UnitedNationsSustainable DevelopmentInitiatives1
I.INTRODUCTION
Sustainabledevelopmentiscurrentlythepredominantglobalmodelforprotectingthe environmentwhileensuringqualityoflifeforhumans.Effortstopromotesustainable developmentaretakingplaceprimarilywithintheUnitedNations(UN),atrulyinternationalgovernancebodycomprising193states.Whilenon-governmentalbodiescontinuetoproliferate,inaglobalsystembas edontheultimateauthorityofsovereign states,theauthorityandpowerremainswiththeUN.Historically,theUNhastakena leadroleinprotectingtheenvironment,startingfromitssponsorshipofthe1972 StockholmConferenceandtheninsubsequentglobalenvironmentalconferences.It hasdraftedandnegotiatedthevastmajorityofpost-1972internationalenvironmental conventions,aswellasasubstantialnumberofsoftlawinstrumentscomprisingtoday’ s globalenvironmentaltoolbox.
Yet,asdiscussedinthischapter,sustainabledevelopmentisdominatedbyanthropocentrism.Sustainabledevelopmentisforthebettermentofpeople.Nature’svalueis ratedbytheservicesitsuppliestohumans,ratherthanforitsowninherentworth.UN effortstomovebeyondsustainabledevelopmenttoanEarthlawparadigmhavebeen minimal,andUNpolicy,determinedbyitsmemberstates,continuestopromoteeconomicgrowthanddevelopment.UNinitia tivescurrentlyunderwayforpromoting Earthlawandrightsofnaturearetakingplacewithinthe “HarmonywithNature” initiative,promotingabiocentricapproachtoimplementingtheUNSustainableDevelopmentGoals,throughresolutionsoftheUNGeneralAssembly(UNGA),and hostingHarmonywithNaturedialoguesontherelationshipbetweenhumansand nature.2
Thischapterisdividedintotwomainparts.The fi rstexploresthebene fi tsand shortcomingsofUNsustainabledevelopmentinitiativesaswellasemergingprinciples inthe field,includingharmonywithnature.ThesecondpartexplorestheGlobalPact
1 AuthoredbyEarthLawCenter;YannAguila,apartneratBredinPrat(Paris)andchairoftheEnvironmental LawCommissionofthe ClubdesJuristes;andShehanaGomez,associatelecturerattheOpenUniversityandcoconveneroftheUKEnvironmentalLawAssociation’swildlawspecialinterestgroup.
2 UnitedNations, Chronology ,HarmonywithNature,http://www.harmonywithnatureun.org/chronology/ (lastvisitedMar.6,2020).
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
fortheEnvironment,aproposedinternati onaltreatythatwouldstrengthenstate dutiestoprotectnature.
II.OVERVIEWOFTHEUNITEDNATIONS
TheUNwasfoundedin1945intheaftermathofWorldWarII.Beyonditsgloballyrecognizedleadershipinissuesofpeace,security,andhumanrights,itsreachincludes activitiesthroughspecializedagenciesasdiverseastheWorldHealthOrganizationand theWorldBank.TheUnitedNationsEnvironmentalProgramme(UNEP)promotes andcoordinatestheUnitedNations’ environmentalinitiatives.
TheUNCharterestablishessixprincipalorgans:theGeneralAssembly,theSecurityCouncil,theEconomicandSocialCouncil,theTrusteeshipCouncil,theInternationalCourtofJustice,andtheSecretariat. 3 Ofthose,theEconomicandSocial Councilbearsprimaryresponsibilityforimplementingsustainabledevelopment. 4 TheGeneralAssemblycomprisesall193membernationsandisthemaindeliberative andpolicymakingorganoftheUnitedNations.5
NotableUN-relatedbodiesactiveinareasrelatedtoEarthlawareUNEP,the UnitedNationsDevelopmentProgram(UNDP),theIntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange(IPCC),theHigh-levelPoli ticalForumonSustainableDevelopment (High-levelPoliticalForumorHLPF),t heUNForumonForests,andtheUnited NationsProgramonHarmonywithNature,amongothers.
Earthlawmaybedevelopedbyforginganewsocialcontractthatinvolvesboth humansandnature.TheUnitedNationsisplayinganimportantroleinthedevelopmentofthiscontract,andthatroleisthesubjectofthischapter.
III.UNITEDNATIONSSUSTAINABILITYEFFORTS
Sustainabledevelopmentisthede fi ningparadigmofUNenvironmentalwork.The famousde fi nitiongivenbythe1987BrundtlandReportisthat “ sustainabledevelopmentmeetstheneedsofcurrentgenerationswithoutcompromisingtheabilityof futuregenerationstomeettheirneedsaswell.”6 Thissectionreviewstheoriginsofthat goalandUNprogresstoachieveitinchro nologicalorder,beg inningwiththe1972 StockholmConferencefortheHumanEnvironmentendingwiththe2019sessionof theHigh-levelPoliticalForum.
3 UNCharter,Art.8.
4 UnitedNations, AboutUs, UnitedNationsEconomicandSocialCouncil,https://www.un.org/ecosoc/en/ about-us(lastvisitedMar.6,2020).
5 UnitedNations, RoleoftheGeneralAssembly,UnitedNationsPeacekeeping,https://peacekeeping.un.org/en/ role-of-general-assembly(lastvisitedMar.6,2020).
6 WorldCommissiononEnvironmentandDevelopment, OurCommonFuture 37(WCED1987)[“theBrundtlandReport”].
Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
A.UnitedNationsConferenceontheHumanEnvironment, Stockholm1972
The1972UNConferenceontheHumanEnvironment(UNCHE),ortheStockholm Conference,wastheUN ’ s fi rstenvironmentalmegaconference.Itsoughttoaddress globalenvironmentalandconservationissues,focusingonescalatingindustrialpollutionanditsimpactontheenvironment.7
Becausetheconferencewastheinitiativeofthedevelopedworld,theUNCHE generateddeepsuspicionamongdevelopingcountries.ManyviewedtheStockholm Conferenceasaplotofdevelopedcountriestosolvetheenvironmentalproblemsthat theyhadcreatedbytheirhighstandardofl iving(dependentonravenousconsumptionofnaturalresources)bydenyingdeve lopingcountriesarighttodevelopand achievethesamestandardofliving.8 Thesuspicionwithwhichdevelopingcountries respondedtotheUNCHEwasalsorootedinthe fierceguardthattheyhadadopted againstperceivedthreatstotheirnationalsovereignty.9
Priortotheconference,asanoutletfortheincreasingtension,UNCHESecretaryGeneralMauriceStrongconvenedameetingonenvironmentanddevelopmentheld inFounex,Switzerland.Thissparkedthee arliestmajordiscussionsonsustainable development.Themeeting’soutcomedocument,theFounexReportonDevelopment andEnvironment,foundthattheenvironmentaldevastationofdevelopingcountries derivesfrompoverty,insharpcontrasttodevelopedcountries,whosepollutionderives fromtheexcessesofdevelopmentandwhocan “ afford ” conservation. 10 Addressing environmentalproblemsofdevelopingcountriesmeanteconomicdevelopment, whichdevelopedcountriesshouldhelpthemachieve.11
Addressingglobalneedswhilerecognizingtheuniquechallengesofdeveloping countriesbecameakeythemeoftheStockholmConference.Thekeyoutputwasthe StockholmDeclaration,whichcontains26principles “toinspireandguidethepeoples oftheworldinthepreservationandenhancementofthehumanenvironment.”12 Principle11epitomizedtheviewpointofmanydevelopingcountries: “Theenvironmental policiesofallStatesshouldenhanceandnotadverselyaffectthepresentorfuture developmentpotentialofdevelopingcoun tries,norshouldtheyhampertheattainmentofbetterlivingconditionsforall. ”
7 TheProblemsoftheHumanEnvironment,G.A.Res.2398(XXIII)(Dec.3,1968).
8 MARTIN HOLDGATE,THE GREEN WEB 111(1999).
9 SusanBragdon, NationalSovereigntyandGlobalEnvironmentalResponsibility:CantheTensionBeReconciledforthe ConventiononBiologicalDiversity?, 33HARVARD INT’ L L.J.381,383(1992).
10 See UnitedNations,DevelopmentandEnvironment(“FounexReport”),ReportofaPanelofExpertsconvenedbytheSecretary-GeneraloftheUNConferenceontheEnvironment,June4-12,1971.
11 See ReportSubmittedbyaPanelofExpertsConvenedbytheSecretary-GeneraloftheUNCHE, Maurice StrongPapers,40/395(June4-12,1971).
12 UnitedNationsConferenceontheHumanEnvironment, DeclarationoftheUnitedNationsConferenceonthe HumanEnvironment, UNDoc.A/CONF.48/14/Rev.1(June5-16,1972).
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
TheStockholmDeclarationisattimesunabashedlyanthropocentric.Considerthe followingexcerptfromthepreamble,whichisrootedinhumansuperiorityover nature:
Thenaturalgrowthofpopulationcontinuouslypresentsproblemsforthepreservation oftheenvironment,andadequatepoliciesandmeasuresshouldbeadopted,asappropriate,tofacetheseproblems. Ofallthingsintheworld,peoplearethemostprecious .Itis thepeoplethatpropelsocialprogress,createsocialwealth,developscienceandtechnologyand,throughtheirhardwork,continuo uslytransformthehumanenvironment. Alongwithsocialprogressandtheadvanceofproduction,scienceandtechnology, the capabilityofmantoimprovetheenvironmentincreaseswitheachpassingday 13
WhileStockholmDeclarationprinciplescallforenvironmentalprotections,they areoftentemperedwithhuman-centeredperspectivesandarighttopollute.Some oftheseincludePrinciple2(callingforsafeguardingto fl oraandfaunabutonly “for thebenefitofpresentandfuturegenerations”),Principle6(callingforahalttotoxic andotherdischargesbutonlywheretheyexceedtheassimilativecapacityoftheenvironment),andPrinciple21( “ Stateshave,inaccordancewiththeCharterofthe UnitedNationsandtheprinciplesofinternationallaw,thesovereignrighttoexploit theirownresourcespursuanttotheirownenvironmentalpolicies ”).
TheStockholmconferencealsoaffordedanopportunityfortheUNtopromote internationalenvironmentallaw.Threeinternationalbiodiversityagreementsreached the finalUNCHEagenda:the1971RamsarConventiononWetlandsofInternational Importance,andthedrafttextsofthefu ture1972WorldHeritageConventionand the1973ConventiononInternationalTr adeinEndangeredSpeciesofWildFauna andFlora(CITES).The1972ConventionforthePreventionofMarinePollutionby DumpingofWastesandOtherMatter(LondonConvention)wasalsoontheUNCHE’ s agenda.
TheUNCHE’semphasisoninternationalconventionswasrepeatedatalaterUN environmentalmegaconference:The 1992UNCEDRioSummit,whichopenedfor signingboththeConventiononBiologicalDiversity(CBD)andtheUNFramework ConventiononClimateChange(UNFCCC).TheCBDpromotesbiologicalconservationandsustainableusealongwithfairan dequitablesharingofgeneticresources. TheUNFCCCistheframeworkagreementforcombatingclimatechangeunderwhich the2015ParisAgreementwasnegotiatedandadopted.
B.WorldCharterforNature,1982
In1982,theUNGeneralAssemblyadoptedtheWorldCharterforNature,theworkof theInternationalUnionforConservationofNature(IUCN),theworld’slargestenvironmentalnetwork.InstarkcontrasttotheStockholmDeclaration,theWorldCharter forNatureadoptsanecocentricor “ deepsustainability ” viewandremainstheUN ’ s
13 Id.atpreamble.
Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
strongeststatementontheintegrityofnature.14 ThecharterdatesfromtheIUCN ’ s 1975TwelfthGeneralAssemblyinKinshasa,Zaire,wherePresidentMobutuofZaire raisedtheideawhilepointedlyblamingdevelopedcountriesforenvironmentalproblemsthatarisefromcolonialismandcapitalism:
Industrializedcountriesputtheblameonthosewhohavenotyetreachedthatstage,for notcontrollingthegrowthoftheirpopulations. Atthesametime,however,theyforget thattheirpopulations,althoughrepresentingone-thirdofmankind,consumeninetypercentoftheplanet’ sresources. We,whohavebeencolonized,weretaughtthatcivilizationofourformermasterswasthebestone. thecrisisisoneofcivilization. Thanks tozairianisation,wehavebecometheownersofourlands. IfIhadanyadviceforyou, IwouldsuggesttheestablishmentofaCharterofNature ::: insofarasZaireisconcerned, wearereadytohelpyousucceed. Thejungleofliberalcapitalismis finished.Everycitizeninthisworldmustdefendhisheritage,theareainwhichhelives,againstthosemodernsavages,thekillersofNaturewhodonothesitatetoslaughterhertoswelltheir wallets.”15
FollowingMobutu’sproposal,thesameIUCNGeneralAssemblyadoptedaresolutionrecommendingthatgovernmentspromoteaWorldCharterforNature.UNGeneralAssemblydeliberationsbeganshortlythereafter.16 WhilemanyAfricancountries weresupportiveoftheinitiativeinlightofZaire’sleadingrole,17 LatinAmericancountriesbelievedthecharterfavoredconservationoversocialandeconomicneeds.Asit haddoneindebatessurroundingtheStockholmConference,Brazilframedthedebate astheGlobalNorth’sexploitationoftheGlobalSouth’snaturalresources.However,in theend,thecharter’svisionofamoreharmoniousrelationshipwithnatureprevailed, andtheUNGeneralAssemblyadoptedthecharterbyavoteof111-1with18abstentions.TheUnitedStateswastheonly “ no ” vote.
TheChartercallsuponamoralcodeofconducttoguidehumanactioninaway thattreatsotherorganismswithrespect.Itwasperhapsthe firstofficialUNdocument tousetheconceptof “ harmonywithnature ” initspreamble.Thefollowingarekey excerptsfromtheCharter.
WorldCharterforNature
UNGARES37/7
TheGeneralAssembly, ReaffirmingthefundamentalpurposesoftheUnitedNations
14 1982WorldCharterforNature,G.A.Res.37/7(Oct.28,1982).
15 IUCNG.A.,12thSess.,Conf.3at217-222,SupplementaryPaperNo44-E(Sept.8-18,1975).
16 Perucautionedthat “theuseandexploitationofallnaturalresourcesofeachcountryconstitutearight inherentinthesovereigntyofeachstate,emphasizingsocio-economicdevelopment. ” Id. at25.Also, Argentinawarnedthat “theprincipleofsovereigntyofStates isatstake.” Id. at19,29,34.
17 Thecharterhadreceivedsigni fi cantsupportfromAfricannations;insubmittingthedraftcharterZaire represented31Africancountries. Id.
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
Awarethat:
(a)Mankindisapartofnatureandlifedependsontheuninterruptedfunctioningof naturalsystemswhichensurethesupplyofenergyandnutrients,
(b)Civilizationisrootedinnature,whichhasshapedhumancultureandinfluencedall artisticandscienti fi cachievements,andlivinginharmonywithnaturegivesmanthe bestopportunitiesforthedevelopmentofhiscreativity,andforrestandrecreation,
Convincedthat:
(a)Everyformoflifeisunique,warrantingrespectregardlessofitsworthtoman,and,to accordotherorganismssuchrecognitio n,manmustbeguidedbyamoralcodeof action.
Persuadedthat:
(a)Lastingbenefitsfromnaturedependuponthemaintenanceofessentialecological processesandlifesupportsystems,anduponthediversityoflifeforms,whicharejeopardizedthroughexcessiveexploitationandhabitatdestructionbyman,
(b)Thedegradationofnaturalsystemsowingtoexcessiveconsumptionandmisuseof naturalresources,aswellastofailureto establishanappropriateeconomicorder amongpeoplesandamongStates,leadstothebreakdownoftheeconomic,socialand politicalframeworkofcivilization.
Adopts,totheseends,thepresentWorldCharterforNature,whichproclaimsthefollowingprinciplesofconservationbywhichallhumanconductaffectingnatureistobe guidedandjudged.
I.GeneralPrinciples
1.Natureshallberespectedanditsessentialprocessesshallnotbeimpaired.
2.Thegeneticviabilityontheearthshallnotbecompromised;thepopulationlevelsof alllifeforms,wildanddomesticated,mustbeatleastsufficientfortheirsurvival,andto thisendnecessaryhabitatshallbesafeguarded.
3.Allareasoftheearth,bothlandandsea,shallbesubjecttotheseprinciplesofconservation;specialprotectionshallbegiventouniqueareas,torepresentativesamplesofall thedifferenttypesofecosystemsandtothehabitatofrareorendangeredspecies.
4.Ecosystemsandorganisms,aswellastheland,marineandatmosphericresourcesthat areutilizedbyman,shallbemanagedtoachieveandmaintainoptimumsustainableproductivity,butnotinsuchawayastoendangertheintegrityofthoseotherecosystemsor specieswithwhichtheycoexist.
II.Functions
6.Inthedecision-makingprocessitshallberecognizedthatman ’ sneedscanbemet onlybyensuringtheproperfunctioningofnaturalsystemsandbyrespectingtheprinciplessetforthinthepresentCharter. :::
III.Implementation
14.TheprinciplessetforthinthepresentChartershallbereflectedinthelawandpracticeofeachState,aswellasattheinternationallevel.
21.Statesand,totheextenttheyareable,otherpublicauthorities,internationalorganizations,individuals,groupsandcorporationsshall:
(d)Ensurethatactivitieswithintheirjurisdictionsorcontroldonotcausedamagetothe naturalsystemslocatedwithinotherStatesorintheareasbeyondthelimitsofnational jurisdiction;
(e)Safeguardandconservenatureinareasbeyondnationaljurisdiction.
22.TakingfullyintoaccountthesovereigntyofStatesovertheirnaturalresources,each Stateshallgiveeffecttotheprovisionso fthepresentCharterthroughitscompetent organsandinco-operationwithotherStates.
Whilethe1982WorldCharterforNaturedeclaredthat “Natureshallberespectedand itsessentialprocessesshallnotbeimpaired, ” the1987BrundtlandReport,which launchedthecurrentglobalmodelofsustai nabledevelopment,largelycontradicts theseprinciplesbyemphasizingdevelopm entoverprotectionoftheenvironment. Wereadaboutthisnext.
C.BrundtlandReport,1987
The1987ReportoftheWorldCommissiononEnvironmentandDevelopment:Our CommonFuture,alsocalledtheBrundtlandReport,wasanattempttoreconcilethe objectivesofeconomicdevelopmentandprotectionoftheenvironment.Thereport arguedthatsustainabledevelopmentcouldbeachievedthroughthe “ threepillars ” : economicgrowth,socialequality,andenvironmentalsustainability.Italsofocusedon
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
theneedtoeradicatepovertyasafundamentalrequirementofsustainabledevelopment.Whilethiswasnotthe fi rsttimetheterm “sustainabledevelopment” hadbeen used,thetermenteredthegloballexiconasaresultofthisreport.
Thechairpersonofthecommission,Pr imeMinisterGroHarlemBrundtlandof Norway,candidlyacknowledgedthetensionofsustainabledevelopment.Thesewere, amongothers,tensionsbetweenrichnationsandpoornations,betweenglobalgovernanceandnationalsovereignty,between economicdevelopmentandenvironment, andbetweeneconomicgrowthandequity. Ms.Brundtlanddescribedtheapproach takenbythecommissioninresolvingthiscon flictasfollows:
WhenthetermsofreferenceofourCommissionwereoriginallybeingdiscussedin 1982,therewerethosewhowanteditsconsiderationstobelimitedto “environmental issues” only.Thiswouldhavebeenagravemistake.Theenvironmentdoesnotexistas asphereseparatefromhumanactions,ambitions,andneeds,andattemptstodefend itinisolationfromhumanconcernshavegiventheveryword “environment” aconnotationofnaivetyinsomepoliticalcircles.Theword “ development ” hasalsobeennarrowedbysomeintoaverylimitedfocus,alongthelinesof “whatpoornationsshould dotobecomericher”
Butthe “ environment ” iswherewealllive;and “ development ” iswhatwealldoin attemptingtoimproveourlotwithinthatabode.Thetwoareinseparable. Further, developmentissuesmustbeseenascrucialbythepoliticalleaderswhofeelthattheir countrieshavereachedaplateautowardswhichothernationsmuststrive.Manyofthe developmentpathsoftheindustrializednationsareclearlyunsustainable.Andthe developmentdecisionsofthesecountries,becauseoftheirgreateconomicandpolitical power,willhaveaprofoundeffectupontheabilityofallpeoplestosustainhumanprogressforgenerationstocome. ::: 18
Thus,fromthebeginning,sustainabledevelopmenthasbeenacompromise betweenthosewhowanttoprivilegetheenvironmentandthosewhowanttoprivilege economicdevelopment.Economicdevelo pmentwouldbeprimary,andsocialand environmentalconcernswouldconditiondevelopment.AswithmanyoftheenvironmentallawscritiquedinChapter1, “ModernEnvironmentalLaw,” sustainabledevelopmentwasbornfromanundeniablyanthropocentricandeconomy-focusedparadigm. Thismodellargelypersiststoday.
D.UnitedNationsConferenceonEnvironmentandDevelopment, RiodeJaneiro,1992
The1992EarthSummit(alsoknownastheRioConference)wasawatershedmoment ininternationalenvironmentallaw.Inattendancewere172governments,including 108headsofstate,aswellashugenumbersofcivilsocietygroups.19 Buildingonthe BrundtlandReport,theEarthSummitsetforthacomprehensiveagenda over300pages
18 TheBrundtlandReport, supra note6.
19 UnitedNations, OutcomesonSustainableDevelopment ,https://www.un.org/en/development/devagenda/ sustainable.shtml(lastvisitedMar.11,2020).
Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
long forsustainabledevelopmentcalledAgenda21:ProgrammeofActionforSustainableDevelopment(Agenda21).20 Theconference’sshortoutcomedocumentwascalled theRioDeclaration.
WhiletheRioDeclarationemphasizesth eneedtoprotectnature,Principle1 makesclearthathumaninterestsareparamount: “Humanbeingsareatthecentreof concernsforsustainabledevelopment.Theyareentitledtoahealthyandproductive lifeinharmonywithnature.” Thedeclarationgoesontohighlightcommonenvironmentalconceptssuchastheprecautionaryprinciple(Principle15),thepolluterpays principle(Principle16),andtheneedforenvironmentalimpactstatements(Principle 17),amongothers.Oneotherprinciplethathasgainedsignificanttractioninrecent yearsisPrinciple10onenvironmentalaccessrights:accesstoinformation,accessto publicparticipation,andaccesstojustice,askeypillarsofsoundenvironmentalgovernance.Thisprincipleisthebasisoftwosubsequenttreaties:the1998AarhusConventioninEurope21 andthe2018EscazúAgreementinLatinAmerica.22
BeyondAgenda21andtheRioDeclaration,theEarthSummitproducedthe ForestPrinciples,anonbindingdocumentontheconservationandsustainableuseof forests.23 Further,theUNFCCCandtheCBDwerebothopenedforsignature.Finally, basedonarecommendationcontainedinAgenda21,theUNCommissiononSustainableDevelopmentwasestablishedshortlyaftertheconference.ItledtheUN’ssustainabledevelopmenteffortsuntilitwasrep lacedbytheHigh-levelPoliticalForum in2013.
E.MillenniumSummitandtheMillenniumDevelopmentGoals2000
TheSeptember2000UNMillenniumSummitwasheldinNewYorkoverathree-day periodattheUNheadquartersinNewYork.Attendedby149headsofstateand high-rankingof fi cials,itsprimarypurposewasashowofstrengthfortheUnited Nationsatthestartofthe21stcentury.ThekeyoutputoftheSummitwastheMillenniumDeclaration,adoptedbytheUNGeneralAssemblythreedayslater.24 Whilethis declarationmostlyrelatestoeconomicandhumandevelopment,italsoaddressesenvironmentalconcerns.SectionI, “Valuesandprinciples” opensasfollows:
1.We,headsofStateandGovernment,havegatheredatUnitedNationsHeadquarters inNewYorkfrom6to8September2000,atthedawnofanewmillennium,toreaffirm
20 UnitedNationsConferenceonEnvironmentandDevelopment, Agenda21:EarthSummit TheUnited NationsProgrammeofActionfromRio, 9,UNDocA/CONF.151/26/Rev.1(Vol.I)(June3-14,1992).
21 AarhusConventionofJune25,1998,2161U.N.T.S.447.Formallythe “UNECEConventiononAccessto Information,PublicParticipationinDecision-makingandAccesstoJusticeinEnvironmentalMatters.”
22 EscazúAgreementC.N.195.2018.TREATIES-XXVII.18of9April2018.Formallythe “RegionalAgreement onAccesstoInformation,PublicParticipationandJusticeinEnvironmentalMattersinLatinAmericaand theCaribbean.”
23 UnitedNationsConferenceonEnvironmentandDevelopment. Non-LegallyBindingAuthoritativeStatementof PrinciplesforaGlobalConsensusontheManagement,ConservationandSustainableDevelopmentofAllTypesofForests, A/CONF.151/26(Vol.III)480(June3-14,1992).
24 UnitedNationsMillenniumDeclaration,G.A.Res.55/2(Sept.8,2000).
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
ourfaithintheOrganizationanditsCharterasindispensablefoundationsofamore peaceful,prosperousandjustworld.
:::
IV.Protectingourcommonenvironment.
21.Wemustsparenoefforttofreeallofhumanity,andaboveallourchildrenand grandchildren,fromthethreatoflivingonaplanetirredeemablyspoiltbyhumanactivities,andwhoseresourceswouldnolongerbesufficientfortheirneeds.
22.Wereaf fi rmoursupportfortheprinciplesofsustainabledevelopment,including thosesetoutinAgenda21,agreeduponattheUnitedNationsConferenceonEnvironmentandDevelopment.
23.Weresolvethereforetoadoptinallourenvironmentalactionsanewethicofconservationandstewardshipand,as firststeps,weresolve:
• Tointensifyourcollectiveeffortsforthemanagement,conservationandsustainable developmentofalltypesofforests.
• TopressforthefullimplementationoftheConventiononBiologicalDiversityand theConventiontoCombatDeserti fi cationinthoseCountriesExperiencingSerious Droughtand/orDesertification,particularlyinAfrica.
• Tostoptheunsustainableexploitationofwaterresourcesbydevelopingwater managementstrategiesattheregional,nationalandlocallevels,whichpromoteboth equitableaccessandadequatesupplies.
DrawingontheMillenniumDec laration,theworldleaderswhoparticipatedinthe SummitadoptedtheMillenniumDevelopmentGoals(MDGs).Eightgoalsweretobe reachedbytheyear2015:
(1)eradicateextremepovertyandhunger;
(2)achieveuniversalprimaryeducation;
(3)promotegenderequalityandempowerwomen;
(4)reducechildmortality;
(5)improvematernalhealth;
(6)combatHIV/AIDS,malariaandotherdiseases;
(7)ensureenvironmentalsustainability;and
(8)developaglobalpartnershipfordevelopment.
In2002,theSecretary-GeneraloftheUNandtheadministratoroftheUNDevelopmentprogramlaunchedtheMillenniumProjecttosupporttheMDGsinmeetingtheir targetdateof2015.Beginningin2012,theUNbeganaprocesstodevelopthePost2015Agenda.ThiseffortledtotheSDGs,or,sustainabledevelopmentgoals,adopted in2015,whichsupplantedtheMDGsandplacedagreateremphasisontheenvironment(see subsectionI).
Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
F.TheEarthCharter(2000)
In2000,theUnitedNationsEducational,Scienti fi candCulturalOrganization (UNESCO)adoptedtheEarthCharter25 atitsheadquartersinParis.TheEarthCharteris “ anethicalframeworkforbuildingajust,sustainable,andpeacefulglobal societyinthe21stcentury. ::: ” 26 TheEarthCharterrejectsanthropocentrisminits goal “ toinspireinallpeopleanewsenseofg lobalinterdependenceandshared responsibilityforthewell-beingofthewh olehumanfamily,thegreatercommunity oflife,andfuturegenerations.” 27 Whilenotanof fi cialUNdocument,itisregarded asanimportantstatementofenvironmen talvaluesbyUNESCOandhassincebeen endorsedbythousandsoforganizationsrepresentingmillionsofpeople. 28 Asyouread thefollowingEarthCharterprinciples,considerhowtheydifferfromthesustainable developmentmandateofAgenda21,theMDGs,andsoforth:
TheEarthCharter
PRINCIPLES
I.RESPECTANDCAREFORTHECOMMUNITYOFLIFE
1.RespectEarthandlifeinallitsdiversity.
a.Recognizethatallbeingsareinterdependentandeveryformoflife hasvalueregardlessofitsworthtohumanbeings.
b.Affirmfaithintheinherentdignityofallhumanbeingsandinthe intellectual,artistic,ethical,andspiritualpotentialofhumanity.
4.SecureEarth’sbountyandbeautyforpresentandfuturegenerations.
a.Recognizethatthefreedomofactionofeachgenerationisqualifiedbytheneedsoffuturegenerations.
b.Transmittofuturegenerationsvalues,traditions,andinstitutions thatsupportthelong-term flourishingofEarth’shumanandecologicalcommunities.
25 EarthCharterCommission, TheEarthCharter (2000),https://earthcharter.org/discover/the-earth-charter/ (lastvisitedMar.6,2020).
26 Id.
27 EarthCharter, TheEarthCharterGlobalMovement,https://earthcharter.org/act(lastvisitedMar.11,2020).
28 EarthCharter, HistoryoftheEarthCharter,https://earthcharter.org/discover/history-of-the-earth-charter (lastvisitedMar.14,2020).
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
7.Adoptpatternsofproduction,consumption,andreproductionthatsafeguard Earth’sregenerativecapacities,humanrights,andcommunitywell-being.
a.Reduce,reuse,andrecyclethematerialsusedinproductionand consumptionsystems,andensure thatresidualwastecanbeassimilatedbyecologicalsystems.
b.Actwithrestraintandef fi ciencywhenusingenergy,andrely increasinglyonrenewableenergysourcessuchassolarandwind.
c.Promotethedevelopment,adoption,andequitabletransferof environmentallysoundtechnologies.
d.Internalizethefullenvironmentalandsocialcostsofgoodsand servicesinthesellingprice,andenableconsumerstoidentifyproductsthatmeetthehighestsocialandenvironmentalstandards.
e.Ensureuniversalaccesstohealthcarethatfostersreproductive healthandresponsiblereproduction.
f.Adoptlifestylesthatemphasizethequalityoflifeandmaterialsufficiencyina finiteworld.
III.SOCIALANDECONOMICJUSTICE
9.Eradicatepovertyasanethical,social,andenvironmentalimperative.
a.Guaranteetherighttopotablewater,cleanair,foodsecurity, uncontaminatedsoil,shelter,andsafesanitation,allocatingthe nationalandinternationalresourcesrequired.
b.Empowereveryhumanbeingwiththeeducationandresourcesto secureasustainablelivelihood,andprovidesocialsecurityandsafety netsforthosewhoareunabletosupportthemselves.
c.Recognizetheignored,protectthevulnerable,servethosewhosuffer,andenablethemtodeveloptheircapacitiesandtopursuetheir aspirations.
IV.DEMOCRACY,NONVIOLENCE,ANDPEACE
14.Integrateintoformaleducationandlife-longlearningtheknowledge,values,andskillsneededforasustainablewayoflife.
a.Provideall,especiallychildrenand youth,witheducationalopportunitiesthatempowerthemtocontributeactivelytosustainabledevelopment.
Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
b.Promotethecontributionoftheartsandhumanitiesaswellasthe sciencesinsustainabilityeducation.
c.Enhancetheroleofthemassmediainraisingawarenessofecologicalandsocialchallenges.
d.Recognizetheimportanceofmoralandspiritualeducationforsustainableliving.
15.Treatalllivingbeingswithrespectandconsideration.
a.Preventcrueltytoanimalskeptinhumansocietiesandprotect themfromsuffering.
b.Protectwildanimalsfrommethodsofhunting,trapping,and fishingthatcauseextreme,prolonged,oravoidablesuffering.
c.Avoidoreliminatetothefullextentpossiblethetakingordestructionofnon-targetedspecies.
G.WorldSummitonSustainableDevelopment,Johannesburg,2002
The2002WorldSummitonSustainableDevelopment(WSSD)inJohannesburgwas thethirdUNmegaconferenceontheenvir onment.Inthetenyearsfollowingthe RioSummit,theglobalenvironmentalcrisishadworsened,andtheimplementation oftheRioDeclarationandAgenda21weredeemedtobeinadequate.Thesummit’ s plannersdecidedtoreinvigoratetheirsu stainabledevelopmentcommitmentwitha focuson fivepriorities:waterandsanitation,energy,health,agriculture,andbiodiversity.ThesummitadoptedtheJohannesburgDeclarationonHumanDevelopment,a generalstatementofpoliticalcommitmenttosustainabledevelopment,andtheJohannesburgPlanofImplementation,whichincludedaspeci fictimetabletoachievetheir goals.29 Unliketheprevioustwomegaconferences,noinitiativesweretakenfornegotiatingnewenvironmentalconventions.30
Despitetheseagreements,thesummitwasconsideredbymanytobeasetbackon environmentalissues.Forexample,theimplementationplanadoptedatthesummit wascriticizedbytheHeinrichBöllFoundation “fornothavingrealnewcommitments, targetsandfundingforimplementationprovided. ” Criticsalsoarguedthatthesummit continuedtopromoteunfetteredeconomic growthasthemainstrategytoalleviate povertyinsteadofadvancingneweconomicmodelsthatbettersupportsustainability.31
29 WorldSummitonSustainableDevelopment, JohannesburgDeclarationon SustainableDevelopment , A/CONF.199/20,(September4,2002),http://www.un-documents.net/jburgdec.htm.
30 D AVID H UNTER ,J AMES E.S ALTZMAN ,&D URWOOD Z AELKE ,I NTERNATIONAL E NVIRONMENTAL L AW &P OLICY 181 (2015).
31 See,e.g. , “ WhatAretheOutcomesoftheWorldSummit? ” (2002),http://www.worldsummit2002.org/ (accessedJune10,2012).
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
Againstthisbackdrop,somecountriesbegantocallfornewinternationalframeworksthatwouldbetterprotecttheenvir onment,includingtheUNHarmonywith NatureInitiative,asdiscussednext.
H.TheUNHarmonywithNatureInitiative
Alongsideitsagendaforsustainabledevelopment,theUNhasalsotakenstepstobuild awarenessofEarthlawconcepts.In2009,theUNGAapprovedaresolutionproclaimingApril22asInternationalMotherEarthDay.Thefollowingexcerptsarefromthe statementofthenPresidentofBoliviaEvoMoralestotheGeneralAssemblyonliving inharmonywithnature:
UNGeneralAssembly
80thplenarymeeting,Wednesday,22April2009
StatementofPresidentEvoMorales,Bolivia
Werecallthat,inpastcenturies,therewasacontinuousstruggleforhumanrights. [W]ithtoday’sdeclarationofInternationalMotherEarthDay,planetEarth,MotherEarth, hasalsowonherrights.Andthisnewcentury,thetwenty-first,shouldbethecenturyof MotherEarth’srights.[:::]Ifwearetoliveinharmonywithnature,weneedtorecognize thatnotonlywehumanbeingshaverights,butthattheplanetdoesaswell.Animals,plants andalllivingbeingshaverightsthatwemustrespect.WhatishappeningtousnowwithclimatechangeisthedirectresultofnotrespectingtherightsofMotherEarth.
TheUnitedNationsmustensurethattherightsofMotherEarthandofalllivingbeings arerespected. Manypeople,inparticularcertainlawyers forgivemeforsayingso willsaythatonlyhumanbeingshaverights.Inourview,itisdifficulttoacceptthat.[:::] AnotherimportantthingthatIwouldliketopointoutistheimportanceofcoexisting withnature,becausehumanlifeisnotpossiblewithoutMotherEarth.[ ]InBolivia, inparticularamongthelocalIndigenouspeoplesthatIamfamiliarwith,MotherEarth issacredtolife.Thatiswhyweundertakesacredritualsoftributetoourrivers,forests, lakesandanimalsandhavemanytunestoexpressourrespectforMotherEarth.[:::] Iwouldliketoproposefourrightsofgreatimportancetohumankind.
• Firstistherighttolife.[:::]WehumanbeingsmustrecognizethatMotherEarthand alllivingbeingshavearighttoexistandthatourrightsendwhenwesetofftheextinctionoreliminationofnature.
• Secondistherightofregenerationfortheplanet’sbiocapacity.[ ]Humanactivity ontheplanetanditsresourcescannotbeunlimited.Developmentcannotbeinfinite. [:::]
• Thirdistherighttoacleanlife.ThatmeanstherightofMotherEarthtolivewithout pollution.
• Fourthistherighttoharmonyandbalancewithandamongallandeverything.
Untilnow,humanbeingshavebeenprisonersofdevelopmentcapitalism,which statesthatmanisthesoleowneroftheplanet.NowitistimetorecognizethattheEarth
Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
doesnotbelongtous.Itistheotherwayaround:webelongtotheEarth,anditisour missionintheworldtowatchovertherights,notonlyofhumanbeings,butofMother Earthandofalllivingbeings.
***
Laterthatyear,inDecember2009,theUNGeneralAssemblyadoptedits firstresolutiononHarmonywithNature:
ResolutionadoptedbytheGeneralAssemblyon21December2009 64/196.HarmonywithNature
TheGeneralAssembly,Expressingitsconc ernoverthedocumentedenvironmental degradationandthenegativeimpactonnatureresultingfromhumanactivity,Recalling the1982WorldCharterforNature,Reaf fi rmingtheRioDeclarationonEnvironment andDevelopment,Reaf fi rmingalsoAgenda21 theJohannesburgDeclarationon SustainableDevelopmentandthePlanofImplementationoftheWorldSummitonSustainableDevelopment
Convincedthathumanitycanandshouldliveinharmonywithnature,
1.InvitesMemberStates,therelevantorganizationsoftheUnitedNationssystem,andinternational,regionalandsubregionalorganizationstoconsider, asappropriate,theissueofpromotinglifeinharmonywithnatureandto transmittotheSecretary-Generaltheirviews,experiencesandproposals onthisissue;
3.Decidestoincludeintheprovisionalagendaofitssixty- fifthsessionasubitementitled “HarmonywithNature”,undertheitementitled “Sustainable development” . ::: 32
***
UniversalDeclarationoftheRightsofMotherEarth
JustoneyearafterPresidentMoralesmadehisimpassionedspeechforprotecting MotherEarthtotheUNGeneralAssembly,inApril2010,Boliviaheldthe firstWorld People ’ sConferenceonClimateChangeandtheRightsofMotherEarthin Cochabamba.Thisgatheringincluded over35,000peoplerepresenting140 countries civilsocietyleaders,56governmentaldelegations,Indigenouspeoples,climateactivists,andothers allofwhomsoughtboldcollectiveactionafterthefailures
32 See fullresolutionathttps://undocs.org/A/RES/64/196.
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
ofthe2009ClimateChangeConferenceinCopenhagen(COP15).AmongtheinitiativespresentedattheWorldPeople ’sConferencewasaUniversalDeclarationforthe RightsofMotherEarth(UDRME),whichcalledfortheUNandallcountriestorecognizetherightsofnature.
TheUDRMEassertsthattherightsofnaturearisefromitsveryexistenceonthe planet.Itspreamblerecognizesthe “criticalimportanceandurgencyoftakingdecisive, collectiveactiontopreventhumanscau singclimatechangeandotherimpactson MotherEarththatthreatenthewellbeingandsurvivalofhumansandotherbeings.” ItthengoesontodescribethespecificrightsheldbyMotherEarth.Someoftherecognizedrightsincludetherighttolifeandtoexist(Art.2(1)(a),therighttoberespected (Art.2(1)(b)),therighttointegralheal th(Art.2(1)(g),andtherighttofulland promptrestorationforviolationoftherightsrecognized(Art.2(1)(j)).
ApetitionfortheUNtoadopttheUniversalDeclarationoftheRightsofMother Earthhasgainedalmost300,000signatures.Italsocontinuestoguiderightsofnature developmentsworldwide.
BuildingfromInternationalMoth erEarthDay,theUNbeganhosting “ interactivedialogues ” thatbroughttogetherglobalexper tsonharmonywithnature,includingmanyEarthlawpractitioners.The fi rstdialogue,inDecember2010,convenedto supporttheUNConferenceon SustainableDevelopmentin Brazil(2012)byprovidingguidanceonbestpracticestopromotea holisticapproachtosustainabledevelopmentinharmonywithnature,aswellascriteriaandindicatorstomeasure progress.
33
Sincethen,aninteractivedialoguehasoccurredannuallyonMotherEarthDay. EachdialogueisprecededbyareportoftheSecretary-GeneralonHarmonywith NatureandthenfollowedbyaResolutiononHarmonywithNaturethatisadopted bytheUNGeneralAssembly.Allofthisworkisinformedbyabodyofexperts,called KnowledgeNetworkExperts,whokeeptheUNapprisedofglobaldevelopmentsonlivinginharmonywithnature.Theseinteract ivedialogues,reports,andresolutions, alongwiththeKnowledgeNetworkExperts,serveasthefoundationoftheHarmony withNatureInitiativeattheUnitedNations.
UnlikemostUNprograms,theHarmonywithNatureInitiativeacknowledgesecocentriclegalmovementsworldwideandbui ldsknowledgeandcapacityaroundtheir growth.Considerhowthe2011resolutiononHarmonywithNaturetiesinUNsustainabilityworktoEarthlawprinciplesyouhavereadaboutinthisbook:
33 UNDocA/RES/65/164(Dec.2010).
Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
ResolutionadoptedbytheGeneralAssemblyon22December2011 66/204.HarmonywithNature
TheGeneralAssembly,
Expressingconcernaboutdocumentedenvi ronmentaldegradationandthenegative impactonnatureresultingfromhumanactivity,andrecognizingtheneedtostrengthen scienti ficknowledgeontheeffectsofhumanactivitiesonecosystems,
Recognizingthatgrossdomesticproductwasnotdesignedasanindicatorformeasuring environmentaldegradationresultingfromhumanactivityandtheneedtoovercome thislimitationwithregardtosustainabledevelopmentandtheworkcarriedoutinthis regard,
Reaf fi rmingthatfundamentalchangesinthewaysocietiesproduceandconsumeare indispensableforachievingglobalsusta inabledevelopmentandthatallcountries shouldpromotesustainableconsumptionandproductionpatterns,withthedeveloped countriestakingtheleadandwithallcountriesbenefitingfromtheprocess,takinginto accounttheRioprinciples,includingthe principleofcommonbutdifferentiated responsibilities,assetoutinprinciple7o ftheRioDeclarationonEnvironmentand Development,
RecognizingthatmanyancientcivilizationsandIndigenouscultureshavearichhistory ofunderstandingthesymbioticconnectionbetweenhumanbeingsandnaturethatfostersamutuallybeneficialrelationship,
6.EncouragesallcountriesandtherelevantbodiesoftheUnitedNationssystemto developandstrengthenthequalityandquantityofbasicstatisticaldataonthethree pillarsofsustainabledevelopment,andinvitestheinternationalcommunityandthe pertinentbodiesoftheUnitedNationssystemtoassisttheeffortsofdevelopingcountriesbyprovidingcapacity-buildingandtechnicalsupport;
7.InvitestherelevantentitiesoftheUnitedNationssystemtoworkwithotherrelevant actors,includingnon-governmentalorganizations,expertsandtheacademiccommunity,asappropriate,bothtoidentifynewwaysandmeanstoovercomethelimitationsofgrossdomesticproductwithregardtosustainabledevelopmentandtobetter measuretheenvironmentaldegradationresultingfromhumanactivity;34
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
The2012ResolutiononHarmonywithNaturegoesevenfurtherbyacknowledging, althoughnotexplicitlyendorsing,theglobalmovementfortherightsofnature:
ResolutionadoptedbytheGeneralAssemblyon21December2012 67/214.HarmonywithNature
TheGeneralAssembly,
4.WelcomesthelaunchingoftheHarmonywithNaturewebsiteontheoccasionofthe UnitedNationsConferenceonSustainableDevelopment
5.RecognizesthatplanetEarthand itsecosystemsareourhomeandthat “ Mother Earth ” isacommonexpressioninanumberofc ountriesandregions,andthatsome countriesrecognizetherightsofnatureinthecontextofthepromotionofsustainable development,andisconvincedthat,inordertoachieveajustbalanceamongtheeconomic,socialandenvironmentalneedsofpresentandfuturegenerations,itisnecessary topromoteharmonywithnature;
6.Callsforholisticandintegratedapproa chestosustainabledevelopmentthatwill guidehumanitytoliveinharmonywithnatureandleadtoeffortstorestorethehealth andintegrityoftheEarth’secosystems;
12.Recognizestheneedforbroadermeasuresofprogresstocomplementgrossdomestic productinordertobetterinformpolicydecisions,andinthisregardnotestheongoing workoftheStatisticalCommissiononaworkprogrammetodevelopbroadermeasures ofprogressandtoconductatechnicalreviewofexistingeffortsinthisarea;35 :::
Insum,theUNHarmonywithNatureInitiativeattemptstodirectglobalsustainabilityeffortstowardsnewparadigmsoflawandculturethatwouldallowhumansto liveinharmonywithnature.ThisprogramservesasanimperativelinkbetweenUN sustainabilityworkandEarthlaw.
Continuinginchronologicalorder,wenowturnbacktotheUN ’ smoreconventionalsustainabledevelopmentwork,pickingupatthenextUNmegaconferenceon sustainabledevelopment:Rio+20.
I.UnitedNationsConferenceonSustainableDevelopment(Rio+20) RiodeJaneiro,2012
TheUnitedNationsConferenceonSustai nableDevelopment(UNCSD),orRio+20, wasthethirdmegaconferenceonsustainabledevelopment.Aswiththepreviousconferences,itsgoalwastobalanceglobaleconomicandenvironmentalgoals.The
35 G.A.Res.67/214,at3(Dec.21,2012).
Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
outcomedocumentofRio+20,entitledTheFutureWeWant,setsoutnewmeasuresto implementsustainabledevelo pment.Importantly,itcalledforSustainableDevelopmentGoals(SDGs)thatwouldbuildfromt heexistingMDGstoimplementapost2015developmentagenda.ConsiderthefollowingexcerptfromTheFutureWeWant thatlargelyreaf fi rmsthesustainabledevelopmentmandatethathasprevailedsince theStockholmConferencein1972:
1.We,theHeadsofStateandGovernmentandhigh-levelrepresentatives,havingmetat RiodeJaneiro,Brazil,from20to22June2012,withthefullparticipationofcivilsociety, renewourcommitmenttosustainabledevelopmentandtoensuringthepromotionof aneconomically,sociallyandenvironmentallysustainablefutureforourplanetand forpresentandfuturegenerations.
2.Eradicatingpovertyisthegreatestglobalchallengefacingtheworldtodayandan indispensablerequirementforsustainabledevelopment.Inthisregardwearecommittedtofreeinghumanityfrompovertyandhungerasamatterofurgency.
3.Wethereforeacknowledgetheneedtofurthermainstreamsustainabledevelopment atalllevels,integratingeconomic,social andenvironmentalaspectsandrecognizing theirinterlinkages,soastoachievesustainabledevelopmentinallitsdimensions.
Despiteitsemphasisonexistingcommitm entsratherthanforgingnewones,the FutureWeWantdidpayhomagetoharmonywithnature:
39.WerecognizethatplanetEarthanditsecosystemsareourhomeandthat “Mother Earth” isacommonexpressioninanumberofcountriesandregions,andwenotethat somecountriesrecognizetherightsofnatureinthecontextofthepromotionofsustainabledevelopment.Weareconvincedthatinordertoachieveajustbalanceamongthe economic,socialandenvironmentalneedsofpresentandfuturegenerations,itisnecessarytopromoteharmonywithnature.Wecallforholisticandintegratedapproachesto sustainabledevelopmentthatwillguidehumanitytoliveinharmonywithnatureand leadtoeffortstorestorethehealthandintegrityoftheEarth’secosystem.
1.Peoples’ sustainabilitytreaties
Rio+20wasconsideredahighlyinclusivemegaconference,with44,000badgesissued forof ficialmeetings,mostofthosegoingtomembersofcivilsociety.However,many civilsocietygroupswereconcernedthats tateactorsinRiowereadvancingaweak internationalagendaonsustainabledevelopment.Toprovideastrongervisionofsustainability,aconsultativeprocesswithhundredsofcivilsocietyorganizationsresulted infourteen “Peoples’ SustainabilityTreaties” thatsetaboldagendaforachievingasustainableworld.36 OneofthesewasaPeoples’ SustainabilityTreatyonRightsofMother Earth. 37 NotetheresponseofthisDeclarationt oDecisionsoftheConferenceitself supported “greeneconomies.”
36 See Peoples’ SustainabilityTreaties,https://sustainabilitytreaties.org.
37 Peoples’ SustainabilityTreatyonRightsofMotherEarth,https://sustainabilitytreaties.org/draft-treaties/ rights-of-mother-earth.
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
1.Preface
Theundersignedrecognizeandacknowledgethefollowing:
WeareallpartofMotherEarth,anindivisible,livingcommunityofinterrelatedand interdependentbeingswithacommondestiny.MotherEarthisthesourceoflife,nourishment,andlearningandprovidestheseaswellasspiritualityandallelseweneedto livewell.
Existinggovernancesystemsthatassumethathumansareseparatefromtheenvironmenthavewroughtgreatdestruction,degra dation,anddisruptionofMotherEarth, puttinglifeasweknowittodayatsignifi cantriskthroughhabitatdestruction,species elimination,climatechange,andotherthreats.Existingeconomicsystemstreatthenaturalworldaspropertythatcanbeexploitedanddegraded,ratherthanasanintegral ecologicalpartnerwithitsownrightstoexistandthrive,leadingtodangerouslyunbalancedrelationshipsamonghumansandMotherEarthandherotherinhabitants.
TheUnitedNations-commissioned2011report, TowardsaGreenEconomy ,de fi nesa “ greeneconomy ” asonethat “ seekstominimisetheimpactofeconomicactivityon theenvironment,” andtherebyfailstoensureeitherthenecessaryreversalofongoing environmentaldegradationortheeventualhealthofMotherEarth.The “ greeneconomy ” mistakenlypresumesthatwecan “protect” MotherEarthbyfurtherforcingenvironmentalpoliciesto fi twithinaneconomicsystemthatiscausingthedestructionin the firstplace,suchasthroughprivatizationofthenaturalworld.
MotherEarth-basedgovernance,ratherth aneconomy-ordevelopment-basedgovernance,isnecessarytorecognizeth erightsofecosyst emsandspecies – including humans – toexist,thriveandevolve.Inaninte rdependentlivingcommunity,itisnot possibletorecognizetherightsofonlyhumanbeingswithoutcausinganimbalance withinMotherEarth.Toguaranteehumanrights,itisnecessarytorecognizeand defendtherightsofMotherEarthandallbeingsinher,andthatthereareexistingcultures,practices,andlawsthatdoso.
Thereexistsnowanurgencytotakedecisive,collectiveactiontotransformstructures andsystemsthatcausehabitatdestructio n,specieseliminationandabuse,climate change,andotherongoing,imminentandimmediatelydangerousthreatsanddamage toMotherEarth.
2.Principles
Principle#1:InherentRightsofMotherEarth
MotherEarthandallecosystemsandspeciesofwhichsheiscomposed[havecertain fundamentalrights].
Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
Principle#2:ResponsibilitiesofhumanbeingstoMotherEarthandtheoverallwellbeingofhumanandenvironmentalcommunities
Everyhumanbeingisresponsibleforrespe ctingandlivinginharmonywithMother Earth.
Theeconomymustserveandadvancetheoverallwell-beingofhumanandenvironmentalcommunities,ratherthanthemaximizationofprivatewealth;communitiesmustnot sufferalossofoverallwell-beingtoservetheincessantdriverofeconomicgrowththatis fuelingthedestructionoftheEarth’secosystemsandspecies.
Humancommunitywell-beingincludesnotonlyafunctioningeconomybutalsothrivingecosystemsandspeciesaswellasdiversecultures,strongsocietal/familialrelations, healthyfood,cleandrinkingwater,adequatesanitation,safehousing,necessarymedical care,democraticgovernance,fulleducation,meaningfulandappropriatelyrewarded labor,supportforspirituality,respectfultreatmentofanimals,andotherelements.
Environmentalcommunitywell-beingincludesthrivingrelationshipswithhumanpartners,aswellasstrongecosystemandspecies biodiversityandwell-being,cleanwater, healthynutrients,andsoundandconnectedhabitats.
Principle#3:Focuson “sustainablecommunities” andabalancedrespectforalllife
“ Sustainabledevelopment” andthe “ greeneconomy ” shouldbere-focusedinsteadas “ sustainablecommunities, ” atermwhichincludesboth humancommunitiesandthe widercommunitiesofthenaturalworld,toensurethatallelementsofsustainablecommunitiesarepromoted,ratherthansu bsumedtotheoverarchingdriverofthe economy.
Abalancedrespectforalllife,andtherecognitionthatalllifehastherighttoexist,persist,andevolveasaninterrelatedandinterdependentsystem,isessentialtoensureboth sustainablecommunitiesandahealthy,thrivingplanetoverall.
ApositiveoutcomeofRio+20formanycivilsocietyattendeeswasaresolvetobuild thepoliticalwillfortransformativechange includingbyshapingthepost-2015UN developmentagendatowardharmonywith nature.However,fewleftRio+20witha feelingthatwhatwasneededhadbeenaccomplished.
J.UNSDGSummitof2015
In2015,theGeneralAssemblyadoptedthepost-2015developmentagenda,calledthe 2030AgendaforSustainableDevelopment,whichdescribesthe17SDGs.AcrucialdifferencebetweentheMDGsandtheSDGsisthattheformersetgoalsonlyfordevelopingcountries.TheSDGs,incontrast,applytoallcountries.
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
TheSDGsareasfollows:
Goal1:NoPoverty
Goal2:ZeroHunger
Goal3:GoodHealthandWell-being
Goal4:QualityEducation
Goal5:GenderEquality
Goal6:CleanWaterandSanitation
Goal7:AffordableandCleanEnergy
Goal8:DecentWorkandEconomicGrowth
Goal9:Industry,InnovationandInfrastructure
Goal10:ReducedInequality
Goal11:SustainableCitiesandCommunities
Goal12:ResponsibleConsumptionandProduction
Goal13:ClimateAction
Goal14:LifeBelowWater
Goal15:LifeonLand
Goal16:PeaceandJusticeStrongInstitutions
Goal17:PartnershipstoachievetheGoal
InAugust2016,theUNSecretary-General releasedaHarmony withNaturenote addressingtheSDGs.Asyouwillread,theSDGscanbecontextualizedinthegoalof achievingharmonywithnature.
HarmonywithNature,NotebytheSecretary-General
UNDocA/71/266(1August2016)
1.On22December2015,theGeneralAssemblyadoptedresolution70/208,itsseventh resolutionon “HarmonywithNature”,inwhichitrequestedtheSecretaryGeneralto initiate,in2016,avirtualdialogueonHarmonywithNatureamong,interalia,experts onEarthjurisprudenceworldwide,includingthosewhohavebeenactiveintheinteractivedialoguesoftheGeneralAssembly,inordertoinspirecitizensandsocietiesto reconsiderhowtheyinteractwiththenaturalworldinordertoimplementtheSustainableDevelopmentGoalsinharmonywithnature,notingthatsomecountriesrecognize therightsofnatureinthecontextofthepromotionofsustainabledevelopment,and requestedthattheexpertssubmitasummary totheGeneralAssemblyatitsseventyfi rstsessionandthatthevirtualdialoguebehostedonthewebsiteonHarmonywith Nature.
2.A fi rststepinrecognizingtherightsofnaturetookplaceinJune2012attheUnited NationsConferenceonSustainableDevelopment,heldinRiodeJaneiro,Brazil,where HeadsofStateandGovernmentadoptedtheoutcomedocument,entitled “Thefuture wewant” ,recognizingthattheEarthanditsecosystemsareourhomeandthatsome
Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
countriesrecognizetherightsofnatureinthecontextofthepromotionofsustainable development.Theyalsoagreedthat,inordertoachieveajustbalanceamongtheneeds ofpresentandfuturegenerations,itisnecessarytopromoteharmonywithnature.38
3.Subsequently,initsresolution70/1,adoptedon25September2015,theGeneral Assemblyadoptedthepost-2015developmentagenda,the2030AgendaforSustainable Development,whichcontains17Sustainab leDevelopmentGoals,includingGoal12, target12.8,whichseeksto “ensurethatpeopleeverywherehavetherelevantinformationandawarenessforsustainabledevelopmentandlifestylesinharmonywithnature” Inthecontextofthe2030Agenda,the2016virtualinteractivedialogueadvancesthe implementationoftarget12.8byprovidi nginformationandrecommendationsfrom expertsinEarth-centredgovernance,alsoknownasEarthjurisprudence.
K.High-levelPoliticalForum2019
The firstpost-2015UNSummitontheSDGs,theHigh-levelPoliticalForum,washeld fouryearslaterinNewYork,onSeptember24to25,2019.Areportreleasedahead ofthesummitfoundthatthecurrenttrajectoryofprogresswouldbeinsufficienttofulfilltheSDGs.39 ThefollowingexcerptisfromtheforewordbytheSecretary-General, AntonioGuterres:
Sinceitsinceptionin2015,the2030Agendahasprovidedablueprintforsharedprosperityinasustainableworld aworldwhereallpeoplecanliveproductive,vibrant andpeacefullivesonahealthyplanet.Theyear2030isjustoveradecadeaway,and wemustaskourselvesifouractionstodayarelayingtherightfoundationtoachieve theSustainableDevelopmentGoals(SDGs ).TheSustainableDevelopmentGoals Report2019providesevidence-basedinsightstoanswerthisquestion.
Thereportdemonstratesthatprogressisb eingmadeinsomecriticalareas,andthat somefavorabletrendsareevident.
Notwithstandingthatprogress,thisreportidentifiesmanyareasthatneedurgentcollectiveattention.Thenaturalenvironmentisdeterioratingatanalarmingrate:sealevels arerising;oceanacidificationisaccelerating;thepastfouryearshavebeenthewarmest onrecord;onemillionplantandanimalspeciesareatriskofextinction;andlanddegradationcontinuesunchecked.Wearealsomovingtooslowlyinoureffortstoendhuman sufferingandcreateopportunityforall:ourgoaltoendextremepovertyby2030is beingjeopardizedaswestruggletorespondtoentrencheddeprivation,violentconflicts andvulnerabilitiestonaturaldisasters.Globalhungerisontherise,andatleasthalfof theworld’spopulationlacksessentialhealthservices.Morethanhalfoftheworld’schildrendonotmeetstandardsinreadingandmathematics;only28percentofpersons withseveredisabilitiesreceivedcashbene fits;andwomeninallpartsoftheworldcontinuetofacestructuraldisadvantagesanddiscrimination.
38 G.A.Res.70/208at3,(Dec.22,2015).
39 UnitedNations, SustainableDevelopmentGoalsReport2019, UnitedNations,https://unstats.un.org/sdgs/ report/2019/(lastvisitedMar.6,2020).
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
Itisabundantlyclearthatamuchdeeper,fasterandmoreambitiousresponseisneeded tounleashthesocialandeconomictransformationneededtoachieveour2030goals. Fromouradvances,weknowwhatworks.This reportthereforehighlightsareasthat candriveprogressacrossall17SDGs: fi nancing;resilience;sustainableandinclusive economies;moreeffectiveinstitutions;localaction;betteruseofdata;andharnessing science,technologyandinnovationwithagreaterfocusondigitaltransformation.In everythingwedo,wemustdiligentlyensure thatpolicychoicesleavenoonebehind, andthatnationaleffortsaresupportedbyeffectiveinternationalcooperation,grounded inacommitmenttodiplomacyandcrisisprevention.
IV.DEEPSUSTAINABILITY ANALTERNATIVEAPPROACH
ThemainstreamUNsustainabledevelopmentparadigmisonlyoneinterpretationof sustainability onethatisunabashedlyanthropocentricandfocusedondevelopment. Otherapproachestosustainabilitytakeamoreholisticapproachtohumanity’splace ontheplanet,moreinlinewiththeteachi ngsofEarthlaw.Considerthefollowing excerptfromJohnIkerd,aprofessoremeri tusattheUniversityofMissouri,which describesdeepsustainabilityasbeing “co-centric ” ratherthaneitheranthropocentric orecocentric.
DeepSustainability:RediscoveringOurConnectedness
JohnIkerd
Allandall,today’senvironmentalmovementhasnotbeensucceeding.Wehavebeen winningbattles,somecriticalones,butlosingthewar.”40 ThesearethewordsofGustave Speth,founderoftheWorldResourcesInstitute,co-founderoftheNaturalResource DefenseCouncil,andadvisortoPresidentsCarterandClinton.Hepointedtoavariety ofecologicalindicatorsinhis2008book, TheBridgeattheEdgeoftheWorld ,todrivethis pointhome:airandwaterpollution,fossilenergyandfossilwaterdepletion,greenhouse gasemissions,andlossofbiodiversity.Spethconcludedthatenvironmentalorganizationshavefailedbecausetheyhavespenttheirtime,energy,andmoneybattlingthe symptomsofecologicaldegradationratherthanattackingitsrootcauses.Today ’senvironmentalcrisisisultimatelyrootedinourdysfunctionalrelationshipswiththeotherlivingandnon-livingthingsoftheearth.Toaverttheimpendingglobalecologicaldisaster, wemustdelve deeper intothenatureofourinterconnectedness.
Theconceptof “deepsustainability” goesdeeperthanenvironmentalism.Itevengoes beyondcurrentapproachestosustainability,whichfocusonresourceprotectionand conservationandsubstitutionofrenewablefornonrenewablesourcesofenergy.Deep sustainabilityexplorestheethical,philosophical,andspiritualrootsofecological,social,
Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
andeconomicsustainability.41 Itisrootedinnewwaysofthinking,knowing,learning, andbeingintheworld:waysnotonlyessentialforavoidingaglobalecologicalcatastrophebutalsoforprogresstowardanewandbetterworldofthefuture.
DeepsustainabilityrepresentsanintellectualconceptualizationofthewisdomofIndigenouspeoplesthroughouttheworldinthatitreemphasizestheimportanceofourinterconnectednesswithnatureandwitheachother.Itcallsonustoreestablish intimate, caring relationshipswiththeearthandwithotherpeople.Itrecognizesthatweneedto connectwithothersnotsolelytomeetourphysicalormaterialneedsbutalsobecause weneedtocareandbecaredfor,toloveandbeloved.Ittruststhatanewsetofethical andculturalvaluescanandwillevolvefromtheselovingandcaring personal relationships.
Sustainabilitymaywellbethedefiningquestionofthetwenty-firstcentury: “Howcanwe meettheneedsofallinthepresentwithoutdiminishingopportunitiesforthoseofthe future. ” Sustainabilityisaboutmeetingthebasi cneedsofall,withequityandjustice, bothwithinandacrossfuturegenerations.Sustainabilityrequireseconomic,social, andecologicalintegrity,allthree;butsustainabilityultimatelyisrootedinnature.Everythingthatisofusetohumans,includingeverythingofeconomicvalue,ultimatelycomes fromnature.Furthermore,beyondself-suf fi ciency,wemustrelyonrelationshipswith otherpeople,meaningsociety,tohelpusbenefitfromnature’sbounty.Tomeetneeds thatcannotbemetthrough personal relationships,wemustrelyon impersonal economies. Tosustainoureconomies,societies,andu ltimatelyhumanity,wemustmaintainthe healthandproductivecapacityofbothsocietyandnature.
Infailingtorespectthe intrinsic valueofourconnectednesswithandwithinnature,we haveallowedquestionsofecologicalandsocialsustainabilitytodegeneratetotheirlowestcommondominator:moneyoreconomicvalue.Certainly,ourrelationshipswith naturehaveeconomicvalue;natureistheultimatesourceofalleconomicvalue.However,naturealsohasintrinsicvaluesthatfarexceeditseconomicvaluetohumans.Economicvalue,asweknowittoday,isinherentlyindividual,instrumental,andimpersonal. Itaccruestoindividualsorcollectionsofindividuals,ratherthantocommunitiesorsocietiesaswholes.Itisinstrumental,inthataneconomictransactionisalwaysameanstoan end,ratherthansomethingdonebecauseofitsinherentworth.Economicvalueisalso impersonal ,becauseifsomethingcannotbebought,sold,ortradedamongpeople,it hasnoeconomicvalue.
Attheveryleast,governmentsshouldbewillingtoidentifyand “internalize ” theeconomiccostsofecologicaldegradation:theyshouldmake “polluterspay” theeconomic coststheyimposeonsociety.Theyshouldalso “ cap ” greenhousegasemissions,andif thecapissuf fi cientlylowtoreverseglobalclimatechange,evenallowtradingofCO2 emissionrights.Theyshouldalsoassigneconomicvaluestoactivitiesthat enhance the
41 JohnIkerd,LonnieGamble,&TravisCox, DeepSustainability;TheEssentials ,DeepSustainability,https:// sites.google.com/site/sustainabilitydeep/(lastvisitedMar.6,2020).
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
economicproductivityofnature.However,whilegovernmentpoliciesthatforcemarketstoreflectfulleconomicvaluesare necessary,internalizingexternalitiesisnot sufficient toensuresustainability.Weshoulddothenecessary,butshouldnotallow “thenecessary ” tobecomeanobstacleto “thesufficient.”
Unfortunately,wehaveallowedourpreoccupationwitheconomicvaluetobecomean obstacletosustainability,mainlybecauseeconomicrelationships depersonalize ourrelationshipswithotherpeopleaswellaswithnature.Webuy,sell,andtrade,ratherthan maintainpersonalrelationships.Wemustultimatelyaccountforthe social and ethical costsofourfailurestocareforsocietyandnature,notjusttheeconomiccosts.Wecan beginbyremindingourselvesthatourecologicalfailureshave personal consequences, andpersonalcostscannotbemeasuredintermsofeconomicvalue.Ourdependence onfossilenergyprovidesaconvenientillustrationofthepersonalconsequencesofour dysfunctionaleconomicrelationshipwithnature.
Theworldviewof deepsustainability goesbeyondsocialjusticeandextendstheconcept ofecologicaljusticetoallthingsoftheearth.Allthingsofnaturehaverights;therights ofallspecies,includinghumanrights,re fl ecttheiruniquepurposeswithinthewhole ofnature.Intoday ’ sworldofscienti fi cmaterialism,theotherthingsofnaturehave nosubjectivityorbeingandthushavenoinherent “ right ” toexistorpurposeapart fromtheirpotentialusefulnesstohumanity .Ironically,thiswo rldviewguideseven today ’ senvironmentalmovement.Inspiteofcl aimstothecontrary,theenvironmentalmovementisanthropocentric.Mostenvir onmentalistsimplicitlyacceptthatthe worldexistsprimarily,ifnotsolely,forth epurposeofsustainingthewell-beingof humanity. “Deepecologists,” ontheotherhand,claimaneco-centricworldview,showingnomoreconcernforhumansthanforanyotherspeciesornon-livingthingon earth.Deepecologistswoulddepopulatethe earthofhumans,ifnecessary,tosustain therestofnature.
Deepsustainabilityis “co-centric” ratherthananthropocentricoreco-centric.Itisnot eco-centricbecauseitisconcernedspeci fi callywithhumans – thepresentandfuture well-beingofhumanity.However,itisnotanthropocentricorhumancentered,inspite ofitsspeci fi cconcernforthehumanspecies.Thedeepsustainabilityworldviewrecognizesthathumanwell-beingandthesustainabilityofhumanityisinseparablyandcriticallyinterrelatedwiththewell-beingoftheothernon-livingandlivingbeingsofthe earth.Deepsustaina bilityisrootedinadeepreverenceandrespectforallthingsof nature – livingandnon-living – specificallybutnotsolelyhumans.Naturedoesnotexist forthesolebene fi tofhumansanymorethanhumansexistforthesolebenefi tofthe otherthingsofnature.Humanityisnotsustainableunlesshumansocietiescontribute to,oratleastdonotdetractfrom,theoverallhealthandwell-beingofthewholeof natureofwhichhumansareapart. 42
42 JohnIkerd, DeepSustainability;RediscoveringOurConnectedness ,A BOUT P LACE J OURNAL ,https:// aboutplacejournal.org/issues/voices/section-1/john-ikerd/(lastvisitedMar.6,2020).
Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
V.EMERGINGPARADIGMS:AGLOBALPACTFORTHE ENVIRONMENT
A.Introduction:WhatIstheGlobalPactinitiative?
Wehavenowreviewedabout35yearsofUNsustainabilityinitiativesalongwithseveral alternatives.Lookingtothefuture,whatwillbethenextmajordevelopmentofthe UN’sworktoprotecttheenvironment?
OnepossibilityisaGlobalPactfortheEnvironment(“GlobalPact”),introducedin 2017.TheGlobalPactproposestheadoptionofalegallybindinginternationaltreaty thatwouldgiveforcetotheenvironmentallawprinciplesenshrinedintheRioDeclarationthatemergedfromthe1992UNCED.TheGlobalPactwouldguideglobaland nationalenvironmentalactionforallstatesandcitizens,aswellastheprivatesector.
Whyisanewlegalinstrumentnecessary?TheGlobalPact’sproponentsarguethat, atpresent,internationalenvironmental lawlacksanoverarch ing,legallybinding umbrellatexttoclarifyandde fi neprinciples,obligations,andrightswithrespectto environmentallawandtheglobalenvironment.Asaresult,internationalenvironmentallawsuffersfrom “ gaps ”43 andineffectiveandunevenimplementationacrossglobal andnationalgovernancestructures.
In2017,aninternationalgroupoflegalexpertsproposedadrafttextforaGlobal Pactbasedonthemutuallyinterdependentsourceprinciplesoftherighttoahealthy environmentandthedutytotakecareofthe environment.Thesesourceprinciples giverisetootherenvironmentalprinciplesrecognizedintheRioDeclaration,including(1)thestates ’ dutyofpreventionandremediationofenvironmentalharms, (2)thepolluterpaysprinciple,and(3)thecitizens’ righttoenvironmentalinformationandpublicparticipationinenvironme ntaldecision-making.Further,thedraft GlobalPactincludescorollaryprinciplessuchasnon-regression44 andof ficialrecognitionofcivilsociety’sroleinenvironmentalprotection.
Thissectiondiscussesthehistory,purpose, andprinciplesoftheproposedGlobalPact.
B.WhyIsaGlobalPactfortheEnvironmentNecessary?
Human-impactedglobalecocideissoundeniablysevereandincreasinglyalarmingthat manyscholarsconsiderourimpactashav ingbroughtaboutanewgeologicera:the Anthropocene. 45 Itisclearthatexistinginternationalenvironmentallawshavenot
43 G.A.Res.72/277,2 TowardsaGlobalPactfortheEnvironment (May10,2018).
44 Theprincipleofnon-regressionisaninternationallawprinciplerequiringthatnormswhichhavepreviously beenadoptedbyStatesnotberevised,ifthisimpliesgoingbackwardsonthesubjectofstandardsofprotection ofcollectiveandindividualrights.
45 MARIA-ANTONIA TIGRE,GAPSIN INTERNATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL LAW:TOWARDA GLOBAL PACTFORTHE ENVIRONMENT xx,2019.
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
beenenoughtomitigatehumanity ’ sdestructiveimpactonourplanet.Withonly 10yearstoimplementtheUN ’ s2030AgendaforSustaina bleDevelopment,which requiresunprecedentedglobalcooperationtoprotect,conserve,andrestoreplanetary systems,46 theadvocatesforaGlobalPactconsideritcrucialtoensurewecanmeetthis globalcommitmentandreclaimhopeforahealthysustainablefuture.Atpresent,they arguethatinternationalenvironmentallawlacksafoundationalandlegallybinding documentthatensuresenvironmentallawp rinciplescanbeevenlyintegratedand effectivelyimplementedinglobalandnationallegalsystems.
1.Globalenvironmentalconstitutionalism
Arguably,asaconstitutionaltextforenvironmentallaw,aglobalpactwouldtransform principlesintocompulsoryenvironmentalactionsandserveasaninviolablesourceof lawforinternationalanddomesticlegalsystems.Overtime,aglobalpactwouldguide environmentalconstitutionalismandcontributetotheincorporationofenvironmental normsintotheconstitutionaltierofnationallegalsystems,leadingtostrongerdomesticenvironmentallawsandsteeringeffectiveimplementationthatwouldradiateoutto theregionalandinternationalgovernancesystems.47 Themovementforenvironmentalconstitutionalismhasalreadyseenmanycountriesincorporateenvironmentalprinciplesintotheirconstitutions,suchasBrazil,China,France,Mexico,andmany others.48 Aglobalpactwouldserveasthebinding,overarchingtextnecessarytoguide allcountriestoelevatingenvironmentalprotectionandsustainabledevelopmentaspillarsofdomestic,regional,andinternationalgovernance.
2.Turningsoftlawintohardlaw
AglobalpactwouldgivebindingforcetotheRioDeclarationprinciplestoensure theseprincipleshaveuniversalrecognition,harmonizedunderstanding,andeffective applicationacrosscomparativelegalsystems.
Asasoft-lawinstrument,theRioDeclarationisnotbinding,andthusthejurisprudentialandpracticaleffectsofsomeofthe seessentialprincipleshavefailedtobe appliedandenforcedeffectively.49 Forexample,theprecautionaryprinciple(RioPrinciple15)isinstructiveastohowcon fl ictinginterpretationsofsoftlawcanprevent
46 G.A.Res.70/1TransformingOurWorld:The2030AgendaforSustainableDevelopment;IntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange, 2019Refinementtothe2006IPCCGuidelinesforNationalGreenhouseGasInventories (June19,2019);UnitedNations2030AgendaforSustainableDevelopment, TheSustainableGoalsReport2019 (2019).
47 See JAMES R.MAY &ERIN DALY,GLOBAL ENVIRONMENTAL CONSTITUTIONALISM (2015);DAVID BOYD,THE ENVIRONMENTAL RIGHTS REVOLUTION (2012).
48 See,e.g., Mexico: CaseXXVII.309CS., SJFG,10thPeriod,Book37,December2016,1840(relyingonPrinciple 15oftheRioDeclarationtointerprettherighttoahealthyenvironmentenshrinedinArticle4oftheMexican Constitution);Brazil:ConstitutionofBrazil,Art.225;China:ChineseConstitution,Art.26;France:French CharterfortheEnvironment(includedinits “blockofconstitutionality”),Arts.2,3,5;Ecuador2008Constitution,Arts.71-74,395-399,400-415.
49 YANN AGUILA &JORGE E.VIÑUALES,AGLOBAL PACTFORTHE ENVIRONMENT:LEGAL FOUNDATIONS (2019).
430
Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
environmentallawprinciplesfromrealizingtheirfullpotential.Onthelegalquestion ofwhethertheprecautionaryprincipleis arecognizednormofcustomaryinternationallaw,theInternationalLawoftheSeaTribunalstatedthattheprecautionary principleisan “emergingnorm,”50 whiletheInternationalCourtofJusticesuggested thatthisprinciple “mayberelevant” forinterpretationpurposes.51
Aglobalpactwouldsettlethequestionofwhichenvironmentalprinciplesarerecognizedasnormsandthereforecreatebindingobligationsonstates.Thiswouldensure thatthesefoundationalprinciplesareuniversallyacceptedandwouldallowforanacceleratedapplicationandimplementationoftheseprinciplesacrossalllegalsystems.
C.HistoryoftheInitiativeforaGlobalPactfortheEnvironment
TheideaofcreatingaglobalframeworkforenvironmentalprotectionliketheGlobal Pacthasevolvedsincethe1970s.TheStockholmConferenceof1972wasseenasthe constitutionalmomentofinternationalenvironmentallawandinspiredwidespread promulgationofdomesticenvironmentallaws; 52 however,theresultingStockholm Declarationwasasoft-lawinstrumentwithoutlegalforce.
The1992RioDeclarationonEnvironmentandDevelopment53 wasthemajorleap forwardfortheideaofaglobalpactbecausethisdeclarationsetforthconstitutional principlesforglobalenv ironmentalgovernance. 54 Signi fi cantly,theRioDeclaration statedthenow-essentialcustomaryinternationallawprinciplesofprevention(RioPrinciple2),conductinganenvironmentalimpactassessment(RioPrinciple17),andtheduty tocooperate(RioPrinciples18and19).Ot herkeyenvironmentalprinciplesstated, manyofwhichwereenvironmentalprinciplesof fi rstimpression, 55 are(1)common butdifferentiatedresponsibilities(RioPri nciple7),(2)theprecautionaryprinciple (RioPrinciple15),(3)polluterpays,(4)notificationofemergencies,(5)notification andconsultationincaseofrisk,and(6)peacefulsettlementofdisputes.Manyofthese environmentalprincipleshavecatalyzedthedevelopmentofcustomarynormsandhave beentransposedintoawiderangeofglobaltreatiesandinstruments.
InspiredbytheRioDeclaration,theInternationalUnionfortheConservationof Nature(IUCN)releasedthe firstofitsconsistentlyupdateddraftsofanInternational CovenantonEnvironmentandDevelopmentin1995.56
50 ResponsibilitiesandObligationsofStatesSponsoringPersonsandEntitieswithRespecttoActivitiesintheArea,Advisory Opinion,ITLOSRep.10¶135(Feb.11,2011).
51 PulpMillsontheRiverUruguay(Argentinav.Uruguay),Judgment,I.C.J.¶164(April20,2010).
52 See RobertLutz, TheLawsofEnvironmentalManagement:AComparativeStudy ,24A M .J. OF C OMP .L.3,447 (1976).
53 UnitedNationsConferenceonEnvironmentandDevelopment. RioDeclarationonEnvironmentandDevelopment,UNDoc.A/CONF.151/26(vol.1)(June3-14,1992).
54 PIERRE-MARIE DUPUY &JORGE VIÑUALES,INTERNATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL LAW 60(2018).
55 See AlexandreKiss, TheRioDeclarationonEnvironmentandDevelopment, IN THE ENVIRONMENT AFTER RIO:INTERNATIONAL LAWAND ECONOMICS (LuigiCampiglioetal.eds.,1994).
56 TheIUCN,incollaborationwiththeInternationalCouncilofEnvironmentalLaw,haspursuedworkona DraftCovenant,whichnowhasseveraleditions. See IUCN, DraftInternationalCovenantonEnvironmentandDevelopment (2017).
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
InNovember2015,thelegalthinktank ClubdesJuristes releasedareportrecommendingtheadoptionofauniversalpacttomergeinternationalenvironmentallaw inabindinginstrumentthatwould(1)imposeenvironmentalobligationsonstatesand non-stateactors,(2)conferenvironmentalrightstocitizens,and(3)createaninviolablelegalinstrumentinnationalcourts. 57 TheadoptionoftheParisAgreement inspiredhigh-levelinternationalsupportforthepactfromLaurentFabius58 (President ofthe21stConferenceofthePartiestotheUNFrameworkConventiononClimate Change)andledtothe2017conveningofaninternationalnetworkofover100environmentallawexpertsfrommorethan40countrieswho fi nalizeda fi naldrafttext fortheGlobalPactinJune2017.LaurentFabius,whochairedtheexpertmeetingthat finishedthedrafttext,presentedittoFrenchPresidentEmmanuelMacronatahighpro filesymposiumfeaturingformerUNSecretary-GeneralBanKi-Moon,FrenchMinisteroftheEnvironmentNicolasHulot,andmanyotherpolitical fi gures,diplomats, experts,andstudents. 59 InSeptember2017,thedrafttextnetworkofexperts,now knownastheInternationalGroupofExpertsforthePact(IGEP)publishedawhite paper, TowardaGlobalPactfortheEnviroment 60 (GPE),tofurtheradvancegovernmentalandcivilsocietysupportfortheGlobalPact.
InSeptember2017,over40headsofstateexpressedtheirsupportattheSummit onaGlobalPactfortheEnvironment. 61 InMay2018,theUnitedNationsGeneral AssemblyadoptedtheEnablingResolution62 TowardsaGlobalPactfortheEnvironment,63 whichwasresoundinglyacceptedbytheglobalcommunity,with143statesvotingtoadopttheresolution,andonly fivevotesagainst,theUnitedStates,theRussian Federation,Syria,thePhilippines,andTurkey.TheEnablingResolutioncalledon theUnitedNationsSecretary-Generaltoprepareareport 64 andtosetupaworking grouptomakerecommendationstotheUNGeneralAssemblyonthematter,includingthepossibilityofconveninganintergovernmentalconferencetoadoptaninternationalinstrument.65
TheSecretary-General’sNovember2018reportfoundthatinternationalenvironmentallawcouldindeedbestrengthened “ throughacomprehensiveandunifying
57 See YannAguila, LaAdopcióndeunPactoInternacionalparalaProteccióndelMedioAmbiente 13M ISIÓN J URIDICA:R EVISTADE D ERECHOY C IENCIAS S OCIALES 431(2017).
58 LaurentFabiuswasthePresidentofthe21stConferenceofthePartiestotheUNFrameworkConventionon ClimateChange,theMinisterofForeignAffairsofFrancein2015,andisnowthePresidentoftheConstitutionalCourtofFrance.
59 See Y.Aguila, “VersunPacteMondialpourl’Environnement:ActeFondateuràParisle24juin2017,” 25LA SEMAINE JURIDIQUE 718(2017).
60 Y.Aguilaetal., WhitePaper:TowardaGlobalPactfortheEnvironment,LE CLUBDES JURISTES (2017).
61 See EmmanuelMacron, SpeechbyM.EmmanuelMacron,PresidentoftheRepublic:SummitontheGlobalPactforthe Environment,FRANCE DIPLOMATIE (Sept.19,2017).
62 UNGA ‘TowardsaGlobalPactfortheEnvironment’ UNDocA/RES/72/277(10May2018).
63 See UnitedNations, GeneralAssemblyDecidestoEstablishWorkingGroupAimedatIdentifyingGapsinInternational EnvironmentalLaw (May10,2018),https://www.un.org/press/en/2018/ga12015.doc.htm.
64 TheresolutionaskedtheSecretary-Generaltosubmit “atechnicalandevidence-basedreportthatidentifies andassessespossiblegapsininternationalenvironmentallawandenvironment-relatedinstrumentswitha viewtostrengtheningtheirimplementation.” EnablingResolution, supra note62,¶1.
65 EnablingResolution, supra note62,¶2.
Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
internationalinstrumentthatgathersalltheprinciplesofenvironmentallaw.”66 The GlobalPact’sworkinggroupmetattheUNEnvironmentProgramme’sNairobiheadquartersforthreesubstantivemeetings during2019,resultinginarecommendation tostatestomakea “politicaldeclaration” onthematterin2022,the50thanniversary oftheStockholmConference.67 WhilethisdelaystheGlobalPact’sadoption,supportersremainhopefulthatcontinuedmobilizationmightseetheformaladoptionofthe GlobalPactin2022.68
D.PrinciplesRecognizedintheDraftGlobalPactfortheEnvironment
ThedraftGlobalPactfortheEnvironmentmustbeseenasapreliminarywork base.Theauthorshavedeliberatelyusedgeneralandconcisewording,asitisadocumentintendedtobereshapedandnegotiat edbythevariousstatesbeforebeing adopted.
1.TheRighttoaHealthyEnvironment
Everypersonhastherighttoliveinanecologicallysoundenvironmentadequatefor theirhealth,well-being,dignity,cultureandfulfillment.
2.TheDutytoTakeCareoftheEnvironment
EveryStateorinternationalinstitution,everyperson,naturalorlegal,publicorprivate, hasthedutytotakecareoftheenvironment.Tothisend,everyonecontributesattheir ownlevelstotheconservation,protection,andrestorationoftheintegrityoftheEarth’ s ecosystem.
3.IntegrationandSustainableDevelopment
Partiesshallintegratetherequirementsofenvironmentalprotectionintotheplanning andimplementationoftheirpoliciesandnationalandinternationalactivities,especially inordertopromotethe fightagainstclimatechange,theprotectionofoceansandthe maintenanceofbiodiversity.Theyshallpursuesustainabledevelopment.Tothisend, theyshallensurethepromotionofpublicsupportpolicies,patternsofproductionand consumptionbothsustainableandrespectfuloftheenvironment.
4.IntergenerationalEquity
Internationalequityshallguidedecisionsthatmayhaveanimpactontheenvironment. Presentgenerationsshallensurethattheirdecisionsandactiondonotcompromisethe abilityoffuturegenerationstomeettheirownneeds.
66 UnitedNationsSecretary-General, GapsinInternationalEnvironmentalLawandEnvironment-RelatedInstruments:TowardsaGlobalPactfortheEnvironment, UNDoc.A/73/4192(Nov.30,2018).
67 AnaMariaLebada, GlobalEnvironmentPactRecommendationsForwardedtotheUNGA (2019).
68 Follow-UptotheReportoftheAdHocOpen-EndedWorkingGroupEstablishedPursuanttoGeneralAssemblyResolution 72/277,UNGAOR,UNDocA/RES/73/333(Aug.30,2019).
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
5.Prevention
Thenecessarymeasuresshallbetakentopreventenvironmentalharm.ThePartieshave thedutytoensurethatactivitiesundertheirjurisdictionorcontroldonotcausedamage totheenvironmentsofotherPartiesorinareasbeyondthelimitsoftheirnationaljurisdiction.Theyshalltakethenecessarymeasurestoensurethatanenvironmentalimpact assessmentisconductedpriortoanydecisionmadetoauthoriseorengageinaproject, anactivity,aplan,oraprogramthatislikelytohaveasignificantadverseimpactonthe environment
6.Precaution
Whenthereisariskofseriousorirreversibledamage,lackofscientificcertaintyshallnot beusedasareasonforpostponingtheadoptionofeffectiveandproportionatemeasurestopreventenvironmentaldegradation.
7.EnvironmentalDamages
Thenecessarymeasuresshallbetakentoensureanadequateremediationofenvironmentaldamages.Partiesshallimmediatelyno tifyotherStatesofanynaturaldisasters orotheremergenciesthatarelikelytoproducesuddenharmfuleffectsontheenvironmentofthoseStates.PartiesshallpromptlycooperatetohelpconcernedStates
8.PolluterPays
Partiesshallensurethatprevention,mitigationandremediationcostsforpollution,and otherenvironmentaldisruptionsanddegradationare,tothegreatestpossibleextent, bornebytheiroriginator.
9.AccesstoInformation
Everyperson,withoutbeingrequiredtostateaninterest,hasarightofaccesstoenvironmentalinformationheldbypublicauthorities.Publicauthoritiesshall,withintheframeworkoftheirnationallegislations,collectandmakeavailabletothepublicrelevant environmentalinformation.
10.PublicParticipation
Everypersonhastherighttoparticipate,atanappropriatestageandwhileoptionsare stillopen,inthepreparationofdecisions,measures,plans,programmes,activities,policiesandnormativeinstrumentsofpublicauthoritiesthatmayhaveasignificanteffecton theenvironment.
11.AccesstoEnvironmentalJustice
Partiesshallensuretheright ofeffectiveandaffordablea ccesstoadministrativeand judicialprocedures,includingredressandremedies,tochallengeactsoromissionsof publicauthoritiesorprivatepersonswhichcontraveneenvironmentallaw,takinginto considerationtheprovisionsofthepresentPact.
12.EducationandTraining
ThePartiesshallensurethatenvironmentaleducation,tothegreatestpossibleextent,is taughttomembersoftheyoungergenerationaswellastoadults,inordertoinspirein everyonearesponsibleconductinprotectingandimprovingtheenvironment.ThePartiesshallensuretheprotectionoffreedomofexpressionandinformationinenvironmentalmatters.Theysupportthedissemi nationbymassmediaofinformationofan educationalnatureonecosystemsando ntheneedtoprotectandpreservethe environment.
13.ResearchandInnovation
ThePartiesshallpromote,tothebestofth eirability,theimprovementofscienti fi c knowledgeofecosystemsandtheimpactofh umanactivities.Theyshallcooperate throughexchangesofscienti fi candtechnologicalknowl edgeandbyenhancingthe development,adaptation,disseminationandtransferoftechnologiesrespectfulofthe environment,includinginnovativetechnologies.
14.RoleofNon-StateActorsandSubnationalEntities
ThePartiesshalltakethenecessarymeasurestoencouragetheimplementationofthis Pactbynon-Stateactorsandsubnationalenti ties,includingcivilsociety,economic actors,citiesandregionstakingintoaccounttheirvitalroleintheprotectionofthe environment.
15.EffectivenessofEnvironmentalNorms
ThePartieshavethedutytoadopteffectiv eenvironmentallaws,andtoensuretheir effectiveandfairimplementationandenforcement.
16.EcologicalResilience
ThePartiesshalltakenecessarymeasures tomaintainandrestorethediversityand capacityofecosystemsandhumancommunitiestowithstandenvironmentaldisruptions anddegradationandtorecoverandadapt.
17.Non-Regression
ThePartiesandtheirsub-nationalentitiesrefrainfromallowingactivitiesoradopting normsthathavetheeffectofreducingtheg loballevelofenvironmentalprotection guaranteedbycurrentlaw.
18.Cooperation
Inordertoconserve,protectandrestoretheintegrityoftheEarth’secosystemandcommunityoflife,Partiesshallcooperateingoodfaithandinaspiritofglobalpartnership fortheimplementationoftheprovisionsofthepresentPact.
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
VI.CONCLUSION
Sustainabledevelopmentisacomprehensivetermcoveringenvironmentalconservationandeconomic,social,andculturaldevelopment.Whilethetermisvague,itbrings everyonetothetable.Sustainabledevelopmentisinthegloballexicon,andwhatever thedifferencesinusages,ituniformlystandsforanalternativemodeofdevelopment thatissustainable,withinthelimitsofn ature,andaddressespovertyandinequity. Withoutdramaticchangesinthedevelopmentpathwithinthenextfortyyears,there willbeenvironmentalandsocialcatastrophe.
Yetsustainabledevelopmentalonecannot reversethecurrentecologicalcrisis. TheUNneedstoundertakeashifttoaparadigmofglobalenvironmentalgovernance thattranscendsitsanthropocentricmodelofsustainabledevelopmentbypromoting, ecocentrism;harmonywithnature;andbindingenvironmentalinstruments,suchas throughtheGlobalPactfortheEnvironment.Asaninternationalorganizationrather thanasupranationalorganization,thisshiftintheworkoftheUNisdependentonthe organization ’smemberstates’ collectivedecisiontoincorporateprinciplesofEarthlaw withinthesustainabledevelopmentmodel,and,mostimportant,toimplementthese principlesonanationalbasis.
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1)Recallingtheoriginsofsustainabledevelopmentinthepreparationsforthe 1972StockholmConvention,wouldyouseeitasanideacraftedspeci fi callyto supplicatethedevelopingcountriesintosupportingtheStockholmConference, orratheraconceptwhosetimehadcomeandwouldhavebeenlaunchedonto theinternationalagendainanycase?Tounderstandthecon fl ictbetweenthe developinganddevelopedcountriesasthebackgroundagainstwhichsustainabledevelopmentbecam etheparadigmfortoday ’ sglobalgovernance,trace thepositionsofthedevelopingcountriesthroughouttheeventsandpolicy papersdiscussedinthischapter.
(2)Article20.4oftheCBDstates: “TheextenttowhichdevelopingcountryParties willeffectivelyimplementtheircommitmentsunderthisConventionwilldepend ontheeffectiveimplementationbydevelopedcountryPartiesoftheircommitmentsunderthisConventionrelatedto financialresourcesandtransferoftechnologyandwilltakefullyintoaccoun tthefactthateconomicandsocial developmentanderadicationofpovertyarethe fi rstandoverridingpriorities ofthedevelopingcountryParties.” Article4.2(6)oftheUNFCCCcontainssimilartext.Doyoufeelthatthesuccessful negotiationofthistextbydeveloping countrieswassimplyameansforthemtoescapeimplementingthesetwomajor conventions,orisitajusti fi ablemechanismconsideringthevasteconomic
growthofthedevelopedcountriesthatisthekeyunderlyingfactorfortheglobal environmentalcrisis?Whatdothesearticlesdiscloseastohowdevelopingcountriesdefinesustainabledevelopment?
(3)Howwouldyouratethethreeglobalenvironmentalmegaconferencesof1992, 2002,and2012?Giventhattheenvironm entalcrisisshowsnosignofletting up,nevertheless,howwouldyoudefinetheircontributiontoglobalgovernance? Iftheirgoaltoowastobalanceglobaleconomicandenvironmentalgoals,think ofreasonswhytheglobaleconomyisgrowingwithoutlimitswhileglobalenvironmentaldevastationisworseningandprovingsohardtoreverse.
(4)Agenda21setouttheblueprintforsustainabledevelopment,butithasn’tbeen implementedasplanned.Isthefailureofthedevelopedcountriestoundertake fi nancialcommitmentstothedevelopin gcountriesanimpassableobstacle? Whatothercircumstancescontributetoitsdisappointingtrackrecord?Cansustainabledevelopmentworkinacompetitiveglobaleconomybasedonunlimited growthandconsumption?
(5)TheUNHarmonywithNatureInitiativeseekstorootsustainabledevelopment inanumberofEarthlawprinciples.DoyouthinkthatEarthlawandsustainable developmentthroughtheUNcanbereconciled?Whatothermeasureswould yousuggestforincorporatingrightsforn atureintointernationallegalinstruments?Wouldyourecommendabindingconventiononrightsfornature?Do youthinkrightsofnaturecanbeupheldinawaythatrespectsthegoalofdevelopingcountriestoalleviatepoverty?Howmightyouarticulatetheadvantages anddisadvantages?
(6)Howwouldyouaddressthenon-governmentalorganizations’ criticismof “ green economies ” atthe2012UNCSD?Doyouthink “ greeneconomies ” isthemost viablesolution,orshouldeconomicdevelopmentnotbethegoalatall?For example,adifferentgoalwouldbea “ greensociety ” ora “ thrivingsociety. ” Thinkofafewmoreexamples.
(7)JohnIkerd ’sdescriptionofdeepsustainabilitydescribesitasbeing “co-centric ” ratherthananthropocentricorecocentric.Similarly,manyofthelegalmovementsthatcompriseEarthlawcanbedescribedasbeingonaspectrumbetween ecocentricandanthropocentriclaw,oftenincorporatingelementsofbothwhile tryingto findabalancethatupholdsthewell-beingofalllifeontheplanet.Do youthinkitispossibleforsustainabilitytobe “ co-centric, ” representingboth anthropocentrismandecocentrismatonce,ormustitbeoneortheother?
(8)Generally,internationalenvironmentalconventionshavefailedinreversingthe environmentalcrisis.Doyouthinkth ataGlobalPactfortheEnvironmentas describedinthischapterwouldbeanappropriateresponsetothecurrentstate oftheenvironment?Inyouropinion,whatarethe fl awsandthestrengthsofa GlobalPactfortheEnvironment? Chapter15:UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
(9)Asthechapterexplains,theproposedGlobalPactincludesrelativelyfewnew principles.Mostoftheideashavealreadybeenstatedinvarioustreaties,conventions,anddeclarations.DoesthatmeantheGlobalPactislikelytoseelittleresistancetoadoption?Or,doesitmeanthattheGlobalPactisunnecessarysince mostoftheprinciplesthatitispromoti ngalreadyenjoybindinglegalstatus throughinternationalconventions?
(10)WhatothercreativewayscanyouthinkoftointegrateEarthlawprinciplesinto internationalfora?Forexample,whatif “nature” wasrecognizedashavingrights andthenhaditsowndelegationtonegotiateenvironmentaltreaties,suchasthe UNFCCC?Orwhatif “nature” (asrepresentedbylegalguardians)heldaseatin theUNGeneralAssembly ormultipleseatsfortheoceans,forests,watersheds, andsoforth?Wouldthis createamoreequitable “eco-democracy” thatgavea voicetonature?Wouldnationsobjecttothisstructure,andifso,howcouldthat beovercome?
CHAPTER16
EcocentricGovernance:TheNew EcologicalSocialContract1
I.INTRODUCTION
Earthlawencompassesalllegalstructuresandmechanismsthatprotect,stabilize,and restorethefunctionalinterdependencyofEarth’slifeandlife-supportsystems.Ecocentricorecologicalgovernance(thetwotermsareusedinterchangeably)isanessential partofEarthlawandisthesubjectofthischapter.Topicscoveredincludethenewecologicalsocialcontract,theroleoflawyersinecologicalgovernance,andtherightsof naturelawsinBoliviaasacasestudyinimplementingecocentricgovernance.
Inaverygeneralsense,thesocialcontractisthemutualagreementofpeopleina societytobegovernedatthistime,inacertainway,andbycertainrules.Asocialcontracttheorygivesanexplanationofwhatthismutualagreementis,and,also,whatpeopleshouldexpectfromthegovernmentanditslaws.Inatimeofstability,thesocial contractisinplace liketheairpeoplebreathe,itistherebuttheydonotgiveattentiontoit.Inatimeofgreathistoricalchangefromoneperiodtoanother,however,the existingcontractreceivesattention,asitmustbereaffirmedorberecreated.
Theearlytwenty-firstcenturyissuchaperiodofgreathistoricalchange perhaps thegreatestsinceagriculturalciviliza tionbegan11,000yearsago.Likethen,both humanhistoryandEarth ’sgeobiologicalhistoryarechanging thenfromthePleistocene(thelasticeage)totheHoloceneepoch,andnowfromtheHolocenetothe stillwarmerAnthropoceneepoch(seeChapter3,SectionII, “ Understandingthe AnthropoceneEpoch ” ).TheHolocenewasaperiodofrelativelystableclimateand humansweregenerallyabletotakenatureforgranted.IntheAnthropocene,climate ischangingrapidlyalongwithEarth ’ slifeandlife-supportsystems.Theexisting human-onlysocialcontractisbeingcalle dintoquestion.Thereisnowaneedfora socialcontractthatincludesnature,anecologicalsocialcontract.
1 ThischapterwasauthoredbyHermanGreene,PresidentoftheCenterforEcozoicStudiesandaneditorof thiscoursebook.
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
II.THEECOLOGICALSOCIALCONTRACT
A.BrunoLatour:TheSocialContractwithNature
BrunoLatourinhis2013GiffordLectureson FacingGaia setsthestageforconsidering anewecologicalsocialcontract.2
Latourstatesweshouldnotbealarmedifthecurrentdisruptionofplanetarylife leadstosocialupheavalendingthehuman-onlysocialcontractbecauseitwasnot designedtoholdtogetherinth epresentencounterwithGaia. 3 Wemightbeupset, frustrated,anddismayed,butnotanymorealarmedthanwewouldbeifslowlyrising sealevelscausedthecollapseofafailingseawall.Wehaveknownaboutthedisruption ofplanetarylifeandthestrainsitisplacingonsocietiesforalongtime.
Latourcontinuesbysayingthatbecausehumansarenowfacingplanetarylimits, theyhaveenteredanewHobbesianconditionofa “warofallagainstall.” Theprotagonistsnowincludeplants,animals, fi res,storms,andcarbonemissions,aswellasthe varioushumanfactions allareseekingtheirplacesinEarth ’ slimitedspace.This new “ stateofnature ” isnottheconditiondescribedbyHobbesthatexistedpriorto theformationofthehumansocialcontractlongago;rather,itisapresentcondition thathasarisenbecausethehumansocialcontractisincomplete.4 Anewsocialcontract thatincludesnatureisneededandithastobeassembledbitbybit.Thelawsofthenew polityhavetobeinventedandbeself-imposedbecause “[w]ithoutdecision,thereisno bodypolitics,noliberty,[no]autonomy.”5
Inhis2018book, DowntoEarth:PoliticsintheNewClimaticRegime,Latourexpands onthenatureofpoliticsintheAnthropocene.Inadditiontorightandleft,heposits therearenowtwonewpoliticalpoles —“Out-of-This-World” and “Terrestrial.” People inclinedtoOut-of-This-Worldseektoescapetheexistingplanetarysituationthrough climatedenial,alternativefacts,populism,fascism,offshoretaxhavens,gatedcommunities,andevensettlingothe rplanets.DuetothepulloftheOut-of-This-Worldperspective,humanityislosingacommonworldofrealityinrelationtowhatis happeningtoEarth.Restoringthiscommonworlddependsonthosewhoareinclined totheTerrestrial.
BeingTerrestrial,asexplainedbyLatour,doesnothaveanobviousmeaningsuch asbecominggreen,natural,ecological,orenvironmental.Thesemovementshavenot beenabletomobilizepoliticallyonasuf fi cientenoughscaletoeffectuatechangein
2 BrunoLatour, FacingGaia:SixLecturesonthePoliticalTheologyofNature (2013),https://eportfolios.macaulay. cuny.edu/wakefield15/files/2015/01/LATOUR-GIFFORD-SIX-LECTURES_1.pdf.
3 InGreekmythology,GaiawasthegoddessoftheEarth.Latour ’suseofthetermcomesfromJamesLovelock ’ sandLynnMargulis ’ sGaiatheory.Gaiaistheself-regulatingplanetarysystem.Sheisnurturingto humansbutmayalsokillthem sheisbothmotherandother.
4 Latour, supra note2,at103.
5 Latour, supra note2,at104.Latourcallspeopletorecognizeandtakeconstructiveresponsibilityforpolitical decisionsregardingEarth’secology.Peoplewhobelieveecologyisapoliticalorjustascientificmatteraremakingamistake.Iftherightpoliticaldecisionsarenotmade,therewon’tbeanypolity,freedom,orautonomy leftforhumansbecauseEarthwillbecomeuninhabitable.
Chapter16:EcocentricGovernance:TheNewEcologicalSocialContract
thesocialcontract;rather,theyhaveresultedindecadesoffrozenpoliticalpositions. ThosewhochoosetheTerrestrialhavenoestablishedpoliticalpartyorinstitutional form(thoughtheyarenecessarilyactivein politicalpartiesandinstitutions).They areneitherleftnorright,conservativenorliberal,reactionarynorprogressive,global norlocal.TheirpulltotheEarthsharpensthesecon fl icts,deploysthemdifferently, andseeksalliesonallsidesbycallingattentiontoissuesthataremorebasicthanthose dominatingcurrentpoliticaldiscourses.Ratherthanaskinghowtogrow(ordegrow) theeconomy,expandthepie,orredistributewealth,Terrestrialsask, “Howishumanity inthetwenty- fi rstcenturygoingtobeabletosubsistonEarth? ” Theirgoalisnotto savetheEarth,toprotectit,ortoliveinharmonywithit;itistolearnhowto become dependent onit.Theydonotdefendnature;the yarenaturedefendingthemselves. TheTerrestrialsarenotengagedinmodernity ’ spursuitofsomein fi nitehorizon whereeveryonewillhavealltheywantanddoastheywish;instead,theyareengaged inajourneytoEarth tobecomingboundbyEarth’slimits(Earthbound).
Terrestrialswillconstructthenewsocialcontractwithnature.
B.BruceJenningsonEcologicalGovernance
BruceJennings,likeBrunoLatour,writ esaboutanewsocialcontract.Themajor themeofJennings’s2016book, EcologicalGovernance:TowardaNewSocialContractwith theEarth,isthathumansneedtomovefromthecurrentconsumptivesocialcontract toanewecologicalsocialcontract.
1.Governanceismorethangovernment,andthemeaningofthesocial contract
Jenningsdistinguishesgovernancefromgovernment: “Governanceistheoverallprocess ofcoordinating,shaping,anddirectingindividualandcollectiveagency.[It]isinherentlynormativeandvalue-laden. ::: [It]embodiesthecharacterofthecollectivity,representingthekindofsocietyanassociationofpeopleaspirestobeorbecome. [I]tswork istheconstructionofinstitutionalizednormativepracticeandsymbolicordersofmeaning.”6 Governanceinvolvesmorethanthegovernment;itinvolveseconomic,religious, cultural,andmanyothercivilsocietyinstitutions.
Thesocialcontractisatthebaseofgovernance. “ [It]referstothefundamental normsofcommonconsentthatprovidesocialcohesion.Itisthemutualagreement thatprovidesgroundsforourmoralidea lsandoursenseofworthandhappiness.” 7 Thesocialcontractlimitsfreedominthatpeopleagreetocommonrulesbecausethey needeachotherforsurvivaland fl ourishing,and,bydoingso,freedomarisesthat wouldnototherwisebepossible.
6 BRUCE JENNINGS,ECOLOGICAL GOVERNANCE:TOWARDA NEW SOCIAL CONTRACTWITHTHE EARTH 173-174(2016).
7 Id. at16.
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
2.Socialcontracttheories:Hobbes,Locke,andRousseau
ThethreegreatwritersonthesocialcontractareThomasHobbes(1588–1679),John Locke(1632 – 1704),andJean-JacquesRousseau(1712 – 1778).ForHobbes,humans aredrivenbythepassions especiallyfearsaboutsurvival notreason.Theyhave noinnatevirtueandoriginallylived,asdepictedinHobbes ’ masterpiece Leviathan, inastateofnaturethatwasnastyandbrutish awarofallagainstall.Peoplelacked adeterrentagainstattackandcommonrul esforcooperation,sotheyvoluntarily enteredintoasocialcontracttoobtainacommonsovereignfordefenseandenforcementoftherules.InHobbes’ sview,onceestablished,thepowerofthesovereignis absoluteandwithoutmorallimit onlyanabsolutesovereigncanavoidtheanarchy ofthestateofnature.Thesovereign,whichmaybeonepersonoranassemblyofpeople,definesthelawsandmorality.Scienceandcommerceareencouragedbutnotreligionormetaphysicalbeliefs.Peace,t ranquility,order,and,inHobbes ’ swords, “commodiousliving” arethepurposeofcivilsociety.8
Locke’ssocialcontracttheoryalsobeginswithastateofnature.Init,peopleare equalandpursuelife,health,liberty,andpossessions(property).Theyarenotamoral asimaginedbyHobbes,rathertheyaresubjecttothelawsofGodandnature,yetthey maybesel fi shandviolent.Humansarefree,but theyarethreatenedbyothers.The alternativetolifeinthisconditionisarep resentativegovernmentsubjecttothewill ofthemajoritythatprotectsthebasichumanrightstolife,liberty,andpropertyunder theruleoflawadministeredbyanimpartialjudge.Peoplearegovernedbytheirconsent.Theygranttothestateamonopolyontheuseofforce(reservingtherightto self-defense).Ifthestate,however,endeavorstobreachtheirrightstolife,liberty, andproperty,theyhavearightofrevolution.Governmentislimited;itsmainobligationsaretoprotecttherightsofitscitizens,especiallytheirpropertyrights,and provideforthecommondefense.
Rousseau,likeHobbesandLocke,sawtheformationofthesocialcontractasan actofreciprocalagreementtoliveinasoci etygovernedbylaws,rules,andpolitical authority(the “State”),butunlikeinHobbes,peoplenevercompletelytransferpower totheState.TheycontinuallyreaffirmandreenactthesocialcontracttoholdtheState incheck.Rousseaudidnotseethesourceofconflictthatleadstothecontractinthe natureofhumansbutratherinthefriction sofsocialexistenceaspeopleculturally andpsychologicallydevelop.Thus,conflict “isacontingentculturalandhistoricalcondition,notanaturalone.”9
UnlikeHobbesandLocke,Rousseaudidnotimagineapurestateofnatureprecedingthesocialcontract.Ratherhesawh umansmovingintosocietiesasanatural process.Thesocialcontractisameanstoorderlyliving,moraldevelopment,and human flourishing.TheStaterespondstoaneedoflivinginsociety inotherwords,
8 JenningsinterpretsHobbes’sversionofthesocialcontractasthebirthofthesocialcontractofconsumption inwhichfreeandequalpeopletransferauthoritytoasovereignforeconomicgrowthandmaterialwell-being. Id. at41.
9 Id. at42.
Chapter16:EcocentricGovernance:TheNewEcologicalSocialContract
oflivinginmutualdependenceandfellowshipofothers buttheStatemayalsobea sourceofoppression.Rousseausoughttoconstructatheoryofthesocialcontractby whichpeoplewouldhavethebene fi tofsocietyyetremainasfreeasbeforethecontract.Hisconceptionoffreedomisnott heabilitytodowhatonewantswithout restraint thisisenslavementtothepassions.Freedomistheabilitytoactinaccord withhigherlaws,rulesofuniversalapplicationthatmakecommunity,care,andassociationpossible.TheStatemay,inlikemanner,actinaccordwithsuchuniversallaws. Whenittreatsitsmembersequallyinaccordwiththecommongood,itaugments, ratherthandiminishes,individualfreedom.
Yet,itisuptothepeopletoensurethattheStatedoesthis.Sovereigntyresidesnot intheState,butinthegeneralwill(lavoluntégénéral)ofthepeople.AsG.D.H.Cole putsit, “[T]heStateisbasednotonanyoriginalconvention,[nor]onanydeterminate power,butonthelivingandsustainingrationalwillofitsmembers.”10 Thisisnotthe sumtotaloftheindividualwillsofthepeople Rousseaucallsthisthe “ willofall. ” Thegeneralwillistheimperishablesenseofthecommongoodinaccordwithamoral idealthatcallstheassociationintobeingandisoperativewithinit.Itisnotanabstract ideal;itexistsbyreasonoftheactivewillingofit. “[T]heGeneralWillisrealizednot whenthatisdonewhichisbestforthecommunity,butwhen,inaddition,thecommunityasawholehaswilledthedoingofit.ThenGeneralWilldemandsnotonlygood government,butalsoself-government notonlyrationalconduct,butgood-will. ” 11 Thissovereigntyisinalienablebecausethepeople,notthegovernment,aretheabsoluteandtheyultimatelycontroltheirowndestiny.
Jenningsdescribesthegeneralwillasfollows: [Thegeneralwill]isnotapersonoranof fice;itisamoralcultureandaspiritofcommunityandsolidarity.Itisacapacityforaradicallydemandingimpartialityofmoral intentionandthescrupulouslypublicuseofpoliticalpower. Itissociallyandpoliticallyembodiedinaparticipatoryrepublic,th atis,inasetofinterlockinggovernance institutionsthatrestontheperiodicre-creationofthegeneralwillbyapopularassembly ofallcitizens.Andthegeneralwilliscult urallyembeddedinaspecialformofmoral imaginationandcivicvirtue,oneinformedbytheindependentjudgmentofeachcitizen andbyastrongwidespreadsenseofcommonneed,vulnerability,andequalconcern andrespect.12
Thesocialcontract,sovereignty,andthe generalwillareallincontinuousprocessesofbecoming.Associationisn eededformoraldevelopmentandful fi llment. Forthepromiseofthisassociationtoberealized,peoplemustcommitthemselvesto itandactivelyengageinitforthecommongood.Theactualwillofthepeopleiscorrigiblebutthroughenlightenedpublicparticipationmaymovetowardtheidealgeneralwill. “ Thewillmustbe ‘ general ’ intwosenses:inthesenseinwhichRousseau
10 G.D.H.COLE, Introduction,in JEAN-JACQUES ROUSSEAU ,THE SOCIAL CONTRACT &DISCOURSES xxiv(G.D.H.Cole, trans.,1920).
11 Id. atxxxix.
12 JENNINGS, supra note6,at43.
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
usedtheword,itmustbegeneralinitsobject, i.e.universal;butitmustalsobegenerallyheld,i.e commontoallortothemajority.”13
Thegeneralwillisalwayspresentasamotivatingforce,evenwhenitisnotrealized. Thereasonitisnotachievedisbecauseoffactionalismand amour-propre “ vanity, self-regard,thetendencytogetone’ssenseofselffrombeingseenandapprovedofby others,insincerityandinauthenticity.”14 Whatisneededis pitié,whichcorrespondsto empathyorcompassion,theabilitytogobeyondoneself,andtheconsiderationofthe needsofothers.Thus,afterdescribingthegeneralwill,Jenningsstates: “[It]isaprecariousachievementinhumanhistory ::: thehighestexpressionofourcommunalhumanity,anditarisesfrom thedevelopmentofhumanityoutofnaturethroughculture.”15 Therefore, thereisaneedforaculturalordertocultivatethegoodthatisinhumannatureand provideeducationforenlightenedpoliticalengagementsothatthecommongoodor idealgeneralwillmightberealized.
3.Jennings’snewecologicalsocialcontract
BuildingonRousseau ’ swork,Jenningsextendsthe socialcontractfromone amonghumanstooneamonghumansandnature.Hestates: “ Thesphereofright, orjustice,asIunderstandit,includes(1)themoralcommunityofbothhumanand nonhumanlifeand(2)theecologicalcommons thesymbiotic,interdependentsystems,bothnaturalandsocial,uponwhi chhumanbeingandb ecomingdepend. ” 16 Thus,thegeneralwillisnotjustthatofhumansbutofhumansandnature,and,further,theculturalorderthatcultivate sandeducateshumansincludesnature ’ sorder andactivity.17 HisworkrespondstoLatour’scallforasocialcontractwithnature.Even thoughthereisanalreadyexistinghumans ocialcontract,planetarylimitshaveput humansandotherlivingbeingsinanew “ stateofnature ” thatisnolongerviable.
13 COLE, supra note10,atxl.Thatthegeneralwillmustbegenerallyheldrequirescommitmenttoademocratic processandrespectforthewisdomofthepeopleasawholeevenifitdoesnotagreewithone’spersonalpositionorinterest.Thisshould,however,notbeunderstoodasmeaningthatalldecisionsarrivedatthrougha democraticprocessexpressthegeneralwill.
14 JENNINGS, supra note6,at45. Amour-propre literallymeans “self-love,” butforRousseauthetermcarriesthis negativemeaningandnotthewilltosurviveandrespectfullycareforoneself,whichheinsteadcalls amoursoi .Jenningslaterfurtherdescribes amour-propre as “aninsecureandduplicitousidentity,andstrategically self-regardingandmanipulativebehavior.” Id. at54.
15 Id. at44(emphasisintheoriginal).
16 Id. at9.
17 Ingeneral,inmodernitynatureisconsideredamoralandthegoodmustcomesolelyfromhumanmorality. RémiBragueobserves: “TheimageoftheworldthatemergedfromphysicsafterCopernicus,Galileo,and Newtonisofaconfluenceofblindforces,wherethereisnoplaceforconsiderationoftheGood.” RÉMI BRAGUE, THE WISDOMOFTHE WORLD:THE HUMAN EXPERIENCEOFTHE UNIVERSEIN WESTERN THOUGHT 185(TeresaLavender Fagan,trans.,2003).Further,asthegoodwasnolongerunderstoodtobeinnature,ithadtobeintroducedby humans “byforce,bytakingnatureagainstthegrain. ” Id. at209.Numerouspeople,includingJenkins, havechallengedthisamoralassessmentofnatureanditsactivityonthebasisofthegoodnessoftheorder anddevelopmentoftheevolutionaryuniverseasrevealedinthepurposive,teleological,symbiotic,cooperative,sentient,interior,orsubjectiveaspectsofnature.JenkinsholdsupRobertNadeauinsupportofhisassessment.Jennings, supra note6,at62.OthersincludeThomasBerry,TeilharddeChardin,andLynnMargulis.
Chapter16:EcocentricGovernance:TheNewEcologicalSocialContract
Thus,anewecologicalsocialcontractisneededfororderlyliving,moraldevelopment, andthe flourishingofallspecies.
AccordingtoJennings,theexistingsocialcontractofconsumptionistheproduct ofthehistoryofmodernity.Thisbeginsinthesixteenthcenturywithemancipation fromtheconstraintsoffeudalism.TheEnl ightenmentoftheseventeenthandeighteenthcenturiesgaverisetoempiricism,materialism,science,technology,reason,utilitarianism,diversity,tolerance,secularliberalism,separationofchurchandstate,lack oftranscendentvalueinpublicculture,andlossofthecommons.TheIndustrialRevolutionofthenineteenthandtwentieth centuriesmeantthemarketeconomyand commodi fi cationofnatureandlabor.Thisledtoadevelopmentmodelbasedon carbon-intensiveenergyuse,technology,andconsumerism.IntheGreatAcceleration, theperiodfollowingWorldWarII,18 thepoliticaleconomyshiftedfromegalitarianliberalismtomarketliberalism(neolibera lism)predicatedontheassumptionthatthe optimalresultsforhumancivilizationw ouldbeobtainedbycontinuouseconomic growth.Thefundamentalvaluesofmoderni tyarefreedom,equality,humanrights, pursuitofhappiness,andpossessiveindividualism.Intheconsumptivesocialcontract, ordinarycitizensgivepoliticalandbusinesselitescontrolinexchangeforthepromise ofeconomicgrowthandimprovedmaterialconditions.
Attheheartofthissocialcontractisapoliticaleconomy.19 “Apoliticaleconomyis astructureofpowerandaformoflarge-scalesocialcoordination.”20 Itisthewaythat societyorganizesitselftomeethumanneedsandmaterialaspirations.Itissociallyconstructedbasedonvaluesandassumptionsa ndtheavailabilityofmaterialsandtechnologies.Itisarule-basedsystemfortheuseandconservationofresourcesandthe productionanddistributionofgoodsandservices.Thepoliticaleconomyofthesocial contractofconsumptionassumesunlimitedresources,unlimitedsinks,21 andcontinuouseconomicgrowththroughindustrialdevelopment.Theopponentofthispolitical economyisnaturallimits.
[T]heacceleratingglobalextractiveassaultonplanetaryresourcesandecosystems,as wellastheunprecedentedextensionsofourtechnologicalreach,donottrulyrepresent progressandthetriumphofhumanfreedomorthehumandestiny.Whynot?[Because] theyarenotsustainableorviableasaroadtothefuture. Whileseemingtoextend humanfreedom,economicbehaviorandtechnologyarelayingthegroundworkforits repression;whileseeminglyrepresentingtheadvancedexpressionofhumancapability, theyareactuallyunderminingwhatismostpreciousinhumanness.22
18 PlanetaryDashboardShows “GreatAcceleration ” inHumanActivitySince1950 ,IGPD,http://www.igbp.net/ news/pressreleases/pressreleases /planetarydashboardshowsgreatac celerationinhumanactivitysince 1950.5.950c2fa1495db7081eb42.html(lastvisitedApril21,2020).
19 Apoliticaleconomyismorethanadescriptionofnaturalresourcesandthemeansbywhichgoodsandservicesareproducedanddistributedwithinagivensociety.Apoliticaleconomyincludesthepublicpoliciesand socialvaluesthatgiverisetoandsustainaparticulareconomy.
