Skip to main content

Sandy Soils New Amendments - Murrayville MRU

Page 1


New amendments for sandy soils

PIRSA Soils Collaboration Centre

3 March 2026, Murrayville

Mallee Sustainable Farming Research Updates

Sands aren’t all the same

Sands aren’t all the same

Sandy soils = less than 10% clay in the top 30 cm

Photo Source: NatureMapsSA

Sandy soils in agricultural regions

Source: https://vas.soilcrc.com.au/map#

Sandy soils in agricultural regions = 16 million ha

Source: https://vas.soilcrc.com.au/map#

Menti question

Do you find sandy soils easy or hard to manage?

Characteristics of sandy soil?

Low reactive surface area

Low

• Water

• Nutrients

• Organic matter

Prone to

• Water repellence

• Acidity

• Compaction

• Erosion

Often have multiple limitations

BUT can respond to light rainfall events

Slide from: Richard Bell

Why amend sands –think about

• What are you trying to amend?

• What amendments are available?

• Consistent response?

• Longevity of the effect?

• Is it cost effective to use?

Slide from: Richard Bell

Types of amendments

Many variations for each type of amendment

Examples

Clay

Clay-rich subsoil, other clay sources

Organic

Compost, Manures, Food/ farm waste, Biochar

Chemical

Mineral

Lime, Fertiliser, Polymers

Mineral-processing residues, naturally occurring

Mixed

Clay-enriched composts, Modified biochar

Slide from: Richard Bell

Types of amendments

Many variations for each type of amendment

Menti Question: What amendments have you tried?

Clay

Clay-rich subsoil, other clay sources

Organic

Compost, Manures, Food/ farm waste, Biochar

Chemical

Mineral

Lime, Fertiliser, Polymers

Mineral-processing residues, naturally occurring

Mixed

Clay-enriched composts, Modified biochar

Slide from: Richard Bell

Meta-analysis highlights

Depth of sand matters

Productivity

• Yields drop as sand gets deeper

• Organic amendments help most on the deepest sands

• Clay addition helped when subsoil clay 30-60cm below surface

Deeper sand reduces yield, organic amendments like compost can maintain yield even when sand > 90cm.

Meta-analysis highlights Depth of sand matters

Organic carbon (OC)

• Little change in OC % in the top 10cm, regardless of depth of sand

• But deeper sands (>60cm), lose ~ 0.5% in the top 30cm

Meta-analysis highlights

Longevity of effect

• Productivity effects show up quickly –usually in 2 years stabilised by 5 years

• With organics alone (no clay), productivity maintained for 3-4 years and then declined

• OC gains from subsoil clay build slowly, 5-10 years but have been shown to persist for 15 years in WA

Meta-analysis highlights

Interesting finding -Iron

• Iron in amendments may help increase productivity and OC

• Addition can help increase the reactive surface area of sands

• Iron binds OC and can slow decomposition

Source: https://wmgroup.org.au/exploring-novel-soil-amendments-in-the-future-carbon-project/

Meta-analysis highlights

Productivity and organic carbon (OC)

• Winter and summer rainfall increase productivity

• Summer rainfall can lead to a loss of soil OC

• OC sweet spot for improved production in sandy soils is between 0.75 to 1.5% in the top 0-10cm

Productivity and OC sweet spot –top 10 cm

Focus Function

Select amendments high in OC to rebuild function Struggles to hold water and nutrients, biology is limited OC is the limiting factor < 0.75%

0.75 to 1.5 %

Choose amendment based on cost per tonne of OC and constraint Improvements in OC can lift soil function and productivity

Adding more OC doesn’t drive productivity –constraints are limiting factors > 1.5%

Choose amendments for specific constraints not OC gains OC is adequate for function.

Subsoil clay

Meta-analysis highlights

• Productivity: yield increased with clay concentration up to 15% then sharp drop

• OC: increased when clay concentration above 15% (largest increase in 10-30cm)

• Clay sweet spot: 6-15% clay –fine tune for rainfall

If subsoil clay works, why look at other amendments?

• Subsoil clay is not always available

• Historic clay rates too high and put people off

• High cost of application

• High activity amendments may be effective at lower rates of application

• Amendments can address constraints not treated by subsoil

Types of amendments

Many variations for each type of amendment

Examples

Clay

Clay-rich subsoil, Bentonite, Kaolinite, Hydrotalcite

Organic

Compost, Biochar, Manures, Food/ farm waste

Chemical

Mineral

Lime, Fertiliser, Polymers

Zeolite, Mineral-processing residues, Spongelite

Mixed

Clay-enriched composts, Modified biochar

Slide from: Richard Bell

Amendments trialled

ClayBentonite

High activity clay (CEC 96)

yield @ 15 t/ha, 5 yrs ↑ Na and B @ 40 t/ha X biomass

Amendments trialled

Amendment

Description

ClayBentonite

ClayHydrotalcite

High activity clay (CEC 96)

Pot Trial

Field Trial

Positive charge, can adsorb nitrate, sulfate, phosphate

↑ Na and B @ 40 t/ha X biomass

↓ plant P uptake

X yield @ 15 t/ha, 5 yrs

X yield @ 10 t/ha, 5 years

Amendments trialled

Amendment

Description

ClayBentonite

ClayHydrotalcite

High activity clay (CEC 96)

Pot Trial

Field Trial

Ironman Gypsum

Positive charge, can adsorb nitrate, sulfate, phosphate

By-product with high Fe and Mn

↑ Na and B @ 40 t/ha X biomass

↓ plant P uptake

X yield @ 15 t/ha, 5 yrs

X biomass X OC

X yield @ 10 t/ha, 5 years

X yield at 10-30 t/ha, 5 years

Amendments trialled

Amendment

Description

ClayBentonite

ClayHydrotalcite

Ironman Gypsum

High activity clay (CEC 96)

Pot Trial

Field Trial

Positive charge, can adsorb nitrate, sulfate, phosphate

By-product with high Fe and Mn

Reactive commercial adsorbent Zeolite

↑ Na and B @ 40 t/ha X biomass

↓ plant P uptake

X yield @ 15 t/ha, 5 yrs

X biomass

X OC

↑ water @ 20 t/ha,

↓ leaching N, P, K,

↑ biomass @ 10-15 t/ha

X yield @ 10 t/ha, 5 years

X yield at 10-30 t/ha, 5 years

↑ yield wheat @ 15 t/ha in year 5

Amendments trialled

Amendment

Description

ClayBentonite

ClayHydrotalcite

High activity clay (CEC 96)

Pot Trial

Field Trial

Ironman Gypsum

Positive charge, can adsorb nitrate, sulfate, phosphate

By-product with high Fe and Mn

Reactive commercial adsorbent Zeolite

↑ Na and B @ 40 t/ha

X biomass

↓ plant P uptake

X yield @ 15 t/ha, 5 yrs

X yield @ 10 t/ha, 5 years

X biomass

X OC

↑ water @ 20 t/ha

↓ leaching N, P, K

↑ biomass @ 10-15 t/ha

X yield at 10-30 t/ha, 5 years

↑ yield wheat @ 15 t/ha in year 5

Composthumicarb

Humus rich product

↑ water @ 20 t/ha

↑ biomass @ 10 t/ha

↑ yield wheat (0.7 t/ha) @ 10 t/ha in year 5

Reflections from West Midlands Group Trial

• Deep amelioration can improve crop establishment for multiple years

• Seasonal effects matter, but the structural gains persist

• Amendments can help, but they are more season-dependent 5 seasons of amelioration and amendments (2021)

https://wmgroup.org.au/four-years-on-soil-amelioration-still-delivering-plantestablishment-gains/

Take homes for new amendments for sandy soils

• Clay-rich subsoil is still the most available and reliable amendment

• Other amendments are still a work in progress

• The challenge is working out where and how they can be used cost effectively

• Match your amendment to the soil constraint

Slide from: Richard Bell

amanda.schapel@sa.gov.au

soilcrc.com.au

SoilCRC

Soil_CRC soilcrc3649

CRC for High Performance Soils Limited

ABN 63 618 897 224

Thanks to Richard Bell, Murdoch University and the project team for the New amendments for sandy soils project for sharing of the latest results and many of the slides used in the presentation

Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook