Case Report: False Positive HIV due to p24 Antigen and CD4 Lymphocytopenia

False Positive HIV due to p24 Antigen and CD4 Lymphocytopenia

Jason Wilson, MD, FACEP, FAAEM

Dept. of Emergency Medicine, Division of Internal Medicine, Tampa General Hospital Heather Henderson, MA

Dept. of Emergency Medicine, Division of Internal Medicine, Tampa General Hospital & Department of Anthropology, USF Kaitlyn M. Pereira, BS

Dept. of Emergency Medicine, Division of Internal Medicine, Tampa General Hospital & Morsani College of Medicine, USF

The likelihood of a false positive HIV test increases as the prevalence of HIV decreases and other potential explanations for the presence of p24 antigen become as prevalent as HIV. Often, patients with a false positive laboratory signature do not have other serum evidence of HIV infection. However, we will outline a case of a patient that underwent routine, ED-based HIV screening and had two false positive HIV tests on different dates (reactive screening test, negative confirmatory Ab test, no detectable virus on further nucleic acid testing), but also had a profound reduction of CD4 lymphocytes. There are several hypotheses to explain false positive screening results, including lupus, CAR T-cell therapy, rheumatoid arthritis, and other autoimmune diseases.1–3 Some have suggested a syndromic emergence of a “Idiopathic CD4 lymphocytopenia,” while others have suggested that it is common to have CD4+ lymphocytopenia with malaria, infections, stress, burns, malnutrition, over-exercising and pregnancy.4

A 45-year-old male with eosinophilic esophagitis (EOE) presented to the Emergency Department (ED) with left facial swelling, weakness and numbness that started one hour prior to arrival. The symptoms started on his left upper lip and spread to his nose and cheek. He denied any associated facial droop, dysarthria, dysphagia, tinnitus, auditory symptoms, blurred vision and headache. He reports no history of stroke or TIA. He denied any recent trauma, bug bites, fever or chills. He was also recovering from a prior gastrointestinal infection. His medications include oral budesonide for EOE. He has no pertinent family history and he denies tobacco, alcohol and illicit drug use. While in the ED, he developed pruritus and hives along his left lateral thigh and arm, which were resolved with solumedrol and Pepcid. He received no medications before the hives occurred. The patient had a NIH stroke scale score of 1. A computed tomography image of the brain without contrast demonstrated right frontal encephalomalacia.

While in the ED, the patient underwent routine fourth generation HIV Ab/ p24 Ag on the Abbot Architect, following CDC guidelines. Follow-up confirmatory HIV-1 and HIV-2 antibody test was negative on the Bio-Rad Geenius. An order was then placed for an HIV viral load via RNA PCR on the Hologic Aptima. No virus was detected. Testing was repeated, and the same laboratory signature was observed (HIV-1/2 Ab/Ag reactive, confirmatory Ab negative, no viral load detected). The patient test results were ultimately classified as false positives. The patient had an initial white blood count of 3.23, but his complete blood count and complete metabolic panel were otherwise unremarkable. The HIV nucleic acid test (viral load) results were not available during the ED encounter. Given the reactive screening test results and potential HIV infection, a CD4+ count was obtained. The absolute CD4+ count was 230, making up 28% of the lymphocytic count.

The patient was also admitted to the hospital for further neurological and medical evaluation. He underwent magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the brain without contrast that demonstrated chronic and septal malacia changes of the posterior right frontal lobe. The neurological symptoms resolved during the hospital course and the patient was discharged home.