Instant digital products (PDF, ePub, MOBI) ready for you
Download now and discover formats that fit your needs...
Fundamentals of Industrial Instrumentation and Process Control, Second Edition William C Dunn
https://ebookmass.com/product/fundamentals-of-industrialinstrumentation-and-process-control-second-edition-william-c-dunn/
ebookmass.com
Electric Motors and Control Systems, Second Edition Frank D. Petruzella
https://ebookmass.com/product/electric-motors-and-control-systemssecond-edition-frank-d-petruzella/
ebookmass.com
Wetlands for Water Pollution Control, Second Edition Scholz
https://ebookmass.com/product/wetlands-for-water-pollution-controlsecond-edition-scholz/
ebookmass.com
Rise of a Dungeon House: A litRPG Story (City of Masks Book 2) John Stovall
https://ebookmass.com/product/rise-of-a-dungeon-house-a-litrpg-storycity-of-masks-book-2-john-stovall/
ebookmass.com
Minimal English for a Global World: Improved Communication Using Fewer Words 1st Edition Cliff Goddard (Eds.)
https://ebookmass.com/product/minimal-english-for-a-global-worldimproved-communication-using-fewer-words-1st-edition-cliff-goddardeds/
ebookmass.com
A Victim Community: Stigma and the Media Legacy of HighProfile Crime 1st ed. 2021 Edition O’Leary
https://ebookmass.com/product/a-victim-community-stigma-and-the-medialegacy-of-high-profile-crime-1st-ed-2021-edition-oleary/
ebookmass.com
The Empire of Disgust: Prejudice, Discrimination, and Policy in India and the US 1st Edition Zoya Hasan
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-empire-of-disgust-prejudicediscrimination-and-policy-in-india-and-the-us-1st-edition-zoya-hasan/
ebookmass.com
Financial Management + Mindtap, 1 Term Printed Access Card
Eugene F. Brigham
https://ebookmass.com/product/financial-management-mindtap-1-termprinted-access-card-eugene-f-brigham/
ebookmass.com
Women and Sustainable Human Development: Empowering Women in Africa 1st ed. Edition Maty Konte
https://ebookmass.com/product/women-and-sustainable-human-developmentempowering-women-in-africa-1st-ed-edition-maty-konte/
ebookmass.com
https://ebookmass.com/product/aukle-gilly-macmillan/
ebookmass.com
BLOWOUTAND WELLCONTROL HANDBOOK
SECONDEDITION
ROBERTD.GRACE PresidentandCEO,GSMEnterprisesandSubsidiaries Amarillo,Texas
GulfProfessionalPublishingisanimprintofElsevier 50HampshireStreet,5thFloor,Cambridge,MA02139,UnitedStates TheBoulevard,LangfordLane,Kidlington,Oxford,OX51GB,UnitedKingdom
© 2017ElsevierInc.Allrightsreserved.
Nopartofthispublicationmaybereproducedortransmittedinanyformorbyanymeans, electronicormechanical,includingphotocopying,recording,oranyinformationstorageand retrievalsystem,withoutpermissioninwritingfromthepublisher.Detailsonhowtoseek permission,furtherinformationaboutthePublisher’spermissionspoliciesandour arrangementswithorganizationssuchastheCopyrightClearanceCenterandtheCopyright LicensingAgency,canbefoundatourwebsite: www.elsevier.com/permissions
Thisbookandtheindividualcontributionscontainedinitareprotectedundercopyrightby thePublisher(otherthanasmaybenotedherein).
Notices
Knowledgeandbestpracticeinthisfieldareconstantlychanging.Asnewresearchand experiencebroadenourunderstanding,changesinresearchmethods,professionalpractices, ormedicaltreatmentmaybecomenecessary.
Practitionersandresearchersmustalwaysrelyontheirownexperienceandknowledgein evaluatingandusinganyinformation,methods,compounds,orexperimentsdescribed herein.Inusingsuchinformationormethodstheyshouldbemindfuloftheirownsafetyand thesafetyofothers,includingpartiesforwhomtheyhaveaprofessionalresponsibility.
Tothefullestextentofthelaw,neitherthePublishernortheauthors,contributors,oreditors, assumeanyliabilityforanyinjuryand/ordamagetopersonsorpropertyasamatterof productsliability,negligenceorotherwise,orfromanyuseoroperationofanymethods, products,instructions,orideascontainedinthematerialherein.
LibraryofCongressCataloging-in-PublicationData
AcatalogrecordforthisbookisavailablefromtheLibraryofCongress
BritishLibraryCataloguing-in-PublicationData
AcataloguerecordforthisbookisavailablefromtheBritishLibrary
ISBN:978-0-12-812674-5
ForinformationonallGulfProfessionalpublicationsvisitour websiteat https://www.elsevier.com/books-and-journals
Publisher: JoeHayton
Sr.AcquisitionEditor: KatieHammon
Sr.EditorialProjectManager: KattieWashington
ProductionProjectManager: MohanaNatarajan
Designer: MarkRogers
TypesetbySPiGlobal,India
ClassicalProcedures DrillStringWashoutEffect150 DeterminationofShut-InDrillPipePressures152 DeterminationoftheTypeofFluidThatEnteredtheWellbore152 FrictionalPressureLosses154 AnnulusPressureProfilesWithClassicalProcedures157 KickToleranceEnvelope172 ConstantCasingPressure,ConstantDrillPipePressure,andModification oftheWaitandWeightMethod173 TheLowChokePressureMethod175 ReversetheBubbleOutThroughtheDrillPipe176 TheOverkillWait-and-WeightMethod180 Slim-HoleDrilling ContinuousCoringConsiderations184 StrippingWithInfluxMigration187 Oil-BaseMudinPressureandWellControlOperations191 FloatingDrillingandSubseaOperationConsiderations197 NegativeTests208 References209 FurtherReading209
PREFACE
Wellcontrolproblemsarealwaysinteresting.Therawpowerthatisreleased bynatureintheformofanoilorgaswellblowingoutofcontrolisawesome. Certainly,wellcontrolisonething,andWILDwellcontrolissomething else.Therewillbewellcontrolproblemsandwildwellsaslongasthere aredrillingoperationsanywhereintheworld.Itjustgoeswiththeterritory.
Theconsequencesoffailurearesevere.Eventhemostsimpleblowout situationcanresultinthelossofmillionsofdollarsinequipmentandvaluable naturalresources.Thesesituationscanalsoresultinthelossofsomething muchmorevaluable—humanlife.Wellcontrolproblemsandblowouts arenotparticular.Theyoccurintheoperationsoftheverylargestcompanies andtheverysmallest.Theyoccurinthemostcomplexoperationssuchas deep,high-pressuregaswells,andtheyoccurinthesimplestshallowoperations.Menhavelosttheirliveswhenthingswentwrongatsurfacepressures of12,000psiandatsurfacepressuresof15psi.Thepotentialforwellcontrol problemsandblowoutsiseverpresent.
Timereallyflies!OnceIwasyoungandnowIamold.Itseemstohave happenedinthetwinklingofaneye.But,alothastranspiredinbetween. Throughthoseyears,Ihadtheprivilegeofbeinginvolvedinmostofthe industry’smostmonumentalandpublicwellcontrolevents,includingthe Al-AwdaProject—theoilfiresofKuwait—andthetragedyontheDeep WaterHorizon,theMacondoblowout.Iworkedoneverymajorblowout inCanadasinceLodgepoleincludingOldSalty,theindustry’soldestthat blewoutin1916onthePeaceRiverinnorthernAlberta.I’vebeeninvolved intheevolutionofoilwellfirefightingononesideoftheequationandthe introductionofengineeringintowellcontrolandhelpedpioneerthetechnicalaspectsofwellcontrol.
Lotshashappenedsincethistextwaslastupdated.Themostsignificantis this.AlltheLionsaregone!We’velosttheiconsofthewellcontrolindustry.
IstartedasadrillingengineerforHumbleOilandRefining,theforerunnerofExxon,inOklahomaCity.WewereworkingintheArkomaBasin andweredrillingwithair.Ofcourse,everywellwasablowoutwiththeonly differencebeinghowbig.Irecallsomethathadfireouttheendoftheblooie lineashighasthecrownonthederrick!Ilearnedalotaboutwellcontrolbut nothingaboutclassicproceduressincethesewerenoclassicoperations.
Shortlyafterthat,IleftHumbleandafewshortmonthslaterstartedin theconsultingbusinessintheTexasPanhandle.Thereweretwoconsultants inallofwesternOklahomaandtheTexasPanhandle—meandCWKelly. KellyhadmostofthebusinessbutIsqueakedby.
AroundthePanhandleandwesternOklahoma,itwascommonpractice todrillintotheMorrowsandswithoutsettingaprotectivestring.TheMorrowwasanabnormallypressuredstratigraphicsandandwasunpredictable. Asaresult,itwasstandardoperatingproceduretodrillintotheMorrow withoutsettingcasingontop.Everyeffortwasmadetominimizeexposure. Theplanwasusuallytodrillnomorethanacoupleoffeetofanydrilling breakintheMorrowandthencirculatetoseeifitcouldbemanaged. Thewellscouldnotbeshutinastherewasalwaysonlyafewhundredfeet ofsurfacepipesetandthousandsoffeetofnormallypressuredinterval betweenthecasingseatandtheMorrow.
