COMPLETE CONCRETE SERVICE OVER 20 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE
Repair • Replace • Resurface • Floor Coatings • Epoxy • Polyspartic
SPECIALISTS AT SNOW & ICE MANAGEMENT
1245 W. Wooster Rd., Ste 3 • Barberton OH 44230 • 330-825-7577 • www.americanqc.net
MEET THE NEW CLASS IN FIBERGLASS.
ENGINEERED PRODUCT FOR HIGH-RISE BUILDINGS
SUPERIOR PERFORMANCE IN ST R E N GT H A N D D U R A B I L I TY 1
2.4 X M O R E E N E R G Y - E F F I C I E N T T H A N T H E R M A L LY B R O K E N A L U M I N U M 2
WINDOWS • DOORS • STOREFRONTS • WINDOW WALLS
Single-Source Solutions at a Competitive Price. From Pella. Envisioning a luxury, suburban-meets-urban experience, the development team looked to Pella’s large combination Impervia® fiberglass windows. Their exceptional durability meets the rigorous performance requirements of the building while providing views that maximize daylight without compromising energy efficiency.
3(//$ :,1'2:6 $1' '2256
3JDINPOE 3PBE #FEGPSE )UT 0)
One Southdale Place • Edina, MN Architect: BKV Group • General Contractor: Kraus Anderson • Owner: StuartCo
3OHDVH FDOO IRU \RXU IHQHVWUDWLRQ FRQVXOWLQJ
SURIHVVLRQDO SHOOD FRP FRPPHUFLDO 1
In testing performed in accordance with ASTM testing standards, Pella’s Duracast® fiberglass composite has displayed superior performance in strength, ability to withstand extreme heat and cold, and resistance to dents and scratches. 2 U-Factor of Duracast frame is 2.4 times greater than that of thermally broken aluminum when compared in thermal testing. © 2017 Pella Corporation
Reducing Real Property Tax Assessments Throughout Ohio And Across The United States
Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill, Co., LPA
When you hire Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill, you work directly with Sleggs, Danzinger and Gill. Each client is directly represented at all levels by a principal of the firm with a combined 75 years of experience. No pyramid, no associates, no on-the-job training. Our clients deserve the very best representation, so we structured our firm to allow each client, throughout the entire process, to work directly with Messrs. SLEGGS, DANZINGER and/or GILL. Our philosophy is to work cooperatively with school district and County officials to ensure that our clients pay the lowest possible real property tax obligations. If a fair resolution requires litigation, SLEGGS, DANZINGER & GILL have the depth of trial and appellate experience to handle the most complex valuation issues. Whether the valuation relates to large industrial plants, apartments, shopping centers, warehouses, office buildings, vacant land or any other type of commercial property, the faces above will ensure that you receive the best counsel, legal advice and litigation expertise. Todd W. Sleggs, Esq. tsleggs@sdglegal.net
Robert K. Danzinger, Esq. rdanzinger@sdglegal.net
Steven R. Gill, Esq. sgill@sdglegal.net
When you hire Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill, (216) 771-8990 you work directly with Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill 820 West Superior Ave. Seventh Floor Sleggs, Danzinger and Gill. Cleveland, OH 44113 sdglegal.net
Member Firm
February 2019, Volume LXXIII, Number 2
FEATURES Phone: 216.251.0035 Toll Free: 888.641.4241 Fax: 216.251.0064 www.propertiesmag.com
Photo courtesy of John G. Johnson Construction
CLEVELAND 3826 W. 158th St. Cleveland, Ohio 44111 AKRON P.O. Box 9 Munroe Falls, Ohio 44262 OWNER/PUBLISHER Kenneth C. Krych kkrych@propertiesmag.com 216.251.0035 MANAGING EDITOR/ART DIRECTOR Mark Watt mwatt@propertiesmag.com 216.251.2655
10
Transform + Transition Brookfield Property Partners, Forest City converge within modernized Key Tower offices
20 Luxury Lakefront Living at Harbor Verandas Redevelopment of North Coast Harbor continues with new mixed-use apartment building
CONTRIBUTING WRITERS Doug Bardwell, Scott Esterly, Ian Frank, Lou Kren, Matt Lehnert, Alec Pacella, Diane DiPiero Rodio, Robert Sandrick, Carlo Wolff, David Woodburn
47 Revitalizing a Cleveland Landmark K&D Group converts historic former department store into Residences at Halle
58
Special Section: Legal Services + Risk Management 58 The Devilish Details: The importance of the fine print in your construction contracts 61 Understanding Your Loan Covenants - The Key to Compliance: Once documents are signed & recorded, it’s the borrower’s responsibility to act in accordance 63 ACAR Corner: What’s the Plan? Succession Planning for Real Estate Brokerages 65 Trending Topics: A look at 3 key legal issues making waves within the commercial real estate community 68 NAIOP News: Opportunity Zones – Who Profits & How? 70 Vantage Point: Funding OZ Building Improvements 72 Legal Perspectives: Building on Blockchain - Considering potential applications in design & construction 76 Risk of New Construction: Mechanics’ Lien Coverage Overview for Ohio 79 Intangible Assets and Your Property Tax Assessment: Be aware of use of the total asset purchase to set real estate tax value
MEDIA CONSULTANTS Matt Lehnert mlehnert@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6753 Larry Overbey loverbey@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6649 OFFICE MANAGER Lisa Larissey 216.251.8506 Cover photo: Brookfield Property Partners/Forest City Headquarters, by Matthew Carbone
DEPARTMENTS Properties (ISSN 033-1287) is published monthly for architects, engineers, building owners and managers, general contractors, home builders, mortgage bankers, savings and loans, real estate agents, appraisers, servicers and suppliers in Northern Ohio by Properties, Inc., 3826 W. 158th St., Cleveland, Ohio 44111. Copyright © 2019 by Properties, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction or use, without written permission, of editorial or pictorial content is strictly prohibited. Periodicals postage paid in Cleveland, Ohio and additional offices. Subscription rates: one year $30, single copy $9, back issues $12 when available. Postmaster: send change of address notices to Properties, P.O. Box 112127, Cleveland, Ohio 44111.
8 35 38 40 45 63 68 70 72 82
PROPERTIES PEOPLE BILLBOARD VANTAGE POINT FINANCIAL STRATEGIES BOMA BUSINESS ACAR CORNER NAIOP NEWS VANTAGE POINT LEGAL PERSPECTIVES CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT www.propertiesmag.com 5
PUBLISHER’S NOTE February 2019
Law in Order elcome to our February issue, featuring our annual Legal Services + Risk Management special section with articles from a number of the elite professionals serving Northeast Ohio’s real estate, development, AEC, building and property management communities.
W
KEN KRYCH
Topics of this year’s articles range from opportunity zones, succession planning and Blockchain applications in design/construction to commercial real estate legal trends and the fine print in construction contracts. We thank the contributing firms of First American Title Insurance Company; Frantz Ward LLP; Hahn Loeser & Parks LLP; McCarthy, Lebit, Crystal & Liffman; Meaden & Moore LLP; Meyers Roman Friedberg & Lewis;
Walter | Haverfield; RSM US LLP; and Siegel Jennings Co. L.P.A. Brookfield/Forest City Headquarters As many of our readers know, Cleveland-based real estate giant Forest City Enterprises was purchased by Canadian firm Brookfield Property Partners in a landmark, nearly $7 billion deal in late 2018. We thought it would be a fitting tribute to Forest City and its decades of development to show-
Are You Ready For April Showers & May Flowers? CALL TODAY FOR YOUR COMPLIMENTARY ANALYSIS!
Grounds Management • Innovative Design & Landscape Enhancement Seasonal Flower Displays • Snow & Ice Management
Commercial Properties • Shopping Malls • Healthcare Facilities Apartment Complexes • Universities • HOAs 986 Broadway Ave., Bedford, Oh 44146 • 440-786-9840 • www.tuckerlandscaping.com 6
Properties | February 2019
case its newly remodeled headquarters, which recently won an honor award at the AIA Cleveland Design Awards for interior design. Located on seven floors within Key Tower, the new collaborative and transparent work environment was designed by Vocon and completed by the A.M. Higley Co. The Residences at Halle Constructed in 1910, the classic Halle Building in downtown Cleveland has a long, storied history, originally housing the upscale Halle Brothers department store. Today, it has been transformed into a mixeduse development with six upper floors of beautifully appointed luxury apartments, with offices, retail and dining situated on lower floors. Harbor Verandas We also visit Harbor Verandas, a Cumberland Development project designed by Dimit Architects and built by John G. Johnson Construction. This $12 million luxury apartment building resides just north of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame of Museum, marking the second completed project in a multiphase development of prime waterfront property between the East 9th Street Pier and West 3rd Street in Cleveland. The building including 16 apartments, each with its own veranda to allow residents to take advantage of superb views of the lakefront and city skyline, plus retail at street level. Coming in March If Punxsutawney Phil is to be believed, it won’t be long until spring – and with that we look toward our annual Landscapes & Hardscapes issue next month. Also in March, we will highlight Vocon Cleveland’s newly renovated offices, tour ECHO Health Headquarters and more. Until then, stay warm and contact us with any company news or project profile ideas. Positively,
Built to work. for Cleveland.
For over 80 years The Krill Co., Inc. has constructed and restored buildings that make our city unique. We are committed to continuing to shape its landscape.
Cleveland is our home, our commitment, and our pride.
C O N S T R U C T I O N M A N A G E M E N T | G E N E R A L C O N T R A C T I N G | D E S I G N - B U I L D | | P : 2 1 6 . 3 5 7. 4 7 7 7 | k r i l l . c o m
Nationwide Fire Protection An EMCOR Company
S.A. Comunale Fire Sprinklers
Alarm & Detection
Corporate Office 2900 Newpark Drive Barberton, OH 44203 330-706-3040 Fax 330-861-0937
Kenneth C. Krych Publisher/Owner
Fire Backflow Extinguishers Preventers
sacomunale.com
Kitchen Suppression Systems
24/7 We do it
all.
800-776-7181 www.propertiesmag.com 7
PROPERTIES PEOPLE Highlighting notable industry events
2
1
3
4
1
5
6
7
NEO/Cleveland Facilities Maintenance Expo 2
Expo Source, Inc. held its 8th annual NEO/Cleveland Facilities Maintenance Expo recently at the Holiday Inn in Independence, with nearly 50 vendors presenting products and services to property managers, facilities maintenance professionals and other attendees. The event also featured a series of educational seminars on a variety of topics, including roofing techniques and products, pest control and LED lighting. P
1 Mason Crowe (Valu-Rooter) 2 Andrew Miller (Tri-Kote Roofing) 3 Gwen Voase and Stephani Davis (Preferred LLC) 4 Mark Gottron (Technique Roofing Systems, LLC) 5 Tony Bishop and Kyle Henkle (Clearview Tinting) 6 Scott Brink and Jeff Butterfield (Arisfor) 7 Robin Bishop and Alexis Millerleile (Diamond Roofing Systems)
3 1 Pamela Neckar (Bostwick Design Partnership) 2 Kelly Riggs (The Business LockerRoom, Inc.) 3 Pamela Neckar (Bostwick Design Partnership), Kelly Riggs (The Business LockerRoom, Inc.) and Jennifer Wahl (Karpinski Engineering) 1
2
3
SMPS NEO Luncheon Speaker Series: Kelly Riggs Recently, approximately 100 members of the Northeast Ohio chapter of Society for Marketing and Sales Professionals (SMPS NEO) gathered at the City Club in downtown Cleveland for a luncheon speaker event, its first in an ongoing series for 2019. The theme was “The Leadership Dilemma: Change, Complexity and Distraction in the Chaotic Four-Generation Workplace,” featuring a presentation by speaker/author Kelly Riggs, of Business LockerRoom. His talk centered on the impact of technology and the challenges and solutions of having four generations of employees in the workplace. P 8
4
ACAR Installation of Officers Recently, more than 160 members and guests of the Akron/Cleveland Association of Realtors gathered at Hilton Doubletree in Independence for the association’s annual Installation of Officers celebration. ACAR’s 2019 Board of Directors includes President Judy Gorbett Darwal (RE/MAX Trinity), PresidentElect Brant Smith (NEO Realty Group, LLC), Treasurer Beth Rodgers (Howard Hanna) and Immediate Past President Karen O’Donnell (Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realty). P
5
6
1 Stacy Nickels, Cindy Householder and Karyn Karyn Pumphrey (Howard Hanna) 2 Mike Valerino (ACAR), Dominic Sabatino (1979 CABOR President) and Sandy Naragon (ACAR) 3 Gwen Petway (Key Realty) and Marla James May (Howard Hanna) 4 Karen O’Donnell (Coldwell Banker Schmidt Realty/ACAR), Jamie McMillen (ACAR), Scott Williams (Ohio Realtors) and Sandy Naragon (ACAR) 5 Karen O’Donnell and Seth Task (Bershire Hathaway Professional Realty) 6 Linda LaFleur and Gary Post (RE/Max Crossroads Properties)
Properties | February 2019
Transform + Transition Brookfield Property Partners, Forest City converge within modernized Key Tower offices By Scott Esterly | Photos by Matthew Carbone
he distance between the Terminal Tower and Key Tower is about the length of a few football fields, but Brookfield Property Partners / Forest City Enterprises jumped into the new millennium when moving into new headquarters.
T
Gone are the private offices, executive wing and dated décor. Huddle stations, pocket parks and generously appointed cafés cover the seven floors Brookfield now occupies in Key Tower. A confluence of factors necessitated the push for new headquarters. Forest City was transforming the entire company by converting to a REIT and divesting its Cleveland-area assets. The company’s existing office space in Terminal Tower no longer met its needs and limited its appeal to potential associates. Maintaining attractiveness to the modern workforce was clearly at the forefront of the new design. 10
“You want to make sure you are competing with other companies that have modern, progressive, fun space where people can work how they enjoy working,” says Don Beck, director of Sustainable Operations Strategies for Brookfield. “The days of coming in and sitting at a desk for eight hours in one spot – that is kind of gone.”
Accelerated timeline Forest City selected Key Tower for the new headquarters in October 2016, construction began in September 2017, and the company moved into the space in March 2018.
Two things to keep in mind during this whole process: Key Tower changed ownership to Millennia Companies in January 2017 and Brookfield completed the purchase of Forest City in December 2018. Forest City selected Vocon for workplace strategy and design and Albert M. Higley Co. as construction manager at risk. Bob Porter, design director at Vocon, and Mark Vega, vice president of Project Management at Higley, and their respective teams worked closely with Alberto Machinena, senior construction manager of Forest City (now Brookfield). Properties | February 2019
Premise Solutions is proud to be the Technology Design and Installation Partner for the FOREST CITY REALTY TRUST Project.
Southside High
Public Square Cleveland
WE ARE DESIGNERS & INSTALLERS OF TECHNOLOGY INFRASTRUCTURE SYSTEMS. Network Cabling & Electronics | Fiber Optics Intrusion | Camera Analytics | POE Lighting & Controls Access Control | Conference Room & School AV Systems Sound Masking | DAS | OSP Installation
Tulane University Freeman Business School
Wooster Community Hospital
Integrated Project Solutions BIM Coordination Services • Site Logistics • 3D Content Creation Revit® • Navisworks® • 3D Studio Max • Residential Design
MIKE FURLONG, CM-BIM Managing Principal
www.premisesolutions.com | 440.703.8200
330.414.9970 | mike@iprojsolutions.com | www.iprojsolutions.com
PROUD TO HAVE SERVED AS CONSTRUCTION MANAGER FOR BROOKFIELD/FOREST CITY’S RENOVATIONS
TRUSTED AND PREFERRED CONSTRUCTION MANAGERS FOR OVER 93 YEARS 3636 Euclid Avenue, Cleveland, OH 44115 p: (216) 861-2050 | f: (216) 861-0038 | e: mail@amhigley.com www.amhigley.com www.propertiesmag.com 11
BUILDING CONNECTION Helping to create a sense of unity throughout seven stories of offices, portions of the floor were removed to make way for a pair of interconnected stairs.
In order for Forest City to come into Key Tower, a significant re-stack needed to take place. Approximately seven existing tenants were moved within the building to make way for the new headquarters. This even included moving the offices of Key Tower’s building management. Machinena and Beck both credit the building management of Key Tower, led by Tom Kroth, general manager of Millennia Commercial Group, for ensuring everything came together.
Construction phase “Probably the biggest element [of construction] was that we have two
interconnecting stairs, so we had two areas where the floor had to be removed,” Vega explains. The staircases are located between floors 24 and 25, as well as 31 and 32. The latter staircase is located in the atrium of the 31st floor and doubles as a design and construction showpiece. “The biggest challenge was the fivemonth schedule,” Vega adds. “And that was not five months for construction. That was five months from start to move-in.” The accelerated schedule meant construction was taking place on all seven floors simultaneously.
An inherent struggle that went along with the tight timeline was amassing the proper manpower for the project. As Cleveland enjoys a bustling construction market, ensuring proper staffing levels was a constant challenge. On-site challenges included limited access with only two freight elevators; not disturbing tenants on surrounding floors; and working around several other construction projects taking place throughout the building, including major upgrades to the entire Key Center complex itself. This necessitated a lot of night deliveries and night work.
The space Congratulations Design & Construction Teams of
Forest City Headquarters From Your Structural Engineering Partner
330.659.6688
12
www.thorsonbaker.com
“I don’t think that our corporate office reflected what Forest City did as a company across the country,” Beck says from a conference room on the 31st floor in the new Brookfield space. Forest City had cultivated a nationally recognized brand by developing headturning high-rise offices and apartment buildings in the biggest markets across the country. It was time to align its own space with the product the company was known for. The main criteria for the new space: remain located in downtown Cleveland. Properties | February 2019
SIGNS OF CHANGE Although ownership has changed, Forest City’s legacy remains in aspects of the design, such as a stone accent sign in the reception desk.
Company leadership ruled out only a few other potential locations, which included new construction or relocating to Post Office Plaza, a building Forest City owned at the time. Key Tower made the most sense. Beck notes that Class A space, access to public transportation, the building’s LEED
“The biggest challenge was the five-month schedule. And that was not five months for construction. That was five months from start to move-in.”
Commercial & Industrial 24/7/365, Since 1987
Mark Vega The Albert M. Higley Co. status and stackability were what made Key Tower the clear choice. The company now occupies floors 23 through 27, as well as floors 31 and 32. Forest City reduced its footprint significantly through its move to Key Tower, transitioning from around 240,000 square feet in the Terminal Tower to 115,000 square feet in the new space. A collaborative and transparent work environment was identified by Vocon during the planning process, which led to the final design. Machinena also mentions that despite the elimination of all the private offices that had been the hallmark of the Terminal Tower
5500 Old Brecksville Road Independence, Ohio 44131 216-642-6040 p | 216-642-6041 f www.precision-env.com www.propertiesmag.com 13
Proud to have furnished & installed all HVAC equipment, sheet metal, and piping at Key Tower with Albert M. Higley Company
MECHANICAL CONTRACTORS • SHEET METAL FABRICATION PROUD MEMBER OF:
SPECIALIZING IN: Ÿ Sheet Metal Fabrication & Installation Ÿ HVAC Piping & Installations Ÿ Design Build / Design Assist Ÿ I.P.D. projects Ÿ HVAC Service
Cleveland Chapter President Thomas E. Martin Tomjr@thmartin.net 6060 Royalton Rd. N. Royalton, OH 44133 (440) 877-3500 www.smacnacle.org
8500 Brookpark Rd., Cleveland, OH 44129 • 216-741-2020 • www.thmartin.net
OPEN LOOK A design goal was to create a collaborative and transparent environment, which is evident with glass-walled huddle rooms (top), meeting spaces (middle) and privacy rooms throughout (bottom).
space, each employee’s personal space was not drastically impacted once all the cafés, conference rooms and collaboration spaces are taken into account. Expanding on the open plan concept, Porter points out that in the new space there is a private or collaborative area for every 1:3.3 people, while the industry average is around 1:10. “You hear a lot of backlash about open planning these days and the problem is they are done without consistently laying out spaces that support the workstations, such as privacy rooms and huddle rooms, or they are located far away from the employee,” Porter says. “No one at Forest
“You hear a lot of backlash about open planning these days and the problem is they are done without consistently laying out spaces that support the workstations, such as privacy/huddle rooms, or they are located far away from the employee. No one at Forest City needs to walk more than 40 feet to get to a huddle or privacy room.” Bob Porter Vocon City needs to walk more than 40 feet to get to a huddle or privacy room.” One of the underlying reasons for the creation of the new headquarters was the desire to foster an environment of warmth and collaboration. In order to accentuate that, daylight follows you throughout Brookfield’s new space. Upon entering the atrium on the main level on the 31st floor, the showpiece staircase connects with the floor above. There is a beautiful moss-covered wall that spans both floors. A friendly assistant sitting at a simple, yet elegant desk cordially greets you and offers refreshments from the modern and inviting café bar on the opposite side of www.propertiesmag.com 15
ENCOURAGING COLLABORATION Informal gathering spaces, referred to as “pocket parks,” are situated along corridors.
the room. A lounging area lines the wall of windows facing west. The tone is set. This is a new era. Employees roam at their leisure to the nearest huddle area or can take a seat across from the liquid-fuel fireplace on the 32nd floor. Associates have assigned work stations on floors 23 through 26, but they are free to situate themselves at any pocket park or conference room they may want or need. The collaboration stations all have quirkily inviting wallpaper and décor. For bigger meetings, the 31st and 32nd floor have the larger meeting and training spaces, as well as the board room. Pocket parks are located just off the main hallways of the associate floors and have a green, grass-like carpet with comfortable chairs and couches. Meeting rooms are named after Cleveland neighborhoods and loca-
tions, such as Public Square, Tremont, Collinwood and Ohio City. This was Forest City’s way of tying their longtime home of Cleveland into their modern space.
