Skip to main content

WesternEye Issue 06

Page 1

Western Eye 05.14  —  Issue 06

07

ADVERTISEMENT

2 1 he 3 t y

Tr

e c i v r e s s u b

y l r u o H e c i v r e s

ided is prov side ) and S eve rn ort 6 8 36 8 m 8 o 4 fr 5 ts ansp Ltd (014 il. All profi unit y Tr y. c sport Comm l communit e Tran rs hire Coun k id n s Li rn s te Vale eve loca d by S uth G louce Towns and eds of the te ra e e o r en ou mS is op e et th arity F e 312 ort fro the ch nsport to m S e rvic ncial supp ck into na tra with fi rt Ltd go ba acces sible o e Transp e lps provid h which

for just

£1 per trip

For help planning your journey visit

www.travelwest.info • c ycl e • ca r s h a re • wa l k • b u s • t ra i n • m oto rc ycl e • s co ot e r •

Name .......................................................................... Email or address ........................................................ ...................................................................................... Have you used the 312 service in the last 12 months? ❑ Yes ❑ No ❑ Please tick here if you do not want us to contact you with future bus information and offers Ticket number ............................................................

for the 312 bus service

£1 ticket voucher

Name .......................................................................... Email or address ........................................................ ...................................................................................... Have you used the 312 service in the last 12 months? ❑ Yes ❑ No ❑ Please tick here if you do not want us to contact you with future bus information and offers Ticket number ............................................................

for the 312 bus service

Name .......................................................................... Email or address ........................................................ ...................................................................................... Have you used the 312 service in the last 12 months? ❑ Yes ❑ No ❑ Please tick here if you do not want us to contact you with future bus information and offers Ticket number ............................................................

for the 312 bus service

Offer expires 30 April 2014

£1 ticket voucher

Name .......................................................................... Email or address ........................................................ ...................................................................................... Have you used the 312 service in the last 12 months? ❑ Yes ❑ No ❑ Please tick here if you do not want us to contact you with future bus information and offers Ticket number ............................................................

Offer expires 30 April 2014

Name .......................................................................... Email or address ........................................................ ...................................................................................... Have you used the 312 service in the last 12 months? ❑ Yes ❑ No ❑ Please tick here if you do not want us to contact you with future bus information and offers Ticket number ............................................................

for the 312 bus service

£1 ticket voucher

Offer expires 30 April 2014

312 Western Eye Advert.indd 1

£1 ticket voucher

Name .......................................................................... Email or address ........................................................ ...................................................................................... Have you used the 312 service in the last 12 months? ❑ Yes ❑ No ❑ Please tick here if you do not want us to contact you with future bus information and offers Ticket number ............................................................

for the 312 bus service

Offer expires 30 April 2014

Name .......................................................................... Email or address ........................................................ ...................................................................................... Have you used the 312 service in the last 12 months? ❑ Yes ❑ No ❑ Please tick here if you do not want us to contact you with future bus information and offers Ticket number ............................................................

for the 312 bus service

£1 ticket voucher

Offer expires 30 April 2014

for the 312 bus service

Name .......................................................................... Email or address ........................................................ ...................................................................................... Have you used the 312 service in the last 12 months? ❑ Yes ❑ No ❑ Please tick here if you do not want us to contact you with future bus information and offers Ticket number ............................................................

for the 312 bus service

Offer expires 30 April 2014

£1 ticket voucher

£1 ticket voucher

Offer expires 30 April 2014

£1 ticket voucher

Name .......................................................................... Email or address ........................................................ ...................................................................................... Have you used the 312 service in the last 12 months? ❑ Yes ❑ No ❑ Please tick here if you do not want us to contact you with future bus information and offers Ticket number ............................................................

for the 312 bus service

Offer expires 30 April 2014

£1 ticket voucher

Offer expires 30 April 2014

for the 312 bus service

Offer expires 30 April 2014

£1 ticket voucher

Name .......................................................................... Email or address ........................................................ ...................................................................................... Have you used the 312 service in the last 12 months? ❑ Yes ❑ No ❑ Please tick here if you do not want us to contact you with future bus information and offers Ticket number ............................................................