Mostoften,thepermeabilityintheMorrowwaslowandthedeliverabilityequallylow.Wecouldhandlethegasweencountered.But,prettyregularly,wewouldhitagoodMorrowsandthatgetsourhatsblownoff!About allyoucoulddowasberiggedupwithagoodchokeandseparatorandletit blowtothepituntilyoucouldgetitkilled.Iwasveryfrustratedbecausewe didn’thavethetechnicalskillstoknowhowmuchmuddensityandpump rateweneededtokillthewell.Oftentimes,thewellwouldjustblowwhateverwepumpedbackintoourfacesuntilaftermanytrialanderrorefforts, werandomlylandedontherightcombinationofmudweightand pumprate.
IrememberonewhenweworkedonforasmallcompanyoutofDallas calledFilonExploration.WeworkedforthenicestguyinTexas,buthe didn’tknowmuchaboutdrillingandnothingaboutwellcontrol.Wewere drillingaMorrowwellnearHiggins,Texas,andwehadonlyashortstringof surfacecasingset.WeweregettingclosetotheMorrow,andIcalledour contactandtoldhimthatifwefoundwhatwewerelookingfor,weregoing togetourbuttsblownoff.Ourcontacttoldmethatwewereoffsettingawell thathadnoMorrowandyoucouldthrowarockandhitthatlocation.Itold himthatdidn’tmeananythingintheMorrow,andwehadbettergetrigged uptohandlesomegas.Heaskedwhatweneeded.Itoldhimagoodseparator,chokemanifold,drillingchoke,andnaileddownflowlines.Hesaid hewouldcallmeback.
Hecalledbackandtoldmehehadtalkedtothedrillingcontractorand thedrillingcontractorassuredhimthatifwedidhitsomegas,wecouldrig allthatstuffup.Itoldhimthatwasnotright,butwewoulddowhatever hewanted.
Icalledourguyattherigandtoldhimtoputanoteontheboardinthe doghousetodrillnomorethan2ftofanydrillingbreakfromthatpoint forward.Hedid.
Laterthatnight,Igotacallfromourguy.Thedrillerhaddrilled26ftof Morrowsandin18min.Hesaidwehadabout800psionthecasing.Itwasa fewdaysbeforeChristmas.IkissedmywifegoodbyeandtoldherIdidn’t knowwhenIwouldbeback.IhadnothadtomissChristmasathomebut wassurethiswastobethefirst.
Iwenttotherig.IcalledJerryandhemetmethere.Wegotriggedup andopenedthewellupthroughthechokes.Itwasscreaming!WehadaBIG Morrowwell.Weriggedupandpumped16ppgmudatabout13bpm.The wellneverblinked!Weregroupedandcalledtheoffice.Ourcontactsaidwe werenotdoingitrightbecausewewerelosingcirculationandshouldbe pumping12ppgmud!Weaboutfainted.Jerrytoldhimhewasnotsure whatwouldworkbutthatwouldnotwork.Filonbackedoffandletus gobacktowork.Wegotallthehydraulichorsepowerwecouldfind,went backouttothewell,mixedupafewhundredbarrelsof20ppgmud, pumpeditat20bpm,andkilledthewell.
IsadlylamentedtoJerrythatFilonwouldinsistthatweworkover Christmas.Wegotitkilledandcementedthedrillcollarsabout3:00am onChristmasEve.Weweresittinginthetrailerattherig.Jerryasked theHalliburtonengineerhowlongweshouldwaitonthecement.The engineerpausedandthoughtforaminute.Jerryinterjectedandproceeded toremindhimhowmuchworkGSMdidaroundthePanhandleduringthe courseoftheyear.JerrytoldhimthatifHalliburtoneverwantedtodo anotherjobforGSM,hisanswerwouldbe72h!Theengineerthought foraminuteandthensaid—Ithinkweshouldwaitoncementabout 72h!WethencalledFilon.Ofcourse,theywantedustogotoworkimmediatelytowhichwereplied,wewantedtogotoworktoobutHalliburton saidweneededtowaitonthecementfor72h.Filonreluctantlyagreedand wewenthomeforChristmas.
Thatjobmadeabigimpressiononme.Iresolvedtosolvethosefluid dynamicmysteriesinthefuture.WhenIwasatHumble,Ilearnedthatthere wasabigseparationbetweenoperationsandengineering.WhenIgottothe field,Ifoundthatchasmwasthegreatestinwellcontrol.Nooneeven attemptedtoapplyengineeringprinciplestowellcontroleventsbeyond theclassicalwellcontrolprocedures.Iharboredtheopinionthatblowouts werenodifferentthananyotherengineeringproblem.Wejustoftendidn’t havealotofdatatoworkwithwhichmeantourzoneofuncertaintywould bebigger.
GoneisPrestonMoore—Mr.Drilling!Prestonpioneeredadulteducationandauthoredthefirsttextsondrillingengineering.Noonewasbetter knownormorerespectedthroughouttheindustrythanPreston.Preston wasmymentorincollegeandfrienduntilhepassedawayinearly2015 attheageof91.Hewasthe“M”inmycompany,GSM.
Ofcourse,DubGoinswasthefirsttorecognizeandwriteabouttheprincipleswenowconsiderclassicalwellcontrolprocedures.Iwasjustgetting outofschool.PrestonwasstillatOUandheavilyinvolvedincontinuing educationwithhis DrillingPracticesSeminar.Prestontrainedliterallythousandsofdrillingengineersandfieldpersonnel.
IworkedwithPrestonatthetimehewasteachinghisseminar,butmy firstlovewasworkinginthefield.Prestonaddedasectioninhisseminaron wellcontrol.ThroughmyassociationwithPreston,Iwasexposedtothe latestinfluiddynamicsandthefundamentalsofclassicalwellcontrol.
Asanynovicewillknow,multiphaseflowisaninterestingandcomplicatedsubject.Theonlyworkdoneonmultiphaseflowintheoilfieldhas beendoneingasliftoperations.Allmultiphasecalculationsarebasedon researchdonearoundoil,gas,andwaterflowingupsmallpipes.Nowork hadeverbeendoneonflowinanannulus.
Wewerehamperedintheearlydaysbythelackofcomputingpower.In thosedays,laptopswerejustsomeone’simagination,andahandheldcalculatorthathadasquarerootfunctionwasrare.Itwasnotuntil1975whenI wenttoMontanaTechthatIboughtanHP-41Cthatwouldmakeallthe calculationsthatcouldbedoneonasliderule.
Goneismyfriendof30plusyears—BobCudd.ItalkedtoBobalmost everydayandsometimesmorethanonceperday.IfirstmetBobwhenhe wasatOtis.AfterheleftOtis,Itriedtohirehimbuthewastoosmartfor that.HewentontofoundCuddPressureControl.Wewereateam—the firsttoofferfullserviceswellcontroloperation.Weworkedtogetheron manydifficultjobs—oftenafterothershadfailed.ItrustedBob’sjudgment morethanmyown.Ididn’talwaysagreewithhimbutIknewhewasalways right.IoncedecidedBobknewmorethananyoneelseintheindustryabout whathedid.Ilaterdecidedthatwasn’ttrue.Bobknewmorethaneveryone elseputtogetherintheindustryaboutwhathedid!Imisshimeveryday.
GoneisPatCampbell,anotherfriendofmanyyears.IalwayslookedforwardtoseeingPateveryyearatOTC.HewouldcomebymyboothorI wouldgobyhis.Patwasagentlemanandmorethancompetentonanylocationunderanycircumstances.Weworkedtogetheronsometoughjobs.Pat wasanicon.
GoneisRedAdair.Redwasoneofthepioneersofoilwellfirefighting. RedstartedoutwithHalliburtonandwenttoworkforMyronKinley.It wasMyron’sdadthatstartedmodernoilwellfirefightingearlyinthelast century.Inthelate1950s,RedlefttheKinleyorganizationandstarted hisowncompany.HewassoonjoinedbyCootsMathewsandBootsHanson.WealwaysreferredtoRedasthePTBarnumofourindustry.Hewas notonlyverycapableandinnovativebutalsoashowman.Ihadthepleasure ofmeetingthosethreewhilestillincollege.TheycametoOUforourengineer’sweekcelebrationinthespringof1960.Theywerealldrivingnewred Cadillacs.Thatimpressedabunchofbrokeengineeringstudents.Asofthis writing,BootsisretiredandCootshaspassedaway.
SafetyBossinCanadaisstillinbusiness.Theyaretheoldestwellcontrol companyinbusiness.MikeMilleristheprincipalinSafetyBoss.Theydo thingsdifferentlyfromtheHoustonguys,buttheirproceduresarevery effective.Factis,theyfixedmoreblowoutsinKuwaitthananyoftheothers.
Inshort,therearenorealwildwellfightersleft.Thewildwellfighting companieshavebeenswallowedupbycorporateconglomerates.Organizationslikethataremoreinterestedinprovidingservicesthatareneededevery dayratherthanservicesthatareneededonlyrarely.And,notmanyareinterestedinworkingonblowouts.Forlongperiodsoftime,thereisnothing goingon,andthenforalongperiodoftime,thingsareveryintense.Often, thejobishalfwayaroundtheworld,goesonfordaysormaybemonths,and isunderadverseworkingandlivingconditions.Noteveryoneisinterested inworkinglikeasleddogandlivinglikeacoyoteforlongperiodsoftime. NoteveryoneisinterestedinworkingregardlessofwhetheritisChristmas ortheirkid’sbirthday.
Whatdoesallofthismeanforthefutureoftheindustry?Itmeansthatthe qualityoftheserviceswillgodownandthecostswillincrease.AsRedAdair oncesaid,“Ifyouthinkprofessionalsareexpensive,waittillyouseewhat amateurswillcostyou!”Brightlycoloredcoverallsandhardhatsdonot makeawildwellfighter.Therewon’tbeanymoremenlikeRedAdair, CootsMathews,BootsHansen,andBobCuddwhodevotedtheirlives andcareersstrictlytowildwellcontrol.Itwillbeinteresting.Ihopethis bookwillcontributetothefutureoftheindustry.Idedicatethisbookto myoldfriendBobCuddandalltheLions.Itwasapleasureandanhonor toknowandworkwiththem.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Iwouldliketoacknowledgemycontributors,Mr.BobCudd,Mr.JeraldL. Shursen,andMr.RichardCarden.Asacloseandpersonalfriendandassociateformorethan30years,BobCuddcontributednotonlytothiswriting butalsomuchmoretothetotalexperienceinthiswork.Ioncereflectedthat Bobknewmorethananyoneaboutvariousaspectsofwellcontrol.Ilater realizedthatheknewmorethaneveryoneelsecombined.Bobrepresented awealthofexperience,knowledge,andexpertise.Bobhaspassedawayand issorelymissedeveryday.
IwouldalsoliketoacknowledgeJerryShursenforhiscontributions.Asa closeandpersonalfriend,businesspartner,andassociate,JerryandIworked verycloselytogethertopioneermanyoftheconceptspresentedinthis book.JerryisthebestdrillingengineerIeverencounteredintheindustry. ThereisnooneI’dratherhavebesidemeinatoughsituationthanJerry Shursen.
RichardCardenhasbeenmyfriendandassociatesincehisstudentdaysat MontanaTech.Heisanoutstandingengineer,andwehaveworked togetheronsomeverytoughprojects.Ihaveyettofindanythinghecan’t do.Richistechnicallysolidandhasworkeddiligentlytocontributetothis bookandensurethequalityofthework.
Forhisinspiration,IwouldliketoacknowledgemylifelongfriendDr. PrestonL.Moore.NoonehascontributedmoretodrillingthanPreston.He wasmymentorincollegemorethan50yearsago.Thoughhehaspassed away,hecontinuestoinspiremetoday.Inthelate1960s,inPreston’s world-renowned DrillingPracticesSeminar,heandIwerepioneeringmany ofthewellcontrolconceptsandtechniquesnowconsideredclassicinthe industry.
Finally,IwouldliketoacknowledgethestaffatGSMwhohaveworked diligentlyandwithprofessionalpridetoensurethequalityofthiswork.Particularly,Imustmentionandthankmyfriend,assistant,andsecretary Ms.AngieVigil.Amongmanyotherthings,shepatientlyworkedthrough themanydetails.Finally,Iwouldliketoacknowledgemygrandson,Quinn Spellmann.Atthiswriting,QuinnisajuniorinPetroleumEngineeringat ColoradoSchoolofMines.Usinghisknowledgeofmoderntechnology, Quinnworkeddiligentlytoimprovethequalityofthefigures,photos, andillustrations.
CHAPTERONE EquipmentinWellControl Operations
“ … Icouldseethatwewerehavingablowout!Gastothesurfaceat 0940hours.”
0940TO1230HOURS
Naturalgaswasatthesurfaceonthecasingsideveryshortlyafterroutingthe returningwellborefluidthroughthedegasser.Thecrewreportedthatmost oftheunionsandtheflexlinewereleaking.A31 2 -in.hammerunioninthe linebetweenthemanifoldandtheatmospheric-type“poor-boy”separator wasleakingdrillingmudandgasbadly.Theseparatorwasmountedinthe endofthefirsttank.Gaswasbeingblownfromaroundthebottomofthe poor-boyseparator.Atabout1000hours,themotorsontherigfloorbegan torevasaresultofgasintheairintake.Thecrewshutdownthemotors. At1030hourstheannularpreventerbeganleakingverybadly.The upperpiperamswereclosed.
1230TO1400HOURS
Continuingtoattempttocirculatetheholewithmudandwater.
1400TO1500HOURS
Thecasingpressurecontinuestoincrease.Theflowfromthewellisdrygas. Thelinebetweenthemanifoldandthedegasseriswashingoutandtheleak isbecomingmoresevere.Theflowfromthewellisswitchedtothepanic line.Thepaniclineisleakingfromnumerousconnections.Flowistoboth thepaniclineandtheseparator.
Thegasaroundtherigignitedat1510hours.Thefirewashigherthan therig.Thederrickfellat1520hours.
Thisexcerptisfromanactualdrillingreport.Wellcontrolproblemsare difficultwithoutmechanicalproblems.Withmechanicalproblemssuchas thosedescribedinthisreport,anotherwiseroutinewellcontrolproblem escalatesintoadisastrousblowout.Inareaswherekicksareinfrequent,it
iscommonforcontractorsandoperatorstobecomecomplacentwithpoorly designedauxiliarysystems.Consequently,whenwellcontrolproblemsdo occur,thesupportsystemsareinadequate,mechanicalproblemscompound thesituation,andadisasterfollows.
Becausethisbookispresentedasablowoutandwellcontrolhandbook, itspurposeisnottopresenttheroutinediscussionofblowoutpreventers (BOPs)andtestingprocedures.Rather,itisintendedtodiscusstherole ofequipment,whichfrequentlycontributestothecompoundingofthe problems.Thecomponentsofthewellcontrolsystemandthemoreoften encounteredproblemsarediscussed.
Thesaying“itwillworkgreatifwedon’tneedit!”appliestomanywell controlsystems.Thefactisthat,ifwedon’teverneedit,anythingwillsuffice.Andthereinliestherootofmanyoftheproblemsencountered.Ona largenumberofrigs,thewellcontrolsystemhasneverbeenusedandwill neverbeneeded.
Somerigsroutinelyencounterkicks,andthecrewisrequiredtocirculate outthekickusingclassicalwellcontrolprocedures.Intheseinstances,the bareessentialswillgenerallysuffice.Formostoftheseconditions,wellsite personnelneednotbetooconcernedabouthowtheequipmentisriggedup orhowtoughitis.
Insomepartsoftheindustry,wellsareroutinelydrilledunderbalanced withthewellflowing.Inthesecases,thewellcontrolsystemismuchmore critical,andmoreattentionmustbepaidtodetail.
Inafewinstances,thekickgetsoutofcontrol,orthecontrolledblowout intheunderbalancedoperationbecomesuncontrolled.Undertheseconditions,itissometimesimpossibletokeepthebestwellcontrolsystems together.Whenithappens,every“i”mustbedottedandevery“t”crossed. Unfortunately,itisnotalwayspossibletoforetellwhenandwhereoneof thoserareinstanceswilloccur.Itiseasierandsimplertomerelydoitright thefirsttime.Sometimes,theworstthingthatcanhappentousisthatweget awaywithsomethingweshouldn’t.Whenwedo,wearetemptedtodo thingsthesamewayoverandoverandeventoseeifwecangetawaywith more.Soonerorlater,itwillcatchupwiththebestofus.Itisbesttodoit rightthefirsttime.
PRESSURE,EROSION,CORROSION,ANDVIBRATION
Wheneverythinggoestohellintheproverbialhandbasket,ourfirstquestionshouldbe,“howlongisallthiss—goingtostaytogether?”Theanswer
tothatquestionisusuallyafunctionoftheitemslistedabove—pressure, erosion,corrosion,andvibration.
Pressure
Ifthewellcontrolsystemisratedto10,000psiandhasbeentestedto 10,000psi,I’mcomfortableworkinguptothatpressureprovidednone oftheotherthreefactorsiscontributing,thoughthatisseldomthecase. Thereisusuallyalargedifferencebetweentheworkingpressureandtest pressureforagivenpieceofequipment.Forexample,a10,000psiworking pressureBOPhasatestpressureof15,000psi.Thatmeanstheramsshould operatewith10,000psi,andunderstaticconditions,everythingshould withstand15,000psi.
Wellheads,valves,andallothercomponentsarethesame.Itiseasyto understandhowavalvecanhavea“working”anda“test”pressure,butit isnaturaltowonderhowaspoolcanhavea“working”anda“test”pressure. Sinceaspoolhasnomovingparts,itseemsthatthetwoshouldbethesame.
Vibration
Whenthingsbegintovibrate,theworkingpressuregoesdown.Thereare nomodelsavailabletopredicttheeffectofvibration.Allconnectionshavea tendencytoloosenwhenvibratedviolently.Aswillbeoutlinedin Chapter9,attheE.N.Ross,achicksanonapumpinlineontherigfloor vibratedlooseduringthefinalkillattempt.Duetothepresenceofhydrogen sulfide,thegaswasignitedandtherigwaslost.
Erosion
Erosionofthewellcontrolsystemisthemostseriousproblemnormally encountered.Whencirculatingoutkicksandbubblesinroutinedrilling operations,erosionisnotgenerallyafactor.Theexposuretimeisshort, andthevelocitiesofthefluidsareminimal.Therefore,almostanyarrangementwillsuffice.Itisusuallyunderadverseconditionsthatthingsbeginto fail.Thatisthereasonmostwellcontrolsystemsareinadequatefordifficult conditions.Difficultconditionsjustdonothappenthatoften.
Inthetimeframeofmostwellcontrolincidents,drygassimplydoesnot significantlyerode,atleastnothingharderthanN-80gradesteel.Ata production-wellblowoutinNorthAfrica,theflowratewasdetermined tobeapproximately200mmscfalongwithabout100,000bblofoilper day.Thewellflowedforalmost6weekswithnosignificanterosionon
thewellheadorflowlines.Thicknesstesterswereusedtomonitorcritical areasandshowednosignificantthicknessreduction.
AtadeepblowoutinthesouthernUnitedStates,theflowratewasdeterminedtobewellover100mmscfpdthroughthe31 2 in.drillpipeby7in. casingannulus.Theflowingsurfacepressurewaslessthan1000psi.There wasgreatconcernabouttheconditionofthedrillpipe:woulditbeeroded orperhapsevenseveredbytheflow?Afterabout10daysexposure,thedrill pipewasrecovered.Attheflowcross,thedrillpipewasshiny.Otherthan that,itwasunaffectedbytheexposuretotheflow.
Unfortunately,theindustryhasnoguidelinesforabrasion.Erosionin productionequipmentiswelldefinedbyAPIRP14E.Althoughproductionequipmentisdesignedforextendedlifeandblowoutsystemsare designedforextremeconditionsovershortperiodsoftime,theAPIRP 14Eoffersinsightintotheproblemsandvariablesassociatedwiththeerosion ofequipmentunderblowoutconditions.Thisrecommendedpractice relatesacriticalvelocitytothedensityofthefluidbeingproduced.The equationsgivenbytheAPIareasfollows:
where
Ve ¼ fluiderosionalvelocity,ft/sec
c ¼ empiricalconstant
¼ 125fornoncontinuousservice
¼ 100forcontinuousservice
ρ ¼ gas/liquidmixturedensityatoperatingtemperature,lb/ft3
P ¼ operatingpressure,psia
Sl ¼ averageliquidspecificgravity
R ¼ gas/liquidratio,ft3/bblatstandardconditions
T ¼ operatingtemperature, °R
Sg ¼ gasspecificgravity
z ¼ gascompressibilityfactor
A ¼ minimumcross-sectionalflowarearequired,in2/1000bbl/day
Pipe sizing to avoid erosional velocities for continuous two-phase flow
Based on Ve = 100 / √rm
Where ve = Fluid erosional velocity, ft/s rm = Gas/liquid mixture density at flowing pressure and temperature, lb/ft3
Assumptions: Flowing temperature = 75° f
Gas specific gravity = 0.65
Liquid specific gravity = 0.85
Sand free stream
Gas compressibility = 1.0
Eqs. (1.1)–(1.3) havebeenusedtoconstruct Fig.1.1,whichhasbeenreproducedfromAPIRP14Eandoffersinsightintothefactorsaffectingerosion. Becausethevelocityofacompressiblefluidincreaseswithdecreasingpressure,itisassumedthatthearearequiredtoavoiderosionalvelocities increasesexponentiallywithdecreasingpressure.
Itis,however,interestingthatpursuantto Fig.1.1 andEqs. (1.1)–(1.3),a highgas/liquidratioflowismoreerosivethanalowgas/liquidratioflow.
Thepresenceofsolidscausesthesystemtobecomeunpredictable.Oilfieldservicecompaniesspecializinginfracturestimulationandthose involvedinslurrypipelinesareveryfamiliarwiththeerosionaleffectsof solidsinthepresenceofonlyliquids.Testingofsurfacefacilitiesindicates thatdischargelines,manifolds,andswiveljointscontainingelbowsand short-radiusbendswillremainintactforupto6monthsatavelocityof approximately40ft/sevenatpressuresupto15,000psi.
Furthertestshaveshownthat,inadditiontovelocity,abrasionisgovernedbytheimpingementangleorangleofimpactoftheslurrysolids andthestrengthandductilityofthepipeandthehardnessofthesolids. Atanimpingementangleof10degreesorless,theerosionwearforahard, brittlematerialisessentiallyzero.Inthesetests,themaximumwearrate occurredwhentheimpingementanglewasbetween40and50degrees.
Pipe cross-sectional area, sq. in /1000 bbls fluid per day
Fig.1.1 Erosionalvelocitychart.
Thewearrateincreasedwhenthesolidsintheslurrywereharderthanthe tubularsurface.Sandisslightlyharderthansteel.Bariteismuchlessabrasive thanhematite.
