Skip to main content

Fall 2017: Free Time

Page 1

HARVARD POLITICAL REVIEW

NO WORK LEFT TO DO

A MACRON PRESIDENCY

INTERVIEW: RAÚL GRIJALVA

VOLUME XLIV NO. 3, FALL 2017 HARVARDPOLITICS.COM

FREE TIME


[

]

WANT TO ADVERTISE IN THE HPR?

CONTACT CIRCULATION@HARVARDPOLITICS.COM


FREE TIME

This issue’s cover topic was originally proposed by Erica Newman-Corre.

7

No Work Left to Do Mikael Tessema

12 Free Time for the Unfree Sophia Z. Li

10 Spain’s Jobless Generation Devontae Freeland

20 Cities Transformed Henry Sullivan Atkins

25 A Macron Presidency Amanda Wasserman

CAMPUS

CULTURE

3

Reflecting on STEM Culture Celine Liang

34 Balance Katie Weiner

5

A Muslim-Jewish Alliance Amitai Abouzaglo & Bushra Hamid

37 Finding the Words for Hope Hank Sparks

UNITED STATES

INTERVIEWS

15 Cities Transformed Henry Sullivan Atkins

40 Raúl Grijalva Meena Venkataramanan

19 Louisiana: Lost Near Sea Beverly Brown

42 Craig Atkinson Marty Berger

21 The Old Guard Wyatt Hurt

ENDPAPER

WORLD

44 Coming Home Flavia Cuervo

24 Red Looked Good on Paper Anirudh Suresh 27 A Macron Presidency Amanda Wasserman 30 Who’s Got the Power? Chad Borgman 34 Balance Katie Weiner Email: president@harvardpolitics.com. ISSN 0090-1032. Harvard Political Review. All rights reserved. Image credits: Facebook: 40- Jake Tapper. Flickr: 1- Elvert Barnes; 1- United States Department of Defense; 14- Elvert Barnes; 25- Gopal Vijayaraghavan; 28- Nicolas Nova; 37- PunkToad. Pexels: 23. Photographer: 5- Elmer Vivas Portillo. Unplash: 14- Kimberly Richards, 34- Gabriel Garcia Marengo. Pixabay: 24- xoracio. The United States Navy: 8. Wikimedia: Cover- Jamelle Bouie; 1- Balatokyo; 1- Jim Bowen; 11- Kyknoord; 20- Ipankonin; 32; 34; 42- Keith Allison; 44- chensiyuan.

FALL 2017 HARVARD POLITICAL REVIEW 1


FROM THE PRESIDENT

HARVARD POLITICAL REVIEW

Free Time

A Nonpartisan Undergraduate Journal of Politics, Est. 1969—Vol. XLIV, No. 3

EDITORIAL BOARD PRESIDENT: Ali Hakim PUBLISHER: Peter Wright MANAGING EDITOR: Samuel Plank ASSOCIATE MANAGING EDITOR: Quinn Mulholland ASSOCIATE MANAGING EDITOR: Samuel Kessler STAFF DIRECTOR: Ari Berman SENIOR COVERS EDITOR: Sal DeFrancesco ASSOCIATE COVERS EDITOR: Nicolas Yan SENIOR U.S. EDITOR: Chad Borgman ASSOCIATE U.S. EDITOR: Henry Brooks ASSOCIATE U.S. EDITOR: Drew Pendergrass SENIOR WORLD EDITOR: Jacob Link ASSOCIATE WORLD EDITOR: Derek Paulhus ASSOCIATE WORLD EDITOR: Akshaya Annapragada SENIOR CULTURE EDITOR: Chloe Lemmel-Hay ASSOCIATE CULTURE EDITOR: Russell Reed SENIOR CAMPUS EDITOR: Akash Wasil ASSOCIATE CAMPUS EDITOR: Katherine Ho INTERVIEWS EDITOR: Martin Berger BUSINESS MANAGER: Jennifer Horowitz ASSOCIATE BUSINESS MANAGER: Enrique Rodriguez SENIOR DESIGN EDITOR: Kyle McFadden ASSOCIATE DESIGN EDITOR: Victoria Berzin ASSOCIATE DESIGN EDITOR: Eliot Harrison SENIOR MULTIMEDIA EDITOR: Sebastian Reyes ASSOCIATE MULTIMEDIA EDITOR: James Blanchfield SENIOR TECH DIRECTOR: Richa Chaturvedi ASSOCIATE TECH DIRECTOR: Alisha Ukani ASSOCIATE TECH DIRECTOR: Will Finigan

STAFF Perry Abdulkadir, Victor Agbafe, Perry Arrasmith, Marie Becker, Devon Black, Evan Bonsall, Beverly Brown, Jiafeng Chen, Pedro Luis Cunha Farias, Justin Curtis, Ashish Dahal, Nick Danby, Sunaina Danziger, Hadley DeBello, Sophie DiCara, Casey Durant, Austin Eder, Steven Espinoza, Adam Friedman, Daniel Friedman, Miro Furtado, Melissa Gayton, Jay Gopalan, David Gutierrez, Olivia Herrington, Thomas Huling, Chimaoge Ibe, Michael Jasper, Cindy Jung, Matthew Keating, Daniel Kenny, Andrew Kim, Kieren Kresevic, Amelia Lamp, Jose Larios, Ashiley Lee, Elton Lossner, Elizabeth Manero, Patrick McClanahan, Olivia McGinnis, Jake McIntyre, Ayush Midha, Andrew Morley, Erica Newman-Corre, Iriowen Ojo, Nadya Okamoto, Mfundo Radebe, Anna Raheem, Anne Raheem, Alyssa Resar, Chico Payne, Darwin Peng, Juliet Pesner, Stefan Petrovic, Lily Piao, Allison Piper, Tess Saperstein, Lizzy Schick, Matthew Shaw, Audrey Sheehy, Wright Smith, Nick StaufferMason, Gloria Su, Anirudh Suresh, Sarah Tisdall, Richard Tong, Rachel Tropp, Nico Tuccillo, Derek Wang, Katie Weiner, Joseph Winters, Jenna Wong, Sarah Wu, Emily Zauzmer, Catherine Zheng, Anna Zhou, Andrew Zucker

ADVISORY BOARD Jonathan Alter Richard L. Berke Carl Cannon E.J. Dionne, Jr.

Ron Fournier Walter Isaacson Whitney Patton Maralee Schwartz

2 HARVARD POLITICAL REVIEW FALL 2017

A

h, free time—that elusive occasion during which worry fades to the back of one’s mind and the James Patterson novel on the coffee table or the dusty baseball hidden somewhere deep inside the coat closet seems to be the only thing of immediate consequence in one’s world. Seldom do we acknowledge, however, that how we spend our free time is a more fundamental reflection of our identities than countless hours spent in the professional, educational, and social realms. Indeed, every moment spent unconstrained by responsibilities to our jobs and our friends becomes an instance of pure self-expression. Perhaps that’s why we use the phrase “me time”— because it tells us who we are and what we want. You may be wondering why a political journal should have any interest in the topic of free time. The answer is simple. Politics is the means by which members of a community bring their private concerns into a public forum and collectively set priorities—in other words, it is a means of self-expression. If the excess hours of the day offer us the best opportunity to express ourselves unbound by many of the restrictions imposed on us in the workplace, classroom, and elsewhere, then the subject of free time is of necessary importance to anyone interested in politics. Furthermore, free time itself is often—although seldom obviously— politicized. Security services monitor how Americans spend their free time surfing the web. Governments impose curfews in the name of public safety. Laws in many countries tell us who we should love and may marry. These are, fundamentally, issues regarding the relationship that a citizenry should have with their government. And intrusive regulations are far from the only ways in which governing institutions place limits on free time. Imprisonment and indentured servitude,

for example, are systems used by state and non-state agents around the globe; and while each arguably fulfills an important social or economic function, they also impose particularly harsh restrictions on both the amount of free time one has and what she may do with that time. While governments often restrict the time citizens have to themselves, they can also enrich the public’s free time. Through publicly funded parks, squares, and after-school programs and through safe streets and clean beaches, government can actually enhance the hours that we have to ourselves. In hopes of stimulating discourse on this deeply personal and inherently political subject, we proudly present to you Free Time, the Fall 2017 issue of the HPR. In it, Mikael Tessema stresses the importance of rethinking the cultural value of work in the face of the rapid pace of automation, a phenomenon that could eliminate jobs and reduce working hours for many Americans. Devontae Freeland examines the phenomenon of youth unemployment in Spain, which has given many recent graduates excess free time. And Sophia Li illuminates the creative ways in which prisoners make the most of their time behind bars. This magazine is the third produced by the HPR’s 49th masthead. I would like to thank and credit them and our entire staff, who have offered up countless hours of their free time to produce this issue. And finally, I would like to thank you for investing some of your free time into reading it.

Ali Hakim President


.REFLECTING ON. .STEM CULTURE.

Celine Liang

T

here has been as much written about the gender gap in STEM as there has been effort to counteract it. But the often-desired goal of “equality”—an approximately equal ratio of males to females in STEM fields—can backfire if we become too solely focused on test results, statistics, and data. Obstacles to gender equality in STEM are comprised of two main aspects: barriers of entry to girls who want to explore STEM, and pressures that cause women already interested in STEM to drop out of these fields. While initiatives to increase the number of women in STEM aren’t perfect, the mere existence of these initiatives is already a step forward. My experiences are hardly representative of all females (and even within STEM, most of my experiences are math-related), but I hope that these reflections will shed some light on ways to restructure initiatives to keep women excited about STEM.

GETTING PERSONAL WITH OUTREACH The most common way to introduce a group of people to a field in which they are a minority is to connect them with others who have walked similar paths. One way many on-campus and off-campus organizations do this is by inviting speakers to present on a special topic or relate her journey to the audience. My first experience with a STEM speaker presentation was a math talk at a middle school summer program. Quite frankly, I don’t remember who the speaker was or the topic of the presentation; I snuck out of the auditorium 20 minutes into the presentation to run to 7-Eleven and grab slushies with friends. Seventh-grade

me felt that the talk was simply too impersonal, as most technical talks tend to be. And this is coming from someone who was already interested in STEM; how could such a talk have piqued the interests of a young girl who wasn’t inclined towards science and math? Girls these days are constantly bombarded with STEM talks given by female scientists and mathematicians. But those talks are usually only directed towards girls who have already expressed interest in the field, rather than those who haven’t. To increase interest among females who haven’t yet explored STEM, the talks should tone down the technical aspects and err on the side of being more personal. When I was first beginning to realize my interests in math and science in middle school, I was much more drawn towards people who talked about what it felt like to work in a wet lab, build spacecrafts for NASA, or spend months on a ship researching krill in the Antarctic, than those who discussed the technical details required of those things. Getting personal is key to inciting curiosity, and in fields where females are lacking, this is crucial to promote interest. The same tactic can benefit young males as well. Female speaker presentations to an all-female audience can be effective and empowering, but they can be even more so to a mixed audience, especially when the speaker addresses personal struggles or interesting observations that she has noticed during her time in the field. What has been your experience with the gender divide? Do you have any advice for the audience or anyone looking to help with the movement? What is one thing you wish you could change about how females are viewed in your field? These

Anna Biggs

FALL 2017 HARVARD POLITICAL REVIEW 3


CAMPUS

are questions that everyone should be aware of, so that those who want to be more involved in the conversation—including men—can do just that. “If the other members who make up the STEM community are willing to be active bystanders and are educated about helpful, effective actions, women can focus on their work in STEM, instead of having to fight for a seat at the table,” Harvard student Grace Lin told the HPR.

THE PINK GROUP Camps and workshops that actively encourage young women to explore STEM are another common initiative toward gender equality in STEM. Some of these initiatives are singlegender programs for the purpose of building communities for women. Others are programs that attempt to address the gender gap in STEM by lowering the acceptance standards for females. Though the mission behind this latter group of programs is admirable, the lack of transparency regarding non-uniform acceptance standards can have an adverse effect on women’s selfconfidence. The camp of slushie-escapade fame was one that I had received a scholarship to attend via another math competition, as did another male student (the scholarship was meant for one male and one female). Although I was excited to receive the scholarship, I knew he had placed in the top 12 of the competition whereas I had placed around fiftieth; seven years later, it still makes me slightly uncomfortable to know that we hadn’t received the scholarship on equal footing. In high school, I was invited to the more intensive Math Olympiad Program as one of the top 50 scorers of another math contest. But MOP invited the eight highest-scoring females as well, regardless of whether or not they scored in the top 50. The camp was grouped into color groups by score, and the girls who hadn’t scored in the top 50 but who were still invited by being one of the top eight female scores were dubbed the “pink” group. Although the nickname started as a joke and stuck for convenience, I could never really get over its somewhat pejorative nature. On balance, I support initiatives like “pink” MOP. They help break ceilings that would otherwise remain unbroken at the highest levels and give the females involved opportunities to challenge themselves in ways they might not be able to otherwise. But I do believe there are some things that should be changed, or at least addressed. Some females may begin to interpret the existence of lower cutoff programs as an indication that females are naturally weaker. Or, along a similar vein, these programs may cause females themselves to view their accomplishments through the lens of their sex. After participating in so many contests and programs with gender-based admission, I identified as a “strong female in math” when in fact, my evaluation of my personal strengths should have had nothing to do with gender. I believe that programs which admit females under a lower cutoff should address why they choose to do this. This transparency could provide a definitive answer to the “did I get in just because I’m female?” question (even if the answer is “yes”), raise awareness about the

4 HARVARD POLITICAL REVIEW FALL 2017

barriers that women face in STEM, and reassure women that they belong in the program.

