7 minute read
COLES APPLICATION IN QUESTION
THE controversial plans for a new major retail precinct on industrial zoned land on the outskirts of Beerwah could be dead in the water, according to a report going before the next Sunshine Coast Council meeting this Thursday, July 22.
The Coles Group Property Developments Pty Ltd lodged three development applications in 2019 to pave the way for an 11ha homemaker centre at the intersection of Roys Road and Steve Irwin Way in Beerwah.
The proposal was for a Coles supermarket, showroom, petrol station and McDonalds to be built fi rst, with plans for an extensive retail complex sometime down the track.
But the council’s principal development planner is recommending that councillors reject the plans at the July 22 ordinary meeting, citing numerous major confl icts with the planning scheme and inconsistencies with council’s vision for Beerwah’s future commercial growth.
Issues involving the contentious proposal have been extensively reported in the GC&M News for the past two years, with community opinion divided on its merits.
Although the three applications attracted only 50 formal submissions to council (ten for the development and 40 opposing), social media posts on the GC&M News Facebook page attracted thousands of interactions, with hundreds of comments.
Many said they were in favour of the development as they wanted to see a Coles supermarket or a McDonalds in Beerwah, while others pointing out that although Coles is a good idea the site chosen was problematic as it would create signifi cant traff ic congestion and is not near or connected to public transport.
Some commented that the jobs were needed in the area while others said jobs would be lost due to trade being taken from existing businesses.
Long-term local and successful businesswoman Joan Tucker has been following the issue from the start and has been vocal in her opposition to the proposal.
“I am relieved to hear that the recommendation of council off icers is that all three applications be refused,” Ms Tucker said.
“With the current and projected residential growth in the region, a Coles supermarket would be as asset to the community. However, it should be established in the existing town centre. It would be the ruination of Beerwah to split the town’s retail precinct, with a fl ow-on impact in our other regional townships.
“The Roys Road site should retain its industrial zoning to accommodate future industry thereby keeping heavy vehicle movements in the one area.
“This has been an anxious wait for many small family businesses, so a big thank you to the off icers for considering their concerns and making this recommendation,” she said.
When formally assessing these applications, the council addresses what is proposed – which in this case was very complicated – against what the planning scheme (and other planning documents) say are suitable uses for the location.
If the proposed development isn’t a perfect match for the location, councillors can suggest options (called conditions) that they feel would improve the outcome for the locality and for the community. They accept some digression from the planning scheme if the community good signifi cantly outweighs the negatives.
In this case, council off icers found that the volume and scope of inconsistencies from the planning scheme were so major that they could not see past these failings and approve the applications.
“All three development applications do not comply with, nor can they be conditioned to comply with, the assessment benchmarks contained within the Sunshine Coast Planning Scheme,” the report from the council off icers stated.
“There are no other relevant matters applicable to the application, including the existence of planning, economic or community need, that justify approving any of the applications despite the noncompliances described in this report.”
The main points that led the council development assessment team to recommend refusal include: • Signifi cant confl ict with the council’s strategic vision for economic development regarding activity centres and industry and enterprise areas. • The proposal would create a new retail centre outside the existing Beerwah major regional activity centre and would fragment and undermine the CBD. • Due to its size, scale and intended function, the proposed McDonalds would represent an unwarranted intrusion of a business activity into an area identifi ed specifi cally for industrial developments.
������������� BA (Psy) (Hons) Registered Psychologist (AHPRA) �����������������������������
4A/21 Peachester Road, Beerwah 0407 613 099
> Interior Blinds & Shutters > Outdoor Blinds & Awnings > Roll out Caravan Awnings & Annexes > Boat & 4WD Canopies > Vehicle Interiors > Furniture Upholstery
Carolyn Williams Lember & Williams Solicitors
����������� 13 Bunya Street, Maleny Q 4552 ��������������� 7 Annie Street, Caboolture Q 4510 �����������������5495 1499
David Zimmermann Mark Hall Shreeragh Sagar
Dentistry you can trust Creating Healthy Smiles since 1995
Medicare Child Dental Benefits welcome 20 Karanne Drive Mooloolah (next to medical centre) 5494 7011 www.mooloolahdental.com
• The size, scale and design of the proposed development would result in signifi cant loss of industry zoned land (more than 11ha). • The proposed road works on Roys Road are insuff icient and inappropriate. • The development does not provide for a transport network that achieves a high level of connectivity to surrounding areas and is defi cient in areas such as links to public transport, eff ective walkability or links for passive transport. • The proposal does not protect, rehabilitate and enhance ecologically important areas, nor does it protect and establish appropriate buff ers to waterways and native vegetation. • The development would not facilitate the achievement of ecological sustainability in that it fails to maintain the cultural, economic, physical and social wellbeing of people and communities.
The council off icers also relied on an external expert to review the economic details and data submitted by the developer.
Although the developer painted a rosy economic forecast, the independent expert was at odds with this, with these fi ndings disputing many of those presented by the developer.
The expert concluded that the economic fi gures don’t stack up, showing that there might be a need for a third full-line supermarket in the future, “perhaps by around the 2025 to 2030 period”.
Considering this economic advice, the council planning assessors concluded that the application was premature, with the proposal negatively impacting on the Beerwah commercial centre, stating that there was “no demonstrated need for an additional full-line supermarket and homemaker centre that would justify [the] impacts on [the] Beerwah activity centre and loss of industry zoned land.”
The council off icers haven’t said that at some time in the future a new Coles, petrol station, McDonalds and other retail outlets wouldn’t be good for Beerwah and the broader region, just that this particular time and location aren’t suitable or feasible and that it would detract from the long-term vision and character of Beerwah.
For the applications to be refused, six of the 11 councillors would need to vote in favour of the report recommendations at this Thursday’s meeting.
THE expansion of the Beerwah Marketplace and Village shopping precinct (where Woolworths, Fresh & Save and KHub are located) has been given the green light by Council.
Village Fair Investments Pty Ltd (VFI) lodged an application with the Sunshine Coast Council in September, 2020 for an additional 3,059m2 of retail space adjoining their existing shopping centres on Peachester Road in the Beerwah CBD.
Along with the over 3,000m2 retail space, there will be an additional 118 car parks (above shops), bringing the total for the whole complex to 574.
VFI managing director Rick Abrahams said his company believes Beerwah is continuing to develop as a major activity centre for the southern Sunshine Coast hinterland, and his company is excited to continue to invest in Beerwah’s future.
“We have worked to deliver a planning outcome designed to keep Beerwah’s retail hub intact and within walking distance to the central Beerwah population,” Mr Abrahams said.
“With Council’s focus on a walkable retail precinct with community safety at the forefront, the new development will see the existing Lodge Lane entry signifi cantly upgraded.” School
Fresh n Save
Other upgrades will include CCTV cameras, public art, landscaping and public seating.
Village Fair Investments purchased the Beerwah Marketplace Shopping Centre during construction in 2002 and acquired adjoining properties in 2006 and 2019.
They have a vision for the development of a fully integrated shopping experience for the Beerwah and Glasshouse Country townships which they plan to implement as soon as a tenant for the new development is secured.
Need help with your mortgage?
Buying a new home or looking to refinance? Take advantage of our knowledge, mortgage expertise and personal service to save yourself time and money.
New home loans Debt consolidation Investment loans Asset finance
Want a free, no obligation assessment? Lets talk!
Smartline Beerwah & Woodford
p 07 5422 9458 w smartline.com.au/tharrison
