Grow Stronger Relationships with Direct Mail
Scan the code or visit usps.com/directresults to start elevating your marketing with direct mail. ©2026 United States Postal Service®. All Rights Reserved. The Eagle Logo is among the many trademarks of the U.S. Postal Service®.
November 9, 2026 • Vol. 104 No. 17
Contents News & Markets
Special Report
Idea Exchange
8
21
37
Closer Look: Top 50 Commercial Lines Leaders
Social Inflation Drives Surge in Commercial Auto Liability Claims
14
23
Ask the Insurance Recruiter: How Is AI Being Used in Insurance Recruiting?
25
The Competitive Advantage: Insurance: Is There Any Value?
27
Is It Covered?: Insurance Isn’t Enough
Spotlight: Insurance AI’s Next Test: Can Carriers Trust the Data?
PHP Security Flaws Highlight Potential Systemic Risk Aggregation for Cyber Insurers
22
Closer Look: Top 50 Personal Lines Leaders
Cyber Direct Premiums Are Up but Majority of Policies Are Endorsements: NAIC
Spotlight: Finding the Best Defense to Protect Against Cargo Theft
42
44 46
28
Emerging Risks to Watch: Geolocation Data, Extreme Heat, and Passive Homes
32
Minding Your Business: Revenue Quality: All Dollars Are Not the Same
Special Report: Managing Safety Begins Before the Crash BRONZE Best Agencies to Work For • East: Evertree Insurance • Midwest: Robertson Ryan Insurance • South Central: BKCW Insurance • Southeast: Riemer Insurance Group • West: Morris & Garritano
48 50
Closing Quote: Unquoted Is a Status, Not a Verdict
38
Premium Finance Directory
Departments 6 Opening Note 4 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
10 Figures
12 Declarations
16 People
20 Business Moves
INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
Built for Growth. Powered by Independence. A network with one goal for the last 49 years: helping our members thrive. Learn more at Ironpeak.com
Build equity value while remaining 100% independent. Increase profit-sharing revenue with enhanced incentives for profitable growth. Win more new business through optimized markets. Grow top-line commission revenue.
Opening Note Write the Editor: awells@insurancejournal.com
Chairman of the Board Mark Wells | mwells@wellsmedia.com Chief Executive Officer Joshua Carlson | jcarlson@insurancejournal.com
ADMINISTRATION / CIRCULATION
Is Shopping Personal Lines Finally Slowing Down?
A
re agencies seeing fewer requests to shop their coverage? According to a recent survey by JD Power, moderating insurance rates have led to a more stable shopping environment among consumers. “As rate actions moderate and premium increases begin to stabilize, consumers are finding fewer opportunities for meaningful savings through switching carriers,” JD Power noted in its Q3 2026 Signals Intelligence for Personal Lines Insurance report. But while shopping volumes are normalizing, the comparison-shopping behaviors developed during the recent market cycle are likely to remain a lasting feature of the insurance landscape, JD Power noted. Auto insurance shopping increased quarter to quarter and is flat year over year, while “switching” increased considerably. The overall shopping rate increased 13.2% from Q2, while switching carriers went up 5.1%. Auto shopping growth has slowed significantly from the elevated levels observed during 2024 and 2025, JD Power said. Home insurance shopping and switching both increased, and while renter insurance shopping is up, switching increased quarter to quarter but is down versus last year. Shopping for home insurance went up 7.7%, and switching went up 3.0%. Renters insurance shopping is up 6.5% in Q3, while switching is up 3.9%. “Property shopping has cooled more sharply, with periods of negative year-over-year growth reflecting reduced urgency among consumers to seek alternative coverage options,” JD Power added. Since Signals launched in 2020, pandemic-driven cost pressures pushed premiums and shopping higher, while widespread rate increases initially limited switching. As pricing stabilized and carriers resumed pursuing growth, switching rose, while shopping has stabilized somewhat, reflecting levels still elevated compared to earlier periods. Is this the new norm, and could AI agents like Meta Muse drive shopping and switching even higher by helping to make it easier for consumers to find better rates? JD Power says that monitoring shopping and especially switching will remain critical for carriers and agents through Q4 2026 and into 2027. Will these trends continue, or will they begin to level off? What’s happening in your agency now? What’s to come in 2027? Thank you to this issue's sponsor, Liberty Mutual.
Andrea Wells V.P. of Content 6 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
Chief Financial Officer Terry Freeburg | tfreeburg@wellsmedia.com Circulation Manager Elizabeth Duffy | eduffy@wellsmedia.com Staff Accountant Sarah Kersbergen | skersbergen@wellsmedia.com
EDITORIAL
V.P. of Content Andrea Wells | awells@insurancejournal.com Executive Editor Emeritus Andrew Simpson | asimpson@wellsmedia.com National Editor Chad Hemenway | chemenway@insurancejournal.com Southeast Editor William Rabb | wrabb@insurancejournal.com South Central Editor/Midwest Editor Ezra Amacher | eamacher@insurancejournal.com West Editor Don Jergler | djergler@insurancejournal.com International Editor L.S. Howard | lhoward@insurancejournal.com Content Editor Allen Laman | alaman@wellsmedia.com Assistant Editors Jahna Jacobson | jjacobson@insurancejournal.com Kimberly Tallon | ktallon@carriermanagement.com Columnists & Contributors Contributors: Dmitry Borovoy, Elizabeth Blosfieldt Columnists: Chris Burand, Mary Newgard, Catherine Oak, Bill Schoeffler, Lee Shavel, Bill Wilson
SALES / MARKETING
Chief Marketing Officer Julie Tinney | jtinney@insurancejournal.com West Sales Dena Kaplan | dkaplan@insurancejournal.com Romeo Valdez | rvaldez@insurancejournal.com Kelly DeLaMora | kdelamora@wellsmedia.com South Central Sales Mindy Trammell | mtrammell@insurancejournal.com Southeast and East Sales (except for NY, PA, CT) Howard Simkin | hsimkin@insurancejournal.com Midwest Sales Lisa Whalen | (800) 897-9965 x180 East Sales (NY, PA and CT only) Dave Molchan | (800) 897-9965 x145 Advertising Coordinator Erin Burns | eburns@insurancejournal.com Insurance Markets Manager Kristine Honey | khoney@insurancejournal.com Marketing Director Derence Walk | dwalk@insurancejournal.com
DESIGN / WEB / VIDEO
Graphic Designer Chris Johnson Web Team Lead Josh Whitlow | jwhitlow@insurancejournal.com Ad Ops Specialist Jeff Cardrant | jcardrant@insurancejournal.com Web Developer Terrance Woest | twoest@wellsmedia.com Web Developer Jason Chipp | jchipp@wellsmedia.com Digital Content Manager Ashley Cochrane | acochrane@insurancejournal.com Videographer/Editor Ashley Waldrop | awaldrop@insurancejournal.com
ACADEMY OF INSURANCE
Director Patrick Wraight | pwraight@ijacademy.com Online Training Coordinator George Jack | gjack@ijacademy.com
SUBSCRIPTIONS:
Call (800) 897-9965
or visit ijmag.com/subscribe Insurance Journal, The National Property/Casualty Magazine (ISSN: 00204714) is published 18 times annually by Wells Media Group, Inc., 3570 Camino del Rio North, Suite 100, San Diego, CA 92108-1747. Periodicals Postage Paid at San Diego, CA and at additional mailing offices. SUBSCRIPTION RATES: $17.95 per copy, $27.95 per special issue copy, $195 per year in the U.S., $295 per year all other countries. DISCLAIMER: While the information in this publication is derived from sources believed reliable and is subject to reasonable care in preparation and editing, it is not intended to be legal, accounting, tax, technical or other professional advice. Readers are advised to consult competent professionals for application to their particular situation. Copyright 2026 Wells Media Group, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Content may not be photocopied, reproduced or redistributed without written permission. Insurance Journal is a publication of Wells Media Group, Inc. POSTMASTER: Send change of address form to Insurance Journal, Circulation Dept, PO Box 708, Northbrook, IL 60065-9967 ARTICLE REPRINTS: Contact (800) 897-9965 x125 or visit insurancejournal.com/reprints
PROTECTING SMALL BUSINESS OWNERS SHOULDNT BE HARD.
A FEW CLICKS. DONE!
Mish Ganssle, RMG Insurance John DeStefano, American Picture Framing
AM Best A++ Rating Ward’s Top 50 2001-2026 96.7% Claims Satisfaction 120+ Niche Industries
Now you can access the value, strength, and service excellence of Philadelphia Insurance Companies to protect your small business customers. PHLYBOP offers a full suite of services to businesses in 150+ different classifications across multiple business categories. And now, PHLYs online portal makes submissions easy. A few clicks. Done!
CALL 855.ASK.PHLY OR VISIT PHLYBOP.COM
RETAIL & SERVICE I RESTAURANTS I CONTRACTORS I OFFICES I WHOLESALE I HABITATIONAL* I LESSORS RISK* I MORE THAN 150 ELIGIBLE CLASSIFICATIONS Philadelphia Insurance Companies is the marketing name for the property and casualty insurance operations of Philadelphia Consolidated Holding Corp., a member of Tokio Marine Group. All admitted coverages are written by Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Company. Coverages are subject to actual policy language. © 2026 Philadelphia Consolidating Holding Corp., All Rights Reserved. * Not available in all states.
News & Markets
Social Inflation Drives Surge in Commercial Auto Liability Claims
A
ccording to a recent report from AM Best, commercial auto liability insurance coverage has continued to bear the brunt of rising litigation costs, outpacing economic inflation. Social inflation has negatively affected commercial auto liability ultimate claim costs for several years, which is evident by looking at average claim severity. Economic inflation from 2014 to 2024 averaged 2.8% annually. Over the same period, commercial auto liability insurance loss payments for the first 12 months have trended upward at 6.4% annually—more than double the annual increase of economic inflation, AM Best said. AM Best defines social inflation as the rising cost of insurance claims that exceeds general economic inflation, driven
8 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
by societal and legal trends like higher jury awards, increased litigation, and expanded definitions of liability. Commercial auto liability losses are capped by policy limits, typically $1 million. Individual auto claims resulting in loss payments exceeding that threshold will fall to an umbrella policy if that type of coverage is in place. Through 2018, umbrella pricing tracked closely with general liability pricing. However, as social inflation began to impact commercial auto claims, and those claims spilled into umbrella coverages, the pricing on the latter has diverged from general liability, becoming more costly, and has yet to return to its prior level. Historically, umbrella pricing followed closely with general liability, but more recently, David Blades, associate director at
AM Best, said, “As social inflation began to impact commercial auto claims, and those claims spilled into the umbrella coverage, umbrella pricing diverged from general liability, becoming more costly.” Among the report’s other highlights: • Claims being open longer leaves more exposure to jury precedent, in addition to most likely resulting in elevated claim adjustment expenses. • After adjusting for settlement rates, commercial auto claim frequency has increased over the past 10 years, which also creates a gap in what has been paid and what is expected to be paid. • Tort reforms may help. Sweeping tort reforms in Florida have helped offset excessive litigation costs, resulting in average paid claim severity to trend downward. INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
Figures
45%
The amount U.S. homeowner policies, averaged at the county level, have gone up in a decade, adjusted for inflation. Nebraska has seen a rise of 79%. Home insurance rates have risen so dramatically over the last decade that the average premium now exceeds the average property-tax bill in two-thirds of U.S. counties, according to an analysis by Bloomberg Intelligence.
960
The number of megawatts that would be generated by an Indiana nuclear plant being discussed by American Electric Power Co. and Amazon.com Inc. The organizations are evaluating plans to build using a new reactor design that would rely on unproven technology while potentially advancing efforts to promote next-generation fission at a retired AEP coal plant. The proposed facility would use 12 small reactors supplied by X-Energy Inc., which is another partner in the effort.
$3 billion The cost of privately insured losses from wind and storm surge during Hurricane Isaias, according to catastrophe risk management firm Karen Clark & Co. AM Best said the Category 2 hurricane, which came ashore on the Florida Panhandle near the resort city of Destin on Oct. 9, will likely turn out to be an “earnings event” for insurers. Losses will be well below the level to make the storm a capital or solvency event, said the insurance industry rating agency.
10 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
16
The number of people arrested by New York state investigators, who accuse the group of staging car crashes and faking injuries to collect nearly $500,000 from insurers. Governor Kathy Hochul recently made auto insurance fraud a focus to lower costs for drivers. The cases include coordinated collisions and allegedly fabricated injury claims in New York City and upstate. Insurers reported 43,811 suspected incidents of motor vehicle insurance fraud to the state’s Insurance Frauds Bureau in 2025.
$495,200
The amount of fines levied against insurance companies, agencies, and producers for insurance law violations between April and August in Washington state, as reported by Commissioner Patty Kuderer’s office. The two largest fines were against USAA Casualty Insurance Co. and Allstate Vehicle and Property Insurance Co. for violations in how the companies handled policyholder claims. INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
! ! " ! ! !
Declarations
IT Financial Fraud Uptick
Quake Coverage Quandary
AI and the Air
— Christine Mapes, cyber managing director and counsel at insurer Travelers, commenting on an uptick in fraud and the evolution of high-tech tactics.
— Missouri Department of Commerce and Insurance Director Angela Nelson discussing recommended earthquake insurance for families living in Missouri‘s primary fault-line areas, including southeastern Missouri and the St. Louis region. Residents already face higher annual premiums to protect their homes, DCI reported. Earthquake damage is not covered in standard homeowners or renters insurance policies.
— Carlos Gamarra, vice president for energy, air, and IT, Houston Advanced Research Center. A new report from the center found Texas’ rapidly growing data center industry could reverse much of the state’s progress on air quality by the end of the decade.
Protecting Mobile Homes
Rough Winter on the Pacific Coast
“Now what we’re seeing is more IT fraud manipulation, the bank fraud manipulation, and the token theft. Instead of them engaging with the victim by asking them to click on a link, they’re actually getting them to turn over the keys to the kingdom voluntarily in a lot of instances…The thing that surprises people the most when I talk to them about claims recently versus three years ago or five years ago is the sheer volume of financial fraud and business email compromise (BEC) that we’re seeing.”
“Evasive companies that cancel all their policies and want to re-domesticate are not committed to Floridians and have no place in our state.”
— Florida Insurance Commissioner Mike Yaworsky, announcing that he had forced St. Petersburg, Florida-based American Mobile Insurance Exchange to surrender its certificate of authority. The action brought some closure to a turbulent period for both the exchange and property owners and for Florida insurance agents looking to place mobile home policies. The company was launched six years ago but exited the distressed Florida market about four years later.
12 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
“We see the numbers, and we understand why families are making the difficult decision to drop this coverage…When you are forced to choose between groceries or gas and an extra insurance premium, the immediate need almost always wins.”
“We’ve already seen some significant impacts in the state, but it’s most likely going to get significantly worse in terms of erosion and flooding and wave impacts and damage. It’s lining up to be a really significant winter for California.”
— Patrick Barnard, research director at UC Santa Cruz’s Center for Coastal Climate Resilience. The compounding shocks of wildfire and erosion are testing residents living on the edge of the Pacific along the California Coast. The powerful El Niño weather system is bringing damaging waves and worsening beach erosion to the region. Governor Gavin Newsom recently declared a statewide emergency as the state prepares for more rainfall, landslides, and coastal erosion.
“What we are showcasing here is that there is a significant increase in different pollutant emissions that needs to be addressed because otherwise this could have strong implications for the population and environment. We need to treat data centers as the industrial facilities they are…to hold them accountable to the same industrial and power generation emissions standards that produced Texas progress.”
Trump Tariff Suit
“No president should have the power to pull a dormant statute off the shelf and use it to impose sweeping tariffs or import bans without the limits Congress required.”
— Sara Albrecht, CEO of the Liberty Justice Center, which has filed a lawsuit in the U.S. Court of International Trade in New York on behalf of U.S. food importer Gellert Global Group. The suit seeks to stop the Trump administration’s latest tariffs on imports from Canada, claiming Trump has used shifting legal rationales and invoked rarely used U.S. laws in a persistent effort to claim authority over tariff power that the U.S. Constitution assigns to Congress.
INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
Good service is hard to describe. But you know it when you see it. The same goes for a great insurance partner. Service businesses know that great service isn’t just about what you do — it’s about how you treat people. That’s the same approach we bring to every partnership, with flexible coverage, specialized professional liability options, and underwriting that understands what makes service businesses different. See why agents choose EMC for service businesses
Learn more ©Employers Mutual Casualty Company 2026. All rights reserved.
News & Markets PHP Security Flaws Highlight Potential Systemic Risk Aggregation for Cyber Insurers By L.S. Howard
R
ecently discovered security flaws in PHP programming language, used by many websites globally, has highlighted the potential for cyber risk aggregation, which has long worried insurers and made them reluctant to aggressively increase their risk appetites, according to ratings agency AM Best. In three separate commentaries, AM Best, cyber risk analysis firm CyberCube, and Moody’s Ratings all highlighted how artificial intelligence is accelerating the discovery of such software flaws and increasing the potential for systemic cyber risks that could simultaneously hit many policyholders across the globe. Vulnerabilities affecting PHP (formally known as PHP: Hypertext Preprocessor) “could allow attackers to gain access to websites and steal sensitive information, as well as create backdoors that can let them access the sites in the future,” AM Best said in a press release announcing the publication of its commentary titled “PHP Vulnerabilities Raises Concerns of Systemic Event for Cyber Insurers.” After PHP’s maintainers on Oct. 21 provided urgent fixes for two critical flaws— known together as PHP2Shell—attack attempts surged within hours and have now run into the millions, said CyberCube, noting that as of Oct. 23 no break-ins had been confirmed. However, complacency is not an option, CyberCube said.
Insurable Losses From PHP Event?
Although governments and security agencies urged organizations to make immediate updates or take their systems offline, AM Best warned the event could have “a longer tail as threat actors may wait for some time before they decide to
act; the tail could also be lengthened as issues play out in court.” CyberCube predicted there could be some insurable losses from medium and large enterprises breached through PHP servers that have not been updated. “In CyberCube’s opinion, this is a long-tail risk that will shrink as fixes are installed, rather than a single catastrophe.” “Cyber insurers and their customers remain concerned about the use of frontier artificial intelligence models by hackers and cyber criminals seeking to develop exploitation techniques faster than software providers can identify vulnerabilities,” said Anandi Kotecha, director, Industry Research, AM Best, in a press statement accompanying the report. These types of programming vulnerabilities are being exposed by AI models that can now exploit previously discovered vulnerabilities “considered too complex for humans to utilize, resulting in a race with those looking to patch versus those looking to exploit,” AM Best said. “PHP2Shell is one of the clearest signs yet that AI is making older, overlooked flaws easier to find. Code that sat flawed
CyberCube explained that PHP is the software that runs the code behind roughly 70% of websites. Two critical flaws in the software “can allow an attacker to take control of a web server, or read passwords and other secrets from its memory, without the need to log in. However, the problem extends beyond websites. In many cases, PHP is built into products that customers cannot fix themselves and may not even know it is there.” 14 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
and untouched for more than a decade was turned into a working exploit with AI’s help. Most of the exploit code now circulating publicly doesn’t work, but the barrier to building one that does is falling fast,” according to William Altman, director of Cyber Threat Intelligence Services at CyberCube, in an emailed statement. CyberCube cautioned that the absence of confirmed break-ins is no reason for complacency. “Successful attacks leave almost no trace, so intrusions made now may only show up as claims weeks or months later,” the company said. “As attackers can steal passwords or plant hidden access now and use it later, some claims will surface long after the first attacks, making it harder to tie losses to a single event or policy period,” CyberCube added. Altman warned that insurers should expect more events like this—when a single flaw could affect many policyholders at once. In emailed comments from Moody’s Ratings, Leroy Terrelonge, senior vice president, Cyber Credit Risk, Digital Economy Group, said the PHP security flaws illustrate how AI can reduce the expertise and effort needed to weaponize software vulnerabilities. “This will put further pressure on organizations that already struggle to
continued on page 22
INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
OUR JOURNEY CONTINUES WITH FRESH WIND IN OUR SAILS.
Rated A+ by AM Best, FSC XV As a proud member of the Odyssey Group family, our new visual identity now reflects our shared foundation. While our logo has evolved, our disciplined underwriting, long-term relationships and financial strength remain the same. Discover what we can do for you at HudsonInsGroup.com.
An Odyssey Group | Fairfax Company
People National
Chubb Limited made three
leadership appointments within its global claims organization. Lisa Wilson has been named head of North America claims, overseeing all aspects of North America commercial and personal Lisa Wilson lines claims and services. Wilson joined Chubb in 2023, most recently serving as Chubb’s deputy head of North America claims. Jamie Trish was named global claims operations officer, responsible for the global claims operational infrastructure. Trish Jamie Trish joined Chubb in 2024 as claims transformation officer before becoming Chubb’s global transformation officer. Norm Rafsol was appointed global claims technical director. Rafsol joined Chubb in 2007 as senior vice president, professional Norm Rafsol liability underwriting. He most recently held the role of head of financial lines, cyber claims and claims segmentation, with oversight of Canada and Bermuda claims. He has also managed casualty claims and Chubb’s regional claims executives.
Michael Crowley joined Marsh as senior enterprise
risk advisor for digital infra-
structure. In this newly created role, Crowley will help digital infrastructure Michael Crowley clients manage risk and build resilience. Crowley joins Marsh from Meta, where he spent 10 years as a risk manager, leading the company’s insurance and risk management programs, including an owner-controlled insurance program for its data centers. He previously served as data center construction sourcing manager at Facebook and Amazon Web Services.
WTW appointed Darrel Beaton director of under-
writing within the company’s insurance consulting and technology (ICT) business. Based in Austin, Texas, Beaton joins WTW Darrel Beaton from Effectus Insurance, where he served as chief underwriting officer. Beaton has over 30 years of experience in commercial underwriting, product development, portfolio management, program design, and underwriting leadership.
Parametrix appointed Tresa Stephens head of U.S.
underwriting, leading U.S. underwriting and supporting broader product strategy and development. Stephens has over 15 years of experience, most recently serving as head of cyber, tech and Tresa Stephens media – North
16 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
America at Allianz Commercial. She previously held senior roles at Argo Group, Chubb, and Hiscox.
Lockton, headquartered in Kansas City, appointed Vince Gaffigan to lead its U.S. casualty practice. With over 30 years of casualty experience, Gaffigan has Vince Gaffigan held several leadership positions across Lockton’s business. Based in St. Louis, Missouri, Gaffigan will partner with Jessica Cullen, whose Lockton leadership role is expanding as executive vice president, U.S. casualty – excess and product solutions, to focus on advancing product innovation, analytics, claims advisory, and technical expertise. Chubb Limited named Sean Ringsted as chief scientist
and executive vice president, Chubb Group. In this newly created role, Ringsted will focus on and have responsibility for the company’s artificial intelligence, data, and analytics strategy and initiatives worldwide. Ringsted has over three decades of experience at Chubb and its predecessor, ACE Group. He most recently served as executive vice president, Chubb Group, and chief digital business officer and has led the company’s AI efforts globally.
Technical Risk Underwriters (TRU), the Ryan Specialty
Underwriting Managers’ managing general underwriter specializing in complex first-party risks for the construction
industry, made two leadership promotions. Earlier this year, Nick Hays was promoted to president. Hays joined TRU in 2023 and has been instrumental in shaping the company’s risk management platform. Hays is a former Navy SEAL, Fortune 500 solutions architect, and performance coach for NBA and NFL organizations. Aaron Reissner was promoted to executive vice president. Reissner has been a part of the team since 2012. He has expertise in construction risks.
East
The Virginia Workers’ Compensation Commission
named two new deputy commissioners, Adam L. Katz and Jason A. Mullins. Both Katz and Mullins will serve as administrative law judges under the Virginia Workers’ Compensation Act and hold evidentiary hearings. Since 2010, Deputy Commissioner Katz has served in the Virginia Attorney General’s Office, representing the Commonwealth in workers’ compensation claims before the Virginia Workers’ Compensation Commission and the Court of Appeals of Virginia. He previously represented employers and insurers in workers’ compensation claims before the Georgia State Board of Workers’ Compensation. Katz will be based in the commission’s Richmond headquarters. Deputy Commissioner Mullins was previously a partner with PennStuart, where he focused on the defense of workers’ compensation claims. Prior to joining PennStuart, he
continued on page 18
INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
Leading Commercial and Personal Lines Coverage COMMERCIAL LINES General Liability, Excess, Professional Lines, Inland Marine, Garage, Flood, Property, and Package Solutions
PERSONAL LINES Homeowners, Personal Umbrella/Liability, Personal Article Floaters, and Unscheduled Personal Property
SCAN QR CODE TO CONTACT US FOR MORE INFORMATION specialtyprogramgroup.com/wholesale
Specialty Program Group LLC doing business in California as SPG Insurance Solutions, License No 0L09546
People continued from page 16
represented both claimants and employers in workers’ compensation matters throughout Virginia. Mullins will serve in the commission’s Harrisonburg office.
OneShield, headquartered in Marlborough, Massachusetts, appointed Terry Brown as chief insurance officer. In this newly created role, Brown will shape the company’s AI-native capabilities and bring them to market. Brown began her career in the independent agency system, then spent 17 years at Cincinnati Equitable Insurance Company, rising to vice president of information systems. She moved to the software side in 2005 and was named president at the core systems vendor in 2016. Selective Insurance Group Inc., headquartered in Short
Hills, New Jersey, appointed
Vaibhav (Vaib) Kalia as exec-
utive vice president and chief investment officer. Kalia has served as interim Vaibhav Kalia chief investment officer since June. Kalia oversees Selective’s investment portfolio and investment-related matters of the organization’s employee benefit plans. Kalia also chairs the management investment committee, setting and executing the company’s investment strategy. Kalia joined Selective in 2014 and most recently served as senior vice president, senior portfolio manager, and head of fixed income.
Selective Insurance Group Inc. also hired Jacob E. “Jake” Rothfuss as executive vice
president and president, standard lines. Rothfuss will lead Selective’s standard commercial lines and standard personal lines businesses. Rothfuss is expected to assume the role no later than April 2027 when Jacob E. Rothfuss his current contractual obligations end. Rothfuss will join Selective from Velocity Risk Underwriters, part of Ryan Specialty Underwriting Managers, where he has served as CEO since 2023. He joined the organization in 2018 as chief operating officer and head of systematized risk and was appointed president in 2020.
ATRI Insurance Services LLC hired Kylor Bellistri
as assistant vice president, financial institutions. Based in New York, Bellistri spent nearly 10 years with Chubb, most recently serving as a senior underwriter. His appointment is part of ATRI’s continued investment in expanding management and professional liability capabilities.
Midwest
Ohio Mutual named Brenton Kratzer assistant vice presi-
dent, internal audit, succeeding Kristy Kinley, who will be retiring in December. Kratzer has over 15 years of internal and external audit experience, including in the property and casualty insurance industry. His background spans financial, regulatory, operational, and technology audits.
18 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
Opterrix, a risk intelligence platform serving the property and casualty insurance industry, promoted Rich Krupar to chief commercial officer (CCO). Previously vice president of catastrophe and insurance solutions at Opterrix, Krupar’s expanded role includes leading the company’s commercial strategy, growth, and revenue initiatives. Karen Spangler joined Alliant Insurance Services
as vice president within its employee benefits group. The Chicago, Illinois-based consultant will partner with employers across the Midwest to develop innovative benefits strategies that address evolving healthcare challenges. Spangler has experience advising large, jumbo, and multinational employers across a broad range of industries. Before joining Alliant, Spangler was a principal with Mercer. Alliant is headquartered in Irvine, California.
West
SAGE Program Underwriters, headquartered in Sparks, Nevada, hired Ken Kaufmann as
a senior vice president. He will help SAGE expand its distribution Ken Kaufmann network, identify new program opportunities, and serve as a field underwriter. Kaufmann has more than 10 years of insurance experience with a focus on workers’ compensation in retail and wholesale insurance platforms. He was previously at Paragon Insurance.
California Department of Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara made five
appointments to two statewide governing boards. Guinevere Doner and Jonathan Parfrey join the COIN Advisory Board as new members, and Deborah La Franchi has been reappointed to the board. The COIN Advisory Board provides guidance to the Commissioner and the California Organized Investment Network (COIN), which was established in 1996 to guide insurers on making financially sound investments. Colbie McRae and Vinh Truong have been reappointed to the Curriculum Board, which oversees the development of pre-licensing and continuing education curriculum for agents and brokers, as well as developing standards for providers and instructors who offer courses and training to licensed agents and brokers.
Aspire General Insurance,
headquartered in Rancho Cucamonga, California, promoted
Isaac Adams
Isaac Adams
Kelson Hughes
Kelson Hughes
from vice president of product to senior vice president of product. Adams previously worked as an agency owner and as an acocunt executive. Aspire also promoted
from assistant vice president of product management to vice president of product management. INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
STRENGTH IN EVERY STEP
When risk challenges your business, you need more than an insurance carrier. You need an ally. At Safety National®, we deliver a suite of risk management services, a dedicated service team to address every client need, and specialized expertise in highexposure complex claims to help secure the best possible outcomes.
Discover partnership beyond the policy at SafetyNational.com.
Workers’ Compensation | General Liability | Public Entity Liability Auto Liability | Excess Cyber
Business Moves CopperPoint Insurance Co., General Indemnity Group
National
The Hartford, Equitable
The Hartford completed its buy of Equitable’s employee benefits business to bolster the insurer’s growth in the small and midsized employer segment. The move will bring in about $500 million in premium in non-medical benefits, as well as Equitable’s employee benefits technology. The acquired portfolio includes group life, disability, paid family and medical leave, supplemental health, as well as dental and vision coverage, plus about 300 employees.
EC-Council, Cyber Insurance Academy
Cybersecurity training and certification organization EC-Council has acquired Cyber Insurance Academy, the credentialing body for the cyber and AI insurance industries. Cyber Insurance Academy will continue operating under its existing brand and leadership as an EC-Council company. Co-founder Guy Simkin will remain CEO, while co-founder Asaf Armoni will continue as chief technology and operating officer. Cyber insurance will remain the Academy’s focus while its capabilities expand into AI risk, emerging technology risk, and role-based technology education.
East
Alliant Insurance Services, Melcher & Prescott
California-based specialty insurance broker Alliant Insurance Services has 20 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
expanded its presence in New England through the acquisition of Melcher & Prescott in Laconia, New Hampshire. Melcher & Prescott will operate as Alliant Insurance Services. Founded in 1862, Melcher & Prescott provides commercial insurance, employee benefits, and personal life and health insurance to businesses and individuals across New England and surrounding areas. Irvine, California-based national broker Alliant offers insurance, risk management, reinsurance, and employee benefits. The Melcher & Prescott acquisition is its first in New Hampshire.
Novatae Risk Group, Specialized Program Solutions
Novatae Risk Group, the wholesale division of World Insurance Associates, acquired Specialized Program Solutions (SPS), a managing general agency in Chester, New Jersey. Founded in 2022, SPS specializes in underwriting, marketing, and program administration for long-haul trucking risks throughout the U.S. Terms of the Aug. 1 transaction were not disclosed. Iselin, New Jersey-based Novatae Risk Group is a specialty insurance brokerage, managing general agency, and program manager providing brokers and their clients with insurance products and services for complex and hard-to-place risks across property, casualty, workers’ compensation, cyber, professional, management, construction, environmental, garage, inland marine/ocean marine, and more.
CopperPoint Insurance Co., a workers’ compensation and commercial insurance provider based in Phoenix, Arizona, acquired Boston, Massachusetts-based General Indemnity Group (GIG). The sale includes GIG’s subsidiaries United Casualty & Surety Insurance Co. (UCS), surety placement platform BOSS Bonds, and the technology platform SuretyBonds.Market. GIG, founded in 2015, is an insurance holding company specializing in commercial and contract surety. GIG provides bonds facilitating construction, commercial, and public sector projects. GIG’s Boston office will remain the headquarters for the company’s surety operations.
Midwest
Marsh, Accel Holdings
Marsh completed its acquisition of Accel Holdings, a diversified independent insurance and advisory firm headquartered in Waverly, Iowa. Accel will operate within Marsh Agency. Terms of the acquisition were not disclosed. All Accel Group colleagues have joined Marsh Agency and will continue to operate from their current locations. The Accel Group was founded in 1936 and provides commercial and personal insurance, employee benefits, and agribusiness solutions, as well as wealth management and retirement advisory services.
