Skip to main content

Coal Geology Volume 1 Part 3 December 1980 - CGG

Page 1

REGISTE RED A

FOR

PUBLICATIO N -

POST ING

AS

CATE GOR Y ( B)

COAL GEOLOGY JOURNAL OF THE COAL GEOLOGY GROUP OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF AUSTRALIA INCORPORATED

VOLUME

1

PART 3 pp(52-1381

SURAT- MORETON BASIN SYMPOSIUM SPECIAL EDITION NO. 1

BRISBANE

DECEMBER

1980


1980 COAL GEOLOGY GROUP OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF AUSTRALIA INCORPORATED

Office Bearers 1978-1979 Surat-Moreton Basin Symposium Sub-committee 1980 Chairman: J. W. Beeston Vice-Chairman: P.A. Rayment Hon. Secretary: W. B. Gould Hon. Treasurer: G . M . Leblang

Hon. Editor: W. L. Hawthorne Geological Survey of Queensland Mineral House, 41 George Street, Brisbane, 4000 Price $5 .00 per issue ISSN 0156-4684


REGISTERED FOR POSTING AS A PUBLICATION - CATEGORY ( B)

COAL GEOLOGY JOURNAL OF THE COAL GEOLOGY GROUP OF THE GEOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF AUSTRALIA INCORPORATED

VOLUME PART 3 pp(52-138J

SURAT- MORETON BASIN SYMPOSIUM NO. 1 SPECIAL EDITION


CO TE TS OF VOLUME I , PART 3

Acknowledg ments . Editorial. Symposium Sub-commit tee Report . Publications

Page 53 56 56

N. F. EXON

The stratigraphy of the Surat Basin, with special reference to coal deposits. K. R. MARTIN Early Jura ssic sedimentatio n in the Surat Basin . R. GOULD The coal-forming flora of the Walloon Coal Measures T. D . FE WICK Water resources of the Surat-Moret on Basin. M. J. RUSSELL Revegetation of open-cut mining areas. T. C. ST. BAKER Electric power generation using Walloon coals . I. W. SMITH The flash pyrolysis method for converting coal to oil

57 71 83 . 107 . 119 . 125 . 133


THIS EDITIO N OF

COAL GEOLOGY JOUR AL OF THE COAL GEOLO GY GROUP OF THE GEOLO GICAL SOCIET Y OF AUSTR ALIA I CORPO RATED HAS BEEN PARTL Y FUNDE D BY DONA TI ONS FROM THE FOLLO WING MAJOR CONTR IBUTO RS


-

a a

PACIF IC COAL PTY. LIMITED (Incorporate d in Victoria)

A .M .P. PLACE, 10 EAGLE STREET, BRISBANE, QUEENSLAND 4000

G.P.O . Box 391 Brisbane, Australia 4001 Telephone : (07) 229 3900 Telex: AA40813

AN IA >< IRO N ORE COR POR ATIO N COAL DIVISIO N

3RD FLOOR, 55 MACQUAR IE STREET, SYDNEY, N .S.W. 2000 AUSTRAL IA.

TELEPHO NE 27 2501. TELEX 21873


OFFSHORE OIL N.L . INCORPORATED IN ACT

82 ELIZABETH STREET SYDNEY BOX 4246 GPO SYDNEY AUSTRALIA 2001 TELEPHONE 233 6022 AA22292 TELEX

Agit1p AlU1st1rallila 1pty. lltdl. 8-12 Bridge Street, Sydney. N.S.W. 2000. Tel : (02) 277031 Telex : AA 21176 Enidro


EDITORI AL

The Surat-Moreton Basin Symposium was held in Toowoomba in August and September, 1979 over a period of three days fo llowed by a two-day field excursion . It was an undoubted success, with papers covering a variety of subjects ranging from the coal-forming floras to enduse technology. It was origi nall y proposed to publish all the symposi um papers together as Parts 3 and 4 of Volume I of Coal Geology. However. some authors have elected not to submit manuscripts and some will be submitting more comprehensive papers for publication in later issues of Coal Geology . At the present time one of the fourteen papers to be published is still outstanding a nd amendments are required to two others, which do not conform with the requirements of the Australian Code of Stratigraphic omenclature. Con equently, in order to enable publication of as many paper as possible at a reasonably early date, it has now been decided to publish Parts 3 and 4 of Volume I as separate issues. Part 3 contain even papers covering a range of topics indicative of the diver ity of subjects discussed at the Sympo ium.

SYM POSIUM SUB-CO MMJTIEE REPORT

Since the conception of the Surat-Moreton Symposium it has been our aim to publish the proceedings. Such publication serves as a record of the Symposium . It also makes available a great deal more information, to participants as well as other , than can be fully covered in the context of a seminar. The standards of presentation at the Symposium were of a high calibre. The prepared papers for publication (with varying degrees of assistance from the Symposium Editor) are of a like standard. Through the various stages of preparation, we have remained con tantly aware of our financial responsibilities, both to the members of the Group, and to the Mining Companies who generously assist with donations. After due consideration, it has been decided to omit discussion sessions and author biographies from the published text. A column format has also been adopted, to assist the inclusion of the large number of figures and diagrams. We believe that the financial outlay has been fully justified. We are confident that these pre entation fulfil the ideals of Coal Geology. that they are a fitting conclusion to a successful Sympo ium. and that they will continue to be important reference documents in the future .

56


THE STRATIGRAP HY OF THE SURAT BASIN , WITH SPECIAL REFERE CE TO COAL DEPOSITS By . F. Exon ABSTRACT

The Jurassic-Cretac eous Surat Basin underlies 300 000 km 2 in eastern Australia, mostly in Queensland . It contains up 'to 2500 m of sedimentary rocks in a simple basin within which dips seldom exceed 2 °, and fault displacements are less than 200 m. The sedimentary strata interfinger with those of the Eromanga Basin to the west, and the Moreton Basin to the east. The Permo-Triassic Bowen Basin limits the basin to the north, and elsewhere it is limited by basement highs. The margins of the basin are eroded, the basinal sequences are all conformable, and younger units normally overlap older ones. There are two distinctive sequences in the basin: a lower (Early Jura ssic-early eocomian) sequence of generally quartz-rich and fluvial sediments up to 1800 m thick, and an upper (late eocomian-late Albian) sequence of varied, dominantly paralic sediments up to 900 m thick. Jurassic sedimentation was cyclic, the cycles being largely controlled by eustatic changes in sea level. Five cycles, each hundreds of metres thick , began with deposition of sand from fast-flowing streams, and ended with deposition of sand , silt, mud and some coal in swamps, lakes and deltas. Marine incursions occurred in the late stages of three cycles. A little coal is also present in paralic and non-marine parts of the Cretaceous sequence, which includes the later part of the fifth cycle, and a sixth regressive-transgressive cycle. Coal has been worked only in the Middle Jurassic Walloon Coal Measures and the Late Jurassic Orallo Formation. Both Walloon and Orallo coals are sub-bituminous to bituminous, with highly volatile contents, and are potentially suitable for liquefaction. Active prospecting is confined to the Walloon Coal Measures, which are thickest in the north and east, contain seams up to 11 m thick , and appear to have the greatest potenPublished with the permission or the Direc tor, Bureau or Mineral Resources, Canberra .

tial for future mmmg. Their coal reserves stood at about 2000 million tonnes in mid 1979.

I TRODUCTIO The Surat Basin underlies 300 000 km 2 in eastern Australia , mostly in Queensland , is elongated north-south , and is filled with gently dipping Jurassic and Cretaceous sediments. Geologists have worked for more than a century in the basin, which has commercial quantities of oil , gas, coal, and artesian water. Gas was first found near Roma in 1900, and has been piped to Brisbane since 1969. Oil was discovered at Cabawin in 1960, and has been piped from Moonie to Brisbane since 1964. Coal was mined at Injune and Warra in the first half of this century, and many companies are actively exploring for coal at present. Water bores were first drilled in the basin in the late nineteenth century, and there are now hundreds of flowing bores and thousands of pumped bores. The most significant early study of Surat Basin geology was that of Reeves (1947) whose work north of Roma laid the basis for the present stratigraphic interpretation. Whitehouse ( 1954) produced the first geological overview of the Great Artesian Basin, of which the Surat Basin is a part. An excellent account of the petroleum geology of the basin was published by Power and Devine ( 1970), Gray ( 1972) summarised the results of stratigraphic drilling by the Geological Survey of Queensland, and Exon ( 1976) synthesised the results of an extensive geological mapping program carried out by the Bureau of Mineral Resources and the Geological Survey of Queensland, and the results of petroleum exploration activities. Figure I is based on Exon (1976), as is the generalised stratigraphy shown in Table I. The isopach and structure contour maps make use of the data and data points (mostly boreholes) used by Exon (1976). The Surat Basin is bounded by the South Coastal Structural High to the northeast, the New England Fold Belt to the southeast, the 57


V,

00

.

M

50

Geological boundaries r-r-r Base of Sura t Basin

_,_

Fault

©

10 0km

M ooni e - Goond1wmd1 Fa ult

rs:s;l W alloon Coal M eas

D Cain ozoi c ~ Hutton Sst et c Precipic e Sst , CJ. Upper Rollin g Dow ns Gp [I] Everg reen Fm e t c ~ Bung ii Fm, Doncas ter Mbr

CD

Nebine Ridge

@

M imosa Syn c li ne

Q)

D

D1r ranband1 Sync line

□

Fig. 1. Localities and solid geology.

Gubb eramu nda Sst t o Mooga Sst Spr ingbok Sst , W estbou rn e Fm et c

m bl □.

Tria ss ic sedim ent s Perm, an str at a

Contour tnterval 100m

Outcrop of Walloon Coal MeHures

- - f•ult

.,...-r Limit of Walloon Coal Measures _ _ g~~~': :.!:~,:: Walloon

Data point

- - Contour: interval 1000 m - - Contour; interval 100 m

@-- r Line of section illustr ated in Figure 5

Basement

Fig. 2. Struc ture conto urs, top of Walio

on Coal Meas ures.


Table I- Generalised Stratigraphy of Widespread Surat Basin Units

Max imum Thickness Unit G rima n C ree k Fo rmati on

480

Surat Siltsto ne Co reena Member (Wallumbill a Fo rm a ti o n)

150 210

Ro llin g Albi a n U pper

Down s

Sequence

G rou p

( m)

En vironment of Deposition and Lithology

Sedimentary Cycle

Para lic and fre shwa ter: sand sto ne, silt sto ne, mud sto ne Marine: silt sto ne, mud sto ne, sand sto ne Pa ralic a nd freshwa ter: siltsto ne, mud stone , sand sto ne

6

U. Apti a n

Do ncaster Member (Wallumbill a F ormati o n)

270

Ma rine: mud stone, some siltsto ne

U.

eocomi a n to L. Apti a n

Bungil Fo rmati o n

270

Paralic and freshwa ter: mud sto ne, siltsto ne, sa nd sto ne

L. Neocomia n

Mooga Sa nd sto ne

300

Freshwa ter: sand sto ne, some siltsto ne a nd mud stone

Orallo Fo rm a ti o n

270

Gubbera mund a Sa nd sto ne

300

Wes tbo urne Form a ti o n

260

Freshwater: labile sa ndstone, siltsto ne , mudstone , coal Freshwa ter: sand sto ne, some silt sto ne a nd conglomerate Freshwater a nd possibl y paral ic: silt sto ne, mud sto ne, sa nd sto ne

Springbo k Sa nd sto ne

150

Freshwa ter: labile sandstone, siltstone , mud stone

Wall oon Coa l Measures

650

Freshwater: labile sandsto ne, silt sto ne, mud stone, coal Freshwa ter: sand stone, som~ conglo mera te, silt stone a nd mudst o ne

Hutt o n Sa nd sto ne

250

Eve rgreen Fo rmati o n

260

Precipice Sa nd sto ne

150

Freshwa ter: sa nd sto ne, some silt sto ne a nd mud sto ne Freshwater , delta ic, shall o w marine: silt sto ne, mud stone, sand sto ne Freshwater , min or delta ic to wa rd to p: qua rtzose sand stone, some silt sto ne and mudsto ne

U. Ju rassic

Lowe r

Inj un c

M-

Seq uence

Creek

M. Ju rassic

Ju rassic

5

Euromba h Fo rm a ti o n

Gro up

L. Ju rassic

Unco nfo rmit y

4

3

2


Central West Folded Belt to the southwest, and by the Permo-Trias sic Bowen Basin to the north. The boundaries with the fold belts are essentially depositional , but that with the Bowen Basin is clearly erosional. The Surat Basin units interfinger with those of the Eromanga Basin to the west across the Nebine Ridge, and those of the Moreton Basin to the east across the Kumbarilla Ridge . The deepest part of the basin, the Mimosa Syncline, containing up to 2500 m of sediments, overlies the Ta room Trough of the Bowen Basin. East of a north-south line of Triassic thrust faults , ex tending from Cracow to Goondiwind i, the basin rests on steeply dipping Palaeozoic ~trata and Triassic volcanics of the ChinchillaGoondiwind i Slope; to the west, it rests on indurated sediments and metasedimen ts, granite, gneiss, and schist of the St GeorgeBollon Slope (Exon, 1976). The Chinchilla-G oondiwindi Slope, the Mimosa Syncline, and the St George-Boll on Slope were extensively eroded in the Late Triassic. In the Early Jurassic, deposition commenced in the Mimosa Syncline, and spread steadily up the adjacent slopes. By the Late Jurassic, the basin had taken up essentially its present simple form (Figs. 1 and 2), with overall dips into the Mimosa Syncline and local dips into the Dirranbandi Syncline. Some movement on the Permo-Triassic faults of the Roma-Injun e area , and on the MoonieGoondiwind i Fault, caused local structural and depositional effects, but dips seldom exceed a few degrees.

STRA TIG RAP HY The stratigraphy of the more widespread Surat Basin units is summarised in Table I; representative sections across the basin are shown in Figure 5. The basin had intermittent connection to the sea, and can be regarded as a mobile shelf basin. It contains a lower (Early Jurassic-early Neocomian) sequence up to 1800 m thick, which is characterised by quartz-rich fluvial sediments, and an upper (late Neocomian- late Albian) sequence up to 900 m thick , which is characterised by paralic sediments. The following stratigraphic discussion of the two sequences is based largely on Exon ( 1976), and Jensen , Exon, Anderson and Koppe ( 1976). 60

LOWER SEQUE CE (JURASSIC EARL Y EOCOMIAN) After a period of erosion in the Late Triassic, Surat Basin deposition began in the Early Jurassic on low-lying plains in the area of the Mimosa Syncline, which were underlain by Triassic sediments and surrounded by hilly blocks of basement and Permian strata. These high blocks were major source areas throughout the Jura sic. The depositional area increased steadily with time, and the outlet for the basin was to the east- probably through the Cracow-Mo ura area initially and the Moreton Basin later. Jurassic tectonism was mostly confined to small movements on pre-existing faults , and the period was characteri ed by slow basinwide sinking. The main depocentres coincided with the th ick , steadily compacting PermoTriassic sequences beneath the eastern Surat Basin (Exon, 1976). Although its sediments interfinger with those of the Eromanga Basin in the west and the Moreton Basin in the east, the depositional basin was essentially oval with its long axis north-south . Erosion has removed a great deal of Jurassic sediment from the north , and , to a lesser extent, from the south and east. Jurassic sedimentatio n was cyclic, with five cycles, each hundreds of metres thick and generally representing I 0-20 million years, the fifth of which continued into the Early Cretaceous. Deposition was slow, and the maximum preserved thickness of Jurassic rocks is about 1800 m near Meandarra in the north of the Mimosa Syncline. The sequence is more than 500 m thick in most of the basin (Fig. 3) . Toward the end of the first cycle, a marine interlude gave rise to oolitic ironstone and beach sands. Late in the second cycle, andesitic volcanic debris, including bentonite. apparently derived from contemporan eous volcanism to the east, accumulated in a thick Middle Jurassic coal-measur e sequence. At the same time the Nebine Ridge to the west, and the northern margin of the basin, were uplifted. Andesitic volcanism persisted through the third and fourth cycles of deposition , bentonite being a minor, but characteristic, component. The Kumbarilla Ridge, to the east, was uplifted during the Late Jurassic , separating the Surat and Moreton Basins. In the fifth cycle, in the Neocomian, fluvial sedimentatio n gave way to the paralic pre-


\\\-

\

•' "( ..,-\ " : , ..

f

I ..,__- ,J

rr~

.w

'"I

~ --\.

.

('II~,...--'\....,_....._ -.. Y~ . ...,;r. ~

M

C

27 '

IT I-

f

•'

50

50

100k m

L-L.. J

ence Erosional margin of sequ ence Top of outcrop of sequ

100k m

Cont our lnter v•I 100m

Cont our Inter val 100m

Data Poin t -20 0 - lsop achs

(11•n•r•lly ~-, - Ero1ion•I m•rgin •! within 20 km of deposition m•rgin)

Data Poin t

--F •uh - - lsop• ch; int•r v•I

100 m

Fau lt

Sequence Fig. 3. lso pachs of Lower

(Early Jur assic-ea rl y Nco

rn mian).

Fig . 4. lso pachs of Upp er

Sequence (la te Neo com ian-

latc Albian) .


cursors of the Cretaceou s ma rine transgression. Sedimenta tion in each cycle generally bega n with the deposition of coarse quartzose to sublabile sand , followed by finer-grained labile sand a nd silt, and ended with labile sand, silt, mud , and coal. The ideal cycle seems to have represented deposition in turn by braided streams, by meanderin g streams, and , finally , in swamps, lakes, and deltas. Marine influence was largely confined to the later stages of cycles. The importa nce of the various environme nts varies from cycle to cycle. Vail , Mitchum and Thompson (1977) showed that rapid eustatic falls in sea level are followed by slow rises, and that, in the Jurassic, these cycles took 5-15 million years. Such cycles should affect not only shelf sediments, but also those in inland basins linked to the sea, beca use of changes in the base level of erosion. In the Surat Basin, each sedimentar y cycle sta rted with a hiat us, which was followed by high-energy deposition , which gave way with time to low-energy deposition . If sedimentar y cycles a re controlled by sea-level changes, the hiatus would be caused by a sharp drop in sea level a nd hence in the base level of erosio n, the hi ghenergy depo its would be laid down while the sea level was still low, and the decrease in energy of deposition would parallel the rise in sea level. From a compariso n of palynological data (J. L. McKellar, Geological Survey of Queenslan d , and D . Burger, Burea u of Mineral Resources ; both pers. comm.) with Figure 2 of Vail , Mitchum and Thompson (1977), it is apparent that the ages of the hi a tuses in the Surat Basin Jurassic do not conflict with the age of the worldwide falls in sea level. The hi at uses below the various units a pparentl y correlate with the falls of sea level as follows: Precipice Sandstone hiatus = 189 million years ago , Hutton Sandstone hia tu s = 174 m.y., Springbok Sa nd stone hia tu s = 156 m.y. , Gubberam u nd a Sa nd stone hi a tus = 148 m.y. , Mooga Sandstone hiatus = 141 m.y. The good fits suggest that eustatic sea level cha nges have indeed controlled the sedimentar y cycles. Cycle I

The oldest Ju rassic unit is the Precipice Sands1one, which unco nformably overlies a 62

va riety of pre-Jurassi c rocks. It consists mainly of quartzose sa ndstone , with a coarser highl y porous and permea ble lower part, and a finer upper part that contains some siltstone . It averages 45 m thick , and has a maximum thickness of 150 m in the central and northern Mimosa Syncli ne. It appears to intertongu e with the Helidon Sandstone of the Moreton Basin (Fig. 5A). The thicker lower part was deposited by braided streams, which derived materi al from all marginal high s, but deposited most of their sedimen t in the east and northeast ( 120 m nea r Wa ndoan). It is an important aquifer and forms the reservoi r at Moonie oil field . Studies of sandstone percentages in petroleum exploratio n wells (Porter, 1979) suggest that the thinner, finergrained upper part of the Precipice Sa ndstone was part of a deltaic seq uence which built northward into the basin . The Precipice Sand stone is conformab ly overlain and generally overlapped by the Evergreen Forma1ion , which consists of siltstone, shale and sandstone. The Evergreen Formation averages 160 m thick , a nd reaches its maximum thickness of260 m in the central and northern Mimosa Syncline. It is equivalent to the lower pa rt of the Marburg Sa ndstone in the Moreton Basin. Much of the seq uence a ppea rs to be controlled by a northward -building delta, and is characterised by delta sand s in the so uth , and prodelta muds in the north (Porter, 1979). The sha ly seq uences in the lower part of the fo rm ation are commonly highl y ca rbonaceou s, a nd contain well-preserved plant impressions. They were deposi ted in a reducing environme nt, and are widely regarded as important petroleum source beds. There are two distinctive seq uences in the upper part of the formation in the north . The Boxvale Sa ndstone Member (Mollan et al., 1972) is confined to the northwest and consists of a lower coarsegra ined fluvia l part derived from the west, and an upper fine-gra ined part, which Exon ( 1976) considered to be marine. An oolitic ironstone seq uence overlies the Boxvale Sandstone Member in the northwest, where it is known as the Westgrove Ironstone Member. In the nort heast, the upper part of the Evergreen Forma tion is ha ly, and the oolitic iron stone occurs within this shaly section . Equivalent pelletal ironstones have been found in the Moreton Basin (Allen, 1971 ), suggestin g an easterly connection to the open sea .


4 00

Ooncot11r Mbr Codno·o .., 11 Fm

400

Wntbourn1 Fm Sprino;ibolo. S11

Hooray SIi Wutbourn1 Fm Ador1 511 81rkh1ocl Fm Hunan S11 Ever9rt1n Fm Pr1c1p1c1

Walloon

0

Cool Meas ures

S11

Mo rburo Sonclston1

Hehclon S11

1000

1000

... ,,., 2 000

2000 MIMOSA

Metres

300

200

100

.

SYNCLINE

50 0 K1lom 1tru

40 0

. E

s

C

6 00

600

Euromboh Fm

Gr1mon Ck Fm Surat S ilts!

Hulton SS!

Everoreen Fm Prec1p1c1

0

Coreeno Mb ,

Sst

Ooncou er Mb, Bun;, t Fm Moo90

. 5,1

Orollo Fm P1ll190

.,

1000

Walloon C M Hullon $,t

1000

RIDGE

B

MOONIE FAULT

Oo""1non1 1+tholo9111

C=:J

3 00

200

100

M vd 11on1

[ ~

2000 Metres

~~ Sil! s tone

400 Kilom elru

V :·~· : : _'.

j

So ndl tone Q/ A/783

Fig. 5. Schematic cross-sections across Surat Basin based on petroleum exploration wells. Locations shown in Figure 2.

63


Cycle II The Evergreen Formatio n is conforma bly overlain by the Hutton Sandston e, a predominan tly well-sorte d quartzose sandston e that contains some siltstone and mudston e. It is generally between 120 and 180 m thick , and as much as 250 m thick in the Mimosa Syncline. It overlaps the Evergreen Formation in all directions, and by as much as I 00 km on the St George-B allon Slope. It is equivalent to the upper part of the Marburg Sandston e in the Moreton Basin. Some of the sandston e beds are very porous and permeable, and the unit is a major aquifer. Largesca le trough cross-stratification is character istic and the formatio n was deposited by a system of meanderi ng rivers, which drained to the east and northeast . A coal-measure sequence , the Injune Creek Group, conforma bly overlies the Hutton Sandston e. The group thickens steadily northeastward , to more than 500 m in the central and northern Mimosa Syncline and the western Moreton Basin (Fig. 6); its maximum preserved thickness is about 850 m, west of Wandoan . In the north of the basin, the change from quartzose fluvial sand depositio n to coal-mea sure depositio n was slow, and a transition al sequence, the Middle Jurassic Eurombah Formation , was laid down by meanderi ng streams. This unit consists of interbedd ed lithic sandston e with some conglomerat e, siltstone, and mudston e, and appears to grade southwar d into the Hutton Sandston e (Fig. 5B). The Walloon Coal Measures conforma bly overlie the Euromba h Formatio n or, where that is absent, the Hutton Sandston e, which they overlap slightly in the south. The coal measures thicken northeast ward to more than 400 m in the central and northern Mimosa Syncline and in the western Moreton Basin (Fig. 5). They intertong ue with the silty, 100 m thick Birkhead Formatio n on the eastern flank of the ebine Ridge . The coal measures consist of interbedd ed mudstone , siltstone, and lithic sandston e, with considera ble coal. Depo_sition wa s from meanderi ng streams, and m lakes and swamps; no marine indications have yet been found in the sequence. Clays in the coal measures are mainly montmorillonite and, as the rocks tend to disintegrate on exposure, outcrop is generally poor. However , calcareou s beds do crop out, largely 64

as concretio ns. The montmor illonite and abundan t volcanic detritus suggest contemp oraneous volcanism , probably to the east of the Surat Basin. The coal measures contain a rich and varied fossil flora .

Cy cle III Overlying the coal measures is the Springbok Sandston e, which consists predominantly of labile sandston e and carbonaceous siltstone and mudston e. It is generally less than 50 m thick , but is I 00-150 m thick in the central part of the basin, between Surat and St George. It intertong ues with the sublabile Adori Sandston e on the Nebine Ridge, and the lower part of the quartzose Pilliga Sandston e in the south (Fig. 5). Coal and bentonite are minor constitue nts. The sandston e contains largescale trough crossstratification and consists predomin antly of volcanic debris. Depositio n was from meandering streams, and in lakes and swamps. The Upper Jurassic Westbourne Formation is the uppermo st sequence in the Injune Creek Group. It consists largely of mudston e, siltstone, and thinly bedded fine-grained sandstone; bentonite beds and coal seams are present in places. It is generally about 100 m thick, but thickens to more than 200 m in the central and northern Mimosa Syncline. It intertong ues with the Pilliga Sandston e, which replaces it in the south (Fig. 5B). Lowangle cross-stratification is common , and much of the formatio n was probably laid down by sluggish, meanderi ng streams. However the sporadic occurrence of glauconite, heavy-mineral concentr ations, barite nodules, and acritarch s suggest that shallow-m arine incursions occurred . It is thin in the central part of the basin, where the Springbo k Sandston e is thick , and thick in the Mimosa Syncline, where the Springbo k Sandston e is thin , and it appears that the lower Westbourne Forma tion in the Mimosa Syncline is a basinal equivalent of the upper Springbo k Sandston e in the central basin.

Cycle IV The Gubberamunda Sandstone overlies the Westbou rne Formatio n with regional conformity, despite local disconformities. It consists largely of medium to coarse-grained sublabile sandston e, which is leached and ferruginised in outcrop, and some siltstone and mudstone .


It is generally less than I 00 m thick, but thickens to more than 200 m in the central Mimosa Syncline and the northern Dirranbandi Syncline. It gives way to the lower Hooray Sandstone on the flank of the ebine Ridge, and the lower Orallo Formation in the south (Fig. 5). Plant impressions, clay clasts, and mud balls are locally abundant. Both planar and trough cross-stratification are common. Initial deposition was probably by braided streams, but meandering streams appear to have predominated later. Conformably overlying the Gubberamunda Sandstone is the Ora/lo Formation , a heterogeneous unit consisting of subequal proportions of generally medium-grained labile sandstone, siltstone, and mudstone. It is normally about 150 m thick, but thickens to more than 200 m in the central Mimosa Syncline and the northern Dirranbandi Syncline, where the Gubberamunda Sandstone is also thick. It is replaced by the middle part of the quartzose Hooray Sandstone on the eastern flank of the ebine Ridge (Fig. 5A). Conglomerate, bentonite, and thin coal seams are characteristic minor constituents. Fossil wood , including tree stumps in their living position, is so widespread that the formation was formerly known as the 'Fossil Wood Beds'. The sandstones are volcanogenic, and contemporaneous volcanism obviously supplied much of the detritus. Sandstone beds are trough crosslarge-scale and thick stratification is characteristic. The formation was deposited by meandering streams near and in swamps. Cycle V The lower eocomian Mooga Sandstone is regionally conformable on the Orallo Formation, although local disconformities are common . It consists largely of sublabile sandstone which is coarse and pebbly low in the formation , and fine to medium-grained elsewhere. It is generally about 50 m thick , but thickens to more than 150 m in the central Mimosa Syncline and on the ea tern part of the St George-Bollon Slope south of Surat. It is replaced by the upper part of the Hooray Sandstone on the eastern flank of the Nebine Ridge, and its lower part is replaced by the Orallo Formation on the ChinchillaGoondiwindi Slope (Fig. 5A). Siltstone and mudstone beds are common higher in the

sequence. Planar cross-stratification gives way to trough cross-stratification higher in the formation, probably indicating a change from braided stream to meandering stream deposition. The exceptionally long fifth cycle was continued by the Bungil Formation and Doncaster Member of the Upper Sequence as discussed below. General Discussion on the Lower Sequen ce The Jurassic sequence as a whole is generally thinner, andier and more quartz-rich on the high area (Fig. 5). On the ebine Ridge, the silty Birkhead Formation replaces the Walloon Coal Measures, and the Hooray Sandstone replaces the GubberamundaOrallo-Mooga sequence. In the southern part of the basin, the Walloon Coal Measures are very thin and the Pilliga Sandstone replaces the Springbok-Westbou rne sequence. UPPERSEQUE CE(LATE EOCOMIA -LATE ALBIA ) During the Cretaceous the Surat Basin was roughly equidimensional, and was connected with the Eromanga Basin across the ebine Ridge and its southerly continuation, the Cunnamulla Shelf. Initial sediment was derived from basement blocks to the south and east and older sediments to the north , which had been uplifted in the Late Jurassic. In the Albian, andesitic volcanism to the east, related to rifting prior to seafloor spreading, provided a large sediment influx into the basin. Cretaceous rock younger than Albian are not preserved in the Surat Basin, and erosion was characteristic of the Late Cretaceous and Cainozoic. Most of the Cretaceous sequence has erosional margins, and the maximum preserved thickness of 900 m southwest of Meandarra is not a depositional maximum; the sequence is more than 500 m thick in most of the southern part of the basin (Fig. 4). Deposition wa more marine and more rapid than during the Jurassic, and there are fewer breaks in the sequence; the basin generally subsided slowly and evenly. However the cyclicity apparent in the Jurassic does continue into the Cretaceous, with the cycles consisting of a regression followed by a transgression. Cycle 5 concludes late in the Aptian, and Cycle 6 in the mid Albian. The first effect of the worldwide Creta65


ceous transgression were felt in the late eocomian. when the sea entered, first from the east and later from the west. Sand, silt, and mud, derived from the Jurassic sediments and older rocks surrounding the basin, were laid down in paralic environments. The marine transgression reached its peak in the late Aptian and mud was laid down , largely below wave base. The scarcity of pelagic organisms suggests lower than normal salinity and restriction of water interchange with the open ocean . By the early Albian, the eastern seaway had closed, and sand, silt, and mud were laid down during a partial regression . A minor transgression marked by deposition of silt and mud preceded a final regression in the late Albian , during which deposition of sand and silt predominated. Cy cle V (continued) The paralic Bungil Formation marks the initial transgression of the Cretaceous sea from the east. It is conformable on the Mooga Sandstone and is heterogeneous, consisting dominantly of fine-grained lithic sandstone, siltstone and mudstone, with subordinate quartzose sandstone and minor coal. The thickness of the Bungil Formation ranges from about I 00 m in the north and west, to as much as 300 m in the central and southern Mimosa Syncline south of Meanda rra . It interfingers with both the underlying Mooga Sandstone and the overlying Doncaster Member in parts of the basin, and gives way on the eastern flank of the Nebine Ridge to the Cadna-owie Formation (Fig. SA). Environments of deposition include coastal plain, lagoonal, beach, and shallow marine. Near Roma , the formation consists of three members: from oldest to youngest the Kingull , Nullawurt Sandstone; a-nd Minmi Members. The Nullawurt Sandstone Member contains the oldest marine fauna in the basin northeast of Mitchell, consisting of late Neocomian molluscs, and the Minmi Member contains a diverse, shallow marine fauna of early Aptian age. Conformably overlying the Bungil Formation is the marine and paralic Wallumbilla Formation, which is generally 200-300 m thick , and thickest in the Mimosa Syncline. It comprises two members, the older of which is the late Aptian marine Doncaster M ember, which consists of thick carbonaceous mudstone sequences with some thinly interbedded 66

siltstone and sandstone intervals. The Doncaster Member is generally 100-150 m thick, but reaches about 200 m in the central Mimosa Syncline. It intertongues with the underlying Bungil Formation in places. Widely spaced calcareous strata, which are commonly concretionary, contain a rich and varied macrofauna . The fauna is dominantly molluscan, glauconite is a common constituent, and fossil logs are abundant in the Mitchell area. The member is a ma rine unit, much of which was laid down below normal wave base. This was the peak of the Cretaceous transgression in the Surat Basin, and connections with the open sea existed to the northwest and east. Cycle VI The early Albian paralic Coreena Member consists essentially of various mixtures of mudstone, siltstone, and fine-grained lithic sandstone, but intraformational conglomerate and coal are minor constituents. The member is generally about I 00 m thick, but thins to 50 m in the northwest, and thickens to a maximum of about 200 m in the southern Mimosa Syncline. The sandstone is lithic, commonly glauconitic and calcareous, and generally thinly bedded and cross-laminated . The marine molluscan fauna is relatively impoverished, but belemnite coquinites, which may have accumulated on beaches, are striking constituents in some areas. The member marks a regression of the Cretaceous sea toward the northwest, with closure of the eastern entrance, and a sudden influx of volcanic detritus, which continued throughout deposition of the Albian sequence. Overlying the Wallumbilla Formation is the paralic Surat Siltstone, which contains interbedded siltstone, carbonaceous mudstone, and fine-grained glauconitic sandstone. It is generally I 00 to 130 m thick. Small pelecypods are common in the formation, which was laid down in a shallow sea, probably largely on mudflats and in estuaries. Griman Creek Formation The youngest Cretaceous unit preserved in the Surat Basin is the late Albian Griman Creek Formation. It is extensively eroded, and its maximum preserved thickness is 480 m. Major constituents are glauconitic and commonly calcareous lithic sandstone, and silt-


stone; minor constitu ents are mudston e and intrafor mationa l conglom erate. Mollusc an coquinit es characte rise the lower part of the formatio n , and intrafor mationa l conglomerate and coal the upper part. The formation marks the final regression in the Surat Basin, with paralic depositi on early and coastal plain depositi on thereafter. LATER EVENT S During the Late Cretace ous and Early Tertiary there was steady erosion and pediplanation , and a deep weather ing profile developed . In Oligocene and Miocene time, basalt was poured out in the north , east, and south of the Surat Basin. This volcanism was probabl y associated with epeirogenic movements, which increased the basinward tilt first developed in the Middle and Late Jurassic . Thereaf ter, the basin has remained very stable with erosion predom inating over deposition.

COAL DEPOSITS Coal seams are present in the finer-grained upper parts of the thick Jurassic cycles mention ed earlier and the paralic parts of the marine Cretace ous sequence. They formed in various swamps : fringing lakes, between stream channel s, between deltaic distribu taries, and fringing the sea. The thickest coal seams can generally be expected where coal measures are thickest, so isopach maps of coal measures should give some assistance in prospec ting for coal. Seams in the Walloon Coal Measure s and the Orallo Formati on have been worked, and those in the Walloon Coal Measure s appear to have the greatest potentia l for future mining. Early Jurassic depositi on was thickest in the north along the axis of the old Taroom and Denison Troughs of the Bowen Basin, and eastwar d through into the Moreton Basin. With time , the main depocen tre moved southward along the Mimosa Syncline, which overlies the Taroom Trough. The oldest coals in the basins are very thin seams in the upper Precipice Sandsto ne and the Evergreen Formati on, a stratigra phic sequence which became generally more marine with time. The coals formed in local short-lived swamps developed on the coastal plain. The most extensive coal seams are in the Injune Creek Group, which is thickest in the

north and east. The maximu m preserved thickness of the group is about 850 m in the northern Mimosa Syncline, and 700 m in the Cecil Plains Syncline north of Millmerran (Fig. 6). Streams drained from the west and south, where sands are abundan t, to the northea st, where they are compara tively rare (see Fig. 5). The most importa nt coals in the basin are those of the Walloon Coal Measure s, which were deposited in extensive swamps in the north and east, where more than 400 m of coal measures is preserved, and where most of the existing Authori ties to Prospec t for coal are concent rated. Maximu m preserved thicknesses are 300 m, west of Injune, 550 m, in the northern Mimosa Syncline, and 500 m, in the Cecil Plains Syncline. Average depositi onal rates of more than 5 cm per thousan d years were the highest of any Jurassic sequence, and may have been caused, in part, by rapid sinking complem entary to Middle Jurassic uplift of the Auburn Arch . The Walloon Coal Measure s in the northern Surat Basin have been extensively drilled by the Geological Survey of Queensl and, and the results summar ised by Swarbri ck ( 1973), who split the sequence into six intervals. Althoug h facies changes are common both vertically and laterally , coals of econom ic significance are confined to his interval 5, low in the sequence, and intervals 7 and 8 at the top of the sequence. In the Mimosa Syncline and at Injune, coal makes up about 4% of the Walloon Coal Measures (Swarbrick, 1973). Within the area covered by this paper, coal seams have been worked at the Marano a Colliery near Injune, and at Warra . By mid 1979 reserves of about 2000 million tonnes had been delineated in the Queensl and portions of the Surat and Moreton Basins (Queensland Departm ent of Mines, 1979). Reporte d individual seam thicknesses are: Marano a Colliery, 1.4 m (Hawth orne, 1971 ); Back Creek near Taroom , 5 m (Swarbrick, 1973); Brigalow , 10.7 m (King, 1976); Warra, 1.3 m (Cribb, 1944); Millmer ran, 6 m (King, 1976). The only present- day working s are further east, in the Rosewo od-Wall oon Coalfield and the Oakey-A cland Coalfield . The Walloon coals are typically subbitumin ous to bitumin ous and perhydr ous, with a greasy lustre, a conchoi dal fracture and a poorly developed cleat. Accordi ng to King 67


~

14;._:1_·_ _ _ _ _ _....,..._ _

_ _ _ _.......;,c,.•:..9"_ _ _

_ _ _--,_ _ _ _ _

M•

_ _.:.;,s;.c'• ---,

,s,•

2 5° 25'

50

100km

0

Conto ur Interv al 50m L...J-J

Erosional margin of isopa ched Top of outcrop of isopached

Fault

Fig. 6. lsopachs of Injune Creek

Gro up.

sequence

sequence

Data Point

- 200 - lsopachs

50

100km

Conto ur Interv al 50 m r._.L.... ,I

- - -

Erosional margin of coal meas ures Top of outcrop of coal meas ures

Fig. 7. lsopachs of Walloon Coa

l Measures.

Data Poin t -200 - /sopachs


( 1976), they contain about 35-42% volatile matter 30-39% fixed carbon, 5-10% inherent moisture, and 12-27% ash ; their high hydrogen content (6-7%) makes them suitable for liquefaction . Thin coal seams are present in the Springbok Sandstone , and in the lower part of the Westbourn e Formation , the orwood Mudstone Member (Swarbrick , 1973). The two formations make up a sedimentar y cycle, with fluvial deposition giving way to paralic deposition with time. The coals were laid down in non-marin e swamps on coastal plains. Any thick coal seams are likely to occur where the whole sequence is thickest: west of Injune, in the northern Mimosa Syncline, in the Cecil Plains Syncline, around Talwood in the south, and in the Dirranban di Syncline. The Orallo Formation contains coal seams which were once worked on a very small scale, and it was originally known as the Orallo Coal Measures (Jensen, 1926). The formation is generally fluvial, and coals were deposited in non-marin e swamps. Lignitic coals up to

80 cm thick crop out between Mitchell and Miles, and somewhat thicker seams have been reported in nearby bores. Two Orallo coal have been analysed , and the cleaner of the e was comparabl e in compositio n to Walloon coals (Jensen, 1926). The formation is thickest in the central Mimosa Syncline and the Dirranban di Syncline, and thicker seams might be present there. Thin coal seams occur within the paralic Kingull Member of the Bungil Formation , and the paralic Coreena Member of the Wallumbilla Formation . These sequences are thicker in the southern Mimosa Syncline, and thicker coal seams could be present near outcrop there. Thin coal seams also occur within the coastal plain deposits of the upper Griman Creek Formation . ACKNOW LEDGME NTS

I am grateful for comments by G. E. Wilford and H. A. Jones on early versions of this paper, and to A. J . Maxwell, B. Pashley and . Price for drawing the figures .

REFERE CES ALLEN , R . J., 1971 : Deep stratigraphic core drilling as an aid to petroleum exploration . APEA J. , 11(2), 80-84. CRIBB, H. G . S., 1944: Coal occurrences at Warra. Pubis Geo/. Surv. Qd, 344. Exo , N . F ., 1976: Geology of the Surat Basin in Queensland . Bull. Bur. Miner. Resour. Geo/. Geophys. Aust., 166. GRAY, A. R . G ., 1972: Stratigraphic drilling in the Surat and Bowen Basins. Rep . Geo/. Surv. Qd, 71. HAWTHOR E, W. L. , 1971 : Maranoa mine area , lnjune. Ree. Geo/. Surv. Qd, /971 / 17 (unpubl.). JENSEN , A. R., Exo ' . F ., ANDERSON , J. c. and KOPPE, W. H. , 1976: A guide to the geology of the Bowen and Surat Ba ins in Queensland . 25th International Geological Congress Excursion Guide 3C. JENSE , H . I. , 1926: Geological reconnais ance between Roma, Springsure, Tambo and Taroom. Pubis Geo/. Sun>. Qd, 277. KtNG, D ., 1976: A review of the coal resources of Australia. Qd Govt Min . J ., 77, 53-63. MOLLAN , R. G ., FORBES, Y. R., JE SE ' A. R., Exo ' . F . and GREGORY, C. M., 1972: Geology of the l:.ddystone, Taroom and western part of the Mundubbera Sheet areas, Queensland. Rep . Bur. Miner. Resour. Geol. Geophys. Aust., 142. PORTER, C.R ., 1979: Fluvio-deltai c deposition in Lower Jurassic sediments of the Surat Basin, Queensland . APEA J ., 19(2), 37-49.

POWER, P. E. and DEVINE, S. B., 1970: Surat Basin, Australia- subsurface stratigraphy, history and petroleum. Bull. Am. Ass. Petrol. Geol., 54, 2410-37. QUEENSLAND DEPARTMENT OF MINES, 1979: Queensland reserves of black coal June 1979. Qd Govt . Min. J., 80, 323-326. REEVES, F. , 1947: Geology of Roma district, Queensland Australia. Bull. Am. Ass. Petrol. Geol. , 31, I 34171. SWARBRICK , C. F . J. , 1973: Stratigraphy and economic potential of the lnjune Creek Group in the Surat Basin . Rep. Geol. Surv. Qd, 79. VAIL, P. R. , MITCHUM , R. M. and THOMPSON , S., 1977: Seismic stratigraphy and global changes of sea level, Part 4: Global cycles of relative changes of sea level. in Payton, C. E. (Ed}, Seismic stratigraphy- applications to hydrocarbon exploration. M em . Am. Ass. Petrol. Geo/., 26, 8397. WHITEHOUSE, F. W ., 1954: The geology of the Queensland portion of the Great Arte ian Basin; Appendix G in Artesian water supplies in Queensland . Departme/11 of the Co-ordinator-General of Public Wo!ks, Qd Par/. Pap., A56-1955 .

N. F. EXON, Bureau of Mineral Resources, Geology and Geophysics, Cnr Constituti on A venue and Anzac Parade, Canberra, A.C.T., 2600.

69


EARLY JURASS IC SEDIME T ATIO

THE SURAT BASI

By K. R. Martin ABSTRACT The Precipice Sandston e is an early Jurassic quartzose sandston e which is·· the basal formation of the Surat Basin sequence. In outcrop and over much of the subsurfac e, the formation is a medium to coarse grained clean, porous quartzose sandston e which shows well developed medium scale planar cro s bedding. The sandston e in the subsurfac e on the Roma Ridge is more and size grain its in variable porosity/ permeabi lity, but is generally finer grained than elsewhere in the basin. Medium scale cross bedding is not as widely developed in the formatio n on the Roma Ridge but fining upwards sediment ary cycles are common . The cross bedding shown by the Precipice Sandston e over much of the Surat Basin is typical of that produced by transvers e bar migration in a braided stream system flowing on a gradient of approxim ately I m/km. The sandston e on the Roma Ridge shows character istics of a lower gradient meanderi ng stream depositio nal system. when evident are Inconsistencies palaeoslo pe direction , indicated by cross bedding, is compare d with that obtained by use of the datum plane-valley floor isopach method . Palaeocu rrent direction s from cross bedding how a consisten t west to east current direction across the Surat Basin, whereas the basin-like a suggests map isopach configura tion with a palaeoslo pe to the west and north west on the east side of the basin and gradients up to 7 m/km in the north of the basin. Such high gradients are incompat ible with grain size and sediment ary structure data and appear to be a result of differential subsidence of the underlyin g Permo-T riassic Basin sequence causing the Bowen configura tion of the unconfor mity surface to change during the time interval between the erosion of the unconfor mity surface and the depositio n of the datum plane (Evergreen Resistivity Marker). The Precipice Sandston e is younger on the western side of the Surat Basin than on the eastern side and represents a fluviatile facies

which transgressed westward and wa replaced by the lacustrine facies of the The Formatio n. Evergreen overlying probably Ridge Roma the sandston e on represents the last stages of low energy fluviatile depositio n just prior to lacu trine condition s becoming established througho ut the basin. Whether there was any significant sediment source on the eastern side of the Surat Basin during the early Jurassic is debatable . Radiome tric dating of micas from the Precipice Sandston e suggest that the main sediment source lay to the west and south of the Great Artesian Basin in the Precamb rian areas such as the Willyama Block. I TRODU CTIO The aim of this paper is to illustrate an approach to basin analysis using, a an example, the Precipice Sandston e in the Surat Basin. The Precipice Sandston e is a quartz-ri ch sandston e which constitut es the basal formation of the Surat Basin in Queensla nd . It is of early Jurassic age and was deposited on an erosion surface formed as a result of widespread uplift in the late Trias ic. Although this discussion is confined to the Surat Basin, the Precipice Sandston e or its equivalents extend well beyond the Surat Basin into the Mulgildie and Moreton Basin to the east and into the Eromang a Basin to the west where the formatio n is traceable at least as far as Tambo. STRUCT URAL ELEME TS (Fig. I) The northern limits of the Surat Basin are erosional , defined by the outcrop of the Precipice Sandston e which forms a sinuou cliff scarp from east of Cracow for over 350 km to west of Carnarvo n Gorge where the formation crosses the Nebine Ridge and passes into the Eromang a Basin. The eastern boundary of the Surat Basin is formed by the Auburn Arch , Yarrama n Block, New England Block and the subsurfac e Kumbari lla Ridge. 71


I

N

I I I

"'I ';l!I ':ii

i.,_ i;

~\ },.\

If) \

~~

I

t

\

MILES '{

s:tl

e

~ ::)

If)\

It

~\

::)

Ill

i\ I

I

I I

•ST GEORG E 0

40

80 Km

I I

I

D U

Fig. l . Structu ral elements of the Surat Basi n.

The depos itiona l axis of the Surat Basin is the Mimo sa Syncline which lies towar ds the easter n side of the basin and is coinci dent with the Taroo m Troug h, the depos itiona l axis of the under lying Bowen Basi n. To the east of the Mimo sa Syncline is the Goon diwin di-Mo onie-B urung a Fault 72

System , a merid ional fault system which has recently been interp reted as a thrust fault (Porte r et al. , 1977). On the western side of the basin is the Roma Ridge , a fault- bound ed subsu rface, shelf-like extens ion of the Nebin e Ridge . The presen t basin config uratio n is evident


I I J

0

I

\ iN JUNE \

\

.0

I

- 200

~

I

I

·' , ~

- : :~TC H!CL

•: ~ ~

I I

I

J,M iTC M[ L L

I

-600

-•

\" "t

I~

i~ ' r.I

N

"

N

0

/

-- .•\

GOO NOl WINOI

'·

,,,..-······

I

,, -

CO N TOU R

I N TERVAL •

-

-

-

J

200 m 0

MOREE

• co,n tours- base of Precipice Sa nd stone. Fig. 2. Structure

f.;;

CONTO UINI

I NT!IIIVAL • 4 0III

F 1•g.3. Isopach map of the Precipice Sandstone.

......... -. _


from the structure contours drawn on the base of the Precipice Sandstone (Fig. 2). The general southerly dip of the sequence reflects basin tilting, which occurred during the Cretaceous (Power and Devine, 1970). Otherwise the sequence is essentially undeformed with fold structures due to differential compaction around basement highs.

DISTRIBUTION AND CHARACTERISTICS OF THE PRECIPICE SANDSTONE The isopach map of the Precipice Sandstone (Fig. 3) indicates a maximum of I 20+m in the Mimosa Syncline adjacent to the Goondiwindi-Mooni e-Burunga Fault System . The formation also thickens abruptly across the fault particularly in the vicinity of Moonie. On the Roma Ridge the sandstone thickness is variable but less than 40 m. Throughout the outcrop section and over much of the Surat Basin in the subsurface, the Precipice Sandstone is a medium-coarse grained, porous and permeable quartzose sandstone. In the Roma area, the sandstone is less mineralogically mature; it contains more mica, feldspar and rock fragments than elsewhere and is sometimes cemented by calcite. Porosity and permeability vary drastically over short distances and grain size is more varied but generally finer than elsewhere in the basin . Some of the differences in mineralogy and porosity-permeabilit y are due in part to diagenesis (Martin, 1977) but differences in grain size and sedimentary structures do indicate environmental differences between the Roma area and much of the basin to the east and north. SEDIMENTARY STRUCTURES Cross-stratification is the main sedimentary structure present in the Precipice Sandstone and is particularly obvious in outcrop sections (Plate I). It is almost exclusively of the medium scale, planar type closely resembling the omikron-type cross-strata of Allen ( 1963). The sets have an average dip of25 ° and range up to 3 m in thickness although most are in the range of 20 cm- I m. The sets are not internally homogeneous but consist of alternations of well sorted sand laminae which differ in their mean grain size. Individual laminae rarely exceed 1.5 cm in thickness and are often 74

lenticular over distances less than 0.5 m. The bounding surfaces between sets are erosional and usually flat or gently undulating but not necessarily parallel to the upper surfaces of sets of cross-strata. The lenticular nature of most of the observed cross-strata is due to truncation at low angles by erosional surfaces. Quartzose lag pebbles are commonly found irregularly distributed on the erosion surfaces or forming thin beds of pebble conglomerate. At some loca tions the erosion surfaces form broad trough shaped scours up to I O m wide and 2 m deep. These scour channels are generally infilled with a sequence commencing with rounded quartzose lag pebbles overlain by massive coarse-very coarse sandstone then medium-coarse, planar cross-stratified sandstone. Cross-stratification types other than medium scale planar are rare in the outcrop sections, with only a few examples of medium scale trough cross-stratification and small scale (ripple drift) cross-stratification being seen. The occasional thin, fine grained sandstones intercalated between cross stratified medium-coarse sandstones appear to be mainly horizontally bedded. From cores it is possible to recognise the characteristics of the formation in outcrop over much of its subsurface extent although discrimination between medium scale planar and trough cross-stratification cannot be reliably made on the basis of core samples. In the vicinity of the Roma Ridge medium scale cross-stratification is less well developed in the Precipice Sandstone and where present it is often associated with fining upwards seq uences which consist of an erosional base, often with a layer oflag pebbles or shale clasts, overlain by a medium-coarse grained crossstratified sandstone which in turn grades up into a ripple drift cross-stratified or horizontally bedded fine sandstone or siltstone. Many cores of the Precipice Sandstone in the Roma area contain significant intervals of fine sandstone, siltstone and shale which may be horizontally or irregularly bedded or ripple drift cross stratified, and are often highly carbonaceous. Shale clasts, which are the products of erosion of poorly consolidated muds, are common in cores from that Roma area and also occur in the sandstone elsewhere in the Surat Basin. Carbonised plant fragments are also widespread . Ripple marks are rare.


processes and those which are the result of vertical accreti on processes. Point bars, channe l bars and alluvial islands are lateral accreti on deposi ts compo sed chiefly of bed load materi al and formed during lateral migrat ion of stream channe ls across the floodplain . Levees , crevasse-splays and flood basin deposi ts are vertical accreti on deposi ts formed by the settling of suspen ded load during overba nk flows . The quanti ty of suspen ded load being carried by a stream may also influence the config uration of its channe l and the resulting lateral accreti on deposi ts. Allen (1965) places channel-fill deposi ts, formed in cut-off channe ls and decayi ng channe ls, in a separa te catego ry (transi tional) because they may be compo sed of either bedloa d or suspen ded load sediments. Stream s may be classified on the basis of their sinuosity (Schum m, 1963) which is the ratio of channe l length to down valley di stance. The bound ary between high and low sinuos ity stream s is usually put at 1.5. Alternatively stream s may be classified accord ing Plate I. Typical exposure of the Precipice Sandstone to their channe l config uration into either showing planar cross-stratification. meand ering or braide d categories. Meand ering stream s are high sinuosity wherea s braidENVIRONMENT OF DEPOSITION ed stream s are of low sinuosity, and consist of an anasta mosin g system of channels. The Precipice Sandst one has generally been Factor s which favour the develo pment of regard ed as fluviatile by most previo us braidin g instead of meand ering include high author s (e.g. Power and Devine , 1970, Exon, nts, high bedloa d volum es and large gradie nment enviro fluviatile The 1976). variati ons in discharge. Table 1 lists the encom passes a spectru m of energy levels and general charac teristic s of the floodplain desubenv ironme nts transit ional from the high posits of meand ering and braide d stream s. nt gradie nt alluvial fan down to the low gradie To provid e a basis for interpr etation of in le desirab re meand ering stream . It is therefo ancien t fluviatile deposi ts a four-fold suband interpr etation enviro nment al division offluv iatile enviro nment s is propos ed palaeo geogra phic recons tructio n to be able to here (Table 2). A more compl ete review of the ile fluviat separa te the subenv ironme nts of the literatu re on which this subdivision is based is system. given in Martin ( 1976). This classification of Depos its of fluviatile origin which are fluviatile regimes utilises the conclu sions of preserved in the geological record mostly Schum m ( 1963, 1968) concer ning the signifriver on represe nt the sediments deposi ted icance of suspen ded load in the developm~nt floodplains . Study of moder n floodplains (e.g. of stream sinuosity. The transit ion from a Allen , 1965) has shown that they are longitu dinal to a transverse bar domin ated compo sed of several elements which may be regime accom panyin g a decrease in gradie nt nature the on variab ly developed depend ent has been described by Smith ( 1970). From the of the river responsible for floodplain literal\Jre on moder n rivers it is also possible format ion . These elements are: point bars, to suggest a general gradie nt range for the cutoff channe l bars and alluvial islands , different regimes. channe ls and channe l fills , levees, crevasse In enviro nment al interpr etation of the A ). wamps (backs basins flood splays and ice Sandst one the main charac teristic s Precip distinc tion can be made between those ed by a deposi tional model are: explain be to on accreti elements which result from lateral 75


Table !--Characteristics of Flood Plain Deposits

BRAIDED STREAM Dl!posil Type

Sedime/11 Charac1eris1ics

Transverse Bar

Medium-coa rse sand, showing planar cross bedding with dips generally in range 25 30 ' . Ripple movement across the bar to the lee side avalanche face results in alternations of grain size in the planar cross-stratification.

Longitudinal Bar

Coarse sand-gravel. May show crude horizontal layering or sometimes trough or planar cross-stratification. Cross-strata may be orientated at large angles to stream direction.

Deposil Type

Sedimenl Charac1eris1ics

MEANDER ING STREAM Point Bar

Fining upwards sequence-er osional base overlain by lag pebbles then mediumcoarse cross-stratified sands and then to fine grained sands and si lts. Medium-coa rse sands in the lower section of the point bar exhibit both planar and trough cross-stratification with trough types probably most common. Fine grained upper point bar sequence shows either small scale (ripple drift) crossstratification or horizontal lamination .

Levee

Wedge shaped deposits of interbedded fine sands, silts and silty clays. May show small-scale cross-stratification or wavy bedding and ripple marks and may be bioturbated.

Crevasse Splay

A tongue-shaped mass of sediment deposited by a series of distributary channels. May show a lateral gradation in grain size from fine sands near the channel to silts and clays in the distal sections. Sediments may show lamination, wavy bedding or small scale cross-stratification.

Flood Basin

Uniform silts and clays with little sand. Sediments highly carbonaceou s and peat la yers often abundant.

Channel Fill

Only limited, coarse grained bedload sediment. Most sediment is fine grai ned- silty sands to clays. Lamination and small cross-stratification may occur.

Table 2-Classificat ion of Fluviatile Regimes

Type

High Gradie111 L o11· Si1111osi1y

M edium Gradienl L oll' Simwsi1y

Lo11· Gradienl Mod. Si1111osi1y

Lo11· Gradil'nl High Sinuosi1y

Sinuosity Channel Config.

< 1.5 Braided

< 1.5 Mainl y Braided

Type of Sediment Transport (Schumm, 1968) Main Lateral Accretion Form Dominant Grain Sizes of Bedload Gradient

Bed Load

Bed Load

Longitudinal Bar Coarse Sand - Gravel > 0.002

Transverse Bar Medium Sand

1.5-2.0 Mainly Broad Meanders Mixed Load Bedload Dominant Point Bar

> 2.0 Tight Meanders Mixed Load Susp. Load Dominant Poin.t Bar

Fine-Medium Sand 0.0005

Fine-Medium Sand < 0.0002

Discharge

76

0.001 Decrease

Periodic High Discharge

Approaching Uniform Discharge


pre-Precipice topograp hic surface. From Table 2 it can be seen that such gradients would support braided streams depositin g longitudi nal bars of gravel sized material and not medium- coarse sand in transverse bars which is the case with the Precipice Sandston e. The most obvious explanati on for the configura tion of the unconfor mity-ER M isopach maps is that they represent a measure of the amount of differential subsidence which has occurred beneath the Surat Basin during the accumula tion of the Precipice -ERM interval. If significant differential subsidence did occur during the accumula tion of thi interval, its effect would be to mask the true palaeo lope and render the datum planevalley floor isopach method unusable as a means of reconstru cting palaeoslope ince the effect of differential subsidence is to alter the configura tion of the unconfor mity surface. The most likely cause of this subsidence i differential compacti on of the fine grained sediment ary rocks in the underlying Bowen Basin equence. An isopach map of the total Triassic section of the Bowen Basin sequence (Fig. 6) hows that the Triassic sequence thickens rapidly PALAEOCURREN T DI RECTIO S from le s than I 000 m over much of the basin Palaeocu rrent data based on 422 crossto over 5000 m in the north of the basin in the stratification measurem ents in outcrop (Fig. Taroom Trough. This sequence includes sev4) indicate a general easterly stream flow eral fine grained , readily compacta ble lithoacross the northern Surat Basin between logies, (Rewan Group, Moolaye mber ForCarnarvo n Gorge and Cracow. This is at and significantly more compacti on mation) variance with the palaeoslope reconstru ction generated ubsidence is likely to have occurpre ented by Power and Devine (1970) and red in the northern Mimosa Syncline than Sell, Brown and Groves ( 1972), using the in the basin and this would account elsewhere datum plane-valley floor isopach method of u ly high palaeogra dient anomalo the for Andresen ( 1962). Both of the e reconstrucmity-ER M i opach unconfor the by suggested tions involve an isopach map of the interval tion of the total configura general The maps. from the unconfor mity at the ba e of the a close resemblance to bears isopach Triassic Precipice Sandston e to a marker within the the unconfor mity-ER M isopach map (Fig. 5), overlying Evergreen Formatio n termed the further supports the contentio n that which Evergreen Resistivity Marker (ERM) . This accumula tion in the early Jurassic sediment isopach map is taken to represent the coninfluenced by differential substrongly was figuration of the unconfor mity surface on compacti on in the underlying to sidence due which the Precipice Sandston e was deposited. Basin sequence . Bowen The isopach map of Sell et al. ( 1972) i shown Isopach maps figured in Power and Devine in Fig. 5. In the north-eas t sector of the Surat (I 970) and Exon ( 1976) sugge t that Basin a northwes terly palaeoslope is indifferential subsidence within the Bowen dicated, which conflicts with the northeast erly Basin sequence continue d to influence sediby to southeast erly palaeoslope indicated accumula tion at least until the end of the ment the of area general this In . cross-stratification Jura sic as all Jurassic units show a consistent basin palaeoslopes measured from the isothickening towards the axis of the Mimosa high pachs are as high as 7 m/km . Such Syncline. the for c unrealisti d gradients are considere

(I) the predomin ance of erosionally bounded , medium scale planar cross-stratification in outcrop and in much of the subsurface sequence. (2) a more varied lithology on the Roma Ridge containin g fining upwards sequences and significant intervals of carbonaceou s siltstones and shales. From Tables I and 2 it is evident that the ubiquitou s planar cross-stratification in the Precipice Sandston e most closely resembles that produced by the migration of tran ver e bars in a braided stream environm ent. The braided streams which deposited the Precipice Sandston e probably flowed across a land surface of little relief with a gradient of approxim ately I m/km. The sandston e on the Roma Ridge wa deposited by meanderi ng stream as point bars with interbedd ed finer grained overbank deposit . The palaeogr adient was probably less than that prevailing elsewhere in the Surat Ba in and may have been in the vicinity of 0.5 m/ km.

77


-.J

00

~,oo,m CANIA GORG E MULGILDIE RIFT

,. CRACOW

• TAROOM

t INJUNE

0

==:.--= ~30

Fig. 4. Cross stratification azimuths in the p:::.: .: : : : : - - - - - - - - --- - = = = = ~ K : m ' __ rec1p1ce Sandstone.

_

_

_ __ __

_


... • SURAT

o:LI

.... o

.,0

(, ... ...

Q

1!10

, oo 0

N

-..... ... ,··

I

,, -~ J--,G OO "IOIWINOI

I '-, ..... ,..·•

I

-·

,.

CONTOUlt

tNUIIIVAL

• 2~0 ,11T C ON TOUIIII

~~- ~•o --~•••· 20

Fig. 5. lsopach map- Evergreen Resistivity Marker to base of Precipice. (From Sell, Brown & Groves ( 1972))

20

t _....,.L_

INTUh'AL

40

IO OOm

•M OIUE

10

...J...._ __ , ,. •

Fig. 6. Isopach map of the Triassic sequence beneath the Surat Basin.


PALAEOGEOGRAPHY OF THE SURAT BASIN IN THE EARLY JURASSIC

From palynological evidence it has been shown th a t the Precipice Sandstone is diach ronous a nd becomes progressively younger in a westerly direction across the basin (Reiser and Williams, 1969). The formation represents a flu viatile facies which migrated in a westerly direction as a non-marine transgression and was replaced by the lower energy fluvio-lacustrine Evergreen Formation . The meandering stream environment which prevailed on the Roma Ridge represents a transition between the higher energy braided streams during earlier stages of Precipice deposition and the lower energy fluviolacustrine conditions of the Evergreen Formation. The Precipice sandstone on the Roma Ridge is probably coeval with the basal Evergreen Formation deposited to the east and north of the Roma Ridge. The Precipice-Evergreen interval is the first of five depositional cycles recognised in the Surat Basi n sequence. Each of these cycles commences with the deposition of a highenergy fluviatile sa ndstone which grades into fluvio-lacustrine and in some cases even marine deposits (Exo n, 1976). PROVENANC E OF THE PRECIPICE SANDSTONE

There is little evidence of sediment contribution from the Auburn Arch which may not have been an elevated area during early Jurassic times. This would have allowed rivers to flow to the east into the Mulgildie Basin as suggested by the cross-stratification azimuths. The New England Fold Belt may have contributed some sediment to the Precipice Sandstone as much of the Jurassic sequence in the southeast of the basin is sandy and current directions measured in the Piliga Sandstone on the southeast edge of the basin suggest a ediment sou rce to the south and east later in the Jurassic. Potassium-a rgon dating of 6 muscovite amples from the Precipice Sandstone yielded five dates in the range 460-521 million years and one date of 620 million years (A. W. Webb pers. comm.). These ages predate metamorphic events in the Tasman Orogenic Zone and post-date the major periods of metamorphism in the central Australian Precambrian blocks. However they do agree 80

closely with a major period of retrogressive metamorphism dated at 500 million years in the Willyama Block (Vernon, 1969). Retrograde schists cover large areas around Broken Hill and may represent a source for the muscovite samples giving dates around 500 million years. Some additional support for the Willyama Block as a sediment source is the presence in the Precipice Sandstone of garnets characteristic of upper amphibolite and granulite facies of regional metamorphism together with a variety of tourmalines. Amphibolite and granulite facies rocks, together with a varied suite of retrogressive metamorphic rocks including tourmaline schists, are widespread throughout the Willyama Block. Thus a major sediment source for the Precipice Sandstone may have been from the Precambrian rocks bordering the western and southwestern sides of the Great Artesian Basin. The presence of fresh garnet in the Precipice Sandstone suggests a direct first cycle contribution from those areas rather tha n by reworking of Palaeozoic sedimentary rocks derived from westerly Precambrian sources.

CONCLUSION S

( 1) The Precipice Sandstone is a diachronous fluviatile facies deposited mostly as transverse bars by a braided stream system flowing in a general easterly direction on a gradient of approximately 1 m/km. (2) The last phase of Precipice Sandstone deposition , such as is seen on the Roma Ridge indicates a meandering stream environment suggesting a lowering of gradient and energy prior to deposition of the Evergreen Formation. (3) Variations in thickness of the sandstone in the Surat Basin are mostly the result of differential compaction in the underlying Bowen Basin sequence. (4) A major sediment source for the sandstone may have been from the Precambrian rocks bordering the west and southwest sides of the Great Artesian Basin. (5) The factors which influenced sediment type and thickness in the PrecipiceEvergreen interval are likely to be similar to those influencing later cycles such as the Hutton-Walloo n interval.


ACK OWLEDG ME TS

This paper forms part of a PhD research project at the University of Queensland .

Thanks are due to Dr. G . R. Orme who supervised the project.

REFEREN CES ALLE . J. R. L., 1963:Theclas sificationofc ross-stratifie d units, with notes on their origin. Sedimemolog y . 2, 93-114. ALLEN, J. R . L. , 1965: A review of the origin and characteristic s of recent alluvial sediments. Sedimentology, 5, 89-191. A NDRESEN, M . J. , 1962: Paleodrainag e patterns: their mapping from subsurface data , and their paleogeograp hic value. Bull. Am. Ass. Petrol. Geol., 46(3 ), 398-405. . F., 1976: Geology of the Surat Basin in Exo , Queensland. Bull. Bur. Miner. Resour. Geol. Geophys .. Aust., 166. Mc GowE , J . H. and GARNER, L. E., 1970: Physiographic features and stratification types of coarse-graine d point bars: modern and ancient examples. Sedimentolog y, 14, 77-111. MARTI N, K . R., 1976: Sedimentolog y of the Precipice Sandstone, Surat Basin, Queensland. Thesis. Univ. Qd (unpubl.). MARTI , K . R .. 1977: Diagenetic processes in the Precipice Sandstone Surat Basin, Queensla nd . 2nd Aust. Geol. Conv. Melbourne. (Abs.). PORTER, C. R ., SEEDSMAN, K . R .. WILTSHIR E. M . J .. KEE IHAN. S. L. a nd ASHTON. S. M .. 1977: Surat Basi n- Petroleum potential and prospects in Petroleum in Queensland . A stocktake for the future. Petrol. Exp/. Soc. Aust. Sym. POWER. P. E. and DEVINE. S. B.. 1970: Sura1 Basin . Au stra lia- subsurface stra tigraphy. hi story and petroleum . Bull. Am. Ass. Petrol. Geol .. 54(12). 2410-2437 .

REISER , R . F. and WILLIAMS. A . J., 1969: Palynology of the Lower Jurassic sed iments of the northern Surat Basin, Queensland . Pubis Geol. Surv. Qd. 339. SCHUMM , S. A., 1963: Sinuosity of a lluvial rivers on the Great Plains. Bull. Geol. Soc. Am. 74, 10891100. SCHUMM , S. A .. 1968: River adjustments to altered hydrologic regimen- Murrumbidg ee River and paleochannel s, Australia . U. S . Geol. Surv. Prof. Pap . 598. SELL, B. H ., BROW , L. . and GROVES, R . D ., 1972: Basal Jurassic sa nd s of the Rom a area. Qd Govt Min . J ., 73, 309-321. SMITH, . D., 1970: The braided stream depositional environment : comparison of the Platte Ri ve r with some Silurian elastic rocks, north-central Appalachian s. Bull. Geol. Soc. Am., 81 , 29933014. VER 'ON, R . P.., 1969: The Willya ma Complex. Broken Hill area. in Packman. G. H . (Ed.), The Geology of ew South Wales. J. Geol. Soc. Aust .. 16, 2054.

K. R. MARTIN ,

Departmen t of Applied Geology, Queensland Institute of Technology, Brisbane, Queensland. 4000.

81


THE COAL- FORMI G FLORA OF THE WALLO O

COAL MEASU RES

By Rod Gould ABSTRACT

Plant mega fossil s recovered from sediments of the Middle Jurassic Walloon Coal Measures in southea stern Queensl and and northeastern New South Wales include representatives of the liverworts, lycopods, equisetaleans, ferns, seed-ferns, cycadeoids, possible pentoxylaleans, and conifers , all of which were mostly growing at or very near to the site of depositi on. Such occurrences in finegrained detrital sedimen tary rocks enable recognition of forms within the flora , whereas in the coal itself individual specimens, which are affected by peatification and are not separate d by inorganic sedimen t are less easily discernible. The coal is essentially autochthono us, the original peat being formed from plants which grew in situ. Plants contributing to the accumu lation of the peat can be roughly divided into spore-be aring herbaceous plants (e.g. ferns) and pollen/seedbearing woody plants (e.g. cycadeoids and conifers). In many instances where fossils are present, fine-grained sediments immediately beneath coal seams contain a predom inance of spore-be aring herbace ous plants in addition to plant roots, while fine-grained sediments immediately overlying seams con fain a greater percentage of conifers; however , this is by no means an inflexible rule and there are different lateral variatio ns. The bulk of the coal appears to be derived from conifer material with addition al contribu tions from certain herbace ous plants as well as cycadeoids; evidence from petrogra phic examination of the coal and palaeopalynological studies essentially agrees with this interpretation . The nature and structur e of floral elements suggest the plants grew in a moist, tempera te climate. INTRO DUCTI ON

The accumu lation of peat and subsequ ent formatio n of coal seams involves a complex interplay of geographical, biological, and geological factors , and the particul ar role of each in the occurrence and resultan t nature of the coal is not unquest ionably indepen dent of the others. Hence the evidence presented here,

based mainly on plant inegafossils, must be treated in that context. In addition to the usual problems attenda nt to the study of plant megafossils, such as the fragmen tary nature of most specimens and the undoubt edly incomplete represen tation of the total flora in any collection, the determi nation of the floral elements which contribu ted to the precursive peat for a particul ar coal has a further degree of uncertai nty. The identity of individual plant megafossil remains within the coal is generally obscure d by the effects of assimilation and degrada tion inherent in the peatification and coalification processe , unless some of the plant material from one-time surface layers of the peat has been fortuitously preserved as, for example , occurs in calcareous concreti ons known as ·coal balls' (see Schopf, I 939). Unfortu nately no such syngenetic or very early epigenetic permineralised preservation has so far been found within the coals of the Walloon Coal Measures, although some coalified plant specimens do protrud e at slight angles from the upper surface of seams into the overlying sediment. Plant fossils in the fine-grained detrital sediments intimately associated with the coal have the advanta ge of being easily discernible in the inorganic sedimen tary matrix, but the disadvantage that, since they are not actually from the coal itself, there is uncertai nty as to whether they were in fact all part of the coalforming flora as opposed to a flora which grew in an adjacen t environ ment, or a mixture of both. However, these kinds of fossils , together with both coalified compres sions and silicified petrifactions from other horizon s in the coal measures, provide the best informa tion there is presently available, so assessment of them will be attempt ed here. THE FOSSIL FLORA The plant megafossil flora of the Middle Jurassic Walloon Coal Measure s from southea stern Queensl and and northea stern New South Wales has been discussed by Gould ( 1974) and addition al specimens _have been reported by Rigby (1978). Some de~ails

83


are provided in the appendix to this paper. The flora includes liverworts ('Thallites' ) , lycopods (Lycopodit es), equisetalea ns (Equisetum) , ferns (Marauia, Hausmannia , Coniopteris, Cladophlebis, and Osmundacaulis, among others), seed-ferns (Pad1_1pteris), cycadeoids (Oto::.amites , Ptilophyllum) , possible pentoxylal eans (Taeniopteris, and a Pentoxy/011-like or Rhexoxylo n-like stem), and conifers (Mataia, Elatodadu s, Araucaria, Allocladus, Pagiophyllum, ovuliferou s scales, and pollen-bea ring cones). Equisetum , Cladophlebis, Taeniopteris, and Oto:::amitesPtilophyl/um are often very abundant locally and hence have been considered as characteristic of the Walloon flora , but the dominant elements are the conifers. The Early Jurassic to Early Cretaceou s floras of Australia are not too dissimilar from one another (Gould, 1976) and can be included in the Ptilophyllu m flora of India which has a similar time range (Shah et al., 1971 ; Lele, I 977). Apart from substantial ly southern hemispher e conifers belonging to the families Podocarpa ceae and Araucariac eae, Jurassic floral elements show a degree of \NOrld-wide uniformity (Wesley, 1973; Miller, 1978). Ho'wever, ginkgos, which are quite prominent in many Jurassic floras , are conspicuously absent from the Walloon flora. Informatio n on the fossil spores and pollen grains actually contained in the Walloon coals, as distinct from the associated sediment, was provided by the palaeopaly nological studies of de Jersey (1960a , b), who gave some indication of their natural affinities and relative abundance . Problems arise of course as similar-loo king dispersed spores or pollen ma y be produced by more than one sort of plant. Filatoff (1975) has also given some indication of the natural affinities of dispersed spore~ a nd pollen from Jurassic strata of W.:~ tl..' rn Aw,tralia: many of these palynomu 1 pn ~ i,-1\e been recovered from Walloon :,,.11npks. De Jersey"s figures on abundance \ I %Ub) a1 e used here as a guide to the contnbutiu n of the ditferent kinds of plant to tnc 1.. v uL this assumes that the so-called ·smith 1..'!kl..'l . (Chaloner & Muir, 1968), where the :, ui-Jp1y uf autochtho nuus spores and pollen ..m: :,v ~1oundant that they reflect the swamp ,eget.1L1u1,. is valid for the Walloon situation. McKell.ir ( 1978) listed palynomor phs with rdati,I.'. :1bundance s from a sediment sample. :S-t

INTERPR ETATION OF FLORAL EVIDENC E

The fossil plants can be roughly divided into two kinds; spore-bear ing herbaceou s plants and pollen/see d-bearing woody plants. The spore-bear ing herbaceou s plants include the lycopods, equisetalea ns, and ferns; the liverworts are similar in as much as they produce spores and lack woody tissue, but true vascular tissue is absent so they are not strictly herbaceou s in the botanical sense. The pollen/seed -bearing woody plants include the seed-ferns, cycadeoids , possible pentoxylaleans, and conifers. The liverworts are represente d in the Walloon flora by specimens of 'Thallites' . Living examples of the thallose liverworts prefer damp or boggy and generally acidic environments, through a range of latitudes from subpolar to equatorial . They are quite delicate plants and would probably not survive sedimentary transport for any great distance. Living relatives of the herbaceou s lycopod Lycopodite s also prefer damp environme nts with a similarly wide latitudinal range, although being more abundant in the tropics. Spores thought to be produced by this kind of plant are fairly common (up to 12%, average 5%; Lycopodiu m spp. in de Jersey, 1960b) in the coal. A couple of species of Equisetum occur in the sediments associated with the coal, and some specimens show well-developed but delicate roots penetratin g the sediment from the nodes of thei r jointed stems (e.g. Gould , 1968, pl. I, fig. 20), indicating autochtho nous preservatio n . Entire portions of the stems of these plants may be devoid of the epidermal pores or stomata that facilitate atmospher ic gas exchange for photosynth esis, possibly because these portions were growing under water. the plants having a reed-like habit. Unusual in the group of spore-bear ing herbaceous plants, E,1uise1Urn had a thin wax} surface covering or cuticle which can be recovered from fossil specimens, and pn.:sumabl 1 this material wa:, abu contribute J tu the coal. Certain spores which can be com pared to those of E,1ui:,etum ha,e been recovered from the coal and included , along with unrelated pollen grains, in ·111apenurvpalle11ites sp.' (de Jersey, I 960a). Living Equise lllm is cosmopoli tan, except for Australia where it became extinct in the Tertiary. It


thought to have formed in a warm equator ial prefers moist acid environ ments and grows in climate (Schopf, 1973) and another , perhaps swamps, lake margins , and damp woodlan ds. more closely related seed-fern, to the cool the Fern fronds are well represented in tempera te (Townro w, 1964) Middle- Late TriMaratto referable Walloon flora . Specimens assic coals of Australi a. tia, which is presently a tropical, sub-trop ical Cycadeo ids (or bennetti taleans) are quite or, rarely, tempera te genus preferrin g moist nt in the flora with numero us fronds promine , rounded conditio ns, are not common . The to Oto::.arnites and Ptilophy llurn , and referable nnia Hausrna of leaves aped somewh at heart-sh one like Pteroph yllurn . Cycadeo ids had tough with their narrow stalks are thought to be woody stems containi ng numero us cuticles, are related to living dipterid aceous ferns that (Seward , 1917, p. 487-489), and ducts resin were but Asia, only found in southea st produce d monosulcate pollen, all of which widespread in the Jurassic . Coniopteris was would be contribu ted to the coal. The cuticles quite commo n in the Walloon flora as it was in be identified in thin and possibly polished can like many floras of similar age. Fern spores of the coal, while palynological sections of species of ia those found in the sporang prepara tions have shown pollen like that of Coniopteris (see Harris, 1961) are very comcycadeoids to be fairly commo n (up to 12%, mon (up to 24%, average 17%; Leiotrile tes average 6%; Entylissa spp. in de Jersey, other but coal, spp. in de Jersey, 1960b) in the 1960b); this sort of pollen grain may also be some in spores; similar produce ferns also produced by other plants like the pentoxyseam horizon s these are the most abundan t of laleans. Some specimens from sediments closepresent. all the kinds of both spores and pollen of ly associated with seams show slender stems, species to e referabl Numero us fronds covered with epiderm al scales and apparen tly Cladophlebis have been collected but, without persistent leaf bases, bearing a crown of the direct evidence provide d by fertile fronds fronds at the apex; for these intact specimens l botanica bearing sporang ia, their exact to have survived, they could not have been e inferenc By ed. ascertain be affinities cannot transpor ted very far, if at all. The cycadeoids from the nature of the stalks or petioles on superficially similar to living tropical to are some specimens and the orientat ion of these te cycads, but differ markedl y in some tempera may it , together d petioles occurrin g clustere details; cycadeoids enjoyed a cosmop olitan be conclud ed that some at least were borne on distribu tion in the Jurassic. Some cycadeoid trunks or the undergr ound axes (rhizomes) of leaves in the Walloon flora feature an inrolled ly common species of Osrnundacaulis that are pinna margin and this has been attribute d to a Coal Walloon the in tions preserved as petrifac modification for dry conditio ns (Dougla s, Measures; living member s of the fern family 1963) but that interpre tation would not seem Osmund aceae occur in tropical to cool tembe in agreeme nt with the development of to in growing s perate climates , some member the coal measure sequence in which they bogs and swamps, others in rain forests and occur. The lack of larger sizes of Oto::.arni1es damp woodlan ds. The trunks and rhizomes of or Ptilophyllum fronds in the Walloon flora , Osmund aceae consist of a central stem with a when compar ed to those that have been mantle a in very resistant outer cortex clothed reported from the Jurassic elsewhere, ma y of persistent leaf bases; the tough nature of indicate adverse conditio ns such as a cooler these together with their subterra nean growth (see Lele, 1977). climate an in the swamp environ ment has resulted in st udies of the Jurassic floras of India From an with Spores . unusually good fossil record (Rao, 1974) it would seem that the common osmund aceous aspect are also represented in leaf fossil Taenivp 1ais spa1ulata may belong the coal. to the pentox ylalea ns and the presence in The seed-fern Pachypteris could have consome Walloon horizon s of small to fairly large tributed cuticle and bisaccate pollen grains to petrified stems or trunks with a curious the coal, althoug h the fronds are not very ent or :,epara te woody bundles in arrangem common . The st:ed-ferns are an extinct group at similar tu Pen1ux_rlvn or somewh each cannot ces of plants, so their habitat preferen Rhexu.rylu11 would tend to support this. These be ascertained from living analogues; howare thought to have produce d monoplants ever, other kinds of set:d-ferns contribu ted pollen like that of the cycadeoids, sukate greatly, along with tht: arboresc ent lycopods, and the lea\es had a thin cuticle. The subto the Carboni ft:rous coals or Euamer ica, 85


stantial woody bundles in each trunk show featured growth rings, apparently whorled distinct growth rings, probably indicating a horizontal -branch scars reminiscent of living periodicity of climate (Chaloner & Creber, araucarian s, a few podocarps , and other 1973), and the fluted nature presented by the conifers, and one example of the base of a base of the petrified trunks may have been an trunk showed some evidence of buttress adaptation for a moist environme nt. development. Conifers are well represented in the WalLiving podocarps and araucarian s grow in loon flora . Leafy shoots have been assigned to moist habitats ranging from tropical to cool the podocarp Mataia and araucarian s Arautemperate alpine; the tropical species are caria , Allocladus , and Pagiophyllum ; shoots of generally restricted to somewhat cooler reElatocladus, which was probably a podocarp, gions of higher altitude. The podocarp bog are also numerous in some localities. Twigs pine (Dacrydium bidwillii) of ew Zealand and even more substantial coalified stems grows in water-logged environme nts; trunks sometimes protrude, generally at low angles, of the ew Zealand araucarian swamp kauri from the upper surface of coal seams into the (Agathis australis) have accumulat ed and overlying sedimentar y rocks, as if the finebeen preserved unaltered in bogs (Dallimore grained sediment had gently covered the & others, 1966). Taxodium, the swamp cypsurface of the peat entombing the plant ress of the southern United States and material. These conifers had tough , thick Mexico, a taxodiaceo us conifer which is cuticles, especially the araucarian s (cf. Stocdistinct from either the araucarian s or podkey & Taylor, 1978), and similar thick cuticles ocarps, has a conspicuously enlarged , fluted are very common in the coal. Araucaria n or buttressed basal trunk when growing in ovuliferous cone scales and various pollen marshy ground or surrounde d by water, and cones are also preserved . Some of the pollen woody protrubera nces known as 'cypress cones contain rounded pollen grains that knees' often arise from the roots ; these appear to be dimorphic , varying from alete, features do not occur when the trees grow in possessing a differentially thickened or folded better drained positions. Swamp cypress trees central region (Townrow , 1969, pl. 2, figs a, b), appear to be able to invade open fresh-water to being cavate. Dispersed pollen grains sites where the depth of water is mostly too similar to those found in the cones and also great to allow other plants to survive and , considered to have some araucarian affinities, because of their deciduous nature, cypress are dominant in most coal seams (up to 53%, peat accumulat es (Spackman et al., 1969; average 37%; Araucariacites, JnaperturopolCohen & Spackman , 1977). lenites and Zonalapollenites spp. in de Jersey, Conifers or oftwoods are well-known for 1960b ). The output of pollen from living their content of gummy material called resin araucarian s is immense, millions or billions of which occurs either in special cavities (resin grain being produced from one cone (Cham ducts or canals) or in various cells and tissues berlain, 1935) and there are generally thouof the plant. This resin exudes from wounds sand s of pollen cones borne on a mature tree; and accumulat es on branches, trunks and at the fossil cones do not seem to have been quite the bases of trees. Both the araucarian s and as productive , but the representa tion of the podocarps produce resin, and the wood of pollen in the fossil record may be somewhat araucarian s and some, but not all , podocarps positively biassed due to this. Living podhas been described as resinous (Dallimore et ocarps produce bisaccate and sometimes trial., 1966). Living podocarps do not display saccate pollen; such forms are not common in resin canals in the wood or cortical tissue, but the coal. canals are developed in the leaves and thinMassive conifer-like trunks of fossil wood walled living cells containing resin are widely exhibiting growth rings occur in the Walloon distributed in the plants (Chamberl ain, 1935). Coal Measures. Some examples in the overlyExtant araucarian s have such canals in the ing Middle-La te Jurassic Springbok Sandcortex, leaves and cones, while cells of the stone at One Arm Man Creek near Wandoan medullary rays and certain wood cells, known (Brigalow Mines, 1979, p. 10) were shown to as resinous tracheids (Jane, 1956), that border participan ts of the Field Conference asthe medullary rays also contain accumusociated with this Symposium by G. M. lations of resin. Fossil deposits of resin in New Leblang (Beeston, 1979); these large trunks Zealand bogs, derived from the araucarian 86


kauri pine (Agathis austra/ia) , have supplied commercial quantities known as kauri gum (Dallimore et al. , 1966). Resinite is an abundant maceral in some Walloon coals (Cook, 1975). Resin is remarkably resistant to chemical and biological attack in the swamp environment, and its presence in the wood and other tissues of these plants would tend to give them a degree of protection from decay not enjoyed by plants lacking such substances; this resin content of the conifers together with that from the cycadeoids may also account for the high hydrogen or perhydrous nature of Walloon coal. Distillation of the New Zealand kauri peat is reported to have yielded liquid hydrocarbons and turpentine (Dallimore et al., 1966, p. 96). Cuticle, spores, and pollen grains also contribute to the waxy nature of a coal, but these are present in other coals that are not so markedly perhydrous; the thick conifer cuticle is a feature of the Walloon coal, and its contribution undoubtedly added to the total hydrogen content. The flora in sediments immediately beneath coal seams is often dominated by the sporebearing herbaceous plants like Equisetum or various ferns, while the plant material protruding from the coal and in immediately overlying sediments is mostly coniferous. Conifers do occur below seams in some localities but not in great numbers, and carbonaceous shales developed laterally to seams generally contain numerous ferns ; roof shales may also be dominated by ferns, so the floral succession from ferns to conifers cannot be rigidly applied. As noted before, Jurassic floras world-wide have a similar floral aspect, and this should lead to similarities in coal type which apparently is noticeable (Cook, 1975); differences observed may be due to differences in detail of the floras , but climate or geological environment may also play a part. The Walloon Coal Measures would appear to have been deposited in a latitude somewhat higher than other known Jurassic coals, as discussed below. INTERPRETATION OF SOME OTHER EVIDENCE

From the reconstructed positions of the present continental masses in the Jurassic as presented by Smith et al. ( 1973), the area of

Walloon Coal Measures deposition would have extended from about 65 cS to 75 cs. Th inclination of the earth's axis of rotation to th ... orbital plane of the earth around the sun. assuming it was the same in the Jurassic as it is now, means that the region in question would have been subject to the marked seasonal fluctuation in day length experienced by that latitudinal range today; this variation in day length. would perhaps have had more influence on the development of normal growth rings in wood than other factors such as hot/cold or wet/dry conditions (Chaloner & Creber, 1973). For a region as far as 65 cs_ 75 cs today, the climate would be antarcticlike and support very little, if any , plant growth; this was clearly not the case, and the climate must have been somewhat more temperate. The time-temperatu re curve derived from oxygen isotope data for Australia by Stevens (1971 ), showed the average temperature of the sea declined during the Middle Jurassic from about I 8 cc to I 5 cc which would indicate a temperate clima k . The production of the original peat itself and the numerous spore-bearing plants in the flora, such as ferns , indicate the climate was a moist one. The coal seams of the Walloon Coal Measures are characteristically thinlybanded, the coal bands, unfortunately for mining interests, being commonly separated by layers of inorganic sediment and generally exhibiting what are regarded as high ash contents. The interbedded sedimentary layers commonly show coalified plant roots penetrating downwards from the coal horizons, adding more evidence for the autochthonous nature of the coal. At Bexhill, near Lismore in New South Wales, the coal measures with such thin regular banded layers of coaly and root-penetrated silty sediments are strikingly exposed in a brickpit (see Nicholson, 1975; Flint et al. , 1976); McElroy ( 1969) concluded this banding was related to the periodic production of plant versus sedimentary material due to minor climatic rhythms. Attempts to invoke a regularly 'shuddering' tectonic subsidence with small scale but rhythmic increases and decreases in rate over a prolonged period of time to explain the banding would seem too complex an answer, especially since the mechanism would have to apply not only to the extensive Middle Jurassic of the Surat and Clarence-More ton Basins but also 87


to coals in other basins of different ages world wide which show similar banding. Peat-producing floras today vary in botanical composition with latitude, and some floras are better adapted to the swamp environment than others even at the same latitude. Perhaps the Walloon coal flora, dominated by conifers, was not quite so well adapted to the aquatic environment when compared to some other coal-producing floras such as the Euamerican Carboniferous lycopod/pteridosperm flora or the Gondwana Permian Glossopteris flora . Both the tropical lycopod/ pteridosperm and temperate Glossopteris floras contained plants with well-developed modifications for internal aeration of their underground root systems enabling them to thrive in the water-logged environments; no such anatomical modifications have yet been identified in the roots of the Walloon flora , apart from Equisetum and some evidence of buttress development. The better adapted floras were able to produce peat deposits less likely to be interrupted by other sediment, since production and accumulation of vegetable matter could keep pace with a greater range of subsidence before being inundated; at slower rates, the excess of production over accumulation would be lost by decay or erosion . The Walloon flora was certainly able to tolerate the swamp environment , but its maximum production of vegetable matter was probably somewhat less than that of the other floras mentioned , and there is a general lack of thick seams. In areas of constant subsidence, where the rate was equal to or just in excess of the average rate of accumulation, periods conducive to plant growth allowed peat to establish, while in adverse periods the peat was inundated and inorganic sediment alone accumulated . The Bexhill locality may represent such an area. These periods could have been seasonal and were certainly cyclical; periodic flooding rains might also have resulted in bringing in the inorganic sediment. Due to the inclination of the earth's axis mentioned above, the seasons, especially with respect to daylength , are more marked nearer the poles. Even in equatorial and sub-equatorial regions the seasonal shift of the atmospheric circulation belts results in seasonal differences (such as the monsoon season), so that coals produced in any latitude under constant conditions of subsidence could show some banding on a larger scale 88

than that produced by the compression of the individual plant remains themselves. Against the argument for seasonal accumulation is the consideration of the reconstructed accumulation rate of plant material in the depositional site. Assuming a compression ratio of peat:coal for Walloon coal as approximately 5: 1, peat accumulation at 2535 cm maximum per 'season' would be required , with an average of approximately 10-20 cm. However, this would seem far greater than present day conditions indicate for an annual cycle. Nevertheless, longer periods of climatic cyclicity, such as those considered to be caused by varying solar activity (see Johnsen et al., 1972), could account for the amount of peat formation to produce each band. There is no evidence for any marine influence on the Walloon peat swamps; the presence of numerous spores and pollen grains in the coal supports this (Cohen & Spackman, 1977) as does the absence of dinoflagellates in the micro-fossil flora (R. Helby, pers. comm.). SUMMARY

The coals of the Walloon Coal Measures were formed from plants mostly growing at or very near to the site of deposition , that is autochthonous in the sense of Stach et al. (1975, p. 19) who distinguished autochthonous coals on the basis of transport of the plant material over a considerable distance from original site to site of deposition; this autochthony is substantiated by the presence of plant roots penetrating the sediment bt:neath many coaly horizons and the delicate nature of intact and attached plant organs recovered from the uni t. The coal-forming flora was dominated by araucarian conifers with some significant contributions from ferns and cycadeoids. The perhydrous and resinous nature of the coal probably resulted from conifers and cycadeoids. Comparison of the floral elements with living analogues where possible, and other evidence, suggests a temperate, moist, non-marine environment. ACKNOWLEDGM ENTS

I wish to thank the men and the management of mines operating in the Walloon Coal Measures during the 1966-1968 period and


the proprietor of the Bexhill brickpit for much hospitality and forbearanc e. Thanks are due to Dr G. Playford who supervised the early stages of this work , and Ors B.

McKelvey, I. Davidson, and R. Haines for discussion. None of these people are responsible for any misconcep tions promulgated here.

REFERENCES BARNARD, P. D. W. , 1968: A new species of Masculostrobus Seward producing Classopollis pollen from the Jurassic of Iran. J . Linn. Soc. ( Bot.), 61, 167-176. BEESTON, J. W. (Ed.), 1979: 1979 field conference. Taroom-Wan doan-Millme rran. Geol. Soc. Aust. , Qd Div., field trip guidebook. . and MAHESHWARI , H. K. , 1973: Some BOSE, M. detached seed-scales belonging to Araucariaceae from the Mesozoic rocks of India. Geophy tology, 3, 205-214. BouREAU, E. (Ed.), 1964: Traite de Paleobotanique. Ill. oeggerathiophyta, Masson, Sphenophy ta, Paris. BoUREAU, E. (Ed.), 1967: Traite de Paftobotanique. II. Bryophy ta, Psi/ophyta, Lycophy ta, Masson , Paris. BRIGALOW MINES, 1979: Wandoan coal. A major nell' Australian coal-to-oil deposit , Theiss Holdings & M.I.M . Holdings, Brisbane. CHALONER, W. G . and CREBER, G . T., 1973: Growth rings in fossil woods as evidence of past climates, in Tarling, D. H . and Runcorn , S. K. (Eds), Implications of con tinental driji to the earth sciences. I, Academic Press, London , 425-437. CHALONER, w. G ., HILL, A. and ROGERSO ' E. c. w., 1978: Early Devonian plant fossils from a southern England borehole. Palaeontology, 21, 693-707. CHALO ER , W. G . and MUIR, M. , 1968: Spores and floras, in Murchison, D. and Westoll , T. S. (Eds), Coal and coal-bearing strata, Oliver a nd Boyd, 127146. CHAMBERLAIN, C. J., 1935: Gymnosperms. Structure and evolution, Univ. Chicago Press. COHEN, A. D . and SPACKMAN , W., 1977: Phytogenic organic sediments and sedimentary environments in the Everglades-m angrove complex. Part II. The origin, description and classification of the peats of southern Florida . Palaeontographica, I62B, 71-114. COOK, A . C. , 1975: The spatial and temporal variation of the type and rank of Australian coals, in Cook, A. C. (Ed .), Australian black coal, Aust. Inst. Min. Metal/. , Jllall'arra Brnch, 63-84. DALLIMORE, W. , JACKSON, A. B. and HARRISON, S. G. , 1966: A handbook of Conijerae and Ginkgoaceae, 4th ed., Edward Arnold . DE JERSEY, N. J., 1960a: Jurassic spores and pollen grains from the Rosewood Coalfield . Pubis Geol. Surv. Qd, 294. DE JERSEY, N . J., 1960b: Spore distribution and correlation in the Rosewood Coalfield . Pubis Geol. Surv. Qd, 295. DOUGLAS, J. G ., 1963: New bennettitalea n leaves from the Mesozoic of eastern Australia. Proc. R. Soc. Viet ., 77, 197-206.

DOUGLAS, J. G ., 1969: The Mesozoic floras of Victoria. Parts I and 2. M em. geo /. Surv. Viet., 28. EAMES, A. J ., 1936: Morphology of vascular plants, lower groups ( Psilophy tales to Filicales), McGrawHill, New York . EDWARDS, W. N., 1934: Jurassic plants from New Zealand. A . Mag . nat. Hist ., ser. 10, 13, 81-109. F1LATOFF, J., 1975: Jurassic palynology of the Perth Basin, Western Au stralia. Palaeontographica, I54B, 1-113. Fu T, J . C . E. and GOULD, R. E., 1975: A note on the fossil mega flora s of the ymboida and Red Cliff Coal Measures, southern Clarence-Mo reton Basin, .S.W. Proc. R. Soc. N .S.W. , 108, 70-74. FLINT, J. c. E., LANCASTER, c. G ., Go LD, R . E. and HENSEL, H . D. , 1976: Some new stratigraphic data from the southern Clarence-Mo reton Basin. Qd Govt Min. J., 77, 396-401. GOOD, C. W ., 1975: Pennsylvania n-age calamitean cones, elater-bearin g spo res, and associated vegetative organs. Palaeontographica, 153B, 28-99. GOULD, R . E., 1968: Morphology of Equisetum laterale Phillips, I 829, and E. bryanii sp. nov . from the Mesozoic of southeastern Queensland. Aust. J. Bot., 16, 153-176. GOULD, R . E. , 1973: A new species of Osmundacaulis from the Jurassic of Queensland . Proc. Linn. Soc. N.S. W. , 98, 86-94. GouLD, R . E. , 1974: The fossil flora of the Walloon Coal Mea sures: a survey. Proc. R. Soc. Qd, 85, 33-41. GOULD, R . E., 1976: The succession of Australian preTertiary megafossil floras . Bot. Rev. , 41, 453483 _ HARRIS, T . M ., 1931 : The fossil flora of Scoresby Sound , east Greenland . Part I. Cryptogams (exclusive of Lycopodiale ). Meddr Gm/and, 85(2). HARRIS, T . M., 1942: On two species of hepatics of the Yorkshire Jurassic flora . A . Mag. nat. Hist. , ser. II, 9, 393-401. HARRIS, T. M., 1961 : The Yorkshire Jurassic /fora. /. Thallophy ta-Pteridophy ta, Brit. Mus. ( at. Hist. ). HAUKE, R. L. , 1957: The stomata! apparatus of Equisetum. Bull. Torrey bot. Club , 84, 178-181. HILL, D., PLAYFORD, G . and WooDs, J . T. (Eds), 1966: Jurassic fo ssils of Queensland, Qd Palaeontogr. Soc. JANE, F . W., 1956: The structure ofll'ood, Black . JOHNSEN , S. J., DANSGAARD, W. , CLAUSE ' H . B. and LANGWAY, C. C. Jr., 1972: Oxygen isotope profiles through the Antarctic and Greenland ice sheets. Na ture, 235, 429-434. JOHNSON , M. A., 1937: Hydathodes in the genus Equisetum . Bot. Ga= ., 98, 598-608. . J. , 1947: Fertile JONES, 0. A. and DE JERSEY, Equisetales and other plants from the Brighton Beds. Pubis Univ. Qd Dep . Geo/. ( N.S.), 3(4).

89


KA UFMAN, P. B., BI GELOW, W . C. , SCHMID , R. a nd GHOSH EH, . S. , I 971 : Electron microprobe analyses of silica in epidermal cells of Equisetum . Amer. J. Bot. , 58, 309-316. LELE. K. M. . 1977: Palaeoclimatic implications of Gondwana flora s. Geophy tology, 6, 207-229. LUNDBLAD. B.. 1954: Contributio ns to the geological history of the Hepat icae. Fossil M archan ti ales from the Rh aetic-Liassic coa l mines of Skronbergia (Prov. of Scania), Sweden. S vensk bot. Tidskr. , 48, 381-417. MCELROY, C. T ., 1969: The Clarence-Moreton Basin in N.S.W. J . Geol. Soc. Aust., 16(1 ), 457-479. Mc KELLA R, J. L. , 1978: Palynology of a sa mple from the Walloon Coal Measures at Rosewood Consolidated Colliery. QdGovt Min. J., 79, 530-532. MILLER, C. N . Jr. , 1978: Mesozoic conifers. Bot. Rev., 43, 217-280. N1 c HOLSON, D . A. , 1975: Clarence-Moreton Basi n. in Ma rkham , N. L. and Basden, H. (Eds). The mineral deposits of Ne11· South Wales, Geol. Surv. N .S.W. , 539-554. PAG E. C. .. 1972: An assessment of in ter-specific relationships in Equisetum subgenu s Equistum . Ne11· Plmol., 71 , 355-369. PA NT. D . D . anct' KJDWAI , P. F. , 1968: Development of stomata in Equisetum . Ann. Bot ., 32, 601-608. RAO. A . R ., 1974: Pentoxyleae, in Surange, K . R ., Lakha npal , R. . and Bharadwaj, D . C. (Eds), Aspects and appraisal of Indian palaeobotany, Birbal Sahni Institute of Palaeobota ny, 201211. RIGBY. J. F., 1977: ew collections of Triassic plants from the Esk Formation, sout heast Queensland . Qd Govt Min . J ., 78, 320-325. RIGBY. J . F. , 1978: Jura ssic plant fossils from the Walloon Coal Me asures at Rosewood Consolidated Colliery. Qd Govt Min. J., 79, 526-529. SCHOPF, J. M. , 1939: Coal ball s as an index to the construction of coal. Illin ois A cad. Sci. Trans. , 31, 187-1 89. Sc HOPF, J. M ., 1973: Coal, climate and global tectonics, in T arling, D . H . and Runcorn , S. K . (Eds), Implications of continen tal drift to the earth sciences. /, Academic Press, London , 609-622. SEWA RD, A . C .. 191 7: Fossil plants. 3, Cambridge Univ. Press. SHAH. S. C. , S1 'GH , G . and SASTRY, M . V. A ., 1971 : Biostratigraphic classification of Indian Gondwanas. Ann. Geol. Dep . Aligarh Muslim Unil•. , 56, 306-326. SMITH. A. G .. BRIDEN, J . C. and DREWRY. G. E .. 1973: Pha nerozoic world maps. Spee. Pap. Palaeontology, 12, 1-42.

SPACKM AN . W ., RI EGEL, W. L. and DOLSON. C. P .. 1969: Geologica l and biological interactions in the swamp-marsh complex of southe rn Florida . Geol. Soc. Am. Spee. Pap., 114, 1-35. STACH, E. et al., 1975: Stach's textbook of coal petrology, 2nd Ed. Gebriider Borntraeger. STEVENS, G . R., 1971 : Relationship of isotopic temperatures and fa un a! realm s to Jurassic-C retaceous paleogeograph y, particularl y of the south-west Pacific. J . R . Soc. N.Z., I, 145-158. STOCKEY. R . A . and T AYLOR, T. N., 1978: Cuticular features and epidermal pallerns in the genus Araucaria de Jussieu. Bot. Gaz., 139, 490-498. SuKH-DEv and Z EBA-BA NO, 1979: Observa ti ons on the ge nu s Allocladus, and it s representat ives in the Jabalpur Formation. Palaeontographica, 169B, 116-1 2 1. T EN ISON-WOODS, J.E ., 1883: On the fossi l fl ora of the coal deposits of Australia. Proc. Linn . S oc. N.S. W. , 8, 37-167. TOW NROW, J. A. , 1964: A specu lation of the Rh aetoLiassic climate of Tasma nia . Pap . Proc. R . S oc. Tasm .. 98, 113-118. Tow ROW, J . A. , 1967: The Brachyphyllum crassum complex of fossil coni fers . Pap. Proc. R . Soc. Tasm ., 101 , 149-172. Tow ROW, J . A ., 1968: A fossil Selaginel/a from the Perm ian of New Sou th Wales. J . Linn. Soc. ( Bot .). 61, 13-23. TOWNROW , J. A., 1969: Some Lower Mesozoic Podocarpaceae a nd Araucariaceae, in Gond1rnna stratigraphy , I UGS Symposium , Beun os Aires, UNESCO, Paris, 159-1 84. Tow Row, J . A. a nd Jo ES, J. , 1969: On Pachypteris pinnata (Walkom) from Ta smania . Pap. Proc. R . Soc. Tasm., 103, 63-67. W ALKOM, A. B. , 19 I 7: Mesozoic floras of Queensland . Part I. ontinued. The Hora of the Ipswich and Wall oon Series. (c) Filica les, etc. Pubis Geol. Su"'. Qd, 257. WALTON, J ., 1925: Carboniferous Bryophyta , I. Hepaticae. Ann. Bot .. 39, 563-572. WESLEY, A ., 1973: Ju rassic plants, in H alla m, A. (Ed .), Atlas of Palaeobiogeography , Elsevier, Amsterda m, 329-338 .

R . GOULD , Department of Geology, University of New England, Armida le, N .S.W. , 2351.

APPE DIX SOME DETAILS OF THE FLORA The Walloon Coal Measures are considered to be of Middle Jurassic age (Filatoff, 1975, fig. 4a .82), possibly extending into the early Late Jurassic (Gould, 1974). Information on 90

the flora has been summarised by Gould ( 1974) with additional specimens being reported since then by Rigby ( 1978). Some examples were illustrated by Hill et al. (1966). Much of the flora is still undescribed.


BRYOPHYTA : HEPAT ICAE (Liverw orts) THALLITES' sp. Fig. 1 The illustrat ed dichotom izing thalloid plant with entire margin and a promine nt to indistinc t midrib is probabl y a liverwor t gametop hyte, but lack of morpho logical detail prevents a more accurate assignm ent. The genus Thallites was defined by Walton (I 925, p. 564) for thalloid fossil plants which could be equally, althoug h somewh at uncertainly , assigned to algae, liverworts or sometim es higher groups; Fucoides erectus Lenkenb y 1864 was designat ed as the type species. Later in the same paper (Walton 1925, p. 565), the genus Hepaticites was propose d for thalloid fossils showing some definite characte r (e.g. unicellu lar rhizoids) of the Hepatic ae, but lacking sufficient structur al detail to warra nt the use of a distinctive generic term ; the type species is H. k idstoni Walton 1925. Howeve r, in 1942, Harris placed Fucoides arcuatus Lindley and Hutton 1837, and F. erectus in synonym y with the combination Hepaticites arcuatus (Lindley and Hutton) Harris 1942, thu s incorpo rating Thallites and its type species into the genus Hepaticites. Howeve r, ifa strict interpre tation of priority is applied, the combina tion should have been Thallites arcuatus (Lindley and Hutton) and the genus Thallites appropr iately emende d. A new genus could be erected for species which belong to 'Thallites Walton 1925' (see Jovet-A st in Boureau , 1967, p. 32) but, under the provisio ns of the Internat iona l Code of Botanic al Nomenc lature, designa tion of a type species would be required . This procedure is not satisfact ory, as sooner or later new techniqu es or better preserved specimens of this type will provide further informa tion leading to detailed definition or synonym y with another genus, again excludin g the less well preserved specimens for which the genus was original ly raised. This process could be continu ed indefinitely. On the other hand , the use of the genera Thallites and Hepaticites in the sense of Walton ( 1925), without regard to the position or structur e of the type species of Thallites , is extremely useful as they are complem entary genera, being theoretic ally defined on the amount of informa tion obtained from the fossil conce1 .1ed . This use would be incorrec t without conserv ation. Howeve r, Harris ( 1942,

1961 ) and Lundbla d (1954) have referred specimens to the e genera without regard to their va lidity. The choice of the type species for Thallit es was unfortu nate in that its morpho logy did not agree with the generic definirion and it should have been initially included in Hepaticites. It would also have been better to have erected Thallites , which is defined on negati ve characte rs, later than the more posi tively characte rised Hepaticites; the principle involved applies to any such series of theoretic ally defined complem entary taxa.

LYCOPODOPHYT A (Lycopo ds) LYCOPODITES GRACILIS (Morris ) Seward and Sahni I 920. Fig. 2. A specimen from the Walloon Coal Mea sures with dichoto mously branchi ng stems bearing small lateral falcate leaves and rare smaller (dorsal/ ventral?) leaves was referred to L. gracilis by Rigby ( 1978). Harris ( 1961 , p. 44) thought the species as describe d from India was S elaginella-like. Small herbace ous lycopod s are also known from the Late Permian (Townro w, 1968) and possibly Middle Triassic (Rigby, 1977) of Au stralia . SPHEN OPHYT A: EQUISE TALES (Equiset ums) EQUISETUM BRYA

II Gould 1968. Fig. 3.

Thi s species shows simple, small, unbranched Equisetum stems, with adpresse d leaf sheaths. The cuticle and epiderm al cells have been discussed by Gould ( 1968). The retangula r epiderm al cells with sinous wall s are reminiscent of those describe d from the nonstomatif erous ridges of living Equisetum subgenus Hippochaete (e.g. Pant and Kidwai , 1968) but the stems of£. bryanii are smooth. EQUISETUM LATERALE Phillips 1829. Fig. 4. Equisetum rotiferum Tenison -Woods 1883. Equisetites 1roodsi Jones and de Jersey 1947. The stems of E. latera/e are characte rised by wheel-like transver se nodal diaphra gms; the tips of the generally spreadin g leaf sheaths are sometim es missing or abraded . The wheel-like structur e of the nodal diaphra gms was apparently part of the vascular system and is attached to the internod al vascular bundles at the nodal xylem ring. The species occurs in the 91


underlying Marbur g Formati on and its equivalents as well as the Walloon Coal Measure s. Some plants, perhaps as a result oflying in a waterlogged environ ment, seem to have partly rotted or decayed prior to burial as many of the preserved stems have flattened out or collapsed from their original cylindrical form. In these specimens the transverse nodal diaphragms have rotated around within the stem to lie in the bedding plane, the flattened width of the stem being approxi mately equal to half the circumference of the nodal diaphra gm as would be consistent with collapse of the stem as opposed to compres sion after entomb ment with no lateral extension possible . The flattened nature of the stems also shows in naturally macerat ed specimens where the vascular bundles from both sides appear in the one bedding plane. Other specimens in which the internod al pith cavity has been filled with ediment prior to compac tion, do not show this flattening. Some specimens described as Equisetites ll'oodsii Jones and de Jersey 1947 are the same as E. laterale, with the characte ristic wheellike nodal diaphra gms present in the holotyp e of E. woodsii. The only fertile specimens of£. laterale described from coalified compres sions of the Walloon Coal Measure s are small cones borne on small stems (Gould, 1968) while fertile impressions of£. woodsii display larger cones borne on larger stems. Cone size in species of living Equisetum is proporti onal to the size of the stem on which the cones are borne as illustrated by fertile specimens of£. hyemale figured in Eames ( 1936, fig . 61 ); the range of £. latera/e stem size includes that reported for E. woodsii, but the larger stems of E. laterale so far reported have all been infertile. The slight difference in the amount of doming exhibited by the individual cone spora ngiopho res, those of E. woodsii being more pronoun ced, may be related to the relative size as well, or due to effects of compres sion as outlined by Chalone r et al. ( 1978). Details of epidermal cells and cuticle have been di scussed previously (Gould, 1968). The stomata on the distal part of the leaf teeth flanges reported by Gould (I 968, fig. 3H) are probabl y hydatho des as described in living forms by Johnson ( 1937). Whethe r the fossil specimens are referable to Equisetum or Equisetites is perhaps a 92

debatab le point (see Harris, 1961, p. 14). The type species of Equisetites is £. muensteri Sternbe rg 1833, which differs from living Equisetum in having trilete spores while those of Equisetum are alete. Good ( 1975), in agreement with Gould (I 968, p. 156), has demons trated that the trilete versus alete spores are not of great consequence, sometimes being present in the one equisetaceous cone (possibly due to different ontogen etic stages being preserved). Spores of E. laterale are identical to those of living forms (see Gould, 1968). A compari son of Equisetites muensteri, the Walloon species, and living Equisetum is presented in Fig. 7. PTERO PHYT A (Ferns)

ot all fern specimens collected from the Walloon Coal Measure s have been determined and further work needs to be done.

Marattiaceae

MARATTIA sp. Fig. 5.

A few small, fertile pinna fragments , some-

times clustered together , and one pinnate but incomplete frond bearing both sterile and fertile pinnae have been collected . The incomplete frond is 12 cm long, about 6-8 cm wide, with small pinnae 4-5 mm wide; the apices of the pinnae are missing. Isolated fertile pinna fragments are 5-10 mm wide and over 5 cm long, with numero us elongate synangia borne almost at right angles to the midrib and occupying most of the lamina.

Osmundaceae

The fern family Osmund aceae is represented by characte ristic radially symmetrical petrified axes with a mantle of persistent stipular petiole bases showing adaxially curved (C-shaped) vascular strands. Some sterile fern foliage referred to Cladophlebis may have been borne on these axes. OsMUNDACAULIS DUNLOPII (Kidston and Gwynne -Vaugha n) Miller 1967. Figs 8, 10, 11. An Osmundacau/is in which the xylem of the vascular cylinder in the stem shows leaf gaps that are narrow, immediate, delayed or in-


complet e, and the leaf traces are initially mesarch or endarch . Toward s the outside of the mantle, the petiole bases show two promine nt masses of sclerenchyma in the concavi ty of the vascular strand, one against each incurved end, a homoge neous sclerotic ring, and a promine nt sclerenchyma strand centrally situated in each stipule on either side of the sclerotic ring; inner cortex of petiole and stipules otherwis e parench ymatous or with small scattere d sclerenchyma strands. This is the most commo n fern axis found in the Walloon Coal Measure s. OsMUNDACAULIS GIBBIANA (Kidsto n and Gwynne -Vaugha n) Miller 1967. Figs 9, 12. Stems with dissected stelar xylem ring, and characte ristic rhombo idal shape of numero us leaf traces in the heteroge neous outer cortex. Leaf bases show scattere d strands of sclerenchyma in the inner cortex and several large masses aligned in a linear series in the stipules with a decrease in strand size towards the tips. ot a commo n species. OsMu DACAULIS H0SKINGII Gould 1973. Fig. 13. Two varieties of stems were reported from the Injune Creek Beds by Gould (1973). The same strata also contain axes which may be referable to 0. sahnii (Vishnu -Mittre) Miller 1967, or 0. rajmahelense (Gupta) Sharma 1971 (Fig. 14).

Dicksoniaceae

CoNIOPTERIS spp. Fig. 16. Numero us infertile and fertile specimens can be referred to Coniopteris (e.g. see Hill et al. 1966) includin g some conside red C. hy menophy lloides (Brongn iart) Seward 1900 by Rigby (I 978), but the group needs detailed study for accurate determi nation . Forms resembling many of the species reported from the Jurassic of Yorkshi re by Harris (1961) seem to be represented . The fronds are finely divided and usually only small fragmen ts are preserved. Other Fern Fronds

CLADOPHLEBIS spp. Figs 17-19. Infertile bipinnat e fronds which are unassignable to a family , but can be included in Cladophlebis are plentiful. Some of these have been assigned to C. australis (Morris ) Seward 1904, and C. mendozaensis (Geinitz ) Frenguelli 1947, while others are undescribed. Some large fronds with pinnules that are dentate, at least in the apical parts, resemble the osmund aceous C. denticulata (Brongniart) Fontain e 1889. Occasio nally petioles of fronds are bunched together in the sediment in such a way as to suggest they could have been borne on Osmundacaulis. Edward s (I 934) described an osmund aceous C-shape d vascular trace in petioles referred to C. australis from New Zealand .

Matoniaceae

PHLEB0PTERIS ALETH0PTER0IDES Etheridg e, Jr. I 888. Fragme nts of sterile fronds were reported from the Walloon Coal Measure s by Walkom (1917). Dipteridaceae

HAUSMA IA (Protorhipis) sp. cf. H . defarrariisii Feruglio I 937. Figs 6, I 5. Rounde d , more or less heart-sh aped leaves with crenulat e margins , deeply incised bases and notched apices, traversed by 8 major radiatin g bifurcat ing veins that are separate d by a network of smaller veins, can be compared to the South America n H. defarrariisii Feruglio I 937. Some specimens show slender petioles extendin g towards the basal notch (Fig. 6).

PTERID OSPER MS (Seed-ferns) Corystospermaceae?

PACHYPTERIS AUSTRALIS (Teniso n-Wood s) comb. nov. Fig. 20. Cunninghamites austra/is Tenison -Woods 1883; pl. 7, fig. I; Walloon Coal Measure s. A pinnate leaf of moderat ely thick substance with straight to undulat e pinna margins; pinna apices are rounded , while the bases may be slightly constric ted on the upper side, decurre nt on the lower. Venatio n almost indistinguishable with midvein and seconda ry veins that occasionally branch. Somewh at similar forms have been reported from the Late Triassic (Flint and Gould , 1975) and Early Cretace ous (Dougla s, 1969). 93


PACHYPTERIS PI ATA (Walkom) Townrow and Jones, 1969. Leaves from the Walloon Coal Measures at Bexhill have been considered referable to this species by Townrow and Jones (1969). PACHYPTERIS sp. cf. P. Crassa (Halle) Townrow 1965. Bipinnate specimens referred to P. crassa from the Injune Creek Beds have been illustrated by Hill et al. ( 1966). CYCADE OIDS (OR BE

ETIITES) Fronds of Oto~amites (Fig 22, 23) and Ptilophyllum (Figs 21 , 24) are common in the flora and appear to intergrade on the basis of gro s morpholog y. Some fronds are clearly bunched into groups as if arising from the one stem apex (Fig. 21 ), and specimens showing fronds arising from slender stems are fairly common (Fig. 24). On many examples the pinnae exhibit an inrolled margin , one form of these being assigned to 0 . incurvatus Douglas 1963 (Fig. 23). A Pterophy llum-like frond is also present (Fig. 25) and impressions of Nilssonia sp. cf. N. elegans Arber 1917 occur in the lnjune Creek Beds. PE TOXYLA LES? The common leaves Taeniopteris spatula/a McClelland 1850 (Fig. 27), trunks with Pentoxylon-like central vascular bundles and omewhat Rhexoxylo n-like peripheral bundles (Fig. 26), plus some seed-bearing structure (Hill et al. 1966, pl. J8 , fig. 5) indicate that pentoxylalean plants (see Rao , 1974) were a prominent feature of the flora . These plants will be discussed more fully in a later paper.

CONIFEROPHYTA (conifers) Leafy shoots, ovuliferous cone scales, and pollen cones belonging to the conifer families Podocarpa ceae and Araucariac eae are corn-

94

mon in the flora , most of the identification of them being due to the work which was summarise d and up-dated by Townrow ( 1969). Podocarps include Mataia podocarpoides (Ettingsha usen) Townrow 1967 and probably Elatocladus planus (Feistmant el) Seward 1918 (Fig. 28). Araucarian s include Araucaria crassa (Tenison-W oods) Townrow 1967 (Fig. 29), Alloc/adus rajmahalen se (Feistmant el) Townrow 1967, Al. cribbii Townrow 1967 (Fig. 30), Al. heterophyllus (Halle) Townrow 1969 (Fig. 31 ); Pagiophyllum feistmantelii Halle 1913 is probably also araucarian . Some araucarian ovuliferous cone scales have been referred to Araucarites cribbii Townrow 1969, and A. cutchensis Halle 1913 non Feistmante l 1876 (Town row, 1969; Bose and Maheshwa ri, 1973). Araucaria n pollen cones (Fig. 32) include species referred to Masculostrobus by Townrow (1969) and associated with A I. cribbii a nd Al. heterophyl/us. Barnard ( 1968) re-defined Masculostrobus to include cones contammg only non-saccat e pollen and specifically excluded M. warrenii Townrow 1967 from Antarctica , which is of similar constructio n to cones from the Walloon flora . The Walloon cones contain pollen which is not saccate but alete or cavate, the tendency being for the intexine to shrink away from the exoexine producing cavate grains with a central corpus (Filatoff, 1975) so that grains in one cone may appear dimorphic ; pollen of this kind is considered to have araucarian affinities (Filatoff, 1975). Sukh-Dev and Zeba-Bano (1979) postulated that Alloc/adus exhibited podocarpa ceous characters and renamed the Walloon material of Al. rajmahalense as Al. 10\rnrovii. Townrow (1967, 1969) was aware that the features of Allocladus were not 100 per cent araucarian , as might be expected in a Jurassic example being compared with modern counterpa rts, but considered that most pointed to an araucarian assignment (Townrow , 1969). The alete or cavate pollen grains with araucarian affinities would certainly support this conclusion when compared to the bisaccate pollen of podocarps .


Fig. I. 'Thallites' sp. UQF56107b, Bymount. Fig. 2. Ly copodites gracilis. Redrawn from Rigby ( 1978). Fig. 3. Equisetum bryanii. UQF52547 , Roughrigg No. 5 Colliery, Rosewood. Fig. 4. Equisetum laterale. GSQF502, Sugarloaf No. 2 Colliery, Acland. Fig. 5. Isolated pinnae of Marattia sp. Sugarloa f No. 3 Colliery, Acland . Fig. 6. Hausmannia ( Protorhipis) sp. Note slender petiole. Tannymorel No. 4 Colliery, via Killarney. All scale bars are I cm .

96


Cl)

tTl

;:io

C:

ci

'"11

m

lJ1

--

w

·- - --,..-:,_ - ---.-~-

-=-===---=--

-~:-_:

-

-

··-

\.

~

.. •···

--~ L_,. .. .

•• ••••••• ·--··:,-.._.,,'

:······

:., ;/

••••


Fig. 7. Comparison of fossil species of Eq11ise111m from the Walloon Coal Measures with Eq11ise1i1es m11ens1eri and living Eq11ise111m . Nodal diaphragms approximately natural size. Cells of internodal epidermis of £ . nwens1eri, E. /a1era/e and £ . bry anii approx. x 85; internodal epidermis of extant Eq11ise111m adapted from Boureau ( 1964). Stomata of£. m11e11s1eri, E. /a/era/e, and extant Eq11ise111m approx. x 200; those of £. bry anii approx. x 85; stomata of living forms redrawn from Hauke ( 1957). Ornamentation of the stomata I subsidary cells in £. 11111e11s1eri is apparently similar to that exhibited by living Eq11ise111111 subgenus Equisetwn (e.g. Kaufman e1 al., I971; Page, I972).

98


EXTANT

EQUISE TITES

MUENST ER!

EQUISET UM

LATERA LE

EQUISET UM

EQUISET UM

BRYANII

DATA FROM HARRIS 1931

STEMS

RIBBED

SMOOTH

AND

POSSIBL Y

BRANCH ED

SMOOTH

SMOOTH

UNBRANCHED

PROBABL Y

RIBBED BENEATH SHEATH AT PROXIMAL ENO OF INTERNOOE

SMOOTH AND/OR UNBRAN CHED

BRANCHED AND UNBRCH ~

0

WEAK

NODAL DIAPHRA GMS

NOT USUALLY ADPRESSED

LEAF SEGMEN TS

MIDRIBS

PRESEN T

SPREADING, RARELY ADPRESSED MIDRIBS NOT USUALLY EVIDENT

RIBBED

EVIDENT

ADPRESSED

ADPRESSED OR SPREADING

NO MIDRIBS EVIDENT

MIDRIBS USUALLY PRESENT

OVATE; WHORLED REFLEXEC CONES

EQUISET UM- LIKE

SPORES

TRILETE

CELLS

UNKNOW N

SPORANGIOPHORES; NO STERILE BRACTS

OF

INTERNO DAL EPIDERM IS

STOMAT A

FIGURE 7

EQUISET UM-LIKE

ALETE

UNKNOW N

ALETE TREATED

NO 'ELATERS' WHEN


Fig. 8. 0 smundacau/is dunlopii. Transverse section of stem and mantle of persistent leaf bases. UQF53514, ·Mt Organ' Station, Wandoan. Fig. 9. 0 smundacaulis gibbiana . Transverse section of stem showing helerogeno us outer cortex . MVP26892, Darling Downs. Figs I0-14. Diagrams depicting cross sections of petiole bases in species of 0 smundacaulis; all al same scale as Fig. 9. 10, 11 , 0 . dunlopii. 12, 0. gibbiana . 13, 0 . hoskingii . 14, 0 . salmii or 0 . rajmahalense. Fig. 15. Hausmannia ( Protorhipis) sp. Tannymorel o. 4 Colliery, via Killamey . Fig. 16. Coniopteris sp. Fragment of frond . Roughrigg o. 5 Colliery, Rosewood. Fig. 17. Cladoph/ebis sp. Tannymorel o. 4 Colliery, via Killamey . Fig. 18. Cladophlebis sp. GSQF197, Beaudesert; redrawn from Hill et al. (1966). Fig. 19. Pinna of large frond of Cladoph/ebis sp. Caledonian o. 6 Colliery, Walloon . All scale bars are I cm.

JOO


~

~ 10

.···. _

~

~ 12

.....

~ ~ .- .

~

-..

· .·13

I 18

'P

-

FIGU RES 8-19

101


Fig. 20. Pachypteris australis (Tenison- Woods) comb. nov. Mt Ellioll o. I. Extended Colliery, Amberley . Fig. 21. Ptilophyllum sp. Group of fronds. Tannymorel o. 4 Colliery, via Killarney. Fig. 22. Oto=amites sp. UQF50303, Coulson Ck., via Warwick; redrawn from Hill et al. (1966). Fig. 23. Oto=amites incunatus . Caledonian o. 5 Colliery, Walloon; redrawn from Douglas (1963). Fig. 24. Group of Ptilophyllum leaves allached to slender stem. Tannymorel o. 4 Colliery, via Killarney. Fig. 25. Pterophyllum-like leaf. Tannymorel o. 4 Colliery, via Killarney. All scale bars are I cm.

102


FIGU RES 20-25

25 103


Fig. 26. Cross section of Pe1110xy lo11-like stem ; growth rings stylised. AMF60072, ?Miles. Fig. 27. Taeniopteris spatulata. GSQF445, Beaudesert; redrawn from Hill et al. (1966). Fig. 28. Elatocladus planus. Apex of shoot. Ta nnymorel No. 4 Colliery, via Killarney. Fig. 29. Araucaria crassa. Macleay Museum 137, ?Walloon-Rosewood; redrawn from Townrow ( 1967). Fig. 30. Allocladus cribbii. UQF50755 , Caledonian No. 5 Colliery, Walloon; redrawn from Townrow (1967). Fig. 31 . A 1/ocladus heterophy llus. Reconstruction of conebearing leafy shoot; redrawn from Townrow ( 1969). Fig. 32. Pollen-bearing cone referred lo Masrnlosirobus sp. Tannymorel o . 4 Colliery, via Killarney. All scale bars are I cm.

104


-

~

~~)~l \~~ ~®) ..

26

;

~

<> ~ '<) ~ - • e______ 'il 61i9oob&ei ~ .,t)~ ~ GO

JflfJ!/;,

0~

.~

~•. •. '1/1 28

31

I

~'\

~

"

~~

N

~~

(' 1

t~,,i t'r-t-,.~

~ - ~:·

AJ-.7

;@1 -

~~0 \'::\

29

'(',

~c \J"

fv\l

I

~"' ½,,:.q (';/"\7

~

~--

\~

30

"

FIG U RES 26-32

105


WATER RESOUR CES OF THE SURAT- MORET O

BAS!

By T . D . Fenwick ABSTRA CT

Future developm ent and controlle d exploitation of the extensive high quality coal deposits of the Surat-Mo reton region will depend to a large extent on the availability of adequate water supplies at economic levels of •• cost of supply. This paper concentr ates mainly on the Surat Basin and outlines existing water resources developm ent and present levels of commitm ent of water supplies within each major coal area of the region. The potential for further developm ent in the future to meet the likely requirem ents of both coal mining and coal processing in these areas is also briefly described . Within the Surat Basin generally, future water requirem ents for mining, as such, could in most instances be met by the developm ent of new sources of supply for these purposes . However , in many areas, the significant water demands of coal processing associated with power generatio n liquid fuel productio n, solvent refining, hydrogen ation or gasification could pose major constrain ts on the feasibility of such industrie s. Where the potential for water resources developm ent appears to be limited due to a lack of suitable storage sites and/or where existing or likely future uses for other industries appear to be in direct competit ion with the coal mining and associated developments, these aspects are also briefly discussed . INTROD UCTION

The widespread shortages of liquid petroleum fuels which have become increasingly evident in recent times have focussed renewed attention on alternativ e fossil fuels, particularly steaming coals and coals suitable for liquefaction- resources with which the southern coal district of Queensla nd is generously endowed . One factor which will play an importan t part in determin ing the rate and scope of developm ent of these extensi".e high-qua lity coa.l deposits will be the availability of adequate water supplies and the capabilit y to

develop sources of water at economic al levels of cost. This report concentr ates mainly on the water resources potential of a generally narrow strip which extends from Taroom southeastward to near Toowoom ba, where coal occurs in the Surat and Moreton Basins at comparat ively shallow depths. The area traverses catchmen ts with widely differing topograp hy and rainfall patterns. The water resources potential ranges from the relatively large undevelo ped supplies in the upper Dawson River catchmen t to the limited and costly supplies in the Condami neBalonne Rivers system. Although it is apparent that limited availability and poor distributi on of supplies in the region could be a major constrain t on the ultimate overall developm ent of coal resources in the Surat Basin, considera ble water resources potential nevertheless exists in most of the major areas. These potential resources should be adequate to service mining ventures in these areas for the foreseeable future. On the other hand. the processing of coal for power generatio n, liquid fuel production, hydrogen ation, gasification or other developm ents raises somewha t different consideratio ns. All of these industrie s would require much more substanti al amounts of water than the mining operation itself. and this could pose a major constrain t on the feasibility of such industrie s in some coal areas in the immediat e future . In the longer term, however, the increasing importan ce and economic value of coal processin g industrie s could more than justify the high cost of obtaining additiona l water supplies for these purposes from remote sites or from neighbouring stream systems, such as the Boyne River and border streams. DESCRI PTIO

OF THE AREA

DELINE ATION OF THE AREA The coal-mea sures of the Surat and Moreton Basins, the largest known coal deposits in the southern coal districts of Queensla nd. 107


FIG . I

oberg ,0

0-0,

~"'<?.,-':···:·_·:_:-..

I

.....

~

EBE WEIR

URAT- MOR TON , COAL MEA URES

;r1

11

'

0ND00MA DAM

~

'f.J'

'

, _:·.:.-:: ::·,:-,. :::.-,<'_'lo

•._·.

AREA OF

150°

+ 0

KILOMETRES

50

100

150

LOCALITY MAP 108

200

orough


are located within a narrow stnp some 350 km long aqd about 50 km average width. The area is orientated in a southeasterly direction between the centres of Taroom and Toowoomba . A smaller narrow area extends from the main area near Millmerran southeastwa rd to the New South Wales border. Because of the extent of the area and its orientation and disposition relative to the principal mountain ranges, the coal measures traverse a number of major river systems of markedly differing topographic and climatic characteristics. The northwestern extremity of the Surat Basin, which contains the potential coal fields of Taroom and Wandoan, is located completely within the catchment area of the upper reaches of the Dawson River, which is bounded in part by the Great Dividing Range and Auburn Range. The central and southern parts of the coal basin generally underlie the relatively fla't and featureless drainage systems of the Condamine and Balonne Rivers, but are also closely associated with the neighbourin g Boyne River system in the southern part of the Burnett River basin to the north and the river systems along the Queensland- New South Wales border in the south .

CLIMATE The study area is located in the sub-tropics of central southern Queensland and experiences extremes of temperature and a concentratio n of rainfall in the summer months. November to April. Over most of the region. annual rainfall averages 650 to 700 millimetres. These conditions are modified somewhat in the eastern districts, where the influence of sea breezes over the ranges results in higher rainfall and generally lower temperatures . As a result, this area is more intensively settled and farmed than the remainder of the region. RAINFALL AND RUNOFF Although the average annual rainfall is fairly uniform over the study area there is considerable variation in rainfall within each year and in the pattern of rainfall from year to year at different points within the region. This seasonal and annual vanat1on in rainfall results in a similar variation in

streamflow in each of the major stream systems and also a variation from one area to another within each catchment. Table I clearly illustrates the wide variability of streamflow throughout the region from records at five representative stations within the major river catchments. A consequence of the wide variability of rainfall and runotf is the frequent occurrence of droughts and floods. Widespread flooding occurs mainly as a result of the gently sloping terrain and the serpentine nature of the stream systems. The region as a whole receives long hours of sunshine and this coupled with high daylight temperatures results in high evaporation.

NEED FOR STORAGE Because of the wide variability of annual streamflow in this region of moderate annual rainfall, construction of adequate storage is essential to ensure that water supplie are available in dry periods, when natural streamflow ceases or is inadequate to provide an assured supply. In most instances. a storage has to be sufficient to carry users over a number of years during periods of critical drought. GROUNDWATER An important feature of the region is the existence of the porous consolidated rocks of the Great Artesian Basin of which the Surat Basin forms part. Extensive use is made of groundwater supplies from this source. although individual supplies are strictly limited to stock and domestic use in the area. To preserve this valuable resource without which much of the development in western areas of the State would not have occurred. the Commission pursues an active policy of conservation based on zero increase in draft from the groundwater system both regionally and overall. Of equal or even greater importance are the unconsolidat ed sediments of the Conda mine. Dumaresq and Dawson River Valleys. of which the Condamine River alluvium in particular. is used as a major source of water supplies for irrigation. Over-use of this resource in the Condamine River Valley. however. has resulted in a significant decline in groundwater levels over a period of time. As a result. the groundwater storage in this area 109


Table I-Recorde d Streamflow at Five Selected Centres (Megalitres)

Dawson R . at Taroom Janu ary February March April May June July August September October November December

Average M onthly Discharge Condamine R . Condamine R. Boyne R . at at at Chinchilla Cecil Pls Dunollie

Macinty re Brook at Jnglewood

63 550 120 316 44 201 23 397 21 263 13 107 17 674 5 018 5 596 11 416 27 220 55 686

28 192 55 925 22 781 5 937 14 520 7 720 19 420 7 007 2 888 9 764 16 036 17 828

40 527 32 236 6 348 I 322 2 438 4 063 4 870 I 175 I 31 2 7 180 5 358 11 863

92 500 121 723 43 326 22 280 13 409 24 003 30 207 13 211 7 042 11598 34 557 62 552

61 385 80 761 39 012 15 474 21 199 32 712 21 493 11 482 6 995 29 719 24 154 41 199

Annual average runoff Max. annual runoff Min. annual runoff

401 955 2 909 172 3 608

210 932 I 302 793 I 953

118 878 978 990 5 393

464 226 2 893 720 6 015

395 596 1 589 266 20 054

Catchment a rea (km ')

15720

19 190

7 795

4 780

3 430

has been greatly reduced and is being reduced further as withdrawals of water annually exceed the natural rate of recharge. The only fractured consolidated rocks of any note are the basalts of the Toowoom baWarwick district. Relatively high yields are obtained in the Toowoom ba area, but elsewhere the aquifer systems are 'confined ' and are of limited yield. EXISTING DEVELO PMENT IN THE AREA

The most importan t industries which have developed in the area to date are the livestock and timber industries and agriculture. Although considerable interest has been shown in mining development, particularly in recent years, the industry is only in its infancy at this stage.

