‘Serving The Nation’s Sugarbeet Community Since 1963’ Volume 49 Number 6 November/December 2010
Sugar Publications 4601 16th Ave. N. Fargo, ND 58102 Phone: (701) 476-2111 Fax: (701) 476-2182 E-Mail: sugar@forumprinting.com Web Site: www.sugarpub.com Publisher: Sugar Publications General Manager & Editor: Don Lilleboe Advertising Manager: Heidi Wieland (701) 476-2003 Graphics: Forum Communications Printing
The Sugarbeet Grower is published six times annually (January, February, March, April/May, July/August, November/December) by Sugar Publications, a division of Forum Communications Printing. North American sugarbeet producers receive the magazine on a complimentary basis. Annual subscription rates are $12.00 domestic and $18.00 for foreign subscribers. Advertising in The Sugarbeet Grower does not necessarily imply endorsement of a particular product or service by the publisher.
Page 4 Page 10
— Feature Articles — 69.6 Tons & 17.6% Sugar! . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Another world record beet crop in the Imperial Valley
EU-27 Beet Sugar Industry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Overview of sugar production, processing, trade policy
History Comes Alive . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 During Harvest Festival at RRV Sugarbeet Museum
A Tribute to Craig Anderson . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 Coloradoan & former ASGA president passes
World Sugar Market Price Volatility . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18 Intensified by market & policy factors
— Regular Pages — Dateline: Washington . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Roundup Ready, New Congress
Around the Industry . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
Visit Our Website! Now Updated & Rejuvenated!
Who, what & where it’s happening
Write Field . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
— Front Cover — Geese found the tops of these beet piles an inviting place to hang out during the fall harvest. This photo was taken in American Crystal Sugar’s Moorhead factory yard. Photo: Don Lilleboe
Thoughts on a dark October night
www.sugarpub.com
THE SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
3
Photo: Ron Tharp
69.6 Tons & 17.6% Sugar! New Gross Sugar/Acre Record Set in California here’s no stockpiling of beets in California’s Imperial Valley, given harvest-time temperatures that often top 100 degrees. The harvest season typically stretches from April until early August, with growers operating
T
4
off carefully scripted daily quotas desinged to ensure that the Spreckels Sugar factory at Brawley can process all beets within 12 hours of delivery. The 2009/10 growing season provided a real test — in a good way — for
growers and processor alike. The average yield for this year’s 25,188 Imperial Valley harvested acres was 43.91 tons per acre. Coupled with a sugar content averaging 17.26% and an 88.71% purity, the crop produced 15,061 pounds of gross sugar per acre and 12,508 pounds of extractable sugar. With overall output like that, perhaps it’s not too surprising that the 2010 harvest also witnessed a new world record in terms of gross sugar per acre across an entire field. Even more impressive, however, is that the old record (21,140 pounds/acre, set in 2004) was topped by no fewer than nine Imperial Valley growers this year. Among them is the new record holder, Ralph Taylor. His 144-acre record-setting field averaged 69.63 tons per acre, 17.63% sugar and 88.9% purity, for a gross sugar total of 24,552 pounds per acre. That topped the former record by more than 3,400 pounds. But there’s more. Between them, Taylor and his son Jason — who together annually produce just over 2,000 acres of beets — harvested three fields this past summer that exceeded
THE SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
800.279.3200, ext. 3402 alerusagstock.com
The Alerus advantage:
Current market pricing Signed written contracts Escrowed funds Assistance with transfer documents
The leader in sugarbeet stock brokerage since 1994. This information does not constitute an offer to buy nor a solicitation to sell. The products offered (1) are not FDIC insured, (2) are not deposits or other obligations of a bank or guaranteed by a bank and (3) involve investment risks, including possible loss of principal amount invested. Alerus Securities is a wholly owned subsidiary of Alerus Financial. Member FINRA & SIPC
Photo: Chris Ball
Buying or Selling Beet Stock?
the previous world record for gross sugar per acre. So what was the formula behind this eye-popping productivity? Favorable weather, a strong variety, an exceptional plant stand — and some tweaking of the irrigation schedule toward the end of the season — sum it all up, according to Taylor. That 144-acre field was seeded to the Holly Hybrids variety Coronado (which went on half of Taylor’s 2009/10 beet acreage — the other half being planted to Phoenix, another Holly variety). Taylor says he took a chance by placing the newer variety on such a large percentage of his acreage. “But I’d grown about 10 acres (of Coronado) the year before, and it went through a hot spell and still came out with good sugar and pretty good tonnage,” he explains. “So I felt pretty comfortable. Luckily, it turned out in my favor.” The record-setting field was planted fairly late (latter October) and followed alfalfa. Its fertilizer regimen was pretty standard — urea, UN 32 and 11-52-0. It was planted-to-stand at a 3.5” in-row spacing. The final plant stand was exceptional, acknowledge Taylor and his Spreckels agriculturist, Chris Ball. “It was a perfect stand,” Ball affirms. “There wasn’t a beet missing.”
Above: Ralph Taylor (left) and his son Jason (right) are joined by ranch foreman Jose Lerma in the field that set the new record for gross sugar per acre. Off to a great start, the field — like much of the Imperial Valley 2009/10 sugarbeet crop — also benefited from favorable spring weather. “Mother Nature really came through for us,” Taylor relates. “We had a nice cool spring — not too cold, not too hot. And we had a series of timely spring rains.” Root rot is always a late-season concern in the hot Imperial Valley summers. To reduce its threat, Taylor cut off his irrigation water earlier than normal. The record-setting field’s final irrigation was on June 25 — roughly five weeks before the harvester pulled into the field. The field ended up with a harvested beet count of 44,632 roots per acre. “They were touching each other all the way down the row,” notes Chris Ball. “You couldn’t fit another beet in there.” “That was the first field I’ve ever grown where we had to slow down the digger because there were so many beets going through,” Taylor smilingly recounts. “A nice problem to have.” Taylor’s 2010/11 sugarbeet acreage is again split between Coronado and Phoenix. About 20% of the current crop had to be replanted due to crusting from hard fall rains. “But we should be all right,” the Imperial Valley grower says. “That’s one good thing about having a lot of acres: if you do have to replant some of them, you can harvest those fields later.” — Don Lilleboe ■
‘That was the first field I’ve ever grown where we had to slow down the digger because there were so many beets going through.’ 6
THE SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
Dateline: Washington — Roundup Ready — The burning question on every grower’s mind is, “When will I know what I can plant?” It is a very simple question that, as of this latter November writing, has no definitive answer. We remain on hold in a very fluid situation until decisions are made by the USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) and, if challenged, potentially a court. On November 4, APHIS published three options for Roundup Ready® sugarbeet (RRSB) plantings in 2011. The first was to continue to keep RRSB restricted, and no plantings of RRSB seed would occur in 2011. That option, which we adamantly oppose, would clearly have significant and damaging ramifications for all producers. The second — and preferred option by APHIS — was to allow growers to raise RRSB with strict conditions under permits issued to the beet processor. A third option is to maintain strict conditions through compliance agreements without the use of permits. The industry is working hard to better understand the operational ramifications of the two options and is developing specific comments that will be filed with APHIS before the December 6 deadline. It will then take some time (weeks) for APHIS to review all the comments before making a final decision. APHIS clearly understands the need for timely decisions to be made in order to plant a crop for 2011. Your local grower-leaders and processor will keep you apprised in a timely manner of any actions made by APHIS. In the meantime, USDA, growers and processors are in the process of appealing the initial court decision of August 13 to vacate the deregulation and make RRSB regulated again. Documents in the appeal will be filed at various times by the parties, with final documents due no later than March 1, 2011. Given the timing of the appeal, it will not impact the planting decision for the 2011 crop. Also pending is a decision by Judge Jeffrey White regarding the 256 acres of RRSB seed that were planted in early September under four separate APHIS permits for the production of stecklings. These stecklings could be important for seed production for 2012-2014 crops’ root crops. Final submissions to the court on this matter were made by the plaintiffs on November 16, and a decision could be rendered at any time. Finally, work on the Environmental Impact Statement is underway, with an estimated completion date of May 30, 2012. A commenting period and review of comments would take additional time.
— Lame Duck Session — Members of the 111th Congress returned November 15 for a final session that will continue until close to Christmas. There are a lot of issues that House
8
By Luther Markwart Executive Vice President American Sugarbeet Growers Assn.
Democrats want to resolve before the Republicans take over in January, but the question is whether anything major can be accomplished. The Republican leadership has declared that their focus in the next Congress will be on jobs and cutting the deficit through a ban on earmarks and other cuts in federal spending. All programs are going to be evaluated, and farm programs will be in the cross-hairs. The co-chairs of the bipartisan commission on the budget deficit recently released proposals for action and budget cuts, which perhaps will generate more heat than light. There is a December 1 deadline for agreement by 14 of the 18 members of the commission over proposals to reduce the national debt by $4 trillion over the next 10 years, including: reducing agriculture subsidies by $3 billion annually; making cuts in Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid; cutting and flattening income tax rates but increasing some taxes; removing popular tax deductions; and slicing government expenditures across the board. If agreement is reached (which appears unlikely), Congress could vote on the proposal before the end of the year.
— Elections — There will be lots of new faces on Capitol Hill in the 112th Congress. After gaining 62 seats, the Republicanled House will welcome 90 new members — making the party ratio 190 D-241 R. All committee chairs and the number of Republicans/ Democrats on committees There will be plenty of will switch. Committee work to do to educate assignments will be finalstaffers and 140 congress- ized in January, but members are already men and 48 senators jockeying for shifts and who have not yet cast promotions. Congressmen a vote on sugar policy. Frank Lucas (OK) and Collin Peterson (MN) will switch roles as chair and ranking member of the House Ag Committee; Rep. Dave Camp (MI) will become chair of the Ways and Means Committee. In the Senate, where Democrats maintained control (53-47), there will be 16 new members — seven are former House or Senate members, and five have previous voting records opposing sugar policy. Sen. Kent Conrad (D-ND) will remain as chair of the Budget Committee, clearing the way for Sen. Debbie Stabenow (MI) to become the new chair of the Agriculture Committee. Committee assignments will be finalized in January, and we will analyze the changes in my next article. The bottom line is that it is a huge change in members, staff and committee assignments. As we begin initial work on the 2012 farm bill, there will be plenty of work to do to educate staffers and 140 congressmen and 48 senators who have not yet cast a vote on sugar policy. ■
THE SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
CRYSTAL SUGARBEET SEED distributed by: ACH Seeds Inc. 1.877.224.7333 Crystal Beet Seed 1.218.236.4788
EU-27 Beet Sugar Industry
Photo: British Sugar Beet Review
Charting a New Course
Above: The Cantley Nearly 1.6 million hectares (4.0 million acres) eflecting the impact of recent sugar policy reforms, the EU-27 has shifted to become one factory is one of four of sugarbeets were planted last season, with the owned and operated three largest producers — France, Germany and of the world’s leading sugar net-importers. The by British Sugar plc. Poland — accounting for about 60% of total beet reforms are also affecting countries that benefit area. According to the European Committee of from preferential access to the EU market. Sugar Manufacturers (CEFS), there are 162,244 beet growers Despite trade reforms, lower internal prices and a restructuring of the sugarbeet industry, the EU remains the world’s in the EU, including France with 26,000, Germany with 34,436 and Poland with 40,988 growers. largest beet sugar producer. Sugar production for 2009/10 was up 20% from the year before and reflected record sugarbeet production — which Beet Sugar Production was attributed to near-ideal year-long growing conditions Concentrated in France & Germany throughout the major producing areas in Western Europe. France in particular had strong yields (Table 1). EU sugarbeet area for 2010/11 is reported to be down EU-27 sugar output is estimated by USDA at 16.8 milslightly, and growing conditions have been more challenging lion metric tons, raw value equivalent, for 2009/10 (Figure compared to last season’s near-perfect weather. The 1). This includes 16.4 million tons of beet sugar and 0.4 European Commission reports that the EU had prolonged million tons of cane sugar, mainly from France’s overseas dry weather through early July. Rainfall in northern departments (Reunion, Guadeloupe and Martinique) and France, Belgium, the Netherlands and western Germany — Portugal’s Azores. the main growing areas in the EU — was 60 to 80% below normal. With a somewhat reduced area planted to beets and lower yields, sugar production is expected to be down by Figure 1. EU-27 Sugarbeet Production 2.0 million metric tons to a forecasted 14.8 million tons 20.0 (including 0.3 million tons of cane sugar).
— Million Metric Tons —
R
16.8
15.0
EU Structure & Sugar Policies The European Union was founded in 1956 by six countries: France, Germany, the Netherlands, Belgium, Luxembourg and Italy. Twenty-one more have joined over the past half-century, and as of 2010 the EU encompasses a
10.0 5.0
2008/09 10
14.8
14.0
2009/10
2010/11 (proj.)
* Peter Buzzanell is director of the decade-old sweetener consulting firm that bears his name. Prior to his retirement from USDA, he was head of the Sugar & Sweetener Analysis Unit at the Economic Research Service.
THE SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
total of 27 countries. Cyprus, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, Poland, Slovakia and Slovenia joined the EU in 2004, bringing total membership to 25. Romania and Bulgaria, the newest, became members in January 2007. According to various sources, in the late 1960s the EU-6 came under the umbrella of the EU sugar regime, which was part of the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP). All national sugar policies of the members were abolished for the overall EU sugar regime. The main features of the regime were as follows: • Production quotas for every producing country. • Fixed prices for sugarbeets and sugar. • Variable tariffs to protect against imports from the world market. • Mechanism to export surplus production to the world sugar market through levies paid by the sugar producers on sugar sales. • Production quotas given to producers of HFCS, thereby limiting market growth. These policies made it possible to run the sugar regime at practically no cost for the government. Over time, the EU’s sugar regime was criticized both internally and externally for its overproduction, regulated prices, export subsidies and discriminatory trade practices. The sugar regime also was very profitable, as EU sugar sold at prices three times higher than the world price. This encouraged expansion in production — even in adverse agronomic areas for sugarbeets. The oversupply of EU sugar led to five to six million tons of surplus sugar being placed on the world market, suppressing world prices. The EU offered export subsidies to close the gap between the world price and internal prices. In 2004 the World Trade Organization (WTO) ruled that the EU had been cross-subsidizing its out-ofquota surplus sugar. In 2006 the EU adopted a farreaching reform of its sugar policy. The main objectives were: • Inclusion of sugarbeet agriculture in the reform of the CAP by reducing the price of beets, as had been done with grains. Initially, beet prices were reduced by 45% and the sugar price was reduced by 36%. • Allocation of sugar production quotas to the most efficient growing regions via a restructuring of the sugar sector. In 2009 the reference price for raw sugar was reduced to EUR 335.20/ton
Table 1. EU-27 Sugarbeet Area & Yields / Selected Countries* Country Austria Belgium Denmark Finland France Germany Greece Italy Netherlands Portugal Spain Sweden United Kingdom Czech Republic Hungary Lithuania Poland Slovakia Romania
Harvested Area Harvested Area Yield (1,000 Hectares) (1,000 Hectares) (Metric Tons/HA) 2009/10 2010/11 (Proj.) 2009/10 43.9 62.7 38.5 14.8 370.0 379.6 24.0 60.6 72.7 0.2 45.5 39.4 119.3 53.7 13.3 15.1 200.0 15.0 21.3
44.0 59.4 38.0 14.0 360.0 362.0 23.4 57.0 71.0 0.2 45.9 39.0 104.0 52.0 13.0 15.0 190.0 17.7 24.3
70.6 82.7 54.5 37.7 89.6 71.5 66.2 53.0 78.9 40.9 82.6 53.4 69.9 52.3 52.9 45.2 46.9 46.6 38.0
Yield (Metric Tons/HA) 2010/11 (Proj.) 71.0 80.0 55.0 38.0 85.0 68.0 66.0 57.0 80.0 40.9 81.3 53.0 60.0 55.0 55.0 45.0 50.0 51.0 33.0
* Additional EU-27 member countries are Bulgaria, Cyprus, Estonia, Ireland, Latvia, Luxembourg, Malta and Slovenia. Sources: EU Commission, Brussels; USDA
(US $429.69/ton) or 19.5 cents per pound. This compares with recent CIF market prices of US $485/ton or 22 cents per pound. But according to the International Sugar Organization (ISO), actual domestic prices in the EU have been considerably higher than the reference price. Thus the EU has grown as an attractive import market.
Consumption Growth & Processing Changes There are close to 500 million people in the EU-27. Domestic sugar use for human consumption in 2009/10 is estimated by USDA at 16.9 million tons, raw sugar equivalent. For 2010/11, the forecast is for use to rise
The number of EU beet processing companies and raw sugar refining companies has declined from 78 in 2000/01 to 59 today.
THE SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
modestly to 17.0 million tons, reflecting an expected improvement in the economies of member countries. The majority of this sugar is used in the domestic food and beverage processing industry, which is taking advantage of abundant domestic supplies from last season’s crop. Sugarbeets are sliced at 108 processing plants across the community, with France, Germany and Poland having a combined 64 plants. Recent trends include consolidation of ownership of a number of processing plants as well as the closure of some plants. The number of beet processing companies and raw sugar refining companies has declined from 78 in 2000/01 to 59 today. The largest companies are Sudzucker, Nordzucker and British Sugar, which combined account for about half of the EU’s market share. The EU-27 sugar reform has resulted in substantial changes in the refining of raw cane sugar. Prior to the reform, only dedicated sugar refineries were allowed to refine imported raw sugar. This restriction was lifted in 2009, so now beet sugar factories are able to refine raw cane sugar. (Cont.)
11
4.0 3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5
Photo: British Sugar Beet Review
Million Metric Tons, Raw Value
Figure 2. EU-27 Sugar Trade: Imports & Exports 3.5 3.2
3.2
Imports
1.6
2007
1.6
1.5
2008
Exports
Above: Beets piled in a “clamp” at the edge of an English field are loaded onto a truck for transport to the factory.
2009
Trade Volumes & Policies Because of the reduction in sugar production due to the sugar reforms, the EU has shifted from being a significant net exporter of sugar to a substantial net importer, to the benefit of its less-developed trading partners. In 2005/06, the last year before sugar reform, the EU was a net exporter of more than 5.7 million tons of sugar; but by 2007/08 the EU was already a net importer of 2.3 million tons. On a calendar year basis, net imports averaged 1.7 million tons for the three years 2007 through 2009, according to International Sugar Organization data (Figure 2). For 2010/11, EU imports are forecast to total 3.6 million metric tons, of which 3.0 million are raw sugar imports and
0.6 million are refined sugar, raw value. The leading source of these imports in 2009 was Brazil, supplying 25% of raw sugar imports and 28% of refined sugar, says the ISO. EU exports of refined sugar for 2010/11 are forecast at 1.5 million metric tons. The leading destinations of EU refined sugar exports in 2009 were Israel (22%), Algeria (16%) and Norway (10%), according to ISO. With respect to sugar trade policy, the EU has two schemes for preferential trade. The Everything But Arms (EBA) initiative allows duty-free access to EU markets for the world’s least-developed countries. Second is the Economic Partnership Agreements (EPAs) with ACP countries. EPAs refer to African, Caribbean and Pacific countries (excluding South Africa), many being former European colonies. Countries eligible under these two schemes can export to the EU without paying any tariffs. USDA reports that the EU has recently signed free trade agreements (FTAs) with Columbia and Peru and a new EU-Central America Association Agreement. All these agreements include EU concessions for sugar imports and are now being ratified and implemented.
Extremely powerful & reliable.
Industry Assessment
2005 Ropa Tiger
#605377
356,700 NOW $321,700
$
6R30, 2786 Engine Hours, 1876 Harvest Hours, Strengthening US Dollar decreases your price! one owner, just reconditioned with over Price reduced $35,000! $20,000 in parts. Unit is field ready! Financing available with 30% down payment required and W.A.C.
Other quality used beet harvesting equipment available. Call for details.
Making Farming Easier
ALLIANCE, NE
BRIDGEPORT, NE
Hwy 385 & 10TH Street 308-762-5870 • 888-762-5870
9738 US 26 308-262-1110 • 800-682-5121
GORDON, NE
IMPERIAL, NE
6742 State Hwy 27 308-282-0665 • 800-535-4450
1001 Hwy 61 308-882-4326 • 800-525-4934
OGALLALA, NE
SIDNEY, NE
101 Road, East 80 308-284-4049 • 800-658-4227
1901 Link 17J 308-254-2511 • 866-233-2511
WWW.21STCENTURYEQUIPMENT.NET
12
Marketing year 2010/11 marks the end of the five-year restructuring period under the sugar reform initiative. As a result of the sugar reform, the EU’s sugar production quota has decreased by a third, down to 5.8 million metric tons, turning the EU from the world’s second largest sugar exporter into the second largest importer. Over the past decade, 147 sugar factories — nearly two-thirds of the total — have been closed. In addition, since 2004 reportedly 140,000 — 45% — of sugarbeet growers have left the industry. These significant changes, while causing massive economic dislocations, also have led to a much leaner and more competitive EU sugar industry. ■
THE SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
SDA’s initial estimate of 2010 U.S. sugarbeet production placed this year’s crop size at more than 31.9 million tons — up about 8% from the 2009 crop production level. The November report number was based on an average yield of 27.7 tons off 1,153,500 harvested acres. The forecast 2010 average yield is two tons higher than the final yield for 2009. Harvested acreage was up slightly from 2009. At an estimated 11.9 million tons, Minnesota remains far and away the nation’s largest producer of sugarbeets. North Dakota is currently estimated at 5.6 million tons this year, followed by Idaho at 5.15 million and Michigan at 3.9 million tons. Four states — Colorado, Idaho, Nebraska and Oregon — were forecast to end up with less production this year versus 2009. The next estimate of 2010 crop production will be released in January. The November USDA report placed national sugarcane production (for both sugar and seed) at 29.4 million tons — which would be down by more than a million tons from 2009. Florida remains the leading cane producer, followed by Louisiana. ■
U
U.S. Sugarbeet Production, 2009 & Initial 2010 Area Harvested (1,000 Acres) 2009 2010 25.3 25.0 35.0 27.8 163.0 170.0 136.0 147.0 449.0 442.0 33.6 42.6 52.6 47.5 218.0 211.0 10.5 10.3 25.6 30.3 1,148.6 1,153.5
California Colorado Idaho Michigan Minnesota Montana Nebraska North Dakota Oregon Wyoming U.S. Total
Yield (Tons) 2009 2010 35.0 40.0 27.5 29.5 34.3 30.3 24.4 26.5 23.7 27.0 29.8 29.5 24.6 22.6 22.0 26.5 37.6 35.1 26.5 28.0 25.7 27.7
Production (1,000 Tons) 2009 2010 886 1,000 963 820 5,591 5,151 3,318 3,896 10,641 11,934 1,001 1,257 1,294 1,074 4,796 5,592 395 362 678 848 29,563 31,934
Source: USDA-NASS Nov. 2010
!%"&'&!#()*$+(&,-$.&!/#0 !"#$-&,12&$3++(%&$4(#5$!$ 678'-&*"&&$9(&4$3+$#5&$43",-:$$$$
!"#$
;#788%
!"#$ %&&'#(")*"+#*+#,#-)",./01."/2)3"#41)#2!1+"#5!1#637#6,+"-#18#2!"#916#,2# !,8-:#812#18#2!"#01;1)#14#2!"#"<3*=."82>#?)1.#21=#21#61221.:#"8-/21/"8-:#2!"+"# !*@!/!1)+"=15")#2),021)+#=)1A"#2!"*)#=)1B0*"807:#-,7#,42")#-,7:#B";-#,42")#B";-> !.&"-&&) 533 ,&
2v
.(/;!"%> -(%>()/3) <!;&/#34) ;()3#
+!"*3 (&""&
*"!)-$+3">/ 5!)>()/3) "! (-$%(#= /(312$+!,,/
W W W . B U T L E R M A C H I N E R Y. C O M
THE SUGARBEET GROWER (Upper Midwest) November/December 2010
— Advertisement —
D
Root maggots, springtails on 2011 sugarbeet insect watch list
on’t bet on 2011 being a repeat of the seemingly mild year for sugarbeet insects that occurred in the Red River Valley in 2010. That’s the advice from Dr. Mark Boetel, research and extension entomologist at North Dakota State University (NDSU). There’s a good chance that sugarbeet root maggots will be back in force in 2011. The growing problem with springtails isn’t likely to go away, either. As in most years, wireworms will be a threat to sugarbeet production, too. In reality, the 2010 root maggot infestation was worse than many growers realize, says Boetel. Evidence of the infestation was covered up
New springtail research
Control tradeoffs Warnings about challenging insect populations will focus decisions on how to control critical insects in the months ahead. On one side of the decision equation are superior performance and lower cost with soil insecticides. On the other: the planting-timing convenience of seed treatments. Boetel says the best choice isn’t clear-cut at lower insect pressures. But when root maggot pressures are high, soil insecticides tend to perform better and deliver more dollars to the bottom line. A three-year NDSU study published last year showed that under moderately high root maggot pressure, yield and
Growers opt for Counter For David Benedict and Glen Hultin, NDSU research on sugarbeet root maggots and springtails confirmed their decision to rely on Counter soil insecticide to control beet insects. David Benedict “When you need a gun, you might as well get the biggest gun you can—that’s what we’ve got with Counter for root maggots, springtails and wireworm,” says Benedict, who farms near Sabin, MN. “Counter is the only at-planting treatment that will take on springtails. The seed treatments aren’t as good. I don’t want to dive off that cliff.”
by frequent rains, which allowed beets to compensate for feeding damage. “This could be a sleeper situation,” he says. “Fly counts and fall root ratings suggest that there are plenty of root maggots out there to over-winter and infest the crop in 2011.” Projected high-risk areas for root maggot infestations in 2011 include Auburn, Glasston, Grafton, Nash and St. Thomas, all in North Dakota. Areas with projected moderate risk include Cavalier, Minto, Manvel, Oakwood, Reynolds and Thompson, in North Dakota, and Ada, Borup and Euclid, in Minnesota.
sucrose recovery from Counter® insecticide treatments were significantly higher than from seed treatments. Bottom-line gross returns from a high labeled rate of Counter were $155/acre better than the top seed treatment. “Growers in the heavily infested areas often use a more aggressive approach at planting with a granular soil insecticide,” he says. “Generally in our research we have seen that the granular materials are more efficacious for root maggot under heavy infestations.” In areas with heavy infestations, Boetel recommends coming back with an in-season postemergence insecticide treatment timed for peak fly activity, regardless of the planting-time treatment.
Hultin, who farms near Hillsboro, ND, remembers having fields devastated by root maggots in the early 1990s—and relies on Counter to avoid that experience again. “I remember harvesting 8 tons/acre in one field,” he says. “For me, using Counter is a noGlen Hultin brainer. It is cheaper and it is better.” Both Benedict and Hultin have outfitted their John Deere central-fill planters with the electronically controlled SmartBox® closed handling and application system. “The closed system is two thumbs up,” Benedict says. “It puts out the proper amount no matter how fast you go.”
Soil insecticides also have a leg up on seed treatments for control of springtails. NDSU rates Counter insecticide as “Excellent” against springtails, while seed treatment products get a “Good” rating. A new three-year NDSU study bears that out that difference. The study showed that at high springtail pressures, a low labeled rate of Counter insecticide produced the highest gross economic return, $1,012/acre – $105/acre higher than the best-performing seed treatment. “Springtails are more difficult to predict than root maggots,” adds Boetel. “In the past 10 years, with wetter springs, springtails have become more of a regular issue on heavy soils conducive to their buildup.”
With Counter’s new 20G formulation, Hultin can plant about 200 acres of beets with his 24-row planter before refilling—typically one fill per day. Benedict’s 36-row system covers about 300 acres before refilling. The Counter 20G formulation, which is available for Lock ‘N Load® and SmartBox application systems, improves planting-time efficiency by covering 33% more acres per fill than the previous 15G formulation, points out Elton Hendrickson, technical sales representative for AMVAC Chemical Corp. For more information on Counter 20G Insecticide and the SmartBox System, contact Elton Hendrickson at eltonh@amvac.net or call 701-741-5608. Counter, Lock ‘N Load and SmartBox are registered trademarks of AMVAC Chemical Corporation.
During RRV Sugarbeet Museum Harvest Festival he Red River Valley Sugarbeet Museum at Crookston, Minn., drew a nice crowd to its 6th annual Harvest Festival on a sunny Sunday afternoon in mid-September. Along with numerous stationary exhibits of old-time sugarbeet production and harvesting equipment, the event featured the actual digging of beets with harvesters of an earlier era. This year’s festival paid special tribute to the Driscoll family (photo below), longtime beet growers from the East Grand Forks, Minn., area. The Red River Valley Sugarbeet Museum, founded in 2004, is governed by a board largely comprised of current and retired beet growers. Its main mission is to collect, display and demonstrate sugarbeet and other agrelated equipment and memorabilia. To learn more about the museum, log on to www.sugarbeetmuseum.com. ■
T
Photos: Don Lilleboe
History Comes Alive Above: A restored 1951 John Deere Model 200 beet harvester sits in front of “The Harris” wagon box. The Harris, which held about 80 bushels of grain, was also used to haul beets to piling stations.
Below: Part of the 2010 Harvest Festival crowd enjoyed riding on a trailer behind a two-row John Deere as it dug beets from the museum’s demonstration area.
Photo: Ron Peterson
Below: The James Driscoll family was honored by the Red River Valley Sugarbeet Museum this fall. James began raising sugarbeets near East Grand Forks, Minn., in the mid-1920s — a time when everything was done by hand, including the topping and the loading on to wagons with a fork. His two sons,
THE SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
Leonard and Jack, continued to raise the crop, delivering them to the then-American Beet Company, which later became American Crystal Sugar Company. Leonard’s sons — Ray, Keith and Jerry — and Jack’s sons — Paul and Dan — have done the same. Plaques were presented to the families of James’ grandsons and their families, honoring them for “continued dedication and leadership to the sugarbeet industry.” The museum’s board also presented a surprise “Founders Award” to Roger Odegaard and Allan Dragseth. The plaques, made by Glen Finkenbinder, were cut in the shape of a sugarbeet and read, “In recognition of your Exemplary Contribution to the Establishment and Ongoing Operation of the Red River Valley Sugarbeet Museum.” Dragseth and Odegaard have been instrumental in the startup and operation of the Crookston, Minn., sugarbeet museum.
13
Around The Industry ASSBT Biennial Meeting Set For March 2-5 in Albuquerque The 35th general meeting of the American Society of Sugar Beet Technologists is scheduled for March 2-5, 2011, at the Hyatt Regency in Albuquerque, N. Mex. The event begins on the 2nd with registration and an evening reception. A general session is held on the morning of the 3rd, followed by technical sessions that afternoon and throughout the next two days. The 2011 ASSBT meeting concludes with the traditional awards banquet on the evening of the 5th. Complete meeting information, including registration details, can be
found at www.bsdf-assbt.org or by calling ASSBT’s Denver office at (303) 832-4460.
2011 Sugarbeet Institute Takes Place March 16 & 17 in Fargo The 49th International Sugarbeet Institute will be on March 16 and 17, 2011, at the Fargodome in Fargo, N.D. This annual event is North America’s largest sugarbeet trade show. Companies desiring exhibiting information for the 2011 ISBI should contact Bob Cournia, exhibits coordinator, at (218) 281-4681. Other ISBIrelated questions should be directed to Dr. Mohamed Khan, committee chairman, at (701) 231-8596.
Syngenta Awards $5,000 Sugarbeet Scholarship to Idahoan
Syngenta recently announced Grant Stevenson of Paul, Idaho, as the first recipient of the Syngenta Sugarbeet Scholarship. Stevenson, a freshman at the College of Southern Idaho studying agri-business, was selected from a pool of applicants to receive the $5,000 award. The scholarship recognizes a student pursuing a career in agriculture who lives in or is attending school in a sugarbeet-growing state. This is the first year of this scholarship, a joint effort between Syngenta’s Hilleshog® Sugarbeet Seed, Syngenta Seedcare™ and Syngenta Crop Protection. Pictured in the above photo are, left to right: Trevor Cook of Syngenta’s Hilleshog Sugarbeet Brand Seed, Dave Dansie of Syngenta Seedcare, scholarship winner Grant Stevenson, and Craig Yearous of Syngenta Crop Protection. Stevenson’s roots in the sugarbeet industry date back to 1962, when his grandfather first planted beets. His family still owns and operates that now-1,800acre south central Idaho farm. Sugarbeet scholarship opportunities for 2011 will be announced at the American Sugarbeet Growers Association meeting in Tucson, Ariz., in February.
14
Michigan/Ontario Research Reporting Session is Jan. 27 The 2011 Michigan/Ontario Sugarbeet Research Reporting Session is scheduled for January 27 at the Doubletree Hotel/Conference Center in Bay City. This fifth annual reporting session will cover current sugarbeet research being conducted in the Great Lakes region. Registration is required. For more information, contact the Michigan State University Extension Service, Saginaw, at (989) 758-2500.
Great Western History Book Available After Second Printing A second printing of Footprints in the Sugar: A History of the Great Western Sugar Company has been completed, and copies are now available. The first printing of the 848-page volume sold out in 13 months, prompting Hamilton Bates Publishers to commission a second. Authored by Candy Hamilton, the book traces the rich saga of Great Western from its beginnings more than a century ago, through its growth into a major beet processor with eventually more than two dozen factories around the sugarbeet districts of Colorado, Nebraska, Montana and Wyoming (plus Ohio and Kansas). The book also chronicles Great Western’s later struggles, including the period when it was owned by the Hunt brothers, who took the once-proud company into bankruptcy during the mid-1980s. Richly illustrated, Footprints in the Sugar also discusses other players in the region’s sugarbeet industry, including the German-Russian families so identified with beets in the West; the Mexican (and Japanese) migrant worker community; and the role of World War II German prisoners of war. Persons interested in ordering copies of the 8-1/2 x 11-inch hardcover Footprints in the Sugar can do so by contacting Hamilton Bates Publishers, 251 W. Idaho Ave., #14, Ontario, OR 97914. Cost is $79.95 per copy, plus postage and handling. Payment is by check or money order only. For more information on this book, visit www.gwsfootprints.com, or email candy@gwsfootprints.com.
THE SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
Construction Progresses on New Louisiana Cane Sugar Refinery
A Tribute to Craig Anderson The U.S. sugarbeet industry lost a true champion last summer with the passing of Craig Anderson. The longtime Colorado grower and former president of the American Sugarbeet Growers Association passed away on July 19 at the age of 87. The following tribute to Craig was delivered by Alan Welp, a fellow Coloradoan and ASGA’s immediate past president, at the 2010 International Sweetener Symposium held in early August in Vail, Colo. It’s an wonderful tribute to an outstanding individual. I had the opportunity to become well acquainted with Craig during visits to his farm near Longmont, as well as at ASGA meetings and on other occasions. He was an exceptionally gracious person. As Alan says, he had a huge heart and was a great friend to everyone. A wonderful man. — Don Lilleboe
He went on the local beet board in the mid-’60s, and a few years later went to the board of the Mountain States Growers of Colorado and Kansas. He helped guide the growers through the tumultuous bankruptcy of the Hunt brothers and the Great Western Sugar Company in 1984 and the loss of the crop in 1985. Craig was instrumental in our recovery by putting the beet grower cooperative and the re-organized Colorado Sugarbeet Growers Association together, and he is one of the reasons that Colorado grows sugar today. He became a board member of the American Sugarbeet Growers Association in Below: The March 1994 issue of The Sugarbeet Grower featured the new president of the American Sugarbeet Growers Association, Craig Anderson.
Craig’s grandfather came to Weld County in 1902 and raised one of the first beet crops in the state for the new Great Western sugarbeet factory in Longmont. Craig’s father raised beets his entire life, and Craig spent most of his youth in sugarbeet fields. He went to Colorado A&M (now Colorado State University) to study veterinary medicine, but left school when he was called to report to duty during WWII. Because he was from a farm, he received an honorable discharge and returned home to farm because of the need for food for the troops. So he never fulfilled his goal of becoming a veterinarian — for which the Colorado beet industry is forever grateful.
THE SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
Left: Construction of the Louisiana Sugar Refining (LSR) cane sugar refinery at Gramercy, La., continues to progress. The refinery, which is scheduled for completion by the summer of 2011, is expected to employ about 150 people. When operational, it will refine approximately 75% of the raw sugar from cane grown in Louisiana. The new facility will have an annual refining capacity of about one million tons of sugar. Louisiana Sugar Refining is a joint venture of Imperial Sugar Company, Cargill, Inc., and Sugar Growers and Refiners (SUGAR) of Breaux Bridge, La. Each entity has one-third interest in LSR. SUGAR is a cooperative comprised of eight Louisiana sugarcane mills and roughly 700 sugarcane growers.
1986, and served on the International Affairs, Public Relations and Legislative committees. He was elected vice president of the ASGA in 1992 and became president in 1994. He always said — with a huge, beaming smile — that some of the greatest moments of his life happened when he was presenting testimony on the 1995 farm bill; debating, arguing and protecting our industry during the Uruguay round of GATT talks; visiting New York City for the first time when he gave a speech at the Sugar Club; and traveling around the world and the country as a respected spokesman for sugarbeet growers and the U.S. sugar industry. He always said, “No matter what we face, we’ll get the job done.” He considered all of this to be a distinct honor and privilege. Craig’s knowledge of our industry was unmatched, and he would “talk sugar” with anyone who would listen. Members of Congress knew him by name, and for many, he was the face of the sugar industry. Craig was a mentor, a good listener, and he had a huge heart. He considered his many opportunities to be a symbol of the trust and dedication that growers had placed in him. He was not just a great role model; he was a great friend to everyone. He was always encouraging, positive and willing to help educate and train new leaders, as he did with me when I became a grower director on the ASGA board. When I became president of the ASGA in 2008, I was proud to continue the tradition that Craig was such a large part of. Craig was completely devoted to his wife, Bonnie, and their children and grandchildren. He was one of the greatest spokesmen that this industry has had over the years, and he will be sorely missed. ■
15
Write Field
By David Kragnes
Dateline: Early October, Clay County, Minn. t’s really dark out here. We have been blessed with clear skies since the beet harvest season started. There is no moon, so the stars are beautiful. But when I shut off the pickup headlights, man, is it dark out here! I could easily describe how dark it is with a saying my Dad had — but I shouldn’t print it. That reminds me:
I
I need to schedule a colonoscopy this winter. The daytime temps have been too high, so we can only harvest at night when things cool down. I am headed out to the topper tractor, so I am the first in our field. I must be just ahead of my neighbors, because I don’t see any of the bright spots in the area that really light up when all
those tractors and trucks get rolling. The tractor easily comes to life, and I sit in the glow of the dash lights, waiting for the temp gage to move — and thinking. It is amazing how fast things flash through my mind. I don’t spend but a second on the night’s work; I have a great crew back who all know their jobs. Instead, my mind jumps to other parts of the country and all the friends I have made in this small world of sugar. I think of fishing in Idaho with Jeff in that little river so full of rainbows there was hardly any room for the water. I recall going with Tom to his grandson’s basketball game in Michigan after speaking at the Michigan annual meeting. Sitting in the gallery of the U.S. House with Mike, watching a successful vote on the farm bill we had lobbied so hard for, marching the halls with Luther, meeting the cane growers with Mark . . . all moments to remember. I turn on the radio just in time to catch John Denver singing, “But more than anything else I’m sorry for myself, cause you’re not here with me.” This brings a sad moment at thoughts of those who aren’t here with me anymore. I think I’ll go to the ASGA meeting this winter to see old friends. It’s been awhile. We need each other in this small world of sugar. I hope you had a great harvest. Happy Holidays — David ■ David Kragnes farms near Felton, Minn. He is a former chairman of American Crystal Sugar Co., and currently serves on the board of directors of CoBank.
American Sugarbeet Growers Association
2011 Annual Meeting February 6-8 Westin La Paloma Tucson, Ariz. — For Details— www.americansugarbeet.org 16
THE SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
World Sugar Price Volatility Intensified by Market & Policy Factors Rising production costs and growing ethanol use in Brazil, combined with policy-induced production swings across Asian countries, are the main sources of higher and more-volatile sugar prices. By Michael McConnell, Erik Dohlman & Stephen Haley* orld sugar prices soared to a 29-year high of nearly 30 cents a pound in early 2010 before falling back to half that level by early summer.** Still, they remain 50% higher than average over the past 20 years. Was this price spike a temporary oscillation caused by a supply shock, or does it reflect a more permanent fundamental shift in global market dynamics? Evaluation of economic and policy factors driving production and trade in key global sugar markets supports both perspectives. Underlying dynamics related to Brazil’s exchange rates and ethanol’s role in energy markets are putting upward pressure on global prices. However, the volatility of price movements in the past year was mostly the result of supply shortfalls tied to changing economic incentives, weather disruptions and policy factors in other countries. The U.S. remains largely insulated from global sugar price movements; but external fluctuations are felt in the United States, particularly when prices are high.
W
Changing Production, Use & Policies Affected Global Sugar Market in 2009/10 Global sugar production fell nearly 20 million (metric) tons (12%) in the 2008/09 marketing year (OctoberSeptember) in response to lower acreage, weather disruptions and policy developments. While prices of other commodities increased in 2007 and 2008, sugar prices remained relatively stable. As a result, sugar acreage declined in many parts of the world as producers switched crops in response to increased returns for competing commodities. Weather-related reductions in yields further hindered production in 2008/09. At the same time, consumption of sugar continues to increase, helping to boost average world raw sugar prices in 2009 to almost double the long-term average of 11 cents per pound. Policies fostering the industrial use of sugarcane also increased demand. Brazil, the world’s largest sugar produc-
* Michael McConnell, Erik Dohlman and Stephen Haley are ag economists with the USDA Economic Research Service. This article initially appeared in the September issue of the ERS publication “Amber Waves.” ** Prices have increased again in recent months, with world raw sugar prices as of early November actually surpassing the January/February 2010 levels. While having fallen from those highs, they still remained in the 25-30 cent/pound range as of the time this issue went to press.
