Skip to main content

Northeast Ohio Properties, February 2017

Page 1

INSIDE : Oatey Customer Support Center • Legal Services Special Section

February 2017/$7.95

Hospitable Healthcare

Cleveland Clinic Avon Hospital delivers modern care, offers patients self-service options


WHERE INNOVATION AND EXPERTISE WORK FOR YOU

TM

ROOFING WATERPROOFING WALL SYSTEMS

CIVIL ENGINEERING

SOPREMA offers a comprehensive line of roofing, waterproofing, wall protection and civil engineering solutions combining superior products and systems with decades of proven performance. Our solutions include industry leading SBS-modified bitumen membranes, polymeric PMMA/ PMA liquid applied membranes and synthetic single ply PVC membranes. For applications as diverse as roofing, below grade waterproofing, plaza deck and balcony waterproofing, air and vapor barriers and bridge and parking structures, SOPREMA has the solution. SOPREMA’s relentless pursuit of technological advancement, sustainability and product quality has been known and respected around the world for over 100 years.

SOPREMA.US

1.800.356.3521

SOPREMA.CA

1.877.MAMMOUTH


Y landscaping Your l d makes k a powerful f l statement to your clients l and prospective clients. Let our Grounds Maintenance Division keep yours in top condition all year long.

*5281'6 0$,17(1$1&( ',9,6,21 3URIHVVLRQDO _ 'HGLFDWHG _ ([SHULHQFHG

ZZZ KPODQGVFDSLQJ FRP *5((1


Reducing Real Property Tax Assessments Throughout Ohio And Across The United States Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill, Co., LPA

When you hire Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill, you work directly with Sleggs, Danzinger and Gill. Each client is directly represented at all levels by a principal of the firm with a combined 75 years of experience. No pyramid, no associates, no on-the-job training. Our clients deserve the very best representation, so we structured our firm to allow each client, throughout the entire process, to work directly with Messrs. SLEGGS, DANZINGER and/or GILL. Our philosophy is to work cooperatively with school district and County officials to ensure that our clients pay the lowest possible real property tax obligations. If a fair resolution requires litigation, SLEGGS, DANZINGER & GILL have the depth of trial and appellate experience to handle the most complex valuation issues. Whether the valuation relates to large industrial plants, apartments, shopping centers, warehouses, office buildings, vacant land or any other type of commercial property, the faces above will ensure that you receive the best counsel, legal advice and litigation expertise.

Member Firm

Todd W. Sleggs, Esq.

Robert K. Danzinger, Esq.

Steven R. Gill, Esq.

tsleggs@sdglegal.net

rdanzinger@sdglegal.net

sgill@sdglegal.net

(216) 771-8990 sdglegal.net

Sleggs, Danzinger & Gill 820 West Superior Ave. Seventh Floor Cleveland, OH 44113


February 2017, Volume LXXI, Number 2

FEATURES Phone: 216.251.0035 Toll Free: 888.641.4241 Fax: 216.251.0064 www.propertiesmag.com CLEVELAND 3826 W. 158th St. Cleveland, Ohio 44111 AKRON P.O. Box 9 Munroe Falls, Ohio 44262

MANAGING EDITOR/ART DIRECTOR Mark Watt mwatt@propertiesmag.com 216.251.2655 CONTRIBUTING WRITERS Doug Bardwell, Jeanne Bluffstone, Dennis Castiglione, Ian Frank, Lou Kren, Matt Lehnert, Alec Pacella, Diane DiPiero Rodio, John Slagter, David Woodburn

Photo by Robert Marrott

OWNER/PUBLISHER Kenneth C. Krych kkrych@propertiesmag.com 216.251.0035

10 New Construction Starts in December Slide 5% Nationally 15 Promoting Productivity Oatey Customer Support Center adopts open office plan, facilitates collaboration

40 Hospitable Healthcare Cleveland Clinic Avon Hospital delivers modern care, offers patients self-service options

55 Special Section: Legal Services 55 Ground Leases & Downtown Redevelopment: Can an old ground lease affect a property’s future?

MEDIA CONSULTANTS Matt Lehnert mlehnert@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6753

57 When Can Landlords Take Matters into their Own Hands? Examining landlords’ self-help rights in commercial & residential leases

Larry Overbey loverbey@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6649

59 Five Common Misperceptions About Overtime Laws: A look at typical mistakes that lead to costly Fair Labor Standards Act liability 62 NAIOP News: Stream & Wetland Permitting – A Moving Target

OFFICE MANAGER Lisa Larissey 216.251.8506

64 Legal Perspectives: Five Points to Consider When Selecting Counsel 66 Vantage Point: 2017 – Changes to Ohio Public Contracting Rules

Cover photo: Cleveland Clinic Avon Hospital, by Kevin Reeves

68 New Tools & Potential Risks in Environmental Due Diligence: An examination of environmental insurance and vapor intrusion 71 A Break in the Chain of Title – Curing Defective Titles: New Ohio law significantly shortens time to cure defective titles – effective April 6, 2017

Properties (ISSN 033-1287) is published monthly for architects, engineers, building owners and managers, general contractors, home builders, mortgage bankers, savings and loans, real estate agents, appraisers, servicers and suppliers in Northern Ohio by Properties, Inc., 3826 W. 158th St., Cleveland, Ohio 44111. Copyright © 2017 by Properties, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction or use, without written permission, of editorial or pictorial content is strictly prohibited. Periodicals postage paid in Cleveland, Ohio and additional offices. Subscription rates: one year $24.95, single copy $7.95, back issues $10 when available. Postmaster: send change of address notices to Properties, P.O. Box 112127, Cleveland, Ohio 44111.

DEPARTMENTS 8 13 28 30 35 74

PROPERTIES PEOPLE BOMA BUSINESS ACAR CORNER FINANCIAL STRATEGIES BILLBOARD CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT www.propertiesmag.com 5


PUBLISHER’S NOTE February 2017

Law in Order elcome to our February issue, featuring our special annual section on Legal Services with input from a number of the top law firms serving Northeast Ohio’s real estate, AEC and property management sectors.

W

The range in topics is broad and diverse, with articles on ground leases and downtown redevelopment; landlords’ self-help rights in residential and commercial leases; and tips in selecting counsel. Additionally, we offer articles on changes in Ohio laws regarding curing defective titles; public contracting rules; and stream and wetland permitting. We thank the contributing firms of Buckingham Doolittle Burroughs LLP; Buckley King, LPA; Frantz Ward, LLP; McCarthy, Lebit, Crystal & Liffman Co. LPA.; Meyers Roman Friedberg & Lewis;

KEN KRYCH

Roetzel & Andress; Ulmer & Berne, LLP; and Walter | Haverfield LLP; for their contributions. Cleveland Clinic Avon Hospital Our cover story this month centers on the new Cleveland Clinic Avon Hospital, which provides Lorain County residents with access to expanded healthcare services. Connected to the previous emergency department opened in 2012, the hospital will provide 114 medical/ surgical beds and 12 ICU beds. This 212,000-square-foot, five-story building

Architectural Product Specialists COMMERCIAL INDUSTRIAL INSTITUTIONAL RETAIL 330.274.3100 6

Specializing In Engineering, Fabrication & Installation Of: • Composite Metal Wall Systems • Copper & Stainless Steel Systems • Custom Fascias, Frieze Boards, Eaves • Metal Roofing (Rolled on Site!) • Flashing & Trim • Custom Gutters & Downspouts • Commercial Gutters (Rolled on Site!)

Properties@CourtadDalton.com

CourtadDalton.com Properties | February 2017


was the next step in providing needed healthcare options in the area. Oatey Customer Support Center The new Oatey Customer Support Center located on Emerald Parkway in Cleveland provides a new two-story 47,000-square-foot building overlooking the Cleveland MetroParks and enables the consolidation of several divisions of Oatey to interact under one roof to improve communication, collaboration and service to clients. Oatey now manufactures over 6,000 key construction and building products distributed to 70 countries worldwide. CEA: We Build This City Properties is very proud to have worked in partnership with Construction Employers Association (CEA) to produce a separate publication this month dedicated to a century of building progress in the region by CEA’s members, with a focus on the association’s past, present and future goals. We’re happy to have covered the remarkable craftsmanship of its members over 70 of the last 100 years within these pages. Congratulations CEA!

Built to work. for Cleveland.

For over years, The Krill Co., Inc. has constructed and restored landmark buildings that make our city unique. With clients from world-class laboratory research facilities and hospitals, to college campuses and corporate headquarters, Krill has earned its reputation of being a premier contractor.

Cleveland is our home, our commitment and our pride.

Visit krill.com or call 216.357.4777

Coming in March Getting a jump-start on Spring, Landscapes + Hardscapes will be our focus in March. We anticipate educational information from the top firms whose work beautifies and accents buildings in our surrounding environment. In addition, we will be touring one of the latest accomplishments for Akron Public Schools with the new Firestone/ Litchfield Community Learning Center. We will also highlight West 25th Street Lofts, an exciting project that brings freshly renovated residential spaces to the edge of the Ohio City neighborhood on Cleveland’s near West Side. Until then, work smart and stay warm, keeping thoughts of spring in mind. Positively,

Kenneth C. Krych Owner/Publisher www.propertiesmag.com 7


CAUTION: PROPERTIES PEOPLE HARD HAT AREA TEAM ULLMAN AT WORK Highlighting notable industry events

1

2

5

6

ACAR Inaugural Event

COMMERCIAL • INDUSTRIAL RETAIL • SYSTEMS

7

3

4

8

1 Mike Valerino (ACAR) and Tom Begam (Fifth Third Bank) 2 Seth Task (Berkshire Hathaway Homeservices) and Karen O’Connell (Coldwell Banker Hunter Realty) 3 Steve Merkle (Cutler Real Estate) and Jim Fox (Stouffer Realty, Inc.) 4 Robert Redmond (Mohr Partners), Patti Gash (Howard Hanna Realty), Joe Aveni, Jim Fox (Stouffer Realty, Inc.) and Joyce Goldsmith (Howard Hanna Realty) 5 Brant Smith (NEO Realty Group), Barbara Reynolds and Sharon Znidarsic (Howard Hanna Realty) 6 Jim Fox (2017 ACAR President) and Joe Aveni (ACAR) 7 Jim Fox and Sara Calo (Howard Hanna Realty) 8 Ahren Booher (Keller Williams), Julie M. Johnson (Boys & Girls Club of the Western Reserve), Ron Soeder (Boys & Girls Club of the Western Reserve) and Tim Damiano (Russel Real Estate)

Over 200 members were in attendance for the 2017 Akron Cleveland Association of Realtors (ACAR) Inaugural Event, held recently at the DoubleTree Cleveland in Independence. Colleagues and peers from across Northeast Ohio networked, forged new relationships and enjoyed a buffet dinner which made for an enjoyable evening. P

DESIGN/BUILD Dedicated to serving our customers & providing quality work at competitive rates.

1

2

Ŷ Generator/UPS Ŷ Data Centers Ŷ Teledata/Fiber Ŷ IP Cameras Ŷ Access Control Ŷ Fire Alarm

0%( )%( &HUWL¿HG 3901 Chester Avenue Cleveland, OH 44114

216.432.5777

www.ullmanelectric.com 8

3

NCBIA Installation Banquet Approximately 100 members of the North Coast Building Industry Association (NCBIA) gathered at Parker’s Grille and Tavern in Avon Lake recently for the association’s Annual Installation Ceremony. The evening banquet dinner event provided an introduction to the association’s recently elected 2017 president, officers and directors. P

4

1 Lisa Matuszak, Revonda Pecze, Michelle Nowlin and Edie Tiller (First Federal Savings of Lorain) 2 Past Presidents: Bill Perritt, Jack Kousma, Chris Majzun, Sr., Mary H. Felton, Jeff Hensley, Chris S. Majzun, Jr., David Linna, Sr. and Tom Lahetta 3 NCBIA 2017 Board of Directors: (back row) Tom Caruso, Chris Majzun Sr., Chris S. Majzun, Jr., Mark F. Craig, Jeremy Vorndran, Jeff Hensley, Steve Fleming and Tom Lahetta, (front row) Keith Martin, Shannon Niebes, Sara MajzunGarwood, Ashley Caruso, Mary H. Felton, Liz Schneider and Michelle Nowlin 4 Jason Scott (Pepperwood Homes at Greyhawk), Mary H. Felton (Fidelity National Title) and Mike Lapos (Lapos Construction, Inc.)

Properties | February 2017


When your fair share of taxes is neither fair... nor your share

Fostering Fairness for All Taxpayers The attorneys at Siegel Jennings bring experience as accountants, appraisers and real estate developers to the practice of law. Our property tax services include: Ŷ Representation at the administrative level through the State Supreme Court Ŷ Local expertise in every state through the American Property Tax Counsel Ŷ Tax management – acquisition/disposition strategies Ŷ Cutting edge approaches to property tax reductions

Siegel Jennings Call J. Kieran Jennings, Esq at 216.763.1004 23425 Commerce Park Drive, Suite 103, Beachwood OH 44122

www.siegeltax.com

Cleveland Ŷ Pittsburgh Ŷ Columbus Founding member, American Property Tax Counsel (APTC) • www.aptc.com


New Construction Starts in December Slide 5% Naturally Provided by Dodge Data & Analytics

ew construction starts in December slipped 5% to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of $613.0 billion, according to Dodge Data & Analytics. The latest month’s decline for total construction was due to sharply reduced activity for the nonbuilding construction sector, reflecting further erosion by public works as well as a steep plunge by the electric utility/gas plant category. At the same time, nonresidential building in December held steady with its November pace, and residential building was able to register moderate growth.

N

New York, New York, which retreated after the robust activity reported in 2015, Murray says. On the negative side, public works settled back in 2016, and steep declines were reported for manufacturing plants and the gas plant portion of the electric utility/gas plant category. “In a broad sense, construction activity shifted to a more mature stage of expansion in 2016, characterized by a slower rate of growth for total construction compared to the 10% to 12% gains of the previous four years,” Murray says. “For 2017, more growth Robert A. Murray at a moderate pace is expected for Dodge Data & Analytics total construction. Commercial building has yet to see much in the way was beginning to regain upward momen- of rising vacancy rates, and the institutional building sector will be helped tum after pausing in 2015.” Single-family housing showed mod- by the passage of such recent bond erate improvement, while multifamily measures as the $9 billion Proposition housing witnessed growth in numerous 51 in California. “Manufacturing plant construction markets with the notable exception of should turn upward, no longer exerting a downward pull on overall construction Construction Survey GIS activity. Despite rising mortgage rates, Sales Service Rentals Training Support housing should benefit from greater & Instrument, Inc.. Shop Online! demand coming from an increasing www.laserinst.com number of millennials moving into their Build Construction Solutions thirties. And, public works will be supported by recent bond measures passed at the state level, although Congress will need to revisit the flat federal funding for highways under the current continuing resolution that expires at the end of April. Additional support for public works will depend on how Congress New Kenai Tablet responds to the proposals by the Trump w/ 10.1 Inch Screen! Administration for more infrastructure Robert Fancher | Build Construction Solutions spending, including incentives to spur 2I¿FH _ &HOO _ 5-)#ODVHULQVW FRP private investment.”

For all of 2016, total construction starts advanced 1% to $676.5 billion, a considerably smaller gain than the 11% increase reported for 2015. If the volatile manufacturing plant and electric utility/ gas plant categories are excluded, total construction starts in 2016 would be up 4%, depicting a more gradual deceleration relative to the corresponding 9% increase in 2015. The December statistics produced a reading of 130 for the Dodge Index (2000=100), down from a revised 136 for November. For the full year 2016, the Dodge Index averaged 143. “The construction start statistics over the course of 2016 revealed a varied pattern, with the end result being a slight gain for the year as a whole,” says Robert A. Murray, chief economist for Dodge Data & Analytics. “On a quarterly basis, growth was reported during the first and third quarters, while activity settled back during the second and fourth quarters.

On the plus side for 2016, commercial building continued to rise, and institutional building provided evidence that it

“In a broad sense, construction activity shifted to a more mature stage of expansion in 2016, characterized by a slower rate of growth for total construction compared to the 10% to 12% gains of the previous four years.”

Precision Laser

Nonresidential building Design

10

Build

Operate

Nonresidential building in December was reported at $224.0 billion (annual rate), basically unchanged from Properties | February 2017


November. The manufacturing plant category jumped 124%, bouncing back from a weak November with the lift coming from the start of a $1.2 billion pharmaceutical plant in Clayton, North Carolina. The commercial categories as a group advanced 11% in December, making a partial rebound after falling 20% in the previous month. Hotel construction climbed 74%, reflecting the start of the $164 million hotel portion of the $500 million Skyplex Entertainment Complex in Orlando, Florida and a $138 million hotel at New York’s JFK International Airport (as part of the conversion of the historic TWA Flight Center building). Office construction in December increased 25%. Warehouse construction was the one commercial project type to retreat in December, falling 35%. The institutional building categories as a group dropped 17% in December. Amusement-related construction plunged 70%, following its elevated activity in November that included the start of the $3.0 billion football stadium for the Los Angeles Rams in Inglewood, California. Despite the steep decline, the amusement category did include two noteworthy projects as December starts – the $242 million amusement park portion of the Skyplex Entertainment Complex in Orlando, Florida and a $130 million student recreation/aquatics center at San Jose State University in San Jose, California. Reduced activity was also reported in December for public buildings (courthouses and detention facilities), down 17%; and healthcare facilities, down 12%. On the plus side, the educational facilities category jumped 34% in December, reaching its highest amount in 2016. For 2016 as a whole, nonresidential building advanced 4% to $227.7 billion, regaining upward momentum after slipping 2% in 2015. Over the past two years the percent change for nonresidential building has been dampened by substantial declines for the manufacturing plant category, which plunged 32% in 2015 and then another 27% in 2016. The weaker performance by manufacturing plants reflected in particular a pullback for new petrochemical plant starts after the exceptional amount that was reported back in 2014. If the manufacturing plant category is excluded,

We’re Out to Clean Up This Town SWEEPING PRESSURE WASHING CONSTRUCTION SITES PARKING LOTS & DECKS WAREHOUSES SPECIAL EVENTS FLUSHING

330.798.9200 | WWW.BUCKEYESWEEPING.COM

www.propertiesmag.com 11


nonresidential building in 2016 would show a 7% increase, slightly stronger than the corresponding 4% gain in 2015.

Residential building Residential building in December climbed 9% to $306.9 billion (annual rate). Multifamily housing finished the year on a strong note, rising 26% after retreating 12% in November. December featured groundbreaking for 14 multifamily projects valued each at $100 million or more, led by the $275 million Ancora Apartment Tower in Chicago, Illinois; a $260 million condominium

tower in Minneapolis, Minnesota; and a $250 million condominium tower in Sunny Isles Beach, Florida. Singlefamily housing in December increased 4%, maintaining the modest if at times hesitant upward trend that was present during 2016. The 2016 amount for residential building was $287.0 billion, up 6% and a smaller gain than the 16% hike reported for 2015. Much of the deceleration was due to a considerably slower increase for multifamily housing, which grew just 3% as opposed to the 22% jump in 2015. The nation’s leading multifamily

reliable & local CALL OUR COMMERCIAL SALES MANAGERS TODAY, TO DISCUSS YOUR ELECTRIC SERVICE NEEDS

Wes Tarver: 216.664.3922 ext.145 Kim Smith: 216.664.3922 ext. 253 VISIT US AT WWW.CPP.ORG

Celebrating 20 years of Excellence

Cleveland 216-663-3777 Toledo 419-865-7100 LQ¿QLW\FRQVWUXFWLRQ FRP

([SHULHQFH 12

([FHOOHQFH &RPPLWPHQW

market by dollar volume, New York, New York, dropped 28% in 2016 after surging 53% in 2015. Multifamily construction in New York City had been supported by the 421-a program, which provided tax incentives to developers who included affordable housing in their projects. During 2015, the pending expiration of the 421-a program contributed to developers moving up the start date for projects, while the expiration of the program in January 2016 removed the incentives. If the New York, New York metropolitan area is excluded, multifamily housing for the nation in 2016 would be up 13% in dollar terms, essentially the same as the corresponding 14% increase in 2015. After New York, New York, the next metropolitan areas for multifamily housing in the top 10 by dollar volume all registered double-digit increases in 2016. Rounding out the top five markets, with their percent change from 2015, were the following – Los Angeles, California, up 50%; Miami, Florida, up 14%; Chicago, Illinois, up 82%; and Washington, D.C., up 20%. Metropolitan areas ranked 6 through 10 were the following – Boston, Massachusetts, up 45%; Dallas-Ft. Worth, Texas, up 22%; San Francisco, California, up 63%; Atlanta, Georgia, up 52%; and Denver, Colorado, up 29%. Single-family housing in 2016 grew 8% in dollar terms, a more measured pace compared to its 14% gain in 2015. By geography, single-family housing in 2016 showed this pattern for the five major regions – the Midwest, up 10%; the South Atlantic, up 9%; the West, up 8%; the Northeast, up 5%; and the South Central, up 4%. The 1% increase at the national level for total construction starts in 2016 was the result of a mixed performance at the five-region level. Total construction gains were reported in the West and the South Atlantic, each up 10%; and the Midwest, up 5%. Total construction declines were reported in the Northeast, down 2% (which reflected the retreat for multifamily housing in the New York, New York metropolitan area); and the South Central, down 16% (which reflected that region’s comparison to 2015 which included the start of several massive liquefied natural gas export terminals). P Properties | February 2017


BOMA BUSINESS Exploring timely topics with BOMA members

Considering a Long-Term Natural Gas Plan? hen it comes to planning for your properties’ natural gas needs, it’s important to feel confident with your pricing and terms. To better understand today’s market conditions, it is helpful to get a sense of what has taken place over the past year to impact pricing, and the factors that may affect future pricing.

W

Last winter was much milder than expected, and natural gas storage levels remained at a three-year high. Interestingly, there was a price spike during the spring-summer time period, but not because of the warm winter. Instead, it was largely due to the upswing in the use of natural gas for power generation (which resulted from the previously low prices). As a result, producers were halting production during those previous low price points in the market, which drove prices up in the short term. However, long-term pricing has actually remained much more stable as of late. How can you use this information in planning for your natural gas (and power) procurement needs?

Planning ahead Where prices will go into the future remains to be seen, but there are a couple of key factors of note that could potentially cause an increase: • The U.S. is now exporting Liquefied Natural Gas, with exports expected to increase – November 2016 marked the first time ever that the United States was a net exporter of natural gas • Power generation continues to rely more and more on natural gas, especially as coal retirements continue

• From a supply perspective, shale production remains strong, but as previously proven, producers have demonstrated that they are willing to curb drilling if prices go too low

WE SPEAK

ENERGY SO YOU DON’T HAVE TO

Given the short-term volatility and the relatively stable long-term pricing, a strong case can be made for locking in a long-term rate now.

Contact us today and

The impact on power pricing

energy costs

With the recent run-up in natural gas prices, power prices have also experienced dramatic volatility, especially January and February 2017 prices. These two months are traditionally very high consumption months as many apartment dwellers and homeowners have electric heaters. The impending cold weather is bringing with it price spikes that we have not seen lately in power pricing. Thankfully, longer term electric prices have been minimally impacted and remain at attractive levels for end users. P BOMA Greater Cleveland is proud to provide this space to our Associate Members so they can inform, educate and share their knowledge with property management professionals. This article was written by Andrea Longbrake, lead commercial account manager of IGS Energy. Andrea can be reached at 614.659.5190 or alongbrake@ IGSenergy.com. IGS Energy can be found on the web at www.igsenergy.com/business.

gain more control over your building’s

Preferred natural gas supplier since 1996

ANDREA LONGBRAKE Senior Commercial Account Manager

614.659.5190

alongbrake@IGSenergy.com

www.propertiesmag.com 13


Proud to be part of the team at Oatey Customer Support Center

(URVLRQ 6HGLPHQW &RQWURO ,QVSHFWLRQV _ &3(6& &HUWLÀHG SWPPP Planning | Environmental Compliance Consulting

Strongsville, OH | 440.590.2903 | lisamvavro@gmail.com 6%( )%( :%( '%( FHUWLÀHG

Solutions that deliver and sustain your vision. Congratulations to the Oatey Company! We are honored to have served as Construction Manager as part of such an outstanding team.

www.donleyinc.com

14

Properties | February 2017


Promoting Productivity Oatey Customer Support Center adopts open office plan, facilitates collaboration By Doug Bardwell | Photos by Robert Marrott

ack in 2012, department heads needed to preplan meetings, put on their coats and possibly drive to another building to discuss engineering issues or product launches. With the opening of the new Oatey Customer Support Center on 7.65 acres at 20600 Emerald Parkway in Cleveland, that’s all just a memory for its 135 associates.

B

The new, two-story, 47,000-square-foot building consolidates marketing, sales, customer service, finance, engineering, R&D and management, all within just seconds of each other. The building’s open plan enables convenient collisions among personnel from all departments which fosters interaction and cooperation on projects.

a manufacturing plant on Berea Road. Within four years, Oatey began manufacturing solvent cements for plumbers. Now, selling millions of cans of plumbing solvents each year, Oatey is the

STRONG RELATIONSHIPS INSPIRE GREAT WORK.

Defining success for 100 years Starting in 1916, company founder Lee Roy Oatey began selling a single product, never imagining that a century later his inventory would boast more than 6,000 SKU’s. It all began with manufactured lead roof flashing. During World War II, Oatey supported the war effort by drilling aircraft bolts. In 1947, at war’s end, the firm built

world’s largest producer of this staple for the plumbing trade. In 1958, a hardware DIY division was begun, and by 1959, a larger facility was needed and the company opened its

Oatey HQ Cleveland, OH

Strategy. Design. Architecture. Cleveland 216.588.0800

New York 646.865.1200

www.vocon.com

www.propertiesmag.com 15


OPEN ENVIRONMENT Taking advantage of the surroundings, a 2,800-square-foot concrete patio overlooks a quarter-mile walking path and the relaxing views of the Rocky River Reservation below.

manufacturing facility on West 160th Street, a location it still uses today. Growth by acquisition started in the ‘80s, acquiring American Roof Flashing Company and United Elchem Industries. The ‘90s saw the addition of Casper

Drains, Cherne Industries and the establishment of Oatey Canada. With the new millennium approaching, Oatey turned its sights toward ISO 9001 certification, receiving the designation in 2001. Within a few

Proud to have provided concrete services for OATEY CUSTOMER SUPPORT CENTER with Donley's, Inc.

short years, Oatey SCS (Supply Chain Services) opened its LEED-certified Cleveland Distribution Center, a quarter-million-square-foot project on Industrial Parkway. Picking up speed, the company acquired Dearborn Brass in 2003, William Harvey Co. in 2006 and Hercules Chemical Co. in 2011. The year 2008 saw the opening of its first oversees facility in Changshu, China, and the beginning of LEAN. Now, with four manufacturing plants and four distribution centers, Oatey provides its products to 70 countries around the world.

A customer-focused corporate culture

NORTH COAST CONCRETE Brian R. Dalrymple, Vice President Ź Quality Workmanship

Ź Customer Satisfaction

Ź On-Time Performance Ź Emphasizing Safety

216-642-1114 www.northcoastconcrete.com 6061 Carey Dr., Valley View, OH 44125 16

Member of:

“Our company has had a customer focus way back to its roots in 1916,” explains Ron Compiseno, vice-president at Oatey. “We never want to forget that serving our customers is why we are here. We place the customers’ needs first and foremost.” Hence, while the building functionally serves as the company’s headquarters, it has been named the Oatey Customer Support Center. “Fortunately, our Cleveland manufacturing plant and our distribution facilities Properties | February 2017


Proud to be the Roofing Contractor at Oatey Customer Support Center with Donleys

ISO 9001 CERTIFIED

INDUSTRIAL FIRST, INC.

THE CONSTRUCTION RESOURCE COMPANY Roofing | Steel Erection Waterproofing & Protective Coatings | Siding & Decking Sheet Metal Fabrication & Installation | Electrical 25840 Miles Rd., Cleveland, Ohio 44146 Fax: (216) 991-2139 | corporate@industrialfirst.com | www.industrialfirst.com

(216) 991-8600


Congratulations to Donley’s & Oatey Customer Support Center

J.P.

PLUMBING & HEATING, INC. COMMERCIAL

INDUSTRIAL

INSTITUTIONAL

Plumbing Installations Industrial Piping Medical Gas

Also Providing Vactor Sewer Cleaning & Jetting

Fire Sprinkler Installation & System Testing

SERVING NORTHEAST OHIO SINCE 1928 216.831.5165 | www.jpplumbing.com


HIGHLIGHTING HISTORY Situated just beyond the reception desk is a centrally located, floor-to-ceiling island. Here, the story of Oatey’s past, present and future – including a time-lapse of the building’s construction – is communicated using digital signage screens.

are both nearby,” Compiseno says. “When necessary, any of our Support Center associates can and do walk the manufacturing or distribution floors to better understand how their work impacts their internal and external customers.” Oatey’s concerns cover not only its customers, but its 135 associates who work in the new facility as well. When it came time to build this facility, Oatey first looked at other Northeast Ohio locations, but ultimately decided on staying nearby to keep workforce stability and facilitate associates’ work life balance. “[Oatey] was committed to staying within the borders of Cleveland, and we were able to find a good site near its distribution center,” says Howard Lichtig, SIOR, vice president with CBRE, which provided real estate services on the project. The present site wasn’t without challenges, however. The land came with deed restrictions and covenants related to the adjacent Cleveland Metroparks, such as a 30-foot height restriction (to the tallest component) as well as drainage, lighting and parking restrictions. By August of 2013, Oatey began talking to several design firms, finally selecting Vocon.

“We probably spent the first six months just talking about process,” says Matt Heisey, LEED AP, principal with Vocon. “This ‘conversation’ about how we work, our design process, and the way in which we can best bring the program together, all preceded us actually being hired.”

Jodi van der Wiel, AIA NCARB, NCIDQ, LEED AP BD+C, continues, “From the start of design work, it was all about their beliefs, including sustainability and a sensitivity to the site, capitalizing on views and giving their employees the most pleasant space in which to collaborate.”

Proud to provide exterior ceramic tile at OATEY CUSTOMER SUPPORT CENTER

Commercial, Institutional & Industrial Floor Covering Provider & Installer

Specializing in the healthcare marketplace with the highest quality & best service since 1989. We provide 24/7 service & installation. Call us today to take advantage of our trained in-house staff and extensive library of product information. Complete line of flooring including: Carpeting • Resilient Flooring, Vinyl & Ceramic Tile • Athletic Floors

Call today for a FREE estimate! 4300 Brookpark Rd., Cleveland, OH 44134 • 216-595-0100 • Toll Free 888-271-8200 www.propertiesmag.com 19


OPENING UP A floating stairway connects both floors, with light wood inserts utilized on each tread which contrast with walnut wall panels and the duranodic bronze-colored structural metal staircase.

Based on the workplace strategy CM helps us make good decisions early research, the Vocon team organized the in the process.” program within the building and worked “I couldn’t agree more,” Heitner says. with the design team to develop key “5:00, 6:00 or 7:00 p.m., I’d be calling architectural moments, integrating exte- Erica or Julie at Vocon looking for a rior to interior. resolution of an issue to present to Ron “The material palettes, both exterior the following morning. Working with and interior, were quite sustainable. Many their consultants and our subcontracof the materials are recycled or recyclable, tors, we were always looking for the best which led to our choice of the dark bronze solutions for the project.” and the stone used on the exterior,” says Seeking LEED Gold certification, van der Wiel. Oatey demanded the After a bidding design/construction phase, contractor team to deliver many interviews, some sustainable solutions. site visitations and In addition, Oatey a lengthy evaluaproduct was specified tion, Oatey felt that throughout the buildDonley’s matched the ing. A white EPDM company’s views and roof reduces heat, and values. Donley’s was the rain runoff is capthen awarded with a tured as grey water in Construction Manager a cistern. That water at Risk contract in is then reused for the early January 2015. water-saving flush Jodi van der Wiel fixtures. Site storm“Our companies were very aligned Vocon water runoff is further with similar values,” mitigated through biosays Nate Heitner, project manager swales incorporated into the landscaping. with Donley’s. “We are both very colThanks in part to the mild winter laborative, very transparent and we of 2015/2016, Donley’s construction both wanted a similar outcome.” Both progressed relatively smoothly and firms have lengthy, family-owned his- allowed for a September 2016 movetories where the founding family is in, with a ribbon-cutting ceremony on still involved. October 11, 2016. “At that point, we were in late scheEntering the building matic/early design development, which “The lobby is a welcoming, open space is a method we prefer for projects like this,” Heisey says. “Working with the where customers, suppliers, candidates

“From the start of design work, it was all about [Oatey’s] beliefs, including sustainability and a sensitivity to the site, capitalizing on views and giving their employees the most pleasant space in which to collaborate.”

20

Properties | February 2017


CREATING COMFORT On the second floor is a common area where associates can gather for informal discussions. Equipped for food service, the space is accented with warm walnut wall coverings, custom light fixtures and a variety of seating options.

and associates can experience who we are and what we are about. We have a great 100-year-old legacy and this lobby provides a wonderful opportunity to tell our story,” says Compiseno. With see-through views of the Metroparks, people are drawn to the opposite side of the building by the floor-to-ceiling panoramic vista. “In the 90 days we’ve been here, I can’t begin to tell you how many people have immediately walked to the other side of the building to enjoy the views.” A centrally located, floor-to-ceiling island is just beyond the reception desk. Making extensive use of the corporate media assets prepared by Oatey’s marketing/communications team, and working with Michael Nilsen, AIA, graphics designer for Vocon, digital signage screens display the breadth and depth of the company’s products and a time-lapse of the building’s construction. Going counter-clockwise around the island, above comfortable bench seating, is the company’s “Purpose – Values – Visions” board on one side and its illustrated corporate timeline and brand identifications on the other side.

Just past the island, in the northeast corner of the building, is a 600-square-foot open seating area or café for associates, who use the space for meetings, for breaks, and for informal get-togethers. Full A/V equipment is available for Oatey’s Town Hall meetings, where approximately 150 salaried personnel meet quarterly. A combination of banquette seating, movable chairs and tables makes the space adaptable for a variety of functions. Tucked away, just off the seating area is a lunch and snack area, comparable

to any fine hotel’s snack vending area. In addition to packaged snacks, frozen entrees, desserts and beverages, they also employee LunchOwl, which brings in fresh, healthy lunches on a regular schedule for those who subscribe. Everywhere you look, you’ll encounter large-scale works of art. “We worked with one of the local Cleveland galleries to select artwork themed around our business,” explains Compiseno. An exception was the very large piece of modern art in swaths of blues and white, entitled Aqueduct Diptych, which

Suntrol It! SUNTROL

™

G L A S S

E N H A N C I N G

F I L M S

Suntrol.com 800-466-TINT(8468) ESTABLISHED 1975

Love Your Windows!

Select Pro Window Film Dealer: • Security • Privacy/Custom • Energy Savings • Glare Reduction • Sun Protection

www.propertiesmag.com 21


GATHERING SPACE A 600-square-foot open seating area/café accommodates associates, who use the space for meetings, for breaks, and for informal get-togethers. Full A/V equipment is available for Oatey’s Town Hall meetings, where approximately 150 salaried personnel meet quarterly.

is the showpiece in the lobby. This original work was commissioned by Oatey and was created by Dana Oldfather. With very little imagination needed, one can interpret the painting’s intent to symbolize water flowing in multiple directions, apropos for the plumbing supplies manufactured by Oatey. A floating stairway connects the two floors, and light wood inserts on each tread contrast nicely with the walnut wall panels and the duranodic bronzecolored structural metal staircase. Just outside, a 2,800-square-foot concrete patio overlooks a quarter-mile walking path and the relaxing views of the Rocky River Reservation below. Look closely and you might see some of the resident, nesting bald eagles. Working with DERU Landscape Architects, van der Wiel selected plant species ideal for their adjacency to the parkway. Exterior signage was manufactured and installed by Cicogna Electric & Sign Company, of Ashtabula. “Careful time and consideration was given to the detailed design intent of [the signage],” says Brad Petro, vice president of Cicogna. “The metallic sign colors were sampled and selected to match the building colors and materials, as well as the natural stone tile bases of the signs.

Where the work gets done Continuing along within the north side of the building, open plan offices abound along the windows. Each of

the 160 cubicles is configured in standard six-foot by six-foot dimensions with motorized, variable-height desks, so that associates can work either seated or standing. Ninety percent of the building utilizes 18-inch, raised-access flooring, with adjustable air flow registers throughout. Heisey explains that it made financial sense, considering upfront costs, lifecycle costs and especially the inherent flexibility it provided. By having all the HVAC below the floor, white-painted, open joists above look relatively clutterfree, and pendant-style light fixtures can be placed precisely where needed. Floating ceilings of white acoustical tile, affectionately known as ‘clouds,’ above the work areas soften the open, industrial feel of the space. In addition, below the floor, a sound masking system has been installed for further privacy in the open office areas. Ten-foot by 12-foot manager’s offices are in the core of the building; but they can still enjoy the wooded surrounds, with floor-to-ceiling glass and ninefoot-high, sliding panel, barn-style, glass and aluminum framed doors. One wall in each office and conference room is covered with whiteboard paint for erasable markers. Spaced around the building and breaking up the open-plan office space are nine conference rooms, each named after one of Oatey’s product lines. Translucent Suntrol film on a portion of www.propertiesmag.com 23


SINCE 1972

Façade Inspection | Tuckpointing/Caulking Pressure Washing | Brick & Stone Repair/Replacement 216.881.4142 | 4408 St. Clair Avenue | Cleveland, Ohio 44103 www.hmhrestoration.com

DEFINING THE SKYLINE®

CONGRATULATIONS TO THE PROJECT TEAM AT OATEY CUSTOMER SUPPORT CENTER

Exterior Cold Formed Metal Framing • Rough Carpentry Thermal Insulation • Weather Barriers • Hollow Metal Doors and Frames • Door Hardware • Fiber Cement Soffit Panels

READY FOR R&D The facility is equipped with lab areas utilized by Oatey’s research and development team.

the glass walls allows visual privacy, but also enables people to tell if the room is occupied or not. In addition, there are two larger conference rooms which can comfortably accommodate 12 to 15 people in a meeting. “Associates now have an opportunity to select a conference room based on the size of their meeting,” allows Compiseno. “In the old facility, we only had one large conference room, and if four people needed to meet, they had no choice but to use a much larger space than necessary. Or they had to put their coat on and go to a smaller conference room across the street in the plant or over to the [Distribution Center]. Now, we have all shapes and sizes, so that’s been extremely helpful for us. It’s another example of how this building has improved collaboration and communication.” In addition, small to larger seating areas abound in the common areas for impromptu meetings with people across department lines. On the second floor, two distinctly different collaboration areas are both accented with a warm, inviting walnut trellis for the walls and ceiling. Both spaces are often used for ‘kick-off’ meetings in the morning, where whole departments might quickly gather to discuss the upcoming day’s priorities. Six huddle rooms on the interior core provide small spaces for an individual to retreat to for a private phone conversation.

When you aren’t working TOLEDO | CLEVELAND | COLUMBUS 24

ocpcoc.com

On the south side of the building, you’ll find an 800-square-foot workout room with the latest Precor machines Properties | February 2017


WORKING ENVIRONMENT Floating ceilings of white acoustical tile soften the open, industrial feel of the office area. In addition, below the floor, a sound masking system has been installed for further privacy.

and free-weights. Lockers, showers and a huge supply of towels are available from 6 a.m. until 8 p.m. “This was a direct response to the survey work Vocon did with our associates before designing the project,” explains Compiseno. “An exercise room was the number one most requested item from our people.” With the idyllic location, next to the Metroparks, several employees either

ride to work or bring their bikes and ride at lunch. Having available showers makes it convenient to change and ride whenever the weather is pleasant. On the second floor, outside the executive offices, is another common space used sometimes as a reception area. The area is equipped for food service with coffee machines, refrigerator, dishwasher and abundant counter space for catering. On the walls are Marlin electronic bul-

letin boards with streaming news, sports and weather. Compiseno points to some uniquely shaped, pendant lights suspended over the banquette seating area. “This was a Jessica Urbin creation from Vocon,” he says. “She used some of our Dearborn Brass product to create these special light fixtures.” Urbin was also responsible for the feature chandelier over the monumen-

HOWARD LICHTIG, GEORGE STEVENS & MICHAEL TOTH

would like to congratulate

on its 100 year anniversary! Thank you for choosing Emerald Corporate Park and the City of Cleveland for its new Corporate Headquarters HOWARD LICHTIG, SIOR VICE PRESIDENT +1 216 363 6410 howard.lichtig@cbre.com

GEORGE STEVENS, SIOR, CCIM VICE PRESIDENT +1 216 363 6438 george.stevens@cbre.com

MICHAEL TOTH SENIOR ASSOCIATE +1 216 363 6422 michael.toth@cbre.com

cbre.com/cleveland www.propertiesmag.com 25


Proud to have completed WS\TIPUN HUK ÄYL WYV[LJ[PVU MVY

OATEY CUSTOMER SERVICE CENTER with Donley’s Inc. EXERCISING OPTIONS An 800-square-foot workout room is equipped with the latest Precor machines and free-weights.

HVAC | FIRE PROTECTION | PLUMBING | PROCESS PIPING

2900 Newark Dr. ◆ Barberton, OH 44203 ◆ 800-776-7181 www.sacomunale.com

Proud to have been part of the team with Donley's Inc. installing the architectural raised access floors for OATEY CUSTOMER SERVICE CENTER

Raised Access Flooring

(440) 235-4264 www.jcsharp.com 27249 Bagley Road, Cleveland, OH 44138 26

tal communicating stair, as well as coordinating the building’s interior color palette with the views of the adjacent Metroparks. The second floor offers another popular space in the northeast corner, outside the boardroom, with a covered exterior ‘porch,’ where people can sit, relax and observe the abundant wildlife on the property. Wi-Fi extends throughout the facility, so people have access to email and their social media wherever they choose to take a break.

Good to go another 100 years Looking at the completed project, all parties seem equally pleased with the outcome. “Working with the Oatey team was outstanding,” Heisey says. “They were collaborative, open to ideas and inquisitive. I wish all clients could be this great to work with. Further, it was the culture of all three organizations that made this the project that it is. It was never about ‘me,’ but always about ‘we.’” “This building kind of lent itself to being built,” Heitner says. “It was a fun project to do with the access floor, essentially giving you twice the plenum space. With the collaboration of Ron and Erica, sitting with our subcontractors, we were probably able to shave $40,000 to 50,000 off the project budget.” A short walk around the building shows that the planning paid off. As engineers meet in corner seating areas with sales people, there are no coats, no car keys. When they are done, they’ll be back at their respective desks within 30 seconds. Productivity has already improved, and this is just the beginning. P Properties | February 2017


director@aiacleveland.com

!30(!,4 0!6).' !30(!,4 2%0!)2 3%!,#/!4).' #2!#+ &),,).' #/-0,%4% 3)4% #/.3425#4)/.

0!6 ) . ' ) . # s %XCELLENT QUALITY COMPETITIVE PRICING RELIABILITY

%8#!6!4)/. 4/ #/-0,%4)/.

s #UNNINGHAM 0AVING IS A FAMILY OWNED BUSINESS WITH OVER YEARS OF EXPERIENCE s ,ICENSED BONDED INSURED s /UR MOTTO h+EEPING OUR CUSTOMERS SATISFIED KEEPS THEM COMING BACK v

* iÊӣȰxn£°nÈää >ÝÊӣȰxn£°nÈnÎ !URORA 2OAD 7ARRENSVILLE (EIGHTS /( www.propertiesmag.com 27


ACAR CORNER Issues in the real estate industry

Six Housing Expectations for 2017 s another strong year for the housing market has come to an end and the calendar has turned over to 2017, it is time to examine the housing outlook and expectations for the new year. Existing-home sales are forecast to muster only a small gain in 2017 because of increasing mortgage rates and shrinking consumer confidence that now is a good time to buy a home, according to new consumer survey findings and a 2017 housing forecast from the National Association of Realtors (NAR).

A

JIM FOX

NAR’s Housing Opportunities and Market Experience (HOME) survey, which asked respondents about their confidence in the U.S. economy and housing expectations for 2017, recently found that 68% of homeowners think now is a good time to make a home purchase compared to 82% in December 2015. Even with this dip in buyer enthusiasm, the market did well and existing sales closed 2016 3.3% higher than 2015 and reached around 5.42 million — the highest since 2006 when sales totaled 6.47 million. In 2017, sales are forecast to grow roughly 2% to around 5.52 million. The national median existing-home price rose to around 5% in 2016 and is expected to rise to about 4% in 2017. By the end of next year, mortgage rates are expected to reach around 4.6%. SAFETY & SECURITY

SUPERIOR INSULATING

® A Female and Minority Owned Company Authorized Dealer & Applicator

28

ENERGY CONSERVATION

“Existing-home sales are expected to see little expansion in 2017 because of affordability tensions from rising mortgage rates and home prices continuing to outpace income growth,” says Jim Fox, president of the Akron Cleveland Association of Realtors (ACAR). “Ultimately, the market needs to see a growth in for sale inventory, otherwise the nation’s low homeownership rate will struggle to rise in 2017.” Here are a few of the trends and predictions ACAR and NAR expect to see in the new year.

1. Tight inventory conditions Recent data from NAR show that the supply of existing homes for sale is insufficient, and new home construction is not meeting demand. More buyers are competing for a fewer number of homes DECORATIVE

See the Difference with Sunray

800.295.8468 www.SunrayFilms.com

Properties | February 2017


than a year ago, which will likely continue in 2017.

2. Increasing home prices With demand rising and listings scarce in many markets, NAR forecasts home prices will increase nationally about 4% in 2017. In cities with the tightest of supply, prices could expand above double digits.

3. Rising mortgage rates The recent rise in mortgage rates will likely continue in 2017 with additional increases. “With inventory tight and prices already rising far above incomes in some areas, the unwelcoming sign of higher borrowing costs only adds to the difficult barrier of entry for many prospective buyers,” Fox says.

4. Waning consumer confidence Declining affordability in many parts of the country has been weakening consumer morale. Rents and home prices outpacing incomes and scarce supply in the affordable price range will continue as a prominent headwind for many prospective buyers this year.

5. Booming rental markets When there’s a surge of high-priced rentals on the market, fewer renters are in a position to become homeowners, says Fox. “Many people in Northeast Ohio are interested in moving to downtown Cleveland or Akron,” he says, and as they do, they are finding a lot of high-priced rentals. “This delays prospective buyers – especially millennials who are also juggling student loans and other debt – from being able to save for and buy a home.”

BANKRUPTCY SALE Subject to Bankruptcy Court Approval

Environmentally Impacted Development Site in

Painesville, Ohio

All Environmental Issues have an Active Responsible 3rd Party

OFFER DEADLINE: MARCH 22, 2017

Immediate Action Required • Offers currently being considered

1,038± Acres Across 21 Parcels 200± Lakefront Acres Ready for Development Land Located Along Grand River and Lake Erie Residential, Commercial & Recreational Uses Possible

6. Anemic new construction markets Fox says “if you build it, they will come” is a saying Northeast Ohio builders – and lenders – should take to heart. “Each new construction home creates two to three buyers in the market,” he says. An increase in new construction in Northeast Ohio would create many opportunities for potential homebuyers, and would have a positive impact on the region’s inventory of homes well into the future. P Contact the Akron Cleveland Association of Realtors or visit www.akronclevelandrealtors.com to speak with a Realtor for information and advice about buying a home in 2017.

KEEN-SUMMIT CAPITAL PARTNERS LLC

(646) 381-9222 • Keen-Summit.com ADDITIONAL PROPERTIES: KEARNY, NJ • NEWARK, NJ • TUSCALOOSA, AL www.propertiesmag.com 29


FINANCIAL STRATEGIES Smart use of fiscal planning & action

Deal or No Deal requent readers of this column will know that I’m a child of the 1970s. Things seemed a lot simpler back then for kids; there was no internet, no video games and cable TV was still in its infancy. As a result, most of my weekday mornings during the summer were spent in front of the TV watching one of three channels – ABC, NBC or CBS. But it was great, as the 1970s was also the golden era of TV game shows. It didn’t matter to me if contestants were spinning the big wheel or trying to avoid the whammy or matching wits with Charles Nelson Reilly – I loved them all.

F

ALEC J. PACELLA

Some recent real estate sales remind me of the treasured games shows of my youth. To see which ones, and how, read on.

The deal: Severance Town Center This 620,000-square-foot retail power center originally opened in 1963 and held the distinction of being Ohio’s first fully enclosed regional mall. The property was also one of the first in Ohio to be “de-malled,” characterized as a partial demolition and repositioning as a traditional open-air center, in the late 1990s. Wal-Mart, Home Depot, Top’s supermarket, Marshalls and Regal Town Cinemas were introduced as new anchors

as a part of this repositioning effort. Upon completion, the center was sold in April 2004 for $54 million. Facing growing competition from nearby Legacy Village, which opened in 2003, and Oakwood Commons, which opened in 2013, the center eventually lost Wal-Mart, Borders and Regal Cinema. It ultimately fell into receivership in 2013 and was sold again in May 2016, this time for $10.5 million.

The game show: Press Your Luck Despite losing many of its anchor tenants and having a vacancy rate hovering around 40%, Severance has several things going for it. Home

EDUCATIONAL EQUIPMENT Serving Cleveland and Northeast Ohio Since 1936 We are specialists in: • Operable Panel Partitions • Accordion Doors • Chalk/Marker Boards • Bulletin Boards • Trophy & Display Cases • Signage • Directories SALES

INSTALLATION

SERVICE

845 Overholt Rd., P.O. Box 154, Kent, Ohio 44240 — Phone (330) 673-4881 Fax ((330) 673-4915)

30

Properties | February 2017


Daus, You Know?

! ! " ! #

ANOTHER SIGN OF THE APOCALYPSE While wading through various emails the other day, I came across one that made me stop dead in my electronic tracks. It was a listing for a net lease Target for sale in San Jose, California. The asking cap rate was 2.95%. Just for kicks, I then checked the 10-year treasury, which was trading at 2.47%. –AP Depot, Marshalls and OfficeMax have remained, the property encompasses 150 acres and the surrounding area is densely populated. The new owner is clearly trying to build on these positives to move the property forward while avoiding any additional setbacks. Or, as the contestants on Press Your Luck used to say: big bucks, big bucks, no whammy!

PCS CONTAINER SALES LLC (330) 696-6458 – Call Carol Pack for Pricing

The Deal: 45 Erieview Plaza This 460,000-square-foot, high-rise office tower is located at the corner of Lakeside Avenue and East 9th Street in downtown Cleveland. The property was built in 1983 by Ohio Bell, who, through their successor AT&T, completed a sale/ leaseback in 2007. The property was sold for $52 million and, as a part of this transaction, AT&T signed a long-term lease that expires in 2019. Although the lease was originally for the entire building, it includes a series of rights to give back space at various dates. AT&T consistently exercised these rights and currently occupies less than half of the building. The building was sold again in late 2016. Although the transfer price was not disclosed, I completed an opinion of value for this property a few years ago on behalf of the previous owner. At that time, I concluded a value of approximately $34 million. If I were a betting man, I’d peg the transfer price within 10% of this number (but I don’t like gambling).

20’ One Way Units For Sale • 20’ Used Containers For Sale 40’ Used Containers For Sale • 40’ Used High Cube Containers For Sale Many Uses – Farm, Industrial, Professional, Construction, School, On-Site Ground Level Storage

FOR SALE Serving Northeast Ohio, West Virginia & Pennsylvania

The game show: The Joker’s Wild There is a lot going on with this property. On one hand, the building has a fantastic location, is relatively new, includes a dedicated parking deck and has a credit tenant locked up for a few more years. But on the other hand, the property was built for a single tenant, so trying to re-tenant it 10,000 square feet at a time would take significant time and money. And AT&T currently has less than 50 employees working there, which points toward the very real possibility of a completely empty building come 2019.

General Contractors Construction Managers Design/Build 440-998-0609 | www.jcibuilds.com | Ashtabula, OH www.propertiesmag.com 31


It’s no secret that there are a few monster office tenants potentially roaming around downtown, including Sherwin Williams, Medical Mutual and Forest City. And this building is one of the few that can easily accommodate any of them, which could turn this deal into a home run. Or, as the tag line for The Joker’s Wild used to say: The game where knowledge is king and lady luck is queen.

The Deal: Park Center Plaza complex This three-building office park in the Rockside Road corridor encompasses

approximately 420,000 square feet. Originally developed by Duke Realty over the late 1990s, this office park is among the best in suburban Cleveland. Shortly after these properties were completed, Duke decided to pull out of our market but the great recession significantly delayed their ability to sell these assets. After being on again/off again starting in 2005, Duke was finally able to sell a five-building portfolio that included the Park Center Plaza properties in late 2013. The total sale price included five properties so I’m

going to focus on the allocated price per square foot, which was $104. The overall occupancy rate for the complex at that time was in the low 80% range. Since then, the suburban office market has tightened and this park has benefitted, increasing its overall occupancy by approximately 10 percentage points over the last three years. The park sold again this past January, garnering $118 per square foot.

The game show: Pyramid The previous owners started with a very nice asset and made some substantial upgrades to the property. At the same time, the suburban office market began to first stabilize and then tighten and the park was able to take advantage of this by boosting its occupancy. The next stage in the real estate cycle is increasing rents, which we have finally begun to see in the office sector. In a typical real estate cycle, new construction would follow.

It’s no secret that there are a few monster office tenants potentially roaming around downtown, including Sherwin Williams, Medical Mutual and Forest City. [45 Erieview Plaza] is one of the few that can easily accommodate any of them. Although we are seeing this occur in the eastern office suburbs, I am skeptical we will see this occur any time soon on Rockside Road, which will put even more upward pressure on rents. When the game show Pyramid debuted in 1973, it was called the $10,000 Pyramid. A few years later, it was renamed the $20,000 Pyramid. This was followed by the $25,000 Pyramid, the $50,000 Pyramid and finally the $100,000 Pyramid. The new owners are hoping for a similar theme – own one of the best assets in the market and take advantage of what will be a slowly but surely rising tide. Hopefully they can avoid the dreaded three strikes in the process. P Alec Pacella, CCIM, senior vice president at NAI Daus, can be reached by phone at 216.455.0925 or by email at apacella@naidaus.com. You can follow him on twitter @dausyouknow or on his blog at http://blog.sbequitiesinc.com. 32

Properties | February 2017


;d]n]dYf\ k Kl]]d @]Y\imYjl]jk

&ROXPELD %XLOGLQJ 3URGXFWV STEEL JOISTS STRUCTURAL IRON METAL ROOF DECK STEEL STAIRS & RAILS STEEL ERECTION

440-235-3363

EXPERTS IN CREATING PROJECTS BUILT WITH EXCEPTIONAL SERVICE Ƥ Worship

Ɣ Education

ƣ Commercial

û Healthcare

ȣ Hospitality

Ɠ Municipal

Ä Multi-Family

G NEERA GE RALL CO C NTTRA ACT C OR ORS S • CO CONS NS NSTR STR TRUC UC CTI T ON MAN ANAG AG AGER GER ERS S • D SI DE SIGN G /B GN /BUI UILD UI LDER LD ERS ER S SU SUBC B ON BC ONTR TRAC TR AC CTO TORS R • BI RS B D PA PACK CKAG CK AG GE SP S EC ECIA IA ALI L ST STS S

*-1.) =de Kl&$ ;d]n]dYf\$ G@ ,,)+0

P.216.938.5050 • F.216.938.5033 • johngjohnson.com

COMMERCIAL & INDUSTRIAL ELECTRICAL CONTRACTORS

SERVICE Upfront Pricing • Trouble-Shoot & Repair NEW CONSTRUCTION Design/Build • Spec/Build ENERGY-SAVING UPGRADES BUILDING & PROCESS AUTOMATION Engineering • Installation ON-TIME PERFORMANCE GUARANTEED

15035 Berkshire Industrial Pkwy, Middlefield, OH 44062 service@jltaylorcompany.com • www.jltaylorcompany.com

440.834.1223

OH LIC #21927

www.propertiesmag.com 33


Ready to Trash Your Dumpsters?

www.suterausa.com

An alternative to traditional dumpsters & expensive trash enclosures. ■ Self-compacting system reduces frequency of emptying and service

■ Dedicated trash truck approach not required! Can be located adjacent to roadways

■ Low cost of installation and long useable life

■ Increases PARKING and PROPERTY AREA by taking up less area than traditional dumpsters

■ Environmentally friendly and aesthetically pleasing – no ugly enclosure fence required ■ Reduces odors and pests, and contains foul liquids

■ Secured locking system mitigates illegal dumping and dumpster diving ■ Adequately contains up to 3,000 pounds of waste

$UFKLWHFWV IDFLOLW\ PDQDJHUV RZQHUV HQYLURQPHQWDO FRQVXOWLQJ ZDVWH PDQDJHPHQW ¿UPV &RQWDFW -HII 0DOFROP DW RI¿FH MPDOFROP#QFLSUHFDVW FRP FHOO

Distributed by:

NCI

Norwalk Concrete Industries 80 Commerce Drive Norwalk, OH 44857 www.nciprecast.com

Toll Free 800.733.3624 Phone 419.668.8167 Fax 419.663.0627

You dream it. We’ll cast it. Verti-Crete Privacy / Security Fence • Recon Retaining Wall Year-Round Outdoor Table Tennis Tables • Storm Shelters Easi-Set Transportable Concrete Buildings • Better Living Basements Stormwater / Wastewater Treatment


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans

CES Announces 2017 Award of Excellence Nominees he Cleveland Engineering Society recently announced award nominees for its Awards of Excellence in Design and Construction, which will be presented at its 65th Annual Design & Construction Conference and Trade Show on Thursday, March 16 at LaCentre Conference Center in Westlake. Nominees for the ‘New Construction – Large Project ($20 million+)’ category include Hilton Cleveland Downtown; Cleveland Drury Plaza Hotel Cleveland Downtown Institute of Art George Gund Building; Cleveland Third District Police Headquarters; Flats East Bank, Phase 2; and Perkins Wildlife Center & Woods Garden. ‘New Construction – Small Project’ nominees include Cleveland Metroparks Zoo Rosebrough Tiger Passage; Kyocera SGS Precision Tools End Mill Facility (Cuyahoga Falls); and Swagelok Cleveland Sales & Service Center. Nominees for the ‘Renovation – Large Project ($20 million+)’ category include First Energy Stadium; The Schofield Hotel; Kent State University Center for the Visual Arts; and Drury Plaza Hotel Cleveland Downtown. ‘Renovation – Small Project’ nominees include The Church of the Saviour (Cleveland Heights); Our Lady of Mercy (Tremont); and Parker Hannifin Downtown YMCA. Lastly, the ‘Infrastructure/Special Project’ nominees include the Ohio Theatre Lobby and the eastbound structure of the George V. Voinovich Bridge. Event registration information is available at www.cesnet.org/events.

