Skip to main content

Edible Indy Winter 2026

Page 1

WINTER 2026

T H E S TO R I E S A N D C E L E B R AT I O N O F F O O D A N D D R I N K

Hoosier Hospitality E X P E C TAT I O N S S H I F T A S I N DY B E C O M E S A N U P - A N D - C O M I N G F O O D D E S T I N AT I O N M E M B E R

O F

E D I B L E

C O M M U N I T I E S


LET TER FROM THE EDITOR

The crackle and pop of a woodburning fire. The sound of a wine cork being pulled. Something delicious simmering on the stove. Snow falling outside, Christmas PUBLISHER Adam Grubb

EDITORIAL MANAGING EDITOR Stephanie Decker SENIOR EDITOR Bailey Shelton

ART | PRODUCTION CHIEF CREATIVE OFFICER Camila Schaefer DIRECTOR OF BRANDS Erik Anderson DESIGN Molly Tippner

music playing and a plate of freshly baked cookies that never stays full. These are the moments I love most about this season. I’ll admit it: I’m one of those people who actually wishes for snow during the holidays. There’s something magical about a winter wonderland, especially when you’re tucked inside with good food and people you love. And let’s be honest, the food might have a little something to do with my love of the holidays.

ADVERTISING | BUSINESS CHIEF OPERATING OFFICER Jennifer Cisternino Advertising queries: sales@adamgrubbmedia.com

Holiday dinners, rich desserts, Christmas cookies and all the sweet, buttery, gooey goodness. I fully intend to enjoy every bite, with absolutely no shame. Beyond the indulgences, though, it’s the way food brings us together

CONTRIBUTORS WRITERS Adam Grubb, Bailey Shelton, Julia Hockman, Claire Trost, Reba Toloday, Samantha Kupiainen PHOTOGRAPHERS Adam Grubb Media, Torrie Hudson, Michael Louis Schrader, Reba Toloday COVER PHOTO Michael Louis Schrader

that makes the season special. Extra chairs around the table, family recipes and conversations that linger long after dinner. That spirit of connection runs throughout this winter issue of Edible Indy. We explore the evolution of Hoosier hospitality, share a makeahead French holiday menu and uncover the science of seasoning. You’ll also find winter date night inspiration and the fascinating history of foods believed to bring good luck. Whether you’re hosting a holiday gathering, discovering a new restaurant

is a member of Edible Communities and is licensed and published by Adam Grubb Media. Published four times yearly in February, May, August and November. No part of this publication may be used without written permission of the publisher. © 2026 All Rights Reserved.

or sneaking another Christmas cookie (I’ll be right there with you), I hope you’ll savor every moment. Here’s to cozy nights, full plates, and a little holiday magic. And yes, snowflakes! (I said what I said) Stephanie Decker, Managing Editor, Edible Indy®

AdamGrubbMedia.com WINTER 2026 •

3


A Little Holiday Cheer A Lot of Seasonal Flavor

VISITBLOOMINGTON.COM


CONTENTS

Hoosier Hospitality Expectations Shift as Indy Becomes an Up-and-Coming Food Destination / 20

03

LETTER FROM THE EDITOR

06

COMMUNITY CALENDAR

09

WE THINK YOU’LL LIKE THIS Local Chef Picks for Favorite Holiday Dishes

10

FORKLORE The History of Foods That Bring You Luck

25

KITCHEN SCIENCE ’Tis the Science of Seasoning

26

THE FOUR TOP Top Comfort Food for Any Mood

30

HOLIDAY MENU A Cozy French Holiday Menu You Can Make Days Ahead

36

HATTIE’S COFFEE HOUSE

12

3 WINTER DATE NIGHT IDEAS FOR FOODIES

38

EDIBLE UPDATE

RECIPES

16

THE INTERVIEW A Conversation with Luz Ramirez

40 WHAT THE GRUBB? Your Holiday Party: My Prediction

Kir Royale 31

18

FEAST YOUR EYES

Fennel & Celery Salad 31 with Castelvetrano Olives and Lemon One-Day Cassoulet 31 Fontainebleau 34

Corrections Fall 2026: page 20, peanut parfait photo was taken by Sofie Dwyer; page 23, grasshopper pie photo was taken by Dave Pluimer.

WINTER 2026 •

5


E VENTS

Winterlights at Newfields PHOTO COURTESY OF VISIT INDY

EVENTS

HAMILTON COUNTY CARMEL WINTER FARMERS MARKET Saturdays, Now – March 27, 9am–noon The Six Eleven, Carmel, IN carmelfarmersmarket.com REINDEER EXPRESS November 14 – December 23, Select dates Nickel Plate Express, Noblesville, IN nickelplateexpress.com CHRISTKINDLMARKT November 21 – December 24, Closed Thanksgiving and Christmas Day Carmel Christkindlmarkt, Carmel, IN carmelchristkindlmarkt.com

6

• WINTER 2026

The Ice at Carter Green

THE ICE AT CARTER GREEN November 21, 2026 – January 31, 2027; Closed Thanksgiving and Christmas Day Carmel Christkindlmarkt, Carmel, IN theiceatcartergreen.com A MERRY PRAIRIE HOLIDAY AT CONNER PRAIRIE November 27 – December 28, Select dates Conner Prairie, Fishers, IN connerprairie.org

PHOTO COURTESY OF THE ICE AT CARTER GREEN

Community Calendar NOBLESVILLE DECK THE DOWNTOWN December 4 – 6 Downtown, Noblesville, IN noblesvillemainstreet.org WESTFIELD TREE LIGHTING CEREMONY December 5, 3–6pm Grand Junction Plaza, Westfield, IN westfieldin.gov SANTA SATURDAYS December 5 & 12, 2–5pm Santa’s House, Carmel, IN carmel.in.gov HO HO HO HOMICIDE EXPRESS December 16 & 17 at 6:30pm (21+) Nickel Plate Express, Noblesville, IN nickelplateexpress.com


INDIANAPOLIS PIZZA WEEK November 9 – 15 Various restaurants throughout Indianapolis, IN indianapolispizzaweek.patchboard.co BROAD RIPPLE WINTER FARMERS MARKET Saturdays, November through April Broad Ripple Middle School, Indianapolis, IN broadrippleindy.org CHRISTMAS NIGHTS OF LIGHTS AT INDIANA STATE FAIRGROUNDS November 6 – December 31 Indiana State Fairgrounds, Indianapolis, IN christmasnightsoflights.com INDY WINTERS FARMERS MARKET Saturdays, November 14, 2026 – April 24, 2027, Closed December 26 The AMP, Indianapolis, IN indywinterfarmersmarket.org A CHRISTMAS CAROL November 15 – December 24 Indiana Repertory Theatre, Indianapolis, IN irtlive.com JINGLE RAILS November 21, 2026 – January 18, 2027 Eiteljorg Museum, Indianapolis, IN eiteljorg.org

INDIANA BREWERS GUILD WINTERFEST February 13, 2027, 1–6pm Indiana State Fairgrounds, Indianapolis, IN drinkin.beer

CHRISTMAS AT THE ZOO November 21, 2026 – January 3, 2027; Closed Holidays Indianapolis Zoo, Indianapolis, IN indianapoliszoo.com DOCS ON DRAFT November 26, 5:30–6:30pm Guggman Haus Brewing Co., Indianapolis, IN guggmanhausbrewing.com BEEF & BOARDS CHRISTMAS November 26 – December 31 Beef & Boards, Indianapolis, IN beefandboards.com

Indiana Brewers Guild Winterfest

SOUPER BOWLS February 6, 11:30am–1:30pm Second Helpings, Indianapolis, IN secondhelpings.org

HOLIDAY LUNCH L.S. AYERS TEA ROOM November 27 – January 3, 2027 Indiana State Museum, Indianapolis, IN indianamuseum.org

FURTHER OUT

A LAWRENCE CHRISTMAS November 28, 2–6pm Lawrence Civic Plaza, Indianapolis, IN visitlawrenceindiana.com

FARMERS MARKET AT THE FAIRGROUNDS 1st & 3rd Saturdays, November through April Hancock County Fairgrounds, Greenfield, IN

SANTA’S HOLIDAY BREAKFAST November 29, December 5, 6, 13, & 19 Indiana State Museum, Indianapolis, IN indianamuseum.org

TONIC BALL November 20, 7p.m. Fountain Square, Indianapolis, IN tonicball.org Jingle Rails

PHOTO COURTESY OF INDIANA BREWERS GUILD

MARION COUNTY

DEVOUR INDY WINTERFEST Beginning January 2027 Various restaurants throughout Indianapolis, IN devourindy.com

WINTERLIGHTS AT NEWFIELDS November 20, 2026 – January 3, 2027 Newfields, Indianapolis, IN discovernewfields.org

3RD ANNUAL CHILI COOK-OFF November 14, 11am VetBuilt Garage, Jeffersonville, IN vetbuiltgarage.org