South Central
Porch Insurance Group, Allied Trust
Porch Insurance Group, headquartered in Seattle, Washington, entered into a definitive agreement to acquire Allied Trust’s insurance carrier and managing general agency. Allied Trust, headquartered in Tampa, Florida, is a regional insurance carrier operating in Louisiana, Texas, South Carolina and North Carolina. Louisiana represented almost half of Allied Trust’s 2025 premiums and would be a new state for Porch Group’s Reciprocal. INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
Closer Look: Commercial Lines Leaders Commercial Lines Leaders
Top 50 Commercial Lines Agencies
About the Commercial Lines Leaders: The 2026 Commercial Lines Leaders in this special feature are taken from Insurance Journal’s Top 100 Property/Casualty Independent Agencies as reported in August. This list utilizes only the 2025 commercial lines property/casualty revenue numbers of the independent agencies and brokerages that submitted data to the Top 100 agencies report. For more information on Insurance Journal’s Top 100 Property/Casualty Independent Agencies list, contact awells@insurancejournal.com.
Ranked by Total 2025 Commercial Lines P/C Revenue 2026 Rank Agency Name
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50
2025 Total Commercial Lines P/C Revenue
2025 Total Commercial Lines P/C Premium
Alliant Insurance Services/Confie $2,862,064,373 $19,856,213,037 HUB International Limited $2,394,000,000 $17,600,000,000 Acrisure $1,721,967,000 $14,097,520,000 Lockton $1,705,160,000 $16,111,000,000 BroadStreet Partners $1,526,331,000 $10,000,000,000 USI Insurance Services $1,439,953,777 $11,905,400,000 EPIC Insurance Brokers & Consultants $863,460,000 $5,761,993,000 IMA $667,031,536 $8,799,019,967 Alera Group $667,000,000 Higginbotham $612,175,000 $6,442,000,000 World Insurance Associates LLC $412,000,000 $3,958,000,000 Trucordia Insurance Services LLC $400,269,223 $2,964,957,206 Highstreet Insurance Partners $333,238,677 $1,692,065,753 Hilb Group $333,163,481 ALKEME $295,000,000 $112,500,000 Insurance Office of America Inc. $277,081,677 $2,739,044,727 Keystone Agency Partners LLC $269,280,000 $1,983,800,000 Leavitt Group $241,545,289 $2,093,154,092 Patriot Growth Insurance Services LLC $222,000,000 $1,480,000,000 Relation Insurance Inc. $184,500,000 Heffernan Insurance Brokers $174,314,348 $1,447,331,581 INSURICA Insurance Services LLC $171,810,014 $1,175,158,365 Cross Insurance $166,500,000 $2,600,000,000 Unison Risk Advisors $154,875,000 $1,501,500,000 Inszone Insurance Services $136,302,595 $118,681,796 Sunstar Insurance Group $135,000,000 $1,000,000,000 Hylant $133,212,832 $1,340,000,000 The Liberty Company Insurance Brokers $114,000,000 $154,600,000 OneDigital $108,000,000 $836,000,000 TrueNorth Companies LC $102,483,805 $1,116,028,061 Oakbridge Insurance $98,593,000 $821,612,000 Shepherd Insurance $93,267,400 $681,746,000 Lawley Insurance $86,859,508 $568,651,292 Sterling Seacrest Pritchard $85,310,143 $725,278,053 Signers National LLC $84,017,000 $535,000,000 Turner Surety and Insurance Brokerage $80,475,600 $486,099,300 TowneInsurance $77,767,500 $520,000,000 Scott Insurance $76,153,233 $617,551,631 Bowen, Miclette & Britt Insurance Agency LLC $74,686,379 $497,481,000 Robertson Ryan Insurance $69,352,500 $590,281,145 Marshall + Sterling Enterprises Inc. $67,676,999 $502,397,944 Starkweather & Shepley Insurance Brokerage Inc. $67,012,096 $399,802,453 Reliance Partners LLC $61,428,100 $488,500,000 The Mahoney Group $58,960,838 $433,944,934 Superior Insurance Partners $58,660,000 $515,283,000 Crest Insurance Group $53,247,725 $394,422,733 King Risk Partners $52,914,294 $431,653,582 Christensen Group Inc. $49,818,926 $475,000,000 Moreton & Company $48,033,021 $230,000,000 Hotchkiss Insurance $39,852,000 $273,845,000
INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
2025 Total P/C Revenue
Main Office
$3,965,472,463 $3,096,000,000 $2,197,362,000 $2,658,120,000 $2,005,293,000 $1,584,219,778 $992,623,000 $710,591,168 $775,000,000 $703,094,000 $714,000,000 $587,783,043 $637,631,857 $478,922,504 $325,000,000 $294,715,079 $354,153,000 $431,174,134 $333,300,000 $270,850,000 $200,258,726 $182,893,343 $323,200,000 $187,645,000 $221,196,020 $177,000,000 $142,833,843 $156,000,000 $145,000,000 $133,032,980 $141,233,000 $124,150,400 $113,611,365 $93,939,040 $85,517,000 $80,617,600 $102,878,226 $76,153,233 $82,376,241 $97,299,250 $97,519,264 $91,889,643 $61,428,100 $61,654,227 $91,550,000 $62,176,642 $104,468,946 $55,490,734 $51,443,289 $43,832,000
Irvine, California Chicago, Illinois Grand Rapids, Michigan Kansas City, Missouri Columbus, Ohio Valhalla, New York New York, New York Denver, Colorado Deerfield, Illinois Fort Worth, Texas Iselin, New Jersey Lindon, Utah Traverse City, Michigan Richmond, Virginia Ladera Ranch, California Longwood, Florida Harrisburg, Pennsylvania Cedar City, Utah Ft. Washington, Pennsylvania Chicago, Illinois Walnut Creek, California Oklahoma City, Oklahoma Bangor, Maine Cleveland, Ohio Anaheim, California Memphis, Tennessee Toledo, Ohio Gainesville, Florida Atlanta, Georgia Cedar Rapids, Iowa Alpharetta, Georgia Carmel, Indiana Buffalo, New York Atlanta, Georgia New York, New York Saddle Brook, New Jersey Norfolk, Virginia Lynchburg, Virginia Houston, Texas Milwaukee, Wisconsin Poughkeepsie, New York East Providence, Rhode Island Chattanooga, Tennessee Chandler, Arizona Chicago, Illinois Tucson, Arizona Gainesville, Florida Eden Prairie, Minnesota Salt Lake City, Utah Dallas, Texas
NOVEMBER 9, 2026 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | 21
News & Markets Cyber Direct Premiums Are Up but Majority of Policies Are Endorsements: NAIC By Chad Hemenway
T
he U.S. domestic cyber insurance market has nearly tripled in size since 2020, with endorsement policies accounting for the largest share of policy counts relative to premium. The observations come from a new report generated by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), which said U.S. domestic direct premiums written (DPW) totaled nearly $7.5 billion in 2025, up from $2.75 billion in 2020. Including premium from surplus insurance companies domiciled outside the U.S., DPW reached about $9.5 billion in 2025, up 3.5% over 2024. Research from NAIC found that more than 60% of U.S. cyber premium comes from primary cyber policies, but the majority of policies are endorsements to other commercial policies, “reflecting the widespread practice of bundling modest amounts of cyber protection into other commercial lines rather than purchasing dedicated coverage.” Endorsements are high volume by count but generate low premium. Overall, 2025 domestic policies in force increased 33% over 2024, to about 5.8 million. Endorsement policies are up 53.8%, primary increased 13.6%, and surplus policies are down 45.3%, NAIC said. Endorsement policies make up 4% of DPW in the cyber market, but these policies were nearly 53% of policies in
continued from page 14
patch vulnerabilities in a timely manner. While AI can weaponize vulnerabilities in days, the median Moody’s-rated company takes 87 days to remediate half of known exploited vulnerabilities on its networks,” Terrelonge added. “The incident also highlights how the growing reliance on third-party platforms can create concentrations of cyber risk, allowing vulnerabilities to affect many organizations simultaneously,” he said. “In a recent study, we found that out 22 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
Source: NAIC Report on the Cybersecurity Insurance Market force in 2025. “U.S. cyber is becoming two distinct sub-markets: a surplus lines market writing primary and excess cyber-specific policies, and an admitted market focused on endorsements to other commercial policies,” NAIC noted in the report. Surplus lines carriers now hold nearly two-thirds of all cyber premium. NAIC said the protection gap in cyber remains stark. Estimates of global economic losses from cyber incidents range from $1 billion to $10 billion, with projections that this number will rise considering the rapid escalation of risk brought on by artificial intelligence, maturing ransomware, third-party dependencies, and geopolitical factors. However, only about 1% of global economic cyber losses are covered by insurance, NAIC said.
The cyber insurance market saw a rising loss ratio, but rates continue to go down. The first quarter of 2026 marked the eighth straight quarter of rate reductions, while the cyber loss ratio worsened to 53 in 2025 from 48.7 in 2024. NAIC said claims severity for large and medium-sized businesses increased though claims frequency is down for both. Severity is down for small businesses. “This combination of lower frequency but sharply higher severity at the top of the market might suggest that improved underwriting selection and security controls may be reducing the number of incidents reaching a claim, even as the incidents that do occur, particularly at large organizations, are becoming noticeably more expensive to resolve,” NAIC said in the report.
of Moody’s-rated organizations that experienced a cyber incident, the share of organizations affected by a cyber incident via a third party more than doubled from 19% to 39% between 2020 and 2025.”
“The value provided by cyber insurers in helping clients with forensic analysis, patch management, and re-examining cyber defenses will increase demand for cyber insurance,” the report continued. In addition, AM Best noted that insured losses may extend beyond cyber into directors and officers (D&O) because regulatory and governmental bodies in the EU and the U.S. (including the SEC and the Department of Defense) have requirements for reporting and patching, AM Best continued.
Insurance Protection Gap
AM Best predicted this event would see a significant protection gap between economic and insured losses, “highlighting the importance of cyber insurance.” (Economic losses include the price tag for both insured and uninsured losses.)
INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
Spotlight: Technology
Insurance AI’s Next Test: Can Carriers Trust the Data? By Elizabeth Blosfield
I
nsurance companies are beginning to look toward the next phase of AI adoption with agentic AI and automation, according to Chris Newman, CEO of ACORD Solutions Group, at this year’s InsurTech Connect conference in Las Vegas. However, as AI moves further into insurance decision-making and business INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
operations, insurers need confidence in the data supporting the technology. “I think AI undoubtedly is capable of making very good decisions and evolving things as we’re all seeing in businesses today,” he said. “But the challenge comes with the trust element in terms of can you trust your data.” This means questions of where the information originated, whether sources
are verified, and if a carrier can account for how decisions are made, he said. Newman stressed the need for verified data sources as insurers consider giving AI a greater role in carrying out business functions. Without reliable information, a company risks making decisions that it cannot adequately explain. “The last thing you want from a regulatory point of view is to have decisions being made
by a black box and you can’t then justify why that’s been done,” he said. The need to demonstrate how decisions are reached could become more pressing as regulators scrutinize insurance applications of AI, he suggested. Regulators may not go so far as to prescribe the exact methods carriers must use, but insurers should anticipate being asked to provide
continued on page 24
NOVEMBER 9, 2026 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | 23
Spotlight: Technology continued from page 23
evidence and accountability for their processes. “To support the regulatory side and the compliance side, it’s really important to have that trust layer,” he said. “And then once you’ve got that base layer, obviously AI then comes into its own from the agentic point of view.”
Balancing Automation and Oversight
Newman said getting the harmonization between AI technology and human oversight correct comes down to verified data and keeping a human in the loop. “There are the guardrails that are needed,” he said. “I think that’s going to be required, and it’s a sensible thing to have in place rather than to automate everything without those guardrails in place.” However, insurers are facing another barrier that stems from the tech environments they
already have. “So many of the insurance companies that we’re talking about, particularly in the U.S., have spent incredible amounts of money either building their own systems or acquiring policy administration systems,” he said. “In some respects, they need to preserve their investment in their systems. They’ve spent a lot of money. They’re not just going to change those systems overnight.” Newman described ACORD Solutions Group’s role as helping different systems communicate and converting data into trusted sources and formats that other participants can use. Instead of insisting that every organization migrate to a single new platform, the aim is to accommodate varying levels of digital maturity. He characterized this approach as building “a bridge between the old world and the new world.” “It’s the difference of putting a brand new platform out there and saying everybody’s got
24 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
to move to that new platform, which is a major, major change program,” he said. “We’re creating that bridge between the old world and the new world, which means anyone can get involved and digitalize their organization regardless of their level of digital maturity.” This offers a way to establish a digital foundation now while Chris Newman, preserving the option CEO of ACORD Solutions Group to change platforms He said some insurers have later, he said. already conducted tactical “And then when you’re experiments involving smaller in a position to change your transactions. For Newman, platform or change your the shift from “hype to actual system, if you choose to, real implementations” is you’ve already got that base layer there of digitalization,” he only the beginning. The next opportunity, as he described said. “So, it’s really looking to it, is to decide which processoperationalize the standards, es still make sense, which bring in that trust layer, but can be redesigned, and what effectively remove a lot of inefficiency that’s in the industry trusted information needs at the moment, particularly for to be in place to support that change. insurance companies.” “Some organizations are Rethinking the Model starting to step back and say, Larger change across ‘Okay. We understand our the industry may come business, but this is how some when carriers stop of the processes have been viewing AI as a way to put together. How would automate individual tasks we like them to really work? and start using trusted How does the business flow data to reconsider entire to us from our agents, from workflows, he added. our distribution channel?’” “The more forwardhe said. “They’re starting to thinking carriers are re-engineer their operating starting to look at their models so they end up with end-to-end operating this new digital operating model. They think, ‘Okay. framework. And I think that’s We’ve got the base layer the real exciting opportunity now, so I can now start that you can move to.” to really look at how Blosfield is the managing editor of Carbusiness could be done rier Management, a sister publication if it wasn’t constrained to Insurance Journal. Email: ebloswith some of these legacy field@carriermanagement.com processes.” INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
Closer Look: Personal Lines Leaders Personal
About the Personal Lines Leaders: The 2026 Personal Lines Leaders in this special feature are taken from Insurance Journal’s Top 100 Property/Casualty Independent Agencies as reported in August. This list utilizes only the 2025 personal lines property/casualty revenue numbers of the independent agencies and brokerages that submitted data to the Top 100 agencies report. For more information on Insurance Journal’s Top 100 Property/Casualty Independent Agencies list, contact: awells@insurancejournal.com.
Lines Leaders
Top 50 Personal Lines Agencies
Ranked by Total 2025 Personal Lines P/C Revenue 2026 Rank Agency Name
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50
2025 Total Personal Lines P/C Revenue
2025 Total Personal Lines P/C Premium
Alliant Insurance Services/Confie $1,103,408,089 $5,080,948,147 HUB International Limited $702,000,000 $5,600,000,000 BroadStreet Partners $478,962,000 $2,900,000,000 Acrisure $475,395,000 $3,960,222,000 Highstreet Insurance Partners $304,393,179 $1,503,428,447 Trucordia Insurance Services LLC $187,513,820 $1,258,482,016 Hilb Group $145,759,023 USI Insurance Services $144,266,001 $924,500,000 World Insurance Associates LLC $142,000,000 $1,364,000,000 Leavitt Group $131,342,689 $1,023,849,233 Cross Insurance $118,000,000 $1,820,500,000 AIS Insurance $116,000,000 $922,000,000 Patriot Growth Insurance Services LLC $111,300,000 $870,000,000 Alera Group $108,000,000 Relation Insurance Inc. $97,050,000 Higginbotham $90,918,000 $136,000,000 Premier Group Insurance Inc. $86,100,000 $735,000,000 Inszone Insurance Services $84,893,425 $83,022,277 Keystone Agency Partners LLC $84,878,000 $601,000,000 EPIC Insurance Brokers & Consultants $70,421,000 $519,841,000 ALKEME $67,500,000 $450,000,000 Home Services Insurance $60,000,000 $428,571,000 Atlas Insurance Brokers LLC $53,755,531 $396,985,995 King Risk Partners $47,055,889 $391,326,324 IMA $43,559,631 $309,438,989 Sunstar Insurance Group $41,000,000 $324,000,000 NavSav $37,362,961 $299,966,175 OneDigital $37,000,000 $264,000,000 Oakbridge Insurance $35,569,000 $296,410,000 The Liberty Company Insurance Brokers $34,500,000 $23,700,000 Superior Insurance Partners $32,890,000 $254,077,000 Unison Risk Advisors $32,770,000 $308,500,000 Shepherd Insurance $30,883,000 $219,711,000 TrueNorth Companies LC $30,549,175 $274,479,389 Vantage Insurance Partners Inc. $30,000,000 $302,000,000 Marshall + Sterling Enterprises Inc. $29,842,264 $175,862,117 Lockton $28,863,000 $172,000,000 Rate Insurance LLC $28,731,439 $212,860,860 Robertson Ryan Insurance $27,946,750 $227,679,870 Lawley Insurance $26,751,857 $158,811,022 TowneInsurance $25,110,726 $191,000,000 Starkweather & Shepley Insurance Brokerage Inc. $24,877,547 $153,741,573 Evertree Insurance $23,440,000 $181,125,000 TRICOR Insurance $21,329,000 $118,972,000 Florida One Insurance Agency $21,000,000 $175,000,000 Bearing Insurance $20,456,003 $93,810,751 Huntington Insurance $20,055,000 $139,000,369 Ansay & Associates $18,802,206 $108,347,898 Insurance Office of America Inc. $17,633,402 $176,334,020 OneGroup NY Inc. $17,000,981 $111,975,258
INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
2025 Total P/C Revenue
Main Office
$3,965,472,463 $3,096,000,000 $2,005,293,000 $2,197,362,000 $637,631,857 $587,783,043 $478,922,504 $1,584,219,778 $714,000,000 $431,174,134 $323,200,000 $120,300,000 $333,300,000 $775,000,000 $270,850,000 $703,094,000 $108,200,000 $221,196,020 $354,153,000 $992,623,000 $325,000,000 $60,000,000 $82,614,067 $104,468,946 $710,591,168 $177,000,000 $54,658,535 $145,000,000 $141,233,000 $156,000,000 $91,550,000 $187,645,000 $124,150,400 $133,032,980 $62,000,000 $97,519,264 $2,658,120,000 $29,720,451 $97,299,250 $113,611,365 $102,878,226 $91,889,643 $29,590,000 $56,219,000 $25,101,320 $52,843,913 $52,820,327 $51,599,674 $294,715,079 $46,136,164
Irvine, California Chicago, Illinois Columbus, Ohio Grand Rapids, Michigan Traverse City, Michigan Lindon, Utah Richmond, Virginia Valhalla, New York Iselin, New Jersey Cedar City, Utah Bangor, Maine Irvine, California Ft. Washington, Pennsylvania Deerfield, Illinois Chicago, Illinois Fort Worth, Texas Denver, Colorado Anaheim, California Harrisburg, Pennsylvania New York, New York Ladera Ranch, California New Brighton, Minnesota Rochester, Minnesota Gainesville, Florida Denver, Colorado Memphis, Tennessee Beaumont, Texas Atlanta, Georgia Alpharetta, Georgia Gainesville, Florida Chicago, Illinois Cleveland, Ohio Carmel, Indiana Cedar Rapids, Iowa New York, New York Poughkeepsie, New York Kansas City, Missouri Schaumburg, Illinois Milwaukee, Wisconsin Buffalo, New York Norfolk, Virginia East Providence, Rhode Island Virginia Beach, Virginia Lancaster, Wisconsin Miami Lakes, Florida Glen Allen, Virginia Columbus, Ohio Port Washington, Wisconsin Longwood, Florida Syracuse, New York
NOVEMBER 9, 2026 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | 25
Partner Perspectives Sponsored by Liberty Mutual
Construction Industry Review
T
he construction insurance market continues to present significant opportunity for agents and brokers, but it also faces new and evolving challenges, particularly from the prevalence of legal system abuse and the casualty-heavy nature of construction risks. Scott Lombardi, Executive Vice President and Chief Product Officer for Small Commercial at Liberty Mutual, says success in the construction market increasingly depends on precision: understanding what a contractor actually does, how consistently the work is performed, where the business operates, and how any related subcontractor relationships are managed.
What’s the biggest shift you’re seeing in small commercial construction right now?
The biggest shift is the impact of legal system abuse, which occurs when certain parties, such as some plaintiff attorneys and third-party litigation financiers, exploit the legal process to obtain outsized financial awards. That drives claim costs and settlements higher than historical loss experience would suggest. This is happening more frequently in construction because it is an industry heavily weighted toward casualty coverage. The coverages that come into play most for construction are general liability, umbrella, and commercial auto, so changes in the legal environment can have a significant impact on the industry. We pay close attention to litigation trends in the construction space, including how legal costs and jury verdicts have shifted over the past three years, and that informs how we underwrite and price risk. The key is not to treat construction as one uniform market. A contractor operating in a relatively benign legal environment, for example, presents a different risk from one working in a more challenging area. The more precisely we understand those differences, the more appropriately we can price the exposure and maintain a broad appetite.
Why does Liberty Mutual continue to lean into construction when some carriers are becoming more selective?
Construction continues to be a core part of our small commercial business. It’s also been a fast-growing market. While 26 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
growth has slowed somewhat more recently, particularly on the residential side, it still presents significant opportunity. Our goal is to always be the go-to construction market for agents and brokers. Our refreshed quoting experience lends itself well to this area as it’s designed around how agents and brokers work, with expanded products and backed by a brand that customers recognize. And because of our long history in construction, we have strong data that allows us to better understand the different types of exposures and how they perform. That gives us a more granular basis for pricing different construction risks. This precision helps us distinguish opportunities from risk rather than applying one broad view to the entire construction market.
Beyond general liability, umbrella, and commercial auto, which coverages do construction clients most often underestimate?
While liability, umbrella, and commercial auto tend to get the most attention, contractors’ equipment and inland marine coverages are often overlooked. Construction businesses rely on equipment and property that are constantly moving between job sites, and that’s an area where we see clients underinsured.
What mistakes do agents make when submitting a construction risk, and what information should they gather up front to speed up the quote?
The biggest opportunity we see is understanding the specific work being performed versus treating “construction” as the general exposure. For instance, an electrician, HVAC contractor, plumber, and handyperson may all be described as construction businesses, but they represent very different risk profiles. We generally prefer specialists because contractors that perform the same type of work repeatedly tend to produce more predictable underwriting results. Scott Lombardi When submitting, agents should also provide a clear picture of any subcontractor relationships: who is performing the work, what insurance subcontractors are required to carry, and how additional insured status is secured and verified. These details matter from both an underwriting and coverage perspective. The more specific and complete the submission, the faster we can assess the exposure and respond with the right coverage and price.
What advice would you give to agents and brokers who want to grow with Liberty Mutual in construction over the next year?
We want agents to think of Liberty Mutual as one of their top construction markets. Our deep and consistent history insuring construction clients, our broad underwriting appetite, and our enhanced capabilities make us a dependable partner agents and brokers can count on in this industry.
INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
AIU places the commercial properties that demand real expertise — older frame construction, multifamily, hotel or healthcare accounts — with E&S coverage built to hold up, not hollow out. We lead with underwriting intelligence, uncanny sensible pricing, and unparalleled coverage. Because your clients deserve more than just another market.
SPEAK TO A REP: AIU-USA.COM HELLO@AIU-USA.COM 800.613.2600
ZURECH 347.765.7824
Soft market. Same board. Different game.
News & Markets
Washington Updates Insurance Claims Handling Rules, Sets New Deadlines
N
ew claims handling rules in Washington require insurers to follow updated rules that establish deadlines for responding to policyholders, conducting investigations, issuing denials and making payments. The rules, which took effect Oct. 18, require insurers to notify policyholders within 30 days whether claims have been accepted or denied and provide updates
every 30 days if a claim is delayed. The updated rules issued by Washington Insurance Commissioner Patty Kuderer revise standards for handling claims that had not been updated since their adoption in 1978. The new rules establish specific timelines and documentation requirements for communication, investigations, denials and payments. The prohibit
insurers from denying claims without conducting an investigation and state they cannot rely solely on a database for that investigation. Other changes include: • Removing language concerning the frequency of unfair claims practices to reinforce that any unfair claims practice can violate state law. • Establishing standards for auto damage and total loss claims, including inspection requirements, communications, valuation data sources and handling additional damage. • Requiring insurers that use databases to determine pricing or labor rates to provide information about those databases upon request. Policyholders can also request an in-person inspection if they dispute the accuracy of a virtual photo inspection. • Requiring insurers to explain claim denials, identify relevant policy provisions, provide vehicle valuation reports and disclose the data sources used in determining vehicle values. The changes follow a 2023 workshop held by the Washington Office of the Insurance Commissioner in response to an increase in auto insurance complaints. More than 80% of complaints filed with the agency leading up to the workshop involved claims handling issues, according to the office.
Report: Arizona Vehicle Thefts Fall 21%, But Fraud Schemes May Mask Losses
R
eported vehicle thefts in Arizona fell 21% through the third quarter from the same period a year ago, but that good news was tempered by the finding that some schemes involving fraudulently obtained vehicles are going uncounted. According to data from the Arizona Automobile Theft Authority, the decline in thefts follows a year in which Arizona recorded its fewest reported vehicle thefts since the authority’s inception in 1992. The authority reported that as technology makes newer vehicles harder to steal, organized criminals are using fake or stolen identities to finance or lease vehicles, W2 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
then creating fake paperwork to conceal liens before selling the vehicles to buyers. The schemes often involve out-of-state titles and occur before lenders discover the fraud, according to the authority. Because some law enforcement agencies treat these organized scams as civil matters, the vehicles are not reported as stolen in the National Crime Information Center database, the authority said. A recent example comes from a local car dealer, which alerted the Arizona
Department of Public Safety’s Vehicle Theft Task Force to someone trying to sell vehicles with potentially fraudulent titles. Investigators identified six vehicles valued at more than $750,000. All six had titles altered to conceal liens and were linked to fraudulent purchases tied to a foreign criminal organization, according to the authority. The authority reported that criminal organizations in Arizona and nationwide are targeting higher-value vehicles through fraud rather than stealing larger numbers of lower-value vehicles. The vehicles are often resold to unsuspecting buyers or taken out of the country. INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
Spotlight: Cargo
Finding the Best Defense to Protect Against Cargo Theft By Andrea Wells
C
argo theft has reached record levels across the United States, prompting some insurers to increase rates, raise deductibles, and impose new coverage exclusions as criminals employ increasingly sophisticated methods to steal freight. Scott Cornell, executive vide president, SPG Cargo & Logistics, and crime and theft specialist for LogistIQ Insurance Solutions, said the dramatic rise in strategic cargo theft has complicated risk management for trucking companies, freight brokers, and their insurers. In the first five months of 2026, Verisk CargoNet recorded 1,120 cargo theft incidents and more than $121 million in estimated losses. In 2025, estimated losses more than doubled to $304.6 million, while theft incidents across the U.S. and Canada fell 26% year over year. Organized crime continues to strong arm the cargo industry, Verisk CargoNet notes, where organized theft groups increasingly targeted high-valINSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
ue shipments with cyber tactics like business email compromise. Business email compromise continues to be the primary access point for most sophisticated cargo theft schemes, which gain access to shipment information, communications, contacts, and transportation management tools to identify high-value shipments, impersonate trusted parties, and alter shipment details while appearing legitimate, according to Verisk. However, Cornell cautioned that traditional cargo theft remains the industry’s largest exposure. “A lot of people lose sight of the fact that straight theft is still 70% of all cargo theft,” he said. Traditional theft occurs when criminals physically steal freight from trucks, trailers, warehouses, or parking facilities. Cornell said theft of individual pallets, known as pilferage, has also increased as criminals seek to avoid tracking devices installed in commercial trucks. “There’s an old adage that we use in the industry: freight at rest is freight at risk,” he said.
“Anywhere that the freight stops and sits is where it’s going to be stolen. So, that’s truck stops, drop lots, parking lots, staging lots, outside of warehouses and distribution centers.” The surge in theft has prompted some insurers to reconsider their underwriting approaches. “When cargo theft exploded, we started to immediately see more exclusions around theft across the insurance industry,” Cornell said. That trend is not going to apply to every insurance carrier, he said, but risks without good loss mitigation, risk mitigation in place around theft, will probably see increased rates, increased deductibles, and exclusions. Some insurers have eliminated theft protection from standard cargo policies, requiring insureds to purchase separate coverage. He said effective risk management begins with established procedures, employee training, and careful vetting of transportation partners rather than relying exclusively on cargo theft technology. For freight brokers, that includes recognizing suspicious carrier credentials and fraudulent pickup attempts. For trucking companies, it means educating drivers about highrisk routes, parking locations, and cargo theft hotspots. “If you lean too heavily into the technology and you leave the human element out of it, the technology will ultimately fail you,” Cornell said. Drivers, he added, remain essential to preventing traditional theft. “Your first and best line of defense is always your driver.” Cornell also encouraged insureds to make sure
their agents communicate their loss prevention investments to underwriters. Companies demonstrating stronger-than-average security practices may qualify for better coverage and pricing. Plus, it’s a great way to bond with the client, he said. “Show your client that you have an interest in their success, and it’s mutual success. The better the client is at preventing the theft, the better that you can help stabilize their rates, help stabilize their coverages.” He advises to first review the client’s process and procedures for theft prevention. “Don’t go right to technology, don’t go right to hard locking devices, don’t go to those things until you have good process and procedures in place,” he said. Good process and procedures include good education as well, he added. “Then you go to things like hard locking devices if you’re a trucking company, or if you’re a freight broker, you go to some of the vetting technology platforms that help you vet carriers.” Then hire good drivers, Cornell said. Good companies get good drivers. “I think if a company operates well, treats their people well, and not only do they pay well, but they try to be creative around what can they offer their drivers,” he said. “There are companies out there that will offer free online college education, a two-year college education for a driver’s child.” Or full gym options, health dieticians, some even collect the driver’s mail for them, he said. “As a cargo theft expert, when you talk about street theft, your first and best line of defense is always your driver.”
NOVEMBER 9, 2026 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | 27
Special Report: Trucking
By Andrea Wells
Why Better Trucking Outcomes Depend on Being Proactive
T
he U.S. commercial trucking insurance market remains one of the most challenging segments of property/casualty insurance. While many commercial line segments have experienced pricing relief, trucking liability continues to face elevated claims severity, limited excess insurance
28 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
capacity, litigation pressures, and rising operational costs. In May, the American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI) released new research detailing the rising costs of commercial auto liability insurance in the trucking industry and the risk management strategies that motor carriers use to mitigate these costs. From 2021 to 2024, liability insurance premium costs rose by 18.6% to 10.2 cents per mile—outpacing consumer inflation by 5.4 percentage points, according to the research. But at the same time, the ATRI
reported that heavy-duty truck-involved crash rates fell by 2.6% industry-wide. “The research confirms that a sharp rise in crash claims expenses fueled this rise in insurance costs: among respondents, permile liability losses rose by an average of 33.1% over the same period,” ATRI noted. Premium costs for excess liability coverage, in particular, rose at an even higher rate. The ATRI report showed that from 2021 to 2024, per-mile premium costs for the $5-$10 million insurance layer rose by 34% to 1.58 cents, and per-mile premium INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
costs for the $10-$15 million layer rose by 45% to 1.05 cents. “These increases in excess coverage expenses point to the role of rampant litigation in inflating claims costs,” ATRI said.
Challenges
Conor O’Leary, president of Shelly, Middlebrooks & O’Leary Inc. based in Jacksonville, Florida, a trucking specialist wholesaler broker and managing general agency, said increases in commercial auto rate have slowed in some states during the past 14 months due to tort reform efforts. But with increasing risk of nuclear verdicts and aggressive plaintiff strategies targeting trucking accounts, the sector can expect to see continued headwinds when it comes to the cost of insurance in 2027. Recent tort reform measures in states such as Florida and Georgia have helped, but not enough to move the needle significantly for the market, he said. “Florida’s done a great job. Georgia’s working on some tort reform, as well, but we have yet to see how that’s going to affect the rates,” he said. “Unfortunately, with inflation costs as high as they are, even though Florida has put in tort reforms, you’re still seeing inflated costs to repair vehicles, inflated costs to repair trucks,” he said. “There are a lot of legislators looking for decrease in commercial auto rates, and I don’t think that that’s coming,” he said. Given other factors inflating loss costs, tort reform is just “holding the tide,” he said. “So, Florida is holding the tide of let’s say a 10% or 12% rate increase on insurance rates, but it’s not going to start rolling down commercial auto rates” any time soon, he added. Trucking firms have been hit with significant downturn in freight hauls in 2026, as well. That’s adding more pressure on profit margins, particularly for smaller fleets and owner-operators. ATRI reported that the average cost of operating a truck reached $2.336 per mile in 2025, a 3.4% increase and the highest level recorded in its annual report. Also, the uncertainty around fuel costs is leading to uncertainty around load volume, O’Leary said. “As fuel continues to fluctuate and we see such drastic fluctuINSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
ations (in diesel prices), it’s more difficult for truckers to operate profitably,” he said.
‘As fuel continues to fluctuate and we see such drastic fluctuations, it’s more difficult for truckers to operate profitably.’ “So, we’ve seen a decrease in over-the-road truck volume for intermodal containers,” he said. Much of that decrease has migrated to rail because rail is more cost effective due to fuel pricing. “So, while we have seen containerized volume remain consistent for 2026, more of that volume has shifted to rail, putting some pressure on trucking markets.” That’s going to continue to be a challenge, O’Leary said. “We’re still seeing a lot of last-mile delivery, a lot of local delivery where those rails are hauling it from a port to a warehouse, or possibly there’s a truck that’s hauling it from a port to a railhead, which did load on a rail spur and headed out, but the long haul trucking has been affected drastically,” he said. Another emerging area for liability exposures is brewing from a U.S. Supreme Court decision in May (Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC) that opened the door for heightened litigation exposure against freight brokers if a driver for a contracted transportation carrier gets into a collision. Until May, freight brokers, which connect businesses with trucking firms to haul their products, defended themselves against negligent truck driver hiring claims by arguing that federal law shielded them from state lawsuits for the carriers they selected. But in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, the Supreme Court unanimously rejected that defense, ruling that such state claims involving motor-vehicle safety can apply to brokers, too. “I think there’s still a lot that must be sorted out with that case, but I think it’s the first one where the trial bar has gone
after effectively the shipper and said, ‘We want to extend liability beyond the trucker. We want to go to the freight forwarder, possibly even to the owner of the goods.’ And so, they’re just going up the chain, which is just going to increase the cost for all consumers,” O’Leary said. There’s still plenty of uncertainty over how the case will impact the insurance industry but, in his view, it will create changes. “I think that’s going to affect the industry. I don’t know if it’ll affect the industry in the next six months or the next 10 months, but it’s something that the industry needs to pay attention to because it’s going to come from the freight forwarding side into the industry,” he said. “There have been other attempts to try to ‘reach up and grab’ the freight forwarder, but I don’t think they had been successful. But this is the first precedent-setting case where they were successful.”
Be Proactive
The best thing that transportation firms can do to improve safety and see better outcomes in commercial auto and trucking is to be proactive in managing their risks, said Brandon Wiseman, owner and president of Trucksafe Consulting and a partner with Childress Law. “I’ve been preaching this for years,” he said. A substantial factor in rising litigation against trucking firms is that fleets are not proactive enough when it comes to safety and compliance programs, Wiseman said. “Too often, we get calls from fleets after
continued on page 30
NOVEMBER 9, 2026 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | 29
Special Report: Trucking continued from page 29
something terrible has happened, whether it be a highway accident or a DOT audit,” he said. “At that point, there’s only so much you can do about those things if you haven’t had the controls in place ahead of time to manage that risk.” For example, if fleet management didn’t have the correct policies and procedures in place for driver qualification or they weren’t properly keeping To hear more about commercial auto and fleet track of drivers’ risk management, watch hours, there is Insurance Journal’s Risky very little that Future Virtual Summit on can be done to November 17. For more help the firm information, or to register through a bad for the free event, visit: situation at that www.riskyfuture.com. point, Wiseman added. “I can’t overstress enough the importance of being proactive,” he said. “Take a close look at your compliance program ahead of time and do what you can now to prevent, or at least mitigate, some of these issues that tend to balloon into significant jury verdicts,” he advised. That includes keeping close track of driver qualifications and having a good process for identifying fatigued or distracted drivers out on the road. “All of these things can be mitigated if you take the time, ahead of time, to put controls in place.” He also stressed the importance of holding drivers accountable when mistakes are made. When using risk management tools such as telematics and cameras, fleets need to have written policies in place for how 30 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
they will use the data to improve safety and outcomes, said Tyler Biddle, partner at Childress Law PLLC., a boutique transportation law firm. “How are we using the data? How are we coaching on the findings?” From an employment perspective, it’s important to implement procedures for what to do with the data the organization is tracking on driver behavior, he said. “If we’re using this technology and you are finding certain violations, have that written down somewhere. Or if you have it written down, follow the procedures so that if you have a driver that keeps doing the same thing over and over, well, at some point, you have to follow your policy and either terminate or provide progressive discipline, things like that.”
‘I can’t overstress enough the importance of being proactive.’ Wiseman added that cameras and event recorders are great risk management tools that get the most attention, but less hightech risk management can go a long way in helping fleets improve safety outcomes. “One (tool) that gets less attention, but not enough fleets in my opinion are leveraging, is something called continuous license monitoring,” he said. “If you’re a fleet that is just following the letter of the law, and the letter of the law tells you that you have to check a driver’s driving record once a year,” that’s a risk, he said. “So, you’re running motor vehicle reports once a year to make sure that
they have a valid and up-to-date license and looking at their violations…then you’re relying on the drivers to tell you if something happens to their license in the gap between those yearly MVR pulls,” he said. “But if a driver loses their license for one reason or another—failing to pay child support or missing a court date—they’re disincentivized to tell you about that, and so it leaves a real gap. You end up with fleets having drivers out there operating with either a revoked license or a downgraded CDL, and that’s a huge exposure.” How firms coach and train driver behavior makes a difference in safety outcomes as well, said Phillip Wigginton, a senior transportation risk consultant in the Texas region of HUB’s Risk Services Division. “I had a conversation with a fleet several years ago about coaching drivers. They just couldn’t figure out why they kept having crash frequency issues,” he said. “They had all the tools, they had great training. So, I asked the safety director, ‘Hey, how do you coach your drivers?’ He says, ‘Well, I tell them if you do it again, then I’m going to fire you.’” “Well, that’s not really coaching. That’s threatening,” Wigginton said. Threatening termination is not going to help. “Every company in the world is looking for good drivers. They can go next door and probably make more money.” But having a culture where the driver feels supported during the coaching will help safety outcomes. “Culture is absolutely critical,” Wigginton said. “It does make a difference.” INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
When your small business book is full of next chapters, write them with us. Every line is yours to write. Start the next chapter with Liberty Mutual.
INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM ©2026 Liberty Mutual Insurance
NOVEMBER 9, 2026 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | 31
Special Report: Best Agency to Work For
East
Evertree Insurance Virginia Beach, Virginia
Listening to the Everyday Employee Experience Fosters Great Culture, Growth By Andrea Wells
F
ounded in 2022, Evertree Insurance, a technology-enabled independent insurance agency and brokerage, is on a growth spurt. The agency has grown to more than $29 million in total property/casualty revenue (2025) and ranks #79 on Insurance Journal’s Top 100 listing in 2026. But that fasttrack growth hasn’t taken the focus off its people, according to employees whose nominations made the firm the Bronze Award winner in the East for Insurance Journal’s 2026 Best Agency to Work For. “Evertree truly cares about the people who work here. They want everyone to succeed, not just for the good of the company, but for the good of the employee’s life and future, too,” a nominating employee told Insurance Journal. Another employee cited the agency’s organizational profile, saying, “I love the diversity of gender, race, and age. The demographics of this agency aren’t typical of the industry.” They added that the agency’s management have “integrity and care about their clients.” “We’ve grown quickly, and with growth comes a lot of change,” said Morgan Pecora, senior vice president of People at Evertree. “Throughout that growth, we’ve worked hard to remain focused on our people and create an environment where employees feel valued,
supported, challenged, and excited about where the company is going.” What makes Evertree special is the people, Pecora added. “We have an incredibly talented team, but we also genuinely enjoy working together,” she said. “We try to give people opportunities to grow, encourage leaders to invest in their teams, recognize great performance, and create an environment where people can build meaningful careers.” That sentiment ran through many of the comments from employees who submitted nominations. “Evertree provides me with the tools and resources that I need and allow me to do what I need to do and don’t micromanage me on a daily basis,” one employee told Insurance Journal. “As a result, I have a lot of freedom to be the best producer I can be.” “We certainly aren’t perfect, but we listen to our employees, continue to evolve, and genuinely care about making Evertree a place where people want to be, ” Pecora said. The insurance industry continues to change quickly, so it’s important for employers to evolve and change quickly as well, Pecora said. “Technology, consolidation, changing customer expectations, and an increasingly competitive talent market mean agencies have to evolve,” she said. “We believe being a great employer today means providing more than a job. Employees want to understand where
32 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
the company is going, how they contribute to its success, and what opportunities exist for them as the organization grows.” That means investing in technology and better processes, but equally important is investing in leadership, development, communication, flexibility, recognition, and career opportunities, according to Pecora. “Our goal is to continue building a company where high-performing people can do great work, grow their careers, and be rewarded for the impact they make.” When nominating the agency one employee said: “The main action that Evertree has pushed heavily is the use of AI. Not to replace agents, but to allow us to seamlessly navigate the underwriting guides and processes for the many carriers we work with.”
Being a great place to work means listening to employees about what works and what doesn’t, Pecora added. “Listen to your employees— and then be willing to act on what you hear,” she said. “It’s easy to focus on compensation, benefits, events, or perks when talking about culture, and those things certainly matter. But great workplaces are ultimately built through the everyday employee experience.” Evertree regularly asks employees for feedback, and sometimes the most valuable feedback is the feedback that is challenging, Pecora said.
Evertree Insurance employees at a recent company event. INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
Special Report: Best Agency to Work For
Midwest
Robertson Ryan Insurance Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Built on Belonging: How Robertson Ryan Thrives on a Family-First Culture By Ezra Amacher
A
t Robertson Ryan Insurance, a strong sense of belonging allows employees to bring their best selves to work every day. Creating such an environment doesn’t happen by accident. Over 65 years, the Milwaukee, Wisconsin-based agency has worked at developing a culture where team members can come together to solve solutions in an authentic, collaborative workplace. “We have grown as an organization, but we have worked hard to maintain a personal, family-type atmosphere where people know each other and feel connected,” said Christine Rogers, senior vice president of customer service. “Insurance can be a challenging business, and customer service isn’t always easy, but we have an amazing group of people who truly care about our clients and each other. That makes a huge difference.” Employees take notice when they feel supported. Robertson Ryan received dozens of nominations for the annual Best Agency to Work For award. The agency is the recipient of this year’s Bronze prize for the Midwest region. To be recognized for the award by colleagues affirms that Robertson Ryan is a special place to work, said Allan Degner, senior vice president of marketing & communications. “Having our employees INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
share that in their own words is agency. In an era of mergers the strongest endorsement we and acquisition and private could receive,” Degner said. equity, Robertson Ryan has Employees who wrote stayed true to its roots. in to nominate the agency “As a producer, Robertson commended the agency’s Ryan gives me something benefits and compensation that is increasingly rare in structure, the ability to work our industry: the freedom where employees not only remotely and take time off to and autonomy to build my want to start or grow a career be with family, the constant business my way while still in insurance but stay for many professionalism exhibited providing the resources, years if not decades. Multiple by company leaders, and the support, and stability of a large employees shared how the family-like atmosphere. organization,” an employee agency accommodated their Many employees said wrote. “The culture is entrepreneurial, transparent, and life circumstances, whether Robertson Ryan is the best relationship-driven.” recovering from a cancer insurance agency they’ve ever Robertson Ryan’s diagnosis or tending to a parent worked for. leadership team makes it a in hospice. “They truly care about point to equip employees the The message comes their employees and having tools to succeed and to create through clear: Employees’ a successful business,” one a space for people to speak up. well-being outside of work employee wrote. “They also Recognition matters, too. matters. A happier, healthier care a great deal about the “Pay attention to the team leads to a foundation community and give back at little things,” said Rogers. where individuals can thrive at every available opportunity. “Recognize people for the work their jobs. I have recommended many they do, communicate with “What makes Robertson people to apply for jobs here; them. You won’t always get Ryan a great place to work it is an exceptional working everything right, but if your is the people and the team environment.” employees know you genuineculture,” an employee wrote. Another employee came ly care about them, are willing “There is a strong sense of out of retirement to work to listen, that goes a long way.” cohesiveness and a genuine for Robertson Ryan. After Robertson Ryan has built desire to see everyone a decades-long career in a reputation as being a place succeed.” the industry, the employee reported feeling more respected for their talents and knowledge than anywhere before. “They just respect your knowledge,” the employee wrote. One of the common themes from employee responses is the spirit of independence Left to Right: Dan Lau, COO, Christine Rogers, Sr. VP of Customer Service, Chris Illman, CEO, Jami Long, CFO, Allan Degner, Sr. VP of Marketing & Communications that pervades the NOVEMBER 9, 2026 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | 33
Special Report: Best Agency to Work For
South Central
BKCW Insurance Austin, Texas
Investment in Education and Culture Paves the Way at BKCW By Ezra Amacher
A
t BKCW Insurance, education is core to the agency’s mission of giving employees the tools they need to succeed. BKCW pays for continuing education and designations, and the company give bonuses when people earn them. For example, employees receive a bonus for each CIC exam they pass. “A more knowledgeable team gives better advice, and our clients feel the difference,” said Tyler Spears, managing partner at BKCW. BKCW’s emphasis on growing employees’ knowledge and skills through education incentives gives team members the conviction to approach their jobs with curiosity and a willing-to-learn attitude. Employees at BKCW brought up educational advancement in nominating the agency for the annual Best Agency to
Work For award. The Austin, Texas, agency is the recipient of the Bronze Award for the South-Central region. Earning the award is “the most meaningful recognition we could get,” Spears said, because it comes from the people who live BKCW’s culture every day. “Awards from carriers and clients measure how we serve customers,” Spears said. “This one measures how we treat each other, and that’s what I’m proudest of.” Employees who wrote in to nominate the agency praised BKCW’s family-oriented culture, which gives team members the flexibility to prioritize time with their loved ones. Employees also highlighted the agency’s mentorship, investment in technology, and community involvement. “BKCW is one of the best insurance agencies to work for because it combines a strong,
BKCW employees enjoy the family-oriented culture of the agency. 34 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
people-first culture with the resources and expertise of an established organization,” one employee wrote. “Employees are empowered to grow professionally through ongoing training, mentorship, and opportunities for advancement while working alongside knowledgeable and supportive colleagues.” Employees say they feel rewarded for hard work and for taking on challenging assignments. They feel confident knowing that agency leadership will listen when they bring up work issues. “Management is open and reactive to concerns voiced,” an employee wrote. “We also have layers of meetings where issues and concerns can be discussed with management—team lead meetings and full department meetings quarterly.” Employees said they receive great compensation and benefits, among them the ability to work remotely multiple days a week. The setup of the organization allows for producers, account managers, and service staff to work together, according to Spears. When an employee is away from work, they can trust that their team members have their back. “They work with you if something comes up and you need to change days, take flex time, or vacation,” one employee wrote. “When you are on vacation, the
teams work together to keep your desk running so you do not come back to a lot of work, which lets you enjoy your time off.” As employees of a fast-growing agency in one of the country’s booming regions, BKCW members appreciate the opportunity to interact face to face with business partners and customers. One way that BKCW encourages this is through its annual Lake Day, which brings in carrier partners from around the country. “That investment in relationships alone showed their efforts toward retention and growth,” an employee wrote. BKCW further invests in the Austin community by giving back to schools and other non-profit organizations. The theme of being generous with one’s time and resources runs through BKCW’s culture. “Invest in your people before you ask them to invest in you,” Spears said. “Pay for their education and reward them for finishing it. Trust them with flexibility, and they’ll repay that trust many times over. Build teams so nobody feels like they’re on an island. And listen. Your employees will tell you what they need if you ask them and actually follow through.” INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
Special Report: Best Agency to Work For
Southeast
Riemer Insurance Group Hallandale Beach, Florida
Investing in People, Tools and Relationships Makes a Difference
By William Rabb
R
iemer Insurance Group, with four offices in south Florida (and one in Westchester, New York), turns 50 in two years and remains family owned. Some employees have been with the agency for decades. And, judging by responses to Insurance Journal’s survey, most of the associates really like working at the agency, making it the Bronze Award winner for the Best Agencies to Work For in the Southeast for 2026. “There is no recognition that means more to me than one that comes from our own people,” said Paul Riemer, president of the agency, which is headquartered in Hallandale Beach, between Miami and Fort Lauderdale. “Awards from the industry are nice, but this one was decided by the people who show up every day and actually make Riemer what it is.” Paul Riemer’s brother, Brian, is CEO of the agency. Their father, Stephen Riemer, founded the agency in 1978 and built it into a firm that now has 85 employees and serves some 8,000 clients. Comments from producers and others at the agency suggest that an emphasis on communication with and support for employees has been a key to the agency’s success. “We complete a producer meeting monthly. This meeting is for us as team members to discuss all goals and team INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
performance. They give advice and never criticize. They offer us the tools to run our own business,” one producer wrote in the survey response.
‘Invest in technology, invest in carrier relationships that give your team real options for clients, and get out of the way.’ Paul Riemer explained the agency’s philosophy in an interview: “What makes Riemer a great place to work comes down to our value system: family first, continuous improvement, loyalty, and always do the right thing.” “Family first means exactly that,” he said. “We are a family business, and we treat our employees as an extension of that family. When someone has something going on at home, home comes first, and the team steps in. Continuous improvement means we invest in our people and our tools, and we expect everyone to get a little better every day. Loyalty runs both directions.” His best advice for other agency owners: “Culture is not what you say at the holiday party. It is how you handle the tough renewal, the claim that goes sideways, or the team member who needs time away. Your team is watching how you act in those moments, and that is what they will believe about your agency.”
“Beyond that, give your people the tools and the training to win. Nothing frustrates a good employee more than being asked to deliver great service with outdated systems and no support,” he added. “Invest in technology, invest in carrier relationships that give your team real options for clients, and get out of the way. People want to work somewhere they can be proud of the work, and where they can see themselves growing.” The management at Riemer believes that artificial intelligence, which has been a growing concern nationwide as layoff numbers grow across some industries, has a place— but not a displacement role. “We are not using AI to replace people,” Paul Riemer noted. “We are using it to give our people the tools they need to succeed in today’s environment. Insurance is still a relationship business. Clients call us because they want someone they trust to explain a coverage form, fight for them
on a claim, or find a market when nobody else can. AI does not do that. Our people do.” “Where AI helps is in taking the grind out of the day,” he said. “We use it to support our internal processes so that fewer things fall through the cracks. That makes us more efficient, it lets us respond to clients faster and more thoroughly, and it frees our team to spend their time where it matters most, which is in front of and servicing our clients and carriers.” “The way we see it, the agencies that will struggle are not the ones that use AI. They are the ones whose people are stuck doing manual work while their competitors are using better tools,” he said.
Paul, Stephen, and Brian Riemer NOVEMBER 9, 2026 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | 35
Special Report: Best Agency to Work For
West
Morris & Garritano San Luis Obispo, California
Why ‘People First’ Values Matter By Don Jergler
T
he success at Morris & Garritano is a simple case of pairing what people are doing with their strongest skills. “People first” is a phrase that frequently popped up in employee compliments about the firm when nominating it for the annual Best Agency to Work For award. The San Luis Obispo, California, agency was nominated by dozens of employees. It won the Best Agencies to Work For Bronze Award in the West. It’s not the first time M&G made the list. The firm won Silver last year, after winning Gold in 2024. “I love to hear that,” said Brandon Morris, CEO, risk advisor and principal of the firm, when he was read some of the employee comments during an interview. “I would say that it’s definitely people
first, because it’s really one of our pillars. We want people to come here and feel like they can build a career out of it—it’s not just a job.” He said the firm put an emphasis in the last several years on constant learning and development. “People can see that career path, whatever that may be, and I think that’s really made a difference,” he said. The firm reports annual revenue of $34.4 million, with a workforce that now numbers 160. It specializes in construction, manufacturing, wine and agribusiness, hospitality, residential care and social services, retail, and real estate. Employees offered praise for the firm in numerous areas, but many of them highlighted the emphasis on constant learning and development. “What stands out most to me is how genuinely invested the agency is in people’s
M&G staff attend the SLO County Housing Summit. 36 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
success. There’s a real effort to help employees grow, build meaningful career paths, and find opportunities that align with their strengths and goals,” one employee wrote. “You can see it in how people are supported and how enthusiastically their accomplishments are celebrated. My own position was created to pair the needs of the agency with my own strength and career goals. That same level of care extends to our clients. Volunteering for the SLO Food Bank’s Hunger Awareness Day We want to do great work, the future of the organization.” but we also want to do what is Employees also echoed the genuinely right for the people “core values” Morris menand businesses we serve.” tioned often in their remarks. Another employee “Our agency lives our nominated M&G because core values every day; love of its “people-first culture, what you do, do the right collaborative environment, thing, always be improving, and commitment to employee go the extra mile, and build growth.” collaborative relationships,” Another wrote that the an employee wrote. “They firm “combines a strong, make employees feel valued people-first culture with and heard by welcoming meaningful opportunities to innovative ideas. We encourgrow.” age coming to the table with “The company genuinely recommendations when invests in employees through improvement or adjustments professional development, are needed. They invest in us, leadership training, coaching and we are proud to do the programs, and clear career best job possible for them, paths,” the employee wrote. which translates to excellent “Employees are encouraged to service and positive relationbuild their skills, take on new ships with our clients.” challenges, and contribute to INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
Idea Exchange: Ask the Insurance Recruiter How Is AI Being Used in Insurance Recruiting?
I
know this topic is top of mind for a lot of agencies in the hope that technology can make it easier to find good talent more quickly. Job seekers are hopeful, too, because the vast amount of information online can be hard to wade through to find the perfect career. Since technology advances so rapidly, I’m cautious about projecting too far into the future. At this time, all I can speak to is where I’ve seen AI be a resource or have influence in the recruiting process for both hiring leaders and candidates.
AI for Creative Writing
Candidates and companies use AI to write cover letters, resumes, job descriptions, and job advertisements. This is a huge relief for people who don’t feel confident with creative writing. For others, it ensures their materials line up with what’s common in the market. Most importantly, AI is interactive, so rather than templates or samples that feel impersonal, you can constantly refine and tailor these pieces to specific jobs, situations, and keyword terms. If you use AI to write job descriptions, make sure to edit it in a tone of voice that sounds like you and doesn’t appear to plagiarize another company’s ad. You also want to make sure all the information
included is compliant with internal and external regulations. As a hiring leader, you also want to scrutinize resumes. At first glance it may be difficult to tell which CVs were written with the help of AI. If something seems out of place—not the standard way insurance people talk—or doesn’t line up with what you know about the market, it’s fair to flag that resume for additional vetting.
AI Matches Jobs to Candidates and Candidates to Jobs
Sometimes my team sees a huge influx of job applications randomly and unexpectedly. That’s largely driven by AI that learns job seeker behaviors and pushes new jobs that are similar to what they’ve applied to before. This can be good for both the company advertising the job as well as the candidate, provided the keywords do match experience and requirements correctly. A lot of agency owners have said they hope AI in agency management systems eliminates tedious backroom servicing. We’ll see this with HRIS and recruiting software, too. HR teams want technology to help with resume screening, candidate sourcing, and initial interviews. If you’ve ever seen the ‘Chat With Us’ feature on a company’s Careers page, then you know
that’s also AI at work to match people faster with job openings.
AI Speeds Up Interview Logistics
Setting up the By Mary Newgard interview process consumes a considerable amount of time, second only to screening applicants. Many companies use interview schedulers, and some programs conduct the initial phone interviews with a virtual assistant. What I really like are features to summarize interviews. It saves a ton of time with documentation and makes prior interview notes available to everyone who participates in the process.
AI for Interview Preparation
A lot of candidates use AI to research companies. They can ask for comparisons with your job description and their skills that will help them know what interview questions to expect. There are practice programs to simulate job interviews. Job seekers can also receive suggested questions from AI that they can ask companies during the interview process. One of the most common things my team hears right now is, “I went on ChatGPT to ask what I should make.” Between relocation situations, cost of living comparisons, and frankly just a desire for people to feel paid appropriately, a quick Google search can generate a lot of compensation information. While that may not be perfect, it is good for you as a hiring leader to be aware of, especially because pay remains one of the most uncomfortable things for people to talk about in an interview and one that easily trips up the process.
Newgard is partner and senior search consultant for Capstone Search Group, a national recruiting firm dedicated to the insurance industry. Email: asktherecruiter@ csgrecruiting.com.
INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
NOVEMBER 9, 2026 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | 37
W
elcome to Insurance Journal’s 2026 Premium Finance Directory, a comprehensive listing of premium finance companies able to assist agents and brokers with their clients’ financing needs. All company information listed in this directory was directly submitted to Insurance Journal. To be listed in future editions of Insurance Journal’s Premium Finance Directory, or any other directory, contact Kristine Honey at: khoney@insurancejournal.com. We hope you find this directory to be a valuable resource when searching for financing options for your clients. Feel free to send us comments and suggestions on how we might improve this directory, or for additional help, e-mail: editorial@insurancejournal.com.
The 2026 Premium Finance Directory is Sponsored By:
SEE HOW OUR SOFTWARE CAN
Lower Cost of Administration & Grow YOUR BUSINESS More
Brokers Financial Services
Agile Premium Finance
475 Half Day Road, Lincolnshire, IL 60069 Phone: (269) 365-6747 Email: ggriffin@agile-pf.com www.agile-pf.com • Driven by innovation and backed by First Financial Bank (NASDAQ: FFBC), Agile is one of the fastest growing companies in premium finance. • Offering convenient, efficient premium finance technology solutions designed to make your days more productive. • Agile takes great pride in offering the best customer experience for both agent partners and insureds. We go above and beyond to deliver for our clients.
38 | INSURANCE JOURNAL November 9, 2026
19500 Middlebelt Rd., Ste. 360 W Livonia, MI 48152 Phone: (248) 478-8723, Fax: (248) 478-8729 Email: nmorrison@brokfinsvc.com www.brokfinsvc.com
Avian Premim Finance
701 N. Brand Blvd., Ste. 310 Glendale, CA 91203 Phone: (818) 333-5900, Fax: (818) 333-5901 Email: marketing@avianpremiumfinance.com www.avianpremiumfinance.com
• Competitive flexible rates and payment plan options • Fast and efficient payment to Brokers and Insurance companies • 24/7 live phone customer service for our agents and clients
• Decrease the down payment by financing your broker fees. We also offer discount renewals with down payments as low as 15%. • Increase your agency revenue by adding referral fees. Over 8% in APR to your agency. • We have a customer service team dedicated to keeping your accounts current and contacting your insureds before their policy cancels.
www.insurancejournal.com www.insurancejournal.com
Premium Finance Directory Cypress Premium Funding, Inc.
Capital Premium Financing
12235 S. 800 E, Draper, UT 84020 Phone: (800) 767-0705, Fax: (800) 700-3170 Email: info@capitalpremium.net www.capitalpremium.net
28202 Cabot Rd., Ste 435 Laguna Niguel, CA 92677 Phone: (949) 487-0602, Fax: (949) 487-0640 Email: info@cypressfunding.com www.cypressfunding.com • Competitive Rates and Terms • Immediate Funding • Cancellation Prevention Programs
General Agents Acceptance Corporation
23441 S Pointe Dr, # 145, Laguna Hills, CA 92653 Phone: (949) 470-9674, Fax: (800) 568-5462 Email: james@mygaac.com www.mygaac.com • With 32 years in business, our White-Glove, Family-Run Service is designed to help reduce cancellations while increasing your retention. • More Earnings & Flexibility: Higher Producer Fees
• Industry leading Agency Revenue Programs • Highest level of Agent/Client service available in the industry • Local presence, multiple payment options, and online access
ClassicPlan Insurance Premium Financing 13750 Pipeline Ave., Chino, CA 91710 Phone: (800) 347-6481, Fax: (909) 628-5490 Email: info@classicplan.com www.classicplan.com
Express Premium Finance Company, LLC 21 E. Main St., Ste. 103 Oklahoma City, OK 73104 Phone: (800) 728-2902, Fax: (888) 413-8898 Email: quote@expresspremium.com www.expresspremium.com
• Five touchpoints before cancellation, including
• Premium Service • Premium Solutions • Premium People
gotoPremiumFinance.com
• Most lines of business accepted, incl. Cannabis • Mobile App, credit card payments, ACH and more for insureds payment submission • Extra services to help increase retention and market your agency
FIRST Insurance Funding
450 Skokie Blvd, Ste. 1000, Northbrook, IL 60062 Phone: (847) 572-4650 Email: jim.miller@firstinsurancefunding.com firstinsurancefunding.com
COST Financial Group, Inc.
807 W. Highway 50, Ste. 4, O’Fallon, IL 62269 Phone: (800) 844-2678, Fax: (618) 206-3223 Email: travisk@costfinancial.com costfinancial.com
Transforming Premium Finance Into a Strategic Enterprise Asset
• Unlock the Revenue Engine Already Hidden Inside Your Business • Create a New, Recurring Earnings Stream from Business Your Organization is Already Generating • No extra staff. No extra overhead. Revenue that grows as your agency grows. • Create Recurring Revenue, Deepen Client Relationships, and Deliver a Better Overall Customer Experience
paid on the interest spread; Finance Broker Fees; Profit Sharing & Down Payment Collection Program
• Premium Finance – Simplified with our
customizable online loan process that works wherever you and your insureds are
• Most complete payment options in the industry for your insureds including Amex, Visa, Mastercard, Discover or by bank account for down payments, installments, and recurring payments • Agency lending, 401K management, Deposit services, and employee benefits programs • Training options for everyone in your agency
two live calls (plus a third on accounts $30k+); 30 days to pay before cancellation (20 days for trucking) - more time than most finance companies
1 Baxter Way, # 270, Westlake Village, CA 91362 Phone: (888) 875-4000, Fax: (818) 610-2066 Email: sales@gotopremiumfinance.com www.gotopremiumfinance.com
• Industry leading digital premium finance and pay in full options that are designed to help agents grow their insurance business and increase their income. • Nationwide premium finance provider for agents, MGAs & insurance companies. • Online quoting, online payment options, real time account status, online cancellation holds, customized notice delivery & more.
Imperial PFS
1055 Broadway, 11th Fl, Kansas City, MO 64105 Phone: (800) 838-2350 Email: marketing@ipfs.com www.ipfs.com • North America’s Largest Premium Finance Company With 47 Years in the Industry • Localized Service with Regional Offices Across the United States, Canada, and Puerto Rico • Privately Held Company Offering Commercial Premium Finance and Payment Solutions
Insurance Finance Company, LLC
P.O. Box 315, Des Moines, IA 50306-1315 Phone: (800) 247-4190, Fax: (515) 223-0226 Brian@ifcorp.biz or banstoetter@ifcorp.biz www.ifcorp.biz • Re-Engineering PREMIUM FINANCE from the Agent Up! • Celebrating 55 years in business • Fanatical Service – Flexible rewards and agency incentives – Competitive terms.
www.insurancejournal.com
November 9, 2026 INSURANCE JOURNAL | 39
Premium Finance Directory Johnson & Johnson Preferred Financing, Inc.
200 Wingo Way, Ste. 200, Mt. Pleasant, SC 27464 Phone: (800) 868-5573, Fax: (843) 724-7085 Email: finance@jjpf.com www.jjpf.com • Finance most lines of coverage both Commercial and Personal lines - including Cannabis Risks • Revenue programs available in most states • Multiple funding options for Money in & Money out!
Liberty Premium Finance, Inc.
6 Centerpointe Dr., Ste. 375 La Palma, CA 90623 Phone: (800) 229-8793, Fax: (562) 356-0131 Email: sporter@libertypf.com www.libertypf.com • Flexible monthly payment options for commercial insurance policies • Quote, bind and archive your contracts with our easy-to-use online quoting center • Convenient payment options including our online payment portal
Mountain West Premium Finance
2535 Kettner Blvd., Ste. 3-A3, San Diego, CA 92101 Phone: (888) 280-0235, Fax: (619) 697-0326 Email: mike@financepremium.com www.financepremium.com • Innovative Premium Financing • Pay As You Go Premium Financing • Form Your Own Premium Finance Company
NCMIC Finance Corporation
14001 University Ave., Clive, IA 50325 Phone: (800) 600-9250, Fax: (800) 630-9250 Email: LLogan@ncmic.com www.nfcfinance.com
PREMCO Financial Corporation
PO Box 19367, Kalamazoo, MI 49019-0367 Phone: (269) 375-3936, Fax: (269) 375-6913 Email: dhofmann@go-premco.com www.go-premco.com
NIC Premium Finance, LLC
6270 NE Bothell Way, Kenmore, WA 98028 Phone: (800) 767-7345, Fax: (206) 441-3141 Email: Omar@nicpf.com www.nicpf.com
• We finance all Commercial & Personal lines with same day funding • Rate Share, Profit Sharing, Stock Dividends & Referral Fees • FREE Online payments and the option to pay with Credit/Debit cards
• No Industry Exclusions - Accepting ACH &
Credit Card Down Payments - Commercial Premium Financing Since 1965.
• Utilize Our Online Platform to Produce a Finance Agreement & Send it For E-Signature in 60 Seconds. • Various Repayment Terms Including Monthly, Quarterly, Semi-Annual, & Payment in Full.
Premins Company
132 32nd St., Ste. 408, Brooklyn, NY 11232 Phone: (800) 599-3279, Fax: (718) 376-8330 Email: info@premins.com www.premins.com
Peoples Premium Finance
200 Unity Circle North, Ste. E Lee’s Summit, MO 64086 Phone: (844) 292-9090, Fax: (816) 246-2659 Email: peoplespf@pebo.com peoplespf.com • Flexible premium finance structures tailored
to your clients, industries, and business needs
• Premium financing options designed to remain competitive and adaptable to market conditions • Connect with agency management systems and simplify quoting, servicing, and account management • 24/7 account access, electronic agreements, and online payments • Work with experienced professionals who understand your territory and provide personalized support
• Commercial and personal financing for over 60 years • Lowest payment fees in the industry! • Get answers and quotes quickly with our fast and effective customer service on the phone and on our customized website
Premium Finance Brokerage, LLC
P.O. Box 623, Jarrettsville, MD 21084 Phone: (866) 381-6501, Fax: (866) 381-6502 tlarsen@premiumfinancebrokerage.com www.premiumfinancebrokerage.com • We work for YOU. As a broker, we have designed very competitive programs with several national premium finance companies with one point of contact. • Our exclusive Concierge Service PLUS program makes it easy for you to manage your premium finance portfolio. • It is our sole objective to provide our customers the best possible experience with the highest degree of integrity along with a service guarantee we put in writing.
• Real relationships with people who care about you and your business. • Providing simple, but meaningful solutions. • Dedicated to Exceeding Your Expectations.
40 | INSURANCE JOURNAL November 9, 2026
www.insurancejournal.com
Premium Finance Directory SIUPREM, Inc.
P.O. Box 105611, Atlanta, GA 30348 Phone: (678) 498-4700, Fax: (678) 498-4747 Email: info@siuprem.com www.siuprem.com • Our success is a result of your success. At SIUPREM, we partner with agents, not over them. While others chase volume, we focus on what matters — your clients, your success, and your growth. • $5 donation to the American Cancer Society for every contract. For every contract you write, SIUPREM donates $5 to the American Cancer Society in support of breast cancer awareness and research. Together, we’re funding hope. • Flat fee of $4.95 for credit card payments. Your clients save more with SIUPREM — just $4.95 for card payments up to $10,000. Simple, flexible, and affordable.
Southern Access Capital, LLC
2231 Arlington Ave. South, Birmingham, AL 35205 Phone: (800) 806-1244 Email: info@southernaccesscapital.com www.southernaccesscapital.com • A trusted regional premium finance company specializing in property & casualty insurance across the Southeast. • Streamlined financing with same day approvals and personalized support. • Over a decade of experience helping agents retain clients, manage billing, and grow their book of business.
www.insurancejournal.com
Standard Premium Finance
13590 SW 134th Ave., Ste. 214, Miami, FL 33186 Phone: (800) 592-7753 or (305) 232-2752 Email: Robert@standardpremium.com www.standardpremium.com • Personal and commercial lines. • No minimum, no maximum premiums. • Our personal service and attention to detail make the difference. • ACH, EFT and credit card payments and down payments. • Revenue-Sharing and traditional commission programs. • Simple one-page online quoting. • E-Sign documents.
US Premium Finance
3500 Parkway Lane, Ste. 300 Peachtree Corners, GA 30092 Phone: (866) 246-9691, Fax: (866) 246-9692 CustomerService@USPremiumFinance.com www.USPremiumFinance.com • TECHNOLOGY: Purpose-built technology,
RPA-powered automation and integrated payment solutions streamline agreement processing, reduce manual work and errors, and help agencies operate more efficiently.
business!
• VALUE: Competitive rates and customizable financing terms help agencies meet client needs while creating new income opportunities that can support EBITDA growth and overall agency value.
Stetson Insurance Funding, LLC
• SERVICE: Responsive, agent-centric service and deep industry expertise help agencies streamline workflows, navigate complex financing needs and grow with confidence.
• The best loyalty rewards program in the
• If you’re not 100% satisfied, we won’t accept your business.
155 N. Wacker Dr., Floor 40, Chicago, IL 60606 Phone: (866) 856-1112 Email: sales@stetsonfunding.com www.stetsonfunding.com • Stetson is a Ryan Specialty company that provides financing for RT Specialty policies and all E&S business, nationwide. • Competitive financing for all of your agency billed commercial lines and personal lines business, including cannabis. • Customized rates, terms, reporting and revenue programs to meet all of your agency’s needs.
• STABILITY: Backed by publicly traded Ameris Bank, US Premium Finance combines financial strength, security and extensive banking resources with the speed, flexibility and responsiveness of a true partner.
November 9, 2026 INSURANCE JOURNAL | 41
Idea Exchange: The Competitive Advantage Insurance: Is There Any Value?
T
he Wall Street Journal ran a fantastic analysis of private passenger auto (PPA) liability claims in August 2026. They identified that approximately 50% of all PPA liability claims were closed no pay (CNP) in 2025. No one needs liability insurance if coverage is a 50/50 proposition. By Chris Burand On August 17, 2026, a new research paper from HUB, one of the largest brokers in North America, identified that approximately 33% of personal lines customers with a claim were not fully indemnified. Another study from the American Property Casualty Insurance Association identified that approximately 67% of all homes are materially underinsured. I received a call from a commercial insured, a non-profit, about an article I wrote on deductible expansion. He thanked me for the explanation because neither his agent nor carrier had explained the importance of going from a flat deductible to a percentage wind/ hail deductible. Sure enough, they had a claim resulting in a $325,000 deductible. He did not have the working capital available for that deductible. A question arises: Why is coverage so insufficient on such a large scale? Many argue that customers lack coverage because they do not read their policies and do not understand the coverage limitations. Without question, this is a huge factor, but it misses the point. One claim cited in the WSJ article involved a dad who ran into another car. His claim was CNP because he hadn’t listed a 14-year-old son. The son did not have a license and was not driving. In other words, the son was not a risk factor, but the policy required listing everyone in the household older than X. The insured did not comply. It goes against common sense for someone too young to legally drive to be listed on an auto insurance policy.
42 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
However, most states’ standards of care require the insured to read and understand their policy. In these examples, the requirements exceed the reasonable person rule because the latter defies common sense, and the former defies it based on a common person’s inability to calculate the value of their building specific to the replacement cost estimators that insurance carriers use. And the insureds don’t get the policy until they buy it. It’s an impossible standard. Carriers have reduced coverage substantially, whether the issue is listing people who cannot legally drive or the fact that insurance carriers are experts on value and, in quite a few claims, have the option of choosing which replacement cost model to use (which is an ethical and maybe legal issue in and of itself) so the claim can be adjusted in a more favorable manner relative to deductibles and coverage. This really makes me question whether anyone should buy insurance other than when the law and mortgage companies require it. When I buy insurance, I don’t want a 50/50 chance of a closed no pay claim, especially given how high premiums are today and, moreover, how incredibly profitable insurance companies have become ($410 billion in the last three years).
‘Walking away from accountability makes a business irrelevant.’ What Is the Value?
What is the value in telling clients, “You only have coverage if you read the policy completely and understand all the language completely, and if you are not happy with it, it is your duty to advise the broker or carrier of the requested improvements”? What if the insured does not understand their own exposures or the policy language? I teach insurance classes, and people with insurance licenses struggle to understand the definition of household
members, much less how that definition varies from one policy to another. The replacement cost estimators used do not differentiate between true replacement cost versus replacement cost including ordinance and law coverage. Almost no one in the industry can point out how much ordinance coverage is required versus just replacement cost. How and why is it OK then to put this burden on insureds? Some insurance companies and agents like putting the burden on the insureds because it reduces their liability— i.e., it reduces accountability to provide a product that provides coverage more than 50% of the time. Imagine that! In some cases, agents’ E&O carriers tell them not to provide professional advice due to the added exposure. This is awesome advice for peddlers but not for professionals. Peddlers are unnecessary going forward with AI, or at least their commission rate only needs to be about 8%. A person can charge more when they accept accountability. The solution is simple but difficult to execute. First, create an insurance company that actually provides the expected coverage. This has already happened at higher levels of commercial insurance. The results are fantastic.
Accountability
Walking away from accountability makes a business irrelevant. Without laws and mortgage companies, most insurance companies and agents would already be irrelevant. Laws and mortgage companies subsidize their sales, even if they don’t recognize this reality. Historically, no one could walk away, but now they can have their own insurance companies, and the options are moving lower and lower in the food chain. I believe many insurance INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
companies think they’re like the post office and can’t be replaced. Maybe they cannot be entirely replaced, but they can definitely be made less important and less valuable. Carriers would be wise to accept responsibility if they want to remain viable. The second part is brokers stepping up. I am seeing new brokerages and other advisory businesses being created simply to advise insureds on their exposures and the coverages they need. These are experts who can read policies and understand exposures. For agents, I have one other suggestion: track claims by carrier. An attorney INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
might say the following differently, but due to disparagement laws designed to protect innocent agents and companies (but, in reality, protect questionable agents and companies), you cannot tell people bad things about insurance companies unless you have documentation. That is why I recommend tracking claims by carrier and then showing a consumer the results. When Company A’s rate is 20% lower, and you provide them with your data showing that it might be a lower rate because they only pay 50% of their claims, the consumer might think twice about accepting that lower rate.
A product that doesn’t work 50% of the time provides no value. Consumers have unknowingly become their own insurance companies given the exclusions and high deductibles. This fact alone means they need professional risk management advice. The value and opportunity are in helping insureds identify their exposures, providing risk mitigating solutions, and identifying carriers upfront that cover only 50% of their claims. Burand is the founder and owner of Burand & Associates LLC based in Mountainair, New Mexico. Phone: 719-485-3868. E-mail: chris@burand-associates.com. NOVEMBER 9, 2026 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | 43
Idea Exchange: Is It Covered?
Logic & Language and Forms & Facts Insurance Isn’t Enough
A
ccording to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), the U.S. averaged about six multi-billion-dollar By Bill Wilson weather-related disasters annually during the period 20002009. In 2010-2019, that number doubled to about 12 per year. Then, from 20202024, we experienced another doubling to about 23 per year. And not only frequency has increased, but so has severity. When we think of weather catastrophes, usually hurricanes are the first kind of phenomena that comes to mind, but the number of hurricanes during this period has not increased enough to explain the growth in losses. Major insurance loss
44 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
drivers are increasingly tied to severe convective storms that include hail and often straight-line or tornadic wind damage. Severity has also been impacted by isolated wildfires in expanding urban areas. These increased losses (along with reinsurance rate increases) have resulted in increases in property insurance rates significantly beyond normal inflation rates. Where premium relief has not been readily available, many insurers have withdrawn from marketplaces, limited access to coverage, or tightened eligibility requirements by sometimes mandating roof covering replacement. Many insurers have introduced coverage reductions in the form of higher deductibles (especially on wind and hail losses), exclusions and limitations for things like “cosmetic” damage, or limiting valuation of damage to certain
types of property only to ACV rather than replacement cost. So, what does this all mean? When insurance becomes unaffordable or unavailable, we must look to risk management alternatives. In fact, insurance should never be the sole risk management technique for addressing most loss exposures. When frequency and severity reach a tipping point, insurance no longer works and becomes unavailable for some and unaffordable for many others. In addition, as greater numbers of insureds are subject to increased loss frequency and/or severity, it becomes more and more difficult to spread the risk of loss—and insurance is all about risk transfer. Long before losses approach a statistical certainty and become truly uninsurable, we run out of people to spread risk to anyway. INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
Managing the Risk
“Risk management” approaches are often classed as (1) avoidance, (2) loss control (pre-loss prevention and post-loss reduction), (3) retention, (4) transfer (insurance/pooling and contractual indemnification), and (5) segregation of exposure units. When loss frequency and severity are low, risk retention is the most common approach. When loss frequency and severity are high, avoidance is virtually mandated. When loss frequency is high but severity is low, retention and loss prevention are the focus. When frequency is low and severity is high, risk transfer and loss reduction are the dominant approaches. If you have ever read my bio on my website or LinkedIn page, you know my early education and industry background was as a fire protection engineer. Most of my work involved underwriting and loss control property inspections for insurers, evaluating risk exposures ranging from Orand’s Barber Shop to FedEx’s aircraft facilities in Memphis. I also was one of the ISO public fire protection guys who rated cities and fire districts from PPC 1 to 10, evaluating fire departments, water systems, and codes enforcement. Last year, one of my college engineering classmates, Carl Baldassarra of the civil engineering firm Wiss, Janney, Elstner Associates Inc., reached out to me for some insurance information related to a presentation he was making at a Society of Fire Protection Engineers conference regarding large losses attributed to climate change or at least evolving weather patterns. His question was whether there was a need for changes in government regulations as occurred in the last century following urban fire conflagrations with regard to municipal water supplies, fire department standards, and local building and life safety codes.
improved building materials standards is a roofing product from a company called Brava that my friend and agent Tim Wahl, CIC of Missouri, told me about.
When insurance becomes unaffordable or unavailable, we must look to risk management alternatives. My understanding is that Brava shingles have a Class 4 hail rating and purport to be able to withstand winds of up to 188 mph with nails and 211 mph with screws. Tim got a sample of the slate-style shingle they offer and beat it mightily with a hammer without any visible damage. He indicated that the cost was about double that of typical asphalt shingles, increasing the cost of construction of a home by 5%-10%. Considering the cost of a home today, that seems to be a relatively small price to pay for near indestructability. If this type of wind-and-hail-resistant shingle was mass produced, the cost could probably drop substantially. Replacing existing roofs with construction of this type following a loss would increase the loss payment but likely make it highly unlikely that such an expense would reoccur in the future. Right now, I’m not sure if any insurers are granting premium credits for the use of such material. This is just one example of a potential solution that involves improved
construction standards and building code enhancements. For wildfires, land management is critical along with zoning restrictions, the latter also critical with regard to flood exposures. For some examples of wildfire solutions, check out several articles written by consultant John Putnam, CPCU, ARM at www.irmi.com (just search for John’s name to get a list of his articles addressing risk management issues involving wildfires). With regard to building codes, zoning ordinances, and land management, government involvement would obviously be critical but futile without the political will to implement and enforce such measures. As I’ve written before, I believe that the NFIP flood program and all its red ink could wash away if flood coverage, with a TRIA-like federal backstop, was built into all property policies and adequate codes and zoning were implemented and enforced by government at all levels. What do you think? Tune in again next month when we address some risk management measures insurers and insureds can do right now to reduce losses. Wilson, CPCU, ARM, AIM, AAM is the founder and CEO of InsuranceCommentary.com and the author of six books, including “When Words Collide…Resolving Insurance Coverage and Claims Disputes,” which BookAuthority ranked as the #1 insurance book of all time. He can be reached at Bill@InsuranceCommentary.com.
Improving Building Codes, Zoning Restrictions
I have blogged about this and discussed it extensively on LinkedIn in the past. I’m convinced that there is a significant need for more realistic building codes and zoning restrictions. A good example of INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
NOVEMBER 9, 2026 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | 45
Idea Exchange: Emerging Risks Emerging Risks to Watch: Geolocation Data, Extreme Heat, and Passive Homes
T
he insurance industry has long been shaped by its ability to identify, understand, and adapt to new forms of risk. Yet many emerging exposures don’t begin as obvious insurance concerns. Instead, they often By Lee Shavel arise quietly from technological innovation, shifting consumer behavior, evolving legal frameworks, or changes in the built environment. Several developments gaining attention today illustrate this dynamic. Increased reliance on geolocation data, the effects of extreme heat on buildings, and the rapid adoption of highly energy-efficient building designs each represent areas where evolving conditions could reshape exposures across multiple lines of business.
Geolocation and Liability
Geolocation data has become a routine feature of modern commerce, powering everything from mobile applications and connected vehicles to targeted advertisements. But as courts and regulators continue to examine the sensitivity of location information, businesses that collect, store,
46 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
share, or monetize this data may face new questions about privacy obligations and potential liability. This personal data generally refers to information that identifies or indicates the geographic location of a device, user, or object through technologies such as GPS, IP address tracking, Wi-Fi triangulation, and cellular network signals. Though this has historically been relegated to cellphone usage, geolocation data can now be collected from a wide range of Wi-Fi technologies and Bluetooth-enabled products, from wearable devices and rideshare platforms to robotic lawnmowers. As a result, a broad range of industries today collect, process, retain, and, in some cases, monetize geolocation information. Retailers and advertising firms, for instance, can now leverage location information to measure foot traffic, analyze consumer behavior, and deliver targeted marketing. Other industries, such as wearable device manufacturers, may use location data to help measure health and physical activity diagnostics, while financial institutions could utilize this data to help detect fraud. Though no single comprehensive federal privacy law governing the collection and retention of personal data presently exists, a 2026 U.S. Supreme Court ruling
could lead to increased judicial sensitivity to the collection and use—or potential abuse—of such data. In Chatrie v. United States, the Supreme Court held that law enforcement’s use of a geofence warrant to obtain a suspect’s personal location data constituted a search under the Fourth Amendment. The decision held that individuals have a reasonable expectation of privacy in their cellphone location records. As privacy laws, regulatory requirements, and litigation involving geolocation data continue to develop, organizations that collect or use such information may face increased legal, compliance, and risk management considerations, raising the potential for claims, such as cyber, technology errors and omissions, directors and officers, and professional liability exposures.
Heat Risks to Buildings
The record-setting temperatures across much of the U.S. and Europe this summer are just the latest warning sign of a rapidly heating planet. While the human health risks of extreme heat exposure are well documented, high temperatures also have the potential to create specific exposures for multiple lines of business. According to one study published in the Journal of Engineering (August 2025), curing temperatures can alter concrete’s microstructure, making concrete durability highly sensitive to temperatures that are too hot or too cold. High temperatures can accelerate or inhibit cement hydration, which can then affect several factors that contribute to concrete stability, including pore structure, microcrack development, and permeability. Steel may face its own heat-related pressures. A 2025 study published in Buildings, an international, peer-reviewed, open access journal on building science by MDPI, examined how structural steel performed INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
under temperature-humidity cycles and found that humid environments caused corrosion that increased with repeated exposure. The researchers reported that this repeated corrosion damage also substantially reduced the strength, ductility, and fatigue life of steel over time. If heat is hard on the materials required for building, it’s harder still on the individuals working with them. Construction workers accounted for approximately a third of occupational heat-related deaths between 1992 and 2016—even though they account for around 6% of the overall workforce, according to a 2019 study. Such risks to worker safety may only increase alongside temperatures as heat waves become longer and more frequent across many regions of the U.S. Less favorable working conditions associated with extreme heat may understandably affect productivity in the construction sector, potentially contributing to insurance implications such as project delays, cost overruns, and heightened safety risks on job sites.
super-insulated envelope with airtight construction methods, incorporates air barriers, and eliminates thermal bridges at junctions while heat recovery ventilation systems supply continuous fresh air. Proponents suggest that passive building may use up to 90% less heating and cooling energy than conventional construction—a potentially significant incentive for builders and homeowners, considering buildings account for nearly 37% of U.S. energy consumption. That draw is translating into real-world adoption: Phius, a leading certifier of passive houses in the U.S., reported a record 155 design certifications were completed in 2025, with the median project jumping from roughly 6,000-7,000 square feet between 2019 and 2024 to 25,000 square feet—driven in part by a surge in multifamily building projects in states such as New York and Massachusetts. Yet many of the same features that may contribute to the energy efficiency of passive buildings—such as air tightness and heavy insulation—may also introduce distinct risk considerations. One area frequently discussed is moisture. Due to airtight design, humidity that may have escaped a conventional structure typically must instead be removed mechanically. The American Society of Civil Engineers
has identified mold as a potential unintended consequence of certain energy-efficient construction approaches, citing instances where insulation blocked airflow entirely. And while passive design standards generally incorporate hygiene and moisture-control criteria intended to prevent mold, rot, and corrosion, sustained long-term performance may also depend on the proper operation of ventilation and related systems by building inhabitants and property managers. Overheating has also been identified as a potential concern. A 2024 review of existing research on passive housing performance found that overheating risks have been reported across numerous climate regions, largely influenced by building characteristics, climate conditions, and occupant behavior. The authors further noted that increasing temperatures and other climate-related factors may only exacerbate those challenges. While these three risks span different domains, each illustrates how shifting societal, environmental, and technological trends can create new exposures. For insurers, it’s critical to recognize these signals early and adapt strategies to manage potential risks. Shavel is president and chief executive officer of Verisk, a data analytics and technology partner to the global insurance industry. He brings nearly 30 years of experience advising and leading publicly traded companies to Verisk.
Passive Home, Active Risks?
Rising energy costs and growing interest in lower-carbon living solutions have led many homeowners in recent years to embrace various energy-efficient construction approaches, such as passive housing design. But these designs may have built-in risk for insurers. A passive house is designed to tightly contain heat during colder months and keep it out during warmer months, while continuously cycling fresh air through the home. The design typically combines a INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
NOVEMBER 9, 2026 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | 47
Idea Exchange: Minding Your Business Revenue Quality: All Dollars Are Not the Same
M
ost agency owners can quickly cite their revenue, growth rate, margin, and retention. None of those measures answer a more basic question: How good is the revenue behind the numbers? Consider two agencies that each report $1 million of By Catherine Oak revenue. One agency is mostly renewal commissions from a diversified, profitably serviced book with strong retention and agency-owned relationships. A and Bill Schoeffler second agency leans on volatile contingent income, a few large accounts, one carrier, and one rainmaker. On paper, they’re twins. In practice, the second agency is one resignation or one carrier decision away from a very different year. That difference is revenue quality. Buyers scrutinize it in a sale, but owners should ask the same questions long before one, because the answers sharpen everyday decisions about staffing, carriers, and budgets. The same $1 million can be priced differently when a buyer haircuts contingent income, puts a retention collar on the earnout, or treats a rainmaker book as a key-person risk. High-quality revenue has six characteristics. It is recurring, retained, diversified, profitable, predictable, and transferable.
profit-sharing income can be valuable but varies with carrier results, market conditions, and the agency’s mix of business. Management should separate core recurring commissions and fees from less predictable revenue. Other income still counts; the point is to know how much of the revenue base can reasonably be expected to repeat.
Retained
Retention shows whether recurring revenue recurs. Agency-wide averages can hide problems: A 90% overall rate may look acceptable while one producer or segment is losing profitable accounts much faster. Examine retention by line of business, producer, office, carrier, and customer segment. A typical benchmark for retention is about 95% for both personal and commercial lines, and again may vary by carrier, producer, etc. Carrier statements also give the agency’s retention rates, so looking at them will provide that information. Also distinguish revenue retention from account retention. Keeping one very large account can mask the loss of 10 small ones, while losing one large account can make
revenue retention look poor even when nearly every customer stays.
Diversified
An agency can be profitable and growing yet carry substantial risk if too much revenue depends on a few clients, producers, carriers, or industries. If one account represents 10% of revenue, losing it creates an immediate problem. If a large share is tied to one rainmaker, what happens if that producer retires or leaves? And appetite changes, commission cuts, or a terminated appointment can suddenly affect a large block of carrier revenue. Some concentration is normal, and some can be a strength. A niche agency whose book is 70% contractors is not the same as an agency whose book is 70% one contractor. Carrier concentration in a hard market can be a relationship, not a flaw, until the appointment is the only one. The danger is learning how much concentration one has after the account, producer, or carrier is gone.
Profitable
Revenue quality also depends on what it costs to produce and service. Two
Recurring
Much of an agency’s revenue repeats as policies renew, but not every source recurs to the same degree. Renewal commissions on a stable book differ from a one-time bond, a builder’s risk policy, a term life case, or a consulting fee. Contingent and 48 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
commercial accounts may each generate $20,000 in commission. One renews smoothly with little staff time. The other requires extensive certificates, frequent endorsements, repeated remarketing, and claims involvement. Once staff time is counted, the second account may contribute far less to profit. Agencies do not need perfect activitybased costing. Reasonable estimates of producer compensation, service payroll, and other direct costs can show which books, segments, and lines of business contribute the most.
for bonuses, if they occur.
producer retires, a carrier pulls back, or the market turns.
Transferable
Transferability usually comes up when an agency is for sale. It matters long before that. If an owner or senior producer disappeared tomorrow, would the account manager know the client? Renewal information should live in the agency management system, not in someone’s head, and major relationships should involve more than one person. Producer agreements should also clearly address ownership of accounts and expirations. Producers should stay at the center of their client relationships; the agency just needs to be in the room, too. That matters as much for internal perpetuation as it does for a sale.
Oak is the founder and president of Oak and Associates, an international consulting firm to the insurance industry with offices in Sonoma, California and Bend, Oregon. Schoeffler is a financial analyst. Email: catoak@gmail.com. Phone: 707-935-6565. Website: www.oakandassociates.com.
Advertisers Index
When analyzing the numbers, don’t try to boil it down to a single “revenue quality score”; some concentration or variability may be appropriate. The value is in seeing where the agency is most vulnerable and where attention can reduce risk or improve profitability. A good management discussion asks two questions: How much revenue do we have, and how good is it? An agency that holds up well on these six measures is far better positioned when a key
Amalgamated Insurance Underwriters www.aiu-usa.com W1, S1, E1, M1 Burns & Wilcox www.burnsandwilcox.com 11 EMC Insurance www.emcinsurance.com 13 Encova www.encova.com SC2, S3, E2, M2 Hudson Insurance Company www.hudsoninsgroup.com 15 IICF www.iicf.org 51 Ironpeak www.ironpeak.com 5 Liberty Mutual www.libertymutual.com 31 National General www.nationalgeneral.com 9 Philadelphia Insurance Companies www.phly.com 7 Safety National www.safetynational.com 19 Shelly, Middlebrooks & O’Leary www.shellyins.com S3 SPG - Specialty Program Group www.specialtyprogramgroup.com/wholesale 17 United Risk www.unitedrisk.global 52 United States Postal Service www.usps.com/directresults 2
November 9, 2026
November 9, 2026
November 9, 2026
Park Avenue Life Insurance Company 10 Hudson Yards, New York, NY 10001
Federal Life Insurance Company 1 Overlook Point, Suite 265, Lincolnshire, IL 60069
ProCentury Insurance Company 200 N.Grand Avenue Lansing, MI 48933
The above company has made application to the Division of Insurance to amend their Foreign Company License to transact Variable Life or Variable Annuities in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts.
The above company has made application to the Division of Insurance to obtain a Certificate of Authority to transact Life, Accident, and Health Insurance in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts.
Any person having any information regarding the company which relates to its suitability for the license or authority the applicant has requested is asked to notify the Division by personal letter to the Commissioner of Insurance, 1 Federal Street, Suite 700, Boston, MA 02110, Attn: Financial Surveillance and Company Licensing within 14 days of the date of this notice.
Any person having any information regarding the company which relates to its suitability for the license or authority the applicant has requested is asked to notify the Division by personal letter to the Commissioner of Insurance, 1 Federal Street, Suite 700, Boston, MA 02110, Attn: Financial Surveillance and Company Licensing within 14 days of the date of this notice.
Predictable
Staffing, compensation, technology, and owner distributions are commitments made today based on expectations about tomorrow’s revenue. Even a high-retention book moves with rates and market shifts, but it is a far more dependable planning base than revenue that swings from year to year. Contingent income is the classic example. It can contribute significantly to profit, but it should not support permanent fixed expenses. Build the operating budget on core commission and fee revenue alone, then layer in contingent and other variable income. That shows whether normal operations are sound on their own. Contingents then can be used
INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
Summary
The above company has made application to the Division of Insurance to amend their Foreign Company License to transact Property and Casualty Insurance in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. Any person having any information regarding the company which relates to its suitability for the license or authority the applicant has requested is asked to notify the Division by personal letter to the Commissioner of Insurance, 1 Federal Street, Suite 700, Boston, MA 02110, Attn: Financial Surveillance and Company Licensing within 14 days of the date of this notice.
NOVEMBER 9, 2026 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | 49
Closing Quote Unquoted Is a Status, Not a Verdict
By Dmitry Borovoy
M
ore than 20,000 unbound commercial auto accounts sit in a public file that updates every morning, and in my experience few of the agents who could work it have ever opened it. On Oct. 26, the pending queue at the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration stood at 23,708 applications for operating authority, one record per authority type. In 22,636 of them (95%), the liability insurance field was empty. Set aside brokers and freight forwarders, who file a bond or trust fund instead. What remains is 20,884 motor carriers stalled on the same form, the BMC-91 or BMC-91X, the insurer’s certificate that liability coverage is in force. No applicant can file it; only the insurer can, once
the policy is bound. Until then, there is no authority, and the $300 fee is not coming back. Those are the three numbers. Nearly every record is a company that has paid its way into trucking and has not been bound by anyone. A second pass on Oct. 23 found 42% of that pool also missing a process agent designation, the routine Form BOC-3 naming who accepts legal papers for the carrier. When both are missing, in my experience, nobody qualified has started on the file.
Why the Standard Market Says No Before Price A first-year company with no policy behind it is not quoted and bound as a matter of routine. The programs that do consider it compare the submission with the carrier’s own FMCSA record before anyone talks rate. In my own book of business, four screens end most of these files. Geography comes first. The policy state, the state where the truck is garaged, and the
state on the driver’s commercial driver’s license have to agree. An owner-operator who formed the company in one state and parks the truck in another, as many first-generation immigrant carriers do, stops here. The license date is second. Most programs look hard at a CDL issued recently, and some also want proof of time on the same class of truck the applicant will run. Claims are third. If the company held a policy before, the underwriter wants its loss runs, and some want them dated within the past 30 days. One open claim on those runs closes the standard channel. Equipment is fourth. A car hauler, a hotshot pickup, a refrigerated trailer, and a cargo van are underwritten as four separate risks, and the type decides whether any market will take the file at all. The public file shows none of this, only an empty insurance field.
What the Quick ‘No’ Can Cost the Caller
Here is what the producer who says no in two minutes does not see. Under 49 CFR 365.109T, both the insurance filing and the process agent designation are due 20 days after the application’s publication date in the agency’s daily FMCSA Register. Miss that and FMCSA serves a notice allowing 60 more days, then dismisses the application. Dismissal means starting over, and reapplying under the same docket number costs $300 again. 50 | INSURANCE JOURNAL | NOVEMBER 9, 2026
The applicant usually cannot see that clock. In Motus, the registration portal FMCSA opened to registrants in May, a pending carrier sees one line: A financial responsibility filing is required.
‘Uninsurable is a verdict, and a verdict takes a producer who reads the FMCSA record…’ The date the 20 days began is printed in the Register and in a letter FMCSA mails that day, and most applicants read neither. The caller who was turned away has a truck payment due, a federal file aging toward dismissal, and no idea which of the four screens stopped it. The next agency will give the same two minutes, because no one has opened the FMCSA record, fixed whatever on it does not match the application, or said what the first payment will look like. Unquoted is a status. Uninsurable is a verdict, and a verdict takes a producer who reads the FMCSA record, matches it to the application, and puts the file in front of an underwriter who writes new ventures. Of the new ventures that come to me believing they were declined, most had never had that. They were not declined. They were unquoted. Borovoy is the founder of TruckerNavi, an FMCSA compliance service, and a producer with SafeBridge Insurance. He is also the author of the book Safety Manager. INSURANCEJOURNAL.COM
P L EASE JOI N US FOR THE 15 T H ANNUAL
I I CF SO UTHEAST GALA
THE SUNNIES: Glimmers of Hope A G A L A C E L E B R A T I N G C O M M U N I T Y A N D L A S T I N G I M PA C T
THURSDAY, MARCH 4, 2027 LI VE ! BY LO EW S , AR L I N GTO N , T EXAS
MEET OUR 2 0 2 7 S O U T H E A S T P H I L A N T H R O P I C L E A D E R S H I P AWA R D R E C I P I E N T
MARK SHULTS
Head of Sales & Distribution, Middle & Large Business The Hartford Reserve your sponsorship and purchase tickets at: https://bit.ly/IICFSoutheastGala2027 Proceeds will benefit the IICF Southeast Community Grants Program and our nonprofit partners focused on education, children at risk, veterans and military families and disaster preparedness and relief.
Winning today takes dedication, expertise, and talent
Today driving distances on tour are over 320 yards. In 1985 driving distances averaged 256 yards.
Luke Donald Ryder Cup Captain, Team Europe 2023 & 2025 Former World Number One.
Luke Donald knows the game has evolved. As a winning Ryder Cup Captain, he chooses his players carefully.
The Global Choice for Apex Underwriting Professionals.
©2026 United Risk Global
At United Risk, we unite elite capability backed by proven results. A magnet for apex underwriting professionals committed to free enterprise and success.