EnergyStar Status In August 2018, the new headquarters achieved Energy Star Charter Tenant Space status, which is a pilot program through the EPA that features high-performing tenants in the area of sustainability. Key sustainability features include daylight sensors for lighting, plug-load control for each work station, digital controls to some air-handlers and submeters for utilities.
Technological wonderland Katie Hagen, Brookfield’s vice president of Business Relationship
Call our commercial sales managers today, to discuss your electric service needs.
reliable & Mark Herron local 216.563.7331
Visit us at www.cpp.org 16
Kim Woodford 216.563.7240
Management, has an IT background and explains the massive shift in technology that accompanied the move to Key Tower. At least half the computers, approximately 350 in total, were desktop units at the Terminal Tower. Leading up to the move, everyone received laptops to enable them to move around and take advantage of their new space. With all new technology at assigned workstations and the mobility of the new laptops, all associates were able to show up on the first day in the new headquarters and begin working anywhere in the building without a problem. The technology component was so important that the entire framework for IT was live in the new space more than a month prior to construction being completed. Vega points out that making IT live is normally the last thing that gets completed on a project like this. “If you wanted to try to do a video conference [in our former space], we had four rooms to pick from, maybe six rooms, and it was so complex you needed IT to come and set it up for you,” Hagen explains. In the new space, there are not only plenty of rooms to choose from to accommodate a video conference, there is a “one touch join” feature that simplifies the process so any associate can get the meeting started without IT support. Properties | February 2019
March 28, 2019 | Windows on the River
Cleveland’s tradition of quality craftsmanship in the building and construction trades can be seen in the iconic structures that personify the downtown Cleveland skyline. In 1956, the Builder’s Exchange began a tradition of honoring Cleveland tradespeople and their contractors through its annual Craftsmanship Awards program. It was the first of its kind in the nation and has since served as a model throughout the country. The Construction Employers Association, in partnership with the Cleveland Building & Construction Trades Council and affiliated union contractor associations is resurrecting this rich tradition by launching the Annual Building Excellence & Craftsmanship Awards.
Visit www.clevelandcraftsmanship.com to purchase tickets or to sponsor the event!
TRAVELING LIGHT One of the underlying reasons for the creation of the new headquarters was the desire to foster an environment of warmth and collaboration. In order to accentuate that, daylight follows you throughout Brookfield’s new space.
Hagen also speaks passionately about how important repeatability was from floor to floor. Associates do not need to stop and think about where someone wants to meet if they are on a different floor because the collaboration areas are all in the same area on each floor and labeled in a consistent manner, while all the A/V bells and whistles work the same across the entire space. Even the sound masking is complex. Vega explains that traditional sound masking for office space is located above the ceiling. With an open floor plan, it also must be placed below the
Adding to the urgency in the design and construction timeline was the fact that Forest City was very possibly going to be bought by Brookfield, which ultimately did happen, as announced by the companies in December 2018. ceiling to help deaden the noise from work station to work station. To aide in privacy, there is also sound masking between each collaboration or huddle space. As a bonus, the sound masking system can function as a PA system should it ever be necessary.
Lasting legacy Adding to the urgency in the design and construction timeline was the fact that Forest City was very possibly going to be bought by Brookfield, which ultimately did happen, as announced by the companies in December 2018. Porter recalls a meeting in which his team collectively wondered, “What if Forest City doesn’t exist anymore?” In the new atrium, the wooden reception desk has a stone accent corner piece with the words “Forest City” engraved, ensuring the legacy of the Cleveland-based company will always remain. P 18
Properties | February 2019
Cover Your Investments With Confidence
Count on Commercial Roofing and Coating Systems, Inc. to get on top of your roofing project – no matter the size. We specialize in roofing repairs, replacements and maintenance for Commercial, Industrial and Residential clients throughout Northeast Ohio. Our main focus? Providing efficient and cost-effective service. Our full line of services includes: Roofing Maintenance | Inspections & Reporting Infrared Leak Detection & Reporting | Low Slope Roofing Single-Ply Membrane Roof Systems | TPO, PVC, EPDM, Modified Asphalt Sheet Metal & Custom Flashings | ACM Composite Panels | Coatings Insulation | Tapered Insulation, Tapered Roofing | Metal-Retrofit Systems Daylighting | Solar Roof Systems | New Construction & Roof Replacement
Contact us today at 330-207-3879 to handle all of your roofing needs! Mailing Address: P.O. Box 73, Garrettsville, OH 44231 | Physical Address: 10025 SR-82, Windham, OH 44288 brandon@ohiocommercialroofing.com | www.ohiocommercialroofing.com
Luxury Lakefront Living at Harbor Verandas Redevelopment of North Coast Harbor continues with new mixed-use apartment building By Mark Watt | Photos by Christian Phillips
or decades, city planners have imagined a lively, dynamic North Coast Harbor, with locals and tourists populating Cleveland’s lakefront year-round, day and night. Step by step, that vision is coming into focus as Dick Pace, his company Cumberland Development and partners continue to complete projects as part of a multiphase development of prime waterfront property between the East 9th Street Pier and West 3rd Street. First was Nuevo Modern Mexican & Tequila Bar, which opened in 2016, bordering Voinovich Park. Now comes Harbor Verandas, a $12 million residential/retail development tucked on a half-acre site just north of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and Museum.
F
Introducing Downtown Cleveland’s first new lakefront living in over a century, the three-story building houses 16 luxury rental units on its top two floors, with an enclosed garage at street level surrounded by six retail spaces. Designed by Dimit Architects and built by John G. Johnson Construction as construction manager at risk, Harbor Verandas has found early success as just two living units remain available for lease. Build-out of first-floor commercial spaces is currently underway, including Cumberland Development’s headquarters and a storefront for Cleveland Bike 20
Tours. Also expected is a 5,000-squarefoot restaurant and coffee shop with outdoor seating, a possible art gallery, plus a public restroom to accommodate passersby. All should be completed by this summer, Pace says. “We wanted to create a building with a contemporary feel that would take advantage of these spectacular views of the lake and downtown, so each apartment has its own private veranda – thus the name of the project,” Pace says. “Then, with the commercial spaces, outdoor seating and new landscaping outside, all of a sudden we’re also activat-
ing this walkway along the waterfront between Nuevo and the Rock Hall. It’s about creating a neighborhood here.”
Full circle at North Coast Harbor Pace has long had an association with this portion of Cleveland’s lakefront. Long before he launched Cumberland Development in 2001, he worked as an architect, joining Cleveland-based firm Dalton, van Dijk, Johnson Architects after graduating from the University of Michigan in 1979. Just a few years later, as a project manager in 1985, he helped draft Properties | February 2019
Harbor Verandas After all of these years, we finally have people living on our downtown lakefront!
Our sincere gratitude to the whole development team... John G. Johnson Construction Company Dimit Architects OJB Landscape Architecture Riverstone Survey WHS Engineering GPD Group The Construction Green Team Envelope Consulting Services
Catherine Pace (216)583-0500 1050 East 9th Street
Port of Cleveland Chemical Bank Huntington Bank Tucker Ellis City of Cleveland Mayor Frank Jackson & Council President Kevin Kelley
SOLI DEO GLORIA
HOME ON THE HARBOR The new three-story building houses 16 luxury rental units with an enclosed garage at street level, surrounded by six retail spaces that are currently under construction.
fronts such as New York’s Battery Park and Baltimore, Maryland’s Harbor Point. Among those responding to an RFQ to fulfill the plan: Cumberland Development, which won the bid in 2014 to lease and build on city-owned properties along Lake Erie. “By June of 2015, we were able to sign a master development agreement to redevelop the waterfront,” Pace says, noting this brings him fullcircle to a process he started Richard Pace 35 years ago. “It’s been a long Cumberland Development time. Now I get to put my money where my mouth was, years ago, working with the national way back then.” architectural firm Perkins Eastman, In addition to Nuevo Cleveland and which has designed well-known water- Harbor Verandas, Cumberland is now developing a yet-to-be-named project Proud to be the Civil Engineer & Land Surveyor for HARBOR VERANDAS on a one-acre site just west of the Rock Hall. The overall waterfront plan also includes the much larger multi-phase HarborView project, a mix of dense residential and commercial properties along 18 acres immediately north of FirstEnergy Stadium, to be developed as a 50/50 partnership between Cumberland and Trammel Crow.
a master plan to develop North Coast Harbor for the City of Cleveland. That effort would eventually take shape with the opening of the Rock Hall in 1995, as well as Great Lakes Science Center next door the following year. FirstEnergy Stadium joined the neighborhood in 1999, creating a confluence of landmark destinations within walking distance of one another. Still, because foot traffic in the area relied heavily on special events or around the museums’ operating hours, crowds typically emptied out by 5 p.m. each day and the area could feel desolate. Despite its world-class tourist attractions, one of the city’s most promising
and prominent locations somehow felt underutilized. Recognizing this, the City updated its master plan for the harbor seven
“We wanted to create a building with a contemporary feel that would take advantage of these spectacular views of the lake and downtown, so each apartment has its own private veranda – thus the name of the project.”
riverstone
3800 800 Lakeside Avenue A en e | Cleveland, Cleveland Cle eland Ohio 44114 | 216 216-491-2000 491 2000 22
Inside and out As phase two of that comprehensive lakefront project, development of Harbor Verandas kicked off in 2015. Properties | February 2019
D I M I T A R C H I T E C T S architecture + interiors + urban design www.dimitarchitects.com
216 • 221 • 9021
Congratulations Cumberland Development!
LEADERS IN MULTI-FAM MULTI-FAMILY CONSTRUCT CONSTRUCTION GENERAL CONTRACTORS CONSTRUCTION MANAGERS DESIGN/BUILDERS
WWW.JOHNGJOHNSON.COM
BID PACKAGE SPECIALISTS
www.propertiesmag.com 23
NODDING TO NEIGHBORING LANDMARKS Cumberland Development sought “a design that was in the same family as Nuevo Cleveland and would also be sympathetic to the Rock Hall and Great Lakes Science Center,” notes Scott Dimit, principal of Dimit Architects. The result is a sleek yet warm, boutique apartment building wrapped in a blend of cedar siding, aluminum curtain walls, metal panels and glazed iron-spot brick.
“Dick [Pace] started looking at designs for the project while we were finishing up construction of Nuevo,” says Scott Dimit, principal in charge of design with Dimit Architects. “We worked
our way through multiple concepts. It’s a pretty daunting site. Because it’s so close to Burke Lakefront Airport, there were height restrictions. It’s also a small site with a footprint of about
Congratulations to Cumberland Development and JG Johnson Construction on the Harbor Verandas project. First American Title National Commercial Services in Cleveland is honored to be a part of their success.
©2019 First American Financial Corporation and/or its affiliates. All rights reserved. NYSE: FAF
24
20,000 square feet and it’s right next to the Rock Hall, so it’s very visible. He wanted a design that was in the same family as Nuevo Cleveland and would also be sympathetic to the Rock Hall and Great Lakes Science Center.” The result is a sleek yet warm, boutique apartment building wrapped in a blend of cedar siding, aluminum curtain walls and metal panels, as well as a glazed manganese iron-spot brick product. “The dark brick has almost a metallic sheen and is Norman size, so it’s a little longer than a modular brick,” says John Holtz, project designer with Dimit Architects. “All horizontal grout joints are recessed and vertical joints are flush, which is a Frank Lloyd Wright detail that accentuates the horizontal lines.” “The exterior is driven by emphasizing the views, while the interiors serve as a frame for the outside, so everything inside is more neutral with gray tones and bleached-out woods,” says Analia Dimit, director of interior architecture. Because the interiors are largely visible from outside though walls of floor-toceiling glass, the design inside serves as Properties | February 2019
Pleased to provide masonry for HARBOR VERANDAS with John G. Johnson Construction & Cumberland Development
5381 553 3381 81 E 81 Erie rie SSt ri Street Str tre reeett SSuite uiite u te B B Bedford eed dffo ord rd H Heights, eeiigh ghts ts, O OH H 444146 44114466 4440-232-2243 4400-2 -23322-2 -222443 5381 ERIE STREET, SUITE B | BEDFORD HEIGHTS, OH 44146 | 440-232-2243
CONTACT US
FOR LEASING CONTACT: STEVE ROSS 216.363.6423 steve.ross@cbre.com
www.propertiesmag.com 25
Thomas Brick is proud to be material supplier for HARBOR VERANDAS
THE
THOMAS BRICK
COMPANY
BRICK Y STONE Y T I L E
Beachwood 216.831.9116 Y Westlake 440.892.9400 Y www.thomasbrick.com Established in 1933
WARM RECEPTION Apartments incorporate their own dedicated foyers with oak flooring, walls and ceilings, providing tenants with customizable entry spaces where they can place furniture or hang art.
an extension of the exterior architecture, she adds. An east-facing lobby entry for tenants includes a seating area with walnut wood wall panels, an L-shaped sofa, a Platner coffee table, glass pendant designed by Michele de Lucchi and a high-top table built with reclaimed wood. Additionally, there is a small kitchenette, secure mail room, an elevator, and access to a hardwood open staircase. Arranged along wide common corridors on floors two and three, apartments incorporate unique, dedicated foyers with oak flooring, walls and ceiling. “The foyers provide tenants with gracious, customizable entry spaces where they can hang a piece of art and place a piece of furniture if they’d like,” Pace says. Adding to the refined ambiance of these common areas, skylights allow natural light to reach deep inside, illuminating the exquisite wood detailing and multi-colored carpeting. “We love working with Dick Pace and his team because they understand that
those beautiful details can make a big difference on a project,” Dimit says. With rent ranging from $3,700 to $4,000 per month, apartment units are
high-end, sized from 1,700 square feet with two bedrooms to 2,000 square feet with three bedrooms, each with a private veranda that’s 150 square feet or larger.
www.propertiesmag.com 27
REFINED FINISHES All units include ample living spaces (top), kitchens with quartz counters and high-gloss Thermofoil cabinetry (middle) and bathrooms with custom tile flooring (bottom).
All units include gas fireplaces in living rooms, bleach Red Oak flooring, laundry rooms with GE washers and dryers, and walk-in closets in master bedrooms. Bathrooms feature custom tile flooring, quartz countertops and walk-in showers with glazed ceramic wall tile, plus double sinks in master bedrooms, while kitchens include premium quartz countertops, pantries, dishwashers and kitchen islands, as well as Bosch steel hoods, ovens and cooktops. “Each kitchen has gray Thermofoil cabinetry with a high-gloss finish,” says
“There are lots of nice reasons to be outside, whether it’s the rooftop patio or the private verandas. The views are just outstanding. There’s the lake, of course, but some of the most breathtaking views are those looking back at the city skyline and the Rock Hall, especially at night.” Gary Ogrocki Dimit Architects
Photo by Ken Krych
Katie Tarase, interior designer with Dimit Architects. “Cabinets above the counter are touch-latch, so there are no handles visible. It’s very minimal since the most important aspects of the interiors are the views to outside.” Apartments feel particularly spacious with 10-foot-high ceilings and eight-foot doors, while recessed lighting and soffits offer an elegant touch. Tenant amenities also include access to the 29-space parking garage, as well as an 850-square-foot rooftop patio with a bar counter and sink. “There are lots of nice reasons to be outside, whether it’s the rooftop patio or the private verandas,” says Gary Ogrocki, principal/architect with Dimit Architects. “The views are just 28
Properties | February 2019
Proud member of the John G. Johnson Construction team at HARBOR VERANDAS chosen to provide: insulation • drywall • metal studs
With nearly 60 styles ranging from warm and inviting, to sleek and sophisticated— we aim to please.
Giorgi Commercial Contracting
For a dealer near you, visit:
EterniaQuartz.com
specializing in: Cold Formed Framing Insulation gypsum assemblies Acoustic Ceilings
Interior Specialists in Commercial & Institutional projects throughout NE Ohio 11145 Chardon Rd. • Chardon, OH 44024 (440) 279-4488 • chris@giorgicommercial.com
We’re up to speed, so you can go full speed. PUT OUR REAL ESTATE INSIGHTS TO WORK FOR YOU. To make confident decisions about the future, middle market leaders need a different kind of advisor. One who starts by understanding where you want to go and then brings the ideas and insights of an experienced global team to help get you there. Experience the power of being understood. Experience RSM. rsmus.com/realestate
RSM US LLP is the U.S. member firm of RSM International, a global network of independent audit, tax and consulting firms. Visit rsmus.com/aboutus for more information regarding RSM US LLP and RSM International.
www.propertiesmag.com 29
STURDY FOUNDATION Because of extremely soft soil conditions, the building is constructed with a post-tension concrete podium that’s supported by 70 auger cast piles, reaching 100 feet deep until meeting bedrock.
Construction challenges Construction of the project started in 2017 and finished in a little under 12
Congrats to John G. Johnson Construction 30
months, Pace says. Presenting an obstacle, Harbor Verandas is constructed atop landfill, which he explains does not compact very well. “A century ago, everything north of the railroad tracks here was water,” he says. “The entire coastline was created later by the City using landfill.”
Because of this, developing a foundation system was the biggest challenge of the project. While the original plan was to utilize a floating mat foundation for the project, Cleveland Cement Contractors recommended an auger cast pile system, which provided substantial cost savings, Pace notes.
Our gratitude is written in stone. Concrete We were proud to be part of the team at HARBOR VERANDAS with John G. Johnson Construction.
Cleveland Cement Contractors, Inc.
Serving Northeast Ohio Since 1944 clevelandcement.com
Properties | February 2019
Photo courtesy of John G. Johnson Construction
outstanding. There’s the lake, of course, but some of the most breathtaking views are those looking back at the city skyline and the Rock Hall, especially at night.”
Photo courtesy of John G. Johnson Construction
YOU HANDLE THE BUSINESS WE’LL HANDLE THE BANKING. Since 1917, we’ve helped families and businesses thrive with abundant financing options and a full range of banking services. Our hometown approach to banking is focused on community banking, highlighted by local leadership and decision making, a devotion to the community and personalized service. When you choose Chemical Bank, you’re choosing a banker who will listen, learn your story and provide expert advice.
BUILT ABOVE Upper floors are wood residential construction, positioned on top of the parking garage and retail spaces.
Jamie Lynch Regional President, NE Ohio 216.706.3709
John Cunningham SVP Group Manager 216.706.3702
“The building is basically built on stilts,” says Mike Weber, vice president/ owner of John G. Johnson. “There are about 70 auger cast piles, which are 100
“There can be extreme weather conditions here with high winds and rain that hit the building sideways coming off of the lake, so the envelope is engineered above and beyond what you’d typically encounter to prevent water from penetrating the skin of the building.”
Proud Project Partner at HARBOR VERANDAS
Mike Weber John G. Johnson Construction feet deep each until they meet bedrock. The building sits on top of those piles with a post-tension concrete podium that includes the parking garage, and there are two floors of wood residential construction above that.” Weber says the tight site created additional challenges, requiring a high degree of coordination and cooperation among project partners. “There was not a lot of space to work with,” he says. “Thankfully, everyone had the same
COMMERCIAL & INDUSTRIAL Complete Electrical Services Throughout Northeast Ohio State License #15314 Call us at 440.259.2464 or visit us at www.HannahElectric.com www.propertiesmag.com 31
DELIVERING VALUE THROUGH PARTNERSHIP.
HARBOR VERANDAS
Your value-added partner to design, fabricate & install innovative, high quality unitized curtain wall & custom building facades.
director@aiacleveland.com
2550 BROOKPARK ROAD, CLEVELAND, OH 44134 216.920.2900 | WWW.PIONEERGLAZING.COM
Over a Century of Service FOUNDED IN 1918
J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc. • Commercial Buildings • Construction Sites
THE OLDEST AND MOST EXPERIENCED WATERPROOFING, CONCRETE & MASONRY RESTORATION CONTRACTOR Concrete Repair Masonry Restoration Brick/Stone Repair Epoxy Injection Post Tensioning Repairs
Caulking/Sealants Expansion Joints 7UDIƓF &RDWLQJV Epoxy Flooring Masonry Sealers/Coatings
Exterior Cleaning :DWHUSURRƓQJ Spray Foam Insulation Air Barrier Systems Fire-Stopping
440.740.0100 | WWW.RAMSERVICES.COM 100 CORPORATION CENTER | BROADVIEW HEIGHTS, OHIO 32
• Special Event Clean-Up • Concrete Cleaning • Carpet Cleaning • Window Cleaning • Wall Washing • Acoustical Ceilings
1230 East Schaaf Road Brooklyn Heights, OH 44131
216-749-1150 www.jvjanitorial.com Properties | February 2019
OUTDOOR AMENITIES Taking advantage of the views, each unit features a private veranda. Residents also have access to a rooftop patio.
goal in mind and came together to solve problems and work as a team.” The building’s waterfront location required special measures to ensure it could withstand harsh weather events, he says. “There can be extreme weather conditions here with high winds and rain that hit the building sideways coming off of the lake, so the envelope is engineered above and beyond what you’d typically encounter to prevent water from penetrating the skin of the building,” Weber says. This included application of a fluidapplied weather barrier around the entire exterior, plenty of flashing and sealing, enhanced insulation and an upgraded window system, which together help to ensure the building is weather-safe, thermally tight and energy efficient. Targeting LEED Silver certification through the U.S. Green Building Council, the building is designed with additional green components, such as high performance, sustainable building
materials, energy efficient appliances and dimmable LED lighting. Outside, as a finishing element of the project, newly installed benches and 20 young Scarlet Maple trees deflect wind while offering an inviting place for visitors to stop and watch boats coming in and out of the transient marina to the north of the site. “The concept is that these trees will ring the harbor and, in the fall, will turn
a deep red,” Pace says. “We think it’s going to be a cool, signature look.”
A clearer vision With Harbor Verandas now open and plans for additional lakefront development underway, the City’s dream of a further energized North Coast Harbor is becoming a reality. Today, even on a chilly winter morning, runners can be seen jogging along the waterfront near
Suntrol It! SUNTROL
™
G L A S S
E N H A N C I N G
F I L M S
Suntrol.com 800-466-TINT(8468) ESTABLISHED 1975
Love Your Windows!
Select Pro Window Film Dealer: • Security • Privacy/Custom • Energy Savings • Glare Reduction • Sun Protection
www.propertiesmag.com 33
PROUD PARTNER AT HARBOR VERANDAS
Adrian Maldonado&Associates Inc. POST CONSTRUCTION CLEAN-UP, PROJECT MANAGEMENT, DEMOLITION DEBRIS REMOVAL, FURNITURE MOVING, STAGING & INSTALLATION
Photo by Ken Krych
:H DUH D FHUWLÀHG ('*( 0%( '%( +8' 6HFWLRQ 6HUYLFH 'LVDEOHG 9HWHUDQ 2ZQHG %XVLQHVV H[SHULHQFHG ZLWK FRPPHUFLDO LQVWLWXWLRQDO UHVLGHQWLDO VWUXFWXUHV *UD\WRQ 5G %HUHD DGULDQ PDOGRQDGR#\DKRR FRP
Pleased to provide custom architectural millwork & cabinetry for HARBOR VERANDAS
ROYAL
CABINET
DESIGN COMPANY
Headquartered in Cleveland, Royal Cabinet Design Company is a family-owned, fully-integrated custom woodwork and architectural millwork manufacturer and supplier.
UNSURPASSED SERVICE
UNCOMPROMISING QUALITY CRAFTSMANSHIP
UNDENIABLY SATISFIED CLIENTS
15800 Commerce Park Dr., Brook Park, OH 44142 www.royalcabinetdesign.com | 216-267-5330 34
COMMON COMFORT A lobby entry for residents includes walnut wood panels, soft seating and a small kitchenette.
Nuevo while visitors pose for a picture by the stylized ‘Cleveland’ sign, installed by Destination Cleveland near bocce and sand volleyball courts at Voinovich Park. “It’s great to be part of this whole adventure to make the lakefront more active and accessible,” says Scott Dimit. “This project is crucial because it’s the first piece where people will be living here 24 hours a day. It’s a big first step. It will be interesting to see how this will
“It’s great to be part of this whole adventure to make the lakefront more active and accessible.... This project is crucial because it’s the first piece where people will be living here 24 hours a day. It’s a big first step.” Scott Dimit Dimit Architects evolve as more residential makes its way to the lakefront.” Catherine Pace, Dick’s daughter and project manager/leasing agent with Cumberland Development, says the expansive HarborView project should break ground by this June and will likely include adaptive re-use of an old warehouse, construction of new commercial and residential buildings, plus parks and a primary school building in partnership with Cleveland Metropolitan School District. “There are still a lot of exciting things to come,” she says. P Properties | February 2019
BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans
Mars Electric Becomes Certified Female Business Enterprise
Photo courtesy of Mars Electric
M
ars Electric, a Northeast Ohio-based independent, wholesale distributor of lighting, gear and electrical supplies, recently announced it is now a certified Female Business Enterprise (FBE). The City of Cleveland recently recognized Mars Electric as an FBE with Fran Doris as the CEO. Started 65 years ago by Sam and Rebecca Doris, Fran’s in-laws, Mars Electric is led by Fran, her husband and President Mark Doris, and sons Michael and Andrew Doris. Mars Electric has 12 locations across (From left) Mars Electric’s Executive Vice President Northeast Ohio, servicing contractors who Michael Doris, CEO Fran Doris, President Mark Doris and VMI Sales Manager Andrew Doris work on job sites from Cleveland to Ashtabula and Youngstown, and Akron to South of Canton and Sandusky.
CRS, AIA Announces Call for Celebration of Preservation Award Nominations Recently, the Cleveland Restoration Society and AIA Cleveland announced a call for nominations for the 2019 Celebration of Preservation awards program. The annual awards event recognizes local preservation projects, and individuals and organizations whose contributions demonstrate excellence and outstanding commitment to historic preservation. Nominations are due Friday, February 15, 2019
by 5 p.m. Awards will be determined by a jury of architects, contractors and experts in historic preservation and announced during the Celebration of Preservation in May. To submit a project, visit clevelandrestoration.org. For more info, contact Michael Fleenor by email at mfleenor@clevelandrestoration.org or phone at 216.426.3109.
Annual Canstruction Event Calls Attention to Hunger On Thursday evening April 4, 2019 at South Park Mall,
local teams will design and build structures made entirely of full cans of food. At the end of the exhibit, the cans will be donated to the local food bank assisting local families in Northeast Ohio. Through combined Canstruction Cleveland and Canstruction Jr. efforts, over 42,000 pounds and an additional check for $5,000 was donated from the event last year. Canstruction, founded in 1992, is a unique food drive created by the Society for Design Administration to call national attention to hunger. Events are held annually in
more than 150 cities and have grown to become one of the largest and most consistent canned food contributors to food banks around the world. If you would like more information on how to form a team, volunteer or sponsor the 2019 Canstruction event, please contact the Canstruction Cleveland Planning Committee by email at canstruction@ onyxcreative.com or phone at 216-223-3202.
Pleasant Valley Acquires NAI Daus, NAI Cummins PVC (Pleasant Valley Corporation) announced recently that it is aligning its commercial real estate services with the Northeast Ohio real estate brokerage offices of NAI Global, thereby creating NAI Pleasant Valley, Northern Ohio’s largest industrial real estate brokerage. NAI Pleasant Valley provides commercial real estate services, worldwide. Locally, it serves Cleveland and Akron and the surrounding counties of Cuyahoga, Summit, Portage, Lorain, Medina, Lake, Geauga and Ashtabula,
Capitalize on Your Coverage. M k a great impression! Make i i ! Contact C info@propertiesmag.com i f i to order d reprints or custom copies of articles originally published in Properties, which can be distributed to your existing and future clients. UWLQJ 6XSSRU :WV[SPNO[PUN [OL WYVMLZZPVUHS ZLY]PJL WYV]PKLYZ J[PVU WYVQLJ[Z ILOPUK Z\JJLZZM ILOPUK Z\JJLZZM\S JVUZ[Y\ &DVW :WV[SPNO[PUN [OL Plan Ahead & Negotiate Wisely to Maximize Value
INDUSTRY LEADER SINCE 1946
Outparcels Ou of Shoppingg Center Out
By Megan C. Zaidan, Esq. Walter | Haverfield LLP
value ad rs to create added of a retail center – allow developers utparcels – small lots on the periphery outparcels are more s, as outparcel utilized by banks or restaurants, to shopping centers. Outparcels are often features, such as specific featur increased visibility and ability to add attractive to these users based on the to the user’s business. a patio or drive-thru, which are important docu Recorded documents
O
Developers will most often convey the parcels either by longterm ground lease or outright sale to the end user.
Legal subdivisions
Exclusive | Focused | Informative | Dependable | Connected www.Propertiesmag.com
From a developer’s perspective, it may be necessary for the outparcel to be legally subdivided from the larger shopping center parcel as a condition of sale to the end user. If a developer knows in the initial stages of development that it is likely to sell off one or more outparcels, it would be wise to create the separate parcels early in the development process. Such a pro-active approach is particularly important in jurisdictions with time-consuming subdivision processes. The sub-dividing of the outparcel from the large shopping center could expedite subsequent sales of any such outparcels created. the Alternatively, developer may require the end-user to cause the parcels to be subdivided; however, the developer will need to remain involved and aware of the subdivision plans
Megan C. Zaidan, Esq.
Equally important for the developer is to ensure that outparcel plans independently meet or exceed applicable parking requirements
ce subdivided, the respecOnce bligations of tthe developer tive obligations own (or ground he parcel owner and the lessee)) will likely be governed Reciprocal Easement by a Reciproca ement (an “REA”). The Agreement fort each party’s REA will set forth matters such as ation for ma obligation ss, utilities, maintenance access, and insurance. In addition, may also look to the developer m ose certain operating and impose upon the restrict ding restrictions building within the REA, arcel with outparcel heigh restrictions to uding height including constructed build ure any building ensure not block the viseon will no thereon signage of the shopping ty or signag ibility tenant ter’s tenants. center’s developer may also look he develop The number of tenants or imit the nu to limit lo If the outparcel userss of the lot. is not restricted to a single user, it develop into a multi-tencould be developed rip-center tthat could eventually ant strip-center compe with the larger compete center for small shoppi shopping shop tenants. Finally, the would likely look develo developer architectural in to include and signage standards for the outparcel, so it conforms form with the shopping ensuring a more center, cent
From a developer’s perspective, it may be necessary for [an] outparcel to be legally subdivided from [a] larger shopping center parcel as a condition of sale to the end user.
Expanding Oppo
Geis Companies By Dan Maurer
rtunity
hits the road to
| Photos by
Marco Zecchin/Im
build $80 million
Thermo Fisher
age Center Scientific facility he Geis Compan ies Streetsboro-based has been busy in Northeas t Ohio in 2014. company complete Brecksville, a Within d a 110,000-s 75,000-square-foot quare-foot medical the past 12 months, the aluminum dye call center for device facility Panther Logistics casting facility for AMT in in building for Firefighters CommunTwinsburg for General Dye. in Medina and a 90,000-sq uare-foot It finished a service center ity Credit Union 12,000-square-foot addition for in Cuyahoga Steel Warehou office Hofbräuhaus Heights, plus se of Ohio. More Cleveland. a 40,000-square-foot recently, the Garnering company also the most buzz, Geis unveiled The completed for 9, the
T
Thermo Fisher massive $170 lion project Scientific, a mil- based in Boston- Fisher multination that incorporate downtown Cleveland Scientific in product developmen al, biotechnology s the East Bay Administrative the Cuyahoga County of California, region t company with enues of $17 prompted by Headquarters, rev- tion of billion. In fact Metropolitan the expiraThe th existing l nea l 60% h t l
www.propertiesmag.com 35
)DEULFDWLRQ ,QVWDOODWLRQ 6HUYLFH
LQ \HDUV U H Y R RU OL]LQJ I 6SHFLD WRS U HG URRI J D RW ZDWH N F K D 3 P GLQJ ¥ VWHD ZHO Q R L W D F %RLOHUV UL HWDO IDE HOGLQJ 6KHHWP ULFDWLRQ Z IDE W 3ODVWLF HHULQJ DUWPHQ Q S L H J G Q H H F 9DOXHG H PDLQWHQDQ UYLF )XOO VH
ZZZ OLVFRKYDF FRP 6WDWH 5G 1 5R\DOWRQ 2+
Serving Northeast Ohio For Over 60 Years! Residential Ŷ Commercial Ŷ Industrial Ŷ Institutional
Expert Brick Matching and Complete Inventory of Brick, Block, Masonry, Cast & Natural Stone, Plaster Products & Tools
16900 Rockside Rd., Maple Heights, OH 44137
216.791.9800 Ŷ www.bruderinc.com
christian phillips photography architectural interiors landscape info @ c-p-photo.com christianphillipsphoto.com 617.990.4587 OH/NY/MA/IL will travel Associate AIA Member financial services company outside houston, tx by vocon.
...see the difference a trained architect can make looking through the lens!
36
Properties | February 2019
BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans
with expanding service for other regions of Northern Ohio as well. NAI Pleasant Valley offers an extensive range of brokerage services, including feasibility studies and management. To comprise NAI Pleasant Valley, PVC’s current commercial real estate operations will be combined with those of the former brokerages NAI Daus and NAI Cummins. The new NAI Pleasant Valley is the Northern Ohio office of commercial real estate brokerage firm NAI Global. NAI Pleasant Valley brings together the skills and experience of the two former NAI offices in Beachwood and Akron, the dynamic growth and breadth of services of sister company PVC, and the
worldwide service network of NAI Global. (NAI Pleasant Valley is a separate entity from PVC.) The principals of NAI Pleasant Valley are Gino Faciana and Barbara Faciana, co-chief executive officers of Pleasant Valley Corporation, and Alec Pacella, former managing partner of NAI Daus, now president of NAI Pleasant Valley.
Shook Construction Promotes Shafer to CFO Shook Construction’s Chris Shafer has been promoted to chief financial officer, the company announced recently. With 20 years of accounting experience, Shafer assumes a strategic role in the over-
Chris Shafer
all management and future growth of the company. As part of his new position, he also will oversee human resources, information technology and risk management. Shafer, who is a Certified Public Accountant, earned his bachelor’s degree from
Wright State University, as well as his MBA from University of Dayton. He began his journey at Shook Construction as controller in 2014. Since then, the company has experienced substantial growth thus creating many opportunities for its own employees to step up into new leadership roles. 2018 was the company’s most profitable year with $505 million worth of new work. In addition, Shook Construction opened a new office in Columbus, further expanding its geographic footprint. P WHAT’S NEW? For coverage within Billboard, send along company news, story ideas and project information to billboard@propertiesmag.com.
www.propertiesmag.com 37
VANTAGE POINT Experts weigh in on industry issues
Construction Technology Trends rom mobile devices, broadband connectivity and cloud computing, to more recent developments in artificial intelligence, augmented reality and Blockchain, technology continues to change the way that we live and work. Despite the fact that research suggests that construction is the slowest industry to adopt new technologies (only ahead of farming and hunting), slowly but surely the industry is beginning to embrace these new tools.
F AARON COOK
For instance, drones, robotics, 3D printing and augmented reality are becoming more prevalent in the construction industry, and new advances in Blockchain technology are poised to impact the industry in the near future.
Drones Larger drones (unmanned aircraft) are often associated with military operations, whereas smaller consumer drones are often enjoyed by hobby enthusiasts, but did you know that drones are used in the construction industry and on a regular basis? In fact, drones are arguably one of the most impactful construction industry technological trends these past few years, and as they become even more affordable, their use is poised to become even more commonplace in the industry. Drones equipped with high definition cameras are being utilized to survey construction sites, which is particularly useful in remote areas, and those sites
38
where traditional surveying techniques pose a significant safety risk. The video captured by drones is used to create 3D mapping and images that otherwise would be unattainable. To boot, the use of drones saves time and cost, as an entire site can be surveyed in a fraction of time as compared to historical construction site mapping.
Robotics For decades, robotics have been used in manufacturing and distribution, and more recently in other industries such as healthcare for use in surgery, but here soon and into the future robotics are finding applications in the construction industry. Similar to drones, robotic technology can be used to survey and perform work otherwise performed by human labor. Applications include routine tasks such as installing rebar or laying bricks, but more importantly robots can be used in dangerous situations to improve worker safety. This includes unsafe high eleva-
Properties | February 2019
tion and underground construction, such as in mining. Even more intriguing, robots are currently constructing small and large structures by controlling 3D printers, with applications ranging from massproduced residential construction to bridge-building. In fact, a 3D printed bridge was completed recently in the Netherlands. These robots are already poised to significantly improve construction speed, safety and quality.
Augmented reality Most of us have been exposed to the concept of virtual reality, and if you are like me, your kids have enjoyed this technology in the realm of video games. While virtual reality provides us with a particular vision of the world through the lens of a camera, augmented reality allows us to change this vision. This technology creates endless opportunities for engineering, design and construction professionals. By altering the virtual conditions of a prospective job site and/or building, project designers have the ability to perform ‘what-if’ scenarios with much more precision and speed than current Building Information Modeling (BIM) technologies. In fact, augmented reality will improve the use of BIM by identifying otherwise unforeseen design issues before the start of construction. In addition, virtual reality simulators are being used to train operators of construction equipment and machinery similar to flight simulators used for training pilots.
a specific user group, such as the stakeholders in a construction contract. A potential application of Blockchain technology in construction is to automate the process of authorizing information between a general contractor and subcontractors. Information that is currently
Robotic technology can be used to survey and perform work otherwise performed by human labor. Applications include routine tasks such as installing rebar or laying bricks, but more importantly robots can be used in dangerous situations to improve worker safety. authorized using a manual process – such as proof of insurance, performance and payment bonds, financial information, safety records, lien waivers, contract documents and applications for payment – can be automated using Blockchain. In addition, the billing and payment process alone could see a significant ben-
efit from Blockchain technology. Industry players know that it’s a laborious process to mitigate the risk of improper payment from a project owner to a general contractor, and down the line from the general contractor to its employees, subcontractors, material suppliers and other vendors. Take for example the process between a general contractor and its subcontractors. Generally, subcontractors submit an application for payment each month for services performed to date. Before authorizing the payment to the subcontractor, the general contractor must verify the accuracy of contract value for each phase and scope of work, the progress towards completion, lien waivers and a handful of other manual procedures before authorizing payment. Blockchain technology can automate this process and make it more efficient for all parties privy to a construction contract. P Aaron T. Cook, CPA, CCIFP is officer in charge of construction & real estate services in Meaden & Moore’s Construction Services Group and is a Certified Construction Industry Financial Professional (CCIFP). He can be reached at 216.928.5372 or acook@meadenmoore.com. For more info, visit www.meadenmoore.com.
Blockchain technology Digital currencies, most notably Bitcoin, are fairly well known with media coverage of the volatile boombust movements in valuation, but lesser known is the potential of the underlying Blockchain technology, which makes Bitcoin transactions possible. Without delving into how Blockchain technology works, think of it as an electronic ledger similar to an accounting or bank ledger. Whereas a bank ledger is housed and maintained by the bank, which is subject to risks from inadvertent human error to more mischievous risks such as computer hacking, Blockchain ledgers are not centralized, but instead are only visible to authorized users. Software can then be designed to meet the needs of www.propertiesmag.com 39
FINANCIAL STRATEGIES Smart use of fiscal planning & action
Position Player ootball, as those who are frequent readers of this column already know, is a favorite pastime of mine. However, my career as a player started and ended in the fifth grade. Despite this short exposure as a participant, it was long enough for me to realize that the game was not as quite as it had initially appeared. Not only were there all these different positions to learn but different rules applied, depending on the position.
F ALEC J. PACELLA
For example, an offensive tackle isn’t allowed to move at the line of scrimmage but a defensive tackle is allowed. I thought about this the other day, when I was valuing a self-storage facility. Although a novice investor may think that all commercial real estate is valued the same, there can be nuances, or rules, depending on the specific kind of real estate. This month, we will look at some of these instances.
Apartments There are generally two nuances that crop up when valuing a multifamily property. First, the value is usually based on a single year of income and expense. While there cer-
tainly are apartment valuations based on multi-year discounted cash flows, this approach is not typical. The rationale is simple; a tenant lease for an apartment unit is almost never longer than one year and often are month to month. As a result, the absolute certainly of cash flow is one year, at best, and attempting to forecast rental income past a year is highly speculative. The second topic is one that can be controversial – the concept of a reserve. Although considering a “rainy day” fund set aside for a future capital repair is commonplace, where this actual expense item shows up is not consistent for most types of real estate. Sometimes, it is considered an operating expense and thus is a part of
9G YQWNF DG RTQWF VQ DG RCTV QH [QWT VGCO QP [QWT PGZV EQPUVTWEVKQP RTQLGEV
CONTAINER SERVICE, INC.
¸;OL 3LHKLY PU *VU[HPULY :LY]PJL¹ -), *:) ,+., *,9;0-0,+
>>> 7,;,(5+7,;,05* *64 40
@6<9 *65:;9<*;065 :7,*0(30:;: .9,,5 3,,+ 7961,*;: @(9+ -965; 36(+ *65;(05,9: @(9+ 96336-- *65;(05,9: Properties | February 2019
What I C at PVC THE NEXT CHAPTER As you may have heard, NAI Daus is now a part of a new company - NAI Pleasant Valley. The Daus name was a part the commercial real estate brokerage landscape in Northeast Ohio for over 50 years and we are excited to see what the next 50 years will bring with Pleasant Valley. –AP net operating income (or NOI) while other times, it is not considered an operating expense and thus is not a part of NOI. The pages of Properties are not long enough to encompass the endless debate on both sides of this topic. But the good news is that there is usually no ambiguity when it comes to handling a reserve for an apartment. It is almost always considered an operating expense, which again is
Although a novice investor may think that all commercial real estate is valued the same, there can be nuances, or rules, depending on the specific kind of real estate (such as apartments, self-storage facilities, assisted living facilities and car washes) related to the very short-term nature of the tenant leases. A reserve for this type of property encompasses all of the things needed to prepare a unit for a new tenant – paint and carpet/flooring being the primary expenses. It is highly likely that an apartment owner will have several tenants move out during an average year and will have to “turn the unit.” A reserve included in NOI paints a much more accurate cash flow picture.
Moisture problems causing delays? KEEP YOUR SCHEDULE AND BUDGET ON TRACK WITH OUR DEHUMIDIFICATION SOLUTIONS.
&OHYHODQG 7ROHGR &DQWRQ
Proud of our new facilities to improve services to our customers and the community.
Maximizing Building Performance As Downtown Cleveland’s district energy provider, Cleveland Thermal offers businesses highly competitive thermal heating and cooling solutions that are more efficient than traditional energy sources and in-house HVAC systems. We help customers save money and achieve their environmental emissions targets.
Self-storage From a modeling perspective, a selfstorage property is very similar to an apartment property in that the value is usually based on a single year of income and expense. The vast majority of storage tenant leases are 30 days and actual tenant occupancy often is even shorter than an apartment tenant lease. But there are some differences and foremost among
To learn more visit www.clevelandthermal.com www.propertiesmag.com 41
them is the concept of running a business versus owning a real estate investment. A couple of examples help to illustrate this point. First, the majority of self-storage properties are smaller in size – nearly three-quarters in this sector are less than 20,000 square feet / 100 units. It’s very common for the owner to run these smaller properties – they collect the rents, pay the bills, take care of landscaping/snow plowing and deal with the routine maintenance needs. Whatever cash flow is left each month is theirs. Put another way, if an owner had to pay a management fee, incur personnel/maintenance costs and use service contracts, there would be little to no cash flow left over. A second example; many facilities have additional sources of revenue that have nothing to do with the actual real estate. Rather, the facility may sell moving supplies, have a U-Haul rental
business or offer actual packing and moving services. While the cash flow associated with these types of ancillary activities have nothing to do with the actual storage units, it can sometimes be hard to distinguish what is related to the storage units and what is related to the other side businesses.
Assisted living facilities The line between valuing incomeproducing real estate and valuing a business becomes even more blurred when dealing with an assisted living facility. Although there are tenants that are paying rent each month at this type of property, that rent covers much more than just that tenant’s occupancy of the premises. It also includes meals, round-the-clock medical care, personal services, laundry, housekeeping and transportation, among other items.
We’re Out to Clean Up This Town SWEEPING PRESSURE WASHING CONSTRUCTION SITES PARKING LOTS & DECKS WAREHOUSES SPECIAL EVENTS FLUSHING
330.798.9200 | WWW.BUCKEYESWEEPING.COM
Commercial, Institutional & Industrial Floor Covering Provider & Installer
Specializing in the healthcare marketplace with the highest quality & best service since 1989. We provide 24/7 service & installation. Call us today to take advantage of our trained in-house staff and extensive library of product information. Complete line of flooring including: Athletic Floors Resilient Flooring • Vinyl & Ceramic Tile • Carpeting
Call today for a FREE estimate! 4300 Brookpark Rd., Cleveland, OH 44134 • 216-595-0100 • Toll Free 888-271-8200 42
As a result, the concept of NOI, which is paramount in valuing incomeproducing real estate, gives way to the concept of Earnings Before Interest, Taxes and Depreciation (or EBITA) as a key metric in establishing value. The other key metric is the concept of a multiple – how many times EBITA that a buyer is likely to pay in order to receive that EBITA. For example, if the property has an EBITA of $500,000 and the buyer is using a multiple of four, they would be willing to pay $2 million or four times EBITA. Assisted living facility investors will also consider the sale of comparable facilities as a secondary approach to estimating value. In this instance, it is usually applied to the total number of beds, resulting in a “per bed” metric.
Car washes If assisted living properties blur the line between valuing income-producing real estate and valuing a business, car washes blast right through it. There are no tenants or leases but only customers that visit for very short periods of time. And with the newest generation of selfservice as well as fully automated car washes, there is very little payroll overhead. Similar to assisted living facilities, the value of a car wash is exclusively based on EBITA applied to a multiple. And while the values of sale comparables can be looked at, the valuation process leans heavily on EBITA and an appropriate multiple. As I said, my football playing career lasted exactly one season, the result of not exactly enjoying the nuances associated with the offensive guard position – especially when tipping the scales at 93 pounds and not being able to sit still for more than five seconds. But I had a much better appreciation for what I would be watching over the next several decades. The same goes for a real estate investor; understanding the nuances associated with the specific property sector will go a long way towards increasing your appreciation while helping to avoid getting sacked. P Alec Pacella, CCIM, senior vice president at NAI Pleasant Valley, can be reached by phone at 216.455.0925 or by email at apacella@naidaus. com. You can follow him on twitter @dausyouknow or on his blog at http://blog.sbequitiesinc.com. Properties | February 2019
Your llandscaping d makes k a powerful f l statement to existing and d prospective clients. Let our Grounds Maintenance Division keep yours in top condition all year long.
LANDSCAPE DESIGN | LANDSCAPE CONSTRUCTION LANDSCAPE MAINTENANCE | COMMERICAL SNOW REMOVAL SERVICES
GROUNDS MAINTENANCE DIVISION Professional | Dedicated | Experienced
www.hmlandscaping.com • 440-564-1157 • 855-GREEN06
Ask Us About HIGH DENSITY SPF Roofing!
ROOF REPAIR, MAINTENANCE & INSTALLATION FLAT, RUBBER & ROLLED ROOFS AMISH-OWNED
CALL OR TEXT 440-725-9672 FOR INSPECTION OF YOUR ROOF 5 STAR RATING @ BBB
FACTORY TRAINED & CERTIFIED
BOMA BUSINESS Exploring timely topics with BOMA members
Benefits of BOMA Membership roperty owners and managers should consider joining BOMA to take advantage of world-class education and training; award-winning publications, research and benchmarking data; and federal, state and building code advocacy that tirelessly protects the commercial real estate industry.
P
In 2018, BOMA made its voice heard on Capitol Hill, in Ohio, and by code officials. BOMA Greater Cleveland spearheaded the effort to counter a ruling by the PUCO that would have expanded their authority and strictly regulated commercial building owners who submeter and include utility fees to tenants. We are watching legislation to make certain that a landlord’s right to submeter impacts only residential and leaves commercial real estate alone. Through BOMA’s efforts during the last International Code Council (ICC) code cycle, properties saved approximately $6 a square foot, mostly in avoided costs. (BOMA Membership typically costs less than one cent per square foot.) BOMA International testified before Congress regarding modernizing and making permanent the Energy Efficient Commercial Building Tax Deduction, (179D), to offset the cost of energyefficient capital improvements. It also defended the Energy Star program from elimination to ensure continued access to free benchmarking tools and energysaving strategies. Locally, BOMA Greater Cleveland supports the Historic Preservation Tax Credit, educating legislators that rehabilitating buildings creates jobs and creates an influx of property, income and sales tax revenue. Also in 2018, BOMA offered worldclass professional development and education to support members’ growth. BOMA Greater Cleveland provided educational articles from members,
such as ‘How to Read Your Energy Bill like a Professional’ and ‘The Plumber Protects the Health of the Nation.’ The organization cohosted the Economic Forecast with IREM Northern Ohio. Its Suburban Section hosted a Stormwater Management Fee Credits presentation. Overall, BOMA presents a wide array of education programs, from in-person events to online learning opportunities, to help train new staff, solve operational problems and advance members’ careers. BOMA connects members to the best business network in the commercial real estate industry, while helping develop emerging leaders and new talent through scholarships, mentoring and leadership counseling. Through BOMA membership, individuals can connect with like-minded peers, collaborate on new ideas, share best practices and meet people who can help take careers to the next level. BOMA provides the tools and resources for members to improve the bottom line. It offers programs, tools and best practices to help evaluate and improve building operations, positioning properties for higher rental rates, tenant satisfaction scores and better performance in a competitive marketplace. Additionally, membership provides access to members-only discounts and rebates on air filters, electricity, natural gas, lamps and ballasts, paint supplies and Home Depot purchases. P To learn more or join, visit Bomacleveland.org or call Janice Parham at 216.575.0305.
5528 Mayfield Road Lyndhurst, OH 44124 (440) 449-2650 www.snowappliance.com www.propertiesmag.com 45
Welcome Home Downtown luxury doesn’t have to mean downsized living. Experience the impressive suites, classic architecture, convenient lifestyle and exciting nightlife of the Playhouse Square Theater District when you call Residences at Halle home. Professionals, couples, families and alike are drawn to the luxurious spaces and modern amenities of Residences at Halle. One-, twoand three-bedroom suites range from 865 to 1,535 square feet and two-bedroom penthouses from 1,335 up to 3,070 square feet the perfect way to experience downtown living without sacrificing space. Your new home is waiting LIMITED SUITES REMAINING!
Built-In Advantages Residences at Halle puts a premium on your convenience with a 21,000 square foot Amenity Center on the lower level. Yours Truly Restaurant is located on the first floor. Connectivity will be a breeze with access to the highest speed wireless internet available in the Amenity Center and all first floor commons areas. You’ll never have to brave the elements again to get to your car thanks to the Halle Parking Garage connected through a well-lit underground tunnel.
Classic Architecture with Six-Story Center Atrium & Modern Amenities » 1st Floor Lobby Area Retail Space Available: 1,042 sq. ft. to 1,231 sq. ft. » All suites are brand new construction » Fireplace in the living room of all suites » Luxury gourmet kitchens with smudge-free stainless steel ENERGY STAR appliances, double oven (most suites), beverage center, and flat cooktop » Granite countertops with farmhouse sinks » In-suite washer and dryer » Light maple-colored hard surface flooring and carpeted bedrooms » Ceramic tile floors in bathrooms » Expansive new windows » Chandelier in the foyer and crown molding » Energy-saving LED lighting throughout » Individually controlled high efficiency heating and air conditioning » Amenity Center on the 21,000 square foot lower level includes: • Largest private Fitness Center downtown at 7,000 sq. ft. open 24/7 with locker rooms and showers • A 6,240 sq. ft. Community Center • A 7,620 sq. ft. Conference Center that holds up to 200 people, with kitchen, restrooms, and smaller conference room » Yours Truly Restaurant, convenience store and salon on the first floor » Highest-speed wireless internet available downtown » Attached parking garage through underground tunnel » Amazing location in the heart of the Playhouse Square Theater District and within walking distance of sporting venues, restaurants and everything downtown has to offer » Secure elevator access for residential floors » Controlled access entry and security on-site 24/7 » Online rental payment and maintenance requests
RESIDENTIAL LEASING INFO: 833.595.4162 COMMERCIAL LEASING INFO: 216.658.8394 1228 Euclid Avenue | Cleveland, Ohio 44115
www.ResidencesAtHalle.com
Revitalizing a Cleveland Landmark K&D Group converts historic former department store into Residences at Halle By Carlo Wolff | Photos courtesy of The K&D Group
ow that the Residences at Halle are complete and nearly fully leased, K&D Group principals Karen Paganini and Doug Price are more than satisfied. Four years ago, when they bought the former Halle Building in Playhouse Square, they thought the $15 million asking price was a bit much.
N
They look at the project differently now that they’ve upgraded the structure through a large-scale adaptive re-use and historic renovation effort, loading it with what they say are the largest apartments in downtown Cleveland. As of mid-January, the 122 Residences at Halle were seven short of being fully leased. In addition, the building, a 392,000-square-foot amalgam of office, commercial and residential, has been restored, not to its former glory as the city’s swankiest department store, but instead to a new and unique level of elegance. The Residences at Halle aims to appeal to empty nesters and families – including those who may recall it as the magical home of Mr. Jingeling, the “Santa’s helper” who made Christmases so special for children at Halle’s Department Store starting in the mid-1950s. A shrine to Mr. Jingeling occupies a corner of the seventh floor. Other souvenirs from a bygone era include a vintage shoe shine stand and jewelry cases, conjuring a time when downtown was a high-fashion, commercial magnet. Halle’s closed in 1982. Today, the lower five floors are commercial, the top six residential. Office tenants include the Republican Party of Cuyahoga County and Yours Truly on the first floor; the Cleveland Rape Crisis Center, high-speed internet provider Everstream and FM radio stations Q104 and WNCX on the second; and the Cleveland Teachers Union and IBM on the third. Occupying the fourth LIVING IN THE PAST K&D Group’s large-scale adaptive reuse project has outfitted the historic, floor is The NRP Group (landing a former department store with 122 newly appointed apartments. 10-year lease for its 40,000-square-foot space was the “finishing touch” of the nity center, and a 7,620-square-foot are on floors six through 10, while 12 project, Price says). Fay Sharpe LLP, a law conference center that can accommo- penthouses as large as 3,070 square firm, continues to occupy the fifth. The date 200 individuals with a kitchen, feet reside on the 11th. All the rental 12th and top floor is for mechanicals. bar and private meeting rooms. units are contemporary, with crown Occupying the lower level – formerly They’re open to use by every tenant moldings, ceilings averaging 15 feet in a food court – are a 7,100-square-foot in the building. height, high-speed internet, state-offitness center with locker rooms and One-, two- and three-bedroom suites, the-art kitchen appliances and washers showers, a 6,240-square-foot commu- ranging from 865 to 1,535 square feet, and dryers, and new, energy-efficient www.propertiesmag.com 47
Congratulations to K&D for preserving another historical landmark
Evolution Construction Services, LLC
is proud to have served as the Owners Representative for the
Historical Halle Building Project “In an ever evolving marketplace, we adapt to best serve your project needs.” 1717 East 9th Street #103 Cleveland, OH 44114 (440) 821-4333 jhounshell@evolution-construction.com Design/Build • General Contractors • Construction Management
Proud to serve K&D Group as Construction Manager for the Historic Renovation of the Residences at Halle
WE DON’T JUST RESTORE BUILDINGS... WE BUILD PARTNERSHIPS. Cleveland Construction, Inc. is a family, consisting of construction professional that are ambitious and passionate for restoring Cleveland. We develop long-lasting relationships with clients, trade partners and design professionals while restoring historic buildings throughout Cleveland. We own our responsibilities and are always there to deliver on our promise to MAKE IT TRUE®. See how our construction team is making it TRUE everyday at www.clevelandconstruction.com
Partners in Restoring Cleveland
You have the vision, we’ll
Tel: 440-255-8000 | www.clevelandconstruction.com 48
Properties | February 2019
CULTIVATING A CLASSIC Enriched marble surfaces on the walls and floors of the Halle Building provide an elegant, timeless atmosphere.
windows, many of them floor-to-ceiling. Rents are $1,300 to $4,500.
Setting the stage The Residences at Halle has been in the works for some time, Price explains. “It was more than we wanted to pay,” he says, noting Rico Pietro of Cushman & Wakefield called to tell him the Halle building was for sale. Their discussions culminated the night of a John Kasich fundraiser at Landerhaven. “I’m outside, we had somebody who was bidding against us, and we settled the deal that night over the phone, but we’d been working on it for over a year. “We reached a little higher than we wanted to, but now that we look back, it’s a no-brainer,” he adds. It was a “nobrainer” with a price tag: the funding stack for the conversion of the former department store to the Residences at Halle includes $29.5 million from Huntington Bank; $5.8 million from the Northeast Ohio Development Fund; $5.4 million from TriState Bank; $5.4 million from Brownfield
Revitalization; and $3.75 million from Foss and Company. The Brownfield Revitalization and NEODF money provides New Market Tax Credit allocations. State and federal historic tax credits also were instrumental in development of the project. When K&D took over the former Halle Bros. Co., it was only 40% occupied by office tenants, and the parking garage across Huron Road was in dire need of improvement. K&D accomplished this
transformation with long-time associates Berardi + Partners, a Columbus- and Cleveland-based architectural firm; general contractor Cleveland Construction, Inc.; and Jim Hounshell, owner’s representative, from Evolution Construction Services LLC, of Cleveland.
From the ground up The first order of business was improving the garage. For K&D to build 100 parking spaces and a ramp in what used
Mullin Bros. is thankful to have participated at Residences at Halle with carpentry & painting
Construction & Painting
1300 East 260th Street Euclid, OH 44132 Phone: 216-731-9070 mullinbros@sbcglobal.net www.propertiesmag.com 49
Photo courtesy of The Cleveland Memory Project/CSU Michael Schwartz Library
PROUD TO HAVE PROVIDED SPRINKLER SYSTEMS AT RESIDENCES AT HALLE
440.234.0700 | WWW.RMRIGGLE.COM 879 W. BAGLEY RD. | BEREA, OH 44017
Family Owned & Operated in Northeast Ohio Since 1903!
Cleveland Chemical Pest Control • Comprehensive, Integrated Pest Control • Pre-Treatment for Construction Sites/ Foundations • FHA/VA/HUD Termite Inspections, Treatments • Wild Animal, Bat Removal & Bird Control
18400 S. Waterloo Rd., Cleveland, OH 44119 | 216-481-8400
www.clevelandchemical.com Congrats to K & D on the renovation of the Halle Building. Thank you for letting Interfinish be a part of this success.
NEW FIT Improving the garage meant building 100 new spaces and a ramp in what used to be the Halle Bros. Co. men’s department, shown here in 1966.
to be the men’s department, it had to clear out what Price called “mountains of garbage. We cut the floor out, added the ramp and cleaned out the basement.” This was not a rebuild. “There wasn’t any parking access to the lower level,” Paganini says. “We were able to devise a good maintenance of traffic plan for our staging area on Huron Road that included temporarily re-striping the road to keep the flow of traffic in both directions,”
“We were well into the third phase before pulling the trigger on the apartment conversion because we had to get the tax credit, so for two years, we ran it as a commercial project.” Doug Price The K&D Group
216-662-6550 www.interfinish.net 9500 Midwest Ave., Suite 100 Cleveland, Ohio 44125 50
says Greg Dalpiaz, project manager for Cleveland Construction. “The city of Cleveland also allowed us to shut down numerous parking meters that would have prohibited the flow of traffic during the construction period. There was a challenge on most mornings because the Wyndham Hotel next door received large deliveries most days of the week, but we were able to work through those with our vendors/subcontractors to keep our construction deliveries on track.” Those weren’t the only issues. Existing leases had to be modified and tenants Properties | February 2019
Photo by Ken Krych
RETAIL RELICS On the Euclid Avenue side of the first floor, a special display area includes artifacts from the past, such as a grand piano, photographs, furniture and original retail display cases.
including IBM and the teachers union had to be moved to the lower floors to make way for the apartments. “We were well into the third phase before pulling the trigger on the apartment conversion because we had to get the tax credit,” says Price, “so for two years, we ran it as a commercial project. We did the parking garage, leased out
more commercial space, and in year three, really started the apartment conversion.” Work on the Residences at Halle began in June 2018, ending mid-January 2019.
Opening up the building “The design focused primarily on how we could achieve the client’s vision of providing high-end market rate units
within an existing building that was largely vacated,” says Joe Berardi, principal of Berardi + Partners. “Once we began the design process, one of the features that was discussed at length was the potential to bring natural light into the units. A majority of the units are long and narrow, relatively speaking. By having the longer units, we had
www.propertiesmag.com 51
Congratulations to K&D Group! Proud to provide LED conversion & exterior RGBW lighting to façade at Halle building
Residences at Halle
New Construction 5HWURȴW ([LVWLQJ )L[WXUHV 'HVLJQ /D\RXW 3KRWRPHWULF /LJKW 6WXGLHV (QHUJ\ $QDO\VLV 3D\EDFN $QDO\VLV 5HEDWH 3URJUDPV
hank@pnrgs.com | pnrgs.com | 216.759.7674
!30(!,4 0!6).' !30(!,4 2%0!)2 3%!,#/!4).' #2!#+ &),,).' #/-0,%4% 3)4% #/.3425#4)/.
0!6 ) . ' ) . # s %XCELLENT QUALITY COMPETITIVE PRICING RELIABILITY
%8#!6!4)/. 4/ #/-0,%4)/.
s #UNNINGHAM 0AVING IS A FAMILY OWNED BUSINESS WITH OVER YEARS OF EXPERIENCE s ,ICENSED BONDED INSURED s /UR MOTTO h+EEPING OUR CUSTOMERS SATISFIED KEEPS THEM COMING BACK v
* iÊӣȰxn£°nÈää >ÝÊӣȰxn£°nÈnÎ !URORA 2OAD 7ARRENSVILLE (EIGHTS /( 52
Properties | February 2019
LIVING WELL Each apartment suite includes a living room fireplace (top), granite kitchen counters and farmhouse sinks (middle) and newly carpeted bedrooms (bottom).
Photo by Ken Krych
to discuss design opportunities, which led us to a skylight/atrium concept. The idea is that the skylight, along with the clerestory windows in the corridors, allows for natural light to filter into living spaces.” Creation of an atrium on the sixth floor required carving out parts of each floor from that level down. Removal of 300 wheelbarrow loads of concrete was required to accommodate a cross-hatched space framed by existing steel beams. “The sixth floor was the most challenging, not only because it was the first residential floor we constructed,
“The design focused primarily on how we could achieve the client’s vision of providing highend market rate units within an existing building that was largely vacated.” Joe Berardi Berardi + Partners but also because we installed a raised, three-foot-deep floor due to the entire fifth floor being occupied by [the Fay Sharpe] legal firm,” says Cleveland Construction’s Dalpiaz. “All-new cast iron plumbing was installed under the floor and tied into existing sanitary risers. It posed another challenge because we could not allow scissor lifts to operate on the raised floor sheeting, so all overhead work had to be performed off of ladders. We closely coordinated this process with K&D, who handled the raising of the four main elevator openings to accommodate the raised floor.” As a consequence of raising the floor, new windows, which replicate the unsalvageable originals, effectively became floor-to-ceiling. “That’s how we solved the problem of converting to apartments without www.propertiesmag.com 53
PRESERVING HISTORY Restorative work in the elevator lobbies (left) included preservation of plaster ceilings, column capitals and original fountains (right).
having to go into the law firm and cut their space open,” Price says. Because the existing concrete-andframe complex was built in pieces, its construction changed, says Price. Over time, there were two vertical additions to the original building completed in 1910, although records of exactly when these were added could not be established. At one time, the roof was sloped for water runoff, but when the 11th floor was added, “they just busted through both sides to flatten the roof out,” Price
says. “So when we got there – surprise, surprise – we had fire penetrations everywhere. We had to spend an extra couple of hundred thousand dollars to drywall a sub-ceiling for fire stoppage before [building] the regular ceiling.” “There was one horizontal addition on the east side, another on the west, and then the vertical addition,” says Isaac Lewin, principal of structural engineering firm I.A. Lewin and Associates. “Because of that, there were old and new types of steel throughout. Some of the older designs were not
exactly what we thought but we dealt with that. On the sixth floor, we used a light-gauge steel frame to raise the floor to facilitate the plumbing systems. In the commercial areas, we placed heavier-gauge concrete plank construction for more support because of great loads and we had to do a bit more extensive work on the façade due to new City of Cleveland requirements.” Cleveland Construction built the residential floors from the bottom up, and the atrium from the top down. The team put shoring under the atrium area on
NorthStar Title Services Congratulates The K & D Group on The Residences at Halle! Proud to Provide Title Insurance and Escrow for The Residences at Halle & Proud to Call Cleveland Our Home! 1406 W 6th Street, Suite 400 Cleveland, Ohio 44113 www.nstitle.com | 216-623-3655
54
Properties | February 2019
each floor before the concrete was sawcut and removed, Dalpiaz says. Ironically, one big issue was the residential trash chute, he says. “The proposed location was in an existing shaft that, upon exploratory demolition, held a 53-inch round steel plate incinerator flue that went from the sub-basement up through the roof,” he says. “With no real sensible alternative for the trash chute location, it was determined that the existing flue was structurally sound and able to be re-used as the trash chute. Hopper doors were cut in on each floor and the bottom of the flue was modified to funnel debris into the new trash compactor.” The trash chute example shows that in this type of project, a contractor is “likely to uncover certain conditions and
Congratulations to K&D Group on the completion of The Residences at Halle
“[A contractor is] likely to uncover uncertain conditions and building features that are unexpected and pose challenges, and which need to be resolved quickly to keep the flow of construction moving.” Greg Dalpiaz Cleveland Construction building features that are unexpected and pose challenges, and which need to be resolved quickly to keep the flow of construction moving,” Dalpiaz says. Inside and out, efforts were made to preserve details of the original construction, he says. “For the interior of the building, the detailed plaster ceilings in the elevator lobbies and plaster column capitals had to be preserved/restored if the existing condition allowed for it,” he says. “For the exterior, we replaced a good number of missing and damaged terra cotta pieces, some more ornate than others.” K&D made efforts to preserve many of the items found during demolition. On the Euclid Avenue side of the first floor, a special display area includes artifacts from the past, such as a grand piano, photographs, furniture and original retail display cases. Remnants of the past also echo in original water fountains with a nautical theme, which have been preserved.
2008-2015
www.propertiesmag.com 55
EXTRA AMENITIES Residents enjoy access to a first-floor commons area (top), a 7,620-square-foot conference center (middle) and a private 24/7 fitness center.
Providing a contemporary touch, a new chandelier featuring approximately 3,000 crystals hangs in an area nearby.
Welcome to a very big home
Photo by Ken Krych
On the residential floors, the vibrant hallway palette of blue, green and gold contrasts with the more subdued, more earth-toned colorways inside the residences. Units, even the one-bedrooms, feel large. In a three-bedroom apartment of about 3,000 square feet, the kitchen space opens to a dining area that invites homeowners to effortlessly segue from the kitchen to the dinner table to a potential dance floor, leading to a huge window with a direct view of FirstEnergy Stadium. With its high ceilings and vast expanses, these places give you room to move. Partitions are minimal and the spaces flow. Extra-wide moldings, solid wood double-paneled doors, electric fireplaces, broad mantels and built-in farmhouse sinks provide a luxurious touch, while kitchens are outfitted with Frigidaire appliances. The laundry room features a Samsung washer and dryer.
Another successful pairing Above all, the building is newly dynamic and vital. Owner’s representative Jim Hounshell, of Evolution Construction Services, says he considers this – his fifth project with K&D, Berardi + Partners and Cleveland Construction – as a favorite. “Mr. Jingeling was a part of my childhood,” Hounshell says. “My parents took my brothers and me to see him when we were young and it’s a place in my heart I’ll never forget. The first floor has endless beauties, such as the gold leaf ceilings and enriched marble surfaces on the walls and floors, and the elevators are a thing of beauty and elegance.... K&D gave everyone on our team and hundreds of professional tradesmen another opportunity to be a part of another unique K&D project and we are all very humbled for that opportunity.” P 56
Properties | February 2019
Quality Products & Services Since 1933
Distributor of Construction & Restoration Products Sealants • Waterproofing Architectural Panels • Air Barriers Concrete & Masonry • Safety Products
13320 Enterprise Ave., Cleveland, OH 44135 1-800-969-1754 www.rlwurz.com DOWSIL is a registered trademark of The Dow Chemical Company
Author Matt Handal will lead a three-step workshop designed to give you new insights into your clients’ decision process and help you leverage science-based tactics to create more compelling proposals. Join us on Tuesday, April 9ƫNjŤŢţūNjfrom 7:45am-12pm at Oswald Conference Centr in Cleveland. For more information or to register for the event, visit smpsneo.org. SPONSORED BY:
www.propertiesmag.com 57
The Devilish Details The importance of the fine print in your construction contracts By Jeffrey A. Brauer and Matthew K. Grashoff Hahn Loeser & Parks LLP
hen you call your lawyer about a real estate, construction or architectural issue, the first question you hear will likely be, “Can you give me the names of the owner, the general contractor, the important subcontractors and the architect?” Next, your lawyer is going to ask to review the contract at issue. If you have been down this road before, you already attached the document to an email so you can just press send. The contract appears on your lawyer’s screen and you hear keystrokes as your lawyer pages through it.
W
The lawyer probably has a few questions about the scope of work and payment history, but soon you will hear the familiar clicks of your lawyer advancing to the back of the contract or the back side of the purchase order. If it sometimes seems like lawyers are more interested in the fine print than in the big picture, it’s because often they are. Why is that? It is because the impact of this small print is anything but small. Here is where you will often find boilerplate language that can be overlooked. The term boilerplate comes from metal printing plates that were distributed to small, local newspapers with advertisements and syndicated content already prepared. The papers could insert some original content, but most of the content could not be changed. These plates looked like rolled steel used for making boilers. This term worked its way into construction contracts and many contractors now dread reading the SUPERIOR INSULATING
other state law, governs the contract. Construction professionals often assume, sometimes wrongly, that contract law is basically the same from state to state. Outside of the construction context, provisions such as this often are enforced. In many construction contracts, however, there is a wrinkle. The Ohio Fairness in Contracting Act, R.C. 4113.62(D)(1), provides that any provision in a construction contract for a project located Jeffrey A. Brauer Matthew K. Grashoff in Ohio that makes the contract boilerplate. Indeed, many construction subject to the laws of another state is professionals focus little energy on these void and unenforceable. Note, however, details, but construction lawyers know that “construction contract” is specifithat these devilish details can be very cally defined, and limited to contracts important. Here are a few considerations or agreements for the design, planning, when reviewing boilerplate. construction, alteration, repair, maintenance, moving, demolition or excavation What law governs? of a building, structure, highway, road, As part of the boilerplate, a contract appurtenance or appliance situated on will ordinarily state its “choice of law.” real estate located in Ohio. While this This will say that Ohio law, or some sounds broad, some agreements that
SAFETY & SECURITY
ENERGY CONSERVATION
DECORATIVE
www.SunrayFilms.com
800.295.8468
A Female & Minority Owned Company “It’s Always a Sunny Day at Sunray!”
58
Authorized Dealer & Applicator
Properties | February 2019
Legal Services + Risk Management relate to construction projects are not within this definition.
What am I missing? As important as what is written in the contract, equally important are obligations that are outside the four corners of the contract. Frequently, construction contracts include “flow-down” provisions which obligate the contractor to mirror the contractual obligations upstream. Other times, contracts will incorporate proposals and other documents into the scope of work. These innocuous provisions can create obligations regarding almost every aspect of a project, including timing of payment, submission of change requests, duties to obtain insurance and bonds, and lien rights. When you are considering your obligations under a contract, you need to know what other obligations have been incorporated into that contract from other contracts or documents and, if there are such obligations, obtain copies of what is missing.
property initiated, proximately caused by, or resulting from its own negligence is void. Moreover, an overly broad indemnity provision which seeks indemnity for the indemnitee’s own negligence might be entirely unenforceable under Ohio case law, unless anti-indemnity concerns are
Many construction professionals focus little energy on [boilerplate language], but construction lawyers know that these devilish details can be very important. carved out. This means that an indemnity agreement must be carefully reviewed. Insurance is obviously a complex topic, but there are two priorities with regard to insurance on a project. First, you must work carefully with your insurance professional so that the risk assumed under
the construction contract mirrors the coverage that you obtain from your carrier. Second, you need to confirm that the insurance coverage that you base your business decisions on is actually in place. For instance, when attempting to confirm that a lower tier contractor has added an upper tier contractor as an additional insured on the lower tier’s insurance policy, many construction professionals end the analysis at getting a certificate of liability insurance. But a certificate of liability insurance often includes the disclaimer that the certificate “is issued as a matter of information only and confers no rights upon the certificate holder.” A best practice is to get the actual declaration page and a copy of the additional insured endorsement, not just a certificate.
How have the parties addressed payment and performance risk? Insurance is playing a lesser role in dealing with conventional construc-
What about risk of the unexpected? In most situations, one of the biggest concerns after defining the scope of work is allocation of risk. Risk comes in many forms, including the risk of the unexpected, such as an injury on site, which differs significantly from conventional business risk. This means that you need to carefully review the indemnity and insurance provisions and understand the roles they play. For unexpected risk, the primary tools are indemnity and insurance. Indemnity provisions are often challenging as even the terms indemnitor and indemnitee are hard to understand. In most construction-related issues, lower tier contractors (usually the indemnitors) will indemnify upper tier contractors (usually the indemnitees) from negligence claims for which they are responsible. But these agreements are not as simple as they may seem. Ohio, like many states, has an Anti-Indemnity Statute, R.C. 2305.31, which provides that a contract in connection with or collateral to a construction contract by which a party seeks indemnity for damages arising out of bodily injury or damage to
YOUR INDUSTRY IS OUR BUSINESS.
At Hahn Loeser, our Construction Team members are recognized as industry leaders by Chambers USA ®, Best Lawyers® and Super Lawyers® :H R̆HU RXU FOLHQWV
exceptional strength, leadership and industry knowledge, and with the recent addition RI -H̆ 5RXVK 'LUHFWRU RI &RQVWUXFWLRQ 6HUYLFHV RXU LQVLJKW LQWR \RXU QHHGV FRQWLQXHV WR JURZ 2XU UHVSRQVLYH WHDP RI KDUGZRUNLQJ SURIHVVLRQDOV LV FRPPLWWHG WR VHHNLQJ outstanding results for our clients around the corner and across the country. :H DUH UHDG\ WR PDNH WKH GL̆HUHQFH IRU \RX
ROB REMINGTON, ESQ. | Construction Group Chair | rrr@hahnlaw.com ANDY NATALE, ESQ. | anatale@hahnlaw.com JEFF BRAUER, ESQ. | jabrauer@hahnlaw.com AARON EVENCHIK, ESQ. | aevenchik@hahnlaw.com JEFF ROUSH | Director of Construction Services | jroush@hahnlaw.com
Hahn Loeser & Parks LLP | hahnlaw.com 200 Public Square | Suite 2800 Cleveland, OH 44114 | 216.621.0150 CLEVELAND | COLUMBUS | NAPLES | FORT MYERS | SAN DIEGO | CHICAGO CLEVELAND | COLUMBUS | NAPLES | FORT MYERS | SAN DIEGO | CHICAGO
www.propertiesmag.com 59
tion business risk in Ohio. Recent Ohio court holdings suggest that, absent specific coverage terms, a conventional Commercial General Liability (CGL) policy might not cover certain construction business risks. For example, the Ohio Supreme Court recently held in Ohio Northern University v. Charles Construction Services, Inc. that a general
contractor’s CGL policy does not cover “property damage caused by a subcontractor’s faulty work[.]” This means that other methods of addressing risk must be carefully administered. As has always been the case, the inclusion of payment and performance bond obligations are critical on any construction contract. But keep in mind
Experts In Exterior Masonry Repair & Restoration
McMahon Masonry Restoration Brick + Stone Repair & Replacement Caulking | Tuckpointing | Sealing Pressure Washing | Building Cleaning 9449 Brookpark Rd. Unit A, Parma, OH 44129 216-778-9666 | Fax 216-661-4520 | mcmahonrest1@att.net
Call for Your Free Building Inspection & Assessment
CELEBRATING
17
OF COST SEGREGATION
YEARS
2002-2019
ACCELERATE DEPRECIATION AND SHIELD INCOME TAXES NOW • Cost Segregation • Energy Efficiency Certifications (179D) • New IRS Repair v. Capitalization
Call Craig Miller
Cleveland 440.892.3339 / Columbus 614.949.4185 Detroit 248.752.7433 / www.costsegexperts.com
THE REGION’S LEADING INCOME TAX REDUCTION EXPERTS 60
that simply obtaining bonds is insufficient to manage the risks that bonds are meant to address. Construction professionals must review and understand the terms of those agreements. Bonds frequently have notice provisions with tight deadlines. In such cases, having copies of the bonds in hand is essential, because obtaining a copy of a bond in advance of demanding the surety’s involvement can delay the process by days or weeks.
How do I address disputes? Finally, your lawyer is going to want to understand how the parties agreed to resolve disputes. The parties must carefully negotiate the change order process. Likewise, key considerations are always whether there is a mechanism for claims to be unresolved but work to move forward (e.g. a construction claim directive). If your rights to additional time or compensation are waived absent a change order, then preserving a claim will likely be of the highest priority. If these processes fail, the parties must understand how disputes are to be resolved (litigation or arbitration) and what steps need to be taken in advance of any such action. If the first time you are reading the dispute resolution provision is after a dispute has happened, it can be challenging to go back and fix any steps that were missed. Pay close attention to the lowly boilerplate. When negotiating, make sure you read the boilerplate and negotiate those terms just as hard as you would any others. When you are bringing this to your lawyer’s attention after the project goes wrong, it will make the process go quicker. Either way, close attention to boilerplate is always a good idea. Your lawyer – and your future self – will thank you. P Jeff Brauer (jabrauer@hahnlaw.com, 216.274.2371) is a partner in the Construction Group of Hahn Loeser & Parks LLP and works in the firm’s Cleveland office. Matt Grashoff (mgrashoff@hahnlaw.com, 216.274.2205) is an associate in the Construction Group of Hahn Loeser & Parks LLP and works in the firm’s Cleveland office. Properties | February 2019
Legal Services + Risk Management
Understanding Your Loan Covenants - The Key to Compliance Once documents are signed & recorded, it’s the borrower’s responsibility to act in accordance By Danielle G. Garson McCarthy Lebit
ue to the intricacies and nuances involved in loan documents, borrowers often rely on their attorneys to ensure that the documents are negotiated in their best interest. Once the documents are signed and recorded, however, it the borrower’s responsibility to act in accordance with the covenants of the loan documents. Therefore, it is vital that borrowers understand their own duties so that they can stay fully compliant.
D
There are three common types of loan covenants: affirmative covenants, negative covenants, and financial covenants. An affirmative covenant instructs the borrower to take a certain action. For example, a lender may require that the borrower furnish quarterly financial statements, maintain a certain amount of insurance, or timely file its tax returns. Conversely, negative covenants prohibit or restrict the borrower from doing something. Limitations on additional indebtedness, the sale of company assets, and changes in the company’s line of business are all illustrations of negative covenants. Lastly, financial covenants are metrics and ratios used by lenders to measure the borrower’s financial performance. This allows the lender to determine whether the borrower
Danielle G. Garson
is financially sustainable and able to live up to its contractual commitments under the loan. There is a litany of different financial covenants,
but generally speaking, financial covenants are categorized as either balance sheet covenants or income statement covenants. Each covenant focuses specifically on a particular balance sheet or income statement item, or a ratio or calculation between two or more items. One common example is the debt service coverage ratio, which measures a borrower’s ability to pay off its debt obligations with its income. Usually, to calculate the debt service coverage ratio, take the company’s net operating income and divide it by the company’s total debt service. The total debt service is the entity’s debt or liability obligations that are due in the current year. Typically, a debt service coverage ratio above one means the borrower has sufficient income to pay its current debt obligations.