20 JENNINGS, supra note6,at22.
21 A “sink” isaplacewherehumanwastemayberecycledwithoutharmtotheenvironment.
22 JENNINGS, supra note6,at27-28.
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
Thedilemmaforleaderstodayisthat,ontheonehand, “[s]ocialorderandstabilityinvirtuallyeverynationrestsoneconomicactivitybasedontheintensiveprocurementanduseofenergy-richfossilfuels. ::: [This]hasmadepossiblemostofmodern technologyandindustrialcivilization; ” 23 andontheotherhand,theprocurement anduseofthesefuelsandtheindustrialsystemstheysupportposesanimminentthreat tocivilization.Modernity’sstorylineisthatnaturallimitscanbealwaysbeovercomeby technologicalinnovationorsubstitutionofmaterialsorsources.Jenningspointsout, however,thatearliernaturallimitswerenotovercome;rather,humansfoundnatural pathwaysthatwouldhandletheburdenofhumanextractionandproductionofwaste andpollutionatthosetimes. 24 Arehumansnowfacingabsolutenaturallimits,sometimescalled “planetaryboundaries,” thatmakethecontinuationoftheconsumptive socialcontractnotonlyunwiseinthene artermbutalsoimpossibleinthemedium andlongterm?ForJennings,theanswerispresumptivelyyes.
Inconsiderationofthispresumption,Jennings,asasocialcontracttheorist,25 puts forwardanecologicalsocialcontractasbeingnormativelythebestforourtimes.In rejectingtheideathatonlytechnologi calchangesareneeded,healignswithand quotesPopeFrancisin LaudatoSi’ :
Ecologicalculturecannotbereducedtoaseriesofurgentandpartialresponsestothe immediateproblemsofpollution,environmentaldecayandthedepletionofnatural resources.Thereneedstobeadistinctivewayoflookingatthings,awayofthinking, policies,aneducationalprogramme,alifestyleandaspiritualitywhichtogethergenerateresistancetotheassaultofthetechnocraticparadigm. Toseekonlyatechnical remedytoeachenvironmentalproblemwhichcomesupistoseparatewhatisinreality interconnectedandtomaskthetrueanddeepestproblemsoftheglobalsystem.26
Thisquoteoffersasegueintoadiscussionoftheimportanceofvaluesystemsina socialcontract.Peopleenterasocialcontractforsurvivalanddefense(negativereasons)andalso,associalbeings,tobewhomtheyaspiretobeforhappiness,fulfillment, andmeaning,andforhowtheycanextendthecapabilitiesfor fl ourishingtoothers (positivereasons).27 Thus,alsoattheheartofasocialcontractare “ethicalprinciples, rules,andnorms,which,whentheyareac ceptedandpracticedwidelyenough, becomeanorientinganddirectingforceinsociety.”28 Thesestandardsgrowoutoftraditionandaremaintainedbyhabit,butarealsocreatedbyre fl ection.Whena
23 Id. at158.
24 Id. at24.
25 ForJennings,socialcontracttheoryhasanormativetask,whichistolayout “whatittakestobeanappropr iategeneralformofculturalbeing[inorderto]providearegulativeideal,againstwhichanyparticularexistingculturalarrangementscanbejudged.” Id. at51.Cultureisthesociallytransmittedsystemsofmeaningsand beliefsthroughwhichweinterpretourexperienceandassignvaluetoit.Insocialcontracttheoryitalso includespoliticalculture,whichis thewaypowerisorganizedthroughsystems,institutions,andsymbols, andthemodeoforderlycooperationoflargegroupsofpeoplewhoshareasenseofcommoninterestand membership.Humansintheiroriginalconditionlackapoliticalculture.Socialcontracttheorytells “howa placeistobecreated(civilsociety)inwhichthepotentialcreatureswearecanbecomeactualandfully human,howeverthatistobecharacterized rational,cooperative,productive,moral.” Id. at49.
26 PopeFrancis, LaudatoSi’:CareforOurCommonHome §111(2015)(quotedbyJENNINGS, supra note6,at151).
27 JENNINGS, supra note6,at89.
28 Id.
historicalshiftoccurs,suchasisoccurringintheearlytwenty-firstcentury,thechanges canbequiteradical.
Jennings’sappealtomoralityisanimportantfactorinthemovetoanewecologicalsocialcontractastheremustbeamoraljusti ficationforpeopletoforegothebenefitsoftheconsumptivesocialcontract.29 Withoutwidespreadconsent,thereisnonew ecologicalsocialcontract,thereisonlyapartisangroupwithinsocietythatholdsecologicalvalues.Thenewcontractinvolvesreasonedconviction,ameasureofcontentment,andanappealtoidealsofahigherorder.Thesocialcontractisnota bargainedagreementforpersonalbene fit;itisamoralcommunity.
Withthisasbackground,Jenningsofferswhathetakestobethekeytermsofthe ecologicalsocialcontract:
Thesetermsare:(1)creatingasystemofwealththatmovesbeyondaf fl uenceand scarcitytoplentitudeandfrugality;(2)creatingasystemofpropertythatmovesbeyond commoditiestocommons;(3)creatingasystemoffreedomorlibertythatmoves beyondnoninterferenceandindependentself-suf fi ciencytorelationalityandinterdependence;and(4)creatingasystemofcitize nshipthatmovesbeyondself-interested advantagetotrusteeshipforrightrelationshipandrightrecognition.30
Thetransitionfromtheconsumptivesocialcontracttotheecologicalsocialcontractwillbedifficult: “Anewsocialcontractforecologicalgovernancewillneedtonavigatecon flictingsocialandeconomicinterestsandblockingcoalitionsonmanyfronts. Itmustbecontinuallyrecreatedandrenewed. ” 31 “ [It]mustprovidethetransitional generationofcitizenswithawaytorespondpositivelytotheforeclosingofanunsustainablegrowthfuturetheyhavebeentaughttoexpect. ” 32 Itmustshowthatitcan achievejusticeintermsofequityforpresentgenerationsandforfuturegenerations. Anditmustofferthepromiseofsustainabilityandcarefornature.
Jenningsisconcernedaboutthefutureofdemocraticsocieties.Heforeseesthree possibletypesofgovernanceorientationsinanecologicalpoliticaleconomy.The first is ecologicalauthoritarianism . “[E]cologicalauthoritariansmaintainthatthesuccessful governanceinanecologicalerawillrequirecentralized,elitist,andtechnocraticmanagementatleastintheareasofeconomicandenvironmentalpolicy.”33
Thesecondis ecologicaldiscursivedemocracy . “ [It]involvesinstitutionalizationand empowermentofparticipatoryanddiscursivegovernancewithinadiverseandpluralisticsocietyandculture. ::: [It]growsdirectlyoutofconcertedactionwithothers, shapedbydebateanddeliberation.” Itdiffersfromthecurrentinterestgroupdemocracy,whichinvolvestheaggregationofinterestsofdifferentgroupsinadiversepopulationwithcon fl ictinginterests.Thesegroupscompetefortheattentionofelected officials.Theroleofthecitizencentersaroundvoting,withonlyafewplayingalarger rolethrough fi nancialcontributionsorinvolvementinpoliticalactiongroups.In
29 Id. at128.
30 Id. at9.
31 Id. at175.
32 Id.
33 Id. at182. Chapter16:EcocentricGovernance:TheNewEcologicalSocialContract
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
contrasttodiscursivedemocracy, “thecitizenroleisactivelyandextensivelyparticipatoryatmultiplelevels.” InJennings’sview,interestgroupdemocracy “ispronetoincrementalismandpreservationofthestatusquo. ”“ [It]isnotsucceedingandis structurallyincapableofpresidingoverthetransitionfromaconsumptivegrowthorientedpoliticaleconomytoanecologicalpoliticaleconomy.”34
Thethirdis ecologicalconstitutionalism .Ecologicalconstitutionalism “wouldinvolve thecreationofseveralelitegoverningentitiesthatcancheckandbalancethemore representativeinstitutionssuchasthepresidencyorlegislature.”35 Therearealready examplesofsuchentities,withthemostfamiliarbeingthejudiciary.TheFederal Reserveisanotherexamplewithauthorityovermonetarypolicy.Yetanotherexample isindependentadministrativeagenciesthatareprotectedfrompoliticalin fluence.The kindsofentitiesthatwouldbeneededforanecologicalpoliticaleconomymightbe specialenvironmentalcourtsmodeledonthebusinesscourtsthatalreadyexistinvariousstates,administrativeagencieswithdifferentpowersthanexistingenvironmental protectionagencies,orcivilsocietygroupsthatexerciseonlysoftpower.36
Jenningsbelievesthatthebestoveralloutcomeisprobablyacombinationofdiscursivedemocracyandecologicalconstitutionalism.
A finalthemeofnoteinJennings’sworkisrecoveryofthepolitical,whichisaconcernofLatour’saswell.Thepresentconsumptivesocialcontractgivesindividualfreedom 37 butnotrelationalfreedom.38 Itworksagainstrelationalfreedom,whichisthe abilitytoactinsolidaritywithothersforthecommongood.Relationalfreedomiswhat isneededtomeetthedemandsofthefutur e.Intheecologica lsocialcontract, “ the problemofpoliticsisnottoseekpower,buttoresistit;andnottodenyvulnerability anddependencybuttoembracethemcreatively.Theproblemof[this]politicsisto resistthekindofpoweranddominationthatactuallyrenderitsagentsimpotentand enthralled.Theproblemof[this]politicsistoacceptrestraintsonbehalfofcommunal agencyandrelationalfreedom. ” 39 “ Itneedsthevocabularyofsolidarity,mutuality, reciprocity,communityandthecommongood.”40
34 Id. at140,180-184.
35 Id. at185.
36 JenningsholdsuptheEarthCharterInitiativeasanexampleofsuchacivilsocietygroup. See EarthCharter Initiative,https://earthcharter.org/(lastvisitedMarch30,2020).TheEarthCharterwascreatedbyahighly participatoryprocessandiswellregardedasavisionforsociety.Atpresent,itlacksthesoftpowertoactasa checkongovernmentsandeconomies.Whetherasoft-powerethicsgroupcouldcheckthepowerofcorporationsandgovernmentsisanopenquestion.
37 AccordingtoJennings,theconsumptivesocialcontractisbasedonnegativefreedom.Negativefreedomis “ self-directedindividualagencyfreefrominterferencebyothersinthepursuitofthesubjectivesatisfactionofneedsthatare ontologicallyandpsychologicallylimitlessandinsatiable.” Id. at128(emphasisintheoriginal).
38 “[R]elationallibertyisfreedominandthroughrelationshipsofinterdependency.Morespeci fically[itis] freedomthroughtransactionsandrelationshipsofinterdependencywithothersthatexemplifyjustice(parityofmembership, voice,andparticipation)andsolidarity (mutualityofcivicconcernandrespect) ” Id., at130-131(emphasisinthe original).
39 Id. at194.
40 Id. at134.
448
Chapter16:EcocentricGovernance:TheNewEcologicalSocialContract
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1)BrunoLatoursaysEarth(Gaia)isbothmother(nurturing)andother(hasa dangerousquality).HowdoesthisdistinctionhelpEarthlawtorecognizethat natureisbothnurturingandthreatening?
(2)LatoursaysthatbybringingissuesdowntoEarthandaskingbasicquestions aboutaviablefutureforhumansandtheirdependenceonEarth,Terrestrials sharpenthedistinctionsbetweenleftan dright,conservativeandliberal,reactionaryandprogressive,andglobalandlocal,andcasttheminanewlight. Howmightthisbeso?
(3)HowdoesJenningsdistinguishbetweengovernmentandgovernance?
(4)Describetheconsumptivesocialcontractanditsmostcriticalelements.
(5)Describetheecologicalsocialcontractanditsmostcriticalelements.
(6)BothLatourandJenningssaythesocialcontractamonghumansaloneisincompleteandneedstoincludenature.Doyouthinkthismeansthatthehuman socialcontractneedstotakenaturemorefullyintoaccount,orthatthereneeds tobeacontractamonghumansandnonhumannature?Ifthelatter,howwould itbepossibleforhumanstohaveacontractwithnonhumannature?Whatwould nature ’srolebeinthegeneralwill?
III.THEROLEOFLAWYERSINECOLOGICALGOVERNANCE
Theremainderofthischapterconcernstheroleoflawyersinecologicalgovernance, andhowtheymightplayapartindevelopinganewsocialcontract.Itcoverstheplace oflawyersinsociety;acceptingEarthasaclient;Earthlawyersandtheecologicalsocial contract;Earthlawyersandthereformoflaw;andacasestudyoftherightsofnature lawsinBolivia.
A.ThePlaceofLawyersinSociety
Formostlawyers,governmentalbodiesandtheirlawsformthebackdropoftheirpractices.Theydevotelittleoftheirattentiontogovernanceitself(withnotableexceptions, suchaslobbyists).Manystudentscometolawschoolexpectingtolearnsocialtheory andpoliticaladvocacyand findinsteadtheylearn “THELAW.” Theirtaskistolearn thelawandunderstandhowlawappliestofa ctualsituations.Afterlawschool,they
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
applythisskillintheirpracticesbyactingasadvocatesfortheirclients,whichmeans helpingclientsachievetheirgoalswithintheboundsofthelaw.
Aslawyerscarryontheirpractices,theymay,overtime,becomelessclearastohow muchTHELAWisdeterminative.Incourt,opposinglawyersarguethefactsandthe law,yetclaimdifferentresults.Inappealscourts,legalargumentsaremadeandthen somejudgesruleonewayandothersanother.Further,practicinglawyersmay findsituationswherelawisnotdeterminativeintermsofachievingjustice.Itmaybecome clearthatthelegalsystemisameansofpowerandexclusionandthatitiscloselytied tothegoalofprogressthroughcontinuousandunlimitedeconomicgrowth.Itmay alsobecomeclearhowlawstructuresrelationshipsbycreating lawscapes oflandand societies.Formanylawyers,practicingEarthlawandmakingalivingwillseeminconfl ict.WhatisgoodfortheEarthmaynotbewhatclientswantandwhatclientswant maynotbegoodfortheEarth.Practicinglawyerswill findthattherulesofprofessional ethicsdonotcovermanyoftheethicalissuesrelatedtoEarthlaw.
Anattorneyisanagent,yetinrespectofEarthlaw(thoughlesssoinrespectof environmentallaw),attorneysmayfeelatalossforagency,or,inotherwords,intheir abilitytoactonbehalfofEarth.Thisisbecausetheirpracticesmayseemunrelatedto Earthlaworevencountertoit.Further,iftheyconsciouslyundertakeanEarthlaw practice,theywillfaceobstaclesinthewaythelegalsystemisstructured.Forexample, doctrinesofpropertylawandissuesofsta nding,asdiscussedinChapters4and5of thisbook,imposeimpediments.
Yet,whoisbetterpositionedthanlawyerstobringintobeingecological governance?
Lawyershavespecialskillsinanalysis,organization,andexpressionofthought,in organizationofentities,innegotiationoftransactions,andinsettlementofdisputes. Manyhaveskillsinovercomingfactionalis mandroadblockstomovethingsforward andinformingandmaintainingalliances.Theyaregrantedenviablestatusin society anylawyerknowsthepowerofsaying, “I’malawyer. ” Onthewhole,lawyers areaffluentmembersofsociety.Historically,theyhaveplayedprominentrolesinelectiveandappointedpositionsofgovernment.Theyalsoplayprominentrolesinsocial organizationsfromchurchestofoundationstothinktankstoadministrationsofuniversities.Barassociationsandlegalsocietieshaveinfl uenceontheappointmentofjudges, andtheyareconsultedonlegislationandpublicpolicy.
And,mostimportantofall,lawyersaretrainedinthelawandareembeddedinthe legalsystem.
B.TakingonEarthasaClient:ARealityCheck
Aqualitythatisimportanttothepracticeof lawisbeingrealistic.Practicinglawyers receivelittletonorewardforwhattheythinkoughttobethecase.Theyaremeasured forthemostpartbytheresultstheyachieve.Lawisanintenseintellectualexercisein thatlawyersarecalledontounderstandcomplexfactualsituationsandweighlegal, social,andeconomicfactorsinadvisingandrepresentingtheirclientstoprovidethe
Chapter16:EcocentricGovernance:TheNewEcologicalSocialContract
bestoutcomes.Lawyersmayagreeordisagreewiththeirclients’ goals,values,anddecisions,yet,solongastheymaintaintherelationship,theyseektofurthertheirclients’ goalswithinthelaw.Indoingso,thetaskofthelawyeristoassessandactonwhatis realistically possible.
Whatifalawyer’sclientwereEarthandtheclient’sgoalwastosurviveandthrive? Yourclientwantsyourrepresentationinpromotingchangefromanthropocentricto ecocentricgovernance.Thisrepresentationinvolvesalevelofcomplexitynotheretoforeimagined.Still,thelawyermightdrawontheskillstheyhaveacquired listen, learn,assesswhatandwhoyoucanrelyonandwhataretheobstacles, berealistic . :::
Youwill findthatasanEarthlawyer,youwillreceivehighlycon flictingaccountsof thestateoftheplanet,theneedsoftheplanet,andhowEarthlawshouldbepracticed. Thiswillnotonlybethecasewiththeplanetbutalsowiththeparticularenvironmental situationsofhumansandotherspecies.BelievingoneknowshowtosaveEarthoreven therightwaytopracticeEarthlawisaliabilitynotanasset.Earthlawyersareseekers, informationhounds,criticalthinkers,anddreamers.Theyareparticipantsinaprocess ofhealingthatwilloutlivethem.Indecidingwhattodo,theyshouldask, “ Willthis engenderlife?”
Theyshouldberealisticwhilestillreachingforandplanningtoaccomplishwhat hasnotbeendonebefore.
C.EarthLawyersandtheEcologicalSocialContract
TheoverarchingtaskofeveryEarthlawyer istobringintobeingthenewecological socialcontract.Withoutthis,nomatterhowmanyEarthlawvictoriesarewon,the objectiveofEarthlawwillnotbeachieved.TobeanEarthlawyer,onedoesnotneed tobeanenvironmentallawyer.AnylawyermaybeanEarthlawyer.AnEarthlawyer isalawyerwhoiswillingtotakeasstartingpointsthatnaturehaslimits,thattheconsumptivesocialcontractisunsustainable,andthatanewecologicalsocialcontractis needed.Earthlawyerscommittobringinganewecologicalsocialcontractintobeing bythought,word,anddeed.
Theycannotdothisactingalone;theycandothisonlyinconcertwithotherlikemindedpeopleinlawandinotherwalksoflife.Ultimatelyforthecontracttocome intobeing,itwillrequiretheconsentofthewholesociety.Inagloballyconnected world,itwillrequiretheconsentofallpeople.Thiswouldnotmeanthateachperson intheworldwouldhavetogiveconsciousconsenttoanexpresswrittensocialcontract anymorethanthiswasrequiredtobringi ntobeingthepresentconsumptivesocial contract.Itwouldmeanpeopleconsciouslyorunconsciouslywouldbecomepartofa newmoralcultureandanewpoliticaleconomy.Inaspiritofcommunityandsolidarity,theywouldacceptnewwaysofdoingthingsaswellastheinstitutionsthatembody themandmakethempossible.Itwouldmeanpeoplewouldhavealevelofsatisfaction thatinthisnewarrangementtheycouldbewhattheyaspiretobeandtheycould extendthecapabilitiesfor fl ourishingtoothers.
Asnotedabove,lawyersbringspecialskills,abilities,socialstatus,androlestothis task.Iftheyarecorporatelawyers,theycouldguidetheirclientsinunderstandingthat thefailuresoftheoldaretheopportunitiesofthenew.Theycouldhelptheirclients seethatpro fitsareameanstoprovidingneededgoodsandservicesandemployment, notanendinthemselves,thatthegrantingofapubliccharteristhegrantofapublic trust,andthatthe fi duciaryresponsibilitiesofof fi cersanddirectorsextendtothe entirecommunityoflife.Corporatelawye rsandotherlawyersinvolvedinbusiness law,suchasemployment,banking,securitie s,tax,realestate,andbusinesslitigation lawyers,areinvolvedatahighlevelinalltheactivitiesoftheconsumptivepolitical economy.Theycouldmodelhumilityandthevaluesoftheecologicalpoliticaleconomyintheirownpersonallives,intheirpractices,andintheirlaw firms.Thechoices theycouldmakeinhowtheylive,theconferencestheyattend,andtherolestheytake oninthecommunitywouldmakeadifferenc e.Thetableconversationstheycould havewiththeirclientswouldaswell.Whileitmightseemdif fi culttobringupEarth law,peopleareinterestedintheEarthandhowtheycanmakeadifference.Bybeing Earthlawyers,theywouldattractclientswhoaremovingonthepathtoanecological politicaleconomy.Theycoulddrawthelin ewhenwhattheirclientsaredoingis wrong evenifitislegal.Theycouldpracticethespiritofthelawaswellastheletter ofthelaw.Ifneeded,theycoulddiscontinuetherepresentationofclients.Business lawyerscouldengageinthereformoflawsandtheestablishmentofthenewinstitutionsfortheecologicalsocialcontract.Theycouldbecomeengagedincivic,political, andreligiousassociationswithothermembersofsociety.
Earthlawyerswhoarenotbusinesslawyerscould findsimilarwaysofbringinginto beinganewecologicalsocialcontract.Forexample,intellectualpropertylawyerscould seektoreformpatentlawsothatitbenefitstheecosystemsfromwhichmany “human inventions ” arederived. 41 Estateplanninglawyerscouldworkwiththeirclientsto bequeathsomeoralloftheirestateforthepermanentbenefi tofnature,aswellas forthebene fitofIndigenouspeoplesandotherswhoselandhasbeentaken.Criminal lawyerscouldcallfortherecognitionofecocideasacrime,bothintheInternational CriminalCourtandinnationallegalsyste ms.Civilrightslawyerscouldlendtheir expertisetoemergingrights-basedmovementsfornature.Votingrightslawyerscould helpconceptualizeandimplementeffect ivevotingschemesonbehalfofnonhuman ecosystemsandanimals.Environmentallawyerscouldcontinueenforcingenvironmentallawswhilecallingforpassageofanewgenerationofecocentriclaws.Everylawyer couldhavearole.
Lawyers,however,cannothelpbyintentionalone.Theymustengageinthetaskin thought,word,anddeed.42
41 TheInterspeciesTechnologyTransferConsortiumseekstodojustthis. See EarthLawCenter, Interspecies TechnologyTransferConsortium ,https://www.earthlawcenter.org/ international-1?rq=interspecies% 20technology(lastvisitedApr.19,2020).
42 Usingdifferentterminology,ThomasBerrycallsthistaskthe “GreatWork” ofourtime.Itmaybehelpfulfor EarthLawyerstothinkofthisoverarchingtaskofbringingintobeinganewecologicalsocialcontractasthe GreatWork. Seegenerally THOMAS BERRY,THE GREAT WORK:OUR WAYINTOTHE FUTURE (1999).
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw 452
Chapter16:EcocentricGovernance:TheNewEcologicalSocialContract
D.EarthLawyersandtheReformofLaw:NormativeJurisprudence
MuchofthisbookisdevotedtolitigationstrategiesinEarthlaw.Attorneystodayare arguingfortherightsofnature,thepublictrust,therightsoffuturegenerations,and environmentalhumanrights.LitigationisessentialfortheadvancementofEarthlaw.
Thissectionofthischapter,however,coversadifferentaspectofEarthlaw the roleofEarthlawyersinthereformofpositivelawandinthemeansofenforcingsuch law. Positivelaw forpurposesofthischaptermeanswrittenlaws,suchasstatutes,regulations,constitutions,andcivilandcriminalprocedure.Enforcementofpositivelaw meansmakingsuchlawoperationalandeffective.
Lawschoolsfocusonwhatthelawis,notwhatitshouldbe.Whilepracticing lawyersandlegalscholarsdoadvocateforchangesinlaw,thesereformstendtobe withinanarrowframeofreferenceconsistentwiththeconsumptivesocialcontract, suchasreformstoadvancetheeconomicint erestsofclients.(Notableexceptions includelawyersadvancingjusticeandwelfarereformsforhumansandnature.)Normativejurisprudence “bothcriticizes[existing]positivelawandsuggestsreformsonthe basisofstatedmoralvaluesandlegalisticideals. ” 43 Itconcerns “ [t]henatureofthe legalgood whatmakeslawgoodandvirtuesagoodlawoughttohave.”44 InterpretingThomasAquinas’sfamousstatementin SummaTheologica, “Anunjustlawisnolaw atall,” onewouldsayalawmusthaveamoraljustificationforittobebinding.Normativejurisprudenceseekstounderstandthemoraljustificationforparticularlawsorthe lackofthesameandproposesgoodlawonthebasisofmoralclaims.
Whatisamoralclaim?Atitssimplest,a moralclaim isastatementmadeofakind thatwhenapersonhearsthestatement,sheresponds, “Yes,thisismyduty.ItissomethingIoughttodo. ” Lawsneedtobelargelyself-enforcing.Forexample,peopleare askedto fi letaxreturnsthatstatetheirtrueincomeandthentheyaretaxedonthis income.Onlyrarelywilltheybeauditedif theydonotaccuratelyrepresenttheir income.Fearofpotentialenforcementactivitymotivatescompliance,butevenmore, itisthesensethatobeyingthelawiswhatoneoughttodotoprovideforthepublic welfare.Ifpeopledonotfeelthismoralobligationandtheyfeelenforcementis unlikely,compliancewillbelow.
Jennings,followingonRousseau,however,offersabroaderconceptionofmoral obligation.Lawsarenotjustwhatiswrittenonpaper;theyarewilledintobeingand aremaintainedbyanactivewill.Whentheynolongerserveapublicpurpose,they mayremainonthebooksbuthavenoeffect.Somelawscomeintobeingby “particular wills” andaremaintainedbythem.Somelawscomeintobeingbythegeneralwill,but whentheirtimeispast,theyaremaintainedbyparticularwillsandperhapswilllaterbe reformedbythegeneralwill.
Thewaythattheconceptofthegeneralwillchangesmoraljustificationisthatits moralityismorethanone ’ spersonalsenseofwhatIoughtoroughtnotdo.Itisa moralityderivedfromapublicdiscourseaboutthecommongood.Itisalwaysmore
43 ROBIN WEST,NORMATIVE JURISPRUDENCE:AN INTRODUCTION i(2011).
44 Id. at7.
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
thanone’spersonalknowledgeordetermination thisiswhycitizensreadop-eds,talk withfriendsabouttheirconcerns,gotoschool,listentothenews,enterintoconversationsinreligiousandsocialgroups,readmagazines,andprayandmeditateinconcert withothers.Someoftheconsiderationsthatemergewillbequitenarrow;thesearethe particularwills,orthosethatonlytakeintoaccounttheneedsofonegrouporinterest. Otherconsiderationsarebroaderastheyareseekingnotonlythegoodofaparticular grouporinterestbutthegreatergood.Thegeneralwilldoesnotadheretosome abstracthighervalueorposition,suchasadoctrine,anideology,aparticularreligious teachingorbelief,theviewsofatalkshowhost,orapoliticalpartyorfaction.Itcomes outofenlightenedpublicdiscourse thewillingofthepeopleforthecommongood. “[T]hemostgeneralwillisalwaysthemostjustalso,and[itisfoundin]thevoiceofthe people.”45
Thereisno fi nalarbiterandnodeitywhoannouncesthisgeneralwill.Itisan ongoingprocessofdiscernment,itisalwaysatwork,anditisalwaysrightinthesense ofMartinLutherKing,Jr.’sstatementthat “thearcofthemoraluniverseislong,but itbendstowardjustice”— thatbend,however,occursonlythroughtheactiveparticipationofpeopleindiscerningandwillingthecommongood.46 Thisdiscerningdoesnot, however,resultina fi nal,clearconsensusagreement.Thediscerningisanongoing processandwhatthegeneralwilliswillbeexpressedindiverseways;nonetheless,this discerningwillbeaunifyingforceforgood.Itwillonlybeunderstoodinretrospect, and,eventhen,interpretationswillvary.
Thus,inthisunderstanding,Aquinas’sstatementthat “anunjustlawisnolawat all” wouldmeantheunjustlawisnotsupportedbythegeneralwillandwillnotstand. Normativejurisprudenceinthisunderstandingwouldmeanthatmoralclaimsinsupportofreformedlawandenforcementthereofshouldbebasedonthegeneralwill andnotsomeparticularinterestormoralframe.
WhatJenningsaddstoRousseauisthatthepublicdiscourseextendstonatureand, therefore,necessarilybeyondhumanlanguage.Thecosmostakesonamoralcharacter andnaturebecomesasourceofwisdom.47 ForRousseau,humanfreedomisfoundin thecommongoodforhumans;forJennings,humanfreedomisfoundinthecommon goodfortheEarthcommunity,includinghumans,whererivers,birds,andwindsalso speakandlisten,andwehumanslistenandspeaktothem,aswell.Itisworthrecalling thatforJenningsandRousseau,freedomisnotprimarilylicense(negativefreedom),it isrelationalfreedom.Onegivesupthefreedomofthestateofnatureinordertohave thegreaterfreedomthatcomesfrombeinginrelationwithothers.Thedistinctionis easilyunderstoodbyreferencetothedynamicsofthenuclearfamily.Ifallfamilymembersinsistondoingjustwhattheywant,thereisnofamily,onlydiscord.Whenfamily memberstakeintoaccounttheneedsofothers,thereisthefreedomtoliveinsupportiveandresponsiverelationships.
45 Jean-JacquesRousseau, DiscourseonPoliticalEconomy, IN THE SOCIAL CONTRACT &DISCOURSES 254(G.D.H.Cole trans.,1920).Rousseau’sactualstatementofthesecondclauseis “andthatthevoiceofthepeopleisinfactthe voiceofGod.” Id.
46 See MychalDenzelSmith, TheTruthAbout “TheArcoftheMoralUniverse,” HUFFINGTON POST (Jan.18,2018), https://www.huffpost.com/entry/opinion-smith-obama-king_n_5a5903e0e4b04f3c55a252a4.
47 Thisisabreachwithmodernity’sunderstandingofnatureandthecosmosasamoral; seesupra note17.
454
Chapter16:EcocentricGovernance:TheNewEcologicalSocialContract
ItwillbeachallengeforEarthlawyerstolistentoEarth’snonhumanlanguagesin consideringthegeneralwill;yet,ifJennin gsisright,theirsuccesswilldependonit. Thiswillinvolveoutside-the-boxthinking.Considerthisextensionofthefranchiseto nonhumanbeingsproposedbyexperimentalphilosopherJonathonKeatsatSanJosé StateUniversity:
Ifthegeneralwillincludesthewillofanimalsandplants,evenbacteria,shouldn’tthey alsobeenfranchisedindemocraticdecision-making?Althoughthisquestionmayat first seemtobepurelyphilosophical,therearewaystodothisinpractice.Forinstance, sciencehasthetoolstomeasurestresshormonesinmanyspecies.Changesinaggregate stressmightpotentiallybepolled,revealinghowthosespeciesarereactingtothecurrentbodyoflaw.Anincreaseinstresshormonelevelsinenoughorganismsmightcount asacallforchangeinthelegal statusquo.Datacouldinformthechoicesmadebyhuman votersorlegislatorswhoarevoluntarilyac tingasproxiesonanon-bindingbasis.Ata greaterextreme,takingthegeneralwilltomeanthewillofGaia,andaccordingGaia withtherighttoself-determination,itcouldbearguedthatthevotesofanimalsand plantsthemselvesoughttobecountedof fi ciallyinthechoiceofrepresentativesorin legislativedecisions.48
Nonationhasyetgrantednaturetherighttovoteinthisway.TheBoliviancase studybelow,however,showshowIndigenouspeopleinBoliviasoughttogivenature avoiceingovernment avoicetheyhadlongincludedintheirpolity.
E.TheRightsofNatureinBolivia
1.Thehistoricalexperience
Boliviaisaland-lockedcountrylocatedinwestern-centralSouthAmerica.Ithashada tumultuoushistory,includingabrutalperiodofSpanishcolonialrulefollowed,during independence,bymanychangesofgovernmentandwarswithneighboringcountries. BoliviaisoneofthepoorestcountriesintheWesternHemisphereasmeasuredbystandardeconomics.MininghasbeenakeyfeatureoftheBolivianeconomyforcenturies andremainssotoday.
AmajorityofBoliviansidentifyasIndigenous.In2005,Boliviaelectedits firstIndigenouspresident,EvoMorales.Hisvictorywasseenasanoutcomeofdecadesofstruggle againstneoliberalpolitics.MoralesbroughtwithhimIndigenousvaluesoflivingwell (sumaqamaña/vivirbien)andrespectforMotherEarth(Pachamama 49 ).In2006,with thebackingofacoalitionofIndigenousorganizationscalledthe “UnityPact,” Morales convenedaConstitutionalAssemblywiththegoalofformingaplurinationalstate
48 ThisideahasrecentlybeenexploredbytheindependentexperimentalphilosopherJonathonKeats,who hasprototypedasystemfor “phytodemocracy” incollaborationwithresearchersatSanJoséStateUniversity. 49 ForQuechua-speakingpeople,Pachamamaisnotequivalentto “nature” oreven “MotherEarth” asconventionallyunderstood.IthasacosmologicalscopeencompassingtheEarth/time,theSunandtheMoon,the GoddessofFertility,andtheprimeoriginofall-lifeaswell.DICCIONARIO QUECHUA ESPAÑOL,QUECHUA EDICIÓN DELA MUNICIPALIDADDEL CUSCO (Perú)(1995).
onemadeupofmanydifferent “national ” groupswithinBolivia,includingthoseof Indigenouspeople.
In2009,Boliviaadoptedanewconstitution.Itspreambl erecognizedtheprinciplesof vivirbien ,protectionofMotherEarth,equity,andredistributionofsocial wealth,anddeclaredBoliviawasbeingfoundedanew:
Wehaveleftthecolonial,republicanandneo-liberalStateinthepast.Wetakeonthe historicchallengeofcollectivelyconstructingaUni fi edSocialStateofPluri-National Communitarianlaw,whichincludesandart iculatesthegoalofadvancingtowarda democratic,productive,peace-lovingandpeacefulBolivia,committedtothefulldevelopmentandfreedeterminationofthepeoples.
WefoundBoliviaanew,ful fi llingthemandateofourpeople,withthestrengthofour PachamamaandwithgratefulnesstoGod.50
TheConstitutiondidnotformallygrantrightstoMotherEarth,butitdidgrant environmentalrightstothepeople:
Everyonehastherighttoahealthy,protected,andbalancedenvironment.Theexercise ofthisrightmustbegrantedtoindividualsandcollectivesofpresentandfuturegenerations,aswellastootherlivingthings,sotheymaydevelopinanormalandpermanentway.
Anyperson,inhisownrightoronbehalfofacollective,isauthorizedtotakelegalaction indefenseofenvironmentalrights,withoutprejudicetotheobligationofpublicinstitutionstoactontheirowninthefaceofattacksontheenvironment.51
WhenMoralesbeganhissecondtermin2009,hewasalreadywell-knownininternationalcircles.InthatyearheattendedtheUnitedNationsClimateChangeConferenceinCopenhagen,whereheblamedclimatechangeoncapitalism,calledfor strongcommitmentstoclimatemitigation,anddemandedthattheGlobalNorthpay itsclimatedebttotheGlobalSouth.Unsatis fi edwiththeresultsoftheconference, MoralesinvitedpeopletocometoCochabambainApril2010fortheWorldPeople’ s ConferenceonClimateChangeandtheRightsofMotherEarth(the “WorldPeople’ s Conference”).Inanoften-festiveatmosphere,33,000peopleassembledandworkedon issuessuchasclimatechange,equityandjus tice,alternativedevelopmentpaths,the rightsofnature,Indigenousrights,patriarchy,andfoodsovereignty.Attheendof theconference,adraftUniversalDecla rationoftheRightsofMotherEarthwas adoptedwithagoalofhavingthedeclarationadoptedbytheUnitedNations.
InDecember2010,Boliviapassedthe LawoftheRightsofMotherEarth( “ the MotherEarthRightsLaw”).InChapterII,Article3,MotherEarth( Pachamama )was definedasfollows:
MotherEarthisadynamiclivingsystemcomprisinganindivisiblecommunityofalllivingsystemsandlivingorganisms,interrelated,interdependentandcomplementary,
50 CONST OFTHE PLURINATIONAL STATEOF BOLIVIA,Preamble(2009).
51 Id. atarts.33&34.
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw 456
Chapter16:EcocentricGovernance:TheNewEcologicalSocialContract
whichshareacommondestiny.MotherEarthisconsideredsacred,fromtheworldviews ofnationsandpeasantindigenouspeoples.
InChapterIII,Article7,MotherEarthwasgiventhefollowingrights:
1. Tolife:Therighttomaintaintheintegrityoflivingsystemsandnaturalprocesses thatsustainthem,andcapacitiesandconditionsforregeneration.
2. Tothediversityoflife:Itistherighttopreservationofdifferentiationandvarietyof beingsthatmakeupMotherEarth,withoutbeinggeneticallyalteredorstructurally modifiedinanartificialway,sothattheirexistence,functioningorfuturepotential wouldbethreatened.
3. Towater:Therighttopreservethefunctionalityofthewatercycle,itsexistencein thequantityandqualityneededtosustain livingsystems,anditsprotectionfrom pollutionforthereproductionofthelifeofMotherEarthandallitscomponents.
4. Tocleanair:Therighttopreservethequalityandcompositionofairforsustaining livingsystemsanditsprotectionfrompollution,forthereproductionofthelifeof MotherEarthandallitscomponents.
5. Toequilibrium:Therighttomaintenanceorrestorationoftheinterrelationship, interdependence,complementarityandfunctionalityofthecomponentsofMother Earthinabalancedwayforthecontinuationoftheircyclesandreproductionof theirvitalprocesses.
6. Torestoration :Therighttotimelyandeffectiv erestorationoflivingsystems affectedbyhumanactivitiesdirectlyorindirectly.
7. Topollution-freeliving:TherighttothepreservationofanyofMotherEarth’ scomponentsfromcontamination,aswellastoxicandradioactivewastegeneratedby humanactivities.
InArticle8,theplurinationalstatewasgiventhefollowingduties,amongothers:
• Developpublicpoliciesandactionsofp revention,earlywarning,protection, andprecaution;
• Developbalancedformsofproductionandpatternsofconsumption,whilesafeguardingtheregenerativecapacityand integrityofthecycles,processesand vitalbalanceofMotherEarth;
• DeveloppoliciestoprotectMotherEarthfromthemultinationalandinternationalscopeofexploitationofitscomponents,fromthecommodi ficationoflivingsystemsortheprocessesthatsupportthem,andfromthestructuralcauses andeffectsofglobalclimatechange;and
• Developpoliciestoensurethelong-termenergysovereigntyandgradualincorporationofcleanandrenewablealternativesourcesintotheenergymatrix.
InArticle9,theseduties,amongothers,wereimposedonnaturalpersonsand publicorprivatelegalentities:
• UpholdandrespecttherightsofMotherEarth;
• PromoteharmonywithMotherEarthinallareasofherrelationshipwithother humancommunitiesandtherestofnatureinlivingsystems;
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
• Participateactively,individuallyorcollectivelyingeneratingproposalsdesigned torespectanddefendtherightsofMotherEarth;
• Assumeproductionpracticesandconsumerbehaviourinharmonywiththe rightsofMotherEarth;
• EnsurethesustainableuseofMotherEarth’scomponents;and
• ReportanyactthatviolatestherightsofMotherEarth,livingsystems,and/or theircomponents.
Article10calledfortheestablishmentoftheOfficeofMotherEarth “toensurethe validity,promotion,distributionandcomplianceoftherightsofMotherEarthestablishedinthisAct.” Therewerenootherenforcementmechanismsintheact.
BoliviaenactedamuchmoreextensivelawfortheprotectionofMotherEarthin October2012,theFrameworkLawofMotherEarthandIntegralDevelopmentforLivingWell(the “FrameworkLaw, ” andtogetherwiththeConstitutionandtheMother EarthRightsLaw,the “MotherEarthlaws”).Article2oftheFrameworkLawstatedthat ithadcomeintobeingwithinthepowersassignedintheConstitutionandtheMother EarthRightsLawandprovidedthat “[i]tconstitutesaFrameworkLawandofpreferentialapplicationforthedevelopmentofspeci ficlaws,policies,norms,strategies,plans, programsandprojects.”
BoththeMotherEarthRightsLawand theFrameworkLawwerenegotiated betweenthegovernmentandtheUnityPact.In2010,followingtheWorldPeople ’ s Conference,theUnityPactpreparedadraftlawontherightsofMotherEarthbased ontheproceedingsofthatconference.Onlyaportionofthedraftwasapprovedand includedinthe2010MotherEarthRightsLaw.MembersoftheUnityPactfeltthat theabbreviatedlawmayhavebeenpassedtobolsterBolivia ’ simageattheClimate ChangeConferenceheldinCancun,Mexico,in2010.Thegovernmentinsisted,however,thattheMotherEarthRightsLawpavedthewayforacomprehensiveframework lawtogiveeffecttotheintentionsofthe2010law.TheFrameworkLawpassedbythe legislaturein2012containedawatered-downversionoftheUnityPactdraftandhad extensivepro-developmentprovisions.Thel egislaturetooktheleadindraftingthe FrameworkLawandexcludedcertainIndigenousorganizations.Othersdroppedout ofthelegislativeprocessandonlyafewremainedinvolvedintheend.52
TheFrameworkLaw,inArticle1,containedthisstatementofpurpose:
ThepurposeofthisLawistoestablishthevisionandfoundationsof integraldevelopment inharmonyandbalancewithMotherEarthtoLiveWell,guaranteeingthecontinuityof theregenerationcapacityofthecomponentsandsystemsoflifeofMotherEarth,recoveringandstrengtheninglocalknowledgeandancestralknowledge,withintheframeworkofthecomplementarityofrights,obligationsandduties;aswellastheobjectives of integraldevelopment asameanstoachieveLivingWell,thebasesforplanning,public managementandinvestmentsandthestrategi cinstitutionalframeworkforitsimplementation.(Emphasesadded.)
52 See PaolaVillavicencioCalzadilla&LouisJ.Kotzé, LivinginHarmonywithNature?ACriticalAppraisalofthe RightsofMotherEarthinBolivia,7TRANSNATIONAL EVNTL.L.397,412(2018).
Chapter16:EcocentricGovernance:TheNewEcologicalSocialContract
Thus,theFrameworkLawintroducestheconceptof “integraldevelopment” inan efforttoreconcileecocentricrespectandcareforMotherEarthandanthropocentric development.Thedif fi cultyisillustratedbytheterm “ extractivism, ” whichmeans “thoseactivitieswhichremovelargequantitiesofnaturalresourcesthatarenotprocessed(orprocessedonlytoalimited degree),especiallyforexport. ” 53 Extractivism aspartofintegraldevelopmentwasrecastas “neo-extractivism” bytheMoralesgovernment.TheintentwastoputminingandoilandgasproductioninBoliviainasubordinatepositiontotheothervaluesofbuildingtheplurinationalstateandalsosetthem withinachronologywhereneo-extractivismwouldbeabridgeto vivirbien.Critics,however,arguedthatneo-extractivismsimply “ maintain[ed]andreproduce[d]keyelementsoftheextractivismthatdate[d]backtocolonialtimes.”54
TheFrameworkLawdidcontainmanyprovisionsinlinewiththeMotherEarth RightsLaw,butitalsoplacedanobligat iononthegovernmenttopursuemining, hydrocarbonextraction,andindustrialization,alwayscautioningthattheseshouldbe undertakenwithrespectandcareforMotherEarth.NotethatBoliviahasahighpopulationgrowthrate,two-thirdsofitspopulationlivesincities,and,inconventionaleconomicterms,manyofitspeoplearepoor.Itisespeciallyvulnerabletoclimatechange. Watersupplyforcitiesandagriculturederivesinpartfromtropicalglaciersinthe AndesMountains,whicharemelting.TheMoralesgovernment,inlinewiththeprodevelopmentprovisionsoftheFrameworkL aw,didsucceedinincreasingeconomic growthandredistributingsomewealth.
In2019,Moralesranforafourthtimeaspresidentunderquestionableauthorityas theconstitutionprovidedforonlytwoterms.(His fi rsttermpredatedtheconstitution.)ThevotewasheldonOctober20.Moraleswonthevote,butelectionfraudwas suspected.SupportersofCarlosMesa,Morales ’ sopponent,protestedandconvened nationwidestrikes.SupportersofMoralesengagedincounterstrikes.TheOrganization ofAmericanStateswasbroughtintoauditthe election,foundseri ousirregularities, andcalledforanewelection.Moralesagre ed,butthemilitarysuggestedheresign. Policeunitsmutiniedalongwithpresidentialguards.Morales fledthecapital.Mexico, declaringMoralesthelegitimatepresident,sentajettopickhimupandtakehimto Mexico,wherehelivesatthetimeofthiswriting.AfterthreesupportersofMorales inlineforpresidentialsuccessionresigned,JeanineÁñez,whohadbeenendorsedby themilitary,proclaimedherselfpresident.Shemadeclearthatsheintendedtopurge Morales ’ slegacy.DuringhispresidencyMoral eshadbeenopposedbyconservative forcesinBoliviaandbytheUnitedStatesforhisleft-wingpoliciesandforissuesrelatingtoBoliviannarcoticstrafficking.Nowtheconservativesarebackinpower.
ThisreportonBoliviaanditsrightsofnaturelawsillustratesthecomplexityofthe relationshipsoflaw,economics,politics,andculture,andthechallengesinvolvedin changingthesocialcontract.ItisinstructiveforEarthlawyers,amongotherways,as setoutbelow.
53 AlbertoAcosta, ExtractivismandNeoextractivism:TwoSidesoftheSameCurse, in BEYOND DEVELOPMENT:ALTERNATIVE V ISIONSFROM L ATIN A MERICA 61,62(M.Lang&D.Mokranieds.,2013),https://www.tni.org/ fi les/ download/beyonddevelopment_extractivism.pdf(lastvisitedApril3,2020).
54 Id. at73.
2.Amodeltobedeveloped
TheBolivianrightsofnaturelawsontheirface(aspositivelaw)arearemarkable achievement.They
• Offeravisionofabetterwayoflife, vivirbien;
• RecognizeadiversityofculturesandtherightsofIndigenouspeople;
• Callforaplurinationalpolity;
• Recognizethatallhumandevelopmentmusttakeplacewithinplanetarylimits;
• CallforrespectforMotherEarth,fortherightsofEarth ’slifesystemstoperformtheirfunctions,andforotherspeciesto flourish;and
• Integratemeetinghumanneedsthroughdevelopmentwithrespectandcare forEarth.
PaolaVillavicencioandLouisKotzéwrotethisaboutthelaws:
Bolivia ’ sefforttolegallyprotecttherightsofMotherEarthisasigni fi cantmilestone. Thecountry’sConstitution,itsLawoftheRightsofMotherEarth,andtheFramework Lawareconcreteexamplesinwhichthelawattemptstoturnaway(ifnotalwayssuccessfully)fromanthropocentrichierarchieswhileembracingcareforMotherEarthasan ethicalobligationofecologicalstewardshi p.Onpaperatleast,thelegalprotectionof therightsofnon-humanentitiesprovidesa nopportunityforsocietytoredirectits behaviourawayfromgrowth-without-limitsparadigmstowardsanaltogethermorecarefulecologicalapproach.55
TheFrameworkLawmightbecriticizedforbeingasetofprinciplesratherthana preciselegaldocument,yetthisiswhatframeworklawsare.Theysetgeneralprinciples withoutnecessarilyincludingspeci fi cgoalsortargetsorenforcementmechanisms. Theyarewrittenwiththeunderstandingthattheywillbefollowedbyadditionallaws, protocols,resolutions,anddecisions. 56 TheFrameworkLawisadocumentalongthe linesoftheUnitedNations ’ WorldCharterforNature 57 andtheEarthCharter. 58 TheFrameworkLawgoesbeyondthose,however,inthatitgroundsprinciplesthat aregenerallyinaccordwiththeseinternationaldocumentsinBolivia’ sownhistory, cultures,andtraditionsandappliesthemtothegovernanceofBolivia.Bolivia ’ s MotherEarthlawstakentogetheraredocumentsofgovernanceinthebroadsense ofthetermusedbyJennings.Theyareanarticulationofanewecologicalsocialcontractandarejectionofthesocialcontractofconsumption.
55 Villavicencio&Kotzé, supra note52,at423.
56 See DANIEL BODANSKY,THE FRAMEWORK CONVENTION/PROTOCOL APPROACH 9(1999),https://www.researchgate. net/publication/289507490_Framework_ConventionProtocol_Approach(lastvisitedApril4,2020).
57 G.A.Res.37/7,WorldCharterforNature(Oct.28,1982).
58 THE EARTH CHARTER (EarthCharterCommission,2000),EARTH CHARTER INTERNATIONAL,https://earthcharter. org/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/echarter_english.pdf(lastvisitedApr.7,2020).
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw 460
Chapter16:EcocentricGovernance:TheNewEcologicalSocialContract
3.Acriticalappraisal
AfterpraisingBolivia’ sMotherEarthlawsontheirface,VillavicencioandKotzé concludetheirarticleasfollows:
[T]hereareimportantgeneralinsightsthatpresentthemselvesfromtheBolivianexperience. [O]nesuchinsightisthatlawhaslimitations,andonemustremainrealistic aboutitspotentialtocounterdeeplyvested political,socialand economicinterests. Lawwillalwaysremainmerelyoneingredient(albeitapowerfulone)inthesocialinstitutionalregulatorytoolbox.However,whereitdoesprovideforradicalformulations (suchasrightsofnature),itpromptsustostarthavingconversationsaboutwaysin whichtoaccommodatesuchnoveljuridicalconstructsinoursocial,economic,religious, legalandpoliticalstructures,includingwaystoimplementthemandwaysofresolving themanynormativeandpracticalcontradictionsthatarelikelytoarisewhentheintereststhattherightsofnatureseektoprotectcollidewiththosechampionedbythe neoliberaldevelopmentalagenda[,whichisthe]ultimatetestforlawinrelationtoprotectingtherightsofMotherEarth.59
Bolivia’srightsofnaturelawswerehailedasabreakthroughonenvironmentaland Earthlawwebsites,inprogressivepublications,andonwebsitesthathighlightpromisingdevelopments.Herearetheheadlinesfromonenewspaper:
Boliviaenshrinesnaturalworld’srights withequalstatusforMotherEarth LawofMotherEarthexpectedtopromptradicalnew conservationandsocialmeasuresinSouthAmericannation60
EarthlawwebsitescontinuetoholdupBolivia ’slawsasanexampleofwherethe rightsofnaturearetakinghold.ThehistoryofBoliviadiscussedabove,however,presentsafarmorecomplexpicture.EvenwhenMoraleswasinpower,Villavicencioand Kotzéquestionedwhetherthelawsweremerelywindowdressingintendedtoelevate Bolivia ’ sstatusontheworldstagewhileitcontinuedtopursuedevelopmentand extractivism.61 TheyobservedthatasofAugust2018(whenMoraleswasstillinoffice), “theBoliviangovernmenthasneitherapprovednewenvironmentallegislationconsistentwiththeLawoftheRightsofMotherEarthandtheFrameworkLaw,norrepealed majorlawsthatareinconsistentwiththoselaws;norhasitestablishedtheOfficeforthe ProtectionofMotherEarth.”62
Inherdoctoraldissertation,CarlaSbertCarlssonexaminedemergingecological lawinvariousnationswithparticularattentiontohowthislawdealtwithmining.She examinedBolivia ’ sMotherEarthlawsbasedonlyontheirtextsthroughathree-fold ecologicallensofecocentrism,ecologicalprimacy,andecologicaljusticeandfound
59 Villavicencio&Kotzé, supra note52,at423.
60 JohnVidal, BoliviaEnshrinesNaturalWorld’sRightswithEqualStatusforMotherEarth,THE GUARDIAN (Apr.10, 2011),https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2011/apr/10/bolivia-enshrines-natural-worlds-rights.
61 Villavicencio&Kotzé, supra note52,at416.
62 Id. (footnoteomitted).
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
onthewholethatthelawswereecocentric.63 Thenshelookedathowthelawsworked inpracticebasedonananalysisoftheSalardeUyunilithiumindustrializationproject. ThisprojectwasannouncedbyMoralesin2008andinvolvedseveralstages from developingaminetoeventuallyproducinglithiumbatteries.SalardeUyuniisthe world ’ slargestsalt fl at.Itisthelegacyofaprehistoriclakethatwentdryleavinga desert-like1,000-kilometerlands cape.Itcontainsoneoftheworld ’ slargestdeposits oflithiumandalsoholdssodium,potassium,magnesium,andborax.Bolivia’sMother Earthlawsdonotestablishlicensingrequ irements,norarethereanyregulations underthelawsthatapplytotheminingproject.Instead,regulationofthemineisgovernedbythe1992LawoftheEnvironment.Themine,whichiscurrentlyactive,is managedbyastateagencyknownasYacimientosdeLitioBolivianos(YLB).YLBrefers onitswebsitetoauthorizationsconcerningtheprojectbutdoesnotmentionBolivia’ s MotherEarthlaws.
SbertCarlssonattemptstoapplytheprin ciplesoftheMotherEarthlawstothe project.Forexample,theminingactivity involvesusinglargeamountsofwaterand thedisposaloflargeamountsofbrineasawasteproduct.Thewateris “ fossilwater” drawnfromwellsandisnonrenewable.Shequestionswhetherdrawingsomuchwater contravenestherequirementintheMotherEarthlawsthateconomicactivitiesarelimitedbythecapacityofMotherEarthtoregenerateherself.Shealsoconsiderswhether mining,sinceitisanonrenewableactivitythatnegativelyaffectswildlife,isconsistent withjusticeforfuturegenerationsandotherspecies.Shenotesthatlithiumisconsideredessentialtoaglobaltransitiontorenewableenergy,butshedoesnotweighthis asabalancingfactor.64
Afterexaminingconflictingrightsamongbeings,shestates: “Thiscomplexityand thegeneraldiffi cultyofestablishingproofinenvironmentalcases,begsthequestion whethertheRightsofMotherEarthLawcouldbeimplementedeffectivelyevenwith themostdedicatedeffort;andifnot,whetherlegalrecognitionoftherightsofnature (inthisdetailedwayatleast)isaviablepathforecologicallaw.”65
HeroverallconclusionregardingtheapplicationoftheMotherEarthlawstothe miningprojectwasasfollows: “Insum,itishardtoconcludefromthiscasestudythat thepotentiallytransformativerecognitionoftherightsofMotherEarthanddirection towardslivingwellinBolivianlawshavehadanybearingontheactualimplementation ofaprojectasnationallyimportantasthatoflithiumindustrialization.”66
4.LessonsforEarthlawyersfromBolivia
Foranon-Bolivian,one’sinitialreactiontowhathashappenedinBoliviamaybethatit isauniquesituationorthatithasapplicationonlytocircumstancesinBolivia,inSouth
63 See CarlaSbertCarlsson,MiningfromtheLensofEco logicalLaw:Obstacles andOpportunitiesfor Re-Formation224-245(2019)(unpublishedPh.D.inlawthesis,UniversityofOttawa),https://www.academia. edu/39149609/Mining_from_the_Lens_of_Ecological_Law_Obstacles_and_Opportunities_for_Re-formation.
64 Id. at245-264.
65 Id. at253.
66 Id. at258.
462
Chapter16:EcocentricGovernance:TheNewEcologicalSocialContract
America,orintheGlobalSouthgenerally.Therearesomeaspectsthatcanbecharacterizedthisway,yettherearealsolessonsapplicabletoallplaces.Someoftheselessons areasfollows.
Bolivia’slawsofMotherEarthofferamodelforhowtodraftconstitutionsandlegislationforanecologicalage.Thevaluesinthelegislationarethatofthenewecologicalsocialcontract.Itwasasignalaccomplishmenttohavepassedtheselaws.This wouldnotcurrentlybepossiblein,forexample,the “ advanced ” UnitedStates.In 1982,theUnitedNations’ WorldCharterforNaturewasapprovedby111nations,18 abstained,andonlytheUnitedStatesvote dagainstit.TheUnitedStateseitherdid notsignordidnotratifytheConventionontheLawoftheSea(1990),Convention onBiologicalDiversity(1992),theKyotoP rotocol(climatemitigation)(1997),the RomeStatuteoftheInternationalCriminalCourt(1998),ortheParisAgreement(climatemitigation)(whichbecameeffectiveinNovember2016 theconventionwas signedbytheObamaadministration,inApril2016,butitwasnotratifiedbytheU.S. Senateand,inAugust2017,theUnitedStateswithdrewfromtheagreement).67 The Trumpadministration,asofDecember2019(afterthreeyearsinof fi ce),hadrolled back95previouslyenactedenvironmentallaws.68
EarthlawyersintheUnitedStatesmustconsiderwhetherorinwhatwayitsenvironmentallawsareasteptowardecologicalgovernance.Whatarethevaluesinthose lawsandhowwelldotheymapthevaluesJenningscallsforinecologicalgovernance? IndraftingitsMotherEarthlaws,BoliviadrewonthewisdomofitsIndigenouspeoples;whatmightdraftersofEarthlawsintheUnitedStatesdrawonfromitshistory andculture?WhatinU.S.culture,ifanything,correspondsto vivirbien ?Inacountry committedtoeconomicgrowthmeasuredbyGDP,ofwhich70percentisaccounted forbyconsumerspending,whatwouldanon-consumptivepoliticaleconomylooklike?
Anotherareaforre fl ectioniswhethertheBolivianexperienceisajudgmenton rightsofnaturelaws.HaveEarthlawyerspromotedthepassageoftheselawswithout criticallyrefl ectingonthecomplexityofapplyingthem?Ifonetakesthepositionthat anecocentricperspectiverequiresthatr ightsofnaturelawsmakenodistinctions amongthevariousbeingsinnature asSbertCarlssondidinapplyingtheecocentric partofherecologicallenstotheMotherEarthlaws cantheyprovidelegalguidance atall? 69 Giventheimpossibilityofdevelopings tatuesdetailingtherightsandduties respectingeachbeingandcomponentofnature,canaframeworklawsuchasthatin Boliviaplayaguidingroleinpolicy?
TheBolivianexperiencealsocallsforrefl ectionontheroleofthewrittenecocentriclawsinrelationtogovernanceasawhole.Forwrittenlawstobeeffective,theymust
67 ListofTreatiesUnsignedorUnratifi edbytheUnitedStates,WIKIPEDIA,https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php? title=List_of_treaties_unsigned_or_unrati fi ed_by_the_United_States&oldid=946035018(lastvisitedApr.5, 2020).
68 NadjaPopovich,LiviaAlbeck-Ripka,&KendraPierre-Louis, 95EnvironmentalRulesBeingRolledBackunder Trump ,N.Y.T IMES (Dec.21,2019),https://www.nytimes. com/interactive/2019/climate/trumpenvironment-rollbacks.html.
69 Herecocentriclenswas: “Ecocentrism,recognizeandrespectthevalueofallbeingsandtheinterconnectednessamongthem,equallypromotingtheinterestsofhumanandnonhumanmembersoftheEarthcommunity.” SbertCarlsson, supra note63,at224(emphasisadded).
besupportedbylawenforcement,thejudi cialsystem,andtheadministrative branch.Lawsmustbelargelyself-enforcingbyvoluntarycompliance.Forlawstobe self-enforcing,thepublicgenerallymust fi ndthemandthepoliticalsystemjustand fair.Economicconsiderations,bothdomesticandinternational,comeintoplay.Peoplemustfeeltheyhaveameansofsupportandthattheycanprosper. “Prosper” can beframedaslessconsumptiveliving( vivirbien ),butthishastobeanestablished expectation.
Itcouldbesaidthatenvironmentallawtreatsthesymptoms,notthedisease,and theBolivianMotherEarthlawsareintendedtotreatthedisease.Thelatteriswhatis needed.Earthlawyersmustaskhowtheycan realistically buildontheBolivianexperience.NeitherlawschoolsnorlawpracticespreparelawyersforthechallengesofEarth law.Conventionallawpracticesrewardlawyerswholearn “either-or ” lawandthenuse ittosolveproblemsfortheirclients.70 Whatisneedednowisrelational-evolutionary jurisprudence.Winningandlosinghaveadifferentmeaninginthisjurisprudence. Winningmeanscreativeadjustmenttoever-changingcircumstances;losingmeansfailingtoadapt.Aclient’ssuccesscanneverbeseparatedfromthesuccessofthesystemas awhole. “Resilience” isatermthathasgainedsomecurrencyasadescriptionofsuccessinanecologicalage. “Vitality” isanothersuchterm.ItisthetaskofEarthlawyers tocreateandpracticeresilient,vitallaw.
IV.CONCLUSION:DEPENDINGONTHEINTERCONNECTED WEBOFLIFE
Inlate2019,aninfectiousvirus,SARS-CoV -2(commonlyreferredtoasCOVID-19), causedbyaparticularcoronaviruswas fi rstidenti fi edinWuhan,acityof11million incentralChina.BecauseCOVID-19hasanearlyidenticalgenomesequenceasabat coronavirus,atheoryfortheoriginofthediseaseisthatitwastransmittedfromabat toahuman.71 Further,thereisatheorythatthevirusstartedinaparticularwetmarket inWuhan.72 Afterinfectionofasinglehumanbeingthere,thediseasespreadrapidly topeopleinnearlyeverynationintheworld.Asofthiswriting,thereisnovaccine forthediseaseandnocure.Socialisolationandquarantinehavebeendeterminedto bethebestwaystoreduceitsspread.Asaresult,onaglobalbasis,economicactivity hasfallenprecipitously,millionshavelosttheirjobs,healthsystemshavebecomeoverburdened,andlargenumbersofpeoplehavediedandcontinuetodie.
70 Thishasbeencalled “mechanicaljurisprudence. ” SeeFRITJOF CAPRA &U GO MATTEI,THE ECOLOGYOF LAW : TOWARDA LEGAL SYSTEMIN TUNEWITH NATUREAND COMMUNITY 101-103,173(2015).
71 PengZhouetal., APneumoniaOutbreakAssociatedwithaNewCoronavirusofProbableBatOrigin,579NATURE 270 (2020),https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-020-2012-7.
72 AylinWoodward, ChinaJustBannedtheTradeandConsumptionofWildAnimals.ExpertsThinktheCoronavirus JumpedfromLiveAnimalstoPeopleataMarket ,BUSINESS INSIDER (Feb.25,2020),https://www.businessinsider. com/china-bans-wildlife-trade-consumption-coronavirus-2020-2.
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw 464
Chapter16:EcocentricGovernance:TheNewEcologicalSocialContract
At firstthismaynotbethoughtofasanenvironmentalissue,butmanyareseeinga connection.AccordingtoKateJones,ChairofEcologyandBiodiversityatUniversity CollegeLondon,
[V]irusesareontherise ::: becausetherearesomanyofusandwearesoconnected. Thechanceofmore[spilloversintohumans]happeningishigherbecauseweare degradingtheselandscapes.Destroyinghabitatsisthecause,sorestoringhabitatsisa solution. It ’ snotOKtotransformaforestintoagriculturewithoutunderstanding theimpactthathasonclimate,car bonstorage,diseaseemergenceand fl oodrisk. ::: Youcan ’ tdothosethingsinisolationwitho utthinkingaboutwhatthatdoesto humans.73
In1970,the firstEarthdayoccurredandmodernenvironmentallawbegan.Then theglobalpopulationwas3.2billion;now,50yearslater,therearenearly8billionpeople.In1970,therewerearound200millioncarsandtrucks;today,therearemorethan 1.5billion.ByalmosteverymeasurehumanimpactonEarthhasskyrocketed.Before 1970, firesthatconsumed100,000acreswererareintheUnitedStates,butsincethen, therehavebeendozens.Inthesummerof2019, firesinSiberiaconsumed17million acresand,inAustralia,in2019and2020, firesburnedmorethan10millionacres.At present,deforestationisaccelerating,cor alreefsaredying,oceansareacidifying, sunnyday floodingisoccurring,stormsarebecomingmorefrequentand fiercer,and iceismelting.AccordingtotheWWF ’ s2018 LivingPlanetReport ,populationsizesof vertebratespecieshavedeclinedonaverageby60percentsince1970(buttherehas notbeenaslargeofapercentagedropinabsolutenumbersacrossspecies). 74 In Germany,astudyfoundthatthebiomassofinsectsincertainprotectedareashas droppedby76percentinthreedecades.75
Cropsdependonpollinatorsthatareindecline.Droneshavebeentestedtocarry pollen,whichraisesthequestionofwhetherhumansarestilldependentontheinterconnectedweboflife?Willhumansalwaysbeableto fi ndsubstitutesforwhatislost innature?ForEarthlawyerstheanswertothelatterquestionisclear:Itisafoolish wagertorelyon.
Muchhasalreadybeensetinmotion.Earthlawyerswillnotbesurprisedtobelivinginanageofcascadingcrises.Theywillnotdismissthem.Instead,theywilllookfor patternsandtheywillseektounderstandthelessonsinthem.InatwistonSoren Kierkegaard’sstatementthat “lifeisnotaproblemtobesolvedbutarealitytobeexperienced,” theywillunderstandthatourplanetisnotaproblemtobesolvedbutarealitytobelived.
Differenttheoriesofthesocialcontrac tarebeingplayedout.Somefollowing Hobbesseethestateassovereign “defin[ing]thelawsandmorality.Peace,tranquility,
73 NickPatonWalsh&VascoCotovio, BatsAreNottoBlameforCoronavirus.HumansAre,CNN(Mar.20,2020), https://www.cnn.com/2020/03/19/health/coronavirus-human-actions-intl/index.html.
74 WWF,LIVING PLANET REPORT 7(2018).
75 See ElizabethKolbert, TheCaseforCatastrophe,NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC 14-21(Apr.2020).
SectionIV:TransformingtheLaw
order,and,inHobbes’swords ‘commodiousliving’ arethepurposeofcivilsociety.”76 OthersfollowingLockeholdthatthe “State’smainobligationsaretoprotecttherights ofitscitizens,especiallytheirpropertyrights,andprovideforthecommondefense.”77 Theconsentofcitizensisconditionalandtheyareevervigilantlestthestateshould trampleontheirrights.ThosefollowingRousseauholdthat “[t]heStaterespondsto aneedoflivinginsociety inotherwordsoflivinginmutualdependenceandfellowshipofothers. ” 78 Peoplearefullycommittedtoth esocialcontractyetremain sovereign.Governanceisamoralcommunityguidedbythegeneralwillofthepeople.
JenningsextendsRousseau:TheStaterespondstotheneedsoflivinginmutual dependenceandfellowship withallmembersoftheEarthcommunity.Theformationofthis newecologicalsocialcontractisonlybeginning.AsLatourwrote: “[It]hastobeassembledbitbybit.Thelawsofthenewpolityhavetobeinventedandself-imposedbecause “[w]ithoutdecision,thereisnobodypolitics,noliberty,[no]autonomy. ”79 Rousseau soughttoconstructatheoryofthesocialcontractwherehumanswouldbeasfreeas intheirnaturalstate.Peoplearenowcomingtoseethattheycannotbefreewithout anecologicalsocialcontract.
Earthlawyerswillplayacrucialrolein shapingthisnewcontract,andtheywill placetheirwagerontheinterconnectedcommunityoflife.
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1)WhatisanEarthlawyer?
(2)Whatspecialskills,abilities,socialstatus,androlesdolawyersbringtothetaskof creatinganewecologicalsocialcontract?
(3)Whatcanlawyersdotobringintobeinganewecologicalsocialcontract?
(4)Whatisnormativejurisprudence?An “objective” legalsystemallowstransactions andresolutionofcon fl ictswithoutdirectreferencetomorals.Whatistherole ofmoralsinlawpractice?Will “ecologicalmorals” causeconflict?
76 Seesupra textaccompanyingnote8.ThisistheroleplayedbytheCommunistpartyinChina.Inpartin responsetothethreatofCOVID-19,inMarch2020, theHungarianparliamentvotedtoallowHungarian PrimeMinisterViktorOrbantorulebydecree.IntheUnitedStates,intheimpeachmenthearingsofPresidentTrumpin2019-2020,thepresidentrefusedtocooperatewiththelegislativebranch.Thiswasanextensionofthetheoryoftheunitaryexecutive,which “ arguesthatthepresident ’ sconstitutionallyallocated executiveresponsibilitiesmaynotberestric tedbyCongressionalorJudicialaction. ” TheUnitaryExecutive , SCHMOOP.COM,https://www.shmoop.com/study-guides/civics/executive-branch/unitary-executive(lastvisited Apr.17,2020).
77 Seesupra textfollowingnote8.
78 Seesupra textfollowingnote9.
79 Seesupra textaccompanyingnote5.Astothecharacterthepoliticsofthenewsocialcontractaccordingto Jennings, seesupra textaccompanyingnotes42and43.
466
Chapter16:EcocentricGovernance:TheNewEcologicalSocialContract
(5)Howmaylawyersandsocietyengagethenonhumanlanguagediscourseof nature?
(6)HowmayEarthlawyersbeguidedbythegeneralwilloftheEarthcommunity?
(7)WhatlessonsdoyoutakefromtheBolivianexperience?
(8)Humanhistoryis fi lledwithcatastrophes,suchasthecurrentCOVID-19crisis. Doyouanticipatecascadingcatastrophes,and,ifso,whatisthemeaningofthis foryou?HowwillthisaffectEarthlaw?
SECTIONFIVE AGLOBALSURVEYOF EARTHLAW
SectionVaddressesEarthlaw’sactualimplementationthroughlawmakingandlitigationatthenationallevel.Thecasestudiesreviewedinthissectionaremarkedby diverselegalstrategiesusedtostopandreverseinjurytoforests,rivers,streams,springs, andotherecosystems.Moreover,eachchapterrevealsadistinctivelegalsystemwithin whichthestrategiesunfold.WediscussedimplementationofEarthlawintheUnited StatesinSectionIII,Chapter9,andusingthatasabasisforcomparison,wenowturn toadiscussionoflitigatingandapplyingEarthlawinothercountriestobetterunderstandhowimplementationatthegroundlevelactuallyworks.
Asyoureviewthecasestudies,notetheirsimilaritiesaswellasthedistinctions.The chaptersonEcuador(Chapter17),Colombia(Chapter18),andBrazil(Chapter19) revealanencouragingnumberofcasesreco gnizingrightsofnature.Yet,thelegal frameworkwithinwhichthesecasesplayoutvariesforeachcountry.EarthlawlitigationinEcuadorspringsfromthecountry ’ sConstitution,whichgrantsnaturebroad rights.WhileColombiaandBrazildonotembodyrightsofnatureintheirConstitutionsorstatuteslaws,theircourts,particularlyinColombia,arecreatingarichbody ofcaselawthroughecocentric interpretationofexistinglegislationtorecognizethe rightsofnature.Ingroundbreakingdecisions,theColombiancourtshaverecognized theAtratoRiverBasinandtheColombianAmazonaslegalsubjectsofrightsinorder tostopdestructivemininganddeforestation,respectively.ThecasestudyonBrazil addressesthefailureofitsenvironmenta llawsandtheeffortsunderwaytoremedy thesituationbypromotingrightsofnatur elaws.Yet,withoutwaitingfornewlaws, courtsinBrazilaremovingaheadwithEarthlaw,recentlyrecognizinganonhuman animal(aparrot)asasubjectofrights.T heemergenceofEarthlawinMexicois unfoldinginpartthroughtheexpansionoflegalframeworksforhumanrights.Similar toBrazil’sconstitution,whichrecognizesthehumanrighttoan “ecologicallybalanced environment ” andsupportsIndigenouspracticesforlivinginharmonywithnature, Mexico ’ sconstitutionalsograntshumansenvironmentalrights,includingaspeci fi c Indigenousrightformaintainingandim provingtheirenviro nment.Whileboth Brazil’sandMexico’sconstitutionsareanthropocentricand,unlikeEcuador ’s,donot recognizerightsofnature,theircodi ficationofthehumanrighttoahealthyenvironmentisfosteringthedevelopmentofEarthlaw.InMexico,threestategovernments haveincludedrightsofnaturewithintheirconstitutionsandotherarenotfarbehind.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
AlthoughthissectiondoesnotincludeachapteronBolivia,in2009Bolivia’ spresidentwasakey figureintheU.N.HarmonywithNatureinitiative,asreviewedinChapter15, “UnitedNationsSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives.” BoliviaadoptedtheLaw oftheRightsofMotherEarth(2010)andtheFrameworkLawofMotherEarthand IntegralDevelopmentforLivingWell( 2010).OnereasonforomittingaBolivia chapteristheabjectfailureexperienced inenforcingthelawsthatgrantnaturea diversityofrights.
Indigenousrights-basedmovementsareexploredinChapter24, “Africa.” Similar toLatinAmericancountries,effortsinAfr icatopromoteEarthlawspringfromthe continent’ slocaltraditionsandcustomsoflivinginharmonywithMotherEarthand thefocusonrestoringIndigenousknowledgeandpracticesatthecommunityandlocal levels.Africa ’sEarthlawmovementhasevolvedundertheleadershipofacivilsociety intentonrevivingcustomarylawsandIndigenouspracticesasthebasisforanewEarth jurisprudence.
ContinuingthefocusonIndigenouslawsandcustoms,Chapter25, “Indigenous Legalities,” addressesAmericanindigenousknowledgeandpracticesandtheirpotentialfortransformingWesternlegalsystemsinthefaceofthecurrentecologicalcrisis. UnlikemanyIndigenouspeople’sbeliefsystems,Westernlawisbasedonan “ontology ofseparation ” betweennatureandculturethatisincompatiblewithecocentriclaw. ThechapteralsoreviewshowWesterncolonialismhasimpactedIndigenouslawsand howcolonialismendures.
EarthlawinIndia(Chapter20)andNewZealand(Chapter22)arebasedonthe modeloflegalpersonhoodfornature.InNewZealand,the2014TeUreweraActrecognizestheformerTeUreweraNationalParkasitsownlegalentity,anda2017treaty agreementbetweenthegovernmentandtheMāoritribeofWhanganuialsorecognizes theWhanganuiRiverasitsownlegalentity.Guardianswereappointedinbothcasesto representtherivers,inIndiabythecourt andinNewZealandthroughlegislation. SpecificallycitingthepersonhoodfornatureinNewZealand,anIndiancourtrecognizedthelegalpersonhoodoftheGangesRiver(adecisionthatwaslateroverturned bythecountry ’ sSupremeCourt)aswellasrightsfortheentireanimalkingdomin 2017.
WhilethesecountrieshavealreadylefttheirmarkaspractitionersofEarthlaw, notethesituationinIsrael(Chapter21),wherebothEarthlawlegislationandlitigationisalmostnon-existent.SimilartoCol ombiaandBrazil,theIsraelcountrystudy demonstrateshowEarthlawcanevolvewithoutspecificlawswhencourtshavethewill tointerpretexistinglegislationtocounterharmtonature.Moreover,theIsraelicase alsoshowsthatcourtsmighthanddownprecedentialjudgementsthatinrealitycreate rightsfornaturewithoutmentioningtheserightsorotherEarthlawdoctrinesand concepts.
IntheNetherlands(Chapter23),implementationofEarthlawreceivedanenormousboostbythe2020decisionofthecountry’sSupremeCourtinthe Urgenda case, inwhichcurrentandfuturegenerationssu ccessfullyestablishedtheDutchgovernment ’ sdutytopreventdangerousclimatechange.TheSupremeCourtcitedhuman rightsconventionsandtheIntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChangeinordering
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
theDutchgovernmenttomeetitsobligationsunderinternationallaw(theParisAgreement)inordertoavoidsevereenvironmentalharm.
Drawingallthesecasestogetheristhestrongconsensusontheneedtotransform nature currentlyobjectifiedashumanproperty intoanindependententitywithits ownlegalpersonhoodorrights.Changingnaturefromanobjectoflawintoitssubject underliestheassumptionthatexistingla wscannotreversetheunfoldingecological tragedy.Hence,thecasestudiessharetheobjectiveofreplacingthecurrentlegalsystemwithanecocentriconethatwillrecognizenature ’ sinherentvalue,ratherthan itscurrentworthtohumansasaresourcetofeedtheglobaleconomy.
Asyoureadthechaptersinthissection,considerhowlitigationcangeneratetransformativechangeatthegroundlevelandthespecifi cimpactofeachcaseonecosystemsatrisk.Alsotrytointe rlinkthecasesdiscussedinChapter9onU.S.Earthlaw, forexample,withthelitigationmodelspresentedintheColombianandDutchcase studies.DothesemodelsofferamoreeffectivestrategytolitigateEarthlawinthe UnitedStates,orareforeign(non-U.S.)legalsystemssimplymorelikelytomakeecocentriclegalinterpretations?Effectivel ypromotingEarthlawrequiresanin-depth understandingofthedifferentlitigationandpolicymodelsbeingusedtosecurerights forecosystemsandtheirapplicabilitytootherincidentsofecologicalharm.
CHAPTER17
Ecuador1
I.INTRODUCTION
In2008,Ecuadormadehistorybybecomingtheworld’ s firstcountrytorecognizethe rightsofnatureinitsConstitution.TheC onstitutionwasdraftedbeginningin2007 bytheEcuadorianConstituentAssembly,c omprising130delegatesrepresentingall ofEcuador ’ sregions. 2 ThemajorityofelecteddelegatesweremembersofPresident RafaelCorrea’scenter-leftsocialdemocraticmovement, PatriaAltivaiSoberana (Proud andSovereignHomelandorPAIS).InJuly2018,theAssemblyapprovedadraftconstitutionwith494articles.InSeptember2008,aconstitutionalreferendumwasapproved by63.93percentofEcuadorvoters.
InEcuador,rightsofnaturerefl ectsthebeliefsystemofitspopulation,especially itsIndigenouspeoples,whohavelivedinharmonywithnaturesincetimeimmemorial. Othersupportersofrightsofnatureincludelawyersandnon-governmentalorganizations(NGOs)seekingstrongerenvironmentalprotectiontocombatanin fl uxof extractiveindustries.Manyviewrightsofnatureasanemergingsuccessstoryofecocentriclawinpractice.Butothers fi nditsimpacttobemoresymbolicthanpractical. Thesecontradictoryvisionsmayexplaintheunevenwayinwhichrightsofnaturehas developedinEcuadoroverthelast12years.
ThischapterexploresrightsofnaturedevelopmentsinEcuador.Itbeginsbydiscussingwhyrightsofnaturereceivedconstitutionalrecognitionandwhatitmeansto Ecuadorians.ItthenreviewsrightsofnaturedecisionshandeddownbytheEcuadoriancourts.Finally,thechapterlooksah eadtohowrightsofnaturemightprogress inEcuadorinthenearfuture.
1 ThischapterwasauthoredbyJulioPrietoMéndez,lawyerfortheUnionofthepeopleaffectedbyTexaco (UDAPT),andHugoEcheverria,ProfessorofLawattheUniversityofSanFrancisco(Quito)andarightsof natureattorneyinEcuador.AspecialthankyoutoSarahStoughtonforherresearch,writing,andtranslation assistanceandtoJordanMichelsonforhiswritingcontributions.
2 See THECARTERCENTER,FINALREPORTONECUADOR ’ SAPPROBATORYCONSTITUTIONAL REFERENDUMOFSEPT.28,20084(2008).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
II.ACLASHBETWEENINDIGENOUSBELIEFSYSTEMSAND WESTERNNORMS
RightsofNaturewasacurrent flowingthroughEcuadorianveinslongbeforethecountry ’ s2008Constitution.Indigenouspeoples inEcuador,comprisedof14separate nationalities,havetraditionallyrecognizedunderlyingrightsofnatureprinciples throughtheirpractices,customs,andlaws.3 Forexample,theyregardforestsasliving entitiesandthusrejectdevelopmentorinterventionthatthreatensforestecosystems.4
Onegroup,theSarayakupeople,believethatforestsarealready “developed” because theycontainnaturalpaths,well-de fi nedhuntingseasonsandareas,androtating chakras (theIndigenousQuechuawordforsmallfarms)thathaveexistedforgenerations.5 TheSarayakuhavedevelopedtheircommunitiesandshapedtheforestinharmonywithnature’srhythms.
Westernbenchmarksofdevelopment roads,electricity,andjobsfromextractive industries areconsideredunnecessarybytheSarayaku.ThisSarayakuphilosophyis consistentwiththeconceptoftherightsandresponsibilitiesofrightsofnaturelawas ithasbeguntobedevelopedinEcuador.
However,Ecuadorishometomanydifferentcultures,andrightsofnatureisnot ingrainedintotheethosofmostofthepopulation.EventhoughmanyEcuadorians areofmixedIndigenousandEuropeanheritage,6 Ecuador’ ssocietyisheavilyin fl uencedbyWesternculture,includingitsemphasisoncontinuousdevelopmentandeconomicgrowth.Ecuadoristhusastoryoftwo competingvisions:embracingage-old beliefsystemsoflivinginharmonywithnatureandpursuingeconomicprogressat theexpenseofnature.
SomeEcuadoriansarecriticalofrightsofnature.Forthem,itiseasytounderstand thelegalinterestinprotecting something becauseofitsvaluetohumanlife,butrightsof natureproposestorespect someone,because she deservesrespect.Theseconceptscan beradicalandthreateningtosomehuman s.Considerthefollowingargumentfrom FarithSimonCampaña:
3 “InBoliviaandEcuador,theseandotherreferencesserveoccasionallyasacademiccorroborationoflongstandingIndigenousdemandsthatbuildonadeeplyingrained,animatedrelationshipbetweenhumansand nature,expressedasmutualcaringandlearningbeyondrationalaccounts ” (internalcitationsomitted).
JOHANNES M.WALDMUELLER &LAURA RODRÍGUEZ,HANDBOOKOF DEVELOPMENT ETHICS INVITED ENTRY CHAPTER: BUEN VIVIR AND RIGHTSOF NATURE 12(JayDrydyk&LoriKelehereds.,2008).
4 Asamplescholarshiphasdemonstrated,theAmazon,forinstance,isneitheranuntouchednorunspoiled ecosystembutinfacthasbeenprofoundlyshapedbyhumanimpactduringthousandsofyears. Id. at19(internalcitationsomitted).
5 TheSarayakucosmovisioniscalled KawsaySachaoSelvaViviente,[meaning] “LivingRainforest,” andisbased onalifeinharmoniouscoexistencewithnature .AsFrancoViteri,theSarayakuleader,says: “Theforestis already ‘developed’,theforestislife. ’” LeahTemper,SarayakuWinsCaseintheInter-AmericanCourtofHuman RightsbuttheStruggleforPriorConsentContinues, ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE O RGANISATIONS,LIABILITIES , AND T RADE (Aug.21,2012),http://www.ejolt.org/2012/08/sarayaku-wins-case-in-the -inter-american-court-of-humanrights-but-the-struggle-for-prior-consent-continues.
6 SILVERIANO CHISAGUANO,LAPOBLACIÓN INDÍGENA DEL ECUADOR [INDIGENOUS POPULATIONIN ECUADOR]26(2006).
Chapter17:Ecuador
AvoidingthedestructionoftheEarthbyhumansisimportant,but[weshouldnot] acceptanyregulatoryreformasvalidjustbecauseitsounds “ revolutionary ” without examiningitspossibleconsequences,especiallywhenthepossibilityexiststoweaken humanrightsprotections.
Whatshouldjudgesgivemoreweighttowheninconflict:therightsofnatureorthe rightsofindividualsandcommunities?Dohumanbeingsandnaturehavethesame ontologicalvalue?[discussingwhatsortofthingsexistinthesocialworldandassumptionsabouttheformandnatureofthatsocialreality].
[E]verythingsuggeststhatwewillsoonbestudying,defending,andexplainingthe importanceofthemostbasichumanright s,rememberingtheneedtoconsiderthe humanbeingasthecenterofeverything.7
Bycontrast,otherEcuadoriansembracetheideathathumansare part ofnature, notthecenterorownerofit.AsexplainedbyRamiroÁvilaSantamaría, “Youcannot separatetheconceptofbeinghumanfromnature;bothareone,hencehurtingnature ishurtingoneself. ::: [R]espectfornaturehasadirectimpactonrespectforhuman beingsand,ontheotherhand,disrespectofanyhumanbeinginevitablymeansdisrespectofnature.”8
Insum,evenwithinEcuadorwhererightsfornaturehavebeenconstitutionally recognized,viewpointsvarysigni fi cantly.Theultimatesuccessoftherightsofnature legalparadigmwilldependinlargepartontheextenttowhichandhowEcuadorean judges,politicians,lawyers,andcitizensembracenature’srightsinpractice.
III.ECUADOR’S2008CONSTITUTION
ThissectionexploresthetextofEcuador ’s2008Constitution.Itbeginswithadiscussionof SumakKawsay ,meaning “ goodliving, ” whichisafundamentalpillarof Ecuador ’ sConstitution.Itthendiscussesconst itutionalrightsofnatureprotections andconcludesbydiscussingEcuador’srecognitionofhumanenvironmentalrights.
A. SumakKawsay
IndigenouspeopleswerecentraltoshapingEcuador ’sConstitution.9 Forexample,the NationalIndigenousConfederationofEcuador(CONAIE)successfullyfoughtto
7 FARITH SIMON CAMPAÑA,DERECHOSDELA NATURALEZA:¿INNOVACIÓN TRASCENDENTAL,RETÓRICA JURÍDICA OPROYECTO P OLÍTICO ?[T HE R IGHTSOF N ATURE :T HE T RANSCENDENT I NNOVATION L EGAL R HETORICOR POLITICAL PROJECT ?]37 (2013)(translatedfromSpanish).
8 RAMIROÁVILA SANTAMARIA, EL DERECHODELA NATURALEZA:FUNDAMENTOS,16-17(2010).
9 J ULIO P RIETO,D ERECHOSDELA NATURALEZA:FUNDAMENTO ,C ONTENIDO YEXIGIBILIDAD J URISDICCIONAL [Rightsof Nature:RationaleandJurisdictionalEnforcement](2013).
ensurethattheConstitutionre fl ectedthemulti-ethniccharacterofEcuadorandits variousbeliefsystems. 10 Oneofthosebeliefsystemsistheconceptof SumakKawsay , usuallytranslatedas goodwayofliving (buenvivir inSpanish).ThePreambleoftheConstitutionstatesthatthesovereignpeopleofEcuador “ herebydecidetobuildanew formofpubliccoexistence,indiversitya ndinharmonywithnature,toachievethe goodwayofliving,the sumakkawsay. ” SumakKawsay,however,isadeeperconceptthan theliteraltranslationofthewordsconveys.AsdescribedbyRaúlLlasagFernández,
Inordertomakevisibleotherformsofknowledgeandwisdom,withoutintendingto essentialize,buttomakepossibletheinterculturaldialogue,[itisnecessaryto]lookat theconceptionofPachamamaforIndigenouspeoplesofEcuador,awarethatthereis diversityofIndigenouspeoplesanddiversityofrealities,therefore,diversityofconceptionsofPacha-mamaand SumakKawsay,buttheyarearticulatedbyfundamentalprinciplesthatmakethemcommon. ” SumakKawsay isanIndigenousideathatrepresents livinginharmonywithpachamama,ornature.11
LuisMacasexplainsthemeaningofthewords Sumak and Kawsay asfollows: Sumak isthefullness,thesub lime,excellent,magni fi cent,beautiful,andsuperior. Kawsay islife,isbeing.However,itisdynamic,changing,itisnotpassive[].Therefore, SumakKawsay wouldbelifeinfullness.Lifeinmaterialandspiritualexcellence.The magnificentandthesublimeareexpressedinharmony,intheinternalandexternalbalanceofacommunity.12
Toalinear-thinkinglegalmind,thedefinitionof SumakKawsay mayseemimpossiblyimprecise.Thatisbecausethetruemeaningof SumakKawsay escapesasimple translation,anditistoodif ficulttocaptureinWesternthought.Trulyunderstanding SumakKawsay requires “ look[ing]attheconception ofPachamamaforIndigenous peoplesofEcuador,awarethatthereisadiversityofIndigenouspeoplesanddiversity ofrealities,[and]therefore,adiversityofconceptionsofPachamamaand Sumak Kawsay. ”13
Nonetheless,thevariousconceptionsof SumakKawsay dosharecommonfundamentalprinciples.AndeanphilosopherJavierLajohasidenti fied fivesuchprinciples:
1.Thereisnolifewithoutwisdom(TucuYachay);
2.WeallcomefromMotherEarth(Pachamama);
3.Lifeishealthy(HambiKawsay);
4.Lifeiscollective(SumakKamaña);and 5.Weallhaveanidealordream(HatunMuskuy).14
10 Id. at28; seealso KATHERINE BOWEN SCOFIELD ,INDIGENOUS RIGHTSAND CONSTITUTIONAL CHANGEIN ECUADOR 1-3 (2017)(IndianaUniversityDissertation).
11 DanielaBressaFlorentin, BuenVivirinEcuador,inTHE POLITICSOF WELLBEING:THEORY,POLICYAND PRACTICE 132(IanBache&KarenScotteds.,2018).
12 LuisMacas, SumakKawsay:LaVidaenPlenitud,J. OF AM.LAT.MOV 14-16(2010).
13 Ibáñez-Elam,at284.
14 JavierLajo, RecuperemoselSumakKawsay-elVivirBien-,porun ‘OrdenAndino’ , AMERICA LATINAEN MOVIMIENTO (July15,2008),https://www.alainet.org/es/active/25273.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw 476
Chapter17:Ecuador
Ultimately,theEcuadorianConstituentAssemblyembraced SumakKawsay asone ofthepillarsofitsnewConstitution.Inlargepart,rightsofnatureemergeddirectly fromthismindset.Asidefromsupporting SumakKawsay,constitutionaldraftersidentifi edmanyotherbene fi tsofrightsofnature:itsupportedplurinationalism(theexistenceofseveraldifferentnationsinapolit icalstate),helpedaddresstheecological crisis,andmightcurbdominantcapitalisticin fl uences,amongstothers.15 Thusrights ofnaturewasincludedinthe2008Constitution,asdiscussedinthenextsubsection.
B.RightsofNatureandRelatedEnvironmentalProtections
Basedinpartupontheconceptof SumakKawsay,Ecuador’ sConstitutionestablished rightsofnatureprotectionsinTitleII,Chapter7 Articles71-74,entitled “Rightsof Nature.” Thesubstantiverightsconstitutionallyrecognizedasbelongingtonatureare speci ficallythoseinArticles71and72:
Art71 .Nature,orPachaMama,wherelifeisreproducedandoccurs,hastherightto integralrespectforherexistenceandforthemaintenanceandregenerationofherlife cycles,structure,functionsandevolutionaryprocesses.
Allpersons,communities,peoplesandnat ionscancalluponpublicauthoritiesto enforcetherightsofnature.Toenforceandi nterprettheserights,theprinciplesset forthintheConstitutionshallbeobserved,asappropriate.
TheStateshallgiveincentivestonaturalpersonsandlegalentitiesandtocommunitiestoprotectnatureandtopromoteresp ectforalltheelementscomprisingan ecosystem.
Art72.Naturehastherighttoberestored.ThisrestorationshallbeapartfromtheobligationoftheStateandnaturalpersonsorlegalentitiestocompensateindividualsand communitiesthatdependonaffectednaturalsystems.
Inthosecasesofsevereorpermanentenvironmentalimpact,includingthosecaused bytheexploitationofnonrenewablenaturalresources,theStateshallestablishthemost effectivemechanismstoachievetherestorationandshalladoptadequatemeasuresto eliminateormitigateharmfulenvironmentalconsequences.
Thesearethebedrockguaranteesofnature ’ srightsinEcuador,althoughtheir exactmeaningisstillsubjecttointerpretation.Forexample,whenisaprojectdeemed tohaveinterferedwiththe “maintenance” ofPachamama’ s “lifecycles,structure,functionsandevolutionaryprocesses”?Isitastrictlyscience-baseddetermination?Doesa courtjust “ knowitwhenitseesit? ” Further,naturehasarighttoberestoredin Article72 buttoberestoredtowhatstate?Thecourtsarealreadygrapplingwith manyofthesequestions.
Continuing,Article73establishescertainaf fi rmativedutiesontheEcuadorian government whichincludesexecutive,legislative,andjudicialbranches toprotect nature,withanemphasisonpreventing permanent harmtonature:
15 Foramoredetaileddescriptionofthedebatelea dingtotheadoptionofthe2008Constitution, see ConstituentEcuadorianAssembly.ActN.º58,June6,2008. Seealso Prieto, supra note19,at40-46.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Art.73.TheStateshallapplypreventiveandrestrictivemeasuresonactivitiesthatmight leadtotheextinctionofspecies,thedestructionofecosystemsandthepermanentalterationofnaturalcycles.
Theintroductionoforganismsandorganicandinorganicmaterialthatmightdefinitivelyalterthenation’sgeneticassetsisforbidden.
Finally,Article74establishesthathumansstillhavearighttobenefitfromtheenvironment,with SumakKawsay (translatedhereas “ goodwayofliving ” )astheendin view:
Art74.Persons,communities,peoples,andnationsshallhavetherighttobenefitfrom theenvironmentandthenaturalwealthenablingthemtoenjoy thegoodwayofliving.
Environmentalservicesshallnotbesubje cttoappropriation;theirproduction, delivery,useanddevelopmentshallberegu latedbytheState.Therightsofnature provisionsinArticles71-74arestrengthenedbysubsequentarticlesaddressingthe legalrelationshipbetweenhumansandnature.Here,theConstitutionaddressesboth thehumandutiesandresponsibilitiesthatarenecessarytoupholdtherightsofnature (Art.83),andonceagaincallsforaharmoniouscoexistencewithnaturethroughthe lensof SumakKawsay (Art.275):
Art.83. Ecuadorianshavethefollowingdutiesa ndobligations,withoutdetrimentto othersprovidedforbytheConstitutionorbylaw:.
6.Torespecttherightsofnature,preserveahealthyenvironmentandusenatural resourcesrationally,sustainablyanddurably.
Art.275. Thedevelopmentstructureistheorganized,sustainableanddynamicgroupof economic,political,socio-culturaland environmentalsystemswhichunderpinthe achievementofthegoodwayofliving(SumakKawsay). Thegoodwayoflivingshall requirepersons,communities,peoplesandn ationalitiestoeffecti velyexercisetheir rightsandful filltheirresponsibilitieswithintheframeworkofinterculturalism,respect fortheirdiversity,andharmoniouscoexistencewithnature.
Tosome,itmaysoundasthoughrightsofnaturewouldprohibitanyactivitythat impactstheenvironment,butthisisnotth ecase.Noteveryenvironmentalimpact hasthepotentialtothreatenorharmtheintegrityofnature’sexistenceandthemaintenanceandregenerationofherlifecycle s,structure,functionsandevolutionary processes thosefundamentalprotectionsestablishedbytheConstitution.Rightsof naturerepresentsarebalancing,notanelim ination,ofhumanactivitiesthatimpact theenvironment,withthegoalofprotectingandrestoringbasicecologicalprocesses. Therefore,lifestylessuchasthosesuggestedbytheSarayakupeoplearenottheonly acceptablelifestyleunderthisenvironme ntalapproach,althoughtheydoprovide helpfulguidance.Ontheotherhand,activitiesthatfailtorespectthesenorms regardlessofwhetheravalidpermitorlicensehasbeenissued wouldbeinviolation ofnature’sconstitutionalrights.
Chapter17:Ecuador
C.EcuadorianEnvironmentalConstitutionalism
Inadditionto SumakKawsay,twoother “pillarsofsupport” forrightsofnaturemaybe recognizedinEcuador ’sConstitution:(1)constitutionalenvironmentalprinciplesthat developedinEcuadorsincethe1990s,suchasthehumanrighttoahealthyenvironment,and(2)internationalenvironmenta llaw,suchassustainabledevelopment agreements,theConventiononBiologicalDiversity,andthe1982WorldCharterfor Nature.16 Asanexampleofthelatter,Principle1oftheWorldCharterproclaimsthat “ Natureshallberespected anditsessentialprocessesshallnotbeimpaired.” ThislanguageisechoedinArticle71ofEcuador ’s2008Constitution,whichupholdsnature’ s rightsandrequirestheStatetopromoterespecttowardsnature.Itmaybehelpfulto considerEcuadorianenvironmentalconstitutionalisminthecontextofthreepillars: Indigenouslaw(including SumakKawsay),constitutionallaw,andinternationalenvironmentallaw.
AsidefromArticles71-74assertionofrightsofnatureprinciples,Ecuador ’sConstitutionappliesotherprinciplesofenvironmentallawthatsupportrightsofnature.For example,Article395isfrequentlycitedinrightsofnaturedecisionsthatalsoinvolve basichumanrights.PayspecialattentiontoArticle395.3,whichcommandstheState toallowaffectedpopulationstoparticipateinplanningandmonitoringactivities impactingtheenvironment:
Art.395. TheConstitutionrecognizesthefollowingenvironmentalprinciples:
1.TheStateshallguaranteeasustainablemodelofdevelopment,onethatisenvironmentallybalancedandrespectfulofculturaldiversity,conservesbiodiversityandthe naturalregenerationcapacityofecosystems,andensuresmeetingtheneedsofpresentandfuturegenerations.
2.Environmentalmanagementpoliciesshallbeappliedcuttingacrossallsectorsand dimensionsandshallbemandatorilyenforcedbytheStateatallofitslevelsandby allnaturalpersonsorlegalentitiesinthecountry’sterritory.
3.TheStateshallguaranteetheactiveandpermanentparticipationofaffectedpersons, communities,peoplesandnationsintheplanning,implementationandmonitoring ofallactivitiesexertingenvironmentalimpacts.
Furthermore,Articles395.4and396establishthe indubiopronatura (whenin doubt,favornature)principleandtheprecautionaryprinciple,respectively.The first statesageneralconstitutionalrulethatnatureshouldbeprotectedaboveotherinterestswhenthereisdoubtabouthowlegalprovisionsshouldbeapplied.Itisprimarily enforcedbythejudicialbranchwheninterpretingenvironmentalrules,butitisalso mandatoryfordecisionsofthelegislativea ndexecutivebranches.Meanwhile,Article396establishesthatthestatehasadutytoprotecttheenvironmentwheneverthere isuncertaintyaboutenvironmentalimpacts.
16 See HUGO ECHEVERRÍA,THE RIGHTSOF NATURE,FUNDACIÓN PACHAMAMA,RECOGNIZING RIGHTSFOR NATUREINTHE ECUADORIAN CONSTITUTION 2(n.d.)(discussingthe1998Constitution’sprotectionoftherighttoahealthyenvironment)andRIGHTSOF NATURE: THE ECUADORIAN CASE,78-79(2017).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Art.395.4. Intheeventofdoubtaboutthescopeoflegalprovisionsforenvironmental issues,itisthemostfavorableinterpretationoftheireffectiveforcefortheprotection ofnaturethatshallprevail.
Art.396. TheStateshalladopttimelypoliciesandmeasurestoavoidadverseenvironmentalimpactswherethereiscertaintyaboutthedamage.Inthecaseofdoubtabout theenvironmentalimpactstemmingfromadeedoromission,althoughthereisnoscienti fi cevidenceofthedamage,theStateshalladopteffectiveandtimelymeasuresof protection.
TheConstitutionalsoestablishesthe human righttoliveinahealthyenvironment thatisdistinctfrom,butrelatedto,therightsofnatureprovisions:
Art.14. Therightofthepopulationtoliveinahealthyandecologicallybalancedenvironmentthatguaranteessustainabilityandthegoodwayofliving(SumakKawsay)isrecognized.Environmentalconservation,theprotectionofecosystems,biodiversityandthe integrityofthecountry’sgeneticassets,thepreventionofenvironmentaldamage,and therecoveryofdegradednaturalspacesaredeclaredmattersofpublicinterest.
Art.66.Thefollowingrightsofpersonsarerecognizedandguaranteed: ::: 27. Therighttoliveinahealthyenvironmentthatisecologicallybalanced,pollutionfreeandinharmonywithnature.
Observethatnature’srightsandhumanenvironmentalrightsarecompletelyseparateunderEcuador’ sConstitution.Theyaredifferentrightsbelongingtodifferent rights-holders.However,theyarecomplementaryinpracticebecausehumanenvironmentalrightscannotbeupheldwithoutres pectfornature.Still,considerwhethera rightsofnatureparadigmshouldestablishasinglesetofrightsfortheentireEarth community includingbothhumansandtherestofnature.Ifthegoalisforhumans andnaturetolivetogetherinharmony,shouldwemoveawayfromthe us (humans) and them (nature)mentality?Orifhumanenvironmentalrightsandrightsofnature areseparated,shoulddiffe rentcomponentsofnaturealsohavetheirowntailored rights forestrights,animalrights,oceanrights,andsoforth?
IV.RIGHTSOFNATURECOURTCASES
ThroughMarch2020,morethan32legaldecisionsinEcuadorhaveinvolvedtherights ofnature.17 Ofthose,atleastsevencaseshavereachedEcuador ’sConstitutionalCourt. Article429oftheConstitutionstatesthattheConstitutionalCourtisEcuador’shighest authorityonconstitutionalinterpretation, soitsdecisionssetprecedentsthatgreatly contributetothedevelopmentofrightsofnature.Thissectionexplorestherightsof naturecasesdecidedbythisCourt.
17 CasosenEcuador,OBSERVATORIO JURIDICO DEDERECHOS DELANATURALEZA (lastvisitedMar.27,2020),https:// www.derechosdelanaturaleza.org.ec/casos-en-ecuador.
Chapter17:Ecuador
A. Biodigesters Case,RulingNo.0567-08-RA(2009)18
The Biodigesters case,submittedin2007,wasthe fi rsttoberesolvedfromarightsof natureperspectivebytheConstituti onalCourt.Thecasewasbroughtasan amparo action,whichseekstoprotectanindividual’srightswhilealsoupholdingtheConstitutionforitsownsake.19 Thecaseconcernedanagro-industrialpigfarmthatplannedto installsixbiodigesters,whichturnhogwasteintomethanegas.Theplaintiffs,neighborsofthefarm,complainedaboutasuiteofenvironmentalharmsarisingfromthe pigfarm,includingairpollution,waterpollutionfromwastewaterdischarges,and otherwisepoorenvironmentalmanagement.However,theonlyremedysoughtbythe lawsuitwastosuspendinstallationofthebiodigesters,whichcanproducetoxicodors.
TheCourtdeniedthe amparo,arguingthattheinstallationofbiodigestersdoesnot, initself,violatethehumanrighttoliveinahealthyenvironment.TheCourtfurther arguedthatbiodigestersfallundertheCleanDevelopmentMechanismoftheKyotoProtocol,sincetheyreplacetheuseoffossilfuelswithbiogasrecycledfromanimalmanure.
Whiletheplaintiffslostonthebiogasissue,theCourttookabroaderlookatthe agro-industrialfarm’senvironmentalimpacts,namelyitswastewaterdischarges,which foryearshadbeenreportedtoauthorities withoutaneffectiveresponse.TheCourt, forthe fi rsttimeever,appliedthe2008Constitution ’ srightsofnatureprotections, whichbythetimeoftherulinghadjustgoneintoeffect.TheCourtstatedthatitwould “consideralltheelementsofthecase,and[all]thepartiesinvolved, amongstwhichis Nature ” becausetheexistenceoflife notonlyhumanlife,but all livingspecies dependsuponwater.20 TheCourtcontinuedbyreaf firmingtherightsofnatureand recognizingtheState’saffirmativedutytoenforcetheserights:
Theintegralandeffectiverespectofherexistencemustbeful fi lledbysafeguarding eachandeveryoneofhersystems,processes,andnaturalelements,consideringitabove allasbeingpartofanimperativeprecautionforthemaintenanceandregenerationof vitalcycles,structure,functions,andevolutionaryprocesses. :::
Forthisreason,wecannotsetaside articles71and72oftheSupremeLawofthe State,whichstatesthatNaturehastherighttohaveherexistencefullyrespected ::: as wellastherighttoberestoredwhennaturalsystemsareaffected.Evenmoresowhen, accordingtothesamefoundationalCharter,assetoutinarticles3and277,itisthe State’sdutytoprotectnaturalassetsandguaranteetherightsofindividuals,communities,andNature.
Insupportofrightsofnature,the Courtalsoappliedtheconceptof indubiopro natura,meaning “ incaseofdoubt,favornature:”
Wemustbearinmindthatthisguaranteeofprotectionofnatureenjoystheprincipleof autonomy,thatis,itmustbeconsideredholisticallyasanendandnotasameansto
18 CorteConstitutional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],LaPrimeraSalajulio16,2009J.P:R.Pinoargote,No. 0567-08-RA,RegistroOficialSuplemento23(Ecuador).
19 Awritof amparo issimilartothe accióndetutela (tutelageaction)discussedinChapter18, “Colombia.”
20 CaseNo.0567-08-RA,supra note18.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
whichherownbehaviorisinevitablyrespected;[tounderstand]otherwisewouldbeto omitthevalidityof[nature’s]rightsandlegalprotection[s].Forthatpurpose,wealso invoketheprinciple indubiopronatura,whichentails[principlesof]preventionasmuch asprecautionandintegralrestorationwithrespecttotheeffectscausedbyhumanactivity.ItisanobligationofthisCourt,asaguardianofcompliancewiththeconstitutional mandates,torealizethewilloftheconstituentinthatourFundamentalChartergrants rightstonatureaspartofabio-centristand non-anthropocentricjudicialphilosophy; thus,incaseofdoubt,environmentalprinciplesandlegalprovisionsshouldbeapplied totheprotectionofnatureinthemostfavorableway.
Finally,theCourtorderedthecreationofacommission,tobecomprisedofthe plaintiffs,supervisorybodies,andthedefendant,whichwouldmonitortheoperations ofthebiodigestersandensurecompliancewithenvironmentallaws.
Havingruledinfavorofrightsofnatureforthe fi rsttimeinthe Biodigesters case, theConstitutionalCourtlateraddressedthepotentialtensionbetweennature’srights andhumaninterestsasdemonstratedinthe GalápagosIslands casethatfollows.
B. GalápagosIslands Case,RulingNo.017-12-SIN-CC(2012)21
TheGalápagosIslandsareabiodiversityhotspotthatishometoanextraordinary amountofendemicspecies(thosefoundnow hereelseonEarth),includingthegiant Galápagostortois e,marineiguana, fl ightlesscormorant,andmanyothers.In1998, theGalápagosIslandswereestablishedasa specialregime undertheframeworkof theSpecialLawforGalápagos(LOREGorLeydeRégimenEspecialparalaConservaciónyDesarrolloSustentabledelaProvi nciadeGalápagos).Thisspecialregime allowsrestrictionsontherightsoffreeresidence,property,andcommerce,inorder toprotectthisglobalbiodiversityhotsp ot.ItalsoestablishedaGalápagosMarine Reserveextending40milesoffthecoastlineinwhichindustrial fi shingwas prohibited.
TheconstitutionalityofLOREG’srestrictionswerechallengedin2001bytheAssociationofIndustrialTunaFishermen.The plaintiffsarguedthattheprohibitionof industrial fisheriesintheGalápagosMarineReserveviolatedthelaborrightsof fishermen.TheConstitutionalCourtdisagreed, findingthatLOREGwasinaccordancewith thespecialregimeofgovernanceestablishedbyEcuador ’s1998Constitutionandreaffirmedbyits2008Constitution.
In2012,theConstitutionalCourtagainreviewedthelaw,thistimeregardingthe constitutionalityofrestrictionsontherightsofresidenceandmobilityofpeoplein
21 CorteConstitutional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],julio11,2015J.P:F.Franco,No.017-12-SIN-CC, (Ecuador).
Chapter17:Ecuador
theGalápagosIslands.TheCourt,affirmingthedecisionoftheformerConstitutional Tribunal,thistimeruledfromarightsofnatureperspective:
[TheCourt’spositioninfavoroftheLOREGiseven]morerelevantifweconsiderthat theConstitutionoftheRepublicof2008establishesachapteronthe ‘rightsofnature’ thattheStateisobligedtopromoteandguarantee.
Highlightingtheconstitutionalrecognitionofrightsofnature,theCourtwrote:
EventhoughthechallengedLawpredatestheConstitutionof2008,it ’ snotonlyin accordancewiththeformerConstitution astheConstitutionalTribunalruled but alsowiththecurrentConstitution,whosearticle258ratifiesthespecialregimeofgovernancefortheprovinceofGalápagos,whosemainobjectiveistopreservethenatural,scienti ficandeducationalvaluesoftheIslands.[TheLawisdefensible] afortiori [i.e.,with evenstrongerevidencethanbefore]iftheConstitutionsetsthehigheststandardsof environmentalprotection(rightsofnature) standardsthattheStateisobligedto protectandguarantee.
TheCourtthereforedeniedthepetitionforreviewandcon fi rmedtheconstitutionalityofthelawgoverningtheGalápagosIslands.
C. Mangroves Case,RulingNo.166-15-SEP-CC(2015)22
Thiscasearisesfromashrimpfarmoperatingwithinaprotectedmangrovesarea.In Ecuador,thereare161,835hectaresofmangrovesin fiveestuarineareas.Oneofthese isthehighlybiodiverseCayapas – Mataje,locatedinnorthwestEcuadorandhometo theworld’stallestmangroves.Cayapas–Matajeisaprotectedecologicalreserveunder EcuadorianlawandisadesignatedRamsa rsiteundertheConventiononWetlands ofInternationalImportance(RamsarCon vention).UndertheRamsarConvention, memberstatesdesignatesignificantimportantwetlands i.e.,Ramsarsites andthen musttakespecialmeasurestoprotectthem.23
Theplaintiff,Ecuador ’sMinistryofEnvironment,invokedrightsofnaturetojustifyitseffortstoremoveshrimpfarmersfromtheecologicalreserve.Theshrimpfarmers,apowerfuleconomicinterestgroupinEcuador,suedthegovernmentinprovincial courtforviolatingtheirpropertyrights.Theprovincialcourtsidedwiththeshrimp farmers.However,itsreasoningfailedtoa ddressseveralenvironmentallawissues. Forexample,theprovincialcourtdidnotco nsiderthespecialconstitutionalprotectionsaffordedtomangrovesasa “fragileecosystem,” whichwastheresultofa30-year effortthatwasexplicitlytoprotectmangrovesfromshrimpfarming.Theprovincial courtalsofailedtodiscussrightsofnature.
22 CorteConstitutional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],LaPrimeraSalaagosto28,2015J.:A.Loor,Sentencia. 166-15-SEP-CC,OfficialRecordNo.575(Ecuador).
23 HugoEcheverría, WhenCourtsMeetNature:ARealCaseonRightsofNature,VTJ. OF EVNTL.L ECOPERSPECTIVES BLOG (2018),http://vjel.vermontlaw.edu/courts-meet-nature-real-case-rights-nature.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
TheplaintiffaskedtheConstitutionalCourttoreviewtheprovincialcourt ’sdecisionbymeansofan “extraordinaryprotectionaction ” ( acciónextraordinariadeprotección ),whichallowsforthereviewofconstitutionalrightsthatareviolatedbyacourt order.
TheConstitutionalCourtofEcuadorrev iewedthecaseandconcludedthatthe lowercourt’sdecisionwasinvalidbecauseitonlyaddressedpropertyrightsinsteadof alsoconsideringrightsofnature,whichwasaparticularlylargeomissioninaprotected andfragileecosystem.TheCourtelaboratedthatallconstitutionalrightsareofequal legalsigni ficanceinEcuador,includingtherightsofnature.AsstatedbytheCourt:
ThisConstitutionalCourthasbeenemphaticinhighlightingtheimportanceofrightsto nature,whichresultintheobligationoftheStateanditsofficialstoencourageandpromoterespectforalltheelementsthatarepartofanecosystem,aswellasforNature’ s righttoberespectedinherentirety.Theseaspectshaveobviouslynotbeenobserved inacasewhosecentralissueistheinstallationofashrimpfarmwithintheCayapasMatajeecologicalreserve,aplacepossessingasystemofmangroveswithawidevariety ofspeciesoffaunaand flora.
TheCourtalsoemphasizedtheecocentricnatureofEcuador’ srightsofnature provisions.Inthefollowingexcerpt,co nsiderwhetheryouagreewiththeCourt ’ s assessmentthatnaturecanbetreatedbothasasubject(i.e.,aholderofrights)and anobject(i.e.,property)undertheConst itution,orwhethernaturecanonlybe treatedasalegalsubjectinallcontexts:
[R]ightsofnatureconstitutesoneofthemostinterestingandrelevantinnovationsfrom thecurrentConstitution,asitdepartsfromthetraditional “nature-object” conception, whichconsidersnatureaspropertyandfocusesitsprotectionexclusivelythroughthe humanrighttoenjoyahealthynaturalenvironment,[andinsteadsupports]arationale thatrecognizesrightsinfavorofnatureherself.Theinnovationreferstoachangeof paradigmonthebasisofwhich,asalivingbeing,natureisconsideredarightsholder. Inthissense,itisimportanttohighlightthattheConstitutioncreates[twotreatments of]natureandtheenvironmentingeneral [notonly]asalegalobject,butalsoasa legalsubject,independentandholdingitsownandspeci fi crights. ::: Theforegoing re fl ects,withinthelegalrelationshipbetweenhumansandnature,abiocentricvision inwhichnatureisprioritized,asopposedtotheclassicanthropocentricconceptionin whichthehumanbeingisthecenterandme asureofallthings[and]wherenature wasconsideredamereproviderofresources.
Next,theCourthighlightedthedutyofallcitizenstoupholdnature ’srightsand calledupontheStatetosupportthisrole:
Ascanbeseenfromtheconstitutionalnorm,itisimportantthatcitizensplayafundamentalroleinprotectingtherightsofnature,sinceeverypersoncanrequiretheadministrativeandjudicialauthoritiestoobserveandfulfi lltheserights[.][Therefore,]the Stateiscalledtopromotecitizens ’ participationtoutilizet hosemechanismsfocused on[nature ’ s]protection.Inthissense,allcitizensenjoylegalstandingtorepresent naturewhenherrightsarebeingviolated.
Chapter17:Ecuador
Ultimately,theCourtconcludedthatthefailuretoconsidernature’srightsinthe previousrulingbreachedtheconstitutiona lstandardsofreasonablenessandjudicial logicneededinajudgment.Therefore,theCourtannulledtheprovincialcourt’srulingandorderedittore-trythecase.
Rightsofnatureprevailedineachofthecasestudiesdiscussedabove.Thenext sectionexploresamajorcasewhereanEcuadorianCourtfavoredeconomicdevelopmentovertherightsofnature.
V.SHORTCOMINGSOFRIGHTSOFNATUREINTHECOURTS: THE MIRADORMINE CASE24
AsidefromtheConstitutionalCourtcas esanalyzedabove,rightsofnaturehashad mixedresultsinEcuador.Thissectionhighlightsafewofthechallengesfacedconstruingconstitutionally-grantedrightsofnature.Itthendiscussesthe MiradorMine caseas anexample.
CraigKauffmanandPamelaMartinidentifyfour “pathways” throughwhichrights ofnaturehasbeenappliedinEcuador:
1.Civilsocietypressure(civilsocietyactionssuchaslawsuits),
2.Instrumentalgovernmentaction(governmentactionssuchaslawsuits),
3.Bureaucraticinstitutionalization(bureaucraticactivitiessuchasroutineadministrativeactions),and
4.Professionalinterpretationsbyjudges.25
KauffmanandMartintrackedtheef fi cacyofeachpathwayintheearlyyearsof rightsofnatureinEcuador,withunexpectedresults: “Surprisingly,civilsocietypressurewastheleastsuccessfulpathway,asactivistslosthigh-pro fi lelawsuits, ” prevailing onlyinlocal,lesspoliticallychargedcases.26 Thesenorm-drivenrightsofnatureadvocateswereundercutbypoliticization,contentiousrelationshipswiththegovernment, andanabsenceofjudicialknowledgeabouthowtointerpretrightsofnature:
Theideathatindividualandcorporatepropertyrightsmustbecurtailedinsomecases toupholdNature’srightswasnotonlyforeigntomostjudges,butrancountertotheir legaltraining.Asaresult,judgesincivilsocietylawsuitshavegenerallyruledthateconomicdevelopmentactivitiesareprotectedby individualrights(e.g.,propertyrights, righttowork)thatsupersedeNature’srights.27
24 See JudgmentNo.1711120130317,CaseNo.3160,ProvincialCourtofPichincha,RepublicofEcuador (20June2013)[MiradorMineCase].
25 CraigM.KauffmanandPamelaL.Martin, CanRightsofNatureMakeDevelopmentMoreSustainable?WhySome EcuadorianlawsuitsSucceedandOthersFail, 92WORLD DEVELOPMENT 130-142,134(2017).
26 Id. at131-132.
27 Id. at134.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
The MiradorMine caseexemplifiesmanyofthehurdlesfacedbyrightsofnaturein thecourts.ThecasewaspursuedbyIndigenousandenvironmentalactivistseagerto testtherightsofnatureprovisionsintheEcuadorianConstitution.Theysettledonthe Condor-MiradorMine,anopen-pitminingprojectauthorizedbytheEcuadoriangovernmentintheZamora-ChinchipeprovinceoftheEcuadorianAmazon.TheMirador MineisamassiveChinese-backed$1.4billionopen-pitcopperandgoldmineon IndigenousShuarandCañari-Kichwaland.Atthetimeofthelawsuit,itwasstillin thedevelopmentstages.Theminethreatenedtodestroylargeareasofprimaryrainforestandpolluteanddewaterlocalrivers,includingtheWawaymeandQuimiRivers. Therightsofnatureviolationswereblatant:
Theminingcompany’sownenvironmentalimpactstudyacknowledgedthattheopenpitminewouldcauseimpactslistedasrightso fnatureviolationsintheConstitution. Theseincludethetotalremovalofecosystems,includingthehabitatsonwhichendangeredendemicspeciesrely,likelycausingtheextinctionofoneormorespecies.Also, contaminatingsurfaceandgroundwaterwithheavymetalsandtoxicproductswould becatastrophicforsurroundingwatershedecosystems.28
Additionally,theplanwouldrequiretheforcibleremovaloflocalIndigenouscommunitieswhohadbeenonthelandforgenerations.Someactivistsresistingthemine wereevenmetwithviolence.ShuarleaderJoséIsidroTendetzaAntúnwasfoundmurderedjustdaysbeforehewastopresentonrightsofnatureatacivilsociety-ledtribunal,whichmanybelievewastheresultofhisprotestsofthemine.29
In2013,activistsandlocalcommunities filedaprotectiveactioninthe25thCivil CourtinPichinchaprovinceagainstEcuacorriente,theminingcompany.Theaction soughttosuspendtheminingprojectand orderanewenvironmentalimpactstudy. ThepetitionersinvokedtheprecautionaryprincipleaswellasArticle73ofEcuador’ s Constitution,whichrequirestheStateto “ applypreventiveandrestrictivemeasures onactivitiesthatmightleadtotheextinctionofspecies,thedestructionofecosystems andpermanentalterationofnaturalcycles.”
Despitewhattheseadvocatesconsideredastrongandunequivocalcaseforrights ofnature,thejudgeruledthattheMiradorMinedidnotviolaterightsofnature. Therulingwasbasedontwopremises.First,thattheaffectedareawasnotaprotected areaandthereforedidnothaveanyrights(despitebeingcontrarytoexpressconstitutionallanguagethat all ofnaturehasrightsregardlessofitsprotectedstatus).Second, thatinthiscaseprotectingnaturewasa private goal,whereastheminingcompanywas actinginthepublicinterestbyadvanc ingdevelopment.Thepublicinterest outweighedtheprivateone,ruledthejudge.Anappealwasunsuccessful.
Afterthelawsuit,theprojectmovedforwardandisnowoperational.TheMirador Mineconcessionssprawlforsome10,000hectares,whereallvegetationandsuper ficial levelsofsoilwilleventuallyberemoved.Already,1,200hectaresofprimaryrainforest
28 Id. at134-135(internalcitationsomitted).
29 DanCollyns, WasthisIndigenousLeaderKilledBecauseHeFoughttoSaveEcuador’sLand?,THE GUARDIAN (June2, 2015).
Chapter17:Ecuador
havebeencutdown.ManyIndigenouspeopleswereforciblyevictedandcontinueto protest.30
Whydidrightsofnaturefailinthiscase?Somebelievethatpoliticalinfl uenceand lackofjudicialindependenceweretheculprits.Othersarguethatmanyjudgessimply donotunderstandtheconceptofrightsofnature,andthereforecannotsuccessfully balancenature’ srightsagainstotherconstitutiona lrights.Anotherpossibilityisthat courtsarewillingtodisregardrightsofnature(aswellasIndigenousrights)whenlarge amountsofmoneyareatstake.TheEcuadoriangovernmenthasalreadyreceived $85millioninroyaltiesfromEcuaCorrientefortheMiradorMine.31
VI.THEFUTUREOFRIGHTSOFNATUREINECUADOR
ThissectionexploresemergingdevelopmentsofrightsofnatureinEcuador,including newConstitutionalCourtcasesandlegislativereform.
A.RightsofNatureintheConstitutionalCourtAgenda
InFebruary2019,anewConstitutionalCourttookthebenchinEcuador. 32 InMay 2019,thenewCourtselectedanimportantcasethataddressestheextentoftheconstitutionalprotectionsfortherightsofnature.ThecasepertainstotheDulcepamba River.
TheConstitutionalCourtcanselectcasesthatarenovelorrelevanttoconstitutionalrightsprotections.TheCourt’srulingsonsuchselectedcaseshavean ergaomnes effect meaningitisenforceableagainstall,notjustthepartiestothecase.33 The Court ’ sreasoningprovidessubstantivecon tentforthoseconstitutionalrights addressedinthecase.Inthisspecificcase,theCourthasalreadyannouncedthatitwill addressstandardsandlimitsregardingth eexploitationofnat ureanditsimpacton rightsofnature.TheCourt’sdecisiononrightsofnature,stillpendingatthetimeof thiswriting,isexpectedtohaveameaningfullong-termimpact.
TheselectedcaseconcernstheSanJosedelTamboHydroelectricProject,which wasbuiltontheDulcepambaRiver.Developingthehydroelectricprojectrequiredsigni fi cantphysicalchangestotheDulcepambaRiver,includingdivertingtheriverbed closetothecommunityofSanPablodeAmalí.Thisultimatelycausedamajor fl ood in2015thatshatteredhouses,destroyedfarmland,andkilledtwowomenandachild.
30 MatthewC.DuPée, EcuadorHasBigPlansforItsMiningIndustry.ButatWhatEnvironmentalCost?,WORLD POLITICS REV.(Aug.12,2019),https://www.worldpoliticsreview.com/articles/28110/ecuador-has-big-plans-for-itsmining-industry-but-at-what-environmental-cost.
31 JoseLlangari, EcuadorBeginsLarge-ScaleMiningatMiradorCopperProject,REUTERS (July18,2019).
32 U.S.DEPARTMENTOF STATE,ECUADOR 2019HUMAN RIGHTS REPORT 6(2019)https://www.state.gov/wp-content/ uploads/2020/02/ECUADOR-2019-HUMAN-RIGHTS-REPORT.pdf.
33 ALLAN R.BREWER-CARÍAS,CONSTITUTIONAL PROTECTIONOF HUMAN RIGHTSIN LATIN AMERICA:ACOMPARATIVE STUDY OF AMPARO PROCEEDINGS 151(2009).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Asfortheriveritself,thehydroelectricprojecthasdevastatednativespeciesinthisbiologicallyrichregionoftheAndesMountains.
In2019,thecasewasadmittedforreviewbytheConstitutionalCourt.As explained,theCourtwillnotonlyprovidean interpartes judgment(i.e.,ajudgment betweentheparties),butalsowillissue ergaomnes dictumonthestandards,limits, andcon flictsbetweenrightsofnatureandtheexploitationofnature,suchasthrough hydroelectricdamprojects.
Numerouscivilsocietyorganizationshavesubmitted amicuscuriae briefsinsupport ofastrongrightsofnaturerulingbytheConstitutionalCourt.34 One amicus briefsubmittedbyacoalitionofenvironmentalorg anizationsrequestedthereliefdescribed below.Asyoureadit,considerwhetheryouthinkthisreliefwouldfulfillthevisionof rightsofnatureinEcuador’sConstitution.
[T]heEnvironmentalOrganizationsrespectfullyrequestthe[followingrelief fromthe]ConstitutionalCourtofEcuador:
a.That,inthepresentcase,theDulcepambaRiverberecognizedasasubject ofrightsandthattheCourt fi rmlyapplytheConstitutionalmandatecontainedinarticles71,72,73and74,whichsetsforththerightsofnatureto exist,tothemaintenanceandregenerationofitslifecycles,structure,functions,andevolutionaryprocesses,as wellastherighttoberestored.This bringswithitanobligationtotheEcuadorianStatenotonlytorespectbut toprotectandguaranteetheserightstonature.
b.ThatthehumanrighttowaterofthecommunitiesofSanPablodeAmalí berecognized.Andalso,thatwaterberecognizedasavitalelementofnature, essentialforthelifeofthecommuniti esofDulcepambaRiverwatershed,in theProvinceofBolívar,andthroughoutthecountryasestablishedinArticles 12and318oftheEcuadorianConstitution.ThealterationstotheDulcepambaRiverputatriskboththehumanrighttowaterandtherightsof nature.
c.ThattheCourtrecognizesthespecificrightsoftherivers,andespeciallyof theDulcepambaRiver.Thefundamentalrightsoftheriversare:(1)theright of flow(groundedintheecological flowrecognizedintheEcuadorianlegislation);(2)therighttoexercisetheiressentialfunctionswithintheirecosystems;(3)therighttobefreefromallcontamination;(4)therighttofeed andbefedbytheirtributaries;(5)therighttonativebiodiversity;(6)theright torestoration;and(7)therighttoindependentappointmentofoneormore
34 See,e.g., AmicusCuriae:EarthLawCenter,GreatLakesEnvironmentalLawCenter,InternationalRivers,& CEDENMA,submittedtotheConstitutionalCourtofEcuador,CaseNo.502-19-JP(2019).
Chapter17:Ecuador
legalguardians,whoactsolelyinthenameofriverrights,withatleastone legalguardianasrepresentative.35
d.ThattheCourtappointoneormorelegalguardiansonbehalfoftheDulcepambaRiver.Thelegalguardiansmustbeindependent,quali fi ed,appropriate,withhumanand fi nancialcapacity,andactsolelyinthenameofthe rightsandinterestsofnature.AlthoughArticle71oftheConstitutionestablishesthat: “ anyperson,community,peop le,ornationmaydemandfrom thepublicauthoritythefulfillmentoftherightsofnature,” theEnvironmental Organizationsrecommendgivingnatureavoice,ahumanfaceandtheability toappearbeforetheCourt.
e.ThatitguaranteestherighttotheecologicalrestorationoftheDulcepamba RiverasprovidedforinArticle72oftheConstitutionofEcuador,byissuing (a)anordertoenjoinanddismantletheHidrotamboSAprojectasitis incompatiblewiththeRightsofNature,thehumanrighttowater,andthe HumanandEconomic,SocialandCulturalRightsofthecommunitiesof SanPablodeAmalí;and,(b)arestorationorderthatmustbeappliedin accordancewithArticle396oftheEcuadorianConstitution.
f.ThatitorderstheEcuadoriangovernmenttoful fillitsobligationtoguaranteetherightsofnatureestablishedinarticle277oftheConstitutionof Ecuadorandeliminatepossibilitiesfordilutionoftherightsofnature.Todo this,thegovernmentmustensurethatstateagenciescoordinatetoprotect andpromotethevalidityoftherightsofnature. :::
g.ThatitinstructstheNationalAsse mblythattheOrganicEnvironmental Codemustincludepositive,concrete,andeffectivemechanismsforeachstate institutiontoprotecttherightsofnatureinitsadministrativeacts.
h.Thatitordersthecreationofanindependentsubcommitteecomposedof environmentalscientistsandengineer s,responsibleforevaluatingcurrent andfuturehydroelectricprojectsforthepreventionofnegativeimpacts,the possibleneedfordismantling,andthe restorationofnature.Theestablishmentofasubcommitteededicatedtotheabovewouldensurethattheenvironmentaleffectsofthedamsareconsideredandthatnewdamsareonly constructedinexceptionalcircumst anceswhennecessarytoobtainavital social,ecologicalorenergyobjectivethatcannotbeachievedbyotherreasonablemeans.36
35 NotethattheserightsarebasedonacivilsocietyinitiativetocreateandimplementaUniversalDeclaration oftheRightsofRivers. See EarthLawCenter, UniversalDeclarationoftheRightsofRivers ,https://www. earthlawcenter.org/river-rights.
36 HugoEcheverria,interviewbyauthor,Mar.20,2019.
B.LegislativeReform
InDecember2019,aproposaltoreformtheEnvironmentalCodeofEcuador,includingchangestotherightsofnature,wassubmittedtotheEcuadorianlegislature.The proposalassertsthatrightsofnatureareco nstitutionalrightsandthereforemustbe givensubstantivecontentvialegislation.Tothisend,itputsforwardreformstothecurrentlaw,whichdoesnotprovideforsuchcontent.Theinitiativeisopentopubliccommentaswellaslegislativedebate.
Todate,despitenumerousvictories,manyregardrightsofnatureasmainlybeing symbolic. 37 However,throughlegislativereform,aswellasthroughlandmarkcourt decisions,rightsofnaturecanfullytake shape,gaininggreaterclarityonhowitcan beappliedinawaycommensuratewithotherhumanconstitutionalrights.Ifthis occurs,12yearsafteritsrecognitioninEcuador,rightsofnaturemaybecometheecocentriclegalregimeenvisionedbyitsconstitutionaldrafters.
VII.CONCLUSION
Asstated,therecognitionofrightsofnatureconstitutesanimportantlegaldevelopmentformanyreasons,includingtheacceptanceofanewparadigmofahumannaturerelationship.Thisisadif fi cultgoal,onethatrequiresmorethanthe12years thathavepassedsincerightsofnatureachievedconstitutionalrecognition.Many humanrights-basedmovementsstillstruggleforrecognition.InEcuador,onepromisingdevelopmentissimplythatnature ’ srightsarebeingfoughtforincourts and, sometimes,natureistheprevailingparty.Thisismorethancanbesaidinalmostevery othercountryintheworld.Additionally,theConstitutionalCourtisonthevergeofa majorrightsofnaturedecision,whichcouldfurtherclarifytheseissues and,withit, agreaterapplicationofrightsofnature.
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1) SumakKawsay (roughlytranslatedto buenvivir inSpanishand goodliving in English)isaworldviewheldbytheQuechuapeoplesoftheAndes.Whatworldviewexistsinyourowncountryorregionthatmightserveasthebackboneofa constitutionalamendmentthatincludesrightsofnatureprotections?
(2)Article74ofEcuador ’ sConstitutionestablishesthatnaturehasarighttobe restored.Youhavebeenappointedasa rightsofnatureombudsmanandyour fi rsttaskistocreateaplanforenforci ngArticle74.Howwouldyougoabout puttingthisintopractice?Wouldyoutr ytorestoreecosystemsthathavebeen
37 RicardoCrespo, LaNaturalezaComoSujetodeDerecho s:¿SímbolooRealidadJurídica?,12I URIS D ICTIO 31-37 (2009).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw 490
harmedperpetuallyfordecades?Orwouldyoufocusonmorerecentimpacts, suchasfromongoingminingprojects?Whatlimitationswouldyouestablishto nature ’srighttorestoration,ifany?
(3)The Mangroves caseemphasizedtheEcu adoriangovernment ’ sdutytoenforce therightsofnature.Doyouthinknati onalgovernmentscanproperlyuphold therightsofnaturewhentheyhavesomanycompetinginterests especially short-termeconomicconsiderations thatmightrunafoulofbasicrightsof natureprinciples?Doyouthinkentirenewformsofgovernancearenecessary inordertoputrightsofnatureintopractice?Wouldanewbranchofgovernmentbenecessary,orperhapsgreaterecosystemrepresentationwithinexisting branchesofgovernment?
(4)The MiradorMine caseindicatesthatnotallEcuadoreancourtsarereadytoplace therightsofnatureaboveeconomicinterests,eveniftherightsofnatureshould prevailbytheletterofthelaw.Howdidthe Mirador courtjustifyitsruling?Do youthinkitwascorrect?Whatdoesthissayforthepotentialofrightsofnature tobethedrivingforcebehindsystemschangeintheeconomicsystem?
(5)TherehavebeenseveralcasesinEcuadoraddressinganimalrightsissues,suchas a2017caseresultinginacriminalconvictionforillegalshark fi nningbasedin partonrightsofnature.38 Considerhowrightsofnaturediffersfromtherights ofaspecificanimal.Allspeciesplayimportantroles,butcertainspeciesareparticularlycriticaltoecosystembalance pollinatorspecies,keystonepredators, andsoforth.Shouldrightsofnatureprotectionsfavortheseanimalsanddisfavor others,suchasoverpopulatedanimals?Domesticanimals,suchassheeporchickens,donotplayanimportantroleinmaintainingecosystembalanceatall.Are theystillrightlessunderarightsofnatureparadigm?
(6)Youhavebeeninvitedtospeakaboutrightsofnaturebyagovernmentaltask forceinyourcountrychargedwithamendingitsconstitution.Theywanttoknow howthelessonslearnedinEcuadorcoul dinformtheirownconsiderationof adoptingtherightsofnature.Whatwouldyoutellthem?Wouldyouputanylimitationsonrightsofnature?Howwouldyouaddressthechallengeofpractical enforcement?
38 EarthLawCenter, RightsofNaturetoSavetheEndangeredSharksoftheGalápagos (July9,2018),https://www. earthlawcenter.org/blog-entries/2018/7/rights-of-nature-to-save-the-endangered-sharks-of-the-galapagos. Chapter17:Ecuador
CHAPTER18
Nature’sRightsinColombia:An EmergingJurisprudence1
I.ANINTRODUCTIONTOCOLOMBIA
Inresponsetothesigni fi cantthreatsitsecosystemsface,theColombianlegalsystem hasdevelopednewwaysofprotectingnature.ThischapterexploreshowColombia’ s developmentofEarthlawhasgrantedspeci ficecosystemsaspecialformofprotection bymakingthemsubjectsofrights.TwosuchecosystemsaretheAtratoRiverBasinand theColombianAmazon,whichhavebothbeengiventhestatusofalegalperson. Thesejudicialdecisionsrefl ecttheColombiancourts’ willingnesstoapplynew,bold environmentalandhumanrightslegalparadigms.
A.Colombia’sEnvironment
ColombiasitsonthenorthwesternborderofSouthAmerica,surroundedbyPanamato thenorthwest;Venezuelatotheeast;andEcuador,Peru,andBraziltothesouth. Colombiaranksasthesecondmostbiodiversecountryintheworld,and fi rstinbird andorchidspecies.2 AsignificantnumberofColombia ’smegadiverseecosystemstranscendnationalborders.3 Forexample,themegadiverseChocó-Dariénecoregionruns fromeasternPanamatonorthwestEcuado r.Thisecoregioncontainsavarietyof importantecosystemsthatserveashabitatforthousandsofplantandanimalspecies, manyofthemendemic(orunique)tothatregion. 4 Thebest-knownexampleisthe
1 ThischapterwasauthoredbyCamilaBustos,aJ.D.candidateatYaleLawSchool,andWhitneyRichardson,a socialscienceresearcherwhofocusesonhumanrightsandenvironmentalpolitics.
2 ChrisBell, Here’sWhyColombiaIsOneoftheMostBiodiverseCountriesonEarth,C ULTURE TRIP (Mar.7,2018), https://theculturetrip.com/south-america/colombia/articles/heres-why-colombia-is-one-of-the-most-biodiverse-countries-on-earth/(mostdiversityinbirdandorchidspecies);VarunKuman, 17MegadiverseCountriesin theWorld,RED RANK (Dec.22,2018),https://www.rankred.com/top-10-megadiverse-countries-in-the-world/ (rankedsecond-mostbiodiversecountry).
3 SeeOtherEcoregionsofSouthAmerica ,Y ALE S CHOOLOF F ORESTRY &E NVIRONMENTAL S TUDIES ,https:// globalforestatlas.yale.edu/amazon/ecoregions/other-ecoregions(lastvisitedJan.23,2020)(thisissignificant initsimplicationsforinternationaljurisdiction,andchallengesassociatedwithdemarcatingthelegalpersonhoodofecosystems).
4 LUIS FERNANDO GÓMEZ N. ETAL.,LANDSCAPE MANAGEMENTIN CHOCÓ-DARIÉN PRIORITY WATERSHEDS 5(LuisFernando GómezN.etal.eds.,2014),http://www.wwf.org.co/?221730/Documento-Landscape-Management-in-ChocoDarien-Priority-Watersheds.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Amazon theworld’slargesttropicalrainforest whichspansninecountries.Interms ofanimallife,theAmazonishometoatleast25percentoftheworld ’ sknownland species.5
B.TheColombianLegalSystem
ThejudiciaryofColombiadoesnothaveasinglesupremeentitytooverseethelower courts,butratherhasfourcourts(the “HighCourts”),whicharethesupremetribunals ofdecisionintheirrespective fields.ThefourhighcourtsaretheConstitutionalCourt (headoftheconstitutionaljurisdiction ),theSupremeCourt(headoftheordinary jurisdiction),theCouncilofState(headof theadministrativejurisdiction),andthe SuperiorCouncilofJudicature(headofthedisciplinaryjurisdiction).Unlikethe UnitedStates,Colombiaisacivillawsystembasedoncodesandlaws,whicharepassed andupdatedbyabicamerallegislature.AlthoughColombiadoesnotrecognizeprecedentthesamewaycommonlawcountriesdo,judicialdecisionsbyitsConstitutional CourtanditsSupremeCourtofJusticehavegainedincreasingrecognitionbyregional courtsinrecentyears.Nevertheless,decisionsbythenationalcourtsareoftencitedas authority,informingjudges’ interpretationofthelaw.Thejudiciarydoesnothavethe legislativepowertocreatenewlaws;itonly restatesexistingnationalobligations.In additiontoconsultingcodesandstatutes,ColombianjudgeslookattheNationalConstitutionof1991whenrulingonlegalquestions.
Article1oftheNationalConstitutionstatesthat “Colombiaisasocialstateoflaw undertheruleoflaw,organizedintheformofaunitaryrepublic,decentralized,with autonomyofitsterritorialentities,democratic,participatory,andpluralistic.”6 While Article1describesColombiaasbeingadecentralizedrepublic,Colombiastillhasa centralizedgovernmentresponsibleformakinglaws.
Colombiaisdividedinto32departments.Unlike “states” intheUnitedStatesand elsewhere, “ departments ” inColombiadonothavelegislativeorjudicialauthority. Theydo,however,enjoyautonomyintheadm inistrationofsectionalissuesandin theplanningandpromotionofeconomicandsocialdevelopmentwithintheirrespectiveterritories.7
C.The1991Constitution
The1991NationalConstitutionemerged fromawidespreadsensethatColombia neededmodernandrobustdemocraticinstitutions,strongerhumanrightsguarantees, anewframeworktotackleviolenceandinequality,andanendtocorruption.8 Itwas
5 SECRETARIATOFTHE CONVENTIONON BIODIVERSITY,FOREST BIODIVERSITY EARTH’S LIVING TREASURE 8(2010).
6 CONSTITUCIÓN POLÍTICADE COLOMBIA 1991,art.1.
7 Id. atart.298.
8 See JULIETA LEMAITRE RIPOLL,EL DERECHO COMO CONJURO:FETICHISMO LEGAL,VIOLENCIAY MOVIMIENTOS SOCIALE 96 (2009)(Thestudentmovementspublishedamanifestocallingforanationalreferendumtitled “WeCanStill SaveColombia,” whichrapidlybecamethewaythemovementidentifieditself).
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
draftedandapprovedbyaConstitutionalA ssemblycomprisedof70delegatesfrom diversebackgrounds,includingpolitician s,formerguerrillamembers,Indigenous leaders,academics,andpeoplerepresentingtheinterestsofbusinessandlabor.9
TheColombianConstitutionhasstrongprotectionsofcitizens’ rights.Itincludes notonlyfundamentalrightsbutalsoeconomicandsocialrights.Italsorecognizes theethnicandculturaldiversityofColombia,includingthelanguagesanddialectsof ethnicgroups.10 Indigenouspeoplesareexplicitlypermittedtoformspecialjurisdictionsoutsidethenationaljurisdiction.11
Someoftheconstitutionalprotectionsoffundamentalrightsincludetherightto life;protectionfromtorture,cruel,inhumane,ordegradingtreatmentorpunishment; equalprotectionandtreatment;freedom ofconscience;freedomofreligion;and others.12 Article13,inparticular,makesexplicitthenotionthatthestatewillgivespecialprotectiontoindividualswho,onaccountoftheireconomic,physical,ormental condition,areinvulnerablecircumstances.
ThesecondchapteroftheConstitutionidenti fi essocial,economic,andcultural rights.Theserightsincludetherighttoafamily,equalrightsandopportunitiesfor menandwomen,therightsofchildren,collectivebargaining,publichealth,education,food,andothers.13 OfspecialinterestisArticle63,whichstatesthatpropertyin publicuse,naturalparks,communallandsofethnicgroups,andothertypesofpropertyare “inalienable,imprescriptible,andnotsubjecttoseizure.”
Thethirdchapterdescribescollectiverightsandtheenvironment.This chapterhasbeenreferredtoasan “EcologicalConstitution,” whereprotectionofthe environmentandbiodiversityischaracterizedasa “higherinterest.” 14 Itcontains30 provisionsintotalthatenshrineaseries ofprinciples,mandates,andobligations focusedon: “(1)protectingtheenvironmentinanintegralmanner,and(2)guaranteeingamodelofsustainabledevelopment.”15 Referencetothe “EcologicalConstitution”
9 DAVID RAMPFAND DIANA C HAVARRO ,THE 1991C OLOMBIA NATIONAL C ONSTITUENT A SSEMBLY:T URNING EXCLUSION INTO INCLUSION, ORA VAIN ENDEAVOUR?8(2014).
10 CONSTITUCIÓN POLÍTICADE COLOMBIA 1991,arts.7,10.
11 Id. atart.246(“theauthoritiesofIndigenouspeoplesmayexercisetheirjurisdictionalfunctionswithintheir territorialjurisdictioninaccordancewiththeirownlawsandprocedures” aslongastheyarenotcontraryto nationallawsandtheConstitution).
12 Id. atarts.11-16,18-19,29,37.
13 Id. atarts.5,42-44,49,55,67.
14 CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],SalaSextadeRevisiónnoviembre10,2016,M.P:JPalacio,SentenciaT-622,(p.31)(Colom.).
15 Id .ForadditionalinformationontheConstituciónEcológica, see CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],SalaPlenadelaCorteConstitucionalmayo23,2018,M.S:C.Schlesinger,SentenciaC-048,GacetadelaCorteConstitucional[G.C.C.](Colom.);CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],Sala PlenadelaCorteConstitucionalmayo18,2016,M.S:L.Pérez,SentenciaC-259,GacetadelaCorteConstitucional[G.C.C.](Colom.);CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],SalaTerceradeRevisiónabril 3,2008,M.P:J.Triviño,SentenciaT-299(Colom.);CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],abril 12,2000,M.P:V.Mesa,Sentencia431(Colom.);ConsejodeEstado[C.E.][StateCouncil],CámaraRegional delaConstruccióndeCundinamarcanoviembre5,2013,C.P:M.Lasso,Fallo66203,GacetadelConsejode Estado[G.C.E.](Colom.);Juzgado34AdministrativodeBogotá[J.Admtivos][34thAdministrativeCourtof Bogota],agosto6,2019,J:O.Marín,Fallo00222(Colom.);Juzgado39AdministrativodeBogotá[J.Admtivos] [39thAdministrativeCourtofBogota],marzo1,2019,J:L.Guevara,Fallo02488(Colom.).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
ismadewithincourtjudgmentsrecognizingnature’srights,andthesearticlesserveas acriticalcomponentinthedecision-makingprocess.16
HumanenvironmentalrightsarerecognizedinArticle79,whichestablishesthat “everyindividualhastherighttoenjoyahealthyenvironment.Thelawwillguarantee thecommunity ’ sparticipationinthedecisionsthatmayaffectit. ” 17 Inthisway,the Constitutionconceivestherighttoahealt hyenvironmentasbothacollectiveright andanindividualone.
TheConstitutionalsoprovidesseveral mechanismsforColombianstovindicate theirrights.Forexample, tutelas ,translatedasguardianshiparrangements,function asamechanismtoprotectfundamentalrightsattheindividuallevel. 18 Sincetheyare designedtoaddressthethreatandviolationoffundamentalrights, tutela actionsare expectedtobe fi ledwithinareasonabletimeafterathreatand/orviolationtakes placeandtoberesolvedpromptly.Theymaybe fi ledwheneveranindividualhas exhaustedotheravenuesorhasnoothermeansofjudicialredress. Tutelas arehandled bytheConstitutionalCourt.
Beyondindividualrights,theConstitutioncreatesarighttocollectiveactionsto protectcollectiverightsandinterestsrelatedtotheenvironmentandpublichealth. Theseinclude accionespopulares (orpopularactions)and accionesdegrupo (orgroup actions).19 Aftertherati ficationoftheConstitution,Law472of1998definedtheproceduresforbothactions.Popularactionsa repreventativeinnature,andtheyserve toaddressactivitiesthatmayresultinharmtoalargenumberofindividuals.Group actionsarereactiveinnature,andtheyseekredressforharmsthathavealreadybeen causedtoalargenumberofindividuals.Bothtypesofcollectiveactionarehandled bytheStateCouncil.
D.TheRoleofSocioeconomicRightsJurisprudence
Inrecentyears,Colombianjurisprudenceonconstitutionalissuesandsocioeconomic rightshasgainedinternationalprominenceforitsprogressiveoutcomes.TheConstitutionalCourt,inparticular,hasmadeprogressiverulingsontherightsofinternallydisplacedpersons,20 therighttohealth,21 andprisonconditions,22 amongstothers.While
16 CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],SalaSextadeRevisiónnoviembre10,2016,M.P:JPalacio,SentenciaT-622,(p.31-35)(Colom.);CorteSupremadeJusticia[C.S.J.][SupremeCourtofColombia], SalaCivilEspecializadaenRestitucióndeTierrasdelTribunalSuperiordelDistritoJudicialdeBogotáabril 52018,M.P:L.Villabona,Sentencia4360(p.18)(Colom.).
17 CONSTITUCIÓN POLÍTICADE COLOMBIA 1991,art.79.
18 Id. atart.86.
19 Id. atart.88.(Articles86and88,togetherreadtosaythatacommunitymaybringan acciónpopular,butan individualinthecommunitymaystill filea tutela toprotecthisorherfundamentalrights).
20 CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCour t],SalaTerceradeRevisiónenero22,2004,M.P: M.Espinosa,SentenciaT-025(Colom.).
21 CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],SalaSegundadeRevisiónjulio31,2008,M.P: M.Espinosa,SentenciaT-760,GacetadelaCorteConstitucional[G.C.C.](Colom.).
22 CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],SalaTerceradeRevisiónabril28,1998,M.P:E.Muñoz, SentenciaT-153,GacetadelaCorteConstitucional[G.C.C.](Colom.).
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
implementationhasbeenfarfromperfect,thesedecisionshavehadpositiveeffectson publicpolicy,publicparticipation,andinstitutionalcoordination. 23 Thesejudicial decisionsarethebackdropagainstwhichthecasesdescribedinthischapterhave developed.
II.ANOVERVIEWOFRECENTJURISPRUDENCE
TheColombiancourtshaveissuedrecentlandmarkdecisionsadvancingtheconcept ofnature ’ srights. 24 In2015,theConstitutionalCourt issuedagroundbreakingdecisionprotectingtheTayronaParkinColo mbia,hometofourdistinctIndigenous groupsandauniqueecosystemmadeofjun gles,beaches,andmangroveswamps. TheCourtrecognizedthatrivers,mountains,forests,andtheatmospheremustbeprotectednotbecauseoftheirutilitybutbecauseoftheirownindependentrightsto exist. 25 TheCourtsaiditwasimperativetotransformhumanity ’ srelationshipwith therestofthenaturalworldandappliedanecocentricperspective,expresslycriticizingapurelyanthropocentricapproach.26 Ayearlater,theCourtissuedagroundbreakingdecisionrecognizingtheAtratoRiverBasinasasubjectofrights.27 Sincethen,a growingnumberofColombiancourtshavefollowedsuit,recognizingtherightsof ecosystemsinresponsetoviolationsofhumanenvironmentalrights.Asmentionedearlierinthischapter,itshouldbenotedthatunderthecivillawsysteminColombia,judicialdecisionsdonottranslateintofor mallawsorbindingprecedents.AsPaola Villaviencioexplains:
althoughnolegislationonrightsofnaturehadbeenadoptedatthattimeinColombia, thecourtsruledinfavorofsuchnaturalentitiesandthroughtwolandmarkdecisions changedtheirtraditionalstatusandrecogn i[z]edthemasrights-bearingsubjects, therebydemonstratingthatrightsofnature/ecosystemscanberecognizedbybothlegislativeandjudicialchannels.28
23 CésarRodriguez-Garavito, BeyondtheCourtroom:TheImpactofJudicialActivismonSocialandEconomicRightsin LatinAmerica,89TexasL.Rev.1670,1676(2011). See CÉSAR RODRÍGUEZ-GARAVITOAND DIANA RODRÍGUEZ FRANCO, CORTESY CAMBIO SOCIAL:CÓMOLA CORTE CONSTITUCIONAL TRANSFORMÓEL DESPLAZAMIENTO FORZADOEN COLOMBIA (MartaRojased.,1sted.2010).
24 Priortojudicialrecognitionofnature’srightsinColombia,thelandwasrecognizedasavictimofthelongrunningarmedconflictbetweenthegovernmentandparamilitarygroupsintheVictims&LandRestitution Law(Law1448of2011)andgrantedtherighttorestitution.Also,theSpecialJurisdictionforPeace(JEP) haspubliclyrecognizedtheenvironmentasavictimofthearmedconflict.Thisrecognitionappliesacustomarilyanthropocentrictermtoanenvironmentalentityandimpliesanunderstandingoftheenvironmentasa livingsubjectwiththecapacitytobeharmed.
25 CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCour t],SalaSextadeRevisiónseptiembre21,2015,M.P: J.Palacio,SentenciaT-606(Colom.);DAVID R.BOYD,THE RIGHTSOF NATURE:ALEGAL REVOLUTION THAT COULD SAVETHE WORLD 225(2019).
26 Id. at225-226.
27 CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],SalaSextdeRevsiónnoviembre10,2016,M.P.J.Palacio, SentenciaT-622(Colom.).
28 PaolaVillavicencioCalzadilla, CaseNote:AParadigmShiftinCourts’ ViewonNature:TheAtratoRiverandAmazon BasinCasesinColombia,15L.,ENVTL AND DEV.J.1,3(2019).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
ColombiancourtsarenotdrawingonexistingColombianinterpretationsofany nature’srightslawswhenreviewinglegalchallengesonenvironmentalrights.Instead, theyareprescribinganewinterpretationtotheselawsbasedonconstitutionalprinciplesandevolvingsocialunderstandings.Theinternationallegalwaverecognizing natureasalegalsubjectofrightsisoneoftheinfluencesthathasledColombiancourts toapplyanecocentriclenswhenreviewingenvironmentalrightscases.Colombiajoins anemergingjurisprudence “builtonecocentricrights-basedapproachestoenvironmentalprotection” thatchallengestraditionallegalparadigms.29
WithinColombianjurisprudence,judicialdecisionsbytheColombianHighCourts haveestablishedalegalanalyticalframeworkforrecognizingnature ’ srights,with regionalcourtsnowalsostartingtoapplyanecocentricperspectivewhenadjudicating cases.Through2019,judicialdecisionsthathaverecognizednature’srightsinclude:
• TheAtratoRiverBasin(2016,ConstitutionalCourt);
• TheColombianAmazon(2018,SupremeCourt);
• PáramodePisba(2018,AdministrativeCourtofBoyacá);
• ThePlataRiver(2019,ColombianMunicipalCivilCourtofLaPlata);
• ThreeriversinTolimaincludingtheC oello,Combeima,andCocora(2019, AdministrativeTribunalCourtofTolima);
• TheCaucaRiverBasin(2019,SuperiorCourtofMedellín);and
• ThePanceRiverBasin(2019,ThirdCourtofEnforcementofSentencesand SecurityMeasuresofCali).
Thisrecognitionofnature ’ srightsbythecourtshasalsobuiltmomentuminthe departmentsofNariñoandBoyacá,culmi natingintheincorporationofrightsof natureintotheirgovernanceframeworksin2019.30 Withintherightsofnatureframework,judicialdecisionshaverecognizedbeesandanindividualiconicAndeanbear namedElChuchoassubjectsofrights,althoughtheserulingsarestillsubjecttofurtherreview.31
ThecasesconcerningtheAtratoRiverBasin,theColombianAmazon,theCauca River,andthethreeriversinTolimawillbeexaminedclosely.The AtratoRiverBasin caseandthe ColombianAmazon casehavebeenpickedbecauseoftheirsignificancein sparkingsimilarrulingsbyregionalcourts,aswelltheirillustrationofthemesinenvironmentallegislation.The CaucaRiverBasin caseandthecaseofthethreeriversin Tolima,bothhandledbyregionalcourts,d emonstratehowEarthjurisprudencehas
29 Id.
30 NuevoSiglo, BoyacáyNariñoFirmanAcuerdoparaProhibirAsbestoyPlásticosdeunSoloUso ,DINERO (Aug.10, 2019,12:01AM),https://www.dinero.com/pais/articulo/gobernadores-de-boyaca-y-narino- fi rman-pactopor-la-naturaleza-como-sujeto/275442.
31 Forinstance,inNovember2018,theTribunalSuper iorofCartagenarevokedanearlierrulingwhich declaredbeesassubjectofrights. AbejasenColombia,sinProtecciónJúridica,SEMANA SOSTENIBLE (May20,2019), https://sostenibilidad.semana.com/medio-ambiente/articulo/abejas-en-colombia-sin-proteccion-juridica/ 44262.Further,inAugust2019,theConstitutionalCourtofColombiaheldapublichearingonamotion issuedbytheSupremeCourtin2016grantinghabeascorpustothebearChuco.CorteConstitucional, Y OU T UBE (Aug.8,2019),https://www.youtube.com/watc h?v=_X0BHUJWPwo(footagefromthepublic hearing).
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
beenappliedbyregionalcourtstoaddresslong-term,ongoingenvironmentalcon flicts acrossColombia.
III.THEATRATORIVERBASIN
In2016,Colombia’sConstitutionalCourtrecognizedtheAtratoRiverBasin(located withinthemegadiverse 32 northwestChocódepartment)asasubjectofrights. AlthoughjurisprudenceoftheConstitutionalCourthadpreviouslyreferredtonature asa “subjectoflegalrights,” theAtratodecisionwasthe firsttimeadesignatedecosystemwasrecognizedasalegalsubjectofrightsinColombia.33 Theserightsincludethe righttobeprotected,conserved,maintained,andrestored 34
Therulingcameinresponsetoa tutela againsttheColombianstate fi ledbythe Colombia-basedCenterforSocialJusticeStudies(TierraDigna)onbehalfofan allianceofChocóresidentorganizations,includingpeopleofAfricandescentand Indigenousand mestizocampesino communities.35 Theactionwasintendedtoholdthe stateaccountableforv iolatinglocalpeoples ’ constitutionalrightsagainstwelldocumented,ongoingillegalminingactivity.36 Theseconstitutionalrightsincludethe fundamentalrighttolife37 aswellasto “health,water,foodsecurity,healthyenvironment,andthecultureandtheterritoryofactiveethniccommunities.”38 Illegalmining activityintheregionutilizestoxicchemicals,suchasmercury,whichseverelycontaminatesthesurroundingecosystem.Thebasin ’ sunfetteredcontaminationhasbeen linkedtothedeathsofatleast37minors;thepoisoningof64peoplebyingesting
32 Thetermmegadiversereferstoregionshostingahighconcentrationoftheworld’sbiodiversity.UNEnvironmentWorldConservationMonitoringCentre, MegadiverseCountries ,B IODIVERSITY A-Z(Nov.20,2014), https://www.biodiversitya-z.org /content/megadiverse-countries.TheChocóregionisknownasabiogeographicregion.NinetypercentofChocóisconsideredaspecialconservationarea,andtheAtratoRiver Basincontainsoneoftheworld ’shighestwateryields.CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt], SalaSextadeRevisiónnoviembre10,2016,M.P:JPalacio,SentenciaT-622,(p.6)(Colom.).
33 Villavicencio, supra note28,at3n.2,mentionsseveralexamplesofrulings,including “NoC-595of27July 2010onaconstitutionalchallenge filedbyJuanGabrielRojasLópez,ExpedienteD-7977;C-632of24August 2011onaconstitutionalchallenge filedbyLuisEduardoMontealegreLynett,ExpedienteD-8379;and,ProtectionRuling(SentenciadeTutela)T-080of20February2015onanactionoftutela(AccióndeTutela) filedby Fundepúblicoyotrosv.SalaCivilydeFamiliadelTribunalSuperiordelDistritoJudicialdeCartagena,ExpedienteT-4.353.004.”
34 CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],SalaSextadeRevisiónnoviembre10,2016,M.P:JPalacio,SentenciaT-622,(p.158)(Colom.).
35 Eighty-sevenpercentofthepeopleofChocóareofAfricandescent,10percentIndigenous,and3percent mestizofarmers.TierraDigna filedonbehalfofthefollowingorganizations:theHigherCommunityCouncil oftheHighAtratoPeasantPeople’sOrganization(Cocomopoca),theCommunityCouncilMajorofthePeasantAssociationAtrato(Cocomacia),theAssociationofLowAtratoCommunityCouncils(Asocoba),theInterethnicForumSolidarityChoco(FISCH)andothers.CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],Sala SextadeRevisiónnoviembre10,2016,M.P:JPalacio,SentenciaT-622,(p.1)(Colom.).
36 CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],SalaSextadeRevisiónnoviembre10,2016,M.P:JPalacio,SentenciaT-622,(p.7)(Colom.).
37 CONSTITUCIÓN POLÍTICADE COLOMBIA 1991,art.11.
38 CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],SalaSextadeRevisiónnoviembre10,2016,M.P:JPalacio,SentenciaT-622,(p.1)(Colom.).
contaminatedwater;andthelossofcriticalfoodandwaterresources,leadingtodehydration,malnutrition,andotherailments.39
The tutela was first filedonJanuary27,2015,beforetheAdministrativeTribunalof Cundinamarca.Inresponse,severaldefe ndantsrequestedthattheCourtdenythe tutela duetolackofstandingandonproceduralgrounds,arguingthata tutela isan inappropriatemechanismtobringthecase.Variousdefendantsarguedthatthe responsibilitytotakeactionlieswithotherauthorities.40
Duetoitsconstitutionalfunctionsandi tsobligationtodefendhumanrightsin Colombia,theOmbudsman ’ sOf fi ce 41 intervenedtoexpandontheplaintiff ’ slegal claims.Theombudsmanaffi rmedthattheseveresocio-ecologicalimpactsofmining intheregionviolatedthefundamentalrightsoftheplaintiffs ’ populations. 42 The ombudsmanfurtheremphasizedthatethniccommunitieshavespecialconstitutional protections,includingtherighttobeprotectedthrougha tutela action.Finally,the ombudsmandeclaredthatapopularactionwasnotasuf ficientmeanstohandlethe casebecauseapopularactiondealsonlywithcollectiverights,whilea tutela dealswith fundamentalrights.43
OnFeb.11,2015,the firstinstancecourtruledagainsttheplaintiffsbydenyingthe tutela actiononproceduralgrounds.TheAdministrativeTribunalofCundinamarca (TribunalAdministrativodeCundinamarca)heldthat,atitscore,thesuitsoughtprotectionofcollectiverights.Consequently,theCourtrecommendedthattheplaintiffs file apopularactionsuit.Theplaintiffsappealedthedecision.44 OnApril21,2015,thesecondinstancecourtonceagainruledagainsttheplaintiffsbydenyingthe tutela action onproceduralgrounds.TheStateCouncil(ConsejodelEstado)heldthatthesuitsought toprotectcollectiverightsandthattheplaintiffs “ failedtodemonstrateirreparable harmorineffectivenessoftheclassactionsforprotectionoftherightsthattheyconsideredviolated.”45 OnNov.13,2015,theSixthChamberofReviewoftheConstitutional Court(SalaSextadeRevisióndelaCorteConstitucional)orderedinputfromseveraluniversities,NGOs,andinternationalorganizationsonseveralmattersrelatedtothecase. TheCourtalsoorderedandcarriedoutajudicialinspectioninQuibdóandsomesectorsoftheAtratoRiverBasininearly2016.46
39 Id. at9.
40 Id. at10-12.
41 TheOmbudsman’sOfficeofColombia,establishedbytheConstitution,(Spanish:DefensoríadelPueblo)is thenationalgovernmentagencychargedwithoverseeingtheprotectionofcivilandhumanrights.The ombudsmanisappointedbythePresident,andelectedbytheChamberofRepresentativesofColombia,to headthisagency.
42 DEFENSORÍADEL PUEBLO (OMBUDSMAN),RESOLUCIÓN NO.64:CRISIS HUMANITARIAENEL DEPARTAMENTODEL CHOCÓ 2014(2014).
43 CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],SalaSextadeRevisiónnoviembre10,2016,M.P:JPalacio,SentenciaT-622,(p.13)(Colom.).
44 Theappealwasmadeonthefollowinggrounds: “(i)ignorance[bythe firstinstancecourt]oftheviolation andthreattothefundamentalrightsofthecommunitiesintheclassaction;(ii)irregularitiesinthejudicial processoftheaccióndetutela;and(iii)theexecutionofotherjudicialactionsthathavenotbeeneffective.” Id. at14.
45 Id.
46 Id. at15.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw 500
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
Initsdecisionrecognizingtherightsofadesignatedecosystem,theCourtfound thattheseriouseffectsofillegalminingexp loitationviolatedmultiplefundamental rightsintheAtratoRiverBasin.Italsode claredthathumanpopulations,whichare interdependentwithrespecttothenaturalworld,must “assumetheconsequencesof theiractionsandomissionswithnature.”47 Thisdecisionmarksthe fi rstinstanceofa Colombiancourtdesignatinganecosystemasalegalsubject,with(inessence)the righttolife. 48 TheCourtpointedoutthatkeyprinciplesconsideredduringthe decision-makingprocessincludedtheroleof internationalEarthjurisprudence,the principleofinterdependence,bioculturalrightsofspeciallyprotectedethnicgroups, andtheprincipleof intercommunis (betweenthecommonswhich,incontrastto inter partes ,meanstherulingappliestoeveryoneinsimilarcircumstances).Asyouread theopinion,noticehoweachprincipleguidestheCourt’sreasoning.
ConstitutionalCourtofColombia(2016)49 JudgmentT-622
Bogotá,D.C.,Nov.2nd,2015
OPINIONOFTHECOURT
9.ANALYSISOFTHECONCRETECASE.
Introduction.
InthecasesubmittedtotheCourt,theplaintiffs filedawritof accióndetutela tostoptheintensiveandlarge-scaleuseofvariousmethodsofillegalmining andlogging,includingheavymachinery dredgesandbackhoes andhighly toxicsubstances likemercury intheAtratoRiver(Chocó),itsbasins, swamps,wetlandsandtributaries.Which,inthiscourt’ sopinion,havebeen intensifyingforseveralyearsandwhicharehavingharmfulandirreversible consequencesontheenvironment,affectingwithitthefundamentalrights ofethniccommunitiesandthenaturalbalanceoftheterritoriestheyinhabit.
47 Id. at99.
48 Itshouldbenotedthatlegalrecognitioncameintheformofacourtorderdefinedinthesentence.
49 ThisopinionwastranslatedbytheDignityRightsProjectatDelawareLawSchoolintheUnitedStates,availableat:http:// fi les.harmonywithnatureun.org/ uploads/upload838.pdf.Citationsandcross-referencesto othersectionsnotreproducedherehavebeenremovedfromtheoriginal.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Tothis,theyaddthatthemechanizedminingexploitation whichhas beendevelopingonalargescaleillegallysincetheendoftheninetiesbydifferentactors mainlyaffectstheupperandmiddlebasinoftheAtratoRiver andevenitsmouthinthegulfofUrabá,aswellasitsmaintributaries concretely,throughtheuseofheavymachinerysuchassuctiondredgers ::: hydraulicelevatorsandbackhoes,whichinturndestroytheriverbedandperformindiscriminatedumpingofmercuryandothersubstancesandsupplies required(suchascyanide,gasolinea ndfats,etc.)forthedevelopmentof theseactivitiesintheAtratoanditstributaries,inadditiontothedispersion ofvaporsthatmercurytreatmentthrowsintheminingentanglements.
Inthissense,theplaintiffsconsiderthatstate-runentities(bothatthe locallevelandatthenationallevel)areresponsiblefortheviolationoftheir fundamentalrightstolife,humandigni ty,health,water,[foodsecurity],a healthyenvironment,thecultureandtheterritoryduetoitsomissiontonot takeeffectiveactionstostopthedevelopmentofsuchillegalminingactivities, whichhavegeneratedthecon fi gurationofaserioushumanitarianandenvironmentalcrisisintheregion.
Resolutionofthelegalproblemraised.
9.3.Inapreliminarymanner,theCourtconsidersthatinordertoresolve thelegalproblem,itmust:(i)outlines omereferencereportsthatdescribe thegravesituationofillegalminingintheDepartmentofChocó; (ii)presenttheeffectsobservedint hejudicialinspectioncarriedoutin ChocóinJanuary2016;(iii)raiseaseriesofconclusionsonthelegalmatters submittedforitsconsideration,and fi nally,(iv)makesomeconsiderations aboutpublicpolicyregardingillegalmining.
9.4.Bywayofillustration,theChambermustbeginbypointingoutthat theserioushumanitarian,socio-cul turalandenvironmentalsituationin whichtheDepartmentofChocóisimmersed,ishistoric.Theoriginsofthe humanitariancrisisintheregionareold,deepandstructural.Someofthefactorsthathavebeenidentifiedintheliteraturethathasstudiedthesubjectin detailsuggestthatpovertyinChocóistheresultof:(i)acoloniallegacyof weakornon-existentpolitical-adm inistrativeinstitutions;(ii)dif fi cult geographicandclimaticconditionsthatincreasethecostsofproductionand “isolate” thedistrictfromtherestofthecountryand,atthesametime,favor thesettlementofillegalarmedgroups;(iii)anextractiveeconomicstructure focusedexclusivelyontheexploitationofnaturalresources,inparticular, theminingofgold,silverandplatinum;and(iv)theisolationofthedistrict fromnationaleconomicactivity.
9.5.Tothishistoricalsituationofpov erty,marginalization,institutional isolationandtheaccumulationofalargenumberofunsatis fi edbasic needs inaregionofthecountrythathasbeenhistoricallyaffectedbyviolence,displacementandinternalarmedcon flict hasbeenaddedinthelast
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
decadestheincursionofnewillegalarmedgroupsandtheexponential increaseofillegalmining,which,inthewordsoftheOmbudsman ’ sOf fi ce, “hasgeneratedanunprecedentedhumanitariancrisisinChocóthatdemands thejointactionoftheentireState,itsinstitutionalismandterritorialentitiesat alllevelstogiveattentionand fi nalsolutiontotheseriouscrisisthatthis Departmentisexperiencing.”
9.11.Theworseningoftheproblemsdescribed,duetotheover fl owof illegalmininginrecentyears,hasmeantthatthevigilanceandcontrolbodies, withoutexception,haverepeatedlycalledthenationalgovernment’sattention tothecriticalsituationthataffectstheDepartmentofChocó,especiallywith respecttominingthattakesplaceillegally.
Stateentitieshavehadthepossibilityofknowingthedimensionofthe effectsonfundamentalrightsthatoccursinthisregionofthecountrywhere theplaintiffslive,byvirtueofthephenomenonofillegalmining ::: .
9.14.Intermsofhealtheffects,thePlaintiffsstatedthatasaconsequence oftheuseofmercuryinillegalminingactivities, “themostseriousdamageto communities intermsofhealthandenvironm entaldegradationofrivers andforests occurintheareassurroundingtheAtratoRiveranditstributaries,intheterritoriesofRíoQuito,Soledad,VillaConto,SanIsidroand Paimadó,amongothers;damagesthattheyestimateoccurredinabout84% ofthecollectiveterritoryofthecommu nities.Theyexplainthat,according tostudiesfromthePaci ficEnvironmentalResearchInstitute IIAP ,there havebeenreportsofspontaneousabortions,vaginal,skinandfungaldiseases causedbythepresenceofmercury,methylmercuryandcyanideintheriver waters.”
Inthesameway,theyindicatedthat “asaconsequenceofthepresenceof mercuryandothertoxicchemicalsubstancesinthewatersoftheAtratoRiver thereisaproliferationofnewvaginalandcutaneousdiseases.Forthesecommunities,theriveristhecenteroftheirsocialandculturallife:itisthere wheretheyidentifythemselvesasapeople,wheretheywashtheirclothes, bath,play,swim, fishandshareculturalandrecreationalactivities.”
Theyindicatedthat “thelevelofmercuryfoundbytheIIAPinthepopulationsisalarmingandreferstoastudythatwascarriedouton160people inthebasinoftheAtratoRiveranditstr ibutaries(QuitoRiver).According towhich,thelevelofmercuryfoundinthebloodis60[parts]permillion, whentheminimumworldaverage,whatisconsideredacceptable,is0.5 [parts]permillion,andinColombiaitis1.0perperson.”
9.15.Intermsofeffectsontheenvironment(rivers,swampsandforests), representativesoftheplaintiffethni ccommunitiesarguedthattheharmful effectsofmercuryusedinillegalminingactivities,whichisspecifiedasfollows: “(i)bydirectcontactwiththeskin;(ii)bycontaminationoftheatmosphere whenthesubstanceisburned(bygeneratingsteamandthenacidrainprecipitation);(iii)contaminationofwatersourceswhenmercuryispouredinto
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
riversaccumulatesinwater,plantsand fish,whicharethebasisofthewayof lifeandfoodpracticesofethniccommunities.ItisaddedthattheethniccommunitiesthatinhabitthebanksoftheAtratoRiver(high,mediumandlow zones)sufferdirectlyfromtheeffectsofmercuryandcyanidepollution,as alltheirhygienic,nutritional,socialandculturalactivitiesarecarriedoutin theriver,intheabsenceofbasicinfrastructureofaqueductandbasic sanitation.”
Inthisregard,itisaddedthat “thecontaminationbychemicalsubstances alsoaffectstheforestsandaddedtothistheforestryexploitationthathasbeen carriedoutforyearsinthezone inparticularintheregionoftheBajo Atrato-withouteffectivestatecontrol.”
Tothisitisalsoaddedthat, “ thisenvironmentaldegradationnotonly respondstoaproblemofcollectiverightsbutalsotoasystematicviolationoffundamentalrightssuchasadignifiedlife,health,freedomofmovement,territory, andautonomy.Itwarnsofaprofoundtransformationofthetraditionalwaysof lifeofthecommunities(agriculture, fishing,hunting)duetomining.”
9.17.Aboutthedamagestotherights,totheculture,andtheterritory, oneofthecommunityleadersofPaimadó(Chocó)af firmed,duringthevisit tothatregionthat, “itisverysadtowalktodayalongtheQuitoriver which isdryingup fromAtratotoPaimadóorManacruzbecauseillegalmining hasnotonlychangedthecourseoftheriverbuthasalsoendedupwithtraditionalformsofsubsistencebasedonagricultureandthecropsofyam,yucca andplantain.Theancestraltreessuchasborojó,chontaduro,the ‘breadtree’ , the ‘ pato ’ andthebananatreearenolongeravailableandcannotbetransportedduetothewayinwhichmininghasdestroyedtheriver.”
Inacomplementarysense,theOmbudsman ’ sOf fi ceindicatedthatthe illegalminingactivityintheAtratoRiverBasinanditstributarieshascaused thedecreaseofagriculturalwork,asatraditionalformofsubsistence, “tothe pointthatallthefoodconsumedistakenfrompopulatedcenterslikeQuibdó andBeté.” TheOfficeaddedthatthissituationhasalsoaffectedthesocialand ecologicalfunctionofthecollectiveterritory, “ becauseitsuseforthetraditionalpracticeofagriculturewassuspended.” Thisishowthefoodsthatwere ancestrallycultivatedforconsumpti onsuchaschontaduro,borojó,cacao, banana,amongothers,theirbasicfoods,arenolongercultivatedintheareas mostimpactedbyillegalmining,alsobecausetheseactivitiesgenerateinfertilityonearth.
9.22.Likewise,thedestructionoftheenvironmentandthethreattobiodiversityintheregionsubjecttothefa ctsofthisactionwascorroboratednot onlybytheChamberbutalsobyalltheaccompanyingentities,asreferredto insections9.14to9.17.FortheCourt,thereisnodoubtthatillegalmining isseriouslyaffectingthefundamentalrightstolife,healthandahealthyenvironmentoftheethniccommunitiesthatinhabittheAtratoRiverBasinand itstributaries.Andthatthisviolatio nhasimpactsdirectandindirectonthe Chocoanoethniccommunities. :::
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
9.23. theChambershouldreiteratethat theprotectionofrivers, forests,foodsourcesandbiodiversity(healthyenvironment)hasadirectand interdependentrelationshipwiththeguaranteeoftherightstolifeandhealth (aswellascultureandterritory),wi thinwhathasbeencalledbiocultural rights.Precisely,thecentralelementsofthisapproachestablishanintrinsic linkbetweennatureandculture,andth ediversityofthehumanspeciesas partofnatureandmanifestationofmultipleformsoflife.Fromthisperspective,theconservationofbiodiversitynecessarilyleadstothepreservationand protectionofthewaysoflifeandculturesthatinteractwithit.
Consequently,publicpoliciesontheconservationofbiodiversitymust adaptandfocusonthepreservationoflife,itsvariousmanifestations,but mainlyinthepreservationoftheconditionsforthatbiodiversitytocontinue deployingitsevolutionarypotentialinastableandinde finitemanner,asthe Courthasindicatedinabundantjurisprudence.Similarly,theobligationsof theStatetoprotectandconservethelif estylesofIndigenouspeoples,black andfarmer,meanguaranteeingtheirc onditionsofbeing,perceivingand apprehendingtheworld.
9.25.Inconsiderationoftheaforementioned,fortheCourtitisnecessary toconcludethattheillegalminingactivity,havingthepotentialtocauseharm tohealthandtotheenvironment,ashasbeenseeninthecaseoftheethnic communitiesthatinhabitthebasinoftheAtratoRiver,itissubjecttothe applicationoftheprecautionar yprinciple.Thisapplieswhen although thereisaprincipleoftechnicalcertainty thereisscienti fi cuncertainty regardingtheharmfuleffectsofameasureoractivity.Inthatcase,thesolutionthatavoidsthedamagemustbepreferredandnottheonethatcanallow it.Thisprincipleisnotonlydesignedtoprotecttherighttotheenvironment butalsotherighttohealthwhenthereisathreatofviolation. :::
[T]heprecautionaryprincipleimpliesinverysimpleterms,thatincaseof scienti ficdoubt,itdoesnotabstainand,onthecontrary,protectstherightto ahealthyenvironmentandhealthinconnectionwithlife.
Speci fically,theapplicationoftheprecautionaryprincipleinthepresent casewillhaveasobjectives,(i)toprohibittheuseoftoxicsubstancessuchas mercury 50 inminingactivities,whetherlegalorillegal;and(ii)declarethat theAtratoRiverissubjecttorightstha timplyitsprotection,conservation, maintenanceand,inthespecificcase,restoration. :::
9.26.Bywayofconclusionandwithrespecttothisparticularpoint,the Court findsthattheDefendantentitieshaveviolatedtherightstolife,health andahealthyenvironmentofthePla intiffcommunitiesbyallowingthe
50 In2018,theColombiangovernmentbannedtheuseofmercuryfromallgoldminingactivities.Afullbanof theuseofmercuryistotakeeffectby2023.AdriaanAlsema, ColombiaBansMercuryinGoldMining,COLOMBIA R EPORTS (July16,2018),https://colombiareports.com/colombia-imposes-ban-on-mercury-in-gold-mining/. Colombiahassomeofthehighestratesofmercurycontaminationintheworld;however,thisissueisnotconsideredtobemonitoredadequately. See OECD,ENVIRONMENTAL PERFORMANCE REVIEWS -COLOMBIA,HIGHLIGHTS 2014(2014).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
indiscriminatedumpingofmercuryandothertoxicchemicalsubstancesnecessaryfortherealizationofillegalmi ningactivitiesintheAtratoRiver,its tributariesandsurroundingterritoriesbynottakingconcreteandarticulated measurestoavoidit,havingfullknowle dgeofthesituation,thatis,byomissionintheful fi llmentofitslegalandconstitutionalduties.Asaresult,the responsibleentitieswillbeorderedtoadoptaseriesofemergencymeasures todealwiththisseriousviolationof thefundamentalrightstolife,health andahealthyenvironment,whichwillbeindicatedintherelativesectionto theorders.
b.AboutthepollutionoftheAtratoRiver,itstributaries,forestsandfood sourcesproducedbythedevelopmentofillegalminingactivitiesintheregion.
9.27.Violationoftherighttowaterasawatersource.Atthispoint,itis cleartotheCourtthat,asprovenbytheevidenceinthecase fi leandinthe judicialinspection whichwereoutlinedinsections9.14to9.17 theillegal miningthattakesplaceintheAtratoRiverBasinanditstributarieschallenges anyideaofrationaluseofwaterandforestresources,andconstitutesanopen violationofthefundamentalrightto water(asaconsequenceofitsserious contamination)thatthreatensnotonlyethniccommunities,theDepartment ofChocóortheenvironment,butalsooneofthemostimportantwaterand biodiversitysourcesintheworld,andthus,presentandfuturegenerations.
Additionally,itcannotbeoverlookedthattherighttowaterisasinequa nonrequirementfortheexerciseofotherrights,while “waterisnecessaryto producefood(righttofood);toensureenvironmentalhygiene(rightto health);toprocurelife(righttowork)andtoenjoycertainculturalpractices (righttoparticipateinculturallife).” Therefore,pollution especiallywith mercuryandcyanide andcarryingoutillegalminingactivitiesintheAtrato RiverBasinanditstributariesnotonly violatestherighttowaterandother componentsoftherighttoahealthyenvironment(ashasalreadybeen stated),butalsoviolatestheessentials tandardsofavailability,accessibility andwaterqualityestablishedinGeneralCommentNo.15,becausethistype ofminingisharmful,theproductionoffood(trees,cropsand fi sh),the healthconditions,thetraditionalways oflifeandtheculturalpracticesof thePlaintiffethniccommunities.
Precisely,thebiggestchallengeofc ontemporaryconstitutionalismon environmentalmatters,istoachievethesafeguardandeffectiveprotection ofnature,associatedcultures,waysoflife,andbiodiversity,notjustforthesimplematerial,geneticorproductiveutilitythatthesecanrepresenttohumans, butbecausebeingalivingentitycomposedofothermultipleformsoflifeand culturalrepresentations,aresubjectsofindividualrights,whichmakesthema newimperativeofintegralprotectionandrespectonthepartofStatesand societies.Inshort,onlyfromanattitudeofdeeprespectandhumilitywith nature,itsmembersanditsculture,isitpossibletoenterintorelationships withtheminfairandequitableterms,leavingasideanyconceptthatislimited tothesimplyutilitarian,economic,orefficient.
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
Ineffect,natureandtheenvironme ntareatransversalelementofthe Colombianconstitutionalorder.Itsim portancelies,ofcourse,inattention tothehumanbeingsthatinhabititandtheneedtohaveahealthyenvironmenttoliveadigni fiedlifeandinwellbeingconditions,butalsoinrelation totheotherlivingorganismswithwhomtheplanetisshared,understoodas stocksworthyofprotectioninthemselves.Itisaboutbeingawareoftheinterdependencethatconnectsustoalllivingbeingsonearth;thatis,recognizing ourselvesasintegralpartsofthegloba lecosystem-biosphere,ratherthan fromnormativecategoriesofdominatio n,simpleexploitationorutility.A positionthattakesonspecialrelevanceinColombianconstitutionalism,takingintoaccounttheprincipleofculturalandethnicpluralismthatsupports it,aswellastheknowledge,uses,andancestralcustomsbequeathedbyIndigenousandtribalpeoples.
Precisely,inrelationtothenaturalandculturalwealthofthenation,Article8ofthePoliticalCharterestabli shesasafundamentalobligationofthe Stateandofsocietytowatchoverthecareofournaturalandculturalriches. Additionally,inthechapteroncollectiverights(Articles79and80)andspecificobligations(Article95-8),thegeneralparametersthatguidetherelationshipbetweenthehumanbeingandhislivingenvironmentareestablished: natural,environmentalandbiodiverse.Inthissense,asaconsequenceofthe attributionsconsecratedattheheadoftheState,societyandindividualsinthe above-mentionedarticles,theobligationtoprotecttheenvironmentisestablishedinordertopreventandcontrolt heenvironmentald eteriorationfactors,procuringitsconservation,restorationandsustainabledevelopment.
9.28.Inthiscontext,itisnecessaryfortheChambertoadvanceinthe interpretationoftheapplicablelawandintheformsofprotectionoffundamentalrightsandtheirsubjects,duetothegreatdegreeofdegradationand threatinwhichitfoundtheAtratoRiver Basin.Fortunately,attheinternationallevelanewlegalapproachcalledbioculturalrightsisbeingdeveloped, whosecentralpremiseistherelationshipofprofoundunityandinterdependencebetweennatureandhumanspecies,andthathasasaconsequencea newsocio-legalunderstandinginwhichnatureshouldbetakenseriouslyand withfullrights.Thatis,asasubjectofrights.
9.29.Inthisorderofideas,theissuethatisconsideredinthisorderbythe Court ontheseriouseffectsproducedbytheintensivedevelopmentofactivitiesofillegalminingexploitationwithdamagetomultiplefundamentalrights intheAtratoRiverBasin(Chocó) ,hasclearlyevidencedthathumanpopulationsarethosethatareinterdependentofthenaturalworld andnotthe otherwayaround andthattheymustassumetheconsequencesoftheir actionsandomissionswithnature.Itis aboutunderstandingthisnewsociopoliticalrealitywiththeaimofachievingarespectfultransformationwith thenaturalworld,asithashappenedbeforewithcivilandpoliticalrights(first generation);theeconomic,socialandcultural(secondgeneration),andenvironmentalrights(thirdgeneration).Nowisthetimetobegintakingthe first
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
stepstoeffectivelyprotecttheplanetanditsresourcesbeforeitistoolate,or thedamageisirreversible,notonlyforfuturegenerationsbutforthehuman species.
9.30.Inthisway,respectfornaturemuststartfromtherefl ectiononthe meaningofexistence,theevolutionaryprocess,theuniverseandthecosmos. Thatis,asystemofthoughtbasedonaconceptionofthehumanbeingas anintegralpart,andnotasasimple dominator,wouldallowaprocessof self-regulationofthehumanspeciesandtheirimpactontheenvironment, recognizingtheirrolewithinthecircleoflifeandevolutionfromanecocentricperspective.Itisfromthisconsideration,forexample,thatrespectforanimalrightshasbeencemented.Inthisway,itisamatterofestablishingalegal instrumentthatoffersgreaterjusticetonatureanditsrelationswithhuman beings,basedonthecollectiverecognitionofourspecies,assuggestedbybioculturalrights.
Inthissamesense,bioculturaldiversityasanapproach,based,ashasbeen seen,inanecocentricperspective,impliesthatpolicies,normsandinterpretationsaboutbiodiversityconservationrecognizethelinkandinterrelationthat existsbetweencultureandnature.Itextendstheparticipationofethniccommunitiesinthede fi nitionofpublicpoliciesandregulatoryframeworks,and guaranteestheconditionsconducivetothegeneration,conservationand renewaloftheirknowledgesystems,withintheframeworkofaSRL[ColombianSocialRuleofLaw].
Theimportanceofthebiologicalandculturaldiversityofthenationfor thenextgenerationsandthesurvivalofournaturalandculturalwealthposes totheColombianStatetheneedtoadoptcomprehensivepublicpolicieson conservation,preservationandcompensationthatconsidertheinterdependencebetweenbiologicalandculturaldiversity.Inthisway,bioculturaldiversityrepresentsthemostintegralandcomprehensiveapproachtoethnicand culturaldiversityinthefaceofeffectiveprotection.
9.31.Inotherwords,justicefornaturemustbeappliedbeyondthe humanscenarioandmustallownaturetobesubjecttorights.Underthis understanding,theChamberconsidersitnecessarytotakeastepforwardin thejurisprudencetowardstheconstitutionalprotectionofoneofourmost importantsourcesofbiodiversity:theAtratoRiver.Thisinterpretation fi nds fulljustificationinthebestinterestsoftheenvironmentthathasbeenwidely developedbyconstitutionaljurisprudenceandthatismadeupofnumerous constitutionalclausesthatconstitutewhathasbeencalledthe “ Ecological Constitution ” or “GreenConstitution ”.Thissetofprovisionsmakesitpossible toaf firmthetranscendenceofthehealthyenvironmentandtheinterdependentlinkwithhumanbeingsandtheState.
Fromtheabove,aseriesofobligationsofprotectionandguaranteeofthe environmentarederivedfromtheState,whois fi rstinresponsibilityforits protection,maintenance andconservation,whichmustmaterializethrough responsibleenvironmentalpublicpolicies(sustainablegovernance),issuance
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
ofCONPESdocuments,legislationandNationalDevelopmentPlans,among others;withoutprejudicetothedutyofprotectionandcarethatalsoassists civilsocietyandthecommunitiesthemselvestotakecareofnaturalresources andbiodiversity.Inthissense,theCh amberconsidersitpertinenttocall attentiontotheethniccommunitiesthatinhabittheAtratoRiverBasinsothat theyprotect,withintheexerciseoftheircustoms,usesandtraditions,theenvironmentofwhichtheyareits firstguardiansandresponsibleforit.
9.32.Tothatextent,consideringthescopeofprotectionofinternational treatiessignedbyColombiainthe fieldofenvironmentalprotection,the EcologicalConstitution andbioculturalrights,whichpreachthejointandinterdependentprotectionbehumanwithnatureanditsresources,isthatthe CourtwilldeclarethattheAtratoRiverissubjecttorightsthatimplyitsprotection,conservation,maintenanceand,inthespeci ficcase,restoration.Forthe effectiveful fillmentofthisdeclaration,theCourtwillarrangefortheColombianStatetoexerciselegalguardianshi pandrepresentationoftherightsof theriverinconjunctionwiththeethniccommunitiesthatinhabittheAtrato RiverBasininChocó;inthisway,theAtratoRiveranditsbasin henceforth willberepresentedbyamemberoftheplaintiffcommunities andadelegateoftheColombianState.Additionally,andwiththepurposeof ensuringtheprotection,recoveryanddueconservationoftheriver,bothpartiesmustdesignandsetupacommissionofAtratoRiverguardswhoseintegrationandmemberswillbedevelopedinthesectionoforderstoprofferin thisruling.
Asacomplementtotheabove,itisnecessarytorememberthatthecentralpremiseonwhichtheconceptionofbioculturalityandbioculturalrights isbased,istherelationofprofoundunitybetweennatureandhumanspecies. Thisrelationshipisexpressedinothe rcomplementaryel ementssuchas: (i)themultiplewaysoflifeexpresseda sculturaldiversityareinextricably linkedtothediversityofecosystemsandterritories;(ii)therichnessexpressed inthediversityofcultures,practices,beliefsandlanguagesistheproductof theco-evolutionaryinterrelationofhu mancommunitieswiththeirenvironmentsandconstitutesanadaptiveresponsetoenvironmentalchanges; (iii)therelationshipsofdifferentan cestralcultureswithplants,animals, microorganismsandtheenvironmentac tivelycontributetobiodiversity; (iv)thespiritualandculturalmeaningsofIndigenouspeoplesandlocalcommunitiesaboutnatureareanintegralpartofbioculturaldiversity;and(v)the preservationofculturaldiversityleadstotheconservationofbiologicaldiversity,sothatthedesignofpolicy,legislationandjurisprudenceshouldbe focusedontheconservationofbiocul turality[316].Theseelements,from nowon,shouldbeconsideredasparametersfortheprotectionoftherights oftheenvironmentandnature,fromabioculturalperspective.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
10.2.Next,theorderstoprofferinthepresentsentenceareoutlined:
1.TheAtratoRiver,itsbasinandtributarieswillberecognizedasanentity subjecttorightsofprotection,conservation,maintenanceandrestorationby theStateandethniccommunities,asindicatedinthemotivatingpartofthis provisionintheSections9.27to9.32.
2.TheMinistryoftheEnvironment,theMinistryofFinance,theMinistry ofDefense,CodechocoandCorpourabá,theGovernmentsofChocóand Antioquia,andthedefendantm unicipalitieswillbeordered ::: andinconjunctionwiththePlaintiffs,withinayearafterthenotificationofthesentence isdesignedandputinplaceaplanto decontaminatethewatersourcesof Chocó,beginningwiththebasinoftheAtratoRiveranditstributaries. :::
3.Likewise,theMinistryofDefense,theNationalPolice-UnitagainstIllegalMining,theNationalArmyofColombia,theGeneralProsecutor’ sOf fice oftheNation,thegovernorsofChocóandAntioquiaandthedefendant municipalitieswillbeordered,inconjunctionwiththePlaintiffethniccommunitiesandwiththesupportoftheMinistryofForeignAffairs,todesign andimplement,withinsix(6)monthsafternotificationofthisruling,ajoint actionplantoneutralizeanderadicatedefinitelyillegalminingactivitiesthat arecarriedoutnotonlyintheAtratoRiveranditstributaries,butalsointhe DepartmentofChocó.Inthisregard,theCourtreiteratesthatitistheobligationoftheColombianStatetoprosecuteanderadicatedefinitivelyanyillegal miningactivitythattakesplaceinthecountry.
Theaforementionedactionsmustincludetheseizureandneutralization ofdredges,andingeneralofthemachineryusedinthesetasks,therestriction andprohibitionofthetransitofinputssuchasfuelandassociatedchemical substances(mercury,cyanide)andthejudicializationofresponsiblepersons andorganizations.Also,thisprocesswillbeaccompaniedbytheMinistryof ForeignAffairsinwhathastodowiththesituationofforeignerswhoengage inillegalminingactivities.
4.Inadditiontotheforegoing,theMinistryofAgriculture,theMinistryof theInterior,theMinistryofFinance ,theDepartmentofNationalPlanning, theDepartmentforSocialProsperity,theGovernorsofChocóandAntioquia andthemunicipalitieswillbeordered[340]thatinaconcertedmannerwith theplaintiffethniccommunities, designandimplementwithinthesix (6)monthsfollowingthenoti ficationofthisrulinganintegralplanofaction [341]thatallowstherecoveryoftradit ionalformsofsubsistenceandfood. Thisplanofactionwillbeintheframeworkoftheconceptofethnodevelopmentthatensuresminimumfoodsafetyinthearea,whichhasceased toberealizedbythecontaminationofthewatersoftheAtratoRiverandby theintensivedevelopmentofillegalminingactivity.
Thisplanshouldalsobe aimedatrestoringtherightsoftheethniccommunities thatinhabittheAtratoRiverBasin,especiallyinrelationtotherecoveryoftheir
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
culture,participation,territory,identity,wayoflifeandproductiveactivities, including fishing,hunting,agriculture,fruitharvestingandartisanalmining. Inthissense,themeasurestakenmustbefocusedonguaranteeing:(i)thefood sovereigntyofthecommunitiesand(ii)preventingtheirinvoluntarydisplacementfromtheareaduetoillegalminingactivitiesandenvironmentaldamage. Thesemeasuresshouldincludeclearandpreciseindicatorsthatallowan effectiveevaluationandmonitoringofthemeasuresadopted. Itissoordered.
Thebreadthanddepthoflegalanalysisinthe AtratoRiverBasin casewasunprecedentedwhenitwasdecidedin2016.Sincethen,inColombiaandelsewhere,ecocentricconsiderationsarebecomingmorecommon.Thecasealsocastacriticalnew lightonhumanrightstosustainableecosystemsandtheculturalrightsofIndigenous communities.
Althoughbioculturalrig htsarenotexplicitlyde fi nedwithinColombianlegislation,theCourtfoundthatthereareculturalrightsbelongingtospecialprotectedethnicgroups.Initsinterpretationofthecase,theCourtrecognizedtheinterdependence betweenthefundamentalrighttolifeandahealthyenvironmentinthelocalcontext oftheChocócommunityofplaintiffs(prima rilyconsistingofspeciallyprotected groups). 51 TheCourtnotedtheculture ’ sdistinctrelationshipwiththeAtratoRiver Basin,whichprovidesthemwithnearlyalloftheirvitalneeds,includingdrinking water,food,abathingsite,recreation,andsoon.TheChocócommunities’ reliance uponthewell-beingoftheAtratoledtheCourttomakeanadditionallink namely, theinterdependencebetweenthisspecia llyprotectedethnicgroupandthelocal ecosystem.TheCourtrecognizedthattheAtratofunctionsasanextensionofthelocal communityand,therefore,sawthetwoasin trinsicallylinked.Thisunderstanding re flectsabiocentricinterpretationofexistingculturalrightsintheConstitution.This isa firstsignalbytheConstitutionalCourtofapotentialecocentricshiftinunderstandingtherightsofspecialprotectedgroups.
IV.THEAMAZON
In2018,theSupremeCourtofColombiaappliedtheecocentricreasoningthathad beenadoptedbytheConstitutionalCourtinthe AtratoRiverBasin case.RulingonaconstitutionalchallengeagainstdeforestationintheAmazonrainforest,theCourtissueda landmarkdecisionthatrecognizedtheColombianAmazonasasubjectofrights.52
51 CorteConstitucional[C.C.][ConstitutionalCourt],SalaSextadeRevisiónnoviembre10,2016,M.P:JPalacio,SentenciaT-622,(p.14)(Colom.)(fromnotesprecedingtranslatedsentence).
52 CorteSupremadeJusticia[C.S.J.][SupremeCourtofColombia],SalaCivilEspecializadaenRestituciónde TierrasdelTribunalSuperiordelDistritoJudicialdeBogotáabril52018,M.P:L.Villabona,Sentencia4360 (p.18)(Colom.). “ColombianAmazon,” laAmazoniacolombiana,referstotheAmazonregionasawhole.
Thecasewas filedwiththesupportoftheCenterfortheStudyofLaw,Justice,and Society(Dejusticia)onbehalfof25plainti ffs,includingchildrenandyoungpeople fromtheregionsinthecountrymostvulnerabletoclimatechange.Througha tutela action,theplaintiffsclaimedthatdeforestationintheAmazonviolatedtheirconstitutionalrighttoahealthyenvironmentandthusthreatenedtheirfundamentalrights tolife,health,food,andwater,aswellastherightsoffuturegenerations.53 ThedefendantsincludedthePresidentofColombia,theMinistryofEnvironment,theMinistryof Agriculture,theNationalParks,theregionalautonomouscorporations(theentitiesin chargeofenvironmentalgovernancebyregion),andlocalmayorsandgovernments.
Atthetimeof fi ling,deforestationintheAmazonhadincreasedby44percent between2016and2017,despiteColombia’snationalandinternationalcommitments totackledeforestation.54 TheColombiangovernmenthadcommittedtoa20percent reductioninitsemissionsby2030undertheUnitedNationsFrameworkonClimate Change,whichmeantsigni fi cantlycurbingdeforestation.55 Furthermore,thegovernmenthadissuedajointstatementwithNorway,theUnitedKingdom,andGermany in2010committingtoreducedeforestationtonetzeroby2020.
Theargumentsoftheplaintiffsweretwo-fold.First,deforestationintheAmazon resultsinsevereconsequencestolocalandnationalecosystems.Forinstance,asignificantsourceofdrinkingwaterinColombia ’ scentralregioncomesfromaspecial ecosystemknownas páramos,whichultimatelydependsontheAmazontoregulateits watercycle.Second,deforestationinColombiaamountstoapproximatelytwo-thirds ofallgreenhousegasemissionsinColombia,withmostdeforestationconcentratedin theAmazonforest.Thus,deforestationhassignificantimplicationsforclimatechange andtheresultingimpacts.
OnFebruary12,2018,the firstinstancecourtruledagainsttheplaintiffsbydenyingthe tutela actiononproceduralgrounds.TheHighCourtoftheJudicialDistrict ofBogotá( TribunalSuperiordelDistritoJudicialdeBogotá SalaCivil )heldthatthe appropriatevehiclefortheplaintiffs ’ claimswasnota tutela action,butratherapopularaction.Theplaintiffsappealedthedecision,arguingthateveniftherewerecollectiveimpactsstemmingfromdeforestation intheAmazon,theirfundamentalrights werethreatenedandthusa tutela actionwastheappropriatemechanismfortheir claims.OnApril5,2019,theSupremeCourtreversedthedecisionbytheCourtof first instanceandissuedarulinginfavoroftheplaintiffs.
TheCourtappliedtheecocentricapproachtheConstitutionalCourthadapplied totheAtratoCase.56 Initsreasoning,thecourtmovedawayfromananthropocentric andutilitarianperspectivebydescribingnatureasitsownautonomousbeing.The Courtpointedoutthekeyprinciplesthatitconsiderswhenissuingadecision,includingtheprecautionaryprinciple,intergenerationalequity,andsolidarity.Asyouread,
53 Theplaintiffsdefinedfuturegenerationsasthosewhowouldbecomeadultsduringtheperiodof2041to 2070,whenitisestimatedthatColombiawillexperiencea1.6°Cincreaseinaveragetemperatures.
54 ThemaindriversofdeforestationintheAmazonregionincludeillegalmining,landgrabbing,illicitcrop cultivations,logging,andinfrastructuresuchasroadsforagro-industries.
55 Colombiacommittedtoareductionof30percentcontingentoninternationalaid.
56 Villavicencio, supra note28,at7.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw 512
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
payattentiontohowtheCourtappliese achprincipletothecase,guidingits reasoning.
FutureGenerationsv.MinistryofEnvironmentetal.
SupremeCourtofJustice STC4360-2018
Bogotá,D.C.,April5th,2018
OPINIONOFTHECOURT
TOLOSA VILLABONA,P.J.
1.BACKGROUND
1.Theplaintiffspleadfortheprotectionof “supralegal” rights,highlighting thoseof “enjoyingahealthyenvironment,” life,andhealth,allegedlyviolated bytheaccused.
2.1.Asa firststep,theyidentifythemselvesas “ agroupof25children, adolescentsandyoungadults between7and25yearsold,wholive[in][2] citiesthatarepartofthelistofcitiesatgreatestriskbyclimatechange ::: [with]alifeexpectancyof78yearsonaverage(75yearsformenand80years forwomen),whichiswhytheyexpecttodevelop[their]adultlivesbetween theyears2041-2070and[their]oldagefromtheyear2071onwards.Inthese periodsoftime,accordingtotheclimatechangescenariospresentedbythe IDEAM, 57 theaveragetemperatureinColombiaisexpectedtoincreaseby 1.6ºCand2.14ºC,respectively ”
2.2.TheyexplainthatintheParisAgreementandLaw1753of2015,the governmentacquirednationalandinternationalcommitmentstoachieve “ ::: reductionofdeforestationandtheemissionofgreenhousegasesinacontextofclimatechange , ” amongwhich,theyemphasizethedutytoreduce “thenetrateofdeforestationtozerointheColombianAmazonfortheyear 2020.” :::
Additionally,the “ComprehensiveStrategyforControlofDeforestation andForestManagementinColombia, ” reportedthat “ ::: thecountrylost 178,597hectaresin2016,thatis,deforestationincreasedby44%compared tothe figurereportedfor2015 , ” andofthatnumber,70,074hectareswere intheAmazon.
57 See INSTITUTODE HIDROLOGÍA,METEOROLOGÍAY ESTUDIOS AMBIENTALES,http://www.ideam.gov.co/(Instituteof Hydrology,MeteorologyandEnvironmentalStudies)(footnoteadded).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Theydenounceascaus esofthisphenomenon “ landgrabbing(6065%),illicitcrops(20-22%),illegalextractionofmineraldeposits(7-8%), infrastructure,agro-industrialcrops,andillegalextractionofwood. ::: ”
2.4.Theyaf firmthat “ ::: deforestationintheAmazonhasconsequences notonlyinthatregionbutalsointheecosystemsoftherest ” ofthe nationalterritory,amongwhichtheylist: “ 1)Thenegativealterationof thewatercycle;2)thealterationofthegroundsthatcaptureandabsorbwater whenitrains(andtheresulting floodsthatthisgenerates);3)thechangesin thewatersuppliesthatarriveatthe páramos 58 andprovidewatertothecities wheretheplaintiffslive;[and]4)globalwarmingduetothecarbondioxide emissions,whicharestoredintheforestsinconditionsofno deforestation. ::: ”
2.5.Accordingtowhatisargued,theaboveispossiblebecausethosesummonedhavenotadoptedtheappropriatemeasurestodealwiththiseventualityand,inaddition,thishasdireconsequencesfortheplacesoftheir residence,alteringtheirlivingconditionsanddeprivingthemofthechance to “enjoyahealthyenvironment” Theyclaimtobepartof “ ::: thefuturegenerationthatwillfacetheeffects ofclimatechangeintheperiods2041-2070and2071-2100. ::: ”
2.6.Intheiropinion,thepresentpetitionis “suitablefortheprotection ” oftheguaranteesinvoked,forwhichtheypresentnumerousjurisprudential precedentsfromtheConstitutionalCourt,speci fi cally,theyensurecompliance “withthecriteriaestablishedforthisinjudgmentSU-1116of2001” . Additionally,theystatethat “ acciónpopular asanalternativemeansof defenseisnotadequateandeffectiveenough ::: , ” as “bothfundamentaland collectiverightsareaffected.”
1.3.Theappeal.
Theplaintiffsformeditinsistingontheirdisagreements,particularly,they believethatthe acciónpopular isnotthe “ idealremedy ” tosettlethecontroversyraisedand,furthermore ,claimingtohaveprovedthe “ irremediable damage” . :::
2.DISCUSSION
[Theopinionsummarizestheproceduraldifferencesbetween tutela and acciónpopular, recognizingthatconstitutionaljurisprudencehasestablisheda righttothe tutela actionwhentheimpairmentofgroupinterestsinfringes,
58 PáramoisaspecialalpinetundraecosysteminColombia. See,e.g.,Páramo,ENCYCLOPEDIA BRITANNICA,https:// www.britannica.com/science/paramo(footnoteadded).
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
consequently,uponindividualrights.T heactionmustmeetseveralrequirementsincluding(i)aconnectionbetw eentheviolationofcollectiverights andtheviolationofoneormoreoftheprimary,fundamental,andindividual rights,(ii)theperson fi lingmustbethepersondirectlyaffected,(iii)the threatoftherightsmustnotbehypothetical,and(iv)thejudicialordermust seektorestoreindividualrightsandnotthecollectivesones,eveniftheseare implicitinthedecision.]
::: Byvirtueofwhathasbeensaid,itcanbepreachedthatthefundamentalrightsoflife,health,minimumsubsistence,freedom,andhumandignity aresubstantiallylinkedanddeterminedbytheenvironmentandtheecosystem.Withoutahealthyenvironment,subjectsoflaw,andsentientbeingsin general,willnotbeabletosurvive,muchlessprotectthoserights,forourchildrenorforfuturegenerations.Neithercantheexistenceofthefamily,society,ortheStateitselfbeguaranteed.
Theincreasingdeteriorationoftheenvironmentisaseriousassaultto currentandfuturelifeandallotherfundamentalrights;itgraduallydepletes lifeandallrightsrelatedtoit.Theinabilitytoexercisethefundamentalrights towater,tobreathepureair,andtoenjoyahealthyenvironmentnegatively affectsthecurrentpopulace;itincreasesthelackoffreshwateranddecreases theabilitytoenjoyadigni fiedlife. :::
Humanityismainlyresponsibleforthisscenario,itsglobalhegemonic positionledtotheadoptionofananthropocentricandselfi shmodel,whose characteristicfeaturesareharmfultoenvironmentalstability,namely:i)the excessivedemographicgrowth;ii)theadoptionofarapidsystemofdevelopmentguidedbyconsumerismandthecur rentpolitical-economicsystems; andiii)theexcessiveexploitationofnaturalresources.
5.However,graduallyanawarenessofthedutytochangeourbehaviors hasbeguncreatingitself.Thereisasurgeofmovementsfavorabletoanew ideologyofan “ecocentricanthropic” society,whichovercomestheexcessive “homomensura”“autistic” anthropocentrism;whichtakesintoconsideration theenvironment,theideaofprogress,andthenotionofsustainabledevelopmenttoachieve “ ::: abalancebetweeneconomicgrowth,socialwelfare,and environmentalprotection,undertheunderstandingthatpresentactionsmust ensurethepossibilityofmakinguseofresourcesinthefuture. ::: ”
5.1. “ [G]iventheexistenceof[the]risksandproblemsofaglobal nature ::: , ” thejudiciarymustadvocateintheConstitutionalState;fortheeffectiverecognitionoftherightsthatinprincipalmayseem “ orientedtotheprotectionofcollectiveinterestsandthesatisfactionofgeneralizedneeds ::: , ” substantiallypointstothedefenseoftheessentialrightsoftheindividual. ::: Theforegoingmeansthatallindividualsofthehumanspeciesmuststop exclusivelythinkingofself-interest.Weareobligatedtoconsiderhowour worksanddailybehavioralsoaffectsocietyandnature.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
5.2.Asnoted,thescopeofprotectionofthefundamentalprinciplesis eachperson,butalsothe “other.” The “neighbor” isalterity;itsessence:the otherpeoplethatinhabittheplanet,coveringalsoanimalandplantspecies. But,inaddition,itincludesthesubjectsnotyetborn,whodeservetoenjoy thesameenvironmentalconditionslivedbyus. :::
5.3.Theenvironmentalrightsoffuturegenerationsarebasedon(i)the ethicaldutyofsolidarityofthespeciesandon(ii)theintrinsicvalueofnature.
The fi rstisexplainedbythefactthatnaturalgoodsaresharedbyall inhabitantsofPlanetEarth,andbytheirdescendantsorfuturegenerations whodonotyethavethemphysically,butwhoaretributaries,recipients,and ownersofthem,evenifthey,inacontradictoryway,areincreasinglyinsufficientandlimited.Thus,withoutthecurrentexistenceofanequitableand prudentapproachtoconsumption,thehumanspeciesmay finditselfcompromisedinthefutureduetothescarcityofessentialliferesources.Inthisway, solidarityandenvironmentalism “arerelateduntiltheybecomethesame.”
Thus,theestablishmentofthedutyofhumansolidaritywithnatureconstitutestheessentialmeaningof “thetruevaluesthatroutinelyfacilitatelife” bothinitspresentandfuturedimensions.Thisideaestablishesadynamic andtangibleethicofenvironmentalv alues,adjustedandcompatiblewith “ ::: theconservationneedsofnatureinthemostfavorablesenseneededto maintainthelivesofhumanbeings[forever]. ”
Thesecondtranscendsfromtheanthropocentricperspective,andfocuses on “ anthropic-ecocentric ” criterion,whichplacesthehumanbeingonpar withtheenvironmentalecosystem,whosepurposeistoavoidarrogant,dismissive,andirresponsibletreatmentofenvironmentalresources,initsentirety,to satisfymaterialisticends,withoutanyprotectionistorconservationistrespect.
Theestablishmentofthedutyofdirectsolidaritywithnatureisbuiltona value,onitself;this,byaf finitywiththeknowingsubjectorexternal “object” by whichitisde fi ned,becausethehumanbeing “ formspartofnature ‘ being ’ , likewise,nature.”
Thisisthemainideaonwhichtheconceptoftheintrinsicvalueofthe environmentisbased:respectforoneselfimplies,initself, “ respectforthe partofoneselfthatiscomposedbynature,andwhich,intime,futuregenerationswillformapartof.”
Whathasbeenstatedthen,developsabindinglegalrelationshipregardingtheenvironmentalrightsoffuturegenerations,suchasan “ omission, ” whoseimpacttranslatesintoalimitationtothefreedomofactionofpresent generations,whilesimultaneouslyimplicitlydemandingnewburdensofenvironmentalcommitments,totheextentthattheyassumethecareandcustody ofnaturalresourcesandthefutureworld.”
6.Inviewoftheforegoing,numerousregulationshaveemergedinthe internationalarena, hardandsoftlaw,whichconstituteaglobalecologicalpublicorderandserveasguidingcriteriaf ornationallegislation,aswellasfor resolvingcitizens ’ complaintsaboutthedestructionofourhabitat,infavor
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
oftheprotectionofthesubjectiverightsofpeople,ofbothpresentandfuture generations.59
7.InColombia,the1991Constitutionupdatedourstanceonenvironmentalissues,fromwhichanationalecologicalpublicorderwasconstructed, inwhichseveralpreceptswereestablishedonthematter,suchas:theprevalenceofthe “ generalinterest ” (Article1);thedutytoprotectthe “ natural assetsofthenation ” (Article8);publichealth(Article49);the “ ecological dimension ” ofprivateproperty(Article58);thequali fi cationof “ natural parks ” aspropertythatis “ inalienable,imprescriptibleandnotsubjectto seizure ” (Article63);onefunctionofeducationwasde fi nedas “ trainthe Colombianwhenitcomesto theprotectionoftheenvironment ” (Article67);thefundamentalrightto “ ::: enjoyahealthyenvironment” andduty ofthestate “ toprotectthediversityandintegrityoftheenvironment ” (Article79);theimpositionupontheStatedutyto “ ::: planthehandling anduseofnaturalresources,toguaranteetheirsustainabledevelopment ” . TheConstitutionalCourtplayedanimportantrolewithitspronouncements,anddesignedajurisprudentiallinewelcomingtheconceptsand advancesthathaveemergedonthesubjectintheinternationalandacademic scene.
Inthissense,ithasanalyzedtheConstitution’spostulatesfroma “ green ” perspective,catalogingthePoliticalCharterasan “ EcologicalConstitution ” andelevatingtheenvironmentintothecategoryoffundamentalrights. :::
10.TheconservationoftheAmazonisanationalandglobalobligation,it isthemainenvironmentalaxisoftheplanet,andhasbeencalledthe “lungof theworld. ”
Theinternationalcommunityhasgeneratedvariouscommitmentsto achieveitsconservation;theAmazonCooperationTreaty(TCA)shouldbe highlighted,asitsmainobjectiveisthe “ ::: promotionoftheharmonious developmentoftheAmazon,andtheincorporationofitsterritoriestothe respectivenationaleconomies,whichisessentialformaintainingthebalance betweeneconomicgrowthandenvironmentalpreservation ::: ”
Likewise,intheaforementioned FrameworkConventiononClimate ChangeinParisin2015,whereColombi a,amongotherresponsibilities, agreedtoreduce “ deforestationintheColombianAmazon, ” withthispurpose,itpromotedthe “ SustainableColombiaInitiative ” andthe “ Vision Amazon” . :::
11.Undertheaboveassumptions,theCourtwillstudytheappropriatenessoftheprotection,establishing,forthatpurpose,whethertheviolation
59 TheopinionsummarizeslegalinstrumentssuchastheInternationalCovenantonEconomic,Social,and CulturalRightsof1966,ConventionontheProhibitionofMilitaryorAnyOtherHostileUseofEnvironmental ModificationTechniquesof1976,additionalProtocolItotheGenevaConventions,TheStockholmDeclarationof1972,theRioDeclaration,theFrameworkConventiononClimateChange.(Footnoteadded.)
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
ofthecollectiverighttoenjoyahealthyenvironmentimplicatesaviolationof fundamentalrights,allegedasviolatedbytheplaintiffs.
Inthisregard,theChambermustdetermine,atthevenueofthedispute, whetherthereisacausallinkbetweenclimatechangegeneratedbytheprogressivereductionofforestcover,causedbytheexpansionoftheagricultural frontier,narco-crops,mining,andillicitlogging;andthesupposednegative effectsonthehealthofpeopleresidingintheColombianterritory;and,next, itwillhavetoestablishiftherampantdegradationofthejungleforestsdirectly underminestherightstodigni fi edlife,thewater,andthehealthofthe tutelantes. :::
Thispreviousreality,incontrastwiththeenvironmentallegalprinciples of(i)precaution;(ii)intergenerationalequity;and(iii)solidarity,leadsthe Courttothefollowingconclusions:
11.1.Regardingthe fi rstoftheaforementionedprinciples,thereisno doubtthatthereisariskofharm,since,accordingtotheIDEAM,theincrease inGHG[greenhousegas]emissionscausedbythedeforestationoftheAmazonrainforestwouldgenerateanincreaseinColombia ’ stemperature, between “0.7and1.1degreesCelsiusbetween2011and2040, ” whileforthe period “between2041and2070, ” anincreaseof “1.4and1.7” degreescentigradeiscalculated,andtoreachupto2.7degreesCelsius “ intheperiod between2071and2100.”
Likewise,themassreductionoftheAmazonforestwouldbreaktheecosystem’sconnectionwiththeAndes,causingtheprobableextinctionorthreatof subsistenceofthespeciesinhabitingthatcorridor,generating “damagetoits ecologicalintegrity.”
Additionally,accordingtotheIDEAM,theGHGemissionsduetodeforestationwouldcause,withrespecttorainfall,twotypesofconsequences.The first,anincreaseinseveralregionsofthecountry,asituationthatwouldtriggeranincreaseinwaterlevels,andtherefore,runoff,generatingthespreadof water-bornepollutants.Thesecond,ade ficitinothernationaldepartments, causingadecreaseinthewatersupply,aswellasprolongeddroughts.
Regardingtheirreversibilityofthedamageandthescienti fi ccertainty, bothadditionalcomponentsoftheprecautionaryprinciple,theyareevident sincetheGHGemittedasaresultofdeforestation,constitutes36%ofthe forestrysector,becominganuncon trolledcomponentofCO2emissions; informationsupported,indetail,bythestudiescarriedoutbytheIDEAM, theMinistryofForeignAffairs,theMinistryofEnvironmentandSustainable Development,andtheUNDP[UnitedNationsDevelopmentProgramme], amongmanyothers.
11.2.Intermsofintergenerationalequity,thetransgressionisobvious,as theforecastoftemperatureincreaseis1.6degreesin2041and2.14in2071; futuregenerations,includingchildrenwhobroughtthisaction,willbedirectly affected,unlesswepresentlyreducethedeforestationratetozero.
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
11.3.Theprincipleofsolidarity,forthespeci ficcase,isdeterminedbythe dutyandco-responsibilityoftheColombianstatetostopthecausesofGHG emissionscausedbytheabruptforest reductionoftheAmazon;thus,itis imperativetoadoptimmediatemitigationmeasures,andtoprotecttheright toenvironmentalwelfare,bothoftheplaintiffs,andoftheotherpeoplewho inhabitandsharetheAmazonianterritory,notonlynationals,butalsoforeigners,togetherwithalltheinhabitantsoftheglobe,includingtheecosystemsandlivingbeings.
11.3[sic].Thediscussedreality,inadditiontotransgressingtheregulationspertainingtotheEnvironmentalCharterofthecountry,andtheinternationalinstrumentsthatmakeuptheglobalecologicalpublicorder,constitutes aseriousignoranceoftheobligationsacquiredbytheStateintheFramework ConventiononClimateChangeofParis2015,whereColombia,amongother commitments,undertookanagreementtoreduce “ deforestationinthe ColombianAmazon,” withtheobjectivetoreducedeforestationtozerointhat regionby2020.
Itisuptotheauthoritiestorespondeffectivelytothespeci ficquestionsof theproblem,amongwhich,itisimportanttohighlighttheurgentneedto adoptmitigationandcorrectivemeasures:i)fortheexcessiveexpansionof illicitcropsandillegalminingthatunreasonablydestroytheAmazonian forest;ii)to fillthevoidleftbytheFARCandparamilitariestomakeanactive statepresenceinfavoroftheconservationofAmazonianterritoriesthatinthe contextofarmedcon fl ictwereconqueredbyinsurgentgroups,merciless predators,irrationalcolonizers,andgenerally,peopleandorganizationsoutsidethelaw;iii)topreventandmitigatethegrowing fires,deforestation,and unreasonableexpansionoftheagriculturalfrontier;iv)forthelackofpreventionoftheconsequencesinherenttoco nstructingroads,grantingtitlesto propertyandminingconcessions;v)fortheexpansionoflarge-scaleagroindustrialandlivestockfarming;vi)fo rthepreservationofthisecosystem duetoitsimportanceinregulatingtheglobalclimate;vii)forthelackofscientificcalculationsofthereleaseoftonsofcarbonthroughburningandtheloss ofbiomass,whichconstitutestheveget ationcover;andviii)toconfrontclimatechangeduetothedestructionoftheAmazonrainforestinthenational territory.
12.Therefore,theexcessiveintensi fi cationofthisproblemisevident, showing:theineffectivenessofthegovernmentalmeasuresadoptedtoconfrontit,and,fromthatperspective,grantingtheprotectionforthebreachof fundamentalguaranteessuchaswater,air,dignifi edlife,andhealth,among others,inconnectionwiththeenvironment.
Inthisregard,thisChamberfollowsthethesisheldbytheConstitutional CourtintheT-622of2016,relatedtotherecognitionofnatureasarealsubjectofrights,apositionconsistent withtherelevance oftheenvironment anditsconservation,fromtheeco-centricperspectivede fi nedinprevious sections. :::
13.Itisclearthatdespiteseveralinternationalcommitments,legislation, andjurisprudenceonthesubject,theColombianStatehasnotefficientlytackledtheproblemofdeforestationintheAmazon.
13.1.Currently,thethreeautonomousregionalcorporationswithjurisdictionintheAmazonianterritory,havenotmadeeffortstoreducetheconcentratedareaofdeforestation,whichregisters47.23%oftheAT-D,distributed betweentheCorporationfortheSust ainableDevelopmentoftheSouthof theAmazon(Corpoamazonia)at24.47%;theCorporationfortheSustainable DevelopmentoftheNorthandtheEastoftheAmazon(CDA)at11.10%;and theCorporationfortheSustainableDevelopmentoftheAreaofSpecialManagementLaMacarena(Cormacarena)at11.67%.
Inthisway,theaforementionedenvironmentalauthoritiesarenotful fillingtheirdutytoevaluate,control,a ndmonitornaturalresources,norto imposeandexecutesanctionsintheeventofaviolationofenvironmentalprotectionnormsintheirjurisdiction;despitebeingableto,incasetheylacksuffi cientresources,requestsupportfromotheragenciesatthenationaland locallevel,inordertoprotectnaturalresources.
13.2.DeforestationintheColombianAmazonalsooccursinplacesunder theprotectionofNationalNaturalParksofColombia(PNN),speci fi callyin theSierradelaMacarena,Nukak,TiniguaandLaPayaparks, “whichoccupy theplaces3,5,6and9,respectively,oftheParkswithahigherconcentration ofAT-Din2017.”
Thedeforestationinnaturalnationalparksisproofofthenegligencein ful fillingthelegalfunctionswhichwereassignedtotheNaturalNationalParks ofColombia(PNN),notingthatthereductionofforestmassinprotected areasisasituationthatbyregulatio n,mustbecontrolledandsanctionedby saidauthority,itbeingempowered,incaseofnotbeingabletofulfillthistask, todemandcollaborationwithotherauthoritiesofthenational,departmental, andmunicipalrank.
13.3.ThedepartmentswithjurisdictionintheAmazonianterritory,such asAmazonas,Caquetá,Guaviare,andPutumayoarealsofailingtoful fi llthe functionsthatthelawimposesonthemregardingtheenvironmentalprotectionoftheColombianAmazon.Itiswellknown,theyhavethedutytoassist theRegionalAutonomousCorporations[(CAR)]withauthorityintheirterritories;thepercentageofdeforestationistheirresponsibilitytomitigateinconcertwiththeCAR.
13.4.RegardingthemunicipalitiesthathaveAmazonianlandaccordingto theAT-Dnewsletter,inparticular,LaMacarena,ValledelGuamuez,Puerto Asís,SanVicentedelCaguán,Vistahermosa,SanJosédelGuaviare,Puerto Guzmán,Orito,PuertoRico,Mapiri pánCartagenadelChairá,Calamar, Uribe,Solano,PuertoLeguízamo,ElRetorno,Mira fl ores,andFlorencia, SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
containedhighlevelsofdeforestationin2017,withoutthem,asobservedin thereportsrelatedtothisaction,counteractingthesituation.
Theforegoingtransgressesthefulfi llmentoflegalandregulatoryassignments,establishedbyArticle3ofLaw1551of2012,whichassignsmunicipalities “toensuretheproperhandlingofnaturalresourcesandtheenvironment, inaccordancewiththeConstitutionandthelaw.”
14.Therefore,inordertoprotectthisecosystemvitalforourglobal future,justastheConstitutionalCourtdeclaredtheAtratoRiver,theColombianAmazonisrecognizedasa “subjectofrights,” entitledtoprotection,conservation,maintenanceandrestorationledbytheStateandtheterritorial agencies.
Consequently,wegranttherelief,andorderthePresidencyoftheRepublic,theMinistryofEnvironmentandSustainableDevelopment,andtheMinistryofAgricultureandRuralDevelopm ent,incoordinationwiththeactors oftheNationalEnvironmentalSystemandtheparticipationoftheplaintiffs, theaffectedcommunities,andtheinter estedpopulationingeneral,within thefour(4)monthsfollowingtoday ’ snotice,toformulateashort,medium, andlongtermactionplantocounteracttherateofdeforestationintheAmazon,tacklingclimatechangeimpacts.
ThepurposeofthisplanwillbetomitigatetheearlydeforestationwarningsissuedbytheIDEAM.
Likewise,itwillbeorderedofthePresidencyoftheRepublic,theMinistry ofEnvironmentandSustainableDevelopment,andtheMinistryofAgricultureandRuralDevelopment,withinaperiodof fi ve(5)monthsfollowing today’snotice,withtheactiveparticipationoftheplaintiffs,theaffectedcommunities,scienti fi corganizationsorenvironmentalresearchgroups,andthe interestedpopulationingeneral,toformulatetheconstructionofan “intergenerationalpactforthelifeoftheColombianAmazon(PIVAC)” toadoptmeasures aimedatreducingdeforestationtoze roandgreenhousegasemissions,and hasnational,regional,andlocalimplementationstrategiesofapreventative, mandatory,corrective,andpedagogic alnature,directedtowardsclimate changeadaptation.
ItwillalsobeorderedofallthemunicipalitiesoftheColombianAmazon, withinaperiodof fi ve(5)monthsfollowingtoday ’ snotice,toupdateand implementtheLandManagementPl ans,andwhenrelevant,includean actionplantoreducedeforestationtozeroinitsterritory,whichshould encompasspreventative,mandatory,corrective,andpedagogicalmeasurable strategies,orientedtowardsclimatechangeadaptation.
TheCorporationfortheSustainableDevelopmentoftheSouthofthe Amazon(Corpoamazonia),theCorporationfortheSustainableDevelopment oftheNorthandtheEastoftheAmazon(CDA),andtheCorporationforthe SustainableDevelopmentoftheSpecialManagementAreaLaMacarena(Cormacarena),willbeordered,withinaperiodof fi ve(5)monthsfromtoday ’ s notice,withrespecttoitsjurisdiction,tocreateanactionplantocounteract
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
thedeforestationproblemsreportedbytheIDEAMthroughpolice,judicial, oradministrativemeasures.
Additionally,withintheirduties,thedefendantswillhaveto,inthefortyeight(48)hoursfollowingthecompletionofthisruling,increaseactionstendingtomitigatedeforestationwhilecarryingoutthemodi ficationscontainedin theaforementionedmandate.Withintheresponsibilitiesassigned,theymust urgentlypresentthecomplaintsbeforethecorrespondingadministrative andjudicialentities.
Itissoordered.
V.THECAUCARIVER
Theplaintiffs fileda tutela againstEmpresasPublicasdeMedellin60 (EPM),Antioquia (departmentinColombia),theItuangoHydroelectricS.A.,theMinistryofEnvironment,theNationalAgencyofEnvironmentalLicenses(ANLA),andotherstoprotect thefundamentalrightsofcommunitieslivingneartheItuangoHydroelectricproject. TheprojectislocatedinAntioquia,alongtheCaucaRiver.61 Hidroituango(thename oftheproject)hasbeenunderpublicscru tinyduetothesocialandenvironmental impactsofthedam.DespiteEPM’sattemptstokeepanopendialoguewithneighboringcommunities,therewaslittleprogr essaddressingtheproblemsaffectingthe nearbyvillagesandmunicipalities.InFebruary2019,astructural fl awledthecompany totakeemergencymeasures,whichresultedinareductioninthewater fl ow,causinga largepartoftherivertorundry.62 Thishadsigni fi cantimpactson fi shingactivities, transportation,andtourisminthearea.Inresponse,theplaintiffs filedalegalaction seekingprotectionoftheirfundamentalrightstohealth,water,andahealthyenvironment,andtheneighboringcommunities’ righttoadigni fiedlife.63
Thecourtof firstinstanceoftheFourthCivilCourtoftheOralCircuitofMedellin (JuzgadoCuartoCivildelCircuitodeOralidaddeMedellín)declinedtograntthe tutela after concludingthattherewasaclearandrealintentiononbehalfofEPMtodealwiththe ongoingissuesaroundHidroiutango.Thecourtfoundthattherehadbeennoomissionbythedefendants,whichisarequirementfora tutela actiontomoveforward. Theplaintiffsappealedthecase,allegingthatthe fi rstinstancejudgefailedtostudy theprecedentofsentenceT-622of2016(the AtratoRiverBasin case).Onappeal,the SuperiorCourtofMedellinreversedthejudgment.
60 EmpresasPublicasdeMedellinoperatesasautilitycompanyprovidinginfrastructureandoperationalservicesforwaterandsewerage,telecommunications,electricityandgas,andgarbagecollectionservices.
61 TheCaucaRivercovers1,350km,reachingmorethan150municipalitiesinColombia,withatotalpopulationofapproximately10millionpeople.
62 See TaranVolckhausen, Colombia’sDisaster-RiddenHydropowerProjectRunsSecondLargestRiverDry,MONGABAY (Feb.7,2019),https://news.mongabay.com/2019/02/colombias-disaster-ridden-hydropower-project-runssecond-largest-river-dry/(“[T]heCauca[]wasreducedtolessthan10percentofnormal flow. ”).
63 NeitherplaintiffwaspartoftheaffectedcommunitiesaswasthecaseintheAtratoRiverBasinlitigation. Nonetheless,theCourtfoundthattheymettherequirementstobringatutelaaction.
522
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
CastroCórdobaandDavidOchoav.MinistryofEnvironmentetal.
SuperiorCourtofMedellín Judgment#38 Medellín,2015.
OPINIONOFTHECOURT64
SOSA LONDOÑO,J.,J.[Thejudgmentdiscussesthefactsand proceduralposture.Itthencites national 65 andinternationallawonsustainabledevelopmentandfuture generations.]
Itisnoteworthythattheregulations implicitlyrecognizethedignityof futuregenerationsandthisprincipleconstitutes,inessence,oneofthedistinguishingelementsofthesubjectsofrightsinmodernlegislation,which imposesananalysisaroundtheconceptandthedeterminationthatnotonly arefuturegenerationsthesubjectsofrights,butofthepossibilitythattheobligationsthatcurrentgenerationshavetowardsfuturegenerationscanbeprotectedthrough tutela actions. :::
[TheopinioncitestheUnitedNationsCharter,theUnitedNationsConferenceontheHumanEnvironment(T heStockholmDeclaration),the WorldCharterforNature,theRioDeclarationonEnvironmentandDevelopment,theViennaDeclarationandProgramofAction,andUNESCO’sDeclarationontheResponsibilitiesofthePr esentGenerationsTowardsFuture Generations.]
5.2SentenceC-256of1994saidthattheconstitutionalbasisofthelegal requirementforadeclarationofimpactorenvironmentaldefectisfoundin theconstitutionalrightthatallpeoplehave,thoseofpresentandfuturegenerations,toenjoyahealthyenvironment. :::
5.3WhenSentenceC-649of1997statedtherightspossessedbyallpersons,currentandfuturegenerationsalike,itreiteratedthattherighttoenjoy ahealthyenvironmentemergesfromarticles oftheConstitution,whichis thebasisfortheobligationthatenvironmentallawhasimposedonpeopleto presentanenvironmental impactstatement ontheconsequencesthat thedevelopmentorexecutionofaspeci fi cprojectoractivitymayhaveon theenvironmentoronnaturalresources.Theconsequencesexplain “ the needtoprotectforcurrentandfutur egenerationsthebasicelements to guaranteeahealthyenvironmentthroughthepreservationandrestoration oftheecosystem ”
64 Translationbyauthors.
65 L.99/93,diciembre22,1993,DIARIOOFICIAL[D. O.](Colom.);L.388/97,julio18,1997,DIARIO OFICIAL[D.O.](Colom.).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
5.4SentenceC-126of1998remindsusthattheConstitutionproducedan “ ecologization ” ofprivateproperty,whichhasnoteworthyconsequencesnot onlyforthesocialfunctionofpropertybutalsobecausethepowersofindividualpropertyownersarelimitedbytherightsofthosewhohaveyettobeborn, thatis,byfuturegenerations,requi ringandempoweringthelegalorderto adoptgreaterrestrictionsonappropriationsofnaturalresourcesandthepowersofpropertyownersthemselves.
6.Basedonthepreviousdoctrinala ndjurisprudentialprecedent,and grantingthepreambleoftheUnitedNationsCharterandtheinstruments mentioned futuregenerations,[have]afundamentalrighttoahealthy environment[and]aretruesubjectsofrights.
Butnothingwouldbedonebysimplyrecognizingtherightsoffuturegenerationsunderthecategoryofsubjects iftherewerenotatthesametimea wayforthoserightstobeexercised,inotherwords,[thecourts]mustgrant fromnowonactionsforthedefenseoftheirinterests,andalthoughitcould bethoughtthatinthiscasetheappropriatemechanismisthe acciónpopular, giventhenatureoftherequestsmadeinthewritofamparo,mainlythethird, regardingthedeclarationoftheCaucaRiverasasubjectofrights,judgment T-622of2016asaprecedentimposesadifferentinterpretation. :::
8.Asstatedinthecomplaint,thereisnodoubtabouttheexistenceofan unprecedentedcrisisthataffectedthe ::: faunaand florathatdependdirectly onthegoodstateoftheriver,anaturalecosystemthat,asthe1972United NationsConferenceinStockholmdeclared,mustbepreservedforthebenefit offuturegenerations. ::: [Arisingfromthisprecedent,]anothernolessimportantsubjectofrightsemerges:thesamerivertowhichEPMowesaseriesof commitmentstoremedythedamagesthatthecontingencyproducedonits ecosystem.
Thisisnotaboutelaboratingontheargumentfortheprotectionofnaturalwealth,theconceptoftheecologicalorgreenconstitution,sincetheConstitutionalCourtalreadydidsothroughitsjudgmentT-622of2016, but aboutthespecialprotectionthattheCaucaRiverdeservesasasourceoffood, environment,anddiversity,butespeciallyoftherighttowaterasahydrologicalsource,ofconservingitsfuturevalue. :::
Theriverhassufferedfromthebehavior,theinterventionofhuman beings,foreseeableornot,takingits flowtoahistoricalminimum. [Thecrisis]demands,claims,arecoveryproces s,(ifoneishighlyoptimisticinthe mediumterm,butinreality,inthelongterm),andthereforemeritsnotonly currentcompensation,but ::: thematerializationoffuturegenerationsasa subjectofrights. :::
[T]herewasmentionoftheinterg enerationalequitythatcanbe expressedinthatfuturegenerationshavetherighttoanadequateinheritance thatallowsthemaleveloflifenotlessthanthatofthecurrentgeneration, whichisaprinciplethatisdirectlyrelatedtotheethicalbaseofthe
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
environmentalorderandthe solidarity concept,thislatterenshrinedinArticle1ofthe1991PoliticalCharter. Insummary,thiscourtessentially declares:
(i)Thatfuturegenerationsarethesubjectofrightsrequiringveryspecialprotection,(ii)thattheyhavefundamentalrightstodignity,water,foodsecurity, andahealthyenvironment,and(iii)thattheriverCaucaisthesubjectof rights,whichimplies,aswasdonewiththeAtratoRiver,itsprotection,conservation,maintenance,andrestorationundertheauthorityofthePublicMunicipalEntityandtheState.
10.TheorderstobeissuedwillbesimilartothoseorderedbytheCourtin judgmentT-622of2016.Withoutadoubt,EPMisresponsiblefortheviolation ofthefundamentalrightsoffuturegenerationstotheirlife,water,foodsecurity,healthyenvironment,butastheabundantdocumentaryevidencethathas beencollectedshowsthateffectiveactions[bythecompany]havebegunto stopthedamagesufferedbytheriverdownstream,noorderwillbeissuedto initiatesuchactions.
Consequently,theNationalGovernmentwillbeorderedtoexercisethe protectionandlegalrepresentationoftherightsoftheriver(throughthe institutiondesignatedbythePresident,whichcouldwellbetheMinistryof Environment),togetherwiththecommunitiesandpeoplewhowerepresent atthepreventivemonitoringhearingoftheItuangoHydroelectricproject heldonFebruary27,2019. Inthisway,theCaucaRiveranditswatershed willberepresentedfromnowonbyamemberoftheseparticipantsandadelegateoftheColombianGovernment,whowillbetheguardiansofthe river.
[Theguardianswillreceivesupportfrompublicorprivateentities,universities,researchcenters,environment alorganizations(nationalorinternational),grassrootsgroups,etc.]
ItisorderedthattheGeneralProsecutoroftheNation,theOmbudsman, andtheOfficeoftheControllerGeneraloftheRepublic inaccordancewith theirlegalandconstitutionalpowers,carryoutaprocessofaccompaniment andmonitoringcomplianceandexecutionofordersalreadyindicated [theseof fices]willsubmitsemesterreportsoftheiractivitiesandcompliance indicators.
11.Finally,sincethejudgmentwillonlybeeffectiveonceitisextendedto allpersonsorcommunitiesthatresideintheCaucariverbasin,itstributaries, andneighboringterritories,theCourtgrans intercommunis effectstothe decision.
Itissoordered.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
VI.THECOELLO,COMBEIMA,ANDCOCORARIVERS
IsaacVargasMorales,actingasMunicipalOf fi cialofIbague, fi ledapopularaction againsttheMinistryofEnvironment,theC olombianGeologicalSurvey,AngloGold AshantiColombia,Continen talGold,andothers,seekingtostopminingactivityin theriverbasinsoftheCoelloGreaterRiver,theCombeimaRiver,andtheCocora River.Goldminingaroundtherivers’ basinsaffectsthequalityandquantityofwater usedforhumanconsumption.Italsoaffectstheagricultural,industrial,andlivestock sectors,whicharecrucialfortheecono myandfoodsecurityofthepopulationof Ibagueandothermunicipalities.Inessenc e,thecomplaintallegedthattheenvironmentallicensesgrantedtominingcompan iesthreatentheCoello,Cocora,and CombeimaRiversand,inturn,thecollectiverightstoenjoymentofthepublicspace, freeofpollution;theenjoymentofahealthyandecologicallybalancedenvironment; thepreventionoftechnicallyforeseeabledisasters;andpublicsafetyandhealth.
VargasMoralesv.MinistryofEnvironmentetal.
Filenumber:73001-23-00-000-2011-00611-000 AdministrativeCourtoftheDepartmentofTolima Ibague,TolimaMay30th,2019
OPINIONOFTHECOURT
ROJAS VILLA,J.,J.[Theopiniondiscussesindepththenationalandinternationalsourcesoflaw onsustainabledevelopmentandtherighttowater,includinginternational humanrightslawandcomparativelaw. Itthendescribest heprecautionary principle.Accordingtoa2011technicalreport,therisksassociatedwithgold miningexplorationandexploitationin cludeincreasedsoilerosion,lossof regularwater fl ows,impactsonfoodproduction,andanincreaseinthekind andnumberoflandslides,amongothers.]
Atthisstageofthejudicialprocess,itseemsplausibletoaf fi rmthatif theserisksarematerialized,thedamagewouldbeofsuchmagnitudethatthey wouldposeaseriousdetrimenttotheenvironmentandnaturalresources.A criticalresultifoneconsidersthat,inaddition,strategicecosystemsarebeing affectedwhich playacrucialroleforthesubsistenceofecosystems,crops, andcommunitiesoftheregion.
[T]hisChamber findsthattheacuteenvironmental,social,andeconomic problemresultingfromthegrantingofminingtitlesinthebasinoftherivers Coello,CocoraandCombeimamakesevidentafundamentalthreatofserious damagetotheecologicalbalanceandt hepreservationofnaturalresources thatcannotbe[ignoredby]theConstitutionalJudgeofPopularAction.
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
[Followingtheprincipleofproportionality,theCourtdeniedthesuspensionsoftheminingtitlesrequestedbyplaintiffs.]
TheChamberdeclarestheviolationofthecollective[rights]toenjoythe publicspacefreeofpollution,ahealth yandecologicallybalancedenvironment,preventionoftechnicallyforese eabledisasters,andpublicsafetyand healthofthecommunitieslivinginthebasinoftheCoelloriver.
TheChamberwilladoptthenecessarymeasurestoprotectthehydric resourcethatisindispensablefortheresidentsoftheMunicipalityofIbague andagreatpartoftheDepartmentofTolima.
[Opinioncitesthe2016Atratoriverdecision.]
TheChamberwilladopttheargumentsdevelopedbytheHonorableConstitutionalCourttorecognizethattheCoello,CombeimaandCocorarivers, theirbasisandtributariesasindividualentities,subjectofrightstotheprotection,conservation,maintenance,andrestorationinchargeoftheStateand communities.
Consequently,itwillorderthenationalGovernmenttoexerciseguardianshipandlegalrepresentationoftherightsoftherivers(throughtheinstitutionthatthePresidentoftheRepublicdesignates,whichcouldwellbethe MinistryofEnvironmentandSustaina bleDevelopment)togetherwiththe communitiesthatliveinthebasisoftheCoello,Combeima,andCocorarivers; inthisway,thethreeriversandtheirbasins,fromnowon,willbeeachrepresentedbyamemberoftheircommunitiesandadelegatefromtheColombian Government,whomwillbetheguardiansoftheriver. ::: 66
Additionally,thisplanwillincludeaseriesofclearindicatorsthatallowto measuretheiref fi cacyandmustbedesignedandexecutedinaconsensual mannerwiththeresidentsofthearea,w hileguaranteeing theparticipation ofcommunities underthe169ConventionoftheILO.
[Opinionordersthecreationofactionplansaswellastoxicologicand epidemiologicalstudiesoftheCoello,Combeima,andCocorarivers,itstributaries,andcommunities.]
ItwillbeorderedthattheGeneralProsecutoroftheNation,theOmbudsman,andtheOfficeoftheControllerGeneraloftheRepublic,inaccordance withtheirlegalandconstitutionalpowers,carryoutaprocessofaccompanimentandofmonitoringcomplianceandexecutionofordersalreadyindicated intheshort,medium,andlongterm.
VII.PÁRAMODEPISBA
In2018,aColombiancourt( TribunalAdministrativodeBoyacá )declaredthatthe PáramodePisbawasasubjectofrights,makingitthethirdrecognizedrights-bearing
66 TheopinionalsoordersthecreationofanadvisoryteamcomposedoftheAlexandervonHumboldtInstituteofBiologicalResourcesResearch,WWFColombia,andotherresearchorganizations,civilsocietygroups, etc.(footnoteadded).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
ecosysteminthecountry.Therecogniti onofthispáramo(auniquealpinetundra ecosystem)raisedquestions,suchas,ifthisecosystemhasrights,shouldn’tallofthem? InthecaseofthePáramodePisba,itisimportanttonotethecontextoftheecosystem. SevenpercentofColombiansrelyonwatersuppliesregulatedbypáramos.Only fi ve countriesintheworldhavepáramoecosystems,andColombiahasthemost.
Theevolutionoftheirlegalprotectionbeganin2011,whenthebasisforthelawof thepáramos(Ley1450,Artículo20267) firstappearedwithinthecontextoftheNational DevelopmentPlan.Theinitiallawsetto demarcatetheboundariesofpáramosand prohibitednewcontractsforthecultivationoftheland,farming,miningandexplorationformineralsandcarbon,andconstructionofoilandgasre fi neries.In2018, Law1930(Ley1930)68 wassignedbyCongress.Article1states, “Theobjectofthepresentlawistoestablishpáramosasstrategicecosystemsandtosetguidelinesthatfavor theirintegrality,preservation,restoration,sustainableuse,andgenerationofknowledge. ” TheLawcontains6chaptersand33articles,pertainingtothemaintenance andprotectionofpáramos,inrelationtoretainingtheirintegrity.
Afewmonthslater,theBoyacáTribunal ’ sdecision( Expediente152383333002 20180001601I) recognizedPáramodePisbaasasubjectofrights,withtherightto maintenance,protection,con servation,andrestoration. 69 Thedecisioncamein responsetoa tutela filedbyresidentsdemandingtheirfundamentalrightstoparticipationintheprocessofzoninganddeterminingtheboundariesofthepáramo.
Initsdecision,thecourtdeclaredtheMinistryoftheEnvironmentandSustainable DevelopmentasthelegalrepresentativeofPáramodePisba.70 Thecourtthengavethe ministryoneyeartodeterminetheboundariesofthepáramo,invitingallactorstoparticipateintheprocess,accordingtominimumstandards. 71 Thejudgecautionedthat theoutcomeoftheprocesscannotinfringeontherightsofthePáramodePisba. 72 Withnoticetotheminingcompaniesoper atingacrossthedepartment,thecourt orderedthatallpeopleaffectedbytherezoningshouldbecompensated,particularly thosegroupswhohavehistoricallybeensubjecttodiscrimination.73
VIII.CONCLUSION
Thecasesdiscussedinthischapter,alongwithothersinColombiathatadvancethe developmentofEarthlawhavefosteredabroaderdiscussioninColombiaoftherelationshipbetweennatureandhumans.Supportersofnature’srightspointtotheevolvingunderstandingsofrightsandlegalpersonhoodthroughouthistory.Atonetime,
67 L.1450/11,junio16,2011,DIARIO OFICIAL [D.O.](Colom.).
68 CongresodelaRepúblicaColombia.Ley1930, “Pormediadelacualsedictandisposicionesparalagestión integraldelospáramosenColombia” (2018).
69 Expediente15238333300220180001601ImakesreferencetotheAtratoCase(seep.25).
70 Id. at68
71 Id. at68-69.
72 Id. at35.
73 Id. at70.
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
children,women,andmanyothergroupswerenotconsideredlegalpersonsintheway theyarenow.Today,inanincreasingnumberofjurisdictions,ecosystems,riverbasins, andindividualanimalsarethesubjectsofrights.
Theseachievementsraiseimportantquestions.Forexample,whatistheimpactof grantingrightstonaturewh enguardiansorrepresentativesarerequiredtosueon theirbehalf?Mightthecreationofnewlegalobligationsinregardtonaturalsystems beredundantandneedlesslycomplicatedecision-makingifhumanrightstoahealthy environmentcouldprovidethesameremedies?Wouldfocusingonhumanrightsyield moreeffectiveresultsthanworkingtowardsthecreationofsuchnewobligations.Considertheargumentthatnature’ srightsarenotanappropriateframeworktofurther environmentalprotectionbecauseecosystemsandtheirnonhumancomponentscannotexerciserightsorbesubjecttodutiesinthewaysthathumansandlegalentities suchascorporationscan.
Villavicencioandothers,writinginsupportofthesenewobligations,havefound thatrecentjudgmentsshedlightontheinef fi ciencyoftheColombiangovernment, institutionalgapsatthelocalandnationallevels,andtheinsuf fi cientprotectionof natureandecosystems. 74 Theysignalanewapproachinwhichjudgesrecognizethe rightsofecosystemssothatlocalcommuni tiesandotherstakeholdersmayenforce theirprotection,conservation,maintenance,andrestoration,evenintheabsenceof actionbythelegislativebranch.75 Furthermore,theyprovideanopportunityforcivil societyactorstoengageinmonitoringandcreatefollow-upmechanismstoaidthe implementationofajudgment.Whiletheplaintiffsinmanyofthesecasesdidnot expresslyrequestthatthecourtsdesignate ecosystemsasthesubjectsofrights,the courtshaveaf firmativelyrecognizedtheirlegalpersonhoodandmadeprogresstoreinforcearightsofnatureparadigm.76
Rightsevolveinamatrixoflegalsystemsandframeworksandneedtobeconsideredintandemwiththesefactors.Despitethejudgments’ tendencytogiveemphasis totheenforcementofnature ’ srights,thechallengesofeffectuatingtheserightsis complicatedinthecontextofinequality,ongoingviolence,andasocialtransitionin Colombiansocietythatwasengulfedinarmedcon fl ictbeforetheConstitutionwas adoptedin1991.
Theremayalsobetensionsbetweentherightsofnatureandthefundamental rightsofvulnerablepopulations.Challengesbetweentherightsofnatureandofvulnerablepopulationshavebeguntoemergeintheimplementationofsomeofthe recentcasedecisionsinColombia.Forexample,inthecaseoftheAtratoRiver,various residentsthoughttobeassociatedwiththeprotectionoftheriverhavebeentargeted forassassinationandthreatenedwithviolence.77 Whilethethreatsandviolenceagainst
74 Villavicencio, supra note28,at9.
75 Id.
76 Id. at10.
77 ThreatsofviolenceagainstenvironmentaldefendersandrightsactivistsareendemicinColombia.Inrecent years,Colombiahasrankedamongthe fivemostdangerouscountriesworldwideforenvironmentaldefenders andrightsactivists. Colombia: ‘TerribleTrend’ ofRightsDefendersKilled,Harassed;UNCallsfor ‘SignificantEffort’ to TackleImpunity,UNNEWS (May10,2019),https://news.un.org/en/story/2019/05/1038281.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
environmentaldefendersarenotanewphenomenon,thejudicialordermaybe increasingthisrisk.Atthistime,theredoesnotappeartobeanygovernmentallyrecognizedsystemtoprotectresidentsfromtheseongoingthreatsofviolence.78 Ananalysis ofthesetensionsdoesnotimplya flawinthejudgmentsperse.Itsimplyindicatesthat theindividualsandentitiesresponsiblefortheimplementationprocessareencounteringforeseeablechallengesincarryingoutthecourts’ decisions.
TensionsarealsopresentintheimplementationofthejudicialordersondeforestationintheAmazonregion.Thereisacomplexwebofgroupswithapresencein theseterritories,includingregionalauto nomouscorporations(CARs),Indigenous groups,foreignlandowners, campesinos (peasantfarmers),andillegalarmedactors. Whilecertaingroupshavespecialrightstooperateintheterritory,suchastheCARs, orspecialconstitutionalprotections,asisthecasewithIndigenouspeople,others,such asillegalarmedgroupsandforeignlandownersorinvestors,havepowerintheterritory.Inthissimpli fi edmatrix,itisimportanttonotethatColombian campesinos do nothaveconstitutionalprotections,despitelong-standingmovementsadvocatingfor theirrights.InthecaseoftheAmazon,attentionshouldbepaidtowhoisprosecuted fordeforestationandhowcertaingroupsmaybedisproportionatelypenalized.Similarly,planstotackledeforestationcanno tdevelopwithoutprovidingcomprehensive programstohelpbuildalternativelivelih oodsthatdonotrelyondeforestation.In 2019,theColombiangovernmentmadedefore stationanationalsecurityissue;the impactswillfurthershedlightonhowthistensionbetweenrightsevolvesandisreconciledinpractice.79
Insum,whiletherearechallengestoimplementingjudgmentsrecognizing nature’ srights,theColombiancasesrepresentanextraordinaryadvancementinthe fi eldofEarthlawandchartapromisingfutureforbothlitigationandlegislation. Recently,RepresentativeJ uanCarlosLozadaVargasintroducedabilltoamendthe Constitutiontomakenatureasubjectofrightsinaccordancewiththerecentjudicial decisions.80 Inaddition,thesedecisionsarespurringmeaningfullegaldebate,pushing institutionstorespond,andinspiringactiviststoimaginenewwaystoleveragethelaw forsocialandenvironmentalchange.Thesedevelopmentswillcontinuetoshapethe fieldofEarthlaw.
78 RedacciónColombia2020,¿NosVanaMataraTodosporDefenderelRíoAtrato?”:LíderSocialdelChocó,EL ESPECTADOR (Feb.26,20192:22PM),https://www.elespectador.com/colombia2020/pais/nos-van-matar-todos-pordefender-el-rio-atrato-lider-social-del-choco-articulo-857687.
79 EnEsteGobierno,laFaltadeAgua,laPérdidadelaBiodiversidadylaContaminaciónAmbiental,seConvirtieronen unaPreocupacióndeSeguridadNacional,MINISTERIODE AMBIENTEY DESARROLLO SOSTENIBLE 2020(2019),http:// www.minambiente.gov.co/index.php/n oticias/4279-en-este-gobierno-la-falta-de-agua-la-perdida-de-labiodiversidad-y-la-contaminacion-ambiental-se-convirtieron-en-una-preocupacion-de-seguridad-nacionalgracias-a-la-nueva-politica-de-defensa-y-seguridad-para-la-equidad.
80 See “Porelcualsemodificaelartículo79delaConstituciónPolíticadeColombia.[Naturalezacomosujetodederechos]” , U NIVERSIDADDELOS A NDES (2019)https://congresovisible.uniandes.edu.co/proyectos-de-ley/por-el-cual-semodi fi ca/10116/(ProyectodeActoLegislativo “ porelcualsemodi fi caelartículo79delaConstitución PolíticadeColombia).
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1) Interpretationofinternationalprinciples.Colombia’slegalsystemintegratesseveral principlesofinternationalenvironmentallawandenvironmentaljusticeinto itslegislationandjurisprudence,suchastheprecautionaryprinciple,thepreventionprinciple,distributivejustice ,participatoryjust ice,environmental equity,andintergenerationalequity, amongothers.Howdoesthejudiciary enlargetheseprinciplesbeyondthei rtraditionalinterpretationsinthe Atrato judgment?Forinstance,thejudiciarye xpandedtheprecautionaryprinciple, whichisoftenappliedintheenvironmentalcontext,tohumanhealth.How canthisexpandedviewoftheprecautionaryprinciplebeusedtodeveloplegislationsuitedtoprotecthumanandnon-humannature?
(2) Establishinganewregime.The Atrato judgmentsetthelegalframeworkforecosystemrights-basedjurisprudenceinColombia,namelytherighttobemaintained, protected,conserved,andeventuallyre stored.Whilemostrightsframeworks applicabletoindividualrightstypicallyincludeduties,naturecannotitselfexecuteassigneddutiesorbeheldliableforharmsdone.Recognizingboth nature’sintrinsicandinstrumentalvaluesasaholisticpackage,isitappropriate topositthat intheabsenceofassigningnaturetraditionallegalduties the intrinsicvaluesandecologicalgood sandservicesprovidedbynaturemay supersedetheneedforprescribedlegalduties?Inthe Atrato case,theCourt hasassignedhumanswiththeresponsib ilitytoactonbehalfofnature,with theunderstandingthataprotectedan drespectednaturalenvironmentpreservesandenhanceshumanqualityoflife.Howcanthereasoningpresented bythiscasecontributetoourunderstandingofanature’srightsregime?
(3) Challengesinimplementation. Itisimportanttonotethatasigni ficantportionof thestatedefendantsinthiscasedonothavearegionalpresenceinChocó, despitetheirprescribedobligationstocoordinateorcollaborateonactivities intheregion.Howmightthiscomplicatetheimplementationofthecourt ’ s orders?Doyouthinkauthoritieswithoutapreexistingregionalpresencecan realisticallymeetthedemandsofthecourtorder?Further,thecasedealsin largepartwithillegalactivityandalludestoillegalarmedactorsintheregion. Duetoarmedcon fl ictandstateabsenceintheregion,Chocóresidentscontinuetolivealongsideillegallyarmedactors.Howmightthisfurthercomplicate fullimplementationofthejudgment?
(4) Nature ’ srights. Initsdecision,theCourtrepeatedlyunderscoredinterdependencebetweenthefundamentalhumanr ighttolifeandotherconstitutional rights,includingtherighttoaclean,healthyenvironment.Thisemphasiscan beseenasasignaltothebroaderjudicialbranchtorecognizethisinterdependence.Additionally,thecasepresentsanecocentricunderstandingofhuman dependenceonnature,linkingthis interdependencetoemergingEarth jurisprudenceandsettingalegalprecedentfornature ’ srightsaroundthe
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
globe.Yet,nature’srightswerenotapartoftherequestedrelief.Whatrational argumentsdidtheCourtusetomakeacasefornature’srights?Areanyexistentialargumentsincludedtojustifytheordertoprotectnature ’srights?Howdo youunderstandtheCourt’sinterpretationofthepetitioner’sclaims?
(5) Softlawv.hardlaw. WhileColombia ’ slegalsystemintegratesinternational agreementsthroughwhatisknownas bloquedeconstitucionalidad ,someofthe sourcesthattheplaintiffsinthe Amazon caseincludedintheircomplaintto assertthegovernment’slegalobligationwerenotinternationalconventionsor otherlegallybindingtreaties.Forinstance,thejointstatementthathadsetzero netdeforestationasagoalfortheyear2020wassimplyastatementreiterating thesupportthatGermany,theUnitedKingdom,andNorwayofferedtoColombiainthe fightagainstdeforestation.Similarly,theplaintiffsreferredtoseveral principlesofinternationalenvironmentallawsuchastheprecautionaryprinciple,thesolidarityprinciple,andintergenerationalequityamongothers,of whichonlysomeareincludedintheCon stitution.Whatwastheimportance oftheseprinciplesintheCourt ’ sreasoning?Doesitmakeadifferencethat someoftheseprincipleswereenshrinedinnationallawwhileotherswere not?HowdidthenationalcommitmentsundertheParisAgreementinformed theopinion ’sreasoning?
(6) Challengesinlitigatingclimatechange. Asinotherclimatechangelawsuitsaround theworld,theplaintiffsinthe Amazon caseriskedtheCourt findingthatitdid nothavejurisdictionoverthecasebeca usethequestionofdeforestationand climatechangepolicywasa “politicalquestion ” reservedfortheexecutiveand legislativebranchestohandle.Altern atively,theCourtcouldhavefoundthat theviolationsallegedbytheplaintiffswerenonjusticiable,althoughthe jurisprudenceonsocioeconomicrightsinColombiamadethisscenariomuch lesslikelythanincountriesliketheUnitedStates.Whatdoyoumakeofthe Court’snon-treatmentoftheseparationofpowersprinciple?Whatotherobstaclesdoyouthinktheplaintiffsfaced?Inaddition,climatechangelitigation facesthechallengeofestablishingcausalitybetweengreenhousegasemissions andtheimpactsattributedtothedefendants ’ (in)action.Climatechangeisa globalproblemcausebyglobalGHGemissions,whichcanrarelybetracedto particularemitters.HowdidtheCourtovercometheobstacleofcausality?
(7) Intragenerationalequity. Whilethe Amazon plaintiffsbroughttheirclaimson behalfofpresentandfuturegenerations,theCourtdidnotruleontheirstandingnordiditadoptadefinitionoffuturegenerations.Theclaimantsusedthe veryspeci fi cde fi nitionoffuturegenerations;namely, “ thoseindividualswho wouldbecomeadultsbetweentheyears2041and2070, ” whichistheperiod inwhichthecountryexpectstoseeani ncreaseinaveragetemperaturesof morethan1.6°Caccordingtoof fi cialdata.Whydoyouthinktheyde fi ned “ futuregenerations ” thisway?Iffuturegenerationswerede fi nedtoinclude unbornchildrenwouldthishavecausedstandingissues?Couldthishavepotentialimplicationsinotherareasoflaw?
Chapter18:Nature’sRightsinColombia:AnEmergingJurisprudence
(8) Scienceandthelaw. Boththe Amazon complaintandtheSupremeCourt ’sopiniondrewheavilyonclimatescienceandthegovernment’sof ficialsubmissions totheUnitedNationsFrameworkonClimateChange.Thegovernmentof ColombiareliesontheInstituteofHydrology,MeteorologyandEnvironmental Studies(IDEAM),theagencytaskedwithproducingenvironmentaldatainthe country.Thismadeitverydif fi cultforthedefendantstoquestionanyofthe sciencethatwaspresented.Instead, thedefendantsarguedonprocedural grounds,pointingoutthatthe tutela wasnottheidealmechanismtobringthe plaintiffs’ claim.Whatdoyouthinkistheroleofscienceinclimatelitigation cases,orinlitigationdealingwiththerightsofnaturemorebroadly?
(9) Separationofpowers. Otherclimatechangelitigationcasesaroundtheworldhave demandedmoreambitionwithrespecttonationalplanstomitigateemissions. 81 Thisinherentlyraisesquestionsabouttheseparationofpowersprinciple.Inthe Amazon case,theCourtissuedaseriesofordersmandatingthe executivebranchtodevelopandimplementactionplans.However,theorder failstomentiontheMinistryofFinance,arguablythemostimportantministry. Whatotheractorsshouldtheopinionhaveinvolved?Doyouthinktheseorders violatetheseparationofpowersprinciple?Aretheyeffective?
(10) Challengesofstructuraljudgments. Similartothe AtratoRiverBasin case,the Amazon judgmentattemptstotacklecomplexandstructuraldynamicsinColombia: ongoingcon fl ict,anabsentstate,weakinstit utions,thepresenceofillegal actors,landgrabbing,andrampantinequality,amongothers.Doyouthinka judicialorderisanappropriatewaytodealwiththeseproblems?Whatshould betheroleofthejudiciarybranchintacklingsystemicissueslikedeforestation intheAmazonorchronicenvironmentalinjusticeinethnicterritories?How shouldotherbranchesofgovernmentengagewiththeproblem?Furthermore, thecaseraisesquestionsaboutmonitoringandcompliance,whichareongoing challengesatthetimeofwriting.Whatissuesmayemergeduringtheimplementationofstructuraljudgmentsliketheoneinthe Amazon case?
(11) Theroleofprecedent. Inbothofthecasesdealingwithrivers,theregionalcourts adoptedanecocentricframework.Howdopreviousdecisionsshapethereasoningofthecourtshere?Doyouthinkthattheirapplicationofpreviousjudgmentsiscompelling?
(12) Legalfetishism.JulietaLemaitreRipollhascoinedthetheoryoflegalfetishismto describeasituationof “desiringandenjoyingthelawnotasameanstoanend,
81 Caseshavebeen fi ledinCanada,Germany,Norway,France,Switzerland,IrelandandtheNetherlands amongothers.Formoreinformation, seeClimateChangeLitigationDatabases,T HE SABIN CENTERFOR C LIMATE CHANGE LAW,http://climatecasechart.com/.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
butratherasanendinitself.”82 Whileingeneralenvironmentalpractitioners praiserecentjurisprudenceapplyinganecocentricapproach,severalconcerns havebeenraised.Somecriticsposittha ttheColombianlegalsystemalready hassufficienttoolstoprotectnatureandthusadvocatesshouldpaymoreattentiontotheimplementationoflegislationorjudicialsentences.Similarly,some critics fi ndthattherearestrongconstitutionalprotectionsbutsignificantgaps inbothinstitutionalcoordinationandful fi llmentoffundamentalrightsona dailybasis. 83 Whatdoyoumakeofthesecritiques?Arethereanyarguments forthesymboliceffectorimpactofthesentencesdiscussedinthischapter?
(13) Legislatingnature’srights. Asofthetimeofpublication,amemberofCongress hadintroducedaconstitutionalamendmenttomodifyArticle79andguarantee therecognitionofnatureasasubjectofrights.Whatdoyouthinkaboutconstitutionalreformasopposedtofurtherjurisprudenceonthisissue?Whatisthe valueofintroducingandpotentiallypassingaconstitutionalamendmenton thisissue?Aretheredrawbacks?
82 JulietaLemaitreRipoll, LegalFetishism:Law,Violence,andSocialMovementsinColombia,77REV.JUR.U.P.R.331 (2008).
83 See UNITED NATIONS ENVIRONMENT PROGRAMME,ENVIRONMENTAL RULEOF LAW:FIRST GLOBAL REPORT viii(2019).
CHAPTER19
EarthLawinLatinAmerica: AGlimpseofBrazilandMexico1
I.INTRODUCTION
LatinAmericaisaworldleaderintherightsofnaturemovement.Already,youhave learnedaboutdevelopmentsinEcuadorandColombia twotrailblazersinthedevelopmentofEarthlaw.OthercountriesinLatinAmericaalsorecognizetherightsof natureinsomecapacity,andmanymorehaveproposedtodothesame.2
InadditiontoEcuadorandColombia,animportantembodimentofrightsof natureinLatinAmericacomesfromBolivia.In2010,Bolivia’sPlurinationalLegislative AssemblypassedtheLawoftheRightsofMotherEarth,whichrecognizednature ’ s rightstolife,tothediversityoflife,towater,tocleanair,toequilibrium,torestoration, andtopollution-freeliving. 3 Thislawwasfollowedupbythe2012FrameworkLawof MotherEarthandIntegralDevelopmentforLivingWell,4 whichrequiredthecreation ofaMotherEarthOmbudsmanOf fi ce(DefensoriadelaMadreTierra)tobolster Bolivia ’ sexistingrightsofnatureprotections.U nfortunately,inpractice,Boliviahas largelyfailedtoupholditsboldrightsofnatureagenda.AslamentedbyPabloSolon, formerUNambassadorfromBolivia: “ Wemightexpectneoliberalextractivistpoliticianstodothis.Butit’sparticularlypainfulwhenitisdonebyformercomradeswho waveabannerofMotherEarthintheairwhilecrushingthoseveryrightsunderfoot.”5
TwootherLatinAmericancountriesthatrecognizenature ’srightsinsomecapacityareBrazilandMexico.BothBrazilandMexicohaveauniqueperspectiveonemergingEarthlawmovementsinLatinAmericannations.Theywerecombinedintoasingle
1 Thechapter’ssectiononMexicowasauthoredbyRaúlGutiérrezPatiño(TransdisciplinaryUniversityCenter forEnvironmentalSustainabilityoftheIberoamericanUniversity(CENTRUS))withmodificationsandadditionsbyEarthLawCenter(particularlyontheRightsofNature)andresearchbyCameliaStanciu(founder ofBalanceEarth).ThesectiononBrazilwasauthoredbyNikolettaPikramenou,Ph.D.
2 RightsofnaturehavebeenproposednationallyinArgentina,(UNHarmonywithNature,RightsofNature Law,PolicyandEducation,http://www.harmonywithnatureun.org/rightsofnature),andacoalitionoflawyers inPerurecentlyproposedalawrecognizingtherightsofrivers.
3 LeydeDerechosdelaMadreTierra,Law071ofthePlurinationalState(2010).
4 LaLeyMarcodelaMadreTierrayDesarrolloIntegralparaVivirBien,Law300ofthePlurinationalState(2012).
5 ShannonBiggs&NickBuston, BoliviaMustPracticeWhatitPreaches,THE ECOLOGIST (May24,2019),https:// theecologist.org/2019/may/24/bolivia-must-practice-what-it-preaches.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
chaptertoencourageacomparisonoftheirrespectiveapproaches.Therearemany similaritiesandsomeimportantdistinctions,aswell.
Despitetheirdifferentbiomes tropicalBrazilisfamousforitsrainforestand savannahwhileMexicostraddlesthetropicofCancerandhassignificantareasofarid anddeserthabitat BrazilandMexicosharesignificantsimilaritiesfromanenvironmentalperspective.Bothareclassi fi edasmega-diversecountrieswithanincredible arrayofplantandanimalspecies.Andwhilebothhavenationalconstitutionsthat emphasizeahuman-centeredattitudetotheenvironment,inbothnations,thereare buddinggrassrootsmovementstostrengthe nIndigenousphiloso phies,ecocentrism, andtherightsofnature.
ThischapterdiscussesBrazil firstandthenMexico.Foreach,itstartsbyexamining thelaw ’ streatmentoftheenvironmentandhowEarthlawcanbederivedfromthe existinglegalsystems.BothsectionsalsodiscussthedevelopmentofEarthlawatthe localorstatewidelevel.Finally,bothsecti onslookatthecurrentandpossiblefuture rolesofIndigenouspeoplesinthedevelopmentofthecountries’ legalsystems.
TherearedifferencesbetweenBrazilandMexico,aswell.Notably,thetwocountriesdiscussuniquetheoriesforexpandi ngcurrentlawstoachievegreaterecocentrism:theBrazilsectiondiscussesincorporatingIndigenoustraditionsintothe existingWesternframework,whereastheMexicosectiondiscussesextendinghuman rightsframeworkstoincludenature.Additionally,theBrazilsectionincludesaunique caseaboutlegalrightsforaparrot.
Asyoureadthesecasestudies,considerhownewrights-basedmovementsare born.Itmaybethroughthepassageofaninnovativelocallawthatinspiresothergovernmentstofollowsuit.Orperhapsthejudiciary,inadisplayofbraveryandcreativity, issuesadecisionbasedonanewlegaltheory.Inbothcases,grassrootsmovementsare oftentheengine activists,lawyers,civilsocietygroups,andothers fightingagainstthe injusticesofthelegalsystem.Finally,astherightsofnaturemovementsinBraziland Mexicogrow,considerhowanEarthlawyermightguidethemoverthecomingyears toensuretheirsuccess.
PARTI:BRAZIL
II.THEENVIRONMENTINBRAZIL’SCONSTITUTION
BrazilisthelargestcountryinSouthAmerica.Itsharesitsborderswiththemajorityof countriesonthecontinentandboastsanextensiveAtlanticcoastline.Givenitsvariety ofterrainandabundanceofdiversespeciesandhabitat,itisamongtheworld ’ s17 mega-diversecountries. 6 Asofthe2010census,therewereapproximately 900,000IndigenouspeopleinBrazildistributedamong305ethnicgroups.Ofitstotal
6 AmberPariona, HabitatsandEcosystemsofBrazil,WORLDATLAS (Apr.25,2017),https://www.worldatlas.com/ articles/habitats-and-ecosystems-of-brazil.html.
536
Chapter19:EarthLawinLatinAmerica:AGlimpseofBrazilandMexico
area,13.8percentofthelandshavebeenreservedforIndigenouspeoples,themajority ofwhichareconcentratedintheAmazon.7
ThecurrentFederalConstitutionoftheFederativeRepublicofBrazilwaspromulgatedin1988,becomingasymboloftheprocessofnationaldemocratizationasthe countryexited21yearsofmilitarydictatorship.ItdescribesBrazilasalegaldemocratic statefoundedonsovereignty,citizenship,dignityoftheindividual,socialvaluesofwork andoffreeenterprise,andpoliticalpluralism.
A.EcologicallyBalancedEnvironment
Brazil’sConstitutionexplicitlyrecognizestheimportanceofanecologicallybalanced environment.However,thevalueofnatureisjusti fiedsolelyinanthropocentricterms foritsbene fi ttohumans.TheConstitutionalsogivesspecialsafeguardstothecountry ’ sIndigenouspeoples,whichallowsspaceforthedevelopmentofanecocentric approachtolawbysupportingtraditionalIndigenouspracticesthatareinharmony withnaturalsystems.Withthisintrodu ction,wenowlookatsomeofthespeci fi c provisions.
TitleVIIIoftheBrazilianConstitutionaddresses “TheSocialOrder” andincludes ChapterVIontheenvironmentandChapterVIIIon “ Indians, ” asthechaptercalls Indigenouspeoples.Brazil’ sConstitutionrefl ectsmanyprogressivevalues.However, unliketheConstitutionofEcuador,theBrazilianConstitutiondoesnotrecognize natureasasubjectofrightswithlegalstandingofitsown.Instead,carefortheenvironmentisjusti fiedintermsofthebene fitstohumans.ConsiderArticle225,whichestablishesastrongecologicalfoundationbutsimultaneouslytreatstheenvironmentasan “assetofcommonuse” :
Allhavetherighttoanecologicallybalancedenvironment,whichisanassetofcommon useandessentialtoahealthyqualityoflife,andboththeGovernmentandthecommunityshallhavethedutytodefendandpreserveitforpresentandfuturegenerations.8
STUDYQUESTION
Althoughseeminglyanthropocentric,howmightonearguethat fi rstwordofArticle 225, “all,” appliestotheentireEarthcommunity,notonlyhumans?Orthatprotections for “futuregenerations” mightincludenonhumans?Whatopposingargumentsmight bemade?
7 MARÍADE LOURDES BELDIDE ALCÁNTARA,BRAZIL, IN THE INDIGENOUS WORLD 135. 8 CF88atart.225.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Article225,para.1establishesspeci ficgovernmentdutiesintendedtoensuretheeffectivenessoftherighttoanecologically balancedenvironment,includingthe following:
• To “preserveandrestoretheessentialecologicalprocessesandprovideforthe ecologicaltreatmentofspeciesandecosystems” ;
• To “promoteenvironmentaleducationinallschoollevelsandpublicawareness oftheneedtopreservetheenvironment”;and
• To “protectthefaunaandthe flora,withprohibition,inthemannerprescribed bylaw,ofallpracticeswhichrepresentarisktotheirecologicalfunction,cause theextinctionofspecies,orsubjectanimalstocruelty.”9
Article225,para.2requiresthosewhoexploitmineralresourcestorestoreenvironmentaldegradation,andpara.3requiresthosewhoconductproceduresandactivitiesconsideredharmfultotheenvironmenttorepairthedamagescaused.10
Article225,para.4addsadditionalprotectionsforspeci ficallynamedecosystems, althoughcriticshavecalledtheseprotections “merelysymbolic.”11 Thewordingdoes notprohibitextractivismandhasevenbeenconstruedtoencourageit:
TheBrazilianAmazonianForest,theAtlan ticForest,theSerradoMar,thePantanal Matogrossenseandthecoastalzonearepartofthenationalpatrimony12,andtheyshall beused,asprovidedbylaw,underconditionswhichensurethepreservationoftheenvironment,thereinincludingtheuseofmineralresources.13
B.IndigenousRights
IndigenouspeoplesareprominentinBrazil,particularlyintheBrazilianAmazon, wheretheyconstitute23percentofthepopulation.14 Brazil ’sConstitutionaffordscertainrightstoIndigenouspeoplesin ChapterVIII,Articles231-232on “ Indians. ” As exploredindetailinChapter25, “IndigenousLegalities, ” andthroughoutthisbook, empoweringIndigenouscultures ’ careforecologicalbalanceisimportantforEarth lawdevelopment.
Article231establishesthat “Indiansshallhavetheirsocialorganization,customs, languages,creeds,andtraditionsrecognized,aswellastheoriginalrightstothelands
9 Id.at¶1.
10 Id. at¶¶2-3,Sect.I,VI,VIII.
11 AndreaSteuerZago&LionelPimentelNobre, TheBrazilianCitizenConstitution,theEnvironmentandTaxation, 20LOYOLAOF LOS ANGELES INTL.&COMP.L.REV.507,519(1998).
12 Thepreservationofculturalandhistorical “patrimony” istypicallyreferredto “heritage” inEnglish.Collins, JohnF. “HistoricalandCulturalPatrimonyinBrazil:RecentWorkinPortuguese. ” LatinAmericanResearch Review 44,no.1(2009):291-301.www.jstor.org/stable/20488182.
13 CF88,Art.225,¶4.
14 ShannonSimms, TheLandBattleBehindtheFiresintheAmazon,THE ATLANTIC (Aug.27,2019).
Chapter19:EarthLawinLatinAmerica:AGlimpseofBrazilandMexico
theytraditionallyoccupy.”15 ItalsorecognizestheinexorablelinkbetweenIndigenous peoplesandtheland: “LandstraditionallyoccupiedbyIndiansare thoseindispensabletothepreservationofenvironmentalresourcesnecessaryfortheirwell-beingand fortheirphysicalandculturalreproduction,accordingtotheiruses,customsandtraditions.”16 Moreover,itvoidsactsthatattempttoexercisedominionandrightsoverthe Indigenouslandsortoexploitthem.
However,Article231,para.6alsocreatesloopholesthatcoulddepriveIndigenous peoplesoftheirlandwherethereisa “relevantpublicinterest” :
Actswithaviewtooccupation,domainandpossessionofthelandsreferredtointhis articleortotheexploitationofthenatural richesofthesoil,riversandlakesexisting therein,arenullandvoid,producingnolegaleffects, exceptincaseofrelevantpublicinterestoftheUnion,asprovidedbyasupplementarylawandsuchnullityandvoidnessshall notcreatearighttoindemnityortosuetheUnion,exceptinwhatconcernsimprovementsderivedfromoccupationingoodfaith,inthemannerprescribedbylaw.17
ThenextsectionexploreshowtheIndigenousrightsandtheenvironmenthave faredunderthestronglypro-developmentadministrationofPresidentJairBolsonaro.
III.DEVELOPMENTSINBRAZILUNDERBOLSONARO
WhileBrazil’sConstitutionopensupthepossibilityofanecocentricapproachtolaw, therehasbeenonlylimitedsuccessinpractice.Insteadofimplementingconstitutional protectionsfortheenvironment,somenat ionallegislationhasdonetheopposite suchasa2012lawthatweakenedforestconservationunderBrazil ’ s1965Forest Code.18 Manyotherenvironmentalinitiativescontinuetoprioritizeeconomicdevelopmentoverhumanandenvironmentalw ell-being.Forexample,Brazil ’ s2007energy infrastructureplan,establishedwithscantpublicinput,prioritizesdamconstruction intheAmazonwithoutfullyconsideringenvironmentalandsocialimpacts,amongst othershortcomings.19
TheattackontheenvironmentandIndigenousrightshasintensifiedsincePresidentJairBolsonarocametopowerin2019.Forexample,inhis firstyearofof fice,he issuedadecreetotransferauthoritytoprotectIndigenousterritorytotheMinistryof Agriculture, “whichiswellknowntodefendtheinterestsofbusinessesthatwantaccess topreviouslyrestrictedandprotectedIndigenouslands.”20 Bolsonaroalsosupportsthe transformationoftheAmazonrainforestintolandforcattleandcrops.WiththeindustryempoweredbyBolsonaro ’ srhetorictodestroyrainforestsforquickpro fi t, “ the
15 Id.atArt.231.
16 Id.atArt.231,¶1.
17 Id.atArt.231,¶6(emphasisadded).
18 Editorial, Don’tBypassBrazil’sEnvironmentalProtection,539NATURE 139(2016).
19 Editorial, supra note13.
20 IndigenousPeoplesinBrazil,InternationalWorkGroupforIndigenousAffairs(IWGIA),https://www.iwgia. org/en/brazil(lastvisitedFeb.15,2020).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Amazoniscompletelylawless,” saidCarlosNobre,aclimatescientistattheUniversity ofSãoPaulo.21
Inanotherefforttocircumventconstit utionalprotections,onMarch4,2019, AdmiralBentoAlbuquerque,thenewministerofMinesandEnergy,announcedplans topermitminingonIndigenousland,evenwithouttheapprovalofimpactedcommunities.HesaidtherestrictedIndigenousareas “havebecomecentersofcon fl ictand illegalactivities,thatinnowaycontributetosustainabledevelopmentortosovereignty andnationalsecurity.”22
PeopleandecosystemsbothsufferasaresultofBrazil'sbackslidingonIndigenous rights.ChiefAntoniaMellooftheMundurukupeopledescribedhow “theactionsof theBraziliangovernment[are]allowingtheassassinationof[our]community ’ sway oflife,awayoflifethathadlivedinharmonywithMotherEarthforhundredsof years. ”23
ManyIndigenousgroupsare fightingback.EvenbeforeBolsonaroassumedoffice, theAssociationofIndigenousPeoplesofBrazil(APIB)24 releasedaletterstating, “We donotacceptbeingtreatedasinferiorbeings. ::: Weareonlydifferent,anditisthe FederalGovernment’sobligation,accordingtotheConstitution,torespectour ‘social organization,customs,languages,beliefsandtraditions. ’” 25 Inearly2020,theAPIB suedBolsonaroformakingracistcomments.Bolsonarohadsaid, “ TheIndianhas changed,heisevolvingandbecomingmoreandmore,ahumanbeinglikeus.”26 Previously,Bolsonarohadcharac terizedIndigenouspeoplesas “ animalsinzoos ” who needtobeassimilatedintoBraziliansociety.SomeIndigenousleadersevenbelieve heisplanningethnocidebyeliminatingtheirculturesandexistence.27
Bolsonarohasalsoweakenedpublicpar ticipationingovernance.Through nationalcouncilsandconferences,civilsocietyhaslonghelpedformulatepublicpolicy.OnApril12,2019,Bolsonarosignedad ecreeextinguishingnationalcouncils, committees,andcommissionscreatedbydecreesofpreviouspresidentsandlimited thecreationofnewones.28 Amongthenationalcouncilstargetedwerethoseaiming toupholdracialequality,sustainablerur aldevelopment,andbiodiversity.OnJune 12,2019,Brazil ’ sSupremeCourtissuedaninjunctionblockingpartsofthedecree, fi ndingthatBolsonarocannotabolishbodiessupportedbylawandcreatedthrough thedeliberationsoftheNationalCongress.29
21 MattSandy, ‘TheAmazonisCompletelyLawless’:TheRainforestAfterBolsonaro’sFirstYear,THE N.Y.TIMES (Dec.5, 2019).
22 SueBranford&MaurícioTorres, Brazil’sBolsonaroGovernmentWantstoCircumventtheConstitutiontoAllow MiningonIndigenousLands,PACIFIC STANDARD (March15,2019).
23 GlobalAlliancefortheRightsofNature, ThirdInternationalRightsofNatureTribunal-Paris ,https:// therightsofnature.org/rights-of-nature-tribunal-paris(lastvisitedJan.31,2020).
24 “ArticulaçãodosPovosIndígenasdoBrasil” inSpanish.
25 PovosIndígenasaBolsonaro: “NãoAdmitimosserTratadoscomoSeresInferiores,” BRASILDE FATO (Dec.6,2018).
26 AnthonyBoadle, Brazil’sIndigenoustoSueBolsonaroforSayingThey’reEvolving,REUTERS (Jan.24,2020).
27 Id
28 Decree9.759EndingNationalCouncils& SocialParticipationPolicyinBrazil ,P ARTICIPEDIA (2019),https:// participedia.net/case/5832.
29 RicardoDellaColetta&FláviaFaria, BolsonaroSuffersFirstSupremeCourtDefeat,FOLHADE S.PAULO (June13, 2019).
Chapter19:EarthLawinLatinAmerica:AGlimpseofBrazilandMexico
Together,theseactionsbyBolsonarosignifyadisregardforenvironmentaland IndigenousrightsinBrazil.AswiththeUn itedStatesundertheTrumpAdministration,theauthorityofBolsonarotosigni fi cantlyweakenenvironmentalprotections underscorestheneedforanenforceablesystemof inalienable rightsforEarthandits inhabitants.Suchrightscoulddevelopinthecourts,asthenextsectionexplores.
IV.ECOCENTRISMINBRAZILIANCOURTS
Thissectionexploresarecentcasethatextendedrightstoanonhumananimal.Asyou considertheBraziliancourt ’ sapproach,recallthereasoninginthedecisionsbythe NewYorkcourtsdiscussedinChapter11, “NonhumanRights.”
Inthe2019case InreIBAMA,theSuperiorCourtofJustice(STJ)30 recognizedthe rightsofanonhumananimalbasedontheprincipleofindividualdignityfoundinthe BrazilianConstitution.Thecaseinvolvedthecapture,confinement,andmistreatment ofanativeparrot. 31 TheCourtfoundthattheparrot ’ slivingconditionswerenot acceptable,butinsteadofmerelyconfiscatingtheparrottobehousedelsewhere,the Courtdeliberatedontherightsoftheparrotandwhatwouldbeinitsownbest interest.
AlthoughtheCourtcouldhavedecidedtoreleasetheparrotintoitsnaturalhabitatortoaqualifiedzoo,itultimatelyfoundthatthebird,havingliveddomesticallywith theIbamafamilyforovertwodecades,wouldbestremainintheircustodyandcare.To separatetheparrotfromitscaregiverwouldbreakacertain “affectivebond ” inviolationof “ theecologicaldimensionofhumandig nity,sincethemultiplechangesin theenvironmentperpetuatethestressoftheanimal,puttingindoubtthefeasibility ofareadaptationtoanewenvironment.”32
Toarriveatthisdecision,theCourtlookedtoArticle225,SectionVIIoftheConstitution,whichobligatesthegovernmentto “protectthefaunaandthe flora,prohibiting allpracticesthatjeopardizetheireco logicalfunctions,causeextinctionof species,orsubjectanimalstocruelty. ”33 Themeaningfulcontributiontothebodyof Earthlawrecognizestheinherentdignityandneedsoftheparrotasanindividual muchthesameastheywouldconsidertheuniqueneedsofachildinacustodycase. TheCourtalsorecognizedtheempathici nterspeciesbondbet weentheparrotand thefamily.AsexploredindetailinChapter11,legalrecognitionofthedignityofeven asinglememberofanonhumananimalspeciesopenstheopportunitytoextendthat
30 “SuperiorTribunaldeJustiça” inSpanish.
31 InreIBAMA RExt.1.797.175-SP,2.STJ,em21.03.2019,http:// files.harmonywithnatureun.org/uploads/ upload820.pdf.
32 Id.at8.TheCourtmadeclearthatthisdecisiontopermittheoriginalinfractionofkeepingawildbirddid notestablishanyprecedenttoincentivizeorallowthecaptureandretentionofwildanimalsasapractice.
33 CF88,Art.225,¶4.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
soundrationaletoprotecttheentirenaturalworld. InreIBAMA providesafootholdto justifyuniversalrecognitionoftherightsofnatureinBrazil.34
InreIBAMA(2019)
SuperiorCourtofJusticeREsp1.797.175/SP
DECISION
Fromtheecologicalperspectiveofth eprincipleofhumandignityandthe recognitionofnon-humananimalsassubjectsoflaw.
Inthiscontext,oneshouldre fl ectontheKantian,anthropocentricand individualisticconceptofhumandignity,thatis,tofocusalsoonnon-human animalsaswellasallformsoflifeingeneral,inthelightofthebiocentric jurisphilosophical[thephilosophyoflaw]matrix(orecocentric),capableof recognizingtheweboflifethatpermeatestherelationshipbetweenhuman beingsandnature. :::
Inotherwords,onecanalsospeakoflimitationsonthefundamental rightsofhumanbeingsbasedontherecognitionofnon-humaninterests. :::
Thus,anyprohibitionagainstthepracticeof “objecti fication ” shouldnot, inprinciple,belimitedonlytohumanlife,butmusthaveitsbroadspectrum toalsocontemplateotherlifeforms. :::
Theveryideaofnon-crueltreatmentofanimalsmustnolongerbe groundedinhumandignityorhumancompassion,butratherintheverydignityinherentintheexistenceofnonhumananimals.Itisaquestionofmoral duty.
Thisviewofnatureasanexpressionoflifeinitsentiretyenablesconstitutionallawandotherareasoflawtor ecognizetheenvironmentandnonhumananimalsasbeingsoftheirownvalueandthereforetodeservethe respectandcarethatthelegalsystemmayattributetothemashavingownershipofrightsanddignity.
Infact,whatwemustrethinkanddiscussisthatthesenonhumanliving beingsarenolongerjustmeansthatguaranteetohumanspeciestheirown dignityandsurvival.
InthereasoningdefendedbyOliveira(2016),35 natureisnotsomething apartfromthehumanspecies,andtherestofthebeingsoftheplanetary
34 GermanadeOliveiraMoraes, DireitosdosAnimaisedaNaturezaLevadosaSério:ComentáriosSobreoJulgamento doSuperiorTribunaldeJustiçadoBrasil(RecursoEspecial1.797.175-SP),39RevistadoProgramadePós-Graduação emDireitodaUFC173(2018).
35 VANESSA HASSONDE OLIVEIRA,RIGHTSOF NATURE 115(2016)(footnoteadded).
Chapter19:EarthLawinLatinAmerica:AGlimpseofBrazilandMexico
community,aswellashumanbeings,arenatureitselfinitsuniversalityand diversity.
Itisnecessarytorethinkanewrationality,distinctfromthelogichegemonicallytracedandreproducedwithinordinaryinstances,thatappreciates demands,includingthisonewhichisthesubjectofdiscussioninthisSuperior Court,sothattheStateandSocietycanthinkinaradicallydifferentwayfrom thealreadyestablishedlegalstandards.
Moreover,withthisreflectionasastartingpoint,itisnotdif ficulttoconcludethattherelationshiptobeestablishedbetweenthehumanbeingand natureismuchmoreaninterrelationmarkedbyinterdependencethanarelationshipofdominationofthehumanbeingovertherestofthebeingsofthe planetarycommunity.
Therefore,itisnecessarytore fl ectontheinternal fi eldofinfraconstitutionallaws,inanattempttopointoutwaystoripenthediscussion abouttherecognitionofdignityofnonhumananimalsand,consequently,of therecognitionofrightsandtomaketheshiftsothatpeoplecanrelateto eachotherandtotherestoflivingthings.36
Asyoujustread, InreIBAMA hadamuchbroaderapplicationthanasingleparrot. TheCourtarguedfortheneedtochangetheanthropocentricparadigmtoabiocentricone regardlessoftheanthropocentricnatureofBrazil’sConstitution.Citingthis caseincourtsintheUnitedStatesandot hernationswillinformjudgesofnew approachestoecocentriclaw,acriticalr esponsibilityofEarthlawpractitioners. Whetheritisconsideredapersuasiveauthoritywilldependonthejudge.
V.LOCALRIGHTSOFNATUREINITIATIVESINBRAZIL
Therehasbeenagrowingmovementsince2015torecognizenatureasasubjectof rightsatthelocallevelinBrazil.AsintheUnitedStates,oneoftheprimarymotivationsisthebeliefthatBrazil’snationalframeworkisinadequatetoprotectnature.
ConsideringthatcurrentenvironmentallawshavebeenfailingtoadequatelyprotectBrazilianecosystems,therehavebeenseveralgrassrootsmovementstorecognize natureasasubjectofrights.ThestorybeginswiththecitycouncilofSãoPaulo’ sconsiderationofadraftbill37 toamenditsOrganicLaw(equivalenttoalocalconstitution) toreadasfollows:
TheMunicipalitywillpromotethedevelopmentofenvironmentalpolicies,considering thatmembersofnaturepossessintrinsicrightstolifeandmaintenanceoftheirecosystemsininterdependencewiththedignifi edlifeofcitizens,inordertoachievesustainabilityinthecity.
36 InreIBAMA at4-5(citationomitted).
37 ProjetodeEmendaàLeiOrgânica04-00005/2015ofcouncilorEduardoTuma(PSDB),CâmaraMunicipaldeSão Paulo.
Theexplanatoryreportforthedraftbillstatedthat “theissueoftherecognitionof therightsofnatureisintrinsicallydependentonanewapproachtotheconceptofsustainabledevelopment ” andhighlightsthe “ needforarealparadigmshift. ” 38 Italso statedthat “BrazilhasapproachedthisunderstandingwithdiscussionsaboutEnvironmentalServiceswhichgofarbeyonddefendingnature’seconomicvaluesandendup exposingitspriceless,intangiblevalue,eveninrelationtohumanbeings.” Humanity, thedraftbillconcluded,hasaduty “topreservelifeworthyofandontheplanet.”
The2015draftbilldidnotpass.Butadvocatestriedonceagain,andin2017the citycouncilofSãoPaulosuccessfullyamendedArticle180-AoftheOrganicLawof theMunicipalitytorecognizenatureashaving “ full,intrinsicandperpetualrights, inherentinitsexistenceontheplanet.”39 Thebillalsocallsuponthegovernmentto promotepolicies,managementtools,andpartnershipstopreserveandrestoreBrazil’ s environmentandfosterharmonywithnature,includingbyaddressingclimatechange. Finally,thebillestablishesthatanyactionstakenthatwouldaffectnature “shouldbe supportedbyScience;observethePrecautionaryPrinciple;andseektoinvolvetheLegislativeandJudiciary,theStateandtheUnion,theothermunicipalitiesofthe MetropolitanRegionandcivilsocietyentitiesingeneral.”
OnMay16,2018,anotherlegalproposalfortherightsofnaturewaspresentedin SãoPaulo,thistimetotheSãoPauloCommissionofLegality. 40 Thedraftbill,which hasnotyetbeenapprovedatthetimeofthisbook’ spublication, “receivedapositive evaluationfromthemaincommissionand isexpectedtogainfurthersupportfor futureimplementationwithinthelegalsystem.”41
OthermunicipalitiesbesidesSãoPaulo havealsoembracedtherightsofnature. ThemunicipalityofBonitointhestateofPernambucopassedanamendmenttoits OrganicLawin2017thatadoptstherightsofnatureinArticle236:
TheMunicipalityrecognizestherightofnaturetoexist,thriveandevolve,andshould actinordertoassureallmembersofthenaturalcommunity,humanandnon-human, oftheMunicipalityofBonito,therighttoanecologicallyhealthyandbalancedenvironmentandtothemaintenanceofecosystemicprocessesnecessarytogoodqualityoflife, beingthePublicPower,aswellasthecollectivity,inchargeofdefendingandpreserving itforthepresentandfuturegenerationsofthemembersoftheearthcommunity. In ordertoensurethisright,theMunicipalityshallpromotetheamplificationofitspublic policiesinenvironmental,health,educationalandeconomicareassoastoprovideconditionsfortheestablishmentofalifeinharmonywithNature,anditshallarticulatewith otherstates,regionalandfederalcompetentbodies,aswellaswithothermunicipalities, ifitisthecase,inordertosolvecommonproblemsrelatedtotheprotectionofNature.42
Oneyearlater,themunicipalityofPaudalhointhestateofPernambucoalso amendeditsOrganicLawtorecognizerightsofnature,usingwordingalmostidentical
38 Justificativa-PLO0005/2015,CâmaraMunicipaldeSãoPaulo.
39 ProjetodeEmendaàLeiOrgânica04-00005/2017ofcouncilorNatalini(PV),CâmaraMunicipaldeSãoPaulo.
40 PLO-ProjetodeEmendaLeiOrganica7/2018de16/05/2018,CâmaraMunicipaldeSãoPaulo.
41 UNHarmonywithNatureInitiative, RightsofNatureLaw,PolicyandEducation,http://www.harmonywithnatureun. org/rightsOfNaturePolicies(lastvisitedJan.31,2020).
42 EmendaàLeiOrgânicaNo01/2017,CâmaraMunicipiodeBonito.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw 544
Chapter19:EarthLawinLatinAmerica:AGlimpseofBrazilandMexico
toBonito.Thechangeaimedtoensurethatpublicpoliciesalignwiththe “establishmentofalifeinharmonywithNature.”43 AsaresultoftheamendmenttotheOrganic Law,theSanSeverinoRamosNaturalWaterSpringwasgrantedrightstoexist,thrive, andevolveinaccordancewiththelaw’srightsofnatureprovisions the firstspeci fic ecosystemtobegrantedrightsinBrazil.
Finally,onMarch28,2018,themunicipalityofFortalezaproposedadraftbillto amenditsOrganicLawinordertograntrecognitiontotherightsofnature.Itstates: “AllbeingsofNaturehavetherighttoanecologicallybalancedenvironment,[which is]agoodforcommonuseforthepeopleandessentialtoahealthyqualityoflife andtonaturalecosystemicprocesses. ” 44 Thislawisstillpendingasofthetimeof publication.
Thesedevelopmentsareallrecent.Itremainstobeseenhowtheselawswill impactlocalenvironmentalprotectionsinpracticeandwhethertheywillsparksystemicchangethroughoutBrazil.However,theexistenceofthemovementinBrazilis itselfmeaningfulandislikelytoleadtot hedevelopmentofmoreecocentriclawin thenearfuture.
VI.BRAZIL’SINDIGENOUSPEOPLEJOINTOSHOWAPATH FORWARD
In2017,twomajorenvironmentalgatheringsinBrazilsetastrongfoundationforthe futureofEarthlaw.Indigenouspeoplesplayedamajorroleineach.The fi rstevent wasalargeenvironmentalforumthatproduceda “ LettertoNature ” de fi ningtheir rightsofnaturevision.ThesecondwastheGreatAssemblyoftheAllianceofMother Nature’sGuardians.
First,inJuly2017,participantsoftheBrazilEnvironmentalManagementForum includingtheMinistryoftheEnvironment,Indigenousleaders,civilsocietyrepresentatives,andothers45 adopteda “LetterforNature,” entitled TheRightsofNatureand PublicPoliciesinCities.Theletter-writingprocesswasledbyVanessaHasson,aBrazilian lawyer,civilsocietyleader,andrightsofnatureadvocate.46 Theletterwasalsoheavily in fl uencedbyIndigenousleadersfromtheUniversityofAncientWisdom,theAcunhanheInstitute,andtheShawādawacommunity.
TheLetterforNatureinvitedforumparticipantstorecognizetheinherentrights ofnatureandre fl ectupontheirresponsibilitytostrengthenpublicpoliciesthatharmonizewithnature.TheLetterforNaturealsowarnsthatcurrentpoliciesand
43 EmendaàLeiOrgânicaNo03,de5Janeirode2018,CâmaraMunicipaldePaudalho.
44 EmendaModificativaNo.0011/2018aoProjetodeEmendaàLeiOrgânicaMunicipalNo09/2017,CâmaraMunicipaldeFortaleza,Article244.
45 Brazil’ sPublicAdministratorsSignfortheRightsofNature,WorldConsciousPact(Sept.18,2017),https:// worldconsciouspact.org/rights-of-nature/brazils-public-administrators-sign-for-the-rights-of-nature/.
46 VanessaHassonisthefounderofMethodsofSupportingEnvironmentalandSocialPractices(MAPAS).
legislationareinsuf ficienttoaddresstheglobalclimateemergency,whichmayresult in “catastrophicruptures,riskingfunctionsessentialtothemaintenanceandreproductionoflife,includinghumanlife.” Asasolution,theLetterforNaturehighlightsthe rightsofnatureandalsoencouragessocietytoreturntotraditional,Indigenous,naturalknowledgethatemphasizestheconnectionsbetweennatureandhumans.
InaccordancewiththeBrazilConstitution’ smandatetopromoteenvironmental education,theLetterforNaturealsoencouragestheexpansionofrightsofnature:
14.Formaleducationateverylevelshouldbeorientedaccordingtothebasicprinciples oftheRightsofNatureandofawayoflifeinharmonywithNature;multi/interdisciplinarytheoreticalandmethodologicalapproachesshouldbeincludedinteachingcurriculumandresearchmethodologydisciplines inbothprimaryandsecondaryeducation andatundergraduateandpostgraduatelevels.47
Finally,toputthesepreceptsintoaction,forumparticipantspromisedto “undertaketheirbesteffortsfortheinaugurationorexpansionofpublicpreservationpolicies oftheenvironment.” Sucheffortsshouldfollowtheprincipleofharmonywithnature, “consideringtheintrinsicvalueofeachofthemembersthatconstitutetheEarth. ” As participantsintheforumrecognized,harmonywithnaturedoesnotmeanacomplete reversiontopre-industrialconditions,butitdoessupportthevalueofancienthuman knowledge.
Buildinguponthiseffort,inOctober2017,the fi rst-everGreatAssemblyofthe AllianceofMotherNature ’ sGuardianswasheldinBrasíliaandattendedbynearly 200Indigenousrepresentativesfromaroundtheworld.Together,thedelegatesdiscussedrightsofnatureparadigmsandoth erglobalissuesimpactinghumanrights andtheenvironment.48
Priortothisevent,theConstituentAsse mblyoftheAllianceofMotherNature ’ s GuardianswasheldinParisandresultedintheadoptionoftheDeclarationofthe AllianceofGuardiansandChildrenofMotherEarth.Thedeclarationstated: “Wemust evolvetowardsaparadigmbasedonIndigenousthoughtandphilosophy,whichgrants equalrightstoNatureandwhichhonorstheinterrelationshipsbetweenalllifeforms andthepreservationofMotherEarth.”49
Inconclusion,Brazilisadvancingnu merouspromisingecocentriclegal paradigms throughthecourts,locallawmaking,andmulti-stakeholdergatherings. Butsimultaneously,thecurrentgovernmentisattemptingtocircumventlawsandoverturnpoliciesinordertoprioritizeincessantextractionanddevelopmentofecosystems, injurioustoIndigenouspeoplesandothers.50 Now,wewillcomparethisdynamicwith rights-basedmovementsinMexico.
47 Id.
48 GlobalAlliancefortheRightsofNature, FirstGreatInternationalAssemblyoftheAllianceofMotherNature’ s Guardians (Sept.29,2017).
49 AllianceofGuardiansofMotherNature ,TheDeclarationoftheAllianceofGuardiansandChildrenofMother Earth
50 HertonEscobar, Brazil’sDeforestationIsExploding–and2020WillBeWorse,SCIENCE (Nov.22,2019),https:// www.sciencemag.org/news/2019/11/brazil-s-deforestation-exploding-and-2020-will-be-worse.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw 546
Chapter19:EarthLawinLatinAmerica:AGlimpseofBrazilandMexico
PARTII:MEXICO
VII.INTRODUCTIONTOMEXICO
MexicoisthefourthlargestcountryintheAmericas,afterCanada,theUnitedStates, andBrazil.Itisalsocountedamongtheworld’s17mega-diversecountries,havingthe second-largestnumberofecosystemsamongstthem.51 At27.5millionpeople,Mexico’ s IndigenouspopulationisthelargestintheAmericasandmakesup21.5percentofthe country’stotal.52
ThissectionexploresMexico ’ sconstitutionalprotectionsoftheenvironment, Indigenousrights,andtheright sofnature.Overall,whileMexico ’ senvironmental enforcementislacking,ithasalegalandsocietalfoundationforthedevelopmentof Earthlaw.
VIII.ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTIONSINMEXICO
Mexico’sConstitutionexplicitlyrecognizestheimportanceoftheenvironment.However,aswithBrazil,nature’ svalueisviewedfromahumanperspective.Nonetheless, withthe InReIBAMA case,itispossiblethatMexico ’ sconstitutionalenvironmental rightscouldbeextendedtoincluderightsofnatureinthefuture.
Herearesomeofthemostimportante nvironmentalprovisionsinMexico ’ s Constitution:
• Article2(A): GrantingIndigenouspeoplestherighttomaintainandimprove theirenvironment,andthepreferentia luseofnaturalresourceswithinsites theyinhabit;
• Article4,para.V: Establishingtherightof “ anyperson ” toahealthy environment;
• Article25 :Requiringnationaldevelopmenttobesustainable,andtheuseof resourcestobeforthegeneralgoodwhilepreservingtheenvironment;
• Article27 :Allowingthegovernmenttoimposerestrictions,includingonthe useofnaturalresourcesandprivateproperty,thatpreserveandrestore “environmentalbalance;”
• Article73 :EstablishingthepowerofCongresstolegislateinordertocoordinatetheactionsofthethreelevelsofgovernmentinenvironmentalmatters andtodirecttheGeneralBoardofHealthoncombatingenvironmental pollution;
51 AmberPariona, TheWorld’s17Mega-DiverseCountries,WORLDATLAS (July25,2018),https://www.worldatlas. com/articles/ecologically-megadiverse-countries-of-the-world.html.
52 JosédeVal,JuanMarioPérezMartínez&CarolinaSánchezGarcia, Mexico, THE INDIGENOUS WORLD 2019102 (DavidNathanielBergered.,2019).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
• Article115,para.III:Organizingstateswithmunicipalpowersinenvironmental matters,includingcreatingnaturereserves;and
• Article122: GivingspecialcompetencetoMexicoCityinenvironmental matters.53
(AswithBrazil,considerhowtheseconstitutionalprotectionscanbereliedupon todevelopEarthlaw.Forexample,couldanecosystembede fi nedasa “ person ” and thushavearighttoahealthyenvironment?OrcouldtheIndigenousrighttomaintain andimprovetheirenvironmentnecessitatetheirapplicationofecocentriclaws?)
Inadditiontoitsconstitutionalprotections,Mexicohaspassedseveralmajorenvironmentalframeworklaws.(Noteinthebelowexampleshowbothlawsnotonlyprotectbut restore naturewhenitisharmed.)First,theGeneralLawofEcological EquilibriumandEnvironmentalProtection(1988)definestheframeworkforallenvironmentallawsinMexico.Itsoverarchingpurposeisthe “preservation andrestoration oftheecologicalbalance,aswellastheprotectionoftheenvironment. ”54 Second, theFederalLawofEnvironmentalRespo nsibility(2013)buildsupontheGeneral Lawbycreatingastrongapplicationofthe “polluterpaysprinciple.” Itsstatedpurpose is “toregulatetheenvironmentalresponsibilitythatarisesfromthedamagescausedto theenvironment,aswellas therepairandcompensationofsuchdamages. ”55 Thislawalso envisionsthecreationofenvironmentalc ourtsthatareseparatefromothercivil, administrative,andcriminalcourts.
Takingabroaderview,someofthemainprinciplesofMexico ’ senvironmental lawsaresustainabledevelopment,conservation,preservation,andenvironmental restoration.Mexicanlawalsosupportsthepreventionprinciple.However,theprecautionaryprinciple,assertingthatactivitiesshouldbeprohibitedincaseofdoubt,ispracticallyabsentfromMexicanenvironmentallegislation.56
Finally,Mexicohasnumerousagenciesthatworktodefendtheenvironment.The MinistryofEnvironmentandNa tionalResources(SEMARNAT) 57 ismandatedto ensuretheprotection,conservation,anduseofnaturewithanemphasisonsustainable development.Additionally,theFederalOf fi ceofEnvironmentalProtection(PROFEPA) 58 istheinstitutionresponsibleforincreasingcompliancewithenvironmental regulationsandminimizingenvironmentald eterioration.Neitheragencyrepresents theinterestsofnaturedirectly.
53 ComparativeConstitutionsProject, Mexico’sConstitutionof1917withAmendmentsThrough2015 (Fernanda GomezAbantrans.),https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Mexico_2015.pdf?lang=en.
54 GeneralLawofEcologicalEquilibriumandEnvironmentalProtection(LeyGeneraldelEquilibrioEcológicoyla ProtecciónalAmbiente),Art.1(1988).
55 FederalLawofEnvironmentalResponsibility(LeyFederaldeResponsabilidadAmbiental).
56 TaniaGarcíaLópez, LaConstituciónMexicanaylosPrincipiosRectoresdelDerechoAmbiental, IN LA CONSTITUCIÓNY EL MEDIO AMBIENTE 36(EmilioRabasaed.,2007).
57 SecretaríadeMedioAmbienteyRecursosNaturales(SEMARNAT).
58 ProcuraduríaFederaldeProtecciónalAmbiente(PROFEPA).
548
Chapter19:EarthLawinLatinAmerica:AGlimpseofBrazilandMexico
IX.DERIVINGRIGHTSOFNATUREFROMHUMAN ENVIRONMENTALRIGHTS?
Asdiscussedlaterinthischapter,inMexico,thereareahandfulofrecentstateconstitutionalamendmentsestablishingrightsofnature.AnotherwaytodevelopEarthlaw inMexicoisthroughhumanenvironmentalrightsframeworks.
ManypeopleinMexicodonotviewrightsofnatureasbeingtotallyseparatefrom humanrights.Instead,rightsofnatureisseenasupholdinghumanrightsthatrely uponhealthyandfunctioningnaturalsy stems.AccordingtoJoséGilbertoGarza Grimaldo,“[t]hepremisesofhumanrightsconsistinbalancingwhatisgoodforhuman beingsandwhatisgoodforotherspeciesandfortheplanetitself,andtofullyunderstandthemeaningoftheinterdependencebetweenallecosystemsandallthatwe shareforourownsurvival.”59
Article1ofMexico ’ sConstitutionestablishesth efoundationofhumanrights protection:
[A]llindividualsshallbeentitledtotheHumanRightsgrantedbythisConstitutionand theinternationaltreatiessignedbytheMexicanState,aswellastotheguaranteesforthe protectionoftheserights.Suchhumanrightsshallnotberestrictedorsuspended, exceptforthecasesandundertheconditionsestablishedbythisConstitutionitself.60
TheanthropocentricnatureofMexico ’ sConstitutioncansupportthedevelopmentofEarthlawiftherightsofnaturecanbepresentedasaninterdependentmanifestationofhumanrights.TheConstitution,aswellas “internationaltreatiessignedby theMexicanState,” guaranteethesecurityofhumanbeings.Thisincludestheirenvironment,food,andhealthsecurity.Earthlawsthatprotect,stabilize,andrestorethe functionalinterdependencyofecosystemsmaybedevelopedbasedonthehuman rightsembodiedinMexico’sConstitution.
Onceagain,considerhowothernationshaveexpandedtheirconstitutionalprotectionstoincludenature suchasinColombia,wherecourtshaveinferredrights ofnaturefromhumanenvironmentalrights ,culturalrights,andrelatedprinciples (seeChapter18).OrinBrazil,wheretheSuperiorCourtofJusticeappliedanthropocentricconstitutionalprotectionstoasinglenonhumananimal aparrot.
X.INDIGENOUSRIGHTSANDTHEENVIRONMENT
AstartingpointforecocentrisminMexico isthetraditionsofIndigenouscommunities.Pre-HispanicMexicanlaw,whichstillresonatesthroughoutthecurrentlegalsystem,includestherecognitionofadiffere ntattitudetonature,andmanyofthese
59 JoséGilbertoGarzaGrimaldo, LosDerechosdelaNaturalezaysusMediosdeDefensa 137(2015).
60 ComparativeConstitutionsProject, supra note53.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Indigenousprinciplescannowbeemploy edinextendingthelawtoencompassthe rightsofnature.
AccordingtoGarzaGrimaldo: “InMexico,theoriginalculturesaddressedtherelationshipwithnaturethroughreligiousla ws,whereworshipand offeringstonatural forcesandmanifestationswerepartoftheirdailyobligations,therebeingdeitiesfor eachoftheelements,forthesun,forMotherEarth,water,wind,volcanoes,plants andevenanimalsandthecyclesoftimeandlife.”61
LikeBrazil,Mexico’ sConstitutioncarvesoutaspecialstatusforIndigenouspeoplesandupholdstheirlandrights.Articl e2(notableinthatitappearsnearlyatthe beginningoftheConstitution)recognizesthatMexico “ ismulticultural,basedoriginallyonitsIndigenouspeoples,describedasdescendantsofthoseinhabitingthecountrybeforecolonizationandthatpreserve theirownsocial,economic,culturaland politicalinstitutions,orsomeofthem.”62 Inturn,Article2(A)(V)upholdsIndigenous peoples’ righttoself-determinationandautonomy,includingtheirrightto “maintain andimprovetheirenvironmentandlands.”63
State-levelconstitutionsestablishevenstrongerlanguagetoupholdthetraditional culturalpracticesofIndigenouspeoplesandrecognizetheircontributionstoenvironmentalwell-being.TheconstitutionofthestateofCampecheisoneexample.ItguaranteestherightofIndigenouspeoplestos elf-determinationandobligatesthestate governmenttoputtheserightsintopractice.Asyoureadthestate’ sspeci fi cduties, considerhowtheseprinciplessupportEarthlaw:
[TheStateofCampecheshall:]
• [R]espect,preserveandmaintaintheknowledge,innovations,andpracticesof Indigenouscommunitiesthatinvolvetraditionallifestylesrelevanttotheconservation andsustainableuseofbiologicaldiversity.
• [P]romotethewiderapplication,withapproval,andparticipationofthosewhopossesssuchknowledge,innovations,andpractices,andwillencouragethebene fi ts derivedfromtheuseofthatknowledge,innovations,andpracticestobeshared equally. [and]
• Protectandencouragecustomaryuseofbiologicalresourcesinaccordancewithtraditionalculturalpracticesthatarecompatiblewiththerequirementsofconservationor sustainableuse;likewise,naturalresources,sacredplacesandthematerialandintangibleculturalheritageofpeoplesandcommunitiesareprotected,withtheactiveparticipationofcommunities.
One fi nalexampleofIndigenousrightsinM exicoistheNationalInstituteof IndigenousPeoples(inSpanish,InstitutoNacionaldelosPueblosIndígenas,orINPI), acentralizedagencyestablishedin2018thatservesasthefederalauthorityofmatters relatedtoIndigenousandAfro-Mexicanpeoples.Itsdutiesaretocreate,defi ne,execute,andcoordinatepoliciesandprogramstoguaranteeIndigenousandAfroMexicanrights.TheINPIisalsocommittedto “recognizeandrespecttheformalities
61 Grimaldo, supra note59,at143.
62 Mexico’sConstitutionof1917withAmendmentsthrough2015,Art.2.
63 Id. atArt.2(A)(V).
Chapter19:EarthLawinLatinAmerica:AGlimpseofBrazilandMexico
establishedbytheIndigenousnormativesystems,havingthecorrespondinglegal effects. ” 64 IrmaPinedaSantiago,whomtheINPIappointedtorepresentMexico ’ s IndigenouspeoplesattheUnitedNations,statedtheimportanceoflearningfrom Indigenouscommunitiestoprotecttheenvironment:
WhenwelookatIndigenouscommunitiesor wheretheyhavemorecontroloverthe land,theyconservetheenvironmentbetter. Ifthelandisbeingbettercaredfor,it mustmeanthatIndigenouscommunitiesknowhowtodothis.Weneedtolearnfrom theseIndigenouscommunities.65
IndigenouscommunitieshelpadvanceMexico’scollectivewell-beingthroughcustomsandworldviewsthatconsiderthecomprehensiveprotectionofecosystemsand thedeepbondsharedbyalllife.Forexample,MaríaGabrielaGonzálezCruzwrites abouttheIndigenous-inspiredconceptofthe “socio-ecosystem ” asameansoflooking holisticallyattheinterrelationshipbetweenhumansandtherestofnature:
Attheendofthe20thcenturysomeresearchers,severalofthemMexicans,showedthat the fi eldsofecologyandbiodiversityconservationcandevelopnotonlyinprotected areas,butalsoinecosystemsinhabitedbyhumansocieties.Ecologistsandconservation biologistsstartedcommunicatingwithanthropologistsandsociologistsanddeveloped researchthatconsideredecosystemsandgroupsofhumanstogether.Asaresultofthis newvision,theyformulatedaconceptwhichisstillcontroversial:thesocio-ecosystem.
Inthesocio-ecosystem,thehumanbeingsandNatureareinterconnected.Ouractionsas individualsandasasocietyhaverepercussionsonnature.Similarly,naturalsystemsdefine usculturally,andthechangesthatoccurinnaturehaverepercussionsonourlifestyle.
Theconceptofasocio-ecosystemcanbeveryhelpfulforestablishingprotectedareas andmanagingnature.Insomeregionsofourcountry,suchastheYucatánPeninsula, theconceptofasocio-ecosystemhasalreadybeenappliedinprojectstodevelopIndigenousvillagesandtoconservebiodiversity.
Thisconcepthashelpedusrealizethatourwell-beingandthatofnaturegohandin hand,andthatitispossibletogeneratestrategiesthatallowtheintegraldevelopment ofhumangroupswhilewealsoseekthepermanenceofnature.66
IndigenouscommunitiesinMexicoalsosupportthenotionof buenvivir,orgood living,whichisdiscussedindepthinChapter17onEcuador.AccordingtoCarlos Cruz,theoriginalpeoplesofLatinAmerica “[b]elieveingoodliving(buenvivir),not inlivingbetter.Livingbettermeanshavingthebestcellphoneandthebestcar.Tolive goodistoliveholisticallyandnothingelse.”67
64 LeydelInstitutoNacionaldelosPueblosIndígenas(2019).
65 LeighThelmadatter, VoicingtheConcernsofMexico’sIndigenousPeople,IntheirOwnLanguage,MEXICO DAILY NEWS (Mar.4,2020).
66 MaríaGabrielaGonzálezCruz, ElSocioecosistéma,163CÓMOVES 34(2012).
67 AdelaSalinas, ConstructoresdePazenMéxico:Perspectivas,ProcesosyAccionesqueDesarticulanlaViolencia 97 (2019)(interviewwithCarlosCruz).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
BasedonIndigenousrightsprotectionsdiscussedinthissection,theMexicangovernmentmustrespectthenotionof buenvivir andotherIndigenouswaysoflifethat supportnature ’ swell-being.Mexico ’ srecognitionofIndigenousself-determination andlegalpluralismalsosupportstheadvanc ementofecocentricgovernancestructures,includingtherightsofnature.For thisreason,manyadvocatesbelievethat strengtheningIndigenousrightsisparamounttorestoringtheplanettohealth.
XI.ENVIRONMENTALNORMSINSTATECONSTITUTIONS
AllMexicanstatesestablishconstitutionalenvironmentalprotectionsbutwithwidelydifferentapproaches.Most,butnotall,statec onstitutionstakeananthropocentricperspective.Somestateconstitutionsframe theenvironmentasaresourcedemanding humanextraction.Otherstateconstitutio nsconceptsofsustainabledevelopmentin accordancewithinternationalenvironmentalinstruments,suchasthe1992RioDeclaration. 68 Finally,severalstateconstitutionsno wrecognizetherightsofnature.This subsectionexploresafewofthesedifferentmodels.
A.IntroductiontoStateConstitutionalProvisionsontheEnvironment
InmostMexicanstateconstitutions,natureisaddressedthroughthehumanrighttoa healthyenvironment.AnexampleofthisapproachisseeninArticle7oftheconstitutionofthestateofAguascalientes,whichestablishesthat “[e]veryonehastherighttoa healthyenvironmentfortheirdevelopmentandwell-being,aswellasthedutytoprotectandpreserveit.”69 Article8oftheconstitutionofthestateofVeracruzhassimilar language.
Insomecases,theenvironmentisunequi vocallylinkedtostatesocioeconomic development,andnatureistreatedasme relyanexploitablehumanresource.For example,Article9,sectionXXXIoftheconstitutionofthestateofBajaCalifornia Sur,establishesagovernmentobligationto “ [p]romotetheintegraldevelopmentof allnaturalresources,amongothers:mining, fishing;andinaddition,agriculturalactivitiesandtourism.”70
Otherstatesrecognizeaconstitutionaldutytoachievesustainabledevelopment. Forexample,Article18,sectionVIIIoftheconstitutionofthestateofTamaulipassays thatallpeoplehaveanobligation “[to]respectandcareforthenaturalheritageofthe Stateandtomakeuseofthenaturalresourcessusceptibletoappropriation without affectingthesustainabledevelopmentoftheState inthetermsprovidedbythelaws.”71
68 The1992RioDeclarationrecognizedthathumanbeingsare “entitledtoahealthyandproductivelifein harmonywithnature” (Principle1).
69 ConstitutionoftheStateofAguascalientes(ConstituciónPolíticaDelEstadoDeAguascalientes),art.7o(2018).
70 PoliticalConstitutionofTheFreeandSovereignStatefromBajaCaliforniaSur(ConstituciónPolíticadel EstadoLibreySoberanodeBajaCaliforniaSur),Art.9,Sect.XXXI(2008).
71 ConstituciónPolíticadelEstadodeTamaulipas,Art.18,Sect.8(2019)(emphasisadded).
552
Chapter19:EarthLawinLatinAmerica:AGlimpseofBrazilandMexico
Whilemanyofthesestateconstitutionshavebeeneffectiveatestablishingatleast baselineprotectionsfortheenvironment,theanthropocentricperspectiveinhibits thedevelopmentofEarthlaw.However,asdiscussedinthenextsection,severalstates havetakentheadditionalstepofexplicitlyrecognizingtherightsofnature.
B.RightsofNatureinColima,Guerrero,andMexicoCity
ThissectionanalyzesseveralrightsofnaturelawsinMexico.Currently,theconstitutionalsystemsofGuerrero,MexicoCity,andColimaallrecognizenatureasacollective entitythatissubjecttorightswithitsownlegalpersonality.Alloftheselocationshave alsorecognizedadeepinterdependencybetweenrightsofnatureandhumanrights. AsnotedbyMaríaValeriaBerros, “In[thestateofGuerreroandMexicoCity],legal recognitionofthehumanrighttoahealthy environmentcoexistswiththisexplicit enlargementofnaturerights.”72
Whilerecognizingrightsofnatureinlawisavaluablefoundation,institutionsand governmentsmustupholdtheminpractice.
1.Guerrero
OnApril1,2014,thestatecongressofGue rreroapprovedcomprehensiveconstitutionalreformthatrecognized, interalia ,therightsofnature.TheproposalwaspresentedanddefendedbythedeputiesArtur oÁlvarezAngliandAlejandroCarabias Icaza.Itspassagefollowedaseminaronthefutureoftherightsofnatureandhumans inMexico,heldattheAutonomousUniversityofGuerrero,inwhichover20keynote speakersdiscussedtheneedforfundamentalreformtoaddressagrowingecological andmoralcrisis.
Article2ofGuerrero’sconstitutioncontemplatestherightsofnaturebystatingthe following:
IntheStateofGuerrero,dignityisthebasisofthehuman,individualandcollective rightsoftheperson.Thehighervaluesofthelegal,politicalandsocialorderarefreedom,equality,socialjustice,solidarity,democraticandideologicalpluralism,secularism, respectfordiversityandrespectforlifeinallitsmanifestations. ::: theStateundertakes toprotecttherightsofnatureinaccordancewiththerespectivelaw.73
NoticethatthewordingofArticle2recogn izesbothprinciplesofhumanrightsand therightsofnature.Thisisimportantbecausethereisnoperceivedconfl ictbetween theserights tothecontrary,theycomplementeachother.Ifnature’srightsareseen assupportinghumanrights,theyaremorelikelytoberecognizedfederally.
72 MaríaValeriaBerros, RightsofNatureintheAnthropocene:TowardstheDemocratizationofEnvironmentalLaw? CHARTING ENVIRONMENTAL LAW FUTURESINTHE ANTHROPOCENE 26(MichelleLimed.,2019).
73 ConstituciónPolíticadelEstadoLibreySoberanodeGuerrero(2016),http://files.harmonywithnatureun. org/uploads/upload665.pdf.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
2.MexicoCity
OnJanuary11,2017,MexicoCity(whichisnowarecognizedstate74)adoptedrightsof natureintoitsnewconstitution. 75 TheconstitutionalamendmentfollowedtheFirst InternationalForumfortheRightsofMotherEarthheldinMexicoCityonJune1–5, 2016.Theforumwas “ centeredaroundtheimportanceoflegislatingtheRightsof MotherEarth ” andworkedtowardsupportingandimplementingrightsofnaturein MexicoCity.
Article13ofthenewconstitutionestablishesthatnature,withallofitsecosystems andspecies,isacollectivebodythatisthesubjectofrights.Thoserightsinclude “the righttothepreservationandprotection, ” whicharetobeguaranteedbytheauthoritiesofMexicoCity.Article13alsorequiresthatasecondarylawshallbepassed “torecognizeandregulatethepr otectionoftherightsofnature,asformedbyallits ecosystemsandspeciesasacollectiveentitywithcollectiverights.” Thissecondarylaw hasnotyetbeendeveloped.Finally,theconstitutionassertsthatcitizensofMexicoCity willbeabletoenforcenature’srights.
3.Colima
InJune2019,thecongressofthestateofC olimaapprovedastat econstitutional amendmentrecognizingtherightsofnature.TheinitiativewaspresentedbyCongresswomanBlancaLivierRodríguezOsorio,whoisalsopresidentoftheCommissionfor EnvironmentalProtection.
Theconstitutionalamendmentestablishesthatnature,includingallecosystems andspecies,isacollectiveentitywithfundamentalrights.Nature’srightsincludethe rightstoexist,torestoration,toregenerationofitsnaturalcycles,andtoconservation ofitsecologicalstructureandfunctions.T heconstitutionalamendmentalsoestablishesthattheprotection,preservation,andrecoveryofbiodiversity,naturalecosystems,geneticheritage,andnativespecie sareajointresponsibilityofthepublic, private,andsocialsectors.
ThestateofColimareceivedsupportfromnumerousorganizations,includingEl DeberesNuestro,EmpoderamientoClimático,andEarthLawCenter.
4.StateofMexico
TheStateofMexico Mexico ’ smostpopulousstate hasalsotakenanimportant stepforrightsofnaturewithoutyetgivingof fi cialrecognitiontotheconceptitself. Article18oftheconstitutionofthestateofMexicodoesnotrecognizetherightsof
74 In2016,MexicoCityofficiallybecameastateandnowhasitsowncongress,constitution,localgovernments, and fi scalrules.ViridianaRios, MexicoCityWillBecomeAState,WILSON CENTER (June2,2016),https://www. wilsoncenter.org/article/mexico-city-will-become-state.
75 ConstituciónPolíticadelaCuidaddeMéxico(201 7),http://www.infodf.org.mx/documentospdf/ constitucion_cdmx/Constitucion_%20Politica_CDMX.pdf.
554
Chapter19:EarthLawinLatinAmerica:AGlimpseofBrazilandMexico
natureinsomanywordsbutassertsthat “ [t]helegislationandregulationsthatare issuedforthispurposewillemphasizethepromotionofacultureofprotectionof nature,theimprovementoftheenvironmen t,therationaluseofnaturalresources andthepropagationofexisting fl oraandfauna. ” Thus,thisprovisioncanbeconstruedtoadvanceEarthlaw;however,itseffectivenesswilldependonwhetherthejudiciarywillmeaningfullyconsidernon-an thropocentricviewpoints.Afavorable indication:inAugust2019,theCongressofthestateofMexicohostedapresentation ontherightsofnaturethatincludedleadingexpertsinMexicoandworldwide. 76
XII.CIVILSOCIETYFORGESAPATHFORWARDINMEXICO
MuchofthedevelopmentofEarthlawinMexicoisbeingdrivenbysocialmovements. Forexample,manyoftheprovisionsforMexicoCity ’ snewconstitutionwerecrowdsourcedfromtheinternet,withcivilsocietygroupssuchasDerechosdelaMadre TierraMexico(RightsofMotherEarthMexico)andtheiralliesmakingastrongplea forrecognitionoftherightsofnature.Asyoulearned,theyweresuccessful.
Thefollowingexcerptfromaninterviewwith “ Coyote ” AlbertoRuz,aleading fi gureintheMexicanenvironmentalmovements,describeshowtherightsofnature movementinMexicoandLatinAmericacameabout:
[EsperanzaProject( “EP ”)]: Canyouexplaintomewhynowisaripemomentin timefortherightsofnatureandashifttowardbiocentricjurisprudence?
Alberto: Whentheenvironmentandecologybecameanimportantissue30–40years ago,themovementwas “humanssavingnature” forhumanbenefitandenjoyment.It wasn ’tuntil2008whenpeoplefromBoliviaandEcuador,RaphaelCorreaandEvo Morales,startedshiftingthediscussiontotheRightsofNatureandpreservingthe environmentforenvironment’ssake.RaphaelCorreaandEvoMoralesstartedincorporatingIndigenousculturetounderstandourrelationshipwiththeEarth.Irealized thatwecouldn’tkeepthinkingoftheEarthasanon-livingbeing,fromtheoccidental viewpoint,thattheEarthexistssolelyasaresourceforus. Latierranoesdenosotros [Theearthisnotours].OurlifedependsonHerbutthelasthundredyearshasbeen asteadydeteriorationofMotherEarth. SilentSpring [the1962bookbyRachelCarson]isnolongeraprophecy,wearelivinginit.Natureistellinguswearereaching thelimitsofhumangrowth.Now,insteadofdegradationhappeninginremoteareas oftheglobe,it’shappeningeverywhere,infrontofeveryone’seyes.Forcenturieswe havehadcollectiveamnesiaaboutthenegativeimpactshumanityhashadonthe environment.
EP: Howcanpeoplesupportthismovementintheirownlives?WherecanIlookfor answerstoknowifmychoicesalignwiththebiocentricethic?
76 RedacciónAsíSucede, UrgenAccionesParaRevertirelDeterioroAmbiental:Especialistas ,A SI SUCEDE (Aug.19, 2019).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Alberto: I firstawoketothisideawhenIwasveryyoung,15or16yearsold,andwent onacampingtripwherewesetuptentsand[made] firesandIrealizedthatthisall affectedtheenvironment.Eventherockswemoved.Weneedtobecomeconscious ofwhatwedoeveryday.Lookaroundyou.Whatisyourfootprint?Don’twaitfora universitylecturetomakechangesinyourlifestyleandhabits.Learntocompost, learnwhereyourwatercomesfrom.Starttoeducateyourselfinsmallthingsand putthemintopracticeandthenotherpeoplewillseewhatyouaredoingandmake changesintheirownlives.It’sallabouttherippleeffect.
EP: Howwouldyoudescribetheprogressyouhaveseenovertheyears?
Alberto: YearsagowhenIstartedtalkingabouttheRightsofNatureinMexicoCity everywhereIwentpeoplelookedatmelike: “What?!” It’saradicalidea.Andforme thatradicalideacamewhenIwenttomy fi rstbioregionalcongressinNorthwest Canadain1988.That ’ swhenit fi rststruckmethateverythingweweresayingor writingordecidingorthinkingwasaffectingthelivesofthecoyote,thelifeofthe river,thelifeofthetree.Intwentyyears,from1988to2008,wesawthe firstgovernment(Ecuador)adopttheRightsofNatur eintotheirconstitution.Itwasavery smallstepin1988butifacountryisdoingit,itisabiggerstep,andwecontinue tomakeprogress.EvoMoralesbroughttheconcepttotheUnitedNationsin2009 andthatwasthebasisfortheUNadoptingaresolutiononHarmonywithNature. AndwearegoingbacktotheUNagainthisyearbecausethisisthewayyouchange legislationandyouchangementality,youchangeeverything.It’sagradualchange. Lastyear,weorganizedthe fi rstforumfortheRightsofEarthinMexico.Here we ’redoinganotherstep,we’rebringingpeoplefromallthedifferentmovements, articulations,organizations,networks,andalliancestogether.Intalkingtoothers yourealizeit ’snotonlymewhoisthinking, “HowIcanprotectthetreesandthe birdsaroundmyhouse? ”
EP: Howdoweconvincepeopletoplacetheinterestofotherspeciesequaltoor abovetheirowninterests?
Alberto: The fi rstthingis[to]takeastepbackandlookatwhatwe ’ redoingand understandwhyit’ssoimportantotherspeciesexistbecausewithoutthebees,butterfl iesandtinyinsects,thewholechainuponwhichwedependisgoingtobreak andweareallgoingtogoifitbreaks.Weareeightbillionhumanbeingsright nowandeverydaythereisonelessbearandonelesslionandonelesselephant andthisisonlythemostvisibleofthespecies.ThelifeofUsisdestroyingthelife ofalltheOthers.Wearethepredatorsnowthataredestroyinglifearounduseverywhere,everysecond.Inthe[UnitedMexican]Statesrightnow,Iseeitasacrossroads,wecouldbeatthebeginningoftheworld ’ s fi rstglobaldarkage(andit’ sa perspectivewecannotforget,wecannotdismissandthinkitisjustapoliticalprophesy,becauseifthisrippleeffecthappensinthatdirectionit’sgoingtohappeneverywhere).Ontheotherside,weareseeinganotherglobalreaction.Asentencecame tomefromthebookofoneofmyfriends, DespertardelaMujer whichmeans “the awakeningofthesleepingwoman, ” whichcomesfromalegendinourcountry
Chapter19:EarthLawinLatinAmerica:AGlimpseofBrazilandMexico
Mexicothatthemomentwhenthesleepingwoman(whichisthevolcanoIztaccíhuatl)wakesup,allofhumanityisgoingtowakeup. Ihaven’theardsuchradical speechsincethesixtiesbutitisdifferentfromtheradicalofthesixtiesbecausethis isaradicalfulloflove,fullofconsciousness,ofnurturing,of fi nding,andthatis maybewhatweneededintheplanetrightnowtohappensothatwecouldchoose tosaynowisthetimewecannotcontinuewaitingforsomethingtohappen,wehave tomakeithappen.SoitmightbeastepinourevolutionthatwillbringustoaplanetaryconsciousnessandatthesametimeaMotherEarthconsciousness,whichis theultimatestep.Wehavetomakechangesinourdailylifeandhabitsandthatwill leadtoachangeincultureandlawsinordertoavoidwakingtoourownextinction.
Thewomenneedtoleadtheway.77
XIII.CHALLENGESINMEXICO
Despitesomestrongfoundationallegalelements,therearemajorchallengesforMexicotofurtherdevelopEarthlaw.TheexistinglevelofpovertyinMexicocloudsthe aimsofconservationbecauseitcanmistake nlybeviewedasadversetohumaninterests.Attitudesofthiskindmakeitdif fi culttoadoptgenerallaws(whichimplement theconstitutionalprovisions)specificallydesignedtodefendandguaranteetherights ofnaturebeyondanthropocentricconsiderations.
Conversely,theeffectsofc limatechange,disparitiesi nqualityoflife,andoverwhelminginequalityallputadditionalpressureonnature.Oftentimes,societydefaults toonlysafeguardinghumanswithoutadequ ateconsiderationoftheenvironment. Unfortunately,thismindsetisusedtojustifyenvironmentaldegradation,drawingupon theso-calledbasicneedsofthepopulationasacrutchtojustifymisguidedenvironmentalexploitation.Thesechallengesarebolsteredbyvoraciousandrampantcapitalism,whichcontinuestotreatnatureasamereresourcetofeedtheeconomicsystem.
Inthefaceofthisreality,wemustalsoacknowledgethelackofresponsibility shownbygovernments.Governmentsandth eirpoliciescenteronconsumptionasa meanstoguaranteequalityoflife.Theresultisaviciouscircleofenvironmentaldegradation,theconsequencesofwhicharefeltbythemostvulnerablesectorsofsociety.
Genuinestrengtheningoftherightsofnatureisalegitimateandvaluablegoalthat iswidelyexpressedinMexico.Respectfortherightsofnatureisatest,notonlyforthe ruleoflawbutalsoforbasichumanandsocietalvalues.Itfallstostatesandsocietyasa wholetoacceptresponsibilityforchangingthecurrentcourse.Thenumerousstate governmentenactmentsandthegrowingg rassrootsmovementsupportingrightsof natureprovideencouragingopportunitiestodevelopEarthlaw.
77 KealaCarter& “Coyote” AlbertoRuzBuen fi l, TowardsaNewJurisprudenceoftheEarth,ESPERANZA PROJECT (Feb.23,2017),www.esperanzaproject.com/2017/sustainability/ecovillages/coyote-alberto-on-the-rights-ofnature.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1)InbothBrazilandMexico,Indigenoustraditionshavebecomeafactorindevelopinglawandpolicyforrightsofnature.GiventhattheseIndigenoustraditions arebasedonanentirelydifferentoutlookthanWesternsociety,whatcouldpersuadejudgesandlawmakerstodrawonthissource?
(2)ThischapterdescribesthreeapproachesfordevelopingEarthlaw:(1)passing rightsofnaturelaws;(2)drawingonInd igenoustraditions;and(3)extending thepresentprotectionsofhumanrigh tstoencompassnature.Whatarethe advantagesanddisadvantagesofeachoftheseapproachesinBrazilandMexico?
(3)DiscusscurrentissueswiththeregulatoryframeworksinBrazilandMexico.How dotheyimpairtheeffortstodevelopEarthlaw?HowmightBrazilandMexico transformtheregulatorysystemtobetterpromotethedevelopmentofEarthlaw?
(4)HowmightBrazilianandMexicanconstitutionallawbereliedupontodevelop Earthlaw?ArethereprovisionsthatmayhinderthedevelopmentofEarthlaw?
(5)TheconstitutionalprotectionsfornatureinBrazilarefoundinTitle8.Title8 alsoestablishestheSocialSecuritysystem,thePublicHealthsystem,andthePublicPensionsystem.Howmightthisplacementhelporhinderthepromotionof rightsofnature?
(6)Whatroledoespovertyplayinthede velopmentofEarthlawinBraziland Mexico?
(7)Howmighttheenvironmentalcourtsthatareseparatefromothercivil,administrative,andcriminalcourts,envisionedbyMexico’sFederalLawofEnvironmentalResponsibility,promotethedevelopmentofecocentriclaw?Howmightthat developmentbedeterredbyaseparatecourtsystem?
CHAPTER20
India1
I.INTRODUCTION
Rightsofnatureareincreasinglyseenasthebackboneofanewgenerationofenvironmentallaws.However,successfulimplementationandpracticalenforcementremaina challenge.InIndia,therehavebeenatleasttwoattemptsbycourtstorecognizetherights ofnature,buttheresultshavebeenmixed.Inonedecision,the firstofitskindinIndia, theUttarakhandHighCourtrecognizedthelegalrightsofpersonhoodfortheGanges (or “Ganga”)andYamuna(or “Jumna”)riversandrelatednaturalsystems.Theruling hasbeenstayedbytheIndianSupremeCourt,whichhasnotindicatedwhenitwill resumeproceedings.(Chapter6, “GuardianshipArrangementsinRightsofNatureLegal Provisions,” alsodiscussesthiscase.)Theseconddecision,alsobytheUttarakhandHigh Court,declaredthatthemembersoftheanimalkingdom,includingavianandaquatic creatures,arelegalentitiesandthereforehavethesamerights,duties,andliabilitiesas otherjuristicpersons.Thischapterwillexaminethesecasestoshowthepossibilitiesand difficultiesposedbythe “firstgeneration” ofrightsofnaturelawsinIndia.
II.THELEGALLANDSCAPEININDIA
Indiaisafederalunionwith28statesand8unionterritories.TheIndianlegalsystemis ahybridofcivil,common,andcustomarylaw,coupledwithIslamicethicalandreligiouslaw,allmoldedintoaframeworkthatisheavilyinfluencedbythecountry’scolonialpast.Indiahasaparliamentarysystemofgovernmentwiththreebranches:the executive,thelegislativeandthejudiciar y.Theoperationsofthesethreebranches aredictatedbytheConstitutionofIndia,w hichwasadoptedbytheConstitutional AssemblyonNovember26,1949,andcameintoeffectonJanuary26,1950.
ThejudiciaryinIndiafollowsacommonlaw,hierarchicalstructure,similartothat oftheUnitedStates.TheSupremeCourtsitsattheapexandischargedwiththe responsibilityofinterpretingtheIndianConstitution.Itisthe fi nalappellatecourt forallmatters.Atthenextlevelarethehighcourts,whichoverseejudicialadministrationinIndia’sstatesandunionterritories.Variousotherbodieshavearighttoappeal
1 ThischapterwasauthoredbyEarthLawCenterstaffandvolunteers.AspecialthankyoutoOdaria Finemore,JyotiChaudhari,andNikitaTanwarfortheirassistance.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
tothehighcourts,includinglowercourtsi nthestatesandterritories,thedistrict courts,and LokAdalats (agenciesthatresolvedisputesthroughconciliation)atthevillageand panchayat (villagecouncil)level.2 PartIIIoftheIndianConstitutionprovides thatboththeSupremeCourtandhighcourtshavethespecialconstitutionalresponsibilityofenforcingthe “fundamentalrights” ofcitizens.
III.LANDMARKDECISIONFORTHERIGHTSOFRIVERS:THE MOHAMMEDSALIM CASE
TherightsofnaturemovementinIndiatookasigni ficantstepin2016whentheHigh CourtofUttarakhand( “ HighCourt ” )gavelegalstatustotheGangaandYamuna Riversalongwiththeirtributaries,glaciers,andcatchments.Thecasecommencedas acitizensuitwhenlocalresidentMohammedSalimsuedtheStateofUttarakhandto removeillegalconstructionandencroachmentsalongthebanksoftheYamunaRiver. TheYamunaRiver,whichoriginatesintheHimalayanfoothills,isthesecond-largest tributaryoftheGangesRiver.Salimalso allegedthatthestategovernmentsof UttarakhandandneighboringUttarPradeshwerefailingtocooperatewiththegovernmentofIndia(hereinafter “thecentralgovernment”)tocreateaGangaManagement Board,whichwasmandatedundertheUttarPradeshReorganizationAct,2000.3
InDecember2016,theHighCourtruledthattheillegalencroachmentsandconstructionongovernmentlandberemoved,thatthegovernmentsofUttarakhandand UttarPradeshjointheGangaManagementBoardandUpperYamunaRiverBoard withinthreemonths,andthatallminingintheriverbedoftheGangaandits fl oodplainsceaseimmediately.4 Muchofthedecisionfocusedonissuesoffederalism,such astherespectiverolesofstateandfederalgovernmentinwatermanagement.
However,thecentralgovernment,aswel lthegovernmentsofUttarakhandand UttarPradesh,failedtocomplywiththedirectionoftheHighCourt,andinafurther orderissuedinMarch2017,theHighCourtjudgesexpressedthecourt’ s “seriousdispleasure” atthetwostategovernments.5 Whiletheearlierorderhadfocusedonissues offederalism,thecourt’ssecondorderdecidedthatprotectingtheGangaandYamuna Riversrequiredtheambitiousandunprecedentedstepofrecognizingtheir “legalpersonhood” inpartbasedontheirspiritualsigni ficancetotheHindupeople.Thefollowingareexcerptsfromthecourt’sorder,writtenbyJusticeRajivSharma.
2 NationalInformaticsCentre, IndianJudiciary,IndianCourts,http://indiancourts.nic.in/index.html(last visitedMar.13,2020).
3 Mohd.Salimv.StateofUttarakhandandOthers,W.P.(C.)126of2014,H.C.Uttarakhand,reservedjudgment, ¶19(Dec.5,2016).
4 Id.at¶25.
5 Id. at¶9.
Chapter20:India
Mohd.Salimv.StateofUttarakhandandOthers
WritPetition(PIL)No.126of2014(Mar20.2017)
10.TheextraordinarysituationhasarisensinceRiversGangaandYamunaare loosing[sic]theirveryexistence.ThissituationrequiresextraordinarymeasurestobetakentopreserveandconserveRiversGangaandYamuna.
11.RiversGangesandYamunaarewor shippedbyHindus.Theseriversare verysacredandrevered.TheHindushaveadeepspiritualconnectionwith RiversGanges&Yamuna.
12.In1969(1)SCC555theirLordshipsofHon.SupremeCourtin Yogendra NathNaskarv.CommissionofIncome-Tax,Calcutta haveheldthataHinduidol isajuristicentitycapableofholdingpropertyandofbeingtaxedthroughits Shebaits[ministersandcustodiansoftheidol]whoareentrustedwiththepossessionandmanagementofitsproperty.Inparagraphno.6,theirLordships haveheldasunder:
6.ThattheconsecratedidolinaHindutempleisajuridicalpersonhasbeen expresslylaiddowninManoharGanesh ’ scase,I.L.R.12Bom.247 ::: Such ascriptionoflegalpersonalitytoanidolmusthoweverbeincompleteunless itbelinked[tohumanguardians]. TheJudicialCommitteeobservedthus: ‘Itisonlyinanidealsensethatpropertycanbesaidtobelongtoanidoland thepossessionandmanagementmustinthenatureofthingsbeentrustedwith somepersonasshebaitormanager.Itwouldseemtofollowthatthepersonso entrustedmust,ofnecessity,beempoweredtodowhatevermayberequired fortheserviceoftheidolandforthebenefi tandpreservationofitsproperty atleasttoasgreatadegreeasthemanagerofaninfantheir’— wordswhich seemtobealmostanechoofwhatwassaidinrelationtoachurchinajudgmentofthedaysofEdwardI: ‘Achurchisalwaysunderageandistobetreated asaninfantanditisnotaccordingtolawthatinfantsshouldbedisinheritedby thenegligenceoftheirguardiansorbebarredofanactionincasetheywould complainofthingswrongfullydoneby theirguardianswhiletheyareunder age(PollockandMaitland’ s ‘HistoryofEnglishLaw’,VolumeI,483).6
TheHighCourt ’ srulingcontinuedbyexaminingprecedentsrecognizing othernonhumans,suchasHinduidolsanddeities,as “ juristicpersons ” in Indianreligiouslaw.Thisprovidedlegalsupportforthenotionthatthe GangesandYamunaRivers,bothsacredrivers,couldalsobejuristicpersons underthelaw.
14.InAIR2000SC1421,theirLordshipsofHon.SupremeCourtinthecaseof ShiromaniGurudwaraPrabandhakComm ittee,Amritsarv.ShriSomNathDass&
6 Id.at¶¶10-12.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
others haveheldthattheconcept “JuristicPerson ” aroseoutofnecessitiesin thehumandevelopment.Recognitionofanentityasjuristicpersonisforsubservingtheneedsandfaithofsociety.Inparagraphnos.11,13and14,their Lordshipsheldasunder:
11.Theverywords “JuristicPerson” connoterecognitionofanentity tobeinlawapersonwhichotherwiseitisnot.Inotherwords,itisnot anindividualnaturalpersonbutanartificiallycreatedpersonwhich istoberecognisedtobeinlawassuch.Whenapersonisordinarily understoodtobeanaturalperson,itonlymeansahumanperson. Essentially,everyhumanpersonisaperson.Ifwetracethehistory ofa “Person” inthevariouscountrieswe findsurprisinglyithasprojecteddifferentlyatdifferenttimes.Insomecountriesevenhuman beingswerenottreatedaspersonsinlaw.UndertheRomanLawa “Slave” wasnotaperson.Hehadnorighttoafamily.Hewastreated likeananimalorchattel.InFrenchColoniesalso,beforeslaverywas abolished,theslaveswerenottreatedtobelegalpersons.Theywere latergivenrecognitionaslegalpersonsonlythroughastatute.Similarly,intheU.S.theAfrican-Americanshadnolegalrightsthough theywerenottreatedaschattel.
13.Withthedevelopmentofsociety,whereanindividual ’ sinteractionfellshort,toupsurgesocialdevelopment,co-operationofa largercircleofindividualswasneces sitated.Thus,institutionslike corporationsandcompanieswerecreated,tohelpthesocietyin achievingthedesiredresult.TheveryConstitutionofState,municipalcorporation,companyetc.areallcreationsofthelawandthese “JuristicPersons” aroseoutofnecessitiesinthehumandevelopment. Inotherwords,theyweredressedinacloaktoberecognisedinlaw tobealegalunit.
CorpusJurisSecundum,Vol.LXV,page40says:
Naturalperson.Anaturalpersonisahumanbeing;aman, woman,orchild,asopposedtoacorporation,whichhasa certainpersonalityimpressedonitbylawandiscalledan artificialperson.IntheC.J.S.definition ‘Person’ itisstated thattheword “ person, ” initsprimarysense,meansnatural person,butthatthegenerallyacceptedmeaningofthe wordasusedinlawincludesnaturalpersonsandarti fi cial, conventional,orjuristicpersons.
CorpusJurisSecundum,Vol.VI,page778says:
Arti fi cialpersons.Suchasarecreatedanddevisedby humanlawsforthepurposesofsocietyandgovernment, whicharecalledcorporationsorbodiespolitic.
7
SalmondonJurisprudence,12thEdn.,305says:
Alegalpersonisanysubject-matterotherthanahuman beingtowhichthelawattributespersonality.Thisextension,forgoodandsuf fi cientreasons,oftheconceptionof personalitybeyondtheclassofhumanbeingisoneofthe mostnoteworthyfeatsofthelegalimagination. ::: Legal persons,beingthearbitrarycreationsofthelaw,maybeof asmanykindsasthelawpleases.Thosewhichareactually recognisedbyourownsystem,however,areofcomparativelyfewtypes.Corporationsareundoubtedlylegalpersons,andthebetterviewisthatregisteredtradeunions andfriendlysocietiesarealsolegalpersonsthoughnotverballyregardedascorporations. If,however,wetake accountofothersystemsthanourown,we fi ndthatthe conceptionoflegalpersonalityisnotsolimitedinitsapplication,andthatthereareseveraldistinctvarieties.(Ellipses inoriginal.)
Wemay,therefore,defineapersonforthepurposeofjurisprudence asanyentity(notnecessarilyahumanbeing)towhichrightsor dutiesmaybeattributed.
14.Thus,itiswellsettledandcon fi rmedbytheauthoritieson jurisprudenceandCourtsofvariouscountriesthatforabiggerthrust ofsocio-political-scienti ficdevelopmentevolutionofa fi ctionalpersonalitytobeajuristicpersonbecameinevitable.Thismaybeany entity,livinginanimate,objectsorthings. ::: Thisrecognitionisfor subservingtheneedsandfaithofthesociety.
15.InAIR1972Allahabad287,learnedSingleJudgeofAllahabadHighCourt incaseof MoortiShreeBeharijiv.PremDass7others’7 hasheldthatadeitycansue asapauper.Inparagraphno.6,itwasheldasunder:
6.Thequestionthenthatarisesiswhyadeitywhois[a]juristicpersonandcansueorbesuedthroughitsPujari,Shebaitoranyother personinterested,cannotsueasapauper?Tomymindwhenan incorporatedlimitedcompanyhasbeenheldbythisCourtcapable ofsuingasapauper,afortioriitfollowsthatadeitycanalsosueas apauper.ThelearnedJudgeofthecourtbelowwasinerrorin explainingawaytheFullBenchdecisionofthisCourtinthecaseof AIR1959All540(FB)(supra)ontheobservationthatItrelatedtoa jointstockcompany,hencenotapplicable.Thecourtbelowthus wasinerrorinrejectingtheapplicationofthedeityforthatreason.
16.Withthedevelopmentofthesocietywheretheinteractionofindividuals fellshorttoupsurgethesocialdevelopment,theconceptofjuristicperson
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
wasdevisedandcreatedbyhumanlawsforthepurposesofthesociety.Ajuristicperson,likeanyothernaturalpersonisinlawalsoconferredwithrightsand obligationsandisdealtwithinaccordancewithlaw.Inotherwords,theentity actslikeanaturalpersonbutonlythroughadesignatedperson,astheirLordshipshaveheldinthejudgmentscitedhereinabove,thatforabiggerthrustof socio-political-scienti ficdevelopment,evolutionofa fictionalpersonalitytobe ajuristicpersonbecomesinevitable.Thismaybeanyentity,livinginanimate, objectsorthings.Itmaybeareligiousinstitutionoranysuchusefulunitwhich mayimpeltheCourtstorecogniseit.Thisrecognitionisforsubservingthe needsandfaithofthesociety. Thus,toprotecttherecognitionandthefaith ofsociety,RiversGangaandYamunaarerequiredtobedeclaredasthelegal persons/livingpersons.
17.AlltheHindushavedeepAstha[care,interest,faith]inriversGangaand Yamunaandtheycollectivelyconnectwiththeserivers.RiversGangaand Yamunaarecentraltotheexistenceofhalfof[the]Indianpopulationand theirhealthandwellbeing.Therivershaveprovidedbothphysicalandspiritualsustenancetoallofusfromtimeimmemorial.RiversGangaandYamuna havespiritualandphysicalsustenance.Theysupportandassistboththelife andnaturalresourcesandhealthandwell-beingoftheentirecommunity. RiversGangaandYamunaarebreathing,livingandsustainingthecommunitiesfrommountainstosea.
18.TheconstitutionofGangaManagementBoardisnecessaryforthepurpose ofirrigation,ruralandurbanwatersupply,hydropowergeneration,navigation,industries.Thereisutmostexpediencytogivelegalstatusasalivingperson/legalentitytoRiversGangaandYamunar/wArticles48-Aand51A(g)of theConstitutionofIndia.
19.Accordingly,whileexercisingthe parenspatrie [sic]jurisdiction,theRivers GangaandYamuna,alltheirtributaries,streams,everynaturalwater fl owing with fl owcontinuouslyorintermittently oftheserivers,aredeclaredas juristic/legalpersons/livingentitie shavingthestatusofalegalpersonwith allcorrespondingrights,dutiesandliabilitiesofalivingpersoninorderto preserveandconserveriverGangaandYamuna.TheDirectorNAMAMI Gange,theChiefSecretaryoftheStateofUttarakhandandtheAdvocate GeneraloftheStateofUttarakhandareherebydeclared personsinlocoparentis asthehumanfacetoprotect,conserveandpreserveRiversGangaand Yamunaandtheirtributaries.TheseOf fi cersareboundtoupholdthestatus ofRiversGangesandYamunaandalsotopromotethehealthandwellbeing oftheserivers.
TheHighCourtmadeimportantconnectionsbetweenArticles48Aand51A(g)of theIndianConstitutionandtherightsofnature.Thesetwoarticlesprovideasfollows:
• Article48A: “TheStateshallendeavortoprotectandimprovetheenvironment andtosafeguardtheforestsandwildlifeofthecountry.”
Chapter20:India
• Article51A(g): “ ItshallbethedutyofeverycitizenofIndiatoprotectand improvethenaturalenvironmentincludi ngforest,lakes,riversandwildlife, andtohavecompassionforlivingcreatures.”
Asappliedtorightsofnature,theHighCourtreasonedthatachievingtheenvironmentalmandateofArticles48Aand51A (g)fortheGangesandYamunaRivers requiredrecognizingthetworiversasjur isticpersons.Inotherwords,thecurrent approachtoenvironmentalgovernancewasnotsuf fi cient. “Today,theStateandthe citizensareunderafundamentalobligationtoprotectandimprovetheenvironment, includingforests,lakes,rivers,wildlifeandtohavecompassionforlivingcreatures,” the HighCourtconcluded.8
Atthetimeofthiswriting,theUttarakhandHighCourt ’srulingin Mohd.Salim is pendingintheSupremeCourtofIndia,pursuanttoaplea fi ledbythegovernment ofthestateofUttarakhandchallengingthejudgmentonseverallegalandadministrativegrounds.9 Amongothercontentions,thegovernmentofUttarakhandarguedthat therulingwas “unsustainableinlaw.” Forexample,theyvoicedconcernovercomplicatedlegalquestionsthatmightariseonceariverisrecognizedashavingrights.If theriver fl oodsanddestroyshumanpropertyorsomeonedrownsinitswater,could theriveritselfbesued?AndwouldthegovernmentofUttarakhandbeliabletopay damagesonbehalfoftheriver?Or,ifnotthem,thenwho?Finally,thegovernment ofUttarakhandraisedjurisdictionaliss ues.Forexample,becausetheriversrun throughdifferentstates,policiespertainingtotheirprotectionshouldbeformulated bythecentralgovernment.
Inresponse,onJuly7,2017,theSupremeCourtofIndiaorderedtheproceedings andtheHighCourtordertobestayed.
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1)OnenoteworthyaspectoftheUttarakhandHighCourt’sjudgmentwasitsinvocationoftheprincipleof parenspatriae Black’sLawDictionary defines parenspatriae as:
a.TheStateregardedasasovereign;thestateinitscapacityasproviderofprotectiontothoseunabletocareforthemselves.
b.ADoctrinebywhichagovernmenthasstandingtoprosecutealawsuiton behalfofacitizen,especiallyonbehalfofsomeonewhoisunderalegaldisabilitytoprosecutethesuit.TheStateordinarilyhasnostandingtosueonbehalf ofitscitizens,unlessaseparate,sovereigninterestwillbeservedbythesuit.10
8 K.M.Chinnappa,T.N.GodavarmanThirumalpadv.UnionofIndia&Ors.,(2002)(10)S.C.C.606.
9 India’sGangesandYamunaRiversare ‘NotLivingEntities’,BBC(Jul.7,2017).
10 ShamaSinha, DoctrineofParensPatriae,HighCourtandSupremeCourtJudgments(Aug.6,2016),http:// latestsupremecourtjudgments.blogspot.com/2016/08/doctrine-of-parens-patriae.html.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Tothisend,theHighCourteventuallyappointedsixgovernmentof fi cials inlocoparentis withadutytoprotect,conserve,andpreservethetworiversand theirtributariesincooperationwithsev enlocalrepresentatives.Havingread theguardianshipchapterandnowlearningaboutthecaseof Mohd.Salimv. StateofUttarakhandandOthers ,whatchallengesmightimpairtheeffectiveness ofaguardianshipbodycomprisedofgovernmentof fi cialsinimplementing therightsofnature?BasedontheCourt ’ srelianceonthejuristicstatusof Hinduidols,whatrolemightbeservedby areligiousorspiritualelementina guardianshipbodythatrepresentstheGangesandYamunaRivers?Whatbenefi tsmightresultfromthereligion-rooted perspective?Whatdrawbacksmightbe encountered?
(2)Inwhatothercountriesmightriver sberecognizedashavingpersonhoodor rightsbaseduponreligiousandspiritualbeliefs?Wouldmoreorfewerriversbe recognizedashavingrightsifthehighestlawofthenationsintheAmericas wasthelawoftheIndigenousAmericans?IfallsovereignnationsintheAmericas recognizedrightsofrivers,whatcon fl ictsmightensuewhenrivers fl owthrough morethanonecountry?
(3)ThegovernmentofUttarakhandarguedthatrecognizingthepersonhoodofa rivercouldleadtoimmenselegalcomplications,posingtheexampleofwhether humansshouldbeabletosueariverifit floods.Cananentityhaverightswithoutduties?Whatmightthedutiesbe?Whatbene fitstosociety,ifany,mightbe achievedifrivershadlegalduties?
(4)DoyouagreewiththeUttarakhandHighCourt’sapproachthatlegalpersonality isausefulalternativeforrivermanagement?Howwouldthelegalpersonality approachchangerivermanagementintheUnitedStates?Howwouldtherights ofriversaslegalpersonalitiesbebalancedwithhumanrightsandinterests?What istheproperbalance?Ifyoudobalance,howdoyouavoid “balancingaway” all oftheimportantriverprotections,andatwhatpointdorightsofnaturebecome nodifferentthanthecurrentapproachtoprotectingrivers?
IV.EXTENDINGTHERIGHTSOFNATURALENTITIES:THE MIGLANI CASE
FollowingtheUttarakhandHighCourt ’ sdeclarationthattheGangaandYamuna Riversare “ juristic/legalpersons/livingentitie shavingthestatusofalegalperson, ” thatsamecourtin Miglaniv.StateofUttarakhandandOthers extendedtheambitofjuristicpersonstoawiderangeofnaturalentitiesthatfeedintotheserivers,suchasother rivers,glaciers,waterfalls,streams,lakes,rivulets,jungles,meadows,forestwetlands, grasslands,dales,air,andforestwetlands.11 Twonaturalentitieswerepickedoutfor
11 LalitMiglaniv.StateofUttarakhandandOthers,W.P.(C.),No.140of2015,H.C.Uttarakhand(Mar.30,2017).
Chapter20:India
specialattention:glaciersandforests.Emphasizingtheexistentialthreatfacedbythe GangotriandYamnotriGlaciers,theHighCourtwroteasfollows:
Miglaniv.StateofUttarakhandandOthers W.P.(C.),No.140of2015,H.C.Uttarakhand,March30,2017
GangotriGlacierissituatedinDistrictUttarakashioftheStateofUttarakhand. Itis330.2kilometreslongandbetween0.5to2.0kilometreswide.Itisoneof thelargestglaciersintheHimalayas.However,itisrecedingsince1780.The recedingisquickafter1971.AccordingtotheimagesofNASA,overthelast 25years,Gangotriglacier[sic]hasr etreatedmorethan850meters,witha recessionof76metersfrom1996to1999alone.RiverGangaoriginatesfrom GangotriGlacier.
RiverYamunaoriginatesfromYamunotriGlacier.ItisalsosituatedinDistrictUttarkashi.YamunotriGlacierisalsorecedingatanalarmingrate.These Glaciersarerecedingduetopollutionaswellasclimatechange.Theurgent remedialstepsarerequiredtobetakentoensurethattherecedingofthese Glaciersisstopped.
