Edición impresa Revista Judicial del 16 de junio de 2011

Page 1

Ä

Ĺ?

(1#!3.1 ēŊ Ŋ Ŋ }

"(3.1 ĹŠ ÂĄ ĹŠ

Ĺ?Ä Ä‡Ĺ? Ĺ? Ĺ? Ĺ?Ä‚Ä€Ä Ä

Ĺ? +. Ĺ? ÄŒĹ? Ĺ? +Ä?Ĺ?Ċćăă

ĹŠ ĹŠ ÂĄ ĹŠ ĹŠ ĹŠ ĹŠ ĹŠĹŠĹŠĹŠ'33/ľľ666Ä“"#1#!'.#!4 ".1Ä“!., (1#!!(¢-Ä–ĹŠ 1#- 2ĹŠ8ĹŠÄˆÄ‡ĹŠ"#ĹŠ %.23.ĔŊ "($ēŊ (5 -!.ĔŊĎ3.ēŊ/(2.ŊġŊ #+_$.-.2Ä–ĹŠÄ‰ÄŽÄŽÄˆÄąÄŽÄŽÄ‰ÄľÄ‰ÄŽÄŽÄŽÄąÄŒÄŠÄˆÄľÄ‰ÄŽÄ‡Ä‡ÄąÄ‰ÄŒÄŽÄľÄ‰ÄŽÄŽÄ‰ÄąÄˆÄŠÄŽŊŊġŊ Äą, (+Ä– ĹŠ)4"(!( +Äž"#1#!'.#!4 ".1Ä“!.,ĹŠ

4 +(!(" "ĹŠ#-% Â .2 ĹŠ

Ä–ĹŠĹŠ ēŊ } ĹŠ ĹŠ ĹŠ } ĹŠ ĹŠÄœĹŠ

7YjkWbc[dj[ [d dk[ijhW b[]_ibW# Y_Œd" bei Z[h[Y^ei Z[ bei Yedikc_Ze# h[i i[ [dcWhYWd [d bW B[o Eh]|d_YW Z[ :[\[diW Z[b 9edikc_Zeh o ik H[]bWc[dje" i_d [cXWh]e ^WijW bW fh[i[dj[ \[Y^W" ‘d_YWc[dj[ [n_ij[ kd fheo[Yje Z[ B[o" fWhW h[]kbWh [b hƒ]_c[d Z[ b_Xh[ Yecf[j[dY_W [d [b ;YkWZeh" hWpŒd feh bW gk[ fWhW [ij[ YWie [d fWhj_YkbWh" Z[X[cei h[c_# j_hdei W bW b[]_ibWY_Œd WdZ_dW$ BW h[\[h_ZW B[o Eh]|d_YW Z[ :[\[diW Z[b 9edikc_Zeh Yedj_[d[ lWh_ei fh_dY_f_ei o dehcWi Z[ij_# dWZei W fhej[][h Wb Yedikc_Zeh e kikWh_e" Z[djhe Z[ kd c[hYWZe Z[ X_[d[i o i[hl_Y_ei" ejeh]|dZeb[ o h[]kbWdZe Y_[hjei Z[h[Y^ei o eXb_# ]WY_ed[i$ ;d ][d[hWb" i[ Yedi_Z[hW Yedik# c_Zeh e kikWh_e W jeZW f[hiedW dWjkhWb e `kh‡Z_YW gk[ YedjhWjW W j_jkbe ed[heie" fWhW ik Yedikce \_dWb" bW WZgk_i_Y_Œd e beYWY_Œd Z[ X_[d[i e bW fh[ijWY_Œd e Whh[dZW# c_[dje Z[ i[hl_Y_ei$ :WZW bW ]hWd Z[i_]kWbZWZ gk[ ik[b[ [n_ij_h [djh[ Yedikc_Zeh[i o kikWh_ei o bWi ]hWdZ[i [cfh[iWi fhel[[ZehWi Z[ X_[d[i o i[hl_Y_ei" Wi‡ Yece W bW fheb_\[hWY_Œd Z[ bWi YedjhWjWY_ed[i [d cWiW c[Z_Wdj[ bei bbWcWZei YedjhWjei Z[ WZ^[i_Œd" dk[ijhe ehZ[dWc_[dje `kh‡Z_Ye" i[ ^W l_ije [d bW d[Y[i_ZWZ Z[ fheY[Z[h W [gk_b_XhWh bW h[bWY_Œd YedjhWYjkWb c[Z_Wdj[ c[Z_ZWi gk[ Yedjheb[d bW YWb_ZWZ Z[ bei fheZkYjei o i[h# l_Y_ei" Wi‡ Yece [b [gk_b_Xh_e [d bWi Z_ifei_Y_ed[i YedjhWYjkWb[i$ ;b [gk_b_Xh_e [djh[ bWi h[bWY_ed[i Z[ fhel[[Zeh[i Z[ X_[d[i o i[hl_# Y_ei" l[hiki Yedikc_Zeh[i o kikW#

#%ĂŒ-ĹŠ-4#231 ĹŠ+#%(2+ !(¢-ĔŊ/4 +(!(" "ĹŠ#-%  .2 ĹŠ#2Ä–ĹŠ ÄĄ ." ĹŠ,." +(" "ĹŠ"#ĹŠ(-$.1, !(¢-ĹŠ.ĹŠ!.,4-(! !(¢-ĹŠ "#ĹŠ! 1;!3#1ĹŠ!.,#1!( +ĔŊ!48.ĹŠ!.-3#-(".ĹŠ2# ĹŠ3.3 +ĹŠ.ĹŠ / 1!( +,#-3#ĹŠ!.-31 1(.ĹŠ ĹŠ+ 2ĹŠ!.-"(!(.-#2ĹŠ1# +#2ĹŠ.ĹŠ"#ĹŠ "04(2(!(¢-ĹŠ"#ĹŠ+.2ĹŠ (#-#2ĹŠ8ĹŠ2#15(!(.2ĹŠ.$1#!(".2ĹŠ.ĹŠ04#ĹŠ 43(+(!#ĹŠ3#73.2ĔŊ"(;+.%.2ĔŊ2.-(".2ĔŊ(,;%#-#2ĹŠ.ĹŠ"#2!1(/Äą !(.-#2ĹŠ04#ĹŠ"(1#!3 ĹŠ.ĹŠ(-"(1#!3 ,#-3#ĔŊ#ĹŠ(-!+42.ĹŠ/.1ĹŠ .,(2(¢-ĹŠ"#ĹŠ" 3.2ĹŠ#2#-!( +#2ĹŠ"#+ĹŠ/1."4!3.ĔŊ(-"49! ĹŠ ĹŠ #-%  .ĔŊ#11.1ĹŠ.ĹŠ!.-$42(¢-ĹŠ +ĹŠ!.-24,(".1Ģ h_ei" j_[d[ ik \kdZWc[dje b[]Wb [d bW B[o Eh]|d_YW Z[ :[\[diW Z[b 9edikc_Zeh" Wb YkXh_h lWh_ei Wif[Y# jei \kdZWc[djWb[i Z[ bWi h[bWY_ed[i [djh[ bei fheZkYjeh[i o bei Yedik# c_Zeh[i" jWb[i Yece0 š Bei YedjhWjei Z[ WZ^[i_ÂŒd0 fhe^‡X[d bWi Yb|kikbWi WXki_lWi gk[ Z[i[gk_b_Xh[d bW h[bWY_ÂŒd Yed# jhWYjkWb [d \Wleh Z[b fhel[[Zeh Z[ X_[d[i o i[hl_Y_ei o jhWjW Z[ Wi[]k# hWh gk[ [b Yedikc_Zeh YedepYW feh Wdj_Y_fWZe jeZWi bWi YedZ_Y_ed[i ][d[hWb[i Z[ bW YedjhWjWY_ÂŒd gk[ [b [cfh[iWh_e fh[j[dZ[ h[Wb_pWh$ š 9Wb_ZWZ Z[ bei X_[d[i o i[hl_Y_ei e\h[Y_Zei$ š H[]kbWY_ÂŒd Z[ bW fkXb_Y_ZWZ o Z[ bWi e\[hjWi Z_h_]_ZWi Wb f‘Xb_Ye$ š ;ijWXb[Y[ fheY[Z_c_[djei [if[# Y_Wb[i fWhW gk[ bei Yedikc_Zeh[i o bWi WieY_WY_ed[i o eh]Wd_icei f‘Xb_Yei Yh[WZei fWhW ik Z[\[d# iW fk[ZWd Z[\[dZ[hi[ o fhe^_X_h Y_[hjWi fh|Yj_YWi WXki_lWi$ ;dkc[hW kd [b[dYe Z[ _d\hWYY_e# d[i feh fWhj[ Z[ bei [cfh[iWh_ei o bWi Yehh[ifedZ_[dj[i iWdY_ed[i W _cfed[h feh bWi Wkjeh_ZWZ[i Yec# f[j[dj[i [d cWj[h_W Z[ Yedikce$ FK8B?9?:7: ;D=7yEI7 9kWdZe kd [cfh[iWh_e W jhWlƒi Z[ ik fkXb_Y_ijW i[ fhefed[ Z[iW# hhebbWh kdW YWcfW‹W fkXb_Y_jWh_W gk[ i[W _cfWYjWdj[" eh_]_dWb o f[h# ikWi_lW fWhW _dYh[c[djWh iki leb‘# c[d[i Z[ l[djW" Z[X[ j[d[h ckY^e Yk_ZWZe Z[ de kj_b_pWh c[diW`[i gk[ fWhW YWfjWh bW Wj[dY_ÂŒd Z[b f‘Xb_Ye" _dZkpYWd Wb [hheh Wb Z[ij_dWjWh_e oW gk[ _dYkhh_h‡W [d bW j[c_ZW o iWd# Y_edWZW ÆfkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W‹eiWÇ1 bW YkWb" W\[YjWh‡W bW _cW][d Z[ bW

[cfh[iW Wdj[ ik c[hYWZe c[jW o Wdj[ bW ieY_[ZWZ [d ][d[hWb$ Feh [bbe" [i d[Y[iWh_e YedeY[h be gk[ [ijWXb[Y[ dk[ijhW b[]_ibWY_ÂŒd h[if[Yje W bW fkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W‹eiW o Yece YedjhebWhbW o YecXWj_hbW$ ;b ;ijWZe ;YkWjeh_Wde W jhWlƒi Z[ bW B[o Eh]|d_YW Z[ :[\[diW Z[b 9edikc_Zeh o ik H[]bWc[dje" fh[# j[dZ[ fhej[][h W bei Yedikc_Zeh[i YedjhW bW fkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W‹eiW e WXki_lW" bei cƒjeZei Yec[hY_Wb[i Ye[hY_j_lei e Z[ib[Wb[i" W jhWlƒi Z[ bW h[]kbWY_ÂŒd Z[ bW fkXb_Y_ZWZ o ik Yedj[d_Ze$ 7b h[if[Yje" Z_ifed[ gk[ i[ fhe^‡X[d jeZWi bWi \ehcWi Z[ fkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W‹eiW e WXki_lW" e gk[ _dZkpYWd W [hheh [d bW [b[Y# Y_ÂŒd Z[b X_[d e i[hl_Y_e gk[ fk[ZWd W\[YjWh bei _dj[h[i[i o Z[h[Y^ei Z[b Yedikc_Zeh$ ;b Whj‡Ykbe ( Z[ bW B[o Eh]|d_YW Z[ :[\[diW Z[b 9edikc_Zeh" Z[\_# d[ W bW fkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W‹eiW Yece0 ÆJeZW ceZWb_ZWZ Z[ _d\ehcWY_ÂŒd e Yeckd_YWY_ÂŒd Z[ YWh|Yj[h Yec[hY_Wb" Ykoe Yedj[d_Ze i[W jejWb e fWhY_Wbc[d# j[ YedjhWh_e W bWi YedZ_Y_ed[i h[Wb[i e Z[ WZgk_i_Y_ÂŒd Z[ bei X_[d[i o i[hl_Y_ei e\h[Y_Zei e gk[ kj_b_Y[ j[njei" Z_|be]ei" ied_Zei" _c|][d[i e Z[iYh_fY_ed[i gk[ Z_h[YjW e _dZ_h[YjWc[dj[" [ _dYbkie feh ec_i_ÂŒd Z[ ZWjei [i[dY_Wb[i Z[b fheZkY# je" _dZkpYW W [d]W‹e" [hheh e Yed\ki_ÂŒd Wb Yedikc_ZehÇ$ Feh ik fWhj[" [b Whj‡Ykbe - Z[ bW h[\[h_ZW B[o Eh]|d_YW" Yedi_Z[hW Yece ?d\hWYY_ed[i FkXb_Y_jWh_Wi W bWi i_]k_[dj[i" i_[cfh[ gk[ _dZkp# YWd W [hheh e [d]W‹e h[if[Yje W0 '$ FW‡i Z[ eh_][d" Yec[hY_Wb e Z[ ejhW ‡dZeb[ Z[b X_[d e\h[Y_Ze e ieXh[ [b bk]Wh Z[ fh[ijWY_ÂŒd Z[b

i[hl_Y_e fWYjWZe e bW j[Ydebe]‡W [cfb[WZW1 ($ Bei X[d[\_Y_ei o Yedi[Yk[dY_Wi Z[b kie Z[b X_[d e Z[ bW YedjhW# jWY_ÂŒd Z[b i[hl_Y_e" Wi‡ Yece [b fh[Y_e" jWh_\W" \ehcW Z[ fW]e" \_dWdY_Wc_[dje o Yeijei Z[b Yhƒ# Z_je1 )$ BWi YWhWYj[h‡ij_YWi X|i_YWi Z[b X_[d e i[hl_Y_e e\h[Y_Zei" jWb[i Yece Yecfed[dj[i" _d]h[# Z_[dj[i" Z_c[di_ÂŒd" YWdj_ZWZ" YWb_ZWZ" kj_b_ZWZ" ZkhWX_b_ZWZ" ]WhWdj‡Wi" YedjhW_dZ_YWY_ed[i" [\_Y_[dY_W" _Zed[_ZWZ Z[b X_[d e i[hl_Y_e fWhW bei \_d[i gk[ i[ fh[j[dZ[ iWj_i\WY[h o ejhWi1 *$ Bei h[YedeY_c_[djei" WfheXWY_e# d[i e Z_ij_dY_ed[i e\_Y_Wb[i e fh_# lWZWi" dWY_edWb[i e [njhWd`[hWi jWb[i Yece c[ZWbbWi" fh[c_ei" jhe\[ei e Z_fbecWi$ Âľ9ÂŒce i[ fk[Z[ fh[l[d_h o Yec# XWj_h bW fkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W‹eiW5 7 jhWlƒi Z[ h[]kbWY_ÂŒd Wb h[i# f[Yje$ Kd fh_c[h fWie [i [b YedjWh oW Yed h[]kbWY_ÂŒd gk[ Z[j[hc_dW be gk[ i[ [dj_[dZ[ feh fkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W‹eiW" _d\hWYY_ÂŒd fkXb_Y_jWh_W" Wi‡ Yece Z[j[hc_dW iki iWdY_ed[i Yehh[ifedZ_[dj[i$ KdW \ehcW Z[ YedjhebWh bW fkXb_# Y_ZWZ [d]W‹eiW" [i gk[ [b ;ijWZe f[hc_jW gk[ bWi f[hiedWi k eh]W# d_pWY_ed[i gk[ j_[d[d kd _dj[hƒi b[]‡j_ce fk[ZWd0 '$ FheY[Z[h `kZ_Y_Wbc[dj[ YedjhW bW fkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W‹eiW1 e" ($ Bb[lWh bW fkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W‹e# iW Wdj[ kd ÂŒh]Wde WZc_d_ijhWj_le Yecf[j[dj[ X_[d fWhW fhedkdY_Whi[ eXh[ bWi h[YbWcWY_ed[i e X_[d fWhW [cfh[dZ[h bWi WYY_ed[i `kZ_Y_Wb[i f[hj_d[dj[i$ ;ijWi fei_X_b_ZWZ[i WYjkWbc[dj[ [n_ij[d" oW gk[ bei Yedikc_Zeh[i e kikWh_ei gk[ ^Wd i_Ze l‡Yj_cWi Z[ fkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W‹eiW" fk[Z[d WYkZ_h Yed ik h[YbWce h[if[Yj_le Wdj[ bW :[\[dieh‡W Z[b Fk[Xbe e bWi 9ec_iWh‡Wi" [d ik Z[\[Yje$ ;djh[ bWi Yecf[j[dY_Wi gk[ i[ Z[X[h‡W ejeh]Wh W bWi Wkjeh_ZWZ[i gk[ jhWc_jWd h[YbWcei h[bWj_lei W bW fkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W‹eiW" WZ[c|i Z[b

h[if[Yj_le h[iWhY_c_[dje Z[ f[h`k_# Y_ei" [i gk[ b[i \WYkbj[d fWhW0 '$ EhZ[dWh [b Y[i[ Z[ kdW fkXb_# Y_ZWZ [d]W‹eiW e [cfh[dZ[h bWi WYY_ed[i f[hj_d[dj[i Yed l_ijWi W ehZ[dWh [b Y[i[ Z[ Z_Y^W fkXb_Y_# ZWZ1 ($ Fhe^_X_h kdW fkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W# ‹eiW YkoW fkXb_YWY_ÂŒd i[W _dc_# d[dj[ e [cfh[dZ[h bWi WYY_ed[i f[hj_d[dj[i Yed l_ijWi W ehZ[dWh ik fhe^_X_Y_ÂŒd" _dYbkie [d Wki[d# Y_W Z[ kd f[h`k_Y_e h[Wb" e Z[ kdW _dj[dY_ÂŒd e d[]b_][dY_W feh fWhj[ Z[b WdkdY_Wdj[$ )$ ;n_]_h gk[ i[ fkXb_gk[ bW Z[Y_# i_ÂŒd Z[ Y[i[ Z[ bW fkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W# ‹eiW1 o%e gk[ i[ fkXb_gk[ kd Yeck# d_YWZe h[Yj_\_YWj_le$ ;ijWi \WYkbjWZ[i bWi fh[lƒ bW WYjkWb B[o Eh]|d_YW Z[ :[\[diW Z[b 9edikc_Zeh" Wb Z_ifed[h [d ik Whj‡Ykbe -(" gk[ bei fhel[[Zeh[i YkoW fkXb_Y_ZWZ i[W Yedi_Z[hWZW [d]W‹eiW e WXki_lW" i[h|d iWdY_e# dWZei Yed kdW ckbjW Z[ '"&&& W *"&&&1 o" gk[ YkWdZe kd c[diW`[ fkXb_Y_jWh_e i[W [d]W‹eie e WXk# i_le" bW Wkjeh_ZWZ Yecf[j[dj[ Z_i# fedZh| bW ikif[di_ÂŒd Z[ bW Z_\ki_ÂŒd fkXb_Y_jWh_W" o WZ[c|i ehZ[dWh| bW Z_\ki_ÂŒd Z[ bW h[Yj_\_YWY_ÂŒd Z[ ik Yedj[d_Ze" W YeijW Z[b WdkdY_Wdj[" feh bei c_icei c[Z_ei" [ifWY_ei o ^ehWh_ei$ BW Z_\ki_ÂŒd Z[ bW h[Y# j_\_YWY_ÂŒd de i[h| c[deh Wb jh[_djW feh Y_[dje )& Z[ bW Z_\ki_ÂŒd Z[b c[diW`[ iWdY_edWZe$ Âľ9k|b [i [b eX`[j_le Z[ fhe^_X_h o iWdY_edWh bW fkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W# ‹eiW5 :[ bW fkXb_Y_ZWZ Z[X[cei [if[# hWh gk[ [bbW dei jhWdic_jW Z[ \ehcW l[hWp bW _d\ehcWY_ÂŒd gk[ \WY_b_j[ bW [b[YY_ÂŒd Z[ kd fheZkYje e i[hl_Y_e h[if[Yje Z[b h[ije Z[ bei [n_ij[dj[i [d [b c[hYWZe" o [bbe _cfb_YW gk[ [ij[ WdkdY_e e Yeckd_YWY_ÂŒd de Yedj[d# ]W [nfh[i_ed[i gk[ fheZkpYWd [hheh e Yed\ki_ÂŒd [djh[ bei Yedikc_Ze# h[i$ Feh jeZe be [nfk[ije" [i d[Y[iW# h_e gk[ bei fhel[[Zeh[i Z[ X_[d[i o i[hl_Y_ei" jec[d YedY_[dY_W WY[hYW Z[ bei [\[Yjei d[]Wj_lei gk[ fk[Z[ j[d[h kdW fkXb_Y_ZWZ [d]W‹eiW [d [b f‘Xb_Ye eX`[j_le" bW [cfh[iW" bei Yecf[j_Zeh[i o bW ieY_[ZWZ [d ][d[# hWb o gk[ bk[]e Z[ YedeY[h bei f[h`k_# Y_ei gk[ bW c_icW b[i fk[Z[ eYWi_e# dWh" Z[Y_ZWd de kj_b_pWh ƒijW fh|Yj_YW Yece [ijhWj[]_W Yec[hY_Wb$

Ĺ? Ĺ?

Ĺ?


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.