13/03/2014 09:39


08

Western Eye 05.14  –  Issue 06

MU S I C & E N T E R TA I N M E N T

MUSIC & ENTERTAINMENT — GAME OF THRONES, DIVERGENT AND WHAT’S ON

‘Game of Thrones’ is Back But will the start of the fourth season kick start G.R.R. Martin to finish the books? all of our favourite child actors, as they can’t pretend to be ten-years old forever. So, as a precaution, Martin has told Benioff and Weiss a very broad overview regarding the ending for ‘A Song of Fire and Ice’ so they can work around it and can continue to write a tv show that is at least going in the same direction as the books it’s based on. Let’s consider for a moment that the show does finish first, would it really be the worst thing in the world if that happened? Would it be better for a tv show to be slightly different, maybe even disappointing, rather than a lifetime’s work of books to be rushed

because he didn’t give it his best go? Although after the outrage at the Dexter finale, perhaps not. Of course, there’s the terrifying possibility that Martin never finishes the books, so maybe it’s a positive that the show runners know the ending. Sort of. This is all pure speculation! Who knows whether Martin will suddenly be inspired and release the next instalment before the start of the fifth season (fingers crossed). Either way, both the books and the show are big hits, and as long as it maintains its high standards, does it really matter which ends first?

Jeanine is curt and quiet, making her all the more terrifying to encounter. Theo James (the typical ‘taking his top off ’ muscular man, with an impressive jaw line Spoilers ahead. Helen Lewington reviews the latest edition of and dark features that is expected from the male lead of a young dystopian book-to-screen adaptation Divergent adult movie aimed at teenage girls) portrays both the overly particular virtue that they feel Tris through the three stages of protective masculine role and HELEN LEWINGTON would have prevented the war: training where she avoids detec- the gentle vulnerable soul needed music@westerneye.net ‘Amity’, the peaceful; ‘Candor’, tion of being a Divergent. As soon to balance the characteristics of the painfully honest; ‘Erudite’, as she meets her instructor Four Dauntless’s Four and his past as © Dir: Neil Burger the intelligent; ‘Dauntless’, the (Theo James), the story develops Tobias Eaton. Considering many © Cert: 12A brave (and slightly mad); and a romantic element. However, it Brits will recognise him as having © Stars: Shailene Woodley, ‘Abnegation’, the selfless. The film becomes apparent that within poo on his nose from the end of Theo James, Kate Winslet. joins heroine Beatrice Prior (an the faction, there are sinister ‘The Inbetweener’s’ movie, it’s © Duration: 2 hours 19 minutes enigmatic Shailene Woodley) and actions in play, behind them is certainly a step up. her brother Caleb (Ansel Elgort) the matriarchal leader Janine Those who have read the roth’s debut novel, written living a sheltered life with their Matthews (Kate Winslet). The book will notice a few differences events that follow are not with- from the original plot. Whilst the during her undergraduate days, parents in Abnegation. Tris discovers that she does out emotional losses… majority of these are understandis the first part of the best-selling Whilst initial impressions of able, the film fails to translate trilogy followed by Insurgent and not fit into any one of these Allegiant. In similar style to The districts comfortably, and is the selected actors do not quite various important details onto Hunger Games trilogy, the novel therefore, Divergent. This is a rare meet the images created by the screen, with many scenes feelfocuses on its female protagonist, (and slightly sinful) result, and is book’s descriptions, the characters ing rushed and unexplained. It is Beatrice ‘Tris’ Prior in a futuristic warned to not tell anyone of her grow on you. Shailene Woodley’s perhaps fair to say that the film Chicago after war has brought the non-conformity. One choosing initial timid personality makes suffers from the normal issues day, a confused Tris decides to her growth even more endear- that cinema adaptations encounplanet to destruction. The film follows suit in its leave home and join Dauntless: ing, showing a relatable personal ter when trying to bring a whole beloved world to life: timing. initial plot line: it introduces a the danger seeking sect who progression. She more than holds her own against the likes of Kate However, the ending of the society divided into 5 distinct protect the whole city. From here, the plot follows Winslet, who’s sharp and cutting film is questionable. Without groups, all of which embody a

giving too much away, I simply cannot understand why the producers felt the need to alter the story here and create a scene that achieves the same outcome but through different means. Hopefully, the end result will not mean further inconsistencies in the follow up movies. The film has been highly panned by critics as falling short to the Hunger Games, with ratings above 3 stars being scarce. Yet, critics love to hate this type of film and it hasn’t stopped audiences from flooding into the cinema to watch it and afterwards praising it. Personally, I feel if you’ve read and enjoyed the book, the film has amazing graphics brining Chicago and its characters to life in a way that does not disappoint. But as is usually always the case, fans of the book with all leave reciting the exact same phrase, ‘the book is much better than the film’. Summit Entertainment has revealed that the sequel, Insurgent, is already in the works and scheduled to be released on the 20th March 2015. The finale, Allegiant, is due the following year.