PHOTO COURTESY OF EITEL JORG MUSEUM

FIBRUARY FESTIVAL February 5 – 6 The Forum Event Center, Fishers, IN fibruaryindiana.com

HOLIDAY LIGHTING AND WINTER MARKET December 5 Downtown Franklin, Franklin, IN discoverdowntownfranklin.com BREAKFAST WITH SANTA December 12, 2 sessions: 8:30 & 10:30am Greenwood Community Center, Greenwood, IN greenwood.in.gov WINTER 2026 •

7


WE THINK YOU’LL LIKE THIS

we think you’ll like this Local chefs share the dishes they are looking forward to preparing this holiday season

DAVID CULI

LUKE LANDGREBE

MIGUEL HERNANDEZ

ADAN SANDOVAL

CORP OR ATE CHEF

E XECUTIVE CHEF

CHEF

E XECUTIVE CHEF

Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse

Harry & Izzy’s Northside

Mo’s A Place for Steaks

Commission Row

OYSTERS

CREAM CORN Growing up in a Latino household we have always enjoyed a mix of traditional Latin American and American food for Thanksgiving. I love experiencing the mix, but when I make our cream corn the whole family just goes crazy over it. It has become our favorite Thanksgiving Day side dish, to the point my nieces and nephews have shared leftovers with their friends, and I have their friends asking for more, or the recipe. It just makes the heart feel full inside.

Two dishes I look forward to making every year for Thanksgiving are oyster stuffing and Oysters Rockefeller. Growing up in South Florida, we ate a lot of fresh seafood throughout the years, and my mother would always make oyster stuffing when we couldn’t eat them all on the half shell. Since she wasn’t a fan of raw oysters, we always made Oysters Rockefeller for her. I tend to host Thanksgiving these days (might have something to do with my profession) and have incorporated these favorites along with the traditional Thanksgiving fare. It keeps them coming back every year.

LOBSTER MAC & CHEESE

APPLE PIE The one dish I never skip at Christmas is apple pie. For me, it brings back some of my favorite memories with my family. I remember going apple picking with my uncle and bringing the apples home to my aunt, who would turn them into a homemade pie completely from scratch. I loved helping her prepare it and knowing that the apples we had picked together were becoming something our family could enjoy. Even now, the smell and taste of apple pie remind me of those special moments with them.

Thanksgiving isn’t complete without a really good mac & cheese. But as a chef, I just have to make it extra by adding lobster. I love the combination of a rich, creamy cheese, perfectly cooked pasta, luxurious lobster and a golden, crispy breadcrumb topping that gives every bite a little crunch. It’s simple comfort food, but when it’s made right, it can be just as memorable as the turkey. The holidays are all about bringing people together over great food, and this is one dish I would never leave off my Thanksgiving table.

WINTER 2026 •

9


FORKLORE

10

• WINTER 2026


FORKLORE

T H E H I S T O R Y O F F O O D S T H AT

k c u L u o Y g n i r B WH Y C E R TA I N FO O D S A R E T H O U G H T TO B R I N G P R O S P E R IT Y A N D G O O D FO R T U N E TO T H O S E WH O E AT T H E M

Written by Samantha Kupiainen Sometimes, a little luck can be served right on your plate. Across cultures and generations, certain foods have become symbols of prosperity, abundance, and good fortune for the individual enjoying them. Whether you believe in superstition or simply enjoy the treat, these foods are a tasty way to welcome a little good fortune to the table. One of the oldest lucky foods you can get is king cake, which originated in 12th-century France as a way to celebrate the Epiphany, according to KingCake.com. Also known as Twelfth Night or King’s Day, the day that marks the arrival of the three wise men at the scene of Jesus’s birth. In present day, from Jan. 6 through Mardi Gras, cakes decorated with purple, green, and gold begin appearing in bakeries, signaling that Mardi Gras is approaching. The “king” in king cake is associated with the biblical three kings who visited Jesus, and a tiny plastic baby Jesus is hidden in king cakes. Finding the baby Jesus in the cake is associated

with luck, and also means that person is responsible for hosting the next king cake party or bringing the next cake. The cakes disappear by Ash Wednesday as the season of Lent approaches. Some of the most notable “luckiest” foods are black-eyed peas and collard greens, which are reserved for eating on New Years Day, especially for Southern families. According to Southern Living, eating black-eyed peas and collard greens on the first day of the new year is believed to invite good luck and health, as well as financial prosperity, into the lives of those who eat it. According to the Food Network, the real reason black-eyed peas and collard greens have become a symbol of good fortune dates back to African roots. In West Africa, black-eyed peas were seen as a good luck charm that could ward off evil spirits. During the Civil War, Union troops often overlooked black-eyed peas and greens, considering them food for livestock and livestock only.

That small detail ended up providing Confederate and enslaved families food to survive the harsh winter, turning the ingredients into a symbol of resilience and survival. In recent years, eating 12 grapes under a table at midnight on New Year’s Eve has become a viral social media trend that claims to attract luck as it relates to finding true love in the upcoming year. In actuality, the trend is built upon a century-old Spanish tradition that promises 12 months of good fortune and prosperity. Dating back to 19th century Madrid, the custom, known as las doce uvas de la suerte, or, “the 12 grapes of luck,” works by eating one grape each time the 12 o’clock bell chimes at midnight. According to AllRecipes, each grape represents one month in the upcoming year and allegedly secures your good fortune. From black-eyed peas and collard greens to grapes and king cakes, these lucky dishes carry traditions and stories that make them more than just something delicious to eat.

WINTER 2026 •

11


DATE NIGHTS

WINTE R DATE NIGHT IDEAS For Foodies Written by Julia Hockman It’s time to ditch the same old dinner-and-a-movie date night routine. When the weather gets cold and the family gatherings start piling up for the holidays, it can feel difficult to carve out special outings for your significant other. We’ve compiled three date night ideas that go beyond the basics to turn a typical night out into a scene straight out of a Hallmark movie. But of course, all of our picks are foodie-focused to ensure your evening together is as tasty as it is fun.

12

• WINTER 2026

PHOTO COURTESY OF MONTI


PHOTO COURTESY OF MONTI

PHOTO COURTESY OF BLUEBEARD

1. EXPLORE YOUR FAVORITE NEIGHBORHOOD WITH A PROGRESSIVE DINNER There’s something adventurous about a night out that unfolds in courses. Instead of committing to one restaurant, a progressive dinner lets you sample an entire neighborhood’s food scene. While you could map out a route in any neighborhood, we’ve selected Fountain Square for its walkable streets, eclectic ambiance, and restaurants made for lingering. We’ll start the night at Monti for aperitivo. Aperitivo is the Italian ritual of pre-dinner drinks and snacks to stimulate the appetite, making this the ideal precursor to your evening. Monti welcomes you with a select pour of aperitif to open your palate. The ample bar space and happy hour menu is built for grazing with spritzes, negronis, light bar snacks, small plates and more. Next up is dinner at Bluebeard, just a half mile down the road. With a menu that rotates almost daily, you might never have the same meal twice. You will always find seasonal variations of vegetable-focused meals and fresh, scratch-made pasta dishes, making it the perfect follow-up to aperitivo. Head next door for our final stop: Amelia’s for dessert. When cold winter nights call for a warm sweet treat,

PHOTO BY JULIA HOCKMAN

Amelia’s pastries, made fresh daily, are perfect. The bakery is open until 8pm nightly, with a mix of staples and specials that rotate semi-regularly. Their core menu features cookies, croissants, cinnamon rolls, brownies, and more. For a bit of an extended evening, add in a round of duckpin bowling, a show at the Hi-Fi, or a stroll through First Friday at the Murphy, which generally runs until 10pm.

2. BOOK A COUPLES CLASS FOR A HANDS-ON EXPERIENCE Nothing says quality time like learning something new together. A culinary class adds an element of teamwork to your night out, no matter what skill you’re looking to hone. It can also double as an experience-based gift idea for the holidays. At Sur La Table in Carmel, every cooking class is led by a chef instructor. There’s no shortage of options, whether you’re looking to try your hand as a French pastry chef, craft the perfect sushi roll, whip up a curry, or learn the art of a Tuscan dinner. The November and December class schedule is full of festive sessions including cookie making, harvest sweets, holiday feasts, classic comforts, and more.

WINTER 2026 •

13


For couples who love wine, up your vino knowledge in time for Thanksgiving at Westfield Wine Vault. They offer approachable wine classes with their 101 and Pour Decisions series. While you sip, learn about various wine regions and the nuances of how to taste and appreciate your next glass. Upcoming classes include pairings for holiday dishes and sweets, and a lesson in bubbly for the New Year.

IPHOTO COURTESY OF BLACK DOG BREWING CO.

To get behind the bar, head to Black Dog Brewing Co. in Fountain Square for a Beer or Mixology 101 class. Beer 101 provides an introduction to beer styles, tasting techniques, and the basics of brewing. Meanwhile, Mixology 101 teaches the fundamentals of spirits and cocktail making.

3. TURN UP THE HEAT WITH AT-HOME CULINARY CHALLENGES For those who don’t want to brave the cold, there are plenty of ways to cook up some creative connection at home. These competitions invite you to turn your kitchen into a pop-up bar or a mini test kitchen and put your skills to the test. For the mixologists: Each of you makes a drink for the other. You can either choose a handful of random spirits, mixers, and garnishes for the other to use mystery-box style, or agree on a shared stash of ingredients and see who comes up with the better drink. Set a time limit and score each other based on taste, creativity, and presentation. Whoever wins gets to choose your takeout order.

14

• WINTER 2026

PHOTO COURTESY OF SUR LA TABLE

For the chefs: Pick an assortment of pantry staples, proteins, and produce to build a dish around for each other. To add a twist, each partner gets to sneak in a few surprise ingredients for the other. The same rules apply: Agree on a time limit and scoring criteria ahead of time to choose a winner. The loser cleans up or plans the next date.

This season, escape the hustle and bustle together by exploring a new neighborhood, learning a new skill, or channeling your inner chef.


ROOTED IN INDIANA. DESIGNED TO INSPIRE. A T R I B U T E TO J E N N A I R ’ S I N D I A N A H E R I TAG E , T H I S B O L D S H OW RO O M K I TC H E N B L E N DS R I C H T E X T U R E S, S T R I K I N G A RC H I T E C T U R A L D E T A I L S A N D M O D E R N L U X U R Y. T H O U G H T F U L L Y D E S I G N E D B Y S H U E E ’ S TO S H O W C A S E T H E I N N O VAT I O N A N D C R A F T S M A N S H I P O F A B R A N D W I T H D E E P LO C A L R O OT S.

R O O T E D D E S I G N E D

I N

I N D I A N A .

T O

I N S P I R E .

A T R I B U T E T O J E N N A I R ’ S I N D I A N A H E R I TA G E , T H I S BOLD SHOWROOM KITCHEN BLENDS RICH TEXTURES , S T R I K I N G A R C H I T E C T U R A L D E TA I L S A N D M O D E R N L U X U R Y. T H O U G H T F U L LY D E S I G N E D B Y S H U E E ’ S T O S H O W C A S E T H E I N N O VAT I O N A N D C R A F T S M A N S H I P O F A BRAND WITH DEEP LOCAL ROOTS .

Showroom located at 96th & Gray Road in Indianapolis

WWW.SHUEES .COM WINTER 2026 •

15


THE INTERVIEW

THE INTERVIEW

A Conversation with Luz Gonza M A C I Z O R E S TA U R A N T Interview by Claire Trost / Photo by Claire Trost

PHOTO COURTESY OF LUZ GONZA

This interview has been edited for clarity and space. Find the full interview on edibleindy.com

They say marriage is much more than just the joining of two people; it brings together histories, cultures, and families while creating something entirely new. At the Indianapolis restaurant Macizo, Peruvian and Mexican traditions meet—not as some Luz Gonza and Omar Ramirez fancy new “fusion” of cuisines but rather as they might in a marriage. The menu is full of the dishes owners and chefs Omar Ramirez and Luz Gonza grew up eating, but also are shaped by their memories and experiences together as they turned their shared dream of owning a restaurant into reality. We caught up with Luz as the couple closes out a big 2026, which included national recognition with a James Beard Awards semifinalist nomination for Best Chef in the Great Lakes region. As we talked, it became clear that Macizo is not just a marriage of cultures. It is a combination of memory and creativity, warmth and ambition, tradition and a willingness to try something new.

16

• WINTER 2026

EDIBLE INDY: Macizo’s Instagram describes it as “a nostalgic tribute to your childhoods.” What does that mean to you? LUZ GONZA: Macizo is how we eat at home. I’m from Peru, Omar is from Mexico, and we’ve been married for a little over 10 years. We’ve learned to combine those flavors, but we also focus on what we used to eat as kids and what our moms used to cook. That doesn’t mean we don’t incorporate new things. As we’ve gone through life and had new experiences— whenever we go out to eat or try something different—we’ll say, “Oh, we can do this with this” or “What if we put this flavor in that?” EI: How do your Mexican and Peruvian backgrounds come together in the food? LG: It happens very naturally. For example, the first time Omar made tamales for us, I made salsa criolla, which is kind of like a Peruvian pico de gallo. It has onion, cilantro, lime and salt. He said “You don’t need that for tamales.” I said, “Try it.” EI: Tell me about a meal from your childhood that is on the menu. LG: Sopa Criolla is a humble Peruvian dish, but it is super tasty. Growing up, this was just a regular meal. I never


thought it was fancy enough to be shared. But when I made it for Omar, he said, “This has to be on our menu.” Omar likes things simple. I sometimes want to make things a little more elevated, and he’ll say, “Let’s be us. There are a lot of other restaurants already doing fancy things. Let’s give people something different.” EI: The food may be simple and humble, but it is also incredibly beautiful. Where does that visual instinct come from? LG: All the credit goes to Omar. He loves color. He loves music. When we eat at home, he does most of the cooking. He has always loved family-style meals, so he keeps the pots in the kitchen and says, “Dinner is ready. Come fix your plates.” I’ll fix my plate. Then Omar comes in five minutes later with this beautiful plate of exactly the same food, but it’s beautiful. And I’m, like, “I want that!” He says, “It’s the same.” I say, “No, it’s not!” He has this ability to take exactly the same food—super homey food—and make it look elevated. EI: You also received some major national recognition this year as a James Beard semifinalist. Congratulations! What was that experience like? LG: To be honest, that was something we never even dared to dream about. The day they announced the semifinalists, we didn’t even know the announcement was happening. It was just a regular day for us. Then we got a text message from Youseff Boudarine, a friend and one of the founders of Epicurean Indy: “Congratulations, guys. You made it on the James Beard list.” I read it and thought, “Maybe this is a cruel mistake. Maybe he meant to send it to somebody else.” About five minutes later, we started getting calls from people congratulating us and people trying to make reservations. It was completely unexpected. EI: What are you looking toward in 2027? LG: We accomplished a lot this year, including the recognition.

But when we opened Macizo, we literally only had tables, chairs, and settings on the tables. That was it. Because of everybody’s support, we’ve been able to add new things to the restaurant—the lights, the plants, the waiting area, the pictures. EI: I love the gallery wall in the restaurant. Tell me about the art. LG: We have a daughter. She’s 10 years old. When we first opened, all the walls were empty. My husband said, “We’re going to put our daughter’s drawings here.” So we did. EI: It’s very special to showcase her art. What does that mean to you, especially with the tagline that it’s a nostalgic place for childhood memories? LG: She’s an amazing artist, and I love that wall because I really feel like it reflects who we are as a family through our daughter’s eyes. Which, in my opinion, is the most honest vision. She really likes to tell our story.

WINTER 2026 •

17


FE AST YOUR E YES

FEAST YOUR EYES

MONTERREY COASTAL CUISINE 110 W. Main St., Suite 135, Carmel, IN @montereycuisine montereycuisine.com

Photos by Torrie Hudson @torriehudson

BLUEFIN TORO CONES Decadent sushi cones are a fun specialty item featuring fresh tuna and hamachi with exciting flavors. They’re a fun, fresh starter to get the table started.

18

• WINTER 2026


CALIFORNIA ROLL Traditional sushi rolled in seaweed and rice, filled with crab, avocado, and cucumber.

HA M ACHI CITRUS SASHIMI Yellowtail, avocado, tropical pico, and spicy ponzu sauce.

FEAST YOUR EYES

EARL GREY OLD FASHIONED Backbone prime bourbon, Angostura bitters, orange bitters, and house-made Earl Grey simple syrup.

WINTER 2026 •

19


COVER FE ATURE

HOOSIER HOSPITALIT Y

Expectations Shift as Indy Becomes an Up-and-Coming Food Destination Written by Bailey Shelton / Photo by Michael Louis Schrader

20

• WINTER 2026

Vida PHOTO BY MICHAEL LOUIS SCHRADER


A power outage leaves a restaurant in Chatham Arch in the dark leading up to the dinner service, so the front-ofhouse staff call each reservation to either reschedule or get them a table at a sister restaurant. One man thinks the restaurant should abide by their own cancellation fee policy, but in reverse. “One star: They should have paid me the cancellation fee.” A guest is upset because she’s supposedly at a fine-dining restaurant but there’s no stool for her purse in the crowded dining room. “One star: I had to put my purse on the ground.” It’s pouring rain, the road to the restaurant is under construction, and it’s been a long, hard day in uncomfortable shoes. One guest almost turned around and went home, but she pushed through to meet her reservation. Now, the staff is giving her extra attention to overcome the bad mood. These are the guests that stick in the memories of restaurateurs as they train their staff. Indianapolis has begun to garner global attention as an up-and-coming foodie destination: Last year the city earned seven James Beard Award nominations; this year the World Food Championships returned for a third time; and next year, Indianapolis restaurants will become eligible for Michelin stars. But a raised bar means higher expectations. Restaurants are left to wonder how they’ll measure up.

SETTING THE STANDARD OF SERVICE Restaurants around Indianapolis are already starting to gain recognition for stellar menus and service. At Monti in Fountain Square, the view from the front door has been dominated by traffic cones for most of their first year of operation. Executive Chef and GM Francesco Settanni credits their employee-focused philosophy for overcoming factors out of their control. “Restaurants right now may be the only place where you can really get the human connection,” said Settanni. “This was always the intention of our hospitality experience, since day one.” Monti Shift Lead Geena Enriquez has experienced that staff culture first-hand; although she’s worked in Indianapolis hospitality for over six years, Monti is the first restaurant

where she’s felt this connected to the position. When they received an OpenTable Diners’ Choice, she toasted along with the team. When Monti was invited to the annual Best Restaurants event via Indianapolis Monthly, Enriquez posed in front of the photo backdrop alongside chefs Trey Christianson, Nate Miller, and Settanni. “Because we care so much about what we’re doing here and what the kitchen’s putting out, it makes you want to be hospitable to everybody,” said Enriquez. “To be eight months old and have gotten the feedback that we get, it’s just incredible.” Across town in Lockerbie, Vida is one of the best-known upscale dining options in the city. Executive Chef Thomas Melvin sets high expectations for what he describes as a “chef-led” menu. With a diverse list of imported wines and ready-for-harvest greenery from a live CRG Grow wall, those expectations are felt throughout the restaurant, and consistency is key. “There are times when things are very tight, but that goes back to having a team in the front who love food, who are experienced, and who are very adaptable,” said General Manager and Wine Director Jared May. May hones his skills every week with other sommeliers for a regular tasting session, and he spends his nights off from Vida trying new restaurants around the city. His continued commitment to the craft led to a semifinalist designation as a James Beard Outstanding Beverage Professional in 2026, one of seven semifinalists around the city this year. In Woodruff Place, Beholder owner and Sommelier Josh Mazanowski, alongside his business partner Chef Jonathan Brooks, built their mystic concept around the experience of the space. Jewel tones and cloak-and-dagger motifs wrap around a chef’s table and curated menu. Mazanowski’s philosophy on dining focuses on the dynamic among the service team. According to him, if the front of house and back of house are working together, diners can feed off of that synergy. “What I do want to accomplish with both of my restaurants, Beholder and Lone Pine, is to build good teams—good players in the restaurant game—and create service that is personable, knowledgeable, and, when called for, fun.” This focus on the service team has consistently landed

WINTER 2026 •

21


Beholder on “best of” lists, and earned them recognition as a James Beard Award semifinalist in 2025. He feels diners have relaxed more than anything in the six years since Covid arrived. “I’m a firm believer that great food is universal. Someone shouldn’t have to tell you that something is good; you will know,” said Mazanowski. “Very similarly, that’s how I think wine pairings should work. You will know!”

THE RETURN TO CHEF CULTURE The year is 2022, and cheffing is back in vogue. Beyond being the show that sold one million white T-shirts, “The Bear” redefined how diners came to the table. Since then, callouts to Carmi’s take on hospitality appear even in reviews for Indianapolis restaurants. The phenomenon spurred an op-ed in Food & Wine from Michelin-star restaurateur and Indiana native John Winterman last November. Winterman got his start from Chicago’s Charlie Trotter, then eventually opened his first Michelin restaurant, Batard, in New York. His latest project, Francie, also earned a star in the Michelin Guide. He contends that “The Bear,” and its partial inspiration, New York Times bestseller Unreasonable Hospitality by Will Guidara, has created unreasonable expectations for diners. “I just feel like the idea of competent service is sort of being cast aside for this notion of restaurants being able to do magic tricks for you.” Winterman thinks of extra-mile expenses like a free dessert for birthdays in terms of return. If something is given away for free, it doesn’t cover the cost of the pastry chef, or the ingredients, or the real estate cost of the table the guest occupies. Instead, they offer a birthday cake as a special order, or a cake cutting fee if someone brings in their own. “Can you imagine dragging your rowing machine down to your local gym and not paying the membership fee but expecting to use their studio space to do your workout?” said Winterman. “I know it sounds harsh and financial, but that’s just the reality for restaurants.” In April, the Michelin Guide announced that they’d be expanding to the Great Lakes region for 2027. Restaurants in Cleveland, Pittsburgh, Milwaukee, Detroit, and Indianapolis would be eligible to earn stars for the first time.

22

• WINTER 2026

“I think people have a lot of misconceptions about Michelin,” said Winterman. “If some stars get distributed in Indianapolis, you’ve gotta learn to manage guest expectations because they will get ramped up. Once you get it, the worst couple of weeks are right after you get it, because everyone is going to come in and complain.” For May, a taste of that has already come to Vida, which sports a host of James Beard accolades and a 4.9-star record on OpenTable. “Guests see the review and come in with super high expectations, because everyone says this is a great restaurant and they had a great experience, and all these things that were great, great, great so they come in expecting greatness,” said May. The culture of their kitchen already comes at a high standard. With each guest averaging around $180, and many of their reservations coming from celebrations, Vida always has to operate on the assumption that this is an important dinner for everyone at the table. “At Vida, I try to encourage the team to never take for granted our guests choosing to dine with us. There are a thousand restaurants downtown, and they only have one 50th wedding anniversary in their lives, and they choose us,” said May. “That kind of honor they’re giving us, it deserves our very best efforts.” May read Guidara’s Unreasonable Hospitality before it broke containment to every industry as a guidepost for business. He said the comparison comes up often in the Vida dining room—sometimes for good, sometimes bad. “The kind of culture described in the book is a very unique concept and culture for a restaurant just based on how they operate and where they’re at,” May said. “Now what is similar is the people in leadership and the people working in all roles can understand the philosophy Will is working with and his approach to guest interaction.” One night, a diner asked if they carried an Italian Chardonnay from Jermann called Where Dreams Have No End. Although it wasn’t on their wine list, May knew a sister location had the bottle. Using a fortunate pad of time, he drove to the other restaurant, brought the coveted bottle back to Vida, and uncorked it at the table. Another diner saw the interaction and flagged May down.


Monti

PHOTO BY BAILEY SHELTON

“Because we care so much about what we’re doing here and what the kitchen’s putting out, it makes you want to be hospitable to everybody.” —GEENA ENRIQUEZ, shift lead at Monti

They’d just read Unreasonable Hospitality and thought May followed all the traits the book outlined. But the book has also been used as an example of what Vida is not. Earlier this year, they lost power to their kitchen and dining room in a neighborhood-wide blackout. They did their best to reschedule guests or get them tables at other Cunningham restaurants around the city on a last-minute notice. Vida has a cancellation fee for diners, which they didn’t charge that night, and they generally waive for reservations who call with extenuating circumstances, be it a bailed babysitter or a flat tire. He calls it operating in good faith, that customers are trying their best to make the reservation. One customer from the blackout night said that Vida didn’t live up to the creed he’d read about in Unreasonable Hospitality. He wanted compensation for the cancellation, their fee in reverse. “That was a kind of disappointing thing to experience,” said May. “Maybe we could have done more. But my understanding of hospitality is that we assume they’re trying their best, and it’s discouraging to know we’re not receiving the same.”

Settanni has seen similar situations as Monti works through their first year. A copy of Unreasonable Hospitality sits on a coffee table next to their front door, and Settanni held a pre-shift meeting around Winterman’s article when it first came out in Food & Wine. “Back in the day, in New York City, going out to feed the meter was normal. Now those gestures are well received, but the expectation is to show unreasonable hospitality to everyone,” said Settanni. “The economy is also a factor. People value their dollar way more than even five years ago. When you go out and spend $20 on pasta, it better be worthwhile.” From Mazanowski’s perspective, Unreasonable Hospitality talks about extreme examples of what is generally common sense and good manners. Mazanowski mentioned these same basic rules of service align with what he was taught at the beginning of his career in Seattle in the 2000s. “Be one step ahead, anticipate needs, and take care of people without making a big production out of it.” For Mazanowski, Guidara’s concept of employee ownership really rings true at his restaurants. He said, “Bartenders in Indianapolis are probably the best example of that. They’re some of the best parts of restaurants for me because they

WINTER 2026 •

23


are asked to be creative, and a lot depends on them and their relationship to the program.”

for a raised minimum wage for staff, Settanni believes Indianapolis restaurants can work toward completely fueling their menu from locally sourced ingredients.

FOODIE DESTINATION: INDIANAPOLIS

“The fact that we are a city surrounded by farms and you see Sysco trucks all over the city… now is the right time. We have a chance to change,” said Settanni.

Three years ago, Youssef Boudarine joined forces with other big names in Indianapolis dining to create Epicurean Indy, a festival celebrating global food in the heartland. Boudarine grew up in Morocco and cheffed in France before coming to Indiana, and he noticed a closed-off nature for both diners and hospitality owners. Epicurean Indy encourages curiosity for guests and restaurants alike. “The real question we push is ‘Who is cooking your food?’” said Boudarine. “Whatever we work through, we always try to invite the people who don’t have a platform or never have a chance to be invited.” In the three years since, the organization has grown beyond the annual festival; they collaborated on a chocolate festival, Mokao, which is back for a second year in 2026. This year they also launched a localized restaurant week called Now Serving, and they partnered with Chreece and First Friday in Fountain Square to expand the reach of the annual global food festival. This past October, they hosted a third annual dinner in support of the James Beard Foundation at the Alexander. Epicurean brought together chefs and sommeliers from around the city. A group of diners from Chicago discovered the event online and drove down specifically for the dinner.

But Epicurean Indy also aims at keeping people in Indianapolis, rather than losing talent and community to other cities. For Boudarine, Hoosier hospitality is both a reason for travelers to visit, and a reason for locals to stay. “The more people that move here, the more that culture grows,” said Boudarine. “If you don’t have local people here supporting your businesses, there’s no way they’ll survive. The visitors will always find ways to eat.” Mazanowski has similar hopes as Indy and other smaller markets come into their own as food destinations. “I think we as chefs and restaurateurs have an opportunity to present an alternate version of food culture—one that expands palates and encourages people to explore new foods, flavors, and tastes,” Mazanowski said.

“Usually people here will go up to Chicago for the weekend then come back, so having these guests discover us and come down, for me, was a big deal.”

Meanwhile, for Enriquez, working at Monti has meant feeling like she has a front row seat to watch her community grow. She feels inspired to try new places on her night off.

One of the goals of Epicurean Indy is to grow Indianapolis as a destination for diners, and in this they are aligned with their partners at Visit Indy. As the city grows, Boudarine believes the city should embrace what makes it unique rather than trying to mimic larger markets.

“I just think it’s really nice to bring a sense of culture to this area,” said Enriquez. “I’ve never seen Italian done like this in Indianapolis; I’ve never seen anything like Bodhi, popping off with their Thai dinners. Seeing all of these different fusions and cultures is a really nice change.”

“We live in a farm state, but we don’t have many farm-totables, for example,” said Boudarine. “I see people driving three to five hours for farm-to-table in New York or Chicago. It doesn’t make sense to me.”

Diners in Indianapolis have a similar opportunity to Enriquez. Chefs are starting to embrace new opportunities in ingredients, community, and diner experience. As the city continues to grow, the potential means a lot more is on the menu.

Embracing Indiana’s agricultural history is a major aspect of Settanni’s goals for the future. Along with advocating

24

Alongside the announcement of Michelin’s expansion to the Great Lakes region, Visit Indy President and CEO Leonard Hoops said, “having personally seen Indianapolis’ dining experiences elevate during the past 15 years, I welcome this opportunity to shine a brighter light on Indy’s culinary creativity, authenticity, and overall excellence.”

• WINTER 2026


KITCHEN SCIENCE

KITCHEN SCIENCE

’Tis the Science of Seasoning THE SCIENCE BEHIND CAST IRON, AND THE DIFFERENCE IT MAKES IN THE LONG RUN Written by Claire Trost Cast-iron skillets and griddles seem to appear on every “foodie” home cook gift guide around the holidays. And, for good reason: A cast-iron skillet is one of the best tools to have in the kitchen. But, want our recommendation? Get it out from under the tree and put it to use for all your holiday cooking. A cast-iron skillet holds onto an impressive amount of thermal energy and it radiates that heat steadily, not dropping in temperature even when something cool enters the pan. This makes cast iron great at creating the deep sear and crisp edges we want from holiday food like large cuts of meat, golden breads and biscuits, and crispy vegetables. Cast iron takes longer to heat up than a lighter pan like copper or steel, but once it gets hot, it has that superior heat retention. This means a dish cooked in cast iron will stay warm longer once it hits the table or family buffet line. Cast iron’s surface is naturally rough and porous, and heating a small amount of oil in the pan triggers a chemical process called polymerization.

The oil bonds to the surface and transforms it into a hard, protective coating that helps create a naturally nonstick surface, often called “seasoning.” The seasoning protects the iron from moisture and rust. And unlike a delicate chemical nonstick finish, the seasoning actually improves with each use. So, every time you cook with oil or fat, you’re helping build that protective layer making cooking, cleaning, and care much easier. Speaking of easy: One of the best things about cast iron at the holidays, when oven and counter space is precious and the last thing anyone wants to do is more dishes? Cast-iron skillets can move from stovetop to oven without changing pans. The cook can sear a pork tenderloin, then finish it in the oven and only one dish is dirty. A true gift! But, cast iron isn’t just cooking chemistry. It can also set the tone and serve as an aesthetic tool for baked goods like a Dutch baby, cinnamon rolls, or a fruit crisp. Serve these items straight from the skillet after baking for a rustic, family-style presentation that will look straight out of Christmas Past at your holiday table.

WINTER 2026 •

25


THE FOUR TOP

TOP COMFORT FOOD FOR ANY MOOD E VERY ISSUE , THE FOUR TOP SHOWCASES FOUR TOP-NOTCH CULINARY FINDS R A N G I N G F R O M R E C I P E S TO R E S TAU R A N T S TO CO C K TA I L S … A N D M U C H M O R E . Written by Julia Hockman

The Eagle PHOTO COURTESY OFTHE EAGLE

26

• WINTER 2026


During the holidays, comfort food starts feeling less like a rare indulgence and more like a nostalgic staple. We start craving the classics, a table to linger at, and the smell of home cooking in the air. Luckily, you don’t have to spend all day in the kitchen to get that same experience. These are our picks for the season’s top destinations that transport you right back to your favorite festive table—no apron required.

1.

THE EAGLE MASS AVE FOR SOUTHERN FRIED CHICKEN

310 Massachusetts Ave., Indianapolis

The Eagle Mass Ave is known for house-brined fried chicken served with spicy hot honey, along with Southern sides. Diners, be warned: Patrons should expect a bit more heat than a typical turkey dinner. Almost every item on the menu comes with a little something extra, whether it’s a delicious topping, sauce, or jam. Plus, if you’re looking for the best mac ’n’ cheese in Indy, this restaurant should be on your short list. The spoonbread and hush puppies are other standout sides. Apart from the fried chicken, there’s an array of snacks, salads, and sandwiches. You can expect a lively, blues-filled atmosphere with craft beer, cocktails, and mocktails to round out the menu. To transform The Eagle into your own holiday table, the restaurant offers a family meal for parties of six or more. The menu includes family-style portions of salad, sides, and, of course, fried chicken.

PHOTO COURTESY OF SAHM’S HOSPITALITY

eaglerestaurant.com

Sahm’s Place

2.

SAHM’S PLACE FOR VARIETY

2411 E. 65th St., Indianapolis

sahmsplace.com

PHOTO COURTESY OFTHE EAGLE

Sahm’s Place has been a staple of the Broad Ripple neighborhood for decades, and for good reason. It’s a master class in true Midwestern cuisine: oversized pork tenderloins will remind you of home, fried chicken dinners are served weekly on Sundays, and multiple styles of meatloaf will satisfy any craving. Sahm’s Place goes beyond comfort food with a massive menu spanning everything from pasta to stir fry to quesadillas.

The Eagle

The extensive sides menu has all the hits, including mac ’n’ cheese, baked potatoes, mashed potatoes and gravy, cornbread casserole, seasonal vegetables, and hot honey Brussels sprouts. This time of year, no meal is complete without a warm dessert. Sahm’s Place is known for its coffee cake, but you can’t go wrong with bread pudding, peach crumble, or a fudge brownie. WINTER 2026 •

27


3.

THE LOFT AT TRADER’S POINT CREAMERY FOR UPSCALE FARM-TO-TABLE

9101 Moore Rd., Zionsville, IN

Settled on a working farm and dairy barn, The Loft sources from its own pastures and other local partners. The rotating menu is inspired by the 150 acres surrounding the restaurant: cheese boards from the creamery’s own wheels, yeast rolls and entrees that lean into the season. Think farmhouse staples like root vegetables, roasted chicken, fish, grass-fed filet, and herb-fromage mashed potatoes. Chef Christian Cline studied at the Culinary Institute of America in Napa, California, where local internships led him to his passion for local sourcing and farm-to-table cooking.

PHOTO COURTESY OF TRADER’S POINT CREAMERY

traderspointcreamery.com

The Loft at Trader’s Point Creamery

4.

