Ä
Ĺ?
(1#!3.1 ēŊ Ŋ Ŋ }
ĖŊ ēŊ ^Ŋ } Ŋ }
;d ik i[dj_Ze \ehcWb i_]d_\_YWd e\[diW" W]hWl_e [njh[ce [ _dj[dY_e# dWbc[dj[ fheZkY_Ze W bW ^kcWd_# ZWZ1 l_[d[ Z[ bW lep bWj_dW BW[ZiW gk[ Z[dejW ik\h_c_[dje e Zebeh fheZkY_Ze _dj[dY_edWbc[dj[1 [ije [i ZW‹e o Wd]kij_W [njh[cW$ ;b jƒhc_de >kcWd_ZWZ" i_]d_# \_YW bW [i[dY_W _d^[h[dj[ e Yediki# jWdY_Wb Wb ^ecXh[" [ije [i W bei Wjh_# Xkjei [i[dY_Wb[i [ _d^[h[dj[i Wb i[h ^kcWde" de iebe [d i[dj_Ze _dZ_# l_ZkWb i_de jWcX_ƒd Yece ]hkfe" [if[Y_[ k ^ecXh[ Yeb[Yj_le" [d jWb i[dj_Ze kd Z[b_je Z[ b[iW ^kcW# d_ZWZ e\[dZ[" b[i_edW e bWij_cW W bW ^kcWd_ZWZ c_icW" i[‹WbW Yed hWpÂŒd bW ZeYjh_dW$ BW c_icW ZeYjh_dW cWd_\_[ijW gk[ ÆBei Yh‡c[d[i Z[ b[iW ^kcW# d_ZWZ ied Wgk[bbei gk[ e\[dZ[d W bW ^kcWd_ZWZ" e i[W" gk[ i[ [dj_[dZ[ gk[ [b ik`[je fWi_le fh_dY_fWb [i bW ^kcWd_ZWZ ieY_Wb" fk[i ^_[h[" ZW‹W k e\[dZ[ bW YedY_[dY_W ][d[hWb Z[ bW ^kcWd_ZWZ o hecf[ bWi Yed# Z_Y_ed[i Z[ l_ZW fWY‡\_YW o Y_l_b_pW# ZWÇ1 c|i W‘d i[ h[YWbYW Æ;b Yh_c[d Z[ b[iW ^kcWd_ZWZ i[ Yedi_Z[hW kd ^[Y^e Wjhep" X|hXWhe o XW`e" Z[ jWd [njh[cW iW‹W cehWb gk[ YkWbgk_[h i[h ^kcWde de iebe i[ _dZ_]dW Wdj[ jWb[i WYY_ed[i" i_de gk[ ik WcehWb_ZWZ o WjheY_ZWZ h[ikbjW feh i‡ c_icW [l_Z[dj[$ FWhW gk[ [ijW YbWi[ Z[ ^[Y^ei i[ Yedi_Z[h[d Yh‡# c[d[i YedjhW bW ^kcWd_ZWZ" Z[X[d i[h l_ebWY_ÂŒd W kd Z[h[Y^e ^kcWde gk[ f[hj[d[Y[ W bW YWj[]eh‡W Z[ _ki Ye][di" Z[X[ i[h ]hWl[ o kdW l_ebW# Y_ÂŒd i_ij[c|j_YWÇ$ I[]‘d [b ;ijWjkje Z[b Jh_XkdWb Z[ D‘h[cX[h]" gk[ [d ik 7hj$ , b_j[hWb Y Z_Y[ ÆIed Yh‡c[d[i Z[ b[iW ^kcWd_ZWZ0 [b Wi[i_dWje" [b [nj[hc_d_e" bW h[ZkYY_ÂŒd W [iYbW# l_jkZ" bW Z[fehjWY_ÂŒd e YkWbgk_[h WYje _d^kcWde Yec[j_Ze YedjhW bW feXbWY_ÂŒd Y_l_b Wdj[i e ZkhWdj[ bW ]k[hhW" _dYbki_l[ bWi f[hi[YkY_e# d[i feh cej_lei feb‡j_Yei" hWY_Wb[i e h[b_]_eiWiÇ$ 7‹WZ[ ÆBei Yh‡c[d[i YedjhW bW ^kcWd_ZWZ feZh|d i[h [`[YkjWZei [d Yed\b_Yje _dj[hdW# Y_edWb" Wb _dj[h_eh Z[ kd Yed\b_Yje _dj[hde e [d j_[cfe Z[ fWpÇ$ BW ZeYjh_dW j[hc_dW i[‹WbWdZe" gk[ bei Yh‡c[d[i Z[ b[iW ^kcWd_# ZWZ WXWhYWd WYjei _d^kcWdei Z[ YWh|Yj[h cko ]hWl[ gk[ _cfb_gk[
"(3.1 ĹŠ ÂĄ ĹŠ
Ĺ?Ä Ä‰Ĺ? Ĺ? Ĺ? Ĺ?Ä‚Ä€Ä Ä
Ĺ? +. Ĺ? ÄŒĹ? Ĺ? +Ä?Ĺ?ĊććĆ
ĹŠ ĹŠ ÂĄ ĹŠ ĹŠ ĹŠ ĹŠ ĹŠĹŠĹŠĹŠ'33/ľľ666Ä“"#1#!'.#!4 ".1Ä“!., (1#!!(¢-Ä–ĹŠ 1#- 2ĹŠ8ĹŠÄˆÄ‡ĹŠ"#ĹŠ %.23.ĔŊ "($ēŊ (5 -!.ĔŊĎ3.ēŊ/(2.ŊġŊ #+_$.-.2Ä–ĹŠÄ‰ÄŽÄŽÄˆÄąÄŽÄŽÄ‰ÄľÄ‰ÄŽÄŽÄŽÄąÄŒÄŠÄˆÄľÄ‰ÄŽÄ‡Ä‡ÄąÄ‰ÄŒÄŽÄľÄ‰ÄŽÄŽÄ‰ÄąÄˆÄŠÄŽĹŠĹŠÄˇĹŠ Äą, (+Ä– ĹŠ)4"(!( +Äž"#1#!'.#!4 ".1Ä“!.,ĹŠ
.2ĹŠ!1~,#-#2ĹŠ"#ĹŠ +#2 ĹŠ'4, -(" "
l_ebWY_ed[i ][d[hWb_pWZWi e i_ij[# c|j_YWi" Ykoe eX`[j_le i[W bW feXbW# Y_ÂŒd Y_l_b [d ik jejWb_ZWZ e [d fWhj[$ BW [nfh[i_ÂŒd Æ9ec[j_Zei YedjhW bW feXbWY_ÂŒd Y_l_b Z[X[ [dj[dZ[hi[ h[\[h_ZW W WYjei Yec[j_Zei Yece fWhj[ Z[ kd WjWgk[ ][d[hWb_pWZe o i_ij[c|j_Ye YedjhW bW feXbWY_ÂŒd Y_l_b feh cej_lei dWY_edWb[i" feb‡# j_Yei" ƒjd_Yei" hWY_Wb[i e h[b_]_eiei$ Bei WYjei fWhj_YkbWh[i W gk[ i[ ^WY[ h[\[h[dY_W [d bW Z[\_d_Y_ÂŒd ied WYjei Z[b_X[hWZWc[dj[ Yec[j_Zei Yece fWhj[ Z[ [i[ WjWgk[Ç$ Feh Yh‡c[d[i YedjhW bW ^kcW# d_ZWZ i[ [dj_[dZ[d bei i_]k_[dj[i WYjei0 W 7i[i_dWje1 X ;nj[hc_d_e1 Y JehjkhW1 Z Ik`[Y_ÂŒd W [iYbWl_jkZ1 [ F[hi[YkY_ÂŒd feh cej_lei feb‡# j_Yei" hWY_Wb[i" h[b_]_eiei e ƒjd_# Yei1 \ :_iYh_c_dWY_ÂŒd _dij_jkY_edWb_# pWZW feh cej_lei hWY_Wb[i" ƒjd_# Yei e h[b_]_eiei" gk[ ikfed]Wd bW l_ebWY_ÂŒd Z[ bei Z[h[Y^ei \kdZWc[djWb[i o [djhW‹[ ]hW# l[i Z[il[djW`Wi fWhW kdW fWhj[ Z[ bW feXbWY_ÂŒd" Z[fehjWY_ÂŒd e jhWibWZe \ehpeie Z[ feXbWY_e# d[i" Yed YWh|Yj[h WhX_jhWh_e1 ] :[iWfWh_Y_ÂŒd \ehpWZW Z[ f[hie# dWi1 ^ L_ebWY_ÂŒd" fheij_jkY_ÂŒd \ehpeiW o ejhWi \ehcWi Z[ WXkie i[nkWb1 [" _ Ejhei WYjei _d^kcWdei gk[ c[deiYWX[d ]hWl[c[dj[ bW _dj[]h_ZWZ \‡i_YW e c[djWb" bW iWbkZ e bW Z_]d_ZWZ ^kcWdW Yece bW ckj_bWY_ÂŒd o bWi b[i_e# d[i ]hWl[i$ :[ be WdejWZe i[ Z[ifh[dZ[" gk[ [b ;ijWjkje Z[b Jh_XkdWb Z[ D‘h[cX[h] [d 7b[cWd_W" gk[ `kp]ÂŒ bei Yh‡c[d[i Z[ bW I[]kdZW =k[hhW CkdZ_Wb YedjhW 7b[cWd_W gk[ f[hZ_ÂŒ bW ]k[hhW" Yedi_Z[#
hÂŒ" Z[X_[dZe WZ[c|i WdejWh gk[ _]kWbc[dj[ bei Jh_XkdWb[i gk[ `kp]Whed W bei Yh‡c[d[i [d bW [n Ok]eibWl_W o HkWdZW" cWd_\[ijW# hed gk[ bei Yh‡c[d[i Z[ b[iW ^kcW# d_ZWZ ied ÆWjheY_ZWZ[i o Z[b_jei gk[ Yecfh[dZ[d" i_d gk[ ƒijW [dkc[hWY_ÂŒd j[d]W YWh|Yj[h b_c_# jWj_le" [b Wi[i_dWje" [b [nj[hc_d_e" bW [iYbWl_pWY_ÂŒd" bW Z[fehjWY_ÂŒd" [b [dYWhY[bWc_[dje" bW jehjkhW" bWi l_ebWY_ed[i k ejhei WYjei _d^kcW# dei Yec[j_Zei YedjhW YkWbgk_[h feXbWY_ÂŒd Y_l_b e bWi f[hi[YkY_e# d[i feh cej_lei feb‡j_Yei hWY_Wb[i e h[b_]_eiei l_eb[d e de [ijei WYjei" bWi b[o[i dWY_edWb[i Z[ bei fW‡i[i ZedZ[ i[ f[hf[jhWdÇ$ C_[djhWi gk[ bW 9ehj[ F[dWb ?dj[hdWY_edWb Z[ bW >WoW [d ik ;ijWjkje Z[ HecW" i[‹WbW [d [b Whj‡Ykbe - gk[ i[ Yedi_Z[hWd Yece Yh‡c[d[i Z[ b[iW ^kcWd_ZWZ Æ7 bei [\[Yjei Z[b fh[i[dj[ ;ijWjkje" i[ [dj[dZ[h| feh Yh_c[d Z[ b[iW ^kcWd_ZWZ" YkWbgk_[hW Z[ bei WYjei i_]k_[dj[i YkWdZe i[ Yec[jW Yece fWhj[ Z[ kd WjWgk[ ][d[hWb_pWZe e i_ij[c|j_Ye YedjhW kdW feXbWY_ÂŒd Y_l_b o Yed YedeY_c_[dje Z[ Z_Y^e WjWgk[0 $$$\ jehjkhW1$$$a ejhei WYjei _d^kcWdei Z[ YWh|Yj[h i_c_bWh gk[ YWki[d _dj[dY_edWbc[dj[ ]hWl[i ik\h_c_[djei e Wj[dj[d ]hWl[c[dj[ YedjhW bW _dj[]h_ZWZ \‡i_YW e bW iWbkZ c[djWb e \‡i_YWÇ$ C|i W‘d bei h[ifediWXb[i Z[ Yh‡# c[d[i Z[ b[iW ^kcWd_ZWZ" de fk[# Z[d _dleYWh d_d]kdW _dckd_ZWZ d_ fh_l_b[]_e [if[Y_Wb" fWhW ikijhW[h# i[ W bW WYY_ÂŒd Z[ bW `kij_Y_W" Wi‡ be i[‹WbW [b ;ijWjkje Z[ bW 9ehj[ F[dWb ?dj[hdWY_edWb" [d [b Whj‡Ykbe (-$($ ;B F7F;B :; B7 =K;HH7 ;D ;B 9EDJ;NJE CKD:?7B 7b]kdei Wkjeh[i fbWdj[Wd gk[ ÆBW ]k[hhW [i bW feb‡j_YW Z[iWhhe# bbWZW Yed bWi WhcWiÇ" o gk[ bWi eiWc[djWi gk[ dkjh[d bWi \eiWi Yeckd[i de ied ejhW YeiW gk[
Yedi[Yk[dY_Wi d[Y[iWh_Wi Z[ [iW Æ\ehcW Z[ ^WY[h feb‡j_YWÇ" o eXl_W# c[dj[ bW ^kcWd_ZWZ i[ h[i_[d# j[ Z[iZ[ iki Y_c_[djei Wdj[ jWd WX[hhWdj[ j[i_i1 feh [ijW hWpÂŒd bei _dijhkc[djei `kh‡Z_Yei _dj[h# dWY_edWb[i Z[ Z[h[Y^ei ^kcWdei ^Wd fbWdj[WZe \ÂŒhckbWi fei_j_lWi [dYWc_dWZWi W fhej[][h bW Z_]d_# ZWZ ^kcWdW \h[dj[ Wb ][deY_Z_e o W bei Z[b_jei Z[ b[iW ^kcWd_ZWZ" f[he [b ;YkWZeh j_[d[ gk[ Whj_Yk# bWh bWi dehcWi Yedij_jkY_edWb[i Yed bWi dehcWi f[dWb[i" fWhW Z[ [iW cWd[hW ZWh Ykcfb_c_[dje W bei Yecfhec_iei WZgk_h_Zei W d_l[b _dj[hdWY_edWb$ ;B ;IJ7JKJE :; B7 9EHJ; F;D7B ?DJ;HD79?ED7B E ;IJ7JKJE :; HEC7 ;ij[ ;ijWjkje j_[d[ l_][dY_W Z[iZ[ '//." Wkdgk[ [djhÂŒ W h[]_h W fWhj_h Z[b &' Z[ `kb_e Z[ (&&(1 WYjkWbc[dj[ ')/ fW‡i[i ^Wd \_h# cWZe Yece i_]dWjWh_ei" f[he iebe '&- be ^Wd hWj_\_YWZe1 o [d [ij[ ;ijWjkje i[ [ijWXb[Y[ kdW 9ehj[ F[dWb ?dj[hdWY_edWb f[hcWd[dj[ Yed i[Z[ [d BW >WoW" gk[ [i bW Yede# Y[ lWh_ei Z[b_jei Z[ b[iW ^kcWd_# ZWZ1 WYbWhWdZe gk[ [ij[ ;ijWjkje Z[ HecW \ehcW fWhj[ Z[b ehZ[dW# c_[dje `kh‡Z_Ye Z[b fW‡i" fk[i [b 9ed]h[ie DWY_edWb be WfheXÂŒ o i[ [dYk[djhW fkXb_YWZe [d [b H[]_ijhe E\_Y_Wb Yehh[ifedZ_[dj[$ 9ED9BKI?ED;I IE8H; B7 @KIJ?9?7 F;D7B O B7 :?=D?:7: >KC7D7 ;d [ijei W‹ei ^W j[d_Ze bk]Wh [d bW cWoeh fWhj[ Z[ bei fW‡i[i Z[b ckdZe" kd l_]eheie fheY[ie Z[ h[\ehcWi W bei i_ij[cWi Z[ `kij_Y_W f[dWb" [d\eYWZei [d bW j_f_\_YWY_ÂŒd Z[ Z[j[hc_dWZei Z[b_jei YedjhW bW Z_]d_ZWZ ^kcWdW" Yece ied [b ][deY_Z_e o bei Z[b_jei Z[ b[iW ^kcWd_ZWZ1 f[he ^Wo gk[ h[Ye# deY[h gk[ [b ;YkWZeh [ij| h[jhW#
iWZe [d [ijW cWj[h_W" fk[i de ^W _djheZkY_Ze l[hZWZ[hWi h[\ehcWi Wb 9Â&#x152;Z_]e F[dWb" Wkd YkWdZe oW j[d]e [dj[dZ_Ze i[ bWi Yedj[cfbW [d [b Fheo[Yje Z[b dk[le 9Â&#x152;Z_]e F[dWb gk[ i[ [ij| [bWXehWdZe [d bW 7iWcXb[W DWY_edWb o gk[ [djhWh| [d l_][dY_W [d [b WÂ&#x2039;e (&'(" Z[X_[d# Ze j[d[h [d Yk[djW" gk[ bW Ze]c|# j_YW f[dWb ]WhWdj_ijW [ijWXb[Y_ZW feh ckY^ei jhWjWZ_ijWi" [djh[ [bbei Bk_]_ <[hhW`eb_" HWc_he =WhYÂ&#x2021;W <WbYedÂ&#x2021; o AWo 7cXei [ijWXb[Y[d bei fh_dY_f_ei f[dWb[i fWhW b_c_# jWh Wb c|n_ce [b feZ[h fkd_j_le Z[b ;ijWZe" [nfh[iWZe [d bW b_c_# jWY_Â&#x152;d Z[ bW b_X[hjWZ f[hiedWb" i_d [cXWh]e Z[ [bbe fWhWb[bWc[dj[ W [ijW f[hif[Yj_lW i[ [dYk[djhWd bei fh_dY_f_ei Z[ Z_]d_ZWZ ^kcWdW o bei fh_dY_f_ei Z[b Z[h[Y^e f[dWb _dj[hdWY_edWb fWhW ieYWlWh bWi c|i \bW]hWdj[i l_ebWY_ed[i o WjheY_ZW# Z[i gk[ i[ Yec[j_[hed [d YedjhW Z[ bW ^kcWd_ZWZ$ BW 9ehj[ 9edij_jkY_edWb Z[ jhWd# i_Y_Â&#x152;d Z[ dk[ijhe fWÂ&#x2021;i ^W i[Â&#x2039;WbWZe gk[ bei Z[b_jei Z[ dWhYejh|\_Ye" gk[ feh iki YeddejWY_ed[i d[]Wj_lWi ^Wd i_Ze YWjWbe]WZei Yece Z[b_# jei Z[ b[iW ^kcWd_ZWZ" be YkWb ^W fhecel_Ze W d_l[b _dj[hdWY_edWb bW WZefY_Â&#x152;d Z[ c[Z_ZWi `khÂ&#x2021;Z_YWi" [djh[ ejhWi" Yed [b \_d Z[ [l_jWh [d Wb]kdW c[Z_ZW ik fhefW]WY_Â&#x152;d1 c|i WÂ&#x2018;d gk[ bW 9edij_jkY_Â&#x152;d Z[ bW H[fÂ&#x2018;Xb_YW [d ik 7hj$ .- dkc[hWb - iWblW]kWhZW [b _dj[hÂ&#x192;i ][d[hWb Z[b Xk[d l_l_h o ]WhWdj_pW bW fb[dW l_][dY_W Z[ c[YWd_icei Z[ Yedjheb Z[ bWi WYjkWY_ed[i Z[ bei `k[Y[i$ B7 9EDIKBJ7 ;D BEI @K?9?EI :; D7H9EJHĂ&#x203A;<?9E ;b _dY_ie gk_dje Z[b 7hj$ '() Z[ bW B[o Z[ IkijWdY_Wi ;ijkf[\WY_[dj[i o Fi_YejhÂ&#x152;f_YWi i[Â&#x2039;WbW bW Yedikb# jW eXb_]Wjeh_W Z[ bWi i[dj[dY_Wi YedZ[dWjeh_Wi o WXiebkjeh_Wi gk[ Z_YjWd bei jh_XkdWb[i Z[ ]WhWdjÂ&#x2021;Wi f[dWb[i W bWi Yehj[i fhel_dY_W# b[i Z[ `kij_Y_W" bWi YkWb[i Z[X[d h[iebl[h [d cÂ&#x192;h_je Z[ bei Wkjei1 o bW 9ehj[ 9edij_jkY_edWb Z[ jhWd# i_Y_Â&#x152;d ^W i[Â&#x2039;WbWZe gk[ [ij[ [i [b Â&#x2018;d_Ye c[YWd_ice `khÂ&#x2021;Z_Ye _ZÂ&#x152;d[e gk[ ]WhWdj_Y[ bW jhWdifWh[dY_W o Yehh[Yje cWd[`e Z[ bei [nf[Z_[dj[i [d cWj[h_W Z[ Zhe]Wi" feh be gk[ de [n_ij[ l_ebWY_Â&#x152;d W bWi dehcWi Z[b Z[X_Ze fheY[ie e W Wb]Â&#x2018;d fh_dY_f_e Z[ fheY[Z_c_[dje f[dWb Yed [ijW YedikbjW$
Ĺ? Ĺ?
Ĺ?