18
er and exporter, uses a variety of tools to promote the production of ethanol from sugarcane, which has increased overall sugarcane production but introduced competition between the two uses — sugar and ethanol. Because Brazil is a major player in world sugar markets, policy and economic conditions that affect Brazil’s ability to produce and export sugar, such as ethanol use and changes in exchange rates, reverberate throughout the global market. Brazil’s leading role as a sugar exporter was further heightened when the European Union (EU), which supplied as much as 20% of global exports in the 1990s, shifted from a net exporter to a net importer following sugar policy reforms in 2005. This shift removed a traditionally important supply source from global markets and has made sugar importers more reliant on Brazilian exports. In addition to exposure to supply and price developments in Brazil, sugar prices have become more susceptible to increasingly volatile production cycles in Asia’s large sugar-consuming markets. Production swings in these countries are tied to policies that ultimately create large oscillations between their exports and imports from year to year. With the full implementation of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) in 2008, the United States now relies on Mexico to supply a significant share of U.S. sugar demand. However, after exporting 1.4 million tons of sugar to the United States in the 2009 marketing year, Mexico was forced to import large amounts of sugar from the world market, thereby helping to support high world sugar prices. Despite the United States’ general isolation from the global market, developments within the United States still can affect world prices, albeit sometimes indirectly.
Low Cost of Production Means Brazil Sets the Tone for World Sugar Prices As the world’s leading producer and exporter of sugar, Brazil plays a leading and increasingly important role in establishing global sugar prices. Brazilian sugar exports have grown steadily over the past several decades — its share of global exports climbed from under 25% in 2000/01 to over 48% in 2009/10, with exports of just over 24 million metric tons. Brazil — particularly the center-south region of the country — has a low cost of production, usually ranking first or second globally, with production costs of $265 per ton, compared with a world average of $353 per ton in 2008, according to LMC International. Brazil also has the world’s largest land base committed
THE SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
to sugarcane, which contributed to its rapid growth as the dominant exporter. Over the past 20 years, Brazil more than doubled its cane production area, from nearly 3.6 million hectares to almost 7.5 million hectares, and it continues to increase area each year. Sugarcane area among other leading exporters has remained relatively stable — Australia with 350,000450,000 hectares and Thailand with 900,000-1.2 million hectares over the past 10 years. Because Brazil is such a significant world supplier, both raw and refined
world sugar prices are closely correlated with Brazilian production costs. A key factor affecting these costs is the exchange rate between the U.S. dollar and the Brazilian currency, the “real,” because sugar is traded in U.S. dollars in international markets. When the U.S. dollar is strong against the Brazilian real, Brazilian sugarcane producers’ costs are relatively lower, which makes exports more competitive. For instance, if Brazilian production costs remain constant in local currency terms and if the value of the U.S. dollar doubled, Brazilian produc-
tion costs would fall by half when measured in U.S. dollars. The real lost 50-70% of its value against major currencies between 1997 and 2003, which coincided with especially strong growth of Brazilian sugar exports and a decline in global sugar prices. However, the real began rebounding in 2003 and steadily strengthened through 2009. The real’s appreciation was modest enough to allow exports to continue increasing, but there was also a close correlation between the appreciating real and the increase in sugar prices after 2003 leading up to the 2009 price spike. The real continued to strengthen through the first half of 2010, indicating that sugar prices could continue to remain elevated if the underlying relationship between exchange rates and world prices continues to hold.
Ethanol Fuels Expansion of Brazilian Sugarcane Area, But Creates Tradeoffs Policy support for ethanol production in Brazil has stimulated dramatic growth in the use of sugarcane for ethanol, which now accounts for 55 to 60% of total Brazilian sugarcane production. A major source of transportation fuel in Brazil, ethanol links the oil and gasoline markets to the sugar and sugarcane markets. This relationship is particularly strong during periods of high oil prices, affirming that energy prices will be an important determinant of tradeoffs between sugar and ethanol production. However, the long-term pattern of growth in both sugar and ethanol production indicates that the relationship may be complementary over a longer time horizon, rather than competitive. Increased production and use of ethanol has generated an additional revenue stream for sugarcane producers and processors, added flexibility to switch between sugar and ethanol production depending on market conditions, and allowed the Brazilian cane industry as a whole to grow. Growth in the use of sugarcane for ethanol production dates to 1975, when the Brazilian government established a national program to regulate alcohol levels in fuel to mitigate the impacts of oil price shocks at a time when Brazil imported over 80% of its oil. The result was a large expansion in sugarcane production and the development of anhydrous alcohol, used for blending in gasoline, and hydrous alcohol, used in a pure form in specially
20
The SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
U.S. Sugar Market Facing Change From External Market Forces .S. sugar prices have traditionally been far above and largely independent of world prices due to import restrictions and provisions of the U.S. sugar program (price supports and domestic marketing allotments). In particular, a tariff-rate quota (TRQ) insulates the domestic market from global price spikes by putting a ceiling on the quantity of sugar that the U.S. is required to import, so domestic prices are set primarily by internal supply and demand conditions. The minimum amount of sugar under the TRQ is an obligation set by the World Trade Organization (WTO) agreement. The TRQ grants preferential, lower tariff duties on imports up to the limit required by the WTO, but places much higher “over-quota” tariffs (above 15 cents/pound) on imports beyond that level. Since fiscal year (FY) 2000 (October 1999 to September 2000), yearly imports under the TRQ have averaged 1.48 million short tons, raw value (STRV), which is equivalent to less than 15% of average annual U.S. consumption. In some years, such as FY 2008, the U.S. authorized additional TRQ entries to relieve upward pressure on domestic prices, but TRQ imports more commonly fall somewhat short of designated levels because some of the countries with quota rights are no longer competitive exporters. However, the full implementation of the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) in 2008 means that external market
U
equipped cars. From 1998/99 to 2008/09, Brazilian ethanol production nearly doubled to 27.5 million liters. Increased vehicle sales have raised demand for fuel and ethanol. The Brazilian government mandates that all gasoline must be blended with 20-25% ethanol. Flexfuel vehicles (FFV), commercially available since 2003 and now in widespread use in Brazil, have the ability to use either blended gasoline or pure ethanol as fuel. Consumers can purchase the fuel that is most cost-effective given the energy differentials between the two, allowing for a greater ethanol capacity and improved substitutability for drivers. In addition, with sugar and ethanol production typically being made in the same facilities, producers can adjust the output mix substantially within each year in response to price movements in both markets, which provides flexibility in the supply of both goods.
forces now have a more significant impact on the U.S. sugar market. While the United States is not fully exposed to global price movements, it has to adapt to the expanded access of Mexican sugar. Under NAFTA, the U.S. gradually liberalized, and, in 2008, completely freed Mexican sugar imports from any tariff. High U.S. sugar prices, and initially low Mexican prices, resulted in Mexican exports to the United States nearly doubling in 2008/09 to a record 1.402 million tons. Mexico subsequently experienced short supplies and is expected to import far more sugar from other countries (904,000 STRV) than it will export to the United States (430,000 STRV) in 2009/10. Although imports from countries other than Mexico are still effectively bound by WTO agreements under normal circumstances (with some discretion for increases by USDA), free trade with Mexico has opened a channel through which market developments outside of the United States can affect the domestic market. High U.S. prices and low prices in Mexico could encourage Mexico to export sugar to the U.S. and allow lower priced imports from Central or South America. However, Mexico’s sugar sector is also heavily regulated by government policies, including restrictions on imports. Policy decisions by the Mexican government will likely be based on concern for its own supply-and-demand balance and the effect on prices within Mexico. As a result, the U.S. sugar supply is more exposed to Mexican supply and prices, as well as to Mexican policymakers’ decisions about import restrictions of their own. ■
India, the worlds’ largest sugar consumer. Sugar production in India, China and Pakistan fell by a combined 15.9 million tons (33%) between 2007/08 and 2008/09, contributing to an unprecedented decline in global sugar stocks. This decline altered trade flows and led to higher prices around the world. Brazil increased its exports in response to the higher prices and greater returns for sugar, but could not fully compensate for the production shortfalls elsewhere, particularly since production in Brazil was held stagnant in 2008/09 by weather problems.
Weather played a role in Asia’s decline in production; but policies also influenced the outcome, and global markets were highly susceptible to perceptions about how production would respond to the economic and policy levers affecting output from this region. China, Pakistan and India together account for over 25% of global sugar consumption — a share that has been growing since 2005. India is the largest consumer, with sugar consumption totaling an estimated 23.5 million metric tons in the 2009/10 marketing year, more than twice the projected U.S. consumption of 9.2 million metric
Production Cycles in Asia Add a Volatile Dimension Despite the fundamental underlying role that Brazil’s exchange rate and sugar-ethanol tradeoff play in shaping world sugar prices, a moreimmediate factor contributing to the sugar price spike in 2009 and 2010 was the decline in production in Asia in 2008 and 2009 — particularly in
THE SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
21
tons. China consumes 14.9 million metric tons of sugar and Pakistan, 4.2 million metric tons. These countries also account for 20 to 30% of global sugar production, depending on the year, but are subject to volatile production cycles. Over the past 10 years, Indian sugar production has ranged from 14.1 to 30.8 million metric tons. Production variability has also increased in China and Pakistan over the past decade, although the cycles are not as large as in India. The result of steadily growing consumption but volatile production has been large swings in net trade for the region as these countries, particularly India, shift from net exporter to net importer and back again. The magnitude of these shifts has increased as production cycles have become more exaggerated. Most recently, India switched from a net exporter of 5.8 million metric tons in 2007/08 to a net importer of nearly 4.5 million tons in 2009/10, representing about 11 and 9% of global trade, respectively. Asian production is expected to increase 23% in 2010/11, and pressures on price due to tight supplies are already beginning to wane. However, continued cyclical production patterns will mean ongoing risks of sudden world sugar price increases — particularly if global demand growth and Brazil’s exchange rate remain strong and if sugarcane for ethanol becomes more lucrative.
Indian Sugar Policies Exacerbate Cyclical Patterns While weather is a critical determinant of output patterns, India’s sugar policies are a major factor behind the production cycles among Asian producers. Most notably, price-setting policies for sugarcane and refined sugar often create conflicting incentives for India’s sugarcane producers and sugar
22
mills. The production cycles filter into global markets when excess production leads to large exports or when deficits in production call for heavy imports to meet consumption needs. Both the central and state governments of India have policies that affect sugar storage, pricing and trade. The Indian Agriculture Ministry recommends annual support prices funded by the central government. State governments then set a price, known as the State Advised Prices (SAP), which sugar millers pay sugarcane growers for their cane. The government also regulates the price of sugar for consumers by using marketing quotas and centrally managed stocks. The relationship between changes in SAP levels and harvested area is clear: reductions in SAPs generally correspond with decreases in sugarcane area harvested, while increased SAPs tend to bring more land into production. However, there is a lag in this relationship due to yield patterns that vary over time. In India, a sugarcane plant is typically harvested for three years — rather than for five or six as in many producing countries — with the first year of growth providing the highest yields. Production depends not only on sugarcane area harvested but on how much of that area is in its first year of growth. Acreage responses are typically stronger in the years following a change in the SAP than in the first year. The result is that price signals affect consumers and producers at different times. For example, in 2005/06, the Indian government began decreasing the SAP for sugar and increasing the support prices for rice and wheat. However, harvested sugar area did not decrease until 2007/08. These policies, designed to support growers and consumers, have caused financial stress for India’s sugar mills, particularly when sugarcane prices are kept high and sugar prices low. The market factors that affect the cost of sugarcane and the price of refined sugar are not aligned. In surpluses, mills face weakening sugar prices but fixed costs based on the SAP. Mills have to defer or default on payments to sugarcane growers. In response, growers will divert sugarcane to the production of alternative sweeteners, such as khandsari and gur, which are not subject to government restrictions. When producers divert land away from sugarcane, the loss of production is exacerbated by the decrease in yields that results from fewer first-year plantings. The central government, in
turn, often modifies its trade policies to encourage exports in surplus years and imports in deficit years.
Global Price Swings Affect U.S. Sugar Market World raw sugar prices have abated on the prospect of increased global production in both 2009/10 and 2010/11. Brazil is expected to produce 28% more sugar in 2010/11, and the Asian countries of India, China and Pakistan are expected to raise production 30%, compared with the low 2008/09 production levels, which should reduce their import demand. Some relief may also come from rising exports out of traditional exporters Thailand and Australia and countries attempting to increase their export potential, such as Colombia. Although many countries attempt to insulate their domestic markets from dramatic price fluctuations like those in the past two years, any country that imports sugar is in some way influenced by global price swings. The U.S., for example, supports domestic prices at or above 20 cents a pound through domestic marketing allotment quotas and through tariff-rate import quotas. The U.S. is still heavily reliant on these imports even though it now imports duty-free sugar from Mexico under the North American Free Trade Agreement. When world sugar prices are close to or above the U.S. base support price, U.S. sugar prices have to be, at minimum, slightly higher than world prices to cover marketing expenses involved with importing tariff-rate quota sugar. Therefore, U.S. sugar prices react to changes in world prices, although not necessarily on a one-to-one basis. So what are the implications of changing world prices for the United States? World prices appear poised to remain at a higher plateau than in the past. Consistently high prices could undermine the rationale for policies that support domestic producers, as well as lower the opportunity cost of government support policies. However, volatility in the global market, such as that caused by Asian production cycles, would still leave U.S. sugar producers vulnerable to low prices without the domestic programs currently in place.■
ASGA 2011 Annual Meeting Tucson, Ariz. • February 6-8 www.americansugarbeet.org
THE SUGARBEET GROWER November/December 2010
INNOVATION.
EDUCATION. NETWORKING.
Sound off on public policy issues and learn new strategies for increasing productivity, running a sustainable operation, and managing your business. From Town Hall Forums to over 35 new education sessions led by industry experts, AG CONNECT Expo has something for you – no matter what size or type of operation you run. See everything AG CONNECT has to offer at agconnect.com.
JANUARY 7—10, 2011 • ATLANTA, GEORGIA, USA PREVIEW DAY: JANUARY 7 BY SPECIAL ADMISSION
CONNECTING THE WORLD OF AGRICULTURE .
• GEORGIA WORLD CONGRESS CENTER