Skip to main content

Standing in the Way

Page 1

Standing in the Way Arthur Robert Goshin


2 • Identity


OTHER POETRY BY ARTHUR GOSHIN One Hundred and Twenty Four Moons Longing Before Dawn Love’s Cloth Both The Harvest And The Seed Time Changes Nothing The Strange Curiosity of Memory Always Searching for Me Keeper Of Memories A Gate Opens Regardless of Time I Am Who They Were

Identity • 1


2 • Identity


IN HONOR AND MEMORY OF THESE MENTORS, COLLEAGUES, AND TEACHERS William Mosher, MD Edward Marine, MD Bertha Laury Richard Carter, MD Frederick Yanni Warren Paley Lowell Bellin, MD Daniel Wolfson Solomon Axelrod, MD Avedis Donabedian, MD Marcia Metcalfe Robert Ludwig Samuel Rabkin

Identity • 3


4 • Identity


About the Poems In the late winter of 2020, as the pandemic began here in the United States, and the trajectory of its impact became clear to me, I decided on a personal project for 2020 and 2021. Namely, to review all of the poems that I had written, select the ones that I would like to share once again, and then to group them by ‘topic’. I further decided that they would best be presented in three different books. This one, ‘Standing In The Way’, includes the ‘topics’ of identity, aging, writing, social commentary, and time. The title for the book comes from a poem in the social commentary section that speaks about the heroism of those individuals who stand in the way of tyranny to protect our democracy and its values. I expect the second of these projected three books to available about six months following ‘Standing In The Way’.

Identity • 5


6 • Identity


About the Photographs All of the photographs in this book are direct reflections off of the surface of water. To me the surfaces of water are always in motion, constantly transforming, often creating a brilliance of ever-changing form and color with help from shifting sunlight, the wind, fish, birds, and insects. I find that there is a sense of unpredictable movement, a spontaneity, inventiveness, of never being the same, of it seeming alive. Like so much of life’s great beauty, it is there, coyly hiding in plain sight waiting to share.

Identity • 7


8 • Identity


‘Everyone should carefully observe what way their heart pulls, and then choose that way with all the strength of one’s being.’ Hasidic Rabbi Yaakov Yitzchak HaLevi Horowitz (‘The Seer of Lublin’). 1745 - 1815 ‘Two roads diverged in a wood, and I —— I took the one less traveled by, And that has made all the difference.’ Robert Frost, 1874 - 1963 ‘Man becomes great in the degree in which he works for the welfare of his fellow men’ Mohandas Gandhi, 1869 - 1948

Identity • 9


10 • Identity


Identity Aging

1 71

Writing

123

Social Commentary

147

Time

197

Identity • 11


12 • Identity


On Identity ‘We are not here just for ourselves, but also for what was, and for what will be.’

Identity • 1


2 • Identity


IT IS DESIRE I am propelled forward by desire. The desire for love, meaning, intimacy, knowledge, joy, creation, wisdom, inner calm, truth, happiness, a life that makes the one for others better, that extends my line safely forward. When I seem to obtain that which I seek the desire is only momentarily fulfilled. It is in a never ending supply. An endless cycle that anticipates a completion that never occurs. It is desire.

Identity • 3


ALWAYS DIFFERENT I will never again be that person. Not even the one from yesterday. No, not the one who played carefree in the park, was hugged and held so tightly by my grandparents, loved unconditionally by my parents, not the one whose world was changed by that first kiss, nor the one who first recognized that time here didn’t go on forever, or the one who constantly wondered about life’s purpose, and not the one who held my newborn sons in my arms, or the one who said Kaddish for my parents and grandparents. No, I’ll always be someone a bit different, a bit new, neither better nor worse necessarily. But certainly someone I’ll always try to treasure.

4 • Identity


Identity • 5


6 • Identity


YES, DREAM Go ahead, fall in love. In love with who and what you are and still aspire to be. Live life as a great romantic adventure. Constantly move out from your ‘comfort zone’, your routines. Think obliquely. Keep fun and comic relief central. Date and court ideas, lead them to consummation. Imagine the unimaginable. Smile and laugh a lot. Ask questions, notice the detail around you. Be 9 when you’re 43, 10 when you’re 50, you get the idea. Make a list each day of at least five inspiring wonders you experience. Dream. Yes, dream.

Identity • 7


EACH DAY’S FIRST GIFT I wait. Just before the morning, in the dark. Watching while the world is still unformed instead of being warm, dreaming, nested in the night’s womb. It is before the sun, before there is light. Before the birds’ sweet songs, before life moves. I sit, I watch, I wait. Time seems suspended, hovering in mid-air, trying to decide what to do. I wait. Finally, the light, pale blue. Each day’s first gift. I sense hope, excitement, the grandeur, the majesty to come. That there is a next, that tomorrow is now today, that once again there is a new start. So, each day I wait.

8 • Identity


Identity • 9


10 • • Identity Identity


SORROWS Sorrows. To be a collector and then disposer of them. All sorrows. All tears. Especially those of children. To share each sorrow with me first, in their own words. Then to be able to wipe each away. All away. Forever. To destroy all memory of each as though the sorrow never occurred. Yes, please, may I be granted that task.

Identity • 11


PROTECT THE THREAD I have to always protect it. To make sure it never tears. The thread that constantly winds its way through my life. Connecting everything. Forever linking what was, with what is, with what will be. No discontinuity. Everything linked together. The thread, often unseen, is always there, and must be forever protected.

12 • Identity


Identity • 13


14 • Identity


THE WIND AT YOUR BACK Hope can whither from disuse, fade away, even disappear. It’s easy to forget to live your own life, the one you want, expect, dream of, hope for, rather than the one others want for you. Always remember just what it is you truly long for. Then find the wind, the one that is always there for you, and always keep it at your back.

Identity • 15


OBLIGATIONS We are what is in between. The link. Between then, now, and to be. Our life, our time, is borrowed, on loan, a gift from what’s past. We are not here just for ourselves, but for what was, and for what will be. Obligations to ours just before, and all before.

16 • Identity


Obligations for ours who are next, and for all beyond. Not a burden, a responsibility. An exchange for the privilege of life, the time, for the opportunity. It is a promise. It is ‘the’ promise that we must fulfill to our long line of ‘what was’ and the future of our ‘what might be.’

Identity • 17


THE UNSEEN At age six, I recall being mesmerized by a late afternoon’s golden light filtering in through the wooden blinds in our Brooklyn apartment. I watched in amazement as what my mother said were dust particles danced about to their own tune. But where did they go when darkness came? And where, exactly, did they come from? I tried using a flashlight to see if I could find them on cloudy days, but that didn’t work. I could never locate these particles outside, even in the sunlight. I finally came to realize that there are unseen things of mystery occurring all around me in this world. Things that I might never fully understand. I still look for such mysteries, and when found I consider each one a wonderful new treasure.

18 • Identity


Identity • 19


20 • Identity


A GRAND ADVENTURE The unforeseen, serendipity. They play such a central, critical, unacknowledged, role in our lives. And, because of that, life is truly an unscripted grand adventure. We cannot know in which day, in what moment of that day, the direction of our life may be forever altered. When it will shift without a return to what was. When we become someone a bit different, in unanticipated circumstances, facing new and unexpected challenges. When we suddenly have a new life script to write. Yes, a grand adventure.

Identity • 21


A LIFE WORTHY OF MY DREAMS With each morning’s first light I look to the far horizon, and amid the silence of this every day precious moment I begin to hear the gentle hum of the universe, the collective breathing of all humanity, now feeling reconnected to all that ever was and all that will ever be. Another day is alive, the daily cycle of renewal begins. If I look, pay careful attention, and am prepared to act, it might be a day of promise, one that might offer new meaning, an opportunity to be of use, to still make myself and others better, to find the fulfillment that I constantly seek, to have a life worthy of my dreams.