BothGangaandYamunaRiversarereveredasdeitiesbyHindus.Glacial IceisthelargestreservoiroffreshwateronEarth.12
Ingrantingthesevariousnaturalentitiessomeofthesamelegalrightsasa livingperson,theHighCourtin Miglani alsoproclaimeditis “thefundamentaldutyofallthecitizenstopreserveandconservethenatureinitspristine glory.”13 Thisdutywentbeyondthelaw: “Besidesourconstitutionalandlegal duties,itisourmoraldutytoprotecttheenvironmentandecology,” wrote thecourt.14
TheHighCourtagaininvokedtheprincipleof parenspatriae,whichdesignatesthegovernment,orsomeotherauthority,asthelegalrepresentativesof citizensunabletoprotectthemselves.TheHighCourtofUttarakhandcited variouscasesfromtheUnitedStateswhichappliedordiscussedtheprinciple of parenspatriae,including MormonChurchv.UnitedStates, Kansasv.Colorado , Oklahomaex.rel.Johnsonv.Cook, Snapp&Son,Inc.v.PuertoRicoexrel.Barez. 15 Yet,despitethevalueoflegalpreced entandcaselaw,thecourtconcluded
12 Id. at5.
13 Id.at42.
14 Id.at59.
15 MormonChurchv.UnitedStates,136U.S.1(1890); Kansasv.Colorado,185U.S.125(1902); Oklahomaex.rel. Johnsonv.Cook,304U.S.387(938); Snapp&Son,Inc.v.PuertoRicoexrel.Barez,458U.S.592(1982).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
thatthebestjusti fi cationfortheuseof parenspatriae inthe Miglani casewas thegravityofthethreatsandharmstothenaturalentitiesthatwouldbene fit fromlegalrepresentation.Accordingly,theHighCourtnamedanumberof of fi cialsaslegalguardians.Recogniz ingtherightsofcommunitiesliving nearby,theHighCourtalsopermittedthechiefsecretaryofUttarakhandto appointsevenpublicrepresentativesfromthestatetorepresentthese communities.
TheHighCourtconcludedbyemphasizingtheimportanceofgivingpersonhoodtonaturetoaddressenvironmentaldegradationcausedbyhumans: RiversandLakeshaveintrinsicright[s]nottobepolluted.Pollutinganddamagingtherivers,forests,lakes,waterbodies,airandglacierswillbelegally equivalenttoharming,hurtingandcausinginjurytopersons.
Rivers,Forests,Lakes,WaterBodies,Air,GlaciersandSpringshavearight toexist,persist,maintain,sustainandregeneratetheirownvitalecologysystem.Theriversarenotjustwaterbodies.Thesearescientificallyandbiologicallyliving.
Therivers,forests,lakes,waterbodies,air,glaciers,[and]humanlifeare uni fiedandare[an]indivisiblewhole.Theintegrityoftheriversisrequired tobemaintainedfromGlacierstoOcean.
However,wewouldhastentoobservethatthelocalinhabitantslivingon thebanksofrivers,lakesandwhoselivesarelinkedwithriversandlakesmust havetheirvoicetoo.
Theriverssustainedtheaquaticlife.The floraandfaunaarealsodependentontherivers.
Riversaregaspingforbreath.WemustrecognizeandbestowtheConstitutionallegalrightstothe ‘MotherEarth’ .
Theveryexistenceoftherivers,forests,lakes,waterbodies,airand glaciersisatstakeduetoglobalwarming,climatechangeandpollution.
Treesarethebufferzonenecessarytoprotecttheglaciersfromdirectand indirectheat.Onetreesustainslifeofthousand[s]ofinsects.Birdschirpand maketheirnestsonthetrees.Treesaremini-reservoirsandhaveacapacityto storethewater.Thewaterstoredbythetreesisreleasedslowly.TheOaktree preservesabout75,000gallon[s]ofpurewater.Pluckingofoneleaf[or]grass bladealsodamagestheenvironmentuniversally.
Theleadingcivilizationshavevanishedduetoseveredroughts.Wateris theelixiroflifeandwemustconserveandpreserveeverydropofwater.The valueofwatershouldnotbeunderminedonlyforthereasonthatitisstill availableinplenty.
Thepastgenerationshavehandedoverthe “ MotherEarth ” tousinits pristinegloryandwearemorallyboundtohandoverthesameMotherEarth tothenextgeneration.
Allthepersonshaveaconstitutionalandmoralresponsibilitytoendeavourtoavoiddamageorinjurytonature(indamnovitando).Anypersoncausinganyinjuryandharm,intentionall yorunintentionallytotheHimalyas, [sic]Glaciers,rivers,streams,rivulets,lakes,air,meadows,dales,junglesand
Chapter20:India
forestsisliabletobeproceededagainstunderthecommonlaw,penallaws, environmentallawsandotherstatutoryenactmentsgoverningthe field.
Thus,theHimalayanMountainRanges,Glaciers,rivers,streams,rivulets, lakes,jungles,air,forests,meadows, dales,wetlands,grasslandsandsprings arerequiredtobedeclaredasthelegalentity/legalperson/juristicperson/ judicialperson/moralperson/artificialpersonfortheirsurvival,safety,sustenanceandresurgence.16
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1)TheHighCourtin Miglani citednumerousU.S.courtdecisionstohelpjustifyits useoftheprincipleof parenspatriae.CourtsinBrazilandColombiahaverelied onthedecisionoftheHighCourtofUttarakhandin Salimv.StateofUttarakhand. DoU.S.courtsrelyondecisionsfromothercountries?Doyouthinkthisisappropriate?HowmightcourtsintheU.S.bepersuadedtorelymoreoftenondecisions fromothercountriesthatembodyEarthlawprinciples?Instateandfederalcourts intheUnitedStates,lawyershavereliedondecisionsmadeunderotherstates’ laws.Manyarefoundtobepersuasiveandtrendsbegin.Considerthedevelopmentofproductliabilitylaw.Whataddi tionalhurdlesarepresentedwhenthe lawisofanothercountry?Howmightthelawofforeigncountriesbereliedon byU.S.courtstocraftnewlegalsolutionsthat fittoday’smostdifficultchallenges?
(2)Shouldcommunityrepresentativesserveaslegalguardiansofnaturewhenthey mayrepresenttheinterestsofthehumancommunityovertheinterestsof nature?Howcanitbeensuredthattheyactonbehalfoftherightsandinterests ofnature?Thereareinnumerablecon fl ictsofinterestswithinecosystems,perhapsthemostobviousbeingpredator-preyrelationships.Aretherightsof humancommunitiesthatdrawbene fitsfromnaturecomparabletotherightsof non-humanpredatorswithrespecttotheirprey.Howmightthesecon fl ictsbe resolved?Identifyotherconfl ictsandpotentialresolutions.
(3)Oneofthenaturalentitiesthatreceivedrecognitionoftheirrightswaswaterfalls. Whatrightsmighttheyhave?Shouldtheirrightsbeconsideredinisolation,or onlyaspartofalargerecosystem?
(4)In Miglani,theHighCourtstated: “Besidesourconstitutionalandlegalduties,itis ourmoraldutytoprotecttheenvironmentandecology,” and “[a]llthepersons haveaconstitutionalandmoralresponsibilitytoendeavourtoavoiddamageor injurytonature. ” Whatroledoesmoraldutyhaveindecisionsmadebytrial andappellatejudgesintheUnitedStates?Whatroleshouldmoraldutyplay?
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
V.THERIGHTSOFTHEANIMALKINGDOM:THE NARAYAN DUTTBHATT CASE
OnJuly4,2018,theHighCourtofUttarakhandheldin NarayanDuttBhattv.Unionof IndiaandOthers thatallmembersoftheanimalkingdomarelegalpersons.17 Thedecisioncameinresponsetoapetition filedfortheprotectionandwelfareofanimals.The petitionerhadsoughttorestrictthemovementofhorsecartsknownas “ tongas ” betweenNepalandIndiathroughBanbasa intheChampawatdistrictofIndia,due tothesufferingexperiencedbythehorses.Asaremedy,thepetitionersoughtvaccinationsandmedicalcheckupsforthehorsesforsuspectedinfectionspriortoentryinto IndiafromNepal.Byconsentoftheparties,thepetition’sscopewasenlargedtopromotetheprotectionandwelfareof all animals.TheHighCourtwroteasfollows:
NarayanDuttBhattv.UnionofIndiaandOthers
W.P.(C.),No.43of2014,H.C.Uttarakhand(July4,2018)
12.LearnedcounselforthepetitionerhasvehementlyarguedthattheIndian authoritieshavefailedtoregulatetheentryofhorsecarts/tongaentering fromNepaltoIndia.Thehorsesarenotmedicallyexamined.Thefareand freightarenotregulated.Hehasreferredtothetreaty[betweenIndiaand Nepal]signedintheyear1991,revisedin2009.Accordingtothetreaty,the contractingpartymayimposerestrictionsforprotectingpublicmorals,protectinghuman,animalandplantlife, safeguardingnationaltreasures.He hasalsoarguedthatthereisoverloadinginthehorsecarts/tongagoingfrom IndiatoNepalandvice-versa.Theanimalsaretreatedwithcruelty.Thehorses areabandonedintheIndianTerritory.Hethenarguedthattheprovisionsof PreventionofCrueltytoAnimalsAct,1960andtherulesframedthereunder andtheprovisionsofPreventionandControlofInfectiousandContagious DiseasesinAnimalsAct,2009havenotbeenenforced.Healsoarguedthat theanimalsaretransportedinviolationofTransportofAnimalsRules,1978. Theanimalsaretransportedonfoottolongdistancescausingimmensepain andsufferingtothem.Healsoprayedthattheentireanimalkingdommay beconferredstatusof[a]legalentity/legalperson.18
TheHighCourtreviewedtherelevantleg islation,notablythePreventionof CrueltytoAnimalsAct,1960,whichstatesthatapersoncommitscrueltytoananimal ifthatperson,amongstotheractions,
17 NarayanDuttBhattv.UnionofIndiaandOthers,W.P.(C.),No.43of2014,H.C.Uttarakhand(July4,2018).
18 Id
Chapter20:India
beats,kicks,over-rides,over-drives,over-loads,torturesorotherwisetreatsanyanimalso astosubjectittounnecessarypainorsufferingorcauses,orbeingtheownerpermits anyanimaltobesotreated;or(employsinanyworkorlabourorforanypurposeany animalwhich,byreasonofitsageoranydisease)infirmity;wound,soreorothercause, isun fi ttobesoemployedor,beingtheowner,permitsanysuchun fi tanimaltobe employed.19
Additionallegislationspeci fi callyappliestoanimalsusedintransportation,setting maximumloadsandnumbersofpassengers,limitingworkinghoursinhotweather, andimposingotherrestrictions.20
Afterexamininganimalcrueltylegislation,theHighCourtthenconsideredthe questionofanimalsuffering.Reviewingpreviouscourtdecisions,itstatedasfollows:
75.TheirLordshipsoftheHon’bleSupremeCourt haveheldthatananimalhasalso honouranddignitywhichcannotbearbitra rilydeprivedofandi tsrightsandprivacy havetoberespectedandprotectedfromunlawfulattacks.Theprincipleofequalityof allspeciesfoundinIshaUpanishads[SanskrittextscontainingHinduteachings]isthe cultureandtraditionofthecountry,particularlytheStatesofTamilNaduandMaharashtra.ThePCAAct[PreventionofCrue ltytoAnimalsAct,1960]hasbeenenacted withanobjecttosafeguardthewelfareoftheanimalsandevidentlytocuresomemischiefandageoldpractices,soastobringintoeffectsometypeofreform,basedon eco-centricprinciples,recognizingtheintrinsicvalueandworthofanimals.Sofarasanimalsareconcerned, “ life ” meanssomethingmorethanmeresurvivalorexistenceor instrumentalvalueforhumanbeings,buttoleadalifewithsomeintrinsicworth, honouranddignity.21
Next,theHighCourtconsideredworksbyanumberofauthorsontheemotions,intelligence,language,self-awareness,andoth ercapabilitiesofanimals.Theseincluded DavidR.Boyd’sbook TheRightsofNature, 22 whichtheHighCourtquotedasfollows: Onthefrontiersoflegalchange,thereisagrowingglobalmovementtorecognizenonhumananimalsaslegalpersons,aradicalchangethatwouldendowthemwiththevarietyoflegalrights.Animalrightsadvocatesarenotsayingprimates,cetaceans,orelephantsarepeople.A ‘ legalperson ’ isnotnecessarilyahumanbeing,butratheran entitytowhichthelawgrantsspecificrights.Acorporationisconsideredalegalperson, asareships,churchesandmunicipalities.Therightsandresponsibilitiesofalegalpersonvaryaccordingtothenatureoftheentity.Corporationsandhumanbeingshavedifferentsetsoflegalrightsandduties.Forexample,corporationsmayassertfreedomof expression,butarenotprotectedbytherighttolife.”23
TheHighCourtcontinuedbytyingitsconceptofajuristicpersontotheanimalkingdomintermssimilartothoseemployedin Mohd.Salimv.StateofUttarakhandand
19 Id. ,quotingPreventionofCrueltytoAnimalsAct,No.59of1960,§11.(Sectionnumbersremovedfrom quotation.)
20 Id.,quotingPreventionofCrueltytoDraughtandPackAnimalsRules,1965.
21 Id.
22 DAVID R.BOYD,THE RIGHTSOF NATURE (2017).(Footnoteadded.)
23 NarayanDuttBhatt, supra note26.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Others.Italsocitedreligiousperspectivesonanimals,includingfromJainismandBuddhism,tosupportthenotionofgivinglegalrightstoanimals.
83.Wehavetoshowcompassiontowardsalllivingcreatures.Animalsmaybemutebut weasasocietyhavetospeakontheirbehalf.Nopainoragonyshouldbecausedto theanimals.Crueltytoanimalsalsocausespsychologicalpaintothem.InHinduMythology,everyanimalisassociatedwithagod.Animalsbreathelikeusandhaveemotions. Theanimalsrequirefood,water,shelter ,normalbehavior,me dicalcare,selfdetermination.
84.Duetodamagecausedtoenvironmentandecology,theavianandaquaticlifeisalso threatened.Majorrivershavebeenreducedtothestatusofasewer.Aquaticlifecannot survivewithoutwater.Therivershaveinherentrightto flowinlengthaswellasinwidth. Theoceansarechockedwithplastic.Manyspeciesarebecomingextinct.Thelossofone speciescausesimmensedamagetotheentireecosystem.Globalwarminghasarrived anditsimpactcanbeseeninday-to-dayexistence.Therearegapsinlaws.Newinventionsarerequiredtobemadeinlawtoprotecttheenvironmentandecology.Theanimalsincludingavianandaquatichavearighttolifeandbodilyintegrity,honourand dignity.Animalscannotbetreatedmerelyasproperty. :::
87.Itwouldbepertinentatthisstagetomakereferenceofthebook, “SacredAnimalsof India ”,writtenbyNandithaKrishna.Shehasintroducedeveryanimalwiththemyths andlegendsthatestablishitsreligiousstatus,followedbyashortnoteontheecological orsocialroleoftheanimal,whichmadeitimportantinpeople ’ slives.Thelearned authorhasalsodiscussedtheAhimsaandN on-violencepreachedbyLordMahavira, LordGautamaBuddhaasunder:
AhimsaorNon-Violence
Theconceptofahimsa ornon-violence isIndia’suniquecontributiontoworldculture.TheVedasandUpanishadswerethe firsttospeakof ahimsa.AlthoughtheAryans werenotvegetarians,theconceptofnon-killingappearsintheearliestliterature.The RigVeda(10.87.16),condemnsallformsofkilling,evenforfood,preferringvegansto drinkersofmilk:
Theyatudhanawho fillshimselfwiththe fleshofman, Hewho fillshimselfwiththe fleshofhorsesorofotheranimals,
Andhewhostealsthemilkofthecow:
Lord,cutofftheirheadswithyour flame.
TheYajurVedasaysthatservicetoanimalsleadstoheaven: ‘Nopersonshouldkillanimalshelpfultoallandpersonsservingthemshouldobtainheaven. ’ Accordingtothe AtharvaVeda,theearthwascreatedfortheenjoymentofnotonlyhumanbeingsbut alsoforbipedsandquadrupeds,birds,animalsandallothercreatures.Theemergence ofalllifeformsfromtheSupremeBeingisexpressedintheMundakopanishadfrom Him,too,godsareproducedmanifold,Thecelestials,men,cattle,birds.
Chapter20:India
Theseideasledtotheconceptofahimsaornon-violence.Muchlater,theManusmriti says, ‘Hewhoinjuriesinnocentbeingswithadesiretogivehimselfpleasurenever finds happiness,neitherinlifenorindeath.’ TheShrimadBhagavatamsaysthatacruelpersonwhokillsothersforhisexistencedeservestobekilled,andcannotbehappy,either inlifeorindeath.Theconsequences,accordingtotheYajunavalkyaSmritiarethat ‘the wickedpersonwhokillsanimalswhichareprotectedhastoliveinhellfi reforthedays equaltothenumberofhairsonthebodyofthatanimal.’
AlthoughSanatanaDharmadidnotrequireitsadherentstobevegetarians,vegetarianismwasrecognizedasahigherformsofliving,abeliefthatcontinuesincontemporary Hinduismwherevegetarianismisconsideredessentialforspiritualism.Aroundthesixth centuryBCE,twogreatreligiouspreacherswereborn,whotooktheUpanishadicphilosophyofgoodconductandnon-killingtothepeopleinthecommonlanguage:Mahavira theJina(Victor),andGautamatheBudha[sic](wise).Thenametraditionallyusedfor Hinduism.Bothemphasizedthatahimsaornon-violencewasessentialforagoodlife.
MahavirawasnotthefounderofJainism:hewasthetwenty-fourthandlastTirthankarawho revisedtheJainadoctrinesandestab lishedthecentraltenetsofJainism. Mahavira [taught]theimportanceofrightfaith,rightknowledgeandrightconduct,whichincludes non-violence(ahimsa) nottocauseharmtoanylivingbeing. :::
AccordingtoJainism,ahimsaisnotthemerecausingofviolence,butratherthe “ severanceofanyofthevitalityinamobileorimmobilebeing.” Ahimsa,asviewedbyJainism, isverycomprehensiveandtakesintoconsiderationthewelfareofallbeingsonearth. Keepinganythinginconfinement,withoutconsiderationforitsfreedomtoexistorlive, isbandhana(captivity).Rearinganimalswithoutadequateshelter,air,light,spaceand foodisatichara(badconduct).Keepingan imals,includingdairyanimals,tiedwith ropesorchainsthroughoutthedayisviolence.ThesimpleprayeroftheJainasis “ let thelawoftheJainagiveallhappinesstoallthelivingbeingsoftheworld.Allbeings desiretolive.Theylikepleasure,hatepain,shundestruction,liketolivelong.Toall,life isdear.” (Ramanujam2006).
TheeightfoldpathtaughtbytheBuddha[(Gautama)]emphasizedabstinencefrom activitiesthatbringharmtootherlivingbeingsandnon-killing.TheBoddhisattvais onewhoisfullofmaitri(friendship)towardsallanimalsandwhichaspirestoachieve Buddha-hood.SaidtheBuddha, “ Asamotherwouldbeverygoodtowardsheronly child,herwell-belovedson’ sotooyoushouldbeverygoodtowardsallcreatureseverywhereandtoeveryone. ” (Dwivedi,1989)TheBuddhahimselfsoughtrefugefromhis bickeringdisciplesbylivingamongtheanimals.TheJatakatalesholdupthenoblequalitiesofvariousanimalsasexamplestoemulate.
TheHighCourtconcluded:
96.ItisthefundamentaldutyofallthecitizensunderArticle51-AoftheConstitutionof Indiatohavecompassionforlivingcreatures.ItshouldbetheendeavouroftheState underArticle48oftheConstitutiontoorganizeagricultureandanimalhusbandryon modernandscienti fi clinesandtakestepsforprese rvingandimprovingthebreeds. TheStateGovernmentisrequiredtoprotectandimprovetheenvironmentandto
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
safeguardtheforestsandwildlifeofthecounterasperArticle48-AoftheConstitution ofIndia.
97.ThemaximumweightprescribedunderRules3and4ofthePreventionofCrueltyto Draught&PackAnimalsRules,1965isprimafacieexcessive.InIndia,byandlarge,the weatherremainsdry.Itcausesimmensestresstotheanimalstodrivevehiclesbycarrying maximumload,asprescribedundertheRules,1965indryconditions.Theneedofthe houristohavetheexpert’sopinionwhetherthemaximumloadprescribedunderRules 3and4ofRules,1965isreasonableornot.
98.TheirLordshipsoftheHon’ bleSupremeCourtin “ A.Nagaraja ’ s ” casehaveheld thatArticle21oftheConstitution,whilesafeguardingtherightsofhumans,protectslife andtheword “life” hasbeengivenanexpandeddefinitionandanydisturbancefromthe basicenvironmentwhichincludesallformsoflife,includinganimallife,whicharenecessaryforhumanlife,fallwithinthemeaningofArticle21oftheConstitution. “Life ” meanssomethingmorethanmeresurvival orexistenceorinstrumentalvaluefor humanbeings,buttoleadalifewithsomeintrinsicworth,honourordignity.Alltheanimalshavehonouranddignity.Everyspecieshasaninherentrighttoliveandare requiredtobeprotectedbylaw.Therightsandprivacyofanimalsaretoberespected andprotectedfromunlawfulattacks.TheirLordshipshaveevolvedtheterm “species ’ bestinterest.” TheCorporations,Hinduidols,holyscriptures,rivershavebeendeclared legalentitiesandthus,inordertoprotec tandpromotegreaterwelfareofanimals includingavianandaquatic,animalsarerequiredtobeconferredwiththestatusoflegal entity/legalperson.Theanimalsshouldbehealthy,comfortable,well-nourished,safe, abletoexpressinnatebehaviorwithoutpain,fearanddistress.Theyareentitledto justice.
99.Accordingly,thewritpetitionisdisp osedofbyissuingthefollowingmandatory directions:
A.Theentireanimalkingdomincludingavianandaquaticaredeclaredas legalentitieshavingadistinctpersonawithcorrespondingrights,dutiesand liabilitiesofalivingperson.AllthecitizensthroughouttheStateof Uttarakhandareherebydeclaredpersons inlocoparentis asthehumanface forthewelfare/protectionofanimals.
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1)In NarayanDuttBhattv.UnionofIndiaandOthers ,theHighCourtexaminesin detailtheconceptsof ahimsa ornonviolenceandexplainsthatin “ Jainism, ahimsaisnotthemerecausingofviolence,butratherthe ‘severanceofanyof thevitalityinamobileorimmobilebeing.’” Isthereanythinginthefoundations ofU.S.lawthatre fl ectstheseconcepts?Compareandcontrastthisconceptual frameworkusedbytheHighCourtofUttarakhandwiththeapproachinU.S. law? “ Personhood ” asappliedtonatureattemptstoapplypersonhoodrights giventohumanstonature.Whatisthebenefitofthisapproach.Whatalternative
Chapter20:India
Earthlawstrategiesexisttograntingaspectsofnaturelegalrightswithoutgrantingthemstatusas “legalpersons”?Discussandexplaintheprosandconsofthese differentapproaches.
(2)EachofthesecasesdiscussedinthischaptercomefromtheHighCourtof Uttarakhand.Howdoesthecaselawcreatedinonejurisdictioninspireorpersuadecourtsinotherjurisdictions?
CHAPTER21
Israel1
I.INTRODUCTION
TheemergenceofEarthlawinIsraelplaysoutagainstthebackdropofthecountry’ s fragilegeophysicalconditions,afast-growingeconomy,rapidpopulationgrowth,and itshightechnologicalcapacity,suchasdesalinationandwastewaterreuse.Earlyforays intoEarthlaw,particularlytherightsof nature,attempttobreakoutofthecurrent legalparadigmcraftedtosupportagovernancesystemgearedforunfetteredgrowth. EarthlawdevelopmentinIsraelfocusesondemonstratingthecostsofthecurrentgovernancesystemfornaturebyreframingecosystemdevastationandbiodiversityloss throughthelensoftherightsofnaturalentitiestosurviveand flourish.
Israel ’ secologicalcrisishasspawnedenvironmentalactivism,whichhasbeen highlylitigiousinitsapproach.Yetthisac tivism,propelledbyhundredsoforganizationsatboththelocalandnationallevel,isstilllargelyanthropocentric,focusingon protectingnaturebecauseofitsservicestohumansratherthanitsowninherentvalue. Nodoubt,thisapproachismorepragmatict hanideological,sinceenvironmental campaignsaremorelikelytosucceedifthe yappealtotheself-interestofthepublic byviewingnatureasasupplierofcriticalgoodsandservices.
Nevertheless,glimmeringsofarightsof naturedoctrineareemerginginIsrael, andthecountryhasmadeitsowncontribution,albeitsmall,inadvancingglobalEarth law,illustratedbythetwocasestudiesdiscussedbelow.The fi rstcasestudyexamines the2004amendmenttotheWaterLawgranti ngnaturearighttowater;thesecond examinesthemountaingazelle’ spetitiontoIsrael ’ sHighCourtofJusticetoprotect itshabitatfromdevelopment.
II.NATURE’SRIGHTTOWATERUNDERISRAELILAW
Inanaridcountrycharacterizedbychronicwaterscarcity,70yearsofintensehuman activityhaspollutedthecountry ’ swatersourceswithsewageandotherwaste,while capturingtheiruseforindustrial,agricultural,andresidentialpurposes.By1980,
1 ThischapterwasauthoredbyRachelleAdam,FacultyofLaw,HebrewUniversity.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Israel ’ swaterusehadreachedthetotalcapacityofavailablefreshwater. 2 Massive exploitationhasravagedIsrael’sstreams,springs,winterponds,andwetlands,resulting intheirdesiccationandthelossofaquatichabitats.Todayonly3percentremainsof thewetlandsthatexistedacenturyago,mostofitinnationalparksandnature reserves.
Israelhashistoricallysolveditswatershortagebycreatingmorewater.Thecountry makesextensiveuseoftreatedwastewatereffl uentsforirrigationinagriculture.Today, roughly90percentofthewastewatergeneratedisreused, 3 makingIsraeltheworld’ s leadingcountryinwaterreuse.Inaddition,sincethebeginningofthiscentury,Israel hasrankedhighintheproductionanduseofdesalinatedwater,whichnowcomprises approximately70percentofitsdrinkingwatersupply. 4 Thequestionofthesustainabilityofsuchextensivereuseofeffluentsaswellasmassivedesalinationloomslargeover Israel’ sformidablesuccessinovercomingitschronicwaterscarcity.Nevertheless,an admirablegoalofgovernmentpolicyinitssweepinguseofdesalinatedwateristocut backonpumpinggroundwatertoallowtherestorationofnaturalinflowtodevastated streamsandsprings.
Overdrawingofgroundwaterhasreducedaquiferlevelsand,subsequently,spring fl ow,transformingmostoftheperennialstreamsincentralandnorthernIsraelinto intermittentstreamswhoseonlysourceofwaterisrain.Moreover,theconversionof coastalstreamsintosewagecanalshasdam agedtheirrichbiodiversity,including uniqueplantandanimalspecies.Publicang eroverthisecologicalcatastrophe,and thecountry’swatercrisisgenerally, finallyeruptedinthe1990s.Inresponse,thegovernmentinitiatedanextensivestreamrestorationprogramasanationalpriority,supportedbyadecisionfromtheyear2000allocating50millioncubicmetersofwater annuallyforstreaminflow. 5
Harnessingthemomentum,acoalitionofgovernmentofficialsandnatureconservationorganizationsintroducedtheconceptof “nature ’srightstowater,” whichcapturedthepublic ’ simaginationandswiftlybecameakeytalkingpointinthe mainstreamenvironmenta ldialogue.In2002,agovernmentmasterplanforwater managementimplementingallocationsforstreamrestorationdefi nednatureitselfas alegitimateconsumerofwater.Theconc eptofgrantingrightstowatertoIsrael ’ s much-abusedstreamsandotherwetlandsbegantodrivegovernmentpolicy.In2003, thegovernment’sEnvironmentMinistryandNatureReservesAuthorityissuedalandmarkpolicypapercalled “Nature’sRighttoWater” officiallyrecognizingstreams’ entitlementtotheirownnaturalin flowratherthantowaterfromthenationalgrid.Finally, in2004,theconceptwasincorporatedintoIsrael’sWaterLaw.
TheWaterLawisabroadframeworkgoverningthecountry ’ swaterinits entirety fromproduction,allocation,anddistr ibutiontopollution,conservation,
2 ArthurWiener, LevelsofControlinWaterQualityunderConditionsofScarcity,inWaterQualityManagementUnder ConditionsofScarcity:IsraelasaCaseStudy 18(HillelI.Shuvaled.,1980).
3 ZafrirRinat, IsraeliWastewaterPolicyContinuestoPayOff,HAARETZ (Mar.23,2015).
4 MelanieLidman, DesalinationIsn’ttheMagicBullet:WaterAuthorityWarnsIsraelis,TIMESOF ISRAEL (Jun.5,2018).
5 GovernmentDecisionNo.46,EconomicsoftheMinist erialCommitteeonEconomicIssuesfromJuly18, 2000;GovernmentDecision2117fromAug.3,2000(see paragraphon “waterallocationsfornature”).
578
Chapter21:Israel
andrestoration.Atthelaw’sadoptionin1959,6 waterwasperceivedasacommodityfor development,andhencethelawwasinitiallycraftedasatoolforintenseurban,industrial,andagriculturaldevelopment.Yetitevolvedalongsidethegrowingawarenessof theenvironmentalcrisis,andin1972achapteronpollutionpreventionwasadded.7 In1991,strongerenforcementprovisionswereaddedtotheWaterLawtostrengthen pollutioncontrol.8 And,in2004,thelaw finallyevolvedtoguaranteenaturetheright towaterfor “conservationandrestorationofnatureandlandscapes,includingsprings, streamsandwetlands.”9 Thetextofsection6oftheWaterLawreadsasfollows:
Anyrightforwaterislinkedtooneofthewaterpurposesthatarelistedbelow:theright towaterceasesuponthecessationofthepurpose;andthesearethewaterpurposes:
1.Domesticneeds; 2.Agriculture; 3.Industry; 4.Labor,tradeandservices; 5.Publicservices;and 6.Protectionandrestorationofnatureandlandscapevalues,includingsprings,rivers andwetlands(inthislaw —“natureandlandscapevalues”).
Toensureaccountabilityandtransparency,thedirectorofIsrael’sWaterAuthority isrequiredto “submittotheEconomicCommitteeoftheKnesset[thecountry ’slegislativebody]bythe fi rstofAprileachyear,anoti fi cationregardingtheamountof waterthatwasdecidedtoallocateduringthesameyearforthepurposeofnature andlandscapevaluesaccordingtoSection6(6). ” Finally,theexplanatorynoteto thebillclarifiedthatthepurposeoftheamendmentwastoallowforboththeconservationandrestorationofnatureandfreshwatersystems:
Currenteffortstorestorenatureandlandscapevaluesarenotanchoredinlegislation sincetheyarenotlistedinsection6totheWaterLaw,1959 ::: Thesaid sectiondetermines,thatanyrighttowatermustbelinkedto ::: domesticneeds,agriculture,industry,labor,tradeandservices,andpublicservices.Itisproposedtoaddtothe list conservationandrestorationofnatureandlandscapeassets,includingsprings, streamsandwetlands,sothatintheframeworkofwaterallocationsthispurposewillalso betakenintoconsideration.
Lookingbacktodayonthe2004amendmenttoIsrael’sWaterLawallowsabroadperspectiveonthelaw’ simplementationandthechallengesthatarose.Addingnature ’ s righttowatertothelawmandatedthegovernmenttoallocatewatertonatureitself. Furthermore,governmentpolicyhasdeterminedthatthesourceoftheallocations mustbefromthestream ’sownnatural flowratherthanwaterfromthenationalgrid. However,overdrawingfromaquiferscontinuesbecauseofhighhumandemand,while
6 TheWaterLaw,S.H.288(1959).ForthecompletetextoftheWaterLawtranslatedtoEnglish, see https:// www.sviva.gov.il/English/Legislation/Documents/Water%20Laws%20and%20Regulations/WaterLaw1959Excerpts.pdf.
7 AmendmenttotheWaterLaw,S.H.640(1971).
8 AmendmenttotheWaterLaw,S.H.1361(1991).
9 AmendmenttotheWaterLaw,S.H.1948(2004).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
droughthasledtodecreasedrechargingofaquifers,andhencetheover-diversionof freshwaterfromspringsandstreamsforhumanusecontinues.Theresultingtrendis ascarcityofinstream fl owandaseveredecreaseinspringresurgenceinnorthern Israel,whichlacksadesalinationplant toreplacefreshwaterappropriatedfor humans.10
WhileIsrael’slawsandofficialpolicyrecognizenature’srighttowater,government policiesaimedatexpandingtheeconomy andincreasinggrossdomesticproduct togetherwitharapidlygrowingpopulatio nhaveundermineditsimplementation. ThesechallengesarelikelytoincreaseasIsrael ’ spopulationisprojectedtoriseto 20millionby2065,arisefrom8.7millionin2019.11 Atpresent,thepriorityofhuman needsintheallocationofecosystemgoodsandservicesisunquestionedandmayintensifyinthisarid,ecologicallyfragile,andgeographicallysmallcountry.
ThecasestudyofIsrael’sWaterLawdemonstrateshowlawsrecognizingtherights ofnaturecanberenderedpowerlesswhenfacedwithformidablepoliticalforces demandingdevelopmentforhousingandjobs.Section6(6)oftheWaterLawhas notsucceededinwardingoffthethreatsofstreamdesiccation.Whileithasensured thatthegovernmentallocateswatertonature,humansstillhavepriorityovernature. FullenforcementofSection6(6)oftheWaterLawwouldrequire,atleast,meeting thebasicwaterneedsofecosystems.
Arecentdevelopmentprojectunderscoresthe fl awedapplicationofnature’sright towaterinIsrael.Inresponsetoobjectionstoaplanforanewneighborhoodin Jerusalemthatwilldryupadjacentnaturalspringscalled EinLavan (WhiteSpring), thegovernmentplanningcommitteedecidedthat “thepublicneedforthisplanjustifi esitsapproval,despiteitsimpactonthesprings. ” 12 Yetthecommitteecouldnot ignorethegovernment ’ sownmandatetoensurewaterforthesprings,andhence devisedaplantobringwaterfromthenationalgridintothespring’ spools.Thus,a shortcomingoftheright-to-wateramend mentaswrittenisthatitdoesnotcommit thegovernmenttoallocatethesprings’ ownnaturalin fl owasthesourceofwater.In anypetitionforjudicialreview,Israelicourtswouldinalllikelihooddefertothegovernmentexpertswhodevisedtheplanandrefrainfrominterfering.
Ontheotherhand,thegovernmentrecognizedtheecologicalneedtoreturnnaturalin fl owtostreams.InJune2018,itapprovedthe “ StrategicEmergencyPlan AddressingtheWaterSectorUnderDroughtConditions.” Theplancallsfortheconstructionoftwoadditionaldesalinationplantswiththegoalofalmostdoublingthecurrentproductionamountto1.1billioncubicmetersannuallyby2030.Oneofthenew desalinationplantswillbelocatedinnorthernIsrael,toallowforadecreaseinpumpingfromaquifersandthereturnofnaturalinflowtostreamsandsprings.
10 See AssafSoknik&UritSkotlasky, Nature ’ sRighttoWater?DilemmasinRestoringIsrael ’ sStreamsinLightof ChangesintheWaterSector ,4E COLOGYAND E NVT .68-75(Dec.2017)http://www .magazine.isees.org.il/ ArticlePage.aspx?ArticleId=715(Hebrew);GovernmentDecisionNo.3866:StrategicPlanforDroughtinthe WaterSector,2018-2030,https://www.gov.il/he/departments/policies/dec3866_2018(Hebrew).
11 See LidarGraveLazi, Israel ’ sPopulationtoReach20Millionby2065 ,T HE J ERUSALEM P OST (May21,2017), https://www.jpost.com/printarticle.aspx?id=492429#.
12 DecisionsfromtheMeetingsoftheSub-CommitteeforObjections,July18,2019&July28,2019,atp.68,¶2 (Hebrew)
Chapter21:Israel
MeanwhilestreamsandspringsinIsraelcontinueto fi ghtfortheirsurvival.They remainsilentstakeholdersdespitetheimprovementoftheirlegalstatusentitlingthem towaterallocations.To fi llthisgap,Israel ’ ssteamsandspringsrequiretheirown uniquelyde fi nedrights suchasrightsto fl ow,tobefreefrompollution,tofeed andbefedbysustainableaquifer s,torestoration,andothers.13 And,ofcourse,they requirearightofstandingsothattheycanhaverepresentationandprotectthemselves inacourtoflawwhentheserightsarenotenforced.
III.THEGAZELLEPETITION
AfurthercasemodeloftherightsofnatureinIsraelisthe “GazellePetition.” Inthis case,theendangeredIsraelimountaingazelle,togetherwith fi vehumans,petitioned Israel ’ sHighCourtofJusticetopreventthedevelopmentofitshabitat andwon. Incontrasttonature’srighttowaternowestablishedinIsraelilaw,thehumanpetitioners,residentsoftheneighborhoodborderingthemountaingazellehabitat,couldnot pointtoaspeci fi clawgrantingthegazellearighttoitshabitat.Instead,thepetition wasbasedonnatureandwildlifeprotectionlawsthatgrantthegazelleaprotectedstatus,albeitonethatfallsshortofstatutorylegalidentity.
Thefollowingexcerptsarefromthearticle FindingSafePassagethroughaWaveof Extinctions:Israel ’ sEndangeredMountainGazelle thatnarratesandanalyzesthecase. 14 Asyoureadtheexcerpts,rememberthattheobjectivebehindthisprecedentialcase wasnotonlytoprotectthegazelles,butalsotopreventdevelopmentofforestlandthat happenedtobethegazelles’ habitat.Attachingtheiconicgazelleasapetitionertransformeditintotheposterchildofthecampa ign,underscoringthatprotectingthe gazellemeansprotectingtheforestaswell.
FindingSafePassagethroughaWaveofExtinctions:Israel’sEndangered MountainGazelle
In2008,theSupremeCourtofIsraeloverturnedadecisionbythecountry’shighestplanningauthoritytoapprovethedevelopmentof2,000housingunitsonMitspehNeftoah,oneofJerusalem’sfewremainingnaturalareas(See HCQ11745/ 04466/05, Reiss,Roth,Shachaf,Adam,Shefer,GazellaGazellav.Nat ’ lPlanning& BuildingComm. (2008)(Isr.))Thesixpetitionerswerefromaneighboringsuburb: fiveofthemwere Homosapiens andthesixthwasthe Gazellagazella(G.gazella),
13 See EarthLawCenter, UniversalDeclarationofRiverRights,https://www.earthlawcenter.org/river-rights/.
14 RachelleAdam, FindingSafePassagethroughaWaveofExtinctions:Israel’sEndangeredMountainGazelle,19J. OF INTL.WILDLIFE L.&POLY.136-158,136,137,147,148,149,150-151,157(2016).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Israel’smountaingazelleandoneofthecountry’smosticonicspecies.Although therangeofthegazellewasonceextensive,Israelisnowtheonlycountrywhere thespeciesisextant,andeventhereitsfutureappearsgrim.[Asmallpopulation ofapproximately200existsinTurkey.15]GazellenumbersoverallinIsraelhave spiraledsharplydownwardsfromapproximately10,000in1985toabout2,500 today.
Thefollowinganalysisfocusesonastageinthecon flictwhenlocalresidents, togetherwiththemountaingazelle,sue dthegovernmentforbreakingitsown laws andwon.Thecourtdidnot,however,mentionthegazelleinitsdecision, nordiditraisethequestionofitsstandingtosue,makingitasortofelephantin theroom.Butneitherdidthecourtdemandremovalofthegazelleasapartyto thecase;thegazelle,thus,retainsitslegalstatusaspetitioner.
The ::: petitionexplainedthat:
Petitioner6istheIsraeligazelle. ::: Atleast30individualsofthespeciesliveinthe areaofMitspehNeftoah,andtheywillbedirectlyinjuredbytheplan’sapproval anddevelopmentofthearea,comprisingatakingofitshabitat.TheIsraeligazelle isaprotectednatureassetinaccorda ncewiththeNationalParksandNature ReservesDeclaration(ProtectedNaturalAssets), 16 1979,aswellasprotected wildlifeinaccordancewiththeWildlifeProtectionAct,1955. :::
Thelaw,petitionersargued, “ protects[thegazelle]andotherprotected speciesbygrantingthemstatusasprotectedlegalassetsandprotectedwildlife intheorytheyhavestandingtoinitiatelegalactionagainstthosewhowouldharm them.Yetakeydistinctionbetweenthegazellesandourselvesisthattheyare voicelessandsocannotargueforthemselvesbeforethecourt.Sowe,asspeech enabledhumanbeings,steppedinastheirguardians. :::Wearguethatsince thegovernmenthasignoredthepotentialeffectsofthedevelopmentplanon thegazellepopulation,. ::: thegazellesshouldbecomepetitionersthemselves. ::: Petitioner6arguesandPetitioners1 – 5concurthattheNationalParksand NatureReservesLawgrantstheIsraeligazelleapropertyrighttoitsnaturalhabitatandrangeareas,whichithasoccupiedforthousandsofyearsinMitspeh Neftoah.Petitioner6willfurtherarguethatthelawgrantshimstatutoryprotectionofhisrights,aswellastherighttoaddressthishonorablecourtsittingasa HighCourtofJustice,toavoidinjury.Therespondents’ decisiontoapprovethe plan willcausesevereinjurytoPetitioner6anddeprivehimofhisproperty rightsofthousandsofyearstohishabitatinMitspehNeftoah. :::
15 LiaHadasetal., WildGazellesoftheSouthernLevant:GeneticProfilingDefinesNewConservationPriorities,PLOS ONE at2(Mar.11,2015),https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0116401.
16 “NaturalAssets” isdefinedas “anythingorclassofthingsinnature,animal,vegetableorabioticthatoriginateinanareaoftheStateoroutsideit.
AlthoughthegovernmenttooktheviewthatthehighestandbestuseofMitspehNeftoahwasasahousingproject,thepetitionerswantedthecourttoaccept thatthelandatissuehadmoreessentia lusesasaproviderofecosystemgoods andservices,valuesoftheutmostimportance.Thepetitionwas,thus,anambitiouslegalattempttoovercomethelimitationsofananthropocentriclegal system asystemthatrecognizesonlythoselandusesthatare perceived asmost importantforhumanbeingsandthatprioritizelanduseswithoutproperregard forthenaturalsystemsthatunderpinlifeontheplanet:
DecisionmakersinIsrael’splanninginstitutionsactsolelyoutofanthropocentric considerations totallyignoringotherformsoflife. Furthermore,evenifthe onlyconsiderationthatguidestheplanningcommitteesishumanwelfare,weourselvesneedotherspecies. :::
Thecourt’sdecisioncautiouslyavoidedmentionofthegazellesandoftheir legalstatusandstandingbeforethecourt.Itdecidedinfavorofthepetitioners, thecourtsaid,ontwogrounds.First,therespondentshadexceededtheirauthoritybyapprovinganamendmenttothedistrictrezoningplanthatviolated NationalOutlinePlan22forforestsandforestation,inbreachoftheamountof forestlandthatthePlanpermittedfor development.Seco nd,thegovernment haddiscriminatedagainstpetitionersbyviolatingtheirrighttoafairhearingby allowingtheJerusalemdistrictplannert oparticipateintheNationalPlanning Council’ sinternalmeetingontheexaminer ’ s fi ndings,whilstatthesametime refusingthepetitioners’ requesttoparticipateinthesamemeeting.Despitethe governmentattorney ’ sattemptstopersuadethecourtthatthe fl awedgovernmentactionsanddecisionswerereparablethroughfurtherdeliberationanddiscussion,thecourttooktheviewthattheprocesswassoegregiousthatonlyatotal andimmediaterevocationofthedecisionsalreadymadecouldprovidepetitionerswithrelief.
ThisdecisionwasremarkablebecauseIsraelicourtsareloathtosecond-guess governmentexpertsandtypicallydefertothem.Inthisinstance,however,the courtjudgedthattheseverityoftheerrorsinthedecision-makingprocessoverrodecustomarydeference.Inaddition,andonamoresubstantivenote,thecourt emphasizedthehighvalueofIsrael’sfewremainingforestlands.Theirscarcity,it said,obligatesthegovernmenttoconductin-depthanalysisanddeliberationson theimpactoftheirlossonthesurroundingenvironmentpriortodecisionson rezoningforestlandsforurbandevelopment.Notonlywassuchananalysisnot undertakeninthiscase,thecourtnoted,buttheinformationonwhichthegovernmentdidrelywasbotherroneousandinaccurate.
Bysidesteppingtheissueofthegazelle ’ srighttostandingincourt,andby basingitsdecisiononaviolationofNationalOutlinePlan22,thecourtadroitly succeededinprotectingthegazelleswhileatthesametimeavoidingwhatcould havebeensignificantpoliticalcontroversy.Thecourt’savoidanceofthegazelle’ s legalstandingisunderstandableasamatterofinstitutionalself-preservation.It leavesinlimbo,however,thequestionofjusthoweffectiveIsrael ’ sexisting
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
wildlifeprotectionlawscanbeinpreventingextinctions.Thedaywaswonforthe gazellenotbywildlifelawbutbyplanninglawthathas,forthemostpart,succeededinbalancingmultipledemandsforlanduseandkeepingatbaythemore egregiousinterestsofprivateentities. :::
AlthoughtheSupremeCourtcarefullyavoidedaddressingtheunusualpetitionerandtheprovocativeargumentsraisedinfavorofitsstandingtobeapetitioner,theprecedent-makingnatureof thecasedidnotgoentirelyunnoticed bythecourt.Whenpetitionerssubmittedarequestforaninterimorderrestrainingthegovernmentfrommovingaheadwiththeactualdevelopmentuntila final decisioninthecase,presidingJusticeElyakimRubinsteintooktheopportunityto addressthestandingofPetitioner6, G.g.gazella.Thejustice firsthastilydisposed ofthepetitioners ’ requestforarestrainingorde r,relyingonthegovernment attorney ’ sreassurancethatthedetailedplan ’ sapprovalwasnotpendingand actualconstructionwasfarfromtangible.Hetheneagerlyturnedhisattention tothebeguilingnonhumanpetitioner:
IwouldliketoaddthatPetitioner6istheIsraeliGazelle. Ihaveconsideredifan animalitself todifferentiateitfromorganizationsforanimalwelfare canbea petitioner ::: Inactualfact,thegazelledoeshaveaprotectedlegalstatusasa “ protectednatureassetandasprotectedwildlife Butisitpossibletograntitstandingasapetitioner?Ithinkthattheanswerisno [R]egardingthisquestionwe havetodifferentiatebetweentheverydeservingandimportantconceptofanimal protectionasprovidedinvariousformsbyIsraelilegislationandcaselaw,andthe questionofananimalasadirectpartytoa judicialproceeding,sinceit cannot amongstotherissues givepowerofattorneyorthinkoranalyzeas humansdo,or paycourtfees ifthepetitionisrejected,andofcourseIam notexpressinganyopinioninthismatter.
JusticeRubinsteinconcludedbyorderingthepetitionersto “notifythecourt within7daysiftheyarewillingtoremove ‘Petitioner6’ whilekeepingtheirright toraiseargumentsconcerningtheplightofthegazelles. ” Thisobiterdicta receivedagreatdealofmediaattentionthatmisconstrueditasa finaldecision tossingthegazellesoutofthecourthouse.Thehumanpetitionersdeclined,however,toabandonthegazelles,andkeepingthemonboardincurrednoretaliatorydecisionorcourtfees,ashadbeengentlythreatenedbyJusticeRubinstein. Intheend,thegazelleremainedanof ficialpetitionerinthecase.
Theattempttogainjudicialrecognitionofthegazelle’srighttostandingin courtwasintendedtogainforthespeciesalegitimacyincourtsoflawthatanimalsneverenjoy.Itreflectsanunderlyingviewthatitisdif ficult,ifnotdownright impossible,tosavefromextinctionnonhumanspeciesthatwedonotrespector simplyjustdonotcareaboutasmuch asmakingmoreroomformorepeople. Preventingtheirextinctionrequiresgrantingthemmoralconsideration.Reasonablyenough,thecourtwouldnotgothisfar.Itwasvigilantinprotectingitsown integrityandinavoidingwhatmighth aveledtopublicridicule.Thefact
Chapter21:Israel
remains,however,thatthegazellehasalegacyonrecord[as]aformalpetitioner inIsrael’sHighCourtofJustice.Perhapsthissignalstheearliestglimmeringsof Israelisociety’srecognitionthatitdoeshaveadutytopreventtheextinctionof itsownendangeredwildlife.
IV.CONCLUSION
Asshownbytheabovediscussionofnature’ srighttowaterandthegazellepetition, Israel ’ sexperiencewithrightsofnaturehassofarbeenlimited.Yetifthehuman speciesistolivewithinecologicallimitsandsavetheenvironmentfromcompletecollapse,legallyenforceablerightsofnaturemaybeacriticaltool.
Theroleofrightsofnatureistocountertheentrenchedassumptionofhumansas conquerorsofnature,tochallengethebeliefthattheEarth’sresourcesareunlimited, thatnatureisindestructibleandwillrecoverfromwhateverwethrowatit,andthatwe canpopulate,mine,dam,farm, fish,manufacture,andconsumewithoutlimits.While fl awed,afoundationforthedevelopmentofEarthlawinIsraelhasbeenlaidbythe legislativerecognitionoftherightsofwaterandthejudicialacceptance,atleastnominally,ofagazelleinthecourtroom.HowIsraelbuildsfromthisfoundationmaydeterminethefateoffreshwaterhabitat,nativespecies,andecosystems.
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1)Whilestreams,springs,andotherwetlandsinIsraelaretodaylegallyentitledto water,asdiscussedabove,thelawhascertainlynotstoppedthegovernmentfrom movingaheadwithdevelopmentthatthreatenstheexistenceofspringsin Jerusalem.17 Relyingonastatutoryrighttowater,doyouthinkthatthethreatenedspringisentitledtopetitionthecourtsforjudicialreview?Takeintoconsiderationthatwhilethelawrecognizestherightofthespringtowater,itdoesnot gofurtheranddeclarethestreamalegalperson;theprovisiontodeclare streams,springs,andotherwetlandslegalentitiesthatappearedintheoriginal versionofthebilldidnotmakeittothe finalversionoftheamendment.
(2)AfterreadingthecasestudyonIsrael ’srighttowater,explainIsrael ’swatertechnologiesasbothasolutiontothecountry’swidespreadwetlanddesiccationand pollution,aswellasadrawbackinpromotingtherightsofnaturetowater.Will
17 See RachelleAdam, SecuringRightsfortheEinLavanNaturalSpring ,E ARTH L AW C ENTER (Nov.15,2018), https://www.earthlawcenter.org/blog-entries/2018/11/securing-rights-for-the-ein-lavan-natural-spring.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
desalinationandwastewaterreusecontributetonormalizingtherightsofecosystemstowaterinIsraelorisitmorelikelytohavethereverseeffect?
(3)Couldthepublictrustdoctrinesupportthespring ’ sstandingincourt?Under Sec.2oftheWaterLaw, “Israel’swatersourcesbelongtoIsrael’spublic,subject tothecontrolofthestate.” Hencegovernmentof fi cialsarepublictrusteesfor protectingthecountry’secosystems,streams,springs,plants,wildlife,andbiodiversity,butwiththepublicasthebene fi ciaryandnotfortheactualecosystem, stream,orspring.Analternativewouldbetoturnthepublicintotrusteeswith natureasthebene fi ciary,butthiswouldentailnewlegislation,whichcanbe politicallydif ficult.Howwouldyouproposedraftingapetitioninvokingthepublictrustdoctrineundercurrentlegislation?
(4)InconsideringtheNewZealandmodeloflegalidentityforrivers(see Chapters6 and22),wouldyousuggestthismodelforIsrael,aswell,inadditiontonature’ s righttowater?WouldthismodelhelpIsrael’sstreamsrecovertheirinstream flow fromhumans?Orwouldhumansstillhavepriority?IstheNewZealandmodel perhapsunworkableinIsraelbecauseofgeographical,political,andculturaldifferences?Takingthisfurther,doyouforeseethedevelopmentofadiversityof Earthlaw,inadaptationtotheuniqueconditionsofeachcountry?Ifso,what expressionsofEarthlawdoyouseeevolving?
(5)Israel’srightofnaturetowaterlawdemonstratesthefragilityoflawwhenpitted againsthumaninterests.T herestorationofnature ’ sowninstreamwaterto streamsandspringsinIsraelisstillcontingentonhumansdrawingenoughwater fortheirownneeds first.Thus,thelawisnotnecessarilytheultimateprotectorof nature.Aboveall,humanculturalvaluesneedtochange,fromananthropocentricapproachtoanecocentricone.Howwouldyousuggestchangingoursociety’svalues,andwouldlawhaveanyroletoplayinthis?Canlawbeacrafterof culturalvalues,ratherthantheirrefl ection?Inthiscontext,doyouagreewith thepetitionersthatthegazellehadstandingasaconsequenceofitsstatusasprotectedwildlifeandasaprotectednaturalassetunderIsrael’snatureandwildlife protectionlaws?Ordoyouthinkthatstandingcanonlybebestowedbyaspeci fic lawclearlygrantingthatright?Doestheargumentthatthedevelopmentplan threatensthegazelle’spropertyrightsstrengthentheargumentforstanding,or doyouthinkthatarguingpropertyrightsforanonhumanentitywouldbecounterproductivebecauseitreinforcestheconceptofownershipofnature?
(6)Thepetitionersarguedthattheywereactingasguardiansofthevoicelessgazelles byarguingthegazelles’ caseincourt,andthattheirdecisiontobringthegazelle asaformalpetitionerwasaresultofthegovernmentignoringtheimpactofthe planneddevelopmentonthisspeci ficgazellepopulation.Doyouthinkthatthere isacontradictioninthisargument,thatifthepetitionersconsideredthemselves thegazelles’ guardiansandsawtheirroleasspeakingforthem,thegazelleneed notbeaformalpetitioner?Howwouldy ouhavewrittenthejudgmentonthis
speci fi cpoint,drawingperhapsonguardianissuesforminorsandthe incapacitated?
(7)ThejudgmentintheGazellePetitionercasewaswrittenbyIsrael ’ sthenChief JusticeDoritBenisch,probablythemostenvironmentally-mindedjudgethathas eversatonIsrael ’sSupremeCourt.Howmuchdoyouthinkthishadtodowith thepetition ’soutcome?Wouldalessenvironmentallyfriendlyjudgehavebeen morelikelytodemandthatthehumanpetitionersremovethegazelleaspetitioner,asJusticeRubinsteinsuggestedinthe obiterdictum judgmentinthe interimorderhearing?Whatdoesthis sayabouttheobjectivityofthecourts whenhearingcaseschallengingexistingvalues,suchasrightsofnatureissues? And,ifthehumanpetitionershadnotincludedthegazelleasapetitioner,do youthinkthatthecourtwouldstillhaverevokedthegovernment ’sapprovalof thedevelopmentplan?Takingintoconsiderationthatthegazellewasnotmentionedinthejudgment,howdoyoufeelthatitcontributedtothishighlysuccessfulcase?
(8)Linkingthetwocasestudiesdiscusse dinthissection,couldastreamunder threatbydevelopmentplansalsopetitionthecourttoprotectitsintegrityasa stream?Lackingastatutoryrightforstanding,wouldyoualsouseIsrael’snature protectionlawstoclaimstandingforthestream?Whywoulditbecriticaltoverify ifthestreamislocatedinastatutoryna tionalparkornaturereserve?Adding humanpetitionersisasurewaytohedgeyourbetsifthenonhumanentityis removedfromthepetitionbyacourtdecisionandthepetitionconsequentlycollapses.Whatqualificationsshouldthehumanpetitionersideallyhaveinorderto increaseyourchancesofafavorablej udgmenttogetherwiththestreamas petitioner? Chapter21:Israel
CHAPTER22
NewZealand1
“Naturewillsthatthereisnoendtolife ”2
I.INTRODUCTION
AotearoaNewZealand(inclusiveofboththeMāoriandtheEnglishnames),isarelativelyyoungandsparselypopulatedstat e.The1840TreatyofWaitangibetweenthe EnglishQueenandtheIndigenousM ā oriprovidedthetermsofEnglishsettlement andsubsequentgovernment.In2020,asaresultofmostlyEuropeansettlementover thelast200years,Māorimakeupapproximately15percentofthepopulationofabout 5million.3 Those fivemillionpeoplearespreadoveralandareaofapproximatelythe sizeofColorado.
Inrelationtoitsenvironmentallawsandlegalsystem,AotearoaNewZealandisa commonlaw,democraticcountrywithoutaw rittenconstitution.Eventhoughthere isnosinglewrittenNewZealandconstitut ion,thereareconstitutionaldocuments, includingaNewZealandBillofRightsAct1990,andthefoundationalTreatyofWaitangi,signedbyrepresentativesoftheBritishCrownandover500Māorichiefsin1840. However,AotearoaNewZealandalsohasasystemofparliamentarysovereignty,similar tothoseintheUnitedKingdomandinIsrael.Therefore,courtdecisionsareimportant,asinanycommonlawsystem,butcourtsdonothavepowertoinvalidateprocedurallyvalidlawspassedbyParliament,whereasParliamentcanpassalawtooverridea courtdecision.Whiletheseparationofpowersistakenextremelyseriously,andNew Zealandisrepeatedlyrankedasoneoftheleastcorruptnationsintheworld, 4 the make-upofParliament andthusthesystemforappointingparliamentarians determinesthecontentofmostofNewZealand’slaws.
NewZealandisapartytomostinternationalenvironmentalagreementsand pridesitselfonbeingastrongprotectoroftheenvironment.Thatpridemaynot
1 ThischapterwasauthoredbyCatherineJ.IornsMagallanes,BA,LLB(Hons) Well,LLM Yale;Professorof Law,VictoriaUniversityofWellington,NewZealand.
2 The firstsentenceofTeKawaoTeUrewera,themanagementplanforTeUrewera,https://www.ngaituhoe. iwi.nz/te-kawa-o-te-urewera;discussedinSect.23.4B, infra
3 See,e.g.,StatisticsNewZealandonpopulationnumbersandethnicity:http://www.stats.govt.nz.
4 See,e.g. ,TransparencyInternational, CorruptionPerceptionsIndex2019,https://www.transparency.org.nz/ corruption-perceptions-index(lastvisitedMar.16,2020)(rankingNewZealand firstequalwithDenmark).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
re fl ectitsdomesticresultsinpractice.5 Ithasarangeofdomesticenvironmentallaws dealingwithdifferentsubjects;thelargestandmostcomprehensivestatutecreating anintegratedmanagementregimeformostusesofland,air,andwateristheResource ManagementAct1991.Separatelegislationgovernsnationalparks,protectedspecies, animalwelfare,andmostresourceextraction.Separatelegislationalsogovernssome oftheinnovativeenvironmentalco-mana gementandco-govern ancearrangements betweengovernmentandtheMāori.
NewZealandisalsoapartytomostinternationalhumanrightsagreementsand similarlypridesitselfonbeingastrongdefenderofhumanrights.Keydomestichuman rightslawsincludetheBillofRightsActandtheHumanRightsAct;bothareordinary statutesandtheBillofRightscontainssolelycivilandpoliticalrights;nonecontain environmentalrights.ItisthroughNewZealand’shumanrightsframeworkthatmany ofthemoreecocentriclegalmechanismshavebeenmadepartofthelaw.Mostsignificantly,thishastakenplaceasaresultofthesystemsNewZealandhasadoptedfor resolvingIndigenousgrievancestobreachesofthe1840TreatyofWaitangi.
ThischapteroutlinesthreeaspectsofNewZealandlegislationthatcontributeto thebodyofEarthlaw:referencestotheintrinsicvalueofnature,recognitionthatanimalsaresentientbeings,andadoptionoflegalpersonalityfornature.
II.LEGISLATIVERECOGNITIONOFTHEINTRINSICVALUEOF NATURE
SeveralsignificantpiecesofNewZealand’senvironmentallegislationcontainrecognitionofthe “intrinsicworth ” or “ intrinsicvalue” ofnature.Thekeyexamplesarethe ReservesAct1977,theNationalParksAct1980,theConservationAct1987,the ResourceManagementAct1991,theHazardousSubstancesandNewOrganismsAct 1996,andtheMarineandCoastalArea(TakutaiMoana)Act2011.Inaddition,several otherstatutesspecifictoparticularnaturalareasrefertointrinsicvaluesofnature.6
Referencestotheintrinsicworthorintrinsicvalueofnatureoccurmostoftenas partofthegeneralpurposeofthestatuteortheprinciplesbywhichdecisionsunder thestatuteshouldbemade.Interestingly,somestatutesdefinethesetermsbutothers donot;thosewithoutde fi nitionsthusleavethetermstotheirordinarymeaningand definitionbydecision-makersandcourts.
5 Forexample,NewZealandhasbeenranked18th/179i ntheworldforitsproportionalenvironmental impact(where1isthegreatestenvironmentalimpactproportionaltototalresourceavailability i.e.,New Zealandisoneoftheworst20countriesoftheworld).CJABradshaw,XGiam,&NSSodhi, EvaluatingtheRelativeEnvironmentalImpactofCountries ,5(5)PLoSONEe10440(2010),https://doi.org/10.1371/journal. pone.0010440.
6 See,e.g.,WaterConservationOrdersinrespectoftheKawerauandRangitataRivers,thetwostatutesconferringlegalpersonalityonTeAwaTupuaandTeUrewerareferredtolaterinthischapter,someforestandheritagearealegislation,andtheAntarctica(EnvironmentalProtection)Act1994.
590
Chapter22:NewZealand
TheReservesAct1977providesforarangeoftypesofreserves,includingrecreation,historic,scenic,nature,andscienti fi c.Onlytheprovisionde fi ningscenic reservesreferstotheirintrinsicworth:
19ScenicReserves
(1)ItisherebydeclaredthattheappropriateprovisionsofthisActshallhaveeffect,in relationtoreservesclassifiedasscenicreserves
(a)forthepurposeofprotectingandpreservinginperpetuityfortheir intrinsicworthandforthebenefit,enjoyment,anduseofthepublic, suitableareaspossessingsuchqualitiesofscenicinterest,beauty,or naturalfeaturesorlandscapethattheirprotectionandpreservation aredesirableinthepublicinterest.
Theterm intrinsicworth isnotfurtherde finedinthestatute,soitislefttotakeits ordinary(anthropocentric)meaning. 7 Nature’ sintrinsicworth,althoughecocentric inabstraction,isstillrootedinhumanenjoymentofnature.Forexample,thecourts havedeterminedthattheviewfromascenicreserveispartofitsintrinsicworth;8 this justi fi edtheMinisterofConservationgrant ingaleasetoenableconstructionofa gazeboonascenicreservetotakeadvantageoftheview.Indeterminingwhenand where “ protectionandpreservationaredesirable, ” thedecision-makingisbasedon whatis “desirableinthe[human]publicinterest.” Thus,themeasureofintrinsicworth isestablishedanthropocentrically.
TheNationalParksAct1980hasaverysimilarpurposeandreferencetointrinsic worth,butfornationalparks:
Principlestobeappliedinnationalparks
4.ParkstobeMaintainedinNaturalState,andPublictoHaveRightofEntry
(1)ItisherebydeclaredthattheprovisionsofthisActshallhaveeffectforthepurposeof preservinginperpetuityasnationalparks,fortheirintrinsicworthandforthebenefit,use,andenjoymentofthepublic,areasofNewZealandthatcontainsceneryof suchdistinctivequality,ecologicalsystems,ornaturalfeaturessobeautiful,unique, orscientificallyimportantthattheirpreservationisinthenationalinterest.
(2)Itisherebyfurtherdeclaredthat,havingregardtothegeneralpurposesspecifiedin subsection(1),nationalparksshallbesoadministeredandmaintainedunderthe provisionsofthisActthat:
(a)theyshallbepreservedasfaraspossibleintheirnaturalstate:
(b)exceptwheretheAuthorityotherwisedetermines,thenativeplantsand animalsoftheparksshallasfarasp ossiblebepreservedandtheintroducedplantsandanimalsshallasfaraspossiblebeexterminated:
7 Theordinarymeaningofthetextisinterpretedinlightofthepurposeofthelegislation:InterpretationAct 1999,§5(1).
8 SummitRoadSociety(Inc.)v.MinisterofConservation,14NZTPA216(1990)(N.Z.).
(c)sitesandobjectsofarchaeologicalandhistoricalinterestshallasfaraspossiblebepreserved:
(d)theirvalueassoil,water,andforestconservationareasshallbe maintained:
(e)subjecttotheprovisionsofthisActandtotheimpositionofsuchconditionsandrestrictionsasmaybenec essaryforthepreservationofthe nativeplantsandanimalsorforthewelfareingeneraloftheparks,the publicshallhavefreedomofentryand accesstotheparks,sothatthey mayreceiveinfullmeasuretheinspiration,enjoyment,recreation,and otherbenefi tsthatmaybederivedfrommountains,forests,sounds,seacoasts,lakes,rivers,andothernaturalfeatures.
AswiththeReservesAct,theterm intrinsicworth isnotfurtherde fi nedinthe statute,soitissimilarlylefttotakeitsordinarymeaning.Todate,ithasnotbeenconsideredbycourtsinanymannerthathasrefinedthemeaningofthe “intrinsicworth” oftheparks.
TheConservationAct1987refersto intrinsicvalues threetimeswhende fi ning “conservation,”“natureconservation,” and “preservation” :
conservation meansthepreservationandprotectionofnaturalandhistoricresources forthepurposeofmaintainingtheirintrinsi cvalues,providingfortheirappreciation andrecreationalenjoymentbythepublic, andsafeguardingtheoptionsoffuture generations natureconservation meansthepreservationandprotectionofthenaturalresourcesof NewZealand,havingregardtotheirintrinsicvaluesandhavingspecialregardtoindigenous floraandfauna,naturalecosystems,andlandscape preservation,inrelationtoaresource,meansthemaintenance,sofarasispracticable, ofitsintrinsicvalues
ConservationisthegoalandpurposeoftheAct,andthedraftingmakesitclearthat intrinsicworthisakeyfactorindecisionsaboutwhattoconserve,preserve,andprotect.Forexample,thepurposeoftheActisstatedinitsLongTitle: “AnActtopromote theconservationofNewZealand’snaturalandhistoricresources,andforthatpurpose toestablishaDepartmentofConservation.” TheNewZealandSupremeCourthasheld thatthedefinitionof “conservation” anditsinclusioninthepurposeoftheActmeans thattheexistenceof “intrinsicconservationvalues” arekeytotheexistenceandprotectionofconservationland;onlywheresuchvaluesnolongerexistcantheprotectedstatusofconservationlandberevoked.9 Thus,intrinsicvalues,asvaguelydefinedandas anthropocentricallydiscernedastheymay be,haveenabledthestrongprotection soughtbytheAct.
9 Hawke’sBayRegionalInvestmentCoLtdv.RoyalForestandBirdProtectionSocietyofNewZealandInc [2017]1NZLR 1041(N.Z.).Inthisjudicialreview,theconservationstatusoflandwasunabletoberevokedforadam,asitstill hadinherentconservationvalue.TheMinister’s(highlypoliticallycharged)decisiontorevokethatconservationstatuswasquashed.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw 592
Chapter22:NewZealand
TheMarineandCoastalArea(TakutaiMoana)Act2011,alsointhepurposeofthe Act:
recognises,throughtheprotectionofpublicrightsofaccess,navigation,and fishing,the importanceofthecommonMarineandcoastalarea
(i)foritsintrinsicworth;and (ii)forthebenefit,use,andenjoymentofthepublicofNewZealand.
Themeaningof “ intrinsicworth ” againisnotprovidedinthelegislation,norisit addressedincommentariesonthelegislat ion.Ithasnotbeenconsideredbycourts inthecontextoftheTakutaiMoanaAct.
TheResourceManagementAct1991refersto “ intrinsicvaluesofecosystems” in oneofthesectionscontainingtheoverridingprinciplesgoverningdecision-making section7(d).Theseprovisionsarecitedintheirentiretybelow,astheirhierarchyand comparisonwithintheoverallschemeisimportanttotheirinterpretation.Helpfully, thetermisdefinedinthestatute:
intrinsicvalues ,inrelationtoecosystems,meansthoseaspectsofecosystemsandtheir constituentpartswhichhavevalueintheirownright,including
(a)theirbiologicalandgeneticdiversity;and
(b)theessentialcharacteristicsthatdetermineanecosystem’sintegrity,form,functioning,andresilience.”
5.Purpose
(1)ThepurposeofthisActistopromotethe sustainablemanagement ofnaturalandphysicalresources.
(2)InthisAct,sustainablemanagement meansmanagingtheuse,development,and protectionofnaturalandphysicalresourcesinaway,oratarate,whichenables peopleandcommunitiestoprovideforth eirsocial,economic,andculturalwellbeingandfortheirhealthandsafetywhile
(a)sustainingthepotentialofnaturalandphysicalresources(excludingminerals)tomeetthereasonablyforeseeableneedsoffuturegenerations;and
(b)safeguardingthelife-supportingcap acityofair,water,soil,andecosystems;and
(c)avoiding,remedying,ormitigatinganyadverseeffectsofactivitiesonthe environment.
6.MattersofNationalImportance
InachievingthepurposeofthisAct,allpersonsexercisingfunctionsandpowersunder it,inrelationtomanagingtheuse,development,andprotectionofnaturalandphysical resources, shallrecogniseandprovide forthefollowingmattersofnationalimportance:
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
(a)thepreservationofthenaturalcharacterofthecoastalenvironment(includingthe coastalmarinearea),wetlands,andlakesandriversandtheirmargins,andtheprotectionofthemfrominappropriatesubdivision,use,anddevelopment:
(b)theprotectionofoutstandingnaturalfeaturesandlandscapesfrominappropriate subdivision,use,anddevelopment:
(c)theprotectionofareasofsignificantindigenousvegetationandsignificanthabitats ofindigenousfauna:
(d)themaintenanceandenhancementofpublicaccesstoandalongthecoastal marinearea,lakes,andrivers:
(e)therelationshipofMāoriandtheircultureandtraditionswiththeirancestrallands, water,sites,waahitapu,andothertaonga:10
(f)theprotectionofhistoricheritagefrominappropriatesubdivision,use,and development:
(g)theprotectionofprotectedcustomaryrights:
(h)themanagementofsigni ficantrisksfromnaturalhazards.
7.OtherMatters
InachievingthepurposeofthisAct,allpersonsexercisingfunctionsandpowersunder it,inrelationtomanagingtheuse,development,andprotectionofnaturalandphysical resources, shallhaveparticularregardto
(a)kaitiakitanga:11
(aa)theethicofstewardship:
(b)theefficientuseanddevelopmentofnaturalandphysicalresources:
(ba)theefficiencyoftheenduseofenergy:
(c)themaintenanceandenhancementofamenityvalues:
(d)intrinsicvaluesofecosystems:
(e)[Repealed]
(f)maintenanceandenhancementofthequalityoftheenvironment: (g)any finitecharacteristicsofnaturalandphysicalresources: (h)theprotectionofthehabitatoftroutandsalmon: (i)theeffectsofclimatechange:
(j)thebenefitstobederivedfromtheuseanddevelopmentofrenewableenergy.
10 Theterm waahitapu isnotdefinedintheRMA.TheHeritageNewZealandPouhereTaongaAct2014Act defineswāhitaputomeanaplacesacredtoMāoriinthetraditional,spiritual,religious,ritual,ormythological sense.A taonga inMāoricultureisatreasuredthing,whethertangibleorintangible.
11 ThisisaMāoritermmeaningguardianshiporstewardshipandresponsibilityforlandandresources.FordiscussionoftheuseofMāoritermsinNewZealandlegislation, see,e.g.,CatherineIornsMagallanes, TheUseof “TangataWhenua” and “ManaWhenua” inNewZealandLegislation:AttemptsatCulturalRecognition,42(2)VICTORIA U. OF WELLINGTON L.R.259-76(2011).
Chapter22:NewZealand
8.TreatyofWaitangi
InachievingthepurposeofthisAct,allpersonsexercisingfunctionsandpowersunder it,inrelationtomanagingtheuse,development,andprotectionofnaturalandphysical resources,shalltakeintoaccounttheprinciplesoftheTreatyofWaitangi(TeTiritio Waitangi).
Theapplicationofsection7(d),the “intrinsicvaluesofecosystems,” hasbeenconsideredbythecourtsinafewcases.Thisprovision,signi ficantly,doesnothaveasmuch weightasthoseinsection6,whichdecision-makers “shallrecogniseandprovidefor” ; theyneedonly “haveparticularregardto” theintrinsicvaluesofecosystems.12 Thus, intrinsicvaluesarenotasfundamentaltothedefinitionofwhatistobeprotectedorto decision-makingundertheResourceManagementActastheyareinthecontextofthe ConservationAct.
Anillustrationofsection7(d)beingoutweighedbyotherfactorsisprovidedbyan EnvironmentCourtdecisiononanapplicationforanopencastcoalmineonaplateau containingrareplantspeciesandauniq ueandendangeredecosystemwithinNew Zealand.TheEnvironmentCourtconsideredtheapplicationofsection7(d),witha focusontheecosystemintegrity:
Section7(d)requiresparticularregardfortheintrinsicvalueofecosystems.Wehaveno doubtthatifthemineisconsentedontheconditionsproposedtherewillbeareduction inthevalueofecosystemsontheminesite.Connectivityandthecurrentassemblages willbedisruptedorlostbychangessuchasthelossofsomeplantspeciesarelikelyto bepermanentlylosttothesite,andsomeofthosehaveconsiderablerarityvalue.The rangeandvolumeofinvertebrateswillbereducedforaconsiderableperiod,alongwith thevariouseco-systemservicestheyprovide.Weacceptthatelsewhereontheplateau weed-controlandpredatorcontrolwilla ssistinprotectingandenhancingtheecosystemspresent,buttheveryconsiderablelikelihoodofthecompletelossofrareplant speciesfromtheminesiteandtheBarrenVa lleygivesusparticularconcerninthese terms,andweurgedBCL[BullerCoalLimited]duringthehearingtoconsiderwhether adverseeffectsonthatareacouldbeav oidediftheproposalwereotherwise consented.13
Inaddition,theEnvironmentCourtfoundthat “thereisclearlyanadverseeffect ontheproposalonsigni ficanthabitatsofindigenousfauna, ” withitbeing “acentury ormorebeforesimilarhabitatstothosepresentlyexistingwouldbeavailableonthe minesite. ” 14 However,despitethesefactors,th ecourtgrantedtheminingconsent, agreeingtotheapplicant’ssuggestedbiodiversityoffsetsinordertomitigatetheclear biodiversitylossesthatwouldoccurfromthemining.
12 Foranoverviewof§7andhowitoperateswithintheRMA, seeEnvironmentalDefenceSocietyIncv.NewZealand KingSalmonCompanyLtd (2014)NZSC41at26(N.Z.).Themattersin§7areimportantconsiderationstobe borninmindateverystageoftheplanningprocess. SeeMcGuirevHastingsDistrictCouncil, NZRMA557at21 (2001)(N.Z.).
13 WestCoastEnvironmentalNetworkInc.v.WestCoastRegionalCouncilandBullerDistrictCouncil (2013)NZEnvC 47at319(N.Z.).
14 Id. at324.
IntheotherRMAdecisionstoconsidersection7(d),thecourtsdidnotdiscussthe meaningof “intrinsicvalue” inanydetailbutmerelyassertedthatitwouldbeupheld bythepromotionofconservationmeasures.Forexample,inrelationtotheuseofa particularpoisontocontrolintroducedandinvasivepestswithinawildlifesanctuary, thepartiesdisagreedabouttheeffectsofthispoisononintrinsicvaluesofecosystems.15 TheHighCourtconsideredthatpesteradicationinthenameofconservation “satisfies theRMApromotionofprotectionofnaturalresourcesandecosystemswithintrinsic value ” becauseoftheultimateaimofprotectingandconservingsuchecosystems,but didnotdiscussanymoredetail.
Asanotherexample,inanappealrelatingtoaconsentgivenforasolidwastelandfi ll,intrinsicecologicalvalueswereidenti fiedasareasoninfavorofimposingconditionsinrelationtotheprotectionofindigenousvegetation.16 Fourhundredhectares oflandsurroundingtheland fillwouldberevegetatedandturnedintoaconservation area.TheEnvironmentCourtwaspersuad edthattheproposedconservationarea wouldproducesigni fi cantecosystembene fi tsand “ thattheintrinsicvaluesofthe ecosystemswouldatleastbemaintainedand,inallprobability,significantlyenhanced asaresultoftherestorationprojectandconservationmanagementarea.”17 Therewas nodiscussionoftheintrinsicvalue,morejusttheassertionthatitwouldbeupheld.
Inanothercase,theEnvironmentCourtstatedthat “[a]hugepartofthiscaseis abouttheintrinsicvaluesofecosystems. ”18 However,therewassimilarlynoseparate discussionofwhatintrinsicvaluemeant,justdiscussion albeitextensive ofthe preservationofindigenous fl oraandfauna.Thecaseconcernedhydroelectricpower generationonariver,whereakeyconcernwastheeffectofchangedwater fl owson waterqualityintheriver,onfreshwatersp ecieswithinthatriver,andonthelower braidedareasoftheriverandthewetlandsdownstreamthatweresigni fi canthabitats fornative fl oraandfauna.LocalM ā origuardiansofferedevidencethatthe mauri thespiritualvalue oftheriverwouldbesignifi cantlyadverselyaffected.TheCourt agreed “thattherewillbeageneraladverseeffectonthemauri” oftheriver.Whilethat wouldbepartlyoffsetbyconditionsenhancingaquaticsdiversity,wetlands,and braidedriverbirds,allofwhichcontributetothat mauri, “thereremainsanetlossto themaurioftheriver.” 19 Despitethis,thecourtconsideredthattheproposalwould beofnetbene fittothecommunity,inlightoftherenewableenergygeneration.The courtwasaccordinglypreparedtograntco nsentsforthewaterdiversionsaslongas conditionswereamendedtobetterprotectwetlandsandthebraidedriverbirds.20
TheHazardousSubstancesandNewOrganismsAct1996hasaprovisionsimilarto thatintheResourceManagementAct,whereby “theintrinsicvalueofecosystems” is
15 BrookValleyCommunityGroupIncv.TheTrusteesoftheBrookWaimaramaSanctuaryTrust (2018)NZRMA51,at 20(N.Z.).
16 TranswasteCanterburyLtdv.CanterburyRegionalCouncil,NZEnvC,DecisionC29/2004(22March2004)at 284(N.Z.).
17 Id. at266.
18 LowerWaitakiRiverManagementSocietyIncv.CanterburyRegionalCouncil&MeridianEnergyLtd,NZEnvC,DecisionC80/2009(24September2009)at231(N.Z.).
19 Id. at457,519.
20 Id. at558.Itisnotedthatthisjudgmentrunsto241pages,withanadditional40pagesofAnnexures.There are560paragraphsandmorethan800footnotes.Theenvironmentalissuesarediscussedindetail.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw 596
Chapter22:NewZealand
oneofalistofsixmattersthatdecision-makersmust “takeintoaccount” whenexercisingfunctionsundertheAct.21 ThisActalsocontainsthedefinitionof “intrinsicvalues” adoptedintheRMA:
intrinsicvalues,inrelationtoecosystems,meansthoseaspectsofecosystemsandtheir constituentpartswhichhavevalueintheirownright,including (a)theirbiologicalandgeneticdiversity;and (b)theessentialcharacteristicsthatdetermineanecosystem’sintegrity,form,functioning,andresilience.
Professionallegalpracticeguidestothislegislationsuggestthatinterpretationsofthe equivalent “RMAprovisionsarelikelytoprovidesomeguidanceininterpretingthese provisionsoftheHSNOAct.”22 Inotherwords,theacademiclegalcommunityexpects themeaningofnature’sintrinsicvaluewillbecometobeunderstoodastranscending speci ficlaws.
III.LEGISLATIVERECOGNITIONTHATANIMALSARE SENTIENTBEINGS
In2015,theNewZealandParliamentpassedamendmentstothe1999animalwelfare legislation,asaresultofthe fi rstreviewofthatlegislationsince1999.OnMay10, 2015,section4oftheAnimalWelfareAmendmentAct(No.2)explicitlyincludeda recognitionthatanimalsaresentient.Thisfollowedcampaigningfromanimalrights andwelfareadvocates,suchthatthegov ernmentdepartmentresponsibleforthe reviewrecommendedthatitberecognizedinthetitletotheActand/orapreamble.
TitleoftheAnimalWelfareAct1999:
AnAct
(a)toreformthelawrelatingtothewelfareofanimalsandthepreventionoftheirilltreatment;and,inparticular,
(i)torecognisethatanimalsaresentient:
(ia)torequireownersofanimals,andpersonsinchargeofanimals, toattendproperlytothewelfareofthoseanimals:
(ii)tospecifyconductthatisorisnotpermissibleinrelationtoanyanimalor classofanimals:
(iii)toprovideaprocessforapprovingtheuseofanimalsinresearch,testing, andteaching:
21 HazardousSubstancesandNewOrganismsAct1996,§6(b).
22 DRandal, “HazardousSubstancesandNewOrganismsAct1996” , EnvironmentalandResourceManagement LawOnline,LEXISNEXIS,at11.5(Nov2019).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
(iv)toestablishaNationalAnimalWelfareAdvisoryCommitteeanda NationalAnimalEthicsAdvisoryCommittee:
(v)toprovideforthedevelopmentan dissueofcodesofwelfareandthe approvalofcodesofethicalconduct:
Thetermsentientisnotde fi nedintheAct.Theonlyothersectionwheresentienceisreferredtoisinrelationtoapprovalsforanimalsinresearch,testing,and teaching.Apurposeoftheprovisionsontheuseofanimalsinresearch,testing,and teachingis “ toreplaceanimalsassubjectsforresearch,andtestingbysubstituting, whereappropriate,non-sentientornon-livingalternatives. ” 23 Twoofthecriteriafor assessingapplicationsforanimaluseareaccordingly: “theextenttowhichtherehas been (i)assessmentofthesuitabilityofusingnon-sentientornon-livingalternatives intheproject;and(ii)replacementofanimalsassubjectswithsuitablenon-sentientor non-livingalternatives. 24 Consequently,theprimepracticaleffectoftheuseofthe word(andconcept) “ sentient ” willbeviastatutoryinterpretation,ascourtsare requiredtointerpretthetextofalllegislation “inlightofitspurpose.”25
NeithertheExplanatoryNotetotheAmendmentBillnortheparliamentary debatesonitdiscussedtheinclusionof “sentient,” indicatingthatitwasnotof ficially seenasbeingofmuchsignificance.ThegovernmentministryresponsiblefortheAct categorizeditasmerelya “minorandtechnicalamendment”26 andasymbolicgesture that “wouldnotaffectthedetailoftherights,dutiesorobligationssetoutwithinthe bodyoftheAct. ” 27 Somecriticshavecalledit “ politicalpufferytomaintainNew Zealand ’ sreputationforthesakeofappearan cestooverseasmarkets,andwindow dressingtoappeaseNewZealand’sanimalwelfaregroups.”28
Incontrast,theNewZealandVeterinaryAssociationsaysthatthelegalrecognition ofanimalsentienceforthe firsttimeinNewZealandlawisoneofthe “keychanges” to thelegislation.Itsinclusion “stronglyreinforcesthatpeopleareobligedtomeettheir animals’ physicalhealthandbehaviouralneeds,andplacesNewZealandatthe ‘forefrontofprogressiveanimalwelfarelegislation.’”29
23 AnimalWelfareAct1999,§80.
24 AnimalWelfareAct1999,§100(1)(fa);inserted,on9November2015,by§41(3)oftheAnimalWelfare AmendmentAct(No2)2015(2015No49).
25 InterpretationAct1999,§5(1).
26 MinistryofPrimaryIndustries, “OverviewoftheAnimalWelfareAmendmentBill:Updatedfollowingthe SelectCommitteeProcess,” https://www.mpi.govt.nz/dmsdocument/6766.
27 MinistryforPrimaryIndustries AnimalWelfareAmendmentBill:ReportfortheMinistryofPrimaryIndustries (Feb. 2014)at69.
28 IanRobertson&DanielGoldsworthy, “ToFeelorNottoFeel;ThatistheLegalQuestion” 2017NZLJ10,at 10.
29 NewZealandVeterinaryAssociation,Pressrelease, “LandmarkAnimalWelfareLegislationWelcomedby Vets,S COOP (May5,2015),https://www.scoop. co.nz/stories/PO1505/S00047 /landmark-animal-welfarelegislation-welcomed-by-vets.htm.
598
Chapter22:NewZealand
Inbetweenthesepositions,thechairoftheNationalAnimalEthicsAdvisoryCommitteesaiditwas “ anotherstepalongtheanimalwelfarejourney ” and “ provideda strongerunderpinning ” fortheotherprovisionsinthelegislation.30
AsubmissionbytheSocietyforthePrev entionofCrueltytoAnimals(SPCA) arguedthatthedeclarationofsentiencewasneeded “becausemostNewZealandlaw treatsanimalsas ‘things’ and ‘objects’ ratherthanaslivingcreatures.” AregionalSPCA manageraccordingly “ hopedthatrecognisinganimalsassentientbeingswouldadd ‘moreweight’ toabuseandneglectcasesincourt.”31 Thismayindeedhavehappened already,astherecognition “thatanimalsaresentient” wasacknowledgedbytheNew ZealandCourtofAppealasoneoftheparticularpurposesoftheactrelevanttosentencingforaconvictionofextremeanimalcruelty. 32 However,itishardtosaythat thesameresultcouldnothavebeenachievedwithoutthatclause,asitwasonlyone ofquiteafewthingslisted,andtheanimal’ssufferingwasalreadyakeyaspectofthe prosecutionandsentencing.
Anotherconcretesuggestionforapositiveeffectoftherecognitionofsentienceis thatitcouldexpandtheresponsibilitiesofanimalcaregivers.Atpresent,theexpectationsforcompliancewithanimalwelfarestandardsfocusesonavoidingpainandsuffering.Sentienceincorporatesthefactthatanimalscanexperiencepleasureaswell aspain,sosomewritersarguethatitmustextendthedutiesoncaregiverstoadequatelyprovideforpositiveexperiencesforanimals,notjustavoidnegativeones.33
Finally,somelegaladvocatessuggestthatthispavesthewayfortheintroductionof classactionsonbehalfofanimals. 34 Perhapsthenext “stepalongtheanimalwelfare journey ” thatsentiencepaves,afterrecognitionofanimalsasbeingswithfeelings,is therecognitionofanimalsasl egalpersons,withallthelegalimplicationsthatthat mayhave.35 ThroughtheuniquerelationshipbetweentheMāoriandtheNewZealand government,andthoughtfulcreativeproblem-solving,lawhasbeendevelopedtomore effectivelyprotectsentientbeings.Ascourtsconsiderandconstruethemeaningof “sentience,” theywilldeterminehowbroadlyitmaybeconstrued.
30 AsquotedinJonathanCarson, “NewZealandLegallyRecognisesAnimalsas ‘Sentient’ Beings,” STUFF (May 9,2015),https://www.stuff.co.nz/nelson-mail/68363264/new-zealand-legally-recognises-animals-as-sentientbeings.
31 Id.
32 AucklandRoyalNewZealandSocietyforthePreventionofCrueltytoAnimalsv.MacPherson [2019]NZDC4102 (N.Z.).Inthiscasethedefendantusedsustainedandextremeviolence,breakingadog’slegintopieces,with theextentoftheinjuriesandlackoftreatmentcausingthedogseverepain,distress,andsuffering.Thedefendantwasimprisonedandorderedtopayreparationsfortheveterinaryandothercosts.
33 Robertson&Goldsworthy, supra note28,at12-13.ThisisinlinewiththeexpansionoftheolderFiveFreedomsmodeltotheFiveDomainsandafocusonqualityoflifeoverall.
34 Id. at10.
35 SeeChapter11, “NonhumanRights,” inthisbook.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
IV.LEGALPERSONALITYFORNATURE
Aswithothersettledcountriesaroundthe worldwithsurvivingIndigenouspeoples, Māorihavemadelegalandpoliticalclaimstolandsandresourcesthattheyhavelost throughsettlement.NewZealandiswidelyregardedasbeingattheforefrontofinitiativestorecognizeIndigenousrightsa ndresolvesuchclaims,includingthe co-managementandco-governanceofNewZealand’slandandresourceswithMāori.
NewZealanddoesnotrecognizeanyhumanrighttoahealthyenvironment,nor haveexistinghumanrightsbeenextende dtoenableanyremediesforviolations throughdegradedenvironments.However,therecognitionofIndigenousrightsand theresolutionofclaimsbasedonth elandtakenbytheBritishfromtheM ā orihas ledtotherecognitionofIndigenousenvir onmentalrightsandresponsibilities. ThroughtheprotectionofIndigenouswo rldviewsandIndigenousenvironmental management,thisparticularcombination hasentailedtheadoptionofmeasuresfor environmentalprotectionthatgobeyonds impleclaimstorightstoalsoimplement complexnotionsofresponsibilityandguardianshiponthepartofindividuals,communities,andthestate.ItisthroughthisrecognitionandsystemforresolvingtheIndigenouspeople ’ sgrievancesthatthelegislaturehasadoptedtheinnovativeuseoflegal personhoodfornaturalfeatures.
A.MāoriEnvironmentalPhilosophies
M ā oriculturalbeliefsviewnaturaland geographicalfeaturesasancestors.36 Itisthe responsibilityofM ā oritodaytoactasguardiansandcarefortheirenvironmental ancestors,whichwillintur nprotectandlookafterthepeople.Theenvironmentis believedtobeinhabitedbyspirits,suchtha teachenvironmentalfeaturehasitsown spiritandlifeforce;humanactionsmustmaintainthislifeforce.Partofbeingancestrallyconnectedtonaturemeansthathumansarenotconsideredseparatefromor aboveit,andtheycannotownit.Whatisimportantfortheinterplaybetweenhuman rightsandtheenvironmentisthattheyareintertwined:humanwell-beingexistsin tandemwiththatofthenonhumannatural world,andeachcaresfortheother.Itis nocoincidencethatthesebeliefsareheldbyIndigenouspeoplesworldwide.
Overthelast40years,theabilityofMāoriasIndigenouspeoplestomanagenaturalresources 37 inawaythatisconsistentwithaM ā oriworldviewhasgraduallybeen incorporatedinNewZealandlawthroughTreatyofWaitangigrievancesettlements, judicialdecisions,anddomesticlegislati on,aswellasthroughlocal,regional,and nationalpolicy.38 Itisnoteworthythatthiscoverspubliclyownedlandsandresources, notjustonescurrentlyownedbyMāori,andthatthishasoccurredwithinaWestern
36 Formoredetail, see CatherineIornsMagallanes, MāoriCulturalRightsinAotearoaNewZealand:Protectingthe CosmologythatProtectstheEnvironment,21(2)WIDENER L.REV.273-327(2015).
37 Aswithotherchapters, “naturalresources” isusedheretodescribetheelementsofnaturecommonlyutilizedbyhumankind,althoughtheeditorsofthisboo kacknowledgetheneedtobegindescribingnature beyonditseconomicutilitytohumansasaresource.
38 ALAN WARD,AN UNSETTLED HISTORY:TREATY CLAIMSIN NEW ZEALAND TODAY 34(1999).
Chapter22:NewZealand
legalsystem.Inparticular,Māoricosmology,includingthespiritualrelationshipwith theenvironment,hasbecomearequiredconsiderationinmostenvironmental decision-makingandhasevenbeengiven “primacy ” asamatterofnationalimportance whenbalancingcompetingfactors.39 Decision-makersundertheResourceManagementActarealsorequiredtopayparticularregardtotraditionalM āori kaitiakitanga (guardianship)orstewardshipofnaturalresources.40 Thisstartedwithcourtdecisions upholdingtheimportanceoftheTreatyandisnowenshrinedintheResourceManagementAct.41
M ā orirelationshipswiththenaturalworldhavealsobeenrecognizedandprotectedthroughgrievancesettlementagr eementsbetweentheNewZealandgovernmentandM ā ori,andtheseareenshrinedinlegislation.Overthelast30years,the governmentandclaimantshavedeviseda widerangeofoptionstorecognizeand restoreM ā oritribalspiritual,cultural,andtraditionalassociationswiththenatural environment,aswellastorecognizeandrestoreMāoriculturalauthority.42 Theyhave includedjointmanagementoflandsandresourcesbetweenthegovernmentand Māoriandtribalownershipofnaturalsitesofgreatculturalsigni fi cancetothetribes, includingthebedsofriversandlakes.43 Themostsigni fi cantofthesemeasureshas beentherecentcreationofseparatelegalpersonalityfornaturalbeings,suchasrivers, withjointtribal/governmentrepresentationandguardianshipofthatbeing ’ s interests.44
Accordingly,legalpersonhoodor personalitytonaturalbeings suchasrivers, mountains,andevenbroadareasofterritorycomprisingecosystems isbeingincreasinglyarguedandusedasatooltoaccordrightstonatureand/orbetterimplement humanresponsibilityforit. 45 NewZealandhaslegislativelyaccordedpersonhoodtoa riverandtowhatwasanationalparkand,atthetimeofthiswriting,hasagreedto dosoforamountain.Thelegislationdoesnotexplicitlyrecognizerightsofnaturein thesenserightsaregenerallyrecognizedinlegalsystems.Itwasnotdesignedprimarily topreventorremedyenvironmentaldegradation.Rather,thelegislationwasdesigned toimplementaMāoriIndigenousvisionofhumanresponsibilityforandrelationship withournaturalenvironmentandwasdonetobetterupholdIndigenouspeople ’ s rights.Whilethelegislationrecognizes theintrinsicvalueoftheenvironment i.e., initsownright italsorecognizesthatpeoplearepartoftheenvironmentanditis intendedtopromoteco-existencebetweenpeopleandallnaturalenvironments.
39 EnvironmentalDefenceSociety,Inc.v.MangonuiCountyCouncil (1989)3NZLR257(CA)(N.Z.).
40 ResourceManagementAct1991,§7.
41 ResourceManagementAct1991,§§6-8.
42 See,e.g., DeanCowie, TheTreatySettlementProcess , IN TREATYOF WAITANGI SETTLEMENTS 48,61(J.Hayward& N.Wheeneds.,2012).
43 See,e.g.,theNgaiTahuClaimsSettlementAct1998;OfficeofTreatySettlements(2015),(n66)at90-94.
44 TeAwaTupua(WhanganuiRiverClaimsSettlement)Act2017andTeUreweraAct2014. Seealso Iorns Magallanes, supra note36.
45 See,e.g,S.RaviRajan,CatherineIornsMagallanes&KirstenDavies, IdentifyingHumanRightsandtheEnvironment, ENCYCLOPEDIAOF HUMAN RIGHTSANDTHE ENVIRONMENT,183,atnotes12-19(JamesRMay&ErinDalyeds., 2019).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
B.TeUrewera46
TeUreweraNationalParkwascreatedinthe1950soutofancestrallandconfiscatedfrom theMāoriTūhoepeople.47 Thiswasthesubjectofagrievanceagainstthegovernment, thesettlementofwhichculminatedintheTeUreweraAct2014.48 Keytothissettlement wasTūhoeregainingcontroloftheTeUreweraNationalParkandtheabilitytoexercise its kaitiakitanga (guardianship)overTeUrewera,alongwithexplicitacknowledgmentof themetaphysicalrelationshipofTūhoewiththeirancestralland.49 Themethodofachievingthiswasthroughthecreationoflegalpersonhoodforthepark,wherebyTeUrewera wouldobtainitsownseparateidentity,withtheestablishmentofalegalguardianforTe Urewera.Whatwasanationalparkcannowbegovernedindependently,withsignificant TūhoeinputandinaccordancewithTūhoeprotocolandcustom.
Underthisagreement,TeUreweraisnolongeranationalpark.Itisitsownlegal entity,with “alltherights,powers,duties,andliabilitiesofalegalperson.”50 Thislegal statuspermitsTeUreweratoholdtitletoland(i.e.,titletoitself),whichismanagedby itsguardian,theTeUreweraBoard,thatacts “ onbehalfof,andinthenameof,Te Urewera. ” Adetaileddiscussionofthisguard ianshiparrangementispresentedin Chapter6, “LegalGuardianshipandRepresentation.”
BoardmembershipisamixofTūhoetrusteesandgovernmentappointees.TheAct grantstheBoardextensivepowersandobligations,includingthepowertomakeby-laws andtograntactivitypermitswithinTeUrewera.Tūhoespiritualityisdirectlyprovidedfor inBoarddecision-making.TheprinciplesgoverningtheimplementationoftheActfocus primarilyonaspectsofenvironmentalprotectionbutarealsoprotectiveofIndigenous relationshipswiththeparkandofpublicaccessforthebenefitofallNewZealanders.
TheBoardreleasedtheirmanagementplanforTeUrewera, TeKawaoTeUrewera, in2017(“TeKawa”).51 Thisplanshowsanewvisionoftherightsandresponsibilities betweenhumansandtheenvironment.TheoverridingpurposeofTeKawaistodelineatedignityandcommandrespectfornatureandtoreaffirmthesubordinateplaceof humanswithinit. 52 Itemphasizesdutyand “ responsibility notpowerorrights ” throughoutthedocument.Itexpresslystates: “[T]heBoardthroughTeKawaisdisruptingthenotionofourfalsesuperiorityoverthenaturalworld ::: wearereturning toourplaceinnature,asherchild.”53
46 ThisdescriptionofTeUreweraisadaptedfromCatherineIornsMagallanes, “Humanrights,responsibility andlegalpersonalityfortheEnvironmentinAotearoaNewZealand”,ENCYCLOPEDIAOF HUMAN RIGHTSANDTHE ENVIRONMENT,550,at554-555(JamesRMay&ErinDaly,eds.,2019).
47 DepartmentofConservation, TeUreweraNationalParkManagementPlan 1(2003). Seealso NgaiTuhoe, TeUrewera (2015),http://www.ngaituhoe.iwi.nz/te-urewera.
48 TangataWhenua(2012) “HistoricTreatySettlementforTuhoe,” 11September,2012.Retrieved30June 2017fromhttp://news.tangatawhenua.com/2012/09/historic-treaty-settlement-for-tuhoe/.
49 TeUreweraAct2014,§9(36).
50 Id. at§11(1).
51 TeKawaoTeUrewera:TheTeUreweraManagementPlan (2017),http://www.ngaituhoe.iwi.nz/Te-Kawa-o-TeUrewera.
52 Id. atp.15.
53 Id
Chapter22:NewZealand
PART1:TEUREWERA
Subpart1 Background,Purpose,andPrinciples
3.BackgroundtothisAct
TeUrewera
(1)TeUreweraisancientandenduring,afor tressofnature,alivewithhistory;its sceneryisabundantwithmystery,adventure,andremotebeauty.
(2)TeUreweraisaplaceofspiritualvalue,withitsownmanaandmauri.
(3)TeUrewerahasanidentityinandofitself,inspiringpeopletocommittoitscare.
TeUreweraandTūhoe
(4)ForTūhoe,TeUreweraisTeManawaoteIkaaMāui;itistheheartofthegreat fi shofM ā ui,itsnamebeingderivedfromMurakareke,thesonoftheancestor Tūhoe.
(5)ForTūhoe,TeUreweraistheirewewhenua,theirplaceoforiginandreturn,their homeland.
(6)TeUreweraexpressesandgivesmeaningtoT ū hoeculture,language,customs, andidentity.ThereTūhoeholdmanabyahikāroa;theyaretangatawhenuaand kaitiakiofTeUrewera.
TeUreweraandallNewZealanders
(7)TeUreweraisprizedbyotheriwiandhapū whohaveacknowledgedspecialassociationswith,andcustomaryinterestsin,partsofTeUrewera.
(8)TeUreweraisalsoprizedbyallNewZealandersasaplaceofoutstandingnational valueandintrinsicworth;itistreasuredbyallforthedistinctivenaturalvaluesof itsvastandruggedprimevalforest,andfortheintegrityofthosevalues;forits indigenousecologicalsystemsandbiodiversity,itshistoricalandculturalheritage, itsscienti fi cimportance,andasaplaceforoutdoorrecreationandspiritual reflection.
T ūhoeandtheCrown:sharedviewsandintentions
(9)TūhoeandtheCrownsharetheviewthatTeUrewerashouldhavelegalrecognitioninitsownright,withtheresponsibilitiesforitscareandconservationsetout inthelawofNewZealand.Tothisend,TūhoeandtheCrownhavetogethertaken auniqueapproach,assetoutinthisAct,toprotectingTeUrewerainawaythat reflectsNewZealand’scultureandvalues.
(10)TheCrownandTūhoeintendthisActtocontributetoresolvingthegriefofTūhoe andtostrengtheningandmaintainingtheconnectionbetweenT ū hoeandTe Urewera.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
4.PurposeofthisAct
ThepurposeofParts5to7istoestablishandpreserveinperpetuityalegalidentityandprotectedstatusforTeUreweraforitsintrinsicworth,itsdistinctivenaturalandculturalvalues, theintegrityofthosevalues,andforitsnationalimportance,andinparticularto
(a)strengthenandmaintaintheconnectionbetweenT ū hoeandTe Urewera;and
(b)preserveasfaraspossiblethenaturalfeaturesandbeautyofTeUrewera,theintegrityofitsindigenousecologicalsystemsandbiodiversity, anditshistoricalandculturalheritage;and
(c)provideforTeUreweraasaplaceforpublicuseandenjoyment,for recreation,learning,andspiritualreflection,andasaninspirationforall.
5.PrinciplesforimplementingthisAct
(1)InachievingthepurposeofthisAct,allpersonsperformingfunctionsandexercisingpowersunderthisActmustactsothat,asfaraspossible,
(a)TeUreweraispreservedinitsnaturalstate:
(b)theindigenousecologicalsystemsandbiodiversityofTeUreweraarepreserved,andintroducedplantsandanimalsareexterminated: (c)T ū hoetanga,whichgivesexpressi ontoTeUrewera,isvaluedand respected:
(d)therelationshipofotheriwiandhap ū withpartsofTeUreweraisrecognised,valued,andrespected:
(e)thehistoricalandculturalheritageofTeUreweraispreserved: (f)thevalueofTeUreweraforsoil,water,andforestconservationis maintained:
(g)thecontributionthatTeUreweracanmaketoconservationnationallyis recognised.
(2)InachievingthepurposeofthisAct,allpersonsperformingfunctionsandexercisingpowersunderthisActmustactsothatthepublichasfreedomofentryand accesstoTeUrewera,subjecttoanyconditionsandrestrictionsthatmaybenecessarytoachievethepurposeofthisActorforpublicsafety.
Subpart3:LegalIdentityofTeUreweraandVestingofTeUreweraLand Legalentity
11.TeUreweraDeclaredtobeLegalEntity
(1)TeUreweraisalegalentity,andhasalltherights,powers,duties,andliabilitiesofa legalperson.
(2)However,
(a)therights,powers,anddutiesofTeUreweramustbeexercisedandperformedonbehalfof,andinthenameof,TeUrewera
Chapter22:NewZealand
(i)byTeUreweraBoard;and (ii)inthemannerprovidedforinthisAct;and
(b)theliabilitiesaretheresponsibilityofTeUreweraBoard,exceptasprovidedforinsection96.
13.TeUreweraLandInalienable
TeUreweralandmustnotbealienated,mortgaged,charged,orotherwisedisposedof, except
(a)inaccordancewithsection111;or (b)ifaleaseoraneasementisgrantedundersection62(1).
PART2:GOVERNANCEANDMANAGEMENTOFTEUREWERA
Subpart1 TeUreweraBoard
Purposes,functions,andpowersofBoard
17.PurposesofBoard
ThepurposesoftheBoardare
(a)toactonbehalfof,andinthenameof,TeUrewera;and (b)toprovidegovernanceforTeUrewerainaccordancewiththisAct.
18.FunctionsofBoard
(1)ThefunctionsoftheBoardare
(a)toprepareandapproveTeUreweramanagementplan;and (b)toadvisethepersonsmanagingTeUreweraontheimplementationofthe managementplan,includingbymeanssuchas
(i)issuinganannualstatementofprioritiesforimplementingthe managementplan:
(ii)undertakinganyspeci fi edfunctionsinrelationtotheannual operationalplanforTeUrewera: (iii)monitoringtheimplementationoftheannualoperational plan;and
(c)toinitiateproposalsandmakerecommendationsfor
(i)addinglandto,orremovinglandfrom,TeUrewera;and (ii)acquiringinterestsinland;and (iii)establishingspeciallyprotectedareas,wildernessareas,and amenityareaswithinTeUrewera;and
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
(d)tomakebylawsforTeUrewera;and
(e)toauthoriseactivitiesthatmustnototherwisebeundertakeninTeUrewerawithoutanauthorisationunderPart2;and
(f)toprepareorcommissionreports,advice,orrecommendationsonmattersrelevanttothepurposesoftheBoard;and
(g)topromoteoradvocatefortheinterestsofTeUrewerainanystatutory processoratanypublicforum;and
(h)toliaisewith,advise,orseekadvice fromanyagency,localauthority,or otherentityonmattersrelevanttothepurposesoftheBoard;and
(i)toperformanyotherfunctionoftheBoardspecifiedinthisActorinany otherenactment;and
(j)totakeanyotheractionthattheBoardconsiderstoberelevantandappropriateinachievingitspurposes.
(2)Inperformingitsfunctions,theBoardmayconsiderandgiveexpressionto
(a)Tūhoetanga:[culturalcharacteristicsspecifictotheTūhoe] (b)Tūhoeconceptsofmanagementsuchas
(i)rāhui:
(ii)tapumenoa: (iii)manamemauri: (iv)tohu.
(3)Inthissection,inaccordancewiththeunderstandingofTūhoe, manamemauri conveysasenseofthesensitiveperceptionofalivingand spiritualforceinaplace r ā hui conveysthesenseoftheprohibitionorlimitationofauseforan appropriatereason tapu meansastateorconditionthatrequirescertainrespectfulhuman conduct,includingraisin gawarenessorknowledgeofthespiritualqualities requiringrespect tapumenoa conveys,intapu,theconceptofsanctity,astatethatrequires respectfulhumanbehaviourinaplace;andinnoa,thesensethatwhenthe tapuisliftedfromtheplace,theplacereturnstoanormalstate tohu connotesthemetaphysicalorsymbolicdepictionofthings. :::
20.DecisionMakingAffectingRelationshipofIwiandHapū withTeUrewera
(1)TheBoardmustconsiderandprovideappropriatelyfortherelationshipofiwiand hap ū andtheircultureandtraditionswithTeUrewerawhenmakingdecisions, including
(a)theapprovalofTeUreweramanagementplan;and (b)theadoptionoftheBoard’sannualstatementofpriorities;and (c)theacceptanceoftheannualoperationalplan;and
Chapter22:NewZealand
(d)themakingofarecommendationtoaddlandtoTeUreweraorremove landfromTeUrewera;and (e)themakingofarecommendationtoestablishaspeciallyprotectedarea,a wildernessarea,oranamenityarea;and (f)thegrantofanactivitypermitoraconcessioninTeUrewera;and (g)theimpositionofcontrolsonaccesstopartsofTeUrewera;and (h)themakingofbylaws.
(2)Thepurposeofsubsection(1)istorecogniseandreflect
(a)Tūhoetanga;and (b)theCrown ’ sresponsibilityundertheTreatyofWaitangi(TeTiritio Waitangi). :::
Subpart2 TeUreweraManagementPlan
Preparation,approval,purpose,andscopeofplan
44.ObligationonBoardtoPrepareandApproveManagementPlanforTeUrewera
(1)TheBoardmustprepareandapproveTeUreweramanagementplaninaccordance withthissubpart.
(2)Publicnotice,asrequiredbyclause19(1)(c)ofSchedule2,mustbegivennotlater than1yearafterthesettlementdat ethatadraftmanagementplanistobe prepared.
45.PurposeofTeUreweraManagementPlan
ThepurposeofTeUreweramanagementplanis
(a)toidentifyhowthepurposeofthisActistobeachievedthroughthemanagementofTeUrewera;and (b)tosetobjectivesandpoliciesforTeUrewera.
46.ContentsofTeUreweraManagementPlan
(1)Themanagementplanmust
(a)statetheobjectivesandpoliciesfortheintegratedmanagementofTe Urewera;and (b)identifyrelevantvaluesatplaceswithinTeUrewera,includingvaluesrelatingto
(i)indigenousspecies,habitats,andecosystems;and (ii)culturalandhistoricalheritage;and (iii)recreationalvalues;and
(iv)scenic,geological,soil,andlandformfeatures;and (v)freshwater fisheriesandfreshwater fishhabitats;and
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
(c)identifytheoutcomesplannedforspecifiedplaceswithinTeUrewera
(i)thatareconsistentwiththevaluesunderparagraph(b);and (ii)thattakeintoaccountrelevantnationalspeciesrecoveryand managementobjectives;and
(d)explainhowanyconflictsbetweenplannedoutcomeswillberesolved;and
(e)identifyanyeffectsofactivitiesundertakenwithinTeUreweraandexplain howadverseeffectsaretobeminimised;and
(f)identifyanyplacesinTeUrewera thathavebeengive ninternational recognitioninagreementsratifiedorgivenlegalstandinginNewZealand andprovideforthemanagementofthoseplacesaccordingly,wherethisis consistentwiththepurposeofthisAct;and
(g)identifywhetherthereisaneedtocreatespeciallyprotectedareas,wildernessareas,oramenityareas;and
(h)identifythecriteriafordecisionmakinginrespectofTeUrewera,includingdecisionsonapplicationsforactivitypermitsandconcessions;and
(i)identifywhatregularmonitoringandevaluationofTeUreweraoughtto beundertaken;and
(j)identifythemattersproposedtoberegulatedbybylaws.
Subpart4 AuthorisationofCertainActivitiesinTeUrewera Activitypermits
58.ActivitiesRequiringActivityPermit
ThefollowingactivitiesmustnotbeundertakeninTeUreweraunlesstheyareauthorisedbyanactivitypermitissuedbytheBoard:
(a)taking,cutting,ordestroyinganyplant,whetherindigenousorexotic:
(b)disturbing,trapping,taking,hunting,orkillinganyanimal,whether indigenousorexotic(otherthansports fish):
(c)possessingdeadprotectedwildlifeforanyculturalorotherpurpose:
(d)enteringspeciallyprotectedareas:
(e)makingaroadoralteringanexistingroad:
(f)establishingaccommodation:
(g)farming:
(h)recreationalhunting:
(i)anyactivitythatwouldotherwisebeanoffenceunderthisAct.
Inrelationtoliabilities,section96oftheActprovidesthatTeUreweraisnotliablefor localgovernmentlandtaxes,norforleviestofundanyrural fi redistrictauthorities, norforcontaminationofanyTeUreweralandifthecontaminationoccurredbefore itbecamealegalperson.
Chapter22:NewZealand
C.TheManagementPlan:TeKawaoTeUrewera54
The fi rstwordsthatgreetyouin(theEnglishversionof)TeKawaoTeUrewera(Te Kawa)are “Naturewillsthatthereisnoendtolife,” inbold72-pointfont.Assucha beginningindicates,TeKawaislikenoothermanagementplan.Itwasdeliberately writtentoestablishtheprinciplestoguidethedecisionsoftheboardandthesetting ofoperationalmanagementplansunderthelegislation.AsboardChairmanTamati Krugersaidatthetime:
TeKawadoesnotworkthesamewayasothermanagementplans,whichfocusonsetting rulesandstock-taking. Thattraditionalapproachcanframenatureasasetofdiscrete resourcestobemanagedandused.TeKawaisdifferent.Itasksustostopandreflecton TeUreweraandwhatthatmeansasalivingsystem.Alivingsystemwedependonforsurvival,culture,recreation,andinspiration.TeUrewerahasitsownidentitythatislegal, butalsophysical,environmental,culturalandspiritual. :::
TeKawasetsoutavisionforbringingallNewZealanders,includingTūhoe,intoacloser relationshipwithTeUrewera,ratherth ansettingouttomanagethelanditself ::: Te KawaoTeUreweraisnotaboutshorttermthinking.TeUreweradoesnotworkto annualplans,butoverseasonsandcenturies.”55
Wenowturntothetextofthemanagementplanitself.Asyouread,considerhowit differsfromthetypesofmanagementplansthatyoumighttypicallyexpectfromyour ownlocal,regional,ornationaljurisdictions.
ExtractsfromTeKawaoTeUrewera:
[Introduction:]
TeKawaisaboutthemanagementofpeopleforthebene fitoftheland itisnot aboutlandmanagement.
Itraiseshopeforarenewedcollectiveresponsibilityforourpeopleimpacton thelandandforeseesourdisciplinedresponsetothoseimpacts. Together,weinviteaninter-generationaloutlooktointroducenewpractice forprincipledbasedresponsibility andmanagementtomeetouradmiration andrespectforTeUrewera.
TeKawaisnotintendedtooperateinthesamewayasausualmanagement planwhichfocusesonrules.Rather,TeKawarecordsprinciplesaslaw,andtraditionsandbeliefsasthesenseofabetterfuture.Asinlife,virtuesshapeour
54 TeKawaoTeUrewera(Englishversion),https://www.ngaituhoe.iwi.nz/te-kawa-o-te-urewera>.
55 TeKawaoTeUreweraDraftReleased,SCOOP,https://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/AK1705/S00487/te-kawao-te-urewera-draft-released.htm.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
responsibilitiesandchoicesguidingTeUreweraBoarddecisionsonappropriate andresponsibleactivitiesinTeUrewera.Theapplicationofthesewillalso developovertimeintheformofoperationalplans,activitiesanduseterms,and otherwide-rangingareas. :::
1.1THEPURPOSEOFTEKAWA
Peopleneednature,landandwatersforlife,purposeandhumanity.Nature enjoyspeoplefortheiraspiration,e ndeavourandfriendship.TeKawathen describestheinterrelationshipbetween peopleandTeUreweraforajustlife. Aninterplaythatacknowledgesourpl aceanddescribesourrenewedrespect andintuitionforthehealthandvitalityofTeUrewera.
Weknowandweunderstandthatnatureistimeless,regenerativeandoperatesbymauriandmana.Life’spurposeisrealisedwhenweunderstandthatlife fl ow,foritbringsusorder,showsushowtodispensejusticeandknowfairness, lettingusseehowtoserveasworthypeopledeservingofbene fitandentitlement. Withoutnature’sprinciplesaliveinourrelationshipswetoooftensufferdiscord fromirrelevanthabitsandcannotapplyjusticetoachieveanaturalbalance. But,ifwecanshareintheseTeUreweratraditionsandbeliefsguidingourway toaresponsiblelife,ourabilityaspeopl etolivewithnaturecanberestored. Andsothatwhatweseeintheworldisthatwhichwewanttoseeinourselves.
Astanatawhenua[peopleoftheland ieTūhoeguardians]andmanuhiri [visitors],weknowthatTeUrewera-Papatūānuku56 predatesusandthatweare ofhercreationlivingwithandamongstallofherkin.Asherchildrenweare bornwithresponsibility,wearenotbornwithpowerandrights.Themost dif fi cultofvirtuesyetmostimportanttoaccomplishisoursenseofbelonging, toknowourplaceandcontributiontocreation.
Inreaf fi rmingthisnaturalordertheBoardthroughTeKawaisdisrupting thenotionofourfalsesuperiorityoverthenaturalworld.Inalldecisiveness,we arereturningtoourplaceinnature,asherchild.
TEUREWERAPRINCIPLES
• PAPATŪĀNUKU:LANDSCAPE
Balance:Nothinginthenaturalworldisequal;natureitselfoperatesonthe basisofdiversity.AhumanviewofdevastationcanbeforTeUreweraaprocess ofrecyclingandregeneration.Nothinginnatureiswasted;everythinghappens forareason.TeUrewerahasascalebeyondourperceptioninwhichtobalance andorderlife.
56 Papat ūānuku refersto “MotherEarth.”
Chapter22:NewZealand
• MAURI:LIFE
Mauri:Alifeforcerequiringgenerosityeachtotheother.Thisgenerosity opensthesoultowantconnectionandcollectivebenefit.Toseetherelationship betweenpastandfuture,speciesandrace,birthanddeath,individualandcommunity,dreamingandscienceandthroughmanagingself-interest,seethecommonthreadsofallcreationstorealisetruepurposethroughwhichtobring prosperitytolife.
• TAPU:WAI
Resilience:Wai[water]iscomprehensivelyhardandsoft,sereneand insurgent[;]shenourishesallthathaveneedsforlife.Fairnessbringsthedisciplinenecessaryforcollectiveprogress,sharinglife,easingthepressureonthose thatmightotherwisestruggle,foreseeingandadaptingforfuturelifeneedsand standardsaseasilyascreatingnewwatercourses.
• AHUA:CHARACTER
Nakauiti:Futuresgrowfromsel fl essnessandsacri fi cetoday.Naturethus humanizesinterestandinspiriteachot hernotthroughbiologicalmakeupbut throughvalues,personalityandvibe.Ourcareforeachotherinspiresustolive togetherforpurpose.Allthingsareboundtogether,everythingisconnected,so theneedforstrictdisciplineandhighregardforreciprocity.
• TATAI:HERITAGE
Time:Oursenseoftimecreatesourpastandfuture.Ourmemoryforunity, hopeandgenerosityurgesourwilltolivetogether.Thismemoryspursusinto thefuture,unlearning,relearning,learninganewsothatwearealwayscurrent adaptingtobenecessaryandrelevanttoeachtimespanwearegranted.
• WHĀNAU:MANUHIRIANDTANATAWHENUA
Discipline:Nocreatureshouldbelievetheybelongonlytothemselves.Our valuesandvirtueshelpguardagainst inherenthumanimpulsestodominate oneanother;tobalanceegoandself-interest.Whenstrong,ourhabitsdefend againstthesepressuresandthewellbeingofthecollectiveoutweighsthegood ofindividual.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
WhenourlawsandrulesdepartfromTeUreweraprinciplesandfromourpracticeofthataliveinourtraditionsandbeliefs,theylosemoralintegrityand authority.Theymakenosense;theycannotbesaidtobefairorjust.
2.1THELEGALPERSONALITYAPPLIED
TheroleofTeUreweraBoardistoactonbehalfof,andinthenameof,Te Urewera.IndoingsotheBoardmustengagewithandembracetheTeUrewera identity.
TeUreweraActrecognisesthatTeUrewerahasitsownidentity,inandof itself,inspiringpeopletocommittoitscare.Throughthisidentity,theActmakes evidentthepresenceanddistinctpersonalitythatisTeUreweraaswellhercreationsofthenaturalworld.TheActdoesnotestablishtheTeUreweraidentity ratheritliberatesitfromhumanspeculationinorderthatnatureandthenatural worldreturntoitsprimalrole,reveredandservedbythoseofherchildrento whomshehasgivenlife.