PRIMARY INDUSTRY The availability of suitable soils, moderate rainfall and the proximity to ready markets are factors which have been responsible for the large scale agricultural productio n in the region, particularly in areas adjacent to the Dawson, Condami ne and Border Rivers. This agricultural productio n, together with the pastoral industry, has laid the basis for the economic and social structure that exists in the region today.

110

Principal areas are the Dawson Valley which produces a variety of crops including cotton, sorghum and wheat; the alluvial flats bordering the lower Condami ne River which support extensive grain crops, pasture and fodder crops; and lands along the Macintyr e Brook and border streams on which tobacco and a variety of fodder, grain and some horticult ural crops are grown. A large percentage of the region does not have access to reliable water for agriculture and is suited only to grazing and other animal industries such as beef and wool productio n. The pastoral industry is an established major industry in the region, although further developments are likely to be related to improvements in drought- proofing techniques and stabilisation of the industry rather than large scale expansion. While timber reserves are not extensive , southern inland Queensland provides some 95% of the total State productio n of cypress. In addition, some fairly large areas of softwood have been established in recent years on the eastern Downs. However , limitations imposed by decreasing rainfall from east to west preclude considera tion of timber harvesting as a growth industry.

MINING A variety of minerals have been identified througho ut the region namely coal, basic and


precious metals, gemstones and construc tion materials. Except for coal, other mineral s are found only in limited and generally uneconomic quantities. Large coal reserves , which are suitable for power generati on and conversion to other energy forms , have been identified in the Taroom , Wandoa n , Millmer ran and Acland areas. A large proport ion of these deposits could be won by open-cu t mining. The Acland mine is currentl y the only produci ng coal mine in the study area . A number of smaller undergr ound operatio ns closed several years ago. There are minor reserves of copper, tin and mangan ese, principally in an area between Warwick and Stantho rpe, althoug h mines in the area are no longer in product ion . In the Dawson Vale area (about 50 km east of Taroom ) drilling has shown deposits of oolitic ironston e estimate d at about 140 million tonnes. As yet oolitic ironston e is not readily treated economically. SECON DARY INDUS TRY A high proport ion of the manufac turing and processing industry in the region has direct links with primary industry . Flour mills, saw mills, cotton ginneries, dairy factories and abattoir s are typical examples of resource-based enterprises with input derived directly from the land. Metal fabricat ion and larger engineering constitu tes a high proport ion of all manufac turing industry in terms of number s employed and capital invested . Seconda ry activity is markedl y concentrated in the eastern Downs, not only because of the higher populat ion density in this area for which labour as well as markets are more readily located, but partly also because of the availability of reliable water supplies . URBAN DEVEL OPMEN T Major centres in the region include Toowoomba , Warwic k and Dalby in the southeastern sector, Chinchilla and Miles in the central section of the region and Taroom in the northwe st. Overall populat ion has remai_ned relatively constan t in recent years. While there has been a growth in populat ion in the major centres such as Toowoo mba and Dalby, in other areas populat ions have declined slightly- possibly reflecting changin g patterns and conditio ns of rural industry.

PRESE NT WATER RESOURCES DEVEL OPMEN T AND USE 1:he develop ment and continu ed viability of agricult ural and associated industries in the region has been largely depende nt on the availability and utilisation of water supplies from both surface and undergr ound sources. At present the major use of water supplies is for irrigation, particul arly along the Dawson Condam ine and Border Rivers where th~ major water resources develop ment has occurred. Use of water supplies for urban and limited industri al develop ment has tended to be concent rated in the centres of major populat ion in the eastern part of the region . To date, some five dams and fourteen weirs have been construc ted in those parts of the Dawson , Condam ine and Border Rivers catchme nts within the study region of this report. The locations of major storages in each of the principal river systems, together with brief details, are shown in Table 2. CONDA MINE RIVER BASIN Groundwater Supplies The main source of water for irrigation in the Condam ine region is from the extensive alluvial deposits which extend over a considerable length of the Condam ine River. Water is drawn by pumpin g from aquifers as shallow as I O m to depths of I 00 m below ground level. Over recent years excessive pumpin g from bores has caused a decline in groundw ater levels. This has resulted in dewater ing of large areas of the upper alluvium to the extent that over much of the main groundw ater area, the top sections of the aquifer are now above the water table. The ultimate solution to the problem lies in the careful monitor ing and efficient use of existing supplies and a progressive change from groundw ater to surface supplies where this is practica ble and can be underta ken economically. Althoug h actual records of consum ption from the groundw ater area are not available for the Condam ine River Valley it is estimated that some 87 000 ML are obtained annually from this source for irrigatio n and urban requirements. Available evidence indicates that practically all recharge of the aquifer results from infiltration to the aquifer from the Condam ine 111


Table 2-Surat Basin Storages Completed Storage Capacity ( ML)

Date Completed

Warwick Warwick Toowoomba Cecil Plains Cecil Plains Dalby Chinchilla Miles

47 100 2 810 23 100 l 040

1965 1927 1940 1947

900 9 780 382

1958 1973 1948

Glebe Weir

Taroom

17 300

1972

Glenlyo n Dam Bonshaw Weir Cunningham Weir Glenarbon Weir Coolmund a Dam Greenup Weir Inglewood Weir Whetstone Weir Ben Dor Weir Goond iwindi Weir

Stanth orpe Texas Texas Yelarbon ln glewood Inglewood Inglewood Inglewood Yelarbo n G oondiwindi

26 1 000 617 543 353 75 200 370 285 506 734 l 660

1976 1958 1954 1959 1968 1958

Stream

AMTD ( km)

Name of Storage

Co11dami11e Basin Sandy Creek Rosenthal Creek Cooby Creek Conda mine River Cond amine River Condamine River Condamine River Dogwood Creek

8. 4 20.3 124.l 89 1. l 879.0 833.6 697.0 107.9

Leslie Dam Connolly Dam Cooby Creek Dam Cecil Plai ns Weir Tipton Weir Loudoun Weir Chinchilla Weir Miles Weir

Dall'son River Dawson River

326.2

Border Rivers Pike Creek Dumaresq River Dumaresq River Dumaresq Ri ver Macintyre Brook Macintyre Brook Macintyre Brook Macintyre Brook Macintyre Brook Macintyre Ri ver

6.4 126.7 67.9 57.0 78.0 73.4 55.2 38.5 18.7 268.8

River a nd this recha rge has been estimated to average some 13 200 ML per annum. Comparing estimated annual use with recharge capacity, it is apparent that there is a current excess of groundwater withdrawal over recharge of some 74 000 ML per annum . Away from the main Condamine aquifer, supplies from groundwater are both limited and variable. Considerable use is made of this source, however, for domestic and limited stock supplies.

Surface Water Supplies To date eight storages have been constructed in the Condamine basin as shown in Table 2. Leslie Dam , loca ted on Sandy Creek, at 8.4 km , was constructed by the Queensland Wa ter Resources Commission in 1965 to provide regula ted water supplies for irrigation of lands riparian to Sandy Creek downstream of the dam and along the Condamine River downstream to Cecil Plains. In addition, the dam provides supplies for the augmentatio n of the existing water supply from Connolly Dam to the City of Warwick . Leslie Dam has a storage capacity of 47 000 ML and provides a total assured 112

Nearest Toll'n

1951 1954 1942

supply of 16 100 ML including inflows to the Condamine River downstream of the dam . Current water use from the regulated section of the river downstream of the dam to Cecil Plains and urban requirements for Warwick City total some 17 700 ML. Leslie Dam is capable of enlargement to 107 400 ML by the construction of a second stage of development. This would increase assured supplies available to 33 700 ML per annum . The construction of Stage 2 has been approved by the Government and will proceed as and when funds can be made available. Supplies from the Stage 2 development will be used to meet the existing deficit in allocations as well as to provide an alternative supply for existing users of groundwater where practicable to allow some reduction in the present over-use of groundwater . Considerable use is also made of unregulated supplies in the Condamine basin in the areas downstream of Cecil Plains and above the Sandy Creek confluence which are outside the influence of Leslie Dam. A total of 120 licenses have been issued to landowners along the unregulated sections of the Condamine River. Chinchilla Weir was constructed by the Department of Local Government on behalf


of the Queensland Water Resources Commission in 1973 for the purposes of augmenting the water supply to the township of Chinchilla and of providing assured supplies of water for riparian irrigation over about 80 km of the Condamine River downstream of the weir. Toowoomba City, the major centre of the region, obtains its water supply from only one storage in the Condamine River basin-on Cooby Creek. However this supply is only used intermittentl y and the present main source of water supply is from Perseverance Creek Dam in the Brisbane River catchment which supplies 4240 ML per annum. A new storage on Cressbrook Creek is being constructed by Toowoomba City Council to augment supplies available from Perseverance Creek Dam . Cressbrook Creek Dam is also located within the Brisbane River catchment. DAWSON RIVER BASIN

Surface Supplies Water resources development in the Upper Dawson region has involved the construction of six weirs for the purpose of providing assured water supplies in the Dawson Valley Irrigation Area. Glebe Weir, the largest of the six weirs on the Upper Dawson River, is the only major storage in the Taroom area. Constructed by the Queensland Water Resources Commission in 1972, the weir is operated in conjunction with the five smaller weirs downstream to regulate natural streamflow in the Dawson River for irrigation in the irrigation settlements of Theodore and Gibber Gunyah, for the irrigation of lands riparian to the Dawson River downstream of the weir at Theodore by private diversion, and for urban and mining use. Supply from the weirs within the region is fully committed . Groundwater Supplies The alluvium of the Dawson River and its tributaries up tream ofTaroom are capable of yielding only limited supplies. On the Daw on River channel relatively narrow aquifers are common features of the area and these give rise to severe boundary effects in production facilities. Where alluvium exists on tributary streams, it appears to act as a limited storage from which water may be extracted via bores

which penetrate the underlying porous beds of the Great Artesian Basin sequence. Little is known of the quality of water in the area but available data suggest that it varies widely. Present use is limited to a few stock and domestic supplies. There is virtually no potential for large scale use. BORDER STREAMS Surface Water Supplies To date, two major storages have been constructed on the border streams which are of particular relevance to the Surat BasinCoolmunda Dam on Macintyre Brook and Glenlyon Dam on Pike Creek . Coolmunda Dam was constructed by the Queensland Water Resources Commission in 1968 to provide water supplies for irrigation of tobacco and also fodder and grain crops, irrigated pastures and some horticultural crops on lands that were previously used for tobacco production. The dam of 75 200 ML capacity is operated in conjunction with four downstream weirs on Macintyre Brook . The storage system is capable of supplying an estimated 18 520 ML annually. This supply is virtually fully committed for irrigation and urban u e in the township of Inglewood and no spare supplies are available from this source for any major development. The Dumaresq-B arwon Border Rivers Commission was jointly established by the Government s of Queensland and ew South Wales and was charged, inter a/ia, with construction of certain works on those sections of the Severn, Dumaresq, Macintyre and Barwon Rivers which constitute part of the boundary of the two States. Glenlyon Dam was constructed by the Dumaresq-B arwon Border Rivers Commission in 1976. The dam has a gross storage capacity of 261 000 ML and an estimated annual assured supply of 115 950 ML which is divided equally between the two States. Queensland' s share of the supply is used for regulating flows in the Severn River and the upper reaches of the Macintyre River downstream to Mungindi Weir on the Border, in conjunction with Glenarbon, Cunningham and Bon haw weirs on the Dumaresq River. At present some 20 000 ML have been committed from the 57 975 ML available to Queensland as its share of the regulated supply from Glenlyon Dam. 113


Table 3----Commitment of Exi ting Supplies

Source

Supply A l'ailable ( ML /annum)

Present Use ( ML/amwm)

Current Commitment

16 100 13 200

17 700 87 000

I 600 ML over committed . 73 800 ML over committed.

18 520 57 975

16 500 20 000

Co11dami11e River (a) Sur/ ace Supplies

Leslie Dam (b) Groundwater

Border Streams (a) Surface Supplies

Coolmunda Dam and D/S weirs Glenl yon Dam and D/S weirs (b) Groundwater

Virtuall y fully committed . Spare supply of 38 000 ML currentl y exists in .the Border strea ms. Limited suppl ies onl y fo r stock and domestic use.

Da1rson Region (a) S ur/ace Supplies (b) Ground1rn ter

All supplies available are full y commi11ed. Limited suppl ie only fo r stock and domestic use.

The torage capacity is capable of being increa ed by the installation of five , ninemetre high ere t gates on the spillway of the dam . Thi facility would increase the assured upply available to Queensland in the border stream to some 74 000 ML. It i desirable to note that while the assured supply which can be made available in the whole length of the border streams is presently some 58 000 ML, this includes a considerable component resulting from use of unregulated river flows . The supply actually available at the storage is substantially less. As an example of this, while addition of the gates to Glenlyon Dam is estimated to provide an additional supply of 16 000 ML for Queen land in the border stream at , say, Texas or beyond , the actual increa e in yield at the storage itself is only about 9250 ML.

Groundwater Supplies The alluvium of the Dumaresq River between Mingoola and Macintyre Brook is capable of yielding moderate to large supplies of groundwater of normally good quality. Existing supplies are mainly u ed for stock and domestic purposes although some irrigation supplies are obtained from groundwater sources. In most areas, drawdown is limited by the shallow depth of the aquifer and costly large diameter extraction facilities are reqt1ired to fully utilise the groundwater potential. This is estimated to be about 45 000 ML per annum but is not regarded as being able to be achieved at economic cost levels. 114

PRESE TA VAILABLE SUPPLIES The extent to which presently available supplies in the region are currently committed is summarised in Table 3. FUTURE WATER RESOURCES POTE TIAL

As mentioned earlier surface water supplies in each of the major stream systems of the Surat Basin a re fully committed with the exception of Glenlyon Dam for which there is currently spare supply available of some 38 000 ML in the Border stream. Any future large scale development in the region would therefore require the construction of additional major storage. A number of sites have been identified in the region which could be considered as potential sources of supply for major coal development in the future . The locations of these ites are shown in Figure I and their potential for water resources development is summarised in Table 4. DA WSO

RIVER BAS!

Dawson River 472.5 km- Baroondah Damsite The Baroondah site is located at 472.5 km on the Dawson River in a deep gorge about 60 km west ofTaroom. The catchment area of the site is 5750 km 2 . A dam of I 098 000 ML storage capacity could be constructed , which would fully develop the site hydrologically to yield an estimated 125 000 ML per annum.


The total cost of a dam of this ca pacity is estimat ed to be $38 million a t today's prices, which is equival ent to a unit capital cost per megalitre of supply of $304.

Palm Tree Creek 11.4 km- Damsit e Palm Tree Creek is a tributa ry of the Dawso n River which joins the main stream about 8 km downst ream of Taroom . The damsite is located at 11.4 km on Palm Tree Creek and comma nds a total catchm ent area of 5220 km 2 . A dam of I 230 000 ML capacit y could be constru cted to fully develop the site and for this level of develop ment the storage would yield an estimat ed 68 000 ML per annum at the site. On the basis of prelimi nary investigations the dam is estimated to cost $53 million , equival ent to a unit capital co t of $779 per megalit re of supply. Da wson River 307.3 km- Nathan Gorge Damsit e athan Gorge a major topogra phical feature on the Dawso n River is located about 40 km northea st of Taroom . The damsite is located within the Gorge area and comma nds a total catchm ent area of 23 630 km 2- virtually the whole of the Upper Dawso n catchm ent. The site is capable of very large develop ment. A storage of 3 150 000 ML could be constru cted to fully develop the site hydrologically and, for this level of develop ment, the storage would yield an estimat ed 327 000 ML annuall y. The deep gorge section lends itself to a concret e arch type structu re. On the basis of prelimi nary estimates, the dam would cost some $61 million at current prices which is equival ent to a unit capital cost per megalitre of supply of$185 . The site could be developed in stages to reduce the high initial capital cost of constructin g the dam to full develop ment. However, for all levels of develop ment the storage would inunda te Glebe Weir and lands currently irrigate d from the weir storage , would inunda te part of Taroom for upper levels of develop ment, and would have conside rable environ mental impact on the Gorge. CONDAMINE RIVER BASIN Condamine River 1137.2 km- Elbo w Valley Damsit e The Elbow Valley site is located at

1137.2 km on the Condam ine River about 20 km southea st of Warwick . ·The catchm ent area of the site is 324 km 2 . A dam of 74 000 ML could be constru cted to fully develop the site hydrologically and at this level of develop ment a total of 1800 ha of land would be inunda ted of which 650 ha are current ly used for agricul ture. The site has been considered as one of several possible storage options in the Condamine River Basin which in conjun ction with the Leslie Dam and downst ream weirs could be operate d to reduce the present overco mmitmen t of surface and ground water supplies in the Condam ine River. If the storage was operate d with the proposed stage II develop ment at Leslie Dam, the increase in supply contrib uted from the Elbow Valley site would be about 17 100 ML per annum . The co t of the dam at present day prices is likely to be some $9.5 million .

Condamine River 1040.9 km- Pratten Damsit e The Pratten damsite is located at 1040.9 km on the Condam ine River about 4 km north of the townsh ip of Pratten and some 30 km northw est of Warwick. At this point the alluvial deposit s in the Condam ine River reduce significantly in width to about 700 m. The site comma nds a catchm ent area of about 3000 km 2 and is capable of development up to a storage capacit y of 200 000 ML. For storage capacities greater than about 100 000 ML the Warwic k-Goon diwind i railway line would have to be relocated around the storage area . At this lower level of develop ment of a storage capacit y of 100 000 ML, an earth and rockfill structu re with a side channe l spillway would be envisaged for which the total cost of constru ction would be some $13.1 million . Operat ed in conjun ction with the propos ed Stage II develop ment of Leslie Dam a 100 000 ML storage at the Pratten site would have a combin ed yield of some 55 700 ML per annum of which 22 000 ML would be contributed by the Pratten site. The storage would , however, inunda te several thousan d ha of highly produc tive agricul tural lands along the Condam ine River upstrea m of the site. This feature would have to be regarde d as a major constra int on the develop ment of the site in the foreseeable future . 115


Condamine River 1033.8 km- Talgai Damsite Conside red as a possible alternati ve storage develop ment to the Pratten damsite, the Talgai damsite is located at I 033.8 km on the Condam ine River about 7 km downstr eam of the Pratten dam ite and comman ds a total catchme nt area of some 3050 km 2. Althoug h conside rably wider than the Pratten damsite, both in terms of alluvial depo its and distance between abutmen ts, the Talgai site is capable of larger develop ment up to a capacity of 400 000 ML, which would fully develop the site hydrologically. However, storage would inundat e the railway line above a capacity of 200 000 ML and, in addition , some 18 km of the Ryeford -Pratten -Cunnin gham road would have to be relocated. For the lower level of develop ment of 200 000 ML the storage would provide an addition al 23 I 00 ML per annum after due allowance for stage II of Leslie Dam and would cost an estimate d $16.6 million . The storage would inundat e several thousand ha of prime agricult ural lands along the Condam ine River and again this must be regarded as a major obstacle to the development of the site in the foreseeable future . BORDE R STREA MS Future possibilities for water resources develop ment in the Border Streams include storages on the Mole and Severn Rivers and the addition of spillway gates on Glenlyo n Dam.

Severn River 198.6 km Damsite The Severn River damsite is located at 198.6 km on the Severn River, on the Queensland side of the State Border at the head of a long gorge section of the river. The site comman ds a total catchme nt area of 1310 km 2 and is capable of a maximu m storage develop ment up lo about I 000 000 ML which is the hydrologic limit for the site. A dam of this capacity would have an annual yield of 76 000 ML and cost an estimated $100 million. The high unit capital cost of supply from the dam of $1316 per ML, reflects the relatively poor storage characteristics of the narrow gorge above the site, in relation to the 116

height and size of structur e required. In common with other storages construc ted on Border streams , the supply would have to be shared equally between the two States resulting in a net supply available in Queensl and of 38 000 ML per annum.

Mole River Damsite Located in New South Wales approxi mately 12 km from the Queensl and border, the Mole River damsite comman ds a total catchme nt area of 1850 km 2 . The Water Resources Commission of New South Wales has investigated a dam of 530 000 ML capacity, which is thought to be the hydrologic limit for the site. For this level of develop ment, the storage would yield a supply of86 000 ML per annum, which would be shared equally between the two States. The estimate d cost of develop ment is $47 million at current prices, which is equivalent to a unit cost of supply of $546 per megalitre.

Pik e Creek 6.4 km- Glen/yon Dam Stage II As mention ed earlier, it is technically feasible to increase the storage capacity of Glenlyon Dam by the installat ion of five, ninemetre high spillway gates which would result in an increase in annual supply from the dam of 18 500 ML per annum. The cost of construc ting and installing the gates is estimated to be some $5.8 million at current prices. OTHER WATER SUPPL Y SOURC ES Boyne River 86 .7 km- Boondooma Dam Boondo oma Dam, currentl y under constructio n on the Boyne River, will provide water supplies for the Tarong Power Station, for the irrigatio n of some 3000 ha of land riparian to the Boyne River downstr eam of the dam as far as Mundub bera, and for other users along the pipeline from the dam to the power station. The dam will have a storage capacity of 210 000 ML from which an annual supply of 46 240 ML will be available. The present design for the dam provides for the possible construc tion of a second stage in the future which would increase the torage capacity to 620 000 ML. This second stage of develop ment would provide an addition al assured supply of23 760 ML per annum for a


Table 4-Potential for Water Resources Development

Estimated Capital Cost $m

Unit Cost of Supply ($/ ML)

125 000 68 000 327 000

38 53 61

304 779 185

74 000 200 000 100 000 400 000 200 000

17 100 26 7001hl 22 0001h1 32 1001b1 23 1001h)

9.5 15.91"' 13.1 21.3 1"' 16.6

555 595 595 663 71 8

I 000 000 530 000

76 000"' 86 0001'1 18 5001«di

100 47 5.8

I 316 546 313

23 760ldl

8.7

366

AMTD (km)

Catchment Area (km')

Optimum Storage Capacity ( ML)

Upper Dall'son River Basin Dawson River Palm Tree Creek Dawson River

472.5 11.4 307.3

5 750 5 220 23 630

I 098 000 I 230 000 3 150 000

Condamine River Basin Condamine River Condamine River

I 137.2 I 040.9

324 3 000

Condamine River

I 033.8

3 050

198.6

I 310 I 580

Stream

Border Streams Severn River Mole River Pike Creek Other Areas Boyne River

6.4

86.7

4 200

Annual Supply ( ML)

railway. (a) Storage at this level inundates the railway line upstream. Estima tes of cost do not include the cost of reloca li on of the (b) Increase in annual suppl y from dam after Leslie Dam Stage II completed . (c) Total supply- to be divided equally between the States of Queensland and New South Wales. (d) Marginal costs and suppl y from Stage II development only.

capital cost of Stage 2 works alone of $8.7 million at current prices.

Other Neighbouring Catchments Storage sites exist in the Mary River basin to the north east and these sites have been examined in the past as possible sources of supply for power station development etc. While these sites are considerable distances away from coal deposits and likely mine locations, and therefore expensive to develop and obtaii:i supplies from , they cannot be totally dismissed in relation to coal processing facilities. During any detailed study of a particular development proposal, these sites could come into further consideration. SUMMARY

Existing surface and groundwater supplies in the Surat Basin and western Moreton Basin are generally fully committed to irrigation, urban and minor industrial development in the region, whilst in some of the principal agricultural areas of the Condamine River Valley there are significant shortfalls in annual supply-available from present sources. Future major industrial development in the region will only be possible if accompanied by

the construction of additional surface storage. Although it is obvious that there is considerable water resource development potential in some parts of the region , which could cater for the requirements of mining and associated industries for a long time in the future, the cost of developing suitable storage sites would be considerable . It is also apparent that the establishment in the region of one or more coal processing industries with large water needs could require the development of several sites located at large distances from one another in different stream basins. The Upper Dawson River basin is, at present, largely undeveloped and consequently a major storage could be constructed in this area with only minor constraints imposed by disruption to existing development and settlement. Storages at 472.5 or 307.3 km on the Dawson River would be the most likely development options particularly for coal mining and coal-based industries centred on Taroom and Waridoan . These sites could also be considered in relation to more remote centres such as Brigalow, Acland and Millmerran, where highly capital intensive projects could perhaps sustain the large investment required in pipelines, pumping and associated works to de117


liver the necessary water needs over long distances. Storage sites on the Condamin e River, although favourably located with respect to potential mine areas, are generally costly in terms of available supply and their development would be subject to constraints other than pure economic feasibility . The sites also pre ent difficulties for constructio n because of unfavoura ble and permeable foundation conditions, and the storage area of both sites would inundate large areas of highly productive and valuable agricultura l land . These sites on the Condamin e River and the resources which they would develop are regarded by the Commissio n as being of use, primarily, to reduce the current substantia l shortfalls in assured supply from existing surface and groundwat er sources. In addition it is possible that urban developme nt in Toowoom ba beyond the 1990's may have to be met at least partially from the water resources of the Condamin e River Valley. Storage sites on the border streams offer significant water resources developme nt potential particularl y in relation to coal mining areas at Millmerran and Acland . Again , however, there are constraints on the development of these sites which are unrelated to their economic or engineering developme nt feasibility. Developm ent of any storage on the border streams requires the agreement of both State Governme nts and an equal sharing of supplies made available from the development. While the costs of any major water resource developme nt would most likely have to be totally provided by a future developer, the supply available is likely to be only half the total supply indicated in Table 4. This dramatical ly increases the unit capital cost per ML of available supply from any storage.

118

At the present time there is spare supply available from Glenlyon Dam, but it is not expected that this position will continue for any lengthy period of time. Past experience with most storages in the State indicates a gradually accelerating take-up of available supplies as landholder s gain experience and see the benefits of irrigated developme nt. Storage si tes in neighbouri ng catchment s to the region , such as Boondoom a Dam and the dam sites in the Mary River Basin, offer some potential as water sources for the central region of the Surat Basin. However the cost of supply is certain to be considerab le and these ites are not likely to be economically attractive at least in the foreseeable future . Land and water use conflicts in the region appear likely to develop in the future in the basins of the Condamin e River and the Border Streams. Continuin g agricultura l development and growth in irrigated production occasioned by urban developme nt and expanding markets for primary produce will all place strains on currently available water supplies and generate demands for their augmentat ion. Against this traditional land and water use the likely water demands for coal mining, coal processing, other industry and urban needs must be recognised , together with the pressures which these new uses will place on limited resources. A resolution of these conflicts will be necessary in the best interests of the State as and when they arise.

T. D. FENWICK , Queenslan d Water Resources Commissio n, Mineral House, 41 George Street, Brisbane, Queenslan d, 4000.


REVEGET ATIO

OF OPE -CUT Ml

I G AREAS

By M . J. Russell ABSTRAC T

Extensive areas of eastern Australia are underlain by coal seams. The nature of the sediments that overlie this coal ha re ulted in most of these areas being under agricultura l or pastoral use. This land must be returned to its former use after temporary disturbanc e due to mining the coal. Both the farmer and the miner impose constraint s on the rehabilitat ion process used . The process of open-cut coal mining and subsequen t rehabilitat ion is described . Rehabilitatio n involves the developme nt of 'watershed units' with special topograph y . The rationale for this is discussed. To date pasture species have been used for revegetatio n in some areas mined in the Bowen Basin and the Millmerran box cut. The nature of the spoils is broadly described and chemical analyses are shown . These analyses have been used to plan agronomic experimen ts based on chemical amendmen ts of the spoil. Results indicate varying degrees of revegetatio n success at Mi llmerran and in the Bowen Basin. When such experimen ts have not been successful the reasons have been physical rather than chemical. Serious crusting problems are described and analysed . They have been overcome by using surface mulch in which to establish pasture species. The rehabilitat ion topograph y of spoils, already described, is essential both for revegetation and economic reasons. It causes high discharge rates following high intensity rain necessitati ng stabilisatio n of channel ways with special grasses. However, the overall increase in discharge rates from large areas of rehabilitat ion will pose serious discharge problems downstrea m from mines. Revegetati on of spoils may be done by reafforesta tion , or by permanent pastures, or by short term pastures if a return to arabl~ use is envisaged . The implication s of these options are discussed . INTRODU CTION

Extensive areas of eastern Australia are sedimenta ry basinS; including coal seams in

their tratigraphy . These sediments were laid down from the Permian onwards and are broadly similar, consisting of mudstones , siltstones and shales interlamin ated with quartzose and feldspathic sandstones , and with some igneous intrusions (Dickins and Malone, 1973; Milligan, 1975; Q .D .P.I. , ·1978). Weatherin g of these sediments has produced soils which range from grey and brown soils of heavy texture to salinised, texturecontrast soils where the influence of sandstone has been greater (Q.D .P.I., I 978). These basins are used for agricultura l and pastoral enterprises . Pastoral enterprises are those in which extensive grazing of sheep and cattle occurs with little cultivation or land amendment other than timber clearing. Agricultur al enterprises are mixed livestock and crop fa:ms depending on more complete land clearing, and a variable amount of cultivation . Agricultural enterpri e occur mainly on the grey and brown soils of heavy texture in zones serviced by roads or railways which enable economic transport of crops to markets. Large areas of these basins were formerly under woodland and have been cleared for agricultura l and pastoral use within the last two decades. The land is a national asset and the principles of proper land use make it incumbent on those temporaril y disturbing it to return it to its former or alternative preferred use . Open-cut coal mining must rehabilitat e the land to as good a condition as before for the farmer and do it as economica lly as possible for the miner. REHABIL ITATIO A D REVEGETATIO

The process of open-cut coal mining currently involve exposing the coal seams by removal of the over-burde n, after loosening by blasting, using large draglines or continuous bucket excavators . Draglines depo it the spoil in parallel heaps, commenci ng with the box-cut, with slopes at . 35 °-39 ° which is the angle of slip for this material. Rehabilita tion involves reducing the slope 119


c::,

'o'

s.· O \ wEsTM 0

i ,a·s+ (

•

I

·O ~ .✓.

\

LAWN HIL e NAROOO

'e KAMILEROI •MOR~TONE MILLUNG

\

20-~~00WEAL +G,:lANAOA

:J,<

+

\ MOUNT l ~ l NCU.lRY . LA KE -;:..,.SH

i

i

-zi-s~ I

i

<-a

2-4 i

i 2,s

•

2-0

0

50 100

200

300km

ALL RAINFALL INTENSJTlfS IN mm/h

Fig. I. 72-hour duration, 50-year recurrence interval rainfall intensity (mm/h) for Queensland. Reproduced from 'Australian Rainfall and Runojf' by the Institution of Engineers, Australia (1977) p. 40.

120


of these spoil heaps to 6 °-11 ° (10 to 20%) with the use of large bulldozers. Because the coal seams are worked down dip, the overburden increases progressively in volume. The reduction in bulk density, due to blasting and handling, of this increasing volume of material results in a slight overall upward slope of the reshaped spoils from the box-cut to the high wall. This is fortunate in some respects, because it ensures drainage away from the excavation pit, but it also imposes severe constraints on the topography of reshaping. The reshaped area between two ramps and stretching from the box-cut to the excavation pit is called a drainage unit. The topography of drainage units must be designed to effect efficient run-off during heavy falls of rain by providing ponds and properly stabilised waterways, which will minimise erosion damage. (Collins, 1976). The spoil derived from mudstones and shales is argillaceous. However, a contribution of sand together with high contents of monovalent cations, particularly sodium, results in severe surface crusting. The spoil has high total soluble salts, and therefore a high electrical conductivity which often exceeds two microsiemens cm- 1 . Most of the spoils are alkaline with pH values sometimes exceeding 9.0. Both total soluble salts and pH are reduced with time of exposure to rain (Russell, 1978). Table l shows chemical analyses of spoils at four mines in the Bowen Basin. It can be seen that calcium, magnesium, potassium and sodium levels are high whilst heavy metal levels are low. Carbonate and bicarbonate levels are high and sulphate levels

must be expected to increase as sulphides oxidise. Phosphate and available nitrate levels are rather low. Revegetation experiments at Utah Development Company (UDC) and Central Queensland Coal Associates (CQCA) mines were based on these analyses and tested ammonium nitrate and superphosphate amendments at several levels (Russell, 1979). The test species were Rhodes' grass (Chloris gayana), Buffel grass (Cenchrus ciliaris), Green panic grass (Panicum maximum var. trichog/ume) and the legume Siratro (Macroptilium atropurpureum), already found to be suitable for the climate and soils in agronomic work by CSIRO (Coaldrake, 1970; Coaldrake and Russell, 1978). Typical results of these trials, both in the Bowen Basin and at Millmerran, are shown in Tables 2 and 3. In neither experiment at Millmerran were the covers shown significantly different due to interaction effects between the test grasses and the fertilisers; buffel behaved atypically to both superphosphate and nitrate. However, at Saraji mine, and to some extent at Goonyella mine, both in the Bowen Basin, there were failures in revegetation experiments due to serious surface crusting. This problem has been overcome by mulching the surface of the soil with top-soil or with coarse reject coal. Results ofthe preliminary mulching experiment are shown in Table 4. As a result of these experiments UDC and CQCA annually seed and fertilise their shaped spoils, usually by aircraft. This must be done in December to maximise the likelihood of

Table I-Spoil Chemical Analyses at Four Mine Sites in the Bowen Basin

Chemical Data

Blackwater

Saraji

Peak Downs

Goonyella

Phosphate (Bicarb) ppm Organic carbon %C itrate ppm N pH SLT* mmho (m siemens) cm- 1 Cl ppm a ppm K ppm Ca ppm Mg ppm Fe ppm Cu ppm Mn ppm Znppm

2.5-9.0 0.9-2. 1 2.3-9.0 7.3-8.4 0.2-0.7 340-992 1670-1870 160-270 1620-6000+ 1290-2260 3.6-39 0.2-3.7 1.2-8.0 0.3-5.5

1.0-16.0 0.8-3.6 3.0-26.0 5.4-9.3 0.02-5.2 1000+ 1000+ 231-278 300-486 604-1000+ 19-39 1.1-2.8 4-8 1.4-10.2

8.5-12.0 0.23-0.38 3.6-9.4 7.2-8.6 0.5-2.2 1920-5000 2550-3250 100-180 700-800 1150-1450 3.0-4.5 0.45-0. 75 0.5-1.5 1.0-2.2

3. 7-5.6 0.5-1.0 3.4-13. 1 7.0-8.8 0.2-2.0 450-1000+ 820-2350 100-155 560-860 700-1220 4.2-30 1.1-1.45 3.7-5.2 2.7-3.0

•Total Soluble Salts.

121


Table 2- The Effect s of Superphosphate and Ammonium itrate on the Cover (o/0 ) of Grasst in Four Experiments al UDC and CQCA Mines in the Bowen Basin

Superphosphate

Ammonium nitrate

Experiment M edium+

Nil

Hig/,+

Blackwa ter S ignificance oj Dijjerences

9.8 3.8*

13.6

32.8 19.2***

Peak Downs I Significance oj Dijjerences

12.0 18.0**

30.0

55.6 25 .6***

Peak Downs 11 Significance oj Dijjerences Goonyella Significance oj Dijjerences

11.6 23.5***

40.2

86.9 46.7**

35. 1

63.0 27.9** *

JOO kg ha- '

Nil

26.5

38.6 12. 1*

41.1

32. 1 9.0*

• Medium and high rates diffe r slightly between experiments but approxi mate 100 a nd 400 kg ha- 1 respecti vely. t AII results are for the first season·s growth.

Table 3-The Effects of Superphosphate and Ammonium Nitrate on the Cover l%) of Grasst in Two Experiments at the Millmerran-Mitsui-Amax Joint Venture Boxcut, Millmerran

S uperphosphate

Ammonium nitra te

Experiment N il

On Flat So il

18.0

On Topsoiled Slopes

17. 1

IOU kg ha- '

400 kg ha- '

22 .6 28.2 375 kg ha- ' 24.3

Nil

14.6 18. I

IOU kg ha-'

400 kg ha- '

22.9 31.3 150kgha- • 23.3

tAfter the first season of growth in each experiment.

Table 4-Effects of Mulching and Ripping on Pasture Establishment t in the Mulch Experiment at Saraji Mine, Bowen Basin

Treatment

o t Ripped Ripped Mulch: Sa nd Coa rse Reject Bushland Soil Grass: Buffel Rhodes grass

Corer %

22. 1 31.0 19.2 22.9 37.6 20.2 32.9

Dijjerence

8.9** 3.7 n.s. 14.7*** 12.7 n.s.

Yield kg ha- '

I 0 10 I 713 859 I 403 I 822 I 101 I 621

Dijjerence

703** 544* 419 n.s. 520 n.s.

t in the first seaso n of growth .

rece1vmg germinating and follow-up rains. UDC and CQCA now have some 820 ha of satisfactorily revegetated spoils at their four mine sites in the Bowen Basin . (Kelly, in press). The cost of rehabilitation at these mines is currently in the range from $5-11 ,000 (Kelly, in press) per ha. Most of this cost is due to spoil reshaping. Because of the shape of the spoil ridges, the cost of reducing the slope increases logarithmically with decreasing slope a ngle. 11 ° (20%) is the maximum slope which can be revegetated and maintained reasonably stable. However slopes of less than 3c (5%) shed water too slowly, and are subject 122

to sheet erosion following heavy rain. A compromise of 6 ° ( I 0.5%) is aimed for in shaping drainage units. Such slopes can be revegetated adequately, and probably permanently, shed water at acceptable rates, and do not involve excessive spoil displacement. Figure I shows the 72-hour rainfall intensities expected in a 50-year recurrence interval for Queensland (Institution of Engineers of Australia , 1977). For the Bowen Basin mines it has been estimated (Collins, 1976) that a drainage unit of 180 ha will receive 133 200 kL (m 3) in the highest intensity fall (74 mm hr- 1) expected with a frequency of once in 50 years (Anon ., 1963).


1 3 This will discharg e at the rate of 18.5 m secout of the final waterwa y of the watersh ed unit. For an 8 m wide waterwa y, this flow will be 2½ m deep. A number of tolonife rous gra ses have been grown at Peak Downs mine to stabilise these waterways (Ru ell, 1979). The most suitable to date is green couch (Cynodon dactylon) but it has not yet been put fully to the test. To date, compara tively small areas have been disturbe d by open-cu t mining. As this .. area increases, overall run-off rate will be conside rably accelerated because the flat terrain of a basin, which formerly flooded shallowly after high intensity rain, will have been transfor med into an undulat ing topography all discharg ing efficiently into nonimpeded channels. These will discharg e into the main rivers within hours of the heavy fall compar ed with days prior to mining. In the example given, discharge would be largely complet e in less than 2 hours. This may cause major problem s downstr eam. In the Bowen Basin, the rational e for using pasture species has been that not only are these the fastest and cheapes t way of revegetati ng and stabilising spoil in this area, but most of the areas were, or were to become, pasture before mining. However, tree planting must also be included in revegeta tion for a number of reasons. Trees are required for shade for grazing livestock and to reduce wind intensity. Deep-ro oted trees also give more stability in valleys and depressi ons subject to erosion. Trees are importa nt in amenity areas, around buildings and on areas difficult to revegetate with herbace ous species. Finally, tree may be very valuable for undergr ound mining where coal seams are too deep to be econom ically mined by the open-cu t method.

A limited amount of tree planting has been done at UDC and CQCA mines. It has been succes ful when trees native to the area have been used. The u e of the mall legumin ous tree Leucaen a (L. leucocephala) has been hampere d bye tablishm ent problems. In much of the Bowen Basin, the climate and long distance s from markets restrict agriculture to extensive farming with much pasture and little cultivati on. In other areas in which coal will be mined , e.g. in closer parts of the Surat-M oreton Basin such as Millmer ran, climatic and econom ic restraint s are less, and in many cases soils are better, and farming is consequ ently more intensive with a major part of the farm being arable. In these areas revegeta tion of spoil with pasture will not be sufficient to return land to its former use. Rehabil itation will have to aim at produci ng good arable conditio ns. This may involve the stockpil ing and return of top soil, the u e of short term leys and green-m anure crops, and the more complet e flattening of the land with careful contour banking and other devices to prevent soil erosion. Such strategie will increase the cost of revegetation. ACKNO WLEDG MENTS wish to acknow ledge the support and assistance of Utah Develop ment Co. and Amax Iron Ore Corp. (Coal Division) in the work described here, and to thank Mr. R. E. Kelly and Mr. J. M iedecke, the environ mental co-ordin ators of the two compan ies respectively, for their assistance and encoura gement. I thank the Instituti on of Engineers, Australia, for permission to repmdu ce Fig. 2.29 from P. 40 of Australi an Rainfall and Runoff (1977) as Figure I in this paper.

REFERE CES ANON ., 1962: Climate of Central Highlands , Region 11 Queenslan d, Bureau of Meteorolo gy, Commonwealt h of Australia. COALDRAKE, J. E. , 1970: The Brigalow, in Moore , R. M. (Ed), Australian Grasslands, Australian National University Press, Canberra. COALDRAKE, J . E. and RUSSELL, M . J ., 1978: Rehabilitatio n with pasture after open-cut coal mining at three sites in the Bowen Coal Basin of Queenslan d. Reclamation Review I, 1-7. COLLINS, A. G .. 4 976: UDC coal operation s environm ental manual. Utah Developm ent Company Report (unpublish ed).

DICKINS, J . M . and MALONE, E. J., 1973: Geology of the Bowen Basin, Queenslan d. Bull. Bur. Min. Resour. Geol. Geophy s. Aust., 130. KELLY, R . E., (In press): The Central Queenslan d Coalfields , in Mining Rehabilitation /979 , Australian Mining Industry Council. M ILLIGA , E. N ., 1975: German Creek-Go onyella District ; in Traves, D. M. and King. D. (Eds), Economic geology oj Australia and Papua New Guinea. 2, Coal, Australas. Inst. Min. Metal!. Monograp h Series 6. PATTISON, A. et al. (Eds), 1977: Australian rainja/1 and runojj, The Institution of Engineers , Australia .

123


Q EENSLAND DEPARTME TOF PRIMARY INDUSTRI ES, 1978: Description and management of the soils of the Eastern Darlin g Downs, Queensland . Tech. Bull. Lands Div. Dep. Prim. Ind. Qd, 33.

RUSSELL. M. J ., 1979: Spoil-heap revegetatio n at open-cut coal mines in the Bowen Basi n of Queensla nd , Australia. Proc. Ill/ . Congr. Energy and the Ecosystem, North Dak ota, University of North Dakota, Grand Forks. R SSELL. M. J. , 1978: Coal mine spoil heaps revegetation on Uta h Development Company mines in the Bowen Basin. Paper read to the Third Bio-

124

technology Conference , University of New South Wales, August, 1978 (unpublished). THE INSTITUTIO OF ENGINEERS, AUSTRALIA , 1977: Australian rainfall and runojj; The Institulion of Engineers, Australia.

M . J. RUSSEL L Darling Downs Institute of Advanced Educa tion, C/- P.O. Darling Heights, Toowoom ba, Queensland , 4350.


ELECTR IC POWER GE ERATIO

USI G WALLO O

COALS

By T. C . St. Baker ABSTRA CT

The relative scarcity of petroleum and natural gas resources is producin g a changeover to more abundan t primary energy resources and changes in energy consump tion patterns to energy forms derived from lower cost resources . Electric power has a key role to play in this developm ent, being able to be produced from virtually any primary energy resource, and being a convenie nt energy form for reticulation and for a wide range of end uses. Until nuclear electric generatio n by breeder reactors is developed so that the world's large reserves of nuclear energy resources can be harnessed for useful energy productio n, coal or coal derived products represent the most readily available primary energy resource for electric power generatio n, subject to economical developm ent and transport ation, and the main prospect in the immediate future to reduce consump tion and dependence on petroleum. The Walloon coal resources are ideally suited to low cost, mine-site power generation, and can be expected to contribut e t_o the State's developm ent through electnc power generatio n as well as possibly through associated liquefaction and electric power generatio n. Like all steaming coals, special consideration must be given to power station plant to handle the particula r coal character istics of Surat-Mo reton coals, and the beneficiation of these coals must be examined in the light of the ultimate cost of electricity productio n. T RE DS I ELECTRJC POWER GE ERATIO

The massive growth of oil consump tion over the last twenty-five years, and more recently also of natural gas consump tion, created the situation where the world came to rely on these primary energy forms for mo_re than two-third s of its energy needs while having known recoverable reserves only sufficient to support these patterns of energy consump tion for 50 to 70 years. Over the same

period world electric power consu~p tion increased at an average rate of approxim ately 8% per annum and ~ow accounts for 25% of the world 's total pnmary energy consump tion. In many parts of the world , this electric power growth was fuelled by petroleum products , but the present oil crisis has bro~ght about an abrupt switch from scarce premium quality fuels to more abundan t energy form for electric power generatio n, in particula r, coal and nuclear energy resources . Since 1975 virtually no power generatin g facilities bas~d on petroleum fuels have been commenc ed m the U .S.A., and there are increasing steps to convert existing oil-burni ng steam generatin g plants away from oil. Even with effective fuel and energy economies, which will obviously be essential to conserve scarce petroleum and natural gas resources and to tailor our energy consumption patterns to our available resou~ces , electric power demand is expected to continue to grow at relatively high rates, at least over the next twenty-five years, because of: (I) the necessity to change to more ab~ndan t forms of primary energy consump tion; (2) the fact that virtually any primary ~nergy source can be harnessed by convers10n to electrical energy, and (3) the natural trend to an energy form of greater convenience and ease of use. The indicated trend in electric power generation since 1975 has been for countries not endowed with economically recoverable coal resources to develop nuclear power for electricity generatio n. A total of 32 cou~tries are already involved in nuclear . electnc power generatio n, with plant either m opera tion or under construct ion. However with delays in the fast breeder reactor de;elopm ent and continue d public concern in Western countries over nuclear power developm ent, many such countries are clearly looking to coal or coal produ~ts to reduce their dependence on petroleum m the immediate term. Further, until fast breeder reactors are fully developed for commercial operation and 125


GROWTH RATE PREDICTIONS

7

I

1975 - 1986 Oil Consumption : 4.8% p.a . Natural Gas Cons'n. :9.9% p.a. Coal COnwmption : 4.5 % p .o . Renewable . zero Electricity Cons'n . : 7% p .o .

1986-2000 Oil Con1umption : Zo/o p .a d1clinin9 to lo/op.a. 1 Noturol Gas Con1 n. : zero 1 Cool Con1 n : 5i % p.a. declinin9 to ~%p.a. Renewable : 5o/o p.o. Electricity con', . 7% p.a.

- Bostd on Dept. of Nat,onal Development q,.~ort of April 1978

- PoMible extension on these pred i cti on, .

I

'Yo

,oo

I...I

·I iu -

- --r-r- 90

r---+--------1--reo

"' J:, 0

2

C:

1 ~

E :,

" ~

2

30

10

10

C

i.. I.. .!

"'..

40

~

..• C

RENEWAB 1985

1990

2DOO

0

Fig. I. Development of primary energy consumptions to meet possible growth in Australia's total energy demand

126


accepted throughout the world , the economical nuclear energy reserves for thermal fission reactors represent a scarce resource in themselves, because only one-sixtieth of the useful energy is recoverable by this conversion process. This leaves coal as the most readily available primary energy resource for the world 's new power stations, subject to economical costs of development and transportatio n. And from Australia's point of view, the inefficiencies involved in transportatio n of coal and in beneficiation of coals for transportation produce good prospects of indirectly exporting our coal resources through minesite power generation and upgrading of the country's mineral resources for export as processed metal . Apart from these latter possibilities, the development of primary energy consumption s in Australia is expected to result in a 5% per annum growth in coal consumption over the next twenty-five years. Figure I illustrates a possible growth in Australian primary energy consumption s based on a report of the Department of ational Developmen t ( 1978) on primary fuels demands to 1986 and a continuing 4% per annum growth in total energy demand thereafter. This indicates at least a five-fold increase in electricity production in Australia over the next twenty-five years, and about a 3½-fold increase in total coal consumption for domestic needs. Developmen ts in power-intensive metals processing could add significantly to these projections. The energy resources position for Queensland compared to world energy developments is fully outlined by Dawson ( 1978). As outlined in a recent Power Station Coal Enquiry issued by The State Electricity Commission of Queensland ( 1979), coal resources capable of producing at least 500 million tonnes of coal suitable for electric power generation are expected to be required to be committed for the life-time requirements of a number of new power station projects in the State over the next sixteen years. Developmen t of new metals processing industries in the State would add significantly to these requirements . CONVERSI ON OF COAL TO ELECTRIC ITY

The conventiona l cycle for electricity gen-

eration from coal involves the combustion of the coal to generate steam in a boiler and superheater, the steam being used to drive a steam turbine and direct-couple d alternator which delivers the output energy into a grid system as electrical energy. Past trends in conventiona l power stations have been towards increasing scale and higher cycle efficiencies obtained with high pressure and high temperature steam cycles. This has been the case for both oil and coal fired power stations, with single boiler and turbogenerating units of up to 1300 MW capacity now operating, with steam pressures up to 5000 psig (34.5 MPa) and double reheat cycles up to 1200 °F/ 1050 F/1 050 °F steam temperatures ( 649 °C/556 cC/556 °C). into investigations and Research alternative coal-to-electricity conversion cycles have been undertaken for as long as electrical energy has been developed . These processes range from fuel cells to magnetohydro-dynam ics, and from thermoelectr ic and thermionic cycles to liquefaction and gasification prior to conversion to electricity in gas turbines or combined cycle plants (Perry et al., 1968). A summary of alternative cycles for generating electricity from coal has already been outlined by the author (St. Baker, 1979), together with a description of the fuel and flue gas cycle in conventiona l coal-fired steam generating electric power plants. This includes details of coal handling plant, pulverising equipment, combustion facilities , boiler heat exchangers, flue gas particulate removal , and ash and dust disposal. Extensive studies are being undertaken throughout the world , and particularly in the U .S.A. , as reported by Freedman et al. ( 1976). In Queensland, we are presently undertaking preliminary feasibility studies of alternative associated including processes, generation power liquefaction/ electric processes, and we expect to be in a position to take the earliest possible advantage of any proven process found to be more beneficial to the State. EFFECT OF COAL PROPERTI ES ON POWER ST ATIO COSTS

For conventiona l coal-fired steam cycle power station plant for conversion of coal to electrical energy, a wide range of coal properties can be provided for at the design 127


stage. However, the cost of handling extreme coal properties or poor coal qualities produces practical limits and the development of power station technologies is generally based on these limits. Once the coal quality is decided upon , and the power station plant designed and constructed, consistency of quality is most important. Variations in coal properties away from design coal quality result in far more pronounced effects on the performance, capability, reliability and availability of existing power station plant than is quoted for new plant especially designed for the different coal properties. COAL PROPERTIES LIMHS The following limits should be used as a guide for conventional pulverised coal-fired plant.

Ash Content Preferably ash content should not exceed 30% on an as-received basis, although higher ash content coals can be considered. Power station economies accrue to reduced coal ash levels so that the exclusion or separation of stone bands from the coal in a beneficiation process with high specific energy yield is generally economically justified. The optimum beneficiation of steaming coal for a new power station development should be arrived at finally after negotiation between the coal supplier and the power authority. Lower ash contents are usually justified where long tran sport distances are involved. Departures in coal ash contents above the determined specification can have adverse effects on power station availabilities and on the costs of electricity generation. This is especially the case with high specification coal ash contents.

Moisture Content This should preferably be not greater than 15% total moisture content, although coals of higher moisture content can be considered; excess surface moisture should be minimised at all times. Normally surface moisture is minimised by minimising the level of fines (- 3 mm) in the coal product. Coal preparation plants should be designed to minimise surface moisture content at all times. 128

Sizing Not more than 20% of the coal product should be less than 3 mm sizing; top size may be of the order of 75 mm . Unnecessary fines generation at the mine should always be avoided. There should ultimately be an optimisation of the coal crushing between the mine and the power station, possibly with only single stage crushing at the mine. Finer coals, especially where available as a by-product, can be handled with special design provisions.

Volatile Matter Content This should preferably be not less than 20% on dry ash-free basis. Below 20% volatile matter content, there is a limited scope in the design of boiler plant to handle marginally lower volatile matter contents, although operating difficulties and potential unavailability may arise. Below 15% volatiles, however, special boiler designs are necessary, at greater expense.

Grindability There is no absolute limit, although nearly twice the number of pulverising mills could be required for the hardest Queensland coals, compared to the softest coals, to handle the same milling duty, with similar increases in operating costs. The required capability of pulverising plant will also depend on the ranges of coal ash content, moisture content and gross heat value, and an appreciation of these aspects by the coal supplier could result in better optimising of coal preparation plant at the mine and pulverising plant at the power station respectively.

Ash Fusibility It is prefera ble if coal be supplied at not less than 1 l 50 °C deformation temperature in an oxidising atmosphere. Reasonably conventional boiler designs can handle ash fusion deformation temperatures down to l l00 °C, and even below this level with special design provisions. Considerable additional operating cost is risked at very low ash fusion temperatures, however, because of the prospect of more frequent forced outages and possible derating of the power station plant if slagging problems persist.


Specially designed boilers can be constructed for coal of extremely low ash fusibility . fusion a h low localised Where concentratio ns are present in a coal deposit , it is particularly important to prevent such concentratio ns occurring in the product coal to be supplied to the power station. In such cases, adequate monitoring and blending capability will have to be provided at the mine to avoid this.

Sulphur Content This should preferably not exceed I%Expensive sulphur removal or flue gas desulphurisa tion may be required by environment al control authorities where coal sulphur content exceeds I%- No special typical measures are expected with Queensland coals.

Electrical Resistivity of Fly Ash Flue gas particulate removal is affected by a number of factors including electrical re istivity of the fly ash in the case of electrostatic precipitators . The design of electrostatic precipitators for new coals generally requires pilot scale precipitator tests to be undertaken, but an indication of the difficulty, and therefore the cost, of electrostatic by removal particulate precipitators can be gauged from the ash and moisture contents of the coal and the electrical resistivity of the fly ash formed . Other Properties Chlorine, Phosphorou s, Nitrogen and trace elements in coal may affect not only the design of power station plant, but also the measures required to be taken to limit discharge of certain of these constituents or their compounds to the environment . EFFECTS OF VARIATIO NS IN COAL PROPERTIES Detailed examples of power station cost variations resulting from coal property variations have been previously outlined by the author (St. Baker 1978 and 1979). Figure 2 illustrates typical pulverising mill characteristics for a nominal coal of: 15% Ash Content 13% Total Moisture Content

(- 6% Air Dried Moisture Content) (- 7% Free Moisture Content) 25% Volatile Matter Content 75 mm top size 55 Hardgrove Grindability Index As indicated earlier, the coal must be ground to a fineness of 70% minus 75 µm . The effects on pulverising mill capacity of varying coal top size, free moisture content, and Hardgrove Grindability are clearly illustrated in Figure 2, by considering the change in mill capacity to maintain the same pulverised coal fineness of 70% minus 75 µm. The effect of low volatile matter content, marginally below 20% on a dry ash-free basis can also be indicated, within the range that this can be compensated by improving the pulverised coal fineness upwards to 80% minus 75 µm . Lower volatile coals also lead to the need for larger furnaces and other special features . The effect of higher ash content is generally to require an increase in milling capacity based on the increase in material to be handled as well as increases resulting from the material being harder and more difficult to pulverise. Higher ash contents also require larger boiler gas pass dimensions to avoid excessive tube wear, and larger capacity equipment for flue gas particulate removal. BENEFICIATION OF STEAMING COALS

OBJECTIVE S As previously outlined by the author (St. Baker 1979), the question of beneficiation of steaming coals demands a quite different approach to the beneficiation of coking coals. While steaming coal beneficiation may be intended to reduce ash content, or some other unwanted property, the heat energy is the commodity which is being marketed, and the beneficiation process must be directed to achieving a high yield of heat energy. After paying the cost to recover coal heat energy from the ground, any steaming coal beneficiation process must be designed for an optimum with the greatest possible retention of this energy in the product. Whereas coking coal preparation plants are concerned with mass yield , steaming coal preparation plants must be concerned with specific energy yield. If the steaming coal preparation processes 129


(i) FOR VARYING COAL FEED SIZING \ •

ao+-----i---+-+--------±-

--c----..:--t--+------j---+ --1-- .... d .ii

....

J I

% FrH lilloiature Content 55 H rdtr•v• lrind. lndea

•

•i C

70 +---lf---+-+----,-- +-+--+--""T-....,., ~~·

i.

• I0-+--1----+---+--- -l-4--~---+----+---- -"'"-~- 'x'~

c

.!!

"' ..: a:

70 ao 60 P. F. Mill Capacity - 0Ao

(ii) FOR E ,

."i ~

VARYING FREE

90

10

10

100

MOISTURE CONSTANT

I

ao-t---1i----t::-+-----t ::--::+-.:::::-t--':::--+-- -l----+-. ::;="=d . ....::°":.:..:....:2=,::,:...:cm=m Cool l"Hd Top Siu 55 Merd9rove lirind. lndea

C

l

7<"H..--+--......- - . -.....-...:.._....-...,....;~,_...;:,.....,....,.,.___---1--+--+-........ j

I

70

90

110

100

120

P. F . Mill Capacity-%

(iii)

FOR VARYING HARDGROVE GRINDABILITY INDEX I

._ e

I

I

I

Je

-I

~~~-......~............;:,,.,,.....;:.e,-::~-I---+-~

10+-1-~............

i.

• 10-r-,r---+--+--- i.........-+--+----+--+--- ~-..+--I-~-_.,,.__ ~

~

,; LL

a:

P.F. Mill Copocity - %

Fig. 2. Typical pulverising mill characteristics

130

.........

··••d on 25 ffllll Cool FNd ...,. .... ,. ao-.---t----+--+--,i-- -c+---..::+-.._--+--+ ----+--+-------1-Fret Moisture Content


in some actual cases are examined, it will be found that ash content may be being reduced from 30% to 15% at about 60% mass recovery in the coal preparatio n plant; but, while the heat value of the product is increased by some 25%, the specific energy recovery in the process may be only 75% with one quarter of the energy mined being discarded in the rejects (St. Baker, 1979). In this example, 33% additional coal.must be mined for beneficiation to 15% ash content, compared to run-of-mine coal at 30% ash content, whereas the steaming coal product is only 25% higher in specific energy. For a coal valued at $10/ tonne run-of-mine, at the mine, the price to the miner would have to increase by 33% plus the cost of coal preparatio n, say $2.00 per tonne, to a total of $17.30 per tonne at the mine. As outlined previously by the author (1979), a power authority could experience a break-even with 30% ash coal for $10/ tonne, at less than $15 .50/tonne of 15% ash coal. On the other hand , if a transport cost of $10/tonne was involved, making the coal a total of $20/ tonne of 30% ash coal, the breakeven cost to the power authority could be of the order of $28/ tonne for 15% ash coal, compared to $27.30/ tonne break-even for the miner. As would be expected, beneficiation is more readily justified where long transport distances are involved, although actual costs and recoveries have to be substituted for the illustration used above. The objective in steaming coal beneficiation is therefore to optimise the cost of delivering the product taking into account the value of the product to the customer.

By examining the effect of different sizes for separation of fine and coarse fractions , and different specific gravities for washing the coarse fraction , most dull coal seams with significant stone band inclusions should indicate an optimum cost of energy with a degree of beneficiation . On the other hand , non-bande d coals of basically an inherent ash content will probably show an optimum cost of energy as raw coal. Ideally, it should be possible to compare an equivalent delivered price curve for the miner with such a curve prepared for the power authority. The optimum price and coal preparatio n process should be indicated by such a compariso n . For an existing power station, the power authority will have a very limited range of options, but the miner should still be able to compare these with his equivalent price curve to establish whether a profitable coal supply is possible and also whether an efficient coal supply is possible. If there were a range of product qualities marketable , the miner might be able to market his optimum product at greater profit, although competitio n in the supply of different quality coals would probably override this. Certainly, for a proposed mine-site power station, an optimum product of energy should be able to be arrived at, with mutual advantage to the miner and the power authority.

OPTIMUM PRODUC T FROM DULL COAL SEAMS

In the assessment of a coal for a convention al power station, all these factors are considered in detail , together with many other cost factors pertaining to the particular site. The distinguishing features of Walloon coals from a new power station point of view are: (I) high volatile matter content, which does not result in any particular cost disadvanta ge or advantage ; and (2) low Hardgrove Grindabili ty Index, which results in cost from the need for additional pulverising capacity.

Because of the limited reserves of coal in the world , the supply of raw run-of-mine steaming coal must always be examined before beneficiation is decided upon. Coal being generally softer than the stone band inclusions, there is generally a concentrat ion of the coal particles in the fine size fractions in any mining and crushing opet"ation. A steaming coal preparatio n process may therefore be directed to supplying a fines fraction raw and only beneficiating the coarse fraction as necessary.

GENERAL ASSESSM ENT OF WALLOO N COALS FOR ELECTRIC POWER GENERATION SIGNIFIC ANT COAL PROPERT IES

131


DISCUSSION Only modest cost penalties result , however, from the harder Walloon coals. The order of cost penalty is less than the order of cost advantages or disadvantages which may result simply from the topographic features of a particular power station ite. Further, whereas the Walloon coals are recognised as being the hardest Queensland coals, the cost penalty for use in power stations is only one third of the order of cost penalty that may accrue to a coal of difficult electrostatic precipitator characteristics. CO CLUSIO S Walloon satisfactory

coals, for

overall, are conventional

quite steam

generation using conventional power station plant; like all steaming coals, special consideration must be given to power station plant designs to handle the particular Walloon coal characteristic. Although ash content is relatively high, Walloon coals occur in relatively large deposits of favourable overburden to coal ratio, and are ideally suited to low cost, minesite power generation. Because of the large extent of the coal basin, there is a good prospect that Walloon coals will contribute to the State's development in the future through electric power generation either in conventional power stations, or associated with liquefaction/power generation developments.

REFERE CES DAwso , K. , 1978: The energy resources of Queensland. Inst. Engineers Aust. Qd Di11. Tech. Pap., (April , 1978). DEPARTMENT OF NATIONAL D EVELOPMENT, A USTRALIA , 1978: Demand for primary fuels, Australia 1976-77 to 1986-87 (unpubl. ). FREEDMA . S. I.. et al .. 1976: The energy alternatives study (ECAS) of coal fired utilities power genera tion systems. Proc. Third International Conference on Coal Research (unpubl. ). PERRY. H. , et al., 1968: Cycles for generation of electricity from coal. American Pou·er Conference, Vol. 28. ST. BAK ER, T . C. , 1977: A power tation consumer's view of coal. Pap. presented to Southern Qd Branch Australas. Inst. Min. Metal/. (unpubl.).

132

ST. BAK ER, T . C. , 1978: Coal for electric power generation . Aust. Electrical World, Jan . 1978. ST. BAKER, T . C. , 1979: Technology of coal utllisation for electric power generation. Aust. M ineral Found a tion Work shop Course 118/79, June, 1979 (unpubl. ). STATE ELECTRICITY COMMISSIO OF Q EE SLAND, 1979: Power station coal enquiry- June, 1979 (unpubl.).

T. C. ST. BAKER, State Electricity Commission of Queensland, Warry Street, Fortitude Valley, Queensland, 4006.


OIL THE FLASH PYROL YSIS METHO D FOR CO VERT! G COAL TO By I. W. Smith ABSTR ACT

In response to national needs the CSIRO is underta king a number of projects relating to the convers ion of coal to oil. A major project, being carried out by the Division of Process Technol ogy, is a study of the technical and econom ic suitabili ty of the flash pyrolysis method for produci ng oil from coal. During flash pyrolysis, pulverised coal < ( 0.1 mm in size) is heated to about 600 cc and decomp osed to char, gas and tar, in reaction times of I second or less. Pyrolysis takes place at atmosph eric pres ure, and without the use of catalyst. The tar, which is produce d in quantiti es substant ially greater than in convent ional pyrolysis proce es, is pumped to a pre urised hydroge nator where it is converte d to syntheti c crude oil, or to lighter grade . In the present paper results obtained with Millmer ran coal are used to illustrat e the pyrolysis behavio ur of coals in I g/h and 20 kg/h experim ental pyrolysers. Data are then given to show the influence of coal properti es on flash pyrolysis results. Test data are used to show the performance, in practice , of a notional flash pyrolysis plant. Results are given for operatio n of the unit with seconda ry power generati on or gasification plants to utilise the char and gas surpluse s from the flash pyrolysis operatio n. I TRODU CTIO Australi a has a vital and growing requirement for liquid fuels , especially fuels for tran portatio n (Durie and Smith 1975). There is a need to conserv e our limited supply of natural oil or to find alternati ves, or both . The nation's reserves of coal are abundan t (Gartlan d and Howard , 1974) con equently , there are a number of projects under way in Australi a with the aim of develop ing effective means of using coal to produce liquid fuels . The CSIRO is underta king a number of studies on coal convers ion. One of the major projects is being carried out by the Division of Process Technol ogy. Its aim is to determi ne the technical and econom ic feasibility of the flash pyrolysi method for produci ng oil from

coal. Flash pyroly i involves heating pulverised coal (- 0. 1 mm in size) rapidly to approxi mately 600 cc. The coal decomp oses to char, gas and tar in a reaction time of I second or less, reaction taking place a t atmosph eric pressure and without the use of catalyst s. The tar is pumped to a pressuri sed hydroge nator, where it is converte d to synthetic crude, or lighter oil. The paper looks at four aspects of the problem . Firstly, the nature of the flash pyrolysis project being carried out by CSIRO is described briefly, then the results of I g/h and 20 kg/h experim ental pyrolysers, operating on Millmer ran coal, are given . Results are then shown for the tar yields from a number of bitumin ous coals, includin g the Blackwa ter, Blair Athol , Galilee and Wandoa n coals from Queensl and . Finally te t data are used to show the perform ance that might be anticipa ted for a concept ual fla h pyrolysi s plant. The plant is conside red to operate in conjunc tion with seconda ry power generati on or with gasification plants, so as to utilise char and gas surpluse s from the pyrolyser. EXPER IMENT AL

Several pyrolysis reactors were operated in the course of the CSI RO project. Principa l of these were a I g/h bench- cale unit, and a 20 kg/h technical- cale rig. The I g/h reactor was used to esta blish the pyrolysis behavio ur of a range of Australi an a nd overseas bituminou s and brown coals (Tyler, 1979, 1980). The 20 kg/h rig was used to examine the effect of scale-up on the results of the I g/h reactor, and to produce amples of tar and char for further te ting and evaluati on (Edwards and Smith, 1980). Convers ion of the tars to light oil was studied by the Division of Applied Organic Chemis try, using batch and continu ous hydroge nators (Smith and Wailes, 1975). The large and small pyrolysis reactors are describe d in detail elsewhere (Tyler, 1979; Edward s and Smith, 1980). In brief, both systems employ coal feeders providin g metered streams of coal that are injected into beds of sand vigorous ly fluidised with hot, oxygen133


Gas vent --vent .

PYROLYSIS REACTOR

Cyclone

Electrical heaters

COAL FEEDER

Water - cooled cool injector

Fluidized ,,. bed

Cool transport line Fluidizing nitrogen

Fluidizing ---~ GAS PREHEATER gas CHAR RECEIVERS

20 kg/h EXPERIMENTAL FLASH PYROLYSIS REACTOR F ig. 1. 20 kg/h expe rimenta l fl ash pyrolysis reac tor.

COOLERS

ELECTROSTATIC PRECIPITATOR ( Tor collector)


free, gas. Pyrolysis takes place within the fluidised bed, and the products are swept from the reactor in the rising gas stream. Metered samples of products are collected to allow the quantity and composition of the tar, gas and char produced to be determined. The layout of the 20 kg/h reactor is shown in Fig. I. In related experiments, samples of char were tested to determine the rate at which they burn. Further samples of char were studied to find out if useful quantities of volatiles can be produced by secondary pyrolysis at temperatures higher than that found optimum for flash pyrolysis (rv6OO °C). RESULTS

The I g/h reactor was used to determine the quantity and composition of the pyrolysis products of a number of coals in relation to a number of variables, namely pyrolysis temperature, coal particle size, fluidising gas composition, and material forming the fluidised bed. All the coals tested so far respond to pyrolysis temperature in a qualitatively simila r way. Figure 2 shows the results obtained for Millmerran coal (Tyler, 1980). ote that the tar yield reaches a maximum at about 600 C. This temperature is close to that at which all the coals tested give peak yields of

tar (Tyler, 1980). The total volatile yield and the yield ofC I to C 3 hydrocarbon gases do not pass through a maximum , but increase continuously with increasing temperature. Results from the pyrolysis of Millmerran coal in the 20 kg/h reactor are shown as solid points in Fig. 3 (Edwards and Smith, 1980). The lines in the figure represent the data obtained from the same coal using the I g/h rig (Tyler, 1980). They include the tar-yield line from Fig. 2. Figure 3 serves not only to show how Millmerran coal behaves in the larger rig, but also to show the close agreement between the tar and hydrocarbon gas yields from the large and small rigs. Close agreement has been found also for a second bituminous coal, and a brown coal (Edwards, Smith and Tyler, 1980). Good agreement also exists for the

=40 0 0

u

0 "C

3:

'3:

~20 "C

a.,

>-

~

70 ~ - ~ - - ~ - ~ - - ~ - - ~ ~

~ -+% 0

0 0

u

0

"C

50

0 B

0

60

§

c0 u

4

lotal volatile matter

40

3:

'3: ~

30

V,

"C

"'

20

C 0

>-

12L

10

~ ---'-----..____, 0 '------'-----'-----' 900 800 700 600 400 500 Jemperature

( °C)

Fig. 2. Flash pyrolysis yields from Millmerran coal, I g/h reactor (from Tyler, 1980). x and + indica1e pyrolysis in hydrogen and helium respectively.

~

o 400

YX~3J3H5

~xM/xo C3Hs

~~&J<~b-'<11--- c.,o BOO 700 600 500 Reactor

temperature

900

1000

0

( c)

Fig. 3. Flash pyrol ysis yie lds from Millmerran coal (from Edwards, Smith and Tyler, 1980). Lines of curves indicate data from I g/ h reactor. Symbols indicate data from 20 kg/h reactor.

135


total volatile matter yields, and the compositions of the tar and char produced in the two rigs. The pyrolysis behaviour of a number of bituminous and sub-bituminous coals is summarised in Fig. 4, which is the diagram given by Tyler (I 980) with additional data points. It shows the tar yield at 600 cc (i.e. the temperature near which maximum tar yields occur) as a function of the atomic H/C ratio of the parent coal. It will be seen that the tar yield increases directly with an increase in the coal H/C ratio. Results for five Queensland coals are included , together with data for three coals from New South Wales, three from the United States, and one each from Japan and South Africa . It should be noted that the same relation between tar yield and H/C ratio does not generally apply to brown coals (Tyler and Schafer, 1980).

generation of hydrogen for tar hydrogenation by char gasification ; supplying process utilities (steam, oxygen, electrical power) using the combustion of some of the residual char. To provide a proper basis for technicoeconomic evaluation it is necessary to make mass and heat balance calculations that take into account the steps outlined above. This has been done (Edwards, Smith and Tyler, 1977) for the process configuration illustrated in Fig. 5. In this configuration all energy and material requirements are supplied by the incoming coal. C1-C 3 nydrocorbons

~

fuel gos (RV}

separation ( ,1 requoredl

Gos

Cool

Cool preporotM>n Pyrolyse,

Hydrogenotor product gos

Tor

-I

Product

C

I

0

u

~ 40 ~

~ 30 = =

•

1 g/ h pyro lyser o 20 kg/ h pyrolyser

.

•i.>'•

~ 20

/

Surplus char

w

•

Fig. 5. Syncrude product ion unit.

1/.

a,

>-

Chor

B\ • /, B

"O

10

~

-

o 0·5

0·6 Cool

o1

O·B

0·9

atom ic

H/C

rat io

1

o

Fig. 4. Dependence of ta r yield at 600 C on coal a tom ic H, C ratio.

CONCEPTUAL PROCESSES

In order to evaluate the likely practical performance of pyrolysis units it is necessary to estimate the behaviour of conceptual processes, usin g, as far as possible, experimental data on plant performance. If realised, the operation of self-sufficient flash pyrolysis plants on a commercial scale will involve a number of processing steps: drying, crushing and pulverising the coal; the pyrolysis and tar hydrogenation operations themselves; combustion of some of the surplus char to generate heat for pyrolysis; 136

Chor

OM

~

<.D

Chor

Syncrude

I Hydrogen

sepora~

B - Bl ac kwater BA - Bla ir Athol G - Golillee M- Millmerron W- Wondoon

I I

Tor

Table I gives a summary of the performance of a self-sufficient flash pyrolysis unit producing synthetic crude oil (Syncrude). The data are for Millmerran (Queensland) and Great Northern (New South Wales) bituminous coals and for Loy Yang brown coal from Victoria. The oil yield is highest for Millmerran coal- the coal that has the highest H/C ratio so far tested (see Fig. 4 and Tyler (1980)). However the brown coal- the lowest-yielding material of the three shown in Table I- gives the least surplus char after all process needs are satisfied. This is mainly because a substantial part of the char is burned to provide the thermal energy required to dry the raw coal which contains about 70% water as mined. For all three coals there is a surplus of char and gaseous volatiles and this amounts to 43.3%, 33.7% and 17.8% of the energy content of the feed material for Great Northern, Millmerran and Loy Yang coals respectively. Effective use has to be made of the surplus char and gas. One way is to operate the pyrolysis unit in series with a power station


Table I-Performance of Unit Producing Syncrude Millmerra11

Coal

Syncrude produced (bbl/ tonne, d.a.f.) Surplus char• C,-C 3 hydroca rbons• Gaseo us volatiles• Process thermal efficiency (% )

2.0 13.6

·,o.3 9.8 72

Great Northern

Loy Ya11g

1.59 21.5 7.7 14.1 75

1.39 9.4 6.3 2.1 51

*percentage of coal energy input.

Table 2-Performance of Pyrolysis nit Coupled to 1000 MW Power Station (75% load factor)

Coal

Syncrude production (bbl/day) % Aust. liquid fuel needs* Coal co nsumptio n (tonnes/day)t Process thermal efficiency (%)

Millmerra11

Great Northern

30 600 5. 1 25 670 51

19 470 3.3 14 440 47

Loy Yang

51 000 8.5 102 000 40

*% of shortfall between demand and natural oil supply, 1984-85 (Lyall, 1976). tas mined coal.

Table 3-Yields of Coupled Pyrolysis-Synthesis Unit, to Produce 10% of 1984-85 Liquid Fuel Shortfall

Coal

Syncrude (bbl/tonne , d.a .f.) Motor Fuel (bbl/tonne, d. a.f.) Total liquid fuels (bbl/ tonne, d .a.f.) Process therma l efficiency (% ) Coal consumption ( I0 6 tonnes/year, as mined)

Millm erra11

Grea t Northern

Loy Yang

2.0 0.58 2.58 48 13.6

1.59 0.75 2.34 44 10.6

1.39 0.24 1.63 39 36

Table 4-Performance of Oil-From-Coal Processes

Process

H- Coa/

Flash PyrolysisSy11thesis

Total liquid yield (bbl/ tonne, d.a.f.) Thermal efficiency ( I) Thermal efficiency (2)

3.00 55 60

2.58 48 48

SASOL II

1.65 32 35

(I) per cent of coal energy input as liquid fuels. (2) per cent of coal energy input in total fuel and energy produced .

fuelled by the surplus materials. Table 2 summarises the performance of pyrolysis units, for each of the coals considered above, rated so as to supply fuel sufficient for a 1000 MW power station operating at 75% load factor. The overall thermal efficiency, that is, the proportion of coal energy appearing as syncrude and electricity, is highest for Millmerran coal and lowest for Loy Yang. However at the fixed power plant rating the Loy Yang coal provides the largest syncrude

output. This is because, as already noted , much of the surplus char is used to dry the Loy Yang coal, consequently the pyrolyser must operate at a high throughput to supply the fuel needs of the power plant. An alternative method of using the surplus material is to gasify the char and reform the gas, the resulting mixture of carbon monoxide and hydrogen being passed to FischerTropsch synthesis reactors to produce more liquid fuel (Edwards, Smith and Tyler, 1977). 137


The output of coupled pyrolysis a nd synthesis units are shown in T able 3. This also shows the quantities of coal to be mined in order to atisfy I 0% of the short fall predicted for 198485 (Lyall , 1976) between total national demand for liquid fuels and indigenous production of oil. Millmerran coal gives the highe t yield of liquid fuel and Loy Yang the lowest. The amou nt of coa l to be mined is similar for both Millmerran and Great orthern coals, which is about one-third of the quantity of high-moisture Loy Yang coal required. It is useful to compare the performance of coupled flash pyrolysis and synthesis units with other means of converting coal to oil. This has been done by Edwards (1978) and some of his data are reproduced in Table 4. Three processes are compared: the H-Coal hydrogenation process, which is now at pilot-

plant state: the SASOL II plant, now under construction, which uses gasifica tion and Fi cher-Trop eh synthesis; a nd the notional CSIRO process (usi ng Millmerran coal) where flash pyrolysis and Fischer-Tropsch synthesis are coupled, as outlined above. The H-Coal process gives the highest liquid yield (3.00 bbl/ ton) . Whilst it must be borne in mind that different coals were used in each case, it is encouraging to find that the yield of oil from the flash pyrolysis/synthesis concept is close to that found for the hydrogenation approach and substantially higher than the anticipated result of the SASOL II plant. ACK OWLEDGMENTS

J . H . Edwards, R. J. T yler and H. N. S. Schafer contributed to the work described above, and kindly made available unpublished data.

REFERE CES D RI E, R. A. and SMITH , I. W., 1975: Production of gaseous and liquid fuel s from coal, in Cook, A. C. (Ed). Australian Black Coal- its occurrence, preparation and use, 161-172. Australasian Institute of Mining a nd Metallurgy, lll awarra Branch. EDWARDS, J. H ., 1978: Oil-from-coal processes: A critical eva luation for Australian conditions. Proc. Con}. "CH EMECA 78', 100-1 07 . EDWARDS, J. H. and SMITH, I. W ., 1980: Flash pyrolysis of coals: Behaviour of three coals in a 20 kg/h fluidised-bed pyrolyser. Fuel, in press. EDWARDS, J. H ., SMITH, I. w. a nd TYLER, R . J. , 1977: Coal to oil by fl ash pyrolysis. Proc. Conf "CHEMECA 77', 79-82. EDWARDS, J. H., SMITH, I. W. and T YLER, R. J., 1980: Flash pyrolysis of coals: Comparison of results from I g/h and 20 kg/h reactors. Fuel, in press. G ARTLA I D , C. F . and HOWARD, J. S., 1974: The Development of Australia 's energy sources. Proc. Inst. Fuel Conj. on changing technology of fuel , Adelaide, 19.1-19. 13

138

LYALL, K. D. , 1976: Prospects for synthetic fuel production in Australia . 47th A ZAAS Congress, Hobart. SMITH , I. W. and WAILES, P. C. , 1975: Oil from coal by fla sh pyrolysis, in Energy a nd Liquid Fuels, Adelaide. Paper 3. (Joint organisers: In st. Fuel, RAC I, Inst. Chem. Engrs., South Australian Chapters). TYLER, R. J., 1979: Flash pyrolysis of coals: Devola tilisation of a Victorian brown coa l in a small fluidised-bed reactor. Fuel, 58, 680-686. TYLER, R . J., 1980: Flash pyrolysis of coals: Devolatilisation of bituminous coals in a small fluidised-bed reactor. Fuel, 59, 2 I 8-226. TYLER, R. J. and SCHAFER, H . N . S., 1980: Flash pyrolysis of coals: The influence of cations on the devolatilisation behaviour of brown coals. Fuel, 59, 487-494.

I. W. SMITH , CSIRO Division of Process Technology, P.O . Box 136, orth Ryde, .S.W., 2113.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Coal Geology Volume 1 Part 3 December 1980 - CGG by GSAustralia - Issuu