materIal obsessIons
Undergraduate Thesis Documentation
materIal obsessIons Matt DiPietro advised by Aki Ishida
Virginia Tech School of Architecture + Design
For My Mom & Dad
FO R EWO R D
AC K N OWLE D G E M E NTS
ORIGINS
23
The Beginning and the End at Once
35
The Process is the Idea
101
The Formwork is Architecture
149
The Process of Construction is a Performance
181
The Building Makes Its Site F UTU R ES
Foreword
Material changes everything. In the first weeks of my first year I was assigned a seemingly simple task: to design a beautiful cube. For weeks I continued to work, seeking beauty until I found the form I deemed so. It was a simple extrusion of a hollow square constructed with pieces of chipboard. I glued the last piece, stepped back and studied the cube. Immediately, I was dissatisfied. I had not found beauty, but instead the chipboard pretending to be something it is not. I had planes coming together to make something solid, but no matter how sharp its edges and clean its glue lines the chipboard cube would never be one. I remember walking through the rows of desks in my studio studying everyone’s work when I happened upon a cube made of Rockite. I was enamored with its oneness. I set out to construct a formwork the next day, and I remember taking the whole day to make. I treated it like a performance—pieces going into place here and there and sequencing the steps of assembly, pour, and removal out in my head. I opened the bag of Rockite and dumped it into a bucket with some water. I stirred until I had a slightly-thinner-than-pancake-batter consistency. I looked down into the bottom of my mold and began pouring. When you pour anything there are the feelings of anxiety, excitement, and anticipation. You can never be a hundred percent sure of anything. The viscous liquid flows into the mold, obeying only gravity. I remember finishing the pour and sitting there at my desk staring at it for a half hour until it cured. The beauty and horror of Rockite is the speed at which it dries. If you do everything right you will soon be rewarded, but a false move spells disaster: a lost formwork, a mess on the floor, a diminished spirit. Looking back on this moment I am glad I spent twelve hours making a formwork that could have achieved the same had I only spent a fraction of that time making it. This mold was the foundation for every mold I came to make in school and every mold I will come to make for the rest of my life. The formwork is ninety-nine percent of the project. It is nearly everything. You must treat the formwork like the outcome because it
13
generates the outcome. Within the hollow space of that formwork was beauty yet to be realized. I began to delicately remove the formwork as I had designed it. Brace by brace, wall by wall, the form collapsed around the now solid piece inside it. Heat radiated off the cube, the signal of the metamorphosis that just took place. The flowing liquid now frozen in solid walls. There were no seams, no glue lines, no frayed edges. It was one. This is what I mean to say that material changes everything.
14
Acknowledgments
This book is dedicated to my parents, William and Karen. Five years ago, you let me pursue a dream, and I will forever be in debt to you for that. Since my first day in studio every model and drawing I made was done with you in my mind and my heart. Your unwavering support gave me the strength to always keep moving forward, and when the going got tough I kept going for you. To my sisters, Nicole and Danielle, thank you for your unrelenting love. I am so proud to be able to call myself your brother. To my friends, there is no greater gift than friendship, and for some reason I was lucky enough to have the best friends anyone could ask for. To my colleagues in studio, it was our late night conversations about buildings, art, and music that helped me discover not just what architecture is about, but also life. To my thesis advisor, Aki Ishida, thank you for giving me the confidence and freedom to be myself as a designer. Your guidance and support allowed me to find my voice and forge my own path.
15
Origins
Opposite:
Anthracite coal pile
Remnants of Coal Landscape excavation 1.
