The Tribune
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17 2026 | VOL. 46 | ISSUE 10
NEWS
TSUM Unit 2 passes motion mandating increase in pressure tactics in bargaining PG. 4
Published by the SPT, a student society of McGill University
OFF THE BOARD
Anachronistic by design PG. 11
THETRIBUNE.CA | @THETRIBUNE.CA
FEATURE
If we won’t take care of our nurses, who will take care of us? PGS. 8-9
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
In Filipino slang, calling someone plastik (plastic) means they are two-faced or insincere. (Gwen Heffernan / The Tribune) Tribune)
Rethinking plastic: A Filipino-Canadian collective movement
How collaborative action from youth innovators can help address plastic pollution PG. 14
EDITORIAL
100,000 students. Three simple demands
The Tribune Editorial Board
A
n estimated 100,000 Cégep and university students across Quebec participated in a week-long strike between Nov. 9 and Nov. 13 to protest the provincial government’s increasing austerity measures and the high cost of student living. The strike, organized by the Coalition de résistance pour l’unité étudiante syndicale (CRUES), culminated with thousands of students gathering in Montreal’s Square Victoria. Strikers demanded three central actions from the Quebec government: address acute infrastructural issues in Cégeps, invest in sufficient support staff, and make student housing affordable and accessible. The newly elected Parti Québécois (PQ) government must recognize that when even a single fundamental educational need is neglected, the resulting deficiencies erode Quebec’s entire education
system—compounding as this neglect continues. The PQ government is not wholly neglecting Quebec’s education sector; rather, its reforms are misdirected. Premier Paul St-Pierre Plamondon has proposed five major initiatives to improve public education in Quebec: promoting vocational training, prioritizing “Quebec culture,” increasing students’ physical activity, strengthening civic engagement, and fostering school diversity. While some of these projects seek to tackle genuine issues within the provincial school system, none address the far more foundational concerns raised by student protesters. The decline of school infrastructure in Quebec is, and has long been, a persistent issue. In 2024, Quebec’s auditor general reported that two-thirds of Cégep school infrastructure was deteriorating. Cégep de Saint-Laurent was forced to close yet another of its pavilions due to safety conPG. 5 cerns in August 2025.
Dolphins sing stories of resistance OPINION
Julie Raout Opinion Editor
T
his October, animal photographer and videographer Renaud Pintiaux captured a moment never before documented: belugas swimming with dolphins in the Saguenay-St. Lawrence Marine Park. Robert Michaud, pioneering researcher of the Saint Lawrence beluga and scientific director of the Groupe de recherche et d’éducation sur les mammifères marins, has highlighted the intriguing quality of the two animals’ relationships and behaviour, and scientists are working to determine the nature of these interactions. While passionate researchers like Michaud focus on the essential scientific knowledge held within these beluga sightings, others might wonder what additional lessons these mysterious creatures can teach about life above water. The value of observing marine mam-
mals goes beyond direct scientific inquiry. These animals’ resilient behaviours offer analogies for our own sociopolitical atmosphere, and can serve as a useful framework for better understanding ourselves and our own inequitable human societies. Black American writer and activist Alexis Pauline Gumbs has proven just that; she spent hundreds of hours researching aquatic animals before writing Undrowned: Black Feminist Lessons from Marine Mammals, merging ecological observations with Black feminist theory. In her book, Gumbs draws a parallel between the displacement and exploitation of marine mammals and Black communities’ experiences with historic subjugation during and because of the transatlantic slave trade. She does so not by equating these experiences to one another, but rather by understanding them PG. 5 as affinitive to one another.
2
NEWS
news@thetribune.ca
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17 2026
Over 100,000 Cégep and post-secondary students hold week-long strike against austerity
Protesters call for revamp of Quebec’s educational infrastructure Talia Moskowitz Staff Writer
O
ver 100,000 post-secondary and Cégep students went on strike from Nov. 9 to Nov. 13 against the Quebec government’s policy of austerity toward higher education institutions in the province. Organized by the Coalition de résistance pour l’unité étudiante syndicale (CRUES), a student union operating across Quebec, the week-long strike concluded with a march on Nov. 13 at 2 p.m. The protest started at Square Victoria and proceeded towards the Palais des congrès. At around 3 p.m., protesters and the Service de police de la Ville de Montréal (SPVM) clashed on av. Viger, where officers used tear gas and stun guns to break up the crowd. The protesters subsequently dispersed. In March 2026, the Quebec government published the Plan québécois des infrastructures, which earmarked $370.2 million CAD for Cégeps for infrastructural improvements. However, the Fédération des cégeps has stated that its actual needs are closer to $950 million CAD to address maintenance deficits and upgrade buildings and equipment. According to a 2024 report by the Vérificateur général du Québec, years of underfunding have left roughly two-thirds of Cégep buildings in poor condition. Julie Briand, academic affairs officer at
CRUES, critiqued Quebec Premier and Parti Québécois (PQ) leader Paul St-Pierre Plamondon’s promised budgetary allocations for Cégeps in an interview with The Tribune. “[The PQ was] pretty clear during the [October 2026 provincial] elections that their budget would be similar [to the former leading party Coalition Avenir Québec] in [terms] of austerity towards education. They’re talking about the [province’s] debt [and] not talking about increasing taxes. So the only way they’re going to be able [to address the debt is] by cutting public services, which includes higher education,” Briand said. CRUES’ two main demands of the weeklong protests were reforms to the Aides financières aux études (AFE) program—which provides scholarships and loans for post-secondary students—and a massive provincial reinvestment in post-secondary education, specifically in Cégeps. Antoine Bourguignon, a student at Cégep de Maisonneuve, described the worsening, unconducive-to-learning physical conditions of his school in an interview with The Tribune. “In my gymnasium, we can’t jump because the floor is too fragile,” Bourgignon said. Charlie Moons attends Cégep de SaintLaurent. He echoed similar concerns about poor building maintenance at his school in an interview with The Tribune. “We have some buildings that fell down,”
Moons said. “As a result, students have to L’Association générale étudiante du Cégep de travel to classrooms 20 minutes away from the Drummond, pointed out that although nominal school.” funding for Cégeps and public universities has Moons emphasized that despite this con- increased over the last decade, this has not met tinuous problem, there is still not enough pro- Quebec’s rising inflation rate. vincial investment in education. The Quebec “For people who are not really aware of government forced Cégeps to find $151 million what’s happening, they might criticize us for CAD of savings across the province’s 48 Cé- wanting more, but it’s because they don’t folgeps in August 2025. low the inflation rate,” Mikita said. Moons also explained that he attended the Briand predicted an unlimited student protest in solidarity with his fellow students, strike if the government does not respond promany of whom are forced to stay hungry dur- ductively to CRUES’ demands. ing the day because they cannot afford a meal “The point is to strike until we get suffiat school. He attributed this to rising inflation cient gains,” Briand said. in the province that has driven up the price of *Mikita’s last name was not published to basic groceries, making it difficult for students preserve anonymity. whose earnings and budgets cannot keep pace. “I know people use techniques, like smok[ing], to reduce the hunger, and it’s really depressing,” Moons shared. “That’s why we’re here to protest, because we think the government doesn’t really care.” Bourgignon underscored that students’ lack of engagement in the classroom is especially aggravated when their schools are in poor condition. “Many people just abandon [their] courses, so there’s a smaller percentage of As part of the Parti Québécois’ 2026 election attendance in the province [....] It affects campaign, Paul St-Pierre Plamondon pledged to our motivation to study,” Bourgignon said. promote vocational training and combat high school Mikita*, a member of the dropout rates. (Claire McCallum / The Tribune)
COFAM sees movement in negotiations with McGill following faculty association strike mandates
McGill provides full counteroffers to COFAM’s monetary and non-monetary demands Francesca Hayes Contributor
O
n Oct. 28, members of the Association of McGill Library Academic Staff (AMLAS) passed a mandate authorizing the union executive to call a five-day strike, following the Association of McGill Professors of the Faculty of Arts (AMPFA) passing its own limited strike mandate on Oct. 10. This means four member associations of the Confederation of Faculty Associations of McGill (COFAM) now have a limited strike mandate, as the Association of McGill Professors of Education (AMPE) and the Association of McGill Academic Staff of the School of Continuing Studies (AMASCS) both passed limited strike mandates unanimously in summer 2026. AMLAS and AMPFA’s strike mandates have come over a year into the negotiation process between COFAM and McGill. In an interview with The Tribune, AMPFA President Catherine Leclerc explained that COFAM has been collectively bargaining with McGill since July 2025. Leclerc highlighted that, amid this remarkably slow negotiation process, faculty unions’ strike mandates are reinvigorating bargaining efficiency. “We’re not even striking for better offers, we’re striking for movement, [for] progress at the table,” Leclerc said. Over the course of negotiations with McGill, COFAM has outlined and separately pursued its monetary demand book and nonmonetary demand book. Its non-monetary demands—which the confederation submitted to
the university’s administration in July 2025— are focused on improving the governance and relations between McGill and COFAM by addressing items such as correspondence, intellectual property, and job classifications. McGill did not respond to COFAM with a full non-monetary counteroffer until Oct. 14, 2026, after AMPE and AMASCS adopted strike mandates. On Oct. 28, McGill also presented its complete response to COFAM’s monetary demand book, following AMLAS’ passing of the strike mandate. One of COFAM’s non-monetary demands specifically addresses the working conditions of Contract Academic Staff (CAS) at McGill. Leclerc shed light on some specific CAS experiences. “[Currently CAS] can be given a threeyear contract, renewable or not renewable. If it’s not renewable, it might be renewed nonetheless, but you will only know at the last minute. You could lose your job after six years for no reason,” Leclerc said. CAS staff are provided far less job security and fewer protections than tenured staff are, but CAS are often still required to complete the same amount and kind of work. One of COFAM’s primary demands is that these staff members be transitioned into the tenure stream. AMLAS President Jill Boruff pointed out, in an interview with The Tribune, how McGill’s lack of transparency around CAS contracts complicates and threatens work allocations for both tenured and CAS librarians. “We [have been] really concerned for our jobs, plain and simple,” Boruff said.
According to COFAM, McGill’s mone“McGill’s librarians are academic staff,” tary counteroffers largely maintain the univer- the MRO wrote. “McGill respects the right of sity’s financial status quo, which COFAM has faculty members to organize in the manner they critiqued for diminishing the purchasing power choose, consistent with Quebec labour law.” of McGill’s faculty. As bargaining continues, The next bargaining dates between McCOFAM will be holding mobilizing committee Gill and COFAM are scheduled for Nov. 17 meetings to discuss potential strikes in light of and 24. Leclerc emphasized the significance the member unions’ new mandates. of continued action and solidarity among COCOFAM also claims that McGill has also FAM’s membership and the broader professooutright rejected or ignored certain articles of rial community. their demand books, including Article 27 on ar“Are we satisfied with the pace [of bartificial intelligence (AI) and Article 28 regard- gaining]? Absolutely not. Are we satisfied with ing staff pension plans. The McGill University [McGill’s] offers? Absolutely not. But we are Pension Plan follows a two-tiered system that still going to the table, the administration is still was outlawed in Quebec in 2018 due to its dis- showing up, [and is] taking us increasingly secriminatory effect on younger workers. How- riously,” Leclerc said. ever, this ruling does not apply to pre-existing pension agreements, allowing McGill to keep its twotiered system, which it established in 2008 for all hires after Jan. 1, 2009. According to Boruff and Leclerc, McGill’s previous actions toward and statements about librarians have made these librarians question whether they are being afforded the same entitlements as other academic staff at McGill, despite the administration’s assertion that they are. In a written statement to The Tribune, McGill’s Media Relations Office (MRO) affirmed that McGill respects all of its In McGill’s monetary counteroffer, the administration staff’s right to unionize, including proposes a 2 per cent base rate increase in some faculty’s librarians. salaries with a reduced merit package. (Zoe Lee / The Tribune)
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17 2026
news@thetribune.ca
NEWS
3
Senators press McGill on deteriorating infrastructure and athletics costs
Meeting discusses provincial funding’s impact on maintenance and reinstatement of varsity Track and Field Clara Smyrski Managing Editor
O
n Nov. 11, the McGill Senate convened for its third session in the Fall 2026 semester. Vivek Venkatesh, acting chair and Faculty of Education professor, led the council, as McGill President and Vice-Chancellor Deep Saini was away on university business. The meeting opened with memorial tributes for three professors emeriti—Peter Schuepp from the Faculty of Agriculture and Environmental Sciences, Frank Dumont from the Faculty of Education, and Derek Gray from the Department of Chemistry— followed by a moment of silence to commemorate Remembrance Day. Next, the Senate moved into a question period. Senator Terry Hébert, professor in the Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, submitted a question regarding the conditions of undergraduate teaching spaces in his faculty, and urged University Advancement to report on its fundraising plans for these facilities. “I’ve been here for more than 20 years now, and I have not seen a renovated teaching space for undergraduate programs in the Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences,” Hébert said. “Saving the spaces we have now is equally important as building new spaces.” Provost and Executive Vice-President (Academic) Angela Campbell replied that
McGill can only fund a small fraction of its deferred maintenance needs, and falling behind on building maintenance compounds the problem. However, Campbell shared that McGill has extra financial capacity this fiscal year and is investing $15 million CAD towards classroom upgrades—significantly less than the estimated $125 million CAD per year necessary for maintenance and renovation. “We get a very small portion of funding for what’s needed from the province, and the rest of it has to come from somewhere or nowhere. And if it’s from nowhere, the work doesn’t get done [....] There’s many, many rooms across campus that are subpar [....] We’re trying our best,” Campbell said. In item four of the following Open Session, the Dean of Students and Associate Provost (Student Life & Learning) Tony Mittermaier presented a report from the Athletics and Recreation Strategic Planning Task Force, which launched in February 2026. The Task Force has recommended that McGill Athletics and Recreation reinstate the women’s and men’s Varsity Track and Field programs. Mittermaier also shared that, per the report, the other 24 teams McGill Athletics cut from its programming in November 2025 should remain discontinued. The Task Force report proposes a transparent framework outlining what teams must do to keep or earn their varsity status. Mittermaier said the report will go through
student consultations this month before re- Pathology Edith Zorychta. turning to the Senate for an endorsement Moment of the Meeting vote in December, followed by a Board of After presenting the Academic Policy Governors vote on Dec. 10. The recruitment Committee’s meeting-specific report and its of a permanent senior director of McGill annual report, Deputy Provost (Academic) Athletics is expected to begin in January. Christopher Buddle was called on a third During the question period, Student time to present his portfolio. Venkatesh Senator Frances Li pointed out that the rethanked Buddle as “Senator Hat Trick” port contains almost no dollar figures, and before handing the floor over. that the annual Athletics and Recreation fee Soundbite the university charges full-time students has “McGill lives and dies on its recently risen; she questioned this increase reputation and its appearance and rankings in light of last year’s cuts. [....] I worry about the reputational damage “Student fees represent [Athletics and in always focusing on the novel at McGill, Recreation]’s largest revenue source, acthe Sustainability Park, which is ironic counting for 55 per cent of its total revenue given the unsustainability of much of the and 75 per cent of its operating revenue. rest of the university.” But since 2020, the mandatory [Athletics —Senator Hébert on McGill’s and Recreation] fee has increased by an infrastructure issue. average of approximately 3 per cent annually,” Li said. “When can the Senate expect a detailed breakdown of the Athletics and Recreation Strategic [Task Force] plans’ projected costs, and how [will] student fees be allocated [...] to support its implementation?” Mittermaier replied that a business development committee—chaired by the McGill Chancellor—will determine the plan’s budget. He did not provide a timeline. The Senate then moved to a confidential session to hear a report from the Honorary Degrees and Convocations Commit- The Nov. 11 report by the Academic Policy tee, presented by University Marshal and Committee’s was its 546th since the Senate’s Associate Professor in the Department of establishment in 1935. (Eliot Loose / The Tribune)
The Tribune Explains: Interim report of new Macdonald Campus task force
McGill introduces task force at Macdonald Campus to determine room for academic and community growth Josette Chandler News Editor
I
n April 2026, aiming to develop recommendations for improving enrolment, research, and academic programs, McGill created the Task Force on the Future of Macdonald Campus. Work on the task force began in May; the Macdonald Campus administration circulated an online survey from June to October and held a virtual town hall in September to collect feedback from the community. On Nov. 6, McGill released an interim report detailing the progress made so far by the task force on future plans for the Macdonald Campus. The Tribune breaks down what plans were introduced in the interim report and what changes will be made for students. What academic changes were introduced in the interim report? In the interim report, the task force’s cochairs—Provost and Executive Vice-President (VP) (Academic) Angela Campbell, VP (Administration and Finance) Fabrice Labeau, and Dean of Faculty of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences Salwa Karboune—established their objectives. Generally, the task force intends to focus on building the Macdonald Campus’s strengths, turning Macdonald Campus into an interfaculty destination, increasing enrolment, and developing intercampus connectivity. As a strategy to expand the Macdonald Campus’ existing strengths, the report outlines the aim of incorporating more hands-on and experiential
learning opportunities at the campus. This would entail using the campus’ environmental strengths, such as its farms, forests, and shoreline. The task force also recognizes the potential for the Macdonald Campus to offer Indigenous-led and co-developed land-based learning by expanding its current hosting of Indigenous events, such as McGill’s annual Pow Wow. The report also announced preliminary plans to expedite the expansion of the Faculty of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences through changes to its existing programs. Strategies include expanding the Biotechnology and Nutrition programs, as well as establishing a greater connectivity between the Macdonald Campus and the Downtown Campus-based Bieler School of Environment. The task force also aims to reposition McGill’s Agricultural Economics major as the campus’ leading interdisciplinary program through collaboration with the Faculty of Arts and Desautels Faculty of Management. In addition, the task force intends to develop the current Minor in One Health—which focuses on the links between human, environmental, agricultural, and nutritional health—into a major. The task force is also considering offering some programs currently provided downtown— specifically those with an existing interdisciplinary element and high enrolment—at Macdonald Campus as well. When will these changes be enacted? The task force has evaluated the proposechanges based upon their enrolment potential, logistical complexity, and estimated timelines, cat-
egorizing initiatives as short-term, medium-term, and long-term in its interim report. The development of the Agricultural Economics Major into a flagship program, strategic growth of the Agricultural and Environmental Science Faculty, and the creation of an experimental learning hub have been classified as short-term projects, meaning they could be implemented within the next three years. The One Health major is projected to be a medium-term project, which would take up to five years to implement. The addition of new programs from the Downtown Campus at Macdonald Campus is classified as a long-term goal, meaning it will require substantial infrastructure development at Macdonald Campus and more than five years to implement.
factors: the REM’s reliability, environmental considerations, and the viability of Société de transport de Montréal (STM) services as an alternative means of transportation for students. How can I share my opinion on the possible changes at Macdonald Campus? The task force continues to accept feedback on the ideas presented thus far in the report. Thoughts can be shared through the feedback survey available on the interim report, or you can reach out to one of the task force’s co-chairs. To share feedback on the intercampus shuttle and its possible discontinuation, email shuttlebus. macdonald@mcgill.ca.
What does this mean for the future of the intercampus shuttle? Following the opening of the Anse-à-l’Orme Réseau express métropolitain (REM) station, McGill announced a possible cancellation of the intercampus shuttle, which connects the Macdonald Campus to the Downtown Campus. The interim report announced that the shuttle will remain active at least until December 2027. Until that time, McGill will evaluate the necessity of the Around 2,000 students study at the Macdonald Campus. (Josette shuttle in light of a variety of Chandler / The Tribune)
4
NEWS
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17 2026
news@thetribune.ca
TSUM Unit 2 passes motion mandating increase in pressure tactics in bargaining Assembly meeting discusses bargaining updates and mobilization Asher Kui Managing Editor
O
n Nov. 11, the Teaching Support Union at McGill (TSUM)’s Unit 2—the union of invigilators at McGill—convened for an assembly. Unit 2 members presented bargaining updates and discussed mobilization and finances, before finishing the meeting by passing a motion mandating pressure tactics when campaigning. Numa Karolinski, a delegate from TSUM’s Unit 1—the bargaining unit representing teaching assistants at McGill— opened the meeting by reading the union’s equity statement, land recognition, and mask policy. TSUM President Ari Blondal welcomed union members to the meeting. Unit 2 Grievance Officer Sneha Senthil then presented bargaining updates. Senthil spoke to TSUM’s non-monetary demands that McGill has rejected, including better shift allocation, an end to bathroom trash monitoring as part of invigilator duties, and access to snacks and coffee. Senthil emphasized the importance of the union’s solidarity. “We also ask for better staffing, and McGill has constantly said no to all these demands,” Senthil said. “Member involvement is very important as long as we have unity, as long as we have more invigilators [in the union]. It’s great, we can show to McGill that we’re not going to back off.” A participant at the meeting, who wished to remain anonymous, then noted that McGill insists on using the term “equitable” over “fair” when discussing TSUM’s demands, specifically the union’s shift allocation requests. The participant explained the possible implications of this language. “A ‘fair’ allocation would be something where everybody seems to have access to benefits, perhaps equal benefits, as opposed to ‘equitable’ allocation, which is somewhat vague and a term that is used
in the law […] to squeeze in this last opportunity [of] […] saying, ‘In equity, this is the way it should go,’” the participant said. “We should insist on using the word ‘fair’ allocation and block McGill from using any opportunity in the future [to say] they’re doing the best they can.” Senthil agreed with the participant, further highlighting the urgency of avoiding unambiguous language in bargaining. “Even if we say ‘fair’ allocation, I agree that it’s much better than what McGill is using, although when it comes to filing grievances […] even ‘fair’ is unfortunately pretty ambiguous,” Senthil said. “We [want] a mechanism that is written clearly about […] how invigilators should be allowed to work almost equal shifts [....] Having a mechanism is much better than having ‘fair’ or ‘equitable’ shift allocation in our collective agreement language.” TSUM Mobilization Officer Gianluca Guglietti then presented the invigilator
unit’s mobilization agenda. He echoed Senthil’s sentiment, calling for invigilators to stand in solidarity with the bargaining unit. “We’ve never been on strike. We’ve never put on serious pressure tactics. Every bargaining session, we end up taking what McGill gives us, and that has to end. McGill wants invigilators to be too scared to bargain hard,” Guglietti said. “We want McGill to know that invigilators are behind the bargaining team, that it’s not just three people sitting at a table, negotiating this collective agreement. It’s an entire workforce that is behind [it].” Guglietti also discussed why the association is pursuing wage bargaining between TSUM’s Unit 2 and McGill. While TSUM is asking for an hourly wage of $25-27 CAD for invigilators, McGill has instead offered a 94¢ CAD increase in invigilator’s hourly wages over the next five years—ultimately raising the hourly wage to $18.94 CAD. Guglietti expressed that
The Association of Graduate Students Employed at McGill changed its name to TSUM in April 2026 to reflect employed undergraduate populations. (Eliot Loose / The Tribune)
McGill’s counterproposal disregards rising living costs in Montreal and growing financial insecurity among students. “We’ve definitely heard a lot of news about budget cuts [at McGill] over recent years, [and] austerity from the provincial government, but if we think realistically about how much an invigilator costs, and we compare that to the hundreds of thousands of dollars that upper admins make [at McGill], it’s ridiculous to say there’s no money for invigilators,” Guglietti said. In a written statement to The Tribune, McGill’s Media Relations Office (MRO) declined to comment specifically on the Unit 2 wage negotiations. “Bargaining is facilitated when both parties can explore trade-offs candidly, test ideas, and move positions without each stage of those discussions being debated publicly,” the MRO wrote. “We will refrain from confirming, denying, or commenting publicly on specific bargaining proposals that may circulate while negotiations remain ongoing.” The Unit 2 assembly passed a motion during the meeting, mandating the creation of an Invigilator Mobilization Unit Committee that collaborates with TSUM’s Mobilization Department. At the end of the meeting, members additionally voted on a motion to increase bargaining pressure tactics, which passed unanimously. Members present at the meeting also voted on a motion to remove the two semester contract from the bargaining mandate, citing McGill’s substandard offer and its lower priority as rationale for the removal. The motion passed with a majority. Guglietti highlighted the crucial role that invigilators play in student and administrative life at the university. “McGill knows that McGill doesn’t work if we don’t work,” Guglietti emphasized. “They know that invigilators are essential to the running of exams. We do have a lot of bargaining power to win a big contract.”
Recap: SPVM officer tampers with proof of domestic violence SPVM conduct raises questions of police accountability and transparency Parisa Rasul Staff Writer
A
ccording to an Oct. 30 Radio-Canada report, a Service de police de la Ville de Montréal (SPVM) police officer from Station 39 in MontréalNord allegedly deleted video evidence of domestic abuse from a woman’s phone in 2025 while responding to her emergency call, as he recognized the alleged abuser. This incident surfaced during a 2026 investigation into widespread discriminatory and racist misconduct at Station 39, and was initially reported to the station’s sergeants by a woman officer who also responded to the domestic violence call. The sergeants did not take action against the alleged police officer—prompting her to raise her concerns to a higher level within the SPVM. In an interview with The Tribune, Abe
Berglas, from the Quebec Public Interest Research Group (QPIRG)-McGill, stressed the importance of holding police accountable while cautioning against vindicating policing as an institution by supporting certain accountability measures. “There are reforms that […] legitimize the institution of policing. For example, body cameras tend to […] give more funding to the police [overall],” Berglas said. “There are incremental changes that can be made to improve the lives of people affected by the system without legitimizing [the police, such as] disarming police officers, [and] investing in alternative justice models.” Berglas also argued that the SPVM’s delegation of investigations into officer misconduct to the Bureau des enquêtes indépendantes (BEI) is a way for the police force to mitigate its accountability. Berglas expressed their concern over the BEI’s ef-
ficacy and mismanagement of cases. ing their children in court than about [send“How this case was handled is a fea- ing] their abuser [to] jail,” Berglas noted. ture and not a bug [....] We’re talking about According to the Radio-Canada report, corruption, but I feel as though it’s really the SPVM officer is currently under internal the [police] institution as a whole [that] investigation but has not been dismissed. can’t be fixed by changing the channels of reporting [incidents],” Berglas said. Berglas also explained that the criminal justice system’s focus often does not match what domestic abuse survivors may want. In this case, the survivor may prioritize their children’s safety over their abuser’s incarceration. “Justice means different things to different people. Sometimes domestic violence victims are much Five SPVM officers from Station 39 have been dismissed for dismore concerned about los- criminatory and racist behaviour. (Rokayah Bellaoui / The Tribune)
opinion@thetribune.ca
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17 2026
T EDITORIAL BOARD Editor-in-Chief Mairin Burke editor@thetribune.ca Creative Director Zoe Lee creativedirector@thetribune.ca Managing Editors Asher Kui akui@thetribune.ca Ellen Lurie elurie@thetribune.ca Clara Smyrski csmyrski@thetribune.ca News Editors Ilia Mehr-Bakhsh Josette Chandler Helene Saleska news@thetribune.ca Opinion Editors Lulu Calame Julie Raout Camila Sierra Ordóñez opinion@thetribune.ca Science & Technology Editors Avery Berry Sarah McDonald scitech@thetribune.ca Student Life Editors Rachel Blackstone Tamiyana Roemer studentlife@thetribune.ca Features Editor Kaitlyn Schramm features@thetribune.ca Arts & Entertainment Editors Norah Adams Annabella Lawlor arts@thetribune.ca Sports Editors Merce Kellner Ivanna Zhang sports@thetribune.ca Design Editors Eliot Loose Gwen Heffernan design@thetribune.ca Photo Editors Emiko Kamiya Sophie Schuyler photo@thetribune.ca Multimedia Editors Will Dawson Daphne Short multimedia@thetribune.ca Web Developers Zola Ball Kate Lauro webdev@thetribune.ca Copy Editor Ella Bachrach copy@thetribune.ca Social Media Editor Chloe Ross socialmedia@thetribune.ca Business Manager Amy Xia business@thetribune.ca
TPS BOARD OF DIRECTORS Zain Ahmed, Nour Khouri, Celine Li, Lialah Mavani, Ilia Mehr Bakhsh, Aleks Rohozinski, Alex Hawes Silva
STAFF Zain Ahmed, Julia Apitz-Grossman, Brooke Barak, Miranda Forster, Abigail Francis, Alex Hawes Silva, Helena Helms, Dylan Hing, Gretta Iraheta Palacios, Lialah Mavani, Shea McDonnell, Jenna Payette, Sofia Vidinovski Rokayah Bellaoui, Chloe Bhogal, Tobias Izenberg, Evy Shamber
CONTRIBUTORS Aélia Gyger, Francesca Hayes, Shivani Mahan
TRIBUNE OFFICE Shatner University Centre, 3480 McTavish, Suites 404, 405, 406 The Tribune is an editorially autonomous newspaper published by the Société de Publication de la Tribune, a student society of McGill University. The content of this publication is the sole responsibility of The Tribune and the Société de Publication de la Tribune, and does not necessarily represent the views of McGill University. Letters to the editor may be sent to editor@thetribune.ca and must include the contributor’s name, program and year and contact information. Letters should be kept under 300 words and submitted only to The Tribune. Submissions judged by The Tribune Publication Society to be libellous, sexist, racist, homophobic or solely promotional in nature will not be published. The Tribune reserves the right to edit all contributions. Editorials are decided upon and written by the editorial board. All other opinions are strictly those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of The Tribune, its editors or its staff.
100,000 students. Three simple demands The Tribune Editorial Board Continued from page 1. Meanwhile, the English Montreal School Board (EMSB) announced in October 2026 that Quebec’s maintenance deficit for school infrastructure has risen to $9.8 billion CAD, and that 53 per cent of the province’s schools are in poor condition. The impact of functional and high-quality educational infrastructure on the wellbeing and performance of students and educators alike cannot be overstated. One study from the National Bureau of Economic Research found that investments in school heating, ventilation, and air conditioning systems increased student test scores even more than investments in scientific equipment. If proper climate control bears such a significant impact on student performance, one can only
COMMENTARY Julie Raout Opinion Editor Continued from page 1. By blurring the boundary of lived experience between humans and non-humans, Gumbs expands definitions of humanity that have long relied on separation and domination, thus welcoming more fluid conceptions of empathetic identification. In Undrowned, she writes, “And I thought I was done writing about striped dolphins, but so many of us are dizzy and labored, bewildered and estranged [like these animals]. So what would I say if I was a striped dolphin? [....] We are sick of these tired cycles of economic vulnerability, resource grabs, and waste and harm spiralling down. We are ready to breathe differently.” As Gumbs observes, much of the behaviours marine mammals display are anchored in resilience and resistance. Gumbs describes marine mammals as “undrowned,” still breathing in the waters that violent human structures have long sought to smother them in—much like Black women who resist the tides of systemic oppression. From the history of
imagine how an entire school building deteriorating to the point of collapse could affect students. Furthermore, the government’s school support staff hiring freeze since 2024 has left elementary and Cégep students across Quebec increasingly undersupported. Remaining staff are overstressed, overworked, and on the brink of quitting. Students with special educational needs who most interact with support staff bear the brunt of these cuts. Quebec’s austerity reflects a clear disregard for students with disabilities’ human right to an education, sending the message that students who require accommodations are not deserving of the same standards of accessibility, dignity, and academic aspirations as their peers. Alongside demands regarding infrastructural repairs and the
hiring of more support and professional staff, the student protesters emphasized that the government must address the major shortcomings in Quebec student housing options. CRUES previously called for the establishment of affordable student housing under public control—rendered increasingly necessary amidst the rising cost of living in Quebec and alarming levels of food insecurity among students. As housing near Cégeps and universities grows increasingly expensive, many students are forced to live further away from campus, undermining their academic performance. Students who live in on-campus residences—which come with hefty price tags—enjoy higher grades and graduate at rates 15 per cent higher than those who live off campus. Quebec’s 100,000 student strikers are not demanding impossible luxuries—quite
OPINION
5
EDITORIAL
the opposite. It is the PQ government’s fundamental responsibility to fulfill these demands in their entirety by providing lower-cost housing for students, investing in staffing, and funding the necessary reconditioning of collapsing educational facilities. These actions must come before investing in secondary reforms like the curricular changes StPierre Plamondon has proposed. McGill students’ own familiarity with austerity necessitates solidarity with our fellow students on strike. McGill, meanwhile, must learn from this strike, and work to uphold the tenets of accessible and highquality education for its own students. It is through sustained collective action that demands for positive change become reality. The Quebec government must stay on the right side of history by investing in students’ right to a functioning, flourishing, and fulfilling education.
Dolphins sing stories of resistance slavery in Quebec that the province’s government still tries to conceal, to the disproportionate representation of Black women in femicide cases, systemic racism against Black women is still very much alive in Canada. Today, nearly half of Black Canadian women report having experienced discrimination, something that becomes particularly visible in the healthcare system. Black Canadians face much higher risks of serious pregnancy complications The beluga population in Quebec’s Saint Lawrence river has plummeted from than their white counterparts, 10,000 at the start of the 20th century to approximately 1,800 in 2026. (Chloe and the Canadian health care Bhogal / The Tribune) system is less likely to take Black women’s pain seriously. in the womb. In these moments, resilience, community, and As a result, almost half of Black other dolphins do not emit their creativity in the face of systemic women, girls, and gender- own whistles, to allow the calf injustice’s drowning tempest. diverse people in Canada have to learn its mother’s. Gumbs As Gumbs demonstrates, marine postponed or avoided consulting interprets these behaviours mammals provide us with a physician out of fear of as acts of tender solidarity— alternative ways to affirm life experiencing racism. connecting them to the story that systemic power structures Black women also face of Black liberation advocate prefer to conceptualize in terms racist barriers in the Canadian Debbie Africa, who secretly of domination. workplace more broadly, dealing gave birth in prison as other So, as humans learn more with misogynoir and receiving, detainees made sounds to muffle about dolphins and belugas’ on average, only 78 cents for her labour, allowing her to spend interactions in the Saint every dollar a white man makes time with her son before the Lawrence River, let us not as an employee. guards took him away. forget to identify with marine Scientists have found that Gumbs’ work brings mammals, rather than solely weeks before and after dolphin Black women’s resistance to identify their species, size, mothers give birth, they sing a the surface via a poetic ode to underbelly colour, and whether signature whistle to their calves marine mammals. She celebrates or not they can swim backwards.
6
OPINION
COMMENTARY
opinion@thetribune.ca
Alberta’s flag policies regulate more than just fabric
Shivani Mahan Contributor
S
tarting Jan. 4, Alberta’s new flag display regulations will dictate which flags are allowed to be flown in school classrooms, while requiring the display of Albertan and Canadian flags in front of all schools. Minister of Education Demetrios Nicolaides asserted that any flags representing a “social or political cause” will be banned. Hence, Alberta’s new flag regulations are not harmful because of their aspiration to neutrality, but rather because they risk eroding fundamental liberal democratic principles by jeopardizing safe identity expression. More than simple pieces of folded fabric, flags symbolize culture, faith, and community, and are used around the world to strengthen allegiance and provide a sense of belonging. Following the recent Alberta referendum, in which voters overwhelmingly rejected projects of provincial independence from the rest of Canada, these regulations may represent the government attempting to inspire communal unity. A flag is most galvanizing when people see and interpret familiar imagery in it. The Canadian flag mirrors the winter snow and autumnal red maple leaves of the country’s scenery, while the Albertan flag, adopted in 1968, bears a provincial shield with scenes from Alberta’s landscape. Alberta’s new flag display rules only permit temporary displays of First Nations, Métis, and foreign national flags on specified days or occasions. Alberta Teachers’ Association President Jason Schilling condemned
COMMENTARY
these regulations for undermining educational awareness and recognition of Indigenous lands, traditional territories, and communities, which shape Alberta’s foundations and warrant unconditional respect. The ban therefore also opposes the multicultural values that Canada claims to uphold. Similarly, in the name of secularism, Quebec’s National Assembly passed Bill 9 last April, prohibiting public workers from wearing religious symbols and banning dedicated prayer zones in public spaces. The assembly pre-emptively invoked the notwithstanding clause to shield the bill from challenges under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. A concerning cross-provincial pattern emerges through these legislative actions, in which policies project discriminatory perspectives onto communities deserving of positive public representation under the guise of protection. Wing Li, communications director for Support Our Students Alberta, argues the Alberta flag regulations appear to be driven by an ideological desire for control, particularly by minimizing 2SLGBTQIA+ identities. Rather than fostering inclusion, such measures decrease the equitable nature of educational spaces. Although far from the only pride flag, the rainbow flag, created in 1978 by artist Gilbert Baker, has become a central symbol of queer solidarity worldwide. Research conducted with 2SLGBTQIA+ youth across Massachusetts, Minnesota, and British Columbia found that the pride rainbow this flag draws on fos-
ters feelings of safety, community support, identity exploration, and kinship—key to protecting the wellbeing of queer individuals who disproportionately experience mental health challenges. As education policy in Canada is largely provincially governed,there is substantial capacity to champion positive social change at a localized level. Instead, Alberta law requires flags be flown in order of seniority, with the flag of Canada given the most precedence. (Gwen Heffernan / The Tribune) Alberta has rolled out a series of antagonistic policies against queer edness is visible signs of pride support in education. In 2024, Premier Danielle Smith schools, including flags and posters. introduced policies making sexual health, Alberta’s incoming flag regulations serve sexuality, and identity education opt-in rather as a gateway for policies which further underthan opt-out. Coupled with a deficit of com- mine the use of flags as emblems of agency, prehensive teacher training across Canada, barring individuals from wearing flags or flag these flag restrictions exacerbate Alberta’s symbols on backpacks, bracelets, and other harmful, anti-2SLGBTQIA+ policy trends, such modalities to signpost and connect with further distancing the province from provid- others. Banning flags does not reinforce neuing an inclusive education for all. trality or unity. It dilutes diverse identities— Inclusive school climates are essential to including cultural heritage, sexuality, and student wellbeing, especially for students who gender—and unfairly dictates which aspects are already marginalized. Studies show that of young people’s identities are welcome trans and non-binary youth who experienced within the borders of the classroom. Rather higher school connectedness were twice as than encouraging students to embrace their likely to report excellent mental health than unique identities from an early age, Alberta peers who felt less connected. A central rec- has left youth to walk around schools with no ommendation for improving such connect- sign that they belong.
Israel’s colonial violence is settling into Canadian markets
Ellen Lurie Managing Editor
S
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17 2026
ince the escalation of Israel’s genocide in Gaza and settler-colonial project in the occupied West Bank, Israeli real estate agents have increasingly sought to advertise property and development opportunities in this occupied region to American and Canadian audiences. These listings falsely identify real estate in the occupied territories as being located in Israel. Since Oslo II, Israel has strategically fragmented the West Bank into an archipelago of Palestinian enclaves. Multiplying checkpoints and permit systems further prevent Palestine’s territorial contiguity; simultaneous settler colonialism in the West Bank further accelerates this theft. Israeli real estate agencies’ pattern of fallaciously depicting properties in the occupied West Bank as being located in Israel is an extension of this violence—a violence which is augmented and internationalized through covert advertising schemes in Canada. In response to these listings, Global Echo Litigation Center and Canadian Lawyers for International Human Rights have filed a 130page complaint with Canada’s Commissioner of Competition, arguing these advertisements constitute false or misleading representations under the federal Competition Act. The complaint names four Israeli companies—Tivuch Shelly, Noam Homes, Meny Group, and Effi Capital—and one Canadian company, Cohen Group, as responsible for such advertisements.
Events such as “The Great Israeli Real Estate Event,” which visited Montreal and Toronto in March 2024, offered Canadian attendees real estate advice pertaining to properties in Neve Daniel, Efrat, and Ma’ale Adumim—all Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank. The “Israel Real Estate Briefing” of April 2026, which also came to Montreal and Toronto, similarly advertised real estate opportunities in the occupied territories, including in Gush Etzion, Mitzpe Yericho, Givat Ze’ev, Sha’are Tikva, Givat Hamatos, and Geva Binyamin. As affirmed by the International Court of Justice’s 2024 advisory opinion, any and all settlements in the West Bank are illegal under international law, as they constitute the transfer of the occupying power—Israel’s—civilian population, into an occupied territory—Palestine. Israeli settlements are intentionally built in horizontal “settlement corridors” intended to disrupt and fragment Palestinian land, thereby hindering the viability of a future Palestinian state. Israeli settlers inflict violence onto Palestinians within these unlawful corridors—setting fire to their homes and classrooms, beating them with rifles, emptying their water tanks, and pumping sewage onto their farmlands. In Israel, settler violence goes far beyond acts of interpersonal aggression: It is an overt attempt to make way for the expansionist Israeli state by displacing and ethnically cleansing Palestinians. Recent reports by Al Jazeera recount Israeli settlers attacking Palestinians in the West Bank and returning days later dressed in Israeli
military uniforms, revealing the intertwined na- Palestinian land, along with other commercial ture of settler and state-led violence. threats to Palestinian autonomy that arise in the As such, discretely advertising real es- future. tate on occupied Palestinian land to unknowIsrael’s colonial project knows no borders, ing North Americans is itself a colonial act and relies on inconspicuous opportunities to designed to deny and suppress Palestinian na- implicitly assert control over Palestinian land. tional identity and statehood. North Americans must remain attentive to IsraFurthermore, failing to identify these el’s manipulation on the stages of rhetoric and properties as being located on occupied Pal- advertising to wholly combat Israeli violations estinian land directly violates Canadian adver- of Palestinian sovereignty. tising transparency principles. In 2017, the Canadian Food Inspection Agency received a similar complaint regarding Israel’s implicit assertion of sovereignty through advertising. Two wines, which appeared on the shelves of Canadian supermarkets, were labelled “Products of Israel” despite being produced entirely in illegal Israeli settlements in the West Bank. In the 2019 ruling of Kattenburg v. Attorney General of Canada, the Federal Court of Canada found that the Israeli wine companies had engaged in false advertising, as West Bank settlements do not constitute part of Israel. Israel’s claims of possession over the West Bank—whether they be made over land, property, or exports—are undeniably imperialist acts organized around the systematic denial of the self-determination and human rights of Palestinians. Canada’s Commissioner of Competition must follow national precedent and condemn these unlawful More than 750,000 Israeli settlers currently live in the real estate advertisements of unceded West Bank. (Eliot Loose / The Tribune)
arts@thetribune.ca
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17 2026
ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT
7
A stop-motion love letter to my hometown
‘Wildwood’ prevails in the dying art of the handmade Abigail Francis Staff Writer
P
lace, the space one’s body inhabits, is integral to identity. I am lucky enough to have called Portland, Oregon, my place for 12 years. I was born in the city and spent my childhood there, and that upbringing is ingrained into the foundations I stand on today. Based in Portland, LAIKA Studios’ newest stop-motion film Wildwood is a staggeringly beautiful homage to both my hometown and theirs. Wildwood follows a young girl named Prue, who lives in a distinctly Portland fashion with her extremely hippie parents and baby brother Mac. When her parents head off to a craft fair, Prue babysits Mac with strict instructions to stay inside the house. Naturally, she de- cides it’s time for her little brother to see the city. But when Mac is snatched away by a murder of crows, Prue is forced to venture into the Impassable Wilderness that lies beyond Portland’s city limits to rescue him. Her meek but lovable classmate Curtis accidentally joins the quest, and the two enter a forest clash between bandits, a faction of talking birds, pacifist mystics, and a powerful dowager who governs the land with the help of her band of coyotes. The film’s entire 132-minute runtime felt like a personal nostalgia trip. LAIKA has crafted the ultimate love letter to the Pacific Northwest, the atmosphere complete with an ever-so-present overcast. I appreciated the studio’s dedication
to showing Portland’s true undercurrent of magic. Of course, there were the obvious nods to Portland’s unique lore: The Darth Vader-clad unipiper, Voodoo doughnuts, and the McCall Waterfront in full cherry blossom bloom were all thoughtfully rendered into life. But having lived in Portland for more than a decade and still returning often, I found myself uniquely privy to recognizing the landscapes woven into Wildwood’s enchanted forest scenes. I would spot a waterfall on-screen and recognize its real equivalent instantly—such as the animated Columbia River Gorge that takes over the screen as characters run through the cliffs. It turned my own viewing experience into a kind of treasure hunt, an opportunity to trace the familiar landscapes that make Oregon so special to me. Although the movie’s plot occasionally felt a bit basic, following closely in the footsteps of traditional good-versus-evil narratives, the detailed visuals more than made up for anything the plotline lacked. That is not to say there was no nuance beneath Wildwood’s familiar storyline. Curtis’ character acts as a vehicle to explore the loss of childhood and the gradual erosion of innocence, while the blurring of grief and malicious intent gives the main villain a more complicated edge. At its heart, the film is entirely humanist; its emphasis on what binds us together, rather than what divides us, was a refreshing change of pace from normative film tropes.
Even external to its nostalgia points, craftsmanship is particularly staggering. Wildwood’s visuals were absolutely as- One of the main characters—a massive tounding. There were many moments that eagle—required some insanely complicated prompted me to turn to my friend, mouth engineering. The 34-inch puppet, with its agape, whispering loudly—with apologies enormous 64-inch wingspan, features apto the couple behind us—“How did they proximately 3,700 hand-placed feathers. It make this?” is the most mechanically complex puppet The impeccable use of such an intricate LAIKA has ever made, with each feather animation form makes the film feel like an then animated individually. enormous middle finger to the growing perWatching it all come together onvasiveness of AI in the creative world. Every screen, you can feel the 16 years of labour detail in Wildwood feels painstakingly con- and love behind Wildwood. There is somesidered and, more importantly, alive: Hair thing deeply moving about seeing a film dances with the characters’ movements, and made with this much patience and intention. even the most minute facial expressions are And even more than that, perhaps, this film fashioned in. afforded me the most beautiful gift of all: Wildwood is LAIKA Studios’ most am- bringing me back to my childhood spent in bitious project to date, and its over-two-hour the magical forests of Oregon, just like Prue runtime makes it the longest stop-motion and her haply crew. film ever made. The scale of the production team’s undertaking is almost impossible to comprehend. LAIKA printed 142,000 individual 3D faces for its puppets, and every garment and set was handmade. The film took 16 years to move from initial development to release, with director Travis Knight describing the process as “filmmaking at the pace of a glacier.” Wildwood’s final battle scene featured more than 3,000 stop-motion Some of Wildwood’s figurines. (Chloe Bhogal / The Tribune)
If Mariah Carey’s music be the food of love, I’m not hungry anymore
The perfect non-holiday playlist for early November Dylan Hing Staff Writer
The peace of November won’t be back for another year.
ovember is the middle child of months, in which both Thanksgiving and Halloween are distant memories, and Santa has yet to “ho ho ho” himself out of a trespassing charge. Even in the United States—where Thanksgiving falls over a month later than in Canada— a lack of turkey-themed music means jolly holiday tunes can’t help but scream from store speakers as you shop. While listening to holiday music in early November may not be at the top of everyone’s bucket list, there is something beautiful to be found in the excited stumble towards December’s winter celebrations. Enjoy these song picks for the not-quiteholiday season, perfect for the month of purgatory.
“My Way” by Frank Sinatra As the semester winds down and New Year’s plans start taking shape, remember all the hard work you’ve put in throughout the year. “My Way” is the perfect listen for this month, when nothing is quite done but your cresting burnout is making you feel like everything should be. While your year may not have been as action-packed as Sinatra’s lyrics imply, there is no doubt you did your absolute best with what life threw at you. With all the trials and tribulations of academics—and life in general— Sinatra hopes you faced them your way.
N
“Four Strong Winds” by Neil Young This song, a cover of Ian Tyson’s 1963 original, is a calming choice with which to endure the coming winter season. In a breezy yet incredibly lonely ballad, Young’s narrator finds himself travelling across Canada to get away from the woman he loves but cannot have. Although feeling nearly ready to move on, he imagines reuniting with her in the future—despite knowing he will only be rejected once again. As excitement for the holidays approaches, Young’s track reminds listeners to never take for granted what they have:
“Autumn Serenade” by John Coltrane and Johnny Hartman This jazz piece, first performed by Hal McIntyre and later popularized by Coltrane and Hartman, perfectly reflects November’s transience through its reference to falling leaves and the passing of October. As with any good jazz song, the slow rhythm of “Autumn Serenade” calms the mind; its gentle, bouncing melody rejects the rush towards the holiday season. “Bags” by Clairo With a bit more pep in its step than these previous tracks, this song explores the choices that must be made when one is running out of time. Clairo, who previously described herself as bisexual, has recently
opened up about the freedom she has found in the fluidity of a queerness without strict labels. Her heart-wrenching song “Bags” emphasises the importance of avowing your identity with pride, as opposed to keeping it in and letting your true desires pass you by.
we must turn Mariah Carey all the way up; it simply suggests we need to diversify our playlists before we get drawn in by her whistle notes. November shouldn’t have to stay in the shadow of December. The month has an identity of its own, as the cool, calm period before the consumerist storm.
“Losing My Religion” by R.E.M. “Losing My Religion” is the most fitting song with which to conclude this playlist. Echoing Young’s “Four Strong Winds,” this track also follows a story of unrequited love. R.E.M. singer Michael Stipe’s struggle to surrender his high expectations for love may invoke memories of the failures we have accrued over a long year—made prominent in November as we inch closer to the season where we forget them all. Uniquely, the song’s title comes from a Southern saying meaning “to lose one’s temper.” While R.E.M. uses this phrase to represent the frustrations of being unable to move on, McGill students may equally be losing their cool over November’s depressing time change. Just because Thanksgiv- Mariah Carey’s All I Want for Christmas Is You has won three ing has passed doesn’t mean Guinness World Records. (Eliot Loose / The Tribune)
I
n 2020, we found ourselves banging pots and pans to recognize the efforts of healthcare workers and nurses during the COVID-19 pandemic. These professionals kept our overwhelmed healthcare system afloat, despite the physical, emotional, and psychological toll that their work took, and in return, received a moment of loud appreciation in an incredibly isolating time. While this was a heartwarming demonstration of unity and acknowledgment, it did not address the most important issues faced by nurses, who deserve action towards change—not just a token of appreciation. Nurses stand as the backbone of Canadian health infrastructure, and it is no surprise that their absence or the overextension of their efforts creates systemic consequences that bleed into the rest of society. In 2022, Red Lake Margaret Cochenour Memorial Hospital in rural northwest Ontario had to completely shut down its emergency department due to staffing issues; with a country-wide nursing shortage that is much worse in rural areas, there were no backup nurses available to help individuals suffering medical emergencies. Similarly, in 2021, Salaberry-de-Valleyfield’s Hôpital
du Suroît experienced an overnight closure after 6 of its 10 scheduled nurses called out of work due to exhaustion. As Quebec overworks and underpays its nurses, our province’s vital healthcare services bear the consequences. In turn, those in need of care are neglected at the fault of the system.
If we won’t ta nurses, take car
The chronic underfundi nurses in
Written by Avery Berry, Science & Gwendolyn Heffern
The nursing pay gap across Canada When it comes to supporting nurses financially, Quebec comes last in Canada. In November 2025, the Labour Force Survey conducted by the Government of Canada found that the base hourly wage for registered nurses in Quebec is the lowest in the country, at $27 CAD per hour—three dollars below the Canadian average. Furthermore, Quebec ranks the lowest in the country in terms of job prospects for registered nurses. Low retirement rates limit open nursing positions, and only a small number of unemployed, experienced nurses available to fill these already limited openings: both of which are contributing factors to the inability for new nurses to find work in Quebec. Statistics like this push Quebec nurses to seek work outside the province, where compensation is stronger and working conditions better address burnout and support a healthy work-life balance: further worsening these employment figures. In an interview with The Tribune, Noelle Leon-Palmer, president of McGill’s Nursing Graduate Student Association, shared her story as a second-year adult care nurse practitioner. “When you compare [Quebec] to other places, a lot of people ask me, ‘What are you doing here?’ Because instead of coming to Montreal, [nurses] leave. They go to other provinces or to the [United States] because you just make so much more money [there]. [Salaries matter,] especially because the cost of living [in Quebec] is going up so much,” Leon-Palmer said. This disparity goes beyond a simple pay gap: Quebec nurses also face a much longer climb to higher wages. The salary of registered nurses in Canada is determined by provincial collective agreements which are negotiated by nursing unions. Salaries advance according to a wage grid—an organized step progression of base wages determined by factors such as years of licensed experience, job classification, and clinical responsibilities. Across other Canadian provinces, the number of steps it takes for a nurse to reach the maximum income in this wage grid ranges from six to ten. However, in Quebec, nurses must climb 18 different pay echelons to reach the top of the wage scale. Not only are nurses paid insufficient wages, but they are burdened by a long path towards a truly fair salary.
The FIQ collective agreement After nearly two years of negotiations and a seven-day strike campaign at the end of 2023, the Fédération interprofessionnelle de la santé du Québec (FIQ) put in place an agreement covering licensed healthcare practitioners from Dec. 15, 2024 to March 31, 2028. This FIQ collective agreement—spanning over 39 articles, 15 appendices, and several letters of understanding—is a renewal of the federation’s previous agreement with nurses from 2021-2023. The renewed agreement shines light on areas of the nursing system that are continually strained. Aspects such as nurses’ pay, overtime compensation, amount of time on-call, and paid leave are discussed, along with changes to accommodate specific pressures following staff loss after the pandemic, inflation across Canada, and disagreements over how care should be organized. The FIQ agreement provides a salary increase for nurses totalling 17.4 per cent over five years, in the form of five pay raises starting in 2023. For many, a pay increase is not enough to make up for the systemic injustices of the nursing sector, and more work is necessary to make the nursing workforce more attractive. Leon-Palmer discussed the relative paltryness of the FIQ’s offer. “I was in Quebec, outside in the freezing cold picketing [....] Everyone got a 17.4 per cent increase, which I guess is good because they were trying to make up for inflation in a way [....] But it didn’t really close the gap,” Leon-Palmer said. “[We] still […] have the lowest median [nursing] salary out of all the provinces. It’s not like our cost of living is so low that it makes sense. So it was a bit disappointing.” To address issues with overtime and holiday understaffing in nursing, the FIQ agreement introduces a premium of 5 per cent on the regular hourly wage and 10 per cent more during overtime hours for working between June 15 and Sept. 15 and between Dec. 15 and Jan. 31. This recognizes the increased demand for nursing ser-
ake care of our who will re of us?
10, introduced in February 2023, which limits the use of private employment and independent contractors in the health and social service sectors. Since the passing of Bill 10, by 3,200 nurses have been moved from private to public employment, a transition that denies nurses autonomy in choosing their healthcare sector and determining flexible schedules for themselves. As a result, burnout has ramped up and contributed to the public nursing deficit we see today.
The comparison Nurses are undervalued across Canada, across the world even, though the discrepancies across provinces highlight Quebec as demonstrating this undervaluation at an all-time high. In an interview with The Tribune, third year Queen’s University Nursing student Caley Heard shared her positive academic experience, highlighting the importance of a smaller and more focused nursing faculty like Queen’s offers. “Your class sizes are really small, which I think contributes to […] really great learning,” Heard said. Nursing school “Because we’re such a small faculty, I feel like we’re The undervaluing of nurses does not just begin very close-knit, we know all of our professors [....] once they reach the Quebec workforce, but is prevThe dean of Nursing is always coming around and alent throughout their nursing education. Teachers talking to us, so in that aspect, it’s really great.” and students alike have expressed their discontent Queen’s small Nursing program size of about with a system that seemingly makes the already 120-140 students per year allows these students to understaffed sector overcome further barriers to receive the instructor attention they deserve, while accommodate the entire healthcare system’s failures. providing the resources to cope with the pressures of At McGill’s Ingram School of Nursing, budget nursing school. cuts have caused nursing school staff to take on “[Specifically] for [Queen’s Nursing students], we heavier workloads without added pay. Nursing class have a mental health coach. So anybody in Nurssizes have grown while teaching credits awarded for ing can book an appointment with her, and she’s these courses have not, leaving professors to take on amazing,” Heard said. “We [also] have a lot of guest more work to earn the same amount of credit. In speakers [who] come in talking about their experi2025, a McGill pharmacology course’s in-person and ences in their field, and then also their experience remote sections were merged, leaving one professor with burnout.” to withstand the workload of teaching roughly 300 Queen’s shows that nursing school does not have students. to be overcrowded, underfunded, and unjustifiably In an interview with The Tribune, second year stressful: It invests in its nurses early through small nursing student Tessa Ward echoed the impacts of cohorts, accessible faculty, and burnout support. the strain on McGill’s nursing staff. Caring for nurses is something we all have a “I know one of my [instructors is] a professor, a stake in because, sooner or later, we all need one. We course coordinator, and also the program director. therefore must treat nurses as what they are—the She’s doing all three roles,” Ward said. “Maybe there’s foundation of Canadian society. Paying nurses fairly, a problem that’s systemically within the organization, supporting them through school, and creating an but it definitely affects the students.” environment that encourages them to stay in the Alongside any administrative difficulties that profession once they get there are not just valuable occur within nursing school, Quebec nurses must implementations, but essential ones. take a licensing exam—the Ordre des infirmières et “I have a really strong belief that remuneration infirmiers du Québec (OIIQ) professional examina- is an excellent way to demonstrate appreciation for tion—after graduation to obtain a permit to practice the role,” Leon-Palmer said. “Ways that the [Quebec] as a registered nurse in the province. Across every government can show that they appreciate nurses is other province in Canada, nurses take and apply by paying them appropriately, or at least meeting the their results from the NCLEX in order to practice median [in] the rest of Canada.” as a registered nurse. In Quebec, the difference in At some point during your McGill career, when examinations makes leaving the province to practice you inevitably find yourself in the Montreal General especially difficult. Hospital emergency room—maybe for your room“It’s the same test [in] every [other] province. mate’s strep throat or after getting whacked in the Everybody takes [the NCLEX], so if you take it in face with a soccer ball in your far-too-competitive Ontario, it’s exactly the same status as if you took it intramural game—your annoyance about the fivein BC. It’s unified. Whereas the OIIQ exam is not. hour wait time should not be directed at nurses, but It’s only Quebec,” Ward said. “You take it, [meaning] instead at the insufficiency of the system meant to you can work as a nurse in Quebec, but you can’t just support these healthcare workers. Do not forget that move to Ontario then and try [to work there]. You while you have waited hours to be seen, the nurses [would] have to [also] take the NCLEX.” have been waiting years to be properly paid, staffed, Beyond the inconvenience that the different and, most importantly, valued.
ing and undervaluing of n Quebec
& Technology Editor & Designed nan, Design Editor
vices at these times of year. The agreement also agrees to pay nurses double their regular hourly wage for weekend overtime, a commitment that does little to prevent the shortages that actually demand this overtime. Frustration remains over staffing-ratio issues that are already recognized in other provinces such as British Columbia, where nurse assignments are set to match care needs. In 2019, and again in 2024, Quebec’s Tribunal administratif du travail ruled that FIQ members were not allowed to refuse overtime shifts as a form of protest. Nurses rejecting these shifts pointed out how these overtime stints stretch incredibly long with little notice beforehand, creating double shifts without arranged childcare for many working parents. The many unaddressed issues in the nursing system as a whole have created a cycle of impractical conditions: Though the FIQ agreement states that mandatory overtime should only be used in emergency and exceptional situations, a lack of permanent, full-time nurses in Quebec makes forced overtime more common—producing burnout and increased nursing walkouts. Nurses leaving the occupation The grievances expressed by nurses are more than just passive complaints. They are legitimate injustices that have led to a decrease in nurses in the Quebec workforce. 2024 saw the extent of this loss, with almost 2,000 nurses in the province under the age of 35 leaving the occupation. During this year, for every 100 nurses entering the workforce, 37 did not renew their license. “There’s been four health reforms [in Quebec] in the past 10 years. If that doesn’t tell you about the health of the [province’s] health[care] system, then I don’t know what does,” Leon-Palmer said. “It’s not a coincidence that people are leaving not only Quebec but also the profession [at large].” Quebec’s nursing shortage has grown nearly five times over the last decade, from being 1,677 nurses short in 2015 to 8,273 nurses short in 2024. A possible explanation for this change comes from Quebec’s Bill
exam system poses for Quebec-educated nurses hoping to practice in other provinces, the OIIQ has also received controversy for its high failure rates and difficulty. For nurses who have already completed years of rigorous training, a licensing exam with such high failure rates gives them one more reason to walk away from the healthcare system.
10
ARTS & ENTERTAINMENT
arts@thetribune.ca
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17 2026
Weaving between pipelines of power
Norouzi engulfs viewers in the soundscape of Iranian oil production Ellen Lurie Managing Editor
E
ntering the Anahita Norouzi. Rift exhibition, sound instantly swallows you. A documentary blares from next door, pipes spill whistling air through the exhibition’s main pavilion, and the murmur of a faraway drill creeps into your ear from a passageway out of sight. In Rift, Anahita Norouzi, a Tehranian artist currently working in Montreal, uses multimedia to communicate the impact of colonialist oil extraction on Iranian land. The exhibition is a six-part project, with its first two chapters unfolding at the Musée d’art de Joliette, and its final four chapters currently on display at the Gallery de l’Université du Québec à Montréal (UQÀM). Building off of the white, bare interior of Gallery de l’UQÀM, Norouzi employs sculpture, photography, and film to question colonial notions of progress and explore historical oil exploitation in Iran. In 1901, British entrepreneur William Knox D’Arcy pressured Iranian Shah Moẓaffar od-Dīn Shāh into signing a concession that forced Iran into a 60-year oil and gas contract. The inequitable arrangement gave Britain exclusive rights to develop Iranian petroleum, natural gas, asphalt, and ozokerite. In exchange, Iran received only £20,000 in cash, £20,000 worth of shares in D’Arcy’s oil venture, and a guaranteed 16 per cent of Britain’s annual prof-
its in Iran. Seven years later, Britain struck commercial oil in Masjed Soleymān. British profits peaked at £170 million in 1950, and Iran received less in royalties from the British than it was forced to pay Britain in taxes. In 1951, the Iranian parliament unanimously voted to nationalize the oil industry, placing the resource under state ownership. In response, Britain, with the support of the United States Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), overthrew the Iranian government and restructured Iranian oil under an international consortium of British, American, and other Western oil majors. It was not until the 1979 Iranian Revolution that the country was able to permanently expel all foreign powers and companies, finally gaining control of its own oil. Through Rift, Norouzi brings viewers to present-day Iran, its scenery interrupted by twisting, winding pipelines. Entering the exhibition space, you encounter a maze of rusty ventilation ducts: a physical reproduction of the crude oil pipelines of the country’s Abadan Refinery—the first in the region to process oil in commercial quantities. The ducts weave between small clusters of dried reeds, a representation of the invasive species that Iran uses innovatively as a filtration system to protect water from oil waste. Air spills through holes on the ducts’ sides, rustling the reeds as viewers
traverse down the winding pipeline. The ing sparks. The theatre’s seating alternates installation illuminates how oil extraction between soft, plush ottomans and pale, texinvades the Iranian natural environment, tured limestone—one of the most important making the resource a historic and ongoing reservoirs of petroleum and natural gas. geopolitical tool as well as a source of doRift’s final chapter is an array of mestic environmental concern. blown-glass vessels full of electric blue The second space, a small alcove that fluid, hanging from the space’s ceiling by protrudes from the main gallery pavilion, industrial chains, with liquid dripping onto is dominated by a red-brown pipe, vibrat- a concrete slab below. Norouzi connects ing and humming in the centre of the room. this scene to petromodernity, critiquing The walls are decorated with postcard pho- how industries pursue oil extraction withtographs of Iranian oil refineries and the out regard for its environmental impacts. sleeping quarters of those who work in By the exhibition’s end, you have tuned them—photos which visitors are encour- out the distant murmur of the pipeline. It aged to take. The pipe, installed to emulate has become part of the gallery’s ambient an obelisk, is decrepit and corroded. Iranian noise, as embedded in Rift as oil extraction oil, once a prosperous industry, has eroded is in Iran’s landscape. into a shell, hollowed out through past and current international sanctions. The third stop in the exhibition is a projection space that displays a video art piece by Norouzi across three of the room’s walls. The 40-minute film weaves natural and industrial imagery into an immersive sensory experience. Wild orchids splash the walls with colour, their speckled petals drowning in thick, undulating waves of oil. Flames lick rocky Gallery de l’UQAM exhibitions are free to the public. (Ellen Lurie / The expanses with flicker- Tribune)
Players’ Theatre’s production of ‘Cagebirds’ exposes prevailing sexist stereotypes Actors’ deft embodiments of characters lay eggs for new revolutionary thought
Norah Adams Arts & Entertainment Editor
staged a performance of Canadian David Campton’s 1971 play Cagebirds. The oneact play is a figuration of Plato’s allegory ix women sit in a semicircle at the of the cave, a thought experiment from the edge of the stage, each with a feath- philosopher’s Republic, Book VII. er affixed to their hair or clothing. In place of ancient Greek men, CageThey cluck to themselves in varying vol- birds models Plato’s prisoners as harmful umes: One preens a fly away, while anoth- stereotypes of women. Its characters range er squawks about aches and pains. Watch- from an ever-gossiping “busy-body” to an ing more closely, the crowd observes an image-obsessed “diva.” The six birds know upright woman in a vibrant outfit chirp- nothing but the cage that holds them; they ing gossip to herself and, across the room, sit in their chairs ignoring each other, unone worryingly pecking at her face with aware of what lies beyond the locked door. her fingers. What the audience cannot Casting for the Players’ Theatre’s see, however, are the invisible chains that rendition was done with masterful care; brace the women’s arms and legs to the each actor embodied the full plumage of chairs beneath them. These shackles are their part through a harmonious blend of not made of iron links, but instead the un- physicality and line delivery. Anne-Fredemerciful latticework of the patriarchy. rique Bellerose, U0 Engineering, played This past week, Players’ Theatre Twitting as buzzingly fidgety and highstrung—a perfect stark contrast to Guzzle, who Tree Payne, U0 Education, portrayed as languid and decadent. The show’s lead, Juliana Arminio, U1 Science, lived up to her star role, with her performance as Wild nothing short of illustrious. Arminio’s frenzied appeals to her fellow caged birds echoed loudly and earThe cast and crew had only one month to prepare for the play. (Harriet nestly against the walls Faught) of the intimate theatre
S
space, sucking viewers into the world of her desperation. Cagebirds’ immersive quality didn’t stop at acting; costuming for the show completed each character’s persona. Gazer (Molly Miller, U1 Arts)’s blue satin slip dress zipped her vanity into place, as Gloom (Audrey Bieling, U4 Arts)’s hanging shawl weighed heavily on her already weary body. Even before production began, director Talia Ross Wittenberg, U0 Arts, started staging her show. In an interview with The Tribune, Wittenberg described how Players’ Theatre’s space was the catalyst for choosing Campton’s play. “I did a lot of one-act plays in high school, and [Cagebirds] was always a show that I had in my book, […] but I never ended up putting it on,” she recalled. “I felt that Players’ would be the perfect place to do it [because] it [takes place in] a black box.” Beyond drawing inspiration from Players’ physical space, Wittenberg described how current political climates can motivate the staging of stories like Cagebirds. “People are very happy nowadays to close their eyes to things and not pay attention to what’s going on around them, […] and I feel like it is really important to try and open your eyes and see how things that may seem not very important are present in your day-to-day life,” she explained. The play’s story uncovers how com-
fort can be a prison, as the group of women refuses to break free from the roles assigned to them by an oppressive patriarchal system. Wild spends the 40-minute runtime begging her fellow birds to band together for freedom, yet they decline, afraid of having to face their identities in the world outside their confinement. Midway through the show, the flock acknowledged their previously intentional ignoring of Wild. Her response revealed the true key to revolution. “A breakthrough, we’re communicating!” Wild exclaimed. Despite Campton’s play turning 55 this year, its themes sadly remain relevant. Gendered stereotyping easily sneaks through the cracks of contemporary feminist movements, with media often mocking or reducing the experiences of women to caricatures. These representations justify histories of mistreatment and ongoing inequalities created by gendered systems of power. “Stereotyping like this really affects people every single day, […] and I feel like it is really important to be able to see that and to not close yourself off to politics,” Wittenberg emphasized. Wittenberg’s vision of Cagebirds is a powerful testament to the continuation of harmful gender stereotypes into the twenty-first century. It is a reminder to women that we must open our eyes and see the cage in front of us if we ever hope to fly out of this misogynistic nest.
studentlife@thetribune.ca
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17 2026
OFF THE BOARD
11
Anachronistic by design
Eliot Loose Design Editor
O
STUDENT LIFE
n Oct. 27, Italian luxury powerhouse Prada announced its holiday campaign, “Drawing Prada: Animated by Hand.” The campaign is advertised in a manner that exhibits the ethos of most luxury brands: an emphasis on craftsmanship in its products and, in this case, its marketing. In a behind-thescenes video, Prada states that it created the campaign’s marketing video through the “anachronistic” craft of hand-drawn animation. Such a statement rebukes the oversaturation of artificial intelligence (AI) in contemporary art. By employing animator John Pomeroy to create the advertise-
ment, Prada boastfully asserts its unwillingness to take shortcuts. As AI becomes increasingly entrenched in the creation of brand identities, the shaping of workplace cultures, and the fuelling of existentialist fears about the future of society, its daunting relationship to art has begun to come full circle. Elucidating the absence of AI in an artistic project has clearly become a source of tangible commercial benefits. With the flaunted clarification that a piece of art was, in fact, created by a human, the “Drawing Prada” campaign emphasizes that the appreciation of art is rooted in its connection to real people’s ideas, their creativity, and perhaps most importantly, their labour. AI’s ability to replicate artistic styles and practices will forever haunt digitized media—there is no denying that. However, a compelling marketing or artistic campaign derived from a rebellious attitude towards AI has its benefits. The appeal of art lies in its ability to be honest with the viewer, acting as a gateway to its artist’s personality or interests. Even if a piece of artwork is uninspiring or unadorned, creation emerges from a person’s effort. That alone, to a certain degree, is enough grounds for the art to be displayed, acknowledged, and
discussed. If AI art were to be considered with this same regard, it would need to replicate this same human intent—an intent that remains, by its digital nature, unattainable. Unfortunately, this has not stopped AI art from attempting a human facade nonetheless. There is a degree of wonder that is shattered when a piece of art someone enjoys is unveiled as a product of AI. A notable example of this is the influx of AI-generated music across Spotify, Apple Music, and other streaming platforms. Controversy surrounding nonhuman-made music has transpired when platforms have not provided disclosure statements that certain songs were created by AI. The concern, in this instance, is an AI song assimilating itself into an expansive digital library of human-created media. Songs often gain traction for their catchiness, and considering that AI models are trained by popular, already existing digitized media, it is no surprise that AI music can be widely revered by those unaware of its origins. But when the guise of humanness comes crashing down, and the listener becomes aware that a piece of art they enjoyed was actually computer-generated, the previously held reverence for that media comes
crashing down as well. As AI’s reach continues to expand— playing an ever-growing role in creative endeavours—so does the uncertainty around our distinctions between human and AI creativity. The Prada campaign is a direct acknowledgement of this phenomenon and a public-facing capitalization off of it. Prada’s campaign reflects an increasing effort among companies, big and small, to employ and celebrate human artists—a movement which may challenge the growing pressure to automate even the most minuscule details of creative projects. In today’s competitive environment of ad production and brand design, an acknowledgement of the human touch is now an advantage. For commercial artists, Prada’s campaign is a productive stepping stone toward the proper recognition of human creativity. It upends the belief that AI can comparably and completely infiltrate the creative processes of art; it is equally a sign that AI will never be a systemic barrier to human artistic expression. No matter how “anachronistic” the process might be, value will always exist in the authentic human effort poured into creating art—even if the final product is a commercial for a luxury bag.
McGill’s competitive exchange application process
Applicants report being kept in the dark about their chances of studying abroad Sophie Wedge Staff Writer
H
undreds of McGill students apply for international exchange programs every year, but only a few get admitted to the institutions they ranked. When applying to a McGill exchange program, many students report not being provided with adequate information about placement availability at host universities. Students feel exchange placement is effectively a blind process, in which they are given no sense of their chances of being admitted to their first-choice school, leaving many to scramble for a place at an institution abroad that they did not originally wish to attend. Lucas Cho, U2 Arts, explained that he found the application process to be extremely stressful. In a written statement to The Tribune, Cho shared that when he met with an exchange advisor, he was told that his preferred destinations were competitive and that his grade point average (GPA) was “likely sufficient” for admission to one of his top two choices. “I am still unsure how spots are selected. I feel that information about competitiveness is not adequately shared,” Cho wrote. “It can be demoralizing to be denied a first or second choice [exchange placement] without knowing how limited the [number] of available spots is.” McGill Abroad, the university’s exchange office, declined an interview request from The Tribune. In a written statement to The Tribune,
McGill’s Media Relations Office (MRO) emphasized that when demand for a particular university exceeds the available exchange spaces there, the placements are allocated by lottery, which contrasts with information from Cho’s exchange advisor. “A higher GPA, being on the Dean’s Honour List, or applying earlier does not provide an advantage or guarantee a placement at a preferred university,” the MRO wrote. The exchange program application asks students to rank their top four host university choices. If they do not receive placements at any of these institutions, they may apply to universities whose exchange spots were not filled in the first round. The MRO affirmed that the supply and demand of exchange opportunities are often unpredictable. “Available spaces and student demand can change significantly from year to year, meaning past application data may not reliably predict future placement chances,” the MRO wrote. “[McGill is] incorporating student feedback to improve the information we share about exchange availability.” In a written statement to The Tribune, Spencer Barth, U1 Arts, expressed that she understands the competitiveness of the admissions process, but the uncertainty of potentially spending a semester at an undesired location would dissuade many students from applying for exchange in the first place. “Everyone wants their choices; obviously [the exchange office] tries to accommodate, but the point is not to spend a semester at a school you were previously uninterested in,” Barth wrote.
Barth continued to highlight the discrep- many spots they granted; it would clear up a ancy between McGill’s pride in its exchange lot of confusion,” Barth wrote. “If students program and the reality of applying for ex- understand the logistics and the number of change. students receiving their top choices, [the “It was a shock to realize how difficult placement outcomes] would be more underit is to get an exchange [placement]. When I standable.” toured [the school], it was a program that McThe high financial cost of going on exGill boasted about,” Barth wrote. “In my sec- change makes studying abroad quite socioond year, I am beginning to realize that it is economically inaccessible to many memsomething that I may not be able to do in my bers of the university. Greater transparency four years at McGill, which is disappointing.” around McGill’s exchange application proBarth also underscored that as her de- cess—which already costs a non-refundable sired exchange destination is known to be $167.19 CAD to participate in—is important competitive, she may not even apply to it. in ensuring that the exchange process be“I am hesitant when planning out my comes more equitable for all students. future and predicting that I will get an exchange [spot]. Spain [will] be popular, so I might as well not put it, even though I would be interested,” she wrote. Barth noted that the exchange application’s required information session should provide students with more concrete admissions statistics. “[They should tell us] how many applicants the exchange office got McGill provides students with exchange opportunities at 150 universities in last year and how more than 40 countries. (Chloe Bhogal / The Tribune)
12
STUDENT LIFE
studentlife@thetribune.ca
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17 2026
Students discuss removal of Mount Royal Cross and Quebec’s politics of religion
Cross under renovation, returning to the the hill in 2027 Aélia Gyger Contributor
A
t night, it’s impossible not to see it: At the top of the hill that gave Montreal its name, the Mount Royal Cross stands over 30 metres tall and illuminates the city with 240 light bulbs. Paul de Chomedey, Sieur de Maisonneuve first erected a cross overlooking the city in 1643 after Ville-Marie was spared from a flood. The current cross was mounted in 1924. However, the cross was removed late last month, leaving its familiar guiding light absent from the horizon. The City of Montreal attributed necessary renovations as the reason for the temporary removal of the cross. The structure of the cross will be strengthened, while the exterior will receive a fresh coat of paint and new LED lights that might reduce the light pollution it creates around the mountain’s summit. The renovations are expected to cost around $3.7 million CAD, and are intended to be finished by late 2027. Not only is the cross an iconic part of the Montreal skyline—recognized by residents and tourists alike—many McGill students also point to the cross as a significant part of their experience in Montreal. In an interview with The Tribune, Jasmine Grewal, U3 Science, noted the beauty of the structure.
“Just walking around, it’s nice to always see the cross, especially at night when it’s lit up. It’s really pretty, and you see it from so many different locations, so I think it’s pretty important,” Grewal said. Beyond its status as a visually pleasing monument, the cross serves as a “North Star” for Julia Jo, U0 Arts, as it leads her home from wherever she finds herself in Montreal. “We look up, and it’s how we get home,” Jo said in an interview with The Tribune. “It’s right near the Upper Residences, and we just follow it. It’s something that’s always there.” In addition to having sentimental significance, the cross remains above all a religious symbol, according to Simon MacLaren, U1 Arts, who has been living in Montreal for the majority of his life. “It’s like a symbol of the […] religious heritage of the city,” MacLaren said in an interview with The Tribune. “A ton of the [buildings in Montreal] have an obvious Christian denotation. To have a massive cross above our city represents to me Montreal’s clear religious past.” MacLaren also questioned the presence of the cross when juxtaposing it with the implementation of Bill 21, entitled “An Act respecting the laicity of the State.” Bill 21 has been in effect in Quebec since 2019, prohibiting public-sector employees from wearing
visible religious symbols—such as crosses, McLaren emphasized the importance of hijabs, kippahs, and turbans—while working. religious tolerance and open-mindedness, esMany have criticized the act for its connection pecially when discussing Quebec’s future. to an increase in xenophobic and discrimina“[Quebec’s] laws are the problem,” tory rhetoric and violence across the province. McLaren said. “It’s an opposing kind of dou“There’s an obvious selectiveness with ble standard. We have to accept that we’re a these laws,” MacLaren said. “The government society that has a Christian past, a religious decides which religions are really cracked past, and that many people [who aren’t Chrisdown on. Muslim women aren’t allowed to tian] who still live here want to display their wear hijabs to work, whereas an overt symbol religion [too].” of Christian faith would be just a cross, which you can just tuck under your shirt and it’s fine.” Grewal echoed MacLaren’s sentiment, pointing to the Mount Royal Cross holding a tenuous place within the broader landscape of Quebec’s politics of religion. “For me, the cross is more of a cultural statement rather than a religious one,” Grewal said. “But I do agree that there’s a contradiction with it, the fact that it is inherently religious, and that people aren’t allowed to wear religious things [in The Mount Royal Cross weighs approximately 26 tonnes. (Evy public].” Shamber / The Tribune)
A guide to beating the November gloom Finding joy between midterms and finals Elisabeth Lum Staff Writer
T
he height of fall foliage and festivities is now behind us. Now, the sun sets earlier, the temperatures hover just above freezing, and campus life firmly revolves around assignments, school work, and the approaching stress of finals season. Yet, beyond late-night study sessions and crowded libraries, Montreal continues to offer plenty of ways to make the most of the month. As the semester winds down, The Tribune has compiled a guide to beating the November gloom. Global sounds Starting on Nov. 17, Mundial Montréal is bringing their annual November boutique event back to the city for its 16th edition. Aiming to unite diverse cultures through music, the festival showcases emerging artists from all over the world in an inclusive and welcoming environment. Tickets are available for sale until Nov. 21 on the Mundial website, starting at $30 CAD for student attendees. Kicking off the holiday festivities Swing by rue Jeanne-Mance to soak up the holiday spirit at Montreal’s Great Christmas Market. From Nov. 13 to Jan. 3, Place des Festivals is home to a festive winter village, hosting almost 60 artisan vendors and food stations serving seasonal treats. Beyond shopping and snacking, visitors can enjoy a lineup of free live entertainment, including Christmas carols and daily
performances of the market’s signature show, Noël à Montréal. Celebrating queer stories Image+Nation, an annual film festival dedicated to representing the diverse stories and lived experiences of the 2SLGBTQIA+ community, returns to Montreal from Nov. 19 to Nov. 29. With an extensive lineup of thought-provoking films and powerful storytelling, Image+Nation offers audiences an opportunity to discover new perspectives, celebrate queer voices, and learn about queer stories that are consistently underrepresented in the media.
Keeping campus spirit alive As always, there is no shortage of events happening at Gerts Bar. Beyond the typical Monday Trivia and Taco Tuesdays, stop by on Nov. 18 for live music or catch Comedy Night on Nov. 25. These casual events are great for a midweek break or a taste of something new that keeps you within walking distance of the library.
While the November gloom may be inevitable, it is no reason to let the changing seasons put a pause on getting out of the house, taking a break, and exploring the city. Whether it be discovering a new food spot, winding down by catching a film, or spending an evening at a holiday market, there is still plenty to taste, see, and experience around Montreal as winter approaches.
The games begin again For all the sci-fi and dystopian fans out there, the beloved Hunger Games franchise is making its highly anticipated return to the big screen with Sunrise on the Reaping, with the first Montreal screening on Nov. 18. Set during the 50th Hunger Games, the film follows Haymitch Abernathy as he competes in the Second Quarter Quell. The movie will play at Cineplex theatres across the city, including Cinema Banque Scotia Montréal, which is located just a seven-minute walk from cam- As November rolls around, Montreal gets just over 10 hours of daylight, with the sun setting at 4:41 p.m. on Nov. 1. (Evy Shamber / The Tribune) pus.
scitech@thetribune.ca
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17 2026
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
13
Extractivism and the gender divide
Gold mining impacts women and men differently in Ghana’s Asufiti North District Miranda Forster Staff Writer
E
xtractivism, a term first coined as extractivismo by South American environmental and Indigenous activists in the 1990s, refers to the processes, ideology, and implications of natural resource extraction. Despite its role as a significant driver of economic growth in the Global South, extractivism remains a site of ecological and human exploitation—where power most often rests with foreign high-income countries, multinational corporations, and elites rather than the local communities in which such extraction takes place. Extractivism contributes to social inequities, including unfair wealth distribution and the displacement of Indigenous and local populations, and impacts the Earth system by augmenting habitat destruction, pollution, and climate change. A recent article by McGill School of Social Work doctoral candidate Ata Senior Yeboah and associate professor Charles Gyan has demonstrated that the varying detrimental impacts of extractivism—which is known to replicate existing systems of racism, classism, and colonialism—are unevenly experienced at the level of gender. In their article, Yeboah and Gyan document how men and women experience extractivism differently. Yeboah and Gyan’s research took place in five communities across Ghana’s Asutifi North district: Wamahiniso, Gyedu, Ntotro-
so, Kenyasi No. 1, and Kenyasi No. 2. Asufiti North is a region heavily impacted by the American Newmont Corporation’s gold mining operations, and serves as the company’s African headquarters. Yeboah has researched the impacts of extractivism in Ghana throughout his academic career, and decided to bring gender into his analysis of mining harms after observing that women and men have different experiences with extractivism. “This article sought to investigate socially assigned roles, responsibilities, norms, and gendered expectations, [and how] they influence a specific gender’s vulnerability to the negative impacts of extraction,” Yeboah said in an interview with The Tribune. Indeed, Yeboah and Gyan’s research reveals a clear difference in the impact of extractivism across gender in the communities he studied. Men are primarily exposed to extractivism through mining work, which puts them at risk of injury and exposure to harmful chemicals. Meanwhile, women are primarily impacted in the home. For example, when mining raises the local cost of living, women—according to gender roles observed in these communities—are responsible for household provisioning on a tighter budget. “The most interesting [result of the research] is the fact that both men and women are exposed to the detrimental social and economic […] impacts of extraction, but women are more disadvantaged because of
their household provision or social repro- the results of his research as applicable duction roles. So for example, I would say across the Global South. men’s vulnerabilities are short-term, imme“[Global South countries] exhibit simidiate, and visible […] but for women, their lar social, economic, political, and cultural vulnerabilities are long-term, invisible, and characteristics. So for Ghana, [this research cumulative,” Yeboah said. is] widely applicable in almost all mining Yeboah hopes to present his work communities with similar characteristics, documenting the hidden vulnerabilities that […] and broadly in sub-Saharan Africa, extractivism forces Ghanaian women to en- these dynamics are almost the same,” Yedure to the communities he studied them- boah said. “And to a larger extent, [it apselves. plies to] some other countries in Asia and “I plan to go back to the [communities] Latin America, where extractive developwhere I did the research to officially thank ment projects take place.” them for participating […], and then do a Resource extraction in the Global knowledge mobilization or a knowledge South supports resource overconsumption dissemination exercise, and then translate in the Global North. As long as this uneven the main findings […] into very accessible flow of resources persists, citizens of the formats for the people to understand,” Ye- Global North will remain implicated in the boah said. harms wrought by extractivism. Yeboah and Alongside local residents of Asutifi Gyan’s research is a crucial step towards alNorth, Yeboah explained that traditional leviating those harms. authorities, local government officials, Newmont, and Ghana’s Environmental Protection Authority and Minerals Commission will be invited to attend this planned knowledge mobilization. “These are institutions that play significant roles in managing the impacts of mining, ensuring that extractive development benefits the communities who host these projects. So I plan to invite them […] to help them refine or revise current policies,” Yeboah explained. Ghana produced approximately 170 tonnes of gold in Beyond Ghana, Yeboah sees 2025. (Zoe Lee / The Tribune)
14
SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY
scitech@thetribune.ca
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17 2026
Rethinking plastic: A Filipino-Canadian collective movement
How collaborative action from youth innovators can help address plastic pollution Avery Berry Science & Technology Editor
T
he event “From Manila to Montréal: Combatting plastics for disaster risk reduction” (DRR) was held on Nov. 7 in Montreal and online. Supported by an Ocean Action Grant from Ocean Wise Canada, the conference connected participants in the Philippines and in Montreal, and was hosted at Maison du développement durable. The session opened with online presentations on youth-led plastic reduction initiatives in the Philippines, followed by a panel discussion in which speakers shared their insights towards plastic pollution. Its hybrid approach allowed youth innovators in the Philippines and Montreal to show how local action can help address global environmental challenges in spite of a 13-hour time difference between both places. An archipelago of more than 7,100 islands, the Philippines is the third-highest national contributor to ocean plastic pollution worldwide. A large part of the country’s persistent plastic problem is the “sachet economy,” a distinct consumer culture wherein small, affordable portions of goods are sold in singleuse packets; studies estimate that Filipinos use about 164 million sachets daily overall. Weak waste-processing infrastructure compounds the Philippines’ plastic problem. The country’s Commission on Audit determined in 2021 that only approximately 39 per cent of barangays—local governments—actually had access to a sanitary landfill. These limited capacities have made illegal dumpsites unavoidable in some areas of the country. The consequences of plastic pollution extend beyond littering. Plastic leakage into the ocean rises two to three times during the country’s rainy season, and this waste can clog drains in flood-prone communities, thus compounding flood risk. Event organizer Val Muñoz spent the summer of 2026 as an intern with the Centre for Disaster Preparedness Foundation Incorporated (CDPFI) in the Philippines, where she experienced the organization’s youth-led projects firsthand. Muñoz’s experience helped to inspire the “From Manila to Montréal” event, bringing the important work of Filipino youth to an international audience. The CDPFI presented its two-year DRRYIELDS project, managed by Elna KaluangAlih, during the session. This project focuses on empowering young people in Camarines Norte and Northern Samar to identify environmental challenges in their communities and develop practical solutions to resolve these issues. Through the initiative, participants developed 22 youth-led innovations, including a school water filter made from crushed clamshells and coconut fibre. “Young people are not only beneficiaries of development. They can also be leaders, decision makers, and innovators,” Kaluang-Alih said during the event. Christian Morecho of the Supreme Secondary Learners Government of the Bobon School for Philippine Craftsmen next presented Catch Up, Clean Up: an initiative which pairs mental health support with campus clean-ups, and turns plastic water bottles into sellable bags. “Our innovation is not simply about cleaning the environment or creating recycled prod-
ucts,” Morecho said. “Just as discarded materials can be given a new purpose, […] meaningful change begins when we provide people with a safe space to grow and give resources, whether human or environmental, another opportunity to flourish.” Next, Manny Lauce, of the Youth for Environment in Schools Organization at Tabas National High School, showcased a machine that crushes bottles and wrappers to create ecobricks. Before this machine, Lauce’s classmates would collect trash and stuff it into plastic bottles as a way to keep waste in one place. However, the narrow openings of the bottles made this system difficult and painful. Lauce’s machine made the process efficient and led to a waste policy being introduced in Tabas’ school handbook. “Through this initiative, we can help reduce plastic bottles scattered on our barangay by collecting them and processing them in our machine,” Lauce said. “Our [innovation] is not just a project for school. It’s also a solution that can [be adapted] and sustain[ed] by our community. Our goal is not only to create a machine, but to create a lasting impact.” The organizers shared how these projects, built around high school students who are continuously growing and graduating, have managed to sustain themselves. “The innovations started [with] about four to five members, and then later on they recruited friends, [and] some of their classmates and schoolmates to join them,” Kaluang-Alih said. “So when some of the students transferred or graduated, there are members that keep up the leadership and maintain the group of individuals and the project itself.” After the online presentations from students in the Philippines, the conversation moved to Montreal, where a panel of local and Filipino diaspora voices offered their own ex-
periences and efforts to challenge the larger forces behind plastic waste, speaking to the role of diaspora communities, individual initiative, and greater environmental advocacy. Panelist Shirley Cavanagh, who founded the Genie in a Bottle Project in 2019 as a shortterm fundraiser, demonstrated how community action can translate into tangible benefits. The project has fundraised over $100,000 CAD for educational and charitable organizations by recycling cans, bottles, and bread tags; nearly 5,000 families in Greater Montreal now take part in the initiative, and the project has funded two wheelchairs for the community. Cavanagh’s project illustrates recycling’s ability to create value beyond waste reduction, providing groups with an opportunity to support people who might otherwise face barriers to accessing essential resources. “Our whole project is based on volunteers. We have 20 volunteers that work with us every week, some from two hours to five hours a week. My youngest volunteer is a five-year-old boy [with autism], and my oldest volunteer is 86,” Cavanagh said. Next, Renz Luyao, a climate activist with the National Youth Commission of World Wildlife Fund Philippines and award-winning multimedia storyteller, urged young people to turn their skills into advocacy. Luyao spoke about using social media to influence government policy. According to Luyao, starting off small and documenting what is happening in your own community produces leverage that inspires broader political action in favour of younger generations. “Turn your local issues into global [tasks]. There are opportunities and platforms out there, and us youth belong in these policy rooms. Our voices matter,” Luyao said. The discussion then turned to highlight the systems that shape everyday consumption.
Christopher Cruz Sorio, a retired plastics technician, lay minister, York University Geography master’s candidate, and secretary general of Migrante Canada, honoured Filipino habits like simot, meaning to use something completely, and tingi, meaning to buy in small sachets, while warning against placing blame on consumers. “We should not simply blame consumers for choosing products they [can] afford. We must also examine the decisions made by [the] companies that design, produce, and market these products,” Sorio said. “If companies invest in understanding consumers and designing packages that appeal to them, should they also not take responsibility [for the packaging’s] environmental consequences?” He also pointed to an important connection between Canadian and Filipino waste production. In 2013 and 2014, a Canadian company sent shipping containers of contaminated waste—declared as recyclable plastic—to the Philippines. These containers were not all returned to Canada until 2019. “Exporting waste does not stop the problem [of pollution] or make it disappear. It transfers the burden to another country, oftentimes [to countries] like the Philippines, [with] fewer resources, [and] less capacity to manage contaminated materials,” Sorio said. Together, the discussions throughout the event highlighted that reducing the use of plastic requires more than just individual action. Connecting local initiatives with broader conversations about sustainability and accountability is necessary to constructively address the system-wide mechanisms upholding waste production and pollution. Meaningful change takes collaboration, accessible resources, accountable companies and governments, and the opportunity for communities to shape solutions to the problems affecting them.
In Filipino slang, calling someone plastik (plastic) means they are two-faced or insincere. (Gwen Heffernan / The Tribune)
sports@thetribune.ca
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17 2026
SPORTS
15
McGill Lacrosse overcomes Bishop’s to advance to CUFLA semifinals
Redbirds secure third consecutive CUFLA East Division title in playoff win Ivanna Zhang Sports Editor
M
cGill Men’s Lacrosse advanced in the playoffs with a 14-8 victory over the Bishop’s University Gaiters in a sudden-death matchup on Nov. 8 at Percival Molson Stadium. The win secured the Redbirds a semifinal spot in the Canadian University Field Lacrosse Association (CUFLA) Baggataway Cup National Championship. The win ended McGill’s regular season with a 9–1 record, earning them the CUFLA East Division title for the third consecutive year. It also extended their 17-game winning streak against the Gaiters, the last win being the Legacy Game on Sept. 30. Redbirds attacker Liam Miletich and offensive midfielder Tyler Miocevich both scored just five minutes into the match, creating an early 2-0 lead for McGill. However, goals from Gabe Young, Ethen Hopkins, and Emmett Legault put the Gaiters in front halfway into the first quarter—giving Bishop’s their first and only lead of the game. In an interview with The Tribune, Redbirds co-captain and midfielder John Miraglia, U4 Arts, explained the team’s mentality when they were down by one goal at this point. “We’ve faced that score before. I don’t think anybody ever had any doubts that we were gonna win this game,” Miraglia said.
“We just wanted to win it in the best way possible.” Just 44 seconds later, attacker Zack Pagé tied the game for McGill. The team then buried three more goals—two from Miocevich and one from offensive midfielder Massimo Thauvette—to end the first quarter with a 6-3 lead. Midfielder Dylan Fenton, U1 Management, stressed the importance of momentum in lacrosse in an interview with The Tribune. “[Lacrosse] is like a roller coaster going up the ramp, and then once you get to the top, all hell breaks loose, and you just ride that momentum, do a little flip, turn, and win the game,” Fenton said. “Once you have the momentum, it’s easy to get two or three more [goals], and it’s just all about maintaining that. Not getting too high, not getting too low, just keep making the easy plays, [and] keep putting the ball in the back of the net,” Miraglia added. The Redbirds certainly rode the high on Nov. 8. Five consecutive goals from Pagé, Miocevich, Miletich, offensive midfielder Cameron Prior, and midfielder Torsten Blodgett secured the team an 11-3 lead within the first ten minutes of the second quarter. In an interview with The Tribune, firstyear Redbirds Head Coach Andrew Meakes pointed to the possible risks that can come with such a large lead. “You know how they say a two-goal
lead in hockey is the most dangerous thing. ly happy to finish out with a win over BishIn lacrosse it’s the same thing when you op’s, who in my career I’ve never lost to.” get some unanswered goals,” Meakes exDespite a goal from Bishop’s Legault plained. “You might start not doing the early in the fourth quarter, Miletich sealed little things and following the technicals as the win for McGill with two consecutive much as you typically would.” goals at the 3:47 and 12:55 minute marks. As the game progressed towards the “With [a] new head coach, some new end of the second quarter and the start of systems, and new ways of doing things, it’s the third, Bishop’s scored four consecu- a challenge, and these guys have just risen tive goals, cutting the Gaiters’ deficit from to it,” Meakes said. eight to four. The Redbirds’ season ultimately ended “We started pushing the ball a little too on Nov. 13 after suffering an 8-11 loss to hard on transition and going to [the] net a the University of Guelph Gryphons in the little too quickly,” Meakes described. “It’s CUFLA national championship semifinal. so important in this sport that you keep an The Redbirds also said goodbye to four even composure.” graduating players—Miraglia, Preston NorMiraglia ended the Gaiters’ run with ris, Rowan Birrell, and Maverick Hoziel— an unassisted goal at the 12:14 minute mark who have had a season to be proud of. in his final home game as a Redbird, giving McGill a 12-7 lead going into the fourth quarter. “[It being my] last time playing in [Percival Molson Stadium] is really sad, but it’s great to be able to do it with all these guys on the team,” Miraglia said. “[I] wouldn’t want to Redbirds Head Coach Andrew Meakes served as assistant coach and do it with anybody offensive coordinator for the Gaiters prior to leading McGill this fall. (Emiko else, and [I’m] real- Kamiya / The Tribune)
Paddle up: The origin story of McGill’s new social sports club How a one-woman side project became McGill’s first pickleball club Zain Ahmed Staff Writer
M
cGill’s newest racket club is not built around winning. McPickle, McGill’s first student-run pickleball club, started from a simpler premise: Hand students a paddle, give them an hour, and let them have some fun on the court. Its founder and president, Kimia Mohammadi, U3 Arts, cares less about who takes a game to 11 than about who shows up. In a city where pickleball has become one of the fastest-growing sports, she bets that its real draw on campus is the company, rather than the competition it offers. Mohammadi came to the sport almost by accident, trying it at Club Atwater two years ago before becoming one of the club’s employees to help launch a new pickleball facility. Her job there was outreach: searching for sponsorships, organizing pickleball events, and finding schools and clubs that might host leagues. Combing through the catalogue of university clubs for leads, she spotted a gap; McGill had the necessary courts but only used them for intramural pickleball—not the social, student-run version of the game she imagined. “There’s no student-run pickleball club at McGill, and I was like, ‘Wait a minute, I can start one!’” Mohammadi said in an interview with The Tribune. “I know what it takes to host an event.” The distinction she draws between her student-run club and McGill’s intramural
league is about purpose, not rules. Intramurals are competition-first, whereas McPickle has a softer entry point. The club is built for any first-time players in Montreal hoping to meet people, or those looking for a social way to blow off some steam with a hint of friendly competition. An early membership survey of McGill students showed Mohammadi that roughly three-quarters of respondents have either never played the sport before or consider themselves beginners. “You find your friends, or you find your new doubles partner,” Mohammadi said. It is also personal. Mohammadi is studying psychology after receiving her first bachelor’s degree from Concordia University in kinesiology, and she frames pickleball as a meeting point of body and mind. “It’s just [about] taking your mind off things for one hour. If you’re mid-exams, all you have to think about is the ball, not what the exam might have [in store] for you tomorrow,” she explained. The hardest parts of establishing McPickle essentially solo, Mohammadi reported, were recruiting people who genuinely cared and filing the paperwork required to register the club through the Students’ Society of McGill University (SSMU). “If you ever need to start a business, it gives you a little bit of insight,” Mohammadi said. McPickle’s team now boasts 10 members, which is the headcount SSMU requires for a group to achieve interim club status. Alongside the mandatory executive roles,
Mohammadi added one of her own: sponsor- most is a more engaging Instagram, and ship, the source of the goody bags and snacks hopes that photos and merchandise designed that will set McPickle’s events apart from just by students can draw in more members. casual meetups. Mohammadi wants to emphasize the “It’s the most important role of all,” she individual identity of the sport itself, which reinforced. newcomers to the game rarely recognize. The McPickle win she is most proud of “Some people think it’s tennis, some came before she had even reached out to other think it’s ping-pong, some say it’s badminclubs: Several venues messaged McPickle on ton,” she said. “It’s a mix of all.” Instagram first, inviting its members to tour The rules are easy, and so is Mohamtheir facilities. madi’s pitch to anyone who has never held a “I’m doing something right out there [if] paddle before. they’re noticing us,” Mohammadi said. “Just put on your shoes, come in, and McPickle’s arrival on the scene is in- you’ll see what happens,” she said. tentionally timed: Montreal winters push the outdoor players indoors, so that Mohammadi expects demand for the club to peak around February and March. In the long term, she pictures friendly inter-faculty competition, such as psychology majors against business majors, building towards a recreational ladder and a competitive knockout tourna- Pickleball was invented in 1965 on Bainbridge Island, Washington, by three ment. For now, fathers improvising a backyard game from leftover ping-pong and badminton what she needs gear. (Eliot Loose / The Tribune)
16
SPORTS
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17 2026
sports@thetribune.ca
Instinct, poise, family: How Sophie Lancup made her mark with the Martlets From rookie MVP to three-match win streak, Lancup proves she belongs at the centre of Martlets’ attack Jenna Payette Staff Writer
S
ophie Lancup’s road to McGill had more stops than most. Born in British Columbia, she moved to Madagascar for three years because of her father’s work before her family settled in Quebec’s Saguenay region. Standing at 6-foot-1, Lancup grew up swimming, but discovered volleyball after witnessing her sister’s passion for the game. Following Cégep, she spent another year abroad in Madagascar and Mauritius before making her way back to Montreal, where the second-year outside hitter has become key to Martlets Volleyball’s attack. Lancup built her volleyball skills at Cégep de Jonquière, where she played middle hitter. The schedule demanded as much time off the court as on it: With games in Montreal almost every weekend, five-hour road trips became a part of Lancup’s routine. In an interview with The Tribune, Lancup, U2 Arts, discussed her early practice with managing an intense sport with other obligations. “I was already used to the busy schedule, which is kind of a blessing in a way,” she said. “Players that are coming from Ontario, they’re younger, and they’re going [straight] from high school to university [....] So I’m very grateful that I had my Cégep experience to shape me and prepare me for university.” After her year abroad, Lancup got in contact with a fellow Martlet.
“I reconnected with an old friend who was studying and playing at McGill,” Lancup explained. “And she said, ‘Why don’t you come and try out for the team?’” Now in her second year of International Development Studies, Lancup has wasted little time making her mark at McGill. Debuting last season alongside new Head Coach Marie-Christine Lapointe, Lancup immediately faced a learning curve. She was shifted from middle attack to right side, a position she had previously played for only a handful of games. This season, she moved again, to the left side—her third position in as many years. For many players, that much change would be unsettling. Lancup handled it the way she handles most things on the court: by not overthinking it. “I’m very instinctive. I don’t really think when I play,” she said. “I kind of just hit the ball, and I’m just trusting the process. I’m trusting that what I’m doing is gonna work.” It didn’t take long for that approach to show up on the stat sheet. No Martlet had more kills per set or points per set than Lancup in her first season, despite a concussion that partially sidelined her. At the team’s awards gala in March 2026, she took home both the Most Valuable Player and Rookie of the Year awards. Her impact has only grown this fall. After a slow start for McGill Volleyball, the team’s turning point came on Oct. 30 at home against the Universite de Sherbrooke Vert & Or. The Vert &
Or arrived unbeaten and were handed their first ritius, Lancup has spent her life adapting to loss of the season by McGill, a 3-0 sweep that new places. With the Martlets settling into their knocked them out of first place in the Réseau du rhythm, this player who trusts her instincts has sport étudiant du Québec standings. Lancup led given McGill every reason to trust her. all players with 14 kills and a .423 hitting percentDespite a loss the afternoon of Nov. 15 to the age without a single reception error. Université du Québec à Montréal Citadins, McMcGill followed with wins over the École Gill Volleyball’s spirits remain high. The Martde technologie supérieure Piranhas and the Uni- lets will face the Vert & Or again on Nov. 27, versité Laval Rouge et Or, leveling its regular- looking to keep momentum up. season record at 4–4 and moving the Martlets into fifth place. For Lancup, the turnaround was critical. “The beginning of the year was rough because we were always so close to winning,” she said. “To be able to close those sets […] just proves that hard work pays off.” Far from the family she followed around the world, she has found a new one in the Martlets locker room. Describing this year’s squad in one word, she didn’t hesitate. “Family,” Lancup said. “You can maybe disagree with some people, but you’re always gonna have their back at the end of the day,” she added. “In a family, you’re allowed to be different.” Lancup played only 16 of the team’s 21 regular-season games From British Columbia to after her concussion, yet still led the Martlets in kills per set and Madagascar, Saguenay to Mau- points per set. ( Zoe Lee / The Tribune)
Kimi Antonelli makes history as the youngest Formula 1 World Champion Antonelli’s victory marks a new era for Mercedes Lialah Mavani Staff Writer
O
n Nov. 1, Kimi Antonelli made history as the youngest Formula 1 (F1) driver to win the World Championship title. At just 20 years and 68 days old, the young Italian secured the championship with a third-place finish at the Mexico City Grand Prix, breaking Sebastian Vettel’s previous record of winning at 23 years and 133 days old. Antonelli’s historic victory also marked the first time in 73 years that an Italian-born driver has won the championship. Antonelli’s win was years in the making. His early introduction to the sport shaped his skills, and he was bolstered by the consistent support of his team, Mercedes-AMG PETRONAS, who recognized his potential long before his F1 debut in 2025. Antonelli started karting at just five years old, and his talent and early success in junior categories quickly made him stand out as one of the sport’s most promising young drivers. In 2019, at 12 years old, he joined the Mercedes F1 Junior Programme, beginning his journey in elite racing. Under Mercedes’ development pathway, Antonelli quickly progressed through the junior F1 ranks. He won the Italian and ADAC Formula 4 championships in 2022
before claiming the Formula Regional Middle East and European Championship titles in 2023. Instead of following the traditional route by moving from Formula 4 to Formula 3, Mercedes promoted Antonelli directly to Formula 2 in 2024. Despite being one of the youngest drivers on the grid that year, he finished sixth in the championship. Later in 2024, Mercedes decided to promote Antonelli again, this time to their Formula 1 team for the 2025 season—replacing the seven-time world champion Lewis Hamilton following his departure to Ferrari. At just 18 years old, Antonelli was stepping into one of the sport’s highest-pressure environments, following in the footsteps of one of F1’s and Mercedes’ best-ever drivers. Antonelli’s rookie season was marked by moments of brilliance, but also revealed his level of inexperience on the grid. He secured his first sprint pole position, setting the fastest lap in the Sprint Qualifying session to earn the first starting spot (P1) for the Miami Grand Prix. He also claimed his maiden Grand Prix podium with a thirdplace finish in Montreal. However, inconsistent results ultimately led Antonelli to place seventh in the Drivers’ Championship, reflecting the struggles that come with
adapting to competition against the sport’s At just 20 years old, Antonelli has albest. ready reached the top of Formula 1. His Mercedes continued to invest in An- historic championship victory not only tonelli despite these difficult moments. shows his talent and determination but Rather than allowing his rookie year to de- also the years of investment and belief that fine his next season, the team provided him Mercedes placed in his development. Anwith the opportunity to learn and gain expe- tonelli’s record-breaking thus marks the rience on the grid. beginning of a new era for Mercedes and And now, Mercedes’ investment has Formula 1. paid off. Across his second season of F1, Antonelli shifted from an inexperienced driver into a championship contender. After opening the season with a second-place finish at the Australian Grand Prix, he claimed his first Grand Prix victory in China, becoming the youngest driver to start a race from pole position. Other victories at the Japan and Miami Grands Prix established him as a serious threat by giving him a commanding lead in the championship standings. When Antonelli arrived in Mexico City this month, he only needed a ninth-place finish to secure his championship title. Yet he clinched third place, becoming the youngest Antonelli is one of three Italians to have ever won the F1 World world champion in F1 history. Championship title. ( Zoe Lee / The Tribune)