) 737-3000 ARCHITECT: ADA Architects, Inc. - Lakewood 17710 Detroit Avenue Lakewood, OH 44107 www.adaarchitects.cc Properties | January 2013


ada@adaarchitects.cc (216) 521-5134 FAX (216) 521-4824 DETAILS: Approx. 2300 SF; single-story building; concrete; masonry; structural steel; thermal and moisture protection; drywall; painting; plumbing; HVAC; electrical; lighting; signage; paving; landscaping; storefront. PN-S0706013

MUSEUM RENOVATION/EXPANSION Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) Wade Oval Drive ESTIMATED AMOUNT: $125,000,000 CONTRACTING METHOD: To Be Announced STATUS: Owner has launched a capital campaign; no additional information has been released at this time. OWNER: Cleveland Museum of Natural History 1 Wade Oval Cleveland, OH 44106 (216) 231-4600 ARCHITECT: Fentress Bradburn 421 Broadway Denver, CO 80203 (303) 722-5000 DETAILS: Expansion and renovation to the existing 226,000 SF Museum of Natural History; plan calls for demolition of the Kirtland Hall of Prehistoric Life and the Sears Hall of Human Ecology with a total of 100,000 SF; construction of new wings, one of which will wrap around the museum’s

shiny new copper-skinned planetarium, will be followed by the relocation of exhibits and the demolition of the older structures (which this will take 30 months); the museum will then build a new, glass-enclosed museum lobby, that will be the centerpiece of the museum, and a 300-space parking garage on the west side of the museum’s property, overlooking Martin Luther King Jr. Drive; there will also be a glassy overhead walkway positioned in the treetops of the Smith Courtyard and the Perkins Wildlife Center; when completed the museum will be 300,000 SF; the expansion will incorporate environmentally sensitive features such as green roofs, solar-power arrays and systems to recycle water. PN-X1127026 DISCOUNT DRUG MART Brunswick Hills, OH (Medina Co.) 5270 Center Road CONTRACTING METHOD: To Be Announced UPDATE: Announcing Architect; owner has submitted a request for building permits; no additional information has been released. OWNER: Discount Drug Mart 211 Commerce Drive Medina, OH 44256 (330) 725-2340 FAX (330) 722-2990 ARCHITECT: DesignWise, Inc.

“Your Custom Architectural Metal Specialists”

6721 Daisy Avenue Independence, OH 44131 (216) 956-5761 DETAILS: Approx. 32,500 SF; renovation and expansion of three existing buildings in shopping plaza; sitework; concrete; plumbing; electrical; HVAC; finishes. PN-X1023039 HERITAGE COLLEGE OF OSTEOPATHIC MEDICINE South Pointe Hospital Warrensville Heights, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) ESTIMATED AMOUNT: $8,500,000 CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids UPDATE: Announcing Architect award. OWNER: Ohio University, Facilities Planning & Space Mgmt. Building 19, The Ridges, 108 Ridges Circle Suite 230 Athens, OH 45701 www.upi.ohio.edu (740) 593-2727 FAX (740) 593-4081 Robin Faires, fairesr@ohio.edu ARCHITECT: BHDP Architecture - Cincinnati 302 W. 3rd Street, Suite 500 Cincinnati, OH 45202 www.bhdp.com (513) 271-1634 FAX (513) 271-7017 AGENT: ODAS - Ohio Facilities Construction Commission 30 W. Spring Street, 4th Floor Columbus, OH 43228

Courtad Inc. Commercial • Industrial • Institutional • Retail Specializing in engineering, fabrication & installation of: • metal roofing (rolled on site!) • flashing & trim • custom fascias, frieze boards, eaves • copper & stainless steel systems • composite metal wall systems • custom gutters & downspouts • commercial gutters (rolled on site!)

330.274.3100 P.O. Box 827, Mantua, OH 44255 www.courtadinc.com

www.propertiesmag.com 67


Experienced Dependable

Structural Steel Fabricators and Erectors since 1958 Contact Mike Smith for a proposal (440) 439-1040 • (800) 686-1223 • www.masonsteel.com 7500 Northfield Road • Walton Hills, Ohio 44146 Other Fine Products Available:

Feb13 Seminar Ad_Layout 1 12/21/12 8:31 AM Page 1 Stone • Pavers • Fireplaces • Windows • Doors

Building Enclosure Council–Cleveland Presents:

Understanding Building Enclosure Performance Testing Presented by John Runkle, P.E. Director of Building Sciences at Architectural Testing, Inc.

February 13th, 2013 Registration 4:30 • Program 5:30 pm

ofcc.ohio.gov/Opportunities.aspx (614) 466-6290 DETAILS: OHU-137010 Cleveland Clinic South Pointe Hospital, Warrensville Heights, Ohio. The University will renovate approx. 60,000 GSF, of the 180,000 GSF building. The building program contains essentially the following major areas: Classroom and Laboratory Space, Learning Resources Center, Clinical Training and Assessment Center, Academic Technologies, Administrative and Faculty Offices and Student and Faculty Lounges. There are also associated support spaces to be positioned throughout the building.The anticipated project delivery method for this project is to be determined. State Prevailing Wage requirements apply to this project. PN-V0308036 ASSISTED LIVING RESIDENTIAL FACILITY Perry Township, OH (Lake Co.) CONTRACTING METHOD: Developer Subcontracts STATUS: Planning is preliminary and is only conceptual at this time. DEVELOPER: Davis Development 32000 Solon Road Solon, OH 44139 (440) 248-7770

Corporate College East • Warrensville Hts, OH Topics that will be covered include: • Types of performance tests for the exterior envelope • Why performance testing is important for the exterior envelope • How to develop project specifications to implement performance testing • Code related changes regarding the building enclosure • Case studies of investigated building envelope failures For more information and to register, visit www.bec-cleveland.org (1.0 CEU can be earned by attending this seminar) John Runkle is the Director of Building Sciences for Architectural Testing which includes building envelope commissioning, forensic services, and field testing. Mr. Runkle has worked on new construction and retrofit projects in most of the 50 states and several international projects. He serves on the board of the Building Commissioning Association and has been heavily involved in the development of the practice of building envelope commissioning and is an active participant in the Sealant Waterproofing and Restoration Institute and Roofing Consultant Institute.

Brought to you by:

J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc. • Commercial Buildings • Construction Sites • Special Event Clean-Up • Concrete Cleaning • Carpet Cleaning • Window Cleaning • Wall Washing • Acoustical Ceilings

1230 East Schaaf Road Brooklyn Heights, OH 44131

216-749-1150 www.jvjanitorial.com 68

Properties | January 2013


DETAILS: SF to be determined; sitework; concrete; masonry; mechanical; electrical; plumbing; HVAC; lighting; roofing; flooring; doors & windows; wood & plastics; drywall; painting; interior finishes; bathroom accessories; landscaping. PN-X1101046 NEW NASA RESEARCH SUPPORT BUILDING Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) ESTIMATED AMOUNT: $15,000,000 to $20,000,000 CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids UPDATE: A/E Services RFQs have been received; award to be announced. OWNER: GSA - Public Buildings Service (5PE) Office of Property Development 230 S. Dearborn Street, Room 3600 Chicago, IL 60604 www.fbo.gov William M. Chapman, Contract Specialist (312) 353-0868, william.chapman@gsa. gov/David Mazzolini, Contracting Officer (312) 353-0617, david.mazzolini@gsa. gov AGENCY: NASA Glenn Research Center 21000 Brookpark Road Cleveland, OH 44135 http://procurement.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/ EPS/bizops.cgi?gr=C&pin=22 (216) 433-4000 FAX (216) 433-5489 DETAILS: The project will require the demolition of an existing building, and in

its place, creation of a new threestory Research Support Building of approximately 100,000 gross square feet (GSF). NASA is in the process of creating a new centralized downtown campus area at Lewis Field with the Research Support Building being at its new central hub. The Research Support building will house support offices such as a credit union, cafeteria, etc on the first floor and federal office space on the 2nd and 3rd floors. The proposed building will be located at NASA’s Glenn Research Center (GRC) located on Lewis Field in Cleveland, Ohio. This new project will need to be responsive to NASA’s overall campus and master plan and is adjacent to a National Register Historic District. PN-X1130036 HIGHLAND PARK MAUSOLEUM & CLEVELAND MEMORIAL GARDENS ADMINISTRATION BUILDING Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids STATUS: A/E Services due Monday, January 7, 2013 at 12:00 Noon (To Owner) OWNER: City of Cleveland Division of Architecture 601 Lakeside Avenue, Room 517A Cleveland, OH 44114