We Build Solutions. "oķ o 1-m 0 bѴ7 b|_ 1omC7;m1;ĺ
u ; r;ub;m1;7 Ѵ- ;uv 1ol0bm; 1olru;_;mvb ; Ѵ;]-Ѵ hmo Ѵ;7]; b|_ u;-Ѵ ouѴ7 0 vbm;vv ; r;ub;m1; |o _;Ѵr 1Ѵb;m|v v 11;vv= ѴѴ m- b]-|; 1oll;u1b-Ѵ u;-Ѵ ;v|-|; |u-mv-1ঞomvķ -v ;ѴѴ -v 7; ;Ѵorl;m| -m7 1omv|u 1ঞom ruof;1|vĺ
SM
Trusted Advisors. Respected Advocates. www.mccarthylebit.com
www.propertiesmag.com 61
Naturally, borrowers worry about their ability to run their business and simultaneously comply with the various provisions in their loan covenants. For example, volatility in a borrower’s financial performance may technically “trip” a covenant, putting the borrower in default, despite the fact that the company is otherwise financially sound. Further, the existence of a financial covenant may cause a borrower to not take an action that would otherwise be beneficial to its business. Whatever the case may be, it is vital for borrowers to fully understand what each specific covenant requires so that they can negotiate more favorable terms, financially strategize for the future, and anticipate a possible default before it occurs. It is important that borrowers carefully read loan covenants with their attorneys and their accountants before signing a loan agreement. It may seem rudimentary, but this allows the borrower to know exactly what it is signing
before it actually enters into the contract. Afterwards, it is the borrower’s duty to constantly monitor its business, especially with respect to its various financial
While loan covenants may seem intimidating, the reality is that they are nothing more than obligations that any borrower can enumerate, monitor and control on its own. Attorneys play a crucial role in negotiating, facilitating and securing commercial loans for their clients but, in the end, it’s the borrower’s obligation to understand and maintain the requirements of its own loan agreement in order to stay in compliance and plan for the future accordingly. P
It is important that borrowers carefully read loan covenants with their attorneys and their accountants before signing a loan agreement. It may seem rudimentary, but this allows the borrower to know exactly Danielle G. Garson is a principal at McCarthy what it is signing before it actually Lebit and can be reached at 216.696.1422 or dgg@mccarthylebit.com. She focuses her practice enters into the contract. in the areas of commercial real estate, business, covenants. As a practical matter, creating a checklist or spreadsheet with the company’s financial covenants is an easy and convenient way to oversee and manage the company’s operations and alleviate fears of future default.
corporate and banking law. Her real estate expertise encompasses a wide range of matters relating to the financing, acquisition, development, construction, leasing and disposition of retail, commercial and industrial property. She is also regularly involved in the representation of corporate entities in entity formation, contract negotiation, general business and commercial matters.
Space Comfort co. )$0,/< 2:1(' 23(5$7(' :,7+ +$1'6 21 (;3(5,(1&( ,1 0(&+$1,&$/ &2175$&7,1* 6$/(6 6(59,&( 6,1&( ([SHUWV LQ Q 7XUQNH\ VROXWLRQV GHVLJQ EXLOG YDOXH HQJLQHHULQJ Q 6HUYLFH LQVWDOODWLRQ PDLQWHQDQFH RI DOO PDNHV PRGHOV RI +9$& HTXLSPHQW ERLOHUV Q 1HZ UHQRYDWLRQ UHPRGHOLQJ UHVWRUDWLRQ Q 3XEOLF SULYDWH 3URYLGLQJ UHOLDEOH SHUVRQDO VHUYLFH WR RZQHUV RI UHWDLO FHQWHUV PDOOV DSDUWPHQW FRPSOH[HV UHWLUHPHQW KRXVLQJ LQ 2KLR QHLJKERULQJ VWDWHV
5201 CLARK AVENUE, CLEVELAND OHIO 44102 Q PH. 216-281-2000 Q FAX. 216-281-8420 Q 800-203-9645 62
Properties | February 2019
Legal Services + Risk Management
ACAR CORNER Issues in the real estate industry
What’s the Plan? Succession planning for real estate brokerages By Judy Gorbett Darwal Akron Cleveland Association of Realtors
any real estate firms are small businesses managed by one broker. What would happen to the firm and its listings if the managing broker was no longer able to serve in that role? Every firm should have an emergency succession plan in place to not only avoid disruption of its business but also to protect its assets and clients.
M
If the brokerage is a corporation and the corporation is a licensed entity, the process for making a transition to a new managing broker could be addressed in the corporation’s bylaws. However, in states where a corporation does not hold the real estate license or if the firm is a sole proprietorship or single member entity, a more elaborate plan is needed. A well-designed emergency succession plan will contain the following elements: 1) the name of a successor to the broker or a hierarchy of individuals to succeed the broker; 2) instructions about the location of current client files, escrow accounts and information about the brokerage’s licensees; 3) information about former client files, bank accounts, contracts, insurance policies and association/MLS membership information; 4) information about current liabilities; and lastly 5) information on how to access computer accounts, voicemail and other important passwords. Another issue the firm will need to address is how to handle pending transactions when the managing broker becomes incapacitated. How these transactions can be handled varies by state. Approximately 15 states have laws that allow for the appointment of an individual on a temporary basis to close transactions that are under contract or have offers pending and to terminate all other listing or buyer representation agreements.
In states without a statute or regulation, like Ohio, closing pending transactions may be more difficult. In some states, giving power of attorney to an appropriately licensed individual may be sufficient to allow the substitute broker to complete the transactions. However, not all state real estate commissions will recognize
Succession planning is an important issue for all real estate brokerage firms to consider. Having an emergency plan will help protect the firm’s clients and assets if the managing broker becomes unexpectedly incapacitated. another licensee taking over the clients of the former managing broker. In those instances, the new broker may need to have the clients transfer their listings to the new broker to complete the transactions. Brokers should discuss their options with their attorney when creating their emergency succession plan. Of course, most brokerages will not need to utilize an emergency succession plan when transferring its leadership from one broker to another. If the firm is having one broker succeed another at
the firm instead of selling the business, here are some best practices in succession planning: 1. Identify the individual or individuals who have the skills to lead the firm forward and confront the future challenges that the firm will face. 2. Expose candidates to all aspects of the brokerage’s operations so the individual has a good understanding of the firm’s business. 3. Once a successor is chosen, introduce the successor to all important individuals who are involved with the firm, whether it is the firm’s directors or other business partners. Succession planning is an important issue for all real estate brokerage firms to consider. Having an emergency plan will help protect the firm’s clients and assets if the managing broker becomes unexpectedly incapacitated. A planned succession will allow the firm to seamlessly transition existing business to a new business broker, but the process for transferring the listings will vary by state. P Judy Gorbett Darwal, broker/owner at RE/ MAX Trinity, is 2019 president of Akron Cleveland Association of Realtors. For more info, visit www.AkronClevelandRealtors.com. Information obtained from National Association of Realtors (www.nar.realtor). www.propertiesmag.com 63
WALTER | HAVERFIELD We are proud to be a part of Cleveland’s newest mixed-use districts.
Church+State “The Walter | Haverfield team did an excellent job simplifying a complex, difficult transaction. They aligned all of the involved parties and brought us to the closing table.” Michael Panzica, Hemingway Development
© LDA ARCHITECTS
Pinecrest “Walter | Haverfield is an extension of our team. Their collective expertise and knowledge of Cleveland’s real estate development space helped us streamline our work and allowed us to focus on what we do best.” Eric Louttit, Fairmount Properties
© CallisonRTKL
Leasing | Development | Urban & Historic Redevelopment | Tax Credit Transactions Real Estate Finance | Land Use & Zoning | Tech, Multi-Family & Shopping Centers CLEVELAND 216.781.1212 | COLUMBUS 614.246.2150 | walterhav.com |
Legal Services + Risk Management
Trending Topics A look at 3 key legal issues making waves within the commercial real estate community By Jack Waldeck, Jr. Walter | Haverfield
hile there are a number of legal topics currently trending within the commercial real estate community – several of which are covered in other articles in this issue of Properties – here’s a look at three particularly thorny issues facing the industry today.
W
These include 1) landlord rights in commercial tenant bankruptcies, 2) restaurant leases and 3) conservation easements.
are provided time to assert damages if the tenant rejects the lease. Landlords should be aware of these dates to ensure they file a proof of claim in a timely fashion.
Landlord rights in commercial tenant bankruptcies Commercial landlords have become familiar with the phrase “retail apocalypse,” a sobering term that refers to the recent epidemic of retail store closings. It is a trend that has resulted from companies filing for bankruptcy, and one that does not appear to be slowing. The Bankruptcy Code contains three key provisions landlords must understand as they navigate this dynamic landscape. Immediately after a tenant files for bankruptcy, an automatic stay is invoked to protect the tenant from collection activities. This action prevents landlords from initiating an eviction, changing the locks or demanding payment of pastdue rent. While it is possible to file a motion to seek relief from an automatic stay, landlords must be aware that the injunction still applies, even if the terms of the lease state the contract is terminated upon the filing of a bankruptcy case. Under Section 365 of the Bankruptcy Code, a tenant who files for bankruptcy may reject or assume the remainder of the lease. Often, the tenant will reject the lease for economic reasons. The landlord then becomes an unsecured creditor with a claim for damages. As such, however, they will likely receive less than the actual amount of the damages claimed. The tenant is still liable to the landlord
Restaurant leases
Jack Waldeck, Jr.
for rental payments that became due after the petition was filed and before the lease was rejected. It is clearly preferable to the landlord that the tenant assumes the lease, the premises remain occupied, and the tenant
While restaurants have shown resilience to certain aspects of retail ills, they can present problems for landlords who desire to keep traditional retail tenants happy. Odors, parking, noise and beer/wine service at restaurants present unique problems. To address the issue of odors and smoke coming out of hood exhaust pipes, scrubbers are and should be required, especially if there are residential components to the center. There is the potential for a very negative impact on leasing to residential tenants who experience smoke and odors penetrating their apartments adjoining restaurants. The cost of such installations may be a challenge to both landlords and tenants. Grease traps are a must in restaurant operations, and have been for a long time. There may be a desire by landlords for a multi-tenant grease trap installation. That’s so the landlord can be assured of the regularity of cleaning and maintenance that are required to ensure efficient operation of the grease traps. On the other hand, dividing up the costs of maintenance and replacement of the multi-tenant traps can be a headache since each tenant’s use and demand on the system can vary widely. Outdoor patio and seating areas are extremely common today. However,
Commercial landlords have become familiar with the phrase “retail apocalypse,” a sobering term that refers to the recent epidemic of retail store closings. It is a trend that has resulted from companies filing for bankruptcy, and one that does not appear to be slowing. agrees to be bound by the terms of the lease going forward. Finally, a proof of claim can be filed by a landlord if they are owed damages by a tenant. The landlord may not know the amount of damages to claim if the client has not yet decided to reject or assume the lease, so they
www.propertiesmag.com 65
they bring with them issues of liability, adequate insurance, controlled entrances, noise and rent charges, if any. All must be taken into account in lease negotiations. Finally, issues relating to the serving of beer, wine and spirits seem to never end. There are licensing matters, whether landlord or tenant control will ultimately control the liquor permit, and unique insurance products that must be accounted for.
Conservation easements Recent case law continues to show IRS pressure on the use of conservation easements as qualified charitable contributions. In one example, a conservation easement was donated which reserved to the landowner, if an eminent domain taking occurred, the value of any post-easement improvements built by the landowner. The IRS attacked this provision successfully (appeal expected), convincing the appeals court that this was an impermissible retention by the landowner of a right to “extinguishment proceeds” by the landowner. The deduction was completely disallowed. In another example, the court held that a golf course easement, which was syndicated, did not protect any of the required conservation purposes. The charitable deduction was completely disallowed. In the third example, also a syndicated easement transaction, the charitable deduction was completely disallowed because the Form 8283 required to be filed by the IRS in such transactions was not completed properly in that a blank space was intentionally left open (apparently on the advice of counsel). Put your experienced, professional team in place in advance of dealing with the issues discussed above. You will avoid surprises after the documents have been signed! P
1993-2019 | Schill Grounds Management 66
John (Jack) Waldeck, Jr. is head of the Real Estate team at Walter | Haverfield. He can be reached at jwaldeck@walterhav.com or at 216.928.2914. Properties | February 2019
zŽƵƌ ,ŝƐƚŽƌŝĐ tŝŶĚŽǁ ZĞƉůŝĐĂƟŽŶ WĂƌƚŶĞƌ ĨƌŽŵ ^ƚĂƌƚ ƚŽ &ŝŶŝƐŚ
ǁǁǁ͘ũĂŵŝĞƐŽŶƌŝĐĐĂ͘ĐŽŵ ͮ ϭϴϰϱ ĂƐƚ ϰϬƚŚ ^ƚ͘ ůĞǀĞůĂŶĚ K, ϰϰϭϬϯ ͮ ;ϮϭϲͿ ϲϮϭ ϰϮϳϳ www.propertiesmag.com 67
NAIOP NEWS Commercial real estate happenings
Opportunity Zones – Who Profits & How? he rollout of new specially designated tax-saving districts slated for development across the United States was unveiled as part of the federal government’s post-recessionary $1.5 trillion tax reform package announced in late 2017 as the Tax Cuts & Jobs Act. These so-called “opportunity zones” were set up to attract investments and stimulate economic growth in urban, suburban and rural areas where development has been stagnant.
T
RON DEGRANDIS
TAMMY GREBER
The U.S. Treasury issued proposed regulations in October 2018 to provide guidance on how the zones would operate, the types of investors permitted to participate and the types of projects that may qualify. In anticipation of the new rules, real estate investment firms, private equity firms, Silicon Valley and others have eagerly begun to raise capital for qualified opportunity zone (OZ) investment funds designed to take advantage of investments in projects targeted for these tax-saving areas. Depending on
the holding period, eligible capital gains from investments in a qualified OZ fund can avoid tax on up to 15% of the original gain and defer tax on the remaining original gain until the earlier of the sale of the fund or the end of 2026. RSM US LLP provides a run-down on how OZs work and the investors and sectors that stand to benefit. Q: What qualifies as an OZ and who has the authority to designate an area? RSM: OZs are low-income census tracts, which are areas with a poverty
EDUCATIONAL EQUIPMENT Serving Cleveland and Northeast Ohio Since 1936 We are specialists in: • Operable Panel Partitions • Accordion Doors • Chalk/Marker Boards • Bulletin Boards • Trophy & Display Cases • Signage • Directories SALES
INSTALLATION
SERVICE
845 Overholt Rd., P.O. Box 154, Kent, Ohio 44240 — Phone (330) 673-4881 Fax (330) 673-4915
www.educationalequipment.com 68
Properties | February 2019
Legal Services + Risk Management rate of 20% or more and a median family income of 80% or less of the areas’ median income. In addition, up to 5% of census tracts that are contiguous to an OZ may qualify, provided the median family income does not exceed 125% of the median family income in the nearby OZ. The governor of each state was allowed to designate up to 25% of these census tracks as OZs. Q: What type of investors qualify? RSM: The range of investors is quite broad. It may include individuals, C corporations, real estate investment trusts, partnerships and other pass-through entities, including common trust funds. It is important to note that in order to benefit from a qualified opportunity zone investment, these investors need to have recognized recent capital gains.
investment for 10 years, the basis of the OZ investment would be automatically adjusted to the sales prices since the original gain is recognized as adjusted for any reductions, resulting in no taxes paid on the sale of the OZ investment. As such, the best hold time for the investment to fully realize the tax benefits is 10 years. For a real estate investor, five-, seven- and 10-year hold periods are the norm and an easy sell to investors.
The rollout of new specially designated tax-saving districts slated for development across the United States was unveiled as part of the federal government’s postrecessionary $1.5 trillion tax reform package announced in late 2017 as the Tax Cuts & Jobs Act.
Q: How does the tax-savings work? Have you assessed what hold time is the best? RSM: The overall concept is one of deferral and partial forgiveness of capital gains tax. In addition, there are potential benefits upon the exit of the qualified opportunity zone investment. Let’s take an investor who recently sold some stock with a basis of $50,000 for $150,000, resulting in a capital gain of $100,000, which would normally be taxed that year. That investor has 180 days to decide to invest a portion or all of the $100,000 gain in an OZ investment, either directly or through an investment vehicle like a fund. At that point, any taxes on the gain are deferred until the OZ investment is sold or until 12/31/26 when it is deemed to be sold. Let’s assume our investor elects to invest all of the $100,000 gain. Now if the investor were to hold onto the OZ investment for five years, the gain would be reduced by 10% ($90,000). If the investor holds the OZ investment for seven years, the gain is reduced an additional 5% ($85,000). If the investor holds the
Q: What type of risk is associated with these OZ districts and are there strategies to mitigate it? RSM: The need for a 90% tangible asset and the 50% income to come from the OZ will be easy for real estate investors to meet. The initial risk is being able to make a qualified investment and required improvements, which means a dollar-for-dollar improvement in the tangible property, in time. Fortunately, the IRS recently released guidance that will make it
easier for real estate companies to meet this requirement. The IRS has stated that land is not included when calculating the basis of the tangible asset needed to be improved, thereby reducing the total cost of improvements. Furthermore, there is a safe harbor that allows for the initial investment and substantial improvement to occur over a 31-month period if a written development plan is provided. Once you have made the investment and substantial improvements required to qualify for the OZ investment benefits, the next biggest risk is helping investors with tax planning. If investments are held past 2026, there will be a tax due on the original gain (as adjusted for any reductions) at December 31, 2026. There is a high likelihood that this tax payment may not be aligned when the investors receive cash from the investments. It is important that anyone investing in OZs understands that this tax is coming and has a clear plan in place to handle this tax payment, likely through a financing or operating distribution. P
Tammy B. Greber, CPA is senior tax manager and Ron DeGrandis is partner of Tax Services with RSM US LLP. Greber can be reached by phone at 216.622.1387 or by email at tammy.greber@rsmus.com. DeGrandis can be reached at 216.522.1080 or email at ronald.degrandis@rsmus.com.
STRUCTURAL STEEL FABRICATORS & ERECTORS SINCE 1958
0DVRQ 6WHHO Contact Mike Smith for a Proposal: (440) 439-1040 | (800) 686-1223 7500 Northfield Rd. | Walton Hills, OH 44146 www.masonsteel.com Other Fine Products Available: Stone | Pavers | Fireplaces | Windows | Doors www.propertiesmag.com 69
VANTAGE POINT Experts weigh in on industry issues
Funding OZ Building Improvements here is growing interest in the redevelopment of existing buildings located in Opportunity Zones as a result of the new tax incentive created as part of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017. Any redevelopment plan must be carefully considered to determine if it will meet the specific requirements of the opportunity zone program.
T
MARIO FAZIO
The tax incentive generally allows a taxpayer to sell an asset and defer the payment of capital gains tax on the sale by reinvesting cash equal to the gain amount in a so-called Qualified Opportunity Zone Fund (“QOZ fund”). The deferral of the capital gain extends to the earlier of the sale by the taxpayer of the QOZ investment or 2026, whichever is earlier. Additionally, if the taxpayer holds its QOZ investment for at least 10 years, the taxpayer may sell the QOZ investment without incurring further capital gain on the appreciation of the investment. Generally, it is relatively straight-forward to create a QOZ fund by private parties and a fund may be created simply to reinvest in one or more buildings located in an opportunity zone. For these tax benefits to be realized by an investor, the QOZ fund must
meet certain requirements, including that substantially all of the QOZ fund assets consist of “qualified opportunity zone property.” Real estate, as well as tangible personal property, located in an opportunity zone generally qualifies provided it is either new when purchased by the fund, or “substantially improved” by the fund. One of the challenges for a QOZ fund is the requirement that a purchased building be “substantially improved,” which requires that the fund make additional capital improvements to the building at least equal to the fund’s acquisition cost for the building. For example, if a QOZ fund purchases a building for $400,000, the QOZ fund would need to make further improvements of an additional $400,000 within 31 months of purchase, making its total invest-
Subscribe Now & Save Over 80% Stay informed BCPVU the very best in construction and development in Northeast Ohio. Subscribe online or by phone at 216.251.8506. INSIDE : Cleveland
Clinic Rehabilitation
Hospital • AkzoNobel
lding uilding • Roofing/Buil
l pe Envelope Envel
INSIDE : SpringHill Suites Independence
• l • Hyatt Place at Legacy Village
Building een Building Green G INSIDE : MetroHealth Brecksville
Sepptember 2016/$7.95 September
7.95 2016/$7.95 April 2016/$7
INSIDE : Larry Health & Surgery Center
Sears and Sally
• Renova Renovation ation & Restoration
October ober 2016/$7.95
Zlotnick Sears think[box] at CWRU
• Phoenix Buildin
g
January 2016/$7.95
INDUSTRY LEADER SINCE 1946 Celebrating 70 Years Since 1946
Exclusive | Focused | Informative | Dependable | Connected
www.Propertiesmag.com 70
ld The Schofield ing ake Reshap awaakens Building Reaw historic h Renovation revives o new to structure as home n Hotel apartments, Kimpton
q Public Square $50 million public-private project brings renewed energy to ti
Encore Resurgence on Performan nce cee the
Restoration specialists re-create e-createe Ohio Theatre’s original lobby bby design at Playhouse Square are
Waterfront
Flats Ea Eastt Bank Phase Ph e II sprou sp ts new residential, t entertainment dining & ex i
Properties | February 2019
Legal Services + Risk Management ment $800,000. The amount of the additional improvements is computed only with regard to the fund’s cost in the building, exclusive of the land. Under Treasury Department proposed regulations, an existing building would have to be purchased through the QOF after 2017, be substantially improved within 31 months of purchase, and continue to be used by the QOZ fund in the opportunity zone throughout its ownership. There may be several ways to fund the improvements, depending on the plan for redeveloping the property. Where the building is purchased by the QOZ fund, the fund may raise capital investment or borrow from a third party to fund the improvements. This would be the case for a multi-tenant building, whether commercial or residential, or for a single tenant building where there is no tenant participation in financing the improvements. Alternatively, where the QOZ seeks a business tenant for the property, such as a manufacturer, the improvements may be a “build to suit” arrangement that takes into account the specific build-out plans of the tenant. The tenant improvements may be either landlord- or tenantfinanced, or some combination thereof. Landlord-financed improvements would typically qualify as additional investment by the landlord in the building and reflected on the landlord’s balance sheet as a depreciable real estate asset. If the improvements are tenant-financed, the tenant improvements would not qualify for the “substantial improvement” requirement for the landlord if the tenant is viewed as owning the improvements. For example, if the lease provides for the tenant to pay for some or all of the tenant improvements, the improvements might not be treated as owned by the landlord, because the landlord did not pay for the improvements and has no obligation to reimburse the tenant for the costs. If the goal is for the tenant improvements to be owned by the landlord to meet the substantial improvement requirement for the building but the
tenant will fund the cost of the improvements, the parties may wish to structure the funding of the improvements as a loan from the tenant to the landlord that will be repaid by the landlord in accor-
is uneconomical. For example, a building may be currently functional, or recently renovated, so that it does not need further substantial improvements. If this is the case, the building could not be qualified opportunity zone business property. However, the tenant, rather than the landlord, may seek to become a qualified opportunity zone business provided that substantially all of its assets are qualified opportunity zone business property that are used in the conduct of a business in the opportunity zone. Any tenant improvements and other new tangible personal property (such as equipment and office furniture) that are owned by the tenant and used in the business likely would qualify as opportunity zone property for the tenant. P
One of the challenges for a QOZ fund is the requirement that a purchased building be “substantially improved,” which requires that the fund make additional capital improvements to the building at least equal to the fund’s acquisition cost for the building. dance with a specific repayment schedule. Also, the lease should specify that the parties intend for the landlord to be the owner of, and entitled to depreciate, the tenant improvements. Furthermore, there may be circumstances where making additional substantial improvements to an existing building located in an opportunity zone
Mario Fazio is chair of the Business & Corporate and Tax practice groups at Meyers, Roman, Friedberg & Lewis. He can be reached at mfazio@ meyersroman.com or 216.831.0042.
Offering a Full Spectrum of Legal Services to Individuals and Business Clients of All Sizes )\ZPULZZ *VYWVYH[L )SVJRJOHPU *Y`W[VJ\YYLUJ` *VUZ[Y\J[PVU *YLKP[VYZ» 9PNO[Z )HURY\W[J` +VTLZ[PJ 9LSH[PVUZ ,Z[H[L 7SHUUPUN 3HIVY ,TWSV`TLU[ 3P[PNH[PVU 9LHS ,Z[H[L ;H_
28601 Chagrin Blvd., Suite 600 • Cleveland, OH 44122
^^^ TL`LYZYVTHU JVT www.propertiesmag.com 71
LEGAL PERSPECTIVES Navigating property laws & regulations
Building on Blockchain Considering potential applications in design & construction By Mark J. Stockman Frantz Ward LLP
great deal of attention has been focused on the emerging technology called “Blockchain” and its potential for bringing a massive change to how business is conducted. Just as the introduction of computers increased the speed and quantity of information that can be used in business, and the internet increased the availability of information, Blockchain technology is poised to greatly increase the trust parties have in digital information.
A
Legislators and business leaders are supporting the “Blockland Cleveland” initiative, focused on making Northeast Ohio a hub for Blockchain technology advancement. While the underlying Blockchain technology is already fairly developed, the initiative aims to put Northeast Ohio ahead of the curve on researching and designing the various industry-specific platforms that will run on Blockchain. The Ohio legislature recently passed Senate Bill 220, which recognizes that contracts created through Blockchain technology are legally enforceable. The increasing application of Blockchain technology in all areas of social and commercial life is inevitable. What exactly is “Blockchain technology” then, and how could its application change the way the real estate, architecture/engineering, and construction industries operate?
What is Blockchain? Blockchain is a software protocol that creates an electronically stored ledger that tracks the history of an asset. The asset can be tangible, such as land, a building, equipment, or currency; or intangible, such as patents or copyrights. It gets its name from the method it uses to 72
gram that runs on the operating system, such as Outlook.
Advantages of Blockchain
store data. Data is stored in a series of “Blocks,” and each new block is linked to the immediately preceding block to form a successive “Chain.” Blocks and Chains are replicated identically over multiple computer systems across a peerto-peer computer network, and the system records the time and sequence of each change to the chain, giving instant notice of changes and events to all participants. A network of participants all agree to the rules of a specific Blockchain system. Since 2009, digital currencies, or “cryptocurrencies,” such as Bitcoin have been utilizing Blockchain technology as their supporting platform. In those circumstances, Blockchain is akin to the “operating system,” such as Windows, and Bitcoin is akin to a pro-
The Blockchain records all transactions in its electronic ledger and makes a permanent record of this transaction history. The ledger is vastly more reliable than the communicating and recording systems we currently utilize because nothing is ever erased; information can only be added. The prior history of the asset is never obscured – there is only a new layer of information added. The shared record is the one, true, agreedupon record of the transaction. The shared ledger is also verified by replicating it identically across a network of multiple computers, decentralizing the location of the data. This verification process makes the information less vulnerable to tampering or hacks. The data is constantly compared, and an authorized change to one copy of the ledger is automatically made to all other copies. Any changes or tampering is immediately visible to all participants. Thus the Blockchain ledger: (1) remains consistent between all participants, (2) cannot be changed without immediate notice to all participants, (3) is decentralized and not controlled by any one participant, and (4) is fully available to all participants. It Properties | February 2019
Legal Services + Risk Management is inherently impossible for one party to manipulate the record to try to fool other participants into believing an untrue set of facts.
Design/construction applications As Ohio has already recognized, one of the most apparent applications in the design and construction industries is the utilization of smart contracts – a contract between parties where the provisions are stored and shared electronically using Blockchain technology. All parties can always see the current status of the agreement and all prior changes to the agreement, and all parties can follow a checklist of conditions that are required to be satisfied (such as completion of a certain task) in order to cause other provisions to be self-executing by the contract program (such as payment for that task) without any further action needed by the parties. Smart construction contracts would most likely be built of form provisions that are recognized as industry standards, much the same way as AIA documents or ConsesusDocs are already used as industry-accepted forms. But a smart contract running on Blockchain would actually be an active participant in the construction administration process, with the contract program itself verifying that certain tasks have been completed and then executing the next required steps. For example, a Blockchain smart contract could vastly streamline the construction payment process. All parties would agree in the smart contract to construction milestones and associated payments. As construction deliveries and completion are verified by the parties, payments could automatically be released. This payment process could essentially be continuous – with no need for payment applications to be limited to monthly requests. The smart contract could also track payments flowing from the owner/ lender though the GC down to subcontractors and materials suppliers, vastly speeding up payments to lower tier parties and reducing the likelihood of payment disputes and mechanics liens. A smart contract could control the visibility of the payment process, permitting
real time information to be universally available to the lender, owner, architect, general contractor, subcontractors and materials suppliers, and all parties would be able to track the flow of funds in real time with full trust in the veracity of details. Suppliers could verify the owner’s availability of funds right at the start of a project, and the checklist of conditions that lead to payment, and then count-
As Ohio has already recognized, one of the most apparent applications in the design and construction industries is the utilization of smart contracts – a contract between parties where the provisions are stored and shared electronically using Blockchain technology. down the satisfaction of those conditions to know exactly where they are in the payment process. Funds could be allocated at the beginning of the project in the exact amount of bids from each party providing materials, so all parties know their funds are available and that they only need to complete their end of the contract for payment to be automatically released.
This saves all of the parties’ time and money, and increases trust between them. For example, if all parties verify on the Blockchain ledger that all steel bar joists were delivered and correctly installed today, the program can send payment out to all parties for that task immediately. Payment could flow traditionally – first to the general contractor, then to the subcontractor and on to the material supplier, with nothing more being reported on the ledger than a verification that payment has been made. This would provide some confidentiality in each party’s price markup along the way. Or, the payment process could be completely transparent, with payment for steel joists being immediately split into multiple individual and smaller payments to each of the general contractor, subcontractor and material supplier with full transparency as to who gets paid what. A Blockchain-based ledger can also be used to speed up common construction tasks such as submittals, inspections, change orders, MEP system startup and adjustments, and other tasks requiring a chain-of-command process that could happen almost instantly with full and immediate notice to all project participants. A Blockchain-based ledger can
www.propertiesmag.com 73
Beachwood Fire Station #2 - Improving response times & firefighter readiness. %HDFKZRRG )LUH 6WDWLRQ ,PSURYLQJ UHVSRQVH WLPHV DQG ÀUHÀJKWHU UHDGLQHVV
Cleveland Toledo 419-865-7100 419-865-7100 Cleveland216-663-3777 216-663-3777 || Toledo www.infinityconstruction.com ZZZ LQÀQLW\FRQVWUXFWLRQ FRP
74
Properties | February 2019
Legal Services + Risk Management be integrated with the BIM process to provide an accurate list of required materials and quantities, which could permit more accurate apples-to-apples bidding, and which could ensure that all bids match exactly what is shown in the building design. Maintaining a single repository of information and the creation of industry standards could smooth out inconsistencies in construction transactions that have an international reach. Customs and currencies that vary between locations could be homogenized by setting up a system of purchases, transfers and payments that is internationally accepted. Transaction procedures similar to this protocol can be applied far beyond the pure construction context. Blockchain platforms are being rolled out to manage real estate leasing, carve up fractional real estate ownership interests into Bitcoin-like “tokens” that can be traded, and to facilitate building management, operations and record-keeping. All of these could even be integrated into one master development or project-based Blockchain protocol.
Challenges The obvious initial challenge is developing a base set of contractual agreements and standards that are universally accepted by all the parties to a typical construction project. This is compounded by the expected cultural lag-time that it would take for everyone from the multi-billion dollar mortgage lender down to the local landscaper to buy into, test and embrace the process. And, a new Blockchain record is only as good as the data that is input into it. If the information gathering can be automated by common industry-wide protocols, a very user-friendly system can hopefully be developed where the participants are passive users of a welldesigned system, and aren’t apt to avoid the system because they feel burdened by having one more layer of required recordkeeping to contend with. The building design and construction industries are poised to transform tremendously with the imminent adoption of Blockchain technology. Flow of information is the foundation of the industry
and many of the issues and inefficiencies in construction transactions can be remedied by having an accurate, absolute and shared archive of information. Implementing Blockchain technology has the potential to reduce transaction risks and the costs of mitigating those risks, such as information discrepancies, lack of uniformity and fraud. With the momentum of the Blockland initiative, Northeast
Ohio has the opportunity to capitalize on this technological innovation to facilitate advancement of the adoption of innovative Blockchain-based procedures within the design and construction industries. P Mark J. Stockman (mstockman@frantzward. com) is a partner in the Construction Practice Group at Frantz Ward LLP in Cleveland. For more info, visit FrantzWard.com.
SINCE 1972
Façade Inspection | Tuckpointing/Caulking Pressure Washing | Brick & Stone Repair/Replacement 216.881.4142 | 4408 St. Clair Avenue | Cleveland, Ohio 44103 www.hmhrestoration.com
:ȝ &Ȫ8ȫ+ 2ȭ5 &ȧ0Ȩ(Ȭ,Ȭ,ȧ1
COMMERCIAL, RESIDENTIAL & INDUSTRIAL DEMOLITION ASBESTOS SURVEYS & ABATEMENT • WRECKING
CAREY DEMOLITION 216-881-0608 | www.careydemolition.com 2695 E. 55th St. | Cleveland, OH 44104 www.propertiesmag.com 75
Risk of New Construction: Mechanics’ Lien Coverage Overview for Ohio By Chris Brooks First American Title Insurance Company
wners of commercial real estate properties and land in Ohio face a risk in new construction – mechanics’ liens. Understanding mechanics’ liens and Ohio laws can help to minimize these risks.
O
A mechanic’s lien is a statutorily created security interest in the title to real property for the benefit of contractors, subcontractors and others that have worked on – or supplied labor or materials to – real property. In Ohio, a mechanic’s lien is filed in the real estate records against the land. The value of the lien is equal to the contract value of the work, materials and/or labor furnished (less any payments). So, who is entitled to a mechanic’s lien anyway? Basically, every person who performs work or labor or furnishes materials is entitled to a lien. Ohio law states that “every person who performs work or labor upon or furnishes material in furtherance of any improvement undertaken by virtue of a contract, express or implied, with the owner, part owner, or lessee of any interest in real estate, or their authorized agent, and every person who as a subcontractor, laborer, or material supplier performs any labor or work or furnished any material to an original contractor or any subcontractor (i.e., a sub of a sub), in carrying forward, performing or completing any improvement, has a lien to secure the payment therefore upon the improvement and all interests that the owner, part owner, or lessee may have or subsequently acquire in the land or leasehold to which the improvement was made or removed.” O.R.C. §1311.02. The priority of a mechanic’s lien in relation to the priority of a mortgage will depend on 1) the date and time construction first started, or materials or equipment were first delivered; 2) the date and time the mortgage was filed for record; and 3) whether a Notice of Commencement was recorded and, if so, the date and time of its recording. At First American Title National Commercial Services, we work with 76
our clients to understand their business needs. Our team conducts extensive analysis to determine the degree of risk posed by a possible loss of priority of a contemplated construction mortgage in relation to potential mechanics’ liens and formulates the most appropriate title insurance coverage approach. While every deal is different, there are several factors considered during the underwriting of a construction loan when priority is lost or uncertain, and there are multiple methods of providing valuable title insurance coverage depending on the applicable facts and circumstances. We know how to structure customized title coverage for large and complex commercial real estate transactions. To best serve our clients, the following is a typical list of items that may be required: • Construction Contract • Loan Agreement • Form of Mortgage • Loan Guarantees
• Construction Budget and Sources and Uses of Funds • Owner’s and Contractor’s Affidavits • Lien Waivers from all parties supplying work, labor and material to date • Indemnity Agreement from a financially secure source This list is meant to be a guide and does not mean that all this documentation will be required. Minimizing risks in new construction from an underwriting perspective involves a strong grasp of Ohio law and an extensive analysis of the transaction. First American Title’s underwriters are experienced and can help you navigate the complexities of today’s commercial real estate transactions. P This article is paid advertorial. Chris Brooks is vice president and counsel with First American Title Insurance Company, National Commercial Services. He can be reached at 216.241.8500. For more information, visit www.firstam.com. Properties | February 2019
THE PROPERTY TAX MAN COMETH. WE KNOW HIM WELL.
WE KNOW HOW TO GET RESULTS BECAUSE WE KNOW PROPERTY TAX LAW. We are THE TVSTIVX] XE\ PE[ ǻVQ .XƶW ALL we do, with more than 40 years of experience and BILLIONS in assessment reductions.
GET A NO-COST NO-FEE REVIEW OF YOUR TAX ASSESSMENT.
The DEADLINE to contest your Ohio assessment is March 31, 2019. A proactive approach allows us to make your best case.
Contact J. Kieran Jennings today at: 216-763-1004 X kjennings@siegeltax.com www.siegeltax.com
SIEGEL BOLD JENNINGS RESULTS P R O P E R T Y TA X L AW
23425 Commerce Park Drive, Suite 103 ◆ Cleveland, OH 44122 ◆ Founding Member, American Property Tax Counsel (APTC)
Legal Services + Risk Management
Intangible Assets and Your Property Tax Assessment Be aware of use of the total asset purchase to set real estate tax value By Cecilia J. Hyun Siegel Jennings Co., L.P.A.
ave you received your real estate tax bills recently? First half taxes are now due for Ohio property owners, prompting many to review the assessments on which their real estate taxes are based.
H
If you recently bought your property, your sale price may be the basis of your property tax assessment. If you bought other assets along with the real estate, the value of those other items should not be included in property tax assessment. For example, if you purchased personal property like equipment with the real estate, the value of the personal property should not be included in your property tax assessment. Ohio Supreme Court affirms nonreal estate assets should be removed from assessment in Harrah’s Ohio Acquisition Co., LLC v. Cuyahoga Ct. Bd. of Revision, Slip Opinion No. 2018-Ohio-4370 In a case involving the Thistledown Racino, the Ohio Supreme Court recently affirmed the principle that personal property value should not be included in your real estate tax assessment, even when those assets are intangible personal property like licenses. Thistledown, a casino and racing property located in Cuyahoga County, is a 128acre horse racing facility that includes a racing track, barns and an eight-story grandstand. The owner, Harrah’s Ohio Acquisition Company, bought the racetrack and related assets in a bankruptcy-related sale for a total of $43 million for the combined assets. A couple of years after purchase, Harrah’s received a video-lottery-terminal license (VLT) from the State of Ohio. There have been a number of appeals over the property tax assessment since Harrah’s purchase. The one involved in
Cecilia J. Hyun
this most recent decision was initiated when the owner sought a reduction in its assessment. Both the owner and the local school district engaged appraisers, and the school district sought to increase the value of the property. Neither party relied on the $43 million sale price,
the business and then deducted the value attributable to non-real property, e.g. tangible personal property, value of VLT license, etc., to arrive at the value for real property. The school district argued the owner’s appraiser was wrong to separate out the value of the VLT licenses (or more precisely, the opportunity to acquire such licenses) because they were indistinct from the real estate and therefore, they could not be valued separately. In support, the school district compared the licenses to zoning laws, arguing that the license simply dictated permissible use of the real estate, but did not create separate personal property. The Ohio Supreme Court rejected this argument, finding that the exercise of the government’s power through zoning and licensing were sufficiently distinguishable. The school district’s second argument was that the VLT license could not have a separate value because it could not be transferred or retained separately from the real estate. This argument was likewise rejected, both with respect to the acquisition of the property itself, and in the use of the sales of comparable properties to help determine the property’s value. It was undisputed that the possibility of obtaining a future VLT license from the state was critical in the owner’s purchase of the property. The purchase of the property then gave Harrah’s the chance to obtain a VLT license sometime in the future. The court did not find any error in putting a value on the intangible asset, i.e. the
If you recently bought your property, your sale price may be the basis of your property tax assessment. If you bought other assets along with the real estate, the value of those other items should not be included in property tax assessment. instead relying on the value of their respective appraisers. Intangible assets do not have to be divisible from the underlying real estate or separately transferable to have a distinct value The property owner’s appraiser assessed the value of the entire going concern for
www.propertiesmag.com 79
COMMERCIAL & INDUSTRIAL RIAL ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS OH LIC #21927
SERVICE Upfront Pricing • Trouble-Shoot & Repair NEW CONSTRUCTION Design/Build • Spec/Build ENERGY-SAVING UPGRADES BUILDING & PROCESS AUTOMATION Engineering • Installation ON-TIME PERFORMANCE GUARANTEED
service@jltaylorcompany.com www.jltaylorcompany.com
440.834.1223
opportunity to obtain a VLT license. The fact that the VLT license cannot be transferred does not mean that it cannot have a value separate from the real estate. It is personal property that may have value as part of the going concern but is not real estate. The sales of comparable race track facilities used by the owner’s appraiser also sold with business assets included in the purchases. The buyers of the comparable facilities were similarly buying real estate and an operating race track and racing licenses, which
In a case involving the Thistledown Racino, the Ohio Supreme Court recently affirmed the principle that personal property value should not be included in your real estate tax assessment, even when those assets are intangible personal property like licenses. also gave them the opportunity to get a VLT license from the state at some point in the future. The court agreed that accounting for the value of these non-real estate assets was not improper.