22 • Identity


Identity • 23


IMPERMANENCE Life offers the appearance of permanence, predictability. We create the illusion by having ordered lives, filled with routine, surrounded by objects that we can touch, hold, see. Like having a schedule for tomorrow, plans for next week. But the reality of life is much more fragile and uncertain. We have no guarantee of a continuing existence, as all things disappear in time. Take a moment right now. Go, gaze upward to the sky. Especially follow the clouds, their constantly changing form, the way their beauty is continuously being altered by the light of the day and of the night.

24 • Identity


Life is often a bit like that. It is filled with so much beauty, but what is to occur next is much more unpredictable than we care to admit. So, always be prepared to allow life to astonish, to surprise, relish spontaneity, cherish serendipity. Treasure the so few really special moments, especially those of transcendental love. And realize, that the greatest remembered moments in a life will be just as ephemeral as the clouds in a spectacular sunset.

Identity • 25


‘A HALF OPENED DOOR’ (‘Every person is a half open door leading to a room for everyone’ - Tomas Transformer; ‘The Half Finished Heaven’)

I just wasn’t ready when I was younger. If I had tried to write then I would have quickly yielded to my limits, to the requirements of ego, and abandoned the intent, the unarticulated need for self-revelation, for externalizing some of the internal. Time, experience, reflection, has given me more to say. Now my ‘door’ is open. Well, at least a bit more than halfway.

26 • Identity


Identity • 27


28 • Identity


DANDELIONS I tried not to think about it. I mean, doesn’t false hope bloom like dandelions? I well know that hanging onto the ifs, woulds and could haves, may lead to repetitive disappointment. Sure, obsessive optimism can brighten dark moments, but with objectivity it fades fast. So, keep but restrain hope. You just never know when life will surprise.

Identity • 29


CONSCIENCE’S DEMAND Strange, how I am now remembering particular events, occurrences, that I believe shaped my inner values, my character, decisions that my conscience would make, the pathways I would later choose ——— the ones that have been so determinative to who I became. Just what was it that I selectively paid special attention to, to what my ear was tuned, to what I chose to see? The emerging personal stories of the Holocaust, the confrontation between Sen. Joe McCarthy and Joe Welch at the Army - McCarthy hearings, to what Adlai Stevenson,

30 • Identity


John Kennedy and Martin Luther King were saying, actions of the Soviets and other dictatorships, the Korean and Vietnam Wars, the civil rights sit-ins and marches, anti-war protests, personally observing the sadness of lives of poverty. How these and my family dialogues were the substrate for the growth of my own conscience because they resonated with my own Jewish identity and my emotional connection to our history of struggle against exclusion, repression, genocide.

Identity • 31


32 • Identity


THE FABRIC AND THE THREAD Things that we most cherish, both animate and not, have an existence beyond the objective, factual, descriptive. They are also alive in our imagination, often enjoying a rich, textured, subjective presence. One that may be constantly crossing the line between non-fiction, fiction, documentary, and romantic adventure. The conscious or subconscious script is by and for ourselves, from our internal well-spring of hope and possibility. It is our fertile imagination that allows us to understand and appreciate beyond the surface, to create a deeper meaning that things have within our lives. We see both the fabric and the thread —— the objective particular, as well as the context for us. It is our imagination, always at work, even as we sleep, that provides enjoyment and wonder of our most special things.

Identity • 33


DETERMINED He stood there, looking out, to nowhere in particular. Perhaps waiting for friends, there in Seth Low Playground, 1953, Brooklyn, about seven years old. Seemingly deep in thought, concentrating, wondering. Black wavy hair, a bit stocky, his dark deep set eyes mark him, in this neighborhood, most likely as Jewish. If you watch him for awhile you can see that he knows his way around, having an unmistakable determination, confidence even at this very young age in what he needs to, intends to do. He is, surprisingly, keenly aware of what his generations have learned before through exclusion, discrimination, torture, genocide —— that freedom, rights, opportunity, won’t be given to him, to them, it sometimes has to be taken, defended, prized. And, he is determined to do just that.

34 • Identity


Identity • 35


36 • Identity


THAT DAY Do you ever hope for a single day of such perfection that all you ever wanted would occur in that day? A day to remember forever. A day that fulfills, even exceeds, all of your hopes, dreams, desires. So that you would know that all you ever wanted were possible to have, and what it was like to have everything fulfilled at least once.

Identity • 37


BEYOND JUST BEING I do understand. That there is a mystery, a marvel to just being. An unwillingness, an inability devoid of any motivation, to reflect, to ponder, to wonder about the unknown, to consider the impenetrable, to obsess about the purpose of life and the meaning of existence. That a preoccupation with the realities and challenges of daily life are more than a sufficient concern and are often overwhelming in and of themselves. Unfortunately, however, the potent combination of my own genetic double helix, and my other double helix of experience and memory, mixed with a big dose of interpretive reflection, forces me to probe beyond just being. Oh, well!

38 • Identity


Identity • 39


40 • Identity


GUILTY I confess. To occasionally feeling guilty. Guilty for feeling joy and happiness at the same time that I see, and am aware of, such terrible sadness and deprivation in the world.

Identity • 41


IN GRATITUDE I offer thankful gratitude for the strength, humanity, wisdom, joyfulness, cordiality of my spirit. This essence, defining, unique, distinguishing set of characteristics that are me. Not sure who or what should take credit for its ever presence, or how, exactly, it was planted, grew, flourished. Certainly genetics and the love and guidance my parents were the most essential ingredients. I don’t remember, on my own, attempting to purposely design and construct it. It surely has been a wondrous companion and guide for and through my life. And on reflection, providing a balance of admirable life choices that I’ve, thankfully, mostly followed.

42 • Identity


Identity • 43


44 • Identity


NO, YOU WILL NOT FIND ME No matter where you look, you will not find me. No matter what you test, measure, examine, observe. I am not what you can touch, see, or analyze. Even if you could translate my encoded electrochemical neuro-activity, synapse by synapse, you would still not know. I am all of, and none of, the sum and the parts. Even if you could gather all possible information and inputs, it might only be an approximation of the ‘was’ me, not the ’now’ me, or the ‘to be’ me. I’m not a static, constant thing. I’m continually changing, evolving, devolving, even mutating occasionally. Different than before, different than whatever is next. No, you will not find me.

Identity • 45


ME? Wait, wait, that can’t be me. I know me, and that isn’t it. I’d remember, wouldn’t I? I’d be able to tell with absolute certainty. I couldn’t have changed that much. I mean, it’s just too different. But, anything is possible, I guess. They say it’s me, but maybe they’re confusing me with someone else. I’d know better than anyone else, wouldn’t I? Sure, things change over time, but not like that. Or, do they?

46 • Identity


Identity • 47


48 • Identity


OUR STORIES Our lives, as we try to recall them, are seemingly collections of stories. We all have them, we all cherish them. Somehow they come to describe and define much of who we were, or think we were. Sometimes remembered accurately, sometimes edited, and other times invented, purposely or not. And occasionally, dreams and stories get melded, confused with each other. Regardless, we talk about them as though they are factual and true. Interestingly, out of all those years, all those days, for each period, there just seem to be a select few that we repeatedly call up. These somehow have become markers on our lives. How often do we remember ourselves as we think we used to be, but fail to recognize that that person is no longer us?

Identity • 49


LOOK FOR THE UNKNOWABLE Look for things that are unknowable. That can be explored but never discovered. That can be approached but never reached. Touched but not fully grasped. Started but never completed. Problems to be understood without concluding solutions. Things that may have enduring meaning. Look.

50 • Identity


Identity • 51


52 • Identity


WITHIN ME Within this outer casing, these boundaries that are the physical me, are things that are surprisingly delicate and previously unrevealed. A certain curiosity, insights, wonderment about time, love, aging, memories, my inner presence. Who knew? I’m not exactly sure how they got there. And, I’m unclear why they were undiscovered for so long. Perhaps a biologic trigger as my clock started to click faster. No, I don’t think that they were never there or lost, just hidden, waiting to make an appearance. It’s another reason why my weathervane can’t help but point to hope. ‘If in me, why not in most anyone?’ It’s given me a deeper appreciation of the wise advice offered by the noted scientist, Carl Sagan, ‘……….cherish your species.’

