MCA Israel Discussion Group

By Harvey Cohen, MCA Member

We all know the old adage that if you have two Jews, you have three (or more) opinions. Perhaps the origins of the MCA Israel Discussion Group, envisioned by the late great Steve Brazina, rests in his recognition that such an open forum would catalyze our passion and understanding for Israel.

Now in its third year, the discussion group regularly finds 12 to 20 plus MCA men ready to share, listen and learn. Most are lifelong Zionists for whom Israel is central to life. Others have a broader view of Israel.

Since the Oct. 7, 2023 horror, the forum has served as a safe cauldron for our rage, fears, vulnerability and hope for a stronger Israel. On numerous occasions, local community members who recently traveled to Israel have shared their experiences by bringing us their firsthand insights.

Additionally, we are fortunate that many members truly hold expertise for our discussions. We’ve discussed Israeli policies, Middle East politics, the Heredi conscription crisis, U.S. politics, Iran, Bibi’s future, IDF, Palestinian politics, antisemitism, Canadian politics, EU and U.N., the future of Gaza, Lebanon and recently post-Assad Syria and more.

Personal emotions often run high and disagreeing respectfully is also interpreted differently. So far, no black eyes nor broken bones! Al Pilver and Colin Lewis lead the animated 90-minute discussion, which takes place in the Price Boardroom at the Nina Iser Jewish Cultural Center (and via Zoom). While differing opinions always surface, everyone has an opportunity to share with the group, followed by an “open mic” period.

Interested? The MCA Israel Discussion Group is held the second Monday of each month from 10 to 11:30 a.m. Men’s Cultural Alliance members are welcome. Details can be found on MCA’s site (mcanaples.org) — or just show up.