Brennan 80
Real property taxes should be based on the value of your real estate only Make sure the value of personal property, whether tangible or intangible, is not included in your real estate tax assessment. Everyone should pay their fair share of taxes based on the value of their real estate; no one should have to pay real estate taxes on assets that are not real estate. P Cecilia J. Hyun (chyun@siegeltax.com) is a partner with Siegel Jennings Co., L.P.A. The firm is the Ohio and Western Pennsylvania member of the American Property Tax Counsel (APTC), the national affiliation of property tax attorneys. She can also be reached at 216.763.1004. Properties | February 2019
;d]n]dYf\ k Kl]]d @]Y\imYjl]jk
&ROXPELD %XLOGLQJ 3URGXFWV STEEL JOISTS STRUCTURAL IRON METAL ROOF DECK STEEL STAIRS & RAILS STEEL ERECTION
440-235-3363 *-1.) =de Kl&$ ;d]n]dYf\$ G@ ,,)+0
HOW BAD IS THAT LEAK?
Keep your assets safe by taking the time to ensure that problems at the top of your building are not damaging your bottom line.
Carey Roofing Corp. has eliminated asset damage due to a leaking roof with practical solutions since 1946. 216 • 881 • 1999 CAREY www.careyroofing.com
Roofing Corp.
founded in 1946
MEMBER: National Roofing Contractors Association
Construction attorneys who go toe to toe with anyone. Our construction attorneys are all construction all the time.
Claims Management, Analysis & Avoidance | Competitive Bidding Disputes | Workplace Safety Construction Litigation, Arbitration & Mediation | Contract Drafting & Negotiation | Surety Law | Lien & Bond Claims
FrantzWard.com
www.propertiesmag.com 81
CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT Updated info on important projects in the region
Project Report #: 01898 RMS INVESTMENT GROUP HEADQUARTERS LOCATION: 3401 Puttle Rd. Shaker Hts., OH (Cuyahoga County) www.rmsmanagement.com PROJECT TYPE: Interior Build-Out CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Work Just Completed OWNER/DEVELOPER: RMS Investment Corp. Contact: Luke Palisano, Joe Carrino 3401 Puttle Rd. Shaker Hts., OH 44120 Phone: 216-372-0080 ARCHITECT: GRA+D Architecture + Design Contact: Anrdrew Rosenthal 330 W. Spring St. #2265 Columbus, OH 43215 Phone: 614-228-2122 www.grad.cc GC: Nyman Construction Contact: Mike Nyman 2309 Miles Rd., 2nd Flr. Cleveland, OH 44128 Phone: 216-475-5333 DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 18,000 sf. Interior completion of offices into new headquarters. All interior trades involved. Project Report #: 01891 SHAKER ROCKS CLIMBING FACILITY LOCATION: Warrensville Center Rd. & Farnsleigh Rd. Shaker Hts., OH (Cuyahoga County) www.shakerrocksclimbing.com PROJECT TYPE: New Construction
Restoration Contractors
440.243.5535 BEREA, OHIO FACADE RESTORATION BALCONY RESTORATION BUILDING CLEANING CAULKING & SEALANTS COATING SYSTEMS GARAGE RESTORATION HISTORIC PRESERVATION MASONRY RESTORATION STONE RESTORATION WATERPROOFING
www.aiconstruction.com 82
CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Work Underway - Set for March Completion OWNER: Shaker Rocks Contact: Annie Richman co- owner Written Inquiries Only ARCHITECT: AoDK Architects Contact: David L. Krebs 17306 Madison Ave. Lakewood, OH 44107 www.aodkin.com CM: The Krill Company Inc. 1275 Main Ave. Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-357-4777 DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 1 story, 17,000 sf. 70 climbing stations - exercise area - yoga area - bouldering - lead, speed, autobelay, top-rope climbing. Part of Van Aken Shopping Center redevelopment. Project Report #: 01887 UH PARMA MEDICAL CENTER RENOVATION LOCATION: 7007 Powers Blvd. Parma, OH (Cuyahoga County) www.uhhospitals.org PROJECT TYPE: Renovation/Addition CATEGORY: Institutional LOCATION: 11100 Euclid Ave. Cleveland, OH 44129 www.uhhospitals.org DESCRIPTION: Enlargement of surgery department including a 7,700 sf addition - expansion
of the pre- and post-operative areas for outpatient procedures - larger waiting room for families. Project Report #: 01881 LORAIN COUNTY DOG KENNEL LOCATION: Site to be Selected Elyria, OH (Lorain County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STATUS: Project Proposed Pending Site Selection & Approvals OWNER: Lorain County Commissioners Contact: Ted Kalo, president 226 Middle Ave Elyria, OH 44035 Phone: 440-329-5418 ARCHITECT: To Be Announced DESCRIPTION: New dog kennel for Lorain County. Project Report #: 01419 925 BUILDING RENOVATION/RESTORATION LOCATION: Former Huntington Bank Building E. 9th & Euclid Ave. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: Renovation CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Plans in Progress - Possible Start Mid 2019 With 2022 Completion Date Pending Final Approvals EST. VALUE: $300 million OWNER/DEVELOPER: Millennia Housing Management Ltd Contact: Frank Sinito - Written Inquiries Only 127 Public Sq., Ste. 1300 Cleveland, OH 44114-1310 Phone: 216-520-1250 www.mhmltd.com ARCHITECT: Sandvick Architects Contact: Bob Vilkas - Written Inquiries Only 1265 W. 6th St., 2nd Fl. Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-621-8055 www.sandvickarchitects.com CONSTRUCTION MANAGER: Joint Venture of Gilbane Company & Marous Brothers Construction Gilbane Company 950 Main Ave., Ste. 1410 Cleveland, OH 44113 www.gilbaneco.com Marous Brothers Construction 1702 Joseph Lloyd Pkwy. Willoughby, OH 44094 Phone: 440-951-3904 www.marousbrothers.com Properties | February 2019
DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 22 stories, 1,400,000 sf. Mixeduse multi-residential, office & retail space renovated from former Huntington Bank headquarters. 250,00 sf offices - 250 to 275 apartments with dozen penthouses - 193 smaller apartments - luxury car showroom - exotic car storage/museum. Project Report #: 01861 MCGREGOR SENIOR ASSISTED LIVING EAST CLEVELAND LOCATION: 14900 Private Dr. East Cleveland (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Residential PROJECT STATUS: Work Underway - Set for July 2019 Completion EST. VALUE: $12 million OWNER: McGregor Home & CMHA Housing Partners Contact: Rob Hilton 14900 Private Dr. East Cleveland, OH 44112 Phone: 216-851-8200 ARCHITECT: HDS Architecture Contact: David DiFrancesco 1939 W. 25th St., Ste. 300 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-696-3460 www.hds-architecture.com GC: The Krill Company 1275 Main Ave Cleveland, OH 44113
www.krill.com STRUCTURAL ENG: Thorson Baker & Associates DESCRIPTION: 1 building, 90 assisted low income units. Project Report #: 01745 POST OFFICE PLAZA CLEVELAND - RENOVATION LOCATION: 1500 W. 3rd St. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: Renovation CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Working Drawings In Progress Construction Underway - Completion Set for 2nd Quarter 2019 DEVELOPER: K & D Group Contact: Doug Price 4420 Sherwin Rd. Willoughby, OH 44094 Phone: 440-946-3600 www.thekanddgroup.com ARCHITECT: DLR Group/Westlake Reed Leskosky Ltd. Contact: Michael Fant 1422 Euclid Ave., Ste. 300 Cleveland State: OH Zip: 44115 Phone: 216-522-1350 www.wrldesign.com CM: Cleveland Construction Inc. Contact: Mike Swally, project mgr. 8620 Tyler Blvd. Mentor, OH 44060 Phone: 440-255-8000 www.clevelandconstruction.com
OWNER’S AGENT: Evolution Construction Contact: Jim Hounshell 1717 E. 9th St., Ste. 101 Cleveland, OH 44111 Phone: 440-918-1628 www.evolution-construction.com DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 5 stories, 437,500 sf. Space ranging from 6,600 sf to full floor 88,875 sf. All interior remodeling trades involved for build-outs. Apartment units - fitness area - conference rooms. Pre-leasing to begin March 2019 Project Report #: 01569 MIDTOWN APARTMENT PROJECT LOCATION: 3101 Euclid Ave. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: Renovation CATEGORY: Residential CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Working Drawings - Start Date Not Set EST. VALUE: $12 million OWNER: The Inspirion Group LTD. Contact: Lemma Getachew, Mark Schildhouse 2020 Carnegie Ave. Cleveland, OH 44114 Phone: 216-307-2766 www.theinspiriongroup.com ARCHITECT: Richard L. Bowen + Associates Inc. Contact: Ken Chow 13000 Shaker Blvd.
BETWEEN THE WEATHER & YOU SINCE 1922
WARREN ROOFING WARREN ROOFING AND INSULATING COMPANY
With 94+ years in business, Warren Roofing knows what it means to provide top-notch customer service and quality workmanship. We work directly with manufacturers to provide a complete selection of roof systems from single ply to modified/built up, liquid applied coating, solar and green roofing, along with maintenance and repairs.
Commercial/Industrial Roofing + Architectural Sheet Metal
440.439.4404
Fax 440.439.7523
www.warrenroofing.com www.propertiesmag.com 83
FEATURED PROPERTY OF THE MONTH Enginehouse No. 3 1325 Carnegie Ave. Cleveland, OH Details: 4,185 SF
• Historic Building • Easy Highway Access • Off Street Parking Available • Secure Access • Fitness Center • Additional Space Available for Expansion
FOR LEASE
Providing World Class Office, Apartments & Parking Services Throughout Northeast Ohio 84
1325 Carnegie Ave., Cleveland, Ohio 44115 / 216-621-9255 www.thefrangosgroup.com / www.americanbookcondos.com Properties | February 2019
Cleveland, OH 44120 Phone: 216-491-9300 www.rlba.com GC: Adam Building Contact: Gene Stancek 4477 Renaissance Pkwy. Warrensville Hts., OH 44129 Phone: 216-831-2277 www.adambulding.net STRUCTURAL ENG: By Architect & CRJ Services LLC. MECH ENG: WHS Engineering Inc. ELEC ENG: WHS Engineering Inc. DESCRIPTION: 2 bldgs, 8 stories, 90,000 sf. Conversion of two existing office buildings constructed in 1959 into 90 apartments - 9th floor penthouse. Project Report #: 01833 ELYRIA PUBLIC LIBRARY - CENTRAL MAIN LIBRARY LOCATION: To Be Determined Elyria, OH (Lorain County) www.elyria.lib.oh.us PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional PROJECT STATUS: Project Proposed Pending Site Selection OWNER: Elyria Public Library Systems Contact: Lyn Crouse, Director 320 Washington Ave. Elyria, OH 44035 Phone: 440-332-0244 ARCHITECT: CBLH Design Inc. Contact: Adam O’Brien 7850 Freeway Cir., Ste. 101 Cleveland, OH 44130 Phone: 440-243-2000 www.cblhdesign.com CM AT RISK: Shook Construction Contact: Matt Danis 6860 W. Snowville Rd., Ste. 100 Brecksville, OH 44141 Phone: 440-838-5400 www.shookconstruction.com OWNERS REP: RFC Contracting DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 22,000 sf. New library. Project Report #: 01832 ELYRIA PUBLIC LIBRARY - SOUTH BRANCH LOCATION: Elyria, OH (Lorain County) www.elyria.lib.oh.us PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional PROJECT STATUS: Preliminary Plans in Progress Bid Date Not Set OWNER: Elyria Public Library Systems Contact: Lyn Crouse, Director 320 Washington Ave. Elyria, OH 44035 Phone: 440-322-0244 www.elyria.lib.oh.us ARCHITECT: CBLH Design Inc. Contact: Adam O’Brien 7850 Freeway Cir,. Ste. 101 Cleveland, OH 44130
Phone: 440-243-2000 www.cblhdesign.com CM AT RISK: Shook Construction Contact: Matt Danis 6860 W. Snowville Rd., Ste. 100 Brecksville, OH 44141 Phone: 440-838-5400 www.shookconstruction.com DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 5,100 sf. Renovation - first part of four phased over time. Project Report #: 01484 THE ATHLON AT THE CLEVELAND ATHLETIC CLUB BUILDING LOCATION: 1118 - 1148 Euclid Ave. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) www.theathloncac.com PROJECT TYPE: Renovation CATEGORY: Residential - Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Construction Underway - 2nd Quarter 2018 Start With Completion Set for Spring 2019 EST. VALUE: $62 million DEVELOPER/OWNER: Group of investors c/o Ned S. Weingart Contact: Ned S. Weingart 17480 Shelburne Rd. Cleveland Heights, OH 44118-4912 Phone: 216-932-6343 ARCHITECT: Sandvick Architects Inc. Contact: Tim Wagner 1265 W. 6th St., 2nd Fl. Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-621-8055 www.sandvickarchitects.com CM: Welty Building Co. Contact: Don Taylor 3421 Ridgewood Rd., #200 Fairlawn, OH 44333-3119 Phone: 330-867-2400 www.weltybldg.com CIVIL ENG: Riverstone Co. STRUCTURAL ENG: Barber Hoffman MECH ENG: Denk Associates ELEC ENG: Denk Assocaites OWNERS REP: Richard Sheehan (NGKF) DESCRIPTION: 15 stories, 253,000 sf. Renovation of former Cleveland Athletic Club into apartment complex - 163 units, ranging from 625 to 1,500 sf - pool - rooftop deck - fitness center - business facilities - yoga/wellness studios - swimming pool - parking garage - approx. 4,000 sf first-floor commercial space. Information included in Construction Progress Report has been produced, processed and/or verified through sources believed to be reliable. Properties Magazine makes no warranty of any kind for this information, express or implied, and is not responsible for any omissions or inaccuracies. To contribute project data or to notify Properties of any reporting errors, we encourage you to email cpr@propertiesmag.com.
Specializing in all aspects of Metal Framing, Drywall, Acoustical Ceilings and Flooring
DESIGN/BUILD TENANT & CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS ARCHITECTURAL TRADES SUBCONTRACTOR At ICON INTERIORS, our goals and values are consistent with all clients: deliver quality work, on time and on budget. We strive to exceed every client’s expectations and form a lasting partnership. Our standards will ensure a flawless project every time. 2150 St. Clair Ave. Cleveland, OH 44114 glenn@iconwcf.com www.iconwcf.com
SERVING ALL OF NORTHEAST OHIO
216.713.2383 www.propertiesmag.com 85
Coming in March Vocon Cleveland Headquarters Renovation Key Tower Renovation ECHO Health Headquarters Landscapes & Hardscapes Special Section …and more Interested in advertising? Call Properties today and an account representative can help you www.propertiesmag.com address your advertising needs: Visit us online for archived fea-
ture articles, advertising rates, 216.251.0035 / 888.641.4241 specs and subscription information.
ADVERTISER INDEX Abraxus Snow Removal ................................................55 Adrian Maldonado & Associates ............................. 34 AIA Cleveland ....................................................................32 Albert M. Higley Company, The ................................11 ALL Construction Services ...........................................27 American Interiors + Knoll...........................................73 American International Construction.....................82 American Quality Construction, LLC.........................2 Brennan & Associates.................................................... 80 Bruder Building Materials, Inc. .................................. 36 Buckeye Sweeping, Inc. ................................................42 Carey Demolition.............................................................75 Carey Roofing ....................................................................81 CBRE, Inc. ............................................................................ 25 Chagrin Valley Steel Erectors..................................... 38 Charles Schulz Building Company .......................... 66 Chas E. Phipps Co.............................................................41 Chemical Bank...................................................................31 Choice Cabinet..................................................................51 Christian Phillips Photography ................................. 36 Cleveland Cement Contractors, Inc........................ 30 Cleveland Chemical Pest Control, Inc.................... 50 Cleveland Construction, Inc....................................... 48 Cleveland Public Power ................................................16 Cleveland Thermal ..........................................................41 Columbia Building Products.......................................81 Commercial Roofing & Coating Systems, Inc......19 Construction Employers Association......................17 Cumberland Development, LLC ...............................21 Cunningham Paving Inc. ..............................................52 Diamond Roofing Systems............................................9 Dimit Architects LLC ...................................................... 23 Duffy & Duffy Cost Segregation Services ............ 60 EA Group .............................................................................87 Educational Equipment ............................................... 68 Evolution Construction Services, LLC.................... 48 First American Title Insurance Co..................... 24, 76 Frangos Group ................................................................. 84 Frantz Ward LLP................................................................81 Giorgi Commercial Contracting, Inc. ......................29 Granex Industries, Inc./Eternia ..................................29 Grout Systems, Inc...........................................................37 H & M Landscaping, Inc. ...............................................43 Hahn Loeser & Parks, LLP .............................................59 Hannah Electric, LLC.......................................................31 HMH Restoration Ltd......................................................75 Icon Interiors ......................................................................85 Infinity Construction ......................................................74 Integrated Project Solutions.......................................11 Interfinish/Surface Logic ............................................. 50 Isaac Lewin & Associates ..............................................55
J Norman Stark, LPA........................................................13 J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc. ...........................................32 Jamieson Ricca Fenestration ......................................67 JL Taylor, Co. Inc............................................................... 80 John G. Johnson Construction Co........................... 23 K & D Group, Inc. ............................................................. 46 Krill Company, Inc ..............................................................7 Lisco Heating & Cooling, Inc. ..................................... 36 Mason Structural Steel, Inc..........................................69 Masonry Restoration Maintenance .........................39 McCarthy, Lebit, Crystal & Liffman Co., LPA .........61 McMahon Masonry Restoration .............................. 60 Meaden & Moore, Ltd ................................................... 88 Messina Floor Covering, Inc. .......................................42 Meyers, Roman, Friedberg & Lewis .........................71 Mullin Brothers Construction Services...................49 NorthStar Title Services ............................................... 54 Novogradac & Company, LLP .....................................57 Pease Photography.........................................................74 Pella Window & Door Company/Gunton Corp..............................................3 Pete & Pete Container Service .................................. 40 Pioneer Cladding & Glazing ........................................32 Planet NRG Solutions, LLC. ..........................................52 Precision Environmental Co. .......................................13 Premise Solutions, LLC. .................................................11 RAM Construction Services of Cleveland .............32 Riverstone Company..................................................... 22 RL Wurz Co..........................................................................57 RM Riggle Enterprises, Inc. ......................................... 50 Royal Cabinet Design Company .............................. 34 RSM US LLP. ........................................................................29 S.A. Comunale Company ...............................................7 Schill Grounds Management..................................... 66 Siegel Jennings ................................................................78 Skoda Minotti Co. ............................................................67 Sleggs Danzinger & Gill...................................................4 SMPS Northeast Ohio ....................................................57 Snow Brothers Appliance, Inc. ...................................45 Space Comfort Co............................................................62 Sunray Window Films LLC........................................... 58 Suntrol Co............................................................................33 T.H. Martin, Inc. .................................................................14 The Thomas Brick Co......................................................26 Thorson Baker & Associates, Inc................................12 Tri-Kote Roofing .............................................................. 44 TriState Capital Bank.......................................................52 Tucker Landscaping, Inc. ................................................6 Walter | Haverfield LLP ................................................. 64 Warren Roofing & Insulating Co................................83 Zavarella Bros. Construction Co. .............................. 25
Contact an Advertiser www.propertiesmag.com
And Tell Them You Saw It In...
Visit us online today to view archived issues in an interactive digital format.
86
Properties | February 2019
EA Group can take the fear out of unforeseen conditions that cause costly delays and keep your project running smoothly.
Don’t be afraid of the environmental emergencies that may be lurking around the corner at your site.
EA Group has been providing hazardous materials assessment and management services to the construction and real estate
BREATHE EASIER
industry for over 25 years. We can evaluate your site, prepare abatement plans and monitor the remediation work. Put our team to work early to avoid environmental emergencies that can cause costly delays and unexpected liabilities. We offer: • Pre-Construction Hazardous Materials Surveys • Abatement Design and Management • Air Monitoring and Exposure Assessment • Mold Assessment and Remediation Management 800.875.3514 • 440.951.3514 • www.eagroupohio.com 7118 Industrial Park Boulevard • Mentor, OH 44060
You Already Take Enough Risks You work with industry experts to reduce risks to you and your employees. Shouldn’t the same be true for your accounting firm?
ACCOUNTING EXPERTISE ◆ BUSINESS PLANNING ◆ TAX PLANNING SUCCESSION PLANNING ◆ PROFIT ENHANCEMENT ◆ BID REVIEWS COST CONTROL ◆ LITIGATION SUPPORT SERVICES ◆ JOB-COST AUDITING
MEADENMOORE.COM | 216.241.3272 AKRON | BEACHWOOD | CLEVELAND | WOOSTER