C A N A D A’ S I N S U R A N C E A N D R I S K M A G A Z I N E . C A N A D I A N U N D E R W R I T E R . C A
M AY 2 0 1 5 PM40069240
Driving Forward BY ANGELA STELMAKOWICH
Faulty No-Fault BY WILLIE HANDLER
On Trend BY GREG HORN
Stolen laptop. Malicious Code. Hacked network.
The types of privacy breaches are evolving. Your business insurance should too. Intact Insurance Company’s new cyber endorsement provides first-party coverage for privacy breaches. In the event of a breach, we provide resources, access to tools and support to help customers get back. • • • •
Policy limit of $25,000* to spend on related remediation costs No questionnaire or form is required Introductory fee of $96 per year Access to information and services provided by IDT911, an independent service provider
At Intact Insurance, we make protecting your business our priority. Contact your Broker from more information about Cyber Endorsement.
*Per claim and in the aggregate. Certain conditions, limitations and exclusions apply. The information that appears on this advertisement is provided to you for information purposes only. Your insurance contract prevails at all times. Please consult it for a complete description of coverage and exclusions. Non-insurance services are provided by IDT911, Inc., an independent third party. These services provided do not constitute legal advice. If you require legal advice, please consult a lawyer. Intact Financial Corporation and its affiliates assume no responsibility for making the services available to you or for your use of the services. The BIP logo is a registered trademark of the Insurance Brokers Association of Canada (IBAC). All other trademarks are property of Intact Financial Corporation used under license. © 2015, Intact Insurance Company.
M AY 20 1 5
M40069240
CANADIAN UNDERWRITER
VOL. 82, NO. 5, May 2015 Canada’s Insurance and Risk Magazine. Published by newcom business media inc.
www.canadianunderwriter.ca
Cover Story
Driving Forward
34
Fuelled by the promise of securing consumer loyalty and gaining competitive advantage, telematics offerings from traditional and non-traditional players in the property and casualty space could help position their companies in the future. But will regulatory requirements stall out the possibilities? By Angela Stelmakowich
features
14
44
By Willie Handler
24
48 Cyber Preparedness
Vehicle buyers in Canada favour compacts. Preferences related to model year and vehicle size can have a big impact on claims cost, loss rate and alternate parts use.
A new report by the Insurance Institute of Canada takes a broad look at cyber risk and suggests how Canadian p&c insurance organizations can bolster their own cyber security.
By Greg Horn
Ontario’s No-Fault Journey VIN Cloning Ontario’s auto insurance system should have private insurers providing coverage while a Crown corporation takes on the task of delivering accident benefits.
20 Collision Claim Trends
Some consumers who buy 28 Replacement vehicles with cloned VINs do Insurance not realize that these vehicles Quebec’s insurance industry could be stolen or declared has received a crystal-clear BY ANGELA STELMAKOWICH irreparable, often leaving message from the regulator their insurers on the hook. that non-compliance with Faulty No-Fault By Greg Meckbach BY WILLIE HANDLERreplacement insurance rules will not be tolerated.
Driving Forward
50
On Trend
By Vincent GaudreaU
BY GREG HORN
By Peter Hohman
54 Distracted Driving Technology offers great promise, but the reliance that people now have on their phones has had the unfortunate effect of contributing to distracted driving. Can apps help? By Ted Hellard & Paul Mlodzik
30 D&O Liability
Ethics: Difficult Claimants
Repair Sustainability
When a claimant is being unreasonable, demanding too much, what should a claims adjuster do to ensure he or she advances a fair settlement?
A clear commitment to using sustainable practices is something that insurers are currently looking for in their collision repair partners.
By The CIP Society
By Rocco Neglia
Directors and officers at Canada’s publicly listed firms are facing personal liability as a result of unfolding securities, environmental and cyber trends. By Cameron Rose
May 2015 Canadian Underwriter
3
we have it covered. VOL. 81, NO. 2, FEBRUARY 2014
Canadian Underwriter’s Insurance Media Group is committed
VOL. 81, NO. 2, FEBRUARY 2014 VOL. 81, NO. 2, FEBRUARY 2014 PROFILE
to providing the most timely and relevant news, information
VOL. 82, NO. 5, May 2015 PROFILE PROFILE profile
Editor Senior Publisher Angela Stelmakowich Steve Wilson and resources from all segments of Editorto insurance professionalsSenior Publisher astelmakowich@canadianunderwriter.ca steve@canadianunderwriter.ca Editor Stelmakowich Senior Wilson Publisher Angela Steve Editor Senior@InsuranceMedia Publisher (416) 510-6793 the industry, providing marketers with aTwitter: range of specialized Angela Stelmakowich Steve Wilson Angela Stelmakowich astelmakowich@canadianunderwriter.ca steve@canadianunderwriter.ca Steve Wilson (416) 510-6800 astelmakowich@canadianunderwriter.ca steve@canadianunderwriter.ca astelmakowich@canadianunderwriter.ca (416) 510-6793 Twitter: @InsuranceMedia Associate Editor steve@canadianunderwriter.ca and highly effective marketing communications opportunities. (416) (416)510-6793 510-6793 Twitter: @InsuranceMedia (416) 510-6800 Greg Meckbach Twitter: @InsuranceMedia Art Director Associate Editor (416) Associate Editor (416)510-6800 510-6800 gmeckbach@canadianunderwriter.ca Gerald Heydens Associate Editor Greg Meckbach Art Director Greg Meckbach Twitter: @CU_Greg Art Director Greg Meckbach Art Consultation Director gmeckbach@canadianunderwriter.ca Gerald Heydens Art gmeckbach@canadianunderwriter.ca Gerald Heydens Heydens (416) 510-6796 gmeckbach@canadianunderwriter.ca Gerald Twitter: @CU_Greg Twitter: @CU_Greg Sascha Hass ArtArt Consultation Consultation Twitter: @CU_Greg (416) 510-6796 (416) 510-6796 Online Editor ArtInsurance Consultation Sascha Hass Sascha Hass Canadian Underwriter’s Media Group is committed Production Manager (416) Editor 510-6796 Harmeet Singh Online Sascha Hass Online Editor Gary White to providing the most timely and relevant Production Manager news, information Jason Contant hsingh@canadianunderwriter.ca Production Manager Online Editor Harmeet Singh Gary WhiteManager (416) 510-6760 jcontant@canadianunderwriter.ca and resources to insurance professionals from all segments of Production Twitter: @CU_Harmeet Gary White Harmeet Singh (416) 510-6760 hsingh@canadianunderwriter.ca (416) 442-5600, Ext. 3652 Gary Whitewith a rangeService (416) 442-5600 ext. 3652 the industry, providing marketers of specialized (416) 510-6760 Subscriptions/Customer National hsingh@canadianunderwriter.ca Twitter: Subscriptions/Customer Service Associate@CU_Harmeet Publisher (416) 510-6760 Gail Page and highly effective marketing communications opportunities. Twitter: @CU_Harmeet (416) 442-5600 ext. 3652 Claims Bona Lao Associate Publisher Subscriptions/Customer Service Paul Aquino gpage@bizinfogroup.ca (416) 442-5600 ext. 3652 blao@annexnewcom.ca Subscriptions/Customer Service Paul Aquino paul@canadianunderwriter.ca Gail Page Manual Associate Publisher (416) 510-5187 (416) 442-5600, Ext. 3552 Gail Page Twitter: @InsuranceCanuk paul@canadianunderwriter.ca gpage@bizinfogroup.ca InsuranceMarketer.com Associate Publisher Paul Aquino (416) 510-6788 gpage@bizinfogroup.ca Circulation Manager Twitter: @InsuranceCanuk (416) 510-5187 Circulation Manager Paul Aquino paul@canadianunderwriter.ca Mary Garufi (416) 510-5187 Account Manager (416) 510-6788 Mary Garufi paul@canadianunderwriter.ca Twitter: @InsuranceCanuk Circulation Manager mgarufi@annexnewcom.ca Michael Wells mgarufi@bizinfogroup.ca Twitter: @InsuranceCanuk National Circulation Manager (416) 510-6788 (416) 442-5600, Ext. 3545 Account Manager Mary Garufi the insurance industry’s social network michael@canadianunderwriter.ca Claims (416) 442-5600 ext. 3545 (416)510-5122 510-6788 Mary Garufi Michael Wells (416) mgarufi@bizinfogroup.ca PrintManual Production Manager Account Manager mgarufi@bizinfogroup.ca InsuranceMarketer.com michael@canadianunderwriter.ca (416) 442-5600 3545 Phyllis Wright ext. Print Production Manager Account AccountManager Manager Michael Wells (416) 442-5600 ext. 3545 (416) 510-5122 Christine Giovis Phyllis Wright President Michael Wells michael@canadianunderwriter.ca Print Production Manager christine@canadianunderwriter.ca INSURANCE the insurance industry’s social network Jim Production Glionna michael@canadianunderwriter.ca Print (416) 510-5122 Account Manager Phyllis Wright Manager President (416) 510-5114 DIRECTORY (416) 510-5122 Vice President & General Manager Phyllis Wright Elliot Ford Creighton insBlogs Bruce Account Manager Account Manager President Joe Glionna INSURANCE eford@canadianunderwriter.ca Account Manager Elliot Ford President Elliot Ford Bruce Creighton Vice President DIRECTORY (416) eford@canadianunderwriter.ca Elliot510-5117 Ford Bruce Creighton eford@canadianunderwriter.ca Alex Papanou Insurance Blogs hosted by Canadian Underwriter (416) 510-5117 insBlogs Vice President eford@canadianunderwriter.ca (416) 510-5117 Property & Casualty Insurance Newswire Vice President Papanou Property & Casualty InsuranceAlex Newswire (416) 510-5117 Alex Papanou
Insurance Limited, James Cameron, president of Cameron &Consultants Associates was recognized by the CIP Cameron &Consultants Associates Limited, Insurance Society when hebyreceived its Insurance Consultants Limited, was the CIP 12recognized Ongoing Adjustment Established Leader Award. was recognized by the CIPits Society when he received As a bread delivery driver in BY ANGELA when STELMAKOWICH Society he received its Established Leader the 1950s, LarryAward. Gilbertson Established Leader Award. BY ANGELA STELMAKOWICH was interested in many BY ANGELA STELMAKOWICH things. Fast forward six decades and the insurance veteran has availed himself of many choices in his SPECIAL field, FOCUS from being a claims SPECIAL FOCUS adjuster to a lawyer, 6SPECIAL Editorial FOCUS appraiser and arbitrator.
6 By Greg Editorial Meckbach 86 Marketplace Editorial 8 Marketplace 56 Moves & Views 8special Marketplace focus 56 Moves & Views 58 Gallery 56 Moves & Views 8 Editorial 58 Gallery 58 Gallery 10 Marketplace 56 Moves & Views 58 Gallery
4 Canadian Underwriter February 2014 4 Canadian Underwriter February 2014 4 Canadian Underwriter February 2014 4
Canadian Underwriter May 2015
Photo: Simon Cheung
14 Leading by Example James Cameron, president of 14 Leading by Example Cameron & Associates 14 Leading by Example James Cameron, president of
Photo: Patrick Thompson Photo: Patrick Thompson Photo: Patrick Thompson
INSURANCE – we have it covered.
instouch.com
insBlogs Ontario
instouch.com
Ontario
insBlogs
Insurance Blogs hosted by Canadian Underwriter
Connect with Canadian Underwriter
insBlogs.com
insBlogs.com
Insurance Blogs hosted by Canadian Underwriter Connecttwitter.com/CdnUnderwriter with Canadian Underwriter facebook.com/CanadianUnderwriter with Canadian Underwriter Insurance BlogsConnect hosted by Canadian Underwriter
twitter.com/CdnUnderwriter
linkd.in/CanadianUnderwriter InsuranceMediaGroup.com twitter.com/CdnUnderwriter
facebook.com/CanadianUnderwriter .ca instouch.com/group/CanadianUnderwriter facebook.com/CanadianUnderwriter
InsuranceMediaGroup.com instouch.com/group/CanadianUnderwriter www.CanadianUnderwriter.ca/MediaGroup linkd.in/CanadianUnderwriter instouch.com/group/CanadianUnderwriter
Published linkd.in/CanadianUnderwriter by
.ca
Canadian BUSINESS UnderwriterMEDIA iswww.CanadianUnderwriter.ca/MediaGroup published NEWCOM INC. thirteen times yearly (monthly + the Annual Statistical Issue) by
InsuranceMediaGroup.com NEWCOM BUSINESS MEDIA INC. www.CanadianUnderwriter.ca/MediaGroup
Canadian at thirteen 80 Valleybrook Drive,(monthly Toronto, + Ontario, M3B Statistical 2S9 Canadian Underwriter Underwriter is is located published times yearly the Annual Issue) by Phone: (416) 442-5600. NEWCOM BUSINESS MEDIA INC. Canadian Underwriter is published thirteen times yearly (monthly + the Annual Statistical Issue) by All rights reserved. Printed in Canada. contentsDrive, of this publication mayM3B not be reproduced or transmitted NEWCOM BUSINESS INC. Canadian Underwriter isMEDIA located at 80 The Valleybrook Toronto, Ontario, 2S9 in any form, in part or in full, including photocopying and recording, without the written consent of the Phone: (416)either 442-5600. Canadian Underwriter is located at 80 Valleybrook Drive, Toronto, Ontario, M3B 2S9 copyright owner. Nor may any part of this publication be stored in a retrieval system of any nature without Phone: 442-5600. All rights(416) reserved. Printed in Canada. The contents of this publication may not be reproduced or transmitted prior written consent. in any form, either in part or in full, including photocopying and recording, without the written consent of the All rights reserved. Printed in Canada. The contents of this publication may not be reproduced or transmitted © Published monthly as a any source technical information comment, and as link between copyright owner. Nor may partofofnews, this publication be stored inand a retrieval system of aany nature without in any form, either in part or in full, including photocopying and recording, without the written consent of the all segments of the insurance industry including brokers, agents, insurance and reinsurance companies, prior written consent. copyright owner. Nor may any part of this publication be stored in a retrieval system of any nature without adjusters, risk managers and consultants. written monthly consent.as a source of news, technical information and comment, and as a link between ©prior Published all segments of the insurance industry including brokers, agents, insurance and reinsurance companies, © Published monthly as a source of news, technical information and comment, and as a link between Privacy Notice adjusters, risk managers and consultants. all segments of the insurance industry including brokers, agents, insurance and reinsurance companies, From time to time we make our subscription list available to select companies and organizations whose adjusters, risk managers and consultants. product or service may interest you. If you do not wish your contact information to be made available, Privacy Notice please contact us via one of the following methods: From time to time we make our subscription list available to select companies and organizations whose Privacy Notice Phone: Fax: 416-442-2191 product1-800-668-2374 or service may interest you. If you do not wish your contact information to be made available, From time to time we make our subscription list available to select companies and organizations whose E-mail: jhunter@businessinformationgroup.ca please contact us via one of the following methods: product or service may interest you. If you do not wish your contact information to be made available, Mail to: Privacy Officer, 80 Valleybrook Drive, Toronto, Ontario, M3B 2S9 please 1-800-668-2374 contact us via oneFax: of the following methods: Phone: 416-442-2191 E-mail: jhunter@annexnewcom.ca Phone: 1-800-668-2374 Fax: 416-442-2191GST Registration number 890939689RT0001 Subscription Rates: 2013 Canada Mail to: Privacy Officer, 80 Valleybrook Drive, Toronto, Ontario, M3B 2S9 jhunter@businessinformationgroup.ca Second Class Mail Registration Number: 08840 1E-mail: Year $49.95 plus applicable taxes Mail to:$73.95 Privacy Officer, 80 Valleybrook Drive, Publications Toronto, Ontario, 2S9 #40069240 Mail M3B Agreement 2 Years plus applicable GST Registration number 890939689RT0001 Subscription Rates: 2013 Canada taxes Return Canadian addresses Secondundeliverable Class Mail Registration Number:to:08840 1Subscription Year Copies $49.95 plus applicable Single $10 plus applicable taxes GST Registration number 890939689RT0001 Rates: 2013 Canadataxes Circulation PublicationsDept. Mail Agreement #40069240 21Years $73.95 plus plus applicable applicable taxes taxes Second Class Mail Registration Number: 08840 Year $49.95 Elsewhere Canadian Underwriter Publications Mail Agreement #40069240 Return undeliverable Canadian addresses to: 2Year YearsCopies $73.95 Single $10plus plusapplicable applicabletaxes taxes 80 Valleybrook Drive, Toronto, Ontario 1 $73.95 Circulation Dept. M3B 2S9 Return undeliverable Canadian addresses to: Single Statistical Copies $10 plus applicable taxes Elsewhere Canadian Underwriter Annual Issue Circulation Dept. WeValleybrook acknowledge the financial support 80 Drive, Toronto, Ontario 1Elsewhere Year $73.95 (included with above subscription) Canadian Underwriter of the2S9 Government of Canada through M3B or1 separately $38 plus applicable taxes 80 Valleybrook Drive, Toronto, Ontario Year Statistical $73.95 Annual Issue the Canada Periodical Fund of the M3B 2S9 We acknowledge the financial support (included with above subscription) Subscription Inquiries/Customer Service Department of Canadian Heritage Annual Statistical Issue ISSN Print: 0008-5251 of the Government of Canada through or separately $38442-5600 plus applicable taxes Bona Lao (416) ext 3552 We acknowledge the financial support (included with above subscription) the Canada Periodical Fund of the ISSN Digital: 1923-3426 blao@bizinfogroup.ca of the Government of Canada through or separatelyInquiries/Customer $38 plus applicable taxes Subscription Service Department of Canadian Heritage the Canada Periodical Fund of the ISSN Print: 0008-5251 Bona Lao (416) 442-5600 ext 3552 Subscription Inquiries/Customer Service Department of Canadian Heritage ISSN 1923-3426 ISSNDigital: Print: 0008-5251 blao@annexnewcom.ca Bona Lao (416) 442-5600 ext 3552 ISSN Digital: 1923-3426 blao@bizinfogroup.ca
ACCEPT THE BATON.
Join WICC Ontario at Relay For Life WHAT IT’S ABOUT: What: Canadian Cancer Society’s Relay For Life – the largest WICC fundraising event in Ontario. All-night, non-competitive team relay. Fun. Inspiring. Lots of activities. You don’t have to spend the night, but you’ll be glad you did. Why: To celebrate cancer survivors, commemorate those we’ve lost, and raise money for life-saving research. Where: Garrison Commons (at Fort York), new exclusive WICC location. When: Friday night on June 12th, from 7pm. Who: You – be a captain and sign up your team right away. It’s easy – we’ll show you how. WHAT YOU DO: Build your team: Friends, family, colleagues, clients. Teams are often 10 people, but more or less is great too. Register: go to www.relayforlife.ca/wicc Choose your WICC Relay For Life event, either Garrison Commons or any other Relay event around the province. Pick WICC! Select WICC under “Team Company” to make sure your funds count for the industry campaign.
Questions? Go to www.wicc.ca Design compliments of
READY. SET. WALK. 27440_RelayAd_Magazine.indd 1
4/8/15 9:06 AM
Articles:1990 – 1992
Covers: 2005 – 2007
editorial
Tele-Envision
Telematics could offer an opportunity to identify customer-specific insurance needs and provide advice, which, it is hoped, could build loyalty that will be there as additional offerings and services unfold. Angela Stelmakowich Editor Canadian Underwriter astelmakowich@ canadianunderwriter.ca
8
Canadian Underwriter May 2015
It is time for a change. Telematics — at present, primarily for auto, but in future, likely for so much more — needs a freer regulatory environment if it is to realize its possibilities and allow players in Canada’s property and casualty insurance industry to find their niche. The discount-only model that currently dominates usage-based insurance (UBI) auto offerings here at home needs some room to expand. Some decisions have been made, with several companies already having moved forward with offerings; others, while not idle, are waiting a while longer to see just how things shake out. Not everyone will fit into that general, across-the-board space. Such an approach could initially be positive for consumers, as providers compete on price and benefits to gain customers. But the ceiling would eventually be reached, necessitating, again, more decisions to determine if the offerings make good business sense or if exiting is a better move. And for providers, it may be that some small (or even medium-sized) players would be unable to compete over the long term. Now is the time — for each insurance company, broker or vendor — to, first, determine its target market for telematics and UBI, and, second, how that market fits with the business’ strategic outlook and goals going forward as the wider possibilities unfold. Rethinking the space in
which a particular provider will play is critically important. That may be the only reliable way that competitive advantage will be gained and all types of customers can benefit. Rather than one very big space, a lot of smaller, focused ones are created. Focusing on a few areas (and understanding them inside and out) can help with advancing and cementing relationships, the loyalty from which will be key as telematics-related offerings move beyond auto to home, life, safety and all manner of customer convenience, needs and wants. It may also help to develop partnerships with those outside the insurance realm that could assume a bigger role for customers and providers alike in the future. Telematics “opens the door for Canadian insurers to build even more precise and custom profiles of their customers activities,” MarcAndre Giguere, EY Canada’s national insurance leader, wrote in a recent article for Canadian Underwriter. “Data mining, or the ability to connect and use multiple streams of digital information to design customized offerings, can identify new hidden revenue opportunities and improve customer satisfaction,” Giguere noted. Auto insurance is clearly not the end game. The data that is already available — understanding and use of which will grow as more customers come on board —
opens the door to much more. In fact, insurance overall is likely not the end game, but rather interconnectedness and improved life, safety and convenience realized through more sophisticated use of data. Still, telematics could offer an opportunity to identify customer-specific insurance needs and provide advice, which, it is hoped, could build loyalty that will be there as additional offerings and services unfold. But before all this happens, telematics must gain more traction. “The discount-only model effectively limits UBI programs to low-risk drivers and low-risk behaviours,” Colin Wright, principal of Corner Two Consulting, said during a recent technology conference in Toronto. And that influences the data being collected, Wright said. “By only collecting data from a subset of drivers, self-selected from the UBI program because they had the reasonable expectation of getting a discount, you don’t get much closer to really understanding the full spectrum of behaviours.” Canada’s property and casualty insurance industry needs an environment in which telematics-related innovation can thrive and a wider breadth of data can be collected, essential to developing market-specific offerings. This will serve providers and consumers alike. Regulators must work with the p&c industry on how best to loosen telematics rules, without making them lax.
WHAT DOES IT MEAN TO BE ACE INSURED?
Participant Accident Insurance | acegroup.com/ca It means my team, coaches and other members of my organization are protected by a sports accident plan that provides the benefits we need. ACE understands how to supplement our general liability programs with a separate accident and medical plan in order reduce liability and costs associated with retained claims. ACE knowing their game, means we can focus on ours.
息 2015 ACE Group. In Canada, coverages are underwritten by ACE INA Insurance and ACE INA Life Insurance. Coverages may not be available in all locations and are subject to actual policy wording. ACE速, ACE logo速, and ACE insured.速 are registered trademarks of ACE Limited.
marketplace
Canadian Market ZURICH CANADA LAUNCHES DRONE INSURANCE PACKAGE Zurich Canada has launched a new drone insurance product that it maintains “closes an important coverage gap” for companies already making use of drones. Developed in partnership with Global Aerospace Underwriting Managers Limited in the United Kingdom, the package will help customers across a range of industries take advantage of the risk mitigation and cost-saving opportunities available through the use of unmanned aircraft systems (UAS), commonly referred to as drones, Zurich reports. The new policy provides companies with both firstand third-party coverage for a variety of risks, including for theft or damage to the drone and any ground equipment used to operate it, or any electronics or components (payload) carried, as well as for property damage and bodily injury caused by the drone, premises liability at locations used in connection with scheduled aircraft, and medical expenses. The package also includes additional coverage extensions. “Zurich’s customers in Canada will be the first ones around the world to have access to this unique insurance solution, thanks to the sophisticated regulatory environment governing the 10 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
use of drones in Canada,” says Urs Uhlmann, chief executive officer of Zurich Global Corporate Canada. The package will next be rolled out on a country-bycountry basis, based on local demand and sophistication of the regulatory environment governing drones.
GUY CARPENTER LAUNCHES FLOOD MODEL FOR CANADIAN INSURANCE MARKET Guy Carpenter has launched its new G-CAT Canada Flood Model, what it calls the “first-ever probabilistic flood model for Canada” that will allow insurers to assess their exposures to the peril. The release seeks to address “the concern of extreme losses from natural hazards in Canada, such as flooding,” says Donald Callahan, president and chief executive officer of Guy Carpenter Canada. The model evaluates fluvial (or riverine) overland flood risk, together with the off-plain component of such events, but does not currently include pluvial, coastal flooding, flash flooding, mudslide (slope failure), groundwater, sewer back-up or tsunami risk. Among other things, the model — which enables clients to evaluate exposure to floods and the financial cost of a range of possible flood events — also features pre-built specific historical Canadian events, variable resolution grids, and a stochastic event set of almost 80,000 synthetic events across the country.
NEW HIGH NET WORTH PERSONAL INSURANCE CAPABILITIES THROUGH ACE ACE Group is offering high net worth personal insurance capabilities in Canada through ACE Private Risk Services, which will provide insurance solutions for Canadians, Americans and other foreign citizens with properties in Canada. The program features a highly customizable and specialized package of policies that can include home, valuable collections, watercraft, umbrella liability, and, through an alliance with CAA Insurance, auto insurance. “We see a tremendous opportunity in Canada, where the high net worth personal insurance market exceeds $1 billion in premium,” James Hasley, senior vice president, Canada country manager for ACE Private Risk Services, says in a statement.
DESJARDINS LAUNCHES APP FOR AUTO INSURANCE IN ONTARIO, QUEBEC Desjardins General Insurance Group (DGIG) has launched a mobile app for its Ajusto usage-based auto insurance, under which the insurer offers discounts based on driving behaviour. With the app — for devices running Apple iOS and Google’s Android operating systems — DGIG is offering “a 100% mobile insurance program that doesn’t require the installation of a device in the vehicle,” it reports. “Anyone, including non-
clients, can try the Ajusto app for 90 days with no obligation to get an idea of the discount that could apply,” notes a company statement. “By the end of the year, the program will also be made available to State Farm (acquired by DGIG) clients in Ontario.”
Regulation WARNING issued ON RIDE-SHARING PROGRAMS The Financial Services Commission of Ontario (FSCO) recently posted an infographic on its website that warns drivers about the insurance risks associated with ride-sharing programs. Ride-sharing services use an online app to connect passengers with drivers using their personal vehicles. “The services may significantly impact your insurance coverage,” the infographic notes, adding that a standard auto insurance policy excludes coverage when the vehicle is used to carry paying passengers or used as a taxi. “You may not be protected against certain damages, losses and liabilities,” it cautions. “Know if you’re covered — ask your driver.” For those looking to take part as a driver, FSCO advises checking to ensure that one’s insurance protects the driver, passenger and others.
DRAFT DEMUTUALIZATION REGS SHOW NEED FOR VIGILANCE, RELATIONSHIPS Ontario mutuals should take note of the new draft federal
marketplace
regulations on demutualization even though, as currently published, they do not apply to provincially chartered mutuals, John Taylor, president and chief executive officer of the Ontario Mutual Insurance Association (OMIA), recently suggested. “OMIA recognizes the importance of being vigilant and proactive at the provincial level. It’s the federal regulations, no doubt, that may form the blueprint for any future provincial demutualization initiatives,” Taylor noted during OMIA’s Annual General Meeting. That is just one more reason for Ontario mutuals to get to know and maintain contact with elected government representatives, he said.
ALBERTA’S BID TO CURB DISTRACTED DRIVING, HIKE PENALTIES GETS GREEN LIGHT Draft Alberta requirements geared at curbing distracted driving by beefing up fines and penalties for texting while behind the wheel have received the green light. Bill 204, the Traffic Safety (Distracted Driving Demerit) Amendment Act, 2014, was tabled in December by MLA Moe Amery and received unanimous support during third reading. The bill amends Alberta’s Traffic Safety Act by adding that a person who is guilty of an offence under subsections 115.1, 115.2, 115.3 or 115.4 is liable to a fine of $250 (up from $172) and shall be assessed three demerit points in accordance
with the regulations. The aforementioned subsections under the act’s Prohibited Operation of Vehicles section are as follows: cellphones, electronic devices, etc.; display screen visible to driver prohibited; global positioning system; and prohibited activities.
Risk traditional supply chains to undergo radical transformation New technologies, competition and customer demands will work together to radically change traditional supply chains over the next five to 10 years, notes a new report by MHI and Deloitte. “The speed at which supply chain innovation is being adopted — coupled with rising consumer expectations for anytime, anywhere service — is stressing traditional supply chains to near-breaking points,” says George Prest, chief executive officer of MHI, which represents the material handling, logistics and supply chain industry. “Companies that continue to use traditional supply chain models will struggle to remain competitive and deliver orders that are accurate and on time,” Prest advises. The report recommends firms embrace the transformation unfolding and invest in new technologies that will allow them to compete and thrive as their supply chains continue to face pressure to do more with less.
Reinsurance NEW GLOBAL ALLIANCE OF DISASTER RESEARCH INSTITUTES FORMED The Toronto-based Institute for Catastrophic Loss Reduction (ICLR) is forming a new worldwide alliance with an international group of disaster research institutes. The proposal builds on initiatives presented at the Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction 2015-2030, reached at the 3rd U.N. World Conference on Disaster Risk Reduction. Glenn McGillivray, managing director of the ICLR, recently reported that the Global Alliance of Disaster Research Institutes (GADRI) will serve as a forum for sharing knowledge and promoting collaboration on topics related to disaster risk reduction and resilience to disasters. GADRI will facilitate discussions on planning and organization of natural disaster research, formation of international research groups to investigate current global disasters, establishment of an international network for timely communication related to natural disaster research, and other issues pertaining to the promotion of natural disaster research.
IBC SUPPORTS EARTHQUAKE REPORT ISSUED in B.C. Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC) has applauded the British Columbia government’s earthquake preparedness report, which recommends
provincial and federal governments engage with the insurance industry and other key stakeholders to develop a disaster resilience strategy and increase public awareness. It is clear from the report and other previous reviews “that more must be done at the individual level, and at all levels of government if B.C. is going to be adequately prepared for a major earthquake or other catastrophic disaster,” the government reports. “Preparing Canadians for an earthquake is a strategic priority for Canada’s insurance industry,” adds Bill Adams, vice president, Western and Pacific for IBC.
Technology IBM SERVICE WOULD let INSURERS EXTRACT INSIGHT FROM CONNECTED VEHICLES IBM has announced plans to introduce a computing service “that helps insurance companies extract insight from connected vehicles.” IBM reports in a statement that it is “building a cloudbased open platform” designed to help companies build solutions for the Internet of things, or IoT. For example, IBM will introduce a cloud-based service that helps insurance companies extract insight from connected vehicles. “This will enable new, more dynamic pricing models and the delivery of services that can be highly customized to individual drivers.” May 2015 Canadian Underwriter 11
Profile
Ongoing Adjustment Greg Meckbach Associate Editor
As a bread delivery driver in the 1950s, Larry Gilbertson’s career choices were wide open. Interested in many things, the six-decades insurance veteran availed himself of quite a few of those choices. Larry Gilbertson, an arbitrator, appraiser, mediator and umpire with almost 60 years under his belt dealing with property and casualty insurance claims, has some advice for young people today. “At some stage, it seems to me, you’ve got to make up your mind that you’re going to follow a certain career, and it’s tough, if you like a lot of things,” says Gilbertson, who spent 16 years as a claims adjuster, 18 as an insurance lawyer and the past 21 with Arbitration and Mediation Services (ADR) Canada Ltd., located in Toronto. “I would have loved to have been a journalist. I would have loved to have been an Ontario land surveyor. I worked for the Department of Highways years ago, on a survey party for (Highway) 12 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
401. At one time, I had five jobs,” he reports. One of those jobs, in the 1950s, was delivering bread for George Weston Limited in the Town of Leaside, which has since been subsumed by the City of Toronto. “There was a day, back in the old days, when insurance agents used to come around and collect premium on life insurance policies, and I believe auto and homeowners’ policies,” he recounts. One agent who visited Gilbertson’s home asked what he did for a living. When he told the agent he was delivering bread, “she said, ‘You’re wasting your time; you should be an insurance adjuster,’” Gilbertson recalls.
INSURANCE BECKONS “I had no idea what an insurance adjuster was, but she very kindly offered to phone and speak to a chap that she knew at the Underwriters Adjustment Bureau (UAB) and recommended that I meet with him,” he says. From 1955 through 1959, Gilbertson worked for UAB, acquired in 2002 by systems integrator and computer services firm CGI Group Inc., which in 2009, sold its insurance adjusting operations to SCM Insurance Services Inc. “I had a delightful year or two delivering bread,” Gilbertson recalls of his life before entering the “rotation” with UAB at its office, then
on Front Street in downtown Toronto. Gilbertson says he had “some wonderful mentors” at UAB to guide him as he spent six months working on auto claims, another six on marine and another six on property and fire. From 1957 through 1959, Gilbertson managed UAB’s branch in Midland, about 150 kilometres north of Toronto. “I told them then, and I still believe it, that there is more scope for an amiable disposition as a property adjuster than as an automobile adjuster, where you are always wrangling about dinged bumpers and all that kind of stuff,” he says. Gilbertson left UAB in 1959 to work for Angell & Townson Insurance Adjusters Ltd., rising to the role of vice president and director, before his resignation in 1971. That is when he decided to study law. “I knew, having dealt with a lot of lawyers, I wouldn’t have to start at the bottom of the ladder,” he recalls. “I decided to try to get into law school and, finally, accomplished that, so that’s how I wound up in law. It wasn’t because I had a great, great driving need or desire from a young fellow to be a lawyer, but I knew that I was a good match for a lot of the lawyers that I had encountered and it worked out very well.” From 1971 through 1974, Gilbertson attended law school at the University of
Western Ontario in London. He was called to the bar in 1976, after articling at Montgomery Cassels Mitchell Somers Dutton & Winkler, where he worked until 1982. That was when he opened his own law firm, Larry H. Gilberston & Associates, now known as Gilbertson Davis LLP, which practices insurance litigation, insurance defence and commercial litigation.
One agent who visited Gilbertson’s home asked what he did for a living. When he told the agent he was delivering bread, “she said, ‘You’re wasting your time; you should be an insurance adjuster.’” Gilbertson retired from active practice in 1994, although he has continued working in alternate dispute resolution. He also keeps busy in his spare time, volunteering at a hospital, and plans to play golf more frequently. “I do more umpiring under the appraisal provision of (Ontario’s) Insurance Act than anything else,” says
Gilbertson, adding he deals mostly with property issues, plus business interruption, stock losses, and industrial and residential claims. “I prefer to do arbitrations or umpiring as opposed to mediating,” he says. “Although I am a firm believer in the mediation process, the trouble is the mediator has to rely on pulling the parties together, and sometimes the people who are at the mediations are not ready to settle, are not interested in getting a resolution, and you have to walk away frustrated because you can’t get them to come together. One thing about umpiring and arbitrating, you can, as an arbitrator or umpire, drive toward a resolution and you can make it happen. You can’t do that as a mediator.” As a lawyer, Gilbertson reports that he handled a lot of fire cases, as well as some involving building collapses. One claim he was involved in arose in September 1977 when an airplane crashed — killing the occupants — into a television tower in Barrie, about 100 kilometres north of Toronto. To this day, he says he still thinks about the case every time he sees that tower while driving on Highway 400. “I was acting in that instance for the subrogated insurers of the tower and the equipment on the tower.” Subrogation “gave me an opportunity to exercise my
Photo: Simon Cheung
Profile
abilities and knowledge and experience in the casualty area,” Gilbertson points out. “I firmly believe that a good property adjuster should have a good grasp of the casualty end of the business, for the purpose of subrogation, because he needs to understand the continuity of evidence, how to take statements and, generally, he’s the first guy there for the insurers,” he explains.
ACROSS the LINES This is one reason Gilbertson advises property adjusters to gain experience in other lines.
“Any property adjuster who doesn’t have a casualty and liability bent — some experience in that area — and then leaves the subrogation to some subrogation specialist — the opportunities are gone by the time he gets through his property adjustment and refers the file,” Gilbertson argues. “I just don’t think that’s a healthy situation at all,” he adds. Many changes have unfolded over Gilbertson’s time in the business, but one thing that has not is the 24-7 nature of a claims adjuster’s job, he suggests.
“Young people today work very hard and deserve a lot of credit, but by God, that job has not changed basically over the years,” he suggests. “I think that the wonderful technology of today makes it easier to do good things quickly and efficiently. I don’t think there’s any question about that, but it doesn’t change the fact that the adjusters of yesteryear had to work hard.” Prior to starting his job with UAB in 1955, Gilbertson says he asked a high school guidance counsellor if she had any information about insurance adjusting. “She said to me, ‘If you can talk people out of what they are entitled to, you can be an insurance adjuster,’” he recounts. “I have often thought of that, and that is just a terrible commentary and a sour outlook on the insurance business, and on the adjusting profession. I hope I was never guilty of doing that and I sure hope that there are no adjusters or claims people that ever do it,” he adds. Six decades after that conversation, though, Gilbertson has no regrets about his career choices. “I believe that there always will be insurance, so that’s a good thing for young people to think about,” he suggests. “At some stage, you have to make the hard decision to focus on something and go for it,” he recommends. May 2015 Canadian Underwriter 13
Ontario’s 25-Year No-Fault Journey
Consultant, Willie Handler and Associates
On September 15, 1989, Murray Elston, Minister of Financial Institutions, announced the unveiling of a new plan to address rising auto insurance costs in Ontario. The plan would provide a “social safety net” where everyone injured in an auto accident would receive compensation without the need to sue. This trade-off between reduced tort access and enhanced accident benefits was meant to reduce costs in the system and stabilize rates. Move forward 25 years and the introduction of the Ontario Motorist Protection Plan (OMPP), the first no-fault auto insurance plan in the province,
14 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
celebrates its silver anniversary on June 22, 2015. The Ontario system is nothing like any other private system or no-fault system. It has a broad range of accident benefits, access to tort, complex entitlement rules and an overburdened dispute resolution process. It also has the highest rates in the country. At about 25% of Canadian property and casualty industry premiums, the health of the Ontario auto insurance product is important to the industry. Many ideas have been tried over the years, but none have addressed cost pressures in the system for anything more than a short period of time. WHY WAS NO-FAULT INTRODUCED? Following the 1985 Court of Appeal for Ontario decision, McErlean v Sarel et al., the insurance industry grew concerned about liability claims, which, in turn, precipitated a liability crisis. Liability insurance costs shot through the roof and capacity was scarce. Little changed when the case was reversed on appeal in 1987, albeit on liability. Ontario had a serious liability problem that went beyond drivers. The crisis was affecting many institutions, including small municipalities and charities. In response, the Ontario Task Force on Insurance was appointed to study problems of availability, affordability and adequacy of general liability insurance in Ontario. Although the focus of the task force report, released in May 1986, was not auto insurance, it
Illustration by Dominic Bugatto/threeinabox.com
Willie Handler
Ontario’s auto insurance system is unrecognizable, and it is time to stop tinkering. The concept of using an insurance system to provide a social safety net is flawed, perhaps requiring in its place a system where private insurance companies provide both third-party liability and physical damage coverage while a Crown corporation delivers accident benefits.
DRIVE YOUR BUSINESS FURTHER
HAGERTY KNOWS HOW IMPORTANT EFFICIENCY IS TO YOUR BUSINESS. We work to create better options for brokers, like our improved online portal and vehicle valuation tools, with no appraisals required. Hagerty’s commitment continues with our streamlined online quoting, Agreed Value 19A coverage and resourceful local field staff. For same-day sign up & quoting visit hagertybroker.ca, email broker@hagerty.com, or call 888-216-2379.
Coverage available in AB, BC, NB, NL, NS, ON & PEI. Hagerty Canada, LLC policies are underwritten by Elite Insurance Company, an Aviva Canada company.
did include some recommendations concerning auto insurance and tort reform. A more in-depth analysis of the auto insurance issues raised in the report were tackled by Mr. Justice Coulter Osborne, appointed in November 1986 to report on the tort system of compensation for injury by automobile accident, the consequences of the implementation of a no-fault automobile accident insurance scheme, and the merits of public versus private automobile insurance delivery systems. Justice Osborne’s Report of Inquiry into Motor Vehicle Accident Compensation in Ontario, issued in April 1988, identified rapidly increasing loss costs for third-party liability bodily injury claims in the early 1980s without offsetting premium increases as the basis for the auto insurance “crisis.” It recommended the following: • retaining the existing system of combined no-fault benefits and unlimited tort recovery, but expanding the type and level of no-fault benefits; • forgoing public delivery of automobile insurance; and • forgoing a no-fault insurance system. Faced with a continuing rate inadequacy problem, the Ontario government responded by introducing a no-fault product, believing it would be less costly. In September 1989, following extensive research and consultation, the government announced its intention to introduce the OMPP. Threshold/no-fault insurance came into effect June 22, 1990. Colleen Parrish, former director of policy for Ontario’s Ministry of Financial Services, says “it was hoped the OMPP would be more consumer-friendly and many claims under the threshold could be settled with the involvement of just the claimant and insurer. Legislation addressed some of the volatility in the marketplace and went beyond the introduction of partial no-fault.” WAS NO-FAULT A GOOD IDEA? Despite current concerns, the ability to access accident benefits after an accident was an important feature and still is. Kathy Bardswick, president and chief executive officer of The Co-operators 16 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
Group Limited, maintains that “the industry supported no-fault because they believed it would allow more money to flow to accident victims quicker, and more of each claim dollar spent on injury would actually go to rehabilitation and support the injured party rather than in support of the administration of the tort system. Too often in a pure tort system, it was taking far too long for many accident victims to see financial support for their recovery. In addition, a no-fault system would provide insurers with the opportunity to deal directly with their own clients through the claims process.” So what went wrong? Bill 164.
The NDP government abandoned its initial intention to introduce a government-run automobile insurance scheme in favour of another set of reforms. On January 1, 1994, Bill 164 replaced the OMPP with a complex no-fault schedule and eliminated the ability to sue for economic losses. Designed for a public insurer, the requirements could not realistically be delivered by the private sector. That system lasted less than three years with the passage of Bill 59, launching Ontario’s third no-fault system within a decade. Although Bill 59 restored some of the balance that existed under the OMPP, it retained the broad range of accident benefits, complex entitlement rules, and the overburdened and pro-
tracted dispute resolution process introduced under Bill 164. Further reforms rolled out from 2003 through 2010, including those relating to health care provider fees and assessment, pre-approved treatment guidelines and an increased deductible for court awards for pain and suffering, as well as introduction of additional “checks and balances” upon the elimination of the designated assessment centre (DAC) system. In 2010, standard accident benefits were scaled back, optional benefits were expanded and a minor injury definition and treatment cap were introduced. Over the past three years, additional reforms have been introduced to address fraud, but even these measures have increased the complexity of the system. Today, the system is overly complex and confusing. It is an entitlement system with far too much moral hazard. The problems first appeared under the OMPP, became worse under Bill 164 and have never been properly addressed. Philip Howell, Ontario’s former Superintendent of Financial Services, accurately describes today’s system as “part insurance and part social program.” Many people contend it is as adversarial as the tort system. Consequently, lawyers are heavily involved in the accident benefit system, something that was not contemplated when no-fault was introduced 25 years ago, and has led to more disputed claims and higher transactional costs. There is little accountability within the system. As soon as there are adverse conditions, the insurance industry begins to pressure the government into making changes. Rather than force the industry to take more ownership, the government is inevitably co-opted into yet another round of reforms. This ongoing tweaking has only made things worse. Nick Gurevich, founder and past chair of the Ontario Rehab Alliance, suggests that “insurers are hooked on frequent government intervention. This removes insurers’ motivation to search and implement long-term internal system improvements.” Since 2010, there have
Stay focused on the big picture
While we manage the details
Partner with Crawford and streamline your business with our full suite of services catered to risk managers Crawford Risk Management Services (RMS) offers a range of services that meet the specific needs of the risk management community. Our services include: • Third Party Administration/ Program Management
• Workers’ Compensation
• Legal Services
• Trust Account Management
• Disability & Absenteeism Services
• Litigation Management
• Appraisal Management Services
• Subrogation
• Contractor Connection™ Vendor Management Program
• Audit Services
• Data Management • CLAIMSALERT®
Contact us at info@crawco.ca for more information on RMS or any of our services.
www.crawfordandcompany.ca
CdnUnderwriterCrawford-RMS-4.indd 1
2/25/2015 1:02:10 PM
been 31 new or amending auto insurance regulations. WHY HAVE RATES REMAINED HIGH? High auto insurance premiums in Ontario are driven by a number of factors. Some factors are unique to Ontario, such as urban density, weather and demographics, but many people believe the product largely contributes to stubbornly high rates. Ontario’s Insurance Act stipulates that auto insurance policies are second-payers to other public and private insurance plans, including the public health care system. However, the government has allowed the second-payer status to erode. Eric Grossman, a partner at Zarek Taylor Grossman Hanrahan LLP, says that “the public health care system has been downloading costs to auto insurance for years.” Not only public insurance, but private insurance plans have been allowed to write in auto accident exclusions in their policies. Rob Sampson, a former Ontario minister with responsibility for auto insurance, agrees. “It is easier for insurers to pass on costs to drivers or persuade the government to make further changes than to address problems on their own. The product has become over-regulated and there is no confidence in the marketplace to manage costs,” Sampson says. Bardswick says she believes that “there has been too much tinkering and not enough fundamental and significant change to improve the overall cost benefit equation long term. With each tinkering, the system has become more complex, more costly to administer, with any immediate cost savings quickly disappearing as players in the system adjust to the changes implemented. The regulatory burden has also driven out much of the ability or desire to innovate.” The high cost of handling claims has become a serious problem. Greg Somerville, president and chief executive officer of Aviva Canada, indicates 48% of accident benefit costs are for non-treatment-related activities. Grossman notes “the irony of the sys18 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
tem is that the high cost of fighting claims encourages settlements which are incentive for more disputes.” Finally, fraud, something no one is able to either accurately quantify or define, continues to place cost pressure on the system. While everyone agrees a staged accident is fraudulent activity, not everyone is prepared to accept the notion of opportunistic or soft fraud. HOW DO YOU FIX THE SYSTEM? Many people would welcome a system that was simpler and would allow most accident victims to navigate the system without a representative. There is a lot of nostalgia for the OMPP because stakeholders remember it as a system that
had few rules and procedures, and fewer disputes. However, it would be naïve to think that the OMPP would not have evolved. It would not have necessarily developed into the existing product, but there would have been pressure to reform the system as a result of growth in the rehabilitation sector, adverse arbitration and court decisions, increased involvement of lawyers, pressure for more consumer protection provisions and fraud. The accident benefits system has been eroded over the past few years, but it must be acknowledged that eliminating these benefits does not eliminate those costs from the system. Many of those
costs migrate to tort claims where there are few controls in place. Some stakeholders would like to see a system with quite modest accident benefits and any additional compensation provided through tort. However, that would bring the industry full circle to the pre-OMPP, which experienced significant cost pressures. It is the concept of using an insurance system to provide a social safety net that is flawed. The current no-fault system resembles a government program with special compensation and eligibility rules for caregivers, retirees, the unemployed and students. Bryan Davies, former chief executive officer and Superintendent of Financial Services, says he believes that “if the government wants to provide a social safety net, then it should be delivered by government.” So what is the answer? The Ontario product has always been different than what exists in other jurisdictions, but looking elsewhere may not provide an answer. A made-in-Ontario solution should include private insurance companies continuing to provide third-party liability coverage and physical damage coverage, while the government creates a not-for profit Crown corporation to deliver accident benefits. A single adjudicative body would introduce significant efficiencies, standardize claims practices and eliminate the adversarial nature of the product. Insurers would collect premiums on behalf of the Crown corporation, which would inform insurers how much to charge for accident benefit coverage based on accident benefit and overhead costs. This system would require reduced advocacy and a scaled-down dispute resolution process, there would be no settlement of accident benefits, and claims would remain open as long as there were insurable losses to pay. It is time for the government to get away from tinkering with the system and eliminate the existing design flaws. A public debate is badly needed. The past 25 years has not been a total failure, but it is not working.
Made in Canada
Trends
buy cars in the compact segment compared to the U.S. market preference for mid-sized vehicles. In fact, eight of the top-selling passenger cars in Canada are compacts, with only the midsized Ford Fusion and Honda Accord making the last two spots of the Canadian Top 10.
DIFFERENCES HAVE IMPACT
Greg Horn
Vice President, Industry Relations, Mitchell International
Vehicle-buying preferences in Canada and the United States differ, with the former favouring compact over the latter’s love of mid-size. Preferences related to model year and vehicle size, however, can have a big impact on claims cost, total loss rate and alternate parts use. What will drive Canadian collision claim trends? Two main factors to watch for in the future are vehicle age and vehicle mix. The insurance industry can also expect that the Canadian claims landscape will see trends develop sooner than the larger United States claims market, in large part because of Canada’s newer vehicle mix. The average age of a vehicle involved in a repairable claim in Canada is a full two years newer than in the U.S. Another contrast to the U.S. market is the sales mix. In passenger cars, the top-selling car in the U.S. for the last decade has been the Toyota Camry; the Canadian top seller is the Honda Civic. Canadian passenger car buyers overwhelmingly
20 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
The differences in model year and vehicle size have profound impacts on the claims cost, total loss rate and alternate parts use. Model year, in particular, makes a significant difference because the number of vehicles equipped with side-impact airbags increased in the mid-2000s. The chart on page 22, courtesy of the Highway Loss Data Institute in the U.S., shows the percentage of vehicles in North America equipped with side airbags by model year. With the average vehicle age in a claim at 6.5 years old, it is easy to see that the percentage of vehicles equipped with side airbags will increase rapidly in the coming years. Nearly 25% of all collisions in Canada involve side impacts in the “B” pillar area, which can potentially deploy the side airbag. Of course, not all side impacts are severe enough to deploy the side bag, but when they are, the cost of the bag replacement, trim and bolster elements average more than $2,000 in additional costs. Canadian vehicles experiencing a claim (both repairable and total loss is 6.52 years old) have an average actual cash value of more than $13,000, which means that adding $2,000 in costs to the rest of the damage could result in a total loss. In the next five years, as the Canadian fleet achieves almost 100% side airbags in the car fleet, total losses will, undoubtedly, rise. Currently, the
Thank you to the thousands of stars that make up our CARSTAR universe — our franchise, insurance and vendor partners, and our employees for helping us achieve Gold status. Over 200 locations nationwide | carstar.ca
advantage to repairing rather than replacing due to the retained value of a vehicle) offsets the increasing complexity of repairs as a result of parts, such as aluminum panels, expensive Xenon headlamps and side airbags. This will not prompt a sudden “flip of the switch” phenomenon, but, rather, a gradual increase in the total loss percentage. The industry should expect increasing part replacement rates, which traditionally hover around 50%, and a rise in the average number of parts replaced in the average estimate as well as the average cost. The rate of use aftermarket and salvage parts will begin to plateau and eventually decline as the styling cycle shortens for cars on Canadian roads. industry is seeing an increase in repairable collision costs as well as total loss volume, due, in part, to the increases in side airbag deployment.
ON TREND As mentioned, Canada’s top-selling car for decades has been the Honda Civic. Because this model sells well throughout the world, aftermarket parts makers are laser-focused on this model. The economics are simple: the more a vehicle is produced, the more popular the replacement parts will be and the larger the aftermarket parts lots can be. When Honda introduced the 2012 model year Civic, the company misread consumer taste trends and created a decidedly “de-contented,” more simply styled car. Many critics panned the interior as cheap, and the exterior was “de-chromed” and “cheapened,” many automotive writers reported. So dramatic was the change that Consumer Reports removed the car from its recommended list. The car had a long history of being on the recommended list, and its removal because of the 2012 styling made headlines. Honda took notice and, in an unprecedented move, offered a refreshed Civic styling for 2013, with a new hood and bumper. That leaves the 2012 Civic as somewhat of an orphan when it comes 22 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
to styling and aftermarket replacement parts. Both insurers and collision repairers have begun to see this in the repair costs for the 2012 Civic. Beyond Honda’s quick response with the 2013 refresh, there have also been changes in vehicle design cycles from other manufacturers, notably those in Korea. Both Kia and Hyundai have entered very competitive segments in the compact and mid-size segments. A key to their growth has been a styling refresh that is much faster than the typical four-to-six-year Japanese styling cycle. Honda and Toyota have taken notice, and have begun emulating the Koreans’ faster product-styling cycles. The industry is beginning to see faster mid-cycle refreshes from Ford, GM and Chrysler as well. The combined impact of these actions could be expected to cause aftermarket part makers to reduce and, in some cases, not create aftermarket part offerings for particular models and parts. Salvage parts utilization, which trails use in the U.S. because of corrosion, supply infrastructure and delivery difficulties in remote areas, will further decline. Lastly, the trend toward smaller vehicles in the Canadian vehicle mix will probably result in more passenger car total losses as time goes on. The trick is to see when the newer year mix (an
The combined impact could be expected to cause aftermarket part makers to reduce and, in some cases, not create aftermarket part offerings for particular models and parts. Salvage parts utilization, which trails use in the U.S. because of corrosion, supply infrastructure and delivery difficulties in remote areas, will further decline. What can a Canadian collision repair shop do to prepare? • educate technicians on the latest in plastics repair; • outfit the shop with an aluminum “clean room” with dedicated tools; and • devote training to understanding the unique repair requirements and characteristics, in addition to parts supply channels, of the top-selling passenger cars in the shop’s province. Collision repair jobs of the future will go to shops that understand the vehicles, their materials and their parts sources.
2 15 September 30 – October 2, 2015 - Le Centre Sheraton Montréal
Register Now! www.niccanada.com The NICC is Canada’s pre-eminent insurance conference attended by senior executives of insurers, brokers, reinsurers, risk managers, regulators and industry associations. Together with our senior advisory committee of industry CEO’s we are once again making the NICC a can’t miss industry leadership event.
Sessions and speakers include:
Platinum Sponsors
• Global Economic Outlook Dr. Kurt Karl, Chief Economist, Swiss Re • Is Property at Risk of Becoming the New Auto? Tim Bzowey (RBC Insurance); Karen Gavan (Economical Insurance); Philip Howell (FSCO); Blake Reichert (Western Financial Group) • Cyber Risk - Insurance Considerations Jamie Rodgers (CGI); Phil Baker (Creechurch); Catherine Murray Ken Taylor (ICSPA); Alice Underwood (Willis Re) Conference Emcee • Auto Insurance Reality Check David Simpson (Facility Association); Barbara Bellissimo (Desjardins); Michael Brattman (IBAO); Allan Cleiren (Alberta Insurance Rate Board); Amanda Dean (IBC) • The Evolving Canadian MGA Model - Is There Ink in the Pen? Bob Dempsey (Retired President & COO, The Guarantee); Tony Fredericks (AM Fredericks); Jean F. Laurin (ENCON Group Inc.); Lynn Oldfield (AIG Canada); Gerry Wolfe (Independent Board Member) • Global Leaders Panel Eric Andersen (Aon Benfield); Tom Bolt (Lloyd’s); Stephen Catlin (XL Catlin); Greg Hendrick (XL Re) • Flood Insurance Programs - Trials, Tribulations and Success Stories Don Forgeron (IBC); Dr. Bernhard Gause (German Insurance Association); Brendan McCafferty (Flood Re (UK)) • Severe Weather & Climate Change - Perspectives From Environment Canada David Phillips, Senior Climatalogist, Environment Canada • Specialty Lines: On the Brink Hugh Sturgess (Arch Insurance Canada Ltd.); David Cook (ENCON Group Inc.); Michael Densham (Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance); Jean-Raymond Kingsley (Odyssey Re Canada)
Gold Sponsors
Silver Sponsors
Keynote Speakers
Jaime Watt
David Andelman
Executive Chairman & Senior Partner, Navigator Ltd.
Editor of World Policy Journal and Columnist at USA Today
Media Sponsors ✦ 110 th
For more information visit www.niccanada.com
ANNIVERSARY
✦
Tried and True The CIP Society Insurance Institute of Canada
The CIP Society represents more than 17,000 graduates of the Insurance Institute of Canada’s Fellow Chartered Insurance Professional (FCIP) and Chartered Insurance Professional (CIP) Programs.The CIP Society, through articles such as this, is working to bring ethical issues to the forefront and provide learning opportunities that enhance the professional ethics of all insurance professionals.
There is no getting around it: claims adjusters will encounter difficult and demanding claimants. But when a claimant grows unreasonable and combative, demanding too much, what is the best course of action for an adjuster wanting to advance a truly fair settlement and meet fiduciary duties to his or her employer? A very busy claims department recently became busier as a result of a sudden increase in promotions, illnesses, family leaves and retirements. The remaining staff were doing the very best they could, but the workload and resulting stress was taking its toll. Many claimants were also expressing their dissatisfaction with service levels and were becoming increasingly demanding. One particular claimant, sensing the mood of the situation, used the opportunity to apply extra pressure and demanded a higher payout on her claim. The claims adjuster felt that the claimant’s requests were excessive and unreasonable, and advised her as such. The argumentative claimant was (likely purposely) wasting the claims adjuster’s time in an effort to wear her down. The claimant threatened to take the company to court and alert the media. Although the claims adjuster knew that these were probably idle threats, she contemplated simply giving in to the unreasonable demands because they might cost less than the considerable time and resources being expended on the file. But what are the implications of doing this?
24 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
Mark MacDonald, B.Comm, FCIP, CRM Vice President and Regional Claims Manager Claims Department Aon Risk Solutions Any insurance professional can likely relate to this situation, as they have all, at some point, been involved in negotiations that have been difficult, tiring and may have eventually broken down; perhaps while trying to settle a claim, negotiate terms with an underwriter, or buy a home or a car. In this situation, it can be assumed the claims adjuster’s valuation of the claim is fair, and that the claimant likely knows this. It can be very tempting in a situation like this to simply give in and “throw some money” at the claimant to make him or her go away. While this may be a quick and easy way out, there are several concerns with this approach. A moral concern is that by doing this, the adjuster is giving the claimant “the win” by giving in to the claimant’s threats, as opposed to negotiating a settlement in good faith based on the facts (with some of the normal give-and-take that is part of the negotiation process).
Illustration by Dominic Bugatto/threeinabox.com
The CIP Society Ethics Series
The adjuster should also take into consideration what sort of precedent she would be setting by giving in to the claimant’s tactics. The next time she faces a difficult and unreasonable claimant, will she be more likely to concede to that individual’s unreasonable demands? The adjuster also needs to bear in mind her fiduciary duties to her employer. Her obligations in this regard include protecting her employer’s assets and only issuing legitimate, and supported, claim payments. As long as the adjuster’s claim valuation is fact-based and reasonable, she should have no concerns about justifying or defending her offer. The adjuster should explain to the claimant the rationale for her offer, and unless the claimant can justify a higher settlement based on the facts, the negotiations have likely reached a conclusion and the claimant should take whatever next steps she feels are necessary. Luc Aucoin, BBA, FCIP Adjuster Plant Hope Adjusters Ltd. It is unfortunate the insurer has allowed staffing to get to the point where claims personnel, who deal with enough stress in their day-to-day activities, have to deal with the added stress of unscrupulous claimants who seek to take advantage of the situation. A cynical adjuster might say that the insurer has created the situation and so should pay what it has to in order to allow the adjuster to satisfy the claimant and get on with other matters, even if that means significantly overpaying the claim. A professional adjuster, however, would say that dealing with difficult people and situations is part of the job. No matter the threats, the amount of the claim that should be paid is what should be paid, no more and no less. Every service provider experiences busy times and customers who are unreasonable in those situations are not worthy of the extra attention — and certainly not worthy of extra payment. Caving in to the claimant’s demands would create future expectations for that 26 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
No matter the threats, the amount of the claim that should be paid is what should be paid, no more and no less. Every service provider experiences busy times and customers who are unreasonable in those situations are not worthy of the extra attention — and certainly not worthy of extra payment. person (and all who would hear his or her story) and would undermine the confidence and credibility of the claims adjuster. It is the insurer’s responsibility to staff appropriately and if there are service complaints, then that will be for the insurer to answer. The adjuster must maintain focus on the claims process, stick to the facts and not be influenced by extraneous influences. While it is easier said than done, professional loss adjusters can and do.
Lee-Ann Vansteenkiste, B.A. (Hons), CIP Branch Manager ClaimsPro The insurer and adjuster must ensure that they are maintaining the integrity of the policy. Each line of business has legislative requirements for responding to claims. There are consequences in the legislation for late responses. For example, if it is a property claim, an insurer has 60 days to respond to the properly submitted Proof of Loss. In an accident benefits claim in Ontario, an insurer must pay interest on late payments and/or concede coverage in situations where timelines are not met. The first thing that the adjuster needs to do is ensure that the insurer has met all legislative requirements in dealing with the claimant. The requirements and transaction of the claim should be properly and professionally explained in writing. An insurer can apologize for delays, but that does not mean they should give in to any demands that may exceed or counteract the intention of the policy and the principals of indemnity. There are times in every claims adjuster’s working life where he or she may not respond as quickly as liked. This is typically not intentional. In this scenario, the adjuster should apologize for any delays or customer service handling, and keep the transactions factual to ensure compliance with the integrity of the policy. The position of the insurer with respect to the resolution should be clearly outlined. Additionally, the communication must advise and direct the insured of the option to dispute should the claimant wish to decline the resolution offered by the insurer. This explanation would detail the dispute process, including methods for appraisal, mediation, etc., along with any timelines that correspond with this. Handling each claim consistently upholds the professionalism of both the insurer and the claims adjuster. It protects the policyholders in general, as the premiums of all pay the claims for those who submit them. It is not always easy to apologize. Al-
though it may be easier just to “cave” and increase the resolution offer, it erodes the consistent, professional claimshandling practices of the insurer and, in the end, lessens the credibility of the adjuster. The claims-handling practices should be consistent with every claim, ensure compliance with whatever legislation governs the line of business being addressed, and provide open, professional and factual communication with every insured person. Claims professionals cannot be responsible for what an insured person does with a determination, but they can be responsible for how they respond to the situation. The very best that can be done is to maintain integrity and uphold the principal of indemnity.
THE LAST WORD
to ensure fairness for the insurer (or future claimants). To balance outcomes for both the claimant and the insurer, the adjuster must negotiate a claim payout that is fair to both. (No one said it was an easy job!) The third approach focuses on the end result of the scenario (a situationbased approach), and in this case, involves an investigation of the outcomes
of giving in to the claimant’s demands. A higher payout to the claimant has the potential of undermining the claims process by suggesting that the payout amount is arbitrary and easily increased by making demands and/or threats. The adjuster can help reiterate the integrity of the claims process and the insurance industry, in general, by following a fair claims process.
If you’re in Manitoba, this is considered an automobile. Surprised? ARC isn’t.
Your customer has a list of the vehicles that are covered by your fleet policy. You have a list of the vehicles that are covered by ARC Group Canada is a national that policy. network of independent law firms, And your lists aren’t theintimately same. each connected to their local market. When the one vehicle that is involved in Insurance risk appear management an accident is the one thatand doesn’t on experts. Regionalnext? strength. both lists, do you know what happens National scope. ARC does. That is the ARC Group.
If Manitob consid auto
Sur
ARC Group Cana network of indepe each intimate th
Insurance and ri
experts. Re Whatever the issue or specifics, three different approaches can help guide That is how insurance professionals respond to Go to various ethical scenarios they may encounter on the job. Depending on the Go to AskARC.com approach, professionals can sometimes end up at different solutions, in which case practice and experience make all the difference in helping them select the best course of action. Sometimes, however, all roads lead to the same outcome. The first approach to solving ethical dilemmas involves an examination of the formal rules around the scenario (a rules-based approach). ARC Group Canada is a national network of independent law firms, In the aforementioned case, there are each intimately connected to their local market. specific legislative requirements and Insurance and risk management experts. Regional strength. organizational standards and guidelines National scope. Go to AskARC.com that the claims adjuster should abide by to ensure a fair claims process for the claimant. In line with this approach, if the adjuster strays from these rules and The ARC Legal Reporter gives the claimant more than what she Winter Issue – Article #1 A National Network of Independent Law Firms deserves (no matter the reason), the adjuster would be acting unethically. When is a medical examination considered a second examination The second approach tries to maximize under Rule 36 of the New Brunswick Rules of Court? outcomes for individual stakeholders in The ARC Legal Reporter the scenario (a people-based approach). v. Crowther and Kelly Case: Winter IssueReported – Article #1 Blyth 2009 NBCA 80 Citation: While giving in to the claimant’s deWhen both the plaintiff’s physical and mental condition are in issue in an action At Issue: National Network of Independent Law Firms the plaintiff undergoes a physical examination, will a subsequent application mands Awould certainly leave her more psychiatric examination be considered an application for a second me examination? satisfied, this outcome would do nothing When is a medical examination considered a second examination Should medical examinations that are ordered as part of the discovery proces characterized as ‘independent’ medical examinations? under Rule 36 of the New Brunswick Rules of The Court? Court of Appeal of New Brunswick Court: ARC_Fleet ad_1/2 page.indd 1
Reported Case: Citation: At Issue:
Judgment Rendered: Factual Summary:
October 13, 2009 (Reasons delivered November 2015-02-14 26, 2009) 1:05 PM The plaintiff suffered injuries in a motor vehicle accident and commenced an a seeking damages. Both the plaintiff’s physical state and mental state were in iss the action. The plaintiff submitted to a physical examination by the defendant’s ex but subsequently refused to submit to a psychiatric examination.
Blyth v. Crowther and Kelly 2009 NBCA 80 When both the plaintiff’s physical and mental condition are in issue in an action, and
No Substitute for (Protection)
Opinion/Analysis
Vincent Gaudreau
Chair, Regroupement des cabinets de courtage d’assurance du Québec
Consumers, car dealerships and the entire insurance industry in Quebec have received a crystal-clear message from the provincial regulator: non-compliance with rules governing replacement insurance, and meant to protect consumers, will not be tolerated and fines will be imposed. Quebec’s financial regulator, Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), delivered an important message in February when it imposed penalties on a number of car dealerships and a damage insurance brokerage in connection with certain illegal business practices. At the same time, the AMF issued a wake-up call to consumers and the entire insurance industry, including auto dealers and insurers. A total of nine auto dealers and a brokerage
28 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
firm were fined by the AMF because of replacement insurance violations. Amounting to several thousands of dollars, the penalties were imposed pursuant to Quebec’s Act respecting insurance (ARI), the Act respecting the distribution of financial products and services (ARDFPS) and various AMF notices.
ABUSIVE AND CONFUSING PRACTICES As a result of various Regroupement des cabinets de courtage d’assurance du Québec (RCCAQ) reports and AMF investigations, abusive practices — all of which were prejudicial to consumers’ interests — were found to be prevalent at the dealerships. The violations included pressuring consumers to take out insurance to obtain financing or, in the event of a partial loss, requiring them to use a specific dealer for vehicle repairs. The AMF also noted that some car dealerships were engaging in insurance areas that are the exclusive purview of certified professionals. For example, when purchasing vehicles, some clients were offered not only replacement insurance (FPQ No. 5), but also products covering civil liability and vehicle damage (FPQ No. 1), even though such sales are exclusively reserved for AMF-registered insurance agents and brokers.
The AMF’s announcement brought the following paradox to light: Why are auto dealers still authorized to sell FPQ No. 5 when sales of insurance products are only meant to be carried out by certified representatives? In view of the recent fines, this question has acquired a new relevance.
LOOKING BACK From 1992 to 2010, auto dealers were authorized to sell vehicle replacement warranties. However, there were so many similarities between these warranties and replacement cost insurance that the AMF questioned whether or not the warranties were actually a form of insurance. Quebec’s Court of Appeal subsequently took up the matter and in the spring of 2008, issued a ruling that replacement warranties were actually a form of insurance since they related to a purely accidental event, not to a vehicle defect. The following year, the AMF was obliged to take a stand: replacement warranties became replacement insurance and, subsequently, fell within the jurisdiction of the AMF. The court ruling, coupled with AMF’s position, makes clear that auto dealers should have stopped selling FPQ No. 5. However, the change represented a loss of a lucrative market, prompting them to make multiple representations to the AMF. They were subsequently allowed to continue selling these products, but were subject to stricter regulations. Effective August 1, 2010, replacement insurance was offered by the network of insurance brokers and agents, as well as by the network of auto dealers, culminating in the recent unfortunate consequences and ongoing broker concerns. It should be noted that replacement insurance is not available in any other Canadian province. The problem with auto dealers is unique to Quebec.
JUST THE BEGINNING Needless to say, the AMF’s decision to impose fines sparked a strong reaction among the car dealers involved, who subsequently filed an application for a judicial review of the court rulings. The
matter is scheduled to be heard by Quebec’s Superior Court. In its ongoing defence of consumers, the RCCAQ maintains the matter is far from settled, although it welcomes the fines imposed by the AMF. In fact, the RCCAQ has been calling for fines to be imposed on non-compliant dealerships for the past three years. Although the AMF’s decision marks a major step forward in the fight to root out these harmful practices, the RCCAQ believes it is naive to think that such practices will end overnight. As such, the brokers association will continue its efforts to denounce these practices until such time as a specific provision is adopted, as part of the ARDFPS review, in which an equitable regulatory framework is put in place for chief financial officers at all auto dealerships, or the right of auto dealers to sell replacement insurance is revoked.
The AMF’s announcement brought the following paradox to light: Why are auto dealers still authorized to sell FPQ No. 5 when sales of insurance products are only meant to be carried out by certified representatives? In view of the recent fines, this question has acquired a new relevance. WAKE-UP CALL When it imposed penalties back in February, the AMF brought the auto dealers back into line. But is also sent a clear message to insurers, as well as to consumers. The AMF voiced certain concerns about insurers operating in the replacement insurance market, particularly in connection with absent or inadequate policies, procedures and controls among insurers overseeing the distribution of
FPQ No. 5. This could end up fostering the emergence and maintenance of substandard practices. The AMF noted that under Section 420 of the ARDFPS, insurers must take all necessary steps to ensure that their distributors have in-depth knowledge of the products they sell. It also referred to Section 222.2 of the ARI, under which all insurers are required to follow sound business practices, provide potential clients with adequate information on products or services, and act fairly in their dealings with them. The AMF also issued a wake-up call to consumers. Its advice in this regard is designed to help them make enlightened choices when buying insurance in connection with vehicle purchases. In its prepared statement, the AMF reported that only AMF-registered insurance agents or brokers are authorized to advise consumers on insurance matters and/or to compare auto insurance products available in the marketplace. A number of auto dealers got the message and took immediate action to ensure compliance. They include the Park Avenue Group, which launched its own brokerage firm shortly after the AMF announced that it would be imposing fines. By creating a brokerage in association with an established firm, Park Avenue Group, made up of 18 dealers in Quebec, has taken steps to ensure compliance with the rules governing distribution of products and services while also meeting its clients’ insurance needs. The AMF also notified all auto insurance industry stakeholders that it intends to take steps to eradicate practices that violate the ARI and the ARDFPS, as well as to ensure that all consumers are treated fairly. The AMF is authorized to impose administrative penalties or to initiate criminal proceedings against anyone who breaks the law. Further, it is authorized to issue orders requiring insurers to stop marketing insurance products via distributors. The matter may not be settled, but the AMF’s message is crystal clear.
May 2015 Canadian Underwriter
29
D&O on
Cameron Rose
Senior Vice President, Chubb Specialty Insurance
Directors and officers at Canada’s publicly listed companies face personal liability as a result of unfolding trends related to securities, environmental and cyber issues. But a well-conceived mix of risk management processes and risk transfer tools can help protect both companies and their directors and officers. Directors and officers (D&O) at the more than 3,500 publicly listed companies in Canada have a duty to the corporations they serve, to shareholders and other company stakeholders, and sometimes to the public. Their primary purpose is to help the corporation set and meet its strategic goals. For this service, however, directors and officers can face personal liability. Three particular trends are now accentuating this reality: securities class actions, environmen-
30 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
lert tal risk and cyber liability. What has transpired to bring each of these trends to the forefront? And what lessons can be learned to help mitigate the exposures?
SECURITIES Ontario’s Bill 198, an omnibus bill titled An Act to Implement Budget measures and other initiatives of the Government, went into effect in Canada about a decade ago in 2005, yet its effects are more than ever being felt. Designed to restore investor confidence and passed in response to strong reforms taking place in the United States, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act that took effect in 2002, the bill sought to protect investors through more accurate corporate disclosure. Bill 198 imposes statutory civil liability — for public companies, investment funds and other issuers, as well as their directors and some officers, influencers and experts — to ensure continuous disclosure in the secondary investment market. In essence, lawmakers intended to create a statutory vehicle to allow securities class action lawsuits to proceed more easily against companies (and the directors who sit on their respective boards) alleged to have misled investors.
BURNS & CONQUER THE HARDTO-PLACE WILCOX EXPERTISE IS OUR MIDDLE NAME. With our global expertise, you have the right solutions for all your hard-to-place risks. Ensure your success with Burns & Wilcox Canada.
Toronto, ON 416.774.2477 St. John’s, NL 709.745.1606 Halifax, NS 902.462.5585
Ottawa, ON 613.237.3939 Calgary, AB 403.444.5611
burnsandwilcox.ca Commercial | Professional | Personal | Brokerage Binding | Risk Management Services
37589 Burns Conquer ad Canada APPROVED.indd 1
4/24/15 10:53 AM
With fallout from the Northstar case, understanding a company’s environmental liabilities is as important as ever. And cyber risks continue to grow in relevance and costs.
