SPECIAL REPORT
Omni-Channel Commerce Solutions for Modern Enterprise Operations Order Management Systems: The Well-Kept Secret of Leaders in Digital Commerce Omni-Channel Commerce: The Future of Retail Omni-Channel Struggles: What’s Standing in the Way? Order Management 2.0: Unlocking Omni-Channel The Connected Store: Visualizing the Future of Commerce
Published by Global Business Media
Time for a better Order Management System Intershop’s order management system enables fully integrated omni-channel processing of incoming orders from many different sources. Intershop is e-commerce pioneer and market leader. We advise and support businesses in the digital transformation of their sales and transaction processes. On the basis of our leading commerce platform and established partner technologies we develop tailormade strategies and solutions driving the success of you and your business. www.intershop.com/order-management
ďƒ’
SPECIAL REPORT
Omni-Channel Commerce Solutions for Modern Enterprise Operations Order Management Systems: The Well-Kept Secret of Leaders in Digital Commerce
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
Contents
Omni-Channel Commerce: The Future of Retail Omni-Channel Struggles: What’s Standing in the Way? Order Management 2.0: Unlocking Omni-Channel The Connected Store: Visualizing the Future of Commerce
Foreword 2 Tom Cropper, Editor
Order Management Systems: 3 The Well-Kept Secret of Leaders in Digital Commerce Intershop Communications AG
The Wide-Ranging Strengths of Order Management Systems Published by Global Business Media
Published by Global Business Media Global Business Media Limited 62 The Street Ashtead Surrey KT21 1AT United Kingdom
Seven Key Features of an Order Management System Customer Case Study: Zamro
Omni-Channel Commerce: The Future of Retail
8
Tom Cropper, Editor
Switchboard: +44 (0)1737 850 939 Fax: +44 (0)1737 851 952 Email: info@globalbusinessmedia.org Website: www.globalbusinessmedia.org
The Omni-Channel Consumer
Publisher Kevin Bell
Omni-Channel Struggles: 10 What’s Standing in the Way?
Editor Tom Cropper Business Development Director Marie-Anne Brooks
Going Omni-Channel Surviving the Digital Age
Jo Roth, Staff Writer
Omni-Channel Struggles
Senior Project Manager Steve Banks
Data Protection
Advertising Executives Michael McCarthy Abigail Coombes
Order Management 2.0: Unlocking Omni-Channel 12
Production Manager Paul Davies
Order management 2.0
For further information visit: www.globalbusinessmedia.org
The Next Generation
The opinions and views expressed in the editorial content in this publication are those of the authors alone and do not necessarily represent the views of any organisation with which they may be associated. Material in advertisements and promotional features may be considered to represent the views of the advertisers and promoters. The views and opinions expressed in this publication do not necessarily express the views of the Publishers or the Editor. While every care has been taken in the preparation of this publication, neither the Publishers nor the Editor are responsible for such opinions and views or for any inaccuracies in the articles.
James Butler, Staff Writer
Building Functionality The Silent Partner
The Connected Store: 14 Visualizing the Future of Commerce Tom Cropper, Editor
Blended Platforms Enhancing the Online Experience Achieving Connected Retail
References 16
© 2018. The entire contents of this publication are protected by copyright. Full details are available from the Publishers. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owner. WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM | 1
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
Foreword
D
IGITAL TECHNOLOGY has transformed the
two articles demonstrate, retailers face a number
way we shop. It has given us more options,
of challenges.
created a host of new services and made us much
Jo Roth will list some of the obstacles which lie in
more demanding. Unsurprisingly, many retailers
the way. Updating from legacy systems, incorporating
are struggling to keep up.
new technology and satisfying the requirements
They know what they have to do. They must move from single channel, to multi-channel and finally to
of new data protection regulations all add to the complexity of tapping the omni-channel potential.
omni-channel in which consumers receive a smooth,
Existing systems are struggling to cope. As James
consistent, experience across all their different
Butler goes on to explain; if retailers want to unlock
platforms. Doing so is easier said than done.
all that potential, they will need to embrace the
The sticking point normally lies in the back office.
next generation of order management systems.
Selling in the new digital world means adapting
He will look at what these systems should do and
to a new and more modern approach to order
how a retailer can ensure a smooth transition.
management technologies, as our opening article
Finally, we’ll move into the future. Companies are
shows. Intershop Communications AG are one
using a host of exciting technologies such as virtual
of the leading providers of next generation order
reality and artificial intelligence to blend the online
management systems. They explain why some
and offline shopping experience. It is creating an
retailers find it so difficult to meet the challenges of
exciting new vision of the retail environment – one
the omni-channel market and how systems such as
which can benefit both retailers and their customers.
these can remove many of the roadblocks. We then look at the rise of omni-channel commerce. When done effectively, it can unlock enormous potential within the business, but as our next
Tom Cropper Editor
Tom Cropper has produced articles and reports on various aspects of global business over the past 15 years. He has also worked as a copywriter for some of the largest corporations in the world, including ING, KPMG, and Zurich Insurance.
2 | WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
Order Management Systems: The Well-Kept Secret of Leaders in Digital Commerce Intershop Communications AG
M
ANY B2C and B2B companies now face increasingly complex digital markets, with all the opportunities and challenges they present. On the one hand, digital sales processes offer more efficient access to customers and markets. On the other, companies have to connect an increasingly diverse range of sales channels using digital technologies. The result is a continuous increase in the complexity of business processes and IT structures. It is therefore no surprise that integrated, multi-channel order processes are becoming an increasingly hot topic for both B2C and B2B vendors. Many SMEs currently use a range of solutions to handle incoming orders. If they do not have a dedicated order management system (OMS), they typically use their e-commerce platform, their enterprise resource planning (ERP) system, or a custom-built solution. Unfortunately, these solutions are rarely able to cope with the increasing complexity generated by the growing number of channels that need to be integrated. E-commerce platforms, for example, can only deal with orders received online – i.e., not from brick-and-mortar stores – while ERP systems take a strictly business view of orders. So, the two systems have overlapping capabilities, but the only way to create uniform processes across all channels is through complex and costly modifications.
The Wide-Ranging Strengths of Order Management Systems Typically, people think an OMS is just a tool for capturing orders, processing them, and forwarding them to a warehouse location. In reality, they are capable of much more. Their key strength lies in the fact that they are specifically designed for multi-channel order processing, making them the ideal resource for digitally connecting the different channels. But that is not all.
A fully integrated OMS uses automation to process orders smoothly and efficiently. It collates all information on customers, orders, and warehouse inventories in a central resource that is visible to all users. This enables companies to make faster decisions and respond with greater flexibility to changing market conditions. In addition, an OMS provides a 360-degree view of each individual customer and all their orders – regardless of which channels were used. Serving as a central hub, it merges data and processes from multiple channels and offers additional specific and customer-oriented functionality that increases customer satisfaction across all channels. According to Forrester, order management products complement ERP systems by adding important functionality, such as consistent order capture across multiple channels and business units. They allow a reliable insight into order status, irrespective of which channel was used to capture the order. This provides the basis for optimum allocation of orders to the various fulfillment systems. The result: harmonious orchestration of the order execution process.a An order management system is the perfect complement to a typical ERP system. When the two are combined, the order management system serves as the central interface between a rapidly changing market place with diverse, customer-oriented applications on the one hand and established ERP-based business processes on the other. The question is not whether it is better to adapt an existing ERP system or to introduce an order management system. In order to increase agility in day-to-day operations without impacting your accounting and financial processes, you have to create an effective symbiosis of ERP and order management systems.
It is therefore no surprise that integrated, multichannel order processes are becoming an increasingly hot topic for both B2C and B2B vendors
WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM | 3
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
REGARDLESS OF THE WAY AN ORDER IS RECEIVED, YOU HAVE A COMPLETE OVERVIEW AT ALL TIMES
Serving as a central hub, it merges data and processes from multiple channels and offers additional specific and customeroriented functionality that increases customer satisfaction across all channels
Seven Key Features of an Order Management System 1. Connected channels: the key to an integrated multi-channel strategy As the borders between channels become increasingly blurred, companies are connecting what were once separate channels to create a single, consistent shopping experience. Instead of focusing on the locations where transactions are performed, businesses are now striving for a seamless customer experience across all available channels. For example, a customer can research a product online, order it on their cell phone, and pick it up from a high street store, which sends them a text when the item is ready for pick-up. After placing an order, the customer can check the order status from a phone, tablet, or any other Internet-enabled device and add the pickup date to their calendar. The key to successful multi-channel selling is the convergence of those channels and removal of the traditional barriers between them. This enables the vendor to focus on selling and a holistic view of the customer – regardless of the channel used. The greatest potential lies in cross-channel integration of order management processes and technologies. The ability to view all orders across all channels and to use all information collaboratively creates new scope for savings, synergies and, ultimately, increased revenue. 92% of companies surveyed have used an order management system to improve their cross-channel order capture processes; 81% have used cross-channel customer accounts to optimize their customer processes.b
4 | WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM
2. Meet demand across all channels and from any warehouse location Intelligent order management begins long before an order is even placed. First, the vendor has to create an inventory that matches the expected demand. It is essential that all local inventories at all locations are visible and accessible to all relevant users. Companies that are able to create a comprehensive inventory view, with stock at multiple locations being available as a shared resource across all channels, can fulfill orders from every channel and from any warehouse location, thereby reducing storage and distribution costs. Connecting all channels with the inventories at all locations provides the basis for cross-channel order management processes and supply chains. The end result is a seamless customer experience incorporating all available channels. 85% of companies surveyed have used an order management system to optimize their cross-channel inventory, thereby achieving long-term savings and improvements in business processes.c 3. One order, one customer: multiple systems and channels For order processes to be efficient, you need a consolidated view of each order. In many companies, however, these processes are spread over a number of separate systems. There is often a partial or complete lack of standardization in the processes used and consolidation of orders and data. With separate systems for the various channels and no (properly) integrated enterprise solutions in place, many companies are unable to manage orders in an efficient and effective way throughout the entire lifecycle.
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
Successful companies use a single order management system to combine all their order processes and integrate them with existing processes and systems. From order acceptance and approval through to billing, payment, and the management of shipments and returns, an OMS ensures that all processes mesh seamlessly and operate robustly, profitably, and harmoniously with all other participating systems. Intershop´s OMS is able to seamlessly integrate the specific business processes of the respective company, enabling a transparent and homogenous order management process that transcends system boundaries. 81% of companies surveyed have used an order management system to improve the efficiency of e-commerce processes.d 4. Automate, split and route Today’s customers expect to be able to buy products whenever, wherever, and however they want. This presents vendors with an enormous challenge and increases the complexity of the order and delivery processes. Successful order management strategies include order placement and routing rules that allow you to coordinate your available inventory with current demand. A sophisticated order management system is thus able to process each order item both as a separate entity and as part of an overall order. The ability to process individually each item makes it possible to optimize every order using automated rules and thus avoid the “all-or-nothing” conundrum for a multi-item order. Custom order routing rules provide the best strategy for processing and shipping orders in accordance with your own commercial considerations, available inventories, and the customer’s specific requirements. 77% of companies surveyed use an order management system to optimize their supply chain processes.e
5. Efficient payment processing through invoice-to-cash management Digitization and the continued rise of e-commerce are presenting new challenges for finance departments and driving long-term changes in payment and receivables management. New online payment methods necessitate new processes and partners, while traditional and online payment methods must be harmonized and combined with effective risk and credit check measures to create an optimized payment and receivables management system. The latest order management strategies are therefore embedded in efficient and transparent payment processes. All processes from billing to payment as well as risk/credit checks and the logging of incoming payments or receivables in the ERP or receivables management system must be implemented and managed with maximum efficiency as part of an all-inclusive order-tocash strategy. An order management system supports cross-system integration of order-to-cash processes through the automation of workflows and transformation of numerous processes within the organization. 6. Better customer service through order management systems The quality of your customer service can give you an important competitive edge in markets where price is just one of many factors that influence the purchase decision. Today’s customers expect a seamless shopping experience—from the time an order is placed through to a potential return. They want to be able to see all the information they need, whenever they want, and in whatever channel they choose. Meeting those demands for each individual customer is virtually impossible without an integrated view of all your customers and all their orders. Companies that have an integrated order management system can provide customers and service staff with transparent, structured, and multichannel access to all information – from purchase
As the borders between channels become increasingly blurred, companies are connecting what were once separate channels to create a single, consistent shopping experience
OMS ARRANGES COMPLEX OMNICHANNEL DELIVERY PROCESSES
WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM | 5
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
The ability to view all orders across all channels and to use all information collaboratively creates new scope for savings, synergies and, ultimately,
THE REASON FOR CONTACT IS AN IMPORTANT FACTOR WHEN SELECTING THE CHANNEL
history to contact details, current order status, and payments. These value-adding services are available to customers at all times. The order management system serves as the central “control room” for a powerful and deeply integrated service portal—a key hub for all the core processes in your digital customer service offering. 72% of customers surveyed would prefer a service portal with more self-service functions.f
increased revenue 7. Efficient return processes – for more profitable e-commerce The more quickly and efficiently a company can perform all the tasks involved in processing returns, the more satisfied the customer will be with the quality of service – which is a crucial element in long-term customer loyalty. The most important variables from the customer’s perspective are the simplicity of the processes in the channel of their choice, the speed with which refunds or credits are provided in the case of returns, and the ease with which incorrect or damaged goods are replaced or repaired. It is therefore essential to have a costefficient method of processing returns throughout your sales network, with seamless interaction between all relevant personnel and systems. There are various ways in which an order management system can be used to process returns efficiently. For example, it is an excellent tool for linking a return to a customer order and validating it in accordance with predefined rules or guidelines. As a central hub, the OMS can organize all processes involving the customer, the vendor, and the vendor’s sales network. 6 | WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM
76% of consumers view a vendor’s return policy before placing an order. 81% of consumers prefer vendors who have a simple return policy.g
Customer Case Study: Zamro Making the connection Zamro is among the companies that have opted to use the OMS as a link between their commerce platform and ERP system, says Thomas Bloemarts, the company’s logistics manager: “Zamro is an online shop that sells tools and spare parts and primarily targets SMEs that have technical requirements. At present, we already have a commerce platform, OMS, and an accounting package, and we are now busy selecting an ERP system.” Dropship suppliers Zamro launched in February 2016 as a subsidiary of the ERIKS group – an industrial service provider. The online shop went live in the Netherlands in October of the same year, followed by Belgium and Germany. “We started off selling ERIKS products, which allowed us to build on their logistics system, making our setup relatively simple with the online shop, OMS, and financial package,” explains Bloemarts. “But we now want to extend our range, which means we must link more suppliers to the system and support various capabilities and operational models. We will keep stock ourselves and use dropship suppliers, and we’ll need an ERP system for our purchasing and financial administration.”
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
Nimble and flexible The Intershop OMS is the linchpin in the new set-up, according to Bloemarts: “The system checks stock availability and sees to the order routing as well as all customer communications, such as order confirmation and order status. It’s the back-end system for order administration, which is where Customer Services goes whenever there are order queries. The OMS allows us a high degree of flexibility when it comes to linking suppliers and extending the functions. Because it’s independent of the front end, we can develop the OMS in parallel. For
example, we are presently working on refining and optimizing the business rules. It was also a strategic decision not to have everything run through the ERP system because that would have meant we were dependent on a single supplier. Moreover, ERP systems are generally not so nimble. The OMS allows us to be flexible.” Another advantage is that the system can easily be replicated for other countries: “Different countries have different tax rates, different e-mail formats, or different billing formalities,” adds Bloemarts. “With the OMS, we can easily adapt to each individual country.”
Successful companies use a single order management system to combine all their order processes and integrate them with existing processes and systems The quality of your customer service can give you an important competitive edge in markets where price is just one of many factors that influence the purchase decision
CUSTOMER CASE STUDY ZAMRO
References:
a Forrester Research, Inc: B2B Order Management Bridges The Gap Between B2B eCommerce And ERP b Intershop B2B Commerce Report 2016 c Intershop B2B Commerce Report 2016 d Intershop B2B Commerce Report 2016 d Intershop B2B Commerce Report 2016 e Forrester Research, Inc: The B2B Omni-Channel Commerce Platform of the Future f MetaPack: Delivering Consumer Choice Report 2015
WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM | 7
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
Omni-Channel Commerce: The Future of Retail Tom Cropper, Editor In a rapidly evolving retail environment, all eyes are turning to omni-channel commerce, but what is it and are retailers making the most of it?
T
More of us are shopping online, but that doesn’t mean we’re forsaking traditional channels. Indeed, we often move quickly between different channels within a single purchase
8 | WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM
HE RETAIL world is going digital and in this fast-paced, high-tech, environment it’s easier for customers to make purchases than ever before. No matter where they are or what time of day it is, people can get online to buy the goods they want and they are showing a remarkable willingness to do so, even on those days which were usually off limits. As reported in the Sun last year, one in five adults were planning to shop online on Christmas Day1.
The Omni-Channel Consumer There is all good news for us, as consumers. Never before have we had so many buying options. Gone are the days when we were constrained by what we could find in the shops. Now, we can just go home and log onto Google. More of us are shopping online, but that doesn’t mean we’re forsaking traditional channels. Indeed, we often move quickly between different channels within a single purchase. For example, I might see an item I like in the shop, but not make the decision to buy until I have gone home. I could then log onto their online store, order the item and collect it when I’m next in the shop. This is what retailers refer to when they are looking for a good omni-channel experience. This creates plenty of opportunities for retailers. Firstly, it’s a chance to increase the revenue they get from each customer. A survey from the Harvard Business Review finds that omnichannel consumers spend 4% more than those who use one channel at a time. The study notes that conversion rates are higher both on and offline2. All that movement across channels also creates more data which, in itself, is valuable. The more data a retailer has about a customer the easier it is to spot what they really want. It can potentially enable a retailer to spot what their customers want, even if they don’t know it at the time. For example, nobody was clamoring for the iPad until Steve Jobs made it available, because it didn’t yet exist. Jobs managed to identify something his customers wanted and develop a new product to fulfil it.
However, the challenge lies in capturing and analyzing that data. The omni-channel world is changing the way consumers work and making us all a lot harder to predict. In the past, retailers might have operated by placing consumers into groups in which they broadly follow similar buying patterns. However, traditional marketing demographics are becoming much less reliable. On the one hand the young are more likely to veer towards e-commerce. For example, a report into the buying behavior of different generations shows that Gen X (ages 35-54) shops online more than any other adult group, with 35 percent shopping online. They edge out 19-34 year-old millennial shoppers (30 percent), 55-74 year-old baby boomers (31 percent), and seniors over 75 (5 percent).3 However, most of them will generally use every different channel to make a purchase, which muddies the waters for marketing teams. For example, a pensioner who you might assume would prefer traditional retail for its familiarity, might equally choose online for its convenience. Someone else might spend months researching a product online before abandoning the process in the shopping cart at the last moment.
Going Omni-Channel We are all generating our own unique buyer profiles. To get the most out of us, retailers need to adopt a much more personalized strategy for each person. Traditional marketing strategies would have designed a user experience for each touchpoint in isolation. Omni-channel commerce takes a cohesive user experience that works across every single touchpoint – be it at a physical store location, via a website, or through a mobile phone app. This helps retailers design a more cohesive, unified and effective customer buying experience. Put simply, omni-channel commerce allows retailers to meet customers where they are buying and connect the dots between those different outlets. The aim is to keep customers moving within that network of touchpoints while always remaining
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
safely inside the brand ecosystem. So, if you’re a store selling a product such as a backpack, you’re happy for a customer in your store to go away and make a purchase online as long as they then do it with you. By doing so you can nurture improved sales and customer engagement. When managed effectively, this creates a positive feedback loop in which the retailer drives deeper and deeper engagement with the customer. It increases revenue per person, improves conversion rates, optimizes stocking levels and increases brand loyalty.
Surviving the Digital Age Most of all, though, omni-channel commerce is the key to surviving the digital age. That’s because the prospects for the future depend on how agile and connected a retailer is to cater to a multi-channel commercial world. The press is often predicting the death of retail. Data suggests that 2018 could be the worst year in a decade for retail store closures. The report from the Centre for Retail Research argued that the current business model for traditional retail is flawed and that this, combined with the growth of online retail, would see 20% of all retail stores close over the course of the year4. Research from the British Retailers Association (BIRA) says more than 1,500 stores shut their
doors in 2017, the equivalent of three high street outlets every day5. The report’s authors argued that a combination of declining footfall and expensive business rates were forcing retailers out of business. However, retail isn’t dead. The business is just evolving. Data from e-Marketer shows retail growing at between five and six percent per year. By 2020, total Worldwide retail sales could be nearing $28bn6. The challenge for retailers is that those purchases are no longer confined within one single location – they are spread across multiple channels. The future, therefore, is either one of positive growth or decline and demise. The difference between the two will depend on a retailer’s ability to adapt to change. To survive they must adopt a comprehensive, connected, cohesive strategy, which enables them to cater to customers wherever they are. The rewards can be enormous. E-Commerce can transform a business – enabling even a small independent retailer to expand its reach beyond its local community - but it’s not an easy goal to achieve. The focus will revolve towards order management systems. Maintaining comprehensive visibility over the customer ecosystem will be crucial to delivering a successful omni-channel strategy for the future.
The challenge for retailers is that those purchases are no longer confined within one single location – they are spread across multiple channels
E-Commerce can transform a business – enabling even a small independent retailer to expand its reach beyond its local community – but it’s not an easy goal to achieve
WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM | 9
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
Omni-Channel Struggles: What’s Standing in the Way? Jo Roth, Staff Writer Multichannel is dead – long live omni-channel. Retailers are scrambling to update their processes to cater to the more lucrative omni-channel customer, but many things stand in the way.
O
The bottleneck lies not with the willingness to embrace the benefits of omni-channel but in a lack of confidence about their ability to do so
MNI-CHANNEL IS the future. Retailers have been reading this a lot recently. To cope with a fast-paced digital marketplace, they must be agile and develop a collection of omni-channel strategies to satisfy a more demanding customer. Success will drive their business forward in many ways, but if that’s the case, why do so many omni-channel strategies fail? Why do so many retailers who pursue omni-channel not see the predicted return in their bottom lines and why do most consumers believe retailers are not delivering the seamless marketing experience they expect? The answer, predictably, is because they are not doing it correctly. Research from Rockpool found that 80% of customers believe that retailers are failing to link up on and offline visits7. When L2 published their annual benchmarking study into omni-channel, they found that, while most retailers thought they were heading in the right direction, very few were truly offering a seamless experience across all their channels. Only five of the 92 brands they surveyed offered a smooth path between their on and offline operations – something which would be key for an effective omni-channel strategy8. For an example of what can happen when things go wrong, read Greg Sterling’s account of his problems with the retail giant Target9. He wanted a running machine and found one on the store’s eBay shop. However, it was $1,000 cheaper than the one they had in the store. There were problems with delivery and, in the end, they withdrew it from stock. It’s a prime example of omni-channel marketing done badly. The eBay store, e-commerce option, delivery team and physical stores were not communicating and, as a result, they let a customer down so badly that he wrote about it in a magazine.
Omni-Channel Struggles So, what’s the problem? Most retailers understand the importance of omni-channel, but not all of 10 | WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM
them are set up to deliver. A study from Periscope found that 78% of retailers said they lacked a single brand experience across all their channels. However around 64% rated it as a top priority for driving digital growth10. The bottleneck lies not with the willingness to embrace the benefits of omni-channel but in a lack of confidence about their ability to do so. Traditional Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) systems are being stretched up to and beyond their capacity. Many are old and designed for a pre-omni-channel world. Data is segmented, providing only a limited vision of stock and inventory and cannot streamline the administrative process into one section. Often the company has grown through mergers, adding new systems onto one another. Sometimes they have tried to cope with existing systems, stretching them as far as possible or adding new capabilities and systems as and when they need to. The result is a complex and cumbersome system which is almost impossible to untangle.
Data Protection That’s a particular problem now thanks to the arrival of Europe’s General Data Protection (GDPR) Act. This is the biggest change to data protection regulations ever. It includes much tighter rules surrounding how data can be gathered, shared and stored and much tougher penalties. Under GDPR, a serious data breach could leave a retailer liable to a fine of e20million or 4% of turnover. These are serious figures and will be enough to deter many organizations. The pub chain JD Weatherspoons, for example, decided to delete its entire customer email database and cease email newsletters rather than deal with the struggle of managing GDPR compliance11. Instead, its updates are now announced over social media. Complying with GDPR involves a lot of work, upheaval and cost. All that valuable data
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
retailers have been building up over the years – email contacts, forms, CCTV, customer enquiries and payment histories – must be accounted for. Unsurprisingly, some will decide it is not worth the effort or the risk. They will scale back their operations and reduce the amount of data they use. However, data is increasingly important to retailers especially with the rise of omnichannel commerce. Data is its backbone – it enables retailers to deliver seamless end-toend customer experience across its multiple channels. This is a trend which is happening whether retailers want it or not. Those who do not join in will be left behind. GDPR, then, is something they will have to get to grips with. Retailers must understand the requirements of GDPR and how they can stay the right side of the regulations. Most of all they will need to have good access, transparency and control of the data they do hold. They will need to know what they have, what layers of consent each piece of data complies with and to be able to access
that data quickly when required by customers and regulators. These challenges explain why the majority of retailers still struggle to deliver omni-channel. However, they are challenges which need to be overcome. Omni-channel is not just something a retailer might like to have, it’s something that customers expect to be there already. We assume retailers will be able to deliver that smooth pathway between on and offline operations. Those who do not will see their customers jump ship to those that do. The question is not ‘if’ omni-channel is the right move, but ‘how’ a retailer can make it work. It’s a case of adapt or die – sink or swim. Retailers see both push and pull factors. On the one hand they are being pulled by the prospects of increased revenue and greater customer insights, and on the other they are being pushed by their customers who demand it and their competitors who are already doing it. The risks and challenges should not be under estimated but, to survive in the digital age, retailers will have to overcome them.
Complying with GDPR involves a lot of work, upheaval and cost. All that valuable data retailers have been building up over the years – email contacts, forms, CCTV, customer enquiries and payment histories – must be accounted for
Data is increasingly important to retailers especially with the rise of omni-channel commerce. Data is its backbone – it enables retailers to deliver seamless endto-end customer experience across its multiple channels
WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM | 11
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
Order Management 2.0: Unlocking Omni-Channel James Butler, Staff writer As customers move into the omni-channel realm, they are forcing retailers to shift towards the next generation of order management technology.
W
E LIVE in the world of the omni-channel consumers – people who are willing to blend new technology with old to get the shopping experience they want. Fulfilling those expectations will require a new outlook, fresh thinking and, most of all, new order management technology.
The age of digital commerce created demand for order management systems which were ready for the online, multi-channel age. Companies needed to view order status, make queries and provide information to customers in real-time
12 | WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM
Order management 2.0 Many existing systems were designed for a bygone age. They are slow, expensive, cumbersome and they do not reveal the entire picture. They offer a basic range of functions to help retailers process their orders. But what they lack is flexibility, automation and the ability to visualize complete customer data from multiple channels. The arrival of the internet exposed the limitations of conventional ERP systems. The age of digital commerce created demand for order management systems which were ready for the online, multi-channel age. Companies needed to view order status, make queries and provide information to customers in real-time. The new age is even more complicated. The move into the digital omni-channel age requires the bringing together of data and orders from multiple locations. Distributed order management enables orders to be fulfilled from multiple warehouse locations, improve stock management and build links between on and offline operations. For this, organizations need total enterprise inventory visibility. They need to know what stock they have available at each location, they need to know what orders have been placed by customers via different channels and what they are expecting to see. The requirements are sizeable and, in many cases, will require radical new thinking. Beate Schiler of SVP Business Consulting Services at Intershop underlines the issue when she states: “Order management is no longer the key issue—it’s all about orchestration. There is so much more to consider than simply forwarding orders to an ERP system. Nowadays, it’s important to orchestrate orders in a holistic
way with regard to channels, CRM, ERP, and other customer-oriented applications. That is a crucial requirement for a successful e-commerce strategy12.”
Building Functionality Not every retailer will have this functionality and that creates both a problem and an opportunity. It’s a problem because meeting customer expectations in the omni-channel world is increasingly difficult but it’s an opportunity because those which do will secure a key competitive advantage. This is why attention is swinging towards a new generation of order management technologies. MarketsandMarkets predicts the Global order management market to grow at more than 10.4% a year up to 2022 from $1.96bn to $3.22bn. The report suggests growth will be driven by a high demand for automated handling of the order process, and for features which track the entire order lifecycle13. There are solutions available which can deliver this level of functionality. However, these will inevitably involve a significant upheaval. Making the transition runs into obstacles of existing legacy systems, costs and the risk that the new technology will not be effective. There may be many issues to address. A system might have been in place for many years. It will have failed to keep up with market developments, may be slow, inefficient and expensive to run and not offer the functionality retailers need in the modern business environment. Organizations can also suffer from ‘legacy thinking’ – a system has served well for years so why change it? Over time, systems may have been adapted to meet specific requirements or market needs. With each new channel, new layers of functionality are placed over the top. This is costly and time consuming and can create confusion within the business.
The Next Generation An alternative lies in creating a solution which works alongside legacy systems and amalgamates all the data from each app
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
into a single platform. This is what the latest generation of products such as Intershop’s Order Management platform seek to do. It sits between all the different applications acting as a conduit between them. This gives users a single source enabling retailers to analyze all the information from their ERP, online shops, warehouses, stores, PSP and any other resources in one place. They can track stock levels, analyze transactions and deliver a more tailored service to their customers. Because data is transparent and available in realtime, staff can provide the same level of service to customers, no matter what channel they are coming through. Stock management becomes easier and more flexible. Retailers can use their inventory as a common resource. If demand is lower in one channel, inventory can be made available to meet excessive requirements in another. The platform provides a real-time view of stock levels in all locations allowing retailers to optimize stocking levels and commit to deliveries immediately.
The Silent Partner Perhaps the most appealing gain, though, is the fact that, when running well, this system should barely be noticed. It is designed to break down barriers, to smooth administration and increase the efficiency of the entire e-commerce process. By doing so, it increases data visibility and reduces operating costs. Last, but not least, the latest systems such as these deliver the flexibility and visibility of data to comply with new regulations such as GDPR and to protect customer data against an ever more sophisticated and complex cyber threat. This, then, is the ideal vision of the omni-channel future. It’s one which can unlock a fluid and realtime flow of data and enable retailers to deliver a seamless customer experience across all of its many different channels. It is secure, efficient and reduces the risk of administrative error and operational costs. While, not unnaturally, retailers be concerned about the upfront purchase cost, omni-channel systems offer the valuable prospect of saving money at one end and increasing revenue at the other. Getting it right is a challenge, but the rewards are worth the effort.
An alternative lies in creating a solution which works alongside legacy systems and amalgamates all the data from each app into a single platform
Over time, systems may have been adapted to meet specific requirements or market needs. With each new channel, new layers of functionality are placed over the top
WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM | 13
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
The Connected Store: Visualizing the Future of Commerce Tom Cropper, Editor Bricks and mortar stores don’t need to be in opposition. In the future they can work in harmony to the benefit of everyone.
T
While some have turned their eyes away from the highstreets to focus on their online operations, the most successful operators will be those who blend the on and offline worlds
14 | WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM
HEY’RE THE bug bear of many store owners: shoppers who use stores as show rooms – a chance to see an item, try it on and then go away to find it cheaper on Amazon. For many retailers, this is the biggest challenge they face and it’s one reason that stores are going out of business in such high numbers. However, that doesn’t have to be the case. Yes, e-commerce has transformed retail, and yes many of those changes have created challenges for traditional stores, but the traditional shop is far from dead. Indeed, with the smart integration of technology it could be the key to the future.
Blended Platforms While some have turned their eyes away from the highstreets to focus on their online operations, the most successful operators will be those who blend the on and offline worlds. The good news is that they have a host of exciting developments which will allow them to do just that. Technologies such as artificial intelligence, virtual and augmented reality can link a retailer’s physical store with its online operations. One example of where this can work could be the use of smart changing rooms in clothing stores. For example, Ralph Lauren’s Polo flagship store on Fifth Avenue in New York uses what it calls ‘smart fitting rooms’. These are equipped with interactive mirrors which can change the lighting to show how an outfit might work in different environments; recommend other accessories to go with the outfit and, if the customer is not ready to decide, can send all this information to their mobile phone. This is designed to increase revenue per customer and overcome some of those obstacles which prevent customers from making a purchase and, according to representatives of Ralph Lauren, it is working well. They say the technology has seen sales rise three-fold and increased the amount of time customers spend in the store14.
Technology such as this helps physical stores harness some of the internet’s flexibility. It can widen the selection of products beyond those which are already in the store and avoid lost sales through customers not being able to find the perfect color, size or style they are looking for.
Enhancing the Online Experience At the same time, AR and VR are being used to improve the at-home online customer experience. For example, the furniture retailer IKEA harnessed the power of AR to create a virtual showroom. Using a mobile app, IKEA Place, customers can superimpose an image of a piece of furniture in their room allowing them to see how it would look in its place15. The idea is to use realistic rendering of a product in-situ to help customers make a more reliable buying decision. Meanwhile, in their stores, IKEA is using VR to create virtual showrooms16. Customers browsing the store can use the headsets provided to see how a product might look in a room. These technologies blend the in-situ and online buying environments and, in doing so, they harness the benefits of both. Retail outlets such as IKEA have always struggled to make the most of e-commerce because people prefer to travel to the stores and see the item before they buy it. They regard digital technology as being crucial in opening up a new online marketplace. Similarly, most people who buy clothing prefer to do so in store. They want to touch, feel and try on an item before they make a purchase, which is why Oasis has fused its e-commerce platforms, mobile apps and high street stores into a single overall system. If a customer enters one of their stores, he or she will be greeted by a member of staff armed with an iPad17. These can be used as mobile cash registers, which means they can process the sale from anywhere in the store. If customers can’t find what they are looking for in the store at that moment, or would like
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
something in a slightly different color, they can order the item then and there and have it shipped directly to their home.
Achieving Connected Retail The growing mobility and flexibility of our shopping experiences will mean one thing: the amount of data retailers collect about their customers will increase in volume and complexity. It will come from multiple sources such as social media, online, in-store and through mobile apps. Storing this data safely and securely represents an enormous technical and logistical challenge for businesses. At the same time, delivering a truly omnichannel commercial experience will require all the information from customers to be brought into a central repository from which actions can be taken. So, if someone has been making purchases online, staff can see this in the store and provide a more personalized service.
The future will be a world in which the user experience becomes unique to every individual. Technologies such as artificial intelligence will enable retailers to increase dramatically the oversight they have over the process and deepen their engagement with each customer. Many retailers currently lack the infrastructure required to handle such an operation. A large number of smaller and medium sized businesses will see this as an opportunity they cannot take advantage of. However, as the technology evolves and becomes more affordable, omnichannel commerce will be open to more and more companies. Those which harness omnichannel effectively will be able to deliver more personalized services, more quickly to customers at a reduced cost. They will increase the revenue gained per customer and feed those gains back into the rest of the business. Those who do not will find themselves falling behind at every step of the way.
If customers can’t find what they are looking for in the store at that moment, or would like something in a slightly different color, they can order the item then and there and have it shipped directly to their home
The future will be a world in which the user experience becomes unique to every individual. Technologies such as artificial intelligence will enable retailers to increase dramatically the oversight they have over the process and deepen their engagement with each customer
WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM | 15
OMNI-CHANNEL COMMERCE SOLUTIONS FOR MODERN ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS
References: Brits Expected to Splash £1bn on Christmas Day: https://www.thesun.co.uk/money/5157123/brits-1billion-christmas-online-shopping/
1
2
Here’s Why Omni-Channel Consumers are More Valuable: https://hbr.org/2017/01/a-study-of-46000-shoppers-shows-that-omnichannel-retailing-works
3
The E-Commerce Ecosystem: The State of Cross-Device Digital Shopping:
http://research.vertoanalytics.com/the-e-commerce-ecosystem-the-state-of-cross-device-digital-shopping 4
2018 UK Store Closures Worst for a Decade: http://www.retail-systems.com/rs/CRR_Retail_At_Bay_Report_2018.php
5
High Street in Crisis. Another 1,500 Stores Close: https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/952659/High-street-shops-closing-figures-report
6
Total Retail Sales Worldwide: http://www.emarketer.com/Chart/Total-Retail-Sales-Worldwide-2015-2020-trillions-change/194243
7
Retailers Failing Badly at Omni-channel Experience: https://www.decisionmarketing.co.uk/news/retailers-failing-badly-at-omnichannel-experience
8
Why Most Retailers Fail at Omni-Channel: https://www.l2inc.com/daily-insights/why-most-retailers-fail-at-omnichannel
9
Omni-channel to Omni-fail: https://marketingland.com/opposite-omni-channel-targets-last-mile-e-commerce-customer-service-failure-112164
10
Retailers Know they Are Not Delivering Omni-channel:
https://www.realwire.com/releases/Periscope-Research-Shows-Retailers-Know-They-Are-Not-Delivering-Omnichannel 11
JD Weatherspoons Deleted its Entire Email Database: http://www.wired.co.uk/article/wetherspoons-email-database-gdpr
12
Order Management Systems: The Key to Successful Order Management in Digital Commerce: http://bit.ly/2KwdPCu
13
Telecom Order Management Market Worth 3.22bn USD by 2022: https://www.marketsandmarkets.com/PressReleases/telecom-order-management.asp
14
Inside Ralph Lauren’s Fitting Rooms: https://digiday.com/marketing/retailtech2016-inside-ralph-laurens-connected-fitting-rooms/
15
How IKEA is Using Augmented Reality: https://digiday.com/marketing/ikea-using-augmented-reality/
16
Ikea is Making it Easier to Shop with Virtual Reality: https://www.realsimple.com/home-organizing/decorating/ikea-virtual-reality
17
Oasis Fashions Shopping Revolution with iPads: https://www.express.co.uk/finance/city/279186/Oasis-fashions-iPad-shopping-revolution
16 | WWW.CEOREPORTS.COM
CEOs Find Solutions To Their Business Challenges With CEO Reports
For the past decade, CEO Reports has been helping CEOs and their management teams to find new solutions to their commercial, technical and operational challenges. Our Special Reports provide readers with an unparalleled depth of information on specialist subjects, which receive limited coverage in the mainstream business media. Each report is designed to help CEOs to make more effective business decisions, by providing a unique mix of: • Subject specific technical information • Insight and knowledge from internationally recognised key opinion leaders • Independent data and analysis • Unbiased editorial content
subscriptions@globalbusinessmedia.org www.globalbusinessmedia.org