[Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest] by Jahnavi J | 19272222 Tutors Adam Holloway, Sebastian Hicks, Chris Fulton
Hanjun Kim, Shahe Gregorian
MArchD Year 1: Digital Craft Studio Advanced Digital Practice Oxford School of Architecture
+
ABOUT Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest is an explorative o昀昀-shoot of the Retroscale project
driven by AI and digital tooling. The project Retroscale in collaboration with Make Architects questions the possibility of retro昀椀tting new future funtionality into existing buildings with minimal intervention and thoughful re-design. Beyond Retroscale derives from the same brief but attempts to use AI in the process as a tool for design inspiration. By highlighting the crital understanding of digital tools through workshops conducted over the course of the project, it establishes a template for a unique work昀氀ow.
CONTENTS
Chapter 1: Digital tooling Workshops - Introduction and structure - Prompt craft for AI using Midjourney - Numerical Approach to Modelling - Itirative Approach - Topological modelling with SubD - Form-昀椀nding and Parametric Detailing
Chapter 2: Beyond Retroscale
- Introduction - Cultural context - Analysis - Tests - Design Iterations - Final Output - AI and the design process- a stand
CHAPTER 1
Digital Tooling Workshops
PART A
- STRUCTURE - PROMPT CRAFT WITH AI USING MIDJOURNEY
STRUCTURE The portfolio has pages with Ai promts and grasshopper wok昀氀ows. For ease of understanding, the pages with the red border represent the Ai promts and the pages with grey represent grasshopper scripts and understanding work昀氀ows.
PROMPT CRAFT This was a workshop conducted in week 0 of the course where the objective was to 昀椀ne tune prompting with midjourney and understand how ai and collage can aid in the design process. The conclusions at this step were leaning more towards the idea that AI is good for a quick reimagination of a concept but not for generating something speci昀椀c.
10
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
11
Imagine
and lights within
pavilion
a
sprical
pavilion
with
light Blend with translusecnt fabric
structure, metal, translucent fabric
MIDJOURNEY EXPLORATIONS- LIGHT PAVILION
Imagine a sprical pavilion with light
Blend with image of pavilion with lights and fairy like e昀昀ect
Feeding collage into midjourney to reimagine
12
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
13
FINAL COLLAGE 1 There were two collages as a group, one showing the form of the space and one showing the feel.
14
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
15
FINAL COLLAGE 2 There were two collages as a group, one showing the form of the space and one showing the feel.
16
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
17
FINAL AI IMAGE
CHAPTER 1
Digital Tooling Workshops
PART B
- NUMERICAL APPROACH TO MODELLING - UNDERSTANDING THE SOFTWARE - WORKFLOW PROPOSED - WORKSHOP OUTCOMES - ADAPTATIONS AND EXPLORATIONS
Establising a particle quelea and feeding it into grasshopper
Setting up the simulators for the fountain or 昀氀ocking simulations, includes the quelea engine and the rules or forces acting on the quelea
Understanding how the quelea functions allows one to understand what rules to manipulate to have control over the simulations
Forces act externally but the agent rules work within the cluster of quelea
Simplex noise is used to generate a height 昀椀eld or a magnetic 昀椀eld which can be used to further manipulate particles in a work昀氀ow
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
23
NUMERICAL MODELLING STEP 1-Quelea
STEP 2
STEP 3
Setting up particle quelea and system for computation
Adding rules to the system
Adding constraints to the system Gravity and attract rule Attractor force Negative force/ gravity Positive force No rules
The above diagram illustrated the movement of quelea under di昀昀erent combination of forces which allows one to understand how the particles might behave for a given set of rules
QUELEA AND TUNDRA EXPERIMENTATION AND ASSIGNMENT 24
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
25
NUMERICAL MODELLING STEP 4- Flocking Simulation Setting up particle quelea and system for computation
26
STEP 5
STEP 6
Adding gradient based on the distance of each quelea from each other
Flocking with acctor and repel forces which makes it behave like birds in 昀氀ocks
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
27
NUMERICAL MODELLING STEP 1- Tundra