(216) 664-2374 FAX (216) 664-4220 Robert Vilkas, Chief Architect/Manager (216) 664-3577, rvilkas@city.cleveland. oh.us DETAILS: The Assessment of the Highland Park Mausoleum must consider the following options: 1. Abandonment and stabilization of all areas other than the mausoleum, which will be retained and renovated for long-term use. 2. Partial demolition of all areas other than the mausoleum, which will be retained and renovated for long-term use. 3. Complete restoration of the building for the longterm use as an office, mausoleum and public restrooms only. Cleveland Memorial Gardens improvements must consider the following options: 1. Construction of an addition to the existing maintenance building to accommodate the office functions of the Cemeteries Unit. 2. Construction of a freestanding building to accommodate the office functions of the Cemeteries Unit with the provision of public restrooms. Construction Progress Reports are provided to Properties by CNCNewsOnline.com. For more comprehensive and up-to-date building and bidding information, call Construction News Corporation at 800.969.4700 or visit the website at www.CNCNewsOnline.com.

Are you satisfied with your current investment returns? Is your IRA growing at 11% - 15% per year? Do you have ANY investments worth DOUBLE what you paid for them? YOU CAN... • Landscape Maintenance contracts – extraordinary seasonal color plans

NOW YOU HAVE A CHOICE!

• Snow & ice management • Irrigation installation & repaire – certified backflow testing • Daily/weekly routine property inspection & maintenance • Retaining walls, pavers, planting, surface drainage and erosion control

440-526-3257 330-239-1995 fax 330-239-0265 4843 Ridge Road Wadsworth, Ohio 44281

Turnkey InvesTor ProPerTIes, A sTArk ComPAny offers a unique and effortless way to earn 11%, 12%, 15% annually, starting with a very low minimum investment. Call Brian Stark directly today at 216-310-1470 to learn more! www.turnkeyinvestorproperties.com

“The Stark Group Live!” Talking Real Estate Thursdays at 7 pm on Newstalk 1490 AM WERE www.propertiesmag.com 69


Coming in February Laurel Lake Retirement Community Addition Robinson Memorial Hospital Surgery Addition Cuyahoga County Public Library – Beachwood & Solon Branch Renovations Landscaping and Outdoor Lighting ...and more Interested in advertising? Call Properties today and an account representative can help you www.propertiesmag.com address your advertising needs: Visit us online for archived fea-

ture articles, advertising rates, 216.251.0035 / 888.641.4241

specs and subscription information.

www.propertiesmag.com

Visit us online today to download archived issues featuring live hypertext links to advertisers’ websites! The 2013 Media Planner is now available as a PDF download! 70

ADVERTISER INDEX 21st Century Concrete

IQ Advisors, LLC.............................................. 35

Construction, Inc........................................ 52

J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc...........................68

Abraxus Snow Removal...............................28

JACCO & Associates Inc................................56

AIA........................................................................54

Jamieson Ricca Co............................................2

American International Construction.... 39

Jands Group Inc., The...................................65

Americon Inc.................................................... 61

Janitorial Services, Inc.................................. 10

Art Window Coverings, Inc........................ 27

Kline Construction, Corp.............................58

Bellwether Enterprise...................................29

Kurtz Bros..........................................................34

BOMA Greater Cleveland............................ 21

LandsKeepers, A Pattie Group

Brennan & Associates................................... 37

Company...........................................................4

Bruder Building Materials, Inc...................56

Leff Electric ......................................................20

Buckeye Sweeping, Inc................................22

Lisco Heating & Cooling, Inc...................... 43

Building Enclosure Council........................68

Manka Design Studio................................... 13

Carey Roofing Corporation........................ 41

Mason Structural Steel, Inc........................68

CBRE, Inc............................................................ 17

McGraw-Hill Construction Network....... 24

CertaPro Painters............................................54

McTech Corp..................................................... 45

Chagrin Valley Steel Erectors....................40

Messina Floor Covering, Inc....................... 24

Charles Schulz Building Company.............7

Nelson Contracting.......................................69

Clark & Post Architects, Inc........................ 51

Ohio Desk/Integrated Interiors

Cleveland Engineering Society................25

Group.............................................................. 52

Cleveland Public Power............................... 57

Ozanne Construction Co.............................48

CNC Construction News Corp.................. 26

Paul Davis Restoration....................................6

Columbia Building Products.....................30

Pease Photography....................................... 52

Corso Construction, Inc...............................60

Pete & Pete Container..................................36

County Fire Protection Inc.........................30

Precision Environmental Co.......................50

Courtad Inc...................................................... 67

Precision ProCut.............................................64

Cunningham Paving Inc.............................. 33

R B Stout, Inc....................................................66

Delta Industrial Services, Inc..................... 57

S.A. Comunale Company............................ 62

DH Kaiser Company......................................38

Sandglo Glass & Mirror Co.......................... 33

EA Group...............................................................3

SE Blueprint, Inc.............................................. 32

Euromark Cabinets........................................63

Siegel Jennings .............................................. 18

Fleischman, Richard & Partners, Inc....... 12

Skoda Minotti Company.............................72

Flexible Pavements of Ohio.......................22

SMPS Northeast Ohio......................................4

FMD Architects, Inc....................................... 61

Sobol Sales Co....................................................9

Frantz Ward LLP.............................................. 16

Space Comfort Co.......................................... 21

Giambrone Masonry, Inc............................. 43

Spray Foam Technologies.......................... 33

Graelic LLC.........................................................65

Star Design-Build Contractors.................. 42

Hallmark Excavating..................................... 62

Stark Group, The.............................................69

Herk Excavating, Inc......................................48

Straub Surveying, LLC..................................48

HMH Restoration Ltd....................................66

Suntrol Co..........................................................34

Horvath Electric, Inc...................................... 14

Svec, Charles Inc.............................................34

IMAGINiT Technologies...............................54

Warren Roofing & Insulating Co.................2

Infinity Construction..................................... 32

Western Reserve Lighting Rod, Co............7 Properties | January 2013


Your Powerful Ally in Building Business in Northeast Ohio Subscribe to Properties today and stay informed on the very best in construction and development activity in Northeast Ohio. The longest running publication of its kind in the state, Properties delivers vital news and revealing in-depth features on residential, commercial, industrial and institutional building!

INSIDE

Evans by Brandt : Pura Vida

ek imer Bol

• Holzhe

+ Mehan

ons al Soluti ironment HQ • Env /$7.95 June 2011

e n ow SubScr2ib4.95 a year!

$ S! for juSt wo y e a r t r o f 5 or $34.9 5% off

th Mammover Makeo

Up to 7 price! cover

eils ks Zoo unv Metropar ssing Cleveland n Elephant Cro ica new Afr

Yes, I want to subscribe to Properties now! Your Name __________________________________________________

Title _______________________________________

Company Name _____________________________________________________________________________________________ Street Address ________________________________________________________________________________________________ City ________________________________________ Phone ________________________

State ________________

Fax ________________________

One year (12 issues) for $24.95

Zip ________________________________

email ______________________________________

Two years (24 issues) for $34.95

Name on Credit Card ____________________________________ Credit Card Type

Visa

Mastercard

Credit Card Number ____________________________ Exp Date (Month/Year) ________________

American Express

Security Code ___________

Billing Address (if different than above): Street Address ________________________________________________________________________________________________ City ________________________________________

State ________________

Zip ________________________________

What is your profession? (Select all that apply.) DEVELOPER BUILDING OWNER PROPERTY MANAGER APPRAISER BANK MORTAGE COMPANY SAVINGS & LOAN TITLE COMPANY

REALTOR REAL ESTATE LAW APARTMENT OWNER GENERAL CONTRACTOR HOME BUILDER DESIGN BUILDER INVESTOR GOVERNMENT AGENCY

ARCHITECTURAL SERVICES INTERIOR DESIGNER STRUCTURAL ENGINEER MECHANICAL ENGINEER ELECTRICAL ENGINEER CIVIL ENGINEER LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT ENGINEERING SERVICES

MATERIAL SUPPLIER INSURANCE/BONDING BUILDING EQUIPMENT SUPPLIER SUBCONTRACTOR (LIST TYPE): OTHER:

Please fax completed form to 216.251.0064. For any questions or to order by phone, call Lisa at 216.251.8506.


construct Connecting Our Construction World to You. Estimating. Project management. Labor issues. These are issues that you deal with daily in your construction world. Job costing. Increasing bidding and bonding capacity. Tax planning and compliance. These are issues that we deal with daily in our construction world. The Construction Group at Skoda Minotti can deliver on the promise of connecting our construction world to you by leveraging our reputation and relationships with bonding agents and financial institutions to help maximize your bonding capacity and obtain the necessary financing you need, when you need it. For a no-risk analysis of your construction business or to sign up for free quarterly e-mail reports on over 20 segments of the construction industry, call Roger Gingerich at 440-449-6800 or visit our website at www.skodaminotti.com.

www.skodaminotti.com


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook