RESPONSIBLE AI LAB
BENDING THE ARC
Insights and Imperatives from the 2026 NFHA Responsible AI Symposium Zero Gap: Aligning AI with Civil and Human Rights Washington, D.C. | March 30 – April 1, 2026 Published November 2026
Bending the Arc: 2026 NFHA Responsible AI Symposium
Table of Contents Acknowledgements .......................................................................................................................... 3 Executive Summary ......................................................................................................................... 4 Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 6 Major Themes of the Symposium ................................................................................................... 8 1. Compliant and Ethical Are Not One and the Same ......................................................................... 8 2. Disparate Impact is an Indispensable Framework ........................................................................... 10 3. Federal Retreat and the Rise of State Action ..................................................................................... 11 4. Agentic AI is Outpacing Governance .................................................................................................. 12 5. Principles vs. Rules ................................................................................................................................. 13 6. AI’s Dual Nature ....................................................................................................................................... 14 7.
AI Infrastructure is a Civil Rights Issue ............................................................................................... 15
8. AI and Economic Justice ..................................................................................................................... 15 9. International Governance Fragmentation .......................................................................................... 16 10. AI is the next frontier of Civil Rights ............................................................................................. 18 Recommendations and the 2027 Symposium ............................................................................. 19
To review the 2026 Symposium Agenda, click here or visit bit.ly/RAIS2026-Agenda
NFHA Chief AI Officer and Head of Responsible AI Lab Dr. Michael Akinwumi and General Counsel Janell Byrd-Chichester in conversation with NJ Attorney General Jennifer Davenport and staff.
2
National Fair Housing Alliance | Responsible AI Lab | nationalfairhousing.org
Acknowledgements
Acknowledgements The National Fair Housing Alliance (NFHA) would like to acknowledge all of the Symposium presenters and Pitch Competition participants for lending their time, wisdom, and talent to this important convening. Without the participation of these experts, the Symposium would not have been a success. The insights shared during the convening will inform local, state, and federal policy; industry practices; and research agendas for years to come. We are grateful to everyone who played a role in the Symposium, especially our amazing staff who were dedicated to ensuring the event’s success. NFHA would also like to thank our Symposium Sponsors. Without the generous support of Airbnb, Bilt, Cotality, Google, JPMorganChase, Meta, National Association of Realtors®, Nationwide, Rocket Mortgage, Truist, and Zillow, this event would not have been possible.
Staff of the National Fair Housing Alliance.
RAIS 26 brought together a broad-based group of representatives from civil rights, financial services, public policy, entertainment, academia, and technology. 3
Bending the Arc: 2026 NFHA Responsible AI Symposium
Executive Summary The 2026 National Fair Housing Alliance (NFHA) Responsible AI Symposium was held March 30 through April 1, 2026, in Washington, D.C., under the theme Zero Gap: Aligning AI with Civil and Human Rights. The third annual Symposium was convened against the backdrop of the U.S. approaching its 250th anniversary and as the global AI race is outpacing democratic deliberation and regulation. It was in this context that we gathered civil rights experts, fair housing advocates, technologists, federal and state regulators, members of Congress, philanthropic leaders, financial market leaders, entrepreneurs, academics, artists, and affected community members for an intersectoral conversation. The 2026 Symposium interrogated a single defining question: Can the AI race have a meaningful ending if it does not align with civil and human rights?
Ten major themes emerged across the three days of the Symposium: 1. Compliant and Ethical Are Not One and the Same
Ethical leadership must be built upstream of deployment, not retrofitted after the fact.
2. Disparate Impact is an Indispensable Framework
Discriminatory effect is a necessary mechanism that makes algorithmic accountability operable.
3. Federal Retreat and the Rise of State Action
States, along with the courts and civil society, are now the load-bearing governance institutions in the sphere of responsible AI.
4. Agentic AI is Outpacing Governance
Autonomous AI agents compound bias risk and create liability questions left unaddressed by legal and governance frameworks.
5. Principles vs. Rules
A central, unresolved tension exists between adaptive principles-based governance and enforceable rules-based governance.
4
6. AI’s Dual Nature
AI can either deepen or close societal gaps; the choice is not inevitable.
7. AI Infrastructure is a Civil Rights Issue Data center construction and location, energy pricing, and environmental impacts produce real-world dilemmas of fairness.
8. AI and Economic Justice
AI risks exacerbating wealth and income inequality without proactive policy that centers humanity.
9. International Governance Fragmentation The shift from multilateral collaboration to nationalist and geopolitical competition endangers civil and human rights.
10. AI is the next frontier of Civil Rights
AI governance is not a new domain; it is the current front of a long struggle to bend our society’s moral arc toward justice.
National Fair Housing Alliance | Responsible AI Lab | nationalfairhousing.org
Executive Summary
The Symposium opened with a special screening of Look Up Now, a documentary produced by Emmy award-winning director, Chris Nolan. The three-day convening featured insights from leading policymakers working to develop regulations to ensure effective oversight of AI as well as technologists on the cutting edge of developing AI systems. Leading academics shared their latest research and thoughts about the risks and benefits of AI. And civil and human rights experts discussed how to ensure AI is human-centered and can benefit everyone in society. During the Symposium, experts explored the latest developments in AI in an effort to dispel the myth that there is an inherent trade-off between advancing civil rights and spurring innovation. Tensions surfaced: between innovation speed and deliberative safety; between principles-based and rules-based governance; between multilateral AI governance and nationalist competition; between philanthropic optimism and the scale of documented harm in tenant screening, rental pricing, automated valuation models, and other systems. Speakers emphasized that the goals of AI innovation and advancing civil and human rights can be mutually reinforcing with planning, intentionality, foresight, effective laws, appropriate governance frameworks, and an ethics-centered approach to developing and deploying AI. Presenters noted that when we prioritize fairness and access in technological development, we foster more trustworthy, widely beneficial innovations that better serve society. The Symposium concluded with a Responsible AI Pitch Competition featuring five AI startups showcasing their innovations around AI-driven tools that promote fair housing and lending, fairness, and improving AI governance. The Pitch Competition was moderated by Emmy award-winning reporter and NFHA Senior Advisor for Communications, Marketing, and Education, Julian Glover. This report highlights major themes that emerged throughout discussions and presentations held at the 2026 Symposium. It describes the engaging discussions and debates of experts who explored how AI can advance fairness, expand opportunities, and promote innovation. Looking forward, NFHA announced that the 2027 Responsible AI Symposium will center on Keeping Humans in Control as AI agents are increasingly used across home searches, finances, managing health records, and digital identities. The central question of next year’s Symposium is no longer whether AI will be governed, but whose values will govern it.
From left: Julian Glover (NFHA), Anna-Lysa Gayle (news anchor), Christopher Nolan (Emmy-winning director), Malik Yoba (actor and entrepreneur), Thema Monroe-White, Ph.D. (George Mason University), and Elizabeth Vella Moeller (AI Trust Foundation for Beneficial AI).
5
Bending the Arc: 2026 NFHA Responsible AI Symposium
Introduction The 2026 Responsible AI Symposium convened at an inflection point. Generative AI has moved from demonstration to deployment across housing, financial services, healthcare, employment, transportation, the environment, and criminal justice. Agentic systems, AI tools that break down goals into tasks and execute these with minimal human supervision, have entered the consumer market, reshaping how governments operate, how industries function, and how people live their everyday lives. The geopolitical frame around AI has shifted decisively from collaboration to competition, with the U.S., China, the continent of Africa, and the European Union pursuing divergent governance philosophies. Domestically, federal civil rights enforcement infrastructure has been significantly weakened: disparate impact enforcement at the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) and Department of Justice (DOJ) has been curtailed, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s (CFPB) capacity has been diminished, regulators are withdrawing from meaningful oversight of AI and cryptocurrencies, and Regulation B interpretive changes have, in some cases, narrowed the Equal Credit Opportunity Act’s (ECOA) reach. A comprehensive federal AI law has not been enacted, and efforts to preempt state AI regulation remain a live legislative threat. It was against this backdrop that Lisa Rice (NFHA) and Dr. Michael Akinwumi (NFHA) opened the Symposium with a challenge framed around America’s then-upcoming 250th anniversary: whether the country’s AI race can have a meaningful ending if it is not aligned with the civil and human rights commitments the nation has spent two and a half centuries struggling, incompletely, to honor.
“Artificial intelligence represents the next great technological inflection point. It is already shaping access to housing, credit, employment, healthcare, and education. It is influencing who is seen, who is valued, and who has a fair shot at success. And that brings us to a defining question for this next chapter of our national journey. Will AI widen the gaps of the past or help us finally close them?” - Lisa Rice, NFHA President & CEO
The opening framed the entire Symposium as an exercise in moving from identifying risks to building actionable solutions, with NFHA’s Responsible AI Lab (RAIL) serving as a bridge between principle and practice. Achieving responsible AI is not a technical challenge alone but a whole-of-society effort requiring the integrated expertise of civil rights professionals, academics, policymakers, industry players, everyday people and others. The Symposium’s theme — Zero Gap — signals an imperative that without
6
National Fair Housing Alliance | Responsible AI Lab | nationalfairhousing.org
Introduction
intentional alignment, AI will automate and amplify biases and inequities, undermining decades of hard-won civil rights progress and harming people and communities in the process. NFHA’s role as convener is distinctive. NFHA is the only national civil rights or“Should the AI race that America is involved ganization dedicated to building inclusive, in right now respect alignment with civil well-resourced, resilient communities where people can thrive, expanding equitable rights and human rights? Think about opportunities, and eliminating housing diswhat could go wrong…Then think about crimination. It is also the only national civil what could go right when that AI race is rights organization with an AI lab that concentered on alignment, centered on the ducts research, advocates for responsible values that we all have within our societies.” AI policies, innovates to build trustworthy AI tools, and helps advance the law. NFHA oc— Dr. Michael Akinwumi, NFHA Chief AI cupies ground few other institutions can — Officer & Head of the Responsible AI Lab translating between civil rights laws, technology practices, industry operations, and community experiences. The Symposium is designed to be a working convening, not a ceremonial one: to surface tensions and challenges, share and examine perspectives, discuss solutions, and move the field toward enforceable standards — all in an effort to improve people’s lives.
Christoph Mügge-Durum & Hana Samad, AI governance researchers at the National Fair Housing Alliance. 7
Bending the Arc: 2026 NFHA Responsible AI Symposium
Major Themes from the 2026 Symposium Ten themes emerged as the central, cross-cutting perspectives of the convening. These themes are drawn from the panel discussions, candid conversations with industry leaders, and keynote addresses featured throughout the Symposium.
Theme 1: Compliant and Ethical Are Not One and the Same A persistent theme across the Symposium was that organizations leveraging AI must look beyond compliance and incorporate ethics into their systems. Legal compliance, while necessary, should not be treated as the ceiling. A company can be fully compliant with every applicable law and still cause measurable harm to the people and communities it serves. The Symposium opened with the screening of the documentary, Look Up Now, followed by an insightful discussion moderated by Emmy award-winning reporter Anna-Lysa Gayle with remarks from the Emmy award-winning director of the film, Christopher Nolan, Elizabeth Vella Moeller (AI Trust Foundation for Beneficial AI), Malik Yoba (Award-winning actor and Entrepreneur), and Thema Monroe-White, Ph.D. (George Mason). The panel emphasized that responsible AI requires going beyond compliance to active ethical engagement. Participants stressed that compliance alone cannot prevent harm; organizations must proactively assess bias, transparency, and real-world impacts. Key themes from the discussion included educating users that AI is not “magic,” embedding values into design is necessary, and anticipating harms before deployment is critical. Ethical responsibility involves cross-sector collaboration, regulatory awareness, and public engagement. Ultimately, individuals, institutions, and governments must understand, question, and shape AI systems — rather than passively rely on them — to ensure they align with human values and avoid reinforcing existing inequities. During the Beyond Compliance panel discussion, Renee Cummings, Ph.D., (University of Virginia), Dominique Harrison, Ph.D., (Equity Innovations Ventures), and Will Fleisher, Ph.D., (Georgetown University) drew a sharp line between compliant AI and ethical AI. Compliance asks, “Are we allowed to do this?” whereas ethical AI examines “should we do this?” Fleisher pointed out the failure in using just one measurement of fairness to determine legal compliance. He suggested using a variety of fairness tools to ensure systems are both compliant and ethical.
“Ethical AI is being proactive and…compliance is reactive.” — Dominique Harrison, Ph.D., Equity Innovations Ventures
8
National Fair Housing Alliance | Responsible AI Lab | nationalfairhousing.org
Major Themes
From Left: John Rogers (Cotality), Lisa Rice (NFHA), Dr. Michael Akinwumi (NFHA), Vilas Dhar (Patrick J. McGovern Foundation), and Nikitra Bailey (NFHA).
Patrick J. McGovern Foundation President Vilas Dhar reinforced this idea in his fireside chat with Dr. Michael Akinwumi, arguing that AI is currently being used to offload moral responsibility, widening the accountability gap in consequential decisions. He cited tenant screening algorithms as a prime example where often no identifiable human decision-maker exists when everyday people are excluded from housing, leaving tenants with little recourse to provide corrective information or plead their case. Dhar proposed three enforceable pillars of accountability that go beyond compliance: a right to explanation (so affected individuals understand why a decision was made), a right to contest (so they can challenge it), and clear legal liability (so someone is responsible if something goes wrong). He called for pre-deployment audits analogous to consumer product safety testing — a shift from post-hoc impact assessments.
“AI is offloading critical decisions in our economic infrastructure— decisions that used to be the domain of people—to automated systems. In doing so, they are offsetting moral responsibility and offsetting accountability for outcomes, and what results is an intentional weakening of the accountability gap.” — Vilas Dhar, Patrick J. McGovern Foundation President
A separate panel on AI Governance and Corporate Social Responsibility, featuring Dr. Shanika Hope (Google), Jennifer Butler (Zillow), Leah Perry (Box), Shannon Terry (Nationwide), and Chancela Al-Mansour (Housing Rights Center), discussed the symbiotic relationship between building strong governance protocols and doing the right thing. Terry noted that he thinks about governance and corporate responsibility in terms of four pillars: structure, process, standards, and culture. Terry emphasized the importance of value alignment and culture and that these mutually reinforcing components help ensure a company has good practices and protocols. Perry explained the importance of the National Institute of Standards and Technology’s (NIST) risk management framework and including impact assessments as a part of good governance to ensure companies have sound protocols and understand how their products will affect people and society.
9
Bending the Arc: 2026 NFHA Responsible AI Symposium
Butler pointed out the potential bias that can often be incorporated in queries that people make when using generative AI models commenting that companies should make efforts to debias systems as much as possible. Zillow’s Fair Housing Classifier, which is open source, helps achieve this goal. Hope explained the importance of continual testing and monitoring and making sure those insights are used to improve model performance. She highlighted Google’s Secure AI Framework which is also open source and comes with a best practices guide that helps users think intentionally about how to best utilize data as well as build and deploy systems responsibly. Panelists concluded that ethical commitments must be more than aspirational statements — they must be embedded in tangible objectives such as key performance indicators, audit requirements, and corporate incentive structures to achieve measurable impact.
“As a self-described ‘old dog’… I get to choose with whom I work, and it’s important that you work at a company that aligns with your own personal values. You need value alignment and the reinforcement of that culture to make all the other things work.” — Shannon Terry, Nationwide
From left: Leah Perry (Box), Chancela Al-Mansour (Housing Rights Center), Shannon Terry (Nationwide), Jennifer Butler (Zillow), Shanika Hope, Ph.D. (Google), and Lisa Rice (NFHA).
Theme 2: Disparate Impact is an Indispensable Framework Throughout the Symposium, disparate impact was a frequently cited legal and analytical framework for ensuring AI systems are trustworthy. The panel dedicated to the topic featuring Roy Austin (Howard Law Artificial Intelligence Initiative), Jonice Gray (Paul Hastings), and Sasha Samberg-Champion (NFHA) made the case that without the disparate impact doctrine, AI systems whose decision logic is proprietary or technically opaque become effectively ungovernable. Intent-based discrimination doctrines require proof of discriminatory purpose, which machine-learning models cannot easily provide due to their inherent black-box nature. Disparate
10
National Fair Housing Alliance | Responsible AI Lab | nationalfairhousing.org
Major Themes
impact analysis asks if a policy or system that appears neutral on its face unnecessarily harms a protected class, is there a legitimate business need and justification for the policy or system, and if so, is there a less discriminatory alternative. It is, therefore, the mechanism that makes Dhar’s proposed three enforceable pillars of accountability legally reachable. Gray, Austin, and Samberg-Champion discussed the current federal retrenchment on disparate impact, which includes directives from federal agencies to abstain from enforcing disparate impact; attempts to remove it as a basis for liability under the Equal Credit Opportunity Act; and the weakening of fair lending oversight at HUD, DOJ, and CFPB. They emphasized that this retrenchment does not eliminate the disparate impact tool. Instead, the center of gravity shifts to state attorneys general and private litigants, both of whom remain active. New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport reinforced this argument “The upshot of it is, you follow the law. You do in her special conversation with NFHA what’s right. Most companies that I am dealing General Counsel Janell Byrd-Chichester. New Jersey has formally incorwith don’t want to just follow a law because porated algorithmic discrimination they’re going to get in trouble if they don’t and disparate impact analysis into its abide by the law. They want to do what is right.” Law Against Discrimination guidance. New Jersey also joined a coalition of — Jonice Gray, Paul Hastings Partner & Chair of 36 states and U.S. territories, including Consumer Financial Services Massachusetts, Arizona, American Samoa, Ohio, North Carolina, and Tennessee in opposing federal preemption of state AI laws. There was also bipartisan Congressional opposition to proposals for federal preemption. This signals that the governance architecture, absent federal leadership, will be led by the states.
Theme 3: Federal Retreat and the Rise of State Action A consequential structural shift identified at the Symposium was the weakening of federal civil rights enforcement. This elevates states, courts, and civil rights organizations as load-bearing governance institutions. Michael S. Barr, Member of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, warned of “collective amnesia” regarding the potential weakening of financial guardrails. In his video address, U.S. Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland criticized the current administration’s retrenchment. The panel on legislative activity in the 119th Congress, moderated by Nikitra Bailey (NFHA) with remarks from Paul Thornell (Mehlman Consulting), Alejandra Montoya-Boyer (Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights), Claudia Ruiz (UnidosUS) and Jon Adame (Mehlman Consulting), assessed that the U.S. House and U.S. Senate are unlikely to pass major AI legislation in the current legislative session. A strong area of consensus was opposition to federal preemption of state AI laws — an alignment that reflects both the absence of federal leadership and the recognition that states are where meaningful near-term governance will occur. New Jersey’s AI Innovation Lab, with dedicated enforcement capacity and public education programming, was cited as a replicable model. AG Davenport pointed out that states are committed to protecting their residents against deep fakes, voice clones, algorithmic bias, and the use of AI to sexually exploit children. She
11
Bending the Arc: 2026 NFHA Responsible AI Symposium
noted the importance of the state’s guidance on disparate impact in helping stakeholders have a clear understanding of how people in the state are protected.
“We make sure that…as technology emerges and as there are different ways for discrimination to occur, that’s captured [in the law] so that we can: A) educate the public about what their rights are; and B) have the tools at our disposal to…hold actors accountable. As we see the federal government stepping back…we [the states] are seen as the primary place where people can have their voice heard and there can be action taken to protect them.” — New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport
Policymakers and philanthropic leaders, including Vilas Dhar, argued that the current moment requires civil society to function as a parallel enforcement infrastructure — funding technical and legal capacity inside state attorneys general offices and the advocacy organizations that support them. The implication for companies: the civil rights liability horizon has not shortened because federal enforcement has weakened. Long statutes of limitations mean that present-day deregulation does not eliminate future accountability.
Theme 4: Agentic AI Is Outpacing Governance The panel on agentic AI — featuring moderator Stephen Hayes (Relman Colfax PLLC), Christine Graham (JPMorganChase), Delicia Reynolds Hand (Consumer Reports), and Amber Thomson (Mayer Brown) — framed autonomous AI agents as the most urgent governance challenge on the horizon. Most organizations, the panel observed, are exploring agent development while still struggling to govern these novel systems. The panel covered the governance gaps specific to agentic systems which are distinct from those of point-in-time decision models. Agentic systems make continuous micro-decisions, each of which may be individually legal and facially neutral but might cumulatively perpetuate
From left: Amber Thomson (Mayer Brown), Christine Graham (JPMorganChase), Delicia Reynolds Hand (Consumer Reports), and Stephen Hayes (Relman Colfax). 12
National Fair Housing Alliance | Responsible AI Lab | nationalfairhousing.org
Major Themes
discrimination in violation of the law. Traditional model risk management frameworks designed for static models are insufficient to comprehensively capture this dynamic. Additionally, security vulnerabilities — particularly prompt injection, in which malicious inputs cause agents to act against users’ interests — are inherent to the transformer-based architectures powering state-of-the-art AI agents. The panel identified loyalty ambiguity as a central unresolved question: whose interests does an agent serve — the consumer’s, the platform’s, or the lender’s? Panelists called for continuous real-time monitoring, clear human accountability chains, and consumer education that does not shift the burden of safety onto users. Panelists also explored low-hanging fruit — easy, less-risky tasks that can increase efficiencies, for example, providing AI-fueled support for customer-facing employees who can have information at the ready to help improve the customer’s experience.
“A lot of clients are agentic curious, but they are not agentic ready.” — Amber Thomson, Mayer Brown LLP
“How can you improve the speed and accuracy of your back-office processes? How do you make sure that your customer-facing employees have the right information at their fingertips so people that are seeking help can actually be routed in an effective way?” — Christine Graham, JPMorganChase
Theme 5: Principles vs. Rules A fault line that ran through the Symposium was the tension between principles-based and rules-based approaches to AI governance. Victoria Luxardo Jeffries (Meta), in her fireside chat with Dr. Akinwumi, articulated the industry case for principles-based governance: AI models evolve faster than rules can be written, and adaptable principles produce more robust safety outcomes than rigid rulesets that quickly become obsolete. Against this, multiple speakers — from Samberg-Champion and Gray to AG Davenport to Senator Chris Van Hollen — consistently argued that enforceable standards, not principles, are what make civil rights actionable. A company committed to the principle of fairness that deploys a discriminatory algorithm has not violated its principles; it has simply defined fairness in a way that excludes accountability. Rules with teeth — liability, audit requirements, contestability rights — are the mechanism that turns principles into protection. Dr. Michael Akinwumi (NFHA) and Victoria Luxardo Jeffries (Meta).
13
Bending the Arc: 2026 NFHA Responsible AI Symposium
Former Acting Comptroller of the Currency Michael Hsu captured the regulatory dimension by arguing regulators need to think like engineers, building proactive safety features (“antilock brakes”) into systems rather than relying solely on human intervention after problems materialize.
Theme 6: AI’s Dual Nature Throughout the Symposium, AI was consistently framed as a technology with dual potential — capable of both deepening existing societal wounds and helping to close them. The documentary screened on the event’s opening night, Look Up Now: AI and the Future of Humanity, posed this as the defining question of this moment. Thema Monroe-White, Ph.D., grounded it in data: AI models are biased, in measurable, multi-standard-deviation terms, against marginalized groups. Speakers throughout the Symposium documented a range of deployed AI harms: tenant screening algorithms that create discriminatory barriers through categorical criminal history bans and housing choice voucher exclusions; algorithmic rent-setting tools that drive up market rents; biased appraisal systems trained on historically discriminatory data; credit scoring and automated underwriting systems that bake in and normalize biases in the marketplace; and chatbots that reject housing voucher holders. These systems have been deployed against the backdrop of an almost unmanageable fair and affordable housing crisis — 3.6 million eviction filings annually, a 7.2-million unit affordable housing shortage, increased homelessness, and a declining homeownership rate for excluded and underserved populations. But presenters also highlighted some benefits of AI. Housing justice leaders and the Responsible AI Pitch Competition showcased concrete affirmative applications: AI tools that predict and prevent evictions before they occur; chatbots that allow understaffed homelessness agencies to query complex datasets in plain language; tools that scan listings for discriminatory language; and distribution-matching techniques that have demonstrably reduced mortgage pricing disparities by up to 20 percent. The co-buying platform PairGap, winner of the Pitch Competition, uses AI to make home“[Cotality] is building resiliency scores [to ownership accessible to underserved help identify] what to do for every single households. The platform streamlines home to make it more resilient to natural the co-buying process to give unmarried partners or co-investors a pathway to hazards like floods, wildfires and hurricanes. unlock the American Dream of homeNot only does this lower the physical risk of ownership. Industry representatives the home it will lower insurance premiums also highlighted the benefits of AI. John which is the hot potato issue in the US putting Rogers (Cotality) described how the company provided NFHA with a data further pressure on housing affordability.” grant to help support groundbreaking — John Rogers, Cotality research on innovative algorithmic fairness techniques and other ways the company is leaning into responsible AI.
14
National Fair Housing Alliance | Responsible AI Lab | nationalfairhousing.org
Major Themes
Theme 7: AI Infrastructure is a Civil Rights Issue One of the Symposium’s most distinctive and robust discussions was around the physical infrastructure required to power AI — data centers, energy systems, electrical grids, and water systems. Presenters elevated concerns around the siting and building of data centers as a present-day civil rights issue rather than ancillary engineering or economic development issues. The panel on data centers, featuring Michael Turner (Loudoun County Supervisor), Chenise Anthony (Metro Memphis Fair Housing Center), Lili Gangas (Kapor Foundation) and Darija Cosic (Meta), documented the complexities around both the challenges and benefits of data centers. Turner discussed the on-the-ground reality. In his Virginia community, there are more than 200 data centers within a 30 square mile area, with by-right development provisions that left local officials unable to regulate siting before decisions were made. The cost-shifting pattern, in which residential ratepayers subsidize grid infrastructure as well as electric and water utilization, was identified as a distributional justice issue. Senator Van Hollen’s keynote highlighted his Power for the People Act which would require data center developers, rather than residential consumers, to pay for the electric grid infrastructure and energy generation their facilities demand. Cosic explained how some technology companies are trying to be responsible citizens. She presented Meta’s sustainability commitments — 100 percent clean energy and water-positive status by 2030 — while acknowledging that local pushback against data center siting is increasing across jurisdictions. Gangas framed the issue directly as a civil rights concern. She pointed to the reality that siting decisions often disproportionately affect low-income communities and communities of color, reflecting that community voice in decision-making processes has been severely weakened. Federal Reserve Governor Michael Barr identified energy demand from data centers as a macroeconomic risk factor. Congresswoman Valerie Foushee identified it as a legislative priority. The Symposium consensus: AI’s physical infrastructure is inseparable from its civil rights implications.
Theme 8: AI and Economic Justice The conversation between Governor Michael Barr and Marc Morial (National Urban League) brought a macroeconomic dimension to the Symposium’s civil rights framing. Barr argued that AI, absent affirmative policy intervention, could exacerbate wealth and income inequality — compressing labor demand in sectors that disproportionately employ low-income workers while concentrating returns among technology-owning capital holders. Morial identified what he called “yellow lights” for the American economy — rising Black unemployment, near-zero net job creation, tariff-driven inflation pressures, and the weakening of regulatory guardrails that protect communities of color in capital markets. He introduced the National Urban League’s Project Genius, an initiative focused on using AI for internal organizational management, workforce development for AI-created jobs, and advocacy for civil-rightsaligned AI regulation. Both speakers expressed concern about “collective amnesia” — the pattern in which deregulation proceeds while guardrails are dismantled, and the next crisis emerges in the gap before
15
Bending the Arc: 2026 NFHA Responsible AI Symposium
the connection is made. Barr called for smart, pro-innovation regulation implemented before problems materialize. The Symposium’s broader argument — that civil rights enforcement is a precondition for capital market integrity, not a constraint upon it — found its clearest expression in the exchange between Governor Barr and Marc Morial.
Marc Morial (National Urban League) and Gov. Michael Barr (Federal Reserve)
“In history, you see these cycles of forgetfulness, collective amnesia…You have to guard against that kind of amnesia blocking society from putting in place the guardrails that are needed…And we can do all that while being pro-innovation. There’s not a conflict between those things.” — Governor Michael Barr, Federal Reserve Theme 9: International Governance Fragmentation The AI Without Borders panel discussed how the collaborative, multilateral approach that once defined international AI policy has begun to break down. Over the past year, the global landscape has shifted significantly. The European Union has moved toward comprehensive, rightsbased regulation with the EU AI Act, while China has adopted a state-controlled model with strong safeguards on deepfakes and algorithmic content. In stark contrast, the U.S. has stepped back from broad federal regulation, relaxing what few standards it did have, favoring more piecemeal, sector-by-sector approaches, and leaning in heavily on competition. Nasir Yammama (Senior Special Assistant to the President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria) described Nigeria’s predicament in stark terms. The country built its AI strategy on assumptions of multilateral collaboration which no longer hold. Nigeria is now focusing on application-layer innovation and language sovereignty, including the Nigerian AI Atlas initiative. The broader concern, expressed by Tomo Lazovich (Brown University) and Margaret Hu (William & Mary),
16
National Fair Housing Alliance | Responsible AI Lab | nationalfairhousing.org
Major Themes
“When ChatGPT came out, the entire discourse changed…No matter who we [The White House] were talking to, it rapidly became clear as we were trying to figure out how to govern this technology, that it could not happen without global cooperation. This is a technology that spans borders…The watchword was always ‘collaboration.’” — Ami Fields-Meyer, Senior Fellow, Harvard Kennedy School and Former White House Senior Policy Advisor
is that abandoning multilateralism concentrates AI governance power among a small number of tech leaders in a small number of countries. Panelists identified the erosion of a shared human rights vocabulary in AI governance and the exclusion of the Global South from innovation ecosystems as serious risks. When national security and global competition frames crowd out human rights frames, the tools for cross-jurisdictional accountability — historically treaties, shared standards, enforcement cooperation, and collaborative research — deteriorate. Hu warned that the central governance question is whether AI will govern the law or the law will govern AI. The sources of hope the presenters identified were litigation brought by civil rights organizations, grassroots advocacy, and the potential for renewed multilateral commitment as the costs of fragmentation become more visible.
From left: Ami Fields-Meyer (Harvard Kennedy School), Nasir Yammama (Office of the President of Nigeria), Margaret Hu (William & Mary), and Tomo Lazovich (Brown University).
17
Bending the Arc: 2026 NFHA Responsible AI Symposium
Theme 10: AI is the next frontier of Civil Rights Framing AI governance as the next frontier of civil rights was the through-line of the entire Symposium, from Rice’s opening remarks to Dr. Akinwumi’s close. Rice situated the convening at the threshold of America’s 250th anniversary, a moment to ask whether the nation’s AI development will honor or betray the civil rights commitments it has spent 250 years struggling, incompletely, to fulfill. Akinwumi closed the Symposium by recognizing the start of Fair Housing Month, which marks the signing of the 1968 Fair Housing Act. He charged attendees to turn insight into action. The argument advanced across the Symposium was that AI governance does not require a new moral vocabulary. The U.S. already possesses the legal frameworks — the Fair Housing Act, the Equal Credit Opportunity Act, Title VII, the Community Reinvestment Act — and the civil rights doctrine, including disparate impact, needed to govern AI. The question is whether those tools will be applied, enforced, and extended, or whether this AI moment will be treated as a domain where existing civil rights obligations do not reach. When Dr. Akinwumi opened the Symposium by asking whether America’s AI race should be aligned with civil and human rights, the answer that emerged over the three-day convening was unambiguous: yes — and there is no version of responsible AI that settles for less. The message from the Symposium was clear and consistent: there is no AI exception to civil and human rights. This is not a technical challenge that engineers alone can solve. It is a defining moral test — one that demands courage, leadership, and an unwavering commitment to the proposition that the people AI affects most must be the people it serves best.
“We must reject the false choice between innovation and equity.” — Senator Chris Van Hollen
18
National Fair Housing Alliance | Responsible AI Lab | nationalfairhousing.org
Looking Forward
Recommendations and the 2027 Symposium The 2026 Responsible AI Symposium covered substantial and weighty ground. The recommendations that follow are drawn from the cross-cutting themes identified above, implications highlighted throughout the convening, and specific solutions and proposals advanced by speakers. The recommendations are organized around the actors — policymakers, companies, civil rights groups, and philanthropy — who must implement them.
For Policymakers • Build state-level enforcement capacity as the primary near-term governance layer. Federal retrenchment and the low probability of federal AI legislation in the 119th Congress mean that state attorneys general, state legislatures, and state regulatory agencies will be the primary enforcement and oversight instruments for the foreseeable future. The New Jersey AI Innovation Lab — with dedicated algorithmic discrimination guidance under the Law Against Discrimination — offers a replicable model. • Preserve and extend disparate impact doctrine across jurisdictions. Disparate impact is the best mechanism that makes algorithmic discrimination legally reachable. States should codify it into AI-specific statutory guidance, and companies should treat it as a compliance standard regardless of the current federal enforcement posture, given the long statutes of limitations in existing laws. • Require pre- and post-deployment audits and enforceable contestability rights for high-risk AI systems. The right to explanation, the right to contest, and clear legal liability should be codified for AI systems operating in housing, lending, insurance, employment, education, healthcare, and criminal justice. Pre- and post-deployment auditing should be a default expectation, not a voluntary practice. • Treat data center infrastructure decisions as civil rights decisions. Legislative models that shift infrastructure cost from residential ratepayers to developers should be advanced. Local jurisdictions should reconsider by-right development provisions for hyperscale facilities, and Community Benefits Agreements should be standard rather than the exception. • Reject federal preemption of state AI laws in the absence of comprehensive federal legislation. The consensus against preemption reflects both the absence of federal leadership and the recognition that state-level protections are the operative civil rights governance layer future federal law should build upon.
For AI Companies • Shift from reactive compliance to proactive ethics-by-design frameworks. Empowering internal review boards with diverse expertise — civil rights, social science, affected community representatives — and giving those voices actual authority rather than consultative roles is the minimum standard for serious commitment. • Implement continuous, dynamic monitoring for agentic systems. Traditional model risk management is insufficient for agents that make ongoing micro-decisions. 19
Bending the Arc: 2026 NFHA Responsible AI Symposium
Real-time monitoring, clear human accountability chains, and explicit loyalty designations are required. • Publish plain-language disclosures for consumer-facing AI agents. Users interacting with agents in housing, lending, insurance, or employment decisions deserve to know whose interests the agent serves and what data it collects. The burden of safety cannot rest primarily on consumers and everyday people. • Treat existing civil rights obligations as opportunities, not constraints. Companies that view Fair Housing Act and Equal Credit Opportunity Act compliance as burdens are misreading the business case and missing outcomes that expand the addressable commercial market.
For Civil Rights Organizations • Partner with state agencies to collaborate on ways to develop, advance and implement responsible AI policies. • Use AI offensively as well as defensively. The Symposium documented numerous examples of AI being used to detect discrimination — scanning listings for discriminatory language, analyzing Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA) data for redlining indicators, and testing chatbots to uncover bias. Civil rights organizations should build or establish partnerships with universities, labs, and others to develop these capabilities. • Invest in AI literacy that goes beyond prompt engineering. Dr. Monroe-White’s call for genuine AI literacy — understanding how models function, what bias looks like at multiple standard deviations — is a precondition for meaningful democratic deliberation about AI governance. • Partner with technology firms, local jurisdictions, academics and other stakeholders to develop and implement Community Benefits Agreements to ensure people and communities are not harmed by and can benefit from the development of data centers.
For Philanthropy • Fund technical and legal capacity inside civil rights organizations, labs, and other organizations with expertise to effectively advance responsible AI principles and practices. Philanthropy plays a distinctive role in providing a blueprint for action — building the infrastructure of litigators, researchers, and organizations that can hold entities accountable when regulators cannot or will not. • Support efforts to operationalize and implement equitable and responsible AI protocols. Invest in tools, frameworks, and pilot initiatives to actualize solutions that will ensure technology is used for good. • Fund organizations that develop and deploy responsible AI tools and systems that expand access to credit, reduce bias, and empower consumers with data insights. • Support open-source tools, systems, and frameworks.
The 2027 Responsible AI Symposium: Keeping Humans in Control NFHA announced at the close of the 2026 Symposium that the 2027 convening will center on an important question: How do we keep people safe in the age of AI and AI agents? The scope encompasses safety across homes, finances, health, employment, education, criminal justice, 20
National Fair Housing Alliance | Responsible AI Lab | nationalfairhousing.org
Looking Forward
environment, and digital identities — the domains where autonomous agents are being deployed most rapidly and where the civil rights implications of loyalty ambiguity, continuous micro-decision bias, and security vulnerabilities are most acute. The 2027 Symposium will take up questions including: What does meaningful human oversight of autonomous agents look like in practice? What protections are necessary for employees working on systems that affect millions of consumers? What civil rights frameworks are adequate for agentic systems? And what does “safe by design” mean when the design evolves faster than any single audit cycle can capture? NFHA leaves the 2026 Symposium with a clear mandate: bend the moral arc of AI toward justice. Not as an aspiration, but as an action. That means building standards, conducting audits, forging partnerships, enforcing compliance, and assembling the coalitions needed to ensure AI is used for good. The next 250 years of American life are being written in code right now. That begs the question: Coded to serve whom?
Don Graves (former Deputy Secretary of Commerce) and Michael Hsu (former Acting Comptroller of the Currency).
About the National Fair Housing Alliance The National Fair Housing Alliance leads a coalition that works to build inclusive, well-resourced, and resilient communities; expand equitable opportunities; and end housing discrimination. NFHA’s Responsible AI Lab (RAIL) was established to ensure that artificial intelligence systems — increasingly deployed across housing, lending, insurance, and adjacent domains — advance civil and human rights rather than erode them. The Lab’s mandate spans research, standards development, auditing methodology, tool-building, and partnership with industry, government, and civil society to operationalize fair and accountable AI. The NFHA Responsible AI Symposium, now in its third year, is the annual convening of record for the intersection of civil rights and AI governance. For more information, visit nationalfairhousing.org
21