FIXING THE CULTURE The problem that most strongly contributes to the gender divide is also most difficult to correct. STEM is a meritocracy which subliminally permeates a culture of “intellectual elitism”—where those who are knowledgeable and established are praised and admired, while newcomers are less welcome and struggle to “break in.” Hiro Tanaka, a post-doc in Harvard’s math department, told the HPR that the clearest example of this elitism at Harvard is the emphasis on the level of difficulty of the classes you take. It starts, according to Tanaka, “even before the first day of classes freshman year, when you are bombarded with the cultural archetypes of what 55-ers are, or with how you should identify your mathematical ability by 25, 23, or otherwise.” There is also a bias against those who speak up during class and ask for help, especially in theory-based fields like math and physics, as if asking questions was a sign of weakness. The stigma against “speaking up” is slowly disappearing but is still present in many upper-level classes—to sit and nod in silence is to give off the impression that you understand or at least respect those who do enough to avoid slowing them down. What’s worse is when this impression of “weakness” becomes a label. Elba Monsalvo, co-president of Gender Inclusivity in Mathematics, told the HPR that she found it “unsettling to think that each time I raise my hand to get a clarification somebody might see that as a weakness expected of my gender.” This fact alone starts a vicious cycle for females trying to enter these fields: the tendency towards remaining silent when it would be best to ask questions hurts those who would benefit the most from that extra help or clarification, including newcomers. The math department is by no means ignoring the issues that are present—in fact, the department has taken some steps to combat intellectual elitism. “Math Night,” an event on Mondays at 8 p.m. in Leverett Dining Hall, is an event where students congregate to do problem sets with friends and receive help at office hours. Additionally, the department works with GIIM to improve math advising for freshmen and prospective math concentrators. But STEM departments are going to have to do more to change the culture simply due to the way their fields are viewed. I’m still optimistic about the progress that’s being made. Many issues remain that I haven’t addressed here, such as the pressure that women face to balance their careers and families, and the fact that I have yet to take a STEM course at Harvard that is not taught by a professor who is white and male. But attempts towards more personal programs, explicit acknowledgement of measures being taken, and a correction of the stigmas inherent to STEM culture will all result in better support for women who are seeking to enter the STEM fields as well as those who are working to gain a stronger foothold in the STEM community.


A Muslim-Jewish Alliance Amitai Abouzaglo & Bushra Hamid

I

t began with smiles. The internet beamed with a photograph of strangers capturing togetherness. At O’Hare Airport in Chicago, a Muslim father-daughter duo shared a frame with a Jewish father-son duo, and a new era of religious-minority cooperation in the United States commenced. American Muslim and Jewish communities have responded to acts of profanity this year with a sacred togetherness, supporting one another in the face of egregious acts of discrimination and hatred. Cooperation between our two communities, however, must go beyond isolated calls for unity and solidarity if we are to navigate the coming years stronger together: only a deeper, sustained sense of shared humanity can extinguish the embers of corrosive separation. With this in mind, an unofficial collection of students, including the authors, have worked to develop a Muslim-Jewish alliance on Harvard’s campus. Our central goal has been to forge lasting bonds between these two communities and between individuals within them. Over two semesters, we learned firsthand that interfaith interactions cultivate friendship and palpable support across backgrounds. Sahar Omar, a member of the Harvard Islamic Society, described in an interview with the HPR how this interfaith alliance fosters deep bonds. “They’re names with faces now, people on the street you smile at—they are your friends who are supporting you,” says Omar of the Jewish students she has gotten to know. “[The alliance has] moved on from being ‘I’m going to represent the Muslim side of community.’ The alliance has become a friendship in my eyes.”

FORGING FRIENDSHIP Last October, a group of 10 Muslims and Jews broke bread and discussed the religions’ high holiday practices and experiences under a Sukkah—a temporary hut constructed for Sukkot, a Jewish festival commemorating God’s sheltering of the Jews in the desert for 40 years. Our conversations translated into friendships, and these friendships laid the foundations for the campus alliance we sought to establish. Over brunch some weeks after, our organizing group decided to name the alliance after the event’s title: Sukkat Salaam, literally “the canopy of peace.” We established this alliance in a political period rife with hostility toward minority populations, including religious minorities. In response to this, we set out to build a sense of inclusion and unity between Muslims and Jews. Ilan Goldberg, a member of Hillel, told the HPR that he is involved in the alliance because “I have a lot of friends who are Muslim and I know they are going through difficult times in the U.S.” Days after the U.S. presidential election, members of the Jewish community attended Jummah, a congregational prayer service Muslims hold every Friday. Muslim students responded in kind and attended Shabbat dinner at Hillel. We emphatically exchanged sentiments of deep care and together denounced hatred. In a period of acrimony and finger-pointing, expressions of support across religious lines can be unexpected and valuable. “There was a whole lot of warmth and unexpected support [from the Jewish community], especially with regard to political turmoil,” Omar said. “Having a Jewish contingency at Jumah

FALL 2017 HARVARD POLITICAL REVIEW 5


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook