Trust in the Value Chain - African Digital Intermediaries

!"#$%&'()*+,-.%/0%1')2%/$/3

Trust in the Value Chain

!"#$%&$'()%($*+,-+ #.$+/(0(#)1+2%$)#(3$+ !"'4*#%($*+("+5-%(6) !"#$%&#'()*+#,%-./01

Foreword '2-.#3*44-+)5#-/.#06/703(.#*+8#/2(#90:-+)#/2(#;034*..# <0%63#=0%#>=%-7*+#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#@ABAA5#*:*-C*!C(#2(%(D#-.# .6440%/(8#!"#/2(#E(%3*+#<(8(%*C#9-+-./%"#=0%#F70+03-7# ;004(%*/-0+#*+8#$(:(C043(+/#@,9GD5#-34C(3(+/(8#!"#/2(# $(6/.72(#E(.(CC.72*=/#=H%#?+/(%+*/-0+*C(#G6.*33(+*%!(-/# @E?GD#0I-7(#-+#J06/2#>=%-7*&##

7%(*/-:(#-+86./%-(.5#/2(%(=0%(#06%#3*44-+)#*88%(..(8#/2%((# 4%-3*%"#.(7/0%.#*.#*#3(72*+-.3#/0#6+8(%./*+8#/2(#-+86./%"# 30%(#!%0*8C"5#+*3(C"#@e4C(*.(#.((#=6%/2(%#*#30%(#8(/*-C(8# 8(.7%-4/-0+#0=#(*72#.(7/0%#-+#J(7/-0+#V#0=#/2-.#%(40%/D_

'2(#%(.(*%72#*+8#3*44-+)#1*.#70+867/(8#!"#$%&#'()*+# ,%-./01#0=#/2(#K-/.#L+-:(%.-/"#J7200C#0=#>%/.5##$-)-/*C#>%/.#$(4/&# -+#4*%/+(%.2-4#1-/2#/2(#<*MN6)(.-#>=%-7*+#$-)-/*C#?++0:*/-0+# <(./-:*C#*/#/2(#'.2-30C0)0+)#?++0:*/-0+#O%(7-+7/&#

;:+ /(0(#)1+<)&$*#

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

>#2-)2#+63!(%#0=#/20.(#3*44(8#201(:(%#-8(+/-="#*.#+0/# =*CC-+)#.4(7-=-7*CC"#-+/0#0+(#0=#/2(.(#/2%((#4%-3*%"#.6!Y.(7/0%.5# -+8-7*/-+)#@*.#-.#*88%(..(8#C*/(%#-+#30%(#8(/*-CD#/2*/#30./# -+/(%3(8-*%-(.#2*:(#*#/(+8(+7"#/0#*7/#*.#)(+(%*C-./#%*/2(%#/2*+# -+#.4(7-*C-./#.(7/0%#.4(7-=-7#%0C(.5#*+8#/2(%(#-.#*#=*-%#*306+/#0=# -+/(%3(8-*%"#10%M#2*44(+-+)#*7%0..#.(7/0%.&#'2(.(#/2(%(=0%(# 3*M(#64#*#=06%/2#7*/()0%"_

9:+ /(0(#)1+5"(&)#(,"#

=:+ !&&$%*(3$+>$'()#@12-72#-.#/2(#)%064-+)#0=#:-%/6*C#%(*C-/"# @]^D5#*6)3(+/(8#%(*C-/"#@>^D5#*+8#(P/(+8(8#%(*C-/"#@Q^D#

?:+ 2%,**@A$6#,%

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`&# '2(#3*44-+)#*+8#-/.#*+*C".-.# A&# \6/703(#0=#*#>=%-7*+#$;?#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#^0*83*44-+)# K0%M.204#70+867/(8#1-/2#AB#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#=%03# J06/2#>=%-7*5#G*3!-*5#a(+"*5#L)*+8*5#F/2-04-*5#b-)(%-*# *+8#J(+()*C#/2*/#=0CC01(8#/2(#-+*6)6%*C#<0%63#=0%# >=%-7*+#$-)-/*C#;%(*/-:(#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#/-/C(8#c90:-+)#/2(# ;034*..d#/2*/#/00M#4C*7(#*/#<*MN6)(.-#>=%-7*+#$-)-/*C# ?++0:*/-0+#<(./-:*C#-+#\7/0!(%#ABAA& # '2(#8-)-/*C#7%(*/-:(#-+86./%-(.#*%(#8-./-+7/#=%03#+0+Y8-)-/*C#

78

45#%6-789%:5*+;<= &5*9>*?8)%@-+-85>,-5 4*7*;8)%A5;+%4-?;#%B9*C-5+*;2%<D%;,-%E*;=8;-5+589.

Contents

1

2

5-%(6)"+!"#$%&$'()%($*+("+#.$+ /(0(#)1+2%$)#(3$+!"'4*#%($*

A4&&)%O+,-+P.%$)#*Q+ LII,%#4"(#($*+M+R$6,&&$"')#(,"*

9:9:+# 9:;:+# 9:=:## # 9:?:##

$(=-+-+)#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#?+#;0+/(P/ J/%(+)/2#?+#'2(#]*C6(#;2*-+ $-)-/*C-/"#T#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#?+#'2(#]*C6(#;2*-+# ?+#>#X&B#F70+03" E(+(%*C#?+=0%3*/-0+#>!06/#'2(#9*44-+)

CD CE CF 9C

;:9:# ;:;:# # ;:=:# # ;:?:# ;:D:# ;:G:# ;:E:##

^0C(#J7*%7-/"#?+#'2(#]*C6(#;2*-+ O%(Y$(:(C043(+/5#<-+*+7-+)5#90+(/-.*/-0+# T#J(7/0%#J4(7-*C-.*/-0+ >#;%-.-.#?+#O%0=(..-0+*C#'%*-+-+)# <0%#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.

O(%=0%3*+7(#?+#>#$-)-/*C#]*C6(#;2*-+ E0:(%+3(+/#>+8#?+86./%"#J6440%/ E(+8(%#T#>)(#$-:(%.-/" ^(7033(+8(8#J/%*/()-(.

3

4

>)II("0+!"#$%&$'()%($*J+ A#%$"0#.+("+#.$+ K)14$+2.)("

LI$%)#("0+A#%46#4%$*+M+ N%,-$**(,")1+A4II,%#+-,%+5-%(6)"+ /2!+!"#$%&$'()%($*

=:9:# =:;:# # =:=:# # =:?:# =:D:## #

7B

b0/(#\+#J(7/0%#$(=-+-/-0+.

9*44-+)#?+/(%3(8-*%"#^0C(.#?+#'2(# ]*C6(#;2*-+ R-3-/.#\=#O%0=(..-0+*C#'%*-+-+)#?+#'2(# >=%-7*+#$;?. ?+/(%3(8-*%"#;2*CC(+)(.#?+#J(7/0%#J4(7-=-7-/" '2(#]*C6(#;2*-+#'2%06)2#># ^()-0+*C#O(%.4(7/-:(

;; ;? ;F =; ?G

?:9:# # ?:;:+# # ?:=:##

$03-+*+/#\4(%*/-+)#J/%67/6%(.#?+#>=%-7*+# $;?#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.

E0:(%+3(+/#J6440%/5#O0C-7-(.#>+8# ?+86./%"#J6440%/ O%0=(..-0+*C#F70."./(3.#T#b(/10%M

9; 9?

9D 9G 9E 9F 9H

DC DE GG

Contents

5

6

<$"'$%Q+50$+)"'+ R)6$+R$I%$*$"#)#(,"

T$6,&("0+5"+!"#$%&$'()%OJ+ AU(11*+M+V",W1$'0$+/$3$1,I&$"#+

D:9:# D:;:# # D:=:#

E(+8(%#$-:(%.-/"#?+#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#?+#>=%-7* >)(#T#;*%((%#f06%+("#\=#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#?+# '2(#>=%-7*+#$;?. ^*7(#T#F/2+-7#$-:(%.-/"#

EC EG F;

G:9:# G:;:# #

FP-./-+)#?+/(%3(8-*%"#'%*-+-+)#g-./0%" a+01C(8)(#E*4.#<0%#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#?+# >=%-7*#'08*"

7

8

<1,**)%O+,-+T)*(6+!"#$%&$'()%O+ R,1$*+("+/(0(#)1+2%$)#(3$+!"'4*#%($*

R$-$%$"6$*+ M+2(#)#(,"*

EC0..*%"

^(=(%(+7(.

7S

FG

F= FD

H;

1

Y:Y+/Z[!\!\<+!\PZR>Z/!5R!ZA+!\+2L\PZ]P

African Intermediaries in the Digital Creative Industries 9:9+ /$-("("0+!"#$%&$'()%($*+ + ("+2,"#$^#

-)-/*C#;%(*/-:(#?+86./%-(.#(+7034*..#*#1-8(#%*+)(# 0=#*7/-:-/-(.#/2*/#-+:0C:(#/2(#6.(#0=#8-)-/*C#/(72+0C0)"# /0#8-)-/*CC"#7%(*/(5#8-./%-!6/(5#*+8#30+(/-h(#7%(*/-:(# 70+/(+/&#'2(#.(7/0%.#*+8#.6!Y.(7/0%.#0=#/2(#$-)-/*C#;%(*/-:(# ?+86./%-(.#@$;?N.D#*%(#%*4-8C"#)%01-+)#*+8#*%(#!(703-+)# -+7%(*.-+)C"#-340%/*+/#-+#/2(#)C0!*C#*+8#>=%-7*+#(70+03"&##

D

$-)-/*C#;%(*/-:(#?+86./%-(.#*%(#/%*+.=0%3-+)#/2(#1*"#4(04C(# 70+.63(#*+8#-+/(%*7/#1-/2#7%(*/-:(#70+/(+/5#*+8#*%(# *88-/-0+*CC"#8%-:-+)#/2(#8(:(C043(+/#0=#+(1#/(72+0C0)-(.5# (Y7033(%7(#*+8#8-)-/-.(8#!6.-+(..#=0%#76C/6%(#*+8#7%(*/-:-/"&# ?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#-+#/2(#$-)-/*C#;%(*/-:(#?+86./%-(.#4C*"#*#:-/*C#%0C(# -+#8%-:-+)#/2(.(#8(:(C043(+/.#*+8#2(C4#!%-+)#>=%-7*+#8-)-/*C# 70+/(+/#/0#)C0!*C#*+8#>=%-7*+#*68-(+7(.&

K(#8(=-+(#*+#i-+/(%3(8-*%"N#*.#*+#-+8-:-86*C# 0%#0%)*+-.*/-0+#/2*/#*7/.#/0#=*7-C-/*/(#/2(# 70++(7/-0+#!(/1((+#/2(#7%(*/0%.#0=#8-)-/*C# 70+/(+/#*+8#/2(#!6"(%.#*+8#70+.63(%.#0=# /2*/#70+/(+/&

7X

Y:Y+/Z[!\!\<+!\PZR>Z/!5R!ZA+!\+2L\PZ]P

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b*/-0+.#$(:(C043(+/# O%0)%*33(#@Lb$OD5#/2(#7%(*/-:(#-+86./%-(.#-+#>=%-7*#2*:(# /2(#40/(+/-*C#/0#70+/%-!6/(#30%(#/2*+#Vj#0=#/2(#70+/-+(+/N.# E$O&##g01(:(%5#/2(#%(40%/#*C.0#+0/(.#/2*/#/2(#8-)-/*C#7%(*/-:(# -+86./%-(.#-+#>=%-7*#=*7(#*#+63!(%#0=#72*CC(+)(.5#-+7C68-+)#*# C*7M#0=#-+:(./3(+/5#C-3-/(8#*77(..#/0#3*%M(/.5#*+8#-+*8(k6*/(# -+=%*./%67/6%(#*+8#C()*C#=%*3(10%M.`&##;6%%(+/C"#>=%-7*N.#.2*%(# 0=#/2(#)C0!*C#7%(*/-:(#(70+03"#%(3*-+.#.-)+-=-7*+/C"#C015# *7706+/-+)#=0%#0+C"#*%06+8#A&lj#0=#)C0!*C#7%(*/-:(#)008.# (P40%/.5#%(4%(.(+/-+)#mnZ&X#!-CC-0+#*+8#C(..#/2*+#`j#0=#/2(# >=%-7*+#E$O&A

6'F2%G<;+8<;+<G<C*97%;,-%H<F?8++%I/$//J

7_

>#C0+)#2-./0%"#0=#8-)-/*C#-++0:*/-0+#*+8#7%(*/-:-/"5#*+8#(*%C"# (./*!C-.23(+/#0=#C(*8-+)#/(72+0C0)"#7034*+-(.#*+8#8-)-/*C# 70+/(+/#4%0867(%.#2*:(#*CC01(8#/2(#L+-/(8#J/*/(.5#/2(#L+-/(8# a-+)8035#;*+*8*#*+8#f*4*+#/0#(./*!C-.2#/2(3.(C:(.#*.# C(*8(%.#-+#/2(#$-)-/*C#;%(*/-:(#?+86./%-(.#)C0!*CC"&#^(7(+/C"# +(1#706+/%-(.#2*:(#(3(%)(8#*.#-340%/*+/#4C*"(%.#*+8# -+7C68(#;2-+*5#J06/2#a0%(*5#?+8-*5#*+8#,%*h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

Y:8+APRZ\<Pa+!\+PaZ+K5bcZ+2a5!\

%0C(.5#*.#/2(#$;?#(70."./(3#./-CC#C*%)(C"#-.#6+8(%Y8(:(C04(8# *+8#6+8(%Y.6440%/(8&# '2-.#3*44-+)#-.#.4(7-=-7*CC"#6+-k6(#*+8#-++0:*/-:(#*.#-/#6.(.# /2(#:*C6(#72*-+#*.#/2(#7(+/%*C#0%-(+/*/-0+#=0%#/2(#3*44-+)5#*+8# -+#/2-.#1*"#1(#)(/#*#7034%(2(+.-:(#:-(1#0=#/2(#-+86./%"#*+8# -/.#76%%(+/#2(*C/2[#*+8#30%(#.4(7-=-7*CC"#12*/#-.#C*7M-+)#=%03# /2(#1-8(#%*+)(#0=#./*M(20C8(%.#%(k6-%(8#=0%#12*/#.206C8#!(# .677(..=6C#*+8#.6./*-+*!C(#$;?#(70."./(3#-+#>=%-7*&

A2<.-)-%K)-7(8%IL87<+%H<F*>%H<9M%NOJ G<C*97%;,-%H<F?8++%I/$//J

9:;+ A#%$"0#.+("+#.$+K)14$+2.)("

'2(#)0*C#0=#/2-.#3*44-+)#2*.#!((+#/0#*..(..#/2(#2(*C/2#0=#/2(# >=%-7*+#8-)-/*C#7%(*/-:(#-+86./%"#!"#6+8(%./*+8-+)#/2(#(P/(+/#0=# (+)*)(3(+/#*+8#7*4*!-C-/-(.#0=#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#-+#*#C*%)(%#:*C6(# 72*-+#-+#/2(#$;?N.#-+#J6!YJ*2*%*+#>=%-7*&

\6%#3*44-+)#*-3.#/0#6+8(%./*+8#/2(# 76%%(+/#C*+8.7*4(#0=#*7/-0+.#*+8#%0C(.#0=# /20.(#10%M-+)#*.#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#*7%0..# /2(#.6440%/-+)#:*C6(#72*-+5#*+8#/2(%(=0%(# -340%/*+/C"#80(.#+0/#*-3#/0#3*4#/20.(#120# *7/#.0C(C"#*.#i7%(*/-:(N#0%#i70+/(+/#7%(*/0%N&#

g01(:(%5#*.#1-CC#!(#.201+5#3*+"#.(C=#-8(+/-="-+)# -+/(%3(8-*%-(.#-+#>=%-7*#/(+8#/0#*7/#*.#!0/2#i70+/(+/#7%(*/0%N#0%# i7%(*/-:(N#-+#*88-/-0+#/0#*//(34/-+)#/0#=6C=-C#36C/-4C(#-+/(%3(8-*%"#

7`

\6%#*44%0*72#/0#6.-+)#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+#*.#*#7(+/%*C#0%-(+/*/-0+# =0%#/2(#3*44-+)#-.#C(8#!"#/2(#0!.(%:*/-0+#/2*/#76%%(+/C"#-+# /2(#>=%-7*+#7%(*/-:(#-+86./%-(.#30%(#(342*.-.#*+8#.6440%/# -.#)-:(+#/0#/2(#i7%(*/-:(N#0%#i7%(*/0%N5##12-C(#/2(#*7/-0+.#0=# -+/(%3(8-*%-(.#*%(#C*%)(C"#6+8(%8(:(C04(85#3-.6+8(%./008# *+8#6+8(%Y%(4%(.(+/(8#-+#8(:(C043(+/#./%*/()-(.#*+8#40C-7"# 8(:(C043(+/#=0%#/2(#>=%-7*+#7%(*/-:(#-+86./%-(.&##'2(#.*3(# 40.-/-0+#(P-./.#=0%#/2(#8-)-/*C#7%(*/-:(#-+86./%-(.#"(/#1-/2#30%(# =*%#%(*72-+)#70+7(%+.#=0%#=6/6%(#4%00=-+)#8-)-/*C#70+.634/-0+# *+8#76C/6%(#*+8#7%(*/-:-/"#=%03#>=%-7*&

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

'2(#8-)-/*C#7%(*/-:(#-+86./%-(.#:*C6(#72*-+#7*+#!(#!%0*8C"# 8(.7%-!(8#/2%06)2#/2(#=0CC01-+)#M("#./*)(.5#70330+#-+#/2(# 4%07(..#0=#/2(#8-)-/*C#7%(*/-:(#-+86./%-(._

Y:B+/!<!P5b!Pe+M+!\PZR>Z/!5R!ZA+!\+PaZ+K5bcZ+2a5!\+!\+5+S:7+Z2L\L>e

A#)0$

<$"$%)1+/$*6%(I#(,"

`&#O%(Y$(:(C043(+/

'2-.#./*)(#-+:0C:(.#/2(#)(+(%*/-0+#*+8#8(:(C043(+/#0=#-8(*.#=0%#+(1#8-)-/*C#70+/(+/#*+8# %(C*/(8#.(%:-7(.#.672#*.#3(%72*+8-.-+)#*+8#?O#4C*++-+)&V

A&#O%0867/-0+

'2-.#./*)(#-+:0C:(.#/2(#7%(*/-0+#0=#8-)-/*C#*..(/.5#70+/(+/#*+8#W#0%#.0=/1*%(&

V&#9*%M(/-+)#T# 90+(/-h*/-0+5#$-./%-!6/-0+

9*%M(/-+)#*+8#8-./%-!6/-0+_#'2-.#./*)(#-+:0C:(.#/2(#4%030/-0+5#46!C-7*/-0+#*+8#8-./%-!6/-0+# 0=#8-)-/*C#*..(/.#/2%06)2#:*%-06.#72*++(C.#.672#*.#0+C-+(#4C*/=0%3.5#70+.0C(#4C*/=0%3.#*+8# 30!-C(#8(:-7(.

X&#;0+.634/-0+

'2-.#./*)(#-+:0C:(.#/2(#6.(#0=#8-)-/*C#70+/(+/#*+8#.(%:-7(.#!"#(+8#6.(%.&

9:=+ /(0(#)1(#O+M+!"#$%&$'()%($*+!"+++ + P.$+K)14$+2.)("+!"+5+ + ?:C+Z6,",&O

>770%8-+)#/0#Lb;'>$N.#%(40%/#i;%(*/-:-/(#?+86./%"#X&BN#X5#-/# -.#70330+C"#0!.(%:(8#)C0!*CC"#/2*/#+(1#/(72+0C0)-(.#*+8# 8(C-:(%"#4C*/=0%3.#-+#8-)-/*C#3*%M(/.#7*+#%(867(#/2(##+((8#=0%# -+/(%3(8-*%-(.#!"#*CC01-+)#.644C-(%.#/0#0I(%#/2(-%#4%0867/.# 0%#.(%:-7(.#8-%(7/C"#/0#70+.63(%.#/2%06)2#0+C-+(#4C*/=0%3.&## g01(:(%#*#.-)+-=-7*+/#70+.-8(%*/-0+#=0%#/2(#>=%-7*+#$;?N.# %(.(*%72#2*.#*C.0#.201+#/2*/#/2(.(#4C*/=0%3.#3*"#*C.0#7%(*/(# =(1(%#!6/#30%(#401(%=6C#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.5#%(4%(.(+/(8#!"#*# =(1#-+/(%+(/Y!*.(8#4C*/=0%3.#*+8#)C0!*CC"#%(70)+-.(8#.07-*C# +(/10%M.&#'2(%(!"#%(867-+)#7034(/-/-:(#0440%/6+-/-(.#=0%#C*/(# 0%#.3*CC(%#(+/%*+/.#=%03#>=%-7*& '2(#;\]?$Y`l#4*+8(3-7#*C.0#70+/%-!6/(8#/0#/2(#/%(+8#0=# 8-)-/*C#8(C-:(%"5#*.#30%(#4(04C(#2*:(#/6%+(8#/0#0+C-+(#4C*/=0%3.# =0%#/2(-%#70+/(+/5#4%0867/.#*+8#.(%:-7(.&# 7d

g01(:(%#/2-.#-.#*#70+7(%+#=0%#>=%-7*+#70+/(+/#/2*/#-.#+0/#1(CC# *C-)+(8#/0#7034(/-/-:(#3*%M(/#(+/%"5#*.#8-)-/*C#4C*/=0%3.#80#6.(# *C)0%-/23.#/2*/#6+=*-%C"#4%030/(#4%(Y46%72*.(8#4%0867/.#0%# 8(3*+8#2-)2(%#=((.#=0%#)%(*/(%#:-.-!-C-/"&## '2(#Lb;'>$#%(40%/#2-)2C-)2/.#/2*/#/2(#8-)-/*C#70+/(+/# (70."./(3#-.#7034(/-/-:(C"#1(-)2/(8#/0#/20.(#120#2*:(#!((+# 10%M-+)#1-/2#/(72+0C0)"#C0+)(%#*+8#2*:(#/2(#-+=%*./%67/6%(#/0# .6440%/#-/& L+8(%./*+8-+)#12(/2(%#>=%-7*+#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#-+#/2(#$;?N.# 2*:(#/2(#/(72+-7*C#7*4*!-C-/-(.#*+8#.6440%/#+(7(..*%"#/0# 7034(/(#-.#*+#-340%/*+/#4*%/#0=#/2-.#3*44-+)&##?/#*-3.#/0# (./*!C-.2#12*/#-.#*:*-C*!C(#/0#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#-+#.(76%-+)#*77(..# /0#!0/2#)C0!*C#*+8#C07*C#W#%()-0+*C#3*%M(/.&#g-)2C-)2/(8#-+#/2(# %(40%/#*%(#/2(#%(k6-%(3(+/.#=0%#*8(k6*/(#.6440%/#=0%#C07*C5# +*/-0+*C#*+8#%()-0+*C#8-)-/*C#-+=%*./%67/6%(#8(:(C043(+/5#12-72# -+7C68(.#=6/6%(#4%00=(8#40C-7"#=0%#8-)-/*C#%-)2/.#*+8#01+(%.2-45# *CC#0=#12-72#.206C8#!(#.6440%/(8#!"#)0:(%+3(+/#%()6C*/-0+# *+8#-.#76%%(+/C"#+0/&## L+8(%./*+8-+)#/2(#%0C(.#0=#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#*.#4*%/#0=#*#8-)-/*C# :-(1#0=#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+#7*+#!(#80+(#/2%06)2#/2(#C(+.#0=# /2(#4%(:-06.C"#40.-/-0+(8#X#M("#./*)(.#0=#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+[# !6/#2-)2C-)2/-+)#/2(#8-)-/*C#%(k6-%(3(+/.#=0%#8-)-/*C#7%(*/-:(# -+86./%-(.#:*C6(#72*-+_

Y:B+/!<!P5b!Pe+M+!\PZR>Z/!5R!ZA+!\+PaZ+K5bcZ+2a5!\+!\+5+S:7+Z2L\L>e

A#)0$

<$"$%)1+/$*6%(I#(,"+

/2!+!"#$%&$'()%($*

`&#O%(Y$(:(C043(+/

'2-.#./*)(#-+:0C:(.#/2(#)(+(%*/-0+#*+8# 8(:(C043(+/#0=#-8(*.#=0%#+(1#8-)-/*C# 70+/(+/#*+8#%(C*/(8#.(%:-7(.#.672#*.# 3(%72*+8-.-+)#*+8#?O#4C*++-+)&

• • • • • •

A&#O%0867/-0+

'2-.#./*)(#-+:0C:(.#/2(#7%(*/-0+#0=#8-)-/*C# *..(/.5#70+/(+/#*+8#W#0%#.0=/1*%(&

• •

<6+8-+)#T#?+:(./3(+/ O*%/+(%.2-4#$(:(C043(+/#.672#*.# ;0YO%0867/-0+#0%#O6!C-7*/-0+#$(*C.# 1-/2#$-)-/*C#OC*/=0%3.#T#O6!C-.2(%.

O%(YJ*C(.#>)%((3(+/. $-)-/*C#?O5#R-7(+.-+)#T## ;04"%-)2/#9*+*)(3(+/ 9(%72*+8-.-+)#T#J*C(.#J/%*/()" $-)-/*C#O%0/0/"4(.#T#'(./-+)

g*%81*%(5#J0=/1*%(#T#$-)-/*C# ?+=%*./%67/6%(#J6440%/ $-)-/*C#O6!C-7*/-0+5#O0%/-+)#T# \4/-3-h*/-0+e#

e>#46!C-7*/-0+#/"4-7*CC"#.6440%/.#/2( 4%0867/-0+#0=#70+/(+/#=0%#*#.4(7-=-7 70+.63(%#4C*/=0%35#.672#*.#*#./%(*3-+)# .(%:-7(#=0%#*+#*+-3*/-0+#0%#*#)*3-+)# 70+.0C(#*+8#30!-C(#8(:-7(.#=0%#*#)*3(&# FI(7/-:(#40%/-+)#*CC01.#/2(#70+/(+/#/0#%6+# .300/2C"#0+#/2(.(#4C*/=0%3.#*+8#%(*72# /2(#-+/(+8(8#*68-(+7(&

7f

V&#9*%M(/-+)#T# 90+(/-h*/-0+5#$-./%-!6/-0+

9*%M(/-+)#*+8#8-./%-!6/-0+_#'2-.#./*)(# -+:0C:(.#/2(#4%030/-0+5#46!C-7*/-0+#*+8# 8-./%-!6/-0+#0=#8-)-/*C#*..(/.#/2%06)2# :*%-06.#72*++(C.#.672#*.#0+C-+(# 4C*/=0%3.5#70+.0C(#4C*/=0%3.#*+8#30!-C(# 8(:-7(.

• • • • • • •

<(./-:*C.#T#FP40N. $-)-/*C#O%030/-0+#OC*/=0%3.5 $-)-/*C#;0+/(+/#T#'*C(+/#>))%()*/0%.

O6!C-7*/-0+#O*%/+(%.2-4. $-./%-!6/-0+#O*%/+(%.2-4. '*%)(/(8#$-)-/*C#>8:(%/-.-+) >68-(+7(#$(:(C043(+/

X&#;0+.634/-0+

'2-.#./*)(#-+:0C:(.#/2(#6.(#0=#8-)-/*C# 70+/(+/#*+8#.(%:-7(.#!"#(+8#6.(%.&

• • • • • •

$-)-/*C#F+8#L.(%#OC*/=0%3. $-)-/*C#;0+/(+/#>))%()*/0%. $-)-/*C#J*C(.#T#;033-..-0+.

9(%72*+8-.-+)#J*C(. $-)-/*C#L.(%#W#>68-(+7(#<((8!*7M $-)-/*C#J*C(.#'%*7M-+)#=0%#!0/2#8-%(7/# *+8#-+8-%(7/#46%72*.(.&

Y:S+<Z\ZR5b+!\[LR>5P!L\+5TLcP+PaZ+>5NN!\<

9:?+ <$"$%)1+!"-,%&)#(,"+5g,4#+ + P.$+>)II("0

'2(.(#-+8:-86*C.#%(4%(.(+/#/2(3.(C:(.#-+#.03(#7*.(.5#!6/# 30./C"#=-%3.#*+8#0%)*+-.*/-0+.#04(%*/-+)#-+#$;?N.#*+8#/2(# .(7/0%.#C-./(8#*!0:(#-+#>=%-7*&##'2(#C-./#0=#VBB#-.#%(*.0+*!C"# .3*CC#0+#*+#-+/(%+*/-0+*C#.7*C(5#!6/#/2(#%0C(#0=#-+/(%3(8-*%"# -.#./-CC#C*%)(C"#6+8(:(C04(8#-+#/2(#>=%-7*#(70."./(3#*.#/2-.# %(.(*%72#*+8#3*44-+)#06/703(#1-CC#.201&#

9:?:9+

\6/.-8(#0=#-8(+/-="-+)#M("#-+8-:-86*C.#/2%06)2#06%#01+#0+C-+(# *+8#8(.M#%(.(*%725#06%#3(/208#=0%#(P4*+8-+)#/2(#4*%/-7-4*+/# +(/10%M#1*.#/2%06)2#.+01!*CC#.*34C-+)_

N)%#(6(I)"#*+("+#.$+>)II("0

'2(#3*44-+)#8%*1.#0+#-+=0%3*/-0+# 70+/%-!6/(8#!"#`oo#4*%/-7-4*+/.#0=# *44%0P-3*/(C"#VBB#-+8-:-86*C.#120#1(%(# -8(+/-=-(8#/2%06)2#06%#01+#8(.M#%(.(*%72# *+8#/2%06)2#+(/10%M#%(7033(+8*/-0+.#*.# *7/-+)#*.#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#-+#=0%#/2(# $;?N.#>=%-7*&

Y7

p#

'2(#3*44-+)#.6%:("#1*.#.(+/#8-%(7/C"#/0#Aqq#-+8-:-86*C.# *+8#1*.#7034C(/(8#!"#`oo5#)-:-+)#6.#*#oBj#%(.40+.(#%*/(# /0#/2(#3*44-+)#.6%:("&#

p#

\=#/2(#Aqq#-+:-/(8#/0#4*%/-7-*4/(5#``o#1(%(#-+:-/(8#/2%06)2# +(/10%M#%(7033(+8*/-0+.#@.+01!*CC#.*34C-+)D5#3(*+-+)# XAj#0=#/2(#-+:-/((.#1(%(#-8(+/-=-(8#-+#/2%06)2#+(/10%M# %(7033(+8*/-0+.&##

p#

\=#/2(#``o#-8(+/-=-(8#/2%06)2#+(/10%M#%(7033(+8*/-0+.5# qA#4*%/-7-4*/(8[##)-:-+)#*#oAj#%(.40+.(#%*/(#-+#/2-.#)%064&##

Y:S+<Z\ZR5b+!\[LR>5P!L\+5TLcP+PaZ+>5NN!\<

'2(#:*C6(#0=#6.-+)#/2(#.+01!*CC#.*34C-+)#1*.#*77(..#*# )%(*/(%#+63!(%#0=#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#120#1(%(#+0/#-33(8-*/(C"# :-.-!C(#/0#6.#/2%06)2#0+C-+(#*+8#8(.M#%(.(*%72&# '2(#70+.(k6(+7(#201(:(%#*+8#/2(#=*7/#/2*/#F+)C-.2#1*.#/2(# 3*-+#C*+)6*)(#0=#3*44-+)5#-.#/2*/#/2(#1(-)2/#0=#/2(#3*44-+)# /00M#4C*7(#=0%#J06/2(%+5#F*./#*+8#K(./#>=%-7*#%(.4(7/-:(C"# 1-/2#*#.3*CC(%#70+/%-!6/-0+#=%03#b0%/2#*+8#9-88C(#>=%-7*&# '2-.#-.#*88-/-0+#/0#/2(#=*7/#/2*/#/2(#=076.#706+/%-(.#=0%#/2(# 3*44-+)#12(%(#7(+/(%(8#*%06+8#J06/2#>=%-7*5#a(+"*#*+8# J(+()*C5#-+#3((/-+)#/2(#E?G#3*+8*/(#=0%#/2.#%(.(*%72&##'2-.# )*:(#6.#=(1(%5#!6/#+0/#8-.706+/(8#%(.40+.(.#=%03#b0%/2# *+8#9-88C(#>=%-7*5#120#*88-/-0+*CC"#/(+8#/0#(+)*)(#-+# <%*+70420+(#!6.-+(..#%(C*/-0+.2-4.#*+8#b0%/2#>=%-7*#80(.# 2*:(#./%0+)(%#4*%/+(%.2-4.#-+#F6%04(#%*/2(%#/2*+#J6!Y J*2*%*+#>=%-7*&# K(#=6%/2(%#70+867/(8#0+(Y0+Y0+(#-+/(%:-(1.#1-/2#An# -+8-:-86*C.#@S6./#0:(%#XBj#0=#/2(#/0/*C#4*%/-4*+/#)%064D#120# 4*%/-7-4*/(8#-+#/2(#3*44-+)&#'2(#-+/(%:-(1#.*34C(#1*.# %(4%(.(+/*/-:(#*#%*+)(#0=#)(+8(%.5#*)(.5#.(7/0%.#*+8#04(%*/-+)#

G<C*97%;,-%H<F?8++%P<5'F%D<5%Q9;-5F-.*85*-+%I/$//J

YY

706+/-(.#*7%0..#/2(#70+/-+(+/&#'2(#-+/(%:-(1.#1(%(#70+867/(8# 1-/2#*+#(342*.-.#0+#)*-+-+)#)%(*/(%#-+.-)2/#0+#/04-7.# %(C*/(8#/0#M+01C(8)(#*77(..5#.M-CC.#C(:(C.#*+8#10%M-+)#1-/2# )0:(%+3(+/.#*+8#-+#70336+-/-(.5#-+=0%3*/-0+#/2*/#706C8#+0/# !(#(*.-C"#)*-+(8#/2%06)2#/2(#3*44-+)#.6%:("&

2

8:Y+RLbZ+A25R2!Pe+!\+PaZ+K5bcZ+2a5!\+M+b!>!PZ/+LNZR5P!\<+APRc2PcRZA

Summary of Threats, Opportunities & Recommendations 2(#=0CC01-+)#/2%(*/.#*+8#0440%/6+-/-(.#8%*1#8-%(7/C"# =%03#/2-.#3*44-+)#*+*C".-.#*+8#*%(#0%)*+-.(8#-+# /04-7#*%(*.#%(=C(7/-+)#/2(#/04-7.#0=#/2(#*+*C".-.#-+# /2-.#%(40%/&#

T

e#E-%5-><FF-9.%;,8;%2<'%5-D-5%;<%;,-%F8*9%(<.2%<D%;,-%5-?<5;% D<5%F<5-%.-;8*)%<9%=,2%89.%,<=%;,-+-%?85;*>')85%;,5-8;+%<5% <??<5;'9*;*-+%-R*+;%89.%,<=%;,-2%85-%-+;8()*+,-.%;,5<'7,%;,-% F8??*97%898)2+*+#

;:9+ R,1$+A6)%6(#O+!"+P.$+K)14$++ + + 2.)("+M+b(&(#$'+ + LI$%)#("0+A#%46#4%$*

Y8

8:Y+RLbZ+A25R2!Pe+!\+PaZ+K5bcZ+2a5!\+M+b!>!PZ/+LNZR5P!\<+APRc2PcRZA

P.%$)#*

LII,%#4"(#($*

$;?.#-+#>=%-7*#*%(#0:(%C"#1(-)2/(8#/01*%8.#/2(#4%0867/-0+# ./*)(#@AD5#1-/2#*#70+7(%+-+)#.7*%7-/"#0=#7*4*7-/"#*+8#.M-CC#=0%# /2(#0/2(%#./*)(.#0=#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+&#

'2(#76%%(+/#1(-)2/#/01*%8.#4%0867/-0+#-+#/2(#>=%-7*+# $;?#:*C6(#72*-+5#.-)+*C.#*+#-+7%(*.-+)#8(3*+8#=0%#8-)-/*C# 7%(*/-:(#70+/(+/#*+8#*+#0440%/6+(#303(+/#/0#-+:(./#-+# /2(#C*%)(%#:*C6(Y72*-+#.4(7-=-7*CC"#-+#4%(Y8(:(C043(+/#@`D5# 3*%M-+)#T#8-./%-!6/-0+#@VD#*+8#*77(..#=0%#70+.63(%.# @XD#./*)(.&#

R-3-/(8#6+8(%./*+8-+)#0=#:*C6(Y72*-+.#*+8#*#.7*%7-/"# *7%0..#/2(#$;?#:*C6(Y72*-+#-.#*#3*S0%#/2%(*/#-+#>=%-7*&# '2(%(#-.#*#70+7(%+-+)#C*7M#0=#6+8(%./*+8-+)#0=#/2(#:*C6(# 0=#*#C*%)(%#:*C6(#72*-+5#-+#*88-/-0+#/0#*#)(+(%*C#C*7M#0=# 7*4*7-/"#*7%0..#/2(#V#M("#./*)(.#0=#*#$;?#:*C6(#72*-+_#O%(Y $(:(C043(+/#@`D5#9*%M(/-+)#T#$-./%-!6/-0+#@VD#*+8#>77(..# =0%#;0+.63(%.#@XD&#O*%/-76*%C"#.(7/0%#.4(7-=-7#@*+-3*/-0+5# )*3-+)5#:%5#(/7D#6+8(%./*+8-+)#*+8#.M-CC#.(/.&

^*%(#C*%)(#7034*+-(.#-+#/2(#>=%-7*+#$;?N.#@VBYnBrD#*%(# >=%-7*+#36C/-+*/-0+*C.5#04(%*/-+)#*7%0..#%()-0+.5#4%0:-8-+)# *+#044(%/6+-/"#/0#(+2*+7(#%()-0+*C#3*%M(/#*77(..&##R01# %()-0+*C#7034(/-/-0+#*+8#*34C(#0440%/6+-/-(.#/0#3((/# :*C6(#72*-+#+((8.#4C*7(.#>=%-7*+#36C/-Y+*/-0+*C.#-+#4%-3(# 40.-/-0+&#J(7/0%#.4(7-*C-.*/-0+#-.#201(:(%#%(k6-%(8#/0#3((/# >=%-7*#.4(7-=-7#:*C6(#72*-+.#+((8.#30%(#(I(7/-:(C"&

>=%-7*+#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#*%(#0:(%Y!6%8(+(8#%(40%/-+)# 7*%%"-+)#A#/0#n#:*C6(#72*-+#*7/-0+.5#-+7C68-+)#4%0867/-0+&# '2-.#4C*7(.#*+#(P7(..-:(#!6%8(+#0+#4%0867/-0+#7034*+-(.5# 120#06/#0=#46%(#+((85#*%(#/*M-+)#0+#30%(#*7/-0+.#/2*+#/2("# 7*+#.6./*-+*!C"#20C85#C-3-/-+)#/2(-%#*!-C-/"#/0#3((/#!0/2#/2(-%# 01+#4%0867/-0+#%0C(.#*+8#0/2(%#*7/-0+.#0=#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+&

\44(%/6+-/-(.#(P-./#=0%#.7*C(8#)%01/2#0=#.3*CC#4%0867/-0+# 7034*+-(.#@803-+*+/#-+#/2(#(70."./(3D#/0#!(//(%#=*7-C-/*/(# 4%(Y8(:(C043(+/#./*)(#10%M5#12-C(#!6-C8-+)#%(C*/-0+.2-4.# 1-/2#%()-0+*C#36/C-Y+*/-0+*C#8-./%-!6/0%.#*+8#*))%()*/0%.&#

>=%-7*+#$;?#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#(70."./(3#-.#803-+*/(8#0=# :(%"#.3*CC#*+8#0:(%#!6%8(+(8#7034*+-(.#Y#2-+8(%-+)#/2-(%# *!-C-/"#/0#3((/#/2(#+((8.#0=#*+#6+8(%8(:(C04(8#:*C6(#72*-+&## 90./#%(40%/#!%-+)#4*%/#0=#:(%"#.3*CC#7034*+-(.#0=#!(/1((+# `#*+8#`B#(34C0"((.5##/2-.#7064C(8#1-/2#/2(#4%0867/-0+Y 1(-)2/(8#:*C6(#72*-+5##36C/-4C(#%0C(.#2(C85#C-3-/(8#%(.06%7(.# *+8#=-+*+7-+)#*77(..#40.(.#*#.-)+-=-7*+/#/2%(*/#/0#/2(# >=%-7*+#$;?N.&#9*M-+)#.7*C-+)#8-I-76C/5#/2(%(=0%(#=6%/2(%# 2-+8(%-+)#/2(-%#*!-C-/"#/0#3((/#/2(#+((8.#0=#12*/#-.#*+# 6+8(%8(:(C04(8#:*C6(Y72*-+&

O*%%*CC(C#044(%/6+-/(.#(P-./#=0%#.6440%/-+)#)%01/2#0=#+(1# 7034*+-(.#/0#.4(7-=-7*CC"#=-CC#3-..-+)#%0C(.#-+#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+# 0=#/*M-+)#>=%-7*+#8-)-/*C#7%(*/-:(#70+/(+/#/0#C07*C5#%()-0+*C# *+8#-+/(%+*/-0+*C#3*%M(/.&

<0%#30%(#-+=0%3*/-0+#0+#/2(#X#a("#J/*)(.#0=#/2(#$;?#:*C6(# 72*-+#4C(*.(#.((#$-)-/*C-/"#T#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#?+#'2(#]*C6(# ;2*-+#?+#>#X&B#F70+03"& <0%#30%(#8*/*#0+#%0C(#.7*%7-/"#4C(*.(#.((#^0C(#J7*%7-/"# ?+#'2(#>=%-7*+#?+/(%3(8-*%"#]*C6(#;2*-+5#;0+.(k6(+7(.# YB

0=#*#O%0867/-0+#g(*:"#]*C6(#;2*-+#T#'2(#^()-0+*C#^0C(.# ?34*7/(8#,"#J/%0+)#O*+#>=%-7*+#OC*"(%.& <0%#30%(#0+#8*/*#0+#04(%*/-+)#./%67/6%(.#*+8#%()-0+*C-/"# 4C(*.(#.((#$03-+*+/#\4(%*/-+)#J/%67/6%(.#?+#>=%-7*+# $;?#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.&

8:8+NRZh/ZKZbLN>Z\P+[!\5\2!\<+M+ANZ2!5b!A5P!L\

;:;+ N%$@/$3$1,I&$"#Q+[(")"6("0Q++ + >,"$#(*)#(,"+M+ + A$6#,%+AI$6()1(*)#(,"

P.%$)#*

LII,%#4"(#($*

'2(%(#-.#*#7%-/-7*C#C*7M#0=#704"%-)2/#*+8#?O#3*+*)(3(+/# -+#>=%-7*+#$;?s.5#C*%)(C"#86(#/0#*#C*7M#0=#%()6C*/0%"# .6440%/#*7%0..#>=%-7*+#+*/-0+.&#'2-.#-.#7064C(8#1-/2#*# =(*%#0=#/2(#-+*8(k6*7-(.#-+#/2(#>=%-7*+#C()*C#."./(3.5# *.#1(CC#*.#*#)(+(%*C#C*7M#0=#6+8(%./*+8-+)#!"#/20.(#-+# /2(.(#-+/(%3(8-*%"#%0C(.#0=#/2(#:*C6(#*+8#!(+(=-/#0=#?O# 3*+*)(3(+/#*+8#4%0/(7/-0+.&#9*+"#!(C-(:(#/2*/#04(+# *77(..#-.#30%(#!(+(=-7-*C#-+#/2(#76%%(+/#C-3-/(8#7C-3*/(&#

\44(%/6+/-(.#(P-./#=0%#/2(#4%030/-0+#0=#M+01C(8)(#0+# $;?#:*C6(Y72*-+.#*+8#64.M-CC-+)#*/#4%(Y8(:(C043(+/#*+8# =-+*+7-+)#./*)(.5#12-72#1-CC#C(*8#/0#*#./%0+)(%#40.-/-0+.#0+# ?O#4%0/(7/-0+#*+8#30+(/-h*/-0+&#

>=%-7*+#$;?#:*C6(Y72*-+.#*%(#+0/#3((/-+)#/2(#*7/-0+.#0=# .(7/0%#.4(7-=-7#+((8.#-+#4%(Y=-+*+7-+)5#?O#3*+*)(3(+/5# *+8#C07*C#0%#%()-0+*C#70+.634/-0+#*:(+6(.5#-+8-:-86*C.# 0%#7034*+-(.#/2*/#20C8#/2(.(#4*%/-76*C%#-+/(%3(8-*%"# %0C(.#C*7M#/2(#.(7/0%Y.4(7-=-7#.M-CC.#+((8(8#/0#4%0/(7/#*+8# 30+-/-.(#70+/(+/#=0%#8-I(%(+/#.(7/0%.&

J(7/0%#.4(7-*C-.*/-0+#=0%#?O#3*+*)(3(+/#@*+-3*/-0+5# )*3(.5#:%5#(/7D#1-CC#.6440%/#)%01/2#*+8#8(:(C043(+/5# .(7/0%#.4(7=-7#:*C6(#72*-+#/%*-+-+)#7*+#2(C4#*88%(..#/2(# 7%-/-7*C#6+8(%8(:(C043(+/#0=#30+(/-h*/-0+#-+#/2(#$;?# :*C6(#72*-+&

'2(%(#-.#*#.-)+-=-7*+/#C*7M#0=#.M-CC#*+8#M+01C(8)(#-+#/2(# $;?N.#/0#%(.40+8#/0#?O#3*+*)(3(+/#*+8#/2(#%(.06%7(.# @M+01C(8)(#*+8#7*4-/*CD#/0#(+)*)(#(P/(%+*C#4*%/-(.#=0%# .6440%/#/00&

<0%#30%(#0+#70+7(%+#*%06+8#O%(Y$(:(C043(+/#*+8# ;0+.634/-0+#./*)(.#4C(*.(#.((#9*44-+)#?+/(%3(8-*%"#^0C(.# ?+#'2(#]*C6(#;2*-+& <0%#30%(#0+#8*/*#*+8#70+7(%+.#*%06+8#.(7/0%#.4(7-t7-/"# 4C(*.(#.((#?+/(%3(8-*%"#;2*CC(+)(.#?+#J(7/0%#J4(7-=-7-/"#*+8# ?34*7/#0=#R-3-/(8#J(7/0%#J4(7-=-7-/"#-+#/2(#X&B#F70+03"& YS

8:B+5+2R!A!A+!\+NRL[ZAA!L\5b+PR5!\!\<+[LR+!\PZR>Z/!5R!ZA

;:=+ 5+2%(*(*+!"+ + N%,-$**(,")1+P%)("("0+ + [,%+!"#$%&$'()%($*

P.%$)#*

LII,%#4"(#($*

O%0=(..-0+*C#/%*-+-+)#-.#!(-+)#2(C8#3*-+C"#-+#10%M4C*7(.# *+8#%(40%/(8#*.#*#4%-3*%"#*7/-0+#0=#3*+"#7034*+-(.5 12-72#12(+#70+.-8(%-+)#/2(#(:-8(+7(#0+#.3*CC#7034*+"# .-h(#*+8#C-3-/(8#%0C(.#*+8#.M-CC.[#-.#!6%8(+-+)#*C%(*8"# !6%8(+(8#0%)*+-.*/-0+.&

\440%/6+-/-(.#/0#7*4*7-/*/(#=0%3*C#/%*-+-+)#-+./-/6/-0+.#/0# /*M(#0+#4%0=(..-0+*C#0%#-+/(%3(8-*%"#.M-CC.#/%*-+-+)#-+#0%8(%# /0#6+!6%8(+#4%0867/-0+#*+8#*8:07*7"#%0C(.#=%03# 4%0=(..-0+*C#/%*-+-+)&

>8:07*7"#)%064.#*C.0#*%(#7*%%"-+)#/2(#!6%8(+#0=# 4%0=(..-0+*C#/%*-+-+)#-+7%(*.-+)#/2(#4%(..6%(#0+#*+#*C%(*8" C-3-/(8#+63!(%#0=#*8:07*7"#*+8#=0%3*C#-+86./%"#.6440%/# )%064.#/0#0I(%#/%*-+-+)5#%*/2(%#4C*"-+)#/2(#-340%/*+/#%0C( 0=#-+/(%=*7(#!(/1((+#-+86./%"#*+8#)0:(%+3(+/.#=0%#40C-7"# *+8#=%*3(10%M#8(:(C043(+/&

\440%/6+-/"#/0#40.-/-0+#103(+#/2%06)2#/%*-+-+)#-+#3((/-+)# /2(#+((8.#0=#/2(#6+8(:(C04(8#:*C6(#72*-+.5#.4(7-t7*CC"#-+ 4%(Y8(:(C043(+/#*+8#76./03(%#*77(..#./*)(.&

<0%#30%(#8*/*#0+#70+7(%+#*%06+8#4%0=(..-0+*C#/%*-+-+)#4C(*.(# .((#^0C(#J7*%7-/"#T#/2(#g-)2#\776%%(+7(#\=#O%0=(..-0+*C# '%*-+-+)#*.#*#^0C(#*+8#'2(#,6%8(+#0=#-+#g06.(#'%*-+-+)& YX

8:S++NZR[LR>5\2Z+!\+5+/!<!P5b+K5bcZ+2a5!\

;:?+ N$%-,%&)"6$+!"+5+/(0(#)1+ + K)14$+2.)("

P.%$)#*

LII,%#4"(#($*

'2(%(#-.#*#7%-/-7*C#C*7M#0=#%(70)+-/-0+#=0%#/2(#8-./-+7/#8-)-/*C# %(k6-%(3(+/.#-+#4%(Y8(:(C043(+/5#.*C(.5#?O#30+-/-h*/-0+# *+8#8-)-/*C#8-./%-!6/-0+#=0%#/2(#$;?N.&#

E*3-+)#*+8#?33(%.-:(#9(8-*#*.#.(7/0%.#12-C(#./-CC# %(k6-%-+)#8(:(C043(+/#*%(#!(//(%#.-/6*/(8#/0#(+)*)(#-+# ./%0+)(%#8-)-/*C#:*C6(#72*-+.#*7%0..#./*)(.#=%03#4%(Y 8(:(C043(+/#/2%06)2#4%0867/-0+5#/0#3*%M(/-+)# *+8#8-./%-!6/-0+&

>+-3*/-0+#*.#*#.(7/0%#-+#>=%-7*#-.#=*CC-+)#%*4-8C"#!(2-+8# E*3-+)#*+8#?33(%.-:(#9(8-*#@12-72#*C.0#+((8#2(C4D#-+# *))%()*/-0+5#8-./%-!6/-0+5#*+8#*77(..#-+#8-)-/*C#72*++(C.&## '2(#>=%-7*+#*+-3*/-0+#-.#+0/#3((/-+)#/2(#8-)-/*C#3*%M(/# (+)*)(3(+/5#40-+/-+)#/0#*#7%-.-.#-+#/2(#30+(/-.*/-0+#0=# 8-)-/*C#*+-3*/-0+&#'2-.#-.#86(#/0#/2(#C*7M#0=#+0/#0+C"#70%(# 8-)-/*C#:*C6(Y72*-+#*7/-0+.5#!6/#4%(Y8(:(C043(+/#./*)(# (+)*)(3(+/#-+#8-)-/*C#?O#*+8#704"%-)2/#3*+*)(3(+/&

E*3-+)#2*.#/2(#30./#8-:(%.-/"#-+#0%)*+-.*/-0+*C#./%67/6%(.# %*+)-+)#803-+*+/C"#-+#.3*CC#!6.-+(..#/0#!(-+)#%(4%(.(+/(8# !"#C*%)(%#36C/-+*/-0+*C.#Y#3*M-+)#-/#/2(#!(./#4C*7(8#.(7/0%# =0%#%()-0+*C#*+8#3(8-63#.-h(8#.6440%/(8# -+/(%3(8-*%"#)%01/2&#

<0%#30%(#0+#.(7/0%#*+8#%()-0+#.4(7-t7-/"#4C(*.(#.((#?34*7/# 0=#R-3-/(8#J(7/0%#J4(7-t7-/"#T#'2(#]*C6(#;2*-+#/2%06)2#*# ^()-0+*C#O(%.4(7/-:(& <0%#30%(#0+#0%)*+-.*/-0+#./%67/6%(.#-+#.(7/0%.#4C(*.(#.((# \4(%*/-+)#J/%67/6%(.5#J-h(.#T#^0C(.#T#;0+.(k6(+7(#0=# FP/%(3(.#-+#E*3-+)#J(7/0%#;034*+"#J-h(.& Y_

8:X+<LKZR\>Z\P+5\/+!\/cAPRe+AcNNLRP

;:D+ <,3$%"&$"#+5"'+ + !"'4*#%O+A4II,%#

P.%$)#*

LII,%#4"(#($*

E0:(%+3(+/#.6440%/#=0%#/2(#$;?N.#-.#7%-/-7*CC"#C01#*7%0..# /2(#70+/-+(+/5#1-/2#0+C"#J06/2#>=%-7*#-+#/2(#J06/2(%+# >=%-7*+#%()-0+#%(40%/-+)#7034*%*/-:(C"#.6!./*+/-*C#.6440%/&# R01(%#%(40%/-+)#-+#F*./#>=%-7*#-.#0+C"#-+8-7*/(8#=0%#a(+"* *+8#^1*+8*#*+8#(:(+#C01(%#K(./#>=%-7*+#.6440%/#-.# %(40%/(8#0+C"#=0%#J(+()*C#*+8#b-)(%-*&

J06/2#>=%-7*#*.#*#30%(#70+867-:(#C07*/-0+#=0%#8(:(C043(+/# *+8#.6440%/#0=#$;?#!6.-+(..5#-/#-.#=6%/2(%#/2(#203(#0= :*%-06.#36C/-+*/-0+*C#04(%*/-0+.#*7%0..#>=%-7*#/2*/#80# .6440%/#%()-0+*C#8-./%-!6/-0+#*+8#*))%()*/-0+#0=#>=%-7*+ 8-)-/*C#7%(*/-:(#70+/(+/&

'2(#=(1#(P-./-+)#*8:07*7"#*+8#.6440%/#!08-(.#/2*/# (P-./#*%(#!6%8(+(8#!"#/2(#+((8#/0#/*M(#0+#-+86./%"#*+8# 4%0=(..-0+*C#/%*-+-+)#%0C(.#*+8#2*:(#C-//C(#7*4*7-/"#/0 .6440%/#)(+6-+(#)0:(%+3(+/#*+8#40C-7"#(+)*)(3(+/#=0%# /2(#>=%-7*+#$;?N.&

'2(%(#-.#(:-8(+7(#0=#./%0+)#40C-7"#*+8#)0:(%+3(+/# =%*3(10%M#*1*%(+(..#!"#-+8-:-86*C.#10%M-+)#-+#/2(#$;?N.# *+8#(P/(+.-:(#+0+Y=0%3*C#4%0=(..-0+*C#.6440%/#+(/10%M#=0%# .(7/0%.#*/#!0/2#706+/%"5#%()-0+#*+8#70+/-+(+/#C(:(C& ?+8-7*/-+)#*#7C(*%#0440%/6+-/"#/0#(+706%*)(#*+8#*..-./#-+# /2(#=0%3*/-0+#0=#=0%3*C#*8:07*7"#*+8#-+86./%" %(4%(.(+/*/-0+#=%03#/2-.#-+=0%3*C#+(/10%M&

>#C*7M#0=#)0:(%+3(+/#.6440%/#7*+#C-3-/#/2(#)%01/2#*+8# 8(:(C043(+/#0=#-+=%*./%67/6%(5#%(.06%7(.#*+8#70%( 8(:(C043(+/&#?/#7*+#C-3-/#/%*-+-+)5#(867*/-0+5#*+8#*77(..#/0# %(.06%7(.5#3*M-+)#-/#2*%8(%#/0#(+/(%#/2(#-+86./%"&

'2(%(#*%(#C-//C(#/0#+0#=0%3*C#-+86./%"#*+8#*8:07*7"#)%064.# %(4%(.(+/-+)#$;?#.(7/0%.#0%#10%M-+)#1-/2#)0:(%+3(+/.#/0 *8:07*/(#=0%#8(:(C043(+/&

<0%#30%(#0+#)0:(%+3(+/.#*+8#4%0=(..-0+*C#.6440%/#4C(*.(# .((#E0:(%+3(+/#J6440%/5#O0C-7-(.#>+8#?+86./%"#J6440%/# 1-/2#*#=076.#0+#40C-7"#*+8#40C-7"#+((8.#2(%(#K2*/#/2(#$;?.# ?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#1*+/#=%03#E0:(%+3(+/.5#E0:(%+3(+/#J6440%/# -.#;%-/-7*CC"#R01#5#O0C-7"#>1*%(+(..#*+8#?/.#?34*7/#0+#/2(# >=%-7*+#$;?.& Y`

<0%#30%(#0+#)0:(%+3(+/.#*+8#0+#4%0=(..-0+*C#+(/10%M.# 4C(*.(#.((#J/%0+)#b0+Y<0%3*C#*+8#b0+Y^()-./(%(8#b(/10%M# 0=#O%0=(..-0+*C#J6440%/#E%064.#*+8#FP-./-+)#O%0=(..-0+*C# J6440%/#T#J-)+-=-7*+/#b((8#=0%#<0%3*C#R0!!"#E%064&

8:_+<Z\/ZR+M+5<Z+/!KZRA!Pe

;:G+ <$"'$%+M+ + 50$+/(3$%*(#O

P.%$)#*

LII,%#4"(#($*

K03(+#*%(#./-CC#6+8(%%(4%(.(+/(8#-+#/2(#$;?N.5#!(//(%# %(4%(.(+/*/-0+#0I(%.#8-I(%(+/#4(%.4(7/-:(.5#*.#1(CC#*.# 30%(#-++0:*/-0+#*+8#(70+03-7#)%01/2&#?34%0:-+)#8-:(%.-/"# 7*+#2(C4#-+7%(*.(#*77(..#/0#%()-0+*C#*+8#-+/(%+*/-0+*C *68-(+7(.5#=6%/2(%#70+/%-!6/-+)#/0#/2(#)%01/2#0=# /2(#-+86./%"&

'2(#>=%-7*+#$;?#*%(#.201-+)#.-)+.#0=#04(+-+)#64#/0# 103(+5#4*%/-76C*%C"#"06+)(%#103(+#*+8#-+#-+/(%3(8-*%" %0C(.&#'20.(#/2*/#*%(#0C8(%#*+8#*7/-+)#*.#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.# 2*:(#!((+#/2(%(=0%(#.03(#/-3(5#*+8#*%(#1(CC#4C*7(8#/0#*7/# *.#3(+/0%.&

'2(%(#-.#*#7C(*%#0440%/6+-/"#/0#.6440%/#7*%((%#8(:(C043(+/# =0%#(*%C"#/0#3-8#7*%((%#103(+#/0#*..-./#1-/2#/2(#C003-+) .M-CC.#)*4.#-+#/2(#$;?#:*C6(#72*-+.&

<0%#30%(#0+#)(+8(%#*+8#8-:(%.-/"#4C(*.(#.((#E(+8(%#$-:(%.-/"# ?+#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#?+#>=%-7*#6+8(%#E(+8(%5#>)(#*+8#^*7(# ^(4%(.(+/*/-0+#=0%#$;?#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.& Yd

8:`+RZ2L>>Z\/Z/+APR5PZ<!ZAJ+AaLRPQ+>Z/!c>+M+bL\<

;:E+ R$6,&&$"'$'+A#%)#$0($*J++ + + A.,%#Q+>$'(4&+M+b,"0

,6-C8-+)#0+#/2(#8(/*-C.#3*44-+)#*+*C".-.#*+8#/2(#%0*83*44-+)# 10%M.204#70+867/(8#1-/2#$;?#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#*7%0..#F*./5# K(./#*+8#J06/2(%+#>=%-7*#@90:-+)#/2(#;034*.._#<0%3#=0%# >=%-7*+#$;?#?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#@ABAADD5#/2(#=0CC01-+)#4%(.(+/.# %(7033(+8(8#*7/-0+.#/0#.6440%/#*+8#8(:(C04#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.# -+#/2(#>=%-7*+#$;?N.&

J/(4#A_###^()-0+*C#+(/10%M.#0=## # # # # ####-+/(%3(8-*%-(.5#7064C(8#1-/2# # # ####%()-0+*C#4%0I(.-0+*C#+(/10%M.#*.# # # ####*8:07*7"#)%064.&# # J/(4#V_###;0+/-+(+/#1-8(#+(/10%M.#0=## # # # ####?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#*+8#.6440%/#=0%#$;?## # # ####-+/(%3(8-*%"#*7/-0+.& T4(1'+P%4*#+("+#.$+K)14$+2.)("

;:E:9+

A.,%#+P$%&+R$6,&&$"')#(,"*

O6.2#.677(..#./0%-(.5#+*3(#*+8#7C*-3# !"#C(:(%*)-+)#/2(#./%(+)/2.#0=#C07*C# (70."./(3.*+8#%()-0+*C#70CC*!0%*/-0+#/0# !6-C8#8-:(%.(#*+8#7*4*7-/*/(8#:*C6(Y72*-+.&

2%$)#$+K(*(g(1(#O+5"'+P%4*#+[,%+P.$+K)14$+2.)("+5"'+ !"#$%&$'()%($*# '2(#$-)-/*C#;%(*/-:(#?+86./%"#-+#>=%-7*#-.#-+#-/.#(*%C"# 8(:(C043(+/#./*)(5#1-/2#.-)+-=-7*+/#)*4.#-+#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+.# *+8#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#10%M-+)#-+#-.0C*/-0+[#1-/2#C-3-/(8#7*4*7-/"# /0#%(.40+8#/0#!6-C8-+)#=6+7/-0+-+)#:*C6(#72*-+.#*+8#8-)-/*C# 30+(/-h*/-0+#(70."./(3.&# >+#-340%/*+/#=-%./#./(4#1-CC#!(#/0#!6-C8#+(/10%M.#*/#706+/%"5# %()-0+*C5#*+8#70+/-+(+/*C#C(:(C#/2*/#7*+#.6440%/#$;?# -+/(%3(8-*%-(.#+0/#0+C"#-+#7%(*/-+)#*#6+-=-(8#C*+)6*)(#*+8# :-.-!-C-/"#=0%#/2(-%#10%M#!6/#-340%/*+/C"#-+#3*M-+)#:-.-!C(#/2(# +((8.#0=#/2(#)%(*/(%#:*C6(#72*-+&#'2-.#/*.M#.206C8#!(#*-3(8#*/# .2*%-+)#M+01C(8)(#*+8#!(./#4%*7/-7(5#*+8#/2(%(!"#*:0-8-+)# %(4(/-/-0+#0=#(I0%/&

T4(1'+\$#W,%U*+M+2,11)g,%)#(," J/(4#`_####;-/"#*+8#706+/%"#+(/10%M.#0=## # # # ####-+/(%3(8-*%-(.5#7064C(8#1-/2# # #######!6-C8-+)#4%0I(.-0+*C#+(/10%M.#-+/0## # #######*8:07*7"#)%064.&

Yf

!"#$%&$'()%O+/$3$1,I&$"#+5"'+5'3,6)6O+P,,1U(# ?+/(%3(8-*%-(.#(+)*)(8#-+#/2(#%0*83*44-+)#10%M.204# .6))(./(8#/2*/#/2(#7%(*/-0+#0=#/00CM-/.#706C8#2(C4#(P-./-+)# -+/(%3(8-*%-(.#*+8#*C.0#.6440%/#*+8#(+706%*)(#+(1# 4%0=(..-0+*C.#/0#/*M(#64#-+/(%3(8-*%"#%0C(.#*+8#*7/-0+.#-+#/2(# .(7/0%#-+#*%(*.#12-72#*%(#76%%(+/C"#8%*./-7*CC"#6+8(%Y%(.06%7(8&# '2(#=0CC01-+)#C-./#0=#i/00CM-/#.6440%/N#-/(3.#-.#C-./(8#!0/2#-+# %(.40+.(#/0#/2(#%0*83*44-+)#10%M.204.#*+8#/2(#3*44-+)&

O*-%(8#1-/2#+(/10%M#8(:(C043(+/#*+8# 70+.-8(%-+)#/2(#(*%C"#./*)(#+((8.5#/2(# /00CM-/#7*+#!(#.-34C(_ i+ A.)%$+/$-("(#(,"*#0=#$;?#:*C6(#72*-+# ./*)(.#*+8#*..07-*/(8#*7/-0+.#%(k6-%(8# =0%#/2(#>=%-7*+#$;?N.#/0#/2%-:(&# #

8:`+RZ2L>>Z\/Z/+APR5PZ<!ZAJ+AaLRPQ+>Z/!c>+M+bL\<

i+ >)II("0+56#(3(#O#/0#(+706%*)(#.(C=# 3*44-+)#0=#(70."./(3.#/0#*#:*C6(Y72*-+# 8(=-+-/-0+&#<0CC01(8#!"#-8(+/-="-+)#)*4.# -+#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+#3*44(8#(70."./(3# Y#-8(*CC"#4(%#.(7/0%#-+#%(.40+.(#/0# .4(7-*C-.(8#.(7/0%#+((8.&# i+ A#,%O#$11("0+P,,1*#/0#*8:07*/(#=0%#*+8# /(CC#.677(..#./0%-(.#*!06/## -+/(%3(8-*%"#10%M&# i+ P,,1*+-,%+/)#)+<)#.$%("0#*.#!0/2# -+86./%"#*+8#)0:(%+3(+/.#C*7M# *+#6+8(%./*+8-+)#0=#/2(#76%%(+/# 4(%=0%3*+7(#0=#$;?N.&#'00C.#.206C8# !(#7%(*/(8#/0#(+706%*)(#8*/*#C0))-+)# *+8#.2*%-+)#0+#(70+03-7#*+8#*7/-:-/"# *7/-0+.#-+#/2(#>=%-7*+#$;?N.&# i+ P,,1*+-,%+L4#6,&$*+/(**$&(")#(,"# =%03#/2-.#3*44-+)#*+*C".-.#*+8#C07*C-.(8# 3*44-+)#*+8#8*/*#)*/2(%-+)#*7/-:-/-(.# *.#8*/*#/0#$;?N.#!%0*8C"#*+8#-+/0# )0:(%+3(+/.&# i+ R$0(,")1+)"'+6,"#("$"#+W('$+ %$I,*(#,%O+,-+("#$%&$'()%O+)6#,%*+ )"'+)6#(,"*#@<*MN6)(.-#?+/(%3(8-*%"# OC*/=0%3D&

;:E:;+

87

>$'(4&+P$%&+R$6,&&$"')#(,"*

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k6(#0440%/6+-/"#/0#=076.#0+#103(+#=-CC-+)#30%(# 8-:(%.(#%0C(.#*7%0..#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+#*+8#.6440%/-+)#"06+)#*+8# (*%C"#7*%((%#(+/%*+/.#8-%(7/C"#*.#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#-+#/2(#>=%-7*+# $;?#C*+8.7*4(5#%*/2(%#/2*+#*.#70+/(+/#7%(*/0%.#0%#4%0867(%.&# # !"#$%&$'()%O+Z^I$%#(*$+R$j4(%$'+56%,**+P.$+K)14$+2.)(" '2(#3*44-+)#*+*C".-.#.201.#*#=076.#0+#4%0867/-0+#./*)(.#0=# /2(#:*C6(#72*-+5#C(*:-+)#0/2(%#./*)(.#.672#*.#4%(Y8(:(C043(+/# *+8#8-./%-!6/-0+#6+8(%-+:(./(8&# >88%(..-+)#)*4.#-+#*CC#./*)(.#0=#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+#-.#+(7(..*%"# /0#=6CC"#4%0/(7/#*+8#30+(/-h(#/2(#70+/(+/&#<0%#-+./*+7(5# -+:(./-+)#-+#?O#4C*++-+)#*/#/2(#4%(Y8(:(C043(+/#./*)(#7*+# 7%(*/(#0440%/6+-/-(.#=0%#30+(/-h*/-0+#*/#/2(#8-./%-!6/-0+#./*)(& [%$$+cI+5'3,6)6O+<%,4I*+P,+T4(1'+A4II,%#(3$+/(0(#)1+5"'+ [4#4%$+N%,,-$'+N,1(6O+P,W)%'*+A4II,%#(3$+ R$0(,")1+R$041)#(," <(1#$;?#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#*%(#-+:0C:(8#-+#-+86./%"#*8:07*7"# *+8#/2(#=(1#(P-./-+)#*8:07*7"#)%064.#*%(#8-%(7/-+)#*//(+/-0+# /01*%8.#.M-CCY!6-C8-+)#-+./(*8#0=#4%(..-+)#C0+)Y/(%3#+((8.5# .672#*.#40C-7"#8(:(C043(+/#7%-/-7*C#=0%#.6440%/-+)#/2(# 7034(/-/-:(#8-)-/*C#+((8.#0=#/2(#-+86./%"&# b(/10%M#./*M(20C8(%.#+((8#/0#(./*!C-.2#=0%3*C#-+86./%"#*+8# *8:07*7"#!08-(.#-+#0%8(%#/0#(+)*)(#70CC*!0%*/-0+#1-/2#>=%-7*+# )0:(%+3(+/.#/0#7%(*/(#.6440%/-:(#(+:-%0+3(+/.5#-+7C68-+)# 6+8(%./*+8-+)#/2(#:*C6(#0=#8*/*5##8-)-/-h*/-0+5#-+=%*./%67/6%(# 8(:(C043(+/#*+8#%()-0+*C#%()6C*/-0+#/0#4%0/(7/#*+8#.6440%/# C07*C#3*%M(/.&

8:`+RZ2L>>Z\/Z/+APR5PZ<!ZAJ+AaLRPQ+>Z/!c>+M+bL\<

;:E:=+

b,"0+P$%&+R$6,&&$"')#(,"*

A4II,%#+5"'+/$3$1,I&$"#+L-+>$'(4&+A(k$'+ 5-%(6)"+L%0)"(*)#(,"* '2(#.3*CC#+63!(%#0=#C*%)(#0%)*+-.*/-0+.#1-/2-+#/2-.#.4*7(#*+8# *7M+01C(8)3(+/#/2*/#/2("#*%(#36/C-Y+*/-0+*C5#-+8-7*/(.#/2*/# /2(%(#-.#*+#0440%/6+-/"#=0%#.6440%/-+)#)%01/2#=%03#.3*CC#/0# 3(8-63#.-h(8#!6.-+(..#-+#/2-.#C*+8.7*4(#/2*/#7*+#-+/(%*7/#1-/2# /2(#*7/-0+.#0=#/2(#C*%)(%#36C/-+*/-0+*C#*7/0%.& 9(8-63#.-h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

8Y

G<9*>8%@<5C*S%IE-+75<=M%TAJ G<C*97%;,-%H<F?8++%P<5'F%I/$//J

3

B:Y+\LPZ+L\+AZ2PLR+/Z[!\!P!L\A

Mapping Intermediaries: Strength in the Value Chain =:9+ \,#$+,"+A$6#,%+/$-("(#(,"*

.#/2(#=6+7/-0+.#0=#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#-+#8-)-/*C#7%(*/-:(# -+86./%-(.#*%(#8-./-+7/#=%03#+0+Y8-)-/*C#7%(*/-:(# -+86./%-(.5#/2(#/2%((#4%-3*%"#.(7/0%.[#8-)-/*C# *+-3*/-0+5#8-)-/*C#)*3(.5#*+8#-33(%.-:(#3(8-*# *%(#6.(8#-+#/2-.#3*44-+)#*.#*#3(72*+-.3#/0#6+8(%./*+8#/2(# -+86./%"#-+#-/.#8-:(%.-/"#*+8#.4(7-=-7-/"&#'2(.(#.(7/0%.#.2*%(# .-3-C*%-/-(.#-+#3*+"#*.4(7/.#0=#/2(-%#:*C6(#72*-+.5#!6/#*%(#*C.0# :(%"#8-:(%)(+/#-+#/2(-%#4%0867/-0+#*+8#8-..(3-+*/-0+#4-4(C-+(.

A

'04#C(:(C#8-I(%(+7(#!(/1((+#/2(.(#.(7/0%#-+#%(.40+.(#/2(#/2(# :*C6(#72*-+#-+7C68(_

/(0(#)1+)"(&)#(,"#-.#A$#0%#V$5#+0+Y -+/(%*7/-:(#*+8#7*+#!(#-+#.20%/#0%#C0+)# =0%3&#;0+.63(8#/2%06)2_#]-8(0#0+# 8(3*+8#@]0$D#.672#*.#U06'6!(#0%# 30!-C(#*))%()*/0%.#.672#*.#E*%*#J/0%([# .6!.7%-4/-0+#.(%:-7(.#.672#*.#b(/=C-P5# $J'][#4*"#4(%#:-(1#.(%:-7(.#.672#*.## 9"90:-(.>=%-7*#*+8#-+#7-+(3*&

88

B:Y+\LPZ+L\+AZ2PLR+/Z[!\!P!L\A

/(0(#)1+<)&$*#*%(#-+/(%*7/-:(#*+8#%*+)(# =%03#(867*/-0+*C#/0#(+/(%/*-+3(+/#)*3(.# 1-/2#4%0867/-0+#:*C6(#.7*C(.#=%03#>>># E*3(.#/0#?+8-(#E*3(.#/0#>8:(%E*3(.& ;0+.63(8#/2%06)2_#90!-C(5#O;#0%# 70+.0C(#12(%(#8-./%-!6/-0+#3*"#-+7C68(# 70CC*!0%*/-0+.#1-/2#4C*/=0%3#40%/(%.5# 46!C-.2(%.#*+8#*))%()*/0%.#/0# /2(.(#4C*/=0%3.&

!&&$%*(3$+&$'()#7*+#!(#-+/(%*7/-:(#0%# +0+Y-+/(%*7/-:(#@VoB#=-C3D#*+8#%(k6-%(.#*+# -33(%.-:(#8(:-7(#=0%#70+.634/-0+_## # ]-%/6*C#^(*C-/"#@]^D#-.#=6CC"#-33(%.-:(#-+#* 2(*8.(/#0%#-+#*#3(/*:(%.(#4C*/=0%3&# >6)3(+/(8#^(*C-/"#@>^#0%#9-P(8#^(*C-/"# 9^D#-.#.7%((+#!*.(8#!6/#-+/(%*7/-:(#1-/2#*# 42".-7*C#(+:-%0+3(+/#*+8#80(.#+0/#%(k6-%( *#2(*8.(/&e## ;0+.63(8#-+#-33(%.-:(#7*4*!C(# (+:-%0+3(+/.#=0%#6.(#-+#.4(7-*C-.(8#C(*%+-+)# 0%#(+/(%/*-+3(+/#=0%3*/.&#\%#-+/0#-33(%.-:(# 8-./%-!6/-0+#72*++(C.#.672#*.#-33(%.-:(# ]0$#C-M(#"06'6!(#0%#70+.0C(#308(C.# .672#*.#/2(#g';#]-:(5#0%#8-%(7/C"#-+#0+C-+(# -33(%.-:(#10%C8.#.672#*.#3(/*:(%.(&## eFP/(+8(8#^(*C-/"#@Q^D#%(=(%.#/0#/2(#=*3-C"#0=# -33(%.-:(#/(72+0C0)-(.

8B

K2-C(#1(#6.(#/2(.(#.(7/0%.#/0#3*4#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#-+#/2(#$;?N.# -+#>=%-7*5#8-./-+7/-0+.#!(/1((+#/2(#.(7/0%.#*%(#+0/#*C1*".#*.# 7C(*%Y76/#*.#8(.7%-!(8#*!0:(&##?+=*7/5#1-/2#>=%-7*+#$;?N.#!(-+)# -+#/2(-%#-+=*+7"5#1(#.((#*#)008#8(*C#0=#7%0..0:(%#!(/1((+# .(7/0%.&#?+#4*%/-76C*%#!"#/20.(#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#120#3*"#10%M# *7%0..#.(7/0%.#0%#*7%0..#36C/-4C(Y%(k6-%(3(+/.#-+#/2(#C*%)(%# $;?#(70."./(3&J03(#7*+#!(#.((+#-+#/2(#=0CC01-+)#(P*34C(.&# OC(*.(#+0/(#/2*/#/2(.(#7%0..0:(%.#*%(#+0/#6+-:(%.*C#*+8#0=/(+# -+#0+C"#0+(#4*%/-76C*%#*.4(7/#0=#*#)%(*/(%#:*C6(Y72*-+5# =0%#-+./*+7(_

$-)-/*C#*+-3*/-0+#0=/(+#*C-)+.#/0#=-C3#-+#-/.# 8-./%-!6/-0+#*+8#46!C-7*/-0+#308(C.5#!6/# 2*.#:(%"#8-I(%(+/#=-+*+7-+)#+((8.#*+8# 4%0867/-0+#4-4(C-+(.& J03(#=0%3.#0=#-33(%.-:(#3(8-*5#.672# *.#VoB#=-C35#*C-)+#/0#=-C3#*+8#*+-3*/-0+# 308(C.5#!6/#(:(+#1-/2#/2-.#/2(-%#8-./%-!6/-0+# *+8#46!C-7*/-0+#308(C.#80+N/&#K2-C(#0/2(%# =0%3.#?33(%.-:(#9(8-*#*%(#30%(#*C-)+(8#/0# )*3-+)#-(&#-33(%.-:(#)*3(.& $-)-/*C#)*3(#8(:(C043(+/#-.#30%(# 0=/(+#/2*+#+0/#30%(#*C-)+(8#/0#?'#*+8# >44#8(:(C043(+/#308(C.5#!6/#80(.#+0/# *C1*".#+0/#.(%:(#i/00CN#/"4(#=6+7/-0+.[# *+8#-.#/2(%(=0%(#8(=-+(8#*.#(+/(%/*-+3(+/# -+#-/.#8-./%-!6/-0+#308(C.5#(:(+#12(+#-/.# 4%0867/-0+#*+8#46!C-7*/-0+.#308(C.#80#+0/& # K-/2#/2(#%*4-8#4*7(#0=#/(72+0C0)-7*C# -++0:*/-0+#1(#.((#*88-/-0+*C#3(%)-+)#-+# +(1#*+8#(P40+(+/-*C#1*".5#*+#(P*34C(#/2(# )%01/2#-+#:-%/6*C#%(*C-/"#)*3-+)#-.# 0+(#(P*34C(&

B:8+>5NN!\<+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+RLbZA+!\+PaZ+K5bcZ+2a5!\

,6-C8-+)#0+#/2(#*!0:(#6+8(%./*+8-+)#-/#-.#-340%/*+/#/2*/#/2(# -+86./%"#3*-+/*-+.#.6440%/#=0%#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+#1-/2#*#./%0+)# %(70)+-/-0+#0=#/2(#.4(7-*C-.*/-0+[#*7M+01C(8)-+)#*+8#10%M-+)# /0#.6440%/#*#.(7/0%s.#*7/-0+.#=%03#i8(:(C043(+/N#/0#i70+.63(%N# ./*)(.&##g01(:(%5#*CC01-+)#=0%#%003#=0%#/2(#7034C(P-/-(.#*+8# 40/(+/-*C.#0=#%*4-8#8-)-/*C#8-:(%)(+7(.#1-CC#*..-./#1-/2#/2(# %(.-C-(+7(#/0#/(72+0C0)-7*C#72*+)(#*+8#=6/6%(#4%00=-+)# /2(#-+86./%"

O8F-%18FU P8SV'7-+*%P-+;*C8)%I/$//J

G<)<%A9*F8;*<9%Q9>'(8;<5 6+,*F<)<7<97%&5->*9>;

=:;+ >)II("0+!"#$%&$'()%O+R,1$*+!"++ + P.$+K)14$+2.)("

=:;:9+ +

P';'5-%AD5*>8%!@%KR,*(*;*<9 P8SV'7-+*%P-+;*C8)%I/$//J

8S

R,1$+A6)%6(#O+!"+P.$+5-%(6)"+!"#$%&$'()%O+ K)14$+2.)("

>#.-)+-=-7*+/#=-+8-+)#0=#/2(#3*44-+)#1*.#/2*/#nBj##0=#(P-./-+)# -+/(%3(8-*%-(.#-8(+/-=-(8#/2(-%#%0C(#0%#4*%/#0=#/2(-%#%0C(#*.# u$-)-/*C#;0+/(+/#O%0867(%5u#*+8#XAj#-8(+/-=-(8#/2(-%#%0C(#0%#4*%/# 0=#/2(-%#%0C(#*.#cO%0=(..-0+*C#'%*-+-+)d#@;2*%/#A#D&###'2(#3*44-+)# =6%/2(%#-+8-7*/(8#/2*/#>=%-7*+#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#*%(#0+#*:(%*)(# (+)*)(8#-+#AYn#-+/(%3(8-*%"#%0C(.#(*72#@;2*%/#VD&###g0C8-+)# 36C/-4C(#%0C(.5#-+#*88-/-0+#/0#/2(#803-+*+7(#0=#c$-)-/*C#;0+/(+/# O%0867(%d#*+8#cO%0=(..-0+*C#'%*-+-+)d#*.#-+Y4*%/#%0C(.#-.#*+# -+8-7*/0%#0=#*#.(%-06.#C*7M#0=#8-:(%.(#.M-CC#-+#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+&#

B:8+>5NN!\<+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+RLbZA+!\+PaZ+K5bcZ+2a5!\

8X

?:+2,"*4&I#(,"

\+C-+(#$-./%-!6/-0+#OC*/=0%3

`n

`n

O0%/-+)#;0+/(+/#,(/1((+#OC*/=0%3.

`n

;0+/(+/#>))%()*/0%

`q

`q

\+C-+(#O%030/-0+#OC*/=0%3

A`

A`

J6440%/-+)#0%#$%-:-+)#J(7/0%#?+:(./3(+/

AA

J6440%/-+)#0%#$%-:-+)#J(7/0%#<6+8-+)

AV

;0+/(+/#$-./%-!6/0%

An

;0+/(+/#O6!C-.2(%

Ao

'(72#;034*+"#J6440%/-+)#$-)-/*C#;%(*/-:(.

Al

'*C(+/#>))%()*/0%

Vl

Vl

<(./-:*C#0%#FP40

X`

X`

?+76!*/-0+#=0%#$-)-/*C#;0+/(+/#;%(*/-:(.

X`

?+86./%"5#>8:07*7"#E%0645#0%#,08"

XA

O%0=(..-0+*C#'%*-+-+)

ol

$-)-/*C#;0+/(+/#O%0867(%

ZA

500%$0)#$'+P,#)1

T:+AU(11+/$3$1,I&$"#+

=:+>)%U$#("0+M+ >,"$#(k)#(,"

``

;:+N%,'46#(,"

``

9:+/$3$1,&$"#

``

R,1$ \+C-+(#>))%()*/-0+#OC*/=0%3

5:+!"'4*#%O+M+N,1(6O+ /$3$1,I&$"#

@<)-%Q.-9;*W>8;*<9%(2%E-*7,;-.%H<'9;%<D%&85;*>*?89;+%*9%;,-%G8??*97%878*9+;%+;87-+%<D%;,-%4HQ%!8)'-XH,8*9

A)&,1$+<%,4I+,-+9GG

P5TbZ+7Y

`n l

AA `A

`V

AV

Ao

An

Al

X`

Al

X`

X` XA ol

X`

ZA

9CE

9H=

9GH

?H

FE

99C

B:8+>5NN!\<+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+RLbZA+!\+PaZ+K5bcZ+2a5!\

'2(#=0CC01-+)#.(7/-0+#.201.#=6%/2(%#/2-.#.7*%7-/"#*+8#/2(# 6%)(+/#C*7M#0=#%0C(.#!(-+)#=-CC(8#/2*/#3((/#/2(#8(:(C043(+/# @`D5#3*%M(/5#30+(/-h*/-0+#T#8-./%-!6/-0+#@AD#*+8#70+.63(%#@XD# ./*)(.#0=#/2(#>=%-7*+#$;?#:*C6(#72*-+&# 24%%$"#+("#$%&$'()%O+%,1$*+)%$+#,,+.$)3(1O+W$(0.#$'+#,+#.$+ N%,'46#(,"+A#)0$ '2(#1(-)2/#0+#/2(#4%0867/-0+#./*)(#-+8-7*/(._ `&# '2-.#8*/*#.6440%/.#06%#-+-/-*C#=-+8-+).#/2*/#30./#-+86./%"# .6440%/#-.#8*+)(%06.C"#0%-(+/*/(8#/0#4%0867/-0+&#?/#-.# 201(:(%#*#)008#-+8-7*/0%#0=#/2(#8(3*+8#=0%#>=%-7*+#8-)-/*C# 7%(*/-:(#70+/(+/&# A&# >#2-)2#+63!(%#0=#/20.(#120#-8(+/-="#%0C(.#-+#4%0867/-0+# *%(#*88-/-0+*CC"#%(40%/-+)#/0#*//(34/#/0#=-CC#0/2(%#%0C(.# 76%%(+/C"#6+.6440%/(8#-+#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+&#<6%/2(%# -+8-7*/-+)#/2(#70+7(%+#=0%#-+*8(k6*/(#7*4*7-/"#*7%0..#/2(# C*%)(%#:*C6(#72*-+&o# V&# '2(#%(C*/-:(C"#2-)2#+63!(%#0=#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#*7/-+)#6+8(%# c/*C(+/#*))%()*/0%N#T#i=(./-:*C#0%#(P40.d5#.6440%/.#/2(# .6))(./-0+#/2*/#/2(%(#-.#-+/(%(./#*+8#8(3*+8#=0%#*+8# -+/(%(./#-+#4%030/-+)#/2-.#10%[##!6/#8(.4-/(#/2-.5#8-./%-!6/-0+# *+8#*))%()*/-0+#-.#+0/#1(CC#.6440%/(8#*/#*CC5#-+8-7*/-+)# *#.(%-06.#)*4#-+#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+#/2*/#2*.#-34C-7*/-0+.# =0%#!0/2#4%0867(%.#*+8#c/*C(+/#*))%()*/0%N#T#i=(./-:*C#0%# (P40.d& N%$@[(")"6("0Q+!N+>)")0$&$"#+M+2,"*4&I#(,"+53$"4$*+ )%$+A$3$%$1O+c"'$%'$3$1,I$' '2(#C01#(342*.-.#0+#%0C(.#-+#/2(#4%(Y8(:(C043(+/#@`D#*+8# 70+.63(%#@XD#./*)(.#.6))(./.#/2(#=0CC01-+) `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j#0=#/2(#0%)*+-.*/-0+.#*+8#

8`

-+8-:-86*C.#-+/(%:-(1(8#-+8-7*/(8#/2*/#/2("#(+)*)(#-+#?O# *+8#704"%-)2/#3*+*)(3(+/&#K-/2#*44%0P-3*/(C"#0+C"## nBj#0=#/2(.(#@ABj#0=#/2(#/0/*CD#80-+)#.0#./%*/()-7*CC"# *.#4*%/#0=#.*C(.#4C*++-+)&##'2(#3*S0%-/"#0=#-+/(%:-(1((.# %(40%/(8#/2*/#?O#0%#704"%-)2/#-.#)(+(%*CC"#+0/#(+)*)(8#*+8# -=#.0#0+C"#*.#4*%/#0=#.(%:-7(#70+/%*7/.5#-+8-7*/-+)_ # # #

>&# # # # #

>#C*7M#0=#%()6C*/0%"#.6440%/#*7%0..#>=%-7*+## +*/-0+.5#*C0+).-8(#=(*%#0=#/2(#-+*8(k6*7-(.#-+## /2(#C()*C#."./(3#*+8#/2(%(=0%(#C()*C#.6440%/&#

# # # #

,&## # # # # # #

>#C*7M#0=#6+8(%./*+8-+)#0=#/2(#:*C6(#*+8## # !(+(=-/#0=#?O#3*+*)(3(+/#*+8#4%0/(7/-0+.5## *+8#=((C#/2*/#04(+#*77(..#!(-+)#30%(# !(+(=-7-*C#-+#/2(#76%%(+/#C-3-/(8#7C-3*/(&#

# # #

;&# # # # #

>#C*7M#0=#.M-CC#*+8#M+01C(8)(#/0#%(.40+8#/0# -/#*+8#/2(#(P4(+.(#0=#(+)*)-+)#(P/(%+*C## # 4*%/-(.#=0%#.6440%/&

=:;:;+

2,"*$j4$"6$*+,-+)+N%,'46#(,"+a$)3O+K)14$+2.)("

'2(#4%0867/-0+#1(-)2/(8#:*C6(#72*-+#-+#/2(#>=%-7*+#$;?N.# 3-%%0%.#/2(#%-.(#0=#/2(#8-)-/*C#7%(*/-:(#-+86./%"#*+8#/2(# -+7%(*.(8#7*4*!-C-/-(.#0=#8(:(C04-+)#706+/%-(.#/0#70+/%-!6/(# /2%06)2#4%0867/-0+#*+8#(P40%/#0=#7%(*/-:(#70+/(+/&# g01(:(%#8*/*#%(=C(7/(8#-+#Lb;'>$N.#%(40%/#i;%(*/-:-/(# ?+86./%"#X&BN#.201.#/2*/#06/.-8(#0=#>.-*5#30./#8(:(C04-+)# 706+/%-(.#%(=C(7/#*#+()*/-:(#/%*8(#!*C*+7(5#1-/2#>=%-7*# 4%(.(+/-+)#0+(#0=#/2(#C01(./#C(:(C.#0=#704"%-)2/#7C*-3.#=0%#-/.# 8-)-/*C#70+/(+/#)C0!*CC"& '2(#70+.(k6(+7(.#0=#6+8(:(C04(8#*+8#6+.6440%/(8# 4%(Y8(:(C043(+/#@`D5#46!C-7*/-0+.#*+8#8-./%-!6/-0+#@VD#*+8# 70+.63(%#@XD#./*)(.#0=#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+5#-.#/2(#$;?N.#2*:-+)# +0#7*4*7-/"#/0#30+(/-h(#0%#7C*-3#-+703(#=%03#8-)-/*C#7%(*/-:(# 70+/(+/#!(-+)#4%0867(8#-+#>=%-7*&#?+#*88-/-0+#/0#C0.-+)# 7034(/-/-:(#*8:*+/*)(#/0#+()0/-*/(#!(//(%#8(*C.#1-/2#C*%)(# 36C/-+*/-0+*C.#1-/206/#7C(*%#4%(Y8(:(C043(+/#0!S(7/-:(.& \440%/6+-/-(.#=0%#-+703(#)(+(%*/-0+#*%(#C0./#-+#/2(#4%(Y 8(:(C043(+/#./*)(#12(+#4*%/+(%.2-4.#0%#=0%1*%8#4%0/(7/-+)# 8(*C.#*+8#30+(/-h*/-0+#./%*/()-(.#@.672#*.#3(%72*+8-.-+)#

B:B+b!>!PA+L[+NRL[ZAA!L\5b+PR5!\!\<+!\+PaZ+5[R!25\+/2!lA

0%#(:(+#(I(7/-:(#/%*8(#%(C*/-0+.2-4.D#*%(#+0/#8(:(C04(8# (I(7/-:(C"#*.#4*%/#0=#(*%C"#42*.(#4C*++-+)&q#

N%,-$**(,")1+P%)("("0+-,%+/2!l*+(*+",#+g$("0+&$#+gO+[,%&)1+ Z'46)#(,"+M+P%)("("0+!"*#(#4#(,"*

?+*8(k6*/(#8(:(C043(+/#4C*++-+)5#-+#*88-/-0+#/0#/2(#:(%"#C01# (+)*)(3(+/#1-/2#70+.634/-0+5#*7/.#/0#!(+(=-/#/20.(#=(1# )C0!*C-.(8#=-%3.#120#*%(#*88-/-0+*CC"#10%M-+)#/0#70%+(%#>=%-7*+# 70+.63(%.5#=0%#!0/2#)C0!*C#*+8#>=%-7*+#8-)-/*C#7%(*/-:(#70+/(+/&##

\+C"#`Aj#0=#/20.(#120#C-./(8#cO%0=(..-0+*C#'%*-+-+)d#*.#*#%0C(# *%(#*..07-*/(8#1-/2#*#=0%3*C#(867*/-0+#0%#/%*-+-+)#0%)*+-.*/-0+# *+8#*#C*%)(#40%/-0+#Y#n`j#Y#120#C-./(8#cO%0=(..-0+*C#'%*-+-+)d# *.#*#%0C(#*C.0#C-./(8#c$-)-/*C#;0+/(+/#O%0867/-0+d#*.#*#%0C(5# .201-+)_

'2(#*%)63(+/#=0%#/2(#8(:(C043(+/#*+8#.6440%/#0=# -+/(%3(8-*%-(.#-.#/0#*.M#=0%#*#.2-=/#=%03#(*%C"#42*.(# 30+(/-h*/-0+#./%*/()-(.#*/#/2(#C(:(C#0=#0+C"#4%0867/-0+# =-%3.#Y#*.#-/#76%%(+/C"#./*+8.#Y#/01*%8.#/2(#700%8-+*/-0+#0=# -+/(%3(8-*%"#7*4*7-/-(.#C07*CC"5#+*/-0+*CC"#*+8#%()-0+*CC"&## K-/2#*#7C0.(#70+.-8(%*/-0+#0=#/2(#0440%/6+-/-(.#0=#)%(*/(%# i8-)-/*C#/%*8(N#!("0+8#.-34C(#3*%M(/#*77(..#12-72#%(C-(.#0+# :*C6(#72*-+.#06/.-8(#0=#>=%-7*5#!6/#=0%#203()%01+#i3*%M(/# 4(+(/%*/-0+N#Y#12-72#.206C8#-+7C68(#-+86./%-*C#64)%*8-+)#*+8# !(//(%#=6/6%(#4%00=(8#40C-7"#*+8#%()6C*/-0+#.6440%/&## ]-/*CC"#-/#1-CC#%(k6-%(#*#7C0.(#6+8(%./*+8-+)#0=#/2(#:*C6(#0=#8*/*# *+8#8-)-/-.*/-0+#-+#/2(#76%%(+/#3*%M(/#*+8#/2(#*!-C-/"#0=#%()-0+*C# %()6C*/-0+#/0#4%0/(7/#-/#*+8#.6440%/#-/.#3*%M(/.#C07*CC"&

=:=+ b(&(#*+L-+N%,-$**(,")1+P%)("("0++ + !"+P.$+5-%(6)"+/2!m*

=:=:9+ +

R,1$+A6)%6(#O+M+#.$+a(0.+L664%%$"6$+L-++ N%,-$**(,")1+P%)("("0+)*+)+R,1$

+

?+#'*!C(#`#*!0:(#1(#3*44(8#*88-/-0+*C#.(7/-0+.#>#*+8# ,#%(4%(.(+/-+)#%(.4(7/-:(C"#/20.(#120#-8(+/-="#*.#*7/-+)# -+#c>8:07*7"#0%#?+86./%"#,08-(.d#*+8#/20.(#120#C-./# cO%0=(..-0+*C#'%*-+-+)d#*.#*#%0C(&#?+8-7*/-+)#*#:(%"#2-)2# 0776%%(+7(#0=#/20.(#-8(+/-="-+)#cO%0=(..-0+*C#'%*-+-+)d#*.# *#%0C(&# K2-C(#-+-/-*CC"#+0/#*44*%(+/5#/2-.#.201.#*#./%0+)#70%%(C*/-0+#/0# %0C(#.7*%7-/"#=0%#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#-+#/2(##=0CC01-+)#1*"._

8d

`&# 90./#7034*+-(.#%(C"#0+#-+Y206.(#/%*-+-+)&#>#=*7/# .6440%/(8#!"#/2(#J06/2#>=%-7*+#i<0%#/2(#K-+NZ#%(40%/#=0%# )*4.#-+#/2(#)*3-+)#.(7/0%5#12-72#-+8-7*/(8#/2*/#30./# /(%/-*%"#)%*86*/(.#-+#/2(#$;?N.#*%(#6+4%(4*%(8#=0%#/2(# 10%M-+)#10%C8#*+8#30./#.4(7-=-7*CC"#=0%#%0C(.#06/.-8(#0=# ./*+8*%8#7%(*/-:(#0%#(+/%"#/(72+-7*C#.M-CC.&#<6%/2(%5#-+#06%# -+/(%:-(1.#*#J06/2#>=%-7*+#?33(%.-:(#9(8-*## 7034*+"#(P4C*-+(8_# # # #

>&# # # # #

'2*/#*CC#/2(-%#(34C0"((.#2*:(#o#/0#`A#30+/2.## 0=#/%*-+-+)#!(=0%(#!(703-+)#7034(/(+/#-+#/2(## 10%M#/2("#80#-+#/2(#7034*+"&##

# # # # #

,&# # # # # # # # #

,*%%-(%.#/0#*77(..#-+#>=%-7*#-+#12*/#-.#*## # %*4-8C"#72*+)-+)#*+8#2-)2C"#/(72+-7*C# -+86./%"#*%(#/00#2-)2#/0#3((/#06/.-8(#0=#/2(## .6440%/(8#/(72+-7*C#(+:-%0+3(+/.#/2*/## # 4%0867/-0+#7034*+-(.#4%0:-8(&#

# # # # # # #

;&# # # # # # # # # # # # #

K2-C(#7034*+"YC(8#/%*-+-+)#-.#.6440%/(8#!"## J06/2#>=%-7*+#)0:(%+3(+/#-+7(+/-:(.# .672#*.#JF'>#@*+8#/2-.#-.#*#%*%(#7*.(#0+## # /2(#;0+/-+(+/D5#/2(#.6440%/#4(%-08#-.#/00#.20%/## /0#3((/#/2(#%(k6-%(3(+/.#0=#-+#206.(#/%*-+-+)# *+8#/2("#*%(#/2(%(=0%(#=0%7(8#/0#*!.0%!#/2(.(## 70./.#-+#/2(-%#04(%*/-0+.&

A&# K2-C(#=0%3*C#(867*/-0+#*+8#/%*-+-+)#-+./-/6/-0+.#*%(#+0/# *!C(#/0#3((/#/2(#%*4-8C"#72*+)-+)#8(3*+8.#*+8#*77(..# %(k6-%(3(+/.#=0%#/2(#4%0=(..-0+*C#.M-CC.#%(k6-%(8#0=#8-)-/*C# 4%0867/-0+#*+8#8-..(3-+*/-0+5#/2("#*%(#=6%/2(%#+0/# 3((/-+)#/2(#+((8#=0%#/%*-+-+)#=0%#-+/(%3(8-*%"#*.4(7/.#0=# /2(#:*C6(#72*-+5#12-72#*%(#.0%(C"#C*7M-+)#*.#.M-CC.#-+#/2(# >=%-7*+#$;?N.& !"#$%&$'()%($*+#.)#+/$3$1,IQ+5'3,6)#$+-,%+M+N%,&,#$+#.$+ /2!l*+)%$+#)U("0+#.$+g4%'$"+,-+#%)("("0 K(#.((#*#:(%"#2-)2#4%040%/-0+#Y#lBj#/20.(#120#.(C(7/(8# s'*C(+/#>))%(*/0%.#W#O%030/(%.d5##c?+86./%"#T#>8:07*7"# E%064.d#*+8#c<(./-:*C.#T#FP40.ss#*C.0#.(C(7/-+)#cO%0=(..-0+*C#

B:B+b!>!PA+L[+NRL[ZAA!L\5b+PR5!\!\<+!\+PaZ+5[R!25\+/2!lA

'%*-+-+)d#*.#*#.2*%(8#%0C([#-+8-7*/-+)#/2*/#/20.(#120#*8:07*/(# =0%#*+8#4%030/(#/2(#-+86./%"#*%(#=-+8-+)#/2(#+((8#/0#=-CC# 8(:(C043(+/#)*4.#/2%06)2#/%*-+-+)&##\6%#-+/(%:-(1.#.6440%/(8# /2-.#-+8-7*/-+)_ `&# ?+/(%:-(1.#1-/2#-+86./%"#!08-(.#-+#a(+"*#*+8#J06/2# >=%-7*#-+8-7*/(8#/2*/#/20.(#*..07-*/(8#1-/2#c?+86./%"#T# >8:07*7"#E%064.#0%#,08-(.d##=076.#0+#.6440%/-+)#.M-CC# 8(:(C043(+/#=0%#J9F.#*+8#(+/%(4%(+(6%.2-45#-+7C68-+)# .M-CC.#.672#*.#%-.M#3-/-)*/-0+#*+8#704"%-)2/#*+8## ?O#3*+*)(3(+/&# A&# '20.(#*..07-*/(8#1-/2#c<(./-:*C#*+8#FP40N.d#*%(#(+*7/-+)# 4%0=(..-0+*C#/%*-+-+)#/2%06)2#46!C-7#4%0)%*3.#.672#*.# 9*./(%7C*..(.#*+8#<(./-:*C#K0%M.204.&#\=/(+#*7/-:(C"# 10%M-+)#/0#=-CC#.M-CC.#)*4.#-8(+/-=-(8#-+#/2(#-+86./%"#/2%06)2# 3*%M(/#)*4.&# V&# >#40.-/-:(#*+8#(P4(7/(8#2-)2#+63!(%#0=#/20.(#120#C-./(8# cO%0=(..-0+*C#'%*-+-+)d#*C.0#-8(+/-=-(8#*.#c?+76!*/0%.#=0%# /2(#$-)-/*C#;%(*/-:(#?+86./%-(.s#Y#Vnj#Y#*#%0C(#.4(7-=-7*CC"# )(*%(8#/0#-+86./%"#*+8#4%0=(..-0+*C#/%*-+-+)5#!6/#0+(#

8f

/2*/#-.#7C(*%C"#+0/#3((/-+)#/2-.#(+06)25#*C0+)#1-/2#=0%3*C# (867*/-0+#-+./-/6/-0+.&

=:=:;+

P.$+T4%'$"+,-+("+a,4*$+P%)("("0

'2(#C-3-/(8#*:*-C*!-C-/"#0=#=0%3*C#4%0=(..-0+*C#(867*/-0+#*+8# /%*-+-+)#=0%#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#*+8#4%0=(..-0+*C.#-+#/2(#>=%-7*+# $;?N.#-.#6+8(%./008#/0#!(#8%-:(+#!"#/2(#%(C*/-:(C"#+(1#+*/6%(# 0=#/2(#-+86./%"5#1-/2#/2(#0C8(./#=0%3*C#(867*/-0+*C#-+./-/6/-0+# 0I(%-+)#(:(+#!*.-7#4%0867/-0+#/%*-+-+)#0+C"#(./*!C-.2(8#`B# "(*%.#*)0& >.#*#%(.6C/#/2(#!6%8(+#0=#4%0=(..-0+*C#/%*-+-+)#-.#76%%(+/C"# !(-+)#.206C8(%(8#-+Y206.(##!"#4%0867/-0+#./68-0.#*+8#!"# *8:07*7"#)%064.&##'2-.#2*.#*#+()*/-:(#-34*7/#0+#/2(-%#*!-C-/"#/0# 4(%=0%3#/2(-%#(P-./-+)#%0C(.#(I(7/-:(C"5#*+8#30%(#.0#-+#/2(#=*7(#

B:S+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+2a5bbZ\<ZA+!\+AZ2PLR+ANZ2![!2!Pe

0=#*C%(*8"#./%(/72(8#7*4*7-/-(.#-+#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+#@*.#.201+#-+# .(7/-0+#V&AD&##'2-.#6+=0%/6+*/(C"#=6%/2(%#(P*7(%!*/(.#/2(#C*7M#0=# 7%67-*C#.M-CC.#C*7M-+)#*+8#%(k6-%(8#-+#./*)(.#`5#V#T#X#0=#/2(# :*C6(#72*-+&# J-3-C*%C"#/20.(#-+:0C:(8#-+#-+86./%"#*8:07*7"5#=*7(#/2(#-34*7/# 0=#C-3-/(8#=0%3*C-.(8#/%*-+-+)5#*.#/2(-%#*//(+/-0+#-.#8-%(7/(8# /01*%8.#.M-CCY!6-C8-+)#%*/2(%#/2*+#/2(#30%(#4%(..-+)#C0+)Y /(%3#40C-7"#*+8#%()6C*/-0+#8(:(C043(+/[#12-72#-.#7%-/-7*CC"# -340%/*+/#*+8#%(k6-%(.#-33(8-*/(#*//(+/-0+#/0#.6440%/#/2(# 7034(/-/-:(#%(k6-%(3(+/.#0=#/2(#$;?N.&

=:=:=+

[(11("0+a,1$*+)"'+",#+R,1$*+("+#.$+K)14$+2.)("

>4*%/#=%03#/2(#*C%(*8"#-8(+/-=-(8#70+7(%+#*%06+8#4%0=(..-0+*C# /%*-+-+)5#06%#3*44-+)#2*.#=6%/2(%#.201+#/2*/#/20.(#76%%(+/C"# 10%M-+)#*.#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#2*:(#+0/#%(7(-:(8#=0%3*C#/%*-+-+)# =0%#/2(-%#%0C(.5#*+8#-+./(*8#C(*%+#C*%)(C"#/2%06)2#0+#/2(#S0!# (P4(%-(+7(#12-C(#*//(34/-+)#/0#=-CC#20C(.#-+#*+#6+=0%3(8# :*C6(#72*-+& 90./#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#-+#/2(#3*44-+)#-+8-7*/(8#/2*/#/2("#8-8# +0/#*7/-:(C"#7200.(#/0#10%M#*.#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#*+8#*%(#%*/2(%# *7/-+)#/0#6%)(+/C"#=-CC#)*4.&#'2(#803-+*+7(#0=#c$-)-/*C#;0+/(+/# O%0867/-0+d#*.#*#%0C(#-.#=6%/2(%#(:-8(+7(#0=#/2-.5#-+8-7*/-+)#/2*/# 30./#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#./*%/(8#*.#7%(*/0%.#*+8#2*:(#.2-=/(8#/2(-%# %0C(#/0#3((/#+((8.&## >+#(P*34C(#0=#/2-.#7*+#!(#.((+#-+#/2(#.3*CC#7%(*/-:(# 4%0867/-0+#./68-0.#/2*/#*88-/-0+*CC"#/%"#/0#%6+#:-/*C##-+86./%"# .6440%/-+)#(:(+/.#.672#*.#R*)0.#;03-7;0+#*+8#^(+8*;0+# -+#b-)(%-*#*+8#;03QO0.(8#-+#G-3!*!1(&##\%#<*MN6)(.-# <(./-:*C#12-72#1*.#=06+8(8#!"#K-/.#L+-:(%.-/"#*+8# '.2-30C0)0+)#?++0:*/-0+#O%(7-+7/#*+#>7*8(3-7#?+./-/6/-0+# *+8#?+76!*/0%#%(.4(7/-:(C"5#0%#/2(#;*4(#'01+#?+/(%+*/-0+*C# >+-3*/-0+#<(./-:*C#=06+8(8#!"#-+86./%"#!08"#>+-3*/-0+J># !(=0%(#!(-+)#i.0C8N#/0#;03-7;0+#>=%-7*&# ?+#(*72#7*.(#*#8(8-7*/(8#4*%/#0=#/2(#0%)*+-.*/-0+s.#*++6*C# %(.06%7(.#*+8#7*4*7-/"#06/.-8(#0=#/2(#0%)*+-.*/-0+s.#70%(#%0C(# 86(#/0#/2(#*!.(+7(#0=#.672#(:(+/.&# <0%#/2(#>=%-7*+#$;?N.#*#C*7M#0=#-+86./%"#(:(+/.#3(*+.#*#C*7M#0=# :-.-!-C-/"5#(P40.6%(5#*+8#8(:(C043(+/&##\+(#-+/(%:-(1((#+0/(8#

B7

/2(#6%)(+/#+((8#=0%#-+86./%"#(:(+/.#/0#.6440%/#/2(#)%01/2#0=# /2(#-+86./%"5#./*/-+)_

u6,-5-%=8+%9<;%F'>,%><99->;*<9%(-;=--9% ><F*>%(<<S%F8S-5+M%D*)FF8S-5+M%89*F8;<5+% <5%78F-%.-C-)<?-5+#%A9.%9<%<??<5;'9*;2% ;<%9-;=<5S%89.%8>;'8))2%7-;%;<%F--;%-8>,% <;,-5M%;,-5-%=8+%8%C-52%,'7-%78?%###%+<%=-% >5-8;-.%89%-C-9;%89.%-98()*97%-9C*5<9F-9;#%% Y<'97%>5-8;*C-+%>89%><F-%85<'9.%89.%;,-2% >89%8>;'8))2%9-;=<5S%89.%7-;%;<%F--;%<9-% 89<;,-5%89.%+--%=,8;%;,-%+;89.85.%*+#%A9.% =-VC-%+--9%8%)<;%<D%75<=;,Z%=-VC-%+--9%8%)<;% <D%><))8(<58;*<9+%89.%=-VC-%+--9%><F?89*-+% +;85;-.%;,5<'7,%;,*+%=<5S#u

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

=:?+ !"#$%&$'()%O+2.)11$"0$*+!"++ + + A$6#,%+AI$6(-(6(#O

,"#*+*C".-+)#:*C6(#72*-+.#/2%06)2#*#.(7/0%#C(+.5#-+.-)2/.# 7*+#!(#)*-+(8#0+#72*CC(+)(.#*+8#0440%/6+-/-(.#-+#$-)-/*C# >+-3*/-0+5#$-)-/*C#E*3(.5#?33(%.-:(#9(8-*5#*+8#>7%0..# J(7/0%.&#O*%/-7-4*+/.#-+#/2(#./68"#.(C(7/(8#0+(#0=#/2(#=06%#*.# /2(-%#4%-3*%"#.(7/0%#(+)*)(3(+/#*+8#/2(#=0CC01-+)#-+8-7*/(# M("#=-+8-+).#0+#%0C(.#*+8#.(7/0%._

B:S+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+2a5bbZ\<ZA+!\+AZ2PLR+ANZ2![!2!Pe

A$6#,%+AI$6()1(*)#(,"+(*+4"'$%'$3$1,I$'+-,%+ N%$@/$3$1,I&$"#+A#)0$* >#2-)2#-8(+/-=-7*/-0+#0=#7%0..Y.(7/0%#10%M#=0%#/20.(#-+#4%(Y 8(:(C043(+/#./*)(#%0C(.#2-)2C-)2/.#/2(#*!.(+7(#0=#%(70)+-/-0+# =0%#/2(#8-./-+7/#.(7/0%#%(k6-%(3(+/.#*+8#/2(#7%-/-7*C#C*7M#0=# .(7/0%#.4(7-*C-.*/-0+#-+#>=%-7*+#$;?N.& `&# ;2*%/#n#/0#;2*%/#q#.201#/2*/#/2(#4%-3*%"#4C*"(%.#-+# /2(#4%(Y8(:(C043(+/#./*)(#0=#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+5#.672#*.# -+76!*/0%.5#/*C(+/#*))%()*/0%.5#*+8#=6+8-+)#(+/-/-(.#*%(# C(..#C-M(C"#/0#.4(7-*C-.(#-+#*+"#4*%/-76C*%#.(7/0%&# A&# ;034*%*/-:(#;2*%/#l#-+8-7*/(.#/2*/#/2(#$-)-/*C#E*3-+)# .(7/0%#-.#%(C*/-:(C"#!(//(%#*/#4(%=0%3-+)#-+#/2(#4%(Y 8(:(C043(+/#./*)(5#!6/#/2*/#=6+8-+)#8(:(C043(+/#*+8# -+76!*/-0+#*%(#C*%)(C"#+0/#.4(7-*C-.(8#*7/-:-/-(.&# V&# $-)-/*C#>+-3*/-0+#2*.#/2(#C(*./#.6440%/#-+#4%(Y 8(:(C043(+/#%0C(.#.672#*.#=6+8-+)5#/*C(+/#*))%()*/-0+5# *+8#46!C-.2-+)5#*.#.201+#-+#;2*%/#o#/0#;2*%/#Z#*+8#;2*%/# l5#/2(.(#*%(#C01(%#/2*+#0/2(%#.(7/0%.&#

BY

G87.8)-9-%@-..2%I4'5(89%P*)F%G85;M%TAJ%[%\*-589%@-*.%IE*;+%4*7*;8)%A5;+M%TAJ G<C*97%;,-%H<F?8++%P<5'F%I/$//J

B:S+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+2a5bbZ\<ZA+!\+AZ2PLR+ANZ2![!2!Pe

B8

B:S+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+2a5bbZ\<ZA+!\+AZ2PLR+ANZ2![!2!Pe