Setting up a rectangular grid of points to manipulate with the noise 昀椀eld
STEP 2
Simplex purlin noise used to generate a 昀椀eld. Overlapping two 昀椀elds of di昀昀erent amplitude is possible through SumFractal
STEP 3
Creating a gradient on the surface created
QUELEA AND TUNDRA EXPERIMENTATION AND ASSIGNMENT 28
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
29
NUMERICAL MODELLING STEP 4
Setting up point 昀椀elds which attract the quelea
STEP 5
Adding di昀昀erent force magnitude to the points creates a variety of interesting forms
Diagram illustrating how the step by step movement of quelea happens. By restricting movement angles to multiples of 45 degrees, it gives a more geometric output, ridding it of the curves
30
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
31
BENCH DESIGN ED THROUGH QUELEA AND TUNDRA
32
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
33
CHAPTER 1
Digital Tooling Workshops
PART C
-ITERATIVE DESIGN APPROACH - UNDERSTANDING THE SOFTWARE - WORKFLOW PROPOSED - WORKSHOP OUTCOMES - ADAPTATIONS AND EXPLORATIONS
Establising an item to aggregate and giving it a direction for aggregation
Constraints added in the terms of 昀椀elds or mesh boundaries
Working of topos explained as a sketchestablishing load and support geometries along with a domain for the optimisation to happen
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
37
WASP STEP 1
Setting up box for aggregation
STEP 2
Aggregation of a tetrahedron allows more play with the directions for aggregations
STEP 3
Combination of di昀昀erent type of input geometries for aggregation
STEP 4
De昀椀ning an attribute inside of the geometry such that once it aggregates, it can be replaced by said attribute
Constraints for aggregation in the form of curve or boundary representations
WASP EXPERIMENTATION 38
STEP 5
Diagram showing wasp dependency on direction for aggregation Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
39
TOPOS STEP 1 Setting up load and support for topos to opimise the geometry within a given boundary
STEP 2
Combination of wasp and topos to create a 昀椀eld at the load geometry and aggregate it with octahedron
STEP 3
Cretaing a joinery between three elements by assigning two as loads and one as support and giving a sphere inbetween as boundary for optimisation
Note: Refer to Chapter 2 for assignment on Topos
TOPOS EXPERIMENTATION 40
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
41
CHAPTER 1
Digital Tooling Workshops
PART D
- TOPOLOGICAL MODELLING WITH SUBD - UNDERSTANDING THE SOFTWARE - WORKFLOW PROPOSED - WORKSHOP OUTCOMES - ADAPTATIONS AND EXPLORATIONS
UNDERSTANDING SUBD SubD refers to subdivided polyhedron or subdivided mesh geometry which allows for creation of smoot curves and organic work昀氀ow. Hence once shift between the subd smooth geometry and its control mesh by using tab
Chairs modelled in workshop with help from Shahe to understanding sculpting with subD
Diagram showing the wat subD relates to its control geomtry in 2D and 3D
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
45
TOPOLOGICAL MODELLING
VITRA CHAIR ASSIGNMENT
STEP 1 Modelling one side of the chair intuitively with help from few guidelines
46
STEP 2 Re昀氀ecing along the central axis
STEP 3 Re昀椀ning the geometry and creating the gaps in the chair and adding thickness to it
STEP 4 Diagram showing the re昀椀nded model in subD smooth format
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
47
TOPOLOGICAL MODELLING
BONE CHAIR ASSIGNMENT
STEP 1 Using guideline to create a multipipe as the beginning geometry
48
STEP 2 Varying the multipipe geometry intuitively to create the form required
STEP 3 Diagram showing the 昀椀nal re昀椀nded chair with the guides
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
49
VITRA CHAIR ASSIGNMENT The modelling is more intuitive and is based on following the guiding image with a few dimensions
50
BONE CHAIR ASSIGNMENT The process is statred by using guidelines which create a base geometry thats close to 昀椀nal product and is then varied to match output
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
51
PARAMETRIC DETAILING
STEP 1 Using box morph anf twisted box to create columns
STEP 2 Using a mesh subdivided by catmullclark subdivisions as control geometry for subD
STEP 3 Creating bespoke joinery using the subd nodes and multipipe
AI TO DIGITAL MODELLING- FACADE AND COLUMN 52
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
53
PARAMETRIC DETAILING Note: Refere Chapter 2 for application of excel organisation.
STEP 4 Using Kangaroo to circle pack on the facade and use this geometry to imitate the AI image
54
STEP 5 Creating Excel sheet using TTToolbox for fabrication on site
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
55
CHAPTER 1
Digital Tooling Workshops
PART E
- FORM-FINDING AND PARAMETRIC DETAILING - UNDERSTANDING THE SOFTWARE - WORKFLOW PROPOSED - WORKSHOP OUTCOMES - ADAPTATIONS AND EXPLORATIONS
Having a continuous mesh allows creatation of curves following the subdivisions on its surface as continuous lines which allows one to split the mesh into surfaces that can be unrolled
Any discrepency in the mesh does not result in continuous lines
Warp lines o昀昀set from the surface for the entire geometry
The warp lines are o昀昀set from the surface and then reduced in length from each side to create curves for lofting Issues with warp lines highlighted: Having unjoined meshes at the end allows for a more continuous warp lines - illustrated by having gaps in geometry
Lofting creates tabs on the surface
Unrolled meshes with tabs allow for fabrication in real life
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
59
MINIMAL SURFACES STEP 1 Using SubD as a refernece to create a mesh divided by catmull clark subdivisions which is then fed into kangaroo create a minimal surface
60
STEP 2 Creating tabs on the split mesh by o昀昀setting the surface and lofting the curves together
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
61
MINIMAL SURFACES STEP 3 Unrolled surface with tabs and numbers which help with fabrication
62
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
63
MINIMAL SURFACES STEP 1 Using SubD as a refernece to create a mesh divided by catmull clark subdivisions
64
STEP 2 Feeding the geometry into kangaroo to create a minimal surface which can be unrolled after splitting
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
65
MINIMAL SURFACES STEP 3 Creating tabs on the split mesh by o昀昀setting the surface and lofting the curves together
66
STEP 4 Unrolled surface with tabs and numbers which help with fabrication
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
67
CHAPTER 2 PART A
Beyond Retroscale - INTRODUCTION TO WELBECK STREET CARPARK - PROBLEMS WITH EXISTING CARPARK - CULTURAL CONTEXT
INTRODUCTION Welbeck Street Carpark
Welbeck Car Park was designed by Michael Blampied and Partners in 1970 for Debenhams Store and is well-known for its brutalist and iconic concrete facade. The facade was made of tessellated concrete diamonds and had an important structural role in the building. The car park was sold to Shiva Hotels in 2016 and as they required a higher 昀氀oor height for the new use, decided to demolish the entire car park. Since the beginning, this decision was criticized by many, including architects, and at the time, JAA Architects also proposed an alternative that could save the building. Even though many tried to change this decision, the building was demolished in 2019.
Photographer Jo Underhill (2021), Ode to Welbeck
70
Digimap, Edited by Alireza
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
71
CONTEXT Then and Now The Carpark once served the Debanhams store and hence has the Basement 昀氀oor connected with the store but in the current context after its sale, it has been converted into BoTree Hotel. The photos below show the Welbeck street carpark in its context and the images on the right show the visual changes in the context between 1999 and 2023.
Google Earth, 1999
72
Photographer Jo Underhill (2021), Ode to Welbeck
Google Earth, 2023
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
73
Typical 昀氀oor plan with area Floor plan highlighting the structure and the 昀氀oor plates along with the stair and ramp cores
Level 8 Level 8 Level 7 Level 7
REASONS FOR DEMOLISHION
Level 6 Level 6 Level 5
Level 3
2560mm
Level 4 Level 4
2140mm
Level 5
Level 3 Level 2 Level 2 Level 1 Level 1 Level 0
Section of the Welbeck street carpark highlighting the fact that the 昀氀oor height is not feasible for human habitation
Once the carpark was sold to Shiva hotels, they wanted to convert it into a hotel but the 昀氀oor heights of the car park made that proposal impossible. Althought other architects like JAA tried to give proposals they were rejected keeping in minde the commercial pro昀椀ts and losses that would be incurred.
Proposal by JAA architects which deals with the roof height by removing 昀氀oor plates- Hence was rejected
Level 0
74
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
75
DEVELOPMENT OF MULTISTOREY CARPARKS Parking Facility no.5, Chicago, 1952
Aeck Associates, Atlanta, 1954
Auguste Perret, Paris, 1905: Garage de la Societe Ponthieu Automobiles
Robert Law Weed, Miami, 1948
The very 昀椀rst multistorey carparks were extensions of warehouses but later they developed into their own type when the use of cars increased. Now they are even combined with large scale infrastructure projects to de昀椀ne cities. The Multistorey carpark typology developed from the warehouse but was adapted to the necessity of parking cars only. Below: Precedents of the multistorey carpark type- left to right: infrastructure and architecture,Car park Rotundas-Hamburg airport, Parkhaus Haniel
76
Louis Khan, City-centre Philadelphia, 1947-62
Intially the Carparks were solid but once they realised the importance of ventilation in the space, architects attempted to provide openings in the form of jaali on the facade. Since the car park had no functional requirement of a facade except for aesthetics, this gave immense freedom for exploration.
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
77
The Stair cores and ramp cores along with the facade
Split levels
Central ramp core acting as a structural core
Why is Welbeck special?
The images below highlight how Welbeck street carpark, especially its front facade would have been a major view on London’s Maryleborne street
CULTURAL ICON
Although a Brutalist building, the Welbeck car park enjoyed a lot of attention from the public because of its intriguing facade. Poems written on the walls of the car park once it shut down highlight how it held value in the local people’s everyday lives.
78
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
79
If one were to adapt an existing building for the future, then the addition would have as much importance as the existing as well as aesthetic value
Brutalist building in concrete
BRUTALIST ARCHITECTURE CHARACTERS Brutalist building in timber Brutalist buildings were characterised by contrasting textured surfaces, unusual and massive shapes and most importantly, an expression of structure through the materiality. It is worth asking whether brutalist architecture would look the same if done in another material?
Collage of building showing merged use 80
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
81
CHAPTER 2
Beyond Retroscale
PART B
- ANALYSIS - TESTS
LOAD STRUCTURE OF WELBECK CAR PARK The diagrams by the original architect of Welbeck street carpark reveal the development of facade geometry based on the load distribution in the facade
84
The building had a horizontal bracing along with the v forms which took load from the top to the columns at the bottom
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
85
Estimated structural detail of the facade panels attaching to the 昀氀oor plates- developed through a study of the images and photographs with 昀氀oor plans and details available
Below: Left- Cutting areas from the central shear wall highlighted Right- Method of lifting at the shear wall
86
Possibilities of cuttingThe conclusion that a horizontal cut at the facade at the bottom of the panels and a vertical cut at the shear walls is the most feasible option looking at the structure
Loads on the additionsFor the scenario where an element is added to the structure after lifting, the loads considered were divided in the ratio of 70:30 between the shear walls and the facade since the facade is only responsible to avoid torque in what can be considered a cantilever structure.
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
87
SCENARIOS EXPLORED
88
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
89
concrete_slabs_held_together_
by_a_timber_lattice
by_a_timber_origami_inspired_
MIDJOURNEY EXPLORATIONS- BLUE SKY THINKING
concrete_slabs_held_together_
columns
concrete_slabs_held_together_ by_transluscent_etfe_bubble_ inspired_structures concrete_slabs_extended_by_
geometric concrete facade with
organic_concrete_additions
panels that are symmetric , made of concrete and timber
90
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
91
a
facade
geometry
inspired by the japanese lantern, symmetrical, brutalist, concrete
blend welbeck facade with
blend welbeck facade with
refernece image
generated image
describing
the
MIDJOURNEY EXPLORATIONS-BLUE SKY THINKING
imagine
reference
image and using the text as prompts
92
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
93
fabric geometry in the form of a tree, soft
REMIX
light, brutalist facade juxtaposed with
structure and fabric organic
organic forms
forms
timber
MIDJOURNEY EXPLORATIONS-BLUE SKY THINKING
extend the facade by adding soft organic lattice
REMIX Car park in london built in brutalist architecture style, with triangular geometric repetitive facade in concrete and timber lattice structure in the middle, contrast of organic forms and facade geometry
Blend with reference image
94
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
Blend with reference image
95
MACHANICAL LIFTING
MECHANICAL LIFTING METHODS
Concept of working
The 昀椀rst experiment at the farm was to try a system made of wood which could be deployed in the structure in its lowered form and then be extended with the help of external machine but with internal mechanism that would push the slab upwards. The element would then become part of the structure as a column. Mainly done as an exploration of using timber with concrete more functionally.
The grasshopper work昀氀ow was to draft the geometry of the 昀氀oor by virtue of one input angle and a point of reference only. This allows for the system to move as desired.
Condition 1: Normal state 96
Condition 2: Extended state Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
97
The study of a suspended bridge is interesting in terms of how the support cable works. Left: Loads on the bridge and detail of members Top: Similar load in all three conditions of attachment of cable
Application of the theory to suspended roof forms
CABLE STRUCTURES Using the force diagrams to design the form of cables: The force diagram represents the forces in each member of the caternary curve as the sides of a triangle where the resultant force puts it in equilibrium. This is effective to design stable cable structure by virtue of a balanced load system
Diagrams illustrating how the difference in the force diagrams can change the form of the elements
98
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
99
For the grasshopper script, the two adjacent panels are taken as a load along with the point loads from the slab and the bottom panel is considered as support with the end beam, the boundary domain is taken as the space inbetween and an attempt is made to get optimised geometry at all heights.
PROPOSED WORKFLOW WITH TOPOS The intension of using Topos initially was to generate an optimised addition to the facade once it is lifted off the 昀氀oor plates. The plan of action was to generate an optimised mesh for structure and then opitmised it for shape so it can be easily fabricated.
100
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
101
ATTEMPTS AT THE GRYMSDYKE FARM The script when applied for the shear walls and the columns yielded desirable results but with the facade was not as successful as expected.
Results for running topos with the panels in the facade with the work昀氀ow that was proposed. The geometry was entirely dependant on the given boundary condition even at very little loads applied.
It was proposed that by attempting to run the script between more than just two panels, more interesting shapes would emerge but also the same could happen by removing some panels from the facade in a pattern which also responds to needs to sun shading and comfort.
Results for running topos with shear walls with the slab as load and wall as supports with region inbetween as domain for addition.
102
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
103
GRASSHOPPER WORKFLOW-TOPOS
STEP 1 Feeding in rhino geometry to grasshopper
104
STEP 2 Anemone looping used to repeat the fed data on all 昀氀oors
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
105
STEP 3 Selecting the panels from the list of facade panels and replacing them with the V-structure which is structural
106
STEP 4 De昀椀ning the load, support and boundary geometries for topos
STEP 5 Topos optimised geometry
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
107
street carpark and then using describe to generate prompts
Blend with reference image
MIDJOURNEY EXPLORATIONS- TOPOS INSPIRED ORGANIC ADDITION
fed with a edited image of the welbeck
prompts given by remixing the descriptions given by midjourney
108
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
109
110
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
STABLE DIFFUSION EXPLORATIONS- TOPOS INSPIRED ORGANIC ADDITION
Stable Diffusion with control net was used to understand whether having the control over the AI prompting will allow one to get closed to desired reults but they were not up to the expectations and also need google collab for functioning after running it on the laptop for a while.
111
Since AI was not able to understand the exact context for the addtions, it was worth trying to prompt the additions on their own and then collage it back into the original image which would then give a desried result when remixed with AI. The idea was also to pull the additive element slightly back as shown to made it three dimentional.
PROPOSALS AFTER THE FAILED AI ATTEMPTS A script was developed for the creation of the organic lattice addtions through the use of geometrical and material constraints. 112
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
113
UNDERSTANING STRUCTURE WITH TOPOS
Note:
Red- Load
Green- Optimised geometry Blue-Support
Note:
Red- Load lines
Green- Optimised geometry Blue-Opimisation boundary
Attempt 1 With two panels as load and bottom one as support and an inverted panel as boundary condition. Result: The results for the opimisation look the shape of the inverted panel 114
Attempt 2 With two panels as load and bottom one as support and region between them as boundary. Result: The results for the opimisation look the shape of the inverted panel connecting the centroids of the upper panels with the centre of the beam
Attempt 3 With four panels as load and two bottom one as support and an inverted panel as boundary condition. Result: The results for the opimisation connect mid point to end beam
Attempt 4 With panel removed and the surrounding geometry used for optimisation Result: The results for the opimisation look the shape of the panel
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
115
LOAD TRANSFERS AND LOAD POINTS From topos it was clear that the original building was optimised in terms of its structure and hence the running of the simluation would not return any wildly different results from the existing geometry.
116
Each panel connects two load points from the upper slabs to one point on the bottom as seen in the image above.
Once the panels are disconnected from the bottom end beam, the panels no longer transfer the load from end to end and hence the best way to transefer the load back to the beam would be to connect the centrid of the element to the beam directly which is simoly what topos did everytime it was run on the structure in all its orientations. This also meant that the proposal of the organic laattice would not be possible with topos work昀氀ow.
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
117
CHAPTER 2
Beyond Retroscale
PART C
- DESIGN ITERATIONS - FINAL OUTPUT - AI AND DESIGN PROCESS- A STAND
IDEAL HYBRID SOULTION FOR THE RETROFIT OF THE CARPARK In order to make sure that the number of 昀氀oors of the building, its facade and its identity is retained yet there is a change in its 昀氀oor height, whilst also making sure the cutting and demolishion was kept to a minimum, a hybrid solution was proposed. The lower two 昀氀oors of the proposed building are hence supported by a mega truss made of low carbon materials and span a double height where as the upper 昀氀oors would retain the panels and would be lifted up by hydraulics. Two additional 昀氀oors added on top would then take the panels removed from the bottom.
120
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
121
massive mega truss and timber panels in the facade, brutalist architecture, timber architecture
blend with Welbeck street carpark facade
blend with staircase cutting through the centre
122
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
MIDJOURNEY EXPLORATIONS-MEGA TRUSS
imagine a timber brutalist building with
123
precast
concrete
panels
with a rough edge and a timber truss which appears like a lattice between the panels, brutalist architecture,
blend with the photoshopped
Japanese
image
timber
joinery,
london carpark facade
124
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
of
the
joinery
inbewteen concrete panels
MIDJOURNEY EXPLORATIONS- ADDITIONS
architectural joinery between
125
CASE STUDIES THE GALLERIA | OMA The creation of a lattice space frame around the circulation areas on the facade is considered as inspiration for future briefs. This building too has the circulation wrapping around the building which is adding to its character but is already a present character in the car park.
CASE STUDIES WERK 12 | MVRDV To decide an AI image which closely related to the design imagined for the Welbeck street site, a few examples were looked at. In each of these, an image of the project was fed into midjourney and the prompts were used to prompt the facade for the carpark. From Werk 12, its staircase wrapping around the building and brutalist aesthetic on the inside were considered as inspirations.
126
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
127
CASE STUDIES RAMPS AND CARPARK ARCHITECTURE Owing to the function of multistorey carparks having to transport cars vertically, ramps are an inherent and important feature. More importantly these ramps connecting all 昀氀oors of a building can be considered as a verical connectivity which is an element pined after by many architects in many other typologies. Since the facade of the car park also had no other functionality, it was quite possible for the facade to successfully show the ramp structure within.
ELEMENTS FOR DESIGN Vertical connectivity Structural expression Low carbon material like timber
128
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
129
MVRDV with welbeck street carpark with text from descriptions
MIDJOURNEY EXPLORATIONS- FACADE
blend reference images of OMA and
imagine a brutalist facade cut across by a staircase which is highlighted by a surrounding lattice structure in timber
blend with the welbeck street carpark facade
130
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
131
blending with the welbeck street carpark
blending with the welbeck street carpark
brutalist building with symmetrical facade
facade and previously generated facade
facade and previously generated facade
with panels
images
images
132
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
MIDJOURNEY EXPLORATIONS- TIMBER TRUSS
imagine a timber megatruss supporting a
133
MIDJOURNEY EXPLORATIONS- LATTICE imagine a space frame lattice made of
blending with the Welbeck street carpark
timber
facade
134
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
135
AI WORKFLOW Overall AI exploration mapped
AI WORKFLOW Failures with AI: Materiality and composition There was scope of AI integration in the design process in steps where a randomised output was favourable or more ideally was desired. The 昀椀rst point was when the choice was to be made of the material which can be used with the existing concrete façade
Where? Working with the collaborative studio, after the research on the systems and context of the Welbeck street carpark was completed, there was a design challenge on how to extend such a building into the future. The collaborative studio requires minimal intervention but given the same brief and the possibilities of design, AI integration could positively bene昀椀t the 昀椀nal output.
Facade Formal explorations with AI result in some workable outputs of the façade. Subjectively, the output is very loosely tied to the collaborative studio brief.
Additions There were a few issues with using AI to generate images of a pre-imagined form as an insert in the design- Main issue is that the diagram points to a predicted formal output, the de昀椀nition of which defeats AI integration in the process 136
Why Collage? After working with AI on multiple platforms, it was clear that the best way to prompt was to edit a sample image and then modify it. When working with AI, prompting in parts and creating sample images could streamline outputs.
Diagram showing the layering of AI inputs from different elements into one larger image to follow
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
137
FINAL COLLAGE
Timber lattice for façade at voids created- addition to existing façade
Timber truss on lower 昀氀oors
Voids and staircase design 138
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
139
AI WORKFLOW
READING THE VOIDS One of the main attempts of this research was to see the application of Ai in spatial design considering it is a 2D output. The attempt here was to read the AI image and rationalise it with the given building as the context. The process has been described and broken down in the next few images.
140
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
141
142
DESIGN BREAKDOWN
DESIGN BREAKDOWN
ENTRY
READING THE VOIDS
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
143
144
DESIGN BREAKDOWN
DESIGN BREAKDOWN
STAIRCASE
TRUSS
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
145
Proposed Ground plan sketch
DESIGN BREAKDOWN LATTICE
Proposed Third plan sketch 146
昀氀oor
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
147
CHAPTER 2
Column design
PART C
FORM FOLLOWS FORCE
148
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
149
RECIPROCAL FORCE DIAGRAMS A STUDY
Diagram showing the equivalence of forces in a triangular form and how it is translated in a tetrahedron. If planes are drawn perpendicular to 3 forces , the normal to the resulting side of the tetrahedron is the direction of the equivalent and the area is proportional to its magnitude. Hence the pipe radii represent the force magnitudes proportionally. This also means that the node is always in compression, unless a force is moving away from the node in which case it can be replaced by a tension wire
Diagram showing how a tetrahedron can be considered the 3dimentional equivalent of triangular force diagrams
Effect and methods of varying force polygon
Subdividing a force polygon and how it had been used in design before 150
References: Juney LEEa*, Tom VAN MELEb, Philippe BLOCKb, ETH Zurich, Form-昀椀nding explorations through geometric transformations and modi昀椀cations of force polyhedrons Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
151
GRAPHICS STATICS STEP 1 Brep for the central connection- caternary curve jointing the centre
STEP 2 With two panels as load and bottom BRep for the double X top part of the bottom
STEP 3 Graphics statics could not combine the polyhedron and hence they needed to be analysed separately
STEP 4 Combination and mirroring to get column form
ITERATION OF COLUMN GRAPHICS STATICS 152
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
153
Aligned Breps
Generated form curves
ITERATION OF COLUMN GRAPHICS STATICS Issues with Graphics Statics: - Does not combine Breps -No way to control the generated form - No way to control the proportion or scale as per the existing model
154
Re昀椀ning the node to be a hexagonal section for easy attachment and remodelling
4 part symmetry in the column structure Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
155
3D NODE GEOMETRY GRAPHICS STATICS
156
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
157
ITERATION OF COLUMNDESIGN PROCESS POLYFRAME
Using an asymmetrical X form- smaller on one side and deeper on the other
Using the lines to generate brep geometry
Double X form rationalised from AI
Variation of the form of the double X depending on staircase height at which it meets it 158
Rationalisation of the asymmetrical form owing to the end beam depth from the column Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
159
ITERATION OF COLUMNGENERATING THE BREPS POLYFRAME
Brep curves drawn from the double x form needed- drawing normals and generating the form
Exploded brep geometry generated
Column form generated by constraining the end vertices and the edge length of the central part where the staircase passes through the column Three types of breps based on the three types of columns in the structure
160
Form diagram given by polyframe without constraints Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
161
POLYFRAME STEP 1 Brep curves drawn in rhino fed into the system STEP 2
Form diagram is made perpendicular PFfoam to PFperp
STEP 4
Edge constraint is added to vary edge lengths to support the staircase STEP 5
Non-organic subD multipipe with a double bevel to create geometry of pipes
STEP 3
The vertex list that needs to be constrained is selected with the cursor and the point list is created in rhino around the column location
162
GRASSHOPPER WORKFLOW POLYFRAME
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
163
ITERATION OF COLUMNFINAL ELEVATIONS POLYFRAME
Diagramatic view of the addtions to the building
164
Final elevation has a massive timber addition which alters the character of welbeck but preserves its past as well. By adding a low carbon element cutting through the facade in the form of a staircase and column also brings back the brutalist nature of structural expression and massive unusual forms Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
165
MODELLING THE COLUMN AND JOINERY Owing to the nature of the column with multiple structs and connectors, in order to model a 1:100 scale model of the same, it was 3D printed on a powder printer with resin. The process took approximately 6 hours. Since the printer cannot print very delicate geometry, the entire column had to be fattened more than its actual scale. It is also more fragile than PLA 3D printing.
166
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
167
JOINERY TYPE 1- CNC CUTTING
Geometry rationalised and cut into 4 parts for CNC cutting- follows from the excel sheet provided
168
Process of CNC milling- had to be performed on foam since bit for wood was unavilable
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
169
Joining the milled pieces together
Final node geometry
170
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
171
NODE FABRICATION
EXCEL SHEET FOR FABRICATION - CNC CUTTING The excel sheet gives information on the Node name, its diagram, the angles needed for fabrication and the sizes of each section.
Step 1: Node names
Step 2: Node information 172
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
173
JOINERY TYPE 2- NON-CNC JOINERY- KERF BENDING
Kerf bending a asymmetrical piece of wood as per the angles generated on the excel sheet
If plywood is not cut deep enough it will break with pressure- more di昀케cult to control in terms of the process
Di昀케culty of using the hand saw because the blade is too thick for the purpose 174
Experiments on hardwood were much smoother and easier
Depth of kerf cut for bending
Spacing of the cuts determined by online kerf cutting tool by giving the angle and radius required
Hand cutting wood pieces as per measurements
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
175
Possibility of attaching connectors at ends because the script generates planar surface at node ends
Bent and joined pieces of wood
176
Final node geometry without CNC or other machines Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
177
blending with the mvrdv staircase images
blending with the 昀椀nal collage output which
interior spaces
from Werk 12
was modelled
MIDJOURNEY EXPLORATIONS- INTERIORS
blending with the OMA reference images of
blending with diagrams from the parking book and interior of Welbeck car park
178
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
179
180
Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
MIDJOURNEY EXPLORATIONS- FURNITURE
imagine furniture inspired by this image
181
MODELLING AI GENERATED FURNITURE
AI image generated
Rationalisation of the geometry 182
SubD Modelling Jahnavi J | Beyond Retroscale: pAlImpsest | DCA
183
AI AND THE DESIGN PROCESS A STAND Through the process of designing something with the aid of AI tools, one can make a speculation about how it can a昀昀ect the design process. SInce the Ai generated image is 2D, it seems to be easier to model objects like furniture or facade or even a column that looks like the image but the spatial bearing of it is still questionable. The generations of interior space images shows that it is possible to an extent but it is best if AI images are used to quickly guage the feasibility of a design rather than becoming the design themselves. There might an internalised process of collage making which has been brought out in this portfolio as an attempt. Nonetheless, it is an extremely powerful tool when combined with the digital software available currently.