Baskin by Island Press

Praise for Under Ground “With fabulous prose, Yvonne Baskin takes us through an ecological looking glass to the

Baskin

SCIENCE / ENVIRONMENT

wonderland of underground . . . required reading (for all) made delightful.” —Thomas E. Lovejoy, President, H. John Heinz III

“Nematodes, slime molds and fungi are unexpectedly fascinating in this enjoyable tour of a new ecological frontier.” —Publishers Weekly “At last, proper attention is given to the vast biomass and biodiversity at our feet, humanity’s absolute dependence upon this layer of life, and the need to expand science and conservation to save it. This is a well-written and important book.” —E.O. Wilson, University Research Professor Emeritus, Harvard University “An excellent book . . . opens up the black box of soil to reveal the wonders of its workings.” —TRENDS in Ecology and Evolution “Engaging . . . rich and descriptive . . . Baskin’s book successfully gives a face to the rapidly changing field of soil ecology.” —BioScience “Under Ground will be both fascinating for laypersons and extremely useful for scientists like myself who understand how critical the soil is but know too little about it.” —Paul R. Ehrlich, Bing Professor of Population Studies, Stanford University and co-author of One with Nineveh: Politics, Consumption, and the Human Future

YVONNE BASKIN is the author of The Work of Nature: How the Diversity of Life Sustains Us and A Plague of Rats and Rubbervines: The Growing Threat of Species Invasions. Her articles have appeared in Science, Natural History, Discover, and numerous other publications.

Jacket design by Brian C. Barth Jacket photos: Acoptolabrus gehinii nishijimai (Imura, 1991), photo by Roman Rejzek; 200 species of mites, photo by Valerie Behan-Pelletier, Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada. Interior Illustrations by Joyce Powzyk

ISBN 1-59726-118-1

90000

9 781597 261180

Under Ground

Center for Science, Economics, and the Environment

a shearwater book

Under Ground

A Project of SCOPE, the Scientiﬁc Committee on Problems of the Environment

Yvonne Baskin

How Creatures of Mud and Dirt Shape Our World

Under Ground

Island Press shearwater books washington • covelo • london

A Shearwater Book Published by Island Press

Copyright © 2005 The Scientiﬁc Committee on Problems of the Environment (SCOPE) All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. No part of this book may be reproduced in any form or by any means without permission in writing from the publisher: Island Press, 1718 Connecticut Ave., NW, Suite 300, Washington, DC 20009. Shearwater Books is a trademark of The Center for Resource Economics. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication data. Baskin, Yvonne. Under ground : how creatures of mud and dirt shape our world / Yvonne Baskin. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 1-59726-003-7 (cloth : alk. paper) 1. Soil animals. 2. Burrowing animals. I. Title. QL110.B35 2005 591.75′7—dc22 2004030330

British Cataloguing-in-Publication data available.

Printed on recycled, acid-free paper Design by McKnight Design, LLC Manufactured in the United States of America 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1

Contents

i ii

Introduction: Opening the Black Box Where Nematodes Are Lions

iii

Of Ferns, Bears, and Slime Molds

The Power of Ecosystem Engineers

v vi

Plowing the Seabed

Microbes, Muck, and Dead Zones Fungi and the Fate of Forests

121

viii

Grazers, Grass, and Microbes

142

Restoring Power to the Soil Epilogue Notes

188

195

Acknowledgments Index

229

227

vii ix

164

100

i introduction

Opening the Black Box

wo golf cart–sized rovers named Opportunity and Spirit bounced to a landing on opposite sides of Mars in early 2004. From 200 million miles away, NASA scientists sent these robotic vehicles rolling about the rubblestrewn surface, poking their sophisticated instrumenttipped arms at rock outcrops, dunes, and dusty plains. Their mission: to search for geologic evidence that Mars was once a warmer, wetter, and perhaps even habitable planet. The prospect of life on Mars has captivated dreamers and visionaries for ages. Barely a century ago, astronomers and fantasy writers could peer into the night sky and imagine the red planet’s mottled surface laced with canals or seething with warlike aliens set to invade Earth. In the 1960s, the ﬁrst images beamed back to us by Mariner spacecraft quashed any lingering visions of canals or ruined cities. If we were ever to ﬁnd signs of Martian life, it was clear we would have to search beneath the surface of an arid, bitterly cold planet with air too thin to breathe. A Viking lander did just that in 1976: it scooped up material from the planet’s surface, analyzed it chemically, and found no clear evidence of life. That disappointment, however, did not quench our curiosity. Perhaps there was once a golden age on Mars,

a warmer time when the planet nodded toward the Sun, polar ice melted, rivers flowed, seas surged, and life took hold. It was almost three decades later when ecstatic space agency scientists announced that Opportunity had found evidence that Mars once hosted water—not just soggy plains but a shallow equatorial sea or swamp of briny, acidic water that had left ripple patterns and salt deposits in surface rocks.1 For months I followed the news and watched online as the rovers beamed back startlingly clear images of the Martian surface. Captivated as I was, one seemingly trivial point kept jarring me. News reports and often the scientists themselves persisted in calling the loose stuff that the rovers were probing “soil.” Soil? Among space buffs, that use of the word had become common enough that Merriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary defines soil in one sense as “the superficial unconsolidated and usually weathered part of the mantle of a planet.”2 But by the time Spirit and Opportunity were sent roving across Mars, I had spent more than a year learning about the mysteries of the earthly stuff we call soil, and using that word to describe the Martian surface sounded, well, oddly alien. Consider this description from Daniel Richter of Duke University who, like many ecologists, considers soil to be not simply the loose surface material of a planet but “the central processing unit of the earth’s environment”: Soil is the biologically excited layer of the earth’s crust. It is an organized mixture of organic and mineral matter. Soil is created by and responsive to organisms, climate, geologic processes, and the chemistry of the aboveground atmosphere. Soil is the rooting zone for terrestrial plants and the filtration medium that influences the quality and quantity of Earth’s waters. Soil supports the nearly unexplored communities of microorganisms that decompose organic matter and recirculate many of the biosphere’s chemical elements.3

In this light, Mars enthusiasts are jumping the gun when they call the dust of that planet “soil.” Theirs is an understandably hopeful

Under Ground

act—a hope that the Martian surface contains, if not current life, at least a legacy of life. So far, however, such hopes linger unfulfilled. True soil, as ecologists see it, remains at least as rare in the universe as life itself. Indeed, life—abundant and long-flourishing life—must precede soil. It is life that substantially organizes and transforms the weathered parent material of the planet into soil. The only soil discovered so far is often called “earth” after the only planet on which it’s found. Ironically, the money and vision expended on probing the secrets of Mars—$820 million for the latest two rovers alone—vastly exceed what has been spent exploring the earth beneath our feet. Yet it is the soils of our gardens, fields, pastures, and forests, as well as the sediments beneath streams, lakes, marshes, and seas, that harbor the most diverse and abundant web of life known in the universe. What’s more, it is life underground that makes possible the green and fruitful surface world that allows us to create flourishing civilizations with the means and the curiosity to probe the universe. Although money for exploring soil life remains relatively sparse, the pace of exploration and sense of excitement are growing among scientists who look down instead of up. Like space scientists, soil ecologists, too, are harnessing new technologies to reveal cryptic realms as little understood as the rusty skin of Mars—and far more vital to our existence. Unlike space exploration, however, the drive to understand life underground is fueled by a sense of urgency. Human activities are increasingly degrading and impoverishing soils and soil life, and this loss, in turn, threatens to diminish the earth’s capacity to sustain us. Soils have been called “the poor man’s rainforest” because a spade of rich garden soil may harbor more species than the entire Amazon nurtures aboveground.4 Two-thirds of the earth’s biological diversity— biodiversity for short—lives in its terrestrial soils and underwater sediments, a micromenagerie that includes uncataloged millions of microbes, mainly bacteria and fungi; single-celled protozoa; and tiny animals such as nematodes, copepods, springtails, mites, beetles,

Opening the Black Box

snails, shrimp, termites, pillbugs, and earthworms. Some are accessible to anyone curious enough to poke through rotting leaves, backyard dirt, or the muddy bottom of a tidal marsh, but most are too small to see without a microscope or magnifying glass. So little effort has been devoted to life underground—and so few scientists specialize in identifying these organisms—that at best only 5 percent of the species in most key groups of soil animals have so far been identiﬁed,5 and in marine sediments, less than 0.1 percent of species may be known.6 Taken together, however, these inconspicuous creatures dominate life on earth, not just in diversity but also in sheer numbers and even body mass. Harvard University ecologist Edward O. Wilson points out that 93 percent of the “dry weight of animal tissue” in a patch of Amazonian rain forest in Brazil belongs to invertebrates living everywhere from soil to treetops, from mites and springtails to ants and termites.7 And that doesn’t count the microbes. Despite their submicron stature, the bacteria in an acre of soil can outweigh a cow or two grazing above them.8 Indeed, bacteria may contain more than half of the “living protoplasm” on earth, most of it to be found either in terrestrial soils or in the mud of the oceans that cover three-fourths of the planet.9 Underworld creatures are not only numerous and weighty in aggregate, but ancient and exceedingly durable. Toughest among them are the “extremophiles,” bacteria and ancient microbes known as archaea that can live a mile or more deep in the earth, or in boiling hot springs or polar ice, enduring extremes of heat, cold, pressure, and pH that were considered unfailingly lethal to any form of life only a few decades ago.10 Some tiny soil animals can time-travel for decades or more in dormant states, impervious to extreme heat, cold, desiccation, and otherwise lethal radiation.11 Although most soil organisms are small and short-lived, some of the oldest and largest creatures ever identiﬁed are sprawling underground masses of the root-rot fungus Armillaria that far outclass blue whales in size. A 220,000-pound specimen that stretches across 37 acres of Michigan woodland was

Under Ground

Two-thirds of the earth’s biological diversity lives in its soils and underwater sediments, and thriving underground communities keep the planet’s surface green and habitable.

reported in 1992, setting off a race of sorts to ﬁnd the biggest “humongous fungus.”12 By 2003, a 2,200-acre Armillaria in Oregon had captured the record.13 Finally, although we think of plants as denizens of our aboveground world, many plants spend more than half the energy they capture from the sun to grow roots that nurture and interact with life underground.14 A prairie, for example, grows more grass biomass below the surface than above.

Opening the Black Box

If scientists still know very little about who lives underground, they know even less about what each species in particular does for a living. Yet the creatures of mud and dirt are so important to our life that Wilson calls them “the little things that run the world.”15 Together they form the foundation for the earth’s food webs, break down organic matter, store and recycle nutrients vital to plant growth, generate soil, renew soil fertility, filter and purify water, degrade and detoxify pollutants, control plant pests and pathogens, yield up our most important antibiotics, and help determine the fate of carbon and greenhouse gases and thus, the state of the earth’s atmosphere and climate. All of these ecological services arise from the spontaneous activities of billions of creatures going about the business of nourishing and reproducing themselves in a series of elaborate food webs below the surface. Since the dawn of agriculture, humans have recognized the value of the soil itself, often invoking its fertility in ritual and sacrifice. Yet most societies have given little thought to, or have been simply unaware of, the multitude of creatures that live and work in the soil. The scientific study of soil developed in the 19th century, driven largely by the desire for greater crop production. Even soil scientists, however, have traditionally treated the soil as a “black box”—a system whose internal workings remain hidden or mysterious—measuring physical and chemical attributes such as pH and organic matter content, monitoring inputs of nitrogen and outputs of carbon dioxide, but making little effort to identify the dynamic workforce within. Yet we now know that these soil attributes and outputs reflect the legacy of billions of organisms eating, breathing, growing, interacting with one another, and, in the process, altering their environment—and ours. Today, a growing cadre of scientists drawn from numerous disciplines and armed with new techniques is working to crack open the black box of soil life and soil processes and fill in that sketchy outline with deeper understanding. Soil ecologists in the 1950s pioneered research on soil biodiversity, food webs, and soil-plant interactions, but since the 1980s that effort has burgeoned dramatically in parallel with the development of ecosystem science.16 Researchers today view

Under Ground

soils and sediments as complex ecosystems, and they recognize that the processes that take place underground vitally affect not only our food and timber supplies but also the quality and sustainability of our environment. Soils and aquatic sediments now draw the attention of multidisciplinary teams of, for example, ecologists, biogeochemists, microbiologists, zoologists, entomologists, agronomists, foresters, marine and freshwater biologists, geologists, and atmospheric scientists. These researchers want to know who is down there, what each contributes to the functioning of the soil, how they are organized into communities and food webs, why some communities are richer in species than others, and how our activities threaten soil life and processes. Unlike Mars exploration, the increasing effort to understand life underground is not driven by curiosity or futuristic speculation alone. The diversity of life in soils and sediments is under increasing threat, just like plant and animal life aboveground, and as a result so is the integrity of the ecological processes that are inﬂuenced by underground life. By some estimates, more than 40 percent of the earth’s plantcovered lands, from dry rangelands to tropical rain forests, have been degraded over the past half-century by direct human uses such as grazing, timber cutting, and farming. Degraded land, by deﬁnition, has a diminished capacity to grow crops and forests and supply other goods and life support services to humanity.17 In that same half-century, erosion has lowered potential harvests on as much as 30 percent of the world’s farmlands. Erosion not only sweeps away mineral soil but also reduces the abundance and diversity of soil creatures, which are concentrated in the top few inches of the soil. “A hectare [2.5 acres] of good quality soil contains an average of 1,000 kg [kilograms— 2,200 pounds] of earthworms, 1,000 kg of arthropods, 150 kg [330 pounds] of protozoa, 150 kg of algae, 1,700 kg [3,740 pounds] of bacteria, and 2,700 kg [5,940 pounds] of fungi,” according to Cornell University ecologist David Pimentel.18 As this life is lost, the soil’s ability to hold water and nurture crops declines. Further, as soil and nutrients wash off the land and into rivers, lakes, and coastal waters,

Opening the Black Box

they damage water quality and smother and degrade sediment communities often already disrupted by pollution, dredging, and trawl fishing. Human-driven changes in climate, acid rain, excessive nitrogen deposition, the spread of nonnative species, and the continuing conversion of land to crops, cities, and other human uses all contribute to the loss of soil biodiversity and functioning.19 Accelerating degradation of the earth’s soils and sediments has not gone unnoticed by national and international organizations concerned with agricultural productivity, fisheries, food security, and poverty relief as well as biodiversity.20 Increasingly they recognize that defining, preserving, and restoring the health of soils and sediments are fundamental to addressing such problems as climate change, desertification, declining water quality, and the sustainability of agriculture, forestry, and fisheries worldwide. In turn, the health and quality of soils and sediments rely fundamentally on the work of the living communities within them. One of the international efforts that grew out of this concern is the Soil and Sediment Biodiversity and Ecosystem Functioning project led by soil ecologist Diana Wall of Colorado State University and sponsored by a nongovernmental scientific organization known as the Scientific Committee on Problems of the Environment (SCOPE). Since 1996, a wide array of specialists from around the world has volunteered time to the project to pull together what is known about the biodiversity of the earth’s soils and freshwater and marine sediments, its role in sustaining vital ecological processes, and threats to soil organisms and the services they provide. This book is an outgrowth of that project, and access to participating scientists has allowed me to explore how human activities threaten the integrity of soil and sediment communities, and in turn, the critical services they provide to human society. The idea for this book grew out of a chance encounter in February 2001 when I happened upon Wall and John W. B. Stewart, a retired soil scientist and SCOPE editor in chief, outside a hotel conference room in San Francisco during a scientific meeting. I had already written one book based on findings from a SCOPE project

Under Ground

and at the time was writing a second.21 Wall began telling me about the soil and sediment project and asked if I would like to get involved. How could I not be interested? Her enthusiasm for her science is infectious, and I’m an obsessive gardener, at least during the brief months when the soils in southwest Montana thaw. Furthermore, I had become fascinated by the link between biodiversity and ecological processes while working on my first SCOPE-sponsored book in the early 1990s. So little was known at that time about the ecological roles of specific soil creatures that SCOPE decided to launch a new effort—Wall’s project—focused specifically on soil and sediments. The first question that occurred to me was would I be able to learn enough about soil life from the results of this second effort to fill a whole book? Wall assured me I would, and she followed up in the months ahead with stacks of journal articles and reports the project teams had produced. That material introduced me to a topic much larger and more significant than I had imagined. Almost 2 years later, in November 2002, I joined more than two dozen project scientists who had gathered at a lodge in Estes Park, Colorado, to synthesize what they had learned about soil and sediment biodiversity, its vulnerability to human activities, and strategies for its future conservation and management.22 That was my first opportunity to mingle with people who “see” below the surface and are aware of and concerned about the underground world. I began to probe for details, to look for situations and stories that would illustrate the work of soil communities and their great relevance to our own well-being. From Estes Park, my explorations of life underground took me to the polar desert of Antarctica, the coastal rain forests of Canada, the rangelands of Yellowstone National Park, the vanishing wetlands of the Mississippi River basin, Dutch pastures, and English sounds. This was not a journey of lament through ruined landscapes but an opportunity to walk and talk with scientists and land managers who are pioneering ways to integrate new knowledge about soil life into efforts to restore, sustain, or monitor the health of our lands and waters. In this book you will hear from a marine ecologist who monitors

Opening the Black Box

the work of burrowing shrimp in Plymouth Sound in hope of gaining more protection for important mud-bottom creatures everywhere in the debate over acceptable fishing practices; learn about researchers in England and the Netherlands who are trying to reverse degradation caused by intensive agriculture on former croplands; follow Canadian forest ecologists as they explore the fate of root fungi vital to forest regeneration in stands logged using controversial “new forestry” techniques; and join ecologists tracking the destructive advance of exotic earthworms through a Minnesota sugar maple forest. The result is not a comprehensive tome on soil ecology but a series of windows to an unseen world that is fascinating in its own right, vital to our well-being, and yet increasingly threatened by our activities. Where possible, I introduce you to the lives and significance of specific creatures or groups of creatures in hopes that you will begin, as I have, to marvel at and perhaps respect the world underground. I have chosen to portray the workings of soil life not in the familiar settings of our lawns and gardens but in contexts that I found unexpected and sometimes startling. My message is that creatures of the mud and dirt lead larger lives and shape the world we experience more powerfully than most of us imagine. Their first service, in fact, was to transform Earth into a planet suitable for life. Some 4.5 billion years ago, swirls of hot interstellar gases and dust began coalescing to form Earth and our solar system.23 For hundreds of millions of years thereafter, massive chunks of rock or ice continued to batter our young planet, periodically melting its crust or boiling away the warm oceans that formed in million-year torrents as the planet cooled. By 3.9 billion years ago, those collisions had grown rare and continents began to rise. Earth was still hot, its atmosphere devoid of free oxygen and lacking a protective ozone layer that could buffer the molecule-shattering ultraviolet radiation from the young sun. Somewhere on the planet, however, life was in the making— perhaps in warm shallow coastal waters, in the open ocean, in hydrothermal vents bubbling from the seafloor, or even deep under-

Under Ground

ground. Wherever it arose, though, this early life itself helped transform Earth into the uniquely habitable planet we enjoy today. By 3 billion years ago, communities dominated by mats of cyanobacteria thrived in the shallow waters of the planet. Cyanobacteria —once called blue-green algae—are ubiquitous in the earth’s soils and waters today, visible in forms ranging from pond scum to living crusts on the desert floor. They pull the nitrogen they need directly from the air and also make their own food through photosynthesis just as green plants do. Using sunlight for energy, these single-celled creatures breathe in carbon dioxide, strip the carbon from it, and use the carbon to assemble sugars and other organic compounds needed to build and fuel life. In the process, the microbes discard the oxygen molecules from the carbon dioxide, creating what paleontologist Richard Fortey calls “the most precious waste in the firmament.”24 Over a billion or so years, the exhalations of microbes created the earth’s oxygen-rich atmosphere and protective ozone layer that allowed more complex life to evolve. Ancient microbes probably transformed the land surface as well as the air. At some point, cyanobacteria and other microbes emerged from the shallow waters onto the inhospitable shores, forming themselves into rich slimes, mats, and crusts that protected them from drying. The organic acids these one-celled life forms secreted helped to speed the weathering of parent rock to sand, silt, and clay and added organic matter to the nascent soil. The sticky slimes would have stabilized this loose material against erosion and allowed the first soils to accumulate.25 With the so-called Cambrian Explosion 530 million years ago, animal life came into its own, arising and proliferating in the waters and muck of the seafloor. Some 400 million years ago, the descendents of that explosion began to emerge onto land. In the vanguard were the ancestors of many of today’s underground dwellers—tiny flatworms, springtails, mites, pseudoscorpions, spiderlike creatures, and the scurrying predecessors of modern insects (many of which live part or all of their lives underground). By 350 million years ago, the first

Opening the Black Box

green plants arose, and together with microbes and animals helped to drive creation of the vital soil systems we rely on today. As the roots of plants and their microbial followers pushed ever deeper into the soil, the carbon dioxide they exhaled reacted with rainwater, creating acids that helped to weather the rock of the earth’s crust into sand, silt, and clay minerals. Those minerals, combined with air, water, and organic matter from decaying plant and animal material, along with living organisms, are the key constituents of soil.26 It takes hundreds to thousands of years to create soil from rock, depending on its hardness; sandstone or shale clearly yields faster than granite. The process of soil formation is so slow relative to the human lifespan that it seems unrealistic to consider soil a renewable resource. By one estimate, it takes 200–1,000 years to regenerate an inch of lost topsoil.27 That is one reason both ecologists and agronomists become alarmed at farming or construction practices or other human activities that promote excessive erosion of topsoil. Scientists classify the earth’s soils, like its life forms, into an intricate and constantly shifting taxonomy. There are 11 major orders of soil, from the dark, fertile Mollisols of temperate grasslands to the highly weathered yellow Oxisols of the humid tropics. Within these orders are numerous subcategories encompassing tens of thousands of distinct soil series worldwide, more than 13,000 in the United States alone. Each soil series is equivalent to a biological species, and the “profile” of its horizontal layers or “horizons” represents a unique interaction of climate and life with parent rocks and topography in a specific place through time. The result is a soil with unique texture, structure, organic matter content, and living communities.28 In turn, the character of the soil helps determine whether we encounter fir forests, grassy savannas, or sagebrush above, and whether the land can be converted to grow wheat or tomatoes or oranges. Until recent decades, soil science focused primarily on agriculture, and only the organic-rich upper horizons to the depth of crop roots were considered soil. Now the definition of soil is being pushed ever deeper into the earth by scientists concerned with everything from the influence of deeply rooted plants and deep-dwelling microbes

Under Ground

to groundwater supplies and the fate of pollutants. Some disciplines define the lower limit of the soil at about 6 feet, whereas others see the zone of biological influence extending 30 feet or even hundreds of feet into the earth’s crust.29 Increasingly, scientists recognize that life deep underground can influence everything from the quality of our water supplies to the character of life aboveground. If more effort has in the past been spent classifying the soils of the earth than examining the work of the living communities within, that is changing rapidly, and the modern efforts to shed light on the black box of the soil are the focus of this book. Paradoxically, the belowground life that we have long ignored or taken for granted is not only more important for our survival, but arguably as bizarre and alien as anything we are likely to find in the dust, ice, or seas of another planet. It seems fitting then to begin the story of life underground with a visit to scientists who are probing the soils of the most Mars-like place on our planet, a continent once lush and temperate until geologic forces drove it into its present position at the end of the Earth.

Opening the Black Box

UNDER GROUND:

How Creatures of Mud and Dirt Shape Our World By Yvonne Baskin Available wherever books and e-books are sold Island Press | Amazon | Barnes & Noble | Your Local Independent Bookstore

What readers are saying about Under Ground: “Accessible and enjoyable, this is a book for ecologists and anyone curious about the world we walk on.” —Amazon reader “This is a model of science writing for the layperson.” —Amazon reader “Baskin manages to accomplish an explanation of basic soil ecology, an appreciation of its relevance to present environmental concerns, and the current research in the field succinctly and clearly.” —Goodreads reader “First rate introduction to soil ecology, the fascinating things that happen underground and how they relate to our life above.” —Goodreads reader What comes next: Chapter 2. Where Nematodes Are Lions Chapter 3. Of Ferns, Bears, and Slime Molds Chapter 4. The Power of Ecosystem Engineers Chapter 5. Plowing the Seabed Chapter 6. Microbes, Muck, and Dead Zones Chapter 7. Fungi and the Fate of Forests Chapter 8. Grazers, Grass, and Microbes Chapter 9. Restoring Power to the Soil

islandpress.org | 800.621.2736

Paper | 9781597261180 | $30.00 E-book | 9781597269384 | $29.99