HIS PLACE EATERY FOR UNIQUE SOUL FOOD

6916 E. 30th St., Indianapolis + 1411 W. 86th St., Indianapolis

hisplaceeatery.com

PHOTO COURTESY OF HIS PLACE

His Place brings fresh twists to homestyle classics. The husband-and-wife owners, James and Shawn Jones, built a menu that reimagines down-home staples to create dishes you won’t find anywhere else. Specialties include red velvet chicken and waffles, collard greens grilled cheese, bourbon peach burgers, and fried chicken pot pie. An entire section of the menu is dedicated to house-whipped butter, with flavors including strawberry, sweet potato, peach, and orange ginger to top your waffles or cornbread.

His Place

His Place also shines for its soul food options, with many variations of catfish, pork chops, fried bologna, and a full stack of smokehouse and barbecue meats. There’s no shortage of Southern sides and sweet treats to complete your meal.

No matter where the season takes you or what craving hits, these spots feel like a true home away from home when you’re looking for the warm, familiar taste of comfort food. Whether you’re craving your usual favorites, something different, a curated selection, or a little bit of everything, these restaurants will have you and your family covered all winter long. 28

• WINTER 2026


YOUR NEXT EVENT COULD USE A LITTLE

COMPETITION Stick & Hack is a seriously fun mix of great food, cold drinks, golf and racing sims, darts and flexible event spaces. From corporate gigs and team parties to birthdays, sponsor events, and full-space buyouts, it’s made for groups that want to do more than just show up.

FISHERS • BROAD RIPPLE • WESTFIELD

BOOK YOUR NEXT EVENT WINTER 2026 •

29


RECIPES

h c n e r F y z A Co u n e M y a Holid

YO U C A N M A KE DAYS A HE A D

Written and Photographed by Reba Toloday

R I CH C A S S O U LE T, A PU N CH Y FENNEL AND OLIVE SAL AD, AND A CLOUD -LIKE FRENCH D E S S E R T, A LL M A D E A HE A D F O R A N E A S Y H O L I D AY DINNER. ’Tis the season for crowded tables and even more crowded calendars. When the holiday season hits, even home-cooking fans will find themselves stretched for time when it comes to prepping big meals. This year, I’m planning ahead. A make-ahead menu that doesn’t skimp on quality makes a big holiday impression and, most importantly, gives you the best gift of all on the day of the meal: time. This French-inspired menu kicks off with a norecipe-cocktail Kir Royale, a festive and gorgeous start to your meal. The centerpiece of the meal is the impressive but easily-made-ahead cassoulet—a dish layered with both history and flavor. It’s paired with a sharp, crunchy salad that takes all of 15 minutes to make (but could easily be made up to a day ahead) and a simple, light, and airy Fontainebleau for dessert—layers of crème fraîche and whipped cream drizzled with jam. This cozy meal serves up to 10 people and is one that I’m keeping in my back pocket for those busy days ahead when the in-laws are coming, the seats are multiplying, and the appetites are growing. 30

• WINTER 2026


KIR ROYALE

Kosher salt

This easy two-ingredient cocktail is the perfect way to kick off a holiday meal. No need to plan ahead, no measuring required: Simply pick up a bottle of crème de cassis (black currant liqueur) and a few bottles of dry sparkling wine (Champagne if you have it!) and before you know it, there’s a celebratory toast underway!

Black pepper

One bottle of sparkling wine makes about five cocktails, easily multiplied. INGREDIENTS ½ ounce crème de cassis 4½ ounces dry (brut) Champagne or other sparkling wine INSTRUCTIONS In a champagne flute or wine glass, pour the cassis first, then add the wine slowly. The bubbles mix it for you, so there’s no need to stir.

FENNEL & CELERY SALAD WITH CASTELVETRANO OLIVES AND LEMON This crisp, punchy salad is the perfect foil to the rich cassoulet. The entire salad comes together in about 15 minutes, but can easily be made up to a day ahead and assembled in less than five minutes. Serves 8–10 INGREDIENTS 1 bunch celery 2 medium (or 1 large) fennel bulbs 1 cup pitted and chopped Castelvetrano olives 1 large lemon 1 cup shaved Parmesan cheese

Extra virgin olive oil INSTRUCTIONS Trim ends of celery and chop into ¼-inch pieces. Add to a large bowl. Repeat with fennel: Remove the core and stem/fronds (if attached), slicing into ¼-inch pieces. Add to bowl. Add olives and toss to combine. When ready to eat: Halve the lemon and squeeze both halves over the celery, fennel, and olive mixture. Season with kosher salt, a few cranks of black pepper, and Parmesan cheese. Drizzle with extra virgin olive oil to taste and toss to combine. Taste for seasoning and adjust as desired with additional lemon juice, salt, or pepper. Transfer to a serving bowl. Leftovers keep well for up to a day. Make ahead: Combine chopped fennel, celery, and olives in a bowl and cover with a damp kitchen towel. Store in the refrigerator for up to 24 hours ahead of eating. When ready to serve, dress as directed above.

ONE-DAY CASSOULET Cassoulet is a hearty French stew, born in the south of France and now enjoyed worldwide. It’s a common staple in France—you can find it at bistros, family gatherings, and village feasts. In fact, it’s so commonplace that the French often simply pick up a can of cassoulet at their local grocery store and heat it on the stove for a weeknight meal. In the U.K. and the U.S., however, cassoulet has a reputation as fullfledged “project cooking.” Multiple

Fennel & Celery Salad

days, multiple ingredients—the authentic ones often hard to find— have made this a dish that many home cooks challenge themselves to make. The heft of the recipe aside, what appeals to me most about this specialoccasion recipe is how it only gets better with time. Like any good stew or casserole, it benefits from a day or two in the fridge: The flavors deepen, and everything melds together and gets cozy and delicious. An added benefit is that you can parcel out the recipe prep in the week before the meal, and wow your friends and family when you only need 90 minutes to get your holiday dinner on the table. I’ve broken this recipe into three sections with make-ahead guidance for each. The entire recipe (up to serving steps) can be done in one big afternoon of cooking if you desire— allow approximately six hours from start to finish, plus an overnight soak for the beans. On the day of, allow for 90 minutes of cooking time prior to serving. Serves 8–10 WINTER 2026 •

31


Make ahead: If desired, you can cook the beans up to four days ahead. Allow them to cool slightly on the stove, then put into smaller containers and store in their cooking liquid in the fridge. If you don’t have enough liquid to cover them, add some stock or water to ensure they remain submerged; this will keep them from drying out.

For the Pork Ragu INGREDIENTS 1½-pound boneless pork shoulder (Boston butt), cut into 1-inch chunks 2 teaspoons kosher salt One-Day Cassoulet

½ teaspoon black pepper 2 tablespoons vegetable oil

For the Beans INGREDIENTS 16 ounces dried cannellini beans, soaked overnight, drained 1 large onion, peeled and cut in half pole-to-pole 8 ounces pancetta (one big 1-inch piece—ask the deli counter to slice it for you) 2 carrots, peeled and halved crosswise 1 head garlic, halved crosswise 4 sprigs fresh thyme 1 bay leaf 1 teaspoon black pepper 2 teaspoons kosher salt INSTRUCTIONS Plan ahead: The beans need to soak overnight, so start them the night before you plan to cook them. Place the dried beans in a large bowl and cover with cold water by at least 2 inches (they’ll roughly double in size). Leave them on the counter overnight,

32

• WINTER 2026

then drain and rinse before cooking. Short on time? Use the quick-soak method: Cover the beans with water in a pot, bring to a boil for 2 minutes, then remove from the heat, cover, and let sit for 1 hour before draining.

2 large carrots, peeled and chopped into ¾-inch chunks

In a large pot (no less than 6 quarts), combine onion halves, beans, pancetta, carrots, garlic, thyme, and bay leaf. Add cold water and cover the beans by at least 2 inches. Season with a few cranks of pepper and bring to a gentle simmer. Partially cover the pot and cook the beans, adding more water if they are no longer submerged. After about 30 minutes, add salt (don’t add it at the beginning; it can make the beans tough) and continue cooking for another 30 minutes, or until beans are tender with just a little bite to them. Go fishing for the onion, carrots, thyme, garlic, and bay leaf and discard. Pull pancetta out of the pot and chop into ¼-inch pieces. Add back to bean pot and set aside for now.

1 bay leaf

1 large onion, peeled and diced 4 cloves garlic, finely chopped 4 sprigs fresh thyme 2 tablespoons tomato paste ½ cup dry white wine 1 (14½-ounce) can crushed tomatoes 6 cups chicken stock or low-sodium chicken broth 2 tablespoons vegetable oil 1 pound sweet Italian sausage 1 pound precooked garlic kielbasa sausage, cut into ¼-inch-thick slices INSTRUCTIONS Season the cut-up pork shoulder with about 2 teaspoons of kosher salt and a few cranks of black pepper. Heat 2 tablespoons oil in a Dutch oven or other heavy-bottomed pot over medium-high heat and, working in batches, cook the pork until nice and


browned all over (does not need to be cooked through). As pieces brown, transfer to a paper-towel-lined plate. Once pork is browned, reduce heat to medium and add onion, carrots, and garlic to the pot. Season with more salt and pepper. Cook, stirring occasionally with a wooden spoon, until vegetables have softened and are starting to brown, about 8–10 minutes. Add tomato paste and stir until it slightly darkens and starts to stick to the bottom of the pot. Add ½ cup of white wine to the hot pot and allow to deglaze, using the wooden spoon to scrape up all the brown fond on the bottom of the pot. Return browned pork pieces to pot and add thyme, bay, crushed tomatoes, and chicken stock. Bring to a boil and then reduce heat, partially cover pot, and simmer gently until meat is forktender, about 1½ to 2 hours. Remove thyme and bay leaf and let cool slightly. Once slightly cooled, use a slotted spoon to transfer the beans and pancetta into the pork mixture. Reserve the bean liquid—do not throw it away! In a separate medium skillet, heat 2 tablespoons vegetable oil over medium heat until shimmering. Prick sweet Italian sausages all over and cook in the skillet, turning occasionally until browned and cooked through—about 15 minutes. Transfer to a paper-towellined plate and let cool slightly, then cut into 2-inch chunks. Add the sliced kielbasa and cooked Italian sausage to the pork mixture. Stir to combine. Make ahead: Once you’ve added the beans and sausages to the braised pork, you can cool the mixture and

refrigerate for up to two days before final assembly.

The Rest INGREDIENTS 3–4 confit duck legs*, meat shredded off the bones 3 tablespoons olive oil 5 cups medium-fine fresh breadcrumbs (see note) or 4 cups plain untoasted panko breadcrumbs ¼ cup finely chopped flat-leaf parsley INSTRUCTIONS *When I first made this dish, I confited my own duck legs. I love project cooking and DIY duck confit is a time-consuming but easy project. Luckily for all of us, if we don’t feel like spending a few hours getting the fat out of duck legs, there’s a really good chance your local grocery store or butcher has ready-to-go duck confit. And if it doesn’t? Well, there’s the internet. I found mine for about $12 each at my local grocery. It’s a luxury for sure, but a must for this meal. If you want to DIY, here’s the recipe I used. A note on breadcrumbs: One of the best parts of cassoulet is the crunchy herb-flecked crust that adorns the top. I’ve provided two options for breadcrumbs, and if you opt for a soft fresh variety over the panko, I recommend you make your own. The easiest way to get there is to buy a loaf of “Italian” bread at your local grocery deli, trim the crust, cut into roughly same-sized chunks, and give them a whir in the food processor until they are the size of peas or smaller. If you’re making everything in one day, first transfer the pork-and-bean

mixture to a large bowl and wipe out the pot. In a large (7¼-quart or larger) Dutch oven, heat 3 tablespoons olive oil over medium heat, then add breadcrumbs. Stir constantly until all breadcrumbs are evenly coated in fat and just starting to toast/darken in color. Once there, transfer to a sheet tray or shallow bowl, toss with chopped parsley, and set aside. Turn off the heat, let the pot cool slightly, then wipe it out with paper towels. In the now-empty pot, add one-third of the pork-and-bean mixture and half of the duck meat. Top with another third of the pork and beans and top with remaining duck. Finally, top with remaining pork and beans. The liquid should come just to the top of the beans; add reserved bean cooking liquid if needed to ensure a stewy consistency. You’ve done it! Consider your cassoulet assembled. You can refrigerate this overnight and pull it out of the fridge about an hour before baking to take the chill off. About 90 minutes before you want to eat: Preheat the oven to 325°F. Scatter two-thirds of the breadcrumbs over the cassoulet and gently press down into the liquid using the back of a spoon. Bake uncovered until a golden crust forms, about 30 minutes. Gently break up the crust and again press down with the back of a spoon to slightly submerge the breadcrumbs. Bake for another 15 minutes. Top with the remaining third of the breadcrumbs and bake one more time until golden brown, about 15 minutes. Let rest at least 15 minutes before serving. Serve with the fennel salad and a good-quality loaf of crusty bread.

WINTER 2026 •

33


YOUR

Make −Ahead GAME PLAN

Most of the work happens days before the party. Day-of, it’s mostly oven time. Up to Five Days Before: Shop and Soak • Buy the duck confit and the dry goods. Ask the deli counter for your 1-inch piece of pancetta.

Fontainebleau

• The night before you cook the beans, put them in a bowl to soak overnight.

FONTAINEBLEAU Keeping with the French theme, the Fontainebleau is a tribute to dairy: a four-ingredient mousse-like treat that takes all of 20 minutes to put together. The traditional recipe uses fromage blanc as the fresh cheese, but I’ve swapped it out for the easier-to-find (and tangier) crème fraîche. I like to serve it slightly flavored with vanilla and offer a variety of jams to drizzle and dollop on top. Serves 8–10 INGREDIENTS 8 ounces crème fraîche 2 cups heavy cream 1 tablespoon vanilla extract or vanilla bean paste ¼ cup confectioners’ sugar Jam(s) of your choosing to top the dessert INSTRUCTIONS In a chilled bowl, using a handheld mixer, combine the heavy cream, vanilla, and confectioners’ sugar. Whip the cream until soft peaks develop. Set aside. In a separate bowl, add the crème fraîche and give it a stir. Add half of the whipped cream, using a rubber spatula, and gently fold and incorporate the whipped cream into the crème fraîche. Add the final half of the softly whipped cream and gently fold until just combined. Cover the bowl, or portion into cups or small bowls, and refrigerate until ready to serve. Pass assorted jams around the table to adorn your dessert as you see fit! Make ahead: This dessert can be made up to 12 hours ahead. If you like, adding a whipped cream stabilizer such as Whip It can help preserve the lift of the whipped cream for longer. 34

• WINTER 2026

Three to Four Days Before: Cook the Beans (About 1 Hour) • Simmer the beans with the pancetta and aromatics. • Cool them, then refrigerate them in their cooking liquid. Two to Three Days Before: Make the Pork Ragu (About 3 Hours) • Braise the pork, then stir in the beans, pancetta, and both sausages. • Cool and refrigerate. Save any extra bean liquid. The Day Before: Assemble the Cassoulet (About 45 Minutes) • Shred the duck and toast the breadcrumbs with the parsley. • Layer the ragu and duck in the Dutch oven, cover, and refrigerate overnight. • Chop the salad vegetables and olives, cover with a damp towel, and refrigerate. • Chill the Champagne. The Morning Of: Make Dessert (20 minutes) • Whip and fold the Fontainebleau, portion it into cups if you like, and refrigerate. 2½ Hours Before Dinner • Take the cassoulet out of the fridge to take the chill off. 90 Minutes Before Dinner • Preheat the oven to 325°F. • Top the cassoulet with breadcrumbs and bake, pressing the crust down twice, for about one hour total. As Guests Arrive • Pour the Kir Royales. While the Cassoulet Rests (15 minutes) • Dress the salad and slice the bread. At Dessert • Pass the jams.


SAHM’S FAMOUS

EASY TO GIVE EASY TO LOVE Sahm’s original famous coffee cake recipe is a time-honored tradition that is sure to delight. It’s the perfect treat for parties, holiday dinners, or someone who’s earned a thank you!

Locally-made in Fishers, Indiana Easy online ordering Ship anywhere in the Continental USA Now accepting holiday orders!

Buy or Gift One Today!

R E S TA U R A N T S | B R E W E R Y | C AT E R I N G | B A N Q U E T S | C O F F E E C A K E

sahms.com

SCAN TO ORDER WINTER 2026 •

35


A D V E R T O R I A L

RESTAURANT SPOTLIGHT

Hattie’s Coffee House THE COMMUNIT Y RO OM /CO FFE E S H O P IN A W H I T E S T O W N FA R M H O U S E Written by Bailey Shelton / Photos by Adam Grubb Media Although Whitestown is one of the fastest growing communities in Indiana, one coffee house is embracing the small town feel. Founded in 2023, Hattie’s Coffee House sits on Main Street in Whitestown just as the road changes to 650 East. With locally roasted RIVET coffee behind the bar, a host of regularly scheduled events on the calendar, and a 36

• WINTER 2026

living-room feel to their main seating area, Hattie’s prides itself on being a community-centered business. “I am from California and Chicago where there are lots of small local businesses in old homes. So, when I moved to Whitestown that was always the idea — find an old home and convert it to a coffee shop,” said owner Kirra Sutton.


A D V E R T O R I A L

Whitestown has quietly enjoyed their corner of Boone County since the 1800s. The town’s namesake, Albert White, was a Lincoln-era abolitionist and a major figure in expanding railroads in Indiana. His wife, Harriet, is the namesake of Hattie’s. Sutton imagines a fictionalized Hattie as a whimsical grandma; gold butterflies climb the walls, an armchair in the corner is upholstered in green gingham. The coffee house is, in a sense, Hattie’s house. Local ties define their menu, as Sutton partners with local apiaries for honey, and sources local dairy for their lattes. Sutton and her family have lived in Whitestown for over ten years. Her son would call himself one of Hattie’s first regulars, and their family of five can all walk or bike to the coffee house from their Whitestown home.