Photo by Lauren Pacini

T

CREW Award Top Women in Real Estate Commercial Real Estate Women (CREW) Cleveland recently announced recipients

of its annual awards, which recognize high-achieving women in the Northeast Ohio commercial real estate market. The Deborah Rocker Klausner Award – presented

each year to recognize a CREW Cleveland member for leadership within CREW or within the community – was presented to Laura Hengle, of Bock & Clark.

Yulu Li

Jennie Church, of Vorys, Sater, Seymour & Pease LLP, was the recipient of the Member of the Year award, which recognizes a CREW Cleveland member who has made exceptional contributions to CREW Cleveland in terms of time and service and has made outstanding achievements in the local real estate community during the current calendar year. The Rising Star Award was presented to Yulu Li, of Hanna Commercial Real Estate. The award is pre-

Everything For Concrete, Except Concrete, Since 1910 THE LAKEWOOD SUPPLY

CONCRETE REPAIR PRODUCTS

COMPANY • Concrete Restoration & Repair Materials • Granular Concrete Colors • Rebar Detailing/Fabrication & Assemblies

216.898.1113 4901 West 150th Street, Cleveland, Ohio 44135 • www.lakewoodsupplycompany.com www.propertiesmag.com 35


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans

dinary commitment to marshal CREW talent, resulting in measurable business for other CREW members. The award is presented to an individual who “exemplifies the power and spirit of CREW” and recognizes the collective CREW business completed over the last 24 months as a result of this member’s efforts. Cecilia Hyun

sented each year to a newer member who shows noticeable effort to participate and promote the CREW Cleveland. Efforts of promotion are through active participation; promoting CREW Cleveland; actively recruiting new members and demonstrating future leadership qualities. Lastly, Cecilia Hyun, of Siegel Jennings Co., LPA, was recognized with the Member-to-Member Business Award, which honors a CREW Network member who consistently demonstrates an extraor-

Tracey Nichols

PMC Welcomes Tracey Nichols Project Management Consultants (PMC), a subsidiary of Thompson Hine LLP, recently announced that Tracey A. Nichols, the former director of economic development for the city of Cleveland, has joined the organization as a director of financial services. Nichols, who is widely recognized for her role in Cleveland’s economic development revival, led her team to complete more than 625 projects and $146.8 million in new grants or pass-through loan funding.

At PMC, Nichols will manage public financing projects for corporate, real estate and public sector clients. Her expertise with HUD financing and other complex financing tools will assist clients in closing project financing gaps. Nichols joins the financial services branch of PMC, which focuses on bringing public and private financing to construction and corporate projects throughout the United States. Her experience in the public sector will allow the group to focus on regional economic growth

in addition to the list of financial services currently offered, including intergovernmental funding strategies, bank financing assistance, public sector bond financing negotiation, tax increment financing analysis, building lease reviews, private sector fund development, New Markets Tax Credit and Historic Preservation Tax Credit strategies and application, bond rating assistance, economic and fiscal impact analysis, public and nonprofit economic development planning, and financial procurement.

Frantz Ward Partner Inducted into Diocese of Cleveland CYO Hall of Fame Frantz Ward LLP recently announced that Andrew J. Natale, partner and chair of the firm’s Construction Practice Group, has been inducted into the Diocese of Cleveland CYO (Catholic Youth Organization) Hall of Fame. The Youth & Young

9G YQWNF DG RTQWF VQ DG RCTV QH [QWT VGCO QP [QWT PGZV EQPUVTWEVKQP RTQLGEV

CONTAINER SERVICE, INC.

¸;OL 3LHKLY PU *VU[HPULY :LY]PJL¹ -), *:) ,+., *,9;0-0,+

>>> 7,;,(5+7,;,05* *64 36

@6<9 *65:;9<*;065 :7,*0(30:;: .9,,5 3,,+ 7961,*;: @(9+ -965; 36(+ *65;(05,9: @(9+ 96336-- *65;(05,9: Properties | February 2017


)DEULFDWLRQ ,QVWDOODWLRQ 6HUYLFH

Q

HDUV L HU \

RY QJ IRU L ] L O D L F 6SH WRS U HG URRI J D RW ZDWH N F K D 3 P GLQJ ¥ VWHD ZHO Q R L W D F %RLOHUV UL HWDO IDE HOGLQJ 6KHHWP ULFDWLRQ Z IDE W 3ODVWLF HHULQJ DUWPHQ Q S L H J G Q H H F 9DOXHG H PDLQWHQDQ UYLF )XOO VH

ZZZ OLVFRKYDF FRP 6WDWH 5G 1 5R\DOWRQ 2+

Quality Products & Services Since 1933 dŚĞ Z͘>͘ tƵƌnj ŽŵƉĂŶLJ ŝƐƚƌŝďƵƚŽƌ ŽĨ ŽŶƐƚƌƵĐƟŽŶ Θ ZĞƐƚŽƌĂƟŽŶ WƌŽĚƵĐƚƐ ^ƚĂƚĞǁŝĚĞ ([SHUWV LQ Sealants • Waterproofing

Architectural Panels Supplies • Air Barriers Concrete & Masonry y Products 7ZR 7HFKQLFDO 6HUYLFH &KHPLVWV RQ 6WDII

13320 Enterprise Ave., Cleveland, OH 44135 1-800-969-1754 www.rlwurz.com Žǁ ŽƌŶŝŶŐ ŝƐ Ă ƌĞŐŝƐƚĞƌĞĚ ƚƌĂĚĞŵĂƌŬ ŽĨ Žǁ ŽƌŶŝŶŐ ŽƌƉŽƌĂƟŽŶ͘

www.propertiesmag.com 37


Serving Northeast Ohio For Over 60 Years! Residential Ŷ Commercial Ŷ Industrial Ŷ Institutional

Expert Brick Matching and Complete Inventory of Brick, Block, Masonry, Cast & Natural Stone, Plaster Products & Tools

NEVER over budget • Due Diligence • Development & Leasing • Retail, Commercial • Historical/Industrial and Industrial Renovations • Construction Management • Design/Build

330-659-2040 Charles Marshall – cmarshall@mccdesignbuild.com

Construction Company a division of

16900 Rockside Rd., Maple Heights, OH 44137

216.791.9800 Ŷ www.bruderinc.com

38

P.O. Box 1092, Bath, OH 44210 • www.beaconmarshall.com

Properties | February 2017


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans

Andrew J. Natale

Adult Ministry and CYO Office along with the Diocese of Cleveland CYO Athletic Advisory Committee hosted this year’s CYO Hall of Fame and Recognition Awards Luncheon in late January at the DoubleTree Hotel in Beachwood.

Those inducted into the Diocese of Cleveland CYO Hall of Fame have made significant contributions to the CYO as a player, coach, pastoral designee, clergy, commissioner or other member of the community whose accomplishments have been of utmost merit and whose actions have brought life to the Mission of the Diocese of Cleveland CYO for an extended period of time.

CHAMPS Group Purchasing, County Fire Protection Launch Contract Recently, CHAMPS Group Purchasing and County Fire Protection launched a contract for all types of

fire protection services (fire alarms, sprinkler systems, backflows, fire extinguishers, kitchen hood suppression) effective until September 30, 2019. The contract is available to all CHAMPS members in County Fire Protection’s service areas in Ohio, Michigan and Pennsylvania. Headquartered in Kent, County Fire Protection now offers CHAMPS GPO discounts on all fire and life safety product sales and services.

Ciuni & Panichi Hosts ‘Fiduciary Risk of Employee Benefit Plans’ Ciuni & Panichi recently announced it will be hosting an educational program

titled “Fiduciary Risk of Employee Benefit Plans” on Thursday, April 27, 2017. The event will include advice on avoiding significant fines associated with deficiencies in a plan audit or a 5500 filing. Attendees can earn one hour of CPE. The event, which includes breakfast, takes place from 7:30 to 9 a.m. at Doubletree Independence, 6200 Quarry Lane, Independence, Ohio 44131. To register, call 216-831-7171 or visit cp-advisors.com. P WHAT’S NEW? For coverage within Billboard, send along company news, story ideas and project information to billboard@propertiesmag.com.

:ȝ &Ȫ8ȫ+ 2ȭ5 &ȧ0Ȩ(Ȭ,Ȭ,ȧ1 J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc. • Commercial Buildings • Construction Sites • Special Event Clean-Up • Concrete Cleaning • Carpet Cleaning • Window Cleaning • Wall Washing • Acoustical Ceilings

1230 East Schaaf Road Brooklyn Heights, OH 44131

216-749-1150 www.jvjanitorial.com

COMMERCIAL, RESIDENTIAL & INDUSTRIAL DEMOLITION ASBESTOS SURVEYS & ABATEMENT • WRECKING

CAREY DEMOLITION 216-881-0608 | www.careydemolition.com 2695 E. 55th St. | Cleveland, OH 44104

www.propertiesmag.com 39


Hospitable Healthcare Cleveland Clinic Avon Hospital delivers modern care, offers patients self-service options By Doug Bardwell | Photos by Kevin Reeves

elf-service’ and ‘hospital’ are generally not used in the same sentence, but such is the situation for the just-opened Cleveland Clinic Avon Hospital. Located at 33300 Cleveland Clinic Blvd., this is a 212,000-square-foot, five-story building adjacent to the existing Richard E. Jacobs Health Center. The new hospital is challenging many past practices to deliver the “right care in the right place at the right time,” per Rebecca Starck, MD, president of the hospital.

‘S

Located just north of the existing health center, the new $161 million hospital will provide 114 medical/surgical beds and 12 ICU beds. Connected to the previous emergency department opened in 2012, the addition provides for two additional operating rooms, a cardiac catheterization lab and a pharmacy, as well as an expanded radiology department. “For the first time, patients in Lorain County and further west will have 40

access to a full-service Cleveland Clinic hospital close to home,” Starck says. “As the first hospital connected directly to one of our family health centers, Cleveland Clinic Avon Hospital will help us build on the exceptional care we already provide on our campus, now offering patients the full range of care they need.” The existing health center, built in 2011, sees an average of 42,000 patient

visits every month and handles 2,400 emergency room visits each month as well. The new hospital will offer care in more than a dozen specialties, including cardiology, endocrinology, gastroenterology, general surgery, orthopedics, pulmonology, urology, gynecology, hospital medicine, vascular medicine and vascular surgery. Patients with more complex conditions or needing highly specialized treatments can Properties | February 2017


Congratulations to Gilbane Building Company for

Cleveland Clinic Avon Hospital DEFINING THE SKYLINE

®

Drywall • Interior & Exterior Metal Studs • Insulation • Rough Carpentry • Finish Carpentry Spray Applied Fireproofing • Acoustical Ceilings • Doors/Frames/Hardware • Specialties TOLEDO | CLEVELAND | COLUMBUS

ocpcoc.com

Proud to have worked at Cleveland Clinic Avon Hospital

WHEN IT COMES TO CLEAN, WE MEAN BUSINESS.

BUILDING SERVICES A TOTAL FACILITY MAINTENANCE COMPANY • CONSTRUCTION CLEANING (LABORERS, ROUGH CLEANUP & FINAL CLEANUP) • INTERIOR/EXTERIOR WINDOW WASHING ON BUILDINGS OF ALL SHAPES & SIZES • DAILY / NIGHTLY CUSTODIAL SERVICES • TILE FLOOR RESTORATION • POWERWASHING (PARKING GARAGES, BUILDINGS, WALKWAYS ETC) 26118 Broadway Avenue • Oakwood Village, Ohio 44146 • 440-439-2288 www.crystalclearbuildingservices.com • www.crystalclearhome.com www.propertiesmag.com 41


PROUD TEAM MEMBER AT CLEVELAND CLINIC AVON HOSPITAL 4933 Neo Parkway *DUðHOG +HLJKWV 2+ www.uscande.com

Your best choice for Voice, Data and Video... ...and now Security, Audio/Visual and In-Building Wireless! www.uscande.com

Proud to have worked with Gilbane Construction on another world-renowned Cleveland Clinic project.

HEALTHY GROWTH Located just north of the existing Richard E. Jacobs Health Center, the new $161 million hospital will provide 114 medical/surgical beds and 12 ICU beds.

be transferred seamlessly within the Cleveland Clinic health system.

Building on success Market data was analyzed and a need was determined prior to the health center being planned for the Avon area. Built along the north side of I-90 at the Nagel Road exit, Cleveland Clinic never expected the degree of its immediate success. “We modeled expectations for the health center,” explains David Krymowski, owner’s representative for Cleveland Clinic, “and within 12 months of it opening, we had already exceeded our five-year forecast.” With the primary care and the ambulatory surgery services being so popular, the obvious next step was to provide for inpatient and acute patient facilities.

Starting the design

The Dependable Painting Co., Inc. COMMERCIAL • INDUSTRIAL • RESTORATION

4403 Superior Avenue • Cleveland, Ohio 44103 216-431-4470 • www.dependableptg.com 42

“We began the visioning, programming and process mapping for the new hospital in September 2013,” says Philip LiBassi, FAIAF ACHA, principal of DLR Group | Westlake Reed Leskosky. “From there, we produced an outline of qualitative and quantitative goals for the new facility.” A large team of administrators, doctors and nurses, as well as patient advocates, were involved in the evaluation of the new facility. The desire was to make this reflective of the latest and best practices and technology available at the time. “We were pleased to be able to work with Nick Watkins, a Ph.D. researcher who studied the latest trends in patient rooms,” LiBassi says. “With his input, we designed a mock-up that hundreds of Properties | February 2017


NATURAL CONNECTIONS Great attention was paid to bringing as much natural light as possible into all areas of the facility. Studies have shown that views of nature have a healing effect on patients, so all rooms have a view of the woods or the wetlands – as does the lobby.

staff and patients reviewed. We had them look at it in the morning and do written reviews. Then, while they ate lunch, we reconfigured the same mock-up, and invited them back in once again to do written reviews of the alternate layout. From all that data, we could finalize a design that represented the best practices

of today while trying to provide for future improvements. Overall, we collectively eliminated a lot of legacy borders and boundaries, combining like services on the support services side as well as the patient care side.” “It was a significant challenge for all participants to fit all these programs into

a smaller space than would have been done using standard hospital planning,” recalls Travis Laird, senior director of operations at Avon Hospital. “The spirit of innovation drove this entire project,” Starck continues. “Using interdisciplinary workstations, we created a central hub where doctors, nurses,

Proud partner of the Cleveland Clinic on the new Roseann Park Family Tower! www.gilbaneco.com www.propertiesmag.com 43


Proud to be part of the team for CLEVELAND CLINIC AVON HOSPITAL

Congratulations CLEVELAND CLINIC RICHARD E. JACOBS HEALTH CENTER

Gilbane, WRL Architects and OCP Contractors

X Plumbing X Heating X Air Conditioning X Power & Process Piping X Service

216/391-1030

LABORATORY

A CULTURE OF QUALITY. gleeson.pro

4975 Hamilton Avenue, Cleveland, Ohio 44114-3972

Proud to install Structural Steel, Stairs & Handrails for Cleveland Clinic Avon Hospital Expansion

FOREST CITY ERECTORS, INC. 8200 Boyle Pkwy. Twinsburg, OH 44087 330-425-7185

3400 Independence Rd. Cleveland, OH 44105 216-363-1111

www.forestcityerectors.com “A Women’s Business Enterprise” 44

Properties | February 2017


INVITING VIEW Second-floor meeting rooms overlook the lobby through walls of glass, creating a sense of openness and transparency.

physical therapists and others cohabitate and do their work as a team.” Using wireless devices, they can all also communicate no matter where they are in the building. As evidence, what appears to be a typical nurses’ station is actually much larger, with more desk space, and now shared by all caregivers. Full-height glass walls enable caregivers to monitor activities around their space, but provide acoustical privacy to patients, even those directly across from the work area. In addition to the new work environment for caregivers, Starck mentions that patients are now given control over their environment as well. From surveys, Cleveland Clinic realized that a common frustration of being in the hospital was the sense of losing control of your daily activities. Combining technologies, patients enjoy ‘self-service’ selections. Interactive flat-screen TVs in the rooms enable patients to control individual room temperatures, view educational videos, access their personal electronic medical records, view home-going instructions and view food menus, as well as watch movies or television.

Even before construction could start “The challenge was formidable to make changes to the original facil-

ity without impacting service,” Krymowski explains. The new hospital would be built over a 300-car parking lot that formerly was being used by the health center. “Therefore

numerous ‘enabling’ projects were performed prior to starting work on the hospital.” The first priority was to create additional parking. An Eco OptiLoc

All Things Concrete – Your Commercial & Decorative Total Concrete Solution

An Equal Opportunity Employer

21ST CENTURY CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION INC. 13925 Enterprise Ave., Cleveland, OH 44135

216.362.0900 www.21stcenturyconcrete.com SBE | CSB | EDGE | ODOT Certified www.propertiesmag.com 45


STRIKING SIMPLICITY Clean, white finishes and floor-to-ceiling walls of glass create a sense of cleanliness and tranquility throughout.

permeable paver system by Unilock was used to create 340,000 square feet of new parking, north of the hospital. This was the largest use of this paver in Ohio and one of the largest applications in the nation. The “L” shaped pavers are even stronger than poured-in-place concrete, and can be machine laid. “One of the real successes of this entire project has been how we have

maintained the wetlands,” explains Krymowski. “We are very proud of our environmental stewardship, being able to maintain that by establishing a drainage system that proactively enables us to direct the filtered water back into the wetlands instead of just filling a retention pond. To do that, we had to import over four feet of premium gravel via barge from northern

Proud to have provided ceramic tile at CLEVELAND CLINIC AVON HOSPITAL

Commercial, Institutional & Industrial Floor Covering Provider & Installer

Specializing in the healthcare marketplace with the highest quality & best service since 1989. We provide 24/7 service & installation. Call us today to take advantage of our trained in-house staff and extensive library of product information. Complete line of flooring including: Carpeting • Resilient Flooring, Vinyl & Ceramic Tile • Athletic Floors

Call today for a FREE estimate! 4300 Brookpark Rd., Cleveland, OH 44134 • 216-595-0100 • Toll Free 888-271-8200 46

Michigan. With the help of the Army Corp of Engineers, we have made a positive contribution to the future of the wetlands in this area.”

Technology meets construction Gilbane Building Company was awarded the contract for the new hospital in October 2014. “The building is steel framed with a combination of brick and curtain wall sections,” says Raymond Rigsby, project executive for Gilbane. “The roof is concrete with metal deck on structural steel, and roofing is a torch-applied SBS modified bitumen system.” Great attention was paid to bringing as much natural light as possible into all areas of the facility. Studies have shown that views of nature have a healing effect on patients, so all rooms have a view of the woods or the wetlands. Even internal rooms like the pharmacy and surgery rooms have clerestory windows to capture available daylight. A light harvesting system on exterior rooms allows reduction of artificial light levels during the day. “Mechanical systems are located in the penthouse on the roof and in a central plant on the second floor,” Rigsby explains. “Exterior chillers and internal air handlers provide for cooling, while hot water is used for heating.” Properties | February 2017


YOUR ONE VISION. OUR INFINITE CHOICES.

CREATE. Begin with your inspired vision. COLLABORATE. Trusted, experienced and on the cutting edge of paving stone technology, the Unilock team has the expertise and customer service to fully develop your creative paving designs. CUSTOMIZE. Unilock will create a unique custom look for your next project. Optimizing color, finish, texture and size, our team will work closely with you from start to finish to make your designs a reality.

PROJECT: Museum of Contemporary Art & Uptown Alleyway. Cleveland, Ohio. DESIGN: James Corner Field Operations / Riverstone Company / McKnight & Associates PRODUCT: Promenade™ Plank Paver with Series 3000® finish. Permeable installation.

UNILOCK.COM

Contact your Unilock Representative for samples, product information and to arrange a Lunch & Learn for your team.

1-800-UNILOCK


Proud to be the Roofing Contractor at Cleveland Clinic Avon Hospital with Gilbane Construction

ISO 9001 CERTIFIED

INDUSTRIAL FIRST, INC.

THE CONSTRUCTION RESOURCE COMPANY Roofing | Steel Erection Waterproofing & Protective Coatings | Siding & Decking Sheet Metal Fabrication & Installation | Electrical 25840 Miles Rd., Cleveland, Ohio 44146 Fax: (216) 991-2139 | corporate@industrialfirst.com | www.industrialfirst.com

(216) 991-8600


ET

E C H, I

EXCAVATION OF COMMERCIAL, INDUSTRIAL, ATHLETIC & MUNICIPAL SITES

N

WO

RK

UT

ILIT

E AR TH

IE S

C.

SIT

Proud to be the site work contractor for CLEVELAND CLINIC AVON HOSPITAL

DE

M O LI TI

ON

At Sitetech, we take a lot of pride in providing our clients with the highest levels of service and professionalism in the industry. Our employees are the backbone of Sitetech and offer uncompromised experience, knowledge and safety to all of our operations.

35700 E. Royalton Rd., Grafton, OH 44044 440-748-SITE (7483) • www.sitetechexcavating.com www.propertiesmag.com 49

Photo by Ken Krych

Hospital MEP systems were devised to be energy efficient while also meeting the project’s construction budget goals, notes Michael J. Berning PE, CEM, LEED Fellow, of Heapy Engineering, which provided MEP systems design. “We used variable primary chilled water pumping with discharge water reset as a controls strategy,” says Heapy Engineering Healthcare Practice Leader Joe Ferdelman. “This certainly saves pump energy, but also has the cumulative effect of reducing the overall electrical usage of the chiller plant and significantly decreases the amount of energy used in building heating. “The heating plant uses 95% efficient condensing boilers, a nearly 20% higher operating range than standard systems. We addressed steam system efficiency using flash MAKING SPACE A cafeteria and kitchen are located on the first floor, with a servery space that economizers and stack economizers can be closed off from the dining area to accommodate community events. to capture previously wasted energy. operation were ever needed, or should assemblies on a flatbed truck. Cranes All this efficiency improvement was accomplished while still maintaining we lose a generator, we have a ‘docking then hoisted each into place. Headwalls the Clinic’s high-quality patient com- station’ set-up so we could plug in an for all the patient rooms were also comexternal generator.” pleted offsite. fort standards.” The highlight of the construction, Unexpected benefits continued as An eTracking system monitors all refrigerant levels for medicines, tissue however, must be the degree to which data showed that working offsite in constorage, as well as food storage, and will multiple components were prefabbed trolled conditions, the health of the alert maintenance personnel the minute offsite. “BIM technology and design- tradesmen benefitted. Working in a it goes out of allowable range. While assist from mechanical, electrical, remote warehouse, tradespeople could hundreds of hours used to be spent moni- structural steel and framing contractors work more ergonomically and more effitoring and logging results, now that is all allowed extensive components to be ciently, not needing tall ladders, and prefabbed offsite,” Krymowski says. therefore reducing workplace stresses done electronically. In addition to utility racks being and injuries. “Emergency backup generators with a All the benefits realized during the 20,000-gallon underground fuel storage fabricated, entire bathroom units were tank can provide for up to 96 hours of pre-plumbed and brought two at a time construction of this hospital will conoperation,” Krymowski says. “If further to the site as eight-foot by 20-foot tinue to benefit the Cleveland Clinic


EXPANDING SIGHTLINES What appears to be a typical nurses’ station is actually much larger, with more desk space, and now shared by all caregivers. Full-height glass walls enable caregivers to monitor activities around their space, but provide acoustical privacy to patients, even those directly across from the work area.

health system for years to come as they are incorporated into future projects, Laird explains. “Everyone on the [Avon Hospital] project team worked together to devise

creative solutions to not only address constructability issues but concurrently maintain the project schedule,” says Brian Stewart, project director with technical and engineering consulting

firm NV5, which assisted in developing the project baseline schedule and monitoring progress throughout construction. “The use of Lean scheduling practices in combination with traditional CPM scheduling was instrumental in achieving the on-time completion of construction.”

Five floors of innovation & efficiency

Proud to have provided Critical Path Method (CPM) Scheduling and BIM Services at

CLEVELAND CLINIC AVON HOSPITAL 50

Owner Representation BIM Integration CPM Scheduling Cleveland 440-247-3700 www.NV5.com

The two buildings connect at the family center’s northeast corner as an extension of the emergency department. The balance of the new first floor consists of a two-story lobby, dining areas with great views, cafeteria space and a fully equipped kitchen. The servery area can be closed off from the dining area to accommodate community events. Internal space on the first floor houses the new laboratory and imaging facilities for both inpatient as well as outpatient needs. A new loading dock, compactor and storage area share a common, small corridor to save space. White corridors are standard throughout, with accents of quarter-sliced maple on all doors, the elevator wall and the reception desk. Frosted glass panels serve as a soffit above the reception desk as well as creating diffusion for the meeting rooms overlooking the lobby on the second floor. Properties | February 2017


We are proud to be a part of the team as Design Assist Site Development Contractor for

CLEVELAND CLINIC AVON HOSPITAL

Precision Engineering & Contracting, Inc. Professional Engineers & Construction Contractors www.precisioneng.us | 31340 Solon Rd., Ste. 25 & 26, Solon, OH 44139 | 440.349.1204


Proud to have provided and PUZ[HSSLK [OL ÄYL WYV[LJ[PVU MVY

CLEVELAND CLINIC AVON HOSPITAL with Gilbane Building Co. EFFICIENT APPROACH Multiple construction components were prefabbed offsite, including headwalls in all patient rooms.

HVAC | FIRE PROTECTION | PLUMBING | PROCESS PIPING

2900 Newark Dr. ◆ Barberton, OH 44203 ◆ 800-776-7181 www.sacomunale.com

Proud partner with Cleveland Clinic as the sole provider of signage & graphics for the new Avon Hospital

Floor two is the location for the meeting rooms as well as catheterization lab and operating rooms. Floors three through five are all identical with staff work centers, patient rooms, visitor waiting areas and large glass-walled solariums facing west for the afternoon sun. Patient rooms feature flush, white, wall-mounted cabinetry along with a large, colorful, fabric-covered wall panel for contrast. The large, interactive TV and an easy-to-read clock are mounted opposite the headboard. Large windows offer great views of the wooded property.

Another first for Cleveland Clinic

216.741.3800

www.brilliantsign.com

4811 Van Epps Road, Cleveland, Ohio 44131 52

November 10, 2016 marked the opening of the new building, with an unexpected new name: the Roseann Park Family Tower. Ray Park and his wife Roseann have been longtime board members and the naming was a surprise from Ray for his wife. “Avon Hospital marks a historic advance for Cleveland Clinic,” says Toby Cosgrove, M.D., president and CEO of Cleveland Clinic. “This is the first regional hospital we’ve designed and built from the ground up. This is a new kind of hospital for a new era. It incorporates everything we’ve learned about delivering 21st century healthcare.” “As the first hospital connected directly to one of our family health centers, Cleveland Clinic Avon Hospital will help us build on the exceptional care we already provide on our campus, now offering patients the full range of care they need,” Starck says. P Properties | February 2017


Charting Your Destination? We’ve been helping companies steer toward new and better futures as an icebreaker in forging strong new relationships for over 70 years!

INDUSTRY LEADER SINCE 1946 Exclusive | Focused | Informative | Dependable | Connected www.Propertiesmag.com

The Renwick Gallery for DLR Group/Westlake Reed Leskosky

Creative Architectural & Fine Interior Photography kevinreevesphotographer.com www.propertiesmag.com 53


Legal Services Ground Leases & Downtown Redevelopment Can an old ground lease affect a property’s future? By Lori Pittman Haas Ulmer & Berne LLP

ver the last few years, downtown Cleveland has benefitted from the vision of developers who saw potential in historic buildings that could be repurposed in ways that lead to Cleveland’s renaissance. We’ve seen buildings transformed from Board of Education headquarters to hotels, from office buildings to mixed-use (retail and residential), old bank buildings into grocery stores, and so on. But for real estate lawyers tasked with examining title for downtown properties, our “vision” was not about the future potential, but an analysis of how a real property’s past affects its future.

O

A buyer’s objective (and the lender’s ideal) is for the buyer to own the fee interest in the real property. However, the existence of a ground lease impacts that objective. A ground lease is a lease of the land only. Usually a ground lease or land lease is for a relatively long period of time, sometimes up to 99 years. Some ground leases have renewal terms that can extend the term for another 99 years. The fee owner or ground lessor has a reversionary interest in the land. The ground lessee owns the improvements constructed upon the land. At the end of the term of the ground lease, the land goes back to the fee owner (ground lessor) and the improvements revert to the ground lessor or are required to be removed by the ground lessee, depending on the terms of the ground lease. In our examination of title for a few downtown properties, we encountered situations in which a bank is a trustee for a group of beneficiaries under a ground lease in which the seller of the real property was the ground lessee. Over time, the beneficial interests in the trust were often split into fractional shares, resulting in multiple beneficiaries under the trust. Further complicating the situation was that the trust instrument was recorded after the deed of conveyance. Thus, from a legal standpoint, the bank is the fee owner but holds the asset in a fiduciary capacity under the terms of the trust instrument. As a result, if a buyer is successful in acquiring the fee interest and terminating the ground

lease, the real property is not conveyed by a fiduciary deed since the bank is technically the fee owner. As buyer’s counsel, trying to effectuate the buy-out of a ground lease subject to these quirks is particularly challenging for several reasons. First, one can’t simply make a deal with the fee owner because the fee owner holds the asset in a trust capacity. Second, each

beneficiary may hold a very small fractional interest due to the original interest being split multiple times over the term of the ground lease; thus, the value of a beneficiary’s share may be negligible. Third, some beneficiaries like to be able to say that they “own” a piece of an iconic building in downtown Cleveland or a relative formerly owned the interest, so the emotional attachment to the building is priceless. Fourth, some beneficiaries simply cannot be located. In one case, the terms of the trust instrument provided that if a beneficiary held at least 75% of the beneficial interests, that beneficial interest holder could terminate the trust. Fortunately, the buyer was able to acquire at least 75% of the interest, terminate the trust and force a sale of the fee interest in the real property. Another peculiarity that we encountered in a ground lease for one downtown property was that a 1921

Landscaping Contracts – with Extraordinary Color Plans Planting, Design & Installation • Irrigation Installation & Repair Routine Ro outtine ti PProperty roperty ope pe y Ins Inspection sspec pecti pec tion o & Maint Maintenance Maintena a tenaa ce ce

T HHNTIFJTGFIK GGNTFGMTEMMI '48+0) .. 1( *+1 www.propertiesmag.com 55


Lori Pittman Haas

HOW BAD IS THAT LEAK?

Keep your assets safe by taking the time to ensure that problems at the top of your building are not damaging your bottom line.

Carey Roofing Corp. has eliminated asset damage due to a leaking roof with practical solutions since 1946. 216 • 881 • 1999 CAREY www.careyroofing.com

Roofing Corp. 56

founded in 1946

MEMBER: National Roofing Contractors Association

amendment made the lease term perpetual. Under Ohio law, perpetual leases are not favored but competent people are free to deliberately enter into such agreements. Cook v. Village of Paulding, 207 N.E.2d 405 (Ohio C.P. 1965). An intention to create a perpetuity must be clearly shown in the instrument of conveyance Hallock v. Kintzler, 142 Ohio St. 287 (1943). That is, if possible, a lease will be interpreted to avoid a perpetual term. Id.; see President & Trustees of Ohio Univ. v. Athens Livestock Sales, 115 Ohio App. 21, 22-23 (1961) (lease is perpetual as it continues for so long as rent is paid); Orchard Isle Mobile Home Park I Condo. Assn. Inc. v. Sandy Shores, 2006-Ohio-326, ¶¶ 14-17 (lease held to be enforceable and perpetual where lessee could renew lease each year “solely at the option of the Lessee under the same terms and conditions set forth herein”). As a result of the lease term being perpetual, the ground lessee under such a ground lease is given special status under Ohio law as it is a “leasehold estate in name and in form only.” Ralston Steel Car Co. v Ralston (1925), 112 Ohio St. 306, 312. Essentially then, such an interest is tantamount to a fee simple interest, but valuing such an interest may be particularly challenging. P Lori Pittman Haas is a partner with Ulmer & Berne LLP and vice-chair of the Real Estate Practice Group. Properties | February 2017


Legal Services When Can Landlords Take Matters into their Own Hands? Examining landlords’ self-help rights in commercial & residential leases By Robert Fuerst Meyers, Roman, Friedberg & Lewis

common dilemma which confronts landlords is what to do when a tenant defaults under its lease. Can the landlord take matters into his own hands and lock the tenant out of its space or must the landlord proceed to evict the tenant through the courts?

A

The answer to this question depends on whether the tenant is a residential tenant or a commercial tenant.

No self-help for residential landlords If the tenant is a residential tenant, the answer is easy. Ohio Revised Code Section 5321.15(A) provides: “No landlord of residential premises shall initiate any act, including termination of utilities or services, exclusion from the premises, or threat of any unlawful act, against tenant, or a tenant whose right to possession has terminated, for the purpose of recovering possession of the residential premises, other than as provided in chapters 1923, 5303 and 5321 of the Revised Code.” Those are the Code sections that govern a landlord or landowner’s ability to recover possession by judicial means.

So, residential landlords are expressly barred from exercising self-help to evict a tenant. The landlord must go through the statutorily prescribed process known in Ohio as “Forcible Entry and Detainer.” Under this process the landlord must first provide whatever notices of default are required under

the lease. If the landlord does that, or if there is no written lease or no requirement to provide notice in the lease, the landlord must then serve the tenant with a “three-day notice,” which must be served by certified mail, personal delivery to the tenant, or left at the residence from which the tenant is to be evicted. The notice must conspicuously contain the following language: “You are being asked to leave the premises. If you do not leave, an eviction action may be initiated against you. If you are in doubt regarding your legal rights and obligations as a tenant, it is recommended that you seek legal assistance.” Assuming the tenant does not cure the default (and the landlord should not accept any future rent after the notices served or the notice will be

Thoughtful, Proactive Legal Representation for Industrial, Commercial & Residential Real Estate Contact our attorneys today to learn why we are one of Cleveland’s most respected providers of Real Estate legal services.

Peter D. Brosse (Chair, Business & Corporate Group)

Hunter W. Benson David V. Croft Bryan J. Dardis Robert A. Fuerst Michael B. Gardner* Janice A. Isakoff Scott M. Lewis Daniel N. Steiger*

28601 Chagrin Blvd., Suite 500 Cleveland, OH 44122 Phone: 216.831.0042 www.meyersroman.com

*Of Counsel

www.propertiesmag.com 57


Capturing Your Inspiration

Northeast Ohio’s Premier Aerial Photography & Videography Provider ■ Real Estate Properties ■ Construction Progression ■ Campus Tours | 360º Photos ■ Corporate/Promotional Videos ■ Full Video Production & Editing

Highest Video/Picture Quality 4K Resolution Professional and Reliable Locally Owned and Operated Framed & Canvas Prints Available HQT ;QWT .QDD[ QT 1HğEG 9CNNU

Utilizing Unmanned Aerial Systems!

440.241.1677 www.aerialagents.com hello@aerialagents.com

58

deemed waived), landlord may file a forcible entry and detainer action against tenant. Once a forcible entry detainer action is filed and the complaint is served on the tenant, the court will schedule a hearing at which the landlord should be able to obtain a judgment for possession of the premises, assuming the default has not been cured. Timing to obtain that judgment and to enforce it by ultimately having the sheriff evict the tenant varies by county.

Commercial landlords have self-help rights A commercial landlord does have the option of self-help, but only if the lease specifically gives the landlord that right and the repossession can be accomplished “without a breach of the peace.” Although there is no statutory recognition of a commercial landlord’s self-help rights, these rights were recognized in the 1987 Cuyahoga County Appeals cour t case of Northfield Park Associates v. Northeast Ohio Harness, which has been recognized as settled law ever since. The lease in that case provided that following a default by the tenant, the landlord could “re-enter into possession of the demised premises, with or without process of law and expel, remove or put out lessee... using such force as may be necessary to do so and to repossess said premises.” For landlords who want to make sure they have the right to exercise self-help, I suggest the following clause:

such force as may be permitted by law and without breaching the peace, change the locks to the Premises, and order utility services changed over into Landlord’s or any other’s name or terminated, take possession of all equipment, fixtures and other property of Tenant, and take whatever means Landlord deems lawfully necessary to effect such repossession and Tenant’s removal.” However, even with such a self-help provision in the lease, landlords should exercise caution before exercising this remedy. If the tenant is still conducting business in the space, the landlord risks a claim for loss of business, with significant potential damages, particularly if there is any question about whether the tenant is in default or might have any defenses to a claim of default. If the tenant has vacated the space, the decision to change the locks is easier. Still, landlords should always be cautious and should consult an attorney before deciding to exercise self-help. Commercial landlords always have the option to proceed with a forcible entry and detainer action, and they can combine the three-day notice with the notice of default and don’t have to include the quoted language above, which is only required in a three-day notice for a residential tenant. This is always the safer course of action and often the preferred one. P

Although there is no statutory recognition of a commercial landlord’s selfhelp rights, these rights were recognized in the 1987 Cuyahoga County Appeals court case of Northfield Park Associates v. Northeast Ohio Harness, which has been recognized as settled law ever since.

“If Landlord elects to re-enter and take possession of the Premises with or without terminating this Lease, Landlord may evict Tenant using

A principal with the law firm of Meyers, Roman, Friedberg & Lewis, Robert A. Fuerst focuses his law practice primarily on the areas of real estate, business & corporate, mergers & acquisitions, finance and construction. He can be reached at rfuerst@meyersroman.com. Properties | February 2017


Legal Services Five Common Misperceptions About Overtime Laws A look at typical mistakes that lead to costly Fair Labor Standards Act liability By Ann-Marie Ahern McCarthy, Lebit, Crystal & Liffman Co. LPA

avigating the labyrinth of employment laws is challenging, especially for smaller employers. And, if employment law compliance is hard, the granddaddy of all tricky statutes is the Fair Labor Standards Act (“FLSA”) – the law that governs, among other things, payment of overtime.

N

But wait, you may have heard that employers are getting a reprieve from new regulations that would have expanded overtime greatly. You may feel heartened by promises of a 75% decrease in the regulations that apply to employers. You may be seeking solace in speculation that the Department of Labor will not as vigorously pursue claims in the coming years. Even if this is true, none of it means that employers should let their guard down when it comes to overtime law compliance. While change may be on the horizon to the regulations that apply to the FLSA, the law itself, with its arcane language and ticky-tacky application, will remain. The availability of attorneys’ fees and the availability of civil penalties will assure that FLSA lawsuit filings will persist. Employers often falsely believe that their good intentions to treat employees fairly will suffice. As a result, we see recurring, common mistakes that lead to

Ann-Marie Ahern

costly FLSA liability. Here are five of the most common:

1. “We’ll just make them independent contractors.” While there are certainly advantages to classifying workers as independent

contractors, misuse of this classification is widespread and risky. In 2015, the National Employment Law Project reported that as many as 459,000 people in Ohio are misclassified as independent contractors and nearly 45% of all employers misclassify. Calling someone an independent contractor does not make them one, and can result in unpaid overtime liability. Courts apply a looser test in determining appropriateness of classification than that applied by the IRS, examining the “economic realities” of the relationship, including: the permanency of the relationship; the degree of skill required; the worker’s investment in equipment; the worker’s opportunity for profit; the degree of control over the manner in which the work is performed; and whether the work is an integral part of the employer’s business. The longer, more exclusive and/or controlling the

Sometimes, the best defense is a great offense. uol _;Ѵrbm] ; ;1 ঞ ;v m;]oঞ-|; ;lrѴo l;m| -]u;;l;m|v |o -7 bvbm] ;lrѴo ;uv om 1olrѴb-m1; bvv ;vķ o u ;lrѴo l;m| ]uo r v|- v -_;-7 o= |_; 1 u ;ĺ

SM

Trusted Advisors. Respected Advocates. www.mccarthylebit.com

www.propertiesmag.com 59


relationship, the more likely the worker is to be found an employee.

2. “Our employees get comp time.” Comp time is dangerous because it seems fair. If an employee works extra hours, they get extra time off. Seems reasonable, but is most often completely illegal. For private employers, comp time can only be offered if the comp time is

used in the same workweek as the extra hours were worked. If the extra hours result in more than 40 hours in any given workweek, a non-exempt employee must be paid overtime.

3. “We don’t count bonuses in overtime calculations.” If an employee earns a bonus that is non-discretionary (i.e. a commission

for volume, or a set amount upon project completion), that bonus must be included in the calculation of base wages to determine the overtime premium.

4. “Our employees are salaried, not hourly.” I am always surprised by the prevalence of this misconception. Placing a person on salary, standing alone, has no bearing on whether they are entitled to overtime pay. A determination must instead be made as to whether a given employee meets the requirements of an exemption. If duties warrant the exemption (see below), then paying a salary above the minimum threshold alleviates overtime requirements. Merely paying a salary does not.

5. “We give our employees ‘Manager’ titles so they are exempt.”

2008-2015

This is the slightly more sophisticated cousin of the mistake detailed above, and it involves fluffing titles in an attempt to make the title fit into one of the FLSA recognized exemptions. Office workers are the most likely to be misclassified, especially when they wear a lot of hats. The job title, no matter how impressive it sounds, will not be determinative of whether a particular exemption is met. Courts instead apply a series of hypertechnical standards to determine whether the work that the employee spends the bulk of his or her time actually doing is exempt work. If you are uncertain about your pay practices, seek help to implement a corrective plan. There are lots of ways that potential overtime liability can be managed or eliminated, but hoping to stumble into compliance is not one of them. P

Ann-Marie Ahern is a Certified Labor and Employment Law Specialist and Head of the Employment Practice at McCarthy Lebit (www. mccarthylebit.com). For more information, contact Ann-Marie Ahern at 216-696-1422 or ama@mccarthylebit.com. 60

Properties | February 2017


EN VI RON M E N T A L C O N S ULTIN G AN D LABO R ATO R Y S ER V ICE S

EA Group can help you make the pieces fit! EA Group is a recognized leader in environmental analysis and management. We’ve worked with a multitude of businesses and institutions to help discover, analyze, and manage their environmental issues. Since 1982, we have provided environmental, health and safety consulting, field, and laboratory services to thousands of clients throughout Ohio and the region. Our consulting staff has extensive experience in environmental, health and safety assessment, remediation, and management. Our laboratory capabilities include full environmental analysis, industrial hygiene analysis, and asbestos analysis.

BREATHE EASIER

EA Group works with clients in the following industries: • Construction & Design Companies • Environmental Consulting and Contracting • Educational Institutions (K-12, Public & Private, Universities) • Healthcare Facilities • Commercial Real Estate Development & Property Management Firms • Manufacturing Companies Put our expertise to work for your organization and start to breathe a little easier with EA Group.

800.875.3514 • 440.951.3514 • www.eagroupohio.com 7118 Industrial Park Boulevard • Mentor, OH 44060


NAIOP NEWS Commercial real estate happenings

Stream & Wetland Permitting – A Moving Target n January 6, 2017, the United States Army Corps of Engineers (“Corps”) announced its revised and renewed Nationwide Permits (“NWPs”) necessary for work in streams, wetlands and other waters of the United States under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act and Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act of 1899. On January 17, 2017, the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency (“Ohio EPA”) made available for review a copy of its draft Section 401 Water Quality Certification (“401 WQC”) for the NWP program.

O SHANE A. FAROLINO

A review of the draft 401 WQC in question reveals that the NWP program in Ohio is about to experience a major overhaul that could have significant ramifications for permit applicants going forward. In most cases, when a party needs to impact streams and/or wetlands in order to develop a site, Clean Water Act permits are often required from the Corps and the Ohio EPA. In such instances, some form of Section 404 Permit (“404 Permit”) is needed from the Corps, and a Section 401 WQC is needed from the Ohio EPA. Generally speaking, there are two different types of 404 Permits: NWPs, which are a type of general permit for projects

ROETZEL & ANDRESS A LEGAL PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATION

with minimal water quality impacts (i.e., typically less than 1/2 acre of wetland impact); and Individual Permits, for projects with more than minimal impacts to water quality resources. General permits such as NWPs are typically issued and remain effective for a period of no more than five years. In the case of the NWP program, the Corps issues NWPs every five years, which issuance triggers the need for the Ohio EPA to promulgate a new 401 WQC for the implementation of the NWP program in Ohio. The NWPs that are currently in effect were issued in 2012. The Corps’ revised and renewed NWPs will take effect on March 19, 2017. As such,

REGIONAL FOCUS, NATIONAL REACH. Experience you can count on. Advice you can trust. At Roetzel, helping clients achieve their objectives is our business. Recognized by Midwest Real Estate News as a “Best of the Best” law firm since 2004, and highlighted by Chambers USA as a “Leading Environmental Law Firm” since 2003, our Real Estate and Environmental attorneys will provide you with a road map to success.

WWW.RALAW.COM/REAL_ESTATE WWW.RALAW.COM/ENVIRONMENTAL 62

AKRON • CLEVELAND • COLUMBUS • CINCINNATI • TOLEDO

Properties | February 2017


Legal Services between now and March 19, the Ohio EPA will be issuing its new 401 WQC for the implementation of the NWP program in Ohio. Notably, Ohio’s wetland permitting rules have historically required permit applicants to characterize wetlands to be impacted pursuant to the Ohio Rapid Assessment Method (“ORAM”). Conversely, however, because Ohio still does not have stream-specific permitting and mitigation rules for the 401 WQC program, stream impacts resulting from proposed projects have traditionally been evaluated using numerous different methods on a case-by-case basis. If the Ohio EPA’s draft 401 WQC for the NWP program is ultimately enacted in its current proposed form, the old way of doing business will soon come to an abrupt halt. Pursuant to the draft 401 WQC that was recently circulated by the Ohio EPA, when an applicant submits an application for a NWP for a project that will result in stream impacts, the applicant will be required to demonstrate that the stream impacts are eligible for NWP coverage pursuant to very specific protocols outlined by the agency in its draft 401 WQC for the NWP program. In order to assist applicants with this eligibility determination, the Ohio EPA has prepared a GIS map of the various watersheds across the state. Notably, the GIS map in question divides the state into three distinct areas: areas ineligible for coverage under the 401 WQC for the NWP program in Ohio; areas that are possibly eligible for NWP coverage; and areas that are eligible for coverage provided that all NWP criteria are met. Roughly speaking, the ineligible watersheds constitute approximately 18% of the state, the possibly eligible watersheds consist of approximately 19% of the state, and the eligible watersheds comprise approximately the remaining 63% of the state. If the proposed stream impacts fall within an ineligible area, the applicant will be required to apply for either an Individual 401 WQC or a Director’s Authorization (an exemption extending NWP coverage to projects that are

demonstrated to result in minimal water quality impacts). If the proposed stream impacts fall within a possibly eligible area, the applicant will be required to evaluate the quality of the streams to be impacted pursuant to the specific protocols identified by the agency in order to determine if the project is eligible for coverage under the NWP program or if an Individual 401

NAIOP of Ohio has, on two separate occasions, previously submitted comment letters to the Ohio EPA expressing its concerns with previous drafts of the 401 WQC for the NWP program in Ohio. The Ohio EPA’s latest draft 401 WQC for the NWP program is currently out for public comment at this time. The Ohio EPA will accept comments regarding the draft 401 WQC until March 10, 2017. At this point, numerous segments of the regulated community are anxiously waiting to see whether the 401 WQC for the NWP program in Ohio will ultimately be issued in its current form. If the 401 WQC ends up being issued as it is currently drafted, it will be equally interesting to see whether any party appeals the issuance of the 401 WQC to the Environmental Review Appeals Commission, and if such an appeal is filed, whether the appeal results in any additional changes to the 401 WQC for the NWP program in Ohio. P

[The] new approach constitutes a major change in the manner in which the NWP program is implemented in Ohio. As a result, many segments of the regulated community are gravely concerned about the manner in which this new approach will impact the ability to obtain permits for a wide variety of projects in the future. WQC will be required from the Ohio EPA. If the proposed stream impacts fall within an eligible area, the project is eligible for NWP coverage and no further assessment of stream impacts is necessary. Without question, this new approach constitutes a major change in the manner in which the NWP program is implemented in Ohio. As a result, many segments of the regulated community are gravely concerned about the manner in which this new approach will impact the ability to obtain permits for a wide variety of projects in the future.

Shane A. Farolino is a Partner with Roetzel & Andress and the Chair of the firm’s Environmental, Energy, and Health & Safety Practice Group. He routinely represents clients in stream/wetland permitting matters. Farolino is a member of the NAIOP of Ohio Board as well as a NAIOP Northern Ohio board member, and has been following the developments discussed in this article on behalf of NAIOP for several years. He can be contacted at sfarolino@ralaw.com or 330.849.6680. www.propertiesmag.com 63


LEGAL PERSPECTIVES Navigating property laws & regulations

Five Points to Consider When Selecting Counsel ttention Construction Players, including but not limited to developers, owners, design professionals, general contractors, subcontractors and suppliers! News flash #1: construction projects are unpredictable and risky. You should select attorneys to help you manage the risks. News flash #2: Attorneys cost money. Spending money on attorneys when project margins are already thin is like bad medicine. News Flash #3: Take the bad medicine, but choose it wisely.

A

JOHN SWANSINGER, ESQ.

Choosing when to utilize construction counsel is an art form. Too much and it’s wasteful. Too little and it can open a Pandora’s box of liability, missed opportunities and litigation. Even the most seasoned construction players struggle with this decision. Certainly, when an attorney is heavily involved in a project from start to finish and that project goes smoothly, the perception of an attorney’s value can quickly evolve into a “could have done it without you” attitude. Correspondingly, when there is little attorney involvement and the project goes smoothly, a “why waste the money” approach may develop. When the going inevitably gets tough however, you will

64

want your attorney fully cognizant of your construction needs. Be mindful of these five key points:

1. Specialty There are upwards of 1,300,000 attorneys in the United States and 40,000 in Ohio alone. You cannot be a construction attorney unless you are involved in construction law on a daily basis. You can’t dabble. You can’t figure it out on the fly. Exceptional attorneys in what seem to be closely related fields will struggle with the peculiarity of the language and the nuances of each individual project while facing a steep learning curve; however, there is no time for it. Perform your due diligence and be

Properties | February 2017


Legal Services sure you are hiring an actual construction attorney.

2. Willingness to learn Even the construction attorney you hire will not be able to understand every nuance about your project. Only hire attorneys who demonstrate to you the willingness to immerse themselves in your way of doing business, the type of project, political landscape of the project and the personalities of the players involved. Each project has its own set of important parameters. Make sure the attorney you hire is engaged in developing knowledge of the subtle nuances of your project.

3. Knowledge of the documents Construction projects are typically governed by specific project documents that may or may not have been negotiable. For an attorney to best represent your interests as the project progresses, familiarity with the documents is paramount. The best way to achieve this is to engage the attorney to assist in the creation and negotiation of the project documents and continue the engagement throughout the project. The attorney will have an edge in advising you as the many issues arise and help you evaluate the associated risks. Selecting an attorney in the middle of the project, after it is apparent there is an issue, will not serve you well. The attorney will be handicapped by the time crunch to become apprised on documents that he or she has neither created nor seen.

and get dirty shoes from time to time, you will not be well served. Similarly, if your attorney is afraid to put on a “hard hat” and challenge the other project players on your behalf, you are not receiving the necessary representation. A construction project is not suited to the meek and mild, “go along/ get along” style of legal counsel. You must know in advance that your construction counsel will fight for you.

5. Dispute resolution knowledge Your attorney should be equipped to establish, initiate and be the advocate for any dispute under the project documents. So many of the modern construction forms, such as the American Association of Architects (AIA) forms, offer court or alternative dispute resolution mechanisms. Regardless of which procedure is negotiated, most of the forms require precision in asserting and establishing most claims. Legitimate claims will easily be lost to a critically tight window of oppor-

CELEBRATING

15 YEARS

Numerous issues will arise on every construction project. Use your gut feeling and the guidelines above to make the medicine go down and find your seasoned, informed and engaged construction counsel. P John Swansinger is a partner with Buckingham Doolittle & Burroughs, LLC (www.bdblaw. com). He specializes in construction law including general counsel and litigation. He can be reached at jswansinger@bdblaw.com or 216-615-7356.

OF COST SEGREGATION 2002-2017

ACCELERATE DEPRECIATION AND SHIELD INCOME TAXES NOW • Cost Segregation • Energy Efficiency Certifications (179D)

4. Willingness to wear a hard hat Choose an attorney who knows, both in reality and metaphorically, how to put on a hard hat. Construction projects are filled with the brightest managers, engineers, operators, suppliers and so on. Construction is often a challenging and intense process. Your attorney should gain project knowledge by field observation and know in the mind’s eye where “that dirt pile was located,” “where the staging ground was set,” “where the utilities connect” and many other key physical properties of the project site. If your attorney won’t put the hard hat on

tunity in which to assert a claim demand, strict notice provisions and oppressive waiver language. Once a claim is asserted, you must know and observe the agreedupon, ongoing relationship in the field with the claim adversary. You also need to understand how payment and retainage will be managed. Your construction attorney should be able to coach you in the establishment and defense of claims in order that you are vested in all of the rights for which you bargained.

• New IRS Repair v. Capitalization

Call Craig Miller

Cleveland 440.892.3339 / Columbus 614.949.4185 Detroit 248.752.7433 / www.costsegexperts.com

THE REGION’S LEADING INCOME TAX REDUCTION EXPERTS www.propertiesmag.com 65


VANTAGE POINT Experts weigh in on industry issues

2017 – Changes to Ohio Public Contracting Rules tate construction spending in Ohio is big business – nearly a billion dollars annually in fact. Each year, the State of Ohio administers dozens of projects worth hundreds of millions of dollars. These projects provide substantial opportunities to design professionals, construction managers, trade contractors, suppliers, manufacturers and other vendors.

S IAN FRANK

MICHAEL FRANTZ, JR.

tary and high schools. The State also modernized its project delivery process by supplementing its old guard – multiprime approach – with more integrated processes, including Design-Build and Construction Manager at Risk (CMAR). Additionally, the State implemented a best value selection process for the revamped delivery methods, in lieu of the lowest and best bidder approach. Under the best value selection process, an evaluation committee determines the best value based upon performance and pricing criteria specified in Chapter 153:1 of the Administrative Code. At the end of 2016, the OFCC reviewed the applicable provisions of the Code as part of a five-year review process, and recommended several changes in January 2017. The revisions are primarily ministerial and clarify references to OFCC specified contracts,

The procurement and performance requirements for doing business with the State can be vastly different than private contracting, so companies that want to take advantage of these opportunities must understand these unique rules, regulations and contractual obligations, as well as stay abreast of a changing landscape. The State has recently approved changes to its construction procedures, and is considering additional amendments that are expected to be implemented in 2017. In 2011, the State changed the way it does business when it ushered in legislation known as “Construction Reform.” With the reforms, the State created the Ohio Facilities Construction Commission (OFCC), which is charged with overseeing construction projects for state agencies, state-supported universities and community colleges, as well as elemen-

Capitalize on Your Coverage. M k a great impression! Make i i ! Contact C info@propertiesmag.com i f i to order d reprints or custom copies of articles originally published in Properties, which can be distributed to your existing and future clients. UWLQJ 6XSSRU :WV[SPNO[PUN [OL WYVMLZZPVUHS ZLY]PJL WYV]PKLYZ J[PVU WYVQLJ[Z ILOPUK Z\JJLZZM ILOPUK Z\JJLZZM\S JVUZ[Y\ &DVW :WV[SPNO[PUN [OL Plan Ahead & Negotiate Wisely to Maximize Value

INDUSTRY LEADER SINCE 1946

Outparcels Ou of Shoppingg Center Out

By Megan C. Zaidan, Esq. Walter | Haverfield LLP

value ad rs to create added of a retail center – allow developers utparcels – small lots on the periphery outparcels are more s, as outparcel utilized by banks or restaurants, to shopping centers. Outparcels are often features, such as specific featur increased visibility and ability to add attractive to these users based on the to the user’s business. a patio or drive-thru, which are important docu Recorded documents

O

Developers will most often convey the parcels either by longterm ground lease or outright sale to the end user.

Legal subdivisions

Exclusive | Focused | Informative | Dependable | Connected www.Propertiesmag.com 66

From a developer’s perspective, it may be necessary for the outparcel to be legally subdivided from the larger shopping center parcel as a condition of sale to the end user. If a developer knows in the initial stages of development that it is likely to sell off one or more outparcels, it would be wise to create the separate parcels early in the development process. Such a pro-active approach is particularly important in jurisdictions with time-consuming subdivision processes. The sub-dividing of the outparcel from the large shopping center could expedite subsequent sales of any such outparcels created. the Alternatively, developer may require the end-user to cause the parcels to be subdivided; however, the developer will need to remain involved and aware of the subdivision plans

Megan C. Zaidan, Esq.

Equally important for the developer is to ensure that outparcel plans independently meet or exceed applicable parking requirements

ce subdivided, the respecOnce t developer bligations of the tive obligations own (or ground he parcel owner and the lessee)) will likely be governed Reciprocal Easement by a Reciproca ement (an “REA”). The Agreement fort each party’s REA will set forth such as ma ation for matters obligation ss, utilities, maintenance access, and insurance. In addition, may also look to the developer m ose certain operating and impose upon the restrict ding restrictions building within the REA, arcel with outparcel heigh restrictions to uding height including constructed build ure any building ensure not block the viseon will no thereon signage of the shopping ty or signag ibility tenant ter’s tenants. center’s developer may also look he develop The number of tenants or imit the nu to limit lo If the outparcel userss of the lot. is not restricted to a single user, it develop into a multi-tencould be developed rip-center tthat could eventually ant strip-center compe with the larger compete center for small shoppi shopping shop tenants. Finally, the would likely look develo developer architectural in to include and signage standards for the outparcel, so it conform with the shopping forms ensuring a more cent center,

From a developer’s perspective, it may be necessary for [an] outparcel to be legally subdivided from [a] larger shopping center parcel as a condition of sale to the end user.

Expanding Oppo

Geis Companies By Dan Maurer

rtunity

hits the road to

| Photos by

Marco Zecchin/Im

build $80 million

Thermo Fisher

age Center Scientific facility he Geis Compan ies Streetsboro-based has been busy in Northeas t Ohio in 2014. company complete Brecksville, a Within d a 110,000-s 75,000-square-foot quare-foot medical the past 12 months, the aluminum dye call center for device facility Panther Logistics casting facility for AMT in in building for Firefighters CommunTwinsburg for General Dye. in Medina and a 90,000-sq uare-foot It finished a service center ity Credit Union 12,000-square-foot addition for in Cuyahoga Steel Warehou office Hofbräuhaus Heights, plus se of Ohio. More Cleveland. a 40,000-square-foot recently, the Garnering company also the most buzz, Geis unveiled The completed for 9, the

T

Thermo Fisher massive $170 lion project Scientific, a mil- based in Boston- Fisher multination that incorporate downtown Cleveland Scientific in product developmen al, biotechnology s the East Bay Administrative the Cuyahoga County of California, region t company with enues of $17 prompted by Headquarters, rev- tion of billion. In fact Metropolitan the expiraThe th existing l nea l 60% h t l

Properties | February 2017


Legal Services but there are a few notable changes. One substantial change relates to the rules that address evaluation committee procedures. Those rules now include language that limits the public authority’s discretion in forming the committee by prohibiting the public authority from creating an evaluation committee with enough members to constitute a quorum of that public authority. This is likely intended to ensure a meaningful review by the public authority of the CMAR or Design Builder proposed by the evaluation committee. According to the OFCC, the revisions will ensure the “integrity and fairness of the evaluation and interview process of short-listed firms.” Another important amendment specifies (and provides) the performance and payment bond forms that must be used for projects with the OFCC. Lastly, the OFCC has developed a new rule increasing the competitive bidding threshold from $200,000 to $215,000, and publishing

the calculation method and inflation index to be used for future revisions. As part of this statutorily required housekeeping, we anticipate the OFCC will also be revising its contract documents. The OFCC General Conditions are likely to be revised, and changes to the contract forms are also possible. Amendments to several sections of the General Conditions are currently under consideration. The proposed revisions primarily relate to a CMAR’s obligations with respect to subcontractors, preconstruction services, construction and closeout documents, modifications, dispute resolution and payment. The proposed revisions illustrate a clear intent to further reduce the State’s risk when utilizing the more integrated project delivery methods. For instance, currently a CMAR is only obligated to review and offer an opinion on the design professionals’ submissions. The revisions will enable the OFCC to hold the CMAR contractually liable for any ambiguities and/or

inconsistencies in the design documents. Additionally, the proposed changes contemplate the OFCC’s use of unilateral change orders to compel the performance of disputed work at a minimal risk to the OFCC. The proposed modifications to the payment terms relate to the use of contingency funds that may limit the right to certain claims and thereby increase the financial risk borne by CMARs and their lower tiers. Finally, if adopted, the OFCC will require a signed acknowledgement from the CMAR’s surety to increase the penal sum to finalize change orders that increase the contract sum. For those bidding on projects affected by the revisions, it is critical to stay up-to-date on these evolving rules and understand the impacts they may have on your bottom line. P Ian Frank and Michael Frantz, Jr. are construction attorneys at Frantz Ward LLP located in Cleveland. For more information, visit www. FrantzWard.com.

Top-tier construction lawyers. With a down-in-the-trenches approach. At Frantz Ward, our Construction Practice Group really digs in to solve complex issues. It’s what has made us nationally recognized as a leading law firm for our depth and experience in the industry.

Claims Management, Analysis & Avoidance | Competitive Bidding Disputes | Workplace Safety Construction Litigation, Arbitration & Mediation | Contract Drafting & Negotiation | Surety Law | Lien & Bond Claims

FrantzWard.com

www.propertiesmag.com 67


New Tools & Potential Risks in Environmental Due Diligence An examination of environmental insurance and vapor intrusion By Leslie G. Wolfe and David Ricco Walter | Haverfield

ost commercial real estate transactions involve some degree of environmental due diligence. Hiring a qualified environmental consultant to conduct a Phase I environmental site assessment (ESA) is a basic but critical step in any property transaction. An ESA can provide vital information as to the nature and extent of existing contamination, the risk of future releases of hazardous substances, the owner or purchaser’s legal exposure, and possible remediation costs.

M

Beyond the Phase I ESA, however, developers should be aware of new tools for managing and evaluating environmental risks, such as environmental insurance. Additionally, parties to real estate transactions should understand the health and environmental risks of vapor intrusion, which has become a significant concern in Ohio and across the country. Keeping up-to-date on emerging issues in environmental due diligence can increase the likely success of any project.

Environmental insurance An effective way to manage environmental risks and unknowns at acquisition is acquiring an environmental insurance policy applicable to the property to be effective upon closing. Premises Pollution Liability (PPL) policies are available from numerous insurers; policy terms, conditions, exclusions and premiums vary widely, so be

David Ricco

Leslie G. Wolfe

sure to work with a well-informed broker and with experienced legal counsel. The basic purpose of this type of insurance is to address the property and liability insurance coverage exclusions for pollution releases and/or exposures emanating from or occurring within the property. A properly placed PPL policy can provide money for bodily injury, cleanup costs, property damage, business interruption losses and for legal defense costs. PPL policies are typically single-

premium, with a term of five to 10 years; premiums, deductibles and available liability limits vary greatly by insurer. A policy can be acquired for a single site, and portfolio policies are available. Industry-specific and other special endorsements are offered by many insurers, and coverage is often available for known conditions in addition to unknown conditions. Also, many policies now include coverage for indoor environmental exposure. A PPL policy is often an excellent way to address information gaps in due diligence and to enable financing and other investment when environmental conditions within a property may be unknown and even in certain circumstances where recognized environmental conditions (RECs) are known to exist. PPL policies are written in a fairly unregulated insurance environment, so policy language and terms vary significantly and must be carefully reviewed, and perhaps negotiated, to be sure that the intended coverages are secured. When shopping for a policy, it is important to be represented by legal counsel experienced in environmental matters that is also familiar with the property to be insured and experienced with placing environmental insurance policies.

Vapor intrusion Vapor intrusion – the contamination of indoor air by volatile chemicals in soil and ground water – is a hot issue in Ohio. It occurs when vapor-forming chemicals migrate from any subsurface source into an overlying building, 68

Properties | February 2017


Legal Services just like radon gas seeping into homes. Property owners and developers should know enough about vapor intrusion to converse intelligently with their environmental professionals about the risk. To start, vapor intrusion results from the presence of vapor-forming chemicals, including volatile organic compounds (VOCs), such as trichloroethylene and benzene; select semivolatile organic compounds; elemental mercury; and some PCBs and pesticides. In addition to the obvious health hazards of long-term exposure to toxic fumes, vapor intrusion can result in dangerous explosions. These risks can be exacerbated by the presence of other vapor-causing chemicals inside the building, such as industrial solvents and gasoline. The Ohio EPA issued a guidance on vapor intrusion in 2010 that was significantly revised in 2016, reflecting a dramatic increase in national

attention on the risks associated with contaminated indoor air. Under the Ohio EPA guidance, if an initial site assessment indicates the possible presence of VOCs or toxic substances in soil or ground water, a further evaluation should be conducted to identify any potential vapor intrusion “path-

qualified environmental consultant can design and conduct an effective vapor intrusion assessment and recommend appropriate actions that comply with both state and federal standards. Developers who stay abreast of new risk management tools and environmental risks can avoid costly and potentially deal-killing remediation issues. Environmental insurance is an effective tool for managing environmental risks and potentially even enabling transactions. Moreover, as the scientific understanding of vapor intrusion increases and Ohio EPA tightens its assessment and cleanup criteria, savvy developers must be prepared to address the risk. P

An effective way to manage environmental risks and unknowns at acquisition is acquiring an environmental insurance policy applicable to the property to be effective upon closing. way.” If a potential pathway exists, then subsurface soils (including subslab) and ground water should be tested to determine whether the pathway is “complete” and, if so, whether it presents an imminent hazard to building occupants. A further assessment of the exposure risk may be necessary depending on the sampling results. A

Leslie Wolfe practices in the environmental services and litigation practice groups of Walter | Haverfield. David Ricco is a partner in the firm’s real estate practice group.

Our strength is in our numbers. Put one of the region’s largest real estate practice groups to work for you. We have the resources and experience to handle transactions of any size. Urban & Historic Redevelopment Land Use & Zoning

The Real Estate Attorneys of

Real Estate Finance

Leasing

Development

Tax Credit Transactions

Tech, Multi-family & Shopping Centers

Josh Hurtuk, Megan Zaidan, Kevin Murphy, Tyler Bobes, Todd Hunt, Jack Waldeck, Sophia Deseran, David Mansbery, Nick Catanzarite, Rick Amburgey, Irene MacDougall, Nate Felker, David Ricco and Geoff Goss

Cleveland | 216.781.1212 www.walterhav.com

www.propertiesmag.com 69


Space Comfort co. )$0,/< 2:1(' 23(5$7(' :,7+ +$1'6 21 (;3(5,(1&( ,1 0(&+$1,&$/ &2175$&7,1* 6$/(6 6(59,&( 6,1&( ([SHUWV LQ Q 7XUQNH\ VROXWLRQV GHVLJQ EXLOG YDOXH HQJLQHHULQJ Q 6HUYLFH LQVWDOODWLRQ PDLQWHQDQFH RI DOO PDNHV PRGHOV RI +9$& HTXLSPHQW ERLOHUV Q 1HZ UHQRYDWLRQ UHPRGHOLQJ UHVWRUDWLRQ Q 3XEOLF SULYDWH 3URYLGLQJ UHOLDEOH SHUVRQDO VHUYLFH WR RZQHUV RI UHWDLO FHQWHUV PDOOV DSDUWPHQW FRPSOH[HV UHWLUHPHQW KRXVLQJ LQ 2KLR QHLJKERULQJ VWDWHV

5201 CLARK AVENUE, CLEVELAND OHIO 44102 Q PH. 216-281-2000 Q FAX. 216-281-8420 Q 800-203-9645 */%6453: -& "%& 3 */ )*() 26"- * 5 : %0 $ , %0 0 3 4 & 37 * $ & ."* /5 & /" / $ &

Opening New Doors

COMMERCIAL / INDUSTRIAL / INSTITUTIONAL ONE-SOURCE FOR:

4"*/5 $-"*3 "7&/6& .&/503 0)*0

www.commercialdockanddoor.com 70

Ì &/53"/$& %0034 Ì 3&70-7&34 Ì *$6 %0034 Ì 4.0,& 3"5&% %0034 Ì "%" %0034

440.951.4541 Properties | February 2017


Legal Services A Break in the Chain of Title: Curing Defective Titles New Ohio law significantly shortens time to cure defective titles – effective April 6, 2017 By Kathryn Carlisle-Kesling Buckley King

title defect may be cured by the passing of the requisite time period, without challenge. By applying Ohio’s curative statutes, some title defects may not be defects at all and may be easily eliminated. Regardless of the type of real property – residential, suburban retail, industrial or downtown mixed use – sellers, buyers and/or investors invariably never want to face a title issue, especially at the closing table.

A

Title issues are generally never resolved quickly and are not always clearly understood (especially if a real estate attorney or title agent is not involved at the beginning of the deal). It doesn’t matter where the real property is located, when asked to consider a title issue or review an opinion of title, the stakes are high and time is of the essence. The first consideration is the title standard applied and agreed upon between the parties. The applicable title standard can be elusive to some practitioners because of choice words employed (most commonly in the sales contract) with differing meanings and risk. These words, whether carefully crafted or just another unfortunate case of a boilerplate purchase contract gone wrong, are also known as a “contract condition.” The title standard may also be dictated by the type of property being sold. For example, if subsurface interests or mineral interests are to be sold, the marketability study period will generally be longer, in part because of a higher potential for adverse claims and profit. Therefore, a higher degree of title marketability may be negotiated. If title insurance is obtained, the parties may not even consider the standard of title (although this is short-sighted for the buyer as owner’s title insurance policies contain exclusions and exceptions from coverage). If there is not coverage or it is being contested, the buyer could hold the seller responsible under the general warranties and title granted. A quick drilldown of the exact words used in the sales contract will usually reveal one of the following:

• Seller shall convey title to the Property to Buyer…; or • No title standard expressed at all.

Kathryn Carlisle-Kesling

• Seller shall convey marketable record title to the Property to Buyer, free and clear of all liens and charges and encumbrances, except for …; • Seller shall convey marketable title to the Property to Buyer…; • Seller shall convey good, marketable, insurable and clear fee simple title to the Property to Buyer…;

Bear in mind the Ohio Marketable Title Act. The standard may be for an absolute or perfect title/conveyance or some lesser standard. The buyer may not demand a perfect title but, customarily, may ask for a “Marketable Record Title.” Defined in R.C. 5301.50, “Marketable Record Title” means that the record title of the property operates to extinguish such interests and claims existing prior to the effective date of the root of title as stated in R.C. 5301.50: Any person having the legal capacity to own land in this state, who has an unbroken chain of title of record to any interest in land for forty years or more, has a marketable record title to such interest as defined in section 5301.47 of the Revised Code, subject to the mat-

STRUCTURAL STEEL FABRICATORS & ERECTORS SINCE 1958

0DVRQ 6WHHO Contact Mike Smith for a Proposal: (440) 439-1040 | (800) 686-1223 7500 Northfield Rd. | Walton Hills, OH 44146 www.masonsteel.com Other Fine Products Available: Stone | Pavers | Fireplaces | Windows | Doors www.propertiesmag.com 71


ters stated in section 5301.49 of the Revised Code. R.C. 5301.48. Once the title standard is understood, the next step is to discern whether there are true defects – liens, burdens, charges, encumbrances, etc. – that affect the value of the property or render the title unmarketable, and whether the defects are curable.

Consider this hypothetical scenario. The buyer is ready to begin construction on the new company headquarters, having obtained construction plans, and both county and township approval to re-zone the parcel. The title examination reveals a problematic deed in the chain of title. There appears on the record to be a hanging interest of a prior Grantor. The warranty deed, filed

on February 14, 2000, which vested title in the seller, wholly omitted a certificate of acknowledgement for one of the Grantors. The seller is distressed as it appears that she cannot grant a marketable record title (the standard which the parties negotiated) and she believes she will have to file a quiet title action to clear the prior interest. Situations such as this are endless and often encountered. While appearing at first to be a deal breaker, applying O.R.C. §5301.07 may resolve the hypothetical problem above without having to bring a quiet title action, or wait the 21 years under the prior version of this statute, to determine if any action is brought to challenge its validity and potential defect. The new law defines “real property instruments” as a deed, mortgage, installment contract, lease, memorandum of trust, power of attorney, or any instrument accepted by the county recorder under O.R.C. §317.08. It creates two rebuttable presumptions: (1) the instrument conveys, encumbers, or is enforceable against the interest of the person who signed the instrument; and (2) the instrument is valid, enforceable, and effective as if in all respects the instrument was legally made, executed, acknowledged, and recorded. The rebuttable presumption arises when the real property instrument is delivered to and accepted by the county recorder. When the instrument is on the record for more than four years from the date of its recording, the instrument and record shall be cured of the defect, as if legally made. The new law sets out four specific scenarios which would be curable defects: (1) not properly witnessed; (2) no certificate of acknowledgement; (3) acknowledgement is defective in any respect; (4) interest holder does not appear in the grantor clause, but signed the instrument – it specifically states defects may include but are not limited to the following. The new law is retroactive and applies to any prior transfer on the record (except for those that would affect any accrued substantive right or

72

Properties | February 2017


> COMMERCIAL REAL ESTATE expertise. vested rights in any person or in any real property instrument). In the scenario above, the buyer’s objection to a defective title should not result in a failure of condition. The seller can convey marketable title to the buyer, free and clear of the hanging interest even though the deed failed to contain a certificate of acknowledgment. The poorly drafted deed was on the record for more than four years from the date of recording, without challenge to rebut the presumption of validity. If four years had not passed since the deed was recorded, a quiet title action may be brought to clear the interest of the grantor. In addition, the presumptions can only be rebutted by clear and convincing evidence of fraud, undue influence, forgery, duress, incompetency, or incapacity, and must be rebutted, if at all, within four years of the recording of the defective real estate instrument. No doubt this new tool will assist in clearing many defects in title and will reduce costly litigation. Title insurance companies will suffer far fewer title insurance claims. Real estate deals will close more smoothly. However, fine-eyed litigators who hold parties to the precise drafting of real estate instruments to get out of poorly crafted contracts have lost a tool in their toolbox. I believe that it will also assist in reducing legal malpractice claims when legal documents fail to comply with the basic tenants and formalities required under the law as it relates to real estate instruments. Just like we have to patrol our property boundaries for squatters, we now have to patrol our real estate titles. This will certainly increase the need to file timely actions to rebut the presumptions laid out in the statute. P This article is meant to provide general information only and is not a substitute for legal advice. Statutory references have been paraphrased for purposes of simplicity and ease of reading. Readers should seek the advice of their attorney or contact Kathryn Carlisle-Kesling at carlisle@buckleyking. com or 216.685.4761. Kathryn Carlisle-Kesling is a partner with the law firm of Buckley King. She is an Ohio State Bar Association Board Certified Specialist in Residential Real Property Law and possesses a thorough understanding of the intricacies of real estate and title matters.

> PERSONALIZED COMMUNITY BANK service.

It’s all about collaboration, individualized service and fostering economic growth in our community. We’re committed to it. And nearly 80 years of community banking expertise supports it.

LET OUR TEA M HELP YOUR S THR I V E . Contact Rig Goss at (216) 239-5904.

on time on budget on mark

Rethink Your Outside Counsel

SM

216.363.1400 I buckleyking.com

CLEVELAND I COLUMBUS I CINCINNATI I ATLANTA I PHOENIX I LAS VEGAS

www.propertiesmag.com 73


CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT Updated info on important projects in the region

Project Report #: 01248 CENTRIC MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT LOCATION:11601 Mayfield Rd. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Commercial CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Work Underway - Construction Completion Date Not Set - Possible Summer 2018 EST. VALUE: $70,000,000 OWNER/DEVELOPER: A joint venture between The Coral Management Co., Midwest Development Partners and Panzica Construction Co. Midwest Development Partners LLC Zac Ponsky 19910 Malvern Rd., Ste. 219 Shaker Hts., OH 44122 Phone: 216-310-1766 www.midwestpartners.com The Coral Management Co. Contact: Peter Rubin 13219 Shaker Square Cleveland, OH 44120 216-932-8822 www.thecoralcompany.com Panzica Construction Co. Contact: Anthony Panzica 739 Beta Dr. Cleveland, OH 44143 Phone: 440-442-4300

www.panzica.com ARCHITECT: Bialosky & Partners Architects Contact: David Craun 2775 S. Moreland Blvd. Shaker Heights, OH 44120 Phone: 216-752-8750 CM: Owner will act as the Construction Manager DESCRIPTION: 2.2 acres, 1 bldg, 7 stories. Mixeduse development to consist of multiple buildings - commercial and possible residential - was Intesa now Centric – plans changed to one seven-story building with 272 apartments and shared 27,000 sf office space and retail on the ground floor - 360 space parking garage. Second phase to include 150,000 office space. Project Report #: 01362 CITY OF KENT POLICE STATION LOCATION: 200 E. College Ave. Kent, OH (Portage County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Competitive Bids PROJECT STATUS: Construction Underway Completion Set For Late Summer 2017 EST. VALUE: $12,000,000 OWNER: City of Kent Contact: Gene Roberts, Service Director 215 E. Summit St.

COMPLETE FACADE RESTORATION www.aiconstruction.com Restoration Contractors

440.243.5535

Kent, OH 44240 Phone: 330-676-8030 ARCHITECT: DS Architecture Contact: Jeff Meyers 136 N. Water St. Kent, OH 44240 Phone: 330-678-6144 www.dsarchitects.net DELIVERY METHOD: Design/Bid/Build BUILDER: RFC Contracting Inc. 13477 Prospect Rd., Ste. 105 Strongsville, OH 44136 Phone: 440-572-9444 www.rfccontracting.com CIVIL ENG: Howard and Baird Inc. STRUCTURAL ENG: Ohlin & Reed Structural MECH ENG: Hinckle Engineering ELEC ENG: Epic Design Group OWNERS REP: The Ruhlin Co. DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 3 stories, 32,760 sf. Dispatch center - jail - operations area - detective bureau - administration area - community center space - additional parking - 55 spaces. Project Report #: 01601 QUATTRO CONDOMINIUM BUILDING LOCATION: 2044 Random Rd. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Residential PROJECT STATUS: Schematics In Progress - Potential Construction Start In August EST. VALUE: $13,000,000 OWNER/DEVELOPER: Bluewater Capital Partners LLC Contact: Russell Lamb 1938 Euclid Ave., Ste. 200 Cleveland, OH 44115 Phone: 216-965-0621 ARCHITECT: RDL Architects Contact: Ron Lloyd 16102 Chagrin Blvd., Ste. 2000 Shaker Heights, OH 44120 Phone: 216-752-4300 www.rdlarchitects.com CM AT RISK: Pride One Construction Contact: Tom Charek 387 Medina Rd., Ste. 600 Medina, OH 44256 Phone: 330-590-8011 www.prideoneconstruction.com DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 5 stories. 26-unit condos ranging from 2,100 sf to 3,000 sf - on site parking. Project Report #: 01551 VERONIKA APARTMENT COMPLEX RENOVATION LOCATION: 12301 Madison Ave. THE

74

Properties | February 2017


Lakewood, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: Renovation CATEGORY: Mixed Use PROJECT STATUS: Construction Underway Completion Set For Early to Mid 2017 EST. VALUE: $500,000 DEVELOPER: Scalish Construction Contact: Frank Scalish 13316 Madison Ave. Lakewood, OH 44107 Phone: 216-226-5251 www.scalishconstruction.com ARCHITECT: Architecture Office Contact: Dru McKeown/Adam Rosekelly 5401 Hamilton Ave. Cleveland State: OH Zip: 44114 Phone: 234-222-8607 www.thearchoffice.com BUILDER: By Owner DELIVERY METHOD: Design/Build STRUCTURAL ENG: Thomas Kovach Associates Inc. MECH ENG: Point One Design, ltd ELEC ENG: Point One Design, ltd DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 2 stories, 73,044 sf. Historical renovation - 6 updated apartments - new bathrooms and kitchens - updated lighting - two updated storefronts - one LBM bar. Project Report #: 01589 NATIONAL INTERSTATE EXPANSION LOCATION: Interstate Dr. Richfield, OH (Summit County) www.nationalinterstate.com PROJECT TYPE: New Construction PROJECT STATUS: Construction Underway Completion Set For End of 2017 EST. VALUE: $25 million OWNER: National Interstate Contact: Amanda Genther 3250 Interstate Dr. Richfield, OH 44286 Phone: 330-659-8900 www.nationalinterstate.com ARCHITECT: Kaczmar Architects Inc. 1468 W. 9th St., Ste. 400 Cleveland, OH 44113 Phone: 216-687-1555 www.kaczarch.com BUILDER: Snavely Building Company 7139 Pine St., Ste. 110 Chagrin Falls, OH 44022 Phone: 440-585-9091 www.snavely.com DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 5 stories, 117,000 sf. Larger cafeteria - additional wellness facilities several outdoor decks and patios. Project Report #: 01609 HEBREW ACADEMY OF CLEVELAND - HIGH/ JUNIOR SCHOOL LOCATION: 1516 Warrensville Center Rd. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: Renovation CATEGORY: Institutional

PROJECT STATUS: Project Completed Recently EST. VALUE: $1,800,000 OWNER: Hebrew Academy of Cleveland Contact: Rabbi Eli Dessler 1860 South Taylor Rd. Cleveland Hts., OH 44118 Phone: 216-321-5838 www.hac1.org ARCHITECT: Ronald Kluchin Architects, Inc. Contact: Ron Kluchin 23215 Commerce Park, Ste. 316 Beachwood, OH 44122 Phone: 216-464-7494 CM: Neshkin Construction Contact: Terry Muth 24204 Aurora Rd., Unit 2D Cleveland, OH 44146-1724 Phone: 216-241-3397 www.neshkin.com DESCRIPTION: 89 acres, 1 bldg, 3 stories, 35,000 sf. Conversion of former Oakwood Country Club into junior/ senior high school renovation to first floor plus gymnasium. Project Report #: 01610 ACADEMY OF CLEVELAND ELEMENTARY SCHOOL LOCATION: 1516 Warrensville Center Rd. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Institutional CONTRACTING METHOD: Construction Management PROJECT STATUS: Site Plans Approved - Construction Schedule Not Set Pending Funding EST. VALUE: $30,000,000 OWNER: Hebrew Academy of Cleveland Contact: Rabbi Eli Dessler 1860 South Taylor Rd. Cleveland Hts., OH 44118 Phone: 216-321-5838 www.hac1.org ARCHITECT: Ronald Kluchin Architects, Inc. Contact: Ron Kluchin 23215 Commerce Park, Ste. 316 Beachwood, OH 44122 Phone: 216-464-7494 BUILDER: To Be Selected DESCRIPTION: 89 acres, 1 bldg, 1 story, 134,000 sf. New elementary and junior high.

Join Us! 65th Annual Design & Construction Conference & Tradeshow

HEBREW

Project Report #: 01594 VA MEDICAL CENTER ADDITION - RENOVATION LOCATION: Cleveland Main Campus - University Circle Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: Renovation/Addition PROJECT STATUS: Shell Completed - Interiors Completion To Start In March EST. VALUE: $20,000,000 OWNER: Veterans Administration Contact: David Sabol 10701 East Blvd. Cleveland, OH 44106 Phone: 216-791-3800

MARCH 16, 2017 7:30 AM - 5:00 PM LaCentre 25777 Detroit Rd. Westlake, OH 44145

Morning Keynote:

Mark Mistur CAED Dean

Kent State University

Lunch Keynote:

Joe Marinucci President & CEO Downtown Cleveland Alliance

Special Welcome by:

Theodore Carter Chief Economic Development Officer

Cuyahoga County Department of Development Contact CES at 216-361-3100 for details about sponsor and exhibitor opportunities. -!'!:).% ).#

is a proud media sponsor of the Cleveland Engineering Society www.propertiesmag.com 75


www.va.gov

2'%+#.+<+0) +0 #.. ARCHITECT: Makovich & Pusti Architects, Inc. Contact: Mike Molchan #52'%65 1( '6#. 111 Front St. Berea, OH 44017 4#/+0)X 4;9#..X Phone: 440-891-8910 %1756+%#. '+.+0)5 MECH ENG:www.mparc.com Fredrick, Fredrick & Heller Eng Inc. ELEC ENG: Fredrick, Fredrick & Heller Eng Inc. #0& .114+0)

DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 58,000 sf. Two-floor vertical addition and renovation to include hemodialysis - PACU - operating rooms - surgical renovation - 10 OR suite renovation - cardio - ENT - vascular-hyprid OR - mechanical penthouse.

f n 6 X 174 )1#.5 #0& 8#.7'5 #4' %105+56'06 9+6* #.. %.+'065U &'.+8'4 37#.+6; 914-X 10 6+/' #0& 10 $7&)'6T ' 564+8' 61 ':%''& '8'4; %.+'06 5 ':2'%6#6+105 #0& (14/ # .#56+0) 2#460'45*+2T 74 56#0&#4&5 9+.. '0574' # (.#9.'55 241,'%6 '8'4; 6+/'T KMF T #).'; &T '4'#X HHNEK ).'00u+%109%(T%1/ 999T+%109%(T%1/

HHNgFFEgLFKI 76

Project Report #: 01580 SALVATION ARMY OF GREATER CLEVELAND EAST CLEVELAND CORPS COMMUNITY CENTER LOCATION: 9000 Superior Ave. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) www.salvationarmycleveland.org PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Commercial PROJECT STATUS: Completed November 2016 Open In January 2017 EST. VALUE: $9.8 million OWNER: The Salvation Army of Greater Cleveland Contact: Major Lurlene-Kay M Johnson 2507 E. 22nd St. Cleveland, OH 44115 Phone: 216-861-8185 www.salvationarmycleveland.org ARCHITECT: Van Auken Akins Architects 1422 Euclid Ave., Ste. 1010 Cleveland, OH 44115 Phone: 216-241-2220 www.vaakins.com BUILDER: Marous Brothers Construction 1702 Joseph Lloyd Pkwy. Willoughby, OH 44094 Phone: 440-951-3904 www.marousbrothers.com DESCRIPTION: 4 acres, 1 bldg, 31,000 sf. Senior center - new Learning Zone program - community center - expanded food pantry - gymnasium - fitness center splash park - chapel. Project Report #: 01579 SALVATION ARMY OF GREATER CLEVELAND TEMPLE CORPS COMMUNITY CENTER LOCATION: 17625 Grovewood Ave. Collinwood, OH (Cuyahoga County) www.salvationarmycleveland.org PROJECT TYPE: New Construction CATEGORY: Commercial PROJECT STATUS: Completed November 2016 EST. VALUE: $10 million OWNER: The Salvation Army of Greater Cleveland Contact: Major Lurlene-Kay M Johnson 2507 E. 22nd St. Cleveland State: OH Zip: 44115 Phone: 216-861-8185

www.salvationarmycleveland.org ARCHITECT: Van Auken Akins Architects 1422 Euclid Ave., Ste. 1010 Cleveland, OH 44115 Phone: 216-241-2220 www.vaakins.com BUILDER: Marous Brothers Construction 1702 Joseph Lloyd Pkwy. Willoughby, OH 44094 Phone: 440-951-3904 www.marousbrothers.com DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 34,182 sf. Expand capacity for its Learning Zone after-school program - computer lab - increase size of the gymnasium, fitness center and the food pantry and storage areas - expanded kitchen and dining area. Will also have a new baseball field by spring 2017. Project Report #: 01439 PROSPECT YARD APARTMENTS LOCATION: 1937 Prospect Ave. Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga County) PROJECT TYPE: Renovation CATEGORY: Residential CONTRACTING METHOD: Bids by Invitation Only PROJECT STATUS: Working Drawings Nearing Completion - Possible April 2017 Construction Start Scheduled EST. VALUE: $16,000,000 OWNER/DEVELOPER: The Woda Group, Inc. Contact: Joe McCabe 229 Huber Village Blvd., Ste. 100 Westerville, OH 43081 Phone: 614-396-3223 www.wodagroup.com ARCHITECT: Chambers Murphy & Burge Contact: Elizabeth Corbin Murphy 43 E. Market St., Ste. 201 Akron, OH 44308 Phone: 330-434-9300 www.cmbarchitects.com GC: The Woda Group, Inc. Contact: Joe McCabe 229 Huber Village Blvd., Ste. 100 Westerville, OH 43081 Phone: 614-396-3223 www.wodagroup.com STRUCTURAL ENG: Thorson Baker & Associates, Inc. MECH ENG: Thorson Baker & Associates, Inc. ELEC ENG: Thorson Baker & Associates, Inc. DESCRIPTION: 1 bldg, 5 stories, 65,900 sf. Renovation of Stuyvesant building - 42 apartments - indoor parking. Information included in Construction Progress Report has been produced, processed and/or verified through sources believed to be reliable. Properties Magazine makes no warranty of any kind for this information, express or implied, and is not responsible for any omissions or inaccuracies. To contribute project data or to notify Properties of any reporting errors, we encourage you to email cpr@propertiesmag.com. Properties | February 2017


Proudly serving Cleveland for 1 0 years Complete Pest Control Services FHA/VA/HUD Termite Inspections/Pretreatments Residential - Commercial Industrial Integrated Pest Management Programs Wild Animal/Bat Removal Pre-Construction Animal Exclusion Consulting Industrial Weed Control Sentricon™ Termite Colony Elimination System

͙​͙͔​͔ ǡ ǡ ͘​͕͕͗͘ Ǧ ͖͕͚Ǥ͚͖͘Ǥ͚͔͔͘ ͖͕͚Ǥ͚͖͘Ǥ͚͔͕͘

Ƭ Ƭ Ȁ Ǧ Ƭ

Ǥ Ǧ Ǥ

Cleveland Chemical Pest Control, Inc. Quality Pest Control Service Since 1903

18400 S. Waterloo Road Cleveland

216-481-8400 Free Telephone Consultation

͖͘Ȁ͛Ȁ͚͙͗

™-Trademark of Dow AgroSciences

BETWEEN THE WEATHER & YOU SINCE 1922

WARREN ROOFING WARREN ROOFING AND INSULATING COMPANY

Working directly with manufacturers to provide efficient, reliable service and installation of a complete selection of roof systems, from single-ply to solar & green roofing. ABOVE ALL... WE ARE THE ROOFING PROFESSIONALS

Commercial/Industrial Roofing + Architectural Sheet Metal

440.439.4404 Fax 440.439.7523

www.warrenroofing.com www.propertiesmag.com 77


Coming in March Akron City Schools’ Firestone/ Litchfield Community Learning Center West 25th Street Lofts Special Section: Landscapes & Hardscapes … and more Interested in advertising? Call Properties today and an account representative can help you www.propertiesmag.com address your advertising needs: Visit us online for archived fea-

ture articles, advertising rates, 216.251.0035 / 888.641.4241 specs and subscription information.

ADVERTISER INDEX 21st Century Concrete Construction, Inc. .................45 Abraxus Snow Removal ....................................................60 AC Electric & General Contracting, LTD .....................78 Aerial Agents .........................................................................58 AIA Cleveland ........................................................................27 Air Control Products, Inc. .................................................27 ALL Construction Services...............................................53 American International Construction ........................74 Brennan & Associates ........................................................32 Brilliant Electric Sign Co. ...................................................52 Bruder Building Materials, Inc........................................38 Buckeye Sweeping, Inc. ....................................................11 Buckley King, LPA ................................................................73 Carey Demolition.................................................................39 Carey Roofing........................................................................56 CBRE, Inc. .................................................................................25 Chagrin Valley Steel Erectors......................................... 64 Charles Schulz Building Company ...............................68 Chas. E Phipps Company, The .......................................29 Cicogna Electric & Sign Co...............................................22 Cleveland Chemical Pest Control, Inc.........................77 Cleveland Engineering Society .....................................75 Cleveland Public Power ....................................................12 Columbia Building Products ..........................................33 Commercial Dock & Door ................................................70 Construction Green Team................................................31 County Fire Protection Inc................................................. 7 Courtad Dalton LLC .............................................................. 6 Crystal Clear Building Services, Inc..............................41 Cunningham Paving Inc. ..................................................27 Dependable Painting, Co. ................................................42 Donley’s Inc. ...........................................................................14 Duffy & Duffy Cost Segregation Services.................65 EA Group .................................................................................61 Educational Equipment ....................................................30 EM Construction Co./BeaconMarshall Companies ....38 First Federal Of Lakewood...............................................73 Forest City Erectors............................................................ 44 Frantz Ward LLP....................................................................67 Gardiner ..................................................................................23 Gilbane Building Co............................................................43 Gleeson Construction....................................................... 44 H & M Snow Pros & Landscaping, Inc. .......................... 3 Heapy Engineering .............................................................50 HMH Restoration Ltd. ........................................................24 Icon Interiors ..........................................................................76 Industrial First, Inc. .......................................................17, 48 Infinity Construction ..........................................................12 Interstate Gas Supply, Inc. ...............................................13 J C Sharp, Corp. .....................................................................26 J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc. ...............................................39

Jamieson Ricca Fenestration ..........................................11 JCI Contractors, Inc. ............................................................31 JL Taylor, Co. Inc. ..................................................................33 John G. Johnson Construction Co. ..............................33 JP Plumbing & Heating, Inc.............................................18 Keen-Summit Capital Partners ......................................29 Kevin Reeves Photographer ...........................................53 Krill Company, Inc .................................................................. 7 Lakewood Supply Co. ........................................................35 Lisco Heating & Cooling, Inc. ..........................................37 Maguire Photo ......................................................................38 Mason Structural Steel, Inc..............................................71 Masonry Restoration Maintenance .............................56 McCarthy, Lebit, Crystal & Liffman LPA .....................59 Meaden & Moore, Ltd ........................................................80 Messina Floor Covering, Inc. ....................................19, 46 Messina Floor Covering, Inc. .......................................... 46 Meyers, Roman, Friedberg & Lewis .............................57 NCI Precast/Norwalk Concrete Industries ................34 Nelson Contracting.............................................................55 North Coast Concrete, Inc. ..............................................16 NV5 .............................................................................................50 OCP Contractors............................................................24, 41 PCS Container Sales............................................................31 Pease Photography.............................................................72 Pete & Pete Container Service .......................................36 Precision Engineering & Contracting Inc..................52 Precision Environmental Co............................................77 Precision Laser & Instrument, Inc. ................................10 Qualified Interiors, Inc. ......................................................79 Relmec Mechanical, LLC .................................................. 44 Roetzel & Andress LPA.......................................................62 S.A Comunale Company........................................... 26, 52 Siegel Jennings ...................................................................... 9 Sitetech, Inc. ...........................................................................49 Sleggs Danzinger & Gill....................................................... 4 SMPS Northeast Ohio ........................................................37 Snow Brothers Appliance, Inc. .......................................20 Soprema Inc. ............................................................................ 2 Space Comfort Co. ..............................................................70 Sunray Window Films LLC................................................28 Suntrol Co. ..............................................................................21 Ullman Electric ........................................................................ 8 Ulmer & Berne LLP...............................................................54 Unilock Ohio ..........................................................................47 US Communications & Electric Company.................42 Vavro Conservation Services, LLC ................................14 Vocon .......................................................................................15 Walter & Haverfield LLP ....................................................69 Warren Roofing & Insulating Co....................................77 Wurz Company, The R.L....................................................37

1( 2KLR·V (OHFWULFDO 6HUYLFH 0DLQWHQDQFH 6ROXWLRQV 6SHFLDOLVWV

&/(9(/$1'

www.propertiesmag.com Visit us online today to view archived issues in an interactive digital format. 78

6LQFH 7URXEOH 6KRRWLQJ ([SHUWV 6XUJH 3URWHFWRUV /LJKWLQJ 5HWURILWV &RQVXOWDWLRQV /,9( 'LVSDWFKHU 2Q &DOO

$.521

,Q +RXVH IW %XFNHW 7UXFN (PHUJHQF\ +RXU 5HVSRQVH 9 /DQGVFDSH² 9 6\VWHPV 758( 52, /LJKWLQJ $QDO\VLV

ZZZ $&(OHFWULF2+,2 FRP

>ŝĐĞŶƐĞ EŽ͘ >ͲϮϰϭϲϭ

Properties | February 2017


CARPET | CERAMIC | RESILIENT FLOORING | WINDOW SHADES | WALLCOVERING PAINT & SPECIALTY COATINGS | PRESSURE WASHING | INDUSTRIAL/EPOXY FLOORS

FOR 25 YEARS, PROFESSIONALLY FURNISHING & INSTALLING: HEALTHCARE & SENIOR LIVING FACILITIES | OFFICE FACILITIES | RESTAURANTS RETAIL & BANKING | INDUSTRIAL | INTERIOR & EXTERIOR SCHOOLS & CHURCHES | HOSPITALITY INDUSTRY | COMMERCIAL

871 Canterbury Rd., Unit C, Westlake, OH 44145 • 440-617-9050 • www.qualifiedinteriors.com


You Already Take Enough Risks You work with industry experts to reduce risks to you and your employees. Shouldn’t the same be true for your accounting firm?

ACCOUNTING EXPERTISE ◆ BUSINESS PLANNING ◆ TAX PLANNING SUCCESSION PLANNING ◆ PROFIT ENHANCEMENT ◆ BID REVIEWS COST CONTROL ◆ LITIGATION SUPPORT SERVICES ◆ JOB-COST AUDITING

MEADENMOORE.COM | 216.241.3272 AKRON | BEACHWOOD | CLEVELAND | WOOSTER


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook