Money Smarts

This book belongs to

Name Address Telephone School Teacher Grade

MONEY SMARTS A Financial Literacy Program

Project Consultant Jane Chamberlain, Master of Education, Curriculum and Instruction

Design & Layout Branko Pejovic Banedsgn Studio

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Written and Edited by Yehudis Leitner, Fraydel Sharf, Miriam Shulamis Eisemann, Jenny Mezzanotte, Ruchi Harnik, Toby Gartenhaus

3

The Whole Book at a Glance Money Smarts is built in three tiers. The first three units build behavior. The next three build strategy. The last two build understanding of the larger money system. Each unit follows

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

one student through a real situation in their own world.

Money Smarts

ISBN 978-1-955773-14-1

Lighthouse Curriculum 718.285.7100 • info@lighthousecurriculum.com For more information visit www.lighthousecurriculum.com ©Copyright 2025 Lighthouse Curriculum Inc. All rights reserved.

No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, stored in a database and/or published in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher. To obtain permission to use portions of material from this publication, please contact Lighthouse Curriculum.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

4

TABLE OF CONTENTS AND SCOPE 8 Units · 32 Lessons · 18 Practical Forms

Unit 1

Smart Spending Choices

Big question How do you make spending decisions you won't regret?

Lesson

Format

Money Rule

1 The Drone or the Trip

Every yes is a no to something else.

11

2 The Cheap Flashlight Problem

Cheap can be expensive.

15

3 The Microscope Surprise

The price tag is rarely the whole price.

19

4 The "Today Only" Sign

A sale only saves money if you were going to buy it anyway. 23

5 Ben's $60 Plan

A smart plan beats a long wish list.

MONEY THROUGH TIME When Money Wasn't Money Yet · The Salt Road · The Knight Who Came With Extras · Tulip Mania · When Pepper Cost More Than Gold

Unit 2

27

PRACTICAL FORMS Reading a Receipt · Tax, Percent Off, and Tips

Save with a Plan

Lesson

Format

Money Rule

1 Sam's Goal

A goal needs a date.

2 Pay Yourself First

If you pay everyone else first, there is nothing left for you. 43

3 The Missing Twelve Dollars

If you do not track it, you cannot keep it.

47

4 Stay or Adjust?

A plan can bend, but it should not break.

51

5 Sam's Full Plan

Small amounts saved every week beat big amounts saved sometimes.

55

MONEY THROUGH TIME The Egyptian Granaries · The Earliest Saving Boxes · The Mathematician Who Changed Business Forever · Shackleton and the Endurance · The First Savings Banks

FORMAT

STANDARD

COMPARE

INVESTIGATION

39

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Big question How do you turn a wish into a plan that actually works?

PRACTICAL FORMS Savings Goal Tracker · A Bank Deposit Slip

DEBATE

BUILD IT

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

5

TABLE OF CONTENTS AND SCOPE 8 Units · 32 Lessons · 18 Practical Forms

Unit 3

Earn Smart

Big question How do you earn money in a way that respects your time Lesson

Format

Money Rule

1 The Yard Job

Set the price before you start the work.

2 Active vs Passive Income

Working money is good. Money that keeps working is better. 71

3 The Missing Hour

Hours you do not track are hours you do not get paid for.

75

4 Negotiating the Rate

The first number is rarely the last number.

79

5 Max's Earning Plan

What you can do in an hour is what you earn in an hour.

83

MONEY THROUGH TIME The Roman Forum Price Lists · The Miller and His Windmill · The Clay Tablets of Sumer · The Master Mosaic Maker · The Castle Builders

Unit 4

67

PRACTICAL FORMS Writing an Invoice · Reading a Paycheck Stub · A Job Application

Choose Smart

Big question How do you choose when more than one option looks good?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Lesson

Format

Money Rule

1 The Coin Find

Your goal picks the winner.

95

2 Two Coins, One Budget

Comparison is faster than wishing.

99

3 The Surprise Offer

If you do not know how it works, do not say yes.

103

4 Adam's Pros and Cons

When in doubt, write it down.

107

PRACTICAL FORMS Comparison Shopping Worksheet · Pros-andCons Decision Template

MONEY THROUGH TIME The Penny Switch of 1909 · The Sears Catalog · The Man Who Sold the Eiffel Tower · Benjamin Franklin's Moral Algebra

FORMAT

STANDARD

COMPARE

INVESTIGATION

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

6

DEBATE

BUILD IT

TABLE OF CONTENTS AND SCOPE 8 Units · 32 Lessons · 18 Practical Forms

Unit 5

Borrow Carefully

Big question What does borrowing really cost, even between friends?

Lesson

Format

Money Rule

1 The First Loan

A loan is a gift unless you ask for it back.

119

2 The Cost of Borrowing

Borrowing always costs more than waiting.

123

3 The Tangled Loans

Every untracked loan is a quiet gift.

127

4 Daniel's Lending Rules

Decide before you are asked.

131

MONEY THROUGH TIME The Code of Hammurabi · The Pawnshops with Three Golden Balls · The Tally Sticks of Medieval England · Honest Abe and the National Debt

Unit 6

PRACTICAL FORMS A Simple Loan Agreement · A Loan Ledger

Protect and Plan Ahead

Big question How do you handle the things you can't see coming?

Format

Money Rule

1 The Broken Eyepiece

Save for the rainy day before the rain starts.

143

2 The Field Trip

Asking what could go wrong isn't worry. It's planning.

147

3 Where Jake's Stuff Lives

What you don't protect, you can lose.

151

4 Jake's Full Plan

Cover what you want, what you need, and what you can't see coming.

MONEY THROUGH TIME The Ant and the Grasshopper · The Captain's Checklist · The Roman Arca · Lloyd's of London

FORMAT

STANDARD

COMPARE

INVESTIGATION

155

PRACTICAL FORMS Rainy Day Fund Tracker · Risk Inventory

DEBATE

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Lesson

BUILD IT

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

7

TABLE OF CONTENTS AND SCOPE 8 Units · 32 Lessons · 18 Practical Forms

Unit 7

How Money Moves

Big question How does money move through a business, and how do you track it?

Lesson

Format

Money Rule

1 The Day's Take

Money sitting still has a job.

167

2 Cash or Check

Some payments are safer slow.

171

3 Henry's Money Flow

Track every dollar in. Track every dollar out.

175

MONEY THROUGH TIME The Medici Bank · The Postal Money Order · The Telegraph and the Birth of Instant Money

Unit 8

PRACTICAL FORMS Writing a Check · Your Signature · Reading a Bank Statement

Money Grows

Big question How does money grow when you leave it alone for years?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Lesson

Format

Money Rule

1 Joseph's Share

When you own a share, you grow when the business grows. 187

2 Joseph's Long Plan

Time does most of the work.

MONEY THROUGH TIME The Dutch East India Company · Compound Interest in Ancient Babylon

FORMAT

STANDARD

COMPARE

INVESTIGATION

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

8

191

PRACTICAL FORMS Reading a Share Statement · The Compound Growth Worksheet

DEBATE

BUILD IT

Unit 1

Smart Spending Choices How do I spend money in a way that matches my goals?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

BIG QUESTION FOR THE UNIT

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

9

Meet Ben Ben is in sixth grade. He likes figuring out how things work. He notices small details: a number on a package, a missing part in a box, a sign that says "today only."

In the afternoons, Ben helps his uncle unload boxes at a workshop. He earns $10 on the afternoons he works. That sounds simple, but Ben is learning something: money is easy to spend and harder to plan.

In this unit, Ben faces five spending choices. Each one teaches him a different question smart spenders ask before they buy.

W H AT ' S I N T H I S U N I T Lesson

Money Rule

1

The Drone or the Trip

Every yes is a no to something else.

2

The Cheap Flashlight Problem

Cheap can be expensive.

3

The Microscope Surprise

The price tag is rarely the whole price.

4

The "Today Only" Sign

A sale only saves money if you were going to buy it anyway.

5

Ben's $60 Plan

A smart plan beats a long wish list.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

#

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

10

INTRO

UNIT 1 | LESSON 1

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E S I T U AT I O N

The Drone or the Trip Ben had spent the summer helping his uncle at his workshop. On the afternoons he worked, he earned $10 sweeping the floor, sorting screws into bins, and carrying lumber from the truck to the saw bench. He did not work every day, and he spent some of what he made along the way. By the end of August, he had $40 saved in an envelope.

On Monday morning at school, Mr. Parker announced a weekend hiking trip to Hawk Ridge.

The trip cost $30 and included a bus, a guide, and a packed lunch. Students who had hiked Hawk Ridge before said the view from the top was "actually worth the climb." The deadline to sign up was Friday.

Then at lunch, Ben's friend Owen showed him a picture of a beginner drone Ben had wanted for

DISCUSSION What if Ben's best friend was going on the trip? What if his uncle said he could borrow a drone any weekend? Would either of those change the answer? Why?

several months. The kit cost $40 and included replaceable propellers and a working camera. The hobby store on Pine Street still had three kits in stock.

Ben had $40 and two good options. He could buy the drone, or go on the trip and have $10 left for later. He could not afford both.

BEN’S CHOICES B

Buy the drone

Cost

$40

C

Go on the trip

Cost

$30

Try to do both

Cost

$70

What he gets The drone he has been wanting for months

What he gets A weekend at Hawk Ridge with classmates

What he gets impossible, he only has $40

What he gives up The trip; $0 left over

What he gives up The drone; $10 left

What he gives up n/a

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

A

BIG QUESTION

FIRST INSTINCT Circle the one Ben should pick before reading anything else.

A. Buy the drone

B. Go on the trip

C. Wait and decide later

D. Ask his parents to chip in

How do you choose when both options are good?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

11

UNIT 1 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

THE SKILL

APPLY

HISTORY

VOCABULARY

Every Yes Is a No to Something Else Ben has $40 and two things he wants to buy. He only has enough money for one, so he has to choose. The hard part is not deciding.

The hard part is accepting that choosing one option means giving up the other. Money is limited, but our wants are not. Even adults with plenty of money face this problem. A single dollar can only be spent on one thing. People who forget this end up surprised by their own spending. People who remember it make better choices, because they know what they are giving up.

There is a name for the thing you give up when you make a choice. It is called the opportunity cost. The opportunity cost is not money you lost. It is the value of whatever you said no to. When Ben buys the drone, his opportunity cost is the trip. When he chooses the trip, his opportunity cost is the drone.

GUIDED EXAMPLE

Opportunity cost - the value of what you give up when you choose something else. The trip is Ben's opportunity cost if he buys the drone.

Tradeoff - a choice where every option costs you something. Almost every money decision is a tradeoff.

Priority - the thing that matters most to you right now. Your priority decides which tradeoff makes sense.

Limited resource anything you have a finite amount of. Ben's $40 is a limited resource. So is time.

Carlos has $25. He wants both a $20 book and a $15 digital watch. Together, that is $35.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

He is $10 short of having both.

His opportunity cost is real: Buy the book: no watch.

Buy the watch: no book.

Try to buy both: not possible with $25.

PRACTICE You have $30. Fill in the blanks.

You spend on

Money left or short

A $18 model kit

$

A $25 hobby case

$

Both a $18 kit and a $25 case

$

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

12

MONEY RULE

Every YES is a NO to something else.

INTRO

UNIT 1 | LESSON 1

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

DECISION LAB

What Ben Should Decide Now you help Ben decide. Use the table below. Pick the option that matches what matters most to him.

STEP 1 What does Ben actually want most this month?

What Ben cares about

Does the drone help?

Does the trip help?

Time with friends from school

No

Yes

Building something he can use again and again

Yes

No

A memory of a place he has not been

No

Yes

Learning a new skill on his own

Yes

Partly

Ben's uncle finds out about the choice. He says: "If you skip the drone for now, I'll match what you save next month. Drones aren't going anywhere." The trip, though, is only this weekend.

STEP 2 Pick one.

DISCUSSION

Buy the drone. Skip the trip. o on the trip. Buy the drone next G month with help from his uncle.

Skip both. Save the $40 for something later.

Did the new information change your answer? Why or why not? Should new information always change your mind?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: what is Ben's opportunity cost if he picks the trip?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

13

UNIT 1 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

When Money Wasn't Money Yet

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Picture a market long ago, before anyone alive had ever seen a coin. A potter walks in carrying a clay jar he shaped with his own hands. He needs grain for the winter. Somewhere in the crowd is a farmer with grain to spare. If the potter can find him, and if that farmer happens to want a jar, the two can trade, and both walk home satisfied. This kind of direct swap is called barter.

But barter hides a hard problem. The potter cannot simply want grain. He has to find a grain farmer who also wants a pot, at the same moment, in the same market. If every farmer there already has enough pots, the potter goes home hungry, no matter how fine his work is. A trade happens only when two people each want exactly what the other is holding, and that match was rare.

People found a clever way around this. They began accepting certain goods that almost everyone wanted, not for that day, but because they knew someone else would take them later. In some places that good was salt. In others it was small polished seashells called cowries. The potter could swap his jar for cowries from anyone, then carry them until he found the grain farmer. The cowries were not money yet. They were more like stepping stones across a river, each one carrying him closer to the grain.

The next step took thousands of years. In a kingdom called Lydia, in what is now Turkey, someone had an idea that changed the world. They took small lumps of metal, each the same weight,

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The first Lydian coins were not pure gold or pure silver. They were made of electrum, a natural blend of the two metals that the Lydians panned from the gravel of a local river called the Pactolus. Each coin was stamped with the head of a roaring lion, the badge of the Lydian kings. A person holding one could not read, but they could recognize that lion, and that was enough to trust the coin.

and stamped every one with the mark of the king.

The stamp was a promise: this piece is real, and worth what the king says. These were the first true coins. They lasted, they were easy to count, and a merchant no longer had to weigh and test every lump of metal. He just looked at the stamp.

Money has changed shape many times since that first coin. It has been salt, shells, gold, paper, and today it is often just a number in a bank's ledger.

But under every shape is the same idea the potter stumbled onto at that market. Money works only because people agree it is worth something. The moment they stop agreeing, even a chest of gold becomes a pile of heavy metal.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

14

INTRO

UNIT 1 | LESSON 2

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

TWO SCENARIOS

Two Ways to Buy a Flashlight Ben's old flashlight had stopped working, and he needed a new one for his work at the workshop. At the store, he found two flashlights for sale on the shelf next to each other. They were not the same.

DISCUSSION

The two scenarios below show the same week through two different versions of Ben. The first version bought the cheap flashlight. The second version bought the more expensive one. Read both, then decide which Ben made the better choice.

Why does the cheap version sometimes end up costing more? Have you ever bought a cheap thing twice because the first one broke?

Time

Ben who bought the $18 light

Day 1

Picked the $18 reliable flashlight from the main shelf.

Worked fine. Felt great about saving $12.

Day 4

Worked fine. Felt a little stung at paying $18.

Batteries died fast. Bought new ones for $3.

Day 10

Switch broke. Returning it required a receipt he had thrown out. Stuck with a broken flashlight.

Day 18

Bought a $14 replacement flashlight to actually get the work done.

Day 22

Ben who bought the $6 light Picked the $6 flashlight off the bargain bin.

Same battery still going.

Still working perfectly.

Same flashlight. Same batteries.

TOTAL: $6 + $3 + $14 = $23

TOTAL: $18 + $0 = $18

FIRST INSTINCT

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

B E N ’ S S I T U AT I O N

BIG QUESTION

Who actually paid more?

A. The $6 Ben

B. The $18 Ben

C. About the same

D. Can't tell yet

When does the cheap option cost more than the expensive one?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

15

UNIT 1 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

THE SKILL

VOCABULARY Price - what the store charges for the item. The number on the tag.

Price and Value are not the Same Thing

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

The price tag tells you what an item costs to buy. It does not tell you what the item costs to own. Those are two different numbers.

The cheap flashlight had a low price, but it also had hidden costs that showed up later. Ben had to buy extra batteries. The switch broke. He had to replace the flashlight with a new one. When you add all of these costs together, the cheap flashlight cost $23 over three weeks.

The reliable flashlight cost $18 over the same three weeks, with no hidden costs. Smart spenders learn to ask two questions before they buy. First: what does it cost to buy? Second: what will it cost to use and replace over time?

Value - what you actually get for your money. How well it works, how long it lasts.

Total cost to own - price plus everything it costs you over time: batteries, repairs, replacements.

Hidden cost - a cost that does not show on the price tag but adds up after you bring the item home.

MONEY RULE

Cheap can be expensive.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Liam needs a school briefcase. He finds two choices. The first briefcase costs $15. The second briefcase costs $40. he $15 briefcase has a thin strap and light fabric. Most kids who T buy this one replace it within a year. he $40 briefcase has a padded strap, heavy leather, and T reinforced stitching. It lasts five years easily. ver five years, the $15 briefcase will need to be replaced five O times, for a total of $75. The $40 briefcase will only be bought once. The more expensive briefcase is actually cheaper over time.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

16

UNIT 1 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

C H O O S E Y O U R PAT H

Run the Math, Then Pick Now you compare two items the same way Ben did. Fill in the total cost to own for each, then pick the smarter buy.

SCENARIO A hobby storage case Item

$8 thin cardboard case

$25 hard plastic case

Price

$8

$25

About 6 months

About 10 years

Replacement costs across 5 years

$

$

TOTAL cost across 5 years

$

$

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

Ben spots a $14 mid-range case. It's more durable than the $8 one but not as good as the $25 one. Estimated lifespan: 3 years. Add it to your comparison.

DISCUSSION

STEP 2 Pick one.

The $8 thin cardboard case. Lowest up-front cost.

The $14 mid-range case. Middle of the road.

The $25 hard plastic case. Buy it once and forget about it.

If someone only has $8 right now, should they buy the cheap case anyway or save until they can afford the better one? Defend your answer.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Expected lifespan

EXIT QUESTION Write one example from your own life of something cheap that cost you more in the end.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

17

UNIT 1 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Salt Road

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Long ago, in the dry hills of central Italy, a line of mules picked its way along a stone-paved road, each animal swaying under two heavy leather sacks. The sacks held no gold and no silver. They held salt. The road had a name, the Via Salaria, the Salt Road, and for hundreds of years it was one of the most important roads in the entire Roman world.

This is hard to picture today, when salt costs almost nothing and sits in a shaker on every table. But long ago, salt was the only way to keep meat from rotting.

A family that wanted to eat through the winter had to pack their meat in salt or watch it spoil. In a town far from the sea, a single handful of salt could be worth a handful of silver. Whoever controlled the salt controlled real wealth, and the Romans understood this completely. Roman soldiers were sometimes paid part of their wages in salt. The Latin word for that payment was salarium. That one word traveled down through two thousand years of history and became the modern English word salary. The next time someone mentions the salary they earn at a job, they are using a word that once meant a soldier's ration of salt. The merchants who ran the Salt Road grew rich, and not by making a single thing. They grew rich on one idea: something cheap in one place can be precious in another. At the coastal flats, where

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The Via Salaria still exists. Today it is a modern highway, but in places it runs along the exact path the mule trains once followed.

Parts of the original Roman stone paving have been dug up and preserved. A traveler there now can stand on the same stones that salt caravans crossed twenty centuries ago.

workers raked salt from shallow ponds of drying seawater, salt was nearly free. A week's journey inland, that same salt sold for ten times the price.

The merchant's whole profit was the distance itself.

Not every merchant was honest. Some mixed cheap white chalk or fine sand into their salt and sold the watered-down mixture at the full price.

The fake salt looked perfect sitting in the sack. But when a family used it to pack their winter meat, the meat rotted anyway, and by then the cheating merchant was long gone. Towns fought back with hard laws. A trader caught selling false salt could be fined, jailed, or banished for good.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

18

UNIT 1 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E S I T U AT I O N

The $45 That Wasn't $45 Ben had been saving for a beginner microscope for six months. The model he wanted had three magnification levels and a wooden case, and it cost $45. By last week, Ben had saved exactly $45.20 in his envelope.

On Sunday, his dad drove him to the science store on Pine Street. Ben walked straight to the microscope shelf, pulled the box down, and carried it to the counter.

His dad held up one finger. "Hold on. What about slides?"

Ben stopped. He had not thought about slides.

His dad pointed at the accessories rack near the counter. It held glass slides, cover slips, prepared

DISCUSSION Was the price tag wrong? If the tag said $45 and the receipt said $84, who is to blame, and for what?

specimens, a storage tray, a clip-on lamp, tweezers, and a cleaning cloth.

Ben looked at the microscope, then at the rack, then back at the microscope. The price tag still said $45. But somehow, the real price had become much higher.

SOMETHING IS HIDING

Item

Price

Beginner microscope

$45.00

Pack of 50 blank slides

$8.00

Box of cover slips

$4.00

Clip-on lamp

$12.00

Tweezers and cleaning cloth set

$6.00

Slide storage tray

$9.00

TOTAL

$84.00

FIRST INSTINCT

BIG QUESTION

Where did the extra $39 come from?

What does this purchase really cost?

A. Store overcharged

B. Microscope is pricier

C. Accessories add up

D. Dad picked extras

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Where did the extra thirty-nine dollars come from?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

19

UNIT 1 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

THE CLUES

Hidden Costs Always Have a Pattern The price tag on an item is rarely the whole price. Almost any purchase comes with extra costs that are not printed on the sticker. The price tag covers only the main item. Hidden costs cover everything else you need in order to actually use it.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

There are four common kinds of hidden cost. Once you learn to spot them, you can stop being surprised when the total comes out higher than you expected.

Kind of hidden cost

What it is

Microscope example

Accessories

Things that go with the item but aren't included

Slides, cover slips, lamp, tweezers

Consumables

Things you use up and have to buy again

Slides (over time), cleaning cloths

Maintenance

Things to keep the item working

Cleaning supplies, replacement bulbs for the lamp

Storage and care

Where you keep it; protecting it from damage

Storage tray, dust cover

VOCABULARY Sticker price - the price printed on the tag. The first number you see.

Accessories - extra items needed to make the main thing work as intended.

Consumables - items you use up. Once they are gone, you have to buy more.

Total to own - the sticker price plus all the hidden costs of using and keeping the item.

MONEY RULE

The price tag is rarely the whole price.

ADAM'S RESEARCH METHOD Adam is a kid in Ben's class who collects old coins. Before he buys any piece of hobby gear, Adam writes down four costs on a piece of paper: The cost of the item itself The cost of accessories the item needs to work The cost of consumables he will use during the first year The cost of storage or care he had not thought about He adds all four numbers together before he opens his wallet. Either way, he is never surprised by the price at the counter.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

20

INTRO

UNIT 1 | LESSON 3

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

S O LV E I T

Find the Real Cost Use Adam's method on the microscope. Fill in the four columns.

STEP 1 Cost category

Ben's number

Amount

Main item

The microscope

$45

Accessories

(write what is needed)

$

Consumables (1st year)

(slides used up, replaced)

$

Storage / care

(tray, cover, cloth)

$

DISCUSSION

TOTAL TO OWN

$

A friend at school offers to sell Ben his older microscope for $30. It's a year old but works fine. He'll throw in twenty used slides for free. How does that change Adam's spreadsheet?

STEP 2 Pick one.

Buy the new microscope and all the new accessories. Total to own: about $84.

Buy the new microscope without the lamp. Save money, work in better lighting.

Buy the friend's used microscope for $30. Save money up front.

Wait. Save more first.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

If Ben had only researched the sticker price, what would have happened at the store? Whose job is it to find the hidden costs?

EXIT QUESTION Name something you have bought, or wanted to buy, that had hidden costs you did not expect.

What were they?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

21

UNIT 1 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

The Knight Who Came With Extras

In the year 1100, a young noble named Geoffrey received his finished suit of armor. The armor had been forged over fourteen months by a smith in his father's village. It included a breastplate, a helmet, gauntlets, and greaves. The polished steel caught the morning light. Geoffrey was now, officially, a knight.

He was also, less officially, almost out of money. Most people picture a knight and think only of the armor.

The armor is what appears in paintings and stories.

But the armor was only the beginning of what it cost to be a knight. A knight by himself, without the rest of his equipment, was like a single tool without a workshop.

Geoffrey needed three horses: one specially trained to carry an armored rider over rough ground, one for ordinary travel, and one for his squire. The trained horse cost as much as the armor itself, and sometimes even more. The squire, usually a teenager from a less noble family, handled all the practical work: cleaning the armor, sharpening the gear, setting up camp, cooking the meals, and caring for the horses. A squire needed pay, room, and board all year long.

And the list did not stop at horses. Geoffrey needed a tent for the long campaign seasons, with bedding and cookware for the road, spare horseshoes, bridles, saddles, and ropes. He needed food for himself, for his squire, and for three hungry horses.

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The English word 'chivalry' comes from the French word for horse, cheval. To be a knight was, at root, to be a horseman. The horse was so central to the job that the entire tradition of knighthood took its name from the animal that made knighthood possible.

He needed coins for the tolls and bribes that every traveler met along the way. And because armor straps and buckles snapped constantly under the strain of riding and fighting, he needed a steady supply of replacements just to stay battle-ready.

A new knight who had not planned for all of these costs could find himself, six months into his career, sitting on a borrowed mule with his polished armor in the saddlebag and no money left to feed his horses.

This actually happened to many young knights.

Geoffrey was lucky. His father had been a knight himself, and he knew the real math of the job. The chest of coins that arrived with the armor was enough to keep Geoffrey on the road for two campaign seasons before he had to ask anyone for more help.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

22

INTRO

UNIT 1 | LESSON 4

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

TWO PEOPLE DISAGREE

Buy It Now, or Wait?

Ben and Liam were at the hobby store on Pine Street one weekday afternoon. Liam was shopping for a model rocket kit. Ben had only $20 in his pocket, and he was not planning to buy anything.

DISCUSSION

As they walked toward the kits, they saw a large red sign: "TODAY ONLY, 30% OFF THE APOLLO STARTER ROCKET KIT." The kit normally cost $40.

Today it was twenty-eight. Tomorrow the price would go back up.

Liam grabbed Ben's elbow. "You have to get one.

You would save $12. That is almost a third off."

Ben hesitated. "I was not going to buy a rocket kit today," he said. "I came in to look at flashlights."

Liam is not lying. The sign is real. The savings are real. So why does Ben sound like he is right?

"But it is a real deal," Liam said. "You will not see this price again. If you wait until tomorrow, you pay full price."

"And if I wait until tomorrow," Ben said, "I will still have $20 that I did not spend on a rocket kit I was not planning to buy."

Liam's position

Ben's position

This is a real deal. If you skip it, you will lose $12 in savings.

I did not want this kit ten minutes ago. The sign is what made me want it.

You will probably want a rocket kit eventually. Buy it now while it is cheap.

If I buy something today that I did not plan for, the sale is not saving me money. It is costing me $28.

Sales do not last. You need to decide quickly.

Real deals do not usually need a countdown. The pressure should make me suspicious, not excited.

FIRST INSTINCT

BIG QUESTION

Who has the better argument?

How do you handle pressure to buy?

A. Liam

B. Ben

C. Both have a point

D. Need to know more first

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

THE DISAGREEMENT

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

23

UNIT 1 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

EACH SIDE'S REASONING

Where Each One Is Right, and Where Each One Slips VOCABULARY Urgency tactic - a sign or message designed to make you decide fast, before you can think it through.

Pre-existing intent - the want or plan you already had before you walked into the store. If your intent matches the sale, the sale is real for you.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Both Liam and Ben are saying something true. The trick is knowing when each one's reasoning works.

Liam is right when the item on sale is something you were already planning to buy. If Ben had been saving for a rocket kit for two months, the sale would be a gift. He would walk in expecting to pay $40 and walk out paying twenty-eight. Those are real savings.

Ben is right when the item on sale was not in his plan. If he buys the rocket kit because the sign told him to, he is not saving $12. He is spending $28 he was not going to spend at all. The sale created the want. The want did not exist before.

The pause - the moment of stopping to ask: did I want this an hour ago? If the answer is no, the sale is not the reason to buy.

MONEY RULE

THE ONE QUESTION When you see a sale sign, ask yourself one simple question. Did I want this item BEFORE the sign told me to want it?

If yes

he sale might be a real deal for you. Run the T numbers carefully.

If no

The sale is just a sales tactic. Walk away.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

24

Impulse purchase - a buy made on the spur of the moment, not part of any plan. Most regretted buys are impulse purchases.

A sale only saves money if you were going to buy it anyway.

UNIT 1 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

WHERE THE TRUTH SITS

Stake Your Position Four shoppers see a sign. Each one's situation is different.

For each, decide: real deal, or sales tactic?

STEP 1 Fill in the four rows.

Situation

Real deal or sales tactic?

1

Has been saving for a $40 model rocket kit for two months.

Sees it on sale today only for $28.

$

2

Walks into store for a flashlight. Sees a sale on hobby kits. Buys a hobby kit instead.

$

3

Has been hoping for a $25 hobby case for weeks. Sees one on sale for $18. Has $20 saved.

$

4

Does not need anything in particular. Sees a 'Today Only 50% off' sign on something he has never wanted before. Buys it because of the savings.

$

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

What if the discount goes from thirty percent to fifty percent?

Does that change any of your four answers? Why or why not?

TAKE A POSITION

DISCUSSION

Liam is right more often than Ben is.

Ben is right more often than Liam is.

It depends on the shopper's pre-existing intent.

It depends on the size of the discount.

Defend your position with one example from the table above or from your own life.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Shopper

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: how do you tell the difference between a real deal and a sales tactic?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

25

UNIT 1 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

Tulip Mania In the autumn of 1636, in the city of Amsterdam, a single tulip bulb sold for the price of a fine townhouse.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Tulips were not native to Europe. They had been brought from the Ottoman Empire a century earlier and had become fashionable in wealthy Dutch gardens.

Certain rare varieties, especially those with streaked or feathered petals, were prized. Rich families displayed them in summer like trophies. Painters painted them.

They were a status symbol of the wealthy.

Then something strange began. Around 1634, ordinary people, not gardeners and not the rich, started buying tulip bulbs. They were not buying them to plant. They were buying them to resell.

A bulb that cost 100 guilders in March might sell for 200 in May, 300 by July, and 600 by autumn.

Buyers were no longer really buying flowers. They were buying the right to sell the same bulb to a more eager buyer next month, at a higher price.

For about two years, it worked. Prices climbed. New buyers kept arriving. A blacksmith in a small town sold his shop and poured the money into three bulbs. A baker mortgaged his house. By late 1636, a single rare bulb called the Semper Augustus was worth more than a fully furnished house on an Amsterdam canal, a flower priced like a mansion.

In February 1637, the market turned in a single afternoon. A small auction in the town of Haarlem opened with bulbs that had sold easily the week before. The auctioneer called for a bid, and

D I D YO U K N OW ?

Most of the trading during the tulip mania was not done with actual bulbs. It was done with promises about future bulbs, signed on small slips of paper. Bulbs changed hands on paper many times over while the flowers themselves stayed in the ground. This system made the bubble spread faster, and it made the crash hurt much more when the paper turned out to be worthless.

the room was silent. He dropped the price. Still nothing. By the end of that day, word raced to the next town, and the next. Within a week, prices everywhere had collapsed. The blacksmith was left holding three bulbs no one would buy for the price of a loaf of bread. The baker was ruined.

Here is the strangest part: nothing about the actual flowers had changed. They were the same plants they had always been. What changed was a single unspoken belief, that someone else would always pay more tomorrow. The instant that belief cracked, the bulbs were just bulbs again. Economists today have a name for this pattern. They call it a speculative bubble: prices climb because everyone expects them to keep climbing, until the expectation breaks and the whole thing falls at once.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

26

UNIT 1 | LESSON 5

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

THE PROBLEM

$60 and a Wish List Ben had $60 saved up in his envelope. He had earned $40 over the last few months at his uncle's workshop. The other $20 had come from his grandmother, who had sent him a $20 bill in a birthday card. This was more money than Ben had ever had at one time.

Ben had also been making a list of things he wanted and things he thought he needed. He had added each item over the last few weeks, every time he had thought, "I should get that."

DISCUSSION What's the danger of walking in with $60 and no plan? What's the danger of planning so much that he never spends?

What he wants

Price

Drone parts (upgrade his existing drone)

$25

Reliable flashlight (replacement, the cheap one died)

$15

Notebook for sketches and ideas

$5

Pen pack (the kind that does not bleed)

$4

Small starter telescope (used, from a friend)

$30

The total cost of everything on the list was $79. Ben had $60. He was $19 short of being able to buy everything on his list. Ben could not buy it all. He had to build a plan.

FIRST INSTINCT

BIG QUESTION

How should Ben start?

How do you put it all together?

A. Cheapest first

B. Most expensive first

C. Decide what matters most

D. Wait for more money

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

BEN'S LIST

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

27

UNIT 1 | LESSON 5

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

EACH SIDE'S REASONING

What Goes Into a Good Plan A spending plan with limited money has four parts. They are the same whether the plan is for a $60 envelope or a $1,000 paycheck.

Each part fixes a different mistake.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

The first part is ranking the list. You put your wants in order of what matters most. The order tells you what to buy first and what to skip if the money runs out. The second part is separating needs from wants. A need is something you really require for daily life or to reach a goal. Ben's replacement flashlight is a need. A want is something you would enjoy but could skip, like a new telescope. When money is tight, needs win.

The third part is leaving a buffer. A buffer is a small amount you choose not to spend, in case something unexpected comes up. A plan without a buffer is fragile. One surprise can break it. The fourth part is knowing when to stop. When the money runs out, the plan stops.

Anything that did not make the cut goes on next month's list.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Theo has $50 saved. He has made a list of five things he wants to buy: Model rocket kit: $35

Priority ranking - putting your wants in order from most important to least important. The order decides who gets the money first.

Need vs want - a need is something you really do require for daily life or your goal. A want is something you would enjoy but could skip. Confusing the two is the most common planning mistake.

Buffer - a small amount held back from spending.

It absorbs surprises (a tool breaks, a price goes up, a chance comes along) without breaking the plan.

Stop line - the moment in your plan when the money is gone.

Everything below the line waits for next time.

Notebook: $5 Snack supply: $5 MONEY RULE

Pens: $4 Hobby T-shirt: $20 Total cost: $69. Theo is $19 short. His ranked plan: rocket kit ($35), notebook ($5), pens ($4). He keeps $6 as a buffer and spends $44 of his $50. The snack and T-shirt go on next month's list.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

28

VOCABULARY

A smart plan beats a long wish list.

INTRO

UNIT 1 | LESSON 5

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

S O LV E I T

Assemble Ben's $60 Plan Use the four parts. Build the plan piece by piece.

STEP 1 Rank the list Number Ben's items from 1 (most wanted/needed) to 5 (least). Put the number in the rank column.

Item

Price

Drone parts

$25

Reliable flashlight

$15

Notebook

$5

Pen pack

$4

Starter telescope

$30

Need or want?

Rank W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N Ben's uncle hands him an extra $10 for finishing a side project. Now Ben has $70. Does the plan change?

Which items stay skipped, and which move up?

STEP 1 Build the plan top down Starting with rank 1, add items until you are at or near $60. Leave at least a $5 buffer.

Running total

1.

$

2.

$

3.

$

4.

$ Buffer

$

Items skipped (next month's list)

$

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: what did the buffer do for Ben's plan?

DISCUSSION Two students might rank Ben's items differently and both be defensible.

What does that say about good plans?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Item kept

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

29

UNIT 1 | LESSON 5

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

When Pepper Cost More Than Gold In the year 1400, a small jar of black peppercorns, about the size of a closed fist, was worth more than its weight in gold.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

This sounds impossible today, when pepper sits in almost every kitchen and costs next to nothing. But for centuries in Europe, pepper was so precious that wealthy families locked it away in small boxes, the way a family today might lock up jewelry. A bride could receive a pouch of peppercorns as a wedding gift. A large debt could be settled in pepper instead of coins. The word "peppercorn" still survives in old legal contracts, where it means a tiny but real payment.

The reason pepper was so expensive came down to geography. Pepper grew only in a few places: southern India, parts of Indonesia, and the islands of the Indian Ocean. Europe had no source. The peppercorns left India on small wooden ships, were unloaded at ports on the Persian Gulf or the Red Sea, carried across the deserts by camel caravan, then loaded onto Italian and Arab ships that crossed the Mediterranean to Venice or Genoa. From there, wagons carried them inland to the few customers who could afford them. The journey took nearly two years.

Each leg of the journey took weeks. Each handler added a markup. Each port collected a tax. Each storm or robber along the way destroyed some of the cargo. The original Indian farmer might have sold his pepper for a few coins per pound.

D I D YO U K N OW ?

In medieval English law, a 'peppercorn rent' meant a very small symbolic payment, just enough to make a contract official. The phrase is still used today in some legal documents in Britain. A lease might require a 'peppercorn rent of one peppercorn per year.' The phrase outlived the value of the spice that gave it birth.

The final European customer paid hundreds of times that price. Whole cities were built on the wealth from the pepper trade. Venice and Genoa grew rich, and the Italian banking families that would later lend money to kings earned their first fortunes from the spice trade.

Then, in 1498, a Portuguese sailor named Vasco da Gama did something no European had done before. He sailed south down the coast of Africa, rounded the southern tip, and kept sailing east until he reached the coast of India. He bought pepper directly from Indian merchants and sailed all the way home with it. In doing so, he cut out every middleman who had been adding to the cost for a thousand years. Within a generation, pepper prices in Europe collapsed. The spice that had once been worth its weight in gold became affordable to ordinary families.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

30

FORM 2 TAX, PERCENT OFF, AND TIPS

Reading a Receipt

PRACTICAL A P P L I C AT I O N S What this section does!

This section covers two real-world forms you will see in your life, a review case study that ties the unit together, and a final reflection.

A receipt is a record of what you bought, what each item cost, and what you paid in total. Most people glance at the total once and throw the paper away. That is a missed habit. A receipt can show whether the store rang up items correctly, whether the tax matches the rate in your area, and what to bring back if something is wrong.

Reading every line takes about ten seconds, and that habit has saved many people a lot of money.

Pinewood Hardware a 123 Main Street, Pinewood b

2

a Store name

*** RECEIPT *** DATE: Tuesday, October 15

·

1

*

b Store Address c Date and time

3:42 PM c

ITEM

QTY

DESCRIPTION

COST

1 2

1 1b

HAND LENS NOTEBOOK a

$14.00 $4.50 c

3

1

PEN PACK

$3.00

DATE:

2

ITEMS YOU BOUGHT a What you bought b How many (QTY) c What each item cost

$21.50 a $1.51 b

TOTAL

$23.01 c

3

3------------------------------------------

4

$25.00 a $1.99 b

RECEIPT

#4582 c

1

1

2

1

3

1

SUBTOTAL PAYMENT MATH

SALES TAX

a Subtotal (before tax) ----------b Sales tax (7%) c Total (what you owe)

Cash paid CHANGE

QTY

-----------

-----------------------------------------SUBTOTAL SALES TAX (7%)

ITEM

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

1

1

Pin STORE INFORMATION

TOTAL

Cash paid

4

PAYMENT RESULT a Cash Paid b Change (money back) c Receipt number

CHANGE RECEIPT

THANK YOU FOR SHOPPING!

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

31

YOUR TURN

Fill In This Receipt You walk into Pinewood Hardware on a Thursday.

You buy:

Pinewood Hardware

A flashlight: $8.00 A pack of batteries: $3.00 A notebook: $4.00 Sales tax in your area is 6%. You pay with a $20 bill. Fill in every line of the receipt below.

123 Main Street, Pinewood

*** RECEIPT *** DATE: ITEM

QTY

DESCRIPTION

1

1

FLASHLIGHT

2

1

BATTERIES

3

1

NOTEBOOK

COST

------------------------------------------

---

SUBTOTAL SALES TAX (6%)

------------------------------------------

--© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

TOTAL

32

Cash paid CHANGE RECEIPT THANK YOU FOR SHOPPING!

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

$20.00

FORM 2 TAX, PERCENT OFF, AND TIPS

Three Money Calculations You'll Use Every Week Three small math skills come up almost every time money changes hands. Sales tax is added to a price. Percent off is subtracted from a price. A tip

is added to the cost of a service. All three use the same idea: finding a percent of a number. Once you learn the pattern, all three become the same move.

T H E PAT T E R N

Step 1

Step 2

Step 3

Convert the percent to a decimal by moving the decimal point two places to the left. 7% becomes 0.07. 25% becomes 0.25.

15% becomes 0.15.

Multiply the original number by that decimal.

The answer is the amount of the tax, the discount, or the tip.

Add or subtract that amount from the original price. For sales tax and tips, you add. For percent off, you subtract.

SALES TAX (added) A book costs $15.

Sales tax is 7%.

PERCENT OFF (subtracted) A flashlight is $20.

It's 25% off.

TIPS (added) A meal costs $14.

You leave a 15% tip.

Step 1

Step 2

Step 3

1: 7% = 0.07

$15 0.07 = $1.05 tax.

$15 + $1.05 = $16.05 total.

Step 1

Step 2

Step 3

25% = 0.25

$20 0.25 = $5 discount.

$20 - $5 = $15 sale price.

Step 1

Step 2

Step 3

1: 15% = 0.15

$14 0.15 = $2.10 tip.

$14 + $2.10 = $16.10 total paid.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

EXAMPLES

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

33

YOUR TURN

PRACTICE For each problem, follow the three-step pattern. Show your work.

Sales tax 1.

A model kit costs $25. Sales tax is 6% Tax: $

Total: $

2. Three notebooks cost $4 each. Sales tax is 8%.

Subtotal: $

Tax: $

Total: $

Percent off 3. A telescope is $80. It's 30% off.

Discount: $

Sale price: $

4. A backpack is $50. It's 40% off.

Sale price: $

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Discount: $

Tips 5. A meal costs $22. You leave a 20% tip.

Tip: $

Total paid: $

6. A meal costs $36. You leave an 18% tip.

Tip: $

Total paid: $

Mixed all three skills 7.

A tool set is normally $50. It's 20% off today. Sales tax is 7%. What is the final price you pay at the register?

Sale price: $

Tax: $

TOTAL paid: $ Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

34

REVIEW CASE STUDY

Ben's $50 Decision

C H EC K YO U R WO R K There is more than one defensible answer to this case.

The point is not to find the one right answer. The point is to use the Money Rules from this unit in your reasoning, so that the choice you make is one you can explain and defend.

Ben has $50 saved up. It is a month after the summer workshop season ended, and Ben has a real decision to make. Work through the case below using the Money Rules from this unit.

T H E S I T U AT I O N Ben wants to buy a model rocket kit. The hobby store sells it for $28.

The cheap flashlight Ben bought a year ago just stopped working. He needs a working flashlight for his afternoons at the workshop. A reliable flashlight costs $14.

DISCUSSION Compare your answer to a classmate's. Did the two of you spend the money the same way?

Defend your choice using at least two Money Rules from this unit.

The hobby store has a sign at the front of the store that says: "TODAY ONLY, 20% off any one item." Ben was not planning to buy anything because of the sign.

Ben has been saving toward a used telescope that his neighbor is selling for $40. Right now, he is $10 short of his goal.

Which Money Rule helps?

Question to ask

Is the flashlight a need or a want? What will happen if Ben does not buy one?

The rocket kit is on sale. Would Ben want it if the sign were not there?

Your answer

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

WA L K T H R O U G H T H E D EC I S I O N

If Ben spends $14 on the flashlight and $28 on the rocket kit, how much money does he have left? What is the cost of not saving toward the telescope this month?

What is the smartest order for Ben to spend his $50?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

35

UNIT CLOSE

Looking Back at Ben’s Unit Ben started this unit with $40 in an envelope and a choice between a drone and a hiking trip. Across five lessons, he learned the questions smart spenders ask before they buy. He learned that the cheap option can cost more in the long run. He learned that the price tag almost never covers everything he will need. He learned that a sale sign is not always a real deal. And he learned that a wish list is not a plan, and that a plan beats a wish list every time.

These are not difficult ideas. The hard part is not knowing them. The hard part is asking them every single time, out loud, before the money leaves your hand.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

THE MONEY RULES FROM THIS UNIT Lesson 1

Every yes is a no to something else.

Lesson 2

Cheap can be expensive.

Lesson 3

The price tag is rarely the whole price.

Lesson 4

A sale only saves money if you were going to buy it anyway.

Lesson 5

A smart plan beats a long wish list.

R E A L- W O R L D A P P L I C A T I O N Choose one Money Rule from this unit. Write about a time when you should have used the rule but did not, or a time when you did use it. Explain what happened in either case. Use the exact words of the rule in your writing. Be honest about what you would do differently next time.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

36

Unit 2

Save with a Plan How do I turn a wish into something I will actually reach?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

BIG QUESTION FOR THE UNIT

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

37

Meet Sam Sam is in sixth grade. He likes building things with his hands. His bedroom shelf holds a row of small wooden boxes, model bridges, and tool holders that he has built over the last two years. Sam enjoys planning a project on paper before he picks up the first piece of wood.

On weekends, Sam helps at a small carpentry workshop two blocks from his house. The owner, Mr. Bennett, pays him $5 a week for sweeping shavings, sanding edges, and organizing the wood scrap bin. $5 a week is not a lot of money. But Sam is learning something important: small amounts saved with a clear plan can add up to bigger things than he expected.

In this unit, Sam works through the five parts of saving money. Each lesson teaches him one piece of how a real saving plan works W H AT ' S I N T H I S U N I T Lesson

Money Rule

1

Sam's Goal

A goal needs a date.

2

Pay Yourself First

If you pay everyone else first, there is nothing left for you.

3

The Missing Twelve Dollars

If you do not track it, you cannot keep it.

4

Stay or Adjust?

A plan can bend, but it should not break.

5

Sam's Full Plan

Small amounts saved every week beat big amounts saved sometimes.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

#

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

38

INTRO

UNIT 2 | LESSON 1

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E S I T U AT I O N

The Toolbox Sam Wanted Sam had been saving money for nothing in particular. For about a year, he had earned $5 a week at the carpentry workshop. Some weeks he spent it all. Some weeks he saved a little. He had no plan, no goal, and no way to know if he was making progress.

Then one Sunday afternoon, Sam walked past the window of the hardware store on Pine Street. In the window sat a wooden toolbox. It was a real craftsman's toolbox, made of cherry wood, with a brass handle, two trays, and a set of chisels and a small mallet that fit inside. The price tag said $50. Sam stopped walking and stood there for a full minute. He had wanted a toolbox like that for as long as he had been building things. It would change how he worked. He could keep his tools in one place, and he could carry them to his grandfather's house when he visited.

DISCUSSION Sam has been earning $5 a week for a year.

That is fifty-two weeks of earnings, or about $260 total. Why does he only have $8 saved? What happened to the rest of the money?

When he got home, Sam opened the small notebook where he tracked his earnings. He had $8 saved, and he needed forty-two more. If he saved every dollar from now on, he could buy the toolbox in about nine weeks, before the start of October.

But if he kept spending some each week, the way he had all year, he would never reach it at all.

What Sam has

What Sam needs

$8 saved so far

$50 for the toolbox

Earns $5 each week

$42 more to save

No plan yet

A plan with a deadline

FIRST INSTINCT Sam has three choices. Which one will actually get him the toolbox? Keep saving when he feels like it. Hope it adds up.

A. Set a specific goal with a deadline. Save the same amount every week.

B. Ask his grandfather to buy the toolbox now.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

S A M ' S S I T U AT I O N

BIG QUESTION

How do you turn a wish into a real goal?

C. Forget the toolbox. Spend his money on whatever he wants each week.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

39

UNIT 2 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

THE SKILL

APPLY

HISTORY

VOCABULARY Goal - a specific thing you are working to reach, with a clear deadline and a plan.

A Goal Needs a Date

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

A wish is something you want. A goal is something you are working toward, with a clear plan to reach it. The difference between a wish and a goal sounds small, but it matters a great deal.

A wish has no plan. You hope it happens. You think about it sometimes. You might even save a little money in its direction. But because there is no deadline, no specific number, and no schedule, the wish stays a wish. Months pass. The money does not add up. The wish stays out of reach. A goal has three parts. It has a specific item or amount. It has a deadline. And it has a weekly plan that shows how the saving will actually happen. With those three parts in place, the wish becomes a real goal. Each week, the saver can check progress and know whether they are on track.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Carlos wants to buy a hobby storage case that costs $30. He has $6 saved. He earns $4 per week mowing his neighbor's lawn.

To turn this wish into a goal, Carlos works out three numbers: Amount still needed: $30 minus $6 equals $24.

Weeks until deadline: Carlos picks a deadline six weeks from today.

Weekly target: $24 divided by 6 weeks equals $4 per week.

Carlos's weekly target matches his weekly earnings exactly.

The plan works, as long as he saves every dollar he earns.

If he wants to spend some of his money each week, he will need to either earn more or extend his deadline.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

40

Deadline - the date by which you want to reach your goal. Without a deadline, a goal is just a wish.

Weekly target - the amount you need to save each week to reach your goal by the deadline.

Found by dividing the total amount needed by the number of weeks.

Progress check - a moment when you compare what you have saved so far to what you should have saved by now.

MONEY RULE

A goal needs a date.

UNIT 2 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

DECISION LAB

Build Sam's Plan STEP 1 Write down the three parts Part of the goal

Sam's number

Item Sam wants

Cherry wood toolbox

Total price

$50

Amount already saved

$8

Amount still needed

$

Sam's weekly earnings

$5

Number of weeks until the goal

$

Weekly target (amount needed ÷ weeks)

$

Two students might choose different plans. Both could be reasonable. What is the trade-off between reaching the goal faster and having some money to spend each week?­

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N Mr. Bennett offers Sam a few extra hours of work helping him reorganize the lumber rack. The job will pay an extra $10 on top of Sam's regular $5 that week.

Sam can take the offer once. How does this change his plan? Does it shorten the deadline? Does it free up some money each week to spend?

STEP 2 Pick a plan Save every dollar of the $5 weekly earnings. Reach the goal in 9 weeks.

Save $3 per week and spend $2 per week on small things. Reach the goal in 14 weeks.

Take the extra job from Mr. Bennett once. Save the bonus plus the regular weekly earnings. Reach the goal in about 7 weeks.

Save nothing extra this week. Decide later.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Now you help Sam turn his wish into a real goal. Use the three parts you just learned about. Fill in the blanks below.

DISCUSSION

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: what makes Sam's goal different from a wish?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

41

UNIT 2 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Egyptian Granaries

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In ancient Egypt, the most important buildings in the whole kingdom were not the palaces, and not even the great pyramids. They were the granaries.

A granary was a tall, round tower of mud brick, with thick walls and a single small opening near the top. Inside, sealed away from rats and rot, sat the grain that the entire kingdom depended on to survive.

Egypt was different from most other ancient lands because of one river. The Nile flooded almost exactly on schedule every year, spreading rich dark mud across the fields on either bank. This mud was so good for growing crops that Egyptian farmers could grow more wheat and barley than their families needed. In a good year, a single farmer could grow enough grain to feed many people.

But not every year was a good year. Some years the Nile flooded too little, and the crops dried up in the fields. Some years it flooded too much and washed away the planted seeds. Some years a plague of insects ate the grain before it could be harvested. In those years, without stored grain, people would starve.

The pharaohs and their officials understood this problem and built a system to handle it. In good years, when the harvest was large, the government collected a portion of every farmer's grain as a tax. This grain was carried by donkey

D I D YO U K N OW ?

Some of the original Egyptian grain tags, made of small pieces of clay with marks pressed into them, still exist in museums today. The tags recorded how much grain was deposited, when, and by whom. They are some of the oldest records of saving and accounting that have survived in the world.

and boat to the great granaries that stood in every major town. The granaries were guarded carefully.

Officials kept careful records of how much grain went in and how much came out, written on small clay tags. In bad years, when the harvest failed, the pharaoh ordered the granaries opened, and the stored grain was given back out to the people as food or as seed for the next planting season.

The granary system lasted for thousands of years.

It was so successful that Egypt rarely suffered the kinds of mass famines that troubled other ancient lands. Even rulers from neighboring countries, when their own harvests failed, would sometimes travel to Egypt to buy grain. The granaries had turned Egypt into the breadbasket of the ancient world.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

42

UNIT 2 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

TWO SCENARIOS

Two Ways to Handle a $5 Bill Sam had set his goal: save $42 more for the toolbox, at $5 a week. He had two ways to handle each week's money. The two look almost identical at first, but over the long run they lead to very different results. The scenarios below show the same eight weeks for two versions of Sam. The first saves whatever is left at the end of each week. The second saves first, then spends what is left. See which one actually reaches the toolbox goal.

DISCUSSION Both versions of Sam earned exactly the same amount of money. Neither had bad luck or wasted money on anything foolish.

So why did the second Sam end up with more than twice the savings of the first?

B E N ’ S S I T U AT I O N Sam who saves last

Sam who saves first

Sam gets $5. He keeps it in his pocket and saves what's left Sunday.

Sam gets $5. He saves $4 first and keeps $1 to spend.

Week 1

Snack after school costs $2. By Sunday, only $3 remains.

$4 saved. Sam spends his $1 on a soda midweek.

Week 2

Sam buys colored pencils for $4. Only $1 is left to save.

$4 saved. Sam still has the $1 in his pocket from last week's leftover. He saves that too.

Week 3

He loses track of spending. By Sunday, only $2 remains.

$4 saved automatically before any spending happens.

Week 4

Bake sale cookies cost money. By Sunday, $1.50 is left.

$4 saved. Sam buys one cookie with his $1.

After 8 weeks Sam has saved about $14 — not halfway there.

After 8 weeks $32 saved plus $1 carried over.

BIG QUESTION

FIRST INSTINCT Who actually paid more?

A. The second Sam earned more money.

B. The second Sam saved his money before he had a chance to spend it.

C. The first Sam had bad luck.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Time

When you earn money, what do you do with it first?

D. The first Sam needed a bigger paycheck.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

43

UNIT 2 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

VOCABULARY

THE SKILL

Pay yourself first - the habit of moving your savings amount out of your pocket before you spend on anything else.

Save First, Spend Second The order in which you handle your money matters more than most people realize. When money sits in your pocket without a plan, it tends to disappear. Small expenses come up. A friend wants a snack.

A sale tempts you. By the end of the week, the money is gone. There is nothing wrong with any one of those small purchases. The problem is that when saving is the last thing you do, it almost never happens.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

There is a simple way to fix this. Before any money goes anywhere else, set aside the amount you have decided to save. Move it. Put it in an envelope, a jar, or a savings account. Get it out of your pocket.

Then live on what is left. This method is called paying yourself first.

The name comes from a useful idea. When you pay rent or bills, you are paying other people. When you save, you are paying your future self. If you pay everyone else first and save last, your future self gets whatever is left, which is usually nothing. If you pay yourself first, your future self gets exactly what you decided to give them.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Liam earns $8 per week mowing the lawn for his neighbor. He has set a goal to save $48 for a model rocket kit by the end of August.

That means he needs to save $6 each week for the next 8 weeks.

Here is what Liam does the moment he receives the $8 from his neighbor. He walks straight home. He folds $6 of the money into his rocket kit envelope. The other $2 goes into his wallet. He has $2 for the week to spend on whatever he wants. If he spends none of the $2, it carries over to next week.

By using this simple system, Liam never has to wonder whether he saved enough. The saving happens automatically, every single week, before he has any chance to spend the money on something else.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

44

Saving rate - the percentage of your money that you save. Sam's plan saves $4 out of every $5, which is an 80% saving rate.

Spending money - the amount left over after you have paid yourself.

This is the money you can spend freely.

Discipline - doing the same useful thing each time, even when you do not feel like it. Saving every week is a kind of discipline.

MONEY RULE

If you pay everyone else first, there is nothing left for you.

UNIT 2 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

C H O O S E Y O U R PAT H

Pick a Saving Method Different savers use different methods to pay themselves first. The methods below all work. Pick the one that fits your situation and your goal.

SCENARIO A hobby storage case How it works

Best for

The envelope

Put the saving amount in a labeled envelope the moment money arrives. Keep it in a safe place.

Small weekly amounts

The two jars

Two jars on a shelf, one labeled SAVE and one labeled SPEND. The save jar gets filled first.

Younger savers; visual reminders

The bank deposit

Take the saving amount to a real bank account each week. Money is harder to spend once deposited.

Larger amounts; longer goals

The lockbox

A small box with a key that only opens once per goal.

The money goes in and stays in until the goal is reached.

Strong temptation to dip into savings

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

Sam's cousin says a savings account pays small monthly interest and is free to open. His parents will help him get one.

Does this change which saving method is better? Why might a bank be safer than keeping money in an envelope?

STEP 2 Pick the right method for Sam. The envelope on the dresser. Simple and easy. Sam can see his progress every day.

The two jars. Even more visible. Sam can watch the save jar fill up week by week.

The bank account at the credit union. The money earns a little interest and is harder to spend on impulse.

The lockbox with a key. Maximum protection from impulse, but no interest earned.

EXIT QUESTION

DISCUSSION

In one sentence: what does paying yourself first actually mean, and why does it work better than saving leftover money?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Method

Why might the same person pick different methods for different goals? For example, why might you use an envelope for a $30 goal but a bank account for a $300 goal?

45

UNIT 2 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Earliest Saving Boxes

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Almost everyone has seen a savings container at some point: a small box or jar with a slot in the top, just big enough for a coin to drop through. A child keeps one on a bedroom shelf. An adult keeps one on the counter for spare change. The idea seems simple and modern, but it is actually one of the oldest inventions in the history of saving money.

In ancient times, ordinary families had no bank accounts. Banks existed only in large cities, and they served wealthy merchants and noble families. A regular person who wanted to save coins had to keep the money safe at home, and the most common solution was a small clay jar. Glass and metal were too expensive for most families, but clay was cheap.

Potters in nearly every village made them, and a saving jar could be bought for almost nothing.

The clever part was the slot. It was just large enough for coins to drop in, but too small for fingers to reach inside. The only way to get the money back out was to break the jar open. Simple as it was, that one detail did something important. It made the saver pause before reaching for their own savings, because taking out a single coin meant destroying the whole container. Most families found it easier to leave the money alone until the jar was full.

D I D YO U K N OW ?

When the Roman city of Pompeii was buried under volcanic ash in the year 79, dozens of household saving jars were preserved exactly where their owners had left them. Some of these jars still contained the coins they had been holding when the disaster struck. Today, more than nineteen hundred years later, those coins are on display in museums in Italy. They are some of the oldest preserved private savings in the world.

Archaeologists have dug up these jars all across the ancient world. Roman saving boxes were found in the buried city of Pompeii. Greek versions, called thesauros, turned up in old marketplaces. Similar containers appear at ancient sites in India, China, and northern Europe. The shapes changed from place to place, but every one had the same feature: a slot money could go into but could not easily come out of. The earliest savers had already figured out something still true today. The best way to keep money you mean to save is to make it just a little harder for yourself to spend it.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

46

UNIT 2 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E M YST E RY

The Envelope That Should Have Had $30 Sam had been paying himself first for six weeks.

Every week, on payday, he had put $4 from his earnings straight into the toolbox envelope. Then he had spent the remaining $1 however he wanted during the week.

On Sunday night at the end of the sixth week, Sam pulled the envelope off his dresser to count the money.

He expected to find $30 inside. That was $4 per week, times six weeks, equals exactly $30. The plan had been simple, and Sam thought he had followed it carefully.

Sam opened the envelope and counted. The total came to $18.

He counted again. $18.

DISCUSSION Look at Sam's notes. How many of the missing $12 can you account for, and how many stay unexplained? What kind of record-keeping would have prevented this?

$12 were missing. Sam had not taken any money out of the envelope on purpose. He had not lost the envelope.

He had not given the money to anyone. But somewhere over the last six weeks, $12 had disappeared. He needed to find out where it went, or his plan would never work.

THE CLUES Sam pulled out his small notebook and tried to remember what had happened week by week. He wrote down what he could recall.

What Sam thinks happened

1

Saved $4. Spent $1 on a snack. Nothing unusual.

2

Saved $4. Spent $1 on pencils. Did he put the full $4 in? He cannot remember.

3

Saved $4. Loaned $3 to Ben at lunch. Ben paid back $1, but never the other $2.

4

Saved $4. Bought a $1 soda, then another $1 soda he forgot about.

5

Saved $4. Bought a $2 magazine. Did he take the extra dollar from the envelope? Maybe.

6

Saved $4. Spent $1 on a snack. Nothing unusual.

FIRST INSTINCT

BIG QUESTION

Where did the $12 go?

A. Someone took the money out of the envelope.

B. Sam spent more than he realized, in small amounts he forgot about.

C. The bank shorted him on his pay.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Week

Where does money go when you do not write it down?

D. He never really saved the full $4 every week.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

47

UNIT 2 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

VOCABULARY

THE CLUES

Tracking - writing down each amount of money you save or spend, so you can see clearly where the money is going.

Ledger - a written list of all money coming in and going out. The earliest ledgers were kept on clay tablets thousands of years ago.

Leak - money that disappears in small amounts that you do not remember spending.

Tracking stops most leaks.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Where Untracked Money Goes When money is not tracked, it tends to leak out in small amounts that no one notices in the moment. A dollar here, $2 there. Each amount on its own feels too small to write down. But the small amounts add up. Six weeks of small leaks added up to twelve missing dollars in Sam's envelope. That is forty percent of what he should have saved.

Most untracked money loss falls into one of three patterns. Knowing the three patterns is half the solution. Once you can see where the money goes, you can start to stop it from going there.

MONEY RULE

If you do not track it, you cannot keep it.

Pattern

How it works

Sam's example

Forgotten purchases

Small spending you do not remember the next day. The money is gone, but you cannot recall where it went.

The extra $1 soda in Week 4 that Sam did not write down.

Unpaid loans to others

Money you lend to friends or family and never get back.

They forget. You forget to ask. The money is just gone.

The $2 of the $3 loan to Ben that was never paid back.

Sneaking from the envelope

Taking a dollar or two out of your savings for a small purchase and telling yourself you will replace it later.

You almost never do.

The extra dollar Sam may have taken from the envelope for the magazine in Week 5.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

48

Account balance - the total amount of money you have right now, based on the numbers in your ledger.

A balance you can check is a balance you can trust.

UNIT 2 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

S O LV E I T

Build Sam's Tracking System Now you help Sam set up a tracking system that will prevent the missing $12 from happening again. Fill in the simple ledger below for the next six weeks.

SAM'S NEW LEDGER SAM'S NEW LEDGER Saved this week

Spent this week (list each thing)

Total saved so far

7

$

8

$

$

9

$

$

10

$

$

11

$

$

12

$

$

$18 + $

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M A T I O N Sam realizes he should talk to Ben about the unpaid $2. He sends Ben a text reminder. Ben apologizes and pays Sam back the next day. How should Sam record the returned $2 in his ledger? Is it new earnings, or is it returning money that was already his?

=$

DISCUSSION Which of the four rules above is the best one? Why are the other three rules likely to lead to missing money?

Think about each of the three patterns of leak from the page before.

Pick Sam's tracking rule.

Write every amount, in and out, in the ledger on the same day it happens.

Write down only the bigger purchases. Skip small ones to save time.

Try to remember everything in his head, then write it down on Sunday.

Keep the envelope but stop tracking. Trust that the system will work.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Week

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: why did writing the numbers down change what happened to Sam's money?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

49

UNIT 2 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

The Mathematician Who Changed Business Forever In the year 1494, in the Italian city of Venice, a mathematician named Luca Pacioli published a thick book about mathematics. Buried in the middle was one short chapter, about thirty pages long, that explained a new way to keep business records. That little chapter would become one of the most important pieces of writing in the history of business.

Before Pacioli, European merchants kept their records in a sloppy way. A trader might scribble what he bought and sold on whatever paper was nearby, some on neat lists, some on the backs of old letters. When a merchant wanted to know whether he was making money or losing it, he often could not tell. His own numbers were too messy to add up clearly.

Pacioli was a teacher and a gifted mathematician who had spent years in Venice, one of the wealthiest trading cities in the world, watching its merchants work. The best of them had built a careful method for tracking money. Pacioli took that method, made it clearer, and explained it in his book so anyone could use it.

D I D YO U K N OW ?

Luca Pacioli was friends with the famous Italian painter and inventor Leonardo da Vinci. The two men worked together on a different book about mathematics, which Leonardo illustrated with his own drawings.

Pacioli taught Leonardo about geometry, and Leonardo helped Pacioli understand how to draw threedimensional shapes.

Together they made one of the most beautiful math books in history.

Pacioli's book was printed on a new machine, the printing press, so copies spread quickly and cheaply.

Within a few decades, merchants all across Europe were using double-entry bookkeeping. More than five hundred years later, every business in the world still uses some form of it. The smallest lemonade stand and the largest company keep their books on the idea Pacioli explained in thirty pages.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

50

INTRO

UNIT 2 | LESSON 4

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

TWO PEOPLE DISAGREE

The Hobby Storage Case Sam had been on his new plan for nine weeks. His ledger was clean and his envelope was on track.

He had saved $36 toward the $50 toolbox, and he needed only three more weeks to reach his goal.

DISCUSSION Neither David nor Grandfather Eli is being foolish. Both arguments make sense. What is the real question Sam needs to answer to decide between them?

Then one Sunday, Sam stopped by the hardware store to look at the toolbox in the window. Nearby he noticed a display he had never seen before: a small mobile hobby storage case with drawers, dividers, and a clip-on lamp on top. The price tag said $25. Below it, a sign read: "Final two in stock.

New shipment in three months."

nine weeks of steady work. The next shipment was three months away, and these were the last two.

Sam thought about what to do. He had $36 in his envelope. He could take $25 and buy the case today, but that would set the toolbox back five weeks, after

He went home and asked his father David and his grandfather Eli what he should do. The two of them had completely different answers.

David's position

Grandfather Eli's position

A plan is a promise. Break it the first time something shiny appears, and the plan is meaningless.

A plan is a tool, not a contract. Its whole point is to help you reach your goals, so it should bend for a real opportunity.

The case is a want, not a need. Wants do not justify breaking a saving plan.

Both are useful tools. If the case will be gone in three months and Sam wants both, buying it now is smart.

Break the plan once and you will break it again. The habit of sticking to a plan is worth more than any one purchase.

Sam is not breaking the plan. He is adjusting it. The toolbox just moves back five weeks, and he still gets both.

FIRST INSTINCT

BIG QUESTION

Who has the better argument?

When should you stick to a plan, and when should you change it?

A. David

B. Grandfather Eli

C. Both have a point

D. Need to know more first

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

THE DISAGREEMENT

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

51

UNIT 2 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

EACH SIDE'S REASONING

APPLY

HISTORY

VOCABULARY Adjustment - a planned change to a plan, made for a good reason. An adjustment moves the deadline or changes the order, but it does not abandon the goal.

When to Bend and When to Stand Firm

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

David and Grandfather Eli are arguing about something that comes up in every long saving plan. Real life does not stand still while a person saves money. New opportunities appear. Prices change. Items sell out. Sometimes the wisest thing is to stick with the original plan, and sometimes the wisest thing is to adjust. The trick is knowing the difference.

David is right when the temptation is just a temptation. If someone abandons the saving plan every time something shiny appears, then the plan has no real meaning. The whole reason a saver makes a plan ahead of time is so that the plan can guide decisions later, when emotions might pull in another direction.

Opportunity cost - the value of what you give up when you make a choice. If Sam buys the case now, his opportunity cost is the five extra weeks before he gets the toolbox.

Scarcity claim - a statement that an item is running out, such as "only two in stock." Real scarcity is rare. Most scarcity claims in stores are sales tactics.

Grandfather Eli is right when the new opportunity is genuine and limited in time. The point of a saving plan is to help the saver reach their goals.

If a real, useful opportunity appears that the original plan did not account for, adjusting the plan is exactly what a smart saver should do.

THE ONE QUESTION Before changing a saving plan, ask yourself these three questions. If the answer to all three is yes, the change is probably an adjustment, not a break.

1.

Is this opportunity actually limited in time, or is the store creating false urgency?

2. Is this item something I would want anyway, or is the discount or scarcity making me want it?

3. Will I still reach my original goal, just on a later date?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

52

Break - an unplanned abandonment of a plan, usually because of impulse. A break means giving up on the goal entirely.

MONEY RULE

A plan can bend, but it should not break.

UNIT 2 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

WHERE THE TRUTH SITS

Stake Your Position Apply the three questions to Sam's situation. For each question, write his honest answer. Then decide whether Sam should stay with his original plan or adjust it.

STEP 1 Fill in the three rows.

Sam's honest answer

1

Is the limit on the hobby case real, or is the store creating fake urgency?

2

Did Sam want a hobby case before he saw it in the store, or did the store make him want it?

3

If Sam buys the case now, will he still reach the toolbox eventually?

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M A T I O N Sam asks the store clerk how often they actually run out of stock on items like the hobby case. The clerk says they almost always get a new shipment within a few weeks, and the "final two in stock" sign goes up on lots of items. How does this change Sam's answer to the first question? Does it change his decision overall?

DISCUSSION Defend your position using the three questions from the page before. Which question matters most? Why?

TAKE A POSITION Sam should buy the hobby case now. The opportunity is real and the toolbox can wait.

Sam should stay with the original plan. The case is not worth breaking the plan for.

Sam should buy the case but extend his saving plan to make up the difference.

Sam should ask his grandfather to buy the case as a birthday gift

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Question to ask

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: what is the difference between adjusting a plan and breaking a plan?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

53

UNIT 2 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

Shackleton and the Endurance

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In December of 1914, a British explorer named Ernest Shackleton sailed south from a port in Argentina aboard a wooden ship called the Endurance. His plan was bold and clear. He and his crew of twenty-seven would land on the icy shore of Antarctica, cross the entire frozen continent on foot and by sled, and come out on the far coast.

No one had ever crossed Antarctica before.

The Endurance reached the edge of the ice in early 1915. But the ice that year was thicker than any map had shown. The ship slowed, then stopped, trapped on every side by floes pressing against the wooden hull. For ten months it drifted, never reaching land. In October, the pressure grew too strong, the hull cracked, and water poured in.

Shackleton and his crew grabbed what they could carry and watched the Endurance sink into the freezing sea. The continent crossing, the whole reason for the expedition, was over before it began.

Most leaders would have despaired. Shackleton did something different. He gathered his crew and announced a new plan on the spot. The goal was no longer to cross Antarctica. The goal now was simpler and harder: get every single man home alive.

Everything from the old plan was thrown out. The new one meant dragging boats across miles of moving ice, camping on drifting floes, eating seal meat to survive, and finally rowing a small boat through some of the

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The journey across the ocean to reach the whaling station was made by Shackleton and five of his men in a small open boat called the James Caird. The boat was about twentythree feet long, with no engine and only a small canvas cover. The men sailed it for over eight hundred miles through some of the stormiest seas in the world. Many sailors today consider that single journey one of the most remarkable open-boat voyages ever made.

deadliest water on Earth. Shackleton adjusted again and again. When the ice broke up, he changed the plan. When food ran low, he changed the plan. When the weather turned, he changed the plan.

After almost two years of constant adjustment, he reached a remote whaling station and organized a rescue. Months later, every one of his twenty-seven men was brought home. Not a single life was lost. By the original goal, the expedition was a complete failure.

By the new goal, it became one of the greatest survival stories in the history of exploration. Shackleton bent his plans endlessly, but he never broke the one promise that mattered, to bring his crew home.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

54

UNIT 2 | LESSON 5

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

THE PROBLEM

A Bigger Goal Sam had reached his toolbox goal. The cherry wood toolbox now sat on the bench in his bedroom, and he used it almost every weekend.

Looking at the toolbox each morning reminded him that saving with a plan actually worked.

Before this summer, Sam had thought of saving as something that happened by accident when he had leftover money. Now he knew it was something he could plan, track, and finish.

Sam started thinking about his next goal. He wanted a complete starter carpentry setup: a workbench, a set of hand planes, a coping saw, and a small bench vise. He had looked at the prices at the hardware store. The whole setup would cost about $150.

DISCUSSION At $5 a week saved fully, it would take Sam thirty weeks to reach $150. That is more than half a year. What problems could come up during such a long saving period? What can Sam do now to prepare for those problems?

This goal was three times the size of the toolbox goal.

Sam realized that the same kind of weekly saving that had worked for the toolbox would still work for this goal, but it would take much longer. He needed to use everything he had learned so far in one combined plan.

Lesson

What it taught him

1

Sam's Goal

A goal needs three parts: a specific item, a deadline, and a weekly target.

2

Pay Yourself First

Move the saving amount out of your pocket before any other spending happens.

3

The Missing Twelve Dollars

Track every dollar in and out in a ledger, so leaks cannot hide.

4

Stay or Adjust?

A plan can bend for real opportunities but should not break for impulses.

FIRST INSTINCT How should Sam start his bigger plan?

A. Use the same envelope-and-ledger method that worked for the toolbox.

B. Open a bank account so he can earn small interest and protect the money.

C. Find a way to earn more money each week, since $150 is a lot at $5 per week.

BIG QUESTION

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

W H A T S A M K N O W S S O FA R

How do you build a saving plan that actually works?

D. Combine all of these ideas into one plan that uses everything he has learned.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

55

UNIT 2 | LESSON 5

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E PA R T S

Putting Every Part of the Plan Together A long-term saving plan has five parts. Each part comes from one of the lessons in this unit. When all five are combined into one plan, the plan becomes much stronger than any single piece on its own.

The first part is the clear goal with a deadline. Sam writes down the exact item he wants, the exact total cost, and the exact date by which he wants to reach the goal. The second part is the weekly target. Sam divides the total amount needed by the number of weeks until the deadline. That number becomes the amount he must save every single week.

The third part is pay yourself first. Sam moves the weekly target out of his pocket the moment he gets paid, into an envelope, a jar, or a bank account. The fourth part is the tracking ledger, a simple written record of every dollar in and every dollar out, checked once a week.

The fifth part is the adjustment rule. Sam decides ahead of time what counts as a reason to change the plan. Real opportunities and real emergencies can justify an adjustment. Small temptations cannot.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Owen wants to save $80 for a model airplane kit by his birthday in twenty weeks. He earns $6 per week walking his neighbor's two cats.

Owen builds his plan using all five parts: Clear goal: $80 model airplane kit by his birthday, twenty weeks from now.

Long-term goal - a goal that takes more than a few weeks to reach. Longterm goals need stronger plans because there is more time for things to go wrong.

Saving system - all five parts of a plan working together. A system is more reliable than any single part by itself.

Milestone - a smaller check-in goal along the way to a bigger goal. For Sam's $150 plan, $50 saved is a milestone. So is $100.

Consistency - doing the same right thing over and over. The toolbox came from consistent saving, not from one big save.

Weekly target: $80 divided by 20 weeks = $4 per week.

Pay yourself first: Owen puts $4 into a jar the moment his neighbor pays him each Sunday.

Tracking: Owen writes each week's deposit in a small notebook and adds up the running total. djustment rule: Owen will only change the plan if the kit A goes on sale by $10 or more, or if a real emergency comes up.

Because Owen saves $4 of his $6 weekly earnings, he has $2 left to spend each week. The plan leaves room for some spending without breaking the saving rate.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

56

VOCABULARY

MONEY RULE

Small amounts saved every week beat big amounts saved sometimes.

UNIT 2 | LESSON 5

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

B U I L D YO U R OW N P L A N

Assemble Sam's $150 Plan Use all five parts of the system. Fill in Sam's complete plan below.

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

STEP 1 The clear goal Sam's answer

Item Sam wants

Starter carpentry setup

Total cost

$150

Amount Sam has now

$0

Deadline (number of weeks from today) Weekly earnings

$5

STEP 2 Calculate the weekly target Divide the total amount Sam needs by the number of weeks until his deadline. Write the answer below.

Weekly target $150 ÷

weeks = $

per week.

STEP 3 Choose where the money goes Envelope on Sam's dresser (simple, visual) Two jars labeled SAVE and SPEND (very visual) Savings account at the credit union (earns interest, protected) Lockbox with a key (strong protection from impulse)

Mr. Bennett offers Sam a raise.

Starting next month, Sam will earn $7 per week instead of $5. How does this change the plan? Does Sam shorten the deadline, lower the weekly target, or increase his spending money? Each of these is a reasonable choice. Which one does Sam pick, and why?

DISCUSSION Two students might fill in the plan very differently. One might pick a fast deadline and a high weekly target. Another might pick a slow deadline and a low weekly target. Both could be defensible. What does the choice between fast and slow tell you about the saver's other priorities?

STEP 4 Write the adjustment rule Sam writes the rule he will follow if a tempting purchase comes up during his thirty weeks of saving.

Fill in the blank.

Sam's adjustment rule: "I will only adjust this plan if

."

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Part

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: which of the five parts of Sam's plan do you think matters most, and why?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

57

UNIT 2 | LESSON 5

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The First Savings Banks

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Two hundred years ago, ordinary working people had almost nowhere safe to keep their money.

Banks existed, but they served merchants and the wealthy and had little use for a servant or a laborer who wanted to deposit a few coins. So most working people kept their savings at home, hidden in a jar, a mattress, or under a loose floorboard, where the money earned nothing and a single fire or theft could wipe it out in a moment.

In the early 1800s, a new kind of bank began to appear, first in Britain and then across America.

It was built for exactly the people the old banks ignored. A laborer, a clerk, or a dockworker could walk in, hand over even a small sum, and open an account. There was no minimum. A person could save a few coins one week and a few more the next, and the bank kept every deposit safe and paid a little interest on top.

The heart of the system was a small booklet called a passbook. Each time a saver made a deposit, a clerk wrote the amount and the new balance into it by hand. The saver carried the passbook home and could open it anytime to see exactly how much had been set aside. For people who had never had a written record of their own money, that slowly growing column of numbers made an invisible habit visible.

The passbook changed how ordinary people thought about saving. A goal that felt impossible all at once, a warm winter coat, a set of tools, a

D I D YO U K N OW ?

Early passbooks were filled in entirely by hand, and the bank kept its own matching record of every deposit. The two copies had to agree exactly. Some families kept the same passbook for decades, adding small amounts year after year, until a worn passbook crowded with tiny deposits became a kind of family record, proof of a lifetime of patient saving.

start on a home, became reachable when it was broken into small weekly deposits. A saver could watch the balance climb toward the number he needed, while the bank held the money safely, added the interest, and kept the record. He only had to keep showing up with a few coins.

These savings banks spread quickly. Within a few decades, millions of working people across Britain and America held passbook accounts, many saving for the first time in their lives. The idea was simple but enormous. Saving was no longer only for the rich. Anyone willing to set aside a little, again and again, could build something real. Every modern savings account grew from those first small banks built for ordinary people.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

58

FORM 2 TAX, PERCENT OFF, AND TIPS

A savings goal tracker is a written record of your progress toward a saving goal. It shows the goal, the deadline, the weekly target, and how much you have saved each week. The tracker can be a simple paper form on your desk, a notebook page, or a card pinned to your wall. The format does not matter as much as the habit of filling it in every single week. A tracker turns saving from a vague hope into something you can see clearly. When the numbers go up each week, the tracker becomes proof that the plan is working.

Line

What this section does!

This section covers two realworld forms you will use as a saver, a review case study that ties the unit together, and a final reflection on what you have learned.

Detail

What this part is

1

Goal: Cherry wood toolbox

The specific item being saved for. Use exact words, not "hobby stuff."

2

Total cost: $50.00

The full price including tax, so the deadline is realistic.

3

Starting amount: $8.00

How much was already saved on the day the goal was set.

4

Amount still needed: $42.00

Total cost minus starting amount. This is what the weekly target divides into.

5

Deadline: October 15

A specific date. Without a date, the deadline is just a wish.

6

Weeks until deadline: 9 weeks

Count the number of weekly paydays between today and the deadline.

7

Weekly target: $4.67

Amount still needed divided by weeks. Round up to the nearest dollar to leave a small cushion.

8

Week 1: $5 saved. Total: $13

Each week's actual deposit, plus the running total of money saved so far.

9

Week 2: $5 saved. Total: $18

Filled in every Sunday night, after the weekly pay is received.

10

Notes column

A short note for unusual weeks: a missed payment, an extra deposit, a borrowed dollar.

11

Progress: 36% of goal

Total saved divided by total cost. Watching this percentage rise is the reward for sticking to the plan.

12

Deadline check: ON TRACK

Each Sunday, compare actual savings to where the plan said they should be. Mark ON TRACK or BEHIND.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

A Savings Goal Tracker

PRACTICAL A P P L I C AT I O N S

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

59

YOUR TURN

Build Your Own Tracker Pick a real saving goal of your own. The goal can be anything you actually want, big or small. Fill in every line of the tracker below. If you do not know one of the numbers yet, take a few minutes to find it out before writing.

Line

Your answer

Goal (exact item)

$

Total cost (with tax)

$

Starting amount

$

Amount still needed:

$

Deadline (specific date)

Weeks until deadline

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Weekly target

$

Source of weekly earnings

Where the saved money will go

Progress check day each week

C H EC K YO U R S E L F Before you put the tracker away, look at the weekly target. Does the number look realistic compared to your weekly earnings? If the weekly target is more than half of what you earn each week, you may have set the deadline too soon. If the weekly target is less than a fifth of your earnings, you might be giving yourself too much time. Both problems are easy to fix by adjusting the deadline.

60

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

FORM 2 A BANK DEPOSIT SLIP

How to Fill Out a Bank Deposit Slip

TIP

A deposit slip is a small paper form that you fill out when you bring money to a bank to put into your savings account. The form tells the bank teller how much you are depositing, what kind of money it is, and which account it should go into. Many people use mobile deposits today, but paper deposit slips are still common at most banks, and they are still required for certain kinds of deposits. Knowing how to fill one out correctly is a basic skill every saver should learn.

usbank SAMPLE DEPOSIT SLIP

1 DATE

2

09/17/2026 Sam Lewis 1234567890

5

CASH

1 5 0 0

6

CHECK

0 0 0

CHECK OR 7 TOTAL FROM OTHER SIDE

0 0 0

8

LESS CASH RECEIVED

0 0 0

9

SUBTOTAL

1 5 0 0

10

$

1 5 0 0

ACCOUNT HOLDER'S NAME

3

Sam Lewis

ACCOUNT NUMBER

4 SIGNATURE

1 Date of deposit

5 Cash amount (bills and coins)

2 Account holder's name

6 Check amount (if depositing one check)

3 Account number

7 Total of checks listed on the back

4 Signature (only if taking cash back)

8 Total deposit before taking cash back

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Always keep a copy of the deposit slip, or take a photo of it, until the deposit shows up correctly in your account.

Mistakes do happen, and a slip is the proof that the deposit was made.

9 Cash you want back from the deposit 10 Final amount deposited into your account

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

61

YOUR TURN

Fill Out a Deposit Slip You are at the credit union on a Sunday afternoon. You have three $1 bills, a $5 bill, and twelve quarters in your pocket.

You also have a $25 check from your aunt as a birthday gift.

You want to deposit all of it into your savings account.

STEP 1 Figure out the cash total Bills total: $

Coins total: $

Cash total: $

STEP 2 Fill out the deposit slip

usbank

CASH

DEPOSIT SLIP

CHECK CHECK OR TOTAL FROM OTHER SIDE

DATE

LESS CASH RECEIVED

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

ACCOUNT HOLDER'S NAME

SUBTOTAL

ACCOUNT NUMBER

$

SIGNATURE

STEP 3 Check your work Does your subtotal equal the cash amount plus the check amount? Does your net deposit equal the subtotal minus any cash you took back? If both answers are yes, the slip is correct and ready for the teller.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

62

REVIEW CASE STUDY

Sam's New Goal Sam has reached his toolbox goal. He has $4 left in his savings envelope after buying the toolbox. Now he wants to start saving for a small portable workbench that costs $90. He will continue earning $5 per week at the carpentry workshop. Work through Sam's new plan using everything you have learned in this unit.

CHECK YOUR WORK There is more than one defensible answer to this case. The point is not to find the one right answer.

The point is to use the Money Rules from this unit in your reasoning, so that the plan you build is one you can explain and defend.

T H E S I T U AT I O N DISCUSSION Sam wants a portable workbench. The hardware store sells it for $90.

Sam currently has $4 in his envelope from the toolbox savings.

Sam earns $5 per week at the workshop.

Sam wants the workbench before the start of the new year, which is twenty weeks away.

Sam's parents have offered to help him open a savings account at the credit union, which pays a small amount of interest each month.

Compare your plan to a classmate's plan. Did the two of you set the same weekly target? Did you pick the same place to keep the money? If your answers were different, whose plan is stronger, and why? Defend your choice using at least two Money Rules from this unit.

Question to answer

Which Money Rule helps?

Your answer

What is Sam's amount still needed? $ What is Sam's weekly target to reach $90 in twenty weeks?

$

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

WA L K T H R O U G H T H E P L A N

Should Sam use his envelope or the new savings account? Why? What would Sam's adjustment rule look like for this longer plan?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

63

UNIT CLOSE

Looking Back at Ben's Unit Sam started this unit by stopping in front of a hardware store window and seeing a toolbox he wanted but could not afford. Over five lessons, he learned how to turn that wish into a real plan and then carry the plan to the finish line. He learned that a goal needs a specific deadline. He learned to pay himself first, so saving did not depend on willpower. He learned to track every dollar in a simple ledger, so leaks could not hide.

He learned how to tell the difference between adjusting a plan and breaking it. And he learned how to put all of those parts together into one stronger plan for a bigger goal.

None of these ideas is complicated. The hard part is not knowing them. The hard part is doing them every week, even on weeks when nothing exciting is happening, even on weeks when the goal still feels far away. Saving is mostly a quiet habit.

The toolbox came not from one big move, but from many small moves repeated for many weeks in a row.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

THE MONEY RULES FROM THIS UNIT Lesson 1

A goal needs a date.

Lesson 2

If you pay everyone else first, there is nothing left for you.

Lesson 3

If you do not track it, you cannot keep it.

Lesson 4

A plan can bend, but it should not break.

Lesson 5

Small amounts saved every week beat big amounts saved sometimes.

R E A L- W O R L D A P P L I C A T I O N Choose one Money Rule from this unit. Write about a goal of your own, real or imagined, that this rule would help you reach. Use the exact words of the rule somewhere in your writing. Be specific about what you would save, by when, and how the rule would guide what you do each week along the way.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

64

Unit 3

Earn Smart How do I set my own price and earn what my work is worth?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

BIG QUESTION FOR THE UNIT

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

65

Meet Max Max is in sixth grade. He is strong for his age and likes physical work outdoors. His grandfather taught him how to handle a rake, a shovel, and a wheelbarrow before he was eight years old. Max enjoys finishing a yard job and seeing the whole place look better than when he started. Last summer, Max started doing yard work for neighbors.

He works Sunday afternoons and a few weekday afternoons after school.

His first regular customer was Mr. Albertson, an older neighbor three doors down. Mr. Albertson believes a young worker should learn three things early: set your own price, track your own hours, and stand behind your own work. Mr. Albertson has been Max's regular customer for six months now. In this unit, Max works through the five parts of earning money well. Each lesson teaches him one piece of how a real earning plan works.

W H AT ' S I N T H I S U N I T Lesson

Money Rule

1

The Yard Job

Set the price before you start the work.

2

Active vs Passive Income

Working money is good. Money that keeps working is better.

3

The Missing Hour

Hours you do not track are hours you do not get paid for.

4

Negotiating the Rate

The first number is rarely the last number.

5

Max’s Earning Plan

What you can do in an hour is what you earn in an hour.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

#

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

66

UNIT 3 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E S I T U AT I O N

Half a Deal

Max said, “Sure.”

Mr. Henderson said, “Good. We will figure out the price after I see how it looks.”

Max walked home thinking about the conversation.

He had agreed to a job on Sunday afternoon. He had no idea how big the yard was, how much trash was in it, or how long the job would take. He also had no idea what Mr. Henderson would pay. The job was set. The price was not.

DISCUSSION Why might Mr. Henderson have said “we will figure out the price after I see how it looks”? Was he trying to be unfair? Or was he just doing what most people do when they hire someone for the first time?

Max’s grandfather happened to be at the house that afternoon. When Max told him the story, his grandfather frowned. “You agreed to a job,” his grandfather said, “but you did not agree to a price.

That is half a deal. Either you do the job and accept whatever Mr. Henderson decides to pay, or you go back tonight and set a price before Sunday comes.”

FIRST INSTINCT

BIG QUESTION

What should Max do?

A. Show up Sunday and do the job. Take whatever Mr. Henderson offers.

B. Go back to Mr. Henderson tonight and ask to walk the yard before Sunday.

Set a price then.

C. Call Mr. Henderson and back out of the job.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

On a weekday afternoon, Mr. Henderson stopped Max as Max was walking home from school. Mr. Henderson was a tall man who lived four houses down from Max. Max had never worked for him before. Mr. Henderson said, “My back yard is a mess. Can you come Sunday and clean it up?”

How do you decide what your work is worth?

D. Show up Sunday with a price in mind and tell Mr. Henderson before he starts.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

67

UNIT 3 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

THE SKILL

VOCABULARY Quote - a price set in advance for a specific job.

Sometimes also called an estimate.

Setting the Price Before the Work A price set before the work is called a quote. A quote tells both sides exactly what to expect. When a worker gives a customer a quote, the worker is saying, “This is what I will charge for this job.” The customer either accepts the quote or asks for a different number.

Once a quote is accepted, both sides know what the deal is, and neither side gets a surprise later.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

A price set after the work is not really a price. It is a wish on both sides.

The customer wishes to pay less than they expected. The worker wishes to be paid more than they expected. When the work is done, the two sides argue about a number that should have been settled days ago.

There is a simple reason setting a price first works better. Before the work begins, both sides can walk away. The customer can say, “That price is too high. I will find someone else.” The worker can say, “That price is too low. I will not do it.” After the work is done, neither side can walk away. The work is finished. The lawn is cut. The leaves are raked. The trash is hauled.

Scope - the exact list of what work is included in the price. Anything not in the scope is a separate job.

Payment terms - when and how the customer will pay. Common terms are “paid when finished” or “paid by the end of the week.”

MONEY RULE

Set the price before you start the work.

Walking away then means doing the work for free, or refusing to pay.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Owen mows lawns at $12 per yard. He uses three steps to set every price: He walks the yard and counts how many grass clippings he will bag.

He estimates how long the work will take.

He gives a quote: “$12 for the front and back, paid when I finish.”

If the yard is bigger than usual, or if there is extra work like trimming hedges, Owen adjusts the price upward before he starts. He never raises the price after the work has begun.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

68

Rate - a price per hour, per yard, or per item. A rate is the building block of a quote.

INTRO

UNIT 3 | LESSON 1

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

DECISION LAB

Build Max’s Quote Max walks Mr. Henderson’s yard with him on Friday afternoon. He sees the following. Use the rate guide below to build Max’s quote.

STEP 1 What Max sees in the yard Area

Condition

Front yard (30 ft x 40 ft)

Three trees. Heavy leaf cover.

Back yard (30 ft x 50 ft)

Three more trees. More leaves. One small flower bed.

Back patio

Trash: a broken plastic chair, an empty box, scraps of wood.

Total estimated work time

About 3 hours

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N When Max arrives Sunday, he sees three things he did not see on Friday: an old garden shed half torn down that has wood scraps to be hauled, a pile of broken bricks behind the garden, and several heavy planter pots filled with dirt. None of this was in the original quote. What should Max do? Should he finish the original work and skip the extras, do the extras for free, or stop and ask Mr. Henderson for a new quote on the surprise work?

STEP 2 Max’s rate guide (from his grandfather) Rate

Yard clean-up (leaves, basic tidy)

$8 per hour

Trash removal (haul to the curb)

$5 flat fee

Hedge trimming or extra trimming work

$5 per hour extra

Is it ever fair to raise a price after a job has started? When?

Two students might disagree. What makes the difference between a fair adjustment and an unfair one?

STEP 3 Calculate Max’s quote Trash removal fee: $5

Estimated hours of yard clean-up: Hours times rate: × $8 = $

Quote total to give Mr. Henderson: $

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

DISCUSSION Type of work

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: what is a quote, and why does setting one before the work make life easier for both sides?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

69

UNIT 3 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Roman Forum Price Lists

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Walk into the central square of any great Roman city, the forum, and you would find prices nailed to the walls. Wooden boards hung outside the shops, and on them tradesmen wrote their rates in plain view. A cobbler’s board listed the cost of new sandals, sole repair, and new straps. A baker’s board showed the price of a loaf of bread and a wheel of cheese. A builder’s board gave his charge for a day of stone-laying or a day of plastering.

This was unusual for the ancient world. In most other cities, a price was a secret between the tradesman and each customer, settled by haggling.

Roman tradesmen worked in the open. By posting their rates, they invited customers to compare one shop against another. A wealthy family who wanted a new mosaic could walk the forum, read the boards, and choose the artist whose rates and reputation fit their plans.

Public pricing changed how Romans thought about work. A price was no longer something to argue over after the job was done. It was declared up front, in writing, where anyone could see it. A tradesman who could not deliver good work at his posted rate lost customers. One who delivered well could hold his rates above his rivals, and customers still came.

The boards protected customers too. If a tradesman tried to charge more than his board

D I D YO U K N OW ?

Many of the Roman price boards have been recovered by archaeologists, especially from the ruins of Pompeii, the Roman city buried by a volcanic eruption in the year 79. The boards were carved into stone or scratched into plaster walls. They show prices for everything from a loaf of bread to a day of skilled work.

Reading these prices today is like looking through a window into ordinary Roman life.

had promised, the customer could point to the public rate as proof, and the local courts sided with the customer almost every time. The whole system rested on one principle: a price written down before the work started was binding on both sides.

When the Roman Empire fell, the price boards fell with it. In the medieval cities that followed, prices went private again, haggled shop by shop and often kept secret. It would take more than a thousand years before posted public prices returned to European cities. The Roman idea, simple as it was, had been one of the great commercial inventions of the ancient world.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

70

UNIT 3 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

TWO SCENARIOS

Two Ways to Spend a Summer Max has been doing yard work all spring. He has gotten good at it. His grandfather has also been teaching him how to build small wooden bird feeders on Sunday afternoons. A bird feeder takes about an hour to build and costs around $3 in wood and screws. The hardware store on Pine Street buys finished bird feeders from local builders. The store pays the builder $8 for each feeder, and then sells the feeders at the front counter to customers.

Now summer is coming. Max has eight weeks. He has been thinking about two different plans for how to spend his time. Read both plans below.

They look similar at first. After eight weeks, they lead to very different results.

DISCUSSION Plan B has more total earnings after eight weeks, but Max also works two more hours each week. Is the extra two hours worth the extra income? What if Max could only work nine hours a week, no more?

Plan A All Yard Work

Plan B Yard Work + Bird Feeders

3 yards each week at $10 per yard.

2 yards each week (6 hrs) + builds 5 bird feeders (5 hrs).

Weekly earnings: $30.

Weekly yard earnings: $20.

Hours per week: 9.

Hours per week: 11.

Miss a week? No earnings.

Miss a week? Feeders can still sell.

After 8 weeks: $240 earned.

After 8 weeks: $160 from yards + about $120 from feeders.

FIRST INSTINCT

BIG QUESTION

Which plan would you pick if you were Max?

What is the difference between money you keep working for, and money that keeps working for you?

A. Plan A. It pays more right now and the math is simple.

B. Plan B. Less money now, more earning potential later.

C. Some mix of both.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

M A X ’ S S I T U AT I O N

D. Neither. Max should find a different kind of work.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

71

UNIT 3 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

W H AT M A K E S T H E M D I F F E R E N T

Active Earning and Building Earning There are two basic ways to earn money. Most workers spend their lives doing one of them. The smartest workers learn to do both.The first way is called active earning. You trade time for money. You show up. You do the work. You get paid. When you stop, the money stops. Max’s yard work is active earning. Each yard he rakes earns $10 right then. If he stops raking, no more money comes in. Most jobs in the world are active earning.

The second way is called building earning. You do work once. The thing you built, or the skill you learned, or the thing you bought, then earns money for you over a longer time. Max’s bird feeders are building earning. Each feeder takes about an hour to build. After Max delivers it to the store, the feeder sits on the shelf. When a customer buys it, Max gets paid $8. The feeder might sell the same week, or it might sell three weeks later. Either way, Max made the feeder once and got paid once.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Building earning is not magic. The work still has to happen. Max still spends his Sunday afternoon building. But the timing is different.

Active earning pays you for the hour you work. Building earning pays you for the work after the work is finished, sometimes weeks later.

And the more things you have built, the more money can come in while you are doing other things.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Theo lives in the same neighborhood as Max. Theo also does yard work. He earns about $25 a week in active income from raking and mowing. But Theo also has a hobby: he paints small wooden signs with house numbers on them, the kind a family hangs by their front door. Each sign takes him about two hours and costs $4 in materials. He sells them through the same hardware store for $20 each. After he pays for the materials, he keeps $16 per sign.

Two months ago, Theo built ten signs and dropped them off at the store. Last month, he built five more. This month, he is busy with a school project and has not built any new signs.

But he still earned $32 from his signs this month, because the older signs kept selling. The work he did two months ago is still earning him money today.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

72

VOCABULARY Active income - money you earn in direct trade for your time. When you stop, the money stops.

Building income - money you earn from work already done. The work happens once. The pay can come later.

Inventory - things you have built or bought that can be sold over time. Each item earns once it sells.

Reinvestment - putting some of your earnings back into more materials or tools, so you can build more and earn more.

MONEY RULE

Working money is good. Money that keeps working is better.

UNIT 3 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

DISCUSSION C H O O S E Y O U R PAT H

Plan Max’s Summer Help Max decide what mix of active and building work fits his summer. Fill in the table below for each plan and compare the totals after eight weeks.

Item

Plan A

Yards per week

3

Pay per yard

$10

Weekly earnings

$

Total over 8 weeks

$

Hours of work per week

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

STEP 1 Calculate Plan B (yard work + bird feeders) Item

Plan B

Yards per week Weekly yard earnings

$

Bird feeders built per week

5

Net profit per feeder (after materials)

$5

Average feeders sold per week (after 3 weeks)

3

Weekly feeder earnings (after 3 weeks) Total weekly earnings (after 3 weeks)

The hardware store owner tells Max that a craft fair is coming to town in six weeks. The fair manager has asked the store to bring fifty handmade bird feeders. If Max builds extra feeders now, the store will buy all of them at the same $8 price to sell at the fair. Does this change Max’s plan? Should he build more than five feeders some weeks?

What is the most he could earn if he doubled his Sunday building time for the next six weeks?

2

$ $

STEP 3 Pick the plan that fits Max best P lan A. Simple and steady. No materials to buy. No risk of unsold feeders.

P lan B. More total earnings. Builds inventory that keeps selling.

A mixed version. Yard work plus a few feeders, but not five every week.

P lan B plus the craft fair extras.

Maximum earning, more building time.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

STEP 1 Calculate Plan A (all yard work)

What is the risk in Plan B that does not exist in Plan A? If a feeder does not sell, what happens to Max’s $3 in materials?

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: what is the difference between active income and building income?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

73

UNIT 3 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

The Miller and His Windmill In medieval Europe, a windmill cost a fortune to build. The wooden tower had to stand thirty or forty feet tall to catch the wind. The stone wheels that ground the grain weighed thousands of pounds and had to be quarried from just the right hard rock. The oak gears took skilled woodworkers a year or more to cut, and the canvas sails had to be sewn and rigged by experienced sail makers. A windmill could cost as much as a stone house, far beyond what any ordinary farmer could afford.

But once it stood, a windmill earned money for the rest of its life. Farmers from miles around had no real choice but to bring their grain to be ground. Grinding by hand with a stone took hours and left the flour rough and full of grit. The windmill ground the same grain in minutes, and the flour came out fine and even.

The miller took a portion of every load as payment, usually a tenth or a twelfth, and sent the farmer home with the rest as flour. He did not have to chase customers. The wind did the grinding. The mill drew the farmers. The miller only had to keep it in working order, collect his share, and sell the surplus grain to bakers in town.

When the miller grew old, he passed the mill to his son, and with it the steady income. A well-built

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The oldest still-working windmill in Europe is in Outwood, England. It was built in 1665. For more than three hundred and fifty years, the same building has been grinding grain into flour. Many generations of one family have run it, and the mill is still earning money today.

windmill could earn for a family for two hundred years or more. It paid for the children’s schooling, for new farm tools, for the family home, and the family still owned the mill at the end of every year.

Compare that to a farm laborer. He worked sunrise to sunset, six days a week, and the moment he stopped, the pay stopped. He could not pass his work to his son; the son had to start over from nothing. The miller had built something once that kept earning. The laborer earned every coin only in the moment he worked. Both kinds of work were honest, but over a lifetime, one built wealth and the other did not.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

74

UNIT 3 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E M YST E RY

The Job That Should Have Paid $10 an Hour Max finished a Sunday yard job for Mr. Reyes, an older neighbor on the next block. Mr. Reyes paid him $30 in cash. Max walked home feeling good. The plan, he had told his grandfather earlier that week, was simple: three hours of work, $10 an hour, $30 total.

His grandfather was on the porch when he got home. "What time did you start?" he asked.

Max had started after lunch, around one o'clock.

"And what time did you finish?"

Max checked the clock. It was six. Five hours had passed, not three. His grandfather wrote two numbers on a piece of paper: $30 and five hours. "At five hours, your real rate today was $6 an hour, not ten," he said. "Two hours went

DISCUSSION Look at Max's time blocks. How many of the five hours were spent doing the actual paid work of raking, bagging, and hauling?

How many hours were spent on other things like walking, waiting, and talking? somewhere you didn't plan for. Where did they go?" The job had not felt like five hours, but the clock said otherwise. Somewhere between starting and finishing, two hours of Max's afternoon had disappeared, and he needed to find them.

THE CLUES Max sat with his grandfather and tried to remember the whole afternoon, step by step.

1:00 to 1:20

Walked to Mr. Reyes's house and stopped for tools.

1:20 to 1:50

Mr. Reyes explained the job and told a story.

1:50 to 2:30

Raked the front yard.

2:30 to 2:50

Sat on the back step. Drank water. Looked over the rest of the yard.

2:50 to 4:20

Raked the back yard and bagged the leaves.

4:20 to 4:35

Mr. Reyes came out to chat and asked about Max's grandfather.

4:35 to 5:30

Cleaned the back patio. Hauled the trash to the curb.

5:30 to 6:00

Walked home, putting tools away on the way.

FIRST INSTINCT Why was Max's real rate $6 an hour instead of ten?

A. Mr. Reyes underpaid him.

B. Max worked slower than he expected to.

C. Max never wrote down his actual hours, so he guessed wrong on the price.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

What Sam thinks happened

BIG QUESTION

Why does Max sometimes earn less per hour than he thinks?

D. Yard work is just slow.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

75

UNIT 3 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

VOCABULARY THE CLUES Hourly rate - the amount you earn per hour. Always tied to a specific definition of "hour" (working hour or total time).

Where the Missing Hours Go When you do not track your hours, you guess. When you guess about hours, you also guess about what you really earned per hour. Most workers, young and old, guess wrong in the same direction. They count the work that felt productive, and they forget the time that felt like nothing happened. But the clock counts everything, productive or not.

Most untracked time falls into one of four patterns. Once you learn to spot them, you can plan around them, or you can charge for them.

Either way, the guessing stops.

Working hour - an hour spent doing the actual paid task. Raking, bagging, hauling.

Total time - every minute from leaving home to coming home. Setup, breaks, conversation, and the work itself.

Effective rate - your total pay divided by your total time. The number that tells you what your afternoon really earned.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

MONEY RULE

Hours you do not track are hours you do not get paid for.

Pattern

What it looks like

Max's example

Setup time

Getting to the job. Gathering tools. Putting on work clothes. The work has not started yet.

Twenty minutes walking and grabbing tools.

Talk time

Conversation with the customer that is not part of the work. Stories. Small talk. Catching up.

Almost an hour of Mr. Reyes telling stories and asking about his grandfather.

Break time

Resting. Drinking water. Looking around.

Catching a breath. Necessary, but not paid work.

Twenty minutes on the back step.

Cleanup and travel back

Putting tools away. Walking home. The work is done, but the day is not over.

Thirty minutes packing up and walking home.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

76

UNIT 3 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

S O LV E I T

Build Max's Time Log Max's next job is for Mr. Albertson on Sunday afternoon. The plan is to clean the front and back yard, haul one bag of trash, and trim the hedge

along the fence. Max wants to track every minute this time, so he will know his real rate at the end.

Fill in the time log below.

SAM'S LEDGER S T E P NEW 1 Max's time log for Mr. Albertson's yard Time block

What Max is doing

WA I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

Counts as

Start time

(time log starts)

First 15 min

Walking over, getting tools out

Setup

Next

min

Raking front yard

Working

Next

min

Water break, chatting with Mr. Albertson

Break and talk

Next

min

Raking back yard

Working

Next

min

Trimming the hedge

Working

Next

min

Trimming the hedge

Working

Next

min

Hauling trash to the curb

Working

Putting tools away, walking home

Cleanup

Last 15 min

Mr. Albertson notices Max using a time log and is impressed. He tells Max to charge based on working hours, but set the rate high enough to cover setup and travel.

If working time is worth $12 per hour, what should Max quote next time?

S T E P 3 Pick the rule that fits Max best Track every minute. Charge a higher rate to cover all time, including setup.

Track only the productive working hours. Quote a flat fee that includes setup.

Skip tracking. Estimate the hours and hope for the best.

Track only the longer jobs (more than three hours). Skip tracking for short ones.

S T E P 2 Calculate Max's effective rate Total time from start to end:

hours

Total payment from Mr. Albertson: $30 Effective rate (payment divided by total time): $

DISCUSSION Look back at the four patterns of missing time on the previous page.

Which one is hardest to control? Which one is easiest to plan around or charge for?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

(time log ends)

End time

per hour

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: why does writing down your time change what you actually earn per hour?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

77

UNIT 3 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Clay Tablets of Sumer

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In the ancient land of Sumer, in what is now southern Iraq, people invented one of the oldest writing systems on Earth. They did not invent it to tell stories. They invented it to keep track of work and pay. The earliest Sumerian writing was simply lists: how many days a worker had worked, how many loaves of bread he was given as pay, how many jars of beer came with his meals.

Sumerian workers were paid in food, not coins. A laborer building a city wall received a set number of loaves each day, plus jars of beer and oil for cooking, with the amount depending on his skill and his hours. A foreman tracked it all on a small clay tablet, pressing marks into the soft clay with a sharpened reed. The tablet was then dried hard in the sun, so the record would last.

This meant no work could be forgotten. When a worker showed up, his name and hours went into the clay before the day ended. At week's end, the foreman counted the marks and handed out pay to match. A worker could not be cheated by a foreman who claimed he had never come, because the tablet was the proof. And a foreman could not lose track of who he had hired, because the tablets told him.

Some of these tablets, baked hard by the sun more than four thousand years ago, still sit in museums today. They show exactly how many

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The Sumerians wrote on clay with a tool called a stylus, which looked like a sharpened reed pen. The marks they made are now called cuneiform, which means "wedge-shaped." Scholars today can still read these marks, more than four thousand years after they were pressed into the clay.

Many of the tablets on display in museums today are work records, ration lists, and pay logs from ordinary working people.

loaves a Sumerian carpenter earned in a day, and how many jars of beer a brickmaker received with his meals. They are among the oldest writings on Earth, and what they record is not poetry or law or the deeds of kings. They record the daily work and daily pay of ordinary people.

The lesson is simple. Tracking hours and tracking pay are among the oldest jobs writing has ever done. The first people who learned to write learned for exactly this reason. If you want to be paid fairly for your time, somebody has to write the time down.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

78

INTRO

UNIT 3 | LESSON 4

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

TWO PEOPLE DISAGREE

$15 or $25?

Mr. Henderson stopped Max again on a weekday afternoon, two weeks after the first job. "My yard needs another clean-up," Mr. Henderson said.

"Same kind of work as last time. I will pay you $15."

Max walked through the yard with him and looked closely. The job looked bigger than the first one.

Heavier leaf cover. Two extra trees that had dropped a lot of debris. Max estimated three full hours of work. Using his rate guide, three hours at $8 per hour came to $24. Add the trash hauling, and the real price was closer to $25, not fifteen.

Max told Mr. Henderson he would think about it and called him later. That evening, Max asked Owen and his grandfather what he should do. The two of them had very different answers.

DISCUSSION Neither Owen nor Max's grandfather is being foolish. Both arguments make sense in different situations. What facts about the job would make Owen's view right? What facts would make grandfather's view right?

Owen's position

Grandfather's position

Take the fifteen. That is good money for a sixth grader on a weekend. Most kids your age earn nothing.

Ask for twenty-two and explain why. Show him the rate guide. Customers respect a worker who knows his own value.

Push for more and Mr. Henderson might hire someone else. Fifteen in your pocket beats twenty-five you do not get.

Take fifteen for $25 of work, and he learns he can underpay you. The next job will be underpaid too.

You are still learning. Build the relationship first, raise the price later.

Show your value now. A customer who respects your prices will respect them next time too.

FIRST INSTINCT

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

THE DISAGREEMENT

BIG QUESTION

Who has the better argument?

A. Owen

B. Grandfather

C. Both have a point

D. Need to know more first

When should you ask for more, and when should you accept the offer?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

79

UNIT 3 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

EACH SIDE'S REASONING

HISTORY

VOCABULARY Negotiation - the backand-forth between two people about the price of something. Most prices are negotiable.

Counter-offer - a different price you propose in response to a customer's first offer.

Always comes with a reason.

Counter-Offers and First Numbers

Anchor - the first number mentioned in a negotiation. It pulls all later numbers in its direction, even if it is unfair.

Owen and Max's grandfather are arguing about something that comes up in nearly every job offer. The first price a customer names is almost never the customer's best price. It is the starting point. The worker has the choice to accept it, walk away, or propose a different number. This back-and-forth is called negotiation, and most adults do it every time they buy a car, take a new job, or hire a contractor.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Walk-away price - the lowest price you would actually accept. Know your walk-away price before you start the conversation.

Owen is right when the price difference is small, when other workers are competing for the same job, or when the worker is new and needs to build a customer relationship. In those cases, accepting the offer can be smarter than pushing for a few extra dollars and losing the work entirely.

MONEY RULE

The first number is rarely the last number.

Max's grandfather is right when the worker has a clear basis for a higher price, when the customer values the worker's specific skill, and when accepting a low offer would set the customer's expectations badly for future jobs. In those cases, a polite counter-offer with a reason almost always works better than silent acceptance.

HOW TO COUNTER-OFFER IN THREE SENTENCES How to counter-offer in three sentences The classic counter-offer follows the same three-sentence pattern. Use it word for word until you are comfortable making it your own.

1.

"Thank you for the offer." (Be polite. Acknowledge what they said.)

2. "Based on the work involved, I would normally charge 3. "Could we agree to

?" (Propose the meeting point. Leave room for them to say yes.)

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

80

." (Name your number, with a reason.)

UNIT 3 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

WHERE THE TRUTH SITS

Stake Your Position Apply the counter-offer pattern to Max's situation. Write the exact words Max should use when he calls Mr. Henderson back.

STEP 1 Calculate Max's real price Work item

Calculation

1

Yard clean-up: 3 hours at $8/hour

2

Trash hauling (flat fee)

3

Max's total normal price

$ $5

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N Mr. Henderson calls Max back the next day. He says: "Look, I started at fifteen because I did not want to overpay for a kid's job. But I respect that you walked the yard before naming a price. Show me your rate guide and we can talk." How does Max's counteroffer change now that Mr. Henderson has invited the conversation? Is twenty-two still the right ask?

$ DISCUSSION

Sentence 1: "Mr. Henderson, thank you for the offer."

Sentence 2: "Based on the work involved, I would normally charge $

because

Sentence 3: "Could we agree to $

." ?"

Compare the four positions above.

Which one builds the strongest long-term relationship with the customer? Which one earns Max the most money this Sunday? Why are those two answers not the same?

TAKE A POSITION Max accepts the $15. He keeps the customer happy and builds the relationship for future jobs.

Max counters at $22 with the rate guide explanation.

Max counters at $25 (his real price) and explains why fifteen does not cover the work.

Max declines the job and tells Mr. Henderson the work is not worth his time at that price.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

STEP 2 Build the counter-offer in three sentences

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: what makes a counter-offer different from a refusal?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

81

UNIT 3 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Master Mosaic Maker

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In the great cities of the Roman Empire, a master mosaic maker was one of the most prized craftsmen a wealthy family could hire. A mosaic is a picture built from thousands of tiny tiles of colored stone or glass, pressed into wet plaster. A single floor could cover hundreds of square feet, and a complex one could take a team a full year to finish. The result was permanent art, walked across by family and guests every day for generations.

The master was the artist who designed the picture and oversaw the placing of every tile. He had spent at least ten years learning the craft: first an apprentice grinding tiles to size, then a journeyman setting simpler tiles under another master's eye, and finally a master leading his own team. A family who wanted a mosaic for their villa had to negotiate with one of these men.

A typical negotiation went like this. The family invited the master to the villa. He examined the floor, asked about the design they wanted, and named his price. The price was high. Sometimes they agreed on the spot. More often, the head of the family countered with a lower number, hoping to talk him down.

The masters had a standard reply. "Then you should hire one of my former apprentices. Their work is good too. Mine costs what it costs because of the years it took to learn." Then the master

D I D YO U K N OW ?

Some of the most famous Roman mosaics are still in place today. The villa floors of Pompeii, the floors of the great houses in Roman North Africa, and the floors at Hadrian's Villa near Rome all show mosaics made by master craftsmen who refused to lower their prices. The mosaics survived twenty centuries because the materials were laid carefully by people who took the time to do the work right.

would politely say goodbye and leave. He did not lower his price, ever. The family could pay his full rate or hire a lesser artist. Many came back the next day and paid in full.

This was not arrogance. It was a man who knew exactly what his work was worth. He had walked the customer through the reasons for his price, offered a real alternative, and given them time to think. He never argued and never insulted anyone. He simply would not go below what his skill commanded. The masters who held that line earned four or five times an apprentice's wage, and their work has lasted two thousand years.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

82

UNIT 3 | LESSON 5

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

THE PROBLEM

The $300 Mower Max stood in front of the hardware store on Pine Street one Sunday afternoon. In the window was a cordless lawn mower with a steel deck, a quiet motor, and a battery that lasted long enough to do four large yards on a single charge. The price tag said $300.

DISCUSSION

Max knew exactly what that mower would mean.

With it, he could take on much bigger yards and mow three in the time a push mower took to do one. His grandfather had said the mower would pay for itself within a few months.

Max only has twelve weeks. He cannot keep adding hours forever, because there are only so many afternoons in a week. What is the highest he could realistically earn in twelve weeks if he stopped at twelve hours of work per week? What is the highest if he learned a new skill that paid more per hour?

The problem was the price. $300 was ten times what Max earned in a typical week. Summer vacation was twelve weeks long. At about $30 a week from three yards, twelve weeks came to $360. That was enough to cover the mower, but only if he saved every single dollar, and he knew he could not realistically do that.

Max needed a plan, one that used everything he had learned so far: setting his price, mixing kinds of work, tracking his hours, and negotiating up when he could. It also needed one new part he had not yet thought about. He had to figure out how to earn more per hour, not just work more hours.

Lesson

What it taught him

1

The Yard Job

Set a clear price before the work starts. A quote tells both sides what to expect.

2

Active vs Passive Income

Mixing active work with building work earns more than active work alone.

3

The Missing Hour

Track your hours so you know your real rate per hour.

4

Negotiating the Rate

The first offer is rarely the last. A counter-offer with a reason is normal.

FIRST INSTINCT How should Max approach this $300 goal?

A. Work more hours. Take on more yards each week.

B. Raise his rate per hour by negotiating with current customers.

C. Learn a new skill that pays more per hour, like hedge trimming.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

W H A T M A X K N O W S S O FA R

BIG QUESTION

How does what you know turn into what you earn?

D. Combine all of the above into one plan.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

83

UNIT 3 | LESSON 5

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E PA R T S

Five Parts of an Earning Plan An earning plan has five parts. Each part comes from one of the lessons in this unit. The first four are skills Max already has. The fifth part is the new idea that ties the whole plan together.

VOCABULARY

The first part is setting your rate. Max has a rate guide from his grandfather: $8 per hour for basic yard clean-up, $5 per hour extra for trimming work, plus a flat trash-removal fee. The second part is mixing kinds of work. Max can do pure yard jobs, which pay only for the hours he spends on them, and he can also build bird feeders that keep selling after he has built them. A mix of both earns more than either alone.

Earning plan - all five parts working together to reach a specific earning goal. A plan is stronger than any one part by itself.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

The third part is tracking his hours, so he knows his real rate per hour and can adjust the next quote. The fourth part is negotiating up when a customer offers less than his normal rate, using the three-sentence counteroffer pattern. The fifth part, the new one, is learning skills that pay more. Better skills mean more dollars per hour, working the same number of hours. The cordless mower is part of this. With it, Max can do bigger yards in less time, earning more per hour without working more hours.

GUIDED EXAMPLE $120in ten weeks, Theo needs $12 per week. His current earnings are only $5 per week. He has three ways to close the gap.

1.

Work more hours: ask for a second walk per week, adding $5. New total: $10. Still short.

2. Raise his rate: ask the neighbor for $6 per walk instead of $5. New total: $7 per week. Still short.

3. Add a new kind of work: Theo starts painting small wooden house number signs at $16 per sign, selling one per week.

New total: $5 + $16 = $21 per week. Over the goal.

Option 3 works best because it adds a new earning stream, not just more hours. The art kit becomes possible by combining the existing work with a new skill.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

84

Skill upgrade - learning a new kind of work that pays more per hour than what you can do now.

Rate ladder - the steps from a beginner's rate to a skilled worker's rate.

Each new skill is a higher rung on the ladder.

Tool investment spending money on a tool that lets you earn more per hour. A cordless mower is a tool investment.

MONEY RULE

What you can do in an hour is what you earn in an hour.

INTRO

UNIT 3 | LESSON 5

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

B U I L D YO U R OW N P L A N

Assemble Max's $300 Plan Use all five parts of the earning plan. Fill in Max's complete plan below.

STEP 1 The goal Part

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

Max's answer

Item Max wants

Cordless lawn mower

Total cost

$300

Number of weeks until end of summer

12 weeks

Amount Max has now

$0

Weekly target (cost ÷ weeks)

$

Mr. Albertson can teach Max hedge trimming.

Training takes two Sunday afternoons, but afterward Max can charge $13/hour.

Is the lost income worth the higher rate?

STEP 2 Current earning vs target Amount

Current weekly earnings (3 yards at $10 each)

$30

Weekly target needed

$

Gap to close each week

$

STEP 3 Pick at least two strategies to close the gap Add a fourth yard each week. +$10/week, +1 hour.

DISCUSSION Max can close the gap by working more hours or by learning a higherpaying skill. Which path is better after summer ends, and why?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Number

Build 2 bird feeders each week. +$10/week, +2 hours.

Learn hedge trimming. Higher rate later; two Sundays of training now.

Negotiate Mr. Albertson from $30 to $35 per yard. +$5/week.

Stretch the goal to 15 weeks. Lower weekly target.

STEP 4 Write Max's earning plan My weekly target: $ My two chosen strategies:

My current earnings: $ My adjustment rule: "I will only adjust this plan if

."

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: which of the five parts of Max's earning plan do you think matters most over a whole working life, and why?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

85

UNIT 3 | LESSON 5

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

The Castle Builders In medieval Europe, building a great stone castle could take more than a hundred years. A boy who began work on a castle as a young apprentice might grow old and die before the building was finished.

His son might continue the work. His grandson might finish it. Three generations of one family could spend their entire working lives on a single great fortress. The men who worked on the great castles were not paid equally. The pay depended on the rank of the worker, and the rank depended on years of training and tested skill. There were three main ranks, and every working stone-cutter or woodworker moved through them in order.

An apprentice was the youngest rank. A boy of twelve or thirteen would begin as an apprentice.

He swept floors, fetched water, carried stones, and watched the older craftsmen at work. He was paid very little, sometimes only food and a place to sleep.

The apprentice spent about seven years learning the basic skills of his trade before he could move up. A journeyman was the middle rank. A young man who had finished his apprenticeship became a journeyman. He could now do the actual work, but only under the supervision of a master. He was paid a real wage, much higher than an apprentice.

A journeyman traveled from project to project, working under different masters and learning new skills with each one. He stayed at this rank for seven more years before he could take the master's test.

D I D YO U K N OW ?

Many of the master builders of the great castles are known to us only by initials they carved into the stones they cut. A craftsman who placed his mark on a stone was claiming responsibility for its quality. If the stone failed, the master could be identified and held responsible. Some of these initials, carved more than seven hundred years ago, can still be seen by visitors to castles in France, Germany, and England today.

A master was the top rank. To become a master, a journeyman had to design and build a piece of work on his own, which the older masters would then inspect. If they approved, he became a master himself. A master led his own crew of journeymen and apprentices. He designed parts of the castle. He was paid four or five times what an apprentice earned. The masters who proved themselves on the great castles were among the highest-paid working men of their time. Some of them earned enough money to send their own sons through the same training, beginning the cycle again.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

86

FORM 2 TAX, PERCENT OFF, AND TIPS

Writing an Invoice

PRACTICAL A P P L I C AT I O N S What this section does!

This section covers three real-world forms every worker should know: an invoice for charging customers, a paycheck stub for understanding what an employer pays you, and a job application for getting hired. The section ends with a review case study and a final reflection.

An invoice is a written record of work done and money owed. After finishing a job, the worker gives the customer an invoice. The invoice tells the customer exactly what was done, how much it costs, and how to pay.

Invoices protect both sides. The worker has proof of the work and the agreed price. The customer has a clear record of what they are paying for. Every working adult should know how to write a simple invoice. a Worker's name

g Hourly rate

b Invoice number

h Subtotal for hours

c Date the invoice was written

i Trash removal flat fee

d Customer name and address

j Total amount due

e Description of the work

k Payment terms

f Hours worked

l Worker's signature

Max's Yard Work

c

October 6

Sample Invoice

Invoice #001 b

Bill to: d

Date of the work:

Mr. Albertson, 415 Cedar Lane

Description e

Front and back yard clean-up, leaves bagged, trash hauled

e

Trash removal flat fee

e October 5 (Sunday)

Hours worked

Hourly rate

3

g $8/hour

f

Total amount due

Payment terms: k

Cash or check, due upon receipt

Subtotal for hours

j

h

$24

i

$5

$29

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

a

Worker's signature:

l

Max

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

87

YOUR TURN

Write an Invoice Max just finished a yard job for Mr. Reyes. He cleaned the front and back yard for two and a half hours at his usual rate. He also hauled two bags of trash to the curb. Write Max's invoice for this job.

T H E D E TA I L S Customer: Mr. Reyes, 220 Maple Street

H ours: 2.5 hours

Invoice Number: 002

H ourly rate: $8 per hour

Date of work: Sunday, October 12

T rash removal: $5 flat fee

Work: Front and back yard clean-up, leaves bagged

Y our terms: Cash or check, due upon receipt

Sample Invoice Bill to:

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Description

Date of the work:

Hours worked

Hourly rate

Subtotal for hours

Total amount due

Payment terms:

Worker's signature:

C H EC K YO U R S E L F Does your subtotal equal the hours times the hourly rate? Does your total equal the subtotal plus the trash removal fee? If both answers are yes, the invoice is correct and ready for Mr. Reyes.

88

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

FORM 2 READING A PAYCHECK STUB (PART 1)

The Earnings Section

VOCABULARY Gross pay - the total amount the worker earned before any deductions. The starting point of the paycheck.

Most adults are paid by an employer who deducts taxes and other amounts from each paycheck. The paycheck stub is the paper or printed record that shows the worker exactly what they earned, what was taken out, and what they actually receive. A typical paycheck stub has two sections. The top half shows the worker's earnings for the pay period. The bottom half shows the deductions and the final take-home pay. This page shows the top half.

Pay period - the stretch of days the paycheck covers. Usually one week, two weeks, or one month.

Hourly rate - the amount the worker is paid per hour of regular work.

SAMPLE STUB Max's older cousin Daniel, who works part-time at the hardware store shows his paychechk stub.

Paycheck Sample Stub

b Oct 1 to Oct 14 (two weeks)

Daniel Carter

c October 20

Employee name

Pay date

Pay period

EARNINGS

Unit

Regular hours worked

d

40 hours

Overtime hours

g

0 hours

Rate

e

i

Total

$12

f

$480

$0

h

$0

GROSS PAYMENT

$480

a Who the paycheck is for

f Hours × rate

b The dates of work this paycheck covers

g Hours worked over 40 in a week, paid at 1.5x

c The date the check is paid

h Overtime hours × (rate x 1.5)

d Hours worked at the normal hourly rate

i Total earnings before any deductions

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

a

Overtime - hours worked beyond the normal weekly hours. By law, most overtime is paid at 1.5 times the regular rate.

e Pay per hour Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

89

PAYCHECK STUB (PART 2)

The Deductions Section The bottom half of the paycheck stub shows the deductions. A deduction is an amount taken out of the gross pay before the worker receives the rest. Some deductions are taxes paid to the government.

Others might be insurance, retirement savings, or union dues. After all deductions are subtracted, the remaining amount is the net pay. Net pay is what actually shows up in the worker's hand or bank account.

Paycheck Oct 1 to Oct 14 (two weeks) Sample Stub S A M P L E S T U B C O N T I N U E D Daniel's deductions Pay period

Max's older cousin Daniel, who works part-time at the October 20 Danielhardware Carter store shows his paychechk stub.

The first time most workers see a paycheck stub, they are surprised by the size of the deductions. On a $480 gross pay, almost $100 is taken out. Knowing this in advance helps you set realistic budgets based on net pay, not gross pay.

Pay date

Employee name

EARNINGS1

TIP

Rate 5UnitTax that funds older adults' health care Total

Starting point

2 Tax paid to the U.S. government Regular hours worked 3 Tax paid to the state government Overtime hours

4 Tax that funds retirement benefits

6 All amounts taken out 40 hours $12

$480

7 Gross pay minus total deductions 0 hours

$0

$0

8 Total earnings this year so far 9 Total take-home this year so far

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

VOCABULARY Net pay - what the worker actually receives after all deductions. Sometimes called "take-home pay."

Deduction - an amount subtracted from gross pay. Tax deductions are required by law. Other deductions are optional.

Federal and state taxes - money paid to the national and state governments to fund roads, schools, courts, and other public services.

1

$480

Federal income tax

2

$48

State income tax

3

$14

Social Security tax

4

$30

Medicare tax

5

$7

TOTAL DEDUCTIONS

6

$99

NET PAY

7

$381

YEAR-TO-DATE GROSS

8

$5,760

YEAR-TO-DATE NET

9

$4,572

GROSS PAYMENT

DEDUCTIONS

Year-to-date - the running total of earnings or deductions for the current calendar year. Resets to zero each January.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

90

YOUR TURN

Read a Paycheck Stub Here is a paycheck stub for Theo's older brother, Liam, who works part-time at a bookstore. Read the stub carefully and answer the questions below.

L I A M ' S P AY C H E C K S T U B

Paycheck Stub

Oct 1 to Oct 14 (two weeks) Pay period

Liam Carter

October 20

Employee name

Pay date

EARNINGS

Unit

Rate

Total

Regular hours worked

30 hours

$11

$330

Overtime hours

0 hours

$0

$0

GROSS PAY

$330

Federal income tax

$33

State income tax

$10

Social Security tax

$20

Medicare tax

$5 TOTAL DEDUCTIONS

$68

NET PAY

$262

ANSWER THE QUESTIONS 1.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

DEDUCTIONS

What is Liam's gross pay? $

2. How much total was taken out for taxes? $ 3. What percentage of Liam's gross pay went to deductions? About

%

4. What is Liam's net pay? $ 5. If Liam wants to save 20% of his net pay each paycheck, how much will he set aside? $ Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

91

PAYCHECK STUB (PART 2)

Looking Back at Max's Unit Max started this unit by agreeing to a yard job for Mr. Henderson without setting a price first. Over five lessons, he learned how to turn his work into a real earning plan. He learned that a price must be set before the work starts, in writing if possible. He learned the difference between active income and building income, and why mixing the two earns more than either one alone. He learned to track every hour of his time, so he could know his real rate per hour. He learned how to counter-offer politely when a customer's first price was too low. And he learned that skills are the longest-lasting way to raise a rate, because better skills mean more dollars per hour, no matter how many hours you work.

None of these ideas is complicated. The hard part is not knowing them. The hard part is doing them on every job, even the small ones. A worker who sets prices clearly, tracks hours carefully, negotiates fairly, and learns new skills steadily will earn more, year after year, than a worker who is smarter but never builds these habits.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

THE MONEY RULES FROM THIS UNIT Lesson 1

Set the price before you start the work.

Lesson 2

Working money is good. Money that keeps working is better.

Lesson 3

Hours you do not track are hours you do not get paid for.

Lesson 4

The first number is rarely the last number.

Lesson 5

What you can do in an hour is what you earn in an hour.

R E A L- W O R L D A P P L I C A T I O N Choose one Money Rule from this unit. Write about a time when you handled money for yourself or your family, and explain how the rule did or did not apply. Use the exact words of the rule in your writing. Be honest about what you would do differently next time.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

92

Unit 4

Choose Smart How do I make a smart choice when more than one option looks good?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

BIG QUESTION FOR THE UNIT

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

93

Meet Adam Adam is in sixth grade and loves old coins. His dad's Indian Head penny folder hooked him; every date felt like a tiny piece of history.

Now Adam and his dad visit Pinewood Coins on Sunday afternoons. The owner, Mr. Karlsen, saves Indian Head pennies for him. Adam buys a few at a time with chore money and birthday gifts, trying to fill every empty window from 1859 to 1909.

In this unit, Adam learns that collecting is really about choices. Every coin he buys means another coin has to wait.

W H AT ' S I N T H I S U N I T Lesson

Money Rule

1

The Coin Find

Your goal picks the winner.

2

Two Coins, One Budget

Comparison is faster than wishing.

3

The Surprise Offer

If you do not know how it works, do not say yes.

4

Adam's Pros and Cons

When in doubt, write it down.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

#

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

94

UNIT 4 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E S I T U AT I O N

Three Coins, One Choice

Adam had $25 folded in his wallet, saved over almost three months, and today was the day he would spend it. Mr. Karlsen lowered the loupe and smiled. "Adam. Good timing. I have three things you might like." He slid a small felt tray across the glass.

The first coin was an 1899 Indian Head in nice condition. Adam was missing 1899, so it would fill an empty window. $15. The second was a 1909-S VDB Lincoln penny, famous and rare, the kind a Lincoln collector would prize. But it was a Lincoln,

DISCUSSION All three coins are real coins at fair prices.

None of them is a bad buy. So why is one of them the right answer for Adam, when another one might be the right answer for a different collector?

not an Indian Head, so it would not fit Adam's folder at all. $20. The third was a roll of fifty common Indian Heads. A few might fill windows, but most were dates Adam already had. $20.

All three were real. All three were fairly priced.

Adam had $25, and he could pick only one.

FIRST INSTINCT

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

The bell over the door of Pinewood Coins jingled as Adam and his dad stepped inside. The shop smelled like old paper and metal polish. Behind the counter, Mr. Karlsen sat on a stool with a magnifying loupe pressed to one eye, sorting a tray of coins.

BIG QUESTION

Which coin should Adam pick?

A. The 1899 Indian Head. It fills a slot in his folder.

B. The 1909-S VDB Lincoln. It is rare and famous.

C. The roll of fifty Indian Heads. More coins for the same money.

How do you choose when more than one option looks good?

D. Save the money and wait for a better option next month.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

95

UNIT 4 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

THE SKILL

VOCABULARY

Your Goal Picks the Winner When every option looks good, the choice can feel impossible. The mind goes back and forth. Each option has something going for it.

None of them is clearly wrong. The longer a person stares at the options, the harder the choice seems to get.

There is a simple way out of this trap. Stop looking at the options.

Look at the goal instead. The goal is the reason you are making the choice at all. The goal is what you are trying to reach. The option that moves you closest to the goal is the right one, even if the other options are also good.

Adam’s goal is to fill every year of his Indian Head penny folder, from 1859 to 1909. That is the reason he is buying coins at all. The 1899 Indian Head fills a slot in his folder. It moves him directly toward his goal. The 1909-S VDB Lincoln is famous and rare, but it is the wrong series. It does not move him toward his goal at all. The roll of fifty pennies is full of duplicates. Most of the coins in it do not fit any empty slot. The 1899 wins, not because it is more famous, but because it matches Adam’s goal best.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

HISTORY

This is why two different collectors, looking at the same three coins, might make completely different choices. A Lincoln penny collector would pick the 1909-S VDB. A dealer who buys low and sells high might pick the roll. Adam picks the 1899. None of them is wrong. Each one has a different goal, and each goal picks a different winner.

Goal - the underlying reason you are making the choice. Without a goal, no choice can be clearly better than another.

Option - one of the possible answers to a choice. Most decisions have at least two options, sometimes more.

Fit - how well an option matches the goal. A good fit moves you closer to what you want. A poor fit does not.

Distraction - an option that looks good on its own but does not fit the goal.

Distractions are the hardest options to say no to.

MONEY RULE

Your goal picks the winner.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Reuben has saved $18. He wants to build a model bridge from a kit. His goal is to finish a wooden truss bridge before the end of October, for a school project. He sees three kits at the hobby store.

Kit A: a wooden truss bridge kit, $15. Exactly what Reuben needs.

Kit B: a wooden cable bridge kit, $16. Beautiful kit, but a different bridge style. Will not satisfy the assignment.

Kit C: a metal arch bridge kit, $12. Cheapest option. Wrong material. Wrong style.

Without a goal, Reuben might pick Kit C because it is cheapest. Or Kit B because the picture looks the best. But Reuben has a goal: a wooden truss bridge for a school project. The goal points to Kit A. The other two are distractions, not real options.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

96

INTRO

UNIT 4 | LESSON 1

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

DECISION LAB

Pick Adam's Coin Use Adam's goal to walk through the three options. Score each one by how well it fits his folder.

STEP 1 Restate Adam's goal in one sentence Adam's goal:

Adam’s dad mentions that Adam’s birthday is in three weeks. He will probably receive some coin-collecting money as gifts. Does this change Adam’s purchase today? Should he buy the smaller coin now and save the rest of his $25 for a bigger coin after his birthday? Or should he stick with the goalfit answer no matter what?

STEP 2 Score each option Option

Does it fill a slot in the Indian Head folder?

How well does it fit the goal?

1899 Indian Head, $15 1909-S VDB Lincoln, $20

STEP 3 Adam's decision Buy the 1899 Indian Head. $15 spent. $10 saved.

Buy the 1909-S VDB Lincoln. $20 spent. $5 saved.

Buy the roll of 50 Indian Heads. $20 spent. $5 saved.

Buy nothing today. Save all $25.

DISCUSSION EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: why does the same set of options have different best answers for different collectors?

If Adam's goal had been different, say, to own one famous and valuable coin, would the answer change?

What if his goal had been to grow his collection as quickly as possible, regardless of which series the coins belonged to?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Roll of 50 common Indian Heads, $20

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

97

UNIT 4 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Penny Switch of 1909

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

For fifty years, from 1859 to 1909, the one-cent piece minted by the United States showed the same design on the front: the head of a woman in a feathered headdress, often called the Indian Head. The designer, James Longacre, had used the headdress as a symbol of American freedom. The Indian Head penny was the smallest coin in everyday use, and it had passed through the hands of nearly every American family for two generations.

As 1909 approached, the United States government faced an important decision. The one hundredth anniversary of Abraham Lincoln's birth was coming up. Some officials at the Treasury Department wanted to honor Lincoln by putting his portrait on a coin. Others wanted to keep the Indian Head design, which had become a familiar part of American daily life. The government had to choose between two reasonable options.

The deciding factor was the goal. President Theodore Roosevelt had been pushing for years to make American coins more beautiful and more meaningful. He believed that coins were a kind of art that every citizen carried in their pocket.

The hundredth birthday of Lincoln was a perfect chance to put a real American president on a coin for the first time. The goal was clear: honor Lincoln on the coin most Americans saw every day.

The Treasury picked the Lincoln design. A sculptor named Victor David Brenner created the new image. In 1909, the Indian Head penny was retired after fifty years of use, and the Lincoln penny

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The Treasury received so many complaints about Brenner's initials on the new Lincoln penny that they removed the letters after only a few weeks. The VDB pennies minted in San Francisco during that short window, only 484,000 coins in total, became famously rare. A 1909-S VDB Lincoln penny in good condition can sell for more than $1,000 today, more than a hundred thousand times its original face value of one cent.

took its place. The change was big news at the time. Newspapers covered it for weeks. Collectors rushed to save the last Indian Head pennies before they disappeared from change. The Lincoln penny, with the same basic design, is still in use more than a hundred years later.

This is why Adam's Indian Head folder ends in 1909, and why a 1909-S VDB Lincoln penny is so famous. The S means it was made in San Francisco.

The VDB are the initials of Brenner, the sculptor.

Only a small batch of the first Lincoln pennies in San Francisco were minted before complaints about Brenner's initials caused the Mint to remove them. Today, those few coins are some of the most valuable American pennies ever made.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

98

UNIT 4 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

TWO SCENARIOS

Two Shops, Two Prices A month later, Adam's dad drove him downtown to a coin show. Adam had never been to one. He walked through the door and stopped. The hall was full of long tables covered in felt trays and glass cases, each one run by a different dealer.

Hundreds of coins, maybe thousands. Adam felt like he had walked into a treasure room.

He had $40 saved and one coin in mind: an 1893 Indian Head, a year he still needed. Within an hour he found it at two different booths. Same year, same coin, two different prices.

The first booth was Pinewood Coins. Mr. Karlsen's 1893 was in the condition called Very Fine. The date was clear, but the headdress details were a little soft. $25. The second booth belonged to

DISCUSSION Adam can argue for either coin based on the numbers alone. What other facts about the situation, beyond price and condition, might matter to him in five years?

Stonebridge Coins, run by a younger dealer Adam had never met. His 1893 was Extra Fine, sharper and almost new-looking. $35.

Both coins were the same year, both real, both fair for their condition. Adam had $40, so he could afford either. But he could only buy one.

Pinewood Coins (Mr. Karlsen)

Stonebridge Coins

1893 Indian Head, Very Fine condition.

1893 Indian Head, Extra Fine condition.

Price: $25.

Price: $35.

Adam keeps $15 from his $40.

Adam keeps $5 from his $40.

Mr. Karlsen knows Adam's collection. He will hold special coins for Adam when they come in.

Adam has never met this dealer. No relationship yet.

The coin's value if Adam ever resells: about $25 to $30.

The coin's value if Adam ever resells: about $40 to $45.

BIG QUESTION

FIRST INSTINCT Which coin should Adam pick?

A. The cheaper coin from Pinewood. Save $10. Keep the dealer relationship.

B. T he nicer coin from Stonebridge. Better quality holds value better.

C. N either. Wait and keep looking.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

A D A M ' S S I T U AT I O N

How do you compare two options when both look like good deals?

D. N eed to know more before deciding.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

99

INTRO

UNIT 4 | LESSON 2

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

VOCABULARY W H AT M A K E S T H E M D I F F E R E N T Comparison - looking at two or more options at the same time, feature by feature, to find the best fit.

Side-by-Side Comparison When two options look similar, the mind tends to flip back and forth.

Each time you look at one option, it seems better than the other.

Then you look at the second one, and that one seems better. The flipping can go on for hours, and at the end, you are no closer to a decision than when you started.

There is a faster way. Put both options side by side. Write down what each one offers, feature by feature, in two columns. Then compare the rows, not the columns. The comparison is faster than the flipping because the differences are no longer hidden by emotion. They are right there in writing, where you can look at them all at once.

A good comparison includes more than just price. Price is the easiest number to compare, but it is rarely the only number that matters.

Condition matters. Resale value matters. The relationship with the seller matters. The time and travel needed to get the item matters.

Risk matters too. A side-byside comparison forces all of these factors into the open, where the right choice often becomes clear.

Feature - one specific quality of an option.

Price, condition, location, brand, and warranty are all features.

Side-by-side - a layout that places two or more options in columns, so each feature can be read across the row.

Total cost - the full cost of an option, not just the price. Shipping, accessories, time, and risk all add to total cost.

MONEY RULE

Comparison is faster than wishing.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Theo wants to buy a new model rocket kit. He sees the same kit at two hobby stores. One is on Pine Street near his house. The other is in the next town over, where his uncle takes him sometimes. He builds a side-by-side comparison.

Feature

Option A: Pine Street store

Option B: store in next town

Price

$26

$22

Travel time

10 minutes walking

30 minutes by car with uncle

When he can buy it

Today

Next weekend, when his uncle drives him

Returns if defective

Walk in and exchange anytime

Exchange only when he visits again

Lunch out at a diner along the way

Not part of the trip

Usually adds about $8

On price alone, the next-town store looks cheaper. But after Theo writes out travel, timing, return policy, and the lunch cost, the Pine Street store wins on almost every row. The total cost is actually lower at Pine Street once everything is counted, and the other features all favor the closer store.

The comparison made the choice obvious.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

100

INTRO

UNIT 4 | LESSON 2

LEARN

HISTORY

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

C H O O S E Y O U R PAT H

Build Adam's Comparison Fill in the comparison table below for Adam's two coins.

Use everything you know about the offers from Page 1.

Then pick the option that wins on the most rows.

STEP 1 List the features that matter to Adam Feature

APPLY

Pinewood Coins

Stonebridge Coins

Year of the coin

Adam's dad reminds him that Mr. Karlsen has been Adam's dealer for almost a year. Mr. Karlsen calls Adam whenever a nice Indian Head penny comes in, even when no one has asked him to. He once held a coin for two weeks waiting for Adam to come by. Does the dealer relationship change the comparison? Should the relationship count as a feature in its own right?

Condition $

Money left after the purchase

$

Relationship with the dealer Approximate resale value in 5 years

$

STEP 2 Count the wins Number of rows where Pinewood wins: Number of rows where Stonebridge wins:

DISCUSSION Two students might pick different coins and both be right.

What goal would lead a student to the Pinewood coin? What goal would lead a different student to the Stonebridge coin?

Which feature matters most to Adam?

STEP 3 Adam's decision Buy the Pinewood coin. The price is lower and the relationship is worth more than the upgrade.

Buy the Stonebridge coin. Higher quality is worth the extra $10.

Wait. Neither coin is exactly right.

Talk to Mr. Karlsen about whether he can get a 1893 in Extra Fine condition. Skip both today.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Price

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: why is a written comparison faster than thinking about the options in your head?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

101

UNIT 4 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Sears Catalog

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In the late 1800s, most Americans lived in rural areas, far from cities. A farm family who needed boots, tools, fabric, or seed had to drive a wagon into the nearest town. There, they shopped at the local general store. The store owner set whatever prices he chose. Because the family had no other options, the store owner had no reason to lower his prices. Goods often cost two or three times what the same items cost in big cities, sometimes more.

In 1893, a Chicago salesman named Richard Sears began mailing a small catalog to farm families across the Midwest. The catalog listed hundreds of products with their exact prices printed on each page. Watches. Tools. Fabric. Boots. Stoves.

A family in a rural town could open the catalog at the kitchen table, read the prices, and order what they wanted. Sears shipped the goods by railroad.

The prices in the catalog were the same for every customer.

This simple idea changed American shopping forever. For the first time, farmers could compare prices easily. A pair of work boots at the local general store might cost $3. The same boots in the Sears catalog cost $1.75, plus shipping. A farm family could see the difference in five minutes.

Many of them started ordering from the catalog instead of the local store.

The local stores were forced to respond. To keep their customers, they had to lower their prices. Stores that refused to change went out of

D I D YO U K N OW ?

By the 1920s, the Sears catalog had grown to more than a thousand pages and offered every product a family might need, including ready-tobuild houses. A family could order a complete house kit, delivered in pieces by railroad, with every board labeled and every nail counted.

Between 1908 and 1940, Sears sold more than seventy thousand of these mail-order houses.

Many of them are still standing today.

business. Stores that adjusted their prices stayed open, but they could no longer charge whatever they wanted. The catalog had created a tool for comparison, and the comparison forced fair pricing across the entire country.

Sears himself wrote a famous note inside the front cover of every catalog: "Cheapest supply house on earth." The claim was not always strictly true, but the catalog held the prices steady year after year. By 1900, Sears was mailing the catalog to more than half of all American farm families. The book itself was so common in rural homes that families used old catalogs for everything from teaching children to read to insulating their walls.

Comparison shopping, once impossible for most Americans, had become as easy as turning a page.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

102

UNIT 4 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E M YST E RY

The $200 Penny

Adam stopped. The 1909-S was the rarest year in the whole series, the one he had wanted for months. He had $55 in his wallet. Fifty was exactly within reach, for a quarter of the coin’s real price.

Adam’s dad stepped up beside him. “Let me see the coin.” The seller hesitated, then held it out.

Adam’s dad turned it over, held it to the light, and frowned. “Where did you get this?” The seller

DISCUSSION If Adam had been alone, without his dad or Mr. Karlsen, would he have bought the coin? What are the warning signs in the seller’s story that Adam might miss if he were not paying close attention? shrugged. “Estate sale. Old man passed away.

Family wants it gone.”

Just then Mr. Karlsen walked by on his way to his own booth. He glanced at the coin, then at the seller, and leaned close to Adam, just loud enough for him to hear. “Adam. That coin is not real. The S mint mark was added later. Walk away.”

BIG QUESTION

FIRST INSTINCT What should Adam do?

A. Buy the coin anyway. $50 is still a great deal, even if it is not perfect.

B. Ask the seller for the original certificate of authenticity. If he has one, buy it.

C. Hand the coin back. Walk away from the booth. Tell Mr. Karlsen thank you.

How do you know when a deal that sounds too good to be true actually is?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Adam and his dad were walking through a big coin show at the community center, forty or fifty booths set up in the gym. A man Adam had never seen stepped out from a booth in the far corner, holding a small coin in a plastic case. “Hey, kid. You look like you know coins. I have a 1909-S Indian Head here. Book value is over $200. I’ll let you have it for fifty.”

D. Tell the seller he is selling a fake. Demand he stop.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

103

UNIT 4 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

VOCABULARY THE CLUES Counterfeit - a fake item made to look real, usually so a seller can charge a high price for it.

Authentication - the process of confirming that an item is real. Done by an expert who knows what to look for.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Why Deals That Sound Too Good Usually Are Real deals exist. Every collector has a story about the time they got something special at a great price. But for every real deal, there are ten fake ones. The fake deals look almost identical to the real ones.

The difference is in the details, and the details are easy to miss when the price excites you.

Pressure tactic - any move a seller makes to rush a buyer’s decision.

Urgency, scarcity, and emotion are the three most common.

A trustworthy seller can answer any question about how they got the item, where it came from, and why they are selling it at this price.

A trustworthy seller wants you to take your time, talk to an expert, and walk away if you are not sure. A trustworthy seller does not lose anything when you slow down to check.

MONEY RULE

An untrustworthy seller, on the other hand, needs you to decide quickly. They press. They use phrases like “only today” or “this offer is just for you.” Their story about how they got the item is vague.

They get nervous when you ask questions. They do not want experts to look closely. Every one of these behaviors is a warning sign.

If you do not know how it works, do not say yes.

Warning sign

What it sounds like

Why it matters

Price far below market

“Book value is $200. You can have it for $50.”

Real sellers price near market value.

A huge gap is a red flag.

Pressure to decide quickly

“This offer is only good today.”

Real deals stay good for a few hours of thinking.

Vague story about origin

“Estate sale. Family wants it gone.” (no details)

Real items come with a clear history.

Reluctance to let experts look

Seller hesitates when asked for closer inspection.

Honest sellers welcome inspection.

They have nothing to hide.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

104

Provenance - the history of where an item came from. A good provenance traces an item back through known owners.

INTRO

UNIT 4 | LESSON 3

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

S O LV E I T

Spot the Warning Signs Look back at the seller’s behavior from Page 1. For each warning sign in the table below, check whether it appeared in the booth scene and write down what the seller said or did.

When Adam’s dad hands the coin back and starts to walk away, the seller raises his voice. He says, “Fine, kid. I will throw in another coin for free. Just buy this one.”

Adam pauses. The free coin sounds tempting. Is this new information a reason to buy, or is it actually another warning sign? Why does an honest seller almost never throw in a free item to close a sale?

SAM'S LEDGER S T E P NEW 1 Check the warning signs Warning sign

Did it happen?

What the seller said or did

Price far below market Pressure to decide quickly Vague story about where the coin came from

S T E P 2 Pick Adam’s best move Hand the coin back. Thank Mr. Karlsen quietly. Walk away. Tell other collectors at the show about the booth.

Tell the seller loudly that he is selling fakes. Make a scene.

Buy the coin anyway, just in case Mr. Karlsen is wrong.

Ask the seller for written proof that the coin is real. Wait while he gets it.

DISCUSSION Why is the safest choice usually “walk away” rather than “argue with the seller”? What good does an argument do for Adam in this situation?

What harm could it cause?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Reluctance to let experts look at the coin

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: why is “I do not fully understand how this works” a strong enough reason all by itself to say no?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

105

UNIT 4 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Man Who Sold the Eiffel Tower

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In the spring of 1925, a Czech-born con artist named Victor Lustig sat in a Paris cafe reading the newspaper. A small article caught his eye. The Eiffel Tower, built thirty-six years earlier for the 1889 World’s Fair, was expensive to maintain, and the writer joked that the city might one day have to tear it down.

Lustig saw an opportunity. He had spent years running swindles across Europe and America, and he knew the secret to a great swindle was not the swindle itself. It was the setting. If a scheme looked official, important, and urgent, even smart people would believe it.

He had fake government letterhead printed and invited five Paris scrap metal dealers to a fancy hotel suite. There he told them a story. The Eiffel Tower was going to be torn down, he explained, and the scrap metal rights would go to the highest bidder. The whole thing was confidential, of course, since the public would protest if word got out. Bids were due within a few days.

Four of the five dealers were skeptical. One, a man named Andre Poisson, believed every word.

Poisson was new to the Paris scrap trade and wanted to make a name for himself, and Lustig saw it. He hinted that Poisson would need to pay a small bribe along with his bid, the way real government deals worked. Poisson handed over a briefcase of cash for the bid and the bribe.

D I D YO U K N OW ?

Victor Lustig was arrested in the United States in 1935, ten years after the Eiffel Tower swindle. He was sent to Alcatraz prison, the famous island prison off the coast of San Francisco. He spent the rest of his life there. His most famous quote, which he kept in his pocket, was a list of ten rules he called “The Ten Commandments for Con Men.” Rule number one was simply: “Be a patient listener.” His method was always to let the target talk himself into the deal, while Lustig nodded and agreed.

Lustig took the train out of Paris that night.

Poisson never went to the police. He was too embarrassed to admit he had been fooled. Lustig was so confident that he returned to Paris months later and sold the tower a second time, to a different dealer, with the same fake letterhead and the same story. Every warning sign had been there: the price too good, the story vague, the seller insisting on secrecy, the deadline forcing a fast yes. The dealers who walked away were the ones who noticed those signs. The one who did not lost everything.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

106

UNIT 4 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

TWO PEOPLE DISAGREE

Three Coins, $80, One Choice

Mr. Karlsen had three Indian Heads available that Adam still needed, each filling a different window, each a different price. Adam could afford only one.

The first was an 1877 Indian Head, one of the rarest years in the series, $75. It had sat at Pinewood for almost a year, waiting for the right buyer, and it was not going anywhere. Buying it would use almost every dollar Adam had.

The second was a 1908-S Indian Head, a less rare year, $35, at a downtown shop closing for good in two weeks. It would leave Adam $45.

The third was the 1909-S, the famous last-year key date, $90. Adam was $10 short and would

BIG QUESTION

When a decision is too hard to keep in your head, what should you do?

DISCUSSION Adam has been thinking about these three options for almost a week. He keeps changing his mind. What does it mean when a choice keeps flipping back and forth in your head, even though you have all the facts?

need a few more weeks to save. Then his dad pointed out that the collection had grown big enough to need a proper album with protective sleeves, instead of the worn cardboard folder. A good album cost $15.

FIRST INSTINCT

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

By the second weekend of November, Adam had $80 saved, the most he had ever had at one time.

Birthday money and a couple of long afternoons helping his dad in the garage had built it up. He sat at the kitchen table with his coin folder open, some windows filled, many still empty.

Which choice should Adam make?

A. Buy the 1877 alone. The rarest coin. Spend $75. Save $5.

B. Buy the 1908-S and the album. Spend $50. Save $30. Add a coin and protect the collection.

C. Save for the 1909-S. Need $10 more, plus the $15 album. Wait two to three weeks.

D. Buy nothing right now. Save the whole $80 for an even bigger purchase later.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

107

INTRO

UNIT 4 | LESSON 4

LEARN

HISTORY

VOCABULARY

T H E PA R T S

How to Write a Decision Down When a decision is small, the mind can hold the whole thing at once.

Should I get the green pencil or the blue one? Easy. The mind sees both, picks one, and moves on. When a decision is bigger, the mind cannot hold all the parts at the same time. Each option has several pros and several cons. The mind starts thinking about one option, partly remembers another, then loses track, then starts over. Hours can pass without making any real progress.

The fix is to take the decision out of your head and put it on paper.

Write the options at the top of three columns. Then write the pros for each option below the column header, and the cons below the pros. Once the whole picture is in front of you, you can compare the options at once, instead of one at a time in memory.

This method has been used for hundreds of years. Benjamin Franklin, one of the founders of the United States, used it for almost every important decision he made. He called it “moral or prudential algebra.”

Modern leaders, scientists, and business owners still use the same basic method. © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

APPLY

Pros and cons - the good reasons (pros) and bad reasons (cons) for each option in a decision.

Decision matrix - a written grid with options across the top and features down the side.

The same idea as pros and cons, organized in a table.

Trade-off - what you give up by choosing one option over another. Every choice has a trade-off.

Weight - how much one factor matters compared to another. Price might matter more than condition for one buyer, and less for a different buyer.

MONEY RULE

When in doubt, write it down.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Aaron is trying to choose between two summer camps. Camp A is closer to home and cheaper. Camp B is farther away but has the exact program he wants. He sits down and writes a pros-and-cons list.

Camp A: closer and cheaper

Camp B: farther and pricier

Pros: shorter drive, $200 less, friends are going.

Pros: exact program Aaron wants, better teachers, brand new facility.

Cons: program is just average, no friends with the specific interest.

Cons: $200 more, longer drive, no friends from school.

Once both columns are on paper, Aaron can see clearly what each option offers. Camp A wins on price and convenience. Camp B wins on the actual program. Aaron realizes that he is going to camp for the program, not the price, so Camp B is the better fit for his goal. The list did not make the decision. It just made his real reasons easier to see.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

108

UNIT 4 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

WHERE THE TRUTH SITS DISCUSSION

Adam’s Pros and Cons Build Adam’s complete pros-and-cons list for his three coin options. Fill in the table for each option, then read the whole list and pick what fits his goal best.

Can two students use the same prosand-cons list and still choose different options? What does that show about decisions?

STEP 1 State the question clearly

STEP 2 Write pros and cons for each option Option

Work item

Calculation

1877 Indian Head, $75 1908-S + album, $50 total Save for the 1909-S, ~3 weeks

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Adam’s question:

WAIT, NEW INFORMATION

STEP 3 Match the option to Adam’s goal Adam’s underlying goal: fill every year of his Indian Head folder, in good condition, while also taking care of his collection. Use this goal to weigh the options.

Which option fills the most empty slots?

Which option includes the album that protects his collection?

Which option matches the urgency from the WAIT box?

STEP 4 Adam’s decision Buy the 1877 alone.

Skip the album for now.

B uy the 1908-S and the album.

Save the rest for next month.

Save for the 1909-S. Skip the closing shop deal.

B uy nothing today.

Wait for more information.

EXIT QUESTION

Adam remembers something important. The 1908-S is at a shop closing in two weeks.

The 1877 has been at Mr. Karlsen's for almost a year and will probably still be there next month. The 1909S appears at coin shows from time to time, with prices going up over time.

How does the timing of each option change Adam's pros and cons list? Which option becomes more urgent?

Which one can wait?

In one sentence: how does writing a decision down change the decision itself?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

109

UNIT 4 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

Franklin’s Moral Algebra

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In 1772, Benjamin Franklin was sixty-six years old and famous across the world for his experiments with electricity, his work in publishing, and his service as America’s first ambassador to England.

That year a younger friend, the English scientist Joseph Priestley, wrote to him stuck on a hard decision and unsure how to even think it through.

He asked Franklin for advice.

Franklin’s reply became one of the most famous letters in the history of decision-making. When he faced a hard choice, he wrote, he used a method he called “moral or prudential algebra.” It was simple. Take a sheet of paper and draw a line down the middle. On one side write every reason for the choice, and on the other, every reason against.

Spend a few days adding to both columns as new reasons come to mind.

Then came the clever part. With both columns full, Franklin looked for reasons that balanced each other out. If a pro on one side seemed about equal to a con on the other, he crossed both off. If three small reasons together equaled one large reason, he crossed all four off. He kept reducing the list until only the strongest reasons remained, and the side with more left standing usually won.

Franklin said the method had saved him from many bad decisions over a long life. It worked, he believed, not because it was perfectly accurate,

D I D YO U K N OW ?

Franklin’s original letter to Joseph Priestley still exists and can be read in libraries today.

It is short, only about three hundred words long. Yet that single short letter is now studied in business schools, law schools, and decision science courses all over the world.

Franklin wrote it almost as a quick note to a friend, not as a famous essay. He had no idea that his “moral algebra” would still be used by everyone from family shoppers to military generals more than two centuries later.

but because it forced him to weigh both sides fairly instead of letting one strong feeling drive the choice.

More than two hundred and fifty years later, the same method is used by scientists, business leaders, doctors, and judges. The format has changed, but a modern table of weighted scores is still a pros-and-cons list, and so is a side-by-side display of options in a store. The tool Franklin described is older than the United States itself, and it is still one of the best ways to make a hard decision well.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

110

FORM 1 COMPARISON SHOPPING WORKSHEET

A Comparison Shopping Worksheet A comparison shopping worksheet is a single page that holds two or three options side by side, with the features that matter most listed down the side. Each cell of the table gets filled in. When the table is complete, the best option usually stands out on its own. Comparison shopping worksheets are used by ordinary shoppers, by business buyers, and by anyone who wants to make a careful choice between similar items.

Sample worksheet

PRACTICAL A P P L I C AT I O N S What this section does!

This section covers two real-world forms every smart decision-maker uses: a comparison shopping worksheet and a pros-and-cons decision template. The section ends with a review case study and a final reflection.

Feature

Pinewood Coins

Stonebridge Coins

Year of coin

1893 Indian Head

1893 Indian Head

Condition

Very Fine (VF)

Extra Fine (XF)

Listed price

$25.00

$35.00

Travel time to shop

10 minutes

35 minutes

$15.00

$5.00

Mr. Karlsen, known for a year

New dealer, never met

Will dealer call about future coins?

Yes

Unknown

Estimated resale value in 5 years

$28 to $32

$40 to $48

Total cost (price + travel + risk)

Low

Higher

Wins on this row?

5 wins

3 wins

Money left after purchase ($40 budget) Relationship with dealer

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Adam comparing two coin shops

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

111

YOUR TURN

Build Your Own Comparison Pick two options for something you might buy this year. The options can be two different stores, two different products, or two different versions of the same item. Fill in the worksheet below. Use at least six features in the rows.

YO U R C O M PA R I S O N Feature

Option A

Option B

Item name Listed price Total cost (with shipping, tax, etc.)

$

$

$

$

$

$

Travel time or wait time Quality, brand, or condition

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Money left after purchase Return policy Other factor that matters to you Wins on this row? (mark A or B)

COUNT THE WINS Number of rows where Option A wins:

Number of rows where Option B wins:

The option that wins on more rows is usually the better choice. Did the worksheet match what you would have picked without it? If not, why?

112

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

FORM 2 PROS-AND-CONS DECISION TEMPLATE

A Pros-and-Cons Decision Template A pros-and-cons template is the simplest decision tool ever invented.

It has been used for more than three hundred years by everyone from Benjamin Franklin to modern business leaders. A pros-andcons template is best for harder decisions where comparison is not enough, because the options are very different from each other. A coin worth keeping versus money saved is a different kind of choice than two coins at two different shops.

TIP Spend a few days adding to both columns as new reasons come to mind. Benjamin Franklin recommended at least two or three days. Some of the most important pros and cons do not show up in the first ten minutes of thinking.

S A M P L E T E M P L AT E

Question to decide

Should Adam buy the 1908-S Indian Head ($35) and a $15 coin album, or save the $50 toward a different goal?

Option A: Buy the 1908-S and the album

Option B: Save the for a different purchase

Pros: Fills a slot in folder. Protects the collection.

Acts on the closing-shop urgency.

Pros: Builds bigger budget. Keeps all options open.

No risk of regret on this specific purchase.

Cons: Spends most of the savings. Less money for the 1909-S later.

Cons: Misses the 1908-S, which may not appear again soon. Folder still unprotected.

Adam’s main reason for Option A: “The album matters more than I thought. The 1908-S is leaving the market.”

Adam’s main reason for Option B: “Bigger goal possible later. I do not want to spend in a hurry.”

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Adam choosing between coins and an album.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

113

YOUR TURN

Make Your Own Pros-and-Cons List Pick a real decision you are facing right now. It can be a money decision, a school decision, or anything else where two or three options each have something going for them. Fill in the template below.

STEP 1 State the question clearly The question I am trying to decide:

STEP 2 List the options Option A:

Option B:

STEP 3 Write pros and cons for each option

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Option A

Option B

Pros:

Pros:

Cons:

Cons:

STEP 4 Make the call After looking at both columns, my decision is: The strongest reason for my decision is: Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

114

REVIEW CASE STUDY

Adam’s Friend Simon Asks for Help Simon is in Adam’s grade. He has been saving up for almost three months and now has $50. Simon wants to buy a starter telescope so he can look at the moon and planets from his back yard. He has been thinking about three different telescopes he saw at the hobby store. He has asked Adam for help thinking it through, because Adam is known in their grade for making good decisions. Walk Adam through the case using everything you have learned in this unit.

Telescope

Price

Key features

Telescope A: a small refractor

$30

Easy to set up. Good for moon and bright planets. Light enough to carry.

Telescope B: a medium-sized reflector

$55

More powerful. Heavier. Needs adjustment before each use.

Telescope C: a beginner kit with two small scopes

$45

Two scopes for the price of one and a half. Each is less powerful than A or B.

A P P LY T H E F O U R M O N E Y R U L E S F R O M T H I S U N I T Question to answer

Money Rule that helps

What is Simon’s underlying goal?

Which telescope fits it best?

Your answer

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

SIMON’S THREE OPTIONS

How does a side-by-side comparison change Simon’s view?

Telescope C: a beginner kit with two small scopes

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

115

YOUR TURN

Looking Back at Adam’s Unit Adam started this unit standing at the counter of Pinewood Coins, looking at three coins he could not all afford. Over four lessons, he learned how to make a choice when more than one option looks good. He learned to look at the underlying goal, not just at the options. He learned to compare options side by side, so the differences would be clear instead of hidden.

He learned to spot offers that sound too good to be true, and to walk away when something does not add up. And he learned to write down a hard decision on paper, the way Benjamin Franklin did, when the choice was too big to hold in his head.

None of these tools is hard to learn. The hard part is remembering to use them when a decision feels urgent.

A smart chooser is not someone who never makes a bad choice. A smart chooser is someone who slows down enough to use the right tool for the size of the choice.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

THE MONEY RULES FROM THIS UNIT Lesson 1

Your goal picks the winner.

Lesson 2

Comparison is faster than wishing.

Lesson 3

If you do not know how it works, do not say yes.

Lesson 4

When in doubt, write it down.

R E A L- W O R L D A P P L I C A T I O N Choose one Money Rule from this unit. Write about a time when you handled money for yourself or your family, and explain how the rule did or did not apply. Use the exact words of the rule in your writing. Be honest about what you would do differently next time.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

116

Unit 5

Borrow Carefully When is borrowing or lending a smart move, and when is it a quiet trap?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

BIG QUESTION FOR THE UNIT

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

117

Meet Daniel Daniel is in sixth grade. He loves strategy games. A wooden chess set sits on his desk, and board games line his bedroom shelf. Most are games where players think several moves ahead, anticipate what others might do, and trade short-term gains for long-term wins. Daniel’s grandfather taught him chess when he was seven, and they have played together every Sunday for the past four years.

Daniel’s grandfather turns ordinary problems into strategy lessons. When Daniel mentioned that a friend had borrowed $5 and never paid it back, his grandfather did not simply say, “Some people forget.” He sat Daniel at the kitchen table and talked through the situation like a chess game. Every move has costs. Every choice changes the board. The smartest player is usually the one who sees the costs others miss.

In this unit, Daniel explores the four parts of borrowing and lending. Each lesson teaches one essential skill for handling money that moves between people.

W H AT ' S I N T H I S U N I T Lesson

Money Rule

1

The First Loan

A loan is a gift unless you ask for it back.

2

The Cost of Borrowing

Borrowing always costs more than waiting.

3

The Tangled Loans

Every untracked loan is a quiet gift.

4

Daniel’s Lending Rules

Decide before you are asked.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

#

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

118

UNIT 5 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E S I T U AT I O N

The $5 Lunch Money On a weekday morning, Daniel was eating breakfast in the cafeteria when his classmate Carlos sat down across from him, looking worried. “Hey, can I borrow five bucks? I forgot my lunch money and the line is already long. I will pay you back tomorrow.”

Tomorrow came. Carlos sat next to Daniel at lunch and talked about an upcoming strategy game tournament. Neither of them mentioned the $5. Daniel figured Carlos would remember. It was only $5.

A week passed. Two weeks. Three weeks. Daniel saw Carlos every day, and they even worked on a science project together. They talked about everything except the $5. By the fourth week,

Why is it so hard to ask a friend for borrowed money back? What is the worst thing that could happen if Daniel asked Carlos for the $5 now? What is the worst thing that could happen if he never asked?

Daniel knew Carlos was not going to bring it up.

The money was probably never coming back.

Daniel mentioned it at family dinner that Sunday. His grandfather listened, then put down his fork. “Daniel, you made a loan, but you treated it like a favor. A loan is a deal: a set amount, with a set time to pay it back. A loan that nobody asks about quietly turns into a gift. There is nothing wrong with giving Carlos $5. But if you wanted it back, you had to make that clear from the start, and ask when the time came.”

FIRST INSTINCT What should Daniel do now?

A. Forget about the $5. Treat it as a gift. Move on.

B. Ask Carlos for the $5 back, calmly and once.

C. Stop being friends with Carlos. He cannot be trusted.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Daniel had $7 in his pocket. He thought for half a second, then handed Carlos a $5 bill. Carlos thanked him and went to buy his lunch. Daniel went back to his breakfast feeling good about helping a friend.

DISCUSSION

BIG QUESTION

What turns a friendly favor into a real loan?

D. Lend Carlos more money next time he asks, but charge interest.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

119

UNIT 5 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

THE SKILL

Three Questions Before You Lend A loan is different from a gift. A gift is money you give freely, with no expectation of return. A loan is money you hand over for a specific time, with a specific agreement to pay it back. Both are fine choices, but they are not the same thing. The confusion between them is where most small loans go wrong.

Before you lend money to anyone, ask yourself three questions. The questions sound simple, but most people skip them in the moment, and that is exactly when the trouble starts. First, can the borrower pay back?

Does the person actually have the means? A friend who lost his lunch money once can probably bring $5 tomorrow. A friend who is always short on money may not be able to pay back any amount. The question is not whether they want to pay back. The question is whether they can.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Second, will the borrower pay back? Even if a person can pay back, they have to remember. They have to make the effort. They have to put it ahead of other things they might want to spend money on.

Some people are careful about this. Others are not. You usually know which kind a person is after one or two small loans.

Third, are you okay if they do not pay back? This is the most important question. If the answer is no, do not lend. The money you cannot afford to lose should never leave your pocket as a loan. If $5 feels like too much to lose, lend two instead, or lend none. A loan you cannot afford to lose ruins both the friendship and your finances when it goes wrong.

VOCABULARY Loan - money handed over for a set time, with a clear agreement to be paid back.

Lender - the person who gives the loan and expects to be paid back.

Borrower - the person who receives the loan and agrees to pay it back.

Default - when a borrower does not pay back what was agreed. Defaults damage trust as much as they damage finances.

MONEY RULE

A loan is a gift unless you ask for it back.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Reuben has $8 in his wallet. His classmate Simon asks to borrow $3 to buy a snack at the school store. Reuben thinks through the three questions.

1.

Can Simon pay back? Yes. Simon has lunch money on most days.

2. Will Simon pay back? Maybe. Simon borrowed $2 two months ago and never paid it back.

3. Is Reuben okay if Simon does not pay back? No. Reuben was planning to buy a small art kit with the money.

Reuben says no, politely. “I cannot lend right now. I am saving for an art kit.” Simon shrugs and asks someone else. The friendship is fine. Reuben kept his money. The three questions did exactly what they were supposed to do.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

120

UNIT 5 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

DECISION LAB

Help Daniel Handle the Carlos Loan Walk Daniel through what to do next. Use the three questions and the new rule from Page 2 to think through his options.

STEP 1 Apply the three questions to the Carlos loan Question

Your answer

Can Carlos pay back the $5 now?

Will Carlos pay back without being asked?

Is Daniel okay if Carlos never pays back?

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N Daniel’s grandfather suggests a different rule altogether. “Try a personal rule,” his grandfather says.

“I do not lend money at school. Period. If a friend really needs lunch money, give it as a gift, and only what you can afford to give.” The rule is strict, but it stops the problem of loans turning into quiet gifts. Should Daniel adopt his grandfather’s rule going forward? Why or why not?

Ask Carlos for the $5 back politely, this week.

Use a friendly tone. Accept the answer.

Treat the $5 as a gift. Stop expecting it back.

Lend Carlos again with clearer rules.

Adopt grandfather’s rule: do not lend money at school.

Give small amounts as gifts only.

Lend Carlos again, but only with a written note that says when he will pay back.

DISCUSSION Two students might pick different options and both be right. What does each option teach Carlos? What does each option teach Daniel about how he wants to handle money going forward?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

STEP 2 Daniel’s decision

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: what makes a loan different from a gift, and why does that difference matter?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

121

UNIT 5 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Code of Hammurabi

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Almost four thousand years ago, in the ancient kingdom of Babylon, a king named Hammurabi created one of the first written law codes in human history. He had it carved into a tall stone pillar, called a stele, that stood in the city center where everyone could see it. Hundreds of laws covered everything from marriage to property to crime, and about a third of them dealt with lending and borrowing.

Hammurabi’s code treated lending as a normal part of daily life. Farmers borrowed seed grain from merchants in spring and repaid it from the fall harvest. Workers borrowed silver or copper to start small businesses. The laws set firm limits: interest on a loan of grain could not top 33 percent, and interest on silver could not top 20 percent. If a lender charged more, the loan was cancelled.

The code protected borrowers in other ways too.

If a farmer’s crop failed in a flood or drought, his debt for that year was forgiven. If a lender used force to collect instead of going to court, the lender was punished. The whole system tried to balance both sides: lenders needed to be repaid, but borrowers needed protection from bad luck.

Most striking was the principle behind it. A loan was a real agreement, not a vague promise. Both sides had specific duties, and both could go to a court

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The original Hammurabi stele still exists today. It is a black basalt pillar about seven feet tall, on display in the Louvre Museum in Paris, France. The laws are carved in cuneiform writing, the same wedge-shaped writing first used by the ancient Sumerians.

The stele was lost for thousands of years before French archaeologists dug it up in 1901 in what is now Iran, where it had been carried as a prize of war by an ancient ruler.

if the other broke the deal. Carved into stone, the rules were visible to the whole kingdom, and anyone who could read could see exactly what was allowed.

For the first time in recorded history, borrowing had moved from private trust to public law.

Almost four thousand years later, every loan made by every bank still follows the structure Hammurabi laid out: a stated amount, a stated interest rate, a stated repayment schedule, and clear consequences if the deal is broken. The details have changed many times. The principle has not.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

122

UNIT 5 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

TWO SCENARIOS

Two Paths to the Same Game A few weeks after the Carlos lunch money situation, Daniel was at the hobby store with his grandfather. In the front window was the game Daniel had been wanting for months. It was called Castle Defenders Deluxe, a complex strategy game with two hundred wooden pieces, four player boards, and a fold-out map of a medieval town.

The price was $30. Daniel had $5 saved up.

As they walked home, his older cousin Aaron, who was visiting from out of town for the weekend, made Daniel an offer. “I have $25 right here,” Aaron said. “You can borrow it today. Just pay me back $5 a week for the next six weeks. That comes to $30. The extra five is what I charge for the loan.”

Daniel did the math. If he saved on his own, $5 a week for five weeks would give him twenty-five

DISCUSSION Aaron is being completely fair. He is not trying to trick Daniel. He is offering a real loan with a clear cost. So why would Daniel pay an extra $5 just to have the game today instead of in five weeks? What does the extra $5 actually buy him? more dollars. Added to his current five, that was the $30 he needed. He would wait five weeks but pay only the price of the game. If he borrowed from Aaron, he could have the game today, but he would pay an extra $5 in interest. Same game.

Same player. Two very different paths.

Plan A: Save up

Plan B: Borrow from Aaron

When Daniel gets the game: in 5 weeks.

When Daniel gets the game: today.

Weekly amount: save $5 each week.

Weekly amount: pay back $5 each week.

Total weeks of saving or paying: 5 weeks.

Total weeks of paying back: 6 weeks.

Total amount Daniel spends: $30 (the game price).

Total amount Daniel spends: $35 ($30 + $5 interest).

Money left over: $5 from his original savings.

Money left over: $0.

FIRST INSTINCT

BIG QUESTION

Which plan should Daniel pick?

A. Plan A. Save up. Pay only $30. Wait the five weeks.

B. Plan B. Borrow from Aaron. Get the game today. Pay $5 extra over six weeks.

C. Combine: save for two weeks first, then borrow a smaller amount.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

D A N I E L’ S S I T U A T I O N

What is the real price of having something now instead of later?

D. Forget the game. Save up for something cheaper instead.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

123

UNIT 5 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

THE SKILL

The Price of Now Every time you borrow money, you pay extra to have something sooner than you could afford it. This extra amount is called interest.

It is the price of “now.” Banks charge interest. Stores charge interest.

Friends and family members sometimes charge interest. Even when no money interest changes hands, there is usually still a cost: a favor owed, a relationship under pressure, the weight of an unpaid debt.

Interest is not bad on its own. It is simply the cost of using someone else’s money. The lender takes a risk and gives up the use of their money for a while. The borrower gets to use that money right now. Both sides agree on a price for this trade. The trouble starts when the borrower thinks of the interest as small or unimportant. $5 on a $30 game is more than fifteen percent. That is a real cost, even when it sounds small.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

The other cost of borrowing is harder to see. When you owe money, you are not as free as before.

Until the loan is paid back, some of your future weekly money is already promised. Daniel’s six weeks of paying back $5 each is six weeks when he cannot easily save for anything else. If something unexpected comes up during those six weeks, he is stuck. He owes Aaron first.

Interest - the extra amount paid back beyond the original loan. The price of borrowing.

Principal - the original amount of the loan, before any interest is added.

Repayment schedule when the borrower must pay back, and how much each time.

Term - the total length of time the borrower has to pay back the full loan.

MONEY RULE GUIDED EXAMPLE Aaron, a boy in Daniel’s grade, sat next to him at lunch one day.

Aaron had forgotten his lunch money. “Can you spot me $3?” he asked. “I will bring it back tomorrow.” Daniel hesitated. He barely knew Aaron, but Aaron had a reputation for being careful with money. Daniel handed over the $3.

The next morning, Aaron walked straight up to Daniel before homeroom. “Here is your $3. Thank you.” He handed over the exact amount and walked off. No interest. No favor owed. No relationship cost. Why? Because Aaron treated it like a real loan with a clear and short term. The cost of borrowing in his case was almost zero, because the term was twenty-four hours and the borrower was reliable. Most loans do not work this cleanly. Aaron’s example shows what a well-handled small loan can look like.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

124

VOCABULARY

Borrowing always costs more than waiting.

UNIT 5 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

C H O O S E Y O U R PAT H

Calculate Daniel’s Real Cost Walk through the numbers for both of Daniel’s plans.

Then decide which path fits his situation best.

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

Item

Plan A

Weekly savings x 5 weeks

$

Daniel's original money

$5

Total available before buying

$

Game price

$30

Money left over after buying

$

STEP 2 Plan B (borrow $25 from Aaron, pay back over 6 weeks) Item

Plan B

Borrowed from Aaron

$25

Daniel adds his own money

$5

Game price today

$30

Repayment plan

$5/week for 6 weeks

Total paid back to Aaron

$

Extra cost (interest)

$

Daniel learns from the store clerk that Castle Defenders Deluxe is going on sale next month for $24, $6 off. The sale will run for two weeks.

How does this change the math? Should Daniel save up and buy the game on sale, paying only $24? How does the new information change which plan makes the most sense?

DISCUSSION Which change matters most: a sale next week, no sale, or a no-cost loan from Aaron?

STEP 3 Daniel’s decision Pan A: save 5 weeks, then pay $30.

Plan B: borrow now and pay $35 over 6 weeks.

Wait 1 month, save, and buy on sale for $24.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

STEP 1 Plan A (save up over 5 weeks)

Compromise: borrow $10, save $15, and buy in 3 weeks.

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: what does the extra $5 in Plan B actually buy Daniel?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

125

UNIT 5 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

The Pawnshops with Three Golden Balls Walk down a street in a medieval European town and you might spot three golden balls hanging above a shop door. That sign meant a pawnshop, one of the oldest forms of borrowing in the world. At a pawnshop, a person brings in an item, such as a watch, a piece of jewelry, or a tool, and borrows money against its value.

The shop holds the item as security. The borrower has a set time, usually one to six months, to repay the loan plus interest and get the item back. If he cannot pay, the shop keeps the item and sells it.

Those three golden balls have marked pawnshops in Europe and America since the medieval period. The symbol came from the coat of arms of an old Italian banking family, and other Italian lenders who wanted to look connected to them used it too. Over time the three balls became the universal sign of a pawnshop, recognized even by people who could not read.

A pawnshop shows the cost of borrowing very clearly. A man brings in a watch worth $100. The owner offers him a loan of $40 against it. The man has thirty days to repay $48, the $40 plus $8 in interest. Pay on time, and he gets his watch back. Miss the deadline, and the shop keeps the watch and sells it, often for far more than the loan.

For the borrower, the costs are real. He gave up a watch he might want or need. He paid extra

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The three golden balls sign is so old that many people in medieval Europe could not read, but they could spot a pawnshop from blocks away by looking for the three balls. The same sign is used today on pawnshops in London, New York, Tokyo, and many other cities, almost a thousand years after the symbol first appeared.

Very few business symbols in history have lasted this long with their meaning unchanged.

for the privilege of having $40 for a month. And if he cannot repay, he loses the watch forever, even though it was worth twice the loan. For the pawnshop, the deal is safe. It already holds the watch, the interest covers its costs, and an unpaid loan just means a profitable sale.

Pawnshops still operate in cities all over the world, many still showing the three golden balls. The basic deal, money for an item as security, plus interest, plus a time limit, has not changed in almost a thousand years. It is one of the clearest examples in everyday life of how borrowing always has a price built into it.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

126

INTRO

UNIT 5 | LESSON 3

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E S I T U AT I O N

The Missing $6 On a Sunday afternoon, Daniel sat at his desk with his money notebook open, getting ready for the week ahead. Over the past month he had earned $30 from yard chores and a Sunday helping his cousin clean out the garage. He had spent $10 on replacement game pieces and $2 on a school store snack. By his math, he should have $18 in his wallet.

Daniel pulled out his wallet and counted. $12. He counted again. $12. $6 were missing. Daniel had not lost any money. He had not given any away that he could remember. But somewhere, between the thirty he had earned and the twelve he was holding, $6 had disappeared. He needed to find out where.

DISCUSSION Add up the money Daniel lent to others, and the money he owes others. What is his real money picture? Is he actually short, or is some of his money just in other people’s pockets?

THE CLUES Daniel sat with his notebook and tried to remember every transaction of the last month, big or small.

Detail

Three weeks ago

Carlos forgot lunch money. Daniel lent him $3. Carlos said “tomorrow.”

Two weeks ago

Simon needed $2 for a school store snack. Daniel said sure.

Two weeks ago

Daniel’s cousin drove him to the hobby store. Daniel said “I owe you $4 for gas,” but never paid it back.

Last week

Daniel’s little brother asked for a dollar. Daniel said “you owe me,” but did not really mean it.

Last week

Daniel needed card sleeves. His older brother paid the $3, and Daniel said “I will pay you back next week.”

FIRST INSTINCT

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Date

BIG QUESTION

Where did the $6 go?

A. Someone stole money from Daniel’s room.

B. Daniel lost track of small loans, both money he lent and money he borrowed.

C. Daniel forgot some purchases.

Where does money go when you do not track who owes whom?

D. His math at the start was wrong.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

127

UNIT 5 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

THE CLUES

APPLY

HISTORY

VOCABULARY Receivable - money that is owed to you. You are waiting to receive it.

Payable - money you owe to someone else. You are obligated to pay it.

Net position - your cash, plus your receivables, minus your payables. The real picture of where you stand financially.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Where Untracked Loans Hide

MONEY RULE

Every untracked loan is a quiet gift.

When you do not track who owes you and whom you owe, your money picture drifts away from reality. You feel broke even though your math says you should have more. Or you feel fine even though you actually owe more than you realize. Both errors come from the same source. Small loans are not being written down.

Most untracked loans fall into one of three patterns. Knowing the patterns is the first step to fixing the problem.

Pattern

How it happens

Daniel’s example

Forgotten lending

You lent someone a small amount. They forgot. You forgot. The money stays in their pocket.

The $3 to Carlos and the $2 to Simon. Both still unpaid.

Forgotten borrowing

You borrowed a small amount. You meant to pay back. You forgot to keep track. Your lender may or may not remember.

The $4 owed to his cousin and the $3 owed to his older brother.

Unclear deals

Was it a loan or a gift? Both sides assume different things. The money may already be a gift, but the lender does not realize.

The $1 he gave his little brother.

“You owe me” said as a joke, but the dollar is gone.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

128

Loan ledger - a simple written record of every loan, both lent and borrowed, with dates and amounts.

UNIT 5 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

S O LV E I T

Build Daniel’s Loan Ledger Help Daniel sort out his money picture. Fill in the loan ledger below, then calculate his real net position.

STEP 1 List every loan Daniel has out or owes Type (lent or borrowed)

Person

Amount

Lent

Carlos

$3

Lent

Simon

$2

Gift (called a loan, but really a gift)

Little brother

$1

Borrowed

Older cousin

$4

Borrowed

Older brother

$3

Status

Cash in wallet: $12

Plus money lent out (receivables): $

Minus money owed to others (payables): $

Real net position: $

STEP 3 Daniel’s rule going forward Ask every person back, no matter how small the loan or how long ago.

Track every loan in a notebook, but only ask back if it is over $5.

Stop lending small amounts at school. Pay back any borrowed amounts within a week.

Give up tracking. Treat all small loans as gifts from now on, and stop borrowing from anyone.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

STEP 2 Calculate Daniel’s real net position

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: how does writing down a loan change the loan itself?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

129

UNIT 5 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Tally Sticks of Medieval England

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

For nearly seven hundred years, from the 1100s until 1826, the English government and English merchants tracked debts with a clever wooden tool called a tally stick. A tally stick was a straight, sturdy piece of wood, usually hazel, about a foot long. When a loan was made, notches were cut into it to show the amount: a small notch for a penny, a larger one for a shilling, a wide cut for a pound.

Then came the clever part. The stick was split lengthwise down the middle, slicing through every notch. The lender kept one half, called the stock, and the borrower kept the other, called the foil. Because each piece of wood has a unique grain, the two halves only fit back together if they had come from the same original stick. When the loan came due, the halves were brought together. If the notches lined up across the split and the grain matched, the debt was confirmed.

This solved a problem that had troubled lenders and borrowers for thousands of years. With only one record, kept by the lender, the lender could claim the loan was bigger than it was. With only one, kept by the borrower, the borrower could claim it was smaller, or already paid. With two records that had to physically fit together, neither side could cheat alone, and a dispute could be settled in minutes by matching the halves.

The English government used tally sticks so long that warehouses of old ones piled up at

D I D YO U K N OW ?

Many of the tally sticks that survived the Parliament fire of 1834 are still in museums today, and they can still be read.

Some of them are nearly a thousand years old. The marks for shillings and pounds are still perfectly clear in the wood, and the matching halves still fit together exactly the way they did when the loans were first made.

Westminster. In 1834, officials decided to burn the whole collection in two stoves beneath the Parliament building. The stoves were overloaded, the chimneys caught fire, and Parliament burned to the ground. The painter J.M.W. Turner watched from across the river and made several famous paintings of the blaze. One of the most expensive disasters of the early 1800s had been caused, indirectly, by seven hundred years of carefully tracked debts.

The lesson of the tally sticks is simple and lasting.

Every loan should leave a record that both sides can point to. Without a record, a loan is just a memory, and memories fade. With a record, both sides know exactly where they stand, even years later.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

130

UNIT 5 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

THE PROBLEM

A Strategy for Lending After untangling his loan ledger, Daniel sat at the kitchen table on a Sunday evening with his grandfather, who was making tea. Daniel had been thinking all week about the patterns in his ledger, and he had reached a difficult conclusion. He needed rules. Not just good intentions, but real, written rules he could follow when the moment came.

“Here is the problem,” Daniel said. “When Carlos asked me for $5 at lunch, I had three seconds to decide. The decision was fine, but the followthrough fell apart. I never asked for the money back. Same with Simon and the $2. And when my cousin lent me gas money, I meant to pay it back and forgot. Every loan, both ways, has the same problem. I decide in the moment, I follow through later, and the two stages do not match.”

His grandfather nodded. “You have noticed something most adults never figure out. A rule made in calm beats a decision made under pressure. If you

DISCUSSION Why is a written rule stronger than a promise you make to yourself? What kinds of moments tend to break promises that you have not written down? When does writing a rule actually change behavior?

decide ahead of time how you will handle lending and borrowing, then when the moment comes, you do not have to think. You just follow the rule.”

Daniel pulled out a fresh page in his notebook. The unit had taught him three lessons about lending and borrowing. Now he needed to combine them into one set of personal rules, and add a fourth that tied everything together. He had to decide before he was asked, not in the three seconds after.

Lesson

What it taught him

Lesson 1: The First Loan

Ask three questions before lending.

A loan with no follow-up becomes a gift.

Lesson 2: The Cost of Borrowing

Borrowing always costs more than waiting, even from family or friends.

Lesson 3: The Tangled Loans

Every untracked loan is a quiet gift.

Both lending and borrowing need a record.

FIRST INSTINCT How should Daniel start building his rules?

A. Just promise himself to be more careful next time. No written rules needed.

B. Write down a strict rule like “never lend, never borrow.” Done.

C. Write down detailed rules covering who, how much, for how long, and what if not paid back.

BIG QUESTION

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

W H A T D A N I E L K N O W S S O FA R

How do you make smart lending and borrowing decisions before the moment of being asked?

D. Ask his grandfather for his lending rules and just copy them.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

131

UNIT 5 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY RULE

EACH SIDE'S REASONING

Decide before you are asked.

Five Parts of a Personal Lending Rule Set A complete lending and borrowing rule set has five parts. Each part answers one of the questions that came up in the earlier lessons.

When all five are written down, the rules work as a unit, and the borrower or lender can follow them in any new situation without having to think it through from scratch.

The first part is the maximum amount, a specific dollar limit per person. The limit can differ by relationship: more for family, less for school friends, none at all for strangers. The second part is the maximum time. A week is short.

Two weeks is reasonable. A month is the outside limit for small loans between friends, after which the loan starts to fade into a gift.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

The third part is the record. Every loan over $1 gets written down: the date, the amount, the person, the due date. The fourth part is the list, a short circle of trusted people who can borrow from you and a short list you would borrow from. People outside the list get a polite no. The fifth part is what happens if not paid. Decide before the loan is made. The classic rule, used by Daniel’s grandfather for sixty years, is to ask once politely after the deadline, then write it off as a gift and never lend to that person again.

VOCABULARY Lending policy - the written rules you follow when deciding whether and how to lend.

Credit limit - the maximum amount you will lend to one person.

Term - the maximum time you will wait for repayment.

Write-off - a loan you have decided to stop trying to collect. The amount becomes a gift in your records.

THE ONE QUESTION Reuben had a tangled loan ledger of his own at the start of the school year. He had lost track of about $15 across small loans. After two months of frustration, he wrote his rules in the back of his notebook.

1.

Reuben lends only to his two closest friends and to his brother.

2. Maximum loan: $5 per person.

3. Maximum term: one week.

4. Every loan is written in his pocket notebook, with date and due date.

5. If not paid back in two weeks, Reuben treats the amount as a gift and stops lending to that person.

Since making his rules, Reuben has lent $14 over three months and received every dollar back, because the rules are clear and his friends know them. The rules did not change Reuben’s friends.

They changed Reuben’s habits, and the habits changed the results.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

132

UNIT 5 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

WHERE THE TRUTH SITS

Write Daniel's Five Rules DANIEL’S LENDING RULES Rule

Daniel’s choice

1. Maximum amount per person

$

2. Maximum term (how long before due)

days

3. Record kept (where and how) 4. List of people who can borrow 5. What happens if not paid back on time

DANIEL’S BORROWING RULES (THE OTHER SIDE) Rule

Daniel’s choice

6. Maximum amount Daniel will borrow

$

7. From whom (specific people only) 8. Daniel’s repayment schedule promise 9. When Daniel will borrow vs. save up first

EXIT QUESTION

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N Daniel’s grandfather offers one more rule he himself has followed for sixty years.

“Never lend the same person twice if they did not pay back the first time. The first loan is a test. If they pass the test, you can lend again. If they fail, the test is over.” Should Daniel add this rule to his five? Why does this rule, simple as it sounds, prevent many of the most frustrating loan situations?

DISCUSSION Two students might write very different rules. One might set a maximum of $1 and never lend to anyone. Another might set $10 and lend to anyone who asks. Both could be defensible.

What does the choice of rule reveal about the student’s priorities?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Help Daniel write his complete personal lending and borrowing rule set. Use the five parts from Page 2. Fill in each rule with a specific number, date, or name.

In one sentence: why does a rule written before the moment of being asked work better than a decision made in the moment itself?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

133

UNIT 5 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

Honest Abe and the National Debt

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In 1832, a young man named Abraham Lincoln became a partner in a small general store in the village of New Salem, Illinois. He was twentythree. The store sold flour, sugar, tools, fabric, and whatever else local farmers needed. His partner, William Berry, ran most of the daily business while Lincoln worked other jobs to make ends meet.

The store struggled from the start. Berry was a heavy drinker and careless with money, and customers who bought on credit often never paid. By 1833 the store was failing. By 1835 Berry had died, leaving Lincoln alone with the debts. The total was about $1,100, an enormous sum for a frontier man, which Lincoln jokingly called his “national debt.”

Lincoln could have walked away. Berry had been the active partner, many of the unpaid customers could not be found, and the frontier had loose rules about debt. Plenty of men in his place simply moved west and started over. Lincoln did not. He believed a debt was a serious promise, and he decided to pay back every penny, however long it took.

For the next fourteen years, he worked one job after another, always sending part of his earnings to the people he owed. He was a postmaster, a surveyor, a lawyer, and eventually a state legislator. Some years he could repay $100, other years only a little. The debt never vanished, and

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The store building where Lincoln and Berry sold their goods has been rebuilt at the New Salem State Historic Site in Illinois.

Visitors can see the small wooden structure, no bigger than a modern bedroom, and imagine the young Lincoln behind the counter, trying to keep a failing business alive while the debt grew around him.

Lincoln never let it. He kept careful records and told every creditor where he was working and when he could pay next.

In 1849, fourteen years after Berry’s death, Lincoln paid the final dollar. He was forty, and he had spent nearly a third of his life clearing the debt of a business that had failed before he was twenty-six. That discipline, his friends later said, helped shape the man who would lead the country through its hardest years. The name “Honest Abe” came partly from how he handled this debt, and the trust it earned him among his neighbors helped launch the political career that carried him to the White House.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

134

FORM 1 A SIMPLE LOAN AGREEMENT

A Simple Loan Agreement

PRACTICAL A P P L I C AT I O N S What this section does!

This section covers two realworld forms every careful borrower or lender uses: a simple loan agreement and a loan ledger for tracking what is lent and what is owed. The section ends with a review case study and a final reflection.

A loan agreement is a short written document that records the terms of a loan between two people. It does not have to be fancy. A single piece of notebook paper, signed by both sides, is enough for most small loans between friends or family. The agreement protects both sides.

The lender has proof of the loan and the agreed-upon repayment. The borrower has a clear record of what was owed and when. With a written agreement, almost every loan disagreement is solved before it happens.

1

Sample agreement Daniel’s loan from his cousin Aaron This Agreement is made and entered into on Lender Name:

October 12 2 Borrower Name:

Aaron Carver 3

5

Loan Terms Loan Amount:

6

Interest Rate:

Daniel Carver 4

$25.00 No interest

by and between:

Interest of

$5.00 total fee (paid with repayment).

Additional Terms

To buy Castle Defenders Deluxe at the hobby store.

Purpose of the loan 11 If the loan is not repaid by the due date, Daniel will do extra Sunday chores for Aaron until the amount is paid in full.

Repayment Terms The Borrower agrees to repay the full amount of

8

In one lump sum In payments of

$30.00 by November 23 (Date), either: 10

$5.00 per week for 6 weeks beginning on October 12 9

Signatures 12 Lender Signature:

(Date).

10

Aaron C.

Borrower Signature:

Daniel C.

1 Title

5 Principal (amount loaned)

9 Repayment schedule

2 Date the loan is made

6 Interest or fee, if any

10 Final due date

3 Lender’s name

7 Purpose of the loan

11 Late-payment consequence

4 Borrower’s name

8 Total to be repaid

12 Signatures of both sides

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

7

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

135

YOUR TURN

Write Your Own Loan Agreement Imagine you are borrowing or lending money for a real reason. The reason can be anything: a school item, a hobby supply, a small gift for a family member, a snack. Fill in a complete loan agreement using the template below. Make every line specific. A vague line is the same as no line at all.

C H EC K YO U R WO R K Is every line specific (no vague answers like “soon” or “some amount”)? If the loan is paid back on time, is the agreement clear about what counts as “on time”? If the loan is NOT paid back on time, is the consequence stated clearly?

Loan Agreement

This Agreement is made and entered into on Lender Name:

by and between: Borrower Name:

Loan Terms Loan Amount:

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Interest Rate:

No interest

Interest of

total fee (paid with repayment).

Additional Terms Purpose of the loan

Repayment Terms The Borrower agrees to repay the full amount of

by

(Date), either:

In one lump sum

136

In payments of

beginning on

Signatures Lender Signature:

Borrower Signature:

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

(Date).

FORM 2 A LOAN LEDGER

A Loan Ledger

TIP

A loan ledger is a running list of every loan you have out or owe. Unlike a single agreement, the ledger covers all your loans at once, on a single page.

With the ledger, you can see your real money picture instantly: who owes you, whom you owe, and what your true net position is. Adults use ledgers to track business loans, mortgages, and credit card balances. The format works just as well for tracking the small loans of sixth-grade life.

Update the ledger every Sunday evening, the same time each week. A ledger that is updated regularly is easy to keep. A ledger that is updated only when a problem appears is already too late to help.

Sample ledger Date

Type

Person

Amou nt

Due

Status

Sep 4

Lent

Carlos

$5

Sep 5

Unpaid

Sep 18

Lent

Carlos

$3

Sep 19

Unpaid

Sep 25

Lent

Simon

$2

Sep 26

Unpaid

Sep 28

Borrowed

Older cousin

$4

Oct 5

Unpaid

Oct 2

Gift

Little brother

$1

n/a

Gift

Oct 5

Borrowed

Older brother

$3

Oct 12

Unpaid

Daniel’s net position summary Calculation

Amount

Cash in wallet

$12.00

Plus receivables (money lent out, unpaid)

$10.00

Minus payables (money borrowed, unpaid)

$7.00

Real net position

$15.00

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Daniel’s loans before he wrote his rules

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

137

YOUR TURN

Build Your Own Loan Ledger Think about every loan you have made or received in the last three months. Money lent to a friend. Money borrowed from a parent. A snack you said you owed your sibling. A small purchase a friend covered for you. Fill in the ledger below with at least four entries. If you cannot think of four real loans, invent two more that are realistic for your life. Then calculate your net position at the bottom.

YO U R L E D G E R Date

Type

Person

Amount

Due

Status

$ $ $ $ $

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

$

YO U R N E T P OS I T I O N Calculation

Amount

Cash on hand

$

Plus receivables (money lent out, unpaid)

$

Minus payables (money you owe, unpaid)

$

Your real net position

$

1.

Was your net position higher or lower than you expected?

2. What is the oldest unpaid loan on your ledger?

3. Will you ask for it back, write it off, or talk to the borrower this week?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

138

REVIEW CASE STUDY

Reuben Asks Daniel for Advice Reuben is in Daniel’s grade. He has just earned $40 from helping his uncle move boxes over the weekend. On Monday morning, three different things happen at school. Reuben is overwhelmed by the choices and asks Daniel for advice during lunch. Walk Daniel through the case using everything you have learned in this unit.

DISCUSSION Compare your advice to a classmate’s advice. Did the two of you give Reuben the same answer on each situation? If your answers were different, whose advice is stronger, and why?

Defend your choice using at least two Money Rules from this unit.

R E U B E N ’ S T H R E E S I T U AT I O N S Situation 1.

Carlos asks for $10

Detail Carlos says he needs $10 to buy a school field trip ticket by Friday. He promises to pay back in two weeks when his mom gives him allowance.

2. Simon offers a loan to Reuben

Simon offers to lend Reuben $20 today so Reuben can buy a strategy game he has been wanting. Reuben would pay back $25 over five weeks ($5 per week).

3. Reuben’s older brother asks for $15

His brother says he needs $15 for an emergency car repair part. He promises to pay back next weekend when he gets paid from his weekend job.

A P P LY T H E F O U R M O N E Y R U L E S F R O M T H I S U N I T Question to answer

Money Rule that helps

Your advice to Reuben

Should Reuben lend to Carlos?

What rule guides the answer? © Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Should Reuben borrow from Simon for the game?

Should Reuben lend to his brother for the car part?

What written record should Reuben keep for any loans he makes?

C H EC K YO U R WO R K There is more than one defensible answer to each situation. The point is not to find the one right answer. The point is to use the Money Rules from this unit, so that the advice you give Reuben is one you can explain and defend with reasons from the lessons.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

139

UNIT CLOSE

Looking Back at Daniel’s Unit Daniel started this unit watching a friend forget about a $5 loan.

Over four lessons, he learned how to handle money that moves between people. He learned the three questions to ask before lending, and how a loan with no follow-up becomes a quiet gift. He learned that borrowing always costs more than waiting, even from family and friends. He learned how untracked loans pile up and tangle your real money picture. And he learned, with his grandfather, how to write personal rules so that the next time he is asked for or offered a loan, the answer is already settled in his head.

None of these lessons is hard to understand. The hard part is acting on them when a friend looks worried at lunch and asks for $5. A smart lender and a smart borrower are not people who never give or receive loans. They are people who treat every loan as a real agreement, with a clear amount, a clear time, and a clear record. The rest takes care of itself.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

THE MONEY RULES FROM THIS UNIT Lesson 1

A loan is a gift unless you ask for it back.

Lesson 2

Borrowing always costs more than waiting.

Lesson 3

Every untracked loan is a quiet gift.

Lesson 4

Decide before you are asked.

R E A L- W O R L D A P P L I C A T I O N Choose one Money Rule from this unit. Write about a real or imagined situation of your own where this rule would help you handle a loan, either as the lender or the borrower. Use the exact words of the rule somewhere in your writing. Be specific about who is involved, what the amount is, and how the rule guides your choice.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

140

Unit 6

Protect and Plan Ahead How do you handle the things you can’t see coming?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

BIG QUESTION FOR THE UNIT

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

141

Meet Jake Jake is in sixth grade. He looks up. At trees. At buildings. Mostly at the sky. Jake’s grandfather was a navigator in the Air Force, back when navigators still used the stars to find their way home over the ocean. When Jake was eight, his grandfather gave him a small refractor telescope and a star chart and showed him how to find the Big Dipper, then Polaris, then the brighter planets. Jake has been outside almost every clear night since. He has a notebook full of sketches of the moon, Saturn, and a few galaxies he can just barely make out from his backyard. His parents call him “the kid who would rather be cold than miss a clear night.”

This unit is about the part of money no one wants to think about. The broken thing. The forgotten step. The bad weather. The lost gear. The unexpected expense that arrives on a Sunday evening when nothing is open. Jake learns, sometimes the hard way, that the people who handle these moments well are not the lucky ones. They are the ones who prepared.

W H AT ' S I N T H I S U N I T Lesson

Money Rule

1

The Broken Eyepiece

Save for the rainy day before the rain starts.

2

The Field Trip

Asking what could go wrong isn’t worry. It’s planning.

3

Where Jake’s Stuff Lives

What you don’t protect, you can lose.

4

Jake’s Full Plan

Cover what you want, what you need, and what you can’t see coming.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

#

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

142

UNIT 6 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E S I T U AT I O N

The Ping in the Dark DISCUSSION Was the eyepiece breaking Jake’s fault?

Was the empty “things that break” envelope his fault? These are two different questions. What’s the difference?

On a Sunday evening in October, Jake set up the telescope as usual. He pulled the eyepiece out of its felt-lined case. Somehow, in the dark, his hand slipped. The eyepiece dropped onto the concrete walkway with a single clear ping.

None of that mattered anymore. Replacement cost: $100.

The lens cracked from edge to edge. Jake stood for a long time in the cold air, holding the broken eyepiece. Saturn was rising in the east. The telescope was set up. The night was perfectly clear.

Jake walked back inside. He emptied his savings envelope onto the kitchen table. $16.25. He sat down and stared at the small pile of bills and coins.

He had no idea what to do.

W H E R E J A K E ’ S M O N E Y W A S O N T H A T S U N D AY N I G H T Where the money was

Amount

What it was for

Savings envelope

$16.25

Saving toward a planetarium book

A jar in the kitchen

$0

Nothing yet. Family change jar.

For things that break

$0

Did not exist.

Total available: $16.25 — Cost to fix: $100.00 = Short by: $83.75

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Jake had been watching Saturn for three weeks.

Every clear night, he carried his telescope out to the patch of grass behind the apple tree, set it up, and watched the planet through his favorite eyepiece. The eyepiece was a twelve-millimeter orthoscopic, an upgrade his dad had given him for his eleventh birthday. It made Saturn’s rings sharp in a way the original eyepiece never could.

BIG QUESTION FIRST INSTINCT What should Jake do?

A. Wait and save

B. Borrow from his dad

C. Use what he has + ask for help

D. Give up on Saturn for now

What do you do when something breaks and you have no money set aside?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

143

UNIT 6 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

THE SKILL

Most people who save money save for something specific. A goal fund. A telescope upgrade. A bicycle. A planetarium book. The goal sits in front of the saver, and the saving feels like progress toward it. This is the kind of saving Jake had been doing. His $16.25 had a name on it. It was telescope book money. When the eyepiece broke, that money was already promised somewhere else.

The trouble is, life does not just bring planned expenses. It also brings unplanned ones. The eyepiece that drops. The bike chain that snaps. The shoes that wear through. The school project that needs a poster board on a Sunday night. These costs are real, but they have no name and no schedule. If the only money a saver has is goal money, every surprise either steals from the goal or has to be borrowed.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

HISTORY

VOCABULARY

Two Funds Are Better Than One

Smart savers keep two funds, not one. The first fund is the goal fund, the money saving toward a specific named purchase. The second fund is the rainy day fund, the money saving for the surprise that has no name yet. Each fund has its own envelope, jar, or account.

Money does not move between them without a real reason. When the eyepiece breaks, the rainy day fund pays for it, and the goal fund stays untouched.

Goal fund - money saved for a specific named purchase with a clear date in mind.

Rainy day fund - money saved for the unexpected.

It has no name yet. It exists for surprises.

Sinking fund - a kind of rainy day fund saved a little at a time over many months, even when nothing is wrong yet.

Touched - informal word for money taken out of one fund to pay for something else. Smart savers keep their goal funds untouched.

MONEY RULE

Save for the rainy day before the rain starts.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Simon had been saving for a model rocket kit. He had $30 in his goal envelope and was about $10 from his target. On the way home from school, the strap on his backpack tore through, and the bag fell open onto the wet sidewalk. The backpack was beyond fixing. He needed a new one before Monday.

Simon had no rainy day fund. To buy a new backpack, he had to take $25 out of his rocket fund. The rocket kit, which he had been days from buying, was now six weeks away. After that day, Simon started a second envelope.

He puts $2 a week into it. He has never had to take from his rocket fund again, because the rainy day fund handles every small surprise that comes up.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

144

APPLY

UNIT 6 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

DECISION LAB DISCUSSION

Set Up Jake’s Two-Fund System

Two students might split Jake’s money very differently and both be defensible. What does each split assume about what is likely to happen next?

Jake decides to start a rainy day fund and continue his goal fund.

Help him split his current money and his future weekly allowance between the two funds. His weekly allowance is $5.

STEP 1 Where the money comes from

Goes in goal fund

Goes in rainy day fund

His current $16.25

$

$

Future weekly $5 (each week)

$

$

Upcoming $20 birthday money

$

$

Total per week to goal $

Total per week to rainy day $

STEP 2 Now pick Put 100% of weekly allowance in goal fund.

Skip the rainy day fund. Risky.

Put 50% in goal fund, 50% in rainy day fund. Slower goal, real safety net.

Put 70% in goal fund, 30% in rainy day fund. Goal comes first but safety net grows.

Put 100% in rainy day fund until it reaches $50, then switch.

Jake’s grandfather points out that the dropped eyepiece could have been avoided with a simple cloth strap that attaches to the eyepiece and to Jake’s wrist. The strap costs $15. Does that change how Jake splits his money? Should the strap come out of the rainy day fund, the goal fund, or somewhere else entirely?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

EXIT QUESTION Name one thing in your own life that broke or got lost unexpectedly. Did you or your family have money set aside for it?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

145

UNIT 6 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Ant and the Grasshopper

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

More than two thousand years ago, in the ancient Greek world, a storyteller named Aesop told short tales about animals. Most were only a few sentences long, and each carried a single lesson. His stories were passed from mouth to mouth for hundreds of years before anyone wrote them down, and they are still told today in almost every language on Earth.

One of them was about an ant and a grasshopper.

All summer, the ant carries small bits of food back to her nest. The grasshopper laughs at her.

He sings, plays his fiddle, and tells her summer will last forever. “Why are you working,” he asks, “when the sun is warm and food is everywhere?”

The ant does not answer. She keeps working, and by the end of summer her nest is full. The grasshopper has nothing but his fiddle. Then the cold winds blow, the leaves turn, and the first snow falls. The grasshopper is suddenly hungry and cold, with no food and no shelter. He goes to the ant’s nest and begs to be let in. The ant says, “You sang all summer. Now you can dance all winter.”

The story is not really about insects. It is about the idea that the time to prepare for hard times is during the easy times. Anyone who waits until the snow has fallen has waited too long. The cost of preparing in summer is small, but the cost of not

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The phrase “a rainy day fund” is centuries old in English. It comes from the idea that money set aside for an unexpected expense is like a coat kept by the door in case it rains. You do not need the coat most days.

But on the day you do need it, no amount of money will buy you a dry walk home if the coat is not already there.

preparing, once winter comes, is enormous. The same logic drives a rainy day fund. The time to save for the unexpected is when nothing is wrong yet. Saving a few dollars a week costs little. Not saving, once something breaks, can cost the whole goal fund or force you to borrow.

Aesop’s fables lasted two thousand years because their lessons are still true. The ant is not greedy or fearful. She is simply looking ahead. That is exactly what a rainy day fund is: the saver quietly preparing for a winter that has not arrived yet, while the sun is still warm.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

146

UNIT 6 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

TWO SCENARIOS

Two Versions of the Same Trip Jake’s astronomy club had planned an overnight field trip to Maple Lake Park, a dark-sky site about two hours from town. Twenty students from the club would set up their telescopes in a meadow at sunset and observe until two in the morning. The buses would leave from the school at four in the afternoon. Sunset was at seven-thirty.

Two days before the trip, Jake’s dad asked him one question. “What could go wrong?” Jake shrugged.

He had not thought about it. His dad smiled.

“That’s not a plan.” The two scenarios below show two versions of how Jake’s trip could go, depending on whether he answers his dad’s question.

DISCUSSION Version B took thirty extra minutes the day before. Was that thirty minutes worth it? What did the extra thirty minutes actually buy?

Version A: Jake didn’t think it through

Version B: Jake spent 30 minutes preparing

Telescope, eyepieces, and flashlight go into a cardboard box. On the bus, the box thumps around with the luggage.

Telescope goes in its padded case. Eyepieces are wrapped in soft cloth. On the bus, the case stays upright.

The focuser is loose, the flashlight is dead, dust is on the mirror, and Jake drops his only eyepiece. He sees Saturn for ten minutes.

The focuser is smooth, batteries are fresh, dust is cleaned, and eyepieces stay protected. Jake sees Saturn, Jupiter, Andromeda, and M13.

FIRST INSTINCT

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

J A K E ’ S S I T U AT I O N

BIG QUESTION

Which version of Jake had the better night?

A. Version A

B. Version B

C. About the same

D. Both, in different ways

How do you plan for things you can’t predict?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

147

UNIT 6 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

W H AT M A K E S T H E M D I F F E R E N T

The Question Before the Question Most people, when they plan an activity, ask one question: what do I need? Jake, when he packed his cardboard box, asked himself exactly that question. He needed his telescope, two eyepieces, and a flashlight. He packed all four. By the question he asked himself, his packing was complete.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

A better packer asks a second question first. What could go wrong?

This question changes everything. The telescope could get bumped, so it needs padding. The flashlight battery could die, so a backup is needed. The primary mirror could get dust on it, so a cleaning brush is needed. The eyepiece could break, like Jake’s did the month before, so a backup eyepiece is needed. Every potential failure suggests a small action that prevents it or recovers from it. Thirty minutes of asking what could go wrong turns a cardboard box into a real travel kit.

This is not about being paranoid or expecting disaster. Most of the time, nothing goes wrong, and the cleaning brush stays in the case unused. The cost of asking the question is small, and the benefit shows up on the rare night that something does go wrong. Pilots ask this question before every flight. Surgeons ask it before every operation.

Smart travelers ask it before every trip. Once a person learns to ask what could go wrong, they almost never get caught by surprise again.

APPLY

HISTORY

VOCABULARY Pre-trip checklist - a written list of what could go wrong and what to bring or do to prevent each thing.

Pre-mortem - an exercise where you imagine the activity has failed and ask yourself why it failed. The reasons become the checklist.

Single point of failure one critical item that, if it breaks or is missing, ends the whole activity. Usually deserves a backup.

Backup - a second copy of something critical, kept in case the first one fails.

Cheap insurance against single points of failure.

MONEY RULE

Asking what could go wrong isn’t worry.

It’s planning.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Carlos had a magic show booked at his cousin’s birthday party. He spent thirty minutes the day before doing a pre-mortem. He asked himself: what could go wrong? The deck of cards could be missing a card. So he packed a backup deck. The wand could roll off the table. So he packed a small piece of putty to anchor it. A prop trick could fail to spring open in the moment.

So he practiced a backup joke to use if any one trick failed.

On the day of the show, two cards from his main deck were stuck together. He pulled out the backup deck without anyone noticing. One trick failed to spring open. He told his backup joke. The audience laughed harder at the failed trick than at the successful ones. Carlos walked away with $20 in tips.

The thirty minutes the day before was the difference between a great show and a disaster.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

148

UNIT 6 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

C H O O S E Y O U R PAT H

Build Jake’s Pre-Trip Checklist For each potential problem in the table below, decide what Jake could do to prevent it or recover from it. Write your answer in the second column.

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

STEP 1 Potential problem

How to prevent or prepare

Telescope damaged in transit Dead flashlight battery Dust on primary mirror

The forecast changes the night before the trip. There is now a forty percent chance of light rain between nine and eleven at night. Does that change the checklist?

What new items does it add?

Eyepiece dropped Got cold; can’t keep observing

DISCUSSION

STEP 2 Now pick Cancel. Stay home. The rain risk isn’t worth it.

How much preparation is too much? Is there a point where asking what could go wrong becomes worry instead of planning?

Go but skip the gear. Just watch with binoculars.

Go with full prep plus rain cover for the telescope and a waterproof bag for the eyepieces.

Go with full prep and bring a backup activity in case the meadow gets too wet.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Forgot to bring star charts

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: what’s the question a smart traveler asks before any trip?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

149

UNIT 6 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Captain’s Checklist

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

On a fall morning in October 1935, at Wright Field in Dayton, Ohio, a brand-new airplane rolled onto the runway. It was the Boeing Model 299, the most advanced bomber ever built, with four engines, retractable landing gear, and dozens of new switches and controls. The Army was watching closely. If the plane performed well, Boeing would win a contract to build hundreds more.

In the cockpit sat Major Ployer Hill, one of the most experienced test pilots in the country, who had flown every kind of plane the Army owned. The plane took off perfectly and climbed to about three hundred feet. Then it stalled, rolled onto one side, and crashed.

Major Hill and one other crew member were killed.

Investigators expected a mechanical fault. Instead they found that Hill, the most experienced pilot in the Army, had forgotten one step. He had not released a small lever called the gust lock, which held the control surfaces in place during ground storage. With it still engaged, the plane could not respond to the controls. Nothing was wrong with the plane. Something was wrong with the procedure.

Boeing’s engineers drew an important conclusion.

The Model 299 was simply too complex for any pilot to run from memory, no matter how skilled.

So they invented the pre-flight checklist: a short card listing every step the pilot had to complete before takeoff, each one checked off out loud

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The crash of the Model 299 made the front page of newspapers the next morning.

Some papers called the plane “too much airplane for any one man to fly.” The Army Air Corps almost cancelled the contract.

The checklist saved the plane. The plane, eventually renamed the B-17 Flying Fortress, became one of the most important aircraft of the twentieth century.

before the next began. It included things every pilot already knew, like releasing the gust lock. But putting them on paper, where they could not be forgotten, changed everything.

With the checklist in use, the Model 299 flew almost two million miles for the Army without a single serious accident. Every plane built since has used one, and so does every spacecraft. Surgeons use checklists before operations, and construction crews use them before pouring concrete. The simple idea, born from one fatal crash in 1935, has saved many thousands of lives. It is the same idea Jake’s dad asked him to use before the field trip: what could go wrong, and what should I do about it now?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

150

INTRO

UNIT 6 | LESSON 3

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E M YST E RY

Walk Through the House After the field trip, Jake came home tired and happy.

He set his telescope down in the garage, dropped his eyepiece case on his bedroom floor, tossed his notebook on the desk, and went to bed. The next morning, his dad asked him to come downstairs.

“Show me where all your astronomy gear is right now,” his dad said.

Jake walked his dad through the house. The telescope was leaning against a metal shelf in the garage. The eyepiece case was on the floor of his bedroom, where the family cat liked to sleep. The notebook was on his desk under a half-empty glass of water. The expensive star atlas his grandfather had given him was on a low shelf in the family room, near the back door, where his older brother kicked off muddy boots almost every day after baseball practice.

DISCUSSION Jake had never been robbed and had never had a flood. So why does it matter where his stuff lives?

His dad listened, then asked one question. “What if there was a fire tonight? Or a flood? Or a stranger walked in through the back door?”

Jake had never thought about any of it. He had thousands of dollars of astronomy gear scattered across four rooms with no plan.

Item

Approximate value

Where it currently lives

What could go wrong

Refractor telescope

$400

Leaning against metal shelf in garage

Fall, theft, temperature swings

Three eyepieces in soft case

$150

Floor of bedroom

Stepped on, knocked, lost

Star atlas (a gift)

$75

Low shelf, family room, near back door

Water damage, taken

Observing notebook

(priceless to Jake)

Desk, under half-full glass

Spilled water, lost forever

BIG QUESTION

FIRST INSTINCT Which of Jake's items is in the most danger right now?

A. Telescope

B. Eyepieces

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

JAKE'S ASTRONOMY INVENTORY AND WHERE IT LIVES

C. Star atlas

What does it actually mean to protect something?

D. Notebook

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

151

UNIT 6 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

THE CLUES

Three Layers of Protection Protecting something valuable does not mean putting it in one giant safe and never touching it. Real protection comes in layers, and different items need different layers depending on how easily they could be lost and how much they would cost to replace.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

The first layer is physical protection. A padded case keeps a telescope from getting bumped. A lockbox keeps small valuables out of reach of pets and casual visitors. A waterproof bag keeps a notebook safe from spills. Each physical container is a thin wall between the item and the most likely way the item could be damaged. The second layer is location protection. The same item in two different rooms is at two different risk levels. A star atlas on a low shelf near a back door is exposed to water and to anyone who walks in. The same atlas on a high shelf in a closet is protected from both, even without any special container.

The third layer is financial protection. Even with the best physical case and the safest location, things sometimes get lost or destroyed. A rainy day fund makes that loss recoverable. For very expensive items, like a $1,000 telescope, the financial layer is sometimes provided by something called insurance. Insurance is a small payment made every month that promises a larger payment back if the item is lost.

The three layers work together. The case prevents the easy losses.

The location prevents most of the harder ones. The fund or insurance handles the worst case. The smartest protection plan uses all three for the most valuable items, and just one or two for less valuable ones.

Physical protection - containers, cases, padding, and locks. The walls between the item and harm.

Location protection - where the item lives matters as much as what it lives in. High shelves beat low ones.

Financial protection - money set aside or insurance bought to recover the cost if the item is lost despite the other layers.

Insurance - a monthly payment that promises a larger payment back if a covered item is lost or damaged.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Aaron had a small collection of antique pocket watches that he had inherited from his grandfather. Five watches in total.

Two of them were quite valuable. Three were sentimental but not worth much money. Aaron built a three-tier system. The two valuable watches went into a small fireproof lockbox his dad bought for $50. The lockbox went on a high closet shelf, out of reach and out of sight. The three sentimental watches went into a soft cloth pouch in a desk drawer in his bedroom.

He kept a written list of all five watches, with their values, in a separate envelope at his grandmother’s house. If anything happened to his bedroom, the list still survived.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

152

VOCABULARY

MONEY RULE

What you don’t protect, you can lose.

UNIT 6 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

DISCUSSION S O LV E I T

Match the Protection to the Item Use the three layers to design a real protection plan for Jake’s gear. For each item, fill in what kind of physical container it should be in, where in the house it should live, and whether it deserves a rainy day fund line of its own.

If Jake could only afford ONE layer of protection (physical, location, OR financial) for the next year, which one should he build first?

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N Jake’s grandfather offers to give him a small lockbox for his birthday. The lockbox holds about the size of a shoebox.

Only a few of Jake’s items will fit. Which ones go in the lockbox, and why those?

SAM'S NEW LEDGER STEP 1 Physical container

Location

In the fund?

Telescope ($400)

Yes / No

Eyepieces ($150)

Yes / No

Star atlas ($75)

Yes / No

Notebook (priceless)

Yes / No

STEP 2 Now pick Lockbox holds the eyepieces. They are small and fit well, plus they are expensive per cubic inch.

Lockbox holds the notebook. It is irreplaceable.

Lockbox holds both the eyepieces and the notebook. They both fit.

Lockbox holds the eyepieces, notebook, and a copy of the inventory list.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Item

EXIT QUESTION Name one thing of yours that has no protection plan right now. Pick one layer you could add this week.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

153

UNIT 6 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Roman Arca

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In the homes of wealthy Romans almost two thousand years ago, one piece of furniture was built more carefully than any other. It was a heavy wooden chest, bound with iron straps, with a thick lid and a complicated lock on the front. The Romans called it an arca, the same root that gives English the words ark and arch. The arca held a family’s most important things: coins, jewelry, documents, the seals used to mark official letters, and sometimes weapons.

But the arca was not just a strong box. It was a system. It sat in the most secure room of the house, often a small windowless room near the main hall. It was bolted to the stone floor with iron pins, so that even a thief who got into the room could not carry it off. The lid was held by a complex Roman lock whose key was shaped almost like a small comb, and only the head of the household carried that key. In the richest homes, a trusted watchman guarded the room through the night.

The lessons of the arca are the lessons of this unit. First, the most valuable things deserve the strongest protection. A poor family kept its few coins in a cloth pouch, while a wealthy family kept its coins in an iron-bound chest bolted to a stone floor in a windowless room. The level of protection matched the value of what was protected. Second, real protection is a system, not a single thing. The chest was strong, but it was also in the right room,

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The word “safe,” used to describe a strong metal box for valuables, did not exist in English until about the 1500s. Before then, the word was usually “strongbox” or just “chest.”

The change from “chest” to “safe” happened when locks got good enough that the box itself, not just the room around it, became the main thing keeping the contents safe.

locked with the right key, and watched by the right person. Remove any one of those layers, and the protection grew much weaker.

The arca slowly evolved into the modern safe.

The iron straps became steel walls. The Roman lock became a combination dial or a keypad. The night watchman became a motion sensor or an alarm. But the core idea has not changed in two thousand years: the most valuable things go in the strongest container, in the safest location, with the most reliable monitoring. Anyone who has used a safe deposit box at a bank or a lockbox at home is using a lighter version of what a Roman would have recognized at once.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

154

INTRO

UNIT 6 | LESSON 4

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

TWO PEOPLE DISAGREE

Three Things on the Table On a cool Sunday afternoon in late autumn, Jake sat at the kitchen table with his dad and his grandfather. The garage door was open, and through it Jake could see his telescope in its new padded case. On the table in front of him were three things.

The first was a single sheet of paper with the complete inventory of his astronomy gear, written out in his own handwriting. The second was a small lockbox his grandfather had brought as a late birthday gift, about the size of a shoebox, with a real key. The third was a blank page.

Jake understood that the blank page was the one they were there to fill in. “What does the plan need to do?” he asked.

Why does the full plan need all three pieces? What goes wrong if Jake builds two of the three but skips the last one?

His grandfather answered. “It needs to cover three things. The things you want, like the telescope upgrade you’ve been saving for. The things you need, like a working backpack for school. And the things you can’t see coming, like the next eyepiece you might drop. A plan that only covers one of those isn’t really a plan.”

JAKE’S DESIGN CHALLENGE The full plan must answer

From which lesson

How much money goes into a rainy day fund each week?

Lesson 1

What’s on the checklist before any big trip or activity?

Lesson 2

Which items live in which kind of protection?

Lesson 3

FIRST INSTINCT

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

“You’ve learned three things in this unit,” his dad said. “Save for what you can’t see coming. Plan for what could go wrong. Protect what matters. Today, we put all three together into one plan that you can actually follow.”

DISCUSSION

BIG QUESTION

Which piece of the plan should Jake build first?

A. Rainy day fund

B. Pre-trip checklist

C. Protection plan

D. All three at once

How do you put all the pieces together?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

155

UNIT 6 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

EACH SIDE'S REASONING

VOCABULARY Full plan - all three parts written down together.

Not a vague idea, but a real document the family can follow.

Three Parts of a Full Protection Plan

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

A complete protection plan has three parts. Each part comes from one of the earlier lessons in this unit. When all three parts are written down and followed, they work together as one system. Take any one part away, and the system breaks down.

The third part is the protected items list. A short inventory of the most valuable things owned, with a clear note for each one about where it lives, what container it lives in, and whether it has financial protection in the form of the rainy day fund or insurance. The list is the daily layer. It does its job every day, just by being followed. The three parts together cover the three time-windows of a problem. The checklist handles the moment before, the protected items list handles the moment of, and the rainy day fund handles the moment after.

Coverage - the range of things the plan handles. A good plan covers wants, needs, and surprises.

Layered defense - using more than one layer of protection so that a failure of one layer does not cause total loss.

Living document - a written plan that gets updated as life changes, not a one-time piece of paper.

MONEY RULE

Cover what you want, what you need, and what you can’t see coming.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Reuben helps his uncle with weekend yard sales. Reuben sells handmade greeting cards at the same sales. Over six months, he built his own three-part plan. He saves $2 a week into a small rainy day fund for when his card materials run out or get damaged. He has a checklist he runs before every yard sale, covering display setup, change box stocking, and weather prep. And he keeps his finished card inventory in a clear plastic bin with a tight lid, in his bedroom closet, not in the garage. Three parts. Each one small.

Together, they have kept his card business running through three rainstorms, two missing supplies, and one yard-sale day his uncle had to cancel at the last minute.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

156

INTRO

UNIT 6 | LESSON 4

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

WHERE THE TRUTH SITS

Assemble Jake’s Full Plan Use the three parts to build Jake’s complete plan. Fill in each part on the blank page in front of him.

PART 1 The rainy day fund Target balance: $

Weekly amount: $

Where it lives:

PART 2 The pre-trip checklist Item 1:

Item 3:

Item 2:

Item 4: Item 5:

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

Jake’s grandfather mentions he has been thinking about giving Jake a small motorized tracking mount for his next birthday, which would be worth about $300. Does that change any part of the plan? Where would the mount live? Does the rainy day fund target change?

PART 3 The protected items list Physical container

Location

Telescope

DISCUSSION Two students might design Jake’s plan very differently and both be defensible. What does each design tell you about what the student thinks is most likely to go wrong?

Eyepieces Star atlas Notebook

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Item

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: which of the three parts of the plan do you think will be the hardest for Jake to actually stick to over the next year?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

157

UNIT 6 | LESSON 4

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

Lloyd’s of London

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In 1688, on a narrow street near the River Thames in London, a man named Edward Lloyd opened a small coffee shop, just a few rooms with wooden tables, a fireplace, and a steady supply of strong dark coffee. Coffee was still a new drink in England, and coffee shops were where merchants, sailors, and traders gathered to talk business.

Lloyd’s shop quickly drew one particular crowd: ship captains, ship owners, and marine insurers.

In those days, sending a ship from London to somewhere far away, like the Caribbean or India, was an enormous risk. About one ship in ten never came back. Storms sank them, pirates captured them, disease killed their crews, and fires destroyed their cargo. A single lost voyage could ruin the ship’s owner and everyone who had invested in the cargo, turning a wealthy merchant into a pauper overnight.

Edward Lloyd noticed that the men in his shop had an unspoken way of helping each other. When an owner was about to send a vessel on a dangerous voyage, he wrote the details of the trip on a sheet of paper. Other merchants read it, and each one willing to share the risk signed his name and an amount underneath. A merchant who signed for one hundred pounds was promising to pay one hundred pounds if the ship went down. In return, the owner paid him a small fee, called a premium, in advance.

Each merchant who signed was called an underwriter, because his name went under the description of the risk. If twenty merchants each signed for fifty pounds, the owner had a thousand

D I D YO U K N OW ?

When a major ship was lost at sea, Lloyd’s of London would ring a bell in the main hall. The bell was rescued from a sunken ship called the HMS Lutine and is called the Lutine Bell. For many years, the bell was rung once for bad news and twice for good news. The Lutine Bell still hangs in the main hall of Lloyd’s today, though it is now rung only on rare ceremonial occasions.

pounds of coverage. If the ship sank, the twenty each paid fifty pounds, and the owner was made whole. A small loss spread across twenty men was far easier to absorb than one catastrophic loss falling on a single owner.

Lloyd’s coffee shop became the center of marine insurance for the whole world, and the system that began there is now known as Lloyd’s of London. It still exists more than three hundred years later. The basic idea has not changed: many people who can each afford a small loss come together to protect one who could not afford a big one. That is the foundation of all insurance, the financial layer of every protection plan, scaled up to global trade. It is the same idea Jake used in his small way, by setting aside a few dollars a week for rainy days. How do you protect what you cannot afford to lose?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

158

FORM 1 RAINY DAY FUND TRACKER

How to Track a Rainy Day Fund

PRACTICAL A P P L I C AT I O N S

A rainy day fund only works if it grows. To grow, it needs three things written down: a target balance, a weekly contribution, and a running total. Without those three numbers on paper, the fund quietly shrinks instead of quietly growing. A simple tracker keeps the fund honest.

What this section does!

This section covers a rainy day fund tracker, a risk inventory worksheet, a review case study that ties the unit together, and a final reflection.

Week

Contributed

Withdrawn

Running balance

1

$3

$0

$3

2

$3

$0

$6

3

$3

$0

$9

4

$3

$0

$12

5

$3

$0

$15

6

$3

$10 (broken telescope leg replaced)

$8

7

$3

$0

$11

8

$3

$0

$14

9

$3

$0

$17

10

$3

$0

$20

O N E T H I N G T H E T R AC K E R S H OWS

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

JAKE’S TRACKER FOR THE FIRST TEN WEEKS

In week six, Jake had to pull $10 out to fix a broken telescope leg. Without the tracker, this might have felt like a setback. Looking at the column, it’s clear that the fund recovered within four weeks and was higher at week ten than at week five. The tracker turns invisible progress into visible progress.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

159

YOUR TURN

Fill in Your Own Tracker Imagine you start a rainy day fund this week.

Decide your target, your weekly amount, and fill in the first ten weeks below. Include at least one withdrawal somewhere in the ten weeks, since that’s realistic.

My target balance: $ Week

1

2

3

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

160

Contributed

Withdrawn

My weekly contribution: $ Running balance

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

$

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

What was it for?

FORM 2 RISK INVENTORY

How to Build a Risk Inventory A risk inventory is a one-page document that lists everything important and what could go wrong with each. It is the written version of the question Jake’s dad kept asking. What could go wrong? Anyone who has filled one out, even once, finds that they think differently about their belongings afterward.

Item

Most likely risk

Protection in place

Telescope

Bumped, dropped, knocked over

Padded case + high shelf

Eyepieces

Dropped, lost

Soft case + small lockbox

Star atlas

Spilled on, taken

High shelf + dust cover

Notebook

Spilled on, lost

Desk drawer + waterproof sleeve

The bike (recent purchase)

Stolen, rusted in rain

Locked + covered when stored outside

School backpack

Strap broken, lost contents

Replace stitching every six months

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

J A K E ’ S R I S K I N V E N T O R Y, C O M P L E T E D

Once a year, Jake re-reads the inventory and updates it. Items get added when he gets new things. Risks get changed when his situation changes (he started biking to school, so the bike was added). The inventory takes ten minutes to update, and it’s the single most useful tool in his protection plan.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

161

YOUR TURN

Build Your Own Risk Inventory Pick five things you own that matter to you. They do not have to be expensive. Some of the most important items have no dollar value at all. Fill out the inventory below.

YO U R R I S K I N V E N TO RY

Most likely risk

Protection in place

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Item

REFLECTION QUESTIONS 1.

Which of your five items has the weakest protection right now?

Answer:

2. What is one small thing you could change this week to improve that item’s protection?

Answer: Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

162

REVIEW CASE STUDY

Jake’s Big Summer Six months after building his plan, Jake faces a much bigger test.

His grandfather invites him on a two-week summer trip to a desert observatory in another state. Jake will bring his own telescope and gear. The trip will involve a long drive, two nights camping, and visits to a famous observatory where Jake will get a chance to look through a telescope twenty times larger than his own. Work through the case below.

T H E S I T U AT I O N Jake’s rainy day fund balance: $87.

Estimated trip cost (Jake’s share of food and supplies): $60.

Astronomy gear coming with him: telescope, three eyepieces, star atlas, notebook, new tracking mount his grandfather gave him for his birthday.

Risks his dad pointed out: long car ride, two nights in a tent, sand and dust at the desert site, possible night-temperature swings.

WA L K T H R O U G H J A K E ’ S P R E PA R AT I O N S Question to answer

Which Money Rule helps?

Your answer

Is Jake’s rainy day fund big enough to cover the trip costs and still have a real cushion left?

What is the single biggest pre-trip checklist item that did not apply on his earlier overnight field trip?

If Jake’s eyepiece breaks during the trip, how should he handle it differently than the first time?

C H EC K YO U R WO R K

DISCUSSION

Multiple answers can be defensible for these questions. What matters is that the reasoning uses the Money Rules from this unit. A choice is well-defended when the rule that supports it is clear.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Which two items from his gear list deserve the strongest protection in the car?

Compare your preparation plan to a classmate’s. Whose plan would have caught more potential problems, and which problem was the one neither of you thought of?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

163

UNIT CLOSE

Looking Back at Jake’s Unit Jake started this unit with a broken eyepiece on a concrete walkway.

Over the four lessons, he learned the three pieces of preparing for the unexpected. Set money aside before you need it. Ask what could go wrong before any big activity. Match the right level of protection to the right item. By the end, he had a complete plan he could actually follow, written on one page, with three parts, all of which work together.

These ideas are not new. Aesop’s ant saved through the summer.

Boeing’s engineers wrote a checklist after a fatal crash. Wealthy Romans bolted their arca to the floor. Merchants in a London coffee shop pooled their risk against shipwrecks. The same three ideas have been with us for thousands of years. They work because they match how problems actually happen in the world. Most surprises arrive too fast to react to. The people who handle them well are the ones who already prepared.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

THE MONEY RULES FROM THIS UNIT Lesson 1

Save for the rainy day before the rain starts.

Lesson 2

Asking what could go wrong isn’t worry. It’s planning.

Lesson 3

What you don’t protect, you can lose.

Lesson 4

Cover what you want, what you need, and what you can’t see coming.

R E A L- W O R L D A P P L I C A T I O N Choose one Money Rule from this unit. Write about a time when you wished you had been more prepared. Use the rule’s exact words in your writing. Explain what you would do differently next time, and what small thing you could start doing this week to be ready.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

164

Unit 7

How Money Moves How does money move through a business, and how do you keep track of it?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

BIG QUESTION FOR THE UNIT

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

165

Meet Henry Henry is in sixth grade. His family owns Locust Bakery, a small shop on the corner of Locust Street and Fifth Avenue. They have been baking bread, rolls, and rye loaves there for forty years.

The bakery is named after his great-grandfather, who opened it after he came to the United States.

Henry helps after school. He sweeps the front of the shop, stocks the bread shelves, and on busy afternoons he counts change at the register. He has been working alongside his dad for about a year, and he has started to notice something. Money does not just sit still. It moves.

Every day, hundreds of dollars come in over the counter. The same dollars go back out to pay for flour, sugar, butter, electricity, and wages. By the end of the week, the bakery has handled thousands of dollars, but only a small portion stays. In this unit, Henry learns how money moves through a business, where it sits along the way, and how to track every dollar from the moment it walks in the door to the moment it walks back out.

W H AT ' S I N T H I S U N I T Lesson

Money Rule

1

The Day’s Take

Money sitting still has a job.

2

Cash or Check

Some payments are safer slow.

3

Henry’s Money Flow

Track every dollar in. Track every dollar out.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

#

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

166

INTRO

UNIT 7 | LESSON 1

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E S I T U AT I O N

Four Places, Four Jobs “What happens to all this?” Henry asked. His dad looked up. “What do you mean?” “That’s a lot of money. Where does it go?”

His dad smiled. He pointed to four different places in the shop. The cash drawer itself. A small lockbox under the counter. A leather folder near the

DISCUSSION Why does the bakery split the money into four places instead of keeping it all together? What problem does each split solve? register. And the safe in the back room. “Each one of these holds a different part of the day’s take,” he said. “And each one has a different job.”

H O W H E N R Y ’ S D A D S P L I T S T H E D AY Place

Amount

Cash drawer

$100 in small bills

Job Tomorrow’s change for customers.

Lockbox under counter

$350

Wednesday’s bank deposit.

Leather folder

$30

Petty cash for small supply runs.

Safe in back room

$7 + earlier savings

Saving for a new oven.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

It was almost eight in the evening at Locust Bakery. The last customer had left twenty minutes earlier. Henry was wiping down the front counter while his dad counted the cash drawer. The total for the day was $487.

BIG QUESTION

FIRST INSTINCT If Henry’s dad had to step out and run an errand right now, which envelope of money would be safest to leave behind?

A: Cash drawer

B: Lockbox

C: Leather folder

D: Safe

When the day is done, where should the bakery’s money go?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

167

INTRO

UNIT 7 | LESSON 1

LEARN

THE SKILL

HISTORY

VOCABULARY

Every Dollar Has a Job A business never keeps all its money in one place. Different chunks of money have different jobs. Some money has to be available right now, so customers can get correct change at the register. Some money has to be safe, so it cannot be lost or stolen. Some money has to be ready for small unexpected purchases, like running out of flour in the middle of the morning. Some money is being saved for big future purchases that will take months to fund.

Putting all the money in one pile makes every dollar do the same job. That sounds simple, but it actually means no dollar can do its job well. The day’s-deposit money sits next to the change money sits next to the savings money, and any one of them can be spent on any of the others by accident. By the end of the week, no one is sure what was supposed to be saved and what was supposed to be spent.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

APPLY

Splitting the money into separate places, with each place having a clear purpose, makes every dollar do the right job. The split does not have to use envelopes or lockboxes. It can be jars at home, accounts at a bank, or pages in a notebook. What matters is that each chunk has a name and a purpose, and that the chunks do not get mixed up.

Cash on hand - money kept physically in the business, ready for everyday transactions like customer change.

Petty cash - a small fund for minor, immediate expenses, like an emergency run to the grocer for missing sugar.

Operating funds - money set aside to pay regular bills like rent, electricity, and supplier invoices.

Reserve fund - money saved for big future purchases or unexpected emergencies. The slowest-moving pile.

MONEY RULE

Money sitting still has a job.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Simon runs a lemonade stand every weekend. By the end of a Sunday he has $45 in cash. He used to keep it all in one jar and pull money out whenever he needed something. After two weekends, he could not tell how much was supposed to be next-weekend supply money and how much was profit.

Simon started splitting his $45 into three envelopes: $15 for next week’s lemons, sugar, and cups. $20 in a savings envelope for a bigger thermos. $10 for unexpected expenses like running out of paper cups midday. Now every dollar in every envelope has a job. He never accidentally spends the supply money on something else, and the thermos savings grows a little each weekend.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

168

UNIT 7 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

DECISION LAB

Where Each Dollar Sleeps Tonight Henry’s dad asked Henry to take the day’s $487 and put each chunk in the right place. Use the table below to assign each amount to one of the four places.

STEP 1 Sort each chunk What this chunk is for

$100

Tomorrow’s customer change

$30

Petty cash for small runs

$50

New oven savings

$307

Wednesday’s bank deposit

If you only had one envelope at home and one bank account, would you still need to split the money? How would you do it?

Where it goes

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

STEP 2 Now pick Move $180 from the lockbox now so Friday’s payment is ready.

Leave everything where it was. Pay Mr. Albertson from Wednesday’s deposit after the bank trip.

Pull $180 from the safe (new oven savings) and replace it later.

Wait until Friday morning to decide.

Mr. Albertson, the flour supplier, drops off an invoice for $180 due Friday. Henry’s dad usually pays him by check from the operating funds. Does that change where any of tonight’s $487 should go? Why or why not?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Amount

DISCUSSION

EXIT QUESTION Name one thing you save money for. Where do you keep that money now, and does it have its own place?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

169

UNIT 7 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Medici Bank

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In 1397, in the northern Italian city of Florence, a man named Giovanni di Bicci de’ Medici opened a small business at a wooden counter in the public square. He had a chair, a strongbox, and a heavy ledger. People came to exchange one kind of coin for another. A merchant arriving from Venice with Venetian ducats could trade them for Florentine florins. A French traveler could trade his coins for the local money. Giovanni took a small fee on every trade.

The wooden counter where he sat was called a banco, the Italian word that became the English word bank. Over the next hundred years, Giovanni’s little counter grew into one of the largest banking houses in Europe, with offices in London, Bruges, Geneva, Venice, Rome, and a dozen other cities. The Medici used their bank to fund kings, rulers, artists, and explorers, helping pay for the paintings, sculptures, and grand buildings that made Florence famous, all from a business that began at a single counter.

Before the Medici, the only place to keep large amounts of money was at home, locked in a chest, and that was dangerous. Thieves knew where the chests were. Fires destroyed homes. Travelers carrying cash across the Alps were robbed regularly. The Medici offered something new. A merchant could deposit money at the bank in Florence and withdraw it later in London, without ever carrying the coins across Europe. A letter from the Florence office, sealed with the Medici stamp, was enough.

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The word ‘bankrupt’ also comes from the Italian word banco. When a banker could no longer pay his debts, the other merchants in the square would smash his wooden counter to pieces in public. The phrase was banca rotta, meaning ‘broken bench.’ A banker whose bench was broken could no longer do business. The English word bankrupt is what that phrase became over the centuries.

This was an enormous change. Money no longer had to travel with the person who owned it. The coins sat safely in one place while the owner moved freely, and business could happen across long distances without the constant risk of robbery on the road. Whole industries that had been impossible before suddenly became possible.

The Medici bank fell apart in the 1490s, after generations of careless management by Giovanni’s descendants.

But the idea did not die. Banks like the Medici’s spread across Europe, then across the Atlantic to the American colonies, and eventually became the bank branches you can walk into today. Every time someone deposits money, exchanges currency, or asks a bank to send funds to another city, they are using a system that traces back to that wooden counter in a Florence square.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

170

INTRO

UNIT 7 | LESSON 2

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

TWO SCENARIOS

Two Ways to Pay the Flour Mill Henry’s family buys flour from a mill in a town three hundred miles away. Once a month, they have to send the mill $300. The mill ships them their flour. They send the mill the payment. The trick is the payment has to travel by mail.

Henry’s dad explained that there were two main ways to send the money. He told Henry to imagine two different versions of the same week. In the first version, he sent $300 in cash. In the second version, he sent a check for $300. Both versions show the same dollar amount going to the same place. Read both, then decide which was the better choice.

DISCUSSION Cash is faster. So why might a slower method end up being safer?

The week he sent cash

The week he sent a check

Counted $300 in $20 bills. Put it in an envelope.

Wrote a check for $300 from the bakery account. Put it in an envelope.

Sealed the envelope. Took it to the post office.

Sealed the envelope. Took it to the post office.

Day 3: Envelope went missing somewhere in transit.

Day 3: Envelope went missing somewhere in transit.

No way to trace the money. No record of which bills were inside.

Bank record shows the check has not been cashed yet.

Bakery is out $300 with no way to recover it.

Henry’s dad calls the bank and stops the check.

The mill never gets the original. He writes a new check.

Pays the mill again with new cash. Total cost: $600.

Mill eventually receives the replacement check.

Total cost: $300.

FIRST INSTINCT

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

H E N R Y ’ S S I T U AT I O N

BIG QUESTION

Which week ended better for the bakery?

A: Cash week

B: Check week

C: They were equal

D: Need more information

When you have to send money to someone far away, what’s the best way to send it?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

171

UNIT 7 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

W H AT M A K E S T H E M D I F F E R E N T

Speed Is Not the Only Thing That Matters Cash and checks both move money from one person to another, but they do it in completely different ways. Cash is the money itself.

The actual bills change hands. Once they are gone, they are gone. A check is not money. A check is a written instruction that tells a bank to move money from one account to another. The bills never move.

Only the instruction moves.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

This difference is small until something goes wrong. If cash is lost or stolen, there is almost no way to recover it. The bills carry no information about who they belong to. Whoever holds them owns them. A check, by contrast, has the name of the person it is meant to be paid to, written right on the front. If a check is lost or stolen, the bank can stop it before anyone cashes it, and a new check can be written to replace it. The money never actually moved until the right person cashed the check.

This is why most businesses pay each other with checks instead of cash, even though cash is faster. The speed of cash is not worth the risk of losing it. The slowness of a check is the price of being able to undo the transaction if something goes wrong.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Carlos’s grandmother lives in another state. Every year on his birthday she sends him $50. For years she sent cash inside a card. One year the envelope arrived empty. Someone had opened it in transit and taken the bills. There was no way to prove the cash had been inside, and no way to get it back.

Carlos’s grandmother now sends a check instead. She writes “Pay to the order of Carlos” on the check. If a check ever gets stolen on the way, the thief cannot cash it, because the bank will only release the money to Carlos. The envelope is still slow.

But the money is much safer.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

172

VOCABULARY Cash - physical paper money and coins.

Whoever holds it owns it.

Check - a written instruction telling a bank to move money from one account to another. The money does not move until the check is cashed.

Stop payment - an order telling the bank not to honor a check, usually because the check was lost, stolen, or sent in error.

Paper trail - the written record of where money came from and where it went. Cash leaves no paper trail. Checks always do.

MONEY RULE

Some payments are safer slow.

UNIT 7 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

C H O O S E Y O U R PAT H

Pick the Right Method for Each Payment Henry’s family has three different payments to make this week. For each one, decide whether cash or check is the better choice, and explain why.

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N Mr. Albertson, the flour supplier, is at the back door waiting for his $180 invoice payment. He says he will be at the bakery for ten more minutes before he has to drive home.

Does the time pressure change which method is better in this case?

STEP 1 List the features that matter to Henry Payment

Cash or check?

Why?

$5 tip for the kid who carried bags of flour from the truck to the back room. $300 to the flour mill three hundred miles away (by mail).

STEP 2 Now pick Cash, because Mr. Albertson is standing right there and there is no risk of loss in transit.

Check, because the bakery wants a paper record of every supplier payment.

Cash for half, check for half. Split it.

Ask Mr. Albertson to wait until tomorrow so the family can decide carefully.

DISCUSSION When does the slowness of a check stop being worth the safety? Name a situation where cash is clearly the right answer.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

$45 to the electrician who fixed the oven, while he is still standing in the kitchen.

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: what is the main reason a business writes checks instead of paying in cash?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

173

UNIT 7 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Postal Money Order

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In the 1860s, the United States was in the middle of a long war between the northern and southern states. Soldiers from farm families were stationed hundreds of miles from home, and many tried to send their pay back to their families. The only way was to put cash in an envelope and mail it. But the mail was not safe in those years. Letters were sorted by hand in dim post offices, some workers stole cash from envelopes, and a great deal of soldiers’ pay simply disappeared on the way home.

In 1864, the Post Office Department invented a solution: the postal money order. A soldier would walk into a post office, hand over his pay in cash, and ask the postmaster to write a money order for the same amount. The postmaster filled out a special form, signed it with a unique number, and gave it to the soldier, who mailed it to his family.

When they received it, they took it to their own post office and exchanged it for cash.

The form was useless to a thief. Only the person named on it could cash it, and only at a real post office. If it was lost in the mail, the soldier could ask his post office to cancel the original and issue a new one. The money itself never traveled through the mail. Only the instructions to pay it out did.

Postal money orders became one of the most important financial inventions of the century. By 1880, the post office was handling more than ten

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The maximum amount of a single postal money order in 1864 was $30. The post office knew that even with the safety of the money order system, putting too much money on one form was risky. The limit meant a soldier sending home a month’s pay often had to buy two or three separate money orders. The limit has been raised many times over the years and now sits at $1,000 per money order.

million a year. Farmers in California could pay catalog companies in Illinois. Sons working in factories could send wages home to mothers in mountain towns. Immigrants could send savings to family in other countries. The system was slow, a money order might take two weeks for the round trip, but the money almost always arrived.

The postal money order is still in use today, working almost exactly as it did in 1864. The form is filled out by hand, the serial number written in ink, the money paid out at the receiving post office. For more than a century and a half, that simple piece of paper has been one of the safest ways to send money through the mail.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

174

UNIT 7 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E M YST E RY

Henry’s Big Question On a Sunday afternoon, Henry sat at the kitchen table with his dad. The bakery was closed. A pile of receipts, invoices, and small notebooks sat between them. His dad looked tired.

DISCUSSION

Henry looked at the pile. He saw stacks of receipts in different sizes. He saw a small notebook where his dad wrote down the daily cash total. He saw invoices from Mr. Albertson and the sugar supplier and the dairy. He saw a few bank deposit slips.

“What do you want it to do?” Henry asked.

“Three things,” his dad said. “First, every dollar that comes in over the counter has to be recorded.

Second, every dollar that leaves, whether by check, cash, or bank transfer, has to be recorded. Third, at the end of each week, the totals have to match what is actually in the bank and the cash boxes. If they do not match, I want to know where the difference is.”

HENRY’S DESIGN CHALLENGE What the system must track

Why it matters

Every dollar in

So the family knows total sales for the day, week, and month.

Every dollar out

So the family knows where the money went.

Weekly balance check

So errors and missing money show up quickly.

FIRST INSTINCT

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Why does Henry’s dad keep saying it would help to write things down instead of carrying them in his head? What is the difference between remembering and recording?

“I want you to build something,” his dad said.

“A way to track every dollar that comes in and out of the bakery. Right now, I keep most of it in my head. I am getting too old to keep doing it that way.”

BIG QUESTION

What is the most important part of this system?

A. Tracking what came in

B. Tracking what went out

C. The weekly check

D. All three equally

How do you keep track of every dollar moving through a business?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

175

UNIT 7 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

THE CLUES

Three Parts of a Money Flow System A complete money flow system has three parts. Each part answers a different question. When all three are working, the family always knows where the money is, where it came from, and where it went.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

The first part is the income log. Every dollar that comes in over the counter or by mail gets recorded as a single line. The line has a date, an amount, and a one-word source. “Tuesday, $487, sales.”

“Wednesday, $200, catering order.” “Friday, $50, refund.” Each line is small. Together, the lines tell the story of where the bakery’s money has been coming from.

The second part is the expense log. Every dollar that goes out also gets recorded as a single line. The line has a date, an amount, the method of payment, and a one-word reason. “Wednesday, $180, check, flour.” “Thursday, $45, cash, electrician.” “Sunday, $120, transfer, electricity.” The third part is the weekly reconciliation. Every Sunday night, the family adds up the income log, adds up the expense log, subtracts the expenses from the income, and compares the result to what is actually in the cash boxes and bank account. If the numbers match, the week’s books are clean. If they do not match, the difference has to be found before another week’s records pile on top.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Reuben sells handmade greeting cards at a weekend market.

After three months, he could not remember how much he had earned or how much he had spent on supplies. He decided to start a simple two-page log. The left page was income. The right page was expenses. Every Sunday night, he added the two pages up. After one month of doing this, Reuben could answer in ten seconds questions that used to take him an hour.

“How much did I make in October?” $42. “How much did I spend on supplies?” $18. “What is my actual profit?” $24.

The two-page log changed nothing about the cards. It changed everything about Reuben’s understanding of his own business.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

176

VOCABULARY Income log - the running list of every dollar coming into the business.

Built one line at a time, in order.

Expense log - the running list of every dollar going out, with the reason and the method of payment.

Reconciliation comparing what the records say to what is actually there.

Done weekly for small businesses.

Bookkeeping - the daily practice of writing down every dollar in and every dollar out. The foundation of every business.

MONEY RULE

Track every dollar in. Track every dollar out.

INTRO

UNIT 7 | LESSON 3

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

B U I L D YO U R OW N P L A N

Assemble Henry’s Bakery Logs Use the three parts to build Henry’s money flow system. Fill in each log with the entries from one Tuesday at the bakery.

DISCUSSION S T E P NEW 1 The income log for Tuesday SAM'S LEDGER Date

Amount

Source

Tuesday

$487

Counter sales

Tuesday

$120

Catering order, the Park School

Tuesday

$15

Refund of cleaning supply return

Why is it important to find an $8 shortage right away, instead of waiting and hoping it sorts itself out?

Total income: $

S T E P NEW 2 The expense log for Tuesday SAM'S LEDGER Date

Amount

Method

Reason

Tuesday

$180

Check

Flour delivery

Tuesday

$45

Cash

Electrician

Tuesday

$25

Cash

Petty cash refill Total expenses: $

S T E P 3 Reconciliation Total income:$

— Total expenses: $

= Net for the day: $

EXIT QUESTION

Henry’s dad checks the cash drawer at the end of Tuesday and finds it is $8 short of what the logs say it should be. What are three possible reasons, and how would Henry track each one down?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

WA I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

In one sentence: what does a weekly reconciliation actually prove?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

177

UNIT 7 | LESSON 3

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Telegraph and the Birth of Instant Money

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In the 1870s, the fastest way to send a message across the United States was by telegraph. The machine was simple: a wooden box on a desk, a key the operator pressed and released, and a wire strung on poles across the country. The operator tapped the key in patterns of short and long signals that raced along the wire at nearly the speed of light. An operator in Chicago could reach one in San Francisco in minutes. The receiving operator listened to the clicks, wrote the message out in plain English, and handed it to a messenger boy for delivery.

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The Western Union telegraph operators developed a special code system for sending money transfers safely. Each transfer had a secret word, agreed on by the sender and the recipient. The receiving office would only pay out the money if the recipient could say the correct word. This protected against forged messages. The secret word system stayed in use for more than a century.

In 1871, a company called Western Union had telegraph lines connecting almost every city and town in the country, and that year it had an idea. If a message could cross the country in minutes, why not money? Western Union opened the first telegraph money transfer service. A customer walked into the New York office and gave the clerk $20 to send to a relative in San Francisco. The New York clerk sent a coded message down the wire. The San Francisco clerk read it, opened the local cash drawer, and paid out $20. The actual cash never left New York. The money paid out came from San Francisco's own drawer, and the two offices settled their balances later.

Western Union ruled the telegraph money business for more than a hundred years. Cowboys sent home wages from cattle drives. Soldiers wired money to their families. Travelers caught short of cash in strange cities asked relatives to wire rescue funds.

The phrase "wire me the money" entered the language and is still used today, even though almost no one sends money by telegraph anymore.

This was a stunning change. Before 1871, sending $20 across the country took at least two weeks by mail and risked being lost on the way. After 1871, the same $20 could arrive in under an hour.

For the first time in history, money could move almost as fast as a message.

The deeper lesson is that the money never had to move at all. Two offices in two cities, with two separate cash drawers, could act as one by trusting each other's records. Every modern bank transfer between cities works the same way. No actual coins or bills move. Only the records change.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

178

FORM 2 TAX, PERCENT OFF, AND TIPS

How to Read a Check

PRACTICAL A P P L I C AT I O N S What this section does!

This section covers two real-world forms you will see in your life, a review case study that ties the unit together, and a final reflection.

A check has six parts. Each part is small. Together, they make a check work. Many people fill out checks every year without ever learning what each line actually does. Once you know the six parts, a check stops being a confusing piece of paper and becomes a simple tool.

T H E S I X PA R T S O F A C H E C K

BANK NAME

00123

CHECK NO.

123 MAIN STREET SPRINGFIELD, ST 00000

1

06202026 M

M

D

D

Y

Y

Y

$

PAY TO THE 2 ORDER OF

Y

3

4

DOLLARS

6

5 MEMO

Aaron C. Please Sign Above

012 34567 89

#

Part of the check

What it does

1

Date line (top right)

The day you wrote the check. Banks may refuse to cash a check more than six months old.

2

Pay to the order of (middle)

The name of the person or business you are paying. Only they can cash it.

3

Amount in numbers ($ box)

The dollar amount in figures, like $180.00.

4

Amount in words (long line)

The same amount spelled out in words.

If the numbers and words disagree, the bank uses the words.

5

Memo line (lower left)

An optional note about what the check is for. “Flour delivery, March 15.”

6

Signature line (lower right)

Your signature. Without it, the check is not valid.

12 34

ONE MORE NUMBER At the bottom of every check are three groups of numbers. The first group is the routing number, which identifies the bank. The second group is the account number, which identifies the specific account.

The third group is the check number, which makes each check unique. These numbers let the bank find the right account in seconds.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

01234 5678 9

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

179

YOUR TURN

Fill Out a Check Henry needs to write a check to Mr. Albertson Flour Mill for $182.50. The date is March 15. Fill out the check below.

T H E S I X PA R T S O F A C H E C K

BANK NAME

00123

CHECK NO.

123 MAIN STREET SPRINGFIELD, ST 00000

M

M

D

D

Y

Y

Y

$

PAY TO THE ORDER OF

DOLLARS MEMO

Please Sign Above

012 34567 8 9

12 34

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

01234 56789

C O M M O N M I S T A K E S T O AV O I D 1.

Leaving any line blank. A blank line is an opportunity for someone to change the check.

2. Writing the amount in words but not in numbers, or vice versa. Always do both.

C H EC K YO U R S E L F 3. Forgetting the date. A bank can refuse to cash an undated check.

4. Forgetting to sign. An unsigned check is a useless piece of paper.

180

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

Y

YOUR SIGNATURE

Your Signature Is Your Mark The last line on a check is the signature, and it is the most important line of all. The numbers, the date, and the name of the person being paid all matter, but the signature is what tells the bank the check is really coming from you. A signature is a promise written in your own hand. When you sign your name, you are saying, in effect, “This is really me, and I agree to this.”

You will sign your name thousands of times in your life. On checks, on forms, on letters, on the back of birthday cards. Most adults have a signature they have used for so long that they can write it without thinking, in one smooth motion. That signature did not appear by accident. At some point, often around your age, the person sat down and developed it on purpose.

W H AT M A K E S A G O O D S I G N AT U R E Consistent. You can write it close to the same way every time. Your bank keeps a copy and compares it to the signature on your checks.

Your own. It is recognizably yours, not a copy of someone else’s, and not so plain that just anyone could fake it.

Natural. It flows from your hand without effort once you have practiced it. A signature you have to think hard about is too complicated.

Start by writing your full name in your normal handwriting. Then try a few variations. Some people write their whole name clearly. Some make the first letter of each name large and let the rest trail off into a line. Some keep their

first name neat and add a flourish to the last name. Try several styles, pick the one that feels the most natural and the most like you, then practice it until your hand remembers it on its own.

H O W T O D E V E L O P Y O U R O W N S I G N AT U R E STEP 1 Write your full name four times in your normal handwriting.

1.

2.

3.

4.

STEP 2 Try three different signature styles. Make each one different from the others.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

H O W T O D E V E L O P Y O U R O W N S I G N AT U R E

A. B. C. STEP 3 Pick your favorite. Practice it until it flows in one smooth motion.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

181

FORM 2 READING A BANK STATEMENT

What a Bank Statement Shows

C H EC K YO U R WO R K Does the ending balance equal the starting balance plus all deposits minus all checks? If yes, the statement balances.

If no, there is an error somewhere, and the bank or the business has to find it.

Once a month, the bank sends a piece of paper called a statement.

The statement lists every dollar that moved in or out of the account during the month. A business owner who reads the statement carefully can catch errors, find missing payments, and confirm that the bank’s records match the business’s own records. A business owner who ignores the statement is flying blind.

S A M P L E B A K E R Y S TAT E M E N T F O R M A R C H

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Max's older cousin Daniel, who works part-time at the hardware store shows his paychechk stub.

Date

Description

In or Out

March 1

Starting balance

March 4

Deposit (week’s sales)

+$2,100.00

$4,550.00

March 7

Check #421 (flour)

-$180.00

$4,370.00

March 11

Deposit

+$1,890.00

$6,260.00

March 14

Check #422 (electricity)

-$320.00

$5,940.00

March 18

Deposit

+$2,050.00

$7,990.00

March 21

Check #423 (dairy)

-$245.00

$7,745.00

March 25

Deposit

+$1,950.00

$9,695.00

March 28

Check #424 (sugar)

-$140.00

$9,555.00

March 31

Ending balance

$2,450.00

$9,555.00

R E A D T H E S TAT E M E N T Use the sample bakery statement above to answer the questions below.

1.

What was the bakery’s starting balance on March 1? $

2. How much did the bakery deposit in total during March? $ 3. How much did the bakery spend on supplier checks during March? $ 4. What was the ending balance on March 31? $ 5. By how much did the bakery’s account grow during March? $ Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

182

Balance

REVIEW CASE STUDY

Henry’s Bakery This Week Henry’s dad gives him the bakery’s notes from a single week and asks him to make sense of them using everything from this unit. Work through the case below.

T H E S I T U AT I O N Monday: Counter sales totaled $420. Henry’s dad paid the dairy supplier $90 in cash because the driver was at the back door and could not wait.

Wednesday: Counter sales were $510. Henry’s dad mailed a check for $200 to the flour mill three hundred miles away.

Thursday: A regular customer ordered $150 worth of catering for a weekend event and paid in advance by check.

Friday: Counter sales were $480. Mr. Albertson stopped by for the $180 flour invoice from earlier in the month. Henry’s dad paid him by check.

Sunday night: Henry’s dad sat down to reconcile the week.

WA L K T H R O U G H H E N R Y ’ S R E C O N C I L I AT I O N Question to answer

Which Money Rule helps?

Your answer

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

What was the total income for the week?

What was the total expense for the week?

Which payments were safer because they were made by check?

Where should the leftover money sit until next week?

C H EC K YO U R WO R K

DISCUSSION

Multiple answers can be defensible for the last two questions. What matters is that the reasoning uses the Money Rules from this unit. A choice is welldefended when the rule that supports it is clear.

Compare your reconciliation to a classmate’s. If your numbers do not match, who found the right total, and why?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

183

UNIT CLOSE

Looking Back at Henry’s Unit Henry started this unit by noticing that money in a business does not just sit still. It moves. Across three lessons, he learned where the money sits when it pauses, how to move it from one place to another safely, and how to keep a record of every dollar’s journey. He learned that each chunk of money has a job. He learned that some payments are safer slow than fast. And he learned that a simple weekly reconciliation can catch errors that would otherwise grow into bigger problems over months.

These are not difficult ideas. The hard part is doing them every week, without skipping, without shortcuts. Every business that lasts more than a few years has someone keeping the books. The bakery on Locust Street has been doing it for forty years. Henry is now part of how it gets done.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

THE MONEY RULES FROM THIS UNIT Lesson 1

Money sitting still has a job. Lesson

Lesson 2

Some payments are safer slow.

Lesson 3

Track every dollar in. Track every dollar out.

R E A L- W O R L D A P P L I C A T I O N Choose one Money Rule from this unit. Write about a time when you handled money for yourself or your family, and explain how the rule did or did not apply. Use the exact words of the rule in your writing. Be honest about what you would do differently next time.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

184

Unit 8

Money Grows How does money grow when you leave it alone for years?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

BIG QUESTION FOR THE UNIT

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

185

Meet Joseph Joseph is in sixth grade. He is the youngest in his family by many years. His grandfather, who shares his first name, is in his eighties. Every year since the year Joseph was born, on his birthday, his grandfather has given him the same gift. One share of stock in a company called Riverbend Tool Company. Riverbend has been making hand tools, mostly for builders and carpenters, for almost a hundred years. The shares come in a small white envelope with a printed letter from the company.

For most of Joseph’s life, he threw the envelopes into a drawer without opening them. A share of stock means nothing to a four-year-old. It means almost nothing to a nine-year-old. But this year, on his twelfth birthday, Joseph sat down at the kitchen table and opened the envelope with attention. He read every line of the letter. And what he saw made him want to understand the rest of the drawer. In this unit, Joseph learns what those twelve small envelopes have actually become, how money grows when it is left alone for a long time, and how to plan for what his shares could be worth by the time he is an adult.

W H AT ' S I N T H I S U N I T Lesson

Money Rule

1

Joseph’s Share

When you own a share, you grow when the business grows.

2

Joseph’s Long Plan

Time does most of the work.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

#

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

186

INTRO

UNIT 8 | LESSON 1

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E S I T U AT I O N

Twelve Envelopes On the morning of his twelfth birthday, Joseph found the usual small white envelope sitting next to his cereal bowl. His grandfather had mailed it from across the state a week earlier, like every year. The return address read Riverbend Tool Company.

Joseph had opened twelve of these envelopes now, counting today’s. The first eleven sat in a drawer in his bedroom, mostly unread. He had been told each one held a share of stock, but he had never really understood what that meant.

This year was different. His dad sat down next to him with a cup of coffee. “Read it,” his dad said. “All of it.”

Joseph read the letter. The company had earned about $2 per share last year. The share price had grown from $68 to seventy-five over the year.

And the company would send each shareholder a dividend of $1.20 per share, which a shareholder

DISCUSSION Joseph’s grandfather never put more than $50 into any single birthday gift. So where did the extra $500 come from? could either take as cash or use to buy a fraction of another share.

Joseph looked at his dad. “How many shares do I have?”

“Twelve,” his dad said. “Plus the partial shares from the dividends that have been reinvested over the years. Closer to thirteen at this point.”

They got out a piece of paper and worked through the math together.

Year

What grandfather bought

Share price that year

Joseph age 1

1 share

About $35

Joseph age 5

1 share (plus 5 dividends reinvested)

About $42

Joseph age 10

1 share (plus 10 dividends reinvested)

About $61

Joseph age 12 (today)

1 share (plus 12 dividends reinvested)

$75

Joseph added it up. Twelve shares plus the reinvested dividends, at $75 each, came to about $975.

He stared at the number. His grandfather had spent maybe $450 over twelve years. The value had more than doubled.

FIRST INSTINCT

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

J O S E P H ’ S S I T U AT I O N

BIG QUESTION

How did Joseph’s gift grow so much?

A. The company made it grow

B: Time made it grow

C. Both, together

D: It was just luck

What does it actually mean to own a piece of a company?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

187

UNIT 8 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

THE SKILL

What a Share Actually Is A share of stock is a small piece of ownership in a company. When Joseph holds twelve shares of Riverbend Tool Company, he literally owns twelve tiny pieces of the company. The company has thousands of pieces in total, called shares outstanding, so any one share is a very small fraction. But the ownership is real. If Riverbend makes a profit, part of that profit belongs to Joseph. If Riverbend grows, the value of his pieces grows with it. If Riverbend shrinks or goes out of business, the value of his pieces shrinks too.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

There are two main ways that money from a share grows. The first is when the company pays a dividend. A dividend is a small piece of the year’s profit that gets sent to every shareholder. Riverbend pays $1.20 per share each year, which means Joseph’s twelve shares earned him about $14.40 this year. The second way is when the share price itself goes up. If a share that was worth $35 when grandfather bought it is now worth $75, the value of the ownership has grown. That growth is called a capital gain. Joseph has not sold any shares, so the capital gain is not real money in his pocket yet. But it is real value.

Companies do not always grow. Some years the share price goes down. Some years the company pays no dividend. The shares of a company that goes out of business can become worthless. Stock ownership is real, but it carries real risk. A shareholder grows with the company, and a shareholder also takes losses with the company.

Share (or stock) - a small piece of ownership in a company. One share is one piece.

Dividend - a small portion of the company’s profit paid to each shareholder, usually once or twice a year.

Capital gain - the increase in the value of a share over time. The gain is on paper until the share is actually sold.

Reinvest - to use a dividend to buy more shares instead of taking the cash. This makes the next year’s dividend bigger.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Reuben’s aunt gave him one share of a company that makes camping gear when he was eight years old. The share cost her $50. Reuben forgot about it. Four years later, he asked his aunt what had happened to the share. She showed him a statement. The share was now worth $80. The company had paid dividends every year, and his aunt had used each dividend to buy a small fraction of another share. Reuben now owned about 1.3 shares, worth about $104.

Reuben had done nothing. The $50 his aunt put in had become more than twice as much, just by sitting still in the right place for four years.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

188

VOCABULARY

MONEY RULE

When you own a share, you grow when the business grows.

UNIT 8 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

DECISION LAB

What Should Joseph Do With His Shares?

Joseph now has thirteen shares of Riverbend Tool Company, worth about $975. He has to decide what to do with them. Three options are open to him.

DISCUSSION Why might a twelveyear-old pick a slowergrowing option over a fast cash payout today? What is being traded for what?

STEP 1 What Joseph does Sell all the shares. Take the $975

Likely result

in cash.

He has $975 today, no more shares. The growth stops.

B

Hold the shares. Let the dividends keep buying more.

Shares stay invested. Growth continues if the company keeps doing well.

C

Hold the shares AND add one more share each year from his own money.

Shares grow faster. He spends about $75 a year of his own money.

A

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N

STEP 2 Now pick Sell the shares. Use the $975 for something Joseph wants now.

Hold the shares. Let his grandfather keep adding. Add nothing of his own.

Hold the shares. Add one extra share per year from his own savings.

Hold the shares. Add money some years but not others, based on what he has.

Joseph’s grandfather mentions that he plans to keep sending one share per birthday until Joseph turns twenty-one. That is nine more shares from his grandfather, with no money from Joseph himself. Does that change which option makes the most sense?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Option

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: what makes a share of stock different from money sitting in a savings jar?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

189

UNIT 8 | LESSON 1

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

The Dutch East India Company

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

In 1602, in the harbor city of Amsterdam, a group of Dutch merchants did something that had never been done before. They created the world’s first publicly traded company. They called it the Vereenigde Oostindische Compagnie, the United East India Company, known ever since by its initials, the VOC. The VOC was built to send ships on long voyages to Asia. Each voyage took two or three years and required a huge amount of money up front for the ship, the crew, the supplies, and the trade goods.

The voyages were extremely risky. About one ship in three never came back, lost to storms, pirates, or disease in distant ports. But the ships that did return came loaded with spices, silk, and porcelain that sold for many times the original investment.

Before the VOC, only the very rich could fund a voyage like this, because the risk of losing everything was too great for a person of ordinary means. The Dutch merchants had an idea. What if the cost of a voyage was split into many small pieces, called shares, and sold to many different people? Buy one small share, and your loss was small if the voyage failed. But if it succeeded, you earned a small piece of the profit.

The Amsterdam Stock Exchange opened to handle the trading of these shares. For the first time, a person who could not afford a whole voyage could still own a piece of one. A baker, a teacher, or a shopkeeper could put in a few coins and become

D I D YO U K N OW ?

The original VOC shares were printed on heavy paper and bore an elaborate seal. A few of them still survive today in museum collections, more than four hundred years after they were printed. The oldest known surviving share, issued in 1606 to a man named Pieter Harmensz, was rediscovered in 2010 in a Dutch archive. It is the world’s oldest stock certificate.

part-owner of a global trading enterprise. Some shareholders held their shares for decades and passed them to their children, while others bought and sold many times a year, betting on whether the next voyage would succeed.

The VOC lasted almost two hundred years. By the time it was dissolved in 1799, the idea of public share ownership had spread across Europe and to the American colonies. Almost every modern company that sells stock to the public traces its method back to that wooden trading floor in Amsterdam, where in 1602 a group of merchants invented a new way for ordinary people to own a piece of something larger than themselves.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

190

INTRO

UNIT 8 | LESSON 2

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

THE PROBLEM

The Chart at the Kitchen Table A week after Joseph’s birthday, his grandfather drove down to spend the afternoon with him. They sat at the kitchen table with a blank sheet of paper between them.

DISCUSSION Why does the gap between the 5% column and the 10% column get bigger over time?

Why is the 50-year row so much more dramatic than the 6-year row?

“You know what your shares are worth right now,” his grandfather said. “$975. What I want you to do today is think about what they could be worth when you are older. Much older.”

Joseph nodded. “How much older?”

“Pick any age you want. Twenty-five. Thirty-five.

Fifty. Sixty-five.”

His grandfather pulled out a small calculator.

He wrote at the top of the paper: $975. Then he made four rows below it. He explained that companies like Riverbend tended to grow, on

average, somewhere between five and ten percent per year over long stretches of time. Not every year.

Some years they grew much more. Some years they shrank. But over many decades, the average tended to land in that range.

Joseph watched his grandfather fill in the chart.

If Joseph holds the in shares for...

At about 5% per year

At about 7% per year

At about 10% per year

6 years (age 18)

$1,306

$1,463

$1,727

13 years (age 25)

$1,838

$2,353

$3,372

23 years (age 35)

$2,994

$4,627

$8,750

38 years (age 50)

$6,225

$12,775

$36,544

53 years (age 65)

$12,944

$35,266

$152,649

Joseph stared at the chart. The bottom right number, more than $150,000, was hard to look at directly. He looked at his grandfather. “Is that real?” “It is the math,” his grandfather said. “Whether it actually happens depends on the company, the country, and time itself. But the math is real.”

FIRST INSTINCT

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

J O S E P H ’ S S I T U AT I O N

BIG QUESTION

What is doing most of the work in the chart?

A. The growth rate

B. The starting amount

C. The number of years

D. Joseph’s effort

How do you make money that you don’t touch grow over decades?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

191

UNIT 8 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

T H E PA R T S

Three Parts of a Long Plan Joseph’s grandfather pointed to the chart. “Three things make this work,” he said. “All three have to be there. If any one is missing, the growth at the bottom of the chart never happens. The good news is that none of the three is hard. They are just patient.”

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

The first part is time. The longer the money sits invested, the more rounds of compounding happen. Compounding means each year’s growth is added to the original amount, and then the next year grows on top of that. After ten years it does not look like much. After fifty years, the math turns into something that almost does not feel real. Joseph could not control how many years he had, but at twelve he had more years ahead of him than most adults. Time was the resource he was richest in.

The second part is reinvestment. Every dividend the company paid had to be used to buy more shares, not taken out as cash. A dividend taken in cash stops growing. A dividend reinvested into more shares keeps growing right along with everything else. The third part is patience. The chart only works if Joseph leaves the shares alone for the full number of years. If he sells them at age twenty to buy a car, the chart resets to zero and starts over. Most people who fail to reach the numbers in the bottom row do not fail because the math stopped working. They fail because they could not wait.

GUIDED EXAMPLE Aaron’s older brother started investing $100 a year at age fifteen. He kept it up for ten years, then stopped adding new money at twenty-five. He never touched the money again.

Carlos’s older brother waited until age thirty to start, but he invested $100 a year for the next thirty-five years. Both brothers reached age sixty-five at about the same time.

Aaron’s brother had only put in $1,000 total. Carlos’s brother had put in $3,500 total, three and a half times as much. But at age sixtyfive, Aaron’s brother had more money than Carlos’s brother. The fifteen extra years of compounding at the start did more work than all the extra money put in later. The math is brutal in this direction. Starting early matters more than putting in more later.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

192

VOCABULARY Compounding - the process by which each year’s growth is added to the previous total, so the next year’s growth is calculated on a larger number.

Long-term investing buying shares with the plan to hold them for many years or decades, not weeks or months.

Rate of return - the percentage by which an investment grows in one year. Average stock market returns historically land near 7% over long stretches.

Time horizon - how many years you plan to leave the money invested before you need it. The longer the horizon, the more compounding can do.

MONEY RULE

Time does most of the work.

INTRO

UNIT 8 | LESSON 2

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

B U I L D YO U R OW N P L A N

Build Joseph’s Long Plan Use the three parts to build Joseph’s full long-term plan. Fill in each step.

DISCUSSION

Pick a target age for Joseph. The plan will leave the money invested until he reaches this age.

Target age:

Years from age 12 to target:

STEP 2 Choose the rate assumption Pick a realistic long-term growth rate. Most long-term stock investments have historically averaged somewhere in this range.

5% (a cautious estimate; covers years when markets do poorly) 7% (close to the historical long-term stock market average) 10% (an optimistic estimate; would require strong markets for decades)

STEP 3 Project the ending value Using the chart from Page 1, look up the value of $975 grown at your chosen rate for your chosen number of years.

Projected value at target age: $

Two students might pick the same target age but different rates and still both be right. What does that say about longterm planning under uncertainty?

W A I T, N E W I N F O R M AT I O N Joseph’s grandfather offers to match every dollar Joseph adds to his own shares, up to $100 a year, until Joseph turns eighteen. That could be another $600 of grandfather money on top of what is already there.

How does that change Joseph’s plan? Does he add more, or stick with the original plan?

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

STEP 1 Set the time horizon

EXIT QUESTION In one sentence: what would have to be true for the bottom-right number on the chart to actually happen?

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

193

UNIT 8 | LESSON 2

INTRO

LEARN

APPLY

HISTORY

MONEY THROUGH TIME

Compound Interest in Ancient Babylon

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Almost four thousand years ago, in the city of Babylon, scribes were already calculating compound interest. They wrote their math on small clay tablets, pressing the wedge-shaped marks of cuneiform script into the soft clay with a stylus, then baking the tablets hard in the sun.

Archaeologists have found many thousands of them. Some are math homework, some are legal contracts, and a remarkable number are tables showing how a loan or an investment grows when interest is added to the principal each year.

Babylonian merchants and farmers regularly borrowed grain or silver and paid it back with interest. A farmer might borrow ten units of grain in spring and agree to repay twelve in autumn, the two extra units being the interest. The scribes who handled these contracts saw that if a debt went unpaid for a year, the next year’s interest had to be figured on the new, larger amount, not just the original loan. That is the heart of compounding.

The Babylonians understood how dangerous fastgrowing debt could be. Their laws set strict limits on how much interest could be charged on grain loans and silver loans, partly because runaway compound interest could ruin a family in just a few years.

Anyone who has watched the bottom-right number of a compound interest chart climb out of sight has felt exactly what those ancient lawmakers feared.

The most famous Babylonian math tablet on compounding now sits in a museum in Berlin. It

D I D YO U K N OW ?

A simple way to estimate how many years it takes money to double at a given growth rate is called the Rule of 72. Divide 72 by the growth rate. At 6% growth, money doubles in about 12 years. At 8% growth, money doubles in about 9 years. At 12% growth, money doubles in just 6 years. The Rule of 72 was being used by Italian merchants in the 1400s and is still taught in business schools today. works out how long it takes a sum of silver to double at twenty percent annual interest. The answer, figured on the clay almost four thousand years ago, is just under four years. A modern calculator gives the same answer. The math has not changed.

The deepest lesson of the tablets is that compounding has always been one of the strongest forces in money. Whether the money is grain in a Babylonian granary, shares in a trading company, or stock in a modern tool maker, the same rule applies.

A small amount, left alone with growth piling on growth, becomes a large amount given enough years. The ancient Babylonians knew it. So did the merchants of Amsterdam. So now does Joseph.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

194

FORM 1 READING A SHARE STATEMENT

How to Read a Share Statement Once a year, every shareholder receives a statement from the company. The statement is one page. It looks complicated at first, but it actually only tells you five things. Once you know what the five things are, the statement becomes simple.

PRACTICAL A P P L I C AT I O N S What this section does!

This section covers a share statement, a compound growth worksheet, a review case study that ties the unit together, and a final reflection.

J O S E P H ’ S A N N U A L S TAT E M E N T F R O M R I V E R B E N D T O O L C O M PA N Y

RIVERBEND TOOL COMPANY Annual Shareholder Statement 1

Account Holder

Joseph

Statement Date

Dec 31

2

Shares Owned (as of December 31)

13.04

3

Price Per Share (as of December 31):

$75.00

4

Market Value

$978.00

5

Dividends Paid

$15.65 (reinvested)

Line

What it says

What it means

1

Account holder

The owner of these shares.

2

Shares owned

How many shares (and partial shares) you have in total.

3

Price per share

What one share is worth on the last day of the year.

4

Total value

Shares times price. The total worth of the position today.

5

Dividends paid this year

How much the company paid out to Joseph this year. Used to buy more partial shares.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Holdings Summary

O N E T H I N G T H E S TAT E M E N T D O E S N O T S H O W The statement shows what the shares are worth today, but not what they will be worth tomorrow, next month, or next year. Share prices move up and down every single day. A statement is a snapshot in time, not a guarantee. The shares could be worth more next year. They could also be worth less. The statement is honest only about what was true on the day it was printed.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

195

FORM 2 THE COMPOUND GROWTH WORKSHEET

How $100 Grows Over Time

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

This table shows what $100 becomes if it grows at three different rates over different numbers of years. Use it to understand how compounding actually works. The longer the time, the more dramatic the difference between a low rate and a high rate.

Years invested

At 5% per year

At 7% per year

At 10% per year

10 years

$163

$197

$259

20 years

$265

$387

$673

30 years

$432

$761

$1,745

40 years

$704

$1,497

$4,526

50 years

$1,147

$2,946

$11,739

YOUR TURN

Use the table to answer the questions below.

1.

At 7% growth, what does $100 become in 30 years? $

2. At 5% growth, how long does it take $100 to roughly triple?

years

3. Over 50 years, how much more does $100 grow at 10% than at 5%? $ 4. Pick one row. Why does the gap between the columns get so much bigger as the years go up?

196

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

YOUR TURN READING A STATEMENT

Read Joseph’s Next Statement Joseph received another statement one year later. Use the new statement to answer the questions below.

Account Holder

Joseph

Statement Date

Dec 31

Line

Last year’s value

This year’s value

Shares owned

13.04

14.25

Price per share

$75.00

$72.00

Total value

$978.00

$1,026.00

Dividends paid this year

$15.65

$17.10

1.

Did the share price go up or down this year?

2. Did Joseph’s total value still go up?

3. How is it possible for the share price to go down but the total value to go up?

4. How many shares did Joseph have at the end of this year compared to last year?

5. Where did the extra shares come from, since his grandfather only gave him one new one?

C H EC K YO U R WO R K

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

RIVERBEND TOOL COMPANY Annual Shareholder Statement

Total value can go up even when the price per share goes down, because reinvested dividends added more shares. More shares times a slightly lower price can still equal more total value. This is a real effect, and it is one of the reasons reinvesting dividends matters so much over the long run.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

197

REVIEW CASE STUDY

Joseph’s Plan for 2050 Joseph sits down with his dad and decides to write a real plan. The plan covers what he will do from age twelve to age forty-five. Work through the case below.

T H E S I T U AT I O N Joseph has 13 shares worth $975 today.

His grandfather will give him one share per year until Joseph is twenty-one. That is nine more shares.

Starting at age sixteen, Joseph plans to add four more shares per year from his own savings (about $300 per year).

All dividends are reinvested.

Joseph plans to leave everything alone until age forty-five.

WA L K T H R O U G H J O S E P H ’S P R O J EC T I O N S Question to answer

Which Money Rule helps?

At 7% growth, what is the $975 alone worth at age 45?

Your answer

$

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Will the share count grow even when prices fall?

What is the single most important thing for Joseph to NOT do over the next 33 years?

If the average growth turns out to be 5% instead of 7%, is the plan ruined?

C H EC K YO U R WO R K

DISCUSSION

Several answers are defensible for the last two questions. What matters is that the reasoning uses the Money Rules from this unit. A plan is welldefended when the rule that supports it is clear, and when the answer makes sense even if some of the assumed numbers turn out to be wrong.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

198

Two students might design completely different plans for Joseph and both be reasonable.

Which choices in Joseph’s plan are most important to get right?

Which ones matter less?

UNIT CLOSE

Looking Back at Joseph’s Unit Joseph started this unit by opening an envelope he had been receiving every year of his life without ever really looking inside.

Over the course of two lessons, he learned what those twelve small envelopes actually were, what they had grown into, and what they could become if he handled them with patience over the next half-century.

Joseph also learned something that is hard to believe at twelve.

The most powerful thing he can do for his future is not work harder, earn more, or pick the right share. It is to wait. Time, applied to even small amounts of money, does more work than effort or cleverness. The Dutch merchants in 1602 knew this. The Babylonian scribes knew it almost four thousand years ago. Joseph now knows it too.

Lesson 1

When you own a share, you grow when the business grows.

Lesson 2

Time does most of the work.

R E A L- W O R L D A P P L I C A T I O N Choose one Money Rule from this unit. Write about a goal you have that would take five or more years to reach. Explain how the rule applies, and what patience would look like along the way. Be honest about what would make it hard to stick to the plan.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

THE MONEY RULES FROM THIS UNIT

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

199

LOOKING BACK

Eight Skills, Eight Stories Across eight units, eight different sixth-graders worked through eight different sides of the same question. How to handle money well.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

Unit

Protagonist

Skill

1. Smart Spending

Ben

Spending wisely. Comparing options. Seeing hidden costs.

2. Save with a Plan

Sam

Setting goals. Tracking. Finding leaks. Bending plans.

3. Earn Smart

Max

Pricing work. Mixing income. Negotiating. Building skill.

4. Choose Smart

Adam

Picking between good options. Pros and cons. Timing.

5. Borrow Carefully

Daniel

Costs of borrowing. The lender’s side. Tangles. Rules.

6. Protect and Plan Ahead

Jake

Reserves. Risk. Protection. The long view.

7. How Money Moves

Henry

Where money sits. How it travels. How to track it.

8. Money Grows

Joseph

Ownership. Compounding. Time. Patience.

Each protagonist learned one skill. Each skill is small on its own.

Together, the eight skills are a way of thinking about money that can carry a person through a whole life.

Practiced once, the skills are useful. Practiced for a year, they become reliable. Practiced for a decade, they become habits.

Practiced for a lifetime, they become wisdom.

Ben, Sam, Max, Adam, Daniel, Jake, Henry, and Joseph keep going. So does the reader.

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

200

Lighthouse M O N EY S M A RTS

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

© Lighthouse Curriculum. Copying strictly prohibited.

www.lighthousecurriculum.com

Mastering Bright Ideas ™

Lighthouse Money Smarts • 718.285.7100 • info@lighthousecurriculum.com For more information visit www.lighthousecurriculum.com