Issue 3/2017 EUROP EAN EDI TI O N
THE MAGAZINE FOR CORPORATE COMMUNICATIONS AND PUBLIC RELATIONS
www.co mmunicatio n-d ir ecto r.co m
European Edition
Issue 3 · 2017
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR
Made to measure The personalisation of communications
This time it’s personal
Today, contemporary anxieties about privacy, the abuse of personal information and rampant commercialisation of the public sphere sit uneasily alongside our ready acquiescence in handing over private data for access to online products and services. Nowhere is this tension better embodied than in the current ubiquity of personalised communications – from algorithms that determine your Amazon recommendations to tailored emails in B2B marketing, data has empowered companies to personalise their messages at scale. The Issue Focus section of this magazine explores the how and why of data-driven personalisation, as well as the pitfalls and ethical implications. What is the business strategy behind personalisation and how can it be used to boost brand awareness and loyalty? How can we find the right balance between protecting our privacy and allowing organisations to track us and our interests? We’ve invited communications heads at major brands as well as experts in data mining to answer these questions. But personalised communications is more than a question of commercial branding: political parties also utilise personalisation techniques such as micro-targeting to get engage us with their ideas and persuade us to vote for them. We’re already living with the consequences of this fracturing of the political sphere: our interview with controversial US political strategist Vincent Harris brings us insights into this development from the front line.
DAFYDD PHILLIPS
Photo: Laurin Schmid
Editor in Chief
Brought to you by the European Association of Communication Directors www.eacd-online.eu
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
3
REGULARS
6
12
52
CAMPAIGNS
PR ESSENTIALS
#KEEPQUESTIONING
BOOKS
Agenda Setter
The personalisation behind your purchases
Melissa Fleming
Communications reader
Recent eye-catching communications campaigns
Customisation that builds brands
We put your questions to the head of communications of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees
84
New and upcoming titles for the communicator’s bookshelf
86
90
EACD
LAST PAGE
Association
5 tips for...
Latest developments in the European Association of Communication Directors
Quick insights into handling social media influencers
ISSUE FOCUS: THE PERSONALISATION
60
64
The personal touch
Analyse this
In order to retain and grow their customer base, businesses need to get personal with their consumers
How can organisations choose the right data-analysis strategy to suit their personalisation needs?
68
72
76
80
A revolution in personalised marketing
The dark side of personalisation
“Micro-targeting allows you to scare people easier”
CEO leadership in a broken system
Can AI deliver on the promise of marketing: true personalisation at scale?
4
Finding the right balance between protecting our privacy and allowing organisations to track our every move
The father of the Republican internet on Trump, Twitter and the pitfalls of online echo chambers
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
A more personalised, authentic approach to communications can help engage the sceptics
Photos: Laurin Schmid; Gage Skidmore; Bernal Revert
OF COMMUNICATIONS
STRATEGY
14
18
21
24
Using transparency to build public trust
Designing a smoke-free future
A reputation of truth
Stand by me
Why one cigarette company is communicating smokefree products
Exploring the new scope of stakeholder engagement
The communications lessons learned by Ireland’s Central Bank in the wake of the financial crisis
Five communications steps to help associations prepare themselves for crisis
26
30
Curiosity-driven content
Sparking conversations with VR
What content is most engaging? Why? What can we learn from it?
How Siemens uses cardboard virtual reality viewers to attract the employees of the future
INSIGHTS
34 Digital and visual The 2017 European Communication Monitor 2017 shows that the strategic communication function is undergoing a fundamental transformation
40
43
46
50
Arts patronage 2.0
Trust in media across Europe
Collaboration versus cooperation
Transformative ideas
According to a new report by the European Broadcasting Union, the trust gap between traditional and new media is widening
To define, encourage and improve on collaboration at your workplace, perhaps it’s time to unearth some old board games?
Communicators need a blended vision of thought leadership in order to position their organisations as a trusted partner
Brands and the arts: making creative partnerships work – trends, best practices and insights into successful collaborations.
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
5
AGENDA SETTER
6
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
AGENDA SETTER
Restorer Christian Eckmann at work on Tutankhamen‘s death mask at the RomanoGermanic Central Museum in Mainz, Germany / Photo: Khaled Elfiqi
Henkel: customised glue When clumsy workers knocked lose the iconic beard of King Tutankhamen’s death mask during routine maintenance work, they hastily chose everyday epoxy glue to fix it back on – leaving visible marks and a crooked beard. Henkel immediately offered the help of its R&D experts to the restorers and developed a customised glue to fix the boy king’s beard back – while at the same time raising awareness of its adhesive business and ensuring good
.
relations with authorities in an important growth market for the German company.
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
7
AGENDA SETTER
Imperial Serve To promote the FIVB Beach Volleyball World Championships 2017 presented by A1 being held in Vienna, the Beach Majors Company invited Austrian Olympic beach volleyball stars Clemens Doppler and Alex Horst to the play against the most unusual opponents in their careers: two of the finest stallions at Vienna’s legendary Spanish Horse Riding School. The campaign generated over 250,000 en-
.
gagements and reached more than one million people across prima-
Photo: Dustin Snipes
ry social channels.
8
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
AGENDA SETTER
Imperial Serve by Dustin Snipes
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
9
PR ESSENTIALS
THE PERSONALISATION BEHIND YOUR PURCHASES From cutting-edge algorithms to customised products, from major e-commerce companies to our favourite lifestyle apps, personalisation exerts a powerful pull on how we interact with brands. Here’s 10 of our favourite examples.
1
N A R R OW I N G D OWN T H E C H O I C E N E TF LIX From its inception, Netflix has used data as an asset to personalise its relationship with customers and solve a problem faced by several content providers: the service has too much content so a viewer gets lost. When it launched an open competition for the best collaborative filtering algorithm to predict user ratings for films in 2006, it positioned itself as a thought leader in personalisation; in 2013, its decision to commission House of Cards was largely based on algorithmic insights that suggested its users would embrace a reboot of a BBC political drama starring Kevin Spacey and led by David Fincher.
10
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
PR ESSENTIALS
2
P E R S ON A L I S E D B OT T L E S C OKE It began in Australia in 2011, spread to Europe in 2013 and then the US in 2014,where it resulted in increased sales volume for the first time in four years. Designed to reach millennials, with each bottle carrying one of the most popular first names in that generation, semi-personal labels were soon added, such as “better half”, and this year the campaign was relaunched to include popular holiday destination “to remind people of the refreshment and great taste that only an ice-cold Coke can bring on a hot summer day”, according to an official statement.
3
T H E PE RF E C T PL AY L I ST S P OT I F Y Has Spotify cracked the personalisation conundrum? With its hugely successful Discover Weekly feature, as well as the regular Recommended for You function. Edward Newett, the man behind what has been called “one of the most influential innovations in music”, described the algorithm to Wired magazine: “By trying to mimic the behaviour of all of our users when trying to put together their perfect mix, we can leverage Spotify’s two billion playlists, target individual tastes and come up with playlists that will be interesting.”
4
MI C R OS I T E S A N D M A R K E T I N G M A I L I N G S IBE R IA A I RL I NE S In 2016, Iberia Airlines sent out emails to their customers posing the question: if you could visit any destination, where would you go and who would you go with? To answer, customers were directed to a microsite to fill in their responses and the email addresses of their travel buddy. The friend would then receive an email with a holiday greeting about the dream vacation – but to view the card, they had to first click a link to view in their browser. That last step is key: by enabling cookies to see the greeting e-card, Iberia Airlines made sure that the friend would be followed by banners across the web, suggesting the perfect gift – a dream vacation.
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
11
FINANCIAL
USING TRANSPARENCY TO BUILD PUBLIC TRUST The financial crisis in Ireland had a profound impact on the way its Central Bank supervises and safeguards financial stability. Today, the Central Bank of Ireland has learned lessons and adapted the way it communicates to build public trust. BY JILL F OR D E
T
he financial crisis rocketed central
watching to ensure that the much-prom-
banks across the world from the
ised reforms were actually delivered. When
business pages to the front pages.
talking to stakeholders, particularly media
The Central Bank of Ireland was
no different. Over the last decade, there has been massively increased public awareness of the Bank – but this has not been matched by public understanding and trust. Rather than simply accept this as the cost of fulfilling an increasingly complex mandate in a challenging global environment, we have taken the view that it is essential to build that understanding and trust of what we do and why we do it. We chose to focus our communication efforts on enhancing transparency and understanding of our organisation through strategic investment in communication and targeted campaigns.
“We did not seek publicity, nor did we go to great lengths to explain our work. That has changed.”
and politicians, it became evident that there were a number of communication challenges still facing the organisation including a lack of trust , low levels of understanding of the roles and functions of the organisation and a perceived veil of secrecy surrounding our work as a regulator. While these issues are not unique to the Central Bank of Ireland, the very significant powers we have been given by legislators and our role within the eurosystem of central banks rightly mean that public scrutiny of our work is intense. This is evident from the variety of our mandate, which extends from the overall financial stability of the country and supervi-
As a central bank, we are responsible
sion of individual firms to ensuring consum-
for safeguarding the stability of the financial
ers are treated fairly, managing operational
system and protecting consumers of financial
activities including deposit protection and
firms in Ireland. But historically, like many
the central credit register, and ensuring that
other central banks, we did not seek public-
cash and payments systems run effectively.
ity, nor did we go to great lengths to explain
Changing from the inside out
our work. That has changed. As an organisa-
year programme focusing on improved me-
tion, we have chosen to put accountability and
dia relations, enhanced digital communica-
transparency at the core of our current busi-
tions and a targeted outreach programme.
ness strategy in order to build understanding
When I joined the senior team, while the fi-
and raise levels of public trust in the organi-
nancial crisis had abated and recovery was
One of the main challenges we encounter is
sation. To deliver this goal, the Central Bank
underway there was still a long way to trav-
that our awareness levels are generally cen-
invested in a new communications function
el in terms of communication strategy. On
tred around notoriety linked to the financial
with a focus on consumer communication,
one hand, the economy was recovering and
crisis rather than positive associations. Our
digital channels and a commitment for sen-
strong personalities in the Central Bank had
research shows that we are still atoning for
ior management to be more accessible to key
begun to put its reputation on a better foot-
the weak regulation and oversight of the fi-
stakeholders.
ing. But a parliamentary inquiry into the
nancial crisis period.
I was appointed as the Central Bank’s
banking crisis was ongoing, media scruti-
The globalisation of the financial sys-
first head of communications two years ago,
ny of the restructured and reformed Cen-
tem, the trend towards light-touch regulation,
and my first step was to set out a three-
tral Bank remained high, and the public was
the availability of cheap money, poor bank bal-
14
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
FINANCIAL
ance sheet management and Ireland’s high-
and reform was substantial and the way we
While we live in a world of confidentiality, the
ly-interconnected open economy all contrib-
work and the way we regulate has changed,
communications team have worked with our
uted to the Irish banking crisis. So too did
the outside perception of the Bank is taking
senior leadership to release externally as much
over-optimism on the part of the Central Bank,
much more time and effort to improve.
information on our work as feasible and we
the commercial banks themselves and industry commentators. When the crisis took hold from 2008 on, every Irish citizen paid a price, either through loss of jobs, equity or higher taxes and
have been incrementally adding transparen-
From the outside in
cy initiatives as we start to build our new approach. This has been possible due to the support of Governor Philip R. Lane (who joined the
reduced investment in infrastructure. The in-
The long tail of the crisis means Irish house-
Central Bank in 2015) and his team, who contin-
jection of public funds into the banking sys-
holds still carry a large debt burden, which is
ue to recognise the importance of good govern-
tem amounted to almost 40 per cent of Ire-
amongst the largest in the OECD. This is par-
ance, building long-term trust in the organi-
land’s GDP and contributed to Ireland’s entry
ticularly the case for the so-called ‘squeezed mid-
sation and giving the opportunity for us to
to an IMF-EU Programme. The Central Bank –
dle’. Our first public research, carried out two
explain our decisions.
and indeed, the European Central Bank – was
years ago, showed that trust levels were low, built
So what are we doing? We’ve just
at the centre of that story for many people.
on a lack of understanding of what the Central
launched a new website built on a ‘user first’
Bank does and why.
principle with specific content aimed at the
Over the last 10 years the organisation has undergone fundamental changes, while
Our first research told us that people find
public. We were the first Eurosystem Central
economic recovery has slowly taken hold. The
the Central Bank both powerful and aloof. De-
Bank to publish the minutes of meetings of
low levels of trust cannot be underestimated
spite the institutional overhaul, the significant-
our board, the Central Bank of Ireland Com-
when looking at the Central Bank’s commu-
ly-strengthened regulatory approach, the return
mission. While these minutes excluded de-
nication challenge. The failure of regulation
to a stable economy and our progress to become
tails of supervised firms, the publication pro-
in the crisis period left a big legacy across the
a strong and independent central bank, there is
cess has gone a long way towards building
organisation and across the nation. Patrick
a sense amongst the public that the Bank has
understanding of our work. Our publication
Honohan, Governor of the Central Bank of
not sufficiently atoned for its shortcomings in
of transcripts for key media interviews has
Ireland from 2009 to 2015 and who led the
the financial crisis. The research says that the
helped ensure our complex messages are ac-
overhaul of regulation at the Bank identified
Bank needs to show the public that the organi-
cessible to all stakeholders and not filtered by
that the culture in the organisation was over-
sation has learned from the crisis, taken action
the media alone.
ly hierarchical, deferential towards the finan-
and moved on.
We have also taken other initiatives.
So what are we doing to achieve this?
cial industry and discouraged challenge. From
We’ve published the diaries of our senior ex-
2011 on, Governor Honohan’s new leadership
Our first goal when I set out to build the new
ecutives, our corporate travel expenses and the
team started to review ways of working, ad-
communication strategy was to prioritise our
salary costs of all of our staff – from the Gov-
dress staff engagement issues, build leader-
target audiences for communications – these are
ernor to our facilities staff. As well as details
ship communication capability and create
the public, staff, parliamentary representatives
of expenditure and contracts, we’ve recently
a new culture around the way we want to
and the media. This is then complemented by
started publishing our correspondence with
work together as colleagues. During the ear-
our business strategy which places accountability
parliamentary committees. We’re also pub-
ly post crisis years, Governor Honohan and
and transparency as key governance pillars. This
lishing details of our engagement with stake-
his chief regulator, Matthew Elderfield, were
is then complimented by our three year commu-
holder groups while we plan greater engage-
both visible and effective in how they over-
nication strategy which is focused on enhanc-
ment with civil society and are in the process
hauled regulation and the culture of the or-
ing media relations, building our digital chan-
of expanding our corporate social responsi-
ganisation. However, while internal progress
nels and direct outreach to our key audiences.
bility programme. Elsewhere, we have just
Crises timeline
State guaranteed € 375 billion of liabilities as the population slept
IMF EU Programme: Banking sector shrinks, lending stalls, house prices plummet Domestic and international regulatory reform
Public reports 2008
2010
2011
Central Bank moves to new building
New borrower measures
2012–2014
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
Parliamentary inquiry into the crisis 2015
2016
2017
15
STRATEGY
DESIGNING A SMOKE-FREE FUTURE This year, PMI launched a new manifesto with the aim of building a future on smoke-free products that will one day replace cigarettes. After a decade of investment culminating in the launch of a new portfolio of smokeless products, the change in company direction and promise to shareholders has set a new tone for the tobacco industry – and a new era for PMI’s communications. BY TO N Y S N YD E R
I
have a question for you: how long will the
this number is projected to remain largely
causes or potential causes of smoking-related
world’s largest tobacco company still be
unchanged by 2025.
diseases such as lung cancer, cardiovascular
making cigarettes? That is a question we are trying to answer for ourselves. We do
not have the answer yet, but we know it will
Smoke-free products
come at some point.
disease, and emphysema. We have developed smoke-free products that heat tobacco without burning it and accordingly generate much lower levels
Our vision to one day stop selling
Cigarette smoke contains flavours from the
of harmful chemicals. With over $3 billion
cigarettes is unprecedented for a tobacco
tobacco blend, as well as nicotine that exists
invested in R&D to date, we now have a
company. Many will question our motives
naturally in tobacco leaves. It’s these elements
suite of non-combustible products, including
based on the distrust surrounding our
in the smoke that consumers enjoy while
e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products,
industry; others will wonder why we would
smoking. However, the very same burning
which have the potential to significantly
completely change our existing, very profitable
process that releases the tobacco flavors and
reduce individual risk and population harm
business model. The answer to this question is
nicotine also produces over 8,000 chemicals, of
compared to continued smoking of cigarettes.
simple, because we can and we should.
which about 1 per cent have been identified as
We are leading a full-scale effort to ensure
We understand the millions of men
reduced risk products ultimately replace
and women who smoke cigarettes. Those who
cigarettes – to the benefit of adult smokers
don’t want to quit are looking for less harmful,
and society, our company and shareholders.
yet satisfying, alternatives to smoking. We have the resources to meet that demand and thanks to the imagination and perseverance of many at PMI we have developed breakthrough products that are smoke-free and enjoyable. We are investing people, resources, time and money to develop further and assess the risk-reduction potential of these new, alternative products to cigarettes. The tobacco industry means different things for different people . For some it is one of the most reviled industries that exists. And
“The tobacco industry means different things for different people.”
This decision has set our company on a new path. Amid the many global trends today, technological innovation is transforming our industry. For commercial, ethical and public health reasons, PMI is leading this transformation. Nearly three million smokers have already converted to our new products, and this is just the beginning. In prioritising the development and commercialisation of these alternative products, we want to address the health impact of our combustible cigarette business
despite tobacco control efforts, the World
head-on, not only setting our company on a
Health Organization estimates that over a
new course, but also making a new contract
billion people currently smoke cigarettes, and
with society.
18
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
STRATEGY
relationship we have had with society has to move from the marketing of a brand to the embracing of a concept. And that requires a whole different set of messages, a whole different set of tools and a whole different agility to make sure we get traction. Our new website, PMI.com, typifies our
When was the last time you visited the
PMI website?
intent. Lots of companies go through website revamps, but an exercise to update our website had a profound effect. As a company, it
Find out more on the new
really helped us establish a new tone of voice,
pmi.com
clarity and simplicity of language designed to demonstrate our commitment to openPMI_Poster_DTP_.indd 1
15/12/16 11:58
Part of PMI’s new poster campaign to raise awareness of their relaunched website / Image: PMI
ness, transparency and honesty. It also represented a significant milestone articulating the company’s shift and vision.
Facing a deficit of trust
Therefore, we have a duty to engage and ac-
The messaging we use on PMI.com is
tivate society. We need to educate on the fact
more than just a style of writing. It is a way
that there is a role for an alternative. It is not
of being. We are coming from below zero to
just a quit or die conundrum. Harm reduc-
earn trust and credibility, and it is important
Let me explain the journey we are taking as
tion is a third option to address the health ef-
we are plain speaking and transparent. There
a company and the communications chal-
fects of smoking.
simply is no time for ambiguity.
lenges we face to build the necessary support
That is where communications has
to accelerate a smoke-free future. In 2017 we
become not just something to reiterate the
launched our manifesto, Designing a Smoke-
position of a company, not just something
Free Future, which we published in conjunc-
of positioning the image of the corporation,
tion with a refreshed website, PMI.com. This
but has become something that really needs
is a very public declaration of our vision for a
to be at the forefront of this disruptive, pos-
smoke-free future, promoting a world where
itive change in our industry.
every smoker has an opportunity to make a
Our commitment to a smoke-free fu-
better choice. In fact, we believe the solution
ture has started a conversation. We want to
of a smoke-free world will benefit all stake-
ensure there is a debate in society. We rec-
holders, from investors to society. But this will
ognise and accept that there will always be
require the transformation of our industry
people who are on a side that says: “you can-
and the disruption of our business models.
not trust the industry”. We know that there
The transformation that we are going
is a deficit of trust. Why should you believe
through goes far beyond the product itself. It
what we have to say? And yet we know that
is a transformation of who we are and who
the message is so important that we have to
we collaborate with. Unfortunately, not every-
do everything we can to make sure it comes
body feels that we have the right to do that.
across. We feel we have a duty to advocate for
To some we have no right in society to talk
what we believe is right.
about the solution because we are so much
Our old communication stance was
part of the problem. Also, we often run into
very much based on a belief that if we stuck
the misconception that smoking is already
our head up we would be shot at. We were
sorted. People don’t see many smokers nowa-
not heavily involved in a wider dialogue with
days. They are not hanging around in bars and
society. We did not need explain who we are
restaurants in the way they were decades ago.
and where we want to go.
It is important regulation is updated
Now, we are moving from the back foot
to allow smokers information on smoke-free
to the front foot, out of the shadows into the
products and provide access to these prod-
world at large. This requires a lot of internal,
ucts, but this is not enough. Treating reduced
cultural and behavioural change. We have to
risk products like cigarettes confuses people
start building new relationships, new chan-
and does not encourage smokers to try them.
nels, and working with different partners. The
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
TOBACCO MEETS TECHNOLOGY According to PMI, its most popular smoke-free products use its tobacco heating system IQCS: over 2.9 million consumers are reported to have switched from cigarettes to this product.
IQOS use electronics that heat tobacco just enough to release a nicotine-containing vapour but without burning the tobacco. The tobacco in a cigarette burns at temperatures in excess of 600°C, generating smoke that contains harmful chemicals. But IQOS heats tobacco to much lower temperatures, up to 350°C, without combustion, fire, ash or smoke. PMI claims that the lower temperature heating releases the taste of tobacco and that, because the tobacco is heated and not burned, the levels of harmful chemicals are significantly reduced compared to cigarette smoke. PMI have announced plans to make IQOS available in over 30 countries by the end of 2017.
19
CONTENT
CURIOSITY-DRIVEN CONTENT What content is most engaging? Why? What can we learn from it? The same curiosity that drives research at CERN has helped develop its editorial content, with findings from a study into how people react to CERN social media helping shape and adapt its content. A few useful tips for crafting digital content and improving engagement. BY KATE K A HL E
C
ERN, the European laboratory for
1. Education: to begin a journey, using social
weeks of data across five of CERN’s social media
particle physics, is home to the
media to link back to the website to encourage
channels. Each social media post in the study
Large Hadron Collider, the larg-
people to find out more; 2. Engagement: to foster
including an image, resulting in 214 posts in
est machine in the world. CERN
engagement and form an online community
total, of which 94 were newsworthy and 120
research is a global endeavour and the world
of stakeholders interested in the laboratory
wide web was born at the laboratory. In 2012,
and its work; 3. Marketing: to retain positive
CERN announced the discovery of a new parti-
sentiment towards the laboratory. By keeping
cle, known as the Higgs Boson and nicknamed
the sentiment positive and handling the negative
“the God particle” by the media. But a Higgs Bo-
sentiment constructively by responding as
son discovery doesn’t come along every day, so
appropriate to questions or concerns, CERN’s
how do we develop regular, engaging content?
strong brand identity is retained.
The editorial content development section
As well as creating and sharing content
includes the writing, web and social media teams.
about the latest advancements in particle physics
We source stories, craft written content and work
(CERN’s raison d’être), we also have regular social
with designers, photographers and videographers
media posts to share more stories and showcase
to showcase CERN in the best possible way. Our
engaging photos, with each post linking back
editorial content is just part of our communication,
to the CERN website. Every Thursday, we
education and outreach offerings, which are all
have a throwback Thursday post highlighting a moment in CERN’s history. Every Friday, we post a photo and ask people to guess what it is by adding their comments, then each Monday we post the answer with a link to find out more.
Testing our content
were simply attractive historic or quirky images.
Being surrounded by curiosity-driven research
Across these 214 posts, we identified 35 high-
at CERN, with scientists asking questions
engagement items and looked closely at these
about the fundamental building blocks of
to see what we could learn from them.
our universe, we can’t help but apply similar
For the highly engaging news items,
curiosity to our content creation. As a way
audiences reacted by liking, commenting, sharing
of testing whether our social media strategy
and clicking-through, but spent very little time
was effective, I collaborated with academics
on the webpage, quickly consuming the content
from Israel to publish a scientific study in 2016
and moving on. Interestingly though, of the 35
entitled Footprints of Fascination: Digital Traces
high-engagement items, more than half were
guided by our communication strategy. As a
of Public Engagement with Particle Physics on
not news-related but instead involved beautiful
component of this, CERN social media has three
CERN’s Social Media Platforms, available via
or surprising images. The power of imagery on
main strands to its strategy:
http://cern.ch/go/plos. We investigated eight
social media can work for organisations for
26
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
CONTENT
“Social media gives nontraditional opportunities to directly engage with the public.”
the same Twitter post in English and in French,
numbers when comparing #InTheory to
the English-language followers had all the
all CERN mentions on social media, there
information they needed in the tweet so were
were moments during the campaign when
less motivated to click-through. Whereas the
more people were talking about #InTheory
140-character-limit made the French tweet
than CERN. And did we keep people on the
a more enigmatic “clickbait”, with readers
website longer? Well, the final moment of
intrigued to find out more, resulting in 2.5 times
the #InTheory series saw the average time
the average click-throughs.
on the website increase from roughly two
Tailoring content to a specific audience
minutes to 14 minutes!
also led to higher engagement, be it a beautiful
Social media gives non-traditional
detector image shared with the visually minded
opportunities to directly engage with the
audience of Instagram or French Twitter users
public . We can convey the same message
being led to a whole publication of content in
with different packaging, to make it more
their native language and spending longer on
accessible and less formal. For example, each
the site by clicking through multiple stories.
year we prepare an April Fools fake news
A human focus is one of the most
story and in 2015, our Star Wars inspired
established attention-grabbing features in the media, and this is no different for a science-minded audience. One of the biggest stories during the data-taking period was the
marketing, engagement and education. We also
announcement that Fabiola Gianotti would
found that when social media took visitors to a
become director general of CERN. The comments
webpage including a video or virtual tour the
discussed different aspects of her identity as a
visit duration increased, especially when the
scientist, an Italian and a female, they related
video was placed further down the page and seen
to her and congratulated her on a personal
after reading the text. Retention also increased
level. In another example, a Facebook post took
when viewers were led to playlists where they
people to a series of stories written in the first
could click to watch additional videos.
person. Although the click-throughs were not
Social media posts with a higher than
higher than average, those that did click were
average number of comments were often due
engaged in the history and kept clicking further
to discourse in unexpected directions, with
to read the full long-form article.
the discussion dominated by arguments about unrelated, user-introduced topics. Social media provides a space for more engagement, but gives organisations less control of the message. What can be controlled is how the comments
The human touch, humour and help
are addressed, either with a suitable response
April Fools story – CERN had discovered “the force” – resulted in 26.5K engagements
or by enforcing a comment policy. CERN’s for
The scientific study awakened our curiosity
on social media. Although not something
example is “CERN welcomes your comments
to test these trends even more. In particular,
we can do every day, these jokes do give us
and will moderate them using these guidelines:
we wanted to test human-interest stories and
an opportunity to tap into the lighter side of
Please keep comments relevant. Irrelevant,
whether they kept readers on the website for
science and strike a chord with our audiences.