Theuseofpropertyrightsbythewesternlegalsystemhashiddenfromview theconceptofnature;renderedherpartsasnaturalresourcesnowcapableof rivalprioritiescompetingwithotherhouseholdchoices.Thesehumangranted rightshavedisplacedourdevotionforPapatūānukuwithownershipnowserving individualadvantage.ThesemotivessuppressthevisionofTeUreweraasdistinct life.Yet,propertyrightsdonotgivelifenordotheyencouragetheconnectedness ofalllivingthingsforlife.Inthisalteredrelationshippeoplestruggletounifyto perceivethewholewhichisnaturecollectively.Needlesslyourfracturingof naturehassponsoredourownfragmentation.Theuseofpropertyrightstoregulatehumandisputesarisingfromhumansocietyisnolongerpermissibleinand ofTeUrewera.TeUreweramayneveragainbeownedbypeople.
TheNationalParksActwassympathetictothevoiceofTeUrewerabutalso createdafurtherdislocationbetweenTeUrewera,itsidentity,andT ū hoe.By ignoringthepresenceandpersonalityofTeUrewera,treatingheraslandsfor theenjoymentofothers,thesemechanismsservedtodisordertheTeUrewera connectiondistortingtherelationshipbetweenpeople,natureandidentity.
TherecognitionofTeUreweraasalegalentityinTeUreweraActredresses theTeUreweraidentity.TeUrewerahasprimacyunderthelaw,withtheroleof institutions,lawsandpeoplebeingtoembrace,respect,andactintheinterestsof TeUrewera.
Now,TeKawaseekstostartthejourney ofunderstandingandarticulating theTeUreweraidentity.Thatrequire sanunderstandingoftraditionsand beliefs,theroleandplaceofpeopleinTeUrewera,theconceptsoftanata whenuaandmanuhiri,andtherelationshipbetweenTūhoeandTeUrewera. :::
Chapter22:NewZealand
3.3MANAGINGHUMANEXPECTATION
WerecognisethatTeUrewera,whichincludesthewell-beingandtheexperiencesofthepeoplethatmakehertheirhomeoraplacetovisit,isalsoin fl uencedbyactivitiesthathappenoutsideofherborders.Globalwarming,pest infestation,waterandairquality,attitudesandaspirationsofpeopleallhavethe potentialtoadverselyimpactTeUrewera ’ slivingsystem.Theseproblemsare ourproblems;wehaveastakeinresolvingthem.Leavingsuchneglectandabuse forthenextgenerationwillnotreflecthonourablyonanyofus.Ourinvestment intheseissuestodaywillcount;theyarerelevantfactorsforourimpact accounting.
Ifwebelievethatthepermanencyofthelandisapreconditionforourlife, thenasweinvitethereturnofnatureintoourhomesandrelationshipswewill relearnherneedsandthroughthatourlimits.Reciprocityandmutualrespect arekeyelementsofTeKawa themoreselfl esstheinteractionwithTeUrewera, betheytransientorgenerational,therichertheengagementandoursecurityfor enduringlife.
3.4OURASPIRATIONS
Theaspirationisthatin20years’ timeTeUrewera,TūhoeandherManuhiri whochoosearelationshipconnectionwithTeUrewerawillbesupportingalocal, nationalandglobaleffortoflivingwith theland,admiringthelivingsystemof natureandmakinguswhole. :::
4.2ESTABLISHINGTEUREWERAPRIORITIES
TeUrewera’slivingsystemhasabalanceandarhythmthatismysteriousand imperceptibletohumansenses.Sheistimelessandpulsestobeatofherown. UnderstandingthenwhatisapriorityorurgencybyTeUreweraopinionissomewhatillusory.Hereapriorityspeakstothecommonworryforexcessiveuseby humanactivityandperhapsalsoourinactivitytobetterourhabitsforlivingwith TeUrewera.Priorityaffectsmorethana presentdaystate,itstruefocusthe behaviouralstandardswhichweneedandwanttoinstillinourselves.Itisfutureoriented.Thesestandardsarethetrueguardsagainstlivingexcessively,thatwhen strongnaturallyrepelhabitsthatleadtoplacingtoogreataburdenonTeUrewera. TheseprioritiesthenareoururgentneedtoregrowResponsibility,tobring resilienceintocommunity,toraisehuma nity,liftingoursighttolivingbyTe Ureweraprinciple,hereternalstandardsthatrevealthemselvesinarangeofways throughoutTeUrewera.ItcountsontheactionsofTūhoetheircommitmentto herforalltime,thisiswhakapapa-ki nshipinaction;andonhermanuhiriconnectionsforsimilar.Herformand fi gureexpectthisadorationforever,where herLivingSystempartsandtheirrelationshipswitheachotherarefelt,understood,respectedandlived.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
YetTeUrewerahasmuchtoconsider,wherereversingtrendsofpoorhealth iscomplex.HistoryhasseenthedisruptionoftheTū hoecontribution.Shewill delighttofeelthereturnofregularandthoughtfulfootfallthroughriverand acrossmauna[mountains],instillinganewgenerationunderstanding,revitalised values,bringingrelevancetothemyriadofpressuresnowfaced.Experiencing theessenceofherLivingSystem reconnectingpassionandmemoryforthe nextkaitiaki. :::
6.1.2NEWACTIVITYANDRESPONSIBLEINNOVATIONWELCOMED
Thepotentialofresponsibleinnovationtoimprovetheefficacyofoperations andexperienceswithinTeUreweraise mbraced.Newideasareencouraged, approachesandtechnologi esconsistentwithTeUreweravalueswelcomed, forevermindfulofthepotentialrisksandunintendedconsequencesassociated withuncheckedinnovations.
Connectiontoandopportunitywithinthisconsidersideassuchas:
• ThepotentialforinnovationsandtechnologiesaroundallaspectsofdeliveringonTeUreweraprioritiese.g.pestcontrol,smart/sensingliving systems.
• Manuhirirelationshipandexperiencesystemstoinformplanningdecisionsmoreef fi cientlytobringtargeteddevelopmentandmanageand deliverbetterexperiencesforpeople.
• Opennesstoexploringnewandbetterwaysofdoingthings.TeUrewera haspotentialtobenchmarkthesafe,responsibleandrobusttestingof newideas,technologiesandotherinnovationsconsistentwithTeKawa principles.
6.2BUSINESSOPPORTUNITIES FRIENDSHIPAGREEMENTS
Forappropriatecommercial-typeactivitiesandlargescaleactivities,moreformalrelationshipwillberequired.T heBoardmaygrantaconcessionnow referredtoasaFriendshipAgreementintheformofalease,license,permitor easement,butonlywheretheactivityisnotinconsistentwithTeKawa. FriendshipAgreementsreplacethepreviousconcessionsregimeappliedby theDepartmentofConservation.Associatedprocessesforapproving,monitoring andadaptingthesewillhavesimilaritiestothepreviousconcessionsregime,but willbedesignedtoachievenewandbroaderstandardsofintegrityforourimpact usesonthelivingsystemofTeUrewera.
ATeUreweraFriendshipAgreementadmitsthatopportunitiesareafforded onlywherewecandemonstrateloyalaff ectiontoTeUreweravaluesandher needtocontinuehercomplexbalancingactamongstherlivingsystem.ThecollaborationneededbyholdersofFriendshipAgreementswillenactandinstill robustexamplesoftheprinciplesrequiredofallinteractionswithTeUrewera.
Chapter22:NewZealand
TheirdesignwillensurethemauriofTe Ureweraisnotdiminishedthrough externalpressures,considerationsorexpectations.
IntroducingaFriendshipAgreementbringsopportunityforthoseseekinga livelihoodwithinTeUrewera,ortoundertakeanactivityofscaleorwithanontrivialimpact.TheBoardinapplyingthetermsof[section]62andschedule3 ofTeUreweraActwillonlydosoinawaythatisconsistentwithTeKawa;
(a)Explicitlyconsidershowsuchanactivitycontributestoachievingthe (i)purposeofTeUreweraAct;(ii)TeUreweraprincipleswhichare TeKawaprinciples;(iii)TeUreweraResponsibilitiesandPrioritised Actions
(b)ClearlyexplainshowtheactivityeffectsthelivingsystemofTeUrewera;
(c)Clearlyprovidesadequateorreasonablemethodsofremedying,avoidingormitigatingtheadverseeffectsonthelivingsystemofTeUrewera;
(d)Sharesthebene fi ts/riskonasustainablebasisbetweentheparties, reflectingtheirrespectivecontributions.
(e)IsenablingofTūhoeparticipation,wheretheyareorhavethepotential inthefuturetobebestplacedtoown/manageanactivity.
(f)Haspositiveobligationsonpartiesgrantedanagreementto “useit,or loseit.”
6.3INTEGRITYANDCOMPLIANCE
TheBoardwillapplyamonitoringoversightatthewholeoflivingsystem level,atanindividualactivityoperatorlevelandatthemanuhiriorpartnersatisfactionlevel.Keyelementsofthemon itoringwillincludeestablishinga “dashboard” tohighlighthowthelivingsystemo fTeUreweraisadapting,whatreal impactparticularactivitiesorfactorsarehaving,andwheretheprioritiesare forfutureaction.
• TheresilienceofthelivingsystemofTeUrewera;
• ProductivityanduseinTeUrewera;
• EconomicopportunitiesandinnovationwithinTeUrewera;
• Tūhoeleadershipandinfrastructure.
6.4EVOLVINGOURTEUREWERAEXPERIENCE
ProvidingforallwhowishtohaveadeeperrelationshipwithTeUrewerathe opportunitytodoso,throughthefacilitationofdialogandopportunitywhich willconsider:
• Informationprovision onTeUreweraandT ū hoepractices,cultures, expectationsetc.sothatwillingm anuhiri[visitors]caneducate themselves;
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
• Opportunitiesformanuhiri[visitors]toannouncethemselves either priororatthetimeoftheirarrival toT ū hoewhocanlistentotheir goalsandhelpthemplanandgetth emostoutoftheirvisit.Thisis expectedtobeanimportantchannelforidentifyingpartieswhowishto haveapositiveexchangewithT ū hoeandTeUreweraandservicesasa firststepinbuildingthenetworksanddialogsforthistohappen;
• Specificinitiatives InvitationsforTūhoeandmanuhiritoparticipatein workshopsanddevelopmentprogrammes,e.g.,acontributiontotrapping pests,plantingtrees,restoringtracks;
• Informationcapture manuhiriprovidedwitharangeofmechanismsto provideacontributiontothecaretakingofTeUrewera;
• Partnerships(andsponsorships)whichthroughintroducingandmobilisingnewandcomplementarycapabilitiesthatcanincombinationcreate newpotentialandopportunities. :::
7.3COMPLIANCE
Ourneedfornewstandard[s]andresponsibilityneedsnewguidance.Naturaltensionsexistfromoldandnewpractices,betweentheindividualandthecollective,betweenuseandpreservation ,scienceandcultureandscienceand people,thesethingsareindesperatene edofsoundreconciliationeffort.The useofnewwhanau[extendedfamily],hapū [sub-tribe],tribal,stakeholderand communityleadershipsupportedbynewinstinctandtechnologyneedstimeto bedeveloped.RaisingourcompliancestandardswillalsoneeddisciplinedinnovationwhichtheBoardacceptsasanimportantcurrentpriority.
TeKawa finisheswithsomelinesfromtheT.S.Eliotpoem “LittleGidding” : “Weshall notceasefromexploration,andtheendofallourexploringwillbetoarrivewhere westartedandknowtheplaceforthe fi rsttime. ” Thepoemalsoexplains: “ Whatwe calledthebeginningisoftheend,andtomakeanendistomakeabeginning.The endiswherewestartfrom.”
Insummary,theTeUreweralegislationelevatesthelegalstatusofanationalparktoa legalentitywithalloftherights,powers,duties,andliabilitiesofalegalperson.Itenvisagesanewrelationshipbetweenhumansandtheenvironmentbasedonaframework ofrightsandresponsibilities.However,itisTeKawaoTeUrewera themanagement planmadeunderit thatrede fi nesthatrelationshipandcreatesatrulynewbeginning,wherethatrelationshipisinharmonywithEarthlawprinciples.
Chapter22:NewZealand
V.FROMTHEWHANGANUIRIVERTOTEAWATUPUA57
TheWhanganuiRiverhasalsobeenaccordedlegalpersonalitybylegislation,andhas beenprovidedwithlegalguardianstore presentandupholditsinterests.The WhanganuiRiveristheancestralriverofanumberofWhanganuiIwi(tribalgroups). Fromthe1800s,thegovernmentassume downershipoftheriverandundertook riverbedworks,gravelextraction,andwa terdiversionsforahydroelectricpower scheme,despitepersistentoppositionfromWhanganuiIwi.Grievancesovertheriver werethesubjectofpetitionstoParliament,RoyalCommissionreports,WaitangiTribunalclaims,andnumerouscourtcasesbetween1938until2010.AnagreementinresolutionofthesegrievanceswasenactedintheTeAwaTupua(WhanganuiRiver ClaimsSettlement)Act2017. :::
ThisActrecognizestheindivisibleconnectionbetweentheWhanganuiIwiandthe WhanganuiRiver,aswellastheriver ’smetaphysicalstatusasalivingbeing:
TeAwaTupuaisanindivisibleandlivingwhole,comprisingtheWhanganuiRiverfrom themountainstothesea,incorporatingallitsphysicalandmetaphysicalelements.
InanefforttoimplementtheMāoriunderstandingoftheriverasalivingwhole, connectedtotheWhanganuiIwibutincapableofbeing “owned” inanabsolutesense, theActgrantstheWhanganuiRiverindependentlegalpersonhoodasTeAwaTupua: “TeAwaTupuaisalegalpersonandhasalltherights,powers,duties,andliabilitiesof alegalperson.”
TitletotheriverbedsofwhatwastheWhanganuiRiveranditstributaries,withina largecatchmentarea,isvestedinthenameofTeAwaTupuaitself.Theriverbedis defined:
bed,inrelationtotheWhanganuiRiver,
(a)meansthespaceoflandthatthewatersoftheWhanganuiRivercoveratitsfullest flowwithoutovertoppingitsbanks;and (b)includesthesubsoil,theplantsattachedtothebed,thespaceoccupiedbythewater, andtheairspaceabovethewater.58
Importantly,theActprovidesthatguardiansshallbeappointedonbehalfofthe WhanganuiRiver:twopersons “ ofhighstanding, ” oneappointedbytheCrownand oneappointedcollectivelybyalltribeswithinterestsintheriver,aretobetheriver’ s guardiansandmustactinthenameofTeAwaTupua.Thisof fi ceofguardianship, calledTePouTupua,must “ promoteandprotectthehealthandwellbeingofTe AwaTupua,”“actandspeakonbehalfofTeAwaTupua,” andact “initsinterestsand consistentlywithTupuateKawa[intrinsicvaluesoftheriver].” Theof fi ceofTePou Tupuaembodiesaco-governancearrangement,withbothM ā oriandnon-M ā ori
57 ThissectionisadaptedfromC.IornsMagallanes, supra note46,at555-556.
58 Id. at§2.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
members,anditspowersenablestrongerlegalrespectfortheenvironmentinlinewith Māoricosmology.
TheActanticipatesthedevelopmentof TeHekeNgahuru, a “WholeofRiverStrategy, ” thataddressesandadvancesthehealthandwell-beingoftheWhanganuiRiver. Italsoestablishes TeKoroteteoTeAwaTupua ,a “RiverFund ” ofNZD$30millionthat isdesignedtosupportthehealthandwell-beingoftheriver.UnlikeTeUrewera,the WhanganuiRiverwasnotanationalparkpriortobeinggrantedlegalstatus.TheenvironmentalprotectionaffordedtoitundertheTeAwaTupuaActisthusgreaterthan hadpreviouslybeenthecase.YetwhatismostimportantfortheWhanganuiIwiistheir understandingandbeliefthattheirhealthandwell-beingisdependentonthehealth andwell-beingoftheriver.Itisexpressedintheirproverb, “Koauteawa,koteawako au ” (Iamtheriverandtheriverisme).59 Asthehealthoftheriverimproves,sowill thehealthofthepeople;theenvironmentandhumanrightsareintertwinedandprotectedtogether.
ExtractsfromTeAwaTupuaAct2017detailingtheguardianshipbodiesandtheir functionsareprovidedinChapter6, “GuardianshipArrangementsinRightsofNature LegalProvisions.” Thelegislationdoesnotdetailthemeansbywhichthesebodieswill interactwiththebodiesestablishedunderotherlegislation.Thisiscurrentlybeing workedoutastheTeAwaTupuaguardiansundertaketheirroles.
Interestingly,thelegalpersonistreateddifferentlydependingonwhichlegislation itmightbecoveredbyorinteractwith:
17.ApplicationofOtherActstoTeAwaTupua
TeAwaTupuaistobetreatedas
(a)aninstitutionforthepurposeofapplyi ngforregistrationasacharitableentity undertheCharitiesAct2005:
(b)apublicbodyforthepurposesofclauses30and30AofSchedule7oftheLocal GovernmentAct2002:
(c)apublicauthorityforthepurposeofsection33XoftheMaritimeTransportAct 1994:
(d)aregisteredcollectoroftaongat ūturu 60 forthepurposesofsection14oftheProtectedObjectsAct1975:
(e)apublicauthorityforthepurposesoftheResourceManagementAct1991:
(f)abodycorporateforthepurposeofapplyingtobeaheritageprotectionauthority undersection188oftheResourceManagementAct1991:
(g)apublicbodyforthepurposesofsections4and35oftheWalkingAccessAct2008.
Anomissionworthnotingisthatthewatersoftherivercatchmenthavebeen excludedfromthislegislation’scoverage.Theriver ’swateristhusnotpartofthelegal personnoritsproperty.Thisisduetoagovernmentpositionthatnooneowns
59 Id. at§69(3).
60 Taongat ūturu meansanobjectthat(a)relatestoMāoriculture,history,orsociety;and(b)was,orappears tohavebeen;(i)manufacturedormodi fiedinNewZealandbyMāori;or(ii)broughtintoNewZealandby Māori;or(iii)usedbyMāori;and(c)ismorethan50yearsold.
618
Chapter22:NewZealand
freshwaterinNewZealand,andthatthegovernmentmerelymanagesitforthegood ofall.Thegovernmentthereforerefusedtorecogniseownershipofthewaterinthe legislation,evenbythenaturalentityitse lf.Despitethisomission,thearrangements enactedinrespectofTeAwaTupuahavecreatedanewbeginning.Theyhavecreated anewrelationshipbetweenlocalandnationalgovernment,thearea’ sresidents,the river,anditsguardians,ifnotalsowiththewholecountrythathascelebrateditspassage.It,too,isarelationshipbasedonanewsetofrightsandresponsibilitiesthatare inlinewithEarthlawprinciples.
VI.CONCLUSION
NewZealandisamodern,WesterndemocracywithitsvaluesandthemajorityofitsculturebeingfamiliartootherEnglish-speakingWesterndemocracies.Inthatsense,the adoptionofstatementsofintrinsicvaluefornatureanddeclarationsofanimalsentienceweresubjecttothepoliticalandpolicyconsiderationsthatmightariseinother suchcountries.Itisthusinstructivetoco nsiderthechoicesmadeintheirlegislative incorporation,aswellasintheirongoingapplicationbycourts,andtoconsideropportunitiestorelyontheNewZealandlawmakingtodevelopEarthlawinothercountries.
NewZealand ’ srecognitionofIndigenousenvironmentalrightsandresponsibilitieshasbeenmoreextensiveandeffectivet haninothercountriesthatsharethe EnglishlanguageandWesternculture.Consider,forexample,theeffortsinthe UnitedStatespromotedbyCELDF,asdiscussedinChapter9, “TheRightsofNature MovementintheUnitedStates.” TheprotectionofIndigenousworldviewsandIndigenousenvironmentalmanagementthroughstatute notablytheadoptionofresponsibility,guardianshipandlegalpersonhood isinnovative.Globally,theyareperceived asathreatbyembeddedeconomicinterestsandhavenotgarneredthesocialand politicalbackingneededtopasslegislation.Nevertheless,theNewZealandexperience indraftinglegislationwillprovidebothperspectiveandpersuasiveauthorityforpractitionersofEarthlawinothercountries.
Aswithalllegislation,thevalueoftheNewZealandlawswilldependonthestatutorywordingandthelegislativehistory,whichprovidetheparametersforwhatjudicial andadministrativedecision-makerscando.Courtswilldeterminethebreadthofsuch parametersastheyconsiderandconstruetheirmeanings.Inconsideringthestudy questionsbelow,focusontheseparametersasyouidentifyandarguetheirinterpretationandapplication.TheexperienceunderstatutessuchastheResourceManagementActshowthatinterpretationsoftheprovisionsimplementingMāoricultureand valuesarearguedasthoroughlyincourtsasanyotherstatutoryprovisionsthatare challengedonthebasisofthemeaning andapplicationofthewords.Thespeci fi c wordingmustbepaidcarefulattention.
TeKawaisnotitselflegislation.Itwasadoptedpursuanttothepowersandguidelineswithinthestatutoryframework.Itillustratesanewvisionoftherightsandresponsibilitiesbetweenhumansandtheenvironment,inlinewithEarthlaws.Theoverriding dignityandrespectfornature,alongwi ththeplaceofhumanswithinit,andits
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
emphasisondutyandresponsibilityratherthanpowerorrights,providesaninnovative opportunityforlandmanagement.TeKawaillustrateswhatcanbedonetochallenge “thenotionofourfalsesuperiorityoverthenaturalworld” andreturnus “toourplace innature,asherchild.”61
ThestudyofEarthlawinitsmanyemergentformsenablesustoexplicitlyidentify anddraftecocentriclegislation,torecognizewhetheritisbeingusedasintendedand effectively,andtotakeactiontoupholdandextenditsapplication.Theseexamples fromAotearoaNewZealandexpandtheideasofwhatispossible.
STUDYQUESTIONS
Intrinsicworthandintrinsicvalues:
(1)Doestheinclusionofreferencetointrinsicworthorintrinsicvaluerepresentthe inclusionofadeepecologyapproach,whichtreatshumanlifeasjustoneof manyinterrelatedcomponents,allessentialintheirownseparateandcollective ways,ofalargerglobalecosystem?Canithaveanyeffectifitoperateswithin andmustbebalancedagainstothermoremainstreamvalues?Howwouldyou explainintrinsicvaluetoacourt?How woulditbedifferentinageneralsense thaninthecaseofaparticularclie nt,forexampleariver?Howdoesthe ResourceManagementAct1991delineatetherangeofmattersthatmustbebalancedbyadecision-maker?
(2)Howmightthepersuasivevalueofanargumentbasedonintrinsicworthor intrinsicvaluebeenhancedordiminishedbythefactthattheyarementioned asanoverridingpurposeandnotelsewhereinthestatute?Howmightacourt instructajuryontheweighttobegiventointrinsicworthorintrinsicvalue? Howmightitbedistinguishedfromextrinsicvalue?
(3)Shouldintrinsicworthandintrinsicvaluesinrelationtonaturebeinterpretedconsistentlyacrossthedifferentstatutes,orshouldeachtermtakethemeaningmost appropriateforthatstatute?Notethatapurposiveapproachtostatutoryinterpretationsuggeststhateachstatuteisconsideredonitsownandthatotherstatutes areirrelevant;theparticularcontextan dpurposeofthatsinglestatuteiskey, unlessitformspartofastatutoryschemeandshouldbetreatedasinterrelated.
(4)Arethereanydifferencesinthemeaningsofintrinsicworthorintrinsicvalue thatwouldmakeanydifferenceinpractice?Thinkabouttheinterpretationof scenicvaluefromtheplaceinthequestion;wouldaninterpretationof “intrinsic value” intheNationalParksActeverbelikelytobesimilartothatforthescenic reservesintheReservesAct?Doyouthinkconstructingagazebototakeadvantageoftheviewwouldbelikelytobeapprovedforanationalpark?
61 TeKawa, supra note51,atp.15.
Chapter22:NewZealand
Sentienceofanimals:
(5)Whatrealeffectcanageneralstatementofprincipleaboutsentiencehavewhenapplyingclearstandardsthatarealreadyspecifiedinthelegislation,orwhendevelopingthe contentofanimalwelfarecodesorotherrulesundertheAct?Howmightacourt,in practice,changethemannerinwhichitconductsitsdecision-makingbusinessto includeaconsiderationofsentience?Howmightalegislativeenactment,orajudicial enactmentofproceduralrulesbedeveloped?Howmuchpowerdotrialcourtjudges haveinyourjurisdictiontouseapurposive approachininterpretinglegislation?
(6)Ifyouweremakingasubmissionontheinclusionofareferencetoanimals beingsentientinanimalwelfarelegislation,howcoulditbeworded,where wouldyouplaceit,andwhateffectwouldyouwantittohave?Isthereotherlegislationthatmightbene fitfromitsinclusion?Ifso,how?
(7)Ifanimalwelfarecodesneededtoberevisedinaccordancewithanexpanded conceptofanimalqualityoflife,andrequiringpositiveexperiences,whateffect wouldthathaveontheanimalfoodindustries,suchasinrelationtoanimal housingandtransport?
(8)Howshouldwebalancesentienceandanimalwelfarewithcontrollinginvasive, introducedpestspecies?
Indigenousrightsandlegalpersonality:
(9)Considerhowthetwodifferentlegalpersonshavebeende fi nedforTeUrewera NationalParkandWhanganuiRiver.Shouldtheybedefinedbygeographicallines onamaporbyecosystemfunction?Howsigni ficantmightitbethatfreshwateris notownedbythelegalpersonsnorunderthecontroloftheirguardians?
(10)DoesusingIndigenouslanguagetermsimporttheirdifferentunderstandingof humans’ relationshipswithnature moreinlinewithEarthlaw oraretheyonly asgoodasthejudgesinterpr etingtheterms?Theuseof “ kaitiakitanga ” inthe ResourceManagementActwillbeconsid eredandinterpretedbydecisionmakerswhoarenotIndigenousandmayhavelittleunderstandingofIndigenous cosmology.Howmightthisbemet?Howwouldyouavertanon-Indigenousinterpretationbasedonthestatutorywordingthatitisonlyneededtobepaidregard to,ratherthanrecognizedandprovidedforbyadecision-maker?
(11)Discusstheotherusesoflanguageinthelegislationaccordingtolegalpersonality tonature.Forexample,notetheuseof “her” torefertoTeUrewera;whatdoesthis signifyandincorporate?Notetheuseoftheword “appointee” totheTeUrewera Board.Boardmembersareappointedb ytheNewZealandgovernmentandby theMāoriTuhoetribe;yettheirjobistorepresentTeUrewera;mighttheirsource ofappointmentaffecttheirviewsoftheinterestsofTeUrewera?Howwouldyou assertyourauthoritytospeakasaguardianofanationalpark?Howwouldyoubalanceyourauthoritywiththeguardianofariverthat fl owedthroughthepark?
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
(12)Insteadofalistofactivitiesallowedinthearea,TeKawarefersto “experience” and “connection”;insteadof “concessions,” TeKawarefersto “friendshipagreements.” Doyouthinktheuseofthiswordingwillmakeanydifferenceintheway theseactivitiesareconducted?Howmighttheymakeadifference?
(13)Inthecontextoflegalpersonalitydiscussedinsection2.1oftheTeKawaextracts, howdopropertyrightsencouragefragmentationanddiscourageconnectedness ofnatureandlivingthingsinit?Whatmightdisputeresolutionwithinhumansocietylooklikeifitdidnotusepropertyrightstoresolvedisputes?
(14)Whenyoureadthatnaturalbeingslikeparksandriversarelegalentitiesandhave “alltherights,powers,duties,andliabilitiesofalegalperson,” whatarethestrengths andweaknessesofargumentsbasedseparatelyon:(1)rights,(2)powers,(3)duties and(4)liabilities?WhydoyouthinktheNewZealandlegislationidentifiesallfour?
(15)DoyouthinkofNewZealand’slawsdiscussedinthischapterareappropriately termedrightsofnaturelaws?Whyorwhynot?Howdoyoudistinguishrights ofnaturefromothertypesofEarthlaws?
(16)WhatbenefitcantheNewZealandlegislationthataccordspersonalitytonature providebywayofaprecedentforEarthla wsinothercountries?Considerthis commentaryonthelawsexaminedinthischapter:
Theseexamplesprovideanexcellentillustrationoftheinterconnectionbetween environmentandhumanrights.UpholdingM ā oriIndigenousrightstoland, resourcesandculturehasresultedinanewwaytonotonlyprotecttheenvironmentbuttoreconceiveourrelationshipwiththeenvironment,upholdinghuman rightsbetterintheprocess,asavirtuouscircle.Inrespectofthelegalpersonhood modelinparticular,thegrantingoflegalpersonhoodtoageographicalfeature representsamomentousshiftfromanext ernalownershipmodel,whichprioritisestheusesthathumansderivefromaresource,toanIndigenousselfownershipmodel,whichrequiresnohumanjusti ficationforenvironmentalprotection.Whileintimatelyconnectedwi thhumanrights,thisisaverydifferent visionoflegalsubjectsandobjects,an dofrightsandduties,fromthatwhich humanrightslawtraditionallyupholds .Thenotionofresponsibilityinthese examplesisusedincontrasttothenotionofrights,andtheseexamplesadopta communalfocus,rejectingindividualisticnotionsofrights.62
(17)HowmighttheNewZealandexampleofupholdinghumanrights Indigenous rights providepersuasiveauthorityforthedevelopmentofEarthlawinajurisdictionyouarefamiliarwith?Whataretheelementsofthedevelopmentofthe NewZealandlawsthatmighthavecompa rableelementsinyourjurisdiction? Howmightafocusonhumanresponsibilityoverrightsbeachievedinajurisdictioninwhichyoumaypractice?
62 Supra note46,at556-557.
CHAPTER23
TheNetherlandsandtheFutureof AtmosphericTrustLitigation1
I.INTRODUCTION
ThischapterexaminestheDutchSupremeCourt ’ s2019decisionin TheStateofthe Netherlandsv.UrgendaFoundation (Urgenda),theworld’ s firstcaseinwhichcitizenssuccessfullyestablishedtheirgovernment ’ slegaldutytoaddressclimatechange.The CourtorderedtheDutchgovernmenttoslashgreenhousegas(GHG)emissionsto 25percentbelow1990levelsbytheendof2020inenforcementoftheEuropeanConventiononHumanRightsandotherlegalstandards.Thiscaseprovidesamodelfor othercourtstomakesimilarlandmarkclimatechangedecisionsworldwide.
SectionIIexaminestheEuropeanUnion’s(EU)environmentalregulatoryframework,whichsetsGHGemissioncommitments;thefundamentalrightssetoutinthe ECHR;andEUlawimpedimentstodevelopingEarthlaw,whichtheDutchCourt ’ s decisioncircumvented.
SectionIIIexplainstheelementsoftheConstitutionoftheNetherlandsandthe DutchlegalsystemthatarecriticaltotheSupremeCourt ’sreasoninginthe Urgenda case.
SectionIVcomparesandcontrasts Urgenda withaU.S.climatechangecase: Juliana v.UnitedStates Urgenda servesasacounterweighttothe Juliana case,whichtheNinth CircuitCourtdismissedforlackofstanding(see Chapter7, “PublicTrustDoctrine ”). Thissectionalsohighlights “atmospherictrustlitigation ” morebroadly.
II.THEEUROPEANCONVENTIONONHUMANRIGHTS
EUenvironmentalandhumanrightsobligationsarebasedonaseriesoflegallybindingtreaties.ExamplesaretheTreatyontheEuropeanUnion,theTreatyontheFunctioningoftheEuropeanUnion,andthe CharterofFundamentalRightsofthe EuropeanUnion.InadditiontothefoundationaltreatiesoftheEU,whichsetout theconstitutionalrightsanddutiesofitsmemberstates,thereareothertreatiesthat
1 ThischapterwasauthoredbyValentijnPunt,EnvironmentalLawAssociateatEarthLawCenter.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
focusonspeci fi careas,suchashumanrights,labormarkets,theeconomy,andenvironmentalprotection.
TheEuropeanConventiononHumanRights(ECHRorConvention)isonesuch treaty.Itlegallybindsthe47membersoftheCouncilofEurope,aninternationalorganizationwiththemissiontoupholdhumanrightsandtheruleoflaw.OftheCouncil’ s 47members,27aremembersoftheEU.TheideafortheECHRwasshapedin1948 duringthe “CongressofEurope,” agatheringintheHaguewherepoliticians,civilsociety,andrepresentativesoftradeunions,un iversities,andotheri nstitutionsworked togethertoproposealistofbasichumanrights. 2 Anumberofarticlesweredirectly basedontheUnitedNations’ UniversalDeclarationofHumanRights.
TheEuropeanCourtofHumanRights(EuropeanCourt)overseesenforcementof theprovisionsoftheECHR.3 TheEuropeanCourtwassetupin1959inStrasbourg andissuesjudgmentsthatarelegallybindingonmemberstates.4
DomesticcourtsofECHRmemberstatesalsohaveanobligationtoapplytheconvention.ThisisbecausetheECHRisincorporatedintothelegislationofallmember statesandisthereforedirectlyapplicableatanationallevel.Thisbecomesimportant inthe Urgenda case.
TherearetwotypesofapplicationsthatcanbebroughttotheEuropeanCourt: (1)individualapplicationslodgedbyanyperson,groupofpersons,ornongovernmentalorganization(NGO);and(2)inter-stateapplicationswhereonestate bringsaclaimagainstanother.Thecasescanonlybebroughtagainstastatethathas rati fiedtheECHR,andthusagreedtohonorjudgmentsmadebythecourt.TheexecutionofjudgmentsismonitoredbytheCo mmitteeofMinistersoftheCouncilof Europe.
TheadmissibilitycriteriaforcomplaintsbeforetheEuropeanCourtaredefinedin Articles34and35oftheECHR.UnderArti cle34,theapplicantmustbeaperson, NGO,orgroupofindividualsclaimingtobea “ victim ” ofaviolationofrightsestablishedintheECHR.(Themeaningof “victim ” becomesrelevantinthedistrictcourt opinionof Urgenda .)UnderArticle35,alldomesticremediesmusthavebeen exhausted,thecontesteddomesticcourtdecisionmusthavebeenmadewithintheprevioussixmonths,andtheapplicantmusthavesuffereda “ signi fi cantdisadvantage, ” amongstotherrequirements.5
Inpractice,enforcementofEuropeanCo urtdecisionshasbeenproblematic.If theEuropeanCourt findsthatarighthasbeenbreached,itsimplydeclaresthataviolationhasoccurredandoftentimesallows thecountrytodetermineitsownplanfor compliance.SometimestheEuropeanCourtdoesprescribearemedy,suchasending
2 TheEstablishmentoftheEuropeanMovement ,CVCE.EU(July4,2020),https://www.cvce.eu/en/recherche/ unit-content/-/unit/04bfa990-86bc-402f-a633-11f39c9247c4/272166ae-84b2-466b-9cfa-4df511389208.
3 CouncilofEurope,EuropeanConventiononHumanRights,asamendedbyProtocolsNos.11and14,SupplementedbyProtocolsNos.1,4,6,7,12,and13ET S5(1950),http://www.echr .coe.int/Documents/ Convention_ENG.pdf[hereinafterECHR].
4 Id.
5 COUNCILOF EUROPE,EUROPEAN COURTOF HUMAN RIGHTS,PRACTICAL GUIDEON ADMISSIBILITY CRITERIA (updatedon Aug.31,2019),https://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Admissibility_guide_ENG.pdf.
Chapter23:TheNetherlandsandtheFutureofAtmosphericTrustLitigation
theviolationinquestion,makingpayment,oramendinglaws. 6 Butoverall,enforcementhasbeenlacking.Forexample,a2017reviewfoundthat9,944judgmentsby theEuropeanCourthadnotbeenimplementedbytherespectivestates. 7 Partofthe problemisthatEuropeanCourtdecisionsdonotforcestatestoenactneworamend existinglegislation.ThisisdifferentfromtheCourtofJusticeoftheEuropeanUnion, forexample,thejudgmentsofwhicheffectivelyoverridenationallaw.Thereisnosuch relationshipbetweentheEuropeanCourtandtheEU:theCouncilofEuropeisaseparateorganizationofEuropeannationsunrelatedtotheEU.Thegeneralruleisfor nationalcourtstofollowtheEuropeanCourt ’ sdecisions,buttherearenopractical meanstoforcerecalcitrantstatestoimplementthem.8
AnaspectoftheEuropeanCourtthatsetsitapartfromotherhumanrightscourts isthatthereisafollow-upsystemintheformoftheCommitteeofMinisters.Thechallengewiththecommitteeitself,however,isthefactthatitismadeupofhigh-levelofficialsrepresentingmemberstates,andrelationshipsbetweencountriesin fl uencehow committeemembersfollowupontheenforcementofjudgments.
Thereare18humanrightssetoutintheECHR,commonlyknownasthe “ConventionRights.” Thearticlesmostrelevanttothe Urgenda caseareArticles2and8.Article2 concernstherighttolifeandstatesthefollowing:
1.Everyone’srighttolifeshallbeprotectedbylaw.Nooneshallbedeprivedofhislife intentionallysaveintheexecutionofasentenceofacourtfollowinghisconviction ofacrimeforwhichthispenaltyisprovidedbylaw.
2.Deprivationoflifeshallnotberegardedasinfl ictedincontraventionofthisArticle whenitresultsfromtheuseofforcewhichisnomorethanabsolutelynecessary:
(a)indefenceofanypersonfromunlawfulviolence;
(b)inordertoeffectalawfularrestortopreventtheescapeofapersonlawfully detained;
(c)inactionlawfullytakenforthepurposeofquellingariotorinsurrection.9
Article8establishestherighttoprivacyandfamilylifeandreadsasfollows:
1.Everyonehastherighttorespectforhisprivateandfamilylife,hishomeandhis correspondence.
2.Thereshallbenointerferencebyapublic authoritywiththeexerciseofthisright exceptsuchasisinaccordancewiththelawandisnecessaryinademocraticsociety intheinterestsofnationalsecurity,publicsafetyortheeconomicwell-beingofthe country,forthepreventionofdisorder orcrime,fortheprotectionofhealthor morals,orfortheprotectionoftherightsandfreedomsofothers.10
6 MariaIssaeva,IrinaSergeeva&MariaSuchkova, EnforcementoftheJudgmentsoftheEuropeanCourtofHuman RightsinRussia, 15INTL.J. ON HUMAN RIGHTS (Dec.2011).
7 GingerHervey, Europe’sHumanRightsCourtStrugglestoLayDowntheLaw, POLITICO.EU(Sept,17,2017,4:05AM, CET).
8 COUNCILOF EUROPE,THE EXECUTIONOF JUDGMENTSOF EUROPEAN COURTOF HUMAN RIGHTS,HUMAN RIGHTS FILES, No.19(2ded.2008).
9 ECHR, supra note3.
10 Id
Articles2and8havebeeninterpretedtoprotectagainstenvironmentalharmsthat affectrightstolife,home,andprivateli fewheresuchharmsarecausedbyastate actionorthestate’sfailuretoproperlyregulateprivate-sectoractivities.Thesearticles alsoimposeapositiveobligationuponstatestotakethenecessaryprecautionarymeasurestopreventfuturerightsviolations, especiallywhenthereisaknownandimminentthreat. 11 Asre fl ectedintheexaminationofthe Urgenda case,theDutch SupremeCourtruledthatthesearticlesre quirememberstatestotakereasonable andsuf ficientstepstoprotectresidentsfromthelife-threateningconsequencesofclimatechange.
III.THE URGENDA CASE
ThissectionbeginsbytakingacloserlookattheDutchlegalsystem.Itthenexplores themeritsofthe Urgenda caseattheHagueDistrictCourt,theHagueCourtofAppeal, andtheDutchSupremeCourt.
A.BackgroundonDutchLegalSystem
TheNetherlandsisaconstitutionalmonarchywithacivillawlegalsystem.ThefoundationofitsnationallawistheDutchCivilCode(DCC),whichaddressesmostsubjectsof Dutchlaw.AllotherlegislationisbasedontheprinciplessetoutintheDCC.Dutch judgeshaveahighdegreeofdiscretionininterpretingtheseprovisions,evenwhen thetextofaprovisionseemsclear.Anunderlyingprincipleofthisdiscretionisthe notionintheDutchlegalsystemof “ reasonablenessandfairness, ” whichreferstoa generallyacceptedstandardofwhatisreasonableandfairinagivensituation.Inother words,ifapartykneworshouldhaveknownacertainfact,thisprinciplerequiresthem toactaccordingly,withconsiderationofthesocietalandpersonalinterests.Thisalso meansthatregulationsandbindinglegalinstrumentsingeneralmaynothavealegal effectif,aswrittenorasapplied,theyaredeemednottobeobjectivelyfair.12
TheDutchlegalsystemhasthreetypesofcourts.First,therearethedistrictcourts (Rechtbank),ofwhichthereare19andwhicharedividedinto fiveareasbasedondifferentsectors;theseincludethecivil,admini strative,andcriminalsectors.Second, fi ve courtsofappeal( Gerechtshof )hearbothcivilandcriminalcaseswhereanappealhas beenlodgedagainstajudgmentbyadistrictcourt.Finally,theSupremeCourt(Hoge
11 See E UROPEAN C OURTOF H UMAN R IGHTS ,E NVIRONMENTANDTHE E UROPEAN C ONVENTIONON H UMAN R IGHTS , (Mar.2020),https://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/FS_Environment_ENG.pdf.
12 See PopkeSjoerdBakker,Redelijkheidenbillijkheidalsgedragsnorm147-153(2012)(unpublishedPh.D. dissertation,VrijeUniversiteit), https://research.vu.nl/ws/portal fi les/portal/42108308/complete +dissertation.pdf.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw 626
Chapter23:TheNetherlandsandtheFutureofAtmosphericTrustLitigation
Raad)isthehighestcourtintheNetherlandsandhearscasesincivil,criminal,andtax mattersincassation,whichmeansthattheSupremeCourtisrequiredbylawtobaseits holdingsonthefactsasestablishedbythelowercourts.13 In Urgenda,thecasemoved fromtheHagueDistrictCourttotheHagueCourtofAppealtotheSupremeCourt, withtheDutchgovernmentappealingeachtime.Asdescribedinthenextsection,ultimatelytheseappealswereunsuccessful.
Also,theDutchjudicialbranchhasanindependentadvisorwhoispartofthejudicialbranch,calledtheprocuratorgeneral.Alongwiththeadvocatesgeneral,therole ofprocuratorgeneralistoprovidetheSupremeCourtwithindependentadvice throughadvisoryopinio ns.Incivilcasessuchas Urgenda ,provisionofthisadvisory opinionismandatorybuttheDutchSupremeCourtisnotrequiredtofollowit.Such advisoryopinionsreviewtherelevantfacts ,legalquestions,scholarlyopinions,case law,aswellasthedecisionofthelowercourtthatisbeingappealed.
B.Urgenda:ProceduralHistoryandRuling
The Urgenda casewasbroughtasacollectiveaction.Dutchcollectiveactionstoprotect apublicinterestcanbeinitiatedpursuanttoArticle3:305aoftheDutchCivilCode. Thisprovisionallowsarepresentativeentitytoinitiateacollectiveactioninacivilcourt basedontheinterestsofnaturalpersons,solongasthoseinterestsarethesameasthe entity ’s.Theentitymustbeanassociationorfoundation,anditsarticlesofassociation andby-lawsneedtostatethattheaimoftheentityistorepresentaspeci fiedgroupof persons.
Inthe Urgenda case,thespecifiedgroupofpersonswasextremelybroad,withthe UrgendaFoundationrepresentingover800individuals. Urgenda alsoasserteditsrepresentationoffuturegenerations,bothwithinandoutsidetheNetherlands,ofpeople impactedbyclimatechange.Urgenda ’ sarticlesofassociationmetthethreshold requirementtorepresentfuturegenerationsinacollectiveactionbyexplicitlyrecognizingthattheFoundation ’spurposeisto “preservetheplanetasasustainableplace forfuturegenerationstolive. ” Additionally,a2001decisi onbytheDistrictCourtof theHagueheldthatArticle3:305aoftheDCCcanserveaslegalbasisforactions broughtonbehalfoffuturegenerations. 14 However,thecourtsneveraddressedthis issuein Urgenda andfoundthestandingofUrgendaanditslivingDutchco-plaintiffs tobesufficient.15
13 Cassation:TheMainTaskoftheSupremeCourt,H OGE R AADDER NEDERLANDEN,https://www.rechtspraak.nl/ Organisatie-en-contact/Organisatie/Hoge-Raad-der -Nederlanden/Supreme-cour t-of-the-Netherlands/ Paginas/Cassation-the-main-task-of-the-Supreme-Court.aspx(lastvisitedJuly4,2020).
14 ECLI:NL:RBSGR:2001:AB1369,DistrictCourtTheHague(May2,2001)[3.5].
15 UrgendaFoundationv.KingdomoftheNetherlands,TranslationofSummons,15,¶28(June25,2015), http://www.urgenda.nl/documents/FINAL-DRAFT-Translation-Summons-incase-Urgenda-v-Dutch-Statev.25.06.10.pdf.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
C.BackgroundandOverviewoftheHolding
The Urgenda caseemergedfromadisputeaboutDutchobligationstoreduceGHGs. AlthoughtheDutchgovernmentandUrgendaagreedabouttheneedtoreduce GHGemissions,theydifferedabouttheexactreductiontarget.Urgendabelievedit mustbea25percentreductioncomparedto1990levels,whereastheDutchgovernmenthadtargeteda20percentreduction.Whilethedifferencemayseemsmall,the importanceofthecaseisthatthelawsuitsoughttoenforcescience-basedclimatechangetargetsestablishedbyinternationalconsensus,regardlessofhowclosethegovernmentwastomeetingthesetargets.
PriortothehistoricSupremeCourtdecision,theDistrictCourtoftheHagueand theHagueCourtofAppealbothruledinfavorofUrgenda.Thetwocourtsuseddifferentlegalreasoning.Thesecasesarediscussedbelowinsequence.
1.DistrictCourtoftheHague(2015)
The firstruling,fromtheDistrictCourtoftheHaguein2015,foundthattheDutchgovernmentbreacheditsdutyofcaretoitscitizensundertortlawbyfailingtoadopta 25percentreductioncriterion.16 Dutchtortlawestablishesadutyofcarethatissimilar tothe “reasonableperson” standardinU.S.tortlaw.Thedistrictcourtconstructedthe standardofcareonthebasisofinternational,European,andconstitutionaldutiesto whichtheDutchgovernmentwascommitted includingArticles2and8oftheECHR, whichupholdtherighttolife,andtorespectprivacyandfamilylife,respectively;the UnitedNationsFrameworkConventiononClimateChange;andArticle21oftheDutch Constitution,whichestablishesthefundamentalrighttoacleanenvironment.Thedistrictcourtfurthersubstantiatedthebreachofthisdutyofcarebaseduponareviewof Dutchclimatechangepolicy,whichitdeemedtobeinadequate.ThedistrictcourtconcludedthattheDutchgovernmentactedunlawfullybyestablishingaGHGreductiontargetthatwaslessthan25percentby2020comparedtotheyear1990.
Onenecessaryelementtoestablishabreachofthedutyofcareundertortlawisa causallinkbetweenthechallengedacto romission,andthedamagesufferedbythe plaintiff.Whenitcomestoclimatechange,thiscanbedifficulttoprovebecauseone country ’ sreductioninemissionsisunlikelytop reventclimatechangebyitself.Considerhowthedistrictcourtaddressedthisissue:
Fromtheaboveconsiderations,particularlyin4.79,itfollowsthatasufficientcausallink canbeassumedtoexistbetweentheDutchgr eenhousegasemissions,globalclimate changeandtheeffects(nowandinthefuture)ontheDutchlivingclimate.Thefactthat thecurrentDutchgreenhousegasemissionsarelimitedonaglobalscaledoesnotalter thefactthattheseemission[sic]contributetoclimatechange.Thecourthastakeninto considerationinthisrespectaswellth attheDutchgreenhouseemissionshave
16 UrgendaFoundationv.TheStateoftheNetherlands,CaseNo.C/09/456689/HA_ZA13-1396(Netherlands), RechtbankDenHaag[DistrictCourtofTheHague,ChamberforCommercialAffairs](June24,2015).
Chapter23:TheNetherlandsandtheFutureofAtmosphericTrustLitigation
contributedtoclimatechangeandbytheirnaturewillalsocontinuetocontributetoclimatechange.17
DespiterulinginUrgenda’sfavor,thedistrictcourtfoundthatUrgendacouldnot baseitsclaimsonArticles2and8oftheECHRdirectly onlyindirectlythroughtort law sinceanonhumanorganizationcannotbea “victim ” perthemeaningofArticle34oftheECHR: “Afterall,unlikewithanaturalperson,alegalperson ’sphysical integritycannotbeviolatednorcanalegalperson ’ sprivacybeinterferedwith. ” 18 Whilenon-governmentalorganizationsareexplicitlyrecognizedaspossible “victims ” underArticle34,thedistrictcourtreject edthenotionthattheycanbevictimsof speci fi cally physical harms.Thedistrictcourtalsodeclinedtoexplicitlyrulethatthe Dutchgovernmenthadbreachedinternationaltreatyobligations(suchasunderthe UnitedNationsFrameworkConventionon ClimateChange)ortheDutchConstitution.Instead,itrelieduponthesesourcesoflawtointerpretthedutyofcareundertort law.TheNetherlandsappealed.
2.HagueCourtofAppeal(2018)
Thesecondruling,fromtheHagueCourtofAppealin2018,upheldthedistrictcourt ruling.19 However,unliketheHagueDistrictCourt,theHagueCourtofAppealfound thatUrgenda,alongwiththemanyhumansitrepresents, could directlyenforcethe ECHRwithouthavingtorelyupontortlaw.Thecourtreasonedthatthelimitations ofa “ victim” underArticle34oftheECHRonlyappliestoadmissibilitytotheEuropeanCourt,nottoDutchcourts.Bycontrast,Dutchlaw speci fi cally,Article3:305a oftheDCC providesforclassactionsofinterestgroupssuchasthisone.Thecourt explainedthatindividualswhofallunderDutchjurisdictionmayinvokeArticles2 and8oftheECHRdirectly.ThecourtthenlaidoutthebasicobligationsoftheDutch government:
Inshort,theStatehasapositiveobligationtoprotectthelivesofcitizenswithinitsjurisdictionunderArticle2ECHR,whileArticle8ECHRcreatestheobligationtoprotect therighttohomeandprivatelife.Thisobligationappliestoallactivities,publicand non-public,whichcouldendangertherightsprotectedinthesearticles,andcertainly inthefaceofindustrialactivitieswhichbytheirverynaturearedangerous.Ifthegovernmentknowsthatthereisarealandimminentthreat,theStatemusttakeprecautionary measurestopreventinfringementasfaraspossible.Inlightofthis,theCourtshallassess theasserted(imminent)climatedangers.20
17 Id.
18 Id
19 TheStateoftheNetherlandsv.UrgendaFoundation,TheHagueCourtofAppeal(Oct.9,2019),case 200.178.245/01,Englishtranslationathttps://www.la w.uh.edu/faculty/thester/courses/Climate-Change2018/Urgenda%20Appeal%20Decision%20100918.pdf.
20 Id.at¶43.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Thecourtthenexploredthescience-basedthreatsofclimatechange,theinternationalobligationsoftheNetherlands,andtheimpactonhumanrightsasderivedfrom Articles2and8oftheECHR.Ultimately,thecourtconcludedasfollows:
[T]heStatehasdonetoolittletopreventadangerousclimatechangeandisdoingtoo littletocatchup,oratleastintheshortterm(uptoend-2020).Targetsfor2030and beyonddonottakeawayfromthefactthatadangeroussituationisimminent,which requiresinterventionsbeingtakennow.
[T]heCourtisoftheopinionthattheStatefailstoful fi litsdutyofcarepursuantto Articles2and8ECHRbynotwantingtoreduceemissionsbyatleast25percentby end-2020. :::
AlloftheaboveleadstotheconclusionthattheStateisactingunlawfully(becausein contraventionofthedutyofcareunderArticles2and8ECHR)byfailingtopursuea moreambitiousreductionasofend-2020,andthattheStateshouldreduceemissions byatleast25percentbyend-2020.TheState’sgroundsofappealpertainingtothedistrictcourt’sopinionaboutthehazardousnegligencedoctrine[i.e.,thetortclaim]need nodiscussionunderthesestateofaffairs.Thejudgmentisherebyupheld.21
TheNetherlandsagainappealed.
3.ProcuratorGeneraladvisoryopinion(2019)
Next,onSeptember13,2019,theProcuratorGeneraloftheSupremeCourt(joinedby theadvocategeneral)releasedaformaladvisoryopinionsupportingtherulingofthe courtofappeal.22 Itagreedthathumanrightslawcanbeusedtointerpretthegovernment’sdutyofcarewithrespecttoclimatechange.Theadvisoryopinionalsorejected thedefensesoftheNetherlands,includin gthatclimatechangepolicyisapolitical issuethatshouldbelefttothelegislativebranchsoastonotinterferewiththeseparationofpowersbetweenbranchesofgovernment.TheProcuratorGeneralconcluded asfollows:
Thejurisdictionofthecivilcourts,underDutchlaw,isindependentfromthequestion ofwhethertheclaimraisesapoliticalissue. Iftheclaimantbasesitsclaimonaviolationorimpendingviolationofarighttowhichitisentitledoronanunlawfulactcommittedagainstit,thecivilcourtsdo,inprinciple,havejurisdictiontotakecognizance ofthatclaimandrenderasubstantiveopiniononit.Thisalsoapplieswhentheclaim isdirectedagainsttheState.
Asdiscussedabove,theProcuratorGeneral’sadvisoryopinionisnotbindingbutis consideredbytheSupremeCourt.
21 Id.at¶¶71,73,76.
22 IntheMatterBetweentheStateof theNetherlandsandStichtingUr genda,ProcuratorGeneralofthe SupremeCourtoftheNetherlands,No.19/00135(Sept.13,2019).
Chapter23:TheNetherlandsandtheFutureofAtmosphericTrustLitigation
4.DutchSupremeCourt(2019)
Finally,inDecember2019,theSupremeCourtupheldtherulingoftheCourtof Appeal.AswiththeCourtofAppeal,itsreasoningderivedfromDutchhumanrights obligations. 23 TheSupremeCourtagreedthat “ thereisthethreatofdangerousclimatechangeanditisclearthatmeasuresareurgentlyneeded. ” 24 UnderArticles2 and8oftheECHR,theNetherlandshasadutytoprotecttherighttolifeandtheright toprivateandfamilylifeofitsresidents.Initsruling,theCourtalsoreferredtothe 2007IPCCreport,whichfoundthatareduc tioninemissionsof25to40percentby 2020wouldbenecessarytolimitglobalwarmingtoa2ºCincrease,andheldthatthe Dutchgovernmenthadprovidedinsuf fi cientreasonsforadheringtoalesser20percentreduction.25 TheSupremeCourtconcludedasfollows:
Thiscaseinvolvesanexceptionalsituation.Afterall,thereisthethreatofdangerousclimatechangeanditisclearthatmeasuresareurgentlyneeded,astheDistrictCourtand CourtofAppealhaveestablishedandtheStateacknowledgesaswell.TheStateis obligedtodo ‘itspart’ inthiscontext.TowardstheresidentsoftheNetherlands,whose interestsUrgendaisdefendinginthiscase,thatdutyfollowsfromArticles2and8 ECHR,onthebasisofwhichtheStateisobligedtoprotecttherighttolifeandtheright toprivateandfamilylifeofitsresidents.ThefactthatAnnexIcountries,includingthe Netherlands,willneedtoreducetheiremissionsbyatleast25percentby2020follows fromtheviewgenerallyheldinclimatesci enceandintheinternationalcommunity, whichviewhasbeenestablishedbytheDistrictCourtandtheCourtofAppeal.ThepolicythattheStatepursuessince2011andintendstopursueinthefuture,wherebymeasuresarepostponedforaprolongedperiodoftime,isclearlynotinaccordancewith this,astheCourtofAppealhasestablished.26
Inmakingitshistoricruling,theDutchSupremeCourt agreeingwiththeProcuratorGeneral rejectedtheDutchgovernment ’ sdefensethatasweepingclimate changerulingwouldinterferewiththeseparationofpowersbyreshapingthelegislativeprocess,therebyblurringthelinesbetweenthejudicialandpoliticalspheres.27 In Urgenda ,thecoreofthegovernment ’ sargumentwasthatrulinginfavorofthe claimantswouldviolatetheseparationofpowersbyunderminingthegovernment ’ s authorityinthecontextofinternationalpoliticsandnegotiationleverage.28 However, theSupremeCourtfoundthegovernment’sargument flawedbecauseitdidnotdistinguishtheseparationofpowersdoctrinefromthesystemofpoliticalchecksand balances.29
23 UrgendaFoundationv.KingdomoftheNetherlands,TranslationofJudgment,Dec.20,2019,¶5.2.1, https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/inziendocument?id=ECLI:NL:HR:2019:2007.
24 Id.at¶8.3.4.
25 Id.at¶2.1.
26 Id.at¶8.3.4(internalcross-referencesomitted).
27 Id.at¶2.2.3.
28 RogerCox, AClimateChangeLitigationPrecedent:UrgendaFoundationv.TheStateoftheNetherlands, 34J. OF ENERGY &NATURAL RESOURCES L.143,148(2016).
29 KJdeGraaf&JHJans, TheUrgendaDecision:NetherlandsLiableforRoleinCausingDangerousGlobalClimate Change, 27(3)J. OF ENVTL.L.517,523(2015).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
TheSupremeCourtstated:
IntheDutchsystemofgovernment,thedecision-makingongreenhousegasemissions belongstothegovernmentandparliament.Theyhavealargedegreeofdiscretiontomake thepoliticalconsiderationsthatarenecessaryinthisregard.Itisuptothecourtstodecide whether,intakingtheirdecisions,thegovernmentandparliamenthaveremainedwithin thelimitsofthelawbywhichtheyarebound.ThoselimitsensuefromtheECHR,among otherthings.TheDutchConstitutionrequirestheDutchcourtstoapplytheprovisionof thisconvention,andtheymustdosoinaccordancewiththeECHR’sinterpretationof theseprovisions.Thismandatetothecourtstoofferlegalprotection,evenagainstthegovernment,isanessentialcomponentofademocraticstateundertheruleoflaw.30
Insum,theSupremeCourtruledthatrequiringtheDutchgovernmenttoprotect itscitizensfromclimatechangedoesnotinfringeupontheseparationofpowerssince itisonlyprescribingtheoutcome,nott hemeansbywhichthegovernmentmust achievethisoutcome.WhiletheCourtdeterminedthatthelawrequiredthecutsin GHGemissions,theDutchgovernmentcoulddecidehowtoachievethem.
IV.COMPARING URGENDA TO JULIANA
ThissectionconsidersthedifferentresultsreachedbytheDutchSupremeCourtand theNinthCircuitCourtofAppealsintheUnitedStatesincasesseekingthesamerelief: compellingthegovernmenttoprotectthefundamentalrightsofitscitizensfromthe adverseconsequencesofclimatechange .Itfocusesontheargumentmadeinboth casesthatclimatechangepolicymustbelefttothepoliticalbranchesofgovernment.
AsdiscussedinChapter5, “Standing” andChapter8, “RightsofFutureGenerations, ” theNinthCircuitdismissed Juliana the “ climatekids ” lawsuit forlackof standing.Similarto Urgenda,theplaintiffssuedthegovernmentforfailingtoaddress climatechange,whichtheyarguedviolatedtheirfederalconstitutionalrightsandthe publictrustdoctrine.However,theNinthCircuit,ina2-1vote,foundthattheredress soughtbytheplaintiffs acourtorderrequiringthegovernmenttocreateaplanto phaseoutfossilfuelsanddrawdownGHGemissions would “requireahostofcomplexpolicydecisionsentrusted,forbetterorworse,tothewisdomanddiscretionof theexecutiveandlegislativebranches. ” 31 Withoutredressability,aplaintiffinthe UnitedStatesdoesnothaveArticleIIIstanding.TheCourtconcludedthat “theplaintiffs’ casemustbemadetothepoliticalbranchesortotheelectorateatlarge.”32
Instarkcontrast,theDutchSupremeCourtfoundthatthejudiciarycouldorder theDutchgovernmenttoaddressclimatechangesolongasthelegislativebranch
30 UrgendaFoundationv.KingdomoftheNetherlands,TranslationofJudgment,Dec.20,2019,Summaryof Decision,https://uitspraken.rechtspraak.nl/inziendocument?id=ECLI:NL:HR:2019:2007.
31 Julianaetal.v.UnitedStates,D.C.No.6:15-cv-01517-AA,at5(2019).Notethatpetitioners filedapetition forrehearingoftheJulianacaseonMarch2,2020.Se edocketathttp://climate casechart.com/case/ juliana-v-united-states/.
32 Id.at32.
Chapter23:TheNetherlandsandtheFutureofAtmosphericTrustLitigation
decideduponthemeans.TheCourtconsidereditaninherentlylegaldecisionasto whethertheplaintiff’srightshadbeenviolatedeventhoughthedecisionwouldhave politicalconsequences.33
Thecontrastbetweenthesetworulingsunderscoreshowacourt ’sunderstanding ofitsownpowerwithinthescopeofitsgovernment’sseparationofpowersmaydeterminetheoutcome.Additionally,thecontrasthighlightsthebreadthofacourt’ spermissibleinterpretationofthepoliticalquestiondoctrine.CourtsintheUnitedStates andelsewherewillcontinuetobepresentedwithclaimsseekingredressfortheadverse consequencesofclimatechange.Whetherclimatechangepolicy,apoliticalquestion, canbedistinguishedfromthelegalquestio nofprotectingconstitutionalrights,as framedin Juliana ,orthelegalquestionofprotectinghumanrights,asdelineatedin Urgenda ,maybeacentralissueforclimatechangelitigationinothercountries.In the finalconsideration,theproblemwithacourtthatrecognizesaviolationofconstitutionalorhumanrightsbut fi ndstheviolationisnotredressableissimplyalackof judicialwill.Asthiscoursebookhaspreviouslyexpressed,inthewordsofUnitedStates SupremeCourtChiefJusticeMarshall: “Itisemphaticallytheprovinceanddutyofthe judicialdepartmenttosaywhatthelawis.”34 Andthisincludesthelawsregardingseparationofpowersandtheroleofthecourts,whetherexpressedasanissueofstanding, redressability,justiciability,politicalquestion,orotherwise.
V.IMPACTOFTHE URGENDA HOLDINGFORCLIMATE LITIGATION
The Urgenda casewasthe firsttimeacourtimposedadutyonanationalgovernmentto loweritsGHGemissions.DavidBoyd,the UnitedNationsSpecialRapporteuron humanrightsandtheenvironment,saidthe Urgenda casewas “themostimportantclimatechangecourtdecisionintheworldsofar,confirmingthathumanrightsarejeopardizedbytheclimateemergencyandtha twealthynationsarelegallyobligatedto achieverapidandsubstantialemissionreductions. ” 35 Whatmightthisrulingmean forboththenationalgovernmentoftheNetherlandsandtherestoftheworld?
TheDutchgovernment,notwithstandi ngthefactthatitdisagreedwiththe SupremeCourtruling,hasactivelypurs uedmeasurestoreduceitsGHGemissions. Oneofthe fi rststepstheDutchgovernmenttookinresponsetotheCourt ’ sorder wastheshutdownofmostcoal- fi redpowerplantsintheNetherlands.Theresulting energylosswillbereplacedbynaturalgas-poweredplantsthatemithalftheamount ofcarbondioxide,areductionofabout9mi lliontons.Inearly2020,italsopassed anambitiouslegislativeactlayingoutacarbonplanfor2030.Someofthemeasures: (1)theintroductionofaCO2taxforlargec ompanies;(2)naturalgastaxincrease;
33 Id.at¶68.
34 Marburyv.Madison,5U.S.137(1803).
35 IsabellaKaminski, DutchSupremeCourtUpholdsLandmarkRulingDemandingClimateAction, T HE G UARDIAN (Dec.20,2019),https://www.theguardian.com/w orld/2019/dec/20/dutch-supreme-court-upholdslandmark-ruling-demanding-climate-action.
(3)stimulationofwindandsolarenergyprojects;(4)zero-emissiondrivingby2050; (5)sustainableandCO2-freebuildings,andnaturalgasphasedoutinnewconstruction;(6)transitionfromgastosustainableheat;and(7)investing € 330millionwith theaimoffurtherreducingCO2emissionsintheagriculturesectorthroughsustainablefarmingpractices.36
BeyondtheNetherlands,the Urgenda holdinghaspromisinginternationalimplications.CourtsinFrance,Canada,Norway,Pakistan,Ireland,Belgium,Switzerland,New Zealand,andColombiahavealltakenonsimilarcasesthatwereinspiredby Urgenda 37 Asimportantly,theholdingprovidesencouragementforEarthlawpractitionersinall countrieschallengedbyinadequateactiononclimatechangebythelegislativeorexecutivebranchesofgovernment.Meaningful changecantakeplacewhenthejudicial branchrespondstofundamentalunfairness.The Urgenda decisionalsocreatedan importantprecedentfornationaljudiciariestocompeladherencetointernationalclimatechangedutieseveniftheyarenotperceivedtobedirectlybindinguponastate. ThiswasemphasizedbytheUnitedNationsHighCommissionerforHumanRights, whopublishedareleasestatingthefollowing:
Thedecisioncon fi rmsthattheGovernmentoftheNetherlandsand,byimplication, othergovernmentshavebindinglegalobligations,basedoninternationalhumanrights law.Toundertakestrongreductionsinemissionsofgreenhousegases TherecognitionbythehighestDutchCourtthattheNetherlands’ humanrightsobligationsprovide alegalbasistocompelstrongerandmorerapidactionbytheGovernmentisvitally important.ThislandmarkrulingprovidesaclearpathforwardforconcernedindividualsinEurope andaroundtheworld toundertakeclimatelitigationinordertoprotecthumanrights 38
VI.ATMOSPHERICTRUSTLITIGATION
Atmospherictrustlitigationisarelativelyrecentdevelopmentinclimatejusticeexempli fiedby Juliana acasewhereyoungplaintiffssoughttocompelthegovernmentto takeactionwithrespecttoclimatechangebymeansofthepublictrustdoctrine.The basicideaisthattheatmosphereisheldintrustbythegovernmentforthebene fitof thepublic,andthereforethegovernmenthasadutytoprotecttheatmosphere. Urgenda,whileitdidnotrelyexplicitlyuponthepublictrustdoctrine,hadmanycharacteristicsthatarecommontoatmospherictrustlitigationcases.
ThepublictrustdoctrineitselforiginatesfromEnglishcommonlawandisan exampleofanenvironmentalrights-basedapproachwherethegovernmentis
36 BakerMcKenzie, TheNetherlands:HighlightsoftheDutchClimateAgreement, GLOBAL COMPLIANCE NEWS (July4, 2019),https://globalcompliancenews.com/highlights-dutch-climate-agreement-20190704/.
37 GlobalClimateLitigation, U RGENDA ,https://www.urgenda.nl/en/them as/climate-case/global-climatelitigation/(lastvisitedJuly4,2020).Thenationsreferencedarethoseinwhichclaimshadbeen fi ledasof March13,2020.
38 BacheletWelcomesTopCourt’sLandmarkDecisiontoProtectHumanRightsfromClimateChange, UNITED NATIONS
HUMAN R IGHTS OFFICEOFTHE HIGH COMMISSIONER (Dec.20,2019),https://www.ohchr.org/EN/NewsEvents/ Pages/DisplayNews.aspx?NewsID=25450&LangID=E.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw 634
Chapter23:TheNetherlandsandtheFutureofAtmosphericTrustLitigation
consideredtobeastewardofnotonlyesse ntialnaturalresources,butalsoofthe public’srighttoprotectionoftheseresources.39 Whilethepublictrustdoctrineoriginallyappliedonlytonavigation,commerce,and fi shing,itsscopewaslaterextended toincludetheprotectionofgroundwater,wetlands,recreation,andwildlife,and,most recently,theprotectionoftheatmosphere.40
Asdemonstratedinboth Juliana and Urgenda,themaingoalsofatmospherictrust litigationinclude:(1)imposingapositiveobligationonnationalgovernmentstoprotecttheatmosphere;(2)promotingtherightsofbothcurrentandfuturegenerations; and(3)pursuingamoreprogressiverolebythejudicialbranchtoaddressclimate change.Inbothcases,plaintiffsarguedthatthegovernmenthasadutytoprotectthe publicfromthedisastrousconsequencesofclimatechangeforbothcurrentandfuture generations.Unfortunately,only Urgenda wassuccessful.
Thereare,however,somechallengesthatcomewithatmospherictrustlitigation. First,somecourtsmaybereluctanttorulethattheatmosphereshouldbecategorized asapublictrustresourcesincethepublict rustdoctrinehasnothistoricallybeen appliedinthatcontext.Thesecondchallengeisthatsomecourts,asillustratedby Juliana,mayconsiderittoomuchofaninterferenceinthepoliticaldecision-making processtoissueaninjunctionmandatingcertainGHGemissionreductions.41
Thereare,however,indicationsthatcourtsinmanystatesarewillingtoconsider atmospherictrustcasesandtoestablishrightstoastableclimatesystemforpresent andfuturegenerations.Inthecomingdecades,court-mandatedGHGemissionswill likelybecomeincreasinglycrucialtothe fightagainstclimatechange.
VII.CONCLUSION
The Urgenda casedemonstratesthattherearecre ativewaysforcourtstoconsolidate domesticandinternationallaws.Intheend,courtshavetheresponsibilitytomakesure thatlawsareexecutedfaithfully,includingthoselawsconcerningthefutureofacountryandtheplanetasawhole.TheDutchCourtin Urgenda hasledthewaybyexercising itsauthoritytochangetheenvironmentalstandardsintheNetherlandsinaccordance withaninternationaltreatywithwhichthegovernmenthadfailedtofullycomply.
The Urgenda caseshowsthatcourtscanhelpaddressclimatechange,inaccordance withdomesticandinternationallegalobligations,whilestillavoidingpoliticalbarriers.It didthisbyframingtheholdingasalegaldecisionwithpoliticalconsequences,rather thanapoliticaldecisionmadebythejudicialbranch.Thisisanapproachothercourts cantakewherelegislativeandexecutivebranchesofgovernmentfailtotaketheurgent actionsneededtorespondtoclimatechangetothedetrimentofthefundamentalrights oftheirpresentandfuturecitizensandindisregardofinternationalconventions.
39 BartonH.ThompsonJr.,T hePublicTrustDoctrine:AConservativeReconstruction&Defense, 15Se.ENVTL L.J.47,67(2006).
40 RandallSAbate, AtmosphericTrustLitigation:FoundationforaConstitutionalRighttoaStableClimateSystem, GEORGE WASHINGTON J. OF ENERGYAND ENVTL.L.(2019).
41 Id
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Incountrieswheretheuseofadutyofcaretestisinapplicableorlesslikelytosucceed,asitdidin Urgenda,eachlegalsystemwillprovideitsownopportunitiesforcreativelegalargumentsfortherighttoasta bleclimate,ahealthyenvironment,and otherecocentricallyfocusedrightsforhumansandnature.Theexistentialthreatofclimatechange,initsglobalscale,severity,andcomplexity,warrantssomethingdifferent fromtheprecedent-based,backward-look ingsystemsofcommonlawandcivilcodes developedinthenineteenthandtwentiethcenturies.Remarkably,in1803,ChiefJusticeJohnMarshallwrotein Marburyv.Madison:
ItisemphaticallythedutyoftheJudicialDepartmenttosaywhatthelawis.Thosewho applytheruletoparticularcasesmust,ofnecessity,expoundandinterprettherule. ItisscarcelynecessaryfortheCourttodisclaimallpretensionstosuchajurisdiction. Anextravagancesoabsurdandexcessivecouldnothavebeenentertainedfora moment. So,ifalawbeinoppositiontotheConstitution,ifboththelawandtheConstitutionapplytoaparticularcase,sothattheCourtmusteitherdecidethatcaseconformablytothelaw,disregardingtheConstitution,orconformablytotheConstitution, disregardingthelaw,theCourtmustdeterminewhichoftheseconflictingrulesgoverns thecase.Thisisoftheveryessenceofjudicialduty.42
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1)Whatfactorswillin fl uencetheextenttowhichthereasoningbythe Urgenda Courtisrelieduponbyothercourtstoaddresstheadverseconsequencesofclimatechange?Whatmightin fl uencecourtsintheUnitedStatestotakesucha boldapproach?Whatwillinhibitit?
(2)Whataretheadvantagesanddisadvantagesof “judicialactivism”— thenotionthat courtshavearoletoplayinshapingissuesofcriticalimportancetosociety?How couldthe Urgenda decisionbecriticizedasinappropriatejudicialactivism?Howcould itbecharacterizedpositivelyasanexampleofacourtinterpretingbothnationaland internationallawstoestablishanewprecedent?Howdidtheroleof “reasonableness andfairness” intheDutchlegalsystemaffectthedecisionin Urgenta?Howwouldyou respondtotheargumentthatanycasethatmakesnewlawisjudicialactivism?
(3)DoyouthinktheDutchSupremeCourtwasrighttointerpretnationallawbyreferencetotheECHRprovisions?Respondtotheargumentthatanationalcourt shouldnotrelyonobligationsagovernmentowestoothernationsto findobligationsowedbythatgovernmenttoitscitizens?
(4)Considerfurtherthedifferencesintheconstitutionalstructureofthelegalsystems intheUnitedStatesandtheNetherlands.Howdidthesedifferencesshapethecontrastingholdingsin Juliana and Urgenda?Werethedifferentresultsmoreaproduct ofdifferencesinthelegalsystemsorindifferinginterpretationsofapplicablelaw?
42 Marburyv.Madison,5U.S.137(1803).
CHAPTER24
Africa1
I.INTRODUCTION
Africaiswidelyrecognizedasthecontinentwithinwhichhumans firstoriginatedand evolved.Itishometoarichculturalheritageandtremendousbiodiversity.Ithasalso beensubjectedtocolonialismandwavesofinvasionsseekingtoplunderitsnatural resources.Savannahgrasslandsandprimevaljunglesteemingwithwildlifeco-existwith therealityofpervasivehabitatdestruction,burgeoningcities,andreckless,destructive development.
Sincecolonialtimes,therehasbeenwi despreadoppressionandviolationof Africa’sIndigenousandtraditionalpeoples,2 theircustomarylaws,andtheirancestral lands.ContemporaryAfricaisbesetwithenvironmentaldegradationcausedbydeforestation,rampantmining,andotherformsofextractionforminerals,metals,andfossil fuels,withresultantair,water,andsoilpollution.Mega-infrastructureprojects,unfettereddevelopment,andurbanovercrowdinghavedriveneconomicinequity,social oppression,andsqualidlivingconditi onsformany.Governmentscompetefor investorsintheirquestforgrowth,prosperity,andeconomicemancipation.3 Likeelsewhereintheworld,theyhavefailedtoregulate,letalonestop,thedestructionof nature,andattemptstopreservetheculturalandtraditionalvaluesthatrootAfrican peoplesareanongoingchallenge.
Africaisaplurilegalcontinent:itslawismulti-layeredandfarmorediversethan thevariousstatelawsalone.Itslegaltraditions,whichhavebeenpracticedovermillenniaonthecontinent,arerootedinthecustomarygovernancesystemsofitsIndigenous andtraditionalcommunities.Thesegovernancesystemsareunderpinnedbyadifferentsourceoflawfromthatofthedominantsystemsofstatelaw.Theyarederivedfrom thelawsthatgovernlife theEarth’slaws basedongenerationsofacuteobservation ofandrelationshipwiththeecosystemstowhichhumansbelong.
1 ThischapterwasauthoredbyRogerChennells,alawyerinSouthAfrica,andTheGaiaFoundation.
2 Inthischapter,wedefine “Indigenousandtraditionalcommunities” broadlyaspeoplesofethnicoriginin Africawhoseidentitiesoriginateandarederivedfromtheirancestrallandsorterritoriesregulatedbytheir owncustomarygovernance systems.InAfricanstates,theseIndig enouspeoples/communitiesmightbe describedvariouslyasIndigenousortraditionalandbeorganizedasclans,communities,tribes,orkingdoms.
3 See,e.g., AfricaUnion, Agenda2063:TheAfricaWeWant,https://au.int/en/agenda2063/overview(lastvisited Feb.18,2020),whichoffersa “blueprintandmasterplanfortransformingAfricaintotheglobalpowerhouse ofthefuture.”
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Inresponsetothedestructiveeffectsofmoderndevelopment,agrowingmovementofAfricanEarthjurisprudencepractitionersispromotingtherevivaland enhancementofAfrica ’ srichculturalheritageofecologicallyrootedtraditionsand Earth-centeredcustomarygovernances ystems.FromBenintoZimbabwe,theyare guidedbyaphilosophyoflaworworldview,recognizedbyThomasBerryattheturn ofthecentury,which findspowerfulculturalexpressionwithintraditionalandIndigenousgovernancesystems.4
ThischapterprovidesapanoramaofAfricathroughthelensofEarthlawbyfocusingonthegrowingEarthjurisprudencemovementinSub-SaharanAfricaandoffering examplesofEarthlawre-emergingonthecontinentatlocal,national,andregional levels.
SectionIIdiscussestraditionalAfricangovernancesystemsthatpredatedthecolonialinvasions theoriginalIndigenousor apriori 5 legalsystemsbywhichhumansregulatedthemselvesandtheirrelationshipwithnatureovermillennia.Theseearlylegal systemsrecognizedtheinherentrightsofnature.Humansco-existedwithnature withinarespectfulandinterdependentrelationship,asopposedtothecurrentanthropocentricapproach,whichcommodi fi esecosystemsandalltheirparts.Thissection alsoaddressestheenduringimportanceofsacrednaturalsitesembeddedwithinthe ancestralterritoriesofIndigenousandtraditionalcommunities.
SectionIIIgivesabriefaccountofthecolonial “ScrambleforAfrica,”6 inwhichall buttwoAfricanstates LiberiaandEthiopia(Abyssinia) becameEuropeancolonies andwererobbedoftheirculturesandcustomarylaws.Theallianceofstateandchurch denigratedIndigenousAfricanculturean donce-vibrantcosmologies,andancient communitygovernancesystemswereseve relyunderminedbymoderninstitutions andbeliefsimportedfromEurope.Inthe1960s,the “windsofchange”7 heraldedthe decolonizationofAfricanstatesandthedriveforpoliticalandeconomic emancipation.
SectionIVdescribesregionalgovernanceontheAfricancontinentbyintroducing theAfricanUnion(formerlytheOrganizationforAfricanUnity)asthecontinent-wide
4 ThomasBerrydrewinspirationforhisbook TheGreatWork fromIndigenouscosmologiesandcustomarylaws whichplaceEarthastheprimarysourceoflawor,inBerry’swords,the “primarytext.” Asnotedthroughout thisbook,Berrycallsforamovefromanthropocentrictoecocentriclaw.Forexample,hewrotethatecology mustbecomethequeenofthesciences,andnotonlyofthesciencesbutalsoofthehumanities,economics, andthestudiesoftheprofessions.Itshouldnotbethoughtofasaseparatecourseofstudy,butas “thefoundationofallcourses[and]programs.[Thus,forexample,]ecologyisnotapartofmedicine;[rather] medicineisanextensionofecology[becausemedicineisanextensionofthehealingpowersofEarth].” Thesamecanbesaidforlaw.THOMAS BERRY,THE GREAT WORK:OUR WAYINTOTHE FUTURE 84(1999).
5 TheLegalInformationInstitutegivesthismeaningto apriori: “ALatintermmeaning ‘ fromwhatcomes before.’” WithreferencetoAfricancustomarylaw, apriori lawmeansnormsofconductinherentinIndigenousculturesthatpredatedmodernstates.
6 Seegenerally THOMAS PAKENHAM,SCRAMBLEFOR AFRICA (1990).
7 InaspeechtotheSouthAfricanparliamentonFebruary3,1960,andafteravisittoalltheBritishcoloniesin Africa,U.K.primeministerHaroldMacmillansaid, “Thewindofchangeisblowingthroughthiscontinent. Whetherwelikeitornot,thisgrowthofnationalconsciousnessisapoliticalfact.” HaroldMacmillan, TheWind ofChange (Feb.3,1960),http://www.africanrhetoric.org/pdf/J%20%20%20Macmillan%20-%20%20the% 20wind%20of%20change.pdf.
Chapter24:Africa
governingbodyandtheAfricanCommissiononHumanandPeoples’ Rights(African CommissionorACHPR),togetherwithitsvisionary “AfricanCharter.”8 Italsoreviews theemergenceoftheEarthJurisprudencem ovementinAfrica,initiatedinpartby AfricansvisitingtheColombianAmazontolearnaboutrevitalizingIndigenousculture andcustomarygovernance.Thisexperiencegalvanizedcommunityandcivilsociety leadersto “gobacktoroots” andcommencesimilarprocessestorevivetheconnection betweenhumansandnatureinAfrica.
SectionVexploresthedevelopmentofEarthjurisprudenceinAfricaatregional, national,andlocallevels.ItcoversthepathwaytowardtheAfricanCommission’ sresolutionontherecognitionandprotectionofsacrednaturalsitesandterritoriesandthe rightsofcustodiancommunitiestoprotectthosesites,9 whichencourageslegalpluralismascalledforbytheAfricanCharter.Legalandpolicydevelopmentssupportthe viewthattheoriginalor apriori legalsystemsthatpredated colonialismhaveavital placeinAfricansocietyandidentityandshouldberecognizedinlocalandnational lawaspartofthedecolonizationprocess.Examplesofcaselawandnationallegislation emphasizetheimportanceofIndigenouslegalsystemsandEarth-centeredlawasprovidingessentialguidancetohumansastohowtoliveaspartofandinharmonywith nature,oursourceoflife.
SectionVIventuresaconclusion,offeringoptimismforpractitionersofEarthlaw whilealsoacknowledgingthechallengesfacedinAfricaandacrosstheplanetinthe currentdecisivedecade,the2020s.
II.AFRICA’SPRE-COLONIALHERITAGE:CULTURAL DIVERSITY,CUSTOMARYGOVERNANCE,ANDSACRED NATURALSITES
Africaisrecognizedasthebirthplaceofthehumanspecies, homosapiens,andthecontinentwherewehavespentthelargestpartofourcollectivehistory.Evolvingwiththe land,thepeopleofAfricaareconsideredthemostgenetically10 andculturallydiverse11 intheworld.Differentlandscapeshavefostereddistinctwaysoflifeanddiverseculturalexpressions spiritual,musical,andothertraditions,aswellasstoriesoforigin, ceremonies,andatleast2,000languages.Embeddedintheseculturalexpressionsare deepunderstandingsoftheecosystemsthatnurturedthem.Thesegaveriseto
8 OrganizationofAfricanUnity,TheAfricanCharteronHumanandPeoples’ Rights(hereafterthe “African Charter”)OAUDoc.CAB/LEG/67/3rev.5,21I.L.M.58(1982)(adoptedJune27,1981;enteredintoforce October21,1986).
9 ACHPR,ResolutionontheProtectionofSacredNaturalSitesandTerritories,Res.372(LX)2017,https:// www.achpr.org/sessions/resolutions?id=414.
10 JoelAchenbach, StudyFindsAfricansMoreGeneticallyDiverseThanOtherPopulations,THE WASH.POST (May1, 2009).
11 MaxFisher, ARevealingMapoftheWorld’sMostandLeastEthnicallyDiverseCountries,THE WASH.POST (May16, 2013).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
sophisticatedknowledgeandecologicalgovernancesystems,whichenabledhumansin Africatomaintainresilientlandscapesovermillennia.
ThecosmologysharedbyIndigenouspeoplesinAfricaandworldwideconsiders humankindaspartofa “ communionofsubjects ” 12 withinMotherEarth, 13 through anintricatewebofceremony,respect,andlore 14 presentsinceancienttimes.The ethosofIndigenousgovernancesystemsisforhumanstocomplywiththelawsthatgovernlifeinordertomaintaintheintegrity ofoursourceoflife,MotherEarth.Reverenceforherbountyisemphasizedthrough sharingintergenerationalknowledge, practices,andceremony.Theunderstandingisthatifwedisturbhercomplexliving systems,wewillinevitablysufferconsequ ences,aswearenowwitnessingacrossour planet.ThisrecognitionthattheEarthsystemislawfulandorderedremainsanintegralpartofIndigenouseducation,health,andgovernance.
Indigenouspeoples,definedbroadlyfromtheFrenchword indigène as “belonging totheEarth,” developedcomplexsystemsoflawovercountlessgenerationsthrough theirdeeprelationshipwiththewiderweboflife.Storiesoforigin,whichareheldby custodiansofthecommunityandsharedatkeyevents,commonlydescribethetribe orculture ’ sancientandmythicoriginandrecognizetheessentialnurturingquality ofthemotherofallhumanandnonhumanbeings.ThesestoriesorientIndigenous peopleintheirancestrallands 15 andplayfoundationalrolesinAfricancustomary law.ThesecustomarylawsandcustomarygovernancesystemscontaincommonprincipleseventhoughthedetailsvarywidelywithinAfrica,astheydoworldwide.
Sacrednaturalsitesandterritories(SNST)andtheircustodiancommunities16 are thelegacyofAfrica ’spre-colonialheritage.Asplacesofecological,cultural,andspiritualimportance,theyareattheheartofthetraditionalcustoms,laws,values,norms, andprinciplesfromwhichcustomarygovernancesystemsarederived.SNSTinclude naturalfeatures,suchasmountains,springs,lakes,forests,waterfalls,andcaves.They includethehorizontaldomainsofplants,animals,andancestralspirits,aswellasverticaldomainsreachingdeepintotheEarth,beyondthesubsoil,rocks,andminerals,and upintothecelestialconstellationsinthesky.Theyincludeplaceswherespiritsand ancestorsarepresent,asinherentpartsofthelivingEarth focalpointsofthecommunity ’ sconnectionwiththespiritualworld,w hereritualsarepracticedtoexpress respectandgratitude.ThereisaprofoundrelationshipbetweencustodiancommunitiesandtheirSNST.Thesecommunitiesreadthelawinthelandandcarryoutrituals whenjusticeorbalanceneedstoberestored.TherightofSNSTnottobedegradedor
12 THOMAS BERRY,EVENING THOUGHTS:REFLECTINGON EARTHAS SACRED COMMUNITY 17(2006).
13 FromanIndigenousperspective,theEarthisconceivedofas “MotherEarth” ratherthan “nature.”
14 Ancientandcomplexgovernancesystemsprovidedbothloreandlawwhichgovernedhumanrelationships aswellasthosebetweenhumansandtherestofnature,themore-than-humanworld.
15 Theterms “ancestrallands” and “territories” areusedinterchangeably,makingthelinkbetweenlanguage usedintheAfricanCharter(ancestrallands)andlanguageusedinotherinternationalfora(sacrednatural sitesandterritories).
16 Indigenouscommunitiesandclanswhosecustodiansarespeci ficallyresponsibleforoneormoresacred naturalsiteandterritory.
Chapter24:Africa
developedhasprofoundsigni fi canceforthehealthoflocalecosystemsaswellasthe livesandculturesthatdependonthem.
Itisatragedythatmanyoftheseancientcommunitygovernancesystemsandcosmologies,whichprovidedcontext,mean ing,andidentityforcommunitiesacross Africa,didnotsurvivethecolonialonslaught.
III.THESCRAMBLEFORAFRICAANDBEYOND
ThomasPakenham’s1990book, TheScrambleforAfrica, 17 describesthecolonizationof AfricabyEuropeanpowersbetween1876and1912,wherenationsviedwitheachother toannexterritories,suchasKingLeopoldIIofBelgium,whoannexedtheCongo.VirtuallytheentirecontinentwascolonizedbyEurope,withtheexceptionofLiberiaand Ethiopia.Othercontinentstoohadsufferedthisfateovercenturiessupportedbythe doctrineof terranullius,whichineffectheldthatIndigenousorcustomarygovernance systemsdidnotconstituteanyformofrecognizablegovernance.Thisdoctrineconvenientlyenabledtheannexationofvasttractsoflandthatweredeemedtobe ungoverned,andthereforeripeforthetaking.
Thereversalofcolonialismgatheredpaceinthe1960s,heraldedinAfricabythe famous “ windsofchange ” speechofHaroldMacmillanannouncingtheendofthe colonialera.Yetitwasonlyinthe1990sthatthe terranullius doctrinethatenabled theentirecolonialeffortwas finallydiscreditedintheseminalAustraliancaseof Mabo andOthersv.Queensland 18 Thiscasefocusedontheimportanceofactivecustomary law,andthejudgmentemphasizedthefactthatIndigenousortraditionalgovernance systemsdoinfactrepresentauthentic,lega lgovernance,aconclusionthathasgatheredmomentuminthetwenty- fi rstcentury.Asthe Mabo judgmentheld,thesource oftitletothetraditionallandsoftheAboriginalandTorresStraitsIslanderswasthe Indigenousconnectiontothelandthroughtheirunbrokencustomarylaw.
The “windsofchange” andthe Mabo casehavebeenfollowedbyagrowingbodyof lawinAfricathatenablesIndigenousandtraditionalcommunitiestoasserttheirrights andresponsibilitiestotheircustomarylawsandgovernancesystems,whicharerooted inEarthlaw.TherevivaloftheseAfricangovernancesystemshasdevelopedagainsta backdropofdevastationforIndigenousco mmunitiesandtheirancestrallands,the consequenceofmodernAfricanstatesthatcollaboratewithforeigninterestseagerto extract “ naturalresources ” fromwithintheirjurisdictions,partofthedominant rhetoriconincessanteconomicgrowth.
17 THOMAS PACKENHAM,THE SCRAMBLEFOR AFRICA:WHITE MAN’S CONQUESTOFTHE DARK CONTINENTFROM 1876 TO 1912(1990).
18 MaboandOthersv.Queensland (no2),HCA23,(1992)175CLR1,1992.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
IV.AFRICANGOVERNANCE,PLURILEGALSYSTEMS,ANDAN EARTHJURISPRUDENCEMOVEMENT
TheOrganizationforAfricanUnity(OAU)was firstformedasacontinentallegislative bodyin1963andwasreplacedbytheAfricanUnionin2002.The55memberstates togetherformalegislativebodyguidedbyacentralvision,whichincludespromoting thecharacteristicsofAfricancommunitiesandembracingAfrica ’ scultureandcommonheritageasitwaspriortothecolonialera.
TheAfricanCharter,adoptedbytheOAUin1981,19 re fl ectsAfrica’ sdesireand struggletoshakeofftheyokeandchainsofWesterndomination.ItcommitsAfrican memberstatestorespectandmaintainplurilegalsystemsasameansofdecolonizing Africa’sjurisprudence.
TheAfricanCharter,foundedonbothindividualandcommunalrightsandacommitmenttodecolonizingthecontinentratherthanentrenchingWesternlegalnorms, isamongthemostvisionaryofrights-basedcharters.Thepreamble,reaf fi rmingthe pledgemadebytheOAU “ toeradicateallformsofcolonialismfromAfrica,” 20 promotesthevisionofacontinentfreefromthevestigesofcolonialism.Afurtheraspirationcontainedinthepreambleistorestore “ thevirtuesoftheirhistoricaltradition andthevaluesofAfricancivilization.”
TheAfricanCommissionisapan-Africanbodyfoundedin1987pursuanttothe AfricanCharterinserviceoftheAfricanUnion.AroleoftheAfricanCommissionis toensurethatbothindividuals(humans)andcommunities(peoples)havetheirinherentrights,asenshrinedintheAfricanCharter,acknowledgedandprotectedacross Africa.Sinceitsfoundation,commissionershavemetatleasttwiceayeartoreporton progressandviolationsoftheserights.TheAfricanCommissionhasamandateto addressandpressureAfricanstatesdirectlyonrightsissuesbypassingresolutionsand producingreportsthathighlightrightsviolationsandbyhearingcasesofviolations internallyorreferringthemtotheAfricanCourtorAfricanUnion.Twosuchcases, oftheEndoroisandtheOgiekinKenya,aredetailedbelow.
TheAfricanCommission’sWorkingGrouponIndigenousPopulations/Communities(WGIP)hasacknowledgedthatcustomarylawsare,intoday’sworld,treatedassubordinatetowrittenlawsandcommented:
Thisisunfortunategiventhewidecross-sectionofpeoplewhostillrelyonAfricancustomarylawasasourceoflaw,particularlyIndigenouscommunities.Indeed,thefactthat mostIndigenouscommunitiesrelyontheirtraditionsandcustomstoseekrecognition andprotectionoftheirhumanandpeoples’ rightsanditsrelegationtothelowestechelonsinthehierarchyofapplicablelaw,meansthatmostofthesecommunitieshaveto labourforrecognitionoftheirfundamentalhumanrights.21
19 AfricanCharter, supra note8.
20 Id. art.2,Sept.13,1963,https://www.refworld.org/docid/3ae6b36024.html(lastvisitedFeb.19,2020).
21 ACHPR, ReportoftheAfricanCommission’sWorkingGrouponIndigenousPopulations/Communities:Researchand InformationVisittoKenya, 56(Mar.1-19,2010).
WithinthiscontextandthevisionoftheAfricanCharter,acivilsociety-ledAfrican Earthjurisprudencemovementhasbeentakingroot.Itiscommittedtoenablingthe revivalofcustomarylaws,Indigenousknowledge,andcustomsfortherightsof humans,peoples,andnature.Thismovementhaditsoriginsintheyear2000,when TheGaiaFoundation22 begantoconsolidateanetworkofAfricancivilsocietyleaders whowerecommittedtotacklingtherootcauseofthemanysocialandecologicalcrises wefaceanddevelopinganotherwayforward.InpartnershipwithGaiaAmazonas,23 in Colombia,theseAfricanleaderstookpartinlearningjourneystoexperiencethethinkingandtheworkofIndigenouspeopleinthe Amazonrainforest.Theyalsoparticipatedinotherexperientiallearning processesattheNgwenyamaschoolfor traditionalhealersinBotswanatoreconnectAfricanleaderstotheirrichbio-cultural heritageofecologicalandspiritualknow ledge,whichtheyhadlargelyrejectedasa resultofthecolonialprocess.24
Morethan150Africanchange-makersandcommunityleadershaveparticipated inthesetransformativeandexperiential learningexperiences.Manynowworkwith custodiancommunitiestorevivetheirbio-culturalknowledgeandpractices;torestore SNSTandassociatedrituals,seeddiversity ,andfoodsovereignty;andtostrengthen ecologicalgovernancesystemsderivedfromthelawsofEarth.TheGaiaFoundation laterdevelopedathree-yearcoursetoenablesmallgroupsofAfricancivilsocietyand communityleaderstoexploreEarthjurisprudenceinmoredepth.Thecourse includedwildernessexperienceandpract icestolearnthelawsofEarth,andexplorationsofWesternandAfricanphilosophic alandlegaltraditions,aswellasanalysis oftheimpactsoftheindustrialgrowtheconomyandpracticesforrevivingIndigenous knowledgesystems.Thegraduates,AfricanEarthjurisprudencepractitioners,arenow playinganimportantroleinpractice-basedadvocacy,workingalongsidetraditional communitiesfortherecognitionofcustomaryEarth-centeredlawsandpoliciesfrom localtopan-Africanlevels(asdiscussedfurtherbelow).25
ThemovementisfoundedontheconvictionthatEarth-centeredapproachestogovernancethatalignwiththelawsofnaturearetheonlywayforwardforAfricaandforthe world.AfricanEarthjurisprudencepractitionersareaccompanyingelders,custodians, andtheirtraditionalcommunitiesonajou rneyofrestoringIndigenousknowledge andpractices,SNST,andcustodialgovernancesystems.Strategiesarecontinuallybeing soughtforreclaimingIndigenouswaysofbeinginpartnershipwith,ratherthanin dominionover,nature.Astheeldersandcommunitiesgainconfidence,theyrecognize therelevanceandimportanceoftheircustomarylawsamidstthecurrentcrises,being remindedthattheirancientwaysandbeliefsareneitherbackwardnorprimitivenor anyoftheotherpejorativetermsthathavecontributedtothewidespreaddenigration
22 TheGaiaFoundationisanNGOwithaglobalreachthatisbasedinLondon,UK,andworkstorevivebioculturaldiversity,regeneratehealthyecosystems,an dstrengthencommunityself-governanceforclimate changeresilience.society. See https://www.gaiafoundation.org.
23 See https://www.gaiaamazonas.org.
24 See theshort filmbytheAfricanBiodiversityNetworkandTheGaiaFoundation,AStoryWorthRemembering? UnearthingAfrica’sIdentity,https://vimeo.com/30482538(lastvisitedFeb.20,2020).
25 GaiaFoundation, TrainingsforTransformation:Africa ’ sFirstEarthJurisprudenceGraduates , www.gaiafoundation.org/what-we-do/earth-jurisprudence/trainings-for-transformation(lastvisitedFeb.20, 2020).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
anddemiseofIndigenousculturesaroundt heworld.InKenya,Benin,SouthAfrica, Ethiopia,Zimbabwe,Cameroon,andUganda,eldersandtheircommunitiesarenow attheforefrontoftherevivalofcon fidenceintheoriginal, apriori laws.Theyareopeningpathwaysforotherstofollowandestablishingprecedentsforlegalrecognition.
V.BUILDINGABODYOFAFRICANJURISPRUDENCEON EARTHLAW:AMULTIFACETEDLEGALSTRATEGYFROM
TheEarthjurisprudencemovementinAfricaisfoundeduponIndigenousandtraditionalcommunitiesforwhomEarthjurisprudenceisalivingrealityinherentintheir cosmologiesandcustomarylaws.Thisbottom-updevelopmentinformslawandpolicy atregional,national,andlocallevels,eff ectinglegislativeandsocietalchangefrom thegrassrootsupwards.TheEarthjurisprudencemovementderivesitsresiliencefrom itsrootsintheworkofcommunitiestorestoretheirknowledgeandpractices,which areunderpinnedbyanunderstandingofthe lawsofnaturethroughdirectrelationship.Byusingamultifacetedlegalstrategy,itaimsproactivelyatopeningspacesatall levelsofgovernanceforrecognitionofadifferentsourceoflaw.
A.RegionalDevelopments
Domesticlawsineachstatearegenerallyinthethrallofthemodernindustrialgrowth anddevelopmentparadigm,andthishasahugeimpactoncommunitiesandthe ecosystemsuponwhichtheydepend.YetthefundamentalvisionoftheAfricanCharter,whichisreflectedinpopulardiscourse,istodecolonizeAfricaandtoenableAfrica toreverttotheoriginalvaluesofAfricanci vilization.Moreover,manyconstitutions withinAfricapromoteculturalheritagea ndcustomaryvaluesaswellasdevolution, self-governance,andfreedom ofreligion.InaccordwiththeAfricanCharter,across thecontinent,thefollowingdevelopmentsrefl ectthegrowingin fluenceandapplicationofEarthlaw.
1.StatementandcalltoactionbyAfricancustodiancommunities,2015
In2012andthenagainin2015,custodiancommunitiesfromBenin,Ethiopia,Kenya, SouthAfrica,andUgandamettodiscus sstrategiestoprotectthecontinent ’ sSNST, tosharestoriesofhowtheyweredoingso,andtocompiletheircommoncustomary laws.Togetherwiththeirallies,theydecidedtotaketheirvoicestotheAfricanCommissionandseekrecognitionfromAfrica’smostrespectedhumanrightsinstitution.
Representativesofcustodiancommuniti esfromTharaka,Meru,Kamba,Kikuyu, andMaasaiinKenya;BugandaandBunyoroinUganda;BaleandShekainEthiopia; VendainSouthAfrica;andAdjarra,Avrankou,andAdjohouninBenin,agreedona
“StatementandCalltoAction,” onMarch24,2015,atLakeLangano,Ethiopia.26 Their statementexplained:
ThewholeEarthissacred.WithinthebodyofourEarththereareplaceswhichareespeciallysensitive,becauseofthespecialroletheyplayinourancestrallands.Wecallthese placessacrednaturalsites.Eachsacrednaturalsiteplaysadifferentbutimportantrole, liketheorgansinourbody.Alloflifeisinfusedwithspirit. :::
Sacrednaturalsitesandterri toriesaresourcesoflaw.Th eyarecentresofknowledge andinter-generationallearning.Ourcustomarygovernancesystemsareestablished throughourrelationshipwithandresponsibilityforsacrednaturalsitesandterritories. OurcustomarylawsarederivedfromthelawsoftheEarth,asinterpretedfromand appliedatoursacrednaturalsitesandterritories.Ascustodians,wehavearesponsibility toensurethatourgovernancesystemscomplywiththelawsoftheEarth,thelawsthat governlife.Ourcommoncustomarylawsthatapplytoalloursacrednaturalsitesand territoriesarestatedasfollows:
Sacrednaturalsitesarethesourceoflife.Sacrednaturalsitesarewherewecome from,theheartoflife.Theyareourrootsandourinspiration.Wecannotlive withoutoursacrednaturalsitesandweareresponsibleforprotectingthem.27
2.ResolutionontheProtectionofSacredNaturalSitesandTerritories
InresponsetotheStatementandCallt oAction,in2017,theAfricanCommission passedthe “ ResolutionontheProtectionofSac redNaturalSitesandTerritories ” 28 (ACHPR/Res.372).ItwasdraftedincollaborationwiththeAfricanCommissionWorkingGrouponIndigenousPopulations/Communities.Thislandmarkpolicystatement calledonstatepartiesto
recognizesacrednaturalsitesandterritories,andtheircustomarygovernancesystems, ascontributingtotheprotectionofhumanandpeoples’ rights[;]upholdtheirobligationsandcommitmentsunderregionalandin ternationallawonsacrednaturalsites andterritoriesandtheircustomarygover nancesystems,andtherightsofcustodian communities[;and]recognizeandrespectt heintrinsicvalueofsacrednaturalsites andterritories.
BuildingonaseriesofpolicyresolutionsandrecommendationsachievedatIUCN WorldConservationCongressesandotheri nternationalfora,ACHPR/Res.372heraldedanewchapterinAfrica’ sacknowledgmentofthecriticalrolethatSNSTand theirassociatedcustomarygovernancesystemsplayintheprotectionofAfricanecosystemsandintherealizationofAfricanpeople ’ srights.Passageoftheresolutionwas causeforcelebrationamongcustodians,civilsocietygroups,andcommissionersalike,
26 https://www.gaiafoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/CalltoAfricanCommission-1.pdf.
27 RogerChennels,Co-AuthoredbyCarineNadal/TheGaiaFoundation, SubmissionToTheAfricanCommission: AC ALLFOR LEGAL R ECOGNITIONOF S ACRED N ATURAL S ITESAND T ERRITORIES , AND T HEIR C USTOMARY G OVERNANCE SYSTEMS 9-10(2015).
28 ACHPR/Res.372(LX)2017. Chapter24:Africa
as,bystrengtheningrecognitionoftheoriginallawsthatmakeupAfrica’ splurilegal systems,itrepresentedanimportantsteptowardsthedecolonizationofAfricanlegal systemsandconservationpractices.
Theresolutionhasnoenforceableprovisions.However,theAfricanCommission canpressureAfricanstatesdirectlytoensuretheyareawareofandimplementtheresolutionatnationallevels.Further,asaquasi-judicialbody,theAfricanCommissioncan hearcasesabouttheviolationofSNST.TheAfricanCommissioncanalsorefercasesto theAfricanCourttoholdviolatorstoacco unt.Theresolutionprovidesabasisfor developingnationalpolicyframeworksandlegislationforrecognizingSNSTandtheir customarygovernancesystems.Sofar,onl yBeninhasadoptedawrittenlawforthe protectionofSNST,alawonSacredForests,whichisdiscussedbelow.29
3.GuidingprinciplesandadraftAfricanModelLaw,2018
FollowingACHPR/Res.372,a “DraftAfricanModelLawfortheRecognitionandProtectionofSacredNaturalSitesandTerritories ” wasdevelopedbyTheGaiaFoundation,theAfricanBiodiversityNetwork,andAfricanEarthjurisprudence practitioners.30 Thisdocumentprovidesguidingprinciplesforthedomesticationof ACHPR/Res.372intonationallawstoprotectandconserveSNSTtogetherwiththeir relatedcustomarygovernancesystemsinAfrica.
ThisproposedAfricanModelLawoffersanimportantvisionofimprovingAfrica’ s plurilegalsystemsthroughrecogni tionoftraditionalinstitutions. 31 Ithighlightsthe needforguidelinesfordraftinglawsprotectingSNSTthatareadaptableinthevarying ecological,cultural,social,andpoliticalrealitiesofeachAfricannation.Italsoexplains howtherecognitionandprotectionofAfrica’sSNSTandcustodialgovernancesystems supportstheimplementationofAgenda2063, 32 the2030AgendaforSustainable Development,33 andthe2050visiononbiodiversity34 oflivinginharmonywithnature, alongwithcontributingtoanintegrated,prosperous,andpeacefulAfrica.
29 RepublicofBeninMinistryoftheEnvironment,HousingandTownPlanningMinistryofDecentralisation, LocalGovernance,AdministrationandCountryPlanningCabinets,InterministerialOrder,N°0121/MEHU/ MDGLAAT/DC/SGM/DGFRN/SA,SettingtheConditio nsfortheSustainableManagementofSacred ForestsintheRepublicofBenin(2014),https://sacre dnaturalsites.org/wp-c ontent/uploads/2014/09/ Benin-Sacred-Forest-law-final-English-version-2014.pdf.
30 TheGaiaFoundation,AfricanBiodiversityNetwork,andAfricanEarthJurisprudencePractitioners, African ModelLawForTheRecognitionAndProtectionOfSacredNaturalSitesAndTerritories:Introduction,GuidingPrinciples AndTheModelLawText (WorkingDraft Oct.2018),https://www.gaiafoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/ 2018/10/AfricanModelLawandGuidingPrinciples_WorkingDraft_bw_October2018.pdf.
31 IPBES, RegionalAssessmentReportonBiodiversityandEcosystemServicesforAfrica (2018),https://www.ipbes.net/ assessment-reports/africa.
32 AfricaUnion, Agenda2063:TheAfricaWeWant,https://au.int/en/agenda2063/overview.
33 G.A.Res.70/1,TransformingOurWorld:The2030AgendaforSustainableDevelopment(Sep.25,2015).
34 IUCN, ANewVisionforBiodiversityConservationStrategicPlanfortheConventionOnBiologicalDiversity (CBD) 2011-2020(2010),https://www.iucn.org/sites/dev/ fi les/import/downloads/cbd_cop10__position_ paper__strategic_plan_2011_2020_1.pdf;andConventiononBiologicalDiversity,Long-TermStrategicDirectionstothe2050VisionforBiodiversity,ApproachestoLivinginHarmonywithNatureandPreparationfor thepost-2020GlobalBiodiversityFramework(COP-1 4,Nov.17-29,2018),https://www.cbd.int/doc/c/ 0b54/1750/607267ea9109b52b750314a0/cop-14-09-en.pdf.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw 646
Chapter24:Africa
Article5ofthedraftAfricanModelLawrecognizesthefollowing “inherentrights” ofSNST:
• Therighttolife,andtoexist.
• Therighttoberespectedandmaintaintheirphysical,cultural,spiritual,and ecologicalintegrityandresilience.
• Therighttopersist,maintainandregeneratetheirvitalcycles,structure,functions,andevolutionaryprocessesfreefromhumanalterationorinterferences.
• Therighttomaintaintheiridentityand integrityasdistinct,interconnected networkswithintheterritory,asself-regulatingbodiesconsistingofdifferent butinterdependentandinterrelatedbeings.
• Therighttobesacred,toberecognisedandtoremainassuch.
• Therighttobefreefromcontamination,pollutionandtoxicorradioactive wasteaswellasanyactivitywhichmightunderminetheirintegrity.
• Therighttofullandpromptrestorationofanyviolationoftherightsrecognizedinthislawcausedbyhumanactivities.
4.JurisprudenceoftheAfricanCommissiononHumanandPeoples’ RightsandtheAfricanCourtonHumanandPeoples’ Rights
ThejurisprudenceoftheAfricanCommissionandtheAfricanCourtonHumanand Peoples’ Rights(“AfricanCourt ” or “ACtHPR”)35 arerepletewithreferencestolegal pluralism,andtheneedtorespecttheancestralorcustomarylawsthatpredatemodernlawand findgreatresonancewithEarthlaw.
The Endorois case 36 standsasatouchstonecaseintheinterpretationofthe AfricanCharterregardingsacredancestrallandsandcustomarygovernancesystems.
35 ThefollowingexcerptisahelpfulintroductiontotheAfricanCourtfromitswebsite:
TheAfricanCourtonHumanandPeoples’ Rights(theCourt)isacontinentalcourtestablishedby Africancountriestoensuretheprotectionofhumanandpeoples’ rightsinAfrica.Itcomplements andreinforcesthefunctionsoftheAfricanCommissiononHumanandPeoples’ Rights.
TheCourtwasestablishedbyvirtueofArticle1oftheProtocoltotheAfricanCharteronHuman andPeoples ’ RightsontheEstablishmentofanAf ricanCourtonHumanandPeoples ’ Rights, (theProtocol)whichwasadoptedbyMemberStatesofthethenOrganizationofAfricanUnity (OAU)inOuagadougou,BurkinaFaso,inJune1998.TheProtocolcameintoforceon25January 2004.
Asofnow,onlynine(9)ofthethirty(30)StatesPartiestotheProtocol[have]madethedeclaration recognisingthecompetenceoftheCourttoreceivecasesfromNGOsandindividuals.Thenine (9)Statesare:Benin,BurkinaFaso,Côted ’ Ivoire,TheGambia,Ghana,Mali,Malawi,Tanzania andRepublicofTunisia.
ACtHPR, WelcometotheAfricanCourt,https://en.african-court.org/(lastvisitedFeb.20,2020).
36 CentreforMinorityRightsDevelopment(Kenya)andMinorityRightsGroupInternationalonBehalfofEndoroisWelfare Councilv.Kenya ,ACHPR,276/2003,https://ww w.hrw.org/sites/default/ fi les/related_material/ 2010_africa_commission_ruling_0.pdf.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
In2003,acomplaintwas filedwiththeAfricanCommissionagainsttheKenyanGovernmentforforciblyremovingtheEndorois,aKenyanhunter-gathererandpastoralist community,fromtheirancestrallands,andinparticularforrestrictingtheiraccessto asacredlake.In2009,theAfricanCommissionbecamethe firstinternationaltribunal torecognizeIndigenouspeoplesinAfricaandtheirrightsascustodianstotheirancestrallands.TheAfricanCommissioninterpretedArticle8oftheAfricanCharter(freedomofconscienceandreligion)asfollows: “religionisoftenlinkedtoland,cultural beliefsandpractices,and[the]freedomtoworshipandengageinsuchceremonial actsisatthecenterofthefreedomofreligion.”37 TheAfricanCommissionalsointerpretedthemeaningofcultureas “includingthespiritualandphysicalassociationwith ancestralland,knowledge,belief,moral s,values,law,customsandanyotherpractices. ” 38 TheAfricanCommissionfoundthattheKenyanGovernmenthadviolated therightsoftheEndoroisundertheAfricanCharterincludingArticles8,14,17,21, and22 respectively,therighttoreligiouspractice,property,culture,freedisposition ofnaturalresources,anddevelopment andrecommendedthatKenya:
(a)RecognizerightsofownershiptotheEndoroisandrestituteEndoroisancestralland.
(b)EnsurethattheEndoroiscommunityhasunrestrictedaccesstoLakeBogoria andsurroundingsitesforreligiousandculturalritesandforgrazingtheir cattle.
(c)Payadequatecompensationtothecommunityforallthelosssuffered.
(d)PayroyaltiestotheEndoroisfromexistingeconomicactivitiesandensure thattheybenefitfromemploymentpossibilitieswithintheReserve.
(e)GrantregistrationtotheEndoroisWelfareCommittee.
(f)Engageindialoguewiththecomplainantsfortheeffectiveimplementationof theserecommendations.
(g)Reportontheimplementationoftheserecommendationswithinthree monthsfromthedateofnotification.39
Inasubsequentcasein2017,theAfricanCourtruledinfavoroftheOgiekIndigenouscommunityofKenya,andindoingso,furtherstrengthenedtheauthorityofcustomarygovernancewithinAfricanplurilegalsystems. 40 TheevictionoftheOgiek peoplefromtheirancestrallandintheMauForestin2009wasfoundtoviolatemultipleprovisionsoftheAfricanCharter,includingfreedomofreligion(Article8)andthe righttoculture(Article17(2)and(3)). Thecourtrecognized thattheOgiekhada communalrighttotheirancestrallandandaf fi rmedtheinterconnectionbetween theForestandtheOgiek’sculturalpractices.Interestingly,theAfricanCourtrejected Kenya’ sargumentthattheevictionoftheOgiekwasneededfortheconservationof theMauForestandtherebyeffectivelyr ecognizedtheroleplayedbyIndigenous
37 Id.at¶166.
38 Id.at ¶241.
39 Id. at¶80.
40 ACHPRv.RepublicofKenya,ACtHPR,ApplicationNo.006/2012(2017).
peoplesintheconservationofland.Thiswasthe firstcaseinwhichtheAfricanCourt ruledonanIndigenouspeoples’ rightscase.41
Despitetheholdingsintheabovetwocases,theKenyangovernmenthasnotfully remediedtherightsviolationsoutlinedinthejudgments.
B.NationalCaseLaw — ExamplesfromSouthAfrica
Atthestateandnationallevels,abodyofcaselawisdevelopingbasedontherecognitionofIndigenouspeoples ’ customaryrights.Thistrendhasbeenabasisforrolling backseveralharmfuldevelopmentprojects.ItalsoempowersIndigenouspeoplesto serveascustodiansoftheirancestrallandandalllifetherein.Thethreecasesbelow exemplifysuchdevelopmentswithinSouthAfrica.
1. Richtersveld Case(RightstoLand SouthAfrica)42
Inthiscase,theRichtersveldCommunity,Nama-speakingIndigenouspeoples,known collectivelyasKhoi-Khoi,suedAlexkorL td,adiamond-miningcompanyownedby thegovernmentoftheRepublicofSouthAfrica.ThecommunityaskedfortheirancestrallandtoberestoredbasedontheRestitutionofLandRightsAct22of1994,which requiredthemtoprovelossofrightstolandasaresultofpastraciallydiscriminatory lawsorpractices.TheSupremeCourtofAppealconfirmedthattheRichtersveldcommunitywasinexclusivepossessionofthelandinquestionpriortoannexationbythe BritishCrownin1847,deemedthepracticeofannexingthecommunity ’slandtobe raciallydiscriminatory,andfoundthatcommunitywasentitledtorestitution.ThedecisionwasconfirmedbytheConstitutionalCourt,whichrecognizedandemphasizedthe valueoftheIndigenouscustomstosupportthereturnofthelandtothecommunity. Thedecisionaf fi rmedtheapplicationofcustomarylawtoprotectthelandinterests ofIndigenouspeoples.
2. Gongqose Case(FishingRights SouthAfrica)43
Thiscasestartedwiththeconvictionforillegal fi shingofmembersoftheHobeni XhosacommunityintheEasternCaperegionofSouthAfrica.Theconvictionwas appealedtotheSupremeCourtofAppealonthebasisthatcustomaryrightswereprotectedunderSection211(3)oftheConstitution,whichstates: “Thecourtsmustapply customarylawwhenthatlawisapplicable,subjecttotheConstitutionandany
41 ESCR-Net, AfricanCourtUpholdsLandRightsforKenya ’ sOgiek, https://www.escr-n et.org/caselaw/2017/ african-commission-human-and-peoples-rights-v-republic-kenya-acthpr-application-no(lastvisitedFebruary 20,2020).
42 RichtersveldCommunityandOthersv.AlexkorLTDandtheGovernmentoftheRepublicofSouthAfrica, SupremeCourtofAppealCaseNo.488/2001(Mar.24,2003).
43 GongqoseandOthersv.MinisterofAgriculture,Forestry&FisheriesandOthers;Gongqose&Othersv. State&Others(1340/16&287/17)[2018]ZASCA87(June1,2018).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
legislationthatspeci fi callydealswithcustomarylaw. ” 44 Thecourtdecidedthatthe MarineLivingResourcesAct(thecurrentlawprohibitingextractionofmusselswithoutapermit)didnotextinguishtheappellants ’ priorcustomaryrightofaccessto andrespectfuluseofmarinelife.Inotherwords,thecourtheldthat apriori customary laws,beingmaintainedbythecommunity,predatedthemodernlawandprovideda validdefensetochargesintermsofsubsequentstatutorylaws.Theconvictionsofthe appellantsweresetaside.
3. Xolobeni Case(Mining SouthAfrica)
Inthiscase,anAustralianminingcompany,TransworldEnergyandMineralResources (TEM),waschallengedoverminingrightsbytheXolobenicommunityintheEastern CapeprovinceofSouthAfrica.Thecommunity firstlaunchedalegalclaimagainstthe DepartmentofMineralResourcesandTEMoverminingrightsin2007.Aftermany yearsoflitigation,duringwhichmininglawsandregulationswerechangedbythegovernment,theHighCourtofSouthAfrica(GautengDivision,Pretoria)in2018awarded judgmentinthecommunity ’ sfavor.Thecourtorderedthatthegovernmentwas requiredtoobtainpriorinformedconsent notsimplyconsultingthecommunity beforegrantingminingrights,whichineffectheldthatthecommunityhastheright todecidewhathappenswithitsland.Thecourt’sconclusionwasbaseduponthecombinationoftwodomesticlaws:theInterimProtectionofInformalLandRightsAct (IPILRA),whichstatesthatnoonecanbe deprivedoflandwithouttheirconsent, andtheMineralandPetroleumResourcesDevelopmentAct(MPRDA),whichis intendedtogiveequalaccesstomineralresourcestoallSouthAfricans.45
C.NationalLegislation
Earthlawisalso findingexpressionwithinnationallegislationinAfrica.Mostlawsrelatingtonaturecontinuetoplacehumansascentral,suchasSouthAfrica ’ sNational WaterAct(1998),whichstatesinthepreamblethat “waterisanaturalresourcethat belongstoallpeople.”46 Thisanthropocentricperspectivefailstoreflectthecountless othernonhumanbeingswhoselivesdependonthehealthandintegrityofwaterbodiesinandaroundwhichtheylive.Thefollowingthreeexamplesaresignsofagrowing trendofecocentricawareness,namelyBenin ’ sSacredForestAct,section4ofthe NationalEnvironmentAct2019inUganda,andtwoRightsofRiverBillsunderreview inNigeria.
44 ConstitutionoftheRepublicofSouthAfrica,1996 Chapter12,Section211(3).
45 Foradditionalinformationonthiscase,seeAlexMitchley,HighCourtRulesinFavourofXolobeniCommunityinHistoricMiningRightsCase,MAIL &GUARDIAN ,Nov.22,2018,https://mg.co.za/article/2018-1122-high-court-rules-in-favour-of-xolobeni-community-in-historic-mining-rights-case/;andZeldaVenter, XolobeniCommunityScoresHugeVictoryagainstMining,IOL,Nov.22,2018,11:51AM,https://www.iol. co.za/news/south-africa/gauteng/watch-xolobeni-community-scores-huge-victory-against-mining-18223575.
46 NationalWaterActNo.36of1998,Preamble.
1.SacredForestsAct,Benin
In2012,civilsocietyandcommunitiessuccessfullyadvocatedfortheBeninGovernmenttopassanationallawforthesustainable “management” andlegalrecognition ofsacredforestsasprotectedareas.Beninisthe fi rstcountryinAfricatopassa nationallawthatexpresslyrecognizessacredforestsandtheircustodiancommunities. Indeed,theInterministerialOrderisam ongthefewlawsintheworldtorecognize SNSTandthecommunitycustodians.TheA ctoffersanexampletootherAfrican nations,heedingthecallofACHPR/Res.372andrespondingtothegrowingnumber ofinternationallaws,policies,resolutions,andguidelinesthaturgefortheprotection ofSNSTandtheircustodiangovernance.
Inaradicaldeparturefromtheforestgovernanceregimespromotedinotherjurisdictions, “ InterministerialOrderNo.0121setting theconditionsforthesustainable managementofthesacredforestintheRepublicofBenin ” (2012)recognizessacred forests,burialforests,andsiteswheregods,spirits,andancestorsresideandprovides forcommunitiestoprotect,govern,and implementmanagementplansforsacred forests.Inaddition,theorderprohibitsindustrialfarming,treefelling,bushclearing, andhunting,amongstotheractivities,withinsacredforests.TheInterministerialOrder No.0121buildsonBenin ’ sConstitution,whichrecognizestherighttoculture,freedomofreligion,andcustomarylawsandaffirmstheState’sdutytosafeguardspiritual andculturaltraditions.
2.NationalEnvironmentAct2019,Uganda
In2019,Ugandabecamethe fi rstAfricancountrytorecognizetherightsofnature withinnationalstatelaw.Section4oftheNationalEnvironmentalAct(NEA2019)providesasfollows:
(1)Naturehastherighttoexist,persist,maintainandregenerateitsvitalcycles, structure,functionsanditsprocessesinevolution.
(2)Apersonhasarighttobringanactionbeforeacompetentcourtforany infringementofrightsofnatureunderthisAct.
(3)Governmentshallapplyprecautionand restrictionmeasuresinallactivities thatcanleadtotheextinctionofspecies,thedestructionoftheecosystems orthepermanentalterationofthenaturalcycles.
(4)TheMinistershall,byregulations,prescribetheconservationareasforwhich therightsinsubsection(1)apply.
Thishugeachievementre fl ectsthebeginningofaparadigmshiftinecological governancebyrecognizingthatUgandans’ righttoahealthyenvironmentcannotbe realizedunlessthehealthofnatureherselfisprotected.Itistheresultofthreeyears ofsustainedadvocacybyUgandanenvironmentalandlegaladvocacygroupANARDE (AdvocateforNaturalResourcesandDev elopment)withthesupportofTheGaia Foundation,NAPE(NationalAssociationofProfessionalEnvironmentalists),AFRICE
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
(AfricanInstituteforCultureandEcology),andtheOpenSocietyInitiativeforEast Africa.
Theregulationsreferencedinsubsection4(4)ofNEA2019areyettobeissued.By restrictingtheareasinwhichtherightsofnaturewillapplythisprovisionpotentially severelylimitsthereachoftheact.Thefor thcomingregulationstoimplementthe rightsofnatureinUgandamarkacrucialnextstepintheestablishmentofEarthlaw inAfricaandofferanopportunitytoreversethepotentiallyrestrictiveeffectofsubsection4(4).Abroadandinclusivedefinitionof “conservationareas” iscrucialsothatthe rightsofnatureapplyasextensivelyaspossible.
3.RiverEthiopeRightsBillandNigeriaRightsofRiversBill,Nigeria
InanefforttoestablishtheRiverEthiopeasthe firstriverinAfricatoberecognizedas alivingentitywithlegalrights,theRiverEthiopeTrustFoundation(RETFON),Earth LawCenter,andotherpartnersdraftedtheRiverEthiopeRightsBill,whichisnow undergoingareviewprocess.TheRiverEthiopeissituatedintheDeltaStateofNigeria andisasacredriverforfollowersofthetraditionalOlokunandIgbereligions.Inparallel,theNigeriaRightsofRiversActhasbeenpresentedtotheupperchamberofthe NationalAssemblyoftheFederalRepublic ofNigeria,anditisbeingscheduledfor review.Inaddition,commentsontheNigeriaNationalWaterResourcesAct2016callingforrightsofriversintegrationintothelawhavebeenpresentedtotheNigerian Parliamentandarecurrentlyunderconsideration.
D.LocalDevelopments
Theregionalandnationaldevelopmentsdescribedabovedemonstratethatthereisa growingbodyofAfricanEarthlaw.Localanddistrictleveldevelopmentsarekeytofurtheringthelegalstrategy.Thefollowingtwoexamplesshowcasegrassrootsinitiatives fortherevivalandrecognitionoftheircustomarygovernancesystemsandSNST.
InUganda,theBuliisaDistrictCouncilhaspassedaresolutionrecognizing Bagungucustomarylawsandgovernancesystems the firstexampleofpractical,local implementationofACHPR/Res.372.TheDistrictCouncilandtheAssociationofCustodianClansofSNSTinBagunguaredevelopinganordinancethatwilldemonstrate howplurilegalsystemscanbeimplementedatthedistrictlevel.47 Inthepreambleof theircustomarylaws,theBagungustate:
OursourceoflawisMaweetu(MotherEarth,theUniverse allofCreationwhichisnot human-made)whichisreadfromourMpuluma(sacrednaturalsites)andourBugungu land,whichhassustainedusforgenerat ions.Ourcustomarylawscomefromthe
47 OpenSocietyInitiativeforEasternAfrica(OSIEA)supportsaprojectwithBagungucustodianstodevelop human,peoples ’ andnature ’ srights,accompaniedbyUgandanor ganizationsANARDE(Advocatesfor NaturalResourcesandDevelopment),AFRICE(AfricanInstituteforCultureandEcology),NAPE(National AssociationofProfessionalEnvironmentalists),andTheGaiaFoundation(U.K.).
Chapter24:Africa
BugunguIndigenousLawsofOrigin,fromourancestors,fromourdetailedobservation ofthelawsofourterritoryandfromourrelationshipwithourButaka(territory),over generations.Weunderstandhowthepatternsandcyclesoflifearepartofacomplexsystemwhichincludesthesolar,lunarandcelestialcycles.48
InKenya,localcommunitiesinTharakaDistrictarerevivingtheirculturalidentity, traditionalfarming,andindigenousseed diversity,andbuildingthecasefortheir SNSTandcustomarygovernancetoberecognizedin-linewithACHPR/Res.372. Tharakanclanmembersdevelopedaten-p ointresolution,andtheTharaka-Nithi countygovernment,recognizingthatIndigenousknowledgeiskeyfortherestoration oflocalriversandthedrought-ravagedecos ystem,hasindicateditssupportforthis Earth-centeredapproach.
VI.CONCLUSION
EarthlawisdevelopingasameanstorestoretheculturalandnaturalheritageofAfrica wherecustomarylawsderive dfromthelawsoftheEarth the “ primarytext ”— are nowbeingrecognizedbycourtsandlegislaturesaspartofAfrica’splurilegalsystems.
Thischapterdocumentstheoriginandjo urneyofAfricanEarthjurisprudence practitionersandcustodiancommunities,togetherwiththeirallies,inagrowingmovementfromgrassrootstotheinternationalpolicyleveltocorrectthewrongsofthepast centuryand,inparticular,wrongsthatravageMotherEarthandhercommunities. TheseEarthjurisprudencepractitionersandIndigenouscommunitiesrecognizeadifferentconceptionandoriginoflaw,identifyingtheEarthastheprimarysourceofour humanlaws.Thedevelopmentsoutlinedaboveprovidegroundsforoptimismfor EarthlawpractitionersthatAfricaisincreasinglymovingtogiveeffecttothevisionof theAfricanCharter,namelythatitcan fi nditssoulinrestoringitsancientcultural andnaturalheritage.Theinspirationforthismovement,asencapsulatedbyEarth jurisprudence,isprovidedbyanewunderstandingandrespectfortheimportanceof customarygovernancesystems,sacrednaturalsites,andancestrallandsacrossthe continent.
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1)MiningisbigbusinessinAfrica.Manyminingcompaniesexploitingmineralson thecontinentareforeign-owned,providelittlebene fittolocalcommunities,and devastatesurroundingecosystemsandthesustainablelivelihoodstheysupport.Is Earthlawincompatiblewiththis “ extractive ” economicparadigm?Ifso,why, whathastochange,andwhoshouldgettodecidewhatchangesareneeded?
48 TheCustomaryLawsofBagunguCustodianClan(2019).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
(2)Ugandahasalreadyrecognizedtherightsofnaturethroughanationalenvironmentallaw,althoughfullimplementa tionispending.Meanwhile,theRiver EthiopeRightsBillisanemergingpossibilityinNigeriathatwouldestablisha sacredwaterwayasarights-bearingentity.Thesearetwodifferentapproaches, onethroughanationallawapplyingtoallofnatureandtheotheragrassroots efforttoprotectaspeci ficwatershed.Whatarethechallengesandopportunities ofbothapproachesasexamplesforotherlocations?
(3)IndigenouspeoplesandEarthjurispr udencepractitionersrecognizeMother Earthastheprimarysourceoflawfromwhichallhumanlawsshouldderive. ThusinordertopracticeEarthlaw,weneedtolearnthelawsoftheEarth whatThomasBerrycalledthe “primarytext.” Earthjurisprudencepractitioners thereforedeveloppersonalpracticestoc ultivatecloseobservationofandrelationshipwiththenaturalworldtowhichtheybelong.Whatpersonalpractices mightyoucultivatetosupportyourunderstandingofthelawsoftheEarth?
CHAPTER25
IndigenousLegalities1
I.INTRODUCTION
Overthelastfewdecades,IndigenouscommunitiesinLatinAmericahavefacedthe interrelatedcrisesofclimatechange,natu ralresourceextraction,andviolence. 2 Indigenousstruggles,rangingfrommobilizationsonthegroundtovariousformsof legalactivismatlocal,national,andinternationallevels,arepartofanongoinggrassrootsmovementtoresisttheworstconsequencesofdevelopmentandWestern modernity.
Westernmodernityis,broadlyspeaking,characterizedbytheseparationbetween humansandthelargercommunityoflife. Itendorsesaparadigmofexpertknowledge3 attheexpenseof “non-modern” legalsystemsthatarebasedonoraltradition andtheintimaterelationshipbetweenhumansandnature.Inaddition,Western modernityoftenproducesandreinforcesp owerasymmetriesbetweensocialgroups andgrowth-orientedeconomicsystems.
Westernenvironmentallawisoftenframedasanindependentsetofnormsand procedurestoregulatethehumanuseofanexternalentity:nature.Thismodel,however,remainsgroundedinwhat scholarJohnLawhascalleda “ one-worldworld ”
1 ThischapterwasauthoredbyIvánDaríoVargasRoncancio,M.Sc.,andPh.D.candidateinNaturalResource Science RenewableResourcesandFellowoftheLeadershipfortheEcozoicProgramatMcGillUniversity, and Taita HernandoChindoyChindoyanIndigenoustraditionalauthorityoftheIngapeopleofColombia, andauniversityexpertonIndigenousissues, UniversidadCarlosIII, Madrid,2013.ResearchassistancebyDaan deBruijn,lawstudentatAmsterdamUniversityCollege.Theauthorsgivespecialacknowledgementtothe IngaIndigenouspeopleofColombia,theWasikamasofAponte-Nariño,andtheeditorsofthisvolume.Also, totheLeadershipfortheEcozoicprogramatMcGillUniversity especiallyDinaSpigelskiandPeterBrown, andColcienciasinColombiafortheirsupport,andlawandenvironmentstudentDaandeBruijnattheAmsterdamUniversityCollegeforheroutstandingresearchassistanceforthischapter.Lastbutnotleast,thanksto JamesMagnusforproofreadingseveraltranslationsforthischapter.
2 ArturoEscobar, SentipensarconlaTierra:LasLuchasTerritorialesylaDimensiónOntológicadelasEpistemologíasdel Sur,11(1)REVISTADE ANTROPOLOGIA IBEROAMERICANA 11,14(2016).
3 SincetheinventionofthediscourseofeconomicdevelopmentafterWorldWarIIandtheproblematizingof “poverty” (inotherwordsthewaysoflifeofmostoftheworld’speopleatthattime),expertisein “economic development” hasbeenparticularlypertinent.PartandparcelofthatexpertisewashowtobringWesternlegal conventionsofpropertyandcontract,amongothers,tobeartopromotethemarketeconomy. See ArturoEscobar, TheProblematizationofPoverty:TheTaleofThreeWorldsandDevelopment,in ENCOUNTERINGDEVELOPMENT:THEMAKINGANDUNMAKINGOFTHETHIRDWORLD21-54(1995).
ontology, 4 whichsuggeststhatregardlessofculturalvariationsandbeliefsystems, humansandnatureoccupyonesinglerealworldmadeupof discrete and separate entities.Thisvision whichwecallan “ ontologyofseparation ” betweennatureand culture posessigni ficantchallengesforecocentriclegalpractice.5
ThischapterwillofferapointofviewofwhatAnishinaabe 6 legalscholarAaron Millscalls “Indigenouslegalities” asawaytorespondtothesefeaturesofWesternlegalities.7 ByIndigenouslegalities,wedonotmeanonlyIndigenouslegal traditions aset ofcustoms,norms,andprocedurestoregulatesocialbehaviorbutalsothelocal “lifeworlds,” whichare “distinctwaysofknowingandbeingintheworld,”8 includingforms oflawsforhumansandnature.
Drawingfromtheseprinciples,thechaptersurveyssomeofthemaintenets, methodologies,andsourcesofIndigenouslegalitiesintheAmericasasacontribution totheemergent fi eldofEarthlaw.Indigenouslegaltheoryandpracticemustdraw fromthelivingandknowledgesystemswherethelegalorderisalreadyembedded.Part ofthistaskconsistsintakingseriouslythesystemsofnorms,procedures,andpractices informedbythemultiplicityoflifeworldsreferredtoasIndigenouslegalities.Inmany countries,suchasColombiaandEcuador,lawatthestatelevelalreadyincorporates Indigenouslegalities.Suchcountriesaresaidtohave plurilegalsystems.
FollowingIndigenouslegalpracticein theAndean-Amazonia nregion,thelifeenhancingvisionendorsedbytheauthorsofthischapterembracesarelational,rather thanseparationist,viewoftheworld.Thisv iewunderscorestheradicalinterdependencybetweenhumanandnonhumanbeings,paysattentiontothebene fitsofplurilegalsystems,andrecognizestheintelligenceandcommunicativecapacitiesofthe nonhumanworld.
EarthlawchallengesthenarrativesandpremisesofWesternlawand,inparticular, environmentallaw.Indigenouslegalitiescontributetotheemergent fieldofEarthlaw byemphasizingaparadigmshiftawayfromanthropocentricismtoecocentrism.The purposeofthischapteristoenablestudentstounderstandthecontributionofIndigenouslegalitiestoEarthlawandpreparepractitionerstobeadvocatesforIndigenous peoplesandIndigenouslegalities.SectionIIconcernsthedifferencesbetweenWesternlawandIndigenouslegalities;Sectio nIIIconcernsthesourcesandmethodsof Indigenouslegalities;SectionIVpresen tsColombianandInter-Americancaselaw regardingIndigenouslegalities;andSectionVoffersavisionofIndigenouslegalities
4 Forthepurposesofthischapter,ontologymeansasetofclaimsaboutthenatureofreality.JohnLaw,Paper presentedattheCenterfortheHumanities,WesleyanUniversity,Middletown,CT(Sept.19,2011),http:// www.heterogeneities.net/publications/Law2011WhatsWrongWithAOneWorldWorld.pdf.
5 See IvanVargasRoncancioetal., FromtheAnthropocenetoMutualThriving:AnAgendaforHigherEducationinthe Ecozoic,11SUSTAINABILITY 3312(2019).
6 Anishinaabe isanethnictermgenerallyreferringtothesharedcultureofthenativetribesoftheGreatLakes areainbothAmericaandCanada.
7 AaronMills, Miinigowiziwin:AllThatHasBeenGivenforLivingWellTogether:OneVisionofAnishinaabeConstitutionalism ,UniversityofVictoriaDissertation,iii(2019),http s://dspace.library.uvic.ca/bitstream/handle/ 1828/10985/Mills_Aaron_PhD_2019.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y.
8 Id.at24.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw 656
intheAndean-Amazonia ncontexttoday:the Wuasikamas law,orthe “ lawforthe guardianshipofEarth” oftheIngapeopleofColombia.
II.COLONIALITYANDTHELAW
ThischapterbuildsuponthebodyofworkthatreversesthepredominantcolonialrelationbetweenWesternmodernityandAmerindian(i.e.,IndigenousAmerican)worlds. ItprimarilyconcernshowAmerindianwaysofknowingandbeingcantransformWesternlegalsystems,ratherthanhowWesternlawimpactsIndigenouslifeandlegalsystems.IndigenouslegalitiesofferausefullenstotransformWesternlawinthefaceof theecologicalcrises.Toilluminatetheways thatIndigenouslegalitiescantransform Westernlegalsystems,onemust fi rstunderstandhowWesterncolonialsystemshave impactedIndigenouslifeworldsandlegalitiesandhowthiscolonizationpersists.
FollowingthefamousValladoliddebateinSpainin1550 – 1551aboutthetreatmentofIndigenouspeoplesinthenewlycolonizedlandsoftheAmericas,the derecho indiano (Spanishcoloniallaw)formalizedthetreatmentofIndigenousothersas “things,” deprivingthemoftheirhumanity.TheValladoliddebatewasthe firstmoral andlegaldisputeinEuropeanhistorytodiscusstheappropriatecourseoftreatment ofIndigenouspeoplesundertheSpanishCrown.Oneoftheoutcomeswaseliminating localepistemologies thatis,waysofrepresentingrealitythroughrituals,socialpractices,andlegalsystems.
Thebook ComparativeLegalTraditions illustrateshowWesternlawtendstoundermineIndigenouslegalities. 9 ThenarrativebeginswithanaccountofhowRomanlaw wasthebeginningof “civilized” legalsystemsandremainstodayaprimarysourcefor understandingandinterpretinglegaldevelopments.TheprogressofWesternlawcontinuedwiththetraditionofcanonlaw asetofnormsderivedfromtheregulationof Christianconduct andtheformationofnationallawsinthemid-sixteenthcentury.
Contextualizingthe “modern” legaltradition ,ComparativeLegalTraditions goeson todescribethelegalstructures,principles,andlegalactorsofacivillawrepublic,the tenetsofcommonlawandparliamentarygovernment,theseparationofpowers,and theenforcementofjudicialre view,amongstothertopics.10 Whilethebookgivesa thoroughdescriptionoflegaltraditionintheWesterncontext,oneshouldask:What ismissingfromthispicture?Theansweristh atthisstandardlega lnarrativeignores Indigenouspeoples ’ systemsoflaw.Italsodoesnot coverhowIndigenouspeoples in fl uencedandshapedlegalinstitutionsintheWesterncontext.Suf ficeittosaywhat wasomittedishighlyrelevanttounderstandingthemultiplicityofIndigenouslegalities incolonialcontextsandtheirimportanceinfacingtoday’secologicalcrisis.
Otherrelevantomissionsintheaccountgivenin ComparativeLegalTraditions includethecompletedisregardfortheviolenthistoriesofimperialandcolonialdomination,aswellasthepervasivetra nsplantationofWesterncultureand
9 MARY ANN GLENDON,PAOLO CAROZZA,&COLIN PICKER,COMPARATIVE LEGAL TRADITIONS (2006). 10 Id Chapter25:IndigenousLegalities
re-appropriationofIndigenousculturesthatarefundamentalpartsofWesternlegal history.Thistext,aswellasthestandardWesternnarrativeofthelegalsystem,also omittherolethatpre-Romanlawandculture,includingMiddleEasternlawandculture,playedintheformationofRomanlaw,andthecolonialcharacteroflegalstructuresimposeduponalreadyexistingpre-Columbianmodesofgovernanceinthe so-calledNewWorld.Theselegalparadigmsandcultures,regardedasthe “ other, ” weresubsumedasthoughtheydidnotexist.
AnishinaabelegalscholarJohnBorrows fi ndssimilar fl awsinCanada ’ slegalsystem.HearguesthatCanada’slegalsystemisincompletebecauseIndigenouslegalities aregenerallyignored,diminished,ordeniedasbeingauthoritativesourcesoflaw. Therefore,hesuggests,thelegalsystemofCanada,acountrythatismadeupofmore thanjustEuropeansettlers,needstobereconstructedaroundabroaderframework, onethattakesseriouslyIndigenouslegalitiesembeddedinlargerlifeworlds.11
Thecolonialistethosjustoutlinedispresentinotherareasofthelaw,aswell.For example,StevenNewcombconsidersthat “[i]nternationallawservesasanexcellent exampleof ‘thelinguisticcolonizationofthepresentbythepast.’”12 Westerncolonizerswereportrayedasdominating “inferior” or “subordinate” people,andnowthese Westernnations “ ::: carryforward,fromgenerationtogeneration,arealityofdominationanddehumanization,especiallyinrelationtonationsandpeoplestermed ‘Indigenous. ’”13 Inotherwords,acceptedinternationallawsupportstheconquestclaimsof nationsoverothernationsandpeoplesandthen,additionally,thecontinuingright tocontrolthoseconquered.Newcombcallsthis “thedominationofIndigenouspeoplesbystates.”14
IreneWatson,anIndigenouslegalscholarfromtheTanganekald,Meintangk BoandikFirstNationsPeoplesoftheCooronginSouthAustralia,callsthetension betweenIndigenouspeoplesandstates “ thestoryofthecon fl ictbetweenauthority andpower.AuthorityisinthehandsofFirstNationsPeoplesandislaw,whilepower isheldbystatesbywayofaviolentfoundation.” 15 Watsonfurtherarguesthat “ [w]e alreadyknowandhaveknownforeverwhomweare, wewerehere fi rst,andwealready knowthelandandeachother.Wehaveourownstoriesofwhomweareandhowwe cametobe,butnowweareinadialogueaboutourfutureandsurvival,about genocide.”16
Thepurposeoftheremainderofthischapteristoproposeasolutionsothat Indigenouslegalitiesmaybepracticedinplurilegalsystemsand,indoingso,transform theWesternlegalsystem,fosteringthe emergenceofEarthlaw.Asyouwillread, achievingthisgoalrequiresexpandingnoti onsofrepresentation,agency,standing,
11 JOHN BORROWS,CANADA’S INDIGENOUS CONSTITUTION 23-24(2010).
12 StevenNewcomb, DominationinRelationtoIndigenous(“Dominated”)PeoplesinInternationalLaw,INDIGENOUS PEOPLESAS SUBJECTSOF INTERNATIONAL LAW 18,20(IreneWatsoned.,2017)(quotingemailfromChetBowers toSevenNewcomb(Feb.27,2016)).
13 Id
14 Id.at21.
15 IreneWatson, FirstNations,IndigenousPeoples:OurLawsHaveAlwaysBeenHere,INDIGENOUS PEOPLES AS SUBJECTS OF INTERNATIONAL LAW 97(IreneWatsoned.,2017).
16 Id.at101-102(emphasisinoriginal).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw 658
Chapter25:IndigenousLegalities
rights,andjusticetoincludeother-than-humanbeingswithinthelegalsystem.Italso requiresunderstandingthatIndigenousl egalitiesaddressnotonlythenormative aspectsoflegalsystemsbutalsotheirworld-makingandemancipatory(i.e.,freedomgiving)capacities.
ThenextstepinunderstandinghowIndigenouslegalitiescantransformWestern legalsystemsistounderstandhowtodisce rnIndigenouslegalitiesfromthemyriad colonial,interrelated,andincreasinglycomplexlegalsystemsandsourcesintheworld today.
III.RECOGNIZINGINDIGENOUSLEGALITIES:FROMSACRED TOCUSTOMARYLAW
IndigenouspeoplesacrosstheAmericash olddifferentviewsonthecharacterand practiceoflaw,aswellasdifferenttheoriesaboutwhatgivesthelawitsbindingforce. ThesourcesofIndigenouslegalitiesarediverseandnumerousandinclude “ sacred teachings,naturalisticobservations,positivisticproclamations,deliberativepractices, andlocalandnationalcustoms, ” amongothers. 17 Thestudyoftheselegalities,therefore,requiresaparticularepistemologicalapproachthroughwhichhumanandnonhumanbeings includingplantsandanimals,t hesupernatural,andeventhe inert areallconsideredsocialagents.
WebeginbyexploringBorrows ’ sjusti fi cationfortreatingnonhumansassocial agentsintheNorthAmericancontext.Then,examplesaregivenfromLatinAmerica totesttheseideas.Wealsonotethecommonalitiesbetweenthetwocontinents.
A.SacredLaw:TheCreator
Borrowswritesthatlawsgivenin “creationstoriesorreveredancientteachings ::: are oftengiventhehighestrespect, ” fortheycomefromtheCreator. 18 Creationstories, whichrefertotheformation oftheworld,areonesourceofsuchsacredlaw.They “containrulesandnormsthatgiveguidanceabouthowtolivewiththeworldandovercomeconflict. They[also]containinstructionsabouthowallbeingsshouldrelateto speci fi cterritories. ” 19 Therecognition,enforcement ,andimplementationofsuch “sacredlaws” canbeseenasfoundationaltotheoperationofotherIndigenouslaws.20 WorkingwitheldersinSaskatchewan,Bo rrowslearnedthateventreatiesbetween IndigenouspeoplesandCanadaarebelievedto flowfromasacredsourcebecausethey “broughtCanadaintoexistencewithintheir[ancestral]territories.” Suchtreatieswere alsobelievedtobenotonlywiththeCrownbutwiththeCreator,aswell.21 Onereason
17 BORROWS, supra note11,at24.
18 Id.at33.
19 Id.at34.
20 Id
21 Id.at35.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Indigenouspeoplesdidnotabandonthesetreaties,despitegenerationsofinjustices,is becausedoingsowouldviolatesacredlaw.22
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1)FortheIndigenousIkuinnorthernColombia, Serankwa, thecreator, “ left everything”— rivers,forests,thelaw:
Accordingtothespiritualteachingsofourancients,theriversareourveinsandarteries; theforestsrepresentourhairandthehairofourbodies;thestonesareourancestors peacefullyresting ::: weunderstandthateverythingwasleftbyourfather Serankwa thecreatorofeverythingthatexistsandtheLawsofUniversalOrder. Theselaws aretokeepthebalancebetweenhumanity,natureandthecosmos.23
Whatarethechallengesandpossibilitiesofconsideringthiscreationstory asasourceoflaw?Howdoesasacredoriginofthelawchallengerationalistconceptionsabouttheoriginofthelaw?Doestheideaofthe “sacred ” imposeyet anotherdualism,inthiscasebetweenatranscendentalentityandtheimmanent powersofEarthitself?
(2)IntheAndeancontext,theConstitutionofEcuador(2008)referstoasacred entityaswell:
Chapter7:RightsforNature
Art.71. NatureorPachamama,wherelifeisreproducedandexists,hastherighttoexist, persist,maintainandregenerateitsvitalcycles,structure,functionsanditsprocessesin evolution.24
Pachamama isafertilitygoddesswhopresidesoverplantingandharvesting,embodies themountains,andcausesnaturaldisasters.Canyouthinkofanotherexampleofstate law(i.e.,caselaw,statute,constitutionalnorms,etc.)withaspeci fi creferencetoa sacredsourceorentity?Whatmightha ppenifWesterncourtroomsinvokedthe Pachamama?Whatdoesthistellusaboutthetransformationofconstitutionallaw?
22 Id
23 TranslatedfromGloriaAmparo-Rodriguez&KasokakuMestre-Busintana, ConcepciónyAplicacióndelaLeyde OrigendelPuebloIku(Arhuaco)inSomosHijosdelsolylaTierra.DerechoMayordelosPueblosIndígenasdelaCuenca Amazónica 58(CONAIetal.,eds.,2007).
24 EcuadorConst.Tit.II,Ch.7(2008).
660
Chapter25:IndigenousLegalities
B.NaturalLaws:NatureasKinship
Naturallaws refertolawsderivedfromobservationsofthenaturalworld.Theselaws arebasedonhowEarthmaintainsherselfandhelphumansunderstandourrolein theworld.Naturallawsalsopertaintorelationships,describinghowallbeingsareconnectedtoeachotherandmustberespectedfortheirroles.Indigenouspracticesdraw fromnaturallaws,asdescribebyBorrows:
Indigenouspeopleswhopracticethisformoflawmightwatchhowaplantinteractswith aninsect,anddrawlegalprinciplesfromthatexperience.Othersmaystudyhowan insectinterrelateswithabird,andtakelegalguidancefromthatencounter.Somemight examinehowacertainbirdrelatestoananimaloranotherbirdandseestandardsfor judgmentinthisrelationship.Theremightalsobeanalogiesdrawnfrombehaviorsof watersheds,rivers,mountains,valleys,meadowsorshorelinestoguidelegalactions.As such,theselawsmayberegardedasliterallybeingwrittenontheEarth.
FormanyIndigenouspeople,thecasebookforlearningnaturallawrequiresanintimate knowledgeofhowtoreadtheworld;understandingnaturallawfromthispointofview doesnotrequireanintimateknowledgeofhowtoreadlegalphilosophy.25
Asdecomposingfoliageinthesoilnurturesnewlife,humanstooconstantlyexperiencetheco-emergenceanddecayofhumanandnonhumanlife.Weexperiencehow everythingthrivesinmutuality,servingitsroleinafunctionalinterdependencyoflife. Undernaturallaw,nonhumanbeings,then,arenottobetreatedasdiscretepartsof anexternalreality,butinsteadmustberecognizedas “bundlesofrelations” thatare constantly fluid allofthembeing subjects ratherthanobjects.Inthecontextoflegal personhood,thevisionofIndigenouslegalitiescontestsdeeplyentrenchedassumptionsaboutwhatcountsasa “ person ” inlegaltheoryandpractice.Thefollowingstory fromtheAndean-Amazonianregionisacaseinpoint.
TheStoryoftheTapir
BytheIngaIndigenouspeopleofColombia Compilationby Taita HernandoChindoyChindoy
Itwasthetimewhenplantsandanimalstransmittedtheirpowersandknowledge tomenastheyarehuntinganddreaming.Oneday, TaitaYachaRuna ,[awise man],hunter,and kuraka [traditionalhealer]oftheIngapeople,lefthishome insearchoftheplaceofthetapir.Hehadwalkedforalongtimetogetherwith his alkusacha [mountaindog],carryingwithhimhisblowpipeanddarts.Hewas soimmersedinhisthinkingthathedidn’trealizehewasinaplacenearthemoor. Followingapathamongthe frailejones [magnolias],hebegantoseethe rukusacha
25 BORROWS, supra note11,at28-29(footnoteomitted).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
[oldmountain] thethickandmysteriousvegetationofthemountainsofthe moor.Asthehunterandhisfaithful alkusacha wentintothemountains,they begantofeelastrangesensationintheirbodies.Instantly,anincredibleandbeautifulplaceappearedbeforetheireyeswheredifferentshapesandcolorsmerged withthevegetation.There, TaitaYachaRuna begantolookatdiverseandvaried typesofplants.Theseplantswiththeirprettyleavesformedamulticolored chagra [cultivatedplot].Havinglookedatthis,hedecidedtocutsomeleavesfromthe chagra andimmediatelytherewasthunderandrain.Suddenly,hesawtwodifferentplants,onesmallandonelarge shishaja [sacredplants]. Itwasmandatoryfor himtochooseoneofthetwoplants,andhethoughtofthesmallerone.Itwouldbethrough thisplantthathewouldbeabletomeetthegoodspirits.Herejectedthelarge onebecauseitshowedtheevilspirits.R ighttherehewasabletoseealagoon, andthesurroundingarea.Forthe firsttime,hewasabletoseetheplacewhere thetapirsleeps.Atthatverymomentandwithoutevenrealizingit,hefellasleep. Inhissleep,hebegantounderstandthevalueofeachoftheplantshehadseen. Helearned thatsomeofthemwereforgoodluck,andthatthesmall shishaja wasusefulfor avoidingevilspiritsandasprotectionagainstenemies.Inthatsamedreamhe wasabletoseethelagoonagain,andthenhesawtwoducksswimming.Oneof themwaswhiteandotheryellow.Hechosethewhiteduck. Havingtheopportunity totaketheyellowduckaswell,hedecidedtoleaveitthere. Afterawhile, TaitaYachaRuna metanelderly kuraka.Believingitwasconvenient,hebegantotellhimwhathehadseenwhenhewasawakeandwhathe hadobservedinthedreamaswell. Hetoldhimthathehadtakenalltheknowledgesthat hadbeenofferedtohiminthemountainsnearthemoor,butthathehadleftoneknowledgeintheplacewherehesawit.Itwastheyellowduckthathehadleftswimming inthelagoon.When TaitaYachaRuna stoppedtalking,theold kuraka replied: Nukakanedantakunapasuyumandayaya (Iamtheownerofthetapir,andofeverythingthatyousawandheard). Youdidwelltochoosewhatyouwanted;youshould havetakentheyellowduckwhenyoulookedatit;thewhiteduckmeansmoney andtheyellowduck,gold.Nowyouwillneverseetheyellowoneagain,andhewill neverbeyours.Thisishow TaitaYachaRuna, hunterand kuraka,discoveredthe knowledgethatwasintheplaceofthetapir.Sincethenthetapiristheauguryof goodtimesandthehoovesofthetapirareusedtocurediseases. Also,thedogis ananimalwithoneofthemostnoblespirits.Thatiswhythedogwillcontinueto accompanyhumanityuntiltheendoftime.(Emphasisadded.)
Asillustratedinthisexcerpt,forsomeIndigenouscommunities,animals,plants, andotherbeingshavehumanfeatures,suchastheabilitytocommunicateandmake decisions.ForotherIndigenouscommunities,itistheotherwayaround:thehuman acquiresthepowersandpersonalitiesofnonhumanbeings,forexample,through ritualanddreams(thetapirbringsgoodfortune).
AfurtherdimensionoftherelationshipbetweenhumansandnatureinIndigenouslegalitiesconcernswhatAustralianIndigenouslegalscholarAmbellin
Chapter25:IndigenousLegalities
Kwaymullinacalls “relationship-based” citizenship.Forher,allrelationshipsultimately tracebacktotheAncestorsandareexpressedthroughkinshipsystemsthatgobeyond thehuman.Thekinshipsystemreflectsthenetworksofrelationships;itiscyclicalasit enfoldsthepresent,past,andfuture.Then, “[t]obeanAboriginalcitizenofanAboriginalNationistoexistwithinthesenetworksofrelationship,thepattern orstory of whichwaslaidoutbythe ::: Ancestorsandwhichisupheldthroughthelaw.”26 Kinship systemsextendnotonlytohumansbutalsotoallformsoflife.InIndigenoussocieties, tobeafullhumanbeingistobepartofalargerecologicalcollective.
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1)Howdoesaconceptionoflifethatisnotcenteredonthehumanbeingimpact thelaw?
(2)Canwethinkaboutthelawbeyondhumanmodesofrepresentation(thatis,symboliclanguage)?
(3)Howdoesonederivenormsofconductfromtheobservationof andparticipationin thenaturalworld?
(4)HowdoesBorrows’snotionofIndigenousnaturallawaslawbasedontheobservationofnaturedifferfromtheWesternconceptionofnaturallawasabodyof unchangingmoralprinciplesexistingi ndependentlyofhumanunderstanding andpositivelawyetdiscernibletohumans?AppealstoWesternnaturallaware oftenassociatedwithhumanrights.For example,theDeclarationofIndependencestates: “ Weholdthesetruthstobeself-evident,thatallmenarecreated equal,thattheyareendowedbytheirCre atorwithcertainunalienableRights, thatamongtheseareLife,LibertyandthepursuitofHappiness.”
C.DeliberativeLaw:TheCommunity
MuchIndigenouslawismadethroughdeliberation,discussion,anddialogue which, followingBorrows,canbecalle ddeliberativelaw.Becausetheselegalitiesaredevelopedthroughcontinualoralcommunicati onsamongpeople,thelawmaintainsa dynamicandadaptiveforce.This fluidcharacteristicisalsocentraltoresistingcolonial systemsofdomination:
AnespeciallybroadsourceofIndigenouslegaltraditionsisformedthroughprocessesof persuasion,deliberation,council,anddiscussion.Whilesacredandnaturallawmight sometimesformthebackdropagainstwhic hdebateoccurs,theproximatesourceof mostIndigenouslawisdevelopedthroughpeopletalkingwithoneanother.Thehuman
26 AmbellinKwaymullina AboriginalNations,TheAustralianNation-StateandIndigenousInternationalLegalTraditions, IN INDIGENOUS PEOPLESAS SUBJECTSOF INTERNATIONAL LAW 1,14(IreneWatsoned.,2018).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
dimensionoftheselawsmeansthatrecognition,enforcement,andimplementation makethemsubjecttore-examinationandrevisionthroughthegenerations. When Indigenouspeoplehavetopersuadeoneanotherwithintheirtraditions,theymustalso dosobyreferencetotheentirebodyofknowledgetowhichtheyhaveaccess,which includesancientandmodernunderstandin gsofhumanrights,dueprocess,gender equality,andeconomicconsiderations. ::: SincenoIndigenouspersonorcommunity iscompletelydetachedfromtheworld,manyin fl uenceswillbebroughttobearon Indigenouslegaldevelopments.27
Givenitssocialparticipation,delibera tivelawisaprocessbasedonrelationships thatcreatestronglegalties.Collectivit yandinclusionareimportantforlawstobe establishedandenforcedinIndigenoussoci eties.Deliberativelawisexpressed,for example,incirclesthatinviteyoutoparticipateinthedevelopmentoflegalstandards. Circlesareconsideredsacredandalsorepresentthegatheringofpeopleinanatmosphereofequality.Everyoneisallowedtospeak.CirclesarealsomeanttoremindpeopleofMotherEarthandherjourneythroughlife.Beyondthecircle,gatheringsand otherlargepublicassembliesmaybeheldtoencouragethediscussionandresolution ofissues.
STUDYQUESTION
ScholarsGloriaAmparoRodriguezandKasokakuMestreBusintanafromtheIku IndigenouscommunityoftheSierraNevadadeSantaMarta,northernColombia,have writtenthefollowingonthenotionofdeliberation:
WithintheprinciplesoftheIkuindigenouscommunity[northernColombia]wetalk abouttheconsultationorspiritualpermissionofnature.Thismeansthatifyouare goingtobuilda maloca [traditionalhut],youmust firstagreewithnature:withthetrees, withthestones,withthevines,withthemud withalltheelementsthataregoingtobe used.Youmustpaythe[spiritual]ownersofthesematerials,otherwise,asindicatedby tradition[thelaw],youarebreakingtheLawofOrigin.Youmustperformthepermissionritualswiththeguidanceofthe Mamos [spiritualleaders],otherwisetherewillbe conflictbetweenpeopleandanimbalanceofthenaturalorder:droughts,heavyrains, landslidesandotherproblems.Theseritesandceremonieswereestablishedbyfather Serankua andtheancestors.28
Thedeliberativedimensionofthelawalsoincludesthe “consultationorspiritual permissionofnature. ” Howdoesthispassageexpandahuman-centeredvisionof deliberation?Howcanahuman-nonhumant heoryofdeliberationcontributetoan expandedtheoryofdemocracy?
27 BORROWS, supra note11,44-45.
28 TranslatedfromAmparo-Rodriguez&Mestre-Busintana, supra note23,63.
Chapter25:IndigenousLegalities
D.CustomaryLaw:BacktotheCommunity
AccordingtoBorrows,customarylaw “ canbede fi nedasthosepracticesdeveloped throughrepetitivepatternsofsocialinteractionthatareacceptedasbindingonthose whoparticipateinthem.”29 ItisalsoimportanttonotethatcustomarylawisnotspecifictoIndigenouscommunities.Westernlawalsoreliesoncustomasasourceofnormativeauthority.Forexample,ininternationallaw:
Customaryinternationallawisonecomponentofinternationallaw.Customaryinternationallawreferstointernationalobligationsarisingfromestablishedinternationalpractices, asopposedtoobligationsarisingfromformalwrittenconventionsandtreaties.Customary internationallawresultsfromageneralandconsistentpracticeofstatesthattheyfollow fromasenseoflegalobligation.Twoexamplesofcustomaryinternationallawsarethedoctrineofnon-refoulementandthegrantingofimmunityforvisitingheadsofstate.30
IndigenouscustomarylawinCanadahasbeenmoststronglyrecognizedinthe contextofmarriageandfamilyrelationships.However,whilecustomarylawhasbeen asourceoflawincountriessuchasCanada,itshouldnotbeconsideredtheonly sourceofIndigenouslegalitiesassometimesoccurs.Inthischapter,wehavealready learnedaboutthreeothers:sacredlaw,naturallaw,anddeliberativelaw.Onemore sourceofIndigenouslegalitiesisdiscussedinthefollowingsubsection:positivisticlaw.
D.STUDYQUESTION
In Casimelv.I.C.B.C.,(1993)30BCAC279(CA),theBritishColumbiaCourtofAppeal heldthata77-year-oldwomananda99-year-oldmanhadlegallyadoptedtheirdaughter’s30-year-oldsonaccordingtoCarrier31 lawand,thus,whenhedied,theywereentitledtodeathbene fitsasdependentparentsundertheprovince’sInsuranceAct.This caserestedonthe fi ndingthatCarrierlawallowedgrandparentstobeconsideredas fullparentsintheircustomaryregime,andthatnaturalparentswerenolongerconsideredtopossesstherightsorobligationsofaparentunderthissystem.Furthermore, thecourtheldthatneitherCanadiancommonlaw,norfederalorprovincialstatute, norconstitutionallawabrogatedCarriercustomarylaw.32
Accordingtothebroadde finitionofcustomarylaw(“repetitivepatternsofsocial interaction”),boththelawofIndigenoussocietiesandthelawofnon-Indigenoussocietiesarebasedoncustom.Howwouldoneprovetheexistenceofthesecustomsina familylawcaseliketheonejustpresented?
29 BORROWS, supra note11,59-60.
30 LegalInformationInstitute, CustomaryInternationalLaw,CornellLawSchool,https://www.law.cornell.edu/ wex/customary_international_law(lastvisitedFeb.10,2020).
31 TheCarrierpeoplearealsoknownasDakelhorYinkaDene.
32 Borrows, supra note11,60-61.OntheCarrier(Dakelh)community see DouglasHudson&MichelleFilice, Dakelh(Carrier) ,T HE C ANADIAN ENCYCLOPEDIA (Oct.5,2018),https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/ article/carrier.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
E.PositivisticLaw:TheLegislator
ForBorrows,positivisticlawreferstoexpr essrulesthatregulatesocialbehavior.As such, “theydonotnecessarilydependonappealstotheCreator,theenvironment,or deliberativeprocessestopossesstheirforce.” Theyaremadebyapersonorgroupof people(acouncil)regardedassufficientlyauthoritativeinthecommunitytoestablish therules.Indigenousauthorshipofthesebindingnormsiskey.Expressionsofpositivisticlawcanbefoundinproclamations,regulations,codes,teachings,andevennormativeproposalstoreformstatelaw. 33 However,toremainfaithfultothespiritof Indigenouslegalities,theseexpressionsofpositivenormsrequiresomegroundingin theothersourcesdiscussedabove.34
IV.COLOMBIANANDINTER-AMERICANCASELAWAND INDIGENOUSLEGALITIES
Uptothispoint,wehavelookedathowIndigenouslegalitiesderivefromsacred,ecological,participatoryordeliberative,positivistic,andcustomarysources.Inaddition, theselegalitiesshouldbeconsideredasbod iesofstories,naturalisticobservations, deliberations,rules,procedures,andcustomsthatchangeacrosstimeandspace.
Indigenouslegalitieshavein fl uencedtheconstructionofstatelaw.TheColombianConstitutionalCourt,forexample,hassince1991widelycitedIndigenousviews andmodesofgovernment.Therewe findjurisprudenceonIndigenousculturalidentity,Indigenousspecialjurisdiction,andlandrights,amongotherissues,whereIndigenouswaysofseeingtheworldhavegreatlyimpactedtheselegalconstructions.
BelowwepresentcaselawexamplesfromtheColombianConstitutionalCourtand theInter-AmericanCommissionofHumanRights(IACHR)toillustratethispoint.As thesecasesreveal,differentexpressionso fIndigenousknowledgeandlegalthought arebeingincorporatedintoregionalandnationallegalsystems,thustransforming legalconcepts,practices,andparadigmsoftheWesternlegalcanon.
33 BORROWS, supra note11,55.
34 Borrowsstates:
Imustconfessthatpositivisticlawasasourceofauthority(withoutabroaderjustificationforitsuse) promptsgreaterconcernformethantheothersourceswehavebeendiscussing.Myconcernabout statutesandcommandsnotonlyrelatestoIndigenouslegaltraditions;Iseeproblemswiththeoverrelianceonthissourcewithincommonlawandcivillawtraditionstoo.Myworryisthatifaprominentleaderorgrouprulesthroughthisformoflawfortoolong,withouttherestraininginfluences foundintheothersourcesidentifiedtothispoint,thiscouldleadtogreatcorruption. Id. at56-57.
Chapter25:IndigenousLegalities
A.TheColombianConstitutionalCourt
Onseveraloccasions,theConstitutionalCourtofColombiahasrecognizedthecountry ’ sethnicdiversityandtheensuingneedtoprotectIndigenouspeoples,systemsof knowledge,andfundamentalrights.Inwhatfollows,wepresentexamplesoficonic constitutionalcasesthattackledifferentaspectsofIndigenouslegalities,namelythe notionof “culturalidentity, ” theconceptof “traditionalknowledge” anditsrelationshipwithlifeandterritory,theideaoftheLawofMotherEarth,andtherighttoprior andinformedconsentwithIndigenousgroups.
1.OnculturalidentityasafundamentalrightofIndigenousgroups
InDecisionT-380/1993,theConstitutionalCourtgavethefollowingopinion:
Theprotectionwhichthe[ColombianConstitution]extendstotheculturaldiversityof thecountrycomesfromtherecognitionofdifferentformsofculturallife whosemanifestationsandpermanentreproductiona reattributabletothesecommunitiesas autonomouscollectivesubje ctsratherthanaggregatesofindividualmembers.These members,precisely,comeintobeingthroughthegroupandassimilateastheirsthe unityofmeaningthatarisesfromtheexperienceofbeinginacommunity. ::: When thecommunity ’ sinterestsareundermined,thedef enseofdiversitycanneitherbe reducedtoapaternalisticattitude,nortothewillofindividualmembersofthecommunity. Itisimpossibletospeakoftheprotectionofethnicandculturaldiversityandits recognitionwithout firstgrantingsubstantiveconstitutional personality totheindigenous community.Constitutionalpersonality,th en,istheonlymechanismthatgivesindigenouscommunitiesastatustoenjoyfundamentalrightsandtodemandtheirprotection everytimetheserightsareviolated(CParticles1,7and14).
Therecognitionof[thecountry ’ s]ethnicandculturaldiversityintheConstitution impliestheacceptanceof otherness , whichislinkedtotheacceptanceofmultipleformsoflife andsystemsofunderstandingthataredifferentfromthoseofWesternculture. Severalindigenous groupshaveretainedtheirlanguage,traditions,andbeliefsystems.Thesesystemsdonot conceiveexistenceassomethingseparatefromtheexperienceofthecommunityasa whole.Thus,thesolerecognitionoffundamentalrightsoftheindividual iscontrary totheconstitutionalprinciplesofdemocracy,pluralism,respectforethnicandcultural diversity,aswellastheprotectionoftheculturalrichnessofthenation.35
Asthiscaseshows,theConstitutionalCourtconsidersthatalltheelementsthat makeupanethniccommunity,i.e.,language,traditions,andknowledgesystems,cannotbeconceivedseparately.Forthisreason ,theconstitutionalprotectionofIndigenousbeliefsystems,languages,andtr aditionsalreadyimpliesthenecessary protectionofotherelementsthatintegrate theethniccommunity,includingIndigenousgovernanceandjusticesystems.
35 CorteConstitucionaldeColombia(1993),SentenciaT-380/1993:ComunidadIndigena/DerechosFundamentales/DerechoalaVida/DerechoalaSubsistencia,https://www.corteconstitucional.gov.co/relatoria/ 1993/T-380-93.htm.
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
STUDYQUESTION
InT-380/1993,thecourtstates: “[T]hese[knowledge]systemsdonotconceive[individual]existenceassomethingseparate fromtheexperienceofthecommunityasa whole. ” IfanIndigenouspersonhasbeenremovedfromtheircommunity,howmay thiseventaffecttheirfundamentalrighttoaculturalidentity?Istherighttoacultural identityacollectiverightperse?
2.OnIndigenousculturalidentityandtraditionalknowledge
InDecisionT-477/2012,Colombia’sConstitutionalCourtaddressedallegedrightsviolationsofIndigenousculturalidentityarisingfromtheabusiveuseofIndigenousbiologicalheritage,particularlytheunauthorizeduseofsacredsignsandsymbolsthat alludetothesacredcocaleaf.Initsdecision,theConstitutionalCourtcontinuedto buildimportantjurisprudenceabouttradi tionalknowledgeand itsconnectionswith culturalidentityasafundamentalrightofIndigenousgroups.Thisdecisionrefersto thenotionof “intangibleknowledge”— traditionalknowledgethatmaybeabstractor intangibleandisexclusivelyheldbyIndigenouscommunities andtherelationship betweenknowledgeandlife.Therulingalsoaddressesthefairdistributionofbenefits derivedfromthecommercialuseofgeneticresourcesandassociatedtraditionalknowledge.Considerthefollowingexcerpt:
Traditionalknowledgeispartoftheculturalidentityofethniccommunities,anditisthe manifestationofanintangibleculturalheritageaswell.Traditionalknowledgemustbe protectedasawaytopromotetheculturalidentityofagroup,whileavoidingtheuse andundulyappropriationoftraditionalknowledgebythirdparties. Traditionalknowledgereflectsindigenouscommunities’ relationshipswiththeirland,theirancestors,cosmogony, andhistory. Traditionalknowledgeisanintellectualactivityexpressedinthesocial,cultural,environmentalandpolitical fields;itistheproductofmanygenerationsandtheirrelationshipwiththe worldaroundthem,andassuch,thisknowledgeisconsistentandvalid.Variousinternationalnorms haverecognizedtheneedtoprotectthetraditionalknowledgeofethnic communities.
[T]heConventiononBiologicalDiversity(RiodeJaneiro,1992) established,among otherobligations,thatStatesmust:a)respect,preserveandmaintaintraditionalknowledgefortheconservationandsustainableus eofbiologicaldiversity;b)promoteits application “withtheapprovalandparticipationofthosewhopossessthatknowledge;” andc)encouragethebenefitsderivedfromthatknowledgetobesharedequally.Inits turn,AndeanDecision391/1996whichestablishedthe “ CommonRegimeonAccess toGeneticResources” recognizestheexistenceoftraditionalknowledgeandthepower ofcommunitiestomakedecisionsaboutthisknowledge.Inthesamevein,Statute191/ 1995, “ThroughwhichprovisionsonBorderZonesaredictated” establishesinarticle8 theneedtoobtainpriorandinformedconsentfromindigenouscommunitieswhen accessingtraditionalknowledgeassociatedwithgeneticresources,aswellasthedutyto
Chapter25:IndigenousLegalities
sharefairlythebene fi tswithindigenouspeoples.Traditionalknowledgeispartofthe fundamentalrighttoaculturalidentityoftheindigenouscommunityandtherefore mustbeprotectedagainstanytypeofviolation.36
Initsruling,theConstitutionalCourtalsoconsideredtheuseofIndigenoussigns andsymbolsbyothersforproducts, findingasfollows:
Therelationshipbetweentrademarklawand therightofindigenouscommunitiesto culturalidentityandtheprotectionoftheirtraditionalknowledgeonly findsitsexpressioninparagraphg)ofarticle136ofAndeanDecision486(2000),whichstatesthat [people]cannotregisterastrademarksthosesignswhoseuseintradeundulyaffects therightofathirdparty,inparticularwhen[thosesigns]consistofthenameofindigenous,Afro-American,orlocalcommunities, orofsuchdenominations,words,letters, characters,orsignsasareusedtodistinguishtheirproducts,servicesormethodsofprocessing,orthatconstituteanexpressionoftheircultureorpractice,unlesstheapplicationis filedbythecommunityitselforwithitsexpressconsent.Withtheregistrationof abrand,itisintendedtograntdistinctivenessforthecommercializationofaproduct andsaiddistinctivenessalsoimpliesrefrainingfromusinggenericordescriptiveexpressions,promotingactsoffaircompetitionandnotmisleadingtheconsumer,muchless affectingtherightsofthirdparties,suchasthatofindigenouscommunitiesthrough theuseofexpressionsordenominationscloselylinkedtotheirculturalidentity,which consistofthenameofthecommunities,orthedenominations,words,lettersorsigns usedtodistinguishtheirproducts.37
Asanextensionofthetheoryofculturalappropriation,theConstitutionalCourt prohibitedtheuseofanIndigenoussigno nacoca-basedproduct.Insodoing,the courtgrantedfundamentalprotectionaga insteconomicabuseofIndigenoussigns consideredbothastraditionalknowledgeandIndigenousculturalidentity.
STUDYQUESTION
Article136ofAndeanDecision486/2000statesthatapersoncannotregisterastrademarksthosesignswhoseuseintradeundulyaffectstherightofathirdparty,inparticularwhentheuseconsists “ ofthenameofindigenous,Afro-American,orlocal communities ::: unlesstheapplicationis filedbythecommunityitself orwithits expressconsent. ” (Emphasisadded.)Apharmaceuticalcompanyobtainstheconsentofmembers ofanAmazoniancommunitytousethenameofthiscommunityonthelabelofa newproduct.However,severalmembersofthecommunitydisagreewiththis.Canthis consentbeconsideredsuf fi cientand/orlegitimatefor thepurposesofusingthe Indigenousnameontheproduct’slabel?
36 CorteConstitucionaldeColombia(2012),SentenciaT-477/12:LegitimacionporActivadeOrganizacion NacionalIndigenaparaInterponerAcciondeTutela(emphasisadded),https://www.corteconstitucional. gov.co/relatoria/2012/T-477-12.htm.
37 Id
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
3.OntraditionalknowledgeandtraditionalIndigenouslaw
DecisionSU-510/1998oftheConstitutionalC ourtaddressestherightoftraditional authoritiesoftheIkapeopletoupholdtheirculturalidentityandintegritywithintheir territorybyprohibitingsomeactivitiesofChristiansinthecommunitywhochallenged thematerialcultureoftheIka.InitsrulingaffirmingtherightsoftheIku,theConstitutionalCourtwroteabouttherelationshipbetweenIndigenouslaw,cosmology,and materialculture.Whenreadingthefollowingexcerpt,considerthesourcesofIndigenouslegalitiesthatwehavebeenpreviouslydiscussed.
FortheIka[anindigenousgroupfromNorthernColombia],weavingisanactivitythat transcendsthemeremanufactureofcottonfabricsfortheproductionofclothing.Thus, thisisanactivityofaprofoundlymoralna turewithprofoundmetaphysicalconsequences.TheIkaconsiderthatweavingafabricisactuallyweaving “thefabricofone’ s life.” Theresultingfabricortapestryrepresentsametaphoricalactivitywherethecotton threadsareconsidered thoughts.Thesethoughtsslowlyorganizeandintertwinethenetworkofsocialrelationswheretheweaverisalsoinserted.FortheIka, “weavingisthinking” and “thinkingisliving.” Thisexplainswhy “thepersonwhodoesnotthink,doesnot live.” Throughweaving,thoughtsareorganizedandembeddedwithinauniversalorder. Byweavingandthinkingabalancebetweentheoppositesisachievedthusful fillingthe “Mother’sLaw.”38
Aheadnoteexplainingthedecisionstates:
TheCourthasindicatedthatthelimitationstowhichtheprinciplesofethnicandculturaldiversityandautonomyofindigenouscommunitiesaresubjectarisefromtheconstitutionaltextitself,whichdetermines,ontheonehand,thatColombiaisaunitary Statewithautonomyfromitsterritorialentitiesand,ontheotherhand,thatthepolitical andlegalautonomyofindigenouscommunities,thatis,theabilitytogovernthemselves andexercisejurisdictionalfunctionswith intheirterritorialscope,canbeexercised accordingtotheirusesandcustoms,aslongastheyarenotcontrarytotheConstitution andthelaw.Theforegoingdeterminesthat,inmattersofindigenouscommunities,the PoliticalCharterestablishesaregimefortheconservationofdiversityinunity.AccordingtotheCourt, “onlywithahighdegreeofautonomyisculturalsurvivalpossible, ” a statementthatmeansethnicandculturaldiversity,asageneralprinciple,canonlybe limitedwhenitsexerciseignoresconstitutionalorlegalnormsofgreaterimportance. Accordingtojurisprudence,inprinciple,theeffectivenessoftherightsofindigenous peoples,determinesthatthelimitsthatmaybeimposedonthenormativeandjurisdictionalautonomyofsuchcommunitiesareonlythosethatarereferred “towhatistruly intolerablebecauseitattackswhatismostprecioustohumanity.”
38 CorteConstitucionaldeColombia(1998),SentenciaSU-510/98:EnNombreDelPuebloyPorMandatode laConstitucion,www.https://www.corteconstitucional.gov.co/relatoria/1998/SU510-98.htm.
Chapter25:IndigenousLegalities
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1)Accordingtothisconstitutionaldecision, “fabric” and “thought” areexpressionsof thesameactionfortheIkucommunity.Therefore,thinkingisweaving,andweavingisthinking.WhatdoesIndigenousmaterialculturehavetodowiththelaw?
(2)Thematerialsforweavingcomefrom nature,andtheendproduct,apieceof clothing,istherepresentationofhumanthought.Insofarasthenotionoftraditionalknowledgeincludestangibleand non-tangibleelements,howdoesthis ideatransformourestablishedconceptsaboutthenatureoflegalmeaningand practice?Isthelawstrictlyreducibletothesymbolic,thatis,tolanguage,i.e., whatthelawsaysonitsface?
4.OninformedconsentbyIndigenouscommunitiesandterritorialand communalgovernance
DecisionSU-039/9739 oftheColombianConstitutionalCourtisaparadigmaticcaseon priorconsultationwithIndigenouscommunities.ThispieceofjurisprudenceexaminedthescopeofIndigenouspeoples’ righttoparticipationinprojectsthataffecttheir traditionallands.TheOf fi ceoftheUnitedNationsHighCommissionerforHuman Rightssummarizedthiscaseasfollows:
ThiscasewastakentotheConstitutionalCourtofColombiabytheOmbudsmanon behalfoftheU’wapeopleandagainsttheMinistryofEnvironmentandtheprivateoil companySociedadOccidentaldeColombia,Inc.Thecasedealtwiththerightofindigenouspeoplesto participatethroughconsultationsindecisionsthatmayaffectthem,inparticularrelatedtodefenseandprese rvationofindigenousland. ::: Thelegalquestion examinedthescopeoftherighttoparticipationofindigenouspeoplesinprojectsthat affecttheirland.TheCourtconsideredConstitutionalrightsrelatedtoprotectionof ethnicintegrity(Articles7,10and70)aswe llastherighttoself-determination(Article330)andtherighttoparticipation(Article40). :::
TheConstitutionalCourtfoundthattheprocessusedtosecureanenvironmental licenseforoilexplorationhadnotbeenadequateasithadignoredtheU’wacommunity ’ sfundamentalrighttobeformallyandsubst antiallyconsulted.Thisdecisionwas groundedontheprinciplethat participationthroughconsultationisafundamentalright becauseitisanessentialwaytopreservet heethnic,social,economicandcultural integrityofindigenouscommunities,whichwasnecessaryfortheirsurvivalasasocial group. 40
39 CorteConstitucionaldeColombia(1997),SentenciaSU-039/97:DERECHOS FUNDAMENTALESDE COMUNIDAD INDIGENA [availableat:https://www.corteconstitucional.gov.co/relatoria/1997/SU039-97.htm]
40 OFFICEOFTHE U NITED NATIONS H IGH COMMISSIONERFOR H UMAN R IGHTS,LANDAND H UMAN R IGHTS:ANNOTATED COMPILATIONOF CASE LAW,75(2015).(Emphasisadded.)
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Similarly,inT-993/2012,whichalsoaddressedthefundamentalrighttopriorconsultationofIndigenouscommunitiesandethnicgroups,theConstitutionalCourtof Colombiasaid:
FortheCourt,therightofindigenouspeoplestohavetheirownsocial,economicand culturallife,andtoprofesstheirownreligionandpracticetheirownlanguage(article27 oftheInternationalCovenantonCivilandPoliticalRights)iscloselylinkedtotheright tohavetheirownterritory [T]heindigenousterritoryandresources,traditions,and knowledgesystemstogetherconstitutealegacythatunites asawhole thepresent generationandthegenerationstofollow.41
Initsruling,theCourthighlightedtheholisticnatureofIndigenousworldviewsas acornerstoneoftherighttoparticipationthroughpriorconsultation.Priorconsultationisanexpressionoftheprincipleofself-determination,whichincludesthepower ofself-governmentandtheabilitytoguidebehaviorinaccordancewithalocalsystem ofnorms,protocols,andprocedures whichbringsustoIndigenouslawandgovernancesystems.Onthistopic,theCourtsaid:
Therighttothe protection ofethnicculturalidentityhasbeenanalyzedbythisBody[the Court]fromtwodifferentperspectives:anegativeperspective ::: [referringto]howpreventingpublicmanifestationsofreligiouspracticesoutsideof[indigenous]traditionsis awaytoavoidthedisappearanceof[aparticu lar]culture;andapositiveperspective expressedinthereproductionof[indigenous]culturalidentitythroughethnoeducationandotherprocesses.Inaddition,basedontheprincipleofselfdetermination. ::: theCourthasaffirmedthatethniccommunitieshavethepowertodeterminetheir owninstitutionsandgovernmentauthorities;todetermineandmaintaintheirnorms,customs,worldviews,developmentoptions,andlifeprojects,andtoadoptthoseinternalorlocaldecisions thatthey deemmostappropriatefortheconservation,orprotectionofthesepurposes.
Asamanifestationofthisprinciple,nationalandinternationallawhasestablishedthe obligation tocarryoutapriorconsultationwiththesecommunitiesbeforeadoptinglegaloradministrativemeasures thatmayaffectthemdirectly. ::: [TheCourthasprotectedtherightto priorconsultationincasesof]environmentallicenses,constructioncontractslinkedto developmentprojectsthatdirectlyaffectethniccommunities,aswellasdecisionsthat allowtheexploitationofresourceswithinindigenousterritories, andissuesrelated toethnoeducation.Itisthusarightincontinuousconstructionwhoseprotection dependsontheimpactthatcanbedemonstratedineachspecificcase. 42
STUDYQUESTION
Basedontheconstitutionalprincipleofself-determination,Indigenouscommunities havethepowertodictatetheirownsystemsoflaws,justice,andgovernment.Doyou
41 CorteConstitucionaldeColombia(2012),SentenciaT-993/12:DERECHO FUNDAMENTALALA CONSULTA PREVIA DE COMUNIDADES INDIGENAS YGRUPOS ETNICOS [availableat:https://www.corteconstitucional.gov.co/relatoria/ 2012/T-993-12.htm].
42 Id.(emphasisadded).
thinkthattherecognitionofIndigenousgovernancesystemsbasedonarelational worldviewcouldtransformstatenotionsofparticipationandconsultation?
B.Inter-AmericanCommissiononHumanRights
1.Onancestralland,communaltenure,andIndigenouspropertyrights
ThecollectivetenureoflandisakeycomponentofIndigenousworldviewsandwaysof being.TheInter-AmericanCommissiononHumanRights(IACHR),abodycreatedby theOrganizationofAmericanStates(OAS)thataimstopromoteandprotectrightsin theAmericas,hasreferredtothisissueinseveralcases.FortheCommission,thecommunalpropertyrighttothelandsthatIndigenouspeopleshavetraditionallyusedand occupiedisafunctionoftheircustomarypatternsoflanduseandtenure.Inaddition, theCommissionreferstothestate ’ sdutytotakeeffectivemeasurestorecognize Indigenouspeoples’ communalpropertyrighttothelandsthattheyhavetraditionally occupiedandusedandtodelimit,demarcate,andtitletheterritoryonwhichtheir rightexists.
In MayaIndigenousCommunityoftheToledoDistrictv.Belize ,MayaIndigenouscommunitiesarguedthattheStateofBelizeviol atedtheirrightsoverlandtraditionally usedandoccupiedbytheMayapeoplebygrantingloggingandoilconcessionsand otherwisefailingtoprotectthoselands,a mongstotherclaims.TheIACHRruledin favoroftheMayapeople:
95.[A]reviewofpertinenttreaties,legislationandjurisprudencerevealsthedevelopmentovermorethan80yearsofparticularhumanrightsnormsandprinciplesapplicabletothecircumstancesandtreatmentofindigenouspeoples.Centraltothesenorms andprincipleshasbeentherecognitionoftheneedforspecialmeasuresbystatesto compensatefortheexploitationanddiscriminationtowhichthesesocietieshavebeen subjectedatthehandsofthenon-indigenous.
98.Indecidinguponthecomplaintsinthepresentpetition,therefore,theCommission willafforddueconsiderationtotheparticularnormsandprinciplesofinternational humanrightslawgoverningtheindividualandcollectiveinterestsofindigenouspeoples,includingconsiderationofanyspecialmeasuresthatmaybeappropriateandnecessaryingivingpropereffecttotheserightsandinterests. :::
151.Insummary,basedupontheforegoinganalysis,theCommissionconcludesthatthe MayapeopleofsouthernBelizehaveacommunalpropertyrighttothelandsthatthey havetraditionallyusedandoccupied,andthatthecharacteroftheserightsisafunction ofMayacustomarylandusepatternsandtenure.TheCommissionalsoconsidersthat thisrightisembracedandaffirmedbyArticleXXIIIoftheAmericanDeclaration.
152.TheCommissionfurtherconcludesthattheStatehasviolatedtherighttoproperty enshrinedinArticleXXIIIoftheAmericanDeclarationtothedetrimentoftheMaya people,byfailingtotakeeffectivemeasurestorecognizetheircommunalpropertyright tothelandsthattheyhavetraditionallyoccupiedandused,andtodelimit,demarcate Chapter25:IndigenousLegalities
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
andtitleorotherwiseestablishthelegalmechanismsnecessarytoclarifyandprotectthe territoryonwhichtheirrightexists.
153.Inaddition,theCommissionconcludesthattheState,bygrantingloggingandoil concessionstothirdpartiestoutilizethepropertyandresourcesthatcouldfallwithin thelandswhichmustbedelimited,demarcatedandtitledorotherwiseclari fiedorprotected,withouteffectiveconsultationswithandtheinformedconsentoftheMayapeopleandwithresultingenvironmentaldamage,furtherviolatedtherighttoproperty enshrinedinArticleXXIIIoftheAmericanDeclarationtothedetrimentoftheMaya people.
154.Finally,theCommissionnotesthePetitioners’ contentionthatthefailureofthe Statetoengageinmeaningfulconsultatio nwiththeMayapeopleinconnectionwith theloggingandoilconcessionsintheToledoDistrict,andthenegativeenvironmental effectsarisingfromthoseconcessions,constituteviolationsofseveralotherrightsunder internationalhumanrightslaw,includingtherighttolifeunderArticleIoftheAmericanDeclaration,therighttoreligiousfreedomandworshipunderArticleIIIofthe AmericanDeclaration,therighttoafamilyandtoprotectionthereofunderArticleVI oftheAmericanDeclaration,therighttopreservationofhealthandwell-beingunder ArticleXIoftheAmericanDeclaration,andthe “righttoconsultation” implicitinArticle27oftheICCPR,ArticleXXoftheAmericanDeclaration,andtheprincipleofselfdetermination.
155.Initsanalysisofthiscase,theCommissionhasemphasizedthedistinctnatureofthe righttopropertyasitappliestoindigenouspeoples,whereby thelandtraditionallyused andoccupiedbythesecommunitiesplaysacentralroleintheirphysical,culturalandspiritualvitality. AstheCommissionhaspreviouslyrecognizedwithrespectoftherighttoproperty andtherighttoequality, “[f]orindigenouspeople,thefreeexerciseofsuchrightsis essentialtotheenjoymentandperpetuationoftheirculture.” Similarly,theconceptof familyandreligionwithinthecontextofindigenouscommunities,includingtheMaya people,isintimatelyconnectedwiththeirtraditionalland,whereancestralburial grounds,placesofreligioussignifi canceandkinshippatternsarelinkedwiththeoccupationanduseoftheirphysicalterritories.Further,theCommissionhasspecificallyconcludedinitsanalysisofthiscasethatthedutytoconsultisafundamentalcomponentof theState’sobligationsingivingeffecttothecommunalpropertyrightoftheMayapeopleinthelandsthattheyhavetraditionallyusedandoccupied.43
2.Ontheobligationtoconsult
In KichwaIndigenousPeopleofSarayakuv.Ecuador,theIACHRconsideredthegranting ofapermitbythegovernmenttoaprivate oilcompanyintheancestralterritoryof theKichwa(alternatively, Quechua,orQuichua)people.ThepermitallowedoilexplorationandexploitationandwasissuedwithoutconsultationwiththeKichwapeople.As withthe Maya case,theIACHRruledinfavoroftheIndigenousKichwapeople:
43 MayaIndigenousCommunityoftheToledoDistrictv.Belize,ReportNo.78/00;Case12.053(2-20October2000) [availableat:http://www.worldcourts.com/iac mhr/eng/decisions/2000.10.05_Maya_Indigenous_ Communities_v_Belize.pdf].
674
Chapter25:IndigenousLegalities
Para.149.Inthiscase,theCourt fi ndsthatthereisnodoubtregardingtheSarayaku Peoples ’ communalownershipoftheirterrito ry,whichisexercisedinatimehonouredandancestralmanner.ThiswasexpresslyrecognizedbytheStatethrough theadjudicationmadeonMay12,1992.Notwithstandingtheforegoing,inadditionto thepointsnotedinthesectiononthefactsofthecase,theCourtconsidersitpertinent toemphasizethedeepcultural,non-pecuniaryandspiritualtiesthatthecommunityhas withitsterritory,soastofullyunderstandthedamagescausedinthiscase.
Para.160.Itisforalltheaforementionedreasonsthatoneofthefundamentalguaranteesforensuringtheparticipationofindigenouspeoplesandcommunitiesindecisions regardingmeasuresthataffecttheirrightsand,inparticular,theirrighttocommunal property,ispreciselytherecognitionoftheirrighttoconsultation,whichisrecognized intheILOConventionNo.169,amongothercomplementaryinternational instruments.
Para.166.TheobligationtoconsultindigenousandTribalCommunitiesandPeoples onanyadministrativeorlegalmeasurethatmayaffecttheirrights,asrecognizedunder domesticandinternationallaw,aswellas theobligationtoguaranteetherightsof indigenouspeoplestoparticipateindecisionsonmattersthatconcerntheirinterests, isdirectlyrelatedtothegeneralobligatio ntoguaranteethefreeandfullexerciseof therightsrecognizedintheConvention(Article1(1).Thisimpliesthedutytoadequatelyorganizetheentiregovernmentalapparatusand,ingeneral,alltheorganizationsthroughwhichpublicpowerisexerci sed,sothatthesearecapableoflegally guaranteeingthefreeandfullexerciseofthoserights.TheforegoingmeansthatStates havetheobligationtostructuretheirsta ndardsandinstitutionsinsuchawaythat indigenous,nativeortribalcommunitiesca nbeconsultedeffectively,inaccordance withinternationalstandardsinthismatter.Thus,Statesmustincorporatethosestandardswithinthepriorconsultationprocesses,soastogeneratesustained,effectiveand reliablechannelsfordialoguewithindigenouscommunitiesinprocessesofconsultation andparticipationthroughtheirrepresentativeinstitutions.
Para.177.TheCourthasestablishedthatinordertoensureeffectiveparticipationby membersofanindigenouscommunityorpeopleindevelopmentorinvestmentplans withintheirterritory,theStatehasthedutytoconsultthecommunityinanactiveand informedmanner,andinaccordancewithitscustomsandtraditions,inthecontextof acontinuouscommunicationbetweentheparties.
Moreover,theseconsultationsshouldbeundertakeningoodfaith,throughculturally appropriateproceduresandmustbeaimedatreachinganagreement.Similarly,the indigenouspeopleorcommunitymustbeconsultedinaccordancewithitsowntraditions,duringtheearlystagesofthedevelopmentorinvestmentplan,andnotonlywhen itisnecessarytoobtainthecommunity’sapproval.Also,theStatemustensurethatmembersofthecommunityareawareofthepotentialbenefitsandriskssotheycandecide whetherornottoaccepttheproposeddevelopmentorinvestmentplan.Finally,the consultationmusttakeintoaccountthetraditionaldecision-makingpracticesofthe peopleorcommunity.Failuretocomplywiththisobligation,orengaginginconsultationswithoutregardtotheiressentialcharacteristics,compromisestheState’sinternationalresponsibility. :::
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Para.232.TheState,byfailingtoconsulttheSarayakuPeopleontheexecutionofaprojectthatwoulddirectlyaffecttheirterritory,wasinbreachofitsobligations,underthe principlesofinternationallawandofitsowndomesticlaw,toadoptallnecessarymeasurestoguaranteetheparticipationoftheSarayakuPeople,throughtheirowninstitutionsandmechanismsandinaccordancewith theirvalues,traditions,customsand formsoforganization,inthedecisionsmaderegardingmattersandpoliciesthat affectedorcouldaffecttheirterritory,theirculturalandsociallife,theirrightstocommunalpropertyandtoculturalidentity.C onsequently,theCourtconsidersthatthe StateisresponsiblefortheviolationoftherighttocommunalpropertyoftheSarayaku People,recognizedinArticle21oftheConvention,inrelationtotherighttocultural identity,underthetermsofArticles1(1)and(2)thereof. 44
V. WUASIKAMAS,THELAWOFTHEINDIGENOUSINGAOF APONTEINCOLOMBIA
This finalsectionstudiessomeaspectsofoneparticularIndigenouslegalsystem,the Wuasikamas oftheIngaofAponte,andhowthissysteminteractswithstatelaw.
A.IntroductiontotheIngaofAponte
TheIngapeoplearepartofthelivingcultureoftheGreatIncanation.By1450,the Incaadministeredtheterritorytheycalled Tawaintinsuyu, whichincludedfour regions Chinchaysuyu (north), Antisuyu (east,theAmazonjungle), Contisuyu (west), and Collasuyu (south).TheregionsofCaquetá,Cauca,Putumayo,andNariñoof today’ssouthernColombiatogethermadeupwhattheIncacalled Chinchaisuyu.Inthis territoryoftheColombianAmazon,theIng aco-existwithother ancestralpeoples, speci fi callytheCofán,Siona,Camentzá,Quillasinga,andPasto.Accordingtothe Colombiancensusof2018,thetotalpopulationoftheIngawas19,561.
TheancestralterritoryoftheIngaispa rtoftheColombian massif(partofthe Andesmountains)eco-regioninsouthwesternColombiathatcoversanareaof4.8millionhectares.ThecentralandeasternAndeanmountainrangesoriginatehere,and Andean,Amazonian,andPaci ficecosystemsalsoconverge.Inaddition,the fivemost importantrivertributariesinthecountryhavetheirsourcesinthemassif:theMagdalena,Cauca,Putumayo,Caquetá,andPatíarivers.Thereservationisextraordinarily biodiverse,withmore471speciesofbirds,includingparrotsandtheAndeancondor, thespectacledbear,thetapir,deer,andcougars.Therearealso28lakesinthisterritory,aswellasagreatdiversityoftreespecies.
44 KichwaIndigenousPeopleofSarayakuv.Ecuador,IACTHRSeriesCNo.245(June27,2012)62-63(emphasis added,citationsomitted),https://www.hr-dp.org/files/2013/10/22/Nkichwa_Community_v_Ecuador.pdf.
Chapter25:IndigenousLegalities
B. Wuasikamas:GuardianshipoftheTerritory
BoththeIngalanguageandculturehavetheiroriginsintheIncacivilizationthat expandedthroughtheAndeanmountainsinthecurrentterritoriesofPeru,Bolivia, Chile,Ecuador,Argentina,andColombiabetweenthethirteenthandsixteenthcenturies.The Wuasikamas oralcodeoriginatedinthedepartmentofNariño,inthesouthwestofColombia,andismaintainedinthelanguageoftheIngacommunity.
Basedonthetestamentofthe TaitadeTaitas ( “ FatherofFathers ” )CarlosTamabioy,theIngacommunityofAponteveneratesEarthasmotherandconsiderstherest ofvisibleandinvisiblebeingsaspartofasinglefamily.ThistestamentwasdatedMarch 1700andwasdulynotarizedbeforetheSpanishCrown.Since1750,theIngacommunityhascontinuouslystruggledtodefenditsancestralterritory.
Wuasikamas means “guardianshipoftheterritory.” ThisdoesnotmeanonlyphysicaldefenseoftheterritoryastheEnglishtranslationmayconnote.Itmeansprotection of and careforawayofbeingthatisrootedinaparticularecosystemcomposedof in finiterelationsofpeople,culture,otherlivingbeings,andland.Consistentwiththe understandingthatIndigenouslegalit iescomefromtheCreatorasunderstood throughstoriesoforigin, Wuasikamas beginswiththisstory,whichisinitselflaw.
GenesisoftheTerritorialLawoftheIngaofAponte
BytheIngaPeopleofColombia Compiledby Taita HernandoChindoy
Inthemostpainfulmomentoftheirhistory,theSpanishcrownexpropriatedthe landsoftheIngaofTawaintinsuyu theChinchaisuyuregion.Inanightoflightning,rain,andwind, TaitaIntí [FatherSun]begatCarlosTamabioy,adistinguishedchieftainandspirituallead eroftheInga.Tamabioywasbornin Aguaríco,asacredplaceinthepan-Amazonianterritory,andsevenmothers, beforedyingofhunger,hadtobreastfeedhim.Thechildgrewsofastandstrong thatbynoonhewasalreadyanadult.Bytheafternoon,hehadalreadytoured thewholeterritory.Attheendoftheday,hegatheredalltheIngaandCamenzá peoplesandsaid: “ThisismylandthatIleaveforyou,mychildrenanddescendants,totakecareof,protect,andbene fitfromasyourownuntiltheendoftime. Nothingandnobodyshallinterfere.Yo umustliveinunityandnotforgetthat youareneveralone,fortherivers,forests,mountains,andeverythingthatexists ispartofourfamily.Theywillbeyourprotectors.” Whenhe finished,heleftwith thelastlightofthesun.Sincethen,andformorethan300years,alltheIngaof today ’ sColombiaeachyearcelebratetheritualof AtúnPuncha TheDayof Forgiveness aceremonyattheendoftheyearandthebeginningofanew one.ThisishowtheIngacommemoratethelegacyandmemoryofCarlosTamabioy,the Taita of Taita s[(FatherofFathers)].Inthisceremony,peopleask
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
theEarthandthespiritualbeingsfortheirforgivenessforallthedamagehumans havecaused.Andifthereisenmitybetweenneighbors,the AtúnPuncha isthe momenttoembraceeachother,todance,andtoenjoy chicha [(fermentedbeverage)]andfoodasasignofkinship.TheIngaalsoprayasacknowledgementof beingalive.Ifsomebodyisnolongeraliveforthecelebration,itmeansthattheir souliscalmbecausetheyhavedonetheirbestinlife.
Wuasikamas isfoundintheIngalanguageasoneofthemostimportantsources throughwhichtheancestralknowledgeofthecommunityisrevitalized;thisknowledge holdsthekeystounderstandingtheAndeanandAmazonianworlds,asexpressed orally. Wuasikamas isrecognizedindailylifeastheexistenceofthein fi nitenetwork ofrelationshipsbetweenhumanbeingsandnonhumanbeingsintheirmaterialand spiritualdimensions.Speakingfromaperspectiveof “ bioculturality ” anda “ political ecologyofpeace,” Wuasikamas expressesthevitalenergyoftheconductivethreadsof lifeandspiritualityoftheIngapeople.
Oneofthoseprinciplesof Wuasikamas is SumaKausai,which,rootedinoriginand history,isthefoundationoftherelationshipbetweentheEarthandthehuman.This relationshiprequirespointsornodesofencounterandnon-separationto “guardthe territory”— whattheWestcalls “property.” FortheInga,however,theterritoryis samai orapointofjoyfulrestingforlivingwell.Inotherwords,whiletheWestdefinespropertyasaninertsectionofland,theIngadescribe samai asameetingandrestingplace ofconnectionforthesoulandt hebodywhichexistsbeyondthis fi niteworldtothe in finitepathofhumanandnonhumanexistencebeyondEarth,time,andspace.
Themethodologyforrecognizingandstudying Wuasikamas isthereturntoancestralknowledgefromadecolonizedperspectiveandthroughthepeople’sownIngalanguage.Thisrequiresajourneyofspiritualconnectionthroughsacredplantssuchas ayahuascaandyagé.ThisconnectionallowstheIngatounderstandandengageindialoguewithnonhumanbeingsthroughoutalltime.
The Wuasikamas oralcodeisinconstantdialoguewiththeconstitutionallawofthe Colombianstate,bothofwhichneedtobeunderstoodinordertomaintain Samai or interculturalpeace.Thereareclashesbet weenthesetwokindsoflaw,and,strictly speaking,theydonot complement eachotherbut support eachother. Wuasikamas exists initsownpath.Itisnotonlyofhumancreationbecausethereareothernonhuman forcesinvolved.Thisconceptualizatio nhastraditionallyb eenbeyondWesternnormativeunderstanding.H owever,recentdevelopmentsinhumanrightstheories andEarthrightsmovementsarethemeetingpointforstrengtheningthesenew dialogues.
C.RelationshipwiththeState
Article7oftheColombianConstitutionof1991,asamended,provides: “TheStaterecognizesandprotectstheethnicandcult uraldiversityoftheColombianNation. ” UnderArticles171and176,Indigenouspeo pleformaspecialconstituencyforthe electionofsenatorsandrepresentatives.UnderArticle246,theyexercisejurisdictional functionswithintheirterritoryinaccordancewiththeirownrulesandprocedures, providedthesearenotcontr arytotheconstitutionorlaws.Theyaregovernedby IndigenouscouncilsaccordingtotheirusesandcustomsinaccordancewiththeconstitutionandthelawunderArticle330.Under Articles63and329,theirterritoriesor reservationsarecollectivepropertythatmaynotbesoldandareofanon-disposable, inalienable,imprescriptible,andunattachablenature.UnderArticle13,paragraph2, asgroupsthatarediscriminatedagainstandmarginalized,theydeservegreater protection.
Since1970,theIngaterritoryhasbeenaffectedbyindiscriminatedeforestation andthepresenceofguerrillagroups,drugtraf fickers,andparamilitaries.Since1991 poppycrops(Papaversomniferum)havebeengrownintheterritoryandeventuallycovered2,500hectares.Fromthesecrops,twoorthreetonsofmorphineorheroinwere extractedanddistributedweeklythroughinternationaldrug-traf fi ckingnetworks. Theindiscriminateloggingandsoildepletioncausedbytheseplantationswasfurther aggravatedbytheimplementationofthe PlanColombia abilateralagreement betweenthegovernmentsofColombiaandtheUnitedStatesin1999tocombatthe guerrillasanddrugtraffi ckinginthecountry.Thisplanaimedtoprovidesocialprogramsforfarmerssothattheywouldabandonillicitcrops.However,whileattempting toprotectfarmersasthecountry’sinternalarmedconfl ictintensified,thedeadlyherbicideglyphosatewassprayedontheillici tpoppycrops,whichhadnegativehealth effectsontheIndigenousandpeasantin habitantsofthisarea.Between1986and 2003,morethan150peoplewerekilledandmorethan1,000wereforciblydisplaced fromtheirlands.ThelifeoftheIngapeoplewasbeingdestroyed.
CourageousIngawomen,facingtheprospectoflosingtheirchildren,ledtheInga communityindiscerninghowtheywouldliveasapeople.Duringanintensecommunitydialoguein2003,theIngarediscoveredthetraditional Wuasikamas oralcodein theancestralknowledgeoftheelderlybasedontheprinciplesofnonviolence.Using thisknowledge,thecommunitydevelopeda strategytoeliminateeconomicdependenceondrugproductionandtoconfronttheforcesthatwereharmingthecommunity.Thisledtoanunprecedentedprocessofinstitutionalstrengtheningandcultural identity.
In2003,theIngaofAponteachievedcolle ctiveownershipovertheirterritory throughlegalrecognitionofareservationissuedbytheColombianInstituteforAgrarianReform-INCORA,currentlyknownasthe NationalLandAgency-ANT.Thistitle wascreatedthroughResolution013ofJuly 22,2003,whichgrantedacollectivetitle over22,283hectares,carefullydelineated,andwiththespecialprotectionbythestate. ThereservationislocatedinthemunicipalitiesofElTablóndeGómez,Nariño,and SantaRosa,Cauca,between1,500and3,800metersabovethesealevel.Accordingto Chapter25:IndigenousLegalities
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
the2015census,thepopulationofthereservationis3,651Indigenousinhabitants(951 families)and620non-Indigenousinhabitants(105families).
In2004,theIngaofAponteagreedwiththegovernmentofColombiatodevelop theNationalFamilyRangersProgramdesignedtorespectculturalandcommunityvalues.ApartoftheprograminvolvedpayingIndigenouspeoplesandpeasantstostop growingillicitcrops.TheIngaofAponte,with Wuasikamas,negotiatedtoreceivethe moneythroughacommunalfundcreatedbythemselvesthatwouldallowthemtosupporttheentirecommunityandworktogethertostrengthentheirgovernanceandfree theirterritoryfromthepresenceofguerrillas,paramilitaries,anddrugtraffickers,as wellasthearmyandthepolice.Thepaymentswerereceivedfrom2004to2006and wereusedtocreatethepillarsforthesocial,economic,cultural,spiritual,andenvironmentaladvancementoftheIngacommunity.In2007,theIngastoppedreceiving moneyfromthegovernmentandbegantostrengthensustainablelivelihoods,while beinggovernedbythe Wuasikamas oralcodeaspartoftheIntegralMandateofLife fortheSurvivaloftheIngaPeopleinAponte.
D.IntentionsandResultsof Wuasikamas
Thesearetheintentionsof Wuasikamas:
• Thrivingascommunityinthein fi nityoftimeandspace,whilefollowingthe relationalcodebetweenhumanandnonhumanbeings.Also,byremembering theoriginofthiscodeinthesacredan dancestralterritoryofthecentraleasternmountainrangeoftheAndes.Inthisterritory,theIngapeoplethrive tokeeptheirownrulesandprocedures thathaveallowedthemtosurviveas anautonomouscommunity,withtheirownterritory,customs,andlanguage, aswellasthespiritualandreligioussystemswithintheframeworkofprinciples thatdiscouragetheft,lies,andlaziness,andaffirmlivingwithdignity,inastate ofwell-being,andincommunitywithMotherEarth.
• ContributingtotheunityoftheIngapeople,whichisrootedinselfgovernment,autonomy,legalstandin g,cosmology,andthinkingthatstems fromancestralknowledge.
• Decolonizingthinkingundertheprinciplesofdignity,respect,andbiocultural peace.
• Rememberingisthethoughtandlivingmemoryof Taita of Taitas CarlosTamabioy,aswellasotherguardiananc estorsthatarepresentinthewind, fi re, water,earth,light,darkness,andpeace.
Inthemidstofthislonghistoryofviolence,andonthevergeofphysicalandculturalextermination,theIngaofAponte ’ sre-encounterwith Wuasikamas andits emphasisonknowledgeofthewaysoflivingwell(buenvivir),hasbeenthemeansto achievepeaceanddevelopment.Itisrootedinprinciplesthatdiscouragetheft,lying, andlaziness,andaf firmlivingadignifiedlife.
Followingthewayof Wuasikamas,theIngapeoplearerecoveringtheirautonomy, sovereigntyandspirituality,andtherightsofMotherEarth.TheIngahavebeenin minga (daysofcollectivere fl ection)torevitalizeanddecolonizetheirgovernancesystems.TheyadoptedtheIntegralMandateofLifefortheSurvivalandPermanenceof theIngaPeopleofAponte,whichisthecharterfortheIngaofAponte.Drawingonthe political-administrativemechanismsofthe MajorCabildo andthe MinorCabildos (similar toministries)ofhealth,education,communication,economy,publicandcommunity services,justice,womenandfamily,childrenandyouth,andIngaguardians,theInga haveestablishedgoverningstructures.TheIngaHighCouncilofJusticeinvestigates andcuresallkindsofwhattheIngacharacterizeas “ diseases”— fromthetheftofa chickentohomicides,thecrea tionofarmedgroups,drugtraf fi cking,andharmof MotherEarth.FortheInga,thereisnoconceptionof “crime.” Humanbeingscommit whatarecalled “crimes” becausediseaseshavepenetratedtheirbodiesandtakenover. Treatmentwithmedicinalplants,advice,andisolationarewaysofdealingwiththese diseases.Intheseways,theIngahavebroughtintobeingandmaintainedasystemof socialcohesionthathasalsoallowedthemtofacegroupsofguerrillas,paramilitaries, drugtraffickers,stateagencies,andpublicforces,amongotheractorsthatthreatened theircommunity.
TheIngahavetakentosharingthe Wuasikamas processwithotherpeoplesofthe regioninordertostrengthentheircommunitiesandlocalgovernance.TheIngahave createdanAllianceofIndigenousWomenofNariñoandaCourtofIndigenousPeoplesandAuthoritiesoftheColombianSouthwest,withtheparticipationofsevenancestralpeoplespresentintheregionsofCaquetá,Cauca,Putumayo,andNariño(the Awá,Cofán,EperaraSiapidaara,Inga,NasaUh,QuillasingaandSionapeoples).In theregionalandglobalcontext, Wuasikamas isanorganizationthatstrivestolayits foundationsintheformofculturalembassiesincapitalcities.Theaimistosharethe historyanddignityoftheIngapeople,mutualunderstanding,andthelifeprocesses thatarealsokeptinheartsbeyondthehuman.45
The Wuasikamas oralcodeisacontributiontothedialoguearoundjusticeand publicpoliciesonEarthandnonhumanrights.The Wuasikamas oralcodeadvances bioculturalpeace,thatis,theharmoniousco-existenceachievedandmaintained betweenhumanbeingsandallvisiblebeings,fromaboveandbelow,andfromall placesintimeandspace.
With Wuasikamas,theIngapeopleofApontehavefostereddialoguesand,sometimes,havereceiveddiscouragingcriticis msintendedtobreaktheirancestralspirit. However,thecommunityhasbecomestronger,andtheirlegalcasesinmatterssuch ashealth,education,legalstanding,andgovernmenthavebeenamodelforother Indigenousgroups,peopleofAfricandescent,andthepeasantsofColombia.Globally, Wuasikamas isrecognizedbytheUnitedNations DevelopmentProgramasaglobal exampleofresilienceandsocial,economic,andenvironmentalprogress.TheInga peoplewereamong21localandIndigenousinitiativesrecognizedbythe2015Equator Prize.
45 SeeWuasikamas,http://www.wuasikamas.org/about-us. Chapter25:IndigenousLegalities
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
STUDYQUESTIONS
(1)Thoughtheindustrialrevolutionbeganinthemiddleoftheeighteenthcentury, theWestwasstillcomposedoflargelyagrariansocietiesuntilthetwentiethcentury.Inasense,Westernagrariansocieties,notjustIndigenoussocieties,were colonizedbyindustrialcivilizationatthistime.PeopletendtothinkofIndigenoussocietiesasexceptionstoWesterndevelopment,onesthatneedprotection butnotonestoserveasguidinglightsforfuturecivilizationaltransitions.
Considerthatcolonizingindustrialsocietiesarenotsustainableandthe waysofagrariansocietieshavebeensu stainableandareinneedofrecovery. UsingtheIngaofAponteandtherecoveryoftheircommunitythrough Wuasikamas asaguidinglight,considerthesequestions:
a.WhatancestralwisdomandknowledgemightthemodernWestdrawonfor livingwellwithEarth?
b.Wheredidthisancestralwisdomcomefrom,whatisitsstoryoforigin?
c.WhatdotheIngateachusaboutthemeaningofpropertyandguardianship oftheterritory?
d.WhatdotheIngatellusaboutthenewcommonsandcollectiverightsand responsibilitiesforterritory?
e.Howwouldtheprincipleofnon-separation,orbeingembeddedinaninfinity ofrelationschangeWesternlaw?
f.WhatdotheIngatellusabouttheroleoflocalcommunitiesinrelationto statesforpurposesofEarthlaw?Whatarethesimilaritiesanddifferences betweentheIngapursuitoflocalcommunityrightsandself-governancefor thesakeofsustainabilityandCELDF’sapproachtocommunityrights(asdiscussedinChapter9, “TheRightsofNatureMovementintheUnitedStates”)?
g.Whatcanbringacommonmindandethos,a Wuasikamas,tolocalcommunitiesincomplexurban/globalizedsocieties?
h.Howcanpeopleincomplexurban/globalizedsocietieslearnfromnatureso astocreatelawsinharmonywithnonhumanbeings?
VI.CONCLUSION
Earthsystemsareundergoingfundamentalchangeswithincreasingsocioeconomic pressureonanddemandforresourcesandecosystemservices.MostdominantWesternenvironmentallawandgovernancesystemsfailtopreventandremediateecologicaldegradation.Environmentallawisprimarilyconcernedwithpollution managementandcontrolwithoutconsidering ecologicalinterdependencies;ittakes thehumanasitsexclusivesubjectandnatureasitsobject,privileging,forthemost part,neo-liberalconceptualpracticeswithinthesphereofgovernance.Thisontology ofseparation avisionoftherealthatseparateshumansandtherestoflife
Chapter25:IndigenousLegalities
reinforcesthemythofhumanexceptionalism,namelytheideathathumansoperate aboveoroutsideEarth’secologicalsystems.
Indigenouslegalitiesenvisionlawandgovernancesystemsappropriateforthe emergentconditionsofatimeperiodwithmutuallyenhancinghuman-Earthrelationships.Broadlyspeaking,theyproposeafu ndamentaltransformationasaresultof whichsocialandlegalinstitutionswouldforegroundhuman-Earthinteractions.
Drawingonandfurthercontributingtothe fieldofEarthlaw,Indigenouslegalities incorporatethenormativetraditionsandrelationalgovernanceprinciplesofIndigenousworldsaspartandparcelofanewlegalvisionfortimesoftransition.Suchan approachalignswithThomasBerry’snotionofthe “greatlaw” basedontheideathat theuniverseisacommunionofsubjects,notacollectionofobjects.46
Inaddition,andinconversationwithscholarsworkingwithlocalcommunitiesin theAndeanAmazonianregion,Indigenouslegalitiesarebasedontheprincipleof interdependenceandmutualco-emergen ceofallbeings.Thisprincipleorients “ a visionoftheworldthatechoestheautopoieticdynamicsandcreativityoftheEarth andtheindubitablefactthatnolivingbeingexistsindependentlyoftheEarth. ” 47 Whenitcomestothelaw,theprincipleofinterdependenceisattherootofboth IndigenouslegalitiesandEarthlaw.
Moreover,asextensivelydescribedinAmerindiancosmologies,animalstudies, andplantscience,amongother fi eldsofknowledge,nonhumanbeingsarecapable ofdifferentformsofrepresentationandcommunication.Morethanobjectsofcognitionandcontrol,nonhumanbeingsareagentsofknowledgeandevenlegalsubjects today.Indigenouslegalitiesacrossthe Americasoffercompellingelementsforan expanded,multiple,andlife-thrivinglegalparadigmbeyondtheindividualandthe state.Thus,Indigenouslegalitiescontrib utetotheemergentEarthlawconceptthat capacitatesother-than-humanselvesassubjectsofrightsbutalsoaslegalagentsintheir ownright.
FromtheAndeanfoothillstotheAmazonianlowlands,theInga’ sancestraland highlystrategicterritoriesreachacrosstheSoutherndepartmentsofNariño,Cauca, Caquetá,andPutumayoinColombia.Theenvironmental,cultural,andlegalagendas oftheIngaintheAndes-Amazonjoinlong-standingeffortsofIndigenousresurgence movementsacrossLatinAmerica,andbeyond.Moreover,theworkoftheIngais inspiredbyseveralinterconnectednormativeprincipleswhicharepartofthe Wuasikamas oralcode:(1)todefendlifeaccordingtoIndigenouslegalandgovernancesystems;(2)tocarefortheterritoryasthe basisofenvironmentalgovernanceand decision-makingmodels;(3)tofosterepistemicautonomy asopposedtoepistemic dependence inharmonywithlocalecologiesandsociopoliticalrealities;and(4)to engageininterculturaldialoguewithWesternscienceandgovernancesystems,among otherprinciples.
46 THOMAS BERRY,THE GREAT WORK:OUR WAYINTO THE FUTURE (1999).
47 ArturoEscobar, SentipensarconlaTierra:LasLuchasTerritorialesylaDimensiónOntológicadelasEpistemologías delSur,11(1)REVISTADE ANTROPOLOGIA IBEROAMERICANA 11,14(2016).
SectionV:AGlobalSurveyofEarthLaw
Inthischapter,wehavestudied,amongotherthings,howstatelawincorporates Indigenouslegalities,andhowlegalpract itionersmayengagewiththeirprinciples andmethodologies.TheincreasedrecognitionofIndigenouslegalitiesishelpingto bringintobeingtheemergingparadigmofEarthlaw,thusbecominganimportant toolfortheprotectionofIndigenouspeopl esandtheirterritories.Thewisdomof Indigenouslegalitiesisbecomingpartofthelegalsystemoutsidethoseterritories transformingstatelaw.
AFTERWORD1
BEYONDANTHROPOCENTRICLAW
Thehumanandothermembersofthecommunitywecall “Earth” shareanevolutionaryhistorythatscientiststellusgoesback13.8billionyearstotheBigBang.This incrediblybeautifulandcomplexcommunityofinterrelatedbeingsisheldtogether andmaintainedbyacomplexnetworkof interrelationshipsthroughwhich fl ow energy,nutrients,andmoremysteriousforc es,suchascreativityandlove.Yet,most contemporarylegalsystemsarealmostcompletelyblindtothisreality.InsteadofseeingwhatThomasBerryreferredtoasa “communionofsubjects,” eachwithacontributiontomaketothewell-beingofthewhole,theselegalsystemsseeonlydiscrete objects,mostofwhichareclassi fiedaspropertysusceptibleofownershipbylegalpersonsandavailableforconsumptionandcommodificationwithinthelimitsprescribed byenvironmentallaws.2
Forcenturiesmanysocietiesaroundtheworldhaveregulatedthemselvesonthe assumptionthathumans(oratleast “civilized” humans)areseparatefromandsuperiortothecommunityoflifeandareentitledtoexploitEarthforpersonalgain.Today, asthedireconsequencesofdegradingthebiospherebecomeincreasinglyapparent, moreandmorepeoplearerealizingthathumansandmanyotherspecieshaveno futureunlessweself-regulatetoensurethatwecontributetothehealthandintegrity ofthecommunityoflife,the “ Earthcommunity, ” insteadofexploitingit.Consequently,theemergenceofEarthlawispartofawidershiftwithinglobalsociety a shiftfromanunhealthyanthropocentrismtowardavisionofhumansasgiftedmembersofacommunityoflifewhobearaspecialresponsibilityforhealingtheharmthat theyhavecaused.Forlawyers,thisshiftinperspectiveopensupexcitingnewvistasas wecontemplatewhatlegalsystemsthatgovernpeopleforEarthmightlooklike.
1 ThisafterwordwasauthoredbyCormacCullinan,thedirectoroftheWildLawInstitute,andCullinan& AssociatesInc.,inCapeTown,SouthAfrica,andauthorofWILD LAW:AMANIFESTO FOR EARTH JUSTICE (2ded., 2011).
2 ThomasBerry ’sobservationthat “theuniverseisnotacollectionofobjectsbutacommunionofsubjects” appearsinmanyofhisessaysandworksandbooks.Forexample: “[T]hattheuniverseisacommunionofsubjectsratherthanacollectionofobjectsisthecentralcommitmentoftheEcozoic.Existenceitselfisderived fromandsustainedbythisintimacyofeachbeingwitheveryotherbeingoftheuniverse. ” B RIAN SWIMME & THOMAS BERRY,THE UNIVERSE STORY 243(1992).
685
Afterword
DOEARTHLAWSHAVEAFUTURE?
ThedevelopingbodyofEarthlawisbasedontherecognitionthathumanlegalsystems arisewithinapreexistingnaturalsyste moforderandshouldaimtoguidehuman beingstoseekfulfillmentandwell-beingbycontributingtothewell-beingoftheEarth communityratherthanbyseveringandweakeningthebondsthatsustainit.However, thelegalsystemsofmostcountriesarebasedonaworldviewthatisfundamentallyat oddswiththerealitythathumanbeingsexistaspartofacommunityoflifethatis essentialfortheirwell-being.
Forexample,intheUnitedStates,manylon g-heldlegalprinciples,established bothbylegislationandcommonlawprecedent,denythatmembersoftheEarthcommunity(otherthanhumanbeings)havelegalpersonality,legalrights,orstandingto litigate.
ThismeansthathumanswhowouldnurtureEarthlawfaceverysigni fi canthurdles.First,mostlegislationandhundredsofyearsoflegalprecedentdenythevalidity oftheirfundamentalpropositions,suchasthatthelawshouldrecognizeother-thanhuman-beingsaslegalpersonswithrights.
Second,thelegalestablishment,whichincludeslegalacademics,practitioners,and judges,havebeentrainedtobelievethattheideaofnaturehavinglegallyenforceable rightsisabsurdandevendangerous.
Third,thelegalsystemprivilegestheinterestsofincorporeal,artifi ciallegalentities,suchascorporations,overcorporeal,naturalentitiesthathaveco-evolvedwith humanitywithintheEarthco mmunity.Throughthelaw,th esecorporationsrestrict thelegalliabilityofthehumanswhomakethedecisionsforthem.Theinterests attributedtotheseabstract, fictionalbeings,imaginedbypeopletoservetheirideologicalbeliefs,takeprecedenceovertheinterestsofrealbeingswhoplayaroleinsustaininglife.Corporationsandtheirshareholdershavevestedinterestsinmaintainingthe statusquo,andsignifi cant fi nancialresourcesandpoliticalin fl uenceavailabletodo so.Thesamecanbesaidaboutnationsandtheirpoliticalsubdivisionswhich,through incorporeal,arti ficialconstructs,arevestedwithlegalpersonhoodandlegalpower.
Thisraisesseveralcrucialquestions:Isthereisalong-termfutureforEarthlaw withinalegalsystemthatishostiletotheveryworldviewEarthlawreflects?CanEarth lawtakerootand flourishinlegalsystemsthatdefineallaspectsofnature,otherthan humanbeings,aslegalobjects property withoutagency?CanEarthlawco-exist withthelegal fi ctionthatabstractcreationslikecorporationsarelegalpersons endowedwithscarcelyfetteredrightstot akepossessionofandlaywastetootherthan-human-beingsandecologicalcommunities?
Iftheanswertoeachofthesequestionsis “ no, ” thenabsentsocialupheavalthat sweepsasidethelegalsystemandreplacesitwithonethatreflectsEarthjurisprudence, Earthlawsisdoomedtowitherandperish.However,assetoutbelow,thereisgood reasontobelievethatEarthlawwill fl ourishandgeneratenewlegalsystems.
LAWSOFNATURETRUMPHUMANLAWS
Despitetheseformidableobstacles,proponentsofEarthlawhaveevenmorepowerful championsintheircorner MotherEarthandthelawsofnature.BythisImeanthat nomatterhowhumanlegalsystemsareconstructedandfunction,theycannotprotect humanbeingsagainsttheoperationofthelawsofnature.Wearealreadybeginningto suffertheconsequencesofactingwithrecklessdisregardtotheinterestsofthewhole Earthcommunity.Asthenegativeimpactsmountandmorepeoplebecomeawareof theroleofthelegalsysteminlegitimizingactivitiesthataredeeplyanti-socialfrom theperspectiveoftheEarthcommunity,thepressureforfundamentalchangewill build.SomemayadvocatedoublingdownonthemanipulationofEarthsystems,for examplebyundertaking “geoengineering.” Otherswillrecognizethattheonlyviable wayforwardistoreorienthumanlawssothattheyencouragehumanitytorelateina responsibleandrespectfulmannertonatureandtorestoreecologicalcommunities tohealth.
Thelawsorprinciplesthatgovernhowtheuniversefunctions, “theGreatJurisprudence,” arenon-negotiableandself-enforcing.Theymakeitinevitablethatifhumanity increasestheconcentrationofgreenhousegassesintheatmospherebeyondacertain point,therelativelystableclimaticconditionsthathaveprevailedthroughoutthe CenozoicerawillbedisruptedThegloba lclimatewillthenbecomechaotic(aswe arealreadyexperiencing)untilEarth ’shomeostaticcapacityre-establishesadynamic equilibrium whichmaybeattemperaturesdif ficultforhumanstotolerate.Thefact thatmostofthehumanactivitiesthatarecausingthisdisruptionarecurrentlylawful meansthatthoseresponsiblefortheseactivitiesareimmunefromlegalconsequences. ButthisdoesnotgrantthemimmunityfromtheGreatJurisprudence,whichwillyield ajudgmentwiththepotentiallyfatalconsequencesofdisruptingEarth’slifesystems.
Asmorepeoplerealizethatcurrentlegalsystemsaremaladaptiveinthattheyhinderratherthanaidourabilitytoadapt(inanevolutionarysense)torapidlychanging environmentalcondition,theywillbemorewillingtoacceptfundamentalchanges.
CRISESASCATALYSTSOFLEGALTRANSFORMATION
Manyoftheconsequencesoffailingtoregulatehumansocietiestoensurethatharmfulthresholdsarenotexceededarereadilyforeseeable;scientistshavewarnedofthe dangersofdoingsoformanyyears.Otherconsequences,particularlythosethatarise fromtheinteractionofseveraldifferentphenomena,arelesspredictable.Forexample,increasedemissionsofgreenhousegasses,thewide-spreaddestructionofforests, thelossoffertilesoils,andtheuseofinorganicfertilizersthatdecreasecarbonsequestrationinagriculturallandareinterrelatedphenomenawithcumulativeimpacts whichmayresultinirreversible,negativ elong-termchanges.Itisnowclearthat humanshavedestabilizedtheconditionswithinwhichtheimmense fl ourishingof life-formsduringtheCenozoiceraoccurred.Wemustnowcopewithmanydifferent Afterword
kindsof “naturaldisasters” thatareoccurringwithincreasingfrequencyandseverity, allofwhichhavethepotentialtocausecum ulativeeffectsofterrifyingmagnitude. Thesenaturaldisasterswillverypossiblybecomeamajordriverofrapid,non-linear changesinlegalsystemsandaproliferationofEarthlaw.
Forexample,asofJune15,2020,thetimeofthewritingofthisAfterword,the novelcoronavirusSARS-CoV-2(commonl yreferredtoasCOVID-19)isspreading rapidlythroughtheworld,drasticallyin terferingwithsupplychainsandmodesof transportationthathavemadehumancivilizationa “ globalvillage. ” Itisunknown whetherhumanitywill findmeanstocontainthespreadofthevirusandtocurethose affectedbeforemillionsorbillionsmoreareinfected.Thediseasehashadaprofound impactonglobalsocietyduetocancelationofevents,restrictionsontravel,quarantines,andtheworsteconomicrecessionsincetheGreatDepressionofthe1930s.3
Scientistsestimatethat75percentofneworemerginginfectiousdiseasesinpeopleare “zoonotic,” meaningthatthe firstpatientcontractedthediseasedirectlyfrom anotherspeciesofanimal.4 InthecaseofCOVID-19,itseemslikelythatthevirusdevelopedinbatpopulationsandwastransmittedtohumansviabodypartsofpangolinsor snakesthatwereboughtatamarketinWuhan,China.5
ThewetmarketsinChina(andothercountries)exemplifythebrutallyexploitative relationshipbetweenthevendorsandco nsumersofwildlifeproductsandthose species.However,thesaleandconsumpti onoftheseproductswerelegaluntilthe healthdangersposedbyCOVID-19anditsnegativeimpactsonglobalhumansociety becameapparentandtheChinesegovernm enthassoughttobanthesemarkets.In manycountriesitislegaltosellpartso fwildanimalsforhumanconsumption,and thereisalsoathrivinginternationaltradeinexoticpets.However,aspeopleandgovernmentsaroundtheworldbecomeawar eofhowmuchmoreimportantthehealth oftheglobalcommunityisthantherightofaminoritytotradeandconsumewildlife products,itislikelythatthecountriesinwhichwetmarketscontinuetooperatewill outlawthesevectorsforthetransmissionofzoonoticdiseases.
Increasingnaturaldisastersandrelate demergenciesmaytriggerchangesatall levelsofsociety.Asdiscussedinthiscoursebook,inAugust2014,atoxicalgaebloom inLakeErierenderedthelakewaterunsafetodrinkforthreedaysandcatalyzeda campaignthatresultedinthecityofToledoincorporatingtheLakeErieBillofRights
3 SzuPingChan, Coronavirus:WorldFacesWorstRecessionSinceGreatDepression Apr.14,2020),https://www.bbc. com/news/business-52273988.
4 Azoonoticviraldiseaseoccurswhenthevirusintheanimalhostdevelopsaseriesofgeneticmutationsthat allowittoinfectandmultiplyinsidehumans;thisisaidedbysomeformofcontactorinteractionbetweenthe infectedanimalandhumans,enablingthetransmissionofthevirus. See CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention, ZoonoticDiseases,https://www.cdc.gov/onehealth/basics/zoonotic-diseases.html(lastvisitedMar.3, 2020).
5 InChina,so-called “wetmarkets” sell fleshfromawiderangeofwildanimalsforhumanconsumptionand bringhumanbeingsintoclosecontactwithavarietyofliveanddeadanimals. See NsikanAkpan, NewCoronavirusCanSpreadbetweenHumans ButItStartedinaWildlifeMarket, NATIONAL GEOGRAPHIC (Jan.21,2020).
Afterword 688
(LEBOR)intothecitycharter.ThepreambletoLEBORmakesexplicitreferenceto thefactthatexistinglawshavefailedtoprotectthelake6 andthatanemergencysituationnowexiststhatmeritsthetakingofextraordinarymeasures.7 Thedecisionbythe U.S.DistrictCourtfortheNorthernofOhiothatLEBORwasinvalidexempli fiesthe dif ficultylawyerswillfaceinadvancingEarthlaw.8
Itisverylikelythatfuturedisasterswillcreateasimilarimpetusforrapidlegislative changethatseekstoensurethathumansrelatetoEarthinwaysthataremorerespectfulofothermembersoftheEarthcommunity andprioritizescollectivewell-being. Despitethedeterminationofsomepowerfulworldforcestodenytherealitythatwe arenowintheearlystagesofaclimaticallychaoticperiod, “natural” disasterssuchas cyclones, floods,droughts,andwild fires, 9 astheimpactsmount,morepeoplearelikely tosupportemergencymeasuresthatwouldnothavebeencontemplatedinless extremecircumstances.
JUDICIALINNOVATION
MostEarthlawadvocatesaroundtheworldhavetendedtofocusoneducatingpeople aboutthebene fitsandwisdomofrecognizingtherightsofnatureandonpromoting legislativereformasameansofimplementingEarthlaw.However,duringthelast fewyears,manyofthemostsigni fi cantadvanceshavecomefromanunexpected
6 “WethepeopleoftheCityofToledo findthatlawsostensiblyenactedtoprotectus,andtofosterourhealth, prosperity,andfundamentalrightsdoneither;andthattheveryair,land,andwater onwhichourlivesand happinessdepend arethreatened.”
7 ThepreambletotheLEBORstatesthat: “WethepeopleoftheCityofToledo furtherdeclarethatthis ecosystem,whichhassufferedformorethanacenturyundercontinuousassaultandruinduetoindustrialization,isinimminentdangerofirreversibledevastationduetocontinuedabusebypeopleandcorporations enabledbyrecklessgovernmentpolicies,permittingandlicensingofactivitiesthatunremittinglycreatecumulativeharm,andlackofprotectiveintervention.Continuedabuseconsistingofdirectdumpingofindustrial wastes,runoffofnoxioussubstancesfromlarge-scaleagriculturalpractices,includingfactoryhogandchicken farms,combinedwiththeeffectsofglobalclimatechange,constituteanimmediateemergency.Wethepeople oftheCityofToledo findthatthisemergencyrequiresshiftingpublicgovernancefrompoliciesthaturgevoluntaryaction,orthatmerelyregulatetheamountofharmallowedbylawoveragivenperiodoftime,toadoptinglawswhichprohibitactivitiesthatviolatefundamentalrightswhich,todate,havegoneunprotectedby governmentandsufferedtheindifferenceofstate-charteredfor-profitcorporations.”
8 DrewesFarmsPartnershipv.CityofToledo,No.3:19CV434U.S.Dist.(N.D.Ill.Feb.27,2020).AlthoughthisrepresentsasetbackforEarthlawpractitioners,itisinstructivethatthejudgeseemedtoimplythatsuchameasurecouldhavebeenupheldifitsapplicationhadbeenlimitedtothecity’ sareaofjurisdictionandifthe rightshadbeenarticulatedmorepreciselysothatpartiesliketheplaintiffcoulddeterminewhatconduct wouldinfringetherightsinquestion.
9 In2019thereweremajorwild firesinAustralia,California,theAmazon,Siberia,Indonesia,andLebanon. Forarankingoftheseverityof firesintheUSA see InsuranceInstituteInformation, Facts+statistic:Wildfires, (March8,2020,4,49PM),https://www.iii.org/fact-statistic/facts-statistics-wild fires.Foranoverviewofwildfiresgloballyin2019, see2019WastheYeartheWorldBurned ,HUFFINGTONPOST(Mar.8,2020,4:43PM), https://www.huffpost.com/entry/wild fi res-california-amazon-indones ia-climate-change_n_5dcd3f4ee 4b0d43931d01baf. Afterword
Afterword
quarter thejudiciary.Judgesinmanycountri es,includingColombia,Bangladesh, andIndia,haveusedtheirjudicialpowerstorecognizerivers,glaciers,andforestsas juridicalpersonsthatpossessrightsandtoimposecorrespondingduties(particularly onpublicbodies)totakeactiontoupholdthoserights. 10 Thesejudgmentshave occurredinbothcivilandcommonlawlegalsystems.Whilethelegaljusti ficationshave varied,intheseandmanyothercases,thejudgesseemtohavebeenmotivatedbya senseoffrustrationthatthelegalsystemhasbeenineffectualinprotectingspeci fi c aspectsofnaturefromdegradationandbyadeterminationto fi ndamoreeffective meansofdoingso.
Asmoreprecedentsfromrespectedcourts,suchastheColombianConstitutional Court,11 accumulate,itwillbeeasierforotherjudgestofollowsuit.Judicialinnovation ofthiskindisparticularlyvaluablebecauseitcanproducechangesfarquickerthanis generallypossiblethroughlegislativeaction.
AWILDIDEA
Inhisseminal1972article ShouldTreeshaveStanding? ,ProfessorChristopherStone referredtotheimportanceofbreakingthroughtheintellectualframingthatdefined allofnatureasobjectsincapableofhavinglegalrightsby “thinkingtheunthinkable.”12 Thegrowthofrightsofnaturemovementgloballyandthemannerinwhichtheideas thatinformEarthlawhavetakenrootindiverseplacesindicatethattheseideashavea lifeoftheirown.Whatwasonceunthinkablehasbeenthought,andoncethought,it cannotbeunthought.Theseideasarenowbeingrapidlytransmittedfromonemind toanother,proliferating,mutating,andtr ansforminglegalsystems.Theideashave goneviral.
THECHALLENGEOFINNOVATION
“Necessityisthemotherofinvention ” isawell-knownmaxim.Certainlyadversitycan spurhumanstoinnovateandachievethin gsthattheywouldnototherwiseattempt. Surelynowisthetimeforgreatinnovationsinlawandgovernance necessity demandsit!
Wecanpredictwithahighlevelofcon fidencethatcrisesanddisasterswillproliferate,butwecannotknowpreciselywhentheywilloccurandwhentheirimpactwill
10 See,e.g., CorteConstitutional,DecisionT-622(Nov.10,2016)(Colombia),inwhichtheColombianConstitutionalCourtrecognizedtheAtratoRiverasalegalperson; Mohd.Salimv.StateofUttarakhand&Others (Mar. 20,2017)UttarakhandHighCourt(India)PIL126/2014,inwhichanIndiancourtrecognizedtheGanges andYamunaRiversandtheirtributariesashavinglegalpersonality.
11 Seesupra note10; seegenerally Chapter25, “IndigenousLegalities.”
12 ChristopherStone, ShouldTreesHaveStanding?TowardsLegalRightsforNaturalObjects,45S.CAL.L.Rev. 450-501(1972).
690
Afterword
besuf fi cienttotippublicopinionandpublicbodiesinfavorofenactingEarthlaws. Consequently,itisnowparticularlyim portantforEarthlawyerstoconductthe researchanddevelopmentnecessarytoenablethemtoproposespecificandpractical legislationandothermeasureswhenthatmomentoccurs.Whereenablinglegislation isunavailable,Earthlawyersneedtobebrave,bold,andcreativeaslitigatorsandin renderingadvicetotheirclients.Sincewearefacingunprecedentedenvironmental conditionsandhaveverylittleEarthlawwithinmoderncontemporarysocieties,innovationandahighdegreeofcreativityareessential.
CONCLUSION
Itwillnotbepossibletoestablishecologic allyviablehumansocietieswithoutfundamentallychanginglegalsystemssothattheyprohibitin fl ictingsigni fi cantharmon thecommunitywecallEarthandprioritizecontributingtothewell-beingofthatcommunity.Wecannotknowwhetherwewillbeabletotransformourlegalsystemssufficiently,thoroughly,andswiftlytoavertchangesinecosystemfunctioningthatwould becatastrophicforourspeciesandothers.However,thegrowingbodyofEarthlaw, someofwhichemergedunexpectedlyandrapidly,holdsthepromiseoffurtherrapid, non-linearchangestolegalsystems.ThetaskofeveryEarthlawyeristoimaginethe legalsystemsthatcommunitiesandsocietieswillneedtobeviableintheforeseeable futureandtoinnovateandcollaboratewithoneanothertobringthemintobeingas theprevailinglegalsystemsloselegitimacyasaconsequenceoftheirinabilityto addressthemostpressingchallengesofthe21stcenturyeffectively.13
13 TheEarthLawCenter,whichbroughtthisbookintobeing,aswellastheGlobalAlliancefortheRightsof NatureandtheEcologicalLawandGovernanceAssociationareleadersamongtheincreasingnumberof organizationsandforathatprovideameanstolinkupwithotherstopromoteEarthlaw.
TABLEOFCASES
Principalcasesareindicatedbyitalics.
ACHPRv.RepublicofKenya,648 Aguirre-Torres;UnitedStatesv.,364 AlbánCornejov.Ecuador,288
Aldred’sCase,12
Allenv.Wright,126
Amadiov.Levin,309 AmericanElec.PowerCo.v.Connecticut,125 Andrusv.Allard,110
AnimalWelfareBd.ofIndiav.A.Nagaraja, 298
AppleInc.v.SamsungElecs.Co.,143 ArizonaStateDep’tofPub.Welfarev.Barlow, 132–133
AtratoRiverBasinCase. See CenterforSoc. JusticeStudiesv.PresidencyoftheRepublic AucklandRoyalNewZealandSoc’yfor PreventionofCrueltytoAnimalsv. MacPherson,599
Aver;Statev.,370
Bailey;UnitedStatesv.,364,366
Bakerv.Carr,124,125
Barlowv.Collins,138–139
Barona;UnitedStatesv.,308 BelleMaerHarborv.CharterTwp.of Harrison,244
Bennettv.Spear,34–35,150
Berrianv.Duncan,312
BiodigestersCase,481–482 Boomerv.AtlanticCementCo.,95, 101, 104–105
Boumedienev.Bush,329 Brevorkaexrel.Wittlev.Schuse,329 BrookValleyCmty.GroupInc.v.Trustees oftheBrookWaimaramaSanctuaryTrust, 596
Brownv.CityofPhoenix,120 Brown,Peopleexrel.v.Johnston,326 Burwellv.HobbyLobbyStores,Inc.,303
Byrnv.NewYorkCityHealth&Hosps.Corp., 302,315,316,319–320
Calawayv.PracticeMgmt.Servs.,Inc.,309 CalvertCliffsCoordinatingComm.v.UnitedStates AtomicEnergyComm’ n, 16,20 Capriv.Jenkins,242 Caseof. Seenameofcase Casimelv.I.C.B.C.,665 CastroCórdoba&DavidOchoav.Ministryof Env’t,498, 523 CaucaRiverBasinCase. See CastroCórdoba& DavidOchoav.MinistryofEnv’t Causby;UnitedStatesv.,103,107 Cecilia,Inre,306,321 CenterforSoc.JusticeStudiesv.Presidencyofthe Republic,169,179,498, 501,511,522,531, 533
CentreforMinorityRightsDev.(Kenya)ex rel.EndoroisWelfareCouncilv.Kenya,647 CertainInterestedUnderwritersatLloyd’ sv. Bear,LLC,215 CetaceanCmty.v.Bush,251,308 Chambersv.Mississippi,370 Chapman,UnitedStatesexrel.v.F.P.C.,156 Chem-DyneCorp.;UnitedStatesv.,38 ChevronCorp.v.Donziger,268 ChevronU.S.A.Inc.v.NaturalRes.Def. Council,Inc.,22,27 ChinchillaSandovalv.Guatemala,287,288 CitizensComm.forHudsonValleyv.Volpe, 136
CitizenstoEndAnimalSuffering& Exploitation,Inc.v.NewEngland Aquarium,308 CitizensUnitedv.FederalElectionComm’ n, 303 CleanAirCouncilv.UnitedStates,219 Coatesv.CityofCincinnati,244
TableofCases
Cole;Statev.,371,373 ColombianAmazonCase. See VargasMorales v.MinistryofEnv’t ColoradoRiverEcosystemv.Stateof Colorado,251,252 Corsov.CrawfordDog&CatHosp.,317 Countyof. Seenameofcounty CowpastureRiverPreservationAss’nv.U.S. ForestServ.,142 Craigv.Boren,126 Curtinv.Benson,111
Darden;Statev.,370 DartmouthColl.v.Woodward,131 DataProcessingServ.v.Camp,138–139 Daubertv.MerrellDowPharms.,Inc.,228 Dawson,Peopleexrel.v.Smith,312,326,330 DeChristopher;UnitedStatesv., 363,367–368 DeLia,Peopleexrel.v.Munsey,314,315 DetroitTimber&LumberCo.;UnitedStates v.,22 Diana;Statev.,370 Douglas,Peopleexrel.v.Vincent,312 DredScottv.Sandford,54,128–130 DrewesFarmsP’shipv.CityofToledo,243, 244–245,248,298,689 DukePowerCo.v.CarolinaEnvtl.Study Group,Inc.,155
Eckart,Matterof,320 EcologicalRightsFound.v.PacificLumber, 226
EndoroisCase. See CentreforMinorityRights Dev.(Kenya)exrel.EndoroisWelfare Councilv.Kenya Enrightv.EliLilly&Co.,320 EnvironmentalDef.Soc’y,Inc.v.Mangonui Cnty.Council,601 EnvironmentalDef.Soc’y,Inc.v.NewZealand KingSalmonCo.,595 Ericksonv.Dilgard,297
Fegerv.WarwickAnimalShelter,317 Fernerv.Ohio,244 Figueroav.Walsh,314 Finnv.Anderson,299 FirstNat’lBankofBos.v.Bellotti,131,146
Flastv.Cohen,138 ForestGuardiansv.Wells,95, 115 422CasksofWine;UnitedStatesv.,127
FriendsoftheEarth,Inc.v.GastonCopper RecyclingCorp.,226 FriendsoftheEarth,Inc.v.LaidlawEnvtl. Servs.,151,158,226 FutureGenerationsv.MinistryofEnv’t, 513
GalápagosIslandsCase,482 Gallegos;Statev.,370,371,372 Garcia;Peoplev.,317 Gault,Inre,132,308 Georgiav.TennesseeCopperCo.,21,154 Gibsonv.UnitedStates,106 GladstoneRealtorsv.VillageofBellwood,125, 226
Glendening,Peopleexrel.v.Glendening,324 Gongqosev.MinisterofAgric.,Forestry& Fisheries,649 GonzalesLluyv.Ecuador,285 Gonzalez,Peopleexrel.v.WayneCnty. Sheriff,312 Gordon;Peoplev.,331 Grahamv.StateofNewYork,308 Graves;Peoplev.,313 Gray;Peoplev.,359, 360,363,368 GroceryMfrs.Ass’nv.EPA,126
Hall,Peopleexrel.v.Rock,312 Hanousekv.UnitedStates,25 Harkavyv.Consilvio. See NewYorkexrel. Harkavyv.Consilvio Harrisv.Nelson,295 HavasuHeightsRanch&Dev.Corp.v.Desert ValleyWoodProds.,Inc.,120 Hawai’i,Countyofv.CivilServ.Comm’n,256 Hawke’sBayReg’lInv.Co.v.RoyalForest& BirdProtectionSoc’yofNewZealandInc., 592 Hercules&Leov.Stanley. See Nonhuman RightsProject,Inc.exrel.Hercules&Leo v.Stanley Hoffv.StateofN.Y.,314 Hynesv.Tomei,320
IBAMA,Inre,541, 542,543,547 IllinoisCentralR.R.Co.v.Illinois,53, 186, 189–190 IndependentLivingCtr.ofS.Cal.,Inc.v. Shewry,126 Inre. Seenameofparty I.V.v.Bolivia,285
Jarmanv.Patterson,302
Jeffriesv.Hassell,119
Johnsonv.M’Intosh,232
JuanAntonio,AnnaRosario&JoseAlfonsoOposa v.HonorableFulgencioS.Factoran,Jr., 219
Julianav.UnitedStates,89,90,123,124,143, 156,159,181,183,206,207,211,213–214, 219,226,229,230,623,632–636
Justv.MarionetteCnty.,215,217
JuvenileRe-educationInst.v.Paraguay, 288
Kabat;UnitedStatesv.,365,366 KaiserAetnav.UnitedStates,107
Kaliña&LokonoPeoplesv.Suriname,279, 282,288
Kansasv.Colorado,567
Kaplan,Peopleexrel.v.Commissionerof Corr.ofCityofN.Y.,312
KauaiSprings,Inc.v.PlanningComm’nof Cnty.ofKauai,199
KawasFernándezv.Honduras,282 Keitt,Peopleexrel.v.McMann,308,314
Kentv.UnitedStates,133
Keta;Peoplev.,320
KichwaIndigenousPeopleofSarayakuv. Ecuador,287,288,674,676
Kikov.Presti. See NonhumanRightsProject, Inc.exrel.Kikov.Presti
Kivalinav.ExxonMobilCorp.,125
K.M.Chinnappa,T.N.Godavarman Thirumalpadv.UnionofIndia,565
LairdvTatum,125
Larner,Matterof,315
LaveryI. See NonhumanRightsProject,Inc.ex rel.Tommyv.Lavery,124A.D.3d148,998 N.Y.S.2d248(N.Y.2014)
LaveryII. See NonhumanRightsProject,Inc. exrel.Tommyv.Lavery,152A.D.3d73,54 N.Y.S.3d392(N.Y.2017)
Lawrencev.Texas,321
Lawrence,Peopleexrel.v.Brady,324 LegalTenderCases,106 Lewisv.BurgerKing,308,326
LhakaHonhatAss’nv.Argentina,278 LoayzaTamayov.Peru,287
Lobenthal,Peopleexrel.v.Koehler,314 Lorettov.TeleprompterManhattanCATV Corp.,107,110
LowerWaitakiRiverMgmt.Soc’yIncv. CanterburyReg’lCouncil&Meridian EnergyLtd.,596 Lucasv.SouthCarolinaCoastalCouncil,95,105, 106,112–113 Lujanv.DefendersofWildlife,125,147,148, 154,155,157,225,227,229
Mabov.Queensland,641 MangrovesCase,483,491 ManuelCepedaVargasv.Colombia,287 Marburyv.Madison,123,159,229,633,636 MarkleInterests,LLCv.UnitedStatesFish& WildlifeServ.,31,33–34 Marksv.Whitney,194–195,217 Martinv.Hunter’sLessee,124 Massachusettsv.EnvironmentalProtection Agency,152,153,157,226,228–229 Match-E-Be-Nash-She-WishBandof PottawatomiIndiansv.Patchak,126 Matterof. Seenameofcaseorparty May;UnitedStatesv.,365 Mayagna(Sumo)AwasTingniCmty.v. Nicaragua,276,277 MayaIndigenousCmty.oftheToledoDist.v. Belize,673,674 McCallister,Peopleexrel.v.McGinnis,312 McGrawv.Wack,320 McGuirevHastingsDist.Council,595 McLeod;Peoplev.,295 MentalHygieneLegalServs.v.Wack,320 Mett;UnitedStatesv.,308,325 Michiganv.EnvironmentalProtectionAgency,21, 22 Mickel,Inre,302 Miglaniv.StateofUttarakhand,566, 567,569 MineralKingv.Morton,140 Minnesotav.MilleLacsBandofChippewa Indians,254 MinorsOposav.SecretaryofDep’tofEnv’t& NaturalRes. See JuanAntonio,Anna Rosario&JoseAlfonsoOposav.Honorable FulgencioS.Factoran,Jr. MiradorMineCase,485–486,491 Mohamedv.Argentina,287 Mongelliv.Cabral,317 MonoLakeCase. See NationalAudubonSoc’ y v.SuperiorCourtofAlpineCnty. MoortiShreeBeharijiv.PremDass,563 MormonChurchv.UnitedStates,567 TableofCases
TableofCases
MotorVehicleMfrs.Ass’nofU.S,Inc.v.State FarmMut.Auto.Ins.Co.,22
Munsingwear;UnitedStatesv.,125
NarayanDuttBhattv.UnionofIndia, 177, 570, 574
NationalAudubonSoc’yv.SuperiorCourtofAlpine Cnty., 191,198 Negrin;Statev.,371
Netherlandsv.UrgendaFound.,54,470, 623–629,631–636
Newtonv.MahoningCnty.Comm’rs,213
NewYorkv.ShoreRealty,37
NewYorkexrel.Harkavyv.Consilvio,315
NonhumanRightsProject,Inc.v.R.W. Commerford&Sons,Inc.,304
NonhumanRightsProject,Inc.exrel.Hercules& Leov.Stanley,313, 313,321–322,323,327, 331
NonhumanRightsProject,Inc.exrel.Kikov.Presti, 301, 311,312–313,320,322,323,326,330
NonhumanRightsProject,Inc.exrel.Tommyv. Lavery(LaveryI),124A.D.3d148,998 N.Y.S.2d248(N.Y.2014), 307,310–312, 315,318–320,321,322
NonhumanRightsProject,Inc.exrel.Tommyv. Lavery(LaveryII),152A.D.3d73,54N.Y.S.3d 392(N.Y.2017), reviewdenied,31N.Y.3d 1054,100N.E.3d846(N.Y.Ct.App.2018), 301,303, 323,327–328, 328,329,330,332 NorthernInd.Pub.Serv.Co.v.W.J.&M.S. Vesey,103
Obergefellv.Hodges,55,316,321
Oetjenv.CentralLeatherCo.,125 OfficeofCommc’nofUnitedChurchof Christv.FCC,137,156 Oklahomaexrel.Johnsonv.Cook,567 1.58AcresofLandSituatedinCityofBos., SuffolkCnty.,CommonwealthofMass.; UnitedStatesv.,212 Oregonv.Fessenden,317 OrtizHernándezv.Venezuela,287
Palazzolov.RhodeIsland,114 Parker;Statev.,372,373 Parksv.Cooper,212 Patton;UnitedStatesv.,364,365 PembinaConsol.SilverMining&MillingCo. v.Pennsylvania,309
PennsylvaniaCoalCo.v.Mahon,105,106, 107,109–110 PennsylvaniaEnvtl.Def.Found.v. CommonwealthofPa.,218 PennsylvaniaGen.EnergyCo.v.GrantTwp., 166,167,238,239,240,242 Peoplev. Seenameofopposingparty Peopleexrel. Seenameofrelatedparty PeoplefortheEthicalTreatmentofAnimals, Inc.v.SeaWorldParks&Entm’t,Inc. See Tilikumexrel.PeoplefortheEthical TreatmentofAnimals,Inc.v.SeaWorld Parks&Entm’t,Inc. PPLMont.,LLCv.Montana,190
Rapanosv.UnitedStates, 24,25,27,202 Rasulv.Bush,319 Raymondv.Lachmann,317 Reiss,Roth,Shachaf,Adam,Shefer,Gazella Gazellav.NationalPlanning&Bldg. Comm.,581 RelianceNaturalRes.,Ltd.v.RelianceIndus., Ltd.,214
RichtersveldCmty.v.AlexkorLTD&the Gov’toftheRepublicofS.Africa,649 RíoNegroMassacresv.Guatemala,287 Rivera;Peoplev.,319 Riversv.Katz,314 RobinsonTwp.,WashingtonCnty.v. Commonwealth,214,217 Roev.Wade,133,135,203 Rosav.Senkowski,314
Sablev.Hitchcock,302
Salimv.StateofUttarakhand,83,173, 174,560, 561,565–566,569,571,690 Sandstromv.Montana,364 SantaClaraCnty.v.SouthernPac.R.R.Co., 131,146,303,326,327 SaramakaPeoplev.Suriname,282 SawhoyamaxaIndigenousCmty.v.Paraguay, 282
Schoon;UnitedStatesv.,365 Scott;Peoplev.,320 Scottv.Sandford,55 Seals,Peopleexrel.v.NewYorkStateDep’tof Corr.Servs.,307 SenecaRes.Corp.v.HighlandTwp.,242 ServiceOrgs.,Inc.v.Camp,150 Seward;UnitedStatesv.,364–367
Shack;Statev.,112
Shainv.Veneman,225,227
Shannon,Peopleexrel.v.Khahaifa,312
ShiromaniGurudwaraPrabandhakComm., Amritsarv.ShriSomNathDass,561
SierraClubv.Morton,56,63,123,138,139, 147,160,252
SisquocRanchCo.v.Roth,308,325 Smithv.ConAgraFoods,Inc.,309
Smithv.Hoff,302 Smythv.Ames,132
Snapp&Son,Inc.v.PuertoRicoexrel.Barez, 567
Somersetv.Stewart,295,302,305 SpringfieldArmory,Inc.v.CityofColumbus, 244
StandingBear,UnitedStatesexrel.v.Crook, 302
Statev. Seenameofopposingparty Sternv.Marshall,158
StreetChildrenv.Guatemala. See Villagrán Moralesv.Guatemala
Strycker’sBayNeighborhoodCouncilv. Karlen,205 Summersv.EarthIslandInst.,224
SummitRoadSoc’yv.Ministerof Conservation,591 SuperintendentofBelchertownStateSch.v. Saikewicz,297
Tahoe-SierraPreservationCouncil,Inc.v. TahoeReg’lPlanningAgency,114 Tatra,Peopleexrel.v.McNeill,307 TennesseeValleyAuth.v.Hill, 29,35 TierraDignav.PresidencyofColombia. See CenterforSoc.JusticeStudiesv.Presidency oftheRepublic Tilikumexrel.PeoplefortheEthical TreatmentofAnimals,Inc.v.SeaWorld Parks&Entm’t,Inc.,308 Tobinv.Grossman,320 Tommyv.Lavery(LaveryI). See Nonhuman RightsProject,Inc.exrel.Tommyv.Lavery, 124A.D.3d148,998N.Y.S.2d248(N.Y.2014) Tommyv.Lavery(LaveryII). See Nonhuman RightsProject,Inc.exrel.Tommyv.Lavery, 152A.D.3d73,54N.Y.S.3d392(N.Y.2017) TransportationCo.v.Chicago,106 TranswasteCanterburyLtd.v.Canterbury Reg’lCouncil,596
Travisv.Murray,317 Trongettv.Byers,302 TrusteesofDartmouthColl.v.Woodward,128 Turner;UnitedStatesv.,365,366 Tweed,Peopleexrel.v.Liscomb,314,320
UnitedStates,Inre,219 UnitedStatesv. Seenameofopposingparty UnitedStatesexrel. Seenameofrelatedparty UrgendaFound.v.Netherlands,628,631,632 Uttarakhandv.Salim,173, 175
ValleyForgeChristianColl.v.Americans UnitedforSeparationofChurch&State, Inc.,225,226 VargasMoralesv.MinistryofEnv’t,498, 526, 532–533 VermontYankeeNuclearPowerCorp.v. NRDC,16 VillagránMoralesv.Guatemala,287
Wartellev.Women’s&Children’sHosp.,Inc., 302,309 Warthv.Seldin,126 Washingtonv.A.M.R.,309 Washingtonv.Ward,357, 369 WasteMgmt.ofWis.,Inc.v.Fokakis,308,325 WaterUsePermitApplications,Inre,214,217 Webb’sFabulousPharmacies,Inc.v. Beckwith,111 Wehle,Peopleexrel.v.Weissenbach,329 WestCoastEnvtl.NetworkInc.v.WestCoast Reg’lCouncil&BullerDist.Council,595 WesternSur.Co.v.ADCOCredit,Inc.,309 WestVirginiav.Zain,309 WeyerhaeuserCo.v.U.S.Fish&WildlifeServ., 31, 35 Whitmanv.AmericanTruckingAss’ns,Inc.,23 Wittlev.Schuse. See Brevorkaexrel.Wittlev. Schuse Woodv.Waugh,186 Woodard,Peopleexrel.v.Berry,324
XolobeniCase,650
YakyeAxaIndigenousCmty.v.Paraguay,282 Yanomamiv.Brazil,276 YickWov.Hopkins,130 YogendraNathNaskarv.Commissionof Income-Tax,Calcutta,561
AarhusConvention(1998),411
INDEX
Aboriginallegalities. See Indigenouslegalities; Indigenousrightsofnature
Abortion,133–135,311
Accesstoinformation,434. Seealso Informed consent
ACHPR(AfricanCommissiononHumanand Peoples’ Rights),639,642,645–649
ACtHPR(AfricanCourtonHumanand Peoples’ Rights),642,646,647–649
AdministrativeProcedureAct(APA,1946), 135–139,150
AdvocateforNaturalResourcesand Development(ANARDE),651 Aerosolloading,asplanetaryboundary, 5n6,70
Aestheticsandrecreation animal-humancoexistenceand,393 ascommons,59 publictrustdoctrine,53 standingtoprotect,152
Africa,637–654. Seealsospecificcountries
AfricanCharter,639,642–643,644, 648,653
AfricanCommissiononHumanand Peoples’ Rights,639,642,645–649
AfricanCourtonHumanandPeoples’ Rights,642,646,647–649
AfricanModelLawfortheRecognition andProtectionofSacredNaturalSites andTerritories,646–647
AfricanUnion,638–639,642 bioculturalrights,643
ColombianAmazoninitiativesand, 639,643 colonialism,637,638–639,641–642
custodiancommunities’ statementandcall toaction,644–645
customarylaw,637,639–643,647–649, 652–653 decolonization,638,639,641–642, 644,646
EarthJurisprudencemovement,639, 643–653
Earthlawimplementation,470,637–654 economicdevelopment,637 governancesystems,637–644,647–649
Indigenouslegalities,470,637–654 legalsystem,637–647,650–653
localdevelopments,652–653 nationalcaselaw,649–650 nationallegislation,650–652
overviewofEarthlawin,470,637–639,653 regionaldevelopments,644–649 rightsofnature,638–639,643–653 sacredplacesandreligiouspractices, 638–641,643,644–649,651–653
socioculturalnormsandheritage, 637–641,643,648,653
WorldCharterforNaturestance,407
AfricanAmericans citizenshiprights,55 enslaved. See Slavery personhood,141 standing,130
AfricanBiodiversityNetwork,646 AfricanCharter,639,642–643,644,648, 653
AfricanCommissiononHumanandPeoples’ Rights(ACHPR),639,642,645–649
AfricanCourtonHumanandPeoples’ Rights (ACtHPR),642,646,647–649
AfricanInstituteforCultureandEcology (AFRICE),651–652
AfricanUnion,638–639,642
AFRICE(AfricanInstituteforCultureand Ecology),651–652 Agency. Seealso Autonomy human,68 lawyers,450 nature,68,87n63 nonhuman,297,396–397
Agenda21:ProgrammeofActionfor SustainableDevelopment,411,437
Agenda2030forSustainableDevelopment, 423–425 AgentOrange,59,333,336
Agriculture
deforestationfor,334,335,512n54, 539–540
Ecuadoriancaselaw,481–482 environmentallawon,13 humanrightsandrightsofnature co-violations,270,271–272,278–279,292 Indigenouslegalities’ conflicts,679 industrialoragribusiness,13,271–272, 481–482 societaldevelopmentwith,45 sustainablefarmingpractices,634 waterpollutionfromrunoff,24,243
Airpollution. Seealso CleanAirAct aerosolloading,5n6,70 atmospherictrustlitigation,54,59,89–90, 156,181,623,634–635 climatenecessitydefense,359–363 criteriaairpollutants,21 environmentallaw,1,12–13,14,21–23, 152–155,204 IndustrialRevolution,12–13 standingtochallenge,152–155,156–159
AirPollutionControlAct(1955),14,21n8 AirQualityAct(1967),21n8
Albuquerque,Bento,540
Algalblooms,13,243,688–689
AllianceofMotherNature’sGuardians, 546
AlvarezAngli,Arturo,553 Amazon biodiversity,334,494 Colombianjurisprudence,298,469,498, 511–522,530,532,639,643 ascommons,85 deforestation,59,183,290–291,333–336, 345–346,350,353–354,486–487, 511–522,530,532,539–540 ecocide,59,183,291,333–336,345–346, 350,353–354 ecosystemservices,334 humanrightsandrightsofnaturecoviolationsin,268,272,273,290–291 oxygenfrom,334 rightsoffuturegenerations,57,512 rightsofnature,298,469,486–487,498, 511–522,530,532
AmericanBarAssociationModelRulesof ProfessionalConduct,236 AmericanConventiononHumanRights,279, 280–288
AmericanDeclarationoftheRightsand DutiesofMan,286nn56–58
AmparoRodriguez,Gloria,664 ANARDE(AdvocateforNaturalResources andDevelopment),651 Áñez,Jeanine,459 Animal-humancoexistence,377–402 alternative,lessharmfuloptionsfor, 394–395 Americanblackbearbiologyandlifecyle, 383–385,393–394 animal’sperspective,378,383–391 anthropomorphizinganimals,386,391 bear,studyofspecific,378,379–383,392. Seealso Mink’sstory subentry beardignity,395–397 bears’ socialandemotionallives,386–388, 389,393,395–397 biocentricapproachto,375,377 cognitiveethologyon,383,386–388 conservationapproachvs.,377,392 contextualapproach,392 dutiesofaffirmativeassistancetobears, 399–401 economicdevelopmentand,398 empathyin,388–389,391,402 ethicsandmoralityin,377,378,383, 388–389,391–401 euthanasia,380,382,383,394–395 habitatencroachment,377,379,380,384, 391,397–402 humansocio-culturalnorms,378, 390–391 huntingand,381,384,390,398 illustrativequestionson,392 individualsorwholepopulation considerations,378,392,395–397,402 landuseplanning,400–401 localgovernmentrole,380,394–395, 400–401
Mink’sstory,378,379–383,385,389, 392–393,394–397,399,400,402 nuisancelabeling,379,380,393,395,399 overview,375,377–378,401–402 rehabilitationandreleaseprograms,382, 386,399
relativeinterests,harms,andbenefits, 393–394 relocationprograms,380–382,385,389, 394–395,396,399 trackingdevices,381,382,397
wildbearsandhumans,generally,379
Animalnexustheory,148–149
Animalrights. See Animal-humancoexistence; Nonhumanrights
Anthropoceneepoch anthropocentrism,generally,78–79 defined,67n5 Earthlawbeyondlawof,685 Earthlawconceptualframeworkin contextof,65–71,75–77,78–79 ecocidein,353 ecologicalperiodand,69,70 formalrecognitionofterm,4,66–67 goodnaturein,75–76
Holocenetransitionto,9,66 identifyingfeatures,67 sciencein,76–77 socialcontract,439,440–441 sustainabledevelopmentand,71,403,406, 410–411,428
Anthropomorphizinganimals,386,391
APA(AdministrativeProcedureAct,1946), 135–139,150
APIB(AssociationofIndigenousPeoplesof Brazil),540
Aquinas,Thomas,453,454
Argentina humanrightsandrightsofnature co-violations,278–279,289
LhakaHonhatCommunities,278–279 nonhumanrights,58,298 rightsofnature,535n2
WorldCharterforNaturestance, 407n16
Aristotle,45
Armenia,ecocidecodes,342,351
ArmyCorpsofEngineers,U.S.,24,136–137
Artificialintelligence,72,87,88n64,311 AssociationofIndigenousPeoplesofBrazil (APIB),540 Atmospherictrustlitigation intheNetherlands,623,634–635 publictrustdoctrine,54,59,89–90,156, 181,634–635 standingin,156
AtratoRiver,169–172,469,497,498,499–511, 529–530
Australia Aboriginallegalities,51,641,662–663 corporatecriminalliability,348–349 customarylaw,641 firesin,465 settlercolonialism,70n16
Automobiles. See Motorvehicles Autonomy. Seealso Agency habeascorpusprotecting,305 Indigenous,681 nonhuman,296–299,305,310,322, 396–397
Autopoiesis,theoryof,87n62,683 ÁvilaSantamaría,Ramiro,475
Bacon,Francis,12,45,50 BaldenegroLópez,Isidro,60 Bangladesh,personhoodofnature,689
BanKi-Moon,432
Banksand financialinstitutions Amazondeforestationresponse, 350 ecocideliability,335 humanrightsandrightsofnature campaignstargeting,289 BankTrack,289
BaselConventionontheControlof TransboundaryMovementsof HazardousWasteandTheir Disposal,61n71
Beaches. Seealso Coastalwaters BeachfrontManagementAct(South Carolina),105,112 CoastalZoneManagementAct(South Carolina),105 oilspills,349 propertylaw,105–115
Bears bears-humancoexistence,375,377–402. Seealso Animal-humancoexistence Colombianjurisprudence,498
Bedoya,Hernán,269
Belarus,ecocidecodes,342,351 Belgium climatechangeresponses,634 colonizationby,641
Belize,Indigenouslegalities’ propertyrights, 673–674
BemidjiStatementonSeventhGeneration Guardianship,204,213
Benin,EarthJurisprudencemovement,644, 646,651
Berat,Lynn,339
Berros,MaríaValeria,553
Berry,Thomas animal-humancoexistencereflecting, 392,397 oncommunionofsubjects,62,81, 683,685
Earthlawconceptualframeworkbasedon, 62,80–81,82–83 onecocide,333 ecologicalsocialcontractasGreatWork of,452n42 oneconomicsystem,3n3 onfutureenvironmentallaw,39 Indigenousgovernancerecognition, 638,683 onrightsofnature,80–81,82–83,259,392
BillofRights,U.S.,232. Seealsospeci fic Amendments
Biocentricapproach toanimal-humancoexistence,375,377 toEarthlaw,78–79 inMexico,555–557 tonon-humanrights,543 toSustainableDevelopment Initiatives,403
Bioculturalrights,169–170,501,511,643
Biodiversity inAmazon,334,494 inBrazil,536 inColombia,493–494,499,676 ascommons,85
Earthlawpreservingandrestoring,65,89 environmentallawprotecting,28n19 extinctionandlossof,71,378 Indigenouslegalities,59,676 internationallaw,61n71,279–280,406, 411,463 loss,asplanetaryboundary,5n6,70 inMexico,547 offsetstomitigatelosses,595 publictrustdoctrineprotecting,199 rightsofnatureprotectionsof,482–483
Biomechatronics,72
Blackmun,Harry,138
BlackPlague,11–12
Bolivia constitutionallaw,90,217 criticalappraisaloflaws,461–462 ecocentricgovernance,376,455–464 FrameworkLawofMotherEarthand IntegralDevelopmentforLivingWell, 458–459,460–461,470,535 HarmonywithNatureInitiativestance, 416–417 Indigenouslegalities,376,455–464,474n3 LawoftheEnvironment,462 lessonsforEarthlawyersfrom,462–464 mining,455,459,461–462 modelrightsofnaturelaws,460,463 MotherEarthRightsLaw,456–458, 460–464,470,535 rightsoffuturegenerations,217 rightsofnature,61,90,95,376,417–418, 455–464,470,474n3,535 standing,95
UniversalDeclarationfortheRightsof MotherEarth,61,417–418,456 Bolsonaro,Jair,335,345,539–541
Borrows,John,658,659,661,663,666 BoulderRightsofNature,235,260 Boundlessresources,mythologyof,47,74 Boyd,DavidR.,56,57,571,633 BP(BritishPetroleum),345,349–350,352n76
Brague,Rémi,71–72 Brain-computerinterfaces,72 Brazil,535–546. Seealso Rio entries biodiversity,536 Bolsonaroadministration,335,345, 539–541 constitutionallaw,536–539,558 DeclarationoftheAllianceofGuardians andChildrenofMotherEarth,546 deforestation,85,183,290–291,334–336, 345–346,350,353–354 Earthlawimplementation,469, 535–546,558 ecocentristjurisprudence,469,541–543 ecocide,183,334–336,345–346,350, 353–354 ecologicallybalancedenvironment, 537–538 environmentalconstitutionalism,430,469 humanrightsandrightsofnaturecoviolations,269,271,272,275–276, 290–291,540–541
Indigenouslegalities,536–537,538–541, 545–546,558
LetterforNature,545–546
localrightsofnatureinitiatives,543–545 nonhumanrights,541–543 overviewofEarthlawin,469,535–536 rightsoffuturegenerations,537 rightsofnature,269,271,272,275–276, 290–291,469,535–546,558
WorldCharterforNaturestance,407 YanomamiCommunity,275–276
BritishPetroleum(BP),345,349–350,352n76
Broswimmer,Franz,339
Brown,Lester,91 BrownWeiss,Edith,216,227
Brundtland,GroHarlem,410
BrundtlandReport(1987),375,404,409–410 Burger,Warren,137,156
CAA. See CleanAirAct,U.S. Cáceres,Berta,60,263,289,292
Cameroon,EarthJurisprudence movement,644
Campaña,FarithSimon,474–475
Camp-Horinek,Casey,254
Canada climatechangeresponses,634 ecocide,353 Indigenouslegalities,658,659–660,665 legalsystem,658 migratorybirdtreatieswithU.S., 28n20 oilandnaturalgas,353 settlercolonialism,70n16
CarabiasIcaza,Alejandro,553
Carbondioxide(CO2) Amazonabsorption,334 atmospherictrustlitigation,54,59,89,156 concentrations,47 Netherlands’ reduction,633–634 rightsoffuturegenerations,206 taxes,633 trajectoryofemissions,49,183
Carbonmonoxide,21n11
Carbonsinks,47,85
Carson,Rachel, SilentSpring,11,13,15,555 Carter,Amy,359
Cataldi,Susan,396
CaucaRiverBasin,498,522–525
Causation
climatenecessitydefense,358,359, 367–368 rightsoffuturegenerations,224–225, 227–228 standingrequirements,125,139,148–149, 154–156,224–225,227–228
CELDF(CommunityEnvironmentalLegal DefenseFund),84,235,237,619 CenterforEarthJurisprudence,235 CenterforEnvironmentalEthicsand Law,235
CERCLA. See ComprehensiveEnvironmental Response,Compensation,and LiabilityAct CharterofFundamentalRightsofthe EuropeanUnion,623 Chemicalpollution ecocide,59,333,336 IndustrialRevolution,12–13 internationallawsandactions,61n71,209 mining-related,499–500 oilspillsand,349 asplanetaryboundary,5n6,70 Childrenandminors birthdefectsamong,268 climatechangeeffects,266 Colombianjurisprudenceondeathsof, 499 guardianshiparrangements,173–174 personhood,141,303,311,529 rightsoffuturegenerations. See Rightsof futuregenerations standing,132–133 Chile,InternationalRightsofNature Tribunalin,273 China classicalcivilizationdevelopment,45 environmentalconstitutionalism,430 RomeStatutenotapplicable,341 wildlifeexploitation,688 ChineseAmericans,legalrights,55,130–131 CITES(ConventiononInternationalTrade inEndangeredSpeciesofWildFauna andFlora,1973),28n20,61n71,406 Cities. See Municipalities;Urbanpopulation Citizenship relationship-based,663 rights-basedmovementsfor,55 standingrequirements,128,130–131 Citizen-suitprovisions,147–159,560
CivicCouncilofPopularandIndigenous OrganizationsofHonduras (COPINH),289 Civildisobediencedefense. See Climate necessitydefense CleanAirAct,U.S.(1963),21n8 CleanAirAct,U.S.(CAA,1970),21–23 airqualitystandards,21 amendments,21n9 citizen-suitprovisions,152–153 cost-benefitanalysis,21–23 enactment,1,21,204 implementationandadministration,21, 152–155 publictrustdoctrineexpansionwith,191 purposes,21n10 CleanWaterAct,U.S.(CWA,1972),23–28 amendments,23n14 citizen-suitprovisions,151–152 corporateecocideliability,350 ecocide,350 enactment,23,204 implementationandadministration,24 oilspills,350 publictrustdoctrineexpansionwith, 191 purposes,23–24 shortcomings,24–28 siloproblem,27–28 waterqualitytargetsandstandards,24 Climatechange atmospherictrustlitigation,54,59,89–90, 156,181,623,634–635 consequencesof,357 constitutionalprovisions,206–207,214, 628–629 defenseforcivildisobedience. See Climate necessitydefense Earthlawformitigatingandadaptingto, 65,89 environmentallawineffectiveness,40 globalwarmingstatisticsandprojections, 49,71,228 humanrightsandrightsofnature co-violations,266,291 internationallawsandactions,61n71,266, 357–358,406,411,463,628–629 judicialrulings,470–471,512,532–533, 623,626–636 litigationchallenges,125,532–533 naturallaw,687
Netherlands’ response,470–471,623, 626–636 asplanetaryboundary,5n6,70 publictrustdoctrine,54,59,89,357, 634–635
rightsoffuturegenerations,57,206–207, 209,226,228–229,512 rightsofnatureand,357,512 scienceof,49,533 separationofpowersand,125,532,533, 630–633,635–636 socialcontractforresponseto,91 standingtocontest,125,156–159,206, 226,229,632
Climatenecessitydefense,357–374 causaloreffectivenessstandard,358,359, 367–368 elementsof,358–359 expertwitnessesfor,368,373 imminentharmstandard,358,359, 367,374 legalalternativesstandard,358,359,363, 367,368 lesserharmstandard,358,359 aslitigationstrategy,183,357–374 motioninliminetobar,363,367,368 NewYorkcasestudy,359–363 overview,183,357–359,374 Utahcasestudy,363–368 Washingtoncasestudy,368–374
CO2. See Carbondioxide Coastalwaters. Seealso Beaches;Oceans climatechangeeffects,226 CWAprotection,24 NewZealandrightsofnature,593 oilspills,349 publictrustdoctrine,54 Co-centricapproach,deepsustainabilityas, 428,437
CocoraRiver,498,526–527
CoelloRiver,498,526–527
Cognitiveethology,383,386–388 Cole,G.D.H.,443 Colombia,493–534 Africaninitiativesand,639,643 Amazonprotections,298,469,498, 511–522,530,532,639,643 AmericanConventiononHumanRights petition,280–288 AtratoRiver,169–172,469,497,498, 499–511,529–530
bioculturalrights,169–170,501,511 biodiversity,493–494,499,676
CaucaRiverBasin,498,522–525 climatechange,512,532–533,634
Coello,Combeima,andCocoraRivers, 498,526–527
CombeimaRiver,498,526–527 communalrights,84,496 constitutionallaw,169–170,494–496,530, 534,667–673,679 culturalidentityrights,667–669,672 deforestation,511–522,530,532 Earthlawimplementation,469, 493–534
ecologicalconstitutionalism,495–496 environmentof,493–494
guardianshiparrangements,96,162–163, 169–172,496,529,676–682 humanrightsandrightsofnature co-violations,269,272,280–288, 499–501,511,526–530,531–532 humanrightsprovisions,495,496 Indigenouslegalities,169,171,495, 499–501,511,639,643,656–657, 660–662,664,667–673,676–683
Indigenoustraditionalknowledgeand laws,668–671,676–682 informedconsentrequirements,668, 671–672 jurisprudence,469,494,496–534,667–673, 689–690 legalsystem,494,534,656,660 nonhumanrights,298 overviewofEarthlawin,469,493,528–530
PanceRiverBasin,498
PáramodePisba,498,527–528 personhoodofnature,96,162–163,298, 493,528–529,689–690
PlataRiver,498
rightsoffuturegenerations,57,512,532 rightsofnature,162–163,169–172,269, 272,280–288,298,469,493–534,660, 661–662,664 scienceresources,533 separationofpowers,532,533 socioeconomicrightsjurisprudence, 496–497
TayronaPark,497
Wuasikamas (lawofIngaofAponte), 676–682,683
Colonialism
African,637,638–639,641–642
Bolivian,455 decolonization,638,639,641–642,644, 646
DoctrineofDiscovery,232 Enlightenmentperiod,69–70 Indigenouseffects,232,470,638, 657–659 rightsofnaturenotprotected,232 settler,70 Colorado,rightsofnatureprovisions,249 ColoradoRiverEcosystem,251–254 Commonlaw autonomy,296–297 defined,294–295 Earthlawas,1 environmentallawdevelopedfrom,9, 21,37
habeascorpus,writof,293–299,301,302, 304,305–332 necessitydoctrine,112,183,357–374 nonhumanrights,58,182,293–299,301, 303–332 personhood,301,303–304,305–332 propertyrights,185,186 publictrustdoctrine,634–635. Seealso Publictrustdoctrine rightsoffuturegenerations,219 rightsofnature,145 strictliability,37 Commons inEarthlawconceptualframework,10, 85–86 ecocentricgovernanceforcommongood, 443–444,448,453–455 generalwill,443–444,453–455 lawseparationfrom,50,51 propertyrightsand,51,85 tragedyofthecommons,85n59 transformingthelawfor,7 Communalrights Africanrecognitionof,648,650 Colombian,84,496 communaltenureofland,673–674 inEarthlawconceptualframework,84 lawseparationfrom,49–51 publictrustdoctrine,52,53–54, 185–199 Communityecology,258
CommunityEnvironmentalLegalDefense Fund(CELDF),84,235,237,619
Communitylawyering,234–235
ComprehensiveEnvironmentalResponse, Compensation,andLiabilityAct (CERCLA,1980),36–38 enactment,36 implementationandadministration,37–38 liabilityconcepts,36–37,38 overview,37–38 purposes,37 shortcomings,38
ConferenceonEnvironmentand Development(RioConference,1992), 208,406,410–411,429
ConferenceonSustainableDevelopment (Rio+20Conference,2012),418, 420–423
ConferenceontheHumanEnvironment (Stockholm,1972),13,405–406,431
Confucius,45
Conservation animal-humancoexistencevs.,377,392 conservationistapproachtonature,74–75 Israeliwaterlaws,579
NewZealandrightsofnature,592,596 WorldConservationStrategy,216 Constitutionallaw. SeealsospecificAmendments
Brazilian,536–539,558 climatechange,206–207,214,628–629
Colombian,169–170,494–496,530,534, 667–673,679 corporaterights,237,243 Earthlawas,1 ecologicalconstitutionalism,448,495–496 economicprovisions,232,495,496,552
Ecuadorian,81–82,90,162,163–164,469, 473,475–480,487–489,660 environmentalconstitutionalism,430,469, 479–480 guardianshiparrangements,164,496 humanrights,549 Indian,559–560,564–565,573–574 Indigenouslegalities,495,538–539,547, 550,679 judicialinterpretation,129,480–489,541, 564–565,667–673 judicialpowerunder,207–208,230. Seealso Separationofpowers
Mexican,547–550,552–555
nonhumanrights,573–574 propertyrights,95,97,105,128–129,232 publictrustdoctrineand,54,89,156,190, 198–199,213–214 rightsoffuturegenerations,206–207,212, 213–214,217–224,537 rightsofnature,81–82,90,162,163–164, 169–170,236,248–251,456,460,469, 473,475–480,487–489,530,534, 536–539,547–548,552–555,558, 564–565,660 rights-basedmovementsaltering,55 slaveryabolishment,128,304 standing,124–126,130–135,156–159, 224–230 sustainabledevelopment,552 U.S.stateconstitutions,212,217–218, 248–251 U.S.staterightsunder,211 ConventionforthePreventionofMarine PollutionbyDumpingofWastesand OtherMatter(LondonConvention, 1972),406 ConventiononBiologicalDiversity,61n71, 279–280,406,411,463 ConventiononInternationalTradein EndangeredSpeciesofWildFaunaand Flora(CITES,1973),28n20,61n71,406 ConventiononNatureProtectionand WildlifePreservationintheWestern Hemisphere,28n20 ConventionontheLawoftheSea,61n71, 463 ConventionontheProhibitionofMilitaryor AnyOtherHostileUseof EnvironmentalModification Techniques,337–338,344 ConventionontheProtectionandUseof TransboundaryWatercoursesand InternationalLakes(1992),208 Cooperativefederalism,21 Copernicus,Nicolaus,12 COPINH(CivicCouncilofPopularand IndigenousOrganizationsof Honduras),289 Corporations aggregationmethodofattributingliability to,348 Amazondeforestationresponse,350 constitutionalrights,237,243
corporateculture,348–349 culturalmethodofattributingliabilityto, 348–349 ecocideliability,335,346–350,352,353 humanrightsandrightsofnaturevs. rightsof,268–273,291–292 identificationmethodofattributing liabilityto,348 jurisprudenceorphilosophywithrise of,70 municipal/locallawschallenging, 237–245,246–247 penaltiesassessed,352 personhood,128,131–132,136,140–141, 146,302–303,327,347,686 rightsofnaturevs.rightsof,237–245, 246–247,268–273,291–292,530,686 standing,128,131–132,136,146
Correa,Rafael,473,555 Corridors,wildlife,400 Cosmocentricapproach,79–80 CouncilofEurope ConventionontheProtectionofthe EnvironmentthroughCriminalLaw, 347–348
EuropeanConventiononHumanRights, 624–625 CouncilonEnvironmentalQuality,15 CourtofJusticeoftheEuropeanUnion,625 COVID-19(Coronavirus),376,464–465,688 Criminallaw
climatenecessitydefense,183,357–374 criminalintent(mensrea),339,348,353 ecocide,59,183,291,333,335–354 ecologicalsocialcontractand,452 penaltiesunder,350–352,353,368
Criteriaairpollutants,21
Criticallegalstudies,69 Crook,Martin,339–340
Crutzen,Paul,66
Cullinan,Cormac,56,146,274
Customarylaw
African,637,639–643,647–649,652–653 defined,65,665 Earthlawas,1 inEarthlawconceptualframework,65,88 Earthlaworiginsfrom,9,50,61 Indigenouslegalities,88,203–204,637, 639–643,647–649,652–653,665 international,210,431,665
rightsoffuturegenerations,203–204,210 CWA. See CleanWaterAct,U.S.
DakotaAccessPipelinecampaign,289 Damages,434. Seealso Penalties;Remedies Dams,263,273,289,487–489,522–525,596
Dann,Carrie,204
Daubertstandard,228 DDT,13
DeChristopher,Tim,363 DeclarationofBasicPrinciplesofJusticefor VictimsofCrimeandAbuseof Power,344
DeclarationoftheAllianceofGuardiansand ChildrenofMotherEarth,546 DeclarationoftheRighttoDevelopment, 335n13
DeclarationonHumanDevelopment,415 DeclarationonHumanRightsDefenders, 264
DeclarationontheHumanEnvironment (1972),208,405–406,431
DeclarationontheRightsofIndigenous Peoples(UNDRIP),60,255
Deepsustainability,426–428,437
DeepwaterHorizonoilspill,345–346, 349–350,352n76
Deforestation foragriculture,334,335,512n54,539–540 commonseffects,85 ecocide,59,183,291,333–336,345–346, 350,353–354 rightsofnatureagainst,486–487,511–522, 530,532
Deliberativedemocracy,394–395
Deliberativelaw,663–664 Democracy deliberative,394–395 ecologicalauthoritarian,447 ecologicalconstitutional,448 ecologicaldiscursive,447–448 generalwillrequiring,444n13 locallawmaking,236,394–395 personhoodin,301 separationofhumansandnaturein,46 socialcontractin,91–92,447–448 U.S.dualsovereignty,211 DemocraticRepublicofCongo,humanrights andrightsofnatureco-violations, 271,272
Desalination,578,580
Descartes,René,45,74n29
Deterrencetheory animal-humancoexistence,395 ecocidepenalties,350,353
Developingcountries
rightsoffuturegenerations,209 SustainableDevelopmentInitiatives,405, 407,410,436–437
DeWaal,Franz,387
Disabilities,personswith climatechangeeffects,266 personhood,303,311 Disease. See Healthanddisease
Displacement
AfricanIndigenous,648 animalrelocationprograms,380–382,385, 389,394–395,396,399 climatechange-driven,266 ColombianIndigenous,679 mining-related,486–487 DoctrineofDiscovery,232
Donaldson,Sue,398–399
Donziger,Steven,292
Douglas,WilliamO.,56,138,139–140
Dyadicthinking,86–88
Earth dynamichomeostasis,48,77–78,687 Earthsystemsscience,47–48,49,67,76, 77–78
Gaiatheory,47–48,76,77–78,87n62, 440n3,449 aslawyer’sclient,450–451 nature. See Nature planetaryboundaries,4–5,9,65,70,446
EarthCharter(2000),61,413–415, 448n36,460 EarthDay,1,13,465. Seealso International MotherEarthDay EarthFirst!,289 Earthlaw. Seealso Ecocentriclaw; Environmentallaw beyondanthropocentriclaw,685 conceptualframework,9–10,65–94 defined,1,43 ecocentricapproach,4–5,10,52, 79–80 ecocideimportanceto,352–354 emergenceof,1–2,6,9–10
emergingapproachesto,52–62 futureof,8,686–691 globalsurvey,7,469–471. Seealsospecific countries goalsof,3,5 jurisprudenceorphilosophy,5,9,68–73, 639,643–653,687 litigationstrategies. See Litigationstrategies originsof,9,43–63 practice-baseddevelopment,2–4,65,77, 233–236 purposesof,65–66,89 thresholdchallenges. See Threshold challenges transformingthelawwith. See Transformingthelaw EarthLawCenter coursebook,6,691n14 co-violationsreport,57,182,265–268, 273–274,290–291 movementlawyering,235 rightsofnatureadvocacy,235,245,652, 691n14
Earthlawconceptualframework, 65–94
inAnthropoceneepoch,65–71,75–77, 78–79 anthropocentricapproach,78–79 biocentricapproach,78–79 commons,10,85–86 communalrights,84 cosmocentricapproach,79–80 customarylaw,65,88 dyadicthinking,86–88 goodnature,74–78 humandutiesandresponsibilities, 83–84,87 jurisprudenceorphilosophy,68–73 lawandlegalethics,65,66,88–90 nature-culturedivide,73–74 overview,9–10,65–66 propertyrights,81,84–85 publictrustdoctrine,89–90 purposesofEarthlaw,65–66,89 reciprocity,83–84,87 rightsofnature,80–84,90 socialcontractin,91–92 sustainabledevelopment,71 systemsthinking,86–87 Earthlaworigins,43–63
connection-basedorientationunderlying, 48,50,52 ecocide,59 emergingapproachestoEarthlaw,52–62 environmentallawshortcomings,44, 51–52
Indigenouslegalities,59–60 internationaldevelopments,60–62 nonhumanrightsapproach,58 overview,9,43–44,62 publictrustdoctrine,52,53–54 rights-basedapproaches,54–58 rightsoffuturegenerations,57–58 rightsofnature,56–57 separation-basedorientationunderlying, 44–52
EarthSummit. See Conferenceon EnvironmentandDevelopment Ecocentricapproach inBrazilianjurisprudence,469,541–543 inColombianjurisprudence,498,511,512 deepecologyas,428 defined,79,80 toEarthlaw,4–5,10,52,79–80 Indigenous,9,204,376,455–464,656 inSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives, 406–407,418
Ecocentricgovernance,439–467 coronavirusand,376,464–465 economicdevelopmentand,459 enforcement,463–464 globalinstitutionsandconventions,5, 375–376,422 governance,defined,441 Indigenousinfluences,376,455–464, 656 interconnectedweboflifedependence, 464–466 lawyers’ role,449–455,462–464 overview,376,439 rightsofnatureand,376,455–464 socialcontractand,376,439,440–449, 451–455,460,463–466 Ecocentriclaw. Seealso Earthlaw; Environmentallaw ecocentricgovernanceunder,5,375–376, 422,439–467,656 emergenceof,1–8 holisticandorganicnatureof,6 international,61
stateconstitutionprovisions,248–251 Ecocide,333–355 defined,59,333,338–339,341,352–353 deforestationas,59,183,291,333–336, 345–346,350,353–354 Earthlawand,352–354 ecologicallyinducedgenocide,339–340 economicdevelopmentand,334,335n13, 353,354 environmentallaw,349–350 historyof,336–343 internationallawsandactions,59,183, 291,335–341,344,346–348,351–352 keyissues,343–352 liableorresponsibleparty,335,339, 345–350,352,353,355 aslitigationstrategy,183,291,333–355 nationalcodescriminalizing,342–343, 348,351–352 originsofEarthlaw,59 overview,183,333 peacetime,338–339,353,354–355 penaltiesfor,350–352,353
RomeStatute,336–338,340–341,344, 346–347,351,352 useofterm,336 victimidentification,343–345 wartime,59,333,336,352–353
Ecologicalauthoritarianism,447
Ecologicalconstitutionalism,448,495–496. Seealso Environmental constitutionalism
EcologicalDefenceIntegrity(EDI),341
Ecologicaldiscursivedemocracy,447–448
EcologicalFootprintNetwork,70
Ecologicalgovernance. See Ecocentric governance
EcologicalLawandGovernanceAssociation, 235,691n14
Ecologicalperiod,69,70,71–73
Ecologicalsocialcontract,92,376,440–449, 451–455,460,463–466. Seealso Social contract
Economicdevelopment
African,637 animal-humancoexistenceand,398 capitalism,51,91,231,407,416,456, 477,557
constitutionalprovisions,232,495, 496,552
Economicdevelopment(continued) consumptivesocialcontract,376,442n8, 445–447,448
Earthlawreevaluationof,3,5 ecocentricgovernanceand,459 ecocideand,334,335n13,353,354 economicutility,46,70 environmentallawconflicts,14,23,35,39, 49,51,70,101,104–105 equity. See Equity greeneconomies,421,422,423 Homoeconomicus model,46n6 humanrightsandrightsofnature conflicts,266,268,270–271,291–292 integraldevelopment,458–459 materialismand,46,91 medievalperiod,11–12 politicaleconomy,445,447–448,451 propertylawconsiderations,101, 104–105,143 rationalchoicetheory,46n5 Renaissanceperiod,12 rightsofnatureconflicts,231–232,266, 268,459,461–462,485,487,539,557 separationofhumansandnaturewith, 46
socioeconomicjurisprudence,496–497 sustainabledevelopmentand,405,410, 421,422,423,427–428. Seealso Sustainabledevelopment Economicjustice,414 Ecosystems inAmazon,334 collapse,withclimatechange,357 defined,75n30,244 Earthlawcaringforandrestoring,65, 69,89 ecocide. See Ecocide ecosystemnexustheory,148 federallawsuitforrightsof,251–254 goodnatureand,75–76 guardianshiparrangements. See Guardianshiparrangements nested,162,163 personhood,162–163,167–168,260 publictrustdoctrine,215 socio-ecosystem,551 standing,148,244 systemsecology,258 systemsthinking,87–88
Ecuador,473–491
biodiversityprotections,482–483 caselawonrightsofnature,480–489 constitutionallaw,81–82,90,162,163–164, 469,473,475–480,487–489,660 DulcepambaRiver,487–489 Earthlawimplementation,469,473–491 EnvironmentalCodereform,490 environmentalconstitutionalism,479–480 environmentalprotectionarticles, 477–480 futureofrightsofnature,487–490 GeneralOrganicCodeofProcesses,164 guardianshiparrangements,162–165,489 humandutiesandresponsibilities,478 humanrightsandrightsofnaturecoviolations,268,292,486–487 humanrightsprovisions,475,479,480 Indigenouslegalities,473–477,486–487, 656,660,674–676 Indigenous-Westernnormsclash,474–475 InternationalRightsofNatureTribunal in,273 mangroves/wetlandsecosystem protections,483–485 mining,268,486–487 nonhumanrights,491 obligationtoconsult,674–676 overviewofEarthlawin,469,473,490 rightsofnature,81–82,90,95,162–165, 268,292,469,473–491,656,660 socio-culturalnorms,474–475 standing,95 SumakKawsay concept,163,475–477,478
EDI(EcologicalDefenceIntegrity),341 Education Africanbiocultural,643 inanimal-humancoexistence,394–395 EarthJurisprudence,643 inEarthlaw,2 GlobalPactfortheEnvironmenton,435 rightsofnaturetaughtin,546
EJOLT,267
Eliot,T.S.,616
Elsesser,Chuck,234–235 Eminentdomain,105,114 Empathy inanimal-humancoexistence,388–389, 391,402 socialcontract,444
Endangeredspecies animalnexustheory,148–149 environmentallaw,28–36,147–151, 204,258 internationallaw,28n20,61n71,406 massextinctions,71,378 nonhumanrights,300 populationecology,258 propertylawand,112–113
EndangeredSpeciesAct(ESA,1973),28–36 citizen-suitprovisions,149,150–151 cost-benefitanalysis,29–35 enactment,28,204 endangered,defined,35–36 implementationandadministration, 29,147 listinganddelisting,35,36 populationecologyand,258 purposes,28–29 shortcomings,35–36 standingtochallenge,147–149,150–151 threatened,defined,36
Enlightenment jurisprudenceorphilosophyin,69–70,97 propertyrights,97 socialcontract,70,97,445
Westernnaturallaw,50
ENMOD(ConventionontheProhibitionof MilitaryorAnyOtherHostileUseof EnvironmentalModification Techniques),337–338,344
Environmentalconstitutionalism. Seealso Ecologicalconstitutionalism inBrazil,430,469 inChina,430 inEcuador,479–480 inFrance,430 global,430 inMexico,430,469
Environmentalimpactstatements,15–16, 20,431
Environmentaljustice,434
Environmentallaw,11–41. Seealso Earthlaw; Ecocentriclawasextensionof AirPollutionControlAct(1955),14,21n8 anthropocentricapproach,78–79 biocentricapproach,78–79 citizen-suitprovisions,147–159 CleanAirAct,U.S.(1970),1,21–23, 152–155,191,204
CleanWaterAct(1972),23–28,151–152, 191,204,350 communalrightsseparationfrom,49–51 ComprehensiveEnvironmentalResponse, Compensation,andLiabilityAct (1980),36–38 connection-basedorientation,48,50,52 contemporarylaws,reviewof,14–40 corporateecocideliability,349–350 cost-benefitanalysis,21–23,29–35,39–40, 49,70 defined,44 Earthlawcoexistenceandextension,10, 14,39–40,43,44–52,62 ecocentricapproach,4–5,10,52,79–80 ecocentricgovernance,463–464 ecocide,349–350 economicgrowthconflicts,14,23,35,39, 49,51,70,101,104–105
EndangeredSpeciesAct(1973),28–36, 147–151,204,258 FederalCoalMineHealthandSafetyAct (1969),14 FederalWaterPollutionControlAct (1948),14 historyof,3,11–14,69–70 humanrightsandrightsofnature co-violationsunder,266 mechanisticjurisprudence,50–51, 464n70 MotorVehicleAirPollutionControlAct (1965),14,21n8 NationalEnvironmentalPolicyAct(1970), 14,15–20,144,191,204,205,213 NationalParkServiceOrganicAct (1916),14 nuisancedoctrine,12–13,21,39 overview,9,11 propertylawconflicts,39,50,51,100–115 publictrustdoctrine,191,213 remedies,9 RiversandHarborsAct(1899),14, 23n15 scienceand,48–50 separation-basedorientation,44,47–52 shortcomings,35–36,39–40,44,51–52, 232,237,258 siloproblem,27–28,39 SolidWasteDisposalAct(1965),14 WildernessAct(1964),14 Index
EnvironmentalProtectionAgency,U.S. CAAadministration,21,152–155 CERCLAadministration,37–38 establishment,1,14–15,204 waterqualitystandards,24
Equity
Earthlawreevaluationof,5,91 GlobalPactfortheEnvironmenton,433 intergenerational,227–228,433 intragenerational,532 SustainableDevelopmentInitiatives and,410
ESA. See EndangeredSpeciesAct EscazúAgreement(2018),411 ESCR-Net(InternationalNetworkfor Economic,SocialandCulturalRights), 275–276 Estatelaw,202,452
Estuaries,24
Ethics. Seealso Morality inanimal-humancoexistence,377,378, 383,388–389,391–401 anthropocentrismand,79 indeepsustainability,428 inEarthlawconceptualframework,65,66, 89–90 ecocentricapproachto,4 landethic,121,140,146,233,258 propertylaw,121 rightsofnature,233,258 separationoflawfrom,51 insocialcontract,446–447 transformingthelawfor,7 Ethiopia,EarthJurisprudencemovement,644 EuropeanConventiononHumanRights,276, 623–626,629–632
EuropeanConventionontheProtectionof theEnvironmentthroughCriminal Law,347–348 EuropeanCourtofHumanRights,275, 624–625 EuropeanUnion,Treatyon,623
Extinction,mass,71,378 Extractivism,459,461,538,653
Fabius,Laurent,432
Fahey,Eugene,328,331–332
Falk,Richard,338
Farber,DanielA.,105–106 Farming. See Agriculture
FederalCoalMineHealthandSafetyAct (1969),14
FederalLawofEnvironmentalResponsibility (Mexico,2013),548
FederalOnshoreOilandGasLeasing Act,363
FederalRuleofCivilProcedure11,235–236
FederalWaterPollutionControlAct (1948),14
FederalWaterPollutionControlAct (1956),23n15
FederalWaterPollutionControlAct(1972). See CleanWaterAct,U.S. Fernández,RaúlLlasag,476
Fertilizers,47,243
Fiduciaryduty
climatechange,628,630,636 ecocide,341,354 publictrustdoctrine,215–216
FifthAmendmentrights climatechangeviolations,89,156,206 propertyrights,105 rightsoffuturegenerations,206,219 rightsofnature,243
Financialissues. See Banksand financial institutions;Economicdevelopment; Penalties
Fires
forestandrainforest,290–291,334,335, 350,353–354,512 prevalenceof,465,689
FirstAmendmentrights,243,251,252
Fish deadzones,13 environmentallawprotecting,28–29 mercurypoisoning,13 oilspillsendangering,349 publictrustdoctrine,185 standingtoprotect,150–151
FishandWildlifeService,U.S.,29
Floods climatechangeeffects,226,689 floodcontrol,ascommons,85 hydroelectricdamscreating,263,487–489 rightsoffuturegenerations,225,226 socialcontractforresponseto,91
Foodresources
Amazonorigins,334 bears’ attractionto,379–380,382,384, 391,393–395,399
Colombianjurisprudenceonlossof,500
ForestPrinciples,411
Forestsandrainforests Africanlegislation,651 ascommons,85
deforestation. See Deforestation ecocide,59,183,291,333–336,345–346, 350,353–354 ecosystemservices,334 guardianshiparrangements,178 humanrightsandrightsofnaturecoviolationswithdamaged,268,270–273, 277–279,290–291 internationallawsandactions,59,183, 291,404,411 nonhumanhabitats,581–585 personhood,298,566–569 rightsoffuturegenerations,57,512 rightsofnature,298,469,474,486–487, 498,511–522,530,532,566–569, 581–585 standing,78,141–146 sustainableuse,411
ForumonForests,UN,404
FounexReportonDevelopmentand Environment,405
FourteenthAmendmentrights climatechangeviolations,89 formerslaverights,128,304 personhood,131–132,146,203n10, 303,327 propertyrights,97 rightsoffuturegenerations,219 rightsofnature,243,251,252,260 standing,128,130–135,146
Fracking,241,273
FrameworkConventiononClimate Change,61n71,209,273,406,411,512, 628–629
FrameworkLawofMotherEarthandIntegral DevelopmentforLivingWell(Bolivia), 458–459,460–461,470,535
France
Amazondeforestationresponse,335, 350 climatechangeresponses,634 environmentalconstitutionalism,430 InternationalRightsofNatureTribunal in,273
Francis(Pope),446
Franklin,Benjamin,23 Freshwateraccessanduse inAmazon,334,512 climatechangeeffects,357 ascommons,85 dams’ effects,488–489,522,596 humanrightsandrightsofnature, 488–489,527–528 Israelirightsofnature,577–581, 585–586 overexploitation,578,579–580 personhoodofnatureand,618–619 asplanetaryboundary,5n6,70 publictrustdoctrine,185–186,214,586
Freyfogle,Eric,66
Futuregenerations,rightsof. See Rightsof futuregenerations
G7(GroupofSeven)deforestation response,335 GaiaFoundation,643,646,651 Gaiatheory,47–48,76,77–78,87n62, 440n3,449 Galilei,Galileo,12,45 Galston,ArthurW.,336 Garner,Bryan,332 Garrison,WilliamLloyd,55 GarzaGrimaldo,JoséGilberto,549,550 GautamaBuddha,45 Gazelle,habitatrights,581–585,586–587 GeneralLawofEcologicalEquilibriumand EnvironmentalProtection(Mexico, 1988),548 GeneralOrganicCodeofProcesses (Ecuador),164 Generalwill,443–444,453–455 Geneticmodification,72 GenevaConventions,55 Genocide,232,333,339–340 Georgia(Republicof),ecocidecodes, 342,351
Germany
Amazondeforestationresponse,335, 350,512 criminalliability,346n47 Holocaustgenocide,340 InternationalRightsofNatureTribunal in,273 Ginsburg,RuthBader,151,234 GlobalAlliancefortheRightsofNature (GARN),235,273–274,691n14
Globalecocentricgovernance,5,375–376, 422
Globalenvironmentalconstitutionalism,430
GlobalExchange,245
GlobalHumanitarianForum,266
GlobalPactfortheEnvironment definitionanddescription,429 globalenvironmental constitutionalism,430 hardeningsoftlaw,430–431 historyofinitiative,431–433 necessityof,429–431 principlesof,433–435 asUNSustainableDevelopmentInitiative, 61,403–404,429–435,436–437
GlobalsurveyofEarthlaw,7,469–471. Seealso specificcountries
GlobalWitness,263,267,269–273,291–292
GoldmanEnvironmentalPrize,60,263
GonzálezCruz,MaríaGabriela,551
Goodall,Jane,296,386
Graham,Nicole,84
GrantTownship,Pennsylvaniacasestudy, 238–242
Gray,JohnChipman,304
Gray,Mark,339
GreatAcceleration,46–47,48,70,445
GreatAssemblyoftheAllianceofMother Nature’sGuardians,546 Greeneconomies,421,422,423
Greenhousegases. Seealsospecificgases atmospherictrustlitigation,54,59,89–90, 156,181,623,634–635 concentrations,47 deforestationand,334,512 ecocideandreleaseof,334 ashumanrightsandrightsofnature co-violations,266,291 Netherlands’ judicialrulingson,623, 628–636 standingtochallengeexcessive,152–155, 156–159
Greenpeace,289
Griffin,Julia,380–382
Ground-levelozone,21n11
Guardianshiparrangements,161–179 inColombia,96,162–163,169–172,496, 529,676–682 inEcuador,162–165,489 inIndia,96,162–163,172–178,566
inlocoparentis doctrine,173–174,178, 566
Model1(reactive,volunteermodel), 162–167
Model2(proactive,appointed representativemodel),162–163, 167–178 inNewZealand,90,96,162–163,167–168, 173,175,178,601–602,617–619 nonhumanrights,177–178,586–587 overview,95–96,161–163,178 standingand,127,132–133,142 inU.S.municipalities,162–163,165–167
GuidingPrinciplesonBusinessandHuman Rights,UN,264
Gutenberg,Johannes,12
Guterres,Antonio,425–426
Habeascorpus,writof Indigenouslegalities,302 nonhumanrights,293–299,301,304, 305–332 two-stepprocessof,306n82 valueof,305–306
Habitat bears,377,379,380,384,391,397–402 corridors,400 Earthlawensuringviabilityof,89 environmentallawprotecting,28,36 internationallawsandactions,61n71, 406,483 landuseplanningand,400–401 nonhumanrightsto,581–585,586–587 restoration,400–401 Hamilton,Clive,67–68,69,71,76,87n63 Hansen,James,206,219 Hardin,Garrett,85n59 HarmonywithNatureInitiative Boliviansupport,416–418,556 Earthlaworigins,61–62 TheFutureWeWantrecognizing,421 purposeof,375 resolution,417,419–420 onSDGs,424–425 SustainableDevelopmentInitiative,61–62, 375,403,404,416–420,421,424–425, 437,556
UniversalDeclarationoftheRightsof MotherEarth,417–418 Hasson,Vanessa,545
Hazardouswaste environmentallaw,36–38 internationallaw,61n71 municipal/locallaws,241 oilspillscreating,349
Healthanddisease
BlackPlague,11–12
Colombianjurisprudenceoneffectsto, 499–500 coronavirus(COVID-19),376, 464–465,688
Indigenouslegalities,679,681 mercurypoisoning,13,21–22,151–152, 499
oilandnatural-relateddangers,268
HeinrichBöllFoundation,415
Higgins,Polly,59,183,338,339,341, 344–345,355
High-levelPoliticalForumonSustainable Development,404,411,425–426
Hinsley,Michael,381–382
Hobbes,Thomas,376,440,442,465–466
Hoffman,Abbie,359
Holoceneepoch Anthropocenetransitionfrom,9,66 socialcontract,439
Homoeconomicus model,46n6
Honduras
humanrightsandrightsofnature co-violations,263,272,289,292 Indigenouslegalities,60,263,289 U.S.-supportedcoup,292
HonortheEarth,233,235
Houck,Oliver,112–114
Hulot,Nicholas,432
Humanexceptionalism,mythologyof,47, 231,683
Humanrights
Colombia’sprovisionsfor,495,496 communal. See Communalrights constitutionallaw,549 Earthlawprotecting,65
Ecuador’sprovisionsfor,475,479,480 humandutiesandresponsibilitieswith, 4–5,10,67–68,83–84,87 Indigenouspeoples,60,673–676. Seealso under Humanrightsandrightsof nature
internationalhumanrightslaw,55,590, 623–626,629–632
NewZealand’sprovisionsfor,590,600,622 personhood. See Personhood rightsoffuturegenerations,57–58, 201–230 rightsofnatureand. See Animal-human coexistence;Humanrightsandrights ofnature separationofhumansandnaturewith,46, 69–70
Humanrightsandrightsofnature,263–292. Seealso Animal-humancoexistence bioculturalrights,169–170,501,511 climatechange,266,291 corporaterightsvs.,268–273,291–292 co-violations,57–58,182,265–275, 278–279,281,289–292,486–487, 499–500,526–528,540–541 dams’ effects,263,273,289,487–489 economicdevelopmentconflicts,266,268, 270–271,291–292 freshwateraccessanduse,488–489, 527–528 humandutiesandresponsibilitieswith, 4–5,10,67–68,83–84,87 Indigenouslegalities,182,263–265, 267–269,272–289,486–487,499–501, 511,540–541,622 internationalactionsandtribunals, 267–268,273–275 landandenvironmentaldefendersof, 263–265,267,269–273,289–290,292, 529–530 aslitigationstrategy,182,263–292,529 miningco-violations,267–268,270–273, 275–279,486–487,499–501, 526–528,540 OrganizationofAmericanStateshuman rightsprotections,275–289 overview,182,289–290 propertyrights,81,264,266,276–277, 278–280 reciprocity,83–84,87 separation-basedorientation,46 violenceagainstdefendersof,263–265, 267,269–273,289–290,292,529–530 HumanRightsCouncil,UN,268–269, 275
Hunting,381,384,390,398. Seealso Poaching Hydroelectricdams,263,487–489, 522–525,596 Index
IACHR(Inter-AmericanCommissionof HumanRights),275–280,673–676
ICCPR(InternationalCovenantonCiviland PoliticalRights),55
Iceandglaciers,59,567–569
Ikerd,John,426–428,437
ILO-convention169(IndigenousandTribal PeoplesConvention,1989),60
Incapacitationtheory,350,353
India,559–575
constitutionallaw,559–560,564–565, 573–574
Earthlawimplementation,470,559–575
Ganges/GangaRiver,83n54,172–177, 470,559,560–566
GangotriGlacier,567–569
guardianshiparrangements,96,162–163, 172–178,566
legallandscape,559–560 nonhumanrights,58,177–178,298,559, 570–574
overviewofEarthlawin,470,559 personhoodofnature,83n54,96,162–163, 470,559,560–569,689–690
PreventionofCrueltytoAnimalsAct, 570–571
rightsoffuturegenerations,214 rightsofnature,83n54,162–163,172–178, 470,559–575
sacredplaces,173,560–564,566
YamunotriGlacier,567–569
Yamuna/JumnaRiver,172–177,559, 560–566
IndigenousandTribalPeoplesConvention (ILO-convention169,1989),60 IndigenousEnvironmentalNetwork,235 Indigenouslegalities,655–684. Seealso Indigenousrightsofnature African,470,637–654 climatechangeeffects,266 Colombian,169,171,495,499–501,511, 639,643,656–657,660–662,664, 667–673,676–683 colonialismeffects,232,470,638, 657–659 communalrights,51,84,648,650, 673–674 connection-basedorientation,50 constitutionalprotections,495,538–539, 547,550,679
cosmocentricapproach,80 culturalidentityrights,667–669,672 customarylaw,88,203–204,637,639–643, 647–649,652–653,665 DeclarationoftheAllianceofGuardians andChildrenofMotherEarth,546 deepsustainabilitybasedonwisdom of,427 deliberativelaw,663–664 Earthlawimplementation,470,655–684 Earthlaworigins,59–60 ecocentricgovernancereflecting,376, 455–464,656 ecocentricjurisprudence,9,204 ecocideofhomelandsof,334,339–340 guardianshiparrangements,90,163, 167–169,171–172,601–602,617–619, 676–682 habeascorpus,writof,302 historyof,52 Indigenous-Westernnormsclash,474–475, 655–659 informedconsent,278,650,668,671–672 intellectualpropertyrights,669 Inter-AmericanCommissionofHuman Rightson,275–280,673–676 internationallawmodeling,61–62 InternationalRightsofNatureTribunal role,182,267,273–275 kinshipsystem,663 aslandandenvironmentaldefenders, 263–264,265,269,272,289 LetterforNature,545–546 naturallaw,50,661–663 obligationtoconsultwith,674–676 overviewofEarthlawin,470,655–657, 682–684 personhood,141,302 positivisticlaw,666 propertyrights,98–100,254–255,276–280, 539,669,673–682 publictrustdoctrine,213 reciprocity,83 rightsoffuturegenerations,203–204,213 rightsofnature. See Indigenousrightsof nature sacredlaw,659–660 sacredplacesandreligiouspractices. See Sacredplacesandrightsofnature socio-ecosystemconcept,551
sourcesoflaw,659–666 traditionalknowledgeandlaws,668–671, 676–682
Indigenousrightsofnature
inAfrica,638–639,643–653
inBrazil,536–537,538–541,545–546,558 customarylaw,647–649,652–653,665 deliberativelaw,663–664 Earthlawconceptualframework,90 ecocentricgovernance,376,455–464,656 inEcuador,473–477,486–487,656,660 guardianshiparrangements,90,163, 167–168,169,171–172,601–602, 617–619,676–682 humanrightsand. See Humanrightsand rightsofnature kinship,661–663 inMexico,469,547,549–552,558 inNewZealand,90,167–168,589–590, 594,596,600–622
positivisticlaw,666 sacredlaw,659–660 sacredplaces. See Sacredplacesandrights ofnature
U.S.rightsofnaturemovement,182, 232–233,236,254–257
IndustrialRevolution environmentallawdevelopment,12–13,70 humanrightsandrightsofnature after,265
jurisprudenceorphilosophyin,70 scienceandtechnology,48 separationofhumansandnaturein, 45–46,47,48 socialcontract,445
Informedconsent,278,650,668,671–672
IngaofAponte,676–682,683
Injunctions,101,144
Injury-in-factstandard rightsoffuturegenerations,224,225–227 standing,137,139,140,147–149,155,224, 225–227
Inlocoparentis doctrine,173–174,178,566
InstitutoNacionaldelosPueblosIndígenas (NationalInstituteofIndigenous Peoples),550–551
Integraldevelopment,458–459
Intellectualpropertyrights,143,452,669
Inter-AmericanCommissionofHuman Rights(IACHR),275–280,673–676
Inter-AmericanCourtofHumanRights (IACtHR),57,275,276–289
Intergenerationalequity,227–228,433
IntergovernmentalPanelonClimateChange (IPCC),49,71,228,404
InternationalCommissionofStratigraphy AnthropoceneWorkingGroup,3–4, 66n4,67
InternationalConventionfortheHighSeas FisheriesoftheNorthPacific Ocean,28n20
InternationalConventionfortheNorthwest AtlanticFisheries,28n20
InternationalConventiononSocialand PoliticalRights,304
InternationalCourtofJustice,275,431
InternationalCovenantonCivilandPolitical Rights(ICCPR),55
InternationalCovenantonEnvironmentand Development(1995),431
InternationalCriminalCourt ecocide,59,183,291,336–338,340–341, 344,346–347,351,352
genocide,340
RomeStatute,336–338,340–341,344, 346–347,351,352,463
InternationalForumfortheRightsofMother Earth,554,556
InternationalLawoftheSeaTribunal,431 InternationalMotherEarthDay,416,418
InternationalNetworkforEconomic,Social andCulturalRights(ESCR-Net), 275–276
InternationalRightsofNatureTribunals,182, 267,273–275
InternationalRivers,235
InternationalUnionforConservationof Nature(IUCN)
InternationalCovenantonEnvironment andDevelopment,431
WorldCharterforNature,406–409,460, 463,479
WorldConservationCongresses,645
WorldConservationStrategy,216
InternationalWarCrimesTribunal,273
Intragenerationalequity,532
IPCC(IntergovernmentalPanelonClimate Change),49,71,228,404
Ireland,climatechangeresponses,634 Irreparabledamagedoctrine,144,150
Israel,577–587
Earthlawimplementation,470,577–587 nonhumanhabitatrights,581–585, 586–587
overviewofEarthlawin,470,577,585 rightsofnature,470,577–587
RomeStatutenotapplicable,341 watersupply/WaterLaw,577–581, 585–586
IUCN. See InternationalUnionfor ConservationofNature
Jaffe,Barbara,313,322
Japan environmentallaw,13
MigratoryandEndangeredBirdTreaty withU.S.,28n20 Jennings,Bruce,91–92,376,441–449, 453–455,460,463,466 JohannesburgDeclarationonHuman Development,415 Jointliability,CERCLA,38 Jones,Felicity,234 Jones,Kate,465
Jusabutendi (righttodestroyproperty),95 Justiciability,89–90,125
Kauffman,Craig,485 Kazakhstan,ecocidecodes,342,351 Keats,Jonathon,455
Kenya
EarthJurisprudencemovement,644, 648,653 wildebeest-humancoexistence, 399–400 Kierkegaard,Soren,465 Kiko(chimpanzee),294,306,311–313, 323–332
Kilham,Benjamin “Ben,” 382,386, 395
King,MartinLuther,Jr.,454 Kinshipsystem,663 KlamathRiver,255
Koons,Judith,69–70 Kotzé,Louis,460–461 Kruger,Tamati,609 Kwaymullina,Ambellin,662–663
Kymlicka,Will,398–399 KyotoProtocol(1997),463 Kyrgyzstan,ecocidecodes,342,351
Lajo,Javier,476
LakeErieBillofRights(LEBOR),242–245, 298n45,688–689
Land Colombianjurisprudence,497n24 colonialviews,232 communaltenure,673–674 landandenvironmentaldefenders, 263–265,267,269–273,289–290,292, 529–530 landethic,121,140,146,233,258 land-systemchange,5n6,70 propertylawandrights. See Propertylaw, U.S.;Propertyrights servitudein,101 trustlands,115–121
Land-systemchange,asplanetaryboundary, 5n6,70
Landuseplanning,115–121,400–401
LaoTzu,45
LatinAmerica. Seealsospecificcountries classicalcivilizationdevelopment,45 EscazúAgreement,411 humanrightsandrightsofnaturecoviolations,272,273 overviewofEarthlawin,469,535–536 rightsofnature,469,535–536 WorldCharterforNaturestance,407
Latour,Bruno,77–78,376,440–441,448, 449,466
Law,John,655 Lawyers communitylawyering,234–235 Earthasclient,450–451 Earthlawyers,450–455,462–464, 690–691 ecocentricgovernancerole,449–455, 462–464 ecologicalsocialcontractand,451–452 movementlawyering,233–236 NationalLawyersGuild,235 normativejurisprudence,453–455 realismof,450–451,464 reformoflaw,453–455 societalplaceof,449–450
Lead,21n11
LEBOR(LakeErieBillofRights),242–245, 298n45,688–689
Legalethics. See Ethics Legalfetishism,533–534
Legalpositivism,50,69. Seealso Positivelaw Legalrealism,69
LegalRightsoftheSalishSea,258
LemaitreRipoll,Julieta,533
Leo(chimpanzee),294,306,313–322
Leopold,Aldo,79,121,140,146,233, 249,258
LeopoldII(King),641
Liminalspecies,398–399
Lithiummining,462
Litigationstrategies
climatenecessitydefense,183,357–374 ecocide,183,291,333–355 humanrightsandrightsofnature,182, 263–292,529 nonhumanrights,182,293–332 overview,7,181–183 publictrustdoctrine,181–182,185–199 rightsoffuturegenerations,181–182, 201–230 rightsofnature,182,231–261,263–292
LittleMahoningWatershed,238–242 Locke,John,97–99,376,442,466
Loder,Reed,375
LondonConvention(Conventionforthe PreventionofMarinePollutionby DumpingofWastesandOtherMatter, 1972),406
Lovelock,James,47,76,77,87n62,440n3
LozadaVargas,JuanCarlos,530
Luther,Martin,12
Macas,Luis,476 Macmillan,Harold,641 Macron,Emmanuel,85,335,350,432
Mangroves,rightsofnatureprotections, 483–485
Marceau,Justin,331
Margulis,Lynn,47,77,87n62,440n3
Marshall,John,123,159,229,633,636
Martin,Pamela,485 Massextinctions,71,378
Materialism,46,91
MATS(MercuryandAirToxicsStandards), 21–22
Maturana,Humberto,87n62
Maximumsustainableyield,75 McKibben,Bill,72
MDGs(MillenniumDevelopmentGoals),412 Meadows,Donella,76
Medievalperiod,11–12
Mello,Antonia,540 Mencius,45 Mensrea (criminalintent),339,348,353 MercuryandAirToxicsStandards(MATS), 21–22
Mercurypoisoning,13,21–22,151–152,499 Mesa,Carlos,459 MestreBusintana,Kasokaku,664 Mexico,547–558 biocentricapproach,555–557 biodiversity,547 challengesforEarthlaw,557 constitutionallaw,547–550,552–555 Earthlawimplementation,469,535–536, 547–558 environmentalconstitutionalism,430,469 environmentalprotections,547–548 FederalLawofEnvironmental Responsibility,548 GeneralLawofEcologicalEquilibrium andEnvironmentalProtection,548 humanenvironmentalrights framework,549 humanrightsandrightsofnaturecoviolations,271,272 Indigenouslegalities,60,469,536,547, 549–552,558 migratorybirdtreatieswithU.S.,28n20 Morales’ asylumin,459 overviewofEarthlawin,469,535–536,547 rightsofnature,271,272,469,535–536, 547–558 societal/socialdriversofEarthlaw, 555–557 socio-ecosystemconcept,551 stateconstitutionenvironmental provisions,552–555 MigratoryandEndangeredBird Treaty,28n20 MillenniumDevelopmentGoals(MDGs),412 MillenniumSummitandDeclaration(2000), 411–412 Mills,Aaron,656 Mills,EnosA.,386 Mining Bolivian,455,459,461–462 communalrightsagainst,84,650 environmentallawon,13,14 extractivism,459,461,538,653
Mining(continued) guardianshiparrangementsforprotection from,169,171–172 humanrightsandrightsofnaturecoviolations,267–268,270–273,275–279, 486–487,499–501,526–528,540 intrinsicvalueofnatureimpacts,595 Minors. See Childrenandminors Mobutu,SeseSeko,407
Moldova,Republicof,ecocidecodes, 342,351
Mo‘oinanea,255–257
Mootness,125,133–135,151–152
Morales,Evo,416–417,455–456,459, 461–462,555,556
Morality. Seealso Ethics inanimal-humancoexistence,377,378, 388–389,391 anthropocentrismand,67–68,78n37 generalwill,443–444 jurisprudenceandviewsof,69 moralclaims,453 moralreasoningforconstitutional interpretation,129 nature-culturedivideand,74n29 nonhumanrightsand,58,297 normativejurisprudence,453–454 rights-basedmovementschallenging, 55,58 inrightsofnaturedecisions,569 separationoflawfrom,46,50,51,69 socialcontractand,443–445,446–447, 451–452,466 SustainableDevelopmentInitiativescall for,407
MotherEarthRightsLaw(Bolivia),456–458, 460–464,470,535
MotorVehicleAirPollutionControlAct (1965),14,21n8
Motorvehicles,14,21n8,46,153–155
Movementlawyering,233–236 MovementRights,235 Muir,John,74 Municipalities. Seealsospecificcountriesand cities bearordinances,380,394–395 GrantTownship,Pennsylvaniacasestudy, 238–242 guardianshiparrangements,162–163, 165–167
LakeErieBillofRightscasestudy, 242–245,298n45,688–689 landuseplanning,400–401 localrights-basedlawmaking,237 nonhumanrights,298 rightsofnature,162–163,165–167,182, 231,236–248,298 SantaMonica,Californiacasestudy, 245–248 statepreemption,241,244
Nash,RoderickFrazier,258 NationalAmbientAirQualityStandards (NAAQS),21 NationalAssociationofProfessional Environmentalists(NAPE),651 NationalEnvironmentalPolicyAct(NEPA, 1970),15–20 enactment,14,15 environmentalimpactstatements, 15–16,20 federalagencyrequirements,15–20, 144 publictrustdoctrineexpansionwith, 191,213 purposes,15 rightsoffuturegenerations,204,205, 213
NationalIndigenousConfederationof Ecuador(CONAIE),475–476
NationalInstituteofIndigenousPeoples (InstitutoNacionaldelosPueblos Indígenas,orINPI),550–551 NationalLawyersGuild,235 NationalMarineFisheriesService,U.S.,29 NationalParkService,U.S.,14 NationalParkServiceOrganicAct(1916), 14
NationalResourcesDefenseCouncil,1 Nativepeoples. See Indigenouslegalities; Indigenousrightsofnature Naturaldisasters,asdriversoflegal transformation,688–689 Naturallaw defined,661 humanlawstrumpedby,687 Indigenous,50,661–663 jurisprudence,68–69 nature-culturedivide,73–74 Western,50,663
Nature agencyof,68,87n63 inAnthropoceneepoch,68 balanceof,77–78 colonialviews,232 conservationistapproach,74–75 defined,73,244 dyadicthinkingon,86–88 Earthlawgoalsfor,3,65,74–78 ecosystemservices,75,334,531 good,74–78 optimalorwiseuse,75 personhood. See Nature,personhoodof preservationistapproach,74–75 propertylawandrights,39,51,72,84, 231–232,264,266 publictrustdoctrine. See Publictrust doctrine reciprocityin,5,10,83–84,87 separationofhumansfrom,44–52,69–70, 656,682–683 socialcontractwith,440–441 socioculturalnormstoward,3,73–74, 76–78
standing,4,56,138–159,244,257,267,686 systemsthinkingon,86–87. Seealso Ecosystems asvictimofecocide,344–345
Nature,personhoodof inColombia,96,162–163,298,493, 528–529,689–690 ecocentricapproach,4 guardianship,96,162–163,167–178 inIndia,83n54,96,162–163,470,559, 560–569,689–690 inNewZealand,90,96,162–163,167–168, 298,470,600–619,621–622 standing,143,160 inU.S.,239–240,251–252,256–257,260, 298,686 Necessitydoctrine climatenecessitydefensebasedon,183, 357–374 privatenecessity,112 publicnecessity,112 Negativefreedom,448n37,454
NEPA. See NationalEnvironmentalPolicyAct Netherlands,623–636 atmospherictrustlitigation,623, 634–635
climatechangeresponse,470–471,623, 626–636 constitutionallaw,628–629 dutyofcare,628,630,636 Earthlawimplementation,470–471, 623–636
EuropeanConventiononHumanRights application,623–626,629–632 impactsofclimatechangeresponse, 633–634
legalsystem,626–627 overviewofEarthlawin,470–471,623, 635–636 publictrustdoctrine,54,634–635 separationofpowers,630–633,635–636
Newcomb,Steven,658
NewHampshire bears-humancoexistence,377,378, 379–383,385,389,392–393,394–397, 399,400,402 rightsofnatureprovisions,250 Newton,Isaac,12,45
NewZealand,589–622
AnimalWelfareAmendmentAct,597–599 biodiversity,595 climatechangeresponses,634 ConservationAct,592 constitutionallaw,589 Earthlawimplementation,470, 589–622 guardianshiparrangements,90,96, 162–163,167–168,173,175,178, 601–602,617–619
HazardousSubstancesandNew OrganismsAct,596–597 humanrights,590,600,622 Indigenouslegalities,90,167–168,204, 589–590,594,596,600–622 intrinsicvalueofnature,590–597,620
Māorienvironmentalphilosophies, 600–601
MarineandCoastalArea(TakutaiMoana) Act,593
NationalParksAct,591–592 nonhumanrights,597–599,621 overviewofEarthlawin,470,589–590, 619–620 personhoodofnature,90,96,162–163, 167–168,298,470,600–619,621–622 ReservesAct,591 Index
NewZealand(continued)
ResourceManagementAct,590,593–597, 601,619
rightsoffuturegenerations,204 rightsofnature,90,162–163,167–168, 173,175,178,298,589–622
standing,96
TeAwaTupuaAct(2017),90,167–168, 175,178,204n13,617–619
TeKawaoTeUrewera,609–616, 619–620,622
TeUreweraAct(2014),470,602–608
TeUrewera[NationalPark],178,298,470, 602–616,619–620,621–622
WaitangiTreaty,90,168,204,470,589, 590,595,600–601
WhanganuiRiver,90,96,167–168,173, 178,204,298,470,617–619
Neyret,Laurent,339
NhRP(NonhumanRightsProject),58,182, 293–295,301,305,306–332
Nicaragua,humanrightsandrightsofnature co-violations,272,276–277
Nigeria
EarthJurisprudencemovement,652,654 humanrightsandrightsofnaturecoviolations,273
NinthAmendmentrights,89,156,206
Nitrogen cycle,interferencewithglobal,5n6,70 syntheticproduction,47 Nitrogendioxide,21n11 Nixon,Richard,205
Nobre,Carlos,334,540
Nonhumanrights,293–332. Seealso Animalhumancoexistence autonomy,296–299,305,310,322, 396–397
Braziljurisprudence,541–543 commonlaw,58,182,293–299,301, 303–332 constitutionallaw,573–574 dutiesandresponsibilitieswith,177, 296,322
Earthlaworigins,58 ecocideand,345 environmentallawprotecting,28–36, 147–151,204,258 guardianshiparrangements,177–178, 586–587
habeascorpus,writof,293–299,301,304, 305–332 habitatrights,581–585,586–587 ofHerculesandLeo(chimpanzees),294, 306,313–322 Indian,58,177–178,298,559,570–574
Israelijurisprudence,581–585,586–587 ofKiko(chimpanzee),294,306,311–313, 323–332 aslitigationstrategy,182,293–332 NewZealandlegislation,597–599,621 NhRPlitigation,306–332. Seealso NonhumanRightsProject overview,182,293–299,332 personhood,58,177–178,182,294, 295–296,298–299,301–332,559, 571–574 propertyrights,4,72,182,299–300 publictrustdoctrine,185 rightsofnatureand,177–178,294,491, 581–585,586–587,597–599 sanctuariesfor,293,298,306,312–313,322 sentience,597–599,621 socio-culturalnorms,296–297,300,305 standing,584 ofTommy(chimpanzee),293–294,296, 297,299–300,305,306–311,323–332 welfarevs.rights,299–301 NonhumanRightsProject(NhRP),58,182, 293–295,301,305,306–332 Non-regression,principleof,429,435 Normativejurisprudence,69,453–455 NorthAmericanAgreementon EnvironmentalCooperation,209 Norway Amazondeforestationresponse,335, 350,512 climatechangeresponses,634 constitutionallaw,217 rightsoffuturegenerations,217 Nuisance animalslabeledas,379,380,393,395,399 defined,100–101 environmentalprotection,12–13,21,39 privatenuisance,12,112 propertylaw,100–104,112–113 publicnuisance,12,112
OAS. See OrganizationofAmericanStates Obamaadministration,23,463
Oceans. Seealso Beaches;Coastalwaters acidification,5n6,70 ascarbonsinks,47n16 ascommons,85 ecocentricgovernance,5 internationallawonpollutionin,406 oilspills,345–346,349–350 risingsealevels,226
Oilandnaturalgas climatechangeinitiatives,634 climatenecessitydefenseforactions against,363–374 ecocidefrom,345–346,349–350, 352n76,353 fracking,241,273 humanrightsandrightsofnaturecoviolations,268,271,273,279,289,528 obligationtoconsultregarding,674–676 oilspills,13,38,345–346,349–350,352n76 taxes,633
OilPollutionAct(1990),349–350 Ombudsman,162,164
OpenSocietyInitiativeforEastAfrica,652
Oposa,Antonio,227
Orderthrough fluctuation,87n62
Oregon,rightsofnatureprovisions,250 OrganizationforAfricanUnity. See AfricanUnion
OrganizationofAmericanStates(OAS) AmericanConventiononHumanRights, 279,280–288
Bolivianelectionmonitoring,459 humanrightsprotections,275–289, 673–676
Inter-AmericanCommissionofHuman Rights,275–280,673–676
Inter-AmericanCourtofHumanRights, 57,275,276–289
Originalism,129
Ozone,5n6,21n11,61n71,70
Pakenham,Thomas,641
Pakistan,climatechangeresponses,634
Palacio,Ivan,169–170
Palmer,Clare,399
PanceRiverBasin,498 PáramodePisba,498,527–528
Parenspatriae doctrine,227,565
ParisClimateAgreement,357–358,406,463
Parrots,non-humanrights,541–543
Particulatematter,21n11
Pastoureau,Michel,390 Pelaez,JuanFrancisco,172 Penalties forclimatecivildisobedience,368 corporate,352 forecocide,350–352,353 GlobalPactfortheEnvironment provisions,434
Peoples’ SustainabilityTreaties,421–423
Personhood APAdefinition,136 children,141,303,311,529 corporations,128,131–132,136,140–141, 146,302–303,327,347,686 ecosystems,162–163,167–168,260 habeascorpusand,305–332. Seealso Habeascorpus,writof Indigenouslegalities,141,302 legalconceptof,301–304,310–311 nature. See Nature,personhoodof nonhuman,58,177–178,182,294, 295–296,298–299,301–332,559, 571–574 slaves,295,301–302 women,141,302,529 Peru humanrightsandrightsofnaturecoviolations,271,272 InternationalRightsofNatureTribunal in,273 rightsofnature,535n2 WorldCharterforNaturestance,407n16 Pesticides,13 Pharmaceuticals,334 Philippines constitutionallaw,219 GlobalPactfortheEnvironment stance,432 humanrightsandrightsofnaturecoviolations,269,271,272 rightsoffuturegenerations,214,219–224, 227–228 RomeStatutenotapplicable,341 Philosophyoflaw philosophicalanthropology,69,71,72 philosophicalcosmology,69,71–72,73 propertyrights,97–100 Phosphoruscycle,interferencewithglobal, 5n6,70
Pinchot,Gifford,74–75
PinedaSantiago,Irma,551
Planetaryboundaries
consumptivesocialcontractandlimits of,446
Earthlawframeworkforlivingwithin,9, 65
ecologicalfootprintexceeding,70 humandutiesandresponsibilities,4–5 overview,5n6
Plants. Seealso Agriculture;Forestsand rainforests ascarbonsinks,47n16 environmentallawprotecting,36
Plastics,12–13,46
PlataRiver,498
Plato,45,78n38
Plurilegalsystems,637,642,646,648, 652–653,656,658
Poaching,271,272. Seealso Hunting
Politicaleconomy,445,447–448,451
Politicalquestiondoctrine climatechangelitigationchallenges,125, 532,630–633 standing,125,140,153–155
Pollution. Seealso Airpollution;Chemical pollution;Soilpollution;Water pollution
“polluterpays” principle,36–37,38,429, 431,434 rightsoffuturegenerations,209
Population global,46,465 urban,46
Populationecology,258–259
Positivelaw,50,61,65,68,94,453,460,666
Pound,Roscoe,302
Pragmatism,129
Precautionaryprinciple components,4n5 Earthlawapplication,4 environmentalconstitutionalism,479 GlobalPactfortheEnvironmenton,434 guardianshiparrangementsbasedon,164 rightsoffuturegenerations,204 softlawinterpretation,430–431
Preservationistapproachtonature,74–75
Prigogine,Ilya,87n62
Privatenecessity,112
Privatenuisance,12,112
Propertylaw,U.S.,97–121. Seealso Property rights
beachfrontdevelopment,105–115 constitutional,95,97,105,128–129 ecocentricapproach,10 economicconsiderations,101, 104–105,143 eminentdomain,105,114 environmentallawconflicts,39,50,51, 100–115 intellectualproperty,143 landethic,121 nuisancedoctrine,100–104,112–113 overview,95,97,121 philosophicalbackground,97–100 publictrustdoctrine,112,185–190 regulatorytakings,105,112–114 remedies,101,143 righttodestroyproperty(jusabutendi),95 servitudeinland,101 stateregulationoflanduse,115–121 trespass,100 trustlands,115–121
Propertyrights. Seealso Propertylaw,U.S. commonsand,51,85 constitutional,95,97,105,128–129,232 inEarthlawconceptualframework,81, 84–85 freedomandlibertytiedto,12,97 Indigenouslegalities,98–100,254–255, 276–280,539,669,673–682 intellectualpropertyrights,143,452,669 natureand,39,51,72,84,231–232, 264,266 nonhumansand,4,72,182,299–300 publictrustdoctrine,112,185–190 Renaissanceperiod,12 rightsofnatureand,81,231–232,254–255, 264–266
slaveryand,4,128–129,182 standingand,127,128–129,143 usufructuary,186,254–255
Protagoras,78
ProtestantReformation,12
Prudentialrequirements,125–126,150
Publicnecessity,112 Publicnuisance,12,112
Publicparticipation GlobalPactfortheEnvironmenton,434 SLAPPsuit,292
Publictrustdoctrine,185–199 atmospherictrustlitigation,54,59,89–90, 156,181,634–635 beneficiaries,213–214 onclimatechange,54,59,89,357, 634–635
corpus or trustres,214–215 defined,53,634–635 inEarthlawconceptualframework,89–90 Earthlaworigins,52,53–54 environmentallawand,191,213 federalgovernmentrole,212–213 fiduciaryduty,215–216 historyof,52,53,185–190 Indigenouslegalities’ role,213 aslitigationstrategy,181–182,185–199 nonhumanrights,185 overview,181,185 propertyrightsand,112,185–190 restrictionsbasedon,53 rightsoffuturegenerations,181–182,189, 199,211–217 staterole,190,212 stewardship,191–199 subjectofthetrust,214–215 trustees,government,211–213 waterrights,185–199,214,586
Rainforests. See Forestsandrainforests
RamsarConventiononWetlandsof InternationalImportanceespeciallyas WaterfowlHabitat(1971),61n71, 406,483
Rationalchoicetheory,46n5
Reciprocity defined,83 Earthlawrecognitionof,5,10,83–84,87 insocialcontract,448
Recreation. See Aestheticsandrecreation
Redressability guardianshiparrangements,162–163 rightsoffuturegenerations,225,228–229 rightsofnature,267 standingrequirements,90,147–149,152, 156–159,206,225,228–229
Regan,Tom,331 Regulatorytakings,105,112–114
Rehabilitationtheory animal-humancoexistence,382,386,399 ecocidepenalties,350,353
Rehnquist,William,131–132,146
Relief. See Remedies Religion animal-humancoexistenceinfluenced by,390 anthropocentrismrootedin,78 colonialismeffects,638 customarylawreflecting,88 Enlightenment,69 medievalperiod,11–12 nonhumanrightsand,572–573 ProtestantReformation,12 sacredlaw,659–660 sacredplaces. See Sacredplacesandrights ofnature separationofhumansandnaturein,45 Relocation. See Displacement Remedies atmospherictrustlitigation,89–90 environmentallaw,9 GlobalPactfortheEnvironmenton,434 irreparabledamagecriteria,144 penaltiesas. See Penalties propertylaw,101,143 redressabilityof. See Redressability standingtoreceive,142–144 Renaissanceperiod,12 Resilience,92,435,464,593,611,615,647, 681
Restorativetheory ecocidepenalties,350–351,353 environmentallawsreflecting,548 habitatrestoration,400–401 Israeliwaterlaws,579 RETFON(RiverEthiopeTrust Foundation),652 Retributivetheory,350,353 Rightsoffuturegenerations,201–230 causationstandard,224–225,227–228 climatechange,57,206–207,209,226, 228–229,512 Colombianjurisprudence,57,512,532 constitutionalprovisions,206–207,212, 213–214,217–224,537 customarylaw,203–204,210 dutytoprotectEarthforfuture generations,203–211 Earthlaworigins,57–58 fiduciaryduty,215–216 futuregeneration,defined,532
Rightsoffuturegenerations(continued) generation,defined,202 identifyingfuturegenerationclaimants, 202–203
Indigenouslegalities,203–204,213 injury-in-factstandard,224,225–227 intergenerationalequity,227–228,433 internationalsoftlaw,208–211 intragenerationalequity,532 aslitigationstrategy,181–182,201–230 overview,181–182,201,230 publictrustdoctrine,181–182,189,199, 211–217 redressabilitystandard,225,228–229
SeventhGenerationPrinciple,204,213 standingand,143,156,206,224–230 sustainabledevelopment,209–210 U.S.environmentalmovement,204–209, 211–219,224–230
Righttodestroyproperty(jusabutendi),95
RioConference(Conferenceon EnvironmentandDevelopment,1992), 208,406,410–411,429
RioDeclarationonEnvironmentand Development(1992),208,429, 430–431,552
Rio+20Conference(Conferenceon SustainableDevelopment,2012),418, 420–423
Ripeness,125
RiverEthiopeRightsBill(Nigeria),652,654
RiverEthiopeTrustFoundation (RETFON),652
RiversandHarborsAct(1899),14,23n15
RodríguezOsorio,BlancaLivier,554
RomeStatute ecocide,336–338,340–341,344,346–347, 351,352 partiesnotsigning,341,463 Roosevelt,Theodore,391 Rousseau,Jean-Jacques,376,442–444,454, 466
RoyalSocietyforthePreventionofCrueltyto Animals,300 Russell,Bertrand,273
RussianFederation ecocidecodes,342–343,352
firesin,465 GlobalPactfortheEnvironment stance,432
RomeStatutenotapplicable,341
Ruz, “Coyote” Alberto,555–557
Sacredplacesandrightsofnature inAfrica,638–641,643,644–649,651–653 inHonduras,263 inIndia,173,560–564,566 Indigenoussacredlaw,659–660 inMexico,550 inNewZealand,90,594,596,600–602 inU.S.,254–257
SalardeUyuniproject,462
Salim,Mohammed,173,560
Salmond,John,302,332
Sanctuaries,nonhuman,293,298,306, 312–313,322
SantaMonica,Californiacasestudy,245–248
Santino(chimpanzee),296
Sax,Joseph,53
SbertCarlsson,Carla,461–462,463
Scalia,Antonin,124,147,160
Schweitzer,Albert,401
SecondTreatiseofGovernment (Locke),98–99
Section1983actions,243
Sentience,nonhuman,597–599,621
Separation,orientationof Earthlaworiginsdueto,44–52 environmentallawaffectedby,44, 47–52 environmentallawshortcomingswith, 51–52 historyof,45–47,69–70 Indigenouslegalitiesvs.,50,656,682–683 inlawandcommunallife,49–51 inscience,45,48–49,50
Separationofpowers climatechangeand,125,532,533, 630–633,635–636 constitutionalinterpretationand,129 standingand,124,125,147–148,159
Servitudeinland,101
SeventhGenerationPrinciple,204,213
Severalliability,CERCLA,38
Shah,Purvi,234–235
Short,Damien,339–340
SierraClub,56,74,123,136,138–141
SilentSpring (Carson),11,13,15,555
Singer,JosephWilliam,99–100
Singer,Peter,78n40
Sinks,47,85
SLAPPsuit(StrategicLawsuitAgainstPublic Participation),292
Slavery colonialismand,232 constitutionalabolishment,128,304 personhoodofslaves,295,301–302 propertylaw,4,128–129,182 rights-basedmovementstoabolish,55–56 SaramakaPeopledescendantsfrom,277 standinglack,128
Socialcontract consumptive,376,442n8,445–447,448 coronavirusand,376,464–465 defined,439,441 inEarthlawconceptualframework,91–92 ecocentricgovernanceand,376,439, 440–449,451–455,460,463–466 ecological,92,376,440–449,451–455,460, 463–466 Enlightenmentperiod,70,97,445 freedom,liberty,and,441–443,448, 454,466 generalwilland,443–444,453–455
Hobbes’ theory,376,440,442,465–466
Locke’stheory,97–99,376,442,466 moralityand,443–445,446–447, 451–452,466 withnature,440–441 personhood,310,321 politicaleconomyand,445,447–448,451 propertylawand,97–98
Rousseau’stheory,376,442–444,454,466 UnitedNations’ roleindeveloping,404
Socialjustice civillegal-aidmodel,234 EarthCharteron,414 legaladvocacymodel,234–235 movementlawyeringand,233–236 personhoodand,302 social-rescuemodel,234 test-caseorimpactlitigationmodel,234
SocietyforthePreventionofCrueltyto Animals(SPCA),599
Socioeconomicrightsjurisprudence,496–497
Socio-ecosystem,551 Socrates,45
Soil,28,47n16
Soilpollution,12–13
Solarenergy,634
Solidwaste,12–13,14,241,596
SolidWasteDisposalAct(1965),14
Solon,Pablo,535 SouthAfrica constitutionallaw,217 EarthJurisprudencemovement,644, 649–650 foreignjudicialprecedent recognition,328 NationalWaterAct(1998),650 rightsoffuturegenerations,217 RomeStatutenotapplicable,341 settlercolonialism,70n16 Sovereignrights commonsand,10,50,85 ecocideand,335 Indigenous,213,681 jurisprudenceand,50 propertyrightsand,99–100 publictrustdoctrineand,89,181,185, 211–213
quasi-sovereigncapacity,153,154–155,227 rightsofnature,166 socialcontractand,442–443,465–466 standingand,146,153,154–155,227,565 UNSustainableDevelopmentInitiatives and,405,406,407n16,410 U.S.dual,211
SPCA(SocietyforthePreventionofCruelty toAnimals),599
Speth,JamesGustave “Gus,” 1,426 Standing,123–160 AdministrativeProcedureAct requirements,135–139,150 animalnexustheory,148–149 causationrequirements,125,139, 148–149,154–156,224–225,227–228 childrenandminors,132–133 citizenshiprequirements,128,130–131 citizen-suitprovisionsasproxy,147–159 climatechange,125,156–159,206,226, 229,632 constitutionalrequirements,124–126, 130–135,156–159,224–230 corporationrights,128,131–132,136,146 defined,123 ecosystemnexustheory,148 FourteenthAmendmentrights,128, 130–135,146 guardianshiparrangementsand,127, 132–133,142
Standing(continued) historyof,infederalcourtsystem,127–138 importanceof,123–127 injury-in-factstandard,137,139,140, 147–149,155,224,225–227 irreparabledamagedoctrine,144,150 mootnessand,125,133–135,151–152 nature’s,4,56,138–159,244,257,267,686 nonhumanrights,584 overview,95–96,123–127,160 politicalquestiondoctrine,125,140, 153–155 propertyrightsand,127,128–129,143 prudentialrequirements,125–126,150 redressabilityand,90,147–149,152, 156–159,206,225,228–229 remediesavailablewith,142–144 rightsoffuturegenerationsand,143,156, 206,224–230 rightsofnature,244,257,267,686 separationofpowersand,124,125, 147–148,159 sovereignrightsand,146,153,154–155, 227,565 testfor,124–125,139,150 treeshaving,78,141–146 invirtueofpropertyclaims,127 vocationalnexustheory,148–149 zone-of-intereststest,139,150 States,U.S.
CAAStateImplementationPlans,21 CERCLAimplementation,38 constitutionalauthoritygranted,211 constitutionalprovisionsby,212,217–218, 248–251
CWAimplementation,24 ecocideliability,350 municipal/localpreemption,241,244 parenspatriae doctrine,227 personhoodunderlawsof,303–304 propertyandlanduseregulations,115–121 publictrustdoctrine,190,212 rightsoffuturegenerations,212,217–218, 226–227 rightsofnaturelaws,236,248–251 standingforfuturegenerations,226–227 standingfornature,153,154–155 standingrequirements,124n6 trustlands,115–121 Staton,Josephine,158–159,206–207,214
Steffen,Will,70
Stein,Shelley,381
Stewart,Potter,138,140–141
StockholmConferenceontheHuman Environment(1972),13,405–406,431
StockholmConventiononPersistentOrganic Pollutants,61n71,209
StockholmDeclarationontheHuman Environment(1972),208,405–406,431
Stoermer,Eugene,66
Stone,ChristopherD. biocentricperspective,78 oncorporatepersonhood,131–132 onhumanrightsandrightsofnature, 264–265 rightsofnature,56,259,264–265,267, 290,690 onstandingofnature,78,141–145
StrategicLawsuitAgainstPublicParticipation (SLAPPsuit),292
Strictliability CERCLA,37,38 ecocide,339,353,355
Strong,Maurice,405
Sulfurdioxide,21n11
SumakKawsay (goodwayofliving)concept, 163,475–477,478
Sununu,Chris,381
Superfund. See Comprehensive EnvironmentalResponse, Compensation,andLiabilityAct (CERCLA)
Suriname humanrightsandrightsofnature co-violations,277–278,279–280 KaliñaandLokonoPeoples,279–280 SaramakaPeople,277–278
Sustainabledevelopment anthropocentrismand,71,403,406, 410–411,428 constitutionalprovisions,552 deepsustainability,426–428,437 defined,71,209,404 economicdevelopmentand,405,410,421, 422,423,427–428 GlobalPactfortheEnvironmenton,433 rightsoffuturegenerations,209–210 rightsofnatureand,544,552,556 UNInitiatives. See Sustainable DevelopmentInitiatives
useofterm,410
SustainableDevelopmentInitiatives,UN, 403–438
anthropocentrismand,403,406,410–411 BrundtlandReport,375,404,409–410
ConferenceonEnvironmentand Development,208,406,410–411,429 ConferenceonSustainableDevelopment, 418,420–423
ConferenceontheHumanEnvironment, 13,405–406,431 deepsustainability,426–428,437
EarthCharter,61,413–415,448n36,460 ecocentricgovernance,375–376,422 economicdevelopmentand,405,410,421, 422,423,427–428
GlobalPactfortheEnvironment,61, 403–404,429–435,436–437
HarmonywithNatureInitiative,61–62, 375,403,404,416–420,421,424–425, 437,556
High-levelPoliticalForumonSustainable Development,404,411,425–426 MillenniumSummitandDevelopment Goals,411–412 overview,375–376,403–404,436
Peoples’ SustainabilityTreaties,421–423 sovereignrightsand,405,406,407n16,410 SustainableDevelopmentGoals,375,403, 421,423–425,430
UnitedNations,generally,404
WorldCharterforNature,406–409,460, 463,479
WorldSummitonSustainable Development,415–416 Sweden,nonhumanrights,296. Seealso Stockholm entries Switzerland,climatechangeresponses,634 Syria,GlobalPactfortheEnvironment stance,432
Systemsecology,258
Systemsthinking inEarthlawconceptualframework,86–87 Earthsystemsscience,47–48,49,67,76, 77–78 onnature,87–88. Seealso Ecosystems
Tajikistan,ecocidecodes,343,352 Tamabioy,Carlos,677
Tansley,Arthur,86
Taxation carbondioxidetaxes,633 generation-skippingtransfertaxes,202 naturalgastaxes,633 TayronaPark,497 Technology. Seealso Artificialintelligence consumptivesocialcontractand,446 ecologicalperiod,72 jurisprudenceorphilosophy,72 sciencedistinguished,48 TeKawaoTeUrewera,609–616,619–620,622
TendetzaAntún,JoséIsidro,486 TenthAmendmentrights,89 Terranullius doctrine,641 TeUrewera[NationalPark],178,298,470, 602–616,619–620,621–622
Textualism,129 ThirteenthAmendmentrights,128,304 Thresholdchallenges guardianshiparrangements,95–96, 161–179 overview,6–7,95–96 propertylaw,U.S.,95,97–121 standing,95–96,123–160 Timmins,Andrew,380–382,389,393 Tommy(chimpanzee),293–294,296,297, 299–300,305,306–311,323–332 Toxicwaste. See Hazardouswaste Trespass,100 Tribalentities. See Indigenouslegalities; Indigenousrightsofnature Tribe,Laurence,302,331 Trumpadministration,23,36,463,466n76 Trustlands,115–121 Turkey,GlobalPactfortheEnvironment stance,432 Uganda EarthJurisprudencemovement,644, 651–653,654 nonhumanrights,296 Ukraine,ecocidecodes,343,352 UNESCODeclarationoftheResponsibilities ofthePresentGenerationsTowards FutureGenerations,208,210 Unitaryexecutivetheory,466n76 UnitedKingdom Amazondeforestationresponse,512 ecocidemodelcode,344–345,347,353 environmentallaw,12–13 nonhumanrights,300
UnitedNations
BrundtlandReport,375,404,409–410
CommissiononSustainable Development,411
ConferenceonEnvironmentand Development,208,406,410–411,429
ConferenceonSustainableDevelopment, 418,420–423
ConferenceontheHumanEnvironment, 13,405–406,431
ConventionforthePreventionofMarine PollutionbyDumpingofWastesand OtherMatter,406
ConventiononBiologicalDiversity,61n71, 279–280,406,411,463
ConventiononInternationalTradein EndangeredSpeciesofWildFaunaand Flora,28n20,61n71,406
ConventiononNatureProtectionand WildlifePreservationintheWestern Hemisphere,28n20
ConventionontheLawoftheSea, 61n71,463
ConventionontheProhibitionofMilitary orAnyOtherHostileUseof EnvironmentalModification Techniques,337–338,344
ConventionontheProtectionandUseof TransboundaryWatercoursesand InternationalLakes,208
DeclarationofBasicPrinciplesofJustice forVictimsofCrimeandAbuseof Power,344
DeclarationoftheRighttoDevelopment, 335n13
DeclarationonHumanDevelopment, 415
DeclarationonHumanRights Defenders,264
DeclarationontheHumanEnvironment, 208,405–406,431
DeclarationontheRightsofIndigenous Peoples(UNDRIP),60,255
DevelopmentProgram(UNDP),404,681
EarthCharter,61,413–415,448n36,460
Educational,ScientificandCultural Organization(UNESCO),208,210,413
EnvironmentalProgramme(UNEP),71, 404,433
ForumonForests,404
FrameworkConventiononClimate Change,61n71,209,273,406,411,512, 628–629
GlobalPactfortheEnvironment,61, 403–404,429–435,436–437
GuidingPrinciplesonBusinessand HumanRights,264
HarmonywithNatureInitiative,61–62, 375,403,404,416–420,421,424–425, 437,556
High-levelPoliticalForumonSustainable Development,404,411,425–426 HumanRightsCouncil,268–269,275
IntergovernmentalPanelonClimate Change,49,71,228,404
InternationalRightsofNatureTribunal recognition,274
MillenniumSummitandDevelopment Goals,411–412 overview,404
RamsarConventiononWetlandsof InternationalImportanceespeciallyas WaterfowlHabitat,61n71,406,483
SustainableDevelopmentInitiatives. See SustainableDevelopment Initiatives,UN
UniversalDeclarationofHumanRights, 55,266,304,624
WorldCharterforNature,406–409,460, 463,479
WorldHeritageConvention,406 WorldSummitonSustainable Development,415–416 UnityPact,458
UniversalDeclarationfortheRightsof MotherEarth,61,82,267,274,290, 417–418,456
UniversalDeclarationofHumanRights,55, 266,304,624
UniversalDeclarationoftheRightsofRivers, 489n35
Urbanpopulation,46. Seealso Municipalities Usufructuarypropertyrights,186, 254–255
Uzbekistan,ecocidecodes,343,344,352
Varela,Francisco,87n62
Vermont,rightsofnatureprovisions,249 VictimsandLandRestitutionLaw (Colombia),497n24
ViennaConventionfortheProtectionofthe OzoneLayer,61n71
Vietnam ecocideagainst,59,333,336 ecocidecodes,343,351,352
Villavicencio,Paola,460–461,497,529
Vocationalnexustheory,148–149
WaitangiTreaty,90,168,204,470,589,590, 595,600–601 Ward,Ken,368,373–374
Wastewater,13,268,578 Water. Seealso Floods;Freshwateraccessand use;Oceans;Wastewater;Water pollution;Watersheds dams,263,273,289,487–489, 522–525,596
Israelirightsofnature,577–581,585–586 mininguseof,462 publictrustdoctrine,185–199,214,586 rightsoffuturegenerations,208 watercycle,334,512 Waterpollution. Seealso CleanWaterAct agriculturalrunoff,24,243 deadzones,13 environmentallaw,12–13,14,23–28,37 humanrightsandrightsofnaturecoviolationswith,268,499–500,526 IndustrialRevolution,12–13 injury-in-factfrom,226 internationallawsandactions,406 municipal/locallaws,238–245 oilandnaturalgas-related,13,268, 349–350
rightsofnatureagainst,238–245,268,578 standingtochallenge,151–152 WaterQualityAct(1948),23n15 Watersheds ascommons,85 CWAprotection,24,28 guardianshiparrangementstomanage, 168,175 municipal/localprotection,238–245 personhood,239–240 rightsofnature,238–245 Watson,Irene,658
Well-being,defined,76n30 Wetlands,24,27,54,61n71,215,349,406, 483–485
WhanganuiRiver,90,96,167–168,173,178, 204,298,470,617–619 Whitaker,Benjamin,338 White,Edward,131,146 Whitesinger,Pauline,204 WildernessAct(1964),14 Windenergy,401,402,634 Wiseman,Samuel,331 Women climatechangedisplacing,266 aslandandenvironmentaldefenders,272. Seealsospecificindividuals legalstatusandvotingrights,55 naturecharacterizedinassociation with,74 personhood,141,302,529 reproductiverights,133–135,203 standing,133–135,141,160 Wood,MaryChristina,54,213,215,216 WorldBank,404 WorldCharterforNature(1982),406–409, 460,463,479 WorldCommissiononEnvironmentand Development,209,409. Seealso BrundtlandReport WorldConservationStrategy,216 WorldHealthOrganization,404 WorldHeritageConvention(1972),406 WorldPeople’sConferenceonClimate ChangeandtheRightsofMother Earth,82,417–418,456 WorldSummitonSustainableDevelopment (WSSD,2002),415–416
YamunotriGlacier,567–569 YestoLifeNotoMiningCampaign,267
Zaire,WorldCharterforNaturestance, 407
Zimbabwe.EarthJurisprudence movement,644
Zone-of-intereststest,139,150 Zoonoticdiseases,688