“My mom works with Hattie’s, she helps me, my daughter, my husband, my sons, so really it’s a family run business,” Sutton said. “It’s cool when I get to connect with my community and my family at the same time.” Hattie’s is built for hosting. The upstairs loft is available for events and meetings, and they’ve rented out the whole property before for bridal showers and special events. As Whitestown continues to grow, a burgeoning neighborhood is cropping up less than a block from Hattie’s front door. Sutton is excited to welcome those new neighbors with open arms. Hattie’s Coffee House is open seven days a week at 607 S. Main St., Whitestown. Find them online at hattiescoffeehouse.com or on Instagram @hattiescoffeehouse.

“It’s really still a community that’s trying to find its identity, I think. We don’t have a lot of community hubs so to have created a destination for our town to go hang out at is so special to me — I love bringing people together.” – KIRRA SUTTON, Owner, Hattie’s Coffee House

WINTER 2026 •

37


EDIBLE UPDATE

edible

U P D AT E

We’ve been busy behind the scenes (and behind the bar!), connecting with the people and places that make Central Indiana’s food scene so special. From conversations with local chefs and restaurant owners to delicious pop-up events and creative video productions, we’ve been capturing great food, sharing stories, and celebrating the businesses that bring our culinary community to life. Here’s a look at what we’ve been up to!

COMMERCIAL SHOOT

POP-UPS

HC TAVERN + KITCHEN

Great food, local chefs, and unforgettable experiences! Our Edible Indy® pop-up events bring food lovers together four times a year to enjoy delicious creations from some of the city’s most talented chefs. Want a seat at the table? Become a print subscriber for a chance to join us at an upcoming event!

A behind-the-scenes look at our recent commercial shoot for HC Tavern + Kitchen, part of Huse Culinary. From beautifully crafted dishes and signature cocktails to the inviting atmosphere, our team captured the flavors, ambiance, and hospitality that make the restaurant experience special.

HC Tavern + Kitchen

38

• WINTER 2026

Edible Indy® Fall Pop-Up


PAIRED INDIANA PORK PRODUCERS A flavorful conversation at Bonge’s Tavern! Adam sat down with Chef Dean Sample and Jeanette from Indiana Pork Producers to explore the art of preparing pork, the inspiration behind the restaurant’s dishes and the important work Indiana Pork Producers does to support the state’s pork industry.

PAIRED – Episode: Chef Dean Sample’s Best Pork Cooking Tips featuring Indiana Pork Producers

BEHIND THE BAR MO’S A PLACE FOR STEAKS A taste of what makes Mo’s A Place for Steaks a standout dining destination! Our publisher, Adam Grubb, sat down with the restaurant’s owner to explore the story behind Mo’s, the passion and values that drive the restaurant, and the memorable dining experience they strive to create for every guest. Of course, no visit would be complete without sampling a few of their signature dishes!

BEHIND THE BAR – Episode: Tasting Mo’s A Place for Steaks’ Most Iconic Dishes / Indy’s Prime Steakhouse

SHUEE’S APPLIANCE Where culinary creativity meets kitchen innovation! Chelsea Kopelman from Keep Up Local sat down with Ron from Shuee’s Appliance to explore the showroom experience and what makes it special for customers. The conversation continued in the showroom kitchen, where a chef from Provision prepared a delicious dish while sharing cooking tips and showcasing the kitchen’s capabilities.

BEHIND THE BAR – Episode: Can Your Kitchen Do This? / Shuee’s Appliance

EDIBLE INDY® CAN HELP SHOWCASE YOUR COMPANY!

Contact Adam Grubb Media for details.

WINTER 2026 •

39


WHAT THE GRUBB?

A LOOK INTO THE BIZ ARRE AND WONDERFUL WORLD OF FOOD AND LIFE WHAT THE GRUBB?

Your Holiday Party: My Prediction By Adam Grubb, Publisher Every company holiday party starts the same way: Everyone arrives, stands near the food, and says things like “I’m only having a couple, after last year, I am going to take it easy.” Nobody believes it, including the person saying it. Then the bar opens. It is a slow walk for some as they wait for sales to make the first move. Once that happens, it is a steady flow of people getting Mich’ Ultras, vodka sodas, and some dude asking for any “10-year”, which he doesn’t know anything about but overheard at a cigar lounge the weekend before. Carol from accounting has been quiet in the corner, in fact, Carol has been quiet since March. She sends emails with the subject line “Per my last email.” By the third drink, she explains to anyone within 8 feet what she really thinks about expense reports. Terry from product development has been waiting all year for this. He has opinions about the new software rollout, and tonight they come with hand gestures. By nine o’clock he has drawn a chart on a cocktail

40

• WINTER 2026

napkin and is calling it “my vision.” Three people are nodding, being polite. And then there is the HR manager (name withheld for legal reasons), standing near the door with a club soda and a lime, watching the room like a lifeguard at a pool full of toddlers. They are not at the party. They are on duty. Every laugh gets a quick scan. Every “one more” gets a mental note. They have a drink ticket in their pocket and have never once used it, and someone will point that out by the end of the night. Here is the thing about the open bar: It does not change who anyone is. It just removes the part where we pretend. Carol has always had opinions. Terry was always a little too excited about workflows. And the HR manager is exactly who we thought she was. By midnight, the whole office has said something it can’t take back. Monday will be quiet. Somebody will bring in donuts. And Carol will send an email to leadership with a subject line that just says “Thanks.”


WINTER 2026 •

41


EUROPEAN JAMÓN CONSORCIOSERRANO Crafted in Spain, Perfected by Time Some traditions cannot be hurried. For generations, Spanish ham makers have understood that exceptional flavor requires patience. Jamón ConsorcioSerrano is the result of that philosophy: authentic Serrano ham crafted according to tradition and perfected through time.

natural process, the ham develops its delicate aroma, balanced flavor, and characteristic texture. Each piece is then individually inspected by expert ham masters, ensuring that only the finest hams earn the ConsorcioSerrano certification.

Every piece carrying the ConsorcioSerrano seal is cured for a minimum of 52 weeks—far longer than the minimum required for Serrano ham TSG (Traditional Speciality Guaranteed). During this slow,

The result is a versatile ingredient that brings a taste of Spain to any occasion. Serve it with crusty bread and olive oil, add it to a charcuterie board, or use it to elevate simple recipes with authentic European flavor.

A simple way to enjoy it For an easy appetizer, pair Jamón ConsorcioSerrano with creamy strained yogurt cheese, roasted cherry tomatoes, fresh thyme, and a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil. The sweetness of the tomatoes and the richness of the cheese perfectly complement the savory character of the ham, creating a dish that is simple, fresh, and perfect for sharing. Because some of the best things in life are worth waiting for.

Do you want to know more? Visit our website

Funded by the European Union. Views and opinions expressed are however those of the author(s) only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food of Spain. Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them.


Behind every meal, there’s a story It begins in the soil, in the field, and in the hands of the farmers and ranchers who feed us. Filmmaker and chef Oliver English has built his work around telling these stories. His deep appreciation for regenerative agriculture and farm-to-table cuisine led to his documentary Feeding Tomorrow and connected him to American Farmland Trust (AFT). “Farmers are the backbone of America,” Oliver says. “And they’re often underappreciated or unseen.” Oliver and his team at Common Table Creative are visiting farms across the United States, hearing how AFT’s farm viability grants, farmland protection efforts and research have helped farms survive and thrive. “It’s one thing to read about these programs on a website,” says Oliver. “It’s another thing entirely to sit at a farmer’s kitchen table and hear that a grant helped to keep their farm running, to protect their land from development, or to transition to more resilient practices.” The stakes are real. “If we lose our farmland, there is no future,” Oliver says. The farmers who steward our farmland need advocates, resources, and people committed to the land that sustains us all. That’s what AFT does. Join Oliver and thousands of others helping to keep America’s farms and ranches thriving for the next generation. Become a member today at farmland.org/edible.

Become a member at farmland.org/edible

American Farmland Trust (AFT) believes in thriving farms and ranches. AFT protects agricultural land, promotes environmentally sound farming practices, and keeps farmers on their land. It is the only national agricultural organization of its kind recognizing the connection between land, practices, and farmers. Because of AFT, millions of acres of farmland that otherwise would have been converted into house lots and shopping malls remain in farming, and tens of thousands of farmers and ranchers have adopted better farming practices.

Photo Simon English

Oliver English Co-Founder and CEO, Common Table Creative Filmmaker, Chef, and AFT Member


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Edible Indy Winter 2026 by havenhome4 - Issuu