To be obsessed means to have an idea or thought that continually preoccupies or intrudes a person’s mind. When I cast concrete for the first time, a domino fell and set off the chain of projects that would become the basis for my thesis work. Perhaps if I had carved wood or stuck to gluing cardboard, my work would have turned out completely different. However, concrete always drew me back in. I was captured by the freeness of the casting process and concrete’s inherent chance of form. There is no final piece at the end of this thesis. The thesis is the tenets by which I work: The Beginning and the End at Once The Process is the Idea The Formwork is Architecture The Process of Construction is a Performance The Building Makes Its Site It is not a thought process, but rather a belief system; this is how architecture should be. I realize now that my first two years of school were about learning how to work with concrete. I wanted to completely understand the material, which at the same time meant completely understanding the process of casting. While I would play around with other materials, I always felt that concrete was my niche. There is so much to do with concrete that I never needed to explore anything else. It had all I needed. In my third year I became fascinated with coal, specifically anthracite. I was enamored with its metallic fractured surfaces. It has the appearance of a stone of great value, but, truly, it is both dirty and cheap; a duality I could not resist. There is very little you can do with coal outside of burning it for power. I found this out quite quickly in my experiments with the material; however, it is not immune to change. Coal can be fractured into smaller and smaller pieces until it is dust. Though this is awfully simplistic, I found that changing the scale of the coal led me to look at the material in a new way. As I smashed the coal and piled it up, the landscape that formed intrigued me. However, these artificial landscapes were momentary. Like any alluvial
17
18
material, the fractured pieces held no permanence on a sheet of paper or the surface of my desk. To preserve this landscape in time I began pouring concrete on top of beds of fractured coal. I would slowly pour the concrete on top and let it spread across the material. Once the concrete had cured, I would excavate the new cast tablet and flip it upside down. This moment was always one of mystery and discovery for me because there is no way to see the final form until the piece is cured and turned over. During my second year I went to Iceland for a week and drove around the entire country. Everywhere I went I fell in love with the landscape. In Iceland the landscape changes dramatically with each twist and curve in the road. You can have the sea crashing
2.
Near the Skogafoss waterfall, Iceland
3.
Jokulsarlon glacier lagoon, Iceland
New York City skyline seen from the New Jersey Meadowlands 4.
on the beach to your left and the mountains piercing the sky to your right. Every so often though you encounter a vastness that is almost impossible to understand in a photograph. The distances between things become blurred through a lens. You could be driving along a mountainside and open into a massive valley. You are so close to one thing, yet so far from another. It is sublime. Even though it is all right in front of you its presence is something you feel, not see. I never had encounters with nature like this in my entire life. The experience was transformative. However, there was another place in the world where I felt these kind of feelings, not from nature, but from building. In New York City you can walk on the sidewalk with an open avenue on one side and a building soaring a thousand feet up into the air on the other. The spatial quality of New York is my first architectural memory from my childhood. I remember going into the city by train across the Meadowlands, a flat and swampy grassland on the New Jersey side of the Hudson River. As the train leaves the suburbs and enters this in-between space you catch glimpses of the skyline as the train begins a long arc away from Secaucus Junction. It appears minuscule- like something you can hold in your hand. As the train descends under the Hudson your view turns black. I remember getting off the train and ascending through the labyrinth of Penn Station. As you walk up the steps to Seventh Avenue the space around you compresses and then releases horizontally in front of you. I remember walking by my father’s side out of the station. I feel like time froze once we got to street level. My eyes went straight up to the sky, but my feet were cemented to the ground. It was sublime. This feeling of monumentality struck me, and all those years later the same feeling came back to me in
19
Iceland. I think the coal pieces are all born out of a subconscious desire to make artificial landscapes. After my experiences in Iceland I became fixated with finding beauty in extreme landscapes. There can never be a greater form of sculpture than a mountain formed over hundreds of millions of years. With the luxury of the internet a person can go anywhere they want in the world. They can stand on top of Mount Everest from their living room. And so I consumed all these things that would take me to new landscapes, and I would imagine the great forces of nature which constructed these works of art. In my thesis year I began working with another cast material, wax. It was like I was in my first year again. I had a material that I knew nothing about. I needed to figure out how to melt and cast the wax. Wax does not forgive little cracks and openings like concrete would. It is like trying to cast water. If there is the slightest air gap in a formwork it will find it and escape. Wax added a new dimension to my work because it was in between coal and concrete. Concrete when cast is permanent, it can only be changed once from liquid to solid, and coal can be changed virtually infinitely but only in one direction, it can only be made smaller. But wax is more permanent than coal and more fluid than concrete. It can be changed from liquid to solid and back and forth under great heat. I saw the wax as an opportunity to question what is formed and what is formwork, and later become another bridge between landscape and the built world. When you work with a material for so long you learn everything about it to the point that you think in that material. A carpenter must think in wood. A sculptor must think in marble. I think in concrete and wax and coal. All the learning I did with these materials eventually gave way to inventing. For my thesis I wanted to make inventions. I wanted to create processes that I would be able to call my own. The thesis is the five tenets, my beliefs and principles, that guide me and the work. The book is organized by these and not by the chronology of the work. Each piece stands on all five tenets, but takes its primary position in its strongest belief. 20
5. Heat gun propped up to melt solid wax in a glass measuring cup
Tenets
The Beginning and the End at Once
It begins like this: Listen: Billy Pilgrim has come unstuck in time. It ends like this: Poo-tee-weet?