T%,)'$%+!"'4*#%O+A4II,%#+(*+",#+A$6#,%+AI$6(-(6+

5"(&)#(,"+[)11*+T$.("'+("+/(0(#)1+>)%U$#+Z"0)0$&$"#

>7/-0+.#*..07-*/(8#1-/2#!%0*8(%#-+86./%"#8(:(C043(+/5#.672# *.#*8:07*7"5#40C-7"#8(:(C043(+/#*+8#-+:(./3(+/5#=*:06%# 7%0..Y.(7/0%#(+)*)(3(+/#0:(%#.4(7-*C-.(8#+((8.&

?/#-.#7C(*%#/2*/#/2(#$-)-/*C#>+-3*/-0+#.(7/0%#-.#=*CC-+)#!(2-+8# $-)-/*C#E*3-+)#*+8#?33(%.-:(#9(8-*#=0%#8-)-/*C# /0Y3*%M(/#(+)*)(3(+/_#

`&# ;2*%/#l#*+8#;2*%/#`B#.201#/20.(#-8(+/-="-+)#*.#10%M-+)# -+#*8:07*7"5#-+86./%"#8(:(C043(+/#*+8#=6+8-+)#%0C(.# -8(+/-="#30%(#1-/2#10%M-+)#*7%0..#.(7/0%.&##

'2(#$-)-/*C#>+-3*/-0+#.(7/0%#-.#76%%(+/C"#C*7M-+)#(+)*)(3(+/# 1-/2#*#6+-k6(#8-)-/*C#:*C6(#72*-+#/01*%8.#8-)-/*C#8-./%-!6/-0+5# *))%()*/-0+#*+8#70+.634/-0+&##

A&# >+-3*/-0+#*+8#E*3-+)#%(40%/#7034*%*/-:(C"#30%(#%0C(.# -+#-+:(./3(+/#.6440%/5#12-C(#?33(%.-:(#9(8-*#-.#/2(## C(*./#.6440%/(8&#

'2(%(#-.#*#40/(+/-*C#7%-.-.#-+#/2(#30+(/-h*/-0+#0=#8-)-/*C# *+-3*/-0+#86(#/0#/2(#C*7M#0=#4%(Y8(:(C043(+/#./*)(# (+)*)(3(+/#@?O#*+8#704"%-)2/#3*+*)(3(+/D5#12-72#2*.#*# M+07MY0+#-34*7/#=6%/2(%#64#-+#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+&#'2-.#-.#8(.4-/(# -/#!(-+)#%()*%8(8#*.#0+(#0=#>=%-7*s.#C(*8-+)#.(7/0%.#-+#8-)-/*C# 70+/(+/#7%(*/-0+&l#

# # # # # #

BB

>&# # # # # # # # # # #

R-M(C"#86(#/0#?33(%-.:(#!(-+)#0+(#0=#/2(## # +(1(./#0=#/2(#.(7/0%.#-+#/2(#$;?N.&#?+#/2(## # .*3(#:(-+#-/#-.#6+.6%4%-.-+)#/2*/#*.#/2(#0C8(./## .(7/0%#*+-3*/-0+#2*.#30%(#-+86./%"# 8(:(C043(+/#.6440%/#@8(.4-/(#!(-+)#C01#0+## *7/6*C#=6+8-+)#*+8#-+:(./3(+/#8(:(C043(+/D&#

B:S+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+2a5bbZ\<ZA+!\+AZ2PLR+ANZ2![!2!Pe

BS

B:S+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+2a5bbZ\<ZA+!\+AZ2PLR+ANZ2![!2!Pe

BX

B:S+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+2a5bbZ\<ZA+!\+AZ2PLR+ANZ2![!2!Pe

B_

B:S+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+2a5bbZ\<ZA+!\+AZ2PLR+ANZ2![!2!Pe

B`

B:S+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+2a5bbZ\<ZA+!\+AZ2PLR+ANZ2![!2!Pe

Bd

B:S+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+2a5bbZ\<ZA+!\+AZ2PLR+ANZ2![!2!Pe

<)&("0+)"'+!&&$%*(3$+>$'()+)%$+<$)%("0+-,%+/(0(#)1+ Z"0)0$&$"#+("+5-%(6)+ '2(#=*7/#/2*/#/2(%(#*%(#%(C*/-:(C"#30%(#-+8-:-86*C.#10%M-+)# -+#46!C-7*/-0+#*+8#*))%()*/-0+#%0C(.#-+#/2(#E*3-+)#*+8# ?33(%.-:(#9(8-*#.(7/0%.#.6))(./.#/2*/#/2(%(#-.#*#%(70)+-/-0+# /2*/#/2(#4-4(C-+(#0=#4%0867/-0+5#8-./%-!6/-0+5#*+8#70+.634/-0+# =0%#/2(.(#.(7/0%.#-.#8-./-+7/C"#8-)-/*C&#'2-.#-+8-7*/(.#/2*/_ `&# E%01/2#0440%/6+-/-(.#-+#/2(#$-)-/*C#E*3(.#*+8#?33(%.-:(# 9(8-*#8-)-/*C#70+.63(%#3*%M(/#(P-./.&# # # # # # # #

>&# # # # # # # # # # # # #

'2(#/(72+0C0)-7*C#*+8#8-)-/*C#=076.#0=#/2(## # :*C6(#72*-+#-+#)*3-+)#*+8#-33(%.-:(#3(8-*## Y#./*%/-+)#=%03#4%0867/-0+#*+8#30:-+)#/0## # 4%030/-0+5#*))%()*/-0+5#8-./%-!6/-0+#-.# :(%"#C-M(C"#*C-)+(8#/0#-/.#70+.63(%## # /(72+0C0)-(.5#.672#*.#30!-C(5#O;5#0%#70+.0C(## @)*3(#T#-33(%.-:(D&

# #

,&# # #

'2(#8-)-/*C#)*3(.#.(7/0%#-.#!(./#4C*7(8#/0### 3*M(#6.(#0=#/2(#.4(7-*C-.(8#8-)-/*C#

QFF-5+*C-%T*F%@8>*97 P8SV'7-+*%P-+;*C8)%I/$//J

Bf

# # # # #

# # # # # # # # # #

%(C*/-0+.2-4.&#?/N.#8-:(%.-/"#-+#70+.63(%## # /(72+0C0)"#*77(..#40-+/.#Y#3*M-+)#-/#/2(# C(*./#30+040C-.(85##40/(+/-*CC"#30./#C67%*/-:(## *+8#.20%/(./#S06%+("#/0#8-)-/*C#70+.63(%.### @;2*%/#`l#*+8#;2*%/#ABD&

A&# '2(%(#*%(#7C(*%#0440%/6+-/-(.#*:*-C*!C(#=0%#)%01/2#-+#8-)-/*C# *))%()*/-0+#*+8#8-./%-!6/-0+#=0%#*CC#.(7/0%.&## V&# '2(#+63!(%#0=#.4(7-*C-./#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#4%0:-8-+)# 2*%81*%(#*+8#.0=/1*%(#=0%#-33(%.-:(#3(8-*#-.#2-)2(./&#?/# -.#C-M(C"#/2*/#/2-.#-.#-+#0%8(%#/0#3((/#/2(#6+-k6(#70+.63(%# 2*%81*%(#%(k6-%(3(+/.#=0%#-33(%.-:(#3(8-*5#12-72#*%(# +0/#%(*8-C"#*:*-C*!C(#/2%06)2#)(+(%*C#70346/(%#2*%81*%(# .644C-(%.#-+#>=%-7*&#'2-.#4%(.(+/.#*+#0440%/6+-/"#=0%# )%01/2&#@;2*%/#An#*+8#;2*%/#AoD&# X&# OC*/=0%3#:*C-8*/-0+#*+8#40%/-+)#=0%#E*3-+)#*+8# ?33(%.-:(#3(8-*5#*.#1-/2#/(72#7034*+-(.#/2(#+63!(%.# *%(#)(+(%*CC"#C01#!6/#-+8-7*/(#*+#-340%/*+/#)%01/2#40-+/# /0#*..-./#-+#8-)-/*C#8(:(C043(+/&#

B:S+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+2a5bbZ\<ZA+!\+AZ2PLR+ANZ2![!2!Pe

S7

B:S+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+2a5bbZ\<ZA+!\+AZ2PLR+ANZ2![!2!Pe

SY

B:S+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+2a5bbZ\<ZA+!\+AZ2PLR+ANZ2![!2!Pe

S8

B:S+!\PZR>Z/!5Re+2a5bbZ\<ZA+!\+AZ2PLR+ANZ2![!2!Pe

SB

B:X+PaZ+K5bcZ+2a5!\+PaRLc<a+5+RZ<!L\5b+NZRANZ2P!KZ

=:?:9+ +

!&I)6#+,-+b(&(#$'+A$6#,%+AI$6(-(6(#O+("+#.$+ ?:C+Z6,",&O

?/#-.#7C(*%#=%03#/2(#=-+8-+).#*!0:(#/2*/#-+#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+#4%(Y 8(:(C043(+/#%0C(.#*+8#%0C(.#/2*/#(+)*)(#-+86./%"#.6440%/#*%(# C*%)(C"#+0/#.(7/0%#.4(7-=-7&# '2-.#-.#4%0!C(3*/-7#*/#/2(#4%(Y8(:(C043(+/#./*)(#*.#(*72# .(7/0%#*+8#/2(#:*%-*/-0+.#1-/2-+#.(7/0%.#%*+)(#*7%0..#*# !%0*8#.4(7/%63#0=#70+.63(%#*77(..#3(72*+-.3[#=%03# ]-8(0#0+#$(3*+8#/0#=%((#/0#4C*"#)*3(.#/0#>Y^*/(8#70+.0C(# (+)*)(3(+/.&##'2(%(=0%(#4C*++-+)#=0%#30+(/-h*/-0+#%(k6-%(.# ./%*/()"#/2*/#./*%/.#*/#/2(#4%(Y8(:(C043(+/#./*)(&#E008#0%# !*8#4C*++-+)#/2*/#/2-.#./*)(#2*.#M+07MY0+#(I(7/.#-+/0#./*)(.# A5V#*+8#X#0=#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+& '2(#2-)2#+63!(%#0=#/20.(#.(%:-+)#*.#i7%0..Y.(7/0%N# -+/(%3(8-*%-(.5#/2(#.20%/*)(#0=#.4(7-*C-.(8#.M-CC#*/#7%67-*C# ./*)(.5#-+#*88-/-0+#/0#/2(#1(-)2/#0=#/2-.#10%M#!(-+)#2(C8#!"# /20.(#-+#.3*CC#4%0867/-0+#206.(.#2-)2C-)2/.#/2(#7%-.-.#0=#/2(# >=%-7*+#$;?N.#!(-+)#*!C(#76%%(+/C"#/0#3((/#.(7/0%# -+/(%3(8-*%"#+((8.&#

/2(#8(:(C043(+/#0=#/2(#$;?s.#-.#-+#=*7/#C-3-/(8#-+#/2(#%()-0+&#?+# b0%/2#>=%-7*5#1(#%(70)+-h(#/2*/#/2(%(#-.#30%(#8(:(C043(+/# /2*+#12*/#-.#%(=C(7/(8#-+#06%#3*44-+)5#!6/#06%#+(/10%M# 308(C#*-3(8#/0#=076.#.4(7-=-7*CC"#0+#J6!YJ*2*%*+#>=%-7*&#K(# /2(%(=0%(#%(7033(+8#/2*/#*#.(4*%*/(#./68"#!(#70+867/(8#0+# b0%/2#>=%-7*#1-/2#*#:-(1#/0#-/.#%(C*/-0+.2-4#/0#/2(#9Fb>#*+8# F6%04(*+#+(/10%M.& E-:(+#/2(#*!0:(5#-/#-.#-340%/*+/#/0#*88%(..#.(7/0%# %(4%(.(+/*/-0+#*7%0..#/2-.#3*44-+)#0+#*#4(%Y%()-0+#!*.-.5# 12-C(#*C.0#/*M-+)#-+/0#*7706+/#/2(#8(=-7-/.#-+#9-88C(#*+8#b0%/2# >=%-7*#/2*/#1(#2*:(#-+8-7*/(8&#g01(:(%#.(7/0%#%(4%(.(+/*/-0+# *7%0..#/2%((#=076.#%()-0+.#-.#%(*.0+*!C"#1(CC#!*C*+7(8&# `&# J06/2(%+#>=%-7*+#3*44-+)#%(=C(7/.#30./#%(40%/(8#%0C(.#-+# $-)-/*C#E*3-+)#*/#VA&nj&## A&# F*./#>=%-7*#3*44-+)#%(=C(7/.#30%(#%0C(.#-+#;%0..YJ(7/0%# F+)*)(3(+/.#*/#VZj#*+8#-+8-7*/(.#/2*/#=0%#-+/(%3(8-*%"# %0C(.#/2(%(#-.#*#C-3-/(8#.4(7-*C-.*/-0+#=0%#.(7/0%.&## V&# K(./#>=%-7*+#3*44-+)#%(=C(7/.#30%(#%0C(.#-+#$-)-/*C# E*3(.#*/#V`j#*+8#C(*./#%(4%(.(+/*/-0+#-+#$-)-/*C# >+-3*/-0+#*/#`Zj&##

K2*/#-.#4*%/-76C*%C"#10%%"-+)#-.#$-)-/*C#>+-3*/-0+N.#*!-C-/"#/0# 3((/#/2(#8-)-/*C#:*C6(#72*-+#%(k6-%(3(+/.5#12-72#2-)2C-)2/.# /2(#8*+)(%#0=#+0/#(I(7/-:(C"#3((/-+)#8-)-/*C#4-4(C-+(.#*+8# 8(:(C043(+/#=0%#/2(#X&B#(70+03"#/0#=6/6%(#4%00=#*CC#.(7/0%.&#

X&# b0%/2#>=%-7*#*+8#9-88C(#>=%-7*#*%(#6+8(%Y%(4%(.(+/(8#=0%# /2(#%(*.0+.#4%(.(+/(8#*!0:(5#!6/#/2(#(342*.-.#0+#$-)-/*C# E*3(.#-+#!0/2#-.#%(=C(7/-:(#0=#.-)+-=-7*+/#36C/-Y+*/-0+*C.# 10%M-+)#*7%0..#%()-0+.&##

=:D+ P.$+K)14$+2.)("+P.%,40.+5++ + + R$0(,")1+N$%*I$6#(3$

n&# 9-88C(#>=%-7*+#+(/10%M#3*44-+)#!%06)2/#=0%1*%8# +0#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#10%M-+)#-+#?33(%.-:(#9(8-*5#(-/2(%# 6+-k6(C"#-+#9-88C(#>=%-7*#0%#*7%0..#%()-0+.&#J201-+)#*# 7C(*%#C*7M#0=#(+)*)(3(+/#0%#.6440%/#=0%#/2-.#.(7/0%#-+#/2(# %()-0+5#=6%/2(%#-+8-7*/-+)#*+#6+8(%8(:(C04(8#$;?#=0%## /2(#%()-0+&# <6%/2(%#1(#.((#3*+"#10%M-+)#-+#>=%-7*+#%()-0+.#*88-/-0+*CC"# %(40%/-+)#*.#04(%*/-+)#06/.-8(#0=#>=%-7*#/00&#

E-:(+#/2(#-340%/*+7(#0=#36C/-#%()-0+*C#4(%.4(7/-:(.#=0%# >=%-7*5#06%#3*44-+)#*-3(8#/0#7*4/6%(#*.#1-8(#*#%*+)(#*.# 40..-!C(#*7%0..#J06/2(%+5#F*./#*+8#K(./#>=%-7*&#>.#*#%(.6C/5# /2(#./%0+)(./#*+8#30./#7034*%*!C(#8*/*#-.#*:*-C*!C(#=0%#/2(.(# /2%((#%()-0+.#!*.(8#0+#06%#6.(#0=#+(/10%M#3*44-+)#*+8# .+01!*CC#.*34C-+)#3(/208.&#K2-C(#1(#8-8#2*:(#%(.40+8(+/.# =%03#9-88C(#*+8#b0%/2#>=%-7*5#06%#3*44-+)#308(C#8-8#+0/# "-(C8#*.#3*+"#%(.40+.(.#=%03#/2(.(#%()-0+.&#K(#6+8(%./*+8# =%03#/2(#%(.40+.(.#1(#8-8#%(7(-:(#=%03#9-88C(#>=%-7*#/2*/#

SS

\=#/20.(#%(40%/-+)#*.#04(%*/-+)#06/.-8(#0=#>=%-7*#@``j#0=#/2(# /0/*C#4*%/-7-4*+/.D#/2(%(#-.#*#3*%M(8#4%(:*C(+7(#=0%#/20.(# %(40%/-+)#*.#7%0..Y.(7/0%#*/#Vqj#*+8#E*3-+)#*/#VVj&##'2-.# )%064#%(4%(.(+/.#/20.(#04(%*/-+)#>=%-7*#*+8#*!%0*8# *+8#-+7C68(._# `&# <0%#>+-3*/-0+#*.#/2(#C01(./#/2-.#-.#S6./#/105#'%-))(%<-.2# 04(%*/-+)#-+#J06/2#>=%-7*#*+8#E*C1*"5#*+8#*+# -+8(4(+8(+/#8-./%-!6/0%#04(%*/-+)#!(/1((+#<%*+7(#*+8#

B:X+PaZ+K5bcZ+2a5!\+PaRLc<a+5+RZ<!L\5b+NZRANZ2P!KZ

90%0770&##<6%/2(%#2-)2C-)2/-+)#70+7(%+.#=0%#/2(#>=%-7*+# >+-3*/-0+#-+86./%-(.#C-3-/(8#%(*72&# A&# ?+#?33(%.-:(#9(8-*#1(#.((#0+C"#*+#-+8-:-86*C#04(%*/-+)# !(/1((+#,(+-+#*+8#<%*+7(5#*+8#%(3*-+-+)#*%(# 0%)*+-.*/-0+.#04(%*/-+)#!(/1((+#>=%-7*#*+8#/2(#LJ>[# 1-/2#0+(#F8(+#R*!.#*88-/-0+*CC"#04(%*/-+)#!(/1((+#J06/2# >=%-7*5#/2(#LJ>#*+8#/2(#b(/2(%C*+8.&###

=:D:9+ +

P.$+R$0(,")1+R,1$*+!&I)6#$'+TO+A#%,"0+N)"++ + 5-%(6)"+N1)O$%*

V&# <0%#E*3-+)#/2(%(#-.#*#4%(:*C(+7(#0=#04(%*/-0+*C# 4*%/+(%.2-4.#-+#;*+*8*#*+8#/2(#LJ>#1-/2#J06/2#>=%-7*+# 0%)*+-.*/-0+.&#>+8#*88-/-0+*C#-+/(%*7/-0+#!(/1((+#b-)(%-*5# ;2-+*#*+8#/2(#9-88C(#F*./&##

^0C(#%(4%(.(+/*/-0+#*+*C".-.#*7%0..#%()-0+.#*+8#-+#:-(1#0=#/2(# :*C6(#72*-+#-.#80+(#-+#/10#1*".&#<-%./C"#/2%06)2#*#7034*%-.0+# 0=#(P*7/#706+/.#=0%#%0C(.#%(40%/(8#4(%#%()-0+&#<0%#/2-.#'*!C(# A#!(C01#.201.#*7/6*C#+63!(%.#0=#/20.(#%(40%/-+)#*7%0..# %()-0+.5#/2(#1(-)2/#0=#-+/(%3(8-*%-(.#%(40%/-+)#=%03#J06/2(%+# >=%-7*5#=0CC01(8#!"#F*./#*+8#/2(+#K(./#>=%-7*#%(=C(7/.#06%# +(/10%M#308(C#*.#-+8-7*/(8#*!0:(&###

X&# ;%0..YJ(7/0%#2*.#/2(#30./#:*%-*/-0+#%(4%(.(+/-+)#=6+8(%.5# =(./-:*C.#*+8#46!C-.2(%#4*%/+(%.#/2*/#-+7C68(#04(%*/-+)# C07*/-0+.#-+#E(%3*+"5#<%*+7(5#;*+*8*5#LJ>5#La5#L>F## *+8#?+8-*&# #

'2(#.(70+8#*+*C"/-7*C#./%67/6%(#6.-+)#/2(#.*3(#8*/*#7*+#!(# .((+#-+#'*!C(#V#12-72#40.-/-0+.#/2(#4(%7(+/*)(#1(-)2/#0=#%0C(.# %(40%/(8#=0%#(*72#%()-0+&#E-:-+)#6.#*+#-340%/*+/#:-(1#0+#/2(# !*C*+7(#0=#%0C(.#*72-(:(8#1-/2-+#(*72#%()-0+#*+8#+0/#*.#*# 7034*%-.0+#*7%0..#%()-0+.&#

SX

n$*#+5-%(6)

\,%#.+5-%(6)

>(''1$+5-%(6)

Z)*#+5-%(6)

A,4#.$%"+5-%(6)

@<)-%Q.-9;*W>8;*<9%D5<F%&85;*>*?89;+%*9%;,-%G8??*97%(2%AD5*>89%@-7*<9%IAB%@-7*<9%4-W9*;*<9+J

511+2,4"#%($*

P5TbZ+78

\+C-+(#>))%()*/-0+#OC*/=0%3

qj

q

V

V

B

`

\+C-+(#$-./%-!6/-0+#OC*/=0%3

lj

q

o

X

A

B

O0%/-+)#;0+/(+/#,(/1((+#OC*/=0%3.

lj

o

q

A

B

`

;0+/(+/#>))%()*/0%

`Bj

o

V

o

V

A

\+C-+(#O%030/-0+#OC*/=0%3

`Vj

`A

X

X

`

`

J6440%/-+)#0%#$%-:-+)#J(7/0%#?+:(./3(+/

`Vj

`V

n

X

B

B

J6440%/-+)#0%#$%-:-+)#J(7/0%#<6+8-+)

`Xj

`A

n

n

`

B

;0+/(+/#$-./%-!6/0%

`nj

l

l

X

X

`

;0+/(+/#O6!C-.2(%

`oj

l

Z

q

n

X

'(72#;034*+"#J6440%/-+)#$-)-/*C#;%(*/-:(.

`qj

`n

Z

o

`

`

'*C(+/#>))%()*/0%

AVj

`o

Z

l

A

A

<(./-:*C#0%#FP40

Anj

`q

``

``

q

A

?+76!*/-0+#=0%#$-)-/*C#;0+/(+/#;%(*/-:(.

Anj

`q

`n

l

A

`

?+86./%"5#>8:07*7"#E%0645#0%#,08"

Anj

`l

`X

``

A

A

O%0=(..-0+*C#'%*-+-+)

XAj

Aq

AX

`l

A

X

$-)-/*C#;0+/(+/#O%0867(%

Xlj

Vn

An

AV

V

o

N$%6$"#)0$

9CCj

?Fo

;Eo

;9o

Fo

?o

>(''1$+5-%(6)

\,%#.+5-%(6)

n$*#+5-%(6)

Z)*#+5-%(6)

A,4#.$%"+5-%(6)

@<)-%Q.-9;*W>8;*<9%D5<F%&85;*>*?89;+%*9%;,-%G8??*97%(2%AD5*>89%@-7*<9%IAB%@-7*<9%4-W9*;*<9+J%=*;,%?-5>-9;87-+%(8+-.%<9% 8C-587-+%5-7*<9%(2%5-7*<9%X%9<;%><9;*9-9;%=*.-#%Q-#%;,-%,*7,-+;%><'9;%<D%5<)-+%*9%N<5;,%AD5*>8%*+%D<5%P-+;*C8)%89.%KR?<M%D<))<=-.% (2%?'()*+,-5%89.%.*+;5*(';*<9%I+--%5-8+<9+%(-)<=J%X%(';%;,-%D'))%><9;*9-9;%8C-587-%D<5%P-+;*C8)%<5%KR?<%*+%<9)2%/]^

511+2,4"#%($*

P5TbZ+7B

\+C-+(#>))%()*/-0+#OC*/=0%3

qj

lj

qj

Zj

Bj

`Vj

\+C-+(#$-./%-!6/-0+#OC*/=0%3

lj

lj

`Vj

`Bj

ABj

Bj

O0%/-+)#;0+/(+/#,(/1((+#OC*/=0%3.

lj

Zj

`nj

nj

Bj

`Vj

;0+/(+/#>))%()*/0%

`Bj

Zj

qj

`nj

VBj

Anj

\+C-+(#O%030/-0+#OC*/=0%3

`Vj

`nj

lj

`Bj

`Bj

`Vj

J6440%/-+)#0%#$%-:-+)#J(7/0%#?+:(./3(+/

`Vj

`oj

``j

`Bj

Bj

Bj

J6440%/-+)#0%#$%-:-+)#J(7/0%#<6+8-+)

`Xj

`nj

``j

`Vj

`Bj

Bj

;0+/(+/#$-./%-!6/0%

`nj

``j

ABj

`Bj

XBj

`Vj

;0+/(+/#O6!C-.2(%

`oj

``j

`qj

`Zj

nBj

nBj

'(72#;034*+"#J6440%/-+)#$-)-/*C#;%(*/-:(.

`qj

`lj

`qj

`nj

`Bj

`Vj

'*C(+/#>))%()*/0%

AVj

ABj

`qj

AVj

ABj

Anj

<(./-:*C#0%#FP40

Anj

A`j

AXj

AZj

qBj

Anj

?+76!*/-0+#=0%#$-)-/*C#;0+/(+/#;%(*/-:(.

Anj

A`j

VVj

AVj

ABj

`Vj

?+86./%"5#>8:07*7"#E%0645#0%#,08"

Anj

AXj

VBj

AZj

ABj

Anj

O%0=(..-0+*C#'%*-+-+)

XAj

VXj

nAj

Xlj

ABj

nBj

$-)-/*C#;0+/(+/#O%0867(%

Xlj

XXj

nXj

nlj

VBj

qnj

N$%6$"#)0$

9CCj

?Fo

;Eo

;9o

Fo

?o

B:X+PaZ+K5bcZ+2a5!\+PaRLc<a+5+RZ<!L\5b+NZRANZ2P!KZ

'2(#)(+(%*C#706+/#*7%0..#%()-0+.#@'*!C(#AD#*+8#/2(# 4(%7(+/*)(#:-(1#@'*!C(#VD#)-:(.#6.#/2(#=0CC01-+)#-340%/*+/# -+.-)2/._ 5-%(6)"+>41#(")#(,")1*+)%$+>$$#("0+\$$'*+("+ c"'$%'$3$1,I$'+R$0(,"*+("+/(*#%(g4#(,"Q+500%$0)#(,"+)"'+ N4g1(6)#(,"+("+<)&$* # '*!C(#A#*+8#'*!C(#V#.201.#*#3*%M(8#4%(:*C(+7(#0=#\+C-+(# $-./%-!6/-0+5#>))%()*/-0+#*+8#O6!C-.2(%#%0C(.#*7%0..#/2(# %()-0+.#(:(+#-+#/2(#6+8(%Y%(4%(.(+/(8#9-88C(#*+8#b0%/2# >=%-7*+#%()-0+.&#>+#-+/(%(./-+)#/%(+8#/2*/#-.#:-.-!C(#8(.4-/(#/2(# )(+(%*C#.7*%7-/"#0=#/20.(#%0C(.#-+#/2(#>=%-7*+#:*C6(Y72*-+.&# K2*/#1*.#=06+8#0+#*#7C0.(%#C00M#*/#/2(#%(.40+8(+/.#-.#/2(# =0CC01-+)_# `&# '20.(#04(%*/-+)#-+#b0%/2#>=%-7*#*+8#9-88C(#>=%-7*# *%(#-+#=*7/#!*.(8#06/.-8(#0=#/2(.(#%()-0+.#*+8#-+#=*7/# ./%0+)#36C/-+*/-0+*C.#04(%*/-+)#*7%0..#%()-0+.5#120#*%(## 803-+*+/C"#!*.(8#06/#0=#J06/2#>=%-7*& # # # # #

>&# # # # # # # # #

'20.(#04(%*/-+)#-+#b0%/2#>=%-7*#.(%:-+)## # 46!C-7*/-0+#*+8#8-./%-!6/-0+#-+7C68(# J(*90+./(%#@J06/2#>=%-7*D5#;*%%"`./#@J06/2## >=%-7*5#LJ>D5#*+8#E*%*J/0%(#@;(+/%*C## >=%-7*5#<%*+7(D&

# # # # #

,&# # # # # # # # #

'20.(#04(%*/-+)#-+#9-88C(#>=%-7*#*%(#*C.0## # C*%)(C"#%(4%(.(+/(8#!"#9'b#@J06/2#>=%-7*D5# O>EE#@O*+#>=%-7*+D5#J(*90+./(%#@J06/2## # >=%-7*D5#9*C-"0#@b-)(%-*D##*+8#E*%*J/0%(## # @;(+/%*C#>=%-7*5#<%*+7(D&

# # #

;&# # # # #

'20.(#C-./(8#*!0:(#*88-/-0+*CC"#04(%*/(## # *7%0..#J06/2(%+5#F*./#*+8#K(./#>=%-7*#/0### :*%"-+)#8()%((.&#

A&# '2(#=0CC01-+)#E*3-+)#J(7/0%#36C/-+*/-0+*C.#2*:(#/2(# C*%)(./#-+=C6(+7(#*7%0..#%()-0+. # #

>&# # #

9'b#@J06/2#>=%-7*D5#O>EE#@O*+#>=%-7*+D5## # J(*90+./(%#@J06/2#>=%-7*D5#9*C-"0#@b-)(%-*D

# # # # # #

,&# # # # # # # # # # #

'2(#7%0..#%()-0+*C#803-+*+7(#-+#)*3-+)## # 36C/-Y+*/-0+*C.#-.#=6%/2(%#.6440%/(8#!"# .(7/0%#*+*C".-.#/2*/#.201.#8-)-/*C#)*3-+)### 3*-+/*-+.#/2(#./%0+)(%#:*C6(#72*-+#=0%# 8-./%-!6/-0+#*+8#70+.634/-0+#./*)(.# -+#>=%-7*&#

b(&(#$'+2%,**@R$0(,")1+LI$%)#(,"*+-,%+!&&$%*(3$+>$'()+ )"'+5"(&)#(," `&# <0%#?33(%.-:(#9(8-*#+0#.(7/0%#%0C(.#1(%(#%(40%/(8# =0%#9-88C(#>=%-7*5#*+8#+0#7%0..Y%()-0+*C#04(%*/-0+#1*.# %(40%/(8#(-/2(%&# # # # # # # # #

>&# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #

\6%#-+/(%:-(1.#201(:(%#-+8-7*/(8#/2*/#12-C(## +0#36C/-Y+*/-0+*C.#76%%(+/C"#(P-./#=0%#/2(## # -33(%.-:(#.(7/0%#*+8#04(%*/-0+*C# *7/-:-/-(.#*%(#%()-0+#.4(7-=-7[#/2(%(#-.#*#)008## 8(*C#0=#7%0..Y%()-0+*C#70Y4%0867/-0+#*+8## # 7004(%*/-0+#-+#%(.(*%72#*+8#)(+(%*C#.(7/0% .6440%/#@.672#*.#/2(#10%M#=06+8#/2%06)2#/2(## >=%-7*#Q^#^(40%/`BD&#

A&# <0%#>+-3*/-0+#+0#.(7/0%#%0C(.#1(%(#%(40%/(8#=0%#b0%/2# >=%-7*#*+8#0+C"#`#=0%#9-88C(#>=%-7*#@*+#>%/-./#$-%(7/0%# %(40%/-+)#4%0867/-0+#*+8#46!C-7*/-0+#*.#%0C(.D&# # # # #

>&# # # # # # #

\6%#-+/(%:-(1.#=6%/2(%#-+8-7*/(8#/2*/#*7%0..## %()-0+#70CC*!0%*/-0+#-+#*+-3*/-0+#-.#C-3-/(8# */#!(./5#1-/2#3*+"#-+8-7*/-+)#*#8(.-%(#/0#=-+8## 1*".#/0#10%M#*7%0..#%()-0+.5#201(:(%&#

=:D:;+ +

A,4#.$%"+5-%(6)+(*+g$*#+I1)6$'+-,%+[(")"6("0+ )"'+!"3$*#&$"#

>.#7*+#!(#.((+#-+#'*!C(#A5#/20.(#04(%*/-+)#-+#J06/2(%+#>=%-7*# 2*:(#7034*%*/-:(C"#2-)2(%#+63!(%.#=0%#.(7/0%#=6+8-+)#*+8# -+:(./3(+/#7034*%(8#/0#F*./#*+8#K(./#>=%-7*+5#/2-.#-.#=6%/2(%# .6440%/(8#-+#/2(#3*44-+)#@4C(*.(#.((#J(7/-0+#XD&# ^()-0+.#:*%"#-+#^0C(#^(4%(.(+/*/-0+#*+8#J201#^(70)+-.*!C(# O*//(%+.#0=#L+8(%8(:(C043(+/&#'*!C(#V#.201.#-+/(%(./-+)# -+Y%()-0+#/%(+8.#0+#12-72#./*)(.#0=#/2(#:*C6(#72*-+#*%(#!(//(%# %(.06%7(8#1-/2-+#%(.4(7/-:(#%()-0+._# `&# 9-88C(#>=%-7*#2*.#*#4%03-+(+/#4%(:*C(+7(#0=#4%0867/-0+# *+8#/%*-+-+)#%0C(.#*+8#C-//C(#(C.(#-+#/2(#%(./#0=#/2(# :*C6(#72*-+&#J6440%/-+)#*#%(70)+-.*!C(#4*//(%+#=0%#*+# 6+8(:(C04(8#*+8#6+.6440%/(8#$;?#-+#/2-.#%()-0+&# A&# ?+76!*/-0+5#-+86./%"#*8:07*7"#*+8#*+"#4%(Y8(:(C043(+/#

Sd

B:X+PaZ+K5bcZ+2a5!\+PaRLc<a+5+RZ<!L\5b+NZRANZ2P!KZ

./*)(#@`D#%0C(.#*%(#.-)+-=-7*+/C"#%(867(8#-+#06%#b0%/2#>=%-7*# %(40%/-+)&#e/2-.#1-CC#+((8#/0#!(#:(%-=-(8#/2%06)2#=6%/2(%# ./68"#201(:(%&## V&# K(./#>=%-7*+#%()-0+#2*.#2-)2(%#0776%%(+7(.#0=#/%*-+-+)# *+8#4%0867/-0+#-+#-/.#%()-0+*C#!*C*+7(&# # # # # # # # #

>&# # # # # # # # # # # # # # #

?+#*#7C0.(%#-+/(%%0)*/-0+#0=#/2(#8*/*#/2(.(#*%(## %0C(.#%(40%/(8#-+#/*+8(3#1-/2# 4%0867/-0+5#.201-+)#/2*/#=%03#*#:*C6(#72*-+## 8(:(C043(+/#4(%.4(7/-:(#K(./#>=%-7*#%(=C(7/.## *+#/2(#4*//(%+#0=#*+#6+8(:(C04(8#:*C6(# 72*-+#*.#8(.7%-!(8#-+#J(7/-0+#V&V&A#12(%(### /2(#!6%8(+#0=#/%*-+-+)#*+8#-+86./%"#.6440%/#-.## 2(C8#!"#-+#/2(#4%0867/-0+#./*)(#@`D&##

# # # # #

,&# # # # # # # # #

<6%/2(%#*+8#!6-C8-+)#0+#40-+/.#-+8-7*/(8## # 4%(:-06.C"5#1(#*%(#*1*%(#/2*/# *))%()*/-0+5#8-./%-!6/-0+#*+8#46!C-7*/-0+#*%(## !(-+)#2(C8#!"#36C/-+*/-0+*C.#(+)*)-+)#-+#/2(## K(./#>=%-7*+#%()-0+&#

X&# ;034*%-+)#/2(#%()-0+*C#0776%%(+7(.#0=#'*!C(#V#!(/1((+# J06/2(%+#>=%-7*#*+8#F*./#>=%-7*#-+8-7*/(8#/2*/#/2(.(#/10# %()-0+.#2*:(#!(//(%#%(4%(.(+/(8#:*C6(#72*-+.#Y#/206)2# /2("#*%(#+0/#-8(*C#Y#1-/2#J06/2(%+#>=%-7*#@C(8#!"#J06/2# >=%-7*D#4%(.(+/-+)#!(//(%#!*C*+7(8#%(4%(.(+/*/-0+#*7%0..# /2(#:*C6(#72*-+.&# # # # # # #

>&# # # # # # # # # # #

F*./#>=%-7*#.201.#!(//(%#%(4%(.(+/*/-0+## # -+#%0C(.#(+)*)-+)#8-)-/*C#*))%()*/-0+#*+8# 4%030/-0+&#;0+.-8(%-+)#/2(#%()-0+s.#=076.### 0+#30!-C(#8(:(C043(+/#*+8#*77(..#-/# -.#6+8(%./*+8*!C(#*+8#7C(*%C"#40-.(8# =0%#)%01/2&#

# # # #

,&# # # # # # #

J06/2(%+#>=%-7*#*.#3(+/-0+(8#4%(:-06.C"# -.#30%(#!*C*+7(8#!6/#*C.0#.((N.#!(//(%## # %(4%(.(+/*/-0+#-+#-+86./%"#-+:(./3(+/#*+8### =6+8-+)#.6440%/-+)#%0C(.&#

To see pages 50-92 please register to receive the full PDF register here: fakugesi.co.za/intermediaries

K.'85.<%H8>,'>,<%?5-+-9;*97%;,-%Q9;-5F-.*85*-+%&)8;D<5F G<C*97%;,-%H<F?8++%I/$//J

Sf