SEPTEMBER MARKET REPORT
STATISTICS & ANALYSIS
MONTH VS. MONTH SALES AS OF SEPTEMBER 30, 2025
YEAR-TO-DATE SALES AS OF SEPTEMBER 30, 2025
September was a very active month for the Nantucket real estate market. The total dollar volume for September was $278 million, representing a 23.7% increase from September 2024, making this month the 2nd largest September in terms of dollar volume in Nantucket’s history. Month to month, transactions were up, increasing from 45 last September to 60 this month, a 33.3% increase. After another strong month, 2025 remains on pace for nearly $1.7B in total dollar volume. Year to date for 2025, total dollar volume sits at $1.07B, up 21.7% from the $878.9M recorded by this time last year. Transactions are also green for 2025, up 29% from the prior year. Historically, September and October are the most active months for real estate transactions on the island. It will be very interesting to see how the current strength in our market plays out as we approach year-end.
SEPTEMBER MARKET REPORT
ALL SALES AS OF SEPTEMBER 30
HOUSE SALES AS OF SEPTEMBER 30
LAND SALES AS OF SEPTEMBER 30
TRENDS & TRANSACTIONS
This year, we have been seeing a noticeable shift toward lower-end and mid-range sales, resulting in year-over-year declines in both average and median sales prices. However, in both August and September, we saw a resurgence in the $10M+ segment, which kept these averages in line with those of 2024. This month, we saw four separate transactions close for over $10M, two of which closed for $15M+:
• 20B Bishops Rise - $14,350,000
• 126 Main Street - $14,500,000
• 83 Squam Road - $15,000,000
• 8 Sachem Road - $31,000,000
YTD Average sales price currently sits at $4.37M, compared to $4.45M prior, while YTD Median sales price is $3.18M vs $3.4M in 2024. Overall, transaction volume remains healthy while dollar volume continues to perform strongly.
*Market data and analysis provided by GPP agent Ethan Ulmer*
FEATURED LISTING | 15 HALLOWELL LANE | $22,000,000
THE CURRENT MARKET AT A GLANCE
$7M
AVERAGE ASKING PRICE OF AVAILABLE HOMES
134
AVERAGE DAYS ON MARKET OF AVAILABLE PROPERTIES
140
AVERAGE DAYS ON MARKET OF PENDING PROPERTIES
178 AVAILABLE PROPERTIES
65 NUMBER OF PENDING SALES