inappropriate or offensive comments may be
longer. It was time to tell stories. In 2016, we had
CERN is part of a scientific community
deleted. Stay on topic. Other readers expect the
two series of long-form articles that showcased
so it’s important to collaborate on social media
comments about a post to deal with the topic at
theoretical physicists and experimental
with other organisations and laboratories. We
hand”. Thus, where comments are concerned, it is
physicists: #InTheory and #InPractice. Then
use our platforms to showcase the successes
important to read the content and tone carefully
in 2017, we launched #IWorkAtCERN, which
of others from congratulating the Physics
to really understand the effectiveness of a post.
began with the International Day of Women in
Nobel Prize winners, to highlighting the
Language played an unexpected role in our
Science but then went wider with more posts
gravitational waves discovery of LIGO. We
high-engagement items. CERN is a bilingual
to highlight different professions at CERN. We
also use #FollowFriday to highlight the
English and French organisation and although
wanted to highlight the people behind the science
worldwide particle physics research taking
our social media platforms are predominately
and showcase diversity around CERN, as well
place in national physics laboratories. As
English-language we do have a @CERN_FR
as keeping the audience on the website for
CERN scientists are strong ambassadors, we
Twitter account in French. When comparing
longer. What we saw was that despite lower
encourage them to use social media and have
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
27
ENGAGEMENT
SPARKING CONVERSATIONS WITH VIRTUAL REALITY To attract today’s talent it isn’t enough to highlight the work your organisation does. Potential employees want to know what it feels like to work in it. For this, Siemens found that a simple cardboard device came in handy. BY R O SA R I ER A
dress. These questions include: what does it
It is about how the people view the
feel like to be part of a team that worked on
organisation as an employer. In contrast to classic corporate branding,
employer branding is not primarily about an organisation’s products and services. Take my company, Siemens. We do some amazing stuff. Among other things, we are currently working on doubling Egypt’s energy production, finding ways to prevent malaria, making cities smarter and more eco-efficient, designing mobile, autonomous, and connected 3D printing robots and helping NASA explore Mars. In short, we are changing the world through engineering. Highlighting these things will help attract talent, for sure. But talent today has plenty of ways of finding out about a company’s portfolio: through ads, business news, events and many other channels. And the power of a portfolio as an attractor is waning, with talent becoming ever more interested in the deep-
“What really sparks an interest in our company as a potential employer is a presentation of the human side.”
this company’s products and services? What does it take to develop the products? How does delivering the services shape the working week? What were the challenges along the way? Questions like these often provide the best answers for interested prospects as to whether they might fit into an organisation. Recently, the need to communicate this more human aspect of working at an organisation has increased due to shifts in labour market preferences. Before we started to develop our own new employer brand, we put a lot of effort into trying to understand these shifts and the ways in which today’s internal and external talent markets are evolving. From this we gained valuable insights into what today’s labour market expects from employers, enabling us to develop our employer value proposition. An example of a recent shift in labour
er questions that even platforms like Glass-
market preferences is the one highlighted in
door or Kununu, where employees can review
a recent study by Universum, a specialist
their employer, often do not adequately ad-
in talent market intelligence and employer
30
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
Assembly instructions for a virtual reality cardboard viewer given to Siemens employees / Image: Siemens
E
mployer branding is about identity.
ENGAGEMENT
branding, which found that within Genera-
doing this, but knew that using technology to
tion Z, 55 per cent prefer the idea of found-
drive scale and, furthermore, selecting a tech-
ing or at least working for a start-up to that
nology that would by its very nature give em-
of working for an established player. For Siemens, these shifts have led to a decline in our attractiveness scores as an employer. Merely doing impressive things no longer automatically makes us the kind of place where a gifted engineer, data scientist or technologist might consider working. Although we have found that the preferencet for start-ups is often based on a misunderstanding of what is like to work for an established player, at the same time we have come to recognise that correcting this misunderstanding is more than a matter of presenting facts and figures. Data can, of course, point prospective employees in the right direction. But according to our research, what really sparks an interest in our company as a
“The rationale for choosing virtual reality is its immersive features and ability to transport people into another world.”
ployees and prospects something interesting and relevant to talk about, would resonate particularly well in an engineering company like Siemens. So, among other things, we decided to produce state-of-the-art virtual reality documentary videos featuring colleagues working in different countries and different businesses. We call these featured employees “Siemens Future Makers” because we want to highlight how they are able to put their unique experience, capabilities and expertise to use at our company not just to do a job but to contribute to making the future of engineering happen. The rationale for choosing virtual reality as a channel is based on its immersive features and ability to transport people into
potential employer is a presentation of the hu-
another world. This technology offers a com-
man side of working at it. In order to change
pletely new way of imparting what it is like to
people’s perceptions of working at a large com-
operate in a particular environment, such as in
pany like Siemens, we found that it is crucial
the work environment at Siemens. The series
that they connect on a human level and feel
of virtual reality documentary videos that we
something. This insight now forms the basis
have produced allows the audience to step into
for employer branding at Siemens.
the various different worlds of work inhabited by different Siemens employees around
The conversation principle
always at the human level and thus provide
the world. They enable prospective employ-
an important insight into what it is like to
ees to experience on a very personal level how
work at Siemens.
these employees spend the working day and
This conversation principle is influenc-
how the impact of their work on society mo-
We know that the most powerful way to
ing all of our employer branding activities. In
tivates them. The employees and stories fea-
find out what working at an organisation is
early 2017, for example, we relaunched siemens.
tured in these documentaries were selected
like is through speaking with someone who
com/careers, the second-most frequently vis-
in collaboration with colleagues from the re-
works there. And we know that the more our
ited website at siemens.com, restructuring it
spective countries to ensure that the content
world digitalises, the more a personal con-
around employee-driven stories that provide
is relevant and authentic and represents Sie-
versation with an old college friend or for-
an authentic look at what it is like to work
mens in the most insightful way.
mer colleague will stand out from a message
at Siemens. Our aim is to give potential can-
To ensure that the experience is scala-
carefully curated by a company department.
didates as unedited an account as possible
ble in practice we employed technology that is
This dialogue creates a much more person-
of what they can expect from Siemens as an
easy to use and easy to share. We created an
al impression of an organisation and helps
employer. We believe that, as long as we re-
app, Siemens 360°, for iOS and Android. This
convey its culture. This is why at Siemens we
sist trying somehow to inject corporate jar-
app, used in combination with the virtual re-
have introduced a new employer branding
gon or corporate messaging into the dialogue,
ality Google Cardboard viewers that, branded
strategy based on sparking conversations,
these conversations are the best tool we have
with our own logo, we were able to produce in
namely ones about the future of engineering
for spreading knowledge about what it is like
huge numbers at relatively low cost, is start-
and what it takes to get there.
to work at our company and the kind of cul-
ing to make it possible for pretty much an-
ture that awaits a new recruit.
yone around the world with a connection to
These conversations are not intended to take place on an abstract level between
And while developing the new strate-
or interest in Siemens to experience virtual
our company and the talent market. The aim
gy, we asked not only what content we could
reality and to do so within the context of the
is to spark a multitude of conversations with
use to spark these conversations but also how
Siemens employer brand. As with all our em-
society. They can be initiated internally or ex-
we could spark these conversations at scale.
ployer branding activities, the initial focus was
ternally. The important thing is that they are
We were pretty agnostic as to how to go about
internal. This was not just because we were
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
31
MONITOR
DIGITAL AND VISUAL The 2017 European Communication Monitor shows that the strategic communication function is undergoing a fundamental transformation. BY DEJA N V E R Č I Č A N D A N S GA R Z E R FAS S
I
nformation and communication technologies and the digital, social and mobile media that develop from them are fundamentally changing strategic com-
From words to pictures
The problem is that, for decades, the most sought competency in communication was written language, first native tongue and later also English. It is therefore not unu-
munication. This is far more than an instru-
sual that every second communication pro-
mental development – today’s economic, so-
For millennia, western civilisation has been
fessional admits to have limited competen-
cial and business environment forces us to
based on words. We are a literal civilisation.
cies in visual communication.
rethink the mission and contribution of com-
Our education is about reading and writing.
The fastest growth in visual commu-
munication in organisations.
Whatever social problem we have, we expect
nication is in the use of online videos (e.g.
The results of the 2017 European Com-
to solve it with higher literacy (‘health liter-
web clips), infographics (e.g. explanatory
munication Monitor present this transfor-
acy’, ‘financial literacy’, ‘media literacy’ and
content), instant photos (spontaneous, un-
mation in many domains, four of which are
so on). This era may be over. 94.4 per cent of
edited) and business graphics (such as ta-
presented in this article: visualisation of com-
the communicators interviewed for the 2017
bles and figures) – all directly related to ad-
munication, automatisation and robots, the
European Communication Monitor witness
vances of digital, social and mobile media.
need for strategy taking precedence over op-
a trend from verbal towards visual commu-
With mobile taking the pole position, this
erations, and that communication quality
nication. Seven out of 10 communicators ex-
trend will only accelerate.
must become certified, i.e. evidence based and
perience rising demand for visual communi-
As digital natives (people who were
not only implicitly assumed. Communica-
cation from their stakeholders. 89.5 per cent
born in the digital age) grow older and be-
tion management has entered the 21st centu-
agree that visual communication requires
come the majority of customers, employ-
ry as a recognised function, but its full affir-
new competencies by practitioners, but only
ees and other stakeholders, visual may take
mation depends on its ability to take the lead
every second believes specific management
precedence over literal with unforeseeable
in embracing hypermodernity (as an era fol-
processes are needed to master the upcom-
consequences. Professional communicators
lowing postmodernity) and its communica-
ing challenges (Figure 1).
must catch up.
tive features.
Visual communication requires specific competencies by communication professionals
89.5%
Visual communication requires specific management structures and processes
50.5% Agree (scale 4 – 5)
33.1% Neutral (scale 3)
Fig. 1: Prerequisites for handling visual communication in organisations
34
7.6%
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
Disagree (scale 1 – 2)
16.3%
2.8%
MONITOR
“Today’s economic, social and business environment forces us to rethink the mission and contribution of communication in organisations.”
Romania (21.6%)
Germany (67.1%)
Austria (53.4%)
Czech Republic (24.0%)
Switzerland (45.8%)
Poland (33.3%) Netherlands (38.4%)
Turkey (31.6%)
France (32.0%)
Serbia (37.7%) Belgium (32.0%)
United Kingdom (37.0%)
Croatia (22.6%)
Ireland (33.7%) Slovenia (25.6%) Sweden (34.0%) Italy (30.6%) Norway (35.2%)
Spain (35.8%) Finland (35.6%)
Western Europe Northern Europe Southern Europe Eastern Europe Fig. 2: Attention to the debate about social bots in key countries across Europe
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
35
BRANDING
ARTS PATRONAGE 2.0 Several high-profile examples of relationships between companies and the arts show the media appeal of cultural collaborations. But how can truly creative communications emerge from these unlikely partnerships? BY ANASTAS I A E L A E VA
C
onsumers are becoming more demanding and, as several recent surveys show, brands need to go beyond merely providing a
quality product or service to win customers’
hearts and minds. They need to create memorable experiences and engage target audiences around their points of passion and interests, with art being a key way to do that. At the same time, faced with constant cuts in pub-
lic funding, cultural institutions are looking
Swatch Art Peace Hotel / Photo: Swatch Ltd.
at establishing corporate partnerships with the goal of making their operations more sustainable. Therefore, collaborations between companies and cultural organisations have the potential to invigorate the brand’s communications while filling a widening gap in
Beyond logo sponsorship
the art world. However, to be successful, such
For years, BMW has been involved in a variety of art initiatives ranging from BMW Art Cars, created in collaboration with acclaimed artists, to sponsorships of world-renowned
initiatives should be based on a clear long-
Our research shows that successful art collab-
cultural institutions, festivals and events. In
term strategy, take into account each side’s
orations require significant commitment in
2015 the company launched an extension to
sensibilities and goals as well as engage a va-
terms of time, effort and investment. One-off
its long-term partnership with the Art Basel
riety of internal and external stakeholders.
projects based on stamping an artistic image
contemporary art fair, the BMW Art Journey.
With the goal of determining what
on a product or a brand’s logo on a press wall
Built around the brand’s idea of mobility, the
makes creative partnerships work and what
at a sponsored cultural event could potential-
award goes beyond just financial support and
trends are driving their future, we conducted
ly do more damage than bring benefits. Such
offers artists from the fair’s emerging art
an international study: Brands and the Arts:
superficial involvement demonstrates that
section an opportunity to undertake a jour-
Making Creative Partnerships Work – Trends,
the brand lacked the effort needed to prop-
ney of creative discovery. Winners can go al-
Best Practices and Insights into Successful Col-
erly understand the arts community and to
most anywhere in the world by any means
laborations. The study analyses more than 40
communicate with it in a meaningful way. To
of transportation to conduct research, make
corporate art programmes and includes in-
be effective, brand engagement with the arts
contacts and create new artworks.
terviews with consultants and managers re-
should go further, and many long-time corpo-
The Swedish alcohol brand Absolut
sponsible for engagements at major global
rate art supporters are constantly reviewing
has been collaborating with artists for over
brands such as Absolut, BMW, Cadillac, Da-
their programmes to try out new approach-
30 years. Its arts strategy also includes the
vidoff, Dior, Hennessy and Swatch, to name
es and to make existing initiatives more stra-
Absolut Art Award for artists and cultural
just a few.
tegic, systematic and sustainable.
writers as well as special art bars at major
40
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
BRANDING
cultural events around the world. In 2015, Absolut went even further, creating a separate entity, Absolut Art, a venture that strives to bring more art to people’s homes and presents an online portal where the works of emerging artists can be discovered and bought at affordable prices. Swatch has been partnering with creatives around its art watch editions since the foundation of the Swiss brand in 1980s. Today, it also serves as the main partner of the Venice Biennale where it presents installations by contemporary artists and works created by the participants of the Swatch artist residency in Shanghai.
BMW Art Car Cao Fei / Photo: Liu Chunquan
BMW Art Journey / Photo: Abigail Reynolds
creative freedom, some brands are partnering with artists who have criticised them specifically or the consumer culture in general. For example, for its spring 2017 collection, US apparel retailer J.Crew collaborated with the street artist Michael De Feo, who had previously challenged the brand and its corporate messaging by painting on top of its ads. As contemporary art often requires so-
Davidoff Art Initiative Studio / Photo: Alfredo Esteban Morales
phisticated technology and materials, this rep-
New brand roles: art experience creator, content creator and educator
resents another opportunity to cooperate and the watch industry (i.e. Richard Mille, Hublot,
to make artistic dreams a reality. The chem-
and Romain Jerome), are starting to collabo-
ical corporation BASF recently collaborated
rate with trendy street, graffiti and tattoo artists.
with the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum
Studies have confirmed the value of the
in New York and the American artist Doug
“art fusion” phenomenon, which suggests that
Wheeler around his ‘PSAD Synthetic Desert
the art has the power to bring creative energy
III’ installation. For almost 50 years, Wheeler
to a brand and to influence its positioning. So,
thought about creating a serene and silent es-
if partnerships around classic culture deliver
cape, and this was eventually realised with the
We are also witnessing more unexpected part-
connotations of heritage, luxury and prestige,
help of BASF’s sound-absorbing material Ba-
nerships. For example, to reach younger audi-
collaborations with contemporary artists can
sotect. The company became so involved into
ences and to add an edgy flair to their products,
highlight a brand’s connection with the present.
installation development, it eventually took
some high-end heritage brands, especially in
To showcase their openness and respect for
on sponsorship of the exhibition.
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
41
COLLABORATION
COLLABORATION TRAINING IN AN ERA OF CONNECTIVITY Do we really know collaboration? Or do we just think we know? Spoiler: it’s more than just the act of working together with someone. To define, encourage and improve on collaboration at your workplace, perhaps it is time to look at games for inspiration and training. BY R A J I V VA I D BASA I AWM O I T
Cooperation
+
Collaboration
+
T
Collaboration can’t be turned on with the flick of a switch
hese days, one often hears that
timates made in 2012) that by 2020 we will be
“collaboration is the new black”.
more than four billion connected people, us-
I first encountered this phrase in
ing over 25 billion embedded and intelligent
2010 when the pharmaceutical in-
systems and sharing over 50 trillion gigabytes
dustry and the biotech industry argued for
of data. I will let that sink in for a second. We
more collaboration. We have of course come a
are not only entering an era of connectivity but
In principle any activity, when framed in the
long way since 2010. The tools of modern soci-
are entering an era of unprecedented connec-
right context, may lead to collaboration. How-
ety have changed – we are much more mobile
tivity in the history of humankind. This kind
ever, unlike cooperation, collaboration cannot
than before, data is much more accessible than
of connectivity is setting up demands for col-
be turned on with the flick of a switch. There
before and we are increasingly more connect-
laboration that are also unprecedented. How-
is a fundamental difference between collab-
ed. In fact, the International Data Corporation
ever, do we really know how to collaborate, or
oration and co-operation. In collaboration,
has predicted (and these are conservative es-
are we only cooperating?
partners have a mutual shared goal with a
46
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
COLLABORATION
The idea of using simulations and games for
thing that is innate or easy to do, why train for
training is not new. For instance, in 1970 the
it in the first place? But as explained earlier, this
Financial Times released a “National Manage-
stems from the fact that most people mistake
ment Game” that successfully ran for 15 years
their cooperativeness (defined by friendly ges-
and involved more than 70,000 people. The
tures, willingness to share information, pleas-
game tried to simulate the day-to-day running
ant behaviour and so on) with collaboration.
of a business and train managers to manage fic-
The second observation also touches on hu-
tive balance sheets and handle competition. Pi-
man behaviour – coupled to an acceptance of
lots have long had to train for many hours on
dogma – that competition is always good and
flight simulators before flying passenger planes
that societies only advance by being competi-
on their own. Medical students are accustomed
tive. This is also reflected in traditional game
to training on cadavers or plastic patients that
design which defines games as “a system in
are pre-programmed with symptoms. So what
which players engage in an artificial conflict,
is new about using games for training today?
defined by rules, that results in a quantifiable
What has changed is the landscape and the com-
outcome” (to quote Katie Salen and Eric Zim-
plexity of games and the ease of accessing, de-
merman in Rules of Play: Game design Funda-
signing and using them. In the past, the entry
mentals). This understanding is also amplified
barrier for simulations had always been high.
by the concept of the Nobel-prize winning Game
Not so today. These days, thanks to technolo-
Theory, which, according to Wikipedia, is “the
high-degree of trust and a high level of in-
gies such as Unity, game design is much more
study of mathematical models of conflict and
ter-dependency. In a cooperation, on the oth-
accessible than ever before. Board games have
cooperation between intelligent rational deci-
er hand, the partners might be inter-dependent
also made a comeback and the board games
sion-makers” and which contrasts games as ei-
but they undertake the partnership with indi-
of today are very different from the simplistic
ther Zero-sum (‘I win or you lose’ logic) or non
vidual goals in mind. Thus, cooperation might
games of the past. They are complex, engaging
zero-sum (win-win or lose-lose logic).
deliver a shared outcome but is built on indi-
and very well designed. These “serious games”
Thus, according to traditional Game The-
vidual goals, whereas true collaboration deliv-
have established an identity of their own. Fur-
ory, games fall into two categories: competitive
ers on a mutual goal and shared value. Cooper-
thermore, the entry and evolution of gamifica-
(for example chess and checkers) or cooperative
ation is comparatively easier to achieve which
tion defined as “the use of games/game-mechan-
(for example, Settlers of Catan). But there is a
is also why more examples of cooperation can
ics in non-game contexts” (Sebastian Deterding,
third genre: that of collaborative games (for ex-
be found than of collaboration.
Gamification: Toward a definition) has cement-
“Collaborative games need to have certain elements to boost collaboration.”
ed the central role of games and gamification
Gaming as a way to facilitate and train for collaboration
in society today.
Effective game design
True collaboration is a process (and thus can be
It should, however, be reiterated that a game is
learned), it is a mindset (and thus can be incul-
only as good as the design behind it. Needless
cated), and is essentially dynamic (i.e. it requires
to say, a game designed to ask the right ques-
flexibility). This is where games and gamifica-
tions will always deliver greater value than just
tion set in. Games designed with collaboration
a good-looking game. While games have en-
in mind require one to spend time with oth-
tered the 21st century and are more pervasive
ers engaged in an activity towards a common
than in the past, games designed for true col-
goal. This allows for trust-building which is an
laboration are still rather rare. The reason for
essential ingredient of collaboration. Anoth-
this can be multi-faceted, though two general
er important ingredient is a level-playing field
observations can be made: 1) The demand for
within a safe environment where players ex-
serious collaboration games is not very high; 2)
change ideas, opinions, strategies, perspectives
The history of game-design itself has often re-
and so on without fear of judgement – gaming
lied on competition as the main driver for en-
often creates this. Often these exchanges con-
gagement with the game.
tinue post-game and lead to real-world boosts
The first observation is rather easy to explain –
in collaboration.
as collaboration has often been viewed as some-
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
COMPETITIVE, COOPERATIVE AND COLLABORATIVE GAMES ••
In a competitive game goals of players are diametrically opposed.
••
A cooperative game models a situation where two or more individuals have interests that are “neither completely opposed nor completely coincident” (John Nash) (e.g. Settlers of Catan).
••
Collaborative games: Collaboration as a team differs from cooperation among individuals in that cooperative players may have different goals and payoffs where collaborative players have only one goal and share the rewards or penalties of their decisions. (e.g. Pandemic, Dungeons & Dragons)
47
#KEEPQUESTIONING
#KEEPQUESTIONING
MELISSA FLEMING In the face of public apathy, can one human story illuminate a large-scale crisis? We put your questions to the head of communications of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.
52
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
#KEEPQUESTIONING
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
53
#KEEPQUESTIONING
“Communicators who speak about people as statistics might make headlines but they won’t build compassion, foster change and inspire action.”
W
hen 19 year old Doaa and her boyfriend Bassam, Syrian refugees trapped in a grinding existence in Egypt, handed over all of Bassam’s life savings to refugee smugglers for a journey on a rusting fishing
boat, little could they have imagined the horrors that lay ahead. After their boat was attacked and left to capsize in the Mediterranean,
Doaa – but not Bassam – was finally found by rescuers after four days in the water, one of just 11 people who survived from the boat. How do we know this? Because Doaa’s experiences before, during and after these harrowing events have found a storyteller – Melissa Fleming, head of communications for the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees – who developed Doaa’s narrative into an online article, then a Ted Talk, then a book... and soon a major motion picture produced by Steven Spielberg. In the first of our new series of #keepquestioning interviews, we invited communication professionals from across Europe to put their questions to the head of communications of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) about the strategy behind UNHCR’s storytelling, the fight against apathy and their long-term vision for supporting refugees.
Melissa Fleming on stage at the 2017 European Communication Summit / Photo: Bernal Revert
54
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
#KEEPQUESTIONING
Helen Palmer Strategic Media Director, Weber Shandwick: “The stories you have told are heart rending and it is hard to comprehend how people could be unmoved by them. However, apathy and prejudice about refugees still persist. How do we reach and move those people who will never watch a TED talk or read a newspaper account of a refugee’s story?” We are doing audience research in a number of key countries to determine people’s attitudes toward refugees and also where they get their information. We also test how various Karin Helmstaedt Television and Event Presenter:
groups respond to certain messages. This allows us to decide
“You’ve taken Doaa’s story a long way: it's become a book and
not just whom we should target but also with what kind of
it is going to become a film. Yet this story will also run its
news and stories, via which medium and how we want them
course, it will reach a point of saturation. Do you have other
to respond. We are trying to move away from just preach-
stories in the pipeline to replace it when you need to make
ing to the converted and working to reach the undecided
the next assault on the lack of empathy?”
and anxious middle. People who care about a fair society,
It is amazing to me how Doaa’s story has not run its course,
human rights and helping people in need but who have very
but actually keeps resonating with new audiences. If I accept-
legitimate worries. We don’t bother trying to convince the far
ed all the speaking requests I am getting, I could be telling her
right who operate on a platform of hate toward migrants and
story full-time around the world! But yes, there are so many
refugees.
other important refugee stories that I and my team are committed to telling. To build empathy, these stories must show
Kathleen Noonan Director of Philanthropies and Education
the person’s resilience, and also that there is hope. For one, a
Communications, Europe, Microsoft:
young Yazidi woman from Iraq recently reached out to me
“In the past, UNHCR worked closely with celebrities and ambas-
wanting me to tell her story. She and her two younger sisters
sadors to draw attention to specific programmes and crises. You
were kidnapped by ISIS and held as sex slaves. She managed
are now expanding beyond that approach and doing innovative
to escape after two years in horrific captivity and get resettled
partnerships with Humans of New York and working with vir-
to Canada. But her sisters are still enslaved.
tual reality to draw attention to the Syrian Refugee crisis. Why have you made the decision to shift your storytelling strategy,
Ivo Banek Managing Partner, Communication Works:
and how you have implemented it?”
“How do you balance empathy and the professional distance
We haven’t fundamentally shifted our strategy – we are still
you need in order to be credible as a communicator?”
working with traditional media and with celebrities as Goodwill
In my field, if you don’t feel empathy yourself with the refu-
Ambassadors. But we have expanded our reach through other
gees you are representing, then you will have no credibility.
partnerships. Your Humans of New York example is a good
As the saying goes, “statistics are human beings with the tears
one. We reached out to Brandon Stanton when the U.S. gov-
dried off.” Communicators who speak about people as statistics
ernment and media were expressing concerns about resettling
might make headlines but they won’t build compassion, foster
Syrian refugees. We arranged for him to meet with refugees in
change and inspire action. That is why I travel frequently to
Jordan and Turkey who were scheduled to depart for the U.S.
war zones and refugee camps to meet refugees and learn about
His photographs and storytelling generated an enormous wave
their circumstances. That said, taking in refugee stories can be
of sympathy and funds. One of the refugees, a Syrian inven-
overwhelming too. You feel a kind of secondary trauma, which
tor, was even invited to the White House and seated next to
can cause a lot of stress and feelings of guilt. So it is important
Michele Obama for the State of the Union address. We have
to recognise how lucky we are to live in a peaceful place, to have
also recently partnered with Google to create this innovative
passports, to have a home and to be able to chose where we live.
website, Searching for Syria which shows Syria then and now.
Only then can we have the strength to help others.
Media partnerships are absolutely crucial to getting our message out and placing our content.
COMMUNICATION DIRECTOR 3/2017
55
ISSUE FOCUS
ISSUE FOCUS
ISSUE FOCUS
The personalisation of communications 60
68
76
The personal touch
A revolution in personalised marketing
“Micro-targeting allows you to scare people easier”
Can AI deliver on the promise of marketing: true personalisation at scale?
The father of the Republican internet on Trump, Twitter and the pitfalls of online echo chambers
BY A N DY PH I L L I PS
I N T E RV I E W BY DA F Y D D PH I L L I PS
64
72
80
Analyse this
The dark side of personalisation
CEO leadership in a broken system
How can we find the right balance between protecting our privacy and allowing organisations to track us and our interests?
Against a background of declining trust in CEOs, a more personalised, authentic approach to communications can help engage the sceptics
In order to retain and grow their customer base, businesses need to get personal with their consumers. BY C ÉL I N E F E N E C H
How can organisations choose the right data-analysis strategy to suit their personalisation needs? BY EL I Z A B E T H P R E S S
BY F E D E RI C O G U E RRI NI
BY J U ST I N B L A K E