JAYDE SMYTH

music@westerneye.net

the hit hbo show made its eagerly anticipated return to our screens on April 6th, becoming the network’s most watched episode since the finale of ‘The Sopranos’ in 2007. So it’s safe to say that despite the seemingly never ending wait between each series, fans are still interested in the show and it looks like the word is spreading on just how amazing it really is. The day after the success of its season opener, hbo announced that ‘Game of Thrones’ would be coming back for a fifth and sixth season, (was there ever really a doubt?) But show runners David Benioff and D.B. Weiss announced earlier this year that the adventure in Westeros is to end most likely after season seven, which has book lovers questioning whether the tv show will overtake the series of novels it is originally based on. But why should they be worried? Well, the last published work in the ‘A Song of Fire and Ice’ collection, A Dance with Dragons, was back in 2011, six years after its predecessor A Feast for Crows. Clearly, G.R.R.

Martin is not one to be rushed into finishing things before he is ready. He also happens to be a busy man; not only does he write an episode per series, but he’s also writing accompanying novellas, including a collection of Tyrion Lannister’s best quotes and quips (and I for one can’t wait for this to be released). On top of all of this he’s editing two other tv series, appearing at fan conventions and overseeing the production of the show itself. So, sure it’s perfectly reasonable to be worried about the show surpassing the books with a workload this size, but is it any wonder the poor guy just can’t get around to finishing up The Winds of Winter? So are there any solutions? Well, they could make the show longer. There’s been talk about ten seasons and a movie, but that really depends on hbo, funding, fan interest and a lot of unpredictable factors. Benioff and Weiss have also voiced concerns about over-staying their welcome, feeling that eight seasons would be more than enough. (Is there such a thing as too much Game of Thrones? (Definitely not.) Of course, there’s always the possibility of the book series being extended,

meaning the show would have to continue, assuming that Martin feels up to the task. Let’s not forget the original novels were only supposed to be a trilogy before he realised this was not a story to be told in three tales. (Can I get a round of applause that this never happened?) Unfortunately, we may have to face the cold hard truth, the show is moving at a much faster speed with a new series being released every year. Within these series is a combination of all the novels (season four alone has glimpses of the last three books in itself) and then there’s the little problem of

GAME OF THRONES NOMADIC LASS

Divergent Review


Western Eye 05.14  —  Issue 06

SOPHIE SEDDON

music@westerneye.net

with another year of uni drawing to a close, and most tenancies ending in June or July, there’s plenty to celebrate and do in the city, especially when we’ve been predicted another beautifully hot summer ahead of us. Here’s a brief guide on what you can expect to be happening for the summer months. Bristol Folk Festival, St. George’s and the Folk House, 3rd-4th May

A slightly alternative start, but a good option for those of you who are not avid dance lovers, and would rather pick up a ukulele than the Apple Mac and decks, dancing around in brogues and straw hats than neon paint and tie-dye tees and shorts. Featuring some of the most established folk acts, as well as newcomers, the festival promises to be exciting within the much loved folk genre. From ‘Fairport Convention’, a respected and highly regarded folk group, to ‘Spiers and Boden’, the BBC Radio Two folk award winners, the event looks to be an exciting two days in two of Bristol’s most prestigious venues. VegFest, Lloyds Amphitheatre, 23rd—25th May

Clashing with Love Saves the Day, this festival will definitely be right up your street if you’re looking for a good day out, rather than just live music. The event promises 140 stalls of vegan produce and products, which is perfect for you herbivores out there. There are also some cookery workshops and various film showings, as well as

09

MU S I C & E N T E R TA I N M E N T

This summer in Bristol

Sophie Seddon looks at the festivals and big musical events coming to Bristol this summer

Ruts DC as the evening highlight. Good perhaps for family friendly fun, but perhaps not quite as student friendly as… Love Saves the Day, Castle Park, 24—25th May

The annual festival brings many a dance and dj lovers to the city for two days of guaranteed great music. Chill out at Castle Park for the weekend with the likes of Annie Mac, SBTRKT, Eton Messy, Hercules and the Love Affair, Clean Bandit and B Traits. No doubt the atmosphere will be perfectly chilled during the day, with face painting, cider flowing and dancing students fuelling the crowds until the early hours. If you’re looking for a weekend with friends to enjoy new and exciting dance tracks, before returning home, look no further.

coming to Ashton Court with Bananarama and Rick Astley among many of the old school artists performing at the three day event. If you have a passion for 80s music and don’t mind being Rick Roll’d, you may also want to look into camping for the weekend. Grillstock BBQ and Music Festival, Lloyds Amphitheatre, 7th—8th June

A VegFest alternative for meat

lovers. On the outer rim of the Clifton Triangle, around the corner from Bill’s and two doors down from Mbargo is Grillstock, one of the tastiest joints in the city where meat is the specialty. Now in its fifth year, Grillstock brings meat and music to the Lloyds building. It’s certainly one you won’t want to miss if you love your meat. Fun Lovin’ Criminals and Hayseed Dixie are the us headliners that will be entertaining you while you pick

up some nifty bbq cooking tips. Paolo Nutini, Lloyds Amphitheatre, 25th June

The beloved Scot returns this year with album Caustic Love and is bringing it to the Bristol crowds out on the Harbourside. While hopefully playing classics such as ‘Rewind’, ‘Last Request’, ‘Pencil Full of Lead’ and ’10/10’, he’ll also be showcasing the new album at the closing gig on his 2014 tour. It is a rare opportunity to see a live act as big as this to be playing in the centre of Bristol, so if you get the chance, head on down. St. Paul’s Carnival, St. Paul’s, 5th July

From its initial beginnings in the sixties, the carnival aims to promote cultural and community development of the Stokes Croft/ St. Paul’s sector of the city. The entire area is taken over, with schools and community groups using African and Caribbean inspired themes to produce what is a major attraction in the West Country. Well worth a trip down, if you’re still in Bristol.

Let’s Rock Bristol, Ashton Court Estate (Bower Aston campus), 6th—8th June

The ultimate 80s festival is

FESTIVAL CROWD SHANE KELLY

What’s on in Bristol’s theatres? Natasha McGregor gives the heads up on the shows coming to Bristol this summer NATASHA MCGREGOR

music@westerneye.net

london is only an hour and a half train journey away, but why travel to the West End when the West End is coming here? Bristol’s Hippodrome is hosting a line of fantastic and well known shows this summer. As well as big names gracing the stage, Bristol pulls out all the home talent in various theatres across the city. Bristol Hippodrome, St Augustine’s Parade, BS1 4UZ

A great selection of shows are coming up over the summer months. Short runs include the all male ‘Matthew Bourne’s Swan Lake’ (May 20—24) and ‘Rock of Ages’ (July 7—12). The big show that everyone has been waiting for is ‘Shrek the Musical’, which will run from August 19th to September 7th. All tickets can be

purchased online from atg tickets or in the box office located next to the Hippodrome Piano bar. And if you need any more of a reason to go, they often have a student concessionary rate that rivals any last minute London ticket! Bristol Old Vic, King Street, BS1 4ED

The highlight from the Old Vic will be their annual Mayfest, which is dedicated to presenting a range of “unusual, playful and ambitious work”. It’s a fantastic festival with a great collection of works being put on all around the city. They will also have their usual collection of spoken word nights, studio productions and the return of ‘Bristol Proms’. The full program can be found on their website at www.bristololdvic.org.uk/shows. The Old Vic is a perfect example of original theatre that showcases fantastic talent; it also received the thumbs up for a revamp earlier this year.

Tobacco Factory Theatre, Raleigh

Redgrave Theatre, Percival Road,

Bierkeller Theatre, All Saints Street,

Road, BS3 1TF

BS8 3LE

BS1 2NA

Brewery Theatre, North Street,

The Redgrave Theatre in Clifton are yet to release their full summer program, but still have a great selection of shows coming up. Bristol Old Vic Theatre School will be performing ‘Sauce for the Goose’, a classic comedy about “untrustworthy husbands, betrayed wives, artful servants and crazed Germans” among other things. baos will also be putting on ‘West Side Story’ and Clifton College Upper School pupils will be taking ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream’ into the grounds of the college itself. Their programme of events can be downloaded from their website here www.cliftonc o l l e g e u k . c o m /c c s l / r e d g r a v e but tickets must be purchased directly from the companies, details of which can be found in their programme.

The Bierkeller is a Bristol gem, it often debuts uwe student performances as well as putting on unique showcases and cheap nights out. Some uwe students will be performing several times at the Bierkeller Theatre this summer. Our Drama Society will be presenting the Moira Buffini play ‘Dinner’, a new writing showcase and a double bill of short plays in collaboration with Steam Powered Tea, a new business by a uwe graduate. These are all taking place between May and July, the details of which can be found on the Bierkeller Theatre website w w w . b i e r ke l l e r t h e a t r e . c o m . There will also be the usual live music nights, including bands such as Halo, Metallica Reloaded and number of local band showcases.

BS3 1JP

uwe’s own students will be taking a night of new writing to the Brewery Theatre, part of the Tobacco Factory Theatre, from 10th—14th June. This will include three new pieces of writing by students, performed by current students and graduates and directed by some of the university’s drama lecturers. As well as this, the Tobacco Factory will have their usual program of Shakespeare, physical theatre, and new drama being presented by a variety of companies. You can check out their events and book tickets on their website www. tobaccofactorytheatres.com Make sure you go and support your fellow uwe students at this brilliant event.


10

ADVERTISEMENT

Western Eye 05.14  –  Issue 06


Western Eye 05.14  —  Issue 06

11

S AT I R E

REVOLUTIONARY NEWS SOURCE COMING OUT OF THE NEW WORLD ORDER

The Stanton Shelter Riots in Nottingham England

The Indian State of Karnataka

Vatican nun banished after

Adrian Lansley accused of

Lybia wins winter Olympics bid,

after Erik Thickles calls Robin

bans smoking in child labour

breaking her celibacy vows with

ordering G-Forces to injure

snow being shipped over from

Hood “a no good crook…”

areas

a man she claims was God

the public in order to get more

Siberia

patients in his private hospital

Sledge Hammer’s address The leader of the revolution ‘Sledge Hammer’ speaks to the world comrades, The interruption changed the landscape and the borders of this world. You may not like your new neighbours much but you must learn to live side by side. Difference is not necessarily dangerous and hopefully we can use these new bonds to our advantage. I dream of a new world where people needn’t fear their future, people needn’t fear their freedom and I dream of this for you. Psychopaths have previously been our rulers and our guides but not for much longer. It’s time for a government that has you in their best interest not their own

sex appeal. Sexy politics has no place in our new world. Prepare yourselves for a struggle because this is not going to be an easy fight. There will be blood sweat and tears, there always will be. If you want to live to see a brighter tomorrow you are going to have to carry tools. I wish to lead this world into the battle for freedom and justice. I will do anything and everything to make our future a utopia but I need your assistance. A leader is nothing without the people. I will see you on the fields. Viva La revolution.

Council man David Westboro missing WILLIE PETE

councilman David Westboro is missing and presumed dead after being propelled into the air after crude oil burst through the ground beneath him at Topeka Country club Kansas. There are no official records of Westboro’s age but he is estimated

A DEPICTION OF HOW GOD MIGHT LOOK ADAPTATION OF MICHELANGELO BUONARROTI’S SISTINE CHAPEL FRESCO

to have been thousands of years old judging by his political views. Westboro was playing golf at Topeka country club when he disappeared. Onlookers say that Westboro was struck by lightning first then an earthquake opened the ground beneath his feet and crude oil shot up at him up thrusting him into the sky. His body has not yet been found and police have called off the search after scouring a 5 mile radius. Westboro has been in the news a recently after a phone call he made to a local Topeka political radio show. During the phone call Westboro shared his controversial opinions on homosexuality and expressed fear that a God would attack the Earth to demonstrate his anger with homosexuality. Until now there has been no evidence to there being oil under Topeka and after inspection there doesn’t seem to be any oil left which has led to some people reaching the conclusion that this itself has been an act of God.

Helpful-Man: help-full or hand-full? KEVIN KLARKER

citopia’s super powered protector ‘Helpful-man’, the cities symbol of hope and freedom, has used his super strength, speed and flight to kill his clown faced nemesis ‘General-Zany’. Helpful-man punched Zany through a skyscraper which fell on hospital which fell on an orphanage which itself fell on a dog shelter. When Helpful-man discovered Zany was still not dead he snapped his neck of the clown based villain finally ending his life. Its estimated during this battle that 100,000 innocent people have been killed or badly injured and at least 10 dogs are seeking therapy for the trauma. costume but he's a complicated, This is the latest in a string dark and brooding person… He of dark and gritty Exploits that deals with the death of his parents Helpful-man has been involved in by pummelling street level crimisince he rebooted his image. This nals born into poverty with his has led me to question: why has super powers, how is that not Helpful-man, a hero traditionally awesome?" children admired, changed to a Now lets take a look at violent murderer? General Zany. Some people believe its The coroner revealed that the because Helpful-man wanted to "Captain of Camp" (as he became appeal more to teenage males. known amongst the city's crime Until recently this demographic mobs) was revealed to be local were unimpressed by Helpful- homeless man, Geoffrey King. man. Popular teenage blogger An investigation revealed that N33killa wrote about Helpful- King was born into poverty. Then man last year going as far to call when he was 14 he lied about his him “homosexually active”. We age to join the Army in the hope asked N33killa if his opinion had he could escape his dire circumchanged recently his response stances. He was dispatched to was "yeah, I know he still wears fight in Switzerland and was sent tights and has a colourful home on honourable discharge

after a traumatic ied attack caused him to develop a serious case of post-traumatic stress disorder. Returning home King began to believe he was a clown and started to call himself General-Zany. There have be several serious campaigns calling for the rehabilitation of super villains such as King. The campaigns have never been able to take off because of a wealthy benefactor, Stark enterprises, who bankroll the no campaign. Owner of Stark enterprises the Mysterious Billionaire Wayne Stark has now green lit a film based on Helpful-man and General Zany. The film is eagerly anticipated to be one of the most profitable films ever with the special affects budget alone costing 400,000,000,000 money.

Written by WIl Anderson & Billiam | Edited by Billiam | Billyrmorris@gmail.com


12

Western Eye 05.14  –  Issue 06

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY

SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY — FRACKING AND ENTOMOPHAGY

Fracking: The Collision of Politics and Science Policy decisions are rarely made on scientific evidence alone. In fact, science has only a small part to play in the convoluted world of policy. In this light, perhaps it is unsurprising that even though we have seen vehement anti-fracking protests across the uk in recent months, it looks like the controversial process will be going ahead as planned. JAMES RILEY

scitech@westerneye.net

fracking, or hydraulic fracturing, is the process by which hundreds of gallons of pressurised water, chemicals and sand are blasted into the ground to open up trapped deposits of gas. In the current controversy the focus is on shale gas extraction, although fracking can be used to extract various gases for use as fuel. The process is nothing new. It made its first appearance in 1947 and was first commercially implemented in 1949. Recent events have sparked public opposition to fracking, with many perceiving the risks to outweigh the benefits. In 2011, two earthquakes struck Lancaster following prospective fracking exercises by Caudrilla Resources (the main company with fracking contracts within the uk), resulting in a nationwide moratoria while a formal investigation into fracking’s dangers took place. However, the risks of fracking stretch beyond the chance of mild earth tremors. It is these environmental concerns which activist groups like Greenpeace are desperately trying to bring to the public’s attention. In their recent publication, “Fracking: What’s the Evidence?”,

Greenpeace set out the wealth of environmental consequences aligned to this extraction technique. Greenpeace says about its report: “From water pollution, to gas flares, to seismic activity to property prices, the report takes an in-depth look at what fracking involves, and the key social and environmental risks that should be taken into consideration as the uk Government attempts to open England up to this new form of extreme energy.” One major concern raised over the fracking procedure is the contamination of groundwater, and the possible contamination of drinking water. In the usa this has indeed taken place, although the Geological Society has said that with proper regulations in place the contamination of groundwater should not be an issue. Another consideration is the fact that fracking uses a large amount of water and some groups claim the water supply couldn’t take the strain. In reality, fracking in the uk should only require the use of around 0.01% of the current usage. But even without these various local environmental concerns, it would still be true that one of the major risks of fracking is our continued dependence on fossil fuels and the inability to cut our emissions; further failing to halt

the seemingly glacial march of climate change. This is one of the biggest concerns anti-fracking groups can urge, and it is almost an uncontested one from the supporters of fracking. However, some politicised points about shale gas producing less greenhouse emissions than coal have been made, along with the claim that it is a “greener alternative” to traditional fossil fuels. The uk government has agreed to a number of targets aimed at decarbonising the home economy. This includes the Kyoto Protocol, which promises an 80% reduction in greenhouse emissions by 2050. The Kyoto Protocol gave rise to the Climate Change Act 2008, which makes it the duty of the Secretary of State to adhere to cutting the greenhouse emissions laid out within the Kyoto agreement. Although large original signatories, such as the United States and Canada, have since not ratified the agreement and subsequently dropped out, the protocol is still taken seriously within European governments. Our reduction promises are one point which anti-fracking campaigners have cited in opposition to fracking. In a world where we are committed to reducing our greenhouse emissions, should we not be more

ILLUSTRATION OF THE HYDRAULIC FRACTURING PROCESS US ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY

focused on alternative forms of energy such as wind farms, solar panels and tidal generators? These technologies have benefited other European economies, whilst continuing to honour the Kyoto agreement. Germany, for example, which boasts Europe’s leading economy, now produces over 25% of their energy from renewables in this way. On 27th September, 2013, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (ipcc) published its fifth Assessment Report and in response to this comprehensive collection of climate change science, the Secretary of State for Energy and Climate change, Edward Davey acknowledged:

change contribution. For some time now the uk, like a lot of European countries, has been trying to decouple its energy dependence from Russia. With current Ukrainian crisis highlights the fragility of the West’s relationship with the old Soviet state. Although the uk’s gas imports from Russia are now only around 1%, we still import over 40% of our coal and solid fuels from the nation. Russia’s power on the world stage comes mainly from its abundance of energy resources. These are resources which Russia has exploited for power in the past. Even despite the West’s efforts to reduce our dependence

FRACKING PROTEST SOUTH OF BALCOMBE, 18 AUGUST 2013 ROBIN WEBSTER

“The message of this report is clear – the Earth’s climate has warmed over the last century and man-made greenhouse gases have caused much of that global warming. The gases emitted now are accumulating in the atmosphere and so the solutions must be set in motion today. The risks and costs of doing nothing today are so great, only a deeply irresponsible government would be so negligent.” This is where the intersection of politics and science is greatly evident. Quite obviously, shale gas will be contributing to climate change. Quite obviously, it is not a green alternative. And, quite obviously, the solutions are not being “set in motion today”. Yet it seems like the government are set to launch full-scale shale extraction within the uk. On the 24th January, 2014, David Cameron said to the World Economic Forum (Davos): “Governments need to reassure people that nothing would go ahead if there were environmental dangers. But if this is done properly, shale gas can actually have lower emissions than imported gas. We should be clear that if the European Union or its member states impose burdensome, unjustified or premature regulatory burdens on shale gas exploration in Europe investors will quickly head elsewhere.” From Cameron’s focus on loss of investors over the environmental consequences, it is quite obvious that there are more factors in this decision than solely the scientific evidence of environmental damage and climate

on Russian power, statistics from 2010 show how Russia’s energy exports were more than twice as much as any other oecd country, and represented a massive 40% of the total oecd energy exports. With the recent events in Ukraine, giving fracking the go ahead seems to make more and more political sense. Even though there may be water contamination, even though there may be earthquakes, even though it will not be a step in the direction of fulfilling our Kyoto Protocol obligations, there is a sense that somehow the scientific facts of the dangers are going to give way to possible political dangers of not acting. This is not a certainty, but it seems likely. When calculating the risks of such a decision, it is a fine balance of deciding between two possible futures. One in which your obligations to reducing greenhouse gases helps to curb insidious climate change, which may for the most part be irreversible; and the other option, the reduction of dependence on the energy exports of a country vying for power, a country which has used its position as an energy provider for geopolitical influence and intimidation before, and could easily choose that path again. When presented as two options it becomes clear how the waters of policy can become muddied by much more than just science’s view of the world. Not that these two futures are the only possible options, there is the truly green alternative. Is it not time we start to take renewable energy more seriously?


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook