Food & Water
The ETF Perspective
Matt Hougan Editor Index Universe.com and ETFR
What’s an ETF?
An ETF is a mutual fund which trades on an exchange, just like a stock.
3
ETF Anatomy: Mutual Funds
Regulated by the SEC under the 1940 Act. Holds a pool of assets: stocks, bonds, futures, even gold. Built on sound corporate governance principles Board of Directors Compensated management Highly detailed recordkeeping and audit requirements
4
ETF Anatomy: Mutual Funds and Net Asset Value
Mutual funds work by taking the whole pie, and slicing it into equal shares. Each share has the same Net Asset Value (NAV). Traditional mutual funds allow investors to create or redeem shares after the market closes each day. Every dollar in gets invested, every dollar out is funded by asset sales. 5
ETF Anatomy: The Twist
ETFs track and hold a known and fully disclosed basket of stocks, usually an index. ETF shares trade directly on a stock exchange. Just like stocks, investors experience commissions and bid/ask spreads. Just like mutual funds, fund sponsors get paid a management fee.
6
ETF Anatomy: Creation/Redemption
New ETF shares are only created by large, institutional investors called Authorized Participants, or APs. New ETF shares are typically made in‐kind, with the AP delivering baskets of stocks. ETF shares are only redeemed for the whole basket of stocks.
No Cash. No Transaction Costs. Lower Taxes.
7
ETF Anatomy: Creation/Redemption $
$
Investor
Broker
ETF Shares
ETF Shares
Authorized Participant
Security Basket
Fund Sponsor
ETF Share Block (10k, 50k, 100k) 8
ETF Benefits Can be very low cost. Complete transparency Generally tax efficient Easily accessible Highly granular
9
WATER ETFS: AS WATER GAINS VALUE 10
A Small Pool: Water ETFs
12/31/08 11
Water ETFs: Big Variations
12/31/08 12
Water ETFs: Big Variations
13
Water ETFs: The Dollar
14
Water ETFs: The Dollar
12/31/08 15
Water ETFs: The Dollar
The international/domestic decision is driving short term returns … perhaps even more than water/not‐water.
The long term thesis of water investing suggests this could be a shorter term issue.
The short term likelihood of a strong dollar? Who knows… 16
Water ETFs: Big Variations
12/31/08 17
Water ETFs: PowerShares
Palisades Indexes Universe divided into sub‐sectors with chosen allocations (e.g. 25% Resources, 30% Utilities) Equal weights inside each sector – but, this can lead to some odd “equal” weights: 6.7% in Tetra Tech 1.3% in Aqua America
18
Water ETFs: Claymore
S&P Global Water Index Universe and weightings divided into two buckets with 25 stocks each Equipment & Materials Utilities & Resources
Traditional cap‐weighting then leads to big concentrations
25% in top 3 names 19
Water ETFs: Choosing The Right Fund?
First choose U.S. vs. international. Then choose concentrated vs. diverse. But don’t just choose “a” water fund.
20
FOOD ETFS: PIGS AND CORN? OR PICKS AND SHOVELS? 21
Food: The Big Question
22
Picks And Shovels: Leveraging Innovation
12/31/08
23
Other Equity Advantages Better Tax Treatment (In Some Cases) Simplicity (Easier to understand, easier to explain) 24
Tapping Ags: 2 Approaches
25
Food: The Big Question
26
Equity Downside Corporate Risk Higher Long‐Term Correlations To Equities
27
Considering Futures Low Correlation to Equities
28
Considering Futures Low Correlation to Equities Direct Food Price Exposure Income: Collateral Yield
29
Futures Downside Contango Tax Treatment Zero Innovation (It’s just stuff) 30
Contango??
31
Roll Yield??
32
Taming Contango Optimized Roll Yield “Continuous Commodity” Straight Index
33
Taming Contango
34
Ag‐Future ETFs and ETNs
35
A Note on Notes A Promise to Pay Pros: No Tracking Error Better tax treatment Con: It’s debt 36
Futures: Tough For Ags
37
Futures: Pockets of Strength
38