CELEBRATING OUR ONE-HUNDRED AND TWENTY-FIFTH YEAR OF EDITORIAL FREEDOM Thursday, September 24, 2015
Ann Arbor, Michigan
michigandaily.com
ACADEMICS
Canvas to replace CTools by fall 2016 AMANDA ALLEN/Daily
Republican presidential candidate Ben Carson speaks to supporters at a campaign rally at the Spring Arbor University Fieldhouse on Wednesday.
Carson talks social issues, education during Mich. stop GOP presidential contender, ‘U’ alum emphasizes conservative values By EMMA KINERY Daily Staff Reporter
SPRING ARBOR, Mich. — Chanting “Go Ben, Go!” and “USA! USA! USA!” the crowd of Ben Carson supporters who filled Spring Arbor University’s gym-
nasium exploded with applause as the former neurosurgeon and University alum walked on stage. Recent polls place Carson, who is running for the Republican nomination for president, in second or third place in the GOP field, behind Donald Trump and in close competition with former Hewlett-Packard CEO Carly Fiorina. Known for his Christian principles and rags-to-riches story, it’s not surprising Carson chose to speak at the small Christian university in Spring Arbor. Brent
Ellis, Spring Arbor University president, led the crowd in prayer during his opening remarks. Prior to Caron’s arrival, Sen. Mike Shirkey (R–Clarklake) and Rep. Earl Poleski (R–Jackson) eased the anxious crowd awaiting Carson — who was stuck in traffic — with a rendition of “God Bless America.” Carson opened his speech by describing his life story, reflecting on how his mother’s faith in God helped him excel in school. In elementary school, Carson said he struggled academically
and envied others in class who were naturally gifted in school. Growing up in poverty in Detroit, his mother forced him and his brother to get serious about their education by making each of the boys write a book report every week — it was only later they discovered she was illiterate. “I was not very enthusiastic about this program — and that’s putting it very lightly — I didn’t want to do that, her friends were always criticizing her. They See CARSON, Page 3A
After pilot, provost says new learning platform received positive feedback By GENEVIEVE HUMMER Daily Staff Reporter
Say goodbye to CTools. In an e-mail Wednesday afternoon, University Provost Martha E. Pollack and Laura M. Patterson, associate vice president and chief information officer, announced that beginning with the fall 2016 semester, all new course sites will be hosted by Canvas. Canvas, piloted during the 2014-2015 academic year, is a digital course management system with discussion boards, classroom notifications and a platform for submitting assignments, among other features. The pilot included more than 10,000 students, 150 instructors
GREEK LIFE
BUSINESS
After 81 years, ‘Mud Bowl’ may conclude streak IFC prevents Greek life involvement in annual event after SAE loses charter By JACKIE CHARNIGA Daily Staff Reporter
The Mud Bowl, a charity touch football game hosted annually by the University’s since-disbanded chapter of Sigma Alpha Epsilon fraternity, will not be played this year. In the last five years, the event has raised more than $100,000 for C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital. The Interfraternity Council has said Mud Bowl cannot be held due to a standing policy that forbids fraternities from co-sponsoring events with chapters that have been disbanded. The University’s SAE chapter, which has hosted the football game for 82 years, lost recognition from its national chapter this year. The policy forbids fraternities from co-sponsoring events with illegitimate organizations — such as an organization that is on social probation, suspended or expelled from the IFC — or they run the risk being disbanded themselves.
Though IFC can’t prevent a private group from hosting an event, Greek life members — who have historically made up a large portion of the event’s participants — would face discipline if they were to participate this year. IFC President Alex Krupiak said the policy was not created with the knowledge that it would result in the discontinuation of Mud Bowl. He said, at that time, SAE was in good standing with the IFC. SAE was expelled from the IFC in 2011 for hazing. “It’s not something that was created in recent times,” Krupiak said, “It was definitely more than three years ago at minimum.” Former SAE President Brett Mizzi, a Business senior, said Greek life is misapplying the policy, because anyone who forms a sevenperson team is invited to participate. “The fact that the University is trying to intervene on individual students’ decisions about whether to play a touch football game or not is absurd,” Mizzi said. Public Policy junior Zachary Dubin, a former member of SAE, said halting the tradition of Mud Bowl was unfair to previous generaSee MUD BOWL, Page 3A
and 130 courses. Of that group, 92 percent of faculty and 100 percent of student focus group participants either preferred Canvas to CTools or were neutral to the change. In a press release, Wallace Hopp, professor of industrial and operations engineering and Business School associate dean for learning and design, said his transition to Canvas went smoothly. “I love the fact that it’s becoming a standard in our industry. I’m talking to some of the other top business schools and they’re on Canvas, making it very easy for us to share best practices,” he said. “I converted over to Canvas this year and I’m really pleased. I am facilitating a flipped classroom delivery and have set-up digital videos and online assessments through Canvas. It’s worked flawlessly for me.” The flipped classroom is a model in which lectures are delivered online and are watched outside of class, allowing profesSee CTOOLS, Page 3A
Pub trolley to launch in downtown Ann Arbor MARINA ROSSDAILY
University Planner Sue Gott discusses potential locations of the Trotter Multicultural Center during a focus group at the current Trotter Multicultural Center location on Wednesday.
Harper outlines plans for new multicultural center Some students say they prefer renovation of current facility By ALLANA AKHTAR Daily Staff Reporter
During the height of #BBUM — the student-driven campaign that aimed to draw attention to the experiences and challenges of Black students on campus — the movement’s leadership stressed the importance of relocating the Trotter Multicultur-
al Center closer to campus. But at a forum on Wednesday, several students were hesitant about moving the facility, even as the University considers options for a new location. E. Royster Harper, vice president for student life, joined several University officials at Trotter to solicit input on the process. During the session, Harper emphasized the need to honor the legacy of the original facility, even if the University moves forward with plans to construct a new one. University officials also discussed a potential the timeline for building a new center and
provided their perspective on the decision-making process. The speakers included University Planner Susan Gott and Diana Adzemovic, senior design project manager for Architecture, Engineering and Construction at the University. There are currently three locations under consideration for the construction of a new multicultural center: the site of the current Michigan News Service building on Maynard Street, between Betsy Barbour and Helen Newberry Residence Halls on State Street and near the Munger Residences on See TROTTER, Page 2A
Peddle-powered, booze-friendly tour to stop at city landmarks, bars By ISOBEL FUTTER Daily Staff Reporter
Trolley Pub, which offers pedal-powered trolley tours in cities across the country and encourages riders of age to bring their own alcohol, is opening a branch in downtown Ann Arbor. The trolleys can transport up to 14 riders, who all help prop the trolley with foot pedals, similar to a paddle board. The BYOB-style pub also offers hop-on, hop-off service at several Ann Arbor bars and local landmarks. Ann Arbor Trolley Pub will start offering rides on Friday, beginning at the Heidelberg restaurant on Main Street. For the first two weeks, the company will offer free promotional rides. Customers are allowed to bring their own beer and wine for the jourSee PUB, Page 3A
the fashion b-side » INSIDE
WEATHER TOMORROW
HI: 77 LO: 51
GOT A NEWS TIP? Call 734-418-4115 or e-mail news@michigandaily.com and let us know.
A look at the threads seen on Tree Town’s streets
NEW ON MICHIGANDAILY.COM Safe sex store closing in October MICHIGANDAILY.COM/SECTION/NEWS
INDEX
Vol. CXXIV, No. 132 ©2015 The Michigan Daily michigandaily.com
NEWS......................... 2A OPINION.....................4A SPORTS......................5A
SUDOKU.....................2A CL ASSIFIEDS............... 5A B-SIDE ....................1B
News
2A — Thursday, September 24, 2015
MONDAY: This Week in History
TUESDAY: Campus Voices
WEDNESDAY: In Other Ivory Towers
CRAZY CRAIG
The Michigan Daily — michigandaily.com
THURSDAY: Twitter Talk
FRIDAY: Photos of the Week
Presidential candidate Dr. Ben Carson spoke today in Spring Arbor, Mich. “Thank you to everyone who came to our rally in Jackson, Michigan!” —@RealBenCarson
“ DAVID SONG/Daily
Ypsilanti resident Craig Wise juggles on the Diag on Wednesday. Wise runs a family comedy juggling variety show business under the name of “Crazy Craig”.
LSA Dean Andrew Martin met with students Monday.
“Great evening. Stop 2. Meeting some of our newest #LSAstudents on scholarships. Wow. Giving back in big ways.” — @ProfADM
“
Each week, “Twitter Talk” is a forum to print tweets that are fun, informative, breaking or newsworthy, with an angle on the University, Ann Arbor and the state. All tweets have been edited for accurate spelling and grammar.
FOLLOW US!
#TMD
@michigandaily
Gov. Rick Snyder tweeted his support for University’s Mott’s Children’s Hospital.