Thereisnoauthorityfortheerosionandwearratewhensolidssuchas sandandbariteareaddedtogasanddrillingmudinablowoutorawellcontrolsituation.Therecanbelittledoubtthatthesteelsareerodingundermost circumstances.APIRP14Emerelystatesthattheempiricalconstant, c, shouldbereducedifsandproductionisanticipated.
Solidsintheflowstreamcanbedisastrousforthewellcontrolsystem. OnecaseinpointoccurredattheApacheKey1–11inWheelerCounty, Texas.ManycalledtheblowoutattheKeythebiggestblowoutinthehistoryofthestateofTexas.Itwascertainlyoneofthemostbaffling,spectacular,andunpredictable.Withover90ftofMorrowsandandanopenflow potentialinexcessof90mmscfpd,theKeywasoneofthebestwellsever drilledintheAnadarkoBasin.On4Oct.1981,whilewaitingonpipeline connection,thewellinexplicablyerupted,launchingthewellhead,80ftof 27 8 in.tubing,80ftof75 8 in.casing,and12ftof103 4 in.surfacecasing.The wellflowedessentiallyunrestrictedintotheatmosphere.
TheKeywasroutinelycappedbytheendofOctober.However,3days later,thewellcratered.Alltheventlineswereopenedinanattemptto relievethepressure.Asillustratedin Fig.1.2,the45degreeturnswere cutoutcompletely.Inaddition,acloselookat Fig.1.2 showsthatthe 7 1 16 in.by10,000psivalvebodytotheventlinehadalsocutout.
Thecappingstackwasremoved,andthewellcontinuedtoflow,while subsequentwellcontroloperationswereconducted.Theparticulatefrom thewellhadadistinctivecolorandwasidentifiedascomingfromazone thatwasoriginallyseparatedfromtheflowstreambythetubingandtwo stringsofcasing.
AtanotherpointinthecontroloperationattheKey,a20in.by 10,000psistackwasbeingriggeduptocapthewell.Duetothesizeand weight,thestackhadtobeplacedontothewellinsections.Whilebringing thesecondsectionintoplace,thecrewnoticedthattheboltsinthefirstsectionwereloose.Thefirstsectionwasremovedandexamined.Asillustrated in Fig.1.3,thecasingheadwascutoutbeyondtheriggroove.Thissevere erosionhadtakenplaceinthetimerequiredtomakeuptheboltsonthe spoolandpickupthesecondsection,whichcouldhavebeennomorethan acoupleofhours.
Timeandagain,theflowfromtheKeydemonstrateditsdevastating nature.Whenthemomentumkillprocedurewasimplemented,several
jointsof51 2 in.casingwererunintothe75 8 in.casing.Therewasa10,000psi gatevalveontopofthe51 2 in.casing.Afterthemomentumkillwasaccomplished,thewellremaineddeadforabout1h,andthenflowcommenced again.Thevalvelastedonlyafewminutes.Theconnectionsofthe51 2 in. casinghadbeenerodedtotheextentthatthethreadsonthepinswerevisible throughtheboxes.Imagine!Allthatfromacasedhole!
Theinsideofalltheequipmentinthestackandtheflowlineshadtobe protectedwithaspecialstellitematerial.Towardtheendofthewellcontrol operations,anaverageof2000yd3 ofparticulatematerialwasbeingseparatedfromtheflowstreamandremovedeachmonth.
Fig.1.2
Wellsdonothavetobedeepandhigh-pressuredtodemonstrate suchfury.On12Mar.2000,awelllocatednearTabor,Alberta,Canada, gotoutofcontrol,despitebeingonly3500ftdeepandnormallypressured.Thevolumerateofflowwasestimatedtobebetween20and 40mmscfpd.
Within30minaftertheblowout,holesareerodedinthechokeline,fillingthemanifoldhousewithgas.Laterinspectionsrevealedseveralholesin thechokemanifold.Oneisshownin Fig.1.4.Within2h,thedrillingcross cutout(Fig.1.5).
(ReproducedwithpermissionfromConocoCanadaLimited.)
Fig.1.3
Fig.1.4
Whenthewellheadwasremovedseveraldayslater,itwaspaperthin (Fig.1.6).Afterthewellwaskilledbythereliefwell,thecasingatthesurface wasfoundtobeerodedandtoothintosupportacappingstack.
Formationsolidsaretheusualculpritsinproblemswitherosion.However,mudsolidsarealsoerosive.Baritewillerode,andhematiteiseven moreerosivethanbarite.
Fig.1.5 (ReproducedwithpermissionfromConocoCanadaLimited.)
Fig.1.6 (ReproducedwithpermissionfromConocoCanadaLimited.)
