Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts
An evaluation of artistic sensory engagement strategies used to mitigate the communication gap between scientific ecological research and general audiences. Sophie Ferrier 2024
Submitted to Hereford College of Arts In partial fulfilment of the requirements For the degree of BA (Hons) Contemporary Design Craft- HECD6020
Validated by the University of Wales Trinity St David Word count: 8864 Edited word count: 5450
1
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts
[FIG 1, Parker L. (2006) Taste of a Place]
Dedicated to the Soil, the life-giving material that holds us, feeds us, and without it, we would cease to exist.
2
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts The term Homo, meaning human, comes from humus, meaning soil. The defining quality of humanity is that after spending their lifetimes working the land, they will return to the land, ‘‘for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return’’ Genesis 3:17 cited in (MINAMI, Soil & humanity: Culture, civilization, livelihood and health, 2009) In this essay, I will explore how the arts can bridge the communication gap between environmental science and the audience, offering a more accessible way to comprehend complex data. Additionally, I will discuss how the arts serve as a vehicle to transform negative perceptions about soil. In addressing how artistic sensory engagement strategies mitigate the communication gap between ecological research and general audiences. I will present and evaluate two artistic case studies, to demonstrate how these strategies convey meaning and value for audiences otherwise excluded from the scientific sphere. Using the selected primary evidence of semiotic frameworks of Gillian Rose Visual Methodologies (2001), Roland Barthes's Theory of sign (1957) with supporting secondary evidence from Sturken and Cartwright’s Practice of Looking (2009), these case studies will show how the arts may employ sensory strategies to transmit meaning, value and operate as a successful vehicle for shifting embedded perceptions towards a crucial and largely overlooked component of our ecology: the soil biome. I have chosen to address these aims in two phases. Firstly, I will present primary and secondary evidence to illustrate this inquiry's motivation and inspiration and orient my critical lens as an artist and practitioner working in the ecological sphere, using supporting secondary material from Schmidt (2009) and Biersteker (2022). Taking the radical work of Alexandra R Toland (2023) as the thematic heart of this investigation, I will present how I aim to evidence my premise, with an evaluation of my selected semiotic methodologies. This will be supported with secondary evidence including but not limited to the work of Emily Brady (2005) and Susanne C. Moser (2012). The second phase of this investigation will utilize these frameworks alongside formal object analysis to examine two artistic case studies centered on soil and how it provokes our material senses, commencing with Laura Parker's ‘Taste of a Place’ (2006). Secondly, I will analyse the collaborative work of artists and academics, Karine Bonneval, Fanny Rybak, and Charlotte Poulsen, ‘Listen to the Soil’ (2016). These case studies were chosen for their interdisciplinary foundation, their exemplifying breadth of sensory characteristics, and the diverse modes of engagement they offer. Ultimately to present a depth of primary evidence on which to draw my conclusions through comparison and illustrate how this category of artistic expression can shift existing perceptions, and therefore mitigate the communication gap between ecological research and general audiences through a radical sensory-based conveyance of meaning and value, demonstrated through the application of semiotic frameworks. Ultimately, creating a body of work that represents how the arts are used as a vehicle to communicate vital information on soil health. Situating the issue of the ‘communication gap’ in its discourse, this exploration is motivated by the apparent inaccessibility of the dissemination structure of most scientific evidence, presenting a challenge for scientists in effectively conversing, whether that be positive ecological developments or the impacts of climate change in the Anthropocene. This gap is an ever-growing issue, (see appendix 1) for primary research from my audience. This disconnect is often called the ‘communication gap,’ (Schmidt, 2009) which excludes the public from engaging with ecological sciences. In this context, I aim to identify these gaps to display how art serves as a beneficial medium for communicating our complex ecologies and establishing a sense of kinship between humans and their environment. Art can foster personal awareness regarding environmental systems and underscore the gravity of their degradation. As Thijs Bierstker states in a TedTalk on ‘How art can help fight climate change’:
3
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts “Once you can see it, you can imagine it, and once you imagine it, then it becomes really hard to deny it, and that leaves one option open, taking action on it” (Biersteker, 2022). Soil consists of minerals, microorganisms, macro-organisms, air, and water, which manifests as a dynamic amalgamation of a diverse rich ecosystem beneath us. Reputed as the most “Dynamic and important natural resource” (America, n.d.), soil encapsulates an intricate interplay of elements that collectively orchestrate its ecological functionality. Despite its pivotal role, soil often languishes in relative obscurity in the everyday existence of human societies, burdened by the pejorative associations of being deemed “dirty” and “pathogenetic.” Regrettably, as a species, we have not understood the profound significance of fostering healthy, diverse, living soils and their indispensable role in preserving the vitality of local ecologies and, by extension, our well-being. “Soil is the great connector of lives, the source and destination of it all. It is the healer and restorer and resurrector, by which disease passes into health, age into youth, death into life. Without proper care for it we can have no community because without proper care for it, we can have no life” (Clive Adams, 2015) Taking inspiration from Alexandra R Toland's paper Soil Art: Sensory and Symbolic Engagement with Soils published in the Encyclopaedia of Soil in the Environment (2023). Where Toland introduces a subset of artistic research landscape focused on soils. In conjunction with advancements in proximal soil sensing technologies, artists contribute a fresh perspective to soil sensing. The artists achieve this by facilitating multi-sensory experiences, developing novel vocabularies for interpreting sensed data, raising awareness about soil ecosystems and their intricacies, and generating innovative research on soil. Characterized by diverse formats, focal points, and presentation methods, that have the potential to engage various audiences and societal segments. Toland’s innovative interdisciplinary mode of artistic yet scientific research demonstrates a burgeoning shift towards employing specific sensory engagement strategies, that serve to mitigate the communication gap between ecological research and general audiences to create a palpable shift in attitudes towards soil. To demonstrate this, I present the theories and methodologies of semiotic academics deriving meaning and value, such as Rose (2015), as well as Barthes (1957), and Sturken and Cartwright (2009). These theories and methods are an anchor whilst analysing the following artworks. I have chosen the framework of sensory engagement within art pieces as I believe this is one of the fundamental ways we can engage with something profoundly and personally. Philosopher Emily Brady (2005, P.177) discusses in her essay ‘The Aesthetics of Smell and Tastes’, "That sniffing and savoring not only form a fundamental pathway to sensory perception of our environment but also help define the quality and character of people, places, and events." In its most fundamental role (Toland, 2023). However, for this essay's sake, I will analyse the artistic pieces through the lens of a computer screen and several books, meaning my interpretation of the decoded meaning and analysis of value may be affected as my senses will not be engaged. The communication gap is a recognized phenomenon that prevents barriers from certain audiences from understanding the information in front of them (Hupp, 2023). Academia communicates using an exclusive vocabulary that can exclude general audiences. Communication gaps can be owed to several personal factors and societal barriers: access to education, neurodiversity, economic status, and poor mental health in the face of ongoing environmental degradation, otherwise known as ‘green fatigue,’ or suggested by Nordhaus and Shellenberger [2009] ‘apocalypse fatigue’ (Susanne C. Moser, 2012).
