Skip to main content

Christ is the Question

Page 1

152 Reviews Romans 4 makes brilliant sense of an otherwise very awkward portion of the letter, but in "Christ Prays the Psalms" Hays advances a more ambitious case, and takes it in more directions, than the scope of this presentation quite sustains. The far-reaching implications that Hays adduces at the end of that essay w ould be better served by a fuller treatm ent of this topic. In his chapter on Paul's use of the Old Testament in ethical reasoning, Hays parses the patterns of Pauline usage into categories that are helpful for general orientation, but which m ight tem pt a less-careful conversation partner to read them as a taxonomy of distinct functions; one pivotal element of Hays's insight in these essays, however, lies in his recognizing that Paul's interpretive imagination has been transformed, and the imagination does not readily accommodate itself to pigeonholes. The closing essay, echoing Frank Lentricchia's disenchantm ent w ith the theoretical epiphenomena of criticism, implicitly points to the relative rarity of simple good reading in the field of biblical studies. At their best, these essays exemplify the possibility that a biblical critic can indeed read the Bible well as a technically astute lover of the text. That example by itself sets high standards for Hays and for his readers— and though readers will find some of these readings more compelling than others, the witness of Hays's imagination suggests the great value of cultivating imaginations tuned to Scripture in ways congruent and critical. A. Κ. M. Adam Duke Divinity School Durham, NC 27708 USA akm.adam@gmail.com

Christ Is the Question by Wayne A. Meeks (Louisville, Kentucky: Westminster John Knox Press, 2006) x + 166 pp. Wayne Meeks's recent Christ Is the Question considers the question of Jesus' identity, but w ithout sum m oning forth the now-familiar procession of historical Jesuses. Instead, Meeks examines the questions concerning Jesus and our contemporary investment in them. By drawing the circle of inquiry wide enough to include both Jesus and also the historians, Meeks brings his command of the sociology of knowledge to bear on the Jesus quest, w ith illuminating results. While Meeks steers resolutely clear of anything resembling facile pietism, his approach allows room for a Jesus whom his followers professed as the resurrected Lord, while at the same time he applies rigorous historical judgm ent to the witnesses and their testimony. The book comprises six chapters, of which five w ere originally presented as lectures at Emory University, Williams College, and several other venues. Meeks preserves the rhetorical characteristics of a public lecture for this published version, offering a scholar's view of the terrain in clear prose w ith few footnotes. The lucid, assured style makes for easy reading, and should attract a w ide audience among students and reading groups. For just this reason, however, scholars may find the book frustrating, since Meeks omits the painstakingly detailed argum entation that w ould ordinarily buttress a work such as this. The first chapter discusses the ways that questions about Jesus' identity have arisen, and the ways that such questions usually attract answers that do not satisfy. Meeks rehearses a capsule history of skepticism, historicism, and efforts to build critical historical bulwarks to faith, ending w ith the confusion that the hermeneutics of suspicion engenders. He proposes an alternative to the dominance of suspicion: an © 2008 The Authors Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd


Reviews

153

account of Jesus that avoids the pitfalls of skeptical, relativist m odernity (without recourse to specifically postmodern discourses). The second chapter questions the m odern tendency to seek ever newer, more up-to-date versions of Jesus. Although the base of evidence for understanding Jesus' identity has expanded over the centuries, the various Jesus quests have not yielded a definitive touchstone for explaining their subject. Meeks argues that part of the problem lies in the questers' defective account of identity; idealism and romanticism misled scholars to construe Jesus' real identity as a private, interior quality. The questers thus sought the introspective consciousness of Jesus, for which no evidence will suffice, whereas Meeks directs his readers' attention to the public, social identity of Jesus. Meeks allows that the public persona of Jesus is not more "real" than was his private interiority, but notes that the interpretive process by which observers learned to explain Jesus' identity drew on culturally prom inent narratives of antiquity and, in turn, affected the dom inant narratives of identity thereafter. The third chapter explores the narrative logic by which Jesus' contemporaries came to recognize him. Meeks foregrounds the interrogative christology manifest in gospel traditions ("Who do they say that I am?" and, addressed to John the Baptist, "Why are you baptizing then, if you are not the Anointed One nor Elijah or the Prophet?"). Meeks takes the characters' questions as clues to the most plausible inferences they could make, and notes that Jesus does not exactly match any of the characters' expectations. By an interpretive process, then, observers came to recognize Jesus' status as G od's Anointed, while also allowing Jesus to redefine their expectations. In the fourth chapter, Meeks surveys various ways in which the interpreted Jesus shapes the Pauline epistles. Meeks summarizes the letters w ith a verve and clarity bom of deep familiarity w ith Paul's concerns. He explains Jesus' place in each letter in vivid paraphrase, showing how Jesus orients Paul's rhetoric; Jesus provides Paul with "a story to think w ith" (p. 83). This story functions to shape, guide, and ground disciples' lives, but it does not function as an exhaustive, univocal compilation of rules. Meeks follows w ith a chapter that calls into question the Protestant doctrine of the perspicuity of Scripture. He questions the usefulness of such terms as "the clarity of scripture," "literal meaning," and "plain sense," w hen they serve theological polemics more than they actually describe the reader's experience of figuring out the Bible. He draws on Hans Frei's Eclipse of Biblical Narrative to outline an approach to Scripture that honors both the church's sense that the Bible does not impose prerequisites upon its readers and the apparent complexity of the collection of the Bible's texts. In the final chapter, Meeks considers w hether Jesus should be construed as the definitive expression of God's interactions w ith humanity. Meeks presupposes that this premise is open to question; "the approach to questions about Jesus' identity advocated here conflicts w ith one of the more cherished and ancient convictions of the church" (p. 123). Meeks develops an alternative account of Jesus' finality by invoking the theology of the cross as a w arrant for a non-coercive Christology. Rather than winning souls for Christ or converting heathens, Meeks construes Jesus' finality as an eschatological ultimacy shrouded in m ystery (quoting Paul's doxological ejaculation from Romans 11:32-36). Meeks submits that we who know not the m ind of God can affirm Jesus' ultimacy, but may not act or teach in ways that unduly arrogate the perspective of divine omniscience. Christ Is the Question offers an excellent sum m ary of M eeks' hermeneutical theology. For just this reason, though, it raises a num ber of questions that lead beyond the bounds of the format of this book. Some are technical questions that m ight provoke a scholarly reader's curiosity, but others raise more substantive issues for Meeks' project. Meeks discards long-held doctrines about C hrist's finality w ithout allowing © 2008 The Authors Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd


154 Reviews that many critical theologians manage to sustain a commitment to Jesus' finality, despite Meeks' offhand claim that "the church has always been tom betw een the desire to pin dow n its teaching about Jesus once and for all, in a system of static dogmas, and the acknowledgement that the story of God's engagement w ith the created w orld is dynamic and still open to G od's perhaps surprising future" (p. 124); here Meeks is indulging in unw arranted rhetorical arm-twisting on behalf of the "openness" and "dynamism" he favors. Meeks laudably describes and criticizes the deleterious effect of romanticism on theological interpretation, and he distances his account from the ideology of m odernity at a num ber of points. He does not, however, give a rich account of the background for his own proposal. A casual reader m ight suppose that Meeks has escaped the traps of romanticism and modernity so as to attain an objectivity untainted by any ideological influences; a more critical reader m ight try to figure out how to situate Meeks' acknowledged intellectual debts to George Herbert Mead and Hans Frei (for instance) relative to modernity. Although Meeks mentions "the postm odern w orld" in his closing pages, he makes no effort to clarify what he means by that term, nor w hy his proposal befits a "postm odern world." He likewise suggests some distance between his project and the postliberal theology of his Yale colleagues, but w ithout offering a rationale for that demurrer. Few scholars could match the richness and readable prose w ith which Meeks sets out his proposal, and no one should fault Meeks for not having done more in such short compass. Sympathetic readers will want to follow up, however, to learn whether Meeks has just proposed a new, improved version of m odem Christologies, or w hether he has broken out of the impasses that he diagnoses. Either way, in these lectures Meeks ably engages a general audience w ith thoughtful considerations of christology, Scripture and culture. A. Κ. M. Adam Duke Divinity School Durham, NC 27708 USA akm .adam@gmail. com

Jewish Liturgical Reasoning by Steven Kepnes (N ew York: Oxford University .Press, 2007) xiv + 233 p p A reader w ho is a stickler for good editing will find Jewish Liturgical Reasoning :frustrating. In addition to a handful of typographical errors in English, there are also oddities in the communication of philosophical information w hen Kepnes refers to )1 G. F. Hegel," and implies that Franz Rosenzweig's use of mathematics extends to" equations such as "A-B=", 2) errors in French w hen Kepnes refers to Levinas's first m agnum opus as Totalité et Infini, w hen it is entitled Totalité et l'infini, 3) typographical -errors in German w hen Kepnes writes " Schöfung" instead of " Schöpfung", 4) typo ,graphical errors in Latin (" imitatio deo" for " imitatio Dei") and 5) m ost surprisingly -errors in basic Hebrew. In this last regard, some errors seem to be merely typographi cal ("tsitsum" for "tsimtsum," "lav" for "lev,” "tsdekkah‫ ״‬for “tzedaqah," “tefillan" for tefillin," and others), but Kepnes also w rites that the trilateral root of korban is" .kuf-resh-nun w hen it is in actuality kuf-resh-bet ,Nevertheless, if such a reader w ere only to remove the stick from a certain orifice she or he m ight see that Jewish Liturgical Reasoning is one of the most im portant books in Jewish philosophical theology in this decade. Unsurprisingly for a field in which © 2008 The Authors Journal compilation © 2008 Blackwell Publishing Ltd


Copyright and Use: As an ATLAS user, you may print, download, or send articles for individual use according to fair use as defined by U.S. and international copyright law and as otherwise authorized under your respective ATLAS subscriber agreement. No content may be copied or emailed to multiple sites or publicly posted without the copyright holder(sV express written permission. Any use, decompiling, reproduction, or distribution of this journal in excess of fair use provisions may be a violation of copyright law.

This journal is made available to you through the ATLAS collection with permission from the copyright holder( s). The copyright holder for an entire issue of ajournai typically is the journal owner, who also may own the copyright in each article. However, for certain articles, the author of the article may maintain the copyright in the article. Please contact the copyright holder(s) to request permission to use an article or specific work for any use not covered by the fair use provisions of the copyright laws or covered by your respective ATLAS subscriber agreement. For information regarding the copyright holder(s), please refer to the copyright information in the journal, if available, or contact ATLA to request contact information for the copyright holder(s). About ATLAS: The ATLA Serials (ATLAS®) collection contains electronic versions of previously published religion and theology journals reproduced with permission. The ATLAS collection is owned and managed by the American Theological Library Association (ATLA) and received initial funding from Lilly Endowment Inc. The design and final form of this electronic document is the property of the American Theological Library Association.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook