Skip to main content

2026.08.31 Vol 9 Stable and Farm Brief

Page 1

THE STABLE & FARM

BRIEF

©

VOL. 9 · WEEK OF AUGUST 31, 2026

A single week produced a presidential beef-import proclamation, a state executive order answering it, an Illinois decision showing exactly how equine liability statutes are won and lost on the pleadings, and a federal ruling that leaves an unlawful farm-labor wage rule standing while the agency rewrites it.

IN THIS ISSUE • Hot Topics & Legislative Developments — Proclamation adds 300,000 mt to the lean beef quota

• Federal Regulatory Updates — USDA settles a Packers & Stockyards carcass-ID case

• Recent Equine & Ag Law Cases — Illinois EALA bars an unpleaded willful-conduct theory

• Oklahoma-Specific Updates — Stitt creates a Beef Industry Advisory Council

• Recent Equine & Ag Law Cases — 2025 H-2A wage rule unlawful, but left in place

• Emerging Issues — Oklahoma constitutional convention goes to the ballot


HOT TOPICS & LEGISLATIVE DEVELOPMENTS Proclamation adds 300,000 metric tons to the lean beef import quota — with a price condition attached. On August 26 the President signed “Further Ensuring Affordable Beef for the American Consumer,” temporarily increasing the quantity of lean beef trimmings that may enter at the in-quota tariff rate by 300,000 metric tons, building on Proclamation 11010 of February 6, 2026 (The White House). What makes it unusual is the enforcement condition written into it: if imports under the increased quota are not sold at a price 25 percent below the market price for lean beef trimmings, the Secretary of Agriculture and the U.S. Trade Representative must notify the President immediately, and the President reserves the right to end the action to prevent a windfall to foreign producers. The legal predicate is a finding that domestic supply would be inadequate to meet demand at reasonable prices because of natural disasters, disease, or major national market disruptions, and cattle-producer groups objected sharply (Reuters). Takeaway: producers negotiating forward contracts or feeder-cattle purchases this fall should read price-adjustment and force-majeure language with the quota expansion in mind, because the added volume is temporary and expressly revocable.

RECENT EQUINE & AG LAW CASES Illinois appellate court: a rider cannot escape the Equine Activity Liability Act by arguing willful misconduct she never pleaded. In J.L.F., a Minor, by her Parent and Next Friend, Melissa Fray v. Denise Hanna and Hannaberry Farm, LLC, Appeal No. 3-25-0346, decided August 26, the Appellate Court of Illinois, Third District,

Stable & Farm Legal

affirmed summary judgment for a lesson barn (FindLaw Caselaw). A minor rider fell and was injured when the horse she was riding was allegedly spooked by a dog that entered the arena; she sued for negligence and under the Illinois Animal Control Act. The court held that the Equine Activity Liability Act applied to the riding lesson, that the statutory exception for failing to assess a participant's ability did not apply because the instructor had made reasonable and prudent efforts to determine the rider's skill, and that the Animal Control Act claim was preempted on these facts (745 ILCS 47). Critically, the court rejected the plaintiffs' willful-and-wanton theory because it appeared only in a motion and in opposition to summary judgment — raising it there was not equivalent to pleading it. Takeaway: for barn owners the intake and skill-assessment record is the case; for anyone evaluating a claim, the willful-and-wanton exception must be pleaded in the complaint, in name or in substance, or it is gone. One caveat: this outcome rests on the law of that jurisdiction. Equine liability law varies from state to state — including whether a state has an equine activity liability act at all and, where one exists, how far it reaches, which exceptions it recognizes, and what signage or release requirements attach. Readers should know how their own state's law applies to their operation rather than assume an Illinois result repeats elsewhere. Federal court finds the 2025 H-2A wage rule unlawful but leaves it in place — and warns of backpay. In United Farm Workers v. U.S. Department of Labor, No. 1:25-cv-01614, U.S. District Judge Kirk Sherriff in the Eastern District of California ruled late on August 26 that the Labor Department's October 2025 revision to the adverse effect wage rate methodology violated federal law (Reuters). The court found the agency failed to explain why the change was necessary, unlawfully depressed wages, and bypassed normal rulemaking by proceeding on an emergency basis; it separately held unlawful the provision letting employers deduct the value of employer-provided housing from wages. Rather than vacate, the court left the rule in effect as too disruptive to the

2 of 4 pages


industry to strike, and instead ordered the Department to promptly revisit the regulation and adopt a new wage methodology (DOL adverse effect wage rates). The order also directs that employers be notified they may be responsible for backpay running from the date of the decision until a revised rate is set. Takeaway: any operation using H-2A labor should begin accruing for a potential retroactive wage differential now and preserve payroll and housing-deduction records, because the exposure clock started August 26.

FEDERAL REGULATORY UPDATES USDA settles a Packers and Stockyards case over carcass identification and a 0.75-pound tare error. On August 25, USDA's Agricultural Marketing Service announced a stipulation agreement, entered June 19, resolving alleged Packers and Stockyards Act violations by J.H. Routh Packing Company of Sandusky, Ohio, doing business as Daiseyfield Procurement LLC and Routh Procurement LLC, together with HK Cooperative Inc (USDA AMS, Release 115-26). A 2025 investigation found the packer changed its method of identifying carcasses by tattooing without notifying livestock sellers, and failed to tell sellers how missing and extra carcasses would be handled and paid for; a review of six slaughter dates found 2,451 misidentified carcasses. The investigation also found the packer deducting a fixed tare weight 0.75 pounds heavier than the equipment actually weighed, which USDA calculated as a $13,202 shortfall to sellers. The packer waived a hearing, paid an $11,000 civil penalty, and made payment to the sellers. Takeaway: for anyone selling livestock on a carcass-weight basis, the accounting mechanics — identification method, tare weight, and how discrepancies are resolved — are enforceable terms, not back-office details, and they belong in writing.

Stable & Farm Legal

OKLAHOMA-SPECIFIC UPDATES Stitt creates a Beef Industry Advisory Council in direct response to the federal import expansion. On August 25, Governor Kevin Stitt signed an executive order establishing the Oklahoma Beef Industry Advisory Council, expressly framed as preparation for the announced federal action to increase imported beef sold below U.S. market rates (Oklahoma Governor's Office). The Council is chaired by Secretary of Agriculture Blayne Arthur and is to be composed of leaders with experience in cattle production, beef processing, agricultural economics, and market development. Its charge is to meet and deliver public recommendations to protect and grow Oklahoma's beef industry and to identify practical, Oklahoma-led solutions. The Governor held a roundtable with Secretary Arthur and Oklahoma cattle producers before filing the order, and the proclamation described above followed the next day — so the Council now has a concrete federal action to respond to rather than an anticipated one. Takeaway: Oklahoma producers and industry associations should watch for the Council's meeting notices and comment opportunities; a state advisory body that must issue public recommendations is a low-cost place to put a documented position on the record.

EMERGING ISSUES Oklahoma voters will decide on a constitutional convention for the first time since 1970. Announced August 26, Governor Stitt issued an Executive Proclamation and Executive Order 2026-30 sending to a vote of the people the question whether the Legislature shall call a state constitutional convention (Oklahoma Governor's Office). Article XXIV, Section 2 of the Oklahoma Constitution requires that the question be put to voters at least once every twenty years; the announcement notes 56 years have passed since it was last submitted in 1970. The proclamation sets a special election for April 6, 2027. The executive order directs the Secretary of State to take the steps necessary to submit the question and creates

3 of 4 pages


an Oklahoma Constitutional Convention Commission to study the Oklahoma Constitution and other states' conventions and to recommend the procedures, rules, and safeguards that would govern a convention if voters approve, with a report due no later than December 31, 2026. Takeaway: everything with a constitutional dimension in Oklahoma practice, from the right-to-farm amendment to tax and judicial-selection provisions, is potentially in scope, and the Commission's December report is the first real window to see what a convention would actually look like.

Two dates to calendar: the Constitutional Convention Commission report on December 31, 2026, and the H-2A backpay period that began running August 26. If any of these developments touch your operation, reach out and we'll walk through it.

• Oklahoma Governor's Office, Beef Industry Advisory Council (Aug. 25, 2026) — https://oklahoma.gov/governor/ne wsroom/newsroom/2026/governor-stitt-establishes-oklahoma -beef-industry-advisory-council-defending-cattle-producers-a nd-strengthening-oklahoma-beef-market.html • Oklahoma Governor's Office, Constitutional Convention to a Vote of the People (Aug. 26, 2026) — https://oklahoma.gov /governor/newsroom/newsroom/2026/governor-stitt-sends-co nstitutional-convention-to-vote-of-the-pe1.html

The Stable & Farm Brief© is provided by Stable & Farm Legal for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading this newsletter does not create an attorney-client relationship. Laws and regulations change frequently and vary by jurisdiction; you should consult a licensed attorney regarding your specific situation before acting on any information here.

© 2026 Stable & Farm Legal. All rights reserved. Stable & Farm Legal 3030 Northwest Expy, Suite 300 #762, Oklahoma City, OK 73112 Phone: 405-237-8737 · Fax: 405-300-4479 Email: mary@stableandfarm.legal · Web: stableandfarm.legal

SOURCES • Proclamation, Further Ensuring Affordable Beef for the American Consumer (Aug. 26, 2026) — https://www.whiteho use.gov/presidential-actions/2026/08/further-ensuring-afforda ble-beef-for-the-american-consumer/ • Reuters, Trump signs proclamation on beef prices (Aug. 26, 2026) — https://www.reuters.com/world/us/trump-says-he-si gned-proclamation-address-unreasonably-high-beef-prices-20 26-08-26/ • J.L.F. v. Hanna, No. 3-25-0346 (Ill. App. 3d Dist. Aug. 26, 2026) — https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/il-court-of-appeal s/348678.html • Illinois Equine Activity Liability Act, 745 ILCS 47 — https: //www.ilga.gov/Legislation/ILCS/Articles?ActID=2074&Cha pterID;=58 • Reuters, judge orders DOL to redo H-2A wage changes (Aug. 27, 2026) — https://www.reuters.com/legal/governmen t/us-judge-orders-trump-administration-redo-changes-farmwo rker-visa-program-2026-08-27/ • U.S. Department of Labor, H-2A Adverse Effect Wage Rates — http://flag.dol.gov/wage-data/adverse-effect-wage-rates • USDA Agricultural Marketing Service, Release 115-26 (Aug. 25, 2026) — https://www.ams.usda.gov/content/usda-s ettles-packers-and-stockyards-case-hk-cooperative-inc-and-jh -routh-packing-company

Stable & Farm Legal

4 of 4 pages


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
2026.08.31 Vol 9 Stable and Farm Brief by Stable & Farm Legal - Issuu