Identity • 53


WONDERMENT I just can’t help it. I truly have no choice. My mind, my life, has always been bound so closely to my heart. I tend to see possibilities, not the limitations, things as they could be, the goodness, hope not doubt, love and the romantic potential of life. Perhaps I’m frozen in the wonderment of childhood, always believing that only happiness and ‘good’ serendipity awaits. Not naive, I think, since my life experience has mostly reinforced these beliefs.

54 • Identity


Identity • 55


COULD I HAVE DONE MORE? Now that I seem to have time to reflect, the question troubles me. Could I or perhaps more importantly should I have done more? Done more to try and make the world, myself, others, better. And, if so, by what standard? My ingrained sense of obligation, ultimate purpose, the exchange for having the privilege of life,

56 • Identity


forces me to make a judgment. I think then the answer is ‘yes’. But, why didn’t I? Others might say——— ‘he’s done more than most’. However, I know better. Self-indulgence, fulfilling personal obligations, aren’t crimes. Sure, the challenge is finding the right balance, and excuses, rationalizations, are easy to come by. Well, I still have time, don’t I? After all, you don’t retire from the obligation.

Identity • 57


UNFORTUNATE LIMITATIONS On reflection, I now realize that I was born to a purpose. One that I cannot abandon. The specifics shaped by my nature, enhanced by nurture, both with a debt to all my generations before. Then shaped by the particular circumstances and the times as my life unfolded, fueled by unrelenting desire, finally modified by my unfortunate limitations.

58 • Identity


Identity • 59


60 • Identity


THE ODD PECULIARITY OF DREAMS You lie there in the dark. In the protective comfort and warmth of your bed. Wondering. There in your self-constructed womb. About the cosmic and the incidental. Your hopes, your hidden desires, about today, about tomorrow. About your disappointments, and your achievements, imagining and reconstructing them. A participant in fantasies you wish could be made real. And then you drift off, no longer having the burden of needing to do anything, regressing into the buoyant warmth of that ‘amniotic fluid’, yielding to nights’ sleep and the odd peculiarity of dreams.

Identity • 61


OMISSIONS I wonder. What didn’t I do that I should have, and what did I do wrong? You know, the errors of omission and commission. No, not all of them. But the few that remain on my mind that I ruminate about. And what would I do differently, if I could? I seem to be troubled most by the errors of omission, especially things I should have said, or said more clearly. To have made my inner most feelings unambiguous. To change those moments when my heart was full, but I was strangely mute.

62 • Identity


Identity • 63


64 • Identity


MAGIC AND WONDER As a child I had always thought that the world was filled magic and wonder. And, I guess that I still do. A lasting forever imprint it seems. I had always believed that the world was a fair and just place. That, in the end, what was wrong would be fixed. That adults, the world, could be relied on, that goodness would always prevail. While some of my life experiences have chipped away at that belief, I still, somehow, see and hope that the world really is, and will always be, that way.

Identity • 65


WHAT I LOST I lost something that day. Hard to say exactly what it was. But it was important, very important. I think it was part of my gyroscope. I was destabilized a bit. No longer absolutely confident about the future, that there might be one for me. Life now more about ambiguity than certainty. The length and clarity about my path now unknown.

66 • Identity


Identity • 67


68 • Identity


HARMONIC RHYTHM With age I see linkages more clearly. That there is an underlying harmonic rhythm to life that stretches far across time and events. Connecting us to both the before and the after. A surprising constancy amidst our perception of change. How little change, how little difference, there really are in the essentials. The connections. The molecule of water that landed on my hand during last night’s rain has likely been recycling over several millennia. There is only one mitochondrial genome type in all animal cells. One degree of separation from my grandfather’s grandfather and it’s the 18th century, and likely one between me and my grandchild’s child and the middle of the 22nd century. We are linked, intermediaries, to both the past and the future.

Identity • 69


70 • Identity


On Aging ‘Oddly, my spirit, my soul, does soar as the days fall away’

Identity • 71


AS THE DAYS FALL AWAY I never fully realized that my days, my time, would wind down. I know that may sound strange, naive. But, with advancing age, I now know that they do. I seem to be on a journey. Towards a more complete understanding. Of myself, of a deeply embedded truth, previously obscured. About the nature of life, about meaning and purpose, about who I am, who I was, and who I might yet be. It’s surprising, refreshing, actually invigorating. No, not dark at all. There’s a sense that I can still achieve some sort of completion, a mastery, acquire elusive wisdom, satisfying insights, about life and purpose. A fulfilling closure. Oddly, my spirit, my soul, does soar as the days fall away.

72 • Aging


Aging • 73


74 • Aging


AS HOPE YIELDS TO FATE Each of my days seem to happily cleave into its next. With that next lovingly saying farewell to the one filled with wonders just before. But I have become increasingly aware that there is an end, not a forever. That my days will run out. I find that there is so much to remember, and so little to forget. I now see how hope yields to fate.

Aging • 75


A BROKEN PROMISE? So, when did my body start to turn on me? I thought we were friends. That we had a bargain. That I would be a good caretaker. I began with pretty good genetics, then made sure to have plenty of rest, lots of exercise, no smoking, no drinking, no drug abuse, decent nutrition. OK, not perfect, but who is? In exchange my body would be a good and loyal partner and last, without too much deterioration, for a long time.

76 • Aging


Be around in optimal working order, for its age, when needed. Instead, I now get the vague sense that maybe it wants to move out sooner, that it’s beginning to fray at the edges, even perhaps abandon its promise, sneak off in the middle of some night and go elsewhere. But where would that be? I mean, don’t we have to stick together?

Aging • 77


78 • Aging


FADING AWAY As time passed his features seemed to lose their shape. The deepening lines on his face did not reveal any contained messages. It appeared that his eyes no longer connected to the vibrant mind that was once present. He now moved at quarter speed. He was becoming increasingly indistinct from his surroundings, colorless. His voice now soundless. He was simply fading away, shrinking. Already labeled as having ‘passed’, he was ignored. A barely living ghost. However, what others thought they saw was at variance to the sharp, wise, and still vibrant person contained within. But no one cared, no one wanted to take the time to find out. He was at the end, and when they saw him they glimpsed into their own future and wanted no part of it.

Aging • 79


DEEPER WITHIN The body deeper within my body needs more strength, more resilience, to be ready. The thoughts within my thoughts need to be more aware, sharper, prepared. The burden of advancing age requires a surprising, special, resolute toughness, not a surrendering passivity. To deal with the remaining choices, the obligations that must be fulfilled, the physical and emotional challenges, the increasing sense of isolation, the inevitable decline, to confront the doubts about what must be done and not done, and what soon will need to be done, to smooth the end, especially for the others.

80 • Aging


Aging • 81


82 • Aging


DISCOVERY As your string of time winds down, treasured moments of self-revelation remain possible. When you can still discover that you are, or are capable of being more, perhaps much more. Able to achieve new insights, comprehension, knowledge, a previously elusive understanding, a new awareness about yourself and the human condition. Maybe recalling a vital memory offering clues to how you became who you are now and who you might yet be. Or a sudden ability to finally articulate and convey a deeply held feeling, perhaps a discovery about how to solve a vital and troubling challenge. This spark reignites an inner glow, a renewed appreciation of the magnificence of the gift of life, recognition that you are not diminished by age, that capability doesn’t whither, only the will does.

Aging • 83


WAS I EVER REALLY YOUNGER? Was I ever really younger than I am now? Was my skin really firm, moist, without blemish? Was I ever able to see, to hear, without assistance? Did I ever have full balance, able to get up and walk without pain or stiffness? Sleep through the whole night? Be unconcerned about the inevitable progression of time? Strange, I no longer remember being young like that, but still perceive myself to be unchanged. How can that be?

84 • Aging


Aging • 85


‘AND WE WILL ALL GO DOWN TOGETHER’ After awhile you begin to wonder. The thought seeps in. You pretend to be unconcerned about yourself, but you are. Some of your contemporaries are dying. Crippling illness suddenly strikes those you know, some who you love. Seemingly a selection made at random. You speculate, ‘will death and disease pass over me and my house, or am I about to hear its knock’. ‘If them now, why not me?’

86 • Aging


There is no comfort when it’s someone else and not you, no deep sigh of relief. Actually, you feel that their loss also chips away at you, your continuance. That somehow you are part of a collectivity, and even part of a shared and special generation in time that has begun to disappear. As you think about this a remembered phrase from the tune ‘Goodnight Saigon’, by Billy Joel, keeps repeating itself within you, ‘………..and we will all go down together…… .’ And then you know, that no matter how much you might wish otherwise, your far horizon just isn’t that far away.

Aging • 87


88 • Aging


FORGOTTEN I fear being forgotten more than dying. I expect that those who I now love, care most about, will remember and miss me deeply, some even profoundly, after I’m gone. Perhaps long for, wish for, more moments together. But, it’s the ones who follow just after, the next generations, who will let me slip away. Because they’re busy with other things, because I wasn’t well known or known to them. Not relevant. Understandably unaware that their grasp on me constantly weakens. That if they don’t somehow hold on I will tumble away, into the void, lost forever. I know it’s my fate, everyones, but one that I, nonetheless, fear, and wish were otherwise.

Aging • 89


THE MOMENT There is this moment in time when you first realize, with absolute clarity, that you are no longer, and will never again be who you were. You’ve crossed over the threshold without a return ticket. The changes are irreversible, your denouement the destination. All that’s left is setting the date. A moment of overwhelming, overpowering, melancholy.

90 • Aging


Aging • 91


WHO IS THAT? Have you recently looked into the mirror and wondered, ‘who is that?’ I loved my father and grandfather, but never did I expect to be them. Oh, you know. Furrows appearing and deepening, muscles slacking, less hair in some places, more in others. Spots and imperfections taking over. You wonder, is anyone, or, is everyone else noticing? You don’t really want anyone, especially the one you love, to be witness to your physical decline. Of course, just as you realize that your Love must notice, you admit that she’s been accumulating a set of related symptoms. You wonder, how did all this happen so suddenly?

92 • Aging


You want to be seen, remembered, for your preferred image of yourself, the one in your mind that is long gone. You still want younger women to notice and appreciate your imagined good looks and virility, not help you to cross the street. Hold it, hold it, get a grip, stay calm. You can modify it a bit, slow it down a little, but not reverse it. You can’t really change life’s physical trajectory. The same you is still there, you just have to look more carefully for him. So, what is the right mindset? In the end, the key is to love yourself. Love yourself for who you are now, who you were, and who you’ll continue to be. I mean, what other good choice is there?

Aging • 93


94 • Aging


MORE I want more. More time. I want to see my children and their children grow old, happy, fulfilled. To always be with my Love. To always feel the warmth and splendor of the sun, to experience all of the beauty and wonders of life. To see the end of poverty and suffering. To know the earth is safe. To see a thousand more full moons and every sunrise and sunset in between. And to find more ways to make the world a better place.

Aging • 95


INSISTENT The past keeps following me. Always getting closer. It wants to be in my words. To always be remembered, never forgotten. So insistent. It wants me there, to always be part of it. I do understand. For the past is what, in the end, we become.

96 • Aging


Aging • 97


98 • Aging


BEWILDERED Bewildered. No longer sure of his place. What he was supposed to do. Even where he was supposed to be. The days seemed endless. He didn’t know how to fill them up. Just wandering through them without purpose, towards an end he was starting to wish for. He was tired, always. He still wore his wedding ring as a reminder of who he had been when life seemed to have purpose. Now alone. Even his most treasured possessions, his memories, were slipping away.

Aging • 99


THEM THEN, ME NOW They always sat comfortably on the nearby park bench, at Seth Low Playground, Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, as we played. The elderly, I barely noticed them then, I was just a child. I did see them walking slowly about, a bit bent over, shuffling along a little. They had this look of easy contentment, appearing relaxed, a bit rumpled, but comfortable in the world, strangely untroubled, even though their time had to be running out. Seeming in no rush to get anywhere, quite happy to chat, to sit relaxed and watch us play and everything else going on there in the park. I write this as I sit here, it’s a late summer afternoon in Central Park, near the Children’s Gate at East 76th Street and 5th Avenue. I’m now in the middle of my eighth decade, watching the children play, wondering if they’ll notice me.

100 • Aging


Aging • 101


102 • Aging


THE LOSS OF IMAGINATION When we’re young we imagine. Imagine the possibilities of a future, our future. Our lives then filled with expectation, with hope. When we’re old we tend to re-imagine the past, in part because our memory is imperfect, patchy, incomplete. And, in part, subconsciously, we edit our stories so that they are more positive, fitting our self-perceived persona. Of course, why shouldn’t we want to feel better about ourselves? But sadly, the gift of imagination and the enthusiasm for possibilities seems to erode as we age. And, unfortunately, it’s imagination that is necessary for hope to exist.

Aging • 103


LASTING TRACKS In what now remains of my future, I want to follow my own path. One always covered with fresh undisturbed snow. Where I can leave deep, indelible, lasting tracks. Of meaning for me and others. With every step, every moment, being a fond remembrance.

104 • Aging


Aging • 105


106 • Aging


WHAT HAPPENED TO MY FUTURE? There comes a point in life when you begin to realize that the future isn’t about you any longer. Time is collapsing in on itself. Your future is really the present, not what lies over the horizon. Possibilities are no longer endless. Those who haven’t gotten there yet just don’t seem to understand. Why would they? With this recognition, I now have a greater requirement for certainty, unambiguous fulfillment, the need for completion, far less for delayed gratification.

Aging • 107


CURATOR OF HER DAYS (Read while humming the Beatles’ ‘Eleanor Rigby’)

She was a curator of her days. Collecting, organizing, observing them as though they didn’t really belong to her. As though up on a shelf, or hanging there in just the right light. Catalogued. Not able to be a participant, an owner of the full body of what life offered. Floating along, hovering, watching, for what she never had a clue. Hope, happiness, sadness, intimacy, all irrelevant emotions and experiences for her. Seemingly incapable of, even disinterested in, connecting. Just playing out her time, letting the collected days unwind until there was no more string. Alone. No one to care about her collection. How sad.

108 • Aging


Aging • 109


110 • Aging


WONDER AT MY VANISHING POINT I awake, so very slowly. A bit confused, uncertain as to where, exactly, I am. After a few moments things clear. Sunlight filters in and I can just see some blue sky at the small gap between the wall and the shade. Birds chirping. I’m at an advanced age, frail, in decline, likely some months or weeks away from my vanishing point. Forever is coming soon. I know that I shouldn’t say this, but I’ve begun to look forward to that moment. I’ve been tired, oh so very tired. Somehow, however, with a rush of unexplainable energy I sit up with a sudden unfathomable renewed enthusiasm. For life. As though I’m younger, closer to the beginning rather than the end, with a sense of hope and possibilities. Even now, life surprises.

Aging • 111


SOLITUDE He had grown used to the solitude. Neither enjoying it nor regretting it, but simply accepting it. Everyone who he had cared about, or who had cared about him, was gone, either dead, moved away, or who no longer knew their own name. His days seemed to crash forward with the meaningless, rhythmic monotony of wave after wave pounding a shore. He thought of himself as a dimming, retreating shadow, knowing that it wouldn’t be long before his final nightfall would arrive and his shadow would simply evaporate as though never having existed. But still he persisted, primarily out of habit, with a vague, ill-defined hope that perhaps some as yet undiscovered pleasure would occur on some day before that final moment.

112 • Aging


Aging • 113


114 • Aging


TO OUTLAST (Thanks to Harvey Shapiro’s ‘Old Jew’)

How did it come to pass that his love of a good cigar, a cheese danish, a game of golf, not having to get up in the middle of the night to pee outlasted his desire for women? And, how did it come to pass that her love of a game of mahjong or bridge, lunch with the ‘girls’, a good pedicure, finding a good pair of flats, outlasted her desire for men?

Aging • 115


SLIPPING AWAY How among all these people did wisdom disappear, evaporate, seep away? I’m struck by how narrow their understanding, their circle of concern, has become. And so quickly. I recall having such vibrant, stimulating, conversations with them about the key concerns of our time. Their compassion, knowledge, argumentative passion was a wonderful thing. Now, all concerns are focused on their personal comforts, chronic care concerns, with perceived slights being events for brutal counterattacks. Yet another cruelty of aging. Disappearing, becoming someone they used to despise.

116 • Aging


Aging • 117


118 • Aging


DEEP, DEEP, INSIDE THE NIGHT He lived deep, deep, inside the night. It was in this quiet, unencumbered stillness, absent other distractions, where he could remember. Her. Now that she was gone it was a chance for him to recall the treasured memories of their wondrous life together, it was these moments that he now lived for, all that he had left. But now, occasionally, he was starting to forget, his ability to recall fading, he was slowly losing her, she was slipping from his grasp, and they were both tumbling into the void, forever.

Aging • 119


ME, THEN? It’s mid-Autumn, late afternoon, a Monday. I’m sitting on a Central Park bench, reading a spy thriller, looking about, reflecting. I can hear a jazz group playing nearby at the East 76th Street entrance at 5th Avenue. Nice. I glance over to my right, and a couple of benches away is a rather elegant gentleman who appears to be about 15 years my senior. He’s looking straight ahead at the canopy of high trees that are beginning to show a bit of yellow, a bit of red. Serene, a slight smile on his face. I project forward to a time when it might be me sitting there instead of him, same demeanor, remembering this same moment, and my smile broadens. Just a few seconds later I look over again and he’s gone, and I now wonder whether that gentleman was ever actually there, or was I projecting myself forward in time?

120 • Aging


Identity Aging • •121


122• Identity


On Writing ‘But for me, poetry is about creating a moment of intimate relevance about an idea, an emotion, an experience, a belief, a memory, something meaningful between a writer and a reader.’

Identity •123


124• •Identity Writing


THESE POEMS ARE A REMEMBRANCE All those other pieces of life I’ve lived are gone. The ones before, gone forever. I mourn their passing, their innocence, their unexpected wonder, their irretrievability, that they were blessed gifts beyond my expectations. My childhood and after, and those until a now unseen conclusion. My great regret is that my parents and all those others who played such treasured roles, and who have now passed on, are not with me to share the joy and happiness of recollections from those lives. To them I offer these poems as a remembrance to their blessed memory.

Writing • 125


‘WILL YOU REMEMBER ME?’ Have you ever noticed how people disappear? People you knew, people you loved, special people. Time seems to wipe away their tracks. Time evaporates the memory of them somehow. First, they are constantly on your mind. You commit to holding on, to remembering them. Then they are there with you occasionally, then less, then still less. They just keep fading away no matter how hard you try. Once in awhile you suddenly remember, feeling embarrassed because you have failed. After awhile, a year, a generation, all that’s left is their headstone in a quiet, rarely visited cemetery. It was these thoughts, personalized, that first led me to begin to write, to write about love and other personal reflections about life.

126 • Writing


To fulfill a need to, somehow, tell and leave pieces of my story. You see, I want to enable a reader to know me a bit, know who I am, who I was. I want my thoughts and words to be direct, unambiguous, strongly emotive, from my heart to yours. You, the reader, perhaps you’re someone who knew me, who loved me, or perhaps you accidentally came across this very limited edition when only my headstone remains. Whoever you might be, it is my hope that some of my words will touch your heart, help you to consider the meaning of your life, and that I will be remembered. Remembered for the best of reasons.

Writing • 127


128 • Writing


INSIDE WE ARE ALL POETS Everyone, everyone, has thoughts inside them that are just out of view, tucked away, resting in comfort, hidden, content to be where they now are, there, maybe, forever. Stored, waiting perhaps, to be shared on the outside. Things then for the telling. The private, unrevealed, is precious, treasured. With so much of everything else being public, shared in peculiar ways via social media, these unrevealed treasures are our special, secret possessions. These are feelings, beliefs, passions, observations, reflections. That could be translated into our own individual language, then communicated, if we so choose. These are our poems, revealed or not. Inside, we are all poets.

Writing • 129


A MOMENT OF INTIMATE RELEVANCE Is it poetry or prose? Just what is it? I mean, does it really matter? Well, perhaps to some, but surely not to most. Rules about form, etc., can be barriers to making the emotive, stimulant power of words accessible. Some poetry is so dense that you need a jackhammer and dynamite to penetrate. Maybe this is why so few people read, and so few people write poetry.

130 • Writing


But for me, poetry is about creating a moment of intimate relevance about an idea, an emotion, a person, an experience, a memory, a belief, something between a writer and a reader. You know, a created communication using an ordered collection of words that offers the possibility of meaning, recognition, felt personal value for both the giver and receiver. Not to be judged, but something that can be appreciated, a human moment or experience that makes a positive difference in a life.

Writing • 131


132 • Writing


WHAT KIND OF POEM? So, what kind of poem shall it be this morning? The beginning of love or the end of love? Love unrequited or love requited? The wonders of love or its burdens? Death and the Grim Reaper? The unkindness of time? Hope or hopelessness? The wonders of childhood or the fears of senescence? The blessings of intimacy or the omnipresence of loneliness? Physical beauty or the end of it? Memories or the loss of them? Come on, come on, pick one, so that I can just get on with it!!

Writing • 133


A POET? A knowledgeable friend, who has read my poems, recently called me a ‘poet’. But, am I really a poet? It sounds lofty, implying a talent and skill, a gift of artistry, that I don’t recognize in myself. Coming to the activity later in life, with little background and experience, I just can’t seem to affix the ‘poet’ label to my lapel. However, that’s not what really matters. What is are the words that I’ve fastened together to express thoughts and feelings that I would like some others to read. Yes, to be read, that’s it. By some who I know, and others who I don’t. For them, hopefully, to discover something of personal meaning and perceived value for themselves. To have taken time for reflection, with some enriching consequence for their lives. Yes, that’s the result that I seek.

134 • Writing


Writing • 135


136 • Writing


JUST LIKE THAT! It’s so tough to get them just right. The exact way you intend it. Words can get twisted so easily. And sometimes you can wring all meaning from them by saying either too much or not enough. Then there are these creases in some words that are so hard to straighten. Other words need a reflective surface but only seem to absorb the offered light. The surface of some are just to slick and slippery, so easy to fall on them. Others too sharp or too dull. Sometimes simple and direct is the best way. ‘I love you now and forever.’ Yes, just like that!

Writing • 137


ON LOST MAN TRAIL (I recently discovered scribbled notes inside an old, unused briefcase for this poem, written in 1997, a few months after my Mom died. It was written on the back of a hiking trail map — the trail being near Independence Pass, Colorado, at an elevation of about 11,000 ft. I now recall that it was the first moment that the idea of writing poems occurred to me. The idea then, subconsciously, incubated for ten years.)

Morning, mid-summer. Cool breeze, deep blue sky. The lush, deep green, alpine valley stretches on and on. Jagged, bare, brown-grey peaks surround. Wildflowers in bloom - yellow, purple, blue, white. I’m joined only by the wind and an occasional bird. Suddenly, a lone marmot rushes by.

138 • Writing


The climb continues. Two lakes, their surfaces looking alive, reflecting snow patches that hang on well past their season. I feel the joy of existence, the confluence of my human and some infinite spirit. I wonder how often again I will be witness to such magnificence, such grandeur, such inspiration. I also feel a vague vulnerability as I reflect on my mother’s recent passing. A void, the loss of parental unconditional love, transience, the disappearance of the last link to all that came before. A stark counterpoint between the seeming immutability of these mountains and the impermanence of human existence. As though putting an end to my mourning, I begin to hum the last line of Kaddish, the Jewish prayer for the dead: ‘Oseh shalom….’

Writing • 139


140 • Writing


UNINVITED Sometimes an idea, a word, a thought, keeps rumbling around in my head. Insistent, uninvited. Imploring me to give it a life, motion, existence, a future in a poem. I try to hide, but it doesn’t quit. I say, ‘I’m not good enough for you, please leave me and find someone else’, or, ‘come back another time when I might be ready’. But, it won’t be deceived. It is relentless. It wants what it wants.

Writing • 141


HIS WORDS Occasionally, he wondered. Whether they made a difference. His words. Whether anyone noticed, anyone cared. He considered the ones just written again. He looked down. Moving from letter to letter. Jumping across the gaps between the words, considering whether the spaces in between were, somehow, important. He glanced back, over his shoulder, at each sentence, to consider whether it ‘worked’. Looking for the essential thread that linked each word, each sentence together into an idea, a thought, that would have some meaning both for himself and for a reader.

142 • Writing


Writing • 143


144 • Writing


LOYAL WORDS So, do you think our words pay singular attention to what we say and write? Or, do they have a life of their own, perhaps continually commenting about us. You know, like, ‘ha!, he says it, but doesn’t really mean it’. Or, are they always loyal servants, believing everything we convey, doing whatever we want? But, sometimes, don’t words just escape from your mouth as though you lack input, control? See what I mean! It’s probably safer to treat words with great respect, just in case. We don’t want them angry, out of control, rebelling, and causing all kinds of trouble.

Writing • 145


146• Identity


On Social Commentary ‘Standing in the way of the abuse of power, defending the rights and opportunities of the less powerful, endeavoring to assure optimal equality and social and political democracy, protecting the earth, advancing values of love and kindness in a respectful communal society.’

Identity •147


STANDING IN THE WAY My life experience has allowed me to consider what I believe to be patriotism, bravery, courage, heroism. I don’t mean the kind that takes place on a military battlefield. But a kind that is rarely recognized as such. For me, it is those who are immovable as they stand in the way of injustice, racism, oppression, by their belief and action, protecting what, I believe, it means to be an American.

148 • Social Commentary


Standing in the way of the abuse of power, defending the rights and opportunities of the less powerful, endeavoring to assure optimal equality and political and economic democracy, protecting the earth, advancing the values of love and kindness in a respectful communal society. Standing in the way without regard to personal gain or consequences, and doing so because it’s the right thing to do. For those who acted, and continue to stand in the way in service to America, there should be respect, honor, recognition, even medals.

Social Commentary • 149


150 • Social Commentary


SAVING THE WORLD It is a terrible thing to see, to know, that there is only gloom, hopelessness, even a premature death lying on the life path of others. And to feel powerless to alter the essential finality of that fate. Yet, as part of the human community, if we ignore it, if we don’t at least try to change the outcome, aren’t we, somehow, complicit in allowing its continuance? Aren’t we obligated to scream ‘fire’ when there is one, and aren’t we obligated to try and put it out? ‘And whoever saves a life, it is as if he saved an entire world (Jerusalem Talmud, Sanhedrin 4:1(21a)).

To have saved an entire world — now that is truly a most worthy aspiration for each of us. Isn’t it?

Social Commentary • 151


IN OTHER PLACES From kerosene lamps, single bulbs, small fires, dim lights barely flicker in millions upon millions of other places. Like hope, like their lives, the fading light slowly escapes out into the darkness. It slithers away under doorways, retreating between cracks in a wall, slipping by canvas flaps, through glassless windows. There’s nothing they can do. Their fate sealed with their first breath. And, in other nearby, now darkened places, other souls have given up, knowing they are lost, having long ago surrendered, resting their heads against decaying surfaces, eyes vacant, just wondering, sometimes even hoping, ‘when?’

152 • Social Commentary


Social Commentary • 153


154 • Social Commentary


HOW? How do we become so possessed by indifference? How does the failure to respond to terrible human suffering seep into our being? How does our conscience so easily disappear at moments when it is most needed? How do our hearts become so readily hardened and frozen? How is it that our humanity is often just a thin veneer? How do such things happen? How? How?

Social Commentary • 155


STOLEN LIVES No. No child should have to sleep in the streets, to sort through garbage for their food, to be scorned, beaten, ignored, never loved, to die far before their time without knowing moments of true happiness, to never have dreams fulfilled. No. No child should have their life stolen.

156 • Social Commentary


Social Commentary • 157


158 • Social Commentary


DESPAIR I am in despair. No, not for myself. Nor for the rest of my time. I despair for the future beyond. As the dark side of human nature continues to flourish unrestrained by taking control of a substantial portion of the collective will, I continue to see a downward spiral where ignorance, cruelty, hatred, bigotry, suspicion, become the norm of our collective daily life. Where all problems, as in other times, are blamed on the ‘other’, who have become the unrelenting target of hostile and brutal persecution. We are on the verge of another Dark Age.

Social Commentary • 159


A WASTED LIFE I can imagine no greater fear than to have had a wasted life. One without meaning, one without love. The gift discarded, squandered. To have failed to care. To have failed to try and make the world and others better. To have failed to share hope and possibilities. A life without consequence, devoid of purpose. An aimless existence. To have taken, but not given. A wasted life.

160 • Social Commentary


Social Commentary • 161


162 • Social Commentary


ASHAMED Sometimes, I confess, that I am ashamed to be a member of the human family, of my species. The cruelty, indifference, the selfishness that so many exhibit to others is so tragic. As though evolution is in reverse. That somehow, modern society is creating mutations that diminish the trajectory of our species.

Social Commentary • 163


IT WAITS Out there, just out of sight, behind closed doors, deep in dark places, especially in the minds and hearts of some people, there is something sinister, foreboding, that lurks just out of sight. It waits, knowing that its time will come. As it always has.

164 • Social Commentary


Social Commentary • 165


166 • Social Commentary


HUMAN BLACK HOLES The homeless, the discarded, the abandoned. They have become invisible, unreal shadows to us. Human black holes. They are unseen, unnoticed, having no acknowledged existence. There is nothing that we care to see or hear from inside their impenetrable darkness. Shame on us.

Social Commentary • 167


OH, OH, OH, KOLKATA! Oh, oh, oh, Kolkata! You have so many wonders, but when the stowaways on your city ship are humanity’s discarded, neglected, abused, forgotten, you can appear as a rotting corpse slowly drifting to an abyss at the world’s edge, where those stowaways only hope is a better life after their coming death and reincarnation. Who then are the guilty, who have sentenced them to this life, who ignore their plight, who are complicit, who stand by and pretend they don’t exist? Each one of us bears that burden.

168 • Social Commentary


Social Commentary • 169


170 • Social Commentary


YES, THERE IS EVIL Oh yes, there is evil. It is out there. Go, turn and face the wind. You will smell its stench. If you search in the dark corners you will see its face, its bestial ugliness, barely hidden. It waits. For its moment. To inflict pain, sadness, and suffering. Beware.

Social Commentary • 171


FORGIVENESS?! Born into abject poverty. A life of constant struggle, torment, hardship. Each day, every day. Working from before dawn to after dusk. Just for food, clean water, basic sanitation, a roof, school for his children, access to health care, hope. He prays to God. Asking for forgiveness for whatever it is that causes him to have this life, this misfortune. But, why should this man be asking for forgiveness?! It should be God asking the man for forgiveness. For His thoughtlessness and cruelty. Let them exchange places for a bit. Amen.

172 • Social Commentary


Social Commentary • 173


174 • Social Commentary


WHAT TO MAKE OF IT? I’m not sure what to make of it. Not certain I know what it means. There are important lessons here, but it’s not clear what they are. Young teenagers and pre-teens, HIV/AIDS orphans in remote, rural Africa. I’ve met them. Sweet, thoughtful, hopeful, purposeful, hard working, unspoiled. Is that how one would describe their Western counterparts? No? Well, why is that?

Social Commentary • 175


A BLESSING I wish that I could thank each one. All of them personally. To offer a blessing to those who, without a thought of personal benefit, engage in repeated acts of kindness and goodness because they see the damage, the need to repair and perfect the world. They are the ones to be admired, respected, whose behaviors are a model for ours.

176 • Social Commentary


Social Commentary • 177


178 • Social Commentary


MORAL WORTH How can a people, a collective, call themselves caring, civil, a democracy, when it is the circumstances of birth that primarily defines one’s life? On the national stage no one any longer speaks of poverty, the discarded, the invisible underclass. It’s as though they no longer exist. A people’s moral worth, its character, is defined by how they, we, care for the most vulnerable. Shame, shame, shame.

Social Commentary • 179


‘THANK YOU……………….’ I thought that I knew about the beauty and power of words. But, it was a young child, an HIV/AIDS orphan, living in a school in rural Uganda, that taught that there is so much more for me to learn. At the school that I have had the privilege of assisting in many ways. In his letter to me he said, ‘thank you for loving me’. Imagine that! ‘Thank you for loving me’. Him thanking me for his gift to me.

180 • Social Commentary


Social Commentary • 181


182 • Social Commentary


THE DEMAND OF PERSONAL INTEGRITY The reality of daily life often forces us to acknowledge the presence of the unacceptable, and that our individual control over externalities can be so limited. But, it is the presence of an inner personal integrity, a conscience, an understanding of right and wrong, our ‘requirement’ to only do the right things, that demands we resist, commit to do what is necessary within our capability to honor our beliefs.

Social Commentary • 183


A TERRIBLE DARKNESS There is a terrible darkness in the hearts of people. A tribal imperative that separates us, always lurking there, just below the surface, that when played upon yields unspeakable hatreds, the greatest danger to civil society. It is a belief that all problems are caused by ‘the other’, the one different, the one weaker — ‘if they would just disappear.’ Those who understand this and seek to use it for their own benefit to achieve power and influence are the enemies of democracy, the enemies of all personal and communal freedoms, the darkness that must, somehow, be banished.

184 • Social Commentary


Social Commentary • 185


186 • Social Commentary


THE RESISTANCE —— THE PLEDGE ‘I pledge to take all non-violent actions, within my capability, to resist all efforts that would diminish the civil and human rights of all in America and their ability to achieve equity and equality in a just, diverse, caring, and democratic society.’

Social Commentary • 187


THE DREAM EXTINGUISHED First as a child, then through the rest of my life until now, I dreamed that this place, earth, America, could be a universal dwelling for hope, for kindness, and for shared communal aspirations. Sadly, I no longer have that dream. There has been a final affirmation that there is an indestructible darkness in our species, a genetic and behavioral immutability, irrepressibly manifest, the implacable enemy of goodness and social justice.

188 • Social Commentary


Social Commentary • 189


190 • Social Commentary


AMERICA IS DYING In only a few moments the world seemed ever so quickly to tilt from joy to sadness, hope to hopelessness, from light to darkness. The always present evil has again awoken from its slumber, its followers surging. The weak, the different, its first victims. Our world, always in delicate balance, its path is now unmistakably downward. While we, individually and collectively, are responsible for perfecting the world through acts of goodness, kindness, and beneficence, a vast part of America is demonstrating that it prefers selfishness, repression, greed, lies, cruelty and hatred. Our collective substrate for life, once fertile as a place for social and political democracy, is now diseased, in decay, perhaps irreparably. America is dying.

Social Commentary • 191


THE DARKNESS WOULDN’T LEAVE It fills all spaces. Like a dense shadow slithering through the streets, our houses, into every corner of peoples’ lives. Taking possession. Replacing all light. The darkness, rolling across our country, washes over the sun and moon, a dark cloth over the heavens. There is confusion, uncertainty, rising disquiet, doubt about its meaning, its intent, its permanence. We search for the light, but it eludes us.

192 • Social Commentary


Social Commentary • 193


RESURRECTION It’s late. The platform is empty. Still, quiet. I’m waiting for the next train. The journey home from Brooklyn, babysitting for my grandsons. Finally, it arrives. My car is empty except for a homeless person, a woman I think, huddled at the opposite end of the car. She is covered completely in what appears to be two heavy coats, wearing well worn boots, a thick black wool hat, gloves, with a green plastic garbage bag by her side that undoubtedly contains all of her worldly possessions.

194 • Social Commentary


Gradually, I begin to notice some back and forth movement under the layer of coats, as if she is awakening, stretching. It continues for a minute or so, appearing as though what is within is actually growing. I’m still, mesmerized, fascinated at what is occurring. Suddenly, the coat buttons can no longer contain what is within, and one by one pop off, rolling across the floor. The coats open, start falling away, as a brilliant, blue, iridescent wing begins to unfold. The coats, gloves, hat, boots, now all fall to the floor as magnificent wings fully unfold revealing the most wondrous, beautiful, spectacular, butterfly of such huge proportions that it nearly fills the entire car. The train arrives at its next stop, the doors open, and this incredible, newly resurrected being softly glides forward and out the door, and gently, fully, unfurls its newly born wings, and heads out to meet the world.

Social Commentary • 195


196• Identity


On Time ‘……………..one’s own conscious awareness of life’s brevity reinforces the need to sanctify the time that we do have.’

Identity •197


198 • Time


TIME STARING BACK AT ME Just who and what do I see staring back at me in the mirror? Is it the grandfather, the father, the son, the husband, the child, who? Is it hope, melancholy, the beginning, the approaching end, happiness, possibilities, missed opportunities, memories, longing, what? Occasionally, just behind me, passing like a shadow, I’ve begun to notice the edge of a wing beginning to unfurl. My angel is waiting. So, yes, now I realize that it is time staring back at me in its many guises, putting me on notice, calling for me to pay attention, that there are fewer and fewer grains of sand in the top half of my hourglass.

Time • 199


TIME IS WATCHING Time is always watching. There, in the shadows. Just beyond the edge of our recognition. Witness to our lives. Sometimes judging. Keeping track. Always ticking forward, diminishing constantly. Never telling us, never reminding us, just how much is left. That is, until it’s too late, about to run out. It is not our friend, not our ally. We can never be its master.

200 • Time


Before it’s too late, learn how to avoid being it unwitting victim, and how to be a wise custodian of your own allotment. In a life there are things we must do, things we hope to do, and things we dream of doing. Don’t wait. Assure yourself that satisfaction will be with you before time runs out. Realize that you can’t be passive or indifferent. Treat time as the rarest of your always diminishing life commodities. Remember that time does run out. Remember, time is watching.

Time • 201


NOT RECOVERABLE It has always been a puzzle to me. How the beauty and wonder that I see and experience in the course of each day fails to be captured in my conscious thoughts as a fully recorded, recoverable, and prized memory, so that these moments can be called up, relished later, exactly as they occurred. The mind seems to have other, more mundane priorities. Strange, how even at days end such cherished moments are forgotten while what we had for breakfast is remembered.

202 • Time


Time • 203


204 • Time


AS TIME RUSHES AWAY As time rushes with increasing speed away from me, I frequently find myself seeking to be alive in yesterdays. There is this growing weight of guilt for not having made sure that many of my moments of greatest remembered and shared happiness and pleasure were more central, frequent, dominant in my life. I had thought that the opportunities for such moments would be endless and always there for me. ……….I held her then, so tightly to me in the night…… I could feel her breathing, the beating of her heart, the warmth and fragrance of her skin…….

Moments of the most supreme intimacy, as though there was nothing else in the world to do and such moments would last forever.

Time • 205


YOU JUST CAN’T TRUST TIME What if time stopped? Today. It died or suddenly ran out. Or just refused to move ahead. Became stuck, frozen where it was. Began behaving unpredictably, erratically. Acting in a way that you could no longer count on it. Take a moment to ask yourself the following questions. Would you have lived the life of purpose and love you had hoped for and desired? Said and done those few things that seemed most important to your heart? Been satisfied with the essentials of the only shot at a life you get? Well, if not, don’t just sit there, get started. Yes, right now. Because, you know, that you just can’t trust time.

206 • Time


Time • 207


208 • Time


YOU CAN FEEL TIME You can feel time. I used to feel it blowing into my face, a very stiff wind, restraining me, much slower going than I wanted. Now, I feel an even stiffer wind at my back, propelling me forward, much faster than I want, much faster than I thought possible. I can now see how little time there is remaining. So, for me, each moment is a precious treasure.

Time • 209


TIME DOESN’T RECYCLE Time. You can’t save it for later, tucked away in a drawer, in the freezer, deposited in a bank drawing interest, or in a hope chest. It doesn’t get recycled or reused like glass, plastic, or paper. And, hopes and dreams are just that —— they are not part of a life lived. If you were to step outside of yourself, and observe, would it look like a frozen, immovable selfie? If so, then you need to change. Now. Because it’s the actual experiences that count, not the thoughts of it. Time does run out.

210 • Time


Time • 211


212 • Time


TIME LOST Have you ever noticed that there is a time in your day when nothing happens? Absolutely nothing. When time is suspended, in limbo, unable or unwilling to move. When nothing is born, nothing dies. No ideas, no work, not even daydreaming. A complete blank. While all is immobile, you subconsciously wait for next moments to occur, for a renewal, for your resting life source to reawaken. When forward movement, and even the possibilities in your life you so hope for, may again return. And, it is only when momentum returns that you realize that this most peculiar daily, reoccurring, time has been lost.

Time • 213


A TIME TRAVELER WHILE STANDING STILL No boundaries, only hope and possibilities. I am drawn to the distant horizon as I begin my early dawn walk, The sprawling foreground is filled with the varied colors of wild flowers and vegetation in the meandering arroyo, with the Sangre De Cristo mountains framing the horizon, while above the just rising sun plays with the clouds coloring them grey, then purple, pink, gold, and finally white. Here I feel part of, deeply connected to, everything in these early morning moments. A time traveler while standing still. Here now, knowing that the same here now has been, and will continue to be, unchanged for millennia. Surprisingly, I’m somehow content to know that this will continue to be here even when I’m not.

214 • Time


Time • 215


MUSINGS ABOUT TIME Albert Einstein: ‘…..….the separation between past, present and future is only an illusion……….’ Unfortunately, it eludes me. An ability to sufficiently grasp an understanding of Einstein’s space-time continuum and his description of a fourth dimension. Because, if I could, I might have an even more meaningful appreciation of, and reverence for, the perfection of the design of the natural world. Further, my internal sense of a continuous connection and bond to all of mine from the before, and all of mine extending forever forward appears to align with my limited understanding of Einstein’s belief that the past, present and future can/do coexist.

216 • Time


Abraham Joshua Heschel: ‘……..that in all of one’s deeds a person’s chief task is to sanctify time.’ With the benefit of time, life experiences, and reflection, I have come to realize the growing internal presence of a conscious spirituality that has rewarded me with a richer understanding of the soul within me. And I’ve importantly observed that one’s own conscious awareness of life’s brevity reinforces the need to sanctify the time that we do have.

Time • 217


218• Identity


ABOUT THE AUTHOR Dr. Arthur R. Goshin first began writing poetry as he turned sixty. Educated as a physician and in public health, he’s had a successful fifty year career in health care. The first phase of his professional life involved the development of comprehensive health centers in communities of poverty. The next phase involved the founding, development, and leading of a very well recognized, large, not-for-profit health plan serving over a half million members. He currently serves as a board chair, board member, or advisor for a range of organizations, foundations and private entities. As a Clinical Professor, Dr. Goshin has reached his fiftieth year as a global health focused faculty member at the University at Buffalo. As he retired from ‘employed work’(as he puts it), and began writing poetry, he also became the founder/ funder/president/ceo of his own foundation (healthyworldfoundation.org) engaged in numerous health projects in India and Africa. His new website, arthurgoshinbooks.com, includes some of his books of poems and photographs. He splits his living time between Santa Fe and New York City with his wife Renee. They have two sons/daughters-in-law, and three grandchildren.


220• Identity


TABLE OF CONTENTS On Identity 3

It Is Desire

4

Always Different

7

Yes, Dream

8

Each Day’s First Gift

11 Sorrows 12

Protect The Thread

15

The Wind At Your Back

16 Obligations 18

The Unseen

21

A Grand Adventure

22

A Life Worthy Of My Dreams

24 Impermanence 26

‘A Half Opened Door’

29 Dandelions 30

Conscience’s Demand


222• Identity


33

The Fabric And The Thread

34 Determined 37

That Day

38

Beyond Just Being

41 Guilty 42

In Gratitude

45

No, You Will Not Find Me

46 Me? 49

Our Stories

50

Look For The Unknowable

53

Within Me

54 Wonderment 56

Could I Have Done More?

58

Unfortunate Limitations

61

The Odd Peculiarity Of Dreams

62 Omissions 65

Magic And Wonder

66

What I Lost

69

Harmonic Rhythm


224• Identity


On Aging 72

As The Days Fall Away

75

As Hope Yields To Fate

76

A Broken Promise

79

Fading Away

80

Deeper Within

83 Discovery 84

Was I Ever Really Younger?

86

‘And We Will All Go Down Together’

89 Forgotten 90

The Moment

92

Who Is That?

95 More 96 Insistent 99 Bewildered 100

Them Then, Me Now

103

The Loss of Imagination

104

Lasting Tracks

107

What Happened To My Future?


226• Identity


108

Curator Of Her Days

111

Wonder At My Vanishing Point

112 Solitude 115

To Outlast

116

Slipping Away

119

Deep, Deep, Inside The Night

On Writing 120

Me, Then?

125

These Poems Are A Rememberance

126

‘Will You Remember Me?’

129

Inside We Are All Poets

130

A Moment of Intimate Relevance

133

What Kind Of Poem?

134

A Poet?

137

Just Like That!

138

On Lost Man Trail

141 Uninvited 142

His Words

145

Loyal Words


228• Identity


On Social Commentary 148

Standing In The Way

151

Saving The World

152

In Other Places

155 How? 156

Stolen Lives

159 Despair 160

A Wasted Life

163 Ashamed 164

It Waits

167

Human Black Holes

168

Oh, Oh, Oh, Kolkata!

171

Yes, There Is Evil

172 Forgiveness?! 175

What To Make Of It?

176

A Blessing

179

Moral Worth

180

‘Thank You……………….’


230• Identity


183

The Demand Of Personal Integrity

184

A Terrible Darkness

187

The Resistance –– The Pledge

188

The Dream Extinguished

191

America Is Dying

192

The Darkness Wouldn’t Leave

194 Resurrection On Time 201

Time Staring Back At Me

202

Time Is Watching

204

Not Recoverable

207

As Time Rushes Away

208

You Just Can’t Trust Time

211

You Can Feel Time

212

Time Doesn’t Recycle

215

Time Lost

216

A Time Traveler While Standing Still

218

Musings About Time


232• Identity


LOCATIONS OF INCLUDED PHOTOS Tahoe National Forest, CA Paris MoMA Gerald Peters Gallery, Santa Fe, NM Pecos River, NM East Fork/Jemez River, NM Las Conchas Trail, NM Preserve, Sacramento, CA Lagoon, Dubai, UAE Huntington Gardens, Pasadena, CA Nambe Falls, NM TNC Preserve, Santa Fe, NM San Francisco Bay, CA Brooklyn Botanical Gardens, NY Mill Pond, Bellmore, NY Pond, New Delhi, India Central Park Pond, NY Ellicott Creek, Amherst, NY


234• Identity


Leonora Curtin Preserve, Santa Fe, NM Golden Gate Park, San Francisco, CA Denver Botanical Gardens McCauley Hot Springs, Jemez Mountains, NM Taos, NM Roslyn, NY Nassau County Museum of Art Roslyn Harbor, NY Glen Park, Amherst, NY Inlet, Oceanside, NY Prospect Park, Brooklyn, NY Nedra Matteucci Gallery Pond, Santa Fe, NM The Nature Conservancy Preserve, Santa Fe, NM Preserve, LI Hudson River, NYC UC/Davis Botanical Gardens, CA Lago di Como, Italy Padua, Italy Tel Aviv, Israel St. James Park, London, England


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Standing in the Way by Arthur Goshin - Issuu