4
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts The media also use the arts as a vehicle to ‘greenwash’1 their chosen audience, creating a divide between ecological restorative art and art/design claiming to be sustainable, thus resulting in a lack of understanding or even confusion among the audiences. How can environmental activists or craftivists, engage all members of the public in the message we are attempting to convey when these factors are incredibly consuming to the individual? Environmental and eco-art consists of aesthetically pleasing and ecological restorative pieces, sustainable or restorative in material choice, which ask probing questions, understand historical aspects of ecosystems, offer restoration and remediations, identify patterns that can enhance ecological relationships, and model ecological values (Wallen, Ecological Art, 2012). I propose that employing artistic sensory engagement strategies enacts a profoundly effective transmission of meaning and value to audiences, therefore mitigating the communication gap between ecological research and audiences. I will evidence this in the second phase of this investigation. Considering supportive evidence from John Berger’s seminal ‘Ways of Seeing’ (1972), whilst viewing these pieces, is that ‘objects’ have different meanings depending on your own experiences, that our knowledge and beliefs shape our perception, and that our gaze is perpetually entwined with the relationships between objects and ourselves (Berger, 1972). With semiotics in mind and analysing the organic matter, soil as a universal material, using philosopher Barthes's (1957) theory of signified levels of meaning [FIG2]. Firstly, ‘Denotation’ refers to its literal explicit meaning (Sturken M, 2009). According to the Oxford dictionary, the literal meaning of soil is the “Top layer of earth in which plants, trees, etc. grow” (Oxford Learners Dictionaries, n.d.).
[FIG 2: Barthes R. (1957), Semiotic table] The second level of meaning is ‘Connotation’, this is the meaning being informed by the cultural and historical context of the item, with the viewer's lived, felt knowledge of those circumstances, all that the item means to them personally and socially (Sturken M, 2009). This is where the meaning can change depending on who's witnessing it. To me, personally; soil represents a spiritual godly substance, the almighty creator that we owe our entire existence to, a material so profound it gives life and recycles death. Conversely, a farmer's viewpoint introduces a pragmatic dimension where soil is construed as a fertile growth medium for crops, intricately linked to both their livelihood and economic sustenance. The multifaceted significance of soil extends further to encompass its role in
1 Greenwashing definition: “At its core, greenwashing is about misrepresentation, misstatement and false or misleading
practices in relation to environmental, social, and governance credentials.” - (Pears, 2023)
5
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts shaping cultural identity within the farmer's realm. To academic Claire Lodder, lecturer at Bath University Spa, the material of soil is: “That cosmos is under our feet, those nodes of connectivity, life pulsating beingness. That's how I feel about the soil, it’s finite because it's on this earth, but it is cosmetically connected as well, it's so beautiful deep, dark, and mysterious”. – (See Appendix 2) Finally, cultural myth is a hidden set of rules and conventions where meanings that are specific to certain groups, are made to seem universal. Thus, allowing the connotative meaning of a particular thing [its value and truth] to appear to be denotative, literal, or nothing (Sturken M, 2009). In the article ‘Soil and Humanity: Culture, civilization, livelihood, and health’ (2010) Katsuyuki Minami asserts the intricate link between soil and the cultural and civilizational aspects of specific ethnic groups residing in a particular location. This connection encompasses their religious beliefs, thoughts, livelihoods, and overall well-being. The author further contends that cultures originate with soil as a foundational element, emphasizing that many cultures centre around the significance of soil. Additionally, Minami underscores that the deterioration of soil played a pivotal role in the downfall of numerous civilizations (Minamo K 2009), this theory is to be considered throughout this paper. This reaffirms the chosen material at the heart of this essay; soil, holds great cultural meaning and value across civilizations across history, indicating it is a powerful tool in changing cultural perceptions about the natural world and thus closing the communication gap between general audiences and the scientific ecological research. This plays two roles in the engagement with the audience: sensory material and cultural material. The first artwork under consideration is American-based, interdisciplinary artist Laura Parker's ‘Taste of a Place’ (2006). Her work focuses on the environment, social structures, and agriculture. She has created an installation/interaction piece that focuses on her audience’s engagement with their senses to inform them where our food comes from, an investigation of the public's relationship with the soil and their food, and to explore the impact of these connections through experience. She questions, “How does the soil touch our lives and our food, and why does it matter?” (Parker, 2006). The installation consists of wine glasses full of different soils from different farms to sniff, and food to taste grown in that same soil. Commencing with formal observations, ‘Taste of a Place’ emphasizes the colour diversity within different soil types, the primary chosen material in the installation, each in clear glass jars and wine glasses [FIG 1]. As an artistic choice, being able to see the difference in colour gradients depending on the sample’s place of origin enables Parker to communicate visually with her audiences the diversity of soil types hidden out of sight beneath our feet, as said by A. Toland: “The collections of soil samples in these artworks are archives of soil diversity that, despite being moved from places of origin, create awareness for soil as more than a homogenous brown substrate to grow crops. Artists shine a light on a veritable subterranean rainbow of difference usually inaccessible to human vision.” (Toland, 2023)
6
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts
[FIG 3: Parker L. (2006) Taste of a Place] Parker (2006) taps into the olfactory sense2, encouraging her audience to take in the aromas of both the soil samples themselves, and the taste of food grown in that chosen soil to create a new sensorial awareness of the relationship between the two. In considering the origins and purpose of the human senses, smell, and taste are two that have evolved to navigate and detect factors of our environment, whether that be a nearby fire or analysing the soil itself (Weintraub, 2016). Therefore, these senses when utilised as an artistic engagement strategy ultimately deepen the connection between the audience, the artwork, and the meaning and message behind it. Recreating the act of connecting soil to our food by smelling and tasting likewise symbolizes smelling your food before eating it. I, therefore question if this piece could also help trigger the senses in our experience of the natural world, for example when the soil gets rained on. A term coined by two Australian chemists, Isabel Joy Bear, and Richard Grenfell Thomas, in 1964 as ‘Petrichor’, which evokes nostalgia as well as certain bodily feelings (Vittal, 2019). Thus, demonstrating that Parker's work is arguably a successful vehicle for connecting the audience to a feeling that evokes meaning through sensory engagement. Decoding through the lens of semiotics necessitates evidence from Sturken and Cartwrights' study of signs. '... “We live in a world of signs, and it is the labor of our interpretation that makes meaning of those signs” (Cartwright, 2009). Applying this to Parker’s work, wine has been a visual signifier of taste, social class, courtship, and the divine throughout different cultures and centuries. The diverse portrayals of wine highlight its changing cultural meaning (Wallentine, 2021). Therefore, acknowledging that there will be a diversity of experience in the audience's interpretation, unified by a universal understanding of the cultural implication of the ‘sign’ of a wine glass. The difference in each experience catalyses the sensory strategy of the installation whilst likewise communicating a new and deeper understanding of the soil biome activated by the deeply personal experiences of taste and smell. 2 Olfactory sense: “The bodily structure that serves the sense of smell”. (The Editors of Encyclopaedia. "olfactory system".,
2019).
7
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts
[FIG 4, Parker L. (2006) Taste of a place] This evaluation takes on a deeper dimension through the application of Gillian Rose’s Visual Methodologies framework, which asserts that meaning is constructed through the intersections of production, imagery, and audience within three distinct categories: technology, composition, and social issues (Rose, 2012). Firstly, I will focus on how the site of the audience may affect the meaning; ‘The site of the audience’s interpretations and experience of the artwork’ (Rose, 2012). We have to ask ourselves what type of audience Parker attracts. As you can see in [FIG 2], the image that promotes and represents the installation shows four women interacting with the piece. These women appear to be in their forties with different ethnic backgrounds, which promotes diversity and inclusiveness. What I notice first about these images is the lack of children and men. Is this because the installation represents that of wine tasting? Something considered within social groups of women, or is wine tasting and enhancing your palate more desirable to women? Or could this be an acknowledgment of Ecofeminism?3 In addition, Rose (2012) states that the historical and cultural context of the audience affects the meanings they make of artwork, like the personal feelings the olfactory senses promote within the individual. One may have a negative experience with soil or fresh raw food, thus bringing a different feeling to one with a curious relationship to them. Ingold states that: “if people from different backgrounds orient themselves in different ways, this is not because they are interpreting the same sensory experience in terms of alternative cultural models or cognitive schemata, but because, due to their previous bodily training, their senses are differentially attuned to the environment.” (Ingold, The Perception of the Environment, 2000)
3 Ecofeminism: “A branch of feminism that sees environmentalism, and the relationship between women and the earth, as
foundational to its analysis and practice. It addresses the parallels between the oppression of nature and the oppression of women.” (Zien. 2017).
8
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts
[Fig 5: Ranch, T. (2006). Gathering of Women in Culinary] Secondly, the intersection of the meaning being made at the site of production due to the sheer amount of research and work that has gone into collecting these soil samples and teaming up with farmers from 78 farms with detailed analyses of soil structures (see appendix 3) (Parker, 2006). This creates a new network for the transmission of meaning, drawing a direct line of artistic communication from the people who grow our food, to the artist, and general audiences across social segments, activated and enabled through a sensory engagement strategy predicated by taste and smell. This brings value to the piece as it fosters an appreciation for the inherent intelligence of soil across cultures and social groups, enabling the construct of connection that underscores a shared experience. This, in turn, promotes a heightened awareness of our commonalities (Adamson, 2018), and therefore facilitates greater opportunity for communication of complex ecological meaning. Evaluating this composition through the lens of social status, I would argue that there is a nuanced interplay between audience perceptions at the intersection of privilege and accessibility. On the one hand, issues of privilege and exclusivity permeate Parker’s installation. The audience observing the promotion of this specific piece may have sentiments of insignificance and a perceived lack of proficiency in the realm of taste palates, as wine tasting is an activity that traditionally belongs to wealthier economic sections of society. Furthermore, the thematic focus on soil and food introduces an additional layer of potential deterrent, as soil traditionally carries connotations of impurity, necessitating cleansing, accommodating pathogens, and posing health risks. Yet alternatively, Parker’s (2006) deliberate incorporation of soil into wine glasses, designed for olfactory exploration, seems geared towards creating a sense of safety in examining soil as reinforced through her artistic appropriation of the form and connotation of a well-known practice as an analogy, and a metaphor. This nuanced approach may inadvertently contribute to perceiving the event as a luxury experience. Luxury possesses the intrinsic ability to evoke sentiments of exclusivity and uniqueness (Prendergast, 2000). Consequently, the installation may hold an allure for those unaccustomed to partaking in sophisticated culinary engagements, effectively broadening its appeal to a broader audience. However, individuals lacking awareness of ecological issues, soil consciousness, or interest in the origins of their food might be disinclined to participate in such a workshop. This demographic, 9
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts however, represents a pivotal target for ecological enlightenment, effectively informing and educating them necessitates strategic modifications to the presentation. One potential approach involves situating soil within containers traditionally associated with individuals of diverse economic status, such as fast-food boxes. Alternatively, employing universally recognized items like mugs could be a relatable medium. A more inclusive strategy could offer a variety of containers, allowing participants to select those they feel most comfortable to engage with. Ultimately as stated by Berger (1972) it becomes apparent that the choice of container significantly influences individuals’ interpretations. Recognizing the subjectivity inherent in these relationships, providing diverse options addresses the inherent diversity in meanings attached to the same object. In this context, the symbolic divide in meaning between the wine glass and its potential interpretations for the audience underscores the need for a more adaptable and inclusive approach to foster engagement and comprehension among a broader spectrum of participants. Therefore, widening the impact of Parker’s intention to re-situate soil in the collective consciousness as an item to be valued and engaged with on a sensory level, bringing participants into a closer relationship with it as an ecological material, and therefore in closer communication with the research she playfully presents in a wine tasting context. Referring back to Barthes's (1957) cultural myth, you could argue that the cultural myth has shifted through this sensory engagement from fear, pathogens, and uncertainty to a more stable, curious relationship with the soil. Being able to explore through vulnerable vital senses in a safe space that Parker (2006) has created has enabled the audience to connect with the chosen discourse in a way that visually you are unable to connect with. Conversing a deeper relationship to the connection between consumer and food, to humanity and the soil. The criticism towards the chosen object used to interact with the soil, the wine glass; may put certain groups of people off, but the use of sign and signifier in this interactive piece is strong and coherent. Considering this, I believe ‘Taste of a Place’ incorporates the sensory engagement strategies successfully by the use of interaction with the soil via scent and taste, therefore successfully using sensory engagement to close the communication gap between the scientific knowledge/research and the audience. The second case study, ‘Listen to the Soil’, emanates from the collaborative efforts of Karine Bonneval, a transdisciplinary artist, Fanny Rybak, a ‘biocoustician’4 an academic affiliated with the University of Paris-Sud, and ceramicist Charlotte Poulsen. Started in 2016 this collective endeavour has yielded an interactive exhibition piece designed to connect the audience with the soil through sound and to deepen the scientific research into the soil biome. This collaborative creation comprises several sizable black ceramic vessels, articulated as a visual representation of “myxomycete5- fruiting body-like objects” (Matthias C. Rillig, 2019). These forms augment the auditory perception of soil microorganisms, thereby offering a voice to the voiceless, the unrepresented organisms of our existence. To create an interdisciplinary dual pursuit of artistic
4
Soil bioacoustics: “Biologists that capture underground noises to open a window into our subterranean world. They've found that listening to underground sounds promises to reveal not only what life forms reside below our feet but also how they go about their existence” (Eberle, 2022) 5 Myxomycete: “Fungus-like organism, commonly known as true slime mold”. (Science & Tech: Myxomycetes, 2020)
10
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts expression and scientific inquiry, figuratively and literally bridging a communication gap with audio soil-scapes.
[FIG 6: Bonneval K, (2020) Listen to the soil] Collaboratively engaging in further research, particularly with scientific counterparts, underscores the project's commitment to not only artist innovation but also the advancement of ecological knowledge. This undertaking collectively contributes to a broader thematic interrogation of humanity's relationship with the terrestrial substrate (Hidalgo-Laurier, 2018). These vessels exhibit distinct elevations strategically positioned at varying heights, rendering them accessible at ear level for both adults and children [FIG 7,8,9]. Constructed from black grog clay and earthenware, the vessels manifest a range of textural nuances, with some presenting smooth surfaces whilst others displaying pronounced textures, including deep cracks within the material. Each vessel assumes a unique form and shape, correlating with the biodiversity of fungi or plant life. The careful consideration of size rendering the vessels accessible to children underscores a notable emphasis on broad inclusivity. This aligns with the overarching ethos of the installation, distinguishing it from ‘Taste of a Place”. This formal strategy conveys a sense of approachability and universality, suggesting that children's participation is an implicit endorsement towards an interactive experience accessible to individuals of diverse age groups, indicating a greater capacity to engage audiences in scientific content facilitated by artistic expression.
11
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts
[FIG 7: Bonneval K. (2016) Listen to the Soil] Considering the work’s scientific aspects, it must be noted that when in a state of health, soil exhibits a richness in biodiversity, a phenomenon substantiated by the associated study's findings (Belowground biodiversity and ecosystem functioning, 2014). A pervasive lack of public awareness prevails in the distinction between flourishing and depleted soils, with the latter typically attributed to chemical inputs, over-ploughing, and overgrazing. These sculptural pieces serve as vehicles for an auditory exploration, encapsulating sound recordings originated with distinct soil types; compost crafted by the artist, a topographical hill in Sri Lanka, intensively farmed agricultural fields, and the Berlin Botanical Garden. Evidencing the interdisciplinary foundation of this artwork, a scientific anechoic chamber (Bonneval, 2018) facilitated the capture of these soil sounds. Indeed “A soil in good shape is noisy” (Augusto Zanella, 2020), with each soil type emitting a distinctive sound reflective of its unique ecological composition. These auditory differences within the sculptures provide the audience with an opportunity for autonomous analysis and judgment, enabling them to discern the level of activity within each soil variant. This auditory engagement fosters a connection between the audience, the landscape, the environment, and the soil, facilitating a nuanced appreciation of the intricate relationship inherent in these ecological systems. Evaluating the power of this work to change audience perceptions, artist Karine Bonneval states, “Usually when I start to tell people that I am working with soil, people say it is dirty” (Wright, 2020). This marks a tangible gap between ecological evidence, concerns, and public perception of a substance integral to planetary well-being, and I would argue that a critical inquiry towards a heightened sense of gravity and concern for soil must be addressed. I propose that this artwork does so successfully with the following theories.
12
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts Given that this work, visually and audibly encompasses a sign through sound amplification, I propose that it projects an otherworldly curiosity. When considered in line with Barthes (1957) stipulating that meaning is made through signs, with signified meaning embodying the ‘voice to the voiceless’, it becomes clear that this work is a tangible example of meaning made accessible through audible signs, facilitated by a scientific and artistic sensory strategy where humans derive meaning through their senses (Marsen, 2008). Furthermore, to consider secondary supporting evidence from cultural myth, depends on the sophistication of this artwork and sheds greater light on its power to change audience perception of the soil, ultimately mitigating the communication gap. For example, to consider these microorganisms would be to detangle the language of ‘microbes’, which is known to trigger a fear response. Bacteria, viruses, and fungi have all been considered bad and negative in some way over the last couple of decades through societies (Coil, 2022). Reframing these organisms in a friendly curious setting brings the public closer to the sounds these creatures make, the sound of creatures necessary for a healthy environment, to befriend these creatures. I would argue further that this form of engagement enacts a deeper transformation in perceptions towards soil when considered through the lens of Alfred Gell’s ‘Technology of Enchantment’ (1992), these objects in theory exceed the limits of human possibility (Jeudy-Ballini, 2010). Technologically, audiences can understand how they were made, but interacting with the sound of soil microorganisms could be considered as a ‘Technology of Enchantment’ since it makes accessible an experience otherwise both misunderstood as ‘dirty’ and out of human reach, creating an artistic catalyst for magical interaction. With the power to change perceptions of what soil is through personal sensory communication of its hidden processes, resulting in an enchanting engagement capable of communicating essential ecological research.
[FIG 8: Bonneval K. (2020) Listen to the Soil]
[FIG 9: Bonneval K. (2016) Listen to the Soil]
13
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts
[FIG 10: Bonneval K. (2016) Listen to the soil]
Considering the collaborative nature of this work, Gaunlette (1971), posits that collaboration is a fundamental facet in augmenting the intrinsic value of a creative endeavour; “Making is connecting because acts of creativity usually involve, at some point, a social dimension and connect us with other people” (Gaunlette D. , 2010) With this in mind, Karine actively engages with researchers and scientists. During one such collaboration, she posed a probing question to Professor Mathias Rilling: “Does the root of fungi emit sounds unto the soil during its growth?”. This seemingly unconventional inquiry prompted Professor Rilling, an ecological scientist, to undergo a night of contemplation, challenging his preconceived notions and initially dismissing the question as an unexplored avenue within the scientific study of soil, where communication was conventionally understood to manifest solely through chemical reactions instead of vibrations (Wright, 2020). Professor Rilling eventually recognized its significance. This pivotal dialogue between the artist and the scientist culminated in a collaborative academic paper titled “Sounds of Soil: A New World of Interactions Under Our Feet” (2009), contributing novel perspectives to the scientific discourse and closing, through artistic inquiry, a before unrecognized communication gap.
“Making is connecting because through making things and sharing them with the world, we increase our engagement and connection with our social and physical environment” (Gaunlette, Making is Connecting, 2010).
14
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts
This collaboration can also be viewed through the framework of Rose's (2012) Visual Methodologies, the modality of meaning made at the site of production. The production of this project represents a vast collaboration between creators and researchers to find a middle ground communication with general audiences, which I argue has been done successfully. Rose (2012) also states that meaning is made at the site of the audience. Being a traveling exhibition means the vessels can be transported to a larger audience group, [see appendix 4] therefore making it more accessible to the public than if it were exhibited in a singular place. Furthermore, in ‘Sounds of the Anthropocene’ (2017), Sebastian Verea discusses a case study whereby artists and scientists aim to create a soundscape that increases awareness to the audience/public about humanity’s unparalleled impact on the Earth. “The outcome must be concrete, tangible, and soundly anchored in scientific facts yet aesthetically enjoyable and, above all, genuine as music arising from the Earth. It epitomizes the simple idea that beauty relies on the search for truth, a simple truth where science and art are bound together…. Music with a shape. Music contains life and death in the form of sound and silence—a message. A piece of art one can touch, experience, sense, and learn from. Music that speaks immediately to our senses..” (Verea, 2017) The collaborative synergy between the artist and scientists has transcended conventional boundaries, elevating the endeavor to a realm that is palpable, scientifically rigorous, and imbued with remarkable aesthetic quality, rendering it both intellectually engaging and aesthetically enjoyable. Ultimately this piece is a poignant example of making a new scientific enquiry. ‘The Sound of Soil’, accessible to general audiences through artistic sensory strategies, employed to signify deeper meaning and a new mode of engagement, resulting in mitigating the communication gap between ecological research and general audiences.
[FIG 11: Bonneval K. (2016) Listen to the soil] 15
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts In conclusion, this dissertation has sought to evaluate how artists have used sensory engagement strategies to mitigate the communication gap between scientific ecological research and general audiences. Through a comprehensive review of the rigorous analysis, research, and academic frameworks, several key findings have emerged. The research question posed was an evaluation of artistic sensory engagement strategies used to mitigate the communication gap between scientific ecological research and general audiences, and my investigation has provided insightful findings to this query. The analysis revealed that both Paker’s, Taste of a Place (2012), and Bonneval’s Listen to the Soil (2016) have successfully closed the communication gap between the ecological research and the audience, underscoring the significance of sensory engagement through the arts. This has been achieved by tapping into the olfactory senses, taste and building a relationship from soil to person through sound. Not only was this successful in the engagement with the public, but academically rigorous within the context of individual research from exploration to collaborating with farmers, scientists, and researchers. One of the notable implications of this study is that this dissertation aligns with the theoretical framework of Rose (2015), Barthes (1957), and Sturken and Cartwright (2009), who have developed theories on how to derive meaning and value of objects through production, audience engagement, technology, composition, and the theory of signs. Including these, not only validates the theoretical underpinning but also extends them into the art theory world. However, it is essential to acknowledge the limitations of this study. Due to the nature of this analysis, I have been viewing the artwork through a laptop and books, limiting my experience to the sensorial engagement that the audience would have personally experienced. These limitations open avenues for future research, to be able to experience personally these sensory strategies would enable me to have a deeper analysis of the success of the engagement. This initial investigation has proposed a bigger question on how we, during a climate crisis, can tackle this communication gap. We have got to this pivotal point in our existence where we are in the seventh mass extinction, yet there is still confusion on what to do, how to do it, where to start, and how to converse with the public. Could the arts truly be the way forward with translating this information thoroughly? Closing the communication gap will enable the public to have the knowledge and awareness to empower. Mass change is needed for any work to happen due to the lack of legislation within our governments. Returning to the initial title, it is evident that my study has successfully evaluated how the arts can assist in closing the communication gap between ecological research and the audience, due to the conduction of comparison. The overall significance of this research lies in the audience being able to sensorily engage with the discourse, soil.
16
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts
Fig List: Fig: 1,3,4: Laura Parker Studio. Taste of Place. [online] Available at: https://www.lauraparkerstudio.com/taste. Fig 2: BARTHES, R (1977) Image-Music-Text. London: Hill and Wang Fig 5: Ranch, T. (2019). Gathering of Women in Culinary. [online] TomKat Ranch. Available at: https://www.tomkatranch.org/2019/09/30/gathering-of-women-in-culinary Fig 6 & 8: Infoliv.com. Listen to the soil | Karine Bonneval. [online] www.karinebonneval.com. Available at: https://www.karinebonneval.com/eng/projets/Ecouter-la-terre-9 Fig 7 & 9: Infoliv.com. Vertimus | Karine Bonneval. [online] www.karinebonneval.com. Available at: https://www.karinebonneval.com/expositions/vertimus-36 Fig 10: Infoliv.com, The Fact Finder | Karine Bonneval. [online] www.karinebonneval.com. Available at: https://www.karinebonneval.com/expositions/the-fact-finder-10 Fig 11: Infoliv.com. Nuit Blanche à Nanterre | Karine Bonneval. [online] www.karinebonneval.com. Available at: https://www.karinebonneval.com/expositions/nuitblanche-a-nanterre-41 Fig 12: Ferrier, S. (2022). Instagram.
17
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts
Appendix Appendix 1) Social Media questions, via Instagram. 14/06
18
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts Appendix 2) Claire Lodder Interview. (20/09/2023). • What is your job title/ craft? - Artist, I’ve never labelled myself as a ceramists, artist feels a
lot more flexible. • What got you into the line of work you’re doing? / Inspirations? I graduated in 1993 from
bath, now known as bath spa, in illustration and graphics, i got a studio soon after that and became a painter. I started showing with bath fringe and finding a way to work, which led to galleries and greeting card companies, I did all the fares and things like that. • When did your practice start? ^^ • What do you love about what you do? - i Love the people that i meet, something about working in the creative sector that means, you can meet anybody under the guidance of being an artist, an excuse to talk to anybody about anything, and no expectations as long as you are creative, imaginative, and have a curious approach. Finding more and more artists interested in the living world, and meeting lots of people who have come from an art background and find themselves working in conservation and ecology, seems to be a two-way exchange between those which have previously been quite distinctly different. A lot more merged now and I think we need the two thinking in both. • If you could portray a message to your audience, what would it be? - it would be about the necessity of plants, they breathe, we breathe. The fact they just get on with it and do it, is part of their life force to give breath to us as humans. This idea that plants are the fifth element is just wonderful. • What role do you believe your discipline has to play in the climate emergency? storytelling, ecology is complicated, climate crisis, biodiversity crisis is complicated, artists are good at complicating things, we are dealing with really complex things, and we need to find beautiful and telling ways to tell complex stories, and we need to understand it ourselves, us artists. So finding a way into that complexity, accepting that it is complex is crucial, so there's stories to be told. Being an artist is mainly about communication. What we need to is lots of beautiful and frightening and fascinating, bold and radical waysthat's what the arts needs to be doing. • What do you find valuable about your practice? - when you can see those approaches happening in other artists. I do think when I see those artists, what are they doing outside of galleries, galleries are extremely restrictive, what are artists doing in their communities? I will always advocate for artists to be working outside of art school, outside of design schools, in their communities, and involved in conversations around food, compost, and all the things. All the things from getting involved with local counsellors, networks, and social engagements, I feel artists need to be on the ground doing stuff, I'm less enamoured less convinced by the gallery spaces these days, it doesn't mean there aren't shows and events happening that aren't compelling, but I’m aware of who can't cross the freehold into that space. • Who have been your key artistic and intellectual influences? - all the writing that's come about around critical plant studies. Trying to learn about different ways of seeing, there are other ways of knowing things. Those are huge influences. • What are the key themes your practice/ethos / research is founded on? - plant awareness, how we reconnect with the non-human world, plant thinking, plant beings, where horticulture sits in this? How to critique the gardener/ growing communities. • Do you believe there is a communication gap between ecological research and the public? If so, what does this gap look like to you? Where do you see it the most? - HUGE, is that is complex, and our basic understanding is still misunderstood. Soil is little understood, the gap looks like an education gap, and this starts in schools. It's like when a road is collapsed, and there’s a big hole that everything is falling into, that’s how I visualize that, its huge. I’ve really started to think about food, and how, basically what most people eat is not food, that whole post food, what is everybody eating? Food is a four-letter word. 19
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts • Do you believe the arts have a role to play in closing this gap? If so what does this look like
in your world? - artists getting out and about, for my own practice, I'm teaching the university, year 0 and MA students the two age ranges, I’m involved in the institution, and conversations and networks within my area, i do stuff outside of my house, what can do you literally outside your doorstep. I’m also working hard to think about a way to bring plants into educational settings. How to relate, understand and learn from plants, I’ve come up with this idea of the novel garden, novel gardening. • Do you believe people can connect to the land in a truthful meaningful way whilst using materials that have damaging effects on the ecosystem? If so, please give examples of what you observed/ found and if the damage is worth it for the personal/ public growth in awareness. - Massive, massive question, there’s something about not chasing the perfect in favour of the good, just by breathing and existing we have a problem, its problematic. As soon as you learn and acknowledge and feel that the land is alive, then every action you take is much more attuned. It’s a chicken and egg isn’t it? If we understand that the land is a living thing, then we understand the compromises we have to make on that land to exist. But that calls into question the means, the luxury, and everything we use for our existence. Like once your life is lived and you’ve done the things you’ve wanted to do, then maybe it’s time to die. • Do you think sensory engagement is important when making art about ecological issues?yes I do, I think that our visual state kind of takes everything over, there’s too much of an emphasis on that sense specifically, Tim Ingold?- when we look with our eyes it places us on the edge of things, but when we close our eyes and engage our other senses it immerses us. Over-emphasis on visual culture/ connection is debilitating in terms of, decentralising our self I guess, and moving towards plant thinking. So yeah I think its really crucial, touch taste, immersing ourselves in the world, • When you think of the word SOIL, what do you think of? What does this mean to you?a beautiful thing, I did a talk a few years ago and i ended on a slide, which was a still from Dr Who, the camera is settled on the actors faces in a village walking, the village is falling away, it pans round and it takes in the cosmos, and it struck me, that cosmos is under our feet, those nodes of connectivity, life pulsating beingness. That's how I feel about the soil, its finite because it’s on this earth, but it is cosmetically connected as well, it’s so beautiful deep and dark and mysterious. Appendix 3) Farm Soils list 7/1/19 3:26 PM 1 / Parker, L. (2006). Retrieved from Laura Parker Studio: https://www.lauraparkerstudio.com/about-2
If multiple listing for a farm, then we used multiple soils from that farm, and each gets a separate number. If one soil has been used multiple times from the same farm, they will get a + for each time. Alba Cooperative, Monterey, CA - 48 Apple Farm, Philo, CA – 26, 27 Baia Nicchia Farm & Nursery, Sunol, CA -68 Bob Cannard, Sonoma, CA - 31 Bodega Goat Cheese, Lake County, CA - 55 Boonville Hotel, Boonville, CA - 33 Budding Prospects, Boonville, CA -34, 35 Burroughs Family Farms -74 Camp Meeker -14 Canvas Ranch, Two Rock, Petaluma, CA - 51 Chickadee Creek Farm, Pennington, NJ - 64 Coleman Farms, Carpenteria, CA – 66, 67 CSU Chico University Farm, Chico, CA -72 Deerbone Gardens – 39 De Haro Gardens, SF, CA - 23 Domergue Family Farm, Puech Méjà, Aveyron, France - 28 Early Bird, Healdsburg, CA - 52 Fritschen Vineyards Healdsburg, CA - 53 Fifth Crow, Pescadero, CA -71 Full Belly Farm; Guinfda, CA-76 Gabriel Farms, Sebastapol, CA - 15 Green Gulch Farm, Muir Beach, CA -43 Green String – 50 Harley Farms, Pescadero, CA - 36 Juniper Grove Farm, Redmond OR - 30 Kern Family Farm, North Fork, CA - 45 Kiva Orchards, Durando CO - 24 Knoll Farms, Brentwood, CA - 32 Lindencroft Farm, Ben Lomand, CA -69 Lagier Ranch – 37 Laguna Farms, Sebastapol, CA – 12-13 Love 20
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts Farms, Healdsberg, CA- 7 Molino Creek, Davenport, CA - 22 Mondavi – 61-62 Occidental Arts and Ecology Center, Occidental, CA – 8, 58 One Gun Ranch, Santa Monica Mountains, National Recreation Area; Malibu, CA -78 Osuna Farm – 47 Perry Farms, Fremont, CA - 60 Patch – 59 Phil Foster Ranch, Hollister, CA -20 & 70 Paicines Ranch, Paicines, CA -73 Preston of Dry Creek, Healdsberg, CA- 3, 4, 5, 6, 56 Pug’s Leap Farm, Healdsberg, CA - 11 Quetzal Farm, Santa Rosa, CA - 10 Rancho Del Pueblo, Oaji, CA -77 Riverdog – 38 Route 1 Farms, Santa Cruz & Davenport, CA – 18, 19 Rodoni Farms, Santa Cruz, CA - 44 Rogowski Farm, Pine Island, New York – 63, Rundle Family Farm, Fresno, CA - 42 Serpentine Ridge, Cloverdale, CA- 9 Shone Farm SRJC, Forestville- 1 SpringHill Farm, Albany, OR - 29 Swallow Valley Farms, Inc, Valley Ford, CA - 54 T&D Willey Farms, Madera, CA - 21 & many more Tierra Vegetables, Santa Rosa, CA – 16, 57 UCSC Farm, Santa Cruz, CA - 17 UCSC Center for Agroecology & Sustainable Food Systems, 2108, Santa Cruz -75 Verdure Farm, Healdsberg, CA – 46 White Crane Springs Ranch, Healdsberg, CA - 2 Windrose, Paso Robles, CA - 65 Wooley - 41
Appendix 4) Karine Bonneval, Listen to the Soil, exhibits: Infoliv.com (2018). Listen to the soil | Karine Bonneval. [online] www.karinebonneval.com. Available at: https://www.karinebonneval.com/eng/projets/Ecouter-la-terre-9.
• • • • • • • • • • •
Nuit blanche, Vive les groues, Nanterre, 2020 Vertimus, experimental Gallery, Cornell,USA, 2019 Manger la terre, les semailles, Agro Paris Tech, 2019 Manger la terre, maison du conte, Chevilly Larue, 2019 Dé-jardiner, Gr_und, Berlin, 2019 Manger la terre, Cahors-Juin Jardins, 2019 L'âme des écorces, galerie Louise Michel, Poitiers, 2018 Sometimes I hear the plants whisper, musée botanique de Berlin, 2018 Comme un frisson assoupi, 2018 Open studios, GlogauAir, Berlin, 2017 The fact finder, Berlin, 2017
21
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts
Reference list: Books: Adams J, Montag D. (2015). Soil culture: bringing the arts down to earth. Devon: Centre For Contemporary Art And The Natural World, Schumacher College. Allison, R. (2014). Introduction to Soil Chemistry: Analysis and Instrumentation, Volume 178, Second Edition. Wiley. Bardgett, R., & van der Putten, W. (2014). Belowground biodiversity and ecosystem functioning. PUBMED. Berger, J. (1972). Way of seeing. Penguin Books. Cartwright, M. S. (2009). Practices of Looking. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS Rose, G. (2012). Visual Methodologies. Toland, A. R. (2023). Soil Art: Sensory and Symbolic Engagement with Soils. In O. M. Goss Michael J., Encyclopedia of Soils in the Environment (2nd Ed.). Elsevier Science Publishing Co Inc.
Journals: Alexandra Toland, G. W. (2009). Merging Horizons – Soil Science and Soil Art. Ingold, T. (2000) The Perception of the Environment: Essays on Livelihood, Dwelling and Skill. 162. Jeudy-Ballini, B. D. (2010). The Theory of Enchantment and the Enchantment of Theory: the Art of Alfred Gell. Laila Fariha Zein, A. R. (2017). General Overview of Ecofeminism Matthias C. Rillig, K. B. (2019). Sounds of Soil: A NewWorld of Interactions under. Soil systems. MINAMI, K. (2009). Soil & humanity: Culture, civilization, livelihood and health. Soil Science and Plant Nutrition, 608. Prendergast, P. a. (2000). The Concept of Luxury from a Consumer Culture Perspective. Raymond, J. A. (2022). Touch, Texture and Haptic Feedback: A Review on How We Feel the World around Us. Applied Sciences. SUSANNE C. MOSER, L. D. (2012). communicating climate change: closing the science- action gap. Verea, S. (2017). Sounds of the Anthropocene. Vittal, A. (2019). Extraction of petrichor and essential oils for the production of Novelty fragrance products. Journal Of Pharmaceutical Sciences and Research. Wallen, R. (2012). Ecological Art. A Call for Visionary Intervention in a Time of Crisis.
Websites: Coil, D. (2022). Microbe.net. Retrieved from Microbial Myths: Common misconceptions about microbes, (w/ some extra focus on those in the built environment): https://microbe.net/simple-guides/microbialmyths-common-misconceptions-about-microbes-in-the-built-environment/
22
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts Development, D.-G. f. (2019). Agriculture and rural development. Retrieved from European Commission : https://agriculture.ec.europa.eu/news/soil-matters-our-future-2019-1205_en#:~:text=Soil%20is%20the%20very%20basis,our%20landscapes%20and%20cultural%20heritage. Eberle, U. (2022). What bioacoustics can tell us about soil health. Retrieved from Future Farming : https://www.hbfuturefarming.org/news/article/30/what-bioacoustics-can-tell-us-about-soil-healthHupp, S. (2023). Earth.org. Retrieved from https://earth.org/bridging-the-gap-on-climate-change-addressingbarriers-in-communication-to-save-the-planet/ Laurier, O. (2018). Karine Bonneval. Retrieved from https://www.karinebonneval.com/eng/projets/Ecouter-laterre-9 Microbes, M. M. (n.d.). microBEnet: the microbiology of the Built Environment network. Retrieved from https://microbe.net/simple-guides/microbial-myths-common-misconceptions-about-microbes-in-thebuiltenvironment/#:~:text=Microbes%20are%20ALL%20bad%20(including,sterilization%20and%20use%20o f%20biocides. Oxford Learners Dictionaries. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.oxfordlearnersdictionaries.com/definition/english/soil_1#:~:text=%2Fs%C9%94%C9%AAl% 2F-,%2Fs%C9%94%C9%AAl%2F,grow Parker, L. (2006). Retrieved from Laura Parker Studio: https://www.lauraparkerstudio.com/about-2 Pears, P. (2023). Greenwashing: Navigating the Risk. Retrieved from Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance: https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2023/07/24/greenwashing-navigating-therisk/#:~:text=At%20its%20core%2C%20greenwashing%20is,which%20companies%20should%20be%20 prepared. Schmidt, C. W. (2009). National Library of Medicine. Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2799486/ Science & Tech: Myxomycetes. (2020). Retrieved from Britannica: https://www.britannica.com/science/Myxomycetes The Editors of Encyclopaedia. "olfactory system". (2019). Retrieved from Britannica: https://www.britannica.com/science/olfactory-system Wallentine, A. (2021). Divinity, drunkenness and desire: the story of wine in art. Retrieved from ART UK: https://artuk.org/discover/stories/divinity-drunkenness-and-desire-the-story-of-wine-inart#:~:text=Over%20the%20centuries%20and%20across,reveal%20its%20varying%20cultural%20signifi cance.
Video: Biersteker, T. (2022, November 29). How art can help fight climate change. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/uk308Fx0keI?si=rRorpVtWuEB7Kstq Bonneval, K. (2018). YouTube. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7oKXrrVCsk Gaunlette, D. (2010). Making is connecting. Retrieved from Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nF4OBfVQmCI&t=29s
23
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts
Bibliography: Books: Adamson, G. (2018). Fewer, Better Things. Bloomsbury Publishing USA. Barthes, R. (1957). Mythologies. Points. Berger, J. (1972). Ways of Seeing. Edmonton, Alta.: The Schools. Brown, A. (2014). Art & ecology now. London: Thames & Hudson. Clive Adams, Daro Montag and And, A. (2015). Soil culture : bringing the arts down to earth. Devon: Centre For Contemporary Art And The Natural World, Schumacher College. Gauntlett, D. (2010). Making is Connecting. Polity Press. Hildyard, D. (2018). The second body. London: Fitzcarraldo Editions. Ingold, T. (2000b). The Perception of the Environment : Essays on Livelihood, Dwelling and Skill. London ; New York: Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group. Joakim Borda-Pedreira (2014). Materiality matters. Oslo Norwegian Crafts. Morton, T. (2019). Being Ecological. A PELICAN BOOK. Rose, G. (2016). Visual methodologies: an introduction to researching with visual materials. Los Angeles Etc.: Sage. Solanki, S. (2018). Why materials matter: responsible design for a better world. Munich: Prestel. Spaid, S., Arts, C., American and Arlington (2012). Green acres: artists farming fields, greenhouses and abandoned lots. Cincinnati, Oh: Contemporary Arts Center. Toland, A., Noller, J.S. and Gerd Wessolek (2019). Field to palette: dialogues on soil and art in the Anthropocene. Boca Raton: Crc Press, Taylor & Francis Group.
Journals: Anna Lowenhaupt Tsing, Swanson, H., Gan, E. and Nils Bubandt (2017). Arts of living on a damaged planet. Minneapolis ; London: University Of Minnesota Press. Copyright. Bamberg, M. (1998). Narrative, Play, and Development. Human Development, 41(3), pp.196–199. doi:https://doi.org/10.1159/000022579.
24
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts Baveye, P.C. (2020). Thinking with Soils: Material Politics and Social Theory Salazar. European Journal of Soil Science, Bloomsbury Academic. Blandy, D. and Cowan, D. (1997). Imagine! Yellowstone: Art Education and the Reinhabitation of Place. Art Education. Burton, J.M. (1992). Art Education and the Plight of the Culture: A Status Report. Art Education Curtis, D.J., Reid, N. and Ballard, G. (2012). Communicating Ecology Through Art: What Scientists Think. Ecology and Society, Derlon, B. and Jeudy-Ballini, M. (2010). The Theory of Enchantment and the Enchantment of Theory: the Art of Alfred Gell. Oceania, pp.129–142 Feller, C., Landa, E.R., Toland, A. and Wessolek, G. (2015). Case studies of soil in art. SOIL, 1(2), pp.543–559. Minami, K. (2009). Soil and humanity: Culture, civilization, livelihood and health. Soil Science and Plant Nutrition. Moser, S.C. and Dilling, L. (2011). Communicating Climate Change: Closing the Science-Action Gap. Oxford Handbooks Online. Oxford University Press. Pellegrini, A.D. (2010). The role of play in human development. Choice Reviews Rillig, M.C., Bonneval, K. and Lehmann, J. (2019). Sounds of Soil: A New World of Interactions under Our Feet? Soil Systems. Rummukainen, M. (2013). Climate change: changing means and changing extremes. Climatic Change. Safwan, M. and Schnitzler, A. (2020). Combined forest and soil management after a catastrophic event. Journal of Mountain Science. Schmidt, C.W. (2009). Communication Gap: The Disconnect Between What Scientists Say and What the Public Hears. Environmental Health Perspectives. See, A.R., Choco, J.A.G. and Chandramohan, K. (2022). Touch, Texture and Haptic Feedback: A Review on How We Feel the World around Us. Applied Sciences. Sky Marsen (2008). The Role of Meaning in Human Thinking. The journal of evaluation and technology. Verea, S. (2017). Sounds of the Anthropocene. Walker, A.W.W. and Hoyles, L. (2023). Human microbiome myths and misconceptions. Nature Microbiology, Wallen, R. (2012). Ecological Art: A Call for Visionary Intervention in a Time of Crisis. Leonardo.
25
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts Weintraub, L. (2006). Forum: Eco-tistical Art. Art Journal. Weintraub, L. (2016). Archetypes of material use and disuse: An art and ecology primer. Cogent Arts & Humanities.
Websites: Agriculture.ec.europa.eu. (n.d.). Soil matters for our future. [online] Available at: https://agriculture.ec.europa.eu/news/soil-matters-our-future-2019-1205_en#:~:text=Soil%20is%20the%20very%20basis. Artuk.org. (n.d.). Divinity, drunkenness and desire: the story of wine in art | Art UK. [online] Available at: https://artuk.org/discover/stories/divinity-drunkenness-and-desire-the-story-of-wine-inart#:~:text=Over%20the%20centuries%20and%20across Bullock, H., Bezerra, L.G., Williams, O., Pears, P., Baines, T. and Sim, W.N. (2023). Greenwashing: Navigating the Risk. [online] The Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance. Available at: https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2023/07/24/greenwashing-navigating-therisk/#:~:text=At%20its%20core%2C%20greenwashing%20is. Coil, D. (2011). Microbial Myths: Common misconceptions about microbes (w/ some extra focus on those in the built environment). [online] microBEnet: the microbiology of the Built Environment network. Available at: https://microbe.net/simple-guides/microbial-myths-common-misconceptions-about-microbes-inthe-built-environment/. Dw.com. (2020). Living Planet: The sound of soil [online] Available at: https://www.dw.com/en/living-planet-thesound-of-soil/audio-52556688 Eberle, U. (2022). What bioacoustics can tell us about soil health. [online] www.hbfuturefarming.org. Available at: https://www.hbfuturefarming.org/news/article/30/what-bioacoustics-can-tell-us-about-soil-health Encyclopedia Britannica. (n.d.). Myxomycetes | protist phylum. [online] Available at: https://www.britannica.com/science/Myxomycetes. Hupp, S. (2023). The Importance of Bridging the Gap in Climate Communication. [online] Earth.org. Available at: https://earth.org/bridging-the-gap-on-climate-change-addressing-barriers-in-communication-to-savethe-planet/ Infoliv.com (2018). Listen to the soil | Karine Bonneval. [online] www.karinebonneval.com. Available at: https://www.karinebonneval.com/eng/projets/Ecouter-la-terre-9.
26
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts Infoliv.com (n.d.). Karine Bonneval artist. [online] www.karinebonneval.com. Available at: https://www.karinebonneval.com/eng/contact Infoliv.com (n.d.). Nuit Blanche à Nanterre | Karine Bonneval. [online] www.karinebonneval.com. Available at: https://www.karinebonneval.com/expositions/nuit-blanche-a-nanterre-41 Infoliv.com (n.d.). The Fact Finder | Karine Bonneval. [online] www.karinebonneval.com. Available at: https://www.karinebonneval.com/expositions/the-fact-finder-10 Infoliv.com (n.d.). Vertimus | Karine Bonneval. [online] www.karinebonneval.com. Available at: https://www.karinebonneval.com/expositions/vertimus-36 Laura Parker Studio. (n.d.). Taste of Place. [online] Available at: https://www.lauraparkerstudio.com/taste. Ranch, T. (2019). Gathering of Women in Culinary. [online] TomKat Ranch. Available at: https://www.tomkatranch.org/2019/09/30/gathering-of-women-in-culinary/ Sciencedirect.com. (2019). Humus - an overview | ScienceDirect Topics. [online] Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/agricultural-and-biological-sciences/humus. Soil Basics (2015). Soil Science Society of America. [online] Available at: https://www.soils.org/aboutsoils/basics/. The Senses. (2019). Design Beyond Vision | Cooper Hewitt, Smithsonian Design Museum. [online] Available at: https://www.cooperhewitt.org/channel/senses/. www.fu-berlin.de. (2022). The Sounds of Silence. [online] Available at: https://www.fu-berlin.de/en/featuredstories/research/2022/soil-ecologist-artists/index.html
Video: Biersteker, T. (2022, November 29). How art can help fight climate change. Retrieved from https://youtu.be/uk308Fx0keI?si=rRorpVtWuEB7Kstq Gaunlette, D. (2010). David Gauntlett: Making is Connecting, (2010). [online] www.youtube.com. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nF4OBfVQmCI&t=29s. YouTube. (2017) Ecouter la terre. Karine Bonneval. [online] Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X5zAKi7A5Cc YouTube. (2017) interview Fanny Rybak et karine Bonneval. [online] Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s7oKXrrVCsk
27
Sophie Ferrier BA (hons) Contemporary Design Crafts Podcasts: Lloyd T & Pearson, Designers. “Tom Lloyd & Luke Pearson on their material change”. Material Matters. Grant Gibson. Spotify. (18/09/2023). https://open.spotify.com/episode/51uw0rsGoEPcSc7czMJtTD?si=254922b60bcc4152 May, K, Author. “Katherine May: Listening to our senses in uncertain times”. Arts & Ecology. Spotify. (07/07/2023). https://open.spotify.com/episode/4k2hD07dQiws120PbOgqFO?si=3124cc12b9964038 Till, Caroline, Academic. “Caroline Till on material futures, regenerative design, and lots more”. Material Matters. Grant Gibson. Spotify. (24/10/2023). https://open.spotify.com/episode/3cri4YawHtp2IHhRyGmfeA?si=f00b3452461b412a
28