“I joined the fight to #BlockOutCancer with @ MottChildren. Let’s help all the #LittleVictors” - @onetoughnerd
CAMPUS EVENTS & NOTES
THREE THINGS YOU SHOULD KNOW TODAY
Social justice fair
Fall open house
Dance performance
Flute and guitar duo
WHAT: Learn about student organizations and programs on campus dedicated to social justice. Sociology faculty will also discuss the social change minor. WHO: Department of Sciology WHEN: Today at 11 a.m. WHERE: The Diag
WHAT: Tour the International Institute. Discover academic and funding opportunities. WHO: Intertnaional Institute WHEN: Today from 12 p.m to 3 p.m. WHERE: School of Social Work Building
WHAT: Join Amy Chavasse, professor of dance, for a lecture and performance centered around Chinese dance. WHO: School of Music, Theatre & Dance WHEN: Today at 12 p.m. WHERE: Vandenberg Room, Michigan League
WHAT: Flutist Tracey Kash and guitarist Pat Shanley will perfrom a wide variety of blues and rock ensembles. WHO: Gifts of Art WHEN: Today from 12:10 p.m. to 1 p.m. WHERE: University Hospital, Main Lobby
Applying to law school 101
Peace Corps workshop
Lecture on graphic arts
BP America info session
WHAT: The Career Center will review the law school admission process and provide tips on how to submit a strong application. All students are invited. WHO: Career Center WHEN: Today from 1 p.m. to 2 p.m. WHERE: Program Room, The Career Center, 3200 Student Activities Building
WHAT: Learn about the Peace Corps as well as receive help on applications for the international program during this workshop. WHO: International Center WHEN: Today from 4 p.m. to 5:30 p.m. WHERE: Conference Room, International Center
WHAT: Anthony Geist, a Spanish and comparative literature porfessor, will talk about visual postmodern discourse in Madrid during the ‘70s. WHO: Romance Languages and Literature WHEN: Today at 4 p.m. WHERE: RLL Commons, Modern Languages Building
WHAT: An opportunity to learn about careers offered by BP America. The company is seeking math, statistics, economics, finance, accounting and engineering majors. WHO: Career Center WHEN: Today from 5:30 p.m to 7 p.m. WHERE: Room 420, Ross School of Business
1
New York Yankees catcher and baseball icon Yogi Berra passed away on Tuesday, The New York Times reported. He was 90 years old. Berra was a three-time American League MVP. He also received a Purple Heart for his service in World War II.
2
Main Street boutique Ayla & Co., founded by a Turkish immigrant in 1980, brings a clean, classic and distinctive aesthetic to Tree Town’s fashionably inclined.
Editor in Chief 734-418-4115 ext. 1251 jcalfas@michigandaily.com
Business Manager 734-418-4115 ext. 1241 rfilipp@michigandaily.com
Newsroom
News Tips
734-418-4115 opt. 3
news@michigandaily.com
Corrections
Letters to the Editor
corrections@michigandaily.com
tothedaily@michigandaily.com
Arts Section
Editorial Page
arts@michigandaily.com
opinion@michigandaily.com
Sports Section
Photography Section
sports@michigandaily.com
photo@michigandaily.com
Display Sales
Classified Sales
dailydisplay@gmail.com
classified@michigandaily.com
Online Sales
Finance
onlineads@michigandaily.com
finance@michigandaily.com
EDITORIAL STAFF Lev Facher
Managing Editor
Sam Gringlas
lfacher@michigandaily.com
Managing News Editor
gringlas@michigandaily.com
SENIOR NEWS EDITORS: Shoham Geva, Will Greenberg, Amabel Karoub, Emma Kerr, Emilie Plesset, Michael Sugerman ASSISTANT NEWS EDITORS: Tanaz Ahmed, Alyssa Brandon, Katie Penrod, Sami Wintner, Gen Hummer, Emma Kinery, Tanya Madhani, Lara Moehlman, Lea Giotto, Isabel Futter
Aarica Marsh and Derek Wolfe Editorial Page Editors
opinioneditors@michigandaily.com
SENIOR EDITORIAL PAGE EDITORS: Claire Bryan and Regan Detwiler ASSISTANT EDITORIAL PAGE EDITORS: Mary Kate Winn, Melissa Scholke, Stephanie Trierweiler, Ben Keller
Max Cohen and Jake Lourim Managing Sports Editors
sportseditors@michigandaily.com
SENIOR SPORTS EDITORS: Max Bultman, Minh Doan, Jacob Gase, Erin Lennon, Jason Rubinstein, Zach Shaw ASSISTANT SPORTS EDITORS: Chloe Aubuchon, Kelly Hall, Ted Janes, Simon Kaufman, Kevin Santo, Brad Whipple
Adam Depollo and Chloe Gilke Managing Arts Editors
adepollo@michigandaily.com chloeliz@michigandaily.com
SENIOR ARTS EDITORS: Jamie Bircoll, Kathleen Davis, Catherine Sulpizio, Adam Theisen ARTS BEAT EDITORS: Alex Bernard, Karen Hua, Jacob Rich, Amelia Zak
Allison Farrand and Ruby Wallau Managing Photo Editors
photo@michigandaily.com
SENIOR PHOTO EDITORS: Luna Anna Archey, James Coller, Virginia Lozano ASSISTANT PHOTO EDITORS: Amanda Allen, Zach Moore, Sam Mousigian
Emily Schumer and design@michigandaily.com Shane Achenbach Managing Design Editors Ian Dillingham Magazine Editor statement@michigandaily.com DEPUTY MAGAZINE EDITORS: Natalie Gadbois STATEMENT PHOTO EDITOR: Luna Anna Archey STATEMENT LEAD DESIGNER: Jake Wellins
Hannah Bates and Laura Schinagle Managing Copy Editors
copydesk@michigandaily.com
SENIOR COPY EDITORS: Emily Campbell and Emma Sutherland
Amrutha Sivakumar Online Editor amrutha@michigandaily.com Kaylla Cantilina and Katie Colosimo Managing Video Editors Carolyn Gearig Special Projects Manager
BUSINESS STAFF
SEE B-SIDE, PG. 1B
3
420 Maynard St. Ann Arbor, MI 48109-1327 www.michigandaily.com JENNIFER CALFAS ROSE FILIPP
Volkswagon CEO Martin Winterkorn, resigned from the company Wednesday, CNN reported. VW was recently found cheating its EPA emission tests for diesel cars. The diesel emissions were up to 35 times higher.
Hussein Hakim Finance and Operations Manager Claire Ulak Production Manager Jordan Yob Marketing Manager Matt Pfenning UAccounts Manager Chris Wang Classifieds Manager Asja Kepes Local Accounts Colin Cheesman National Accounts Anna He Special Guides and Online Manager The Michigan Daily (ISSN 0745-967) is published Monday through Friday during the fall and winter terms by students at the University of Michigan. One copy is available free of charge to all readers. Additional copies may be picked up at the Daily’s office for $2. Subscriptions for fall term, starting in September, via U.S. mail are $110. Winter term (January through April) is $115, yearlong (September through April) is $195. University affiliates are subject to a reduced subscription rate. On-campus subscriptions for fall term are $35. Subscriptions must be prepaid. The Michigan Daily is a member of The Associated Press and The Associated Collegiate Press.
Mathematics professor Safe Sex Store closes dies of heart attack amid declining sales Peter Smereka won teaching honors, national awards By TANAZ AHMED Daily Staff Reporter
Mathematics Prof. Peter Smereka died unexpectedly Sept. 15 following a heart attack. Smereka began working at the University in 1994 as an assistant professor of mathematics. He was promoted to a full professorship in 2003. Smereka obtained a bachelor’s degree in physics from the University of Waterloo, Canada, in 1983 and a Ph.D. doctorate in chemical engineering from the University of California, Santa Barbara, in 1989. During his time at the University, Smereka was a member of the Michigan Center for Theoretical Physics. He was also a part of the
math department’s Applied and Interdisciplinary Mathematics program, which he directed for several years. He also helped develop and instruct an honors program for freshman science and engineering students. While in Ann Arbor, Smereka was awarded the National Science Foundation Career Award in 1996 and the Excellence in Education Award from LSA in 1997. In an obituary submitted by the Smereka family and the math department, family and colleagues described him as funny and insightful. “Smereka was always inquisitive and provided a lot of humor, insight and thought-provoking questions for his family over the years,” they wrote. “He was an incredibly sensitive and kind person often running to help his family members when in need.” Smereka published more than 60 research articles throughout his
lifetime. His work in fluid dynamics — the science behind liquids and gases in motion — was influential. Condolences from faculty members filled the comments section of the obituary posted on the website for the University Record. “Peter was a dearest friend and my best colleague,” wrote Giovanni Russo, a mathematics professor at the University of Catania in Italy. “To work with him has been one of the most exciting experiences of my life. Very dedicated to science, with an extraordinary good taste for interesting problems, he was an extremely sensitive, scrupulous and kind man with highest intellectual honesty. I always admired him, and I will miss him forever.” A memorial will be held for Smereka in the spring. Memorial contributions can be made to the Peter Smereka Memorial Graduate Student Fund.
TROTTER From Page 1A Thompson Street and Packard Street. Planners are also still considering an alternative plan to renovate the current center on Washtenaw Avenue. Trotter Director Jackie Simpson said in a poll of 715 students, most respondees said they preferred the State Street location. Amid talk of relocating, LSA senior Bree Sullivan pointed to the significance of the current building for many students. She said for decades, the building has been a home for minority students on campus — and the space may not feel as safe if located closer to campus. “This is a lot of history, this building,” she said. “I want it, and I want future generations to have it.” Harper recalled the tradition and activism from which the Trotter Center was born. According to their website, Trotter opened in 1971 as a space to hold meetings
Ann Arbor staple to shutter storefront after two decades By LEA GIOTTO Daily Staff Reporter
BethAnn Karmeisool, owner of the S3 Safe Sex Store, said Wednesday the store will close its doors at the end of October. She said her decision to close the storefront, located on South University Avenue, is a result of her building being sold and the recent decline of in-store sales. “My building has been sold and I don’t know the future of the building,” Karmeisool said. “I don’t know exactly, but the rumors are the building is going to be knocked down for a larger project to go up much like Landmark.”
and cultural events for Black students. The desire for the multicultural center grew out of efforts by the Black Action Movement and other prominent civil rights movements in the 1970s. “We are doing for the next generation what the people you were talking about did for you,” Harper said. However, Harper also drew upon the difficulties that come with the current Trotter location. The decision to build a new multicultural center closer to campus came from organizers of the 2013 #BBUM movement, who said the site’s location between fraternities and sororities made minority students feel uncomfortable when walking back and forth at night. “This movement to move as fast as it can has been built on the notion that this place does not meet students’ needs,” Harper said. “We are at some point going to have to say this is what we need.” Gott listed the criteria that students and administrators worked on last year when looking for sites of a new center. Some of these criteria included making sure the new
The owner said she thinks sales have declined in recent months due to increased competition and popularity of online retailers, such as Amazon Prime. While physical sales have decreased, Karmeisool said the need for the community outreach services she offers, such as free HIV testing and individual counseling, have increased. “I think (the closing) is going to have a large impact on the community because of all of the services we do provide,” she said. “People in the community are going to have to go elsewhere for that, and many do not have transportation options.” Karmeisool stressed that while she close the physical storefront, S3 is not going out of business. She is going to maintain S3’s online store, which is currently
running in tandem with the storefront location. She plans to update the store’s website to include a blog stocked with sexual health information. “That telephone number will be linked directly to me, so if any student needs someone to talk to, and they don’t have that outlet, I will still be available to them as much as possible,” Karmeisool said. The owner also ensured she will remain involved with the University through outreach programs, as a visiting lecturer at the School of Public Policy and through hosting sexual health workshops. “I plan on quarterly workshops where people can get their sexual health questions asked, learn about new things going on with sexual health at large and also get free HIV testing,” she said.
space is able to accommodate banquet or multi-purpose rooms and is near loading and unloading docks for special events. The checklist also prioritizes a new location near the Diag and other student services — such as transit, food services, study spaces and computer labs. Gott said the administration has worked to expedite the selection process to fulfill the needs of a new multicultural center on campus. “What is so unique here is we just spent a lot more time with the students,” Gott said. “We asked over and over again what Trotter should be doing for Michigan.” Sullivan also suggested building a space solely for Black students, adding that the voices of Black students are sometimes overshadowed. She said though the students at the time of the #BBUM movement liked the idea of moving Trotter closer to Central Campus, students now might not feel the same way. “I would say we should take into consideration how times change, and how things in world are changing around us,” Sullivan
said. “What students might need at the moment could be very different from what they needed two years ago.” Rackham student Asya Harrison, secretary of Students of Color of Rackham, said while moving to Central Campus would allow for more use of the site, Trotter would lose its current quietness and distance from classes and schoolwork. “That is one of the downsides, it will get a different kind of use and more use,” Harper said. Social Work student Zachary Pritchett said though he likes the current location of Trotter, moving the building would lead to more visibility on campus and subsequently a larger voice on campus issues. He pointed to the Spectrum Center as an example of a powerful voice because of their location in the Michigan Union. Gott said no matter the decision on renovating or relocating Trotter, it is important to remember the history of the center and the significance it will have for future generations of students.
The Michigan Daily — michigandaily.com
PUB From Page 1A ney, but will not be permitted to bring liquor. Evan Wood, Trolley Pub’s regional manager based in North Carolina, helps set up new locations nationally. He said the company has been in communication with Ann Arbor officials to ensure a smooth launch. “Before we start in new locations, we build a relationship and start conversations with the chief of police, City Council and anybody that may have a major role,” Wood said. “We do a lot of public relations so that we’re in no way inconspicuous.” Amanda Swan, managing partner for the Ann Arbor Trolley Pub, said she is excited to get business started. “It’s going to be really, really fun,” Swan said. “I’m excited to kick it off by having a complete public kick-off, like a meet and greet. Anyone can hop on and hop off.” A 14-person private tour costs $375. However, if a party does
CARSON From Page 1A would say: ‘You can’t make your boys sit around reading books, they’ll grow up and they’ll hate you.’ … I didn’t like it much at first, but as I started reading these books, I started knowing stuff; stuff that nobody else knew. And within the space of a year and a half I went from the bottom of the class to the top of the class.” Carson graduated from the University’s Medical School in 1977 and spent his career at Johns Hopkins University. He said growing up he always aspired to be a doctor, but did not think his career would take a turn into politics. “I never thought when I left Michigan that I would end up in the political arena,” Carson said. Though he deemed the higher education proposals of other candidates fiscally irresponsible, including a plan proposed by Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders, a Democratic presidential candidate, to provide free, universal higher education, Carson’s speech focused on the key role education plays in economic advancement.
CTOOLS From Page 1A sors to spend in-class hours troubleshooting with students as they work through assignments and projects. This semester, more than 1,700 University courses and 28,700 students are using Canvas. For the rest of the academic year, instructors will be able to choose between either system. However, students have expressed frustration with the simultaneous use of CTools and Canvas, a grievance Pollack acknowledged in the e-mail and in a September interview with The Michigan Daily. “I can appreciate the challenge,” she said in September. “On the other hand, we’re such a
News
not have enough people to fill the entire pedal pub, they can purchase $30 single tickets to ride on a “mixer” pedal-pub. Both options include a tour around the downtown area and the option to stop at bars along the route. Swan said the pedal pub operates like any stationary restaurant or bar. “We card everyone that wants to drink,” Swan said. “People that are over 21 get a stamp on their hand so we know they can drink and we have a tour conductor or driver that keeps an eye on things.” Despite the drinking, guests as young as 13 years old are allowed to ride. Trolley Pub first opened in North Carolina and has expanded around the country. Swan starting working for Trolley Pub in Madison, Wis. After she moved to Detroit, the company asked if she was interesting in setting up a location in Michigan. Swan told the company Ann Arbor would be the perfect location. “I just love the restaurant scene. It’s such a fun downtown,” Swan said. “It’s something for everyone, and the energy is really good.
People are open and relaxed, it’s fun and there’s a vibe. I’m excited to bring an interesting way to get around downtown and for people to see Ann Arbor.” In July, Gov. Rick Snyder signed a law allowing individuals to consume beer and wine while pedaling from bar to bar. That means pedal trolleys in the state can now allow their customers to drink beer or wine while on board. However, individual cities are permitted to pass their own ordinances against drinking. Ann Arbor does not currently have an ordinance outlining rules and regulations for pedal-powered pubs. City Councilmember Jane Lumm (I–Ward 2), who is a member of the Liquor License Review Committee, said the city is working to fast-track an ordinance. “The Liquor License Advisory Committee and the city staff are at this time doing the necessary due diligence,” Lumm said. “We’re obtaining the necessary staff and stakeholder input to inform the development of an ordinance and policy recommendation for the committee’s consideration. The committee will then make a rec-
ommendation for council consideration.” It is unclear whether drinking will be banned on the trolley pubs or merely regulated. Some cities, like Royal Oak, have voted to completely ban drinking on board. Wood said the pedal pubs will respect whatever ordinance the city produces. He also said they would continue tours alcohol-free if necessary. “We do a very good job of selfregulating and I think if it goes well-enough and they see how responsible we are, hopefully that will turn into less of a concern,” Wood said. “We like to not take advantage of the laws and city that we’re in.” The city has also expressed concerns about customers of Trolley Pub exiting the vehicle with open containers. Wood said they have a zero-tolerance policy with open containers leaving the pedal pub. “You wouldn’t walk out of a bar into the street with a beer or drink, so don’t do that here,” Wood said. “We put city laws and ordinances way before we worry about getting a bad review on Yelp or TripAdvisor.”
He recalled the nation’s history of emphasizing education, dating back to the early colonists who settled the Massachusetts Bay Colony. “That’s one of the reasons we were able to rise from nothing to the pinnacle of the world on such short order,” Carson said. “Think about this: before America came on the scene — 100 years, 500 years, 1,000, 3,000, 5,000 — people did things the same way. Within 200 years of the advent of America, men were walking on the moon. This is the most exceptional nation in the world.” He said for all the bad things people say about the United States, there are still always people trying to come here and not very many trying to leave. In a span of five minutes, Carson was able to touch on all of the major social points of contention in the election: women’s rights, religious freedom and same-sex marriage. “The war on women — what a phony thing to say. That is all hype,” Carson said. “I say that as someone whose life was shaped and made successful by women. I have the most wonderful mother, the most wonderful wife, PAs,
administrative assistants, colleagues who are women, and who I could never have been successful without them, and I recognize that. I think most Americans recognize that.” Carson also cited examples of places where women are worse off than in the United States. “There are some nations in the world where they don’t recognize that — where women are not even allowed to drive, where their testimony in court is worth half as much as a man’s, where they’re treated more like children than like equals,” he said. On the issue of religious rights in the U.S., Carson referenced the founding fathers — many of whom came to the New World to escape religious oppression in Europe. He called particular attention to Benjamin Franklin, who, Carson recounted, asked the founding fathers to pray together during the stressful process of writing the Constitution. “(The founding fathers) felt very strongly that we must do everything we can to allow people to practice their faith,” Carson said. “Many people in our nation today who think that our constitution’s law says we should be free
from religion, but no, it’s freedom of religion.” Despite this outspoken support of the First Amendment, Carson made national news Tuesday when, during an appearance on “Meet the Press,” he said he was against the election of a Muslim president. Carson said while he disagrees with the Supreme Court decision in June to permit same-sex marriage in the United States, he has nothing against people who are gay. “I personally believe that the Supreme Court made a mistake when they basically voted to change the definition of marriage from what it has been traditionally for thousands of years,” he said. “I have nothing against gay people — zero — but, I’m a pragmatic person and I realize if you change the definition of marriage for one group, what right do you have not to change it for the next group, and the next group, and the next group.” Carson is one of several GOP candidates to visit Michigan in recent months. Over the weekend, five Republican contenders spoke to state party leaders at conference on Mackinac Island.
big University that we can’t really just flip a switch and do it all at once. When you go through system changes there’s just always a little period of some added challenge.” Pollack accepted a recommendation from the group who oversaw the pilot program — the Digital Innovation Advisory Group’s Digital Ecosystem Subcommittee — to expedite the full transition to Canvas by fall 2016. The University of Michigan’s Dearborn campus, as well as close to 700 other schools across the country, currently use Canvas. In an interview Wednesday morning before the transition was announced, Comparative Literature Prof. Silke-Maria Weineck, chair of the Senate Advisory Committee on University Affairs,
said she thought the transition process had been well handled and that faculty were generally optimistic about it. “There’s been a lot of consultation, so we think that’s been done well,” Weineck said. “There’s been a lot of faculty input, there’s been a careful pilot program to identify possible programs, so fingers-crossed. There are always transition costs.” Public Health Prof. David Mendez, chair of the Digital Ecosystem Subcommittee, said in the release that faculty should take advantage of the resources available to aid their transition. “I encourage faculty to experiment with Canvas and to engage with colleagues who have used it,” he said. “Talk to your local IT support or instructional designers who can help you get the
most out of Canvas. Once people start using Canvas, they realize the transition is not that hard and the rewards far exceed the cost of moving to a new system. I encourage our colleagues not to wait too long to get started.” The University’s ITS Service Center is offering Convert2Canvas assistance, available to instructors upon request. The service moves material for faculty from CTools to Canvas within a few days. Existing course sites on CTools will be available through August 2017, at which point they will be archived and available to faculty upon request. CTools sites not used for courses — such as those created for student organizations, research and other projects — will remain active for now.
Thursday, September 24, 2015 — 3A
MUD BOWL From Page 1A tions of University students. “We really want to continue it, for the literally thousands of people who have played in it and have memories of it,” Dubin said. Mary Beth Seiler, director of the Office of Greek life, said the discontinuation of Mud Bowl is only in response to the involvement of members of the former SAE, who fall under the category of “rogue.” “Nobody is trying to discontinue the Mud Bowl in Greek Life,” Seiler said, “If another organization that was recognized were sponsoring the Mud Bowl, that would not be a problem.” Rogue fraternities refer to a
situation in which the chapter is either removed from the IFC or its national organization withdraws recognition. Seiler said SAE has been considered a rogue organization since it was expelled from the IFC, but lost ts national charter this summer. Seiler added that the Office of Greek Life simply requests that fraternities uphold the policies they have passed. “It’s part of the bylaws, and that is why the students will be unable to participate, based upon our rules,” Krupiak said. “If it were hosted by an IFC fraternity, that fraternity should be allowed to play, but because it’s SAE, they’re not.” A Change.org petitition calling on the Office of Greek Life to allow SAE to reinstate the Mud Bowl currently has 1,421 signatures.
Opinion
4A — Thursday, September 24, 2015
Edited and managed by students at the University of Michigan since 1890. 420 Maynard St. Ann Arbor, MI 48109 tothedaily@michigandaily.com JENNIFER CALFAS EDITOR IN CHIEF
AARICA MARSH and DEREK WOLFE EDITORIAL PAGE EDITORS
LEV FACHER MANAGING EDITOR
Unsigned editorials reflect the official position of the Daily’s editorial board. All other signed articles and illustrations represent solely the views of their authors.
FROM THE DAILY
A house misled Representatives must consider facts, opinions before voting
O
n Friday, the U.S. House voted to defund Planned Parenthood (248-177) based upon false beliefs surrounding its abortion services. The Center for Medical Progress, an anti-abortion group, recently released several videos depicting Planned Parenthood workers discussing the sale of fetal tissue for profit, an illegal act under federal law. Shortly after their release, the videos were criticized for unethical reporting, misleading edits and referred to as contributions of a prolonged campaign of deception. Unfortunately, the videos were the basis of many Republican arguments to defund the organization in their recent House vote. Their vote to defund Planned Parenthood is deplorable and we strongly encourage the House of Representatives to consider the facts and popular opinion before making such rash decisions. Though most of the talk surrounding Planned Parenthood is based on the abortion services that some branches of the organization offer, it should be noted that abortions only account for 3 percent of the services Planned Parenthood provides. In fact, the organization is responsible for many other basic sexual health services such as contraception, family planning, HIV and STI testing, and breast exams, to name a few. Though much of Planned Parenthood’s financial support comes from private donations, removing federal funding from its budget may hinder access to basic sexual health care for those who wouldn’t regularly be able to afford it. According to the Guttmacher Institute in 2010, “Planned Parenthood provided about a third of the services to women who obtained contraceptive care at federallysubsidized safety-net centers.” Lawmakers who support the sudden end of federal funding to Planned Parenthood seem to have a skewed perception of the nonprofit organization. For example, Diane Black (R– Tenn.) recently said, “Planned Parenthood can get their money back if they fully commit to what they talk about, women’s healthcare, and stop performing abortions for this year.” Federal funding given to Planned Parenthood is prohibited by Title X to provide abortions to those who are not in medical need or in cases of rape or incest. Essentially, those who voted to defund Planned Parenthood cut money that did not even go toward the issue they are trying to stop. Planned Parenthood dissenters simply are not thinking about any of the consequences to removing funding for a pivotal, national organization. While the cause and effect aren’t necessarily directly linked, closing Planned Parenthood facilities across the country has
been closely correlated to various HIV outbreaks. For example, Scott County, Ind., has been battling a recent HIV outbreak since the closing of its only Planned Parenthood back in 2013; the clinic that was closed didn’t even provide abortion services. Aside from the increase in HIV cases, unplanned pregnancies will inevitably rise as well. Unfortunately, these are only a few of the unintended consequences of defunding such an important organization. Other repercussions may be more severe. Furthermore, polls taken by Hart Research associates found that 63 percent of registered voters are opposed to defunding Planned Parenthood, causing one to wonder why the decision was made in the first place. The recent House vote seems like a strategic political move with no regard for what the public actually supports. Basing their argument solely on accusations made against Planned Parenthood that were proven false further makes the Republicans’ case irrational. Any videos made by anti-abotion activists posing as Planned Parenthood patrons were proven to be heavily edited to contain material that was not in fact related to what was actually happening at the time. Investigating leadership within Planned Parenthood or any corruption that is hidden under the core of the institution is valid. U.S. citizens, including those who are registered Republicans, are well within their rights to call out any wrongdoings of Planned Parenthood and demand corrections accordingly. However, the move to completely remove federal funding from Planned Parenthood was wholly preemptive and brash. The House needs to thoroughly rethink such decisions and withhold any impulse to make such an ill-advised political statement at the expense of millions.
Shove it: A rant on tampon taxes
S
anitary products including tampons, pads, panty liners and even the costconscious, eco-friendly DivaCup are items taxed in all but five U.S. states. Besides Massa- GABRIELLE chusetts, Maryland, MinDECARO nesota, New Jersey and Pennsylvania, the United States considers the tampon to be a nonessential item and a luxury (like a yacht or Lady Gaga’s dog’s collar). As if being a female isn’t costly enough, we pay to have our periods like it’s something we enjoy. “Wow, I’m sooo looking forward to this new box of pads. I can’t wait to get home and try one on!” an eager PMSer exclaims. Or, “Girl — could I trade you a regular for a super? That’s one rare rag I must get for my collection,” because feminine hygiene is just that fun. It’s like we are all in this club, and we keep paying the same union dues, but there are no visible changes being made to improve our group’s experience. Instead, we continue to fight for equality, basic rights for our own bodies, respect for our existence, health care, access to contraception — all the while paying a tax on something that is considered dispensable by a group of males in power. At this point, who wouldn’t jump at the idea of involuntary muscle contractions and fluctuating hormones? Sign me the “F” up. This is an essential part of being a woman; it isn’t an accident or something we choose to have. Females bleed, we have periods, and affordable feminine hygiene has always been a necessity. This should not even be in ques-
tion. As basic as they are, tampons are expensive (with an average box costing about $6.99). What makes an already fundamental need out of reach is placing a tax on it, which discriminates against women for having menstrual cycles in the first place. This sanitary tax puts women in a position of irregularity (no allusion intended) where we pay to acknowledge our biological differences from men. If you can agree that our reproductive systems are our own business and not the government’s, the sooner we can all agree that no gender should be taxed. This brings us closer to the necessary separation of body and state/body and nation. Over the course of a lifetime, the amount of money we spend on tampons and pads proves that having a period isn’t cheap. I mean it’s actually ridiculous. Let’s be real. For the sake of progress: Canada recently passed a motion to drop the tax completely. Yet in the United States, the sales tax for sanitary products still ranges from 4 to 9 percent. This is a nationwide dilemma and I hope these facts motivate more petitions and women who fight for representation. We have a long way to go, ladies — but don’t forget how luxurious periods are in the meantime. “WOMEN FOR GLITZ: We put the bling-bling in reproductive systems!” “Period? MORE LIKE SURPRISE PARTY!” “Period? Let’s celebrate with these decorative plates. I hope you like them.” Let’s do something about this. Gabrielle out. — Gabrielle DeCaro can be reached at gbricker@umich.edu.
For the accompanying cartoon to Gabrielle’s article, please visit www.michigandaily.com/opinion
The Michigan Daily — michigandaily.com
Trumped and scammed
F
ast and brash, Donald Trump has certainly succeeded in enrapturing the American public with his unconventional presidential campaign. We have watched him before, hosting “The Apprentice” and “Celebrity Apprentice” as he cashed in ASHLEY for providing AUSTIN us with raucous entertainment disguised as legitimate business. We should ask ourselves how he would cash in armed with the disguise as the democratically elected American president. Because he would cash in. What lies beneath the show is the quagmire of this campaign. Accusations of associations with the Italian-American mafia, running an alleged scam known as Trump University and shepherding four businesses into bankruptcy bring about questions regarding how he would run the country. First, if the mob association accusations made by Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist David Cay Johnston and journalist Wayne Barrett are true, Trump has done business with Philadelphia and New York crime families. He purchased the future site of Atlantic City’s Trump Plaza for twice its market value from Philadelphia mobster Salvatore Testa and constructed the casino using two firms controlled by Philadelphia mob boss “Little Nicky” Scarfo. Additionally, Trump Tower and other New York City properties were constructed with concrete from a firm owned by NYC bosses “Fat Tony” Salerno and “Big Paul” Castellano. These ties reveal Trump’s resolve to achieve business
at any cost and a potential presidency marked by cronyism and corruption. The price for our country could be steep if Mr. Trump facilitated organized crime as America’s leader. Furthermore, Trump ran an alleged scam himself. Trump University enrolled students who lost up to $35,000 each in fees for courses and seminars that failed to provide them with degrees or participation in an accredited program. Trump is accused of overcharging former students for services that were not delivered. Trump launched Trump University in 2005, offering courses and seminars in real estate. Fees ranged from $1,495 for a three-day seminar to up to $25,000 for individual coaching. Investors’ software packages cost $2,000 and a “Gold Elite” package for $34,995 promised to provide the mentorship necessary for jumpstarting a real-estate business, but often the mentors were unreachable. Controversy began when the New York State Bureau of Education declared that calling the organization a university was possibly illegal in 2010, leading to the organization to change its name to The Trump Entrepreneur Initiative. The Trump Entrepreneur Initiative lasted until 2013, at which time the Office of the New York Attorney General had gathered enough evidence from its 2012 investigation to file the civil lawsuit. The now defunct Trump Entrepreneur Initiative was embroiled in a $40 million civil lawsuit filed by New York Attorney General Eric Schneiderman and was found guilty of not obtaining a license for a for-profit university. The organization continues to face a class-action suit in California. The ongoing Trump University fiasco indicates that Trump hasn’t followed all of our country’s laws and has been keen to take advantage of
the more vulnerable. A Trump presidency could include tax breaks and incentives for for-profit vocational schools and a reduction in Pell grants and government loans for nonprofit universities. As college students, we must ask ourselves what a man who ran a forprofit university into destruction would do for us. He has stated on numerous occasions that he wants to cut the U.S. Department of Education down, perhaps as a way to ease regulations. He isn’t afraid to leave behind his messes. Additionally, four of Trump’s businesses in Atlantic City declared bankruptcy, including: Trump’s Taj Mahal (1991), Trump Plaza Hotel (1992), Trump Hotels and Casino Resorts (2004) and Trump Entertainment Resorts (2009). When asked about these bankruptcies by ABC’s George Stephanopoulos in 2011, Trump remarked, “I’ve used the laws of this country to pare debt … We’ll have the company. We’ll throw it into a chapter. We’ll negotiate with the banks. We’ll make a fantastic deal. You know, it’s like on ‘The Apprentice.’ It’s not personal. It’s just business.” Well, Mr. Trump, continue to use the laws of this country to your advantage. It seems to be working out. The Republican candidate has masterfully marketed an image of a blunt businessman who has achieved “greatness” through obtaining an exaggerated amount of wealth, but in actuality he is hustling us all. His past of cutting deals with the mafia, scamming students and running his Atlantic City businesses to the ground highlight his lack of empathy, the most important quality for our country’s commander in chief. — Ashley Austin can be reached at agracea@umich.edu
EDITORIAL BOARD MEMBERS Claire Bryan, Regan Detwiler, Ben Keller, Payton Luokkala, Aarica Marsh, Adam Morton, Victoria Noble, Anna Polumbo-Levy, Melissa Scholke, Michael Schramm, Steph Trierweiler, Mary Kate Winn, Derek Wolfe
“Y
Seeing social skills
ou don’t need people,” I told my sister’s strained self-esteem on the phone one afternoon. PAYTON “They aren’t LUOKKALA necessary to the life we live. We are independent.” I could hear her processing the information on the phone. “But if you want some, find the people you want to be with; if they are more trouble than they are worth, let them go.” I took a few seconds to listen to my own advice, “Call Mom and run that advice by her, will you? I’m not sure that it is healthy.” She mumbled she would as I hung up and walked to class. Looking back, it seems that in addition to giving poor advice, I was right. It isn’t healthy. Though I pride myself on being independent, it’s undeniable that social support has a positive impact on health. Having people to depend on, to relax with, to stop you from studying yourself into an early grave, lowers your stress, which affects every aspect of health, mental and physical. A Harvard University study, found that a lack of strong relationships increased the risk of premature death (by all causes) by 50 percent. This is to say, even though relationships may take effort, they’re imperative. You hear that, Brooke? I was wrong. She never asked my mom, by the way. If you’re not one to care about your health, it might persuade you if I said fellow human beings are also critical in learning. This is something I find immensely more important than health, but I’ve never been quite right that way. Community, it’s called. While the interpretation of the word may be the members of the town you grew
up at, or members of the University you now attend, communities are much more. My definition of a community is people who are bonded by similar action. Whether painting, running, learning Spanish or embracing a common culture, the people with whom you share passions are important because of how you can grow from one another. As a member of the Lloyd Hall Scholars Program, a Michigan learning community dedicated to writing and the arts, I have been exposed to new interests such as slam poetry and journalism, things I believe have made me a better writer. Without community, what knowledge am I to cultivate? I’ve never been all that great at making friends. I’m not trying to seem pitiful, it just seems that way. Independence is my scapegoat, and while I love the friends I have, it takes the pressure away when I tell myself there isn’t a requirement to be sociable. But I’ve been wrong before. The other morning I was sitting in the dining hall shoveling in some watermelon before heading off to class. Some boy, oblivious to my solitude and my still-sleeping brain, sat across from me emitting cheer. “How are you doing?” he asks me. I breathe out a “good,” my voice still adjusting to the sunlight. “How’s your first week at U of M?” I didn’t tell him I was a sophomore, because it didn’t really matter. I tried to muster a little enthusiasm, but plain pleasantries have a way of bringing me down. “Great,” my answer had no voice inflection. He wanted more from me: “You aren’t convincing.” With the same flat sound I replied, “That isn’t my job.” I got up and walked away in awe of myself, but now I cannot stop thinking, someday, it will be. Aside from peer relationships, socializing with people has become even more crucial to our existence, now more so than ever. Networking is necessary for entering many
career fields. The University’s Alumni Association even states, “(Eighty) percent of a job-seeker’s energy should be focused on networking.” Our futures are held in strangers’ hands, and so, if we want to amount to anything, we need to impress them. Luckily, our dear University must sense our newly adult awkwardness, because be it Health Management and Policy’s Griffith Leadership Center or the Tauber Institute for Global Operations, events are frequently planned to meet the important people with these strange hands. These events are decorated with appealing phrases like “informal conversations with senior executives” and “interact in a small-group setting.” To me, those words are not comforting, but intimidating and sweaty. Whatever my personal comfort level, these opportunities are nonetheless important, and students should take advantage of the generosity by practicing networking at the play dates organized for us. The advice I should have given sounds a little more like this: You don’t need to be a people person, however, you do need some people. Remember, though, that no relationship you have should be the same. While you may rely on people, you don’t need everything from them and certainly not everything from one person. There should be people you rely on for loyalty, others for the passion of shared interests. Some people can only be relied upon when you need a good time (a very important type, I must add). There will be those who teach you, those who help lift you and those you just have to survive being around. All are important, but none are all-encompassing. Life would not be impossible without social networking; it would just be a lot harder. — Payton Luokkala can be reached at payluokk@umich.edu
Do you like caramel apple suckers? Giant teddy bears? 50 cent cans of pop?
Join us at Edtiboard on Monday and Wednesday evenings at 6:30 p.m. For more information, e-mail tothedaily@michigandaily.com.
The Michigan Daily — michigandaily.com
Sports
Thursday, September 24, 2015 — 5A
Michigan defeats Oakland, 4-1 ‘M’ defies history MEN’S SOCCER
By KEVIN SANTO Daily Sports Writer
ROCHESTER, Mich. — If you blinked, you might have missed it. In the 41st minute, freshman forward Francis Atuahene received the ball on the left wing and — in 4 MICHIGAN a fashion 1 OAKLAND that is becoming all too familiar to opposing defenders — bolted to the goal line before serving a perfect ball back to the penalty spot. Redshirt sophomore midfielder Michael Kapitula found himself in the right place at the right time and shot the ball into the open net. Kapitula’s finish broke a 1-1 tie and completely altered the tone of the game, as the Michigan men’s soccer team went on to cruise to a 4-1 victory against Oakland. “It was the last five minutes of the half, and Oakland had a lot of possession before that,” Kapitula said. “I feel like the goal changed the momentum of the game. I just wanted to put myself in a good position, and I did. The ball came to me, so I had a tap-in.” The Wolverines (1-0-1 Big Ten, 4-2-1 overall) were the first to strike in the match, when freshman midfielder Ivo Cerda headed junior defender Rylee Woods’ corner kick from the six-yard box past Grizzlies’ goalkeeper Wes Mink in the 16th minute. But Michigan’s lead was shortlived. In the 19th minute, junior defender Lars Eckenrode took Oakland forward Gerald Ben down in the 18-yard box for a penalty kick.
Ben stepped up to the ball and calmly finished it up the middle, as sophomore goalkeeper Evan Louro dove early in anticipation that the shot would be directed to the right. For the ensuing 22 minutes, Oakland (0-1-0 Horizon League, 3-4 overall) had the Wolverines frustrated and on the defensive, maintaining the majority of possession and forcing Michigan to play long balls to its target forwards. The Grizzlies drew six fouls in the same timeframe — a sampling of the physicality of the matchup, in which the two teams accumulated 33 fouls and five yellow cards. Eventually, Kapitula and the Wolverines recovered to finish on an opportunity that sent them into halftime with a lead. “When we made it 2-1, I think that was a dagger,” said Michigan
coach Chaka Daley. “Oakland had a little sense of belief after getting a penalty kick that could get them going, and we stifled that pretty quickly (when Kapitula) put it away nicely. “Ramp up the intensity was the conversation at halftime. And make sure we’re not complacent with 2-1. And I think the guys did a great job of responding to that.” Michigan ended the half with a 10-4 shot advantage and carried the momentum from Kapitula’s goal into the second half. At the onset of the second half, the Wolverines regained control of possession and dictated the pace of play, while finding ways to combine with each other instead of sending long balls. And as Michigan’s pressure on Oakland mounted, Atuahene
finally put the game out of reach in the 64th minute. After receiving a ball near the 18-yard box, Atuahene carried the ball to the corner of the six-yard box before firing a shot near-post past Mink. From that point, Michigan coasted to victory, and senior forward William Mellors-Blair added a fourth goal in the 85th minute to put the finishing touches on the Wolverines’ fourth win of the season. After coming away victorious Sunday in its first Big Ten game against Northwestern, Michigan followed up the impressive performance with a win over an in-state foe the Wolverines haven’t always fared well against. Now the key for Michigan is to stay consistent as it heads into the bulk of the Big Ten schedule.
LUNA ANNA ARCHEY/Daily
Redshirt sophomore midfielder Michael Kapitula scored the goal that broke Michigan’s tie against Oakland.
in blowout victory By KATIE CONKLIN Daily Sports Writer
ROCHESTER, Mich. — It was clear that the Michigan men’s soccer team was in enemy territory during its Wednesday night game at Oakland. The game drew a crowd of more than 800 spectators, and students gathered on the hill adjacent to the field. Others chose to observe from a bird’s-eye view, perched atop the neighboring parking garage, while young fans rallied the crowd in a “Let’s go Oakland” chant near the goal line. They came expecting a Grizzlies win. Most would make the assumption that the Wolverines would come out on top, especially after they won their 150th game in program history against Northwestern, 3-0, earlier in the week. Michigan holds a 9-1-4 overall record against the Grizzlies, but recent history indicates that visiting their campus is no easy task. During their past three visits to Rochester, the Wolverines have not been able to pull away early, resulting in the nail-biter finishes Oakland fans have come to expect. With all three previous meetings at Oakland Stadium extending into an overtime period, games between the two teams have been anything but boring in recent years. The record between the in-state foes on Grizzly turf remains 1-1-1, and the fans, enjoying success against
Michigan’s defense keys on aggressiveness, confidence Classifieds By JAKE LOURIM Managing Sports Editor
In Saturday’s game against UNLV, the Michigan football team’s defense allowed just 235 total yards (92 rushing, 143 passing), forced eight punts and intercepted two passes. But another number stuck out to the Wolverines. And it frustrated them: seven points allowed. “We wanted that shutout,” said junior cornerback Jourdan Lewis on Monday. “They weren’t supposed to score. We weren’t supposed to let them score, so we let up seven points, and that’s the biggest statistic we’re supposed to fix. There wasn’t supposed to be points on that board.” Michigan blanked Oregon State for the last 58 minutes of its second game of the season heading into the UNLV game. An early touchdown prevented a shutout in that game, but the sentiment was the same: Rather than being pleased with giving up just seven points, the Wolverines were upset that they allowed even that many. And it’s that sentiment that has Michigan among the top defenses in the country. “Since spring ball, there’s been an increase in that (mentality),” said secondary coach Mike Zordich on Wednesday. “It’s something we want to build on. We’ve got a long way to go, but it’s something we want to build on.” The first step in building on it will be Saturday at home against Brigham Young. Through three games, the Wolverines rank seventh in the nation in total defense and are tied for 12th in scoring defense. But they haven’t faced an offense as potent as the Cougars’, led by freshman quarterback Tanner Mangum and a host of receivers. They have the ability to pose an issue for Michigan. But the Wolverines can counter with aggressiveness. They pulled down two interceptions Saturday. On one, junior cornerback Channing Stribling jumped a slant route and snatched the ball out of the air. On the other, redshirt junior cornerback Jeremy Clark stuck with his receiver, used his hands to gain separation and turned around at just the right
moment for the interception. Michigan might need those kinds of plays in its tough games going forward. “We’ll line up Jourdan Lewis against a (6-foot-6 receiver), scrappy as Jourdan is, that’s a tough matchup,” Zordich said. “But that’s how we’re going to play it. They’ve got to fight, for sure.” And fight the Wolverines have on defense in each of their first three games. While they’ve had struggles of their own, they’ve also helped out the offense by getting a stop when needed or gaining valuable field position. In order to do so, they’ve developed a confident attitude that’s the hallmark of all great defenses. More than once this year, Michigan has dug in while defending its own red zone or come up with a turnover to give the offense an opportunity. “It might sound bad, but we kind of thrive off those situations,” said senior linebacker James Ross III. “We like them. I mean, we would like to limit them, but if it happens, we love to be back on that field, and we love to get the ball back for our offense, so if that happens we go
back out there and we look at it as an opportunity. We try to do our best and get the ball back.” The Wolverines will need that mindset, too: Their games are about to get closer, starting Saturday. They might find themselves behind and in need of a stop to stay in the game, or just ahead and in need of a stop to protect the lead. As Michigan has struggled over the past few years, its defense has been more of a stopgap than a true asset. The Wolverines are ready to take the next step, aided by a high confidence level. “We can be the best in the country if we just continue to use our technique,” Lewis said. “Just need to get the ball back, honestly. Need to improve on turnovers, get more turnovers. That’s the main goal.” Asked on Wednesday about Lewis’ comment, Zordich — his position coach — smiled. “That’s what we want them to think,” Zordich said. “Certainly the work they produce has to match that. We absolutely want that kind of attitude for those guys. It helps. Certainly their position requires that kind of attitude.”
ALLISON FARRAND/Daily
Jourdan Lewis goes for a pass breakup in Michigan’s win against UNLV.
the state’s flagship university, remember. The crowd arrived for a show, but it was one the Wolverines weren’t aware of. “(We) don’t know anything about the past,” said Michigan coach Chaka Daley. “The past is gone.” Michigan took the field with this mindset, prepared to earn a win regardless of prior results. The Wolverines were the first to hit twine. Freshman midfielder Ivo Cerda knocked in a header near-post off a short cross just over 15 minutes into the match. However, the Grizzlies retaliated quickly, capitalizing on a penalty kick opportunity. The back-and-forth scoring kept the many spectators enthralled. But first to the ball at the start of the second half, the Wolverines began to capitalize on their shots and took advantage of opportunity. The viewers remained absorbed in the match well into the second half, not because it was the even game they came to watch, but because of the numerous scoring chances the Wolverines created. With 21 shots on goal, Michigan kept the bystanders on their toes, never knowing when they could slip a ball into the back of the net. “If we can live up to the standard the team has set, and we can live up to that standard every single game … we’ll get what we deserve out of every single game,” Daley said.
Call: #734-418-4115 Email: dailydisplay@gmail.com
FOR RENT ! NORTH CAMPUS 1-2 Bdrm. ! ! Riverfront/Heat/Water/Parking. ! ! www.HRPAA.com ! 3 BEDROOM TOWNHOME 2 1/2 bath with den, incl. all appliances, full size washer and dryer 1275 Wisteria ‑ $1,700/mo for 1 yr lease Call 734‑663‑7633 for more info RELEASE DATE– Thursday, September 24, 2015
Los Angeles Times Daily Crossword Puzzle Edited by Rich Norris and Joyce Nichols Lewis
ACROSS 1 *Subject of a San Francisco museum 9 Speculate 15 Intimate meeting 16 Reluctant 17 Five-pointed, say 18 Coordinated health program 19 Ticked-off state 20 Honorary law deg. 21 Debussy contemporary 22 December purchase for many 24 Singer Lenya married to Kurt Weill 26 Stood the test of time 29 Damage 30 “¿Cómo __?” 33 Egyptian city on the Nile 34 Clever 35 Laugh syllable 36 Deflategate letters 37 *Unpretentious 40 1970 Jackson 5 chart topper 41 __ Andreas Fault 42 Works in un museo 43 M16, for one 45 Sharpen 47 Half a Western couple 48 Less than broadcast 49 Polite title 51 Fermented beverage usually served warm 52 Take five 54 N.L. East team 55 Nutritional stat 58 Steal, Westernstyle 60 Random way to decide 63 Bay windows 64 Arrived at, Western-style 65 Rite-related 66 Office building feature, which can precede the ends of the answers to starred clues
DOWN 1 Right triangle ratio: Abbr. 2 Naysayer 3 Really hard test 4 Lynn with the album “I Remember Patsy” 5 Phot. lab request 6 Ready to strike 7 Bracelet site 8 Sax, e.g. 9 Simple card game 10 Out in the open 11 Prove false 12 *Torqueproviding component 13 Salinger title 13year-old 14 Rod attachment 23 Clinton’s attorney general 24 Shop class fixture 25 Longtime Hydrox competitor 26 Run out 27 Syrian leader 28 *Big band genre 29 Dank 31 Set aside
32 Moved like a pendulum 34 Data storage medium 38 “Good Morning America” coanchor Spencer 39 Composer Satie 44 Sluggishness 46 Parade time 48 Silver __, compound used in film
50 Perry’s secretary 51 Bar patron’s option 52 J.B. Holmes and Bubba Watson, e.g. 53 Atmosphere 54 Part of a plot 56 “Stop it!” 57 About 59 Immigrant’s subj. 61 Ariz. neighbor 62 Campus org.
ANSWER TO PREVIOUS PUZZLE:
ONE BEDROOM APARTMENT now available close to Ross & Law School 1 year lease September 2015 ‑ August 2016 $875 utilities included. Call: (734) 834‑5021 WWW.CARLSONPROPERTIES.COM 734‑332‑6000
SERVICES THESIS EDITING, LANGUAGE, organization, format. All Disciplines. 734/996‑0566 or writeon@iserv.net
HELP WANTED BLUE NILE HIRING! Positions Available Wait Staff, Busers, Hosts/Hostesses, and Bartenders Needed. Stop by the Blue Nile to Apply 221 E. Washington St. xwordeditor@aol.com
09/24/15
have fun doing the sudoku. By Timothy L. Meaker ©2015 Tribune Content Agency, LLC
09/24/15
xoxo
6A — Thursday, September 24, 2015
The Michigan Daily — michigandaily.com
B
The Michigan Daily | michigandaily.com | Thursday, September 24, 2015
2B — Thursday, September 24, 2015
the b-side
The Michigan Daily — michigandaily.com
Grad Glam Credits // B. May black leather crossbody, Ayla, 323 S. Main Street; AVN wool coat, Ayla, 323 S. Main Street; Citizens of Humanity girlfriend jeans, Bivouac, 336 S. State Street; Tank and shoes stylist’s own.
We sent Daily arts writer Danielle Raykhinshteyn to the Diag to find out what students are wearing for fall. The answer? Old standbys with plenty of history, thrifted gems and sartorial souvenirs from far-off places.
Allison Fedler, 18 — LSA freshman, undecided: “I have a pair of suede, taupe-colored wedges. They’re an ankle boot. They’re comfortable, and I like wearing heels because I like being taller than I am. I think they look good with a lot of different outfits.” Anita Ho, 18 — Music, Theatre & Dance freshman, clarinet performance: “I really like flannel shirts, so I’m planning on going thrifting next weekend with my roommate for some flannels. I’m pretty petite, so I’m looking for anything that I can tie at the waist or that fits my height.” Sean Zhang, 21 — Engineering senior, mechanical engineering: “I care more about my hair than my clothes, so I’ll keep growing my hair. I like keeping this ponytail. I’m not really focused on how I’m going to dress today.” Brandon Patterson, 28 — Rackham student: “This leather bag is a bag I got after traveling to India this summer. It reminds me of the trip and is just a good bag all around that is pretty versatile. It’s a brown bag with magnet clips on the sides and pretty simple in its design, but inside there are three pockets, a few zippered ones, and it also holds a laptop, which is what I need it for.”
Cover Credits // Bella Dahl fringe moto jacket; Majestic Filatures black turtleneck; Citizens of Humanity high-rise flair jeans, all from Bivouac, 336 S. State Street; Michigan sweater, 1883 Clothing Co. The Victors Collection, 307 S. State Street; BDG red skirt, Urban Outfitters, 231 S. State Street / shoes model’s
TRAILER REVIEW In Mexico, sicario means hitman. The trailer for “Sicario” will tell you as much. However, the trailer B+ won’t tell you exactly Sicario what’s going Lionsgate on, plotwise. Which Thursday, Oct. 1 is actually one of its strengths. The first official trailer for “Sicario” takes you south of the border with protagonist Emily Blunt (“Edge of Tomorrow”), as she becomes engaged in the bloody, neverending war between drug enforcement officers and the high rollers of illegal drug industry. One such high roller appears to be Benicio Del Toro (“Snatch”), while Josh Brolin (“No Country for Old Men”) plays Blunt’s ally. The trailer begins with the oft-used strobelight
LIONSGATE
strategy, flashing bits of the film between blank black space. While unoriginal, the technique works well with similarly styled sound effects. Intimidating figures, tense, unexpected action and a
Mexican backdrop seem to provide a reliable idea of what to expect from “Sicario.” For what it’s worth, talks of a sequel have already begun. - CONRAD FOREMAN
the b-side
The Michigan Daily — michigandaily.com
Thursday, September 24, 2015 — 3B
Ranking the fall AYLA fashion editorials A breakdown of seven hundred pages of style By MARA MACLEAN Daily Arts Writer
As fall approaches, the fashion world is abuzz with excitement for the coming fashion month and September issues. Each magazine produces its thickest issue of the year, stuffed with advertisements from every luxury brand and retailer. The product is overwhelming — 700 pages of gorgeous images and top editors all trying to say that jackets are important for fall — so we got Daily Style Writer Mara Maclean to rank them. 5. VANITY FAIR: Though Taylor Swift’s cover story was not the most jaw-dropping or influential, her shoot with Mario Testino captured a different layer of strength and beauty that can get lost amid the constant #squad instagrams and red carpet moments. The writing was more of a standout in Vanity Fair than in the other September issues (as it should be for this magazine), which leads to its lower ranking. Our rankings are focusing on the quality of editorial shoots, and many of this issue’s insights weren’t worth mentioning. Still a powerful voice in fashion, VF was essential to include in the top five. There was a nice story about Gigi Hadid’s social media power, but again, nothing truly ground-breaking. 4. ELLE: Similar to Vogue, Elle released The Elle Look, a definitive listing of fashion’s brightest stars with their muses. It was fascinating to see who inspires some of the greatest talents in the fashion universe. Alexa Chung jumped around with Erdem Moralioglu and Diane von Furstenberg posed with actress Allison Williams — it was an interesting take on Vogue’s who’s who. Cover star Keira Knightley looks out from the pages in eye-popping colors in her “Everything is Illuminated” spread. Paola Kudacki and Holly Millea show us just how beautiful, talented, well-read, opinionated and fashion-forward the actress is. Next, Elle walks us through fall’s crazy textures — fur, brocade, chiffon, lamé (yes!) — in “Road
to Marrakech.” Like many other issues, Elle touched on the bright colors and wild prints to come in “Mad Max,” highlighting fashions turn towards maximalism. Their pastel editorial, “Beyond the Pale,” just couldn’t compare to the similar spread seen in Porter. Finally, to end on the dopest of notes, Elle spotlights the modern woman at age 30 for their 30th anniversary. Basically a catalogue of every power woman, Elle lists every outstanding comedian, musician, novelist, athlete, actor and politician who portray the strength of 30.
The Vogue team sets an incredibly high standard. 3. VOGUE UK: Vogue UK set the tone for their September issue with another powerful choice in cover star — Emma Watson. In “Voice of a Generation,” Violet Henderson and Josh Olins try to capture everything that is Emma Watson. The images are soft and feminine, while the clothes show the strength and powerful voice that is synonymous with the UN ambassador; the images were just as intriguing as the story. Vogue UK’s strongest editorial, “Fade to Black,” showed the color of fall in sculptural silhouettes, crazy wools and graphic hardware. The stark shots emphasized the interesting shapes and lines that can be created with the classic color. Immediately following, in “No Debutante,” primary colors and splashy prints popped off the page in an ‘80s shoot. In “The Witching Hour,” Vogue UK showed their greatest strengths in the portrayal of delicate lace and wisps of chiffon in dark, eerie shots — a look not mentioned by fashion’s other players. Overall, this issue was solid, as always, but not at the editorial level of Porter and U.S. Vogue. 2. PORTER: The only reason Porter holds the number two spot is Vogue’s ability to reach a wider audience. Overall, the editorials and fashion insights reached an entirely new level in Porter’s Fall 2015 issue. The excellence begins with the cover star, Daria Wer-
bowy. Fashion’s favorite rebel, known for her incredibly closed off personal life and modern femininity, poses in the most striking editorials to date. Mikael Jansson captures the supermodel in two very different stories — “True Grit” and “Soft Focus.” Porter, known for its innovation and commitment to the finest production, shows Werbowy among the dirt and grease, in powerful shapes and colors; then, transitions into a world of pastels and delicate lingerie. The contrast is overwhelming and insightful, and Porter claims its rightful place as one of the leading voices in the fashion industry. Read on for more glamorous shots and sensational editorials, all thrown together with incredibly well-written cultural and humaninterest pieces. 1. VOGUE U.S.: For anyone who has seen “The September Issue,” it is clear the Vogue team sets an incredibly high standard for this particular month’s edition. September 2015 was the greatest example of this constant pursuit of excellence. To begin, the fashion bible spelled out who’s who in the fashion industry with “Forces of Fashion.” Over a 37-page spread, fashion’s top influencers were spelled out from Phoebe Philo of Céline, to Uniqlo and Novak Djokovic. Vogue decreed Victorian influence was a fall essential — embroidered florals and old lace — in a gorgeous editorial Hustle & Bustle. The standout among the 700+ pages was the season’s coat feature, “Into the Woods.” One of the most stunning editorials ever to be published, folkish models roamed through a fairy-tale forest. The patchwork and bright red coats popped against the brilliant blue and green mossy background. The only small disappointment of the entire issue was Beyoncé’s cover story. B’s shots were as gorgeous as ever, but Margo Jefferson’s letter dictating the definition of Beyoncé was slightly lackluster. Redemption was found, however, in the form of exclusive insights into lake life with Cindy Crawford and her equally beautiful children. And to finish on the strongest of notes, the cast of “Empire” was shot sporting the most spectacular clothing — reds, silvers, sequins and sparkles.
New season of ‘Empire’ strikes back By HAILEY MIDDLEBROOK Daily Arts Writer
In case you haven’t heard, the Lyons are back on the prowl. And they’re hungrier than ever. In its own right, FOX’s A “Empire” hasn’t so much Empire changed the TV world as it has Season 2 epitomized it — Premiere soapy glamour, Wednesdays sex, violence, at 9 p.m. family drama, banging style FOX and an on-point soundtrack — it’s all there, bold and unabashed. At its core, the storyline follows Shakespeare’s “King Lear:” an aging king, Lucious Lyon (Terrence Howard, “Iron Man”), must decide which of his three sons will inherit his hiphop recording kingdom, Empire Entertainment. But unlike Lear, Lucious is lucid and ruthless — and he’ll stop at nothing to preserve his Lyon pride. That is, as long as the rest of the Lyons agree with him. Lucious and his family not only own Empire, they run the damn show. Oldest brother Andre (Trai Byers, “Selma”) is a Wharton-educated businessman who is intent on raising Empire stock and promoting himself to CEO; but his savvy is tampered by mental health
issues and dark secrets, like his father’s murder of their cousin, Bunkie. Light-hearted Jamal (Jussie Smollett, “North”), the middle Lyon, was the R&B sensation that put Empire on the map; after a season of coming in terms with his homophobic father, he’s now the CEO of the company. Jamal’s good nature is often tested by his youngest brother, Hakeem (newcomer Bryshere Y. Gray), an up-andcoming rapper and ladies’ man with an appetite for cougars — including Lucious’s ex-fiance, Anika “Boo Boo Kitty” Calhoun (newcomer Grace Gealey).
‘Empire’ didn’t change TV so much as epitomize it. But as in the animal kingdom, the real work isn’t done by the alpha male, but rather his leading lady. And she knows it. Infamous Cookie Lyon (Taraji P. Henson, “Person of Interest”), hardened by a 17-year prison sentence for drug dealing, is back to claim her throne in the Empire, with or without her
IN PROFILE
VIRGINIA LOZANO/Daily
Ayla owners Narmeen Gaeta and Nadia Sesi took over the Main Street store four years ago.
By CAROLINE FILIPS Daily Arts Writer
From a distance, the world of high fashion seems an insular realm separate from reality. It appears an esoteric bubble, often associated with pretentious overtones — a universe inhabited by inflated personalities and embellished veneers floating within a sea of fabrics. But a visit to Main Street’s Ayla & Co. eschews any preconceived notions of fashion’s surreal associations. In the theme of Ann Arbor’s inviting allure, the boutique sustains a genuine, unique vibe that the Ayla herself established in 1980. The dynamic Ayla emigrated from Turkey with a pioneering vision to introduce fashion to Ann Arbor. She created her eponymous retailer as a space for tree town’s fashionably inclined women to shop, sip fresh-brewed coffee or tea and intermingle among exquisite textiles. “She was a wonderful woman with incredible style and an incredible vision,” current co-owner Narmeen Gaeta said. “She was kind of fearless and always ready to try something new.” Ayla transmitted that captivating bravado into her inventory’s signature aesthetic — clean and classic, yet distinctive — one Gaeta defines as good design and high style, but not fashion victim-y. Unfortunately, Ayla succumbed to breast cancer just four years into her small-business venture. Luckily, she left the store in good hands with her husband, a former shoemaker, and Gaeta, a prior sales associate during her time at the University. Gaeta’s sister, Nadia Sesi joined her on the retail team until the duo decided to oversee
TV REVIEW
FOX
“I am your father.”
ex-husband. For season two, Cookie and Lucious’s roles are flipped: Lucious is in jail for murder, while Cookie is orchestrating a “Free Lucious” concert that’s really geared toward winning back Empire investors. She’s banking on Mimi Whiteman (Marisa Tomei, “Crazy, Stupid, Love”), a rich business mogul who’s smitten with Anika, to sign a $250,000 check to rocket Empire again — but this time, with Cookie rightfully on top. To her credit, Cookie insists that she’s “doing it for family,” but her equally power-hungry sons see ulterior motives. Without Lucious in the lead, the younger Lyons must grow up on their own. Andre and controlling wife Rhonda (Kaitlin Doubleday, “Catch Me if You Can”) have big news ahead; Jamal is accepting his responsibilities as a boyfriend and gay rights advocate. Even wild child Hakeem is finding his way, ready to drop his first album. Conversely, the head Lyons — Cookie and Lucious
ANN ARBOR FASHION
— are floundering, as Cookie’s power missions fail and Lucious is stripped of entitlement behind cell walls.
The Lyons are on the prowl. But let’s be real. This is “Empire” we’re talking about, where a character’s pitfall always has a springboard at its base, ready for a full-throttle rebound. The show’s careful balance of its elements — of failures and successes, horrible violence and heartfelt reunion, disillusionment and humor — are what make it palatable. Where season two could have faltered with the solved case of inheritance, it pushes forward with the multidimensional growth of the Lyons. But as Cookie says: we’re not out of the jungle yet.
operations as co-owners and buyers. The sisters opened as “Ayla & Company” in 1989, rebranding from the former storefront of “Ayla.” Gaeta and Sesi continue to preserve Ayla’s magnetic essence, but have refashioned as necessary through the years. “We kept the spirit of it, but over the years we’ve elevated the quality as the customer base grows older,” Gaeta said. “We’ve taken the seedling of the idea and made it grow and blossom. We’ve put our own stamp on it.” With longevity to boot, the sister act has proved successful in Ann Arbor’s ever-changing retail scene. The secret seems to be an emphasis on building genuine rapport with their clientele and resisting commercialization. Though the owners stray from the promotional virtues of social media, the shop promotes a real, live space for likeminded connectedness. A visit to Ayla & Co. feels more like a personal shopping appointment than a rote retail experience of scripted customer service. Regular shoppers gossip while poring over their specific style selections per recommendation of either Gaeta or Sesi, with one of the two always working the floor. “We’re service intensive here,” Gaeta said. “The customer base likes to see us here, and they trust our opinions. We’re definitely active owners.” Their collection encompasses lifestyle pieces of eveningwear and work wear, a majority of which are European-designed. The most popular sellers range from the contemporary designs of Cacharel, to the colorful, whimsical Italian line Maliparmi; Michigandesigned b.may handbags have been a customer-coveted item, along with an accessory assortment of ornate statement
jewelry, scarves, shoes and various handbags. Though they don’t carry big-name designer labels such as Lanvin or Chloé; quality remains a top priority for Gaeta and Sesi. “Every season we try to bring in new designers,” Gaeta said. “The hallmark of our store is that we showcase lesser known designers that are really, really good. The look and the style sensibility is similar.” Keeping up with the fashion industry’s rapidity, Gaeta and Sesi curate prospective seasonal collections approximately six months in advance. Just last week Gaeta met with countless retailers in New York to assemble the store’s spring selection. “We go and buy the clothing and visit showrooms,” Gaeta said. “We do attend some trade shows because that’s where a lot of new designers get their name out.” It’s clear to see Ayla’s mentality resonates with the sisters, as they always make a point to seek out up-and-coming designers in efforts to continually present a fresh sartorial assortment. “You kind of have to risk a little bit and try something new,” Gaeta said. “That’s how you have to be in fashion. It’s very easy to stay on a certain track and never deviate. Sometimes you have to try something new because you never know when it will be wellreceived.” It’s a fearless philosophy that’s panned out well for the duo. With distinguishable sophistication in design, Ayla & Co.’s collections are multi-generational — Gaeta even admitted to selling the ombré shift dress seen in this issue to both teenage and senior patrons. Though far from dated, the standout of Ann Arbor’s retail landscape endures as a destination of accessible high fashion.
4B — Thursday, September 24, 2015
the b-side
Style by the Books Credits // Hoss ombre wool dress, Ayla 323 S. Main Street; shoes stylist’s own.
The Michigan Daily — michigandaily.com