Impactful Substantives I Safeguarding the Tourist Sites of Tomorrow

ENGLISH DEBATE

SUBSTANTIVES GUARDIANS OF GLORY SENIOR LEVEL 01

Powered by EduDrift No material may be used, distributed or reproduced in whole or in part without prior written consent.

All rights reserved.

IF YOU ARE NEW HERE

Welcoming Remarks Welcome back to class, everyone! If this is your first class, we’re very excited to meet you! Before moving on to our lesson, let’s all introduce ourselves.

Tell us your:

Name

Age

Favourite Subject

Fantastic! Now that we all know each other, we are ready to embark on an exciting journey of learning.

Along the way, you will discover new ideas, practice thinking on your feet, build your confidence when speaking in front of an audience, and develop your critical thinking skills.

Expectations

1 2 3 MODULE BY

Thrilling activities awaits The activities will keep you on the edge of your seat!

Give awesome speeches!

We'll have a chance to speak up and get helpful feedback!

Active participation I'll call on your wacky ideas to make this class extra special.

HOUSE RULES FOR EVERYONE

Class Rules to make this a fantastic experience for all!

Now that we all know each other, let’s make this class into a proper classroom!

Here are some rules that we will all follow together:

Before Class 1. Make sure that you’ve eaten breakfast/lunch and have gone to the bathroom 2. Join the Zoom call a few minutes before class starts so we can get started right away!

At the Start of Class 1. Turn your camera on so we can see your lovely smile!

2. Let your coach know if you need to leave class early

During Class 1. Keep your camera on unless you are preparing during an activity 2. Put your hand up if you want to say something 3. Do not leave your computer during class - if you need to go to the bathroom, put your hand up and ask your coach before you go 4. Immediately unmute yourself and reply when you are called on

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

CLASS ROADMAP YOUR DREAM HOLIDAY DESTINATIONS Warm Up Activity

1. What is sustainab 2. Why is it importa 3. Case study of su

LETS BE REAL: How to make arguments sound more pragmatic

ARG CONSTRU

ARGUMENT CONSTRUCTION

A

Activity

1

2

SYMBOL OBJE

Key takeaway

MODULE BY

Question

Speak

ble tourism? ant? ustainable tourism

SPEAK UP FOR TOURIST SITES: A SPEECH ON HOW WE CAN CONSERVE OUR NATIONAL HERITAGE

GUMENT UCTION, PART 2

Activity

Activity

2

3

ECTIVES:

king Activity

Quiz

Dictionary

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

CLASS OVERVIEW

Overview By the end of today’s class, you’ll learn:

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

How to make your arguments sound important How to make arguments sound impactful

Sustainable tourism

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

CLASS INTRODUCTION

INTRODUCTION Hi class!

Today we will be talking about how to make our arguments persuasive by making strong impacts and learning how to ground them. The theme we will be using for this class is “Tourism.”

So to get things started we have a small but fun warm up activity planned for you.

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

WARM UP ACTIVITY YOUR DREAM HOLIDAY DESTINATIONS

YOUR DREAM HOLIDAY DESTINATIONS Warm Up Activity

1. What is sustainab 2. Why is it importa 3. Case study of su

LETS BE REAL: How to make arguments sound more pragmatic

ARG CONSTRU ARGUMENT CONSTRUCTION

A

Activity

SYMBOL OBJE

Key takeaway

MODULE BY

Question

Speak

ble tourism? ant? ustainable tourism

SPEAK UP FOR TOURIST SITES: A SPEECH ON HOW WE CAN CONSERVE OUR NATIONAL HERITAGE

GUMENT UCTION PART 2

Activity

Activity

ECTIVES:

king Activity

Quiz

Dictionary

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

WARM UP ACTIVITY | YOUR DREAM HOLIDAY DESTINATIONS

Your Dream Holiday Destinations Warm up Activity

Time Given 1 min: Think

Activity Instructions Given budget is not an issue, name your dream tourist destination that you would want to visit this year.

Additionally, also explain why you would want to visit this place.

Guidelines & Directions It could be places you want to visit or places you have already been to

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART ONE IMPACTING

1. What is sustainab 2. Why is it importa 3. Case study of su

NAME YOUR FAVORITE TOURIST DESTINATIONS Warm Up Activity

ARG CONSTRU

LETS BE REAL: How to make arguments sound more pragmatic

A

SYMBOL OBJE

Key takeaway

MODULE BY

Question

Speak

ble tourism? ant? ustainable tourism

SPEAK UP FOR TOURIST SITES: A SPEECH ON HOW WE CAN CONSERVE OUR NATIONAL HERITAGE

GUMENT UCTION PART 2

Activity

Activity

ECTIVES:

king Activity

Quiz

Dictionary

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART 1: IMPACTING

Let's Be Real: Making arguments sound pragmatic Debates are often decided on the basis of which team was able to prove that their argument is likely to be the most impactful in the entire debate. Government might be able to show 5 different arguments with small impacts but if the Opposition is able to prove 1 argument with the largest impact in the debate then the opposition team will win.

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

Debates are not won by the number of arguments but rather by the scale of impact those arguments can implement.

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART 1: IMPACTING

For the following section we will be using the following topic:

Tourists should not pay taxe in the country they visit.

There are 2 benefits of this policy: 1. Because they can save money and buy more things 2. They will visit more often since its cheaper Answer the following questions while proving the impact of an argument to make it sound more “impactful”:

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

es

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART 1: IMPACTING

1) How many people will the argument impact?

Impacts are often based on numbers and the higher the number of people that we can impact the more impactful our arguments become. Hence, whenever we are trying to present an impact, try and prove why you have the highest number of people on your side.

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

This is how it is likely to play out with the sample motion mentioned above: Because tourists are now likely to have more money saved, this money is likely to be used to buy local goods and services from the communities they are visiting. This has a huge impact on ALL of the people living in these areas because it helps flourish their business and if they have more money they can spend to make their quality of life better. As a result, we impact large groups of people very positively.

Tourists visiting more often is a dream scenario for all the individuals within the local communities. Tourists end up spending a lot of money on their trips for things such as food, cultural artifacts, accommodation, transportation etc.

If more tourists end up visiting it results in more income for the people in these communities.This impact includes but is not limited to professions such as farmers, cooks, carpenters, sculptors, doctors, taxi drivers etc.

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART 1: IMPACTING

2) What is the current state of the group that is being impacted?

It is not enough to prove that we are impacting people. If an argument’s impact is shown to benefit the privileged class of society it is not a good argument as these people can do without more benefits for themselves.

Impacts are more persuasive and better rewarded when we are able to show that they make the lives of vulnerable individuals better. By portraying the vulnerability of the group being impacted, you can frame that the impacts not only are a net positive but also an absolute necessity.

You can portray vulnerability by discussing the problems your target group faces on a daily basis and why they do not have any alternatives.

MODULE BY

Th m

O ar th be no se

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

his is how it is likely to play out with the sample motion mentioned above:

Our argument has already proven why a large group of people re impacted. Why is it so important that these people receive hese benefits? Some of these individuals that we are enefitting are the most vulnerable within a country. They do ot have access to a regular income source as tourism is a easonal business and are oftentimes seen facing huge shortage of funds in the offseason. Due to a lack of resources they have also not had the opportunity to access education and training and hence are also locked out of conventional jobs. So extra tourists and extra spending by tourists brings some much needed help to these individuals.

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART 1: IMPACTING

3) To what extent are you making their lives better or worse?

Making lives better or worse is a vague and generalized statement. In order to actually prove lives are getting better or worse we have to measure what the quality of life was before the argument and what it is likely to be after the argument.

An effective way to do this is to talk about how they are likely to get access to certain goods/ services/ opportunities that they did not have access to before but can afford now.

MODULE BY

Th m

A co of of su w ha op gr

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

his is how it is likely to play out with the sample motion mentioned above:

As a result of the impacts mentioned above we can state with onfidence that this will significantly improve the quality of life f the people that we are trying to protect over here. Because f a lack of funds many of them struggled to meet basic needs uch as food, medicine, education. Now they will not have to worry about such needs anymore. This will lead to them living appier and more fulfilled lives and will also allow them the pportunity to build bigger and better things from here such as rowing their business or pursuing higher education.

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART 1: IMPACTING

Let’s try this method with a motion:

Topic: THBT governments should prioritize promoting slum tourism over other types of tourism Slum tourism, poverty tourism, ghetto tourism or trauma tourism is a type of city tourism that involves visiting impoverished areas.

Argument from Government: Slum tourism raises money for people living in slums and that helps them out in their life.

1. How many people is the argument impacting?

- Usually large numbers of people live in slums.

Around 100,000 people live in slum areas in Mumbai and Rio. So we will be impacting a large number of people.

2. What is the current state of the group that is being impacted?

- Slum dwellers live in terrible conditions.

There is a lack of food, medicine, and education. These areas are also very unhygienic and don’t have adequate security.

They desperately need help.

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

3. To what extent are we making their lives better?

- After this motion passes, slum areas will have more tourism inflow. Tourists will spend money there and people in that area will have more income. Previously, they could not afford to buy food and medicine but now they will be able to. Because there will be more tourists, the government will also want to make the area cleaner and safer.

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART TWO SUSTAINABLE TOURISM

NAME YOUR FAVORITE TOURIST DESTINATIONS Warm Up Activity

1. What is sustainab 2. Why is it importa 3. Case study of su

LETS BE REAL: How to make arguments sound more pragmatic

ARG CONSTRU

A

SYMBOL OBJE

Key takeaway

MODULE BY

Question

Speak

ble tourism? ant? ustainable tourism

SPEAK UP FOR TOURIST SITES: A SPEECH ON HOW WE CAN CONSERVE OUR NATIONAL HERITAGE

GUMENT UCTION PART 2

Activity

Activity

ECTIVES:

king Activity

Quiz

Dictionary

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART 2: SUSTAINABLE TOURISM

What is sustainable tourism?

Sustainable tourism is a form of tourism that takes full account of its current and future economic, social, and environmental impacts, addressing the needs of visitors, the industry, the environment, and host communities. It seeks to provide a positive experience for tourists and hosts, while ensuring a sustainable long-term benefit to the destination and its residents. The aim is to strike a balance between the economic benefits of tourism and the preservation of cultural and natural resources.

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART 2: SUSTAINABLE TOURISM

Different types of sustainable tourism: Some of the different types of sustainable tourism are as follows:

Ecotourism Type of sustainable tourism that focuses on responsible travel to natural areas that conserves environment

Cultural tourism Cultural tourism emphasizes the exploration of cultural heritage, traditions, and practices in a way that respects and benefits the host communities.

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART 2: SUSTAINABLE TOURISM

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

Community based tourism Community-based tourism involves the active participation of local communities in the planning, development, and management of tourism activities.

Agrotourism Agrotourism promotes visits to farms, agricultural areas, and rural landscapes, allowing tourists to experience and learn about agricultural practices and local food production.

Voluntourism Volunteer tourism involves travelers participating in voluntary work that contributes to the well-being of local communities and the conservation of natural environments. It allows tourists to engage in meaningful and sustainable development projects, such as community service, wildlife conservation.

If you were offered a free trip to take part in one of the five types of sustainable tourism, which one would you choose?

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

ACTIVITY 1 | ARGUMENT CONSTRUCTION PART 2

Argument Construction Part 2 Activity

Time Given 5 mins: Prepare 2 mins: Speak

Activity Instructions You will be given a topic and an argument. Please follow the structure given in the guidelines to show the impact on the argument.

Guidelines & Directions How many people is the argument impacting?

What is the current state of the group that is being impacted?

To what extent are you making their lives better?

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES| GUARDIANS OF GLORY

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

ACTIVITY 1 | ARGUMENT CONSTRUCTION PART 2

Argument Construction Part 2 Activity

Motion & Argument Motion: This House regrets the rise of tourism in tribal areas Argument: Rise of tourism in tribal areas has disrupted the daily lives of tribal communities.

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES| GUARDIANS OF GLORY

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

FEEDBACK

Feedback Congratulations on completing the activity.

Your coach will give you feedback on: 1. Were you able to identify who would be impacted?

2. Were you able to prove how much their lives would be disrupted?

MODULE BY

TITLE | SUBTITLE

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

ACTIVITY 2 | ARGUMENT CONSTRUCTION

ANSWER KEY Argument: Rise of tourism in tribal areas has disrupted the daily lives of tribal communities.

1. This argument impacts almost all the individuals living in the tribal areas. They may be small in number but you need to understand that this is an entire community we are talking about.

2. People living in tribal areas are disconnected from the cities and towns because they want to live in peace on their own. We should respect their choice.

3. The increase in tourism has resulted in them having a complete lack of privacy and compromises their safety and security. They have people coming over and littering their land and disrupting their everyday activities. Imagine if someone came into your house and wanted to stay there and take pictures of you.

Would you be okay with it even if they paid you? Lives of people in trial areas have become worse as a result compared to before when they could live in privacy and peace.

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES| GUARDIANS OF GLORY

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART 2: SUSTAINABLE TOURISM

Sustainable Tourism Case St Costa Rica

Costa Rica has been leading the world in the industry of susta earns around USD 1.4 billion annually from its ecotourism industry

Costa Rica offers a range of safe environmental tourism options s biological reserves, bird watching tours and more. The lodges an are also eco-friendly. They run on electricity powered by renewa water and the construction materials are the majority of sustainab

The government of Costa Rica has introduced a number of mea environment remains unharmed from tourism. On average only 7 for tourists and the rest are closed off from the public. Tourism certificate known as the Certification for Sustainable Tourism (C register and run a business.

Costa Rica is truly a global pioneer and a leader when it comes to

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

tudy

ainable tourism. The country y.

such as nature parks, forests, nd hotels built for the tourists able energy such as wind and ble materials.

asures to make sure that the 7% of natural parks are open m businesses have to earn a CST) in order to successfully

o sustainable tourism.

https://nearshoreamericas.com/tourist-arrivals-costa-rica-rises-4/ DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART 2: SUSTAINABLE TOURISM

Preservation of Tourist Sites:

Governments can take a few steps in order to maintain and preserve tourist sites: Tourist Quota: Limiting the number of tourists that can visit every year will reduce things like pollution in those areas. Also closing down certain tourist spots for a specific time of the year will help nature heal itself and allow the authorities to manage the tourist sites with more ease.

MODULE BY

d

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

Educational and awareness programs: Running awareness programs across local communities can help educate the locals in terms of how they can contribute to protecting their communities better. Tourists can also be educated and made aware of actions that they usually commit that may harm the tourist.

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART 2: SUSTAINABLE TOURISM

Introducing strict laws: Strong laws in tourist areas against littering and pollution can force tourists as well as locals to not take part in acts that might cause damage to the environment.

Promotion of responsible tourism: Encourage responsible tourism practices such as minimizing the carbon footprint, supporting local businesses, respecting local customs and traditions, and promoting environmentally friendly activities.

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES | GUARDIANS OF GLORY

Planned conservation and restoration: Governments can also plan to run sustainable conservation and restoration programs to preserve tourist sites. This includes things such as tree planting, coral rehabilitation and much more.

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

PART THREE MAIN ACTIVITY

NAME YOUR FAVORITE TOURIST DESTINATIONS Warm Up Activity

1. What is sustainab 2. Why is it importa 3. Case study of su

LETS BE REAL: How to make arguments sound more pragmatic

ARG CONSTRU

ARGUMENT CONSTRUCTION

A

Activity

SYMBOL OBJE

Key takeaway

MODULE BY

Question

Speak

ble tourism? ant? ustainable tourism

SPEAK UP FOR TOURIST SITES: A SPEECH ON HOW WE CAN CONSERVE OUR NATIONAL HERITAGE

GUMENT UCTION, PART 2

Activity

Activity

ECTIVES:

king Activity

Quiz

Dictionary

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

ACTIVITY 3 |SPEAK UP FOR TOURIST SITES

Speak up for tourist sites Activity

Time Given 5 mins: Prepare/Discuss 3 mins: Speak

Activity Instructions For the purpose of this activity, imagine you are a youth activist in Brazil who is advocating for preserving the Amazon Rainforests in your country.

You have 3 minutes to make a speech towards the Brazilian government.

The speech should include the following things: 1. How is the Amazon rainforest hurting? (tourism and deforestation) 2. What are the impacts of this on the tribal communities living in the Amazon? ( livelihood, security) etc.

3. What steps can be taken by the government to help preserve these forests?

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES| GUARDIANS OF GLORY

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

ACTIVITY 3 |SPEAK UP FOR TOURIST SITES

Speak up for tourist sites Activity

Guidelines & Directions 1. Refer to Part 2 to come up with solutions the government can use to help preserve the rainforests.

2. Use the case studies of Costa Rica as an inspiration to how other countries have overcome these challenges.

Pro Tip While explaining the impact on tribal communities please use the structure that was taught in “ Part 1: Let's be real “ 1. How many people is the argument impacting?

2. What is the current state of the group that is being impacted?

3. To what extent are you making their lives better?

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES| GUARDIANS OF GLORY

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

FEEDBACK

Feedback It’s time for me to tell you my favourite thing about your speech, as well as what you can improve on.

1. Were you able to use proper hand gestures and voice modulation?

2. Did you come up with adequate solutions for the problems you highlighted?

MODULE BY

TITLE | SUBTITLE

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

RECAP

MODULE BY

SUBSTANTIVES| GUARDIANS OF GLORY

Here’s a recap of what we learned today: Target large groups of people to make an argument sound impactful.

Analyze the vulnerability of the target group to make an argument sound important.

Sustainable tourism is a form of tourism that takes full account of its current and future economic, social, and environmental impacts, addressing the needs of visitors, the industry, the environment, and host communities Ecotourism is one of the most widely used forms of sustainable tourism.

Government can take steps such as limiting tourists to preserve tourist sites

DEBATE & PUBLIC SPEAKING

ENGLISH DEBATE

THANK YOU SEE YOU AGAIN NEXT WEEK

Powered by EduDrift No material may be used, distributed or reproduced in whole or in part without prior written consent.

All rights reserved.