LEADING WITH INTEGRITY IN A DIGITAL AGE
CEYHUN PEHLIVAN
ILIANA GROSSE-BUENING, ALINA KUKARINA
CERI LAWLEY
TY FRANCIS MBE
VERA CHEREPANOVA
ANNABEL GILLARD
REMI SMEETS, DIRK DE BILDE
KATJA BECHTEL
PATRICK WELLENS
BILJANA CVETANOVSKA GUGOSKA
CONTENTS 9
INTEGRITY IN THE DIGITAL AGE: THE CHALLENGE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
15
WHAT DOES INTEGRITY REQUIRE OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION? A COMPASS FOR A FLOURISHING FUTURE
23
PRESERVING HUMAN JUDGMENT IN THE AGE OF AI
31
ABSOLUTION ENGINES
39
BOARD ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE AGE OF AI
45
TRANSPARENCY, TRACEABILITY AND ETHICS BY DESIGN
51
PUTTING PEOPLE AT THE CENTRE OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION: DIGNITY, INCLUSION, AND LIFELONG LEARNING IN AN AGE OF AI
57
WHO OWNS INTEGRITY IN A VALUE CHAIN?
65
INTEGRITY CHALLENGES IN SOCIAL MEDIA
73
TRUST, DEMOCRACY AND CIVIC SPACE IN A DIGITAL WORLD
FOREWORD It is a pleasure to introduce this publication on “Leading with Integrity in a Digital Age” as part of the 10th ICC Netherlands “Week in Integrity”. This edition focuses on how organisations keep human judgment, honesty and trust at the centre as AI reshapes the way decisions are made. We have seen how AI technologies have the potential to broaden personalised access to information and resources, bridging the digital divide and empowering individuals worldwide. As we know, Artificial Intelligence is a technology that enables the simulation or extension of human intelligence in machines, allowing them to perform tasks commonly associated with human intelligence, such as speech recognition, content creation, problem-solving and learning, with the potential to boost productivity and augment creativity. From online education platforms to AI-powered language translation tools breaking down language barriers, AI has accelerated the spread of knowledge and opportunities. Unlike previous technological revolutions, AI’s broad accessibility creates the potential for individuals, businesses, and communities everywhere to participate in and benefit from it. Realising this potential, however, depends on putting the right enabling conditions in place. It is against the backdrop of great promise and potential challenges that the imperative emerges for leadership to preserve trust in the use of AI. Inclusive AI adoption is essential to ensuring that the benefits of AI contribute to sustainable development, economic growth and shared prosperity. By “inclusive AI”, we mean building AI systems that are accessible, fair and beneficial to all. Achieving this objective requires ensuring that AI systems are designed and deployed in ways that reflect human-centered design and end-user needs. As AI continues to evolve, it is essential to strike a balance between realising its full potential for socioeconomic development, while ensuring that it aligns with globally shared values for equality, transparency, fairness, and a human-centric approach. Effective governance of AI requires international cooperation. A cohesive framework for such cooperation should prioritise convergence of governance standards to prevent fragmentation of the policy landscape. There needs to be an international approach that will enable industry standards, domestic regulation, and global governance to come together and reinforce one another. These policy frameworks must be rooted in democratic principles and designed to anticipate and address potential risks and challenges. Also, policy frameworks should recognise the diverse roles and responsibilities of stakeholders throughout the AI lifecycle, from development to deployment and beyond. Related to this, laws should distribute responsibility across the value chain appropriately. Critical policy areas to look out for in artificial intelligence include data governance, safety and security, inclusion and inclusive access, environmental sustainability, competition and mis- and disinformation. AI governance frameworks should be risk-based, proportionate, technology-neutral and sufficiently flexible to evolve alongside technological progress. Policymakers should commit to long-term AI strategies, seek to avoid policy fragmentation and support interoperability through international cooperation, market-driven standards and crossborder collaboration.
4
Week of Integrity
Building on existing international frameworks and standards, such approaches can help build trust while enabling innovation and wider adoption. Leadership needs the right policy frameworks and direction from business, to ensure that AI technologies are designed, deployed and utilised in ways that align with ethical considerations, human rights, and the welfare of society. We know that trust and safety are essential to ensuring AI is adopted widely and used with confidence. Governments should work with business, researchers and experts to align on safety evaluation and testing methods, interoperability, transparency and disclosure practices, mechanisms for user redress, and shared approaches to mitigating potential risks and harms, so that safeguards keep pace with the technology and people adopt AI with confidence in its benefits. The International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) views a multistakeholder model— bringing together businesses, governments, civil society, and technical experts—as essential to shaping future-proof governance and promoting trust in artificial intelligence. We emphasize the need for harmonized, risk-based policies to ensure greater alignment across regional frameworks that hinder cross-border data flows and erode consumer trust. Business brings expertise, infrastructure, technical capabilities, investment and implementation experience that can complement public policy objectives and help scale impact. Industry and multistakeholder initiatives on AI policy and governance serve as valuable learning tools for policymakers and fellow industry stakeholders alike. These examples demonstrate the effectiveness of various approaches to address societal implications of AI technologies. By maintaining a dynamic repository of best practices, ICC fosters knowledge-sharing and encourages the adoption of responsible AI practices across diverse contexts and industries. In conclusion, ICC has long been a trusted partner for promoting trade based on integrity, trust and the rule of law, and ICC stands poised to continue to contribute leadership and expertise toward the responsible development and use of AI. We welcome the ICC Netherlands initiative to foster discussion of solutions to increase trust in the AI, for both economic betterment, and for the greater good.
John W.H. Denton AO ICC Secretary General
Leading with integrity in a digital age
5
OPENING REMARKS Intelligence may be artificial, integrity never is “Confidential Board Appointment Aligned with Your Leadership Experience.” Who would not be interested in opening an email with a heading like that? It certainly attracted my attention when I received it recently. The message was flattering and seemingly well informed about my background. It referred to a confidential board search and my potential fit. It looked professional and included what appeared to be an appropriate signature from a global executive search firm. Still, something did not feel quite right. I did not know the recruiter. A quick search of the company name produced an unexpected connection with an entirely different business. The sender used a Gmail account, and even his name was not written as one would expect. I then looked up the person on LinkedIn. He existed and worked in HR, but his profile did not fit the message either. I contacted him to let him know that his identity might be being used for impersonation. Once I started checking, the red flags became quite visible. What made the message effective was that, at first sight, it was entirely plausible. I do not know whether AI was used in this particular attempt. But AI undoubtedly makes it easier to create convincing content, personalise communication and operate at scale. At the same time, we increasingly use AI ourselves — legitimately — to analyse information, create content, support decisions, and improve the way we work. For me, that creates a very practical leadership challenge. The better we understand and use AI ourselves, the better equipped we are to recognise both its possibilities and its risks. Senior leaders and board members do not need to become technical experts. But neither can we afford to treat AI as something that belongs only to specialists. We need enough hands-on understanding to know what questions to ask, what to verify, and when human judgement matters. As Vera Cherepanova writes in her contribution to this Book of Essays: “Board accountability in the digital age does not mean that directors must become technologists.” But boards do have to understand the conditions under which AI is introduced and what it means for strategy, people and accountability. That brings me to a second point: human responsibility must remain visible. When AI contributes to something going wrong, “the AI did it” cannot be the end of the inquiry. We need to understand who instructed, designed, deployed or monitored the technology and where responsibility ultimately sits. Where AI is deliberately used for fraud or other wrongdoing, we must investigate the human conduct and intent behind it. One of the essays in this volume puts this very simply: “Professional duties remain human duties.” And finally, keeping a human somewhere in a process is not enough. Human oversight only works when people have the knowledge, authority and willingness to question what technology produces and to intervene where necessary.
6
Week of Integrity
These questions go directly to the theme of this year’s tenth Week of Integrity: Leading with Integrity in a Digital Age. The programme deliberately looks beyond AI and digitalization itself to leadership, judgement, trust, cyber security, supply chains, misinformation and the integrity of public debate. The essays in this book do the same. They approach digital integrity from very different perspectives: boards, professional responsibility, value chains, civil society, and trust. Katja Bechtel captures one of the tensions particularly well when she writes: “Data may increasingly become the language through which organisations communicate trust.” Yet her essay also reminds us that trust itself still depends on relationships, judgement and the ability to act responsibly on the information we have. That, for me, is ultimately the point. Technology may change rapidly. Intelligence may increasingly be artificial. Integrity remains a human responsibility. As in previous editions, this Book of Essays brings together different voices rather than offering one answer. We hope it will encourage reflection, discussion and, above all, better questions about the choices leaders and organisations make in a digital age. We extend our gratitude to the distinguished contributors whose essays enrich this volume. Through the Week of Integrity and this Book of Essays, ICC Netherlands seeks to inspire courageous ethical leadership in business and beyond. We wish you an insightful and thought-provoking reading experience.”
Mirjam Bakker-Vergouw Chair, ICC Netherlands Mirjam Bakker-Vergouw is an international Executive and Non-Executive Director with over 30 years of experience across industry, banking and insurance. She has led major transformations in complex organisations, strengthening governance, decision-making, culture and execution. Her executive roles include Chief Compliance Officer at ABN AMRO, Group Risk & Compliance Director at SBM Offshore and Global Head of Compliance at Aegon. She brings extensive experience in navigating regulatory scrutiny, organisational transformation and complex stakeholder environments. Mirjam is Chair of ICC Netherlands, bringing together business, government and civil society around responsible business conduct and international trade.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
7
INTEGRITY IN THE DIGITAL AGE: THE CHALLENGE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE Ceyhun Pehlivan Ceyhun Necati Pehlivan is one of the leading lawyers in technology and digital law in Spain and across Europe. He is the founder and managing partner of Cornerstone Counsel, a boutique law firm specialised in strategic advice on technology, digital regulation, data governance, artificial intelligence, and cybersecurity. Previously, he worked and led the Technology and Intellectual Property practice at leading international law firms in Madrid, where for almost two decades he advised on some of the most sophisticated and high-profile matters in the market. His practice focuses on advising multinational corporations, scale-ups, investors, and digital platforms on regulatory, transactional, governance, and compliance issues relating to AI, data protection, cybersecurity, digital services, IT contracts, and emerging technologies. Ceyhun is widely recognised by major international legal directories. Chambers & Partners ranks him as a Leading Individual in TMT: Data Protection in Europe, while Legal 500 recently named him Next Generation Partner of the Year in Spain and Portugal. He has also been recognised by Iberian Lawyer, Global Data Review, and Best Lawyers for his outstanding work in privacy, cybersecurity, and technology law. Alongside his legal practice, he maintains an active academic and thought leadership profile. He is Adjunct Professor and Academic Director at IE Law School and lectures regularly on digital regulation, AI governance, integrity and compliance. He is also the founder and editor of the Global Privacy Law Review and co-editor of leading publications on AI and digital regulation. Leading with integrity in a digital age
9
CEYHUN PEHLIVAN
INTEGRITY IN THE DIGITAL AGE: THE CHALLENGE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE Integrity has long been a cornerstone of legal practice and professional conduct. Traditionally associated with honesty, accountability, consistency, and adherence to ethical principles, integrity presupposes transparent decision-making and identifiable human responsibility. Yet these assumptions are increasingly challenged in a world shaped by digitalisation and artificial intelligence (AI). As AI systems become embedded in legal practice – from legal research and contract review to judicial decision-making and compliance systems – the legal profession confronts a fundamental question: can traditional notions of integrity survive in an age of algorithmic decision-making? AI presents both an opportunity and a risk. On the one hand, AI promises greater efficiency, consistency, and analytical capability. On the other hand, it introduces significant concerns relating to transparency, accountability, bias, confidentiality, and trust. The challenge is no longer whether AI will transform legal practice, but whether that transformation can remain aligned with the values that integrity represents.
The Traditional Understanding of Integrity Integrity in professional life has historically encompassed truthfulness, reliability, consistency, and adherence to ethical standards. In legal practice, integrity requires maintaining client confidentiality, avoiding conflicts of interest, exercising independent judgement, and upholding the rule of law. Traditional frameworks of integrity are built around clear human agency. They assume that decision-makers can explain their reasoning, justify their conduct, and ultimately be held accountable for their choices. Legal systems and professional rules were developed in a world where technology functioned merely as a passive tool under direct human control. AI fundamentally challenges this assumption. AI systems increasingly participate in decision-making processes in ways that are often difficult to understand, explain, or scrutinise. As a result, many of the traditional safeguards supporting integrity become harder to apply.
10
Week of Integrity
AI and the Integrity Paradox AI creates a paradox for integrity. In theory, AI should strengthen integrity by improving consistency, reducing human error, and enabling more objective analysis. Machine learning systems can process vast amounts of information, identify patterns humans might overlook, and apply rules with remarkable speed and precision. At the same time, AI introduces risks that directly threaten core principles of integrity. One of the most significant challenges is the lack of transparency associated with many advanced AI systems. Certain machine learning models operate as “black boxes,” meaning that even developers may struggle to explain precisely how a particular conclusion was reached. This lack of explainability conflicts with one of the foundations of integrity: the ability to justify, understand, and scrutinise decisions. The legal profession depends heavily on reasoned analysis and accountability. Lawyers, judges, and regulators are expected not only to reach conclusions, but to explain them. Reliance on opaque systems therefore raises difficult questions. Can legal professionals responsibly rely on tools they do not fully understand? Can accountability exist without transparency? AI also challenges the notion of moral judgement itself. While AI systems may apply programmed rules consistently, they do not possess ethical reasoning, empathy, or contextual understanding. They cannot truly weigh fairness, justice, or proportionality in the human sense. Integrity therefore cannot simply be reduced to computational consistency. The paradox is clear: AI may improve technical accuracy whilst simultaneously weakening transparency, accountability, and human responsibility.
Key Integrity Challenges in AI Algorithmic Bias and Fairness AI systems learn from historical data, which may contain existing social biases and inequalities. As a result, AI systems can unintentionally reproduce – and in some cases amplify – discriminatory patterns or unfair outcomes. Examples already exist across multiple sectors. Facial recognition systems have shown lower accuracy rates for ethnic minorities, recruitment algorithms have discriminated against female candidates, and predictive policing tools have disproportionately targeted marginalised communities. Similar concerns arise in legal contexts involving sentencing recommendations and automated compliance systems. The integrity challenge lies not only in biased outcomes, but in the false perception of neutrality. AI systems are often viewed as objective simply because they rely on data and algorithms. In reality, they may encode historical inequalities and subjective assumptions.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
11
Accountability and Responsibility Traditional legal and ethical systems are based on identifiable responsibility. AI complicates this framework. When an AI system produces an incorrect or harmful outcome, responsibility may become fragmented between developers, deployers, organisations, and end users. This creates the risk of a “responsibility gap” in which accountability becomes diffuse and unclear. For legal professionals, this issue is particularly significant. A lawyer cannot simply defer responsibility by claiming that “the algorithm decided”. Professional duties remain human duties. AI may assist legal work, but it cannot replace personal accountability or independent professional judgement. Data Protection and Confidentiality AI systems require enormous quantities of data, raising important concerns regarding privacy, confidentiality, cybersecurity, and the protection of personal data. In legal practice, these concerns are especially sensitive because lawyers routinely handle confidential, privileged, and highly sensitive personal information. The use of cloud-based AI tools may create uncertainty regarding where data is stored, who can access it, and whether information is used for further model training. These issues can create significant risks under data protection frameworks such as the GDPR, as well as under professional duties of confidentiality. At the same time, the reliability of AI outputs depends heavily on the quality of training data. Inaccurate or outdated datasets can produce flawed outcomes, often without users fully appreciating the risks involved. Authenticity and Deepfakes The emergence of generative AI, namely AI systems capable of producing humanlike text, images, audio and video content, creates additional integrity risks by making it increasingly easy to generate convincing synthetic material. AI systems are now capable of generating fabricated legal authorities, forged documents, manipulated images, and realistic deepfake recordings. Recent cases involving lawyers submitting fictitious AI-generated case law to courts demonstrate that these risks are no longer theoretical. This development challenges fundamental assumptions regarding authenticity and trust in legal and commercial environments. Legal professionals must therefore adopt heightened verification standards and exercise increased scepticism regarding digital evidence and AI-generated materials.
Maintaining Integrity in an AI-Enabled World Preserving integrity in the digital age requires evolution rather than abandonment of core principles. Transparency and Explainability AI systems used in sensitive or high-risk contexts should be sufficiently transparent to allow meaningful scrutiny and accountability. Users must understand the 12
Week of Integrity
capabilities, limitations, and risks associated with AI systems, particularly where legal rights or significant commercial interests are involved. Human Oversight and Independent Judgement AI should support human decision-making, not replace it entirely. Meaningful human oversight remains essential, particularly in legal contexts involving rights, obligations, and significant consequences. Lawyers and decisionmakers must retain the ability – and responsibility – to question, verify, and override AI-generated outputs where necessary. Education and Technological Competence Maintaining integrity in the digital age also requires greater technological literacy. Legal professionals do not necessarily need to become software engineers, but they must develop sufficient understanding of AI systems to use them responsibly, recognise their limitations, and identify potential risks. Ethical AI Development and Regulation Developers of AI systems also bear significant responsibility. Integrity should be embedded into AI systems from the outset through responsible design choices, robust testing, diverse datasets, and ongoing monitoring. At the same time, regulatory and professional frameworks must continue evolving to address AI-specific risks while preserving innovation. Recent regulatory initiatives, such as the EU AI Act represent important steps towards establishing standards for transparency, accountability, and trustworthy AI governance. However, regulation alone cannot guarantee integrity. Ultimately, maintaining trust in AI-enabled environments will depend upon ensuring that human responsibility remains at the centre of decision-making and that technological advancement does not come at the expense of ethical judgement.
Conclusion Integrity in the digital age is not about resisting technological change, but about ensuring that innovation remains anchored in human responsibility and ethical judgement. AI can strengthen legal systems if deployed transparently, responsibly, and under meaningful human oversight. Equally, it can undermine trust and fairness if efficiency is allowed to eclipse accountability. For legal professionals, integrity increasingly requires technological literacy, critical scrutiny of AI systems, and the courage to retain independent judgement in the face of algorithmic authority. Transparency, accountability, fairness, and human oversight must remain non-negotiable principles. The true challenge is not whether AI can act with integrity, but whether those who design, deploy, and rely upon it can ensure that integrity remains at the heart of decision-making.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
13
WHAT DOES INTEGRITY REQUIRE OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION? A COMPASS FOR A FLOURISHING FUTURE Iliana Grosse-Buening Iliana Grosse-Buening is an AI ethics and digital wellbeing expert working at the intersection of technology, ethics and human flourishing. She is Co-Founder and CEO of Deeply Human Innovation, a strategy, research and design firm advancing humanity-centred innovation. She serves as Chair of the IEEE Global AI Systems Flourishing Initiative and is an expert with UNESCO’s AI Ethics Experts Without Borders network. She is also Adjunct Professor of Digital Wellbeing at IE University and IE Business School, and an Affiliate of the IE UNESCO Chair for AI Ethics and Governance. With more than a decade of international experience across five continents, Iliana advises multinational companies, global charities, universities and public institutions on AI ethics, digital wellbeing and responsible innovation. Her research has been published by Springer Nature and De Gruyter.
Alina Kukarina Alina Kukarina is an engineer, and strategist working at the intersection of business, technology, and human psychology. With an interdisciplinary background spanning engineering, law, life sciences, and communication, Alina bridges technical architecture with operations and implementation. She trained professionals in responsible innovation and agile development and has guided complex digital transformation initiatives, enterprise systems, and product strategies for global organisations, ensuring technological adoption translates into sustainable business value and ethical integrity. Her insights on the human element in tech transformation and digital innovation are featured in Entrepreneur and tnw. She is Co-Founder of Deeply Human Innovation and has published in Springer Integrated Science.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
15
ILIANA GROSSE-BUENING, ALINA KUKARINA
WHAT DOES INTEGRITY REQUIRE OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION? A COMPASS FOR A FLOURISHING FUTURE “Sustainable solutions based on innovation can create a more resilient world only if that innovation is focused on the health and well-being of its inhabitants. And it is at that point—where technology and human needs intersect—that we will find meaningful innovation.” (Frans van Houten, former CEO, Philips) For decades, technological progress has been closely tied to the idea of human progress. Digital technologies have reshaped how we live, learn and connect, widening access to knowledge, communication and opportunities in ways previously unimaginable. Yet, technological progress does not automatically translate into human progress. The effects of digitalisation are wide-ranging, interconnected and often contradictory (Gluckman & Allen, 2018; Floridi & Burr, 2023). Digital technologies can promote autonomy, competence and connection while also undermining these same dimensions of wellbeing, depending on how they are designed, deployed and integrated into people’s lives (Peters, Calvo & Ryan, 2018; Vanden Abeele, 2021). Research on Digital Wellbeing has increasingly called for a more holistic assessment of technology’s effects on human welfare (Liscio et al., 2023). AI increases the urgency of this orientation. Its influence increasingly reaches beyond an individual interaction with a tool, shaping how people learn, make decisions, develop expertise, relate to one another and participate in organisations and society (UNESCO, 2021). The question before us is therefore larger than what these systems can do. It is what kind of future they are helping us create. This is also a question of integrity, by which we mean consistency between what we say we value and what we build, measure, reward and are willing to change. For digital transformation, that raises a series of questions: Do our purposes match our decisions? Do our measures of progress reflect what we actually care about? Do people retain meaningful agency in shaping technological change? And are we willing to adapt when what we learn challenges the direction already chosen?
Integrity of purpose: what kind of future are we building? Over the past decade, significant progress has been made in AI ethics, regulation and responsible innovation. Principles around safety, fairness, privacy, transparency and accountability provide an essential foundation for responsible technological development.
16
Week of Integrity
There is, however, a difference between identifying undesirable outcomes and articulating the future we actively want technology to contribute towards. Spiekermann (2021) has observed that the policy and corporate conversations have often focused on what shouldn’t happen for society rather than what needs to happen to create a purpose-driven, positive future. This distinction informed both the proactive and purpose-driven principles of the Wellbeing Compass. Harm prevention establishes important boundaries. A purpose-driven approach extends this to ask: what positive human and societal value are we trying to create? Positive Psychology made a similar shift decades earlier. Seligman argued that addressing pathology alone could not tell us what allows people to thrive. The field therefore expanded from preventing illbeing towards understanding and promoting human potential (Seligman, 1999). Positive Computing later brought a similar perspective into technology design, exploring how digital technologies might actively support wellbeing and human potential (Calvo & Peters, 2014). The language currently surrounding AI transformation is dominated by measures such as adoption, automation, capability, scale, productivity and efficiency. These can tell us a great deal about technological and organisational performance. They tell us less about the direction in which that performance is taking us. A purpose-driven approach begins with another set of questions: Does this technology expand people’s capabilities? Does it create greater opportunity to learn and contribute? Does it strengthen meaningful relationships and human judgement? Does it give people more agency over their lives? The Capabilities Approach developed by Sen and Nussbaum offers a useful parallel, shifting attention away from resources alone towards what people are actually able “to do and to be” (Sen, 1985; Nussbaum, 1992; Robeyns, 2005). This is particularly important, because technological development is always shaped by assumptions: about what people need, what counts as progress, what should be automated, which behaviours should be encouraged and which outcomes are worth measuring. Integrity of purpose therefore begins by making these assumptions visible and asking whether they are aligned with the future we say we want to create.
Integrity of measurement: what are we calling progress? Many measures used in development of novel technology are attractive precisely because they are readily available. Yet, they may be incomplete, short-termist and poorly representative of people’s wider experience. As Thomas et al. (2020) put it, “Any metric is just a proxy for what you really care about”. The social-media era made this problem especially visible. Engagement can tell us how frequently somebody returns to a platform or how long they remain there. Taken literally, optimisation for engagement can turn maximum time on a device into a proxy for success while remaining insufficient about whether that behaviour contributes to a life well lived. AI creates a new generation of proxies: Prompts, active users, tasks completed, time saved and productivity gains can tell us about technology use. They tell us considerably less about what is happening to human capability over time. Leading with integrity in a digital age
17
One employee may become faster because AI is helping them learn. Another may become faster while gradually losing opportunities to practise the skills through which expertise and judgement develop. Short-term performance may improve in both cases. Their longer-term trajectories could be very different. The measurement problem has also changed with the environments in which people think, decide, relate and learn. The system being evaluated can itself influence the human capacities we later seek to measure. Short-term convenience, satisfaction or productivity may consequently diverge from longer-term agency, capability, cognitive independence, social connection or professional competence. Economics has confronted a similar problem. GDP remains useful while offering an incomplete picture of whether people and societies are doing well. The Human Development Index, Capabilities Approach and other wellbeing measures emerged from efforts to broaden what we understand as progress (Stiglitz, Sen & Fitoussi, 2009; Sen, 1985; Nussbaum, 1992). The Wellbeing Compass argues that technological progress now requires the same reorientation. Integrity of measurement means becoming clearer about what a metric can tell us, what it cannot, and which human outcomes remain invisible.
Integrity of agency: who gets to shape the relationship? Humanity-centred design broadens the traditional focus on the “user” towards people as members of families, teams, organisations, communities and ecosystems (Norman, 2023). This wider perspective helps reveal cause-and-effect chains that disappear when technological impact is reduced to an interaction with an interface. For AI in organisations, this is particularly important. Human involvement cannot be assessed solely by whether a person remains formally “in the loop”. Someone may technically remain responsible for a decision while having very little ability to understand, challenge or influence the system shaping it. Meaningful agency therefore requires more than presence, but rather the capacity to understand, participate, contribute and exercise judgement. It also changes the question we ask about technological value. Alongside asking what AI allows an individual to do, organisations should consider what technology is making possible between people. Does knowledge travel more widely through an organisation? Are more perspectives included in important decisions? Are junior colleagues still gaining the experiences through which expertise develops? Does AI create space for mentorship and collaboration? Does the removal of certain tasks also remove interactions through which trust, knowledge and professional judgement were previously developed? For organisations, this also means recognising that some interactions which appear inefficient from a narrow process perspective may form part of the human infrastructure through which learning, belonging, trust and collective intelligence develop (Ryan & Deci, 2000, Norman, 2023). Integrity of agency asks whether the people affected by technological transformation have a meaningful role in shaping the relationship they are being asked to have with it. 18
Week of Integrity
Integrity of action: do we have the courage to adapt? The Wellbeing Compass proposed four principles for humanity-centred technological development: Proactive, Purpose-driven, Humanity-centred and Adaptive. The final principle recognises that innovation is built on assumptions, and we cannot know every consequence in advance. Especially in areas as complex and context-dependent as Digital Wellbeing, technological development therefore requires continual learning and refinement. From initial assumptions to product design, organisational processes and business models, new evidence may require us to reconsider decisions already made. That may mean revisiting an assumption, changing a metric, redesigning a role or product, altering an incentive or, ultimately, reconsidering a business model. Integrity of action asks for the courage to change direction when the signals demand it.
A compass for a flourishing future In the Wellbeing Compass, we argued that technology is never simply technical. Its effects are sociocultural and deeply connected to the context in which it is developed and applied. For too long, a certain “taken-for-grantedness” in our relationship with technology has obscured the fact that we retain agency in shaping that relationship (Vanden Abeele, 2021). The same principle applies to the current period of AI transformation. A humanitycentred perspective reminds us that technological development is something we make choices about: through the purposes we set, the outcomes we measure, the people we involve and the decisions we are prepared to revisit. So what does integrity require of digital transformation? Alignment between the future we describe and the decisions we make. Between the values we profess and what we build, measure and reward. Between listening to people and allowing what we hear to influence what happens next. The AI era gives us an opportunity to ask what that progress enables people to be and to do, what happens to the relationships and systems around them, and whether people retain meaningful agency in shaping the future that results. The challenge before us extends beyond successful AI adoption. It is to shape a digital landscape in which technological innovation and human flourishing can genuinely advance together.
References •
Calvo, R. A. & Peters, D. (2014). Positive Computing: Technology for Wellbeing and Human Potential. MIT Press.
•
Cooke, P. J., Melchert, T. P. & Connor, K. (2016). Measuring well-being: A review of instruments. The Counseling Psychologist, 44(5), 730–757.
•
Floridi, L. & Burr, C. (2023). Digital Wellbeing: A Multidisciplinary Study. Oxford University Press. Leading with integrity in a digital age
19
•
Freeman, R. E., Harrison, J. S., Wicks, A. C., Parmar, B. L. & de Colle, S. (2010). Stakeholder Theory: The State of the Art. Cambridge University Press.
•
Gasson, S. (2003). Human-centered vs. user-centered approaches to information system design. Journal of Information Technology Theory and Application, 5, 29–46.
•
Gluckman, P. D. & Allen, K. (2018). Understanding Wellbeing in the Context of Rapid Digital and Associated Transformations: Implications for Research, Policy, and Measurement. New Zealand Government.
•
Grosse-Buening, I. & Kukarina, A. (2025). The Wellbeing Compass: Navigating towards a humanity-centered tech future. In C. H. Hoffmann & D. Bansal (Eds.), AI Ethics in Practice, Integrated Science, Vol. 35, pp. 223–246. Springer.
•
IEEE (2021). IEEE 7000-2021: IEEE Standard Model Process for Addressing Ethical Concerns during System Design. IEEE Standards Association.
•
Liscio, E., Van Hove, L., De Marez, L. & Vanden Abeele, M. (2023). Towards a holistic approach for measuring digital wellbeing. Computers in Human Behavior, 115, 106622.
•
Lomas, E., Calvo, R. A., McLachlan, J. & Peters, D. (2023). Positive AI: Promoting wellbeing in the age of artificial intelligence. The International Journal of Wellbeing, 13(1), 1–27.
•
Mattelmäki, T., Vaajakallio, K. & Koskinen, I. (2014). What happened to empathic design? Design Issues, 30(1), 67–77.
•
Mittelstadt, B. D. (2019). Principles alone cannot guarantee ethical AI. Nature Machine Intelligence, 1(11), 501–507.
•
Morley, J., Floridi, L., Kinsey, L. & Elhalal, A. (2020). From what to how: An initial review of publicly available AI ethics tools, methods and research to translate principles into practices. Science and Engineering Ethics, 26(4), 2141–2168.
•
Morley, J., Floridi, L., Kinsey, L. & Elhalal, A. (2021). Operationalizing AI ethics: Translating principles into practice. Science and Engineering Ethics, 27(1), 24.
•
Norman, D. A. (2023). Design for a Better World: Meaningful, Sustainable, Humanity Centered. MIT Press.
•
Nussbaum, M. C. (1992). Human functioning and social justice: In defense of Aristotelian essentialism. Political Theory, 20(2), 202–246.
•
Peters, D., Calvo, R. A. & Ryan, R. M. (2018). Designing for motivation, engagement and wellbeing in digital experience. Frontiers in Psychology, 9, 797.
•
Robeyns, I. (2005). The capability approach: A theoretical survey. Journal of Human Development, 6(1), 93–114.
•
Ryan, R. M. & Deci, E. L. (2000). Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development and well-being. American Psychologist, 55(1), 68–78.
20
Week of Integrity
•
Seligman, M. E. P. (1999). The President’s Address. American Psychologist, 54, 559–562.
•
Sen, A. (1985). Well-being, agency and freedom: The Dewey Lectures 1984. The Journal of Philosophy, 82(4), 169–221.
•
Spiekermann, S. (2021). Digital Ethics: A Value System for the 21st Century. Routledge.
•
Stiglitz, J. E., Sen, A. & Fitoussi, J. P. (2008). Report by the Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social Progress. Commission on the Measurement of Economic Performance and Social Progress.
•
Thomas, M., Kohli, V. & Brown, R. (2020). Measuring digital wellbeing: A multidimensional approach. Journal of Medical Internet Research, 22(5), e16649.
•
UNESCO. (2021). Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization.
•
Vanden Abeele, M. M. P. (2021). Digital wellbeing as a dynamic construct. Communication Theory, 31(4), 932–955.
•
Yang, C., Liang, P. & Avgeriou, P. (2018). Assumptions and their management in software development: A systematic mapping study. Information and Software Technology, 94, 82–110.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
21
PRESERVING HUMAN JUDGMENT IN THE AGE OF AI
Ceri Lawley Ceri Lawley is an international board director and governance adviser specialising in integrity, risk oversight and emerging technologies. She previously served as Chief Compliance Officer of the International Finance Corporation (IFC), the private sector arm of the World Bank Group, where she established and led its Business Risk & Compliance function. Ceri advises boards and organisations on governance, integrity, AI, data, regulatory oversight and investment risk, drawing on more than three decades of international legal, compliance and board experience in the private sector and international organizations across both developed and emerging markets. She currently serves on the board of Coalition for Integrity and on a number of other boards and advisory councils in the corporate and non-profit sectors, and writes and speaks regularly on integrity and governance.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
23
CERI LAWLEY
PRESERVING HUMAN JUDGMENT IN THE AGE OF AI
The conventional narrative is that AI will increasingly automate integrity and compliance activities. It is already improving efficiencies and accelerating decisionmaking. Yet the more significant development may be that as AI becomes more capable, the importance of human judgment is increasing rather than diminishing. As AI capabilities expand, the central leadership task is to cultivate human judgment and create an organizational culture in which it can flourish.
Evolution of AI usage in the integrity space Over roughly the past decade, integrity and compliance functions have experienced a rapid evolution in technology. Early deployments focused on sanctions screening, name matching, transaction monitoring and adverse media analysis. More recently, graph analytics, ownership mapping and automation have enabled more sophisticated analysis and streamlined workflows. The last three years have brought a step change. Generative AI systems can now draft summaries, identify themes, propose follow-up questions and prepare first drafts of approval memoranda. Most recently, organizations have begun experimenting with agentic AI systems capable of executing elements of defined workflows, such as retrieving records, assembling supporting materials, updating cases and routing matters for review. As discussed in a recent Coalition for Integrity Report on Responsible AI in Integrity and Compliance1, these technologies are increasingly being combined within integrated solutions to provide enhanced decision support. In many of these activities, AI can now operate at a scale that no human team could reasonably be expected to do. That being said, AI should not replace professional judgment on high-impact or sensitive decisions. Companies must carefully define where humans need to intervene so that decisions continue to reflect context, nuance, organizational values and risk appetite2. This is particularly important when so many integrity and compliance-related decisions face reputational exposure, regulatory scrutiny, and may ultimately result in enforcement action. Put simply, integrity is ultimately not about technological acceleration and augmentation in the processing of information. Instead, it is about humans exercising judgment under uncertainty. The real test for leaders is not technological, but cultural. Four particular challenges stand out.
24
Week of Integrity
1.
Delegation of judgment: Increasingly, AI systems offer the temptation to delegate judgment. While they can screen counterparties, identify adverse media, map beneficial ownership and draft reports, there is a danger that humans may start treating AI recommendations and outputs as decisions. Humans must not delegate judgment and need to intervene to interpret and apply context. A practical example is where the AI produces large amounts of data supporting a recommendation. Humans need to intervene to peel away allegations from anonymous sources, assess regulatory investigations that ended with no findings, and determine when evidence consists of recycled articles repeating the same event. Where there is a politically exposed person (PEP) in a potential investment, humans need to apply judgment on matters that the AI cannot answer, such as the exact nature of the person’s political influence, and whether it is relevant to the investment in question. They also need to assess what role the PEP plays in the investee company (both formal and informal), whether the risk can be managed by enhanced risk controls, and importantly, whether the risk is aligned with the organisation’s risk appetite and business priorities. Ultimately, preserving judgment is less about limiting AI than about maintaining organisational practices in which humans remain intellectually engaged in difficult decisions.
2. Erosion of professional skepticism: A strength of experienced integrity and compliance professionals is their ability to apply healthy skepticism, to probe assumptions and to ask difficult questions. An emerging risk with AI automation is the tendency of humans to place undue reliance on machine-generated recommendations and to become passive consumers of outputs3. Integrity professionals must continue to ask whether the underlying information is reliable, complete and fairly interpreted, and whether alternative, possibly more plausible explanations exist. An example of the need for professional skepticism is where allegations involve criticism from political opponents or are part of a political campaign, or where there is a spike in negative allegations following regime change. Another example would be a detailed benefit ownership mapping where the AI analyzes shareholdings, intermediate holding companies and the like, but does not assess nominee shareholders or informal control arrangements that would not appear in corporate filings. To reinforce professional skepticism, organisations need to encourage constructive challenge and diverse viewpoints, and need to create space for difficult questioning before important decisions are finalized.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
25
3. Blurring of accountability. When decisions involve a combination of humans, AI tools, vendors and automated workflows, responsibility can become diffuse. Organisations must be explicit with their workforces that responsibility for decisions remains with humans, not with the technology, and each person needs to understand what their role is. An illustration here would be a company considering a new distributor in a high-risk jurisdiction. The AI performs sanctions screening, adverse media reviews, ownership mapping and third-party due diligence, assembles a comprehensive package with a risk score and produces an approval memorandum. Let’s say serious corruption allegations emerge a year after approval. Immediately questions emerge as to whether the integrity officer, procurement specialist or business sponsor approved the relationship, whether management relied on AI-generated recommendations. Other questions include who, if anyone, was responsible for reviewing the underlying evidence, and whether the vendor supplying the technology configured the risk model correctly. The risk is that everyone can point to someone else and no one feels fully accountable for the outcome. A strong integrity culture requires that accountability remains explicit and that every decision has a clear owner. Policies should define roles and responsibilities, establish escalation thresholds and support auditability. Further, clear accountability depends on decision-making processes in which participants understand their own role, and also how important it is for differing perspectives to contribute to the final decision. 4. Speed over wisdom: AI is accelerating almost everything, from research and drafting to analysis and monitoring, but it is becoming clear that many integrity failures occur because organizations are moving too quickly. AI can now generate risk analyses and approval materials so fast that organizations start to expect decisions to be made with equal speed. There is a danger that ‘in person’ discussions are no longer held to weigh concerns, ask probing questions such as what is not known, and question whether the risk is consistent with risk appetite. One of the challenges of leading with integrity in a digital age is ensuring the organizations do not confuse faster decisions with better decisions. Yes, taking time for reflection and meaningful conversation can slow decisionmaking, but it improves the quality and consistency of decision-making. It also allows the development of shared judgment, as well as establishing clearer positions for similar cases and situations in the future. The above challenges are deeply interconnected. For example, delegating judgment can weaken professional skepticism. In its turn, reduced skepticism can blur accountability, which then encourages organizations to prioritize speed over deliberation.
26
Week of Integrity
Integrity as a leadership issue These developments point to a broader test for leaders. As AI becomes embedded across organizations, integrity cannot be viewed solely as the responsibility of integrity and compliance specialists. The question is no longer simply whether AI can identify risks. It is whether leaders can create a culture in which those risks are interpreted, debated and acted upon appropriately.4 This means creating environments in which assumptions can be challenged, different views are actively sought, and difficult decisions are tested through thoughtful discussion rather than accepted simply because technology has produced a persuasive answer. That being said, integrity decisions are rarely made in a vacuum. They are made in the context of growth targets, budget pressures, market-entry objectives, shareholder expectations and project deadlines.5 An illustration here might be a business director facing significant pressure to meet ambitious growth targets and considering a new distributor that could open a new market. During the due diligence process, the AI identifies a PEP in the ownership chain, historic allegations of improper payments in local media, and lack of transparency in parts of the ownership structure. When viewed individually, none of these issues is necessarily disqualifying, but during the approval discussion, each concern is addressed in isolation. For example, the PEP connection is distant, the media allegations are unproven, and the ownership questions can probably be resolved later. Yet what this misses is the significance of all of the risk flags appearing together. The AI system can identify each risk individually, but it cannot determine how much weight should be given to them cumulatively. The critical question is often not whether a particular risk can be explained away, but whether leaders have the discipline to recognize that a series of individual concerns collectively create a level of risk that exceeds the organisation’s risk appetite. Integrity decisions rarely involve a single clear red flag. And there are often supplemental related concerns on the legal, financial, credit side or ESG. Assessing the entirety of the situation is key. Leadership therefore involves more than deciding where AI should be deployed. It involves creating an environment in which important decisions benefit from thoughtful reflection, constructive challenge and different perspectives, and which does not allow business considerations to automatically dominate.
Concluding remarks As AI increasingly permeates the world of integrity and compliance, the most important question is not whether organizations can deploy AI responsibly, as many are already doing this. The more important question is whether leaders can preserve the practices that should always underpin integrity, such as skepticism, accountability, careful deliberation, and the willingness to make difficult decisions when circumstances warrant it.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
27
Technology will continue to change how organisations gather information, analyse risks and support decisions. However, deciding which risks are worth taking remains fundamentally a human responsibility. This responsibility is strengthened through leadership and disciplined organisational habits that encourage thoughtful deliberation and constructive challenge, and a culture where difficult conversations are welcomed rather than avoided.
References 1
Coalition for Integrity, AI in Corporate Integrity and Compliance: Use Cases, Governance and the Role of Human Judgment (2026), available at www. c4integrity.org/category/publications/.
2
See, e.g., National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework (AI RMF 1.0) (2023); OECD, Recommendation of the Council on Artificial Intelligence (updated 2024); Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (EU AI Act); and COSO, Achieving Effective Internal Control Over Generative AI (2026).
3
Daniel Kahneman, Thinking, Fast and Slow (2011), the modern classic in psychology and behavioral economics, on cognitive shortcuts, overconfidence and the tendency to rely uncritically on apparently authoritative information.
4
See also How Do Workers Develop Good Judgment in the AI Era?, Harvard Business Review (2026), discussing how organizations can ensure that employees continue to develop judgment, discernment and decision-making capabilities as AI increasingly performs analytical and information-processing tasks.
5
Eugene Soltes, Why They Do It: Inside the Mind of the White-Collar Criminal (2016). Based on extensive interviews with executives involved in corporate misconduct, Soltes argues that poor decisions often arise not from deliberate criminal intent but from incremental decision-making, organizational pressures, and failures of judgment.
28
Week of Integrity
Leading with integrity in a digital age
29
ABSOLUTION ENGINES
Ty Francis MBE Ty Francis MBE is a British-American subject-matter expert in Corporate Governance, AI Governance, Ethics, Compliance, and Culture. Ty has evaluated, advised on, and launched E&C programs and forums worldwide, helping organizations measure corporate culture and the effectiveness of compliance programs. Ty spent over a decade in New York City, where he was EVP of Global Programs at the Ethisphere Institute and VP of the New York Stock Exchange’s Governance Services division. For 6 years, he was Chief Advisory Officer at LRN, where he led the company’s advisory, thought leadership and corporate board services. He is currently the Founding Strategic Advisor for Boundary, a company pioneering runtime context governance, controlling what enterprise AI sees and uses from business systems in real time, and proving what was allowed, withheld and why. He is also an advisory board member for the Leonid Group’s Corporate Governance and Compliance business, where he advises companies on AI Governance and Compliance, and recently joined Confide, the compliance and ethics company founded by Wirecard whistleblower Pav Gill, which helps handle anonymous whistleblowing, workplace grievances, fraud and integrity issues. Ty was awarded an MBE for Services to Business by King Charles III, is a Certified Compliance & Ethics Professional (CCEP) and Chair of the Business and Law School Board at Solent Univeristy.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
31
TY FRANCIS MBE
ABSOLUTION ENGINES
In September, I was on a panel at AI House in Amsterdam, in a room full of ethics and compliance leaders, and one of the first things I asked them was to put their hands up if they used an AI system at work every day. Unsurprisingly, pretty much every hand went up. I then asked them a follow-up question: in the next five seconds, without really thinking about it, name two people you could go to who could switch that system off right now if you felt it was acting unethically. Most of the hands came down. What did that show? Probably not quite as much as I suggested at the time. Five seconds isn’t very long, but in my opinion, the people who still had their hands up had governance, while those with their hands down had something that looked a lot more like wallpaper. It was a slightly cheap piece of theatre, but the reality is that every organisation in that room had an AI policy, and had likely delivered training on it. Ask who actually owns the decision to stop a system, however, and things suddenly become much less certain. That gap between the governance we have written down and what actually happens when somebody has to make a decision is the real dilemma. So, I used another example. Say your corporate gift limit is €150 and your dinner limit is €400. I tell my compliance officer that I want to give a client a €200 bottle of wine, and I am told that the limit is €150. I then take the client to lunch and come back with an argument. Dinner came to €400, he drank two bottles of wine and I drank none, so in effect I have already put €300 worth of wine in front of him. Surely that creates some kind of precedent? The compliance officer will probably look at me and say that if I want to give him a bottle of wine, it costs €149.99 or less. That is the whole conversation, and importantly, the answer holds. Now put the same conversation through a newly built compliance AI agent. The first time it will probably give me exactly the same answer. The policy says €150. I give it the lunch example, the two bottles and the precedent, and it politely explains that it understands my reasoning but the limit is still €150. But imagine months of this, with dozens of employees asking versions of the same question, introducing the same exceptions and pushing at the same boundary. You now have a system built to be helpful being repeatedly presented with reasons why the simple answer may not be quite right. Somewhere along the way, it is at least conceivable that helpfulness starts to look a little too much like agreement. It tells someone, in effect, that it takes their point and that another €200 is probably fine. Six months later, people are routinely sending €200 bottles of wine. But nobody changed the policy. The limit says €150 and may still accurately reflect what the company believes should happen. The problem is that it no longer accurately describes what actually happens. The boundary has moved without anybody formally deciding to move it, which is a very different governance problem from somebody simply ignoring a rule. 32
Week of Integrity
I started calling this an absolution engine, meaning any system somebody can consult to feel a little less responsible for what they do next. Nobody sets out to build it this way, though. A tool is introduced to help employees find an answer, then it starts suggesting an answer, then recommending one, and eventually people begin treating the recommendation as the decision itself. I understand why. People are busy, they have a dozen other things to get through, and the machine has just handed them something that sounds sensible, and it did it so confidently. Taking delivery of that answer rather than thinking it through from first principles is a very human response. I suspect a lot of people would do this on a rough Thursday. We have all met the person who did something questionable because Legal “signed off on it,” only to discover that Legal probably answered a much narrower question, never saw the whole transaction, or said something considerably more qualified than the employee later remembered. The difference with AI is the loss of friction. A colleague can refuse to give you the answer you are fishing for. They can ask another question, tell you they are uncomfortable or simply say no. Maybe that resistance was doing more work inside that organisation than we ever give it credit for. AI should actually make accountability better. Prompts can be logged, outputs stored and overrides timestamped. Compared with the nod in the corridor that four people remember differently a year later, an AI-assisted decision may be the best documented decision an organisation can make. But I’m not sure the record tells us quite what we think it tells us. It can tell us that the system was consulted and what answer it produced, but it can’t really tell us what the person on the other side. Also, a perfect audit trail may create a different problem. Imagine an employee follows the approved process, uses the approved tool and accepts its recommendation. When something goes wrong, the record may not be the strongest evidence against them. It may be the strongest part of their defence. They used the system the company gave them and followed the process the company designed. Ask why they made the decision and the answer is fairly predictable: the agent told me, and you told me to use the agent. In those circumstances, the audit trail has not necessarily solved the accountability problem. It may simply have documented the alibi. All of that also assumes the conversation took place inside the approved environment, and we already know it often does not. I think companies have partly created this problem for themselves. For much of the past year, employees have been told to use AI, experiment with it, find efficiencies, work faster and become more productive. Senior leaders have encouraged whole organisations to build these systems into how they work, often with a sense that anyone moving too slowly would be left behind. Now some of those same organisations are becoming more cautious. The technology costs more than some expected, token usage matters, and security teams are rightly asking harder questions about what employees are putting into these systems. Access is being restricted, particular models are being prescribed, and employees who were previously told to experiment are now being told which systems they can and cannot use. The difficulty is that the employee has already changed. If somebody has spent a year using a particular model every day, there is a good chance they have become very comfortable with it. It may know how they Leading with integrity in a digital age
33
write, how they structure an argument, what sort of answer they want and what they are trying to achieve. They may have uploaded previous work to it or built prompts and workflows around it. Whatever the case, they have invested time in making that tool useful to them. You cannot assume they will happily abandon all of that because the company has now chosen a different corporate model that is slower, less capable or simply less familiar. Some employees will move across without any difficulty, but others will find a way to continue using what works for them. That is where shadow AI stops being an IT problem and becomes a governance problem. An employee starts making compromises with themselves. They remove the customer’s name, take out the account number, decide the information is sufficiently sanitised, and then carry on using the tool that helps them do the job. You can therefore end up in the slightly ridiculous position where the company thinks it has reduced AI usage because fewer people are using the approved systems, while in reality the opposite may be happening. People are still using AI. The company has simply stopped seeing some of it. For a governance programme, that strikes me as a particularly poor outcome: the controls have not necessarily changed behaviour; they have changed the visibility of behaviour. One of my co-panellists in Amsterdam, who runs responsible AI at a large European technology manufacturer, made a point that has stayed with me. A policy, he said, is often just a piece of text sitting on an intranet and we should stop assuming everybody is going to read it. Put the controls in the technology itself, because that is where they can scale and be applied consistently. I think he is right, but I also think it creates another problem. A policy document, for all its limitations, sits still. If you change it, somebody normally knows that you have changed it. If the control increasingly sits inside a learning system, then the thing enforcing the policy may itself start to move. We audit behaviour against the written rule and, if the written rule has not changed, we tend to assume the boundary has not changed either. I am not convinced that assumption is going to remain safe. This is why I keep coming back to a distinction between retrieval and adjudication, although I think it is simpler in practice than those words make it sound. One of the most sensible compliance agents I have seen was built by a company I spoke to a few months ago at another AI event. What impressed me was how little it was trying to do. It was essentially point and click, sandboxed against the code of conduct. An employee asks what the limit is for entertaining a client, the system goes into the policy, finds the answer and gives it to them. Ask a question that requires judgement and it tells you to contact Compliance. It was not trying to act like a compliance officer. It was retrieving a fact and knowing when to stop. I am perfectly happy with AI doing that. In fact, I would rather it did. It is probably better than asking the person sitting at the next desk what they vaguely remember the policy saying. Where I get nervous is when retrieval quietly becomes judgement. Asking what the policy limit is should be straightforward. Asking whether this particular exception is acceptable, or whether the organisation can justify doing something despite what the rule appears to say, is quite different. At that point 34
Week of Integrity
somebody is making a decision on behalf of the organisation, and it may be a decision the organisation later has to explain to a customer, or maybe a regulator. I don’t think that responsibility should quietly migrate into a system just because the system is capable of producing an answer. That is when you have built an absolution engine, whether you intended to or not. Shadow AI needs the same practical response. Telling people not to use tools they have already found useful is unlikely to reverse the behaviour, especially if the approved alternative is worse. Think about if you’ve been using Claude at home. It knows you, your voice, it has helped you write emails, it understands what you like and what you don’t. Having to use a sanitized enterprise version of Copilot would be painful and would likely take you more time to create anything close to what you’ve been used to. So access controls matter, but access controls alone won’t solve this. We can also teach very simple behaviours. Not every interaction with an AI system requires the underlying confidential information. If you want help writing an email about a difficult client situation, for example, ask the model to draft a generic email about that kind of situation. Get it to help with the structure, tone and wording, then add the client name, the sensitive facts and the actual commercial context afterwards, inside the controlled environment. That sounds almost trivial, but I think we need much more of this kind of advice. You wanted help writing the email; you did not necessarily need to give the AI the contents of the file. We have spent a lot of time telling employees which tools they may and may not use, and far less time showing them how to use AI sensibly when, whether we like it or not, the technology is already embedded in how many of them work. There is one more thing these systems do that I do not think we have fully reckoned with, and the easiest way I can explain it is through my brother. When I was about eight, I came off my bike. My father was not there when it happened and apparently did not know quite what to do about it, so he bought me ten Star Wars figures. I already had them, which meant these new ones went into a box in the loft, still sealed. Years later, it occurred to me that I had ten pristine Star Wars figures sitting up there that might now be worth quite a lot of money. What I had forgotten was that sometime in between I had sent my younger brother into the loft to get some school memorabilia for me. He found the books, but he also found the Star Wars figures and opened every single one of them. He never told me, not because he was hiding it but because it simply did not occur to him that opening the figures was something worth reporting back. His task was to find the books. He found them. Everything else was incidental from his point of view, even though it mattered quite a lot from mine. That, to me, is a useful way of thinking about agents. Ask an agent why a customer is not renewing and it may not confine itself to the renewal history and the contract. It may pull other information because that helps it answer the question. It may access billing details, account information or the names of people associated with the customer, then come back and tell you why it thinks the customer is not renewing. Everything else it touched may not be concealed from you. It may simply not be considered relevant enough to mention.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
35
That is why I don’t think governance can live entirely in the prompt or on a policy page. Some of it has to live at the technical boundary, deciding what the agent is allowed to touch before it goes looking. In a way, that brings me back to the same problem I started with. Nothing necessarily looks broken. The policy has not changed, the system is still operating and the employee may even have followed the approved process. Yet the organisation can end up in a slightly different place from the one it thought it was in, and nobody can point to the moment the change happened. I would normally argue that values beat rules, and I still believe that. You want a warehouse where you could take every hard hat sign off the wall overnight and everybody would still turn up wearing one the next morning because that is simply how things are done there. I am not sure we are there yet with this technology. It is still young, the ground is moving quickly and, at least for now, I think ambiguity is probably doing more damage than a little over-instruction would. So think again about the system you picked when you started reading and ask yourself who could switch it off tomorrow morning if they needed to.
36
Week of Integrity
Leading with integrity in a digital age
37
BOARD ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE AGE OF AI: FROM RESPONSIBLE AI AS A SLOGAN TO RESPONSIBLE BOARDS AS A PRACTICE
Vera Cherepanova Vera serves as chair, director, and ethics advisor to global professional bodies, corporations, and international nonprofits. She is the Executive Director of Boards of the Future, a US-based nonprofit advancing ethical governance in corporate boardrooms globally. Vera is the chair of the Global Forum for Governance, Risk and Performance at the Association of Certified Chartered Accountants, a member of the International Council at Compliance and Business Ethics Association of Kazakhstan, and serves on the Steering Committee of ComplianceNet, an interdisciplinary research network on compliance. Vera writes and speaks about business ethics, philosophy, and corporate governance. She is the author of books, book chapters, practical guides, as well as hundreds of articles on all aspects of ethics, risk, compliance, and corporate accountability. Her insights have been featured in the Financial Times, Wall Street Journal, Law360, City AM, FT The Banker, and Thomson Reuters.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
39
VERA CHEREPANOVA
BOARD ACCOUNTABILITY IN THE AGE OF AI: FROM RESPONSIBLE AI AS A SLOGAN TO RESPONSIBLE BOARDS AS A PRACTICE Terms such as “AI ethics” or “Responsible AI” appear to carry a great deal of weight these days. Their original purpose was to create space for questions about fairness, accountability, transparency, privacy, inclusion, and labour, and to make the societal impacts of AI more open to collective scrutiny. Now they are doing too many things at once, with none of their meanings sufficient on their own. The underlying challenge, however, is not only governing AI but ensuring that digital transformation remains anchored in human values, purpose and responsible leadership. If “Responsible AI” has become too vague and elastic to carry accountability, boards need to translate it into something much more concrete. That means ensuring that powerful technologies are adopted for a clearly articulated purpose, measured against a fuller definition of value, governed with proper regard for workplace culture and employee dignity, and led by executives capable of steering an enterprise into the AI-driven future.
Start with purpose The idea is deceptively simple, yet fundamental: every organization’s AI journey should begin not with technology, but with a clear purpose for why it needs to be adopted. What problem are we trying to solve? How does the payoff look in economic and strategic terms, and how does it align with the human values our organization wants to uphold? Even more critically, where do we see a potential — or actual — misalignment? Boards should model and expect ethical curiosity, displaying the courage to ask discerning questions and steering management away from using AI simply because everyone else appears to be doing so, or treating it mainly as a short-term cost-cutting tool, toward longer-term value creation.
40
Week of Integrity
Focus on organization-wide value creation It is not uncommon for Responsible AI to be defined in the language of risk avoidance. Boards are told to focus on privacy, cybersecurity, data quality, algorithmic bias, model governance, regulatory compliance, and third-party risk. These are all important. However, when AI governance is reduced to technical risk control, boards can miss the broader governance question of whether AI is creating durable value in ways consistent with the organization’s purpose, values, and responsibilities to people. St the end of the day, value creation also includes trust, employee engagement and long-term societal value—not only financial performance. If most of the value depends on people and processes, a responsible board should extend AI oversight beyond the narrow technology box and ask management whether the company is ready to absorb the change it claims to want. Which processes need to be redesigned? Which employees need to be trained? Which roles will change? Which incentives could distort behaviour? What does AI value look like for us, and how will we measure it? Boards that apply a reductionist approach at the expense of strategic, operational, ethical, and human capital context are likely to lose in the AI race.
Govern the Human Consequences As we move from AI playing an assisting role — helping humans with certain tasks — to acting on behalf of them and, in some cases, on behalf of the company as a whole, securing acceptance from and building trust with the human part of the workforce is becoming ever more critical. Introducing digital labour may affect human labour in ways management might be understating. The usual promise is that, as machines take over mundane tasks, humans will move to more interesting and enriching work full of meaning. That might be the case for some. More often, though, employees are expected to train the agents, manage them, improve them, and ultimately compete with them. So, a good board question is whether human work is becoming more meaningful, or whether humans are being turned into machine validators until the final phase-out. Capital allocation discipline likely gets too much airtime in boardrooms at the expense of the most expensive, and still most strategic, asset: people. Boards are racing to bank on technology, obsessing over AI expertise, but risk ignoring the workforce transformation that makes AI succeed or fail, systematically underweighting the potential impact of employee distrust and rejection.
Make AI leadership a succession criterion No board accountability framework is complete without the question of leadership. Choosing the CEO is one of the board’s most consequential responsibilities. In the digital age, that responsibility should now include a timely question: does the company have a leader who can run an AI-capable enterprise?
Leading with integrity in a digital age
41
The leadership succession profile that has long guided selection decisions still holds: revenue growth, M&A experience, cultural credibility, judgement, and financial fluency remain essential. The point is that AI intensifies the need for all of these qualities. A CEO who cannot understand how AI changes the economics, workforce, risk profile, customer experience, and operating model of the business is unlikely to lead the organization responsibly through the next phase. What’s more important, these qualities now need to be tested in a different context. Can the next CEO allocate capital toward AI without treating it as a fashionable technology spend? Can they redesign processes to meet the technology? Can they lead people through transformation? All of that means that boards should treat AI fluency as a must-have in the CEO succession profile. Board accountability in the digital age does not mean that directors must become technologists. The board does not manage AI adoption. However, directors must define and clarify the conditions under which that adoption takes place. The accountability gap in AI starts with language. When “Responsible AI” means everything, it risks meaning nothing. Boards that translate responsibility into operational terms — purpose, value, human consequences, and leadership capability — are on the right track to ensuring that technology serves the strategy, and not the other way round.
42
Week of Integrity
Leading with integrity in a digital age
43
TRANSPARENCY, TRACEABILITY AND ETHICS BY DESIGN
Annabel Gillard Annabel advises clients on ethics and organisational culture in an AI-driven future workplace and its role in building trust in a digital economy. She co-founded LSE FORGOOD, advising corporate clients on ethical applications of behavioural science, and ‘Conversations on AI’, a cross-sector tech ethics network, and is a member of the City of London Corporation’s ‘Women Pivoting to Digital’ taskforce. Previously she spent over 20 years building institutional businesses in asset management and she serves on the Trustee Board of Clore Social Leadership, and the advisory committees of the Institute of Business Ethics and Blueprint For Better Business. She has an MA in Philosophy and AI, an MSc in Behavioural Science and is a CFA charterholder.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
45
ANNABEL GILLARD
TRANSPARENCY, TRACEABILITY AND ETHICS BY DESIGN
Context Our current era, of accelerating technological transformation, brings greater requirements for, and challenges to, integrity. The internet and social media have dramatically transformed social and communication channels and disrupted the information landscape, resulting in a loss of confidence and clarity as to who and what to believe. Algorithms dispassionate ‘one-size-fits-all’ approach can result in life-changing determinations based on incomplete data and an absence of context of understanding. Against this backdrop, reports of low trust in business, the media and institutions are not surprising, despite the apparent increase in transparency and traceability that the digital age affords. The trust shortfall has come into sharp focus during 2026 as low trust also appears to be slowing AI adoption, in turn contributing to the disappointing returns on AI investment according to the Stanford Human-Centred AI Index, while Edelman found that “Trust is the missing ingredient in the AI boom”. Rushing to adopt AI without having responsible governance in place, risks hard won corporate reputations, with every one of the ‘big four’ having been caught including AI hallucinations in published work. The Stanford Index finds that 79% of the US public do not trust in businesses to use AI in a responsible way. Yet trust is essential to a successful business as both the cornerstone of innovation and the source of customer loyalty. In an era of change and disruption, trust is how you take your customers and talent with you on your journey, and, transparency and traceability are key components in building the trust that enables organisations to prosper. Trust comprises a competence element-- can you do what you promise? - along with a character element - will you do what you promise? Transparency and traceability enable customers and employees to track whether promises are being met, while ‘ethics-by-design’ demonstrates proactive intent to behave responsibly. For organisations seeking to build trust, transparency, traceability and ethics-by-design provides a blueprint to demonstrate trustworthiness.
Why AI is not just business (ethics) as usual AI contains novel ethical dimensions that, if not managed effectively, introduce multi-dimensional liabilities such as legal, ethical, reputational, cultural. Algorithms do not have moral awareness and so do not offer a like for like replacement when taking on roles that were formerly performed by humans. AI brings strengths - fast processing, data at scale - but also limitations i.e. lacking context, judgement, moral awareness. This combination – very rapid confident determinations based 46
Week of Integrity
on only part of the picture can be organisationally risky if acted on unquestioningly. AI is self-reinforcing and amplifies patterns in the data, rather than seeking to understand causation. This can result in destructive feedback loops, such as when AI has been used to allocate police resources to areas with greater crime reports, thus resulting in more crime being recorded in that area and ever more resources being allocated to a smaller number of neighbourhoods. The Algorithmic Justice League tracks such incidents, to build understanding of how algorithmic design can have unintended consequences so we can better mitigate harms in future. Where AI performs a role previously undertaken by a human employee there are four dimensions to AI-use that carry ethical vulnerability which I have termed: ‘the 4 Ds’. These consist of the Data used to train the AI, the Design of the algorithm, how the AI is Deployed and the Drift that occurs when AI interacts with the realworld data. Each of these Ds has an ethical profile, even if unintentional. The selection of which Data is included and how it is categorised may represent people and circumstances differently, meanwhile taking care with setting the objective and parameters can avoid unintended harm when Designing the algorithm - e.g. Amazon’s famously sexist hiring bot could have been pre-empted by setting a parameter to preclude gender being a determining characteristic. Deployment refers to the operationalising of AI recommendations within an organisational context. Where organisations take an AI ‘flag’ as a determination, rather than an indication, great harm can follow. The Dutch government was brought down after Dutch tax authorities penalised those flagged as higher risk by its welfare fraud algorithm without adequate human oversight. Algorithms are very effective at identifying exceptions to a regular pattern but not at determining whether the reason is suspicious or simply atypical life circumstances. The most effective way of managing these ethical risks is by design. Many of these risks cannot be remedied later. For example, Amazon had to retire its hiring bot, finding the gender bias unfixable. A range of frameworks exist to guide those developing and designing AI systems to build in checks and a diverse set of challenges before it is too late. The development of ISO standards and an emerging field of AI Assurance offers publicly accountable commitments to ethical AI. AI brings fresh ethical risks to business not just because of these four additional vulnerabilities, but also because of the human tendencies to defer to automated decision-making systems and to become dependent on systems that make our lives easier. Indeed, humans also have biases and ethical blind spots that also introduce risk into a business and designing a governance approach that takes account of behavioural biases offers greater resilience. By adopting ‘Ethics-by-design’, best practice in building responsible AI systems, firms can also improve their organisational resilience and demonstrate trustworthiness to customers and employees.
Trust is business critical The investment of time and resource to build and apply ethical frameworks and employee challenge into development and operational practice can be in tension with commercial imperatives to realise the competitive benefits of successful AI adoption and avoid getting left behind in the AI race. However, trust famously Leading with integrity in a digital age
47
arrives on foot but leaves on horseback. In an environment in which trust is low and falling, trustworthiness has even more of a premium. Integrity, as represented by transparency, traceability and ethics-by-design, is key to building trust. And trust is key to success in a digital age. As organisations undergo accelerating change in how they interact with customers, and their operating model, they risk failing to meet their promises. Where it is possible to demonstrate authentic ethical intent, customers are likely to be more forgiving of mistakes. Employee trust is of growing importance in an era in which innovation is essential to survival, a belief shared by most leaders in recent surveys. Psychological safety is a foundation of innovation, which requires employees to trust that they can challenge the status quo. Committing to ethics-by-design, transparency and traceability enables innovation without breaching values or losing institutional knowledge or identity.
Proactive ethics-by-design as strategic advantage It is not sufficient to merely rely on regulation to build trust and organisational resilience. Regulation sets the minimum standard and is slow, specific, backwardlooking and jurisdictional. The proactive choice to adhere to a higher standard, communicates responsibility and trustworthiness in a changing and uncertain world. Further, regulation does not account for every eventuality, particularly given that technology is changing both the customer experience and employee behaviour, and that many real-world dilemmas are not cut and dried. Navigating complex choices in an opaque and complex world can be undertaken with more confidence when supported by a robust ethical framework to facilitate judgement under uncertainty.
Structuring ethics for agile decision-making and confident leadership Ethics can be seen as opaque, a philosophical maze, or a dry and dusty goslow department. However, when ethics-by-design is married with a structured framework, it can help provide clarity and thoroughness. As an example, the framework (Lades and Delaney, 2022) was developed to synthesise ethical considerations into a manageable structure using a mnemonic to facilitate ethical deliberation. Fairness, Openness, Respect, Goals, Opinions, Options and Delegation, supported by a question-prompting structure, offers a comprehensive yet agile methodology to pre-empt such problems. Using frameworks, and structured ethical decision-making support, can facilitate decision-making in complex adaptive systems and empower confident judgement under uncertainty. Investing the time to do this thinking at the outset pays dividends by providing a form of quality control, resilience and proactive trust building as well as insuring against reputational disaster. Further, engaging in ethical reasoning builds critical thinking capabilities and cognitive discernment at a time when such skills are at risk from AI-induced cognitive surrender.
48
Week of Integrity
In conclusion This is a time of profound and fast-paced change in which previously reliable systems of governance may no longer serve their purpose, the stakes are high and public confidence is low. Against that backdrop, actively building and maintaining customer trust, and proactively prioritising integrity with ethics-by-design offers a strategic competitive advantage. Transparency and traceability demonstrate both by providing accountability after the fact. As trust is a part of every business transaction, scaling prosperity, enabling innovation and facilitating transformation, investing in building responsible and trustworthy foundations offers both resilience and a sustainable premium.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
49
PUTTING PEOPLE AT THE CENTRE OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION: DIGNITY, INCLUSION, AND LIFELONG LEARNING IN AN AGE OF AI
Dirk De Bilde Dirk De Bilde is CEO of Siemens Netherlands. He leads the company’s operations across industry, infrastructure, and mobility, with a strong focus on driving the digital and sustainable transformation of Dutch industry. Dirk is committed to building partnerships that create long-term value for customers, employees, and society.
Remi Smeets Remi Smeets is Director of People & Organization at Siemens Netherlands. He is responsible for shaping the company’s people strategy, with a particular focus on employability, inclusion, wellbeing, and the development of future-relevant skills in a rapidly changing technological landscape.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
51
DIRK DE BILDE, REMI SMEETS
PUTTING PEOPLE AT THE CENTRE OF DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION: DIGNITY, INCLUSION, AND LIFELONG LEARNING IN AN AGE OF AI Humankind is at an inflection point. The shift to renewables, the transition to circularity, and the rapid rise of digitalization and artificial intelligence are reshaping how we work, learn, and relate to one another. For technology companies like Siemens, this raises a question that goes beyond efficiency or competitiveness: how do we ensure that digital transformation serves people, not the other way around? This is not a theoretical concern. It is a challenge that plays out every day; on our shop floors, in our engineering teams, and across the communities we serve. And it is a question of integrity: are we willing to put human values at the center of technological change, even when the pressure to move fast is immense? We believe the answer must be yes. And we believe that leading with integrity in a digital age means making deliberate choices about dignity, inclusion, and the continuous development of people.
The human dimension of digital change At Siemens, we create technology to transform the everyday, for everyone. Our innovations are embedded in modern life, from factories and buildings to trains and energy grids. But as we combine the real and digital worlds, we must be honest about what this transformation means for the people who operate, maintain, and depend on these systems. Digitalization and AI are not neutral forces. They change the nature of work, shift valued skills, and alter power dynamics. If we are not careful, they can deepen existing divides - between those with access to new tools and those without, and between those whose skills remain relevant and those who are left behind. This is why we are convinced that technology is only as powerful as it is accessible. The moment we lose sight of the human being at the center of transformation, we risk building systems that are technically brilliant but socially hollow.
52
Week of Integrity
Dignity and meaningful work in the age of AI A pressing question is what happens to the dignity of work when algorithms perform tasks once uniquely human. We do not believe AI will simply replace people, but it fundamentally changes what it means to contribute, to be competent, and to feel valued in a professional setting. At Siemens, we have seen this firsthand. As we deploy industrial AI, digital twins, and automated systems, we are constantly confronted with the need to redesign roles, not eliminate them. A maintenance engineer may now work alongside predictive analytics; a production planner may collaborate with AI-driven optimization tools. These shifts can be empowering, but only if people are given the time, training, and trust to grow into their new roles. Dignity in the workplace is not just about having a job. It is about understanding your contribution, having agency over your development, and being treated as a whole person, not as a resource to be optimized. This requires us to look beyond productivity and ask whether technology enhances the human experience of work or diminishes it. When we invest in reskilling alongside automation, involve people in shaping the tools they use, and redesign roles with care, technology becomes an enabler of dignity rather than a threat to it.
Inclusion by design, not by afterthought Digital transformation also carries a significant risk of exclusion. Design gaps, digital divides, and unconscious bias in algorithms can systematically disadvantage certain groups, whether by age, background, education level, or geography. Inclusion must therefore be embedded in the design of technology and the design of organizations, not treated as a corrective measure after the fact. At Siemens, we have set measurable targets in this area. Through our DEGREE sustainability framework, we track progress on pay equity, inclusion, wellbeing, and learning, including reducing the global adjusted pay gap, sustaining an inclusion level above eighty percent, maintaining a strong Work Well-being Score, and ensuring access to our Employee Assistance Program for our global workforce. These commitments reflect a conviction that inclusion is not a cost center; it is a condition for resilience. Diverse teams make better decisions. Inclusive workplaces attract and retain talent. And organizations that take equity seriously are better equipped to navigate the complexity of a digital world. Inclusion also demands something often overlooked: the courage to disagree. In organizations centered around innovation, diversity only creates value if people feel able to speak up, challenge assumptions, and embrace the friction that comes from genuinely different viewpoints. For a technology company navigating the complexities of a digital age, polite consensus is not enough. Real innovation requires environments where disagreement is not a risk, but a resource. Representation is one practical area where this commitment becomes visible. In the Netherlands, we are actively working to increase the representation of women in our workforce, but our focus extends far beyond gender alone. We
Leading with integrity in a digital age
53
intentionally foster an environment that embraces different cultural backgrounds and neurodiversity, recognizing that unique perspectives and ways of thinking are essential for true innovation. These efforts reflect our conviction that inclusion starts with access, and that access must be built intentionally, not assumed.
Skills for life: the imperative of lifelong learning Perhaps the most concrete expression of putting people at the center of digital transformation is our approach to learning and employability. In a world where millions of new jobs are expected to emerge in technology and green sectors, while many employers cite skill gaps as a barrier to progress, investing in human capability is not optional. It is essential. At Siemens, we embrace a growth mindset. We empower our people to gain not just the skills for today but the skills for life; to stay ready for the future. This is more than a training program. It is a philosophy that recognizes that in a rapidly changing environment, the ability to learn, unlearn, and relearn is the most valuable competency of all. We have set ourselves an ambitious target: to reach three million people in our business ecosystem and society at large with learning offerings focused on digitalization and sustainability by 2030. In fiscal year 2025, we already reached 1.1 million people. Our programs range from micro credentials and industrial learning platforms to dual vocational education and training initiatives. Crucially, we believe that knowledge should not be held back. As a technology company, we have a responsibility to share what we know; about digitalization, about sustainability, about the foundational skills needed to thrive professionally and personally. In the Netherlands, we put these principles into practice through collaborations with vocational colleges such as ROC Da Vinci College and universities including TU Delft and TU/e. We deliver guest lectures, organize workshops, support educational programs, and, as a recognized training company for nine vocational education programs, provide pathways that combine classroom learning with hands-on industrial experience. We also contribute to initiatives such as Sterk Techniek Onderwijs and advocate for technology to become a permanent part of primary school curricula. One example captures this approach well. Siemens supports students at TU Delft’s Eco-Runner Team with advanced design and simulation software and professional guidance. The team built a road-approved hydrogen car in just nine months, illustrating what becomes possible when technology companies invest in talent development and sustainable innovation side by side.
54
Week of Integrity
A call for collective responsibility We do not pretend to have all the answers. Digital transformation is too complex and fast-moving for any single organization to solve alone. But companies have a responsibility to lead by example and be transparent about both their progress and their struggles. Leading with integrity in a digital age means being honest about the tensions in transformation: balancing speed and scale with care and inclusion, and investing in people even when the return is not immediately visible on a balance sheet. At Siemens, our purpose is to create technology that transforms the everyday, for everyone. The word “everyone” is not a rhetorical flourish. It is a commitment to our employees, to the communities where we operate, and to the broader society that depends on the systems we help build and maintain. Digital transformation will define this century. The question is not whether it will happen, but whether it will happen in a way that upholds human dignity, promotes inclusion, and equips people to thrive. That is a question of integrity. And it is one that every organization and every society must answer - together. Ultimately, as we navigate this era of rapid change, the values an organization stands for become more than just a corporate compass; they become a vital anchor. In a society where we unfortunately see core values increasingly under pressure or even disappearing, the responsibility of businesses to lead with integrity and humanity has never been greater. For us, digital transformation is not merely a technological shift but a moral commitment to ensure that progress serves people, fosters inclusion, and upholds the dignity of every individual. By staying true to need-driven values, we can build a future that is not only technologically advanced but also profoundly human. This content was created with the help of artificial intelligence.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
55
WHO OWNS INTEGRITY IN A VALUE CHAIN?
Katja Bechtel Katja is an international expert in business integrity, anticorruption, and governance. She is currently Senior Advisor to Leadership and Global Strategy Lead, Business Integrity, at Transparency International, where her work sits at the intersection of civil society, international institutions, and the private sector. She previously held a senior role at the World Economic Forum and, over 20 years, has advised companies and international organizations on anti-corruption and financial crime strategy and on structuring public-private partnerships, initiating and leading several multi-stakeholder initiatives. Katja has also served in leadership capacities with the Business 20 (B20) Integrity & Compliance Task Force and other international platforms, and continues to work closely with regulators, civil society, and global business on advancing integrity in practice.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
57
KATJA BECHTEL
WHO OWNS INTEGRITY IN A VALUE CHAIN?
A supplier can be outside the scope of regulation and still be inside the expectations of the market. Over the past decade, companies have paid far greater attention to transparency, governance and responsible business practices. Regulation, investor expectations and market pressure have encouraged companies to look beyond their own operations and better understand the risks and impacts connected to their value chains. This reflects an important recognition: integrity is shaped not only by what happens within an organisation, but also by the relationships through which goods, services and investments move. Yet this evolution raises a fundamental question: as expectations travel further through increasingly complex value chains, how can organisations of different sizes and capacities meaningfully participate in this transition? Recent developments in EU sustainability regulation bring this question into sharper focus. Changes to the EU sustainability regulatory framework have sought to balance ambition with proportionality by reducing unnecessary reporting burdens and clarifying expectations for companies of different sizes. Measures such as the Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD) value-chain cap aim to limit the sustainability information that companies subject to reporting requirements can request from smaller business partners for reporting purposes. These developments respond to legitimate concerns about proportionality. Small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) represent the backbone of the European economy. They account for the vast majority of businesses and provide a significant share of employment and economic activity across the European Union. Many SMEs operate with fewer resources, less specialised expertise and less formalised governance structures than larger organisations. 1 At the same time, regulatory scope and business expectations do not always follow the same boundaries. A company outside the direct scope of CSRD reporting or Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD) obligations may still be part of the value chain of a larger company and may be asked to provide sustainability, governance or due-diligence information. Such requests can arise through procurement processes, contractual requirements, financing decisions, customer assessments or sector initiatives. This is not necessarily a problem. Companies have legitimate reasons to understand the risks connected to their business relationships. Due diligence exists precisely because impacts and risks do not always stop at organisational boundaries. 58
Week of Integrity
However, the value of integrity extends beyond responding to external expectations. Strong governance, transparent business practices and effective anti-corruption measures can also create business value. Companies that demonstrate responsible conduct can strengthen trust with customers and partners, improve resilience, access new opportunities and position themselves as reliable participants in increasingly interconnected markets. Integrity systems help companies meet expectations, but they also help companies succeed. The challenge is therefore not only how organisations respond to growing expectations, but how they build the capabilities that allow integrity to become part of everyday business practice.
When expectations meet reality Third-party risk management has become increasingly sophisticated. Supplier codes of conduct, questionnaires, screening tools and reporting processes help companies identify potential risks and establish expectations with their business partners. These mechanisms play an important role in strengthening accountability and transparency. Yet information alone is not enough. A completed questionnaire can demonstrate that a company has responded to a request. It does not necessarily show whether policies are understood and implemented whether employees feel able to raise concerns, or whether ethical considerations are integrated into everyday decision-making. This distinction matters particularly for SMEs. Many smaller companies operate with strong values, long-standing relationships and informal governance practices. The challenge is often not a lack of commitment, but the difficulty of translating that commitment into the language, systems and formats increasingly expected by larger business partners. For example, a small manufacturing supplier may receive integrity-related requests from several multinational customers: a code of conduct to sign, an anti-corruption questionnaire to complete, a whistleblowing process to describe and evidence of employee training to provide. Each request may be reasonable from the perspective of the individual customer. For the supplier, however, the cumulative effect can be significant, particularly where requirements differ in format or terminology. However, strengthening these practices is not only about responding to requests from customers or regulators. For SMEs, stronger integrity systems can support competitiveness by demonstrating reliability, reducing risks, improving access to business opportunities and strengthening relationships with partners who increasingly consider governance practices when selecting suppliers. The OECD has highlighted this challenge in relation to sustainability reporting, noting that SMEs increasingly need sustainability information to participate in markets and value chains, while facing barriers including “a lack of resources and expertise; difficulties in data collection; and complexity and insufficient interoperability among different sustainability reporting frameworks and standards.” 2 These challenges extend beyond sustainability reporting. Similar dynamics exist Leading with integrity in a digital age
59
in areas such as anti-corruption, human rights due diligence, cybersecurity and responsible procurement. Across these areas, expectations are increasing, but the ability of organisations to respond remains uneven. The OECD’s Due Diligence Guidance for Responsible Business Conduct emphasises that effective due diligence requires a risk-based approach, meaningful engagement with business relationships and ongoing efforts to prevent and address adverse impacts. Responsible business conduct is not achieved through monitoring alone, but through continuous improvement and collaboration with relevant stakeholders.
When data becomes the language of trust Digitalisation has transformed how organisations manage relationships with suppliers and other business partners. Procurement platforms, supplier management systems, disclosure tools and automated screening technologies allow companies to engage with thousands of organisations across global value chains. This creates important opportunities. Digital tools can improve transparency, make information easier to analyse and help companies identify where engagement and support may be most needed. Emerging technologies, including artificial intelligence, may further enhance the ability to process information, identify patterns and support risk-based decision-making. At the same time, the growing reliance on data raises important questions about how trust is built and assessed. Trust, in other words, appears to be shifting in nature: once built primarily through relationships, it has become increasingly transactional, and may in time become more algorithmic still. More information does not automatically lead to better decisions. Automated screening tools may generate false positives based on incomplete, outdated or context-dependent information. They may also fail to identify risks that are not visible in available datasets. In both cases, effective third-party governance requires more than data collection; it requires human judgement, contextual understanding and meaningful engagement with business partners. Digitalisation can also amplify fragmentation. When each organisation develops its own platform, questionnaire or data requirements, technology can unintentionally increase complexity. A supplier may find itself responding to multiple systems that request similar information but use different formats, terminology or expectations. The challenge is therefore not simply how to collect more information. It is how to ensure that information contributes to better decisions, stronger relationships and more effective integrity practices. The development of the voluntary sustainability reporting standard for SMEs (VSME) reflects broader efforts to create more proportionate and accessible approaches to sustainability reporting. Originally developed for smaller companies outside the scope of mandatory CSRD reporting, the VSME provides a common reference point to help businesses respond to sustainability-related information requests while reducing unnecessary complexity. As the EU sustainability reporting landscape evolves, ensuring that reporting tools
60
Week of Integrity
remain proportionate and fit for purpose across different business realities will require not only appropriate frameworks, but also practical guidance and capacity building. 3
From oversight to shared capability The future of third-party governance depends not only on better assessment, but also on stronger capability. Capacity building is often treated as an optional extra. In practice, it is central to effective compliance. Organisations cannot be expected to meet evolving expectations if they lack access to practical guidance, relevant tools, peer learning opportunities or spaces for dialogue. Supporting SMEs does not mean lowering expectations. It means creating the conditions that allow expectations to become meaningful in practice while avoiding unnecessary burdens that do not contribute to stronger governance outcomes. It also means recognising that integrity is not simply a compliance obligation. Companies that invest in governance, anti-corruption measures and responsible business practices can strengthen their reputation, build trust and position themselves as reliable partners. For companies managing large and complex value chains, this creates an opportunity to develop longer-term partnerships; for smaller businesses, practical support can help turn external expectations into stronger internal practices. Collaboration will therefore be essential. Business associations, civil society organisations, public institutions and companies of different sizes all have a role in creating greater coherence across the responsible business landscape. Collective action approaches can help organisations address shared challenges, develop common solutions and create practical pathways for improving integrity across value chains. Shared approaches, common language and practical tools can reduce unnecessary complexity while strengthening the integrity of business ecosystems.
Conclusion The answer to the question “who owns integrity”: not one company, one regulator or one stakeholder group. Integrity in a value chain is created through relationships. Regulation provides an important foundation. Transparency provides visibility. Digital tools provide new possibilities for connection with affected stakeholders, analysing information and support engagement. But ultimately, integrity depends on whether organisations have the knowledge, capacity and commitment to turn expectations into everyday practice. Data may increasingly become the language through which organisations communicate trust. But trust itself is built through the quality of relationships, the ability to act on information and the shared commitment to integrity across value chains. As responsible business expectations continue to evolve, the question is not only how organisations identify risks in their value chains; it is how they help build value chains in which integrity can take root. That is a shared responsibility. Leading with integrity in a digital age
61
References 1
Source: European Commission, SME Performance Review https://single-market-economy.ec.europa.eu/smes/sme-strategy-and-sme-friendlybusiness-conditions/sme-performance-review_en
2
Source: OECD, Guidance Note on Fostering Convergence in SME Sustainability Reporting https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/2025/06/oecd-guidance-note-on-fosteringconvergence-in-sme-sustainability-reporting_b1f6af62.html
3
Source: European Commission, Questions and answers on the Recommendation on a voluntary sustainability reporting standard for SMEs (VSME) https://finance.ec.europa.eu/publications/questions-and-answers-recommendationvoluntary-sustainability-reporting-standard-small-and-medium_en
62
Week of Integrity
Leading with integrity in a digital age
63
INTEGRITY CHALLENGES IN SOCIAL MEDIA
Patrick Wellens Patrick Wellens is Chairman of Ethics & Compliance Switzerland, a Board Member of the Association of Corporate Investigators, member of the Editorial Board of Society for Corporate Compliance and Ethics and member of editorial Board of Risk & Compliance magazines. He has published close to 40 articles in leading compliance journals and handbooks. Patrick has 30 years of experience in Governance, Risk, Ethics and Compliance, with a particular focus on building and operationalizing effective Compliance Programs. He has held global senior Compliance leadership roles with a multinational pharmaceutical company, built an internal audit function for another pharmaceutical company, and served as a country CFO. He also has 20 years of experience conducting and leading complex and sensitive investigations across all continents. Patrick is a Certified Compliance & Ethics Professional (CCEP), Certified Fraud Examiner (CFE), and recipient of several compliance awards.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
65
PATRICK WELLENS
INTEGRITY CHALLENGES IN SOCIAL MEDIA
On a daily basis more than 3 billion people consume some sort of social media (Instagram, Facebook, Whatsapp, Tiktok, X, Youtube, Messenger etc.). One of the biggest integrity challenges is misleading or false information on social media platforms. Prior to AI, producing convincing false information required considerable effort. Journalists, photographers, video editors etc. had to be involved. Now with the introduction of artificial intelligence the cost to produce false, fake or misleading information is much lower. With AI a person can now produce numerous articles, videos, fake profiles, convincing customer reviews and/or hundreds or thousands of social media posts. A society depends on scientific evidence, journalism, public institutions, companies; courts, elections etc. to maintain integrity of information. If people repeatedly encounter contradictory information, manipulated images and AI-generated content, they may eventually reach the conclusion: “I don’t know what to believe anymore”, which might lead to an erosion of trust. False information can also reinforce existing beliefs. Social-media algorithms can potentially compound this by showing people more content similar to that with which they already engage in. This can create situations in which two groups have completely different perceptions of reality and disagree about what actually happened. This article aims to explore some of the integrity challenges applicable to companies but also the integrity challenges of social media platforms
Integrity challenges for companies Integrity challenge 1: Authenticity vs. manipulation Social media rewards attention. That can create pressure to manipulate images, videos or reviews, exaggerate claims or selectively present facts or use emotionally provocative content to increase engagement. Exaggerated claims An investigation by the EU Commission showed that 40% of environmental product claims were not substantiated and that in 50% of cases a company did not provide sufficient elements for judgment of a claim’s accuracy i.e. whether the claim covered the whole product or only one of its components and/or which stage of the lifecycle was covered. Research shows that there are more than 230 different eco-labels, but most consumers are not aware of what is exactly covered under such eco-labels. To prevent this “Greenwashing” numerous consumer protection agencies provided guidance to companies and EU created the “Anti-greenwashing 66
Week of Integrity
Directive”. The aim is to ensure that any company communication or product claims which state that a product or company has a positive or no impact on the environment or is less damaging to the environment than other products or companies needs to be corroborated by proper evidence to avoid deceiving consumers. The use of words such as eco-friendly, green etc. are somewhat vague, does not allow consumers to make an informed purchasing decision. Using products with green color to suggest “natural” products is a form of deception and exaggerated product claims if not supported by proper evidence. Promotion laws for medicinal products, cosmetics, food supplements etc. clearly specify what can be said about a product and with which audience (professional doctors or consumers) communication can be shared. Consumers or patients must be informed including about the product, side-effects, and dosage and companies typically should not promote products outside the approved use (“off-label usage”). To ensure integrity in scientific or commercial communication, in most pharma companies a so called LMR (legal, medical and regulatory) review/approval takes place of all communication materials. Integrity challenge 2: Transparency about who is behind a communication A company should make it reasonably clear who is behind communication and what interests they have. Consumers should be able to distinguish between genuine personal expression, corporate communication, advertising and sponsored advocacy. Typically forms of deception that should not happen: • A key opinion leader (doctor) gives a speech and promotes the benefits of a given pharma product but hides that he/she is sponsored/paid by the pharma company. When key opinion leaders are sponsored by pharma companies, that should be part of the communication to consumers. • Companies use social media influencers to promote their product. If it is made clear to the consumers that the social media influencer is paid by the company or the product claim is a paid promotion, then the communication message is fully transparent. However, if social media influencers are being used to take advantage of their millions of followers but the message from the influencers to the consumers is not the honest opinion of the social media influencer but a sponsored message by the company, this borders deception and is not in line with integrity principles. • Testimonials that are incentivized but not disclosed. • Advocacy campaigns where the funding by sponsors is not disclosed. Integrity challenge 3: Social listening VS Surveillance Companies increasingly monitor social media: what employees say publicly; customer sentiment; criticism of the company; competitors; activists; and emerging reputational risks. But there is an important distinction between: “We monitor publicly available information to understand risks” and “We monitor individuals because we want to know what they are saying about the company.” Integrity requires consideration of purpose, proportionality, transparency and legitimate expectations. Leading with integrity in a digital age
67
Integrity challenge 4: Moderation and freedom of expression Companies running platforms, or companies managing their own social-media communities, also face a difficult integrity question: What should be removed? There are legitimate reasons to remove harassment; threats; hate speech; confidential information; fraudulent content and deliberate misinformation. But excessive moderation can also suppress legitimate criticism. A company therefore needs principles that are applied consistently, rather than simply deleting comments because they are inconvenient.
Integrity challenges for media platforms For companies such as Meta Platforms and Google, the central issue is that they are no longer simply communication channels. Their algorithms decide, to a significant extent, what people see, what gets amplified, what is monetized and what becomes visible. When a company has the technological ability to influence the behavior and information environment of hundreds of millions of people, does its responsibility end with complying with the rules, or does integrity require it to ask what it should do, even where the law does not yet provide the answer? Social media platforms’ commercial models may also reward engagement, attention and data collection. This raises an important question for the digital age: is it sufficient for a platform simply to comply with the law, or should we expect more—an integrity framework that also considers the foreseeable consequences of its technology and business model for individuals and society? Integrity challenge 1: Freedom of opinion vs control Social media platforms (Meta, Google etc.) have an integrity dilemma. Should they create the necessary processes and controls to ensure that fake or misleading news is not spread, and should they design a “code of conduct” of what consumers are allowed to say? If the platform does not do anything, then there is a risk that fake news spreads rapidly, whereas if there are strong control and intervention, this would limit the freedom of expression. The United States and Europe have different opinions about the responsibility and accountability of social media platforms. In Europe, the Digital Services Act was created to make social media platforms accountable. A more important question is therefore “What principles should platforms use when deciding whether and how to intervene, and are those principles transparent, consistent and accountable?” Is the platform transparent and consistent about how it handles demonstrably false, manipulated or harmful content? Does the platform apply its rules consistently, regardless of whether the content benefits or harms the platform commercially or politically?
68
Week of Integrity
Some of the more important integrity questions are: • Who establishes the rules? • Are the rules publicly available? • Are they applied consistently? • Can users appeal? • Are automated decisions reviewed? • Are vulnerable groups disproportionately affected? • Is the company transparent about errors? A company can potentially say: “We complied with the law.” while society asks: “But was what you did responsible?” In the US there are several ongoing lawsuits against social media platforms claiming that they did not do enough in protecting social media from minors. In Europe in numerous countries legislation has been created to protect minors in using excessively social media. In the eyes of these legislators, social media platforms should have acted with more integrity. Integrity challenge 2: Engagement vs. integrity The more time is spent on social media platforms, the more engagement is created, leading to more collection of user data /behavior which then generates more advertising and revenue. Some content that generates engagement can also be sensational, addictive, harmful to minors, misleading, socially destabilizing or divisive. Therefore, from an integrity perspective, the question is “if a social media platform knows that a particular algorithm increases engagement, but also creates societal harm, what should it do? Is it sufficient for a platform to comply with the law, or should we expect something more, an integrity framework that considers the foreseeable consequences of the technology and business model on individuals and society? Integrity challenge 3: Algorithmic integrity Suppose an algorithm learns that people are more likely to click on angry or sensational content. The algorithm then progressively shows more of that content. From an integrity point of view, we could ask: “Should companies be responsible not only for the content they host, but also for the consequences of the systems they use to amplify that content?” Integrity challenge 4: Transparency of algorithms Imagine two platforms show completely different information to two people searching for the same subject. Both users might believe: “This is what people are talking about.” But neither knows exactly why that particular information was selected. Integrity therefore requires more than transparency about what the algorithm is. It potentially requires transparency about what factors influence recommendations; how advertising affects visibility; how content is ranked, how moderation decisions are made; how users can challenge decisions; how algorithms are tested for unintended consequences.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
69
Integrity challenge 5: Integrity and misinformation One of the biggest integrity challenges is misleading or false information on social media platforms. 4 out of 10 adults encounter misinformation according to OFCOM, the British regulator for communication services. False information can lead to poor individual decisions on products and services, health, investments and financial products etc. The implications of fake news go much further than people simply believing something that isn’t true. In the digital age, the more important issue is that false or misleading information can change behavior, trust, markets and social relationships, especially when algorithms amplify it. The integrity problem is particularly serious when the person cannot reasonably distinguish reliable information from fabricated information.
Conclusion Integrity in social media is broader than simply “not posting false information.” For companies, it is about whether the organization—and its employees, leaders, influencers, and automated systems—communicate and behave online in a way that is truthful, transparent, fair, respectful, authentic, accountable and consistent with the organization’s values. Social media platforms should create an integrity framework that includes transparency on the (integrity of) algorithms, how algorithms are tested for unintended consequences and the principles used to intervene (or not) on false/ misleading information.
List of References •
https://environment.ec.europa.eu/topics/circular-economy-topics/green-claims_en
•
https://www.ofcom.org.uk/media-use-and-attitudes/attitudes-to-news/four-in10-uk-adults-encounter-misinformation
70
Week of Integrity
Leading with integrity in a digital age
71
TRUST, DEMOCRACY AND CIVIC SPACE IN A DIGITAL WORLD Biljana Cvetanovska Gugoska As Regional Programme Specialist for Local Governance and Integrated Urban Development at the UNDP Istanbul Regional Hub, she provides strategic leadership and policy advice on complex development agendas, supporting governments and partners in designing and implementing reforms that strengthen institutions, democratic participation, accelerate sustainable urban and regional development, and improve the quality of public services. Her work brings together policy, finance, innovation, and partnerships to translate development priorities into measurable and sustainable results. Throughout her career, Biljana has led large-scale programmes, mobilized significant resources, built strategic partnerships, and advised national and local institutions on governance and development reform. She has extensive experience working across sectors and across development and crisis contexts, with a particular focus on strengthening institutional capacity, enabling inclusive economic development, and advancing resilient and forward-looking governance systems. Before joining UNDP, Biljana served as State Secretary for Local Self-Government in the Government of North Macedonia, where she played a leading role in advancing reforms in local governance and balanced regional development. Her public-sector experience, combined with her international development expertise, gives her a distinctive perspective on connecting national policy with local implementation and community-level impact. Biljana’s contribution to international cooperation has also been recognized through the conferment of the Cavaliere dell’Ordine della Stella d’Italia, awarded by the President of the Italian Republic for her contribution to strengthening friendly relations and cooperation between North Macedonia and Italy. She holds a Master’s degree in Social Policy and Strategic Management for Sustainable Development from the University of Bologna and a Ph.D. in Regional Economic Development from the State University in Skopje. She has authored and contributed to publications, policy papers, conference contributions, and professional reports on local democracy, regional development, strategic planning, and governance in North Macedonia and the wider Western Balkans. Biljana’s professional focus is grounded in a commitment to inclusive, innovative, and resilient development, helping institutions navigate complex challenges, strengthen their capacity to deliver, and create conditions for sustainable prosperity and improved quality of life for communities.
Leading with integrity in a digital age
73
BILJANA CVETANOVSKA GUGOSKA
TRUST, DEMOCRACY AND CIVIC SPACE IN A DIGITAL WORLD
Democracy has always depended on a simple but fragile belief: people can come together, exchange ideas, challenge power and shape the future of their communities. For generations, Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) have been among the guardians of that belief. They have defended rights, amplified voices that might otherwise remain unheard, supported communities and helped transform public concerns into democratic action. Today, however, the foundations on which civic life rests are facing new pressures. Civil society stands at the crossroads of two powerful currents: shrinking civic space and expanding digital space. One narrows the room for action; the other widens the stage while making it increasingly difficult to distinguish truth from illusion. Across Europe and Central Asia, the space in which CSOs operate is shrinking rapidly1. New restrictive laws, limitations on access to foreign funding and growing state control, often justified through security concerns, are reducing civic freedoms and exposing CSOs, activists and journalists to increasing risks. These pressures frequently coincide with broader backlashes against gender equality and human rights, creating an environment in which even routine civic action has become more difficult. At the same time, digital transformation is redefining how democratic participation takes place. Much of today’s civic engagement now unfolds online, particularly among young people. Digital technologies have made it easier to organize, advocate and collaborate across borders, opening new opportunities for participation and collective action. But every new space for participation also creates new vulnerabilities. The digital public square has become both a marketplace of ideas and a hall of mirrors, where facts, emotions and manipulation can often appear with the same face. Surveillance, online harassment, hate speech and the rapid spread of mis- and disinformation increasingly shape how people experience civic life. The challenge is not simply that false information exists. The deeper challenge is that trust itself is becoming harder to sustain. The result is a more fragile information environment. The rapid spread of misleading content and divisive narratives blurs the line between civic action, misinformation, and manipulation, weakening public debate, deepening polarization, and eroding trust in democratic institutions. As Unites Nations Development Programme (UNDP) work on information pollution across Europe and Central Asia highlights, information pollution is not only a communications challenge, it affects informed decision-making and democratic resilience, while
74
Week of Integrity
often reflecting deeper societal fractures that require broader responses. Protecting civic space today means more than safeguarding freedom of expression. It also requires protecting the integrity of the information environment in which democratic participation takes place. In this context, integrity means access to trustworthy information, transparency about how information is produced and shared, accountability for harmful or misleading communication, and responsible communication that strengthens rather than undermines public trust. This calls for stronger capacities among citizens and civil society to navigate complex digital environments, counter information pollution, and build trust through responsible communication. For CSOs, the challenge is to use digital tools to broaden participation while grounding engagement in ethical storytelling, informed citizenship, and meaningful connections between online mobilization and offline democratic action. Ultimately, civic resilience depends not only on the freedom to speak, but also on the ability to participate with confidence and informed judgment.
Digital Activism: Opportunity and Responsibility Online engagement alone cannot deliver lasting democratic change. Followers, views, and shares do not automatically translate into stronger communities or greater accountability. While digital activism can raise awareness, its impact remains limited without offline action, such as advocacy, community organizing, or citizen engagement. Echo chambers can also reinforce divisions rather than promote inclusive dialogue. The real question is what happens after engagement begins. Do citizens become better informed? Do they become more connected to their communities? Do online conversations lead to sustained civic participation and action? Leading with integrity means asking these questions from the outset. Digital tools should not be used simply to attract attention, but to foster informed, meaningful and trustworthy participation. The purpose of civic engagement is not only to be visible; it is to build relationships, strengthen communities and support people in becoming active participants in democratic life. This also requires recognizing that freedom of expression comes with responsibility. Open societies depend on the ability to debate, disagree and exchange ideas, but they also depend on access to reliable information and the ability to distinguish facts from manipulation. Protecting civic space today therefore also means protecting the integrity of information. Without trust in the information environment, participation itself becomes weaker.
Are civil society organizations ready? To better understand how CSO is adapting to the digital landscape, UNDP commissioned an assessment with Social Movement Technologies across the Western Balkans and Eastern Europe. The findings highlighted both resilience and vulnerability: despite political pressure, public mistrust, and complex information environments, organizations remain closely connected to communities, adapt creatively, and are committed to strengthening their digital capacities. Leading with integrity in a digital age
75
The assessment identified three key capacity gaps. First, many organizations lack integrated digital infrastructure and strategic use of digital tools. Second, they struggle to convert public support into sustained civic participation and local leadership. Third, they need stronger communication practices that prioritize ethical storytelling, transparency, and public trust. These findings show that digital capacity extends beyond technology, it is also essential to building credibility, accountability, and trust and to strengthening integrity in digital civic space.
Building Integrity in Digital Civic Spaces Strengthening civic resilience in the digital age requires more than adopting new technologies, it requires ensuring that digital participation is informed, meaningful, and trustworthy. As civic engagement increasingly moves online, organizations must expand participation while protecting the integrity of the information environment that underpins democratic dialogue. First, digital engagement should support long-term relationship building rather than stand-alone campaigns. The most effective digital activism is embedded in broader civic movements, strengthening community networks, public narratives, and resilience, particularly where civic space is restricted. Second, online engagement should create pathways for deeper participation. Supporters should have opportunities to volunteer, organize, and lead, linking digital engagement with offline civic action through community initiatives, advocacy, and local organizing. Third, organizations need secure and integrated digital systems to protect information, manage communications, and reduce digital risks while improving efficiency and outreach. Fourth, information integrity must become central to civic action. This requires strengthening media and information literacy, promoting responsible communication, supporting citizens to recognize manipulation, and understanding the opportunities and risks of artificial intelligence and other emerging technologies. Finally, trust depends on leadership and integrity. Ethical storytelling, transparency, accountability, and informed consent are essential for maintaining public confidence and ensuring that civic participation remains inclusive and credible. In the Western Balkans, UNDP, together with partner agencies, is working with journalists, decision-makers and youth leaders to empower young people to take a stand against hate speech and contribute to safer, more inclusive digital environments. These efforts recognize that building integrity online requires not only addressing harmful content, but also supporting the voices, skills and networks needed to foster respectful dialogue and social cohesion.
76
Week of Integrity
The Way Forward The future of civic space will depend on how societies respond to the opportunities and risks of digital transformation. Technology can reshape how people participate, but its impact on democracy depends on how we use it. For CSO and their partners, the focus should be on three priorities: ensuring that digital engagement builds trust rather than simply generates attention, connecting online participation with meaningful action, and putting safeguards and leadership practices in place to protect information integrity. This includes investing in secure systems, ethical communication, media and information literacy, and stronger links between digital engagement and community action. This is the approach increasingly guiding UNDP’s work across the region. Recognizing that digital transformation presents both opportunities and risks for civic participation, UNDP supports CSO, youth actors, and public institutions to strengthen digital governance, build more resilient information ecosystems, and promote safe, inclusive, and meaningful civic engagement. In practice, this includes support for digital outreach, media and information literacy, tools to counter mis- and disinformation, prevent hate speech, and platforms for sharing practical approaches to digital activism, ethical storytelling, and social cohesion. Digital activism is not a shortcut to democratic change. When grounded in integrity, informed participation, and trust, it can help protect civic space, strengthen social cohesion, and turn digital engagement into lasting democratic impact. The goal is not simply to make civic participation more digital, but to make it more meaningful, trustworthy, and inclusive.
References 1
Civicus Monitor Tracking Civic Space Europe and Central Asia - Civicus Monitor (monitor.civicus.org)
Leading with integrity in a digital age
77
Compliance is nonnegotiable. We stand against bribery, fraud, and any form of misconduct. Integrity guides all our decisions because it is deeply embedded in our culture and business operations. Roland Busch President and CEO of Siemens AG
“True character is revealed not in grand gestures, but in the small, unwitnessed choices we make every day. It’s the quiet decision to do the right thing, to stay honest under pressure, and to hold ourselves to the same standard whether anyone is watching or not. I am proud to be a part of a company where integrity isn’t treated as a slogan on a wall, but as a daily discipline embedded in how decisions get made. It is this consistency that earns the genuine trust of our people, customers, and partners.” Araz Alasgarov Group Ethics & Compliance Director, NEQSOL Holding
This book was established in the context of the Week of Integrity 2026, an initiative of the Week of Integrity Foundation, founded by ICC Netherlands. © Week of Integrity Foundation. 2026. The views expressed in this publication are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of the Week of Integrity Foundation nor of ICC Netherlands. The Week of Integrity Foundation does not guarantee the accuracy of the data included in this publication and accepts no responsibility for any consequences of their use. The Week of Integrity Foundation holds all copyright and other intellectual property to this work. Week of Integrity Foundation | Stichting Week van de Integriteit Bezuidenhoutseweg 12, 2592 AV, The Hague, The Netherlands www.weekofintegrity.org Graphic Design: Polina Bila, www.linkedin.com/in/polinabila Cover Concept: Hetty van der Linden, www.paintafuture.org Cover Photo: Fred Hoffmann Photos: The photos included in this publication were provided by the authors with their explicit approval for use in this publication. The authors retain all rights to their photos. These photos may not be reproduced, distributed, or used for any other purpose without the explicit permission of the respective authors.
Before algorithms carried messages around the world, canvas did. Artist Hetty van der Linden conceived this cover around three stages in the history of communication, brought together here in a sail painted within her project Sail a Future. Discover Sail a Future
Hetty van der Linden
Initiator
For her the canvas is the medium, and here the medium is literally the message. The same light cloth that caught the wind in a ship’s sails could hold a painted image and carry it overseas. In fifteenth-century Venice, painters realised that on canvas, pictures could be rolled, shipped and carried to distant lands, crossing the divide of language. Then came the printing press, which made the written word reproducible. The essays in this book still travel that way, in paper and ink. Today the medium is digital. Canvas carried its message in plain sight; you could always see whose hand had painted it. Digital communication reaches further and faster, but often anonymously and open to manipulation. The sail on this cover, painted by children in collaboration with artists, as a fitting emblem for a Week that asks what it means to Lead with Integrity in a Digital Age.
Supported by