Skip to main content

Northeast Ohio Properties, February 2018

Page 1

INSIDE : The Foundry • OCP Contractors • Legal Services + Risk Management

February 2018/$8.95

Unlocking Imagination

Th Children’s The Child ’ M Museum off Cleveland creates new home in revived Stager Beckwith Mansion


Y landscaping Your l d makes k a powerful f l statement to your clients l and prospective clients. Let our Grounds Maintenance Division keep yours in top condition all year long.

*5281'6 0$,17(1$1&( ',9,6,21 3URIHVVLRQDO _ 'HGLFDWHG _ ([SHULHQFHG

ZZZ KPODQGVFDSLQJ FRP *5((1


Cover Your Investments With Confidence

Count on Commercial Roofing and Coating Systems, Inc. to get on top of your roofing project – no matter the size. We specialize in roofing repairs, replacements and maintenance for Commercial, Industrial and Residential clients throughout Northeast Ohio. Our main focus? Providing efficient and cost-effective service. Our full line of services includes: Roofing Maintenance | Inspections & Reporting Infrared Leak Detection & Reporting | Low Slope Roofing Single-Ply Membrane Roof Systems | TPO, PVC, EPDM, Modified Asphalt Sheet Metal & Custom Flashings | ACM Composite Panels | Coatings Insulation | Tapered Insulation, Tapered Roofing | Metal-Retrofit Systems Daylighting | Solar Roof Systems | New Construction & Roof Replacement

Contact us today at 330-207-3879 to handle all of your roofing needs! Mailing Address: P.O. Box 73, Garrettsville, OH 44231 | Physical Address: 10025 SR-82, Windham, OH 44288 brandon@ohiocommercialroofing.com | www.ohiocommercialroofing.com


Reducing Real Property Tax Assessments Throughout Ohio And Across The United States Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill, Co., LPA

When you hire Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill, you work directly with Sleggs, Danzinger and Gill. Each client is directly represented at all levels by a principal of the firm with a combined 75 years of experience. No pyramid, no associates, no on-the-job training. Our clients deserve the very best representation, so we structured our firm to allow each client, throughout the entire process, to work directly with Messrs. SLEGGS, DANZINGER and/or GILL. Our philosophy is to work cooperatively with school district and County officials to ensure that our clients pay the lowest possible real property tax obligations. If a fair resolution requires litigation, SLEGGS, DANZINGER & GILL have the depth of trial and appellate experience to handle the most complex valuation issues. Whether the valuation relates to large industrial plants, apartments, shopping centers, warehouses, office buildings, vacant land or any other type of commercial property, the faces above will ensure that you receive the best counsel, legal advice and litigation expertise.

Member Firm

Todd W. Sleggs, Esq.

Robert K. Danzinger, Esq.

Steven R. Gill, Esq.

tsleggs@sdglegal.net

rdanzinger@sdglegal.net

sgill@sdglegal.net

(216) 771-8990 sdglegal.net

Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill 820 West Superior Ave. Seventh Floor Cleveland, OH 44113


February 2018, Volume LXXII, Number 2

FEATURES Phone: 216.251.0035 Toll Free: 888.641.4241 Fax: 216.251.0064 www.propertiesmag.com CLEVELAND 3826 W. 158th St. Cleveland, Ohio 44111

OWNER/PUBLISHER Kenneth C. Krych kkrych@propertiesmag.com 216.251.0035 MANAGING EDITOR/ART DIRECTOR Mark Watt mwatt@propertiesmag.com 216.251.2655 CONTRIBUTING WRITERS Doug Bardwell, Ian Frank, Lou Kren, Matt Lehnert, Alec Pacella, Diane DiPiero Rodio, Robert Sandrick, John Slagter, Carlo Wolff, David Woodburn

Photo by Mark Steele Photography

AKRON P.O. Box 9 Munroe Falls, Ohio 44262

10 School-to-Apprenticeship Deal Reached with Local Training Center Landmark agreement creates new sheet metal, HVAC apprenticeship program

12 A Robot Revolution? Cleaning robots may not usher in utopia, but maintenance costs will go down

14

Scanning for Solutions Utilizing infrared technology to identify roofing issues

16 Unlocking Imagination The Children’s Museum of Cleveland creates new home in revived Stager Beckwith Mansion

28 OCP Contractors: Defining the Skyline MEDIA CONSULTANTS Matt Lehnert mlehnert@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6753 Larry Overbey loverbey@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6649

Northeast Ohio’s largest interior contractor continues strategic growth

50 Making Waves The Foundry Community Rowing & Sailing Center opens in transformed industrial complex

59

59 Risks of Marijuana-Related Businesses 61 Builders Risk Claims in Focus 65 Purchase Agreements Versus Options 66 NAIOP News: Real Estate Investment Changes Under Tax Law 68 How to Avoid Employee Discrimination Claims 71 Recent Ohio Supreme Court Decision May Help Ohio Taxpayers Challenge Tax Assessments 72 Changing Markets, Changing Tax Codes, Changing Property Taxes?

OFFICE MANAGER Lisa Larissey 216.251.8506 Cover photo: The Children’s Museum of Cleveland, by Mark Steele Photography

Properties (ISSN 033-1287) is published monthly for architects, engineers, building owners and managers, general contractors, home builders, mortgage bankers, savings and loans, real estate agents, appraisers, servicers and suppliers in Northern Ohio by Properties, Inc., 3826 W. 158th St., Cleveland, Ohio 44111. Copyright © 2018 by Properties, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction or use, without written permission, of editorial or pictorial content is strictly prohibited. Periodicals postage paid in Cleveland, Ohio and additional offices. Subscription rates: one year $29.95, single copy $8.95, back issues $12 when available. Postmaster: send change of address notices to Properties, P.O. Box 112127, Cleveland, Ohio 44111.

Special Section: Legal Services + Risk Management

DEPARTMENTS 8 38 43 44 46 48 66 74

PROPERTIES PEOPLE BILLBOARD BOMA BUSINESS FINANCIAL STRATEGIES ACAR CORNER MARKETING MENTOR NAIOP NEWS CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT www.propertiesmag.com 5


PUBLISHER’S NOTE February 2018

Law and Probability elcome to our February issue, featuring our annual Legal Services + Risk Management section with articles from a number of top professionals serving Northeast Ohio’s real estate, AEC, building and property management communities.

W KEN KRYCH

Topics range from tips on challenging tax assessments to builders risk claims, and from avoiding employee discrimination claims to the risks associated with marijuana-related businesses. We thank the contributing firms of Dworken & Bernstein LPA; Hahn Loeser & Parks LLP; Meaden & Moore; O’Toole McLaughlin Dooley Pecora; Siegel Jennings Co. LPA; and Sleggs Danzinger & Gill Co. LPA. The Children’s Museum of Cleveland Our cover story highlights The Children’s Museum of Cleveland and

its new home within the restored historic Stager Beckwith Mansion. The 40,000-square-foot gem is the oldest mansion along the fabled Millionaire’s Row and one of just four still standing. After being vacant for years and sustaining considerable water damage, the space has been transformed into a learning playground for children with three floors of interactive play areas. Having personally attended it when it was a former private club, I can attest that the team has retained the very best of it and through a careful and thoughtful

Sponsorship and Exhibitor Opportunities still available! Our Corporate Sponsors Include...

Wednesday March 7 & Thursday March 8 Huntington Convention Center of Cleveland Educational Conference Trade Show 8:00 a.m. – 3:00 p.m. 12:00 p.m. – 9/8:00 p.m. 334 Exhibitors | 35+ Classes | 4,000+ Attendees

www.electroexpo.org to register for FREE admission Plus: Schedule | Travel and Lodging | Past Exhibitors Sponsored by Northeast Ohio Distributors

6

Properties | February 2018


transformative process given this 19th century icon new life. The Foundry We tour The Foundry, a newly opened rowing and sailing center along the Cuyahoga River in The Flats. MCPc Family Charities has succeeded in converting an aged maze of former manufacturing buildings into a state-of-the-art facility where middle and secondary school students can pursue their dreams of potentially becoming world-class athletes. OCP Contractors 50th Anniversary Also this month, we turn the spotlight on OCP Contractors as they celebrate their 50th anniversary. We take an indepth look into this successful firm, which has contributed to many of the most notable building projects throughout our region to become Northern Ohio’s largest interior contractor. Electro Expo 2018 As a special supplement this month, we have included the official program for the Electrical League of Ohio’s Electro Expo 2018. The “Powering Innovation + Technology” trade show and educational conference will be held on Wednesday, March 7 and Thursday, March 8 at the Huntington Convention Center of Cleveland. This event occurs here only once every three years and we are proud to be Media Sponsor. Coming in March Looking ahead to March, we will present our annual Landscapes + Hardscapes special section, focusing on the best in landscaping, hardscapes and outdoor lighting with input from many of the area’s top experts. In addition, we will be featuring indepth stories on Cleveland State University’s new Washkewicz College of Engineering building and Walsh University’s Global Learning Center, as well as a profile on Richard Fleischman | DS Architecture. Until then, bundle up, work smart and keep thoughts of spring in mind. Positively,

Kenneth C. Krych Owner/Publisher

Nationwide Fire Protection An EMCOR Company

S.A. Comunale Fire Sprinklers

Alarm & Detection

Fire Backflow Extinguishers Preventers

Corporate Office 2900 Newpark Drive Barberton, OH 44203

Kitchen Suppression Systems

24/7

sacomunale.com

We do it

330-706-3040 Fax 330-861-0937

all.

800-776-7181 Celebrating a Century of Service FOUNDED IN 1918

THE OLDEST AND MOST EXPERIENCED WATERPROOFING, CONCRETE & MASONRY RESTORATION CONTRACTOR Concrete Repair Masonry Restoration Brick/Stone Repair Epoxy Injection Post Tensioning Repairs

Caulking/Sealants Expansion Joints 7UDIƓF &RDWLQJV Epoxy Flooring Masonry Sealers/Coatings

Exterior Cleaning :DWHUSURRƓQJ Spray Foam Insulation Air Barrier Systems Fire-Stopping

440.740.0100 | WWW.RAMSERVICES.COM 100 CORPORATION CENTER | BROADVIEW HEIGHTS, OHIO www.propertiesmag.com 7


PROPERTIES PEOPLE Highlighting notable industry events

1

2

3

1

5

4

6

AIA Cleveland Sponsor Recognition Party 2

3 1 Thomas Laird (Gilbane Co.) and Mary Beth Levin (University Hospitals) 2 Courtney Behm and Thomas Laird (Gilbane Building Company) and Tari Rivera (Regency Construction) 3 Jeffrey R. Appelbaum (Thompson Hine LLP), Richard Mayer (Sodexo USA, University Hospitals) and Mark Panzica (Panzica Construction)

In recognition of its sponsors, AIA Cleveland recently hosted a gathering at The Forest City Shuffleboard Arena & Bar in Cleveland. Over 150 association members and guests attended, enjoying food, drinks and games of shuffleboard, as well as comments from incoming 2018 AIA Cleveland President Allan Renzi, of Richard L. Bowen + Associates, LLC. P

1

1 Allan Renzi (Richard L. Bowen + Associates, Inc.) 2 Wayne Mortensen (Cleveland Neighborhood Progress, Inc.) and Patty Lampert (AIA Cleveland) 3 David Maniet (Blatchford Architects) 4 Pete DiAmico (Tim O’Neil & Assocs) and Amanda Romeo (The Krill Co.) 5 Adam Yaracs (Perspectus Architects) 6 Lauren Greco and Ahmi Goyal (Blink Marketing & Signs)

2

3

4

CEA Announces Scholarship Construction Employers Association (CEA) recently announced that a new $5,000 annual scholarship has been created in the name of Thomas Laird, of the Gilbane Building Company, in recognition of his service and guidance for the ACE Mentorship program over the last 10 years. The scholarship is donated by University Hospitals and Sodexo USA. It was presented to Laird as a surprise after a CEA board meeting held at the new offices of Thompson Hine/PMC within Key Tower. P 8

5

ACAR 2018 Inaugural Recently, 160 members of Akron Cleveland Association of Realtors (ACAR) came together for the association’s annual dinner and installation of officers at the DoubleTree Hotel in Independence. The event included the swearing in of ACAR’s new Board of Directors, an annual report, plus a ceremonial passing of the gavel from outgoing 2017 President Jim Fox to incoming 2018 president Karen O’Donnell. P

6

7

1 Felicia Hengle (Coldwell Banker Schmidt Family of Companies) 2 Roz Campbell and Donna Dopslaff (ACAR) 3 Karen O’Donnell (2018 ACAR President) 4 John J. Lynch (Keller Williams Realty Greater Cleveland West) 5 Peter and Karen O’Donnell (Coldwell Banker) and Melanie O’Donnell 6 Jim Fox (Stouffer Realty Inc.) 7 Tiffany Hattendorf-Smith (Chicago Title) and Kady Overton (Keller Williams Greater Cleveland)

Properties | February 2018


EA Group can take the fear out of unforeseen conditions that cause costly delays and keep your project running smoothly.

Don’t be afraid of the environmental emergencies that may be lurking around the corner at your site.

EA Group has been providing hazardous materials assessment and management services to the construction and real estate

BREATHE EASIER

industry for over 25 years. We can evaluate your site, prepare abatement plans and monitor the remediation work. Put our team to work early to avoid environmental emergencies that can cause costly delays and unexpected liabilities. We offer: • Pre-Construction Hazardous Materials Surveys • Abatement Design and Management • Air Monitoring and Exposure Assessment • Mold Assessment and Remediation Management 800.875.3514 • 440.951.3514 • www.eagroupohio.com 7118 Industrial Park Boulevard • Mentor, OH 44060


ADVANCING OPPORTUNITY Eric Gordon (CEO, Cleveland Metropolitan Schools), John Sickle Jr. (Co-Chairman, JATC), John Nesta (CCS) and Kevin Tolley (Co-Chairman, JATC & BA for LU 33) gathered to sign a landmark school-to-apprenticeship agreement recently (left). Among those celebrating the new partnership (right) were John Sindyla (CEO, SMACNA), Chris Scarcella (Principal, Max Hayes High School), Kristina Martinez (student, Max Hayes), Eric Gordon (CEO, Cleveland Metropolitan Schools), Matthew Gonzalez and Austin Williams (Students, Max Hayes).

School-to-Apprenticeship Deal Reached with Local Training Center Landmark agreement creates new sheet metal, HVAC apprenticeship program By Properties Staff | Photos courtesy of SMACNA Cleveland

landmark school-to-apprenticeship agreement was signed recently by representatives of Cleveland Metropolitan School District, Max S. Hayes High School and Sheet Metal Workers Joint Apprenticeship and Training Committee of Cleveland. The signing took place in mid-January at the Cleveland Local #33 Sheet Metal Workers – SMACNA Training Center.

A

The new agreement will allow students from Max Hayes High School who complete their school work to get direct entry into an apprenticeship program at the one of the nation’s top training facilities including handson training and classroom time in welding, sheet metal, safety courses, computer-aided drafting (CAD), computer aided manufacturing (CAM), project management, reading plans and specifications (blueprint reading), supervisory training, as well as trade related mathematics. “The great things about this program is it becomes a direct tie so our students can actually come to this facility and see the direct connect between the curriculum they are doing at the high school and how it ties to the industry,” says Max Hayes High School Principal Chris Scarcella. “We have roughly 20-30 students in every grade that as they move through their high school career could take advantage

of this program. This program was berthed through a community benefits agreement between the city and local contractors. One of the components of that community benefits agreement was an educational com-

of construction and welding programs directly into apprenticeship programs so that we can get from school-to-work. This program is supported fully by the union, so that when students leave, they leave right into an apprentice status journeyman and right onto the bench and there are not many opportunities for urban students to do that kind of work. This is the first in Cleveland.” Additionally, based on another agreement with the Ohio Board of Regents, individuals working as union apprentices will now also be Chris Scarcella, Principal able to transfer more math and Max Hayes High School science credits when pursuing an associate’s degree from an ponent – Tri-C and Max Hayes High accredited state college, such as Tri-C, School are both a part of that com- Columbus State Community College and Owens Community College. munity benefits agreement.” The program will not only provide Eric Gordon, CEO of Cleveland Metropolitan School District, says, more upward mobility and education for “This has been in the works for over 16 those interested in working within the years, so to be here today is significant sheet metal and HVAC industries, but in all kinds of ways. It’s creating access will also provide the Ohio industries with for my high school kids coming out top, well-trained youthful talent. P

“The great things about this program is it becomes a direct tie so our students can actually come to [the SMACNA Training Center] and see the direct connect between the curriculum they are doing at the high school and how it ties to the industry.”

10

Properties | February 2018


)LQG D &HUWLÀHG 4XDOLÀHG &RQWUDFWRU Ensure your project receives the highest quality expertise from the safest and most reputable HVAC companies in the industry. LOCAL 33 SHEET METAL WORKERS

www.NEOHVAC.com

...SINCE 1961

Proudly serving SMACNA & SMART

RESIDENTIAL | COMMERCIAL | INDUSTRIAL RIAL HVAC • Service • Testing & Balancing &XVWRP )DEULFDWLRQ $UFKLWHFWXUDO 5RRÀQJ Fire Life Safety • Duct Cleaning • Kitchen

SMACNA - Cleveland 6060 Royalton Rd. North Royalton, OH 44133 (440) 877-3500 www.smacnacle.org

SMART Local #33 12515 Corporate Dr. Parma, OH 44130 (216) 267-1645 www.smwlu33.org


A Robot Revolution? Cleaning robots may not usher in utopia, but maintenance costs will go down By Larry Green Janitor Jack

t’s impossible to escape the barrage of news about how technology will disrupt everything – either we will be ushering in utopia or we’ll all be thrown out of work and starve. Artificial intelligence (A.I.), the Internet of Things (IoT) and robotics are the usual suspects, according to self-proclaimed “futurists” (who were formerly known as soothsayers).

I

These technologies are not only on the horizon but in full speed development as you read this. Time will tell how each technology will play out, but robotics has easily emerged as a frontrunner in the disruption race and cleaning robots may be the first of these technologies to visibly make a difference in the commercial real estate industry. The utilization of robots can reduce a building’s operating expense, thereby changing the valuation of the property. Cleaning robots have a head start on A.I. or IoT because there are already millions of cleaning robots deployed across U.S. homes. The company iRobot manufactured space exploration robots and bomb-defusing robots to be used on the battlefield or in law enforcement situations where explosives were present. When they launched a small vacuuming robot for

residential use, they had no way to see how the market would respond. With 10 million units sold by 2013, cleaning robots exceeded all other products in generating immediate interest. Worldwide sales today for iRobot is 20 million robots.

Cleaning robots for commercial use have lagged far behind residential use. There are 5.6 million commercial buildings, comprising 87 billion square feet of space in the U.S., yet robotic cleaning has not significantly penetrated the nation’s commercial real estate industry. The non-use of commercial cleaning robots is limited to the U.S. as robotics has been adopted in Australia, several Middle East nations, Europe, Japan and Singapore. Although it was a U.S. company which first went to market with a commercial cleaning robot, a succession of ownership changes torpedoed their efforts; there are four major companies in the market at the moment, with more on the way. Adoption of robotics has been slow in the U.S. for several reasons but the main obstacle has been the high cost of the machines

You Don’t Know Clean, If You Don’t Know Jack Cleveland Owned & Operated with 20+ Years of Management Experience in Facility Maintenance

FACILITIES

SERVICES JANITORIAL TURN KEY

OFFICES

WORKSPACE CARE

INDUSTRIAL

CARPET/FLOOR CARE

RETAIL

POST CONSTRUCTION CLEAN-UP

HEALTHCARE

PRESSURE WASHING

APARTMENTS

WINDOW CLEANING

INSTITUTIONAL

PORTER & MATRON

GOVERNMENT

COMMON AREA CARE

RESTAURANTS

www.janitorjack.net 12

216-307-7007

info@janitorjack.net Properties | February 2018


and resistance by janitorial contractors who have become comfortable with very minor equipment expenses. The cost of labor or the shortage of labor have driven adoption of robots in other countries and the U.S. will follow along for these same reasons. Floor care is the focus of most cleaning robots now, as vacuuming carpet and scrubbing tile floors account for approximately 50 cents of each cleaning dollar. Research is now under way to tackle other cleaning tasks, such as cleaning windows and restroom fixtures, and even collecting and disposing of desk-side trash in open offices. Robots that perform services as opposed to robots used in manufacturing are what the coming robot

Floor care is the focus of most cleaning robots now... Research is now under way to tackle other cleaning tasks such as cleaning windows and restroom fixtures, and even collecting and disposing of desk-side trash in open offices.

Proudly Serving Northeast Ohio

ѴѴŊ";u b1; -m7v1-r; ;vb]m Ň omv|u 1ঞom Maintenance | Snow & Ice

ĺr;u=;1ঞomѴ-m7v1-r;vĺ1ol

EXPERTS IN CREATING PROJECTS BUILT WITH EXCEPTIONAL SERVICE ƕ Worship ƅ Education ì Healthcare

Celebrating 75 Years: 1943 –2018 Ƅ Municipal Ɣ Commercial

Ȕ Hospitality µ Multi-Family

GENERAL CONTRACTORS CONSTRUCTION MANAGERS DESIGN/BUILDERS SUBCONTRACTORS BID PACKAGE SPECIALISTS P.216.938.5050 • F.216.938.5033 • johngjohnson.com

revolution is all about. Both Japan and South Korea see service robots as primary contributors to their GDP. The manufacturing robot market is mature, but service robots are the big growth area. Cleaning robots will come down in price and that means you will be seeing them in our buildings sooner rather than later. When the savings begin to be realized, look for architects and space planners to take notice. Smart CRE folk always pay attention to cost reductions that boost property valuations. Would a 20-25% reduction in cleaning expense get your attention – especially if robots outperformed their human counterparts? P

Larry Green is president of Janitor Jack. He can be reached by phone at 216-307-7007 or by email at larry@janitorjack.net. Janitor Jack can be found on the web at janitorjack.net.

ALWAYS INSPIRING the places we work, learn, heal, and play.

in

2018

www.propertiesmag.com 13


It’s: Project Management Advanced Diagnostics Photo courtesy of RAM USA

Unbiased Information

Cost Effective – Proven ROI LOOKING INSIDE Aerial infrared scans have proven to be an effective way to locate hidden moisture within a roof system.

Scanning for Solutions Utilizing infrared technology to identify roofing issues By Tiffany Lacey RAM USA

et a second opinion. What harm would it do? Second opinions can help reinforce a decision that is being made or help you find a better solution. With most major life decisions, a fresh perspective can help you make the right decision for yourself.

G

Aerial Infrared Roof Scan

Roof and Building Envelope Consulting and Engineering Services

Contact us today to learn more: (216)393-7663 www.RAM-USA.com

14

This is the same concept building owners and property managers should be using when considering roof work for their facilities: finding the most logical, cost effective and proactive measures to protect their buildings for the long run. An objective aerial infrared scan is a great start. This scan is the fastest, most accurate and most cost-effective way to find hidden moisture within a roof system. This process is used to help prevent larger, pricier problems and can also help figure out if a roof truly needs to be replaced or not. If you believe you need a roof replacement, ask yourself these questions: • Did somebody do the proper inspections and provide a report that clearly outlines issues?

• What information was utilized to determine if roofs need replacement? • Can the insulation be re-used? • How did the roofs fail and was a failure mode analysis completed? Below is typical client scenario we see over and over again: a building owner is replacing a roof (spending a large amount of capital dollars) that doesn’t need to be replaced. Bringing in a consultant to get a second opinion is a good best practice.

Challenge A building owner was told by a roofing contractor that the roof should be replaced. Since this would be such a big expense, they wanted to make sure Properties | February 2018


this was the appropriate action. They called upon an industry consultant’s expertise to offer unbiased recommendations. The initial step was to utilize aerial infrared roof scanning and analysis, and then receive a detailed roof survey.

Solution The consultant’s approach offered checks and balances to the current information provided. This offered objective information and recommendations for selecting the best course of action on each roof section based on the lowest lifecycle costs.

Results After all the data was collected, the roof could be restored to perform like a new roof for about half the cost and

Research has shown that 50% of roofs being replaced in fact do not need to be – meaning a large amount of money is being unnecessarily spent on roofs nationwide. was given a 10-year warranty. With the help of the consultant, the client was able to spend a small amount of the overall project cost to save hundreds of thousands of dollars. Clients with a large portfolio of facilities could implement a similar plan that would save millions. Research has shown that 50% of roofs being replaced in fact do not need to be – meaning a large amount of money is being unnecessarily spent on roofs nationwide. Taking a step back every once in a while and getting that second opinion can be beneficial in more ways than one. Money, time and peace of mind can all be saved when a smart and proactive plan is used. P

Tiffany Lacey is marketing manager/AP/AR manager with RAM USA (1680 Industrial Parkway, Brunswick, Ohio 44212). For more information, call 216.393.7663. www.propertiesmag.com 15


Unlocking Imagination The Children’s Museum of Cleveland creates new home in revived Stager Beckwith Mansion By Doug Bardwell | Photos by Mark Steele Photography

s this Cleveland mansion gets older, its inhabitants are getting younger and younger. The stately Stager Beckwith Mansion at 3813 Euclid Ave. is the oldest of the mansions on Millionaire’s Row and the only 19th-century example of the four still standing. After serving as a men’s club, then serving as a college, it’s now home to The Children’s Museum of Cleveland. With 40,000 square feet of renovated space, children have recently flocked to the three floors of interactive play area designed to stimulate their creativity.

A

Formerly located in a 10,000-squarefoot space in University Circle, the 35-year-old Children’s Museum has grown exponentially in not only space, but also in number of visitors. Re-opening November 6, 2017, the museum has already sold more than 3,000 new memberships and welcomed 35,000 visitors.

Anson would have never guessed While employed by the Western Union Telegraph Company, Anson Stager built the mansion in 1866. He lived here with 16

his wife and three daughters for only three years, selling to Thomas Sterling Beckwith and moving to Chicago to become president of Western Electric. The mansion continued as a private residence until purchased by the University Club in 1913. (Charles Brush owned the Stager Beckwith mansion for a few years between Thomas Beckwith and the University Club because he didn’t want to see his property value fall.) Operated as a men’s club, the University Club expanded the mansion and contin-

ued operating until 2002. In 2004, it was purchased by Myers University (the successor to Dyke College.) Needing all new windows and serious mechanical and electrical upgrades, the university poured $11 million into remodeling, including a reported $2 million for renovations of the apartment for Paul Feingold – then-president of the university. Having received federal and state historic tax credits, an easement was placed on the property preventing it from being torn down or from having its façade altered. Properties | February 2018


;d]n]dYf\ k Kl]]d @]Y\imYjl]jk

Congratulations to The Children’s Museum on its new home in MidTown!

&ROXPELD %XLOGLQJ 3URGXFWV STEEL JOISTS STRUCTURAL IRON METAL ROOF DECK STEEL STAIRS & RAILS STEEL ERECTION

440-235-3363

CDA is a proud investor in this project and in all the children it will benefit. www.clevelanddevelopmentadvisors.com

*-1.) =de Kl&$ ;d]n]dYf\$ G@ ,,)+0

Construction

Management

General

Contracting

Design-Build www.propertiesmag.com 17


INTERACTIVE EXHIBIT Adventure City, one of the museum’s largest activity areas, encourages children to build, climb and use their imaginations as they work through stairways, balconies and two-story lookouts.

(The easement was a way to raise cash for the improvements.) Unable to meet its financial obligations and unable to maintain the property, the university went out of business in 2007. The property was not maintained properly, and no one ever drained the pipes. Eventually, a pipe burst upstairs, causing major damage throughout the property.

18

Sitting empty from 2007 until 2015, many efforts to attract a buyer met with no success. As the property slipped into foreclosure in 2012, taxes continued accumulating. Cuyahoga County eventually offered the property for auction, twice. Two prospective bidders from New York and Texas failed to put in acceptable bids. As the property headed into forfeiture, it was picked up

by the Cuyahoga Land Bank to sell to the museum.

Meanwhile in University Circle The small but popular Children’s Museum of Cleveland had been leasing space from University Circle Inc. for almost 35 years. With the colorful double-peaked tent design over the former Howard Johnson restaurant, it

Properties | February 2018


ALBER & RICE

CIVIL + STRUCTURAL ENGINEERS

ALBER & RICE IS PROUD TO HAVE PROVIDED ALBER & RICE IS PROUD TO HAVE PROVIDED STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SERVICES AT CIVIL AND STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING SERVICES THE CHILDREN’S OFEXPANSION CLEVELAND FOR THE HYLANDMUSEUM SOFTWARE WITH THE KRILL CO. 17138 LORAIN AVENUE | CLEVELAND | OHIO | 44111| 216.252.7840 | www.alberandrice.com

PROUD TO BE A MEMBER OF THE KRILL TEAM PROVIDING ROUGH & FINISH CARPENTRY FOR THE CHILDREN’S MUSEUM OF CLEVELAND ENCOURAGING EXPLORATION Themed play areas within Adventure City include a construction zone (above), as well as a farmer’s market.

attracted the eye of most all who drove down Euclid Avenue as they entered the University Circle area. Unfortunately, the space was considerably smaller than most of its peers in other cities, according to Maria Campanelli, executive director of the museum. Only 6,000 of its 10,000 square feet were devoted to actual exhibit and play areas. As popular as it was, it needed to grow. Additionally, as private developers planned a high-rise apartment tower

“Within a one-mile span of Euclid... there are eight organizations that focus on early childhood development. So, we dubbed this the Early Childhood Development Corridor.” Maria Campanelli The Children’s Museum of Cleveland for the museum’s location, the museum was told they needed to vacate by the summer of 2015. “Initially, we considered building a facility of our own, but estimates of $15 million were beyond our means,” says Campanelli.

The perfect location Approached first by Tracy Nichols, Cleveland’s now-former Director of Economic Development, the museum’s

Quality Guaranteed

STRANO CONSTRUCTION COMPANY 216-381-5548 • 591 Parkside Blvd., S. Euclid, OH 44143

Congratulations to

The Children’s Museum of Cleveland on the successful completion of their new home. Thank you for choosing Singerman, Mills, Desberg & Kauntz Co., L.P.A. as your legal counsel for this project. 3333 Richmond Road, Suite 370 | Beachwood, Ohio 44122 (216) 292-5807 | Fax (216) 292-5867 www.smdklaw.com www.propertiesmag.com 19


Neptune Plumbing is proud to provide plumbing services for The Children’s Museum of Cleveland

Neptune Plumbing offers the necessary plumbing prefabrication services to help increase the efficiencies of your next project.

Commercial / Industrial / Institutional Complete Plumbing Systems Engineering & Design True 24/7 Service Sewer Jetting / Drain Cleaning Sewer Locating / Camera Inspection %DFNÁRZ 7HVWLQJ

216.475.9100 / neptuneplumbing.net

EDUCATIONAL EQUIPMENT Serving Cleveland and Northeast Ohio Since 1936 We are specialists in: • Operable Panel Partitions • Accordion Doors • Chalk/Marker Boards • Bulletin Boards • Trophy & Display Cases • Signage • Directories SALES

INSTALLATION

SERVICE

845 Overholt Rd., P.O. Box 154, Kent, Ohio 44240 — Phone (330) 673-4881 Fax ((330) 673-4915)

20

Properties | February 2018


CREATING SPACE In the ‘Arts and Parts’ area, children can develop their own creations with a variety of materials and tools available.

board looked at the mansion and considered a purchase. The location was perfect – just two blocks from I-90, I-71 and I-77 and on the Healthline. The three-acre property was also ideal, providing lots of parking and outdoor green space. The museum’s guests were evenly divided between east- and west-siders, so this property was centrally located. “The other thing that was of interest to us,” adds Campanelli, “was that within this one-mile span of Euclid, beginning with Cleveland State University, Department of Children & Family Services, Starting Point, The Centers for Families & Children, Positive Education Program (PEP), and UH’s newly opening Women’s & Children Clinic; there are eight organizations that focus on early childhood development. So, we dubbed this the Early Childhood Development Corridor.” Unfortunately, the price was just too high, considering all the work that would be required. Private developers considered purchasing the property and one even proposed a purchase, with the idea of leasing it to the Children’s Museum. Potential museum

donors objected however, insisting that the museum own its future home. In December 2014, The Children’s Museum of Cleveland purchased the property from the Cuyahoga Land Bank for $50,000. After taking title to the prop-

erty, they immediately kicked off their capital campaign and replaced the roof which had been leaking for some time. Tim Panzica, of IQ Advisors LLC, was brought in as owner’s representative. “It was such an odyssey with more twists and

Painting

Proud to be part of the team at

Intumescent Fireproofing

CHILDREN’S MUSEUM OF CLEVELAND

Heavy Duty Floor Coatings

with The Krill Company

Wallcovering Staining Epoxy Coatings Lead Abatement Acoustical Panels Mural Installation

DBE | EDGE | City of Cleveland FBE & LPE NEORSD SBE & WBE | WOSB | edWOSB

1520 East 365th Street Eastlake, OH 44095 440.269.8898 www.summitpaintingllc.net

www.propertiesmag.com 21


Proud to have provided & installed all flooring at THE CHILDREN’S MUSEUM OF CLEVELAND

Charting Your Destination? We’ve been helping companies steer toward new and better futures as an icebreaker in forging strong new relationships for over 70 years!

4515M Cleveland’s Preferred Flooring Specialists. Since 1988.

Ŷ Leaders & innovators in specialty flooring Ŷ Recycling and sustainable surfaces Ŷ Commercial, industrial & healthcare

216.431.6551 1567 E. 40th St. Q Cleveland, Ohio 44103

22

INDUSTRY LEADER SINCE 1946 Exclusive | Focused | Informative | Dependable | Connected www.Propertiesmag.com

Properties | February 2018


SIZABLE COLLECTION ‘Making Miniatures,’ an exhibit featuring an extensive collection of dollhouses and dolls (top), resides within a series of interconnected rooms on the museum’s second floor (bottom).

turns than almost all my other projects,” Panzica recalls. “Moreover, the hurdles to overcome were overwhelming.” Cleveland Development Advisors (CDA) provided an $8 million New Markets Tax Credit (NMTC). Chase served as the NMTC investor and Huntington National Bank provided a bridge loan for capital campaign pledges. This project marked the first loan made from CDA’s Community Reinvestment Fund. “We invested in this project because of the strong community impacts,” says CDA President Yvette Ittu. “The larger building and Midtown location would ensure even more children and families benefit from this educational and cultural resource.” By the end of 2015, the museum had raised $4 million in donations and it was time to begin design work in earnest.

Ideal project for a design-build team An RFP was issued in February 2016. “With such a massive old building, we adopted the design/build delivery approach in order to match our targeted budget with the best design possible,” explains Panzica. “The Krill Co., Inc. was chosen as our design/builder and they brought on board AoDK as their design architect.” “Myers University had done considerable improvements with the electrical and mechanical systems, so that made this project feasible,” says Doug Fischback, senior project manager with The Krill Co., Inc. “One of our first challenges was to track down all the pipes that had frozen during the many years the building sat vacant.” The final remaining issue left by prior ownership was the clay pipe sanitary sewer line which ran up to Euclid Avenue. Concerned that a backup could be devastating to all the displays being installed on the lower level, Krill proceeded to create all new sewer lines running out toward Chester at the rear of the property. “Fortunately, we discovered a manhole in the back corner of the property which enabled us to save approximately $50,000 by not having to core www.propertiesmag.com 23


Suntrol It! SUNTROL

™

G L A S S

E N H A N C I N G

F I L M S

Suntrol.com 800-466-TINT(8468) ESTABLISHED 1975

Love Your Windows!

Select Pro Window Film Dealer: • Security • Privacy/Custom • Energy Savings • Glare Reduction • Sun Protection

SIGNS OF THE PAST Existing architectural elements take on a new look throughout. For example, a series of archways with semicircular transoms have been retained, but now incorporate playful new signage.

2008-2015

24

drill out into the center of Chester Avenue,” says Fischback. “As we got into the project, the client already had a pretty good idea of where they wanted to place their main exhibits,” says John Swidrak, project architect with AoDK Inc. “That work was originally to be done by independent exhibit designers and fabricators. Our initial scope was limited to some painting, remodeling bathrooms and doing the outer shell. But, as the project progressed, we looked at this as a comprehensive project and said, if we are going to do this right, let’s look at some additional team members to bring in, and that’s when we brought in Richardson Design.” The team then considered building all the large exhibits locally. Krill would be involved, along with Ark Builders doing the main exhibit downstairs. “Once that decision was made, we could start to look at this as one cohesive plan,” adds Swidrak. “Circulation was then our next big challenge, wanting to utilize as many of the existing arched openings as possible on the first floor. We even considered removing the stair at one point, but we did want to retain the character of the building.” “It was too low for code compliance, and the banisters were too far apart,” says Jim O’Donnell, project superintendent for Krill. “So, the entire railing system Properties | February 2018


Photo by Hattie Kotz Photography

ACTIVE LEARNING AREAS Science-based play finds a home in ‘Wonder Lab’ with a captivating mix of interactive exhibits on the lower level.

was removed, laid out on the floor, and each banister was increased eight inches in length. As we reassembled it, one-byones were added between each banister to make it safe for children.”

Navigating the mansion “One of the big challenges was how to aid the children and their parents in navigating this massive space,” says Tracy van der Kuil, senior designer with Richardson Design. “Considering budgets and impact, it made the most sense to achieve this with paint and color, so we created color-coded portals to each of the exhibits and main museum areas. This concept worked its way into signage and graphics for a comprehensive wayfinding system throughout the building.” “I think the team really hit the mark for what we call sophisticated play,” adds Campanelli. “From the colors to the exhibit design, everything is fun and playful, but sophisticated enough to appeal to the parents and grandparents as well. After all, while our main clientele is two-, three- or four-years-old, it’s the parents or grandparents who drive them and have to want to come here.” “And yet, we wanted it to be something that the children would have designed for themselves,” explains van der Kuil.

“When they make things, colors don’t always match, or when building things, lines don’t always have to be straight.” Throughout the space, there are hints to this being a ‘Cleveland’ museum. Interface carpet tile is used throughout the main areas depicting paths you may find in the Metroparks, and a custom col-

into the ticketing area. From there, families pass by, not through, the gift shop and into the large coat room with space for dozens of coats and strollers. Blue and green organizer bins are available above the coat racks for diaper bags, snacks, gloves, hats and all the other paraphernalia families need to bring along. Off to the other side of the entry is a large eating area, where families are encouraged to bring their own snacks or order from local restaurants for a little ‘down time’ between activities. The feature attraction on the first floor is ‘Arts and Parts’ where children can create their own art creations with a variety of materials and tools available. Across from the art room Tracy van der Kuil is a smaller ‘Sensory Friendly Room’ Richardson Design for those children who prefer smaller spaces with less commotion or noise. ored grey carpet tile represents the more Downstairs on the lower level are two urban idea of concrete found throughout of the largest activity areas. ‘Adventure our city. In ‘Adventure City,’ people will City’ challenges children to build, to be quick to notice hints to the West Side climb, and use their imaginations as they Market and a large drawbridge. work their way through stairways, balconies and two-story lookouts. A fully equipped farmer’s market Touring the property Entering the mansion from its Euclid- offers artificial produce complete with facing entrance, people will be impressed a weighing scale. Boxes and seating of with the grandness of the architecture. child-friendly sizes can be rearranged, Wide, wooden trimmed archways with whatever the group setting. In the consemi-circular glass transoms lead visitors struction area, children can don safety

“We created color-coded portals to each of the exhibits and main museum areas. This concept worked its way into signage and graphics for a comprehensive wayfinding system throughout the building.”

www.propertiesmag.com 25


PROPERTIES FOR LEASE & FOR SALE The Bolivar Building 1020 Bolivar Road Cleveland, OH Details: Up to 108,000 SF available. 36,000 SF per floor FOR SALE OR FOR LEASE Enginehouse No. 3 1325 Carnegie Ave. Cleveland, OH Details: 4,185 SF

FOR LEASE Brownell Development 1340 Sumner Ave. Cleveland, OH Details: Up to 13,500 SF

FOR LEASE Brownell Development 1320 Sumner Ave. Cleveland, OH

American Book Bindery 1104 Prospect Ave. Cleveland, OH

Details: 5,000 SF

Details: 1 and 2 bedroom Units and Lofts Available for Purchase

FOR LEASE

FOR SALE

Providing World Class Office, Apartments & Parking Services Throughout Northeast Ohio 1325 Carnegie Ave., Cleveland, Ohio 44115 / 216-621-9255 www.thefrangosgroup.com / www.americanbookcondos.com


Photo by Hattie Kotz Photography

TAKING A BREAK Loaded with books, cushioned seats and recessed alcoves, the reading nook offers a respite from higher-energy activities.

vests and begin constructing their own walls and partitions with wooden slats and posts that interconnect, reminiscent of the old Lincoln Log construction sets. The “Reading Nook” is loaded with books and comfortable, cushioned seats and recessed alcoves. Also on the lower level is the ‘Wonder Lab.’ With magnetic connecting tubes on the walls, balls can be set in motion or scarfs can be launched into the air. Two water tables offer dozens of ways to have fun while getting wet. Raincoats are provided. The floors throughout this area are a special slip-resistant material with a small raised-knob design. Multiple party rooms are available downstairs for parties of up to 50 people. The second level is home to an extensive collection of dolls and dollhouses. “During our fundraising campaign, I ran into Cathy Lincoln, who traveled the world with her mother, collecting dolls,” says Campanelli. “That inspired her to start creating dollhouses. As her collection grew, she wanted to see them in a dollhouse

plans are already underway to expand the museum into other areas of the mansion. ‘The Meadows’ will be the next exhibit opened, especially for infants and toddlers. “Acting as owner’s rep, I am incredibly proud of the entire team and the small role I was able to play in bringing this to reality,” Panzica says. “Collaboration and compromise are many times over-used words; but, they most aptly describe the team’s approach in successfully completing this project.” “The level of play, supported by this environment, has even exceeded our expectations,” says Campanelli. John Swidrak “She’s right,” adds Swidrak. “We’ve floored by the level of creativity AoDK Inc. been shown by the kids using these areas. We kind of set the stage, but they conFamily learning guides on the wall tinue to come up with amazing things.” Open six days a week, and closed point out ways children of all ages can benefit from a discussion about the on Thursdays, the museum is once again ready to welcome all children homes they see. with their parents and grandparents. For more information about The Children’s An instant success While attendance during these first Museum of Cleveland, go to their website couple months has been tremendous, at CMCleveland.org. P museum, although she had no desire to operate the museum herself. ‘Making Miniatures’ is now the display space resulting from us having collided.” Multiple rooms interconnect, displaying large dollhouses, from formal mansions to stucco haciendas and from a safari camp to a Gothic greenhouse.

“We’ve been floored by the level of creativity shown by the kids using these areas. We kind of set the stage, but they continue to come up with amazing things.”

www.propertiesmag.com 27


LEADING THE WAY OCP Contractors’ management team includes (from left) Senior Project Manager Matt Yaros, President Ed Sellers, General Superintendent Tom Lutgring and Vice President-Preconstruction Services Brian Exl

OCP Contractors: Defining the Skyline Northeast Ohio’s largest interior contractor continues strategic growth By Doug Bardwell | Photos courtesy of OCP Contractors

he firm’s slogan is ‘Defining the Skyline’ and is quite appropriate, since they have completed a majority of the new buildings in Cleveland, Toledo and Columbus. With three offices, OCP has become Northern Ohio’s largest interior contractor.

T

OCP Cleveland employs a significant number of tradespeople in Northeast Ohio, while statewide OCP keeps over 500 employees working. An average year’s business consists of typically 200 or more projects, roughly 50/50 private and public.

Service to their clients A list of the company’s services from their LinkedIn page reads like a list of the newest and most sophisticated construction techniques: BIM, LEAN construction, Total Station, Integrated Project Delivery (IPD), pre-construction services, design/build, prefabrication & panelization, metal framing & drywall, acoustical, EIFS, millwork, specialty services and paint28

work for have a lot on their plate, and we provide more construction management services [like conceptual estimating] for our clients than anyone else in this city. It’s one of the things that sets us apart.” “The other thing that we stress is openness and honesty. We keep exact records for all our projects, from budgeting through construction, enabling us to easily submit costs verifications whenever Ed Sellers to requested. That’s what gets us the OCP Contractors majority of integrated project delivery work in town.” all their needs, not just a narrow list of things an interiors contractor Begun in 1968 might typically offer,” explains OCP In Toledo, during the mid-1980s, President Ed Sellers. “The CM’s we under a Bowling Green State University ing, plus spray-on fire protection and spray foam insulation. “When we work with clients, we listen intently – trying to understand

“When we work with clients, we listen intently – trying to understand all their needs, not just a narrow list of things an interiors contractor might typically offer.”

Properties | February 2018


Defining THE Skyline®

ocpcoc.com


BASWA a c o u s t i c ®

HAPPY 50TH ANNIVERSARY

OCP CONTRACTORS Certified Installer of All Steel Mid-Rise CFS Framing Systems Partner on Build Ohio Award Winning AC Hotel by Marriott, Dublin, Ohio

allsteelmidrise.com

30

833-MIDRISE (643-7473)

Properties | February 2018


REPRESENTATING A BRAND “Everyone has a reputation, and our employees’ reputations drive our firm’s reputation,” says OCP President Ed Sellers, noting the company is proud to support its employees with robust training and benefit plans.

internship, Matt Townsend began working for Ohio Ceiling & Partitions, which had been founded in 1968 by Barney Paskiet. In 1995, to reflect Ohio Ceiling and Partitions’ growing capabilities, the firm’s name was changed to OCP Contractors. Two years later, Matt Townsend purchased the majority of stock in OCP and became president. With an eye to expand the firm, he looked for someone to head up an office in Cleveland.

Branching out In 2004, Sellers partnered with Townsend, opening the Cleveland office. “Our initial hope was for OCP Cleveland to be as successful as our office in Toledo had been for over 35 years,” says Townsend. Due to Sellers and Townsend’s combined reputations and the fantastic team built in Cleveland, that is exactly what happened. “The relationships that many of our employees in the Cleveland market had from their very experienced past employment, played a huge roll in our success in the Cleveland market,” asserts Townsend. With his reputation for honesty, dependability and creativity, Sellers had no trouble finding projects in even some of Cleveland’s slowest years. The Cleveland office’s first project was the Cleveland Clinic’s parking garage at East 93rd. Being a ‘Clinic-Approved’ contractor meant substantial work would follow. In its first year, the team landed more than $5 million worth of projects.

“We’re doing a lot of design assist and integrated project delivery,“ says Sellers. “We’re far more active on the front end of jobs than we were in the 1990s. It’s a much more sophisticated delivery now.”

In 2009, with OCP continuing to land prestigious projects, the firm opened its third office, OCP of Columbus. Two years later, Sellers was named president of OCP as Townsend became CEO.

www.propertiesmag.com 31


Photo by Maguire Photographic

BIG DEAL 2013 was a historic year for OCP as the firm completed its largest ever contract – the $16 million combined Cleveland Convention Center and Medical Mart, now known as the Huntington Convention Center and Global Center for Health Innovation.

2013 would become a historic year for OCP Contractors as the firm began its prefabricated component system, enabling much of the field work to be preassembled before being delivered to the jobsite. “We typically have a team of carpenters in the shop prefabbing much of our material. They can make whatever multi-repetitious item is needed for the project,” explains Brian Exl, vice-president of Pre-Construction Services.

32

It was also a historic year as the firm completed its largest ever contract – the $16 million combined Cleveland Convention Center and Medical Mart, now known as the Huntington Convention Center and Global Center for Health Innovation. By the end of 2013, OCP Cleveland completed projects including the 600,000-square-foot Eaton Center campus in the Chagrin Highlands of Beachwood, and the sevenstory, 639,000-square-foot Goodyear

Global Headquarters in Akron. More than 100 tradespeople were employed on each project. Perceiving further opportunities, the firm expanded once again in 2015, adding a certified spray insulation group. “This gives us the opportunity to create a continuous insulation system over the exterior sheathing, creating a great air barrier,” says Exl. The firm’s package now covered most all specialties from CSI Division

Properties | February 2018


Photo by Maguire Photographic

POWER IN NUMBERS OCP employed more than 100 tradespeople on the 639,000-square-foot Goodyear Global Headquarters project in Akron.

6 through Division 10. “And, if the CM needed someone to handle dock equipment, we’d add that in as well – whatever it took to meet a customer’s needs,” says Sellers. “In-house, we utilize just about every technology possible to make sure we serve our clients better,” asserts Sellers. “We use AutoCAD, Revit, BIM, Rhino, and we’ve even added Total Station where all components can be laid out on X, Y and Z coordinates. When we see the door crack, we push it open.” Sellers has always been interested in doing things that haven’t been done before. Over the years, he has developed many construction techniques that would eventually revolutionize the interiors construction business, such as prefabrication. “We now precut and preassemble everything possible before

www.propertiesmag.com 33


Photo by Feinknopf

Register Now! 66th Annual Design & Construction Conference & Tradeshow TUESDAY, MARCH 20, 2018 LaCentre Conference & Banquet Center Westlake, OH Featuring Keynote Speakers: Matthew Zone 15th Ward Council Member City of Cleveland President National League of Cities

EARLY ADOPTER OCP Contractors was a regional pioneer of prefabrication, notes Ed Sellers, president. “We now precut and preassemble everything possible before sending it to the jobsite,” he says. “The Hard Rock Rocksino project was probably sent out 85% preassembled.”

sending it to the jobsite. The Hard Rock Rocksino project was probably sent out 85% preassembled.” “Another of our projects utilizing precut and preassembly was the Oatey World Headquarters, where again, probably better than 50% of the materials were precut before delivery,” says Exl, noting that while unions were initially worried that preassembly was all about eliminating labor, they’ve come to realize that the work can now be done more safely and more conveniently in a shop environment. “OCP is constantly pushing new technology,” Townsend says. “In 2017 alone, we implemented a new ERP, production tracking technology and

increased our push statewide into greater opportunities in prefabrication. Additionally, we are increasing our use of robotic layout, consistent use of tablet software on our projects and new technology in our prefab operations. We also continue to grow our use of BIM not only in precon but also internally to provide greater project coordination. Implementing greater use of technology within OCP has greatly helped our growth.”

Service to the industry In addition to running one of the most successful interiors firms, Sellers makes time to give back to the industry where he found his success. Over

Bill Koehler Chief Executive Officer Team NEO

Register or see more details at www.cesnet.org. -!'!:).% ).#

is a proud media sponsor of the Cleveland Engineering Society 34

Properties | February 2018


the years, he’s been president of AGC of Ohio and Cleveland AGC (Associated General Contractors), and is the current president of AWCI (Association of the Wall and Ceiling Industry). He is presently chairman of the Construction Employers Association (CEA) and serves on the Carpenters’ Pension Board. Having been involved with AWCI since 2006, Sellers has had the opportunity to travel the world meeting other interior contractors and sharing ideas. “I’ve incorporated dozens of ideas I’ve discovered and happily share those ideas and techniques with other contractors outside our market.”

Service to their employees Where too many contractors claim RECEIVING RECOGNITION In 2017, OCP won a Build Ohio award for its work on the AC Hotel “our employees are our biggest asset,” by Marriott, located in Dublin, Ohio. Receiving the prize on behalf of OCP Contractors were OCP puts them to shame with its (from left) Matt Townsend, Brian Exl, Clark Townsend, Halie Townsend, Matt Vander Hooven, training and benefit plans. Since Ed Sellers and Brian Stone. its inception, Townsend and Sellers CEA’s involvement in its Community about that, most often exceeding OSHA have promoted annual bonuses and Benefits effort. “We are constantly requirements,” says Exl. “We also offer profit sharing. While other companies may fear advocating that contractors bring other project-specific training for those training their employees will make them the inner-city community into the doing things like project management or easy targets for their competitors, OCP trades,” explains Sellers. “We also project estimating.” “We have a high-performance aims to offer its people the best culture that allows our employtraining available, like sending them ees to thrive,” explains Townsend. to the Lean Construction Institute. “Safety is first not only on our “Lean construction is a core value jobsites but also in everything that of what you can expect when you we do. Our culture centers around have OCP on your team along with life balance, along with an aggresIPD and design assist project delivery sion to win. We have an answer methods,” says Townsend. to the issue or problem at hand “Everyone has a reputation, and rather than a ‘no’. Training is our employees’ reputations drive Matt Townsend ongoing, and we push innovation. our firm’s reputation,” philosoOCP Contractors We work hard and play hard.” phizes Sellers. Family-friendly is another The workforce at OCP reflects diversification, both in gender and love to match millennials with our description that aptly fits OCP. race, and the firm advocates strongly older workers. We found that they Family outings and employee perks are common and enjoyed by all the staff. for programs to encourage more both benefit from the matchup.” The firm also provides its people with “Our other big focus is safety trainparticipation in the construction industry. OCP eagerly lobbied for the ing for all employees. We are very strict the top technology available, from iPads

“Our culture centers around life balance, along with an aggression to win. We have an answer to the issue or problem at hand rather than a ‘no’. Training is ongoing, and we push innovation. We work hard and play hard.”

www.propertiesmag.com 35


We’re Out to Clean Up This Town SWEEPING PRESSURE WASHING CONSTRUCTION SITES PARKING LOTS & DECKS WAREHOUSES SPECIAL EVENTS FLUSHING

330.798.9200 | WWW.BUCKEYESWEEPING.COM

Cleveland Chemical Pest Control • Comprehensive, Integrated Pest Control • Pre-Treatment for Construction Sites/ Foundations • FHA/VA/HUD Termite Inspections, Treatments • Wild Animal, Bat Removal & Bird Control

18400 S. Waterloo Rd., Cleveland, OH 44119 | 216-481-8400

www.clevelandchemical.com

Congratulations to OCP on 50 Years of Success.

3848 Prospect Ave., Cleveland, Ohio 44115 216-696-8340 • suttonhardware.com 36

Photo by Ken Krych

Family Owned & Operated in Northeast Ohio Since 1903!

TAKING SHAPE OCP’s diverse project portfolio includes Hilton Cleveland Downtown, which opened in 2016.

and Plan Grid, to an Oracle-powered comprehensive software package. “We know our competition is watching what we do and are quick to pick things up that have worked for us,” says Sellers. “OCP is very entrepreneurial and willing to take risks into new opportunities and expand our capabilities,” adds Townsend. “We believe it is OK to have a few mini failures to ultimately reach greater success and lessons learned. There is a willingness at OCP to try new things and to do business better. Expansion is always on the horizon geographically and through a diversified range of work scope.”

Contractor of Choice “One of the many reasons OCP has been successful over the past 50 years is that we are continually pushing to be the best at managing project schedules and always work to beat the project end date,” Townsend says. Focusing on his customers’ needs and the development of his team, Sellers is in an enviable position for the foreseeable future. Their reputation with customers is unmatched anywhere in the state, and their 50-plus awards attest to the quality of their work. “We like to use as our tagline, ‘Contractor of Choice’,” adds Sellers. “But, you can’t use that as a tagline if you don’t measure up, so that’s what we are always striving for.” P Properties | February 2018


Promoting Progress.

Serving Northeast Ohio For Over 60 Years! Residential Ŷ Commercial Ŷ Industrial Ŷ Institutional

TODAY 2017 ,16,'( 'HYHORSHUV 'LYHUVLILHG 5HDOW\ +4 7ULSRLQW 0HGLFDO &HQWHU 3K\VLFLDQV 3DYLOLRQ

December 2009/$6.95

2010 -VY^HYK 7YVNYLZZ

2000

,16,'( 6WRQHEULGJH 3OD]D 1DJHOH 0DQXIDFWXULQJ &R 6HFXULW\ )LUH 3UHYHQWLRQ

G[lgZ]j *((/' .&1-

<UP]LYZP[` VM (RYVU JOH <UP]LYZP[` VM (RYVU JOHYNLZ HOLHK ^P[O UL^ 0UMV*PZPVU :[HKP\T :\TTH -PLSK

73<:!

)<03; ;6 :<0; A special i l llook k att C Con Construction struction t ti n Management in Northeast Ohio

1990

HIGHFLYING

DESIGN Celebrated Viennese architectural firm creates new Akron Art Museum addition as cultural beacon

INSIDE: Wellington Place • East Hall at Hiram College • Security & Fire Prevention

PLUS

1980

Cleveland Clinic Courts equips quips Cavs with aining facility state-of-the-art athletic training

October 2008/$6.95

1970 1960

Class C las la las aass ssss Act A

Dramatic Dram matic mati a ic renovation renov re-im reima ma agines Hanna Ha re-imagines Theatre for as permanent a perm rmanent home h Great Theater Festival Grea at LLakes akes The

Expert Brick Matching and Complete Inventory of Brick, Block, Masonry, Cast & Natural Stone, Plaster Products & Tools

1950 1946

INDUSTRY LEADER SINCE 1946 Exclusive | Focused | Informative | Dependable | Connected

16900 Rockside Rd., Maple Heights, OH 44137

www.Propertiesmag.com

216.791.9800 Ŷ www.bruderinc.com

Congratulations on your business milestone. We thank you for each and every opportunity to share in your success.

Founded on Principle, Built with Purpose 5245 W. 130th St., Parma, OH 44130 | 216-265-8260 | www.fbmsales.com www.propertiesmag.com 37


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans

Cushman & Wakefield | CRESCO Real Estate Welcomes Senior VP ushman & Wakefield | CRESCO Real Estate recently announced that Jason Laver, SIOR has joined the firm as senior vice president. He joins Cushman & Wakefield | CRESCO after a 17-year affiliation with Independence-based Dalad Group, a developer of office, industrial and historic redevelopment throughout the Cleveland market. Laver brings over 20 years of experience with a broad range of real estate transactions, including landlord and tenant representations, land sales and purchases, lease buyouts, built-to-suits and sale leasebacks. His portfolio of assignments include award-winning engagements with national and local users, and receiving awards from NAIOP for New Office Building Development, Office Building Jason Laver Redevelopment, Multi Family Redevelopment and Office Lease Transaction of the Year. In addition to his work on behalf of real estate developers, owners and tenants, Laver leads an economic development consulting practice that represents municipalities.

C

Brouse McDowell Announces New Partner & Practice Chair Appointments Regional business law firm Brouse McDowell recently announced Alexandra V. Dattilo has been elected as partner in the firm, and Daniel L. Silfani has been named co-chair of the firm’s Corporate & Securities Practice Group. Dattilo is a member of the firm’s Litigation and Insurance Coverage Practice Groups. She has experience SUPERIOR INSULATING

with all aspects of litigation including representing clients in mediations, arbitrations and court hearings. Silfani, a member of the firm’s Executive Committee, will also serve as the Corporate and Security’s practice chair for the Akron office. He has a broad range of expertise in all aspects of corporate law and transactions, franchise and business opportunity law, as well as various public finance matters. This includes franchise development and operations,

mergers and acquisitions, joint ventures, general corporate counseling, and acting as issuer’s, underwriters or bond counsel with respect to taxable and tax-exempt conduit bond transactions.

SAFETY & SECURITY

ENERGY CONSERVATION

R.G. Nieto Expands Into MultiFamily Management R.G. Nieto Co., a local property management company specializing in shopping center management exclusively for over 40 years, has recently expanded into multi-

family, according to Bob Nieto, president. The company is now comanaging with a firm out of Dallas, Texas the 468-unit Cottage Cove Apartment complex in Miami Florida. This is not its first Florida venture as the company has also participated in the brokerage of Florida shopping centers as well.

KS Associates Names Coastal Engineering Services Director Elyria-based civil engineering and land surveying firm KS Associates, Inc. recently announced the promotion of Mark P. Cencer, P.E., to director of Coastal Engineering Services. In his new role, Cencer leads the KS Associates Coastal Engineering Group in providing planning, design and construction engineering services for all types of waterfront infrastructure, with a focus on projects along the Great Lakes and inland bodies of water throughout Ohio. Since joining KS Associates in 2013, Cencer has assumed increasing levels of responsibility, overseeing important waterfront projects DECORATIVE

www.SunrayFilms.com

800.295.8468

A Female & Minority Owned Company “It’s Always a Sunny Day at Sunray!”

38

Authorized Dealer & Applicator

Properties | February 2018


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans

for diverse clients. Recent work includes performing an assessment of infrastructure at the Cleveland-Cuyahoga County Cleveland Bulk Terminal on Whiskey Island, and leading the design of necessary improvements; serving as project manager for the new fishing pier and shoreline protection at Lake Metroparks’ Painesville Township Park; working with Cleveland Metroparks on several waterfront improvements including designing infrastructure to support water taxis on the Cuyahoga River, improvements to E. 55th Street Marina, and several lakefront park and beach enhancements; and designing repairs to the shoreline

Science Degree in Ocean Engineering from Florida Institute of Technology. He is also an NAUI Certified Open Water Diver.

Meyers Roman Announces Managing Partner, Committee Leaders

Mark P. Cencer

of Burke Lakefront Airport after it suffered damage from Superstorm Sandy. Cencer is a professional engineer licensed in Ohio, Michigan and Florida. He has a Bachelor of Science Degree and a Master of

Meyers, Roman, Friedberg & Lewis recently announced that Seth P. Briskin has been named the firm’s new managing partner. In addition, partners Bryan J. Dardis and Jenifere R. Singleton have been elected to leadership positions on the firm’s Management Committee. Briskin succeeds Peter Turner, who is stepping down after six years of service and

Seth Briskin

will continue in his role as chair of the firm’s Civil and Commercial Litigation practice. In its 20+ years, Meyers Roman has been led by two managing partners – Anne Meyers, founding partner, and Turner. Briskin

www.propertiesmag.com 39


What’s New? Promote your company announcements and events here in the Billboard section of Properties. Best of all, it’s FREE! Add us to your mailing list: billboard@propertiesmag.com Southside High

Public Square Cleveland

Tulane University Freeman Business School

Wooster Community Hospital

Integrated Project Solutions BIM Coordination Services • Site Logistics • 3D Content Creation Revit® • Navisworks® • 3D Studio Max • Residential Design

INDUSTRY LEADER SINCE 1946

MIKE FURLONG, CM-BIM Managing Principal

Exclusive | Focused | Informative | Dependable | Connected

330.414.9970 | mike@iprojsolutions.com | www.iprojsolutions.com

www.Propertiesmag.com

*/%6453: -&"%&3 */ )*() 26" - * 5 : %0 $ , %0 0 3 4 & 37 * $ & ."* /5 & /" / $ &

Opening New Doors

COMMERCIAL / INDUSTRIAL / INSTITUTIONAL ONE-SOURCE FOR:

4"*/5 $-"*3 "7&/6& .&/503 0)*0

www.commercialdockanddoor.com 40

Ì &/53"/$& %0034 Ì 3&70-7&34 Ì *$6 %0034 Ì 4.0,& 3"5&% %0034 Ì "%" %0034

440.951.4541 Properties | February 2018


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans

will be the firm’s third, and youngest, managing partner and will continue to serve as chair of the Labor & Employment Group. Briskin will work with Dardis and Singleton to set the firm’s strategic direction, oversee firm governance and business operations, and cultivate the firm’s entrepreneurial culture. Dardis acts as outside general counsel to closely held companies, real estate developers, lenders, manufacturers, contractors and service providers throughout all life cycle stages, including startup and organization, growth, maturity and exit. He previously served as the firm’s co-marketing chair for two years. He is a board member for NAIOP Northern Ohio and Greater Cleveland Mortgage Bankers’ Association. Singleton has worked in the firm’s Divorce and Family Law Group for 15 years. In her role as the firm’s Administrative Partner on the Management Committee,

Stephen Taylor

she provides constructive feedback and resolutions to address administrative issues, while also providing assistance in guiding the direction of the firm.

Hasenstab Architects Announces Staff Additions Hasenstab Architects recently announced the hire of James Marshaus, RA and Stephen Taylor. Marshaus joins the firm as a project manager specializing in healthcare design. He brings more than 36 years

of architectural experience to the Hasenstab team, having managed a multitude of projects for the leading healthcare systems throughout the region. With more than 45 years of experience, Taylor brings a thorough understanding of the design and construction process. He has been involved in the development, design and project management of numerous large-scale facility upgrades for healthcare, education, research, corporate office and religious clients throughout Northeast Ohio. Both Marshaus and Taylor will be working out of Hasenstab’s Cleveland office.

Omni Title Welcomes Title & Escrow Officer Omni Title LLC recently announced that Julie Barnhart has joined the firm as a title and escrow officer. She previously served as senior title officer for another respected independent title

Julie Barnhart

agency for 25 years, and she has experience as a commercial title examiner, advancing multi-million dollar transactions from inception through post-closing. Barnhart has been a licensed title agent in Wisconsin, Michigan and Ohio. She has a degree in paralegal studies from Madison College. P WHAT’S NEW? For coverage within Billboard, send along company news, story ideas and project information to billboard@propertiesmag.com.

Come C ome s see ee u us s iin n Booth B ooth 1136 1136 a att tthe he NPE N PE 2 2018 018 s show! how! Use U se V VIP IP c code ode MIDWEST MIDWEST ffor or free free entry! entry!

SEALCOAT • STRIPING Crack Fill - Signage - Parking Blocks 216.310.4314

MidwestPLM.com

WBE / FBE / SBE / LPE / EDGE www.propertiesmag.com 41


)DEULFDWLRQ ,QVWDOODWLRQ 6HUYLFH

UV LQ \HD U H Y R RU OL]LQJ I 6SHFLD U URRIWRS G H J D RW ZDWH K 3DFN P GLQJ ¥ VWHD ZHO Q R L W D F %RLOHUV L U HWDO IDE HOGLQJ 6KHHWP ULFDWLRQ Z IDE QW J 3ODVWLF LQHHULQ QFH GHSDUWPH J Q H G HQD 9DOXH PDLQW H F L Y U H )XOO V

director@aiacleveland.com

ZZZ OLVFRKYDF FRP 6WDWH 5G 1 5R\DOWRQ 2+

42

Properties | February 2018


BOMA BUSINESS Exploring timely topics with BOMA members

Selecting Proper Cleaning Products id you know a building’s restroom(s) is usually the source of the most complaints for a facility manager? It is a high-traffic area, and its appearance has a huge impact on how individuals possibly view the entire facility.

D

Regular cleanings are essential of course, but perhaps just as important is the selection of the best cleaning solutions and products to create a positive experience for building occupants and guests. Here are some tips on determining the best products for your facility.

Trusted products It is important to select products from a brand your employees and visitors trust and know. For example, we have conducted research that shows having a trusted brand in the restroom and throughout the facility leaves people with a more positive impression of a facility, as well as thoughts on its cleanliness overall. This demonstrates the power a brand can have on your facility’s image. Look for trusted, recognizable brands when selecting products for your restroom and facility. This will give your employees and visitors added confidence that you care.

Products for health and well-being Hand hygiene is one of the most important measures any of us can take to help reduce the spread of germs that can cause illness. This is why it is critical to select hand hygiene products – soaps and an alcohol-based hand sanitizer – that people want to use. Formulation matters, and it is important to select products that are efficacious, pleasant to use and either improve or maintain skin health. Having these products present can help to encourage the practice of good hand

PURELLR Brand HEALTHY SOAP R with CLEAN RELEASE™ Technology Reaches into skin’s cracks and crevices to remove more dirt and germs than regular soap.1,2,3 Remarkably mild, free of harsh preservatives and antibacterial ingredients. Good for you and the environment.

hygiene, and, in turn, help to reduce the spread of illness-causing germs.

Maintenance ease Products that help a facility’s staff also help to minimize complaints about the restroom. For example, select soap systems that are sanitary sealed. These types of refills feature factory-sealed refills that help lock out germs and help protect the health of restroom users. New dispenser innovation has also come onto the market. In addition to featuring refill design that provides facility managers and staff with the ability to see, not guess, when a dispenser is getting low, this new dispenser innovation also comes with energy on the refill. This means facility managers no longer have to worry about replacing batteries. In addition, today, facility management can use technology to monitor restroom traffic to ensure soap, hand sanitizer and other consumables, such as toilet paper, are stocked and operational. While we may not be able to eliminate all complaints, know there is a solution to help minimize them. Learn more at www.GOJO.com/office. P BOMA Greater Cleveland is proud to provide this space to our Associate Members so they can inform, educate and share their knowledge with property management professionals. This article was written by Thom Wojtkun, market development director of GOJO Industries, Inc. Wojtkun can be reached at 330-255-6647 or WojtkunT@GOJO.COM. GOJO Industries, Inc. can be found on the web at www.gojo.com.

PURELL R ES8 Dispensing System R with Breakthrough Energy-on-the-Refill Technology Say goodbye to the two biggest service issues — dead batteries and empty refills. Each new AT-A-GLANCE™refill comes with a coin cell battery, so ES8 is always ready when you need it.

Game-Changing Innovation in Dispensing & Formulation

Introducing the PURELL SOLUTION™ To see the complete PURELL SOLUTION™, including specialized products for Healthcare, Foodservice, Education and Professional settings, visit www.PURELLSOLUTION.com.

1. Augustine Scientific, Newbury OH, Ex Vivo Soil Removal Analysis, August 5, 2017. 2. BioScience Laboratories, Inc.; Bozeman, MT, Study# 1707304-101, Evaluation of In-Vivo Germ Removal, August 22, 2017. 3. All references to regular soap are based on our top-selling non-antibacterial soap.

C 2018 GOJO Industries, Inc. All rights reserved.

www.propertiesmag.com 43


FINANCIAL STRATEGIES Smart use of fiscal planning & action

Tax Man Cometh aking up on January 1st is sometimes an adventure in uncertainty. Some of us, for example, may have chosen to blow that mental stop sign and knock back one more Old Fashioned. But the dawn of a new day brings certainty associated with these types of decisions.

W

ALEC J. PACELLA

For those of us involved in the commercial real estate industry, January 1st carried some extra uncertainty. The tax reformation act of 2017 was signed into law a mere six days prior and most of us were wondering how it would impact the industry going forward. If you are a frequent reader of this column (and shame on you if you aren’t), you know my stance on taxation as it relates to commercial real estate – I know just enough to be dangerous. My good friend Mark, the CPA, is part accountant and part guardian angel when it comes to my relationship with the IRS. I’m going to preface this month’s column as I do with all of my columns on the subject of taxation – relying on the advice of a trained tax professional is always a good idea. With this in mind, below are my opinions on the good news and

bad news associated with the items that impact our industry.

Like-kind exchanges The bad news: The use of Section 1031 Like Kind Exchanges was repealed for the majority of personal property, including art work, auto fleets, heavy equipment, race horses, etc. The good news: Real estate was excluded. In other words, the 1031 exchange is a tool that real estate investors can continue to use. This was a major item, as the loss of this tool most certainly would have a huge impact in the commercial real estate industry.

Carried interest The good news: Carried interest, or the ability for a real estate investor to have realized appreciation of real estate assets taxed at capital gains

Everything For Concrete, Except Concrete, Since 1910 THE LAKEWOOD SUPPLY

CONCRETE REPAIR PRODUCTS

COMPANY

• Concrete Restoration & Repair Materials • Granular Concrete Colors • Rebar Detailing/Fabrication & Assemblies

216.898.1113 4901 West 150th Street, Cleveland, Ohio 44135 • www.lakewoodsupplycompany.com 44

Properties | February 2018


rates versus ordinary income rates, made it through the revision. The bad news: Previously, an asset had to be held for at least one year in order to qualify as a long-term gain and thus be taxed at the lower capital gains rate. But under the new law, the time horizon has increased to three years in order to qualify.

Cost recovery (aka depreciation) The good news: The cost recovery schedules associated with nonresidential real property and residential rental property is unchanged, continuing at 39 years and 27.5 years, respectively. The to-be-determined news: The previous tax code included three additional categories for cost recovery purposes – qualified Restaurant, Leasehold and Retail Improvements. The new tax code has consolidated everything into one category, now called Qualified Improvement Property. However, everything I have read so far on this topic has been fairly ambiguous as to what this really means to the real estate owner/investor.

Daus, You Know? NO TIC-TAC-TOE, THREE IN A ROW Last summer, Tower at Erieview, 1100 Superior and Oswald Center were all put on the market. Six months later and all is quiet, with the latter two pulled from the market. –AP eligible to claim a 20% deduction for business-related income. For example, if an LLP owns an office building that generates $200,000 of income before taxes, the individual investors could avoid paying taxes on $40,000 of that income if they are eligible for the full 20% deduction.

income earned by sole proprietors, such as independent contractors, as well as by pass-through entities, such as partnerships, LLCs and S-corps, should also receive a reduction. The compromise contained in the final bill, as previously mentioned, was an upfront deduction of 20% for business income earned. The bad news: In order to be eligible for the 20% deduction, the business must be considered a ‘non-personal service business.’ These do NOT include businesses that provide health, law, consulting, athletics, financial services, brokerage services and ‘any business where the main asset of the business is the reputation or skill of one or more of its employees or owners.’ The good news (at least from some of us): Real estate practitioners are a listed exception from the non-personal service business category. Although there are guidelines and requirements, those in the real estate brokerage business can generally qualify for the 20% deduction.

For those of us involved in the commercial real estate industry, January 1st carried some extra uncertainty. The tax reformation act of 2017 was signed into law a mere six days prior and most of us were wondering how it would impact the industry going forward.

Low Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) The good news: This credit survived and is unchanged from the previous tax code. The (maybe) bad news: A significant change in the new tax code is a reduction in the corporate tax rate, from 35% to 21%. This could potentially decrease the value of these types of credits to corporations, as they are the usual end buyer of these credits.

Historic Rehabilitation Tax Credit The good news: The current 20% credit for certified historic structures will continue, unchanged from the previous tax code. For Cleveland, this was huge, as historic tax credits have been an integral component in most of the redevelopment projects that have occurred in the downtown area. The bad news: The 10% credit for pre-1936 buildings has been repealed, and the 20% credit associated with historic structures is now spread out over a five-year period, based on ratable share each year.

The to-be-determined news: The previously mentioned reduction in the corporate tax rate, from 35% to 21%, may cause investors to consider forming a corporation to own investment real estate as opposed to a partnership entity. However, I’ll be the first to admit that there is a myriad of other factors that can come into play on this one. There is no universal ‘right’ answer, as much will depend on the characteristics and goals of the investor as well as the real estate asset.

Deduction for qualified business income Because the new tax code dramatically decreases the corporate tax rate, there was an argument that business

As I mentioned at the outset, the ink is still drying on the tax code revisions and it will take weeks, if not months, to continue to sort out all of the ramifications. And I almost forgot one of the most important changes – at least come New Year’s Eve 2018. Under Section 179 Expensing, the new tax code has repealed the deduction associated with any activity generally considered to be entertainment. There goes that last Old Fashioned. P Alec Pacella, CCIM, senior vice president at NAI Daus, can be reached by phone at 216.455.0925 or by email at apacella@naidaus.com. You can follow him on twitter @dausyouknow or on his blog at http://blog.sbequitiesinc.com.

Pass-through income The good news: Individuals and family trusts that invest in real estate via partnership entities, such as LLPs, may be www.propertiesmag.com 45


ACAR CORNER Issues in the real estate industry

Realtors Offer 2018 Market Landscape his time of year has potential buyers and sellers reflecting on last year’s market data and examining the outlook for the next 12 months to better prepare themselves for entering the market and buying or selling a property.

T KAREN O’DONNELL

The number of sales and prices both increased in 2017. In 2018, existing-home sales are projected to be unchanged from 2017, at about 5.5 million sales, after rising the past three years, and the median home price will edge up only about 2%. One of the biggest expected challenges in 2018 will continue to be the low levels of inventory. The NAR (National Association of Realtors) Housing Opportunities and Market Experience (HOME) survey tracks topical real estate trends and renters’ and homeowners’ views and aspirations regarding homeownership. Released in December, the latest quarterly survey showed that at the end of 2017 a smaller share of homeowners believed that now is a good time to buy or sell a home, even with strong job creation and faster economic growth in the last months of 2017.

“Since rising to 62% in the third quarter of last year, optimism that now is a good time to buy slipped to 60%, from 57% a year ago,” says Karen O’Donnell, 2018 President of the Akron Cleveland Association of Realtors. The report also found that 76% of homeowners think now is a good time to list their home for sale, which is down from last quarter (80%) but up from a year ago (67%). This data should help potential buyers and sellers better understand the market environment and know what to expect in 2018. “The takeaways from this survey should help buyers and sellers who are heading into the market, and working with a real estate professional they can apply the lessons learned from the past year and expectations for the year ahead to achieve their home buying and selling goals,” O’Donnell says.

9G YQWNF DG RTQWF VQ DG RCTV QH [QWT VGCO QP [QWT PGZV EQPUVTWEVKQP RTQLGEV

CONTAINER SERVICE, INC.

¸;OL 3LHKLY PU *VU[HPULY :LY]PJL¹ -), *:) ,+., *,9;0-0,+

>>> 7,;,(5+7,;,05* *64 46

@6<9 *65:;9<*;065 :7,*0(30:;: .9,,5 3,,+ 7961,*;: @(9+ -965; 36(+ *65;(05,9: @(9+ 96336-- *65;(05,9: Properties | February 2018


As far as the inventory shortage goes, new construction is still falling short in many markets in alleviating the shrinking inventories of properties for sale. But builders are blaming the construction shortfall on a number of factors. Builders revealed the following top 10 “significant” problems they expect to face in 2018, according to the National Association of Home Builders and Wells Fargo Housing Market Index:

440.234.0700 | RICK@RMRIGGLE.COM 879 W. BAGLEY RD. | BEREA, OH 44017

1. Cost & availability of labor: 84% 2. Building material prices: 84% 3. Cost & availability of developed lots: 62% 4. Impact/hook up/inspection or other fees: 60% 5. Local/state environment regulations and policies: 45% 6. Inaccurate appraisals: 42% 7. Federal environment regulations and policies: 42% 8. Difficulty obtaining zoning/permit approval: 42% 9. Gridlock/uncertainty in Washington making buyers cautious: 42% 10. Development standards (parling, setbacks, etc.): 38% Once again for 2018, builders said the cost and availability of labor is their chief concern. The number of builders who are reporting this as a problem is growing. In 2017, 82% of builders said cost and availability of labor was their top concern; the percentage has grown to 84% of builders heading into 2018. The availability of labor started growing as a problem among builders since 2011. In 2011, just 13% of builders rated labor as a significant problem, but by 2012, the percentage jumped to 30% and has ever since continued to increase each year. “Both the availability of labor and lots highlight the expected constraints of a recovering housing market,” the NAHB reports. P

Karen O’Donnell is 2018 president of Akron Cleveland Association of Realtors. For more info, visit www.AkronClevelandRealtors.com. www.propertiesmag.com 47


MARKETING MENTOR Building value through creative communication

Leadership: The Pivotal Force eople want leadership! In business, sports, politics, government, religion or family, people crave effective leadership. Unfortunately, we see failed examples of leadership regularly splashed across all forms of communication media: in print (newspapers, magazines, journals, newsletters); via broadcast (television, radio, movie theaters); on the Internet (websites, blogs, twitter, RSS feeds, video feeds, YouTube); and in public relations (speeches, charity events, press releases, annual reports, sponsorships, joint ventures and alliances).

P

JIM CASTIGLIA

What leadership isn’t

So, how can we meet expectations – ours and all other stakeholders to whom we’ve made promises? How can we be an effective leader?

Leadership skills were once thought a matter of birth. Leaders were born, not made. This is the “Great Man” theory of leadership. The fortunate few held power; all others must be led. This view eventually failed to explain leadership and was replaced by the “Great Events” theory. George Washington just happened to be “on hand” when the American Revolution began. But, this point-of-view also failed to explain leadership. No matter where you stand on the political spectrum, we can agree that there is a crisis of leadership at the local, state and national levels. This crisis can be defined as “a pervasive incapacity to cope with expectations.”

Allow me to present a powerful perspective for you to consider: leadership is the wise use of power. Bertrand Russell once said, “The fundamental concept in social science is power, in the same sense in which energy is the fundamental concept in physics.” Power and its use are basic to understanding the art of leadership. Author and professor Rosabeth Moss Kanter, chair and director of Harvard’s Advanced Leadership Initiative, was one of the earliest international business gurus to focus on empowerment and its importance to organizational growth and sustainability.

Yet leadership is the pivotal force in any environment.

What leadership is

Subscribe Now & Save Over 80% Stay informed BCPVU the very best in construction and development in Northeast Ohio. Subscribe online or by phone at 216.251.8506. INSIDE : Cleveland

Clinic Rehabilitation

lding uilding l • Roofing/Buil Hospital • AkzoNobe

l e Envelope

INSIDE : SpringHill Suites Independence

• Hyatt Place at Legacy Village •

Building en Building Green G INSIDE : MetroHealth Brecksville

Sepptember 2016/$7.95 September

7.95 2016/$7.95 April 2016/$7

INSIDE : Larry Health & Surgery Center

Sears and Sally

• Renova Renovation ation & Restoration

October ober 2016/$7.95

Zlotnick Sears think[box] at CWRU

• Phoenix Buildin

g

January 2016/$7.9 5

INDUSTRY LEADER SINCE 1946 Celebrating 70 Years Since 1946

Exclusive | Focused | Informative | Dependable | Connected

www.Propertiesmag.com 48

ld The Schofield ing ake Reshap awaakens Building Reaw historic historic Renovation revives too new structure as home n Hotel apartments, Kimpton

q Public Square $50 million public-private project brings renewed energy to ti

Encore Resurgence on Performan nce cee the

Restoration specialists re-create e-createe Ohio Theatre’s original lobby bby design at Playhouse Square are

Waterfront

Flats Ea Eastt Bank Phase Ph e II sprou sp ts new residential, t entertainment dining & ex i

Properties | February 2018


Here are four components on which to focus to improve your leadership skills.

1. Vision Vision is the world as you define it, arranged the way you’d like to see it. What are the outcomes you want? What must you and your organization focus on to create that reality? And do you have the right people on board to accomplish your grand vision?

2. Communication

Finally, the great former leader of GE, Jack Welch, defined several characteristics of the best leaders as the E4: 1. Energy – Enormous energy and passion for the job 2. Energizer – Ability to motivate and energize others 3. Edge – Competitive spirit; instinctive drive; strong convictions 4. Execution – Deliver results

There are many obstacles to becoming an effective leader, but with study, awareness, flexibility, openness, hard work, focus and intention, you can learn and acquire advanced leadership skills. P Jim Castiglia is the founder of Business Street Fighter Consulting, LLC (www.BSF.consulting) and supports entrepreneurial business owners in their desire to quickly grow and maximize the value of their business. He can be reached by email at JimC@BSF.consulting or by phone at 919.900.7865.

World-renowned leadership expert Warren Bennis said a leader must be a social architect who understands the organization and shapes the way it works. I prefer Bennis’ “social architect” because it avoids the vagueness, rigidity

Vision is the world as you define it, arranged the way you’d like to see it. What are the outcomes you want? What must you and your organization focus on to create that reality? And do you have the right people on board to accomplish your grand vision? and intractability of a trendier buzzword you hear a lot today: “culture.” You as a social architect can actively and intentionally design and create an organizational culture that exactly fits your needs.

3. Trust Trust is the emotional glue that binds followers and leaders together. You may be tough, you may be demanding, you could even be disliked; but if your employees trust you, they will follow you.

4. Know thy self Do you know your strengths and vulnerabilities? Are you competent in the skills of listening, supporting others, dealing with conflict and helping others handle rapid change? Business is an emotional roller coaster with the highest highs and lowest lows. Can you navigate and redirect powerful negative emotions into productive, creative and positive ones? www.propertiesmag.com 49


Making Waves The Foundry Community Rowing & Sailing Center opens in transformed industrial complex By Carlo Wolff | Photos by Scott Pease

he logo of The Foundry Community Rowing & Sailing Center in Cleveland’s Flats depicts an anvil memorializing Cleveland’s history of industrial might. Today, The Foundry, which overlooks more than 500 feet of Cuyahoga River frontage, is singularly dedicated to Cleveland’s future, a robust one in which rowing and sailing play a major part.

T

“You know the expression, ‘Mistake on the lake?’” says Mike Trebilcock, referring to an ancient meme about Cleveland. “Let’s get the kids on the lake so future generations want to be on the lake.” Trebilcock is chairman of the board and CEO of MCPc, a technology services firm that developed The Foundry, a former manufacturing site on Columbus Road in Cleveland’s old industrial core. In partnership with MCPc Family Charities, Mike and his wife Gina bought the 2.7-acre site from Pipeline Development Co. for $3 million in 2015, and work began soon after with the design/build team of Kaczmar Architects Inc. and The Krill Company. Officially opened last September after more than two years of con50

struction, The Foundry has become a nationally recognized rowing and sailing center, aiming to turn boys

“You know the expression, ‘Mistake on the lake?’ Let’s get the kids on the lake so future generations want to be on the lake.”

to more than 50 public and private secondary schools from as far west as Sandusky. Trebilcock hopes The Foundry’s rapidly rising profile makes it a must-stop for the America’s Cup Satellite Series.

Landing a site

Trebilcock and MCPc Family Charities converted a site that at its inception in 1837 was home to Mike Trebilcock Cleveland’s first Catholic Church, St. Mary’s on the Flats. Other prior The Foundry incarnations included a soap factory, a heating and cooling equipment comand girls from middle and secondary pany, a lumber yard and the U.S. Bronze schools all over Northeast Ohio into Company. By the time MCPc got to it, world-class athletes. It is home to the however, it was largely vacant – and ripe Cleveland Foundry Juniors, catering for transformation. Properties | February 2018


Proud to be the mechanical contractor For the CLEVELAND FOUNDRY ROWING CENTER

MID STATE

DESIGN/BUILD

Geauga MECHANICAL

Proud Partner at The Cleveland Foundry

SHEET METAL FABRICATION

RESTORATION, INC.

INSTALLATION

Not too big. Not too small. Just right.

Masonry Restoration Specialists Since 1954

BUILDING AUTOMATION

*HDXJD 0HFKDQLFDO FRPELQHV %LJ &LW\ H[SHULHQFH DQG H[SHUWLVH ZLWK 6PDOO 7RZQ VHUYLFH DQG YDOXHV

SERVICE & MAINTENANCE GREEN BUILDING SERVICES

&KDUGRQ :LQGVRU 5RDG &KDUGRQ 2+ RIILFH _ ID[ ZZZ JHDXJDPHFKDQLFDO FRP

2+

Brick Repairs | Stone & Concrete Restoration Building Cleaning | Caulking/Tuckpointing | Water Repellents Lintels, Parapet & Terra Cotta Repairs/Replacement

2521 Monroe Avenue, Cleveland, Ohio 44113-4121 216.771.2112 www.midstaterestoration.com

BETWEEN THE WEATHER & YOU SINCE 1922

WARREN ROOFING WARREN ROOFING AND INSULATING COMPANY

Proud project partner at

THE FOUNDRY COMMUNITY ROWING & SAILING CENTER

Edgewater Beach House

Drury Plaza Hotel

The Foundry Community Rowing & Sailing Center

Commercial/Industrial Roofing + Architectural Sheet Metal

440.439.4404

Fax 440.439.7523

www.warrenroofing.com www.propertiesmag.com 51


PLACE IN HISTORY Located along the Cuyahoga River, the site has previously housed a church, a soap factory, a heating and cooling equipment company and the U.S. Bronze Company, and once served as a lumber yard. By the time MCPc got to it, however, the property was largely vacant – and ripe for transformation.

Getting six sturdy but weary structures ready for new use was demanding, according to David A. Kaplan, of Kaczmar Architects. “The biggest challenge was to convert structures built as a manufacturing facility to its current use,” he says. It meant converting a largely dormant, 65,000-square-foot complex to a multifunctional compound, which houses exercise equipment, event spaces, areas dedicated to education, and separate locker rooms for students and adults of both sexes. The second floor incorpo-

52

rates staff offices and conference rooms, with future plans for a complete kitchen.

Launching The Foundry The Krill Company worked closely with Kaczmar on conceptual plans, says David F. Fischback, Krill president and co-chairman. “A really important factor was [Mike Trebilcock’s] trust in the process and the design-build team,” he says. At the same time, both Fischback and Trebilcock acknowledge a certain degree of improvisation in the effort – an approach that continues to this day.

“We started engaging in the demolition and construction process before we really had a good grasp of our overall budget,” says Fischback. In February 2016, the team began evaluating the buildings, coming up with preliminary designs and starting clean-up. Christopher J. Kaczmar, Kaczmar president, says that in his first tour of the site he noted quite a lot of disrepair, along with low clearances, “disparate smaller portions” and odd heights. A lot of old manufacturing debris had to be removed. They also began implementing some modifications to bring the complex up to code, and would install all new MEP systems. “Then we attacked the riverfront,” Fischback says, and built new docks, which at 521 linear feet comprise the longest rowing dock in the world. Because historic tax credits were involved, the team was tasked with maintaining the character of the original buildings by retaining original doorways, windows and stairways, as well as keeping beams exposed and seamlessly tuck pointing the brick exteriors. Faded exterior signage was refreshed with white paint Properties | February 2018


Congratulations Design & Construction Teams of

The Foundry From Your Structural Engineering Partner

330.659.6688

www.thorsonbaker.com

PROUD TO BE A MEMBER OF THE KRILL TEAM PROVIDING ROUGH AND FINISH CARPENTRY FOR THE FOUNDRY

STRANO CONSTRUCTION COMPANY 216-381-5548 • 591 Parkside Blvd., S. Euclid, OH 44143

d, O

H.

Comm ty

Ro

lan

uni

in several areas. Much of the original roof systems were repaired or replaced with wood frame, wood deck and EPDM rubber membrane material. In all, 11 separate spaces were created within the facility. One area that needed major alteration was the Tank House, one of The Foundry’s most specialized buildings. It houses state-of-the-art Inriver rowing simulators, incorporating 36 rowing stations and giant troughs of water with a synchronized flow to match oar strokes. In that space, the team lowered the floor to allow a larger ceiling height, and built a two-foot-thick waterproof foundation, digging down some 14 feet for the special rowing tanks, which are literally a stone’s throw from the river. Tim McKenna, The Foundry’s facilities manager, notes that the overhead lighting in the space, which looks irregularly positioned, is an homage to the pattern of the rowing stroke. The room, which also features custom sprinklers and sophisticated sound dampening, is low-key and low-impact, like rowing itself. In the Crane Building, the team built more boat storage space, two executive board rooms and an 1,800-square-foot special event community room. The lobby is actually an enclosed, converted old alleyway that runs west to east through the entire

Quality Guaranteed

win

Cle

ve

NEW CONNECTION The lobby is actually an enclosed, converted old alleyway that runs through the entire structure. This area includes a new, modern two-story glass and aluminum entranceway addition with space ready for a future elevator.

g & S aili n g c e n t e r,

COMMUNITY ROWING & SA ILING CENTER Every crew strives to “row as one.” Otherwise, you stop. Rowing takes teamwork.

Make the Foundry the site of your next corporate retreat. Use our indoor tanks and expert coaches for team-building exercise and our state-of-art conference rooms for your business meeting. Relax in our interior courtyard with what may be the oldest living tree in Cleveland! Consider the Foundry for your next corporate retreat! To make the Foundry the site of your next business meeting, call Michael Ferry, Director of Corporate & Community Partnerships, at 440.862.0247.

The Foundry Community Rowing & Sailing Center 1831 Columbus Road, Cleveland Ohio

www.propertiesmag.com 53


PROPELLING PROGRESS The Tank House, one of The Foundry’s most specialized buildings, houses state-of-the-art InRiver rowing simulators, incorporating 36 rowing stations and giant troughs of water with a synchronized flow to match oar strokes.

structure. This area includes a new, modern two-story glass and aluminum entranceway addition with space ready for a future elevator. Creating spaces for 100 rowing machines with a full Olympic weight room facility had “major code implications in an existing building,” Kaplan notes. “We achieved that by installing a firewall at one of the existing exterior walls off the main lobby.”

The last phase was the main building, aka The Big House, ideal for the conferences and events The Foundry is eager to attract. Overall, 25,000 square feet within the complex are available for purposes other than those related to rowing and sailing, including conferences, social gatherings and small conventions. A tour of the whole facility, a marvel of textures, tones and alluring juxtapositions of old and new, ends off the

Proud to have provided concrete services for THE CLEVELAND FOUNDRY with THE KRILL COMPANY + KACZMAR ARCHITECTS

NORTH COAST CONCRETE Brian R. Dalrymple, Vice President Ź Quality Workmanship

Ź Customer Satisfaction

Ź On-Time Performance Ź Emphasizing Safety

216-642-1114 www.northcoastconcrete.com 6061 Carey Dr., Valley View, OH 44125 54

Member of:

courtyard in the 19th-century Carriage House, a two-story, brick-walled, irregularly brick-floored room with a central, hub-like fire pit and original gaslight fixtures. McKenna has called the space the “jazz bar.” Rumor has it that it could have been a speakeasy during Prohibition, with hidden cupboards, openings and decades of history. Options considered for future use include a coffee house.

Doing things ‘the right way’ Overall, there were 18 to 20 months of actual construction in a staggered rollout. The Foundry was at least partially functional (called the “enabling phase”) long before build-out concluded in December 2017. “We were on the fly with a lot of what we were doing,” says Trebilcock, suggesting formation of The Foundry team was unusually organic. He also acknowledges the input of Aaron Marcovy, The Foundry’s first executive director, in the institution’s programming and facilities. “This project is significant,” says Marcovy, a St. Ignatius graduate and a champion rower at Columbia and Oxford universities, who now works for SecureView, a Cleveland-based property rehabilitation company. “After being in the national and regional rowing communities for 16 years, [I have yet to encounter] a single individual who has Properties | February 2018


Charting Your Destination?

Commercial & Industrial 24/7/365, Since 1987

We’ve been helping companies steer toward new and better futures as an icebreaker in forging strong new relationships for over 70 years!

Proud to have been part of the Krill team at the Foundry! INDUSTRY LEADER SINCE 1946 Exclusive | Focused | Informative | Dependable | Connected

www.Propertiesmag.com

5500 Old Brecksville Road Independence, Ohio 44131 216-642-6040 p | 216-642-6041 f www.precision-env.com

!30(!,4 0!6).' !30(!,4 2%0!)2 3%!,#/!4).' #2!#+ &),,).' #/-0,%4% 3)4% #/.3425#4)/.

0!6 ) . ' ) . # s %XCELLENT QUALITY COMPETITIVE PRICING RELIABILITY

%8#!6!4)/. 4/ #/-0,%4)/.

s #UNNINGHAM 0AVING IS A FAMILY OWNED BUSINESS WITH OVER YEARS OF EXPERIENCE s ,ICENSED BONDED INSURED s /UR MOTTO h+EEPING OUR CUSTOMERS SATISFIED KEEPS THEM COMING BACK v

* iÊӣȰxn£°nÈää >ÝÊӣȰxn£°nÈnÎ !URORA 2OAD 7ARRENSVILLE (EIGHTS /( www.propertiesmag.com 55


CELEBRATING

15 YEARS

OF COST SEGREGATION 2002-2017

ACCELERATE DEPRECIATION AND SHIELD INCOME TAXES NOW • Cost Segregation

J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc. • Commercial Buildings

• Energy Efficiency Certifications (179D) • New IRS Repair v. Capitalization

• Construction Sites • Special Event Clean-Up • Concrete Cleaning • Carpet Cleaning • Window Cleaning • Wall Washing • Acoustical Ceilings

Call Craig Miller

Cleveland 440.892.3339 / Columbus 614.949.4185 Detroit 248.752.7433 / www.costsegexperts.com

THE REGION’S LEADING INCOME TAX REDUCTION EXPERTS

56

1230 East Schaaf Road Brooklyn Heights, OH 44131

216-749-1150 www.jvjanitorial.com

Properties | February 2018


OLD MEETS NEW The former industrial facility is well suited to its new use with plenty of boat storage space (above) and numerous skylights. The new lobby (below) embraces the building’s past with the existing exterior brick façade now serving as an interior wall.

not remarked at the magnitude of this project. The implications for the sport in Cleveland and throughout the Midwest – and hopefully across the country – are significant.” Trebilcock notes that income from special events and from an associated adult fitness program are designed to help defray The Foundry’s program costs and subsidize kids who can’t otherwise afford to participate. “Our mission is the enablement of kids,” he says. While neither he nor his wife row, the three Trebilcock children do, and their enthusiasm is infectious, he says. As for The Foundry’s youthful customers, “these kids are healthy,” he says. “They’re like swimmers. It’s a cardiointensive sport. It’s also definitely a team

“[I have yet to encounter] a single individual who has not remarked at the magnitude of this project. The implications for the sport in Cleveland and throughout the Midwest – and hopefully across the country – are significant.” Aaron Marcovy The Foundry sport. There is no LeBron James in the boat – it’s not like you’re focused on one athlete – and even though you might have a superstar, if the other seven kids can’t row, the boat isn’t going anywhere.” Since opening, the facility has worked toward fulfilling The Foundry’s mission: to create a positive space for youth fitness and empowerment by way of the nautical sports of rowing and sailing. The future looks bright, Trebilcock says, noting that two national regatta competitions are scheduled at the facility for this year alone. “From the start, our mantra, our goal, was to do the right things the right way, so they last at least 100 years,” he says. “Thanks to a great team and a shared vision, we’ve done that at the Foundry.” P www.propertiesmag.com 57


NEVER over budget

Quality Products & Services Since 1933 dŚĞ Z͘>͘ tƵƌnj ŽŵƉĂŶLJ ŝƐƚƌŝďƵƚŽƌ ŽĨ ŽŶƐƚƌƵĐƟŽŶ Θ ZĞƐƚŽƌĂƟŽŶ WƌŽĚƵĐƚƐ ^ƚĂƚĞǁŝĚĞ ([SHUWV LQ Sealants • Waterproofing

Architectural Panels Supplies • Air Barriers Concrete & Masonry y Products

• Due Diligence • Development & Leasing • Retail, Commercial • Historical/Industrial and Industrial Renovations • Construction Management • Design/Build

7ZR 7HFKQLFDO 6HUYLFH &KHPLVWV RQ 6WDII

330-659-2040 Charles Marshall – cmarshall@mccdesignbuild.com

Construction Company a division of

P.O. Box 1092, Bath, OH 44210 • www.beaconmarshall.com

13320 Enterprise Ave., Cleveland, OH 44135 1-800-969-1754 www.rlwurz.com Žǁ ŽƌŶŝŶŐ ŝƐ Ă ƌĞŐŝƐƚĞƌĞĚ ƚƌĂĚĞŵĂƌŬ ŽĨ Žǁ ŽƌŶŝŶŐ ŽƌƉŽƌĂƟŽŶ͘

Space Comfort co. )$0,/< 2:1(' 23(5$7(' :,7+ +$1'6 21 (;3(5,(1&( ,1 0(&+$1,&$/ &2175$&7,1* 6$/(6 6(59,&( 6,1&( ([SHUWV LQ Q 7XUQNH\ VROXWLRQV GHVLJQ EXLOG YDOXH HQJLQHHULQJ Q 6HUYLFH LQVWDOODWLRQ PDLQWHQDQFH RI DOO PDNHV PRGHOV RI +9$ & HTXLSPHQW ERLOHUV Q 1HZ UHQRYDWLRQ UHPRGHOLQJ UHVWRUDWLRQ Q 3XEOLF SULYDWH 3URYLGLQJ UHOLDEOH SHUVRQDO VHUYLFH WR RZQHUV RI UHWDLO FHQWHUV PDOOV DSDUWPHQW FRPSOH[HV UHWLUHPHQW KRXVLQJ LQ 2KLR QHLJKERULQJ VWDWHV

5201 CLARK AVENUE, CLEVELAND OHIO 44102 Q PH. 216-281-2000 Q FAX. 216-281-8420 Q 800-203-9645 58

Properties | February 2018


Legal Services + Risk Management

Risks of Marijuana-Related Businesses By Aaron S. Evenchik and John Paul Lucci Hahn Loeser

wners of land and industrial, commercial and retail properties in Ohio are struggling with best practices in contracting with, leasing to, or doing business with marijuana-related businesses. Attorney General Jeff Sessions’ recent memorandum providing federal prosecutors the discretion to enforce existing laws and prosecute marijuana-related crimes, even in those states that authorize marijuana-related commerce, only increases risk.

O

The State of Ohio has and will issue permits for marijuana growers and distributors. While authorized by the state, these businesses still violate the Federal Controlled Substances Act, which generally prohibits the cultivation, distribution and possession of marijuana. Further, these activities may serve as the basis for the prosecution of other crimes, such as those prohibited by the money laundering statutes, Aaron S. Evenchik John Paul Lucci the unlicensed money transmitdeveloped in industrial facilities and ter statutes and the Bank Secrecy Act. Imagine the personal injury claims shopping centers across Ohio. Property arising from a marijuana-related accident owners must evaluate the risks of rentor death? The plaintiff’s lawyer will file ing space to businesses in the marijuana suit against everyone involved in the industry. In spaces with multiple tenmanufacture and distribution of mari- ants, will a lease to a marijuana business juana – now easily identifiable since these violate compliance with law represenactivities are now outside of the black market. Finally, an aggressive federal prosecutor may seek criminal penalties or jail time. Adding to these challenges, many banks are unwilling to service marijuana businesses, forcing business to operate with cash and incur the expense of protecting large quantities of cash. National title companies are also refusing to issue title insurance when the purchaser is in a marijuana business. Even though title insurance covers past title risk and has nothing to tations made by the tenant and the do with future use of the property, title landlord? Will adjacent tenants object insurance companies want to avoid these (or do they have the right to object) to a marijuana facility in the same center? customers and risk. If there are common area changes, is it unfair to pass the elevated security Risks to property owners Despite these risks, marijuana facilities cost requirements along to other tenfor cultivation and retail sales are being ants? Can the landlord obtain complete

The State of Ohio has and will issue permits for marijuana growers and distributors. While authorized by the state, these businesses still violate the Federal Controlled Substances Act, which generally prohibits the cultivation, distribution and possession of marijuana.

indemnification from a high-risk marijuana-related tenant?

Risks to contractors & subcontractors Those contracting for new construction or interior build-out for a marijuana-related business must be cautious. In addition to the criminal prosecution risks, construction raises the risk of non-payment. In standard projects, contractors and subcontractors can confirm bank financing is in place and have lien and litigation rights. Conversely, in marijuana projects there is often no bank – simply a group of investors with a “pot” of cash that is difficult to secure. To the extent there is a project payment default, it may be more difficult to work through the foreclosure process or find a buyer for the property given the potential federal criminal violations. Contractors performing work for the marijuana industry are forming stand-alone construction companies, solely devoted to marijuana, to isolate their operations and contain risk. Those doing so should maintain corporate formalities to keep the marijuana business separate from the main operating entity. While the purpose of this structure is to limit potential exposure if there is a claim against the entity conducting business with the marijuana industry, there is no guarantee that these steps will fully protect the contractor against zealous federal prosecution. The goal is to segregate assets and operations in order to mitigate the contractor’s risk and overall exposure. Even lower-tier www.propertiesmag.com 59


HOW BAD IS THAT LEAK?

Keep your assets safe by taking the time to ensure that problems at the top of your building are not damaging your bottom line.

Carey Roofing Corp. has eliminated asset damage due to a leaking roof with practical solutions since 1946. 216 • 881 • 1999 CAREY www.careyroofing.com

Roofing Corp.

founded in 1946

MEMBER: National Roofing Contractors Association

YOUR INDUSTRY IS OUR BUSINESS. At Hahn Loeser, our results-oriented Construction Law Team has more than 20 attorneys who serve clients in all aspects of construction law. We pride ourselves on hard work, responsiveness, and an unyielding commitment to achieving outstanding results for our clients.

OUR NEWEST MEMBERS

Andy Natale

Aaron Evenchik

anatale@hahnlaw.com

aevenchik@hahnlaw.com

Rob Remington

Construction Group Chair rrr@hahnlaw.com HAHN LOESER & PARKS LLP | HAHNLAW.COM | 216.621.0150 CLEVELAND | COLUMBUS | NAPLES | FORT MYERS | SAN DIEGO | CHICAGO

60

GROWING INTEREST Despite the risks, marijuana facilities for cultivation and retail sales are being developed in industrial facilities and shopping centers across Ohio.

subcontractors are considering forming separate entities. Those who may otherwise object to a pay-if-paid clause are being forced to accept the risk of nonpayment due to federal enforcement in their subcontracts. There are many traps for unwary property owners, construction managers and contractors when working with businesses in the marijuana industry. From financial risks to potential claims and criminal enforcement, the added complexities when working with these businesses can be challenging to navigate without proper guidance. The best approach to mitigate risk is to consult with counsel for specific advice, as early in the process as possible. By planning ahead, you can take steps to protect yourself and your company. P Aaron S. Evenchik is a partner at Hahn Loeser, where he specializes in construction and real estate law and represents clients in both transactional and litigation matters. He can be reached at aevenchik@hahnlaw.com, or 216.274.2450. John Paul Lucci is a partner and co-chair of Hahn Loeser’s Corporate Transactions Group who represents clients in a wide range of corporate law matters. He can be reached at jlucci@hahnlaw. com, or 216.274.2310. This article was created for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice or a solicitation to provide legal services. Readers should consult legal counsel knowledgeable in the nuances of these issues to ensure they navigate the complex issues arising from the marijuana industry in Ohio. Properties | February 2018


Legal Services + Risk Management

Builders Risk Claims in Focus By Patrick Kelleher and Sean Sica Meaden & Moore

uilders risk claims often include numerous complex issues. Delay-in-completion claims add a layer of complexity with General Conditions and Construction Loan Interest being the more common issues that lead to disputes.

B

Each can involve significant claim dollars, and each can be a source of dispute and confusion.

Builders Risks Delay- in-Completion Claims - General Conditions “General Conditions” is a construction term, typically understood to be a catchall for construction overhead and other project expenses that are not trade specific. Because the term is often perceived as vague and allencompassing, it provides occasion for the potential overstatement of claimed and measured amounts. General Conditions, depending on the wording of the construction contract, may involve either on-site or off-site expenses for some or all of the parties engaged in the project. These expenses are typically not trade-specific, like carpentry work or plumbing would be, but they are still costs required to complete the project. On-site general conditions can include construction trailer rental, cell phone bills, site lighting, portable toilets, snow removal, job office rental, site utilities, temporary heat and power, superintendent’s salary, rubbish removal and site security. Off-site conditions can include home office rent, salaries of project manager or accountant, and cost of hiring consultants, including testing labs, surveyor, engineers and others. The contractor typically invoices the costs on a monthly basis, with a detailed list of all charges for the previous period. To ascertain which General Conditions are claim related, key information is necessary. Some information may present coverage or adjusting issues for the underwriters and adjusters to address. If the General Conditions costs

are claimed as a soft cost resulting from a delay, are they incurred during the delay period? Are the General Conditions expenses additional, or would these expenses have been incurred, absent the loss? Are the General Conditions

Because the term “General Conditions” is often perceived as vague and allencompassing, it provides occasion for the potential overstatement of claimed and measured amounts. expenses necessary to repair the damage resulting from the loss? Are the General Condition costs being charged consistent with the base contract? Is there a dollar limit or percentage of General Conditions that is permissible in the underlying construction contract? Asking some mix of these questions should allow the measurement to be prepared accurately, subject to the cover-

age advice of the underwriter or adjuster. However, problematic issues or potential areas of dispute may still arise, as demonstrated in the following example. Example: Relationship between the project fee and general conditions The general contractor/insured and insurer agree that there is a delay as a result of a covered peril. The loss results in a four-month delay, and the insured parties assert a claim for $25,000 per month based on the historical average General Conditions. The General Conditions have yet to be incurred, but the estimate includes costs as follows: trailer rentals ($5,000), home office rent ($10,000), project manager time ($4,000) and superintendent time ($6,000). Prior to the loss, only trailer rentals and project manager time were included in the General Conditions. Moreover, the prime contract specifically delineates what costs are allowable versus excluded. Home office rent is specifically excluded and superintendent time is included in www.propertiesmag.com 61


+TWJSXNH *]FRNSFYNTS TK (TSXYWZHYNTS (TXYX +FHNQNYNJX FSI T\SJW SJJIX FHWTXX RFS^ NSIZXYWNJX FWJ GJHTRNSL RTWJ HTRUQJ] &X YMJ HTRUQJ]NYNJX FWJ LWT\NSL YMJ HTSXYWZHYNTS IJQN[JW^ RJYMTIX FWJ J[TQ[NSL

4ZW FHHTZSYFSYX FWJ (JWYNKNJI +WFZI *]FRNSJWX (+* (JWYNKNJI 5ZGQNH &HHTZSYFSYX (5& FSI (JWYNKNJI NS +NSFSHNFQ +TWJSXNHX (++ <J HFS GJ WJYFNSJI FY \MFYJ[JW XYFLJ SJHJXXFW^ IZWNSL YMJ UQFSSNSL UMFXJ GNI UMFXJ FY YMJ XYFWY TK HTSXYWZHYNTS TW \MJS F UWTOJHY MFX LTSJ F\W^ <J FUUQ^ KTWJSXNH UWTHJIZWJX YT NIJSYNK^ NSJKKNHNJSHNJX J]HJXXN[J XUJSINSL FSI GNQQNSL IZUQNHFYNTSX FSI ZSWJQFYJI HTXYX IJUFWYZWJX KWTR HTSYWFHY FLWJJRJSYX FSI XHTUJ NSHTSXNXYJSHNJX \NYM NSIZXYW^ XYFSIFWIX FSI KWFZI FSI FGZXJ

MEADENMOORE.COM | 216.241.3272


Legal Services + Risk Management the fixed fee that the general contractor is charging on the time and materials of the job. The corrected claim for general conditions costs is $9,000 per month during the delay period.

Construction Loan Interest The proper flow of funds on a construction project is critical to the existing construction project as well as other concurrent and future projects for developers and contractors. Construction projects are capital-intensive, and construction loan interest is often the largest component of a Delay-in-Completion claim. A thorough understanding of the financing mechanism(s) of a project during and after the construction phase is necessary to determine the potential for additional interest expense exposure that may be incurred by insured parties in the event of a delay-related loss. Additional considerations include the security interest encumbering the property improved or created, the repayment provisions of the loan agreement, and the insured’s intent to repay the loan upon completion of the project. Financing for construction projects is dependent upon many factors, including creditworthiness, credit availability, the economy and geopolitics. Lenders for non-public construction projects are typically banks making construction loans. Other funding mechanisms are syndicated loans, bonds and mezzanine loans. The interest component of a Delayin-Completion claim is frequently misunderstood. When measuring the additional construction loan interest, the additional and construction language typically included within the insurance contract is often overlooked. Soft cost claims involving construction loan interest are often presented as the full “normal” interest expense on all existing borrowed funds during the delay period. For example, a project owner may present additional construction loan interest expense without considering if any of the loan proceeds were used for the land acquisition, and without considering whether the construction loan interest would have been ongoing, post-construction.

An owner’s presentation frequently contemplates the additional months’ interest that the project is being forced to carry because of the delay. This may seem like a reasonable basis for damages, without considering any other facts. However, this approach neglects to consider the ongoing construction loan interest expense of the project upon completion and potential overlap with continuing interest expense on related business interruption claims. Some background information is needed

A thorough understanding of the financing mechanism(s) of a project during and after the construction phase is necessary to determine the potential for additional interest expense exposure that may be incurred by insured parties in the event of a delay-related loss. to determine if there is additional interest exposure, including: 1. The funding mechanism(s) financing the land acquisition and construction costs. 2. The term and other provisions of the loan agreement, i.e., the drawdown and repayment period considered, including the permanent financing mechanism. Many financing agreements specify a time period in which the construction project should be completed in order to adhere to the loan covenant.

3. Resetting interest rates – A delay in construction can also result in a higher interest rate or postpone the move to a lower interest rate upon conversion of the construction loan to a mortgage. Key measurement questions to ask the insured regarding additional interest expense during the delay period include: Is there a principal amount of money borrowed and repayable at some interest rate and within a defined time period? Has money been advanced in return for an equity interest in the insured’s company, with repayments to be made, in whole or in part, out of profits? Is this interest preferred over some other subordinate interest, or subordinated after some preferred interest? Were any loan proceeds used to acquire the property, and potentially part of the construction loan interest being claimed? When were advance payments made and how should these be used to offset the claim for additional construction loan interest, if considered at all? How has the scope of the insured’s construction (non-loss related work) changed since the beginning of the project and since the date of the loss? What is the effect on the loan balance? Answers to some mix of these questions will help to prepare a better measurement. P Patrick Kelleher and Sean Sica are both vice presidents at Meaden & Moore. They specialize in investigative accounting services to the insurance industry and legal profession.

SINCE 1972

Façade Inspection | Tuckpointing/Caulking Pressure Washing | Brick & Stone Repair/Replacement 216.881.4142 | 4408 St. Clair Avenue | Cleveland, Ohio 44103 www.hmhrestoration.com www.propertiesmag.com 63


BaMJHMF Business Domestic Employment Estate Planning Insurance Labor Litigation Municipal Natural Resources Probate Public Education Real Estate Transportation Water NQJDQR NLpensation

Clients first. Our guiding principle since 1931. TSSHMF BKHDMSR EHQRS HR MNS ITRS NTQ RKNF@M S R HMFQ@HMDC HM @KK VD CN We understand that attorney-client relationships should no longer be defined by a billable hour. We build our relationships @QNTMC NTQ BKHDMSR NAIDBSHUDR SN DMRTQD SG@S @ UHBSNQX HR MNS pyrrhic, but meaningful. Our clients rely NM TR SN CDKHUDQ QDRTKSR SG@S G@UD KNMF-SDQL ONRHSHUD HLO@BSR NM HMCHUHCT@KR~ E@LHKHDR~ FNUDQMLDMSR and organizations. It R an enormous QDRONMRHAHKHSX SG@S VD DLAQ@BD ADB@TRD VD L@JD NTQ BKHDMSR FN@KR NTQ NVM

VVV NLCOK@V BNL

64

Properties | February 2018


Legal Services + Risk Management

Purchase Agreements Versus Options By Abraham Lieberman O’Toole, McLaughlin, Dooley & Pecora Co., LPA

ery few agreements for the purchase and sale of real property are totally free of contingencies. Sometimes the contingencies are for the benefit of the seller or both the seller and buyer. An example of the latter is a contingency that all necessary approvals are obtained to split the property being purchased from a larger parcel.

V

More often, however, the contingencies are primarily, if not exclusively, for the benefit of the buyer. Some of those contingencies are part of almost every real estate transaction. Those would include a contingency that title to the property is marketable. Often, the buyer will also want a contingency that financing to purchase the property can be obtained or that an inspection of the property indicates that the physical condition of the property is acceptable. It is not uncommon, particularly in transactions for substantial properties, for the list of contingencies to be quite extensive. It is also not uncommon that satisfaction of those contingencies is primarily, if not exclusively, within the control of the buyer. Examples of such contingencies are ones that allow the buyer to terminate the transaction if the buyer determines that the governmental authorities will not approve the buyer’s plans for the property or if the buyer determines that the property is unsuitable for the buyer’s intended purposes. The due diligence period for satisfaction of the contingencies may be quite long, and the buyer is often given a right to extend the due diligence period. Due diligence periods of six months to a year are not uncommon. If the buyer terminates the agreement, then the buyer is typically entitled to the return of any earnest money deposited. As a result, the seller receives no compensation for having kept the property off the market for a significant period of time and may even have incurred unreimbursed costs such as title examination and escrow fees. While some contingencies in a purchase agreement are unavoidable, at some point it may be

advisable for the seller to acknowledge that the true nature of the transaction is not really a purchase, but instead an option to purchase, and to prepare the agreement accordingly. This approach has at least one benefit for the buyer and several benefits for the seller. The buyer

While some contingencies in a purchase agreement are unavoidable, at some point it may be advisable for the seller to acknowledge that the true nature of the transaction is not really a purchase, but instead an option to purchase, and to prepare the agreement accordingly. has total discretion to decide whether the option will be exercised and the purchase completed. One benefit for the seller is that if the transaction is not completed, then the seller will at least have received an option fee as com-

pensation for having kept the property off the market. By granting an option, the seller also typically does not incur title examination charges, escrow fees or other costs if the sale is not completed. If the parties do elect to use an option agreement, that agreement should include all the relevant terms of the purchase. That can be done in the body of the agreement or in an exhibit. That way, if and when the option is exercised, both parties will be bound to complete the transfer and the terms for the transfer will be set. A provision that, upon exercise of the option the parties will enter into an attached purchase agreement, is inadvisable, because it adds an extra step after exercise of the option. Even worse is an option agreement that states that, upon exercise of the option, the parties will enter into a purchase agreement, but does not have the form of purchase agreement attached. That leads to uncertainty and possible litigation if the parties cannot agree upon the terms of the purchase agreement. P

Abraham Lieberman is an attorney with the Ohio law firm of O’Toole, McLaughlin, Dooley & Pecora Co., LPA. His practice emphasizes real property law, municipal law and civil litigation. Contact Lieberman by phone at 440-930-4001 or by email at alieberman@omdplaw.com.

Experts In Exterior Masonry Repair & Restoration

McMahon Masonry Restoration Brick + Stone Repair & Replacement Caulking | Tuckpointing | Sealing Pressure Washing | Building Cleaning 9449 Brookpark Rd. Unit A, Parma, OH 44129 216-778-9666 | Fax 216-661-4520 | mcmahonrest1@att.net

Call for Your Free Building Inspection & Assessment www.propertiesmag.com 65


NAIOP NEWS Commercial real estate happenings

Real Estate Investment Changes Under Tax Law n Dec. 22, 2017, President Donald Trump signed into law the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (the Act). The Act makes several significant changes for real estate investors.

O

Assuming an individual taxpayer in the highest marginal rates, here is a summary of the key provisions.

Tax rates may come down for top bracket investors TAMMY B. GREBER

66

Under previous law, net income from rents was taxed at 39.6%, plus a 3.8% Affordable Care Act (ACA) tax for passive investors. All in, that is 43.4% for passive investors, 39.6% for active investors. Under the tax bill, investors qualifying for the new 20% deduction, net income from rents would effectively be taxed at 29.6%, plus the 3.8% ACA tax for passive investors. All in, that is 33.4% for a passive investor and 29.6% for an active investor – approximately a percentage point reduction. Income that does not qualify – such as rental income on land in many cases – would be taxed at the top marginal income tax rate of 37%, plus the 3.8% ACA tax for passive investors for a top, all-in tax rate of 40.8%.

In order to qualify for the full 20% deduction, the business must either pay a minimum amount of wages – generally twice the desired deduction – or have a minimum investment in tangible, depreciable property used in the trade or business, such as a building, but not including such items as land or inventory property.

REITs are big winners The wage or asset requirements would not apply to shareholders receiving a share of real estate rental income through REITs as ordinary REIT dividends. Assuming that the REIT meets the same income and asset test requirements under previous law, those ordinary dividends would automatically qualify for a 20% rate reduction in the hands of the shareholder. All in, REIT ordinary dividends would be taxed at an all-in rate of 33.4%. This is significantly better than the 43.4% maximum tax rate on ordinary REIT dividends under current law.

Properties | February 2018


Legal Services + Risk Management In addition, this treatment appears to apply to mortgage REITs that pool and collect interest income from real estate mortgages.

taxpayers with average annual gross receipts for the three-taxable year period ending with the prior taxable year that do not exceed $25 million.

Active losses limited

Like-kind exchanges preserved for real estate

Under a set of provisions that are still quite unclear in scope and meaning, active losses would be subject to new limitations, limiting their ability to be used against wage or fee income or portfolio income.

Interest expense still deductible, but depreciation may change Most real estate investments are heavily debt-financed. Under current law, business interest is fully deductible. Under the final bill, new limits are imposed on business interest deductions of corporations and pass-through businesses that do not qualify for a small taxpayer exception. However, real estate trades or business can irrevocably elect to be exempt from those rules. In exchange, more restrictive depreciation rules will apply. In general, the owners must use 30-year straight line depreciation (not the otherwise applicable 27.5year rule) for residential real property and 40-year straight line (not the otherwise applicable 39-year rule) for nonresidential real property, with other rules for specific items. For real estate trades or businesses that do not elect-out of the business interest limitations, the rules will generally limit net interest deductions to 30% of earnings before interest. For the first four years after enactment (tax years after Dec. 31, 2017 and before Jan. 1, 2022), that rule will be applied also adding back amortization and depreciation to make it equivalent to a 30% of EBITDA rule, not 30% of EBIT. After that period going forward, the EBIT rule will apply. Interest that is disallowed will generally be carried forward indefinitely and may be used in later years if it satisfies the applicable standard for that year. However, there is an exemption from the limitation for

The allowance of tax-free “likekind” exchanges of rental real estate is preserved under section 1031 of the tax code. It is not clear how such exchanges would interact with the asset test used in the new passthrough income deduction.

Changes to carried interest Under previous law, capital gains passed-through to holders of profits interests received for the provision of services (so-called “carried interests”) are treated like all other capital gains. Under the final bill, carried interests in certain activities – generally, private

equity, real estate private equity, hedge funds and similar enterprises – would only get capital gains treatment if the assets generating the gain were held for a three-year holding period, longer than the one-year holding period of previous law. It appears that this rule applies to the asset generating the gain, whether it be a partnership interest or the underlying assets. It may be appropriate to consider possible structural or deal modifications to maximize after-tax benefits under this rule. For additional details and specific examples on how the new tax legislation will impact commercial real estate visit www.rsmus.com/realestate. P

Tammy B. Greber, CPA is senior tax manager with RSM US LLP. She can be reached by phone at 216.622.1387 or by email at tammy.greber@rsmus.com.

> COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE expertise. > PERSONALIZED COMMUNITY BANK service.

It’s all about collaboration, individualized service and fostering economic growth in our community. We’re committed to it. And nearly 80 years of community banking expertise supports it.

LET OUR TEA M HELP YOUR S THR I V E . Contact Rig Goss at (216) 239-5904.

www.propertiesmag.com 67


How to Avoid Employee Discrimination Claims By Ric Selby Dworken & Bernstein, Co., L.P.A.

ritical to the success of any business is understanding how to avoid subjecting itself to claims by its employees. Both federal and state law contain a myriad of laws that address the employer/employee relationship as it relates to hours worked, employee safety and discrimination. Understanding common ways that employers violate these laws can go a long way in helping a company avoid expensive and unnecessary claims from its employees.

C

There are some obvious steps which employers can take to help assure themselves that they are not violating the law. For example, having all employees’ job descriptions periodically reviewed to make sure employees are properly classified as “exempt” or “non-exempt” under the Fair Labors Standards Act is a good practice. Unless an employee is properly classified as exempt under the FLSA, most employers are required to pay employees at the rate of time and one half for all hours worked over 40. Many claims for unpaid overtime do not result from a miscalculation of overtime hours, but, rather, from the misclassification of salaried employees as exempt. In order to avoid paying an employee overtime, not only does the employee have to be salaried, but they also have to meet the requirements of the various exemptions. If an employee does not meet the requirements of the exemption, even if they are salaried, they will still be entitled to overtime. Hopefully, all businesses in Ohio know that it is unlawful to discriminate against employees because of their race, age, gender, religion, national origin and other protected characteristics. Policies and practices that expressly treat individuals in a protected class less favorably than other employees are going to be a clear violation of the law. Many employment claims, however, do not arise from these types of express policies or practices, but rather from more subtle actions that flow from certain preconceived biases that an employer may not even be aware of. A prime example of this can be found in a typical age discrimination claim. Let’s

Ric Selby

say for example, a company employs two individuals: Thomas who is 70, and Bobby who is 25. Thomas has been a successful salesperson for the company for 30 years. He has been a fine performer and hopes to work until age 75. Bobby is relatively

Discharging an employee is absolutely an area where an ounce of prevention can be worth a pound of cure. Spending a few hours with your company’s attorney or human resource professional to walk through the grounds for terminating an employee can help avoid [common] pitfalls.

68

new to the industry, but has seen some success in his few years with the company since getting out of college. The company decides it is going to implement a new computer-based sales protocol. Thomas’ supervisor is concerned that at 70 years old, Thomas is going to have trouble adjusting to the new computer system. He

has no such concerns regarding Bobby, however, who has grown up using computers his entire life. Several months into the implementation of the new computer sales program, the supervisor notices that during that three-month period, Thomas has made three errors. His worse fears confirmed, the supervisor decides he has no choice but to terminate Thomas because of these repeated errors caused by the new computer system. Thomas brings an age discrimination lawsuit, which the company defends by pointing to the errors he made using the new system. They argued that the errors were unjustified and were grounds for termination. During discovery, however, Thomas’ lawyer discovers that Bobby, during the same period of time, had six errors. Indeed, when compared to all of the salespeople, Thomas had the second fewest errors. The company ended up settling with Thomas, costing them a significant amount of money as well as attorneys’ fees. This company fell into a common problem of confirmation bias. Thomas’ supervisor had a not uncommon fear that an older employee was going to have more difficulty adjusting to technological changes than younger co-workers. As a result of this concern, the supervisor was specifically looking for those problems to occur with respect to Thomas, while he wasn’t necessarily looking for those problems with the other employees. Every time one of those problems popped up with Thomas, it just confirmed the fear that he already had regarding Thomas because of his unconscious bias. Properties | February 2018


Legal Services + Risk Management When disciplining an employee, it is important to look not just at whether the conduct itself would, in a vacuum, justify discipline, but also whether the same standards are being uniformly applied throughout the company for all similarly situated employees. While, in a vacuum, disciplining Thomas because of his three errors may not seem unreasonable, once you realize that no other employees were disciplined for similar or worse conduct, it does not look nearly as reasonable. Moreover, if that differing treatment unconsciously arose out of bias surrounding concerns over an older employees’ ability to understand new technology, it is easy for a plaintiff’s attorney to connect the dots between an employee’s age and their disparate treatment by the company. This confirmation bias can appear in numerous contexts. For example, a supervisor’s concern that a single mother may miss more work because of childcare obligations may make that supervisor more likely to notice every one of the single mother’s absences, and not necessarily be conscious of the fact that she is not missing work any more frequently than the other employees, whose absences he doesn’t particularly monitor. The notion of confirmation bias is also prevalent in retaliation claims. Once an employee has filed a charge of discrimination either internally or with an agency like the EEOC, it is human nature that the employee accused of the discrimination is going to be upset by that allegation. This in turn can result in a supervisor placing an employee who made the complaint under far greater scrutiny than all of the other employees. Every little minor infraction suddenly becomes grounds for major concern in that supervisor’s eyes, regardless of whether it is viewed that way with other employees. Sometimes, otherwise innocuous behavior is characterized as not acceptable. If you find yourself thinking things along the lines of “Why does that employee always come into my office to ask questions, hasn’t he ever heard of email?”, you need to ask yourself if that employee e-mailed you all of their questions, would you be thinking, “Why is this person constantly berating me with emails, can’t he just come to my

office and ask me a question?” If you are already unhappy with an employee, it is easy to fall into the trap of viewing all of their conduct in a negative light, whether justified or not. Another common mistake arises out of many supervisors’ unfortunate fear of conflict. A supervisor may be extremely unhappy with an employee’s legitimately declining performance. That supervisor,

however, doesn’t confront the employee about it, doesn’t write the employee up and simply complains about the employee to the other management-level employees. Eventually, the supervisor reaches his last straw and terminates the employee because of poor performance. When the discrimination lawsuit is brought, the supervisor testifies that the employee’s performance had been

Aggressive. Creative. Successful. Dworken & Bernstein Co., L.P.A. is a full-service law firm that has represented businesses and individuals in Northeastern Ohio for more than 50 years. Bankruptcy Business Law Class Action Commercial Litigation Commercial Real Estate

Criminal Law Employment Law Estate Planning Family Law

General Litigation Immigration Law Personal Injury White Collar Crime Worker’s Comp

www.dworkenlaw.com

Over $32 million in cy pres funds directed to charity since 2003. Visit www.ohiolawyersgiveback.org for more information.

Cleveland Office 1468 W. 9th St. • Ste 135 • Cleveland, Ohio 44113 • 216.861.4211

Painesville Office 60 South Park Place • Painesville, Ohio 44077 • 440.352.3391

www.propertiesmag.com 69


declining for years. The supervisor, however, has to admit this was never communicated to the employee, and that the employee was never written up. Even worse, when the plaintiff’s attorney pulls out the performance reviews, the last four years reviews all show the employee met expectations, because it was far easier for the supervisor to

quickly write up performance reviews that showed everybody meeting expectations than it was to honestly assess each employee’s pros and cons. Performance reviews can be a mixed blessing. If used properly, they can both be a tool to help employees improve, and a method of documenting poor performance that can ultimately be used

Restoration Contractors

440.243.5535 BEREA, OHIO FACADE RESTORATION BALCONY RESTORATION BUILDING CLEANING CAULKING & SEALANTS COATING SYSTEMS GARAGE RESTORATION HISTORIC PRESERVATION MASONRY RESTORATION STONE RESTORATION WATERPROOFING

www.aiconstruction.com

Commercial, Institutional & Industrial Floor Covering Provider & Installer

Specializing in the healthcare marketplace with the highest quality & best service since 1989. We provide 24/7 service & installation. Call us today to take advantage of our trained in-house staff and extensive library of product information. Complete line of flooring including: Athletic Floors Resilient Flooring • Vinyl & Ceramic Tile • Carpeting

Call today for a FREE estimate! 4300 Brookpark Rd., Cleveland, OH 44134 • 216-595-0100 • Toll Free 888-271-8200 70

to support disciplinary action. If the supervisors are not going to take the reviews seriously, or put in the time to do the detailed, honest analysis that performance reviews require, they can actually be more of a hindrance to a company than a benefit. From a litigation perspective, no written performance reviews are more useful than performance reviews that are put together in 15 minutes each year and which result in every employee in the company meeting expectations, warranted or not. If you are not going to take the reviews seriously, you should not do them at all. Discharging an employee is absolutely an area where an ounce of prevention can be worth a pound of cure. Spending a few hours with your company’s attorney or human resource professional to walk through the grounds for terminating an employee can help avoid the pitfalls I have described above and can save a company a tremendous amount of money in litigation costs and settlements or verdicts. You will want to discover any holes in your rationale for firing an employee from your own legal counsel before you undertake the termination, rather than from the employee’s lawyer while being deposed. Engaging a disinterested person with knowledge of how these claims play out in litigation and having them review everything before you take any action can be extremely beneficial. This is particularly true in circumstances where the employee can pursue potential retaliation claims, such as in situations where they recently have taken FMLA leave, filed a workers compensation claim or filed some type of discrimination claim with the EEOC or OCRC. Not every discrimination claim results from a bigoted animus towards some protected group. Recognizing the types of unconscious biases or common practices that give rise to employment-related claims is very important in helping employers avoid these type of problems. P Ric Selby is partner at Dworken & Bernstein, Co., L.P.A. He can be reached by email at rselby@ dworkenlaw.com or phone at 440.352.3391. Properties | February 2018


Legal Services + Risk Management

Recent Ohio Supreme Court Decision May Help Ohio Taxpayers Challenge Tax Assessments By Robert Danzinger Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill Co., LPA

n 2006, the Ohio Supreme Court decided a case that caused many property owners to pay real estate taxes based on ridiculously high assessments. These high assessments were based on the transfer price of properties that were subject to a recent sale. Specifically, the “Manlaw” case involved the valuation for tax purposes of two buildings encumbered by older, long-term leases that were subject to a recent arm’s-length sale. Despite hearing arguments that appraisal and other evidence should be considered in determining value even for properties subject to a sale, the Ohio Supreme Court held that “the law requires using the sale price for tax purposes.”

I

In other words, the sale price, regardless of the circumstances of the sale, must be utilized to establish value. Therefore, “a sale is a sale” had been the rule for tax purposes since the Manlaw decision, despite a strong belief by many in the industry that blind reliance on a purchase price to determine value is too simplistic and naïve. Twelve years after Manlaw made Ohio a “leased fee” state for real property tax assessment in a sale case, the Ohio Supreme Court has issued a favorable decision that gets Ohio out from under the absurd results that were the progeny of the Manlaw decision. The case is Terrazza 8. Ohio taxpayers can now introduce appraisal and other evidence to show that a sale price does not reflect the true value of the underlying real estate. Importantly, the valuation standard in Ohio in sale cases is no longer leased fee value, but rather unencumbered fee simple value. The Terrazza 8 case involved a health club assessed by the County at a value of $4,850,000 that sold on a leased fee basis for over $14,000,000. The lease in effect at the time of the sale had been negotiated prior to the “great recession” and reflected a rental rate of over $20 per square foot. In opposing the school district’s complaint to increase the assessment

Robert “Kip” Danzinger

to the sale price, the taxpayer introduced into evidence an appraisal which showed that the post-recession

Ohio taxpayers can now introduce appraisal and other evidence to show that a sale price does not reflect the true value of the underlying real estate. market rent for the property was less than the $20 per square foot rent in the pre-recession lease. The

appraisal showed that the unencumbered fee simple value of the real estate was $7,000,000, not the $14,000,000 espoused by the school district. In a unanimous decision, the Ohio Supreme Court held that it was an error for the Ohio Board of Tax Appeals and local Board of Revision to ignore the appraisal evidence of the property owner showing that the sale did not reflect the unencumbered fee simple value of the real estate. Therefore, the taxpayer no longer was “handcuffed” to the sale price and the assessment was decided at a value consistent with the appraisal evidence. Thanks to the Terrazza 8 decision, property owners now have the right to challenge the increased tax valuation resulting from a sale of property. Ohio taxpayers should be mindful of this decision when reviewing property assessments prior to the upcoming March 31, 2018 deadline to challenge tax assessments for tax year 2017. P

Robert K. Danzinger is a principal with Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill Co., LPA. The firm represents Ohio and national taxpayers in contesting real property tax assessments. Robert Danzinger can be reached at 216.771.8990 or at rdanzinger@sdglegal.net. www.propertiesmag.com 71


Changing Markets, Changing Tax Codes, Changing Property Taxes? By J. Kieran Jennings and Cecilia J. Hyun Siegel Jennings Co., L.P.A.

tate and local governments nationwide rely on property tax more than any other tax to fund their spending. With the new federal tax code cutting other taxes for taxpayers, it is expected that the federal government will shift some of its funding burden back to state and local governments. Unless you have confidence governments will cut spending, taxpayers may want to keep an eye on their wallets as local government looks to fill that need.

S

Taxpayers can plan for the increased taxes by looking at their property tax assessment now. If they have not filed a tax complaint in the current triennial, Ohioans can file to contest their property assessments by March 31st (extended to April 2nd this year because the deadline falls on a weekend). A caveat: if you are under-assessed, you run the risk of having the assessment increased as well as decreased, so it is important to be prudent when deciding whether to file. You are not the only one invested in your property’s value. The local school district is also interested in your assessment. Most of your property taxes go to the school district; it is one of their most important funding sources. Even if you decide not to file a complaint, the school district may want to increase your assessment. Ohio and Pennsylvania are the only two states where schools routinely file to increase the assessments on taxpayers, whether or not there has been a sale of the property. No triggering event is needed. How do school district attorneys know which properties are under-assessed? A recent purchase is the easiest way for school attorneys to assume that you are under-assessed. They have also been known to review mortgage filings. A new mortgage may signal that the assessment is not matching up with your mortgage amount and the corresponding market value of your property. Or the district

recently ruled in favor of a taxpayer under the new definition.

J. Kieran Jennings

Cecilia J. Hyun

may simply believe your assessment is too low based on its interpretation of the market. When the school district files a complaint to increase your taxes, taxpayers may file a counter-complaint to the school’s initial complaint. Taxpayers should be wary of the gut reaction to file a counter-complaint. (You do not need to file a counter-complaint to defend against any increase sought). Taxpayers should be aware that a property tax lawsuit has the potential to cost them significant dollars and should consider the implications of filing a counter-complaint. What has been done to help protect taxpayers and ensure fair revenue to the government? The State of Ohio specifically defined in the Ohio Revised Code the market value that is used for the application of property taxes – that value is the fee simple unencumbered value. Simply, it is the most likely selling price of a property that reflects market rent, occupancy and other market indices. It is the manner in which most homes and owner-occupied properties sell. The Ohio Supreme Court

Why is the definition and the Ohio Supreme Court decision important? Property tax is the only tax that is determined by an opinion of value instead of the submission of a quantified measure such as sales receipts or net income. For that opinion of value to be fair and uniform, it must be based on consistent parameters. Defining the interest to be taxable as unencumbered fee simple is an important step toward uniformity. In addition to having defined terms, states like Illinois and Texas have the additional protection of comparing assessments to ensure uniform taxation. If a school district files a complaint seeking an increase in your property taxes, comparing your assessment with your neighbors or competitors is not an allowable defense. When defending against an increase in tax valuation, taxpayers have to consider how circumstances at their property affect the fair market value of the property under appeal. These factors include comparable sales, comparable rents and comparable occupancy of similar properties. Often, this information will be found in an appraisal report. Real estate markets have been improving. If your property value has increased, expect your assessment to increase, too; unchecked, you may find that you are shouldering more than your fair share of the tax burden. P

J. Kieran Jennings (kjennings@siegeltax.com) is managing partner of Siegel Jennings Co., L.P.A. Cecilia J. Hyun (chyun@siegeltax.com) is a partner with the firm. Siegel Jennings is the Ohio and Western Pennsylvania member of the American Property Tax Counsel (APTC). They can also be reached at 216.763.1004. 72

Properties | February 2018


:ȝ &Ȫ8ȫ+ 2ȭ5 &ȧ0Ȩ(Ȭ,Ȭ,ȧ1

Congratulations to

Joshua T. Morrow, JD, on his appointment to partner!

Ranallo & Aveni LLC is a boutique

COMMERCIAL, RESIDENTIAL & INDUSTRIAL DEMOLITION ASBESTOS SURVEYS & ABATEMENT • WRECKING

ODZ ȴUP VSHFLDOL]LQJ LQ WKH UHDO HVWDWH DQG FRQVWUXFWLRQ LQGXVWULHV

CAREY DEMOLITION 216-881-0608 | www.careydemolition.com 2695 E. 55th St. | Cleveland, OH 44104

5$1$//2/$: &20 _

Construction and surety law isn’t just something our attorneys do. It’s the only thing they do.

Ian Frank Frank

Marc S Sanchez anchez

Michaell Frantz, F Frantz Jr

Mark k Rodio R

Allison T Taller aller ll Reich

Nora Loftus Loftus f

Thomas C Cardone ardone

Mark Stockman Stock kman

Alan D Dailide ailide il

Melissa Meliss a JJones

Colleen Collee n Murnane M

FrantzWard.com

www.propertiesmag.com 73


CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT Updated info on important projects in the region

Project Report #: 01708 WESTERN RESERVE ACADEMY SEYMOUR HALL LOCATION: 115 College St. Hudson, OH (Summit County) www.wra.net PROJECT TYPE: Renovation CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STAGE: Construction Underway PROJECT STATUS: Renovation - Completion Set for May 2018 EST. VALUE: $14 million OWNER: Western Reserve Academy Contact: Jeff Jacot, Director of Facilities 115 College St. Hudson, OH 44236 Phone: 330-650-4400 www.wra.net ARCHITECT: MacLachlan, Cornelius & Filoni (MCF) Architects Contact: Bob Russ 307 Fourth Ave., # 200 Pittsburgh, PA 15222 Phone: 412-281-6568 www.mcfarchitects.com CM: The Ruhlin Co.

Contact: Don Rife 6931 Ridge Rd. (P.O. Box 190) Sharon Center, OH 44274 Phone: 330-239-2800 www.ruhlin.com STRUCTURAL ENG: Thorson Baker & Associates Inc. MECH ENG: McHenry & Associates Inc. ELEC ENG: McHenry & Associates Inc. DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 3 stories, 37,000 sf. Renovation of main classroom building, Seymour Hall - 29 classrooms - geothermal heating and cooling system. All new mechanical - electric - plumbing. Project Report #: 01754 BEACHWOOD FIRE STATION # 2 LOCATION: NE Corner Richmond Rd. & Park East Dr. Beachwood, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STAGE: Construction Underway PROJECT STATUS: Possible March Completion Set EST. VALUE: $9.7 million OWNER: City Of Beachwood Contact: Merle Gorden & Patrick Kearns

Cleveland 216-663-3777 Toledo 419-865-7100 LQ¿QLW\FRQVWUXFWLRQ FRP

([SHULHQFH 74

([FHOOHQFH &RPPLWPHQW

2655 Richmond Rd. Beachwood, OH 44122 Phone: 216-292-1965 www.beachwoodohio.com ARCHITECT: Erickson Wilcox 11250 Roger Bacon Dr. Reston, VA 20190 Phone: 703-965-5600 BUILDER: Infinity Construction Contact: Jim Fantozzi 18440 Cranwood Pkwy. Warrensvlle Hts., OH 44128 Phone: 216-663-3777 DESCRIPTION: 5.25 acres, 1 bldg, 26,000 sf. Police and fire dispatch center - training center emergency operations center - fire station. Project Report #: 01756 DISCIPLES CHRISTIAN CHURCH LOCATION: 3663 Mayfield Rd. Cleveland Hts., OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Religious PROJECT STAGE: Project Proposed PROJECT STATUS: Construction Schedule Not Set OWNER: Disciples Christian Church CONTACT: Rev. Roger McKinney Written Inquiries 3663 Mayfield Rd. Cleveland Hts., OH 44121 Phone: 216-382-5344 www.disicpleschristian.org ARCHITECT: Kurtz Architects Contact: Jonathan Kurtz 2969 Yorkshire Rd. Cleveland Hts., OH 44118-2425 Phone: 330-328-7347 www.jonathankurtz.com DESCRIPTION: New, 10,000 sf church Project Report #: 01757 TRU BY HILTON HOTEL LOCATION: 70th & Euclid Ave. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STAGE: Working Drawings in Progress PROJECT STATUS: Working Drawings In Progress - Possible 2nd Quarter 2018 Start - 2nd Quarter 2019 Completion EST. VALUE: $12,000,000 OWNER: Group of investors c/o architect & builder ARCHITECT: Kaczmar Architects Inc. Contact: Chris Kaczmar 1468 W. 9th St., Ste. 400 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-687-1555 www.kaczarch.com CM: The Krill Company Properties | February 2018


1275 Main Ave. Cleveland, OH 44113 DESCRIPTION: 1.5 acres, 1 bldg, 4 stories, 50,700 sf. 114 guest rooms - lower-cost, smallerthan-average rooms - large public spaces. Project Report #: 01721 STREETSBORO MICRO HOSPITAL LOCATION: 9300 Rte. 14 Streetsboro, OH (Portage County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional PROJECT STAGE: Project Proposed PROJECT STATUS: Construction Date Not Set OWNER/DEVELOPER: Embree Asset Group Contact: Denise Valenta 4747 Williams Dr. Georgetown, TX 78633 Phone: 512-819-4700 www.embreegroup.com ARCHITECT: Page/ 400 W. Cedar Chavez St., Ste, 500 Austin, TX 78701 Phone: 512-472-6721 www.pagethink.com BUILDER: To Be Selected DESCRIPTION: 2 acres, 1 bldg, 1 story, 18,223 sf. 8 inpatient rooms - imaging center infectious disease room - quarters for physicians - lab - staff lounge - nurses’ stations - 6 treatment rooms (trauma and major treatments rooms) - triage room EMS lounge - ambulance vestibule.

STRUCTURAL STEEL FABRICATORS & ERECTORS SINCE 1958

0DVRQ 6WHHO Contact Mike Smith for a Proposal: (440) 439-1040 | (800) 686-1223 7500 Northfield Rd. | Walton Hills, OH 44146 www.masonsteel.com Other Fine Products Available: Stone | Pavers | Fireplaces | Windows | Doors

Project Report #: 01711 RESIDENCE INN BY MARRIOTT HOTEL LOCATION: 19149 Bagley Rd. Middleburg Heights, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Commercial PROJECT STAGE: Construction Underway PROJECT STATUS: Completion Set For Summer 2018 EST. VALUE: $16 million OWNER/DEVELOPER: Bagley AHI Contact: Sachin Patel 600 Enterprises Dr. Lewis Center, OH 43035 Phone: 614-846-6600 ARCHITECT: Architectural Group III Contact: Gary Franks 201 S. Napanee St. Elkhart, IN 46514 Phone: 574-293-0008 www.architecturalgroup3.com CM: Witness Management Group Contact: Kenny Leckrone 600 Enterprise Dr. Lewis Center, OH 43035 Phone: 614-846-6600 www.thewitnessgroup.com ENG CONSULTANT: Mannik Smith Group DESCRIPTION: 4.3 acres, 2 bldgs, 99,000 sf. 112 suites with full kitchens - large meeting www.propertiesmag.com 75


All Things Concrete – Your Commercial & Decorative Total Concrete Solution

An Equal Opportunity Employer

21ST CENTURY CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION INC. 13925 Enterprise Ave., Cleveland, OH 44135

216.362.0900 www.21stcenturyconcrete.com SBE | CSB | EDGE | ODOT Certified

room - private meeting rooms - business/ computer center - fitness center - indoor pool - gift shop - patio area - sports court. 12,000 sf out-building that will have retail or restaurant businesses. Project Report #: 01732 AMAZON FULFILLMENT CENTER LOCATION: Site of Euclid Square Mall, Euclid, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Commercial PROJECT STATUS: Demolition Underway Construction to Start in Second Quarter 2018 - Projected Completion for Second Quarter 2019 EST. VALUE: $175 million + OWNER/DEVELOPER: Seefried Industrial Properties Inc. Contact: David Riefe, SVP, Chicago & Midwest 8745 W. Higgins Rd. Chicago, IL 60631 Phone: 847-298-1122 www.seefriedproperties.com ARCHITECT: MacGregor Associates Architects Contact: Clay Phipps 2727 Paces Ferry Rd., Ste. 1400 Atlanta, GA 30339 Phone: 770-432-9400 www.macgregorassoc.com DESCRIPTION: 68 acres, 650,000 sf. Fulfillment center for smaller items, including electronics, games, toys and books. 53 truck docks parking for 200 trailers and 1,800 cars. Project Report #: 01727 INTERNATIONAL HOUSE AT SAN TOMASSO TOWNHOUSES LOCATION: N. Main St., near St. Thomas Hospital and St. Anthony of Akron, OH (Summit County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Residential CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Groundbreaking Scheduled for 2nd Quarter 2018 DEVELOPER: Partnership of Testa Cos. and International Institute of Akron Testa Cos. Contact: Joel Testa 2355 2nd St. Cuyahoga Falls, OH 44221 Phone: 330-928-1988 www.testacompanies.com International Institute of Akron Contact: Elaine Woloshyn 2017 E. Tallmadge Ave. Akron, OH 44310 Phone: 330-376-5106 www.iiakron.org ARCHITECT: Mota Design 2321 Second St., Ste. 102 Cuyahoga Falls, OH 44221 Phone: 234-738-2840

76

Properties | February 2018


www.mota.design DESIGN/BUILDER: C/o Developer DESCRIPTION: 69,000 sf. 40 townhomes to be occupied largely by refugees. Project Report #: 01748 TALLMADGE FIRE STATION LOCATION: To Be Selected Tallmadge, OH (Summit County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STAGE: Project Proposed PROJECT STATUS: Feasibility Study Is Complete - Further Progress Not Set Pending Owner’s Decision To Proceed EST. VALUE: $9.5 million - $12.2 million OWNER: City of Tallmadge Contact: Michael G. Passarelli 46 North Ave. Tallmadge, OH 44278 Phone: 330-633-5127 www.tallmadge-ohio.org ARCHITECT: Richard Fleischman | DS Architecture Contact: Sean Barbina, Studio Director 315 Gougler Ave. Kent, OH 44240 Phone: 330-678-6144 DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 3 stories, 26,000 sf. Classic style fire station - sleeping quarters on the third floor. Project Report #: 01770 WARNER & SWASEY BUILDING REDEVELOPMENT LOCATION: 5701 Carnegie Ave. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: Renovation/Addition CATEGORY: Industrial PROJECT STAGE: Pre-planning PROJECT STATUS: Owner Seeing Developer Proposals March 23, 2018 OWNER: City of Cleveland Contact: David Ebersole & Richard Barga 601 Lakeside Ave., Ste. 210 Cleveland, OH 44114 Phone: 216-664-4274 STRUCTURAL ENG: Thorson Baker + Associates DESCRIPTION: 3 acres, 1 bldg, 5 stories, 221,727 sf. Restoration and development including some demolition to former Warner & Swasey Building. Project Report #: 01765 CSU WASHKEWITZ HALL ENGINEERING BUILDING PHASE TWO LOCATION: E. 24th & Chester Ave. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) www.csuohio.edu PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STAGE: Planning Stage PROJECT STATUS: Plans in Progress - Set For Completion for 1st Quarter 2019

OWNER: Cleveland State University Contact: Shehadeh AbelKarem 2121 Euclid Ave., PS 235 Cleveland, OH 44115-2214 Phone: 216-875-9944 www.csuohio.edu ARCHITECT: Bialosky Cleveland 6555 Carnegie Ave Cleveland, OH 44103 Phone: 216-752-8750 www.bialosky.com CM: Gilbane Building Co. Contact: Travis Okel 950 Main Ave., Ste. 1420 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-535-3000 www.gilbaneco.com DESCRIPTION: 5 stories, 40,000 sf. Completion of exterior building enclosure - HVAC systems - all interior finishes - completion from shell. Project Report #: 01747 PUBLIC SAFETY TRAINING FACILITY LOCATION: Tri-C Western Campus Parma and Parma Heights, OH (Cuyahoga County) WEBSITE: www.tri-c.edu PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STAGE: Design Development in Progress PROJECT STATUS: Design Development In Progress - Bid Date Not Set EST. VALUE: $11,000,000 OWNER: Cuyahoga Community College Contact: John Lang 700 Carnegie Ave. Cleveland, OH 44115-2878 Phone: 216-987-4882 www.tri-c.edu ARCHITECT: Richard Fleischman | DS Architecture Contact: David Potts, Studio Director 1020 Huron Rd., Ste. 101 Cleveland, OH 44115 Phone: 216-771-0090 www.dsarchitecture.com CIVIL ENG: Thorson Baker & Associates STRUCTURAL ENG: Thorson Baker & Associates MECH ENG: Karpinski Engineering ELEC ENG: Karpinski Engineering OWNERS REP: Constructability Inc. DESCRIPTION: 6-8 bldgs. Public safety training facility at Cuyahoga Community College western campus - multiple buildings. Information included in Construction Progress Report has been produced, processed and/or verified through sources believed to be reliable. Properties Magazine makes no warranty of any kind for this information, express or implied, and is not responsible for any omissions or inaccuracies. To contribute project data or to notify Properties of any reporting errors, we encourage you to email cpr@propertiesmag.com.

Specializing in all aspects of Metal Framing, Drywall, Acoustical Ceilings and Flooring

DESIGN/BUILD TENANT & CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS ARCHITECTURAL TRADES SUBCONTRACTOR At ICON INTERIORS, our goals and values are consistent with all clients: deliver quality work, on time and on budget. We strive to exceed every client’s expectations and form a lasting partnership. Our standards will ensure a flawless project every time. 2150 St. Clair Ave. Cleveland, OH 44114 glenn@iconwcf.com www.iconwcf.com

SERVING ALL OF NORTHEAST OHIO

216.713.2383 www.propertiesmag.com 77


Coming in March Cleveland State University’s Washkewicz College of Engineering Building Richard Fleischman | DS Architecture Schill Grounds Management Landscapes + Hardscapes …and more Interested in advertising? Call Properties today and an account www.propertiesmag.com representative can help you Visit us online for archived feaaddress your advertising needs: ture articles, advertising rates,

specs and subscription informa216.251.0035 / 888.641.4241 tion.

ADVERTISER INDEX 21st Century Concrete Construction, Inc. ........................... 76 Abraxus Snow Removal ............................................................... 24 AIA Cleveland .................................................................................... 42 Alber & Rice Inc................................................................................. 19 All Steel Mid-Rise .............................................................................30 American Interiors + Knoll .......................................................... 13 American International Construction................................... 70 AODK, Inc............................................................................................. 18 Baswa Acoustic .................................................................................30 BOMA Greater Cleveland ............................................................22 Brennan & Associates .................................................................... 75 Bruder Building Materials, Inc................................................... 37 Buckeye Sweeping, Inc.................................................................36 Building Enclosure Council......................................................... 42 Carey Demolition ............................................................................73 Carey Roofing....................................................................................60 Chagrin Valley Steel Erectors.....................................................66 Charles Schulz Building Company.......................................... 45 Chas. E Phipps Company, The .................................................. 33 Cleveland Chemical Pest Control, Inc. ..................................36 Cleveland Development Advisors, Inc. .................................17 Cleveland Engineering Society ................................................34 Columbia Building Products ......................................................17 Commercial Dock & Door/Timbers Kovar Co. ..................40 Commercial Interior Resources ................................................22 Commercial Roofing & Coating Systems, Inc. .....................3 County Fire Protection Inc.......................................................... 15 Cunningham Paving Inc. ............................................................. 55 Diamond Roofing Systems......................................................... 79 Duffy & Duffy Cost Segregation Services ...........................56 Dworken & Bernstein Co. ...........................................................69 EA Group.................................................................................................9 Educational Equipment ...............................................................20 Electro Expo ..........................................................................................6 EM Construction Co./Beacon Marshall Companies.......58 First Federal Of Lakewood.......................................................... 67 Foundation Building Materials/FBM...................................... 37 Frangos Group .................................................................................. 26 Frantz Ward LLP................................................................................73 Geauga Mechanical, Co. .............................................................. 51 Gojo Industries, Inc......................................................................... 43 H & M Snow Pros & Landscaping, Inc.......................................2 Hahn Loeser & Parks, LLP ............................................................60 HMH Restoration Ltd. ....................................................................63 Icon Interiors ......................................................................................77 Infinity Construction...................................................................... 74 Integrated Project Solutions......................................................40 J Norman Stark, LPA ....................................................................... 76

J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc. ..........................................................56 Jamieson Ricca Fenestration ..................................................... 47 Janitor Jack ..........................................................................................12 JL Taylor, Co. Inc. .............................................................................. 78 John G. Johnson Construction Co. ......................................... 13 Kaczmar Architects Inc. ................................................................ 52 Krill Company, Inc.............................................................................17 Lakewood Supply Co.....................................................................44 Lisco Heating & Cooling, Inc. ..................................................... 42 Maguire Photo .................................................................................. 39 Mason Structural Steel, Inc......................................................... 75 Masonry Restoration Maintenance........................................ 15 McMahon Masonry Restoration .............................................. 65 Meaden & Moore, Ltd.................................................................... 62 Messina Floor Covering, Inc. ...................................................... 70 Mid State Restoration, Inc. .......................................................... 51 Midwest Parking Lot Maintenance, LLC .............................. 41 Neptune Plumbing & Heating Company............................20 North Coast Concrete, Inc...........................................................54 Novagradac & Co., LLP. .................................................................20 O’Toole McLaughlin Dooley Pecora/OMDP ......................64 OCP Contractors ..............................................................................29 Panel Tech Group ............................................................................ 33 Pease Photography ........................................................................56 Perfection Landscapes ................................................................. 13 Pete & Pete Container Service ..................................................46 Precision Environmental Co....................................................... 55 RAM Construction Services of Cleveland ..............................7 Ram USA............................................................................................... 14 Ranallo & Aveni LLC........................................................................73 RM Riggle Enterprises, Inc. ......................................................... 47 S.A. Comunale Company ...............................................................7 Schill Grounds Management..................................................... 49 Siegel Jennings ................................................................................80 Singerman, Mills, Desberg & Krantz Company ................ 19 Skoda Minotti Company..............................................................64 Sleggs Danzinger & Gill ...................................................................4 SMACNA Cleveland .........................................................................11 Space Comfort Co. ..........................................................................58 Strano Construction Co.........................................................19, 53 Summit Painting .............................................................................. 21 Sunray Window Films LLC...........................................................38 Suntrol Co............................................................................................ 24 Sutton Industrial Hardware & Tool Rental ..........................36 The Foundry/MCPc ........................................................................ 53 Thorson Baker & Associates, Inc. ............................................. 53 Warren Roofing & Insulating Co. ............................................. 51 Wurz Company, The R.L. ..............................................................58

COMMERCIAL & INDUSTRIAL RIAL ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS SERVICE Upfront Pricing • Trouble-Shoot & Repair

OH LIC #21927

NEW CONSTRUCTION Design/Build • Spec/Build

www.propertiesmag.com

ENERGY-SAVING UPGRADES

Visit us online today to view archived issues in an interactive digital format.

BUILDING & PROCESS AUTOMATION Engineering • Installation ON-TIME PERFORMANCE GUARANTEED

78

service@jltaylorcompany.com www.jltaylorcompany.com

440.834.1223 Properties | February 2018


The Diamond Difference. Ƥ Ǧ Ƥ Ǧ Ǥ ơ ǡ ȋ ͖͘Ȁ͛ Ȍ ǡ Ǥ Ƥ Ǧ ơ Ǧ Ǧ Ǧ Ǥ

www.DiamondRoofSystems.com CORPORATE OFFICE

AKRON/CLEVELAND BRANCH

8031 E. Market St. Suite #6 Warren, Ohio 44484 330-856-2500

6726 Tallmadge Rd. Rootstown, Ohio 44272 330-850-5360

Service@TeamDiamond.co


When your fair share of taxes is neither fair... nor your share

Fostering Fairness for All Taxpayers The attorneys at Siegel Jennings bring experience as accountants, appraisers and real estate developers to the practice of law. Our property tax services include: Ŷ Representation at the administrative level through the State Supreme Court Ŷ Local expertise in every state through the American Property Tax Counsel Ŷ Tax management – acquisition/disposition strategies Ŷ Cutting edge approaches to property tax reductions

Siegel Jennings Call J. Kieran Jennings, Esq at 216.763.1004 23425 Commerce Park Drive, Suite 103, Beachwood OH 44122

www.siegeltax.com

Cleveland Ŷ Pittsburgh Ŷ Columbus Founding member, American Property Tax Counsel (APTC) • www.aptc.com


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Northeast Ohio Properties, February 2018 by REjournals - Issuu