Alarming Reproducibility Crisis Invading Social Sciences Journals Enago Academy is here to answer all your questions related to academic research and publishing.
ENAGO ACADEMY Enago Academy offers comprehensive and up-to-date resources for researchers, publishers, editors, and students to learn and share their experience about research and publishing. Enago Academy also conducts workshops primarily for ESL authors, early-stage researchers, and graduate students. Our advanced workshop modules cater to the needs of researchers who want to know more about the issues pertinent to successful publication.
ENAGO Enago is the trusted name in author services for the global research community. Since 2005, we have worked with researchers in more than 125 countries improving the communication of their research and helping them to achieve success in publication. We have offices in Tokyo, Seoul, Beijing, Shanghai, Istanbul, and New York. Enago operates globally with regional teams supporting researchers locally. Enago is the preferred partner for many leading universities and research organizations worldwide. In addition, we also collaborate with prominent publishers and societies to overcome regional challenges.
10/1/2018
Alarming Reproducibility Crisis Invading Social Sciences Journals - Enago Academy
Alarming Reproducibility Crisis Invading Social Sciences Journals Last updated Sep 26, 2018 Reproducibility crisis has affected the scientikc community for more than a decade now. This crisis has raised doubts about the validity of scientikc studies and papers published in academic journals. When scientists and researchers attempted to reproduce the experiments in these papers, they were unable to yield the same results. Recently, researchers could reproduce only 8 out of 50 cancer research papers in the long duration of 5 years. After cancer biology, as a recent study has shown, the reproducibility crisis has spread to social sciences.
Reproducibility in Social Sciences A recent study in Nature’s Human Behavior illustrates the reach of this crisis. A collaborative team of researchers from a in group of universities decided to lookscientikc into it. The teamThese attempted to reproduce originally published Science and Nature, two leading journals. articles were basedthe on several kndings in 21 studies t
opics of social science such as link between analytical thinking and religious skepticism,
anxiety and performanceduring exams etc.
https://www.enago.com/academy/alarming-reproducibility-crisis-invading-social-sciences-journals/
4/3
10/1/2018
Alarming Reproducibility Crisis Invading Social Sciences Journals - Enago Academy
The results obtained conkrmed the reproducibility crisis in the social sciences keld. More than one-third (8 of 21) of the published studies could not be reproduced. In addition, the evidence found in the other studies showed weak links between the kndings in the original studies and the conclusions of the reproducibility tests.
What do the Researchers Say? Since two of the most prestigious journals in the scientikc community had published these articles, these results came into notice. Brian Nosek of the University of Virginia in Charlottesville says that these types of high-prokle kndings can receive signikcant media attention. However, the attention is not always positive; some of it may be negative as well. Using the study of stress and performance during exams as an example, Nosek feels that these studies still yield important information. However, he did admit that some kndings in the study could not be replicated. He says that this could be due to some minor change, like the differences in the sample sizes used in the experiments. In that case, Nosek says, “studies that obtain a signikcant result are likely to be exaggerations of the actual effect size.”
Reproducibility in Crisis: True or False? Some claim the kndings are exaggerated while some claim them to be simply false. However, this is still a serious issue for the larger scientikc and academic communities. According to Magnus Johannesson of the Stockholm School of Economics, the results show that cautious interpretation of ‘statistically signikcant’ scientikc kndings is a must. Even if the most prestigious journals publish the research, the replication of the experiment is mandatory. To address this, the academic community conducted several reproducibility studies over the years. One example is the Reproducibility Project: Cancer Biology (RP:CB) that began in 2013. This project set out to test the reproducibility of 50 signikcant studies in cancer biology. To date, the results for 10 replication studies have been published on eLife.
Future of Scientikc Reproducibility The implications of the reproducibility crisis are wide-ranging in social sciences and academia as a whole. Two years ago, the keld of psychology made headlines when two classic studies failed reproducibility tests. According to John Ioannidis of Stanford University, more such studies could improve the accuracy of the knowledge produced. Ioannidis and many others see the attention that reproducibility crisis received as benekcial for the scientikc and academic communities. More such research projects, like the Reproducibility Project and the study in Nature’s Human Behavior, will bring out the reproducibility crisis in academia, thereby eliminating it. In the end, the initiative taken to investigate the validity of scientikc studies can help society in endless ways. If this approach works in academia, what other areas of life can benekt from this investigation and scrutiny? Please share your thoughts with us in the comments section below. Scientikc transparency
https://www.enago.com/academy/alarming-reproducibility-crisis-invading-social-sciences-journals/
5/3
10/1/2018
Alarming Reproducibility Crisis Invading Social Sciences Journals - Enago Academy
This article was originally published at Enago Academy by Enago Editing services which provides scientific editing and manuscript editing services to researchers, authors and Phd students. For more information contact - - orders@enago.com.
REPORTIN G RESEARCH
PUBLISHING RESEARCH
IMPORTAN T LINKS
Language
Selecting
PhDs & Postdocs Services English Editing
& Grammar
Journals
Journal G
Submitting
uidel ines
Manuscripts
Manuscripts
Understanding
& Grants
Reviews
Reference M
Understanding
anagement
Ethics
Figures & Tables
OUR SERVICES ABOUT US
Product & Service Copy Editing Reviews
Services
Ask a Question!
Substantive
GLOBA L ENAGO
Contact Us Guest Contributor About Enago Academy
Editing Services Publication Support Services Proofreading Services
Enago Academy offers comprehensive and up-to-date resources for researchers, publishers, editors, and students to learn and share their experience about research and publishing. Enago Academy also conducts workshops primarily for ESL authors, early- stage researchers, and graduate students. Our advanced workshop modules cater to the needs of researchers who want to know more about the issues pertinent to successful publication. Read More Copyright © - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED | Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Contact Us
https://www.enago.com/academy/alarming-reproducibility-crisis-invading-social-sciences-journals/
6/3