Eleven new securities class action lawsuits were filed in 2014 — about the annual average since 2008 — 10 of which were statutory secondary market cases related to Bill 198. Of the 96 total securities class actions filed since 2005, about two-thirds, 63, have been Bill 198 claims. The potential costs are significant. NERA Economic Consulting reports that more than $32 billion in total claims are represented in the 38 statutory secondary market cases unresolved at the end of 2014. Defendants in the 22 settled statutory secondary market cases agreed to pay a total of more than $345 million. Complicating the picture are macroeconomic trends that could be making Canadian corporations more vulnerable to securities litigation. Canadians are leveraged today to a greater degree than the U.S. debtors were prior to the credit crisis. Both interest rates and the prime lending rate remain at all-time lows, while the Canadian dollar continues to decline against its southern equivalent.
ENVIRONMENTAL Beyond these key macro indicators driving uncertainty, directors and officers can look to the courts for a crucial emerging risk: environmental liability. One case, in particular, is driving the trend. Its roots date back to 2005, when Northstar Aerospace (Canada) began a voluntary remediation of its contaminated properties in Cambridge, Ontario. In 2012, Northstar found itself in financial difficulty. In response, the Ministry of the Environment issued orders requiring further remediation and more than $10 million in financial assurance 32 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
to be set aside. It was to no avail; Northstar was insolvent by June 2012, prompting the provincial ministry to undertake the remediation. To pay for the remediation, regulators named 12 former Northstar directors and officers and the parent company in the United States to conduct the work. The critical takeaway from the case: Regulators imposed personal liability on the directors and officers, even though they had not been in their positions during the time of contamination. Regulators demanded that each pay $800,000 for the interim remedial work. The defendants settled for $4.75 million before an appeal could be heard. For board members across Canada, there is a lesson to be learned from this incident. They should understand their companies’ environmental pollution risks and be satisfied that policies and procedures are in place to prevent unlawful contamination. Incoming board members need to dig into a company’s pre-existing exposures. And all officers and directors could benefit from risk transfer, whether that comes in the form of adequate insurance or separate indemnity agreements between board members and companies in the event of a Northstar-like fact pattern. The Northstar case also brings to light the question of governance. Generally, directors and officers are not liable for environmental liabilities by their corporations when they have taken reasonable steps to prevent those liabilities. Such adequate due diligence can include being satisfied that those directly responsible are adequately supervised,
that pollution prevention systems meeting industry standards are introduced, and that response when such systems have failed is immediate.
CYBER Unlike environmental risks, cyber liabilities do not appear to have yet shaken Canadian officers and directors. Corporate loss experience has been more benign in Canada than south of the border. Headline-grabbing data breaches have occurred against large, well-known U.S.based retail companies and banks. However, concern is warranted. Canada ranked 15th in the world in data security practices in the EMC Global Data Protection Index, and the IT services firm estimated that it is costing the nation’s economy $16.8 billion every year. Specific incidents have gained headlines, too. Of note was the hard drive lost by Canada Student Loans that contained 583,000 Canadians’ records. This event and others like it were not on the scale of U.S. breaches, in which millions of records were involved, but it is only a matter of time before all global companies face those catastrophic-level breaches. That reality requires a change of thinking among directors and officers. Unlike many other aspects of directing public company affairs, cyber risk may be new for many directors and is not intuitive. Directors may fail to be properly informed on the issue or take the chief information officer’s optimism on face value that breaches will not happen to their company. Directors may also feel cyber security is simply more a company issue than a director-level concern.
A recent U.S. court case demonstrates that cyber security is a board issue. Shareholders of Wyndham Worldwide Corporation filed a derivative-action lawsuit in February 2014 in an attempt to hold the organization’s directors and officers liable for three hacking attacks against the corporate parent, which compromised the personal information of approximately 600,000 customers and led to government investigations. Shareholders demanded that the board investigate the breaches and sue the company. When rebuffed, the shareholders then sued the board members. A U.S. federal judge dismissed the case last October. The case, nonetheless, sends a clear signal to boards around the world that they must be involved in the information security of their organizations. Public company directors and officers can follow several best practices to ensure their oversight of corporate cyber
ATTENTION WARRANTED
However, concern is warranted. Canada ranked 15th in the world in data security practices in the EMC Global Data Protection Index, and the IT services firm estimated that it is costing the nation’s economy $16.8 billion every year. security programs. A crucial one is placing cyber security within the framework of enterprise risk management (ERM). Specific focus should also be placed on incident response and crisis management programs, as well as the potential value of standalone insurance to transfer some of the risk.
All three aforementioned trends are worthy of renewed attention. Going forward, Bill 198 may inspire further securities class actions, adding to the tally of unresolved cases or those headed to settlement, a process that may be influenced by changing macroeconomic trends like currency and energy price fluctuations. With fallout from the Northstar case, understanding a company’s environmental liabilities is as important as ever. And cyber risks continue to grow in relevance and costs. Despite the pressing nature of these three D&O exposures, directors and officers do not need to stay awake at night. Sound risk management processes combined with risk transfer tools such as insurance can help protect companies and their directors and officers both before and during a lawsuit.
41 st
SEPT. 27-30, 2015 QUÉBEC CITY CONVENTION CENTRE Join us and enhance your competitive advantage. Known for its expert-led educational sessions and networking events, the RIMS Canada Conference attracts risk managers from across the country.
FOR MORE INFO
www.rimscanadaconference.ca | LinkedIn/RIMS in Canada | Twitter/@RCC_Quebec2015 May 2015 Canadian Underwriter
33
Driving Forward Telematics is revving up. Fuelled by the promise of securing consumer loyalty and gaining competitive advantage, offerings from traditional and non-traditional players in the property and casualty space are meant to help position companies for the future. But will current regulatory restrictions serve to stall out the possibilities? ANGELA STELMAKOWICH
34 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
T
he possibilities of telematics look to be almost endless, poised to play a role not only in auto and home insurance, but perhaps even the daily lives of consumers across the country. Although the telematics experience elsewhere may be deeper than in Canada, offerings from insurances companies, direct writers, broker partners and vendors are expanding here at home, albeit unfolding with a sort of “sameness” as a result of the regulatory restrictions and the persistence of the discount-only model. Sources suggest that changes on the regulatory front, a loosening of what is currently permitted, will be essential if the promise of telematics and usagebased insurance (UBI) is to be fully realized. Should that freedom be introduced, however, is the data mature enough and the understanding of what to do with it sufficient to provide a solid foundation for accurately assessing risk and determining price? And will the type of data now being collected provide the insights needed to propel “telematics” beyond discussions of pricing to the next level of reflecting consumer wants, needs and convenience, perhaps even before they voice those preferences? While not all insurers are currently “in” when it comes to telematics and UBI offerings, some commentators suggest the time is now for capitalizing on the opportunity. What happens to those remaining on the sidelines while earlyadopters move on to the next stage? Will inactivity leave some p&c insurance players stuck in neutral? And are consumers ready to come along for the ride?
May 2015 Canadian Underwriter 35
COVER STORY
Driving Forward REVVING UP From an insurance carrier perspective, there is a lot of activity on the telematics front, says Blair Currie, vice president of business development for Intelligent Mechatronic Systems Inc. (IMS). Currie says that Canada’s auto insurance industry is moving into a “second phase” with respect to telematics, where earlyadopters (largely marked by direct or agent-based distribution systems) are trying new and different things, including various models and experimenting with mobile. Desjardins General Insurance Group (DGIG) was among the early-adopters. It was the first “to widely offer telematics in Ontario and Quebec. Now we are the first to offer usage-based insurance through a smartphone app,” says Alex Veilleux, the company’s vice president of Ajusto & Innovation. For those who have not yet released a telematics offering, there is the group of insurers that can be called the “fast followers,” Currie suggests. “I believe more insurers will enter the arena because they don’t want to be left behind,” comments Colin Wright, principal of Corner Two Consulting. “I would think almost every major provider will have some sort of telematics option available to consumers in the next year or two,” predicts Andrew Lo, chief marketing and chief strategy officer for Kanetix.ca. Though some carriers have indicated their intention to enter the telematics arena in the near future, says Michael Brattman, president of the Insurance Brokers Association of Ontario (IBAO), others seem content to watch “on the sidelines as they determine how they will participate in this space.” Activity is clearly not only unfolding on the insurer and direct fronts. “There are a number of Tier 1 and some Tier 2 brokers who are trying telematics on their own,” Currie points out. Canadian insurers “have shown that telematics is something that is here to stay,” says Donna Ince, senior vice president of personal insurance for RSA Canada. 36 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
The insurer plans to launch telematics in the Canadian marketplace this year, Ince reports. This “is reflective of our commitment to ensuring our brokers have a competitive and compelling product proposition.” On the consumer front, though, some figures indicate telematics may be a bit of a tougher sell than anticipated.
“I think there is a need to first get started and get used to telematics, before trying something untested. Telematics itself is a radically different way of doing business for insurers, so it’s important to test and learn and to grow as your confidence with the data grows,” says Blair Currie of Intelligent Mechatronic Systems. Lo reports that his company carried out surveys gauging consumer awareness of usage-based insurance (UBI) in 2014 and 2015, and found it to be generally flat. “In 2014, 18% of (polled) Canadians were familiar with (UBI), and in 2015, 19% were familiar with it. However, Quebec is the exception, where awareness actually increased.”
SIMILAR MODELS Quebec, in fact, represents a bit of an odd (but less restrictive) duck. As it stands, there is a “sameness” today, both with regard to UBI products and discounts, notes Veilleux. “We think this has a lot to do with the regulators.”
Michel Laurin, president and chief operating officer of iA (Industrial Alliance) Auto and Home Insurance, says that he does not expect things to change “as long as the players in the insurance industry continue to replicate one another.” Wright would agree. “Market conditions and the regulatory environment would have to change in order for there to be more flexibility and greater differences among offers.” But Lo’s view is that the products will evolve. “In addition to discounts, I would think the products will be developed to include value-added services.” Despite the current “sameness,” Currie points out that, already, different models are in use: discount and surcharge, discount only, recycle and time-based. Currie says he sees the iA (Industrial Alliance) model in Quebec as “revolutionary because it takes advantage of both discounts and surcharges, and is based mostly on recent driving behaviour than traditional driving proxies.” While “differentiation is important, I think there is a need to first get started and get used to telematics, before trying something untested. Telematics itself is a radically different way of doing business for insurers, so it’s important to test and learn and to grow as your confidence with the data grows,” he says. “At this point, the most significant differentiator appears to be in the use of the data,” Brattman says. The ingenie offering for young drivers in Ontario (being rolled out to brokerages through IBAO, as well as through ingenie.ca) “is the first program with a quarterly adjustment in the policy premium,” he says. “This is significant when we look at ways to change driving behaviour. Waiting for an annual adjustment at the end of the policy is asking a lot of drivers to wait until the end of the policy period to be rewarded for good driving,” Brattman adds. Says Currie, “There is an interest in differentiation and the sameness you see at the start of many programs is just to get a proof of concept going, to get familiar managing physical devices versus paper or digital policies, to learn how
Wawanesa Motorcycles The best journey starts with the right coverage We’ve boosted our Motorcycle coverage to make rating faster and easier than ever. Ask your Wawanesa Insurance representative about our Enhanced Motorcycle Program, a suite of endorsements providing additional coverage for Protective Equipment, Motorcycle Accessories and more.
wawanesa.com
AUTO
|
HOME
|
BUSINESS
|
FARM
|
LIFE AND GROUP
COVER STORY
Driving Forward to deal with the tremendous volumes of data generated and to build models for ratings, customer relationship management and to better employ telematics for claims management and cost reduction.” The Kanetix survey shows those who were aware of the technology were likely to be younger (under 45), Lo reports. Additionally, men were more likely to be familiar with UBI than women. A survey of 1,000 consumers in the United States, released last summer by Towers Watson, revealed 79% of those polled “said they either would buy a UBI policy or are willing to consider the concept” if insurers guarantee that premiums would not increase. “We expect the uptake to increase as more cost-effective solutions become available, competition for the best drivers heats up, and the regulation changes — which it will in time,” Currie says. “Canadian companies tend to ‘stand on the shoulders of giants’ (to paraphrase Isaac Newton) and launch programs after they have been proven — at home or elsewhere,” he suggests. Savings will likely figure in how “proven” consumers view a program. “For young drivers insured through (iA’s) Mobiliz, the savings are very material; it can easily add up to more than $1,000 a year,” Laurin notes. “With our original plug-in device, customers were saving about 12% on average,” Veilleux says of the Ajusto program. Figures from DGIG show that 50% of clients save 10% or more. The “uptake has been good, on target, and we believe that our simpler offer using the smartphone app will bring even more customers to our UBI program,” Veilleux comments. The 2014 survey from Kanetix indicates that 30% of respondents said they would need to see savings of $100 to $249 annually on their insurance to switch to a UBI program. A further 26% of those polled reported that they would need savings of $250 to $500 a year. “Consumers obviously benefit from the upfront discounts,” Currie says. But the real “savings” may be the impact on driving behaviour and performance. 38 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
Experience, mostly from the U.S., shows “claims drop anywhere from 15% to 40% depending on the program,” he says. Based on scores and ratings on key driving indicators, “over 90% of young drivers and more than 70% of ‘regular’ drivers think they are above average. Many change their behaviour when they see they are below the 50% mark.”
Working with technology will evolve rapidly, suggests Michel Laurin of iA Auto and Home Insurance. “New ways for collecting information will appear, apps will be introduced and more is, for sure, to come in ways we don’t even expect today. We have to stay open to change.” Veilleux reports an Ajusto participant survey last year showed “a majority of users said they were more conscious of their driving behaviour and about half felt they were now safer drivers.” An ingenie client, says Brattman, “benefits from an automatic 10% enrollment discount with the ability to receive up to 25% based on good driving behaviour.” Based on experience in the U.K. and the U.S., telematics is expected to “reduce both the incidents and frequency as good driving behaviour is recognized and rewarded on a much more frequent basis than traditional underwriting methods.”
Currie points out that “those insurers we have with young driver programs believe they have saved lives — which is an incredible ROI if you think about it.” Aviva Canada announced last October it had committed to writing auto insurance using telematics provided by Quindell in partnership with Independent Broker Resources Inc. (IBRI), a subsidiary of IBAO. At the time, IBAO reported that Aviva Canada had selected Quindell on an exclusive basis for five years. “We firmly believe that telematics and usage-based insurance solutions will benefit our customers as we are able to customize their insurance based on individual driver experience, and reward safe driving behaviour with premiums,” Greg Somerville, chief executive officer of Aviva Canada, said last fall.“This initiative is consistent with our strategy of leveraging advanced data analytics and providing digital solutions that enhance value for our customers.” Beyond safety, Ince suggests Canadian insurers’ experiences with telematics to date “demonstrates that there is customer acceptance for the proposition and that it can be used as a way to assist in the management of Ontario rate decrease pressures and to continue to drive pricing and underwriting sophistication into auto portfolios.”
FUTURE FEATURES As more players emerge, what will the impact be? “As more telematics offerings are made available, the potential for niche offerings increases as insurance companies identify their target customers and, thereby, become more focused in their marketing to attract their preferred segments,” Brattman predicts. Veilleux says he can see telematics being offered for other types of vehicles, such as motorcycles. As well, additional value-added services could emerge. Lo agrees. “I think more value-added services will be added to telematics as the technology hits the mainstream. Things like discounts at major retailers for being a good driver, features that give the ability for parents to monitor driving
ESR ad full page:Layout 1
10/5/12
10:38
Page 2
Elliott Special Risks LP. A Markel International company
Commercial general liability Directors and oďŹƒcers liability Environmental impairment liability Marine program Professional liability Property and inland marine Security and protection industry Umbrella and excess liability
Helping brokers with eective insurance solutions since 1966. Montreal Toronto Calgary Vancouver www.elliottsr.com
COVER STORY
Driving Forward and travel of their children, roadside assistance and, even, vehicle diagnostics.” Currie sees the integration of contextual data sources — such as lighting conditions, road conditions, traffic and weather — giving rise to better analytics, insights and intelligence, leading to the development of surcharges. “Most of the conversation is around the business side of telematics,” he says. “But consumers have incredible say in the matter. We are building on business to provide connected car solutions that will benefit these consumers.”
which is already being built and has auto manufacturers considering their next steps.” Brattman suggests “apps are a good identifier to help determine if a customer is a good ‘fit’ for telematics.” A number of companies already offer apps, including Desjardins and Kanetix. Both apps “have made the technological leap to using smartphones instead of devices that plug into the car,” Lo says.
STALLING OUT? The activity and benefits are clear, but what are the consequences for those not yet in the game? Wright contends “an entry now would be more of a defensive move. To achieve competitive advantage would require offering something that would in all likelihood be unprofitable, either through richer discount benefits or because of the substantial marketing spend that would be required, or some combination of the two.” Others are not so sure. “The market is still in its infancy,” says Brattman. “There is an underlying belief that the better drivers will self-select themselves for telematics, so, although first-movers are expected to gain the upper hand, there is still plenty of room for innovation in the market. You only need to look south of the border to see the wide variety of telematics products and uses that favour consumers.” Currie says that industry is seeing better programs that are only now taking advantage of mobile technology, and a number of auto OEM (original equipment manufacturer) plays emerging. “Those already in will likely try to reduce costs, which may mean the increased use of mobile devices,” says Wright. Some companies are moving towards apps using mobile phones as the source of the data, says Robin Joshua, director of corporate underwriting and risk management for CAA Insurance Company (Ontario). “Eventually, this will be replaced by in-car technology, 40 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
“Usage-based insurance is not just a personal auto play — it is something that could be used in other lines of business as well by leveraging what other industries have already been implementing,” notes RSA Canada’s Donna Ince. “I also believe that you will see more insurers develop smartphone apps that monitor driving,” he predicts. While the maximum 25% discount for Ajusto drivers has not changed with the app, says Veilleux, how the driver is measured has. Desjardins is basing the discounts on the individual driver’s behaviour as opposed to the vehicle, which could have multiple drivers. Brokerage InsureMy Ltd. recently announced a new time-based insurance product for commercial drivers and fleets in both Alberta and Ontario. It allows commercial vehicle operators to pay their regular premium based on traditional rating criteria, but then receive a refund at the end of the term for vehicle inactivity.
Currie says there are a number of ways that embedded systems are evolving. For example, a number of auto OEMs are interested in selling data generated via the vehicle, the data for which will need to be priced and graded before it can be sold on marketplaces, he says. “Embedded systems are also resulting in dealer plays where auto dealers use telematics for asset management, generating recurring revenue, to capture repairs and to enhance loyalty over very long purchase cycles,” Currie reports. “New ways for collecting information will appear, apps will be introduced and more is, for sure, to come in ways we don’t even expect today. We have to stay open to change,” suggests Laurin.
GETTING CONNECTED “Telematics is really just a subset of connected car solutions. While telematics will grow for personal lines and commercial lines business, it will also push into the life side of insurance (not just with speed ratings) but with health telematics,” Currie predicts. “With the use of Apple Watch and FitBit, healthier people may receive discounts. However, that is far in the future. The majority of Canadians surveyed still have grave concerns with privacy when using telematics for cars,” Lo cautions. “It will also touch the property side of insurance because homes or farms with vehicles parked beside them will be safer,” Currie adds. Laurin suggests that such areas as commercial auto, long-haul trucking, motorcycles and snow vehicles are natural fits with telematics longer term. Unica Insurance recently endorsed Fleetadvisor, a commercial auto insurance product announced earlier this year by IBRI. The tool “will provide sophisticated data as a means to refine fleet rates,” said Dave Smiley, vice president of operations at Unica Insurance. Most importantly for brokers, Smiley noted, the tool “will enable them to solidify client/broker relationships by putting brokers in a position of a true fleet risk management advisor.”
property
|
auto
|
business
Because their story is ours too. When our policyholders feel good about their claims experience, so do we. That’s why we’re committed to providing quick, reliable and caring service, earning a reputation our broker partners have counted on since 1871. Watch real claims journeys at economicalinsurance.com/stories
The Economical brand includes the following property and casualty insurance companies: Economical Mutual Insurance Company, Perth Insurance Company, Waterloo Insurance Company, The Missisquoi Insurance Company, Federation Insurance Company of Canada. ©2015 Economical Insurance. All rights reserved. Economical® and related trademarks, names and logos are the property of Economical Mutual Insurance Company and are registered and/or used in Canada. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners.
COVER STORY
Driving Forward
“Outside of Quebec, the regulatory regime is a chokepoint that prevents innovation and the realization of the potential that UBI has to offer,” argues Colin Wright of Corner Two Consulting. “The regulators need to step aside.” Wright says telematics as a platform has enormous potential to deliver a range of non-insurance services. “I don’t see one service, insurance or anything else, being the ‘killer app’; I believe that the “killer app” will be an array of services that share a common platform and, therefore, the cost of delivery,” he says. “The really big picture is when all vehicles are connected so that we can have vehicle to vehicle (V2V) communications and infrastructure to vehicle (I2V) communications,” Currie says. “That’s going to be the real, long-term promise of telematics,” he maintains. “Once enough data has been collected, analytics will allow rates to be developed based on the experience, which would result in rates commensurate with driving habits,” Joshua says. “In the future, telematics will be a true rate for the individual and not a rate for general groups,” he suggests. Noting that companies are currently focused on different rating variables, eventually, everyone will use similar variables, Joshua believes. “However, the providers will try to differentiate with additional features, be it diagnostics, infotainment or traffic information.” UBI “is not just a personal auto play — it is something that could be used in other lines of business as well by leveraging what other industries have already been implementing,” Ince comments. “For example, the concept of the ‘connected home’ is very real in other industries, for home monitoring products offered by telecom companies. Those connections (very similar to ‘sensors’) can very intuitively be leveraged into insurance to help the customer better manage risk (water, theft, occupancy, 42 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
etc.) and they afford a very similar communication platform akin to what we are seeing on the automobile side.”
REMOVING ROADBLOCKS Much of this promise, however, may not have a chance to play out — or play out as quickly as possible — absent changes on the regulatory front. Laurin and Veilleux agree regulators must be more flexible. “At Industrial Alliance, we consider ourselves lucky to operate in the province of Quebec where the regulator lets the market drive itself on the basis of free competition. It has allowed Quebec insurers to become much more creative in developing new products which, in turn, has given them a hedge in becoming more and more influential in the Canadian market as a whole,” Laurin suggests. “Outside of Quebec, the regulatory regime is a chokepoint that prevents innovation and the realization of the potential that UBI has to offer,” Wright argues. “The regulators need to step aside and stick to fulfilling their mandates of ensuring the financial health and stability of insurers to safeguard the public,” he maintains. “Let the market decide how the product should be priced and allow both discounting and surcharging. That would make for a more transparent product and a more competitive product, both of which would significantly benefit consumers,” Wright contends. “In the future, with more mature Canadian data, the regulator will be in a better position to allow for more elaborate offerings, which ensures that consumers are protected and that telematics products are sustainable,” says Brattman.
“Customer customization and fulfilling the wants of the client will go a long way in encouraging consumers to embrace telematics,” Lo suggests, but emphasizes consumer concerns over privacy and how the data could be used will also need to be addressed. “Customer behaviours and expectations of how they want to do business are rapidly evolving and, as a result, the insurance and broker business landscape is shifting,” comments Ince. Currie sees telematics becoming “very personal and drivers will, in the near future, have driving scores and be able to shop around their data. BYOD will expand into ‘bring your own data’ and consumers will use their data to select an insurance carrier. This is one of the places where brokers will remain relevant.” Hugh McTavish, president of InsureMy and president of Godfrey Morrow Insurance and Financial Services, said during a recent technology conference that telematics “actually provides more opportunity for me to discuss things” with customers and represents a way for brokers to add value. “There is more data, there are more touch points.” Telematics, Joshua predicts, “will become the norm. The data being collected individually and collectively will drive how insurance works, how individual policies are rated, product development, vehicle safety and traffic management.” A report last year from Aite Group LLC would seem to bear that out. Aite predicts UBI, as a business model, and telematics, as a technology enabler, will “act as bridges towards an inevitable future for the insurance industry.”
ANNOUNCEMENT
The Board of Directors of CANATICS is pleased to announce that the newest tool in the fight against auto insurance fraud is now fully operational. The Board is also pleased to introduce the leadership team behind CANATICS. The auto insurance industry created CANATICS in 2013 in response to the growing problem of organized insurance crime, and following recommendations from the Ontario government’s Anti-Fraud Task Force. Ben Kosic was named President and CEO. Mr. Kosic has more than 20 years’ experience running large projects in management and information technology across a diverse range of sectors, including insurance, insurance fraud, IT, health and pensions. His past roles include: Partner and Business Intelligence Practice Lead with KPMG Canada, and Chief Information Officer and Chief Financial Officer of Chartwell IRM Inc. He is a results-oriented leader with a track record of driving growth and excellence in delivery. Ben Kosic
In early 2015, the leadership team was extended to include: Mario Silvestre, VP, Analytics and Operations Mr. Silvestre has over 20 years’ experience in auto insurance claims management, working for leading insurers such as Cooperators and RSA. He has prior experience and knowledge working with the same data analytics technology being used by CANATICS. In his most recent role with RSA, as Director of Shared Services, Mario led the implementation of their fraud detection strategy. Mario Silvestre
Alexander Adeyinka, Chief Privacy Officer and General Counsel Mr. Adeyinka has over 20 years’ experience as a lawyer in the communications industry, most recently with Rogers Communications as Associate Chief Privacy Officer & Senior Regulatory Counsel, and prior to that as Vice President, Regulatory Law & Policy. In addition to substantial privacy law work he was significantly involved in legislative and regulatory policy submissions to government and communications regulators. Alexander Adeyinka
CANATICS analyzes pooled auto insurance industry data, using the most current tools, to identify suspicious claims that individual insurers can then investigate. As of April 1, the system is up and running and sending alerts to member insurance companies. Learn more at www.canatics.ca
CANATICS ad/CU.indd 1
15-04-08 11:58 AM
Greg Meckbach Associate Editor
Criminals are getting more sophisticated at cloning vehicle identification numbers. But because there is no single tool specifically designed to detect cloning, some consumers who buy vehicles do not realize they are actually stolen or declared irrepairable, often leaving insurers on the hook. Insurance carriers can be victimized twice when criminals “clone” a vehicle identification number (VIN): once when a vehicle is stolen and again with a cloned VIN, if both owners make claims. Although there appears to be no tool specifically designed to detect such a crime, experts suggest risk to consumers and their auto insurers can be reduced if prospective buyers check the histories of vehicles, especially when buying through online advertising services. A VIN is a series of 17 letters and numbers that identifies each individual vehicle in North
44 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
America and is placed on the dashboard and other areas of a vehicle, notes information from Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC). A criminal may take a VIN “from a wrecked vehicle and place it on a stolen vehicle to mask its identity.” Some criminals also “look into the windshield of a car, copy the VIN number from the dashboard and reprint that number on an engine and clone that VIN,” reports Mario Silvestre, vice president of analytics and operations at Canadian National Insurance Crime Services (CANATICS), a non-profit organization that uses data analytics tools to identify suspicious claims and facilitate investigations by insurance companies. By cloning an existing vehicle’s VIN, “a criminal may be able to sell a vehicle that was stolen or has serious hidden damage,” IBC notes. “An unsuspecting consumer who purchases a stolen vehicle may have it permanently seized by the police.”
INVENTIVE FRAUDSTERS VIN cloning is “one of the main ways that thieves are changing the identity of the vehicles in order to sell them or ship them out” of Canada, says Constable Matt Pelissier of the commercial auto crime bureau at Peel Regional Police, whose jurisdiction includes the cities of Brampton and Mississauga, west of Toronto. Pelissier’s duties
Illustration by Dominic Bugatto/threeinabox.com
Attack of the Clones
include identifying re-VINed vehicles. The Royal Canadian Mounted Police does not keep nation-wide statistics on the extent of the problem, although Statistics Canada notes in a paper that was published last July that the total rate of police-reported vehicle theft in the country dropped about 62% from 2003 to 2013. “From a size and scope perspective, it’s pretty hard to get a handle as to how big of a problem it is right across the country,” Garry Robertson, national director of investigations at IBC, says of VIN cloning. But police in Canada “are starting to see an increase in the number of vehicles being stolen and re-VINed as clones to
insBlogs
dollar is a factor. In the past, he suggests stolen motorcycles were having cloned VINs installed “and then put back on the road and sold through Kijiji” and other similar online advertising services.
Silvestre, adding that a vehicle with a cloned VIN could be sold to an unsuspecting victim. “That person insures the vehicle and pays the premium for it,” he says. “This is really a sophisticated crime.” TOUGH TO PINPOINT An insurer must respond to a claim if “Today in the industry, there is really the vehicle owner “shows they bought no tool that is specifically designed to the vehicle in good faith,” such as havprevent or catchInsurance VIN cloning,” reports ing paperwork Blogs hosted by Canadian Underwriter confirming the purchase
insBlogs
Recent Blog Posts Featured on
insBlogs.com
Insurance Blogs hosted by Canadian Underwriter Random thoughts: Drones by Christian Bieck – May 11 Technology, Innovation, and the Evolution of our Industry by Catherine Smola – May 4 How Much Have Ontario No-Fault Accident Benefits Been Eroding? by Willie Handler – April 30 Another Sneak Peek at Retention Factors by Christian Bieck – April 27
legitimate vehicles or with false (VINs),” says Bob Lucas, a former police officer who is now an investigator for the Ontario Motor Vehicle Industry Council, which administers the provincial Motor Vehicle Dealers Act. “The stronger American dollar and global market makes the sale of these vehicles more profitable,” Lucas points out. The Canadian dollar has dropped, from US$0.91 in April 2014 to US$0.82 in late April 2015, against the U.S. dollar. “On a domestic level, we’ll soon see a greater demand for our vehicles by American consumers as a result of the savings created by the buying power of their currency,” Lucas predicts. Robertson agrees the lower Canadian
More Benefit Cuts Coming for Ontario Auto Insurance Consumers by Willie Handler – April 24 SCC finds Nexus in Zurich v. Chubb by Daniel Strigberger – April 22 Ridesharing Bill Proceeds Through Ontario Legislature by Willie Handler – April 22 Want a Sneak Peek at the IBV Customer Retention Study? by Christian Bieck – April 20 Ontario Rates Continue to Decrease Slowly by Willie Handler – April 19 Who Is Profiting Most From Ontario Auto Insurance? by Willie Handler – April 11
May 2015 Canadian Underwriter
45
and showing that they paid fair market value, explains Kevin McConkey, director of casualty claims at Allstate Insurance Company of Canada. “All the innocent parties are the victims,” of VIN cloning, McConkey warns. “This could be multiple parties, including the person who’s VIN got stolen, the person who bought the car with the cloned VIN and the insurance company. Sometimes other parties are involved, too — like car dealerships that can get in the middle of car sales,” he says. Pelissier notes that, in many cases, consumers are not aware that they are buying cloned vehicles. “Maybe they are getting a bit of a deal,” he says of consumers who buy vehicles with false VIN plates. “Obviously, in some cases, they have some knowledge that there’s something up with the vehicle,” Pelissier adds. Insurance companies are affected by VIN cloning “when they become involved in the fraud and have to pay out on claims,” notes McConkey. “Sometimes, insurers could even end up paying twice — once on the stolen car and then again on the car with the cloned VIN if both owners make a claim.”
STOLEN OR WORSE? There are resources to help consumers. In Ontario, for example, the Ministry of Transportation (MTO) is notified by police when a vehicle is declared stolen. All transactions involving stolen vehicles are blocked on the ministry’s vehicle registration system database. Consumers may only buy a used vehicle for on-road use if the status of the vehicle is either “rebuilt” or “none.” Vehicles that have been declared a total loss must be assigned a different brand — either “irrepairable” or “salvage” — by the insurer, owner, dealer, auto recycler, salvager or auctioneer. VIN cloning is “an ongoing issue” in the Greater Toronto Area, says Pelissier, adding that he regularly works with police officers in the neighbouring jurisdictions of Toronto, York and Halton, as well as with IBC, insurance investigators, the Canada Border Services Agency 46 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
and the MTO. The Canadian Police Information Centre database lets consumers know if a VIN belongs to a vehicle that has been reported as stolen, Pelissier says, or consumers can also search databases such as Carfax and CarProof. “They are not all fool-proof, but they are of assistance,” he suggests.
“Changes in the design and manufacturer of (VIN) plates, labels and placards and the advancement in computer technology make it very easy to reproduce public points of identification to mask the true identity of a stolen vehicle.” In addition, Robertson advises that consumers can use VIN history checks to look for suspicious patterns. “Especially if you are going through an online auction or something like Kijiji or eBay or anything like that, look at the VIN number and see if there is a history to it,” he recommends. “Especially if the history is out of province, or particularly out of country, then that should make the person look a little bit further
at it, and the same holds true with the insurers when they are looking at the underwriting. What’s the history on that vehicle? Do we have a consistent history in Ontario?” Vehicle makers “are trying to improve VIN tags so they are more tamper-proof,” reports McConkey. “In addition, there are now tools like the National Motor Vehicle Title Information System, which is a registrar of VINs across the U.S.,” he says. “It’s designed to keep stolen vehicles from being sold and help prevent title fraud. The problem right now is that it only includes U.S. VINs. However, there is talk about bringing Mexico and Canada on board as well to help prevent cross-border cloning,” he points out. Lucas warns that “changes in the design and manufacturer of (VIN) plates, labels and placards and the advancement in computer technology make it very easy to reproduce public points of identification to mask the true identity of a stolen vehicle.” The practice of VIN cloning is “getting more sophisticated,” McConkey suggests. “As the industry tries to come up with ways to combat VIN cloning — in hopes to make things better — the perpetrators figure out ways to get around our solutions.” So, for now, “it is kind of buyer beware,” Pelissier cautions. “A lot of times when we recover these vehicles, there is not sufficient information provided by the purchaser as to where they got the vehicle. They might have a name and a cellphone number, they may have met in a parking lot somewhere, but there’s not a lot of information for us to follow it up if we don’t already have an active investigation targeting the sellers.” Allstate Insurance recommends that consumers check the VIN history of cars before buying, even if they are brand new. “If a deal seems too good to be true, it probably is,” suggests McConkey. “A consumer should never be pushed, or rushed into a car purchase. If the person selling the vehicle says, ‘the deal is only good today,’ then the buyer should walk away,” he advises.
It’s Time to Make a Difference
16th Annual
Ontario Golf Tournament on July 6, 2015 Held at the prestigious Angus Glen Golf Club Online golfer registration and sponsorship opportunities available now at:
www.wicc.ca Design donated by
27376_golf ad#2.indd 1
5/14/15 10:01 AM
Managing
Threats
A new report by the Insurance Institute of Canada takes a broad look at cyber risk and suggests how Canadian property and casualty insurance organizations can bolster their own cyber security and protect themselves in cyberspace.
Peter Hohman
President and Chief Executive Officer, Insurance Institute of Canada
Cyberspace is a risky place to be right now — a breeding ground for identity thieves, extortionists and fraudsters to steal valuable information from people and companies and sell it for profit. Media headlines are near-daily reminders that managing cyber risk has emerged as a major issue for Canadian property and casualty insurance companies and the clients they protect. But the exposures are not fully known and change very quickly. What can the Canadian p&c insurance industry do to bolster its resilience to cyber attacks? How can insurance organizations make sure that their clients are protected? The Insurance Institute of Canada’s seminal report on cyber risk — the research was prepared by Paul Kovacs, founder and executive director of the Institute for Catastrophic Loss Reduction, and president and chief executive officer of the Property and Casualty Insurance Compensation Corporation — makes a number of recommendations specifically targeting Canadian p&c insurance organizations. Cyber Risks: Implications for the Insurance Industry in Canada surveys the most common forms of cyber attacks, who the criminals are and what they are after, the type and scope of cyber losses, and why the losses are expected to get worse, including catastrophic scenarios in which criminals knock
48 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
out the power grid via cyberspace. The report provides a number of specific recommendations to help Canadian p&c insurance organizations bolster their resilience to cyber attacks, including encouraging organizations to do the following: • appoint a senior executive to develop and implement a comprehensive plan to manage and reduce the long-term consequences of cyber risks; • identify the consumer information and corporate knowledge that matters most, and then direct the highest protection effort to shield these critical assets; and • build a corporate culture of cyber security that includes actions to address technological threats and security training for employees.
PROTECTING THE INDUSTRY “I think the research report is absolutely needed,” says Serge Solski, vice president of business development at Watsec, which provides consulting services to insurance and other businesses on cyber risk. “The more people who can talk about this, the better. When people say things like, ‘I’m too small, or ‘I’m in a small town, they are not going to look for me,’ well, we’re in one big town and it’s called the Internet,” Solski advises.
“It doesn’t matter what size you are, cyber criminals don’t care. This is a global problem. No one is safe from it based on geography,” he contends. “About one in five small businesses will be hit. We focus on small and medium-sized business for this reason: 60% of them who are hit won’t be around after six months. They will be bankrupt or in financial ruin. That’s a pretty severe risk to be taking with your eyes closed,” Solski cautions. Offering a brief history of how Canadian p&c insurance organizations have shifted their approach to cyber security over time, the report notes that in the early days, for example, “information technology professionals managed the detection, response and threat of cyber attacks,” adding that “technology experts managed the threat that technology might disrupt corporate activity.” But the characteristics of cyber threats changed, as did the way Canadian insurance organizations managed the risk. Casual hackers sending infectious worms and viruses gave way to more sophisticated security attacks by cyber criminals seeking to steal or destroy personal data and corporate information. In response, the report notes p&c insurance companies “developed an approach that combined the expertise of security specialists and information technology experts.” The emergence of enterprise risk management (ERM) means several insurance organizations no longer manage cyber risk in a vacuum. Cyber risks are assessed in relation to all of the other risks facing the p&c organization. “This integration supports a better evaluation of the resources that should be devoted to detecting and mitigating the consequences of attacks,” the report states.
RESOURCES TO PROTECT INSURANCE ORGANIZATIONS The report lists a variety of resources to help Canadian p&c insurance organizations assess their exposure to cyber threats, including the Cyber Security SelfAssessment Guidance, issued in October 2013 by the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI).
OSFI’s guidance includes 89 questions that probe whether or not Canadian p&c organizations have an adequate cyber security framework. The self-assessment template lists desirable properties and characteristics of cyber security practices that could be considered by insurance and other financial institutions when assessing the adequacy of their own cyber security frameworks. It encourages organizations to assess if their structures are capable of managing cyber risk not just from IT, technical or risk control points of view, but also from a broader ERM perspective. All federally regulated financial institutions “are encouraged to reflect the current state of cyber security practices in their assessments rather than their target state, and consider cyber security practices on an enterprise-wide basis,” OSFI points out. “Attackers realize that technology is very, very difficult to crack now, so now everything is just coming through social engineering,” explains Solski, who observed that a cyber attack on Target was not an IT issue, but rather the business practice of giving external contractors privileged access to the company’s network where sensitive financial information was being stored. A broader risk management approach would have highlighted the situation as a potential exposure, he contends. “If you’re not addressing your people problem, you’re not addressing cyber risk,” Solski argues. “People are your number 1 exposure. They’re the ones that cannot be patched by technology.”
PROTECTING CLIENTS AGAINST RISK “There is considerable scope for insurance to penetrate into new fields of cyber security,” the report states. The global cost of cyber crime in 2013 was between $375 billion and $575 billion, comparable to the worldwide damage resulting from vehicle collisions ($518 billion), the report adds. But whereas global auto insurance premiums exceed international estimates of vehicle collision damage, global cyber insurance premiums are less than one
half of one per cent of the estimated cost of cyber crime. Cyber risk can be seen as a business opportunity for insurers, since many cyber risks are not insured. As the report notes, insurers have been very successful in breach and identity theft coverage, but barriers remain to expanding coverage into other areas, such as the theft of trade secrets and accumulated risk associated with a catastrophic cyber incident. The report explores what needs to be done to remove these barriers so that protection for clients can be comprehensive in scope. A Risk Education Cyber Risks: Implications for the Insurance Industry in Canada makes several recommendations to help Canadian property and casualty insurance organizations provide solutions for cyber risks in Canada. Among them, it proposes that the industry engage in future public policy discussions about cyber security. Participating in public discussions about emerging risks requires that risk professionals be educated and well-informed about different aspects of insurance and risk transfer. To this end, the Insurance Institute is introducing a number of new measures to keep insurance professionals’ knowledge of emerging risks current and relevant, including a new series of Emerging Issues Research Reports (of which the cyber report is the first to be released) and a new, three-course Risk Management Certificate, meant to provide industry professionals with the tools and knowledge they need to help create comprehensive risk management strategies for their clients. Successful completion of the three courses — Risk Management Principles and Practices, Risk Assessment and Treatment, and Risk Financing — will qualify individuals to take the exams leading to the Canadian Risk Management (CRM) designation.
May 2015 Canadian Underwriter
49
Opinion/Analysis
Sustainable Repair
Rocco Neglia Vice President of Claims, Economical Insurance
Sustainability is arguably the most important issue facing the collision repair industry today. More and more, insurance companies are looking to partner with collision repair shops that are demonstrating a clear commitment to creating a sustainable collision repair industry. The depth of a repairer’s commitment to sustainable operations and practices is likely to play a role in whether or not it succeeds in the future, and if it is able to engage in long-term relations with the insurance industry. By adopting sustainable workflows and processes, repairers are sending a clear message to their insurance partners that they are on a journey to improving their efficiency and profitability, and becoming more competitive. Repairers can achieve this by identifying and stripping out waste. It becomes a win for the repairer, its employees, the consumer, their insurance partners and, ultimately, the planet. In a nutshell, sustainability in the collision repair industry is about extracting more value from fewer resources. It is about doing business
50 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
smarter — being more productive and efficient — which reduces costs and increases profitability and capacity. It must be viewed as an investment in a repairer’s long-term competitive advantage. Many insurance companies, including Economical Insurance, support sustainability because it helps the collision repair industry be more respectful of the planet. When workflows and processes are made more efficient, unnecessary costs are removed, performance improves and capacity increases, which aids in stabilizing overall repair costs and enhances the repairer’s profitability. When a repairer is more profitable, investments can be made in people and in the business to keep pace with developments in technology. Increased efficiency and capacity ensures that repairs are made to the highest standards and that repair delivery dates are honoured. That, in turn, helps ensure policyholders receive the level of service they expect, including getting their vehicles back on the date promised. Economical Insurance recently partnered with
Illustration by Dominic Bugatto/threeinabox.com
A clear commitment to using sustainable practices is something insurers are looking for in their collision repair partners, who themselves can benefit by being ready to meet consumer needs in the unfolding low-carbon economy and investing in an approach that could translate into a long-term competitive advantage.
c
Recent Insurance Press Releases featured on insPRESS.ca Pario Engineering and Environmental Sciences appoints Mark Samis as Vice President, Environmental Services by SCM Insurance Services – Apr 30
NIAC Claims System Readiness Close At Hand as Bill C-22 Approved By Senate by NIAC (Nuclear Insurance Association of Canada) – Apr 14
FIRST Canada offers IBAA delegates Payment Solutions that Engage and Grow Their Business by FIRST Insurance Funding of Canada – Apr 30
FIRST Insurance Funding of Canada Announces A Dedicated Sales Team for Quebec and the Atlantic by FIRST Insurance Funding of Canada – Apr 13
WINMAR® Franchise Corp Announces the Opening of WINMAR Nanaimo by WINMAR – Apr 30
ProFormance Group’s Training Division Expands Nationally by ProFormance Group Inc. – Apr 13
Elliott Special Risks is relocating May 22nd by Elliott Special Risks Ltd. – Apr 30
Creechurch Expands in Western Canada with Opening of Vancouver Office by Creechurch International Undewriters – Apr 13
10,000 policies in under 10 Months by Insurance Technology Solutions Inc. – Apr 29 ARC Group Spring Seminar 2015 - A personal invitation from keynote Ray Boisvert: Are you cyber ready? by The ARC Group Canada | Le Groupe ARC Canada – Apr 29 SCM appoints Ross Betteridge as new President to lead ClaimsPro by SCM Insurance Services – Apr 29 Bermuda promotes captive insurance to Canadian industry by Bermuda Business Development Agency – Apr 29 Paul Davis Celebrates Unity through Refreshed Brand by Paul Davis – Apr 29 FIRST Canada offers IBAM Delegates Payment Solutions that are Anything but Conventional by FIRST Insurance Funding of Canada – Apr 23 Cunningham Lindsey Introduces Enhanced Claims Management System by Cunningham Lindsey Canada Claims Services Ltd. – Apr 22 Expert panel to tackle cyber risk at the ARC Group’s Spring Seminar by The ARC Group Canada | Le Groupe ARC Canada – Apr 21 DKI Canada Welcomes Frank Sparfel To The Team At Head Office by DKI Canada – Apr 20 Here’s how drones are going to transform the insurance industry by EagleView Technologies, Inc. – Apr 17 Distracted walking: Could mobile phone use affect a person’s likelihood of slipping/tripping and falling? by SCM Insurance Services – Apr 17 Crime Stoppers of Halton receives $50,000 commitment from Economical Insurance by Economical Insurance – Apr 16 ARC Group heads to The Big Easy by The ARC Group Canada | Le Groupe ARC Canada – Apr 15 ENCON Group Inc. Celebrates the One-year Anniversary of its CGL and Umbrella Liability Facility by Encon Group Inc. – Apr 15 FIRST Insurance Funding of Canada Announces A Dedicated Sales Team for British Columbia by FIRST Insurance Funding of Canada – Apr 14
Save the date in May: The ARC Group’s spring seminar brings you leading speakers on cyber risk by The ARC Group Canada | Le Groupe ARC Canada – Apr 10 Canada Embraces More Analytics for Insurance Industry Growth by FC Business – Apr 9 Crawford & Company (Canada) Inc.’s Global Technical Services (GTS) Strengthens Team with Industry-Recognized Marine Professionals by Crawford & Company (Canada) Inc. – Apr 9 SPECS Limited – New Program Development Manager – Sidney, British Columbia by SPECS (Specialized Property Evaluation Control Services) – Apr 8 The Boiler Inspection and Insurance Company of Canada (HSB BI&I) celebrates 140 years by HSB BI&I – Apr 8 Roberston Morris Consulting marks its first full year of operation by Robertson Morris Consulting – Apr 8 On Side Restoration Ontario Ushers in Personnel Changes in Support of Continuous Performance Improvements by On Side Restoration Services Ltd. – Apr 8 SPECS Limited Appoints New Director of Operations – Greig Boyle by SPECS (Specialized Property Evaluation Control Services) – Apr 7 SPECS Ltd. Announces New Quebec City Office Location by SPECS (Specialized Property Evaluation Control Services) – Apr 6 Cunningham Lindsey Appoints Darren Berg Director, Quality Assurance & Training, Major Loss Services by Cunningham Lindsey Canada Claims Services Ltd. – Apr 6 TRINITY Underwriting Managers Ltd launches insurance product for anti-spam exposures by Trinity Underwriting Managers – Apr 6 Economical Insurance appoints Dr. Micheál Kelly, Dean of Laurier’s School of Business and Economics, to its board of directors by Economical Insurance – Apr 1 Zurich Canada launches drone insurance package for corporate clients by Zurich Global – Apr 1
Read the Full Story for Each Press Release
Putting the pieces together.
Events and Seminars Calendar You work hard to protect your clients’ property. Now, it’s time to ensure that you apply the same kind of energy and commitment to your own success. CIP Society Events and Seminars give you the opportunity to learn, to network, to catch up on industry developments and to think about your career.
CIP Society Events
PROedge Seminars & Professional Development Curriculum
St. John’s – CIP Society Spring Fling .................................................... May 20 Toronto – Annual Fellows’ Reception .................................................. May 20 Ottawa – CIP Society Trivia Night ........................................................ May 21 Calgary – Battle of the Insurance Bands .............................................. May 21 Toronto – Golf Tournament .................................................................... June 8 Vancouver – Golf Tournament ................................................................ June 5
Winnipeg – PROedge: Financials for the Non-Financial Professional ...... May 26 Webinar – ADVANTAGE LIVE: Being Social Online ................................. June 2 Ottawa – Spring Luncheon: Empathetic Claims Handling .................... June 4 Edmonton – Essential Management Skills ....................................... June 9-11 Calgary – PROedge: Beyond the Sales Script ....................................... June 11 Conestoga – Building Better Relationships at Work ........................ October 1 Edmonton – Think on Your Feet® ............................................. October 20-21
Keeping you at the forefront of the P&C industry. The CIP Society. MEMBERS BENEFIT. www.insuranceinstitute.ca/cipsociety
AkzoNobel, a leading global paints and coatings company ranked number one on the Dow Jones Sustainability Index, to develop a sustainability assessment tool that allows it to identify collision repair facilities sharing the same commitment to continuous process improvement in their business practices. The tool has been used to audit more than 400 of the insurer’s designated repair facilities. Both companies have a shared vision of sustainability and sustainable business practices within the collision repair industry. Both also see that the low-carbon economy is already under way, meaning insurers must be prepared to meet consumer needs in a low-carbon economy. With the tool, the criteria has been enriched to help identify, evaluate and select preferred vendors focused on continuous process improvement and those that are making investments in becoming more efficient and more profitable, as well as developing a solid plan towards sustainability. The tool — Economical Insurance was recognized with AkzoNobel’s FIT Sustainability Award in 2014 — further helps to demonstrate that operational efficiency, lean practices, greater profits and environmental sustainability are not mutually exclusive goals. The tool is made available to collision centres that want to measure themselves in the area of sustainable practices or that are seeking guidance on futureproofing their business in terms that can be easily understood and actioned. This will help them boost their competitiveness in the marketplace. From a profit standpoint, when a collision repair shop strips out waste in its workflow and practices, it becomes more efficient and profitable, ultimately becoming more competitive. From an insurance perspective, when a shop is more efficient and is able to increase its production capacity along with reducing repair cycle times, overall claim costs are reduced. The adoption of AkzoNobel’s concepts of process-centered environments has improved the efficiency of Economical
Insurance’s claims-handling process, and has harmonized workflows with the activities of the collision repair shops, thereby reducing touch time in the repair process and allowing for more efficient and effective deployment of resources.
From a profit standpoint, when a collision repair shop strips out waste in its workflow and practices, it becomes more efficient and profitable, ultimately becoming more competitive. In addition, strides made by accredited collision repair networks mean they are trusted to make repair decisions on the insurer’s behalf and to address customer needs right away. They are accountable for those decisions as part of a robust re-inspection and audit process, the net effect of which is a smoother process with shorter cycle times. Awareness of sustainable business practices help repairers realize how they can strip out waste in their workflows and reduce costs to improve the bottom line. It helps the industry be more prof-
itable and capable of investing in the technology necessary to be accredited for making repairs to vehicles that are constructed with increasingly sophisticated technology and advanced materials. Initiatives that will improve a repairer’s sustainability include the following: • consider ways of improving the frontoffice administration and processing of claims to reduce touch time and to save money on internal expenses and overhead; • stay up to date on the best, most efficient products and follow through on investments in the business to stay efficient; • ensure 100% compliance in the proper disposal of paints and other hazardous materials; • reduce energy costs by investing in more efficient lighting, compressors and spray booths, as well as by taking steps to reduce heat loss; • reduce water consumption by capturing and reusing car wash water; • upgrade lighting and insulation to qualify for available improvement grants; • involve employees in business sustainability efforts so that employees understand the positive impact to the bottom line, and that a stronger bottom line translate to both better job stability and growth opportunities; • have repair shops tell their sustainability stories to enhance their corporate images and reputations; and • have repair shops give back to their communities through donations and sponsorships to demonstrate their longterm commitment to the communities they serve. The first and foremost step towards achieving sustainability is accepting the fact that a sustainable repair industry is vital to its future success. Repair shops need to know how to read the signs of change in their marketplace. As such, they must be prepared to invest as they build their sustainability plan, they need to always be aware of the impacts on the customer and the environment, and they must never lose focus of front-line employees in their drive towards sustainability. May 2015 Canadian Underwriter
53
Modern App-roach Technology offers great promise, but the reliance that people now have on their phones has had the unfortunate effect of contributing to distracted driving, now a leading cause of vehicle collisions.
Ted Hellard Founder, AppColony
Paul Mlodzik Vice President, Marketing and Communications, The Co-operators
Ever taken a call or replied to a text while driving? Most would agree that distracted driving is dangerous, and yet people rationalize taking that call or sending that text because it takes just a few seconds. It turns out those few seconds matter a lot. Distracted driving is a factor in about 4 million collisions in North America each year, notes the Canadian Automobile Association (CAA). CAA further cites figures from the Government of Canada, which reports economic losses caused by traffic collision-related health care costs and lost productivity are at least $10 billion annually; from Alberta Transportation, which reports distracted drivers are three times more likely to be in a crash than attentive drivers; and from the British Columbia RCMP, which reports distracted driving was a contributing factor in 104 collision deaths in the province in 2010. A Virginia Tech Transportation Institute (VTTI) study of heavy vehicles or trucks, released in 2010, found that texting while driving raises a driver’s crash risk by 23 times and that dialing a cellphone made the risk of crash or near-crash event 5.9 times as high as non-distracted driving. Separate VTTI research on light vehicles or cars showed that dialing a cellphone made the risk
54 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
of crash or near-crash event 2.8 times as high as non-distracted driving, while that risk was 1.3 times higher when talking or listening on a cellphone. Distracted driving is not tracked as part of an insurance claim, making it impossible to accurately or reliably measure the impact of distracted driving on claims costs or auto premiums. Even in the aftermath of an accident, there is no reliable way to determine whether or not distraction was a factor. However, a distracted driving conviction does affect a person’s premium. A driver convicted of using a hand-held communication device while driving will generally see a premium increase of 5% to 10% for a first infraction. This indicates just how seriously insurance companies view the issue of distracted driving, despite specific and reliable statistics being unavailable. 2014 research conducted by Catalyst Canada shows that more than half of Canadians now own smartphones, and owners seem to have become increasingly dependent on them for pretty much everything. As smartphones have risen in popularity, reports of distracted driving have also risen sharply. Anecdotally, law enforcement officials in the country
say distracted driving contributes to as much as 80% of collisions on Canadian roads.
CHALLENGES PERSIST Distracted driving incidents are entirely preventable. However, the reliance on (and addiction to) personal devices — which provide connection to family, friends, information and entertainment — makes reducing the number of distracted driving events a challenge. This challenge persists despite the actions taken by Canadian provinces and territories to enact laws restricting or prohibiting phone usage while driving, and the fact that enforcing these laws has become a priority for police. While the logical solution is simple — turn off phones when behind the wheel — logic and the law have failed to persuade all drivers to refrain from talking or texting while driving. It is not that Canadian motorists are not looking for a solution: an independent survey by Insights Matter, conducted on behalf of OneTap — an app created by AppColony, with support from The Cooperators Group Limited — found that 91% of polled Canadians feel it is important to address distracted driving. However, if technology is the problem, perhaps it can also be the solution. The survey indicates that 59% of the individuals polled feel technology will help reduce the problem of distracted driving, and app developers know this. Recently, a number of new smartphone apps have been introduced, including OneTap, that seek to tackle the distracted driving challenge by eliminating those distractions. The free app, available in English and French, can currently be used with Android devices and an iPhone version is expected to be available in the summer of 2015. Results of the Insights Matter survey indicated that 77% of Canadians would download these kinds of apps. To facilitate that, AppColony is creating different versions of the app for businesses and fleets. These will use the same technology, but offer new features, in-
cluding reporting and custom communities. A version for parents wanting to keep on eye on their teenagers’ driving habits will follow, again using the base app features with added reporting and security. “I see drivers using their phones everyday on the roads, which is an issue I take extremely seriously,” says Superintendent Denis Boucher, co-chair of the Canadian Association of Chiefs of Police’s Traffic Safety Committee. “Technology-based solutions are a powerful tool when combined with enforcement and education in the effort to end distracted driving,” Boucher argues in a statement.
“The app doesn’t just solve the immediate problem of distracted driving by blocking messages; it also helps spread awareness of the issue with each message sent out to those trying to reach someone who is driving and using the app.” PROMISING OUTLOOK “As an insurance company, we want to be a partner of our clients in helping them understand their risks and how to manage them. We want to be more than just a commodity. One way we can do this is by leveraging technology in new ways to promote safety,” suggests Kathy Bardswick, president and chief executive officer of The Co-operators. “The app doesn’t just solve the immediate problem of distracted driving by blocking messages; it also helps spread awareness of the issue with each message sent out to those trying to reach someone who is driving and using the app. This is a first step. Down the road there will be more functionality, and we’ll look for opportunities to tie it in
with other technology we use to support our clients,” Bardswick reports. The app helps to fight distracted driving by intercepting calls and texts without entirely cutting off people from their phones. It is designed to manage alerts intelligently, blocking these while automatically responding to any calls and texts with a message that lets the caller know the recipient is driving. The app automatically activates when it detects the vehicle is in motion and, upon reaching the driver’s destination, turns off and presents a summary of calls and messages received over the course of the trip. The app uses trademarked technology that allows urgent notifications to get through when sent by callers and texters who have a unique code to notify the driver. When one of these codes is received, the app alerts the driver that he or she should pull over as soon as possible to respond. Calls can also be set to pass through when connected to a Bluetooth system, and emergency calls can be made in a single tap. Users can add friends and family within the app, choosing to share their location with specific people. The privacy settings can be adjusted and all data is sent securely. The app can then track the number of distractions prevented, letting users compare their totals with their family and social network, and add their distractionfree driving stats to the global totals. The need, desire and market for these apps is growing. In just a few months, the app has been downloaded almost 10,000 times. That translates to more than 2 million kilometres of distraction-free driving and 50,000-plus notifications blocked. Distracted driving is a cultural problem, although the attitude towards the issue is changing and improving. The fight against distracted driving is similar to when seat belts arrived in the 1970s and 1980s. Initial indifference — even resistance — gave way to safety and common sense. It is hoped a similar cultural shift will be seen with distracted driving.
May 2015 Canadian Underwriter
55
MOVES & VIEWS
upcoming events: for a complete list visit
www.canadianunderwriter.ca
and click ‘my events calendar’ on the home page
1
Liberty International Underwriters Canada announced in April the appointment of Garth Pepper [1a] as president, replacing Mike Molony [1b], who is retiring and has served as LIU Canada president since 1999. Pepper most recently was senior vice president of LIU Canada, a position he has held since 2008. Prior to joining LIU Canada, Pepper led the management risk practice at Integro Insurance Brokers in Canada, and has held senior positions, in both Britain and Canada, with The Chubb Group of Companies.
2
Ross Betteridge [2a] is the new president of SCM Insurance Services Inc.’s ClaimsPro unit, replacing Bob Fitzgerald [2b], who was named chief executive officer of SCM Insurance Services in January. Betteridge has spent the last four years with Travelers Canada in senior roles, including as chief operating officer and executive vice president, corporate strategy and shared services. His experience also includes working at Aviva Canada.
3
ingenie (Canada) Inc., which provides auto insurance in Ontario to drivers aged 16 to 24, has appointed Lorie Phair [3] as its chief executive officer. Phair has previously held leadership
56 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
1a
1b
2a
6
8
9
and board positions with organizations, such as the Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario, the Insurance Brokers of Toronto Region and the Insurance Institute of Canada, where she served as a member of the Board of Governors and as chair of its Academic Council for six years. She currently also holds an advisory council position with Magnet, a not-for-profit social initiative.
4
Managing general agent Creechurch International Underwriters has opened a Western Canada office in Vancouver, with Rhea Turchinetz relocating to lead the office as Western Region assistant vice president. “With our new
office in Vancouver, we expect to provide enhanced local service to clients and further develop our business, particularly in the specialty property and casualty areas,” Phil Baker, vice president of Creechurch International, which also has Canadian offices in Toronto and Montreal, says in a statement.
5
Darren Berg [5] is Cunningham Lindsey Canada Claims Services Ltd.’s new director of quality assurance and training for its major loss services division, based in Vancouver. With 28 years of adjusting and managerial experience, Berg has “extensive knowledge and great capability of handling claims that are complex and technical in nature.”
6
Micheál Kelly [6] has been named to Economical Insurance’s Board of Directors, replacing Charles Ormston, who retired in February after serving on the board for two decades. Ormston had been chair of the board’s Human Resources and Compensation Committee and was also a member of the Special Committee on Demutualization. Kelly is currently dean of business and economics at Wilfrid Laurier University and is a past dean of the University of Ottawa’s Telfer School of Management.
7
The Insurance Brokers Association of Nova Scotia (IBANS) has named the recipients of its latest awards. Patricia Calder
MOVES & VIEWS MOVES & VIEWS
of Calgary; Gordon Adams; Robert Cartwright, Jr.; Al Gorski; Leslie Lamb; John Phelps; Michael Phillipus; Frederick Savage; and Lori Seidenberg.
3
5
2b
3
9
10
positions 10a have included general adjuster, branch manager, of MacLeod Lorway Insurance vice president of operations Group received IBANS’ client and Lloyd’s Division leader. service award, Robert Wyre of Portage Mutual Insurance was recognized asChisholm insurance Macdonald representative of the Trask Insuranceyear, (MCT) Jamesannounced Mizzi of Macdonald in early Chisholm Trask wasjoin named January that it will propyoung of the year, erty andbroker casualty brokerage Robert Wilson R.K. Wilson BrokerLink. Theofterms of the Insurance Services transaction were notInc. dis-was honoured witha the volunteer closed, notes statement service award, Anderson from BrokerLink. BrokerLink Brown Company Insurance companies, subsidiaries of was named brokerage Intact Financial Corp., of the year, and Insurance include 84Founders offices serving Group Inc. received the proclients in Atlantic Canada, fessional development award. Alberta and Ontario. Dating
6
8
back more than 60 years, Restoration MCT has more thanfirm 110DKI inCanada has appointed surance professionals in 18 Sparfel [8]who offices.Frank Michael Brien, as director commercial has led MCTofover the last 12 services. Sparfel “brings years, joins BrokerLink asover 25 years experience in the head of itsofAtlantic operations.
10b
7
Carolyn Snow [7] will restoration insurance lead and RIMS as president industry, with a strong focus for the 2014 term, on strategic business develwhich took effect January 1. opment andhas partnerships,” Snow, who been on the notes a statement from for RIMS Board of Directors DKI Canada. He “will be diseven years, is currently responsible developing for rector of riskformanagement the commercial services Humana Inc. She previously sector with supporting servedalong as RIMS’s treasurer, the continued growth of secretary and director ofthe (p&c insurance) market and external affairs. The RIMS broker community.” board for 2014 also includes
9
vice president Richard Canadian National Roberts, Jr.; treasurer Julie Insurance CrimesecrePemberton; corporate Services (CANATICS) tary Nowell Seaman, director reports itsrisk system — which for of global management identifies suspiciousofclaims Potash Corporation and facilitates investiSaskatchewan further Inc.; Gloria gations by individual insurers Brosius; Steve Pottle, director — now up and running. of is risk management services Itathas started sending alerts York University; Jennifer to memberJanet insurance Santiago; Stein,firms, direcwhich Allstate Canada, tor of include risk management and Aviva Canada, belairdirect, insurance at the University
8
As of January 8, Toronto insurance broker Jones DesLauriers 5 Insurance Management Inc. (JDIMI) had acquired Whitley Insurance and Financial Services. Whitley Insurance has offices in Belleville, Ontario and the nearby communities of Trenton, Deseronto and Stirling. “The acquisition is expected to build a solid presence for JDIMI in Eastern Ontario 10c and position the firm to better service their clients, The withCo-operators, strengthened Desjardins commerGeneral Insurance, Intact cial and personal insurance Insurance, Pafco, Pembridge, offerings in the region and a The RBC Insurance, new Personal, financial services diviTD Insurance, sion,” notes a Travelers statementand from Wawanesa Insurance. JDIMI. President andInsurers CEO participate by allowing their Shawn DeSantis will lead the data to from be pooled analyzed, teams both and companies. with controls. Lorisprivacy Clarke [8] has been “Organized crime that named successor rings to Paul stage collisions and frauduWhitley, president of Whitley lently bill insurance Insurance, who willcompanies remain should be very nervous right during a transition period. now,” says Ben Kosic [9], president and chief executive officer Ken of CANATICS. Rayner [9] has
9 10
joined Anderson Crawford & McTague & Associates Company Ltd. as its director of busi(Canada)Central Inc. ness development, has announced three Region. “Ken brings anew wealth appointments in our the commarine of experience to survey area. Mark pany, having held Thompson various [10a], holds a diploma senior who management positions in Marine Surveying from with insurers and other MGAs,”
says Chuck McTague, president of Anderson McTague & Associates, a familyLloyd’s Maritime Academy, owned MGA based in New is now a senior marine surveyor Brunswick. In January, Anfor the company’s derson McTague &Global Associates Technical (GTS) announcedServices it was expanding, team; Trudeau [10b], addingJoseph an office in Toronto to who has experience as a service the brokers of Ontario marine surveyorRayner’s conducting and Manitoba. valuation surveys, damage appointment confirms the appraisals and investigations, company’s “commitment to has been appointed senior the Ontario/Manitoba marketmarine surveyor the GTS; place, and to thefor building of and Jason Trudeau [10c], a local support team to assist who haswith beentheir a marine brokers surplus surveyor and appraiser for lines and difficult to place 20 years, has been named business,” McTague adds. a marine surveyor.
11 10
Intact Financial The Guarantee Corporation has Company of announced plans North America to Intact Lab, centre hasopen announced thatits Tara for digital excellence, this Wishart [10] became viceMay in Montreal. It will house president of claims for the user experience digital insurer’s Torontoand branch on analytics specialists, frontDecember 2, 2013. Having end developers, research 21 years of experience inand The development teams, project Guarantee’s claims managers andWishart other experts department, will be who will workforwith areas responsible theall operations of the business to drive digital of the Toronto Branch Claims. innovation and create solutions She first joined The Guaranto customers, brokers teebenefit in 1995 as an adjuster and the industry and has held roles of increasing seniority with the com-
CORRECTION pany, including, most
In our April 2015 issue, afor recently, claims manager reference to Cunningham specialty lines. Wishart is a Lindsey member Canada of both Claims the Surety Services Ltd.’s Global unit Association of EFI Canada and was misspelled. CU apologizes the Canadian Association of for the error. Women in Construction. Follow @CdnUnderwriter on http://twitter.com/CdnUnderwriter
May 2015 Canadian Underwriter
57
February 2014 Canadian Underwriter
57
APPOINTMENT
GALLERY
Lisa Weinstein LawPRO President & CEO Kathleen Waters is pleased to announce the appointment of Lisa Weinstein as Vice President, TitlePLUS®. As Director, National Underwriting Policy, TitlePLUS since 2007, Ms. Weinstein has overseen the underwriting of LAWPRO’s TitlePLUS title insurance program that complements the work of the lawyer in a real estate transaction. In her new role, she will continue to oversee underwriting as well as focus on strategic direction and growing the subscriber base to meet future challenges. Called to the bar in 1980, Ms. Weinstein was formerly a partner with Strauss, Cooper and is a frequent speaker on real estate law and title insurance. She holds an LL.B. from the University of Toronto and a Certificate in Business French and Translation from Ryerson University. LAWPRO is owned by the Law Society of Upper Canada and is licensed to provide professional liability insurance and title insurance in numerous jurisdictions across Canada. Through its primary and excess insurance programs, LAWPRO insures over 25,000 lawyers in private practice in Ontario and provides risk and practice management information.
58 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
CRU Adjusters held its spring seminar at the Delta Markham Hotel on March 12 and 13. The event was open to all insurance professionals and covered a breadth of topics, including the following: Controlling the Outcome of an Environmental Disaster; The Fingerprints of an Environmental Claim; New Technology and Data – the Effect on Claims Processes; Better Catastrophe Protection; Fracking and the Potential Damaging Effects; Are Extremes Becoming the Norm?; Catastrophe Response in Canada, as well as many others. Attendees heard from expert speakers, including Dr. Burns Cheadle of the University of Western Ontario, Dr. Paul Nony, senior toxicologist at the Center for Toxicology and Environmental Health, Dan Sandink of the Institute for Catastrophic Loss Reduction and Anthony Farnell, chief meteorologist for Global National. CRU also hosted a complimentary evening social featuring dinner and live music, where attendees had the opportunity to meet the staff of Maltmans Group International.
GALLERY
More than 200 senior insurance industry executives gathered in Toronto for the Swiss Re 2015 Canadian Outlook Breakfast on March 31. Attendees got their first look at the Canadian P&C industry’s 2014 results and learned about market trends, economic factors and 2015 outlook. Speakers included Veronica Scotti, the new president and CEO of Swiss Re Canada; Christian Mumenthaler, CEO, Reinsurance, Swiss Re; and Gregor Robinson, senior vice president policy and chief economist of the Insurance Bureau of Canada.
May 2015 Canadian Underwriter
59
GALLERY
The Honourable Order of the Blue Goose Ontario Pond held its in the Carlton Ballroom of the luxurious Ritz-Carton Toronto on April 1. With record attendance, Ed Patrick, president and founder of the International Order of the Companions of the Quaich Whisky Appreciation Society, presided over the nosing and led the tastings. A cocktail hour that saw ganders and guests mixing and mingling preceded a fabulous dinner. All proceeds raised at the event were in support of the Women in Insurance Cancer Crusade (WICC).
60 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
GALLERY
May 2015 Canadian Underwriter
61
GALLERY
Next is Now was the theme of AudaVision, a conference held April 7 to 8 and presented by Audatex, a subsidiary of Solera Holdings Inc., which provides auto claims software and data services. AudaVision was held at the Palais Royale on Toronto’s waterfront. Attendees gained insight on information technology and auto claims from, among others, Audatex, Oracle Corporation, Google Inc., Strategy Meets Action, Deloitte, DesRosiers, Commonwell Mutual Insurance Group, Altimeter Group and Tesla Motors.
62 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
GALLERY
Service Excellence.
Delivered One Policy at a Time™ The Insurance Institute of Ontario held its 11th CIP Society Symposium, the theme of which was “Bigger and Better: Growth in a Finite Industry”, at the Toronto Region Board of Trade on April 16. The CIP Society symposium committee welcomed more than 170 current and future leaders. The full-day program provided a platform for learning about a variety of issues. Specific session topics included the following: Growth: Challenges of Getting Bigger; Does Bigger Mean Better; and Commercial Strategy: Are You Advancing or Surviving? The breakfast keynote speaker was Dr. Nick Bontis, a leading strategy and management expert, while the luncheon keynote was delivered by Sylvie Paquette, president and chief operating officer of Desjardins General Insurance Group Inc.
With a 45-year history and an unprecedented client retention rate, GroupOne is the Broker’s Source for standard, substandard, specialty and hardto-place insurance programs. Our personalized service, along with access to the best domestic and Lloyd’s markets, provides you with best-in-class programs to suit your clients’ needs. Please contact us and let us introduce you to the standard in service. GroupOne Insurance Services 888-489-2234 www.grouponeis.com
“Now Serving…You”
May 2015 Canadian Underwriter
63
GALLERY
On April 16 at The Design Exchange in Toronto, Guy Carpenter launched its new G-CAT Canada Flood Model, what it calls the “first-ever probabilistic flood model for Canada” that will allow insurers to assess their exposures to the peril. The launch event included presentations from senior executives from the industry as well as from Guy Carpenter G-CAT Canada Flood Model development team members. “By launching the G-CAT Canada Flood Model, Guy Carpenter addresses the concern of extreme losses from natural hazards in Canada, such as flooding,” said Donald Callahan, president and chief executive officer of Guy Carpenter Canada. “To produce this state-ofthe-art flood model for the Canadian insurance market, Guy Carpenter collaborated with experts in hydrological and hydraulic modeling to produce simulations for hurricane, rainfall and river flow flooding catastrophes,” Callahan added.
64 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
GALLERY
May 2015 Canadian Underwriter
65
GALLERY
Catlin Canada Inc. held its “Masters Golf” event on April 9 at the Catlin Broker Café & Seoul Boardroom at the company’s offices in Toronto. About 120 people, including a mix of brokers and staff, attended the event, which featured a putting competition with Masters prizes. It was a chance for all to enjoy an afternoon watching the Masters while socializing and enjoying a Masters-inspired menu.
66 Canadian Underwriter May 2015
Embrace your potential and
stand out
as a leader in our evolving industry. Leadership Defined.
Take the next step along your career path and pursue the FCIP. You will deepen the critical insights that will define you as a future leader, and join the elite of your profession.
Test your readiness online. Take our short assessment quiz: www.insuranceinstitute.ca/AreYouReady
The FCIP Program. Enrol now. www.insuranceinstitute.ca/fcip fcip@insuranceinstitute.ca 1-866-362-8585
Educating the property and casualty industry since 1899.
Water is beautiful. Until it isn’t.
Protection from overland water damage – only from Aviva
Heavy rains
Spring run-off
Overflow from lakes and rivers
Find out more. Talk to your Aviva Business Development Team.
AvivaCanada.com Home | Auto | Leisure & Lifestyle | Business | Group | Surety Aviva and the Aviva logo are trademarks used under license by the licensor.