Skip to main content

Northeast Ohio Properties, April 2013

Page 1

,16,'( /00 5LFKDUG 6HULQJ &HQWHU %XLOGLQJ (QYHORSH 5RRILQJ 6SHFLDO 6HFWLRQ

April 2013/$7.95

*SHZZPJ *VTLIHJR

7\ISPJ WYP]H[L WHY[ULYZOPW Z\JJLZZM\SS` YL]P]LZ OPZ[VYPJ <UPVU )\PSKPUN PU KV^U[V^U *SL]LSHUK SPECIAL INSERT:

NAIOP Annual Awards of Excellence


construct Connecting Our Construction World to You. Estimating. Project management. Labor issues. These are issues that you deal with daily in your construction world. Job costing. Increasing bidding and bonding capacity. Tax planning and compliance. These are issues that we deal with daily in our construction world. The Construction Group at Skoda Minotti can deliver on the promise of connecting our construction world to you by leveraging our reputation and relationships with bonding agents and financial institutions to help maximize your bonding capacity and obtain the necessary financing you need, when you need it. For a no-risk analysis of your construction business or to sign up for free quarterly e-mail reports on over 20 segments of the construction industry, call Roger Gingerich at 440-449-6800 or visit our website at www.skodaminotti.com.

www.skodaminotti.com


You may see it as just a parking lot. We see it as the welcome mat to your business. With over 70 years of experience, Ronyak Paving is the one contractor that understands the importance of affordably keeping a clean and safe parking surface for your employees and customers. We have the machinery and manpower to get in and get out with minimum distruption of traffic. For all your paving needs, count on Ronyak Paving.

800.PAVE.NOW

www.RonyakPaving.com

PAVING THE WAY TO A BETTER WORLD

! " # $ %

& % '## %%( )%

&*+ % ,- # .+ - .

4

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


April 2013, Volume LXVII, Number 4

phone: 216.251.0035 toll free: 888.641.4241 fax: 216.251.0064 www.propertiesmag.com

FEATURES

CLEVELAND 3826 W. 158th St. Cleveland, Ohio 44111 AKRON P.O. Box 9 Monroe Falls, Ohio 44262

Photo courtesy of Studio Techne

OWNER/PUBLISHER Kenneth C. Krych kkrych@propertiesmag.com MANAGING EDITOR/ART DIRECTOR Mark Watt mwatt@propertiesmag.com CONTRIBUTING WRITERS Nicole Nashar Andrews, Doug Bardwell, Jeanne Bluffstone, John Elliott, Lou Kren, Jean Leathers, Alec Pacella, John Slagter, David Woodburn ACCOUNT EXECUTIVES Andrea Keener akeener@propertiesmag.com 216.849.4350 Larry Overbey loverbey@propertiesmag.com 216.251.6649

10 February Construction Slides 7% 14 Classic Comeback Public-private partnership successfully revives historic Union Building in downtown Cleveland

23 Communal Spirit Lutheran Metropolitan Ministry, North Presbyterian Church team to enhance outreach

49

Accessible Education LCCC expands academic offerings with new University Partnership Ridge Campus

53 Special Section: Building Envelope/Roofing Report 53 Prolonging Performance: Specialized roof coatings reduce capital expenditure, maintenance & energy costs 56 Built to Last: Family-run Southwest Companies works to lengthen operating life of NE Ohio facilities 59 Project Profile: Keystone Threaded Products – Hailstorm damage forces roof replacement at Valley View facility 64 Project Profile: Kleist Center for the Arts – Project at Baldwin Wallace University demands creative problem-solving 65 Industry Profile: CTL Engineering Inc. Roofing & Building Envelope Services

OFFICE MANAGER Lisa Larissey 216.251.8506 Cover photo: The Union Building, by Jim Maguire

INSERT: NAIOP Annual Awards of Excellence

DEPARTMENTS Properties (ISSN 033-1287) is published monthly for architects, engineers, building owners and managers, general contractors, home builders, mortgage bankers, savings and loans, real estate agents, appraisers, servicers and suppliers in Northern Ohio by Properties, Inc., 3826 W. 158th St., Cleveland, Ohio 44111. Copyright © 2013 by Properties, Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction or use, without written permission, of editorial or pictorial content is strictly prohibited. Periodicals postage paid in Cleveland, Ohio and additional offices. Subscription rates: one year $24.95, single copy $7.95, back issues $10 when available. Postmaster: send change of address notices to Properties, P.O. Box 112127, Cleveland, Ohio 44111.

8 13 30 32 34 37 42 45 66

PROPERTIES PEOPLE BOMA BUSINESS LEGAL PERSPECTIVES CABOR CORNER NAIOP NEWS BILLBOARD FINANCIAL STRATEGIES VANTAGE POINT CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT www.propertiesmag.com 5


PUBLISHER’S NOTE April 2013

Moving Up mong many positive developments taking place throughout Northeast Ohio right now, revitalization of Cleveland’s Euclid Corridor continues to progress with the completion of numerous construction projects. This month, we highlight one of those projects: the renovation of the Union Building at 1836 Euclid Ave.

A KEN KRYCH

Made possible through a public-private partnership between Cleveland State University and Liberty Development, the Union Building has undergone a complete historic restoration, inside and out, to house multiple administrative departments for the university. The design and construction team worked hard to bring the building back to its original beauty, which we explore in this month’s cover story. Development continues at another Northeast Ohio educational institution:

Lorain County Community College (LCCC), which we have highlighted with a series of articles in early 2013. This month, we look at LCCC’s University Partnership Ridge Campus, a facility which houses classrooms for medical and computer studies, as well as offices for partner colleges. Lutheran Metropolitan Ministry (LMM) has found a new home along Superior Avenue in a formerly vacant manufacturing/warehouse space, which has been creatively transformed into the

When your fair share of taxes is neither fair... nor your share Billions in assessment reductions The attorneys at Siegel Jennings bring experience as accountants, appraisers and real estate developers to the practice of law. Our property tax services include: Ŷ Representation at the administrative level through the State Supreme Court Ŷ Local expertise in every state through the American Property Tax Counsel Ŷ Tax management – acquisition/disposition strategies Ŷ Cutting edge approaches to property tax reductions

Siegel Jennings 6

Call J. Kieran Jennings, Esq at 216.763.1004

Cleveland Ŷ Pittsburgh Ŷ Columbus

23425 Commerce Park Drive, Suite 103, Beachwood OH 44122 www.siegeltax.com

Founding member, American Property Tax Counsel (APTC) • www.aptc.com

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


Richard Sering Center, with modern offices and meeting spaces. This ministry has helped to feed the homeless, poor and others, and offers classes for individuals to upgrade themselves with new skills. The building also houses LMM’s partner North Presbyterian Church. Also this month, we offer our annual Building Envelope/Roofing Report, a special section focusing on the exterior systems of buildings. We have collected a series of informative articles from area experts, including Hecei Roofing, Tusing Roofing, CTL Engineering and Absolute Roofing. These include profiles of several challenging roofing projects throughout the region. We are also pleased to provide a profile of Southwest Companies, a company that specializes in all phases of restoration including the repair of roofs and building exteriors. NAIOP Awards of Excellence As a special supplement this month, we are proud to provide the event program for NAIOP’s Annual Awards of Excellence, which will be held May 8. These awards recognize construction, design, development and marketing success in office, industrial, multi-family and mixed-use development throughout 2012. Best wishes to all involved. Coming in May Every year in May, we present our Plumbing & HVAC Systems special section, which looks into the latest trends and techniques in the industry, while highlighting the work of area experts. In addition to this section, we will be offering profiles of some interesting projects in the region. We’ll take you on a tour of the new Cuyahoga County Public Library – Mayfield branch, highlight recent renovation work at Western Reserve Historical Society and take a look at Kent State University’s new Williams Hall Multi-Discipline Lab. Until then, enjoy the warming weather and colors of springtime.

All Things Concrete – Your Commercial & Decorative Total Concrete Solution

Positively,

21ST CENTURY CONCRETE CONSTRUCTION INC. 13925 Enterprise Ave. Cleveland, OH 44135

216.362.0900 Kenneth C. Krych Owner/Publisher

www.21stcenturyconcrete.com www.propertiesmag.com 7


PROPERTIES PEOPLE Highlighting notable industry events

1

6

2

3

7

CES Design & Construction Conference The Cleveland Engineering Society (CES) held its annual Design & Construction Conference recently at LaCentre in Westlake. Over 50 companies and sponsors exhibited their products and services to more than 350 attendees. The event included the presentation of six Awards of Excellence for key projects completed in Northeast Ohio, plus induction of J. Wesley Hall, of CT Consultants, and Paul Westlake, of Westlake Reed Leskosky, into the Hall of Fame. P

4

8

9

5

1 10

1 Mark “Rusty” Sherwood (FMI Center for Strategic Leadership), Brandon Davis (URS Corporation) and Ron Czaplicki (Barber & Hoffman, Inc.) 2 Dennis Wiseman and Bridget Johnson (Advanced Solutions) 3 Scott Vura and Jennifer Stull (Osborn Engineering) 4 Frank Loughan, Mike Lanese and Ron O’Neill (ARC) 5 Dave Eyssen (Precision Environmental Co.) 6 Jerry Hutchinson (PSI Engineering & Consulting) 7 Susan Davis (ESA Automation Services), Colin Wantz (The Mannik & Smith Group), Dan Sernicola (Osborn Engineering) and Tuwhanna Lewis (CES) 8 Larry Overbey (Properties), Lori Marlow (CES) and Ken Krych (Properties) 9 Aimee Pergalsky (Euclid Chemical) 10 Jason McKinney and Rebecca Florjancic (HzW Environmental Consultants)

1

2

3

Jerry Herschman, Mike Crislip, Carole Sanderson and Jud Kline (Herschman Architects Inc.)

Jud Kline Retirement Party Recently, a host of friends and colleagues celebrated the career and retirement of Jud Kline, of Herschman Architects Inc. Kline, noted for his work in retail, shopping centers and college housing projects, started his long relationship with Herschman Architects in 1976. Among leadership roles held with various associations over the years, he was past AIA Ohio president and AIA Cleveland president. Kline intends to spend time teaching and volunteering for youth educational groups. P 8

4

Canstruction Cleveland Over 17,000 pounds of food were provided to the Cleveland Food Bank recently as the result of the 7th annual Canstruction Cleveland design and build competition. Five company teams participated in this charity event at Beachwood Mall. Teams constructed sculptures from canned foods that were then donated. A dinner and awards event was held at Maggiano’s Restaurant in Beachwood. P

5 1 Merle Gorden (Mayor of Beachwood), Christopher Tadych (Christopher@ Architects), Jackie York and Bobby Mingus (Playhouse Square), Sarah Sinclair (NOW Consulting LLC) and Mehmet S. Turkel (Technical Assurance, Inc.) 2 Michael Crislip (Herschman Architects Inc.) 3 “Cleveland Rocks” (Domokur Architects) 4 “Fin The End of Hunger – Representing The Playhouse Square” (Emerging Green Builders) 5 Ann E. Long (S Rose Company), Merle Gorden (Mayor of Beachwood) and Amanda Romeo (Herschman Architects Inc.)

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


8

7

Au G O L D

Rubber. Now available in silver, platinum, copper and gold. Johnsonite® Metallurgy combines rubber flooring with modern metal aesthetics for a sleek, upscale look. Twelve different colors can be combined in bold and subtle ways for stunning metallic results. Then, coordinate the tile with metallic finishing borders, transitions and stair nosings for a complete flooring system that’s as practical as it is alluring. Johnsonite Metallurgy – cool elements of metal with the performance of rubber. That’s Balanced Choice. For more information, visit johnsonite.com.

2011

Ru

M E T A L L U R G Y

Distributed by

Sobol Sales Company

7KH %XLOGLQJ 2ZQHUV 0DQDJHUV $VVRFLDWLRQ RI *UHDWHU &OHYHODQG

<RXU 0RQH\ DYLQJ 5HVRXUFH zŽƵƌ ŝŶǀĞƐƚŵĞŶƚ ŝŶ KD 'ƌĞĂƚĞƌ ůĞǀĞůĂŶĚ ƉƌŽǀŝĚĞƐ ƐŝŐŶŝĮĐĂŶƚ ƌĞƚƵƌŶƐ ƚŽ LJŽƵ ĂŶĚ LJŽƵƌ ĐŽŵƉĂŶLJ͛Ɛ ďŽƩŽŵ ůŝŶĞ͘ DĞŵďĞƌ͛Ɛ ƌĞĐĞŝǀĞ ƐƵďƐƚĂŶƟĂů ƐĂǀŝŶŐƐ ĨŽƌ ƚŚĞ ĨŽůůŽǁŝŶŐ ŝƚĞŵƐ ĂŶĚ ƐĞƌǀŝĐĞƐ͗ ŝƌ &ŝůƚĞƌƐ x x ůĞĐƚƌŝĐŝƚLJ ^ƵƉƉůLJ x EĂƚƵƌĂů 'ĂƐ ^ƵƉƉůLJ x tŽƌŬĞƌƐ ŽŵƉĞŶƐĂƟŽŶ /ŶƐƵƌĂŶĐĞ >ĂŵƉƐ͕ ĂůůĂƐƚƐ Θ ůĞĐƚƌŝĐĂů ^ƵƉƉůŝĞƐ x x ŶĚ ŵĂŶLJ ŽƚŚĞƌ ŝƚĞŵƐ Θ ƐĞƌǀŝĐĞƐ͊ x WĂŝŶƚ Θ ZĞůĂƚĞĚ ^ƵƉƉůŝĞƐ

&DOO DERXW PHPEHUVKLS DQG VWDUW VDYLQJ WRGD\

dŚĞ ŵŝƐƐŝŽŶ ŽĨ ƚŚĞ ƵŝůĚŝŶŐ KǁŶĞƌƐ Θ DĂŶĂŐĞƌƐ ƐƐŽĐŝĂƟŽŶ ŽĨ 'ƌĞĂƚĞƌ ůĞǀĞůĂŶĚ ŝƐ ƚŽ ƉƌŽǀŝĚĞ ĂĚǀŽĐĂĐLJ͕ ƉƌŽĨĞƐƐŝŽŶĂů ĚĞǀĞůŽƉŵĞŶƚ͕ ŶĞƚǁŽƌŬŝŶŐ ĂŶĚ ĞĐŽŶŽŵŝĐ ƐĂǀŝŶŐƐ ŽƉƉŽƌƚƵŶŝƟĞƐ ĨŽƌ ŝƚƐ ŵĞŵďĞƌƐ͘

ϮϬϬ WƵďůŝĐ ^ƋƵĂƌĞ͕ ^ƵŝƚĞ ϮϬϵ͕ ůĞǀĞůĂŶĚ͕ KŚ ϰϰϭϭϰ ǁǁǁ͘ďŽŵĂĐůĞǀĞůĂŶĚ͘ŽƌŐ ƉŚ͗ Ϯϭϲ͘ϱϳϱ͘ϬϯϬϱ

www.propertiesmag.com 9


February Construction Slides 7% t a seasonally adjusted annual rate of $435.4 billion, new construction starts in February dropped 7% from the previous month, according to McGraw-Hill Construction, a division of The McGraw-Hill Companies. The loss of momentum was present in two of construction’s three main sectors – nonresidential building and nonbuilding construction (public works and electric utilities). Meanwhile, the housing sector in February continued to strengthen. For the first two months of 2013, total construction starts on an unadjusted basis came in at $62.4 billion, up 5% from the same period a year ago.

A

The February statistics lowered the Dodge Index to 92 (2000=100), down from 99 in January. For all of 2012, the Dodge Index averaged 99. “Over the past year, the construction industry has shown signs of renewed expansion, but diminished activity in January and February indicates that the upward trend remains hesitant,” says Robert A. Murray, vice president of economic affairs for McGraw-Hill Construction. “The broad pattern for construction starts is dependent upon the performance of its main sectors, and right now only housing is strengthening in a sustained manner. For nonresidential building, the commercial structure types are showing improvement, but the institutional side of the market is still being restrained by tight state and local budgets. For nonbuilding construction, the public works categories are dealing with flat-to-reduced funding support from the federal government, and new

electric utility starts are in the process of pulling back from the record pace reported last year. While total construction starts are expected to see more growth in 2013, the gain will likely stay gradual as a result of this divergent behavior by construction’s main sectors.”

Nonresidential building Nonresidential building in February retreated 6% to $139.7 billion (annual rate). The manufacturing plant category, which can be volatile on a month-tomonth basis, plunged 79%, given the absence of large projects reported as construction starts for the month. While January had included a $550 million methanol plant and a $235 million cellulosic ethanol plant, the largest manufacturing project reported as a February start was a $22 million chemical and gas products warehouse in Florida. For the institutional categories, education-related construction in February was unchanged from the

General Contractor Construction Manager Design/Builder Carpentry Contractor 440-746-9900 www.cqcohio.com 315 Ken Mar Ind Parkway Broadview Heights, OH 44147 10

previous month, at a pace down 6% from its average monthly amount during 2012. February did include several large education-related projects, such as an $83 million research laboratory in Cambridge, Massachusetts; a $75 million high school modernization in Auburn, Washington; and a $60 million renovation for the Boston University Law School building in Boston, Massachusetts, but these were not enough to lift the educational building category. Healthcare facilities construction in February slipped 5%, remaining at a lackluster volume despite the start of a $179 million ambulatory care center at Andrews Air Force Base in Maryland and a $97 million hospital renovation in New Orleans, Louisiana. The smaller institutional categories in February showed these declines – public buildings, down 10%; churches, down 12%; and transportation terminals, down 27%. The one institutional category that registered a February increase was amusement-related work, which rose 6%. The commercial categories in February witnessed a mixed performance. Office construction climbed 14%, boosted by several large projects. These included the $192 million Social Security Administration’s National Support Center in Urbana, Maryland; a $150 million office tower in New York, New York; and an $80 million technology center in Palm Bay, Florida. Store construction in February rose 12%, reflecting the start of a $150 million town center shopping mall in Sarasota, Florida. On the negative side, hotel construction in February retreated 19%. A steeper February decline was reported for commercial warehouse construction, which dropped 36%.

Nonbuilding construction Nonbuilding construction, at $98.1 billion (annual rate), plunged 32% in 3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


February. The electric power category fell sharply, plummeting 68% from its January pace, as February included the start of only one very large project – a $500 million transmission line in Minnesota and Wisconsin. After registering consistently robust activity during the first half of 2012, electric utility construction is now seeing more of an up-and-down pattern, indicative of an emerging downward trend. The public works categories overall in February dropped 25%, following the brief improvement in January. New highway and bridge construction starts in February were down 31%. River/harbor development also weakened in February, slipping 8%. At the same time, water supply construction in February edged up 1%, and sewer construction climbed 19% with the help of these projects – a $255 million waste water treatment facility in Colorado, a $182 million garbage transfer station in New York, and a $91 million waste water system in Florida. “Going forward, federal spending cuts under sequestration will restrain public works construction during 2013, although in a manner somewhat

different from the pattern of construction starts in February,” Murray says. “Transportation-related public works were largely exempt from the spending cuts, while the EPA water infrastructure and the Corps of Engineers accounts were subject to reduced funding.”

Residential building Residential building in February advanced 11% to $197.6 billion (annual rate), bouncing back after a modest pause in January and maintaining the upward trend that gained

traction during 2012. Multifamily housing had a particularly strong February, jumping 39% with the start of several very large projects – the $200 million multifamily portion of the Cira Center South project in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; a $200 million apartment building in New York, New York; and a $117 million residential tower at the Atlantic Yards development in Brooklyn, New York. Single-family housing in February rose 5%, continuing to strengthen on a wide geographic basis. By major region,

• Landscape maintenance contracts – extraordinary seasonal color plans • Landscape planting, design and installation • Irrigation installation & repair • Daily/weekly routine property inspection & maintenance

6LWH :RUN /DQGVFDSLQJ 3URSHUW\ 0DLQWHQDQFH 440-526-3257 • 330-239-1995 Fax 330-239-0265 4843 Ridge Road Wadsworth, Ohio 44281 www.propertiesmag.com 11


single-family housing in February showed gains in the South Atlantic, up 11%; the South Central and West, each up 4%; the Northeast, up 3%; and the Midwest, up 1%. “This year’s prospects for housing are bright, even with a sluggish economy,” Murray says. “The demand for singlefamily housing is picking up, as shown by the improvement in home sales and home prices, while inventories are currently very low. Multifamily housing continues to see rising occupancies and rents, and condominium projects are now joining

the upward path that’s already well-established for apartments.” The 5% gain for total construction starts on an unadjusted basis during the first two months of 2013, compared to 2012, was the result of a varied performance by major sector. Residential building led the way, climbing 32% year-to-date, with single-family housing up 35% and multifamily housing up 20%. Nonresidential building in the first two months of 2013 was down 7% from last year. While commercial building showed a year-to-date increase

It takes a little more than wishful thinking to get and keep your buildings in tiptop shape. It takes the experts from Technical Assurance that can outline and execute a strategy for assessing, planning, restoring, maintaining and managing all of your structures. It’s much better than just crossing your fingers in hopes of that nausty leak going away on its own.

of 20%, weaker activity was reported for the manufacturing and institutional segments, each down 20%. Nonbuilding construction during the first two months of 2013 dropped 9% from last year, as a 9% gain for public works was outweighed by a 53% decline for electric utilities. By region, total construction starts for the January-February period of 2013 revealed this behavior compared to last year – the Northeast, up 25%; the South Atlantic, up 12%; the South Central, up 10%; the Midwest, down 2%; and the West, down 10%. Useful perspective is also obtained by looking at 12-month moving totals, in this case the 12 months ending February 2013 versus the 12 months ending February 2012. On this basis, total construction starts were up 8%, as the result of the following performance by sector – residential building, up 31%; nonresidential building, down 8%; and nonbuilding construction, up 5%. By region, the 12 months ending February 2013 showed this pattern for total construction compared to the prior twelve months – the South Atlantic, up 19%; the South Central, up 14%; the Northeast, up 10%; the Midwest, up 9%; and the West, down 7%. P

The Road to Cleanliness Starts Here Ê ",Ê Ê "Ê "-/Ê* , Ê , Ê -- --

So uncross your fingers, and use them to

UÊ-Üii« } UÊ*ÀiÃÃÕÀiÊ7>Ã } UÊ-VÀÕLL } UÊ*>Ûi i ÌÊ,i«> ÀÃ UÊ-ÌÀ « } UÊ-> Ì }

/

UÊ- ÜÊ* Ü } UÊ ÃÌÀÕVÌ Ê- Ìià UÊ*>À }Ê Ìà UÊ*>À }Ê iV à UÊ7>Ài ÕÃià UÊ-«iV > Ê Ûi ÌÃ

dial this number to learn more about our

440. 953.3147

Five-Step program to sustainability and how it can lower your cost of ownership by extending the useful life of your buildings.

Co-founder of:

TECHNICAL ASSURANCE

- ViÊ£ ä

Assuring Building Enclosure Sustainability www.TechnicalAssurance.com 12

www.BEC-Cleveland.org

330-798-9200

ÜÜܰLÕV iÞiÃÜii« }°V

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


Building B uilding Owners Owners and a nd Managers Managers Asssociation sociation

B U S I N E S S ooff GGreater re ea ater C Cleveland leveland cies and estimated costs to correct them. Systems and components exhibit differing wear and tear conditions due to age, climate, use and frequency of maintenance schedule. Understanding the condition of n this latest recessionary era, corpo- assets in a facility portfolio enables more rations have challenged their facility accurate funding projections and minimanagers to improve the efficiency mizes the risk of unexpected and costly and effectiveness of facilities infrastruc- component failures. The next step is to implement a preture while staying within tight budgets. However, with limited resources the man- dictive maintenance and repair program. agers’ focus has been on responding to This allows managers to extend system life emergency situations, such as heating and cycles in order to push back capital renewcooling problems or roof leaks, rather than als as far as possible, and to make wise developing and achieving efficiency goals. capital renewal investments. “If facility managers take both these Deferred maintenance backlog lists have been growing longer. The lack of downtime steps, they will lower the total cost of and unfamiliarity with analytical tools to asset ownership,” Taylor says. “In addition, spreading out assess building system system life cycles will conditions has made “Unless the actual allow them to do more achieving efficiency condition of building with less.” even more elusive. If you are not familEd Taylor, president systems is known, iar with the condition of Technical Assurance Inc., addressed this managers are destined index, you will find issue in a recent pre- to stay in an increasingly information on the IFMA (International sentation to corporate and educational facili- costly reactionary mode.” Facility Management Association) and APPA ties managers at a Case Western Reserve University work- websites: www.appa.org and www.ifma.org. shop sponsored by APPA, an international Also, there are competent consultant association of educational institutions and members of BOMA Greater Cleveland their facilities and physical plant depart- who would be happy to assist. ments. He began by reminding attendees BOMA Greater Cleveland is proud to that unless the actual condition of building systems is known, managers are destined provide this space to our Associate Members to stay in an increasingly costly reaction- so they can inform, educate and share their ary mode. The only sustainable way to knowledge with property management profesimprove the efficiency and effectiveness sionals. This article was written by Mehmet of facility infrastructure is through a com- Turkel, director of business development and marketing at Technical Assurance, Inc. prehensive asset management program. As a first step, Taylor recommends (www.technicalassurance.com). Turkel can the development of a condition index be reached by phone at 440.953.3147 or email for each major building system (roofs, at mturkel@technicalassurance.com. façades, mechanical) based on actual inspection of the system. “If you do not know what you have, you cannot build a program of sustainability based on a strong foundation,” he says. “Otherwise it Janice Parham is all guess work.” Executive Vice President He explains that a condition index is BOMA Greater Cleveland designed to provide a record of deficien-

Improving Efficiency Starts With a Conditions Index

I

For more info on this article or BOMA Greater Cleveland, contact Janice Parham at 216.575.0305 or jparham@bomacleveland.org

Gain your competitive edge through CEA. Contractor Success Series The sessions target construction professionals offering best practices and tips to improve business operations.

Estimating Wednesday, April 17th, 2013 Overview of contractor process and role in estimating and bidding construction projects: reviewing plans and specifications, job costing, manpower and materials, takeoffs, how assembled, bid submission.

Financing & Surety for Construction Wednesday, May 8th, 2013 Understand the Banking and Surety markets, non-standard/secondary surety markets, “Fast track” markets based on business/ personal credit reports. Learn about Bid, Performance & Payment bonds, underwriting basics, hard to place bonds and Small Business Administration programs.

Accounting Wednesday, May 22nd, 2013 Review of contractor revenue recognition methods and accounting considerations. How to prepare and understand the work in progress schedule and produce meaningful job schedules for management.

Legal Series Construction Legal Matters | Presenter: Andy Natale, Frantz Ward LLP | June 6, 2013 Construction Delay Claims | Presenter: Tucker Elliott – VN Services | June 12, 2013 Employment, Labor & Health Care Law | Presenter: Jason A. Rothman - Ogletree, Deakins, Nash, Smoak & Stewart | June 19th, 2013

Join us | Register | Engage www.ceacisp.org | 216.398.9860 www.propertiesmag.com 13


Classic Comeback Public-private partnership successfully revives historic Union Building in downtown Cleveland By Jean Leathers | Photos by Jim Maguire

he Union Building was in sorry shape. In 2010, when Tom Kuluris, president and owner of Liberty Development Company, walked through the eight-story building at 1836 Euclid Avenue in downtown Cleveland, the historic property had been vacant for more than six years.

T

Pigeons had taken up residence inside and atop the building, a falcon had nested in the penthouse and a tree was growing out of the exterior mortar on the 8th floor. Storefronts had been made flush with the building’s façade, creating an uninspiring pedestrian experience. Upper story windows had been covered in to make them smaller, and various forms of tile masked the original beauty of floors, ceilings and façade. Liberty Development wasn’t the only developer in town to recognize that the bones of this forlorn structure were still solid and worthy of reuse. Several others had reimagined the Union Building as residential apartments; none were able to arrive at financial models to resuscitate the building and create a positive return on investment. It would take a trust-based, publicprivate partnership between Cleveland State University (CSU) and Liberty Development to bring the Union Building back to life.

A partnership in the making The relationship between Liberty Development and CSU began in 2006 when Kuluris reached out to the CSU Foundation to learn more about an opportunity to propose on the North Campus development. While the company ultimately decided not to pursue the project, the inquiry led to a tour of the University during which he expressed an interest in looking for investment opportunities. Over the next several months, Kuluris developed a relationship with John “Jack” Boyle III, then chief financial officer of CSU, building a connection that would lay the foundation of the public-private partnership. After investigating the Union Building, Liberty Development decided to acquire the property. While the building had been looked at for redevelopment into an apartment or condo project, it became 14

SIGNIFICANT SUPPORT Availability of historic tax credits was crucial in making redevelopment financially feasible at the Union Building, constructed in 1914.

clear very quickly that converting the building to residential wouldn’t work. “We did our due diligence and the math confirmed that the building did not make sense financially as a residential property,” Kuluris says. “There’s no parking and you couldn’t get the rents needed to afford the mortgage. It just didn’t work.” Knowing how focused Boyle and CSU President Ronald M. Berkman were on campus development, Kuluris shared his interest in developing the Union Building

with them, sparking the beginning of a highly collaborative relationship. Boyle immediately began looking at space that CSU was renting off campus. He identified a number of departments and functions that would benefit from being located on campus. Still, the project had to work financially. While residential use had been ruled out, as an office building it was hard to ignore the fact that downtown vacancies would make creating a competitive rent rate challenging. 3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


BETWEEN THE WEATHER & YOU SINCE 1922

WARREN ROOFING WARREN ROOFING AND INSULATING COMPANY

3URXG WR EH SDUW RI WKH SURMHFW WHDP DW 7+( 81,21 %8,/',1* ZLWK 3DQ]LFD &RQVWUXFWLRQ

440.439.4404

Commercial/Industrial Roofing + Architectural Sheet Metal

Fax 440.439.7523

www.warrenroofing.com

3DQ]LFD LV SURXG WR EH SDUW RI WKH 8QLRQ %XLOGLQJ WHDP

%HWD 'ULYH 0D\¿HOG 9LOODJH 2+ _ _ ZZZ SDQ]LFD FRP

&RQVWUXFWLRQ 0DQDJHPHQW

'HVLJQ %XLOG

*HQHUDO &RQWUDFWLQJ www.propertiesmag.com 15


A. Gershen, president of Northeast Ohio Medical University (NEOMED), to the Union Building for a walkthrough. The timing was right and NEOMED is now occupying two floors for medical education. “A lot of people at CSU made this project come together – the board was incredibly supportive, President Berkman, Jack Boyle and then Stephanie McHenry who became CFO after Jack retired, the Facilities Department, the Planning Department… the list could go on,” Kuluris says. “The partnership wasn’t about money, or about signing on a line. It was working together to make this project happen and we achieved that result.” RETRACING STEPS Original building elements were restored throughout the building, from the terra cotta exterior and storefront to terrazzo staircases (above) and corridors.

The key was the Ohio Department of Development. Historic tax credits effectively brought rents to market rates, making the project financially feasible. According to Kuluris, “everyone wanted to see this project bring people back to campus, so we just kept working with Jack on the rent. We kept finding ways to increase operational efficiencies. We got great architectural work from Arkinetics, and Thorson Baker, our engineers, introduced systems that maximized return on investment. The tipping point though was working with Arkinetics to garner historic tax credits. We had invested the equity, but if it wasn’t for the tax credits, we couldn’t have gotten this done.” Ty Stewart, principal and director of development at Liberty Development, oversaw construction management. He selected Panzica Construction to serve as CM, thus bringing the final critical team player to the table.

Bill Davis, vice president and senior project manager at Panzica, says about being selected, “We met with Tom three or four times, looking at options and sharing information based on the Tom’s experiences and our experiences. We just developed a deep sense of trust really quickly.”

The nature of the partnership Public-private partnership models can take many forms, with the common denominator being a partnership between a public sector entity and a private party to provide a public service or project. While some partnerships are contractual, the relationship between CSU and Liberty Development is not. Liberty Development owns the building and CSU is a tenant. Kuluris describes the relationship as a working partnership. For example, it was President Berkman who brought Jay

Architectural history preserved Arkinetics Architects + Urbanists provided great care in restoring original building elements that stand testimony to the building’s heritage: terrazzo staircases and corridors, and the beautiful exterior terra cotta and storefront. Thorson Baker & Associates served as consulting engineers. The MEP consultant designed a leadingedge HVAC system, and state-of-the-art communications and information technology infrastructure. As construction managers, Panzica worked closely with Liberty and Arkinetics to set appropriate allowances, interview contractors and develop contracts that were acceptable to everyone. Dan Barney, principal at Arkinetics, served as the project architect, while Gary Fischer, also principal at Arkinetics, contributed a focused eye on historic preservation. They worked together from a photograph of the Union Building taken around the time of its opening to restore the building’s exterior to its

office industrial retail hospitality restaurant historic preservation Architect and Interior Designer at The Union Building, a historic preservation project providing university departments for Cleveland State University and the first Cleveland home for NEOMED. Cleveland 216.749.7800

16

Lorain 440.246.3100

arkinetics.com

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


ADDING OFFICES The building now houses space for various Cleveland State University administrative functions, including the Enrollment Services, Health Services, Counseling, Financial Aid, Registrar and Treasurer departments.

original state, as it had been altered in many ways. The first story of the façade had been covered with granite tile. When removed, the terra cotta was severely damaged, so many of the pieces were recast and reinstalled. In the 1950s, the original storefronts were torn out and reconfigured. Doors were in different locations, and upper windows had been blocked in and covered with unsightly red fabric awnings. Through the restoration, new storefronts once again offer an inviting street-level presence. Doors have been relocated to their historic entry places. Pedestrians walking by on the street will now experience welcoming, newly enhanced retail space. “Because the original storefronts extended farther out onto the sidewalk, we had to replicate the terrazzo,” Davis says. “We incorporated the address into the terrazzo at the entranceway, just as it had been originally. It’s a nice touch.” The other significant architectural feature quite noticeable on the façade is the reopening of previously brickedin transom windows on the first floor. Original windows on the second floor

were refurbished and insulated glazing installed. All other windows have been restored to their original larger sizes. To satisfy historic preservation requirements, the new windows are

wood construction. They are operable and utilize self-cleaning, energy efficient glass. According to Dave Panzica, project manager, the team saved thousands of

Precision Environmental has reached our 25th anniversary as an abatement, selective demolition and specialty services company serving Northeast Ohio. Thank you to everyone who has contributed to the success of our company for the past 25 years.

We look forward to working together for many more years to come.

5500 Old Brecksville Road • Independence, OH 44131 216.642.6040 • www.precision-env.com

www.propertiesmag.com 17


0DOW] 0XVHXP RI -HZLVK +HULWDJH

0DQGHO -HZLVK &RPPXQLW\ &HQWHU

7+( $5($·6 ),1(67 '(6,*1(56 $1' $5&+,7(&76 $/:$<6 &+226( 681752/ )25 7+(,5 0267 35(67,*,286 352-(&76 (QHUJ\ 6DYLQJ :LQGRZ )LOPV 2SDTXH 3ULYDF\ )LOPLQJ 6FUHHQV /RJRV &XVWRP *UDSKLFV 6HFXULW\ )LOP

6 8 1 7 5 2 / 7KH /HDGHU ,Q (QYLURQPHQWDO 'HVLJQHU *ODVV )LOP

0DQGHO -&& (QWUDQFH

ZZZ VXQWURO FRP &RPPHUFLDO ƒ 5HVLGHQWLDO ƒ 5HWDLO /((' &RQWULEXWLQJ 3URGXFWV 6HUYLQJ 2KLR )RU 0RUH 7KDQ <HDUV

:KDW GRHV %,0 PHDQ WR \RX" %,0 FDQ EH PDQ\ WKLQJV²JUHHQ LQWHJUDWHG D SURFHVV D WHFKQRORJ\ D WHFKQRORJ\ %XW DOO \RX FDUH DERXW LV \RXU %,0 \RXU WHDP DQG \RXU FOLHQWV FOLHQWV $OO ZH FDUH DERXW LV PDNLQJ %,0 ZRUN IRU \RX 5HYLW 1DYLVZRUNV DQG )DFLOLWLHV 0DQDJHPHQW H[SHUWV WV ,PSOHPHQWDWLRQ WUDLQLQJ WHFKQLFDO VXSSRUW²LQ SHUVRQ RU RQOLQH RQ RU RQOLQH WR %,0 DQG ,0$*,1L7 &ODULW\ IRU $XWRGHVN 5HYLW 6HUYHU 6FDQ WR %,0 DQG ,0$*,1L7 8WLOLWLHV IRU 5HYLW 3URGXFWLYLW\12: 3RUWDO SURYLGHV VXSSRUW H/HDUQLQJ IUHH IUHH 8WLOLWLHV DQG DQ DFWLYH FRPPXQLW\ 7KH 3URGXFWLYLW\12: 3RUWDO KDV 2: 3RUWDO KDV FRQWHQW IRU HYHU\RQH ZLWK DGYDQFHG IXQFWLRQDOLW\ DYDLODEOH RQO\ WR DLODEOH RQO\ WR ,0$*,1L7 FOLHQWV 7R JHW VWDUWHG RU DVN D TXHVWLRQ FDOO RXU &OHYHODQG RI¿FH ¿FH DW RXU &ROXPEXV RI¿FH DW RU RU YLVLW LPDJLQLW FRP

18

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


OPEN TO ACCOMMODATE The University Registrar is equipped with spacious third-floor offices, including low-set workstations and ample views to outside windows.

dollars by being persistent at creating a solution for the historic windows. “We mocked up four full-size windows and reviewed them with Arkinetics and the State to create a solution that allowed us to keep the original frames and introduce new windows,” he says. “Matching the existing glass size was a critical element in the preservation. Not only did we save on materials, we eliminated the need for masonry infill that new windows would have required.”

Inside, the once dark and dingy lobby has been freshly painted to historic colors, including the decorative arched ceiling. Chandeliers have been cleaned and repaired, as were the ornamental iron railings. The original terrazzo flooring, which had been covered up with tile and carpeting, has been exposed, restored and polished. A glass security wall was designed to replace a metal fence midway up a staircase from the lobby to the second floor.

Only those with a keycard can gain access through the entry point, which is nearly transparent. A nice touch is a gallery space designed along the walls of the rear entry to the building. Spot lighting provides the right level of illumination for ongoing exhibitions. The infrastructure throughout the building is completely new. The building had no air conditioning. Thorson Baker incorporated one of the most

>L HYL WYV\K [V IL WHY[ VM [OL [LHT MVY [OL <UPVU )\PSKPUN YLUV]H[PVU WYVQLJ[

9,:<3;: @6< *(5 :;(5+ 65 :WLJ[YH *VU[YHJ[ -SVVYPUN PZ [OL JVU[YHJ[ PU[LYPVY PUK\Z[Y`»Z TVZ[ JVTWYLOLUZP]L ]L JVTTLYJPHS ÅVVY JV]LYPUN YLZV\YJL :7,*;9( ISLUKZ [OL ÄUHUJPHS Z[YLUN[O [O VM )LYRZOPYL /H[OH^H` ^P[O [OL PUUV]H[P]L WYVK\J[Z VM [OL PUK\Z[Y`»Z KVTPUHU[ THU\MHJ[\YLYZ HKKZ L_WLYPLUJLK JVTTLYJPHS ÅVVYPUN WYVMLZZPVUHSZ ;OPZ JVTIPUH[PVU WYV]PKLZ \UWHYHSSLSLK YLZV\YJLZ HU [` L_JLW[PVUHS KLNYLL VM ÄUHUJPHS Z[HIPSP[` ¶ `V\Y HZZ\YHUJL [OH[ ^L»SS Z[HUK ILOPUK OPUK `V\Y WYVQLJ[ MVY `LHYZ [V JVTL

216-901-5710 www.spectracf.com

www.propertiesmag.com 19


SHAPING UP In CSU’s Advancement Offices for Planned Giving, a backlit, elliptical recessed ceiling feature adds aesthetic interest.

efficient HVAC systems available with Variable Refrigerant Flow (VRF) technology. The building is now completely sprinklered, and new energy efficient elevators have been installed.

NEOMED spatial programming With NEOMED occupying two floors, a lot of programming effort was dedicated to working with them to create successful learning spaces. Bruce Taylor, managing partner of

Arkinetics, worked with Jeffrey Susman, M.D., dean of the NEOMED College of Medicine and professor of family medicine, and Mark A. Penn, M.D., then senior vice president for Academic Affairs at CSU and executive associate dean at NEOMED, to develop the spatial program and design for their space. “CSU came into the space generally knowing which departments would be relocating and what each would need

in the new spaces,” Taylor says. “The situation was different with NEOMED. We helped them to create a program for the simulation-based, interactive learning methodology the institution uses. We worked very closely with them to help formulate what they were going to do in the space.” For example, to meet the need for flexibility, a large lecture room can be partitioned into smaller spaces to accommodate groups of up to 10

Let our PERFORMANCE help your bottom line

PERFORMANCE PAINTING )%( 6%( ('*( &HUWLÀHG FBE City of Cleveland

SBE Cuyahoga County

Proud to be part of the team at the UNION BUILDING

Commercial, Institutional & Industrial Painting Contractor Serving all of Northeast Ohio • Interior/Exterior Painting • LEED Projects • Female-Owned Enterprise

• Wallcovering • Historic Preservation • Epoxy Flooring

• High Performance Coatings • Rigid Wall Protection • White Boards

7603 First Place Suite 3B Oakwood Village, OH 44146 Q 440-735-3340 Q F: 440-735-3341 Q Performpaintllc@aol.com 20

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


students. Mock exam rooms are oversized to make room for instructors and additional students observing the doctor-patient interactions. The space is designed to simulate a real medical experience. Students start with instruction in one of the various group rooms, then move to the Physical Diagnostic Laboratory (PDL) where they initially practice what they have learned on a medical simulation mannequin, then assume the role of a care provider in a mock exam room with a volunteer who acts as a patient. To practice the art of patient diagnosis, the student acting as the doctor interviews the patient actor, listens to the patient describe symptoms, and then prescribes treatment. All of the rooms are equipped with cameras so that professors and students can continue to learn from the experience.

Alignment & transparency Ask Kuluris what he thinks gave Liberty Development the ability to succeed with the Union Building project when others had been unsuccessful and he’ll answer: alignment and transparency. “The right parties all came together at the right time,” he says. “CSU had a need, we were looking for our next project, NEOMED was interested in space, the State of Ohio and federal government provided tax credits, and Arkinetics really understood what the project needed. There was a tremendous amount of trust and alignment of interest among all the team players – people really came together as partners, each making a personal commitment to see that this project happened.” The other key was transparency. The key players on the team had formal meetings every two weeks including CSU, Liberty, Arkinetics and Panzica. “Everything was on the table,” Panzica says. “Cost, allowances, details, issues. Everyone had access to all the information about the project, which really keep the project on track and moving smoothly.” According to Kuluris, “A lot of people have the idea that developers are only driven by the bottom line. Not all developers are like that. We were transparent with CSU about the numbers, and we kept working to lower the rent versus increasing our profit. I’d much rather have a higher hit rate

NEW LIGHT An existing skylight was uncovered and updated to illuminate a transition area linking former garage space with the renovated lobby.

at getting things accomplished than a smaller ratio where we’re making more money on each.” “I’ve been a Clevelander all my life,” Kuluris adds. “There’s no way to describe the value of what it feels like to have an idea in your head and to watch it come alive. Seeing construction folks in here working, taking home paychecks, taking care of their families. I think, ‘Wow, there was a time when this idea was in my head and now people are going to work here everyday, or to teach and learn here everyday.’ It’s really gratifying.”

Barney makes the same point as he describes what it’s like to drive past a project he helped to design and restore. “As for the Union Building,” he says, “this was a feel good project, for sure.” The pigeons had been evicted, wildlife officials removed the falcon, and the tree growing from the 8th floor mortar has been replanted in front of Liberty Development’s offices. The dilapidated building has undergone a thorough makeover, revealing its rich architectural heritage and opening its doors to a whole new generation of Clevelanders. P www.propertiesmag.com 21


^^^ [OVTHYPVZ JVT


Communal Spirit Lutheran Metropolitan Ministry, North Presbyterian Church team to enhance outreach By John Elliott | Photos courtesy of Studio Techne

roviding services to people who are homeless and disadvantaged has long been an important calling to Lutheran Metropolitan Ministry (LMM) of Greater Cleveland. As the need for these services continues to grow, LMM has taken a major step forward in meeting its mission with the completion of its modern, newly renovated building at 4515 Superior Ave., at the corner of Superior Avenue and East 45th Street.

P

The 41,000-square-foot Richard Sering Center, named after the organization’s founder, has a welcoming exterior, featuring large windows and a gridded, metallic canopy that slopes like a curtain across the front of the building. Inside, the clients have access to counseling and support services provided by an 80- to 90-member staff who carry on LMM’s 44-year-old mission of providing assistance to the most forgotten members of the community. The completion of the project, totaling $5 million in construction costs, allowed LMM to relocate from its previous 26,000-square-foot building at 1468 West 25th Street. The new space also houses the new 4,400-square-foot North Presbyterian Church, a mission project of the Presbytery of the Western Reserve, which relocated to the LMM building from a 125-year-old church five

blocks away at East 40th Street and Superior Avenue. This newly renovated building allows the two organizations to work together in providing services to people who are disadvantaged. The two organizations have separate entrances on Superior Avenue. The North Presbyterian Church portion consists of a two-story, bronze-colored exterior building standing in contrast with the metallic exterior Richard Sering Center. Both organizations are designated by distinct large signs above their entries. A landscaped walkway and parking area sets the Richard Sering Center 40 feet back from Superior Avenue, giving passing cars an ample view of the contemporary-looking building. “Through the generosity of many, LMM is able to expand our presence in the community with a seven-day-a-week

service center,” notes Rev. Richard Gahl, chairman of LMM’s board of directors. “The Richard Sering Center has strengthened LMM’s ability to fulfill its mission of service and advocacy with people who are oppressed, forgotten and hurting.” With five branches, LMM serves and advocates with youth at risk, people involved in the criminal justice system, vulnerable adults, people in need of employment, and people who are homeless. Every year, LMM serves with more than 10,000 people, with the help of hundreds of partners. LMM prepared 250,000 meals in 2012 for its shelters, and this year will serve more as the organization has contracted to provide meals for additional homeless shelters. LMM’s 21-member board of directors realized the need for a larger building several years ago, and in 2007 the organization hired a consultant to assess www.propertiesmag.com 23


reliable & local Photo by Ken Krych

CALL OUR COMMERCIAL SALES MANAGERS TODAY, TO DISCUSS YOUR ELECTRIC SERVICE NEEDS

Wes Tarver: 216.664.3922 ext.145 Kim Smith: 216.664.3922 ext. 253 VISIT US AT WWW.CPP.ORG

CREATIVE COVER A gridded, metallic canopy provides shade while adding visual interest to the front of the building.

fund raising capabilities, notes Robert P. Kirschner, vice president of development and communications. The board set a fund raising goal of $5.5 million. LMM ultimately raised $5.6 million for the project. Cleveland Development Advisors (CDA), an affiliate of Greater Cleveland Partnership, provided an $8 million federal and a $2.75 million Ohio New Markets Tax Credit (NMTC) allocation for the new building, which brought $1.7 million to the project. The NMTC program provides tax credit incentives for equity investments in certified community development entities, which invest in low-income communities. These tax credits generated enough equity to bring LMM to more than 100% of its goal. “Lutheran Metropolitan Ministry has a phenomenal track record of helping members of our community in need,” says Steve Luca, managing vice president of CDA. “The addition of an innovative social enterprise program being created by LMM will positively influence the future of both economic and community development for Northeast Ohio.” LMM also received assistance during the funding process from Betsy Figgie, a consultant at Cleveland-based Your CFO Resource, which assists non-profit organizations with funding; legal counsel from Cleveland-based Ulmer & Berne LLP; and accounting support from San Francisco, California-based Novogradac & Co. LLP. The Cleveland-based Gund Foundation awarded a $1 million capital grant to the project. “We helped structure the transaction so that new market tax credits could be used, which actually made this project possible,” says Mary Forbes-Lovett, partner with Ulmer & Berne LLP. “In 24

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


EXISTING INFLUENCE Much of the building infrastructure was salvaged and reused: steel columns, wood beams and the exposed wood roof deck. Original concrete floors were cleaned and stained a mottled, dark grey.

this case it was substantial, representing approximately $2.75 million of the total $8 million dollar transaction. It made the project viable so it could move forward.”

Search committee defines need To meet the community’s increasing needs, the LMM search committee

determined that it needed to find a larger building that was easily accessible to public transit. Plus, the building needed to have sat vacant for a certain period of time to qualify for new market tax credits. After two years, the committee identified the former National Key

Co. building on Superior Avenue, a two-story steel frame building with wood beam deck, as an ideal property. The building was owned by a clothing manufacturer that had ceased operations, leaving the facility unused for about 10 years. The building contained no extensive heating, ventilating and

2TQWF VQ DG RCTV QH VJG VGCO CV VJG .WVJGTCP /GVTQRQNKVCP /KPKUVT[ 4KEJCTF 5GTKPI %GPVGT

CONTAINER SERVICE, INC.

¸;OL 3LHKLY PU *VU[HPULY :LY]PJL¹ -), *:) ,+., *,9;0-0,+

>>> 7,;,(5+7,;,05* *64

@6<9 *65:;9<*;065 :7,*0(30:;: .9,,5 3,,+ 7961,*;: @(9+ -965; 36(+ *65;(05,9: @(9+ 96336-- *65;(05,9: www.propertiesmag.com 25


Photo by Ken Krych

INVITING ENVIRONMENT Prevalent use of glass, soft seating and exposed ceiling throughout serve to create an open and welcoming atmosphere for clients and staff alike.

air conditioning system, and it was not insulated. This ensured the design team would be able to come up with a user-friendly and efficient interior work space. “It was essentially empty inside, a blank canvas,” notes Marc Ciccarelli, a principal of Studio Techne, the design firm for the project. Cleveland-based

Studio Techne has a long history designing buildings for the religious community and non-profit agencies, and began working with LMM on this project in 2009. The purchase also included a parking area across the street and an adjacent building for future use. This building will provide space for new business enterprises

,QVWDOOLQJ $ 1HZ 9LHZ )RU /LIH

( 5 )O\QQ &R *O *OD]LQJ &RQWUDFWRUV

Serving Northeast Ohio for over 45 years, we are proud to be part of the team at Lutheran Metropolitan Ministry's new Richard Sering Center

( WK 6W &OHYHODQG 2+ ZZZ IO\QQFRPSDQ\ QHW 26

not suited to the main building. The open land may be used for urban gardening and future expansion.

Church steps forward During the planning process, one LMM board member, Rev. Henry C. Doll, a retired Presbyterian minister, immediately saw the opportunity to involve the North Presbyterian Church in the project. Doll helped organize support from 25 Presbyterian congregations around Northeast Ohio. With total gifts from the Presbytery and Presbyterian congregations exceeding $350,000, the partnership led to a stronger, more economical and more ecumenical project. In addition to having the church occupy part of the new building, the two organizations share the kitchen for their meal programs. “It’s a really nice relationship that helped move this project along,” Kirschner says. According to General Presbyter Rev. Liza Hendricks, “it’s important in this era for people of faith to work together and for all of our different communities to find ways to collaborate to make a difference in the world. This 3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


5HGXFH <RXU 6WRUPZDWHU 3URSHUW\ &RVW

. 1948 EST

65 Yea r s

/DQGVFDSH DQG ,QGXVWULDO 6XSSO\

Proud to have provided the interior general trades for LMM Richard Sering Center & North Presbyterian Church with Thomarios

Sterling Professional Group 5531 Turney Road Garfield Heights, Ohio 44125 (216) 475-7670 www.propertiesmag.com 27


Photo by Ken Krych

JOINT MISSION In addition to the Richard Sering Center, the project provides a new home for North Presbyterian Church in an adjacent 4,400-square-foot structure.

project is a wonderful way for us to join together to do something that alone we can’t do.”

Construction/design team evolves For construction, Studio Techne suggested Akron-based Thomarios, a construction firm which had worked with Studio Techne on the Wolstein Center parking deck downtown. LMM named Thomarios a Construction Manager At Risk, an arrangement by which Thomarios held all contracts and committed to deliver the services for a set payment. The board wanted an open and welcoming building, in both the exterior

and interior design. Universal accessibility was also a critical component of the design. The design removed the first 40 feet of the warehouse to allow for drop-off and accessible parking. Glass curtainwall was installed to provide views of the activity inside the structure. On the inside, partitions are arranged to provide interactions among staff and maintain an open and welcoming environment for both clients and staff. “[LMM] didn’t want to be secluded,” Ciccarelli says. “The design focused on providing an open, comfortable and welcoming environment where clients and staff can genuinely meet and discuss difficult issues.”

HVAC ■ Plumbing ■ Fire Protection ■ Process Piping ■

28

“All of the work done in this building depends on effective interactions between staff and clients,” adds Tim Roos, project manager for Studio Techne. This is in keeping with the late founder Sering’s management philosophy. “It is designed for utilization by staff partners,” notes Megan Billow, LMM associate vice president of development and communications. “It is comforting and welcoming for program participants.” Construction lasted about one year and was completed in the winter. George Brkich, Jr., project manager for Thomarios, notes that the trades worked well together and the project met its budget goal. Much of the building infrastructure was salvaged and reused: steel columns, wood beams and the exposed wood roof deck. Original concrete floors were cleaned and stained a mottled, dark grey. The existing sprinkler system was modified and extended to coordinate with the new building layout by SA Comunale Inc. Designed to achieve LEED Silver certification, the renovation added many energy-saving features. The built-up roof system was removed and replaced with insulation and a white TPO membrane. To ensure adequate daylight reached every space in the building, 64 solatubes were installed, along with a system of sensors to turn off the LED lights when required.

Proud of our involvement at Richard Sering Center with Thomarios 800-776-7181 www.sacomunale.com

“Large Enough To Meet Your Needs, Small Enough To Care” 3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


During the construction phase, Thomarios, in cooperation with Laborers Union Local 310, hired LMM personnel as part of the union’s apprenticeship program, providing training in demolition, masonry, carpentry and electrical skills.

Most of the client services are provided on the first floor, with a central commons area, a food prep area, offices and conference rooms. The second floor has administrative offices and additional conference rooms. The main entrance has a vestibule leading to the reception area, which welcomes visitors with recycled barn siding and an immediate view of the lobby, its orange and grey cushioned seating, white painted structure and angled, floating drywall ceilings. The ceilings and most interior walls are white, along with blue, green and brown accents. A café overlooks Superior Avenue with a serving counter made from zinc, and the building’s past is captured in counters and stairways made by repurposing the maple tops of the sewing tables. The commons area adjacent to the lobby has tables and chairs where people can eat or hold meetings. A food prep area separated from the lobby by a glass partition serves dual purposes: to provide meals and to allow LMM to train people in culinary skills as part of its social enterprise program. Marking the entrance to the main hallway in the lobby is a wood wall made from pieces of 60-year-old Douglas fir, on which glass plates will be mounted to honor donors. The wood was salvaged from beams removed by A Piece of Cleveland, a group that creates building materials from recycled materials. “This is unique – it has a story and history of the building,” notes Kirschner. “It will be historical and beautiful.” A new open stairwell and elevator at the east end of the commons allows access to the second floor. The stair treads are made from refurbished sewing tables inherited from the clothing manufacturer previously located in the space.

Photo by Ken Krych

Accessible to clients

NEW ANGLES A stylized ceiling in the church sanctuary incorporates suspended triangular panels composed of medium-density fiberboard.

Thanks to a collaborative effort between the Dominion Foundation and the city of Cleveland’s Economic Development Department, Metro Metal Works is producing and installing bicycle racks throughout Cleveland. “Cleveland is becoming a more bikefriendly city,” Kirschner says.

Space for North Presbyterian Church North Presbyterian Church has its own entrance on Superior Avenue. The church entrance leads to a hall between the wall that separates the church from the Richard Sering Center and a glass wall that allows visitors to immediately view the church sanctuary. There are various wall decorations welcoming visitors in this hallway, along with a decorative tree trunk brought from the original church. The space was a collaboration of Marc Manack, of Silo AR+D, and Kurt Weaver, of AKW Inc., whose desire was to create a special sacred space for the

church meeting area. Instead of doing something simple, they worked in special windows and a unique ceiling to accent the space instead of just a plain acoustic ceiling. “We wanted the design to be creative, interactive and functional with plenty of light – something to draw you to the space,” Weaver says. Without a lot of space to work with, the team was able to design a chapel area that can also be broken up into smaller meeting spaces with partitions, an office, classroom and separate inviting entrance way.

Working together LMM and North Presbyterian Church have joined together in a new and improved facility. They will continue their missions to allow the most forgotten members of the Greater Cleveland community to access services that will help them survive and possibly be able to one day take care of themselves. P

3URXG WR EH SDUW RI WKH WHDP DW WKH /XWKHUDQ 0HWURSROLWDQ 0LQLVWU\ 5LFKDUG 6HULQJ &HQWHU

Vocational projects The building provides additional space for one of LMM’s more ambitious vocational programs, Metro Metal Works, which designs, manufactures, sells and installs bicycle racks.

Phone 440.526.1200 | Fax 440.526.1270 10275 Brecksville Road, Brecksville, OH 44141 www.propertiesmag.com 29


LEGAL PERSPECTIVES Navigating property laws & regulations

Cuyahoga County Raises Stakes on Contractors n an apparent effort to reverse its past history of lax oversight of its public improvement procurement process, Cuyahoga County recently passed a new law that will prevent contractors, subcontractors and suppliers from doing business with the County for various misdeeds.

I

IAN FRANK

The County’s “Debarment Law” (Ordinance No. O2012-0026) comes in the wake of the Cuyahoga County corruption scandals and the subsequent overhaul of the County government. The Debarment Law, however, is most notable for its expansive reach over conduct that does not involve fraud, bribery and criminal activity, but rather encompasses potentially legitimate oversights and even good faith contractual disputes. The Debarment Law permits the County to prevent a company from working on its projects for a period of one to five years. If debarred, a contractor may not submit any bids, proposals or make any other offers to contract or do business with Cuyahoga County for the debarment period. The contractor also is prohibited from serving as a subcontractor on any County project. There is a hefty price to pay as well (three-year automatic debarment) for subcontracting with a company that is known to be debarred. The County website will include a link to the list of debarred contractors, including the relevant debarment period, maintained

by the County’s Inspector General, who is charged with enforcing the new law. The maximum five-year period that a contractor may be barred by the Inspector General is reserved for convictions or civil judgment arising from fraud or criminal activity in connection with obtaining or performing a public contract; violation of ethics or antitrust laws; collusion; theft, forgery or tax evasion; and similar conduct involving “a lack of business integrity or business honesty that seriously and directly affects the present responsibility of a contractor.” The Inspector General, though, can debar a contractor for three years based upon a “reasonable belief” that the contractor violated a public contract or subcontract “in a serious manner,” failed to pay prevailing wages, failed to cooperate in monitoring contract performance by refusing to provide information or failing to respond to complaints, or “any other cause determined by the Inspector General to be sufficiently serious and compelling so as to represent lack of good faith or responsibility by the contractor.” The Inspector General can also institute a three-year

Custom Reprints Make a Great Impression Did you know you can now order custom reprints of articles originally published in Properties? Imagine the impact of a customized publication – a profile on your company or a project with which you were involved – that can be distributed to your existing and future clients. Use reprints as a proven, effective marketing tool to build your business.

Call 216.849.4350 today for a free quote! 30

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


ban for a contractor’s violation of the terms of a Small Business, Disadvantaged Business, Minority and Female Business Enterprise program or “any other similar program.” This could include other localities’ diversity-based programs or even resident employment requirements, such as the City of Cleveland’s Fannie M. Lewis Resident Employment Law. Finally, the Inspector General can debar a contractor for a period of 18 months based upon a “reasonable belief” that the contractor breached or violated any contract with the County. The County can hold a contractor responsible for the acts of any individual or entity that has a “substantial interest” in the company. The definition of “substantial interest” though sets the bar low. It includes anyone with at least 5% ownership or control of the company; any officer, director or manager of the company; any parent, subsidiary or affiliate of the company; and anyone that provided various forms of financial support. Consistent and even-handed implementation of the Debarment Law will be problematic based on its expansive scope, the substantial discretionary authority given to the Inspector General, and the ambiguities inherent in the language chosen by the County. Criminal activity such as fraud, bribery and theft are all clearly understood and likely admonished by any reputable company. Unfortunately, the catch-all language used in many provisions, coupled with the absence of clear definitions and lack of precedent interpreting this language, make it difficult to discern what conduct will fall within the law’s prohibitions. Consequently, it may be difficult, if not impossible, for contractors to modify their behavior to entirely avoid the law’s reach. Consider a situation where a contractor is pursuing an extension of time and added costs for delays that were outside of the contractor’s control, and the County disputes this position. This is a fairly common scenario on any construction project. Under these facts, the County considers the contractor in breach for failing to complete the project on time. Will the County now have the right to debar that contractor for 18 months, or even three years, rather than relying on the remedies spelled out in the contract? Will the contractor be forced to waive a good faith claim to avoid being blackballed? What happens if a court or arbitrator later determines that

the contractor was right after it has been debarred? Is the contractor entitled to be compensated for its inability to pursue County projects? What is clear now is that contractors must be cognizant of the increased risk of working on County projects. The Debarment Law creates the opportunity to exert substantial leverage in the event of disagreements relating to project performance. Companies must create and maintain clear documentation of their communications and project developments. They should also ensure that their internal policies and procedures regard-

ing acceptable conduct are explicit and communicated in writing to all of their employees. Finally, contractors should routinely check the County’s website and maintain copies of the debarred contractors list to confirm that any subcontractors were not debarred at the time of subcontracting. P Ian H. Frank is a partner in Frantz Ward LLP’s Construction Law Group in Cleveland, Ohio, where he dedicates his practice to representing contractors, subcontractors, suppliers, construction managers, developers, design professionals, and sureties.

When Quality Counts, Count on Delta.

Providing Industrial Cleaning, Painting & Maintenance with Quality & Service that is Second to None. INDUSTRIAL CLEANING & MAINTENANCE • Hot pressure / steam cleaning • Waterproofing and sealing • Parking deck cleaning, painting, and striping • Overhead cleaning / painting • Exterior and interior building cleaning • Industrial oven cleaning • Dust collector cleaning • Pigeon / bat excrement removal • Graffiti removal

• Roof fan and ventilator cleaning • Industrial exhaust system cooling and heating coil cleaning • Kitchen exhaust system and kitchen equipment cleaning • Machinery cleaning / painting • Welding exhaust cleaning • Construction clean-up or restoration of property for sale and leasing

INDOOR AIR QUALITY • HVAC system cleaning & sanitizing • Air duct cleaning • Mold remediation

Contact Delta Industrial today! 216-281-8700 5201 DENISON AVE., CLEVELAND OHIO 44102 www.propertiesmag.com 31


CABOR CORNER Issues in the real estate industry

Opposing Expansion of Sales Tax to Services ecently, the Cleveland Area Board of Realtors (CABOR) announced its opposition to the expansion of the Ohio sales tax to services.

R

In February, Ohio Governor John Kasich released a $63.3 billion dollar, two-year budget proposal, which included a 20% reduction in the state income tax; a reduction in small business tax for LLC, S corporations, partnerships or sole proprietors; as well as a 0.5% decrease in the state sales tax. To offset the cuts, under the budget proposal, the sales tax would be expanded to services – including real estate services – in Ohio, with the exception of a few areas (education, medical, funeral services, home construction, residential rents, and some insurance). The Ohio Association of Realtors (OAR) allocated significant resources to reviewing the proposal and the impact it would have on a variety of real estate professionals. The OAR announced its opposition to expansion of the sales tax base to services, including those involved in a real estate transaction. CABOR joined OAR in its opposition to expansion of the sales tax base.

JOANNE ZETTL

At a time when the real estate recovery in Northeast Ohio is still in its infant stages, additional costs to real estate transactions would add financial burdens that could be devastating. CABOR believes that the recent market turnaround could be derailed by the imposition of a sales tax on every aspect of a housing purchase, including home inspections, appraisals, mortgages, warranties, radon inspections, title searches, commissions and more. This is not something that will only affect residential real estate professionals. A sales tax on commercial rent leases poses a threat to future economic development by adding to the cost of business operations in Ohio. “The impact to commercial property owners will be dramatic,” CABOR member Vicki Maeder (CBRE) says. “The costs for services to operate apartment buildings or office, retail or industrial buildings for cleaning, snow removal, lawn services and management fees – to

EDUCATIONAL EQUIPMENT Serving Cleveland and Northeast Ohio Since 1936 We are specialists in: • Operable Panel Partitions • Accordion Doors • Chalk/Marker Boards • Bulletin Boards • Trophy & Display Cases • Signage • Directories SALES

INSTALLATION

SERVICE

845 Overholt Rd., P.O. Box 154, Kent, Ohio 44240 — Phone (330) 673-4881 Fax ((330) 673-4915)

32

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


name a few – will all be charged a sales tax. Even the commercial rent that they pay will be taxed. While the leases may allow a pass through to the tenants of these extra fees in their net charges, it could be a problem for some tenants to pay, which could hurt small business.” In Ohio, a State Budget must be in place by July 1. As such, this will be a fast moving process, and we encourage our members and consumers to contact their State Senator and Representative, and to stay informed as this legislation progresses. As always, the CABOR staff is happy to assist with any questions you may have. P Joanne Zettl is the Chairwoman of the Cleveland Area Board of Realtors (CABOR). CABOR is the voice of real estate in Northeast Ohio, serving the community, real estate professionals who sell real property, and businesses that work in or with the real estate industry. CABOR provides a variety of services to its professional members including education, insurance, affinity programs and legislative representation, as well as membership in the Ohio Association of Realtors (OAR) and the National Association of Realtors (NAR). For more information, visit www.CABOR.com.

Light is Life! Light Bulb Supply Company carries a full line of commercial grade lighting products you need! • Decorative • Ballast • Batteries • Energy Saving Fixtures • Starters • Capacitors • Incandescent • Low and high voltage lamps • Fluorescent: Energy Saving T5, T8, T12 Standard, HO and VHO. • Halogen: MR11, MR16 , Compact fluorescent. • LED, Sign lamps, HID: Metal Halide, High Pressure Sodium, Mercury Vapor. • Specialty: Lenses/ Tube Guards, Miniatures, Stage/studio, Reprographic/Projector lamps,

J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc.

Sockets, Wire connectors. • No minimum order required.

• Commercial Buildings • Construction Sites • Special Event Clean-Up • Concrete Cleaning • Carpet Cleaning • Window Cleaning • Wall Washing

5 2 2 5 W 1 4 0 t h S t re e t | B ro o k Par k , O H 4 4 1 4 2

• Acoustical Ceilings

216 898 1111 | 800 247 8752 | f ax 216 898 0700 1230 East Schaaf Road Brooklyn Heights, OH 44131

216-749-1150 www.jvjanitorial.com www.propertiesmag.com 33


NAIOP NEWS Commercial real estate happenings

NE Ohio Office Market Activity Update s reported, 2012 had the highest volume of investment transactions in the commercial real estate market since 2007, both in Northeast Ohio and nationally. With interest rates continuing to bottom out, 2013 looks to be at least as active, if not more so, than 2012. According to a recent economic forecast by the Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, interest rates will stay down as long as the national unemployment rate stays above 6.5%. Below that figure, the Federal Reserve would slowly raise interest rates by 0.25% increments as unemployment continues to decrease.

A

THOMAS GUSTAFSON

PHILLIP BADALAMENTI

34

Following the recent financial crisis, a few different types of activities have become prevalent or are picking up momentum. With the supply of troubled CMBS and alternatively financed assets still feeling the distress, investors have many opportunities to acquire income producing properties with moderate yields. Local banks have portfolios of commercial properties that need to be introduced to investors so they can be purchased at attractive pricing. For holders of financially healthier assets, refinancing of loans at more attractive, longer term rates are, in many cases, keeping more desirable properties off the market. In certain niche markets where those attractive assets are not available, demand has created new development most certainly recogniz-

able in the multifamily, office and industrial sectors. New suburban and rehab CBD is steadily increasing with more projects. Speculative multifamily in the Cleveland CBD is not yet happening, but is close. Building speculatively in the office and industrial sectors is premature according to many; however other discussions say the industrial market is ripe for speculative development in the 75,000- to 150,000-square-foot size range.

On another note Northeast Ohio assets are a great marketing tool. The state boasts one of the lowest unemployment rates in the country. Fresh water is our most valuable resource and can, and should, be an attraction for heavy water users in the manufacturing sector. In speaking with other Midwest and East Coast

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


investors and users, it’s apparent that Cleveland has more going on than any other metropolitan area. It’s no surprise considering the presence of Greater Cleveland’s density of innovative biotech and medical institutions and $3.5 billion in new development. The downtown Cleveland residential market is booming with 1,165 additional residential units becoming available in the next 18 months. This activity should help to promote office tenant growth in the CBD. The City of Cleveland is a national model city as a source for financial incentives to retain and attract tenants and developers for redevelopment and new development projects. Other Tier 2 cities have visited and toured Cleveland in attempts to understand the great success stories underway.

IQ Advisors, LLC Owner Representation & Independent Advisory Services for Building Projects & Sustainability Initiatives

Tim Panzica, LEED AP President timpanzica@iqadvisorsllc.com 216-469-0512

www.iqadvisorsllc.com

Office Market Summary Seven County Area Cleveland, Akron and Suburban Markets The entire seven county area’s office inventory is about 144 million square feet with an overall vacancy of 12.1%, down from 12.2% in the previous quarter. Rental rates ended 4Q 2012 at $16.80 per square foot, an increase from $16.62 per square foot in the previous quarter. The Cleveland Office Market ended 2012 with 754,225 square feet of positive net absorption. New construction is being completed on three buildings during Q1 2013, delivering 710,100 square feet of office space to the market. At year end, 1.2 million square feet was under construction. Downtown Cleveland In Downtown Cleveland, Geis Companies was awarded the County Headquarters office development of 230,000 square feet located at East 9th Street and Euclid Avenue. The project also includes the redevelopment of the Ameritrust Tower into approximately 80 apartments and 150 hotel rooms under a yet to be named brand. The historically preserved Rotunda in combination with 1010 Euclid will put approximately 50,000 square feet of office into the downtown market by its scheduled completion in mid-2013. The 450,000-square-foot Flats East Bank office tower will be receiving its approximately 350,000 square feet of

A SENSIBLE SOLUTION TO STORMWATER MANAGEMENT Porous Asphalt Pavements provide an innovative approach to detain or infiltrate storm-water runoff. The design of POROUS ASPHALT PAVEMENTS allows water to flow through them. They are: •

Economical – fast, easy to construct and long lasting

•

Sustainable – conserves water, reduces runoff, improves water quality, replenishes aquifers, protects streams, cooler cities

•

Safer – imagine never again stepping in a puddle of water or on an ice covered surface

For more information, contact Flexible Pavements of Ohio at (888) 4HOTMIX or visit our website at www.flexiblepavements.org.

6205 Emerald Parkway, Suite B, Dublin, Ohio 43016 • www.flexiblepavements.org Twitter: @Ohio_Asphalt • www.facebook.com/flexiblepavements

www.propertiesmag.com 35


new tenants including Ernst & Young and Tucker Ellis-West by June 2013. The Aloft Hotel and five restaurants will come online shortly afterward. The Global Center for Health Innovation, formerly the Medical Mart, is a $465 million joint venture by Cuyahoga County and MMPI and will provide 120,000 square feet of permanent showroom space for manufacturers and service providers of medical devices, equipment, imaging and healthcare IT, focusing on an array of healthcare specialties. Seventy

percent of the permanent showroom space is leased. Additionally, 375,000 square feet of high quality, high ceiling exhibit space and 100,000 square feet of meeting, seminar and panel discussion space will hold its first event July 15. The facility can accommodate multiple events simultaneously. Other office projects being presented and discussed are the Burke Lakefront Office development of approximately 200,000 square feet on 20 acres, the ninestory, 120,000-square-foot Class A Intesa office building at University Circle and

the lakefront, mixed-use development north of First Energy Stadium. Midtown Corridor The Midtown Corridor connects downtown Cleveland with world class institutions such as the Cleveland Clinic, University Hospitals, Case Western Reserve and Cleveland State University via the Euclid Health Tech Corridor. It is home to manufacturing companies, distribution and warehouse operations, a mix of live/work buildings, a large car dealership, restaurants, the Asian Plaza, the Midtown Technology Center and an entire collection of predominately commercial users. There are several new developments underway in the Midtown Corridor, centering to a large extent on healthcare and technology, but also with office, residential and entertainment projects. These new developments include the Agora complex, Midtown Park, Tyler Village, Midtown Technology Center (expansion), Victory Center, Baker Building, the Cleveland Police Precinct and the Frost Building.

Don’t miss these upcoming events: • 4/23 Tuesday: NAIOP of Ohio Legislative Day, 11:30 am – 5:30 pm, The Athletic Club of Columbus.

Rocksolid Stone Works H:GK>C<

COMMERCIAL CONSTRUCTION | ARCHITECTS | INTERIOR DESIGNERS For over 30 years, Rocksolid Stone Works has been serving northern Ohio commercial markets with complete design, fabrication and installation of granite, quartz, natural stone, solid surfaces and woodwork. Our convenient Cleveland location has everything you need to meet any type of surfacing project - from the most exotic retail space to large commercial projects. To learn more, call 216-251-5509 or visit RSWSTONE.COM

:(67 7+ 675((7 _ &/(9(/$1' 2+,2

36

• 5/8 Wednesday: Awards of Excellence, 3:30 – 7:00 pm. Location: Windows on the River. • 6/10 Monday: 20th Annual Charity Golf Outing, 9:00 am 6:00 pm, Weymouth/Fox Meadow Country Clubs • 8/1 Save the date: NEW Developers’ Showcase, 3:00 pm 7:00 pm, Flats EastBank For additional information on these events, to sponsor, or to register, contact Donna Haders at (440) 899-0010 or djh@wherryassoc.com. P

Thomas K. Gustafson is senior vice president and principal, Cleveland, at Colliers International. Phillip D. Badalamenti, AIA, is architect/sr. project manager at Herschman Architects and is editor of NAIOP News. He can be reached at pbadalamenti@herschmanarchitects.com. 3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans

OLA ‘Landscape Ohio!’ Awards Event Recognizes Top Efforts in State he Ohio Landscape Association (OLA) recently held its 16th annual “Landscape Ohio!” Awards, honoring the best of the best in residential and commercial landscaping throughout the state. The awards dinner was held at the Cleveland Botanical Gardens with participants from around Ohio. Designed to increase the awareness of quality landscaping and how it improves our environment, the “Landscape Ohio!” Awards event is an annual competition that recognizes and applauds designers, LANDSCAPING LEADER The Brickman Group was installers and property owners. This year, honored with a Commercial Installation & Honor 40 projects were recognized in a total of 16 Award for Columbus Commons (Columbus, OH). different categories. The evening also included the presentation of OLA’s Lifetime Dedication and Outstanding Contributions to the Landscape Industry Award. This year’s recipient was David Richards, CLT, Horticulture Science teacher at Auburn Career Center in Concord Township.

T

MBI | K2M Architecture Announces Recent Additions MBI | K2M Architecture, Inc., recently announced key hires in its Cleveland office, located in historic Ohio City. The team has hired Geoff Varga as Director of Architecture and Debbie Andrews as Accounting Specialist. Varga provides over 35 years of valuable experience, having designed and man-

aged a multitude of projects within Northeast Ohio. He has worked closely with the Cleveland Metropolitan School District, NASA, Cleveland Metropolitan Housing Authority and University Hospitals to name a few. Most recently, he was the director of architecture for a local firm, and spent several years on the teaching staff for University of Detroit School of Architecture.

Andrews joins the firm’s administrative team as an accounting specialist, bringing vast experience within the A/E field.

National Law Publication Recognizes CBRE as Top Firm The National Law Journal, a leading publication serving the legal profession, has ranked CBRE Group, Inc. the number one commer-

cial real estate services firm nationally for representing law firm tenants. The ranking, which was featured in the March 25th publication, was derived from votes by its national readership base of in-house and private practice attorneys and other lawrelated professionals. The CBRE Global Law Firm Practice Group is an industry-specific corporate advisory group dedicated to servicing law firms and their real estate portfolios, with more than 50 law firm industry experts covering major, secondary and emerging law markets worldwide.

NAI Daus Elects Pacella as Managing Partner, Promotes Brokers to Partners NAI Daus recently announced that it has elected Alec Pacella as the firm’s new managing partner, effective immediately. Two other brokers from within the ranks of the firm have been promoted to partner and include Scott Garson and William Sadataki. The actions were unanimous among the firm’s partners.

www.propertiesmag.com 37


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans

With 24 years of experience in real estate investment strategies, Pacella is a three-time winner of NAIOP’s Investment Deal of the Year. He was named to Crain’s ‘Forty Under 40’ in 2005 and was appointed as an associate instructor for the CCIM institute. He succeeds Robert Brehmer, who will continue to serve as a majority partner of NAI Daus, focusing his efforts on client relations. Scott Garson leverages his 24 years of commercial property experience to represent tenants and landlords in leasing and sales in a wide range of product types, including office, warehouse, manufacturing, retail and land.

William Sadataki has been actively involved in industrial real estate for 25 years. He specializes in the acquisition and disposition of significant industrial properties.

CES Inducts CT Consultants VP to Hall of Fame CT Consultants recently announced that Wes Hall, P.E., LEED AP has been selected as a recipient of the Cleveland Engineering Society 2013 Hall of Fame Award presented at the CES 61st Annual Design and Construction Conference in March. The Cleveland Engineering Society Hall of Fame Award is the highest award given to an individual by the Society.

Wes Hall

It is presented to an engineer for the purpose of honoring his or her outstanding achievements or career in the field of engineering, architecture, construction, or related areas for the betterment of professional efforts beyond the day-to-day

routine of a candidate’s work and business with outstanding contributions to the profession, the public welfare, and/or humankind. As CT’s Vice President of Civil Engineering and Land Development, Hall is responsible for the management of staff and projects for a wide variety of public and private sector clients. He is a member of the firm’s Board of Directors and he serves as Corporate Secretary.

South Russell Home Earns LEED Platinum Certification The Treehouse Project, the name given to a local resident’s custom home project, was recently awarded with LEED Platinum cer-

Space Comfort co. )$0,/< 2:1(' 23(5$7(' :,7+ +$1'6 21 (;3(5,(1&( ,1 0(&+$1,&$/ &2175$&7,1* 6$/(6 6(59,&( 6,1&( ([SHUWV LQ Q 7XUQNH\ VROXWLRQV GHVLJQ EXLOG YDOXH HQJLQHHULQJ Q 6HUYLFH LQVWDOODWLRQ PDLQWHQDQFH RI DOO PDNHV PRGHOV RI +9$& HTXLSPHQW ERLOHUV Q 1HZ UHQRYDWLRQ UHPRGHOLQJ UHVWRUDWLRQ Q 3XEOLF SULYDWH 3URYLGLQJ UHOLDEOH SHUVRQDO VHUYLFH WR RZQHUV RI UHWDLO FHQWHUV PDOOV DSDUWPHQW FRPSOH[HV UHWLUHPHQW KRXVLQJ LQ 2KLR QHLJKERULQJ VWDWHV

5201 CLARK AVENUE, CLEVELAND OHIO 44102 Q PH. 216-281-2000 Q FAX. 216-281-8420 Q 800-203-9645 38

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


Complete Glass Experts Family-Owned & Operated for 60 years! Specializing in: • Commercial Glass and Glazing • Aluminum Doors & Storefronts • Custom Sandblasted “Etched” Glass with Clearshield • Bullet Resistant Glass & Polycarbonate • Custom Frameless Shower Doors, Mirrors & Glass Table Tops

Free Commercial Estimates 24 Hour-Board-Up Service phone 216-621-1971 | fax 216-621-6602 www.sandgloglass.com 2316 St. Clair Avenue | Cleveland, Ohio 44114

*LDPEURQH &RQVWUXFWLRQ )XOO 6HUYLFH :%( )%( *HQHUDO &RQWUDFWRU

*LDPEURQH 0DVRQU\

0DVRQ 6WRQH ,QVWDOODWLRQ 5HSDLU

8QLYHUVDO 6FDIIROGLQJ

5HQWDO /HDVH 6DOH RI 4XDOLW\ 6FDIIROGLQJ

ZZZ *LDPEURQH FRP $NURQ &OHYHODQG $XURUD +XGVRQ 5G +XGVRQ 2+

!30(!,4 0!6).' !30(!,4 2%0!)2 3%!,#/!4).' #2!#+ &),,).' #/-0,%4% 3)4% #/.3425#4)/.

0!6 ) . ' ) . # s %XCELLENT QUALITY COMPETITIVE PRICING RELIABILITY

%8#!6!4)/. 4/ #/-0,%4)/.

s #UNNINGHAM 0AVING IS A FAMILY OWNED BUSINESS WITH OVER YEARS OF EXPERIENCE s ,ICENSED BONDED INSURED s /UR MOTTO h+EEPING OUR CUSTOMERS SATISFIED KEEPS THEM COMING BACK v

* iÊӣȰxn£°nÈää >ÝÊӣȰxn£°nÈnÎ !URORA 2OAD 7ARRENSVILLE (EIGHTS /( www.propertiesmag.com 39


)DEULFDWLRQ ,QVWDOODWLRQ 6HUYLFH

The Chas. E.

Company

Q

HDUV L HU \

RY QJ IRU L ] L O D L F 6SH WRS U HG URRI J D RW ZDWH N F K D 3 P GLQJ ¥ VWHD ZHO Q R L W D F %RLOHUV UL HWDO IDE HOGLQJ 6KHHWP ULFDWLRQ Z IDE W 3ODVWLF HHULQJ DUWPHQ Q S L H J G Q H H F 9DOXHG H PDLQWHQDQ UYLF )XOO VH

$GKHVLYHV $QFKRUV %DFNHU 5RG %RQGLQJ $JHQWV &RQFUHWH &OHDQLQJ &RQFUHWH &RDWLQJV &RQFUHWH 5HSDLU &RQFUHWH 6WDPSV &RQWURO -RLQWV &XULQJ &RPSRXQGV 'DPSSURRILQJ 'HFRUDWLYH &RQFUHWH 'UDLQDJH &RPSRVLWHV (ODVWRPHULF &RDWLQJV (SR[\ 5HVLQV (SR[\ -RLQW )LOOHUV ([SDQVLRQ -RLQWV )LUHVWRSSLQJ )ODVKLQJ )RUPLQJ 7XEHV

ZZZ OLVFRKYDF FRP 6WDWH 5G 1 5R\DOWRQ 2+

&/(9(/$1' :LOORZ 3NZ\ &OHYHODQG 2+ )D[

4XDOLW\ 3URGXFWV 7HFKQLFDO ([SHUWLVH 7UXVWHG 6HUYLFH *UDIILW &RQWURO 6\VWHPV *URXWV ,QMHFWLRQ *HOV 0DVRQU\ $FFHVVRULHV 0DVRQU\ 5HLQIRUFHPHQW 0DVRQU\ 5HSDLU 0DVRQU\ &OHDQHUV 0RUWDUV 3RO\ILOP 3URWHFWLRQ %RDUGV 5HOHDVH $JHQWV 5LJLG ,QVXODWLRQ 6HDODQWV &DXON 6HDOLQJ &RPSRXQGV 6KDNH +DUGHQHUV 7UHQFK 'UDLQ 8QGHUOD\PHQWV 9DSRU %DUULHUV :DWHU 5HSHOOHQWV :DWHUSURRILQJ &$1721 72/('2

ZZZ FKDVHSKLSSV FRP

0HVVLQD )ORRU &RYHULQJ //&

Commercial, Institutional & Industrial Floor Covering Provider & Installer Specializing in the healthcare marketplace with the highest quality & best service since 1989. We provide 24/7 service, installation and flooring maintenance. Call us today to take advantage of our trained in-house staff and extensive library of product information. Complete line of flooring including: Carpeting • Resilient Flooring, Vinyl & Ceramic Tile • Athletic Floors

Call today for a FREE estimate! 4300 Brookpark Rd., Cleveland, OH 44134 • 216-595-0100 • Toll Free 888-271-8200 40

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


BILLBOARD News about people, products, places & plans

builder that was recently recognized as the 2012 Builder of the Year by the Home Builders Association of Greater Cleveland. Other team members on the project included AODK Architecture and Design Within Interior Design.

The Albert M. Higley Co. Announces Hires “The Treehouse Project” in South Russell

tification by the U.S. Green Building Council for achievement in green homebuilding and design. LEED for Homes is a green certification program that rewards homes that are designed and built to be energy- and resource-effi-

cient and more healthy and durable for the occupants. The Treehouse Project is the first custom home in Northeast Ohio to achieve the LEED Platinum certification. The home was built by Payne & Payne Builders, an area home-

The Albert M. Higley Co. recently announced new hires and promotions within the company. Kathy Heflin, CPA joins the firm as Chief Financial Officer. She brings experience from spending the past 11 years at a national technology-enabled marketing services company.

Dionne Kuykendall, CPS/ CAP who joined the firm in 2011 as a project administrator, has accepted promotion to the recently created position of Subcontractor Relationship Advocate. Amanda Kline, who began working as a Co-Op for the firm in 2011, joins as a Project Engineer. Grace Sauline, a current Co-Op with the firm, has accepted a position as Project Controls Engineer. Cory Schiebel, a 2012 graduate of Slippery Rock University, joins the company’s Safety Department as Safety Manager. Zac Burgess, a 2012 University of Akron graduate, joins the company as a Project Engineer. P

We’re not your ordinary commercial landscapers. We’re LandsKeepers.

LandsKeepers Five

Star Landscape & Property Care

440.338.8200 15533 Chillicothe Rd. Novelty, OH 44072

/RFDWLRQV (DVW :HVW WR 6HUYH \RX %HVW LandsKeepers is a Pattie Group sister company

www.propertiesmag.com 41


FINANCIAL STRATEGIES Smart use of fiscal planning & action

Getting Saucy grew up in an Italian family, which meant that food was the centerpiece of every family event. Whether a wedding, a birthday party or a holiday gathering, there was never a shortage of food. All of my aunts would contribute and, of course, everything was homemade. Except for my Aunt Norma’s lasagna. It wasn’t actually the lasagna that was the problem – it was the sauce. You see, much to the rest of my aunts’ chagrin, Aunt Norma used Prego, whose famed tag line is “it’s in there.”

I ALEC J. PACELLA

This month, we are going to discuss the most basic component of a cash flow model – the lease. Similar to Prego, the net cash flow is the result of many individual components of the lease that are “in there.” Listed below are the most common of these components, including the specific impact on the resulting net cash flow:

Rent This is the largest and most influential component of the net cash flow – akin to the tomato in the sauce. There are two important items that need to be determined with regards to rent. First is the lease structure – specifically what portion of the rent that is apportioned to operating expenses.

If the lease is pure “net,” meaning that the tenant is directly responsible for the payment of all operating expenses, that is one extreme. And if the lease is pure “gross,” meaning that the tenant makes a single payment that includes all operating expenses and associated occupancy costs, then that is the other extreme. The norm is somewhere in the middle, with rent including a portion of operating expenses and the tenant being responsible for the rest. The second item is lease escalations. Although some leases are flat, meaning that the rent does not change over the life of the lease, most leases contain some provision for increases in rent over time. Sometimes the amount of these increases is precisely stated while other

%QPETGVG 5CYKPI CPF &TKNNKPI 2TQHGUUKQPCNU # &K)GTQPKOQ %QORCP[

9CNN 5CYKPI 5NCD 5CYKPI 9KTG 5CYKPI %QTG &TKNNKPI

5JQV $NCUVKPI )TKPFKPI 5JQTKPI 0GGFNG $GCOKPI %QPETGVG 4GOQXCN 4GRNCEGOGPV +PVGTKQT $WKNFKPI 'ZECXCVKQP )TQWPF 2GPGVTCVKPI 4CFCT 0'9

5RGEKCNV[ GSWKROGPV RTQXKFKPI GOKUUKQP CPF FWUV HTGG QRVKQPU KPENWFKPI XQNV OKPK GZECXCVQT RTQRCPG RQYGTGF DQDECVU CPF *'2# ſNVGTGF CKT ſNVTCVKQP FGXKEGU 1NF $TGEMUXKNNG 4QCF +PFGRGPFGPEG 1JKQ RJQPG Ŗ HCZ

YYY RTGEKUKQPRTQEWV EQO 42

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


Daus, You Know? VARYING VALUE Lakewood Center North, a 258,000-square-foot office building in Lakewood, recently traded for $3.4 million. It last sold in December 2006 for $14.5 million. –AP times, the amount of the increases is tied to some type of index.

Free rent Tenants are sometimes given a full or partial reprieve on the payment of rent for a period of time. This can take various forms, perhaps several consecutive months at the beginning of a lease term or one month each year of the lease term. Whatever the stated arrangement, the net impact is a reduction of the tenant’s overall occupancy cost.

Pass-thru expenses This includes charges incurred by the landlord that are forwarded to the tenant. For example, the landlord may pay the real estate taxes associated with the property and then require the tenant to pay back their share. This is called a “direct pass-thru.” Or the landlord may be subject to an increase in the gas bill over time due to rising rates and require the tenant to pay the amount of this increase. This is called an “escalation pass-thru.” When determining a net cash flow, it is critical to understand what expenses the tenant is paying directly, what expenses the landlord is paying directly and what expenses the landlord is paying and then passing on to the tenant for reimbursement.

Operating expenses This item is directly related to the rent and pass-thru components highlighted above. But regardless of who makes the actual payment, the tenant is ultimately responsible for the payment of operating expense, either directly in the form of a net lease or via pass-thrus or indirectly in the form of a gross lease.

:PVS /VNCFS 0OF 4PVSDF GPS "MM :PVS 1BWJOH /FFET /FX *OTUBMMBUJPOT Š 3FTVSGBDF 8PSL Š .JMMJOH Š 3FQBJST 4FBMDPBUJOH Š 4USJQJOH Š (SBEJOH Š &YDBWBUJPO

'SFF &TUJNBUFT BOE 3FDPNNFOEBUJPOT 8<(30;@ 05;,.90;@ *647,;0;0=, 790*,:

Additional income This component includes any additional charges that a tenant will incur that are associated with their occupancy, such as parking and, for retail tenants, overage rent.

Tenant improvements Although there are instances of a tenant leasing a space “as-is,” with

MJDFOTFE Š CPOEFE Š JOTVSFE

9V`HS[VU 9VHK 5VY[O 9V`HS[VU 6OPV ^^^ 7YLTPLY(ZWOHS[7H]PUN JVT www.propertiesmag.com 43


no changes in the configuration or replacement of carpet and paint, it is much more common for the landlord to perform alterations and improvements to the space. When analyzing the net cash flow of a lease, this cost is typically recognized at the beginning of the lease.

Amortized tenant improvements Landlords will usually limit the amount of money they are willing to spend on improvements associated with a specific lease but tenants will

sometimes want additional improvements, in excess of what the landlord is willing to provide. This extra cost can be paid for directly by the tenant or by the landlord who is then repaid by the tenant. In the case of the latter, it is typically treated as a loan, with the tenant paying it back over the term of the lease at a stated interest rate.

Leasing commission A lease will usually have an associated commission due that is based either on the aggregate value of the

lease or on a per-unit basis. Similar to the cost of tenant improvements, this cost is also recognized at the beginning of the lease. Once all of these components are identified and properly accounted for, a net cash flow model for the lease can be developed. All of the associated income and expense are laid out over the duration of the lease. I have posted an example of this analysis on my blog (http://blog.sbequitiesinc.com) but there are some common measurements that are usually considered.

Total Effective Rent This is a single number that represents the total value over the life of the lease. It simply is an aggregate that nets out all of the outflows (expenses, cost of improvements, leasing commissions, other concessions, etc) against the inflows (rent, amortized improvements, additional charges, etc).

Average Annual Effective Rent This is the Total Effective Rent, over the entire term of the lease, divided by the number of years in the lease term.

Average Annual Effective Rate This is the Average Annual Effective Rent divided by the square footage of the leased premises.

Discounted Effective Rent *HQHUDWLRQV RI 6HUYLFH ,QWHJULW\

This is the sum of all discounted cash flows over the entire term of the lease, with the cash flows discounted to the present value at either the tenant or the landlord’s discount rate. Evaluating a lease is a lot like tastetesting sauce. It may look good and sound good but unless you have a solid understanding of all of the components, it’s very hard to tell how it will taste. And, just for the record, I really liked my Aunt Norma’s lasagna. P

Alec Pacella, CCIM, senior vice president at NAI Daus, can be reached by phone at 216.455.0925 or by email at apacella@naidaus.com. You can follow him on twitter @dausyouknow or on his blog at http://blog.sbequitiesinc.com.

44

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


VANTAGE POINT Experts weigh in on industry issues

Far-Reaching Effects of ‘Cherryland’ he Ohio Legacy Trust Act (the “Act”) became effective as of March 27, 2013. The Act includes multifaceted borrower-friendly provisions modifying various aspects of Ohio’s debtor-creditor, property and trust laws. One portion of the act that may have far-reaching effects for commercial real estate lenders and borrowers in Ohio is a prohibition of insolvency (or “Cherryland”) carveouts for nonrecourse loans.

T BRYAN J. DARDIS

A nonrecourse commercial real estate loan is a secured mortgage loan under which the borrower and its principals are not personally liable for the indebtedness. Generally speaking, if a borrower defaults on a nonrecourse loan, the lender’s recovery is limited to the collateral securing the Loan. This differs from traditional recourse real estate loans under which, in addition to the first position mortgage, lenders

can generally seek recovery against the borrower and guarantors for the full amount of the Loan. Most nonrecourse commercial real estate loans contain certain “carveouts,” which impose some level of personal liability upon the borrower and guarantors if certain events occur. For example, most nonrecourse loan documents contain socalled “bad act” provisions of the principals (such as fraud, misappropriation of funds,

www.propertiesmag.com 45


and failure to pay taxes or insurance) under which borrowers and guarantors have personal liability for losses resulting from these acts. In addition to the bad act provisions, nonrecourse loans often include other covenants imposing personal liability on nonrecourse borrowers and their guarantors upon the occurrence of certain events such as the bankruptcy or insolvency of borrower.

In Wells Fargo Bank, NA v. Cherryland Mall Limited Partnership, a Michigan appellate court interpreted nonrecourse insolvency carveout provisions and ruled that a guarantor was personally liable for the entire deficiency judgment of a loan as the result of the borrower’s insolvency. The Cherryland case had far-reaching implications for commercial real estate lenders and bor-

Parking Planning, Design & Consulting Parking Technologies Parking Assessment & Studies Signage Programming Design/Build Services

5455 Broadview Road, Suite 202, Parma, OH 44134 www.graelic.com 216-335-9910

*6473,;, -09, 796;,*;065 :,9=0*,:

s Fire Extinguishers, Fire Alarms, Fire Sprinklers, Exit/Emergency Lighting, Kitchen Fire Suppression, FM-200/Halon/ CO2 Systems s Division 10 fire extinguishers and cabinets to construction trades

^^^ JV\U[` ÄYL JVT

s Fire protection contracting services to property owners/ managers

(2965 *3,=,3(5+ *63<4)<: ;63,+6

rowers, and was subject to significant discussion. Since projects that are in the foreclosure process are generally, by nature, insolvent, the Cherryland result essentially turned defaulting projects containing the insolvency carveouts into recourse loans. In response to the Cherryland decision and its aftermath, the Michigan legislature enacted laws prohibiting post-closing solvency covenants as a nonrecourse carveout, effectively reversing Cherryland.

The Ohio Legacy Trust Act Ohio law had not previously addressed the Cherryland issues directly. With the enactment of the Act, however, the legislature cuts off any attempt to enforce insolvency carveouts in nonrecourse real estate loans. The applicable provisions in the Act (Ohio Revised Code Sections 1319.07 through 1319.09) state that a post-closing solvency covenant shall not be used, directly or indirectly, as a nonrecourse carveout for the basis of any claim or action against a borrower or any guarantor of a nonrecourse loan. The Act further states that any such provision is invalid and unenforceable. The Act defines “post-closing solvency covenant” as “any provision of the loan documents for a nonrecourse loan, whether expressed as a covenant, representation, warranty, or default, that relates solely to the solvency of the borrower including, without limitation, a provision requiring that the borrower maintain adequate capital or have the ability to pay the borrower’s debts, with respect to any period of time after the date the loan is initially funded.” Covenants not to file or collude in a voluntary bankruptcy or insolvency proceeding are expressly excluded from the definition.

Effect of law The most direct effect of the Act is to eliminate the so-called Cherryland carveouts for new nonrecourse loans made in Ohio. Other carveouts, such as the “bad act” carveouts and bankruptcy carveouts, will remain effective. Pursuant to its terms, the Act has no effect on loans that are fully or partially recourse. Less clear is the effect the law will have upon insolvency carveouts for nonrecourse loans that were already www.propertiesmag.com 46


made prior to the Act’s enactment. Though the new laws are silent as to loans in existence, the legislative analysis of the Act indicates that it was the legislature’s intent for the Act to apply to “any claim made or action taken to enforce a post-closing solvency covenant on or after the effective date of the act and to any action to enforce a post-closing solvency covenant that is pending on the effective date of the act, unless a judgment or final order has been entered on that action.” Therefore, in addition to restricting these provisions on new loans going forward, it appears that the intent of the legislature was to render insolvency carveouts on existing loans invalid and unenforceable going forward, provided such claim have not yet been reduced to judgment. (It is unknown whether the courts would follow the Cherryland decision for a claim reduced to judgment.) The Act does not define how a post-closing solvency covenant could be used indirectly, presumably leaving some interpretation up to the judiciary. The General Assembly did provide some guidance, however, noting that it is inherent in a nonrecourse loan that the lender takes the risk of a borrower’s insolvency, inability to pay, or lack of adequate capital after the loan is made. In its commentary, the General Assembly noted that use of a post-closing solvency covenant as a nonrecourse carveout is not only inconsistent with the nature of a nonrecourse loan, but is “an unfair and deceptive business practice and against public policy,” thereby potentially opening the door for claims resulting from violations of the Act by lenders in addition to invalidating the provisions.

SPECIALIZING IN EXTERIOR MASONRY REPAIR & RENOVATION SINCE 1972 • COMPLETE INSPECTION/ASSESSMENT OF FAÇADE CONDITIONS • TUCKPOINTING/CAULKING

• BRICK & STONE REPAIR/REPLACEMENT

• SEALING/WATERPROOFING

• CLEANING/PRESSURE WASHING

Ph 216.881.4142 | Fx 216.881.6557 | 4408 St. Clair Ave., Cleveland, OH 44103

The art of a job well finished

Art Window Coverings, Inc. The “very best” just got better Art Window Shades’ slogan has always been “Next to Your Windows, We’re the Very Best.” So how can “the very best” get better? With a new location and larger showroom under the experienced management of KEVIN BOLL, Art Window Coverings, Inc. is still the same trusted source for professional commercial window coverings it has been since 1922 but has grown to meet today’s need for top quality, style and selection in Ohio. And in addition to great signature brands such as HunterDouglas and Levelor, Art Window

Conclusion The Ohio Legacy Trust Act could have far-reaching effects for commercial real estate lenders and borrowers in Ohio, and lenders, borrowers and their respective counsel need to be cognizant of the newly enacted law. P

Coverings remains your primary contract dealer of MechoShade Systems. Beautiful and intelligent, MechoShades are the smart choice for designers looking for stylish, quality window coverings that make a lasting impression. Call us today to discuss YOUR next work of art.

MechoShade® From your authorized contract dealer

Bryan J. Dardis is a business and corporate attorney who focuses his practice on real estate, including all types of financing and leasing transactions, sales, construction and development. For more information, visit Meyers, Roman Friedberg & Lewis online at www.meyersroman.com

Art Window Coverings, Inc. VISIT US AT OUR NEW LOCATION

3620 Perkins Ave. Cleveland, OH 44114 P s F

www.propertiesmag.com 47


Accessible Education LCCC expands academic offerings with new University Partnership Ridge Campus By Doug Bardwell | Photos by Matt Carissimi

riving west on I-480, you’ve no doubt seen a giant, new LED digital billboard as you near the Lorain Road and Ohio Turnpike exits. Flashing messages like “Impacting community through partnership” and “Impacting economy through innovation,” the board delivers the ever-so-subtle message that quality education is available right in the neighborhood, for everyone.

Newest of the five Learning Centers spaced across Lorain County, the University Partnership Ridge Campus is located on 4.5 acres at 32121 Lorain Road in North Ridgeville. This modern looking, three-story building encompasses 45,000 square feet of Lorain County Community College (LCCC) labs, classrooms and meeting areas for students and community alike. Sharing the facility, the University of Toledo also offers classes on the third floor. This latest LCCC project was designed collaboratively by Sasaki Associates of Boston and Clark & Post of Lorain. With a wide range of carefully selected features, LCCC hopes to obtain Silver LEED certification. Budget for the project was $12 million, exclusive of equipment, furnishings and technology purchases made by the college. According to Ronald Cocco, president of Clark & Post, there were three 48

criteria that drove site selection for this project. “The college first wanted an outreach location on the under-served easterly edge of Lorain County,” Cocco says. “Secondly, they hoped to find a location close to the I-480 and Lorain exit where some 80,000 cars drive by daily. But most importantly, they felt that the I-480 motorist fit their target audience profile: adult learners wanting an education for career enhancement or career change.” It was generally accepted that many people would be attracted to the facility if easy access was provided. The site, as it is, couldn’t be more perfect – and evening motorists see that large sign every night as they drive home.

Design and construction Drawings were ready for competitive bidding in mid-2011. Early site work

and miscellaneous prep work started in August 2011. Competitive bid packages number two and three were awarded in fall and the successful general trades contractor, RFC Contracting Inc. from Strongsville, started work in November. Despite the most horrific, rainiest fall in years, RFC managed to get the building enclosed and under roof by June 2012. Interior work was phased to allow the University of Toledo to open as planned for its winter semester on January 7, 2013. “Essentially a greenfield project, the site offered unique opportunities for water control,” recalls Robert Flyer, director of plant operations and construction. In what is reputedly the largest permeable paving project in the area, all 378 car parking spaces utilize Unilock EcoOptiloc pavers for drainage. “Bio swales, both above and below ground, also help with both site drainage and water filtration,” Flyer says. 3URSHUWLHV | April 2013

Photo by Ken Krych

D


M We are proud to have worked with Lorain County Community College and the University Partnership.

6*' 'SRXVEGXMRK -RG MW E JYPP WIVZMGI GSRWXVYGXMSR GSQTER] WTIGMEPM^MRK MR +IRIVEP 'SRXVEGXMRK 'SRWXVYGXMSR 1EREKIQIRX 4VSKVEQ 1EREKIQIRX 3[RIV´W 6ITVIWIRXEXMZI (IZIPSTQIRX ERH (IWMKR &YMPH WIVZMGIW 7MRGI 6*' LEW GSQTPIXIH E [MHI VERKI SJ TVSNIGXW MRGPYHMRK 'SQQIVGMEP / )HYGEXMSR ,MKLIV )HYGEXMSR +SZIVRQIRX 7EJIX] 7IVZMGIW +VIIR &YMPHMRK ,IEPXL 'EVI ERH 6IRSZEXMSRW

5)& CONTRACTING, INC .

4VSWTIGX 6H 7XI Q 7XVSRKWZMPPI 3, Q Q *E\ Q [[[ VJGGSRXVEGXMRK GSQ www.propertiesmag.com 49


STYLIZED SURFACE In all, 36,000 square feet of polished concrete was used on the three floors of the building.

LED fixtures provide illumination at night. Other sustainable elements within the project include a live green roof, a courtyard rain garden that collects and filters roof run-off, drought tolerant plant selections and low-maintenance native wildflower meadows, according to Katia Lucic, principal at Sasaki. “Visitors and students alike will enjoy the paved entry court plaza of pea-stone gravel and cherry trees,” Lucic says. The design intent of the site was to integrate the building into the landscape and to create a welcoming arrival sequence for visitors, adds Isabel Zempel, landscape architect and principal at Sasaki. “While celebrating parking and creating an integrated green concept with 50

a ‘parking garden,’ we provided clear pedestrian and vehicular connections for visitors,” Zempel says. “We also created communal outdoor spaces with courtyards, plazas and gardens where students can get together, study and hold events. As we created a green image for the campus, we also promoted sustainable strategies with storm water mitigation, green roofs and native plant materials.” In addition to parking for cars, bike racks have been installed for those who would like to pedal to class. A shower and changing room facility is also provided inside for the convenience of the bike commuters. The majority of the exterior surface is corrugated metal siding over insulated

panels. “Insulated metal wall panels are usually not anywhere near as prominent as the ones used on this building,” says Ryan Naymik, project manager for RFC. “For the whole building to be encased in them is quite unique.” For design interest, simulated walnut-grained 3/8” Formica Vivix panels accent the entry area and appear on the first floor level on three sides of the project. While other exotic materials were first proposed, the decision was made to source more locally available materials for sustainability, cost and ease of installation during one of Cleveland’s rainiest winters. Bright-orange sunshades shield the windows on floors two and three, and also on the south side of the building, facing the parking lot. Visible from the third floor classrooms, the bumped-out second floor is covered with a modular pre-vegetated, green roof system. A mix of sedum and other succulents covers almost 100% of this building-long rooftop. All roofs boast an R25 insulation rating. White Tectum panels, often used as roof decking, are suspended as either vertical baffles or horizontal clouds for acoustical sound absorption below the corrugated steel deck on each floor. Many ideas for student and faculty collaboration in the general instruction areas were gleaned from the learning model developed for the iLOFT Building (see Properties, January 2013) on the Abbe Road campus. Modular and movable furniture permit multiple configurations in the classrooms and meeting areas. Classrooms can be setup in traditional format or tables can be rearranged for small group discussions. Design was driven by budget on this project, and while the effectiveness of the space was never compromised, there was very little budget left for embellishments. The entry area, which will also be utilized for community events, has a polished concrete floor and floor-to-ceiling glass. Full building height glazing on the east and west walls allows light to filter into the innermost rooms, aiding in illumination and helping to save on lighting costs. All lighting is managed by the building automation management system located on the main campus in Elyria. 3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


RAISING INTEREST As a daring focal point, the staircase to the second floor is located directly across from the entry doors. Sided with brilliant orange, 1/8-inch steel panels, the stairs and intermediate landing create a lightning bolt pattern as they rise to the floor above.

In all, 36,000 square feet of polished concrete was used on the three floors. Below the slab floor, a series of PVC tubing provides radiant heat in the entry area. Air conditioning for the building is provided by two rooftop cooling-only units. Those combine with a variable air volume (VAV) system with reheat coils. As a daring focal point, the staircase to the second floor is located directly across from the entry doors. Sided with

brilliant orange, 1/8-inch steel panels, the stairs and intermediate landing create a lightning bolt pattern as they rise to the floor above. For color counterpoint to the orange stairs, a bold blue wall to the left encloses the vending area and carries the school logo in large white letters. Colorful, upholstered bench and sectional seating can be found to the east of the entry doors. Moveable steel-col-

ored tables and chairs occupy the area to the west. Wireless Internet is available all through the building, stretching even outside to the nearby seating areas around the entrance.

Educational opportunities In addition to the University Partnership engineering classes taught by Toledo University, the Ridge Campus offers two unique pro-

[MXL 7EWEOM %WWSG

EhkZbg <hngmr <hffngbmr <hee^`^ Ngbo^klbmr IZkmg^klabi Kb]`^ <Zfinl ?Z\bebmr

% 2 38 , ) 6 - 2 2 3:%8 - : ) ( ) 7 - + 2 7 3 0 9 8 - 3 2

[[[ GPEVOERHTSWX GSQ

www.propertiesmag.com 51


CLEAR DIFFERENCE Full building height glazing allows light to filter into the innermost areas – from conference rooms (top) to corridors (bottom) – aiding in illumination and helping to save on energy costs.

grams which should be very popular with LCCC students. On the first floor, you’ll find the Health Care Careers simulation center as part of the Allied Health and Nursing Department. Here, a whole family of extremely high-tech SIMs (simulation mannequins) awaits all sorts of catastrophes. While the man, woman or child mannequin lies on a hospital bed, in an adjacent room behind oneway glass, instructors can remotely simulate changes in breathing, pulse, temperature, heart rate, etc. Students in the room with the “patient” try to diagnose the ailment and render appropriate care. All types of simulations can be created, from infant sicknesses through pregnancy though old age maladies. In addition to giving students “near-real” learning experiences, the simulation center will also be invaluable for EMS certification and continuing education. Upstairs on the second floor, you’ll find the Digital Forensics Lab. Here, Engineering Department students and faculty work to reconstruct data from erased hard drives or similar foul play perpetrated on computers or cell phones. Digital forensics is growing as a career path and is in demand by both the BCI (Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation) and the FBI. In addition to providing credits toward an Engineering degree, LCCC also has created a business enterprise for the digital forensics operation. “Offering this service to outside businesses and organizations, the school has the opportunity to fulfill a need in the community, generate a small revenue stream, and provide real world experience to students,” says Laura Carissimi, director of purchasing and facilities planning. One thousand students are forecast to use the building in this, its inaugural year. Expectations are that the total will be 2,500 to 3,000 in the foreseeable future. With easy vehicular access and affordable classes, there aren’t many reasons left to avoid getting off at the exit and getting the education that one needs. P 52

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


Building Envelope/Roofing Report

Prolonging Performance Specialized roof coatings reduce capital expenditure, maintenance & energy costs By Nick Hecei Hecei Roof Coating Systems, Inc.

eflective coatings are now being used extensively throughout the U.S. to restore existing roof systems and to shield the roof substrate from ultraviolet radiation, wind erosion, rain, snow and hail. High reflectivity and emissivity are enhanced through the use of reflective coatings, protecting your existing roof and extending its overall service life. In addition, preserving our energy resources has become a major focus of government and industry as building codes are amended to recognize the benefits of reflective coatings as a method of reducing energy costs and improving air quality.

Photo courtesy of Hecei Roof Coating Systems, Inc.

R

For these reasons and more, a specialized coating system may be a perfect fit for your roof. Your facility is an investment, a vital element for your business operations and profits. Your roof protects that investment, attracting little attention until it leaks, resulting in potential property damage, business disruption and safety hazards. Careful planning and budgeting can avoid such a crisis.

Innovative polymer technology Many of today’s “fluid applied” systems are manufactured from the latest

polymer technology, offering excellent elongation, weathering and adhesion. These outstanding performance characteristics allow for a roof’s natural expansion and contraction, keeping your underlying roof system protected and watertight. Further, such coatings are VOC compliant (meeting permissible requirements on regulations for volatile organic compounds) and environmentally friendly. Available in white and colors, the coating adds no appreciable weight at only a few

ounces per square foot with no effect on design loads.

Eliminate tear off & disposal costs Reflective coatings will preserve and protect your existing roofing system, eliminating the high cost of replacement with a positive impact on the environment. The coating system is a fraction of replacement costs.

Sustainable Quality coatings require little maintenance and typically perform for ten www.propertiesmag.com 53


Extend the life of your roof. With Reflective Roof Coating Systems… A Sustainable Option COST EFFECTIVE - 1/3 the cost of replacement SUSTAINABLE - can be extended to last the life of the building ADVANCED POLYMER TECHNOLOGY - long-term warranties FLUID APPLIED, 100% ADHERED - no seams, fasteners or adhesives to fail UP TO 90% REFLECTIVITY – protects roof from further deterioration & lowers energy costs

BuildingRetrofit.com | nick@buildingretrofit.com

Call 216-533-0563 today to schedule your FREE Roof Inspection!

%XLOGLQJ (QFORVXUH &RXQFLOò&OHYHODQG 3UHVHQWV

5VdZX_Z_X R_U :_deR]]Z_X 4fceRZ_HR]]d Presented by John Myers, Director of Technical Services, Harmon, Inc.

>Rj #*eY #!"$ CVXZdecReZ`_ %+$! Ac`XcR^ &+$! a^ 4`ca`cReV 4`]]VXV 6Rde HRccV_dgZ]]V 9ed @9 This program will review thermal topics related to the design and installation of curtain walls. Topics that will be covered include: s 5NDERSTANDING FACTORS AFFECTING CONDENSATION s 5NDERSTANDING 5 &ACTORS s 5NDERSTANDING THERMAL EXPANSION AND CONTRACTION OF CURTAIN WALLS

Learning objectives include: s )DENTIFY lVE ATTRIBUTES AFFECTING WINDOW 5 &ACTOR s %MPLOY AT LEAST THREE DESIGN OPTIONS TO IMPROVE WINDOW 5 &ACTOR s $IFFERENTIATE BETWEEN .&2# AND !!-! TESTING AND CERTIlCATION PROCESSES s $RAFT NON DEFECTIVE SPECIlCATION REQUIREMENTS FOR 5 &ACTOR s 2ECOGNIZE OTHER IMPORTANT ENERGY RELATED WINDOW DESIGN FACTORS AND THE IMPORTANCE OF A BALANCED DESIGN

For more information and to register, visit www.bec-cleveland.org (1.0 CEU LU/HSW/SD can be earned by attending this seminar) John Myers is Director of Technical Services, and provides in-house technical expertise in the design, fabrication, assembly, glazing, and installation of curtain wall systems. John also engages with architects, contractors, and owners in the development and selection of curtain wall systems for their projects. John has over 30 years of experience in the industry, most of those years with Harmon. John has significant knowledge and expertise in materials, engineering, and systems.

%URXJKW WR \RX E\

54

years and longer. Through periodic recoating, the coating system can be extended to last the life of the building.

Monolithic Elastomeric coatings are 100% adhered. Once cured, the coating has no seams to come apart, no fasteners to come loose, no adhesives to disbond and no ballast adding unnecessary weight.

Reduce energy needs, thermal stress Reflective coatings lower both your roof’s surface and “under-the-roof” temperatures. Most of the sun’s radiant heat is reflected rather than absorbed into the roof substrate, reducing interior temperatures dramatically. Further, by reflecting up to 90% of the sun’s radiant heat, a white coating will help stabilize thermal expansion and contraction by lowering the temperature of the underlying roof substrate, preventing further surface degradation and reducing roof stress.

Tax savings & energy rebates Your coating project may be considered a maintenance expense (not a capital cost) and, therefore, a deductible expense in the year completed. Further, energy rebates may be earned through your local utility company when installing an energy efficient roof coating. Although the benefits of a reflective coating system are plentiful, selecting the right contractor is vital in assuring you receive a quality installation. Why? Because if not installed by a qualified, experienced contractor, even quality coatings and roofing systems can fail prematurely. Extending the life of your roof can save you considerable expense now and in the future and that means more to your bottom line. P Nick Hecei is president of Hecei Roof Coating Systems, Inc., celebrating 40 years in commercial/ industrial roof restoration. Hecei applies sustainable, state-of-the-art coating solutions to the problems associated with aged metal roofs, Hypalon®, TPO, & EPDM single ply membranes, smoothsurface built-up roofing, and modified bitumen. For more info, or to schedule a free roof inspection/ assessment email nick@buildingretrofit.com, call 216-533-0563 or visit www.buildingretrofit.com. 3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


What are you doing to prevent small roof problems from turning into

BIG ROOF PROBLEMS? If you saw ice dams, icicles and water stains inside your facility this past winter, you have roof problems that must be corrected. Roof problems always grow! A small leak turns into a big one… which turns into mold, dry rot, crumbling dry wall and electrical problems. Don’t let it happen to you.

Our 10 Year No-Excuses Warranty Lets You Forget About Your Roof Problems If you have a problem, we fix it. No Excuses. We focus on taking care of all the details and doing the job right the first time.

Roofing • Siding • Gutters • Skylights Ventilation • Repairs • Re-Roofs • Emergencies

´8SRQ \RXU VWUXFWXUH ZH FRYHU WKH LQYHVWPHQWµ

6WUXFWXUH 5RRÀQJ &RPSDQ\ ,QF

ZZZ VWUXFWXUHURRI FRP

)5(( $1$/<6,6 )5(( (67,0$7(6


LEGACY OF LEADERSHIP In 1986, Steven Tomason (left) founded Southwest Companies. His son Michael (right) now serves as president.

Built to Last Family-run Southwest Companies works to lengthen operating life of NE Ohio facilities By Lou Kren | Photos courtesy of Southwest Companies

ormed as a commercial painting company in 1986, Southwest Companies has grown and diversified to encompass services for an entire building envelope. Specializing in maintaining and restoring the interior/exterior envelope of facilities, including professional project management and corporate account services, the company’s main services include painting, roofing, concrete work and masonry restoration.

F

Headquartered at 7717 Commerce Park Oval in Independence, Southwest Companies boasts as many as 35 employees during the peak summer season. Crews tackle projects throughout Northeast Ohio, with some work taking the company west to Chicago and east into Pennsylvania.

Protection against harsh weather Northeast Ohio weather plays havoc with buildings of course, and services offered by Southwest Companies addresses anything that Mother Nature throws our way. 56

“We are specialists in envelope waterproofing, which protects against a major problem in Northeast Ohio – the freeze-thaw cycle,” explains Michael Tomasone, president of Southwest Companies. “That cycle breaks up concrete sidewalks as well as brick and block buildings, and also causes leaking windows. Every type of building has similar issues. There are a series of things we can do to prevent these problems from happening or worsening over time. Sealing, caulking, re-tuckpointing and repairing concrete are just a few services we offer to combat Ohio’s

weather and maintain your building’s overall appearance and structural integrity. Unfortunately, where we live the freeze-thaw cycle beats everything up.”

Benefitting from experience At 28 years old, Tomasone learned the ins and outs of building repair and damage prevention from his father Steve, who founded Southwest Companies and today serves as a director. Steve, in turn, earned his stripes working with his dad. “My grandfather was a concrete contractor, so my father poured concrete for most of his younger years,” 3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


Building Envelope/Roofing Report

FINDING A FIX A project for Linde Gas in West Virginia required application of Elastomeric coating to revive an existing metal roof.

Tomasone says. “Grandpa also used to build homes and commercial buildings, so the family brought these experiences into the business and that is how we were able to diversify in the early 2000s and start fixing buildings entirely as a building restoration contractor. Today we have a wealth of versatile knowledge and services. We know how to do roofing, concrete, brickwork and tuckpointing. We took many classes to learn about interior and exterior envelopes of buildings, and how to waterproof and maintain them. Building upkeep and maintenance is more than just a paint job.” A visit to www.southwestcompanies.net, the company’s website, reveals a laundry list of building-envelope services provided by Southwest Companies. Bonded and insured, the company provides a guarantee on every job. “With all of our expertise and experience, we are an in-house one-stop shop, so we don’t have to call in six other companies to fix one problem,” Tomasone says.

smile. But Tomasone does have serious advice for building owners and managers. “Every building has different, specific needs because every building’s envelope may be different. But the weather has an effect on all buildings. Put together a preventive maintenance schedule so you don’t have costly repairs in the future.”

Southwest Companies strives to maintain and keep buildings together for a longer period of time, Tomasone explains. “We are not here just to repair, but to make sure that you get your money’s worth out of the investment in maintenance and repair,” he says. “We bring your property back to life by offering cost-effective solutions that will last.” P

WE BRING YOUR PROPERTY BACK TO LIFE

Keeping buildings in shape Graduating from the University of Dayton after studying entrepreneurship and operations management, Tomasone is positioning Southwest Companies for continual and incremental growth, he says. And Northeast Ohio should continue to supply opportunities for the company to shine. “People ask how we are doing, and I tell them that what keeps me in business is our weather,” he says with a

PAINTING, ROOFING, CONCRETE & MASONRY SERVICES

6RXWKZHVW &RPSDQLHV ,QF Commercial Property Restoration 7717 Commerce Park Oval, Independence, Ohio 44131 (216) 642-1195 Toll Free (877) 642-1195 www.southwestcompanies.net www.propertiesmag.com 57


Expert Brick Matching

7KH 1XPEHUV 'RQ·W /LH

SPRAY FOAM TECHNOLOGIES OF

OHIO

<RXU $YHUDJH +HDWLQJ &RROLQJ 6DYLQJV ZLWK 6SUD\ 3RO\XUHWKDQH )RDP 63) ,QVXODWLRQ 6RXUFH 6SUD\ 3RO\XUHWKDQH )RDP $OOLDQFH 5HVXOWV PD\ YDU\ EDVHG RQ LQGLYLGXDO +9$& XVDJH

5

3HU ,QFK

63) KDV 1HDUO\ 7ZLFH WKH ,QVXODWLQJ 9DOXH RI 7UDGLWLRQDO )LEHUJODVV· 5 SHU LQFK

9005 Woodland Ave. Cleveland, OH 44104 216-791-9800 office 216-791-5116 fax www.bruderinc.com

&DOO &OLFN WR XWLOL]H 63) ,QVXODWLRQ RQ \RXU QH[W SURMHFW

6SUD\)RDP7HFK2KLR FRP $%$$ 1&), 26+$ &(57,),(' $XURUD +XGVRQ 5G +XGVRQ 2+

():63<;, 966-05. 05* 5L^ 9VVMZ • ;LHY 6MMZ • 9LWHPYZ • -SH[ 9VVMZ • *VH[PUNZ -SHZOPUNZ • *\Z[VT *VWWLY >VYR • -HJ[VYPLZ • >HYLOV\ZLZ *O\YJOLZ :[LLWSLZ • (KKP[PVUZ • (WHY[TLU[Z • *VUKVZ 0UK\Z[YPHS • *VTTLYJPHS • 3PJLUZLK )VUKLK & 0UZ\YLK 796 *VU[YHJ[VY VM [OL @LHY (^HYK ^PUULY *VTTLYJPHS ,_[LYPVY *H[LNVY` -(403@ 6>5,+ 67,9(;,+

7O -H_ ^^^ HIZVS\[LYVVÄUN JVT

Approved applicators for RPI, Firestone, Polyglass, CTD, GAF 58

56, 723

4LTILY *SL]LSHUK 3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


Building Envelope/Roofing Report

Project Profile: Keystone Threaded Products Hailstorm damage forces roof replacement at Valley View facility Story & images courtesy of Absolute Roofing, Inc.

eystone Threaded Products is a well-established manufacturer and a leader in the Northeast Ohio manufacturing scene. In late 2011, the company decided to move its operation to a larger location. During a thorough inspection of its new building in Valley View, it was discovered that the facility had possibly sustained hail damage to the roof. Absolute Roofing and Construction was brought in to perform an inspection of the complete roof system. Its comprehensive approach to roofing and insurance claims was extremely important to this process. This was no small task as the building comprises five separate roof sections totaling 79,000 square feet.

K

All five of the roof surfaces on the building had an apparent white TPO (thermoplastic polyolefin) single-ply membrane installed over a BUR pea gravel ballasted roof of unknown manufacture. Various repairs were noted throughout the roofing systems, including what appeared to be a recent core test repair. Core testing – a process performed by extracting cross sections of the roof for analysis – revealed 1) signs of condensation/moisture present on the underside of the existing TPO membrane and 2) a composition of TPO over ¼” styrene

insulation over pea ballast over 3-ply BUR over 1” fiberglass insulation over a steel corrugated perforated metal deck. A cursory interior walkthrough was performed to help identify possible moisture infiltration areas into the building, but due to rooftop conditions the exact origin of the roof moisture infiltration could not be definitively determined. The existing flat roof appeared to be in fair to poor shape, with expected normal wear and tear due to weathering and lack of maintenance. There was clear evidence of defects in the roof that required immediate

attention. Of note were several impact fractures in the membrane. The impact fractures observed were consistent with hail stone damage. There were a number of severe storms in 2010 and 2011 that produced hailstones large enough to cause impact damage. It was clear that there was a previous inspection performed to this roof as a number of the impact fractures had been circled by a red and/ or blue grease pencil, which led Absolute to believe that someone was aware of the apparent impact damage that was present on this roof surface. www.propertiesmag.com 59


DEALING WITH DAMAGE As Absolute Roofing examined the roof, it was clear that a previous inspection had been performed as a number of impact fractures had been circled by grease pencil (left). Further studies led the company to recommend removing the existing roof surface down to the roof deck, perform repairs as needed, and then install new ISO board insulation and an EPDM rubber roof membrane (right).

The damage to the roof membrane presented itself in several ways; short (½” to ¾”) tears, half circle or crescent shape tears and series of concentric circle tears (bulls-eye) ranging from ½” to 2” plus size impacts. Based upon the experience of hundreds of other similar type membrane evaluations, Absolute concluded the damage was a result of hail stone impacts. Once it was determined that the roof had experienced hail damage, Absolute focused the evaluation on the extent of hail damage. The company determined that this roof surface had experienced moderate to major hail damage based on the number of impact fractures observed. Hailstones normally vary in size, shape and hardness and are usually distributed

randomly which are indicative of the fractures found in the roof membrane.

Hail damage explanation According to Haag Certification, which serves as a standard among numerous insurance companies for assessment and repair/replacement options, most roofing systems are susceptible to damage from the impact of hailstones falling at high velocities: “The extent of the damage depends on the nature of the roof system and other factors, such as age and surface temperature at the time of impact, may also come into play.” Haag notes that catastrophic failure damage is very clear and easy to observe, as this would be “a complete fracture through the installed product.” However, other types of damage are not so obvi-

([SHULHQFHG 'HSHQGDEOH

6WUXFWXUDO 6WHHO )DEULFDWRUV DQG (UHFWRUV VLQFH &RQWDFW 0LNH 6PLWK IRU D SURSRVDO ZZZ PDVRQVWHHO FRP 1RUWKILHOG 5RDG :DOWRQ +LOOV 2KLR 2WKHU )LQH 3URGXFWV $YDLODEOH 6WRQH 3DYHUV )LUHSODFHV :LQGRZV 'RRUV 60

ous. “In some cases, an indentation can occur, and the fracture in either the reinforcement mat is not readily observable. The effects of hail damage often can be readily seen, but visual observation of roof surfaces often does not reveal serious damage. This may include weakening of the membrane reinforcement, membrane adhesion, fractures, punctures and the like. Damage to the insulation substrate can also occur. In such cases, testing is required to determine the extent of damage of the roof system components. Unfortunately, some damage may not be apparent until after many months or years of exposure. If substantial damage has occurred, the roof systems waterproofing integrity is at risk and its service life threatened.”

Repair vs. replacement According to Haag, one method that can be used to determine if a roof should be repaired or replaced is the use of a “test square area.” This approach recommends that if seven to 10 impact hits are observed within a 100-square-foot sample test area, then the roof be completely replaced. Absolute utilized this method at Keystone Threaded Products and the results indicated that the entire roof surface should be replaced. Due to the conditions observed throughout the roof surface, the recommendation was 3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


The company to trust with your window replacement needs.

The Commercial Window Experts...Since 1969

2800 Euclid Avenue | Cleveland, OH 44115 | (216) 621-4277 | Fax: (216) 621-7665 | www.jamiesonricca.com

\ 174 75 61/ 4%*+6'%674#. '6#. 2'%+#.+565[

1746#& 0%T *VTTLYJPHS 0UK\Z[YPHS 0UZ[P[\[PVUHS 9L[HPS :WLJPHSPaPUN PU LUNPULLYPUN MHIYPJH[PVU PUZ[HSSH[PVU VM! TL[HS YVVMPUN YVSSLK VU ZP[L MSHZOPUN [YPT J\Z[VT MHZJPHZ MYPLaL IVHYKZ LH]LZ JVWWLY Z[HPUSLZZ Z[LLS Z`Z[LTZ JVTWVZP[L TL[HS ^HSS Z`Z[LTZ J\Z[VT N\[[LYZ KV^UZWV\[Z JVTTLYJPHS N\[[LYZ YVSSLK VU ZP[L

GGNTFKHTGENN T T 1: LFKX #067#X HHFII 999T%1746#&+0%T%1/

www.propertiesmag.com 61


TOPPING OFF After removing the existing surface and completing roof deck work, the team attached poly-ISO insulation board, which was then covered with a Firestone .060” EPDM rubber roofing membrane.

to remove the existing roof surface down to the roof deck, perform repairs to the roof deck as needed, and then install new ISO board insulation and an EPDM rubber roof membrane. In lieu of installing a tapered insulation system, the owner opted to add additional roof drains to help with ponding water on the roof surface. After careful consideration form Keystone’s insurance company it was decided that the roof was a total loss and required replacement. The insurance company agreed to cover the entire cost of the roof. Absolute was

awarded the project after a competitive bid process was performed. The project had to be scheduled around the expected inclement weather. Whenever a flat roof is replaced, careful consideration must be given to the weather to avoid water getting into the building. Staging of the materials was performed in the early morning hours due to the confines of the worksite and the amount of materials required. “It decided to start snowing that day, and being that it was 6:30 in the morning it was also pitch black out,

so extreme caution was utilized by my men while staging this project,” says Mike Kamis, production manager at Absolute. “It couldn’t have gone better though, which is a true testament to the skills of my men” The flat was removed in sections no larger than 2,000 square feet to accommodate installation of the new roof within the available daylight hours. To prevent leakage, the transition from the new roof to the old roof was “night sealed” at the end of every shift. The roof deck was reviewed and repaired as necessary for a good, solid sound surface. A vapor barrier was then placed onto the bare roof deck for further protection from the elements. Poly-ISO insulation board was then mechanically attached using heavy duty screws, which was then covered by a Firestone .060” EPDM membrane. A new perimeter flashing metal was custom fabricated in the Absolute metal shop then installed to the roof. With the cooperation of Keystone’s management; Willoughby Supply, the material supplier; Firestone, the mem-

7,5(' 2) %(,1* 5,33(' 2))"

7KHQ VWRS KLULQJ À\ E\ QLJKW ³URR¿QJ FRQWUDFWRUV´ ZKRVH RQO\ RI¿FH DGGUHVV LV ZKHUHYHU WKHLU SLFN XS WUXFN KDSSHQV WR EH SDUNHG DW WKH WLPH 7KH QR LQVXUDQFH LUUHVSRQVLEOH RSHUDWRUV DUH GULYLQJ WKH IHZ UHPDLQLQJ KRQHVW URR¿QJ FRQWUDFWRUV RXW RI EXVLQHVV 8QOHVV WKH FRQVXPHU JHWV ZLVHU WKHUH ZLOO EH QR TXDOLW\ URRIHUV OHIW :H DUH ORRNLQJ IRU D IHZ ZLVH FRQVXPHUV ,I \RX ¿W WKH ELOO FDOO XV WRGD\

6,1&(

(DVW WK 6WUHHW &OHYHODQG 2+ ZZZ FDUH\URR¿QJ FRP )D[ 62

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


'6#. T T T 11( 1#6+0) -;.+)*65 brane manufacturer; and Absolute, the installer, the project was completed by the imposed deadline. The installation achieved the required 20-year manufacturer’s warranty. Chris Kamis, of Absolute, summarizes the Keystone Threaded Products project by citing the accomplishments of all of the Absolute Roofing and Construction, Inc. crewmembers. “Keystone Threaded Products is an extremely important asset to the community and I am very proud of our project, the skills of our employees and the way our people performed beyond expectations with all of the other professionals involved,” he says, adding that credit must be given to Mike Kamis, production manager at Absolute for his skills and patience, as well as the skilled craftsmen on the project, including Lead Foreman Ken Belcher, Shift Foreman David Frindt, Operations Manager Brian Kamis and Safety Coordinator Getty Wompamack. P

;d]n]dYf\ k Kl]]d @]Y\imYjl]jk

1//'4%+#. n 0&7564+#.

GGNTKKGTFMNN

6*1/u%122'45/+6*75#T%1/

Making Your Roof Last Longer Q Flat, Built-Up & Asphalt Shingle Roofing Q EPM & TPO Installations Q Complete Roof Evaluations Q Roof Asset Management Q Award-Winning Service EDGE Certified Company RESIDENTIAL

&ROXPELD %XLOGLQJ 3URGXFWV STEEL JOISTS STRUCTURAL IRON METAL ROOF DECK STEEL STAIRS & RAILS STEEL ERECTION

440-235-3363

Q

330.966.9902 www.buxtonroofing.com COMMERCIAL

Q

INDUSTRIAL

Restoration Contractors American International Construction, Inc. is a company dedicated to the restoration and preservation of numerous types of buildings, including related services on new structures. Let our commitment to quality and client satisfaction work for you. UÊ >Õ }ÊEÊÃi> > Ìà UÊ Õ ` }ÊV i> } UÊ/ÕV « Ì } UÊ >V>`iÊÀiÃÌ À>Ì UÊ >à ÀÞÊEÊÃÌ iÊÀiÃÌ À>Ì UÊ-Ì ÀivÀ ÌÊÀi Û>Ì UÊ7>ÌiÀ«À v } UÊ ÃÌ À VÊ«ÀiÃiÀÛ>Ì

Michael Petrasek president

1073 WEST BAGLEY ROAD, BEREA, OHIO 44017 ph: 440.243.5535 f: 440.243.7745 www.aiconstruction.com

*-1.) =de Kl&$ ;d]n]dYf\$ G@ ,,)+0

www.propertiesmag.com 63


Photos courtesy of Tusing Builders & Roofing Services

Project Profile: Kleist Center for the Arts Project at Baldwin Wallace University demands creative problem-solving By Jon Paull Tusing Builders & Roofing Services

aldwin Wallace University, located in the heart of Berea, was faced with a difficult decision of how to remedy an aging and troublesome roof on its Kleist Center for the Arts (shown above, left). With the university’s desire to be “Green,” the Building & Grounds Department had their work cut out for them as to find a way to resolve their problems.

B

After evaluating the structure and listening to the university’s concerns regarding maintaining the facility’s very visible appearance, the Building & Grounds Department contacted Tusing Roofing Services to assist with their resolution.

The difficulty was that this roof was a sloped metal system (shown above, right) comprised of small individual panels welded in place, resembling the scales of an animal. An added problem was that the new roof was tying into a

& 2 0 0 ( 5 & , $ / , 1 ' 8 6 7 5 , $ / , 1 6 7 , 7 8 7 , 2 1$ /

ȋ͚͜​͚Ȍ ͙͘͜Ǧ͖͕͖͛ Ǥ Ǥ 64

portion of the existing roof that was to remain unchanged. Tusing Roofing Services in conjunction with membrane manufacturer Duro-Last Roofing Inc. was able to provide a custom designed membranecoated rib detail that would emulate the previous roof and tie into the adjoining roof system. Tusing utilized a flute fill insulation, rigid recovery board and fully adhered Duro-Last gray membrane as its substrate. The decorative rib detail was laid out to match the existing profile of the upper roof and then hot-air welded into place. The new roof system was able to be installed over the existing system, eliminating excessive costs and rubbish, while also providing additional insulation to the building. Tusing Roofing Services’ experience and reputation paid off. Upon final inspection, Duro-Last Roofing Inc. was able to provide a manufacturer’s 15-year warranted application. Though not very large, the slow and tedious project was a great success for all of the parties involved. P Joe Kaput is project manager with Tusing Roofing Services (www.TrustTusing.com). 3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


Building Envelope/Roofing Report Industry Profile: CTL Engineering Inc. Roofing & Building Envelope Services

W

hen CTL Engineering was established in 1927, its focus was primarily on providing testing and inspection services for soils, foundation engineering and construction. In the decades since, its scope of services has expanded naturally into a multitude of other disciplines, such as the metallurgical, non-destructive testing, mechanical, mining and environmental service industries. Three decades ago, the company also began applying its testing experience and expertise to the roofing industry. EVALUATING ABILITIES CTL performs a range of diagnostic and design services in all facets of the building envelope, including roof systems.

samples to identify materials, for laboratory analysis, and to obtain data on moisture infiltration. The company routinely performs non-destructive testing using infrared, nuclear and capacitance equipment and methodology as a part of the diagnostic process.

CTL’s roof inspectors are trained to observe all phases of installation to ensure the materials are in compliance with project documents. The company also provides air/water barrier testing during construction to comply with commissioning requirements. As the company does not manufacture or sell roofing products, nor apply them, CTL prides itself on maintaining an objective viewpoint when evaluating roofs and specifying remedial actions. To learn more, call 330.220.8900 or visit CTL Engineering Inc. online at www.crleng.com. P

We Keep You Covered.

ENGINEERING

INC.

A Trusted Supplier since 1998

REPLACE? WHY NOT RESTORE? Before

After ElastiKote

$ 0%( DQG ('*( FHUWLÀHG FRPSDQ\

4XDOLW\ 6HUYLFH 6LQFH 5RRÀQJ 6\VWHP 'HVLJQ DQG 0DQDJHPHQW %XLOGLQJ (QYHORSH 'HVLJQ DQG (YDOXDWLRQV *HRWHFKQLFDO (QJLQHHULQJ (QYLURQPHQWDO &RQVXOWLQJ &RQVWUXFWLRQ 0DWHULDO 7HVWLQJ $05/ &HUWLÀHG /DERUDWRULHV $&, DQG 1,&(7 &HUWLÀHG 7HFKQLFLDQV 6L[ RIÀFHV WKURXJKRXW 2KLR )RU D FRPSOHWH OLVW RI RIÀFHV DQG VHUYLFHV YLVLW RXU ZHEVLWH DW ZZZ FWOHQJ FRP RU FRQWDFW

&7/ (QJLQHHULQJ ,QF ,QWHUVWDWH 3DUNZD\ %UXQVZLFN 2K 3+ _ );

Cost Effective Alternative To Roof Replacement. CALL TODAY

440.899.0242

www.disilvestroroofing.com www.propertiesmag.com 65

Photos courtesy of CTL Engineering, Inc.

Today, CTL’s Roofing and Building Envelope Department provides a full range of diagnostic and design services in all facets of the building envelope, including roof systems, wall systems and waterproofing. The company’s roof engineering and building envelope services include due diligence, design, evaluation, condition assessment, non-destructive testing, materials testing, construction quality assurance, asset management, maintenance programming and expert testimony. The firm also conducts seminars on envelope design, maintenance and current issues. To aid clients in managing facility assets, CTL provides various levels of condition assessment. Its team examines the envelope assembly from the building interior as well as from the exterior, obtaining


CONSTRUCTION PROGRESS REPORT Updated info on important projects in the region PN-Y0131053 ALZHEIMER/MEMORY CARE CENTER Beachwood, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) Harvard Road ESTIMATED AMOUNT: $4,000,000 CONTRACTING METHOD: G.C. Subcontracts UPDATE: Bidding possible May 2013. OWNER: JEA Senior Living 12115 Northeast 99th Street, Suite 1800 Vancouver, WA 98682 (800) 254-9442 G.C.: Erwin Construction 12115 NE 99th Street # 1800 Vancouver, WA 98682 (360) 433-0181 DETAILS: Approx. 32,900 SF, one-story, 46-unit, 66-bed facility; trades could include sitework; thermal and moisture protection; foundation; concrete; metals; wood and plastics; windows and doors; finishes; specialties; HVAC; electrical; mechanical; plumbing; specific details to be announced. PN-W0321072 NEW FIRE STATION NO. 36 Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) 3552 East 131 Street ESTIMATED AMOUNT: $3,200,000

CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids UPDATE: Project expected to bid late spring or early summer 2013; no additional information available at this time. OWNER: City of Cleveland 601 Lakeside Avenue, Room 128 Cleveland, OH 44114 www.city.cleveland.oh.us (216) 664-2620 FAX (216) 664-2177 AGENT: City of Cleveland Division of Architecture 601 Lakeside Avenue, Room 517A Cleveland, OH 44114 (216) 664-2374 FAX (216) 664-4220 Robert Vilkas, RA, LEED GA (216) 6643577, rvilkas@city.cleveland.oh.us ENGINEER: Richard L. Bowen & Associates 13000 Shaker Boulevard Cleveland, OH 44120 www.rlba.com (216) 491-9300 FAX (216) 491-8053 DETAILS: 12,500 SF, two-stories; four-bay apparatus room, training facilities, meeting facilities, kitchen and dining facilities, bathing and individual sleeping accommodations for 14 personnel; sitework; utilities; concrete; thermal and moisture

Are you satisfied with your current investment returns? Is your IRA growing at 11% - 15% per year? Do you have ANY investments worth DOUBLE what you paid for them? YOU CAN...

NOW YOU HAVE A CHOICE!

TURNKEY INVESTOR PROPERTIES, A STARK COMPANY offers a unique and effortless way to earn 11%, 12%, 15% annually, starting with a very low minimum investment. Call Brian Stark directly today at 216-310-1470 to learn more! www.turnkeyinvestorproperties.com

“The Stark Group Live!” Talking Real Estate Thursdays at 7 pm on Newstalk 1490 AM WERE 66

protection; HVAC; electrical; tele/data systems; plumbing; carbon-monoxide exhaust vent. PN-X1101046 NEW NASA RESEARCH SUPPORT BUILDING Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) ESTIMATED AMOUNT: $15,000,000 to $20,000,000 CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids UPDATE: Announcing A/E selection. OWNER: GSA - Public Buildings Service (5PE) Office of Property Development 230 S. Dearborn Street, Room 3600 Chicago, IL 60604 www.fbo.gov William M. Chapman, Contract Specialist (312) 353-0868, william.chapman@gsa. gov/David Mazzolini, Contracting Officer (312) 353-0617, david.mazzolini@gsa.gov AGENCY: NASA Glenn Research Center 21000 Brookpark Road Cleveland, OH 44135 http://procurement.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/ EPS/bizops.cgi?gr=C&pin=22 (216) 433-4000 FAX (216) 433-5489 ARCHITECT/ENGINEER: Ten Arquitectos 227 W. 29th Street, 11th Floor New York, NY 10001 www.ten-arquitectos.com (212) 620-0794 DETAILS: SOL GS-05P-12-GB-C-0027 The project will require the demolition of an existing building, and in its place, creation of a new three-story Research Support Building of approximately 100,000 gross square feet (GSF). NASA is in the process of creating a new centralized downtown campus area at Lewis Field with the Research Support Building being at its new central hub. The Research Support building will house support offices such as a credit union, cafeteria, etc on the first floor and federal office space on the 2nd and 3rd floors. The proposed building will be located at NASA’s Glenn Research Center (GRC) located on Lewis Field in Cleveland, Ohio. This new project will need to be responsive to NASA’s overall campus and master plan and is adjacent to a National Register Historic District. PN-Y0305017 NEW VETERINARY CLINIC BUILDING Mentor, OH (Lake Co.) 8240 Tyler Blvd. CONTRACTING METHOD: To Be Announced STATUS: Owner seeking conditional use permit and preliminary site plan approval. OWNER: Animal Emergency Clinic Northeast 3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


8250 Tyler Blvd., Unit C Mentor, OH 44060 http://aecne.com/ (440) 255-0770 ENGINEER: Jones Surveying, LLC 1924 Mentor Ave. Mentor, OH 44077 (440) 357-1811 DETAILS: Approx. 7,400 SF; veterinary clinic; 3.4 acre vacant lot; sitework; concrete; plumbing; electrical; HVAC; finishes PN-X0611069 NEW POLICE STATION Brecksville, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) 9020, 9028 and 9034 Brecksville Road CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids UPDATE: Owner will seek Architectural RFPs in 2013; no additional information has been released. OWNER: City of Brecksville 9069 Brecksville Road Brecksville, OH 44141 www.brecksville.oh.us (440) 526-4351 DETAILS: SF to be announced; trades could include sitework; thermal; and moisture protection; metals; wood and plastics; windows and doors; finishes; foundation; concrete; specialties; HVAC; electrical; mechanical; plumbing; specific details to be announced. PN-Y0315061 “CIRCLE OF WILDLIFE” CAROUSEL PROJECT Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) 3900 Wildlife Way CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids STATUS: Criteria Architect RFQs due Thursday, March 28, 2013 at 5:00 PM (To Owner) OWNER: Cleveland Metroparks 4101 Fulton Parkway Cleveland, OH 44144 www.clevelandmetroparks.com (216) 635-3200 FAX (216) 635-3286 Richard J. Kerber, Chief Planning and Design Officer, rjk@clevelandmetroparks.com DETAILS: RFQ No. 5902 Enclosed structure to surround the new “Circle of Wildlife” Carousel, Nature Play Zone, and Event Center to be located on the ground of Cleveland Metroparks Zoo; additional details to be determined. PN-Y0226067 MIXED-USE BUILDING The Village at Town Center Tallmadge, OH (Summit Co.) 76 North Ave. CONTRACTING METHOD: Owner/Developer Subcontracts (By Invitation Only) UPDATE: Announcing Architect; project dependent on owner receiving federal senior tax credits; city applied for Summit County Home Investment Partnership grant. OWNER/DEVELOPER: Testa Builders

2335 2nd Street Cuyahoga Falls, OH 44221 www.testacompanies.com (330) 928-1988 FAX (330) 928-7755 ARCHITECT: Mota Design Group 2321 Second St. Suite 102

Cuyahoga Falls, OH 44221 motadesigngroup.com (234) 738-2840 FAX (330) 947-3009 DETAILS: Phase one will include a four-story mixed-use building; low-income senior apartments; market-rate condominiums; retail space; sitework;

0DNLQJ \RX ORRN JRRG LV RXU EXVLQHVV 5HVLGHQWLDO FRPPHUFLDO ODQGVFDSH LQVWDOODWLRQ PDLQWHQDQFH 6LQFH

LLQIR#UEVWRXWLQF FRP I # E W

ZZZ UEVWRXWLQF FRP

Built to work. for you.

As a Krill client, you receive the benefit of a professional construction resource available to you. Anytime. You can count on us to help you out whenever questions or ideas arise.

Star t working with Krill. Visit krill.com or call 216.357.4777

www.propertiesmag.com 67


concrete; plumbing; electrical; HVAC; finishes.

Dedicated to real estate & building progress in Northeast Ohio since 1946 ,16,'( (XFOLG &RPPRQV DW &68 6WHSKDQLH 7XEEV -RQHV 7UDQVLW &HQWHU &($

TODAY

,16,'( :KLWH 3RQG 7KH 5HVLGHQFHV DW 6L[ 6L[ (LJKW 3DUWQHUV IRU 8URORJ\ +HDOWK

January 2011/$7.95

June 2010/$6.95

)\PSKPUN /HYTVU` Celebrat 65 Yearsing

11Haa Z[\KPLZ WYVNYHT [HRLZ [ KP [ R JLU[LY Z[HNL H[ 6ILYSPU *VSSLNL ^P[O KYHTH[PJ UL^ MHJPSP[`

Since 1946

,16,'( 'HYHORSHUV 'LYHUVLILHG 5HDOW\ +4 7ULSRLQW 0HGLFDO &HQWHU 3K\VLFLDQV 3DYLOLRQ

Pinnacle of Patient Care

December 2009/$6.95

University Hospitals weds wellness, healthcare at new Ahuja Medical Center

2010

73<:! ,U]PYVUTLU[HS :VS\[PVUZ :WLJPHS :LJ[PVU

INSIDE: INSI IDEE: Wellington Weellingto lling P Place laace • East Hall at Hiram College • Security Securitty & Fire Fire Prevention Prev

October Octo Octobe oberr 20 2008/$6.95 200 008 08/ 08 8/$6 $66.95

-VY^HYK 7YVNYLZZ

PLUS: Financial Review & Forecast 2010/2011

<UP]LYZP[` VMM (RYVU JOHYNLZ <UP]LYZP[` VM (RYVU JOHYNLZ HOLHK ^P[O UL^ 0UMV*PZPVU :[HKP\T :\TTH -PLSK

Crunching C i the numbers on Northeast Ohio’s real estate & construction markets

73<:!

,16,'( /DQGHUEURRN 'HQWDO 2IILFH %XLOGLQJ )<03; ;6 :<0; 6SHFLDO ,QVHUW *LDPEURQH &RPSDQLHV A special look at Construction Management in Northeast Ohio November 2008/$6.95

2000

Class Act

Dramatic renovation re-imagines Hanna Theatre as permanent home for Great Lakes Theater Festival

,16,'( 6WRQHEULGJH 3OD]D 1DJHOH 0DQXIDFWXULQJ &R 6HFXULW\ )LUH 3UHYHQWLRQ

G[lgZ]j *((/' .&1-

Healthy Progress

1990

Cleveland Clinic expands presence, capabilities with Miller Family Pavilion, Glickman Tower and 89th Street Garage & Service Center

HIGHFLYING

DESIGN Celebrated Viennese architectural firm creates new Akron Art Museum addition as cultural beacon

PLUS Cleveland Clinic Courts equips Cavs with state-of-the-art athletic training facility

PN-Y0308053 DRURY PLAZA HOTEL Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) 1380 East Sixth Street CONTRACTING METHOD: To Be Announced STATUS: Developer has just recently purchased property; options are being considered; no additional information has been released. DEVELOPER: Drury Southwest Inc. 101 Farrar Drive Cape Girardeau, MO 63701 (573) 335-3134 FAX (573) 335-5125 DETAILS: Former Cleveland Metropolitan School District headquarters to be converted/ renovated into a Drury Plaza; specific details to be announced. PN-V0602086 NEW POLICE STATION Copley Township, OH (Summit Co.) Sunset Drive off Copley Road ESTIMATED AMOUNT: $5,400,000 CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids UPDATE: Owner and architect finalizing contract; owner seeking funding. OWNER: Copley Township - Summit Co. 1540 S. Cleve-Mass Road Copley, OH 44321 www.copley.oh.us

Proudly serving Cleveland for 100 years

1980

Complete Pest Control Services FHA/VA/HUD Termite Inspections/Pretreatments Residential - Commercial Industrial Integrated Pest Management Programs Wild Animal/Bat Removal Pre-Construction Animal Exclusion Consulting Industrial Weed Control Sentricon™ Termite Colony Elimination System

1970

1960

Cleveland Chemical Pest Control, Inc. Quality Pest Control Service Since 1903

1950

18400 S. Waterloo Road Cleveland

216-481-8400 Free Telephone Consultation

1946

www.propertiesmag.com w ww 68

™-Trademark of Dow AgroSciences

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


(330) 666-1853 ARCHITECT: Horne & King Architects 7219 Sawmill Road, Suite 106 Dublin, OH 43016 www.horneandking.com (614) 766-6711 FAX (614) 766-6713 David King DETAILS: SF to be determined; new Copley Police Department station; 100-seat multipurpose room/back communication center; sitework; concrete; plumbing; electrical HVAC; finishes. PN-W0817084 NEW RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT CENTER Solon, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) CONTRACTING METHOD: To Be Announced UPDATE: Owner still seeking Army Corps of Engineers permit; no additional information has been released. OWNER: Nestle USA, Inc. 30003 Bainbridge Road Solon, OH 44139 (440) 349-5757 FAX (440) 498-7726 DETAILS: New global research and development center to be located on existing grounds off Hawthorne Parkway and Cannon Road; sitework; concrete; thermal and moisture protection; plumbing; electrical; HVAC; finishes; SF and specific details have not been determined at this time. PN-Y0311076 FORMER NASA GLENN NORTH CAMPUS REDEVELOPMENT Fairview Park, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) 21000 Brookpark Road ESTIMATED AMOUNT: $3,000,000 CONTRACTING METHOD: To Be Announced STATUS: Developer was high bidder in real estate auction; plans to be announced. DEVELOPER: RestoreCleveland 4205 St. Clair Ave. Cleveland, OH 44103 (216) 881-0644 PROPERTY OWNER: NASA Glenn Research Center 21000 Brookpark Road Cleveland, OH 44135 http://procurement.nasa.gov/cgi-bin/ EPS/bizops.cgi?gr=C&pin=22 (216) 433-4000 FAX (216) 433-5489 DETAILS: SF to be determined; renovate the two-building former NASA Glenn north campus to attract new tenants; sitework; concrete; plumbing; electrical; HVAC; finishes. details to be determined. PN-Y0108039 ADMINISTRATION - DATA CENTER Cleveland, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids UPDATE: Announcing Engineer; bidding possible late 2013. OWNER: Cuyahoga County Office of Procurement & Diversity

1219 Ontario Street, Room 110 Cleveland, OH 44113 opd.cuyahogacounty.us (216) 443-7200 FAX (216) 443-7206 AGENCY: Cuyahoga County Dept. of Public Works 2100 Superior Viaduct Cleveland, OH 44113 www.cuyctyengineers.org (216) 348-3800 FAX (216) 348-3896 ENGINEER: Karpinski Engineering - Cleveland 3135 Euclid Avenue Cleveland, OH 44115 www.karpinskieng.com (216) 391-3700 FAX (216) 391-0108 DETAILS: RFQ No. 26257 New Data Center to Cuyahoga County; SF to be announced; sitework; concrete; thermal and moisture protection; plumbing; electrical; HVAC; finishes; specific details to be determined. PN-Y0221037 CUYAHOGA COUNTY EMERGENCY OPERATIONS CENTER Broadview Heights Campus Broadview Heights, OH (Cuyahoga Co.) 9543 Broadview Road CONTRACTING METHOD: Public Bids STATUS: A/E Services RFQs due Friday, March 22, 2013 at 4:00 PM (To Owner) OWNER: City of Broadview Heights 9543 Broadview Road Broadview Heights, OH 44147 www.broadview-heights.org (440) 526-4357 DETAILS: The City of Broadview Heights wishes to construct a building of approximately 20,000 SF to be leased to Cuyahoga County as the County Emergency Operations Center (EOC). Initial estimates place the construction of the EOC (facility only) in the range of $5,000,000 to $6,000,000. The structure may contain classrooms, offices, simulation labs, training/conference space, kitchen, locker room and toilet facilities. The City of Broadview Heights is examining the potential efficiencies of relocating City Police, Fire, and/or Dispatch Center in the proposed EOC facility. The City is also considering constructing an additional 30,000 SF (approximate) building to house County emergency vehicles. These decisions will be made prior to the request for a Cost Proposal.

Construction Progress Reports are provided to Properties by CNCNewsOnline.com. For more comprehensive and up-to-date building and bidding information, call Construction News Corporation at 800.969.4700 or visit the website at www.CNCNewsOnline.com.

Please join us! Leadership Breakfast Series Engineering Opportunities & Solutions in Oil & Gas

FEX FNEG

10; #//'45 MAR Systems

ELX FNEG

0&4'9 *'4/#0 MesoCoat, Inc. .. 241)4#/5 9+.. $' *'.& #6U 4190' .#<# 0&'2'0&'0%' IGNN 1%-5+&' 1#& 0&'2'0&'0%'X T

7:30 a.m. - 9:00 a.m. +'9 #.. 241)4#/ &'6#+.5 #6 999T%'50'6T14)T #$.'5X 57$5%4+26+105 #0& 52105145*+25 #4' #8#+.#$.'T 14 /14' +0(14/#6+10 14 61 4')+56'4 %#.. FEJgGJEgGENNT -!'!:).% ).#

+5 # 2417& /'&+# 5210514 1( 6*' .'8'.#0& 0)+0''4+0) 1%+'6; www.propertiesmag.com 69


&RPLQJ LQ 0D\ .HQW 6WDWH 8QLYHUVLW\ :LOOLDPV +DOO /DE 5HQRYDWLRQ *UHHQEULDU +HDOWKFDUH &HQWHU 5HQRYDWLRQ :HVWHUQ 5HVHUYH +LVWRULFDO 6RFLHW\ &X\DKRJD &RXQW\ 3XEOLF /LEUDU\ ² 0D\ILHOG %UDQFK 3OXPELQJ +9$& DQG PRUH ,QWHUHVWHG LQ DGYHUWLVLQJ" &DOO 3URSHUWLHV WRGD\ DQG DQ DFFRXQW UHSUHVHQWDWLYH FDQ KHOS \RX DGGUHVV \RXU DGYHUWLVLQJ QHHGV

ZZZ SURSHUWLHVPDJ FRP 9LVLW XV RQOLQH IRU DUFKLYHG IHD

WXUH DUWLFOHV DGYHUWLVLQJ UDWHV VSHFV DQG VXEVFULSWLRQ LQIRUPD WLRQ

ZZZ SURSHUWLHVPDJ FRP

9LVLW XV RQOLQH WRGD\ WR GRZQORDG DUFKLYHG LVVXHV IHDWXULQJ OLYH K\SHUWH[W OLQNV WR DGYHUWLVHUV· ZHEVLWHV 7KH 0HGLD 3ODQQHU LV QRZ DYDLODEOH DV D 3') GRZQORDG 70

ADVERTISER INDEX 21st Century Concrete Construction, Inc...... 7 Absolute Roofing Inc. .........................................58 American International Construction ..........63 Americon Inc. ....................................................... 44 Arkinetics, Inc. .......................................................16 Art Window Coverings, Inc. .............................47 BOMA Greater Cleveland .................................... 9 Brennan & Associates ......................................... 11 Bruder Building Materials, Inc. ........................58 Buckeye Sweeping, Inc. .....................................12 Building Enclosure Council ..............................54 Buxton Roofing.....................................................63 Carey Roofing Corporation ..............................62 Carrissimi Photography .....................................49 CertaPro Painters .................................................71 Chagrin Valley Steel Erectors...........................34 Charles Schulz Building Company ................33 Chas. E Phipps Company, The ........................40 Clark & Post Architects, Inc. .............................51 Cleveland Chemical Pest Control, Inc. .........68 Cleveland Engineering Society ......................69 Cleveland Public Power .....................................24 CNC Construction News Corp .........................37 Coastal Quality Construction ..........................10 Columbia Building Products............................63 Construction Employers Association ...........13 Coppersmith Group, LLC...................................63 County Fire Protection Inc. ..............................46 Courtad Inc............................................................61 CTL Engineering, Inc...........................................65 Cunningham Paving Inc. ...................................39 Delta Industrial Services, Inc. ..........................31 DiSilvestro Roofing Co. ......................................65 EA Group .................................................................72 Ebersole Structural Engineers Ltd .................29 Educational Equipment .....................................32 ER Flynn, Co............................................................26 Flexible Pavements of Ohio .............................35 Giambrone Masonry, Inc. ..................................39 Graelic LLC ..............................................................46 H & M Snow Pros & Landscaping, Inc............. 2 Hecei Roof Coating System, Inc. ....................54 HMH Restoration Ltd. .........................................47 IMAGINiT Technologies .....................................18 Infinity Construction ............................................ 7 IQ Advisors, LLC ....................................................35 J.V. Janitorial Services, Inc. ................................33 Jamieson Ricca Co. ..............................................61 Krill Company, Inc ................................................67 Kurtz Bros. ...............................................................27 LandsKeepers, A Pattie Group Company ..... 41 Leff Electric ............................................................43 Light Bulb Supply ................................................33 Lisco Heating & Cooling, Inc. ...........................40 Mason Structural Steel, Inc. .............................60 McGraw-Hill Construction Network ............... 4 Messina Floor Covering, Inc. ............................40 Nelson Contracting ............................................. 11 Novogradac & Company, LLP ..........................27

Panzica Construction, Co. ................................15 Pease Photography .............................................45 Performance Painting ........................................20 Pete & Pete Container ........................................25 Precision Environmental Co.............................17 Precision ProCut ...................................................42 Premier Asphalt Paving, Co..............................43 R B Stout, Inc. .........................................................67 RFC Contracting, Inc. ..........................................49 Ronyak Paving ......................................................... 4 RSW/Wood Dimensions ....................................36 S.A. Comunale Company ..................................28 Sandglo Glass & Mirror Co. ...............................39 Siegel Jennings ...................................................... 6 Skoda Minotti Company ..................................... 3 Sobol Sales Co. ........................................................ 9 Southwest Companies Inc................................57 Space Comfort Co. ...............................................38 Spectra Contract Flooring ................................19 Spray Foam Technologies ................................58 Stark Group, The...................................................66 Sterling Professional Group .............................27 Structure Roofing Company, Inc....................55 Studio Techne Architects ..................................24 Suntrol Co. ..............................................................18 Technical Assurance............................................12 Thomarious Painting ..........................................22 Tusing Roofing Services ....................................64 Warren Roofing & Insulating Co. ....................15

INSERT: NAIOP AWARDS OF EXCELLENCE AIA ........................................................................ N-17 Ariel Ventures ................................................... N-14 Arkinetics, Inc. ...................................................N-11 Baker Hostetler ................................................ N-13 Bialosky & Partners Architects ....................N-11 CAM Inc............................................................... N-14 CBRE, Inc. .............................................................. N-9 Cooperative Business Services .....................N-7 CRESCO Real Estate .......................................... N-4 Duffy & Duffy Cost Segregation Services ............................................................. N-8 First American Title ........................................ N-15 First Federal Lakewood ................................ N-12 First Merit Bank .................................................N-11 Fogg Corporate Properties LLC ................. N-17 Geis Construction ........................................... N-24 Herschman Architects, Inc. ......................... N-20 Liberty Development ....................................N-22 Maguire Photographics ................................ N-20 mbi k2m Architecture ................................... N-17 McGladrey.............................................................N-2 Meyers Roman Friedberg & Lewis ............ N-14 Novogradac & Company, LLP ....................... N-4 Ostendorf Morris Financial Services ........ N-20 PNC Real Estate ...................................................N-7 RDL Architects.................................................... N-4 Taft, Strettinius & Hollister........................... N-19 Walter & Haverfield LLP ................................ N-12

3URSHUWLHV | April 2013


216.823.0064 cleveland.certapro.com


Ignoring your environmental issues won’t make them go away.

EA Group has provided environmental consulting and laboratory services to a wide range of clients for over 25 years. We’ve helped

BREATHE EASIER

hundreds of companies solve their most challenging environmental issues from assessments and analysis to project management and remediation. Stop hiding from the problem and put our team to work early to avoid environmental emergencies that can result in costly and unexpected delays. Our expert technicians are experienced in: • Asbestos and Hazardous Materials Management • Site Assessment and Remediation • Indoor Air Quality Assessment • Industrial Hygiene and Safety • Mold Remediation Management • Analytical Laboratory Support

800.875.3514 • 440.951.3514 • www.eagroupohio.com 7118 Industrial Park Boulevard • Mentor, OH 44060


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook