Damage Assessment Report

Damage Assessment Report

Address

Client

TILAL DE BEYROUYH Building Achrafieh/ Furn Elhayek

ADVANTA

Page |1

Contents A.

Introduction ........................................................................................ 4

Background .............................................................................................................. 4 Objective & Scope .................................................................................................... 5 The Surveyor ............................................................................................................ 5

B.

The Property ....................................................................................... 6

Full Address .............................................................................................................. 6

C.

The Inspection ..................................................................................... 7

The Procedure utilized .............................................................................................. 7 Limitations ................................................................................................................ 7

D.

The Building......................................................................................... 8

Overview .................................................................................................................. 8 The as-built Specification & Price Index .................................................................... 9

E.

Assessment Value Summary ............................................................. 13

F.

The Apartments ................................................................................ 14 Guide: how to read the report................................................................................ 14 Section Number: A4 ............................................................................................. 16 Section Number: A5 ............................................................................................. 22 Section Number: A6 ............................................................................................. 29 Section Number: A7 ............................................................................................. 33 Section Number: B4 ............................................................................................. 40 Section Number: B5 ............................................................................................. 45 Section Number: B6 ............................................................................................. 54 Section Number: B7 ............................................................................................. 62 Section Number: B8 ............................................................................................. 74 Section Number: B9 ............................................................................................. 82 Section Number: B10 ........................................................................................... 94 Section Number: B11 ......................................................................................... 101 Section Number: B12 ......................................................................................... 117 Page |2

Section Number: B13 ......................................................................................... 125 Section Number: B14 ......................................................................................... 143 Section Number: B15 ......................................................................................... 153 Section Number: B16 ......................................................................................... 165 Section Number: B17 ......................................................................................... 174 Section Number: B18 & B20 ............................................................................... 186 Section Number: B19 ......................................................................................... 197 Section Number: B21 ......................................................................................... 206 Section Number: B22 ......................................................................................... 214 Section Number: B23 ......................................................................................... 226 Section Number: B24 ......................................................................................... 234 Section Number: B25 ......................................................................................... 241 Section Number: B26 ......................................................................................... 251 Section Number: B27 ......................................................................................... 262 Section Number: B28 ......................................................................................... 273 Section Number: B29 ......................................................................................... 281 Section Number: B30 ......................................................................................... 291 Section Number: B31 ......................................................................................... 301 Section Number: B32 ......................................................................................... 319 Section Number: B33 ......................................................................................... 326 Section Number: B34 ......................................................................................... 337 Section Number: B35 ......................................................................................... 345 Section Number: B36 ......................................................................................... 367 Section Number: B37 ......................................................................................... 378 Section Number: B38 ......................................................................................... 388 Section Number: B39 ......................................................................................... 399 Section Number: B40 ......................................................................................... 407 Section Number: B41 ......................................................................................... 417

Page |3

A. Introduction Background On 4 August 2020, a large amount of ammonium nitrate stored at the port of the city of Beirut, the capital of Lebanon, exploded, causing at least 207 deaths, 7,500 injuries, and US$15 billion in property damage, and leaving an estimated 300,000 people homeless. A cargo of 2,750 tons of the substance (equivalent to around 1.1 kilotons of TNT) had been stored in a warehouse without proper safety measures for the previous six years, after having been confiscated by the Lebanese authorities from the abandoned ship MV Rhosus. The explosion was preceded by a fire in the same warehouse, but as of February 2021, the exact cause of the detonation is still under investigation.

The blast was also felt across Turkey, Syria, Israel, Palestine and parts of Europe, and was heard in Cyprus, more than 240 km (150 mi) away. It was detected by the United States Geological Survey as a seismic event of magnitude 3.3, and is considered one of the most powerful artificial non-nuclear explosions in history.

The Lebanese government declared a two-week state of emergency in response to the disaster. In its aftermath, protests erupted across Lebanon against the government for their failure to prevent the disaster, joining a larger series of protests which have been taking place across the country since 2019 Source: Wikipedia

Page |4

Objective & Scope Objective: 3DA has been instructed by “Advanta” / http://www.advantaglobal.com to conduct a loss assessment survey for the material losses directly resulting from the Beirut port blast which occurred on the 4th of August 2020, in “Tilal de Beyrouth” Building in Achrafiyeh.

As per the client’s instructions, we shall assess the damages to the apartments based on the original specification set by the promoter at the date of the construction completion Additional improvements by the apartment owners shall be disregarded.

Scope: The scope will be limited to the apartments’ closure, excluding the common areas and the exterior building skin, as follows:    

The apartment floor lift’s lobby (including the fire rated staircase door) The complete interior of the apartment The skin limited to the windows, the balconies’ parapet and the balustrade The second skin including balconies walls, windows & doors

The Surveyor The team:   

Architect Mohamed Chebaro Mr. Tony Abou Rizk Mrs. Rana Tabbara

Company name: 3rd DIMENSION Architects mohcheb@3da-lb.com www.3da-lb.com +961 1 750276

Page |5

B. The Property Full Address Coordinates

33°53'14.6"N, 35°31'00.7"E

District

Achrafieh/ Furn Elhayek

Street

Between George haymari street and Achrafieh street

Directions

Click on the map to access web google maps

Page |6

C. The Inspection The Procedure utilized 1. The survey visit: We have personally visited all the residential apartments and all the commercial sections in “Tilal de Beyrouth” building 2. The survey has been conducted visually, and photographs have been taken for all the damaged elements.

3. Although the normal procedures in such circumstances would have been to record and assess the damages before repairs, but due to the delay in our appointment very few apartments and offices remain not repaired to the date of our site survey, namely Apartment B13 and B35 only.

Since the majority of the apartments and offices have already been restored back to their original state prior to the process of evaluating the losses was as follows: a. Where available, we gathered photographs and videos of the damages shot by the owners prior of initiating the repairs. b. Where available, we gathered invoices of the repairs as submitted by the apartments’ owners. c. We have surveyed the repaired items in the presence of the apartment’s owner or his delegate who assisted us by verbally describing the damages.

Additionally, where possible, we have crosschecked during the survey the repairs with the available damage photographs and the invoices.

4. We have received a set of Architectural drawings in soft CAD format. These drawings were not as-built drawings; nevertheless, the general architectural layout was enough to assist us in taking all the required measurements. When the damaged item necessitated further on-site measurements, we have recorded such information during our survey visit.

Limitations 1. The photographs and videos shot by the owners were not intended at accurately documenting the damages at that time, but rather it was a general record of the apartment/ office state immediately after the blast. Therefore, the owner’s photographic document was assistive but not conclusive.

2. In most of the cases, the invoices were not detailed and ambiguous at times, since it did not accurately designate the nature and the location of the repairs undertaken.

Add to that, most of the invoices included repaired items that are not included in the scope of our assessment, and/ or included improvement to the original state of the damaged item. Therefore, we have referred to this document cautiously as a means of further clarifying the extent and nature of the damages reported by the owners.

In conclusion, the accuracy of the assessment was directly related to the accuracy and completeness of the proof of loss documents supplied by the owners, which varied extensively.

Page |7

According to all the above, we have extensively relied on our common sense, fair judgement and our expertise in the subject matter to reach a comprehensive assessment, which covers as accurately as possible the required repairs cost.

D. The Building Overview Number of Residential floors: Number of private apartment: Number of Offices: Number of Commercial space: Approximate year the building was completed:

22 38 3 1 2003

A (East) Floor Section #

B (West)

Owner's Name

Owner's Name

Section #

22

B41 André khalil Kamel

21

B40 Fady Karam

20

B39 Fouad Karam

19

B38

18

B37 Joelle Abou Jaoudé

Jacques Antoine Raphael - Rented to Vanda Barakat

B36

17

B35 Joseph Jreissati/ Byblos Bank SAL

Andree Emile Riachi

B34

16

B33 Paul Zahlan

Raymonde Sabbagh Ferneini

B32

15

B31 Ralda Maroun Boulos

Victor Gebara

B30

14

B29 Michel & Stephanie Philippe Chami

Fadi Nader

B28

13

B27 Pierre Chidiac

Rafic Mouawad

B26

12

B25 Rony Bridi

Sara Ghazi Shaker

B24

11

B23 Jihad Majid Saad

Ste Seaview SAL/ Fady Ziade

B22

10

B21 Alain Ibrahimcha

Nader Al Mously

B20

9

B19 Jacques Georges Sacy

Nader Al Mously

B18

8

B17 Georges Lorenz Real Estate Company SAL

Georges Lorenz Real Estate Company SAL

B16

7

B15 Ghassan Joseph Geagea

Fida Georges Boustany

B14

6

B13 Oussama Mandil

Fayez Najjar

B12

5

B11

Société Foncière du Mont-Liban SAL

Siham Eid Bekhazi

4

B9 Jacques Antoine Raphael

Kamal Zahlan

B10

3

B7 Claude Pierre Issa

Nabil Zahlan

B8

2

B5 Toufic Khoueiry

Laurice Rochdi Safadi

B6

1

B4

3

A7 Firm, T. L. L. SAL / El Khoury Law

2

A5

Hisham Jaroudi & Nadim Mounla

1

A4

Abella Delices SAL (Owner)/ Gray Mackenzie Retail Lebanon SAL – Rented to Spinneys

GF

A4

Abella Delices SAL (Owner)/ Gray Mackenzie Retail Lebanon SAL – Rented to Spinneys

-1

A4

Abella Delices SAL (Owner)/ Gray Mackenzie Retail Lebanon SAL – Rented to Spinneys

-2

A4

Abella Delices SAL (Owner)/ Gray Mackenzie Retail Lebanon SAL – Rented to Spinneys

Ste Tilal N. O /Mr. Michel & Randa Accad Block C: Commercial Ziad Chawki Fakhoury

A6

Page |8

The as-built Specification & Price Index Most of the owners have bought their apartments during the construction stage. Every owner had the opportunity to modify and improve his apartment layout and finishing specification as he wished. Therefore, each apartment is different with very few common items.

The building committee could not provide us with an “original builder’s specification” document which was ultimately the basis of the insurance policy; therefore, we have established a benchmark specification chart based on the owners feedback.

Note that wherever the sentence “Replace with similar” has been used, we are strictly referring to the original specifications for cost calculation, irrespective of the visible improvements by the owners.

Improvements by owners that have been damaged shall not be included in the current assessment.

Items that have been removed by the owners prior to the blast shall not be included.

This matrix includes the relative cost gathered by our team based on current market prices as follows:

Contractor's OH Division

Item

Division 8 - Doors &

All Aluminum Doors & Windows,

Windows

except bathrooms and Kitchens

Division 8 - Doors & Windows

Aluminum Windows: Kitchens

& profits

Total Cost/ $

Cash $

Check $

Aluminum "TECHNAL GX", Sliding + Double Glazing Clear

m2

$

205.00

30%

$

267.00

80%

20%

m2

$

155.00

30%

m2

$

185.00

m2

$

(8mm)

$

202.00

80%

20%

Clear

30%

$

241.00

80%

20%

135.00

30%

$

176.00

80%

20%

Aluminum "TECHNAL FX", Hinged Leaf + Single Glazing Clear Aluminum Door: Bedroom

Division 8 - Doors & Windows

Cost/$

Aluminum "TECHNAL FX", Hinged Leaf + Double Glazing Aluminum Door: Bedroom

Division 8 - Doors & Windows

unit

Aluminum "TECHNAL GX", Sliding + single Glazing Clear

Division 8 - Doors & Windows

Specifications

(8mm) Aluminum "TECHNAL FX", Hinged Leaf + Single Glazing

Aluminum Windows: Bathrooms

(8mm) Translucent

m2

$

145.00

30%

$

189.00

80%

20%

Windows

Aluminum windows: Fixed

Aluminum "TECHNAL", Fixed + Double Glazing Clear

m2

$

100.00

30%

$

130.00

80%

20%

Division 8 - Doors &

Glass: All Fenestrations except

Windows

bathrooms and kitchens

Double Glazing, Clear

m2

$

65.00

30%

$

85.00

80%

20%

Division 8 - Doors &

Page |9

Division 8 - Doors & Windows

Glass: Bathrooms

Single Glazing (8mm), Translucent

m2

$

35.00

30%

$

46.00

80%

20%

Glass: Kitchen

Single Glazing (8mm), Clear

m2

$

25.00

30%

$

33.00

80%

20%

Glass: Balustrade

6mm Laminated (Triplex) Black tinted glass

m2

$

50.00

30%

$

65.00

80%

20%

columns

Lm

$

125.00

30%

$

163.00

80%

20%

Double Glazing, laminated & tempered (10+10mm)

m2

$

225.00

30%

$

293.00

80%

20%

Division 8 - Doors & Windows Division 8 - Doors & Windows

Aluminum & Glass: Including rectangular handgrip + 6mm Division 8 - Doors &

Laminated (Triplex) Black tinted glass + black steel support

Windows

Balustrade, Complete

Division 8 - Doors &

Commercial Section: Glass

Windows

skylight

Division 8 - Doors &

Commercial Section: Glass for

Windows

door

Clear tempered glass (10mm)

m2

$

70.00

30%

$

91.00

80%

20%

Rolling Shutter

Wood, "Clear" Including painting

m2

$

155.00

30%

$

202.00

80%

20%

Rolling Shutter

Extruded Aluminum

m2

$

55.00

30%

$

72.00

80%

20%

Unit

$ 1,258.20

30%

$

1,636.00

80%

20%

Division 8 - Doors & Windows Division 8 - Doors & Windows Division 8 - Doors & Windows

Wood, Oak Veneered with solid oak frame and Architrave Main Door

Division 8 - Doors & Windows

including accessories (120x233cm=2.8m2) Wood, Oak Veneered, leaf only including accessories

Main Door

(120x233cm=2.8m2)

Unit

$

978.60

30%

$

1,272.00

80%

20%

Main Door Lock

Multi-Point Lock

Unit

$

250.00

30%

$

325.00

80%

20%

Main Door Cylinder

Cylinder only

Unit

$

25.00

30%

$

33.00

80%

20%

Division 8 - Doors & Windows Division 8 - Doors & Windows Division 8 - Doors & Windows

Wood, Oak Veneered with solid oak frame and Architrave Interior Door

(93x233cm=2.17m2)

Unit

$

595.90

30%

$

775.00

80%

20%

Interior Door

Wood, Oak Veneered, Leaf only (93x233cm=2.17m2)

Unit

$

300.10

30%

$

390.00

80%

20%

Interior Door

Plywood or MDF hollow core including paint (92x233cm)

Unit

$

289.39

30%

$

376.00

80%

20%

Division 8 - Doors & Windows Division 8 - Doors & Windows

P a g e | 10

Division 8 - Doors & Windows

Plywood or MDF hollow core, Leaf only, including paint Interior Door

(92x233cm)

Unit

$

150.05

30%

$

195.00

80%

20%

Interior Door

Solid wood including spray paint, Leaf only (92x250cm)

Unit

$

299.00

30%

$

389.00

80%

20%

Closets

Veneered Wood Leaf

m2

$

85.00

30%

$

111.00

80%

20%

Closets

Veneered Wood, Shelves

m2

$

60.00

30%

$

78.00

80%

20%

Division 8 - Doors & Windows Division 6 - Wood and Plastics Division 6 - Wood and Plastics Division 6 - Wood

MDF wood with a solid lipping including accessories, Spray

and Plastics

Closets

painted

m2

$

55.00

30%

$

72.00

80%

20%

Division 9 - Finishes

Kitchen

Laminated wood leaf

m2

$

45.00

30%

$

59.00

80%

20%

Division 9 - Finishes

False Ceiling

MDF wood with a solid lipping, Spray painted

m2

$

45.00

30%

$

59.00

80%

20%

Division 9 - Finishes

False Ceiling

Wood veneered with solid lipping

m2

$

70.00

30%

$

91.00

80%

20%

Division 9 - Finishes

False Ceiling

Modular Gypsum panels, painted, including support tracks

m2

$

25.00

30%

$

33.00

80%

20%

Division 9 - Finishes

False Ceiling

Modular PVC panels, including support tracks

m2

$

17.00

30%

$

22.00

80%

20%

Division 9 - Finishes

False Ceiling

Gypsum Board including paint

m2

$

35.00

30%

$

46.00

80%

20%

135.00

30%

$

176.00

80%

20%

Wood strips: "Clear" including necessary reinforcement and Division 9 - Finishes

False Ceiling: Balconies

clear paint

m2

$

Division 9 - Finishes

Wall Plastering

Sand & Cement plaster

m2

$

8.00

30%

$

10.00

80%

20%

Division 9 - Finishes

Wall Cladding

Travertine tiles

m2

$

125.00

30%

$

163.00

80%

20%

Division 9 - Finishes

Wall Cladding

Ceramic tiles

m2

$

45.00

30%

$

59.00

80%

20%

Division 9 - Finishes

Threshold

Marble

m2

$

110.00

30%

$

143.00

80%

20%

Division 9 - Finishes

Paint

Eggshell acrylic emulsion

m2

$

12.00

30%

$

16.00

80%

20%

Division 9 - Finishes

Paint

Clear Lacquer on wood doors and leafs

m2

$

8.00

30%

$

10.00

80%

20%

Division 9 - Finishes

Paint

Clear Lacquer on wood false ceilings and rolling shutters

m2

$

11.00

30%

$

14.00

80%

20%

Division 9 - Finishes

Paint

Spray paint on wood

m2

$

13.00

30%

$

17.00

80%

20%

Division 9 - Finishes

Acrylic glass

translucent acrylic panels

m2

$

22.00

30%

$

29.00

80%

20%

Spot light

Interior LED Spot light, European

Unit

$

18.00

30%

$

23.00

70%

30%

Spot light

Exterior IP rated Spot light, European

Unit

$

28.00

30%

$

36.00

70%

30%

Division 16 Electrical Division 16 Electrical

P a g e | 11

Division 15 Mechanical

Water Cabinet

European WC with related accessories and installation

Unit

$

300.00

Bidet

European Bidet with related accessories and installation

Unit

$

225.00

Rolling shutter motor

Somfy motor

Unit

$

235.00

Restore to original condition (Labor Units)

Unit

$

20.00

$

390.00

70%

30%

30%

$

293.00

70%

30%

30%

$

306.00

70%

30%

$

26.00

50%

50%

30%

Division 15 Mechanical Division 15 Mechanical

Effort driven repairs (Labor Miscellaneous

Intensive)

30%

P a g e | 12

E. Assessment Value Summary Block Floor

Consolidated Data Column Labels Section Check $

C C C

A4 A5 A6

$3,570.40 $15,036.88 $18,607.28 $7,333.31 $30,884.53 $38,217.84 $1,017.49 $4,244.56 $5,262.05

A7

$5,255.12 $22,132.15 $27,387.27

B4 B5 B6 B7 B8 B9 B10 B11 B12 B13 B14 B15

$1,266.24 $1,858.90 $3,398.90 $2,796.72 $2,252.33 $2,710.95 $3,588.34 $6,568.09 $2,977.20 $5,350.14 $2,801.26 $2,941.24

B16

$2,928.57 $11,764.69 $14,693.26

B17 B18+B20 B19 B21 B22 B23 B24 B25 B26 B27 B28

$4,229.55 $3,718.15 $4,137.02 $4,635.24 $4,098.94 $1,573.99 $1,532.21 $3,502.59 $3,532.03 $4,093.09 $3,538.94

$17,487.73 $15,649.99 $17,341.92 $19,236.96 $17,069.81 $6,506.95 $6,452.94 $14,665.93 $14,631.13 $16,425.21 $13,893.63

$21,717.29 $19,368.13 $21,478.94 $23,872.20 $21,168.76 $8,080.94 $7,985.15 $18,168.52 $18,163.16 $20,518.30 $17,432.57

B29 B30 B31 B32 B33 B34 B35

$2,945.27 $3,377.45 $6,003.14 $1,841.78 $4,082.93 $2,185.67 $2,883.83

$11,509.81 $13,651.00 $22,536.25 $7,515.94 $16,879.59 $9,083.08 $10,934.20

$14,455.07 $17,028.45 $28,539.39 $9,357.72 $20,962.52 $11,268.75 $13,818.03

B36 B37

$2,865.63 $11,097.81 $13,963.44 $2,345.01 $9,453.98 $11,799.00

C A A B A B A B A+B B A B A B A B A A B A B A B A B A B A B A B A B A A A A A

Owner Abella Delices SAL (Owner)/ Gray Mackenzie Retail Lebanon SAL – GF Spinneys 2 Hisham Jaroudi 3 Fakhoury, Ziad Chawki Firm, T. L. L SAL / El Khoury Law/ 3 Société Independance sal Ste Tilal N. O /Mr. Michel &Randa 1 Accad 2 Toufic Khoueiry 2 Laurice Rochdi Safadi 3 Claude Pierre Issa 3 Nabil Zahlan 4 Jacques Antoine Raphael 4 Kamal Zahlan 5 Siham Eid Bekhazi 6 Fayez Najjar 6 Oussama Mandil 7 Fida Georges Boustany 7 Ghassan Joseph Geagea Georges Lorenz Real Estate 8 Company SAL Georges Lorenz Real Estate 8 Company SAL 10 & 11 Nader Al Mously 9 Jacques Georges Sacy 10 Alain Ibrahimcha 11 Ste Seaview SAL 11 Jihad Majid Saad 12 Sara Ghazi Shaker 12 Rony Bridi 13 Rafic Mouawad 13 Pierre Chidiac 14 Fadi Nader Michel & Stephanie Philippe 14 Chami 15 Victor Gebara 15 Ralda Maroun Boulos 16 Raymonde Sabbagh Ferneini 16 Paul Zahlan 17 Andree Emile Riachi 17 Joseph Jreissati/ Byblos Bank SAL Jacques Antoine Raphael/ Rented 18 by Vanda Barakat 18 Joelle Abou Jaoudé Société Foncière du Mont-Liban 19 SAL 20 Fouad Karam 21 Fady Karam 22 André khalil Kamel

B38 B39 B40 B41 Grand Total

$8,716.26 $2,482.70 $4,784.19 $2,885.55 $144,606.40

Fresh $

$4,519.83 $7,259.73 $14,091.03 $11,046.79 $9,021.44 $10,543.28 $15,162.15 $27,111.88 $12,538.61 $22,146.13 $9,683.82 $12,061.95

$36,221.06 $10,212.10 $20,047.18 $10,709.54 $588,463.19

Grand Total

$5,786.07 $9,118.63 $17,489.94 $13,843.50 $11,273.77 $13,254.22 $18,750.49 $33,679.98 $15,515.81 $27,496.26 $12,485.08 $15,003.19

$44,937.32 $12,694.80 $24,831.37 $13,595.09 $733,069.60

P a g e | 13

F. The Apartments Guide: how to read the report For each apartment/ office you shall find: a) A key plan: An architectural layout where the rooms have been selectively numbered (1, 2, 3…)

On this Key plan all damages have been annotated at the approximate location using a color coded circle with a number as shown below

Room number

Damage number

Legend

Total Loss

Partial Loss

Repairable

Not Included

2. Attachments: Digital archive comprising a number of folders with the following content: a) Excel Sheets (Soft copy): Tables describing the damage: Location, type, category etc… as well as the required repairs and related costs b) Documents submitted by the owners: i. Invoices ii. damage photos and videos c) Architectural drawing: CAD format including all floors, sections and elevations of the building. These drawings have been provided by the building committee and have been compiled in one file for ease of reference.

P a g e | 14

3. A table which will describe the damage: Location, type, category etc… as well as the required repairs and related costs, as shown below Section Number

Room Number

Item Number

Referenced with colors on Key plan Section No. Room No.

B35.21b Item No. Photo a, b….

P a g e | 15

Section Number:

2

B14

Block

B (West)

Floor

Owner

Fida Georges Boustany

7

Key plan showing the location and the category of the damages 1

2

5

3 4

1

2

3

4

1

4

6’

2

2 1

1

6 2

3

3

2

3

1

10 1

1

4

1

1

3

2

7

4

1

11

1

8

9 2

Legend

Total Loss

Partial Loss

3 Repairable

Not Included

P a g e | 143

P a g e | 144

Section: B14

1/8/

Photographic Document

B14.11a

B14.21b

B14.21a

B14.22a

P a g e | 145

Section: B14

2/8

Photographic Document

B14.23a

B14.41a

B14.24a

B14.41b

P a g e | 146

Section: B14

3/8

Photographic Document

B14.42a

B14.43a

B14.51a

B14.52a

P a g e | 147

Section: B14

4/8

Photographic Document

B14.52b

B14.53a

B14.54a

B14.61a

P a g e | 148

Section: B14

5/8

Photographic Document

B14.62a

B14.6'1a

B14.71a

B14.72a

P a g e | 149

Section: B14

Photographic Document

6/8

B14.73a

B14.74a

B14.91a

B14.92a

P a g e | 150

Section: B14

7/8

Photographic Document

B14.101a

B14.102a

B14.103a

P a g e | 151

Section: B14

8/8

Photographic Document

B14.104a

B14.111a

P a g e | 152

Section Number:

B28

Block

B (West)

Floor

Owner

Fadi Nader

14

Key plan showing the location and the category of the damages

2

1

3

3 3

2

2

10 1 4

71

2

1

2

1

1 1

3

1

9

8

3 34

2

3 3

1

1

6

2

5

2

1

11

12

2 1

Legend

Total Loss

Partial Loss

Repairable

Not Included

P a g e | 273

P a g e | 274

Section: B28

1/2

Photographic Document

B28.11a

B28.12a

B28.31a

B28.32a

P a g e | 275

Section: B28

1/2

Photographic Document

B28.33a

B28.41a

B28.42a

B28.43a

P a g e | 276

Section: B28

Photographic Document

2/2

B28.51a

B28.52a

B28 61a

B28.71a

P a g e | 277

Section: B28

Photographic Document

2/2

B28.81a

B28.82a

B28.83a

B28.84a

P a g e | 278

Section: B28

Photographic Document

2/2

B28.92a

B28.93a

B28.94a

B28.101a

P a g e | 279

Section: B28

Photographic Document

2/2

B28.102a

B28.111a

B28.112a

B28.121a

P a g e | 280