Opposite:
Naoya Hatakeyama. Blast
This excerpt from Slaughterhouse- Five by Kurt Vonnegut fascinates me because it defeats the purpose of reading the book until you realize it does not. Imagine the feeling of reading a book. It captivates you to the point where you can’t stop reading, you need to know what happens on the next page until all of a sudden you get to the last paragraph, the last sentence, the last words. You were dying to get to those last words, but ultimately those words mean nothing without all the words that came before it. The way I understand architecture is like this. The process of making architecture is to imagine the end and work backwards to figure out how to construct the image we built in our head. I think without process our understanding of architecture is incomplete. This feeling drove the idea of being able to see the beginning and the end at once. I think it is a beautiful contradiction because you can never have both at the same time. The series of construction superimpositions are born directly out of this idea. Of the series of superimpositions, three stand out to me as the most significant: Ronchamp by Le Corbusier, the Bruder Klaus Chapel by Peter Zumthor, and the Oberrealta Chapel by Christian Kerez, coincidentally three chapels. Each building has a unique formwork. Ronchamp’s formwork looks more like shipbuilding than buildingmaking. Bruder Klaus’ formwork is for a building made from the inside out, and its material and process are unique in its own right: a teepee made from logs and burned for removal. The formwork for the Oberrealta Chapel is maybe the most recognizable as it is the outline of the formed space. I think these are also the most significant because they deal with the idea of casting a building in concrete.
25
26
Around the time of making the series of superimpositions, I happened upon the book Excavating the Future City, a monograph of Japanese photographer Naoya Hatakeyama’s work. It was like divine intervention. I was walking through the stacks in the Art and Architecture Library when the title caught my eye. Hatakeyama’s photo essay of mine blasts absolutely captivated me, and the way he spoke of them resonated with the work I was doing- trying to visualize the beginning and the end at once through freezing moments of the process in time. The blasts also intrigued me because of the role of chance in their form. Explosives and gravity were the only players in the formation of the moving rock. This aspect of the blasts gives profound meaning to Hatakeyama’s work. On one hand the blasts must be photographed because that is the only way to make them permanent, while on the other hand each blast is different; no blast can be replicated. In this way the photographs act to document and preserve. These questions of making the process permanent made me want to leave a physical trace of the process in building so that, in a way, you could see the beginning and the end at once. Of course, this could never be as true of a representation of this
1.
Naoya Hatakeyama. Blast
2 and 3. Toyo Ito. Sendai Mediatheque photographed by Naoya Hatakeyama
idea as the superimpositions are, but it might provoke the viewer into imagining how the building began and where it might be going in time. The formwork should be made from a material that becomes a part of the building. In other words, the process becomes architecture.
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
The Process is the Idea
There is a theory in art called presentness that describes work that looks as if it simply appeared in one instant. It is a term commonly attributed to the work of Jackson Pollack or Minimal Art sculptors like Donald Judd. This theory interests me a great deal in my own work because cast objects- objects with no seams or glue lines- can easily be perceived as acts of spontaneous and instant creation. Richard Serra speaks on this regarding his own work as well. Serra’s Verb List has always been a significant influence for me because it is about acting on material without advance thinking as to what the 1.
Richard Serra. To Lift
Opposite:
Richard Serra. Verb List
outcome will be. I find great joy in asking “If I do this, what will happen?”. The openendedness to the question leaves so much room for possibility. Working this way also frees me from the fear of a project not turning out as I imagined in my head. I am free from all assumption, and I find when I start to assume a form of a project that I end up disappointed or disliking the outcome. Embracing the process is freeing. I treat the process like a system. I design the system to be as beautiful as it can be and by result, I believe the outcome will be beautiful. Often we like to describe projects by the idea put forth in their final state. For me I am less interested in the final state than the entirety of the process of creation. To me the process is the idea- the result of that process is an anticipation or a byproduct of the idea, not the idea itself. Every time I look at a sculpture or building my mind ponders how it was made. It is always my first reaction. I see something that catches my eye and my mind tries to gather the materials and reconstruct the piece in my head. I look at a work and begin to dismantle it in my head until I have nothing and then I try to reconstruct it to understand the process of its creation.
37
Layer Cake II Rockite, anthracite, and cement
1–7. 38
39
40
41
42
43
44
Layer Cake Building Digital collage
8.
45
Layer Cake III Rockite, cement, and steel rods 9–34.
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
Layer Cake IV Rockite, wax, and steel tube 35–46.
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
A Space for Performance Formwork Foamboard and wax
47–58. 84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
A Formwork for Concrete Acrylic sheet 59–63.
96
97
98
99
100
The Formwork is Architecture
The Kunsthaus Bregenz is a perfect building. Its allure lies in its truth, its mystery in its lies. It is a building full of contradictions, dualities, simplicity, and complexity. During my semester in Riva San Vitale, I encountered countless masterpieces of architecture every single day. To see that much great architecture is almost exhausting. When you are constantly consuming these masterpieces, your criteria for great architecture must change. The nuance of details, the precision of construction, and the innovative uses of materials are no longer an adequate measure of greatness. They become standard. Many
Opposite:
Bregenz
Peter Zumthor. Kunsthaus
good buildings have these things, and I visited so many good buildings. I needed a new metric by which to evaluate architecture. I began to judge buildings by how much they stimulated my imagination and drove my curiosity. When I entered a building, I wanted it to make me think; I wanted it to make me feel. The Kunsthaus Bregenz inspired me more than any other building I have ever been to. I imagined my whole life in that building. I remember when we visited we were only supposed to stay there for two hours and then go to the Vorarlberg Museum next door, but after everyone entered the Vorarlberg I snuck back to the Kunsthaus to spend more time there. Two hours is not enough for this building. A day is not enough. As one catches a glimpse of the building from the banks of Lake Constance, all that is seen is a tiny grey box, its glass scales indecipherable from a distance. The Kunsthaus seems to take on whatever shade of grey the lake is reflecting that day, and even on the walk towards it each new glimpse may present a new shade of grey. Now closer to the building the panes of glass covering the façade, like scales on the body of a reptile, are perceptible. Even closer now and their slight skew and overlap can be noted. Initial readings blurred by distance get increasingly more focused through one’s shifting proximity to the building. Standing in the square in front of the Kunsthaus, one’s understanding of the façade becomes clear. The building rises above the ones surrounding it, but remains quiet, as if to not overshadow its neighbors. Even more quiet than the Kunsthaus is the café and administration building adjacent to it. It is almost like it is not there, yet it is crucial to the operation of the museum. The frosted glass
103
104
skin blurs everything that lies behind it. Only shadows lead us imagine what is hidden behind. The only thing that punctures the glass skin is a small metal box, the entryway into the Kunsthaus. From the outside it is impossible to imagine what is inside, and from the inside impossible to imagine what is outside. The entrance to the building offers visitors a peek behind the glass curtain, but it is only a mere moment in the staircase down to the coatroom. A frosted glass wall on the exterior side of the staircase plunges underground as if to create the illusion that it does not descend below ground at all. The underside of a concrete stair cascades above. This stair does not break the glass wall to the right, suggesting it rises the full height of the building. Emerging from the coatroom and walking deeper into the ground floor of the Kunsthaus, one begins to immerse themself in a world made of concrete. Light reflects
1–7.
Peter Zumthor. Kunsthaus Bregenz
off the polished concrete floor and smooth concrete walls spiral around the space. The frosted glass paned walls allow light into the building but obstruct views to the exterior. The ground floor is a space of transition, prodding the visitor to forget the outside world. Zumthor places the beginning of the stair on the same wall as the entrance, but on the opposite side. Here one is met with a heavy metal frame door, a single piece of frosted glass hiding the next room’s contents. Heaving the door open one finds themself inside a concrete chamber, a long and tall stair leading to the next floor. The door slowly shuts as if to signify the close of the building’s first act. Staring at the concrete wall, one’s mind is telling them there must be a glass wall here. In the staircase directly below the visitor watched the glass ascend upward passed the stair, but it is no longer there. The same space between the stair and the exterior wall from below exists here as well, furthering one’s thought as to what happened to the glass. Ascending to the second floor returns the visitor back where they were when they first entered the building. The space is the same as the one that was just left, but the glass paneled walls are replaced with concrete. All the walls are concrete now. A glass ceiling hangs above, the concrete walls rising through them. It is the same glass ceiling from the first level, but it hangs much lower now, and whereas below one could overlook it, here it glows just overhead begging for attention. The monolithic concrete surface reflects the even hum of light radiating down from above. Standing in this space, the world outside is completely forgotten. If one came into existence in this space, they would not have the slightest idea of what the exterior of the building is like. The building’s lies which pushed the visitor to this point, have now seduced them and veiled them in mystery. At this point it is believed that the building is concrete even though as one stands in front of the museum all that can be seen is glass. At this point the visitor could be anywhere in the universe in this building. It makes no references to the outside. There is nothing to tell one where to move, but still one moves through the space. Intuition drives the visitor forward until again they are facing a metal frame door with a single pane of frosted glass. Beneath all of the Kunsthaus’ lies here is truth. One opens the door and enters the
105
106
staircase, the same staircase they were in before just a floor below. Whereas the preceding lies pressed the visitor forward, the truth now guides them. The next floor is like the last, and as one moves to the end a familiar metal frame door with a single pane of frosted glass invites them to continue ascending through the building. The next floor is different. The concrete walls remain in the same position as below, but the glass ceiling hangs higher, even higher than on the first floor. Intuition must say this difference is significant; that it signifies a shift in the reality the building has generated. Reaching the end of this space the visitor is faced with another door in the same exact place as all the other doors they moved through to get to this one. But this door one cannot move through. The outline of the door the visitor knows stands in front of them on the concrete wall. There is a metal bar, a door handle, but one does not touch it. This is a moment of great contradiction in the reality of the Kunsthaus. Is it a lie or is it the truth? The truth of the Kunsthaus is in the promise of movement, while its lies are in the universe it creates. And as one stares at this door- or this outline of a door- one questions if the building is telling the truth or a lie. Is there another staircase behind this
door? The door is in the same spot as the others so there must be a staircase, or is there no door at all, and therefore no staircase. The door does not tell the visitor to open it. It pushes back on them. It turns one around to go the way which they came. During my time in the Kunsthaus Bregenz I completed this journey many times. As I walked through the building studying its precise details and nuanced materials, I felt a kind of creative energy I have never felt before. When I walked inside all the white noise of the outside world stopped, and the soft hum of the building remained. If great buildings generate ideas about buildings yet to be made, then the Kunsthaus is a temple for building worship. I imagine the Kunsthaus as a building encased in its formwork. Like any cast object or building, the formwork of the Kunsthaus stands in complete contrast with its cast counterpart- the formwork is tectonic and the cast object stereotomic. Its skin, a delicate glass panel and metal component construction, sheathes the solid and void concrete interior from the outside world. The building seems to have
107
been built from the outside in- it contradicts the logic of its construction by reinforcing the idea that the skin is really a formwork left in place. It holds all the dualities of a traditional formwork and cast concrete building except it makes them permanent. The Kunsthaus presents two moments of the same building set apart in time by the process of casting concrete. The exterior presents anticipation for what is to come, the interior the realization of what can be. One is given the beginning and the end at once and left to imagine the process between them. I believe that the formwork is architecture. Within the voided space of the formwork is a building and within the voided space of a building is the formwork. The two are so distinctly inseparable yet stand so far apart at the same time- they can never exist in the same moment. However, if one begets the other, then both must be the same. The formwork should be able to exist without the presence of cast material. Formworks are not machines for building-making, they are buildings themselves. They are just one reality of the building yet to be cast, and when I began to understand this, my love for process deepened. After a cast object has cured, I remove the formwork and rebuild it again. Each piece is delicately pulled off and set aside. The walls of the mold, now covered in residue and still hot from the exothermic reaction of the concrete, come back together again as a monument to what it just created.
108
A Formwork for Soap Acrylic sheet, steel sheet, soap, and steel rods 64–83.
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
Pink Panther I Digital collage 84.
130
Pink Panther II Digital collage 85.
131
The Block I Formwork Acrylic sheet, steel sheet, threaded rod, steel tube, wax 86–91.
132
133
134
135
136
137
The Block II Formwork Foamboard and wax
92–103. 138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
The Process of Construction is a Performance
Le Corbusier. Ronchamp under construction
Opposite:
Every day I would walk to studio from my home on Main Street and pass by the construction site of the new dormitory on Kent Street. Each time I would notice the incremental progress being made, and though these quick snapshots would grab my attention for a moment it was never enough for me to stop. Construction is slow, and that always bothered me. It seems as if buildings only get made in the past. By the time a building is finished the design is already a year to five years old, maybe even older. I saw the construction site as something very static. The images I gathered in my head played out like a stop motion film. The process I witnessed was never fluid, but broken up into pieces by my walk to and from campus. One day in the early fall on my usual walk home I stopped. A massive crane was on the site. A steel beam was suspended from its cables, hovering two stories above the ground. From a distance I could barely make out the cables. It was as if the beam floated in the air, weightless. The crane pressed down on the earth, four legs reaching out to stabilize its mass. The crane began to move the beam across the site and into place on the steel skeleton of the building. As the beam lowered, it met a welder perched atop a ladder two stories high. Sparks began to surround the welder as he melded steel to steel, the beam still hanging from the crane. I was entranced by it all. The juxtaposition of scale and mass fascinated me: the crane grounded to the earth, the beam made weightless, and the man between them all, my only reference to scale and reality. I play this sequence back in my head over and over again. There is a story being told in the movement of all its pieces. The still images previously ingrained in my mind were replaced with the motion of the beam swinging across the site and the sparks of the welder’s torch flashing off the steel. It is like watching a performance; each piece moving independently but to the same rhythm, together making something whole. I find it a beautiful thought to think that the construction workers are like dancers building the stages they perform on. However, dance is an ephemeral art. Dance exists only in the moment that it is happening. After the last dancer leaves the stage, the stage is empty, it is just how you found it. The process of constructing a building leaves something behind
151
152
that was not there in the beginning. I wanted to treat the process of construction as something that is more than a means to an end, and maybe even dare to say that constructing buildings is more interesting than buildings themselves. This is different than to say the process is the idea because ideas about buildings precede building. In this instance I am referring only to the actual sequence of constructing architecture, not the ideas about how a building should be constructed. When I think about the way I make projects, it is always so important to me to think about the setting the project is going to be made in, the way I move around the project, and the way the pieces of the project come together. Even the
1 and 3.
lead
Richard Serra splashing molten
2.
Yuri Ancarani. Il Capo
music I listen to is very crucial; it gives the movement rhythm and timing. I want it all to be so beautiful that when it is over you long for that movement once again. Beyond my experience at the construction site on Kent Street, I can trace the origins of this idea back to first seeing images of Richard Serra throwing molten lead. The image of Serra hurling lead against a white brick wall is perhaps more famous than the splash pieces themselves. He is dressed head to toe in protective gear: face mask, respirator, gloves, knee pads, boots. It is a very purposeful costume. One leg is planted firmly on the ground, the other raised behind him intensifying the moment of throwing the lead across his body and against the wall. We see the molten lead leaving the ladle and splashing against the wall. The moment, which lasted less than an instant, preserved perfectly in the photo. The photo is the action captured in time. It recalls to mind the mine blast series of Naoya Hatakeyama. In another well documented moment, Serra seems to acknowledge the performative nature of the splash pieces as he stands in the center of the room surrounded by his works posed like an ancient Roman stature, his body contorted to exacerbate the motion of throwing the molten lead. In my first year I watched an excerpt from the film Il Capo by Yuri Ancarani, which documents the process of excavating marble from the famed Carrara Quarry in Italy. Countless times I have watched it; fascinated by every aspect of it: the material, the movement, the process, and the setting. Ancarani takes the task of removing stone from
153
Richard Serra. Berlin Block (for Charlie Chaplin) 4.
the side of a mountain and turns it into a high art. There are no words spoken between the capo and the machine operators, only hand signals. Each movement of the excavators appears delicately choreographed by the capo, who stands between the machines like conductor commanding an orchestra racing towards a great crescendo; the moment when a piece of marble finally topples to the ground. I find myself thinking back on this film in every project that I make. I want the process to be a performance; to be a piece of art.
154
The Block I Formwork Acrylic sheet, steel sheet, threaded rod, steel tube, wax 104–110.
156
157
158
159
164
165
The Block I Concrete and wax 111–114.
166
167
168
169
Layer Cake I Formwork Acrylic sheet 115-116.
170
171
Layer Cake I Anthracite and cement 117–119.
176
177
Layer Cake II Rockite, anthracite, and wax
120.
A Space for Performance Concrete, anthracite, and wax 121–125.
182
183
184
185
186
188
The Building Makes Its Site
Opposite.
Peter Zumthor. Therme Vals
1. A defective formwork for a wax block
A slab of wax is like a piece of rock. It can be fractured under great force, carved by the repeated strikes of a hammer and chisel, and made liquid under intense and constant heat. Its properties lend itself to the earth. Wax is constantly in a raw state, continuously ready to change and be changed again. Its resting state is solid, but when liquid it takes the shape of its container and flows freely in the absence of one. A formwork for wax is like that of concrete, however there is absolutely no room for error. When liquid, wax is virtually as thin as water. It will find any crack, no matter how miniscule, and seep out of its mold. Wax in motion is wax yearning to be at rest. The hot liquid flows like lava until it slowly cools into a formless solid, building itself up in layers around the base of a defective formwork. A formwork without faults will produce a perfect prism of wax. Its clean faces and edges are delicate, yet as a solid mass the block is strong. Like concrete, when cured its surface mirrors that of the material it was cast in. An acrylic formwork produces a glassy and marbled texture, while a foamboard formwork leaves the block matte with a fine grit. These prisms can be placed in a formwork, cast around, and then melted away to carve out a void within a concrete solid. In this process the wax first becomes a part of the formwork, and then, after the concrete cures, a part of the formed piece. As wax begins to melt it starts to drip down the sides of the concrete mass, slowly gathering at the base of the block. Once the wax is thoroughly heated the slow drip will give way to a steady stream and the scattered droplets will amass into a small pool. This moment resembles the splash of water and the trace of rust collecting on the floor and wall around the steel pipes pumping hot spring water into Therme Vals. Over time the runoff grows wider and wider, a sign of the continuous flow of water into and through the building. Inside the baths, water becomes the site. The architecture provokes the visitor into believing that water has always been there. Walls of stacked gneiss blocks rise out of the various pools as stairs of the same material gently descend into them. Almost level with the floor, the plane of water is calm like the still surface of a lake nestled between two mountains. In Vals water is a material equal to stone and
189
190
concrete. Without water it would not just be incomplete, but also site less. The building creates the landscape it exists in. Cascading down the side of the block, wax gathers around the base of the concrete and flows outward. The melting wax reveals openings in the block but can never be completely removed from the concrete. Coating the interior of the block, it darkens the hue of the concrete. It is soft and smooth to the touch. Any air pockets within the concrete become filled with wax, making the surface feel flat without appearing so. Thin coatings of dry wax spread on the exterior walls of the block giving the illusion that the concrete is wet. The streams of wax solidify and hang on the side of the block like
Wax solidifies around the base of the Block I 2.
3.
Peter Zumthor. Therme Vals
waterfalls frozen in time. All the wax that once occupied the voids of the block now surround it. The cooling wax rises to a level almost equal to the lowest opening in the concrete block, grounding the piece permanently in the field of solid wax. The material which helped build the block and then became a part of it has now made the site in which it rests. The resulting image is not unlike the one that was created by the defective formwork; however, the presence of the concrete block transforms the way the moment is perceived.
191
The Block III Concrete and wax 126–131.
192
193
194
195
196
197
The Block II Concrete and wax 132–139.
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
Layer Cake I Anthracite and cement 140–145.
206
207
208
209
210
211
Layer Cake IV Rockite, wax, and steel tube 146–155.
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
The Block I Concrete and wax 156–186.
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
Futures
The foundation of architecture is beauty. This much I know to be true. Beautiful things last forever, but the buildings that are being built now do not. Too often buildings are destroyed before their useful life is over. Their unsustainable materials seem designed for failure and destined for a second life as trash. The materials we use should look like the Earth they come from and the buildings they make should evoke the same Earth. And if buildings do not last forever, then what we take from the Earth we must return. I want to make buildings that look 100 years old on the day they are completed and just completed on the day they turn 100. I imagine these buildings forming like the great mountains of the Alps and Himalayas. I want them to be built over the span of a million years, perhaps never completed at all, this way their beauty might last forever.
259
260
261